29
A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective Steve Melek, FSA, MAAA Doug Norris, FSA, MAAA, PhD June 3, 2015

A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

A Roadmap to Integrated CarePrimary Care and Behavioral Health

The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare

An Actuary’s Perspective

Steve Melek, FSA, MAAADoug Norris, FSA, MAAA, PhDJune 3, 2015

Page 2: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

2

Integrating Behavioral and Medical Healthcare

Source: Kathol and Gatteau – Healing Mind and Body, 2007

June 3, 2015

Page 3: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

3

48.3%

12.7%

34.9%

5.3%

June 3, 2015

Page 4: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

4

The Quality of Treatment

In spite of effective treatments and evidence-based guidelines, only 1 in 5 individuals with depression who seek treatment are treated according to minimum standards (JAMA, 2003).

Page 5: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

5 June 3, 2015

Condition Identification

Page 6: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

6

Prevalence of Co-morbidities

Unützer, Jürgen. Integrated Behavioral Health Care. Powerpoint Presentation. Seattle , Washington. May 2, 2011.

Page 7: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

7 June 3, 2015

Cost Impact and Savings Opportunities

Page 8: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

8

Findings from an Analysis of Comorbid Chronic Medical & Behavioral Conditions in Insured Populations

Basis for analysis was detailed claim and membership files for Commercial, Medicare and Medicaid populations

Commercial and Medicare populations were divided into 4 cohorts:1. No MH/SUD

2. Non-SPMI MH

3. SPMI

4. SUD

Total spending and per member per month (PMPM) costs were separated between Medical, Medical Rx, Behavioral, and Behavioral Rx

June 3, 2015

Page 9: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

9

Findings from an Analysis of Comorbid Chronic Medical & Behavioral Conditions in Insured Populations

June 3, 2015

PopulationBehavioral Health

DiagnosisMember Months Medical Behavioral Medical Rx Behavioral Rx Total

Commercial No MH/SA 2,048,000,000 $280 $3 $53 $4 $340Non-SPMI MH 278,000,000 $661 $23 $145 $74 $903SPMI 47,000,000 $759 $128 $135 $175 $1,197SA 22,000,000 $830 $73 $102 $67 $1,072Total 2,386,000,000 $335 $8 $66 $16 $425

Medicare No MH/SA 508,000,000 $579 $3 N/A* N/A* $582Non-SPMI MH 23,000,000 $1,369 $40 N/A* N/A* $1,409SPMI 21,000,000 $1,222 $215 N/A* N/A* $1,437SA 6,000,000 $1,291 $213 N/A* N/A* $1,504Total 556,000,000 $640 $13 N/A* N/A* $653

Medicaid No MH/SA 437,000,000 $309 $4 $63 $5 $381MH/SA 109,000,000 $757 $286 $172 $86 $1,301Total 546,000,000 $398 $61 $85 $21 $565

Total No MH/SA 2,993,000,000 $335 $3 $55 $4 $397MH/SA 494,000,000 $751 $100 $148 $86 $1,085Total 3,487,000,000 $394 $17 $69 $17 $497

Per Member Per Month (PMPM) Healthcare Costs by Market

Total Spending for Full Population(PMPM, 2012 Allowed Dollars)

Page 10: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

10

Findings from an Analysis of Comorbid Chronic Medical & Behavioral Conditions in Insured Populations

June 3, 2015

PopulationBehavioral Health

DiagnosisMedical Behavioral Medical Rx Behavioral Rx Total

Commercial No MH/SA $573,171 $5,628 $109,464 $8,833 $697,096Non-SPMI MH $184,147 $6,502 $40,361 $20,507 $251,517SPMI $35,408 $5,954 $6,312 $8,167 $55,841SA $18,227 $1,596 $2,236 $1,473 $23,532Total $800,317 $18,336 $157,038 $37,695 $1,013,386

Medicare No MH/SA $294,241 $1,619 N/A N/A $295,860Non-SPMI MH $31,167 $914 N/A N/A $32,081SPMI $26,142 $4,596 N/A N/A $30,738SA $8,346 $1,379 N/A N/A $9,725Total $355,559 $7,234 N/A N/A $362,793

Medicaid No MH/SA $134,920 $1,963 $27,710 $2,176 $166,769MH/SA $82,655 $31,264 $18,759 $9,389 $142,067Total $217,575 $33,227 $46,468 $11,566 $308,836

