Upload
others
View
2
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Annual Review for the period ended 31 December
Printed by MLG, Edinburgh
Alliance Trust PLC 8 West Marketgait Dundee DD1 1QN
Tel +44 (0)1382 321000 Email [email protected]
www.alliancetrust.co.uk
Contact
Dividend Source: Alliance Trust
9.00p
8.395p
8.15p
8.00p
7.90p
2011 (Dec)
2011 (Jan)
2009 (Jan)†
2010 (Jan)
2008 (Jan)
Pence 0 2 4 6 8 10
† excludes special dividend of 0.5p
Company highlightsContents
Objective and Corporate Structure 2Chairman’s Statement 4Chief Executive’s Review 6Key Performance Indicators 10Portfolio Review 12Subsidiary Businesses 18Risk Factors 20Corporate Responsibility 22Summary Financial Performance 24Summary Directors’ Report 25Directors 26Summary Directors’ Remuneration 28Independent Auditor’s Report 31Summary Financial Statements 32Information for Shareholders 34
Net Asset Value Source: Alliance Trust
405.8p
439.0p
377.7p
316.8p
402.3p
2011 (Dec)
2011 (Jan)
2009 (Jan)
2010 (Jan)
2008 (Jan)
Pence 0 100 200 300 400 500
Share Price Source: FactSet
342.8p
364.0p
313.0p
268.0p
338.0p
2011 (Dec)
2011 (Jan)
2009 (Jan)
2010 (Jan)
2008 (Jan)
Pence 0 100 200 300 400 500
Total Expense Ratio Source: Alliance Trust
0.65%
0.63%
0.69%
0.70%
0.54%
2011 (Dec)*
* Annualised
2011 (Jan)
2009 (Jan)
2010 (Jan)
2008 (Jan)
% 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8
9.00pDividend
• OutperformedGlobalGrowthSectoraverage
• Ranked5th,6th,10thand10thoutof32membersoftheGlobalGrowthSectorover1,3,6monthsandtheperiod
• TopquartileTotalShareholderReturnwithintheGlobalGrowthSector
• Ranked6thoutofthe32membersoftheGlobalGrowthSectorfortheperiod
• Dividendof9.00p,anincreaseof7.2%onlastyear
• 45thconsecutivedividendincreaseandhighestincreaseinregulardividendsin20years
• Paidoutofcurrentyearearnings
• CostsremaininthelowestquartilewithintheGlobalGrowthSector
Net Asset Value(pershare)
405.8pNetAssetValue
342.8pSharePrice
0.65%TotalExpenseRatio
-5.7%
-3.5%
7.2%
2bps
Total Return
Total Shareholder
Return
2|Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011
Who we are What we did in 2011 What we will do in 2012Statement of Investment
Objective and Policy
AllianceTrustisaself-managedinvestmentcompanywithinvestmenttruststatus.Ourobjectiveistobeacoreinvestmentforinvestorsseekingincreasingvalueoverthelongterm.Wehavenofixedassetallocationbenchmarkandweinvestinawiderangeofassetclassesthroughouttheworldtoachieveourobjective.Ourfocusistogeneratearealreturnforshareholdersoverthemediumtolongtermbyacombinationofcapitalgrowthandarisingdividend.
Wepursueourobjectiveby:
• Investinginbothquotedandunquotedequitiesacrosstheglobeindifferentsectorsandindustries;
• Investinginternationallyinfixedincomesecurities;
• Investinginotherassetclassesandfinancialinstruments,eitherdirectlyorthroughinvestmentvehicles;and
• Investinginsubsidiariesandassociatedbusinesseswhichallowustoexpandintootherrelatedactivities.
Wearepreparedtoinvestanyproportionofthetotalcorporatecapitalinanyoftheaboveassetclasses,subjectonlytotherestrictionsimposedonusbytheregulatoryorfiscalregimewithinwhichweoperate.However,wewouldexpectequitiestocompriseatleast50%ofourportfolio.Changestotheassetallocationwillbedependentuponattractiveinvestmentopportunitiesbeingavailable.
Wheremarketconditionspermit,wewillusegearingofnotmorethan30%ofournetassetsatanygiventime.Wecanusederivativeinstrumentstohedge,enhanceandprotectpositions,includingcurrencyexposures.
Weareaninvestmenttrustwhosepurposeistogrowthevalueofthecapitalthatourshareholdershaveinvestedwithus.Thishasbeenouraimforover120yearsandwemaintainaprudentapproachtoinvestmentwithanemphasisonlongtermreturns.
WearetheUK’slargestgeneralistinvestmenttrustbymarketvaluelistedontheLondonStockExchange.Asat31December2011wemanagednetassetsofover£2.4bn.
Ourfocusisoninvestmentinglobalequitiesandfixedincome,whichwebelievewillprovidegoodlongtermgrowthandincome.Wealsoholdotherinvestmentswhereweseethatvaluecanbeachievedoveralongerperiod.Theserepresentedonlyasmallproportionofournetassetsattheperiodend.
AllianceTrustPLC
AllianceTrustInvestments
Weareaboutiquefundmanagementbusinesswhichlauncheditsfirstfundin2009andwhichoffersabroadselectionofopenendedfundsandinvestmentsolutions.Asat31December2011wemanagedthirdpartyassetsofover£125m.
OurpurposeistoutilisetheexperienceandskillsofthemanagerswhoinvesttheTrust’sfundstoprovideaflexibleandbespokeservicewhichwillaimtoattractthirdpartyassets.ThiswillprovidetheTrustwithanadditionalprofileand,throughthemanagementfeeincomeearnedasthelevelofinvestmentsgrows,anadditionalrevenuestream.
AllianceTrustSavings
Since1986wehavebeenprovidingataxefficientwayforshareholderstoholdsharesinAllianceTrust.Todayweprovidehighqualityfinancialproductstoprivateinvestors,financialadvisersanddiscretionaryfundmanagers.
Overthelastthreeyearsthebusinesshasbeensignificantlydevelopedandisnowanestablished,awardwinning,ISAandpensionproviderwithacomprehensiveonlinesharedealingandinvestmentplatformservice.
ThefocusistohaveabusinesswhichbothaddsvalueandincreasesthevisibilityoftheTrusttopotentialinvestors.
Alliance Trust PLC(Investment Trust)
Alliance Trust Savings(Financial Products)
Alliance TrustInvestments
(Asset Management)
ObjectiveandCorporateStructure
Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011|3
Monthly IncomeBond Fund
Europe
Asia-Paci�c 44.6
12.6
154.3
33.9
207.5
52.7
45.0
Global
Japan
North America
UK
0£millions 50 100 150 200 250
Funds by Value (£m) at 31 Dec 2011 Source: Alliance Trust
(7.7)Net Debt
% -20 0 20 40 60 80 100
Other Assets(inc subs)
Fixed Income
Quoted Equities 96.4
5.0
3.3
0.9
2.1
Private Equity
Property
Holdings (%) at 31 Dec 2011 Source: Alliance Trust
Transactional chargesRecurring fee income
Interest earned on deposits
Other income
21.2%
26.0%
40.8%
12.0%
Revenue source (%)
Source: Alliance Trust
We will continue the work that has been taking place over the last few years and which has been aimed at streamlining the portfolio to deliver improved investment performance.
We will seek to deliver strong performance in order to narrow the discount between our Net Asset Value and share price.
Who we are What we did in 2011 What we will do in 2012
Wehaverestructuredourequityexposuretoconcentrateonfourgeographicalregions:UK,NorthAmerica,EuropeandAsia.
Weboughtbackover10%ofoursharecapital.
Ournetdebtendedtheperiodat7.7%ofnetassetsdownfrom10.8%atthebeginningoftheperiod.
Wereducedourprivateequityandpropertyinvestments.
OurTotalShareholderReturnwasinthetopquartileoftheGlobalGrowthSectorfortheperiod.
We will launch new funds where we have the appropriate level of skills and identify a demand. In addition to the existing funds, all of which are available to individuals as well as institutional investors, we will increase awareness of the skills of our investment team to attract third party fund management mandates.
WerecruitedadditionalresourcetotargetbothIndependentFinancialAdvisersandtheinstitutionalinvestmentmarket.
WesawsignificantinflowsofthirdpartyassetsintoourMonthlyIncomeBondFund.
AttheendoftheperiodanewGlobalThematicOpportunityFundwaslaunched.
Welaunchedinternationalequities,ajuniorISAandalsorepricedourproducts.
WerestructuredourbusinessmodeltomakeitlessreliantonbaseratesandwideneddistributionthroughtheIndependentFinancialAdvisermarket.
Wesawsignificantyearonyearnewaccountgrowthofaround80%.
We will build on the growth and momentum achieved in recent years. We will continue to enhance our customer and adviser propositions and further significantly develop our online capabilities. Our i.nvest platform is well positioned in both the retail and intermediated markets to take full advantage of the changes being introduced through the Retail Distribution Review in 2013.
4|Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011
Chairman’sStatement
Investment performance
InmyfinalChairman’sstatementIampleasedtoreportthecontinuingimprovementininvestmentperformanceduringtheyearagainsttheKeyPerformanceIndicatorswhichwesetoutinlastyear’sreview.OverthefinancialperiodourTotalShareholderReturnandNetAssetValuetotalreturnranked6/32and10/32respectivelyagainstourpeergroupofGlobalGrowthinvestmenttrustscomparedto24/33and22/33inthepreviousyear.WecontinuedtogrowthedividendandmaintainedtightcontroloftheCompany’scoststoreflectthechallengingmarketconditions.Investmentperformanceremainsourtoppriorityandthisfocuswillcontinueunderthechairmanshipofmysuccessor,KarinForseke.
Dividend
Werecognisethatmanyofourshareholdersdependonasteadilyrisingdividendalongsidecapitalgrowth.Wehavemaintainedourrecordofannualincreasesinthedividendfora45thconsecutiveyear,withanincreaseinthefullyeardividendof7.2%from8.395ppershareto9.00ppersharedespitetheshortened11monthfinancialperiodfollowingthechangeofouryearend.Importantly,thisdividendiscoveredfromearningsandwehavenotneededtocallonourreserves.Theestablishmentofourfixedincometeamhasgivenusgreaterflexibilitytomeetshareholders’expectationswhilecontinuingtoinvestinequitieswhereweseegrowthopportunities.
Discount and share buybacks
Therewasmuchdebateaboutthediscountbetweenoursharepriceandournetassetvalueduringtheyear.Aresolutiontointroducearigiddiscountcontrolmechanismwhichwasrequisitionedbyashareholderwasdefeatedbyasubstantialmajorityatour2011AGMfollowinganunprecedentedturnoutfromourshareholders.TheBoardwasclearthroughoutinitsviewthatarigidmechanism,whichfailstotakeintoaccountfactorssuchasperformance,peergroupdiscountsandgeneralmarketconditions,isnotappropriateforAllianceTrust.
InourmanymeetingswithshareholdersoverthisperiodwerecognisedconcernsastothelevelofdiscountandtheBoardgavecarefulconsiderationtotheactionswhichcouldbetakentonarrowthediscount.FollowingtheAGMinMay2011weconfirmedourcommitmenttotheongoingflexibleuseofbuybacks,takingintoaccounttheCompany’sdiscountrelativetothepeergroup.Duringtheperiodunderreviewweboughtbackjustover10%oftheCompany’ssharecapital.Thiscontributedtoareductioninthevolatilityofthediscountduringaperiodofturbulentmarketconditionsandtoanarrowingfrom
“2011wasayearinwhichyourCompanyhadtoconfrontthechallengesarisingfromdifficulteconomicandmarketconditions.Attheendoftheyear,althoughweforeseecontinueduncertainty,particularlyintheEurozone,IbelievethatyourCompanyiswellplacedtotakeadvantageoftheopportunitieswhichmayemerge.“
LesleyKnox
Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011|5
17.1%to15.5%.OverhalfofthoseshareswereboughtbackbetweenMayandJuly2011,withbuybackscontinuingthroughouttheremainderoftheperiod.Wewouldnotexpecttomaintainthislevelofbuybackactivityinnormalmarketconditions.
The Board
IwritethisstatementwiththanksfortheguidanceandsupportIhavereceivedfromshareholders,otherdirectorsandmanagementthroughoutmy10yearsontheBoardofyourCompany,andalsowithoptimismforitsfutureunderKarinForseke,whowillbecomeChairmanon2AprilwhenIstanddownfromtheBoard.Karin’sextensiveexperienceoffinancialservicesandherinternationalperspectivemakeherideally-suitedtotheopportunitiesandchallengeswhichthefuturewillbring.
SincethelastAGMwehavewelcomedConsueloBrooketotheBoardasanon-executivedirector.Consuelo’sexperienceofover40yearsasafundmanagerunderlinestheBoard’srecognitionthatinvestmentperformanceisattheheartofyourCompany,andshewillbeaworthysuccessortoHughBollandwhosadlyhasdecidedtoretireatthisyear’sAGM.Hughhasplayedanimportantrolebothasanon-executivedirectorofyourCompanyandlatterlyasthechairmanofourassetmanagementbusiness,andIamgratefultohimforhiscontribution.
TimothyIngramhasalsodecidednottostandforre-electionbecauseofanticipatedincreasedcommitmentselsewhere.IwouldliketothankhimforhiswisecounselandinsightduringhistimeontheBoard,duringwhichhehasalsoservedasChairmanoftheRemunerationCommittee.
ChrisMasters,whohasbeenanon-executivedirectorsince2002andSeniorIndependentDirectorsince2007,wouldalsohaveretiredatthisyear’sAGMhavingservednineyears.Howeverhehasagreedtostandforre-electionand,ifre-elected,willremainontheBoardforaperiodofupto12monthstoassistwiththetransitionoftheBoard.RobertBurgessstooddownasChiefExecutiveofAllianceTrustSavingsandlefttheBoardinFebruary2012.HeleaveswithourthanksfortheworkhehasdoneindevelopingAllianceTrustSavingsandourbestwishesforthefuture.
Duringtheyear,followingpublicationofLordDavies’review“WomenonBoards”,therehasbeenacontinuingdebateabouttheimportanceofdiversityonboardsoflistedcompanies.YourBoardwholeheartedlyendorsesthis;diversitybringsdifferentperspectivestobearontheopportunitiesandchallengesfacingeverycompany.WehavechosennottoadoptatargetforgenderdiversityandourpolicythroughouttheCompanyisasimpleone–atalllevelstoappointthebest-qualifiedpersonforthejob.
Currentlywomencompriseone-thirdoftheBoardandofourExecutiveCommittee,whichincludestheexecutivedirectorsandotherseniorexecutives.Womencomprisearoundone-quarterofourSeniorLeadershipGroupandmorethanhalfofourtotalworkforcearewomen.Wecontinuetoencouragethedevelopmentofallemployeestoequipthemforboththeircurrentandfutureroles.
