Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
APPENDIX C
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 1 of 23 PageID #: 38284
Appendix C: Category 1Claimants Who Object to Settlement Amounts
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
7 200000214 BRAITHWAITE SHERMAN MRCD-OBJ-000023 MRCD-OBJ-000025 X
9 200000219 BRESILIEN HENRY MRCD-OBJ-000027 MRCD-OBJ-000029 Peter Gleason X
41 200001140 MARIN HECTOR MRCD-OBJ-000320 MRCD-OBJ-000329
42 200001153 MARTIN KHALID MRCD-OBJ-000330 MRCD-OBJ-000333 X
54 200001690 RODRIGUEZ ARNALDO MRCD-OBJ-000398 MRCD-OBJ-000402 Peter Gleason X
67 200002056 VELEZ RAYMOND MRCD-OBJ-000514 MRCD-OBJ-000524 X* X
90 200006013 ROMERO ROLANDO MRCD-OBJ-000639 MRCD-OBJ-000643 Peter Gleason X
92 200006382 SONERA CARLOS MRCD-OBJ-000647 MRCD-OBJ-000650 X
* Claimant established good cause for his untimely objection.
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 2 of 23 PageID #: 38285
Appendix C: Category 2Claimants Who Object to Their Individual Back Pay Awards Based on Allocation Methodology
Page 1 of 3
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
1 200000047 ALPHONSE ROBERT MRCD-OBJ-000001 MRCD-OBJ-000006 X
4 200000125 BARCENE MICHAEL MRCD-OBJ-000013 MRCD-OBJ-000016
5 200000145 BATSON WAYLAND MRCD-OBJ-000017 MRCD-OBJ-000020
6 200000164 BERRIOS EDWARDO MRCD-OBJ-000021 MRCD-OBJ-000022
7 200000214 BRAITHWAITE SHERMAN MRCD-OBJ-000023 MRCD-OBJ-000025 X
10 200000246 BUCHELLI BORIS MRCD-OBJ-000030 MRCD-OBJ-000032
16 200000468 DANIELS AARON MRCD-OBJ-000078 MRCD-OBJ-000082 X
18 200000483 DAVIS SHARIF MRCD-OBJ-000144 MRCD-OBJ-000150
20 200000487 DE LA CRUZ EDUARDO MRCD-OBJ-000155 MRCD-OBJ-000167
21 200000521 DETRES RAYNARDEE MRCD-OBJ-000168 MRCD-OBJ-000170 X
24 200000693 GARRIDO RICHARD MRCD-OBJ-000177 MRCD-OBJ-000180 X
29 200000889 HILL DWAYNE MRCD-OBJ-000201 MRCD-OBJ-000226 Levy Ratner X
31 200000901 HOLLINGSWORTH LAWRENCE MRCD-OBJ-000232 MRCD-OBJ-000243 X
32 200000915 HOWELL ERROL MRCD-OBJ-000244 MRCD-OBJ-000249
33 200000924 HUTCHINSON DAREN MRCD-OBJ-000250 MRCD-OBJ-000253 X
34 200000928 IGBOWU NATHANAEL MRCD-OBJ-000254 MRCD-OBJ-000256 X
35 200001025 KIMBROUGH LOUIS MRCD-OBJ-000257 MRCD-OBJ-000260 X
36 200001051 LAURENCEAU HAROLD MRCD-OBJ-000261 MRCD-OBJ-000264 X
37 200001052 LAURENCEAU JERRY MRCD-OBJ-000265 MRCD-OBJ-000271 Levy Ratner X X
38 200001063 LEGER ALEX MRCD-OBJ-000272 MRCD-OBJ-000273 X
40 200001113 MACIAS JAVIER MRCD-OBJ-000316 MRCD-OBJ-000319
41 200001140 MARIN HECTOR MRCD-OBJ-000320 MRCD-OBJ-000329
42 200001153 MARTIN KHALID MRCD-OBJ-000330 MRCD-OBJ-000333 X
43 200001209 FORBES TENISHA MRCD-OBJ-000334 MRCD-OBJ-000336 X
44 200001254 MENENDEZ DAVID MRCD-OBJ-000337 MRCD-OBJ-000341 X
45 200001262 MERCADO ORLANDO MRCD-OBJ-000342 MRCD-OBJ-000349
47 200001349 MYERS ANTHONY MRCD-OBJ-000352 MRCD-OBJ-000352 X X
48 200001359 NAVARRO EDDYS MRCD-OBJ-000353 MRCD-OBJ-000381
49 200001450 PARKER HARRY MRCD-OBJ-000382 MRCD-OBJ-000385
51 200001546 POUERIET RAFAEL MRCD-OBJ-000389 MRCD-OBJ-000389
