Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    1/49

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    2/49

    Presentation Overview

    2Confidential

    1) Introduction 1 min

    2) Vertical Take off 5 min

    3) Process Transfers vs. Technology Transfers 10 min

    4) Technology Transfer Deliverables 5 min

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfer 35 min

    6) Technology Transfer Skill Sets 10 min

    7) Question Answer Session 10 min

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    3/49

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    4/49

    2. Technology Transfer Success

    Successful technology transfer will depend

    on your ability to deploy these patterns ofsuccess within your project organization

    The slides that follow describe a roadmapyou can follow to optimize your project

    organization of technology transfer

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    5/49

    2. Typical Take-Off Curve

    Typically, a newly transferred process experiences less than optimal performance at

    the start. Like an out-of-tune biplane, the take-off is bumpy, experiencing ups and

    downs at the start as the receiving team/site works out the kinks of the new process

    and its technology. Performance ramps slowly over time, eventually achieving the

    desired level of performance.

    Time

    Performance

    TechnologyTransfer

    Process Go-Live

    Secondary

    Development(fixing issues)

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    6/49

    2. The Concept of Vertical Take-Off

    The goal of any technology transfer should be to achieve the desired level ofperformance quickly and smoothly. Like a jet, the new process takes-off at the

    receiving site and delivers the desired heights of performance right from the start

    (vertical take-off).

    Time

    Performance

    TechnologyTransfer

    Process Go-Live

    Secondary Development

    (fixing issues)

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    7/49

    2. The Value of Vertical Take-Off

    There is a cost associated with most Technology Transfers that tends to stay hidden.The slow, bumpy ramp-up to desired performance represents cash to the business in

    the form of wastes, lower product yields , lost sales opportunities and slower return on

    investment (ROI).

    Time

    Performance

    TechnologyTransfer

    Process Go-Live

    $Low Yields

    Inefficiency

    Rework

    WasteSlow Speeds

    Unplanned downtime

    Unclear roles

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    8/49

    Confidential 8

    3) Process transfers vs. Technology transfers

    Process Transfer is the transfer of process information, or capability, associatedwith process from a donor side (knowledge center) to a receptor side. The process is

    learned and realized by both sides and complies all the regulatory requirements in

    terms of Efficacy, Quality and Safety.

    Technology Transfer, also called Transfer of Technology (TOT) is the process ofskill transferring, knowledge, technologies, methods of manufacturing, samples of

    manufacturing to ensure that scientific and technological developments areaccessible to a wider range of users who can then further develop and exploit the

    technology into new products, processes, applications, materials or services. It is

    closely related to (and may arguably be considered a subset of) knowledge transfer.

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    9/49

    Confidential 9

    3) Technology Transfers vs. Process Transfers

    A) Process Transfer examples B) Technology Transferexamples

    Bi-Layer tablet compression for FDC

    DPI encapsulation

    Gamma radiation sterilization for parenteralproducts

    Includes:

    Change control, Process Flow, URS, FDS,IOQ, PQ, Cleaning validation, PV, Training,

    SOPs

    OPINA- Two process train transfers every weekend

    API manufacturing technology

    NDA Product manufacturing

    ANDA Product transfer

    Includes:

    Process transfer plus- Strategic Plan,Validation master plan, Document

    matrix, Supply chain planning, Method

    transfer, PDA, CPP,

    SPIRIVA- One transfer 5 years

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    10/49

    Confidential 10

    3) Technology Transfers vs. Process Transfers

    OPINA Process Transfer

    Project Objective Consolidate North American pharmaceutical processing in 1 plant

    Special Boundaries- No stockpiling of inventory

    Solution Transfer two process trains and ancillary equipment every weekend for 5weekends

    Method Dedicated transfer team developed plan for 6 months prior to execution.

    - Process transfer was like for like.

    - All non production transfer activities (training, utility installation, method

    transfers, RM transfers, qualification documents completed prior to transfer.- Minute by minute (micro) plan developed with video tape test runs.

    - Easiest transfer first.

    - Post mortem review of each process to fine tune for next transfer.

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    11/49

    Confidential 11

    3) Technology Transfers vs. Process Transfers

    SPIRIVA Technology Transfer

    Project Objective Create redundant US production facility for German blockbuster

    Special Boundaries-Process not defined, 1 billion x18 g capsule fill.

