13
UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL, GEELONG FELLOWSHIP WRITTEN EXAMINATION WEEK 1– TRIAL SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS Suggested answers PLEASE LET TOM KNOW OF ANY ERRORS/ OTHER OPTIONS FOR ANSWERS Please do not simply change this document - it is not the master copy ! Question 1 (18 marks) 9 minutes A 40 year old male presents to the ED with fever and confusion for 24 hours. He has just returned from one month back- packing through Papua New Guinea and Indonesia. His observations are: PR 120 bpm BP 130/80 mmHg RR 16 bpm Temp 39.5°C GCS 13 (V3) a. List four (4) likely differential diagnoses for this presentation. For each diagnosis list the expected incubation period prior to clinical features. (8 marks) NB: GCS ↓ Don’t pick a DDx for which you have no idea of incubation period! Differential diagnosis (5 marks) Expected incubation period (5 marks) Malaria- Cerebral/ Falciparum MANDATORY Falciparum: 6–30 days (98% onset within 3 months of travel) Vivax:8 days to 12 months (almost ½ have onset > 30 days after completion of travel) Typhoid fever- MANDATORY 8-14 days (3 days- 1 month) Japanese encephalitis (endemic area) 3–14 days (1–20 days) Enteric fever 7-8 days (3-60 days Scrub Typhus 6-20 days Leptospirosis (wild rodents/ water) 7-12 days Dengue (not usually ACS) 4-8 days (3-14) Meningitis- bacterial Hours- days Pneumonia Hours- days Viral encephalitis 3–14 days (1–20 days) b. List four (4) key investigations that you may perform to assist with the diagnosis. (4 marks) NB “to assist with the diagnosis” Blood films- T&T Blood cultures Serology- Dengue Serology-- viral CTB c. List two (2) specific medications that you would consider as empiric treatment prior to obtaining confirmatory tests for this patient. For each, list your dose and route. (6 marks) Medication (2 marks) Dose (2 marks) Route (2 marks) 1 Ceftriaxone 2g IV 2 Artesunate (1 st line severe malaria) OR (if parenteral artesunate is not immediately available) quinine dihydrochloride 2.4 mg/kg 20 mg/kg IV You should know the features/ Dx/ Mx of : Malaria, Dengue, Typhoid, Yellow fever, Travellers’ Diarrhoea & Schistosomiasis “List” = 1-3 words “State”= short statement/ phrase/ clause

“List” = 1-3 words UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL, GEELONG … · WEEK 1– TRIAL SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS Suggested answers PLEASE LET TOM KNOW OF ANY ERRORS/ OTHER OPTIONS FOR ANSWERS Please

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: “List” = 1-3 words UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL, GEELONG … · WEEK 1– TRIAL SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS Suggested answers PLEASE LET TOM KNOW OF ANY ERRORS/ OTHER OPTIONS FOR ANSWERS Please

UNIVERSITYHOSPITAL,GEELONGFELLOWSHIPWRITTENEXAMINATION

WEEK1–TRIALSHORTANSWERQUESTIONSSuggestedanswersPLEASELETTOMKNOWOFANYERRORS/OTHEROPTIONSFORANSWERSPleasedonotsimplychangethisdocument-itisnotthemastercopy!

Question1(18marks)9minutes A40yearoldmalepresentstotheEDwithfeverandconfusionfor24hours.Hehasjustreturnedfromonemonthback-packingthroughPapuaNewGuineaandIndonesia.Hisobservationsare:PR120bpmBP130/80mmHgRR16bpmTemp39.5°CGCS13(V3)

a. Listfour(4)likelydifferentialdiagnosesforthispresentation.Foreachdiagnosislisttheexpectedincubationperiodpriortoclinicalfeatures.(8marks)

NB: GCS↓ Don’tpickaDDxforwhichyouhavenoideaofincubationperiod!

