-
Meeting will be aired live and recorded. PUBLIC COMMENT: Any
member of the public may address the Committee on any subject in
its area of responsibility on any matter not presently pending or
previously discussed at the Committee. Pursuant to the provisions
California Executive Order 29-20, Committee meeting will be held
via teleconference until further notice. In lieu of in-person
attendance, members of the public may submit their comments via a
public comment webform. Members of the public wishing to address
the Committee under Public Comment must submit a Public Comment
webform prior to the meeting. Instructions for word limitations and
deadlines will be noted on the webform. Pursuant to open meeting
laws, no discussion or action, other than a referral, shall be
taken by the Committee on any issue brought forth under non-agenda
public comment. The information contained in this agenda is
available in alternative formats and can be requested by calling
858-573-1441 or e-mailing [email protected] at least three (3)
working days prior to the meeting to insure availability.
Montgomery-Gibbs Executive Airport and Brown Field Municipal
Airport
AIRPORTS ADVISORY COMMITTEE AGENDA
Online Meeting To view the meeting please click here
Tuesday, January 12, 2021 3:00 p.m. – 4:00 p.m.
1. CALL TO ORDER Tom Reid, Chair
2. ROLL CALL Tom Reid, Chair
3. NON-AGENDA PUBLIC COMMENT – Instructions Provided Below Tom
Reid, Chair
4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES – November 10, 2020 Tom Reid, Chair
5. UNFINISHED BUSINESS A. Receive and File – Clarification on
the Proposed Airports Division Jorge Rubio, Airports
Business Plan
6. NEW BUSINESS A. Airports Advisory Committee Review of AAC
Bylaws Tom Reid, Chair
7. STAFF’S REPORTS Jorge Rubio, Airports
8. AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL TOWER REPORT Joel Ryan, FAA
9. OPERATIONS and NOISE REPORTS Jorge Rubio, Airports
10. COMMITTEE COMMENTS Tom Reid, Chair
11. ADJOURNMENT Tom Reid, Chair
https://www.sandiego.gov/boards-and-commissions/public-commenthttps://www.sandiego.gov/boards-and-commissions/public-commenthttps://www.sandiego.gov/boards-and-commissions/public-commenthttps://www.sandiego.gov/airports/aac
-
1
CITY OF SAN DIEGO AIRPORTS ADVISORY COMMITTEE
DRAFT MINUTES Meeting of November 10, 2020
Montgomery-Gibbs Executive Airport,
3750 John J. Montgomery Drive, San Diego, CA 92123 Via
teleconference
1. CALL TO ORDER
Chairman Reid called the meeting to order at 3:01 PM.
2. ROLL CALL A quorum was present.
MEMBERS PRESENT: MEMBERS ABSENT: Buzz Gibbs Kearny Mesa
Community
J.H. Aldrich Montgomery Field Aviation Lessee Community
Lisa Golden Otay Mesa Community
Jackie Ander (E) Serra Mesa Community
David Gordon Special Expertise
Gary List Brown Field Aviation User Group
Ron Lee Special Expertise
Rich Martindell Special Expertise
Vice-Chairman Chuck McGill Montgomery Gibbs Aviation User
Group
Mike Ogilvie Tierrasanta Community Council
Chairman Tom Reid Clairemont Community
Tom Ricotta Brown Field Aviation Lessee
Joel Ryan FAA Control Tower
STAFF PRESENT: Jorge Rubio, Charlie Broadbent, Thurman Hodges,
Millie Moore, David Reed, Andy Schwartz, and Debbie Shauger.
3. NON-AGENDA PUBLIC COMMENT
Mr. Turner stated that engine runups are noisy, dangerous, and
against City code in hangar areas. He suggested they should be
permitted if the operator is aiming at their own hangar otherwise,
they should use designated run-up areas. Mr. Turner suggested an
education campaign emphasizing the danger of debris being blown at
bystanders and danger to aircraft.
