Answer Mining by Combining Extraction Tech With Abductive

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/2/2019 Answer Mining by Combining Extraction Tech With Abductive

    1/8

    " $ % ( 0 2 5 7 2 $ A 7 E G H 2 E S H 7 2 V

    X 5 $

    ` a c e a h a p a r a s u w y a c e a c y p u u c a p y u j e c y k c l u u a o a c e k p o c

    a c s w a s o w p p p a u c

    u a p e c y { | } |

    ~

    c | | y

    p a a e j a p a a

    a c e

    o

    a p u u a e u c r a o a u c a o r u c e

    p e u p c w u c a u e y u a c e e c u

    u c a u e w u c p y a r a e a c j p

    u c e w o c u c y s |

    ` o a u e w u c o a c

    a a c a c j p u c

    u c y a c e w

    p p a c j p u c u a u p j u y

    p p y a a c j p u a c c u y s p |

    a u e w u c j p a w a e u o u a p u c | |

    p a u a p j p y p

    o a u c a j a o w e a a j u s e a p a s

    a u e p j u p r a u c e p p u c s u

    w u c a c e e c u u c w u c

    ! " $

    & '

    ) $

    1'

    )

    $

    1'

    u p o w a j a u c | | y a o j u

    p s e p p o a c 2 s 4 5 7 c a u e w u c

    a c e j u c } 5 p p o a c p u w u c a c e

    9| 5 c e c u u c w u c j w e a a u e { { 5

    A B D D F

    p a p p o a c c p o y j u o w j p

    p p o a c c a u e w u c 2 s

    9

    | 5 7 r w r p

    p p o a c p u w u c 2 s 4 | 5 7 a c e e c u u c

    w u c 2 s } | 5 7 j w e a a u e a o p

    p o a c

    c s c p a y a u w u c p w a

    u c a c u e y w a | 9

    R

    T p

    9

    | U W

    X p c a u w u c u a c c

    c w y w c p e p e a c e w c r w c e e a c j p u c a c

    c p u w a p y a p e u c a u u

    o c p u c a c j a u e u c w u c

    c

    | |

    y u w u c e u e c u a p

    s c w o r p p c c a a c j p p a c

    u w u c j a p a e p o w c u c e u u c y

    p p p c p w p c e r a a p u u a c w

    a c j p w c e r

    ` a p e w p u c s w u c

    e o c u c a a c j p j a w e p o

    w u c s o a w p w u c y j u w a

    j u s e u c a c p a 2

    7 a c e u c a c p

    u u c 2

    d

    7 o a w p j p e c e a

    e

    " g i g

    e

    r " g i g

    e w

    "

    B

    '

    r

    '

    i r )

    p p u o c c j a o a c

    p u w u c p c a

    e c u u c w u c j a a o a w p e r p y

    r w u c p p a u c c a j a e u p c

    p a e c u u c w u c y a p a p

    a e a u a a r u c p o a u c c w s s p o

    w c u c p w p c e p c a c e u c p o a u c

    e u p e e w p u c s w u c e o c ` o

    c w s s a p e o e c u a y u a u u c p o a u c

    a o w r u c e c u u c a p s u c p e p

    c u e p u a a u e e c u u c p o a u c u c s c w s s

    u c u a p a a r c u a a r

    c w s s a p p a e y a p e u e w c a

    a r a c e c u a c w s s p w p c e r a o

    p a w u c

    a c w s s j a o a e c c

    e c u u c w u c j p p e w u c s c w s s p a

    2

    7 a c e a c a p u o a u c c w s s p u u c 2 d

    7

    r a e c c s p a p o r u c e w u c s

    o a w p u c j u

    u u o o p u o p a c

  • 8/2/2019 Answer Mining by Combining Extraction Tech With Abductive

    2/8

    Named EntityRecognition

    (CICERO LITE)

    Answer Type

    Hierarchy

    (WordNet)

