12
!"#$%&’( *%’+& ,$-.+/ 0 !+$($1.+2 3 4( 5(6&#7$8&#(1&(6’- ,&#2%&+6.8& 4(’-/2.2 !"#$%&"’%# )*#+%,%,%-%# . 9:& !"#$%&’( +.8.- 2%’+& %#$7#’1 ;$#12 6:& 2&+$(< -’#7&26 2%’+& &(<&’8$#= 2"#%’22&< $(-/ >/ 6:& ?(.6&< *6’6&2@ 9:& !"#$%&’( 2%’+& %#$7#’1 .2 "(.A"& .( 6:’6 ’>$"6 6B$C6:.#<2 $; 6:& 6$6’- &D%&(<.6"#& .2 +:’((&-&< 6:#$"7: ’( .(6&#7$8&#(1&(6’- $#7’(.E’6.$(= 6:& !"#$%&’( *%’+& 47&(+/ F!*4G 6:’6 :’2 ($ ;$#1’- $#7’(.+ -.(H B.6: 6:& !"#$%&’( I$11"(.6/ F!IG@ 5( ’<<.6.$(= 2&8&#’- -&’<.(7 !"#$%&’( (’6.$(2 2"+: ’2 J#.6’.(= K#’(+&= L&#1’(/ ’(< 56’-/ :’8& 6:&.# $B( (’6.$(’- 2%’+& ’7&(+.&2 ’(< %#$7#’12@ *.7(.;.+’(6-/= $( M’/ NN= NOOP 6:& ;$"#6: !"#$%&’( *%’+& I$"(+.- ’<$%6&< 6:& ;.#26 !"#$%&’( *%’+& ,$-.+/ F!*,G <#’;6&< >/ 6:& 6B&(6/C(.(& 1&1>&# +$"(6#.&2 $; !"#$%& 6$ .(6&7#’6& 6:& ’%%#$’+: $; !*4 ’(< !"#$%&’( ?(.$( F!?G 1&1>&# 26’6&2@ 9:& %#.1’#/ $>Q&+6.8& $; !*, .2 6$ >&66&# +$$#<.(’6& !"#$%&R2 2%’+& &;;$#62 6$ >#.(7 2"26’.(’>-& >&(&;.62 6$ .62 +.6.E&(2 >/ 7"’#’(6&&.(7 ;"-- ’(< "(#&26#.+6&< ’++&22 6$ 2&#8.+&2 %#$8.<&< >/ 2%’+& 2/26&12= ’<8’(+& 2%’+& &D%-$#’6.$( ’(< %#$1$6.$( $; .(6&#(’6.$(’- +$$%&#’6.$(@ 9:.2 %’%&# %#&2&(62 ’( ’(’-/2.2 $; 6:& &1&#7.(7 !*, $( 6:& !"#$%&’( 2%’+& %#$7#’12 ’(< #&-’6&< &+$($1.+2@ 9:& ’.1 $; 6:& %’%&# .2 6$ <.2+"22 6:& $8&#’-- 2%’+& %$-.+/= 2+.&(6.;.+ ’(< &+$($1.+ ’2%&+62 $; !"#$%&’( %#$7#’12@ 4 26"</ $; 6:& !"#$%&’( .(6&#7$8&#(1&(6’- %&#2%&+6.8& .2 $; 7#&’6 8’-"& ;$# ’(/ ;"6"#& 7-$>’- 2%’+& 26#’6&7/ ’(< 1.22.$(2 2"+: ’2 !’#6: $>2&#8’6.$( +$(26&--’6.$( ;$# +-.1’6& +:’(7& 1$(.6$#.(7 ’(< &D%-$#’6.$( $; 426&#$.<2= M$$(= M’#2 ’(< >&/$(<@ 5S9TUV?I95US /,01"%# 23435 ’1%2" "660,&’ 20#’3’&’ 06 &7" #%&30#%5 ’1%2" %8"#23"’ 06 9%#: 5"%+3#8 ;*,01"%# /#30# <;/= 20*#&,3"’ %#+ &7" ;*,01"%# )1%2" >8"#2: <;)>=? &7%& @%’ 60,9"+ 3# .ABC D: &7" 9",8", 06 &7" ;*,01"%# )1%2" E"’"%,27 F,8%#3G%&30# <;)EF= %#+ &7" ;*,01"%# H%*#27", I"4"5019"#& F,8%#3G%&30# <;HIF=J K# %++3&30#? &7" ;*,01"%# F,8%#3G%&30# 60, &7" ;L1503&%&30# 06 M"&"0,050832%5 )%&"553&"’ <;/M;N)>N= 3’ 3# 27%,8" 06 1,043+3#8 ’%&"553&" +%&% %#+ 1,0+*2&’ &0 3&’ 9"9D", ’&%&"’ 60, 01",%&30#%5 9"&"0,0508: %#+ 2539%&" 90#3&0,3#8J N7" 20990# %39 06 &7" ;*,01"%# O099*#3&: <;O= %#+ ;)> 3’ &0 ’&,"#8&7"# ;*,01" %#+ D"#"63& 3&’ 23&3G"#’ &7,0*87 ’23"#&3632 ,"’"%,27 %#+ 1,08,%9’ *&353G3#8 &7" ’1%2" ’"2&0, 2%1%D353&3"’ %#+ %3+ 3# %273"43#8 &7" 0D-"2&34"’ 06 &7" O0990# P0,"38# %#+ )"2*,3&: Q0532: <OP)Q= 06 &7" ;*,01"%# /#30#J . ; K# RSSB? &7" ;*,01"%# )1%2" >8"#2: <;)>= %220*#&’ 60, %D0*& &@0T&73,+’ 06 %# "’&39%&"+ UCJC V35530# ;*,01"%# 23435 ’1%2" %2&343&3"’J ;)> 15%2"’ 3#+*’&,3%5 20#&,%2&’ 3# 1,010,&30# &0 "%27 M"9D", )&%&"W’ 20#&,3D*&30#J N7" M"9D", )&%&"’ 20#&,3D*&" &0 ;)>W’ M%#+%&0,: %2&343&3"’ <’1%2" ’23"#2" 1,08,%9’ %#+ 8"#",%5 D*+8"&= 3# %220,+%#2" @3&7 &7"3, 20*#&,:W’ 8,0’’ +09"’&32 1,0+*2& <XIQ=J V*&? "%27 M"9D", )&%&" +"23+"’ @7327 F1&30#%5 1,08,%9 &7": @3’7 &0 1%,&3231%&" %#+ 8%3# 8"08,%1732 3#+*’&,3%5 ,"&*,# %220,+3#85:J )09"&39"’? &73’ 7%’ 15%2"+ 20#’&,%3#&’ 0# 01&39%5 *&353G%&30# 06 ’1%2" ,"’0*,2"’J E"2"#& ;)> O0*#235 +"23’30#’ 7%4" D""# 3#2,"%’3#85: 65"L3D5" &0 &7" 8"08,%1732 ,"&*,# ,*5"’J R X34"# &7" 6,%89"#&"+ #%&*," 06 &7" ;*,01"%# ’1%2" ’"2&0,? ;)>W’ ,05" %’ % 53%3’0# @3&7 4%,30*’ #%&30#%5 ’1%2" %8"#23"’ %#+ ;/ 3’ 06 1%,%90*#& 3910,&%#2"J N7" ;OT;)> P,%9"@0,$ >8,""9"#& ’38#"+ D: &7" ;*,01"%# O0*#235 0# F2&0D", B? RSSY %#+ %+01&"+ ’3#2" RSSZ 60,9’ &7" D%’3’ 60, 2001",%&30# 3# +"4"5013#8 20990# 105323"’? %403+ +*1532%&30# D"&@""# #%&30#%5 %#+ ;*,01"%# ’1%2" "660,&’ %#+ 602*’ 0# &7" "9",83#8 850D%5 ’1%2" 9%,$"& 27%55"#8"’J Y N7" +"4"5019"#& 06 % &,*5: ;*,01"%# )1%2" Q0532: @%’ ,"208#3G"+ %’ % ’&,%&"832 27032" 60, ;*,01" 36 3& 3#&"#+’ &0 D" % 9%-0, 850D%5 ’1%2" 15%:", %#+ 20#’"[*"#&5: %6&", 066323%5 20#’*5&%&30# *#+", &7" %"83’ 06 &7" ;*,01"%# O0993’’30#? % X,""# Q%1", %#+ % \73&" 1%1", <%2&30# 15%#= @"," ,"5"%’"+ 3# RSSY %,&32*5%&3#8 &7" #""+ %#+ 1*,10’" 60, % 200,+3#%&"+ ;*,01"%# )1%2" Q0532: &7%& 3’ +"9%#+ +,34"# %#+ ’*110,&3#8 06 ;/ 105323"’J Z . )"#30, M"9D",? >K>> >9",32%# K#’&3&*&" 06 >",0#%*&32’ %#+ >’&,0#%*&32’ . AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition 9 - 11 September 2008, San Diego, California AIAA 2008-7717 Copyright © 2008 by Venkatesan Sundararajan. Published by the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Inc., with permission.

[American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - San Diego, California ()] AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - European Space Policy

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: [American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - San Diego, California ()] AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - European Space Policy

!"#$%&'()*%'+&),$-.+/)0)!+$($1.+2)3)4()

5(6&#7$8&#(1&(6'-),&#2%&+6.8&)4('-/2.2

!"#$%&"'%#()*#+%,%,%-%#.

9:&)!"#$%&'()+.8.-)2%'+&)%#$7#'1);$#12)6:&)2&+$(<)-'#7&26)2%'+&)&(<&'8$#=)2"#%'22&<)$(-/)>/)6:&)

?(.6&<)*6'6&2@)9:&)!"#$%&'()2%'+&)%#$7#'1).2)"(.A"&).()6:'6)'>$"6)6B$C6:.#<2)$;)6:&)6$6'-)&D%&(<.6"#&)

.2)+:'((&-&<)6:#$"7:)'().(6&#7$8&#(1&(6'-)$#7'(.E'6.$(=)6:&)!"#$%&'()*%'+&)47&(+/)F!*4G)6:'6):'2)

($);$#1'-)$#7'(.+)-.(H)B.6:)6:&)!"#$%&'()I$11"(.6/)F!IG@)5()'<<.6.$(=)2&8&#'-)-&'<.(7)!"#$%&'()

('6.$(2 ) 2"+: ) '2 )J#.6'.(= )K#'(+&= )L&#1'(/ )'(< ) 56'-/ ):'8& ) 6:&.# ) $B( )('6.$('- ) 2%'+& ) '7&(+.&2 ) '(<)

%#$7#'12@ ) *.7(.;.+'(6-/= ) $( )M'/ ) NN= ) NOOP ) 6:& ) ;$"#6: )!"#$%&'( ) *%'+& )I$"(+.- ) '<$%6&< ) 6:& ) ;.#26)

!"#$%&'()*%'+&),$-.+/)F!*,G)<#';6&<)>/)6:&)6B&(6/C(.(&)1&1>&#)+$"(6#.&2)$;)!"#$%&)6$).(6&7#'6&)6:&)

