29
r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 .................. . 6' (a 'Ylrr·nu.) , I "" 0 "" A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI D. GJGJolwcrcro lrJ ' 1uri .96'l riu1fl3J l"!'Yltiin"l1"1l' q 6" 0 ... ( q VJ a 'I fl a 'Yl ti"l ru fl1 l-'11 n L U fl 'V\3J 1 tl L "lJ 1 Ci!. o Ci!./1£J ct Ci!.b 'IJ q ' V13J1 CiJ b ct/l£J ctc£(1!. "ll v:l a'l11 v:l a 'I fl L fl "il LL VI U'l U'l Vlll 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ mo l£JctCi!.l£J ;w 'IJ q m (1!. 'IJ 'IJ q q 'IJ iun 3J 1wn aV11t u (i.n 'IJ q q L Ci) 'IJ q 'IJ l£Jctc£l!:! l£J b cn//1£J ctCi!.m n 3J1l1oWUlf 1!:1 ctc£m q q q ... I Q...l ,AQ...of I 1).; #1:11),; ,d 1),; I Q,.;l Q..<l 'Yl1'11 Uti a tl1'1"l1 mL"l'l mru1 "ll au ., (i.n t1u1 ..... /"lnti"l"l3J ...

(a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI .................. .

6' (a 'Ylrr·nu.) ,

I

"" 0 "" A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI D. GJGJolwcrcro

A~"V~3J1Ut~tJU61\Irl e.~ltwcr lrJ

' 1uri .96'l L~au riu1fl3J l"!'Yltiin"l1"1l' l£lctct~

q

6" 0 ...

( a'Ylti"lnl.fl1l"'l"'1m~n) q

~ VJ a 'I fl ~flU a 'Yl ti"l ru fl1 ~ l-'11 n ~1 L U fl ~ 'V\3J 1 tl L ~ "lJ ~ 1 ~ Ci!. o Ci!./1£J ct Ci!.b 'IJ q ' ~

V13J1 m~"ll LL~'Ifi CiJ b ct/l£J ctc£(1!. "ll a'I~1~Unfl"la'li'u~u (~1~Unfl"la'l~'l"ll~1)

fl~ if~v:J a'lfl~ v:l a'l11 ~ v:l a 'I fl ~ L fl t~ftJ"l1 "1l'n1"l~1"l1 "il ~1 LL VI U'l ~ U'l ~u Vlll 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

(Yi1Wtl'1~VIU1t1Ufiu1in1"l~L~~) ~1"l1"il1llni'IVI1~.W'Yl~'11~m~a1u~ mo numt~u l£JctCi!.l£J ;w 'IJ q

~v:l a'lfl~L~rtmi1VIU1~~m"il"ll'~iunaJ"il1n'l1u m na'lrhnurrrmu~u~u~u ~1TI"il1lli11l1fl (1!. 'IJ 'IJ q q 'IJ

LL~~Li1V1u1~ ~1TI"il~1U~1TI"il1lln~1L1lmrl a'loW'Yl~ '~ iun 3J 1wn aV11t n~auL~un1"ll"'U u (i.n 1~) 'IJ q q

LL~~nn~1 L ilufl~~13Jnn'VI3J1tl ~1~i'IVI1~.W'Yl~'li.~rif11~l"'1n~1ufu~v:l a'lfl~ L~ a1u~ Ci) 'IJ ~ q 'IJ

~ ~1fl3J l£Jctc£l!:! ~ a3J1i'I'VIl~oW'Yl ~'I L~i:if11i'1~ l£J b cn//1£J ctCi!.m ~'llU ~ ~ n 3J1l1oWUlf 1!:1 ctc£m q q q ...

I Q...l ,AQ...of I 1).; #1:11),; ,d 1),; I Q,.;l Q..<l

LL~ 'I~ 'lflrn::nTI3Jn1"l~au~1U 'Yl1'11 Uti a tl1'1"l1 mL"l'l n"lru.~ a'IVI1fl~ mru1 "ll a'V\1"l13Jnu~ n~ au .,

L~Un1"ll"!uu (i.n 1~) l"!,;u~a1'Ylfl"' tf~unu 1~ t~i.lli.~fu m.p1J1~ 1~ t1u1 t~~1tJ~1"l1"il auu~

..... /"lnti"l"l3J ...

Page 2: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

i'n!i1'UJ Lilu~r~nn~11~1~ G> ~oWEJ\If'l~ Lilu~r~nn~11~1~ l!:! "ii1~1J~111';1 ~ETu ~uun1 'II 'II 'II 'II 'II 'II

LUU~flnn~11~1~ m LLL'I::"ii1~1J~111';1 :uuru m "ll'1~~ LUU~flnn~11~1~ ~ ~El:IJ1 'II 'II 'II ., 'II 'II

Lrlan11~El1J~1ULLtr1L~1';1 ~flnoWEl\lf'l~L~iif11&\li.:JWr~.W'YlL'I\I ~ l!:!l!:!~/l!J<f~<f L'l\llU~ mG> 'II 'II q

:un11 f1 :u l!:! <t~ ct L'l .:~ t w1~ i.~ ~-w a.:~ f1 ~a a n";J1 n11"1l'n11 ~-w a.:~f'l ~~.:~ i.~ EJ'Yl!i1rnf11 &.:~ L'I.:J t 'Yl ~ 'II 'II q

i. ~a an";J1n11"ll'n11~ e:Jf'l m::n11:1Jn11,r111"ll'n11~111';1 LLL'I:: i.~i'u LL ..ij .:~ ~ L'ln11~ ';111rn1 a 'Yl!i1rn q

~1:1JWU\I~El ~ ~"ll' ooo~.<fiG>~~~ L'l\llU~ l!:!~ n1n1'11fl:IJ l!:!<f~i> 1~£Jne:J'Yl!i1rn ~oWEl\lfl~ ~ q 'II

L ~u 11 f11 &.:~L'I.:~ t 'Yl~L~ ~-w EJ\If'l~ a an";J1n11"ll'n11"ll a.:~ ~r~n-w EJ\If'l~ Lilun11n1::rh t~wi.~"ll'au 'II '1.1'1.1

~1£Jnn~:u1 £J LLL'I:: i.~ LUU!iTI:unu~-w EJ\If'l~ L ita.:~";J1nf11&.:~~.:~n~11Lilun11 1"11~ L'I~U";J t~ £JL~"ll'au ~ 'II q

1un1TIUW\Il'I£J1u~tmnu ~-w EJ\If'l~ L~u11 ~-w EJ\If'l~iii.~n1::rhf111:1J~~ 1un11L~Un11l'I1Xu ... 'II 'II

L ~~~~oW El \1 fl ~ fl niu n :IJ 1 Uf111 :IJ ~ ~ L ~ £J1 n 1Jn11l'I1XU L ita.:~ ';11 n L~L ,]1 i.tltliiu~~ U1~ q'IJ 'II q CiJ

~1:uf11&.:~"1J a.:~ ~u.:~~uuru"ll'11 u~1 LL ~u..:~~tb £Jtliiu~n11~Lfl~ ~.:~f'lrn::n11:1Jn11~au~1u 'II ., CiJ

~~r~n-w a.:~f'l~ LL~.:~i.:~rhn11~au~1u t~ £Ji.~i.~L~£Jnl'l £J1ULan ~11~.:~ Liluf11 i.:~~1 ~ ~-w a.:~f'l~ '1.1'1.1 'II

tliiu~~,z1~1 u ~u.1 £Jtliiu~n11~ Lfl~ LLL'!::i.~i.~ ~au ~1u l'IL'I ~111';1~~ t1\!1rn ~:u\!1rn (~.:~ Lilu~u.:~~un11~111';11l!i1i.:~~1 ~-w'YlL'I\11 U"llrn::tf u) ~u.:~~uu ru"ll'1"ll a.:~~-w EJ\If'l~~ ~.:1n11

'II 'II q 'II ., 'II

~1 £111';111 ~ ~-w a.:~f'l~tliiu~~,z1~1 u ~u.1 £Jtliiu~n11~ Lfl~ au.Lilu l'l £J1u ~~1~ru~ ~-w a.:~f'l~ 'II CiJ CiJ ., 'II

L~ eJ1\I L 1l u.ffu~au ~1'1-l. LLL'I::f'l rn::n11:1Jn11~E11J ~1'1-l. i.~ii :u~1 ~ £J ~ L~El\1 L ita.:J";J1nL ~u 11 q

~oW El \1 fl ~L~L~ n1::Yi1 ~ ~i,X £J El ~1 .:1f1 £J LL 1\1 LL~ ~ fl noW El \1 fl ~~ \1 L UU~ El El n fl1 i.:~ LL~ \1 i.:~ 'II 'II 'II 'II

f'lrn::n11:1Jn11~El1J~1un ~u L ~ u 11 f111UL'I~ ~oW EJ\If'l~ a an";J1n11"ll'n11 au.Lilun11~';111nn 'II

~\I L iJu 1 'Yl ~LL fi ~oW El\1 f1 ~ t~ £JL~ L tJ ~ la n1 ~1 ~~oW El\1 f'l~L~iit an1 ~:jLL';I\1 LL~~\1 L ~ ~ ~ L'1 'II 'II q

L vl ai'n~1~'Yln-~1:1J~nn~:IJ1 £Jrl1~U~ LLL'I::~ fl noW El\lf'l~ ttl,] m Yl ';I ';I~ \1 :u11 "lfi'uW\Il'l £J1U ~ t n\1"1'1-l. ~ '1.1'1.1 ...

t~£JL~~";J~~ n~11~ El tb,Ya L Yl';l';l~\l~l'I,Xn.:~1U~El1J~1ULU~£J1J L Yl £Jutli'u ~oW El\lf1~1 u,J El~1 q 'II

u..ij.:~;m Yl';l~ m..ij1l'I1Xn.:~1u:u11"ll'LUn11L'I\I t 'Yl~~-w EJ.:Jf'l~ ~.:~~-w EJ\If'l~ L ~u11 n11Lm£JuLYI £Jutli'u 'II 'II

~\In ~111 u,J El ~1 LL ..ij'.:J;El L Yl';l tf U ~oW El \1 f1 ~ L ,]11 ';111 L iJ un11"1J El f111 :u·h :1J ii ElL vl a•1h £J L ~ ~ El 'II

l'I1Xn.:~1u~au~1u ~~1 L ii. un11iun :u~L~Un11l'I1X uii1 ~ r~n~1 L ii. un11'Y11.:1i1X£J ~.:~~oW EJ\If'l~ q 'II 'II 'II

iii.~~ar f11 1';1 LL~ a ~1.:~1~ ~.:~ 'l ~fl1 L'li.:~wr ~-w'Yl L'I.:J i.~~l'l1 n~1 Ltl~£Ju L Y1 £Jutli'u ~-w a.:~ f1 ~ q 'II

1 Uf111:1J ~~ L ~ £J1nun11l'I1Xu i.tlLLtr1~L'I1 £J L~ au LL~~flnoW EJ\If'l~n~ut.b,Y a L Yl';l';l~\l~\ln~11 '1.1'1.1

:u1 hrt un11L'I\I 1 'Yl~~-w EJ\If'l~ au.Lilun11W\Il'l £J1U~ ~n\1"1'1-l. t~ £JL~ LUU!i11:1J LLL'I:: 1 "lf~L'I~U";J 'II ... q

t~£Jii"ll'El1J

Page 3: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

"lJe.l 'l ~fl1~~~T~vnm.f1'VI~a~1 i., 'l ~L ~nfl au~1i..1"ll a..1 ~fin~ a..1r~~~1:1J~1 i., '1.1'1.1

~ l£1101!i'!/l£1<f<1'<:t ~..1-lu~ rnCi) aJn'l1fi:JJ l£1<:t<1'<f ~i..1~..11'Yl~1~~~a..lfl~aan-;nn'l1"15n1'l '1.1 .,

~fin~ a..1 r~~'l ~ n1'l11 ~fin~ a..1r~~1~~n1'lLL~..1<1l..1 r~ru.::n'l'l:JJn1'l~au~1'" '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 '1.1

'Yl1..11 uf..l~ a~~ a..1r~~ LL~::r~m::n'l'laJn1'l~au~1'" 'Yl1..1iuf..l1~ ~1 Lit un1'l~au~1u~1aJn!) n. ~. '1.1

uuu~ Ci)~ (~.fl. l£1<f<1'o) aan~13Jfi113J LU~'l::d1"15Ut1JtY~'l::LU f..IU"li1Tl"l5n1~~L~au ~.fl. l£1<frn<:t

11~1f..ln1'l~au~1U~'<il1'lnl.1 hw'lu1u~ \o> ~U1fi:JJ l£1<f<1'rn r~ru.::nTiaJn1'l~au~1U'Yl1..1iuf..l 1~LLi..lLL~::aRU1f..l"li an~11'VI1 L~ ~~ a..lfi~'Yldl1JLL~1 ~~ a..lfl~1~~ n1'lU1i L~li~~a~"li an~11'VI1

'1.1 '1.1 ~

LL~:: L U 1uL~ f..l1nun1~LL i..1 L ~ ~~ a..1 fl ~'Yl'l11J ti..1 ~'YlR~'<il::1~~1J LL i..1 ~'lU~ f..I1U 'VI ~n ~1U ~ '1.1 ~ ~

~UU~U u"li an~11'VI1 LL~::n1'l L ~ tl a ml1'VI~a:fLL'<il..l LLn"li an~11'VI1 ~ ~ a~'<iJUel1..1~ f.J1U 'VI ~n~1U ~ ~

'VI~mt 1~ f..I1U 'VI tn~1u:u1~u LLn"li an ~11'VI1 'VI ~..l'<il1ntt'" r~ru.::nnaJn1'l~au~un1~~1Litun1'l ~

~aU~1U'l11J'l13J~f.J1U'VI~n!1U~L~f..l1"lia..1 LL~::Lrla-Ju~ \o> ~fJ~1l1fi3J l£1<f<1'rn n1~~uwnn n1'lLLi..lLL~::~U'Yl'l1u"li an~11'VI1LL~::~f..I1U'VItn~1'"~~uu ~'" u"li an~11'VI1 'l ~~~ a..1r~ ~'Yl'l1U

~ ~ '1.1

LL~!:fl ru.::n'l'l:IJ n1'l~au ~1U 'Yl1..1luf..l1~1 'V11 an1 ~~~ a..1 fl ~ LL n"li an~11'V11 ~1:uuufi nn af..l~1 '1.1

"ll a..1 ~ fl nn ~11'VI1 Lrl a1'" ~ Ci)~ ~fJ~1l1flaJ l!:l<f<1'rn LL~::~ ~ a..1r~~1~ LLn"li an~11'VI1 L ~ aJ L~ aJ '1.1'1.1 '1.1

Lrl a1u~ 1!:1~ ~fJ~1l1fi3J l£1<f<1'rn t~f..l1~ ~aUfi13J~~ a..lr~~11'<il!:el1..1~f..I1UL~ 'lun1'l~uu~u'" '1.1 ~

~1 L ~ n1'lLL n"li an ~11'VI1 LL~ ~ ~ a..lfl~ LLi ..11113J"ll a el1..1~ f.J1U L~ L U n1 'l L ~ n 1 'l ~UU ~U U '1.1 ~

LLn"li an ~11'VI1 LL~ a ~1..1 'l~ ~fin~ a..1r~ ~~., L ~'" 11 n1'l~1 Lit un1'l~au ~1U"ll a..1 r~ ru.::n'l'laJn1'l '1.1'1.1

~aU~1U 'Yl1..1lUf..l1~1 'VI1an1 ~LL~:: L ~ fi113J dJUli'l'l:IJ LL ri ~~ a..lfi~L un1'l'VI1~ f..I1U 'VI ~n~1U '1.1 ~

L ~aLL n"li an ~11'VI1 LL~1 LL~!:fl ru.::n'l'l:IJ n1'l~au ~1U 'Yl1..1l Uf.J1~ ~'lU ~ ~ n1'l~au ~1 UL~Ua ~

~fin~ a..lfl~ttu ~fin~ a..lfl~ L ~U 11 LLaJ11flnl.!:n'l'l:JJn1'l~aU~1U'<il!:~fi113J L ~U L ~ f.J~ L~a..l '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 ~

LL~:: L ~Ua~ a ~fin~ a..1 fl ~L U~1U:: ~LL~..l ~..1 fl ru.::n'l'l:IJ n1'l~au ~1U 'Yl1..1lUf..l LL~ ~fin~ a..lfl ~ '1.1'1.1 ~ '1.1 '1.1'1.1

L ~u11 ~fJ ~n1'lrn"ll a..1 ~~ a..1r~~ LiJun1'ln'l::lh tl~iuf..l a ~1..11'1 f..l LL'l..l~ ~aJfl1'l~., t 'Yl~ '1.1

tl ~~a an'VI~a1~ a an ~.,~fin~ a..1 fl ~~a :u ~ a1u 1'<il 'l un1'l~'<il1'lm11~ t~ f..l~ a..1 L"i..1 L~a..l 'l ~ '1.1'1.1

a.n.~'l. ~..l'VI1~ ~.,~~a..lr~~i..ln~a~~'<il1'lm1 Lrla a.n.~'l. i..1'V11~~aJ~a~1..1'l~ ~fln~a..1r~~ '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 '1.1

n ~ a~tliju111tl~13Jtt'" t~f.J LU'Y11..1tl1iu1i Lrl a~ fl n~ a..lfl~1~~ ~1i..lLL~..l~..lflm::nTI3Jn1'l~au~u ~ '1.1'1.1

'Yl1..11 u f..l LL~ 1 'VI1n ~ ~n1'l~au ~1UU'l1nlJ11r~ru.::n'l'l:JJn1'l~au~1'" 'Yl1..11 u f..I'VI~ a~ fl n~ a..1r~~ '1.1'1.1

~fi113JL ~ u11~ fl nn~11'VI1n'l::·vhtl ~1 uf..la~1..1f1mL'l..l~ ~3Jfl1'l~..l 1 'Yl~tl~~aan'VI~ a1~ a an '1.1'1.1

~ fl n~ a..1r~~'<il::~ a..1L"i ..lL~a., 'l~ ~u ru"l51n1'l~1'l1'<il1lmn1r~ ..., ~.,1~~uaJaua1U1'<il'<il1n~1u n..11u '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 ., '1.1

Page 4: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

~1TI';JLL~\I"lf1~iLilu~~\IL~EJ\11\X n.~1. ~';111rn1 L~EJ n.~1. ~3J~EJ~1\11~ ~1Un\11\.b~1TI';JLL~\I"lf1~ '1.1

'VI~mfuru"lf1n11~111';1111l1111fl ~ ';l:;LU\.b~i\I'VI~mJ 1iu~1U~13J3J~"ll El\1 n. ~1. LL~:;';l::LL,)\1 '1.1 ... '1.1 '1.1 CcJ

~~n11~1 L itun11 1\X~rm~ EJ\Ifl~'Y1111J ~\ln11~1 L itun11~\ln~11~V1 ~1 r.~.ffu~ au r'h 1\Xdi~ '1.1'1.1

fl113J~1"1f1 ~1Un\11\.b~1TI';JLL~\I"lf1~~\11~~fhi\l~ "0Jct!1§:Jcf.ct(i) ~\11\.b~ (i)O 'V'l'l~~n1r.l\.b l!lcf.ci(i)

3JEJUEl1\.b1';1 1\X ~nn~ EJ\Ifl~ Lilu~ ~\1~1\.b1Un11GlEJUGn\.bLL~::~u~~n11GlEJUff'"lU1lX n. ~1. ~';111rn1 '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 q

LL~:: 1\X~nn~a\lfl~Lilu~i..,'VI~a1\Xu1i~~13J3J~ n.~1. l~r.1~1\l ~\ILilu 1u~13J'V'l1::1l"lfururu~ '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 CcJ ......

... ... ... '1 ... "'.":1 ... 1::LlJr.llJ"ll111"lfn11'V'l~L1El\.b 'V'l.~. l!lcf.rncf. 111~11 (i)oci 111flGlEJ\I (l!l) ~un1rn"llEJ\I~l"'El\lfl~

'1.1

L~ a~nn~ EJ\Ifl~~';l11rn1~ ~n11GlEJUGl1ULL~1 L v;w:h n1::r'i1 ~~iur.~ a ~1\li'1 mL1\I ~..,1~~.., '1.1'1.1

L~a\11\X n.~1. ~';111rn1 t~r.~ a.n.~1. L~rJ1nun11~1Lilun1')'1'11\Jiur.~ flrn::~ (i) ~..,1~fu3JEJU'V13J1rJ ';11n n.~1.1un11U1::"lf3Jflf\l~ l!l"'J/l!lcf.ctct L~a1u~ (i)G1/ numr.~u l!lcf.ctct ~';111ni.1LL~1~3J~1\X

q

~\ll'YIM1~~~EJ\Ifl~EJEJn';J1n11"lfn11 ~\1 n.~1.1un11U1::"lf3Jflf\l~ (i)~/l!:Jcf.ctct L~a1u~ (i)(i) '1.1 q

i'U11fl3J l!Jcf.ctct n~3J~flJ'YI111J ~nn~EJ\Ifl~~\I~El\l~fhi\1~ l!Jl!J~/l!Jcf.ctcf. ~\11\.b~ rn(i) '1.1'1.1

11n11 fl3J l!l cf.ctcf. ~\I l 'YIM 1~ ~~ EJ\Ifl ~a an';l1n11"lfn11 ~ EJ3J1 ~~ EJ\Ifl~1~"11ua'YI1rnll·~ a n.~1. '1.1 '1.1 q

VI "' .,.. "' ' '1 ::. ..1 d ..... ..1 LL~:: ~~ LLrl~\ln11nl.~1r.l11';11 LL~ n.~1. ~\.bn1W~"lf3Jfl1\I'YI (i)/l§:Jcf.ct"'J L3J El1\.b'YI (i)cf. 3Jn11fl3J l!Jcf.ct"'J

q

n ij 3J~ r.~n El 'Yill1rn LL~::1EJ\I\.b 1 r.~nf~ll\.b~~ ('V'l ~ L El n "lf1 ~ ~ rJ \IL ';1 rJ 'YI ll) U 1i U~ 11 "lfn11 LL 'YI \.b q ... q CcJ

u1 r.~nf~11u~~n ~f11 i..,1\X r.~n EJ'Yill1rn~13J 11 ~"ll a \I n. ~1. n11~1 Lit un11~\ln ~11"1l1\l ~u ... q

"llEJ\I~nn~ EJ\Ifl~1~u1i~~13J.ffu~ au"ll a \In 1l'V\3J1 r.~ LL~di1~nkuLLn~..,~~ EJ\Ifl~1 'VIL~fu l 'YIM '1.1'1.1 CcJ ~ '1.1

'1'11\liumL~ a ~1..,1~ ~1un1rn ~~~a \I fl ~ eJ1\I':h 1 u"ll rn::~ ~~ EJ\1 fl ~ nniu n 11 ~~a.., fl ~ '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 q '1.1

1~u~u~V1tl:1~1 un11~utl1u V11"1l11 LL~::~ a\lunil~ Glrl1U111'V'l~ LL 'tl';)'i\l"ll a \I~~ a\lfl~ fh ~a '1.1

u1:: lr.~"lfu1un11~uGnuVI1"ll11~13J~1~fu3Jau'V13J1rJL'lXu1iu~VIu1~,fu, ~n n~ EJ\Ifl~ Lv;u11 CcJ '1.1'1.1

"llrn::Ln~L'VI~Lu1u~ rno rl\.br.11r.l\.b l!lcf.ctl!l ~~El\lfl~1~nn~unll1u~Ln~L'VI~ .ffuiunll q '1.1 '1.1 q q q

LL~::.ffUGlEllJff'"l\.bfl~ mru1 ~~ El\lfl~1~1\X n1TilJGl11111'V'l~1r.lfl113JGl~ fl11';1 LL~1~LL,)\I~mL~::~ El ~ ... '1.1 '1.1

eJ \.bLU \.bL Yl ';1 ~~fl~ Ellru1~1~i\I'VI1 ~oW 'YI~ \1~ ffinM1~\I l 'YIMUflJ~ ~ El\lfl~ L~ a1 \.b ~ (i) ~ ~1fl3J l!lcf.ctl!J ... q '1.1 q

LL~:: 1u1u~ rno 'V'l{l~~n1r.l\.b l!lcf.ctl!J n1~nmmrJULfi r.~uufu"ll El'VI1LL,)\I~mL~::~ El~ el\.bLU\.bLYJ';l '1.1 '1.1

LL~::~~n11GlEJUGl1U '1'11\11 u r.~~..,1~~ n11GlEJUGl1u~113J~ un 11~1\lnl\X n11fl urT u 11 ~ ~ EJ\Ifl~ '1.1 q '1.1

1~1111nu~n ~au L~un11'V'lu u,-;)1\1 ~..,,! u, n1~ ~~ EJ\Ifl~ eJ1\Ii1L'VI~~nn~un 3JLttEJ\1';11n;uff'"Ju '1.1 q '1.1 q

V11"ll11LL~::<ti El\IUniJ~Glrl1\.b111'V'l~ LL'tl-;)1\IL ~ EJU1:: l rJ"lfU1 un11~1J Gl1\.b V11"1l11 ~\Iii EJ1';JflJVJ'\11~

Page 5: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

L ~ EJ~1'Yl1..1"1hm ~~ EJ1u.'t'lu.Yi't'lu.1~"ll rn~fl n ~ u n 11 LL~ n t u 11111 £1-.'11 u. 1 tX ~ u-.1 T1uu ru"..f1'Yl111J 'IJ q 'IJ .,

L~ EJ1u. ~ (j) G'll 11 n11 fl11 l!:! ct<L' m 1 ~ £J ~1u ~fl n-rl e1..1 "~~"LV: u. i1 n11~1 L ii, u. n11'Yl1-.'lium1u q 'IJ 'IJ

~YlEJ..1fl~1~ £Jn11~..1 1 'Yl~L~EJ e1n~1n11".lfn11L~~1L itu.n11LU~111.ffu.~EJU. i~n11 ~tmnrnsti' 'IJ

~n!J~111m11~u.~'Ylnu1~n11 ~Yl EJ-.'Ifi~T1~~1u.~h 1tX n11i1 ~111f111tX n11"11El-.'l~flnYl El-.'lfl~i1fl~n1111n11 'IJ 'IJ'IJ

~EllJ ~1-u. 'Yl1-.'li ,X £JL~ ~EllJfl111 ~ Yl e1..1 "~ LL~ 1i1~~ a1..1'W £J1U. 1~ 1 u.n11~1X u~u. u.f111 tX n11 'IJ q

mi"li e1n~11~1 LL~~~Yl EJ-.'Ifi~L~LL~-.'Ifl~n1111n11~EllJ~1U.'Yl1-.'liu£Ji1 LaJ"lJEJ el1-.'I'W mu.uflfl~ 1~ 'IJ q

1 u.n11~UlJ ~'" u.f11 LL n"li El n ~11~1,!'" eriAl El" fl ~ L V:u. i1 ~Yl El-.'lfl ~L~ ~ EllJ"li EJi'n fi111"1J El-.'1 q 'IJ 'IJ

"~n1111n11~e1u~1u. 'Yl1-.'liu£Ji1 "iJ..,1aJ a1..1-w £J1u." ~"~111£J~..,~~a1-.'I'W£J1u. 1-u..ffu.~ e1u.~ e1 1u

~t-.'I'Yl11lJ"liEln~11~1on~LL~-.'ILL~1 LL~fl~nTI11n11~EllJ~U.'Yl1-.'llU£Jniuuu.fini1 "LaJel1-.'I'W£J1U."

au.d:Ju.n11uu. Yinti' e1 £1f11~-rr~nuf111 tX n11"ll e1..1 ~Yl e1..1" ~ LL~~n11~ ~finiAl EJ-.'Ifl~~~11rn1 'IJ 'IJ'IJ

~1U.1U.n11~EllJ~1U.~fl~nTI11n11~EllJ~1U.'Yl1-.'liu£JL~'L~Eli1fi11£J~L~El-.'l ~1nerflnYlEJ..1fl~ q 'IJ 'IJ

LaJ LV: u.~1£JnlJfi1111L V: U."llEJ-.'Ifl~n1111n11~EllJ~1U.'Yl1-.'liu£J ~finiAl EJ-.'Ifl~ ~ e1..1 1ifl~nTI11n11 'IJ'IJ

~EllJ~1u. 'Vl1-.'li ,X £J'Yl1n11~EllJ ~1U.L ~ 11 L~ 11~-u. L~"li e1 L l1 ~~~ ..1 LL~~u11n!]~ i n!1U.~ -n~ L ~ u.