-
2
Another suggestion is to have helicopters and fixed wings on
same frequency when transitioning North to South which would only
require one quick radio call to local controllers. Mr. Rubio
responded the Airport agrees with the public comment regarding the
engine run-ups and will include the language in the Newsletter to
address this item. Mr. Rubio requested for Mr. Ryan to address the
public comment regarding the helicopter radio frequency during his
report.
4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Chairman Reid requested any comments, changes, or deletions to
the meeting notes Mr. Martindell stated on the footnote of the roll
call matrix include the description of Mr. Ryan as FAA Control
Tower and in paragraph 8, should read: “Mr. Martindell inquired
about coordination between Air Traffic Control Tower (ATCT) and
Southern California Terminal Radar Approach Control (SoCal TRACON)
for ATCT issue class Bravo clearances”. Chairman Reid had a comment
regarding paragraph 4, the word minutes has two letter “S’s” in it.
Mr. Martindell made a motion to approve minutes as corrected, Mr.
Lee seconded the motion, passed unanimously.
5. UNFINISHED BUSINESS None
6. NEW BUSINESS A. Adoption of Airports Advisory Committee
Meeting Calendar for Calendar year 2021.
Mr. Rubio stated there is no public comment. Mr. Gordon made a
motion to approve the 2021 Calendar and Mr. Martindell seconded the
motion, passed unanimously.
B. Proposed Airports Division Business Plan Presentation Mr.
Rubio started there is not public comment.
Mr. Rubio gave Airports Division Business Plan for FY 2021
presentation. Mr. Martindell inquired about the national comparison
as to the Current Ratio for the
airports. Mr. Rubio responded our airports are pioneers in this
area as not many other airports show this number in their financial
statements.
Mr. Rubio stated the Master Plan is to be completed by early
2022. Mr. Gordon inquired about the Annual Contracted Services
amount. Mr. Riego responded
there are other contractual services included such as Security
and Janitorial services, along with various supplies for the
airports needs and that he will provide a more detailed listing to
the AAC.
Mr. Ricotta Inquired about the significant increase in revenue.
Mr. Riego responded most of it is from the leases of properties,
lease appraisals and airports efficiencies.
7. STAFF REPORTS
Deputy Director Report – Jorge Rubio
• Mr. Rubio announced that on November 4th Kathy Chavez retired.
She has worked with the City for 20 years and she will be greatly
missed.
• The current Biologist position will be reclassified to a
Planner position in order to assist with numerous future capital
projects. Due to COVID-19 there is a continual cleaning, new
thermometers were installed, and face masks are required. Also,
there will be no indoor dining at the restaurant upstairs
-
3
due to COVID-19 restrictions. • The ARC of San Diego Property
rights are for sale. A portion of the property rights belong
to the City and staff is in the process of determining if The
City portion belongs to Airports or the general fund in order to
determine if it will be a good idea for the Airports to purchase
the ARC portion of it.
• The City and the Control Tower drafted a Letter of Agreement
(LOA) putting conditions as to what is needed for the Navy to
conduct night jumps at Brown Field Municipal Airport (SDM) and it
will continue in the future. Another part of the Navy is looking
into proposing a new drop zone on the north side of the airport,
which is on existing federal land and currently most agencies
(Airport’s District Office of the FAA, Approach, City etc.) are not
in favor of the proposal. If all parties agree the proposed drop
zone should be used, the FAA will conduct a safety review and
according to the result the proposed drop zone will be either
approved or denied.
• On September 24th at Montgomery-Gibbs Executive Airport (MYF)
a single engine aircraft hit a tree by the fence on the north side
of MYF. There were no casualties and staff responded
accordingly.
• On October 8th, at SDM a light sport aircraft during a soft
field take off crash landed off the side of the runway. No injuries
were reported.