'%%#$'+:)$;)!*4)'(<)!"#$%&'()?(.$()F!?G)1&1>&#)26'6&2@)9:&)%#.1'#/)$>Q&+6.8&)$;)!*,).2)6$)>&66&#)

+$$#<.('6&)!"#$%&R2)2%'+&)&;;$#62)6$)>#.(7)2"26'.('>-&)>&(&;.62)6$).62)+.6.E&(2)>/)7"'#'(6&&.(7);"--)'(<)

"(#&26#.+6&<)'++&22)6$)2&#8.+&2)%#$8.<&<)>/)2%'+&)2/26&12=)'<8'(+&)2%'+&)&D%-$#'6.$()'(<)%#$1$6.$()$;)

.(6&#('6.$('-)+$$%&#'6.$(@

9:.2)%'%&#)%#&2&(62)'()'('-/2.2)$;)6:&)&1&#7.(7)!*,)$()6:&)!"#$%&'()2%'+&)%#$7#'12)'(<)#&-'6&<)

&+$($1.+2@)9:&)'.1)$;)6:&)%'%&#).2)6$)<.2+"22)6:&)$8&#'--)2%'+&)%$-.+/=)2+.&(6.;.+)'(<)&+$($1.+)'2%&+62)$;)

!"#$%&'()%#$7#'12@)4)26"</)$;)6:&)!"#$%&'().(6&#7$8&#(1&(6'-)%&#2%&+6.8&).2)$;)7#&'6)8'-"&);$#)'(/)

;"6"#&)7-$>'-)2%'+&)26#'6&7/)'(<)1.22.$(2)2"+:)'2)!'#6:)$>2&#8'6.$()+$(26&--'6.$();$#)+-.1'6&)+:'(7&)

1$(.6$#.(7)'(<)&D%-$#'6.$()$;)426&#$.<2=)M$$(=)M'#2)'(<)>&/$(<@)

5S9TUV?I95US

/,01"%#(23435('1%2"("660,&'(20#'3'&'(06(&7"(#%&30#%5('1%2"(%8"#23"'(06(9%#:(5"%+3#8(;*,01"%#(/#30#(<;/=(20*#&,3"'(%#+(&7"(;*,01"%#()1%2"(>8"#2:(<;)>=?(&7%&(@%'(60,9"+(3#(.ABC(D:(&7"(9",8",(06(&7"(;*,01"%#()1%2"(E"'"%,27(

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

;

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

N7"(+"4"5019"#&(06(%(&,*5:(;*,01"%#()1%2"(Q0532:(@%'(,"208#3G"+(%'(%('&,%&"832(27032"(60,(;*,01"(36(3&(3#&"#+'(&0(D"(%(9%-0,(850D%5('1%2"(15%:",(%#+(20#'"[*"#&5:(%6&",(066323%5(20#'*5&%&30#(*#+",(&7"(%"83'(06(&7"(;*,01"%#(O0993''30#?(%(X,""#(Q%1",(%#+(%(\73&"(1%1",(<%2&30#(15%#=(@","(,"5"%'"+(3#(RSSY(%,&32*5%&3#8(&7"(#""+(%#+(1*,10'"(60,(%(200,+3#%&"+(;*,01"%#()1%2"(Q0532:(&7%&(3'(+"9%#+(+,34"#(%#+('*110,&3#8(06(;/(105323"'JZ

.()"#30,(M"9D",?(>K>>

>9",32%#(K#'&3&*&"(06(>",0#%*&32'(%#+(>'&,0#%*&32'.

AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition9 - 11 September 2008, San Diego, California

AIAA 2008-7717

Copyright © 2008 by Venkatesan Sundararajan. Published by the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Inc., with permission.

Page 2: [American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - San Diego, California ()] AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - European Space Policy

55@ )!?TU,!4S)*,4I!),UW5IX)F!*,G)V!Y!WU,M!S9

N7"(63,'&(;*,01"%#()1%2"(Q0532:(<;)Q=(@%'(%+01&"+(0#(M%:(RR?(RSSB(D:(&7"(;/T;)>(M3#3'&",'(%&(&7"(60*,&7()1%2"O0*#235(D%2$"+(D:(&7"(RA(;*,01"%#(804",#9"#&'J(N7"(;)Q(1,"'"#&'(&7"(;*,01"%#(43'30#(60,('1%2"(%#+(3&'(1,30,3&3"'(%#+(0D-"2&34"'J(N7"(60*#+%&30#(1,3#2315"'(06(&7"(;)Q(%,"(<%=(N"27#050832%5(3##04%&30#(%#+(+"4"5019"#&(<D=(Q*,'*3&(06(@0,5+(

25%''('23"#2"(%#+("L150,%&30#(%#+(<2=(K#+"1"#+"#&(%#+(20'&T"66"2&34"(%22"''(&0('1%2"J(C

N7"(9%-0,("5"9"#&'(06(&7"(;*,01"%#()1%2"(Q0532:(<;)Q=(3#25*+"(&7"(60550@3#8]

3J )1%2"(!3'30#(60,(;*,01"(%#+(X"#",%5()&,%&"8:33J ;*,01"%#()1%2"(Q,08,%9(%#+(K915"9"#&%&30#333J ;*,01"%#()"2*,3&:(%#+(I"6"#'"34J K#+"1"#+"#&(>22"''(&0()1%2"4J K#&",#%&30#%5()1%2"()&%&30#(%#+(;L150,%&30#43J )23"#2"(%#+(N"27#0508:(I"4"5019"#&433J X04",#%#2"4333J K#+*'&,3%5(Q0532:3LJ K#&",#%&30#%5(E"5%&30#'

N7"(,"'05*&30#(0#(&7"(;*,01"%#()1%2"(Q0532:(25"%,5:(%2$#0@5"+8"'(&7"(5"%+3#8(,05"(06(;*,01"(%'(%(850D%5('1%2"(15%:",(%#+(3&'(20993&9"#&(&0(9%3#&%3#(&73'(10'3&30#(43%(3#&,%T;*,01"%#(%#+(3#&",#%&30#%5(2001",%&30#(3#(%220,+%#2"(@3&7(&7"(/#3&"+(^%&30#'(F*&",()1%2"(N,"%&:(P,%9"@0,$J

N7"(;*,01"%#(O0*#235(7%'(+"90#'&,%&"+(&7"(1,%2&32%5(3915"9"#&%&30#(06(&7"(;)Q(D:(&%$3#8(+"23'30#'(&0(3#4"'&(3#(&7"(X50D%5(#%438%&30#('%&"553&"(':'&"9(_X>HKH;F?(&7"(;*,01"%#(X"0'&%&30#%,:(^%438%&30#(F4",5%:():'&"9(_(;X^F)(%#+(&7"(X50D%5(M0#3&0,3#8(60,(&7"(;#43,0#9"#&(%#+()"2*,3&:(_(XM;)(3#3&3%&34"'J

N7" (*&353G%&30# (06 ( '1%2" ( %''"&' ( 60, ( &7" (;*,01"%# ('"2*,3&: (%+4%#2"9"#& (%#+ (%' (% ( '*110,& ( &005 ( 60, ( &7" (;*,01"%#(O0990#(P0,"38#(%#+()"2*,3&:(Q0532:(<OP)Q=(60,9'(%('&%&"+(80%5(06(&7"(#"@5:(%+01&"+(;)QJ(N7"(;)Q('&%&"'(&7%&(;*,01"('70*5+(1,0&"2&(3&'('1%2"TD%'"+(2%1%D353&3"'(%8%3#'&(+3',*1&30#(834"#(&7%&(&7"("20#09:(%#+('"2*,3&:(06(;*,01"(%#+(3&'(23&3G"#'(%,"(3#2,"%'3#85:(+"1"#+"#&(0#(&7"9J`

N7"(;)Q(,"1,"'"#&'(%(2,*23%5('&"1(3#(;*,01"W'('1%2"("660,&'(%'(%(5"%+3#8(850D%5(15%:",(&7%&(7",%5+'(&7"(3#2,"%'"+(1053&32%5(@355(D:(;*,01"%#(804",#9"#&'(&0(*'"()1%2"(%'(%(&005(&0('*110,&(;/(105323"'?(%(200,+3#%&"+("660,&(&0(60,9*5%&"(%#(;*,01"%#()1%2"(1,08,%9(%#+(60,9%53G3#8(&7"(,05"(06(;)>(%'(%#(3#&"8,%&0,(06(;*,01"%#('1%2"(%2&343&3"'J(N7"(;)Q(%39'(&0(9%$"('1%2"(%'(%('&,%&"832(%''"&(&0(;*,01"W'(3#+"1"#+"#2"?('"2*,3&:(%#+(1,0'1",3&:J(

>9",32%#(K#'&3&*&"(06(>",0#%*&32'(%#+(>'&,0#%*&32'R

Page 3: [American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - San Diego, California ()] AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - European Space Policy

>(20990#(6,%9"@0,$(06('&,%&"832(%2&30#(60,(%273"43#8(@3+"T,%#83#8(0D-"2&34"'(06(&7"(;)>(M"9D",()&%&"'(%'(1%,&(06(&7"(;)>(H0#8(N",9(Q5%#(RSSBTRS.`?(2%55"+(>8"#+%(RS..(3'(D"3#8(+"4"501"+(3#(1%,%55"5(&0(&7"(;)QJ(N7"(X%535"0(%#+(XM;)(60,9(&7"(60*#+%&30#%5(%11532%&30#(1,08,%9'(60,(1%#T;*,01"%#("660,&'J(I"4"5019"#&(06(%#(04",%55(;)>()1%2"()23"#2"(Q0532:(D:(%(a387T5"4"5()23"#&3632(>+43'0,:(O0993&&""(%#+(60,83#8('&,0#8",(53#$'(D"&@""#('23"#&3632(2099*#3&3"'(%#+(;*,01"%#(3#+*'&,:(%#+('&,"#8&7"#3#8(3#&",#%&30#%5(2001",%&30#(&7,0*87('1"23632(3#3&3%&34"'(%5'0(60,9(1%,&(06(&7"(>8"#+%(RS..J(N7"(#"L&('&"1'(3#(&7"(3915"9"#&%&30#(06(&7"(;)Q(3#25*+"("'&%D53'73#8(%(;*,01"%#()1%2"(1,08,%9(%#+(200,+3#%&30#(06(#%&30#%5(%#+(;*,01"%#(5"4"5('1%2"(%2&343&3"'(@3&7(%(*'",T5"+(602*'JB

555@)!?TU,!4S)*,4I!)4L!SIX)F!*4G)4SV)!?),TULT4M*

N7"(;*,01"%#()1%2"(>8"#2:(<;)>=(@3&7(%(&0&%5("L1"#+3&*,"(06(UYJ``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b(06(3&'(&0&%5(D*+8"&(%#+(%D0*&(RCb(06(3&'(&"27#32%5(@0,$60,2"Jc

