ARIEL CASTRO - WEWSmediaassets.news5cleveland.com/uploads/WEWSArielCastroRecord… · Ariel Castro Professional Driver, East 49 St. Depot Attached please find a letter from Ann Carlson,

ARIELCASTRO

DISCIPLINEFILE

LLevel.AINUMETROPOUTAN

SCHOOL DISTRICTvision to victory Nicholas P. Jackson

Deputy Chief,Business Operations

1380 East Sixth Street, Cleve/and, OH 44114 216.574.8147 - Fax 216.574.8120 www.cmsdnet nelChief Executive Officer

Eric S. Gordon

Bosniof Education MEMORANDUMDenise W. Unk

Chair

Louise P. Dempseyvicechair TO: Serena Houston-Edwards, Deputy Chief -a

Patricia Crutchfield Human R.

-ces

Robert M. Heard, Sr.Wifletta A. Milam

Shaletha T. Mitchell FROM: Nichol . kson, Deputy ChiefIris M. Rodriguez Busirress Oe tions

Lisa Thomas .4

Eric L Wobser -a

DATE: October 10, 20 2 m oEx Officio Members

Dr. Ronald M. BerkmanDr. Jerry Sue Thornton SUBJECT: Support of Termination

Ariel CastroProfessional Driver, East 49 St. Depot

Attached please find a letter from Ann Carlson, Director of Transportationrecommending termination for Ariel Castro, Professional Driver, East 496 St.Depot.

After review of the information contained in the letter, I support herrecommendation. Therefore, please move forward with the termination of ArielCastro.

If you have any questions or need further information, pleases contact me.

NPJ: san

Attachment

cc: Patrick Zohn, Chief Operating OfficerAnn Carlson, Director, Transportation

The primary goal of the Øeve/and Metropolitan SchoolDistrict is to becomea premier school district in the United States of America

CLEVEl,ANDMETROPOUTAN

SCHOOL DISTlUCT. * Vision10viclo<y

Ann CarlsonDirectoi, Transportation Depaitment

3832 Ridge Road, Cleveland, OH 44144 Office:216,634.7021 Fax 216.634-7025 www.cmsdnet netChief Executive Offiœr

Eric 5. Gordon

IBoard of Education Memorandum

Denise W. Unk 'BoardChair

t.ouiseP, oeropsey To: Nick Jacksonvicechair Deputy Chief, Transportation & Facilities

Patricia CrutchfieldRobert M. Heard, Sr. From: Ann CarlsonShaletha T. Mitchell DÎreCtOr, TranSPOrtatiOD

Willetta A. MilamIris M. RodriguezDr. Lisa Thomas Date: October 9, 2012

Eric L Wobser

Ex Officio Members R€: Afiel CBStfO,Dr. Ronald M. Berkman PrOfeSSional Driver,East 49 St. DepotDr. .lerry Sue Thornton

Charges: Class I, #11 - Unauthorized Use of DivisionEquipment

Mr. Castro is receiving this charge as a resultof leaving his bus at Scranton Schoolfrom 9:30 a.m. until 1:30 p.m. on September 20, 2012. Mr.Castro's explanation wasthat his preschool route was cancelledthatday and since he only lives two blocksaway, he went home.

Mr.Castro said that he did not know about the cancellation; however that notice wasmade over the radio and posted within the depot severaldays-before Septernber 206.He did not notify the depot nor dispatch that he was leaving the unit unattended.

This is Mr. Castro's fourth demonstration of lack of judgment. He has previously beensuspendedsixtydays for leaving a childon a bus; sixtydays for makingan illegalu-turn in rush hour trafficwith a bus load of students, and, last schoolyear for usingthe bus to do his grocery shopping.

I am recommending his termination.

/ac

Xc: Kevin Marino, WinfordTerrentine, Depot Manager, E. 49 St. DepotNick Hascka, Viœ President, Local 407Ariel Castro, Professional Driver,E. 49 St. Depot

The primary goal of the Geveland Metropolitan School Districtis to becomea prernier school district in the United States,

www.cmsdnet.net

CLEVELANDMETROPOLITAN

SCHOOL DISTRTCT Transportation Divisioni . I Vision to Victory

DATE

MEETINGNOTICE

TO: C 4 /

FROM: Kevin Marino

DATE: TIME: TS.ÀLOCATION: /Dgg ¿pg

Be advised that on the above date you are to appear before the Directoron the above charges.

Results of this meeting can and may result in suspension or termination.

I acknowledgethat the above has been discussed with me and understand mysignature does not imply agreement or disagreement.

EMPLOYEE S1GNATURE DATE

The primary goal of the Cleveland Metropolitan School District is to become a premier school district inthe United States of America.

REV 05-04-01 DOT 23

1380 East Sixth Street, Cleveland, Ohio 44114(216) 574-8500 Fax: (216) 574-8139

DIVISt0N OF SAFETY AND SECURITY

1380 East Si×thStreet BUS # tClevealand. Ohio 44114

(216)574-8552 SCHOOL SC&½(INCIDENTREPORT

YS NOON SCHOOL PROPERTY REGION: incident Report # Event #GANG RELATED

lNCIDENT LOCATION ADORESSOR SCHOOL NAME: SCHOOL NUMBER

INctDENT TITLE (S): DAYOF WEEK: DATE: TIME:

if time of incident is unknown use these blocks to give the start and stop of the timespan duringwhich the incident occurred.

Victim NAME: SEX: D.O.B: RACE: CMSD FDOR SSAN:SuspectOtherADDRESS &ZIP CODE: TELEPHONE #: GUARDIA 4 tF JUVENILE:

Victim NAME: SEX: D.O.B: RACE: CMSD ID OR SSAN:SuspectOtherADDRESS ZIP CODE: TELEPHONE #: GUARDIAN IF JUVENILE:

Victim NAME: SEX: D.O.B: RACE: MSD ID OR SSAN:SuspectOtherADDRESS & ZlP CODE: TELEPHONE #: GUARDIAN IF JUVENILE:

CPD CALLED: YES NO, RESPONDED: YES NO , CAR# BADGE #S , ,

ARREST MADE:YES NO , ARRESTING OFFtCER'S NAME BADGE

CONFISCATION MADE: YES NO , ITEM , CONFISCATINGOFFICER BADGE IF CPD

CPD CALLED: YES NO RESPONDED: YES NO , UNIT#S , .

BUILDINGEVACUATED: YES NO , TIME STARTED TIME RETURNED TO BUILDINGDAMAGETO BUILDING: YES NO , IF DAMAGE ESTJMATEVALUE $

EMS CALLED: YES NO , RESPONDED: YES NO , UNIT#S INCLUDING ANY DFD:

INJURIES: YES NO .NUMBER MINOR SERIOUS.SEVERE . FATAL

TRANSPORTS: YES NO ,NUMBER TRANSPORTED , TRANSPORTED TO O

OTHER AGENCYCALLED: RESPONDED: YES NOPERSONAL CONTACTED:

PERSON SU NG THlS REPORT: (Print Name)

S)GNATURE - DATEIF REPORT:PERSON TAKINGCALL:

SUPERVISOR'S RECOMMENDATION

FOLLOW UP: CLOSE: REFERRED TO:

FINAL ACTlON:

SIGNATURE: DATE:

t '

e en6 Lo sc<4N Lo ry seÁeo o /' AÑA--e-«

Ne kW/ev 9 63o e4 ao «A + saheduÁEoÑ eensc Aso/ eris ds/s ode. Temi' aocME vo va -.T/af+ A-; buse+rteef//N Woa+e & Le P< oc l' AdË

4( go,d Ao e sso blocks +-w4s,

r me d-a exed 4 ok t' / e /* L-,« ad o

ya -w w+ Eo 9ÿ*' p- Ne A M /oe Se de pm , Road A; ree/o de

ymWÁgw a s esuaa e,L ça 4gday .

is Rex3o Nort leau i mg k vi -ÉÁ«reeU

bus MS se coP E¯d Ge ff , g . wesh hom e' 60ges give 6 e chi helpt <f beged mÄkra syy koué62 4A+k-- yr c h Eb ce> om op c,Œ4Ef é d e'e EcÍ << cLa y SE gasto s stwo -ecÁool so & 476 67 kiwÑ N Øk/MP

e x.<9 o ik PA t ar -Redtcf o - ,4 go | 0 9 / 1 6

.

A uk arf R,M casseo

6 & se<+RLoy seÁ(ooÁA-(GegNek /y/ep 9 .3 o -Ko g a a so -d à Jp

pee se Aco/ M S Ä* o ŸC , dæ k ØsE vo ava (wŠc .T &q at bus

(<Wt it Ÿ«o a se & Le re A e e, f gl .

( g «--d Å,o edoo á ( ockr go 4 , ,

r em « ed « mk 'te /elen a eos - o ey + 6 o e,

o cio a , Road res/di o .+ s es«s/ 2 cLay ,

t's Rea3og ÑO €œU (_MÇ v rdebox as seco me-/ aof/f, I wesh homenoweak-, Ove 6er i helpt rf beged mÃKM 4-- Ny &OU ~6 US A+ w Åh Eg de ty ER eg eny Géfé 4<'e E<Á it cLAy, Te yo6oy sM ecAcel so f di 'Ab/ kiukAN Eks'NP

u2 en «'tik Ro ¯r or f-Ác--af79 I477

herk s;V i d /w, M ca à¡\

Page 1 of I

bus 978Troy Beadlingto:Winford Terrentine09/20/2012 11:02 AM

Cc:Ivette Colon, Ann CarlsonShow Details

This email is to inform you that bus 978 sat vacant outside my school buildingfromapproximately9:30 am until1:30 pm. I made announcements and checked affrestrooms in my buildingto see if the driver was here andreceived no response. The bus door was unlocked and partiallyopened so I entered the bus to see if the driverwas on the bus and helshe was not. The bus was parked in the lane that wouldbe used by the fire dept if we hadan emergency. Cars wereable to get through, but I am not sure if large emergencyvehicles would have beenable to make it. Sergeant Fortson was at Scranton yesterday to see thisand shared the same concerns we had atScranton. Please let me know if there is anything more I need to do with thissituation and please keep meinformed. Trianks!

Troy BeadlingPrincipalScranton

216.621.2165

file://C:\Documents and Settings\carlan01\Local Settings\Temp\notesFCBCEE\~web8586.... 9/24/2012

MEETING NOTICE

TO: BONNIE NEWELL

FROM: CHARLES JENKINS, DEPOT MANAGER

DATE: May 24, 2012

SUBJECT: DISCIPLINARY MEETING

CHARGES: Class I, #23 DISREGARD FOR THE SAFETY OFPASSENGERS

DATE:_ TBD ÛCA/4: TIME: 10:OOam

Be advised that on the above date you are to appear before the Directorof Transportation on the above charges.

Results of this meeting can and may result in discipline up toTermination.