Differentialdiagnosis(5marks)

Expectedincubationperiod(5marks)

Malaria-Cerebral/FalciparumMANDATORY

Falciparum:6–30days(98%onsetwithin3monthsoftravel)Vivax:8daysto12months(almost½haveonset>30daysaftercompletionoftravel)

Typhoidfever-MANDATORY 8-14days(3days-1month)Japaneseencephalitis(endemicarea) 3–14days(1–20days)Entericfever 7-8days(3-60daysScrubTyphus 6-20daysLeptospirosis(wildrodents/water) 7-12daysDengue(notusuallyACS) 4-8days(3-14)Meningitis-bacterial Hours-daysPneumonia Hours-daysViralencephalitis 3–14days(1–20days)

b. Listfour(4)keyinvestigationsthatyoumayperformtoassistwiththediagnosis.(4marks)NB “toassistwiththediagnosis”

• Bloodfilms-T&T• Bloodcultures• Serology-Dengue• Serology--viral• CTB

c. Listtwo(2)specificmedicationsthatyouwouldconsiderasempirictreatmentpriortoobtaining

confirmatorytestsforthispatient.Foreach,listyourdoseandroute.(6marks)

Medication(2marks)

Dose(2marks)

Route(2marks)

1 Ceftriaxone 2g IV

2 Artesunate(1stlineseveremalaria) OR(ifparenteralartesunateisnotimmediatelyavailable)quininedihydrochloride

2.4mg/kg20mg/kg

IV

Youshouldknowthefeatures/Dx/Mxof:Malaria,Dengue,Typhoid,Yellowfever,Travellers’Diarrhoea&Schistosomiasis

“List”=1-3words“State”=shortstatement/phrase/clause

Page 2: “List” = 1-3 words UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL, GEELONG … · WEEK 1– TRIAL SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS Suggested answers PLEASE LET TOM KNOW OF ANY ERRORS/ OTHER OPTIONS FOR ANSWERS Please

ClickontheimagebelowtoviewtheentirePDF(&print/saveifnecessary)

Ihaven’tfoundabetterarticlethanthisonthistopic-stillrelevantdespiteitsage

Page 3: “List” = 1-3 words UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL, GEELONG … · WEEK 1– TRIAL SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS Suggested answers PLEASE LET TOM KNOW OF ANY ERRORS/ OTHER OPTIONS FOR ANSWERS Please

Question2(8marks)6minutes

A59yearoldobeseman receives5mgof intravenousmorphine foranalgesia forabdominalpain.Thirtyminuteslater,hisGCShasfallento12andinvestigationsareperformed. ReferenceRange FiO2 0.21 pH 7.24 7.35-7.45 pCO2 92mmHg 35-45 pO2 45mmHg 80-95 Bicarbonate 49mmol/L 22-28 Baseexcess 10 -3-+3 O2saturation 78% >95 Lactate 1.2mmol/L <1.3 Na+ 142mmol/L 134-146 K+ 3.8mmol/L 3.4-5 Cl- 86mmol/L 98-106 Glucose 11.4mmol/L 3.5-5.5 Haemoglobin 184g/L 135–180 CarboxyHb 7% <6%

a. Providetwo(2)calculationstohelpyoutointerprettheseresults. Derivedvalue1: A-agradient=150-(1.25x92)-45=-10thereforenonA-agradient Derivedvalue2: ExpectedHCO3=

ACUTE:foreveryincreasedin10ofCO2above40,HCO3↑by1from24=24+5=29 CHRONIC:forevery↑in10ofCO2above40,HCO3↑by4from24=24+(5x4)=44 Thereforefullcompensationwithsuperimposedmetabolicalkalosis

Simplerespiratoryalkalosis:Acute↓ HCO3-2in10minevery10mmHg↓ PCO2.Minimumof18∴<18highlysuggestiveofmetabolicacidosis(pCo2valuescannotbenegative)Chronic ↓ HCO3-5ifsustainedfor2-3days

b. Usingthescenarioandthederivedvalues,definetheprimaryabnormality/s.(2marks) • Respiratoryacidosis:

o Acuteonchronic• Superimposedmetabolicalkalosisnotaccountedforbycompensationforrespiratoryacidosis

o secondarytovomitinginsettingabdominalpain

c. Usingthescenarioandthederivedvalues,definethesecondaryabnormality/s.(2marks)• MetabolicalkalosisascompensationforchronicRespacidosis

d. Provideaunifyingexplanationfortheseresults.(2marks)• Chronicrespacidosissecondarytopossiblehypoventilationfromobesity,+/-obstructive

sleepapnoea• Respiratorydepressionandhypercapniaexacerbatedbyopioids->lifethreateninghypoxia• Acutedeteriorationsecondarytodepressioncentralrespiratorydrivefromadministration

opioidswithnoevidenceofunderlyingV/Qmismatch• Metabolicalkalosisinsettingofabdominalpainandpossiblevomiting/GIlosses

Page 4: “List” = 1-3 words UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL, GEELONG … · WEEK 1– TRIAL SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS Suggested answers PLEASE LET TOM KNOW OF ANY ERRORS/ OTHER OPTIONS FOR ANSWERS Please

Question3(12marks)6minutes

A42yearoldfemalepresentsviaprivatecartotheEDwithsevererightflankpain.