;)>('1"#+'(%D0*&(RSb(06(3&'(D*+8"&(0#(H%*#27",'(Q,08,%9?(%(2,3&32%5("5"9"#&(3#(%273"43#8(&7"(3#+"1"#+"#&('1%2"(%22"''(0D-"2&34"(06(&7"(;)QJ(>50#8(@3&7(&7"('*22"''6*5(+"4"5019"#&(%#+(2099",23%5("L1503&%&30#(06(&7"(>,3%#"(C(7"%4:(536&",? (20#'&,*2&30#(06(&7"()0:*G(5%*#27(6%2353&3"' (3#(d0*,0*?(P,"#27(X*3%#%?(&7"(+"4"5019"#&(06(&7"('9%55 (5%*#27",(<!"8%=(%#+(&7"(1,08,%9('*110,&3#8(&7"(;*,01"%#(X*%,%#&""+(>22"''(&0()1%2"(<;X>)=(,"1,"'"#&( &7"(9%3#(%,"%'(06("L1"#+3&*,"(3#(&7"(H%*#27",(+09%3#J

N7"(O0'932(!3'30#(RS.CTRSRC(3'(&7"(&"#T:"%,(;)>()23"#2"(Q,08,%9(60,(@7327(93''30#'(%,"('"5"2&"+(2091"&3&34"5:(D:(&7" ()1%2" ()23"#2" (>+43'0,:(O0993&&"" ( <))>O=J (O0'932 (!3'30# (RS.CTRSRC (@355 ( &%2$5" ( '09" (06 ( &7" (D38 ( '23"#&3632([*"'&30#'(20#2",#3#8(&7"(/#34",'"(%#+(0*,(15%2"(3#(3&J

\7%&(%,"(&7"(20#+3&30#'(60,(15%#"&(60,9%&30#(%#+(&7"("9",8"#2"(06(536"e(

a0@(+0"'(&7"()05%,():'&"9(@0,$e(

\7%&(%,"(&7"(6*#+%9"#&%5(17:'32%5(5%@'(06(&7"(/#34",'"e(

a0@(+3+(&7"(/#34",'"(0,383#%&"(%#+(@7%&(3'(3&(9%+"(06e

F#(.c(F2&0D",(RSSB?(%6&",(%(9""&3#8(06(&7"())>O?(&7"(60550@3#8(2%#+3+%&"(O0'932(!3'30#(93''30#'(@","('"5"2&"+(60,(6*,&7",(%''"''9"#&(%#+(20#'3+",%&30#(60,(5%*#27(3#(RS.BfRS.c@)A

M.22.$(2)S'1& *+.&(+&)U>Q&+6.8&

;/OHKI M%113#8(&7"(8"09"&,:(06(&7"(+%,$(/#34",'"

g;/) gT,%:(FD'",4%&0,:(60,(&7"(;L&,"9"(%#+(;40543#8(/#34",'"

)QKO> K#6,%,"+()1%2"(N"5"'201"(60,(O0'90508:(%#+(>'&,017:'32'

QH>NF ^"L&(X"#",%&30#(Q5%#"&(P3#+",

M>EOF(QFHF ^"%,(;%,&7(FD-"2&()%915"(E"&*,#(M3''30#

N>^I;M M3''30#(&0(N3&%#(%#+()%&*,#():'&"9

OEF))T)O>H; K#4"'&38%&3#8(M*5&3T)2%5"(O0*153#8(3#()1%2"(Q5%'9%

H>QH>O; M3''30#(&0(;*,01%(%#+(h*13&",():'&"9

HK)> )1%2"(K#&",6",09"&",(&0(I"&"2&(X,%43&%&30#%5(\%4"'

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cCb(06(&73'(%90*#&(3'("%,9%,$"+(60,(&7"(XM;)(1,08,%9J(;*,01"%#(O0993''30#(9%#%8"'(%2&30#'(60,(3+"#&36:3#8(%#+(+"4"5013#8('",432"'(@735"(;)>(@355(3915"9"#&(&7"('1%2"(20910#"#&J(XM;)(6*5635'(%#(0D-"2&34"(06(&7"(;)Q(&0(9%$"()1%2"(%(&005(&0('",4"(&7"(105323"'(06(&7"(;/?(3&'(M"9D",()&%&"'(%#+(3&'(23&3G"#'J.S

>9",32%#(K#'&3&*&"(06(>",0#%*&32'(%#+(>'&,0#%*&32'Y

Page 4: [American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - San Diego, California ()] AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - European Space Policy

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

5Y@!?TU,!4S)*,4I!),TULT4M)V!Y!WU,M!S9

N7"(;*,01"%#()1%2"(Q,08,%9(20#'&3&*&"'(%(20990#?(3#25*'34"(%#+(65"L3D5"(1,08,%99%&32(D%'"?(0#(@7327(;*,01"(1",60,9'(3&'(%2&343&3"'(D:(*&353G3#8(&7"(%4%35%D5"(,"'0*,2"'(90'&("66"2&34"5:(%&(%55(5"4"5'J(N7"(1,08,%9(3'(3#&"#+"+(&0(D"(3#(209153%#2"(@3&7(&7"(;)Q(0D-"2&34"'(%#+(8*3+"53#"'J(N7"(;*,01"%#(%2&0,'(&%$3#8(1%,&(%,"(;)>?(;/?(M"9D",()&%&"'(%#+(0&7",(3#&",804",#9"#&%5(0,8%#3G%&30#'(01",%&3#8(%&(&7"(;*,01"%#(5"4"5('*27(%'(;/M;N)>NJ(

N7" ( 6*&*," ( '201"(%#+ ('1"23632 (+"'38# (06 ( &7" (;*,01"%# ()1%2"(Q,08,%9( 3' (D"3#8 (1,"1%,"+ (D:( &7" (;)>f;O(h03#&()"2,"&%,3%&J (N7"(P36&7(9""&3#8(06 ( &7"()1%2"(O0*#235 (@355 ( ,"43"@(%#+("#+0,'"( 3& ( &70*87( 3&' ( 60,9%5 (%+01&30#(D:( &7"(O091"&3&34"(O0*#235(%#+(D:(&7"(;)>(O0*#235(%&(M3#3'&",3%5(5"4"5J(N7"(1,08,%99%&32(0D-"2&34"'(06(&7"(;*,01"%#()1%2"(Q,08,%9(%,"(D%'"+(0#(1,043'30#'(@3&73#(&7"(;)Q(+02*9"#&?(&7"(;)>(H0#8TN",9(Q5%#(RSSBTRS.`(%#+(&7"(B&7(P,%9"@0,$(Q,08,%9'(60,(E"'"%,27(%#+(N"27#050832%5(I"4"5019"#&(<PQB=J.R

9'>-&)Z[)5(<.+'6.8&)J"<7&62);$#)M'Q$#)*%'+&),#$7#'12)$()!"#$%&'()W&8&-

UT5L5S S4M!)UK),TULT4M)

4I95Y59X

95M!KT4M! J?VL!9\)!],!SV59?T!)

F^)J.--.$(2G

!*4 H%*#27",' RSSBTRS.Y CJS

;%,&7(FD'",4%&30# RSSBTRS.Y ZJC

a*9%#()1%2"(P5387&?(M32,08,%43&:(%#+(;L150,%&30#

RSSBTRS.Y ZJR

)23"#2"(Q,08,%9' RSSBTRS.Y YJZ

^%438%&30#(i(N"5"209 RSSBTRS.Y YJZ

V%'32(>2&343&3"' RSSBTRS.Y .JZ

N"27#0508: RSSBTRS.Y SJc

K#&"8,%&"+(>11532%&30#' RSSBTRS.Y SJC

9U94W N_@N

!I PQB()1%2"( RSSBTRS.Y .JZ(<06(@7327(cCb(60,(XM;)=

PQB(N,%#'10,& RSSBTRS.Y SJZC

X%535"0 RSSBTRS.Y YJZ

4?TUT4)3)9`!)!?TU,!4S)*,4I!)!],WUT495US),TULT4M

>*,0,%(1,08,%9(3'(1%,&(06(;*,01"j'('&,%&"8:(60,('1%2"("L150,%&30#?("#+0,'"+(D:(&7"(;*,01"%#(/#30#(O0*#235(06(E"'"%,27(%#+(&7"(;)>(O0*#235(3#(RSS.J(N7"(>*,0,%()1%2"(;L150,%&30#(1,08,%9(3'('&,*2&*,"+(%'(%(D*35+3#8(D502$(3#(%(D,0%+",(3#&",#%&30#%5("660,&(60,(&7"(,0D0&32(%#+(7*9%#("L150,%&30#(06(M%,'?(@3&7(&7"(M00#(%'(%#(3910,&%#&('&"113#8('&0#"J(N7"(1,"1%,%&0,:(17%'"(5%'&"+(6,09(&7"(D"83##3#8(06(RSSR(&0(I"2"9D",(RSSC?(@3&7(.R()&%&"'(1%,&3231%&3#8(%#+('1"#&(%D0*&(UZc(935530#J(K&%5:(@%'(&7"(9%3#(20#&,3D*&0,J(.Y

N7"('&,%&"8:(60,(;*,01"W'(50#8T&",9('1%2"("L150,%&30#(7%'(&7"(60550@3#8(0D-"2&34"']

;L150,"(&7"()05%,():'&"9(%#+(&7"(/#34",'"

)"%,27(60,(536"(D":0#+(;%,&7

>9",32%#(K#'&3&*&"(06(>",0#%*&32'(%#+(>'&,0#%*&32'Z

Page 5: [American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - San Diego, California ()] AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - European Space Policy

)&39*5%&"(#"@(&"27#0508:

K#'13,"(&7"(:0*#8(1"015"(06(;*,01"(&0(&%$"(%(8,"%&",(3#&","'&(3#('23"#2"(%#+(&"27#0508:>*,0,%(3'(D"3#8(3915"9"#&"+(3#(%('&"1TD:T'&"1(%11,0%27?(@3&7(93''30#'(3#2,"%'3#8(3#(20915"L3&:(04",(&39"(_(@3&7(&7"(

80%5(06(%#("4"#&*%5(7*9%#("L1"+3&30#(&0(M%,'(D:(RSYSJ(N7"('"[*"#&3%5("L150,%&30#(06(M%,'(3#25*+"(&7"(60550@3#8('&"1']

E"90&"()"#'3#8(06(&7"(M%,&3%#(;#43,0#9"#&

E0D0&32(;L150,%&30#(%#+()*,6%2"(>#%5:'3'

M%,'()%915"(E"&*,#(M3''30#'

>(E0D0&32(F*&10'&

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

;L0M%,'(E04",('27"+*5"+(60,(5%*#27(3#(RS.Y(3'(&7"(63,'&(>*,0,%(,0D0&32(93''30#(&7%&(@355(7%4"(3#'&,*9"#&'(&0(3#4"'&38%&"(@7"&7",(536"("4",(%,0'"(0#(&7"(E"+(Q5%#"&J(K&(@355(%5'0(D"(&7"(63,'&(93''30#(209D3#3#8(90D353&:(%#+(%22"''(&0('*D'*,6%2"(502%&30#'(@7","(0,8%#32(905"2*5"'(9%:(D"(@"55T1,"'",4"+J(;L0M%,'(@355(+"150:(%(E04",(2%,,:3#8(%(2091,"7"#'34"('*3&"(06(%#%5:&32%5(3#'&,*9"#&'(+"+32%&"+(60,("L0D30508:(%#+(8"0508:(,"'"%,27?(&7"(!"#$%&'(!")*+",J(N7"(E04",(3'(3#&"#+"+(&0(&,%4"5('"4",%5($3509"&",'(3#('"%,27(06(&,%2"'(06(1%'&(%#+(1,"'"#&('38#'(06(536"?(2055"2&3#8(%#+(%#%5:G3#8('%915"'(6,09(@3&73#('*,6%2"(,02$'(%#+(6,09(&7"('*D'*,6%2"?(+0@#(&0(%(+"1&7(06(R(9"&",'J(