    DOCUMENT PROCESSING

    Document Index

    Passage Retrieval

    Single Factoid

    Passages

    Multiple ListPassages

    PassagesMultiple Definition

    RepositoryPattern

    FactoidQuestion

    ListQuestion

    Question Parse

    Transformation

    Keyword Extraction

    Semantic

    Recognition of

    Expected Answer Type

    Question

    Definition

    QUESTION PROCESSING

    QUESTION PROCESSING

    Question Parse

    Pattern Matching

    Keyword Extraction

    ANSWER PROCESSINGFACTOID

    Answer Extraction

    Answer Justification

    Answer Reranking

    Theorem Prover

    Axiomatic Knowledge Base

    AnswerFactoid

    ANSWER PROCESSINGLIST

    Answer Extraction

    AnswerList

    ANSWER PROCESSING

    DEFINITION

    Answer Extraction

    Pattern MatchingAnswerDefinition

    Threashold Cutoff

    AQUAINT

    Collection

    Document

    u s w p p u w p

    o

    a c

    d

    p o w a w e p o a w p u c s e c u

    u c p a p

    e

    " g i g

    e

    r

    "

    D D

    '

    g

    ! #

    & ' ( " g

    r " 1 #

    r "

    ! i

    e w

    "

    B 4

    '

    r

    '

    i

    B 6

    '

    r )

    c

    | | y

    9

    a u e w u c j p a w a e 7

    u w u c a c e { | e c u u c w u c a r

    j e u p u r w u c p p c e u c s a c j p

    u e a o a e p a } a a c j p p

    a u e w u c y u e c u |

    w u c r w a

    e u p {

    9

    u u c a c a c e | c u a c w s s

    e c u u c

    u u c a c a c e e c u u c

    c w s s a p a p u o a e a a a c j p y a u e

    a c j p p w p c e r u u e a o j w e a a

    w c e c p

    9

    5 c u p a c j p

    o a u c a p y a w s e u e r p c j u c s

    a p e u c a u c a p u a c e e c u u c

    w u c y a p u r w a { | 5 u o p a c a u e w

    u c c p a c u e a o

    c p j p e y a c j p

    u c s a u e w u c j a a u o p a c p o a u a

    | |

    a w a u c a a c j p u c s u p

    e c u u c w u c

    a a s a y u c c p a y w e c a u e

    w u c p o o a u c a w r o u u c w e c

    a u c c c p c p a w u c y j u w e r

    u p p u c s p a c p a p o e w o c

    9

    @ D ' F H P R '

