APPENDIX F-1 FTA Operational Noise Analysis Calculation ...web.mta.info/capital/esa_docs/eafiles06/Appendix F-1 FTA Operation… · OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility

APPENDIX F-1 FTA Operational Noise Analysis

Calculation Spreadsheets July 2004

OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Daytime Operation, Off-Peak LoadEQUIPMENT LISTNumber Tag Equipment Location Location of louver or Capacity Size Height of Enclosed Receptor Distance Notes

air opening to outside (hp) Total Active Source Yes/No # 63 125 250 500 1k 2k 4k 8k (feet) 63 125 250 500 1k 2k 4k 8k

ROOFTOP1 CT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) Roof NA 230 rpm 60 hp 3 2 512 No R6 65.2 59.2 53.2 53.2 51.2 50.2 45.2 32.2 36 Marley, Model NC8312JL1 97 91 85 85 83 82 77 641 CT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) Roof NA 230 rpm 60 hp 3 2 512 No R7 63.3 57.3 51.3 51.3 49.3 48.3 43.3 30.3 48 Marley, Model NC8312JL1 98 92 86 86 84 83 78 651 CT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) Roof NA 230 rpm 60 hp 3 2 512 No R8 61.2 53.2 48.2 47.2 44.2 42.2 36.2 23.2 36 Marley, Model NC8312JL1 93 85 80 79 76 74 68 551 CT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) Roof NA 230 rpm 60 hp 3 2 512 No R9 59.3 51.3 46.3 45.3 42.3 40.3 34.3 21.3 48 Marley, Model NC8312JL1 94 86 81 80 77 75 69 56

INDOORS2 GEN-1,2 Generator 6th fl. (Z-wall design) north façade 1800 rpm 2647 bhp 2 0 475 Yes 95 95 91 86 74 78 81 81 Lw Cummins, 2MW 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

(without treatment) 100 101 101 101 99 97 94 89 LwZ-wall return (used data for 3ft. Silencer) 5 6 10 15 25 19 13 8

3 GEN-EX-1,2Generator Exhaust 6th fl. Roof Vertical Ex. Roof 1800 rpm 2647 bhp 2 0 488 No 79 82 80 78 71 66 63 63 5 Cummins 2 MW 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0(without silencer) 98 107 111 114 111 109 102 95 5Muffler 19 25 31 36 40 43 39 32

4 MAF-1,2,3,4Makeup Fans (Gen.) 6th fl. south façade 31,400 cfm 6.81 bhp 4 0 475 Yes 85 88 78 69 57 63 56 54 Lw Greenheck, QEI-40, 700 rpm 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0(without silencer) 90 94 88 84 82 82 69 62 LwSilencer (3ft. Length) 5 6 10 15 25 19 13 8

5 HV-4,5,6,7 Vent Fans 5th fl., south north façade 1400 cfm 4 4 457 Yes 48 50 43 43 38 33 30 29 Lw Centrifugal Radial, 1000 rpm 54 56 49 49 44 39 36 356 CWP-1,2,3 Condenser Pumps (2 at 80% capacity) concourse level NA 3000 gpm 76 hp 3 2 314 Yes 77 78 80 80 83 80 76 70 3 76bhp, 1760rpm 90 91 93 93 96 93 89 837 CWP-5 Condenser Pump (standby) concourse level NA 600 gpm 25 hp 1 0 314 Yes 75 78 79 79 78 75 72 67 3 1750 rpm, 17 bhp 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08 CH-1,2,3 Chillers (2 at 80% capacity) concourse level NA 1000 tons 3 2 314 Yes 97 98 99 96 98 98 94 87 Lw NY Trane CSO 100 101 102 99 101 101 97 909 CH-4 Chiller (nighttime use only) concourse level NA 200 tons 1 0 314 Yes 93 84 81 80 79 78 75 68 Lw Trane 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

10 CHP-1,2,3 Primary Chilled Water Pumps (2 at 80% capacity) concourse level NA 2000 gpm 32 bhp 3 2 314 Yes 68 71 72 72 71 68 65 60 3 1160 rpm, 32 bhp 81 84 85 85 84 81 78 7311 CHP-4 Primary Chilled Water Pump (standby) concourse level NA 1160 rpm 12 bhp 1 0 314 Yes 72 75 76 76 75 72 69 64 3 1160 rpm, 12 bhp 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 012 CHS-1,2,3 Secondary Chilled Water Pumps (2 at 80% capacityconcourse level NA 2500 gpm 150 bhp 3 2 314 Yes 81 84 85 85 84 81 78 73 3 1750 rpm, 150 bhp 94 97 98 98 97 94 91 8613 CHS-4 Secondary Chilled Water Pump (standby) concourse level NA 1750 rpm 25 bhp 1 0 314 Yes 75 78 79 79 78 75 72 67 3 1750 rpm, 25 bhp 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 014 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Intake Fans (100% fan speed) 4th fl., Intake Plenum north façade 200,000 cfm 4 2 436 Yes 97 104 103 91 96 107 105 100 Lw Howden Buffalo, REV 100 107 106 94 99 110 108 103

(without silencer) (50% capacity) 109 122 125 127 125 121 115 109 LwConical Silencer (6 to 8ft. Length) 12 18 22 36 29 14 10 9

15 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Ex Fans 4th fl., Exhaust Plenumnorth façade 200,000 cfm 0 0 436 Yes 97 100 100 88 95 105 103 99 Lw Howden Buffalo, FWD 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0(without silencer) 109 118 122 124 124 119 113 108 LwConical Silencer (6 to 8ft. Length) 12 18 22 36 29 14 10 9

16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 3rd fl. north façade 1400 cfm 3 3 414 Yes 48 50 43 43 38 33 30 29 Lw Centrifugal Radial, 1000 rpm 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34Note:TVF intakes or exhausts air depending on which mode (Forward or Reverse Mode)GEN exhaust assumed pipe exits through roof, extending approx. 21.5 ft. above roof (similar to 3/04 analysis)50th Street Facility with Through Drive = "Altnerative 6D"

Operation Schedule: Daytime Off-Peak Load2 CT at 80% capacityNo GENNO GEN exhaustNo MAF2 CH/CHP/CWP at 80% capacity2 TVF at 100% fan speed, 50% capacity (assumed Forward Mode)

Number of Units Octave Band Sound Power Levels or Sound Pressure Levels at Specified Distance (dB Octave Band Sound Power Levels (dB)

OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Daytime Operation, Off-Peak LoadSOUND SOURCE SUMMARYNumber Tag Equipment Height of Enclosed Receptor

Source Yes/No 63 125 250 500 1k 2k 4k #

ROOFTOP1 CT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) 511.98 No 97 91 85 85 83 82 77 64 R61 CT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) 511.98 No 98 92 86 86 84 83 78 65 R71 CT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) 511.98 No 93 85 80 79 76 74 68 55 R81 CT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) 511.98 No 94 86 81 80 77 75 69 56 R9

INDOORS2 GEN-1,2 Generator 475.41 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

3 GEN-EX-1,2 Generator Exhaust 488.16 No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

4 MAF-1,2,3,4 Makeup Fans (Gen.) 475.41 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

5 HV-4,5,6,7 Vent Fans 457.16 Yes 54 56 49 49 44 39 36 356 CWP-1,2,3 Condenser Pumps (2 at 80% capacity) 313.55 Yes 90 91 93 93 96 93 89 837 CWP-5 Condenser Pump (standby) 313.55 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08 CH-1,2,3 Chillers (2 at 80% capacity) 313.55 Yes 100 101 102 99 101 101 97 909 CH-4 Chiller (nighttime use only) 313.55 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

10 CHP-1,2,3 Primary Chilled Water Pumps (2 at 80% capacity) 313.55 Yes 81 84 85 85 84 81 78 7311 CHP-4 Primary Chilled Water Pump (standby) 313.55 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 012 CHS-1,2,3 Secondary Chilled Water Pumps (2 at 80% capacity 313.55 Yes 94 97 98 98 97 94 91 8613 CHS-4 Secondary Chilled Water Pump (standby) 313.55 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 014 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Intake Fans (100% fan speed) 435.66 Yes 100 107 106 94 99 110 108 103

15 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Ex Fans 435.66 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 413.91 Yes 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34

Octave Band Sound Power Levels (dB)

RECEPTOR 6: COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 1-story above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Off-Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded

inside by Distance 63 125 250 500 1k 2k 4k 8k 63 125 250 500 1k 2k 4k 8kEquipment structure structure 63 125 250 500 1k 2k 4k 8k X Y Z X Y Z (feet) 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 1 3 5 9 23 30

ROOFTOP1 CT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) No No 97 91 85 85 83 82 77 64 48 62 512 78 50 503 34 31 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 63 57 51 51 49 48 43 30

INDOORS2 GEN-1,2 Generator Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 34 71 475 78 50 503 56 36 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

3 GEN-EX-1,2 Generator Exhaust No No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 34 71 488 78 50 503 51 35 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

4 MAF-1,2,3,4 Makeup Fans (Gen.) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 43 30 475 78 50 503 49 34 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

5 HV-4,5,6,7 Vent Fans Yes No 54 56 49 49 44 39 36 35 44 32 457 78 50 503 60 36 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 06 CWP-1,2,3 Condenser Pumps (2 at 80% capacity) Yes No 90 91 93 93 96 93 89 83 12 75 314 78 50 503 202 47 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 20 16 19 12 11 1 0 07 CWP-5 Condenser Pump (standby) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 43 26 314 78 50 503 194 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08 CH-1,2,3 Chillers (2 at 80% capacity) Yes No 100 101 102 99 101 101 97 90 36 82 314 78 50 503 197 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 31 27 28 18 16 9 0 09 CH-4 Chiller (nighttime use only) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 34 22 314 78 50 503 196 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