N7"(;L0M%,'(E04",(93''30#(@355(D"(20915"9"#&"+(D:(&7"(-&./+*,$(!")*+",0(&0(D"(%220990+%&"+(0#(%(H%#+",J(P0550@3#8(&7"(E04",W'("8,"''?(&7"(a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

>(60550@T0#(M%,'()%915"(E"&*,#(<M)E=(3'(%5'0(D"3#8(15%##"+(%'(1%,&(06(&7"(>*,0,%()1%2"(;L150,%&30#(Q,08,%9J(X34"#(&7"("#0,90*'(20915"L3&:(%#+(20'&'(%''023%&"+(@3&7('*27(%(93''30#?(3&(3'(D"3#8(15%##"+(%'(%#(3#&",#%&30#%5("660,&J(N7"(3#&",#%&30#%5(M%,'(>,273&"2&*,"(60,(&7"(E"&*,#(06()%915"'(<3M>E)=(\0,$3#8(X,0*1(@%'(27%,&"+(D:(&7"(K#&",#%&30#%5(M%,'(;L150,%&30#(\0,$3#8(X,0*1(<KM;\X=(3#(93+TRSS`(&0(+"4"501(%(10&"#&3%5(15%#(60,(%#(3#&",#%&30#%55:('10#'0,"+(%#+("L"2*&"+(M%,'()%915"(E"&*,#(<M)E=(93''30#J(N7"(1*,10'"(06(3M>E)(\0,$3#8(X,0*1(3'(&0(0*&53#"(&7"('23"#&3632(%#+("#83#"",3#8(,"[*3,"9"#&'(60,('*27(%#(3#&",#%&30#%5(93''30#(3#(&7"(RS.cTRY(&39"(6,%9"J(

>(Q,"5393#%,:(Q5%##3#8(60,(%#(K#&",#%&30#%5(M%,'()%915"(E"&*,#(M3''30#(E"10,&(@%'(,"5"%'"+(D:(3M>E)(\0,$3#8(X,0*1(3#(h*#"(RSSc(&7%&(1,043+"+(&7"('23"#&3632(0D-"2&34"'?(7387T5"4"5(,"[*3,"9"#&'?(+"4"5019"#&(&39"53#"?(9%#%8"9"#&(15%##3#8?(1*D532(0*&,"%27(%#+("+*2%&30#(%#+(#"L&('&"1'J.Z

N7"(60550@3#8(2%#+3+%&"('23"#&3632(0D-"2&34"'(06(&7"(M)E(93''30#(7%4"(D""#(3+"#&363"+J(a0@"4",?(&7"(27032"(06(5%#+3#8('3&"(@0*5+(15%:(%(2,3&32%5(,05"(3#(+"&",93#3#8(70@(9%#:(06(&7"'"(0D-"2&34"'("#+(*1(%'(1%,&(06(&7"(93''30#(15%#J(

.= I"&",93#"(&7"(27"932%5?(93#",%50832%5(%#+(3'0&0132(20910'3&30#(06(&7"(2,*'&%5(,"'",403,'(06(2%,D0#?(#3&,08"#?('*56*,?(%#+(0&7",("5"9"#&'(@3&7(@7327(&7":(7%4"(3#&",%2&"+?(3#(0,+",(&0(+02*9"#&(1,02"''"'(&7%&(20*5+('*'&%3#(7%D3&%D5"("#43,0#9"#&'(0#(M%,'(D0&7(&0+%:(%#+(3#(&7"(1%'&J

R= >''"''(&7"("43+"#2"(60,(1,"D30&32(1,02"''"'?(1%'&(536"?(%#+f0,("L&%#&(536"(0#(M%,'JY= K#&",1,"&(&7"(20#+3&30#'(06(M%,&3%#(@%&",T,02$(3#&",%2&30#'(&7,0*87(&7"('&*+:(06(&7"3,(93#",%5(1,0+*2&'JZ= O0#'&,%3#(&7"(%D'05*&"(%8"'(06(9%-0,(M%,&3%#(2,*'&%5(8"050832%5(1,02"''"'JC= /#+",'&%#+(&7"(1%5"0"#43,0#9"#&'(%#+(&7"(73'&0,:(06(&7"(#"%,('*,6%2"(@%&",(0#(M%,'J`= O0#'&,%3#(&7"(9"27%#3'9(%#+(&393#8(06(15%#"&%,:(%22,"&30#?(+366","#&3%&30#?(%#+(&7"('*D'"[*"#&("405*&30#(06(&7"(

M%,&3%#(2,*'&?(9%#&5"?(%#+(20,"JB= I"&",93#"(70@(&7"(M%,&3%#(,"8053&7(@%'(60,9"+(%#+(90+363"+?(%#+(70@(%#+(@7:(3&(+366",'(6,09(15%2"(&0(15%2"J

>9",32%#(K#'&3&*&"(06(>",0#%*&32'(%#+(>'&,0#%*&32'C

Page 6: [American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - San Diego, California ()] AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - European Space Policy

c= O7%,%2&",3G"(&7"(,3'$'(&0(6*&*,"(7*9%#("L150,",'(06(M%,'(%#+(20#&,3D*&"(&0(&7"(%''"''9"#&(06(10&"#&3%5(3#('3&*(,"'0*,2"'(&0(%3+(3#(&7"("'&%D53'79"#&(06(7*9%#(1,"'"#2"(3#(M%,'J

A= I"&",93#"(&7"(1,"'",4%&30#(10&"#&3%5(06(1,"'"#&T+%:(M%,&3%#('*,6%2"(%#+('*D'*,6%2"("#43,0#9"#&'(60,(&7"("4%5*%&30#(06(27"932%5('38#%&*,"'(06("L&%#&(536"(%#+(1,"D30&32(27"93'&,:J

.S= K#&",1,"&(&7"(3#3&3%5(20910'3&30#(06(&7"(M%,&3%#(%&90'17","?(&7"(,%&"'(%#+(1,02"''"'(06(%&90'17",32(50''f8%3#(04",(8"050832(&39"(%#+(&7"(,%&"'(%#+(1,02"''"'(06(%&90'17",32("L27%#8"(@3&7('*,6%2"(20#+"#'"+('1"23"'J

N7"(@3+"(,%#8"(06(10&"#&3%5('23"#2"(0D-"2&34"'(@0*5+(,"[*3,"(&7"('%9153#8(06(%(,%#8"(06(53&705083"'(_('"+39"#&%,:?(7:+,0&7",9%5?(%#+(38#"0*'J(>('*3&"(06(%D0*&(C(&0(c('%915"'(,"1,"'"#&(%(,"%'0#%D5"(2091,093'"(D"&@""#('23"#&3632(#""+'(%#+(93''30#(20#'&,%3#&'(60,(M)E('%915"'J(N7"(1,"5393#%,:(15%#(%5'0(,"208#3G"+(&7"(27%55"#8"'(6%23#8(%#(M)E(93''30#(3915"9"#&"+(@3&73#(%#(3#&",#%&30#%5(6,%9"@0,$(@0*5+(D"(200,+3#%&30#(06(&7"(F,D3&",(%#+(H%#+",(O0910'3&"("#83#"",3#8?(+"4"5019"#&?(%#+(01",%&30#'(%2&343&3"'J(

N7"(60550@3#8('27"9%&32(,"1,"'"#&'(&7"(3M>E)(E"6","#2"(>,273&"2&*,"J(N7"(638*,"('70@'(&7"(5%*#27(06?(%#+(3#&",%2&30#'(D"&@""#(&7"(H%#+",(O0910'3&"(%#+(&7"(F,D3&",(O0910'3&"(3#(&7"(3M>E)(&@0T5%*#27(%,273&"2&*,"J(

.M4T*)T&;&#&(+&)4#+:.6&+6"#&

)0*,2"](Q,"5393#%,:(Q5%##3#8(60,(%#(K#&",#%&30#%5(M%,'()%915"(E"&*,#(M3''30#?(E"10,&(06(&7"(3M>E)(\0,$3#8(X,0*1?(h*#"(RSScJ

>9",32%#(K#'&3&*&"(06(>",0#%*&32'(%#+(>'&,0#%*&32'`

Page 7: [American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - San Diego, California ()] AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - European Space Policy

N7"(1,"5393#%,:(15%##3#8('&%8"("'&39%&"'(60,(&7"("#+T&0T"#+(M)E(93''30#(20'&'(,%#8"(6,09(kZJC(V(&0(kc(V(0,(UY(V(&0(UCJY(V(+"1"#+3#8(0#(&7"(63#%5(,"[*3,"9"#&'(%#+(3#&",#%&30#%5(2001",%&34"('&,*2&*,"J)>($":(,"[*3,"9"#&(@0*5+(D"("%,5:(3#4"'&9"#&(%#+(1%,%55"5(+"4"5019"#&(06(&"27#05083"'J

W5Y5SL),W4S!9)3)9`!)!*4),TULT4M)KUT)!4T9`)UJ*!TY495US=)!4T9`)*I5!SI!)

4SV)IW5M49!)MUS59UT5SL

N7"(;*,01"%#))1%2"(>8"#2:(7%'(D""#(+"+32%&"+(&0(;%,&7(FD'",4%&30#('3#2"(.ABB?('&%,&3#8(@3&7(&7"(5%*#27(06(&7"(63,'&(;*,01"%#(9"&"0,050832%5('%&"553&"?(M"&"0'%&J()3#2"(&7"#('"4",%5(9"&"0,050832%5('%&"553&"'(%#+(&7"(;*,01"%#(E"90&"()"#'3#8()%&"553"'?(;E)T.(%#+(;E)TR(5%*#27"+(3#(.AA.(%#+(.AAC(,"'1"2&34"5:(%50#8(@3&7(;#43'%&(7%4"(1,043+"+(%(@"%5&7(06(3#60,9%&30#(%D0*&(&7"(;%,&7W'("#43,0#9"#&J(

;)>(5%*#27"+(&7"(l123245(!*"4%$(!'+5'".m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

N7"(;%,&7(;L150,",(93''30#'(%,"('"5"2&"+(@3&7(250'"(2001",%&30#(@3&7(&7"(;*,01"%#(%#+(O%#%+3%#('23"#&3632(2099*#3&3"'(6,09(&7"(D"83##3#8(%#+("%27(93''30#(3'("4%5*%&"+(&7,0*87(%(1"",(,"43"@(1,02"''(&0(%++,"''(&7"(1,"'"#&(+%:(;%,&7('23"#2"(27%55"#8"'(&7,0*87(*&353G%&30#(06(D,"%$&7,0*87(&"27#0508:(3#('1%2"(D%'"+(0D'",4%&30#J(

