A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

  • Upload
    kbs109

  • View
    232

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    1/208

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    2/208

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    3/208

    !"#$%& $( &)" *$++,--,$. &$ /--"-- &)"0)%"1& &$ &)" 2.,&"3 4&1&"- (%$+

    56"7&%$+18."&,7 9:6-" ;5

    !"#$#%&' )&$#*+&' ,+-"&.$"/%$/"0.

    !"##$%%$"& ()#*)+%

    ?%@ A$). 4@ B$-&"%C A%@

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    4/208

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    5/208

    !"#$#!%&(%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%& '( )'*+&*+,

    --

    $$..//00112233!!22445511445566"#$%

    !"#$%'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' )*+&,-./0#12#3#-45 ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' *6

    78%94#" :' ;-$"%54"% R;8#82;#7 &%9H;2%+ 08@6+,9*........................................................................... QJ5678%9#:;7;,* ,3 PD"........................................................................................... QQ'38+%S6%82%+ 34 R;8#82;#7 0849#+,962,69% R#;769% ............................................... BMK%23--%8@#,;38+................................................................................................ BO

    78%94#" G' !#4".0#% (6,3-3:;7% #8@ A962X;8$ 0849#+,962,69%+..................................................... //MD#9;,;-% &>;11;8$ ............................................................................................... //?

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    6/208

    !"#$#!%&(%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%& '( )'*+&*+,

    ---

    '3--%92;#7 (H;#,;38........................................................................................... /MMK%23--%8@#,;38+................................................................................................ /ML

    78%94#" ?' E..1 ;-$"%54"% [#,%9 [39X+ ................................................................................................. /ON5678%9#:;7;,* ,3 PD"........................................................................................... /OM'38+%S6%82%+ 34 [#,%9 0849#+,962,69% R#;769%..................................................... /OIK%23--%8@#,;38+................................................................................................ /O?

    78%94#" J' >3#"2#-&M N#")*''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' :C?08,93@62,;38.......................................................................................................... /OL

    P-%9$%82* &%9H;2%+ &*+,%-+ (92>;,%2,69% #8@ Y1%9#,;38+ ................................ /OL0-1#2, 34 #8 PD" (,,#2X..................................................................................... /OBK%23--%8@#,;38+................................................................................................ /J?

    78%94#" :K' N9% NM54#35''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' :GF08,93@62,;38.......................................................................................................... /JQA%9-+ 34 K%4%9%82% 439 ,%77;,%+......................................................................... /JBW;8%C34C&;$>, P\13+69% ,3 # T627%#9 )%,38#,;38 ................................................ /JB"%9+;+,%8,7* A9#11%@ K#@;#,;38 #8@ 0,+ P44%2,+...................................................... /?/T627%#9 [%#138 P44%2,+ 38 P7%2,938;2 &*+,%-+.................................................. /?M,%77;,% U9368@ &,#,;38+ ..................................................................................... /?L);+26++;38 34 K%+67,+ ........................................................................................... /?QR;8@;8$+................................................................................................................ /LNK%23--%8@#,;38+................................................................................................ /L/

    78%94#" ::' I.)#"-3#-4'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' :?=08,93@62,;38.......................................................................................................... /LMD#;8,#;8;8$ U3H%98-%8, '388%2,;H;,* #8@ '3>%9%82%....................................... /LMK%23--%8@#,;38+................................................................................................ /LM

    78%94#" :=' O##9*-2 A8# 7*4*P#-"M ;-$."3#1Q >$$#&45 R- !#.90# '''''''''''''''''''''''' :?B08,93@62,;38.......................................................................................................... /L?0-1#2, 34 #8 PD" (,,#2X..................................................................................... /L?K%23--%8@#,;38+................................................................................................ /Q/

    +99#-1*6 +' A8# 7.33*55*.- %-1 ;45 78%"4#"'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' +S:Y9$#8;]#,;38......................................................................................................... (C/

    D%,>3@ ................................................................................................................. (CM(2,;H;,;%+ .............................................................................................................. (CM

    +99#-1*6 D' D*.2"%98*#5'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' DS:

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    7/208

    !"#$#!%&(%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%& '( )'*+&*+,

    -.

    &&7766552233**778899::1166"#$%

    R;$69% /C/. A*1;2#7 &'()( (92>;,%2,69% .................................................................... MR;$69% /CM. U%8%9;2 &'()( (92>;,%2,69%.................................................................... I

    R;$69% /CI. "W' &^;,2> (2,6#,39 ................................................................................. OR;$69% /CO. PD" &;-67#,39 ^;,> A%+, &,962,69%+ #8@ 08,%98#7 P7%2,938;2+ .................. JR;$69% /CJ. &3-% 34 ,>% P7%2,938;2 '38,937 &*+,%-+ P\13+%@ ;8 A%+, R#2;7;,* ........... ?R;$69% /C?. ">*+;2#7 D3@%7 V+%@ ,3 _6#8,;4* '3617;8$ ,3 );44%9%8, '#:7%

    W%8$,>+ ;8 # =*13,>%,;2#7 W32#7 (9%# T%,^39X EW(TG ....................................... LR;$69% /CL. ( '382%1,6#7 0776+,9#,;38 34 ,>% 08,%92388%2,%@8%++ 34 P7%-%8,+

    '38,#;8%@ [;,>;8 P#2> '9;,;2#7 0849#+,962,69%. .................................................... /MR;$69% /CQ. 08,%9@%1%8@%82* 439 (8,;2;1#,%@ T%,^39X 34 ,>% R6,69% ........................... /OR;$69% /CB. K%+67,+ 34 # D3@%7 &;-67#,;38................................................................... /JR;$69% MC/. "3^%9 &*+,%- YH%9H;%^............................................................................ M/R;$69% MCM. TPK' 08,%92388%2,;38+ ............................................................................. MJR;$69% MCI. U0' )#-#$% ,3 A9#8+439-%9 )69;8$ /BQB U%3-#$8%,;2 &,39-............... II

    R;$69% MCO. PD" &;-67#,39........................................................................................... IQR;$69% MCJ. A%+, 0,%-< P7%2,938;2 K%7#*........................................................................ ONR;$69% MC?. R7#+>3H%9 Y:+%9H%@ )69;8$ 08`%2,;38 "67+% A%+,;8$ ................................. O/R;$69% IC/. U%8%9;2 A%7%23--68;2#,;38+ T%,^39X (92>;,%2,69%................................. ??R;$69% ICM. &%1,%-:%9 //Z MNN/Z a732X%@ '#77 K#,%b'%7767#9 T%,^39X+................... LNR;$69% ICI. P\#-17% T%,^39X D#8#$%-%8, R#2;7;,* ................................................... L/R;$69% ICO. '%7767#9 a#+% &,#,;38 PS6;1-%8, ............................................................... LMR;$69% ICJ. K36,%9+ '377%2,;8$ T%,^39X D#8#$%-%8, )#,# ........................................ LMR;$69% IC?. '%7767#9 T%,^39X A%+,;8$ #, 0TW ............................................................... LOR;$69% ICL. A%+,;8$ #, TYAP& R#2;7;,*......................................................................... LOR;$69% ICQ. &%269% (22%++ '#9@ #8@ '%77 ">38%+......................................................... LJ

    R;$69% ICB. "%92%8,#$% 34 '#77+ '3-17%,%@ 0--%@;#,%7* (4,%9 PD" PH%8, ................ L?R;$69% IC/N. "%92%8,#$% 34 '#77+ '3-17%,%@ O =369+ (4,%9 PD" PH%8, ..................... L?R;$69% IC//. "%92%8,#$% 34 '#77+ '3-17%,%@ M )#*+ (4,%9 PD" PH%8,....................... LLR;$69% IC/M. "%92%8,#$% 34 '#77+ '3-17%,%@ #, A;-% A EW3$#9;,>-;2 A;-% &2#7%G

    E[;,>;8 PD" '38,369+G........................................................................................ LLR;$69% JC/. "%,937%6- 0849#+,962,69%............................................................................. B?R;$69% JCM. T#,69#7 U#+ 0849#+,962,69%.......................................................................... BLR;$69% JCI. A*1;2#7 &'()( (99#8$%-%8, 439 Y;7 Y1%9#,;38+..................................... BBR;$69% JCO. &'()( 08,%$9#,%+ '38,937 34 K%-3,% T#,69#7 U#+ R#2;7;,;%+................... /NNR;$69% JCJ. P\#-17%+ 34 Y;7 08,%9@%1%8@%82;%+ ........................................................... /NMR;$69% JC?. P\#-17%+ 34 T#,69#7 U#+ 08,%9@%1%8@%82;%+ ............................................. /NMR;$69% ?C/. MNNI '7#++ 0 K#;793#@ A38+ Y9;$;8#,%@...................................................... /NL

    R;$69% ?CM. '&cA A9#;8 );+1#,2> '%8,%9 ..................................................................... /NQR;$69% ?CI. A*1;2#7 a732X &;$8#7 '38,937 PS6;1-%8, P8273+69% ................................. //NR;$69% ?CO. U9#@% '93++;8$ &>%7,%9 #8@ &%8+39 '388%2,;38 ........................................ //NR;$69% ?CJ. D3@%98 W323-3,;H% R682,;38#7 a732X );#$9#- ....................................... ///R;$69% ?C?. ( A*1;2#7 &;$8#7;]%@ 08,%9+%2,;38.............................................................. //IR;$69% ?CL. '38,#;8%9 '9#8%+ #8@ &,39%@ '38,#;8%9+ ................................................... //LR;$69% ?CQ. KAU #, &%#$;9, D#9;8% A%9-;8#7 ............................................................... //QR;$69% ?CB. =#8@>%7@ [;9%7%++ )#,# V8;,..................................................................... //B

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    8/208

    !"#$#!%&(%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%& '( )'*+&*+,

    .

    R;$69% ?C/N. A962X '38,937 &,#,;38............................................................................... //BR;$69% ?C//. (8 (KA'' Y1%9#,;38+ K33- ................................................................. /MMR;$69% BC/. ( U%8%9;2 D3@%98 P-%9$%82* &%9H;2%+ &*+,%-....................................... /OQR;$69% /NC/. R93- 7%4, ,3 9;$>,Z ,>% YK(TUPZ AP(dZ d0TUR0&=Z

    '=P'dD(APZ #8@ &A(KR0&= >;$>C#7,;,6@% 8627%#9 ,%+,+ 238@62,%@;8 /BJQ #8@ /B?M :* ,>% V8;,%@ &,#,%+ 8%#9 e3>8+,38 0+7#8@ ;8 ,>% -;@C"#2;4;2 ................................................................................................................... /JB

    R;$69% /NCM. ,%77;,% Y9:;,+ 0776+,9#,%@ ........................................................................ /JBR;$69% /NCI. (9%#+ 34 &1#2% 099#@;#,%@ :* ">3,38+ #8@ T%6,938+................................ /?NR;$69% /NCO. T#,69#77* 322699;8$ :%7,+ E5#8 (77%8 :%7,+G 34 %8%9$%,;2 1#9,;27%+

    1%9+;+,%8,7* ,9#11%@ ;8 ,>% $%3-#$8%,;2 4;%7@ #9% ;776+,9#,%@ ................................ /?/R;$69% /NCJ. &2>%-#,;2 @;#$9#- 34 9%7#,;H% ;8,%8+;,;%+ 34 ,9#11%@ 476\%+

    493- ,^3 ;@%8,;2#7 >;$>C#7,;,6@% 8627%#9 @%,38#,;38+ ........................................... /?/R;$69% /NC?. ,%77;,%+ 9%-#;8;8$ #4,%9 # /N DA :69+, 3H%9 W#X% &61%9;39.................. /?LR;$69% /NCL. ,%77;,% $9368@C:#+%@ 9%2%;H%9 36,#$% ,;-% #4,%9 # /N DA

    :69+, 3H%9 W#X% &61%9;39....................................................................................... /?LR;$69% /NCQ. =PY +#,%77;,% %\13+69% ,3 ,9#11%@ 9#@;#,;38 193@62%@ :* PH%8,+

    //Z /LZ #8@ M/........................................................................................................ /?Q

    &&7766552233$$..//001166A#:7% IC/. A%7%23--68;2#,;38+ PS6;1-%8, A%+,%@ ..................................................... LIA#:7% /NC/. A9;#7 T627%#9 PH%8,+.................................................................................. /?IA#:7% /NCM. (8#7*+;+ 34 ,%77;,%+ ................................................................................. /?OA#:7% /NCI. "93:#:;7;,* A>#, ,%77;,%+ &644%9 )#-#$% :* );9%2, P\13+69% ,3

    cCK#*+ .................................................................................................................. /?JA#:7% /NCO. A9;#7 PH%8,+ ;8 U9361 / ............................................................................. /?JA#:7% /NCJ. A9;#7 PH%8,+ ;8 U9361 M ............................................................................. /??