52 200001667 RIVERA WALTER MRCD-OBJ-000390 MRCD-OBJ-000394
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 3 of 23 PageID #: 38286
Appendix C: Category 2Claimants Who Object to Their Individual Back Pay Awards Based on Allocation Methodology
Page 2 of 3
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
53 200001689 RODRIGUEZ ANTHONY MRCD-OBJ-000395 MRCD-OBJ-000397
55 200001702 RODRIGUEZ JOHN MRCD-OBJ-000403 MRCD-OBJ-000406
56 200001723 ROLDAN ERIC MRCD-OBJ-000407 MRCD-OBJ-000421 X X
57 200001806 SANTANGELO MICHAEL MRCD-OBJ-000422 MRCD-OBJ-000469Margaret Santangelo X
58 200001854 SIERRA LUIS MRCD-OBJ-000470 MRCD-OBJ-000475 X
59 200001870 SINGLETON JOSEPH MRCD-OBJ-000476 MRCD-OBJ-000479
60 200001920 STEWART DONALD MRCD-OBJ-000480 MRCD-OBJ-000483
61 200001940 TALTON JASON MRCD-OBJ-000484 MRCD-OBJ-000489 X
62 200001941 TANIS JEAN MRCD-OBJ-000490 MRCD-OBJ-000495 X
64 200002007 UCETA FRANKLIN MRCD-OBJ-000505 MRCD-OBJ-000505 X
65 200002030 VARGAS JOSEPH MRCD-OBJ-000506 MRCD-OBJ-000509 X
66 200002042 VEGA CARLOS MRCD-OBJ-000510 MRCD-OBJ-000513
67 200002056 VELEZ RAYMOND MRCD-OBJ-000514 MRCD-OBJ-000524 X* X
70 200002241 ADAMS JASON MRCD-OBJ-000534 MRCD-OBJ-000537 X
71 200002572 BETANCOURT DAVID MRCD-OBJ-000538 MRCD-OBJ-000556
Jose Pena & Associates/ Sandford Rubenstein X
72 200002663 BRANFORD HASANI MRCD-OBJ-000557 MRCD-OBJ-000562 X
73 200002962 CHILE LUIS MRCD-OBJ-000563 MRCD-OBJ-000566 X
74 200003122 COUCH DARRELL MRCD-OBJ-000567 MRCD-OBJ-000570
76 200003152 CRONENBERG CHRISTOPHER MRCD-OBJ-000574 MRCD-OBJ-000577 X
78 200003370 DIAZ ROBERT MRCD-OBJ-000581 MRCD-OBJ-000584 X
79 200003436 DUARTE MAURICE MRCD-OBJ-000585 MRCD-OBJ-000591 X
80 200003627 FIGUEROA ROBERT MRCD-OBJ-000592 MRCD-OBJ-000597 X
81 200003674 FOSTER SEAN MRCD-OBJ-000598 MRCD-OBJ-000602 X
83 200004640 LOPEZ THOMAS MRCD-OBJ-000604 MRCD-OBJ-000612 X
84 200004790 MARTINEZ JACKIE-MICHELLE MRCD-OBJ-000613 MRCD-OBJ-000621 X
85 200005403 PAYNE CHRISTOPHER MRCD-OBJ-000622 MRCD-OBJ-000623 X
86 200005490 PETERS OMAR MRCD-OBJ-000624 MRCD-OBJ-000626 X X
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 4 of 23 PageID #: 38287
Appendix C: Category 2Claimants Who Object to Their Individual Back Pay Awards Based on Allocation Methodology
Page 3 of 3
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
87 200005610 QUINONES MATTHEW MRCD-OBJ-000627 MRCD-OBJ-000630Wellerstein Associates X
88 200005835 ROBERTS SEAN MRCD-OBJ-000631 MRCD-OBJ-000634 X
91 200006232 SCOTT IHSAN MRCD-OBJ-000644 MRCD-OBJ-000646 X
93 200006524 THOMAS ABUNDI MRCD-OBJ-000651 MRCD-OBJ-000656 X
94 200006833 VIRRUSO PIETRO MRCD-OBJ-000657 MRCD-OBJ-000660 X
95 200006841 WAITE DAMION MRCD-OBJ-000661 MRCD-OBJ-000663 X
97 200007115 CUMINALE CARL MRCD-OBJ-000665 MRCD-OBJ-000668
99 200007156 FERNANDEZ JASON MRCD-OBJ-000675 MRCD-OBJ-000678
100 200007159 MIRANDA JEFFREY MRCD-OBJ-000679 MRCD-OBJ-000684 X
101 200007173 PRIDGEON TERRENCE MRCD-OBJ-000685 MRCD-OBJ-000690 X
* Claimant established good cause for his untimely objection.