N7"(;%,&7(;L150,",(93''30#(20#'3'&'(06('3L(20,"(93''30#'(%#+(%(6*,&7",('3L(2%#+3+%&"(93''30#'(*#+",(%''"''9"#&(60,(6*&*,"('"5"2&30#J(>('*99%,:(06(&7"('23"#&3632(0D-"2&34"'(06(&7"('3L(20,"(;%,&7(;L150,",(93''30#'(3'(1,043+"+(D"50@]

M5**5US *I5!S95K5I)UJa!I95Y!*)KUT)9`!)M5**5US W4?SI`)

X!4T

LUI!(<X,%43&:(63"5+(%#+('&"%+:T'&%&"(F2"%#(O3,2*5%&30#(;L150,",=(.`

T N0(+"&",93#"(&7"(;%,&7(8,%43&:(63"5+(%#09%53"'(@3&7(%#(%22*,%2:(06(.9X%5(<@7","(.9X%5(n(.STC(9f'R=

T N0(+"&",93#"(&7"(8"03+(@3&7(%#(%22*,%2:(06(.TR(29(%&(%('1%&3%5(,"'05*&30#(D"&&",(&7%#(.SS($9J

)"1&"9D",(RSSc

*MU*)<)035(M03'&*,"(%#+(F2"%#()%53#3&:=(.B

T N0(1,"1%,"(850D%5(9%1'(06('035(903'&*,"(%#+(02"%#('%53#3&:(60,(7:+,050832%5('&*+3"'(%#+(391,04"(*#+",'&%#+3#8(06(02"%#(23,2*5%&30#(1%&&",#'J(

RSSA

4VMC4&$-"2)

<>&90'17",32(I:#%932'(M3''30#=(.c

T N0(9"%'*,"(850D%5(@3#+(1,0635"'(<.RS(1",(70*,=(*1(&0(%#(%5&3&*+"(06(YS($9(&0(%#(%22*,%2:(06(.9f'(3#(&7"(15%#"&%,:(D0*#+%,:(5%:",(%#+(&0(%#(%22*,%2:(06(R9f'(3#(&7"(6,""(&,010'17","J(M"%'*,"(@3#+(4"5023&:(04",(CS$9(&,%2$'J(

RSSA

I#/$*'6CN).A T N0(+"&",93#"(&7"(65*2&*%&30#'(3#(&7"(9%''(06(&7"(;%,&7W'(9%-0,(5%#+(%#+(9%,3#"(63"5+'(&0(7"51(1,"+32&(6*&*,"(2539%&"(%#+('"%(5"4"5'J(

RSSA

*b4TM)

<O0#'&"55%&30#(06(Y('%&"553&"'(3#(H;F=(RS

T N0(+"&",93#"(&7"(20,"(+:#%932'(06(;%,&7W'(3#&",30,(D:('*,4":3#8(&7"(8"09%8#"&32(63"5+(%#+(3&'(&"910,%5("405*&30#

T N0(9"%'*,"(&3+%5(%#+(02"%#(23,2*5%&30#('38#%&*,"(

RS.S

!'#6:I4T!(<;%,&7(O50*+'(>",0'05'(%#+(E%+3%&30#(;L150,",=(R.

T N0([*%#&36:(%",0'05T250*+T,%+3%&30#(3#&",%2&30#'(3#(0,+",(&0(20,,"2&5:(,"1,"'"#&(&7"9(3#(2539%&"(%#+(@"%&7",(60,"2%'&3#8(90+"5'J

T >11532%&30#(10&"#&3%5(3#25*+"'('"3'90508:(%#+(8,%43&:(90+"53#8J(

RS.Y

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`NU[(N0(391,04"(&7"(3#60,9%&30#(0#('#0@?(85%23",'(%#+('*,6%2"(@%&",J

>9",32%#(K#'&3&*&"(06(>",0#%*&32'(%#+(>'&,0#%*&32'B

Page 8: [American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - San Diego, California ()] AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - European Space Policy

<Z=(KW!][(N0(9%$"(850D%5(0D'",4%&30#'(06(170&0':#&7"'3'(&7,0*87(&7"(9"%'*,"9"#&(06(2750,017:55T65*0,"'2"#2"J<C=(,T!M5!T[(N0(%+4%#2"(0*,(*#+",'&%#+3#8(06(&7"(1,02"''"'(&7%&(53#$(&,%2"(8%'"'?(,%+3%&30#(%#+(27"93'&,:(3#(&7"(*11",(&,010'17","(%#+(50@",('&,%&0'17","J<`=(9T4c[(N0(*#+",'&%#+(90,"(%D0*&(&7"(,%&"(06(%3,([*%53&:(%#+(50#8(,%#8"(&,%#'10,&(06(%3,(1055*&%#&'J

Y@ !?TU,!4S)S495US4W)*,4I!)4L!SI5!*

>55(&7"(9%-0,(;*,01"%#(20*#&,3"'(7%4"(@"55("'&%D53'7"+(#%&30#%5('1%2"(%8"#23"'(&7%&(2%&",(&0(&7"('1"23632(#%&30#%5(#""+'?(105323"'(%#+(60'&",(3#&",#%&30#%5(2001",%&30#J(N7"(&01(;*,01"%#(#%&30#%5('1%2"(%8"#23"'(%,"(O^;)(<P,%#2"=?(IHE(<X",9%#:=?(V^)O(</d=?(>)K(<K&%5:=(%#+(OINK(<)1%3#=J(P,%#2"(,"9%3#'(&7"(&01(20#&,3D*&0,(60,(;)>(D*+8"&(%220*#&3#8(60,(%D0*&(RCb(06(&7"(&0&%5J (N7"(&0&%5(D*+8"&(60,(&7"(4%,30*'(#%&30#%5(23435('1%2"(%8"#23"'(3#(;*,01"("L25*+3#8(&7"3,(20#&,3D*&30#'(&0(;)>(%90*#&"+(&0(%D0*&(U.JA(V35530#(3#(RSSBJRY

IS!*)FK#'(+&G[

N7"(P,"#27(^%&30#%5()1%2"(>8"#2:?(O^;)?(3'(&7"(5"%+3#8(#%&30#%5('1%2"(%8"#2:(3#(;*,01"(@3&7(%#(%##*%5(D*+8"&(06(U.JZ(V35530#(3#(RSSBJ(N7"(#0#T;)>(20910#"#&(%90*#&"+(&0(UB.YJR(M35530#J(N7"(P,"#27('7%,"(3#(;*,01"%#(23435('1%2"(&0&%5(%90*#&'(&0(%D0*&(YZJRbJ(N70*87('&355(&7"(5"%+3#8(;*,01"%#('1%2"(6%,3#8(#%&30#?(P,"#27(3#4"'&9"#&'(3#('1%2"(7%4"(+"2,"%'"+(0#(%4",%8"(D:(.J`b(1",(:"%,('3#2"(RSSS(D*&(1*D532("L1"#+3&*,"'(3#('1%2"(7%4"(3#2,"%'"+(D:(.J.b(1",(:"%,(3# (X",9%#:?(K&%5:(<ZJ.b=(%#+(/#3&"+(d3#8+09(<`J.b=J(N7"(O^;)(D*+8"&(3'('"&(&0(3#2,"%'"(D:(SJBb(1",(:"%,(60,(&7"(1",30+(RSSBTRS.S(@3&7(%#(3#2,"%'"(06(.JCb(1",(:"%,(60,(&7"(#%&30#%5(20910#"#&JRZ

>(#*9D",(06(7387T5"4"5(P,"#27('1%2"(10532:(+02*9"#&'(@","(,"5"%'"+(+*,3#8(RSSB?(D0&7(3#(O3435(%#+(M353&%,:()1%2"?(%663,93#8(&7"('*'&%3#"+('*110,&(60,('1%2"(%&(&7"(1053&32%5(5"4"5J(N7"(l67"8%(!+*28)9(:"'245(+'(:%8*24%(;(-+<($+(."=%(>&'+7%(<+'*,(*%",%'(24($?%(#7"8%(,+."24m(1,"'"#&"+(&0(&7"(P,"#27(Q%,53%9"#&(0#(P"D,*%,:(B?(RSSB(73875387&"+(&7"(8,0@3#8 (8%1 (@3&7 ( &7" ( 5"%+3#8 ('1%2" ( 6%,3#8 (#%&30#? (/#3&"+ ()&%&"'J ( K& ( %5'0 (73875387&"+ (;*,01"W' ( 5%2$ (06 (1,08,"'' ( 3#(3#4"'&9"#&'(2091%,"+(&0(%(,"'*,8"#&(E*''3%#('1%2"("660,&(%#+(@3&7(8,0@3#8('1%2"("#+"%40,'(06(O73#%?(K#+3%(%#+(h%1%#J(N7"(oO%D%5(E"10,&W(%'(3&(3'(%5'0(2%55"+?(M,J(O7,3'&3%#(O%D%5?(MQ?(D"3#8(%(20T%*&70,(06(&7"(,"10,&?(D,3#8'(0*&(&7"(5%2$(06(3#+"1"#+"#&(a*9%#()1%2"65387&(2%1%D353&:(3#(&7"(;*,01"%#('1%2"(+09%3#(%'(%(20#2",#(60, (;*,01"J(N7"(E"10,&(7%'(1,010'"+(90,"(&7%#(CS(,"2099"#+%&30#'(&0(&7"(P,"#27(%#+(;*,01"%#(10532:(9%$",'(&0(,"4%91(&7"('1%2"("660,&'(&0(9%3#&%3#(;*,01"W'(5"%+3#8(10'3&30#(3#(&7"('1%2"('"2&0,(%#+(2%13&%53G"(0#(3&'(2099",23%5('1%2"(3#+*'&,:('&,"#8&7JRC

N7"(RSSCTRS.S(20#&,%2&(D"&@""#(&7"(P,"#27(X04",#9"#&(%#+(O^;)(1,043+"'(&7"('&,%&"8:(%#+(6,%9"@0,$("#+0,'"+(D:( &7" (X04",#9"#& ( 60, ( '7%13#8 (%#+ ( 5"%+3#8 ( &7" (P,"#27 ()1%2" (Q0532: ( %#+ ( 3# (@0,$3#8 (@3&7 ( 3#&",#%&30#%5 (1%,&#",'?(1%,&32*5%,5:(3#(;*,01"J(N7"(634"(8,"%&('&,%&"832(%,"%'(60,(O^;)(%,"(<.=(>22"''(&0()1%2"(<R=(X"#",%5(Q*D532(<N"5"209?(V,0%+D%#+?(K#&",#"&?(^%438%&30#?(a"%5&7(%#+(;+*2%&30#=(<Y=()*'&%3#%D5"(+"4"5019"#&(<XM;)?(;F?(9"&"0,0508:=(<Z=()23"#2"?(N"27#0508:(%#+(K##04%&30#(%#+(<C=()"2*,3&:(%#+(I"6"#'"JR`