LL ~ ~ ~ El "1 ~1 El n 1 ~ ~ Yl El " fl ~ L ~ LL n "li El n ~ 11 ~ 1 L ~ 11 L ~ 11 a n flf" ~ it" n 11 ~ er fl n Yl El " fl ~ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

LaJ ~1Lit u.n11~..1n~11 LL~ntu~-.'IL~El-.'1~ e1 LUrJ-.'1 n.~1. ~..1Ltlu.n11n1~'Y11~LaJfl n~ EJ..1~111.ffwnEJU. 'IJ

LL~~LUU.n11n1~'Y11~LaJ"..fEJ1J~1£Jnn~111 £J LL~~~YJ El-.'lfl~ L V:u.i1 uu.finn11~1Jn11~-.'llU.~ mo ~ 'IJ q

' ' Q...ol o A Q...ol Q..f Q...l A a....- d

nU.£11 £J U. l!:J ctCL'l!J LL~ ~fl1 'W 'W1 n ~1"11 El ..1 f'l1 ~ ~-.'! ~1 ~'W 'Vl ~ -.'1 L 11 El1 U. 'Vl f9) ~ ~1 fl11 l!:J ct CL'l!:J q q

~" LUU.LEJn ~11~1T1ru~'Y111 tX ~Yl EJ-.'Ifl~flnn ~11~1J u. LaJu11n n~EJ"ll e1..1 ~Yl e1..1 fl~i1fln~un 11 ., 'IJ 'IJ ow 'IJ 'IJ q

~~Elflnf'I1~~'W1n~11 i~-.1 1 'Vl~LL~ El ci1..1 1~ 'IJ

~ fl n-rl El-.'lfl~1i n11L ~ 11L~ 11i1 n11~ er Yl El-.'lfl~ el1-.'li1 L~ ~EllJ"li Eli'nfi111"1Jel-.'l 'IJ'IJ 'IJ

fl~nTI11n11~EllJ~U.'Yl1-.'llU£Ji1 LaJ"lJEJel1-.'I'W£J1U.lJ flfl~ 1 u.n111 tX n11~UlJ ~'" U.LL n"li El n ~11~1 q q

~..1~111£J~-.'IiJ-.'!LaJ el1-.'I'W£J1u.1u."llrn~J u. ~finiAl EJ-.'Ifl~ LV:u.i1 n11n~11el1..1~-.'ln~11"1JEJ-.'!~Yl EJ-.'Ifl~ 'IJ'IJ 'IJ

n ci El11~111 £1~-.'1 ~YJ El-.'lfi~LaJ el1-.'I'W£J1U.lJflfl~ 1u.n11~1J~ U.LLrl"li e1n~11~1,_t U.LEl-.'1 ~1U.fi1111L V:u. 'IJ q q

"lJEl-.'lerflnYl El-.'lfi~~LaJ L V:u.~1£JrllJfi1111L V:u."lJEJ-.'Ifl~n1111n11~EllJ~1U.,fu, erflnYl El-.'lfl~ L V:u.i1 'IJ'IJ 'IJ'IJ

' A A.Q..;.d .d fJI f(t;

L11 EJn11~EllJ ~1U."ll e1..1 fl rn~n1111n11~e11J ~1-u. 'Vl1..11U.£J1111 £J ~~ LEJ £J~ fi11Jfi1U.~111J1ni.LL~1 'IJ

n1aJ'il1Lu '"~ e1..1 1 tX ~EllJ~1u.L ~ 11L~ 11~~El~El1J~1u.1 ~aJ LL~~1aJ'il1Luu.~ e1..1 LL~.., 1tX eriAl El-.'lfi~'Vl111J 'IJ

L -d, El-.'1~1nn11~EllJ~1U.LU U.11 £J~~La £J~"ll El-.'ln11111J1111"li ElL -ti ~~~ ..1 LL~~"li Eln!J~111 £J ~1U.L~El-.'l

~

/fi1111LWU. ...

Page 6: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

fl113JL~ U iJJ~1Lih~,] El\IL ~ UL ~ij EJUrlU LL~::n1-ITI ~oW El\lfl~ el1\l';h uufi nn1')~ un aJLL~::fh~Ynm~n 'IJ q

' " ' "lJEl\lff1~i\l~l ~oW'Yl~\ILlhh1nn~a~.W El\lfl~ LL~ aci1\11~tt U ~fl n.W El\lfl~ L ~w;h n L'ilEJ\13J1-;J1n

q dJ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

~oW El\lfl~ LL,)\IimL~::~ El ci el udJuL Yl -;J';hia U1 m~ ~ L OW"D'')U U LL~::L~ ~\lim Yl-;JJ\11 uuwn n 'IJ 'IJ q

' ' ' ,:::.Q...I AQ..,I o Q,..l cv Q,..l Q..,l a A

'Yl1\11U~"ll EJ\1 fl ru::n')')aJ n1')"EJ1J "1u 'Yl1\11U~ ~1aJ fl1 "\I -;J\1~ 1 ~ow'Yl ~\I 'Yl 1!:1" cn~ll!:l <f<i:' rn L ')EJ\1 q

.... ' ' I Q.,, lj,.l Q,.ll ,::::1 Q...l fj' .cl I C),.l I

LL~\I~\Iflnt::n')')aJn1')"EJ1J"1U"lJ1')1"11n1') ~\11U 'Yl ~ n aJ1110WU!i l!:l<f<i:'rn 'Yl L~El~ Elf.J11')1"11n1') q 'IJ

~..,~1 ~-w'Yl ~..,J..,~ aJ ~ (l!:l) ~ tt.., ~a a'Yl!i')rufh i.., ~..,1 'Yl ~1~ a an-;J1 n')1"11n1')"1J a \I ~.W a \I fl ~ q q 'IJ

uuu ~\11u ~ " iiu 1 flaJ l!:l <f<i:' <f ( rn) G&1 L u 1')1 ~\11U n1')1h::"l1aJ aun')')aJ n1')fl ru::n')')aJn1') q q

I .... I I I """ o d Q..l 6' ""' 6' Q...l .::1. A Q..l .d. ca,..o

"111')1 "11n1')'il1')1 ';) Ln ~ 1 n 1J El 'Yl !i')ntLL~ !;')EJ\1 'Yl n"ll fl') \1 'Yl cnl oll!:l <f <i:' <f L 3J El1 u, 'Yl GTI 0 n u, ~1 ~ u, q q

l!:l <f<i:'<f LL~:: ( <i:') G&1 L U1')1 ~\11Un1')th::"l1aJflnt::n')')aJn1')"li1')1"11n1')~1')1-;J flf\1~ Ci)/l!:l <f<i:'" q

d ..., d L aJ a1 u 'Yl Ci) ct aJ n ')1 flaJ l!:l <f <i:'"

" ff1 ~tJn fl')EJ\Joiu,Yu, ~';11')nt, 1 LL~1 L ~ U 11 3J1 'iJ')1 rn ~ LL v\\10W')!:')1"11UnJ ru~ ... ...

')!; LU ~1J"li1')1"11n1')~1')1';) ow. ff. l!:l <fl!:l Ci) u ruru~1 ~~11')1"11n1')~\J~l~ ii el1U 1';1 i\1 LL~\1~\1 ... ... 'IJ

' " fl nt:: n ') ') 3J n 1 ') " EllJ "1 U LL ~ :: ~ \1 ~ \1 1 'Yl ~ "li 1 ') 1 "11 n 1 ') ~ 1 ') 1 ';! ~ 1 LL ~ U \1 ;( \1 LL ~ "1 ') 1 'il ') ~1m Yi ~ u "1')1 'il')~ \laJ11 u ')1 "11n1')1J~~1')~1 u11 ii 111 fl"ll a \1 n')aJ ~1')1 -;J aJ1 'il')1 "o L~ a \1

'IJ

1 ~t.b n!) n')!:'Yl')1\l n!) n. OW. t!i ~ t!i aJ11 "lfu\1 f1'u 1 ~ ~ El t.t 1 ~ 3J LL ~:: 3J1 'iJ')1 "Ci) rh ~ U~ 1 ~

n1')~1 L U U n1 ')'Yl1 \li tt ~ n u"li1 ')1 "11n1')~1')1 ';! 1 ~ t.b ~ 3J1 ~ <i:' ~ 3J1 ~ <f LL ~ ::~ 3J 1 ~ cnl

n !I~ aJ1 ~11 ~1 ~'):: L ii ~ u"li1')1"11n1')0W ~ L1auaJ11 "lfu\1 f1u 1 ~~a t.t 1 ~ aJ LL ~:: aJ1 'il')1 Ci) o 1!:1

LL ri"li1')1"11n1')0W ~ L1au"13T ru ~.., iin')rnel'uiiaJ ~~fl1')n ~11~111n')::th ~~itt~ 1 ~"au "1u ... 'IJ

L vl a1 ~1~fl11aJ';J~\I LL~:: ~~!i')')aJ 1~ ~Llii'n"lf1 n1')~1 L ii. un1')'il1aJ1')')fl~ rt.., n1 Lilun')rn q

n~11~111n')::·vh ~~it!~ a ci1.:JLl1~1 ~ LL ')\11 ~ ~1 L ii.un1')'il1aJinn1')~ ~u.:Jf1uuru"l11 'IJ ...

" L ~u"aJ fl1')tl1 d]un')rnn ~11~111 n')::rh ~~itt~ a cl1\1~1 ~ LL ')\11 ~LL~\1 i.:J fl ru::n')')aJ n1')

..r 0 1 .¥.... .... .... ' tJ ..., d ..., "1JU'Yl1n1')"EJ1J"1U LL~:: Un1')"EJ1J"1UU'il El\ILL';l\l"ll an~11~1LL~::~ OW~1U~~mi1U'Yl ~1J~ U

q a q

"lian~11~1L rh~ii1 ~~r~nn~11~1'Yl')11J 1~ ~-;J::')::u~1a Lli')::uiaow ~1u~ ~mnunL~ J..,d' 'IJ 'IJ q q a

Lvl a1~ ~flnn~11~1:JLL-;J\JLL~::u 1~1JLLn"li an~11~1 Ld El~1L U Un1')LL~1tl1V! \IL~11 ~flnn~11~1 'IJ'IJ 'IJ'IJ

1~n')::th~~itt~n1~~1Lii.un1') 'il1aJaJ1'il')l Ci)OGTI ~~am'il')l Ci)o<i:' LL~1LL~n')rn n1tT.:JVI\IL3JL~11

.... ' lr.J r1 nn~11~1 ...

'IJ'IJ

Page 7: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

~flnn~11'VI1n'l::'Yl1~<iliu£J~\I";J::£J ~ L~a\IL~ ~1U'VI~mnru.~LL~::ilin1'l~ L ~ £J1nun1'l~au~1u, ~~ q

'W';J1'lnt1 n'lrn~~ a\ILL~\I~\Iflnt::n'l'l3Jn1'l~au~1uiu£J a ~1\11'1 £J LL 'l\11 V:Ltlu i.tJ<i~13J~n1'VIU<il 1un!J n:v-1. ~\In!) n:w. uuu~ (g)~ ('W.fl. l!!cf~o) aan<il13Jfl113J1u-w'l::'l1"1l"UtytY~'l::Lu£Ju

"li1'l1"l!"n1'l'W~ L~au, -w. fl. l!:l elm ct 11~1 £Jn1'l~au~1U 'W';J1'lnt1 i.~iin1'lll1'VIU<il'l1 £J ~::La £J<il ~ CV CV fJ' A.d. A 1.1 d I I 0 A A CV

Ln £J1n u'VI ~ m n nt'Yl LL~::1tin1'l~au ~1u -w ';J1'lnt1"ll1'l1"1l"n1'l'Yl fl nn~11'VI111n'l::'Yl1 ~ <il1 u, £J ~

a~1\li'1£JLL'l\IL1 ~1'VIi'Ufl~tt"limii";J';)'i\IU'l1n!J11 L~a1u~ rno nu£J1£JU, l!Jcf~ "llnt::~~v:la\lfl~ LUU"li1'l1"1l"n1'l~1'l1';) ~1LL'VI'I-i\I~U\IfllJ'V\aJ vl1'VIU1~'VI't.i. 1£JtJnu~ n1'l'W Lfl~ ~1'l1';J11tn"i\I'VI1 <il

~ ~ dJ ~

'l4''Yl~\l i.~r~n L ,)1'VIU1~~1'l1';J";J1nn a\ln1nun1'l~1J~1u~au~1u ~1'l1';Jl11l'l111fl ~ LL~:: q ~ ~

L ,)1'VIU1~ ~1'l1';J~flTil~1'l1';J111l'lih L11 m~ a\l'l4''Yl ~\I ,Jun3J 1 u"li a'V\1 L~Un1'l'WU u, (Lu 1~) ~ q q

1<il£JiiL~fuau,nn~ ~v:J a\lfl~L~LL,)\I;mL~::~a~ 5uLUULii";J11 U1£JL~<il L'W"ll"'nLU 'WUn\11U~au~u, qOI ~ ~ q

i.~ 'Yl1n1'l"Ltn £JU L fl £JutJfu~ v:J a \If!~ ;j1U i.aJ LL~<il\IU ~'l"U'l::~1~ 1 LL~:: LL-;) \1; a~ a~ 5 ULU UL Vi ";J ~ ~ ~

~1Ufl113J ~ ~;j1ut n~ auL~ un1'l'WU u, (Lu 1~) 1<il £Ji.aJi.~fu au ru1~ ~v:J a\lfl~fu~1'l111'W ~ q 01 ~

fl1 ~i\I'VI-l <i!'l4''Yl ~ \I'W'W1 n ~1 ~\11 'Yl ~tJfu ~v:l a \I fl ~ LUUL~U (9), cfoo 1J1'Yl ~a 3J1 ~fl nv:l a \If!~ q ~ ~ ~

I I I ....

i.~ii~hi\li\I'VIi'<i!'l4''Yl~\l Yll!l'o>G'll/l!!ct~rn ~\1-lufl ~ n3J111'l4'ulf l!!cf~rn LL~\I~\Iflnt::n'l'l3Jn1'l q q

~au ~1 u, 'Yl1 \li ,r £J ~v:J a \1 fl ~ LL ~ ::-w 1 n 'l13J ~ 'l1 £J n'lrn fl n n ~11 'V\111 n'l::'¥11 ~ <il i ,r £J ~ ~

a ~1\11'1 £JLL 'l\1_!1U~n~ au L~Un1'l'WU u, (Lu 1~) 1<i! £JLaJi.~fu attty1~ L 'VI~ L n<il L~ ai'u, ~ rn o

nu£J1£JU l!!cf~l!! ~U1UL~"ll~ rn~/G'll flUUL"l!"£JlJ~ ~11J~fl'VI1~1'l'l~ ehL11m~a\l'l4''Yl~\l q ~ q

i\I'VI-l <i!'l4' 'Yl ~\I LL~:: L v; u, 11 ~v:J a \I fl ~ L tlu~i.aJtJ'l::-w q ~ ~u, 1 V:L fl'i \1 fli'<il ~a 3J'l'l£J1'Yl LL~::'l:: LU £J u q ~ ~

LLlJlJ LL~U"ll a\1~1'l1';J U'l::'Wq~ ~u, LaJ~3Jfl1'l LL~:: L UU"li1'l1"1l"n1'l'W~ L~aU~13Jty~ a\lfn~1

;a L ~£J \l"ll a \I~ ULL~ ::fn ~1 L n £J'l~ ~n ~"ll a \I ~1 LL 'VI U\1 'VI U 1~'l1"1l"n1'l"ll a \1 ~uii1 V:L ~a 3J L ~£J 1 <il £J i.aJ n'l::'¥11 n1'l1<il GJ 5u i.~;a11 L tlu~ u'l::-wq~i'1 LL~::n'l::'Yl1n1'l~ u, 1<i15u i.~;a11 LU u,

~

~ U'l::'W '1 ~ i'1 a ~1 \11'1 £] LL 'l \1 5 u, L tJ Ufl113J ~ <il ~13J 'W 'l::'l1 "ll"U ru ru~ 11 ~ 1 £] i ,r £] ~1 'l1 ';) ~ 01 01

'W'Yl1l~n'l1"1!" l!J~G'l!G'll 3J1~'l1 ct au, rn, G'll LL~:: (9)l!J LL~::LUUfl113J~<il~13J3J1~'l1 ~~ q q

.d I CVCVA 1 .a:l ljl A

1'l'lfl 'VI U\1 LL~::1'l'lfl~a\l LL 'VI \I'W'l::'l1"1!"1J ruru ~ LL 'VI \l'l:: L lJ £J lJ"lJ1'l1 "ll"n1'l'W ~ L 'la u, 'W. fl. l!J ct rn ct 01 01

~v:J a \I fl ~L<i!L ,X ti a £JfhtJ~ L~1l~ ~ a<il"li an~11'VI1 fl ru.::n'l'l3Jn1'l~au ~1u 'Yl1\liu£JL~'l1U'l13J

-w £J1U 'VI tn;j1U 1<il £J~au~1u -w £J1U1Jflfl~ (9) ~ tJ1n LL~::'l11J'l13J'W £J1ULan~1'lLL~::'VI ~n;j1U ~ ~ q ~

L ~ £J1"1i a\lnu"li an ~11'V11 L :nru ~v:J a \If!~ 3J1'WlJ L vj aLL ,)\I LL~::flJ'Yl'l11J"li an~11'VI1'Wfa 3J'W £J1U, 01~

'VItn;j1U~13JLL1JlJ ~1. rn ~v:la\lfl~L~~\I;afu'Yl'l1U"lian~11'VI1L~a1u,~ 'o> -wn~111fl3J l!!cf~rn ~ ~ "I

"".':! ... /~ ¥'1 a\lfl<il ... ~

Page 8: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

~~ eh1fl~1~ ~~a mh<ii Elflrn!:n')"')"3Jn1'H~EJU~1u 'Yl1\11 UtJ<1113.l1JU.Yi n~ a r.Jfl1"11El\l~ rmn~11~1 ~ ~~

<1113JLLUU ~1. cr Lde:JlU~ G>~ l'Hl~111fl3J l!:J<i!crc;n LL~::L~~EltJfl1Lfi3JL~3JLda1u~ l!:J~ 'V'Hl ~111 fl3J l!:J <i!crc;n fl ru,:;n')"')"3Jn1')"~EJU ~1U'Yl1\11UtJ1~ ~ElU ~1Ul'W1U.Ufl fl ~ l!:J 1hn

~

1 U~1U::l'l tJ1U~1 tJ ~finn ~11~1 LL~:: 1 U~1U1Un1')"~EJU~1UU')"1n ni1 ~l'l tJ1ULEln~1')" "" ~~ ow

U')"::n El u '111 tJ ~ ~ n1')"U nu~\11U 1~ tJ ~ El"ll El \1 ~~ El \1 fl ~ ~ U\1 ;El1'Yl tJ 111 fl <;'! ~hu ~ ~~ ow ~ ~ ~

~ ool!:lo.oG>rniG>G>crcr ~\llU~ G>G'JI iJfiU1tJU l!:J<i!crl!:J L~El\11~'Yln~U1tJi~"ll'~LYlm11\11U ~ ~ ~

'111u!iailu~u..ij1\11~mul'l1:: (Yl1\11u'111u.L~tJ1) f11i\ltil1TI';l11rn\1~1~~'Yl~\l ~ crG'Jic;nll!:J<f~ ~ ~

a.,.,. _cJ A _d o Ad A fi' ff' t,; a.,..o a.,..o o a.,.o CV IV

~\11U'Yl l!:Jb ~\1~1fl3J l!:J<i!~ 'Yll'l~<111TI';l<11')" !i')"U')"nl. ~U')"nl. ~U\IflUn1')"<111TI';l111IT';l\1~1~l'l'Yl~\l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

LL<ii\li\11~ ~ ~ El\lfl~ LUUL..ij1~U1~"1!~tlflu~ n1')"U')"1UU')"13J!i ailu~u..ij1\l fl1i\I~U1r.Jtlfj u~ n1')"

~Lfl~~ G>l!!G>Il!:J<f~ ~\llU~ G> numr.Ju l!:J<i!~ ~far.Jtil1')"1';11'Yl 3J1U:: ~1n~ ~1~U1~U1tJ ~

tJ nu~n1')"~ Lf!~tiJ1')"1';111!i')"i\J~l~~'Yl~\l LL<ii\li\IL ~ ~~ El\lfl~~U ~ ~"ll'ElU;U~1U U 1 tJ ~3JU')"rn ow ~ ~ ~ ~

(UU) LatJ~L~"ll' ~~l'lfl~n1')"rnLtJU!ie:JiJU~U..ij1\l uu.Yin'2iElfl113J"11El\l U.Ul'l.11.';11. ~'Yl~\1 ~ ~ ~

~ l'l'Yl ool!:Jo.G'JI/- ~\llU~ G>G'JI 3Jn')"1fl3J l!J<i!crc;n ~~~El\lfl~')"ltJ\11U~1~~El\1~1fl~El1ru1 ~ ~ ...