    Solution Mirror German implementation with 6 month lag.Method Dedicated team, Clear roles and responsibilities.

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    12/49

    4) Technology Transfer Deliverables

    In order to specify or to document the results of the technology transfer in a flexible

    manner, a TTP or TTR could cover the technology transfer of one or all process steps 1).

    Required documents detailing the technology transfer are listed in the Appendix of the

    TTP or TTR.Technology Transfer Documentation One

    Process StepAll

    Process Steps

    Prepare Technology Transfer

    Technology Transfer Protocol Quality Control () 1)

    Laboratory Qualification Report - Part 1 (TTLQ-Part1)

    Checklist 'Laboratory Equipment (CLLE)

    Checklist 'Raw Material Specifications (CLRMS)

    Checklist 'Shipping (CLS)

    Technology Transfer Protocol Production (TTPP) () 1)

    Equivalency Report Part 1 (TTEQ-Part1)

    Checklist Process Equipment (CLPE)

    Execute Technology Transfer

    Technology Transfer Report Quality Control () 1)

    Laboratory Qualification Report - Part 2 (TTLQ-Part2)

    Technology Transfer Report Production (TTRP) () 1)

    Equivalency Report Part 2 (TTEQ-Part2)

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    13/49

    9 Gate Technology Transfer Approach

    13

    Initial

    Assessment 1

    ProjectRecommendation

    & Proposal

    Customer

    Review 2

    ProjectGo

    Develop

    Project

    Plan3

    ProjectPlan

    Approved

    Process

    Mapped with

    CPP4

    CPP with GapAssessment

    Quality DocsCreated 5

    QualityDocuments

    Complete

    Execution 7

    ExpansionDocumented

    Prepare

    for

    Validation8

    Ready forValidation

    MFG

    Validation.

    batches9

    Post-ApprovalAssessment /Post Mortem

    Production

    Documents

    Completed

    6

    Ready forExecution

    Project

    Opportunity

    Eng. / TransferBatches

    Validation /CommercialBatch

    Milestones assessed

    Confidential

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    14/49

    Gate 1. Project Charter -Scope of Transfer Process

    Project Recommendation includes the following components:

    1) Safety assessment

    2) Quality assessment

    3) Financial assessment

    4) Overall Timeline

    5) Framework for Technical Transfer Plan

    6) Defines project boundaries What is in scope, what is out of scope

    7) Risks and Opportunities identified.

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    15/49

    Gate 1. Project Recommendation -Scope of Transfer Process

    Specify ...

    scope of transfer (process steps)

    technology transfer activities and documentation

    qualification & regulatory activities

    release as additional manufacturer

    Product Transfer Master Plan (PTMP)

    Establish PTMP

    The Master Documentation provides the framework for the transfer process. The Product Transfer Master Plan (PTMP) scope

    document defines the boundaries of the transfer.

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    16/49

    Gate 1. Gate 1. Project Recommendation Know what you aretransferring.

    P1 Stokes Mixer

    Add MCC, API, Dextrose

    and Starch, Mix for 5 min

    Pony Mixer

    Add P1 and P2

    Mix for 10 min

    Pony Mixer

    Add Mag Stearate

    Mix for 5 min

    Poly Lined Drum

    Transfer Blend through #10 screen

    Manesty Press

    Compress 25 mg tablets

    SS Bin

    Transfer Blend through

    #10 screen

    Killian Press

    Compress 10 mg tablets

    Sending Site Process Receiving Site Process

    Study*

    P2 Stokes Mixer

    Add MCC, API, Dextrose

    and Starch, Mix for 5 min

    P1 Stokes Mixer

    Add MCC, API, Dextrose

    and Starch, Mix for 5 min

    Pony Mixer / Blend Cube

    Add P1 and P2

    Mix for 10 min

    Pony Mixer / Blend Cube

    Add Mag Stearate

    Mix for 5 min

    P2 Stokes Mixer

    Add MCC, API, Dextrose

    and Starch, Mix for 5 min

    These processes have the same SUPAC classification per CDER

    This product transfer will be filed as a CBE 30

    Study*

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    17/49

    Gate 1. Project Recommendation Know what you are transferringvs. Company Metrics

    CTD Metric Most Favorable Less Favorable Least Favorable Critical #

    Comment

    P7 Number ofWorldwide

    Primary

    Packaging

    Configurations

    Maximum 3(e.g. one size clear blister of one

    material, one size opaque blister,

    one size HDPE bottle)

    Maximum 6

    2 blister (7-ct push + 10-ct peel-

    push)

    2 bottles 60mL + 120mL

    Above 6 4

    The number of worldwide primary packaging configurations reported here is determined for each drug

    product dosage form and strength.