I acknowledge that the above has been discussed with me andunderstand my signature does not imply agreement or disagreement.

mpfoyee Signature <Date

CLEVELANDMETROPOUTEN

SCHOOL DISTRICTal Vision to Victory

Human Resources Department

1380 East Sixth Street, Cleveland,OH 44114 - 216 348-4564 Fax 216.574.8072· www.cmsdnet.netEric S, Gordan

Chief Executive Offiœr

Board of EducationDen e n November 6, 2012

Louise P. Dempsey ARIEL CASTROVice Chair

2207 SEYMOURPatriciaCrutchfield CLEVELAND, OH 44113

Robert M. Heard, Sr.Willetta A. Milam

Shatetha T. Mitchell Dear MS. CASTRO:Iris M. Rodriguez

Dr. Lisa ThomasEric L Wobser As a result of your hearing held October4, 2012 a recommendation for termination

was made to the Board of Education. At its meeting October 23, 2012 the BoardEx-Officio MembersDr. Ronald M. Berkman concurred with this recommendation and, therefore, your termination will beDr. Jerry Sue Thomton effective Tuesday, November 6, 2012.

Please contact Robin Andrews at 547-8252 if you have any questions regarding yourbenefits.

Sincerely,

Serena ouston-EdwardsInterim Deputy Chief of Human Resources

cc: Eric Gordon,Chief Executive OfficerPatrick Zohn, Chief of OperationsWayne Belock, Deputy Chief of Legal ServicesNicholas Jackson, Deputy Chief of Transponation & FacilitiesAnn Carlson, Director of TransportationKevin Marino, Depot Manager, East 49* Street DepotMinford Terrentine, Depot Manager, East 496 Street DepotNick Haschka, Vice President, Local 407Personnel File

The primary goal of the Develand Hetropolitan School District is to becomea premier schoo/ district in the L/nitedStates of ß"

Resolution No. 2012- (B)

Title: AUTHORIZING THE TERMINATION OF A NON-TEACHING EMPLOYEE

The Chief ExecutiveOfficer of the Cleveland Municipal School District presents thefo]Jowing resolution for adoption:

WHEREAS, the Board of Educationof the ClevelandMunicipal School District isauthorized by Ohio Revised Code 3319.081 to terminatethe contracts of employment of non-teaching employees for:

a. Violation of written rules and regulations set forth by the board of education;or,

b. Incompetency, inefficiency, dishonesty, drunkenness, immoral conduct,insubordination, discourteous treatment of the public, neglect of duty, or anyother acts of misfeasance, malfeasance, or nonfeasance;

WHEREAS, it has been determined through the collective bargaining disciplinaryprocess that ARIEL CASTRO has committed violations of Districtpolicies, procedures andrules which warrant termination of employment, specifically, unauthorized use of divisionequipment; now, be it

RESOLVED, that upori the recommendation of the Chief Executive Officer that ARIELCASTRO be terminated due for:

Unauthorized use of division equipment; now, therefore be it

RESOLVED, that the Board of Education hereby authorizes and/or ratifies the action ofthe Chief Executive Officer and/or designee to terminate the employment of ARJEL CASTROand to take other appropriate action to implement this resolution.

CLEVELAND MUNICIPAL SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD OF EDUCATION

By:Eric S. Gordon Demse W. LinkChief Executive Officer

tardCh r

John ScanlanChief Financial and Administrative Officer

' CLEVELANDMETROPOLITAN

SCHOOL DISTRICT- veion to vetory Nicholas P. Jackson

Deputy Chief Business Operafíons

1380 East9xth Street, Develand, OH 44114 216.574.8147 · Fax 216.574.8120 www.cmsdnet.netChief Executive Officer

Ðic 5. Gordon

Board of Education MEMORANDUMDenise W. Link

Chair

Louise P. DempseyviceChair TO: Serena Bouston-Edwards,Deputy Chief

Patricia Crutchfield Human Re. cesRobert M.Èeard,Sr.

Willetta A. MilamShaletha T. Mitchen FROM: Nichola . kson, Deputy Chief

Iris M. Rodriguez Business Oe tionsLisa Thomas

Eric L. WobserDATE: October 10, 20 2

Ex Officio MembersDr. Ronald M. BerkmanDr. Jerry Sue Thornton SUBJECT: Support of Termination

Professional Driver, East 49th

Attached please find a letter from Ann Carlson, Director of Transportationrecommending termination for Ariel Castro, Professional Driver, East 49* St.Depot.

After review of the information contained in the letter, I support herrecommendation. Therefore, please move forward with the terminationof ArielCastro.

If you have any questions or need further information, pleases contact me.

NPJ: san

Attachment

cc: Patrick Zohn, Chief OperatingOfficerAnn Carlson, Director, Transponation

The prirrety.goa/ of the Gem/and Aletropo//tan School District ¡s to becomea premier school districtin the United States of America.

CLEVELANDMETROPOUTAN

SCHOOL DISTRICTvision lo vicory

Ann CarlsonDirector, Transporiation Department

3632 Ridge Road, Cleveland, OH 44144 Office: 216.634.7021 Fax 216 614-7025 · www.cmsdnet.netChief Executive Officer

Eric5. Gordon

Board of Education MemorandumDeriiseW. Unk

Board Chair

Louise P. Dempsey TO: NickJacksonvicechair Deputy Chief,Transportation & Facilities

Patricia Crutc.hfieldRobert M. Heard, Sr- From: Ann Carlson

Shaletha T. Mitc.bel!Willetta A. Milam DÍfêCtOr, TranSPOrtatÍODIris M. RodriguezDr. UsaThomas Date: October 9, 2012

EricL Wobser

Ex orrico members Re: Ariel Castro,Dr. Ronald M. Berkman Pr0fessional Driver,East 49 St. DepotDr. Jeny SueThornton

Charges: Class I, #11 - Unauthorized Use of Division Equipment

Mr. Castro is receivingthischarge as a result of leaving.his bus at Scranton Schoolfrom 9:30 a.m. until 1:30 p.m. on September 20, 2012. Mr.Castro's explanationwasthat his preschool route was cancelled that day and since he only lives two blocksaway, he went home.

Mr. Castro said that he did not knowabout the cancellation;however that notice wasmade over the radio and posted within thedepot several days before September 20"'He did not notifythe depot nor dispatch thathe was leaving the unit unattended.

This is Mr. Castro's fourth demonstration of lack ofjudgment.He has previously beensuspendedsixty days for leaving a childon a bus; sixty days for making an illegalu-turn in rush hour trafficwith a bus load of students, and, last schoolyear for usingthe bus to do his grocery shopping.


Jac

Xc: Kevin Marino, WinfordTerrentine, Depot Manager, E. 49 St. DepotNick Hascka, Vice President, Local 407Ariel Castro, Professional Driver,E. 49 St. Depot

The primary goal of the Develand Metropolitan School District is to becomea premier school district in the UnitedStates.

www.cmsdnet.net


SCH OOL DISTRICT Transportation Divisioni

,i Vision lo Victory

DATE

MEETINGNOTICE

TO: / C Ñ W

FROM: Kevin Marino

SUBJECT: rád/RVA/))L'l ß'JUAff

DATE: - TIME: TS.ALOCATION: / gg 2 ¿pyy-


Results ofthis meetingcan and may result in suspension or termination,

I acknowledge that the above has been discussed with me and understand mysignature does not imply agreement or disagreement.

EMPLOYEE SIGNATURE DATE

The prirnary goal of the Cleveland Metropolitan SchoolDistrict is to become a premier school district inthe United States of America.

REV 05-04-01 DOT 23

1380 East Sixth Street, Cleveland,Ohio 44114(216) 574-8500 Fax: (216) 574-8139

'CLEVEOND METROPOLITANSCHOOL DISTRICT

. DIVlS

t xt S

rEeTYAND SECURITY

BUS#.

Clevealand.Ohio44114

(216)574-8552 SCHOOL CÑA(INCIDENTREPORT

YES NO

ON SCHOOLPROPERTY REGION: Incident Repon # Event #GANG RELATED

JNCIDENT LOCATION ADDRESSOR SCHOOL NAME: SCHOOL NUMBËR

INCIDENT TITLE(S):. DAY OF WEEK: DATE: TIME:

if time of incident is unknown use these blocks togive the$1811and stop of thetimespan duringwhich the incident occurred.

Victim NAME: SEX: D.O.B: RACE: CMSD ID OR.SSAN:SuspectOtherADDRESS ZIP CODE: TELEPHONE #: GUARDIAN IF JUVENiLE:

Victim NAME: SEX: D.O.B: RACE: CMSD ID OR SSAN:SuspectOtherADDRESS &ZIP CODE: TELEPHONE#: GUAROlAN JF JUVENILE:

Victim NAME: SEX: D.O.B: RACE: CMSD 10 OR SSAN:SuspectOtherADDRESS &ZJP CODE: TELEPHONE#: GUARDIAN JF JUVENILE:

CPD CALLED: YES NO, RESPONDED: YES NO , CAR# BADGE #S

ARREST MADE:YES NO. ARRESTING OFFICER'S NAME .. BADGE

CONFlSCATJON MADE: YES NO ITEM , CONFISCATING OFFICER BADGE tF CPD

CPD CALLED:YES NO , RESPONDED: YES NO , UNIT#S .BUILDING EVACUATED: YES NO , TIME STARTED TIME RETURNED TO BUILDING

DAMAGE TO BUILDING: YES NO . IF DAMAGEESTIMATEVALUE $EMS CALLED: YES NO . RESPONDED: YES NO . UNIT #S INCLUDING ANY OFD:

INJURIES: YES NO ,NUMBER MINOR SERt0US , SEVERE . FATAL

TRANSPORTS: YES NO ,NUMBER TRANSPORTED TRANSPORTEDTO

OTHERAGENCYCALLED: RESPONDED:YES NOPERSONAL CONTACTED:

PERSON SU NG THIS REPORT: (Print Name)

SIGNATURE - DATEIF REPORT:PERSON TAKINGCALL:

SUPERVISOR'S RECOMlÝ\ENDATION

FOLLOW UP: CLOSE: REFËRRED TO:

FINAL ACTION:

SIGNATURE: DATE:

ey 6 & sc 4N Lo a seÁto o AÑ-&-FR

iMe k,W/sp 9 :3 o -bo /4¾ 4 sooÑ etAscAoc/ & day eW.Te essoeXE A.coA'ava v'ic.TGd44vbv<

w-«fc ti/ cQ Booke LE Tch e e. ( gË4((G,d io iMoo 6/ceks N ,

«=+a wed 4 mk 'i o le « pod e--wei+ o 4ÿ*' p- Ne A cd- c/oe È

o dá.pm -R 04e¯ Ai <ce/m.WWWMY Mid LVw a s ce de 4 s,-L Fok N Ar<dpyy .

Ës Rea3o ·ÑOR €¤-U f.Mp Lug ÈÅi<bosons secue :laoff, -T wesh homodomea±-,2,vr 6er Le/parf beged wikM on y R_o u '6 Es 4- A+ N

C~ÁbEb d à t, c eg e

'Eipé'{+ </med < cLay; Tässac6ow /M -eci oc Í Jo 4-- 4 6 i k i M AN 6 K s'

9 « ik ese f or i FAOÌ09/T

.