10 CHP-1,2,3 Primary Chilled Water Pumps (2 at 80% capacity) Yes No 81 84 85 85 84 81 78 73 5 85 314 78 50 503 206 47 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 11 9 11 4 0 0 0 011 CHP-4 Primary Chilled Water Pump (standby) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 85 314 78 50 503 206 47 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 012 CHS-1,2,3 Secondary Chilled Water Pumps (2 at 80% capacity Yes No 94 97 98 98 97 94 91 86 5 85 314 78 50 503 206 47 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 24 22 24 17 12 2 0 013 CHS-4 Secondary Chilled Water Pump (standby) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 85 314 78 50 503 206 47 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 014 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Intake Fans (100% fan speed) Yes No 100 107 106 94 99 110 108 103 5 85 436 78 50 503 105 41 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 36 38 38 19 20 24 12 3

15 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Ex Fans Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 85 436 78 50 503 105 41 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans Yes No 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34 21 28 414 78 50 503 108 41 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Note:Sound Pressure Level Lp = Lw - Adiv - Aatm - Aground - Ascreen - ATL - AD - 0.6 63 125 250 500 1K 2K 4K 8KDistance factor Adiv = 20logD Total Lp (dB) 62.8 56.9 51.1 50.8 48.8 47.7 42.6 29.6Air Factor Aatm = αD(m)/1000; α is the air attenuation coefficient, dB/Km, D is distance from source to receiver (see Table 15.1 in Handbook of Acoustical Measurements and Noise Control, Cyril M. Harris). Total Lp (dBA) 36.6 40.8 42.5 47.6 48.8 48.9 43.6 28.5 54.3 dBAAground = the sound reduction due to the effects of hard ground (see Table 15.2 in The Noise Manual, E.H. Berger and ...).Ascreen = Assuming 5dBA screen effect is based upon buildings and any structures blocking the view between sound sources and receivers (see P48.14 in Handbook of Acoustical Measurements and Noise Control, Cyril M. Harris). FTA CriteriaTransmission Loss factor ATL based on sound transmission loss of concrete masonry units (see P372 in Noise Control Manual for Residential Buildings, David A. Harris). Result

Existing Project Build Impact Severe ImpactCategory 3 Leq

Daytime 63.2 54.3 63.7 64.7 70.1 No Impact

Threshold of Impact - Land Use Category 3

LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70

Threshold of Severe Impact - Land Use Category 3

LE<44 Lp= 22.322+0.940LE44<=LE<=77 Lp= 101.725 - 1.992LE + 3.02x10-2LE

2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80

125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4kSource Location Receptor Location

dB 63

Noise Level FTA Criteria

Basic Octave Band Sound Power Level (Lw)Distance factor (Adiv) = 20logD+0.6 Shielding

factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)

Transmission Loss factor (ATL) Air factor (Aatm) Octave Band Sound Pressure Level (dB) at receptor

RECEPTOR 7: ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 1-story above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Off-Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded


ROOFTOP1 CT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) No No 98 92 86 86 84 83 78 65 48 62 512 -1 50 503 51 35 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 60 54 48 48 46 45 39 26

INDOORS2 GEN-1,2 Generator Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 34 71 475 -1 50 503 49 34 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

3 GEN-EX-1,2 Generator Exhaust No No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 34 71 488 -1 50 503 43 33 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

4 MAF-1,2,3,4 Makeup Fans (Gen.) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 43 30 475 -1 50 503 56 36 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

5 HV-4,5,6,7 Vent Fans Yes No 54 56 49 49 44 39 36 35 44 32 457 -1 50 503 67 37 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 06 CWP-1,2,3 Condenser Pumps (2 at 80% capacity) Yes No 90 91 93 93 96 93 89 83 12 75 314 -1 50 503 192 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 21 17 20 13 12 1 0 07 CWP-5 Condenser Pump (standby) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 43 26 314 -1 50 503 196 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08 CH-1,2,3 Chillers (2 at 80% capacity) Yes No 100 101 102 99 101 101 97 90 36 82 314 -1 50 503 196 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 31 27 29 18 16 9 0 09 CH-4 Chiller (nighttime use only) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 34 22 314 -1 50 503 195 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

10 CHP-1,2,3 Primary Chilled Water Pumps (2 at 80% capacity) Yes No 81 84 85 85 84 81 78 73 5 85 314 -1 50 503 193 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 12 10 12 5 0 0 0 011 CHP-4 Primary Chilled Water Pump (standby) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 85 314 -1 50 503 193 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 012 CHS-1,2,3 Secondary Chilled Water Pumps (2 at 80% capacity Yes No 94 97 98 98 97 94 91 86 5 85 314 -1 50 503 193 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 25 23 25 18 13 2 0 013 CHS-4 Secondary Chilled Water Pump (standby) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 85 314 -1 50 503 193 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 014 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Intake Fans (100% fan speed) Yes No 100 107 106 94 99 110 108 103 5 85 436 -1 50 503 76 38 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 39 41 41 22 23 27 15 6

15 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Ex Fans Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 85 436 -1 50 503 76 38 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans Yes No 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34 21 28 414 -1 50 503 94 40 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Note:Sound Pressure Level Lp = Lw - Adiv - Aatm - Aground - Ascreen - ATL - AD - 0.6 63 125 250 500 1K 2K 4K 8KDistance factor Adiv = 20logD Total Lp (dB) 59.8 54.0 48.6 47.7 45.7 44.7 39.4 26.4Air Factor Aatm = αD(m)/1000; α is the air attenuation coefficient, dB/Km, D is distance from source to receiver (see Table 15.1 in Handbook of Acoustical Measurements and Noise Control, Cyril M. Harris). Total Lp (dBA) 33.6 37.9 40.0 44.5 45.7 45.9 40.4 25.3 51.3 dBAAground = the sound reduction due to the effects of hard ground (see Table 15.2 in The Noise Manual, E.H. Berger and ...).Ascreen = Assuming 5dBA screen effect is based upon buildings and any structures blocking the view between sound sources and receivers (see P48.14 in Handbook of Acoustical Measurements and Noise Control, Cyril M. Harris). FTA CriteriaTransmission Loss factor ATL based on sound transmission loss of concrete masonry units (see P372 in Noise Control Manual for Residential Buildings, David A. Harris).




LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)

Transmission Loss factor (ATL) Air factor (Aatm) Octave Band Sound Pressure Level (dB) at receptorSource Location Receptor Location

dB 63 125 250 8k

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria

RECEPTOR 8: COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 2-stories above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Off-Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k

RECEPTOR 9: ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 2-stories above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Off-Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria


dB 63 125 250 8kBasic Octave Band Sound Power Level (Lw)

Distance factor (Adiv) = 20logD+0.6 Shielding factor

(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)

FTA Land Use CategoriesLand Use Category Noise Metric (dBA) Description of Land Use Category

1 Outdoor Leq(h)* Outdoor land uses such as concert pavilions, National Historic landmarks with significiant outdoor use.2 Outdoor Ldn Residences and buildings where peopole normally sleep, including hospitals, hotels.

3 Outdoor Leq(h)*Note: * for noisiest hour of transit-related activity during hours of noise sensitivity.

FTA Criteria - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Daytime Operation, Off-Peak LoadReceptor Location Existing Build ResultSite Ambient Leq

(dBA) (dBA)(Leq or Ldn) (Leq or Ldn) Impact Severe Impact

R6 COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 1-story above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Off-Peak Load) Cat 3 Leq 63.2 54.3 63.7 64.7 70.1 No ImpactR7 ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 1-story above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Off-Peak Load) Cat 3 Leq 63.2 51.3 63.5 70.1 70.1 No ImpactR8 COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 2-stories above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Off-Peak Loa Cat 3 Leq 63.2 47.8 63.3 64.7 70.1 No ImpactR9 ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 2-stories above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Off-Peak Load) Cat 3 Leq 63.2 44.8 63.3 64.7 70.1 No Impact

Institutional land uses including schools and churches. Buildings with interior spaces where quiet is important such as conference rooms.

FTA Category

Predicted Project Noise Exposure

LevelAllowable Project Noise

Exposure Level

Leq or Ldn

24-hr. Measured Noise Levels (rooftop) -weekday

Hour Ending Leq Leq+10 dB 10^Leq/101:00 AM 64.7 74.70 295120922:00 AM 63.4 73.40 218776163:00 AM 63.0 73.00 199526234:00 AM 63.9 73.90 245470895:00 AM 63.1 73.10 204173796:00 AM 63.0 73.00 199526237:00 AM 64.5 74.50 281838298:00 AM 66.0 66.00 3981071.79:00 AM 67.2 67.20 5248074.610:00 AM 68.0 68.00 6309573.411:00 AM 67.7 67.70 5888436.6Noon 68.2 68.20 6606934.51:00 PM 68.7 68.70 7413102.42:00 PM 67.9 67.90 61659503:00 PM 68.0 68.00 6309573.44:00 PM 68.1 68.10 6456542.35:00 PM 69.0 69.00 7943282.36:00 PM 68.2 68.20 6606934.57:00 PM 68.3 68.30 6760829.88:00 PM 68.1 68.10 6456542.39:00 PM 67.1 67.10 5128613.810:00 PM 67.1 67.10 5128613.811:00 PM 66.3 76.30 42657952Midnight 66.7 76.70 46773514Sum 346278794Ldn dBA 71.6

OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Daytime Operation, Off-Peak LoadEQUIPMENT LISTNumber Tag Equipment Location Location of louver or Capacity Size Height of Enclosed Distance Notes

air opening to outside (hp) Total Active Source Yes/No 63 125 250 500 1k 2k 4k 8k (feet) 63 125 250 500 1k 2k 4k 8k

ROOFTOP1 CT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) Roof NA 230 rpm 60 hp 3 2 512 No 78 72 66 63 61 60 55 42 5 Marley, Model NC8312JL1 96 90 84 81 79 78 73 60

79 76 73 73 71 70 65 52 51 4 7 10 10 10 10 10 60° directivity









16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 3rd fl. north façade 1400 cfm 3 3 414 Yes 48 50 43 43 38 33 30 29 Lw Centrifugal Radial, 1000 rpm 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34Note:TVF intakes or exhausts air depending on which mode (Forward or Reverse Mode)GEN exhaust assumed pipe exits through roof, extending approx. 21.5 ft. above roof (similar to 3/04 analysis)50th Street Facility with Through Drive = "Altnerative 6D"



OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Daytime Operation, Off-Peak LoadSOUND SOURCE SUMMARYNumber Tag Equipment Height of Enclosed

Source Yes/No 63 125 250 500 1k 2k 4k 8k

ROOFTOP1 CT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) 511.98 No 96 90 84 81 79 78 73 60





10 CHP-1,2,3 Primary Chilled Water Pumps (2 at 80% capacity) 313.55 Yes 81 84 85 85 84 81 78 7311 CHP-4 Primary Chilled Water Pump (standby) 313.55 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 012 CHS-1,2,3 Secondary Chilled Water Pumps (2 at 80% capacity 313.55 Yes 94 97 98 98 97 94 91 8613 CHS-4 Secondary Chilled Water Pump (standby) 313.55 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 014 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Intake Fans (100% fan speed) 435.66 Yes 100 107 106 94 99 110 108 103


16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 413.91 Yes 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34


RECEPTOR 1: COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST (Daytime Operation, Off-Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k

RECEPTOR 2: ITT AMERICAS TOWARD WEST (Daytime Operation, Off-Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)

RECEPTOR 3: SIDEWALK ADJACENT TOWARD NORTH (Daytime Operation, Off-Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded









16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans Yes No 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34 21 28 414 39 114 363 102 41 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Note:Sound Pressure Level Lp = Lw - Adiv - Aatm - Aground - Ascreen - ATL - AD - 0.6 63 125 250 500 1K 2K 4K 8KDistance factor Adiv = 20logD Total Lp (dB) 49.3 45.1 44.0 35.5 33.3 31.5 24.6 14.6Air Factor Aatm = αD(m)/1000; α is the air attenuation coefficient, dB/Km, D is distance from source to receiver (see Table 15.1 in Handbook of Acoustical Measurements and Noise Control, Cyril M. Harris). Total Lp (dBA) 23.1 29.0 35.4 32.3 33.3 32.7 25.6 13.5 40.2 dBAAground = the sound reduction due to the effects of hard ground (see Table 15.2 in The Noise Manual, E.H. Berger and ...).Ascreen = Assuming 5dBA screen effect is based upon buildings and any structures blocking the view between sound sources and receivers (see P48.14 in Handbook of Acoustical Measurements and Noise Control, Cyril M. Harris). FTA CriteriaTransmission Loss factor ATL based on sound transmission loss of concrete masonry units (see P372 in Noise Control Manual for Residential Buildings, David A. Harris).


Daytime 74.3 40.2 74.3 70.0 77.7 No ImpactFTA Criteria


LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 72.8LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 77.7

LE >77 Lp= 80

Result


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)

Transmission Loss factor (ATL) Air factor (Aatm) Octave Band Sound Pressure Level (dB) at receptorSource Location

Noise Level

dB 63Receptor Location

4k

FTA Criteria

125 250 8k500 1k 2k

RECEPTOR 4: SIDEWALK ACROSS 50TH STREET TOWARD NORTH (Daytime Operation, Off-Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded










Existing Project Build Impact Severe ImpactCategory 2 Ldn

24-hr 71.6 38.9 71.6 65.0 70.6 No Impact


LE<42 Lp= 11.450+0.953LE42<=LE<=71 Lp= 71.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE

2 - 4.088x10-5LE3 = 65.6

LE >71 Lp= 65



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.6

LE >77 Lp= 75

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)

RECEPTOR 5: HOTEL ELEVATED RECEPTOR ACROSS 50TH STREET TOWARD NORTH (Daytime Operation, Off-Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded











24-hr 71.6 42.9 71.6 65.0 70.6 No Impact


LE<42 Lp= 11.450+0.953LE42<=LE<=71 Lp= 71.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE

2 - 4.088x10-5LE3 = 65.6

LE >71 Lp= 65



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.6

LE >77 Lp= 75

Result


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


Noise Level


4k

FTA Criteria

125 250 8k500 1k 2k




FTA Criteria - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Daytime Operation, Off-Peak LoadReceptor Location Existing Build ResultSite Ambient Leq


R1 Colgate-Palmolive Building (east) Cat 3 Leq 63.2 49.6 63.4 64.7 70.1 No ImpactR2 ITT Americas Building (west) Cat 3 Leq 63.2 46.7 63.3 70.1 70.1 No ImpactR3 Sidewalk Adjacent (north) Cat 3 Leq 74.3 40.2 74.3 74.3 77.7 No ImpactR4 Sidewalk Across 50th Street (north) Cat 4 Ldn 71.6 38.9 71.6 65.0 70.6 No Impact

R5Hotel Elevated Receptor Across 50th Street (north) Cat 4 Ldn 71.6 42.9 71.6 65.0 70.6 No Impact


FTA Category



Exposure Level

Leq or Ldn



Sound Data Comparison

Cooling Tower 63 125 250 500 1000 2000 4000 8000 A-w1 CT SPL at 5ft. (100% capacity) 83 80 77 77 75 74 69 56 87

(80% capacity) -4 -4 -4 -4 -4 -4 -4 -41 CT (80% capacity) 79 76 73 73 71 70 65 523 CT 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 53 CT (80% capacity) 84 81 78 78 76 75 70 57 88

1 CT SPL at 5ft. (100% capacity) 83 80 77 77 75 74 69 56 872 CT 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 32 CT (100% capacity) 86 83 80 80 78 77 72 59 90

2 CT at 100% capacity is louder than 3 CT at 80% capacity, therefore better to have more CTs and operate them at reduced capacity.

OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Daytime Operation, Peak LoadEQUIPMENT LISTNumber Tag Equipment Location Location of louver or Capacity Size Height of Enclosed Distance Notes



79 76 73 73 71 70 65 52 51 4 7 10 10 10 10 10 60° directivity






10 CHP-1,2,3 Primary Chilled Water Pumps (3 at 80% capacity) concourse level NA 2000 gpm 32 bhp 3 3 314 Yes 68 71 72 72 71 68 65 60 3 1160 rpm, 32 bhp 83 86 87 87 86 83 80 7511 CHP-4 Primary Chilled Water Pump (standby) concourse level NA 1160 rpm 12 bhp 1 0 314 Yes 72 75 76 76 75 72 69 64 3 1160 rpm, 12 bhp 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 012 CHS-1,2,3 Secondary Chilled Water Pumps (3 at 80% capacit concourse level NA 2500 gpm 150 bhp 3 3 314 Yes 81 84 85 85 84 81 78 73 3 1750 rpm, 150 bhp 96 99 100 100 99 96 93 8813 CHS-4 Secondary Chilled Water Pump (standby) concourse level NA 1750 rpm 25 bhp 1 0 314 Yes 75 78 79 79 78 75 72 67 3 1750 rpm, 25 bhp 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 014 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Intake Fans (100% fan speed) 4th fl., Intake Plenum north façade 200,000 cfm 4 2 436 Yes 97 104 103 91 96 107 105 100 Lw Howden Buffalo, REV 100 107 106 94 99 110 108 103



16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 3rd fl. north façade 1400 cfm 3 3 414 Yes 48 50 43 43 38 33 30 29 Lw Centrifugal Radial, 1000 rpm 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34Note:TVF intakes or exhausts air depending on which mode (Forward or Reverse Mode)GEN exhaust assumed pipe exits through roof, extending approx. 21.5 ft. above roof (similar to 3/04 analysis)50th Street Facility with Throught Drive = "Alternative 6D"

Operation Schedule: Daytime Peak Load3 CT at 80% capacityNo GENNO GEN exhaustNo MAF3 CH/CHP/CWP at 80% capacity2 TVF at 100% fan speed, 50% capacity, (assumed Forward Mode)


OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Daytime Operation, Peak LoadSOUND SOURCE SUMMARYNumber Tag Equipment Height of Enclosed







10 CHP-1,2,3 Primary Chilled Water Pumps (3 at 80% ca 313.55 Yes 83 86 87 87 86 83 80 7511 CHP-4 Primary Chilled Water Pump (standby) 313.55 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 012 CHS-1,2,3 Secondary Chilled Water Pumps (3 at 80% 313.55 Yes 96 99 100 100 99 96 93 8813 CHS-4 Secondary Chilled Water Pump (standby) 313.55 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 014 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Intake Fans (100% fan speed 435.66 Yes 100 107 106 94 99 110 108 103


16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 413.91 Yes 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34


RECEPTOR 1: COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST (Daytime Operation, Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded







10 CHP-1,2,3 Primary Chilled Water Pumps (3 at 80% capacity) Yes No 83 86 87 87 86 83 80 75 5 85 314 78 50 493 197 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 13 11 13 6 1 0 0 011 CHP-4 Primary Chilled Water Pump (standby) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 85 314 78 50 493 197 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 012 CHS-1,2,3 Secondary Chilled Water Pumps (3 at 80% capacit Yes No 96 99 100 100 99 96 93 88 5 85 314 78 50 493 197 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 26 24 26 19 14 4 0 013 CHS-4 Secondary Chilled Water Pump (standby) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 85 314 78 50 493 197 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 014 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Intake Fans (100% fan speed) Yes No 100 107 106 94 99 110 108 103 5 85 436 78 50 493 99 41 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 36 38 38 19 20 24 13 4






LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80


dB 63



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


RECEPTOR 2: ITT AMERICAS TOWARD WEST (Daytime Operation, Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded







10 CHP-1,2,3 Primary Chilled Water Pumps (3 at 80% capacity) Yes No 83 86 87 87 86 83 80 75 5 85 314 -1 50 493 183 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 14 12 14 7 2 0 0 011 CHP-4 Primary Chilled Water Pump (standby) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 85 314 -1 50 493 183 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 012 CHS-1,2,3 Secondary Chilled Water Pumps (3 at 80% capacit Yes No 96 99 100 100 99 96 93 88 5 85 314 -1 50 493 183 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 27 25 27 20 15 5 0 013 CHS-4 Secondary Chilled Water Pump (standby) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 85 314 -1 50 493 183 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 014 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Intake Fans (100% fan speed) Yes No 100 107 106 94 99 110 108 103 5 85 436 -1 50 493 68 37 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 40 42 42 23 24 28 16 7






LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria

RECEPTOR 3: SIDEWALK ADJACENT TOWARD NORTH (Daytime Operation, Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 72.8LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 77.7

LE >77 Lp= 80


dB 63

FTA CriteriaNoise LevelResult


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


RECEPTOR 4: SIDEWALK ACROSS 50TH STREET TOWARD NORTH (Daytime Operation, Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded











24-hr 71.6 40.3 71.6 65.0 70.6 No Impact


LE<42 Lp= 11.450+0.953LE42<=LE<=71 Lp= 71.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE

2 - 4.088x10-5LE3 = 65.6

LE >71 Lp= 65



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.6

LE >77 Lp= 75


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria

RECEPTOR 5: HOTEL ELEVATED RECEPTOR ACROSS 50TH STREET TOWARD NORTH (Daytime Operation, Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded











24-hr 71.6 44.5 71.6 65.0 70.6 No Impact


LE<42 Lp= 11.450+0.953LE42<=LE<=71 Lp= 71.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE

2 - 4.088x10-5LE3 = 65.6

LE >71 Lp= 65



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.6

LE >77 Lp= 75


dB 63



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)





FTA Criteria - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Daytime Operation, Peak LoadReceptor Location Existing Build ResultSite Ambient Leq







Exposure Level

FTA Category

Leq or Ldn


Hour Ending Leq Leq+10 dB10^Leq/101:00 AM 64.7 74.70 295120922:00 AM 63.4 73.40 218776163:00 AM 63.0 73.00 199526234:00 AM 63.9 73.90 245470895:00 AM 63.1 73.10 204173796:00 AM 63.0 73.00 199526237:00 AM 64.5 74.50 281838298:00 AM 66.0 66.00 3981071.79:00 AM 67.2 67.20 5248074.610:00 AM 68.0 68.00 6309573.411:00 AM 67.7 67.70 5888436.6Noon 68.2 68.20 6606934.51:00 PM 68.7 68.70 7413102.42:00 PM 67.9 67.90 61659503:00 PM 68.0 68.00 6309573.44:00 PM 68.1 68.10 6456542.35:00 PM 69.0 69.00 7943282.36:00 PM 68.2 68.20 6606934.57:00 PM 68.3 68.30 6760829.88:00 PM 68.1 68.10 6456542.39:00 PM 67.1 67.10 5128613.810:00 PM 67.1 67.10 5128613.811:00 PM 66.3 76.30 42657952Midnight 66.7 76.70 46773514Sum 346278794Ldn dBA 71.6

Sound Data Comparison

Cooling Tower 63 125 250 500 1000 2000 4000 8000 A-w1 CT SPL at 5ft. (100% capacity) 83 80 77 77 75 74 69 56 87

(80% capacity) -4 -4 -4 -4 -4 -4 -4 -41 CT (80% capacity) 79 76 73 73 71 70 65 523 CT 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 53 CT (80% capacity) 84 81 78 78 76 75 70 57 88

1 CT SPL at 5ft. (100% capacity) 83 80 77 77 75 74 69 56 872 CT 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 32 CT (100% capacity) 86 83 80 80 78 77 72 59 90

2 CT at 100% capacity is louder than 3 CT at 80% capacity, therefore better to have more CTs and operate them at reduced capacity

OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Daytime Operation, Peak LoadEQUIPMENT LISTNumber Tag Equipment Location Location of louver or Capacity Size Height of Enclosed Receptor Distance Notes











16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 3rd fl. north façade 1400 cfm 3 3 414 Yes 48 50 43 43 38 33 30 29 Lw Centrifugal Radial, 1000 rpm 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34Note:TVF intakes or exhausts air depending on which mode (Forward or Reverse Mode)GEN exhaust assumed pipe exits through roof, extending approx. 21.5 ft. above roof (similar to 3/04 analysis)50th Street Facility with Throught Drive = "Alternative 6D"



OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Daytime Operation, Peak LoadSOUND SOURCE SUMMARYNumber Tag Equipment Height of Enclosed Receptor

Source Yes/No 63 125 250 500 1k 2k 4k 8k #








16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 413.91 Yes 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34


RECEPTOR 6: COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 1-story above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k

RECEPTOR 7: ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 1-story above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)

RECEPTOR 8: COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 2-stories above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80


dB 63



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


RECEPTOR 9: ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 2-stories above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




FTA Criteria - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Daytime Operation, Peak LoadReceptor Location Existing Build ResultSite Ambient Leq


R6 COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 1-story above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Peak Load) Cat 3 Leq 63.2 56.0 64.0 64.7 70.1 No ImpactR7 ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 1-story above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Peak Load) Cat 3 Leq 63.2 52.9 63.6 64.7 70.1 No ImpactR8 COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 2-stories above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Peak Load) Cat 3 Leq 63.2 49.5 63.4 64.7 70.1 No ImpactR9 ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 2-stories above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Peak Load) Cat 3 Leq 63.2 46.4 63.3 64.7 70.1 No Impact




Exposure Level

FTA Category

Leq or Ldn



OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Daytime Operation, Testing ModeEQUIPMENT LISTNumber Tag Equipment Location Location of louver or Capacity Size Height of Enclosed Distance Notes



79 76 73 73 71 70 65 52 51 4 7 10 10 10 10 10 60° directivity

1a Load Bank Load Bank 2nd fl. Roof NA NA NA 1 1 386 No 79 90 87 89 89 87 89 93 Lw NA 79 90 87 89 89 87 89 93INDOORS

2 GEN-1,2 Generator 6th fl. (Z-wall design) north façade 1800 rpm 2647 bhp 2 1 475 Yes 95 95 91 86 74 78 81 81 Lw Cummins, 2MW 95 95 91 86 74 78 81 81(without treatment) 100 101 101 101 99 97 94 89 LwZ-wall return (used data for 3ft. Silencer) 5 6 10 15 25 19 13 8




10 CHP-1,2,3 Primary Chilled Water Pumps (3 at 80% capacity) concourse level NA 2000 gpm 32 bhp 3 3 314 Yes 68 71 72 72 71 68 65 60 3 1160 rpm, 32 bhp 83 86 87 87 86 83 80 7511 CHP-4 Primary Chilled Water Pump (standby) concourse level NA 1160 rpm 12 bhp 1 0 314 Yes 72 75 76 76 75 72 69 64 3 1160 rpm, 12 bhp 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 012 CHS-1,2,3 Secondary Chilled Water Pumps (3 at 80% capacitconcourse level NA 2500 gpm 150 bhp 3 3 314 Yes 81 84 85 85 84 81 78 73 3 1750 rpm, 150 bhp 96 99 100 100 99 96 93 8813 CHS-4 Secondary Chilled Water Pump (standby) concourse level NA 1750 rpm 25 bhp 1 0 314 Yes 75 78 79 79 78 75 72 67 3 1750 rpm, 25 bhp 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 014 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Intake Fans (100% fan speed) 4th fl., Intake Plenum north façade 200,000 cfm 4 2 436 Yes 97 104 103 91 96 107 105 100 Lw Howden Buffalo, REV 100 107 106 94 99 110 108 103



16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 3rd fl. north façade 1400 cfm 3 3 414 Yes 48 50 43 43 38 33 30 29 Lw Centrifugal Radial, 1000 rpm 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34Note:TVF intakes or exhausts air depending on which mode (Forward or Reverse Mode)GEN exhaust assumed pipe exits through roof, extending approx. 21.5 ft. above roof (similar to 3/04 analysis)50th Street Facility with Through Drive = "Alternative 6D"

Operation Schedule: Daytime Testing Mode3 CT at 80% capacity1 GEN (2 GEN tested sequentially) GEN exhaust2 MAF3 CH/CHP/CWP at 80%2 TVF at 100% fan speed, 50% capacity, (assumed Forward Mode)Load Bank


OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Daytime Operation, Testing ModeSOUND SOURCE SUMMARYNumber Tag Equipment Height of Enclosed



1a Load Bank Load Bank 385.66 No 79 90 87 89 89 87 89 93INDOORS

2 GEN-1,2 Generator 475.41 Yes 95 95 91 86 74 78 81 81






16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 413.91 Yes 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34


RECEPTOR 1: COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST (Daytime Operation, Testing Mode)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded



1a Load Bank Load Bank No No 79 90 87 89 89 87 89 93 44 10 386 78 50 493 120 42 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 34 45 42 44 44 42 43 47INDOORS

2 GEN-1,2 Generator Yes No 95 95 91 86 74 78 81 81 34 71 475 78 50 493 52 35 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 37 32 29 17 1 0 0 0










LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 65.5LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.9

LE >77 Lp= 80



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k

RECEPTOR 2: ITT AMERICAS TOWARD WEST (Daytime Operation, Testing Mode)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded




2 GEN-1,2 Generator Yes No 95 95 91 86 74 78 81 81 34 71 475 -1 50 493 45 34 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 38 33 30 18 2 0 0 0










LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 65.5LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.9

LE >77 Lp= 80

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)

RECEPTOR 3: SIDEWALK ADJACENT TOWARD NORTH (Daytime Operation, Testing Mode)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded














LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 72.8LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 77.7

LE >77 Lp= 80

Result


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


Noise Level


4k

FTA Criteria

125 250 8k500 1k 2k

RECEPTOR 4: SIDEWALK ACROSS 50TH STREET TOWARD NORTH (Daytime Operation, Testing Mode)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded












24-hr 71.6 52.3 71.6 65.0 70.6 No Impact


LE<42 Lp= 11.450+0.953LE42<=LE<=71 Lp= 71.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE

2 - 4.088x10-5LE3 = 65.6

LE >71 Lp= 65



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.6

LE >77 Lp= 75

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)

RECEPTOR 5: HOTEL ELEVATED RECEPTOR ACROSS 50TH STREET TOWARD NORTH (Daytime Operation, Testing Mode)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded












24-hr 71.6 54.8 71.7 65.0 70.6 No Impact


LE<42 Lp= 11.450+0.953LE42<=LE<=71 Lp= 71.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE

2 - 4.088x10-5LE3 = 65.6

LE >71 Lp= 65



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.6

LE >77 Lp= 75

Result


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


Noise Level


4k

FTA Criteria

125 250 8k500 1k 2k




FTA Criteria - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Daytime Operation, Testing ModeReceptor Location Existing Build ResultSite Ambient Leq





FTA Category

Leq or Ldn



Exposure Level


Hour Ending Leq Leq+10 dB 10^Leq/101:00 AM 64.70 74.70 295120922:00 AM 63.4 73.40 218776163:00 AM 63 73.00 199526234:00 AM 63.9 73.90 245470895:00 AM 63.1 73.10 204173796:00 AM 63 73.00 199526237:00 AM 64.5 74.50 281838298:00 AM 66 66.00 3981071.79:00 AM 67.2 67.20 5248074.610:00 AM 68 68.00 6309573.411:00 AM 67.7 67.70 5888436.6Noon 68.2 68.20 6606934.51:00 PM 68.7 68.70 7413102.42:00 PM 67.9 67.90 61659503:00 PM 68 68.00 6309573.44:00 PM 68.1 68.10 6456542.35:00 PM 69 69.00 7943282.36:00 PM 68.2 68.20 6606934.57:00 PM 68.3 68.30 6760829.88:00 PM 68.1 68.10 6456542.39:00 PM 67.1 67.10 5128613.810:00 PM 67.1 67.10 5128613.811:00 PM 66.3 76.30 42657952Midnight 66.7 76.70 46773514Sum 346278794Ldn dBA 71.6

OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Daytime Operation, Testing ModeEQUIPMENT LISTNumber Tag Equipment Location Location of louver or Capacity Size Height of Enclosed Receptor Distance Notes








10 CHP-1,2,3 Primary Chilled Water Pumps (3 at 80% capacity) concourse level NA 2000 gpm 32 bhp 3 3 314 Yes 68 71 72 72 71 68 65 60 3 1160 rpm, 32 bhp 83 86 87 87 86 83 80 7511 CHP-4 Primary Chilled Water Pump (standby) concourse level NA 1160 rpm 12 bhp 1 0 314 Yes 72 75 76 76 75 72 69 64 3 1160 rpm, 12 bhp 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 012 CHS-1,2,3 Secondary Chilled Water Pumps (3 at 80% capacitconcourse level NA 2500 gpm 150 bhp 3 3 314 Yes 81 84 85 85 84 81 78 73 3 1750 rpm, 150 bhp 96 99 100 100 99 96 93 8813 CHS-4 Secondary Chilled Water Pump (standby) concourse level NA 1750 rpm 25 bhp 1 0 314 Yes 75 78 79 79 78 75 72 67 3 1750 rpm, 25 bhp 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 014 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Intake Fans (100% fan speed) 4th fl., Intake Plenum north façade 200,000 cfm 4 2 436 Yes 97 104 103 91 96 107 105 100 Lw Howden Buffalo, REV 100 107 106 94 99 110 108 103



16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 3rd fl. north façade 1400 cfm 3 3 414 Yes 48 50 43 43 38 33 30 29 Lw Centrifugal Radial, 1000 rpm 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34Note:TVF intakes or exhausts air depending on which mode (Forward or Reverse Mode)GEN exhaust assumed pipe exits through roof, extending approx. 21.5 ft. above roof (similar to 3/04 analysis)50th Street Facility with Through Drive = "Alternative 6D"



OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Daytime Operation, Testing ModeSOUND SOURCE SUMMARYNumber Tag Equipment Height of Enclosed Receptor



1a Load Bank Load Bank 385.66 No 79 90 87 89 89 87 89 93INDOORS

2 GEN-1,2 Generator 475.41 Yes 95 95 91 86 74 78 81 81






16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 413.91 Yes 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34


RECEPTOR 6: COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 1-story above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Testing Mode)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded














LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 65.5LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.9

LE >77 Lp= 80



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k

RECEPTOR 7: ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 1-story above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Testing Mode)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded














LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 65.5LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.9

LE >77 Lp= 80

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)

RECEPTOR 8: COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 2-stories above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Testing Mode)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded














LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 65.5LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.9

LE >77 Lp= 80


dB 63



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


RECEPTOR 9: ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 2-stories above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Testing Mode)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded














LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 65.5LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.9

LE >77 Lp= 80


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




FTA Criteria - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Daytime Operation, Testing ModeReceptor Location Existing Build ResultSite Ambient Leq


R6 COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 1-story above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Testing Mode) Cat 3 Leq 64.5 59.2 65.6 65.5 70.9 No ImpactR7 ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 1-story above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Testing Mode) Cat 3 Leq 64.5 58.8 65.5 65.5 70.9 No ImpactR8 COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 2-stories above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Testing Mode) Cat 3 Leq 64.5 56.7 65.2 65.5 70.9 No ImpactR9 ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 2-stories above cooling tower (Daytime Operation, Testing Mode) Cat 3 Leq 64.5 57.1 65.2 65.5 70.9 No Impact


FTA Category

Leq or Ldn



Exposure Level

OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak LoadEQUIPMENT LISTNumber Tag Equipment Location Location of louver or Capacity Size Height of Enclosed Receptor Distance Notes







5 HV-4,5,6,7 Vent Fans 5th fl., south north façade 1400 cfm 4 4 457 Yes 48 50 43 43 38 33 30 29 Lw Centrifugal Radial, 1000 rpm 54 56 49 49 44 39 36 356 CWP-1,2,3 Condenser Pumps (1 at 80% capacity) concourse level NA 3000 gpm 76 hp 3 1 314 Yes 77 78 80 80 83 80 76 70 3 76bhp, 1760rpm 87 88 90 90 93 90 86 807 CWP-5 Condenser Pump (standby) concourse level NA 600 gpm 25 hp 1 0 314 Yes 75 78 79 79 78 75 72 67 3 1750 rpm, 17 bhp 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08 CH-1,2,3 Chillers concourse level NA 1000 tons 3 0 314 Yes 101 102 103 100 102 102 98 91 Lw NY Trane CSO 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 09 CH-4 Chiller (nighttime use only) (80% capacity) concourse level NA 200 tons 1 1 314 Yes 97 98 99 96 98 98 94 87 Lw Trane 97 98 99 96 98 98 94 87




16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 3rd fl. north façade 1400 cfm 3 3 414 Yes 48 50 43 43 38 33 30 29 Lw Centrifugal Radial, 1000 rpm 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34Note:TVF intakes or exhausts air depending on which mode (Forward or Reverse Mode)GEN exhaust assumed pipe exits through roof, extending approx. 21.5 ft. above roof (similar to 3/04 analysis)50th Street Facility with Through Drive = " Alternative 6D"

Operation Schedule: Nighttime Off-Peak1 CT at 80% capacity (assumed summer-worse case, winter 1 CT at 25% capacity)No GENNO GEN exhaustNo MAF1 CHP/CWP at 80% capacity1 TVF at 100% fan speed, 25% capacity (assumed Forward Mode)1 Chiller 80% Capacity


OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak LoadSOUND SOURCE SUMMARYNumber Tag Equipment Height of Enclosed Receptor






5 HV-4,5,6,7 Vent Fans 457.16 Yes 54 56 49 49 44 39 36 356 CWP-1,2,3 Condenser Pumps (1 at 80% capacity) 313.55 Yes 87 88 90 90 93 90 86 807 CWP-5 Condenser Pump (standby) 313.55 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08 CH-1,2,3 Chillers 313.55 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 09 CH-4 Chiller (nighttime use only) (80% capacity) 313.55 Yes 97 98 99 96 98 98 94 87

10 CHP-1,2,3 Primary Chilled Water Pumps (1 at 80% capacity) 313.55 Yes 78 81 82 82 81 78 75 7011 CHP-4 Primary Chilled Water Pump (standby) 313.55 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 012 CHS-1,2,3 Secondary Chilled Water Pumps (1 at 80% capacity) 313.55 Yes 91 94 95 95 94 91 88 8313 CHS-4 Secondary Chilled Water Pump (standby) 313.55 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 014 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Intake Fans (100% fan speed) 435.66 Yes 97 104 103 91 96 107 105 100


16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 413.91 Yes 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34


RECEPTOR 6: COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 1-story above cooling tower (Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded






5 HV-4,5,6,7 Vent Fans Yes No 54 56 49 49 44 39 36 35 44 32 457 78 50 503 60 36 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 06 CWP-1,2,3 Condenser Pumps (1 at 80% capacity) Yes No 87 88 90 90 93 90 86 80 12 75 314 78 50 503 202 47 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 17 13 16 9 8 0 0 07 CWP-5 Condenser Pump (standby) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 43 26 314 78 50 503 194 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08 CH-1,2,3 Chillers Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 36 82 314 78 50 503 197 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 09 CH-4 Chiller (nighttime use only) (80% capacity) Yes No 97 98 99 96 98 98 94 87 34 22 314 78 50 503 196 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 28 24 25 15 13 6 0 0







LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.6LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.0

LE >77 Lp= 80


dB 63



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


RECEPTOR 7: ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 1-story above cooling tower (Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded






5 HV-4,5,6,7 Vent Fans Yes No 54 56 49 49 44 39 36 35 44 32 457 -1 50 503 67 37 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 06 CWP-1,2,3 Condenser Pumps (1 at 80% capacity) Yes No 87 88 90 90 93 90 86 80 12 75 314 -1 50 503 192 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 18 14 17 10 9 0 0 07 CWP-5 Condenser Pump (standby) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 43 26 314 -1 50 503 196 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08 CH-1,2,3 Chillers Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 36 82 314 -1 50 503 196 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 09 CH-4 Chiller (nighttime use only) (80% capacity) Yes No 97 98 99 96 98 98 94 87 34 22 314 -1 50 503 195 46 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 28 24 26 15 13 6 0 0







LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.6LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.0

LE >77 Lp= 80


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria

RECEPTOR 8: COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 2-stories above cooling tower (Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.6LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.0

LE >77 Lp= 80



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k

RECEPTOR 9: ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 2-stories above cooling tower (Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.6LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.0

LE >77 Lp= 80

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)




FTA Criteria - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak LoadReceptor Location Existing Build ResultSite Ambient Leq


R6 COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 1-story above cooling tower (Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak Load) Cat 3 Leq 63.0 51.2 63.3 64.6 70.0 No ImpactR7 ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 1-story above cooling tower (Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak Load) Cat 3 Leq 63.0 48.3 63.1 64.6 70.0 No ImpactR8 COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 2-stories above cooling tower (Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak Load) Cat 3 Leq 63.0 44.7 63.1 64.6 70.0 No ImpactR9 ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 2-stories above cooling tower (Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak Load) Cat 3 Leq 63.0 41.8 63.0 64.6 70.0 No Impact


FTA Category

Leq or Ldn

Predicted Project Noise

Exposure Allowable Project Noise

Exposure Level





OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak LoadEQUIPMENT LISTNumber Tag Equipment Location Location of louver or Capacity Size Height of Enclosed Distance Notes



79 76 73 73 71 70 65 52 51 4 7 10 10 10 10 10 60° directivity





5 HV-4,5,6,7 Vent Fans 5th fl., south north façade 1400 cfm 4 4 457 Yes 48 50 43 43 38 33 30 29 Lw Centrifugal Radial, 1000 rpm 54 56 49 49 44 39 36 356 CWP-1,2,3 Condenser Pumps (1 at 80% capacity) concourse level NA 3000 gpm 76 hp 3 1 314 Yes 77 78 80 80 83 80 76 70 3 76bhp, 1760rpm 87 88 90 90 93 90 86 807 CWP-5 Condenser Pump (standby) concourse level NA 600 gpm 25 hp 1 0 314 Yes 75 78 79 79 78 75 72 67 3 1750 rpm, 17 bhp 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08 CH-1,2,3 Chillers concourse level NA 1000 tons 3 0 314 Yes 101 102 103 100 102 102 98 91 Lw NY Trane CSO 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 09 CH-4 Chiller (nighttime use only) (80% capacity) concourse level NA 200 tons 1 1 314 Yes 97 98 99 96 98 98 94 87 Lw Trane 97 98 99 96 98 98 94 87




16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 3rd fl. north façade 1400 cfm 3 3 414 Yes 48 50 43 43 38 33 30 29 Lw Centrifugal Radial, 1000 rpm 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34Note:TVF intakes or exhausts air depending on which mode (Forward or Reverse Mode)GEN exhaust assumed pipe exits through roof, extending approx. 21.5 ft. above roof (similar to 3/04 analysis)50th Street Facility with Through Drive = " Alternative 6D"



OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak LoadSOUND SOURCE SUMMARYNumber Tag Equipment Height of Enclosed






5 HV-4,5,6,7 Vent Fans 457.16 Yes 54 56 49 49 44 39 36 356 CWP-1,2,3 Condenser Pumps (1 at 80% capacity) 313.55 Yes 87 88 90 90 93 90 86 807 CWP-5 Condenser Pump (standby) 313.55 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08 CH-1,2,3 Chillers 313.55 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 09 CH-4 Chiller (nighttime use only) (80% capacity) 313.55 Yes 97 98 99 96 98 98 94 87

10 CHP-1,2,3 Primary Chilled Water Pumps (1 at 80% capacity) 313.55 Yes 78 81 82 82 81 78 75 7011 CHP-4 Primary Chilled Water Pump (standby) 313.55 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 012 CHS-1,2,3 Secondary Chilled Water Pumps (1 at 80% capacity) 313.55 Yes 91 94 95 95 94 91 88 8313 CHS-4 Secondary Chilled Water Pump (standby) 313.55 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 014 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Intake Fans (100% fan speed) 435.66 Yes 97 104 103 91 96 107 105 100


16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 413.91 Yes 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34


RECEPTOR 1: COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST (Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.6LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.0

LE >77 Lp= 80



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k

RECEPTOR 2: ITT AMERICAS TOWARD WEST (Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.6LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.0

LE >77 Lp= 80

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)

RECEPTOR 3: SIDEWALK ADJACENT TOWARD NORTH (Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.6LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.0

LE >77 Lp= 80



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k

RECEPTOR 4: SIDEWALK ACROSS 50TH STREET TOWARD NORTH (Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded











24-hr 71.6 35.4 71.6 65.0 70.6 No Impact


LE<42 Lp= 11.450+0.953LE42<=LE<=71 Lp= 71.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE

2 - 4.088x10-5LE3 = 65.6

LE >71 Lp= 65



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.6

LE >77 Lp= 75

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)

RECEPTOR 5: HOTEL ELEVATED RECEPTOR ACROSS 50TH STREET TOWARD NORTH (NIghttime Operation, Off-Peak Load)Number Tag Enclosed Shielded











24-hr 71.6 39.9 71.6 65.0 70.6 No Impact


LE<42 Lp= 11.450+0.953LE42<=LE<=71 Lp= 71.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE

2 - 4.088x10-5LE3 = 65.6

LE >71 Lp= 65



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.6

LE >77 Lp= 75



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k




FTA Criteria - 50th Street Facility with Through Drive - Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak LoadReceptor Location Existing Build ResultSite Ambient Leq





FTA Category

Leq or Ldn


Exposure Allowable Project Noise

Exposure Level



OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility - Daytime Operation, Off-Peak LoadEQUIPMENT LISTNumber Tag Equipment Location Location of louver or Capacity Size Height of Enclosed Receptor Distance Notes





3 GEN-EX-1,2Generator Exhaust 6th fl. Roof Vertical Ex. Roof 1800 rpm 2647 bhp 2 0 509.5 No 79 82 80 78 71 66 63 63 5 Cummins 2 MW 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0(without silencer) 98 107 111 114 111 109 102 95 5Muffler 19 25 31 36 40 43 39 32


5 HV-4,5,6,7 Vent Fans 5th fl., south north façade 1400 cfm 4 4 458 Yes 48 50 43 43 38 33 30 29 Lw Centrifugal Radial, 1000 rpm 54 56 49 49 44 39 36 356 CWP-1,2,3 Condenser Pumps (2 at 80% capacity) 4th fl., north north façade 3000 gpm 76 hp 3 2 435 Yes 77 78 80 80 83 80 76 70 3 76bhp, 1760rpm 90 91 93 93 96 93 89 837 CWP-5 Condenser Pump (standby) 4th fl., north north façade 600 gpm 25 hp 1 0 435 Yes 75 78 79 79 78 75 72 67 3 1750 rpm, 17 bhp 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08 CH-1,2,3 Chillers (2 at 80% capacity) 4th fl. north façade 1000 tons 3 2 437 Yes 97 98 99 96 98 98 94 87 Lw NY Trane CSO 100 101 102 99 101 101 97 909 CH-4 Chiller (nighttime use only) 4th fl. north façade 200 tons 1 0 437 Yes 93 84 81 80 79 78 75 68 Lw Trane 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

10 CHP-1,2,3 Primary Chilled Water Pumps (2 at 80% capacity) 4th fl. north façade 2000 gpm 32 bhp 3 2 429 Yes 68 71 72 72 71 68 65 60 3 1160 rpm, 32 bhp 81 84 85 85 84 81 78 7311 CHP-4 Primary Chilled Water Pump (standby) 4th fl. north façade 1160 rpm 12 bhp 1 0 429 Yes 72 75 76 76 75 72 69 64 3 1160 rpm, 12 bhp 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 012 CHS-1,2,3 Secondary Chilled Water Pumps (2 at 80% capacity4th fl. north façade 2500 gpm 150 bhp 3 2 426 Yes 81 84 85 85 84 81 78 73 3 1750 rpm, 150 bhp 94 97 98 98 97 94 91 8613 CHS-4 Secondary Chilled Water Pump (standby) 4th fl. north façade 1750 rpm 25 bhp 1 0 426 Yes 75 78 79 79 78 75 72 67 3 1750 rpm, 25 bhp 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 014 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Intake Fans (100% fan speed) 3rd fl., Intake Plenum north façade 200,000 cfm 4 2 403 Yes 97 104 103 91 96 107 105 100 Lw Howden Buffalo, REV 100 107 106 94 99 110 108 103


15 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Ex Fans 3rd fl., Exhaust Plenumnorth façade 200,000 cfm 0 0 403 Yes 97 100 100 88 95 105 103 99 Lw Howden Buffalo, FWD 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0(without silencer) 109 118 122 124 124 119 113 108 LwConical Silencer (6 to 8ft. Length) 12 18 22 36 29 14 10 9

16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 2nd fl. north façade 1400 cfm 3 3 394 Yes 48 50 43 43 38 33 30 29 Lw Centrifugal Radial, 1000 rpm 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34Note:TVF intakes or exhausts air depending on which mode (Forward or Reverse Mode)GEN exhaust assumed pipe exits through roof, extending approx. 21.5 ft. above roof (similar to 3/04 analysis)50th Street Facility = "Base Scheme"



OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility - Daytime Operation, Off-Peak LoadSOUND SOURCE SUMMARYNumber Tag Equipment Height of Enclosed Receptor


ROOFTOP1 CT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) 513 No 97 91 85 85 83 82 77 64 R61 CT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) 513 No 98 92 86 86 84 83 78 65 R71 CT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) 513 No 93 85 80 79 76 74 68 55 R81 CT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) 513 No 94 86 81 80 77 75 69 56 R9

INDOORS2 GEN-1,2 Generator 475 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0


4 MAF-1,2,3,4 Makeup Fans (Gen.) 475 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

5 HV-4,5,6,7 Vent Fans 458 Yes 54 56 49 49 44 39 36 356 CWP-1,2,3 Condenser Pumps (2 at 80% capacity) 435 Yes 90 91 93 93 96 93 89 837 CWP-5 Condenser Pump (standby) 435 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08 CH-1,2,3 Chillers (2 at 80% capacity) 437 Yes 100 101 102 99 101 101 97 909 CH-4 Chiller (nighttime use only) 437 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