Scottish independence
WenotetheproposalbytheScottishGovernmenttoholdareferendumonScottishindependencein2014.YourBoarddoesnotbelieveitisappropriatetotakeapoliticalstanceonthisissue–itwillbefortheelectoratetocasttheirvotesastheyseefithavingheardthearguments.WewillhoweverendeavourtoensurethattheimplicationsofanindependentScotlandinareassuchaseconomicandfiscalpolicyandregulationoffinancialservicesareclearlyspeltout.Inparticularwewillwishtoestablishthatthebenefitsofinvestmenttruststatusandthepositionofourinvestorsandcustomers,wherevertheylive,willbepreservedinordertoensurethatthestrengthofScotland’sinvestmentsectorispreservedregardlessoftheoutcomeofthevote.
Annual General Meeting
OurAnnualGeneralMeetingwillbeheldinDundeeonFriday27April2012.IthasbeenanhonourtoserveasChairmanofyourCompanyandIhaveenjoyedmeetingmanyshareholdersovertheyears.IhopethatasmanyofyouaspossiblewilltaketheopportunitytoattendtowelcomeKarin,whowillbechairingherfirstAGM,andtomeettherestoftheBoardaswellashearingaboutyourCompany’sprogressandoutlook.
6|Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011
ChiefExecutive’sReview
(8.0%) 10/32
Peer Group* RankingAlliance1 Feb to
31 Dec 2011
(5.7%)NAV Total Return
Total Shareholder Return
(8.6%) 6/32(3.5%)
* Global Growth Sector
Overview
2011wasayearinwhichthemarketsweredrivenbynon-financialnews.Theyearstartedwithaseriesofnaturaldisasters.ThehumansufferingwasinstantlyvisiblearoundtheworldasimagesoffloodsinQueensland,earthquakesinChristchurchandthedevastatingtsunamiinNorthEastJapan,werebroadcastacrosssocialmedianetworks.Thefullscaleofthedisastertothosecaughtupintheseeventscannotbefullyunderstoodbymostpeople,andthehumancostoftheFukushimatsunamiisincalculable.
Thefocusoftheworld’spressthenmovedtoNorthAfrica,wheretheArabspringuprisingspreadeastfromTunisiathroughNorthAfricaandonintotheMiddleEast.
Whilemarketsdidnotreactparticularlytotheuprisings,theydidreactwhenthefinancialcrisisinEuropehittheheadlinesinJuly,tothepointwherethemarketstookfrightand,despiteregularmeetingsofEuropeanleaders,westillseemtobealongwayawayfromfindingasolutionthatwillsatisfyinvestorsforthelong-term.ThistimelastyearourviewwasthattheEurowouldsurvive.ThereisnoexitclauseintheTreatiesandthereforethereisnolegalwayinwhichacountrycanbeexpelled,noryetexpelitself.Overthelastyear,therehasbeenasubtle,butperceptiblechangetothatthinkingandmorepeopleareconsideringhowtomitigateandcontainwhatislikelytobeahugelydifficultexperienceforall.
WhiletheEurodominatedtheheadlinesoverthesummer,itwasnottheonlyregionwherefinancialdevelopmentsaffectedthemarkets.InearlyAugust,theUSmarketsuffereditslargestonedayfallsinceNovember2008whentheratingsagency,Standard&Poors,downgradedthecreditratingoftheUnitedStates.Thiswasthefirstinaseriesofsuchevents,themostrecentofwhichhasbeenthedowngradingofFrance,AustriaandsevenotherEuropeancountries.TheeffectofthelattereventistoincreasethecostoffundingfortheEuropeanFinancialStabilityFacility(EFSF),whichinturn,increasesthecostofbailingoutEurope.
TheUKwasnotimmunefromtheseevents.TheausteritypackageimplementedbytheCoalitionhasbeenrelativelywellreceived,withtheresultthatborrowingcostsfortheUKGovernmenthavereducedsignificantly,unlikethemeteoricriseexperiencedinSouthernEurope.ThegrowthoftheUKeconomyhasbeensluggishatbestandthereisconcernthatcurrentplanswillacttostifleanysignsofrecovery.Inflationhas,however,stabilisedandstartedtofall.
TheoverallincreaseinthelevelsofindebtednessoftheUSGovernmentisalarmingandwillcontinuetoactasadragoneconomicgrowthbutquantitativeeasingandmonetarypolicyhavekeptfundingcostsclosetoalltimelows.
“Ourperformanceovertheperiodunderlinesourabilitytoprotecttheportfoliofromthejarringshocksthathavebecomesomuchofafeatureofequitymarketsoverthelastfouryears.Wehavealsomanagedtogenerateincreasedlevelsofincomethatenableustopay,outofcurrentyearearnings,asubstantiallyincreaseddividend.”
KatherineGarrett-Cox
Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011|7
Portfolio performance and attribution
Forthefirsttime,weareprovidingperformanceattributionfortheTrust.Thiswillhelpexplainhow,whyandwheretheTrusthasperformedagainstaspecifiedreferencepoint.Wewillusethistoaidunderstandingbutitisimportanttorecognisethattheportfoliodifferssignificantlyfromthatofthereferenceindexintermsofweightingsanditisanticipatedthatthiswillremainthecasegoingforward.Thisshouldthereforenotbeviewedasafixedassetallocationbenchmark.Wewillcontinuetomanagetheportfolioonthebasisoftheunderlyingfundamentalsofthecompaniesconcernedwiththeobjectiveofprotectingandgrowingourshareholders’capitalirrespectiveoftheregionalandsectorweightingsoftheindex.Ourinvestmentstyleisfocusedonthedriversofinvestmentperformanceintheequityportfolio.
TotalShareholderReturn(TSR)outperformedtheNAVTotalReturn(NAVTR)by2.2%,asaresultoftheclosingofthediscountfrom17.1to15.5%andtheNAVTRoutperformedthereferencepointbyafurther0.2%.Thiswasprimarilydowntothesuccessfulassetallocationdecisions,mostnotablybymaintainingoverweightpositionsinUKequitiesandfixedincome,andunderweightintheunderperformingEuropean,AsianandEmergingMarkets,whichadded0.5%totheoutperformance,tacticalallocationdecisionswhichaddedafurther0.2%andbuybackswhichadded1.7%.Overallstockselectionwasnegative0.3%,althoughacrossthequotedequityportionoftheTrustwasneutralovertheperiod.ThecostofrunningtheTrustinperformancetermsis0.6%andtheimpactofgearingreducedthereturnbyafurther0.9%asmarketsfell.
Income Generation
Weareparticularlypleasedtobeabletodeclareadividendfortheperiodof9.0p,up7.2%onlastyearandpaidoutofcurrentyearearnings.Overthelastsixyearswehavebeenworkingtorebuildtherevenuereservestothepointwheretheyrepresentnearlytwoyears’dividendcover,enablingustodistributeagreaterproportionofthecurrentyearearnings.Goingforward,wewillstrivetopayagrowingdividendfromcurrentyearearningsconsciousthat,formanyofourshareholders,theimportanceofthedividendthatAllianceTrustpaysouthasincreasedsignificantlyoverthelastfouryears.Thisisparticularlyrelevantasinterestrateshavefallentohistoricallylowlevels.
AverywelcomedevelopmentoverrecentyearshasbeentheinitiationofdividendpaymentsbyAsiancompanies.TogetherwiththecontributionfromourFixedIncomefund,thishasallowedustoadjustourregionalassetallocationawayfromtheUK,withoutforegoingsignificantlevelsofincome.Aswehavegrownconcernedabouttheshort-termoutlookforequitymarkets,sowehavemovedtheportfoliotobemoredefensivelypositioned.Despitethisshiftwehavebeenabletogenerateayieldofover3%fromourAsianassets,somethingthatwouldhavebeeninconceivableevenfiveyearsago.However,theUKcontinuestoprovideconsistentdividendsastotalpayouttoshareholdersrosebynearly20%toarecord£67.8bnin2011.
Asset Stock Average Average Allocation Selection Attribution Weight (%) Return (%) Weight (%) Return (%) (%) (%)
UK 32.1 (2.7) 8.2 (2.9) 0.7 0.1
NorthAmerica 24.9 (1.3) 46.3 0.9 (1.5) (0.6)
EuropeexUK 13.6 (13.0) 17.4 (16.8) 0.4 0.5
Asia 17.0 (10.9) 21.8 (11.4) 0.3 0.1
Global 4.4 (11.8) 3.0 (6.2) (0.0) (0.2)
EmergingMarkets 4.2 (10.3) 3.3 (13.2) (0.1) 0.1
Contribution from Equities 96.2 (5.8) 100.0 (5.9) (0.2) 0.0
FixedIncome 4.3 (0.1) 0.0 0.0 0.5 (0.3)
OtherAssets 7.8 (0.5) 0.0 0.0 (0.0) (0.0)
Discretionary Assets 108.3 (6.4) 100.0 (5.9) 0.3 (0.3)
Expenses (0.6)
Cash 3.3 0.5
ImpactofGearing (11.6) (0.9)
EffectofBuybacks 1.7
Total Return 100.0 (5.7) 100.0 (5.9)
Source:AllianceTrust
Alliance Trust FTSE All World Index
Asset Allocation: measurestheeffectofstrategicallyoverweightingorunderweightingassetclassescomparedtothereferencepoint,theFTSEAllWorldIndex.
Stock Selection: measureshowthestockswithineachassetclasshaveperformedcomparedtothereferencepoint,theFTSEAllWorldIndex.Effect of Buybacks: measurestheeffectofdecreasingthenumberofsharesinissuethroughsharebuybacks.Impact of Gearing: measurestheimpactofborrowingsontheportfolioreturn.
8|Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011
ChiefExecutive’sReview
EmergingMarkets
AsiaEuropeNorthAmerica
UK
% Geographic weight Revenue split
Revenue
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
37.3
7.0
28.730.4
15.119.7 18.9
23.0
9.5
Source: Alliance Trust
Asset Allocation
DuringtheyearwehavecontinuedtheprocessoffocusingtheTrustbackonitscorecompetencies;investinginequitiesandfixedincome.InMarch,weannouncedthedecisiontoexittheprivateequitymarketandwehavenowsignificantlyreducedourexposuretothatassetclass.Wehavemorethanhalvedourundrawncommitmentsandwillnotbetakingonanynewliabilities.WehavealsomanagedtosellourexistingholdingsatNAVorbetter,reflectingthequalityoftheassetsheldintheportfolio.WehavealsocontinuedtoselldownourpropertyportfolioandbytheendofDecember2011retainedonlytwoofourproperties;weoccupythepropertyinEdinburghandwealsoownMonteithHouseinGlasgow.
Wehavestreamlinedourequityportfoliostofocusonthefourmainregionsofexpertise:theUK,NorthAmerica,EuropeandAsia.AlthoughweremainpessimisticabouttheUKeconomy,wecontinuetohaveover30%oftheportfoliolistedintheUKaswerecognisethatalistingintheUKisnotsynonymouswithexposuretotheUKeconomy.Infact,ouranalysisshowsthatwhiletheUKportfoliorepresentsover30%ofourequityportfolioonthebasisofwhereourinvestmentsarelisted,only7%oftheincomeearnedbythecompaniesinwhichweinvestissourcedintheUK.AsthemarketpeakedinearlyJuly,wetookadvantageoftherallytorefocustheportfolioandreducedouremergingmarketexposure,allowingustoincreaseourexposuretomoredevelopedmarkets.ThiswasfollowedbyafurtherreductionintheAsianportfolioandageneralshifttowardsamoredefensiveslanttotheportfolioasStandard&PoorsdowngradedthecreditratingoftheUSinearlyAugust.
Wewereactiveinthederivativesmarket.Howeverthiswaslimitedtoassistingwithmarkettimingforefficientportfoliomanagement.Wewouldtypicallyinvestinfuturesinordertoadjusttheregionalweighting,andthenexpectthatthefundmanagerwouldunwindthepositionintoorfromhisunderlyingassets.
Managingthecurrencyexposureintheportfolioisanintegralpartofourinvestmentprocess.OvertheyearwetookadvantageoftheflexibilityofourmulticurrencybankingfacilitytoborrowinEuroswiththeviewthatthecurrencywouldweaken.ByreducingourexposuretotheweakeningEurowehelpedprotectthevalueofourunderlyingequityholdings.InthethirdquarteroftheyeartherelativestrengthofSterlingagainsttheUSdollaralsogaveusanopportunitytoincreaseourweightingtothedollarandthenunwindourpositionasthepoundsubsequentlyweakened.Bothofthesestrategiesaddedtoperformance.Currencyfluctuationscanhaveasignificantimpactonthevalueofouroverseasholdingsandwecontinuetomonitorsuchmovementsandtakeactiontoprotectagainstthem.
Gearing
Wehavelongbeenabletocommandverycompetitiveratesofborrowing,whichaveraged2.0%attheendoftheyear.Wehavebeenabletoexploittheshort-termnatureofourborrowingfacilitiestoadjustourlevelofexposuretoequitymarketsinordertoreflectourrelativelevelofconfidenceintheoutlookforthevariousassetclasses.Overtheperiodwehavereducedthelevelofnetdebtfrom10.8%atthestartoftheyearto£184m(7.7%ofnetassets)aswebecameincreasinglyconcernedabouttheimplicationsoftheEurozonecrisisoverthesummer.Wemaintainanongoingprogrammeofrenewingandreplacingborrowingfacilitiestoprovideuswiththeflexibilitytoenhanceequityreturnsbygearingtheportfolio.
Risk
AssessinginvestmentriskisafundamentalpartofmanagingtheTrust’sassets.Weseektodiversifyriskacrosstheportfoliobyinvestinginover200discreteholdingsacrossdifferentassetclasses,regionsandsectors.Someoftheseassetsarecorrelatedbutbyspreadingtheriskacrossthisnumberofholdingsweaimtoreducethesinglestockspecificrisksignificantlytherebykeepingvolatilitylower.Weutiliseanindustrystandardriskmodeltoanalysethetechnicalaspectsofrisksandlooktoachieveabalancebetweenriskandrewardwhenconsideringportfoliostructure.Wemanagetheportfoliorisksactivelyandlooktoreduceriskintimesofuncertaintyandincreaseitwhenouroutlookismorefavourable.
Outlook
ItseemsinevitablethatpoliticswillcontinuetodrivemarketsentimentacrosstheglobeuntiltheuncertaintiesinEuropeandthemacroeconomicissuessubside.Therearemajorissuesfacingpolicy-makersintheUK,EuropeandtheUS.ForthcomingpresidentialelectionsinFranceandtheUSlaterthisyearwillcausefurtheruncertaintyandtheFrenchelection,inparticular,islikelytoleadtoachangeofpolitical
Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011|9
Investmentcredibilitycomesprimarilyfromtheperformanceoftheportfoliorelativetoourpeers.Inordertoachievethisweneedtoensurethatwehavethepeople,systemsandprocessesinplace.
Wehavedemonstratedourabilitytodeliverperformanceinturbulentequitymarketsandwearefocusedonmakingthedecision-makingprocessmoreflexibleinorderthatwecanidentifysystemicchangestotheoutlookonamoretimelybasis.