    A#:7% /NC?. A9;#7 PH%8,+ ;8 U9361 I ............................................................................. /??

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    9/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'$

    ()

    !!""##$$%%

    "#$ %#&'()*+ *,- '.)(*+ /*01() ./ 2#$ 3,(2$- 42*2$' (' '5'2*(,$- 0& * '&'2$6 ./ '&'2$6'7* ).6%+$8 *,- -&,*6() ,$29.1: ./ (,2$1+.):(,; *,- (,2$1-$%$,-$,2 (,/1*'215)251$'? 9#.'$ #*16.,(.5' /5,)2(.,(,; $,*0+$' 2#$ 6&1(*-*)2(.,'@ 21*,'*)2(.,'@ *,- (,/.16*2(., /+.9 2#*2 5,-$1;(1- 2#$ .1-$1+& ).,-5)2 ./ )(A(+

    '.)($2& (, 2#(' ).5,21&B "#$ A5+,$1*0(+(2& ./ 2#$'$ (,/1*'215)251$' 2. 2#1$*2' C -$+(0$1*2$@*))(-$,2*+@ *,- *)2' ./ ,*251$ C (' 2#$ /.)5' ./ ;1$*2+& #$(;#2$,$- ).,)$1, (, 2#$ )511$,2$1*@ * %1.)$'' *))$+$1*2$- 0& 2#$ $A$,2' ./ DEFF *,- 1$)$,2 #511()*,$'@ (,)+5-(,; G*21(,**,- H(2*B

    "#(' 1$%.12 %1$'$,2' 2#$ 1$'5+2' ./ 2#$ I.66(''(.,J' *''$''6$,2 ./ 2#$ $//$)2' ./ * #(;#*+2(25-$ $+$)21.6*;,$2() %5+'$

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    10/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'$

    ())

    (,)+5-(,; $6$1;$,)& %.9$1 '5%%+($'@ 0*22$1($'@ '2*,-0& /5$+ '5%%+($'@ ).665,()*2(.,'@*,- 6*,%.9$1 1$'.51)$' 2#*2 )*, 0$ 6.0(+([$-@ )..1-(,*2$-@ *,- -('%*2)#$-@ 2.;$2#$1+$*- 2. * ).,2(,5(,; -$;1*-*2(., ./ )1(2()*+ (,/1*'215)251$' /.1 * %1.+.,;$- %$1(.- ./ 2(6$B

    K+$)21()*+ %.9$1 (' ,$)$''*1& 2. '5%%.12 .2#$1 )1(2()*+ (,/1*'215)251$'@ (,)+5-(,; '5%%+&*,- -('21(052(., ./ 9*2$1@ /..-@ /5$+@ ).665,()*2(.,'@ 21*,'%.12@ /(,*,)(*+ 21*,'*)2(.,'@

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

    $+$)21.,()'B

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

    * 65)# +.,;$1 2(6$ 2#*, %+*,,$-B

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

    "#$ I.66(''(., 1$S5$'2$- *,- 1$)$(A$- (,/.16*2(., /1.6 * ,560$1 ./ Y$-$1*+ *;$,T)($' *,- ^*2(.,*+ W*0.1*2.1($'B U$ 1$)$(A$- (,/.16*2(., /1.6 2#$ ^.12# N6$1()*, K+$)T21() H$+(*0(+(2& I.1%.1*2(.,@ 2#$ M1$'(-$,2J' ^*2(.,*+ 4$)51(2& "$+$).665,()*2(.,'N-A('.1& I.66(22$$@ 2#$ ^*2(.,*+ I.665,()*2(.,' 4&'2$6

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    11/208

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    12/208

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    13/208

    !"#$#!%&(%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'()*+),)%-./0

    %%..//00112233445566447744008899"#$ %&''())(&* () +,$-)$. /& -01*&2,$.3$ /#$ )4++&5/ &6 (/) )/-667 2#&)$

    +5&6$))(&*-,()' -*. /$0#*(0-, 0&'+$/$*0$ #-8$ 0&*/5(94/$. )49)/-*/(-,,: /& /#() 5$+&5/;

    $&53$ ?-1$5

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    14/208

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    15/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,-($.&(/0&/(' "1221,$34&4'.)

    !!..//001122334455##667733//88113399::11993322!!;;2288"#$ %#&'()*+ *,- '.)(*+ /*01() ./ 2#$ 3,(2$- 42*2$' (' '5'2*(,$- 0& * '&'2$6 ./ '&'2$6'7

    * ).6%+$8 *,- -&,*6() ,$29.1: ./ (,2$1+.):(,; *,- (,2$1-$%$,-$,2 (,/1*'215)251$'? 9#.'$ #*16.,(.5' /5,)2(.,(,; $,*0+$' 2#$ 6&1(*-*)2(.,'@ 21*,'*)2(.,'@ *,- (,/.16*2(., /+.9 2#*2 5,-$1;(1- 2#$ .1-$1+& ).,-5)2 ./ )(A(+

    '.)($2& (, 2#(' ).5,21&B "#$ A5+,$1*0(+(2& ./ 2#$'$ (,/1*'215)251$' 2. 2#1$*2' C -$+(0$1*2$@*))(-$,2*+@ *,- *)2' ./ ,*251$ C (' 2#$ /.)5' ./ #$(;#2$,$- ).,)$1, (, 2#$ )511$,2 $1*@ *%1.)$'' *))$+$1*2$- 0& 2#$ $A$,2' ./ DEFF *,- 1$)$,2 #511()*,$'@ (,)+5-(,; G*21(,* *,-H(2*B

    "#(' A.+56$ /.)5'$' ., * -$')1(%2(., ./ 2#$ %.2$,2(*+ A5+,$1*0(+(2($' ./ .51 )1(2()*+,*2(.,*+ (,/1*'215)251$' 2. $+$)21.6*;,$2() %5+'$

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    16/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,-($.&(/0&/(' "1221,$34&4'.5

    +,-# !. - /012134PSRS' *1$ $+$)21.,() ).,21.+ '&'2$6' 2#*2 6*& 0$ 5'$- /.1 -*2* *)Q5('(2(., *,- ).,21.+.A$1 +*1;$ *,- ;$.;1*%#()*++& -('21(052$- (,/1*'215)251$ '&'2$6'B "#$& /(,- $82$,'(A$ 5'$(, )1(2()*+ (,/1*'215)251$ *%%+()*2(.,' '5)# *' $+$)21()*+ 21*,'6(''(., *,- -('21(052(.,@9*2$1 6*,*;$6$,2@ *,- .(+ *,- ;*' %(%$+(,$'B 4PSRS 2$)#,.+.;& #*' 0$,$/(2$- /1.6'$A$1*+ -$)*-$' ./ -$A$+.%6$,2B O2 #*' (2' ;$,$'(' (, 2#$ 2$+$6$21& '&'2$6' 5'$- 0& 2#$1*(+1.*- *,- *A(*2(., (,-5'21($'B

    !" $%&'()'* +,,,- ./" 01'2% 3%4"56 7/5'* 8459%*156 /": ./" 01'2% ;/< /": =>'?5*1? ?%(@/"1'>%" @'* :/6 B>%C */5' %%:1"2- /": *'>/5': :/(/2' 5%

    @*1&/5' /": @4)>1? @*%@'*56EK G9' 4*' C/< >/5'* :'5'*(1"': 5% )' */:/*

    %@'*/5': %" / '< %BB 59' ?%/

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    17/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,-($.&(/0&/(' "1221,$34&4'.6

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

    S 2&%()*+ 4PSRS *1)#(2$)251$ /.1 2#$ $+$)21() %.9$1 (,-5'21& 6*& ).,'('2 ./ * )$,21*+L

    (N$- ).6%52$1 C 2#$ 6*'2$1 2$16(,*+ 5,(2

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    18/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,-($.&(/0&/(' "1221,$34&4'.7

    *, .(+ 1$/(,$1& .1 * )#$6()*+ %+*,2B O, ).,21*'2@ * 4PSRS 2&%()*++& 6(;#2 0$ '(2$- (, *,$,A(1.,6$,2 9(2# -('%$1'$- *''$2' 9#$1$ 1$*+L2(6$ '(25*2(.,*+ *9*1$,$'' /1.6 1$6.2$+.)*2(.,' (' * :$& $+$6$,2 ./ )$,21*+(N$- ).,21.+B J.'2 RP4 (,'2*++*2(.,' ).,21.+ ).6%+$8@-&,*6() '&'2$6' 2#*2 9.5+- 0$ -(//()5+2 .1 (6%.''(0+$ 2. ).,21.+ (, * '*/$ .1 $).,.6()*+6*,,$1 5'(,; .,+& 6*,5*+ ).,21.+B

    IA$, * 1$+*2(A$+& '21*(;#2/.19*1- %1.)$'' '5)# *' $+$)21()*+ %.9$1 ;$,$1*2(., 5'(,; *).,A$,2(.,*+ '2$*6 )&)+$ 1$Q5(1$' #(;#+& ).6%+$8 '&'2$6' 2. 6*8(6(N$ $//()($,)&@ 9#(+$6*(,2*(,(,; '*/$2& *,- $,A(1.,6$,2*+ %1.2$)2(.,B [.1 $8*6%+$@ ).,21.+ '&'2$6' (, *'2$*6 ;$,$1*2(,; %+*,2 9.5+- (,)+5-$ %*1*6$2$1' '5)# *' ;$,$1*2.1 '%$$-@ ;$,$1*2.1+501()*2(., .(+ %1$''51$@ $8)(2*2(., )511$,2 *,- A.+2*;$ .52%52@ /$$- 9*2$1 %1$''51$ *,-0.(+$1 '2$*6 -156 +$A$+@ *,- *(1 0.8 %1$''51$ *,- 1*2$ ./ ).605'2(.,B

    3%'$2 ./ 2#$'$ ).,21.+ %.(,2' #*' 2#$ %.2$,2(*+ 2. )*5'$ '$A$1$ %#&'()*+ -*6*;$B S )*'$(, %.(,2 (' 2#$ 0.(+$1 $,-%.(,2' ./ ).605'2(., *,- )(1)5+*2(.,B T.16*++&@ 2#$ ).,21.+ '&'L2$6 9.5+- /(1'2 1$*)# 2#$ $,-%.(,2 ./ ).605'2(.,

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    19/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,-($.&(/0&/(' "1221,$34&4'.8