<tiEJ~1~U1~U1tJtlnu~n1~Lfi~1TI';l11m~\1~1~~'Yl~\l uu.Yin'2iElfl113J"11El\l utll'l.1l.';l1. ~'Yl~\1 ow ~ ~ ~

~~1~U1 ~U1 r.Jtl nu~n1')"~ Lf!~til1')"1';111!i')"i\J~l ~~'Yl ~\I ')"1 tJ\11Un')"til~~ El\1 fl ~ ~ El\1~1 ow ~ ~ ~

fl~ a1ru1<ii a~u\lf1un1')"til1')"1';111!i')"i\1~1~~'Yl ~\I LL~::uu Yin'2i Elfl113J"ll a \I utll'l.11. ';11. ~'Yl ~\I ... ~ ~ ~ ~

~ Yl'Yl ool!:Jo.G'JI/cr<i'! ~\llU~ 1!:!1!:! l'lfl~111fl3J l!:l<i!crrn ~~1~U1~U1r.Jtlfju~n1')"~Lfl~ til1')"1';111!i')"~\J~l~~'Yl ~\1;5LL';l\ln')"m~~ El\1 fl~~ El\1~1fl~ EJ1ru1 L fi 3J L~ 3J<ti El ~U\IflUn1')"

~ ~ ~ ... ~

ti11')"1 ';! 11 !i')"i\1~ 1 ~ ~'Yl ~\I <ii EJ3J1 fl ru.::n')"')"3J n1')"~e:Ju ~1u 1~tl')"::"lf3J~';J1')"nt1~\13J~~ \JU')"lnn ~ ~ ~ ow

<1113Juu.Yinn1W~"1!3J"11El\lflru.::nnaJn1')"~EJu~u flf\1~ rn/l!:J<fcrrn Ld a1u~ l!!G> n')"n!)1fl3J l!:l<i!crrn

wi'am.f\11~~')"1tJ\11Un1')"~ElU~U <1113JLLUU ~- b ~\llU~ l!:JG> n')"n!)1fl3J l!:J<i!crc;n ')"1tJ\11UL~ ~i1')"1"1l'n1')"i\1~1 ~~ 'Yl ~\1~\1 LtlU.~LL<ii\1 i\lfl ru.::n')"')"3Jn1')"~e:Ju ~1 u 'Yl')"1Ui1 ~~ EJ\1 fl ~13.11~ ~ ~ ~ ~

0 A AQ..,Ij I t.J d I d ~ Ad 0 A

n')"::'Yl1 ~~1UtJ El tl1\1')"1 r.JLL')"\1<1J13J'Ylflnn ~11~1 ';!\I L ~Ufl1')"tJ<1J L ')"EJ\1 n1')"~1 L U.Un1')"~EJU ~1U ~ ~

~';11')"nt1"11 a \1 fl ru.::n')"')"3J n1')"~e:Ju ~1 u 'Yl1\11 utJ ~\In ~11'2l1\l ~u ~\I L tlu 1tl 111111 ~ ~ n L n ru.~

LL~::1~n1')"~n1~U~<1113Jn!) n.l'l. uuu~ G)~ (Yl.fl. l!:J<i!cro) ElEln<1113Jfl113J1ul'l')"::')"l"ll'UtlJtY~ ')":;Lu tJU'2i1')"1"1fn1')"l'l~L1EJu l'l.f!. l!:J<i!rn<i! i1~1 r.Jn1')"~EJU~1U~';l1')"nl.1 ~\IU13J1L "lfU\IflU LLri

'2i1')"1"1fn1')"til1')"1';1 1~ tJ ElU 1~ 3J LL~::fl ru.::n')"')"3J n1')"~EJU ~1U'Yl1\11utJ1~L ~LEln1 ~~~ El\lfl~ ~ ~

Page 9: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

Gi1u,nTi~ tf\Al EJ\Ifl~ e11.:Ji1f1rn::n1"1"3Jn11"~EJ1J~1'1.t 'Y11\Iiu£J 1 i~ ~~it';! 1 u,nT~fuw\1-w £J1'1.t VI~ n~u, cu ~ ...

1aJ"lrEJlJ LiiEJ\1';11n~\Al EJ\Ifl~ 311~n'l::'t11f1113J~~ 1u,n11"L~'I.tn11"'WU u, L Vl~~nn~un 3JL -w1"1::1~L"l111tl cu ~ cu ~

tllju~VIu1~~13Jf11i\l"ll EJ\1 ~u..,f1uuty"lr11 u,~1 LL VI 't.i.:JVIl-h r.Jtllju"i~ Lfl~ t~ r.Jfl rn::n1"1"3J n11

~EllJ ~1-u, 'Y11.:Jiu£J 1aJ1~L1£Jnow £J1'1.tLEJ n ~'lel'l.tL tJu,f11 t.., i.:J n ~11 laJL~ ~EJlJ ~1 u, ow~ ~11"1';1 ~1 ~'llJ'lrn ~3JlJ'lrn ;B.., Lilu,~u..,f1uu ru"lr1"lJEJ\Itf\Al El\lfl~J u, L v; u,i1 f1rn::n'l1"3Jn11"~au~u, 'Y11\Iiu£J

cu cu cu ., cu

L~1"11J1"13Jow £J1'1.t VI ~mnu,~1.., 'J ~ L ~ £J1"11 a.:Jnun1ru~tf\Al EJ\Ifl~nnn~11V11i1n1::'t11 ~~iur.J ... cu cu

m.h.:Jf1 r.JLL 1"\li\ln ~11"li1\I~U,LL~1 LL~::~\AJ El\lfl~ n 311~ f11\I'W £J1'\.t VI~ mnu, VI~El'll1'W £J1'\.t VI~ n~u, cu ... ...

3J1 ~u LLn"li an ~11VI11 wffu,fl rn::n1"1"3Jn11"~EJ1J ~1-u, ;B.., Ld EJf1rn::n1"1"3Jn11"~EJlJ ~1'\.tL v;u, i1

ow £J1'\.t VI ~n\i1'1.ti\ln ~11ij"l1 E1 L ll';J-;)1\1 L -w r.J\I'W E1 t~ r.JLaJ-;)1~ El\I~EllJ~1'\.t'W~~111';1~~ ~'llJ'lrn ... cu

~3JlJ'lrn ;B.., dju,tf El Elnfl1 t.., LL~\1~\11 \X~\Al El\lfl ~tl1iu~VIU1~1 u, VIU 1 £Jtl1iu~n11"~ Lfl~a n cu cu cu ~ ~

LL~::-w £J1 u, VI~ n \i1'1.ti.:Jn ~11 L -w r.J\I"W EJ LL~1 ~ \1 L~ ~1tl ~1 u, 1 'l.tL ~'l.tEJ1"1 r.J\11 u, n11~EJ1J ~1 u, ... ~

' ... ~atfaanf11i\ILL~\Ii.:Jf1rn::nn3Jn11"~EJ1J~'I.t'Y11\Iiu£J n1TilJW\I"W£J1'1.tVI~n\il'l.t"llEJ\If1rn::nn3Jn11"

cu ...

~EllJ ~1 u, 'Y11\Ii ur.J i.:J n ~11 ~ \1 L tlu, 1tlt ~ r.J"lrEJlJ ~1 £J n !I VI3J1 mLtr1 "11 EJ f11 \l"ll EJ\1 ~\Al EJ\1 f1 ~

LaJ EJ1 ';Ji'lJ w \1 L~ i.:J J u, n11~1 Lit u, n11~EJ1J ~1 'l.t"ll EJ\1 f1 rn::n'l1"3J n11~EJ1J ~1-u, 'Y11 .:Ji ur.J

~13J~hi.:Ji.:Jwr~-w'Yl~\l ~ lrl'olrl/lrlcf<i:'rn ~..,1-u,~ ~ n3Jrn.Wu,f lrlcf<i:'rn ~\1Ltlu,n11~1Litu,n11 ~ ~ ... '

~EllJ~1Wil13J'l"U LLlJlJ anu,~ El'l.t VI~Eli~n11el'l.tLU'I.t~11::~1f1rufin flVI3J1 £Jrl1VI'!.t~ 11LL~1 cu ., ~

iJ'ruV11~~ EJ\1~';11'lnt1~ a1tJiji1 n1~ tfnn\Al EJ\Ifl~i\1~\1 1'Y1~1~~\Al EJ\Ifl~ EJEJn';J1n ., cu cu cu

1"1"1rn11""1rEJlJ~ 1 £Jn!)V13J1 r.JVI~ a1aJ t ~ £J ~ \Al EJ\Ifl~ n ~11 e11\11"1 r.J\11'\.t"ll EJ\Ifl rn::n'l1"3Jn11"~EJ1J ~1-u, I .... I I 1

mfluun~nn\AJEJ\Ifl~LL~\Ii\lm3Jf11i~\I'VIl~'Yl~\l fi l!J'oldlt!lcf<i:'c;n ~\llu,fi ~ n3JffioW'I.tf l!Jcf<i:'c;n i1 cucu ~ ~

~ \AJ El\lfl~ 3j 1~ n1::'t11~ ~i U £J~13J~ n~11VI1 LL~::ij 3J~1\X £J ~ L~ El\1 LL~ tf tl n\AJ El\lfl~ ~ ';111"ni.1LL~ 1 cu ~ cucu

i\1 ~\I 1 'Yl~tf\AJ El\lfl~t~ £J 1aJ LiJ~ 1 Eln1 ~ 1 \X tf\AJ El\1 fl ~:fLL ';!\I LL~~\1 LVI~~~ LL~::nn11"\.bl"li ElL ll-;)';11\1 cu cu ~

~owun\11'\.t~EllJ~'I.tLmr.JlJL fi r.JlJtli'utf\Al El\lf1~1u,"li EIVI1LLi\I~El~ El~ el'l.tLU'I.tL ll';Jn'lrnL~'I.tn11'WU u, cu cu

(Ln t~) 3J11iLtl'l.tLVI~ ~~ 1 u,n11~\l t 'Yl~tf\Al EJ\Ifl~ 5u,Ltlu,n11W \lOW £J1'1.t VI~ n\i1'1.t t~r.JLaJ LU'I.tti'n3J ~ cu ...

LL~:: 1 "lf~ ~~it';) t~ £J31 "lrEJlJtt 'l.t L y; 'l.t i1 3J1~1"1 <i>O<i:' 11"1"fl~El\l LL vi \1 'W1"::11 "lrU ru ru~1:: Lij £J lJ ~ ., .,

"li111"1rn11'W~ L~EJU, 'W. fl. 1rJ cfrncf ururu~i1 1 '\.tn'lru~flnt::n'l'l3Jn11"~EllJ~1'\.t~ LL~\I~\1~13J ., ., A ...,a o .d. IIJ,J 1),.1 • .c::1.

3J1 ~1"1 <i> o 1rJ Vl'l El ~ 3J El1 U, 1 ';) ~13J 3J1 ~1"1 <i> o 1rJ 11"1"fl ~13J 11"1"fl ~ 11"1"fl V11 LL~ 1 LL~ n'lnt cu

L v; u,i1 "11111"1rn11'W~ L~ EJ'!.t~1iJ ru~1~n1::'t11 ~ ~i ur.J EJ ~1\li'1 r.JLL 1"\1~3Jf111"~\l t 'Yl~tl~~ EJ an "'CU

Page 10: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

<0)0

V11aL~m:m 1i~1LUUn1~i"d' '1~'1 (rn) &t1VIfu~~1~"~1LLVI'I-i"i"LL~b:::iu rl ~"3.111u~ozrn1~ 'IJ

1J~V11~~1U113j111fl sB" ij1"lf~1VIU1 ~1U ~1"1fn1~tJ~:::-,l1~"VIl~ 1 i trii el1U 1~ i"u~~~~13J 'IJ 'IJ q

m~~ <.fl!J (ct) ~"L~a"1i a.n.l"l. ~"VI1~ sfi"trnnn~11VI1i"n~aci'W~~ru.1 LL~:::Lrla a.n.l"l. ~"VI1~ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

ii !l~iLtlutl~:::n1~1~ 1i ~ii e11u1~i"u~~~ i"n~11i"VI1atJ1h1~1iLtlu 1tl~13J J u LL~:::~h i" 'IJ q :w

' ' ' gQ,.,II 0 I Ad Q...ll.c:l A A 0

~1Un"1U~1~1~LLVI""lf1~ 'Yl ~~/l!:J<i!~<O) ~"1U'Yl <O)o l"ltlfl~n1r.JU l!:J<i!~<O) L~El" 3JEllJEl1U1~

n1~~1 Lit U n1~'Yl1 "~Jottr.J Gt1u n"1U~1~1 ~ LL ~ ""lf1 ~ El1 ~ r.J el1U1~ ~13.1 3.11 ~~1 r;n ~ ( rl) 1 Q..ol G..oiA .:f A I A I Q.,ll Q..IIA,

LLVI"l"l~:::~ozrururu~~:::LlJr.JlJlJ~VI1m"lfn1~LLt.JWiiU l"l.fl. l!:J<i!rn~ 3.11~~ ~<0) LLVI"l"l~:::~"lflJruru~ Ql Ql Ql Ql

~::: LU r..~ui1~1ozrn1~~1~1~ l"l. fl. l!:J ctl!:J <i) LL n1 "ll L ~ 3J L~ 3J 1~ r..~tl~:::n1 flfl ru.:::~n 1Y1 fl113J~"u .d. ., I A Q.,l .d Q,.,ll d Q..l ~ IJ,ol

L~r.JlJ~Elr.JLLVI""lf1~ QlJlJ'Yl r;n~ ~"1U'Yl l!:J~ n3J111l"!Uli l!:J<i!rn~ "lJEl <0)<0) LL~:::3J1~~1 <0)0~ q

LL~"l"l~:::~ozrururu~~:::Lu r..~ui1~"1fn1~l"l~L1au l"l.fl. l!:Jctrnct 3.1aue11u1~ 1i ~11~ozrn1~~"V11~ ~ ~ 'IJ

Ltlu~ ~" L~El" (Gt1u 1Un1~~au~1u 'Yl1"1ur..~ a ci1"f1 r..1 LL~" sB"~11~"1fn1~~"VI1 ~ L tlu~ i" LL ~" i" 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

' "" flrn:::n~~3Jn1~~EllJ~1U'Yl1"lUr.J LL~:::t.~~n1~~EllJ~U1uL1El"UU flrn:::nTI3Jn1~~EllJ~1U'Yl1"lUr.J

V11a~11~1ozrn1~~"V11~ L ~u11~nnn~11VI1n~:::r'h ~~i'!Xr..~ a ci1"f1 mL~" ~3Jfl1~~" 1 'YllY 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

ti"tl ~~a anVI1a 1~ a an~1n~1ozrn1~) 1 i n. ~~. 'W~1~ru.1 LL~:::Lllu~i"VI1atl~u~1 iLtlu1tJ A Q.; Q...oo.:=t, .d. ., ,d

~13J3J~ n.~~- ~13Jl"l~:::~1"1fUruru~~:::LlJr.JlJ"ll1~1"1fn1~l"l~L~ElU l"l.fl. l!:Jctrnct 3.11~~1 <O)o~ ~ ~

1Tifl~a" (l!:J) tl~naunu3.11~~ ~<i) u~"l"l~:::~ozruty~~~:::Lur..~ui1~ozrn1~~1~1~ l"l.fl. l!:Jctl!:J<O)

rl1VIU~1iti.11J'YlUqj~~1uL~El"i,Xr..~LL~:::n1~~nlY1lUr.J~13Jnl)VI!l1r.J11~1r.J~:::Lur.Jui1~1"1fn1~ l"l~L1au3J11"1fu"~umii1~"1fn1~~1~1~ 1~r..~au 1~3.1 i"J u Vl1nflru.:::nn!ln1~~au~u'Yl1"1'1Xr..~

q

Vl1a~11~"1fn1~-;ij"w1 ~ii fl113JL~ u11~nnn~11V11n~:::r'h~ ~i'IXr..~aci1"f1mL~" ~3Jfl1~~" 1'Yl1Y 'IJ 'IJ'IJ

tl~~aanVI1a1~aan ~11~1"1fn1~-;ij"VI1~~:::~a"~"L~a"1i n.~~- 'W~1~ru.1 Lrla n.~~- ii!l~ 'IJ

Ltlutl~:::n1~ 1~ ~11~1"1fn1~~"VI1~~:::Ltlutri"VI1atliiu~1 iLtlu 1tl~13J3J~ n. ~~- i"n ~11 'IJ 'IJ :w

Lrl aim -n~~~"tl~n!J11 flrn:::nn!ln1~~au~u'Yl1"1ur..~~13Jfhi"~"VI1~~'Yl~" ~ l!l~rl/l!:Jct~rn ~r..1"1u11 ~~a" fl~ij1~n~:::r'h ~~1'1Xr..~~13J~ n ~11VI1 u~:::ii3J~1 i r..~ ~ L~a" LL~ ~nn~ a"fl ~

'IJ q 'IJ 'IJ

A 0 QQ..~' tj;l ~ 1 A

l"l ~1~ni.1~13J~1U 1Un1~~EllJ~1U"lJ El"flru.:::nTI3Jn1~~EllJ ~1U 'Yl1"1 Ur.J LL~1 LVI U 11 "lJru.:::L n ~LVI~ q

Lrla1u~ r;no numr..~u l!lct~ ~~El"fl~fln~un3JL~LU~Ln~LVI~ ~El3J1~~El"fl~Lin1TI1J~~111l"l 'IJ 'IJ q q 'IJ

~ ~ El ~,y El n ~11VI1 ~1 r.J fl113J ~ar fl~ 1~ 1~ r.J LL ~"~El LL~:::~ El ci elUL UUL -n~ fl1 ~~"VIl ~~'Yl ~" 'IJ q

'Wl"l1n1Y1~" 1'Y11Ytlfu~~El"fl~Lrla1u~ <i) ~~1fl3J l!:Jct~l!:J Ltlu-,11U1UL~U <O),<i!oo 1J1'Yl 'IJ q

LL~:::i1~"1fn1~~1~1~~i13J~Un3J~~El"fl~1u1u.Ln~LV1~~1"1in1~fiur.Ju11 ~~El"fl~L~i13Jnu q 'IJ q 'IJ

/~mHllJ ...

Page 11: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

~nfl m.J L~Un11Y·nX u~"n~11 Gi1un11~~.W a"fl~ eJ1"';h L 'VI~~rm~unaJL'Wd1::L~fufhi"-;nn 'IJ ~ 'IJ ~

~u"~uu ru~11i aJ1tliiu~w~t1~ ;u~1U'VI1"ll11 LLfl::n11LL~"~a~ a~ L .Yhni L ~a~ a"n11tlnil ~ 'IJ ... ~ 'IJ

~fi1U111'W~ m-1';11""11 a"~uLa" L ~ atl1:: 1£J~u1 un1,-;U~1U'VI1"ll11,Xu 1 u1u~r~niun aJ 'IJ ~

~.Wa"fl~fiijL~d1£J"1u1i~u"~uuru~1~1aJih~u.ffuL~a'V11'Y11""1hm'VI~a ~r~n.Wa"fl~~"LV:w:h 'IJ 'IJ ... 'IJ'IJ

y.jn~ n11rnLLfl::n11n1::'Yl1"11a"~.W a"fl~ dJufl11aJ~ ~~htr.Ja ~1"i'1mL1" ;nun1::'Y11n11mu 1~ "I 'IJ ~

5uL~~a11Lilu~ti,-::'Wq~i'1a~1"i'1mL1" ~1aJaJ1~11 Cil!~ 111fl~a" LL~"'W1::11~ururu~ 'IJ ......

1::Lu£Ju"li1d1~n11'Wf!L~au 'W.fl. l!:Jtirntt LV:t.~.fl11fl" 1'Y11!1-L~~.Wa"fl~aan-;nn11~n11 LL~~L'VI~ 'IJ ~

auf111tl11mfi~'VI~ au1 'Y11!1- L ita"';J1n ~flnn~11'VI1~"~a" Lfl £J'Yl1fl rntl1:: 1 £J~unu'Y11"11~n11 'IJ 'IJ ~

~"LV:ufl11Ufi~~.Wa"fl~aan';J1nd1~n11 LLfi::L~Gi"L~a"1i n.~'i. W';J11nl.1 ~" a.n.~'i. L~r.J1nu 'IJ

I .., I I I

n11<111Lii.Un11'¥11"1u£J flrn::fi Ci> 1un1W'i::~aJflf"fi l!:J'o>/l!:Jttctct Li:la1ufi Ci>rl numr.JU l!:Jtictct ~

0 ~ ~

W';J11ni.1LL~1L V:u11 ~.W a"fl~fln~un aJL~1uu1nrnfi Ln~L'VI~ i'u~unaJLLfl::i'u~au~ufl~ a1ru1 'IJ 'IJ ~ ~ ~ ...

~.W a"fl~1i n11fu~1111'W~f!a~"li an~11'VI1~1£Jfl11aJ~aJ fl'i h 1~ mL~"~a LLfl::~ a~ 5uLiluL tl';J 'IJ 'IJ

~ fl fl ~ ii"~ ~~ 1 ~ £J fl1 fli"wr ~-w 'Y1 fl" W'W1 n 1!1-1 fl" 1 'Y11!1-tlfu L iluL'~ u Ci) ,cl. o o u1 'Y1 LLfl::-;)1 n ~ ~

n11~au~1UL~1'VIU1~<11111';J~i1aJiunaJL~fl11aJ11~.Wa"fl~L~i1aJnu~nf!auL~un11'WUunu 'IJ ~ 'IJ

~ ~ a"'V\1~ fl niun aJ 1ufl~d ';11" 'W'l~ n11rnLLfl::n11n1::'Y11"11a"~.W a"fl~L~~a11Lilu~ti,-::'Wq~i'1 'IJ 'IJ ~ 'IJ 'IJ

a~1"i'1mL1" LiJt.~.fl11aJ~~1u£Ja~1"i'1mL1" maJm~d1 Cl'!~ 1Tifl~a" LL~"'W'i::d1Wrurir~,-::Lii£Ju ...... "1i111~n11'Wm~au 'W.fl. l!:!ttrntt ~"~aJ~L~~.W a"fl~ aan';J1n11~n11 LLfl:: 1un11tl1::~aJ n.~'i.

'IJ ~

flf"~ Ci)~/l!:Jtictct Lrla1u~ Ci)Ci) nt.~.11flaJ l!:Jtictct ~aJ~fU'Y1111J ~flnoWa"fl~~"L~~'hi" 'IJ'IJ

~ l!:J l!:J Ci'!/1!1 ttct tt fl" 1u ~ rn Ci) aJ n11 fl aJ 1!1 ttct Ci'! fl" 1 'Y11!1-L~ r.r .W a"fl~ a an';J1n11~n11~1aJaJ~ 'IJ

"11 a" a. n. ~,-. fl1 f!tlnfl'ia".ffuCiluw ';111rn1 LL~1 LV: u 11 LLaJ flrn::n11aJn11~au~1U'Y11"1 u £J

~1aJ,hi"i"wr ~-w 'Ylfl" ~ l!:! ~o> ri/l!:!ttctrn ';1::~ aJ~1 i £J ~ L~ a" LL~ ~ fl n.W a"fl~ a1';1~ ~floW it';) ~ ~ 'IJ 'IJ ~

~';J::L V:ud:Jua ~1"mu ~hi~,-"nufl11aJ L V:u"ll a"flrn::n,-,-aJn11~au~1uiu£JL~ LL~ Cil a"Gi"L~a" 1i n.~1. W';J11rn1 LLfi::Lrla n.~'i. ~aJ~d:Jutl,-::n111~ ~r~n.Wa"fl~~aaJCila"i"'VI~atliiu~

'IJ'IJ ~

1id:JuLtl~1aJaJ~ n.~,-. ~"n~11 J"d~1aJU£JaJ1~11 Ci)oct 111fl~a" LL~"'W1::11~ururu~ ...... 1::Lur.Ju"li111~n11'Wm~au Y-l.fl. l!:!ttrntt anJ"n11iii.';Ju£Ji"fl" 1'Y11!1-~.Wa"fl~n1ii.';Ju£J 1~£J~~ti a

'IJ

offaL tl';J';J1"~1aJ~1u 1Ufl~"ll a"flrn::n,-,-aJn11~au ~1u 'Y11"1u£J ~" L~Lfl £J u~""li an ~11'VI1 LLfl::

L 'VI1an1 ~~VJ a"fl~~LL';J" LL~~"'W £J1U 'VI ~n\i1U 1CilLLEJ"aff an ~11'V11 LL~1 ijL~~n11LU~ r.JULLU fl" 'IJ ...

'VI~m ~ aJ L~ aJaff an ~11'VI11 'V\aJ LLfi::L 'VI~~~ fin oW a"fl~ i"fl" 1 'Y11!1-fl dJUL 'VI~ ~fl~ ~'W £J1U 'VI ~n\i1U ~ 'IJ 'IJ ~ ...

-:;: •.. '/ '•.