    Blister packaging configurations are determined by counting the different combinations of forming and

    lidding materials being developed with consideration of the sealing area and perforations. Although the

    number of tablets per blister is not considered when determining the number of worldwide primary

    packaging configurations being developed, this aspect must be evaluated and taken into considerationduring capacity, transfer and launch planning by Operations.

    Bottle packaging configurations are determined by counting the different combinations of bottles and

    closures, with consideration of size, product count and materials.

    P7 Packaging

    (Primary or

    protective

    secondary or

    functional

    having impact

    on product

    quality)

    Standard HDPE bottle or standard

    PVC and/or PVDC blister suitable.

    Special moisture barrier packaging

    needed (PVDC based materials

    inadequate) or if hygroscopic

    formulation prone to major failure

    after HDPE bottle opened or failure

    if bottle not reclosed in-use.

    Special light protective packaging

    needed (lined bottles or dark glass).

    Special design or configuration of

    HDPE bottles (e.g. desiccant),

    Polypropylene bottle, or

    Aluminum blister, bag, overwrap

    required.

    Special inert atmosphere and

    oxygen barrier packaging

    required. Novel packaging

    materials required not

    commonly used for

    pharmaceutical products.

    Materials not approved for

    use in food or drug

    packaging in US or EU.

    2+

    Multiple suppliers available.

    Blister foils: Alcan + Constantia

    Only single supplier available but

    other suppliers can be developed.

    Bottle: Gap last

    Single source supply with

    patent restrictions against

    alternate suppliers.

    5+

    Product Design Attribute (PDA) TABLES

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    18/49

    Handbook for Transfers of Chemical Products V02

    18/102 January 17, 2007

    Gate 2. Project Go

    In order to support the documentation of the decision to execute technical

    transfer the Decision' template specifies format and content.

    Template

    eRoom Folder:

    1 Transfer Management

    Technology Transfer

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    19/49

    Gate 3. Project PlanThe checklist 'Activities' (CLA) contains a proposal regarding activities which are in

    principle relevant for a transfer. Relevant activities can be marked and copied to the

    project plan.

    Transfer of Chemical Product - Checklist 'Activites'

    Process Step GL Activity Start Date End Date Resp. Rel.

    Set-up Transfer 2 Set up transfer project PL yes

    Set-up Transfer 2 Set up eRoom PL yes

    Set-up Transfer 2 Denominate transfer team PL yes

    Set-up Transfer 2 Prepare kick-off meeting PL yes

    Preparation of TTP 2 Idemtification of documents PM RU yes

    Preparation of TTP 2 Preparation of documents PM SU yes

    Preparation of TTP 2 Preparation of TTP - Quality Control QC SU yes

    Preparation of TTP 2Acquisi tion and evaluation of the exist ing documentation on the synthetic

    method, including eventual batch recordsP SU yes

    Preparation of TTP 2Acquisi tion and evaluation of general documentation about ritical

    parameters or of a complete development reportP SU yes

    Preparation of TTP 2 Check production needs and their compatibility with the actual planning P SU yes

    Preparation of TTP 2Feasibility analysis in plant on the existing documentation and lay-out

    hypothesis of the processP RU yes

    Preparation of TTP 2 Cost analysis on production hypothesis PM RU yes

    Preparation of TTP 2Acquisi tion and evaluation of the safety documentation of the process ,

    including MSDSP RU yes

    Example

    eRoom Folder:

    1 Transfer Management

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    20/49

    Gate 3. Project Plan

    Template

    In order to specify the product transfer, the Product Transfer Master Plan (PTMP)

    template provides predefined structure, format and content.

    eRoom Folder:

    2 Tech Transfer

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    21/49

    Gate 3. Project PlanMS Project serves as standard tool for the project planning of the product transfer. In

    order to accelerate the preparation of the project plan, tasks from the activity list could

    be pasted in.