    '$1A()$ *' * %1.2$)2(A$ [*1*-*& )*;$ (' 2&%()*++& 6(,(6*+B \$,$1*++& '5)# 6$2*++() ).,L2*(,$1' *1$ -$'(;,$- .,+& 2. %1.A(-$ %1.2$)2(., /1.6 2#$ $+$6$,2' *,- * 6.-()56 ./%#&'()*+ '$)51(2&B "#$& 2&%()*++& *1$ ,.2 -$'(;,$- 2. %1.2$)2 2#$ $+$)21.,()' /1.6 #(;#L$,$1;& $+$)21.6*;,$2() %5+'$' 2#*2 6*& (,/(+21*2$ $(2#$1 /1.6 2#$ /1$$ /($+- .1 /1.6 2#$6*,& *,2$,,*$

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    20/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,-($.&(/0&/(' "1221,$34&4'.9

    !"#$%& ()G* 1?C& ?7 65& A0&.6%?:". 2?:6%?0 1,D6&CD AH-?D&E ": +&D6 !/."0"6,

    456 /)9':-#)%" ;7.#)"

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    23/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,-($.&(/0&/(' "1221,$34&4'.D

    /'99-$=4PSRS '&'2$6' *1$ A5+,$1*0+$ 2. IJK (,'5+2B "#$ +*1;$ ,560$1' *,- 9(-$'%1$*- 1$+(L

    *,)$ ., '5)# '&'2$6' 0& *++ ./ 2#$ T*2(.,U' )1(2()*+ (,/1*'215)251$' 1$%1$'$,2 * '&'2$6()2#1$*2 2. 2#$(1 ).,2(,5$- .%$1*2(., /.++.9(,; *, IJK $A$,2B S--(2(.,*++&@ 2#$ ,$)$''(2& 2.1$0..2@ 1$%*(1@ .1 1$%+*)$ +*1;$ ,560$1' ./ ;$.;1*%#()*++& 9(-$+& -('%$1'$- '&'2$6' 9(++).,'(-$1*0+& (6%$-$ 2#$ T*2(.,U' 1$).A$1& /1.6 '5)# *, *''*5+2B

    #673/8139:19328 /6F $.2>3 #6123F2026F26:>28

    !"#$%&'(#)%"S++ )1(2()*+ ,*2(.,*+ (,/1*'215)251$' *1$ /*5+2 2.+$1*,2 2. '.6$ -$;1$$B R$'(;, $,;(,$$1'

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

    O2 (' (6%.12*,2 2. ,.2$@ #.9$A$1@ 2#*2 '*/$;5*1-' *;*(,'2 '(,;+$ %.(,2 /*(+51$' ;$,$1*++&-$%$,- ., 2#$ %1.%$1 /5,)2(.,(,; ./ 2#$ 1$'2 ./ 2#$ ,*2(.,*+ (,/1*'215)251$@ * %+*5'(0+$*''56%2(., /.1 #(;#L1$+(*0(+(2& (,/1*'215)251$ '&'2$6' 9#$, 2#$& $8%$1($,)$ 1*,-.6@5,).11$+*2$- '(,;+$ %.(,2 /*(+51$'B

    K+*,,(,; /.1 65+2(%+$ /*(+51$'@ %*12()5+*1+& 9#$, 2#$& *1$ )+.'$+& ).11$+*2$- (, 2(6$@ ('65)# +$'' ).66.,B O2 (' '*/$ 2. '*& 2#*2 ,. .,$ #*' %+*,,$- /.1@ *,- /$9 #*A$ $A$,(6*;(,$-@ * ')$,*1(. 9(2# 2#$ +.'' ./ #5,-1$-' .1 $A$, 2#.5'*,-' ./ ,.-$' *)1.'' *++ 2#$)1(2()*+ ,*2(.,*+ (,/1*'215)251$'@ *++ '(65+2*,$.5'+&B "#*2@ #.9$A$1@ (' %1$)('$+& 2#$ )(1L)56'2*,)$ ).,2$6%+*2$- 0& *, IJK *22*): ')$,*1(.B

    "#$ *0(+(2& 2. %1$-()2 2#$ ).,'$Q5$,)$'./ /*(+51$ 9(2#(, * )1(2()*+ (,/1*'215)251$

    9(++ 1$Q5(1$ 2#$ 5'$ ./ 1$+(*0+$ 6.-$+(,;*,- '(65+*2(., 2..+'B 4.6$ 2..+' $8('2 /.12#$ (,-(A(-5*+ (,/1*'215)251$' *,- '$1A$ *'$(2#$1 %+*,,(,; 2..+'@ 1$*+L2(6$ ).,21.+6.-$+'@ .1 .%$1*2(.,*+ '5%%.12 $+$6$,2' 2.*++.)*2$ .1 ).,21.+ 1$'.51)$' -51(,;,$29.1: .52*;$' *,- 1$'2.1*2(., *)2(A(2($'B"#$& *1$ ;$,$1*++& A*+(-*2$- 9(2#(, 2#$ %*1*6$2$1 '%*)$ ./ ,.16*+ .%$1*2(,; $8%$1($,)$*,- ).,)$1,@ *,- 2#$& '$1A$ 2#$(1 %51%.'$' 9$++B ^52 (2 (' *+'. 1$).;,(N$- 2#*2 2#$ '&'2$6'0$(,; 6.-$+$- *1$ '. ).6%+$8 2#*2 )511$,2+& *A*(+*0+$ 6.-$+(,; 2..+' )*,,.2 )*%251$ 2#$/5++ 1()#,$'' ./ %.2$,2(*+ '&'2$6 1$'%.,'$' 2. *++ %.''(0+$ ,$29.1: ).,/(;51*2(.,' *,-

    .%$1*2(,; '2*2$'B"#5'@ /.1 $8*6%+$@ ., 2#$ .1-$1 ./ .,)$ * -$)*-$ .1 '.@ %.12(.,' ./ 2#$ ,*2(.,*+ %.9$1

    ;1(- 9(++ $8%$1($,)$ *, 5,%1$-()2$- 6*Y.1 -('15%2(., 9(2# /*(+51$' )*')*-(,; 2#1.5;#'.6$ ./ 2#$ ,$29.1: %*2#9*&'B [.++.9(,; 2#$ 6*Y.1 T.12#$*'2 %.9$1 0+*):.52 ./ S5;5'2Fc@ X__]@ *,*+&'2' ).,2(,5$- 2. -$0*2$ 2#$ )*5'$ ./ 2#$ -('15%2(.,B "#$ '.%#('2()*2$-@1$+*2(A$+& 6*251$@ *,- .%$1*2(.,*++& -$%+.&$- 6.-$+(,; *,- '(65+*2(., 2..+' #*A$ ,.20$$, *0+$ 2. 1$%+()*2$ 5,*60(;5.5'+& 2#$ .0'$1A$- $A$,2' ./ S5;5'2 FcB

    =W$ #*A$ %1.-5)$- -$'(;,' '. ).6%+(L)*2$- 2#*2 9$ )*,,.2 %.''(0+& *,2()(%*2$*++ 2#$ %.''(0+$ (,2$1*)2(.,' ./ 2#$ (,$A(L2*0+$ /*(+51$'7 9$ *-- '*/$2& -$A()$' 2#*2*1$ -$)$(A$- .1 *A.(-$- .1 -$/$*2$- 0(--$, %*2#' (, 2#$ '&'2$6'B> P#*1+$'K$11.9@$%*(/> 8??1:'"5

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    24/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,-($.&(/0&/(' "1221,$34&4'.)A

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

    P#*1+$' K$11.9F (, %*12()5+*1 #*' -1*9, *22$,2(., 2. 2#$'$ 2&%$' ./ /*(+51$'@ 9#()# #$

    #*' 2$16$- "%*(/> /??1:'"5

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    25/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,-($.&(/0&/(' "1221,$34&4'.))

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

    O, 2#$ ).51'$ ./ .1-(,*1& (,2$115%2(.,'@ 6*,& ./ 2#$'$ (,/1*'215)251$ (,2$1-$%$,-$,)($'*,- (,2$1*)2(.,' )*, 0$ '*/$+& (;,.1$-B O, *, IJK *22*): ')$,*1(.@ 2#$ (66$-(*2$ (,'5+2 ('$8%$)2$- 2. *//$)2 2#$ -(//$1$,2 (,/1*'215)251$' '(65+2*,$.5'+& 2#1.5;# 65+2(%+$ $+$)21.,()

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

    O, %1*)2()$@ 5,-$1'2*,-(,; 2#$ (,2$1-$%$,-$,)$ 6*& 0$ * -(//()5+2 2*': 0$)*5'$ '50Y$)2*1$* $8%$12' *1$ ,.2 ,$)$''*1(+& *225,$- 2. ).5%+(,; 6$)#*,('6' 2#*2 '%*, 2#$ 0.5,-*1&0$29$$, 2#$(1 1$'%$)2(A$ -(')(%+(,$ *,- *,.2#$1@ *,- 0$)*5'$ *, *))51*2$ 1$%1$'$,2*2(., ./2#$ (,2$1-$%$,-$,)$ 1$Q5(1$' * /*6(+(*1(2& 9(2# 21*,'-(')(%+(,*1& %#$,.6$,*B

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i.1: P(2& 1$;(.,@ ,.2 .,+&0+.):$- b_ %$1)$,2 ./ *++ )*++' (,2. *,- .52 ./ T$9 i.1:@ 052 *+'. -('*0+$- *++ *(1 21*//()).,21.+ /5,)2(.,' /1.6 W*'#(,;2.,@ RBPB@ 2. ^.'2., C 2#$ 05'($'2 /+(;#2 ).11(-.1 (, 2#$T*2(., C *,- )1(%%+$- 2#$ .%$1*2(.,' ./ 2#$ T$9 i.1: J$1)*,2(+$ I8)#*,;$B

    X"#$'$ :$&

    (,2$1-$%$,-$,)($' 9$1$ *+9*&' 2#$1$@ 052 2#$& 9$1$ ,.2 1$).;,(N$- *' 9*11*,2(,;

    *-A*,)$- ).,2(,;$,)& %+*,,(,;@ '(25*2(.,*+ *9*1$,$'' (, -$;1*-$- ).,-(2(.,'@ *,-.%$1*2(.,*+ 9.1:*1.5,-'B

    XT$56*,,@ K$2$1@ 3%(@45'*RP'>/5': P1

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    26/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,-($.&(/0&/(' "1221,$34&4'.)5

    !"#$%& ()R* 3 2?:.&-6$/0 F00$D6%/6"?: ?7 65& F:6&%.?::&.6&E:&DD ?7 A0&C&:6D 2?:6/":&E S"65": A/.5 2%"6"./0F:7%/D6%$.6$%&* .%(' ?%""'?51%"< /*' "%5

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    27/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,-($.&(/0&/(' "1221,$34&4'.)6

    2. *,*+&'(' ./ )1(2()*+ (,/1*'215)251$'B O, *--(2(.,@ \$.1;$ J*'., *,- e*6$' J*-('., 5,(LA$1'(2($' (, g(1;(,(* #*A$ )1$*2$- 2#$ P$,2$1 /.1 O,/1*'215)251$ K1.2$)2(., K1.;1*6' 8?51&151'

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    28/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,-($.&(/0&/(' "1221,$34&4'.)5

    "#$"#%#&' (&)* + %,+)) -"+.'/(& (- '0# '"+--/. 1* 23456 70#"# /% + .(""#%$(&8/&9 (&9(/&9#:();'/(&< 1('0 /& '0# '=("> +".0/'#.';"# +&8 '0# ;&8#")*/&9 0+"8=+"#< '0+' /% 8#%."/1#8/& ,("# 8#'+/) /& ?0+$'#" @ (- '0/% "#$("'6

    A ."/'/.+) #)#,#&' (- '0# '=("> (- '0# -;';"# =/)) 1# "#)/+&.# (& $;1)/. 8+'+ '=(">%BCDE%F6 G& '0# $+%'< '0# #)#.'"/. $(=#" 9"/8 "#)/#8 (& /'% (=& .(,,;&/.+'/(& %*%'#, '(