Torestoreinvestmentcredibility
Toregenerateourinvestorbase
WeareworkingtoincreasethelevelofunderstandingoftheTrustwithaviewtoensuringthatthereissustainabledemandforthesharesoftheTrust,whichwillinturnhelptodeliveranarrowerdiscount.
Webelievethatourcoreshareholderisandshouldultimatelyremaintheprivateinvestor.Weprovideaccesstoequityinvestmentsfromallovertheworld,whichweunderstandismoreappealingtothoseinvestorswhodonothavetheresourcestoundertaketheirownregionallydiversifiedassetallocation.Themostcost-effectivewaytoachievethisistofocusonthosewhoadviseandmanagetheportfoliosofprivateindividuals.
Key Priorities
Since2009wehavefocusedonfivekeyprioritieswhichwebelievedwerenecessarytoenableustoachieveourobjectiveofdeliveringlong-termvalueforshareholders.
Theseweretofocusoninvestmentinequities,continuetoimproveinvestmentperformance,manageourcostbaseinlinewithmarketconditions,developoursubsidiarybusinessesandinvestinthedevelopmentofourpeople.
Goingforward,wewillconcentrateondeliveringagainstthetwooverarchingprioritiesbelow.
direction,whereasweexpectlittlechangefromtheUSelectioninNovember.EuropewilldoubtlessdominatethenewsintheshorttermaspoliticiansstruggletoresolvethecomplexproblemoftheEuro.Atthetimeofwriting,theGreekdefaultissuewouldseemtobeinabeyancehoweverourcentralcaseisthattheissuehasnotbeenpermanentlyresolvedandsomeformofdefault,leadingtotheeventualdepartureofGreecefromtheEuro,willprobablyoccurinthenextcoupleofyears.Closertohome,austeritymeasuresarelikelytoleadtoaprolongedperiodofweakgrowthandfurtherpressureontheconsumer.AcrossWesterneconomiesweanticipatefurtherquantitativeeasingwillbedeployed,shouldgrowthstallfurther.
Againstthisbackdrop,equitymarketsarelikelytoremainvolatileintheshortterm,howeverequitiesremaingoodvaluerelativetootherassets,particularlygovernmentbondsandtheyremainourfavouredassetclass.Corporatebalancesheetsremainrobustandvaluationsforsomecompanieslookcompelling,particularlyforlong-terminvestorssuchasAllianceTrust.Manycompanieshaveweatheredthisfinancialstormbetterthantheydidin2008andareinamuchstrongerpositiontocapitaliseonanyrecovery.Theyhavereducedtheirlevelsofborrowingandwhatremainsiscostingthemlesstoservice.Theyhavealsobuiltupsignificantcashreservesandarewaitingfortheopportunitytoputittoworkinthemarketwhentheyfeelmoreconfidentabouttheeconomicoutlook.
Wearenotcurrentlyforecastingaglobalrecession,althoughwebelievethattheissueisfinelybalanced.InvestorsarewaitingforconfirmationthattherecentpickupineconomicactivityissustainableinordertobringthembackintothemarketandawayfromUK,USandGermangovernmentbondswheresomerecentauctionshavepricedwithnegativerealyields.Weconsiderthatthispositionisunsustainableandthatacorrectionisoverdueandourexposuretothisassetclassislargelyrestrictedtocorporate,notgovernmentbonds.Ourcentralcaseisthattherecoveryofequitymarketswillbealongdrawn-outaffair,butasweinvestforthelongterm,thisprovidesinterestinginvestmentopportunities.Weseecompaniestradingatvaluationsthatdonotreflecttheirtrueworthandtheopportunity,onastock-specificbasis,toinvestatlevelswehavenotseenforsometime.Theproblemthereforeisnotsomuchthedirectionthatmarketswilltake,butquitewhentheywillsetoff.
10|Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011
Key Performance Performance What we did during Indicators the period
WereporthereonthefourKeyPerformanceIndicators(KPIs)thatweusetomonitorthefinancialperformanceofourbusiness.
ThesemeasuresprovidetheBoardwiththeinformationitrequirestomonitorhowourperformancematchesourstrategyandobjectivesascontainedinourbusinessplan.
EachoftheseKPIsformpartoftheCorporateTargetswhichareusedtodeterminerewardsforourExecutiveDirectors.
PercentagechangeinNetAssetValueagainstthepeergroupover6months,1,3and5yearsonarollingbasis.
ThiswasselectedasameasuretoshowhowourinvestmentperformanceranksagainstotherinvestmenttrustsintheAICGlobalGrowthsector.Weconsiderperformancefromtheshorttothelongterm.
PercentagechangeinTotalShareholderReturnagainstthepeergroupover6months,1,3and5yearsonarollingbasis.
ThisKPIcomplementsthefirstKPIastheBoardisconsciousthatinvestmentperformanceofitselfdoesnotalwaysreflectthereturntoourshareholders.Againweconsiderperformancefromtheshorttothelongterm.
Dividendgrowthover1,3and5years.
WehaveanestablishedpolicyofpayingaprogressivedividendandbyincorporatingthisasoneofourKPIsweensureitiskeptattheforefrontoftheBoard’sconsideration.
ManagementoftheCompany’scostbaseinlinewithmarketconditions.
Inthecurrenteconomicconditionsitismoreimportantthaneverthatcloseattentionispaidtothecostofrunningthebusiness.
KeyPerformanceIndicators
Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011|11
On an NAV basis, Alliance Trust is ranked 5th, 6th, 10th and 10th out of the 32 stocks in the Global Growth sector over 1, 3, 6 months and the period respectively. The comparative rankings at the start of the period were 29th, 28th, 25th and 22nd.
Key Performance Performance What we did during Indicators the period
Total Shareholder Return was comfortably ahead of the indices, ranking 6th out of 32 trusts in the Global Growth Sector and ahead of the other large trusts in our sector for the 11 month period.
The final dividend will be 2.577p, payable on 2 April 2012. The total dividend of 9.00p, up 7.2%, will be the 45th annual consecutive dividend increase and will be paid out of the current year earnings of the Trust.
Trust costs have been controlled, even after including the necessary expenses associated with the additional professional fees relating to the shareholder resolutions at our Annual General Meeting in May. Our costs remain in the lowest quartile of the peer group.
Alliance Trust
6 months 11 months* 3 Years 5 Years
(9.0%) (5.7%) 7.3%
Global Growth Sector
NAV TotalReturn
(11.3%) (8.0%) 10.1%
2.3% 2.3%
29.9%
34.4%
(4.5%) (2.8%)
* 11 months for this reporting period only
Out/(under)Performance
Alliance Trust
6 months 11 months* 3 Years 5 Years
(10.1%) (3.5%) 6.8%
Global Growth Sector
Total ShareholderReturn
(11.7%) (8.6%) 9.1%
1.6% 5.1%
30.0%
39.0%
(9.0%) (2.3%)
* 11 months for this reporting period only
Out/(under)Performance
Total over the period
11 months* 3 Years 5 Years
7.2%
In the period
Dividend Growth
7.2%
12.5%
* 11 months for this reporting period only† Compound average growth
4.0% pa†
18.8%
3.5% pa†
Company Expenses
Dec 11 Jan 11 Jan 10
£16.0m
Total Expense Ratio
Costs
0.65%*
£17.0m
0.63%
£16.0m
0.69%
* Administrative expenses have been annualised given the �nancial reporting period is for 11 months, except for incentives which are on an actual basis
12|Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011
PortfolioReview
North Emerging Total Total UK America Europe Asia Markets Dec ‘11 Jan ‘11 % % % % % % %
Oil&Gas 7.6 3.2 0.8 1.2 - 12.8 13.2BasicMaterials 4.5 1.4 0.8 1.5 - 8.2 9.0Industrials 3.4 5.6 2.4 3.5 - 14.9 17.0ConsumerGoods 4.5 2.4 4.0 2.0 - 12.9 12.0HealthCare 3.6 4.3 2.4 0.7 - 11.0 7.6ConsumerServices 1.3 2.5 0.7 1.0 - 5.5 6.8Telecommunications 1.2 0.1 - 2.5 - 3.8 1.2Utilities 1.6 0.3 - 0.3 - 2.2 1.6Financials 6.5 4.5 2.7 3.3 - 17.0 17.9Technology - 4.4 1.0 1.9 - 7.3 10.7Core Equity Portfolio 34.2 28.7 14.8 17.9 - 95.6 97.0OtherAssets 0.1 0.5 - - 0.8 1.4 1.7PrivateEquity 3.1 - - - - 3.1 3.9Subsidiaries 1.2 - - - - 1.2 0.6Property 0.9 - - - - 0.9 1.5FixedIncome 5.0 - - - - 5.0 5.1Total Investments 44.5 29.2 14.8 17.9 0.8 107.2 109.8NetCash/(Debt) (6.4) 0.2 (2.0) 0.2 0.3 (7.7) (10.8)OtherNetAssets 0.5 - - - - 0.5 1.0 Net Assets Dec 2011 38.6 29.4 12.8 18.1 1.1 100.0 100.0Net Assets Jan 2011 34.6 25.2 12.2 21.7 6.3 100.0
AssetsheldinourEmergingMarketsandGlobalPortfolioswerereallocatedduringtheperiodtootherportfolios.
Classification of Investments
Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011|13
% of Country Value quoted Stock of listing Sector £m equities
RoyalDutchShell UK Oil&GasProducers 67.1 2.9%GlaxoSmithKline UK Pharmaceuticals&Biotechnology 58.3 2.5%BP UK Oil&GasProducers 50.8 2.2%HSBCHoldings UK Banks 44.6 2.0%RioTinto UK Mining 42.7 1.8%BritishAmericanTobacco UK Tobacco 38.8 1.7%BHPBilliton UK/Australia Mining 38.0 1.6%BG UK Oil&GasProducers 37.3 1.6%Pfizer USA Pharmaceuticals&Biotechnology 35.5 1.5%Diageo UK Beverages 31.8 1.4%Prudential UK LifeInsurance 31.5 1.4%AmericanTower USA MobileTelecommunications 31.2 1.4%Unilever UK FoodProducers 31.2 1.3%AstraZeneca UK Pharmaceuticals&Biotechnology 29.1 1.3%Vodafone UK MobileTelecommunications 27.9 1.2%CleanHarbors USA SupportServices 27.4 1.2%Nestlé Switzerland FoodProducers 26.3 1.1%PhilipMorrisInternational USA Tobacco 25.6 1.1%StandardChartered UK Banks 25.4 1.1%NationalGrid UK Gas,Water&Multiutilities 23.9 1.0%NewYorkCommunityBancorp USA Banks 23.0 1.0%InterOil Canada Oil&GasProducers 22.9 1.0%BankofNovaScotia Canada Banks 22.7 1.0%Carillion UK SupportServices 22.5 1.0%Apple USA TechnologyHardware&Equipment 21.5 0.9%YamanaGold Canada Mining 20.4 0.9%Visa USA FinancialServices 20.4 0.9%Legal&General UK LifeInsurance 20.1 0.9%WeirGroup UK IndustrialEngineering 20.0 0.9%SAP Germany Software&ComputerServices 19.7 0.9%RossStores USA GeneralRetailers 19.4 0.8%AshmoreGlobalOpportunities UK MutualFund 19.4 0.8%Anheuser-BuschInBev Belgium Beverages 19.2 0.8%Total France Oil&GasProducers 18.9 0.8%SuncorEnergy Canada Oil&GasProducers 18.7 0.8%Amdocs USA Software&ComputerServices 18.4 0.8%Pearson UK Media 17.9 0.8%EnterpriseProductsPartners USA Oil&GasProducers 17.5 0.8%Sanofi France Pharmaceuticals&Biotechnology 17.3 0.8%Fresenius Germany HealthCareEquipment&Services 17.2 0.8%Elementis UK Chemicals 16.9 0.7%UnitedTechnologies USA Aerospace&Defense 16.8 0.7%Melrose UK IndustrialEngineering 16.7 0.7%TaiwanSemiconductorManufacturingCo. Taiwan TechnologyHardware&Equipment 16.4 0.7%LionsGateEntertainment USA Media 16.2 0.7%Apache USA Oil&GasProducers 16.1 0.7%DaVita USA HealthCareEquipment&Services 15.7 0.7%TullowOil UK Oil&GasProducers 15.4 0.7%CanadianPacificRailway Canada IndustrialTransportation 14.9 0.6%MedcoHealthSolutions USA HealthCareEquipment&Services 14.9 0.6%
Top 50 quoted equity holdings as at 31 December 2011
Theseinvestmentsmaybehelddirectlyand/orindirectlythroughinvestmentinAllianceTrustInvestmentFunds.Afulllistofthecompaniesinwhichweinvestcanbefoundonourwebsitewww.alliancetrust.co.uk
14|Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011
Theme Portfolio activity Case studies
PortfolioReview
Thecombinationofincreasedindustrialization,thegrowthbothinthenumberandwealthoftheAsianconsumerandthemassivepublicsectorinfrastructuredevelopmentsinChinaandothermarkets,arecreatingmassivedemandforrawmaterialssuchascopperandsteel.Thesefactorsarealsocreatingopportunitiesforcompaniesfromallpartsoftheeconomicspectrumtoservicethesenewmarkets.TherehasbeenaslightcoolingoffoftheexpectationsforAsianeconomiesasfearofcontagionfromtheEurozoneissuedampenstheoutlook,butconsensusGDPgrowthforChinafor2012is8.4%andforIndiais7.3%,whichcompareswithaforecastcontractionwithinWesternEuropeof0.3%.
Asiangrowth
Eurozonecrisis
ThefutureforEuropeisfarfromclear.Europe(exUK)hasbeenamongtheworstperformingmarketsoverthelasttwoyearsandalthougheventscametoaheadinJuly,nosolutiontowhatisanintractableproblemhasbeenagreeduponbytheEuropeanpoliticians.Thisuncertaintycrippledtheregion’sequitymarketswhich,duringtheperiod,fellaround17%,whereasAsiawasdownaround12%,theUKwasdownaround4%andtheUSwasupover1%insterlingterms.Atthesametime,Europeanbondyieldsrosesharplyandthecurrencyhasweakened.
Incomegeneration
ThedividendswereceivefromtheinvestmentportfolioaredistributedtoshareholdersafterthecostsoftheTrusthavebeenpaid.Wehavegrownthedividendpaidtoshareholdersineachofthelast45yearsandthisyearwewillincreasethedividendby7.2%to9.00p,oratotalpaymentfortheperiodofaround£54.8m.
PORTFOLIO
Stock Review
PortfolioConstruction
MonitoringTeam
Discussion
In house:Research
Centre, Valuation Model, Stock
Selection
Companymeetings,site visits,
on the ground fact�nding
Researchmeetings
Theobjectiveofourinvestmentstrategyistoselectstocksthatcanaddtoshareholdervaluethroughouttheeconomiccycleandinsomecaseshaveaparticularnichethatallowsthemtocapitaliseonregionalspecificthemes.Forus,stockpickingrequiresdetailedanalysisofcompanyaccounts,meetingwithseniormanagementandafullunderstandingofwhatgivesthemtheedgeovertheircompetitors.
Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011|15
HSBC, listed in the UK, has less than 20% of reported profits coming from Europe. Over 50% comes from Asia and it has a network of 7,500 offices in over 80 countries. It has survived the turmoil in the financial markets because of its strong balance sheet and business model that has benefitted from Asian growth and that of other emerging markets in the Americas, Middle East and Africa. Its share price has benefitted from the rise of consumerism in many of its markets augmented by the bank’s strong capital base, prudent lending policy and strict expense discipline which also allows it to reward shareholders through dividends.
HSBC represented 4.8% of our UK portfolio at the end of the period.
Theme Portfolio activity Case studies
Over18%oftheportfolioislistedinAsia,butouranalysisshowsthatover25%oftherevenuesthattheunderlyingcompaniesweareinvestedinisderivedfromAsianmarkets.Weanalyseourentireportfolionotonlyonthebasisofwherethestockislistedandthesectoritisin,butalsowithreferencetowherethecompanyinquestionderivesitsincome.Forexample,withsignificantrevenuesofanumberofUKlistedcompaniesbeingderivedoutsidetheUK,weexploittheopportunitytoaccessAsianmarketswithouttakingthecurrencyriskorsufferingwithholdingtaxonincomegeneratedwhichisinevitablewheninvestingdirectlyintherelevantmarket.ThesituationisthesameintheUSandEurope,whereweinvestinbrandswithanestablishedpresenceintheregion.
Barry Callebaut is the world leader in cocoa and chocolate products and its share price rose almost 27% in the period. It is the only fully integrated manufacturer with a global presence. This enables them to take advantage of the outsourcing trend as large producers such as Cadbury/Kraft look to cut costs in the highly capital intensive cocoa processing and semi-finished product stage.
Barry Callebaut represented 4.5% of our European portfolio at the end of the period.
Whilethemarketfellsharply,ourholdingsintheregionoutperformedbecausewewereinvestedincompanieswhichwerelesscorrelatedwithmarketmovements.Atasectorlevelthedivergencebetweentheperformanceoftheutilitiesandthefinancialssectorswhichbothfellalmost40%insterlingtermsandtheConsumerGoodsandHealthCaresectorswhichshowedpositivereturnsofover10%wasstark.WhenlookingatstocksthatareactiveinEurope,wehavebeenalerttothelikelyimpactontheirearningsofthecostofresolvingtheEurozonecrisis,whichwillinevitablyfallhardestonthosecompanieswithhighlevelsofdependencyontheperipheralEuropeanmarkets.However,westillbelievethatthereareinvestmentopportunitiesinEurope.Weremainheavilyexposedtointernationalcompaniesinlesscyclicalindustries.
National Grid rose 13% and performed well operationally over the period. Their focused efforts to improve their underperforming US assets delivering cost savings ahead of target. Rate reviews and relationships with US regulatory bodies appear to be improving too and this culminated in better cash delivery and greater dividend confidence for the future. Based on consensus market forecasts, the expected dividend for 2012 is over 6%.
National Grid represented 2.9% of our UK portfolio at the end of the period.
Ourmanagersconsiderthedividendpolicyofthecompaniesinwhichtheyinvestbecausewebelievethatadividendpolicyisausefuldisciplineforcompanies.Overrecentyearswehavereducedourexposuretothehigh-yieldingUKportfolio,butsourceincomeelsewheretomatchourdividendcommitment.OurUKinvestmentsgeneratedayieldof4%intheyear.Wehavebeenabletodiversifyincomegenerationwhichnowincludesasignificantcontributionfromthefixedincomeportfolio,yieldingover6%.FiveofthesixlargestholdingsinAsiaareyieldingaround4%ormoreandtheAsianequityportfolioasawholegeneratedayieldofover3%.
16|Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011
Theme Portfolio activity Case studies
PortfolioReview
Thegrowingpopulationoftheworldhasanimpactonmanypartsoftheeconomy.Itputsgreaterpressureonlanduseandastheaverageincomeofthedevelopingeconomyrises,thisinturnincreasesthedemandforfoodandfurtherdowntheline,consumerdiscretionaryitems.WesawincreasesinthecostofsomefoodstuffsinIndiaofalmost70%lastyear.
Demographicsandpressureontheconsumer
Divergenceofviewsbetweeneconomistsandinvestors
Despitethestrongrecoveryincorporateprofits,theeconomicrecoveryintheUShasnotfedthroughtomosthouseholds.Therehasbeenaminimalriseinemployment,noriseinhousepricesandnexttonowagegrowth.Thishasbeenthecaseforsometimeandisunlikelytoeasesubstantiallyforsometimetocome.
Deleveraging
ForUKhouseholdsthedeleveragingprocesstoreducelevelsofindebtednessbeganin2008andtheyarenowdownfromtheirpeak.However,manydevelopedcountriesnowhavehigherlevelsofSovereigndebtthancountriesinemergingmarketswheretherehasbeenaquantumshiftinsavingratiosandbalanceofpayments,overanumberofyears,resultinginmanynowhavingastrongfiscalandmonetaryposition.
Technologicaladvances
OneareaofrobustgrowthisgasandoilproductionfromshalebedsandoilsandsacrossNorthAmerica.Technologicalinnovationhasopenedupnewproductionfronts,buttightandtighteningenvironmentalstandardsmeansthereisalotofcleanupandwastepreventionwork.
Aspartofthisfundamentalanalysiswehavetoassesswhatisafairpriceforastockthatclearlydemonstratesthesecharacteristics.Inmanycasesthiscompetitiveadvantagemayalreadybepricedintoashareprice,leavinglittleinthewayofupsidepotential.However,inothersitmaynotandthesearethestocksweaimtoinvestin.Thecurrentenvironment,wheremanydomesticeconomiesarestruggling,cancreategreatopportunitiesassharepricesaredrivenintheshort-termbyeconomicconcernsandnotbycompanyfundamentals.However,overthelong-termthesefundamentalcompanyspecificdriverswillre-assertthemselvesandprovidesignificantrewardsforthepatientinvestor.
TheprocessofmonitoringandassessingthepotentialvalueofstocksalreadyintheportfolioallowsustoshapetheTrusttobenefitfromthekeydriversoflong-termvalue.Italsoallowsustoisolateholdingsthathavereachedtheirfullpotentialortheircompetitiveadvantagehaschangedtotheextentthatwewouldselltheholding.
Asaninvestorwearecommittedtoalong-termrelationshipwiththecompaniesinwhichweinvest.WewelcomedtheintroductionoftheUKStewardshipCodewhichpromotesdialoguebetweenshareholdersandtheboardsoftheirinvesteecompaniesandtransparencyabouthowinvestorsoverseethosecompanies.Wereportonourvotingactivitiesonpage22.
WearealsosignatoriestotheUNPrinciplesforResponsibleInvestmentwhichadvocatesenvironmental,socialandcorporategovernanceconsiderationswhentakinginvestmentdecisions.Weuseanonprofitmakingorganisation,EthicalInvestmentResearchServices,toassistintheprocess.
Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011|17
Sanofi, a French company, is engaged in the research, development, manufacture and marketing of healthcare products. Their products are available in over 170 countries with emerging markets accounting for nearly one third of total sales and, more importantly, their highest growth rate for sales in 2011; up 10%. Over the past two years new management have refocussed the business and dramatically reduced cost resulting in some of the valuation potential of the business being realised. Shareholders also benefit from a yield of nearly 5%.
Sanofi represented 4.9% of our European portfolio at the end of the period.
Theme Portfolio activity Case studies
Despiteongoinggovernmentpressuretosqueezehealthcarespending,ageingpopulationsinthedevelopedworldandrisingwealthinemergingnationsaredrivingdemandforpharmaceuticals.Weaddedsignificantlytothissectorovertheyearaslowvaluationsandimprovingnewdrugprospectsofferedmuchpotential.Achangetodomesticspendingpatternswasalsoathemethatwedevelopedovertheperiod.
Ross Stores, a US company which sells discounted end of line branded goods, continues to generate profitable sales growth and is attractively valued. This strong domestic market strategy is against a poor US economic backdrop but is designed to benefit from the change in consumer attitudes which looks set to continue for some time.
Ross Stores represented 3.2% of our North American portfolio at the end of the period.
Weholdmanyworldclassinternationalcompanieswithintheportfoliototakeadvantageoftheirexposuretoeconomicgrowth.
Thereareotherdomesticplayswherecompanieshaveacompetitiveadvantageornichemarketwhichcanleadtosuperiorreturnstoshareholders.Bydevelopinginvestmentthemeswecanfocusourexposureinregionsandsectorswhereweseeclearandsignificantbenefits.Wealsolookforopportunitiesfromcompaniesthatusetheenvironmentintheirowneconomiestotheiradvantagebyadaptingaparticularsalesstrategytosuittheneedsoftheircustomers.
Unilever, a UK listed consumer group, derives less than one third of its revenue from the UK economy. More than 50% of its business is in emerging markets and its products are sold in over 180 countries including a number of higher growth markets where its brands are seen as the product of choice. Of the eleven product areas in which it operates it is the global leader in seven of them. It has launched a global Sustainability Living Plan which aims to help more than a billion people improve their health and well-being.
Unilever represented 4.0% of our UK portfolio at the end of the period.
AtageographiclevelmuchoftheTrust’sexposureremainsintheUK,EuropeandtheUSwherethelevelsofpublicdebtaretoohighandeconomicactivityremainssluggish.However,therevenuesreceivedbytheTrustbearlittleresemblancetothisgeographicsplit.ForexampletheUKportfolioaccountsfor34%oftheTrust’sequitiesbutonly7%oftheTrust’srevenuesaregeneratedintheUKbythoseUKlistedinvestments.Thisistheresultofourdeliberatestrategyofinvestingincompanieswithinternationalexposuretohighergrowthmarketswherethereareconsumerswithsavingsandawillingnesstospendandgovernmentswhoarenotconstrainedbyfiscalpressures.
Clean Harbors, a US company known for their expertise in cleaning up off-shore oil spills, have been rapidly building up their land based waste prevention services. The vigorous activity in North America to extract oil and gas by deep water drilling and using the new ‘fracking’ technology has resulted in the services provided by them being in high demand. Clean Harbors does much of the clean up and waste handling in this area and performed extremely well against this backdrop.
Clean Harbors represented 4.6% of our North American portfolio at the end of the period.
TheBPdisasterintheGulfofMexicoresultedinrenewedfocusonregulationwithintheoilsector.Tobenefitfromthischangewelookedforcompanieswithaproventrackrecordinanareathatwouldbepositivelyaffectedfromthechanges.Wastedisposalandpostcrisiscleanupoperationsaswellaslandbasedwastepreventionservicesareanareathatplaytothistheme.
18|Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011
BydeliveringexcellentinvestmentperformanceourobjectiveistobuildlongstandingrelationshipsandgenerateprofitswhichwillflowthroughtotheTrust.
ThecontinuinginflowintoourMonthlyIncomeBondFundistestamenttothecredibilityofourfixedincometeamanditsattractivenesstoclientsseekingincome.Wehavebeenencouragedbythelevelofinterestexperiencedinourlatestfund,theGlobalThematicOpportunitiesFund,whichlaunchedattheendoftheperiod.
Wehaveidentifiedthefollowingdriverstoourfuturegrowth:
• InvestmentPerformance–fouroutoffiveequityfundshaveperformedinthetophalfoftheirsectorfortheperiod.WhiletheMonthlyIncomeBondFundwasinthelowestquartileofitspeergroupitdiddeliveritsinvestmentobjectivewithanannualisedincomereturnof6%.
•Distribution–throughourexperiencedbusinessdevelopmentteamwenowhaveastrongbasefromwhichtobuildonourrelationshipswithprivatewealthmanagersandinstitutionalinvestors.Ourfundsarenowavailableon11platforms.
• Profile–duringtheperiodourmarketingactivityincreasedawarenessofourinvestmentofferingsandourchangeofnamefromAllianceTrustAssetManagementhasrefreshedourbrandwhilereinforcingourlinkswiththeTrust.
• Choice–wenowhavesevenfundsmanagedbyourequityandfixedincometeams.Wewilllooktolaunchadditionalfundswhereweseepotentialgrowthinthemarketsuchasincomefundsoraroundaglobalinvestmenttheme.
• Wehaveaninnovativeapproachtofees,structuringourfundsintosharecategorieswhichcaneitherincludeorexcludeadditionalfeesforoutperformance.
Alliance Trust Investments was launched in 2009 with the aim of developing and fully utilising the skills of the Trust’s investment team. It allows third parties the opportunity to invest through a range of open ended funds. During the past year we made solid progress with third party assets under management rising over 50% to £125m at the period end. Our Monthly Income Bond Fund has averaged net inflows of over £1m per week in a corporate bond sector which has seen large net outflows over much of the period.
Key Differentiators
• Weareaboutiqueinvestmentmanagementcompanywiththebackingofastrongparent
• WehavebeenabletorecruitexperiencedandwellqualifiedmanagersattractedbytheopportunitytomanageboththirdpartyfundsandtheTrust’sownassets.
Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011|19
Thestrongbusinessmodelnowinplacepositionsuswelltotakeadvantageoftheconsiderablemarketopportunitiestogrowthebusinessanddelivervaluetoshareholders.
Ourbusinessmodelhadbeenbuiltaroundprovidingahighqualityandlowpriceservice.Historicallywewerereliantoninterestratesreceivedoncustomerdepositsforasignificantproportionofourincome.Thecontinuedlowbaserateenvironmentpromptedustoreviewourbusinessmodel.
Ourbusinessmodelnowhasinplacethefollowingdriverstofutureprofitability:
• Pricing–wehaveincreasedpricingtobothourexistingandnewcustomers,toalevelmoreinlinewiththemarket,whilstsufferinglittleattritiontocustomernumbers.
• Scaleability–oursystemsandprocesseshavecapacitytoaddsignificantnewvolumes.
• Transactionactivity–webenefitfromtheincreasingusebycustomersofouronlinedealingfacility.
• Market
- ourshareoftheUKplatformandFullSIPPmarketisaround5%–weexpectthismarkettogrowthroughmigrationfromDefinedBenefitpensionstoproductssuchasthoseofferedbyus.
- growingdesireamongstinvestorstoconsolidateassetsinoneplace.Ourplatformprovidesthatfacility.
- intheshortertermweseethelowyieldenvironmentprovidingcontinuingimpetusforinvestorsseekingtoreplacelostdepositincomewithhigheryieldingmutualfunds.Ouri.nvestplatformoffersover1,500funds.
- higherpersonaltaxratesintheUKshouldunderpininflowsintoourSIPPsandISAs.
• Regulatory–RetailDistributionReview
- weexpectanincreaseinourdirectcustomerbasefromindividualswhohavechosennottoseekadvice.
- IndependentFinancialAdviserswillberequiredtohavemorethanoneplatform.
Alliance Trust Savings is held as an investment on which the Trust seeks to make a commercial return. We made strong progress, reporting a loss of £3.1m against £5.4m the previous year. Overall the number of accounts grew by 8% in the period.