    Example

    eRoom Folder:

    1 Project Management

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    22/49

    Confidential 22

    Gate 4. Process Flow

    oknot ok

    Conduct thePre-Use Flush

    for the ClosedSolventTransferSystem

    Ensure ventbungholes on

    both metalwaste drum and

    solvent drumare open

    Ensure properbondingandgroundingofequipment.

    Sequential orparallel?

    ok

    not ok

    Wheredescribed

    open them

    Do Ineedtocontact

    supervisorfirst?

    Attach Inlethose andValve

    No.2 ofCSTsystem to the

    vessel andrecordthe

    weight.

    Calculate 95%oftotal required

    DehydratedAlcohol,

    USP/EP/BP toaddtotheformulation

    vessel

    Calculatet heamount of

    DehydratedAlcohol,

    USP/EP/BP toaddto the

    vessel via theCSTsystem(underfill?)

    Calculate95%minus theUnderfill

    is thiscorrect?

    confusing tome..

    Addthisamount to theformulation

    vessel.

    Continue agitation throughout solvent transfer

    Remove inlethose and ValveNo.2from the

    vessel andrecordweight.

    Target transferweight ofthe

    vessel achieved

    1) Map production process with SME / Operators

    2) Identify Critical Process Parameters (CPP) and Critical

    Quality Attributes (CQA) as they relate to finishedproduct

    3) Confirm all CPP / CQA have studies to support

    acceptance ranges.

    4) Conduct studies to confirm CPP / CQA ranges to fill

    gaps

    5) Determine best practice / gold standard process6) Create CPP / CQA database (PANDA)

    7) Compare CPP / CQA data values to gold standard

    and ranges to determine cause of variance.

    8) Provide real time data trending to operators to enable

    educated process adjustment.

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    23/49

    Confidential 23

    Formulation SetUpProcessSubStep

    CheckRoom

    for

    Cleanliness

    Check

    Isolatorfor

    Cleanliness

    CheckTank

    for

    Cleanliness

    Collect

    Equipment

    andcheckfor

    Cleanliness

    PitCheck

    Scale

    Load

    Isolator

    Attach

    CST

    Attach

    Isolatorto

    tank

    Record

    Tare

    Wt

    CQA Specification

    Logbookconf

    VisualConf

    Logbook

    conf

    VisualConf

    Visual,

    Mork sheet

    Alcohol

    rinse.

    VisualConf

    BOM

    Props/

    clamp

    Challenge

    Calibration

    Verifycal

    Verify

    BOM

    Integrity

    Setup

    perSOP

    Setup

    perSOP

    Nobreach

    alarms

    Printtick

    0.5kg

    Appearance

    Clear,colorlesstopale

    yellowfreefromvisable

    Contamination 1 1 5 3 1 1 1 1 1

    Volume Notlessthan16.7mL/Vial 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

    Assay 98.0%108.0%oflabel 1 3 3 3 3 1 1 1 5

    pH 4.06.0 1 1 3 3 1 1 1 1 1

    Moisture NMT0.6% 1 3 5 5 1 1 1 2 1

    Colorofsolution

    NMT0.05AUatA420nm

    usingethylalcoholblank 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 1 1

    Ethanol 90%110%oflabeledamt 1 1 5 1 3 1 1 1 5

    Limitof

    Degredation

    PaclitaxelProductsNMT

    0.1%

    7EpipaclitaxelNMT0.3%

    TotalDegredProductsNMT

    1.0% 1 1 2 4 1 1 1 1 4

    ResidualSolvents USP467 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

    Microbe

    Testing

    NMT0.67EU/mgof

    Paclitaxel 3 3 5 3 1 3 1 2 1

    ParticulateMatter

    NMT6,000parts>10micron

    NMT600parts>25micron 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

    Gate 4. CPP / CQA Matrix

    Based on ICH Q9 Guidelines

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    24/49

    Gate 5. QC Documents Completed

    Specify ...

    scope of transfer (process steps)

    technology transfer activities and documentation

    qualification & regulatory activities

    release as additional manufacturer

    Product Transfer Master Plan (PTMP)