• A public hearing was conducted at SDM on the Metropolitan
Airpark Project (MAP) and received one public comment from the
military which is being reviewed and will be responded to
accordingly. At the last AAC meeting there were comments made
regarding windsocks at both ends of the runways at MYF. Staff
noticed that windsocks have been approved in the Airport Layout
Plan. Currently, staff is discussing the time frame of the
windsock’s implementation.
Montgomery-Gibbs Executive Airport – Mr. Broadbent, MYF Airport
Manager
• The Airport recently received full airfield mowing services. •
One Airport sign was damaged due to the high winds during the last
storm and a
replacement sign will be ordered. • The construction is being
conducted at CrownAir and Coast Flight. It is on track for
completion in the next few months. • Operations totaled over
28,000 in October.
Brown Field Municipal Airport – Mr. Schwartz, SDM Airport
Manager
• Operations were up 14% for the year. • Staff did concrete
repair at Taxiway Golf. • The airfield lighting computer is not
operational but a new one has been ordered. • Airside and landside
sweeps have been completed. • A virtual Runway Safety Action Team
(RSAT) meeting took place at SDM last month.
The report is currently in draft form and after reviewing final
copy will be provided. • It is Storm Water sampling season and SDM
operations is working on collecting a
sample during a qualifying rain event. Airports Real Estate –
Mr. Hodges, Supervising Property Agent
• The Gibbs Leasehold project is on hold pending the new City
Council being seated and expect to move forward with recommendation
to award the lease to MYF Properties, LLC doing business as
Executive Airpark. A project status scheduled today with Corporate
Helicopters was canceled. Currently the
-
4
consultant is preparing a resubmittal project to Development
Services Department (DSD) and schedule a follow-up meeting to
discuss environmental concerns.
• Crownair is moving forward with their project. The City
exercised option for Crownair to lease Option Area 1 and add 1.4
acres to the leasehold effective November 1, 2020.
• Maintenance and repair were performed on the MYF Office/Retail
Complex with anticipation time of December to January for
completion.
• Public Works requested another 30,000 sq. ft of office space
at 8775 Gibbs Drive. Currently preparing the list of tenant
improvements that will go out to bid for this space.
• The Memorandum of Understanding (lease) is reviewed by City
Attorney’s Office: o 1st lease rent is $42,000 per month for 24,000
sq. ft. o 2nd lease rent is $48,000 per month for 30,00 sq. ft. o
Total of $90,000 per month. o Office leases generates $64,000 per
month. o Retail Center generates $44,000 per month.
• Draft Building Condition Assessments have been conducted on
all three office buildings. There is plans to conduct a building
assessment for the Retail Center.
• The fiber optic installation for intranet services has been
completed at SDM. Staff is working with the City’s Informational
Technology Department to implement services.
• The sewer rehabilitation project was completed. • At lot 8A
there is one hangar available for lease. Those interested may
contact Ms.
Shauger, Airports Property Agent. • The 94th Aero Squadron lease
has been completed. • Appraisal has been prepared for the San Diego
Fire Department for the north side of
MYF. • Appraisal is being prepared for the San Diego Police
Depart for a rental adjustment
Mr. Gibbs inquired about the net rents in the newly acquired
buildings at the retail center. Mr. Hodges responded the leases
that we have with office space are full service, the leases at the
retail center, add the Common Area Maintenance (CAM) charges into
the base rent
Mr. Gordon requested a better system of billing for the tie down
rent. Mr. Hodges responded that there has been a change in the
accounting into the real estate billing SAP system, which is a
fixed format.
8. AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL TOWER REPORTS
• Traffic has increased about 14% for MYF. • Staff issues are
the same as last time. • Effective November 8th the Tower hours are
back to normal schedule hours from 6:00
a.m. – 9:00 p.m. • A typo was found in paragraph #4; it should
read Runway 23 and 28L. The Tower is the
process of getting a waiver to get the hold short marking on the
runway at the intersection 28L and runway 23.
