Appendix-A Database of Traditional Shear Failure Specimens ...ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S2352012419301924-mmc1.pdf1 1 Appendix-A Database of Traditional Shear Failure Specimens

1

Appendix-A Database of Traditional Shear Failure Specimens with Stirrups 1

Table A.1 Shear Database of Flexure-Shear Critical Specimens 2

Reference Specimen ID Vtest

(KN)

Geometric Properties fy (MPa) s

(mm) Pe

(KN) Ap

(mm2)

Studied Variables

b (mm)

D (mm)

Ac (mm2) I (mm4) a/d fc

(MPa) fpe/fpu l

yfy (MPa)

Garber et

al.(2016)

Q-20A 2520 178 1168 490967 82450866866 421 152 6077 5723 3.09 81 0.57 0.032 4.01

Q-46 2440 178 1168 490967 82450866866 421 152 6037 5723 3.09 81 0.57 0.032 4.01

DeWilder

et al. (2016)

B101 378 70 630 90000 4288388400 608 150 940 790 3.13 78 0.64 0.033 1.64

B102 322 70 630 90000 4288388400 608 150 940 790 3.91 78 0.64 0.033 1.64

Labib et al. (2014)

C2-S 745 76 711 143700 9402905451 413.7 80 1542 1382 2.87 103 0.6 0.029 13.61

C4-S 776 76 711 143700 9402905451 413.7 65 1542 1382 2.87 106 0.6 0.029 16.75

Hovell et

al. (2014)

B5-N 4586 254 1594 1096772 280412993901 440 102 7294 6514 2.61 91 0.6 0.009 6.82

B6-S 4688 254 1594 1190320 297244759757 586 102 7073 6317 2.6 83 0.6 0.009 5.86

Laskar et al. (2010)

B4 431 152 711 178064 9469264932 414 254 1324 1184 4.29 71 0.6 0.035 0.69

B5 436 152 711 178064 9469264932 414 254 1324 1184 4.29 65 0.6 0.036 0.69

Choulli et

al. (2008)

C2TE 721 100 750 194500 15002572458 525 200 1225 792 3.13 72 0.8 0.009 2.64

S2TW 605 100 750 194500 15002572458 525 200 1225 792 3.13 77 0.8 0.009 2.64

Heckmann

(2008)

CB-60-1 1624 178 1016 319290 34381548217 413.7 610 2867 2566 2.2 85 0.6 0.044 0.99

CB-60-2 1597 178 1016 319290 34381548217 413.7 610 2867 2566 2.2 88 0.6 0.044 0.99

CB-70-1 1597 178 1016 319290 34381548217 413.7 610 2867 2566 2.2 83 0.6 0.044 0.99

CB-70-4 1583 178 1016 319290 34381548217 413.7 610 2867 2566 2.2 86 0.6 0.044 0.99

CB-70-5 1512 178 1016 319290 34381548217 413.7 610 2867 2566 2.2 86 0.6 0.044 0.99

CB-70-6 1664 178 1016 319290 34381548217 413.7 610 2867 2566 2.2 88 0.6 0.044 0.99

CD-70-1 1770 178 1016 319290 34381548217 413.7 610 3969 3554 2.2 76 0.6 0.061 0.99

CD-70-2 1819 178 1016 319290 34381548217 413.7 610 3969 3554 2.2 80 0.6 0.061 0.99

CD-60-1 1784 178 1016 319290 34381548217 413.7 610 3969 3554 2.2 81 0.6 0.061 0.99

De Silva (2006)

IPRC-1 707 150 500 125000 3596348741 438 125 375 531 3.38 42 0.57 0.093 1.32

Byung &

Kim (2004) Girder II 1480 180 1200 398000 73289283226 345 200 1791 1777 3 62 0.54 0.039 2.43

3

4

2

Table A.1 (Cont...) 1


(KN)


(mm) Pe

(KN) Ap

(mm2)

Studied Variables

b (mm)

D (mm)


(MPa) fpe/fpu l

yfy (MPa)

Shahawy et

al. (1996)

A1-00-R/2 738 152 1117 454838 64730089342 414 203 1671 1579 2.6 48 0.57 0.008 0.95

A1-00-R/2 770 152 1117 454838 64730089342 414 203 1671 1579 3.16 48 0.57 0.008 0.95

A1-00-R 934 152 1117 454838 64730089342 414 203 1671 1579 2.6 48 0.57 0.008 1.73

A1-00-3R/2

921 152 1117 454838 64730089342 414 203 1671 1579 2.6 48 0.57 0.008 2.67

B0-00-R 916 152 1117 454838 64730089342 414 203 1570 1481 3.14 48 0.57 0.008 1.73

Tawfiq

(1995) R10N 1201 152 1118 404895 58763094192 414 203 1764 1579 2.68 70 0.6 0.007 1.72

Hartman (1988)

