Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Armin MüllerMinisterium für Umwelt, LandwirtschaftErnährung, Weinbau und ForstenRheinland-Pfalz
WISE Water Information System for Europe
Data management in Germany Data management in Germany with regards to European with regards to European reporting requirementsreporting requirements
Better information needed to support policies
Improvement of existing information flows
Differentiation across regions to be considered
Revision of approach to reporting and monitoring, moving to concept of sharing of information
Directives, initiatives and systems…the path is the goal
Directive xx - WISE - INSPIRE
The views of the different EU bodies are converging, but are not common yet.
Difference between formal compliance reporting and WISE process. Compliance aspect causes confusion, defensive attitude and “fears”.
Too many processes, projects, interests – management challenging, leadership essential
Too many experts talking about different things, no common language. WISE will be an opportunity for MS to present themselves in the
European context.
Joint process of EU bodies and MS is crucial for success WISE conceptually fully integrated in wider environmental reporting
discussion (incl. INSPIRE) WISE is a complex process to manage, it needs positive commitment if
we were to succeed WISE will be, what we want it to be and what we make out of it!
European Commission, DG EnvironmentUnit D.2 – Water and Marine, WFD Team January 2006
NeedsBetter information needed to
support policiesImprovement of existing
information flowsDifferentiation across regions
to be consideredRevision of approach to
reporting and monitoring, moving to concept of sharing of information
Situation in EuropeData policy restrictions
– pricing, copyright, access rights, licensing policy
Lack of co-ordination– across boarders and
between levels of government
Lack of standards – incompatible information
and information systemsExisting data not re-usable
– fragmentation of information, redundancy, inability to integrate
DIRECTIVE 2007/2/EC OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF
THE COUNCILestablishing an Infrastructure for
Spatial Information in the European Community (INSPIRE)
AlsbachAlsbachAlsbachAlsbachAlsbach
AltwiedAltwiedAltwiedAltwiedAltwied
AndernachAndernachAndernachAndernachAndernach
AnhausenAnhausenAnhausenAnhausenAnhausen
BendorfBendorfBendorfBendorfBendorf
Berg SchoenstattBerg SchoenstattBerg SchoenstattBerg SchoenstattBerg Schoenstatt
BonefeldBonefeldBonefeldBonefeldBonefeld
BreitenauBreitenauBreitenauBreitenauBreitenau
BuerderBuerderBuerderBuerderBuerder
CaanCaanCaanCaanCaan
DatzerothDatzerothDatzerothDatzerothDatzeroth
DeesenDeesenDeesenDeesenDeesenEhlscheidEhlscheidEhlscheidEhlscheidEhlscheid
EllenhausenEllenhausenEllenhausenEllenhausenEllenhausen
EngersEngersEngersEngersEngers
FaulbachFaulbachFaulbachFaulbachFaulbach
GladbachGladbachGladbachGladbachGladbach
GrenzauGrenzauGrenzauGrenzauGrenzau
GrossmaischeidGrossmaischeidGrossmaischeidGrossmaischeidGrossmaischeid
Gut zur NetteGut zur NetteGut zur NetteGut zur NetteGut zur Nette
HardertHardertHardertHardertHardert
Heimbach-WeisHeimbach-WeisHeimbach-WeisHeimbach-WeisHeimbach-Weis
HilgertHilgertHilgertHilgertHilgert
HillscheidHillscheidHillscheidHillscheidHillscheid
Hoehr-GrenzhausenHoehr-GrenzhausenHoehr-GrenzhausenHoehr-GrenzhausenHoehr-Grenzhausen