I, t/

cxav

Page 1 of I

bus 978TroyBeadlingto:Winford Terrentine09/20/2012 11:02 AMCc:IvetteColon, Ann CarlsonShow Details

This email is to inform you that bus 978 satvacant outside my schoolbuilding from approximately9:30 am until1:30 pm. I made announcements andchecked all restrooms in mybuilding to see if the driver was here andreceived no response. The bus door was unlocked and partially opened so i entered the bus to see if the driverwas on the bus and helshe was not. The bus was parked in the lane that would be used by the fire dept ifwe hadan emergency. Cars were able to get through,but i am not sure if large emergency vehicles would have beenable to make it. Sergeant Fortson was at Scranton yesterday to see thisand sharedthe same concerns we had atScranton. Please let me know if there is anything more I need to do withthis situation and please keeP meinformed Thanks!

Troy BeadlingPrincipalScranton216.621.2165

clovelantiMunicipalS °s", ,c B nansportation

To: Ariel Castro

. Professional Driver

From: Mickey Brown, DirectorTransportation

Date: March 18, 2004

Subject: Suspension

As a resuit of a discipiinary meeting heiò on liiarch 15, 2004 for "Distegard for theSafety of Passengers" (child left unattended on the bus), a recommendation of a sixty(60) day suspension without pay was rnade.

Per the agreement between the Cleveland Municipal School District and the TeamstersLocal 407, it is the employee's option that suspension may be imposed by a reduction ofvacation days up to the maximum accumulated vacation, or by serving the actual daysof suspension.

Please be advised that the serving of actual days of suspension could effect yourattendance incentive and depending upon the number of suspension days, it couldeffect your scheduled pay.

I agree to the following:

Suspension reduced from vacation days -

Suspension by serving actual daysFeb. 3 thru March 3, 2004-March 16 thru April 13, 2004 A.M. only

Employee Signaturecc: Operations

Personnel

Rev. 10-21-99 DOT 71

3832 Ridge Road. Cleveland. Ohio 44144(216) 634-7013 Fax {216) 634.7025

TO: ARIEL CASTRO

FROM: ANN CARLSONWINTERRENTINE

SUBJECT: DISCIPLINARYHEARING

Be advised that you wil be scheduled for a disciplinaryhearing to held with theDirector of Transportation on charges of : .

CLASS I VIOLATION: §y)#22. UNAUTHORIZED STOP .

#29. FAILURE TO FOLLOW PROPER RADIO PROCEDURESCLASS II VIOLATION:# 35. FAILURE TO EFFECTIVELY CARRY OUT JOB DESCRIPTION ·

ACTIVITIES

The hearing will be held in the in the office of the Director located at the RIDGEROADfacility on Monday March 15, 2004 at 9:30am.

OcMickey BrownTheresa Brown

2Ÿgz &se 5sosessak

Ñ23 3 - :MV »mkW "

EQ W¿S .Fo ¼2 e

/'DF FC / A/o N//á l

vareh s

CLEVELAND POLICE DEPARTMENT Date: 03/04/2004OFFENSE/INCIDENT REPORT Page: 2

Case Ôescription: Case Number: 2004-00033260Child Endangering

Offense Date , . . : 01/26/2004 Victim Drug Related : NoVictim Alchl Related: No victim Comp Related : NoAbandoned Structure : NO Property Damage . .

Gang Related . . . : N Additional Subcode :

SUBJECTS:

Reporting. : Present InformationPrimary FRANKLIN,TATIANA,R, Phone: 216-658-0455

627 E 115 ST

CLEVELAND OH 44108

Race : Black Sex: FEMALE D.O.B: 12/16/78 Age: 25Hgt : 5'05" Wgt: 135 Hair: Brown Eyes . . : BrownDr Lic #: St:

Residence Type : Other/Unk Residence Status : ResidentStatement Type : Verbal Related Offenses : 1 2

Suspect , : Present InformationPrimary CASTRO,ARIEL,, Phone: 216-323-3527

Not Susp 2207 SEYMOUR AVCLEVELAND OH 4 4113

Race : Hisp (wht) Sext MALE D.O.B: 07/10/60 Age: 43Hgt : 5'08" Wgt: 180 Hair: Black Eyes . . : BrownBuild: Complexion: Ethnicity: PuertoRicoDr Lic #: RR988791 St: OH

Business: CLEVELAND PUBLIC SCH Phone: 216-578-8552

1380 E 6 ST

CLEVELAND OH 44104Residence Type : Other/Unk Residence status : ResidentStatement Type : Written Related Offenses : 1 2

Witness . : Present InformationPrimary JENNINGS,LOUISE,, Phone: 721-0278

1598 E 85 ST

CLEVELAND OH

Race : Black Sex: FEMALE - D.O.B: 12/27/43 Age: 60Hgt : " Wgt: Hair: Unknown Eyes . . : UnknownDr Lic #: St:

Business: CITY OF CLEVELAND Phone: 216-000-0000

44114Residence Type : Other/Unk Residence status : ResidentStatement Type : Verbal Related offenses : 1 2

ORIGINAL NARRATIVE (CASE}04-33260 (ABDUCTION/ENDANGERING CNILDREN/NS).

DRP) FRANKLIN DID STATE TRAT SHE WAS NOTIFIED ON ABOVE DATE AT

TRUCK DRIVERS UNIONLOCAL 407

Aflllat¢d with the InternatlanalBrotherhood of Transfers

3701 Bosworth RoadCleveland,Ohio 44111-6037

Room #204PRESIDEMTPhone: (216)6884833

BUSINESS REPRESENTA7WE Fußt 46MAM6FRANK BURDELL

V)CE PRESIDENTBUSINESS REPRESENTA1WE

NICK HASCHKA

SECRETARY-TREASURER

BUSINESS REPRE3£NTATWE

PAUL WOJNAR

FAX NO:216-781-4074

RECORDING SECRETARY

MICHAEL HIENTON pg ggg_gggg

TRUSTEBB

J. K. TANSKI

GREG ROBERSON ÀClrian ThompsonJEFF THEODUS

BUSINESS REPRESENTATtvEs FKM: Pam OgborinaDENNIS ROBERTS

J. D. SMITH . .

PAMELA L OGBONNA P COUR -

JESS W. WOODY

KEVINJ.PATTON SENT CN 3-4-04 AT 9:35 A.M. A.M.JP.M.

COMMENTS:

TRANSMISSION VERIFICATION REPORT

TIME : 83/04/2004 10:45NAME :FAX :

TEL :

DATE,TIME . 63/04 18:43FAX NO./NAME 97814674DURATION 08: 01: 35PAGE(5) 64RESULT OKMODE STANDARD

ECM

nePrint Only

erat ions . . .

RouteBus # Actual In Actual Out

50NIid-day ount Head count Accumulated Miles

.

FTSRNOON --

------- -- 7600 AD2 DARK AVE

iver / Att Signature

L/C 0 1.2207)

o 2.49

(07)0 4.18

iper or

'ARNING: Any Alterations to time sheet wiúresult in forfeiture fACE

lime entered

White - Payroll • Yellow - Supervisor • Pgimþy

./05/2004 2age 2

J Report

y period

7e01/26/2004

.<, ARIEL 290692925 200 515 - 5 00 10GE 1 . REGULAR

10 IN Dept ACTrytyy ,

2c 01/17 Unscheduled 00= ID IN Depjan 01/LG..Unscheduled ......

ACTIVITY 097Non 01/19 ASSENTTue 01/20 617a*:?ue 01/20 1023e*V 942a*L 15.92)

ed 01/21 Gl6a-E ESP*E 3.42 3.42Wed 01/21 1300-E 100Sa-Y 6.53 9.95Thu 01/22 617ass 4599*5 3.82 13.77Thu 01/22 117e•y 930a 3-48 17.25Pri 01/2] 613a*E 506p 3.22 20.17Sat 01/24 Unscheduled '? 2.82 24.23Sun.01/25 Unscheduled 0-00 24.28Mon 01/26, 616a*EMon 01/26 1010a-V 930a

ACCt:RIDGE 1 3,23 27.520.00 23.52

Totals: 2200.32 00N pap

FS -|c- É£'Áy - La ey

// s dom / & 44,e/ved' x Àso Ao /¿s 2 4 og J-«-W-yve-a o&«

A Úf2 ÁR<> C// A/G S e- Éob PRoCes e o..Â¾ÅnA *¾« u c r/ + = Á><&sc R e/ >< e -

T me keÁ w r£ ica/ T AN SA;e /7 ( y A sse e-E

, Ed & p , wewr he rio de./e§foxrs ', Ic +//e esle ÃaA knoco 44 4, émig/w& As a-Zadem,A A k do sdoof GE AC

e A- / 1 á¯á 6 4 /†ck 40 C

toa Le ook44e e de C

c Á¯::&c Á 4 d,E eS i e xÀ 4 e Ë 66¯4 « Afs- omäWN d-A Ark / K/

Øsd U/w hee Á 7¾¤ « -ew s arke '

>8552

INCIDENTREPORTNO

ONSCHOOLFROPERTY REGION: incident Report # Event *GANGRELATED

INCIDENT LOCATIONADDRESS OR SCHOOLNAME: SCHOOL NUMBER

INCIDENT TITLE (S): OAY OF WEEK' DATE: TIME:

If time of incident is unknown use these blocks to give the stan ard stop of the timespan duringwhich the incident occurred.

Áctim NAME:. SEK . D.O.13: RACE: CMSDID OR SSAN:

>uspect

)thertDDRESS ZIP CODE: . TELEPHONE# GUARDIANIF JUVENILE:

ictim NAME: SEX: D.O.B: RACE: CMSDID OR SSAN:uspectther3DRESS &ZIP CODE: TELEPHONE# GUARDIAN tF JUVENILE:

Mm NAME: SEX , D.O.B: RACE: CMSD ID OR SSANspect

'

1er

DRESS & Z)P CODE:.., ,- .- TELEPHONE#: GUARO1ANIFJUVENJLE:

) CALLED: YES NO , RESPONDED: ¥ES NO , CAR# BADGE #S

lEST MADE: YES NO , ARREST1NGOFFIGER'S·NAME ..

- BADGE

IFISCATIONMADE:YES NO , ITEM , CONFISCATNGOFFICER BADGE lF CPD

CALLED: YES NO i, RESPONDED: YES NO , UNÍT#S ,

DING EVACUATED: YES NO , TIME STARTED TIMERET1JRNED TO BUILDING

AGE TO BUlLblNè: YES NO .

, IF DAMAGEESTlMATEVALUE5CALLED: YES NO ,.RESPONDED: YES NO , UNIT#S JNCLUDINGANY DFD:RIES: YES NO ,NUMBERMINOR SERIOUS , SEVERE , FATAL

:SPORTS: YES NO NUMBERTRANSPORTED . TRANSPORTED TO

:R AGENCY CALLED: ' RESPONDED: YES NO;ONALCONTACTEDON SUSMi i INGTH RE RT: rint Name) pf-·$ r y

ATURE /\ DATE.iERERORT: -

ONTAK)NG GALL ¯¯"^¯

SUP.ERVISOR'S RECOMMENDATION .

)W UP: CLOSE: REFERRED TO:

«CTION:

l]RE: DATE:

NARR-\T. Pt -e

.