01-Mar 163 51 546 81677 3041819258 303 249 322 275 3 78 0.63 0.005 0.76

Xuan &

Maruyama (1995)

PSN4-

WDH 247 113 490 91500 1895000000 593 152 220 198 2.91 32 0.61 0.037 0.98

PSN5-S6H 254 113 490 91500 1895000000 483 150 220 198 2.91 33 0.61 0.036 0.89

Maruyama (1988)

PS2-S6M 151 113 490 91500 1895000000 536 152 220 198 2.93 44 0.61 0.012 0.99

PS3-D2 156 113 490 91500 1895000000 335 152 220 198 2.93 45 0.61 0.012 1.2

PS4-M2 146 113 490 91500 1895000000 393 152 220 198 2.93 43 0.61 0.012 0.72

PS6-WD 139 113 490 91500 1895000000 645 152 220 198 2.93 38 0.61 0.012 1.07

PS7-WSH 134 113 490 91500 1895000000 564 152 220 198 2.93 39 0.61 0.012 1.01

PS8-WS 123 113 490 91500 1895000000 558 152 220 198 2.93 40 0.61 0.012 1

PS9-WDH 128 113 490 91500 1895000000 676 152 220 198 2.93 42 0.61 0.012 1.12

Elzanaty et

al. (1986)

CI10 141 76.2 356 58710 853933456 434 203 440 396 5.8 73 0.6 0.022 2

CI11 127 76.2 356 58710 853933456 434 203 431 396 5.8 56 0.58 0.023 2

CI12 122 76.2 356 58710 853933456 434 203 432 396 5.8 40 0.41 0.026 2

CI13 155 76.2 356 58710 853933456 434 203 604 560 5.8 72 0.58 0.028 2

CI14 165 76.2 356 58710 853933456 434 127 613 560 5.8 74 0.59 0.028 3.2

CI15 121 76.2 356 58710 853933456 434 203 433 396 5.8 70 0.59 0.022 2

CI16 163 76.2 356 58710 853933456 434 203 609 560 5.8 73 0.58 0.058 2

CI17 129 76.2 356 58710 853933456 379 203 607 560 5.8 70 0.58 0.028 0.78

2

3

3



(KN)


(mm) Pe

(KN) Ap

(mm2)

Studied Variables

b (mm)

D (mm)


(MPa) fpe/fpu l

yfy (MPa)

Moayer and

Regan

(1974)

P8 178 150 320 84503 725066331 310 152 329 188 3.64 43 0.94 0.021 0.65

P13 140 150 320 84503 725066331 310 152 169 140 3.51 39 0.65 0.019 0.65

P18 160 150 320 84503 725066331 310 152 329 188 3.68 44 0.94 0.013 0.65

P49 190 150 320 84503 725066331 255 102 329 187 3.61 38 0.95 0.036 1.07

P50 230 150 320 84503 725066331 283 102 329 187 3.61 41 0.95 0.035 1.98

Bennet and Debaiky

(1974)

NL-6-240 82 51 330 28344 370119600 280 240 179 232 3 39 0.45 0.071 0.72

NH-6-240 89 51 330 28344 370119600 545 240 178 232 3 33 0.45 0.075 1.2

NL-6-160 91 51 330 28344 370119600 280 160 177 232 3 37 0.44 0.073 1.09

NL-10-160 103 51 330 28344 370119600 280 160 179 232 3 36 0.45 0.073 2.43

PL-6-240 89 51 330 28344 370119600 280 240 179 232 3 42 0.45 0.07 0.72

PH-6-160 94 51 330 28344 370119600 545 160 252 232 3 38 0.63 0.072 1.8

CH-6-240 103 51 330 28344 370119600 545 240 179 232 3 54 0.45 0.065 1.2

CL-6-160 103 51 330 28344 370119600 280 160 179 232 3 55 0.45 0.064 1.09

Cederwall

et al. (1974)

824-2B 116 131 262 34322 196333281 520 200 125 226 2.56 26 0.58 0.1 1.12

803-2S 76 130 260 33800 190406667 235 200 103 226 2.56 29 0.48 0.073 0.51

803-1S 85 130 260 33800 190406667 235 200 92 226 2.54 25 0.43 0.077 0.51

842-6 131 131 262 34322 196333281 530 200 120 226 2.55 46 0.56 0.127 1.14

842-7B 129 131 260 34060 191871333 530 200 126 226 2.54 36 0.59 0.14 1.14

842-8 160 132 262 34584 197832008 530 150 134 226 2.55 56 0.63 0.121 1.51

842-10 107 131 261 34191 194093759 353 200 118 226 2.54 51 0.55 0.126 0.76

842-11 91 131 260 34060 191871333 353 200 118 226 4.24 51 0.55 0.127 0.76

2

3

4



(KN)