    Establish PTMP

    QC Documentation must be set prior to process transfer

    Quality Control

    Docs complete

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    25/49

    Gate 5. QC Documents Completed

    Quality Control

    Production

    Test

    Sending Unit

    Test

    Receiving Unit

    Product

    Sending Unit

    Product

    Receiving Unit1st step:

    Qualification of laboratory(Parallel analysis of referencesubstance by SU and RU)

    2nd step:Equivalency check of

    product(Comparison of transfer batches

    with reference batches)

    Production Transfer

    The technology transfer products starts with the qualification of the laboratory (QC

    Transfer) and continues with the transfer of the manufacturing process (Production

    Transfer). The equivalency check of the chemical product has to be performed by the

    QC of the Sending Unit

    1)

    .

    Quality ControlTransfer

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    26/49

    Gate 5. QC Documents CompletedThe Part 2 of the Technology Laboratory Qualification Report (TTLQ) template

    supports to record the analytical results obtained in the parallel analysis by the RU, to

    document the comparison of the results and the conclusions with regard to the

    fulfillment of the acceptance criteria.

    Example

    TTLQ P2

    (TTRQC relevant part)

    eRoom Folder: 3 Quality Control

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    27/49

    Gate 6. Expansion Documents Completed

    Specify ...

    scope of transfer (process steps)

    technology transfer activities and documentation

    qualification & regulatory activities

    release as additional manufacturer

    Product Transfer Master Plan (PTMP)

    Prepare

    Technology Transfer Docs

    Establish PTMP

    Quality Control

    Docs complete

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    28/49

    January 17, 2007

    The technology related part of the transfer is documented in technology transfer

    documentation. Technology Transfer - ProductionTechnology Transfer Quality Control

    PreparePrepare

    Execute

    Execute

    Specify scope of QC Transfer1)

    TT Protocol Quality Control (TTPQC)

    Check equivalence of laboratory CL Laboratory Equipment (CLLE)

    Check raw material specifications at

    CL Raw Material Specifications (CLRMS)

    Ship reference substances to RU

    CL Shipping (CLS)

    Specify qualification of RU laboratory

    TT Laboratory QualificationPart 1 (TTLQ-P1)

    Train analytical methods at SU3)

    CE Certificate Training Quality Control

    Execute parallel analysis at RU

    TT Laboratory QualificationPart 2 (TTLQ-P2)

    Document results of QC Transfer

    TT Report Quality Control (TTRQC)

    Specify scope of Production Transfer4)

    Define Transfer Campaign Size

    TT Protocol Production (TTPP)

    Check equivalence of process

    CL Process Equipment (CLPE)

    Specify equivalency check5)

    TT Equivalency QualificationPart 1 (TTEQ-P1)

    Train manufacturing process at SU

    Coach manufacturing process at RU

    CE Certificate Training Production (CETP)

    Produce transfer campaign at RU

    Execute equivalency check

    TT Equivalency QualificationPart 2 (TTEQ-P2)

    Document results of Production

    TT Report Production (TTRP)

    Gate 6. Expansion Documents Completed

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    29/49

    Gate 6. Expansion Equivalency Check

    Target Value

    NormalOperating Range

    ProvenAcceptable Range

    KnowledgeRange

    ParameterScale

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    30/49

    Confidential

    30

    30/102

    The equivalency check has to be conducted for non critical parameters by min/max

    comparison.

    For critical parameters QC Charts 1) have to be used to demonstrate equivalency.Production RUProduction SU

    Specification

    SampleNo

    + 3 3)

    Upper Tolerance Limit (UTL) 2)

    Lower Tolerance Limit (LTL) 2)

    Upper Specification Limit (USL)

    Lower Specification Limit (LSL)

    MeasuredValue

    Remarks: 1) upper or upper/lower limited control chart 2) Synonym: Upper/ Lower Control Limit; 3) 99,7% of the data should lie within the tolerance limits, the probability of afalse decision is 0,3%

    EXAMPLE

    Gate 6. Expansion Equivalency Check

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    31/49

    Gate 7. Expansion Completed

    Specify ...

    scope of transfer (process steps)

    technology transfer activities and documentation

    qualification & regulatory activities

    release as additional manufacturer

    Product Transfer Master Plan (PTMP)

    Prepare

    Technology Transfer Docs

    Establish PTMP

    Execute

    Regulatory Activities

    Quality Control

    Docs complete

    Execute Expansion Document ...

    results of technology transfer

    results of qualification and regulatory activities

    release as additional manufacturer

    Product Transfer Master Report (PTMR)

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    32/49

    Gate 8. Validation / Stability

    1) Never fail validation / stability batches.

