Upload
piers-park
View
216
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
ALTRUISMAn attempt to overcome some problems with Hobbes
Task
Complete the task on the sheet
This activity forces us to consider what would happen if everyone behaved in a certain way
What becomes clear is that everyone’s behaving self-interestedly means they are all worse off
On this basis it has been argued that those of us who develop dispositions to altruism are going to be better off than those who remain short-sightedly self-serving in their behaviour
What This Means So with time we will all internalise the need
for cooperative behaviour and thus willingly contract into moral behaviour without the need to be coerced by authority
On this account we can imagine human beings having genuinely altruistic motives, while at the same time the existence of such motives can be explained in terms of what best serves their individual as well as collective interest
Do You Agree?
Do you agree with this?
What effect, if any does it have on social contract theory?
Altruism Is In Our Genes There is an alternative approach that has
developed from the perspective of evolutionary biology
Altruistic behaviour amongst modern humans may be explained because it leads to greater evolutionary success
In other words, if strong altruistic instincts in an animal lead to its having more offspring than lack those instincts, then such interests are evolutionarily beneficial
Evolution and Altruism
Such animals, of course, never chose to be moral
There was never a conventional agreement struck in the understanding that this would be mutually advantageous
But the fact that it is mutually advantageous to behave morally means that the genes which tend to produce such behaviour will survive
So...
So modern humans may well have genuinely altruistic motives which are hard wired precisely because this is an effective survival strategy, and those of our ancestors who were not so moral have died out
Discussion
Do you think altruism is beneficial for the development of humans?
Can you see any problems with this?
Criticism Morality involves adopting an impartial
perspective: Any account of moral behaviour that explains why it
is advantageous can still be accused of failing to understand what morality is really about
Morality necessarily involves taking an impartial perspective on matters
Even if it turns out that moral behaviour is to my and others advantage, this is not what makes it moral
Rather it is moral precisely to the extent that it is unconcerned with serving the advantage of any party, or, because moral behaviour is good in-itself, irrespective any agreements made or advantages sought
Continued Criticism
Moral principles are applicable universally, to all persons equally
This means that in order to discover them we have to adopt a point of view which is impersonal, from which we can consider all interested parties equally, rather than from the narrow perspective of self-interest
Recap of Rawls
A more recent version of the contract approach to ethics comes from John Rawls
The key problem with Hobbes’ approach is that individuals will not enter into negotiation over a contract on equal footing, meaning that in the state of nature those who are stronger are going to gain advantages over the others
Can Rawls Overcome This Problem?
Unlike Hobbes, for Rawls it is essential to a just social arrangement that each of us should be free from fear or having their rights violated and so, even if I happen to be in a minority, the majority cannot act in a way which benefits them at my expense
To ensure that we come up with a system of rules which doesn’t unfairly benefit anyone, Rawls reckons the contract needs to be negotiated from a position of equality
How Do We Do This?
The position from which we must negotiate the rules by which civil society is going to be organised must be one in which we are unaware of the place in society we are going to hold
In Rawls’ words we must negotiate from behind a ‘veil of ignorance’ which ensures our impartiality
This approach sees moral reasoning as intrinsically to do with adopting an impartial perspective and emphasises the importance of fairness