Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
ADAPTIVE WATER
GOVERNANCE IN HIMALAYAN
TOWNS
Zeeshan Tahir Virk
Pakistan Agricultural Research Council
Pakistan Agricultural Research
Council
• Established in 1978, PARC is the apex body for agricultural
research in Pakistan
• Research Centres all across Pakistan
• Largest centre (National Agriculture Research Centre – Islamabad)
• Climate Change, Alternate Energy, and Water Resources Institute
• HI-AWARE Project
HI-AWARE
Himalayan Adaptation, Water and
Resilience Research on Glacier
and Snowpack Dependent River
Basins for Improving Livelihoods
Introduction to HI-AWARE
HI-AWARE funded through Collaborative
Adaptation Research Initiative for Africa &
Asia (CARIAA) (IDRC / DFID)
Project time period – 2013 to 2018
Pakistan – PARC
India – TERI University
Bangladesh – BCAS
Nepal – ICIMOD
Introduction to HI-AWARE
Study Areas in Pakistan
Hunza Sub-basin in
Upper Indus Basin
Soan Basin in Pothowar
Plateau
Chaj Doab in Indus
plains
High Mountain Study Area
(Hunza River Basin)
Flood Plain Study Area
(Chaj Doab)
Mid-Hill Study Area
(Soan River Basin)
Adaptive Water Governance in
Himalayan Towns
Introduction
A regional study, focusing on impacts of;
Urbanization Climate
Change
Water
Resources
Introduction
This study is focusing on water;
– Availability
– Demand and Supply
– Governance
– Impacts of climate change
• Increasing urbanization, population and climate change
impacts in Himalayan river basins are stressing the existing
water resources of these areas.
• This study is investigating emerging urban settlements in
Himalayan river basins, such as “Murree” in Pakistan
Himalaya's unique topography and hydrogeology is able to
support only
3 % Large cities 8 % Small towns People are
flocking to
nearest urban
centers
increasing
urbanization and
water access
challenges in
Himalayan
towns
By 2050, more than 50% of the population in six HKH
countries (Bangladesh, Bhutan, China, India, Myanmar,
and Pakistan) will live in cities. In Afghanistan and
Nepal, this %age is expected to reach earlier .
Urban centers in the HKH region
<50000
50000 -100000
100000 - 500000
500000 - 1000000
>1000000
Source: ICIMOD, 2017
Haveliyan
Murree
Mussorie
Devaprayag
Tansen
Palpa
Singtam
Kalimpong
FocusFrom left to right-
Objectives
• Assessing the current status of water
resources in Himalayan towns in
Pakistan.
• Understanding the ways in which
residents are adapting to the change in
water availability
Methodology
• Literature Review
• Secondary Data
• Quantitative Data
– Household Survey (Stratified Random
Sampling)
• Qualitative Data (Participatory Rural
Assessment)
– Focus Group Discussions
– Key Informant Interviews
Literature Review
Secondary Data
Quantitative Data
Qualitative Data
Data Analysis
MURREE
90% reliance on
springs for
domestic water
uses 1981
1998
20162017
153023
176426
214230250000+
Population ProjectionOriginal water supply network
installed by British army in
1884
Estimated current demand is
3 million gallons per
day
Historic hill station founded in 1800s
Murree Tehsil: 15 Ucs
Murree City: 1 UC (Murree
Urban)Rawalpindi, Pakistan
Murree City (Adminstrative)
Challenges
Tourist based water
demands and
resultant stresses on
available water resources
Commercial activities such
as hotels and
restaurant activities
involved in water stealing
No water-body source
such as lake/river/dam
Adaptation measures small
and scattered
Unsustainable and
resource intensive
development
Rain water
harvesting
Seasonal
migration
Identification
of new
sources
Jhelum
Water
Supply
Project
Strategies
Murree City (Major Settlements)
Major Settlements in Urban Murree
• Kachi Abadi Baroori
• Kashmiri Muhalla Bansra Gali
• Sunny Bank
• Pindi Point
• Sardar Noor Khan Town (Ihata Noor Khan)
• Shawala
• Dhobi Ghaat
• Abbasi Muhalla
• Kashmiri Muhalla Murree Hills
Major Settlements in Urban Murree
• Lower Bazar
• Kasai Muhalla
• Mochi Mandi
• Kashmir Point
• Hill Dholo
• Jhika Gali
• Mussairri
• Mall Road
• Kuldana Road
Murree City (Water Sources and Distribution)
Water Sources
• The main source: Spring water 90%
• 5 major water sources pump water to the reservoirs at Kashmir
point. These include the following;
• Doonga Gali:
– Oldest water scheme.