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 5 of 23 PageID #: 38288
Appendix C: Category 2-aClaimants Who Object That Their Back Pay Awards Do Not Equal What They Would Have Earned as Firefighters
Page 1 of 3
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
1 200000047 ALPHONSE ROBERT MRCD-OBJ-000001 MRCD-OBJ-000006 X
4 200000125 BARCENE MICHAEL MRCD-OBJ-000013 MRCD-OBJ-000016
6 200000164 BERRIOS EDWARDO MRCD-OBJ-000021 MRCD-OBJ-000022
7 200000214 BRAITHWAITE SHERMAN MRCD-OBJ-000023 MRCD-OBJ-000025 X
10 200000246 BUCHELLI BORIS MRCD-OBJ-000030 MRCD-OBJ-000032
16 200000468 DANIELS AARON MRCD-OBJ-000078 MRCD-OBJ-000082 X
18 200000483 DAVIS SHARIF MRCD-OBJ-000144 MRCD-OBJ-000150
20 200000487 DE LA CRUZ EDUARDO MRCD-OBJ-000155 MRCD-OBJ-000167
21 200000521 DETRES RAYNARDEE MRCD-OBJ-000168 MRCD-OBJ-000170 X
24 200000693 GARRIDO RICHARD MRCD-OBJ-000177 MRCD-OBJ-000180 X
29 200000889 HILL DWAYNE MRCD-OBJ-000201 MRCD-OBJ-000226 Levy Ratner X
32 200000915 HOWELL ERROL MRCD-OBJ-000244 MRCD-OBJ-000249
33 200000924 HUTCHINSON DAREN MRCD-OBJ-000250 MRCD-OBJ-000253 X
34 200000928 IGBOWU NATHANAEL MRCD-OBJ-000254 MRCD-OBJ-000256 X
36 200001051 LAURENCEAU HAROLD MRCD-OBJ-000261 MRCD-OBJ-000264 X
37 200001052 LAURENCEAU JERRY MRCD-OBJ-000265 MRCD-OBJ-000271 Levy Ratner X X
38 200001063 LEGER ALEX MRCD-OBJ-000272 MRCD-OBJ-000273 X
41 200001140 MARIN HECTOR MRCD-OBJ-000320 MRCD-OBJ-000329
42 200001153 MARTIN KHALID MRCD-OBJ-000330 MRCD-OBJ-000333 X
43 200001209 FORBES TENISHA MRCD-OBJ-000334 MRCD-OBJ-000336 X
44 200001254 MENENDEZ DAVID MRCD-OBJ-000337 MRCD-OBJ-000341 X
45 200001262 MERCADO ORLANDO MRCD-OBJ-000342 MRCD-OBJ-000349
47 200001349 MYERS ANTHONY MRCD-OBJ-000352 MRCD-OBJ-000352 X X
48 200001359 NAVARRO EDDYS MRCD-OBJ-000353 MRCD-OBJ-000381
49 200001450 PARKER HARRY MRCD-OBJ-000382 MRCD-OBJ-000385
51 200001546 POUERIET RAFAEL MRCD-OBJ-000389 MRCD-OBJ-000389
55 200001702 RODRIGUEZ JOHN MRCD-OBJ-000403 MRCD-OBJ-000406
56 200001723 ROLDAN ERIC MRCD-OBJ-000407 MRCD-OBJ-000421 X X
57 200001806 SANTANGELO MICHAEL MRCD-OBJ-000422 MRCD-OBJ-000469Margaret Santangelo X
58 200001854 SIERRA LUIS MRCD-OBJ-000470 MRCD-OBJ-000475 X
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 6 of 23 PageID #: 38289
Appendix C: Category 2-aClaimants Who Object That Their Back Pay Awards Do Not Equal What They Would Have Earned as Firefighters