NLIUCÏN I KCttKl INUlvitta

nerve yo,eA >F 37 04 - ½gO ar/r,<< RP V

S en o r'- d-c sdarfu me B s,P Sc44

I ca +c le vev arv =_.me.-+xe car 90/ ¯

c 4- c Á¿& veo c.4-ut.

c A Ät'Mc'. R ReW D A

'Ás e no be.c,40SC

C se No Ne ce oc/<!«»t' osA 'r

THE CLEv .ANDMUNICIPALSCHOOLDISTRICT War 20032004ATTENDANCE RECO D

Ernployee Nam Q, r € Employee ID No. Site r y Hire Date

MT WT F MT WT F M :T WT \F MTWT F MT WT F ABSENCE CODE

July 1 2 3 4 7' 8 9 10 11 14 15 16 2_1 22_ 23 24 25 26 29 30 y ^ - Personar

0-- -- -- --- -- ---- -- AE - Absent Doctor E×cuse1 4 5 5 7 8 11_ 12 13 14 15)_19 20 21 22 25 26 7 28 29

8 - Personal Business·SP Priv.Septem er 1 2 3 4

,5 8 9 10 11 12 15 16 17 18 19 22 23 24 25 26 29 30 .

0- - - ----- --...-----._ - c. Personal eusinesswio pay

1 2 3 6 7 8 9 10 3 14 15 16 17 20 21 22 23 24 27 28 29 30 31 o -Famity lliness

.

E- Death in FamilySovember 3 4 5 6 7 10 11 12 13 14 .17 18 19 20 21 24 25 26 27 28

- G - Leave or absence with pay |

3ecember 1 2 3 4 5 8 9 10 11 12 15 16 17 18 19 22 23 24 25 26 29 30 31 H - Leave or absence w/o pay

/0 0lanuary 1 2 6 7 8 9 12 13 14 15 16 19 20 21 22 23 26 27 26 29 30

0 ff g~£' O x -vacation

2 3 4 5 6 9 10 11 12 13 16 17 18 19 20 23 24 25 26 27 L - Jury DutyC gg i

.

4--M - Transfer to or from school

/larch 1 2 3 4 5 8 9 10 11 12 15 16 17 18 19 22 23 24 25 26 29 30 31

1 6 7 8 9 2 13 14 15 16 2 20 21 22 23 26 27 LE - Left early

3 4 5 6 7 ) 11 12 13 14 2 18 19 20 21 24 25 26 27 28 31 LL - Long Lunch

0 T - Tardy

une 1 2 3 4 7 8 9 10 11 14 15 16 17 18 21 22 23 24 25 28 29 30.. - -- - -- WOP - Without Pay

TRANSPORTATIOA DlV1SION - OPERATI NS MAINTENANCE NWD - Non Work Day

pecial Remarks

CLEVEi.ANl)METROPOl.lTAN

. .. vanovaise. Ann Carlson

interiin Transportation Director

Eugene T.W. Sanders, Ph.D.Chief Exewtive Office;

Boardof Education TO: N1CKJACKSONsoucaM. Neard, se. DEPUTY CHIEFOF OPERATIONS

Grady P. 0:Irrows

v.re o"" FROM: ANN CARLSONsasunionmaintion INTERIM DIRECTOR

Louise P. Dempsey,

. TRANSPORTATIONHarvey A. Hopksos, )r.

Denise W, Linkwiilen.u.Muam DATE: April 30, 2009

NMalie L. PetersoitIris M. Rodriguer

RE: Ariel Castroexoraciomemoe's ProfessionalDriverDr. MirlMel SdiwMt E 49th Depot

Mr. Castro had a disciplinaryhearingon April 15, 2009 on the followingcharges:Class I Item 23: Disregard for the safety of passengersClass II Item 2: Negligence or carelessness in the performance of workthat adverselyaffects quality,equipmentor personal safety.

The charges stem from witness statements documenting that Mr, Castromade a u-turn in front ofRG Jones elementaryschool on W 1506 at4:00pm with students aboard. This action was not only dangerous to thestudents and other motorists it was totallyunnecessary. Mr. Castro knewthere was a street on which to make a left tum less than a quarter blockfrom the pick up area in front of the school, and acknowledged both that hehad enough time on his route to safelymake that turn and that trafficonthat street at that time is heavy.I recommend a sixty day suspension.

Cc. Eric Taylor, Winn TerrentineDepot Managers, E 49th

7710¡VitunryU.UlvillieGve/ruhlit/cIng>alittinSC/100/Districtis10QCCorni aprenti,rSchool(/ishicito the Uin/cd States of Anterica.

k Clevelant!MetropolitanSchoolDistrict '"""°"'"°"

4/3/09

DATE

MEETING NOT]CE

TO: Ariel Castro

FROM: Eric Taylor

SUBJECT: Disciplinary Meeting

CHARGES: Class I Item 23: Disregard for the safety of passengers.

Class II Item 2: Negligence or carelessness in the performance of

Work that adversely affects quality, equipment or personal safety.

DATE: TB ' f TIME: TBA / wnf

LOCATION: y Ridge Road




EMPLOYEE SIGNATURE DATE

The primary goal of the Cleveland Metropolitan School District is to become a premier school district inthe United States of America.

REV 05-04-01 DOT 23

P.005

APR-02-2003 16:15 RGAones CSOSS

l CLEVELAND MUNICIPAL SCHOOL DISTRICT #WITNESS STATEMENT

investigator - incident Number

SCHOOL t'AJ2-

INCIDENT DATE / / INCIDENT TIME : am pm REPORT DATE / I ÛMark One: STUDEN THER Mark On WITNESS SU¾PECT VICTIM RACE

SS # or Student ID BIRTHDATE . - SEX (circia one) M F

LAST NAM FIRST NA M

ADDRESS

PHONE . PARENT / GUARD1AN

STATEMENT

(CONTINUEON REVERSE SIDE tF MORE SP(ACE IS NEEDED)

i DECLARE THis STATEMEWT TO BE ACCURATE Aþ AS EEN TAKEN sEPARARATELY WITH NO OTHER WITNESSES PRESENT

WITNESS SIGNATURE DATE:

STATEMENT DICTATED TO AND WRITTEN RV·

P.004

RO Jones CSO99APR-02-2009 16.15

CLEVELAND MUNICIPAL SCHOOL DISTRICT *WITNESS STATEMENT

investigator incident Numb

SCHOOL , ,

INCIDENT DATE I $ I INCIDENT TIME :/ am / REPORT DATE i i

Mark One: STUDENT EMPLOYEE OTHER Mark On W NESS, USPECT VICTIM RACE

SS # or Student ID BIRTHDATE . . SEX (circle one) M F

LAST NAME FIRST N MI

ADDRESS CITY

PHONE 2( PARENTI GUARDIAN

(CONTINUE ON REVERSESIDE \F MORE SPIAcE is NEEDED)

i DECLARE THIS STATEMENT T BE CURATE AND T T IT HAS BEdN TAKEN SEPARARATELY wtTH NOOTHER WITNESSES PRESENT

WITNESS SIGNATURE:

STATEMENT DICT ""

P.003

RG Jones CSOSSAPR-02-2009 16:16

CLEVELA.ND MUNICIPAL SCHOOL DISTRICT eWITNESS STATEMENT

lavestigator incident Nur

SCHOOL \ffff\ T . A (FY\ph

INCIDENTDATE I I INCIDENT TIME : Ì am REPORT DATE I I Û

Mark One: STUDENT EMPLOYEE OTHER Mark One WITNESS SUSPECT VICTIM RACE

SS # or Student ID BIRTHDATE - . SEX (circle one) M F

L.ASTNAM FIRST NAME MI

ADDRESS CITY \ IP

PHONE PARENT I GUARD AN

(COWTINVE ON REVERSESIDE IF MoAE SP ACE15 NEEDEO)

i DECLARE THIS STATEMENT To BE ACCURATE AND THAT IT HAS BEEN TAKEN SEPARARATELY WITH NO OTHER WITNESSES PRESENT

WlTNESS SIGNATURE: O .

STATEMENT DICTATED

APR-02-2009 16:15 RO Jones CSOSS P.002

CLEVELAND MUNICIPAL SCHOOL DISTRICT #WITNESS STATEMENT

nvestigator incident Number

SCHOOL

NCIDENT DATE / / INCIDENT TIME : am REPORT DATE I I

Mark One: STUDENT EMPLOYEE Matk On NE ) SUSPECT VICTIM RACE

SS # or Student ID BIRTHDATE - - SEX (circle one) M F

LAST NAME FIRST NAME Mt

ADDRESS r CITY ZP

PHONE PARENT [ GUARDIAN

TEMENT

(CONTINUE ON REVERSE SIDE 1FMORE SP(ACE IS NEEDED}

Dect..ARE THISSTATEIEWT BE ACC E A AT IT M SEPARARATELY WITH No OTHER TNESSESPRESENT

CLEVELANDMFTROPOI.iT

Joshua J. Gunvalsen

Eugene T.W. Sanders, Ph.D.Chief Executive OtTicer

iBoard of EducationRobert M. Heard, Sr.

Chair

Gr dy P. Bistrows 1

Rashidah Abdu1haqq :

Louise P. DempseyHarley A. Hopfen, Jr. ;

Denise W. Link |winettaA. Milam i A ril 8, 2009Natalie L. Petelon j PIris M, Rodriguez

To Whoñalt May Concern:Ex OfMcio AlembersDr. ochaelschwartz Good morning. I am writing in regards to one of our bus drivers,Mr. Castro. Ior, arrysuerhornt°" understandthat Mr. Castro is being called in for a hearing regarding a "u-turn"

incident. I was not in the buildingat the time, so I did not wítness what occurred. Ican not speak to the specific incident involviiig Mr. Castro, but I do want to say thatI have known Mr. Castro to be an effective bus driver. I have witnessed him tryingto work with students, familiesand myself to handle student issues. If you havequestions about the kind of servicethat Mr. Castrohas provided to my school, pÍeasecontact me at the schooL

espe

. J. Gunvalsen

77mcoinary gcal of ?!:eCi veland Men;pohan Schoci District is 10 beccinea premier 5000/ distra to the UG|Œd S?aies GTA;nfika

ELAND METROPOLITAN SCHOOL DISTRIßT Year 2009-2010 'oNDe aCnEeR

Employee ID No Site Hire Date Ä fŸ 9/

Mi14 W Ti Ý& lÚTú WT¾ FRMiå V½Ti a M.: 4 W:$if ABSENÇQcdDE

1 2 3 6 7 8 9 10 13 14 15 16 17 20 21 22 23 24 27 28 29 30 31A - Personal {Sick Day)

3 4 5 6 7 10 11 12 13 14 17 18 19 20 21 24 25 26 27 28 31 AE - Absent DoctorExcuse

1 2 3 4 7 8 9 10 11 1 15 16 17 18 21 22 23 Ò45 28 29 30 B - Personal Businesp(Soecial Pdvilege)

O .

.Cd - CC .

1 2 5 6 7 8 9 12 13 14 15 16 19 20 21 22 28 27 28 29 30.