(mm) Pe

(KN) Ap

(mm2)

Studied Variables

b (mm)

D (mm)


(MPa) fpe/fpu l

yfy (MPa)

Bennett and Balasooriya

(1971)

4A1 70 25.4 254 20968 179022870 265 38 220 232 4 37 0.51 0.052 8.7

3A2 70 25.4 254 20968 179022870 265 38 203 232 3 42 0.47 0.05 8.7

3C2 76 25.4 254 20968 179022870 265 38 176 232 3 33 0.41 0.054 8.7

3C3 79 25.4 254 20968 179022870 265 38 136 154 3 34 0.47 0.039 8.7

3D1 86 25.4 254 20968 179022870 265 25 174 232 3 44 0.4 0.049 13.21

3D2 77 25.4 254 20968 179022870 265 38 179 232 3 44 0.42 0.049 8.7

Hanson (1965)

E.17 169 76.2 457 65806 1604155914 410 203 342 485 3.39 45 0.41 0.03 0.84

E.18 172 76.2 457 65806 1604155914 410 254 343 485 3.39 46 0.41 0.03 0.67

Bruce

(1962)

CW.14.34 81 45 305 31163 331267341 220 64 148 184 3.41 27 0.47 0.03 2.41

CW.14.38 60 45 305 30760 331267341 220 89 110 138 3.38 20 0.46 0.025 1.73

CW.14.40 65 44.5 305 30484 331135327 308 102 150 184 3.4 23 0.47 0.031 2.19

CI.14.34 70 44.5 305 30685 331135327 207 64 151 184 3.39 27 0.47 0.03 2.3

CI.14.36 54 44.5 305 30685 331135327 207 89 114 138 3.39 19 0.47 0.025 1.65

FW.14.089 115 43.4 355 61954 823317081 231 41 146 184 2.87 22 0.42 0.007 4.1

FW.14.091 100 45.2 355 62418 825904481 208 35 154 184 2.82 21 0.45 0.007 4.13

FV.14.063* 90 45.7 355 64363 826619905 231 51 105 138 2.89 23 0.4 0.005 3.13

FV.14.065* 87 44.5 355 63276 824900485 207 51 115 138 2.88 22 0.44 0.005 2.88

CU.14.29 60 45.2 305 30797 331320146 325 102 115 138 3.38 24 0.47 0.023 2.27

CU.14.31 58 45 305 30961 331267341 324 102 116 139 3.38 22 0.47 0.024 2.28

CU.14.32 45 44.5 305 30645 331135327 325 102 114 138 3.39 22 0.47 0.024 2.3

CU.14.33 58 45.7 305 30952 331452161 324 102 116 136 3.39 21 0.48 0.024 2.24

CU.14.35 68 44.7 305 30803 331188132 324 102 152 184 3.39 27 0.48 0.03 2.29

CU.14.37 59 44.5 305 30685 331135327 325 102 141 184 3.39 25 0.44 0.031 2.3

CU.14.38 51 45.5 305 30673 331399355 324 102 145 184 3.37 24 0.46 0.031 2.25

CU.14.39 66 46.2 305 30945 331584175 325 102 149 184 3.39 24 0.47 0.031 2.22

2 3

5



(KN)


(mm) Pe

(KN) Ap

(mm2)

Studied Variables

b (mm)

D (mm)


(MPa) fpe/fpu l

yfy (MPa)

MacGregor

(1960)

BW-14-26 51 72.6 305 33885 333483492 296 114 98 118 3.56 24 0.45 0.021 0.64

BW-14-34 58 73.7 305 34058 333843825 234 267 129 153 3.56 25 0.45 0.027 0.59

BW-14-38 59 74.9 305 34247 334236914 300 64 129 156 3.56 21 0.44 0.029 0.56

BW-14-45 55 76.2 305 34452 334662761 284 191 130 156 3.59 20 0.45 0.029 0.74

BW-14-58 68 73.9 305 34089 333909339 296 127 178 236 3.61 22 0.4 0.044 0.57

BW-14-60 65 73.4 305 34011 333745552 296 127 179 236 3.61 21 0.41 0.044 0.57

CW-14-17 35 44.7 305 30722 331188132 300 127 68 78 3.43 22 0.47 0.014 0.48

CW-14-21 36 43.2 305 30503 330792090 254 127 68 78 3.42 21 0.47 0.014 0.6

CW-14-23 36 44.5 305 30693 331135327 254 127 68 78 3.44 19 0.47 0.014 0.58

Mattock

and Kaar (1961)