Page 2 of 3
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
59 200001870 SINGLETON JOSEPH MRCD-OBJ-000476 MRCD-OBJ-000479
61 200001940 TALTON JASON MRCD-OBJ-000484 MRCD-OBJ-000489 X
62 200001941 TANIS JEAN MRCD-OBJ-000490 MRCD-OBJ-000495 X
64 200002007 UCETA FRANKLIN MRCD-OBJ-000505 MRCD-OBJ-000505 X
65 200002030 VARGAS JOSEPH MRCD-OBJ-000506 MRCD-OBJ-000509 X
66 200002042 VEGA CARLOS MRCD-OBJ-000510 MRCD-OBJ-000513
70 200002241 ADAMS JASON MRCD-OBJ-000534 MRCD-OBJ-000537 X
71 200002572 BETANCOURT DAVID MRCD-OBJ-000538 MRCD-OBJ-000556
Jose Pena & Associates/ Sandford Rubenstein X
72 200002663 BRANFORD HASANI MRCD-OBJ-000557 MRCD-OBJ-000562 X
73 200002962 CHILE LUIS MRCD-OBJ-000563 MRCD-OBJ-000566 X
74 200003122 COUCH DARRELL MRCD-OBJ-000567 MRCD-OBJ-000570
76 200003152 CRONENBERG CHRISTOPHER MRCD-OBJ-000574 MRCD-OBJ-000577 X
78 200003370 DIAZ ROBERT MRCD-OBJ-000581 MRCD-OBJ-000584 X
79 200003436 DUARTE MAURICE MRCD-OBJ-000585 MRCD-OBJ-000591 X
80 200003627 FIGUEROA ROBERT MRCD-OBJ-000592 MRCD-OBJ-000597 X
81 200003674 FOSTER SEAN MRCD-OBJ-000598 MRCD-OBJ-000602 X
83 200004640 LOPEZ THOMAS MRCD-OBJ-000604 MRCD-OBJ-000612 X
84 200004790 MARTINEZ JACKIE-MICHELLE MRCD-OBJ-000613 MRCD-OBJ-000621 X
85 200005403 PAYNE CHRISTOPHER MRCD-OBJ-000622 MRCD-OBJ-000623 X
86 200005490 PETERS OMAR MRCD-OBJ-000624 MRCD-OBJ-000626 X X
87 200005610 QUINONES MATTHEW MRCD-OBJ-000627 MRCD-OBJ-000630Wellerstein Associates X
88 200005835 ROBERTS SEAN MRCD-OBJ-000631 MRCD-OBJ-000634 X
91 200006232 SCOTT IHSAN MRCD-OBJ-000644 MRCD-OBJ-000646 X
93 200006524 THOMAS ABUNDI MRCD-OBJ-000651 MRCD-OBJ-000656 X
94 200006833 VIRRUSO PIETRO MRCD-OBJ-000657 MRCD-OBJ-000660 X
95 200006841 WAITE DAMION MRCD-OBJ-000661 MRCD-OBJ-000663 X
97 200007115 CUMINALE CARL MRCD-OBJ-000665 MRCD-OBJ-000668
99 200007156 FERNANDEZ JASON MRCD-OBJ-000675 MRCD-OBJ-000678
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 7 of 23 PageID #: 38290
Appendix C: Category 2-aClaimants Who Object That Their Back Pay Awards Do Not Equal What They Would Have Earned as Firefighters
Page 3 of 3
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
100 200007159 MIRANDA JEFFREY MRCD-OBJ-000679 MRCD-OBJ-000684 X
* Claimant established good cause for his untimely objection.
