Upload
vancong
View
216
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
October 10-12, 2006 Washington, D.C.
Government Summit 2006
Balanced Scorecard Collaborative/Palladium • 55 Old Bedford Road • Lincoln, MA 01773 • Tel: 781.259.3737 • Fax: 781.259.3389 • bscol.com
Aligning Agency Resources to Drive Performance
Dennis RichardsonChief Executive Officer
Maria CristalliChief Strategy and Quality OfficerHillside Family of Agencies
Presentation Highlights• Hillside Family of Agencies Overview• Organizational alignment to the strategy using the
Balanced Scorecard• Key Results to Date• Lessons Learned
Hillside Family of Agencies• Founded as an orphanage in 1837• Rochester, NY-based organization is
an umbrella organization that provides administrative and business support to six service affiliates• Four affiliates offer services to
youth and families• Two affiliates provide investment
and fundraising support
Hillside Family of Agencies• Offer more than 120 services across
24 counties in Central and Western NY
• FY 2007 budget of $105 million • Approximately 2,000 staff
Strategic Intent
To be the nationally recognized leader and preferred provider of an integrated system of care for children, youth, parents, and families.
Shifts required to realize our Strategic Intent• Fragmented to systematized services • Decentralized, non-standard business
support processes to centralized administrative functions to create economies of scale
Commitment to change, alignment to strategy
• Agree upon Strategic Intent • Select the Balanced Scorecard to
articulate and execute strategy• Initial implementation – significant
shortcomings with ownership and buy-in
5 Key Principles of Strategy-Focused Organizations
TranslateStrategy
Everyone’s Job
OrganizationAlignment
Translate Strategy
Executive LeadershipExecutive
Leadership
Continual Process
Organization Alignment
Everyone’s Job
Continual Process
2
3
4
5
1
Mobilize Change through Executive Leadership• Balanced Scorecard Development –
Early 2002 • CEO ownership• Core team facilitated the 6 step
development process (Office of Strategy Management)
• Executive Team and Board of Governors engaged
• Clear expectations and accountability
Translate the Strategy to Operational Terms• Developed a strategic architecture • Constructed a strategy map with 19
strategic objectives, 32 strategic measures, and 8 strategic initiatives
• Established annual and stretch targets • Aligned initiatives with strategic
objectives
Strategic Architecture, 3 Key Themes• Service Innovation – create the
System of Care• Operational Efficiency – the use of
effective, standardized work processes
• Customer Intimacy – involve youth, families, and Strategic Partners
Internal Work Processes
Customer- Youth and Families/Strategic Partners
Learning and Growth
Financial
To be the nationally recognized leader and preferred provider of an integrated system of care for children, youth, parents, and families.
F1. Develop new and existing revenue streams F2. Achieve
profitable growth that builds system of care.
W3. Provide care coordinator to manage
relationships.
C1. Youth and families are involved in services.
L4. Retain highly skilled, culturally competent, diverse,
productive staff
L2. Develop a cultureof inclusion that embraces system of care principles
L5. Develop leaders at all levels with management
skills to deliver “system of care”services
L3. Standardize Information Systems
across HFA
W1. Manage internal access to
services
L1. Include youth and familiesas partners in development
of org and staff.
W2. Effectively execute quality services.
S1. HFA’s system of care is validated by the
outcomes produced.Stakeholder
W5. Develop effective service models
W6. Develop service model marketing
strategies.
Operational EfficiencyCustomer Intimacy Service Innovation
S2. HFA is the mosttrusted brand in communities
we serve.
C2. HFA is the preferred provider of services for
youth and families.
W4. Build HFA’s system of care service array.
HFA SOC BSC FY05-06 revised, 6.21.05
Balanced Scorecard Implementation
• Defined and communicated the Hillside Family of Agencies’ strategy
• Balanced Scorecard was rolled out in July 2002
• Broad acceptance of the strategic direction across the business and shared service units
Align the Organization to the Strategy• Developed a common Balanced
Scorecard reporting tool• Focused on 8 key strategic initiatives• Constructed a two year plan to align
the organization to the strategy• Involved Boards of Directors for
each business unit
Align the Organization to the Strategy
• Aligned 6 business and 6 shared service units to the HFA Balanced Scorecard
• Selected a hybrid model for cascading process
• Selected and trained core teams to facilitate each process
• Balanced Scorecards are presented to the Executive Team for final approval
Organizational Alignment HFA SOC Balanced Scorecard
Affiliate Balanced Scorecard
The Executive Team defines HFA System of Care priorities to achieve our Strategic Intent using the Balanced Scorecard.
The Executive Team defines HFA System of Care priorities to achieve our Strategic Intent using the Balanced Scorecard.
Affiliate Balanced Scorecard
Affiliate Balanced Scorecards are the centers of direct value creation that support the achievement of HFA System of Care priorities.
Affiliate Balanced Scorecards are the centers of direct value creation that support the achievement of HFA System of Care priorities.