S8 328 89 647 141716 7351071579 341 127 722 604 3.25 47 0.62 0.006 1.95

S11 280 89 647 146558 7588828105 341 191 722 604 3.25 43 0.62 0.006 1.3

S12 241 89 647 143860 7458299050 341 191 722 604 4.5 45 0.62 0.006 1.3

S13 266 89 647 144641 7496614077 341 127 722 604 4.5 44 0.62 0.006 1.95

Hernandez

(1958)

G15 36 43.2 305 30503 330792090 245 127 68 78 3.42 21 0.47 0.014 0.6

G26 57 44.5 305 30693 331135327 286 191 128 157 3.58 24 0.46 0.028 2.27

G33 55 76.2 305 34452 334662761 271 191 130 157 3.59 19 0.47 0.03 0.71

G34 81 44.5 356 61660 825100469 245 64 127 156 2.93 27 0.46 0.005 3.16

G35 44 76.2 305 34452 334662761 252 127 132 156 4.73 25 0.48 0.027 0.49

2 3

6

Table A.2 Shear Database of Web-Shear Critical Specimens 1

Reference Specimen ID

Vtest

(KN)

Geometric Properties fy

(MPa)

s

(mm)

Pe

(KN)

Ap

(mm2)

Studied Variables

b (mm)

D (mm)

Ac

(mm2) I (mm4) a/d

fc

(MPa) fpe/fpu l

yfy

(MPa)

Sandra et

al. (2017)

13.3-5.1-

326P 800 152 711 178064 9466821154 607 457 1496 987 3.68 92 0.81 0.158 2.25

16.2-5.1-326P

956 152 711 178064 9466821154 607 457 1496 987 3.68 111 0.81 0.158 2.25

Garber et

al.(2016) Q-20B 2470 178 1168 490967 82450866866 421 152 6116 5723 3.09 81 0.57 0.032 4.01

Long et al.

(2015)

IH1 421 120 600 157500 7287667411 416 120 561 396 3.15 73 0.76 0.072 1.83

IH2 439 120 600 157500 7287667411 416 120 972 792 3.15 76 0.66 0.051 1.83

IH3 559 120 600 157500 7287667411 416 120 1544 1188 3.15 76 0.70 0.048 1.83

Ross et al. (2015)

DC 3471 178 1575 601663 149813760785 434 76 10140 7280 1.98 73 0.71 0.021 6.40

DM 3249 178 1575 601663 149813760785 434 76 10140 7280 1.98 73 0.71 0.021 6.40

Nabipay & Dagmar

(2014)

PR-3.5-S1 324 150 270 80500 448991951 827 204 267 304 3.50 48 0.42 0.014 1.71

PR-3.5-S2 317 150 270 80500 448991951 827 204 267 304 3.50 48 0.42 0.014 1.71

Labib et al.

(2014)

A1-S 520 76 686 192796 11165000000 414 150 1542 1382 1.77 48 0.60 0.014 7.26

A2-S 552 76 686 192796 11165000000 414 115 1542 1382 2.99 50 0.60 0.014 9.47

F1-S 897 76 686 192796 11165000000 414 140 1542 1382 1.77 91 0.60 0.013 7.78

F2-S 842 76 686 192796 11165000000 414 100 1542 1382 2.24 90 0.60 0.013 10.89

F3-S 905 76 686 192796 11165000000 414 110 1542 1382 1.77 92 0.60 0.013 9.90

F4-N 724 76 686 192796 11165000000 414 75 1542 1382 2.24 90 0.60 0.013 14.52

C1-S 767 76 686 192796 11165000000 414 100 1542 1382 1.77 108 0.60 0.013 10.89

C3-N 971 76 686 192796 11165000000 414 75 1542 1382 1.77 117 0.60 0.013 14.52

Hovell et

al. (2014) B7-N 5382 254 1594 1156772 291358800435 431 102 8309 7420 2.59 86 0.60 0.010 4.31

Wang & Ding

(2012)

PB-1 416 250 500 125000 2604166667 413 200 266 280 3.13 42 0.51 0.112 0.84

2

3

7



(KN)


(MPa) s

(mm) Pe

(KN) Ap

(mm2)

Studied Variables

b (mm)

D (mm)

Ac

(mm2) I (mm4) a/d

fc

(MPa) fpe/fpu l

yfy

(MPa)

Lee et al. (2010)