    S T S

    S

    D

    6 F U

    W

    B D Y

    W

    F

    Y

    a r u p u r w u c a c j p u c

    | |

    e w o c p a u a c c u c s o a p

    p w a { | r u e c u u c p a a

    j e a w a u c p u a r p p o e r

    j u c s a o p e w p a u c

    | | a

    a s w e r 2 a 7 u c p p y j c u e u e c c a u c

    a c j p 7 2 r 7 w c w p e y j c u c a u c e a c j p

    r w e w o c e u e c w p a c j p 7 p 2 7

    p p c a p j a p a u c w

    u c ` w e s e p p

    a b d e

    b

    d

    d g

    b d i q s u s

    d w

    a p u w p

    o u u w p a e u c

    u s w p

    u r c e a w u c p u c s

    o e w u u e c u a p a u e a c e u w u c y r w

    e u p c p e c u u c w u c p a u e p

    u w u c y o c e u e c u

    e a c j p c e e u p a a o a c u a

    p s c u x e r y y w p

    a o e

    c u

    s c u x p y p u c a u p a p o a c u c y r w u w

    u c s l p e

    u p a p u p p r a c e c w c

    e a c j p u u a u c e u a e r a e

    c w u c p a p s c u u c u

  • 8/2/2019 Answer Mining by Combining Extraction Tech With Abductive

    3/8

    ORGANIZATION

    AUTHORED WORK

    PRODUCT

    CONTINENT

    PROVINCE

    QUOTE

    UNIVERSITY

    ACRONYM

    ADDRESS

    ALPHABET

    URI

    PRICE

    SCIENCE NAME

    55

    45

    35

    31

    21

    19

    19

    15

    11

    11

    3

    2

    1

    1

    1

    1

    QUANTITY

    NUMBER

    DATE

    PERSON

    COUNTRY

    OTHER LOCATIONS

    CITY

    5

    5

    3

    5

    u s w p

    a o a

    a e u r a e c c a u e c e c u a j a o

    o a c u e c e c u a a p a p u o a e p o

    w u c a p p a o y u c a a u e

    w u c U W

    U y

    e a c j p u

    d

    `

    y a

    a o e

    c u a y

    e p o u c e r c w c j u u w c e u c

    u p a p w o a c u c l p e

    a o e

    a c j p u w c e j c p u c s u w u c

    R w o a u c

    e u p c a o c s j u c e w u c o p o

    a a u c a a u e w u c y

    o j u a p p a w c u w d

    `

    j p a p u

    w u c y u j u p u e c u a o a c d

    `

    ` a

    u r u c a c p a c a a s

    l c p u c s e c u u c w u c y w u c

    a p a p e u c p e p e

    d

    c

    d

    a p c

    o a e a s a u c a a p c p a o y w

    u c |

    9

    u o a e a s a u c

    a p c l a u w u c d

    p a y j u u a u

    a e j u a c j p a p c w u c d

    p a y j u

    o a c c j p d

    p a

    c u a y w u c

    d

    p a u a c e a c j p p a j u r p a e

    p o " X $ & R " X

    ' X W ) R

    &

    3

    w o c d

    p u c s o e w u a o p a c

    p p o w u c y a u p p u p a c

    a a s r a e c j p e p u e e r w u c

    p u c s p a u e w u c y u p a c a c e u

    e a a a s a p p u c s w a a a s a e

    c c a u c a c e a c j p

    c

    a u w u c y u p p a a s a u c s o w

    u w p p c e a c j p

    c

    a e c u u c w u c y u a j o w u o a

    j p e

    c j p p a u c u p p o e e u p c x p a

    p o w u c

    c a a u e w u c y a c

    j p a p p p a e r a e c p s c u u c

    a c j p p a p u e e r y

    a c j p

    u c p a e a a c a o e c u y u u ` w u e a r e w

    u r w u c s a p o p p a o a w a

    u o e p u e p o l p e

    a j a p a u o a

    p u o a u c s o a c u p a u c p u c s w u u p a s o a u

    p a o y p a u e w u c {

    X U ' y r a w a a p a u e

    u c l p e

    w c e pd

    `

    y y

    a o e

    c u

    s c u x p u c a r e c a o a u c

    a d

    `

    y u c u j a c p a u c e e

    c

    o u c p o a u a p a s p a y j c a o a a p

    w c e a d

    p a c e a d

    a w

    a w p r U ' u c w e a a j p e y

    a c e u e a a c j p r o U w j c

    a r e w u c u p p o e y p p a c j p y

    u p w p c e a a a c j p

    p a u c e c u u c a c j p p u c a p c

    o a u c s a c j p p a 2 d

    7 u u e c u e r a e

    c p w a p p a c j p w u c

    |

    9

    y j c w s s p o

    d

    j p a w a e a u

    a R X a c e ) R & ' X

    3

    u w u c a p p a e r w u c s p a c e

    a p a s p a a c e u p p p c e u c s a a c j p

    a p a s p a a p p j u s a c e u c s

    a w o a w p r a e c o a c u u o u a p u

    a c j p u w o a w p e p o u c c w o r p

    o c u c a u a c j p p a o y a c j p

    w u c | 9

    R T u u

    y X y y C X y E

    F G e

    He

    s P d

    s

    g ge

    Q d s

    s

    w p w u c c j p u c s o p a e } p p

    a c j p w { | | a u e w u c w y 9

    p p a c j p j p r a u c e r p a u c s a c j p

    j u j a u e c u e r y o p p

    s c u x u c s u p o c j p h u p a p a r

    u w p a o a u e w u c a a e p

    u c a o a j a a c j p p w p c e r w p

    o

    T

    U

    T

    W S

    U

    4

    W S

    W

    U

    T

    4

    ! S

    !

    U

    B

    S

    r

    a r a u e w u c a u c s p u c a o

    ` u o u a p p u w

    a w a u c y

    a o e

    c u

    s c u x p a e u e c u a a p u e

    o a c u a u s w p u o o a c

    u a c a o a j a c w o r p u o

  • 8/2/2019 Answer Mining by Combining Extraction Tech With Abductive

    4/8

    X DIEafter suffering

    suffering of CONDITION

    MEDICAL

    DIE

    be killedACCIDENTinX

    DIE

    be killedX {from | of} DISEASE

    seed:

    (ACCIDENT) car wreck

    seed:

    AIDS

    seed:

    (ACCIDENT) complications caused

    by diabetes

    train accident,

    cancer,

    stroke,

    (DISEASE)

    u s w p

    h a p c

    a o j p p s c u x e p p j c p a u c s

    a a u e a c j p

    p a u c y y e u u c s w u e a o c s

    w c p u y u u y p u c y c u c c a c e p a

    u c p

    a c e

    y o a c u

    a a u a e j u a u c j p o c w o p

    w u a a c a o j a p a u c e p a w p e

    j p y u c a o r y c s p o a r

    u w p a o a u e w u c a j p a c

    j p e r u a c a o

    U

    S

    F

    S

    U Y 4

    S

    r

    U

    T

    B

    U

    T

    U

    S

    W ! W

    B D

    T

    D

    S

    B

    D B

    S

    a r w u c a u c s p c a o a w p e j p

    5 a u e w u c j p a c j p e p p

    r a w a c a o a j a p s c u x e r y

    p 5 p p a c j p e a

    u e w u c j p a c j p e r c a a p p

    p c e u c a c j p a c o o e r w p

    o a o a ` p u c w a a

    c o u a u c u c w a a

    `

    `

    y

    ` y

    ` y

    `

    ` p

    `

    p u c a p u w a p u p a p a e p o p

    e u w u c

    u

    h a s p y

    e e r a w p u w

    w u c u

    X o u c u c s c u w

    p u e c u u c s w u c p o a u c j p e e y r a e

    c u o a c u a p c p o l p e

    a j p

    p c p e u c p a o y c w a p c

    u u c 2 p r 7 a w e u c 2 p r 7 $

    ` o p c o p c p r

    a p a c e u e a p

    h u p

    a p y s y X y y y y

    h j p y u c c a

    h a p

    u a u x e a p r y j w e p o u c a e e u u c a

    U B

    &

    S

    @ R ( ( 1

    U B Y

    &

    3 S

    ' ( D ' ( 6 ' (

    4 Y

    U B

    T

    r

    H D @ (

    r

    U

    S

    U

    &

    S

    6

    D D D

    D R H ' R D 1

    9 1 B ( D ' ( R D F @ B @

    B D

    B

    &

    ! S

    W T

    U

    T

    B

    6 Y

    ( D ' ' ' E

    B D Y B

    &

    S

    G

    U U

    S

    B

    F

    S

    &

    W S

    B B

    U

    S

    F

    W @ ( ' ' 1 ' (

    B B

    4

    &

    W S

    B H ( ' ( @ R @ 1 9 F D @ H ( D ' D F H D 9 B @

    B B 4 6

    &

    ! U S

    D 9

    D

    ( B D D (I &

    6 Y

    B

    S S

    6

    &

    &

    S

    D ( 1 '