VWT)*%'+&)FL&#1'(/G[

IHE()1%2"(3'(,"'10#'3D5"(60,(3915"9"#&3#8(&7"(X",9%#('1%2"(%2&343&3"'(60,(3&'(804",#9"#&J(>D0*&(`Bb(06(X",9%#('1%2"("660,&'(%,"(+"+32%&"+(&7,0*87(;)>?(RSb(60,(&7"(#%&30#%5('1%2"(1,08,%9(%#+(&7"(,"'&(06(&7"(.Yb(0#('1%2"(EiIJ(N7"(X",9%#('1%2"(D*+8"&(60,(RSSB(@%'(UcBZ(M35530#JRB

X",9%#:W'(#%&30#%5('1%2"(1,08,%9(7%'(60*,(;%,&7(FD'",4%&30#(1,0-"2&'](N",,%)>ETg(<RSSB=p(E%13+;:"(<RSSc=p(N%#I;MTg(<RSSA=(%#+(;#M%1(<RS.S=J(X",9%#:(%5'0(1%,&3231%&"'(3#(&7"(;)>(;F(1,08,%9'(%#+(XM;)J(X",9%#:(3'(&7"(5"%+3#8(;*,01"%#(20#&,3D*&0,(60,(&7"(O05*9D*'(E"'"%,27(M0+*5"(06(&7"(K#&",#%&30#%5()1%2"()&%&30#(<K))=J(X",9%#:(3'("4%5*%&3#8(%(#%&30#%5(H*#%,(;L150,%&30#(F,D3&",(60,(%('27"+*5"+(5%*#27(3#(RS.RJ(K&(3'(3#&"#+"+(&0(+"90#'&,%&"(X",9%#("L1",&3'"(3#(20#+*2&3#8(%(20915"L(93''30#(D":0#+(;%,&7(0,D3&(%#+(20915"9"#&(1%'&(3#&",#%&30#%5(93''30#'(@3&7(%('38#3632%#&(1%,&3231%&30#(6,09(&7"(X",9%#('1%2"(3#+*'&,:J

4*5)F56'-/G[

K&%5:(3'(%(,%3'3#8('1%2"(10@",(3#(;*,01"(@3&7(%#(%##*%5(D*+8"&(06(UcRR(M35530#'(3#(RSSBJ(N73'(15%2"'(K&%5:(%'(&7"('"20#+(5"%+3#8(;*,01"%#('1%2"T6%,3#8(#%&30#(%6&",(P,%#2"J(N7"(K&%53%#(X04",#9"#&(7%'(%11,04"+(&0(3#2,"%'"(&7"('1%2"('1"#+3#8(%&(cb(60,(&7"(#"L&(&7,""(:"%,'J(N7"(&7,""(1,39%,:('1%2"('"2&0,'(60,(1*D532("L1"#+3&*,"'](;%,&7(FD'",4%&30#(<RAb=p()23"#2"(<R.b=(%#+()1%2"(N,%#'10,&%&30#(<.cb=JRc

JS*I)F?dG[

>9",32%#(K#'&3&*&"(06(>",0#%*&32'(%#+(>'&,0#%*&32'c

Page 9: [American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - San Diego, California ()] AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - European Space Policy

N7"(,"5"%'"(06(&7"(l@A(B232*(67"8%(6$'"$%5)9(CDDE;CDFC("4,(/%)+4,m(D:(&7"(V,3&3'7(^%&30#%5()1%2"(O"#&,"(<V^)O=(9%,$'(%(6*#+%9"#&%5(23435('1%2"(10532:('736&(3#(3&'(1,30,3&3"'J(N7"(634"(7387T5"4"5(43'30#(60,(/d('1%2"(%2&343&3"'(%,"]I"4"501('1%2"(':'&"9'(60,(&090,,0@W'("20#09:?(M%#%8"(&7"(27%#83#8(15%#"&?(;L150,"(&7"(/#34",'"?()&,"#8&7"#(3##04%&30#(6,09('1%2"(%#+()$355'(+"4"5019"#&(%#+(0*&,"%27(60,(%(7387T&"27(6*&*,"J(V,3&%3#(3'(&7"('"20#+(5%,8"'&(63#%#23%520#&,3D*&0,(60,(&7"(;)>(>*,0,%(1,08,%9(&0("L150,"(&7"(M00#?(M%,'(%#+(D":0#+JRA

V,3&%3#(3'(&7"(0#5:(Xc(9"9D",(#0&(&0(7%4"(%(9%##"+('1%2"(1,08,%9J(K&('1"#+'(%D0*&(qR.BJcc(M35530#(<URBZ(M35530#=(3#(23435('1%2"(%2&343&3"'?(`Cb(&7,0*87(;)>J(N7"(#"@(/d()1%2"(Q0532:(15%2"'("917%'3'(0#(90#3&0,3#8(2539%&"(27%#8"(&7,0*87(;F('%&"553&"'(%#+(%(+"+32%&"+(2"#&",?(7"51(+0*D5"(&7"(#*9D",(06(2091%#3"'(3#4054"+(3#('1%2"(D*'3#"''(D:(RS.R(%#+("4%5*%&"(&7"(20'&TD"#"63&'(06(%(9%##"+('1%2"(1,08,%9(1%,&3231%&30#J

Y5@ !IUSUM5I*)UK)!?TU,!4S)I5Y5W)*,4I!)*!I9UT

)))0*,2"](;*,020#'*5&?(P"DJ(RSSc X,%1732'()0*,2"](N7"(;20#093'&?(>1,35(RSSc

))0*,2"](;)> )0*,2"'](V^)O?(>)K?(IHE?(O^;)

>9",32%#(K#'&3&*&"(06(>",0#%*&32'(%#+(>'&,0#%*&32'A

;*,01"%#()1%2"()"2&0,(<RSSB=]Rc?SSS(h0D'(<&7","06(c(;)>(>'&,0#%*&'=

RCS?SSS(-0D'(3#+3,"2&

ZSb(\0,5+(M%,$"&(<9%#*6%2&*,3#8?(5%*#273#8(%#+('",4323#8('%&"553&"'=

Page 10: [American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - San Diego, California ()] AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - European Space Policy

Y55@ !?TU,!4S)5S9!TS495US4W)*,4I!)IUU,!T495US

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

;)>(20#'3'&'(06(.B(9"9D",('&%&"'?(#%9"5:?(>*'&,3%?(V"583*9?(I"#9%,$?(P3#5%#+?(P,%#2"?(X",9%#:?(X,""2"?(K,"5%#+?(K&%5:?(H*L*9D0*,8?(^"&7",5%#+'?(^0,@%:?(Q0,&*8%5?()1%3#?()@"+"#?()@3&G",5%#+(%#+(/#3&"+(d3#8+09J(N7"(OG"27(E"1*D532(7%'(D""#(%11,04"+(&0(D"209"(%(6*55T65"+8"+(9"9D",(06(;)>J(>55(&7"(9"9D",('&%&"'(1%,&3231%&"(3#(&7"(M%#+%&0,:(Q,08,%9'(20#&,3D*&3#8(%220,+3#8(&0(&7"3,(XIQ(%#+(9%#:('&%&"'(1%,&3231%&"(3#(&7"(01&30#%5(1,08,%9'(%'(@"55J(

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

N7"(;*,01"%#()1%2"(>8"#2:(3'(,"'10#'3D5"(60,(+"4"5013#8(%#+(200,+3#%&3#8(3#&",#%&30#%5(,"5%&30#'731'(@3&7(#0#T;*,01"%#('1%2"(15%:",'(60,(234353%#('1%2"("#+"%40,'(%#+(7%'("L&"#'34"(2001",%&30#(@3&7('"4",%5('1%2"(6%,3#8(#%&30#'J(O%#%+%(3'(%('1"23%5(2001",%&3#8(#%&30#(%#+(1%,&3231%&"'(3#(&7"(;)>(8"#",%5(D*+8"&(%#+(9%#:(06(3&'(1,08,%9'('3#2"(.ABAJ(O%#%+%W'('1"23%5(,"5%&30#'731(@3&7(;)>(%5'0(%550@'(3&(&0(,"%1(3#+*'&,3%5(D"#"63&'(6,09(;)>(1,08,%9'JY.

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b(06(;*,01"%#(20#&,3D*&30#'J(h%9"'(\"DD()1%2"(N"5"'201"?(HK)>?(a",'27"5TQ5%#2$(%,"('09"(06(&7"(6*&*,"('23"#2"(93''30#'(@3&7('38#3632%#&(;)>T^>)>(1%,&3231%&30#J(

N7"(;)>(2001",%&30#(@3&7(E*''3%(3'(8"%,"+(&0@%,+'(*&353G%&30#(06(E*''3%#(5%*#27",'(%#+(6%2353&3"'(%#+(%22"''(&0(3&'(9%##"+('1%2"65387&'J(E*''3%(8%3#'('&%&"(06(&7"(%,&(;*,01"%#(&"27#0508:(3#(&"5"2099*#32%&30#'(%#+(+%&%(3#&"8,%&30#J(N7"(20915"&30#(06()0:*G(5%*#27(6%2353&3"'(%&(P,"#27(X*3%#%(@0*5+(9%,$(%(935"'&0#"(3#(&7"3,(2001",%&30#J(YR

;*,01"(%#+(O73#%(7%4"('&,"#8&7"#"+('1%2"(2001",%&30#(04",(&7"(,"2"#&(:"%,'?("'1"23%55:(3#(;%,&7(FD'",4%&30#(1,08,%9'('*27(%'(I0*D5"()&%,(%#+(I,%80#()%&"553&"'J(O73#%(1%,&3231%&"'(3#(&7"(;*,01"%#(X%535"0(#%438%&30#(1,0-"2&(@3&7(%#(3#4"'&9"#&(06(%D0*&(kRYS(M35530#(<0#"T636&7(06(&7"(&0&%5(20'&=(%#+(3'("L1"2&"+(&0(8%3#(9%#*6%2&*,3#8(20#&,%2&'J(;*,01"(7"51"+(O73#%(3#(3&'(63,'&(900#(93''30#(O7%#8W"T.(&7,0*87(8,0*#+(&,%2$3#8(01",%&30#'(%#+(3'(15%##3#8(&0(%''3'&(3#(3&'('"20#+(900#(93''30#?(%#(*#9%##"+(,04",J(YY

;)>(%#+(h>g>?(&7"(h%1%#"'"('1%2"(%8"#2:?(7%4"(2001",%&3#8(%8,""9"#&(1%,&32*5%,5:(0#(;%,&7(FD'",4%&30#(%#+('23"#2"(93''30#'(%#+(K))(1%,&3231%&30#J(K#+3%#()1%2"(E"'"%,27(F,8%#3G%&30#(<K)EF=(%#+(;)>(7%4"(%(2001",%&34"(%8,""9"#&(@3&7(K#+3%(1,39%,35:(*&353G3#8(;*,01"%#(5%*#27",?(>,3%#"(60,(3&'(7"%4:('%&"553&"(5%*#27"'(%#+(;)>(3'(20#&,3D*&3#8(&7,""(3#'&,*9"#&'(%50#8(@3&7(%#0&7",(0#"(6,09(V*58%,3%(3#(K#+3%W'(63,'&(900#(93''30#?(O7%#+,%:%%#T.('27"+*5"+(60,(5%*#27(3#()"1&"9D",(RSScJ(O^;)(%#+(K)EF(%,"(@0,$3#8(&08"&7",(0#(M"87%TN,013[*"'(%#+()>E>H(;%,&7(0D'",4%&30#('%&"553&"'J(