Page 12: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

~u-u ~u u ~i'uw" i.~ l'f"-d' ~ EJ3J1 ~w a" f1 ~i.~~UEJ'Yl1l'nll'fh i" ~" 1 'YllY i.~ a a n-;n n~1"1rn1~ ~ 'IJ ~

:fi"I1~El"I1U1£Jnf!3JWil~ ('W~LEln "11'1~<11 £J"I11';l~'Yl1l) U~U~~"ll'fi1~LL'YlUU1£Jfif!3JU<11~~';)1~ni.1LL~1 iifhi"1~£JnEJ'Ylmrn<1113J3J~ n.<11~.1un1~~"1l'3Jf1f"~ (i)/l!:J<t.~ Ldai'u~ (i)<i. 3Jn~f13J l!!<t.~

~ ~

i"Ju n1~~~rmWEJ"I1f1~iifhi"~ l!!l!!~/l!!<t.<i.'<t. ~"1u~ m(i) 3Jn~1f13J l!:l<i.<i.'<t. ~"1'Yl1Y 'IJ'IJ

i.~~WEl"11fl~EJEJn';J1n~"ll'n1~ ~"11LlJUn1~n~·rh~"ll'EllJ~1£Jn!j'V13J1£JLL~1 ...

fl1~tlnf1~El"l1iu~u~ow1n1Y1£JnW El"l1

~W El"l1fl~ El'Yl1l~rnLL~::: LL n1. "lJ L ~ 3J L~ 3Jfl1 El'Yl1l~rn ';h n1~~ fl1 ~tJ n fl~EJ"I1.ffu~u, 'IJ ~ ~

i.t11"1 u "u £J11 fi1 i""ll a"~ t1 nw a" f)~~ i" ~ "1 'YllY i. ~ ~w a" f)~ a a n"1 n~1"1l'n1~"1l'au ~1 £J 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

"' ' ' n 11 'V13J 1 £J LL ~ 1 U U ~ W El "11 fl ~ L ~ U l1 LL aj' ~ tl n W El "11 fl ~ El1 ';) ii <11 ~ ~ U ';) fi ';)::: L ~ U L iJ U El ci 1 "11 El U ~ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ ~

~LaJ <11~"11 rllJ fl113J L ~ U"lJ El"l1 fl ru.:::n~~3Jfi1~~EllJ ~1U 1u£J 1 UL~El"11 fi1~~EllJ ~1U 1u£J <1113J fl1 i"l1

"ll EJ"I1~tlnw EJ"I1f1 ~ 1<11 m .W £J"I1 ~tlnW EJ"I1 f1 ~t'f" L~El" 1 ~ n. <11~. :fi" Lilu~ii a1u 1';1 i"u~~"~"1~ru.1 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ ~

LL~:::Ld a n.<11~. ii 3J~ Lilutl~:::n1~ 1<11 ~t1nw EJ"11f1~ ci EJ3J~ a"i"'VI1atl1iu~1 ~Lilu i.tlt1113J3J~ n. <11~. 'IJ'IJ ~

i"n~11<1113J~fl1~tlnf1~EJ".ffu~u1U."u£J 3J1 i.~n<1113J LL~n1~~1 L U.un1~<1113J.ffut11 aui"n~11 ...

';)::;~ El"11~1L UUfi1~ 1~tln~El"I11U~1~:::~1~ru LL~::: 1~f1113J£J~1l~~3J LLri~tlnn~11'VI1UU '] ~1 £J 'IJ ., ~ 'IJ 'IJ

'VI1n ~LL~"I1~"11fl ru.:::n~~3J n1~~EllJ ~1U 1u£J ii f1113J L ~ULUUEJ ci1"11~U ~LaJ <11~ "11rllJ f1113J L ~u, 'IJ

"llEl"11f1nt:::n~~3Jn1~~EllJ~1u1u£J 1<11 £Jiii.~~1 L U.un1~ 1 ~tln~ El"l1 1 u~1~:::~1~ru LL~:::ii tn1Yru.::: 'IJ .,

i.aJ1 ~ fl113J £J~1)~~3J LLri ~ tlnn ~11'VI1 LL~1 n';l::: LUUn1~£J El3Ji'lJ 1 ~iin1~~1 L u. un1~i.aJ1 tli"11 1~ ~ 'IJ 'IJ

LL~::: rJ"11 L ilun1~fl"l1 i.16fi" n1~EJU n 3J .nu~::: n1~~" L~U, 1 u, ~:::1JlJ~1"1l'n1~L~~ n ~ El i.tJ ,f" '] ~ ~

f1 ru.::: n~~3Jn1~~EllJ ~1U1U£JL~ ~~tlow £J1U 'VI~ n ~i1ULL~:::f1113J L ~ U3J1 LL~1 :fi" ~ El L~11 ~ ~

f1 ru.:::n~~3Jn1~~au ~1u 1u£J Lilu~ ~au ~1U';l1 now £J1U 'VI t n~1u~1" 'J ~1n ~~<11~ ~<11 LL~1 'IJ ~ ~

u:::Ju ~WEl"l1f1~~"11L ~U~3Jf11~LL£Jfi~';)1~nl.1 LUUU~:::L~UciEJ £J i"l1if 'IJ

tl~L~ULLm ~ tl nw El"l1fl~ ii L'V\<11 ~~ 1<11£J"ll'EllJ~';):::ii fl113JL~ ULUUEJci1"11~U~i.aJ <11~"11rllJ 'IJ 'IJ ~

fl113JL~ U"lJEl"l1f1rn:::nTI3Jfi1~~EllJ~U1U £JLL~:::Gf"I1L~El"l1~ El1~ fi.t11~. 'ti'ufiL~'V11EJ i.1i ~W El"11fl~ L~ Ul1 'IJ

n1~ ~ t1 nw El"l1fl~ iif1113JL~U~"I1 1 'YllY~W El"l1fl~:fi"i.mu';JU£J 1<11£J~ <11~ a"ll mfi';l';l~"I1<1113J~1U1Uf1~ 'IJ'IJ 'IJ

"llEJ"I1f1rn:::nTI3Jn1~~EJu~u1 u£Jl'f"I1'V13Jt11 ii i.~ii n1~Ltl~ £JULLU~"I1'VI1EJ L ~ 3JL~ 3J"l1 an~11'V11'VI1 a-wmu

L~ 3JL~3J 1'VIaJ :fi~ Elfi~11'VI1i"l1n~11~tlnW El"l1fl~L~Lfl£JLL-;)"11LL~:::~W El"l1fl~L~:ffLL';l"l1 1~LLrj"l1"li Elfi~11'VI1 'IJ'IJ 'IJ

i"l1n~11L1LL~111 L'VIt1l~tln~un3JL'W~:::i.~i'ufi1i""1n~u"~uuru"ll'11~3J1tl1iu1i'VIu1~~u~1u ~'IJ ~ 'IJ ., ~

'V\1"1111 LL~:::n1~LL-;)"11~El~ EJci L fi';ln L yj El~ El"l1fi1~ntJ <1l~tl1Ull1'W~ LL..,;';l~"11"1JEl"I1<11ULEl"I1L yj ElU~::: 1£J"ll'\.b 'IJ

Page 13: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

LUfi1'l~1J~1U'VI1"ll11 LL~ cr{l n~ El\l~~i.~~~1'lnb1LL~::1il~u£J t~wLiL 'VI~~~ L .w tJ\I':h 1'" 1u ~ ~ ~ q

rlniun :JJ cr~ El\l~~n iii.~'l1 tJ\11'1-l, 1 i cru\1 ~1JUnJ"lf1 ~1 :JJ ~1~u.ffu 'Yl'l11J L yj El'V\1'1'11\I"lh m 'VI~ El ~ q ~ ~ "'

L'Yhtf u u~::~r1n~ a\1~~ ~~11:JJL v;u-nwYi11 v-nl~n1'lrnLL~::n1'ln'l::l11"11El\lcr~ a \I~~ Li:Ju~11:JJ~~ ~~ ~

1U£JEl~1\lf1£JLL'l\l t~ tJ~rln~ El\1~~ ii L~1i ~rn::nTI:JJfi1'l~El1J~U'tl1n1'l~El1J~UL ~ :JJL~ :JJ~U L~ ~~

off m fi~~1 \ILL~::tlnnn'VIt n;nu ~-E'~L~u:fl U:JJ1L 'V13J tf\lrJ\Iiii.~1'VILEJn1~~ ~ EJ\I~~i.~ m)-ff an~11'VI1 :w ... ~

L~:JJL~:JJ~ULUU ~n'l::-;11\IEln 'l11n1J11 crrln~ El\l~~i.~~\11)\I'V\~El ~ ~ LL vi\! f'h1il~u£J i.1 ~1\I'VI U1 ~~

ri ElULUh LL~L~~n1'l LL~ \1 ~\I~ rn::n'l'l:JJ fi1'l~El1J ~1 U 1u£J L .W tl\1 L yj ElL iL tJ U i.tJ ~1 :JJ.ffu~ El U .,

Q IIJ..ol Q...o'Q.,.. 1 ca.,.. 11J..o1 AQ...I .::1 ~

~1 :JJn!) 'VI :JJ1 £J 'l:: L 1J tJlJ LL~::"ll EllJ \1 ~ 1J L '1'11 U U {11 ~ rn:: fi'l'l:JJ fi1~~El1J ~1 U 1 U tJ~:: :JJ ~11 :JJ L 'VI U

LL~:::JJ~ LUUL "lfuL~ £J1ll1J1l\I'VI~El ~ ~ LL vi\! f'h1il~u£J~ ~rln~ El\1~ ~~\I i.1LL~1 crrln~ El\1 ~ ~n~::~ ~~ ~~

~1i\l L v;wwa\1~1:JJ~1 m yjati~uvru~~ 'VI1n~rn::n'l'l:JJn1'l~au~1u1u£J~~11:JJ L v;u~1\lnu ]) \I'VI~El ~ ~ LL vi \1 ~11il ~ UtJ~ cr {1 n~ El \1 ~~~\I i.1 cr {1 n~ El \1 ~ ~ n ~:: n tu :JJ ~"11 El \1 ~ rn:: fi'l'l:JJ n1'l

~~ ~~

~EllJ ~1 '"1 UtJ LL~::~::~U't11 ~11 :JJ L v; '"1 iLtlu i.tl~1 :JJ])\I'VI~El ~ ~ LL vi \1 ~11il~ Utl~ cr {lfi~ El\1 ~ ~ ~~

~\IL1LL~::~h L ilun1'l~1:JJ.ffu~ ElU~ El i.tJli'wYi :J\In1'l~1L ilun1'l'Yl1\11u£Jtf U cr~El\I~~L v;u 11 ~

fi1'l~~::~ ~11:JJL v; UL un'lm ~ ~ :JJ ~~ ~1'lfi~11'VI111~ {lfifi~11'VI1n'l::'t11~ ~1u£Jtf '"~ El\I~EllJ~U ~ ~ ~

1 'VIL~~11 :JJ~1\I ttli\IL~LL~:: [J~])'j'j:JJ LUU~1~ru u::tf'" fi1'l~ crrln~ El\l~~i.~fu ~11 :JJ L v;u q "' ~ ~

LL~:::JJ~"ll El\l~rn::n'l'l:JJn1'l~El1J~U 'Yl1\11U£J~L i £J ~ L~El\1~ n~11'VI1cr~ El\1~~ LL~1 LL~ crr1n~ El\1~~ q ~ ~ ~

ntuiii.~1 i~ rn::n'l'l:JJfi1'l~El1J ~1U 1u£J~El1J~1UL ~ :JJ L~:JJ'VI~ElL 'VILElfi1 ~~~ El\1 ~~;fLL~\1 LL~~\1 ~

L 'VI~ ~~m n~f\lwd.\1 L yj EJL'VIL~-ff m fi~~1 \lelULUU~ n'l::-;11\1-E'~ ttli\IL~ LL~::LUUllTI:JJLLri cr~ El\1~~ q ~

:A\ILtlu~rJnn~11'V11 t~£Jiii.~1iL 'VI~~~ 1u'Yl1\1~"1fauLtlua~1\lmu~ L .W £J\IV·m~~::fuw\li.~11 ~ :JJ ~ ~ ~ q ~

~:JJ~1~~\I t '1'1~'1'11\11 UtJEl ~1\11'1 tJLL'l\ILLri cr {1 nn~11'V11 LL~ ntu't11~11:JJL v; '"~ ~1\llllJ~nl.::nTI:JJfi1'l ~~

~au~u1umL~::Gi\IL~El\l~ ai.tlrT\1 n.~'l. li'wYi 5u~tn~rn::d\l~udiu~:JJ~1'lLLri~11 :JJ~1 Ltlu

Gia1 iL v;Utl\1~11 :JJL3Jltli\IL~ i.aJ LUUll'l'l:JJLLri cr~ El\1~~ L V-l'l1:: L~ El crrln~ El\1~ ~ L v;u i.3J~'l\lll1J ~ ~~

~rn::n'l'l:JJfi1'l~El1J~1U ~ ~U~\I:flU:JJ1 ~rln~ El\l~~n ~1'l"L i~ fi1'l~El1J~1U V-l £J1UL ~ :JJ L~ :JJ L 'V13J ~~

'VI~EJL i ~~ El\1 ~ ~;fLL ~ \IL utl'l:: L ~'" ~ ~ r1 n~ EJ\1 ~~~\I ~tJ L yj EJ'V11-ff a L fi ~~1 \IL i n'l::-;11 \JoE'~ ~ ~ ~

~ULL UL ~11 cr~ El\1 ~ ~i.~n'l::'t11 ~ ~1u£J El ~1\11'1 £J LL 'l\1 L yj Elfi1'l~~11 :JJ L v;U~\1 t 'Yl~ i.~l:~ tJ"lfEllJ ~

"Yf\lif L yj El~11:JJrln~ El\1 ltJi\IL~LL~::Ltlun'l:JJLLri ~ rl nn~11'VI1 LLaJ ~1:JJ1J'YlU ruru~ LL vi \In 11'V\:JJ1 £J ~ ~~ "'"' ~

'l::Lu tJu LL~::-n au\l~u~ L ~ £J1-ff a\l~::iii.~ururu1i'VI~m11'VIu~ i.1n~1:JJ LL~ L vJ a Ltlun1'1iJ a\lnu "' "'

n1'l~\li.1:A \l'l::uuatl5 :JJn'VI~an1'l~\l L~unu 1 u'l::UU'l1"1fn1'l'VI~an1'lmtuLLn ~\I ~r1n~ a \I~~ q ~ ~

..: /n~:JJ~1'l ...

1 3 g!,R, 2558

Page 14: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

n tUJ fl11~ El" n~r'hn11~"n~11 LL~::n11n~rh~"n~11n ~L~ ri EJLiLn ~fl113JL~r.J'VI1r.J LU'Yl1" L~LLri

~'VIit"~L~LL~n~u;J::L~futh:: lr.~"ll'ULLri'Ylm:l1r.J Lrl a~nn~ EJ"fl~~L~n1::rhn11~"n~11~" 'J ~ '1.1 '1.1 q '1.1 '1.1

~3J11fln1::r'h 1tJ1 u 'Yl1"~"1l'EJ1J~"n ~11 L~ n11i:if111l! L ~u-na" ~nn~ EJ"fl~~ ~" t 'Yl~~~ EJ"fl~ '1.1'1.1 '1.1

~"Li:Jun11n~rh~L3J"ll'EJU~1r.Jn!)'VI3J1r.J ~u::Jun11LL~"~"mu::nn3Jn11~auWJunLi:Ju5u1f~~ LaJ El1~ 1iu"~1JL~~13JL~~U.113JnL"lJEJ"n!J'V13J1r.J LaJri a1iLn~t11::lr.J"l!'U~ EI~1J1J11"1l'n11LL~ mh" 1~

L 'Yh nu-h n11LL~" ~" fl m::n113Jn11~EI1J ~1U~U3J1 dJULL~ LoW r.J"n11EJUt~nUL vl ElL ii:i ~ ~ q

~13Jn 11 'V13J1 r.J L 'Y11J U LL~~UEI ~ nu f1113J L ~U"ll El" ~ fl n~ El" fl ~ L tJut&1 ~ru LL~::LaJ £i L 'VI~~~ :cJ '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 "' q

5u~3Jf111 't11L i n11fl"L i~"1::uu at153Jn'VI~Ein11~"L~u1 u1::uu11"1l'n11rJ"fl"EJ ~ ~"'ib~::-n~ q '1.1 ...

~a L ~~U113J ru"ll a"n!J'VIll1 r.1 1 u 'Yl1"t1nf11EJ" ~m-1'"'V11n~~11m1~1n ~~11 r.J"1un11~au ~1u.

"lJ El" f) m::n113J n11~EI1J ~1 u 1 Ur.J LL~1 off ElL fi ~ ~~" nfuw" L~ 11 ~~ El" f)~~ L~L off1 LU '1.1

L~U.n11~UU LL~L~L off1 LU~1J'VI1"ll11L i~u" ~1JUqj"ll'1elULUUn11U~U~'VIU1~t~ r.J"ll'EilJ

~" LaJ L tJ u n11n1::r'h tJ ~1 ur.~ ~13J~ n ~11 'V\1 ~",Xu fh1 ii. ~ u r.J"ll a" ~1 ~ tJ n f11EJ ".ffu~u ~" 5"f1~1~ Lfl~ au L3J"ll'EJ1J~1 r.~n!)'VI3J1 r.1

~1ut11::L~u~ ~a"11 n11£i f1113JL ~ U"llEJ"~ n n~ EJ"fl~ ~"n~11Ltlu 1t1~13Jf1113J '1.1'1.1

nn~ a"1u.~1::G&1~ruu~::i:i ~n~m:: 1 if1113J r.J~1i113J uri ~nnn ~11'VI1'VI~EJ LaJ Ju ~~ EJ"fl~ '1.1 "' q '1.1 '1.1 '1.1

L ~U11 Lrl E1 ~fin~ El" fl~L~~ E1 L EJ1off E1 L fi~~~"~13J G&1u 1'\.l.fl ~"ll El"fl m::n113Jn11~EI1J ~1U 1ur.J '1.1'1.1

~ £if1113J L ~U ~fall~ r.J1U 'VI ~n qj1U3J1 LL~1,_f U ~"'VI3J~11 ~~ El"fl ~ ~L~n1::'t11 t:J~1Ur.J~13J~ ~ '1.1

n ~11'VI1 LL~::£i 3J~L i r.J~ L~EI" LL~~"11off ElL fi~\1~" ~13J G&1u 1Ufl ~~"n ~11f1JW" L~11 ~~ El"fl~ q '1.1

~L~ n1::'t11 tJ ~1 ur.~ Lrl a~ fl n~ a" f1 ~ L ~ ULU u a ~1"~u 11 ~~a" f1 ~ n1:: 't11 tJ ~1 ur.~ a ~1" '1.1'1.1 '1.1

f1 mL 1" ~ fl n~ a" f1 ~ f111~ a" 1 'VILa n1 ~LL ri ~ n n n ~11 'V\1 ~ n flf"'VI it" LLaJ f1 m::n113J n11 '1.1'1.1 '1.1'1.1

111 ... 1 !.IT" "'.':I ... .d !'I ... I ..t ..... t ... ... ~EilJ ~1'\.l.~:: L~ Lfl r.J 'VI L Eln1 ~~l"l El"fl ~'1!'" Lull.~ nnn ~11'V11"1l'LL\l" LL~~"~ r.J1U 'VI ~nqj1U ~ LLr.J"

'1.1 '1.1'1.1 ~

off an ~11'VI1 LL~1n~13J u~ Lrl a ~nn~ EJ"fl~ L ~ uLtlua ~1" ~u ~ LL~n ~1" LU\11nf1 ru.::n11lJn11 '1.1'1.1

~EI1J~1U1Ur.J L 'Yl1n1J11~fln~ El"fl~fuW"~ r.J1U'VI~nqj1ULUUEI ~1"~U rlfl11 1 i~~ El"fl~ '1.1 '1.1 ~ '1.1

~" L tJ U~ fl n n ~11 'V\1 :ff'LL \1" ~ n flf" 'VI it" ~"ttL vl El fl113J t tJi" 1~ LL ~:: L UU 1i113J LL fi ~~ EJ" fl ~ '1.1'1.1 '1.1

~" LUU~fl nn ~11'V11 t~ r.J LU ~1:: El ~1" D" Lrl El ~~ El" f)~ Lfl r.J a1"off ElL fl\1\1~" LL~::~ r.J1U 'VI ~nqj1U '1.1'1.1 '1.1 ~

11lu.ffu~au~1u Liu~111 L 'VI~~~~EJ"f1~nniun3J 1 Uf1113JtJ~ L ~ r.11nun11~uu Liia"\11n q '1.1 '1.1 q

1~Loff1 1tJtJ ~u~V11Z1~ ~13J~1 i""ll a" ~u" ~uuty"ll'11 u~1 LL 'VIU"'VI'ih r.~tJ ~u~n11~ L~~ ~""llm::Jui:i~~~111\1~1 ~1u1ru ~3JU1ru Ltlu~u"~uuru"l!'1~L~i"n11~1r.J11\11 ~"'V11n

'1.1 '1.1 '1.1 "'

Page 15: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

/./ ;.'·,.;;::--·

i'\.l l'b

·,, .. "!h~~(3M~/

F !;.",...

L~~11h,2-~L~::1ll~'tl.~,~~~~ki-1(3,llollU.U.::~~1Lll 'ti._!L::~ flt.~lht1Lll::111~,, ;pw;pl8\ "kfM '11.(3~mM ' ' "

1Lll.lfgL1L11.1lfl m ::t!hfufull.!fgL1::1M~Is1. ,, ;pp L11hLI'efl'tl.f'CL!h1Lll.lfgL1~LU.ll,, fl Lls1.flk!H'e Lt.~lhll, 1"'i J=l' ~ ~ I ~ I J=l' 'CiJ

b l'b ...

J1. t lh ls1. ,'tl.f.p ~~~(3 ~~~(311.L~::1U1LllL~~ ~~~ki-m !foullL111 ft1~ t.L~ll~~'tl. _!LM1Lll'l1. ~, Lls1.(3 !f-'tl.t

ll!11LHllLM~~L~UU::~,mUil~llU'11.~L.!fgfu£tll~~£t~~(311.~.¥L!PI'CLihi11~L,tLis1.~£tgl1~1~~~(3~~ U.1Lll::~, ;pw;pl8\ ·~·M '11.(31,~M1Lll.lfgL1LI1.1lfl m::tlhfufull.!fgL1::1M~Is1.,, PP L11hLI'Cfl'tl.f'CL!h F' JP' l"'i J=l' 'CIJ~ ~ I l"'tl

~1 '11. ~~L~ (3'11.[J,~fl ~,ll ~ ls1.::~,,'11.!!:1h _(,t.~L(3 ft1 flLI'Cis1.flllfl t,~ll(3.1fgfllhl1Lll.lfgU.~L ,tLis1. '11. t L.!fgfu £til~~ £t~ ' ' '

~(311.~ .¥ L!PI'CL!h ~£t gl1~(3 ~L~ ~~~(3 ~~ ~ fl ft1rl_!L ~~LU.'tl. t lh ~ Lls1. ~'11. r~ fl Lf'Cis1.flllfl t, ~ll(3.1fg~ ~ l'b l'bl'b l'b

L.lfgfll£tll~~£t~~(311.~»L!Pf'CL~hl11 L~::1ll~1 '11. _!LLis1.t.L~ llllU~ L~~~'tl.~k!~llLis1.~l't 111 (, ~(3~,'11.~, I .... .... I

b b

~~lhls1. ,::~, lhls1. ,Lk!L'IU1L~~~(3~ ~1fl_!L~~LU.'I1. t lh~I'CLt-~'11.~, ft1 ~L(3~,, ~L~~(311.LHULM~L!P l'bl'b

re Llh lh ~ L~::tu ~L(3 Lls1.t.L~ llllU ~!111ll ~ Lll:: L1M, fl_!L~~LU. '11. t lh ~ re Lt.~ ll L~ll(3 (3ll Lls1.~L~ b

ll fl,, ~(3 ~~fl f'C11.!l~fl1Lll '11.t.ll::1ll~(3f1.'11.(3!h'tl.g.re Llhf'C Lt.~~~ f'C Llhl11 'tl.fJ, ~ll!11LHULM~L!P!] l'b b l'b b l'b l'b

~ L~llU1Lll~,, f'C Llh~ll!11LH llLM~L!P!]~~ U.!1-lhl-ls1.~~~L~UU::~, f'Cllll~ll u::~~ ~~(3 ~~lf,, l'b ~ l'b

p-(3 !f-'11. t Lls1.t.L~ llllU~re Llh fl_!L~~LU.Ih~ re Lt.~'tl.fJ, ft1 L.lfgfll£tll~~£t~ ~(311.~.¥ L!P re Llh L~::1ll1Lll

'11.[JH'e(3 ~ ~vls1. 'ti.L~ 1Lll.lfgL1~LU.~L,tLis1.~£tgi11Lll'tl.fJ, L~~1 (3 ~re (3 ~ L.!fgfu£tll~~£t~ ~.¥ L!PI'CL!h b l'b l'b l'b

t.L[l.Lis1.1l~I11::L1M,~ t.L~ll~~'ti._!LM1Lll'tl.~,~t,'tl.treUil~llU~1~~~(3~~~1Lll ~~~~L~~~~(3~~ ... l'b l'b l'b l'b

~f'CL!h1Lll.lfgL1~LU.J1. t t.L[l.Lis1.1l~~L,tLis1.~£t~ 1111~1s1. t~~~(3 ~~ ~~~'tl.fJ,L~Il! _l1l11lf'Ck! _l1l11l1.S ' ' '

l'bl'b ~

~lh ~t.1L~ ~ Mll Lls1.~fl Lls1. t.L~ llll U ~H U.l ~ ~1Lll (3 ~ ,'11. ~, re Lt.~ !]J1. t lh ~1Lll '11. t f1l ~ L~ ::1Lk!