Key differentiators
• Wehavethebackingofastrongparentandareindependentoflifecompanyproductproviders
• AlreadyRetailDistributionReviewcompliant
• Werefundtoourcustomerstheentirecommission(circa£0.7mp.a.)receivedbyus
• Wehaveaflatfeechargingstructure.
An Award Winning Business
Principal risks Mitigation Key developments
20|Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011
RiskFactors
Thefollowingsectionsetsoutourapproachtoriskmanagementandfocusesontheprincipalrisksthatwebelievecouldimpactontheperformanceofthebusiness.Effectiveriskmanagementisakeycomponentofthebusiness’soperatingmodelandassistsinensuringthatthedifferentpartsofthegroupoperatewithinacceptableriskparameters.
TheBoardhasoverallresponsibilityforsettingthelevelofriskwhichitispreparedtoaccept.TheriskframeworkisoverseenbytheRiskCommitteewhichischairedbytheFinanceDirectorandismadeupofrepresentativesfromAllianceTrustandeachofitsregulatedsubsidiarybusinesses.TheChairmanoftheAuditCommitteealsoattendsatleastonemeetingeachyear,toprovideadditionaloversightandaNon-executiveperspective.Eachbusinessmaintainsandreviewsitsriskregisterandthecontrolsinplacetomitigate,reduceorpreventlossarisingfromtheirkeyrisks.Acommonriskcategorisationisinplaceforallbusinessunits.
DuringtheperiodtheRiskCommitteemetoneightoccasionsandreceivedexternalpresentationsonfraudriskandtheproposednewregulatoryenvironmentintheUKaswellasinternalreviewsoninformationtechnologysecurity,dataprotection,upcomingregulatorychangeandtheresultsofglobalrisksurveys.TheCommitteedividesitstimebetweenidentifyingandevaluatingemergingrisks,challengingbusinessselfassessmentriskprofilesandperforminganoversightroleforthecompletionofremediatingactions.
WecontinuetoenhancetheRiskFrameworkandintheperiodimprovedourriskreportingcapabilitieswiththecreationofKeyRiskIndicatorswhicharereportedatbothManagementandBoardlevel.
Inappropriateobjectiveandstrategyinrelationtoinvestordemandsinarapidlychangingfinancialservicesmarket.
Strategy
Market
TheTrustcurrentlyinvestsprimarilyinUKandoverseasequitiesanditsprincipalrisksarethereforemarketrelatedandincludemarketrisk(currency,interestrateandotherpricerisk).
SomenationsintheEuropeanUnion(EU)haveseentheirsovereigndebtcomeunderpressureamiddeterioratingeconomicandfiscalconditions.ThishasincreasedtheriskofagovernmentdefaultoracountrybeingforcedtoexittheEuroarea.
AllianceTrusthasdirectexposuretotheEUvia(i)itsEuropeanportfolio(ii)holdingsinfundsmanagedbyitssubsidiarycompanyAllianceTrustInvestments,and(iii)investmentsmadebyitsPrivateEquitybusiness.WithintheaboveourexposuretoGreece,Italy,Ireland,PortugalandSpainisminimal(<1%totalNetAssetsoftheTrustasat31December2011).
Otherrisksareassociatedwithassetallocation,sectorandstockselectionwhichcouldleadtoinvestmentunderperformance.
Gearing
TheTrusthastheabilitytoborrowmoneyforinvestmentpurposes.Iftheunderlyinginvestmentfallsinvalue,anyborrowingswillmagnifytheextentofthisloss.Ifborrowingfacilitiesarenotrenewed,theTrustmayhavetosellinvestmentstorepayborrowings.
Accounting,legalandregulatory
InordertoqualifyasaninvestmenttrusttheCompanymustcomplywithsections1158-59oftheCorporationTaxAct2010.FailuretodosowouldresultintherealisedcapitalgainsoftheCompany’sportfoliobeingsubjecttoCorporationTax.
MajorregulatorychangecouldimposeunnecessarycomplianceburdensontheTrustorthreatentheviabilityofitsbusinessmodel.
Operational
FailureoftheTrust’saccountingorinternalcontrolsystemsorthoseofotherthirdpartysupplierscouldleadtoaninabilitytoprovideaccuratereportingandmonitoringoramisappropriationofassets.
Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011|21
• DecisiontowithdrawfromPrivateEquityinfavourofquoted equities.
• DiscounthasnarrowedwhiletheGlobalGrowthsectoraverage has widened during the period.
Principal risks Mitigation Key developments
TheBoardregularlyreviewsthestrategyoftheTrustandthelevelandsourcesofdemand.TheBoardrecognisestheneedforconsistentlygoodperformanceinordertodriveinvestordemand.
ThesubsidiarybusinessesareasourceofvaluegoingforwardandtheirneedtodeliveragainstbusinessplanisrecognisedbytheBoard.
• Strengtheningofcapabilitiesofequity investment team.
• LaunchofGlobalThematicOpportunitiesFund.
• Ranked6/32ofPeerGroupforTSRand10/32forNAV return over the period.
TheAssetAllocationCommitteemeetsatleastmonthlytomanagetheallocationofthecapitaloftheCompanybetweenandamongtheassetclassesapprovedbytheBoardwithintheriskparameters,policiesandotherlimitsandguidelinessetbytheBoard.
OurinternalResearchCentreprovidesananalysisofeconomies,marketsandsocio-economicissuesthatmayaffectmarketstoinforminvestmentdecisions.
WecloselymonitorexposurestoEuropewithinourinvestmentportfoliosandconsiderbothdirectandindirectexposures.
AllborrowingsrequirethepriorapprovaloftheBoardandgearinglevelsarereviewedbytheBoardandtheAssetAllocationCommitteeateverymeeting.ThemajorityoftheTrust’sinvestmentsareinquotedequitiesthatarereadilyrealisable.
• Paceofregulatorychangeremainsachallengeto the Group. This includes not just legislation emanating from the UK and Europe but also from the US such as the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act.
TheFinanceDirectorregularlymonitorsthecompliancecriteriaundersections1158-59oftheCorporationTaxAct2010.
TheGroup’sComplianceDepartmentmaintainsaforwardradarofupcomingregulatorychanges.WhereasignificantdetrimentaleffectontheTrustisenvisaged,representationiseithermadeindividuallyorviatradebodies.ManagementoftheregulatoryforwardradarisoverseenbytheRiskCommittee.TheComplianceDepartmentperformmonitoringactivitiesduringtheyeartoensurecompliancewithrelevantregulations.AnybreachesarereportedtotheBoardandwhererelevanttotheappropriateauthorities.
• DuringtheyeartheeffectivenessoftheContinuityofBusiness Plan was tested by way of a crisis scenario workshop. The result of the test was positive.
TheTrustmaintainsaContinuityofBusinessPlanwhichfacilitatesthecontinuedoperationofthebusinessintheeventofaservicedisruptionormajordisaster.
AreportontheeffectivenessofinternalcontrolsisreviewedbytheBoardandexternalreportsonthecontrolenvironmentsofsignificantthirdpartyserviceprovidersareobtainedandreviewed.
• Anewfacilityforupto£100mwasapprovedwiththe same lender to replace an existing facility of the same amount.
• Borrowingcommitmentsarewithdifferentbanksand over different durations.
Accounting,legalandregulatory
Operational
22|Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011
CorporateResponsibility
Marketplace – meeting the expectations of our investors and customers
Ourprioritiesare:
• toconsideralloftherisks,includingnon-financialandreputationalrisk,whenwetakeinvestmentdecisions
• tooffercompetitiveproductsinwhichourcustomerscaninvestwithaclearunderstandingofthelikelyrisksandreturns.
BothAllianceTrustPLCandAllianceTrustInvestmentsaresignatoriestotheStewardshipCodepublishedbytheFinancialReportingCouncil,whichisintendedtosetoutthestandardsexpectedofresponsibleinvestors.Ourstewardshippolicystatementsandfulldetailsofourvotingactivityonaquarter-by-quarterbasisarepublishedonourwebsite.During2011wealsobecamesignatoriestothePrinciplesforResponsibleInvestment,backedbytheUN,whichprovidesaninternationally-recognisedframeworkforinvestorstotakeaccountofenvironmental,socialandcorporategovernanceissues.
Ourinvestmentmanagerslooknotjustatthefinancialperformanceofthecompaniesinwhichweinvest,butalsoconsidertheirenvironmental,socialandgovernance(ESG)profileinordertoidentifyanyaspectsoftheirbusinessactivitieswhichmightgiverisetounexpectedlossofvalue.Wemeetregularlywiththemanagementofcompaniesandraiseanyconcernswhichwehaveidentified.
Ourpolicyistovotewhereverpossible–inmostcaseswesupportmanagementbutwillvoteagainstmanagementwherewebelieveproposalsarenotinshareholders’interestsandhavebeenunabletoeffectchangethroughengagement.
Duringtheyearwevotedasfollows:
Infavourofmanagementrecommendations 146Againstmanagementrecommendations 16Abstentions 1
VotesagainstmanagementweremostlyinrelationtoUScompaniesandinfavourofhavinganannualadvisoryvoteonremuneration.
Wealsoaimtomaintaineffectiverelationshipwithourownshareholders,bothindividualandinstitutional,meetingwiththemregularlyduringtheyearandpublishingregularperformancereportsonourwebsite.
BothAllianceTrustInvestmentsandAllianceTrustSavingsofferproductswithinaregulatedframeworkwhichpromotesfairtreatmentofcustomers.Ourproductsaredesignedandmarketedinawaywhichmakescleartocustomersthenatureoftheinvestmentandtherisksinvolved.
Allofouremployeesaresubjecttopoliciesongiftsandhospitalityandconflictsofintereststoremovetheriskofundueinfluenceorbias.DuringtheyearweissuedaCodeofBusinessConducttogiveadditionalguidanceonthebehavioursweexpectfromemployees.
Inordertomeetourcorporateobjectiveofgeneratingarealreturnforshareholdersoverthemediumtolongtermweneedbeabletodemonstratethatwebehaveresponsiblytowardsourcustomers,ouremployees,thewidercommunityandtheenvironment.Thissectionexplainshowweachievethis.
Weweredelightedtowinthe2011HRNetwork(Scotland)OrganisationalDevelopmentAward.Thejudgestookintoaccountourorganisationandstructure,leadershipandtalentprogramme,culture,valuesandbehavioursandoverallemploymentexperience.Wewereabletodemonstratetheengagementofemployeesatalllevelsaswellaseffectivecollaborationbetweenthedifferentpartsoftheorganisation.
Thisawardunderlinesourcommitmenttorespectingourpeopleandgivingthemeveryopportunitytomaximisetheirpotential.Italsohelpsinattractinghighqualitycandidatesacrossalllevelsoftheorganisation.
Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011|23
Workplace – providing an environment in which our employees can realise their full potential
Ourprioritiesare:
• tomaintainasafeanddiscrimination-freeworkingenvironment
• toofferallemployeesopportunitiestolearnanddevelopnewskillsforthebenefitoftheCompanyandthemselves.
Wehavewell-establishedpoliciesandprocedurestoremoveallformsofunlawfuldiscriminationandencourageouremployeestotreateachotherwithrespect.Thesearesupportedbyaconfidentialwhistleblowingfacilitythroughwhichemployeescanraiseconcernsindependentlyoftheirownmanager.Wealsoundertookanemployeeengagementsurveyduringtheyearwhichachievedaresponserateof82%ofemployees,upfrom76%inthepreviousyear.Inthesewayswealsomeetourhealthandsafetyobligationsandtreatdisabledemployeesinaccordancewithourstatutoryobligations.
EmployeesareencouragedtotakeaninterestintheprogressoftheCompany.Aswellasteammeetings,regularcompany-widebriefingstakeplacewhereseniormanagerscommentontheprogressofourthreebusinesses.ThisinterestisreinforcedbyopportunitiesforemployeestoacquiresharesintheCompany,includingourAll-EmployeeShareOwnershipPlanwhichoffersanannualallocationofsharesbasedoncompanyperformance.AllemployeeswhojoinedtheCompanybeforeAugust2010areshareholdersandtheaverageholdingisover5,000shares.
Wecontinuedourgraduaterecruitmentprogrammeandnowhavealeadershipdevelopmentprogrammethatallowsustoidentifyandoffertailoredtraininganddevelopmentopportunitiestoindividualsacrossourbusinesswhowebelievehavethepotentialtoprogressandbecometheleadersofthefuture.
Community – playing our part to support the wider community
Ourprioritiesare:
• tosupportthedisadvantaged,particularlyyoungpeople,inourlocalcommunity
• topromoteasenseofresponsibilityinourownemployees.
Againthisyearwesupportedlocalorganisationsthroughourstafffoundation,matchingtheamountraisedbyouremployeesthroughtheirfund-raisingactivities.Wemadedonationsof£2,925intotaltosupportorganisationsworkingwithyoungpeopleinTaysideandFife.
Wealsocontinuedtoencourageemployeestoundertakevolunteeringactivitiesandatotalof15dayswerespentbyemployeesattheBraeDundeeRidingAbilityCentreduringtheyear.
AsignificantdevelopmentduringtheyearwastheAllianceTrustCateranYomp.This52mileteamevent,basedontheCateranTrailinPerthshireandtheAngusGlensandsponsoredbytheCompany,attractedover200participantsincluding53staffandraised£282,000throughsponsorshipandentryfeesinaidofABFtheSoldiers’CharityandthePrince’sScottishYouthBusinessTrust.
Environment – using natural resources and energy responsibly
Ourprioritiesare:
• tominimiseenergyconsumption
• toencouragerecyclingofwaste
OurprincipalofficeinDundeewasdesignedtomaximiseenergyefficiencyandrecyclingopportunities.Weusepaperfromsustainablesourceswhereverpracticableandcost-effectiveandcomputerequipmentiseitherrefurbishedorrecycledattheendofitsusefullife.
WealsoencourageshareholderstoreceivecommunicationselectronicallyandmakeadonationtotheWoodlandTrustforeachshareholderwhooptstoreceivetheircommunicationselectronically.
Carbon footprint reporting
Wereportoncarbondioxide(CO2)emissionsbasedontheGreenhouseGasProtocolCorporateReportingandAccountingStandardusing:
Scope1:gas,fueloil,refrigerantloss
Scope2:non-renewableelectricitypurchased
Scope3:businesstravelbypersonalcar,airandrail
OurCO2emissionsduringtheyearamountedto870tonnes,anetdecreaseof5.5%comparedtothepreviousyear.Thisrepresents3.19tonnesperfull-timeemployee.Thereductionispredominantlyduetoyear-on-yearreductionsinelectricityandgasconsumptionatourHeadOffice,offsetinpartbyanincreaseindomesticandothershort-haulflights.Abreakdownisshownbelow.