Herobservationsare:BP70 PR150 RR16 Temp37°C GCS15

a. Listfour(4)likelydifferentialdiagnosesforthisscenario.(4marks)

NB: Dxneedstoexplainobswhichshowshock.Ie“ectopicpregnancy”isnotcorrect Rupturedovariancystmaycausethispicturebutmostcysticbleedingisusuallycontained

• Intra-abdo/retroperitonealbleed• Rupturedectopicpregnancywithhaemorrhageshock• Pyelonephritiswithsepsis-egG-ve• Renalcolicwithobstruction&sepsis• Rupturedappendicitiswithperitonitisandsepsis

b. Listfour(4)investigationsthatyouwouldperformtoassistwiththediagnosis.Stateone(1)justificationforeachchoice.(8marks)

NB: “toassistwiththediagnosis” “straighttotheatre”isnotaninvestigation

Investigation Justification

FASTscan

Rapidlydiagnoseintraperitonealbleed/fluidascauseforshock

CTabdo/pelvis

Diagnoseretroperitonealbleedorfreefluid,hydronephrosis/perinephricstranding,aorta,biliarydisease,intraperitonealgasetc

CTKUB Dxobstructedkidney/renalcalculi

OnlyifContrastCIaswouldexpectacontrastscan

βhCG

SupportsDxpregnancy/ectopic

FWT ScreenforUTI

Page 5: “List” = 1-3 words UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL, GEELONG … · WEEK 1– TRIAL SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS Suggested answers PLEASE LET TOM KNOW OF ANY ERRORS/ OTHER OPTIONS FOR ANSWERS Please

Question4(14marks)6minutes

A72yearoldmalepresentstoEDwithextremeshortnessofbreath.HehasahistoryofCOPDandisotherwisewell.Heis70kg.Hehasnotbeengivenanymedications.Hisobservationsare: BP130PR120RR36Temp38.2°CGCS15

a. List three (3)medications thatyouwouldconsiderusing forhis initial treatment. Listdoseandrouteofadministration.(9marks)

Drug(3marks)

Delivery(3marks)

Dose(3marks)

Ventolin Neb(useairifsats>88%)

5-10mg

(carefulwithoverdosing)

Steroid:

Prednisolone

Dexamethasone

Hydrocortisone

Ō

IV

IV

50mg

10mg

250mg

Antibiotic:

Penicillin

Ceftriaxone

IV

IV

2.4g

1g

Hedoesnotrespondtoyourtreatmentandrequiresintubation.

b. Stateyourinitialventilatorsettings.(3marks)

Ventilatorsettings

Rate Low8-10

Tidalvolumes 6-8ml/kg

I:Erate Loweg1:4(prolongedexpiatoryphase)

c. Statetwo(2)reasonsforyourchoiceoftheseventilationsettings.(2marks)

• Controlled/Permissivehypercapnia-allowlongexpirationandpreventdynamichyperinflationwithpermissivehypercapnia

• ReduceIPs• Lungprotectiveventilation/sedation• Preventdynamichyperinflation/barotraumabyallowingforlongexhalationandlowI:E• Minimiseriskofvolutrauma

Page 6: “List” = 1-3 words UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL, GEELONG … · WEEK 1– TRIAL SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS Suggested answers PLEASE LET TOM KNOW OF ANY ERRORS/ OTHER OPTIONS FOR ANSWERS Please

Question5(12marks)6minutes

A6yearoldboypresentswith1dayofthisrash.

a. Listfive(5)diagnosticfeaturesofthisrash.(5marks)

• Targetlesions• Welldemarcated/discreteinitially• Coalescewithmoreadvanceddisease• Centralareausuallyslightlyoffcentre• Centreareamaybepale/erythematous/darkrad/purple• Widespread,nosparedareas(mildtendstobeperipheral)• Varyingsizes

b. List5likelycausesforthisrash.(5marks)

Herpessimplexvirus Mycoplasma Drugssulphas,penicillinsNSAID’sphenothiazinesanticonvulsants

