1
29 NSC May 19 Advisory Desk / Codes and Standards AD 430: Wind load on unclad frames The purpose of this note is to correct errors in BRE Special Digest SD5 which lead to the prediction of significantly higher wind loads on unclad frames than were calculated using the report which SD5 superseded. BRE published Special Digest SD5 in July 2004. The document was produced principally because at the time, the current guidance for determining wind loads on frames, lattice structures and individual members was based on the BS code of practice CP3 Chapter V: Part 2 which had been withdrawn in October 2001. SD5 is based on BS 6399-2 and includes guidance on determining loads on individual members and lattice structures. It also includes a section on unclad building frames which is based on and intended to supersede BRE report BR173, Design guide for wind loads on unclad framed building structures during construction. BR173 considers a series of identical parallel frames of overall width W at spacing S. The parameter S is used to select the appropriate normal force coefficient C D according to the ratio W/S and the total solidity ratio denoted φ. In a given direction, φ is presented in BR173 as the sum of the horizontal and vertical solidity ratios: φ = φ v + φ h . In the direction perpendicular to the secondary beams, the horizontal solidity ratio used is the equivalent solidity ratio which allows for all the secondary beams in a bay denoted φ = φ v + φ h * (see item iii in the design example in BR173 para. 4.2.2). In SD5, the total solidity ratio is erroneously given as φ = φ v + φ h + φ h,s ie the equivalent horizontal solidity ratio φ h,s is added to, instead of substituted for the horizontal solidity ratio φ h . The total solidity ratio in this direction should be given in SD5 as φ = φ v + φ h,s . The spacing of the secondary beams is used in the determination of the equivalent solidity ratio for secondary beams. In BR173, this parameter is also denoted S and is likely to be different from the frame spacing but unfortunately, SD5 does not differentiate between the two parameters. In SD5, the relevant equation is no. 11: φ h,s = (φ 1 + φ 2 )φ h where φ 2 = (n – 1)(S/d – 7.5)/25. According to BR173, in the expression for φ 2 the parameter S is the secondary beam spacing not the frame spacing. The equivalent expression in BR173 is equation (4): f 2 = (N bb – 1)(S/b – 7.5)/25. The secondary beam spacing should be used in the determination of φ 2 . The approach to determining the wind load on unclad structures (lattice structures, frames and individual members) in SD5 (corrected as indicated) can also be used with BS EN 1991-1-4 and its UK National annex as the design pressures have identical target reliability to BS 6399-2. Contact: Richard Henderson Tel: 01344 636555 Email: [email protected] NEW WORK STARTED EN 1990 Eurocode. Basis of structural and geotechnical design Will supersede BS EN 1990:2002+A1:2005 ISO PUBLICATIONS ISO 17607-1 Steel structures. Execution of structural steelwork. General requirements and vocabulary Will supersede None ISO 17607-2 Steel structures. Execution of structural steelwork. Steels Will supersede None ISO 17607-3 Steel structures. Execution of structural steelwork. Fabrication Will supersede None ISO 17607-4 Steel structures. Execution of structural steelwork. Erection Will supersede None ISO 17607-5 Steel structures. Execution of structural steelwork. Welding Will supersede None ISO 17607-6 Steel structures. Execution of structural steelwork. Bolting Will supersede None New and revised codes & standards From BSI Updates April 2019 To discuss advertising opportunities in NSC please contact Fawad Minhas 01892 553149 [email protected]

AD 430: Wind load on unclad frames - SteelConstruction.info · 2019-05-09 · wind loads on frames, lattice structures and individual members was based on the BS code of practice

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    18

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

29NSCMay 19

Advisory Desk / Codes and Standards

AD 430: Wind load on unclad framesThe purpose of this note is to correct errors in BRE Special Digest SD5 which lead to the prediction of signifi cantly higher wind loads on unclad frames than were calculated using the report which SD5 superseded.