– Surface water
– Two reservoirs of 6.2 Million Gallons.
• Khanitak:
– Spring water
– capacity of 50000 gallons.
– It supplies nearly 100,000 gallons
– 4 stage pumping system.
Water Sources
• Masoot
– Spring water
– 2 capping tanks, of 50000 gallons.
– Daily supply 150,000 gallons
– 2 stage pumping system
• Dharjawa
– Largest spring water source
– Supplies nearly 800,000 to 1 million gallons daily
– 5 stage pumping system.
Water Sources
• Shawala:
– Spring Water
– Multi stage pumping system
– Supplies 70,000 to 100,000 gallons daily
Water Distribution
• Water is distributed by means of gravity with water stored in
6 reservoirs at Kashmir point and two other small water
tanks, one at Pindi point and the other at Kuldana Road.
• Original Water Supply Network Installed by British army in 1894
• Subsequent Addition to the Network (1974 – 1993)
• Complete Rehabilitation of the System 2009 – 2010
Water Distribution
S. NO Tank Name Capacity
1. Tonely Tank 1.3 Million Gallons
2. New Tonely Tank 0.7 Million Gallons
3. 3rd Storage Tank 2.6 Million Gallons
4. Panj-Paandu Tank 0.65 Million Gallons
5. Panj-Paandu Tank No. 2 2 Million Gallons
6. Panj-Paandu Tank No. 3 0.5 Million Gallons
7. Pindi Point Tank 1 Million Gallons
8. Kuldana Road Tank 0.5 Million Gallons
Other Water Sources
In addition to the above main water sources the
residents of the city utilize other sources such
as
• Small Springs ( Community based Capping)
• Un-capped springs
• Hill Torrents
• Rain Water Harvesting
Results
Demographics
12%
18%
14%32%
13%
8%3%
Education
Not literate
Primary School
Middle School
High School
Higher Secondary
Graduation
Post Graduation and above
65%
35%
Type of Family
Nuclear
Joint
70%
30%
Gender
Male
Female
16%
84%
Migrant/Non-Migrant Status
Migrant
Non Migrant
Household Statistics
92%
5%
3%
Type of House
Independent
Apartment
Slum/Informal Settlement
7%
92%
1%
Ownership Status
Rented
Owned
Others (Government House, etc.)
7%
92%
1%
Construction Type of House
Kucha
Pakka
Others(Both Kucha & Pakka)
9%
26%
37%
15%
6%7%
Monthly Household Income
Less than 10000
Between 10001 and 15000
Between 15001 and 30000
Between 30001 and 50000
Between 50001 and 100000
More than 100001
9%
91%
Dependence on Foreign Remittances
Yes
No
Main Water uses
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
Drinking Cooking Washing Bathing Livestock Kitchen Garden
Different uses of water at Household
Different uses of water at Household
Main Water Sources
10%
5%1%
1%
1%
82%
Main source of water for drinking purpose
Municipal supply
Ground water drawn from personal bore/tube-well
Ground water drawn trough community tube-well
Stream/river/lake
Private water vendor selling bottled water
Springs
11%
4%2%
0%
1%
82%
Main source of water for cooking purpose
Municipal supply
Ground water drawn from personal bore/tube-well
Ground water drawn trough community tube-well
Stream/river/lake
Private water vendor selling bottled water
Springs
Main Water Sources
17%
5%2%
2%
70%
4%
Main source of water for washing purpose
Municipal supply
Ground water drawn from personal bore/tube-well
Ground water drawn trough community tube-well
Stream/river/lake
Springs
Rain water storage
17% 4%
2%
3%
1%
69%
4%
Main source of water for bathing purpose
Municipal supply
Ground water drawn from personal bore/tube-well
Ground water drawn trough community tube-well
Stream/river/lake
Private water vendor selling bottled water
Springs
Rain water storage
Alternate Water Sources
3%4%
4%0%
3%
83%
1%
2%
Alternate source for drinking purpose
Municipal supply
Ground water drawn from personal bore/tube-well
Ground water drawn trough community tube-well
Stream/river/lake
Private water vendor selling bottled water