    U

    T

    B

    S T S

    &

    3 W S

    3 W W U

    3

    U U 6

    ( D ' ' ' E

    B

    S T

    4

    &

    &

    &

    S

    U B 4

    &

    &

    W D R H ' R D 1 H H 1 ( Y

    a r

    9

    w u c a u c s p

    h

  • 8/2/2019 Answer Mining by Combining Extraction Tech With Abductive

    5/8

    10

    20

    30

    10 20 30 40 50

    Question #

    Nr. patternsmatched in answers

    u s w p 9

    w o r p a c j p p a e u a a p c p a e c u u c w u c

    a p c a e o a c c p e a

    u a p a j c a w e a u c

    u a u x e r a u c s c w c p p r p o l p e

    e u u c a p y j a e e a c u w p a w u p u c s

    2 7 e u u c a p u p a w e a 7 a j a 2 7

    a p c a p s c u x o a c c p e a p u p a

    c y j a p e j u 2 a 7 a e a p c a c e 2 r 7 a

    u r e a a w u s w p u o

    e a p c a c e u p p p c e u c s e a a w

    w u c s o w u r p a u c s c u w p

    p e u c 2

    u k c 7 j w a e u a

    c o j u | | c y j u j p o a c w a p u e

    a r 9

    u a u e w u c a a p p e r a

    p c p a e p

    h w u c

    y a c e a c j p a c o u a c a p

    p c u r p p p p a u c s 9

    a c j p 4 { a e

    e u u c a p p a c j p a p e w p o p p

    j o e y j u j a p p e u c 2 e a c T

    | | 7 p p o p p u r

    p u u c r p u c s w u c p p a c j p y a a p c

    w p e r a c a r e w u ` w u a u c p a o y

    w u c U ) R

    u a c j p e r ) " X

    c o a p u p s c u x e a a

    c a o y p p u p a e a a c a c j p p p y

    s c

    p p u p y e o u c u c y p u c

    u R U

    s u a p a c p o a u c p u s u

    c p 2 y y 7 w c p c 2 7

    p w u c s a 2Q 7 u c c 2 7

    p p u p u a a 2 7 $

    u c j u a o a p o a

    p a p l p e

    c $

    o a p p e u a u x e y r w p r o a a

    u a p a c a p s w o c j u a c e p

    c w a u c y a p a u c p

    p c 2 a u e c u a c p a o c a u c 7 a c e u p

    a p s w o c a c e p w r ` y r ` w r

    ` a c e r ` a p p s c u x e a p e u a a u c s

    a p s w o c a c e p u a o a p s w

    o c a p a p e r o e u p w r ` a c e

    r ` l c p s c w s j a u p c

    c o c p c u o p s u a a p u a

    u c 2 s p p u p u a p p p u p 7 a e s c w

    u c e u a a u a u x a u c p r a p e u a

    c u

    a y c p u p u e r a u c y p p

    s u a p o s p c p p u p y e

    o u c u c y p u c a c r u a u x e

    2 y y 7

    c 2 7

    p w u c s a 2 7 p p u p c 2 7 $

    u u a u x e s u a p a c p o a u c a w

    w c u a u c r j c c p 2 y y 7

    u c c 2 7 p p u p u a a 2 7 $ a c e

    2 y y 7 p p u p c 2 7 $ e e u u c a y

    r w u c s s u p o s p r R W

    y j u u R y p e u

    a 2 y y 7 o a r p a e j u r

    c s 2 y y 7 y j u p a r e w u c a

    p w u c y u a c j p u

    p r 2 y y 7 a c e r c s 2 y y 7

    p a p o o p c o j u u c u a

  • 8/2/2019 Answer Mining by Combining Extraction Tech With Abductive

    6/8

    ' ' D D @$ & R @ ' (

    B 6

    r

    D

    F

    S

    U D Y

    S

    U

    r r

    D

    B

    T

    U

    Y

    S

    r r

    D

    U

    T

    Y

    S

    &

    w

    T

    D D

    U 4

    T

    S r

    D

    D B

    B D F B

    S

    !

    B

    r r

    D

    D B

    w

    S

    w

    W

    !

    a r {

    a o e c u u c a p c y w a s a c e p w c w p p c

    c e e u c l p e

    u p o o p c o p

    p c e o a c u p p u p u r u c s a p

    w c p u s p r u c e u a a u

    o p c o u p a p u j e a a p o u c y

    j u e w p r p o s W

    j p p c o p e u p c p a u c

    s p c u c s p p w u c s p p u p u r u p w c p u

    u r c e a p c a c e u c e e u c l p e

    y

    u s W j w e

    a e a o ` w u a u c a c e p o u c e

    r c u p p u e p o

    p

    w y p a u c s a c p a e u u c r j c c W

    a c e R w p p c y

    a r e w u p u o o c e u c

    p o p p 2 e a c T | | 7 e c a c e w

    c p a e u u c

    p a u c p u c p p u p u

    r c s u c s w c p u j w e a r c c e e a

    o p c o y c p c a c e w e a r c c e e

    a a p c o a p u c l p e

    2 w p p c y u u c

    e e a a a p a c u a c 7 7 a p

    j o p c o j p p c p s s p a u a o o

    r p u p a p a c w c p c a u c u c

    p w u c y a r c a r e w u

    ` w u a u c j w e a p e w e a a c

    j p y r a w c u

    ) R U U

    F G e

    He

    s P d

    s

    g d

    Q d s

    s

    w p o p a e

    9

    } { a c j p u c p c

    { | e c u u c w u c a w a e u c

    | |

    l w r o u e j p w c y c j u c u e a

    a c j p a c e p p p c e u c s c c

    a c j p w 9

    } { a c j p y a p a

    w c e a a 4 } 2 a 7 a c e } 4 2 c c 7 u a

    o a p o a a | e a c e a

    a | 2 a 7 a c e

    9 9

    2 c c 7 o a w

    9 a e u c u p c a e c u u c w u c

    a w a e u c

    | | a c r a u e u c

    w u c a u c s a r w 7

    w u c a u c s a r w p c a o 7 a c e

    w u c a u c s a r w s c p a c

    w u c a u c s a r w a p e j u

    w u c o a c e c a u c e c a o a p

    c p j p | w w u c y j u a e

    p c c a o u c p o a ' W y

    s y p R )

    c w u c a e c a o u c p o a '