VirusesVaricellaCMVAdenoHepatitisViralimmunisation

CollagenVascularDiseaseProtozoanInfectionFungalInfectionSkinAllergies

c. Listtwo(2)featuresofthisdiseasethatdifferentiatesmildtoseveredisease.(2marks)

• Epithelialloss→absent→EMultiformaepresent→SJSvsTEN• %BSAinvolved<10%→SJS>30%→TEN

Page 7: “List” = 1-3 words UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL, GEELONG … · WEEK 1– TRIAL SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS Suggested answers PLEASE LET TOM KNOW OF ANY ERRORS/ OTHER OPTIONS FOR ANSWERS Please

Question6(14marks)6minutesA52yearoldmalepresentstoEDwithchestpain.HisECGisshown.

a. Statefour(4)abnormalitiesshownonthisECG.(4marks)• Wenckebachtype,Mobitztype12nddegreeHB• STEII,III,aVF(1mm,2mm,2mmrespectively)• STDV2-V6,I,aVL• BiphasicTwavesI,aVL,V2,V3

b. Statefour(4)significantimplicationsofthesefindings.(4marks)

• InfSTEMI-meetscriteriaforurgentreperfusionRx• Likelyposteriorinvolvement

o largeinfarcto carewithMorph/GTN&fluidloadif↓BP

• Anticipatefurtherbradycardia/block/-vechronotropicinstability

c. List two (2) specific complications that youmay anticipate for this patient within the first 30minutesofyourcare.Stateone(1)specifictreatmentforeachcomplication(4marks)

Complication(3marks)

Specifictreatment(3marks)

Cardiogenicshockwith

hypotension

FluidsUrgentPCI(betteroutcomesincariogenicshockcfthrombolysis)

CHB/bradycardia Atropine-300-600mcgPaceAdrenaline(carewith+veChronotropes)Isoprenaline(AVnodesuppliedbyRCA90%)

Ventriculararrhythmiasesp

VT/VF-

DCR

↑Pain UrgentPCIFentanylforongoingpain

Page 8: “List” = 1-3 words UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL, GEELONG … · WEEK 1– TRIAL SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS Suggested answers PLEASE LET TOM KNOW OF ANY ERRORS/ OTHER OPTIONS FOR ANSWERS Please

Question7(13marks)6minutes

a. Completethefollowingstatementwithfive(5)statements.(5marks)

Apersongivesvalidinformedconsentifthey:

• havecapacitytogiveinformedconsenttothetreatmentormedicaltreatmentproposed• havebeengivenadequateinformationtoenablethepersontomakeaninformeddecision• havebeengivenareasonableopportunitytomakethedecision• havegivenconsentfreelywithoutunduepressureorcoercionbyanyotherperson• havenotwithdrawnconsentorindicatedanyintentiontowithdrawconsent

b. Listthree(3)circumstancesinwhichapatientcanbelegallyheldagainsthis/herwishes.(3

marks)

• Insituationsinwhichurgenttreatmentisrequiredtopreventmorbidityormortalityand:• Thepatientisa:

o Minoro RecommendedundertheMentalHealthacto MedicalPowerofAttorneyexistsandagreestodetainmento Abnormalmentalstateo Significantphysiologicalderangemento Undertheinfluenceofalcohol/drugso Behaviourinconsistentwithpersonality(fromfamily,friends,GP,oldnotes)

c. Definemedical"negligence".(1mark)

• Negligenceisafailuretotakereasonablecaretoavoidcausinginjuryorlosstoanotherperson

d. Listthefour(4)legalconditionsrequiredtoprovenegligence.(4marks)• adutyofcareexists• breachofduty-thatthebehaviororinactionofthedefendantinthecircumstancesdidnot

meetthestandardofcarewhichareasonablepersonwouldmeetinthecircumstances• damage-thattheplaintiffhassufferedinjuryorlosswhichareasonablepersoninthe

circumstancescouldhavebeenexpectedtoforesee• causation-thatthedamagewascausedbythebreachofduty

Page 9: “List” = 1-3 words UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL, GEELONG … · WEEK 1– TRIAL SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS Suggested answers PLEASE LET TOM KNOW OF ANY ERRORS/ OTHER OPTIONS FOR ANSWERS Please

NB:MentalHealthactsvaryacrossAus&NZ-theactbelowispresentedtogivesomeguidelinesandexplanations

AnexcerptfromMentalHealthAct2014(Vic)