Total No MH/SA $1,002,332 $9,210 $137,173 $11,009 $1,159,724MH/SA $371,119 $49,587 $66,333 $38,252 $525,291Total $1,373,451 $58,797 $203,507 $49,261 $1,685,016

(Millions, 2012 Allowed Dollars)

Total Spending for Full PopulationTotal Healthcare Costs by Market

Page 11: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

11

Findings from an Analysis of Comorbid Chronic Medical & Behavioral Conditions in Insured Populations

June 3, 2015

Condition No MH/SA SPMI Non-SPMI SAArthritis $814 $2,065 $1,586 $1,827Asthma $569 $1,851 $1,389 $1,774Cancer $1,360 $2,525 $2,338 $2,668Chronic Kidney Disease $4,650 $5,664 $6,232 $6,901Congestive Heart Failure $1,274 $2,649 $1,955 $2,827Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease $992 $2,719 $2,088 $2,028Chronic Pain $1,259 $2,355 $1,780 $2,387Back Pain $1,624 $3,109 $2,395 $2,705Headache $1,659 $3,311 $2,221 $3,354Diabetes (with complications) $1,821 $3,366 $2,681 $3,678Diabetes (without complications) $811 $1,775 $1,353 $1,848Hypercholesterolemia (with complications) $1,369 $2,769 $2,061 $2,349Hypercholesterolemia (without complications) $649 $1,498 $1,065 $1,411Hypertension (with complications) $1,447 $3,056 $2,220 $2,621Hypertension (without complications) $688 $1,641 $1,157 $1,494Ischemic Heart Disease $1,443 $3,006 $2,319 $2,335Osteoporosis $874 $2,312 $1,592 $1,720Stroke $1,673 $3,556 $2,590 $2,554None $221 $762 $528 $615Any Condition $695 $1,690 $1,271 $1,577Total $340 $1,197 $903 $1,071

2012 Allowed PMPMsImpact of Co-mobidities (Commercial Population)

Page 12: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

12

Findings from an Analysis of Comorbid Chronic Medical & Behavioral Conditions in Insured Populations

June 3, 2015

Condition No MH/SA SPMI Non-SPMI SAArthritis $1,237 $2,109 $1,852 $2,010Asthma $1,381 $2,227 $2,051 $2,325Cancer $1,230 $2,117 $1,826 $2,083Chronic Kidney Disease $2,677 $3,986 $3,772 $4,581Congestive Heart Failure $2,230 $3,478 $2,882 $3,713Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease $1,598 $2,546 $2,335 $2,171Diabetes (with complications) $1,740 $2,964 $2,755 $3,085Diabetes (without complications) $811 $1,486 $1,379 $1,719Hypercholesterolemia (with complications) $1,292 $2,465 $2,119 $2,302Hypercholesterolemia (without complications) $676 $1,186 $1,043 $1,267Hypertension (with complications) $1,608 $2,917 $2,438 $2,936Hypertension (without complications) $822 $1,528 $1,326 $1,642Ischemic Heart Disease $1,392 $2,659 $2,261 $2,634Osteoporosis $1,052 $1,882 $1,627 $1,988Stroke $1,567 $2,809 $2,400 $2,409None $185 $665 $673 $821Any Condition $971 $1,701 $1,561 $1,744Total $582 $1,436 $1,410 $1,504

2012 Allowed PMPMsImpact of Co-mobidities (Medicare Population)

Page 13: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

13

Findings from an Analysis of Comorbid Chronic Medical & Behavioral Conditions in Insured Populations

June 3, 2015

Condition No MH/SA MHSABenign/In Situ/Uncertain Neoplasm $686 $1,580Cardio-Respiratory Arrest $4,798 $5,134Cerebro-Vascular $2,052 $3,299Cognitive Disorders $2,319 $3,552Diabetes $1,066 $2,368Ears, Nose, and Throat $488 $1,455Eyes $587 $1,625Gastrointestinal $843 $1,932Genital System $662 $1,538Heart $1,023 $2,134Hematological $1,419 $3,003Liver $1,328 $2,564Lung $737 $1,912Malignant Neoplasm $1,913 $3,185Musculoskeletal and Connective Tissue $693 $1,624Neurological $1,476 $2,365Nutritional and Metabolic $815 $1,923Pregnancy-Related $1,147 $1,669Skin and Subcutaneous $598 $1,771Urinary System $1,079 $2,395Vascular $1,808 $3,375Total $382 $1,301

