16
A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum Guided by Tuol Sleng survivor/artist Van Nath with CIVICUS Cambodia founding president Theary Seng for Kerry Kennedy, Michaela Kennedy Cuomo, John Heffernan (22 Feb. 2011) and psychologist/author Dr. Ervin Staub, psychotherapist Dr. Luann Warren-Sohlberg (a trustee of the Headington Institute), Sivnin Eam (7 March 2011). A new entrance of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum, southeast corner of the former high school compound, bemoaned by Mr. Van Nath for the destruction of authentic sites to create this entrance and the sanitized ce ment parking dr ivew ay along the b ack of the buil dings, former gr av esite s (befo re mass killings w ere moved to Ch oeun g Ek) w here Mr. Van Na th remembers encou ntering human remains every w here. 7 March 201 1. Cambodians d o no t h av e t o pay to ente r Tuol Slen g, foreig ners do pay , however only in cash and overt loophol es in fin ancial accounting (r eceipts).

A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

8/7/2019 A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-virtual-tour-of-tuol-sleng-genocide-museum 1/16

A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum 

Guided by Tuol Sleng survivor/artist Van Nath with CIVICUS Cambodia founding president

Theary Seng for Kerry Kennedy, Michaela Kennedy Cuomo, John Heffernan (22 Feb. 2011) and

psychologist/author Dr. Ervin Staub, psychotherapist Dr. Luann Warren-Sohlberg (a trustee of 

the Headington Institute), Sivnin Eam (7 March 2011).

A new entrance of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum, southeast corner of the former high school

compound, bemoaned by Mr. Van Nath for the destruction of authentic sites to create this

entrance and the sanitized cement parking driveway along the back of the buildings, formergravesites (before mass killings were moved to Choeung Ek) where Mr. Van Nath remembers

encountering human remains everywhere. 7 March 2011. Cambodians do not have to pay to

enter Tuol Sleng, foreigners do pay, however only in cash and overt loopholes in financial

accounting (receipts).

Page 2: A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

8/7/2019 A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-virtual-tour-of-tuol-sleng-genocide-museum 2/16

A former classroom split into two rooms for the interrogation and torture of special victims.

Here Mr. Van Nath, Dr. Ervin Staub and I looking at the photograph of a fresh corpse whose

identity is unrecognizable by the torture, taken by a Vietnamese photographer accompanying

the victorious new occupying Vietnamese military force, probably a few days after the Jan. 7

military victory. Fourteen of them found in these large torture/interrogation rooms, now 

represented by 14 white graves at the entrance. It is good to see a sign “Do Not Touch” on the

metal bed, a new and improved step toward preservation. When I first visit in 1995, I remember

blood stain still on the floor. Mr. Van Nath during his incarceration carried cement to build the

wall splitting each classroom into 2 interrogation rooms. The open windows near the ceiling

were sealed to muffle the screams of torture.

Page 3: A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

8/7/2019 A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-virtual-tour-of-tuol-sleng-genocide-museum 3/16

We are in front of “The Gallows”, a former high school rope-climbing exercise bar. Here, Mr.

Van Nath is recalling what he witnessed one evening as depicted in the painting by him in 1980:

he saw through an opening window from his workroom (in the direction of the pointing fingers,

middle of the former school) victims being drowned in the water containers and hung from the

exercise bar. Upon notice, a security guard went to shut the window.

Work brigades (of children, women, men – forced slave labor) in the provinces across Cambodia

during the 3 years, 8 months 20 days of the Khmer Rouge regime.

Page 4: A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

8/7/2019 A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-virtual-tour-of-tuol-sleng-genocide-museum 4/16

Evacuation of Phnom Penh, 17 April 1975, with young soldiers barely strong enough to carry the

AK-47. Map of the movements of people during the Khmer Rouge regime.

Former Khmer Rouge female personnel of Tuol Sleng who later became themselves became

victims. Mr. Van Nath pointed to a woman who is still alive but is reluctant to talk about her

Page 5: A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

8/7/2019 A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-virtual-tour-of-tuol-sleng-genocide-museum 5/16

experience as a former KR cadre. One feels the heaviness and the cruelty of the Khmer Rouge

regime; however, information about the rise of the Khmer Rouge and the victims are scant or

completely lacking… If we are to memorialize and educate, we need more than to know of the

cruelty but the lessons of history through objective, non-politicized facts and personal narratives

to give this generation and future ones hope and honored, sobered remembrance.