    W " W $ y u W

    p w u c a e c a o a a u c s j p e y

    u s c u u c s a a p p j c j c U y

    R a c e R

    c a p a y c

    j a a u e R ' )

    j p p c c a o j p c a o e u c s p

    p u c 1 a c e R ) y a u c s

    p o a ' W R U

    p j p

    9

    w u c a u c s a r w p

    c a o w p a e a r w e u p c p s a c u x a u c y s

    U 3 R y ) y 6 p &

    j a e a r w u u y s U r w a

    c u c a o u u y s X j a e a r w

    o e u a p r u s p o y s ) p p a e

    a r w j p e u c p u s c a c s w a s s u c p a r u y

    C U u c p o a c y a c e 9 C U u c ` a c p u

    ` u e c u u c w u c a e a r w s c p a c y

    s y U p U

    p e w a c j p p e c u u c w u c y w p

    o w } a p c w y a p c a e a

    a a o a p e

    w u c a r {

    u w p a o w a p a p c u s w p 9

    u w

  • 8/2/2019 Answer Mining by Combining Extraction Tech With Abductive

    7/8

    r p p p u s a c u u c s c u w u e w p u p a r w u u c c e u c s p p

    c c a

    u p a u c x a p c u a c c u u ` w c e a

    C s u a o u c s p o c e p p o a c a c c a

    u p a a c e u a p r u c s p a c

    c u c s a p u a u p a e u w a o a u c s p a a

    c c a

    u p a e w p o e o a c a a o w p o c a w p a p c a u u c s p 2 1 U ) 7

    a p o c a w p p

    c u p y p c a c r a p p w u w p a c e a p c s a a u c w e e j p w r a

    c

    da a y w p p u u c s y a a a s u

    p 7 w u u p a c

    c o u c s a a c c a c c a

    p u 7 a c e w o u c w u e p a c 3 3 a c c a

    u p a

    c j o p y

    p j s u a c p a c C 9 R y a c s c c a

    u p a j u a a c u c c u

    u r p a e p p x a p p 2 a c e p p e e p u p e u u s u u c u a c w y w c u c

    a p p u a s u s a p y a c e c c a

    u p a u c c u a c c u 7 a p u p u a c r p a e a p s a c

    p p a a w c 7 a c e p p ` p a w 2 a a c p p a r a y a p a u c y w c

    a e u c y a c e C o o a ` p p a w j p e 7

    a r 4 c j p p w u c | |

    p a c w o r p a c j p p a e p w s a p c

    o a u c s p a { | e c u u c w u c

    q

    s P d H

    s Q

    d s

    s

    a c j p u w u c a w a e u c

    | | y w p o c u e p e a p e r a e w

    a c j p p a e s c p a u e a j a a

    r w u c s c u o u a p u u r j c a c e u e a a c

    j p j w e e u e c p e a w p w r o u

    u c s o c u u c a p a w u c

    j p a u a c j p y j p o w u o u a p

    u r j c p a c j p a c e a a c j p y

    c s c p a y o w u o u a p u r j c a a u p

    a c j p 2 ! # & 7 j c u e p a j u c e j p c w c

    p p r c a c e p u s

    a a c j p (!

    2 )

    !

    1 2

    # )

    !

    1 5

    # )

    !

    1

    # )

    !

    6

    # )

    !

    6

    5

    # )

    !

    6

    2

    7 a c e

    ( & 2 )

    &

    1 2

    # )

    &

    1 5

    # )

    &

    1

    # )

    &

    6

    # )

    &

    6

    5

    # )

    &

    6

    2

    7 c j

    a p a c u c c w c a c e p r r a u c u c s !

    y

    & y 9 ! y a c e 9 & u o u a p u u o a w p e r p

    o w a A C E 2 ! # & 7

    5

    2 A C E

    2 ! # & 7 R A C E U 2 9 ! # 9 & 7 7 y

    j p A C E

    2 !