10 CHP-1,2,3 Primary Chilled Water Pumps (2 at 80% capacity) 429 Yes 81 84 85 85 84 81 78 7311 CHP-4 Primary Chilled Water Pump (standby) 429 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 012 CHS-1,2,3 Secondary Chilled Water Pumps (2 at 80% capacit 426 Yes 94 97 98 98 97 94 91 8613 CHS-4 Secondary Chilled Water Pump (standby) 426 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 014 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Intake Fans (100% fan speed) 403 Yes 100 107 106 94 99 110 108 103

15 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Ex Fans 403 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 394 Yes 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34


RECEPTOR 6: COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 1-story above cooling towerNumber Tag Enclosed Shielded


ROOFTOPCT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) No No 97 91 85 85 83 82 77 64 48 62 513 78 50 503 34 31 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 63 57 51 51 49 48 43 29











LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k

RECEPTOR 7: ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 1-story above cooling towerNumber Tag Enclosed Shielded


ROOFTOPCT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) No No 98 92 86 86 84 83 78 65 48 62 513 -1 50 503 51 35 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 60 54 48 48 46 45 39 26







16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans Yes No 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34 21 28 394 -1 50 503 113 42 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Note:Sound Pressure Level Lp = Lw - Adiv - Aatm - Aground - Ascreen - ATL - AD - 0.6 63 125 250 500 1K 2K 4K 8KDistance factor Adiv = 20logD Total Lp (dB) 59.8 53.9 48.5 47.7 45.7 44.6 39.4 26.4Air Factor Aatm = αD(m)/1000; α is the air attenuation coefficient, dB/Km, D is distance from source to receiver (see Table 15.1 in Handbook of Acoustical Measurements and Noise Control, Cyril M. Harris). Total Lp (dBA) 33.6 37.8 39.9 44.5 45.7 45.8 40.4 25.3 51.2 dBAAground = the sound reduction due to the effects of hard ground (see Table 15.2 in The Noise Manual, E.H. Berger and ...).Ascreen = Assuming 5dBA screen effect is based upon buildings and any structures blocking the view between sound sources and receivers (see P48.14 in Handbook of Acoustical Measurements and Noise Control, Cyril M. Harris). FTA CriteriaTransmission Loss factor ATL based on sound transmission loss of concrete masonry units (see P372 in Noise Control Manual for Residential Buildings, David A. Harris). Result




LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80


dB 63



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


RECEPTOR 8: COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 2-stories above cooling towerNumber Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)

RECEPTOR 9: ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 2-stories above cooling towerNumber Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




FTA Criteria - 50th Street Facility - Daytime Operation, Off-Peak LoadReceptor Location Existing Build ResultSite Ambient Leq


R6 COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 1-story above cooling tower Cat 3 Leq 63.2 54.2 63.7 64.7 70.1 No ImpactR7 ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 1-story above cooling tower Cat 3 Leq 63.2 51.2 63.5 64.7 70.1 No ImpactR8 COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EAST, Windows 2-stories above cooling tower Cat 3 Leq 63.2 47.9 63.3 64.7 70.1 No ImpactR9 ITT AMERICAS BUILDING TOWARD WEST, Windows 2-stories above cooling tower Cat 3 Leq 63.2 44.8 63.3 64.7 70.1 No Impact


FTA Category

Leq or Ldn


Exposure Allowable Project Noise Exposure

Level

OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility - Daytime Operation, Off-Peak LoadEQUIPMENT LISTNumber Tag Equipment Location Location of louver or Capacity Size Height of Enclosed Distance Notes



79 76 73 73 71 70 65 52 51 4 7 10 10 10 10 10 60° directivity












OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility - Daytime Operation, Off-Peak LoadSOUND SOURCE SUMMARYNumber Tag Equipment Height of Enclosed


ROOFTOP1 CT-1,2,3 Cooling Towers (exh., 80% capacity) 513 No 96 90 84 81 79 78 73 60





10 CHP-1,2,3 Primary Chilled Water Pumps (2 at 80% capacity) 429 Yes 81 84 85 85 84 81 78 7311 CHP-4 Primary Chilled Water Pump (standby) 429 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 012 CHS-1,2,3 Secondary Chilled Water Pumps (2 at 80% capacity 426 Yes 94 97 98 98 97 94 91 8613 CHS-4 Secondary Chilled Water Pump (standby) 426 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 014 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Intake Fans (100% fan speed) 403 Yes 100 107 106 94 99 110 108 103


16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 394 Yes 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34


RECEPTOR 1: COLGATE-PALMOLIVE BUILDING TOWARD EASTNumber Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k

RECEPTOR 2: ITT AMERICAS TOWARD WESTNumber Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)

RECEPTOR 3: SIDEWALK ADJACENT TOWARD NORTHNumber Tag Enclosed Shielded













LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 72.8LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 77.7

LE >77 Lp= 80



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k

RECEPTOR 4: SIDEWALK ACROSS 50TH STREET TOWARD NORTHNumber Tag Enclosed Shielded











24-hr 71.6 39.1 71.6 65.0 70.6 No Impact


LE<42 Lp= 11.450+0.953LE42<=LE<=71 Lp= 71.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE

2 - 4.088x10-5LE3 = 65.6

LE >71 Lp= 65



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.6

LE >77 Lp= 75

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)

RECEPTOR 5: HOTEL ELEVATED RECEPTOR ACROSS 50TH STREET TOWARD NORTHNumber Tag Enclosed Shielded











24-hr 71.6 43.0 71.6 65.0 70.6 No Impact


LE<42 Lp= 11.450+0.953LE42<=LE<=71 Lp= 71.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE

2 - 4.088x10-5LE3 = 65.6

LE >71 Lp= 65



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.6

LE >77 Lp= 75



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k




FTA Criteria - 50th Street Facility - Daytime Operation, Off-Peak LoadReceptor Location Existing Build ResultSite Ambient Leq





FTA Category

Leq or Ldn



Level





OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility - Daytime Operation, Peak LoadEQUIPMENT LISTNumber Tag Equipment Location Location of louver or Capacity Size Height of Enclosed Distance Notes



79 76 73 73 71 70 65 52 51 4 7 10 10 10 10 10 60° directivity












OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility - Daytime Operation, Peak LoadSOUND SOURCE SUMMARYNumber Tag Equipment Height of Enclosed









16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 394 Yes 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34















LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)

Transmission Loss factor (ATL) Air factor (Aatm) Octave Band Sound Pressure Level (dB) at receptoSource Location Receptor Location

dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k














LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)














LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 72.8LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 77.7

LE >77 Lp= 80



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k








10 CHP-1,2,3 Primary Chilled Water Pumps (3 at 80% capacity) Yes No 83 86 87 87 86 83 80 75 5 85 429 39 144 363 95 40 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 20 18 20 13 8 0 0 011 CHP-4 Primary Chilled Water Pump (standby) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 85 429 39 144 363 95 40 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 012 CHS-1,2,3 Secondary Chilled Water Pumps (3 at 80% capaci Yes No 96 99 100 100 99 96 93 88 5 85 426 39 144 363 93 40 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 33 31 33 26 21 11 0 013 CHS-4 Secondary Chilled Water Pump (standby) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 85 426 39 144 363 93 40 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 014 TVF-3,4,5,6 Tunnel Vent. Intake Fans (100% fan speed) Yes No 100 107 106 94 99 110 108 103 5 85 403 39 144 363 79 39 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 38 40 40 21 22 26 15 6




24-hr 71.6 40.3 71.6 65.0 70.6 No Impact


LE<42 Lp= 11.450+0.953LE42<=LE<=71 Lp= 71.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE

2 - 4.088x10-5LE3 = 65.6

LE >71 Lp= 65



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.6

LE >77 Lp= 75

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)












24-hr 71.6 44.7 71.6 65.0 70.6 No Impact


LE<42 Lp= 11.450+0.953LE42<=LE<=71 Lp= 71.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE

2 - 4.088x10-5LE3 = 65.6

LE >71 Lp= 65



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.6

LE >77 Lp= 75



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k




FTA Criteria - 50th Street Facility - Daytime Operation, Peak LoadReceptor Location Existing Build ResultSite Ambient Leq





FTA Category

Leq or Ldn



Level



OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility - Daytime Operation, Peak LoadEQUIPMENT LISTNumber Tag Equipment Location Location of louver or Capacity Size Height of Enclosed Receptor Distance Notes














OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility - Daytime Operation, Peak LoadSOUND SOURCE SUMMARYNumber Tag Equipment Height of Enclosed Receptor









16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 394 Yes 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34















LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k














LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80


dB 63



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)















LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)














LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.7LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.1

LE >77 Lp= 80


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




FTA Criteria - 50th Street Facility - Daytime Operation, Peak LoadReceptor Location Existing Build ResultSite Ambient Leq




FTA Category

Leq or Ldn



Level



OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility - Daytime Operation, Testing ModeEQUIPMENT LISTNumber Tag Equipment Location Location of louver or Capacity Size Height of Enclosed Distance Notes



79 76 73 73 71 70 65 52 51 4 7 10 10 10 10 10 60° directivity












OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility - Daytime Operation, Testing ModeSOUND SOURCE SUMMARYNumber Tag Equipment Height of Enclosed



1a Load Bank Load Bank 386 No 79 90 87 89 89 87 89 93INDOORS

2 GEN-1,2 Generator 475 Yes 95 95 91 86 74 78 81 81






16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 394 Yes 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34
















LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 65.5LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.9

LE >77 Lp= 80



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k




1a Load Bank Load Bank No No 79 90 87 89 89 87 89 93 44 10 386 -1 50 493 123 42 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 34 45 42 43 43 41 43 46INDOORS











LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 65.5LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.9

LE >77 Lp= 80

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)















LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 72.8LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 77.7

LE >77 Lp= 80

Result


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)

Transmission Loss factor (ATL) Air factor (Aatm) Octave Band Sound Pressure Level (dB) at receptoSource Location

Noise Level


4k

FTA Criteria

125 250 8k500 1k 2k













24-hr 71.6 51.2 71.6 65.0 70.6 No Impact


LE<42 Lp= 11.450+0.953LE42<=LE<=71 Lp= 71.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE

2 - 4.088x10-5LE3 = 65.6

LE >71 Lp= 65



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.6

LE >77 Lp= 75

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)













24-hr 71.6 53.7 71.7 65.0 70.6 No Impact


LE<42 Lp= 11.450+0.953LE42<=LE<=71 Lp= 71.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE

2 - 4.088x10-5LE3 = 65.6

LE >71 Lp= 65



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.6

LE >77 Lp= 75

Result


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)

Transmission Loss factor (ATL) Air factor (Aatm) Octave Band Sound Pressure Level (dB) at receptoSource Location

Noise Level


4k

FTA Criteria

125 250 8k500 1k 2k




FTA Criteria - 50th Street Facility - Daytime Operation, Testing ModeReceptor Location Existing Build ResultSite Ambient Leq





FTA Category

Leq or Ldn


Allowable Project Noise Exposure Level



OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility - Daytime Operation, Testing ModeEQUIPMENT LISTNumber Tag Equipment Location Location of louver or Capacity Size Height of Enclosed Receptor Distance Notes














OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility - Daytime Operation, Testing ModeSOUND SOURCE SUMMARYNumber Tag Equipment Height of Enclosed Receptor



1a Load Bank Load Bank 386 No 79 90 87 89 89 87 89 93INDOORS

2 GEN-1,2 Generator 475 Yes 95 95 91 86 74 78 81 81






16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 394 Yes 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34
















LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 65.5LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.9

LE >77 Lp= 80



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k















LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 65.5LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.9

LE >77 Lp= 80


dB 63



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)
















LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 65.5LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.9

LE >77 Lp= 80

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)















LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 65.5LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.9

LE >77 Lp= 80


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




FTA Criteria - 50th Street Facility - Daytime Operation, Testing ModeReceptor Location Existing Build ResultSite Ambient Leq




FTA Category

Leq or Ldn





OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility - Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak LoadEQUIPMENT LISTNumber Tag Equipment Location Location of louver or Capacity Size Height of Enclosed Receptor Distance Notes







5 HV-4,5,6,7 Vent Fans 5th fl., south north façade 1400 cfm 4 4 458 Yes 48 50 43 43 38 33 30 29 Lw Centrifugal Radial, 1000 rpm 54 56 49 49 44 39 36 356 CWP-1,2,3 Condenser Pumps (1 at 80% capacity) 4th fl., north north façade 3000 gpm 76 hp 3 1 435 Yes 77 78 80 80 83 80 76 70 3 76bhp, 1760rpm 87 88 90 90 93 90 86 807 CWP-5 Condenser Pump (standby) 4th fl., north north façade 600 gpm 25 hp 1 0 435 Yes 75 78 79 79 78 75 72 67 3 1750 rpm, 17 bhp 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08 CH-1,2,3 Chillers 4th fl. north façade 1000 tons 3 0 437 Yes 101 102 103 100 102 102 98 91 Lw NY Trane CSO 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 09 CH-4 Chiller (nighttime use only) (1 at 80% capacity) 4th fl. north façade 200 tons 1 1 437 Yes 97 98 99 96 98 98 94 87 Lw Trane 97 98 99 96 98 98 94 87







OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility - Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak LoadSOUND SOURCE SUMMARYNumber Tag Equipment Height of Enclosed Receptor






5 HV-4,5,6,7 Vent Fans 458 Yes 54 56 49 49 44 39 36 356 CWP-1,2,3 Condenser Pumps (1 at 80% capacity) 435 Yes 87 88 90 90 93 90 86 807 CWP-5 Condenser Pump (standby) 435 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08 CH-1,2,3 Chillers 437 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 09 CH-4 Chiller (nighttime use only) (1 at 80% capacity) 437 Yes 97 98 99 96 98 98 94 87



16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 394 Yes 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34








5 HV-4,5,6,7 Vent Fans Yes No 54 56 49 49 44 39 36 35 44 32 458 78 50 503 59 36 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 06 CWP-1,2,3 Condenser Pumps (1 at 80% capacity) Yes No 87 88 90 90 93 90 86 80 12 75 435 78 50 503 98 40 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 24 20 23 16 15 4 0 07 CWP-5 Condenser Pump (standby) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 43 26 435 78 50 503 80 39 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08 CH-1,2,3 Chillers Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 36 82 437 78 50 503 85 39 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 09 CH-4 Chiller (nighttime use only) (1 at 80% capacity) Yes No 97 98 99 96 98 98 94 87 34 22 437 78 50 503 84 39 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 35 31 33 23 21 14 0 0







LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.6LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.0

LE >77 Lp= 80


dB 63



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)








5 HV-4,5,6,7 Vent Fans Yes No 54 56 49 49 44 39 36 35 44 32 458 -1 50 503 66 37 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 06 CWP-1,2,3 Condenser Pumps (1 at 80% capacity) Yes No 87 88 90 90 93 90 86 80 12 75 435 -1 50 503 74 38 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 26 22 25 18 17 7 0 07 CWP-5 Condenser Pump (standby) Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 43 26 435 -1 50 503 84 39 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08 CH-1,2,3 Chillers Yes No 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 36 82 437 -1 50 503 82 39 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 09 CH-4 Chiller (nighttime use only) (1 at 80% capacity) Yes No 97 98 99 96 98 98 94 87 34 22 437 -1 50 503 80 39 0 3 20 25 24 31 35 42 51 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 35 31 33 23 21 14 1 0







LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.6LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.0

LE >77 Lp= 80



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k500 1k 2k 4k














LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.6LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.0

LE >77 Lp= 80


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria














LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.6LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.0

LE >77 Lp= 80

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria




(Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)




FTA Criteria - 50th Street Facility - Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak LoadReceptor Location Existing Build ResultSite Ambient Leq




FTA Category

Leq or Ldn





OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility - Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak LoadEQUIPMENT LISTNumber Tag Equipment Location Location of louver or Capacity Size Height of Enclosed Distance Notes



79 76 73 73 71 70 65 52 51 4 7 10 10 10 10 10 60° directivity





5 HV-4,5,6,7 Vent Fans 5th fl., south north façade 1400 cfm 4 4 458 Yes 48 50 43 43 38 33 30 29 Lw Centrifugal Radial, 1000 rpm 54 56 49 49 44 39 36 356 CWP-1,2,3 Condenser Pumps (1 at 80% capacity) 4th fl., north north façade 3000 gpm 76 hp 3 1 435 Yes 77 78 80 80 83 80 76 70 3 76bhp, 1760rpm 87 88 90 90 93 90 86 807 CWP-5 Condenser Pump (standby) 4th fl., north north façade 600 gpm 25 hp 1 0 435 Yes 75 78 79 79 78 75 72 67 3 1750 rpm, 17 bhp 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08 CH-1,2,3 Chillers 4th fl. north façade 1000 tons 3 0 437 Yes 101 102 103 100 102 102 98 91 Lw NY Trane CSO 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 09 CH-4 Chiller (nighttime use only) (1 at 80% capacity) 4th fl. north façade 200 tons 1 1 437 Yes 97 98 99 96 98 98 94 87 Lw Trane 97 98 99 96 98 98 94 87







OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility - Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak LoadSOUND SOURCE SUMMARYNumber Tag Equipment Height of Enclosed






5 HV-4,5,6,7 Vent Fans 458 Yes 54 56 49 49 44 39 36 356 CWP-1,2,3 Condenser Pumps (1 at 80% capacity) 435 Yes 87 88 90 90 93 90 86 807 CWP-5 Condenser Pump (standby) 435 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08 CH-1,2,3 Chillers 437 Yes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 09 CH-4 Chiller (nighttime use only) (1 at 80% capacity) 437 Yes 97 98 99 96 98 98 94 87



16 HV-1,2,3 Vent Fans 394 Yes 53 55 48 48 43 38 35 34















LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.6LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.0

LE >77 Lp= 80


dB 63



factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)















LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.6LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.0

LE >77 Lp= 80


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria














LE<42 Lp= 16.450+0.953LE

42<=LE<=71 Lp= 76.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE2 - 4.088x10-5LE

3 = 64.6LE >71 Lp= 70



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.0

LE >77 Lp= 80

FTA Criteria

125 250 8k500 1k 2kdB 63Receptor Location

4k

Result


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


Noise Level












24-hr 71.6 35.9 71.6 65.0 70.6 No Impact


LE<42 Lp= 11.450+0.953LE42<=LE<=71 Lp= 71.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE

2 - 4.088x10-5LE3 = 65.6

LE >71 Lp= 65



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.6

LE >77 Lp= 75


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


dB 63 125 250 8k

Noise LevelResult

500 1k 2k 4k

FTA Criteria












24-hr 71.6 39.8 71.6 65.0 70.6 No Impact


LE<42 Lp= 11.450+0.953LE42<=LE<=71 Lp= 71.662 - 1.164LE + 0.018LE

2 - 4.088x10-5LE3 = 65.6

LE >71 Lp= 65



2 - 1.043xx10-4LE3 = 70.6

LE >77 Lp= 75

FTA Criteria

125 250 8k500 1k 2kdB 63Receptor Location

4k

Result


factor (Ascreen)

Ground factor

(Aground)


Noise Level




FTA Criteria - 50th Street Facility - Nighttime Operation, Off-Peak LoadReceptor Location Existing Build ResultSite Ambient Leq





FTA Category

Leq or Ldn





Documents

APPENDIX F-1 FTA Operational Noise Analysis Calculation ...web.mta.info/capital/esa_docs/eafiles06/Appendix F-1 FTA Operation… · OPERATIONS NOISE ANALYSIS - 50th Street Facility