'tl.fJ,'tl.~ (, lht ~.¥L!P!](3~1s1.'11.~, f'CLt.~!];:~~ '11.(3 ~ ft1 (3~1s1.Lis1.t.L~llllU~HU.l ~~~.¥L'IU1L~~;:~,, '11.t.k!ll(3k!1Lll'tl.t f'C11.!1'11.[JmLt.~::~,,lh,2-~~mtLt,~(3 ~ ,Lf'C~(3 !fot-rl ~, ~lht '11.~1Lk!ll(3,'11.Lfl Mllfl~,;:~,

I I I I

H~, ~1Lll~£tg 11fl t, 1tls1. '11. t~L ,tLis1.~£tg 1111~1s1. t ll(3.1fgfllhl ~.¥ L!Pil!~1 L~~L~ ~~~(3 ~~ ~fl _lUtl\rek! l'b l'bl'b

_l1l1111.S ~lh~t-1L~~M llfl~mlhl re ~m ~,'11.~1l(3k!1Lllf'Cllll::'IU~J1-t~~L!P!]~(3 ~1t.~M~~~~~(3 ~llU~ ' ' l'b l'bl'b

~1,, fl Lk~L~ (3 fl_!L~Ih~L~::1ll~1~~~(3~~L~ 'ti.~~L~ (3'11.[J,'I1.~ ,~~~(3~llU~(3 ~,~,, ~1 '11.~ H'eLt,~ l'b l'b

~ ~ 11,'11. fl ~11 ,~L(3 ft1::U.M, '11.t.k!ll(3k!Lf'C _l1l11li'Ck! _l1l11l1.S ~lh~t.1L~~Mllfl~,~(3 ~'11. [J,L~ ft1~~ b l'b ...

~(3~, ~fl ~f'C!] fl_!L~Ih~L~::1ll~1~~~(3 ~~L~~1~k1.1l!~L(3 ft1'11.~ll~ls1.'11.LflM::~, ~~'tl.t.'ti.L~ L~'tl.~,

fl_!L~'tl.~ll(3k!1Lllf'Cllll::'IU~::U.Mm[J,~ '11.~1l(3k!Lf'Cllfl~,~1tJfl_!L~'tl.~ll(3k!1Lllf'Cllll::'IU~~Lll~,,

f'CL!h~'tl.t.k!ll(3k!Lf'C ('11._!L::'IUI1.'11.t) ~~~(3 ~~~(3f1.L.!fgfu£tll~~£t~ _lUtl\rek! _l1l11\t.S ~lh~t.1L~~M "

ll fl ~,~1 tJ:: ~fl_!L ~ '11. t.k! ll(3k!1Lll f'C11ll::'IU ~ ,tf, lht 1Lll::111 ~,, fl_!L ~lh ~ L ~::1ll1Lll '11. fJ ,~1 ft1

fl Lf'C \s1.1l(3 re ~1 L.!fgfu £t ll ~ ~ £t ~ ~ re Llh ll (3.1fgfllhl~L ,tL ls1. ~£t g 111Lll '11. fJ, ~ ~ L.!fgfu £til~~ £t ~ J1. t l'b l'b

t.L[l.Lis1.1l~(3 ~ ,'11._!LM1Lll'tl.~,~t,'tl.tl11 L!f-,~1~~~(3 ~~ ~1Lll 'ti._!LLI'C~L~ ~~~(3 ~~ ~~~~ ~~'tl.fJ, I I .... I

;p~

Page 16: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

rr ~ El" fl ~ i. ~i. tl tl1i u~ ~ ,z 1 ~ 'Yl1 "~ 1 "11 n 1 ~ ~ 1 3J ~ 1 i" "lJ El" ~ u" f'1u u ru "111 ~ 1 Eli. 3J ,X'" '1.1 :;w '1.1 ...

'411 ~ El" ~EllJ ~1 u"li' ElL rhr;:J1" ,f W;:J1 n rr U" f'1u U ru "111 ~13J ~ ~ ~ El" fl ~ eJ1" tJ" 1 U"ll ru,:;,f Ufl El '1.1 ... '1.1

VHHh~1~ ~~ ~~u~rn ~3J1J~rn Lrl El ~ fln~ El" fl~ ET" iii.~ii n1~~El1J ~1U"li' ElL -n~~1 "~1n '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 '1.1

'V'l~ti\1~1~~~ ~~lJ~rn ~3J1J~rn ~u"fi11JUnJ"lf1~13J~ rr~ El"fl~ eJ1" LL~ rrr1n~ El"fl~ntru~humtJ '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 ... '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 ~

~1 U 1 U LL ~:: ij fl113J L v; u-;h ~ ~ El" fl ~L~ n~:: 'tll ~ ~i U £J El ~1 "f1 E.JLL ~" ,_f" ') ~"li' ElL i1 ~ ~1" '1.1

ET"i.aJ ~3JlJ~rnL ~ £J"l'l El~~::iil~u£Ji.~11~~ El"fl~L~n~::.Yh~ ~iu£J~13J~ ~ fl n~ El"fl~ ii fl113JL v;'" '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 '1.1

Lrl El rrr1n~ El"fl~iJL~L~£Jnl'l~tiJ1~1~~~ ~~lJ~rn ~3J1J~rn ~u"fi11JUnJ"lf1"ll El" ~~ El" fl~ LL~1 '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 ... '1.1

rrfln~El"fl~'Yl~lJL~El~1"h11~~El"fl~n~::Yl1~~iu£Je:J~1"i'1mL~" ,_f" ') ~~1U1Un1~~El1J~1U '1.1'1.1 '1.1

"lJ El" fl ru.:: n~~3J n1~~El1J ~1 U n ij 3J ~1 ~ £J ~ L~ El" L l'l~1:: L v; U 11 ~~ El" fl ~ iJ L~ n ~:: Yl1 ~ ~ ~ '1.1

iu£J LL~ El ~1" 1~ n1~n~::Y11"1J e:J" ~r1n~ e:J" fl~~"n ~11~"~ El i.~11~" 1~ ~:: L i'un1~~e:Ju ~1u '1.1'1.1

l'l £J1U ~ ~ fi!1U ~ fl1~~El1J ~1U 1 utJ~:: L~ULL v\""li' El n ~11~1 1 ~ £J ~~" n ElUii fl113J L v;u 1~ ') tJ"~1n rr~ El"fl~L~~EllJ ~1'\.l,l'l £J1U~"n ~11~13J~~~ El"fl~L~ eJ1"3J1,Xuni.aJ LUU~~ L~£J~ El

'1.1 '1.1

n1~~El1J ~1U L l'l~1::~:: L~"li' ElL i1~~1"~n~::':ii1"i~ LL~!:LUU LU~13J~tJ LLuu.ffu~ e:JULL~::i~n1~ '1.1

' ~

auLiJu~1~::~1f'1rutin 11 ~ a-~1 mh~u~ LL~::~1a-~"ll e:Jn ~11~1"11 e:J"'t1" ~El" ~1 £Jfl~url'1uu1u~rn ... ~ '1.1

auL ~ £J"l'l El~~::~ El i.~11 ttli" 1~L tlull~~aJ rh~~~::uu e:Jtlti"a-~ .nu~::~::u e:Jun1~~" L~u ~

1'" 1"~1"lfn1~El El n i.tli.~ ,.r" rrfl n~ El" fl~ n~:: i.~iifl113J L v; '"i.tl1'" 'Yl1"~"lfEllJ~1 £Jn 11~ 3J1 £JL~ '1.1'1.1 ~

LL~ ~fl n~ El"fl~ n~1 L~ n~::Y11n1~~"n~11 L3J fi1~n~::Yl1"lle:J"rrfl n~ El"fl~~ "iJhhtJun1~~EllJ~U '1.1'1.1 '1.1'1.1

LL~::ii ~1 i" i.aJ Ltlu i.tl~1a-~~tl uuu .ffu~ e:JU LL~::i~n1~auLtlu~1~::~1f'1ru~n 11~ a-~1 m11~u~ '1.1 ... ~

,.r" LUUn1~ 1 -n~ ~-wu.~ 1 un1~iifl113J L v;u 1 ~~" t 'Yl~L~ rr~ El"fl~ El Eln~1n~1"lfn1~i.tl1 U'Yl1"~ ~ '1.1

i.3J"lfe:JU~1£Jn{J~aJ1 £J 5uLtlu~~Y111~ ~1i"LL~::aJ~"lle:J" e:J.n.~~. 1un1~tl~::~a-~fl.f"~ 1!:1 \>/l!:Jctcrcr

Lrl e:J1u ~ ~ G'll rlU£J1 £J'" l!:J ctcrcr ~ ii 3J~L~ rr~ El" fl~ El El n~1n~1"lfn1~ LUU~1 i" LL~:: 3J~ ~ '1.1

i.3J"lfe:JU~1 £Jn{J~aJ1 £J~ElaJ1~1aJfh~uL "lfuL~ £J1nu L ite:J"~1n~1i""ll e:J" e:J. n .~~. ~"n~11 Lllu

~1i"~ ii ~ ~;u L ite:J"aJ1~1nfl11aJ L v;u ~i.3J"lfe:JU~1 £Jn 11~ a-11 £J"ll e:J" ~r1n~ e:J"fl ~ ~n,.f"n1~~ ~ '1.1'1.1

~fln~ El"fl~,;b"li' ElL i1~~1"~l'lUfi"1U~EllJ ~1ULm£Ju L ti £Jutlfu ~~ El"fl~1 u"li' El~1 LLi"~El L il~ '1.1'1.1 '1.1

~ElL i1l'lUfi"1UaJ11-rl Ufi1~~" t 'Yl ~'Yl1"iumLn rr~ El"fl~~1 mf'" rr~ El"fl ~ L v;u 11 Lll"lfe:JlJ '1.1 '1.1

~1 £Jfi{J~ 3J1 £J LL~::n1~Lm£Ju L Vi £Jutlfu"ll El"l'lUn"1U~EllJ ~1uii1 "lfLUU~1-wl'l1n ~1"11 El"~1 ~

~"i.aJ e:J1~'1l 1a-~1fuw"Ltlu"ll e:J£J~ i.aJ m~'ll1a-~11"1f~" t 'Yl~1u'Yl1"iumLn ~~ e:J"fl~i.~ tl~::ne:Junu ~ '1.1

1ufl113J~~~1UL~un1~l'luu (i.~t~) ~~~ El"fl~r1nn~11~1 LL~::r1n~" t 'Yl~1u'Yl1"iu£J~1aJ~1i" .. '1.1 '1.1 '1.1

~ ' ~

"lJ El" rrfln~ El"fl~UU n LUULLflfl113J~~ L ~ £)" L~n1l'El £Jtifln~1 ~ii~1-wl'l1fi~1tlfu L rhu'" iii.~ '1.1 '1.1 '1.1

Page 17: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

rmvn~vh·-nm~1sh1 1 'Y1~~1fln'VI1a L~fu 1 'Yl~'VIunn--h 1 'Y1~~1fl n'VI1a LtlunTm'l:::l'l15u L~~a11 '1.1 q q

dju~th:::YHl@ii'1 a ci1~i'1 mL 'l~ a ci1~L 'l ~1llUmJ1~'l1 G'!~ 1'l'lfl~e:J~ LL vi~'V'l'l:::'l1"111JtytY@i A ~ d .d o tL 1).1 A~

'l::: L u £J1Jsn1'l1"1l'n1'l'V'l ~ L 'le:JU 'V'l. f'l. l!:J elm ct sn~ ~1ll fl1 ~~"11 a~~ r1 nVJ a~ fl ~'Yl l!:J l!:J G'!/l!:J etc£' ct '1.1'1.1

~~-ru ~ m (i) llfi'l1flll l!:J etc£' ct n iiL~'l:::U'VI1e:J 1 'iXL 'VI~~~ 1 wn e:J~';l1'lnl.1 LL~:::-n e:J ~UlJ~U '"1'" q q q

n1'l1 i~~~U'\I~l'l11 'iXL v;u L~11 n1'ln'l:::l'l1"ll a~ ~VJ e:J~fl~~1ll~flnn~11'VI1 Lllun1'ln'l:::l'l1 q '1.1 '1.1

5u L~a11 Lllu~th:::'V'lq@ioi'1 a ci1~i'1 £J LL 'l~ a ci1~ L'l L 'V'l'l1:::fh i~"ll a~ ~r~nVJ a~ f1 ~~~n ~11 Ltlu '1.1 '1.1'1.1

~1i~'Y11~Unfl'le:J~~1llll1~'l1 ct LL vi~'V'l'l:::'ll"ll'Utyty'1i1n-uiju'1i'll"ll'n1'l'Y11~Unfl'le:J~ 'V'l."'. l!:lctm G'!

L iia~'\11n Lllun1'l1 i~1U1'\1~1lln!J'VIll1 £J~ii ~ ~n'l:::'Ylu~ a~r~1u.n1'W"ll a~ ~'Yln'V11awu1~"ll a~ ~VJa~fl~ ~1i~~~n~11~~~a~11Xm~~~11~1£J LL~:::L'VI~~mfu~a~u'l:::nau~1£J (Ci>) "llmti'\1'\11~ '1.1 q q