BRE published Special Digest SD5 in July 2004. The document was produced principally because at the time, the current guidance for determining wind loads on frames, lattice structures and individual members was based on the BS code of practice CP3 Chapter V: Part 2 which had been withdrawn in October 2001. SD5 is based on BS 6399-2 and includes guidance on determining loads on individual members and lattice structures. It also includes a section on unclad building frames which is based on and intended to supersede BRE report BR173, Design guide for wind loads on unclad framed building structures during construction.

BR173 considers a series of identical parallel frames of overall width W at spacing S. The

parameter S is used to select the appropriate normal force coeffi cient CD according to the ratio W/S and the total solidity ratio denoted φ. In a given direction, φ is presented in BR173 as the sum of the horizontal and vertical solidity ratios: φ = φv + φh. In the direction perpendicular to the secondary beams, the horizontal solidity ratio used is the equivalent solidity ratio which allows for all the secondary beams in a bay denoted φ = φv + φh* (see item iii in the design example in BR173 para. 4.2.2). In SD5, the total solidity ratio is erroneously given as φ = φv + φh + φh,s ie the equivalent horizontal solidity ratio φh,s is added to, instead of substituted for the horizontal solidity ratio φh. The total solidity ratio in this direction should be given in SD5 as φ = φv + φh,s .

The spacing of the secondary beams is used in the determination of the equivalent solidity ratio for secondary beams. In BR173, this parameter is also denoted S and is likely to be diff erent from the frame spacing but unfortunately, SD5 does

not diff erentiate between the two parameters. In SD5, the relevant equation is no. 11: φh,s = (φ1 + φ2)φh where φ2 = (n – 1)(S/d – 7.5)/25. According to BR173, in the expression for φ2 the parameter S is the secondary beam spacing not the frame spacing. The equivalent expression in BR173 is equation (4): f2 = (Nbb – 1)(S/b – 7.5)/25. The secondary beam spacing should be used in the determination of φ2.

The approach to determining the wind load on unclad structures (lattice structures, frames and individual members) in SD5 (corrected as indicated) can also be used with BS EN 1991-1-4 and its UK National annex as the design pressures have identical target reliability to BS 6399-2.

Contact: Richard HendersonTel: 01344 636555Email: [email protected]

NEW WORK STARTED

EN 1990Eurocode. Basis of structural and geotechnical designWill supersede BS EN 1990:2002+A1:2005

ISO PUBLICATIONS

ISO 17607-1Steel structures. Execution of structural steelwork. General requirements and vocabularyWill supersede None

ISO 17607-2Steel structures. Execution of structural steelwork. SteelsWill supersede None

ISO 17607-3Steel structures. Execution of structural steelwork. FabricationWill supersede None

ISO 17607-4 Steel structures. Execution of structural steelwork. Erection Will supersede None

ISO 17607-5Steel structures. Execution of structural steelwork. WeldingWill supersede None

ISO 17607-6Steel structures. Execution of structural steelwork. BoltingWill supersede None

New and revised codes & standardsFrom BSI Updates April 2019

tata-steel-europe

Image courtesy of EFFEKT Arkitekte and Camp Adventure

CELSIUS® HOT FINISHED HOLLOW SECTIONSCombining the high quality of a true hot-fi nished hollow section with the corrosion resistance of weathering steel, Celsius® is now available in weathering grade. Weathering steels have small additions of copper and aluminium that help improve the corrosion resistance of the steel to atmospheric sources for a long, maintenance-free life. Through natural wet-dry cycles, the steel forms a dense surface patina which inhibits further corrosion.

It is available in a wide range of circular, square, rectangular and elliptical sizes. Unlike some other hot-fi nished hollow sections, Celsius® is fully normalised. The strength and weldable qualities of Celsius® mean that it can be used for all structural and mechanical applications including bridges, motorway gantries, multi-storey columns, space frames and lattice beams.

For more information, call our Hotline: T: +44 (0)1536 404561E: [email protected]

www.tatasteelconstruction.com/celsius

To discuss advertising opportunities in NSCplease contact Fawad Minhas 01892 553149

[email protected]