    ,(&/'(" +&8 .(&'"() '0# 9"/8< +&8 ,;';+) 8#$#&8#&.# 1#'=##& '0# $(=#" +&8 '#)#.(,,;H&/.+'/(&% %*%'#,% =+% #%%#&'/+))* &/)6 7(8+* '0# $(=#" 9"/8 "#)/#% (& CDE% -(" +1(;' 45$#".#&' (- /'% '#)#.(,,;&/.+'/(& #8%< +&8 '0/% -/9;"# /% #I$#.'#8 '( 9"(= '( 53 $#".#&'/& '0# +" -;';"#6 !"#$%& ()* /));%'"+'#% '0# #I$#.'#8 /&'#"8#$#&8#&.# -(" '0/% #:():/&9'=(">6

    70# CDE% "#$"#%#&' '=(">% $(=#"#8 1* '0# $(=#" 8/%'"/1;'/(& '=(">6 70# $(=#"9#"+'/(& +&8 8/%'"/1;'/(& '=("> /%< /& ';"&< .(&'"())#8 1* J?ADA %*%'#,% '0+'8#$#&8 (& '#)#.(,,;&/.+'/(&% '( $"(:/8# %/';+'/(&+) +=+"#%% +&8 '( #I#.;'# .(&'"()-;&.'/(&% -(" '0# $(=#" 9"/86 !"#$%& ()+"#$"#%#&'% '0# "#%;)'% (- + ,(8#) %/,;)+'/(&6 70#'#)#.(,,;&/.+'/(& '=("> "#:#"'% 1+.> '( + 8#$#&8#&.# (& .(,,#"./+) $(=#" =0/)#1('0 +"# /& '0# "#.(:#"* $0+%#6 70# $(=#" /&-"+%'";.';"# .(&'/&;#% '( 8#$#&8 /& $+"' (&

    '0# $"(1+1/)/'* (- .+)) 1)(.>/&9< =0/)# '0# "#.(:#"* -(" '#)#.(,,;&/.+'/(&% 8#$#&8% (&'0# +:+/)+1)# $(=#"6

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

    ,-./0 123 4/5/6-778296149-2924/03/,/23/26:

    ,-./0

    6-240-5

    ,-./04012;79;;9-2

    ,-./0

    39;409&?@AA$B"?CD"@BE 5"B&

    ,@F&% 5"B&

    !8/5

    ;-806/,32

    ,32

    ,32

    4&>&?@AA$B"?CD"@BE 5"B&

    + 1

    .

    8

    #

    -

    +

    1

    . 9

    #

    -8

    !"#$%& ()*G 9BD&%H&I&BH&B?J K@% 1BD"?"ICD&H 2&DF@%L @K DM& !$D$%&

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    29/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,-($.&(/0&/(' "1221,$34&4'.)8

    !"#$%& ()T* U&D$06D ?7 / B?E&0 1"C$0/6"?:;

    O, *,.2#$1 $//.12@ 2#$ TO4SP '25-($- 2#$ ).,'$Q5$,)$' ./ *, IJK *22*): ')$,*1(.c

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

    9$1$ %1.A(-$- 0& 2#$ IJK P.66(''(.,7 /.1 '25-& %51%.'$'@ 2#$& (,)+5-$- -$')1(%2(.,'./ 2#$ %.2$,2(*+ (,(2(*+ '2*2$' ./ 0.2# 2#$ %.9$1 *,- 2$+$).665,()*2(., (,/1*'215)251$'(66$-(*2$+& /.++.9(,; $8%.'51$ 2. 2#$ IJK $,A(1.,6$,2B "#$ '(65+*2(.,@ 9#()# 9*' ,.2).,'(-$1$- 1$*+('2() 0$)*5'$ (2 -(- ,.2 ).,'(-$1 +(:$+& %#&'()*+ -*6*;$ 2#*2 9.5+- (6%$-$*,& 1$).A$1& %1.)$''@ 9*' '2(++ 5'$/5+ (, %1.A(-(,; (,'(;#2 (,2. 2#$ %.2$,2(*+ /.1 -('251L0*,)$' (, .,$ (,/1*'215)251$ 2. )*')*-$ (,2. .2#$1'B

    +9> *>"'B,-+

    C30"-"9"3. &$.A"-.$

    D"& 0$>$'"993-,'/0,"-.

    E>/--,-+ 0,9$ ="& &$'"($&)"= 0$>$'"993-,'/0,"-.

    F39A ,- A&"*/*,>,0)

    "= *>"'B,-+ E"

    E*;

    GHIG9

    J-0$$A$-#$-')K$+,-. 2$&$

    L$>$'"993-,'/0,"-.

    */'B?3A A"M$& $-#.

    /0 ; #/)N)A"02$0,'/>

    A"M$& &$'"($&)N)A"02$0,'/>

    A"M$& &$'"($&)

    K/.,' &$.A"-.$ "=

    0$>$'"993-,'/0,"-.

    M2$- ;88< "= A"M$&

    ,. /(/,>/*>$

    K/.,' &$.A"-.$ "=

    0$>$'"993-,'/0,"-.

    M2$- ;88< "= A"M$&,. /(/,>/*>$

    4,&$'0,"-

    "=&$'"($&)

    ="&A"M$&

    8

    4 "2=/1>L2 O;N23

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    30/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,-($.&(/0&/(' "1221,$34&4'.)9

    2#*, )1(2()*+ 6*''B "#$& *+'. *1$ /1*;6$,2$- *,- 5,)..1-(,*2$-@ 9#()# (' ,.2 *, $,2(1$+&,$;*2(A$ .0'$1A*2(.,@ *' 2#$ ).6%+$8(2& ./ 2#$ 2*': 6$1(2' $8%+.1*2(., ./ (,-$%$,-$,21$'$*1)# *,- -$A$+.%6$,2 *%%1.*)#$'B

    H$)$,2 *,*+&2() 9.1: '5;;$'2' 2#*2 $A.+A(,; (,2$1-$%$,-$,)($' 6*& 0$ (,*-A$12$,2+&(,21.-5)(,; $,2(1$+& ,$9 *,- %.2$,2(*++& '$1(.5' A5+,$1*0(+(2($' 2#*2 ).5+- +$*- 2. (,/1*L

    '215)251$ /*(+51$'@ $A$, 9(2#.52 2#$ %1$)(%(2*2(,; )*2*+&'2 ./ *, IJK *22*):B"2:;

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    31/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(23

    !!..//001122334455--6622771133887799::;;2233

    #718:7 /'/3.-)- 1/. 6$ )++3+;7 M#*3$ )#*- 1/))$2 *- / #*,#3. )$(#'*(/3 *--&$ )#/) /;/*)- %&2)#$2 *'5$-)*,/)*+' 6. =7>7-(*$')*%*( $C4$2)-? *) 2/*-$- )#$ -4$()$2 +% *'(2$/-$0 &'($2)/*'). /6+&) )#$ /0$:&/(. +%(&22$') =7>7 8JK 1*)*,/)*+' /442+/(#$-7

    9 G$. *--&$ %+2 )#$ )/)$-? /33 *' /' *'-)/')L 6&) 1+2$ -*,'*%*(/')3. ;*0$-42$/0 0/1/,$1/. ;$33 /05$2-$3. *14/() )#$ )*1$ )+ 2$(+5$2 /'0 )#&- #/5$ / 4+)$')*/33. (/)/-)2+4#*(*14/()7

    D+2 #*,#3. 0$4$'0$') -.-)$1- -&(# /- (+11$2(*/3 )$3$(+11&'*(/)*+'- /'0 )#$ %*'/'@(*/3 -.-)$1? $3$()2*( 4+;$2 *- %2$:&$')3. %*3)$2$0 )#2+&,# 6/))$2*$-7 "#$-$ /() )+ (+'0*)*+')#$ 4+;$2 /- ;$33 /- )+ 42+5*0$ 3*1*)$0 6/(G&47 Y+(/3? /)@-*)$ $1$2,$'(. ,$'$2/)+2- /2$

    &-$0 :&*)$ $C)$'-*5$3. %+2 #*,# 42*+2*). 3+/0-7 "#$-$ *'(3&0$ #+-4*)/3-? (+30 -)+2/,$? ;/)$2-.-)$1-? /*24+2) (+')2+3-? 2/*3 (+')2+3- /'0 -*1*3/2 &-$-7 "#$-$ -.-)$1-? #+;$5$2? /2$)#$1-$35$- *'(2$/-*',3. 0$4$'0$') +' $3$()2+'*(- )+ *'*)*/)$ -)/2) &4? -$,2$,/)$ )#$1 %2+1)#$ 3/2,$2 4+;$2 -.-)$1? /'0 (+')2+3 )#$*2 +4$2/)*', $%%*(*$'(.? )#$2$6. 2$'0$2*', )#$15&3'$2/63$ )+ 8JK7

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

    42*+2*). 3+/0-? /2$ *')$'0$0 )+ 6$ )$14+2/2. /) 6$-) \ 62*0,*', )#$ )*1$ &')*3 2$-)+2/)*+'(/' )/G$ 43/($7

    "#$ *14/() +% -&(# /' 8JK@)2*,,$2$0 +&)/,$ ;+&30 6$ -$5$2$ 6&) '+) (/)/-)2+4#*( *%)#$ 2$(+5$2. ;/- 2/4*0 +2 )#$ ,$+,2/4#*( *14/() -&%%*(*$')3. 3*1*)$07 "#$ 2$(+5$2. )*1$-%2+1 42$5*+&- 3/2,$@-(/3$ +&)/,$- #/5$ 6$$' +' )#$ +20$2 +% +'$ )+ -$5$2/3 0/.-7 "#*-2$(+20 +% :&*(G 2$(+5$2. *- /))2*6&)/63$ )+ )#$ 2$1/2G/63. $%%$()*5$ +4$2/)*+' +% 42+)$()*5$-.-)$1- /'0 (+11&'*(/)*+'- )#/) /2$ /' $--$')*/3 4/2) +% )#$ 4+;$2 *'%2/-)2&()&2$ /'0 )#$1&3)*43$ -+&2($- +% 2$43/($1$') (+14+'$')- %2+1 -&22+&'0*', '+'*14/()$0 -.-)$1-7 H')#*- (+')$C)? / -#+2) 63/(G+&) -($'/2*+ +5$2 / 2$3/)*5$3. -1/33 ,$+,2/4#*( 2$,*+' ;+&30 6$$(+'+1*(/33. 4/*'%&37 Q% )#$ 1+2$ )#/' ]VB )2*33*+' =7>7 ^2+-- _+1$-)*( K2+0&()? /6+&))#2$$ 4$2($') *- $3$()2*(*). -/3$-7 `+;$5$2? $-)*1/)$- +% $(+'+1*( 3+-- %2+1 #*-)+2*(/363/(G+&)- 2/',$ %2+1 %/()+2- +% -*C I%+2 0+1$-)*( (&-)+1$2-L )+ WB I%+2 *'0&-)2*/3 &-$2-L)*1$- )#$ 5/3&$ +% )#$ *')$22&4)$0 -$25*($7 N. )#$-$ 1$/-&2$-? )#$ $(+'+1*( *14/() +% /'+&)/,$ *- 6$);$$' Va /'0 bB 4$2($') +% )+)/3 42+0&()*+' *' )#$ /%%$()$0 /2$/7 9,/*'? )#*-$-)*1/)$ *- %+2 2$/-+'/63. -#+2)@3*5$0 63/(G+&)-7 9 -#+2) 63/(G+&) 42$-$')- '+ )#2$/) )+'/)*+'/3 -&25*5/37

    Q' )#$ +)#$2 #/'0? / ,$+,2/4#*(/33. ;*0$-42$/0 63/(G+&) )#/) *'5+35$- 4#.-*(/3 0/1/,$)+ )#+&-/'0- +% (+14+'$')- 1/. 42+0&($ / 4$2-*-)$') +&)/,$ )#/) ;+&30 %/2 $C($$0 #*-@)+2*(/3 $C4$2*$'($? ;*)# 4+)$')*/33. (/)/-)2+4#*( $%%$()7 >*1&3/)*+' ;+2G -4+'-+2$0 6. )#$