aULUU~1'l:::~1flty (l!:!) ian!J'VIll1£J~el1~a~ LL~::: (m) ia~'\11'lni.1LL~:::"lla~ulJ~lt'"1un1'l1"lf "' .

~~~U'\1 L lULL~ L 'VI~~~UULUWni'nua ci LL~1 ~1llll1~'l1 m{l'){ LL v\~'W'l:::'l1"1l'Ururu'1i1n-u iiu@i q q '1.1 '1.1 .,., :w

'l1"1l'fi1'l'Y11~Unfl'le:J~ 'V'l. f'l. l!:J elm G'! LL~'\11n~1i~"ll e:J~~flncW e:J~fl~~~n~11 fl~'l:::UL lLL~ L .W £J~ '1.1 '1.1 q . "'

"11m fi'\1'\11~ aULUU~'l:::~1flnJLL~:::,j e:Jfi1'l'V\lJ1£Jfi el1~a~L rhu U ti1u"11 e:J~'\11'lni.1LL~:::,j e:J~lJ~ U ., ~ q

1un1'l1 "lf~ ~~ii.'\l~'\1:::1ii.'\lu£J11 n1'ln'l:::l'l1"ll a~ ~VJ a~"~ Ltlun1'ln'l:::l'l1au L~~a11 L tlu q '1.1

~U'l:::'V'lq@ii'1 e:J ci1~i'1 mL 'l~ e:J ci1~L 'l niiL~'l:::U'VI1e:J 1 'iXL 'VI~~~ L 1 fl~'l:::lJLL~ L -w []~11 ~VJ e:J~fl~ '1.1 q q q '1.1

L~ n'l:::l'l1 ~ ~ ~1ll"11 an ~11'VI1 'V'l q @i n1'lrnLL ~ :::n1'ln'l:::l'l1"ll a~ ~VJ a~"~~~ .W ~ 1~11 L tl u '1.1

~U'l:::'V'lq@ioi'1 e:J ci1~i'1 mL 'l~ L 'Yi1J U :J~,j e:J f111ll~'l:::U1 U~1 i~"ll e:J~ ~flncW e:J~fl~ ~~n ~11Ju '1.1 q '1.1 '1.1

n iiL~LL~~~L 'VI~~~ 1 u"ll e:J~'\11'lnl.1 LL~:::-n e:J~UlJ~U '"1 Ufi1'l1 i~ ~~U'\1 ~'\1:::1ii.'\IU£J11n1'ln'l:::fl1 q q q

"11 a~ ~VJ a~ f1 ~ Ltlu~u'l:::'V'l q @ioi'1 a ci1~i'1 £J LL 'l ~a ci1~ L 'l LL~::: L 'VI~~~~~ n ~11~ ~r~nVJ a~ f1 ~ '1.1 '1.1 q '1.1 '1.1

L~'l:::uL 1JuniihhtluL 'VI~~~~i'nua ci LL~1 L 'V'l'l1:::f111ll ~~~1ll~1~'V'l1n~1sn a~f'l1~~1a-i1"1i q q '1.1 '1.1

fin~~ 1 'Y1~~1flnJ'" ~ll1'lf1LL[Jfifl11ll~ ~ L~L '"'V\~1 [J'l:::~u vr~'l:::~lJLUU~U'l:::'V'ln@i ~~ LL~ ii1"1i '1.1 q '1.1 "I

u'l:::'V'lq@ioi'1 ~u'l:::'V'lq@ioi'1 'VI1a ~u'l:::'V'lq@ii'1 a ci1~i'1 mL 'l~ ~~ LL~1 LL~'V'l q@i n1'lrnLL~:::n1'ln'l:::l'l1 '1.1 '1.1

LtluL~a~ GJ 1u '\l:::'l1l1Lm11'VI1nr~nf'I1~~'V'l1n~111iif111ll~~ LLil'\l:::r~n~~ 1 'Yl~ufun~1llni1 a11 '1.1 '1.1 . ... "'

LUU~U'l:::'V'lq @ii1 e:J ci1~i'1 mL 'l~'Yl~~'" ~1lJU[J ll1~'l1 G'!~ 1'l'lfl ~e:J~ LL vi~'V'l'l:::'l1"1l'Ururu@i '1.1 ., .,

A A 1 A d A Q..oO Q..II.Q .d. 1).1

'l:: LlJ [JlJlJ'l'VI1'l'l1"1l'fi1'lLL~U~U 'V'l. f'l. l!:J elm ct ('Yl~ n fl e:J 'V'l'l:::'l1"1l'1J tyty ~'l::: LlJ [JlJ"lJ1'l1"1l'fi1'l

'V'l~ L1au 'V'l. fl. l!:Jctm ct) fl~ La-iL~i~~ m '\I~U1'lll rnLL vi~1J'Ylfi!J'VIll1 [J~~n~11 L~ e:J~1i~"ll e:J~ ~r~nVJa~f1~~1ll~1i~~ l!:Jl!:JG'!/l!:Jct<I:'ct ~~-ru~ m(i) lln11flll l!:Jct<I:'ct iiL~'l:::UL'VI~~~1,X '1.1 '1.1 q q

fl'llJ ti1U~1ll ll1 ~'l1 m {!')/ LL vi~'V'l'l:::'l1"1l'Uty I!T@i1n-uiju@i'l1"1l'n1'l'Y11~Unfl'le:J~ 'V'l."'. l!:J elm G'!

~1 i~"ll e:J~ trr~nVJ e:J~ fl ~ ~~n ~11~~ L UU~1 i~ ~La-i"ll'e:J lJ ~1 [J'V'l'l:::'l1"1l'U ruru@i1n-u 1iu@i'l1"1l'fi1'l CUCU lUlU ~

I'Y11~Unfl'le:J~ ...

Page 18: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

'Yl1·nJn~rHh1 'V'I. ~. l!:l elm~ i.aJ en~ 1 iu"fiunu ~VJ eh1fl~i.~ Ld Elfl113J L ~u."ll a" ~tmv:J a"fl~ ~ ~~

""" I I I I

(j]13J3J~ El.fi.(j]'J. LU.fi1'J1h::"11'3Jflf"fi l!:J\)/l!:Jcl~~ Lria1u.fi fiJG?I flU.r.l1r.IU. l!:lcl~~ LL~::f11Gl" ~

"l!El"~rmv:Ja"fl~ ~ l!:ll!J~/l!:lcl~cl ~"1'"~ m(i) 3Jn'ilfl3J l!:lc:t~ct dju.f11i"~i.3J"li'EllJ~1rJn!)'VI3J1rJ ~~

.... ""' I I

<i!" U U. f11 ~ 'V'I1 n ~1 "lJ El" ~1 ~ U n fl 'J El "i U. ~ U. fi L v; U. .W El" ~ 1 rJ n 1J 3J ~ LL ~:: f11 Gl" <il" n ~ 11

~" ET" fl ~1 (jJ L fl ~au.~ a"li a L -n~~1" LL~::"li ann 'V13J1 r.1 "llElL ~ ~1~Unfl'JEl"~"~(j]~~1'Jru.1~'V'I1n~1 ~ ~ ~

ntuf11v:i'V'I1n~1~1~Unfl'JEl".ffu.~u.LiJu.l~L~nrtaUaJ~"llEl" a.n.lj]'J.LU.n1W~"11'3Jflf"~ l!:J\)/l!:J<f~~ ~

Lda1u.~ (i)G?I nU.rJ1rJU. l!:lcl~~ 3J~"lJEl" El.fi.(j]'J. (~rtn~El 3J~"lJEl" fi.lj]'J.) lu.n1'JU'J::"11'3J ~ ~

flf"~ (i)~/l!Jcl~~ Lda1u.~ (i)(i) iu.11f1!1 l!:l<f~~ LL~::f11~""llEl"~nnv:Ja"fl~ ~ l!:ll!:l~/l!:l<f~ct ~~

~"1u.~ m(i) 3Jfi'J1fl3J l!:lcl~cl LL~:: L~ii~~U1JLL~1u.~ii3J~LL~::f11~"<i!"n~11 .,

~rtnv:J El"fl~ LLn El'Ylli'lrn 11 ~rtnv:J El"fl~ L ~u.11 f11~'Y'I1 n~1~1 ~Ufifl'JEl"iu.~u. ~~ ~ ~~

"li'El1J~1 m 'V\(j] ~~ LL~1 L il.a"~1n ~VJ El"fl~L~n'l::'t11fl113J~Ij] El1lli1 El ci1"i(j] LL -oil" L U.fi1'J~n ~ EllJ ~ ~ ~

L~U.n1'i'V'Iuu.1(j] r.~i.aJi.~i'u au.ru1(j] LL~::LLi"~a el'u.dJu.L ii~~ a L -oil1'V'!un"1'" ~VJ El"fl~L(j]L ~ n1'J ~ ~ ~

fu~1'J1l1'V'I~U.~1~v:i'V'I1n~1~" 1 'Yl~fl~ r.I~LL~1 n1'i~~VJ El"fl~ eJ1"11~u"fiuuru"11'1 i.~i" 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

~VJ a"fl~i.uuiju~wtl'1~1'" 'V\u 1 r.~uiju~n1'J~ L~~ ni.aJi.~'V13J1 r.~fl113J11~VJ a"fl~~:: i.aJii

L 1 ~1 i.u L ~ u. n1'l'V'IU u. "11 ru.::~ ~ VJ a" fl ~ n'l:: 't11 fl113J ~ (jJ t n ~au L ~ u. n1'l'V'IU u.1 (jJ r.~ i.aJi.~i'u ~

au.ru1(j] 'V'I ~~1'J1~(j]~ t'Ju'Jn! ~3Ju'Jn! ~u"fiuuru"11'1"ll a"~VJ a"fl~i.aJi.~d:Ju.u'J::~n,;'V'I r.~1u. ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

i'L ~ u. n1'Jn'J::'t11"ll a"~ VJ a" fl ~ LL~ a ci1" l(j] fl ru.:: n'i'i3J n1'i~El1J ~1u. 'Yl1 "1 t!r.~ a ci1"f1 r.1 LL 'J" ~ ~

~" L v; u.11 i.aJ ii fl113J~1 Lil '"~~::~a" 1 ~ 'V'I ~ ~1'J1~ (j]~ t'Ju'Jn! ~3J u'Jn! 3J11 ~ t1 a r.~ f11 ~a ~ ~

flrn::nnaJn1'i~EllJ~u. LL~ Lil(j] 1an1~1~ ~VJ a"fl~U1'Y'Ir.11U.3J1L~ n1'i~ Elflrn::nn3Jn1'JElci1"L~ 3J~ ~

LL~ ~ VJ El"fl~ n t ui.aJi.~ U1'V'I rJ1U.3J1L ~ n1'J~t! 1J ~u. u."li a 5 1""ll a"~ VJ El"fl ~La" n1'J~E11J ~1 u. ~ ~ ~

"ll a" fl ru.:: n'l'i3Jn1'i~El1J ~1u. 'Yl1"1 t!r.~ a ci1"f1 r.1 LL 'J "i.~~1 Lit u. n1'i~El1J ~1u.~VJ a" fl ~rtn ~a" ~ ~

(j]13J'J:: L U rJ 1J n 1l 'V13J1 rJ LL~1 ~ rt nv:J El" fl ~rB" L UU.~ Elan f11 i" LL~" ~" fl ru.:: fi'J'J3J fi1'J~El1J ~1 U. ~ ~~ ~

~" ii ~1u.1~ ~~::a an f11 ~" ~" 1 'Yl ~~VJ a" fl ~ (j]13J"li a L -n~~1" ~i.~ fl113J (j]13J n1'i~El1J ~1 u. ~

~" L il u. n1'Ju iju~ 'VI 'll'1~1(j] r.~"ll'au ~1 r.~ n n 'VI3J1 r.~ LL~1 "ll al ~ ~1 ~ u n fl'Ja" ~" ~(j] v:l ~1'Jru.1 ~ ~ ~ .,

~'V'I1n~1tiu.(j]13Jf11~'Y'I1n~1~1~unfl'iEl"iu.~u.

Page 19: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

... fl1~Unfl"Hh'l ~\'1 ~<ilL~ <il1'HJoW';JTHU.1 Lan ~11't1\IVI3J<il 1 u~1u1ufl~ n 1l'V\3J1 ~

'll q ~

1::Lu~u "llmJ\IfllJ ~~~ ~L~~1"llEl\IU1::nauLL~1 "ll m YJ-;)';11\Ifuw\1 L~11 "lim::~ ~YJ El\lfl~i'u11"1l'n11~111';1 ~1 LL wt.i\I~U\IflUV\3-1

'll 'll 'll

Yi1VIU1~V\'l.b~1Jnu~n11oWLfl~ ~111';1111i1i\IVI1<iloW'Yl~\l Lrla-Ju~ mo nu~1 ~U lflctctlfl ou 'll q

~YJ El\lfl ~L~fln L i1VIU1~~111-;)"lf<j)i1J n 3J"ll El\I\11U m n El\1 rh nu n11;1J ~1U~El1J ~1 u 'll 'll q q

~111';1111i1111fl ei!. LL~::L i1VIU1~~111';J~fl1U~111';1111i1eh L11 mi:J El\loW'Yl~\1 iun3J 1 u"ll El'V\1 'll 'll q q

L~un11vntu (Ln1~) 'YiUULEl1'Yli'var~unu1<il~ijL~fuauru1<il wi'a3J~~El\IVI1~U113J lflct flU q "' 'll

.ffuiun 3J~ ~ e:J\IV\1~\1 lfl ct flU 1 ~ n11i'u ~11111'Yi ~\I~ n11'll1 ~1 ~<ii El\IVI1Yii'a3J"ll El\ln ~1\1 q 'll 'll

~\I'ViU n\11U~El1J~1U~fl1U~111';1111i1ih L11 El Li:J El\loW'Yl~\1~1 L ii. Ufl~ ~YJ El\lfl~~\lflniun 3J~1 ~ 'll q 'll 'll q

L~LLi\l~mL~::~aciauLiJuLYI-;)11 ~a u1m~<il L'Yi"ll'Tiiu 'YiUn\11u~au~uL~Yi1n11Lm~uLYi~u1Jfu 'll q

~YJ El\lfl~ ;nu L3J LL~<il\IU<il1U1::~1~1 LL~:: LLn ~\llJ an~mL~::~ El ci audJUL YJ-;) ~1Ufl113J ~<j) 'll ... 'll

~1utn~ auL~un11'YiUU (Ln 1~) 'YiUULEl1'Yli'Yi J~unu 1<il ~L3JL~i'u a~ty1<mtu ~YJa\lfl~ fu~1111'Yi ~~fl~n\1~ ~<ilfl1~i\IVI1<iloW'Yl~\loW'Yi1n~1~\11 'Yl~ufu~YJ e:J\Ifl~ dJuL~u (i),ctoo U1'Yl

q q 'll I I I ....

<ila3J1 ~nnYJa\lfl~L~~fh~\IYi l!l'o>dll!:!clctm ~\11uri ~ n3J111oWulf l!:lcfctm LL<il\l~\lflru::n113Jn11 'll 'll q

~au~1uiu~"ll111"1l'n11 ~1u1u ct 11~ 1<il~~ ((§)) u1~<il1U~111';1 auu<tl i'n1i113J ~u\lf1u'VI3J 'll 'll

(Yi1VIU1~;1J~1U} \11U;1J~1U ~111';1111i1i\IVI1<iloW'Yl~\l dJU~flnn~11VI1~ (i) (1!:1} ~YJe:J\Ifl~ 'll q 'll'll 'll

~U\IfllJV\3-l Yi1VIU1~V\'l.b~1Jnu'11n11oWLfl~ ~111';1111i1i\IVI1<iloW'Yl~\l dJU~flnn~11VI1~ lfl 'll 'll ou 'll q 'll 'll

I A 0 Q..ol " "Q..ol Q..ol I A A 0 0 A Q..ol

(m) ';11~1J<i1111';1 ~1~U VIULLn1 ~1J\Ifl1JVI3J \11U~1J~1U ~fl1U<il111';1111i1El1L11ElL3JEl\I'Vi'Yl~\l 'll 'll 'll 'll q

i\I'VIi'<iloW'Yl~\1 LlJU~flnn~11VI1~ m LL~:: (ct) ~1~1J~111';1 3JUru ru "ll'1<il1 ~U\IfllJV\3-J q 'll 'll 'll "' 'll 'll

\11UiJ El\lnu1J11UU113J ~fl1U~111';111 mihLnmi:l El\loW'Yl~ \1 i\IVI1 <iloW'Yl~\1 Li:Ju~ nnn~11VI1~ ct 'll q q 'll 'll

n1rnnnn~11VI111n1::Yi1~<il1u~aci1\li'1mL1\11<il~~flnn~11VI1~ (i) LL~::~ ct <ila\IVI1fl~a1ru1 'll 'll'll "'

"llaVI1~13Jnu~n~auL~un11YiUU (Ln 1~) 'YiUULEl1'Yli'Yi J~unu 1<il ~L3JL~i'umttlJ1<ilLL~::

Vl~lJVIUn11iUn3J"llEl\ILi1'YiUn\11U ~1U~flnn~11VI1~ lfl (~YJe:J\Ifl~) LL~::~flnn~11VI1~ m q 'll'll 'll 'll'll

<ila\IV\1 fl~ a1ty1 ~13Jnu~n ~au L~un11'Yiuu (Ln 1~) 'YiUULEl1'Yli'Yi J~unu 1<il ~L3JL~

fuauru1<il ~YJa\lfl~L~i'u'Yl11Uf11i\l~\ln~11Lrla1u~ (§)'o> n3Jn1.Wulf lflctctm q "' 'll q

' ' a,... ,::!I Q Q..ol -=I Q.,l 6"

<il13JVIU\I~El 'Yl 'Yi'Yl oolflo.(§)m/cl~o ~\11U'Yl (§)o n3J111'YiU1i l!:Jctctm flrn::n113Jn11 q

~au~1UL~~uwYinn11LLi\ILL~::i'u'Yl11U"llan~11VI1 (~1. lfl} 1~~YJa\lfl~'Yl11U Lrla1u~ '"' 'll

~u1 fl3J lfl ctctm ~YJ El\1 fl~L<ilL ~n111Jij L~li<il ~ a<il"ll an~11VI1 fl ru::n113Jn11~au ~1uiu~

L~111J113J'Yi ~1u VI ~mnu ~ L ~ ~1"ll a\lnu"ll an~11VI1 1J1::n au~1 ~n11~au ~1u Vi ~1uu fl fl ~ ... q

\., 1 3 51, R I 2558 /(§)ei!.lhn ...

Page 20: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

l!:Jo

. ... . ~~ 1.J1n LLfl:V'l£J1t.LLan~r~au 'J LL~1Lv;u11 ~rmn~11'VI11'1~~LaJL~n,-:rh~~iu£Ja~1~i'1mL,-~

'1.1'1.1

;)1\.LLU \.L~LaJ 1.J,-:V'l{l~ ~u1~Lfli ~fl~~~ EJ3J,-,-£J1'YlLLfl:,-:LU £J1JLL1J1JLL~WlJD~~h,-1~ 1.J,-:V'l{l~ ~ \.L ... 'IJ

LaJ ~3J fl1,.LLfl::: LUt.L"l11,-1"1l'n1,-LaJ~n~1;El L ~£]~"1.1 El~~\.LLLfl:::~n ~1 L n £],.~in ~"1.1 El~ ~1 LL 'VI'I.i~ wtX 1~"1.1D~~u~1 ~ L;D3JL~£J 1~ £JLaJ n,-:::,hn1,-1~ '] 5 u, L~; a11LU u,~ 1.J,-:::V'lf1~ i1 a ~1~f1mL,.~

'1.1

5uLtlt.Lfl113J ~~~13JV'l,-:::,-1"1l'unnu~11 ~1 £Jiu£J ~1,.1~ V'l'Yllifl'n,-1"1!' l!:! <L' G'lf G'lf 3J1 ~,.1 c1. ( rn) ... ... q

.... ....... .... "' ... d (G'lf) LLfl::: (~l!:J) LLfl:::V'l,-:::~"ll'1Jtyty~,-:::L1J£J1J"ll1~"1l'n1~flL,-El\.L V'l.fl. l!:Jc!.rnc!. 3J1~~ ~~ 1Tifl'VI\.L~

LLfl:::1,-,.fl ~a~ ~13J~nnn ~11'VI1~~ L v;t.Lfl1,.£J~ L~D~ 1~ £J1.J,-:::1i1t.Ln,-,-3Jn1,-~Du ~1u L~~~ 'IJ q

~1 u, 1 u, n1,-~Du ~1 u, V'li' D3J 3J ~"1.1 a~"' rn::: n,-,-3J n1 ,-~au ~1 u, 1 ~ ~tr~ ~ u n1,-~1,.1 ~ 11li,. '1.1 'IJ . .

Q,...l Q..oo a.,.. Q.;A, .d. A Q..# .d. A

~~'VI1~V'l'Ylfl~'Yl,-11J ~13J'VI\.L~~El 'Yl V'l'Yl ool!:Jo./V'lLfl~ fl~1\.L'Yl rno ~~'VI1fl3J l!:Jc!.<L'rn q

LL~ ~ fl n -w El~fl ~L~W~1,-rn 1,.1 £]~1 \.1, n1,-~El1J ~1\.LLL~1 L v; \.1, 11 rr~ LaJ fl,.1J tl1\.L ~ ~ ii 'VIU~ia '1.1'1.1

d .... d "'1"' 'Yl V'l 'Yl o o l!:! o. ~ rn/ ~ G'lf ~ G'lf~ fl ~1 u, 'Yl l!:! G'lf ~ fl1 fl3J l!:! c1. <L' rn LL ~ ~ 'VI fl rn:::n,-,-3J n1,-~au ~1\.L q

"1.1 a~1 L u1 L 'VI<il ~fln1,.-w~1,-rn1~~ LaJ.W a~"ll D~V'lun~1t.LeJ £Jn1,-~i~ LaJ.W a~ ~nnn~11'VI1~ ~ q '1.1 '1.1

LLfl:::~n n n ~11'VI1~ <L' 1.J,-:::n au ~1u 1un1,-~au ~1u~1 £J ~ D3J11.J,-:::1i1t.Ln,-,-3J n1,.~au ~1u '1.1'1.1

L~ii'VIu~ia ~ V'l'Yl ool!:Jo.~c;n/WLfl~ fl~1u~ ~0 V'l{lfl~n1£J\.L l!:Jc!.<L'rn ~~LDn~1,.L ~3JL~3J ~~ n ~111 ~~n n.W a~ fl ~'Yl,.11J ~ D3J1 ~tr~ f1un1,-~1,.1~11li,-..ij~'VI1~w'Yl fl~ 'W~1,.rn1

'1.1 '1.1 '1.1 '1.1 q

~1u 1un1,-~au ~1wtt'~'VIaJ~ LL~1L v;u, 11 1 u 1uLn~L 'VI<il~.Wa~fl~L~~nfl auL~t.Ln1,-V'lUt.L~~~ qcu

~~ ~.W a~ fl~L~L ~ n1,-~u ~1,.111V'l LLfl:::fl1 fl..ij~'V\1 ~W'Yl fl~ L~ fl~ 1 'Yl ~1.J-i'u ~.W a~ fl ~ L tluL~t.L '1.1 q '1.1

~ ,c!.oo 1J1'Yl ~1\.Ln1,-~ ~oW EJ~fl ~ el1~11 L~LLi~;El~ EJ ~ eJ\.LLU\.LL fl~ LLfl:::~u ~1,-111V'l <il fl EJ ~ 'IJ '1.1

"11 an~11'V11 L ~ atl ~tr~~fi1\.L111V'l"ll D~<ilt.LLD~~1 ~ ~1~i'11LU u~1,.1~ L ~ a1.J,-:::1£J"ll'u1 un1,-iu~u, '1.1 '1.1

V11"ll11J u, L v;u,11 Lrl a~.W D~fl~ nmi1'VIU1~~1,.1~-;ijun 3J ~.W D~fl~'l.i1~::: 1-A1~1,-rnnn rn 1 u, '1.1 '1.1 q '1.1 ...

n1,-~~:::~ a~,-1 £J~1u 1~~tr~f1uuru"ll'1'Yl~u 1 u 1'1u rh~fi L ~ DV11Y11~·1h £J L 'VI~ a LLfl:::wu~1,.1~ 1 'Yl '1.1 ...

~3J~u~ fl1au nf ~i13J..ijun 3J 1 t.Lfl~ttfhtluL i1V11l'1~ ~1,.1~~n1ii.~1,.1~11me:h L11 mrl a~W'Ylfl ~ '1.1 q 'IJ q

~.W a~fl~ n ~L~~£J~1t.LL 'VI<il~ 3J1iu~1t.L'V11"ll111~'Yl~UL~ D'VI1'Yl1~"11'1m'VI~ a~ aLlJ "11 an~11a1~ '1.1 q

"llD~~-w a~"~~ ~-w ~ 1aJ:fiu V'lfl~ n1,-ruLLfl:::n1,-n,-:::rh"ll a~~ .W a~"~ Ltl t.Lfl113J~ <ili u £J a ~1~1'1 mL,-~ '1.1 '1.1

~1u,n,-:::'Yl1n1,.~ u, L~~ a11LU u,~ 1.J,-:::V'lfl~ i1 a ~1~1'1 mL,-~ <il13JV'l,-:::,-1 "ll'U ty t!T~ ,-::: L li £J u

"111,-1"1l'n1,-V'l fl L~au, V'l. fl. l!:! c!.rn c1. 3J1<il,.1 ~~ 1,-,-fl ~a~ L v;t.Lfl1,-fl~ 1 'Yl~ L~ ~.W D~fl~ a an~1n '1.1

,-1"1l'n1,- LL~ ii L 'VI <il eJ\.Lfl1,-1.J,-1Ufl~'VI ~ El\.L 1 'Yl ~ L il.a~~1 n ~oW El~fl~ Lfl £J't11 fl rnl.J,-:::1 £J"ll't.L1 ~ nu q '1.1 q

'Yl1~,.1"1l'n1,- Lv;t.Lfl1,.fl~1'Yl~1.Jfl~~-wa~fl~Dan~1n,-1"1l'n1,- 1.J,-1n!J<il13J'VIU~ia

fl~i'u ~ l!:! ~ n 3J111wui l!:! c/.<L'<L' ~ D3J1 ~nn.W a~ fl ~'W~1,-rn 1 LL~1 ii fl113J L v; uLrl a1u ~ l!:! q 'IJ '1.1

.... /3J\.L1fl3J ...

Page 21: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

o A .:::4 d CV o .cll. AGJ d ~1')"1~'V'I~1')"Ul.1 (fi.~')".) 6lhHlUfi')"')":IJfi1')" n.~')". Lfi£J1filJfi1')"~1LUUfi1')"'Yl1~1U£J flUl.::'Yl 1i>

q t,.l I I I

1un1')"th::"ll':JJflf~Yi l!:!\l/l!:!<t<t<t Li:lu1uri li)G1/ nu£J1£JU l!:J<t<t<t ~~1')"Ul.1LL~1Lv;w-;h trwu~fl~ q ~

tlniun :1J L~1 UlJ1L 1 rn~ L n ~ L ~ ~ .ffuiun :IJ LL~::.ffu~EllJ ~11-l.fl ~ El1ru1 trw El~ fl~L ~ fi1')" ~ q q q ., ~

flJ~')"1l1'V'I~~El~-ff Elfi~11~1~1£Jfl11:JJ~3Jfl')" h 1~ £JLL..ij'~~EILL~::~ Elci elULlJUL ii~ ~~fl~n~~~~ ~ q

1~£Jf'l1~i~~1~~'Yl~~~'V'I1fi~1~~ 1'Yl~ufutrwEl~fl~LUUL~U li>,<too 1J1'Yl LL~::~1fifi1')"~EllJ~1U q ~

L ..ij1~ U1 ~ ~1')"1~ tr·h :JJiu n :IJ L~ fl11 :JJ11 trw El ~ fl ~L~·h :IJ nui n ~ EllJ L~U fi1')"'V'IUU nu ~ q ~

tr ~ El ~ ~ 1 ~ tl n i lJ n :IJ 1 u fl ~ if~ 1 ~ 'V'I fJ ~ n 1 ')" nr LL ~ :; n 1 ')" n ')":; 'Yl1 "lJ El ~ trw El ~ fl ~ L ~~ El11 L tJ u ~ ~ q ~

tru')"::'V'I fl ~i1 El ci1~f1 mL ')"~ L 1lufl11 :IJ ~ ~iu£J El ci1~f1 mL ')" ~ ~1 :IJ :IJ1 ~')"1 i<!~ ')')"')"f) ~El~ ~

LL ~~'V'I')"::')"1"1!'ururu~')"::dj £Ju"li1')"1"1l'n1')"'V'I~ L~Elu 'V'I. f'l. l!:J <trn <t ~~i:i:JJ~L~ trw El~fl~ El un~1n ., ., ~

')"1"1!'fi1')" 1~£J n.~')". LUfl')"11U')"::"l!':JJ flf~~ li)~/l!:!<t<t<t Ldu1u~ li)li) iu11fl:JJ l!:!<t<t<t q

Lv;U"ll'EllJ~1:JJ~L~UEl trt1nWE1~fl~~~L~iif11i~i~~-r~~'Yl~~ ~ l!:!l!:li<!/l!:!<t<tct ~~1u~ rnli) ~ ~ q

:JJn')"1fl:JJ l!:!<ttt<t ~~ 1 'Yl~L~trwu~fl~El un~1n')"1"1!'n1')" trwu~fl~fu'Yl')"1Uf11i~~~ 1 'Yl~L~ El un ~ ~

~1n')"1"1!'fi1')"Ldu1u~ li)li) n:JJ1l1~ui l!:!<t<t<t LL~::L~ii~,X~~El~~1u~ \l iiu1fl:JJ l!:!<t<t<t q

El'Yl1i')"ruf11 i~~~ 1 'Yl ~i~n ~11 El'-l.fi')"')":IJfi1')"fl rn:;n')"')":IJfi1')"-ff1')"1"1!'n1')"~1')"1~ L ~ £J1rllJ El'Yl1i')"ru q q q

LL~::i'El~'Yln"ll1Ufl')"11U')"::"l!':JJflf~~ G?lo!l!:l<t<t<t Ldu1u~ rna nU£J1£JU l!:!<t<t<t L~~~1')"Ul.1 q q

El'Ylmrn"llEJ~trw El~fl~ LL~1L v;u11 -ff ElL ii~~1~LL~::'V'I £J1U~~n~U~U')"lnnfuw~L~ Elci1~an~LL..ij~11 q ~ .... ;w

trw El~fl~tlniun :JJL~L uu1L 1 rn ~ L n~ L ~~ LL~::fu ~1')"1l1'V'Ii~ LL~L u.ffuiun :IJ LL~::.ffu~EllJ ~11-1. ~ ~ q q q

fl~ E11ru1~1 £Jfl11:JJ~3Tfl')" h 1~ £J LL..ij~~El LL~::~ El ci auLUUL ii~ ~~f'l1~i~~-r~~'Yl~~ L~~'V'I1n ~1 ., ~ q

~~ 1 'Yl ~ufu trw El~ fl ~ LL~1 fl ~ n ~ ~ ~~ U')"::n EllJ n lJ'V'I £J1Utriu n :IJ ~1 ~ flurTu 11 trw El~ fl ~ ~ q ~ q ~

L~Un1')"'V'Iuu1uflf~tt~1~ "lim)1~"llEl~trwu~fl~1uu')"::L~U~1~ 'J ~~13-iiim~~mL~::'V'Imu~~n~u ~ q ....

~uu~u uL Vl £J~'V'I ufuw~in ~1~'V'I £J1U~ ~n~1u~u')"1n n L~ ~1 £JL ~~~~ LL~::'V'I £J1U~ ~n~1u q .... ;w q ....

~ u ')" 1 n !J 'V'I fJ ~ n 1 ')" nr LL ~ :; n 1 ')" n ')" :; 'Yl1 "lJ El ~ trw El ~ fl ~ ~ ~ ,r lJ L ~ 11 L tJ u tr u ')" :; 'V'I fJ ~ -t 1 ~ ~

Elci1~f1£JLL')"~ elULUUfl11:1J~~iu£JElci1~f1mL')"~ ~1:JJ:IJ1~')"1 i<!~ '"J')"')"fl~El~ LL~~'V'I')"::')"l"l!'Ururu~ ., ., ... "' .... 6" "'.";'! ... d -~ VJ ,..¥ ..: 6"

')":;Lu £JlJ"lJ1')"1"1!'fi1')"'V'I~ L')"EIU 'V'I. f'l. l!:J<trnci! El'Yl1i')"Ul."lJEl~~l"l El~fl~~~l"l~ b:IJ"llU L ~Ufl1')"£Jfi El'Ylmrn q ~ q

flrn::n')"')":JJfi1')""li1')"1"1!'n1')"~1')"1~ LUfl')"11U')"::"l!':JJflf~~ li)/l!:J<t<t\) Ld u1u ~ li)<t :JJfi')"1fl:JJ l!:J<t<t\) q

f:t ..... .d. I 0 Q,; Q..,ll .c=l.c:t Q..l A Q..<tl d L ~U"ll'EllJ ~1 £J ~1 :IJ'Yl L ~UEI ~ El:IJ1 ~11-1. nu 1 £J fi')"~:IJU~')":IJ~U~ ~El ~lJ 'Yl U ')" o 1i> o <t/1!:! l!:J rn <t ....

~~11-1.~ G1f 'V'Ifj~1l1fl:IJ l!:J<t<t\) LL..ij~11 ')"El~U1£Jnf~:JJU~~ ('V'ImEln "1!'1~~ £J~h~'Yl1i) UijlJ"i')"l"l!'fi1')"

..... ... ILL 'YlU 1-1.1 £Jn')"~:IJU~')" ... ....

Page 22: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

LL 'Yllt '1-41 ~Jni';j3Jt.t~ii VhJ1')nl.1 LL~1~ f'l1i\11 ~ FJn El 'Yl1fH~"lJ El\I~VJ El\lfl~ 1~ FJ~~LL,) \1 ~ flfi1')~';11')nl.1 ~ q ~

El'Yl1l')nl.1~r.rVJa\lf!~'Yl')11J~13J'VIU\I;El ~ ~"11' ooo~.cf.lri'J~~Iii fl\ll'l-4~ l!:Jiii fi')fi1'11fl3J l!:Jcf.ctb q ~ ~

r.rVJ a\lfl~~ll'V-l a h ~fln1')~';)1')ru.1 a'Yl1l')ru~\ln~11 ~\I flu VJ e:J\Ifl~d ~ a3J1f'l1 fltlnf!')e:J\J.ffu~u ~ q

~';11')nl.1 LL~1~ f'l1~'V-l1n1Y1 FJnVJ a \I r.rVJ a\lfl~~ \1 flu a 'Ylmrnf11~'V-l1n1Y1"ll a\lf'l1 fltlnfl')e:J\J.ffu~ u ~ q

1 ~ FJ"ll a1 ~ f'l1 fl tl n fl') a \1 ~ \1 ~~ ~ ';11')nl.1 ~ 'V-l1 n 1!1-1 n ~ u f11 ~ 'V-l1 n 1!1-1 f'l1 fl tl n fl') a \l.ffu~u ~ q