TheinformedconsentofapersonmustbesoughtbeforetreatmentormedicaltreatmentisgiventothepersonundertheMentalHealthAct2014.AllpeoplearepresumedtohavecapacitytogiveinformedconsenttotreatmentormedicaltreatmentregardlessoftheirageorlegalstatusundertheMentalHealthAct.TheMentalHealthActsetsout:

• therequirementsforinformedconsent• thecircumstancesinwhichtreatmentcanbeprovidedtoapatientwithoutthepatient’sinformed

consentandtheprocessthatmustbeundertakenbeforeprovidingthattreatment• theprocessforprovidingmedicaltreatmenttoapatientwhodoesnothavecapacitytogiveinformed

consenttomedicaltreatment.InformedconsentTheinformedconsentofapersonmustbesoughtbeforetreatmentormedicaltreatmentisgiventoapersoninaccordancewiththeMentalHealthAct.Apersongivesinformedconsentifthey:

• havecapacitytogiveinformedconsenttothetreatmentormedicaltreatmentproposed• havebeengivenadequateinformationtoenablethepersontomakeaninformeddecision• havebeengivenareasonableopportunitytomakethedecision• havegivenconsentfreelywithoutunduepressureorcoercionbyanyotherperson• havenotwithdrawnconsentorindicatedanyintentiontowithdrawconsent.

CapacityThepersonseekinginformedconsentofanotherpersontoatreatmentormedicaltreatmentmustpresumethattheotherpersonhasthecapacitytogiveinformedconsent.Thismeansthateveryonemustbepresumedtohavecapacitytomakedecisionsabouttheirtreatmentormedicaltreatment,regardlessoftheirage(e.g.youngpeopleorolderpersons)orwhethertheyareapatientundertheMentalHealthAct.TheMentalHealthActcontainsanumberofguidingprinciplestoassistapersonwhoisrequiredtodeterminewhetherapersonhascapacitytogiveinformedconsent.Adequateinformation

Apersonhasbeengivenadequateinformationtomakeaninformeddecisionif:• theyhavebeengivenanexplanationoftheproposedtreatmentormedicaltreatment,includingthe

purpose,type,methodandlikelydurationofthetreatmentormedicaltreatment• theyhavebeengivenanexplanationoftheadvantagesanddisadvantagesofthetreatmentormedical

treatmentincludinginformationabouttheassociateddiscomforts,risksandcommonorexpectedsideeffectsofthetreatmentormedicaltreatment

• theyhavebeengivenanexplanationofanybeneficialalternativetreatmentsthatarereasonablyavailable,includinganyinformationabouttheadvantagesanddisadvantagesofthesealternatives

• theyhavereceivedanswerstoanyrelevantquestionsthatthepersonhasaskedandanyotherrelevantinformationthatislikelytoinfluencetheperson’sdecision

• theyhavebeengiventherelevantstatementofrightsandhadthatstatementexplainedtotheminamannerthatthepersonismostlikelytounderstand.

ReasonableopportunityApersonhasbeengivenareasonableopportunitytomakeadecisionif:

• thepersonhasbeengivenareasonableperiodoftimetoconsiderthemattersinvolvedinthedecision• thepersonhasbeengivenareasonableopportunitytodiscussthedecisionwiththeregisteredmedical

practitionerorotherhealthpractitionerproposingthetreatmentormedicaltreatment• thepersonhasbeengivenareasonableamountofsupporttomakethedecision• thepersonhasbeengivenareasonableopportunitytoseekanyotheradviceorassistanceinrelationtothe

decision.

Page 10: “List” = 1-3 words UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL, GEELONG … · WEEK 1– TRIAL SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS Suggested answers PLEASE LET TOM KNOW OF ANY ERRORS/ OTHER OPTIONS FOR ANSWERS Please

GivenconsentfreelywithoutunduepressureorcoercionInformedconsentmustbefreelygiven.Apersonmustnotfeeltheyhavetogiveinformedconsentsimplybecausetheclinicianbelievesitisnecessaryfortheirtreatmentorintheirbestinterestsortopleaseafamilymemberorcarer.HavenotwithdrawnconsentApersoncanwithdrawconsentatanytime.Apersoncanwithdrawconsentverballyorinwriting.Apersoncanwithdrawconsentbeforethetreatmentstartsorduringacourseoftreatment.Ifthepersonwithdrawsconsent,thetreatmentmuststop.Apersonwithdrawsconsentiftheysayorindicatebytheirbehaviourthattheydonotconsenttothetreatment.ProvidingtreatmentwhenapatientdoesnotgiveinformedconsentTheMentalHealthActrequiresthatpatientsaregiventreatmentfortheirmentalillness.Onlythepatientcangiveorrefuseinformedconsenttotreatment.Nootherpersonorbodyauthorisedbylawtomakedecisionsforthepatientcangiveorrefuseinformedconsenttotreatment.ThismeansthataguardianorapersonresponsibleundertheGuardianshipandAdministrationAct1986oranagentundertheMentalTreatmentAct1988cannotgiveorrefuseinformedconsentonbehalfofapatient.However,theMentalHealthActpermitsanauthorisedpsychiatristtomakeatreatmentdecisionforapatientwho:

• doesnothavecapacitytogiveinformedconsenttothetreatmentproposedbytheauthorisedpsychiatristor

• hascapacitytogiveinformedconsenttothetreatmentproposedbytheauthorisedpsychiatristbuthasnotgiveninformedconsenttothattreatment.

Theauthorisedpsychiatristcanmakeatreatmentdecisionforthepatientiftheauthorisedpsychiatristissatisfiedthatthereisnolessrestrictivewayforthepatienttobetreatedotherthanthetreatmentproposedbytheauthorisedpsychiatrist.TheMentalHealthActdoesnotpermitanauthorisedpsychiatristtomakeatreatmentdecisionaboutelectroconvulsivetreatmentorneurosurgeryformentalillnessforapatient.Seeelectroconvulsivetreatmentandneurosurgeryformentalillnessformoreinformation.DeterminingtheleastrestrictivetreatmentIndeterminingwhetherthereisnolessrestrictivewayforthepatienttobetreated,theauthorisedpsychiatristmusthaveregard,totheextendthisisreasonableinthecircumstances,toallofthefollowing:

• thepatient’sviewsandpreferencesabouttreatmentofhisorhermentalillnessandanybeneficialalternativetreatmentsthatarereasonablyavailableandthereasonsforthoseviewsandpreferences,includinganyrecoveryoutcomesthatthepatientwouldliketoachieve

• theviewsandpreferencesofthepatientexpressedinhisorheradvancestatement• theviewsofthepatient’snominatedperson• theviewsoftheguardianofthepatient• theviewsofacarer,iftheauthorisedpsychiatristissatisfiedthatthetreatmentdecisionwilldirectly

affectthecarerandthecarerelationship• theviewsofaparentofthepatient,ifthepatientisundertheageof16years• theviewsoftheSecretarytotheDepartmentofHumanServicesifthepersonisthesubjectofa

custodytoSecretaryorderoraGuardianshiptoSecretaryorder• thelikelyconsequencesforthepatientiftheproposedtreatmentisnotperformed• anysecondpsychiatricopinionthathasbeengiventotheauthorisedpsychiatrist.

ProvidingmedicaltreatmenttoapatientwhodoesnothavecapacityMedicaltreatmentcanbeadministeredtoapatientifthepatientgivesinformedconsenttothemedicaltreatment.Apatientwithcapacitycanrefusemedicaltreatment.Therequirementsforinformedconsenttomedicaltreatmentarethesameastherequirementsfortreatment.SubstituteconsenttomedicaltreatmentTheMentalHealthActsetsoutrequirementsforwhocanprovidesubstituteconsentforpatients18yearsoraboveandpatientsunder18yearsofage.AdultpatientsMedicaltreatmentmaybeadministeredtoapatient18yearsorolderwhodoesnothavecapacitytogiveinformedconsenttomedicaltreatment,withtheconsentofthefirstpersonofthefollowinglistedbelowwhoisreasonablyavailable,willingandabletomakeadecisionabouttheproposedmedicaltreatment:

• apersonappointedbythepatientundersection5AoftheMedicalTreatmentAct(thepatient’smedicalagentorguardian)

• apersonappointedbytheVictorianCivilandAdministrativeTribunaltomakedecisionsconcerningtheproposedmedicaltreatment

Page 11: “List” = 1-3 words UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL, GEELONG … · WEEK 1– TRIAL SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS Suggested answers PLEASE LET TOM KNOW OF ANY ERRORS/ OTHER OPTIONS FOR ANSWERS Please

• apersonappointedunderaguardianshiporderwithinthemeaningoftheGuardianshipandAdministration