Springs
Rain water storage
Water Tankers
3%6%
4%0%
3%
81%
1% 2%
Alternate source for cooking purpose
Municipal supply
Ground water drawn from personal bore/tube-well
Ground water drawn trough community tube-well
Stream/river/lake
Private water vendor selling bottled water
Springs
Rain water storage
Water Tankers
Alternate Water Sources
3%6%
5% 3%
1%
74%
3%5%
Alternate source for washing purpose
Municipal supply
Ground water drawn from personal bore/tube-well
Ground water drawn trough community tube-well
Stream/river/lake
Private water vendor selling bottled water
Springs
Rain water storage
Water Tankers
4%6%
5%
3% 1%
73%
3%5%
Alternate source for bathing purpose
Municipal supply
Ground water drawn from personal bore/tube-well
Ground water drawn trough community tube-well
Stream/river/lake
Private water vendor selling bottled water
Springs
Rain water storage
Water Tankers
Source Water Quality
Type of Water
Source
Color Smell Taste
Dirty/ha
s ColorClear
Foul
Smell
No Foul
Smell
Unaccept
able Taste
Normal
Taste
Municipal water
supply
2 27 6 23 9 20
18.2% 16.5% 60.0% 13.9% 45.0% 12.9%
Ground Water0 8 0 8 0 8
0.0% 4.9% 0.0% 4.8% 0.0% 5.2%
Lake/river/pond0 1 0 1 0 1
0.0% .6% 0.0% .6% 0.0% .6%
Private water
vendors selling
bottled water
0 1 0 1 0 1
0.0% .6% 0.0% .6% 0.0% .6%
Spring Water9 127 4 132 11 125
81.8% 77.4% 40.0% 80.0% 55.0% 80.6%
Total11 164 10 165 20 155
100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
Seasonal Variation in Water quality
Type of
Water
Source
Seasonal
Variation in
Water Quality Summer Monsoon Winter
Yes No Good Average
No
Response Good Average
No
Response Good Average
No
Response
Municipal
water supply
7 22 0 6 22 0 2 22 2 5 22
17.1% 16.4% 0.0% 22.2% 16.4% 0.0% 25.0% 16.4% 11.8% 31.3% 16.4%
Ground Water 0 8 0 0 8 0 0 8 0 0 8
0.0% 6.0% 0.0% 0.0% 6.0% 0.0% 0.0% 6.0% 0.0% 0.0% 6.0%
Lake/river/pon
d
0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1
0.0% .7% 0.0% 0.0% .7% 0.0% 0.0% .7% 0.0% 0.0% .7%
Private water
vendors selling
bottled water
0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1
0.0% .7% 0.0% 0.0% .7% 0.0% 0.0% .7% 0.0% 0.0% .7%
Spring Water 34 102 5 21 102 4 6 102 15 11 102
82.9% 76.1% 100.0% 77.8% 76.1% 100.0% 75.0% 76.1% 88.2% 68.8% 76.1%
Total 41 134 5 27 134 4 8 134 17 16 134
100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
Spring Water
89%
11%
Use of Spring Water
Yes
No
83%
6%
11%
Frequency of Spring Water Use
Very Often
Only During Crisis
Not Applicable
82%
6%
0%
1%
11%
Seasonal Dependency on Water from Springs
Throughout the year
Summers and Pre-monsoon
Monsoons
Winters
Not Applicable
83%
5%
1%
11%
Last time since Spring Water was used
Within Last 15 Days to One Month
Within Last 6 months
More than 6 months to one year back
Not Applicable
Spring Water
0 50 100 150 200
Drinking
Cooking
Bathing
Washing
Others(Livestock and Kitchen Garden)
Different Uses of Spring Water
Different Uses of Spring Water
• Average Distance of
household from
spring source = 380
meters
• Average cost of
accessing spring
water =913 PKR
approximately 1000
PKR
Spring Water
0 20 40 60 80 100
Adult Females
Adult Males
Female Children
Male Children
Not Collecting
Household Water Collection
Household Water Collection
Average Household Daily Water
Consumption & Storage
S.NO Consumption (Litres) Storage (Litres)
Drinking15.07 -
Cooking10.28 -
Drinking + Cooking 24.92 27.67
Bathing77.085 -
Washing84.11 -
Bathing +Washing 159.65 196.1
Household Water Storage
58%
42%
Access to Household Storage Tank
Yes
No
52%
6%
42%
No. of Household Storage Tanks
One
Two
Not Applicable
19%
3%
36%
42%
Source of Water for storage Tank
Personal Bore-wells
Water Tankers
Others (Municipal Supply, Springs etc.)