• Regarding the public comment about the helicopter frequency,
depending on controller’s workload for safety and efficiency reason
controls may wish to keep an aircraft on one frequency.
• Currently in process of creating a Letter of Agreement (LOA)
with helicopter operators on the airfield to standardize in balance
and out balance Procedures at MYF?
-
5
Discussion took place regarding making Taxiway Bravo more
accessible to reduce delays and increase efficiency. Chairman Reid
recognized the Tower for doing a great job. 9. OPERATIONS AND
AIRCRAFT NOISE REPORT
None
10. COMMITTEE COMMENTS None
11. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 4:31 PM. Next meeting will be held
January 12th, 2021
Respectfully, Millie Moore
-
1
BYLAWS OF
THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO AIRPORTS ADVISORY COMMITTEE
Adopted April 9, 2019
I. PURPOSE
101. Establishment and Purpose
The City of San Diego Airports Advisory Committee is formed
pursuant to City of San Diego Ordinance number O-20013, dated
January 18, 2011. The purpose of the City of San Diego (City)
Airports Advisory Committee (Committee) is to provide the Mayor and
City Council with advice on general aviation issues related to City
owned and operated airports.
102. Duties
The Airports Advisory Committee shall: Serve in an advisory
capacity to the Mayor and City Council on selected issues
related to airport policies and development projects at
Montgomery and Brown Fields.
Provide recommendations to airport staff on selected actions
that require
Council approval. Conduct public meetings to provide a forum
for, and receive input on, airport-
related issues. Recommend methods of improving communications
and relations between
the member-represented communities, airport users and the City.
Serve as liaisons between the public, airport tenants, and the
City.
Provide advice, input and support to the City Real Estate Assets
Department,
Airports Division, when requested. The Committee shall have no
managerial, financial or budget authority.
-
2
II. ORGANIZATION
201. Membership
Members of the Committee shall be comprised persons who are both
pilots and non-pilots; persons who are sensitive to the needs of
the needs of the users of Montgomery and Brown Field Airports and
the surrounding communities; and persons who are sensitive to the
role of general aviation in the area. Not more than four members
shall be master lease holders (master leaseholder is defined as a
representative from a business entity that leases directly from the
city, more than 1 acre of land at a City operated airport, and who
provide services or act as landlords to other airport users) at any
City owned airport. Appointments to the Committee shall be made as
needed by the Mayor, and confirmed by the City Council.
Specifically, the Committee shall be comprised of:
a. One member who represents Serra Mesa Community b. One member
who represents Tierrasanta Community c. One member who represents
Clairmont Community d. One member who represents Kearny Mesa
Community e. One member who represents Otay Mesa Community f. One
member who represents Montgomery Field aviation user group g. One
member who represents Brown Field aviation user group h. One member
who represents Montgomery Field aviation lessees i. One member who
represents Brown Field aviation lessees j. Three members who have
special expertise in the field of aviation, airport
operations, or community relations that will benefit the
Committee k. Non-voting members such as ATC, Control Tower staff or
others with local
expertise may be appointed by the vote of the Committee.
202. Terms
Members shall serve four-year terms and shall serve until a
successor is duly appointed and confirmed. No member shall serve
more than two consecutive terms. Termed-out members may be
reappointed in accordance with the City Charter. In the event that
more than four board members need to be appointed, four members
will be appointed to full four-year terms and the remaining members
will be appointed to an adjusted, shorter term to ensure no more
than four members terms expire in the same year. Members whose
initial appointments are less than the full term of four years will
be allowed to serve their partial term and then two full terms. The
expiration date of all terms shall be February 28. Any vacancy
shall be filled for the remainder of the unexpired term. Vacancy
appointment recommendations will
-
3
come from the Mayor. Any vacancy replacements will be eligible
to serve the remaining term of the vacant position and two full
terms.