C - Personal Business w/o pay

O . Œ d CCC d,. L D - Familyillness2 3 4 5 6 9 10 11 12 13 16 17 18 19 20 23 24 25 26 2 30

O O. ( .

E- Death in Family

1 2 3 4 7 8 9 10 11 21 22 23 24 25 28 29 30 3 G - Leave or abseqCe withpay

. OO : 6 (snowoav)1 5 6 7 8 11 12 13 14 15 18 19 20 .21 22 25 26 27 28 29 O - Leave erabsence wlo pay

O O 3J - Sçhool busines;

1 2 3 4 5 8 9 10 11 12 15 16 17 18 19 22 23 24 25 26 (ABSH:UnionavstnessiO

1 2 3 4 5 8 9 10 11 12 15 16 17 18 19 22 23 24 25 26 29 30 31 N-vagation

' ' & L •)ury Dúty.

1 2 5 6 7 8 9 12 13 14 15 16 19 20 21 22 23 26 27 28 29 30M - Tran¢ertoor from sc49ci

3 4 5 6 7 10 11 12 13 14 17 18 19 20 21 24 25 26 27 28 31 .o - Holidav

LE- t,eftearly1 2 3 4 7 8 9 10 11 14 15 16 17 18 21 22 23 24 25 28 29 30

LL . Long Lunch

TRANSPORTATION DIVlSION- OPERATIONS MAINTENANCE /f T - Tardv

Specla1Remarks WOP - Without Pay

BUS DRIVERPERFORMANCEEVALUATION

Employee: p Date:

JobTide:, à < Check Ride: Yes No

Evaluation Period: - Check RIde Score

SEPT. NOV DEC FEB. MAR. * JUN.

KNOWLEDGE OF JOB:

Comply with Ohio pupil Transportalion Laws & Regulations. Ias estabilshed by the Ohio Department of Education and Ohio /Department of Highway Safety.Opetates theassigned bus over the established, approvedroutes and stops.Runs routes and makes pick-ups, drop-offs and arrives atschool jn a timely manner.Resourceful in meetingproblemsituations.

QUALITY OF WORK:Makes daily safely inspeclion of bus and records on proper

.

docurnentation and maintains a clean vehicle.Practices good pupil-management skills at all timesandreports improper behavior to school administratror.Conducts at least lwo emergency bus evacuationsyear.Reports mechanical defects and vandalism and allotherdamages in a timelymanner.Assist in the promötion of good public relations.

.

54321.54321543

TOTALS:

CLEVELAND MUNICIPALSCHOOL DISTRICT Year 2008-2009

Emp

oNy

eN

eR D

Employee ID NO Site ÁŽ§f Hire Date)/6Ÿ/

1 2 3 4 7 8 9 10 11 14 15 16 17 18 21 -22 23 24 25 28 29 30 31A - Personal (Sick Day)

1 4 5 6 7 8 11 12 13 14 15 18 19 20 21 22 25 26 27 28 29 AE - Absent Doctor Excuse

i 2 3 4 5 8 9 10 11 12 15 16 17 18 19 22 23 24 25 26 29 3 B - Personal Business(Soecial Privilege)

01 2 3 6 7 8 9 10 13 14 15 16 17 20 21 22 23 24 27 28 29 30 31 C-PersonalBusinesswlopay

0 / D -Fpmily Illness3 4 5 6 7 10 11 12 13 14 17 18 19 20 21 24 25 26 27 28

0 0 E- Death In Farnliy

1 2 3 4 5 8 9 10 11 12 15 16 17 18 19 22 23 24 25 26 29 30 31 G - Leave or absence with pay

0 0 0 isnow Davi

1 2 5 6 7 8 9 12 13 14 15 16 19 20 21 22 23 26 27 28 29 30 H -Leave or absence wlo pay0 0

2 3 4 5 6 9 10 11 12 13 16 17 18 19 20 23 24 25 26 27 busn BesSsiness)

0 J'2 3 4 5 6 9 10 11 12 13 16 17 18 19 20 23 24 25 26 27 30 31 K -vacation

4 - Juw Duty1 2 3 6 7 8 9 10 13 14 15 16 17 20 21 22 23 24 27 28 29 30

.

M - Transfer toor fromschool

1 4 5 6 7 8 11 12 13 14 15 18 19 20 21 2 25 26 27 28 29 O-Holiday

0 / LE - Left eady66 1 2 4 5 8 9 10 11 12 15 16 17 18 19 22 23 24 25 28 29 30

LL - Lonq Lunch

TRANSPORTATIONDIVlSION- OPERATIONSMAINTENANCE T - Tardv/5'

Special Remarks WOP - WithoutPay

NWp - Non Work Day

BUS DRIVER PERFORMANCE EVALUATION

Employee: gg Date:

Job Bde A< p, (// / -Check Ride: Yes No

Evaluation ariod: ¿d / Check Ride Score

SEPT. * NOV. DEC. * FE B. MAR. * JUN.I i

KNO\ÑLËDGE OF JOB:

Comply with Ohio pupilTransportation Laws &Regulations.as estabilshed by the Ohio Department of Education and Ohio /Department of Highway Safety.Opetales the assigned bus over the established, approvedroutes and stops.Runs routes and makes pick-ups, drop-offs and arrives atschool in a timely manner.Resourceful in meeting problemsituations.

QUAÚTY OF WORK:Makes dai\y safety inspection of bus and records on properdocumentation and maintains a clean vehicle,Practices good pupil-management skills at all times andreports irnproper behavior to school administratror.Conducts at least twoemergency bus evacuations year.Reports mechanical defects and vandalism and all otherdamages in a timely manner.Assist in the promotion of good public relations.

543 21543 2 1543 2 i

TOTALS:

CLEVELANDMETROPOUTANSCHOOLDISTRICT Year 2011-2012ATTENDANCE RECORDEmployee Name Employee ID No Site Wre Dat )

ABSENCECODE1 4 5 6 7 8 11 12 13 14 15 18 19 20 21 22 25 26 27 28 29

A - Personal (Sick Dav)

1 2 3 4 5 8 9 10 11 12 15 16 17 18 19 22 23 24 25 26 29 30 31 - AE - Absent Doctor Excuse

B - Personal Business1 2 5 6 7 8 9 12 13 14 15 16 19 20 21 22 2 6 27 28 29 30 (soecialerivilegel

o -

C- Personal Business wlo pay3 4 5 6 7 10 11 12 19 20 21 24 25 26 27

O - Farn ily IIIness

1 2 3 4 7 8 9 1 16 17 18 21 22 23 24 25 28 29 30 E- Death in Family

O O O G - Leave or absence withoav1 2 5 6 7 8 9 13 14 15 19 20 21 .22 23 26 27 28 29 30 (snowcavi

. O H - Leave or absence wlo pay

2 3 4 5 6 9 10 11 12 13 16 17 18 1 23 24 26 26 27 30 31 J-SchoolbusinessO O <AasH-union Business)

1 2 3 6 7 10 13 14 15 16 17 20 21 22 23 24 27 28 29 k-vacationO

1 2 7 8 9 12 13 14 15 16 19 .20 21 22 23 26 27 28 29 30 N"

1 1 . M - Transferto or fromschool

2 3 4 5 6 0 11 12 13 16 17 18 9 20 23 24 25 26 27 30 O - Holidav

O LE - LefteartyÑa 1 2 3 4 7 8 910 11415161718212223242528293031« r LL - LongLynch

ËC 1 4 5 6 7 8 11 12 13 14 15 18 19 20 21 22 25 26 27 28 29 T-Tardy

VyOP-Without Pav

TRANSPORTATION DIVISION - OPERATIONSMAINTENANCE F NWD- NonWorkDaySpecial Remarks

i

BUS DRIVER PERFORMANCE EVALUATION

ATTITUDE:

Courteous to drivers ofother vehicles and fellowemployeesorthedistrict.

Represents the school district in a positive manner whendealing with the students, public,parents,and school staff.

INITIATIVE:

Participates in all trainingprograms, meetings andconferences as required.Shows wilingness to giveassistance to others.Checks mail box before and after each run.

APPEARANCE:

Complies with Regulation #14 "dress code" in the EmployeeHandbook

DEPENDABILITY:

Maintains consistent and reliable attendancePunctualityComplies with Board of Education Policies and

,

Transportation Procedures.

Performs such other duties as assigned by the Transportation /Division.Driving/Defensive Drivingperformanceduring thisevaluation /period.

54321543215432

nature Manager Signature


SCHOOL D1STRICTvirontovico y Nicholas P. Jackson

Deputy Chief Business Operations

Chief Executive OMicer1390 East Sixth Street, Cleveland, OH 44114 216.574.8.147 - Fax 216.574.8120 www,cmsdnet.net

Eric S. Gorden

Bosni of Education MEMORAN DUMDenise W. Link

Chair

Louise P, Dempsey -

vicechair TO: Serena Houston-Edwards, Deputy ChiefPatricia crutchneld Human Re ces

Robert MÆeard, Sr. /Willetta A. Miiam /

Shaletha T. Mitchell FROM: Nichola. P. Å kson, Deputy ChiefIris M. Rodriguez Busù:ess O er rtions

Lisa ThomasEric L. Wobser

DATE: October 10, 2012 /> c,Ex Officio Members

Dr. Ronald M. BerkmanDr. JerrySue Thornton SUBJECT: Suppon of Termination

Ariel CastroProfessional Driver, East 49 St. Depot

Attached please find a letter from Ann Carlson, Director of Transportationrecommending termination for Ariel Castro, Professional Driver, East 496 St.Depot.

After review of the information contained in the letter, I support herrecommendation. Therefore, please move fonvard with the termination of ArielCastro.

If you have any questions or need further information,pleasescontact me.

NPJ: san

Attachment

ec: Patrick Zohn, Chief OperatingOfficerAnn Carlson, Director, Transportation

The prrmary goal of the C/eve/and Metrocolitan Rhool District is to becomea premier school disdict in the United States of America.

CLEVELAN.DMETROPOLITAN

SCHOOL DISTRICTI m o Visio to Victory

Ann CarlsonDirector, Transportation Departrrient

3632 Ridge Road, Cleve/sod, DH 44144 · O//ice: 2./6 631.7021 Fax 216.634-7025 www.cmsdnet.netChief Executive Officer

EricS. Gordon

Board of Education MemorandumDenise W. Link

Board Chair

Louise P. Dempsey To: NickJacksoniso c"* Deputy Chief, Transportation 8L Facilities

Patricia CrutchfieldRobert M. Heard, Sr FFOT: Ann CarlSOO .

$haÏethaT. MitcheliDirettOr, TranSportation '

Willetta A. MilamIris M.RodriguerDr. Usa Thomas Date: October 9, 2012

Eric L Wobser

Ex OMcio Members Re: Ariel Castro,Dr. Ronald M. Berkman PrOf€SSIOnal DrÍver,East 49 St. DepotDr. Jerry Sue Thornton

Charges: Class I, #11 - UnauthorizedUse of DivisionEquipment

Mr.Castro is receiving this charge as a result of leaving his bus at Scranton Schoolfrom 9:30 a.m. until 1:30 p.m. on September 20, 2012. Mr. Castro's e×planation wasthat his preschool route was cancelled that day and since he only lives two blocksaway, he went home.