    Highest variation

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    33/49

    Gate 8. Validation / Stability

    1) Never fail validation / stability batches.

    Degradation T @ 25C/60% r.H.

    97.5

    98.0

    98.5

    99.0

    99.5

    100.0

    100.5

    101.0

    0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

    time [month]

    assayT[%]

    G76757

    G76972

    G77267

    G77989

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    34/49

    Gate 9 Post Approval Assessment / Post Mortem

    5) Application Techniques for Technology Transfers

    1. Review deliverables vs. plan

    2. Review budget vs. plan

    3. Review timeline vs. Base Plan

    4. Revise templates accordingly.

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    35/49

    35

    6) Technology transfer skill sets

    Management, Safety, QA, QC, Finance, Change Management, Engineering, Micro, Validations,

    Operations, Customer, Contract Management, DRA

    RACI

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    36/49

    Questions?

    36Confidential

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    37/49

    Reference Sources *Sources:

    Project Management Best-Practice Report, APQC, 2004

    A Guide to the Project Management Book of Knowledge, U.S. Department of Defense, 2003

    European Technology Transfer Guide to Best Practice, Teurpin, 2001

    Benchmarking Best-Practices in Technology Transfer, Colorado Institute for Technology Transfer

    and Implementation, 1993

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    38/49

    In Compliance

    +

    On Schedule

    +

    In Budget

    =

    SUCCESS !

    ProPharma Group is the Best Choice

    to balance all three needs!

    Conclusion

    38Confidential

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    39/49

    Confidential 39

    CTD Metric Most Favorable Less Favorable Least FavorableCritical at

    Milestone #

    Comment

    P7 Number of

    Worldwide

    Primary

    Packaging

    Configurations

    Maximum 3

    (e.g. one size clear blister of one

    material, one size opaque blister,

    one size HDPE bottle)

    Maximum 6

    2 blister (7-ct push + 10-ct peel-

    push)

    2 bottles 60mL + 120mL

    Above 6 4

    The number of worldwide primary packaging configurations reported here is determined for each drug

    product dosage form and strength.Blister packaging configurations are determined by counting the different combinations of forming and

    lidding materials being developed with consideration of the sealing area and perforations. Although the

    number of tablets per blister is not considered when determining the number of worldwide primary

    packaging configurations being developed, this aspect must be evaluated and taken into consideration

    during capacity, transfer and launch planning by Operations.

    Bottle packaging configurations are determined by counting the different combinations of bottles and

    closures, with consideration of size, product count and materials.

    P7 Packaging

    (Primary or

    protectivesecondary or

    functional

    having impact

    on product

    quality)

    Standard HDPE bottle or standard

    PVC and/or PVDC blister suitable.

    Special moisture barrier packaging

    needed (PVDC based materials

    inadequate) or if hygroscopicformulation prone to major failure

    after HDPE bottle opened or

    failure if bottle not reclosed in-use.

    Special light protective packaging

    needed (lined bottles or dark

    glass). Special design or

    configuration of HDPE bottles

    (e.g. desiccant), Polypropylene

    bottle, or Aluminum blister, bag,

    overwrap required.

    Special inert atmosphere and

    oxygen barrier packaging

    required. Novel packagingmaterials required not

    commonly used for

    pharmaceutical products.

    Materials not approved for

    use in food or drug

    packaging in US or EU.

    2+

    Multiple suppliers available.

    Blisterfoils: Alcan + Constantia

    Only single supplier available butother suppliers can be developed.

    Bottle: Gaplast

    Single source supply withpatent restrictions against

    alternate suppliers.

