7/21/2019 Answer with Counterclaim

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/answer-with-counterclaim-56de3593a487d 1/4

Republic of the PhilippinesNATIONAL CAPITAL JUDICIAL REGION

REGIONAL TRIAL COURTBranch !

"UE#ON CIT$ Juan dela CruzPlaintif 

%s&

PLB Corporation, operating under theName and t!le o" Pedro’s Lipat Bahay” CI'IL CA(E NO& ))))))))))))) Respondent  *OR+ COLLECTION O# U$

$ONE% 

 

,--------------------------------------------------,

AN&ER &IT' COUNTERCLAI$

Defen.ant/ throu0h the un.ersi0ne. counsel/ unto this 1onorable

Court 2ost respectfull3 4les his Ans5er in response to the Co2plaint of the

Plainti6 an. interposes as 5ell/ his counterclai2 a0ainst the latter/ to 5it+

A($IION AN( (ENIAL

& Para0raphs an. ! of the co2plaint are a.2itte.7

!& Para0raph 8 of the co2plaint is a.2itte. insofar as Pe.ro9s Realt3 is o5ne. b3

:r& Pe.ro (antos ;hereinafter as <Defen.ant=> an. the container 3ar. is bein0

lease. b3 :r& Juan .ela Cru? ;hereinafter as <Plainti6=>7

@& Para0raph of the co2plaint is a.2itte.7

8& Para0raph an. of the co2plaint are a.2itte. insofar as Defen.ant a0ree. to

purchase 4%e ;> %ehicles fro2 the Plainti6 in the a2ount of One :illion Pesos

;PhP//> for each %ehicle in the total a00re0ate a2ount of *i%e :illion

Pesos ;PhP//>7

& The Contract of (ale bet5een the Defen.ant an. the Plainti6 / attache. in the

co2plaint as ANNE <A= is a.2itte.7

& The Letter of De2an. that 5as sent b3 the Plainti69s counsel to the Defen.ant/

attache. in the co2plaint as ANNE <B= is a.2itte.7 an.

7/21/2019 Answer with Counterclaim

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/answer-with-counterclaim-56de3593a487d 2/4

& Para0raph of the co2plaint is .enie. an. the truth is state. as one of the

aFr2ati%e .efense pro%i.e. hereun.er&

A##IR$ATI)E (E#ENE

 The Co2plaint 4le. b3 the Plainti6 is nothin0 but a 2alicious la5suit

calculate. to harass the Defen.ant/ thereb3 ren.erin0 it .is2issible outri0ht7

& Hhile it is true that a Letter of De2an. ;attache. in the Co2plaint as ANNE

<B=>/ 5as sent to the Defen.ant b3 the Plainti69s counsel/ the truth of the 2atter

is there 5as alrea.3 <PARTIAL PA$:ENT= 2a.e b3 the Defen.ant on Dece2ber

/ ! in the a2ount of *our :illion Pesos ;PhP8//>7

& In support of our alle0ation/ Ban of the Philippine Islan.s ;BPI> Chec

No&))))))))))))))))))))))))))/ .ate. Dece2ber / ! in the a2ount of *our

:illion Pesos ;PhP8//> issue. b3 the Defen.ant in fa%our of the Plainti6/ for

the partial pa32ent of the obli0ation is herein Attache. as ANNE <=7

&:oreo%er/ an Acno5le.0e2ent Receipt .ate. Dece2ber / ! an. issue. b3

the Plainti6 to the Defen.ant acno5le.0in0 the receipt of partial pa32ent isherein attache. as ANNE <!=7

&Hhile it is true that a Contract of (ale ;attache. in the Co2plaint as ANNE <A= >/

5as e,ecute. bet5een the Defen.ant an. the Plainti6/ both parties e,ecute. a

(upple2ental to the Contract of (ale statin0/ a2on0 others/ the follo5in0+

 xxx...the Plaintif guarantees that each o the vehicle covered

under the Contract o Sale is free from any DEFECTSwhatsoever ...xxx 

 xxx... in the event the Seller breach the said warranties stated in

the Contract o Sale, the Seller shall pay an aggregate amount of 

ne !undred Thousand Pesos "PhP#$$%$$$&...xxx

!& The (upple2ental to the Contract of (ale is herein attache. as

ANNE <@=7

@& That on Januar3 / !/ 5hile en route to a Harehouse in

:an.aue Cit3/ one of the trucs .ri%en b3 :r& :ice3 Chatto/ 5as

in%ol%e. in an acci.ent .ue to a 2alfunction 5ith the %ehicle9s brae

7/21/2019 Answer with Counterclaim

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/answer-with-counterclaim-56de3593a487d 3/4

s3ste2 an. other electrical parts an. asse2bl3& A cop3 of the Police

Report is herein attache. as ANNE <8=7

8& Upon in%esti0ation/ it 5as re%eale. that t5o ;!> of the 4%e ;>

trucs that 5as sol. b3 the Plainti6 to the .efen.ant ha. a .efect onits electrical asse2bl3/ 5irin0s an. brae s3ste27

& That because of the fault3 electrical 5irin0s of the sai. %ehicles/

one of the Defen.ant9s .ri%ers 5as inKure. .urin0 the acci.ent7 an.

B% &A% O# COUNTERCLAI$

& Pursuant to the pro%isions in the (upple2ental to the Contract

of (ale/ Plainti6 is liable for Da2a0es in the a2ount of One 1un.re.

 Thousan. Pesos ;PhP/>/ for breach of 5arranties on the %ehicles

subKect of the Contract of (ale&

& Due to the 2alicious 4lin0 of this instant suit/ Defen.ant ha%e

hire. the ser%ices of the un.ersi0ne. counsel for an a0ree. a2ount

*i%e 1un.re. Thousan. Pesos ;PhP/&> an. ha%e su6ere.

sleepless ni0hts/ 5oun.e. feelin0s/ bes2irche. reputation an. 2oral

shoc 5hich 5hen uanti4e. in 2onetar3 ter2s is in the a2ount of 

*i%e 1un.re. Thousan. Pesos ;PhP/&>

PRA%ER

&'ERE#ORE/ in %ie5 of the fore0oin0/ Defen.ant 2ost respectfull3

pra3 for the .is2issal of the Co2plaint an. the a5ar. of counterclai2 in the

a00re0ate a2ount of One :illion One 1un.re. Thousan. Pesos

;PhP//>&

Other Kust an. euitable reliefs are lie5ise pra3e. for&

*ebruar3 !/ !& Cebu Cit3/ Philippines&

B3+

7/21/2019 Answer with Counterclaim

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/answer-with-counterclaim-56de3593a487d 4/4

ATT%* JULIE ANN $AE O* PAJO

Counsel for the Defen.ant

Roll of Attorne3 No& 8

IBP :e2ber No& 8M!!M! Cebu Cit3

PTR No& 8!8 M8M! Cebu Cit3

:CLE Co2pliance No&+ E,e2pt