dJt.t1~L~nne:Jt.t3J~"lJEl\l El.fi.~').1t.tn1')U')::"lf3Jflf\l~ l!:Jb/l!:Jcf.ctct Lda1u~ (i)G'N nt.tFJ1FJlt l!:Jcf.ctct q

3J ~"ll El\1 n. ~'). 1 '1-4 fi1')U')::"lf3J flf\1~ ri'J !iill!:J cf.ct ct Ld Elllt ~ ri'J ri'J iu 11 fl3J kl cf.ct ct LLfl::fl1 i\1 q

"lJ El\lr.rnnVJ El\lfl~ ~ l!:J l!:J ~/l!:J cf.ct cf. fl\ll'l-4 ~ m ri'J 3Jfi')1fl3J l!:J cf.ct cf. LLfl:: 1 ~~ ~ flUlJ LL~llt ~~ 3J~ ~~ . 0 Q.; Q.,oo I

LLfl::fl1 ~\I ~\In fl11

fl ~ ~tl'):: L~ u ~"::~a \I iii." uFJ11 n1')~ ~ rmVJ e:J\Ifl~ ~ f11~\l~ l!:! l!:! ~/l!:Jcf.ctcf. ~~

fl\llt.t ~ m(i) 3Jfi')1fl3J l!:Jcf.ctcf. i\lfl \11 'Yll!l-~~ r.rVJ a \1 fl ~a a n"1 fi')1 "11'fi1') L ilu n1')n')::'Yl1 ~"ll'au ~

~ 1 FJ n 1'1 'VI 3J 1 FJ 'VI~ El ~ ll 1 ~ FJ ~ u ru 'V\1 ~ ~ El \ll ii," u FJ ~ 1 3J El 'Yl1)') nr "lJ El \1 ~ VJ El \1 fl ~ n El '"11 ~ ~ q ~

n')::lJ1t.tn1')it.t~at.tn1')~e:J1J~1t.t11XFJ~VJa\lfl~"ll'au~1FJn!)'VI3J1FJ'VI~a~ll A ff'"~l 1 Q...oo CV.c~~t. .Q

'V-l L fl')1 ::'VI LLfl1 L 'VI '1-4 11 3J1 ~')1 ri'J oct 1')')fl ~El \1 LL 'VI \1 v.l'):;')1 "11'1J qj qj ~'):; L 1J FJ 1J . . ... "Ji1')1 "11'fi1')'V-l fl L~Ellt 'V-l. f'l. l!:J cf.m cf. U ru nJ~l1 1 '1-4 n ')ru .y) fl ru.:; fi')')3J fi1')~El1J ~1 Wn LL ~ \1 ~\I

~ ~

' A ._,a, o .::::1 A t;l t..- 1 d

~13J3J1~')1 ri'JOl!:J 'V\')e:J~3Je:J1lt1';1~13J3J1~')1 ri'JOl!:J 1')')fl~3J 1')')fl~ 'V\')e:J1')')fl'V\1 LLfl1LL~fi')nl. ~

L ~'1-4 11"li1')1"1ffi1')'V-l fl L~Ell4~1aJflJ ~1~ n')::'Yh ~ ~iuFJ El r.l1\li'1 FJLL ') \1 ~3J fl1')fl\11 'Yll!I-U fl ~ El El n ~~

'VI~El~~aan 1~~1Lii.t.tn1')~\Jtt ... (m} ~1'VIi'1J~~1')\1~1LL'VIU\I~\ILL~'):;~u r:» fl\13J11t.t')1"1ffi1W1'V11') ~

ff1t.t1lii1l1fl s=A\Iii1"ll'i1'VI1l'1ff1t.t')1"1fn1')tl')::~1~\I'VI1~ 1~ r.r~ ~1t.t1';Ji\Ju')')-;)~13J3J1~')1 ci.l!:! ( ci.) ~ ~ q

ff \1 L ~ El \11 ~ El . n . 'V-l . ~ \1 'VIl ~ :A \1 r.r n n n ~ 11 'V\1 i \1 n ~ El rJ ~ ';! 1 ') n1.1 LL fl:; L d El El. n . 'V-l . ~ \1 'VI1 ~ ~ ~ ~

~ 3J~ Ltlt.ttl')::n1') 1~ 1 ~~~ ~1u 1" i\JlJ')')';I~\In ~11 i\I'VI~atl1iu"i1 ~Lilu ~tl~13J,f u LLfl::f'l1 i\1 ~ q ;w

' ' ' 0 Q..l o I A .:1 Q.; A A .4 o

~1ltfi\11l4~1')1';1LL'VI\1"11'1~ 'Yl bcs:'/l!:Jci.ei:'ri'J fl\11lt'Yl ri'JO 'V-lrjf'I';Jfi1FJ'I-4 l!:Jci.ei:'ri'J L')e:J\1 3JEl1JEl1lt1';1 0 A .:.,Q.; 0 Q...ll 0 I A Q,; 0

fi1')~1 L ltltfi1')'Yl1\11l4FJ ~1'1-4 fi\11'1-4~1')1';1 LL 'VI\1"11'1~ El1f'IFJ El1l41';1~13J 3J1~')1 m Iii ( fd} I Q.,..ClJA d A lA I Q.;CI.-IA

LL 'VI\Jv.l'):;')1"1!'1JflJflJ ~')::LlJ FJ1J1J')'V11m"ll'n1')LL~lt~lt 'V-l. f'l. l!:Jcf.mct 3J1~')1 b ri'J LL 'VI\Iv.l'):;')1"1!'1J ruru ~ cu ., Ql cu

'):; d:i FJ u"li1')1"1fn1')~1')1" 'V-l."'. l!:J cf.l!:J (i) LL n1 "lJ L ~ 3J L ~ 3J 1 ~ FJ tl')::n1 f'lfl ru.::i'n 1!1-1 fl113J ~\llJ . . .c:::l IJ I A Q..ld Q..l,d. Q.;tj' I1J

L')FJlJ')e:JFJLL'VI\1"11'1~ UlJlJ'Yl mlii fl\11lt'Yl kllii fi3J1l1'V-ll41l l!:Jcf.mcs:' "lle:J ri'Jri'J LLfl::3J1~')1 ri'JO<i:' q

LL'VI\Jv-l')::')1"1!'Ururu"i'):;dj FJ1J"Ji1')1"1ffi1')'V-lflL~Elt.t 'V-l.f'l. l!:Jcf.mcf. 3J El1J~1lt1';1 1 ~r.rl1')1"1ffi1')~\J'VIl~ ~ ~ ~

Lilu~ ff\1 L~e:J\1 ( ~1u 1u n1')~e:Ju ~1u 'Yl1\liuFJ a r.l1\li'1 FJLL ') \1 :A \1 r.r11')1"1fn1')~\J'VIl ~ Lilur.r i\1 ~ ~ ~ ... ' ...

LL~ \1 ~\I fl ru,:; fi')')3J fi1')~e:J1J ~1 '1-4 LL fl:; ~ fl fi1')~El1J ~1 '1-4 1 ltL~ El \1 U ltfl ru,:; fi')')3J fi1')~e:J1J ~1 '1-4

Page 23: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

'VI~e:J ~11~1"1l'n1~~..:~'VI1~ L v;u11 ~r1nn~11V11n~::'Yl1 ~~ittr.J e:J ci1..:~f1 r.J LL ~..:J~llf11~~.., 1 'Y1 M ~ ~~

~..:~tl~~ e:J e:Jn'VI~e:J i.~ e:J e:Jn-;nn~1"1l'n1~) 1 i n. ~~. 'W-;)1~m1 LL~::LiJu~i..:~'VI~e:Jtlfju~1 idju i.tl A Q..,.l Q...l'.::., A CJ,.I .4.

~1llll~ n.~~- ~1ll'W~::~1"1l'1H1HlJ~~::LlJr.JlJ"ll1~1"1l'n1~'W~L~e:JU 'W.~. l!:Jcfmcf ll1~~1 Ci>O~ ., .,

1Tif1~e:J..:J (1~) tl~::ne:JlJrllJll1~~ \o>Ci) LL~..:~w~::~"ll'UqJtlJ~~::LUr.JlJozJ1~"1l'n1~<il1~1';1 w.~. l!:!cfl!:!Ci)

n1'VIu~1iu1lJ'Ylururu~1uL~e:J..:~it!'r.JLL~::n1~1'nM1itt'r.J n1~e:Je:Jn';J1n~"ll'n1~ LL~::n1~e:J'Y11l~rn ., ., q

~1llnlJ'VIll1 r.J11~1 r.J~::Lu r.JlJozJ1~1"1l'n1~'W ~ L~ElUll11 "lfu..:~ilJ LLrlozJ1~1"1l'n1~<il1~1';1 t~ r.J El~ t~ ll ...

Q;' Q..,.l A Q.,..oO A " • Q.; Q..,.l A ~ I "" I

~..:~u u 'VI1nf1 m::n~~lln1~~e:JlJ ~1u 1Ur.J'VI~e:J ~11~1"1l'n1~';J..:J'VI1~ ll f111ll L 'VI u 11 ~r1nn ~11'V11 ~ ~~

n~::'Yl1~ ~ittr.J e:J ci1..:~f1mL~..:J~llf11~~.., 1 'YlMtl~~e:J e:Jn'VI~e:J i.~ e:J e:Jn ~11~"1l'n1~i'..:~'VI1 ~';!::~ e:J-.1~ ..:JL~e:J-.1 ~

1i n.~~- 'W';J1~m1 Lrle:J n.~~- iill~djutJ~::n1~1~ ~11~1"1l'n1~i'..:~'VI1~';J::d:Ju~i..:~ ~ ~

'VI~e:Jtlfju~1 idju i.tl ~1llll~ n -~~. ~..:~n~11 G&1V11'1Jfl~d LLaJ f1m::n~~lln1~~e:JlJ~1uittr.J ~1ll ~1 i..:~"ll El-.1 ~rln~ El-.1 fl~';J::iif111ll L v;ULL~::ll ~1 ~ r.J ~ L~e:J-.1 LL~ ~rln~ El..:lfl~ e:J1';Jij~ ~'Wii,';J

~~ q ~~ q

~';J::L v; ULUUEJ ci1..:~5u ~hi~~..:JrllJf111llL v; U"ll e:J..:Jflm::n~~lln1~~e:JlJ~1uittr.Ji.~ LL~ ril e:J..:J~-.1 L~e:J-.1 1i n.~~- 'W-;)1~m1 LL~::Lrle:J n.~~- iill~LiJutl~::n1~1~ ~rln~e:J..:Jfl~cie:Jllrile:J..:~i..:~'VI~e:Jtlnu~

~ ~ ;w

1iLUULU~1llll~ n.~~- ~..:1n~11 ..f..:~tt ~1lltt'r.Jll1~~1 Ci)o~ 1~~fl~El..:l LL~..:JW~::~1"1l'Ururu~ ., ., ... .... ...

~::LlJr.JlJ"ll1~1"1l'n1~'W~L~e:JU 'W.~. l!:Jcfmcf

~ ~ El-.1 fl ~ El 'Yltl~ ru 11 ~ ~ e:J-.1 fl ~ ii L~ n~::'Yl1 fl11ll ~ ~ 1 U n1~L ~ U n1~Wt!' U ~ q ~

(i.~t~) wtt uLm'Y11-wrf~unut~r.Ji.aJi.~11Je:Juru1~ L 'VI~~ r1ni'1Jn ll L w~1:: i.~L "li1 i.tltlfiu~wll'1~ qOI q ~ q ;iJ

~1llfhi..:~"ll e:J..:~~u..:~ilJuru"ll'11 u<il1LL 'VIti..:~ 'VIti 1 r.Jtlnu~'W L~M &'i1..:~ 1 u"llm::tfu ~ e:1 w~<il1~1';1~~ ~ ., ;w

n-~lJ~nr ~lllJ~nr Lrl e:1~r1n~ El..:Jfl~ ir..:~iii.~iin1~~EllJ~1u"li m fl-;)';11..:~';11nw~<il1~1';1~~ n-~lJ~nr ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

~lJ~rn LL~ntlJ~1U~~tiG&1U 1ULL~::iif111ll L v;-u, 11 ~~ El..:lfl~L~n~::rl1 ~~it!'r.J El ci1..:1f1 r.JLL ~..:! ~ q ~

..f..:~~"li e:J L fl-;)';11..:~ rT..:~ i.aJ ~lllJ~rnL .W r.J..:~w e:J ~..:~LiJun1Tiuw..:~wmu'VItmnu~i.3J"ll'e:JlJ~1r.Jn1l'VIlJ1r.J ~ ~ ~

t~r.J~~ e:J..:Jfl~ Lv;u11 'VI1n~rln~ e:J..:Jfl~i.aJ Lv;U~1r.JrllJf1nl.::n~~lln1~~e:JlJ~1uit!'r.J t~mv;u11 ~ ~~

~~ e:J..:Jfl~L~ n~::'Yl1f111ll~ ~it!'r.Je:Jci1..:~f1mL~..:J ~ r1n~ e:J..:Jfl~ ~llf11~ii ~1i..:~ 1i f1m::n~~lln1~~ ~ ~~

~EllJ~UW~<il1~1';1~~ n-~lJ~rn ~lllJ~rn ~U..:JilJUnJ"ll'1"lle:J..:J~~ El..:lfl~ L ~ll L~ll LL~::L~r.Jn"W r.J1U ~ ~ ~ ., ~

Le:Jn~1~~u1~~ L~ r.J1ozl El..:Jll1L Yl Elfl11llLLi..:Ji~LL~::f111llLUU1l~~ll 1un1~~EllJ~1ULL~::i..:~~..:J 1 'YlM

~..:~'V11nw ~ <il1~1';1 ~~ n-~lJ~nr ~lllJ~nr -!'lJ11 LiJu~ i..:~ 1 i ~~ El..:Jfl ~i.tltlnu~wll'1~~1J'V11"li11 ~ ~ ~ ~ ;w

1i'Y11..:J~"ll'n1~~1ll~~~ e:J..:Jf1~n~11el1..:J';J'i..:J n1~ ~~ e:J..:Jfl~rlni'lJn ll 1u1..:1L~un1~tt u~..:~n~11 ~ ~ ~ q

n LU UL 'W~1::Ltl~lJ'V11"li11~1ll~1i..:J~ u..:~i lJU nJ"ll'1 i.aJ LUUfl11ll~ ~'Y11..:Ji ttr.J~1ll~ rl nn~11'V11 ~ ., ~

n1~n~::rl1"ll El-.1 ~ rl n~ El-.1 fl ~ ii1 "lfL UU n1~~EllJ ~1ULL~:: 3j ~1 i..:~ L iJ U LU ~1ll~tJ LLlJlJ .ffu~ e:JU ~ ~ ~

Page 24: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

LL~::1~n1')eJUdJU~1'):: ~1 ~ ru~ n n 'VI:IJ1 tlfl1'VI U~ vf" d:Jun1') 1 "lf~ ~~ii."il t~ £JL3J"lfatJ~1 £J ., ~ ~ ~ ' Q..l ~ I ,Q Q..f A 1.1 A Q..l I

n!J 'V\3J1 £JU U L 'VIU 11 fl rn::n')'):IJ n1')~atJ ~1U 1U£J:IJ'VI U 1'Yl')1lJ')13JYW1U 'VI~ n!1U~1" ')

~ L ~ £J1"li a"nu n')rn~ ~~a""~ nn n ~11 'VIYh n')::'Yh ~~1u£J aci1"f1mL')"~"n~11"1i1"~u 'IJ 'IJ

')13J vf" LL .ij" LL~:: a~tJ1 £J"li an ~11 'VI11 ~~~a" fl ~ 'Yl')1lJ LL ~:: 1 'VILa n1 ~~~a" fl ~~LL "il" LL ~~" 'IJ 'IJ

'Y'l £J1U 'VI tn~1UL Vl a l~LLti""li an~11'VI1~"n~11 LL<1in1')n~11 a1""ll a"~~ a""~~"n~11 Ltlu ~ 'IJ

L 'VI~ 'hu~1 L Vl a~ n~1""li a L Vl"il"il~"~" rn::n')'):JJn1')~au ~1u ')1tJ')1:JJ :JJ1 ~" Lilu 'VIU1~"ll a" ~

' ~

~~a""~La"fi"il::~a"n~11a1"'Y'l~~1TI"il~1 ~w')n! ~u')n! ~tr"~uuru"ln Lilu'Y'lmu TI:JJl1"e1'1" 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ .,

'Y'lmu'VItn~u~u5uLL~~"1~L~uti"'hi""lla"~u"~uuru"lf1 m.Yh"ll'u ti'a£Jf11"lla"'Y'l~~1')1"il~1 ~ 'IJ .,

~w')nt ~:JJu')n! ~tr"~uuru"lf1~"i"n1')~1£J11"il11~~~a""~L"li11th.Jiiu~'VI,z1~~u~u'VI1"ll11 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ ., 'IJ ;;w

1 u~ L n~ L 'VI~ LL<1i~~ a"fl~n ~L~ eJ1"'Y'l £J1U 'VI tn~1UelULUUfl1i""ll a"~u"~uuru"lf1 'VI~au1 ~ 'IJ ~ 'IJ .,

'Y'l £J1U 'VI tn~1u~u:JJ1~u LLn"li an ~11'VI11 u.ffuflrn::n')'):JJn1')~au~1u1tX£J ')1:JJvf" ~L~ a1" ~" ~

t1a£Jf11"lla"'Y'l~~1')1';)~1 ~')lJ')ru ~:IJtJ')ru ~tr"~uuru"lf1~"i"n1')~1£J11"il11~~~a""~L"li11u 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ ., 'IJ

uiiu~'VIU1~~1J~U'VI1"li111u~ Lfl~L'VI~ LL<1i aci1" 1~ vf" rJ"U')1n n·:h Ld a"lJrn::nn~un 3J ~~ a"fl~ ;;w ~ ;;w 'IJ ~ 'IJ

n ~ L~')1 £J"1UL 'VI~ 1~ ~ u"~ lJU nJ"lf1~13Jfh~ u.ffU'Yl')1lJL Vl a'V\1'Yl1""1l'1m 'VI~ a 1 u-.1 ufi -.1 u1~ ~ 'IJ .,

LL<1i n tu :JJ1')1 £J"1 u 1 ~ ~tr" ~u tr ru"1r1 'Yl')1tJ Ld a1u ~ Ci) G'll :JJ n')1 fi:JJ 1!:1 ct~ rn ~" L ~ u 1~11 'IJ .,

fl rn::n')'):JJ n1')~au ~1u L~L tJ ~ t a n1 ~ 1 ~~~a" fl ~ u 1 'Y'l £11 U:JJ11 ~ n1')<11 a fl rn::n')'):JJ n1') 'IJ

a ci1" L~ :JJ~ LL~1 ut11 ~~ a"fl~n tuL3JL~u 1'Y'l £J1U:JJ11 ~ n1')~U'u ~u u"li a a1""ll a"~~ a""~ La" 'IJ ~ 'IJ

')13Jvf" L~LL .ij" LL~::a~tJ1£J"li an~11'V111~ ~~ a"fi~'Yl')ltJ u~:: 1 'VILa n1 ~~~a" fl ~~LL "il" LL ~~" 'IJ 'IJ

'Y'l £J1U 'VItn~1UL Vl a l~LLrJ""li an ~11'VI1 LL~1 LL~::LLaJ'Y'l~~1')1"il~1 ~')tJ')ru ~:IJtJ')ru "il::1tJ11 ~ 'IJ 'IJ

Lilu~ i" ~~ a""~1'VI1.uuiiu~'VI,z1~~u'VI1"ll111~'Yl1"')1"1fn1')~13J~ ~~a""~ a1""il~" n LiluLYl £]" 'IJ 'IJ ;;w 'IJ

~

'Y'l£J1U'VIt n~1UU')::natJ~1U1Un1')~atJ~1UL 'Yhu u 'V11'Yh 1~ n1')n')::'t11"lla"~~ a"fi~L3J Ltl u ~ 'IJ

fi113J ~ ~'Yl1"1u£J~13J~rlnn ~11'VI1 LL<1i a ci1" 1~ L3J ~"Ld aflrn::nTI:JJn1')~atJ~U1um~u11 'IJ

'Y'l £J1U 'VI tn ~1U ~')1lJ')13J 3J1 £i"li a L Vl"il "il~" L Yl £J"'Y'l a t~ £JL3J-;h ~a" ~au ~1U 'Y'l ~ ~1')1 ';1~1 ~

~')lJ')ru ~:IJtJ')ru~" L ilu~ a an fl1 i" LL<1i"i" 1 ~~~a" fl ~u 1iu~'VIU1~1 u 'V\U 1 £JU iiu~ n1') 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ ;;w ;;w

~ L~HiJn ~"L~ ~')U~1U 1UL~Ua')1 £J"1Un1')~atJ~1Ut1i a~ a anf11 ~" LL<1i"i"flnl.::n')')3Jn1') ~ 'IJ

~au~1u1u£J n1')1tJ~"'Y'l£J1U'VItn~1u"lla""rn::n')'):JJn1')~au~u1u£J~"n~11 ~"13-ltimilu ~

n1')n')::'t111 utf1u ~ dju~1')::~1~ru e1un""llU1~~"il::LiJuL 'VI~ 1 ~n1')a anf11 i"~"n~11"ll a" ., ~

~nn~ a""~ Lilun1')n')::'t11~L3J"lfatJ~1 £Jn1'l'V\:JJ1 £J "li a a1""li ad"lla"~~ a""~~"L3J m"il1u~"L~ 'IJ'IJ ~ 'IJ

~

~",!' U n')::lJ1U n1')~atJ ~1 U 'Yl1"1U£J a ci1 "f1 £J LL ')" Mi au~" t 'Yl H~~ a" fl ~L~ ~1 L ii, Un1') 'IJ

Page 25: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

~ A.c:l Q...i' ~ A.c:l Q...l Q...IA A

'ii13J"ll\.l.'il eJULL ~:::1!inTH~'eJ 1J ~1 U'i113J 'VI~ n L n lli'Yl LL~:::1 !in11'i113J 'V'11:::11 "1!'1J qj qj 'il1::: L 1J £.11J

eff111"l!'n11'V'Im1eJu 'V'I.fl. l!J~rn~ 1.h:::neJ1J n~ n.'V'I. uuu~ CiJ" ('V'I.fl. l!l~<to) eJeJn'i113J~11:JJ1u

llil£J"l!'eJ1J~1£Jn~'VI:JJ1mL~1 an..f" n11iu-;Jumr"~" l 'Yl~~YJ eJ"~~niil-;Ju£J llil£Jnlilfi e1"1Y m ii-;)-;)1"

'ii13J~1u 1u~~"ll eJ"~ ru:::n11:1Jn11~eJ1J ~1u 1u£J ~" 1iL~ £J LL-;1" LL~::: eJ~1J1 £Jeff eJ n ~11'V111 'IX

~YJ el"~ ~'Yl111J LL~::: 1 'VILeJn1 ~~YJ el" ~~:fLL -;J" LL~'ii"'V'I £.11\.I.'VI t n~1U liLLrj""JJ eJn ~11'VI1 LL~1 'IJ 'IJ ....

l'il £.1 ~YJ eJ" ~ ~1~ ~"U13J~1J'Yl111J LL~::: 1 'IX n11tl ~ L ~!i"JJ eJn ~11'VI1 113J..f" 11il1 'IX n11L ~ 3J L~ 3J

mi"JJ eJn ~11'VI1 a n~.f"'VIrt" LL~:::U1'V'I £.11\.l.lJ~ ~ ~ ~1 £.1 ~YJ el"~~ :JJ11 'IX n11'il el~ ru:::n113J n11 q 'IJ

~eJ1J~1UlU£.1 cieJ:IJLL~'il" 1 '!XL ~U11~i"JeJ"~~1~'Yl111J"J! eJ L ii-;J-;J1"LL~:::1'i1LiLLrj" LL~'ii"'VItn~1U 'IJ ....

"11 eJ" 'i!UeJ ci1" L .W £.1" 'V'I eJ LL~1 LL~::: 1aJ tl11n n11 ~ rmYJ eJ"~~1iiin11Ltl~ £JULLtl~"'VI1m ~ :JJ L~ :JJ ;...~ 'IJ 'IJ

eff eJ n ~ 11 'V\11 'VI aJ LL Iii eJ ci 1 "1 'i1 a n ..f" L 'VI 'il ~ ~ ~ ~ rl n YJ eJ " ~ ~ i" ~ "l 'Yl ~ n L U U L 'VI 'il ~ ~ ~ ii q 'IJ 'IJ q

'V'I £.11\.1. 'VI tn~1u~uu~u u ~fuf:J'" 1i .... q

~ ~ iiuru'V\1 ~ i eJ"oW ';111ru 1 Iii eJ 11..111 ~YJ eJ" ~ ~1i n1:::rh ~113J ~ 'il 'i113J~ ... 'IJ

r1 n n ~11 'V\1 LL ~::: ~ r1 nYJ eJ" ~ ~1'il1 i''il ~ 'W il-;J ~ "l 'Yl ~~YJ eJ" ~ ~ "1!' eJ u i1 £J n n 'VI:JJ1 £J 'VI1eJ 1aJ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ q 'IJ ~

~~ iitl,-:::L~u~-;J:::i eJ"iil-;Jumd e1"iu11 ~YJ eJ"~~1iL~un11'V'IU u (1n t~) 'V'IU uLm'Yl~'V'I Ef~unu 'IJ

l'i1£J~1i~ueJuru1'ii-;JUrJm-;11'VIU1~~111-;J,)un:JJ LL~:::fl1~,r"'VIl'ii~'Yl~"'W'V'I1n~1~" l 'Yl~tlfu q ... 'IJ q q

~YJ eJ"~~ LtluL'~u Ci),~oo 1J1'Yl 'i113Jeff eJn~11'VI1'VI1eJ 1aJ LL~:::n11n1:::rhJ ULUUn11tl1:::'V'Iq~i1 'IJ

eJci1"11mL,-"'VI1eJ1aJ L ~u11 l'il £J~:JJ1'il11 <t~ LL v\"'V'I,-:::11"ll'ururu~,-:::Lu £Ju"1Y111"ll'n11til111-;) ... ...

'V'I.fl. l!:l~l!JCi) utytl}'~111UmL~:::n11i'n~1lU£J"lleJ""J!111"ll'n11~111-;) 1"'LUU 1tl'i113Jn~'VI:IJ1 £.1

11 i1 £JlU£.1~111-;) LL~::::IJ1'i111 b Ci) LL v\"'V'11:::11"ll'Ururu~ L~ £.11rl\.l. ururu~11 1 U1:::'V111" ~ ~ ~ ~

~ rT" ii 1~ LL n1 "11 L ~ 3J L ~ 3J 'V'I1:::11"ll'U ru ru~11 i1 £Jl U£.1 ti\111-;) 'V'I 'Yl !ifln11"1!' '1!:1 <£' 4')/ 4')/ 1 '!Xu 1 ... ... q

'V'I~ L1eJu 'V'I. fl. l!l ~Ci)" :JJ11i'u"~u LLriL~ eJ"i umL~:::n11fn~11 u£J n11e1 eJn-;J1n11"l!'n11

LL~:::n11eJ'Yl!i1rn"ll eJ""lY111"ll'n11til111';l'i11:JJ'V'I1:::,-1"ll'ururu~dt'il £J e1u t~ :JJ l'il £J 1 '!Xfi e111 dju q ~ ~ q

~1u 'VIit""ll eJ"n ~'VI:JJ1 £.111~1 £Jiu£Jtil111-;J ... "JJ m ii-;J-;J1"tl,-1 nlJ11 1 U"ll ru:::~ iin11LL!il"i"

~ ru:::n113J n11~el1J ~1\.1. lU£.1 LL ri ~YJ el" ~ ~J uET" ~1iii n11LL n1 "11 L ~ 3J L~ 3J'V'I1:::11"l!'Uru ru~ 'IJ ... ...

11i1£Jiu£J~111-;J 'V'I'Yl!ifln11"1!' l!l<i.'4'lf4'lf ~"ieJ"U11J'Ylururu~1u'VI:JJ1'il <i.' iumL~::: q ......

Q... AQ.,.I 0 A AQ...I ~ I Q...l Q...IA

n111n~11U£J 'VI:JJ1'il ~ n11'il1mun11'Yl1"1U£J u~:::'VI:JJ1'il 4'lf n11eJ'Ylmrn LL'VI"'V'I1:::11"1!'1Jruru'il q ... ...

1:::LU£J1Jeff111"ll'n11'V'I~L1eJu 'V'I.fl. l!J~rn~ :JJ11i'u"~1JLLri"lY111"l!'nT~til111-;J llil£JeJUl~:JJ llil£.1~ q

/3J1'i111 ~ ( Ci) l!J ) ...

Page 26: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

1 Q.,,l Q..IIAito<l A<Vo Q.,,l Q..ll Q,.IAI

3J1~11 (/. ( (i) l!:J} bb 'Vh'I'W1~11"1l''lJ qJqJ ~11 ~1 EJ1'1-HJ ~111';1 ~'Yl1lflfi11"1l' l!:J <i:' ~ ~ '1JqJqJ~11

n11n1~~1~113J~~iuEJ~1';11-;Jiu ~1u1i~3J1EJ~113J113Jn~n11n1~~1i~-;J~n~11 ~a 1tld ( (i)l!:J) tl1~-wq~ ~~iumi111"1!'n11-w~b~au i~~uqJt!Y~11l u-w1~11"1l'uqJt!Y~';l~bu EJ'lJ

"ll111"1l'n11'W~b~au~1iaci bb~~3J1~';11 ~~ 111~wct~ bb~~'W1~11"1l'ururu1h~LUEJ'lJ"li'111"1l'n11 ~ ~ ~

' A Q...l G..IAt 4JJ A Q..t" Q..; d .d. Q..ll

'W~b1e.JU 'W.fl. l!:J(/.m(/. '1Jruru~11 "1J111"1l'n11'Wm1eJU~13JnJ~eJ~1n~1"1l'm~EJ~"lleJ~~u bb~~1n~1 ~ ~ ~

Ln EJ1~in~"lla~~1Lmti~wtX1~';11"1l'n1';l"1JeJ~~u~1iL;a3Jb;EJ 1~ EJ11ln1~~1n111~ 'J 5u 1~~ai1 bUU~tl1~-wq~i'1111~~a~ ururu1ii1 n11n1~~1~113J~~eJ1nJ1-;Ju1tlii''lJ 1 'Yl~-;l1~n ... Li'uu~ cu QIQI Ql q

Lilu1 'Yl~th~i''lJ~113J~~~1~n1~~1 1~E.Jtl1~3J1'Yl ~~e.J~113J~~~~ 1'Yl~ ~~an11n1~~1~ut~ q

5u1<1i~ai1Lilu~tl1~-wq~i'1aci1~i'1mb1~ bUU~113J~~iuE.Jaci1~i'1EJLb1~ "llm-tl-;J-;J~~tu~~d ~

i''lJW~EJ~1<1ii1 ~v:Ja~~~1<1ii13Jrl'lJ~~Ub~Un11'WUU (1~1~) 'WUUbeJ1'Yli'-wEf~unu1~EJ13J"ll'eJ'lJ q ~ ~

<li1 EJ n 11 ~ 3J1 EJ bb~~ ~ ~ n11~1 b ii. u~ ~ a1 ru1 i~ n ~11 fl1 ~-;ij~ ~1 ~~'Yl ~ ~ 1<1fij fi1 ~-w1 n ~1 ~ ~ q

~13J~~~ 3J1 E.Jb~"1J~1~ (i)<i:' ~(/./l!:J (/.<i:'l!:J ~3J1 E.Jb~"ll bb~~~ (i)Gn b o/l!:J cl<i:'l!::J ~~ 1 'Yl~tlf'lJ ~VJ e.J~~~ ~

LUUL~u (i),ctoo 'lJ1'Yl 1~EJ~VJa~~~1aJ1<1ia'Yl1l1rnfiT~'W1n~1 ~~~~n~~~~ n11b~un11-wuu ~ q q

(1~ 1~) 'WU Ube.J1'Yli''W Ef~unu 1~ EJ13J"ll'eJ'lJ~1 E.Jfi!)~3J1 EJ ci eJ 3Jtli a~ne.Ji1 bUUfi11U1~'Wtl~~u

b;e.J 3J b;EJ 1aJi'n~1~eJL;EJ~ bb~~ b n EJ1~in ~"ll a~~1 bb ~u.~~U1~11"1l'n11"1l a~ ~u 5ubilu

n11tl1~-wq~i'1 ~13J3J1~11 ~~ 111~~rt~ bb~~'W1~11"1l'UqJqJ1i1~buEJ'lJ"li'111"1l'n11'W~b~au 'W. fl. l!:J (/. m cl bb~~b~ eJ 1<1f~';l11tu1n ~'Wtl ~ fi11rn"ll e.J~~VJ e.J~~~ ~1t1fbb ,)~~ eJ i1 bb ~~~ eJ ~n ~

~ q

eJUbUUb i1 -;Ji1~u~a u1 m~ ~ b 'W"1!'1ti u "1l ru~fl mi1~1Z1~ ~111-;J-;ij''lJn 3JL u"ll a~1~ n~ eJ'lJ q ~ q

b~un11-wu u (1~ 1~) bb~~r1n~1bii. u~~~13Jfi1l~3J1EJ ~VJ a~~~ bUUbi1~u1~ ~1TI-;Jci aaJtli a~'Yl';ll'lJ ~ ~ ~

Lil ua ci1~~i1L~ mi1-wu n~1u~1n11-;ij 'lJn 3J ~ r1 n-;ij 'lJ n 3J-;J~tli a~ Lbi ~~ ai1 bb~~~ a ~n ~~13J q ~ ~ q q

~113J Lil U-;J~ ~"ll a~~u 1 iL i1-wu n~1u~ ~1n11-;ij 'lJn 3J'Yl11'1J~13Jn 11 ~3J1 EJ ~1n bb-;) ~~ai1 bb~~ ~ q ~

~a~n ~ 5 uLiluL i1 -;)~a Li1-wun~1u~~1n11-;ij'1Jn 3J ~VJ a~~~n-;J~ij ~113J~ ~ 1 uY11~ a1ru1 1<1i q ~ q ~ ~

n11n1~~1"1J a~ ~VJ a~~~i~n ~11~~ b ~ub ilu~11li1~1n ~VJ a~~~ bUU~'lJ~~'Yl~~~a~L<Ii ~ q ~ ~ q

~n~a'lJL~un11-wu u (L~ 1~) -wuuLm'Yli'-wEf~unu1~EJ~1tlii''lJauru1~ m~ 1~~~~ a~ui~~ai1 q ~ q

bb~~~a~n ~eJUbUUb Yi-;J~1atlntl ~~ai1u~~~a~n ~~ bb tl-;J~~ tl1~na'lJn'lJtl11fi1l~13JUU fin q q :w

~'lJ~3Ji1~VJa~~~1~1imn'lJ~m-w1u"lla~1~n~a'lJL~um';l'Wuu (1~1~) -wuULmm-wEf~unu

1~ EJ~ L~ i''lJeJU ru1~ bL~~~ VJ e.J~~~ nL<Ii ~~~ ai''lJ'Yl11'lJU uri nn11-;ij 'lJn 3J11 ui 1 LL~~~ t.l3J1 q ~ ~ q

1u.ffun11~ ';111tu1"1J e.J~fl1 ~i~~-r ~~ 'Yl ~ ~ ~ VJ e.J~~~ n1 i n11i''lJ ~111l1'W~ eJ fl1 ~-;ij~~-r ~~ 'Yl ~ ~ q ~ q