Actwithpowertomakedecisionsconcerningtheproposedmedicaltreatment(thepatient’sguardian)• apersonappointedbythepatient(beforethepatientbecameincapableofgivinginformedconsent)asan

enduringguardianwithinthemeaningofGuardianshipandAdministrationActwithpowertomakedecisionsconcerningtheproposedtreatment(thepatient’senduringguardian)

Patientsunder18yearsofageMedicaltreatmentmaybeadministeredtoayoungpatientunder18yearsofagewhodoesnothavecapacitytogiveinformedconsenttomedicaltreatment,withtheconsentof:

• apersonwho,inrelationtothepatient,hasthelegalauthoritytoconsenttomedicaltreatmentandwho,inthecircumstances,isreasonablyavailable,willingandabletomakeadecisionabouttheproposedmedicaltreatmentor

• theauthorisedpsychiatrist.Amedicaltreatmentdecisionmaybemadebythefirstpersonwhois‘reasonablyavailable,willingandable’tomakeadecisionaboutthepatient’smedicaltreatment.Theauthorisedpsychiatristmayconsenttomedicaltreatmentbeingadministeredtoapatientwhodoesnothavecapacitytogiveinformedconsentiftheauthorisedpsychiatristissatisfiedthatthemedicaltreatmentwouldbenefitthepatient.MakingasubstitutedmedicaltreatmentdecisionTheMentalHealthActrequirestheauthorisedpsychiatristtohaveregardtothefollowingmatterstotheextentthatisreasonableinthecircumstanceswhendeterminingwhetheramedicaltreatmentwouldbenefitapatient:

• thepatient’sviewsandpreferencesaboutmedicaltreatmentandanybeneficialalternativemedicaltreatmentsthatarereasonablyavailableandthereasonsforthoseviewsandpreferences,includinganyrecoveryoutcomesthatthepatientwouldliketoachieve

• theviewsofthepatient’snominatedperson• theviewsoftheguardianofthepatient• theviewsofacarer,iftheauthorisedpsychiatristissatisfiedthatthetreatmentdecisionwilldirectlyaffectthe

carerandthecarerelationship• theviewsofaparentofthepatient• theviewsoftheSecretarytotheDepartmentofHumanServicesifthepersonisthesubjectofacustodyto

SecretaryorderoraGuardianshiptoSecretaryorder• ifthemedicaltreatmentislikelytoremedytheconditionoflessenthesymptomsofthecondition• thelikelyconsequencesforthepatientifthemedicaltreatmentisnotperformed• anysecondopinionofaregisteredmedicalpractitionerthathasbeengiventotheauthorisedpsychiatrist.

Iftheauthorisedpsychiatristisoftheopinionthatapatientwhodoesnotcurrentlyhavecapacitytogiveinformedconsenttomedicaltreatmentislikelytohavecapacitytogiveinformedconsentwithinareasonableperiodoftime,theauthorisedpsychiatristmustnotconsenttothemedicaltreatmentunlessthedelayinadministeringorperformingthemedicaltreatmentcouldresultinseriousharmto,ordeteriorationin,thementalorphysicalhealthoftheperson.UrgentmedicaltreatmentTheMentalHealthActpermitsa‘healthpractitioner’toperformmedicaltreatmentonapatientwhodoesnothavecapacitytogiveinformedconsenttothemedicaltreatmentwherethemedicaltreatmentneedstobeperformedasamatterofurgency.Amatterofurgencymeanswheremedicaltreatmentneedstobeperformed:

• tosavethepatient’slifeor• topreventseriousdamagetothepatient’shealthor• topreventthepatientsufferingorcontinuingtosuffersignificantpainordistress.

Thereisnorequirementthatthehealthpractitionerseektheconsentofanyotherpersonwhoislegallypermittedtogiveconsenttomedicaltreatmentonbehalfofthepatientwherethehealthpractitionerissatisfiedthatthemedicaltreatmentisrequiredasamatterofurgency.However,ifsuchapersonisreasonablyavailable,willingandabletogiveconsenttotheurgentmedicaltreatment,thatperson’sconsentshouldbesoughtasamatterofgoodclinicalpractice.Thereisnorequirementthatthe‘healthpractitioner’beregisteredundertheHealthPractitionerRegulationNationalLaw(Victoria)Act2009.Ahealthpractitionerwhoingoodfaithcarriesoutorsupervisesthecarryingoutofmedicaltreatmentinthereasonablebeliefthattherequirementsforurgentmedicaltreatmenthavebeencompliedwithisnot:

• guiltyofassaultorbattery• guiltyofprofessionalmisconductorunprofessionalconduct• liableinanycivilproceedingsforassaultorbattery.