)"4",%5(;*,01"%#(#%&30#%5('1%2"(%8"#23"'(%#+(;)>(%,"(9"9D",'(06(&7"(lG?%(H*+/"*(>I7*+'"$2+4(6$'"$%5)9(G?%(J'".%<+'=(K+'(B++',24"$2+4m('38#"+(3#(M%:(RSSB(D:(60*,&""#(3#&",#%&30#%5('1%2"(%8"#23"'J(K&(3'(%(405*#&%,:?(#0#TD3#+3#8(60,*9(@7","(#%&30#'('7%,"(15%#'(60,('1%2"("L150,%&30#(%#+(2055%D0,%&"(&0('&,"#8&7"#(D0&7(3#+343+*%5(%#+(2055"2&34"("660,&(3#(&7"("L150,%&30#(06(M00#?(M%,'?(#"%,(;%,&7(%'&",03+'(%'(1,39%,:(&%,8"&'J(YZ

>9",32%#(K#'&3&*&"(06(>",0#%*&32'(%#+(>'&,0#%*&32'.S

Page 11: [American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - San Diego, California ()] AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - European Space Policy

F#(h*5:(RA?(RSSc?(&7"(/d?(O%#%+%?(K#+3%?(P,%#2"?(K&%5:?(h%1%#?()0*&7(d0,"%(%#+(X",9%#:('38#"+(%(8,0*#+TD,"%$3#8(%8,""9"#&(&0(2001",%&"(04",(900#("L150,%&30#(@3&7(^>)>(0#(D*35+3#8(%#+(01",%&3#8(%(#"&@0,$(06('"#'0,T'&*66"+(,0D0&32(5*#%,(1,0D"'(&7%&(@355(90#3&0,?(9"%'*,"(%#+(%#%5:G"(&7"(900#j'('*,6%2"(%#+('*D'*,6%2"(8"0508:(3#(*#1,"2"+"#&"+(+"&%35J(N7"(20#2"1&(06(%#(K#&",#%&30#%5(H*#%,(^"&@0,$(<KH^=(1,043+"'(%#(0,8%#3G3#8(&7"9"(60,(/)(%#+(K#&",#%&30#%5(5%#+"+('23"#2"(93''30#'(3#(&7"(#"L&(+"2%+"(D:(3#40543#8("%27(5%#+"+('&%&30#(%'(%(#0+"(3#(%(X"017:'32%5(#"&@0,$J(YC?(Y`

Y555@ K5SV5SL*)4SV)IUSIW?*5US

! (N7"(;*,01"%#()1%2"(Q,08,%9?('1"%,7"%+"+(D:(&7"(;*,01"%#()1%2"(>8"#2:(<;)>=(3'(%(*#3[*"(3#&",804",#9"#&%5(%,,%#8"9"#&(&7%&(3'(06(3#2,"%'3#8(3910,&%#2"(60,(850D%5('1%2"(2001",%&30#(3#3&3%&34"'('*27(%'(2539%&"(27%#8"('&*+3"'?(;%,&7(90#3&0,3#8(60,('"2*,3&:(%#+('*'&%3#%D5"('1%2"("L150,%&30#(06(+3'&%#&(2"5"'&3%5(0D-"2&'J

! (N7"(%+01&30#(06(&7"(#"@(;*,01"%#()1%2"(Q0532:(<;)Q=(D:(&7"(RA(;*,01"%#(#%&30#'(7",%5+(;*,01"W'(1053&32%5(20993&9"#&(3#(*&353G3#8()1%2"(%'(%('&,%&"832(3#'&,*9"#&(60,(%273"43#8(;*,01"%#(10532:(80%5'(@3&7(,"'1"2&(&0(&"5"2099*#32%&30#'(%#+(#%438%&30#?(;%,&7(0D'",4%&30#(%#+(90#3&0,3#8(%#+(%++,"''3#8(850D%5('"2*,3&:(20#2",#'J

! (N7"(;*,01"%#(/#30#(1,08,%9'?(XM;)(%#+(X%535"0?(%,"('38#3632%#&(&,%#'60,9%&30#%5(3#3&3%&34"'(&7%&(@0*5+(15%2"(;*,01"(%'(%#(3#+"1"#+"#&('1%2"(10@",(D*&(2091%&3D5"(@3&7(0&7",(850D%5(':'&"9'J

! ()1%2"()23"#2"(,"9%3#'(&7"(20,"(%2&343&:(06(;)>(1,08,%9'(%#+(3'(%(1,39%,:(&"27#0508:(3##04%&30#(+,34",(60,(;*,01"%#('1%2"(3#+*'&,:(%#+(%(2%&%5:'&(60,(3#&",#%&30#%5(2001",%&30#(%8,""9"#&'(3#('1%2"(%2&343&3"'J

! ((N7"(1,010,&30#%5(%5502%&30#(06(3#+*'&,3%5(20#&,%2&'(&0(&7"(9"9D",('&%&"'(D%'"+(0#(20#&,3D*&30#'(7%4"(D:(%#+(5%,8"(D"#"63&"+(9%#:('9%55",(;*,01"%#(#%&30#'(%#+(O%#%+%(D*&(&7"(Q*D532(Q,34%&"(Q%,&#",'731(<QQQ=(7%4"(,"'*5&"+(3#(20#&,%2&(+"5%:'(%#+(93'%538#9"#&(60,('09"(1,0-"2&'('*27(%'(X%535"0J

! (;*,01"(3'($""#(&0(15%:(%(5"%+3#8(,05"(3#(850D%5(2539%&"(27%#8"(90#3&0,3#8(&7,0*87(&7"(H343#8(Q5%#"&(1,08,%9(%#+(3&'(9*5&3T#%&30#%5('"&*1(3'(%1&(60,('*27("#+"%40,'(&7%&(%66"2&(&7"(850D%5("#43,0#9"#&(@3&7(#0(,"8%,+(60,(#%&30#%5(D0*#+%,3"'J()1"23632%55:?(;*,01"(3'(5"%+3#8(;%,&7(FD'",4%&30#(3#(>6,32%(%#+(M3++5"(;%'&(,"830#'(%1%,&(6,09(&7"(O0#&3#"#&(3&'"56J

! (N7","(3'(%(+34",8"#2"(06(3#&","'&(%90#8(&7"(9%-0,('1%2"(6%,3#8(#%&30#'(3#(;*,01"?(@3&7(P,%#2"(5"%+3#8(&7"(@%:(3#(5%*#27",'(%#+(3#+"1"#+"#&(93''30#'?(X",9%#:(3#(K))?(K&%5:(3#('1%2"('23"#2"(1%,&3231%&30#(%#+(V,3&%3#(3#(1,01*5'30#f(,0D0&32'("L1",&3'"J

! (N7"(,"2"#&(23435('1%2"('&,%&"8:(15%#'(06(/#3&"+(d3#8+09(%#+(P,%#2"(15%2"(8,"%&",("917%'3'(0#(9%3#&%3#3#8(&7"(;*,01"%#('1%2"(3#+*'&,3%5(2091"&3&34"#"''?(2%,"6*5(%538#9"#&(D"&@""#(&7"(#%&30#%5(%#+(;/f(;)>(1,08,%9'(%#+("917%'3'(0#(3#&",#%&30#%5(2001",%&30#(60,('1%2"("L150,%&30#(%#+(850D%5(2539%&"(27%#8"(90#3&0,3#8J

! (N7"(;*,01"%#(/#30#(&7,0*87(&7"(;*,01"%#(O0993''30#(200,+3#%&"'(;/('1%2"(10532:(3915"9"#&%&30#(&7,0*87(;)>(D%'"+(0#(%#(;)>T;O(P,%9"@0,$(>8,""9"#&J

! (;*,01"(3'('&355("40543#8(3&'(50#8T&",9('1%2"(1,08,%9(&7%&(3'(&0(3915"9"#&(&7"('&,%&"83"'(%#+(105323"'("#*#23%&"+(3#(&7"(#"@(20990#(;)QJ

! (>22"''(&0(3#+"1"#+"#&(9%##"+('1%2"65387&(%#+(,"5%&"+("L1",&3'"(3'('&355(5%2$3#8(3#(;*,01"?(&70*87("L&"#'34"(2001",%&30#(@3&7(/)(%#+(E*''3%(7%'(1,043+"+(&7"(;*,01"%#(>'&,0#%*&'(@3&7(%22"''(&0(K))J(I"4"5013#8(%#(3#+"1"#+"#&(9%##"+('1%2"65387&(2%1%D353&:(D%'"+(0#(&7"(>N!(>+4%#2"+(E"&*,#(!"7325"(1,0-"2&(3'('5%&"+(&0(D"(+3'2*''"+(3#(&7"(#"L&(;)>(M3#3'&",3%5(9""&3#8(&0(D"(7"5+(3#(^04"9D",(RSScJ

! (N7"(;*,01"%#(>*,0,%(1,08,%9(60,('1%2"("L150,%&30#?(H343#8(Q5%#"&(1,08,%9(60,(;%,&7(90#3&0,3#8?(;*9"&'%&(1,08,%9(60,(;%,&7(FD'",4%&30#?(X%535"0(20#'&"55%&30#(60,(850D%5(#%438%&30#(':'&"9(3#+"1"#+"#2"?(XM;)(60,(850D%5('"2*,3&:(90#3&0,3#8(%#+(K))(1%,&3231%&30#(60,(9%##"+('1%2"65387&(1,043+"(;*,01"(@3&7(&7"(6*55(,%#8"(06('1%2"(D%'"+(%2&343&3"'J

! ((;*,01"%#('1%2"(1,08,%9'(%#+(&7"3,(D,0%+(,%#8"(06(%2&343&3"'(%#+(2001",%&30#(@3&7(5"%+3#8('1%2"(10@",'?(/)(%#+(E*''3%(%#+(@3&7("9",83#8('1%2"(10@",'('*27(%'(h%1%#?(O73#%(%#+(K#+3%?(15%2"(3&(%'(%(+"'3,%D5"(%#+(3910,&%#&(15%:",(60,(6*&*,"(850D%5('1%2"(3#3&3%&34"'J

>9",32%#(K#'&3&*&"(06(>",0#%*&32'(%#+(>'&,0#%*&32'..