Air travel
Natural Gas/Fuel Oil
Electricity use
Air conditioning refrigerant loss
Personal carbusiness travel
60.5%
18.6%
15.2%
4.1%
Rail travel 1.1%
Company vehicle use 0.1%
0.5%
Corporate carbon footprint
Source: Corporate Citizenship
24|Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011
SummaryFinancialPerformance
Financial year end
Aspreviouslycommunicated,theCompany’sfinancialyearendhaschangedto31December.Ourresultsto31December2011arethereforeforan11monthperiodandthecomparitives,whichareinbrackets,arefortheyearended31January2011.Referencesbelowtoannualisedpercentageincreasesfromtheprioryearhavebeenincludedtoreflectthisinlinewithbestpractice.Therehasbeennocostimplicationasaresultofthischange.
Consolidated Results
Fortheperiodended31December2011theconsolidatedlosspersharewas30.75p(gain68.46p)comprisingrevenueearningpershareof8.91p(8.20p)andcapitallosspershareof39.66p(gain60.26p).
Consolidatedadministrativeexpenseschargedagainstrevenueprofitswere£37.4m(£38.1m).Consolidatedadministrativeexpenseschargedagainstcapitalprofitswere£2.0m(£2.7m).
Company Total Return
TheCompanygeneratesreturnsthroughrevenueearningsandcapitalgrowth.Fortheperiodended31December2011therevenueearningspersharewere9.87p(9.67p)andthecapitallosspersharewas41.06p(gain58.93p)representingatotallosspershareof31.19p(gain68.60p).
Company Revenue Performance
RevenueearnedfromtheCompany’sassetsincreasedbyanannualised6.9%to£85.1m(£86.8m).Incomefrominvestmentsincreasedbyanannualised8.8%to£81.4m(£81.6m)duetoincreaseddividendreceipts.
RentalincomeontheCompany’spropertyportfolioreducedto£2.2m(£3.5m),followingthesaleoftwopropertiesduringtheyear.
Company Capital Performance
Lastyearsawadeclineinthefinancialmarketsandournetassetvaluepersharefellby7.6%(increase16.2%).Lossesonourinvestmentportfoliototalled£254.8m(gains£391.9m).
Company Expenses
TheannualisedTotalExpenseRatio(TER)fortheperiodwas0.65%(0.63%).TheTERexcludestheexpensesofoursubsidiarybusinessesasthesecostsdonotrelatetorunningtheinvestmenttrust,consistentwithindustrypractice.
Weremainconsciousofprevailingmarketconditionsandtherequirementtoapplystrictcostcontrolsacrossthebusiness.Companycostsincreased0.9%onanannualisedbasisto£16.0m.ThiswasachieveddespitenecessaryadditionalprofessionalfeesrelatingtotheMay2011AGM
requisitionssubmittedbyshareholdersandtheclosureofourprivateequitybusiness.ClosureofourDefinedBenefitSchemetoaccrualduringtheyearresultedinaone-offgainof£0.8m.
Dividend
TheCompanyhasapolicyofgrowingthedividendand,subjecttoexternalfactorssuchaschangesintheeconomicenvironmentandtaxation,theDirectorsseektomanagetheassetsoftheCompanytogenerateagrowingrevenuestreamwhichwillallowthemtocontinuetodeclareincreasingdividendsyearonyear.
Havingpaidthreeinterimdividendsof2.141pforlastperiod,theDirectorshavedeclaredafourthinterimdividendof2.577ppersharepayableon2April2012.Thetotaldividendfortheperiod,of9.00p,isanincreaseof7.2%onthe8.395ppaidforthepreviousyear.
Intheabsenceofanyunforeseendevelopments,weexpecttobeabletorecommendquarterlyinterimdividendsof2.3175p,payableonoraround2July2012,1October2012and31December2012andafourthinterimdividendofatleast2.3175p,payableonoraround2April2013.
Subsidiary Businesses
Bothofoursubsidiarybusinesseshavemadegoodprogressduringtheyearasoutlinedonpages18and19.AllianceTrustInvestmentsmadealossof£4.8m(£3.4m)inlinewithourstartupplanforthebusiness.AllianceTrustSavingsmadealossof£3.1m(£5.4m),benefitingfromincreasedsalesandtightcontrolofcosts.
Borrowing Facilities
At31December2011wehadnetdebtof7.7%(11%).TheCompanyhadcommittedfundinglinesof£450m(£450m)inplaceattheperiodendandgoodcovenantcover.
Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011|25
SummaryDirectors’Report
Summary Financial Statement
ThisSummaryFinancialStatementhasbeenpreparedvoluntarilybytheDirectorsinaccordancewithsection426oftheCompaniesAct2006.ItdoesnotcontainsufficientinformationtoallowafullunderstandingoftheresultsandstateofaffairsoftheCompanyandofitspoliciesandarrangementsconcerningDirectors’remuneration.Forfurtherinformation,thefullannualfinancialstatements,theAuditor’sReportonthosefinancialstatementsandtheDirectors’Reportshouldbeconsulted.AcopyoftheAnnualReport,whichmaybeobtainedfreeofchargefromtheCompanySecretary,willbedeliveredtotheRegistrarofCompaniesaftertheAnnualGeneralMeeting.ShareholderswishingtoreceivethefullAnnualReportinfutureyearsmayopttodosobywritingtotheCompanySecretary.DeloitteLLPhavereportedontheCompany’sAnnualAccountsandtheauditablepartoftheDirectors’RemunerationReportfortheperiodended31December2011;thisreportwasunqualifiedandcontainednostatementundersection496oftheCompaniesAct2006.
Review of Business
AsummaryoftheCompany’sactivitiescanbefoundonpages4to19,RiskFactorsareonpages20and21,ourCorporateResponsibilityReportisonpages22to23andaSummaryofFinancialPerformanceisonpage24.
Corporate Governance
TheBoardconfirmsthatthroughouttheperiodtheCompanyhascompliedwiththeprinciplesoftheCombinedCodeonCorporateGovernanceissuedinJune2008.DuringtheyearweconsideredthetermsoftheUKCorporateGovernanceCodeissuedinJune2010andtheAICCodeofCorporateGovernanceissuedinOctober2010.
ThefullCorporateGovernanceReportissetoutintheAnnualReportfortheperiodended31December2011,whichisavailableonapplicationtoourCompanySecretaryoronourwebsitewww.alliancetrust.co.uk.
The Board
TheBoardsetsthelong-termobjectivesoftheCompanyandapprovesitsbusinessplansandstrategicdirection.Itisresponsibleforensuringthatthereisinplaceaframeworkofprudentcontrolstoenablerisktobemanagedeffectively.Itprovidesleadershipandreviewsbusinessperformance.
EachDirectorbringsdifferentskillsandexperiencestotheBoardandtheseareoutlinedonpages26and27.TheyarehoweverallresponsibleforthedecisionstakenbytheBoard.TheChairmanwasconsideredindependentuponappointmentandnoneoftheNon-ExecutiveDirectorshashadapreviousrelationshipwiththeCompanyotherthanasshareholder.TheNon-ExecutiveDirectorstakenopartindaytodaymanagementoftheCompanyandareallconsideredtobeindependent.
Re-election of Directors
ConsueloBrookewasappointedon25November2011andKarinForsekeon1March2012.TheirappointmentfallstobeconfirmedbyshareholdersattheAnnualGeneralMeeting.HughBolland,TimothyIngramandLesleyKnoxarestandingdownfromtheBoard.TheBoardhasdecidedthatinlinewiththeUKCorporateGovernanceCodealloftheDirectorswillbesubjecttore-electioneveryyear.Thereforetheremainingdirectorswillstandforre-electionatthismeeting.
TheindividualperformanceofeachDirectorandtheirongoingsuitabilityforelectionorre-electionwasconsideredandendorsedbytheNominationCommittee.Allarerecommendedforelectionorre-electionattheforthcomingAnnualGeneralMeeting.EachofourDirectorshasconfirmedthattheyremaincommittedtotheirroleandhavesufficienttimeavailabletomeetwhatisexpectedofthem.
DrMastershasagreedtoofferhimselfforre-electiondespitehavingservedasanindependentnon-executivedirectorfornineyears,inordertoassistwiththetransitionoftheBoard.HewillretirefromtheBoardduringthecourseoftheyear.TheBoardisoftheviewthatDrMastersremainsindependentincharacterandjudgement–independencecannotbedeterminedbylengthoftimealone,andDrMasterscontinuestodemonstratetheconstructivechallengetomanagementexpectedfromnon-executivedirectors.HisexperienceofseniormanagementrolesoutsidethefinancialservicessectoralsoaddstothediversityofviewsaroundtheBoardtable.
Investment Trust Status
TheCompanyisaninvestmenttrustandseeksannualapprovalfromHMRevenueandCustomstomaintainitsstatusasaninvestmenttrust.Thelastsuchapprovalwasgrantedinrespectofthefinancialyearending31January2011.
26|Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011
Directors
Lesley Knox Chairman s JoinedtheBoard2001, AppointedChairman 2004 Chairman, Nomination Committee
LesleyKnoxgraduatedwithanMAinLawfromtheUniversityofCambridge,qualifiedasalawyerandworkedintheUKandUS.ShewasagroupdirectorwithKleinwortBensonandalsoHeadofInstitutionalAssetManagementatKleinwortBensonInvestmentManagement.
SheisChairmanofGrosvenorGroupLtdandDundeeDesignLtd.HerotherboardappointmentsincludeTurcanConnellAssetManagement,SABMillerplcandCentricaPLC.
Herexperienceofassetmanagementandcorporatefinance,togetherwithherongoinginvolvementintheboardsofbothlistedandprivatebusinessesacrossawiderangeofsectors,enablehertoleadadiverseboardwithvariedskillsandexperience.
Karin Forseke Chairman Designate s JoinedtheBoard2012
KarinForsekestudiedEconomics,SociologyandMarketingbeforemovingintofinancialservicesintheUSandtheninLondon.SheservedasChiefOperatingOfficerofLondonInternationalFinancialFuturesExchange,(LIFFE),andthenjoinedDCarnegie&CoABbecomingitsChiefExecutiveOfficer.
ShehasbeenaNon-ExecutiveDirectoroftheFinancialServicesAuthority(FSA)sinceDecember2004andiscurrentlyitsDeputyChairmanandChairmanofitsAudit,RemunerationandNonExecutiveDirectorscommittees.SheservesasaNon-ExecutiveDirectorofWalleniusLines,aNon-ExecutiveDirectoroftheRoyalOperainStockholmandisaBoardmemberoftheEuropeanCouncilonForeignRelations(ECFR).
HerwideexperienceofthefinancialservicessectorandmorerecentlyfromaregulatoryperspectivecomplementsthoseoftheotherDirectors.Combinedwithherbroadgeographic,economicandpoliticalknowledgesheisequippedwiththerequiredlevelofskillsandunderstandingtoprovideconstructivechallengeacrossthegroupandtoleadtheBoard.
Christopher Masters Senior Independent Director l n s JoinedtheBoard2002
ChristopherMasterstookhisdoctorateinChemistryattheUniversityofLeeds.HeworkedinternationallywithShellandalsoChristianSalvesenwherehewasChiefExecutive.HewasExecutiveChairmanofAggrekoPLCandisChairmanoftheFestivalCityTheatresTrustandamemberoftheCourtoftheUniversityofEdinburgh.
OtherdirectorshipsincludeTheCrownAgents,JohnWoodGroupPLCandSpeedyHirePLC.
Comingfromindustryratherthanthefinancialservicessector,andhavingworkedintheUSandEuropeaswellintheUK,hecanbringadifferentperspectivetoBoarddiscussionsandofferconstructivechallengebasedonhisownexperience.
Hugh Bolland l n s JoinedtheBoard2007
HughBollandgraduatedwithaBA(Hons)inEconomicsandStatisticsfromtheUniversityofExeter.HehasheldvariousroleswithSchrodersincludingInvestmentDirectorandthenManagingDirectorofSchrodersinHongKongandlaterChiefExecutiveofSchrodersAustralia.IntheUKhehasbeenChairmanofSchroderUnitTrusts,ChiefExecutiveandlatterlyViceChairmanofSchroderInvestmentManagement.
HeisaNon-ExecutiveDirectorofJPMorganIndianInvestmentTrustPLC,FidelityAsianValuesPLCandDutchlistedEurocommercialPropertiesN.V.
Drawingonhismanyyearsofhands-onexperienceoffund
Non-executiveDirectors
Chairman
1 2 3
4
1
2
3l MemberoftheAuditCommittee
n Memberofthe RemunerationCommittee
s Memberofthe NominationCommittee
Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011|27
managementacrosstheglobe,hecanspeakwithauthorityonthiscentralelementoftheCompany’sbusiness.
John Hylands l n s JoinedtheBoard2008 Chairman, Audit Committee
JohnHylandsgraduatedwithaBScinMathematicsfromtheUniversityofGlasgow.InhiscareerwithStandardLifeheheldvariousactuarial,financeandmanagementpositionsincludingservingasFinanceDirector.
HeisamemberoftheAvivaUKLifeWithProfitsCommitteeandisaNon-ExecutiveDirectoroftheBoardofEcclesiasticalInsuranceGroupPLC.HealsochairsthetrusteesoftheStandardLifeandBOCpensionschemes.
Hisqualificationasanactuaryandsubsequentexperienceinseniorrolesinthefinancialservicessectorenablehimtoapplyarigorousandanalyticalapproach,inparticularinhisroleasChairmanoftheAuditCommittee.
Timothy Ingram l n s JoinedtheBoard2010 Chairman, Remuneration Committee
TimothyIngramgraduatedwithanMAinEconomicsfromtheUniversityofCambridgeandanMBAfromINSEADBusinessSchool.HehasbeenFinanceDirector,ChiefExecutiveandlaterChairmanofFirstNationalFinanceCorporation,aManagingDirectorofAbbeyNationalandChiefExecutiveofCaledoniaInvestmentsPLC.
HeisChairmanofCollins
StewartPLC,SeniorIndependentDirectorofSavillsPLC,aNon-ExecutiveDirectorofAlokIndustriesLimitedandwas,untilMay2011,SeniorIndependentDirectorofSagePLC.
Hisexperienceofleadingaself-managedinvestmenttrust,coupledwithhiswiderknowledgeofthefinancialservicessector,meanthathehasaclearunderstandingoftheopportunitiesandchallengesfacingtheCompanyandthemanagementteam.
Consuelo Brooke l n s JoinedtheBoard2011
ConsueloBrookegraduatedwithaB.Sc(Hons)inpolitics,economicsandinternationalrelationsfromtheUniversityofSouthampton.ShehasworkedforS.G.Warburg,MercuryAssetManagementandMerrillLynchInvestmentManagers.ShesubsequentlyestablishedherownfirmCBrookeInvestmentPartnersLtd.
ConsueloBrookehaspreviouslyheldNon-ExecutiveDirectorshipsatBTGplcandXansaplcandiscurrentlyanIndependentMemberoftheCouncilofSussexUniversityofwhichshewasTreasurerfrom2002-2011andaTrusteeofSussexCommunityFoundation.
WithabackgroundinassetmanagementshebringsaconsiderableamountofinvestmentknowledgetotheBoard.Herpreviousnon-executivedirectorshipsprovideherwiththeexperiencetoenablehertocontributetoBoarddiscussions.