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 8 of 23 PageID #: 38291
Appendix C: Category 2-bNonhire Claimants Who Object to Use of Interim Earnings to Calculate Their Back Pay Awards
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
5 200000145 BATSON WAYLAND MRCD-OBJ-000017 MRCD-OBJ-000020
29 200000889 HILL DWAYNE MRCD-OBJ-000201 MRCD-OBJ-000226 Levy Ratner X
35 200001025 KIMBROUGH LOUIS MRCD-OBJ-000257 MRCD-OBJ-000260 X
41 200001140 MARIN HECTOR MRCD-OBJ-000320 MRCD-OBJ-000329
52 200001667 RIVERA WALTER MRCD-OBJ-000390 MRCD-OBJ-000394
53 200001689 RODRIGUEZ ANTHONY MRCD-OBJ-000395 MRCD-OBJ-000397
60 200001920 STEWART DONALD MRCD-OBJ-000480 MRCD-OBJ-000483
67 200002056 VELEZ RAYMOND MRCD-OBJ-000514 MRCD-OBJ-000524 X* X
* Claimant established good cause for his untimely objection.
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 9 of 23 PageID #: 38292
Appendix C: Category 2-cDelayed-Hire Claimants Who Object That Their Back Pay Awards Do Not Equal the Difference Between Their Interim Earnings
and What They Would Have Earned as Firefighters
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
20 200000487 DE LA CRUZ EDUARDO MRCD-OBJ-000155 MRCD-OBJ-000167
31 200000901 HOLLINGSWORTH LAWRENCE MRCD-OBJ-000232 MRCD-OBJ-000243 X
43 200001209 FORBES TENISHA MRCD-OBJ-000334 MRCD-OBJ-000336 X
70 200002241 ADAMS JASON MRCD-OBJ-000534 MRCD-OBJ-000537 X
101 200007173 PRIDGEON TERRENCE MRCD-OBJ-000685 MRCD-OBJ-000690 X
* Claimant established good cause for his untimely objection.
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 10 of 23 PageID #: 38293
Appendix C: Category 2-dClaimant Who Objects That Priority Hires Should Receive Greater Back Pay Awards Than Nonhire Claimants Not Appointed to the FDNY
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
40 200001113 MACIAS JAVIER MRCD-OBJ-000316 MRCD-OBJ-000319
* Claimant established good cause for his untimely objection.
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 11 of 23 PageID #: 38294
Appendix C: Category 3Claimants Who Object to the Calculation of Their Individual Awards
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
8 200000216 BRATHWAITE DONALD MRCD-OBJ-000026 MRCD-OBJ-000026 X
12 200000323 CASTRO RUBEN MRCD-OBJ-000036 MRCD-OBJ-000051
13 200000337 CHAMBERS RICARDO MRCD-OBJ-000052 MRCD-OBJ-000061
14 200000431 CRUZ DANIEL MRCD-OBJ-000062 MRCD-OBJ-000074 X
15 200000459 DALEY ANITA MRCD-OBJ-000075 MRCD-OBJ-000077 X
17 200000471 DARBY DEVIN MRCD-OBJ-000083 MRCD-OBJ-000143 X
30 200000896 HOLDER RIVOLENA MRCD-OBJ-000227 MRCD-OBJ-000231 X
39 200001078 LIBURD ELLERY MRCD-OBJ-000274 MRCD-OBJ-000315
46 200001293 MOLINA AARON MRCD-OBJ-000350 MRCD-OBJ-000351
57 200001806 SANTANGELO MICHAEL MRCD-OBJ-000422 MRCD-OBJ-000469Margaret Santangelo X
76 200003152 CRONENBERG CHRISTOPHER MRCD-OBJ-000574 MRCD-OBJ-000577 X
77 200003312 DELLAVALLE GREGORY MRCD-OBJ-000578 MRCD-OBJ-000580 X
96 200007062 GOMEZ DAVID MRCD-OBJ-000664 MRCD-OBJ-000664 X
* Claimant established good cause for his untimely objection.