C40P2S10 1425 200 1200 312450 48307000000 470 300 1143 1110 2.47 45 0.54 0.090 1.12

C40P2S13 1541 200 1200 312450 48307000000 470 300 1143 1110 2.47 45 0.54 0.090 1.98

C60P1S10 1353 200 1200 312450 48307000000 470 300 519 555 2.47 73 0.49 0.073 1.12

C60P2S10 1666 200 1200 312450 48307000000 470 300 1143 1110 2.47 73 0.54 0.080 1.12

C60P2S13 1851 200 1200 312450 48307000000 470 300 1143 1110 2.47 73 0.54 0.080 1.98

C80P2S10 1556 200 1200 312450 48307000000 470 300 1143 1110 2.47 85 0.54 0.080 1.12

C80P2S13 1877 200 1200 312450 48307000000 470 300 1143 1110 2.47 85 0.54 0.080 1.98

Laskar et

al. (2010)

B1 772 152 711 178064 9469264932 414 254 1324 1184 1.61 72 0.60 0.035 0.69

B2 895 152 711 178064 9469264932 414 178 1324 1184 1.61 75 0.60 0.035 3.95

B3 1014 152 711 178064 9469264932 414 178 1324 1184 1.61 65 0.60 0.039 3.95

Gustavo et al. (2009)

B1U4 801 178 1321 479978 98331013043 391 457 2468 2369 4.83 39 0.56 0.017 1.24

B4U4 881 178 1321 479978 98331013043 391 457 2468 2369 4.83 39 0.56 0.017 1.24

Avendano

et al. (2008)

Tx28-II-L 1648 178 914 659354 64255310096 517 305 6756 5006 3.48 78 0.73 0.038 2.43

Tx28-II-D 1670 178 914 659354 64255310096 517 305 6756 5006 3.48 78 0.73 0.038 2.43

Tx28-I-L 1854 178 914 601934 58695290712 414 305 6508 5006 2.71 95 0.70 0.038 1.97

Tx28-I-D 1780 178 914 601934 58695290712 414 305 6508 5006 2.71 95 0.70 0.038 1.97

Choulli et al. (2008)

C1TE 779 100 750 194500 15002572458 525 200 1859 1386 3.13 65 0.69 0.015 2.64

S1TE 632 100 750 194500 15002572458 525 200 1859 1386 3.13 73 0.69 0.015 2.64

Heckmann (2008)

CC-70-1 1655 178 1016 319290 34381548217 414 610 3969 3554 2.20 74 0.60 0.061 0.99

CC-70-2 1815 178 1016 319290 34381548217 414 610 3969 3554 2.20 77 0.60 0.061 0.99

CC-65-3 1699 178 1016 319290 34381548217 414 610 3969 3554 2.20 77 0.60 0.061 0.99

CC-65-4 1757 178 1016 319290 34381548217 414 610 3969 3554 2.20 79 0.60 0.061 0.99

CC-60-1 1686 178 1016 319290 34381548217 414 610 3969 3554 2.20 74 0.60 0.061 0.99

CC-60-2 1681 178 1016 319290 34381548217 414 610 3969 3554 2.20 74 0.60 0.061 0.99

CD-65-3 1730 178 1016 319290 34381548217 414 610 3969 3554 2.20 66 0.60 0.061 0.99

CD-65-4 1793 178 1016 319290 34381548217 414 610 3969 3554 2.20 74 0.60 0.061 0.99

CD-60-2 1837 178 1016 319290 34381548217 414 610 3969 3554 2.20 83 0.60 0.061 0.99

8



(KN)


(MPa) s

(mm) Pe

(KN) Ap

(mm2)

Studied Variables

b (mm)

D (mm)

Ac

(mm2) I (mm4) a/d

fc

(MPa) fpe/fpu l

yfy

(MPa)

Runzell et

al. (2007)

I 1712 203 1600 717934 218407451029 464 533 3667 4245 3.01 70 0.46 0.031 1.08

II 1436 203 1372 509031 108528598142 464 533 3667 4245 3.57 70 0.46 0.016 1.08

De Silva et al. (2007)

HIPRC-4 1033 150 500 125000 3596348741 438 125 375 531 3.38 100 0.57 0.113 1.32

IPRC-2 644 150 500 125000 3596348741 438 225 375 531 3.38 49 0.57 0.088 0.73

IPRC-3 623 150 500 125000 3596348741 353 125 375 531 3.38 45 0.57 0.091 1.06

IPRC-4 745 150 500 125000 3596348741 438 125 375 531 3.38 43 0.57 0.142 1.32

Byung and Kim (2004)

Girder I 1474 180 1200 398000 73289283226 345 200 1791 1777 3.00 43 0.54 0.043 2.43

Ma et al. (2000)