Katherine Garrett-Cox Chief Executive s JoinedtheCompanyas ChiefInvestmentOfficer in2007.Appointed ChiefExecutivein2008
KatherineGarrett-CoxgraduatedwithaBA(Hons)inHistoryfromDurhamUniversityandisamemberoftheUKSocietyofInvestmentProfessionals;CFAInstitute.
ShehasheldChiefInvestmentOfficerandExecutiveDirectorroleswithAberdeenAssetManagementPLCandMorleyFundManagement,nowAvivaInvestors.SheisamemberoftheSupervisoryBoardofDeutscheBankAG.
Inherrolesheisresponsibleforboththeinvestmentpolicyandassetallocationofthecompanyaswellasexecutiveoversightforthebusiness.Shehasmorethan22years’experienceintheinvestmentindustry,havingmanagedNorthAmerican,EmergingMarketandGlobalEquitiesportfolios.
Herhands-onfundmanagementexperience,combinedwithseniorleadershiprolesinmajorinvestmenthousesandacommitmenttothedevelopmentofthenextgenerationofbusinessleaders,giveherthenecessaryskillstoleadtheCompanyandtoevolveitsstrategyforfuturegrowth.
Alan Trotter Finance Director JoinedtheBoard2010
AlanTrottergraduatedwithaBAcc(Hons)inAccountancyfromtheUniversityofGlasgowandwithanLLBfromtheUniversityofLondon.
HequalifiedasacharteredaccountantwithErnst&YoungworkinginboththeUKandHongKong.HeheldseniorfinanceroleswithStandardLife,StandardLifeBankandRoyalBankofScotlandbeforemovingtoLegalandGeneralwherehewasGroupCorporateDevelopmentDirectorwithresponsibilityforthecentralfinancefunction.HeisamemberoftheUniversityofEdinburghAuditCommitteeandoftheFinancialReportingReviewPanel.
Histechnicalandanalyticalskills,gainedbothinprofessionalpracticeandsubsequentlyinseveralmajorfinancialservicesbusinesses,equiphimwelltoleadthefinanceandcontrolfunctionsandtocontributetotheshapingofthefuturestrategyforthebusiness.
ExecutiveDirectors
98
7
5
6
4
5
6
7
8
9
28|Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011
SummaryDirectors’Remuneration
Remuneration Approach
AtthestartoftheperiodweconsideredtheimplicationsoftheFSARemunerationCodeandreportedonthislastyear.
Performanceassessment:WehaveinplacethroughouttheCompanyanannualperformancereviewbasedonachievementofpersonalobjectivesalignedtotheCompany’sKeyPerformanceIndicators(KPIs).
Guarantees:Theuseofguaranteedbonuseshasalwaysbeenlimitedandthiswillcontinuetobethecase.
Severance:TheCompany’spolicyisonlytomakepaymentsonearlyterminationthatreflecttheleaver’scontractualentitlementsandotheramountswhichacourtortribunalwouldbelikelytoaward.
Leverage:TheRemunerationCommitteehasreviewedtheproportionofvariablepaytoannualsalaryofDirectorsandotherseniormanagersandissatisfiedthatitisappropriate.
Multi-yearframework:TheCompanycurrentlyoperatesacombinationofannualandthreeyearperformanceconditionstogetherwitharequirementforDirectorsandotherseniormanagerstodeferpartofanyawardintheformofshares.
Ourinvestmentmanagersareeligibleforannualbonusesbasedonachievementofannualperformancetargetsrelevanttotheirownportfolioandthewiderequityportfolio.Atleastonehalfofanyannualbonusisdeferredforthreeyears.Attheendofthethreeyeardeferralperiodamatchingawardmayvestbasedonindividualportfolioperformance(includingconsiderationofconsistencyoffundperformance,riskprofileofthefundandmarketconditions)andachievementofthecorporatetargetassetbytheBoard.
Otherseniormanagers’annualbonusesarebasedonperformanceagainstbusinessandindividualobjectivesduringtheyear,withthelong-termelementbasedoncorporateand/orbusinessperformancemeasures.
InsettingthelevelsofremunerationfortheExecutiveDirectors,theRemunerationCommitteetakesaccountofthelevelsofremunerationofotheremployees,particularlyatseniorlevel,withintheCompanyandoftheoveralllevelofpayawardsmade.TheExecutiveDirectors’remunerationisnotsetthroughanyformulaicapproachormultipleofanyotheremployeesengagedwithinthebusiness,butisdrivenbytheirexperienceandmarketratesforcomparableroles.
WehaveusedourKPIstosetthefollowingCorporateTargetsforthedeterminationoftheamountofanyannualbonusandinthecaseoftheExecutiveDirectorsbetween25%and70%oftheirannualbonusisbasedonachievementofthesetargetsovertheperiod:
• PercentagechangeinNetAssetValueagainstthepeergroup
• PercentagechangeinTotalShareholderReturnagainstthepeergroup
• Dividendgrowth
• Achievementofcostbudget
ThepeergroupistheAICGlobalGrowthInvestmentTrustsector.
Thisyearwehavenotreducedthelevelofincentiveawardsmadetoreflectthattheywerebeinggivenforan11monthperiodratherthanforafullyearbuttheCommitteetookintoaccountperformanceagainsttargetsovertheshorterperiod.InrespectoftheCorporateTargetstherewerenosignificantdifferencesbetweenthepositionoftheendoftheperiodandthatattheendofJanuary2012.
Basic Salary
ThePolicyadoptedbytheCommitteeisthatbasesalariesofexecutivesshouldbetargetedatmarketmedianforjobsofasimilarsizeandcomplexity.Asat31December2011thesalariesofalloftheExecutiveDirectorsarebeloworaroundthemarketmedian.NosalaryincreaseshavebeenawardedtoExecutiveDirectorsfor2012.
All Employee Share Ownership Plan
ExecutiveDirectorsandallemployeesmayparticipateintheCompany’sAllEmployeeShareOwnershipPlan.
AllfulltimeparticipantswhowereinthePlanforthefullfinancialperiodwillreceivethemaximumawardofshares,valuedat£3,000.Part-timestaffandthosethatjoinedthePlanpartwaythroughtheperiodwillreceiveaproratedaward.
Variable Pay
Therearetwocomponentstovariablepay;firstlytheAnnualBonusand,secondly,awardsmadeundertheCompany’sLongTermIncentivePlan(LTIP)whichwasapprovedbyshareholdersin2007.
Annual Salary
ThetablebelowshowstheannualsalariesofeachofourExecutiveDirectors.
Salary at 1/2/09 (£) 1/2/10 (£) 1/2/11 (£) 1/1/12 (£)
KatherineGarrett-Cox 405,000 405,000 425,250 425,250RobertBurgess 230,000 250,000 262,500 262,500AlanTrotter - 210,000 225,000 225,000
Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011|29
Annual Bonuses
KatherineGarrett-Coxiseligibleforanannualbonusofupto150%ofsalary.OtherExecutiveDirectorsareeligibleforanannualbonusofupto100%oftheirsalary.Allaretotallydependentuponperformance.Atleast50%ofanyannualbonusawardmustbedeferredintoshareswithintheLTIPdescribedbelow.TheDirectorcanchoosetoreceivetherestofanybonusincashorhaveitdeferredintotheLTIP.
TheCorporatetargets,detailedonthepreviouspage,comprised70%ofthepotentialbonusawardforKatherineGarrett-Cox,50%forAlanTrotterand25%ofthepotentialawardforRobertBurgess.Theremainderofthepotentialawardwassubjecttoperformanceagainstacombinationofbusinessandindividualobjectivesdeterminedatthestartoftheyearassetoutbelow.
Corporate Business Individual Director objectives objectives objectives
KatherineGarrett-Cox 70% 20% 10%RobertBurgess 25% 55% 20%AlanTrotter 50% 30% 20%
ThebusinessandindividualtargetsforKatherineGarrett-CoxreflectedbothherroleasChiefInvestmentOfficerandChiefExecutive,andincludedfinancialperformanceofthesubsidiarybusinesses,peopledevelopment,oversightandinvestorrelations.
ThebusinessandindividualobjectivesforRobertBurgessrelatedtothefinancialperformanceofAllianceTrustSavings,thestrategicdevelopmentandoperationaleffectivenessofthegroupanddevelopingtheAllianceTrustSavingsmanagementteam.TheobjectivesforAlanTrotterrelatedtotheembeddingofriskmanagementandinternalcontrolsacrossthebusiness,leadershipinfinancialmattersandbusinessplanning.
Thefollowingbonusesinrespectoftheperiodending31December2011wereawardedandwerepayableaftertheperiodend.
Director Bonus % of maximum
KatherineGarrett-Cox £527,850 83%RobertBurgess £157,500 60%AlanTrotter £194,175 86%
Long Term Incentive Plans
Thecurrenttarget,asapprovedbytheshareholdersin2011,isbasedonacombinationoftwoseparateperformancemeasures–onerelatingtogrowthinNAVandanothertoTSR–eachofwhichwilldeterminetheextenttowhich50percent.ofanawardvests.Undertheseconditions,theTSRandNAVgrowthofyourCompanywillbemeasuredoveraperiodofthreeconsecutivefinancialyears(commencingwiththefinancialyearinwhichtheawardinquestionisgranted)andthencomparedtothecorrespondingperformanceofeachcompanyinacomparatorgroupcomprisedoftheAICglobalgrowthinvestmenttrusts(themembersofthecomparatorgroupattheendofthefinancialperiodcanbefoundonpage31).
However,notwithstandingtheleveloftheCompany’sperformanceagainsttheTSRandNAVgrowthconditionsnopartofanawardwillvestunlesstheCompanyhasdeclaredaprogressivedividendinrespectofeachofthefinancialyearsthatmakeuptheperformanceperiod.
Itisintendedthatallawardswillbesatisfiedfromsharespurchasedontheopenmarketandnonewshareswillbeissuedtosatisfyawards.
Fixed and Variable Remuneration
Maximum that could be received1
2
566,751
Total (£)
461,751Actual received 66% 34%
46%54%
Robert Burgess
Maximum that could be received1
2
487,734
Total (£)
456,909Actual received 58% 42%
46%54%
Alan Trotter
Maximum that could be received1
2
1,769,861
Total (£)
1,034,175Actual received
Fixed Cash
49% 51%
36%29% 35%
Variable Cash Variable Share AwardKatherine Garrett-Cox 1
Includes Salary, Car Allowance, Taxable Bene�ts and Other Payments.1
Refers to the Annual Bonus awarded in respect of the period but paid after the period end.2
If the LTIP target had been met the Director would have received shares in the period from the awards made in 2008 (valued at the Market Price of shares on the date of award (5 May 2008: £3.51)).
3
2
3
30|Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011
Directors’ Shareholdings
AllDirectorsarerequiredtoacquire3,000sharesintheCompany.DetailsoftheshareholdingsofallDirectors,togetherwithdetailsofsharesacquiredintheyear,areshownbelow.TheCompanyhasissuednooptionstosubscribeforshares.
Directors’ Shareholdings*
As at 1 Feb 11 Acquired or date of between appointment As at 31 Dec 11 Name if later 31 Dec 11 & 1 Mar 12
LesleyKnox 156,976 160,109 746HughBolland 10,000 10,000 -ConsueloBrooke - 3,000 -RobertBurgess 58,724 89,764 2,651KatherineGarrett-Cox 287,522 343,828 3,776JohnHylands 65,073 66,595 387TimothyIngram 38,182 44,524 -ChristopherMasters 11,401 11,657 95AlanTrotter 8,771 18,181 79
*Unaudited
KarinForsekewasappointedduringthecloseperiodpriortoannouncementoftheCompany’sresultsfortheperiodending31December2011.Sheintendstopurchasetherequisiteholdingfollowingannouncementoftheresultson6March2012.
TheRemunerationCommitteehasadoptedapolicythatExecutiveDirectorsshould,overtime,accumulateapersonalholdingofsharesintheCompanyequivalenttotheirannualsalary.
Company performance graph
WedonothaveabenchmarkbutarerequiredbylawtoincludeagraphshowingthetotalshareholderreturnoftheCompanyagainstabroadequitymarketindexoverafiveyearperiod.ThecomparatorwhichhasbeenselectedasabroadmeasureofourperformanceistheFTSEAll-WorldIndex.
ItshouldbenotedthattheCompanydoesnotseektotrackthisindex.
Performance relative to Peer Group*
Name 11 Months 3 Years 5 Years
TSRRanking 6/32 29/32 20/31
*ThepeergroupconsistsofthecompaniesintheAICGlobalGrowthsectorandislistedopposite.
Source:MorningstarandFactSet
SummaryDirectors’Remuneration
1Thisincludesthebonuspayableinrespectoftheperiodending31December2011andwaspaidaftertheyearend.2Thisshowsthemaximumtotalnumberofawardsmadeunderlongtermincentiveplans.Awardsarefornilpricedoptions.Awardsonlyvestafterthreeyearsfromthedateoftheawardandaresubjecttoperformanceconditions.Noawardsvestedfortheyearand178,251awardsheldbyKatherineGarrett-Coxlapsedduringtheyear.3ThisIncludesDirectorfeesandadditionalpayments,asappropriatetotheindividualDirector,forChairmanshipormembershipofRemunerationandAuditCommittees,ChairmanshipormembershipofsubsidiaryboardsandtheroleofSeniorIndependentDirector.
Total Emoluments Total Emoluments 1/2/11 to 1/2/10 to Long Term Long Term Executive Date of 31/12/111 31/01/11 Incentive awards Incentive awards Director Contract (£) (£) as at 31/12/112 as at 31/01/112
KatherineGarrett-Cox 20/04/07 1,034,175 842,645 989,880 876,730RobertBurgess 02/02/10 461,751 549,572 584,831 380,680AlanTrotter 01/02/10 456,909 405,833 311,484 158,209
Non-executive Date of Director Appointment
LesleyKnox 15/06/01 91,667 90,000HughBolland3 01/07/07 37,583 39,000ConsueloBrooke3 25/11/11 3,600 -JohnHylands3 22/02/08 42,167 44,000TimothyIngram3 24/09/10 33,000 11,994ChristopherMasters3 15/11/02 37,583 39,000ClareSheikh3 14/09/05 10,024 31,500
Summary Table of Salary and Benefits
Company performance Source: FactSet
Dec2011
Jan2011
Jan2010
Jan2009
Jan2008
% Alliance Trust FTSE All-World Index
Jan2007
-25
-15
-5
5
15
25
35
-25
-15
-5
5
15
25
35
Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011|31
Peer Group (AIC Global Growth Sector)BankersBritishEmpireSecuritiesBrunnerCaledoniaInvestmentsCayenneEdinburghWorldwideEPGlobalOpportunitiesEstablishmentForeign&ColonialF&CGlobalSmallerCompanies
F&CManagedPortfolioGrowthHendersonGlobalIndependentJPMElectManagedGrowthJPMorganOverseasJupiterPrimadonaGrowthLawDebentureLindsellTrainMajedieMartinCurriePortfolioMidWyndInternationalMitonWorldwideGrowth
MonksNewStarPersonalAssetsRITCapitalPartnersRuffer(fromOct2011)ScottishInvestmentScottishMortgageSVMGlobalFundWitanWorldTrustFund
IndependentAuditor’sReport
INDEPENDENT AUDITOR’S STATEMENT TO THE MEMBERS OF ALLIANCE TRUST PLC
Wehaveexaminedthesummaryfinancialstatementforthe11monthperiodended31December2011whichcomprisestheSummaryConsolidatedandCompanyIncomeStatement,SummaryConsolidatedandCompanyBalanceSheet,SummaryDirectors’ReportandtheSummaryDirectors’RemunerationReport.