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    34/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'()6

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    35/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'()2

    (+'5$2)- )#$ +2*,*'/3 %+21 +% $'$2,. *')+ 2+)/)*+'/3 1$(#/'*(/3 $'$2,.? /- +((&2- *' / )&2@6*'$7 "#$ )&26*'$ )#$' 02*5$- / ,$'$2/)+27

    9:;23 +A@12B )C23C82;

    +"#$%& ()*, -./&% 0123&4 56&%6"&/

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`+;$5$2? ;*'0 /'0 -+3/2 1/. +2 1/. '+) 6$ ,$'$2/)*',

    *' /'. $5$')? ,*5$' )#$*2 *'#$2$') &'($2)/*').7 `.02+ /'0 ,$+)#$21/3 /2$ -*,'*%*(/') (/4/@6*3*)*$-? 6&) )#$. /2$ #*,#3. 3+(/3*P$07

    **$$%%##++,,''++++''((##))83$()2*(/3 4+;$2 %2+1 )#$ 5/2*+&- 4+;$2 43/')- )2/5$3- +5$2 / -.-)$1 +%3*'$- /'0 -&6-)/)*+'- )+ )#$ 2$,*+'- /'0 3+(/3$- ;#$2$ *) ;*33 6$ (+'-&1$07 "#$ )2/'-1*-@-*+' -.-)$1 1+5$- 3/2,$ /1+&')- +% 4+;$2 ,$'$2/33. +5$2 -&6-)/')*/3 0*-)/'($- /'0[+2 )+0*2$()3. -$25$ 5$2. 3/2,$ $3$()2*(/3 3+/0-7 "#*- 0$%*'*)*+' -$4/2/)$- *) %2+1 )#$ 0*-)2*6&)*+'-.-)$1? ;#*(# *- 0$-(2*6$0 6$3+;7 "2/'-1*--*+' *'(3&0$- 3*'$- I;*2$- -)2&', %2+1 *'-&@

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    36/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'())

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

    >)/'0/20 5/3&$- %+2 1+0$2' /3)$2'/)*', (&22$') I9

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    37/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'()7

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

    00((##&&$$((11%%##3344$$((&&""55&&''((##6677++&&"",,++))Q5$23/*0 +' )#$-$ )#2$$ 42*1/2. $3$1$')- h ,$'$2/@)*+'? )2/'-1*--*+' /'0 0*-)2*6&)*+' h *- / (+')2+3 -.-)$1 )#/) 0*2$()- )#$ 4+;$2 ;#$2$ *) *-'$$0$0? 1/*')/*'- )#$ %2$:&$'(.? /'0 42+)$()- )#$ -.-)$17

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    38/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'()8

    $C/143$? -3+;3. *'(2$/-*', $3$()2*(/3 )2/'-1*--*+' 0$1/'0 #/- 3/2,$3. 6$$' 1$) ;*)#*')#$ 3*1*)- +% (&22$') 42+0&()*+' (/4/(*). %+2 )#$-$ (+14+'$')-7

    "#$ (+')*'&*', $5+3&)*+' +% $3$()2+'*( 0$5*($- *')+ -.-)$1- )#/) +'($ ;$2$ $C(3&-*5$3.$3$()2+1$(#/'*(/3? $'/63*', (+14&)$2 (+')2+3 *'-)$/0 +% 0*2$() #&1/' *')$25$')*+' /'0&-$ +% 62+/0 '$);+2G- 3*G$ )#$ H')$2'$)? 2$-&3)- *' $5$2 ,2$/)$2 2$3*/'($ +' 1*(2+$3$()2+'@

    *(- /'0 )#&- )#$ 42$-$') /'0 -#/243. ,2+;*', 5&3'$2/6*3*). +% )#$ 4+;$2 -.-)$1 )+ 8JK/))/(G7 i&-) /- )#$ (+14&)$2 '$);+2G- #/5$ +4$'$0 )#$ 4+--*6*3*). )+ (.6$2 /--/&3) +' )#$4+;$2 -.-)$1 +2 )+ $3$()2*(/3 4+;$2 -.-)$1 (+33/4-$ /--+(*/)$0 ;*)# -+%);/2$ %/*3&2$ I/-0&2*', )#$ 9&,&-) Vj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

    *' )#$ /%)$21/)# +% 8JK7

    "#$ G$. 5&3'$2/63$ $3$()2+'*( -.-)$1- /2$ >)/)$- /'0 *')$,2/)$0 -.-)$1- *'

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    39/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'()9

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

    H' !"#$%& ()( )#$ 1/4 +% )#$ )#2$$ F8c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

    3+/0- /'0 *14+2)/')3. *14$0$- 2$-)+2/)*+' ;#$2$ 0$3/. *'(2$/-$- )#$ /05$2-$ *14/()-5*2)&/33. $C4+'$')*/33.7

    +"#$%& ()(, 789: ;

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    40/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'():

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

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    41/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'()3

    M#*3$ ,2$/)$2 42+)$()*+' /'0 (+')2+3 -(#$1$- #/5$ -)*33 42+5*0$0 / 5$2. 2$3*/63$ -.-)$1 *'-4*)$ +% )#*-? )#$ -.-)$1 *- 6$*', -)2$--$0 6$.+'0 2$/-+'/63$ 3*1*)-7 "#$ $3$()2*(/3 4+;$2-.-)$1 #/- 6$(+1$ 5*2)&/33. %&33. 0$4$'0$') &4+' $3$()2+'*( -.-)$1- ;+2G*', '$/23.%3/;3$--3.7 "#$ +5$2/33 -.-)$1 2$3*/6*3*). *- )$-)*1+'. )+ )#$ -G*33 /'0 $%%$()*5$'$-- +% )#$(+')2+3 -.-)$1-7 `+;$5$2? )#$ 3/(G +% 1/2,*' I(+16*'/)*+' +% ,$'$2/)*+' /'0 )2/'-1*-@-*+' 1/2,*'-L 2$-&3)- *' 1/G*', (/)/-)2+4#*( (/-(/0*', +&)/,$- %/2 1+2$ 3*G$3.? /'0-#+&30 )#$ $3$()2+'*(- 6$ 0*-2&4)$0? )#$ -.-)$1 *- #*,#3. 3*G$3. )+ %/*3 +' / 62+/0 -(/3$7"#&-? )#$ -1/33 1/2,*' /'0 2$3*/'($ +' $3$()2+'*(- ,*5$ 2*-$ )+ 8JK 5&3'$2/6*3*).7

    `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jL %2+1 )#$ 0*-)2*6&)*+' )+ )#$ 3+/07

    "#$ )2/'-%+21$2- )#/) #/'03$ $3$()2*(/3 4+;$2 ;*)#*' )#$ )2/'-1*--*+' -.-)$1 /'0 *)-

    *')$2%/($- ;*)# )#$ ,$'$2/)*+' /'0 0*-)2*6&)*+' -.-)$1- /2$ 3/2,$? $C4$'-*5$? /'0 )+ / (+'@-*0$2/63$ $C)$')? (&-)+1 6&*3)7 "#$ )2/'-1*--*+' -.-)$1 *- %/2 3$-- -)/'0/20*P$0 )#/' )#$4+;$2 43/')- /2$? ;#*(# )#$1-$35$- /2$ -+1$;#/) &'*:&$ %2+1 +'$ )+ /'+)#$27 933 42+@0&()*+' %+2 )#$-$ 3/2,$ )2/'-%+21$2- &-$0 *' )#$ ='*)$0 >)/)$- *- (&22$')3. +%%-#+2$7_$3*5$2. )*1$ %+2 )#$-$ *)$1- &'0$2 6$'*,' (*2(&1-)/'($- *- ).4*(/33. +'$ )+ );+ .$/2-7"#$2$ /2$ /6+&) W?BBB -&(# )2/'-%+21$2- 2/)$0 /) +2 /6+5$ AjR Gg *' )#$ ='*)$0 >)/)$-;*)# /6+&) V 4$2($') 4$2 .$/2 6$*', 2$43/($0 0&$ )+ %/*3&2$ +2 6. )#$ /00*)*+' +% '$;+'$-7 M+230;*0$ 42+0&()*+' (/4/(*). *- 3$-- )#/' VBB &'*)- 4$2 .$/2 /'0 -$25$- / ;+2301/2G$)? +'$ )#/) *- ,2+;*', /) / 2/4*0 2/)$ *' -&(# (+&')2*$- /-

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    42/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'()4

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

    "#$ )2/'-1*--*+' *'%2/-)2&()&2$ #/- 2$1/*'$0 2$,&3/)$0? /'0 )#$ 42$5*+&- 5$2)*(/33.*')$,2/)$0 -.-)$1- *' 1/'. *'-)/'($- ;$2$ '+) /33+;$0 )+ (+11$2(*/33. (+')2+3 )#$*2)2/'-1*--*+' *' +20$2 )+ %2$$ &4 (+14$)*)*+' /) )#$ ;#+3$-/3$ 3$5$3-7 _&$ )+ )#$(+143$C*). +% /' +4$' 1/2G$) &-*', /' *'%2/-)2&()&2$ )#/) ;/- 6&*3) %+2 /'+)#$2 +4$2/)*',$'5*2+'1$')? )#$ 2$:&*2$1$')- %+2 *'5$-)1$') *' )#$ )2/'-1*--*+' -.-)$1 #/5$ 6$$'&'($2)/*' /'0 1+2$ $C4$'-*5$7 D8c< 2$,&3/)$- )#$ )2/'-1*--*+' %/(*3*)*$- *' )$21- +% &-$/'0 42*(*',? 6&) '+) 3+(/)*+'7 "#$ %$0$2/3 )2/'-1*--*+' 2$,&3/)*+' 4/2/0*,1 *- 1+5*',)+;/20 6$*', 1/2G$) 6/-$0? ;#*(# ;*33 #/5$ &'G'+;' *14/()- 6&) *- 6$3*$5$0 )+ /--*-) *')#$ 0$5$3+41$') +% '$; )2/'-1*--*+' %/(*3*)*$-7 "#$ -)/)$- /3-+ 43/. /' *14+2)/') 2+3$ *'

    )#$ 2$,&3/)*+' +% )2/'-1*--*+' /'0 ,$'$2/)*+' )#/) *- '+) (+'-*-)$') %2+1 -)/)$ )+ -)/)$7M*)# )#$ 1/2G$) I/'0 )#$ 1/2G$) 1+0$3 *)-$3%L *' %3&C? )#$2$ *- &';*33*','$-- 42$-$')3. )+*'5$-) *' )2/'-1*--*+' *'%2/-)2&()&2$7

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

    4+;$2 4&2-&/') )+ / (+')2/() %+2 0$3*5$2. 6$);$$' );+ 4/2)*$-? *) *- &'3*G$3. )#/) )#$4+;$2 ;*33 %3+; 4#.-*(/33. /- $'5*-*+'$07 "#&- *) *- &'(3$/2 ;#+ ;*33 4/. %+2 )#$ &-$ +%)#$ '$; 3*'$7 M#*3$ '$; (/4/6*3*). )+ )2/(G 9< 4+;$2 I8@)/,-L (+&30 42+5*0$ )#$ 6/-*- %+2%*-(/3 *'($')*5$- %+2 '$; 3*'$ (+'-)2&()*+'? *) *- '+) .$) ;*0$3. 0$43+.$0 '+2 ;$33 &'0$2@-)++0 +2 /(($4)$07 J+2$+5$2? 2$,&3/)+2. 2$:&*2$1$')- (2$/)$ *14$0*1$')- )+ '$; 3*'$(+'-)2&()*+' $5$' *% )#$ *'($')*5$- /'0 (/4*)/3 /2$ /) #/'07 H' -#+2)? %2+1 / 6&-*'$-- 4$2@-4$()*5$? )2/'-1*--*+' 3*'$- /2$ +%)$' 3+; 2$)&2' +2 3+-- ($')$2- *' )#$ (&22$')$'5*2+'1$')7

    "#$ $'0 -)/)$ +% )#$ 2$,&3/)+2. 4/2/0*,1 *- -)*33 &'0$)$21*'$0? /'0 )#*- &'($2)/*').(+&43$0 ;*)# 3/(G +% 3+(/3 6$'$%*)- ;#$' 4/--*', )#2+&,# -)/)$ /'0 3+(/3 /2$/- /33 (+')2*6@&)$ )+ )#$ 0*1*'*-#*', )2/'-1*--*+' (/4/(*). 1/2,*'-7 "#$2$ *- &'($2)/*'). ;#$)#$2? 6.

