15
APPA RELIABILITY STANDARDS & COMPLIANCE SYMPOSIUM Case Study: City Utilities of Springfield, MO January 11, 2007

APPA RELIABILITY STANDARDS & COMPLIANCE SYMPOSIUM Case Study: City Utilities of Springfield, MO January 11, 2007

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: APPA RELIABILITY STANDARDS & COMPLIANCE SYMPOSIUM Case Study: City Utilities of Springfield, MO January 11, 2007

APPA RELIABILITY STANDARDS & COMPLIANCE SYMPOSIUM

Case Study:City Utilities of Springfield, MO

January 11, 2007

Page 2: APPA RELIABILITY STANDARDS & COMPLIANCE SYMPOSIUM Case Study: City Utilities of Springfield, MO January 11, 2007

Overview

• Introduction

• NERC Functional Responsibilities

• Documentation and Review of Transmission Operator Function

• Conclusion

Page 3: APPA RELIABILITY STANDARDS & COMPLIANCE SYMPOSIUM Case Study: City Utilities of Springfield, MO January 11, 2007

• Service Area

– Population 222,000

– Size (in square miles) 320

• Electric System

– Customers 104,853

– Hourly Peak demand 801 MWh

– MWh Annual Growth 2.1%

• Natural Gas

– Customers 81,610

– 2006 System Sales 10,434,889 Dth

• Water

– Customers 78,943

– 2005 System Sales 10,015,838,000 Gal

• Transit

– 2005 Riders 1,708,824

– Miles of Route 175

• Telecommunications (Springnet)

– High Level/Commercial Broadband Supplier

– Secure Server/Remote Site Backup Service

Page 4: APPA RELIABILITY STANDARDS & COMPLIANCE SYMPOSIUM Case Study: City Utilities of Springfield, MO January 11, 2007

Transmission System

• 345 kV Transmission - 44.2 miles– 1 Substation

– 2 Points of Interconnection

• 161 kV Transmission– 74 miles of 161 kV Transmission Circuits

– 13 Substations

– 4 Points of Interconnection

• 69 kV Transmission– 90 miles of 69 kV Transmission Circuits

– 26 Substations

Page 5: APPA RELIABILITY STANDARDS & COMPLIANCE SYMPOSIUM Case Study: City Utilities of Springfield, MO January 11, 2007

• 13.2 kV Distribution– 1,934 Miles of 13.2 kV Distribution Circuits

• 1,437 Miles Overhead

• 497 Miles Underground

– 31 Distribution Substations

Distribution System

Page 6: APPA RELIABILITY STANDARDS & COMPLIANCE SYMPOSIUM Case Study: City Utilities of Springfield, MO January 11, 2007

City Utilities’Power System

Control

Power Generation5 Generating Sites

450 MW Coal-Fired

367 MW Oil & Gas-Fired

3.2 MW Landfill Gas

14 Generators

Transmission &Distribution

40 Substations

208 Miles of Transmission Line

1,934 Miles of Distribution

104,853 CustomersSecurityCoordinator

SPP

Market Agent

TEA

BalancingAuthority

SWPA

Page 7: APPA RELIABILITY STANDARDS & COMPLIANCE SYMPOSIUM Case Study: City Utilities of Springfield, MO January 11, 2007

City Utilities’ NERC Registered Functions

• Distribution Provider

• Generation Owner

• Generation Operator

• Load-Serving Entity

• Purchasing-Selling Entity

• Resource Planner

• Transmission Owner

• Transmission Operator

• Transmission Planner

Page 8: APPA RELIABILITY STANDARDS & COMPLIANCE SYMPOSIUM Case Study: City Utilities of Springfield, MO January 11, 2007

Operations - T & D - Maintenance - Testing - Vegetation Management

Electric Supply- Dispatch- Generation- Transmission Planning

Administration

- Information Technology- Cyber Security

Finance- Risk Management- Physical Security

Board of Public

Utilities

John Twitty

General Manager

Page 9: APPA RELIABILITY STANDARDS & COMPLIANCE SYMPOSIUM Case Study: City Utilities of Springfield, MO January 11, 2007

Examples of Cross Area Responsibilities

• Standard EOP-004-0 — Disturbance Reporting– 3. Purpose: Disturbances or unusual occurrences that jeopardize the

operation of the Bulk Electric System, or result in system equipment damage or customer interruptions, need to be studied and understood to minimize the likelihood of similar events in the future.