2012 Allowed PMPMsImpact of Co-mobidities (Medicaid Population)

Page 14: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

14

Findings from an Analysis of Comorbid Chronic Medical & Behavioral Conditions in Insured Populations

June 3, 2015

Medical Condition SPMI Non-SPMI SA TotalArthritis $7,931 $26,567 $3,013 $36,372Asthma $6,298 $22,770 $2,633 $30,801Cancer $2,236 $13,100 $1,149 $16,201Chronic Kidney Disease $267 $2,082 $192 $2,485Congestive Heart Failure $2,981 $10,166 $1,308 $13,953Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease $2,369 $7,829 $1,590 $11,428Chronic Pain $1,007 $3,686 $455 $5,002Back Pain $1,688 $4,598 $841 $6,894Headache $231 $398 $119 $683Diabetes (with complications) $1,745 $6,246 $586 $8,381Diabetes (without complications) $2,850 $9,982 $798 $13,334Hypercholesterolemia (with complications) $1,707 $6,106 $720 $8,285Hypercholesterolemia (without complications) $5,151 $17,842 $1,596 $24,000Hypertension (with complications) $2,399 $7,905 $1,090 $11,031Hypertension (without complications) $5,645 $20,161 $2,505 $27,241Ischemic Heart Disease $1,380 $5,321 $732 $7,208Osteoporosis $518 $1,602 $90 $2,209Stroke $632 $1,689 $262 $2,465None $13,373 $42,270 $4,547 $56,991Any Condition $21,781 $81,029 $9,188 $105,376Total $35,154 $123,299 $13,735 $162,366

Annual Value Opportunity (Commercial Population) - Total 2012 Dollars (millions)

Note: Results are not additive across conditions due to insureds with multiple conditions

Page 15: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

15

What IMBH Programs have worked?

Multifaceted Diabetes and Depression Program (MDDP) – medical savings of $39 PMPM observed over 18 months

Pathways program for diabetes & depression - $46 PMPM saved, or about 5% over 2 years

IMPACT program for depression among the elderly - $70 PMPM saved over 4-year period, or about 10%

Missouri CMHC health homes in 2012 – independent living increased by 33%, vocational activity increased by 44%, overall healthcare costs decreased by 8%

Observed savings of between 9% and 16% of value opportunity

Page 16: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

16

Findings from an Analysis of Comorbid Chronic Medical & Behavioral Conditions in Insured Populations

June 3, 2015

Payor Type Member Months Allowed Claims Value PotentialCost Impact of

IntegrationCommercial 2,386,000,000 $1,013,386 $162,366 $15,815-$31,629Medicare 556,000,000 $362,793 $30,803 $3,347-$6,693Medicaid 546,000,000 $308,836 $100,374 $7,103-$9,945Total 3,487,000,000 $1,685,016 $293,543 $26,265-$48,267

Average Annual Cost Savings Achievable through Effective IMBH (millions)

Page 17: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

17

More Economic Impact Analyses

A Focus on Children and Adolescents

Dependent Children and Adolescents

Age Groups 0-5. 6-12, 13-18, 19+

4 Cohort Analysis: Comorbid chronic medical-behavioral, SMI, non-SMI MH, SUD

Impact of behavioral conditions on the healthcare costs of parents

June 3, 2015

Page 18: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

18

PMPM Cost Comparison of Cohorts

June 3, 2015

Figure 2a: Children – Per Member Per Month (PMPM) Commercial Healthcare Costs by Age Group and Presence of Behavioral Conditions – 2015 Costs