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 12 of 23 PageID #: 38295
Appendix C: Category 3-aNonhire Claimants Who Object That Their Back Pay Awards Were Calculated Assuming Maximum Average Interim Earnings
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
8 200000216 BRATHWAITE DONALD MRCD-OBJ-000026 MRCD-OBJ-000026 X
12 200000323 CASTRO RUBEN MRCD-OBJ-000036 MRCD-OBJ-000051
14 200000431 CRUZ DANIEL MRCD-OBJ-000062 MRCD-OBJ-000074 X
15 200000459 DALEY ANITA MRCD-OBJ-000075 MRCD-OBJ-000077 X
30 200000896 HOLDER RIVOLENA MRCD-OBJ-000227 MRCD-OBJ-000231 X
* Claimant established good cause for his untimely objection.
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 13 of 23 PageID #: 38296
Appendix C: Category 3-bClaimant Who Objects to Damages Category Used to Calculate Award
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
13 200000337 CHAMBERS RICARDO MRCD-OBJ-000052 MRCD-OBJ-000061
* Claimant established good cause for his untimely objection.
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 14 of 23 PageID #: 38297
Appendix C: Category 3-cClaimant Who Objects to Award and Requests to Withdraw Claim for Relief
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
96 200007062 GOMEZ DAVID MRCD-OBJ-000664 MRCD-OBJ-000664 X
* Claimant established good cause for his untimely objection.
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 15 of 23 PageID #: 38298
Appendix C: Category 3-dNonhire Claimants Who Object That Their Interim Earnings Should Have Been Discounted When Calculating Their Back Pay Awards
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
46 200001293 MOLINA AARON MRCD-OBJ-000350 MRCD-OBJ-000351
57 200001806 SANTANGELO MICHAEL MRCD-OBJ-000422 MRCD-OBJ-000469Margaret Santangelo X
* Claimant established good cause for his untimely objection.
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 16 of 23 PageID #: 38299
Appendix C: Category 3-eDelayed-Hire Claimants Who Object That Months of Delay Used to Calculate Their Back Pay Awards Are Incorrect
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
76 200003152 CRONENBERG CHRISTOPHER MRCD-OBJ-000574 MRCD-OBJ-000577 X
77 200003312 DELLAVALLE GREGORY MRCD-OBJ-000578 MRCD-OBJ-000580 X
* Claimant established good cause for his untimely objection.
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 17 of 23 PageID #: 38300
Appendix C: Category 3-fClaimants Who Object That They Were Not Awarded Additional Fringe Benefits
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
17 200000471 DARBY DEVIN MRCD-OBJ-000083 MRCD-OBJ-000143 X
39 200001078 LIBURD ELLERY MRCD-OBJ-000274 MRCD-OBJ-000315
46 200001293 MOLINA AARON MRCD-OBJ-000350 MRCD-OBJ-000351
* Claimant established good cause for his untimely objection.
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 18 of 23 PageID #: 38301
Appendix C: Category 4Claimants Who Object to Employee Pension Contributions Being Withheld from Their Back Pay Awards
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
29 200000889 HILL DWAYNE MRCD-OBJ-000201 MRCD-OBJ-000226 Levy Ratner X
63 200001975 WHYTE LAURIETTE MRCD-OBJ-000496 MRCD-OBJ-000504 X
* Claimant established good cause for his untimely objection.