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

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    43/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'()5

    D>6

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    44/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(76

    0+;' 0+$- '+) $',/,$ $1$2,$'(. 3&62*(/)*+'7 "#$2$ /2$ -*1*3/2 *--&$- *'-*0$ 5$2. (+1@43$C 1/(#*'$- +4$2/)*', /) #*,# )$14$2/)&2$- /) %/-) -4$$0- ;*)# )*,#) )+3$2/'($-7 "#&-?4+;$2 43/') -&25*5/6*3*). 0$4$'0- +' / ,2$/) 1/'. 42+)$()*5$ -.-)$1- (2$/)*', 1&3)*43$4/)#;/.- )+ 43/') 0/1/,$ /'0 %/*3&2$7

    c$-)+2/)*+' +% -+1$ 0/1/,$ (/' 6$ 5$2. 3+', )$21? ($2)/*'3. 1+')#- /'0 *' -+1$

    *'-)/'($- .$/2-7 "#$ 3+-- +% ,$'$2/)*+' +% /'. -*P$ *)-$3% ;+&30 (+')2*6&)$ )+ -.-)$1;*0$(+33/4-$ /'0 ($2)/*'3. ;+&30 3*1*) 2$-)+2/)*+'7 J/'&%/()&2$2- +% ,$'$2/)*+' 43/') 42+)$(@)*+' /'0 (+')2+3 $:&*41$') 4$2%+21$0 -+1$ 3*1*)$0 $5/3&/)*+' /'0 ;#*3$ )#$2$ /2$ 3/.$2-+% 2$0&'0/'(.? /- '+)$0? 1+2$ /'0 1+2$ )#$-$ -.-)$1- /2$ ,+*', )+ (+14&)$2@(+')2+33$01*(2+$3$()2+'*(-? /'0 )#&- /2$ 1+2$ -&-($4)*63$ )+ 8JK 0*-2&4)*+'7

    9) )#$ 0$5*($ 3$5$3? 4+;$2 43/') 42+)$()*5$ -.-)$1- /2$ 3$-- $C4+-$0 )#/' )#$ (+22$@-4+'0*', -.-)$1- *' )#$ )2/'-1*--*+' ,2*07 "#$. /() +' 3+(/3 *'%+21/)*+'? -+ %/*3&2$ +%)$3$(+11&'*(/)*+'- -.-)$1- *- '+) /- 1&(# +% /' *--&$ %+2 43/') 42+)$()*+' ;#$2$ +4$2/@)+2- /2$ /5/*3/63$ *' 1+-) *'-)/'($- Wj[X /'0 (/' *'0$4$'0$')3. /--$-- )#$ -*)&/)*+' /'0/()7 "#$ (+')2+3 $:&*41$')? 42+)$()*5$ -.-)$1-? -$'-+2-? /'0 (&22$') )2/'-%+21$2- ).4*@(/33. I6&) 6. '+ 1$/'- /3;/.-L ;*33 6$ *'-*0$ )#$ 43/') /3)#+&,# )#*- 0+$- '+) '$($--/2*3.

    1$/' )#$. ;*33 '+) 6$ $C4+-$07 H' ,$'$2/3 )#$2$ ;*33 6$ '+ +&)-*0$ (/63$ 2&'-? -+ )#$6&*30*', *)-$3% ;*33 42+5*0$ -+1$ 8JK 42+)$()*+'7 `+;$5$2 )#$ 3$',)#- +% )#$-$ *')$2*+2(/63$- (/' 6$ +' )#$ +20$2 +% VBB 1$)$2-7 &6O$()*', /' $')*2$ -+4#*-)*(/)$0 /'0 1+0$2' 4+;$2 43/'))+ )$-)*', *- '+) %$/-*63$7 `+;$5$2? *) 0+$- '+) )/G$ 1/'. 0/1/,$0 43/')- +&) +% )#$ 1/'.#&'02$0- )+ -$2*+&-3. *14/() )#$ -.-)$1 +4$2/)*+' /'0 )#$ /6*3*). )+ 2$-)+2$ -$25*($7 "#$%/() )#/) /33 4+;$2 43/')- $C4+-$0 )+ 8V 8JK ;*33 6$ *33&1*'/)$0 -*1&3)/'$+&-3. I;*)#*'+'$ 4+;$2 (.(3$L 1/G$- )#$ -*)&/)*+' $C)2$1$3. -$2*+&-7

    6677++&&"",,88""++&&(($$%%&&''((##99!!""##""$$%%&&''((##

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

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    45/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(72

    )$1 *- 6$*', 2$-)+2$0 /'0 )#$2$ /2$ %$; 3+/0- /'0 ,$'$2/)+2- (+''$()$0? )#*- 1/)(#*',2$:&*2$- (/2$%&3 1/'/,$1$') /'0 (+11&'*(/)*+' 6$);$$' 3+/0 /'0 ,$'$2/)*+'7

    ^$'$2/)*+' -)/2)@&4 %+2 1+-) 43/')- 2$:&*2$- 4+;$2 %2+1 /'+)#$2 -+&2($ )+ 02*5$ 4&14-?%/'-? -/%$). -.-)$1-? %&$3 0$3*5$2.? /'0 -+ +'7 >+1$? 3*G$ #.02+$3$()2*( /'0 -1/33$2 0*$@-$3- (/' -)/2) 0*2$()3. +2 %2+1 6/))$2. -+&2($- /--&1*', )#$. (/' (+')2+3 )#$*2 /(($-- )+

    1/)(#*', 3+/07 H' )#$ (/-$ +% 8JK? 3/2,$ ,$+,2/4#*( /2$/- +% )#$ $3$()2*(/3 -.-)$1 ;*33 6$0+;'? /'0 )#$2$ 1/. 6$ '+ $C*-)*', -.-)$1 +4$2/)*', +' )#$ 4$2*4#$2. %+2 )#$ ,$'$2/)*+'/'0 3+/0- )+ 6$ *'(2$1$')/33. /00$0 ;*)# $/-$7 D&2)#$21+2$? 2$(+5$2. +% 3+-) ,$'$2/)*+';+&30 6$ *14/()$0 6. )#$ 3+-- +% +)#$2 *'%2/-)2&()&2$ *' 5/2.*', 0$,2$$- /((+20*', )+ )#$).4$ +% 43/')7 H' )#/) *'-)/'($? *) *- '$($--/2. )+ #/5$ / T63/(G -)/2)Uf / -)/2) ;*)#+&) $C)$2@'/3 4+;$2 -+&2($7

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    46/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(7)

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    47/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(77

    i&-) /- *' )#$ (/-$ *'5+35*', 4+;$2 43/')-? )#$ %*2-) (2*)*(/3 *--&$ *- )#$ 42+4$2 %&'()*+'@*', +% )#$ 42+)$()*5$ $3$1$')-? -4$(*%*(/33. 2$3/.-? %+33+;$0 6. )#$ 3+(/3 (+')2+3 -.-)$1-7"#$-$ $3$1$')- 42+)$() )#$ #*,#@5+3)/,$ 62$/G$2- /'0 )2/'-%+21$2- )#/) /2$ #*,#@5/3&$/--$)-7 `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

    "#$ 3*G$3*#++0 /'0 -(+4$ +% )#$ 8A 42+63$1 /2$ $C/($26/)$0 6. )#$ -1/33 )2/'-1*--*+'1/2,*'- (&22$')3. /5/*3/63$7 "#$ (3+-$2 / )2/'-%+21$2 *- +4$2/)*', )+ *)- 4$2%+21/'($3*1*)? )#$ -1/33$2 )#$ ^H< '$$0$0 )+ (/&-$ %/*3&2$7 J+2$+5$2? '$;$2 )2/'-1*--*+' -&6-)/@)*+'- /2$ *'(2$/-*',3. &-*', )#2$$ -*',3$@4#/-$ )2/'-%+21$2- )+ #/'03$ #*,#$2 4+;$2 )2/'-@

    %$2? -*'($ )#$ $:&*5/3$')3. 2/)$0 )#2$$@4#/-$ )2/'-%+21$2- /2$ )++ 3/2,$ )+ -#*47 "#$ )#2$$@4#/-$ -.-)$1- /2$ 1+2$ 2$-*-)/') )+ ^H

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    48/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(78

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c< 2$,*+' +2 4+--*63. 1+2$?2$-)+2*', )#$ -.-)$1 %2+1 )#$ -)*33 %&'()*+'*', 4$2*1$)$2 1/. ;$33 '+) 6$ 4+--*63$ /) /33 +2;+&30 )/G$ / ,2$/) 0$/3 +% )*1$S )#$ >).,- $> '?@ 'A@ "+B 'C"#$ $%%$()- +% 8JK +' )#$ $3$()2*(/3 4+;$2 -.-)$1 /2$ %&'0/1$')/33. 4/2)*)*+'$0 *')+

    *)- $/23.? 1*003$? /'0 3/)$ )*1$ $%%$()- I(/&-$0 6. )#$ 8V? 8W? /'0 8A (+14+'$')-?2$-4$()*5$3.L7 "#$ '$) *14/() +' )#$ $3$()2*( 4+;$2 ,2*0 *'(3&0$- )#$ -.'$2,*-)*( *')$2/(@)*+' +% /33 )#2$$? +((&22*', '$/23. -*1&3)/'$+&-3. +5$2 / 3/2,$ ,$+,2/4#*( /2$/7 "#$

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    49/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(79

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    50/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(7:

    (*$') 6. *)-$3% )+ (/&-$ 0*-2&4)*+' /'0 42+6/63$ %&'()*+'/3 (+33/4-$ +% 3/2,$ 4+2)*+'- +% )#$*')$2(+''$()$0 $3$()2*(/3 4+;$2 -.-)$1 /) 8JK )#2$/) 3$5$3-7 H' $5$2. 8JK /))/(G? /33)#2$$ /--/&3)- I8V? 8W? /'0 8AL /2$ 0$3*5$2$0 *' -$:&$'($ /'0 '$/23. -*1&3)/'$+&-3.7 H) *-)#$

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    51/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(73

    9"*"3) 0.)+"%/$-"#$ 3$5$3 +% 0/1/,$ 0$4$'0- 42*1/2*3. +' )#$ %&'()*+'*', +% )#$ 42+)$()*5$ $:&*41$')?