AR05908X 2800 150 1290 681353 128315823884 414 229 3307 2961 1.23 56 0.60 0.012 4.82

AVW14408X 2638 150 1290 681353 128315823884 414 102 3307 2961 1.13 56 0.60 0.011 4.89

BVW20408X 2623 150 1290 681353 128315823884 552 102 4189 3751 1.13 74 0.60 0.013 9.30

AVW14608Y 2045 150 1290 681353 128315823884 414 152 2866 2566 1.13 56 0.60 0.009 3.28

Shahawy et

al. (1996)

A0-00-R 1392 152 1117 454838 64730089342 414 203 1671 1579 2.17 48 0.57 0.008 3.45

A0-00-R 1228 152 1117 454838 64730089342 414 203 1671 1579 2.17 48 0.57 0.008 3.45

B0-00-R 979 152 1117 454838 64730089342 414 203 1570 1481 2.58 48 0.57 0.008 1.73

Rangan (1991)

II 1 461 64 615 114960 6092680500 485 50 323 279 2.51 45 0.67 0.058 9.15

II 2 379 63 615 114570 6087737250 485 50 323 279 2.51 32 0.67 0.065 15.47

II 3 489 73 615 118470 6137169750 485 50 323 279 2.51 45 0.67 0.058 8.03

II 4 479 74 615 118860 6142113000 485 50 323 279 2.51 43 0.67 0.059 13.17

III 1 368 66 615 115740 6102567000 485 50 462 398 2.57 40 0.67 0.053 8.88

III 2 391 66 615 115740 6102567000 485 50 462 398 2.57 37 0.67 0.054 14.77

III 3 397 77 615 120030 6156942750 485 50 462 398 2.57 39 0.67 0.053 7.61

III 4 453 73 615 118470 6137169750 485 50 462 398 2.57 37 0.67 0.054 13.35

IV 1 375 62 615 114180 6082794000 485 50 831 716 2.63 37 0.67 0.030 15.72

IV 2 338 64 615 114960 6092680500 485 50 831 716 2.63 33 0.67 0.031 9.15

IV 3 465 72 615 118080 6132226500 485 50 831 716 2.63 36 0.67 0.030 13.54

IV 4 391 72 615 118080 6132226500 485 50 831 716 2.63 29 0.67 0.032 8.14

2

9



(KN)


(MPa) s

(mm) Pe

(KN) Ap

(mm2)

Studied Variables

b (mm)

D (mm)

Ac

(mm2) I (mm4) a/d

fc

(MPa) fpe/fpu l

yfy

(MPa)

Alshegeir & Ramirez

(1992)

I-3A 503 152 711 178064 9469264932 317 229 1073 843 2.35 61 0.65 0.022 1.22

I-4A 716 152 711 178064 9469264932 359 457 1091 843 2.31 61 0.67 0.021 1.26

II-1A 987 152 914 238064 21219061846 359 343 1600 1264 2.16 62 0.65 0.025 1.68

Hartman (1988)

2-1 435 51 546 81677 3041819258 503 127 876 825 3.00 74 0.57 0.018 11.12

2-2 475 51 546 81677 3041819258 503 102 876 825 3.00 74 0.57 0.018 13.90

2-3 467 51 546 81677 3041819258 503 102 876 825 3.00 74 0.57 0.018 13.90

Xuan &

Maruyama (1995)

PSN2-WD 218 113 490 91500 1895000000 587 152 220 198 2.91 38 0.61 0.035 0.97

PSN3-D2 258 113 490 91500 1895000000 344 150 220 198 2.91 33 0.61 0.036 1.25

PSN6-WS 254 113 490 91500 1895000000 578 152 220 198 2.91 34 0.61 0.036 1.03

Kaufman et

al. (1988) I 2 645 152 711 178064 9601045288 339 533 1325 1077 2.20 58 0.60 0.029 1.07

Durrani &

Robertson

(1987)

3 154 76 508 81774 1780776500 559 152 284 296 2.75 46 0.51 0.009 0.78

4 165 76 508 81774 1780776500 559 152 314 296 2.75 44 0.57 0.009 0.78

5 167 76 508 81774 1780776500 493 152 312 296 2.75 45 0.57 0.009 0.91

8 170 76 508 81774 1780776500 432 152 312 296 2.75 39 0.57 0.009 0.72

10 172 76 508 81774 1780776500 432 152 310 296 2.75 42 0.56 0.009 0.72

11 179 76 508 81774 1780776500 576 152 308 296 2.75 42 0.56 0.009 1.28

Elzanaty et al. (1986)