Motivate to Make Strategy Everyone’s Job• Educated staff about Hillside’s Shared
Vision and Strategic Intent • System of Care training was cascaded
across the organization• Personal scorecards for the Executive
Team members are in place• Piloted an incentive compensation
program
Govern to Make Strategy a Continual Process
• The Balanced Scorecard is the focus of bi-monthly Executive Team meetings
• Annual refresh process combines customer feedback, competitive analysis, and evaluation of strategic performance to drive Balanced Scorecard changes
• Strategy and budgeting are linked to maximize resources
Office of Strategic Management
Functions include:• Strategy Development • Planning • Organizational alignment• Balanced Scorecard management• Strategic Initiative project management• Six Sigma quality coaching
Align short-term CQI plans
Strategic Management
Evaluate progress
Implement and communicate Refresh
Strategy
Overall Strategic Planning ProcessExternal trends Competitive Analysis Market Research
Key Results – Customer Intimacy Theme
• % parent and youth seats filled on specific workgroups and boards has doubled from 2002 to 2006
• Parent involvement in service planning has hit or exceeded targets for nine quarters
• Performance on the Customer Satisfaction Index has exceeded targets for three quarters
Key Results – Operational Efficiency• Centralized administrative costs have
yielded big cost savings – 25% decrease in overhead costs for Crestwood Children’s Center in one year
• Cycle time from referral to service initiation has decreased 56%, falling from an average of 6.2 weeks to 2.7 weeks
• The number of standardized work processes in shared service units continues to grow, 6 key processes were completed during FY 2006
• Standardized Information Systems that drive our organization, 27% decrease in non-standard systems
Hillside Family of Agencies, Revenue by Fiscal Year
10000
20000
30000
40000
50000
60000
70000
80000
90000
100000
110000
1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
HFA B alancedScorecard imp lement ed
Revenue Growth for Hillside Famiy of Agencies Fiscal 1990 through Fiscal 2006
F1.1. % of revenues from discrete services less than 3 years old.F1.1. % of Revenues from Discrete Services <3 Years Old
FY 03 - FY 06
12.1% 12.3%14.7%
13.1% 11.9% 12.6%
8.1%6.2%
11.3%8.7%
12.5%13.9%
23.6%21.5%
23.8%26.4%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
Q1 02-03
Q2 02-03
Q3 02-03
Q4 02-03
Q1 03-04
Q2 03-04
Q3 03-04
Q4 03-04
Q1 04-05
Q2 04-05
Q3 04-05
Q4 04-05
Q1 05-06
Q2 05-06
Q3 05-06
Q4 05-06
Actual
Target = 11%
Note: This measure has exceeded our target for six consecutive quarters.
Hillside Family of Agencies, New Revenue Streams
Hillside Family of Agencies, Market share.
F1.2 Market Share FY03 - FY06
8.14% 7.94% 7.84%
8.93%
7.00%
7.50%
8.00%
8.50%
9.00%
9.50%
FY03 FY04 FY05 FY06
Actual Market Share Annual Targets
F2.1. # affiliates with problematic bottom line budget variances.F2.1. Number of Affiliates with Problematic Budget Variances
FY 03- FY 06
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Q102-03
Q202-03
Q302-03
Q402-03
Q103-04
Q203-04
Q303-04
Q403-04
Q104-05
Q204-05
Q304-05
Q404-05
Q105-06
Q205-06
Q305-06
Q405-06
Note: This measure met our target for four consecutive quarters.
Hillside Family of Agencies, Budget Variances
Partnership Subsidies FY 03 - FY 06
6
3
10
01234567
FY03 FY04 FY05 FY06
Hillside Family of Agencies, Partnership Subsidies
Hillside Family of Agencies, Three Year Revenue Growth to Target
3-Year Average Revenue Growth vs. Quarterly Revenue Growth (Non-Investment Income)
10.8%14.2%
29.70%
47.50%
40.30%
34.80%
62.30%
48.60%
14.9%
20%
12.20%16.70%
22.0%
16.4%
26.8%
16.2%16.2%
21.5%19.8% 20.3%
18.4% 17.8% 17.3% 17.2% 16.7% 18.2%20.6%
22.6% 23.3%
27.1%29.3%
17.0%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
40%
45%
50%
55%
60%
65%
70%
Q103 Q203 Q303 Q403 Q104 Q204 Q304 Q404 Q105 Q205 Q305 Q405 Q106 Q206 Q306 Q406
Quarterly values3 year growth to target
Key Results – Stakeholder Perspective
• Youth discharged from Hillside services between July 1, 2002 – June 30, 2004:• Family permanency: 64% • Not living in a mental health facility:
97%• Not in jail or detention: 96%• CAFAS improvement by 20 points
or greater at discharge: 61% • For Hillside Work-Scholarship
Connection students, high school graduation rates have tripled
Key Results – Stakeholder Perspective• Donor loyalty – % repeat donations to
Hillside has met or exceeded targets for the past 4 quarters
• Brand Strength of Hillside Family of Agencies is very strong among Strategic Partners (Departments of Social Services, Office of Mental Health and school districts in Western and Central New York)