~~~~ n ~~ ~~ fl1~-;ij~~-r ~~'Yl~ ~1<1fij fl1~ 'W1n~1 LUU~~ ~3J1 E.Jb~"1J~1~ (i)<i:'~(/./l!:J cfctl!:J q q

A."'_..•~"--·~---,-p;--.j~?1~~;. ~ -- ·--=='~.- '-.... :.·.f /

. I

Page 27: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

fi~'V16J1fJL~"lJLL~hl~ ~Hni>o/l!Jcf<L'l!J 1~~"1'Yl~ u-ru ~.cfoo 1J1'Yl LLaJ~~a"fi~';J::eJ1"11;a~1 'IJ

LL~::;a~n~~u·nnn1u.~1~"W1n~1"1Ja"fl1~i"wr~~'Yl~"';l::U11nnLuu.;a u.1m~~ L"W"1r1'\.iu. q ;w q ;w q

'VI11 "lf;a~1LL~::;a~~"1Ja"~~ a"fl~n~16J LL<1i~~ a"fl~nL~ £J a6J-r1J11~U.LL,)";a~1LL~::;a~n~ q 'IJ 'IJ q

elU.L UU.L Yl';l LL~:: i.~ fl n L ,)1'VI 1X1~ @1111';1 L u1 r.JlJ L .y; r.J1Ju-ru"li a'V\1 LL ,r";a LL~::~ a~ elU.L UU.L Yl';J 'IJ 'IJ

~" LL6JL u.n11~';111lli1~"W1n~1fi~Unfl1a" i.1i~n!]'V16J1 m11'VIU.~ 1 ~ fl1 ~~1~ a"~ a"li a L Yl';l';J1"

~16J~U11 n!J1 u.~1~-w1n~1fl~ ~1u.a1ty1 LL<1iu1:: L~u. ~~ a"iii.';!Ur.J Lif a" ~u.1 U.fl ~d'~11 ~~ a"fl ~i.~L~u.n11-wu u. (L~ 1~) -wu u.La1'Yl-r-w Ef~u.nu.1~ £J iii.~-ru au.ru1~';JU.flnL,r1'VI1X1~ 'IJ q ., 'IJ

@1111-;)iu naJ LL~:: ~ ~fl~ii"~ ~~ fl1 ~:ij"'VIi' ~~'Yl ~"~-w1n~1 ~" 1 'Yl~u-ru~~ a"fl~ dJu.L~u. q q q 'IJ

~.<foo 1J1'Yl ~16J"li an~11'VI1'VI~a i.3-i LL~::n11n1::rhtt u.Ltlu.n11U1::'Wfl~-E'1a ~1"i'1 rJLL 1"'VI~a i.3-i

~" fl1 ~i"'VIi' ~~'Yl~"i.*lii.';Jur.J i.1LLtr1 LL~:: 1u.fl~ mru1i"n~11~~ a"fl~i.~1 ~ n1TI1J~11l1'W~ ~ q ., 'IJ

~16J~ a" ~ "~ mu U.~1 hX fi11~ LU u.u ~if n,;LL~~ LU u.1 'Yl~~ a~~ a"fl~ La" LL~~LU u,~~ 1 '\X

fl1~i"'VIl ~~'Yl~"~'W1fi~1~" 1 'Yl~~~ a"fl~1u.n~1~ a6J1 ~11~ fi11"1Ja"~~ a"fl~ LL~::~1~'W1fi~1 q 'IJ 'IJ

fl~ mru1i"n~11~"Ltlu.-wmu.'V1tmnu.~ ~J1'VIum ;a~ a i.~ L~ a~~ a"fl ~iii.~ a'Yl1i1rnfl'~~1u. ., ... 'IJ q

fi116JL1i"lra1J~1 r.Jn 11'V\6J1 r.J"ll a"~1~ -w1n~1~ ~" 1 'Yl~~~ a"fl~1 U.fi116J~ ~i"n~11 ';JU.fl~ ii "~ ~~ ~ 'IJ q

off mfi';J';)1"~16J~11~ n11"1Ja"~~ a"fl~i"n~11~"~ aaJ~ ~~~n~u.~~ a"fl~ LLaJ~~ a"fi~';J::a'Ylmrn 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ q

a1"11i.~-ru~1i"~1£J11';11';11n~u"fl'uuru"lr1 ~a-w~@i111';1~1 n1u1rn ~6Ju1rn 1'VI1uuiiu~ 'IJ ., 'IJ 'IJ ;w

'V11X1~'VIli1£JU~U~ n11~ Lfl~L ~ a~1J~1U.'VI1"ll11 LL~::n11LL,r";a~1LL~::;a~~ ~elU.LUU.L Yl';J'VI~a untJ~;a~1LL~::;a~n~~ LL't'i-;)1" n L ~ auntJ~~fi1U.1l1'W~ LL't'i';l1""1Ja"~U.La"L ~ au1:: 1£J"lrU.1 U.

q

fi11~1J ~1'1-l. 'VI1"ll11n ~16J n LUU.L .w r.J"fi11fi~11eJ1"'W r.J1U.1J flfl~~ "LUU.lJ flfl~1l1£JU.an e) U.L tJ u. q q

n11"JJ~ LLiJ"nlJ ~11 ~ n11-ru ~11 1l1'W"lJ a"~~ a"fl ~1 U.fl ~ a1ru1 L~ 6J 1~£J~U.L ;a" ~"~ a6JL3-i ~ 'IJ .,

J1'VIu m .W r.J"owa 1~-ruw"i.~ LL~::';J1n-wf1~n11rnLL~::n11n1::'Yl1"1Ja"~~ a"fl~~" 'V16J ~ i"~ n ~11 'IJ

6J1 LLtr1"1i1" ~u. ~a 6J LUU.Lfl~a" ~u.ETu.ii"L ';l~U.1"1Ja"~~ a"fl~ a~1"i~ LL-;)"11 ~~ a"fl~ ~ L';l~U.1 'IJ 'IJ

L ~ U.n11'WU U.~ ~ n!] 'VI6J1 £J a U.L uu. n11i.1i-rn ~1;a L ~r.J""ll a"~ U.LL~ ::-rn ~1 L n r.J1~ fl'n ~"ll a"

@11 LL 'VIli"'VI1X1~11"1rfi11"1J a"~u.ii1 'iXL~a6J L~r.J ~"~a LUU.fi11fi1::'Yl1 au. i.~;a11 LUU.~ U1~'Wfl~i1 'IJ

a~1"i'1mL1" LL~::LUU.fi116J~~iur.Ja~1"i'1mL1" ~16J6J1~11 ~tr:i 111fl~a" LL~"'W1::11"11Ururu~ ., ., ... .., ... .,j ' ... .,j "".':1 ... 6' ' 1:: L 1J r.J1J"ll111"1rn11'W ~ L 1 au. ow. fl. l!l cfm <f ~16J'Yl fl n n ~11'VI1 n 1m 'Yl ~~a" fl ~a 'Yl1i1rn 11

'IJ 'IJ q

~1i""ll a"~fl n~ a"fl~ iii.~1::1J'VI~a 1 'iXL 'VI~~~ 1 u."li a~';l11rn1 LL~::"li a~uu~u. u.1 u.n11 1"11~ ~~it';! 'IJ 'IJ q q q q

11 fi11n1::'Yl1"1J a"~~ a" fl~ ~16J~fl nn ~11'VI1 LUU. fi11n1::'Yl1 au. i.~;a11 LUU.~U1=:'Wfl~-E'1 'IJ 'IJ 'IJ

a ~1"i'1 mL1" a ~1" i. 1 ~u.Ltlu.~1i"~i.1i"lrau~1£Jn!]'VI6J1£Jtt u. ~"i.3-i m';l-ruw"i.~

Page 28: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

UnJ'V\T;J::~ El\I~\ITHU.1~ El LU~\1~11 rrr1n~ El\l~~i.~1-n~~~U\I~\I 1 'Yl~rr~ El\1~~ ., '1.1 '1.1 ~ '1.1

"ll'El1J~1£Jn!)'V13J1£l'VI1EJi.aJ L~U11 3J1~11 ~of£ 111~'VIrt\l LL~\I'W1::11"1l'Ut!JtY~1::LU£.J1J "li111"1l'n11'W~L1ElU 'W.f'l. l!:J<lm<l ururu~11 "li111"1l'n11'W~L1ElU~1aJrum~n1::Yi1~~lU£.J

Ql Ql Ql 'U

El ci1..1i'1 mL1\I 1 ~rru\lf11Juru"D'1i"~" t 'Yl~u ~~ El Eln 'VI1El i.~ El Eln ~13J~113Ji'1 mL1\I LL ~..1n1nl '1.1 .,

tl1~ L 'VI~ elU~11~~'VIci ElU\1::\t 13J1U1::nEJ1Jn11~\111nl.1~~ t 'Yl~ni.~ LL~~13Jii1~ ~~ t 'Yl~vhn11 ~

u~~EJEln ,.f\lif 111£.J1~u\lf11J111~~El\l U1::nEl1Jrl1JLhUn\11U~111\ILL~\I"ll'1~ (n13J~111\I L~3J) i.~~n11n1'V\U~'VI tn L n rn~n11~\l'tl rn~"li111"1l'n11~111\l rrn1::Yi1 ~ ~lUE.J LL~::~'V\ U\1 ~El

'1.1

~ ~1. ocfl!:Jl!:J.c£~/rlmbb ~\11U~ b iirlU1£.JU l!:J<lm~ LL-;)\11~~~el1U1\I~\111nl.1~\lt'Yl~ ~ '1.1

'Yl1\liu£.Jii EJ LUULL u 1'Yl1\11 un11~\111rn1 ~"'tl rn~"li111"1l'n11~111\l~n1::Yi1~~iu£.J 1 ~Ltlu '1.1

3J1~1!1UL~ £.J1rlU ;B\11::~1Jn11~\l'tlrn~ (1 'Yl~) "li111"1l'n11~111\l LL U1J'Yl1 £.J'VIU\I~El~\ln~11 ~1~1J~ rl ~113J~~L~£.J1n1Jn11"WUU rl.m LUU~L~Un11'WUU~~n!)'VI3J1£.J (~) L~un11-wuu u1::L11'Yl~i.aJ~3J11rJElttt!J1~ 1 ~L~ui.~~13Jn!)'V13J1 £.J 1::~1J'tlrn~~ El i.~ El Eln Lrl El~1JW\IL~11 rr~ El\1~ ~ ~'W{l ~n11mLL~::n11n1::Yi1 ~13J"li Eln ~11'V11 LL~::n11n1::Yi1"1J El\1 ~~ El\1 ~~~\In ~11 '1.1 '1.1

ii1"Jl'dJUL Vl £.J\In11L~Un11'WUU~~n!)'VI3J1 £.J LL~ rJ\I~n11LL,)\I;El~1 LL~::;El~~~ elULUUL il\1~ El

L -;l1-wun.:~1u~Yi1n11i1Jn 3J :B" Ltlu ow q ~n11m~ L -;l1wtX1~~111\I i.aJ~11n1::Yi1 LUUEl ci1..1 ri" '1.1 ~

LL~::~ ~1 f) ru ~~ El\1 ~ ~ L 11 UL ,)1 'VI U1 ~ ~111 \1 LL ~:: ~ el1 u 1\1 'VI U1 ~iJ El \1 nULL~ ::u111J U113J "''1.1

~n1::Yi1~~nn'V13J1 E.Jn11owuu~1 mL~1 n11~rrr1n~ EJ\I~~~'hi\1~ l!:ll!:l ~/l!:l<tc£<t ~..1-Ju~ '1.1 ~ '1.1'1.1

m ~ 3Jn11~ 3J l!:J <tc£<t ~\It 'Yl ~ L~ ~~ El\1~~ El Eln\11n11"1l'n11~\l"ll'El1J~1 E.Jn !)'VI3J1 £.J LL~::LUU

n111 -n~ ~~U\11 un11~\l t 'Yl~~ L 'V13J1::~3Jn1Jowq~n11mLL~::n11n1::Yi1~113J~~"llEl\l~~ El\1~~ ~ '1.1

~13J3J1~11 ~oc£ LL~\I"W1::11"1l'Ururu~~\ln~11 u1::nEJ1Jrl1J'VIU\I~El~1Un\11U~111\ILL~\I"ll'1~ ., ., ' ' 0 .Q. #:I Q.,, .c:l A 4).1

(n13J~111\I L~3J) 'Yl ~1. o<ll!:Jl!:J.c£~/rlmbb ~\11U'Yl b 3JtlU1£.JU l!:J<lm~ LL~1 ~

n1m ~ ~~ El\1~~ El'Yl1l1m 11 LL3J ~~ El\1~~\l::rlnilJn 3J LL~::tlnf'l1 ~i\I'VI1~oW'Yl ~\I '1.1 ~ '1.1 '1.1 ~ '1.1 ~

~ ~1~'W1 n ~1 U~1Jn ~13J LL~n11tln f'l1 ~ ~ ~1~'W1 n ~1U~1J n LU u i.u ~13J.ffu~ ElU"lJ El\1 '1.1

n1::1J1un11£.J ~m13J :B"~ El\ILL£.Jn~1\I'VI1n\11n~113J~~ 1u 'Yl1\liu£.J L -w11::1J1\In1mrrr1nn~11'V11 ~ '1.1 '1.1

El1\ln1::Yi1 ~~~13J~1~"W1n~1"ll El\lf'l1 ~ LL~ El1\l i.aJ LUU~113J ~~ 1 U'Yl1\llU£.J LL~::~113J ~~

~1uL~un11-wuu (i.~ t~) ~~~El\l~~rJnn~11'VI1LL~::rJn~" t 'Yl~'Yl1\liumfun Ltlu~113J~~ ~ '1.1 '1.1 '1.1

LVl E.J\IL~nt!EJE.J~ r1 nf'l1~ii ~1~-w1n~1ui'1JL ·rhJ u iii.~ r1 nf'l1~~-w1n~1~\l t 'Yl~-;)1~ n'V11El i.~i'1J t 'Yl~ '1.1 '1.1 ~

'VIunn11 t 'Yl~-;l1~n 'VI1mtlun11n1::Yi1aui.~;El11LUU~U1::'W{l~-i'1Elci1\li'1mL1.:JLL~ EJci1..11~J u ~ '1.1

<:: ' IL'VIU11 ...

Page 29: (a 'Ylrr·nu.)pr.moi.go.th/Law/คำพิพากษาศาล...r. I d Q.l d 1 2 'UJ.A. 7558 ~ 1tJ~~DdtJVI ..... .(a , 'Ylrr·nu.) 6' I A61'Vi3J1Ut6UJ611YI "" 0 "" D. GJGJolwcrcro

L ~ u11 n11~1L ii, un11'Yl1"11Xmil U3J1<111n1TIJeN u"~ n1~1 r.Jtlnfl1u" 1 un11fl11J fl3J<1111~ ~uu ~

VHl~ n11rn"ll u""li'111"1!'n111 Uu" ~ n1 ~"ii nlJVI3J1 r.J LL~::1::LU r.J1J rl1'VIU<1l'VIU1~ LL~::i~n11 ~uu~1u 'W ~11ru.1L 'Yl~'Yl1"1 ur.JL1t<11 mu vn:: u~::LLr.Jn~h"V11n~1nn1::1J1U 'W ~11ru.1"1J u"fl1~

effm't1~~~"~1nn11~u1J~1uYJ"i.~11~rmn~11'V11ii'1"4n~n11rnn1::'th~<115u~u"~1r.J1J'YlUruru"i 1\JCU Dl cucu

~ t1 nn~11V1111n11n1::'t11~"n~11 LUUfl113J ~ <11iur.J ~tr"~ uu ruozr1n ii e:i1u1~ 1 un11'W ~11ru.1 '\J '\J .,

1ii.~ur.J~" 1 'Yl~'Y11"1ur.Ji.~ u'Ylmrn"li' ud"llu"~VJ f)"fl~~"i.aJ fl1~1'uYJ" L~L "ll'unu ~ '\J

ff1ll.u'Yl1l1rnsn u ~ll. ') "lJ u" ~VJ u"fl~~ U Vl1't111 ~ ~~ LL vi" fl~ttLtJ~ r.Jll.LLU ~" i.tJi.aJ ~ '\J

~"w~1~ u"1ii.~ur.J ~fl1~tlnfl1u".ffu~ww'l"41n~1 r.JnVJ u" fl1~tlnfl1u" ~"~<11 L ~u ~ e1"~1 r.J '\J ~

6"

U1r.J~3J"1!'1r.J "13J1"fi'l"lfll.

<11~1n11fl1~tlnfl1u"~"~<11 ~ '\J ~