203. Officers
At the February meeting each year, the Committee shall elect a
Chairperson and Vice Chairperson by majority vote. The Chairperson
shall preside at all meetings and hearings of the Committee, decide
all points of order or procedure, and perform all duties required
by these rules. The Vice Chairperson shall serve in the absence of
the Chairperson.
204. Candidacy for Elective Public Office
Any member, upon publicly announcing his candidacy for elective
public office associated with the City of San Diego government, or
upon filing petitions pursuant to becoming a candidate for elective
public office associated with the City of San Diego government,
shall forfeit membership prior to the next public meeting of the
Committee.
205. Subcommittees, and Ad Hoc Committees The Chairperson may,
from time to time establish sub-committees, define their powers and
duties, and appoint their members. The majority of sub-committee
members must be members of the Committee, but the chair may appoint
members of the public in order to provide diverse opinion and
input. Any sub-committee may, by majority vote of its members, use
as technical advisors, individuals who are not members of the
Committee, for the purpose of furthering the work of the given
sub-committee. All sub-committee appointments to standing
committees shall be for a term of one calendar year unless the
Chairperson designates a shorter time period. Ad-Hoc sub-committees
are those established for a finite period of time to deal with
special issues or topics. Sub-committees are not subject to the
Brown Act if they include less than a quorum of the Committee.
However, meetings should be open to the public in an accessible
location and, at a minimum, be noticed on a website, listed on the
regular group agenda or announced at a regular AAC meeting.
III. MEETINGS
301. Regular Meetings
-
4
Regular meetings of the Committee shall be held monthly, or as
scheduled by the Committee. A calendar scheduling the next 12
month’s meetings shall be presented and adopted at the last meeting
of each year.
302. Special Meetings
Special meetings for good cause may be held by the Committee on
call of its Chairperson, which call shall be filed with the
Airports Deputy Director. The manner of the call shall be noted in
the minutes of the special meeting, and at least a twenty-four (24)
hour notice of the meeting shall be given to each member.
303. Public Meetings and Study Sessions
All meetings and study sessions of the Committee shall be open
to the public. Any action calling for a formal vote shall take
place only at a public meeting.
304. Quorum
A quorum necessary for the transaction of business shall consist
of a majority of the filled seats of the Committee. The business of
the Committee shall be transacted by the majority vote of members
present.
305. Absence of Chairperson and Vice Chairperson
In the absence of the Chairperson and Vice Chairperson, a senior
Committee member, defined as the member with the most time serving
on the committee, may convene the meeting if a quorum is
present.
306. Member Attendance
If any member of the Committee is absent from four (4) scheduled
meetings in the previous 12 months, his/her office shall be
automatically vacated. Excused absences are exempted from this
provision. The Mayor will be the final authority in determining
whether or not an absence is excused. Should a position be vacated
by this section, the Committee Chairperson, in consultation with
the Airports Deputy Director, shall then determine a list of
eligible candidates to recommend to the mayor, and the Mayor shall
nominate and appoint a new member, contingent upon the nominee’s
confirmation by the City Council.
307. Agenda Items
-
5
Items will be placed on the agenda by the Airports Deputy
Director and/or the Chairperson.
309. Abstention
Any member who believes participating in discussion or voting on
cases coming before the Committee could give the appearance to the
general public of a Conflict of Interest may voluntarily abstain
from participating in discussion or voting.
IV. OFFICIAL RECORDS
401. Definition
The official records shall include the Airports section of the
San Diego Municipal Code, as amended, these bylaws and the minutes
of the Committee meetings together with all findings, maps, and
other official statements.
402. Recording of Vote
The minutes shall show the vote on every question on which the
Committee acts. Any statement any member may wish to make regarding
his vote will be recorded upon his request.
403. Retention of Files
All matters coming before the Committee shall be filed in the
Airports Administration Office in accordance with that department’s
general file system for the period of time, as dictated the City’s
Municipal Code, Administrative Regulations and Council Policy.
404. Public Record
All of the records of the Committee shall be public records and
shall be open for public inspection during customary working hours.