Thisreportismadesolelytothecompany’smembers,asabody,inaccordancewithsection428oftheCompaniesAct2006.Ourworkhasbeenundertakensothatwemightstatetothecompany’smembersthosematterswearerequiredtostatetotheminanauditors’reportandfornootherpurpose.Tothefullestextentpermittedbylaw,wedonotacceptorassumeresponsibilitytoanyoneotherthanthecompanyandthecompany’smembersasabody,forourauditwork,forthisreport,forourauditreport,orfortheopinionswehaveformed.
Respective responsibilities of directors and auditors
ThedirectorsareresponsibleforpreparingthesummarisedannualreportinaccordancewithapplicableUnitedKingdomlaw.
Ourresponsibilityistoreporttoyououropinionontheconsistencyofthesummaryfinancialstatementwithinthesummarisedannualreportwiththefullannualfinancialstatements,theDirectors’RemunerationReportandtheDirectors’Report,anditscompliancewiththerelevantrequirementsofsection428oftheCompaniesAct2006andtheregulationsmadethereunder.
Wealsoreadtheotherinformationcontainedinthesummarisedannualreportasdescribedinthecontentssection,andconsidertheimplicationsforourreportifwebecomeawareofanyapparentmisstatementsormaterialinconsistencieswiththesummaryfinancialstatement.
WeconductedourworkinaccordancewithBulletin2008/3issuedbytheAuditingPracticesBoard.Ourreportonthecompany’sfullannualfinancialstatementsdescribesthebasisofourauditopiniononthosefinancialstatements,theDirectors’RemunerationReport,andtheDirectors’Report.
Opinion
Inouropinion,thesummaryfinancialstatementisconsistentwiththefullannualfinancialstatements,theDirectors’ReportandtheDirectors’RemunerationReportofAllianceTrustplcforthe11monthperiodended31December2011andcomplieswiththeapplicablerequirementsofsection428oftheCompaniesAct2006,andtheregulationsmadethereunder.
Deloitte LLP
CharteredAccountantsandStatutoryAuditorsLondon,UnitedKingdom
5March2012
32|Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011
Summary consolidated income statement for the 11 month period ended 31 December 2011
11 months to December 2011 Year to January 2011
£000 Revenue Capital Total Revenue Capital Total
Revenue
Income 104,610 - 104,610 101,943 - 101,943
(Loss)/Profitonfairvalue
designatedinvestments - (253,611) (253,611) - 404,536 404,536
(Loss)/Profitoninvestmentproperty - (240) (240) - 589 589
Total revenue 104,610 (253,851) (149,241) 101,943 405,125 507,068
Administrativeexpenses (37,419) (1,957) (39,376) (38,138) (2,684) (40,822)
Finance(costs)/income (8,736) 5,914 (2,822) (5,306) (4,462) (9,768)
Impairmentlosses - - - - (297) (297)
Lossondisposalofofficepremises - (5) (5) - - -
Lossonrevaluationofofficepremises - - - - (47) (47)
Foreignexchangegains - 1,275 1,275 30 95 125
(Loss)/Profit before tax 58,455 (248,624) (190,169) 58,529 397,730 456,259
Tax (2,562) (100) (2,662) (4,439) (73) (4,512)
(Loss)/Profit for the period 55,893 (248,724) (192,831) 54,090 397,657 451,747
All(loss)/profitfortheperiodisattributabletoequityholdersoftheparent
Earnings per share from
continuing operations attributable
to equity holders of the parent
Basic(ppershare) 8.91 (39.66) (30.75) 8.20 60.26 68.46
Diluted(ppershare) 8.89 (39.66) (30.77) 8.17 60.10 68.27
Summary Company income statement for the 11 month period ended 31 December 2011
11 months to December 2011 Year to January 2011
£000 Revenue Capital Total Revenue Capital Total
Revenue
Income 85,117 - 85,117 86,837 - 86,837
(Loss)/Profitonfairvalue
designatedinvestments - (254,584) (254,584) - 391,349 391,349
(Loss)/Profitoninvestmentproperty - (240) (240) - 589 589
Totalrevenue 85,117 (254,824) (169,707) 86,837 391,938 478,775
Administrativeexpenses (14,824) (1,159) (15,983) (15,110) (1,924) (17,034)
Financecosts (3,026) (2,950) (5,976) (3,244) (2,302) (5,546)
Lossondisposalofofficepremises - (5) (5) - - -
Lossonrevaluationofofficepremises - - - - (47) (47)
Foreignexchangegains - 1,275 1,275 - 862 862
(Loss)/Profit before tax 67,267 (257,663) (190,396) 68,483 388,527 457,010
Tax (5,369) 100 (5,269) (4,696) 328 (4,368)
(Loss)/Profit for the period 61,898 (257,563) (195,665) 63,787 388,855 452,642
All(loss)/profitfortheperiodisattributabletoequityholdersoftheparent
Earnings per share from continuing
operations attributable to equity
shareholders
Basic(ppershare) 9.87 (41.06) (31.19) 9.67 58.93 68.60
Diluted(ppershare) 9.84 (41.06) (31.22) 9.64 58.77 68.41
SummaryFinancialStatements
Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011|33
Summary balance sheet as at 31 December 2011
Group Company
£000 Dec 11 Jan 11 Dec 11 Jan 11
Non-current assets
Investmentsheldatfairvalue 2,625,615 3,237,614 2,560,576 3,172,639
Investmentproperty 9,775 28,515 9,775 28,515
Property,plantandequipment:
Officepremises 6,025 6,270 6,025 6,270
Otherfixedassets 15 27 15 27
Intangibleassets 1,598 2,345 390 542
Pensionschemesurplus 3,150 846 3,150 846
Deferredtaxasset 907 182 907 151
2,647,085 3,275,799 2,580,838 3,208,990
Current assets
Outstandingsettlements
andotherreceivables 190,644 47,051 22,171 29,687
Withholdingtaxdebtor 789 1,413 789 1,413
Corporationtaxdebtor 179 79 179 79
Cashandcashequivalents 415,435 295,355 72,349 27,511
607,047 343,898 95,488 58,690
Total assets 3,254,132 3,619,697 2,676,326 3,267,680
Current liabilities
Outstandingsettlements
andotherpayables (600,539) (383,505) (22,661) (32,613)
Taxpayable (141) (2,260) (3,991) (1,198)
Bankoverdraftsandloans (248,768) (338,997) (248,768) (338,997)
(849,448) (724,762) (275,420) (372,808)
Total assets less current liabilities 2,404,684 2,894,935 2,400,906 2,894,872
Non-current liabilities
Deferredtaxliability (907) (303) (907) (303)
Amountspayableunderlongterm
InvestmentIncentivePlan (404) (128) (205) (65)
Net assets 2,403,373 2,894,504 2,399,794 2,894,504
Equity
Sharecapital 14,833 16,527 14,833 16,527
Capitalreserve 1,665,692 2,158,630 1,629,129 2,131,651
Mergerreserve 645,335 645,335 645,335 645,335
Capitalredemptionreserve 4,165 2,471 4,165 2,471
Revenuereserve 73,348 71,541 106,332 98,520
Total Equity 2,403,373 2,894,504 2,399,794 2,894,504
Allnetassetsareattributabletoequityholdersoftheparent
Net Asset Value per ordinary
share attributable to
equity holders of the parent
Basic(£) £4.06 £4.39 £4.06 £4.39
Diluted(£) £4.05 £4.38 £4.04 £4.38
ThesummaryfinancialstatementswereapprovedbytheBoardofDirectorsandauthorisedforissueon5March2012.
Theyweresignedonitsbehalfby:
Lesley Knox Katherine Garrett-Cox
Chairman ChiefExecutive
34|Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011
Incorporation
AllianceTrustPLCisincorporatedinScotlandwiththeregisterednumber1731.
TheCompany’sRegisterofMembersisheldatComputershareInvestorServicesPLC,LochsideHouse,7LochsideAvenue,EdinburghPark,EdinburghEH129DJ.
General Enquiries
IfyouhaveanenquiryabouttheCompany,pleasecontacttheCompanySecretaryatourregisteredoffice:
8 West Marketgait, Dundee DD1 1QNTel:01382321000Fax: 01382321185Email: [email protected]
Forsecurityandcompliancemonitoringpurposestelephonecallsmayberecorded.
Investor Relations
OurHeadofInvestorRelationscanbecontactedatourregisteredoffice(detailedabove).
Ourwebsitewww.alliancetrust.co.ukcontainsinformationabouttheCompany,includingdailysharepriceandnetassetvalue.TheInvestorRelationssectionofthewebsitecontainsthetermsofreferenceoftheAudit,RemunerationandNominationCommittees.
Registrars
Ourregistrarsare:
Computershare Investor Services PLC PO Box 82, The Pavilions, Bridgwater Road, Bristol BS99 7NH
ChangeofaddressnotificationsandregistrationenquiriesforshareholdingsregisteredinyourownnameshouldbesenttotheCompany’sregistrarsattheaboveaddress,whichshouldalsobecontactedifyouwouldlikedividendsonsharesregisteredinyourownnametobesenttoyourbankorbuildingsocietyaccount.YoumaycheckyourholdingsandviewotherinformationaboutAllianceTrustsharesregisteredinyourownnameatwww.computershare.com.
Data Protection
TheCompanyisadatacontrollerasdefinedundertheDataProtectionAct1998.Informationreceivedfromoraboutshareholdersorinvestors(forexamplefromastockbroker),whetherbytelephoneorinwriting,byfaxorbyanyotherelectronicordigitalmeansofcommunicationmaybeprocessed.
InformationheldontheCompany’sRegisterofMembersis,bylaw,informationtowhichthepublicmay,foraproperpurpose,haveaccessandtheCompanycannotpreventanypersoninspectingitorhavingcopiesofitforsuchpurpose,onpaymentofthestatutoryfee.
Electronic Communications
Ifyouholdyoursharesinyourownname,weareabletosendyouannualreportsandnoticesofmeetingselectronicallyinsteadofinpaperformat.Ifyouwishtoregisterforthisservicepleaselogontowww.alliancetrust.co.uk/ec.htmwhichwillprovideyouwithalinktoourregistrars’website.
Taxation
IfyouareinanydoubtaboutyourliabilitytotaxarisingfromashareholdingintheCompanyyoushouldseekprofessionaladvice.
Income Tax
DividendspaidbytheCompanycarryataxcreditat10%ofthegrossdividend.Dividendsarepaidnetofthetaxcredit.
Ifyouholdyoursharesinyourownname,thetaxvoucherwhichyouneedforyourtaxrecordswillbesenttotheaddresswehaveforyouontheregistermaintainedbyComputershare.TheRegistrarwillsendaconsolidatedtaxvouchertomembersafterthefinaldividendduringthetaxyearispaid.
Ifyourdividendsarereceivedbyanominee,suchasyourstockbroker’snominee,youmustcontactthatpersonforthetaxvoucher.IfyouinvestintheCompanythroughAllianceTrustSavings,itwillautomaticallysupplyyouwithaconsolidatedincometaxvoucherforincomereceivedforyouintheInvestmentDealingAccount.
Capital Gains Tax
Forinvestorswhopurchasedsharespriorto31March1982,thecostofthosesharesforcapitalgainstaxpurposesisdeemedtobethepriceoftheshareonthatdate.ThemarketvalueofeachAllianceTrustPLCordinary25pshareonthatdatewas£2.85which,whenadjustedforthesplitona10for1basison21June2006,givesanequivalentvalueof£0.285pershare.ThemarketvalueofeachSecondAllianceTrustPLCordinary25pshareon31March1982was£2.35.HoldersofSecondAllianceTrustPLCsharesreceived8.7453ordinary2.5psharesforeach25pordinarysharetheyheldon20June2006andaretreatedasthoughtheyacquiredthesesharesatthesametimeandatthesamecostastheSecondAllianceTrustsharestheypreviouslyheld.Thisgivesanequivalentvalueof£0.269pershare.
Informationforshareholders
Alliance Trust PLCAnnualReviewDecember2011|35
Risks
IfyouwishtoacquiresharesintheCompany,youshouldtakeprofessionaladviceastowhetheraninvestmentinoursharesissuitableforyou.Youshouldbeawarethat:
• Investmentshouldbemadeforthelongterm
• ThepriceofasharewillbeaffectedbythesupplyanddemandforitontheLondonStockExchangeandmaynotfullyrepresenttheunderlyingvalueoftheassetsoftheCompany.ThepricegenerallystandsbelowthenetassetvalueoftheCompany(‘atadiscount’)butitmayalsostandaboveit(‘atapremium’).Yourcapitalreturnwilldependuponthemovementofthediscount/premiumovertheperiodyouowntheshare,aswellasthecapitalperformanceoftheCompany’sownassets
• TheassetsownedbytheCompanymayhaveexposuretocurrenciesotherthanSterling.Changesinmarketmovementsandinratesofexchangemaycausethevalueofyourinvestmenttogoupordown
• Pastperformanceisnotaguidetothefuture.Whatyougetbackwilldependoninvestmentperformance.Youmaynotgetbacktheamountyouinvest.
Important dates
Oureventsgiveustheopportunitytomeetandhearfromourshareholdersandclients,andareanidealoccasiontogetanupdateonwhatishappeningatAllianceTrust.YoucanmeetseniorrepresentativesfromtheCompanyincludingKatherineGarrett-Cox,ourChiefExecutive,andotherkeymembersofourteam,andlearnaboutourproductsandservices.Therewillbemanyopportunitiesduringtheeventtoaskquestions.
Annual General Meeting
The124thAnnualGeneralMeetingoftheCompanywillbeheldat11.00amonFriday27April2012attheApexCityQuayHotel,Dundee.TheNoticeofMeeting,detailingthebusinessofthemeeting,issenttoallshareholders.
Investor Forums
Wearepleasedtoannouncethatwewillbeholdingtwoinvestorpresentationsduring2012.
27 AprilApexHotel,Dundee
27 SeptemberVictoriaPlazaHotel,London
Detailsoftheseandfutureeventscanbefoundatwww.alliancetrust.co.uk/events.
Financial Calendar
Proposeddividendpaymentdatesforthefinancialperiodto31December2012areonoraround:
2July20121October201231December20122April2013
Report and Accounts for the period ended 31 December
Alliance Trust PLC
Report & Accounts D
ecember 2011
Printed by MLG, Edinburgh
Alliance Trust PLC 8 West Marketgait Dundee DD1 1QN
Tel +44 (0)1382 321000 Email [email protected]
www.alliancetrust.co.uk
Contact