CW10 173 51 457 54193 1410192070 434 254 439 396 3.80 73 0.60 0.041 2.40

CW11 157 51 457 54193 1410192070 434 254 429 396 3.80 56 0.58 0.043 2.40

CW12 141 51 457 54193 1410192070 434 254 431 396 3.80 40 0.58 0.047 2.40

CW13 182 51 457 54193 1410192070 434 254 604 560 3.80 72 0.58 0.052 2.40

CW14 188 51 457 54193 1410192070 434 178 610 560 3.80 74 0.59 0.052 3.42

CW15 150 51 457 54193 1410192070 434 254 433 396 3.80 70 0.59 0.041 2.40

CW16 187 51 457 54193 1410192070 434 254 607 560 3.80 73 0.58 0.110 2.40

CW17 142 51 457 54193 1410192070 379 254 608 560 3.80 70 0.58 0.052 0.93

2

3

10



(KN)


(MPa) s

(mm) Pe

(KN) Ap

(mm2)

Studied Variables

b (mm)

D (mm)

Ac

(mm2) I (mm4) a/d

fc

(MPa) fpe/fpu l

yfy

(MPa)

Lynberg

(1976)

2A-3 506 120 600 159600 7349726086 616 160 631 678 2.78 33 0.50 0.040 3.24

2B-3 515 120 600 159600 7349726086 643 160 629 678 2.78 34 0.50 0.039 3.38

3A-2 489 120 600 159600 7349726086 663 160 421 452 2.78 31 0.51 0.053 3.49

3B-2 433 120 600 159600 7349726086 625 160 421 452 2.78 28 0.51 0.055 3.29

4A-1 469 120 600 159600 7349726086 639 160 217 226 2.78 32 0.52 0.066 3.36

4B-1 454 120 600 159600 7349726086 658 160 209 226 2.78 30 0.50 0.067 3.46

Bennet & Debaiky

(1974)

NM-6-240 89 51 330 28344 370119600 418 240 177 232 3.00 36 0.44 0.073 0.97

NM-6-160 94 51 330 28344 370119600 418 160 180 232 3.00 36 0.45 0.073 1.45

NL-6-80 106 51 330 28344 370119600 280 80 179 232 3.00 37 0.45 0.072 2.17

NH-6-80 114 51 330 28344 370119600 545 80 178 232 3.00 36 0.45 0.073 3.59

NM-10-160 103 51 330 28344 370119600 410 160 180 232 3.00 36 0.45 0.073 3.95

PM-6-160 96 51 330 28344 370119600 418 160 257 232 3.00 40 0.64 0.071 1.45

PL-6-80 106 51 330 28344 370119600 280 80 256 232 3.00 41 0.64 0.070 2.17

CL-6-240 100 51 330 28344 370119600 280 240 179 232 3.00 53 0.45 0.065 0.72

CM-6-240 100 51 330 28344 370119600 418 240 181 232 3.00 54 0.45 0.065 0.97

CM-6-160 112 51 330 28344 370119600 418 160 177 232 3.00 58 0.44 0.063 1.45

CH-6-160 112 51 330 28344 370119600 545 160 179 232 3.00 56 0.45 0.064 1.80

CL-6-80 116 51 330 28344 370119600 280 80 180 232 3.00 57 0.45 0.064 2.17

CM-6-80 126 51 330 28344 370119600 418 80 181 232 3.00 56 0.45 0.027 2.90

CH-6-80 140 51 330 28344 370119600 545 80 182 232 3.00 53 0.46 0.028 3.59

Cederwall

et al.

(1974)

842-12 191 131 260 34060 191871333 353 200 107 226 1.68 54 0.50 0.124 0.76

842-13 122 132 259 34188 191113769 353 200 107 226 1.48 54 0.50 0.124 0.76

2

3

4

5

11



(KN)


(MPa) s

(mm) Pe

(KN) Ap

(mm2)

Studied Variables

b (mm)

D (mm)

Ac

(mm2) I (mm4) a/d

fc

(MPa) fpe/fpu l

yfy

(MPa)

Bennett &

Balasooriya (1971)

2A3 81 25 254 20968 179022870 265 38 214 232 2.00 34 0.50 0.053 8.70

1A4 126 25 254 20968 179022870 265 38 210 232 1.00 35 0.49 0.053 8.70

2B2 100 25 254 20968 179022870 265 38 181 232 2.00 43 0.42 0.050 8.70

2B3 102 25 254 20968 179022870 265 38 140 154 2.00 44 0.49 0.036 8.70

2F1 151 25 457 36452 1143327026 265 44 299 309 1.37 39 0.52 0.026 7.51

2F2 148 25 457 36452 1143327026 265 44 288 309 1.52 39 0.50 0.026 7.51

2F3 132 25 457 36452 1143327026 265 44 181 232 1.37 39 0.42 0.020 7.51

Hanson (1965)