Not Applicable
53%
3%2%
42%
Number of times the storage tanks are filled in a day
Once
Twice
More than two times
Not Applicable
Average
Capacity of
Storage Tank =
525 Litres
Perceptions of Water Availability
33%
8%
1%14%
8%
9%
27%
Most Critical Water ChallengeLong distance of the water source from the house
Limited people in the house to help in water collection
High expenditure on water (includes water bills, investments, transportation costs etc.)
Limited Hours of Supply
Low Quality of Water
Lack of sufficient storage facilities
Others
71%
22%
7%
Changes in Water availability over the past 20 years
Yes
No
No Response/Don't Know/Can't Say
Perceptions of Water Availability
24%
26%
18%
19%
10%
3%
Reasons for Change in Water Availability
Decrease in Rain and Increase in Temperature
Depleteing Water Resources due to Increasing Demand
Over Exploitation of Ground Water Resources
Mismanaged Water Resources
Poor and Inefficient Water Infrastructure
Others(Increase in Poupulation, Urbanization, Earthquakes etc.)
Perceptions of Climate Change
81%
19%
Household Perception of Climate Change in
the city
Yes
No57%22%
2%
19%
Changes in Winters over the last 20 years
Warmer
Colder
No Change
Not Applicable 74%
4%
3%
19%
Changes in Summers over the last 20 years
Warmer
Colder
No Change
Not Applicable
7%
73%
1%19%
Changes in Snowfall over the last 20 years
Increased
Decreased
No Change
Not Applicable
27%
50%
4%
19%
Changes in Summer Rains over the last 20 years
Increased
Decreased
No Change
Not Applicable
38%
22%
21%
19%
Changes in Onset of Monsoon Rains over the last 20 years
Before time
On time
Delayed
Not Applicable
Perceptions of Climate Change
59%
5%
15%
0%
2%
19%
Changes in Intensity & Duration of Monsoon Rains over the last 20
years
Short Duration Heavy Showers
Long Duration Heavy Showers
Short Duration Light Showers
Long Duration Light Showers
No Change
Not Applicable
14%
9%
59%
18%
Occurrence of Flash floods
Increased
Decreased
No Change
Not Applicable
8%
73%
19%
Occurrence of Frequent Droughts
Yes
No
Not Applicable
Organizational Support
5%
95%
Organizational Support
Yes
No
22%
67%
11%
Type of Organization
NGO
Political Party/Party based organization
Government Organization
12%
75%
13%
Type of Support
Financial
Technological/Infrastructural
Capacity building/awareness generation
Discussion
Water Demand and Consumption
Estimated current demand as per TMA is 2.5 to 3 Million
Gallons per Day (MGD).
The per capita demand is considered to be around 40
gallons per capita per day as per Town Municipal
Administration.
The current water supply to the city varies from 1.2 to
1.5 MGD.
55% Municipal Water for Civil Population, 45%
Cantonment
Increase in population, increased tourism in recent years
and load shedding of electricity are the main reasons of
deficit
Commercial Water Consumption
• Tourism is a huge Industry for the City.
• Seasonal Tourist Influx plus the migrant
population increases the original 25000
inhabitants to 0.5 Million people
• Limited hours of Municipal Water Supplies to
the Hotel Owners
• Use Water Tankers at High costs to meet
demands
• Often forced to steal water and affect the
system
Water in Sub-Urban Murree
• Condition of Water Resources, availability
and management is extremely poor in the
Sub-Urban areas and Urban-Rural Fringe
areas.
• Most Communities rely on spring water for
drinking and rain water for domestic
purposes.
Water in Sub-Urban Murree
• Government and NGOs have worked in past on
water supply schemes, many of which have
become dysfunctional and need rehabilitation,
others are over stressed due to increase in
population
• The slow development process is unable to
compete with fast urbanization and increasing
population
Potential Adaptive Strategies
• Rain Water Harvesting
• Deep Water Wells
• Seasonal Migration
• Identification of New Sources
• Revival of the Jehlum Water Supply
Project
Thank YouQuestions ?