Copies may be obtained for established fees.
V. RULES AND AMENDMENTS
501. Bylaws
Bylaws shall be developed by the Committee.
-
6
502. Amendment Procedure
Amendments to the bylaws may be recommended by the Committee
upon the affirmative vote of a majority of members, provided any
such amendment is proposed at a preceding meeting or is submitted
in writing at a prior, regular meeting of the Committee and is
noted in the minutes of such meeting. Amendments recommended by the
Committee shall become effective majority vote of Committee
members.
503. Copy of Rules and Regulations
A certified copy of these rules and any amendments thereto shall
be placed on record in the Airports Administration Office.
504. Robert’s Rules of Order
If a question of parliamentary procedure arises, it shall be
decided upon the basis of Robert’s Rules of Parliamentary
Procedure, unless otherwise specified in these bylaws of the
Committee.
505. Interpretation and Conflict
In the event that any Airports Advisory Committee bylaw shall be
at variance with any State Statute or any ordinance or resolution
of the City, the statute, ordinance, or resolution shall prevail.
These bylaws are intended only to supplement such ordinance and
resolutions and may not amend, invalidate, or abrogate any
ordinance or resolution of the City.
_______________________________________ ________________________
Chairperson, Airports Advisory Committee DATE
-
Monthly Airport Operations Report
Flight Operations (Month) Dec-20 Dec-19 % Diff Based A/C
48323,247 20,466 13.6%
Flight Operations (CY) 2020 YTD 2019 YTD % Diff276,208 253,090
9.1%
Total OperationsFlight Operations (FY) FY21 YTD FY20 YTD % Diff
10-Year History
158,421 133,391 18.8% 2020 276,208 2019 253,090
Operations Office Revenue FY21 YTD FY20 YTD % Diff 2018 226,588
Landing Fees $4,817.00 $6,603.00 -27.0% 2017 207,103 Transient A/C
Parking $6,933.00 $8,874.00 -21.9% 2016 200,676 Monthly A/C
Parking* $185,553.17 $279,974.07 -33.7% 2015 216,295 Vehicle
Parking $1,379.00 $3,199.00 -56.9% 2014 215,114 Conference Room
$0.00 $166.00 -100.0% 2013 186,192 Other $1,920.00 $2,462.00 -22.0%
2012 182,455 Total $200,602.17 $301,278.07 -33.4% 2011 193,341 *
Revenue increase reflects acquisition of Lot A-8 Hangar
inventory
Flight Operations (Month) Dec-20 Dec-19 % Diff Based A/C
1578,787 5,777 52.1%
Flight Operations (CY) 2020 YTD 2019 YTD % Diff Total
Operations100,462 86,358 16.3% 10-Year History
2020 100,462 Flight Operations (FY) FY21 YTD FY20 YTD % Diff
2019 86,358
58,193 43,919 32.5% 2018 78,916 2017 77,355
Operations Office Revenue FY21 YTD FY20 YTD % Diff 2016 86,027
Landing Fees $16,608.00 $8,998.00 84.6% 2015 93,529 Transient A/C
Parking $1,766.00 $2,375.00 -25.6% 2014 90,266 Vehicle Parking
$4,722.00 $4,676.00 1.0% 2013 89,707 Other $400.00 $608.00 -34.2%
2012 92,043 Total $23,496.00 $16,657.00 41.1% 2011 101,117
December 2020
MONTGOMERY-GIBBS EXECUTIVE AIRPORT
BROWN FIELD MUNICIPAL AIRPORT
-
Monthly Airport Operations Report
Flight Operations (Month) Nov-20 Nov-19 % Diff Based A/C
48325,508 20,083 27.0%