Mr. Castro said that he did not knowabout the cancellation;however that notice wasmade over the radio and posted within the depot several days before September-206.He did not notifythe depot nor dispatch that he was leaving the unit unattended.

This is Mr. Castro's fourth demonstration of lack of judgment. He has previouslybeensuspended sixty days for leaving a childon a bus; sixtydays for makingan illegalu-tum in rush hour trafficwith a bus load of students, and, last school year for usingthe bus to do his grocery shopping.


/ac

Xc: Kevin Marino, Winford Terrentine, Depot Manager, E. 49 St. DepotNick Hascka, Vice President, Local 407Ariel Castro, ProfessionalDriver, E. 49 St. Depot

I

The primary goal of the Develand Metropolitan School District is to becomea premier school district in the United Stötes,

WIVV/.CII:Sd/3el.ndt


SCHOOL Dl STRI CT Transportation Divisioni . I Vision to Victory

DATE

MEETING NOTICE

TO: / C /A520

FROM: Kevin NIarino

SUBJECT: rddrPUN))LY' | /M.ufy

DATE: Z- À - TIME: T $ÀLOCATION: Á /pgg ¿pg




EMPLOYEE SIGNATURE . DATE

The primary goal of the Cleveland Metropolitan Schoo1District is to become a premier school district inthe United States of America.

REV 05-04-()] . DOT 23

1380 East Sixth Street, Cleveland,Ohio 44114(216) 574-8500 Fax: (216) 574-8139

CLEVE0\ND METROPOLITAN SCHOOL DISTRICT

ÓlVISION OF SAFETY AND SECURITY1380 East Sixth Street BUS#Clevealand. Ohio 44114

(216)574-8552 SCHOOL CÑA(INCIDENT REPORT

YES NO

ON SCHOOL PROPERTY REGION: Incident Report # Event #GANG RELATED

INCIDENT LOCATION ADDRESS OR SCHOOL NAME; SCHOOL NUMBER

INCIDENT TITLE (S): DAYOF WEEK: DATE: TIME:

If time of incident is unknown use lhese blocks to give the start and stop of the timespan duringwhich the incident occurred.

Victim NAME: SEX: D.O.B: RACE: CMSD ID OR SSAN:SuspectOtherADDRESS ZIP CODE: TELEPHONE#: GUARDIAN IF JUVENILE:

Victim NAME: SEX: D.O.B: RACE: CMSD ID OR SSAN:SuspectOtherADDRESS ZIP CODE: TELEPHONE #: GUARDIAN JF JUVENlLE:

Victim NAME: SEX: D.O.B: RACE: CMSD )D OR SSAN:SuspectOtherADDRESS &ZIP CODE: TELEPHONE #: GUARDíAN IF JUVENILE:

CPD CALLED: YES N0 , RESPONDED: YES NO , CAR# BADGE #S

ARREST MADE: YES : NO , ARRESTING OFFICER'S NAME BADGE

CONFISCATION MADE: YES NO,

ITEM.. CONFISCATING OFFICER = BADGE IF CPD

CPD CALLED;YES NO , RESPONDED: YES NO . UNIT#SBUILDINGEVACUATED: YES NO , TIME STARTED TIME RETURNED TO BUILDING

DAMAGE TO BUlLDING: YES NO, IF DAMAGE ESTiMATE VALUE5

EMS CALLED: YES NO, RESPONDED: YES NO , UNJT#S INCLUDINGANY DFD:

INJURIES: YES NO .NUMBER MINOR SERIOUS . SEŸERE . FATALTRANSPORTS: YES NO .NUMBER TRANSPORTED , TRANSPORTED TO

OTHER AGENCY CALLED: RESPONDED: YES NOPERSONAL CONTACTED:

PERSON SU NG TH1S REPORT: (Print Name)

SlGNATURE A - DATE IF REPORT:PERSON TAKINGCALL:

SUPERVISOR'S RECOMMENDATIONFOLLOW UP: CLOSE: REFERRED TO:

FINAL ACTJON:

SIGNATURE: DATE:

i

e en 6 E-o sc.«+R 4 o ry seÁos j' A-4-G<'÷N

V4e k oy/eve '3 e 4 o acé 4 sc /as-d u 4' pse Aoc | M sd / o¾, Tees i era

c?_AE Mo . 7 j a §+ A / 6 vsEf / A-( fou e 9,_.. A e e, ./ g

4(¯d iosii ocÚT 04v,

es JR er Ed 4 ff fo $ ous o er -r * o <-t' te

C~B-cloeoce gw -Roode A e/ O S

o kok lesutM Lo -ÉÁirea secu me¯d 4 04 e-m á h o

V l¯ I e 2 O

ou é 63 A+ & w b Eb ca a c| E E<Á << cL 5'<, yoéo

col so é i' 6 kig ANPsa (M -Acif

e /TC

A ukikip/ Isy A- C as

oas é sc<÷>r Low al,os / em

Me kW/s> 9 53 e 4,o acé a sM crl u Áger sc Aco/ MÖ As e-PF.Ww k ens

o &&_E tw o a v a C-. T /- §+ x / 6 vsp¯÷‡-r(cef /4 9 o a+ e i L_E Te½ e & ( MIL

4(god Isoke^±oo bfoeks owins,eeko

exed¯÷ok t'/ e //+Ac« poÁ<o

oo.e + Go 49*' p- e A c<-L of oe Èo dá p .Roode A res/ ulos,5

pH Á w .4 s og aa of e,l ça g-e<-Qis secos -Core isov tw ç Los ,éÁLrc<F,bus As secu me¯d sof/q T wee n homedoReae 1,vc 6er Le./g, e6 mAt

i4s y Aou-6E-5 - A+E- we bcò c>yanoge]¯¯&c-ik </mesi t da väg ss os i srws ecAoo( so é WI£¾é/ L,;w/½ g 64,w

si, le xx 9 « -tke se Er er F A afido .4 poleyiz

I, +¾ ¾swel l,s. ,zp/cm

Page 1 of 1

bus 978Troy Beadlingto:

Winford Terrentine09/20/2012 11:02 AMCe:lvette Colon, Ann CarlsonShow Details

This email is to informyou that bus 978 sat vacant outside my school building from approximately 9:30 am until1:30 pm. I made announcementsand checkedallrestrooms in mybuilding to see if the driver was here andreceived no response. The bus door was unlocked and partially opened so I entered the bus to see if the driverwas on the bus and helshe was not. The bus was parked in the lane that would be used by the fire dept it we hadan emergency. Cars were able to get through, but I am not sure if large emergency vehicles would have beenable to make it. Sergeant Fortson was at Scranton yesterday to see this and shared the same concerns We had atScranton. Please let me know if there is anythingmore l need to do with this situation and please keep me.informed. Thanksi

Troy BeadlingPrincipalScranton216.621.2165

file://C:\Documents and Settings\carlan01\Local Settings\Temp\notesFCBCEE\~web8586.... 9/24/2012

MEETING NOTICE

TO: BONNIE NEWELL

FROM: CHARLES JENKINS, DEPOT MANAGER

DATE: May 24, 2012

SUBJECT: DISCIPLINARY MEETING

CHARGES: Class I, #23 DISREGARD FOR THE SAFETY OFPASSENGERS

DATE:_ TBD Û TIME: 10:00am

Be advised that on the above date you are to appear before the Directorof Tratisportation on the above charges.

Results of this meeting can and may result in discipline up toTernination.

I acknowledge that the above has been discussed with me andunderstand my signature does not imply agreement or disagreement.

mpfoyee Signature <Date

CLEVELANDMETROPOUTAN

SCHOOL DISTRlCT.« a ,, visionto Yktory

Ann CarlsonDirector, Transportation Departrnent

3832 Ridge Road, Cleveland, OH 44144 Office:216.634.7021 - Fax 216.6349025 · www.cmsdnet nethief Executive Officer

Eric 5. Gordon

Board of Educatíon MemorandumDenise W. Unk

Board Chair

Louise P. Dempsey To: NickJackson -

vicechair Deputy Chief, Transportation & FacilitiesPatricia Crutchfield

Robert M. Heard, Sr. From: Ann CarlsonShaletha T. Mitchell DÍrectOr, TranSpOftatÍOn

Willetta A. MilamTrisM. RodriguezDr. Usa Thornas Date: October 9, 2012

Eric L. Wobser

Ex DWicio Members Re: Ariel CBStrO,Dr. Ronald M. Berkman PrOfessional Driver, East 49 St. DepotDr. Jerry Sue Thornton

Charges: Class I, #11 - Unauthorized Use of Division Equipment

Mr.Castro is receiving this chargeas a result of leaving his bus at Scranton Schoolfrom 9:30 a.m. until 1:30 p.m. on September 20, 2012. Mr.Castro's e×planation wasthat his preschool route was cancelledttiatday and since he only lives two blocksaway, he went home.

Mr. Castro said that he did not know aboutthe cancellation;however that notice was '

made over the radio and posted within the depot several days before September 20°.He did not notify thedepot nor dispatch that he was leavingthe unit unattended.

This is Mr.Castro's fourth demonstration of lack of judgment. He has previously beensuspendedsixty days forleaving a childon a bus; sixty days for makingan illegalu-tum in rush hour trafficwith a bus load of students, and, fast school year for usingthebus to do his grocery shopping.


/ac

Xc: KeviifMarino, Winford Terrentine, Depot Manager, E. 49 St. DepotNickHascka, VicePresident, Local407ArielCastro, Professional Driver,E. 49 St. Depot

,The primary goal of the Oeveland MetropolitanSchool District is to becomea premier schooldistrict in the United States,


SCHOOL DISTRICTvision to victory - Nicholas P. Jackson

Deputy Chief Business Operations

1380 East SixthStreet, Cleveland,OH 44114 216 574.6147 Eax 216.574.0120 www.cmsdnet.netChief Executive Offiœr

EricS. Gordon

Board of EducationDenise W. Link November 19, 2012

Chair

Louise P. DempseyViceChair Nick Haschka, Vice President

Patricia Crutchfield Truck Driver's Union - Local 407Robert M. Heard, Sr. 3320 Superior Avenue

wiiiettaA. Milam Cleveland, Ohio 44144-4123Shaletha T. Mitchell

Iris M. Rodriguez

ErLa hob" SUBJECT: Step 2 Grievancelfearing - Denied

Ariel Castro, Professional Driver, East 49thÛ€þOÊEx Officio Members

Dr. Ronald M. BerkmanDr. Jerry Sue Thornton Dear Mr. Haschka:

On November 16, 2012, a Step 2 Grievance hearing was held, at which time theCleveland Metropolitan School District reviewed the information presented.

After careful review of the information presented at the hearing, the grievance isdenied. My recommendation is termination.

If you have any questions or need additional information please contact me.