    5+

    Product Design Attribute (PDA) TABLES

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    40/49

    Confidential 40

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    41/49

    Confidential 41

    5) Technology Transfer Skill Sets

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    42/49

    Confidential 42

    3) Process transfers vs. Technology transfers

    Trouble -Typically both process transfers and technology transfer projects get intotrouble because:

    1) Process was not Right the first time before the transfer.2) Process technology was not up to date technology before transfer.3) Resolve compliance issues during transfer.

    Result Extended timelines, cost overrun.

    Appendix

    A B CDAppendix

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    43/49

    Appendix

    9 Technology Transfer Document Flow

    Jan 17, 2008Handbook for Transfer of Chemical Products

    A B CDpp

    9 Technology Transfer Document Flow1)

    IChC decision on

    Transfer of CPIChC Decision (FID)

    Specifytransfer of CP

    Specify scope of

    Technology Transfer QC

    Product TransferMaster Plan (PTMP)

    Check equivalencyof laboratory

    Check adequacy of raw

    material specifi cations RU/SU

    Ship reference substances

    to RU

    Specify qualifi cation

    parameters (RU laboratory)

    Execute parallel analysis

    at RU

    Coach analytical methods atRU (optional)

    Document results ofTechnology Transfer - QC

    Train analytical methods

    at SU

    Specify scope of Technology

    Transfer Production

    Define Transfer CampaignSize

    Check comparability of

    process equipment

    Specify equivalencycheck

    Produce transfer campaign

    at RU

    Train manufacturing

    process at SU

    Execute equivalency check

    Coach manufacturing

    process at RU

    Document results of Techn.

    Transfer - Production

    Document transfer of CP

    Technology TransferProtocol QC (TTPQC)

    Checklist LaboratoryEquipment (CLLE)

    Checklist Raw MaterialSpecifications (CLRMS)

    ChecklistShipping (CLS)

    Laboratory QualificationReport Part 1 (TTLQ-P1)

    Quali fy CP

    Techn. Transfer ProtocolProduction (TTPP)

    Execute Regulatory Activities

    Checklist Process

    Equipment

    Equivalency Report

    Part 1 (TTEQ-P1)

    Training Certificates(CETP)

    Training Certificates(CETQC)

    Laboratory QualificationReport Part 2 (TTLQ-P2)

    Technology TransferReport QC (TTRQC)

    Equivalency Report

    Part 2 (TTEQ-P2)

    Techn. Transfer ReportProduction (TTRP)

    Product TransferMaster Report (PTMR)

    End

    Remarks: CPChemical Product; 1) for more detail s please see Handbook

    Production TransferQC Transfer

    North to Phase V Product Transfers:

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    44/49

    44

    GATE 4

    GATE 3

    GATE 2

    GATE 1

    North to Phase V Product Transfers:

    Project Phases / Responsibilities

    North to Phase V Product Transfers:

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    45/49

    45

    GATE 8

    GATE 7

    GATE 6

    GATE 5

    North to Phase V Product Transfers:

    Project Phases / Responsibilities

    North to Phase V Product Transfers:

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    46/49

    46

    GATE 9

    Project Phases / Responsibilities

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    47/49

    Confidential 47

    3) Technology transfer deliverables

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    48/49

    Handbook for Transfers of Chemical Products V02

    48/102 January 17, 2007

    Scope of Transfer Process (1)

    Establish Product Transfer Master Plan

    Prepare Technology Transfer QC

    Execute Technology Transfer QC

    IChC decision (Start)

    Execute Technology Transfer Production

    Release as additional Manufacturer (End)

    ...

    Qualify API (by MP)

    CRC

    ApplicationEstablish Product Transfer Master

    Report

    Remarks: 1) Start of production of transfer batches; MP Manufacturing Pharma; CRC Change Review Committee; IChC International

    Chemicals Committee

    Tech Transfer

    Execute regulatory activities

    Laboratory Qualification 1)

    Equivalency of API

    Time

    Prepare Technology Transfer Production

    MP Approval

    ...

    The Tech Transfer starts with a decision to transfer continues with the transfer of

    (documented) knowledge, the demonstration of ability of the receiving unit to

    manufacture the product to the satisfaction of all involved parties and ends with

    successfully regulatory variations and the release as additional manufacturer.

    Manage project

    conceptual

  • 8/10/2019 Approach to Technology Transfer Bob Beall

    49/49

    Confidential 49