Child’s Behavioral

Age Member

Medical Behavioral Med BHV Total

Diagnosis Group Months

Rx Rx

No MH/SUD

Child 0-5 157,739,550 $190.17 $0.41 $16.67 $0.44 $207.69

Child 6-12 196,614,885 $109.59 $1.66 $19.25 $3.59 $134.10

Child 13-18 167,624,597 $160.07 $5.53 $34.19 $4.86 $204.65

Child 19+ 122,836,661 $168.77 $5.31 $29.78 $4.84 $208.70 Total No MH/SUD

644,815,692 $153.70 $3.06 $24.51 $3.39 $184.65

Non-SPMI MH

Child 0-5 2,971,671 $989.18 $12.10 $57.74 $22.10 $1,081.13

Child 6-12 13,647,733 $291.72 $39.71 $52.13 $85.72 $469.27

Child 13-18 17,922,960 $344.04 $78.10 $68.70 $76.40 $567.24

Child 19+ 16,171,774 $415.78 $72.79 $65.04 $61.89 $615.50 Total Non-SPMI MH

50,714,137 $390.64 $62.21 $62.43 $71.10 $586.38

SPMI

Child 0-5 466,498 $1,339.10 $75.20 $37.02 $16.47 $1,467.78

Child 6-12 1,735,388 $658.87 $82.87 $77.33 $132.64 $951.71

Child 13-18 2,197,781 $536.41 $240.27 $80.21 $198.11 $1,055.00

Child 19+ 1,998,917 $657.13 $280.65 $64.31 $185.20 $1,187.29

Total SPMI 6,398,584 $665.86 $198.16 $71.31 $163.08 $1,098.41

SUD

Child 0-5 17,237 $6,066.54 $1.73 $152.92 $40.52 $6,261.72

Child 6-12 20,034 $444.46 $50.92 $82.47 $76.55 $654.41

Child 13-18 922,384 $457.50 $208.95 $42.13 $54.48 $763.06

Child 19+ 3,824,943 $594.32 $218.39 $56.34 $38.32 $907.37

Total SUD 4,784,597 $587.03 $215.09 $54.06 $41.60 $897.78

Total

704,465,793 $176.35 $9.37 $27.72 $9.73 $223.17

Page 19: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

19

PMPM Cost Comparison of Parents

June 3, 2015

Figure 2b: Parents – Per Member Per Month (PMPM) Commercial Healthcare Costs by Child’s Diagnosis Category – 2015 Costs Dependent’s Member

Medical Behavioral Med BHV

Total Diagnosis Months Rx Rx

Co-Morbid 18,775,451 $574.45 $17.43 $134.10 $41.57 $767.56

BH/SUD 78,974,834 $479.84 $14.85 $104.32 $32.64 $631.65

Medical 88,762,288 $416.77 $6.12 $89.47 $16.14 $528.49

No Condition 435,372,898 $371.79 $5.58 $72.30 $13.16 $462.83

Total 621,885,472 $398.05 $7.19 $80.68 $16.92 $502.84

Page 20: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

20

Total Costs for Children & Adolescents

June 3, 2015

Figure 3a: Children – Total Commercial Healthcare Costs by Age Group and Presence of Behavioral Conditions – 2015 Costs (millions)

Child’s Behavioral

Age Member

Medical Behavioral Med BHV Total

Diagnosis Group Months

Rx Rx

No MH/SUD

Child 0-5 157,739,550 $29,997 $65 $2,629 $69 $32,760

Child 6-12 196,614,885 $21,547 $327 $3,786 $706 $26,366

Child 13-18 167,624,597 $26,832 $928 $5,732 $814 $34,305

Child 19+ 122,836,661 $20,731 $652 $3,658 $595 $25,636 Total No MH/SUD

644,815,692 $99,107 $1,971 $15,804 $2,184 $119,067

Non-SPMI MH

Child 0-5 2,971,671 $2,940 $36 $172 $66 $3,213

Child 6-12 13,647,733 $3,981 $542 $711 $1,170 $6,404

Child 13-18 17,922,960 $6,166 $1,400 $1,231 $1,369 $10,167

Child 19+ 16,171,774 $6,724 $1,177 $1,052 $1,001 $9,954 Total Non-SPMI MH

50,714,137 $19,811 $3,155 $3,166 $3,606 $29,738

SPMI

Child 0-5 466,498 $625 $35 $17 $8 $685

Child 6-12 1,735,388 $1,143 $144 $134 $230 $1,652

Child 13-18 2,197,781 $1,179 $528 $176 $435 $2,319

Child 19+ 1,998,917 $1,314 $561 $129 $370 $2,373

Total SPMI 6,398,584 $4,261 $1,268 $456 $1,043 $7,028

SUD

Child 0-5 17,237 $105 $0 $3 $1 $108

Child 6-12 20,034 $9 $1 $2 $2 $13

Child 13-18 922,384 $422 $193 $39 $50 $704

Child 19+ 3,824,943 $2,273 $835 $215 $147 $3,471

Total SUD 4,784,597 $2,809 $1,029 $259 $199 $4,296

Total

704,465,793 $124,229 $6,604 $19,529 $6,856 $157,218

Page 21: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

21

Total Costs of Parents

June 3, 2015

Figure 3b: Parents – Total Commercial Healthcare Costs by Child’s Diagnosis Category– 2015 Costs (millions) Dependent’s Member Medical Behavioral Med BHV Total