    6&) *) /3-+ 0$4$'0- +' 5/2*+&- /-4$()- +% )#$ (+33/4-$7 H' /' 8JK $5$')? )#$ (+33/4-$ *-5*2)&/33. *'-)/')/'$+&-7 "#$ -*P$ +% )#$ )2/'-*$')- +' )#$ -.-)$1 1/. 6$ ,2$/)$2 )#/'$C*-)*', 42+)$()*5$ -.-)$1- /2$ (/4/63$ +% #/'03*',? $5$' )#+-$ '+) 0/1/,$0 6. )#$ 8JK*)-$3%7

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

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    52/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(74

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

    +"#$%& ()E, 8F- 0"4$GA3.%

    ,2/0&/33. *'(2$/-$0 )#$ $3$()2*(/3 -)2$-- +' )#$ (+')2+3 -.-)$1-7 _&2*', )#*- )$-)*',? /33-.-)$1- ;$2$ +4$2/)*+'/3 ;*)# 0*/,'+-)*(- /'0 (#$(G+&)- 2&' /) )#$ (+'(3&-*+' +% $/(#-*1&3/)$0 8JK $C4+-&2$7

    "#$ -*1&3/)*+' )$-)*', 42+5*0$0 /' +44+2)&'*). )+ +6-$25$ )#$ *')$2/()*+' +% )#$ $3$(@

    )2+1/,'$)*( $'$2,. ;*)# $:&*41$') *' /' +4$2/)*+'/3 1+0$7 Q6-$25$0 $%%$()- (/' 6$2$3/)$0 )+ )#$ -.-)$1 2$-4+'-$ *' 1+2$ 2$/3*-)*( -($'/2*+- )#2+&,# /'/3.-*- 6/-$0 +' (+&@43*', 0*%%$2$'($- 6$);$$' )#$ -*1&3/)$0 /'0 2$/3@;+230 (/-$-7 >*'($ )#$ -*1&3/)*+' *- '+)4$2%$() h )#$ 4&3-$ 3$',)# *- )++ 3+', /'0 )#$ )$-) 5+3&1$ )++ -1/33 )+ (/4)&2$ )#$ 3+',$2(/63$ 2&' (+&43*',- )+ 6$ %+&'0 *' / 2$/3 $'5*2+'1$') h 4+-) )$-) /'/3.-*- /'0 $',*'$$2@*', O&0,1$') *- 2$:&*2$0 )+ 2$3/)$ )#$ )$-) 2$-&3)- )+ $C4$()$0 >

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    53/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(75

    $*)#$2 2$6++) +2 2$(.(3$ )+ 4#.-*(/3 0/1/,$ )#/) 2$:&*2$0 )#$ /()&/3 2$43/($1$') +% )#$/%%$()$0 #/20;/2$7

    "#$ 2$-4+'-$ +% )#$ (+')2+3 -.-)$1- )$-)$0 5/2*$0 %2+1 -.-)$1 )+ -.-)$1 /- ;$33 /-%2+1 -&6-.-)$1 )+ -&6-.-)$17 D+2 $C/143$? / &'*) (+'-*-)*', +% 1&3)*43$ *'4&)[+&)4&)4+2)- I+2 -&6-.-)$1-L (+''$()$0 )+ / 5/2*$). +% %*$30 +2 (+11&'*(/)*+'- 0$5*($- #/0

    -+1$ 4+2)- $C4$2*$'($ &4-$)-? -+1$ $C4$2*$'($ 4#.-*(/3 0/1/,$? /'0 -+1$ $C4$2*$'($ '+$%%$()? /33 *' )#$ -/1$ -*1&3/)*+' $5$')7

    9- /' $C/143$? /) 2$3/)*5$3. 3+; $3$()2+1/,'$)*( -)2$-- 3$5$3-? / 4+2)*+' +% / _ 42+(@$-- (+')2+33$2 42+5*0$0 %/3-$ *'0*(/)*+'- +% )#$ 42+($-- -)/)&-7 9' +4$2/)+2 *')$2%/($ *'0*@(/)$0 / -;*)(# ;/- +' ;#$' *' /()&/3*). *) #/0 6$$' )&2'$0 +%%? ;#*3$ *')$2'/3 5+3)/,$ /'0)$14$2/)&2$ ;$2$ 2$4+2)$0 /- +&) +% )#$*2 '+21/3 +4$2/)*', 2/',$- ;#$' )#$. ;$2$ /()&@/33. '+21/37 "#$-$ $%%$()- ;$2$ -*,'*%*(/') 6$(/&-$ )#$. +((&22$0 1+-) %2$:&$')3. +'(+')2+3 -.-)$1- &-$0 *' >H[H888L +2 *')$2'/)*+'/3 IH8

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    54/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(86

    %+2 / -$2*$- +% $3$()2+1/,'$)*( (+14/)*6*3*). I8J

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    55/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(82

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

    "#$ '$) 2$-&3) +% )#*- )$-)*', 42+5*0$- $5*0$'($ )#/) )#$ 4+;$2 ,2*0 *- /3-+ 5&3'$2/63$ )+(+33/4-$ 0&$ )+ )#$ 8V (+14+'$') +% /' 8JK /--/&3)? 42*1/2*3. )#2+&,# )#$ &4-$) /'00/1/,$ +% )#$ -+%) (+14&)$2 -.-)$1- )#/) /2$ *' (+11+' &-$7 "#*- #+;$5$2 -&,,$-)- )#/)+4$2/)*+'/3 4$2%+21/'($ (/' 6$ (+'-*0$2/63. $'#/'($0 /) 1+0$-) (+-) 6. /))$'0*', )+*'-)/33/)*+' /'0 (+'%*,&2/)*+' *--&$-7

    F8@1:387/6 #

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    56/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(8)

    / 1/O+2 %/()+2 *' )#$ %/*3&2$ +% 4+3*($? $1$2,$'(. /'0 2$-(&$ -$25*($- 0&2*', )#$ #&22*@(/'$? ;#*(# G*33$0 V?jbj 4$+43$7 "#$ 63/(G+&) (/&-$0 ,/- -)/)*+'- )+ ($/-$ +4$2/)*',?4/2/3.P*', )2/'-4+2)/)*+' /'0 ,2$/)3. *14$0*', $5/(&/)*+' $%%+2)-7 "#$ m/)2*'/ 63/(G+&)?;#*(# /%%3*()$0 )#$ 2$,*+' %+2 ;$$G- /'0 3/-)$0 %+2 1+')#- *' -+1$ 3+(/3*)*$-? -+ -$5$2$3.*14$0$0 2$(+5$2. $%%+2)- )#/) $5$' )+0/.? A .$/2- 3/)$2? F$; Q23$/'- /'0 *)- 5*(*'*). *--)*33 %/2 %2+1 6$*', %&33. 2$(+5$2$07

    A/?/+& HID EFFJD K1%5@(/&)"#$ 9&,&-) Vj 63/(G+&) ;/- 42$(*4*)/)$0 6. / -*',3$ 3*'$%/*3&2$ *' +'$ (+')2+3 /2$/7 H) $5$')&/33. /%%$()$0 '*'$ (+')2+3 /2$/- +5$2 / 4$2*+0 +% -$5@$2/3 #+&2-? ;*)# 2/4*03. -42$/0*', (/-(/0$- +% +&)/,$ +5$2 )#$ 3/-) AB 1*'&)$-7 "#$ $C)$')+% )#$ 63/(G+&) ;/- $C/($26/)$0 6. 0$%*(*$'(*$- *' -4$(*%*( 42/()*($-? $:&*41$')? /'0#&1/' 0$(*-*+'-7 H'*)*/3 2$)2+-4$()*5$- #/5$ %+(&-$0 +' )#2$$ 3*G$3. (+')2*6&)+2. (/&-$-f

    !H'/0$:&/)$ -*)&/)*+'/3 /;/2$'$-- /) D*2-) 8'$2,.

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    57/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(87

    "#$ 63/(G+&) +% )#$ `.02+@l&$6$( -.-)$1 ;/- (/&-$0 ;#$' -$5$' -)/)*( 5+3)/,$@/14-2$/()*5$ Ig9cL (+14$'-/)+2- I>gg< )2*44$07 96+&) b1*33*+' 4$+43$ ;$2$ 3$%) ;*)#+&) 4+;$2 %+2 -$5$2/3 #+&2- /'0? $5$' Z #+&2- 3/)$2? )#$2$;$2$ -)*33 V 1*33*+' 4$+43$ ;*)#+&) 4+;$27

    ^$+1/,'$)*( -)+21- 2$42$-$') /' /442+C*1/)*+' )+ /' 8A@*'0&($0 5+3)/,$ $%%$()7 "#$$C4$2*$'($ )+ 0/)$ *- +% $5$')- )#/) 1/. 6$ +20$2- +% 1/,'*)&0$ -1/33$2 *' -(+4$ /'0 3$---$5$2$ )#/' )#/) $C4$()$0 %2+1 /' 8JK h /3)#+&,# )#$

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    58/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(88

    ;*33 6$ 0/1/,$0 )#/) #/5$ $'-&2$0 (2*)*(/3 -.-)$1 (+14+'$')- /2$ -/%$ )+ /33+; %/-)2$(+5$2.7 9- / 2$-&3)? -+1$ /'0 4$2#/4- 1&(# +% )#$ $3$()2*(/3 -.-)$1 ;+&30 '+) 6$/63$ )+ 42+)$() *)-$3% %2+1 )#$ $%%$()- +% 1&3)*43$ -*1&3)/'$+&- /'0 (/-(/0*', %/*3&2$-7M*0$-42$/0 0/1/,$ )+ )#$ ,$'$2/)*+'? )2/'-1*--*+'? /'0 0*-)2*6&)*+' *'%2/-)2&()&2$-/'0 $:&*41$') /2$ 42+6/63$7 c/)#$2 )#/' -*143. 2$-)+2*', 4+;$2 )+ /' *')/() *'%2/@-)2&()&2$ ;*)# +'3. / 5$2. %$; 0/1/,$0 (+14+'$')-? )#$ 2$(+5$2. )/-G ;+&30 6$ )+2$43/($ /' $C)$'-*5$3. 0/1/,$0 -.-)$1 &'0$2 5$2. 0*%%*(&3) /'0 0$(/.*', (*2(&1@-)/'($- /'0 )#$' 42+($$0*', )+ 2$-)+2/)*+'7

    !"#$ (+')2+3 -.-)$1- ;+&30 6$ 0/1/,$0 )+ -+1$ $C)$') /- +44+-$0 )+ 2$1/*'*', %&33.+4$2/)*+'/3 /- *' #*-)+2*(/3 +&)/,$-7 "#$ +4$2/)*+'- /'0 0*-4/)(# ($')$2- ;#$2$ )#$ 5/-)*')$2(+''$()$0 -.-)$1 *- (+')2+33$0 /'0 1/'/,$0 ;+&30 42+6/63. #/5$ 0/1/,$0 /'00*-2&4)$0 (+14+'$')-? )#$ 2$/0*',- %2+1 )#$ -.-)$1 ;+&30 6$ %2/,1$')$0 /'0 *' 1/'.(/-$- %/3-$ +2 '+'$C*-)$')? /'0 (+11&'*(/)*+' 6. ;#/)$5$2 1$/'- ;+&30 6$ 0*%%*(&3))+ *142/()*(/3 )+ *14+--*63$7

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    59/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(89

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c$-)+2/)*+' )+ (&22$') -)/'0/20- +% $3$()2*( 4+;$2 (+-) /'0 2$3*/6*3*). ;+&30 /31+-)($2)/*'3. )/G$ .$/2- ;*)# -$5$2$ *14/() +' )#$ $(+'+1. /'0 /33 )#/) *) $')/*3-7

    +13/12GA"#$ $3$()2*(/3 -.-)$1 1&-) 6$ 42+)$()$0 /,/*'-) )#$ (+'-$:&$'($- +% /' 8JK $5$') )+

    )#$ $C)$') 2$/-+'/63. 4+--*63$7 "#$ 3$5$3 +% 5&3'$2/6*3*). /'0 $C)2$1$ (+'-$:&$'($ (+1@6*'$ )+ *'5*)$ /' 8JK /))/(G7 "#&- 2$0&()*+' +% +&2 5&3'$2/6*3*). )+ /))/(G /'0 )#$2$-&3)*', (+'-$:&$'($- 2$0&($- )#$ 42+6/6*3*). +% /))/(G7 H) *- /3-+ (3$/2 )#$