    # &

    7

    ` a c e f c g i p

    A C E q 2 s!

    # s&

    7 y j u

    t u

    e v

    g x

    p p c u c s a u r a u p 2 s ! # s & 7 u c

    j u s ! ! a c e s & & 7 a c e A C E U 2 9 ! # 9 & 7

    ` a e f g ip

    A C E q 2 ! # & 7 y j u

    t u

    U

    e v

    U

    g x

    p p c u c s a

    u r a u p 2y ! # & 7 u c j u r ! 9 ! a c e & 9 &

    c r a e u o u a p u u o w e a

    A C E 2 s ! # s & 7 E A C E 2 ! # & 7 y j p 2 ! # & 7 a p

    a u r o r u c a u c l p e

    c s!

    a c e s&

    y a c e

    A C E 2 ! # & 7

    jk

    l

    km

    # C ! &

    | # C ! s & s z { s

    | z A E z | C z | ~

    A C E

    q

    2 ! # & 7 # | z C A z

    j p A C E

    q

    2 ! # & 7 u

    a e p j u o u a p

    u 2

    a e p j } 7 e c e a

    A C E

    q

    2 ! # & 7

    s

    { z s 2 ! # & 7

    j p { z s 2 !

    # &

    7 u p a r j c !

    a c e &

    a c e u p a e l p e

    a c o

    p e a w ) u o w e w

    u c s u o u a p u r j c p a c e a c

    a c j p o w u u e j u a c a c ) w

    u e p o u c e a a p s a w a a u

    p

    !

    ! l c w u e p o u c e y u

    p p c c s u a c j p a u w r

    o u e

    r p u u c a c e p a j a r a u c e p

    | |

    3 & )

    a r 4 u a c j p p a e p u w u c

    p j p { p p a c j p w 4 w r o u e y p

    p c e u c s a p u u c | } a c e a p a | 4 { 7

    o r u c e p j a |

    9

    d g w e d d e e

    a r w o o a p u x p p u e e r

    ` p

    w p o l a w r o u e j e u p c p w c

    e u p c u c j a e c u u c a c j p j p

    p a e

    c p w r o u u c y c a a c j p

    j p p a e j p a u c c e j c

    c c a u c u c s a c j p j a w r o u e

    a r u w p a c p u r w u c a u e y u

    a c e e c u u c o c c p a p

    o a u c a

    a u e u e c u u c a

    a u c a | | 5 5 4 5 { } 5

    w r o u u c

    a u c a | | 5 4 5

    9 9

    5 { { 5

    w r o u u c

    d

    a a s 4 } { 5

    a

    a r

    w u c

    | | a w a u c

    p c e w r o u u c j a u s

  • 8/2/2019 Answer Mining by Combining Extraction Tech With Abductive

    8/8

    u s p a c a p w r o u u c r a w

    r p p r a u c e p e c u u c w u c y j u

    u c u a j p u c p o a a c c u p c c

    u a j e o p u a c w s s r u e c u e r

    a p y w r a u c u c s a r p p c p u o

    p a c r p a u c o p o a a a u e

    w u c u c o a u c a j p u s r p a w

    a e a c u c a a s a l a u c u a r

    w p r u a a a s o u s a c a u c e o w u

    c u o u a p a c j p y a c e w p e w e

    a o p a s w a w a u c c

    q P d H w d s

    l j w e u a c p u a u ` w p e a c w a c e a p

    u w

    d

    a a p u p a w a r c p u r w u c u j p y

    a j a w p r p a e p p a p c y u w p e

    r e a c e

    a p a c e o c u u

    2

    7 e a c e w u c c j p u c s p

    c u

    s c 2

    7

    d

    p s p a o

    d g d d d s

    a y y a c e e p j y }

    R C W

    d

    p a p o r u c u c s a c

    a c e l p e

    u o u a p u p j p e c u e c u a u c y

    4 { }

    e a c y 7 a p y 7 h a p a r a s u w y ` 7 a c e a u

    p a c y ` | | s s u p p p w u c a c

    j p u c s

    c U U ) W

    W

    U U

    )

    W

    $ y }

    u y

    y a c e k c y

    a p c u c s e u u c a p u

    p u c p o a u c p a u c r o w u r p a

    u c s

    c C W

    ' W y9

    9

    9