We are in front of another painting by Mr. Van Nath depicting victims being transported in

convoy trucks to be killed in Choeung Ek, a field about a 30 minute drive from central Phnom

Penh.

Each torture/interrogation room has this handwritten security regulations, now translated into

French and English and magnified for visitors (photo below). Mr. Van Nath says by the time

victims were brought into the interrogation room and see this security regulation, they would

have already lost consciousness.

Page 6: A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

8/7/2019 A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-virtual-tour-of-tuol-sleng-genocide-museum 6/16

 photo from Wikipedia

Page 7: A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

8/7/2019 A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-virtual-tour-of-tuol-sleng-genocide-museum 7/16

Kerry Kennedy, Michaela Kennedy Cuomo with special tour guide, Tuol Sleng former inmate

Van Nath, who is the epitome of dignity, 22 Feb. 2011. The inmates in Tuol Sleng comprised of 

former Lon Nol civil servants and officers, Cambodian peasants from the countryside, Khmer

Rouge rank-and-file falling out of favor of the regime and their family members, former Tuol

Sleng personnel, and . . .

. . . a handful of foreigners, like Kerry Hamill, a sailor from New Zealand (brother of civil party 

Rob Hamill).

Page 8: A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

8/7/2019 A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-virtual-tour-of-tuol-sleng-genocide-museum 8/16

Mr. Van Nath and I are standing next to a photo of corpses, taken immediately after they were

tortured and killed, as proofs to their KR superiors that they have done their job well, that these

individuals have not escaped. The one particular corpse above my head is that of a woman who

committed suicide from the 3rd floor (2nd floor French/Cambodian counting) of Building C,

witnessed by Mr. Van Nath. Every morning the security guard would come to unchain the ankle

of Mr. Van Nath to escort him to his work room where he drew huge portraits of Pol Pot. Every 

morning, the interrogator would come for 2-3 victims, shouted from the ground as interrogators

cannot enter the building, for the security guard to take these victims down. One morning the

security guard unchained the ankle of this woman and turned to unchain the ankle of Mr. Van

Nath. Within that split second, the woman jumped from the 3rd floor window to her death on

the dirt/pebbled ground (Mr. Van Nath's testimony at the Extraordinary Chambers).

Page 9: A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

8/7/2019 A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-virtual-tour-of-tuol-sleng-genocide-museum 9/16

 John Heffernan, Kerry Kennedy, Michaela Kennedy Cuomo with special guide of Tuol Sleng,

former inmate Van Nath in front of rows of shackles: the long ones are for many prisoners,

shackled by only one ankle; the shorter ones are for prisoners taken to be interrogated when

both ankles, criss-crossed, are shackled. Similar iron shackles were used for prisoners at

Boeung Rai Security Center in Svay Rieng where my mom, brothers and I were detained.

According to Mr. Van Nath, the provincial security centers tend to have wooden shackles.

Initially, the victims were killed on the grounds of Tuol Sleng but later they were transported in

convoy trucks to a field 30 minute drive away at Choeung Ek, now known as “The Killing Fields”

– what should be a place of honorable memorializing turned into a despicable commercial

private enterprise, sold to a Japanese company.

Page 10: A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

8/7/2019 A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-virtual-tour-of-tuol-sleng-genocide-museum 10/16

See my column: In (Sa cred) M em ory : M u s t P o l it i cs Obs t r u c t Ho no r i ng t h e Dead?

http://ki-media.blogspot.com/2010/04/in-sacred-memory-must-politics-obstruct.html 

http://www.thearyseng.com/images/VoiceOfJustice/vojinsacredmemoryjuly07.jpg 

Here we are in front of Building C where Mr. Van Nath was detained as a prisoner in 1978 on the

3rd floor (2nd Cambodian/French counting). A few steps to my right, behind Mr. Van Nath, was

the spot where the woman who committed suicide landed. Dr. Ervin Staub is pointing the steps

to the entrance where Mr. Van Nath informed us used to have a rug placed there by the Khmer

Rouge guards to mock the prisoners of their former class-consciousness. Here also Dr. Ervin

Staub explained to us how in other genocides as well the artists were valued by the perpetrators,

how during the Holocaust, the Nazis would have victim musicians play music to accompany the

killing of other victims. Mr. Van Nath bemoaned the fact that there is no sign to indicate the fact

this rug had been there as well as the sign slogan above the main entrance gate to Tuol Slengexhorting the beauty of the revolution.