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 19 of 23 PageID #: 38302
Appendix C: Category 5Claimants Who Object to Issues Outside the Scope of the Decree
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
2 200000095 ASSEMIAN FELIX MRCD-OBJ-000007 MRCD-OBJ-000008 X
3 200000107 AVILA JOSE MRCD-OBJ-000009 MRCD-OBJ-000012
7 200000214 BRAITHWAITE SHERMAN MRCD-OBJ-000023 MRCD-OBJ-000025 X
28 200000861 HERMO ANTHONY MRCD-OBJ-000197 MRCD-OBJ-000200 X
29 200000889 HILL DWAYNE MRCD-OBJ-000201 MRCD-OBJ-000226 Levy Ratner X
45 200001262 MERCADO ORLANDO MRCD-OBJ-000342 MRCD-OBJ-000349
48 200001359 NAVARRO EDDYS MRCD-OBJ-000353 MRCD-OBJ-000381
50 200001461 PATRICK ANTOINE MRCD-OBJ-000386 MRCD-OBJ-000388 Levy Ratner X
57 200001806 SANTANGELO MICHAEL MRCD-OBJ-000422 MRCD-OBJ-000469Margaret Santangelo X
60 200001920 STEWART DONALD MRCD-OBJ-000480 MRCD-OBJ-000483
63 200001975 WHYTE LAURIETTE MRCD-OBJ-000496 MRCD-OBJ-000504 X
65 200002030 VARGAS JOSEPH MRCD-OBJ-000506 MRCD-OBJ-000509 X
69 200002187 YAR MOHAMED MRCD-OBJ-000529 MRCD-OBJ-000533
75 200003135 CRAWFORD MALIK MRCD-OBJ-000571 MRCD-OBJ-000573
81 200003674 FOSTER SEAN MRCD-OBJ-000598 MRCD-OBJ-000602 X
85 200005403 PAYNE CHRISTOPHER MRCD-OBJ-000622 MRCD-OBJ-000623 X
87 200005610 QUINONES MATTHEW MRCD-OBJ-000627 MRCD-OBJ-000630Wellerstein Associates X
* Claimant established good cause for his untimely objection.
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 20 of 23 PageID #: 38303
Appendix C: Category 6Claimants Who Submitted Blank or Unknown Objections
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
11 200000264 CABRERA DAMIAN MRCD-OBJ-000033 MRCD-OBJ-000035 Mr. Coiro X
23 200000687 GARCIA JOSE MRCD-OBJ-000175 MRCD-OBJ-000176 X
25 200000718 GILLIS DERECK MRCD-OBJ-000181 MRCD-OBJ-000184
26 200000725 MICHEL GLINORY MRCD-OBJ-000185 MRCD-OBJ-000192 X
68 200002154 WILLIAMSON DAMEL MRCD-OBJ-000525 MRCD-OBJ-000528 Levy Ratner X X
82 200003928 GORIS ERVING MRCD-OBJ-000603 MRCD-OBJ-000603 X
89 200006000 ROMAN RICARDO MRCD-OBJ-000635 MRCD-OBJ-000638 X
* Claimant established good cause for his untimely objection.
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 21 of 23 PageID #: 38304
Appendix C: Category 7Claimants Who Returned Submissions That Were Supportive of Decree or Non-Objections
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
19 200000486 DE COSTA EMMETT MRCD-OBJ-000151 MRCD-OBJ-000154
22 200000683 GARCIA DANIELLE MRCD-OBJ-000171 MRCD-OBJ-000174 X
27 200000843 HEARD CORRY MRCD-OBJ-000193 MRCD-OBJ-000196 X X
98 200007150 DUTCHIN SIMONE MRCD-OBJ-000669 MRCD-OBJ-000674
* Claimant established good cause for his untimely objection.
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 22 of 23 PageID #: 38305
Appendix C: Category 8Claimants Who Submitted Untimely Objections
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit Number
Claimant Number
Last Name First Name Bates Number Begin Bates Number EndAttorney's
NameUntimely
Did Not Submit
Complete Form
Requested to Appear at Fairness Hearing
27 200000843 HEARD CORRY MRCD-OBJ-000193 MRCD-OBJ-000196 X X
37 200001052 LAURENCEAU JERRY MRCD-OBJ-000265 MRCD-OBJ-000271 Levy Ratner X X
42 200001153 MARTIN KHALID MRCD-OBJ-000330 MRCD-OBJ-000333 X
47 200001349 MYERS ANTHONY MRCD-OBJ-000352 MRCD-OBJ-000352 X X
62 200001941 TANIS JEAN MRCD-OBJ-000490 MRCD-OBJ-000495 X
67 200002056 VELEZ RAYMOND MRCD-OBJ-000514 MRCD-OBJ-000524 X* X
86 200005490 PETERS OMAR MRCD-OBJ-000624 MRCD-OBJ-000626 X X
* Claimant established good cause for his untimely objection.
Case 1:07-cv-02067-NGG-RLM Document 1469-4 Filed 09/22/14 Page 23 of 23 PageID #: 38306