Since

Nicholas . Jackson

cc: Carlson, Director of TransportationFrank Brudell, President, Loca1407Payroll

- Personnel

The primary goa/ of the Geveland Metropolitan Schoo/District is to becomea premier schoo/district in the UnitedStates of America.

l

CLEVELAND -

METROPOLITANSCHOOL DISTRICT Transportation Diviston

a - Vision to VI¢tory

DATEI

MEETINGNOTICE

TO:.II

FROM: Kevin Marino

SUBJECT: / ¿P¿/MP / //XVy

CHARGES: //- M /Vok/zEd Cr3£ OF 7];V/5/CN E¢ delfNT

DATE; Ê.Ñ TIME: S.ÀLOCATION: Ñ/P g Ñ/) dgBe advisedthat on the above date you are to appear before theDirectoron the above charges,

|Results of this meetingcan and may result in suspensionor termination,

I acknowledgethat the above hasbeen d1scussed withme and understand mysignature does not Implyagreement or disagreement.

EMPLOYEESIGNATURE DATE

The primary goalof the Cleveland Métropolitan SchoolDistrict 1sto become a premierschooldistrictinthe United States of America.

IR.EV 05-04-01 DOT23

1380 Bas SixthStreet,Cleveland,Oldo 44114(21 574-8500 Fax: (216) 574-8139

\

ClevelandMetrooliten KevinMarino ,

, , FleidSupport Manager, East 49* Depot

SchoolDistnet "--av'•=

4177 East deth Street, Clevolgnd Ohio,44105 • (218) 441-8228 • Fax: (216) 441. 8234

Eas 49th Faxbate: /X pagesfgL,

To: From: Kevin Marino

ClevelandMetropolitanSchoolDepartment: District

Phone: Phone # (216) 441-8226

Fax # SG/- 95g Fax # ( 216) 441- 8234

Special Notes/Comments:

O UROENT O POR REVlaw O PLEASE COMMENT O PLEASE REPLY O PLBASERECYCLEI

\l

II

The primarygoal oftheCleveland Metropolitan SchoolD1strictis to become a premier schooldistrictin the United States of America.

CLEVELANDMETROPOLifANSCHOOL DISTRICT i

OlVlSiONOFSAFETYANDSECURITY \1380 East SluthStreet

.

BUS #Clevealand, Ohio44114(216)S74-8852 SCHOOL C .4,((

. INCIDENTREPORTYES NO

ON SCHOOL PROPERTY REGION: Incident Report # Event #GANGRELATED

(ÑõÏDfNŸLOCATIONADDRESSOR SCHOOLNAME SCHOOL NUMBER

lÑ0]¯DENTTITLE(S): DAYOF WËEK:

¯

DATE: TIMË:Loe 'Ÿ/Op93à

If time ofincidentis unknownuse theseblocks togivethestartand stopofthetimespan duringwhichthe incident occurred.Victim NAME:

.SEX: D.O.B: RACE: CMSD IDOR SSAN:

Suspect .

OtherADDREss IIP CODE: TELEPHONE#: GUARDIA4 IF JUVENILE:

Victim NAME: SEX: D.O.B: RACE: CMSD 10 OR SSAN:SuspectotherADDRESS ZIP CODE: TELEPHONE#, GUARDIANIF JUVENILE:

Victim E: SEX: D.O.B: RACE: CMSD JDOR SSAN:

OtherADDRESS &ZIPCODE: TELEPHONE#: GUARDIANIF JUVENILE:

CPD CALLED: YESJO , RESPONDED: YES I NO CAR# GADGE#S ,

ARREST MADE: YES N ARRESTINGOFFI R'S NAME BADGE30NFISCATION MADE: YES NO , ITEM CONFISCATINGOFFICER BADGE )F CPD

3PDCALLED:YESJO RESPONDED:YES NO , UNIT#8 ,

3UILDINGEVACUATED:YES NO , TIMESTAR D TIMERETURNEDTOBUILDINGJAMAGETO BUILDING:YES O , IF DAMAG STIMATEVALUES . .

IMS CALLED: YESJO . RESPONDED' YES NO , UNlT#SINCLUDING ANYDFD:4JURIES: YES NO NUMBERMlNOR SERIOUS , SEVERE , FATALRANSPORTS: YES NO .NUMBERTRANSP O , TRANSPORTEDTO

ITHEA.AGENCYCALLED: RESPONDED: YES NOEAŠONAL CONTACTED:

I

ERSON SU G THIS REPORT: (Print Name)

IGNATUR DATEJFREPORT:ERSON TAKINGCALL

..i

SUPERVISOR'S RECOMMENDATION)LLOW UP: CLOSE: REFERRED TO: = |

JALACTION: . iI

VNATURE DATE:

emu 6 e Sc<+ Le N SeA Q / A EN

AS Mo 4« &DCA, a§± Ay 6 ve«g g/ o ud e 4 4-L A e . ( sŒ.

4 (|--s,d C -a <--vo 6 | å ekt 4-u 4 y ,

« kva d «dk le/>&« Me .

. KS e Á A- c./o c-C,o d.6 Re / eN'gMy MRÅ¾ +s 4-++,e 4i s riea-3 o

<°^

bec as seeved!ke X was6 hoso-doAeau tyr 6 e var Lagt f hyped o'ÁkMo w. y Ao o -d -C.- we b e3 d e>« c ey eI pedd -4; e se d,a seyasos , atww .ec Aoef « (< Ny&¾>r

rGu9 ,»'lT¯¿̄n ...+ pelfyt

In i t /C'gsd« »

. i. I

i .

I..

. .

.. p n 1.

r /amydÛm a/vAaá // ma/e 4 * 74m

Ikn< à unng-I & al m own danhan

,

d aspen - /// on heI Á o à /vUto/ J

.

Aar 2 y á m/<- mz a4 arath AW A Aagram ja JJrp' AyAn &at

by JopensianSnd;á exMM

.

- gl mal «dewsœ o - apo/aà d & Jmgwaf

/22 # /297/ caça - A4 & &[nm num &c

ch Spún re .fgding

QPT-PUT

thm úl ¢½nut awW **

SA v.0Audcm/

Nicholas Jackson

ut Chief of Business Operations

Eugene T.W. Sanders, Ph.D.Chief Executive Oincer

Bosni of EducationDenise w. unk Au ust 4, 2009Board Chair Ë

Louise P. DempseyMce Chan

Rashrdah Abdulho<w Nick Haschka, Vice PresidentRobert M. Heard, Sr. Teamsters Local 407

Harvey A. Hopson, Jr.wilienaA. Milam 3320 Superior Avenue

Natalie L. Peterson Cleveland, Ohio 44114-4123Iris M. Rodrigue: .

- -

Subject: Ariel CastroEx Officio Members i

DJ. Ronald M. BerkmanDr. Jerry Sue Thomton

Dear Mr. Haschka:

In response to your request to reconsider the extent of the consequences for Mr.Castro's unsafe and irresponsible U-turn in front of RG Jones Elementary schoolwith a bus load of students, I have reconsidered the number of the days off that he isto serve.

At your request and on a non-precedent setting basis I will reduce his suspensionfrom 60 to 55 work days.

If you hav any questions or need additional information please contact me.

Sincerely

Ni os ackson

ec: A Carlson, Interim Director of TransportationFiank Brudell, President, Local 407PayrollPersonnel FileAriel Castro2207 Seymour AveCleveland, Ohio 44113

The primary goa/ of the Øeve/and Metropolitan Schoo/ Œstrict is to becomea premier schoo/ districtin the UnitedStates of America.

MediationAgreementRevisedVersionAug2005

FEDERAL MEDIATION & CONCILIATION SERVICEUNITED STATES GOVERNMENT

MEDIATION AGREEMENT

The undersigned herebyrequest the assistance of theFMCSin the attemptedresolution of the dispute betweenthem today.They understand thatmediation is a voluntary process that may beterminatedat any time.Further,the undersigned agree to maintain the confidentiality of all informationdisclosed in the course of the mediation:

1. The undersigned agree that all statements by the parties, participantsor the mediator duringthe mediation process,.and any documentscreated for or duringthese.proceedings,arepinadmissibleand notdiscoverable for any purpose.whatsoever, in any pending orsubsequent judicialor other proceeding, absent consent of all of theparties, the mediator and the FMCS.

2. The undersigned agree not to subpoena thimediat6r o ore elseemployed by FMCŠto lestifyfor any reason, nor to subpoenadocuments created for or duringthe mediation.

3. It is understood by the undersigned that evidence that is otherwiseadmissible or discoverable shall not be rendered inadmissibleor non-discoverable as a result of its use in the mediation proceedings.

4. The undersigned shall not rely on, nor introduceas evidence in anyproceedings any views, comments or suggestions made by any partyor participant with respect to a possible settlement of the dispute, anyadmissions made by another party or participant in the course of themediation proceedings, or any proposals, opinions, or comments ofthe mediator. It is understood that FMCSpolicy is such that the

TEAMSTERS8 TRUCK DRIVERS UNIONLOCAL 407

giated with th¢ Insonationaf Brorhuhoodof T¢ananers

3320Superior AvenueCleveland, ONo44114•4123

PRESIDENT June 30, 2009 Phone: (216)688-0833BUSINESS REPREtrMTAYTVE Fax: (216) 381-9568

FRANK BURDELL www.LU407.comVICEPRESIDElff

Ot/SINgBE REPRESENTATIVE Ms.Ann CarlsonNICK HASCHKAClevelandBoardof Ed

SECRETAAV-TNEAGUAE" 3832 Riage Rd.BUSINESS AKPRESENTAWVE

PAUL WOJNAn Cleveland.Oh 44144

ACCORDINGEECRETARYRusiNESSREPREGENTAWV, Dear Ms. Carlson:

MICHAEL HIENTON

vnustaa In an attempt to resolve the followinggrievances beforetaking them toBUSINESBREPR€BENTANVE arbitration, we are attempting to set-up a meeting with CarolynBrommerof

DENNIS ROBERTS FMCSSer. ices. The dates available are July 17,2009, July 20,2009,JulyautWESS ENTANVE 29, 2009, July 30, 2009, and July31, 2009. If any of these dateswill work.

J. K. TANSKI please contact the undersigned.TRUSTEE

BUSfkESSREPRESENTATIWE Se IOÌÏWing gfÍBVanC€S are tÎleones to be heard:KEVIN J. PATTONrievance # 1296 - Linda Roy

BustNESS REÞNESENTAnvE

JESS W. WOODY • rrievance # 1290 and 1291 - LindaRoyRUSINEssREPREGENTAWVS Grievance # ) 298 -- Theresa Brown

J. D, SMITH e ÀTieÏÛ&Stro - Ÿ¾OteSting Susperision• Grievance# 1344 - On behalfof all Drivers• Grievance# 939 - ShirleyHunter• Grievance# 1283 - Class Action

Thank you in advance for your cooperation.