Page 11: A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

8/7/2019 A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-virtual-tour-of-tuol-sleng-genocide-museum 11/16

 During our discussions in front of Building C, we were nicely joined by Dr. Helen Jarvis, retired

from the Extraordinary Chambers (ECCC) but still a spokesperson for the government, who

came to meet the Tuol Sleng director, but tomorrow (March 8 being a national holiday 

celebrating International Women’s Day), everyone had gone away. She informed us how her

book Getting Away with Genocide is now being translated into Khmer by DC-Cam.

Mr. Van Nath is showing us where the KR guards would hang the keys to the shackles of each

cell, on a numbered wooden plank.

Page 12: A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

8/7/2019 A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-virtual-tour-of-tuol-sleng-genocide-museum 12/16

 Individual cells where Mr. Chum Mey was detained. The prisoners were shackled by one or both

ankles depending on how difficult they are perceived to be.

The cells have been reinforced by the reddish metal structure. The other buildings and floors

also have these cells but they have been removed for other exhibitions; however, the marks

outlining each cell are still on the floor.

Page 13: A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

8/7/2019 A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-virtual-tour-of-tuol-sleng-genocide-museum 13/16

 A painting by Mr. Van Nath depicting his living conditions and those of the prisoners on the 3rd 

floor (2nd floor French/Cambodian counting) of Building C (still with screens of barbed wires).

The prisoners must ask for and be granted permission to sit up; their normal state was lying

down. They would eat there (twice a day at 8 a.m. and 8 p.m. – watery porridge totaling 5

spoonfuls, but to mock/demonize the prisoners, there were given the small coffee stirring

spoons) and would go to the bathroom there (in the bucket found near the ankles). Two to

three prisoners died daily; the corpse would not be taken away until a day or so later, lying next

to the other prisoners still breathing. Here, Mr. Van Nath showed us photos saved in his mobile

phone of two paintings he is saving for his children and grandchildren (refusing offers of sale):the prisoners being hosed down through the window by KR security guards, and another one of 

Tuol Sleng director Duch sitting between mounds of skulls with the verdict/judgment before

him.

Page 14: A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

8/7/2019 A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-virtual-tour-of-tuol-sleng-genocide-museum 14/16

 Photo of the only 7 known survivors of Tuol Sleng; now only three are still living: Mr. Van Nath,

Mr. Chum Mey (pictured below) and Mr. Bou Meng (pictured below) – all dynamic outspoken

advocates of victims’ rights.

Mr. Chum Mey, one of three living survivors of Tuol Sleng, here with Peder Pedersen of The

Charitable Foundation (founded by Australian philanthropist Steve Killelea who also founded

the Global Peace Index), 2010. He can be found most days at Tuol Sleng, here a chance

encounter after I had just finished telling Peder about Mr. Chum Mey and how we may run into

him. Mr. Chum Mey generously gave Peder and me a tour of the single cell he was detained in.

Page 15: A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

8/7/2019 A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-virtual-tour-of-tuol-sleng-genocide-museum 15/16

 

Mr. Bou Meng, one of the 3 living survivors of Tuol Sleng, here at our national conference:

Transforming Killing Fields into Healing, Living Fields of the Center for Justice &

Reconciliation (now a major project of CIVICUS: Center for Cambodian Civic Education), 11

Dec. 2009.

Mr. Van Nath and I are standing in front of an Exhibition with the biographies of the survivors

of Tuol Sleng, here in front of the photo/biography of Mr. Van Nath, 7 March 2011.

Page 16: A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

8/7/2019 A Virtual Tour of Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-virtual-tour-of-tuol-sleng-genocide-museum 16/16

 Mr. Van Nath, Dr. Ervin Staub and I sharing a lighter moment during our very heavy, dark tour

of Tuol Sleng, 7 March 2011.

Photos of Phnom Penh immediately after the end of the Khmer Rouge regime in January 1979,

including one of the National Bank completely destroyed, blown to pieces.