Thisprotectionfromliabilitydoesnotaffectanydutyofcareowedbythehealthpractitionertoapatient.

Page 12: “List” = 1-3 words UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL, GEELONG … · WEEK 1– TRIAL SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS Suggested answers PLEASE LET TOM KNOW OF ANY ERRORS/ OTHER OPTIONS FOR ANSWERS Please

Question8(13marks)6minutesA62yearoldfemalepresentstoEDwithmassivehaematemesis.Shehasahistoryofalcoholdependence.Hervitalsignsonpresentationare:GCS15 BP70PR150RR16 Temp37°C

a. Listfive(5)likelydifferentialdiagnosesforthecauseofherbleeding.(3marks)NB:“Massive”“alcoholdependence”&sheisinshock• GOVarices• PUD• Oesophagitis• Alcoholicgastropathy• DU• MWtear• Coagulopathy+gastritis/anyofabove• Aorto-entericfistula• Angiodysplasia

b. Listthree(3)indicationsforurgent(<1hour)gastroscopy.(3marks)• Knownvaricesandongoingmassivehaematemesis/haemodynamicinstability• Persistenthaemodynamicinstabilitydespiteappropriateresuscitation• Ongoingmassivehaematemesis

c. Other than endoscopy, list three (3) steps in the management of her

haemodynamicstate.Listone(1)detailforeachstep.(8marks)

Management(3marks)

Detail(3marks)

Fluids IVnormalsalinebolus250mlReassesswithplanforearlybloodproductsAimforpermissivehypotensione.g.SBP80-90mmHg

Blood-activateMTP Evidencehaemorrhagicshock,startwithO- ifdelay, thenaimrationXMbloodPRBC:FFP:platelets1:1:1

Octreotide 50mcgbolustheninfusion50mcg/hr48hrsDecreases bleeding via increased intragastric pH (noevidence)

Reversecoagulopathy FFP2-4units,prothrombinX20-50IU/kg????,vitaminsK10mgIV

Pantoprazole 80mgIVtheninfusion8mg/hr↓ LOS↓ needforendoscopictherapydoes not reduce transfusion req, re-bleeding, need forsurgeryordeathat30d

NB:Maycombinefluidsandbloodinto1point

Page 13: “List” = 1-3 words UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL, GEELONG … · WEEK 1– TRIAL SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS Suggested answers PLEASE LET TOM KNOW OF ANY ERRORS/ OTHER OPTIONS FOR ANSWERS Please

Question9(13marks)9minutesA2yearoldfemalepresentstoEDafteraccidentalingestionof2x400mgrapidreleasecarbamazepine

tablets.

a. Listthree(3)mechanismsofpossibletoxicityfromthisexposure.(3marks)

• Nachannelblocker• NAreuptakeinhibitor• Anticholinergic-muscarinicandnicotinic• InhibitscentralNMDAadenosinereceptors

b. Listtwo(2)ECGfindingsthatwouldsuggestsignificanttoxicityfromthisingestion.(2marks)

• 1stdegreeHB• QRSprolongation• Sinustachycardia• DominantRwaveaVR>3mm• R/SratioinaVR>0.7

c. List two (2)methodsofdecontaminationorelimination.Stateone (1) indication foruse in this

patientforeachmethod.(4marks)

Method(2marks)

Indication(2marks)

AC Early&asymptomatic<50mg/kg:allingestionsif>50mg/kg:onlyafterintubatedasneedairwayprotection

MDAC ETT&BSpresent

Haemodialysis Prolongedcoma>48/24haemodynamicinstabilityhighserumlevelsafter48/24

d. Listfour(4)criteria,specifictothisexposure,thatneedtobemettoallowsafedischarge. (4marks)

NB: “specific to this exposure”- safe environment probably ok, “clinically well” probably not- toobroadandapplicabletoanyOD

• Observefor>8/24• Daylighthour• Nosedation• Noanticholinergiceffects• Safeenvironment

ThisresourceisproducedfortheuseofUniversityHospital,GeelongEmergencystaffforpreparationfortheEmergencyMedicineFellowshipwrittenexam.Allcarehasbeentakentoensureaccurateanduptodatecontent.Pleasecontactmewithanysuggestions,concernsorquestions.DrTomReade(StaffSpecialist,UniversityHospital,GeelongEmergencyDepartment)Email:[email protected] April2017