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    60/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(8:

    +% &'42+)$()$0 (+14+'$')-7 >*'($ )#*- *- / ,*5$'? )#$ %+(&- +% 42+)$()*+' *- )+ 2$)/*' /'02$-)+2$ -$25*($ )+ (2*)*(/3 3+/0- ;#*3$ 4$21*))*', 2$3/)*5$3. 2/4*0 2$-)+2/)*+'7

    "#$ /442+/(# )+ 42+)$()*+' #/- )#$ %+33+;*', %&'0/1$')/3 /-4$()-7 "#$-$ ;*33 (+33$(@)*5$3. 2$0&($ )#$ 2$(+5$2. /'0 2$-)+2/)*+' )*1$- /'0 1*'*1*P$ )#$ '$) *14/() %2+1/--/&3)7 933 +% )#*- *- %$/-*63$ *' )$21- +% (+-) /'0 )*1*', *% 0+'$ /- 4/2) +% / (+142$#$'@

    -*5$ /'0 2$/-+'/63$ 2$-4+'-$ )+ )#$ )#2$/)-? ;#$)#$2 )#$ /--/&3) *- 4#.-*(/3? $3$()2+1/,@'$)*( I-&(# /- 8JKL? +2 (.6$27V7 K2+)$() #*,#@5/3&$ /--$)- )#2+&,# #/20$'*',7 `/20$'*',? 42+5*0*', %+2 -4$(*/3

    ,2+&'0*',? /'0 +)#$2 -(#$1$- /2$ 2$:&*2$0 )+ /--&2$ )#$ %&'()*+'/3 +4$2/)*+' +% 42+@)$()*+' $:&*41$') %+2 3/2,$ #*,#@5/3&$ /--$)- -&(# /- )2/'-%+21$2-? 62$/G$2-? /'0 ,$'@$2/)+2- /'0 )+ -+ 42+)$() /,/*'-) -$:&$')*/3? -&6-$:&$') *14/()- %2+1 8W /'0 8A (2$@/)*', 0/1/,$7 K2+)$()*+' )#2+&,# #/20$'*', (2*)*(/3 $3$1$')- +% )#$ '/)&2/3 ,/- )2/'-@4+2)/)*+' /'0 ,/- -&443. -.-)$1- )+ G$. 4+;$2 43/')- )#/) ;*33 6$ '$($--/2. %+2 $3$(@)2*(/3 -.-)$1 2$(+5$2. *- *14$2/)*5$7

    W7 9--&2$ )#$2$ /2$ /0$:&/)$ (+11&'*(/)*+' /--$)- 0$0*(/)$0 +2 /5/*3/63$ )+ )#$ $3$()2*@(/3 -.-)$1 +4$2/)+2- -+ )#/) 0/1/,$ 0&2*', -.-)$1 (+33/4-$ (/' 6$ 1*'*1*P$0S (+1@4+'$')- 2$:&*2*', #&1/' *')$25$')*+' )+ 62*', )#$1 +'@3*'$ /2$ *0$')*%*$0 /'0 3+(/)$0S

    (2*)*(/3 1/'4+;$2 (/' 6$ (+')/()$0 /'0 0*-4/)(#$0S %&$3? -4/2$ 4/2)- /'0 +)#$2 (+1@1+0*)*$- (2*)*(/3 )+ )#$ $3$()2*(/3 -.-)$1 2$-)+2/)*+' (/' 6$ /33+(/)$0S /'0 42+5*0$ )#$/6*3*). )+ 1/)(# ,$'$2/)*+' )+ 3+/0 /'0 62*', )#$ -.-)$1 6/(G +' 3*'$7

    A7 K2+)$() )#$ &-$ +% $1$2,$'(. 4+;$2 -&443*$- /'0 %&$3 0$3*5$2.? /'0 *14+2)/')3.? 42+@5*0$ %+2 )#$*2 -&-)/*'$0 &-$ /- 4/2) +% )#$ 42+)$()*+' +% (2*)*(/3 3+/0-? ;#*(# 3+/0- 1&-)6$ *0$')*%*$0 6. ,+5$2'1$') 6&) (/' /3-+ 6$ /--&2$0 6. 42*5/)$ /()*+'7 >4$(*%*(/33.fh H'(2$/-$ )#$ 6/))$2. /'0 +'@-*)$ ,$'$2/)*', (/4/6*3*). %+2 G$. -&6-)/)*+' /'0 (+'@

    )2+3 %/(*3*)*$- )+ $C)$'0 )#$ (2*)*(/3 4$2*+0 /33+;*', 2$(+5$2.7 "#*- *- 2$3/)*5$3. 3+;(+-) /'0 ;*33 *142+5$ 2$3*/6*3*). /- ;$33 /- 42+5*0$ -&6-)/')*/3 42+)$()*+' /,/*'-)/33 %+21- +% /))/(G7

    h c$:&*2$ G$. ,/-+3*'$ /'0 0*$-$3 -$25*($ -)/)*+'- /'0 0*-)2*6&)*+' %/(*3*)*$- *' ,$+@

    ,2/4#*( /2$/- )+ #/5$ /)@-*)$ ,$'$2/)*+'? %&$3$0 +%% $C*-)*', )/'G-? )+ /--&2$ %&$3%+2 )2/'-4+2)/)*+' /'0 +)#$2 -$25*($-? *'(3&0*', 2$%&$3*', $1$2,$'(. ,$'$2/)+2- *')#$ *11$0*/)$ /2$/7

    h c$:&*2$ G$. %&$3*', -)/)*+'- %+2 )#$ 2/*32+/0- )+ #/5$ -)/'06. ,$'$2/)*+'? -*1*3/2)+ )#/) 2$:&*2$0 %+2 -$25*($ -)/)*+'- /'0 0*-)2*6&)*+' %/(*3*)*$-7

    h c$:&*2$ )#$ $1$2,$'(. ,$'$2/)+2 -)/2)? +4$2/)*+'? /'0 *')$2(+''$()*+' 1$(#/@'*-1- )+ 6$ 8JK #/20$'$0 +2 1/'&/37 "#*- ;*33 /3-+ 2$:&*2$ )#$ /6*3*). )+ *-+3/)$)#$-$ %/(*3*)*$- %2+1 )#$ 1/*' $3$()2*(/3 4+;$2 -.-)$1 0&2*', $1$2,$'(. ,$'$2/@)*+' +4$2/)*+' /'0 -&(# *-+3/)*+' -;*)(#*', 1&-) 6$ 8JK #/20$'$07

    h J/G$ )#$ *')$2(+''$()*+' +% 0*$-$3 $3$()2*( 2/*32+/0 $',*'$- /'0 3/2,$ -#*4- 4+--*@63$ /'0 #/20$' -&(# (/4/6*3*).? *'(3&0*', )#$ (+')*'&$0 +4$2/)*+' +% )#$ &'*)-7

    h "#$ ^+5$2'1$') 1&-) 0$)$21*'$ /'0 -4$(*%. *11$0*/)$3. )#+-$ -)2/)$,*(/33.

    *14+2)/') $3$()2*(/3 3+/0- (2*)*(/3 )+ )#$ F/)*+' )+ 42$-$25$ *' -&(# /' $1$2,$'(.7j7 >$4/2/)$ )#$ 42$-$') *')$2(+''$()$0 -.-)$1-? 4/2)*(&3/23. )#$ 8/-)$2' H')$2(+''$()*+'?

    *')+ -$5$2/3 '+'-.'(#2+'+&- (+''$()$0 -&62$,*+'- +2 $3$()2*(/3 *-3/'0-7 H) *- 5$2.*14+2)/') )+ 42+)$() )#$ /6*3*). +% )#$ -.-)$1 )+ 2$)/*' /- 1&(# *' +4$2/)*+' /- 4+--*@63$ )#2+&,# 2$(+'%*,&2/)*+' 4/2)*(&3/23. +% )#$ 8/-)$2' .-)$1 *')+ / '&1@6$2 +% '+'-.'(#2+'+&- (+''$()$0 2$,*+'-? -+ 0*-2&4)*+'- ;*33 '+) (/-(/0$ 6$.+'0)#+-$ 8JK@0*-2&4)$0 /2$/-7 N/-*(/33.? )#*- 1$/'- $3*1*'/)*', )+)/3 F8c< 2$,*+' -$2@5*($ 3+--? ;#*3$ /) )#$ -/1$ )*1$ 1/*')/*'*', )#$ 42$-$') *')$2(+''$()*+' -)/)&- ;*)#

  • 8/8/2019 A2473 EMP Commission 7MB

    61/208

    !"#$#!%& (%$#)(%& #(*"%+$",!$,"-+

    "#$%&'( )* +,'-&(.- /01'(83

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

    R7 H'-)/33 -&6-)/')*/33. 1+2$ 63/(G -)/2) ,$'$2/)*+' &'*)- (+&43$0 ;*)# -4$(*%*( )2/'-1*-@-*+' )#/) (/' 6$ 2$/0*3. *-+3/)$0 )+ 6/3/'(*', 3+/0-7 "#$ F8c< 2$,*+'- '+; 0+ -&2@5$.- +% /5/*3/63$ 63/(G -)/2) /'0 %&$3 -;*)(#/63$ ,$'$2/)*+'7 c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

    42+5*0$0? /- '$($--/2.? )+ -&6-)/')*/33. $C4/'0 )#$ (2*)*(/3 4$2*+0 %+2 2$(+5$2.7b7 H142+5$? $C)$'0? /'0 $C$2(*-$ 2$(+5$2. (/4/6*3*)*$-7 _$5$3+4 42+($0&2$- %+2 /002$--@

    *', )#$ *14/() +% -&(# /))/(G- )+ *0$')*%. ;$/G'$--$-? 42+5*0$ )2/*'*', %+2 4$2-+''$3/'0 0$5$3+4 8JK 2$-4+'-$ )2/*'*', 42+($0&2$- /'0 (++20*'/)$ /33 /()*5*)*$- /'0/442+42*/)$ /,$'(*$- /'0 *'0&-)2.7 M#*3$ 0$5$3+4*', 2$-4+'-$ 43/'-? )2/*'*', /'0(++20*'/)*+' /2$ )#$ 42*1/2. 4&24+-$7

    7).$8)%1 "+B 7)-,$%",/$+"#$ G$. )+ 1*'*1*P*', (/)/-)2+4#*( *14/()- %2+1 3+-- +% $3$()2*(/3 4+;$2 *- 2/4*0 2$-)+@

    2/)*+'7 "#$ 42+)$()*5$ -)2/)$,. 0$-(2*6$0 *- /*1$0 42*1/2*3. /) 42$-$25*', )#$ -.-)$1 *' /2$(+5$2/63$ -)/)$ /%)$2 )#$ /))/(G? 1/*')/*'*', -$25*($ )+ (2*)*(/3 3+/0-? /'0 $'#/'(*',2$(+5$2.7

    "#$ %*2-) -)$4 *' 2$(+5$2. *- *0$')*%.*', )#$ $C)$') /'0 '/)&2$ +% )#$ 0/1/,$ )+ )#$ -.-@)$1 /'0 )#$' *143$1$')*', / (+142$#$'-*5$ 43/' ;*)# )2/*'$0 4$2-+''$3 /'0 / 2$-$25+*2+% -4/2$ 4/2)- )+ 2$4/*2 )#$ 0/1/,$7 _/1/,$ *- 0$%*'$0 /- /'.)#*', )#/) 2$:&*2$- / )2/*'$04$2-+' )+ )/G$ /' /()*+' ;*)# / (+14+'$')? ;#*(# (/' *'(3&0$ -*143. 2$6++)*', /33 )#$;/. )+ 2$43/(*', 1/O+