– 4. Applicability

• 4.1. Reliability Coordinators.

• 4.2. Balancing Authorities.

• 4.3. Transmission Operators.

• 4.4. Generator Operators.

• 4.5. Load Serving Entities.

• 4.6. Regional Reliability Organizations.

Page 10: APPA RELIABILITY STANDARDS & COMPLIANCE SYMPOSIUM Case Study: City Utilities of Springfield, MO January 11, 2007

Examples of Cross Area Responsibilities

• Standard FAC-002-0 — Coordination of Plans for New Facilities

– 3. Purpose: To avoid adverse impacts on reliability, Generator Owners and Transmission Owners and electricity end-users must meet facility connection and performance requirements.

– 4. Applicability

• 4.1. Generator Owner

• 4.2. Transmission Owner

• 4.3. Distribution Provider

• 4.4. Load-Serving Entity

• 4.5. Transmission Planner

• 4.6. Planning Authority

Page 11: APPA RELIABILITY STANDARDS & COMPLIANCE SYMPOSIUM Case Study: City Utilities of Springfield, MO January 11, 2007

Examples of Cross Area Responsibilities• Standard IRO-004-0 — Reliability Coordination —

Operations Planning– 3. Purpose: Each Reliability Coordinator must conduct next-day reliability analyses for

its Reliability Coordinator Area to ensure the Bulk Electric System can be operated reliably in anticipated normal and Contingency conditions. System studies must be conducted to highlight potential interface and other operating limits, including overloaded transmission lines and transformers, voltage and stability limits, etc. Plans must be developed to alleviate System Operating Limit (SOL) and Interconnection Reliability Operating Limit (IROL) violations.

– 4. Applicability• 4.1. Reliability Coordinators

• 4.2. Balancing Authorities

• 4.3. Transmission Operators

• 4.4. Transmission Service Providers

• 4.5. Transmission Owners

• 4.6. Generator Owners

• 4.7. Generator Operators

• 4.8. Load-Serving Entities

Page 12: APPA RELIABILITY STANDARDS & COMPLIANCE SYMPOSIUM Case Study: City Utilities of Springfield, MO January 11, 2007

Preparation

• Late Start– Company organization structure led to fractured approach

• Attended SPP Compliance Workshop

• Preparation for SPP and NERC Transmission Operation Audit in 2006– Developed cross-area team to prepare all documentation

• Corporate-Wide Standards Review– Critical Assets

– Division of Standards

Page 13: APPA RELIABILITY STANDARDS & COMPLIANCE SYMPOSIUM Case Study: City Utilities of Springfield, MO January 11, 2007

Ongoing

• Identifying Overlap/Gaps in Standards Management

• NERC Standards Education

• Training Program Enhancement

Page 14: APPA RELIABILITY STANDARDS & COMPLIANCE SYMPOSIUM Case Study: City Utilities of Springfield, MO January 11, 2007

Future

• Develop job description and hire/transfer new Standards Administrator

• Select Sr. Manager to oversee and manage CIP Standards

• Incorporate Corporate-wide Standards, update meetings to ensure compliance without overlap

• Determining level of compliance

Page 15: APPA RELIABILITY STANDARDS & COMPLIANCE SYMPOSIUM Case Study: City Utilities of Springfield, MO January 11, 2007

Lessons Learned

• Start now• System Operator certification, training and documentation

are essential• Internal and external training should be used• Identify responsible area(s) for each applicable standard• Document, document, document……• Establish formal document management program

including management review and approval