Flight Operations (CY) 2020 YTD 2019 YTD % Diff252,958 225,628
12.1%
Total OperationsFlight Operations (FY) FY21 YTD FY20 YTD % Diff
10-Year History
135,174 112,925 19.7% 2019 253,090 2018 226,588
Operations Office Revenue FY21 YTD FY20 YTD % Diff 2017 207,103
Landing Fees $3,917.00 $5,793.00 -32.4% 2016 200,676 Transient A/C
Parking $5,923.00 $7,808.00 -24.1% 2015 216,295 Monthly A/C
Parking* $150,376.21 $98,152.56 53.2% 2014 215,114 Vehicle Parking
$1,182.00 $2,914.00 -59.4% 2013 186,192 Conference Room $0.00
$166.00 -100.0% 2012 182,455 Other $1,870.00 $2,387.00 -21.7% 2011
193,341 Total $163,268.21 $117,220.56 39.3% 2010 185,506 * Revenue
increase reflects acquisition of Lot A-8 Hangar inventory
Flight Operations (Month) Nov-20 Nov-19 % Diff Based A/C
1578,915 6,887 29.4%
Flight Operations (CY) 2020 YTD 2019 YTD % Diff Total
Operations91,675 80,581 13.8% 10-Year History
2019 86,358 Flight Operations (FY) FY21 YTD FY20 YTD % Diff 2018
78,916
49,406 38,142 29.5% 2017 77,355 2016 86,027
Operations Office Revenue FY21 YTD FY20 YTD % Diff 2015 93,529
Landing Fees $13,719.00 $7,219.00 90.0% 2014 90,266 Transient A/C
Parking $1,720.00 $2,042.00 -15.8% 2013 89,707 Vehicle Parking
$4,422.00 $3,527.00 25.4% 2012 92,043 Other $400.00 $608.00 -34.2%
2011 101,117 Total $20,261.00 $13,396.00 51.2% 2010 91,025
November 2020
MONTGOMERY-GIBBS EXECUTIVE AIRPORT
BROWN FIELD MUNICIPAL AIRPORT
-
2020 Annual Noise Report
Montgomery Gibbs Executive & Brown Field Airports
Complaints Households Complaints Households
Annual Totals 301 53 Annual Totals 67 20
Community Complaints Households Community Complaints
Households
Allied Gardens 11 5 Otay Mesa 73 17
Bay Park 1 1 Chula Vista 2 2
City Heights 2 2 Imperial Beach 1 1
Clairemont 108 41
Clairemont Mesa
East 1 1
Del Cerro 1 1
Del Mar 155 2
Encinitas 1 1
Hillcrest 1 1
Kearny Mesa 1 1
La Jolla 3 3
Mission Beach 1 1
North Park 2 2
Pacific Beach 2 2
Serra Mesa 7 7
Sorrento Valley 1 1
Tierrasanta 3 3
A/C Type A/C Type
Piston Prop 264 50 Piston Prop 0 0
Helicopter 28 23 Helicopter 0 0
Turboprop 2 2 Turboprop 0 0
Jet 5 5 Jet 0 0
Jet (Mil) 0 0 Jet (Mil) 74 21
Helicopter (Mil) 2 2 Helicopter (Mil) 0 0
Cause Cause
Loud 94 44 Loud 134 38
Low 3 3 Noise 2 2
Noise 62 26
Helicopter 22 2
Other 1 1
Overflight 133 6
Time of Day Time of Day
0630 - 2330 158 11 0630 - 2330 4 2
2330 - 0630 157 71 2330 - 0630 72 20
Day 5
Night 29
Fines $2,400.00
Montgomery Gibbs Executive Brown Field
Violations Violations
Brown Field Municipal Airport
does not have noise limits
restricted by legislation
-
Quarterly Aircraft Noise Report
October-December 2020
Month Complaints Households
October 26 7 Day 0
November 14 4 Night 4
December 8 5 Fines $950.00
Total (Q4) 48 16
Year to date 365 53
Community Complaints Households Cause Complaints Households
Clairemont 9 7 Loud 42 12
Serra Mesa 1 1 Helicopter 2 2
Allied Gardens 6 3 Low 2 1
Del Mar 28 1 Other 2 1
Del Cerro 1 1
Clairemont
Mesa East 1 1 A/C Type
La Jolla 1 1 Piston Prop 45 14
Pacific Beach 1 1 Helicopter 2 1
Turboprop 1 1
Time of Day Jet 0 0
0630 - 2330 33 12 Jet (Mil) 0 0
2330 - 0630 15 4 Helicopter (Mil) 0 0