E.14 239 76 457 65806 1604155914 410 222 358 485 2.54 47 0.42 0.030 1.53

Hanson &

Hulsbos (1964)

F-X1 142 76 457 65806 1604155914 410 203 408 371 3.33 46 0.59 0.023 0.84

F-1 267 76 457 65806 1604155914 410 127 411 371 2.08 47 0.59 0.023 1.34

F-2 178 76 457 65806 1604155914 410 203 384 371 2.78 45 0.55 0.023 0.84

F-3 178 76 457 65806 1604155914 252 102 390 371 2.78 47 0.56 0.023 0.58

F-4 169 76 457 65806 1604155914 410 212 421 371 3.47 44 0.60 0.023 0.80

F-5 143 76 457 65806 1604155914 252 106 387 371 3.33 44 0.56 0.023 0.56

F-7 129 76 457 65806 1604155914 410 254 417 371 4.17 46 0.60 0.023 0.67

F-11 116 76 457 65806 1604155914 252 127 399 371 4.86 42 0.57 0.024 0.46

F-19 176 76 457 65806 1604155914 410 159 389 371 2.08 51 0.56 0.022 1.08

MacGregor

(1960)

CW-13-28 82 45 305 30693 331135327 254 64 128 156 2.69 30 0.44 0.026 2.32

CW-14-22 62 43 305 30532 330844896 246 64 131 156 3.55 32 0.45 0.025 1.59

CW-14-35 57 45 305 30693 331135327 307 191 128 156 3.58 24 0.44 0.028 2.42

CW-14-37 57 43 305 30503 330792090 254 64 130 156 3.56 22 0.45 0.028 1.19

CW-14-39 49 45 305 30693 331135327 300 64 129 156 3.56 21 0.44 0.029 0.95

CW-14-47 53 43 305 30503 330792090 246 127 128 156 3.55 17 0.44 0.030 1.66

CW-14-50 54 45 305 30693 331135327 234 127 131 156 3.55 17 0.45 0.031 2.07

CW-14-51 58 46 305 30868 331452161 254 127 183 229 3.63 22 0.43 0.042 1.14

2

3

12



(KN)


(MPa) s

(mm) Pe

(KN) Ap

(mm2)

Studied Variables

b (mm)

D (mm)

Ac

(mm2) I (mm4) a/d

fc

(MPa) fpe/fpu l

yfy

(MPa)

Mattock &

Kaar

(1961)

S1 637 89 647 134410 6960256911 341 64 722 604 1.00 46 0.62 0.006 3.87

S2 449 89 647 134544 6967795026 341 64 722 604 2.00 45 0.62 0.006 3.87

S3 569 89 647 139071 7214304528 341 64 722 604 1.50 45 0.62 0.006 3.87

S5 534 89 647 140771 7302806903 341 127 722 604 1.00 42 0.62 0.006 1.95

S6 438 89 647 142384 7384831342 341 127 722 604 1.50 44 0.62 0.006 1.95

S7 395 89 647 141946 7362769385 341 127 722 604 2.00 44 0.62 0.006 1.95

S9 446 89 647 143164 7423855766 341 191 722 604 1.00 45 0.62 0.006 1.30

S10 340 89 647 141577 7344046685 341 191 722 604 2.00 43 0.62 0.006 1.30

S21 330 89 647 138353 7176290605 341 191 722 604 2.00 46 0.62 0.006 1.30

Hernandez

(1958)

G5 57 43 305 30503 330792090 245 64 130 156 3.56 22 0.45 0.028 1.19

G6 49 45 305 30693 331135327 293 64 128 156 3.56 21 0.45 0.029 0.95

G7 62 43 305 30532 330844896 232 64 131 156 3.55 32 0.46 0.025 1.54

G10 53 43 305 30503 330792090 232 127 128 156 3.55 18 0.44 0.030 1.56

G13 35 45 305 30722 331188132 293 127 68 78 3.43 22 0.47 0.014 0.48

G14 59 75 305 34247 334236914 293 64 129 156 3.56 21 0.45 0.029 0.56

G20 54 45 305 30693 331135327 212 127 131 156 3.55 17 0.46 0.031 1.89

G21 36 45 305 30693 331135327 245 127 68 78 3.44 19 0.47 0.014 0.58

G28 59 76 305 34452 334662761 271 254 126 156 3.59 27 0.46 0.027 0.80

G29 79 45 305 30693 331135327 245 64 128 157 2.79 30 0.46 0.026 2.30

2

3

4

Documents

Appendix-A Database of Traditional Shear Failure Specimens ...ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S2352012419301924-mmc1.pdf1 1 Appendix-A Database of Traditional Shear Failure Specimens