Diagnosis Months

Rx Rx

Co-Morbid 18,775,451 $10,786 $327 $2,518 $781 $14,411

BH/SUD 78,974,834 $37,895 $1,173 $8,238 $2,577 $49,884 Medical 88,762,288 $36,993 $543 $7,941 $1,433 $46,910

No Condition 435,372,898 $161,867 $2,431 $31,477 $5,730 $201,505

Total 621,885,472 $247,541 $4,474 $50,175 $10,521 $312,710

Page 22: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

22

PMPM Costs by Medical Condition - Children

June 3, 2015

Figure 5a - Children and Adolescents - Impact of Behavioral Comorbidities, Commercial Population – 2015 Total PMPM Costs

Child’s Medical Condition No MH/SUD SPMI Non-SPMI

MH SUD

Arthritis $461 $1,907 $1,155 $1,508

Asthma $354 $1,466 $1,044 $1,282

Cancer $1,686 $3,461 $3,704 $3,589

Chronic Kidney Disease $4,727 $11,005 $9,024 $8,967

Congestive Heart Failure $2,228 $3,869 $3,787 $4,615

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease $465 $2,412 $2,614 $2,106

Chronic Pain $1,923 $4,918 $3,049 $2,559

Back Pain $1,610 $3,697 $3,510 $3,409

Headache $1,502 $5,554 $4,457 $2,766

Diabetes (with complications) $1,377 $6,392 $3,533 $7,234

Diabetes (without complications) $996 $2,272 $1,744 $2,843

Hypercholesterolemia (with complications) $4,637 $5,931 $4,071 $1,564

Hypercholesterolemia (without complications) $464 $1,761 $1,422 $1,789

Hypertension (with complications) $6,026 $6,701 $9,086 $13,905

Hypertension (without complications) $1,093 $3,138 $2,399 $2,221

Ischemic Heart Disease $3,721 $12,433 $6,891 $3,568

Osteoporosis $3,125 $8,621 $8,484 $3,667

Stroke $3,972 $3,202 $4,758 $3,422

No Medical Condition $156 $974 $460 $765

Any Medical Condition $440 $1,646 $1,193 $1,486

Total $185 $1,098 $586 $898

Page 23: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

23

Prevalence Rates of Conditions - Children

June 3, 2015

Figure 6a - Children and Adolescents - Condition Prevalence, Commercial Population – 2015

Child’s Medical Condition No MH/SUD SPMI Non-SPMI

MH SUD

Arthritis 2.55% 5.28% 5.34% 7.34%

Asthma 6.45% 10.42% 9.83% 7.61%

Cancer 0.28% 0.64% 0.73% 0.64%

Chronic Kidney Disease 0.02% 0.06% 0.06% 0.06%

Congestive Heart Failure 0.10% 0.30% 0.37% 0.31%

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease 0.58% 1.02% 0.85% 1.89%

Chronic Pain 0.01% 0.05% 0.06% 0.10%

Back Pain 0.00% 0.10% 0.08% 0.25%

Headache 0.00% 0.02% 0.01% 0.03%

Diabetes (with complications) 0.01% 0.06% 0.06% 0.06%

Diabetes (without complications) 0.35% 1.46% 0.92% 1.00%

Hypercholesterolemia (with complications) 0.00% 0.02% 0.01% 0.02%

Hypercholesterolemia (without complications) 0.10% 0.80% 0.38% 0.50%

Hypertension (with complications) 0.00% 0.04% 0.03% 0.05%

Hypertension (without complications) 0.14% 0.83% 0.53% 1.15%

Ischemic Heart Disease 0.00% 0.02% 0.02% 0.08%

Osteoporosis 0.00% 0.03% 0.02% 0.01%

Stroke 0.02% 0.13% 0.07% 0.16%

No Medical Condition 90.03% 81.43% 82.77% 81.62%

Any Medical Condition 9.97% 18.57% 17.23% 18.38%

Total 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00%

Page 24: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

24

The Annual Value Opportunity - Children

June 3, 2015

Figure 6b – Children and Adolescents – Annual Value Opportunity - Commercial Population – Total 2015 Dollars (millions) Child’s Medical Condition SPMI Non-SPMI SUD Total