Page 12: [American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - San Diego, California ()] AIAA SPACE 2008 Conference & Exposition - European Space Policy

T!K!T!SI!*

.X,0''?(;4%J(r\7%&()1%2"(60,(;*,01"e(N7"(E05"(06(&7"(;/(OP)Q(3#(^%&30#%5(P0,"38#(Q0532:](N7"(O%'"(06(X",9%#:r(!"7%'(7'%#%4$%,("$($?%("44&"*(.%%$245(+K($?%(L4$%'4"$2+4"*(6$&,2%#(M##+82"$2+40(-+4+*&*&0(-"<"22?(h*#"(RSScJ

Rh"%#Th%2[*"'(I0,+3%#?(lE"60,93#8(&7"(V*+8"&?(O7%#83#8(;*,01"m?(M(!&/*28(B+4#&*$"$2+4(B+..&428"$2+4?(R.(M%,27(RSScY;)>(Q0,&%5?(l;)>(%#+(&7"(;/m?(;)>(\"D'3&"?(/EH] (7&&1]ff@@@J"'%J3#&f"'%OQf);MP;Qs!.)It3#+"LtSJ7&95?(<>22"''"+(0#(h*#"(

Rc?(RSSc=Z;*,01"%#(O0993''30#?(l)1%2"](%(#"@(;*,01"%#(6,0#&3",(60,(%#("L1%#+3#8(/#30#m?(>#(>2&30#(Q5%#(60,(K915"9"#&3#8(&7"(;*,01"%#(

)1%2"(Q0532:(_\73&"(Q%1",?()1,3#8",?(F6632"(06(&7"(;*,01"%#(O099*#3&3"'?(RSSYJC>#+,"@(\35'0#(<"+J=?(lE"'05*&30#(06(&7"(;*,01"%#()1%2"(Q0532:?(>6M(:2'%8$+'(H%4%'"*N#(!'+7+#"*?(N7"(^"&7",5%#+'?(

;)>(O099*#32%&30#'(<VETR`A=?(h*#"(RSSBJ(`^3205%'(Q"&",?(l)1%2"(Q0532:?(K''*"'(%#+(N,"#+'(3#(RSS`fRSSBm?(>&'+7%"4(67"8%(!+*28)(L4#$2$&$%(O%7+'$(P?()"1&"9D",(RSSBJB(;)>(O099*#32%&30#'?(l>X;^I>(RS..(_(>(I02*9"#&(D:(&7"(I3,"2&0,(X"#",%5(%#+(I3,"2&0,'m?(>6M(Q&**%$24(FCE?(^04"9D",(RSS`Jc(;)>(Q*D532%&30#'?(l;)>(>##*%5(E"10,&(RSS`m?(>&'+7%"4(67"8%(M5%48)(<RSSB=JA()",830(!050#&"?(lO0'932(!3'30#(RS.CTRSRC(_(N7"(O%#+3+%&"(M3''30#'m(?(>6M(67"8%(682%48%(!*"44245?(F2&0D",(RSSBJ.Sa%,&@38(V3'27066?(lN7"()1%2"(E"'"%,27(@3&73#(&7"(PQBm?(682%48%("4,(G%8?4+*+5))(B%4$%'#(B+4K%'%48%?(H*D5-%#%?(M%,27(RSScJ..d%&7%,3#%()&0665?(lX%535"0(80"'(X50D%5](\7%&(&0("L1"2&(6,09(;*,01"(3#("'&%D53'73#8(&7"(#%438%&30#('%&"553&"(l':'&"9T06T':'&"9'm?(

>&'+7%"4(67"8%(!+*28)(L4#$2$&$%(R>6!LS(!%'#7%8$23%#(T?(h*5:(RSScJ.RO0993''30#(06( &7"(;*,01"%#(O099*#3&3"'?l;*,01"%#()1%2"(Q,08,%99"(_(Q,"5393#%,:("5"9"#&'m? (;*,01"%#(O0993''30#()&%66(

\0,$3#8(I02*9"#&?(V,*''"5'?(>1,35(RSSBJ.YQ3",,0(M"''3#%(i(P,%#20(F#8%,0?(l>*,0,%(_(N7"(;*,01"%#()1%2"(;L150,%&30#(Q,08,%99"m?(>6M(Q&**%$24(FFU?(>*8*'&(RSSYJ.ZI%43+(V"%&:?("&J%5?(lQ,"5393#%,:(Q5%##3#8(60,(%#(K#&",#%&30#%5(M%,'()%915"(E"&*,#(M3''30#m? (O%7+'$(+K($?%(2VMO6(RL4$%'4"$2+4"* (

V"'#(M'8?2$%8$&'%(K+'($?%(O%$&'4(+K(6".7*%#S(W+'=245(H'+&7?(h*#"(RSScJ.CQJOJ()390#?("&J%5?(lN7"(O7%#83#8(;%,&7](^"@()23"#&3632(O7%55"#8"'(60,(;)>W'(H343#8(Q5%#"&(Q,08,%99"m?(>6M(6!;FXDY?(RSS`J.`MJEJ(I,3#$@%&",?("&J%5?(lXFO;](;)>W'(P3,'&(;%,&7(;L150,",(O0,"(M3''30#m?(67"8%(682%48%(O%32%<#(F;FY?(N7"(^"&7",5%#+'?(RSSYJ.B;)>(Q*D532%&30#'?(l)035(M03'&*,"(%#+(F2"%#()%53#3&:(<)MF)=(P%2&()7""&m?(>6MN#(123245(!*"4%$(!'+5'"..%?(RSSBJ.c;)>(Q*D532%&30#'? ( l>IMT>"05*' (I0115", (\3#+ (H3+%, ( <I\H= (M3''30#? (6&.."') (+K ( $?% (M:V;M%+*&# (W+'=#?+7(>6MZ>6G>B?(

)"1&"9D",(RSS`J.A;)>(Q*D532%&30#'?(lO,:0'%&(M3''30#(E"[*3,"9"#&'(I02*9"#&m?(B6;O!;>6M;6[;DDUT?(h%#*%,:(RSSBJRS;)>(Q*D532%&30#'?(l)\>EM](N7"(;%,&7W'(M%8#"&32(P3"5+(%#+(;#43,0#9"#&(;L150,",'m?(>"'$?(>I7*+'%'(@#%'(B+4#&*$"$2+4(V%%$245?(

>1,35(RSSZJR.;)>(Q*D532%&30#'?(l;%,&7O>E;](N7"(;%,&7(O50*+'?(>",0'05'(%#+(E%+3%&30#(;L150,",m?(>"'$?(>I7*+'%'(@#%'(B+4#&*$"$2+4(V%%$245?(

>1,35(RSSZJRR;)>(Q*D532%&30#'?(lO%#+3+%&"(;%,&7(;L150,",'(3#(>''"''9"#&(Q7%'"m?(>6M(123245(!*"4%$(!'+5'"..%?(RSSBJRYQ3",,"(H30##"&?(lN7"(;*,01"%#()1%2"(K#+*'&,:(3#(RSSBm?(M6:;>&'+#7"8%(J"8$#(\(J25&'%#?(h*#"(RSScJ(RZ?RCO7,3'&3%#(O%D%5(%#+(a"#,3(E"405?(l)1%2"(Q0532:](a0@(&0(9%$"(;*,01"(\0,5+(H"%+",(3#(&7"()1%2"(I09%3#m?(O%7+'$(+4($?%(

!'24827"*(!'+5'".."$28(M'%"#(+K(J&$&'%(67"8%(!+*28)?(P,"#27(Q%,53%9"#&%,:(F6632"(60,()23"#&3632(%#+(N"27#050832%5(>''"''9"#&?(P"D,*%,:(RSSBJ

R`)&"17%#"(h%#327"@'$3?(l>(O0#&,%2&(D"&@""#(P,"#27(X04",#9"#&(%#+(O^;)(60,(&7"(RS.ST.C(N",9m?(B]>6(6$'"$%528(!*"44245?(M%:(

RSScJRBE%3#",()27%,"#D",8?(lIHE(3#()1%2"?(>",0#%*&32'?(N,%#'10,&(%#+(;#",8:m?(H%'."4(M%'+#7"8%(B%4$%'?(H-*D5-%#%?(M%,27((RSScJRc()1%2"(P0*#+%&30#?(lN7"()1%2"(E"10,&(RSSc](N7"(>*&70,3&%&34"(X*3+"(&0(X50D%5()1%2"(>2&343&:m?(CDDE^(

RA(V,3&3'7(^%&30#%5()1%2"(O"#&,"(<V^)O=?(l/d(O3435()1%2"()&,%&"8:](RSScTRS.R(%#+(D":0#+m?(/EH](@@@JD#'2J804J*$?(<>22"''"+(0#(

>*8*'&(.?(RSSc=JYS(X3*'"11"(M0,'3550?(l;)>T;/(h03#&(Q,0-"2&](P*&*,"(O7%55"#8"'_0L`?(>&'+7%"4(L4$%'7*"4%$"')(67"8%(B+4K%'%48%0(E09"?(RSSBJ

Y.(H:+3%(I0&&0?(lO%#%+%(%#+(N7"(;*,01"%#()1%2"(>8"#2:](N7,""(I"2%+"'(06(O001",%&30#m?(>6M(-6O;CU?(M%:(RSSR

YR(O7%,50&&"(M%&73"*?(l>''"''3#8(E*''3%W'()1%2"(O001",%&30#(@3&7(O73#%(%#+(K#+3%(_(F110,&*#3&3"'(%#+(O7%55"#8"'(60,(;*,01"m?(

>&'+7%"4(67"8%(!+*28)(L4#$2$&$%(O%7+'$(FC?(h*#"(RSScJYY(V%&"'(X355(%#+(M"53''%(M*,17:?(lO73#%T;*,01"(E"5%&30#'](K91532%&30#'(%#+(Q0532:(E"'10#'"'(60,(&7"(/#3&"+()&%&"'m?(M(O%7+'$(+K($?%(

B6L6(J'%%."4(B?"2'(24(B?24"(6$&,2%#?(M%:(RSScJYZ(;*,01"%#()1%2"(>8"#2:(M*5&39"+3%?(lN7"(X50D%5(;L150,%&30#()&,%&"8:](N7"(P,%9"@0,$(60,(O00,+3#%&30#m?(M(,+8&.%4$(7'+,&8%,(

/)(M6L(RL$"*)S0(Q]6B(R@AS0(B]>6(RJ'"48%S0(B]6M(RB?24"S0(B6M(RB"4","S0(B6LOa(RM&#$'"*2"S0(:1O(RH%'."4)S0(>6M(R>&'+7%"4(67"8%(

M5%48)S0(L6Oa(RL4,2"S0(bM`M(Rb"7"4S0(AMOL(RO%7&/*28(+K(A+'%"S0(]M6M(R@6MS0(]6M@(R@='"24%S0(O+#8+#.+#(RO&##2"S?(M%:(RSSBJYC(^"@)23"#&3'&)1%2"(>,&325"?(l^%&30#'()38#(H%#+9%,$(H*#%,(;L150,%&30#(>8,""9"#&m?(@O19(

?$$79ZZ#7"8%^4%<#82%4$2#$^8+.Z"'$28*%Z.5FTTCPPcX^XDD;424%;4"$2+4#;#254;*"4,."'=;*&4"';%I7*+'"$2+4;"5'%%.%4$^?$.*(RM88%##%,(+4(b&*)(

XF0(CDDES^Y`(NJ(M0,8%#?("&J%5?(lNa;(K^N;E^>NKF^>H(H/^>E(^;N\FEd(>^OaFE(^FI;)(MK))KF^u>(/J()J(O0#&,3D*&30#(&0(&7"(

K#&",#%&30#%5(H*#%,(^"&@0,$m?(;*,01"%#(Q5%#"&%,:()23"#2"(O0#8,"''?(;Q)O(>D'&,%2&'?(!05J(Y?(;Q)ORSScT>TSSCYc?(R(SScJ

>9",32%#(K#'&3&*&"(06(>",0#%*&32'(%#+(>'&,0#%*&32'.R