Nick Haschka,Vice President&Business RepresentativeTeamsters Truck Drivers Union, Local407

NH/bk

Cc: Linda RoyTheresa BrownShirleyHunterGregTaylorMichael Hienton

TEAMSTERSTRUCK DRIVERS UNION

LOCAL 407Ag7/Inted wkh tht14ternational Rwtherhood of Tenneters

3320 Superior AvenueCleveland, Ottio 44114-4123

PRESIDENT NÒ $$Û$Bus;NÉssatPRESENTArtvE July 7, 2009 Fax: (216) 361-9568

FRANK SUADELLwww.LU407.com

vict ÞRCelotWT

Bus/NESS ACPRESENTATIVE

NICK HASCHKAMr. Nick Jackson

SECRETARY-TREASURER ClevelandBoardof EdBUSINESS REPRESENToftVE

PAUL WOJNAn 1380 E. SixthSt.Cleveland, Oh 44114

NECORDWGSECRETARYÐUSINESS REÞRESENTA7tvE

MICHAEL MIENTON Dear Mr. Jackson:Inust Et

avstNESSarPRESENTArive This letter will confirm our mediation meeting on Monday,July 20, 2009 atDENNIS RODERTS 10:00A.M.at the FMCSBuildingon 6161Oak TreeBlvd.,Suite 100,

'""** Independence Oh.BusinSSS REPRESENTAnvE

J. K. TANSKI

,,as,,, Thank you in advance foryour cooperation.SUSINESS NEPRE8tMTATIVE

KEVIN J. PATTON Regards,BUSTNESS REPRESENTATlvt

JESS W. WOODY

aus,sessnararsruranv, TEAMSTERS TRUCK DRIVERS UNION, LOCAL 407J. D. SMITH

Nick HaschkaVice President&

. BusinessRepresentative

NH/bk

Cc: Frank Burdell, President407ShirleyHunterGreg TaylorLinda RoyTher:sa Brown

103

TEAMSTERSTRUCK DRIVERS UNION

LOCAL 407agm.¢ wra se intensionat arowhomeof maneras

3320Superior AvenueCleveland,Ohio441144123

PRESIDENT DC $Û, MODEI 1Û)$Û$•Û$33avslMEss agWhiggNTAnvr Fax: (216)381-9368

FRANK BURDELLwww.LU407.com

VICEPREtt0EWTsusrwes s nevnessuranvr

NICK HASCHKA Mr.NicholasJacksonClevelandBoard of Ed

SECRETAWT-TREASUREN e thBUSFNENREMESENTARVE 1a30Eass6 St.

PAUL WOJNAR Cleveland,Oh 44]14WECDRDING.SECRETARY

BUSINESS RErne.eux.nvr Dear Mr.Jackson:MICHAEL HIENTON

TRUSTEE 10an attCmpt to TCSolve the followinggrievances before taking them toMSUNSWEREPRESENTATIV' arbitration, we are attemptmg to set-up a meeting with Carolyn BrommerofDENNIS ROBERTS FMCSSeràces. Thedates availableare July 17,2009, July 20, 2009,July

ausmessiÃ8ENTAWVE 29, 2009-I 1730, 2009, and July 31,2009. If anyof these dateswill work,J. K. TANSKI pleasecontact the undersigned.

YAUSTERBustNEPS REPRESENymfrvr

KEVIN J. PATTON The folÎ0Wing grieratices are the onesto be heard:BMSWESSAFPHfSENMME

• Grievance# 1296 - LindaRoyJass w. wooDY • Grievance# 1290 and 1291 - Linda Roy

susmess nernrBENTAnvr • Grievance# 1298 - TheresaBrowna o. savn • Ariel Castro - Protesting Suspension

• Grievance# 1344 - On behalfof all Drivers• Grievance# 939 - ShirleyHunter• Grievance# 1283 - ClassAction

Thankyou in advancefor your cooperation.

NickHaschka,Vice President &BusinessRepresentativeTeamstersTruckDrivers Union, Local407

NH/bk

Cc: LindaRoyTheresaBrownShirley HunterGregTaylor yMichaelHienton/

103

TEAMSTERSTRUCKDRIVERSUNIONN° 1296LOCAL 407

GRIEVANCEFORMGREEVANCENo, , GRIEVANT ATE OP INCIDENT RECEVEDBY

DEPARTMENT CLASSIFICATION SENI RITY DATE

ARTICLES VlOLATED //.2' to / /'a 4 4&

si MENT OF THE FACTS t.9 Q / / .4 A , M , ,,

STFD l. rh /

ED DATEANSWE SIGNA

DSWER(ATTACHED)MTEANSWERED SIGNATURE

Whim•Ofike Copy Yellow- Emp¢oyericCopy Pink - Steward's Copy Gohi- MemÞer'sCopy • los

, -, TEAMSTERSTRUCKDRIVERS UNIONN° 1290

i' GRIELoAcN

FORMGRIEVANCENo. GRIEV NT DATEOF JNCIDENT RECEIVED BY

DEPARTMENT (/ CLASSIF)CATIO SENIORI7Y DATE

SUPERVISOß'SNAMEAN Gl¶EVANCEWAS RRST DtSCUSSED

STATEMENTOF THE FACTS 74, /tŸ9,f' i M 0 /<Á2A Av;?r / .ra

ashAA LL, v/«AF6,; 46/4£ 4) 7¾, 4/ /zdt .

p/w<A//7X, emmyAmar s fx /, # 7 / - Á¿//Åg¯†Éaf AA½r l' t'7'à¿M afAQ·oò a--,, A 4<Ãt'yJ.du,trate

EV ATESIGNED

DATERLED DATEANSWERED SIGNATURE

STEP 2 ANSWEA(ATIACHED)DATEFILED DATEANSWERED SIGNATURE

Wone- Dirico Copy Yellow- EmployotaCopy Pink - Steward'sGopy Gold - Membert Copy •gwa

TEAMSTERS TRUCK DRIVERSUNIONi 1291LOCAL 407

GRIEVANCEFORMGRIEVANCENO. G ANT DATE OF INCIDENT

'RECEIVED BY

DEPARTMENT A / LASStFicATroN SENIORFrYDATE

SUPERVISOR'SNAMEANDDA G IEVANCEVVAS T DISCUSSED

g/ //7 /r/P / ' 7ARTICLESVIOLA ED / d .F.4 Araa

STATEMENT OF TNEFACTS t/Lok,dA fl, FI

RELIEF REQUERED 'a ¿T..es ÅÞ x/JÊtr .? . /7 to // . a.; «

GRIEVANT'SSi DATESIGN A SIGNATURE TESIGNED v

STEP 1 ANSWER CHED)DATEFILED DATEANSWERED SIGNATURE

I

STEÞ 2 ANSWER[AT7ACHED)

DATEFILED .DATEANSWERED SIGNATURE

I X -

Métie - OMiceCopy Yehow- Employers Copy Pink - StewartfsCopy Gold- Member's Copy •gm

TEAMSTERS TRUCK DRIVERS UNION le 1298LOCAL 407

GRIEVANCEFORMGRIEVANCENO. GRfEVANT DATEOF INCIDENT RECEfVED BY

-244¾554 a -Mye¢¾ R//. 13 - r ? -of

DEPARTMENT CLASSIFICATION SENIORITYDATE

.g&PVWPf/DA Oc&C ß > kv ICJUPERVISOR'S NAME ANDDATEG IEVANCEWAS RST DISCUSSED

t'WJ 7h Q /f ¢TY46 #' 7/DA

ARTICLES VJOLATED r r

STATEMENT OF THE FACTE (DN /)? /Ñ N///ÝÑñ/¿ /7 c'2tW>Ÿ X Srt/7m/?? ??1 77/f 0/OFYPV°

REUEF REQUESTED . T.x) /> /V2 n /.. / /

.

XE G

DATEFILED DA7E ANSWERED SIGNATCAE

b -Z--y

STEP zANSWER(AmCHED)DATEFILED DATEANSWERED SIGNATURE

White•Of?Ice Copy Yehow - Employer's Copy Pînk .Stewersfs Copy Goki- Memberk Copy • m

AMSTERS TRUCKDRIVERS UNIONy 1344LOCAL 407

GRIEVANCEFORMGRIEVANCEÑÑ GRIEVANT DATEOF WCIDENT RECEIVEDBY

DEPARTlvlENT CLASSIFICATlÒN SENIORITYDATEC4-CD -Ras ¥rses

SUPERvisOR'S NAMEANDDATEGRIEVANCEWAS FIAST DISCUSSED

ARTICLES VIOLATED 18, Ž2, 9

STATEMEWT OF THE FACTSm.m -

Th¾ grievance is filed on behalf of all CMSDLead Drivers, II, Professional Drivers,

.itare Drivers, etc. The CMSÐis violating the contract by bidding runs with a 5 hour

guarantee. The contract Article 18 requires a 6 hour guarantee. Past practice in the

last two summers has been to guirantee 6 hours per day.

RELIEF REQUESTED -The--union is- requesting that all drivers be made whole Ëor all losses

flost wares) for this violation and that all drivers be guaranteed 6 hours per work day.

y_ and all articles that apply, Further facts to be presented.

>"^"UN RE NED STEWAR G DA ED

STEP i ANSWER (ATTACHED)DATEFILED DATEANSWERED SIGNATURE

Y

STEP 2 ANSWER (ATTACHEO)DATE FILED DATEANSWERED SIGNATURE

White - Omce Copy Yenow- Em yets Copy Pink - StewardhCopy Gohi - Member's Copy • ta

- - ----- P. 82/03

TEAMSTERSUNIONLOCAL#407

GRIEVANCEFORMGRJE/ANCENO GRIEVANT DATEOF INCIDEbil RECElvED

ass Arn« s+c 4DEPARTMEfK CLASSiFICATION SENIORITYDAT

SUPE VISOR'S NAMEANDDATEGR1EVANCEWAS FIRST DISCtJSSED

ARTict.mvioi.ATED,

7,.

STAT EntTAFTHFFACTS An i Itfa.M

A 31 teu

GRI SIGNA RE DATESIGNED D St0MA

STEP ANSWER MTTACHEDDATE ILED . DATEANSWERED StGNATURE

STEP ! ANSWER(ATTACHEDDATEFil.ED DATEANSWERED gy gg

WMe- Otheecopy Yafow- EmpbyensCopy Þink- Stmetih Copy Gold - Membefa Copy

TEAMSTERSTRUCK DRIVERSUNION Na 12838 LOCAL 407GRIEVANCEFORM

GRIEVANCENO. GRFEVANT DATEOFINCIDENT ItECENEDBY

/d R'3 LAŒ A"V/oENT CIASSI CAT10N SENIORITYDATE

SUPERVISQRS NAMEANDDATEGRIEVANCEWASFlRST DISCUSSED

ARTICLESVIOLATED

ewsmur or tus racts AnfX' Ñtya¶ /PR RE/N/, R217'd SWyarc%/n rrlagert? " yrrev we a,e SMænede<.>r' r, w'Ir'w'

g ietiv FWMAR2 3 Pil!N

TRUCKDRIVEAŠUNIONuyu. 4ù7 Cl£Vil-AND

REUEF REQUESTED /7241 /D///V.K /M £V 2 ' t.<.k '

GRIEVANPS NATURE DATESIGNED SIGNATURÊ DATEMGNED

STEPi ANSWW(A CHEDDATE Fil.ED DATEANSWERED SIONATURE

Y

STEP2 ANSWER (ATTAGNED)DATE Fil.ED DATEANSWERED BleNATLIRE

f

nue , otra copy vtan.- Empeyers copy esa - anna car copy som.Meneera copy • wo