Arthritis $489 $1,881 $368 $2,738

Asthma $741 $3,439 $338 $4,518

Cancer $72 $749 $58 $879

Chronic Kidney Disease $25 $129 $12 $166

Congestive Heart Failure $32 $289 $35 $356

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease $128 $922 $148 $1,198

Chronic Pain $10 $37 $3 $50

Back Pain $13 $73 $22 $107

Headache $5 $20 $2 $28

Diabetes (with complications) $19 $65 $17 $101

Diabetes (without complications) $119 $350 $88 $558

Hypercholesterolemia (with complications) $2 $0 $0 $0

Hypercholesterolemia (without complications) $66 $186 $32 $284

Hypertension (with complications) $2 $47 $19 $68

Hypertension (without complications) $109 $348 $62 $519

Ischemic Heart Disease $9 $34 $0 $42

Osteoporosis $11 $60 $0 $72

Stroke $0 $30 $0 $19

None $4,257 $12,747 $2,378 $19,382

Any Condition $1,434 $6,584 $920 $8,938

Total $5,691 $19,331 $3,298 $28,320

Page 25: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

25

Annual Value Opportunity - Parents

June 3, 2015

Figure 6c – Parents – Annual Value Opportunity - Commercial Population – Total 2015 Dollars (millions) Parent’s Medical Condition Co-Morbid BH/SUD Total

Arthritis $967 $1,817 $2,784

Asthma $655 $1,036 $1,691

Cancer $260 $288 $548

Chronic Kidney Disease $34 $0 $18

Congestive Heart Failure $245 $358 $603

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease $171 $302 $473

Chronic Pain $98 $83 $181

Back Pain $139 $374 $514

Headache $27 $18 $45

Diabetes (with complications) $165 $204 $369

Diabetes (without complications) $362 $990 $1,352

Hypercholesterolemia (with complications) $122 $194 $315

Hypercholesterolemia (without complications) $586 $1,655 $2,242

Hypertension (with complications) $136 $289 $426

Hypertension (without complications) $647 $1,490 $2,136

Ischemic Heart Disease $90 $156 $246

Osteoporosis $31 $70 $101

Stroke $6 $61 $68

None $1,138 $4,240 $5,378

Any Condition $2,311 $5,266 $7,577

Total $3,450 $9,505 $12,955

Page 26: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

26

Annual Potential Savings Projection

June 3, 2015

Figure 7: Average Annual Cost Savings and Impact Through Effective Integration – 2015 Totals (All Costs in Millions)

Payer Type Member Months Total Claims Value

Opportunity Cost Impact of

Integration

Child 0-5 161,191,635 $36,734 $3,288 $296 - $526

Child 6-12 212,009,339 $34,426 $6,004 $540 - $961

Child 13-18 188,129,569 $46,947 $8,883 $799 - $1,421

Child 19+ 143,135,251 $39,111 $11,207 $1,009 - $1,793

Child Total 704,465,793 $157,218 $28,320 $2,549 - $4,531

Parent 621,885,472 $312,710 $12,955 $1,166 - $2,073

Total 1,326,351,265 $469,929 $41,275 $3,715 - $6,604

Page 27: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

27

The Colorado SIM Opportunity

$65 million award

4-year program, 1 ramp up year, 3 test years

Targeting 80% of Coloradans

CMS wants an ROI

CMS wants sustainability

CMS wants portability

CMMI investment of $1 billion annually is “cheap” compared to the costs of Medicare/Medicaid of $2 billion every day

Payment reform is a MUST

The Triple Aim and the 3-legged stool

June 3, 2015

Page 28: A Roadmap to Integrated Care Primary Care and Behavioral Health The Business Case for Integrated Medical-Behavioral Healthcare An Actuary’s Perspective

28

Payment Model Reform Ideas

Primary Care Capitation, including primary physical and behavioral healthcare services with care coordination and management

Cap rates must be population-specific and risk adjusted Options in Cap Rate for the addition of different levels of

behavioral service responsibilities Variations between urban, rural and frontier areas Risk Sharing or Gain Sharing of non-primary care services Requires setting risk adjusted targets PMPM for different

member populations (commercial, Medicaid, Medicare) for IP facility, OP facility, other physician specialists, Rx and all other services.