Month Complaints Households
October 0 0
November 0 0
December 0 0
Total (Q4) 0 0
Year to Date 67 20
Community Complaints Households Cause Complaints Households
Otay Mesa 0 0 Loud 0 0
Chula Vista 0 0 Noise 0 0
Imperial Beach 0 0 Overflight 0 0
Time of Day A/C Type
0630 - 2330 0 0 Piston Prop 0 0
2330 - 0630 0 0 Helicopter 0 0
Turboprop 0 0
Jet 0 0
Jet (Mil) 0 0
Helicopter (Mil) 0 0
8,915
Brown Field Municipal Airport
does not have noise limits
restricted by legislation
27,150
54,300 1 household - 0% of complaints
Aircraft Operations
8,787
Noise Complaints Detail
9,448
Violations
MONTGOMERY-GIBBS EXECUTIVE AIRPORT
Aircraft Operations Violations
28,569
25,508
23,247
77,324
154,648 1 household - 33% of complaints
Noise Complaints Detail
BROWN FIELD MUNICIPAL AIRPORT
AAC AGENDA & MEETING PACKET JAN 12 2021.pdfAAC AGENDA 2021
January 12, 2021
Draft AAC Minutes November 10 2020 DRDRAFT MINUTES1. CALL TO
ORDER3. NON-AGENDA PUBLIC COMMENTMr. Turner stated that engine
runups are noisy, dangerous, and against City code in hangar areas.
He suggested they should be permitted if the operator is aiming at
their own hangar otherwise, they should use designated run-up
areas. Mr. Turner sugges...Mr. Rubio responded the Airport agrees
with the public comment regarding the engine run-ups and will
include the language in the Newsletter to address this item. Mr.
Rubio requested for Mr. Ryan to address the public comment
regarding the helicopter r...4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES6. NEW
BUSINESSA. Adoption of Airports Advisory Committee Meeting Calendar
for Calendar year 2021.Mr. Rubio stated there is no public
comment.Mr. Gordon made a motion to approve the 2021 Calendar and
Mr. Martindell seconded the motion, passed unanimously.B. Proposed
Airports Division Business Plan PresentationMr. Rubio started there
is not public comment.Mr. Rubio gave Airports Division Business
Plan for FY 2021 presentation.Mr. Martindell inquired about the
national comparison as to the Current Ratio for the airports. Mr.
Rubio responded our airports are pioneers in this area as not many
other airports show this number in their financial statements.Mr.
Rubio stated the Master Plan is to be completed by early 2022.Mr.
Gordon inquired about the Annual Contracted Services amount. Mr.
Riego responded there are other contractual services included such
as Security and Janitorial services, along with various supplies
for the airports needs and that he will provide ...Mr. Ricotta
Inquired about the significant increase in revenue. Mr. Riego
responded most of it is from the leases of properties, lease
appraisals and airports efficiencies.9. OPERATIONS AND AIRCRAFT
NOISE REPORTNone10. COMMITTEE COMMENTSNone11. ADJOURNMENTThe
meeting adjourned at 4:31 PM.Next meeting will be held January
12th, 2021Respectfully,
AAC AGENDA & MEETING PACKET JAN 12 2021BYLAWS AMENDED v3
2019.04.09-WRAirport Operations Report December 2020 -
FinalSheet1
Airport Operations Report November 2020 - DraftSheet1
Annual Noise Report 2020Quarterly Noise Report- Q4 2020