HundsdorfHundsdorfHundsdorfHundsdorfHundsdorf
IsenburgIsenburgIsenburgIsenburgIsenburg
KadenbachKadenbachKadenbachKadenbachKadenbach
KaltenengersKaltenengersKaltenengersKaltenengersKaltenengers
KausenKausenKausenKausenKausen
KettigKettigKettigKettigKettig
KleinmaischeidKleinmaischeidKleinmaischeidKleinmaischeidKleinmaischeid
KoblenzKoblenzKoblenzKoblenzKoblenz
KuemmelbergKuemmelbergKuemmelbergKuemmelbergKuemmelberg
KurtscheidKurtscheidKurtscheidKurtscheidKurtscheid
MelsbachMelsbachMelsbachMelsbachMelsbach
MiesenheimMiesenheimMiesenheimMiesenheimMiesenheim
Muelheim-KaerlichMuelheim-KaerlichMuelheim-KaerlichMuelheim-KaerlichMuelheim-Kaerlich
NauortNauortNauortNauortNauort
NeuwiedNeuwiedNeuwiedNeuwiedNeuwied
NiederbreitbachNiederbreitbachNiederbreitbachNiederbreitbachNiederbreitbach
NiederwerthNiederwerthNiederwerthNiederwerthNiederwerth
OberbieberOberbieberOberbieberOberbieberOberbieber
OberhaidOberhaidOberhaidOberhaidOberhaid
Ransbach-BaumbachRansbach-BaumbachRansbach-BaumbachRansbach-BaumbachRansbach-Baumbach
RengsdorfRengsdorfRengsdorfRengsdorfRengsdorf
RodenbachRodenbachRodenbachRodenbachRodenbach
RuescheidRuescheidRuescheidRuescheidRuescheid
Selters (Westerwald)Selters (Westerwald)Selters (Westerwald)Selters (Westerwald)Selters (Westerwald)
SessenbachSessenbachSessenbachSessenbachSessenbach
Siedlung IsenburgSiedlung IsenburgSiedlung IsenburgSiedlung IsenburgSiedlung Isenburg
SimmernSimmernSimmernSimmernSimmern
St.SebastianSt.SebastianSt.SebastianSt.SebastianSt.Sebastian
StebachStebachStebachStebachStebach
StrombergStrombergStrombergStrombergStromberg
ThalhausenThalhausenThalhausenThalhausenThalhausen
TorneyTorneyTorneyTorneyTorney
UrbarUrbarUrbarUrbarUrbar
UrmitzUrmitzUrmitzUrmitzUrmitz
Urmitz-BahnhofUrmitz-BahnhofUrmitz-BahnhofUrmitz-BahnhofUrmitz-Bahnhof
VallendarVallendarVallendarVallendarVallendar
WeissenthurmWeissenthurmWeissenthurmWeissenthurmWeissenthurmWeitersburgWeitersburgWeitersburgWeitersburgWeitersburg
WirscheidWirscheidWirscheidWirscheidWirscheid
WolfenackerWolfenackerWolfenackerWolfenackerWolfenacker
AlsbachAlsbachAlsbachAlsbachAlsbach
AltwiedAltwiedAltwiedAltwiedAltwied
AndernachAndernachAndernachAndernachAndernach
AnhausenAnhausenAnhausenAnhausenAnhausen
BendorfBendorfBendorfBendorfBendorf
Berg SchoenstattBerg SchoenstattBerg SchoenstattBerg SchoenstattBerg Schoenstatt
BonefeldBonefeldBonefeldBonefeldBonefeld
BreitenauBreitenauBreitenauBreitenauBreitenau
BuerderBuerderBuerderBuerderBuerder
CaanCaanCaanCaanCaan
DatzerothDatzerothDatzerothDatzerothDatzeroth
DeesenDeesenDeesenDeesenDeesenEhlscheidEhlscheidEhlscheidEhlscheidEhlscheid
EllenhausenEllenhausenEllenhausenEllenhausenEllenhausen
EngersEngersEngersEngersEngers
FaulbachFaulbachFaulbachFaulbachFaulbach
GladbachGladbachGladbachGladbachGladbach
GrenzauGrenzauGrenzauGrenzauGrenzau
GrossmaischeidGrossmaischeidGrossmaischeidGrossmaischeidGrossmaischeid
Gut zur NetteGut zur NetteGut zur NetteGut zur NetteGut zur Nette
HardertHardertHardertHardertHardert
Heimbach-WeisHeimbach-WeisHeimbach-WeisHeimbach-WeisHeimbach-Weis
HilgertHilgertHilgertHilgertHilgert
HillscheidHillscheidHillscheidHillscheidHillscheid
Hoehr-GrenzhausenHoehr-GrenzhausenHoehr-GrenzhausenHoehr-GrenzhausenHoehr-Grenzhausen
HundsdorfHundsdorfHundsdorfHundsdorfHundsdorf
IsenburgIsenburgIsenburgIsenburgIsenburg
KadenbachKadenbachKadenbachKadenbachKadenbach
KaltenengersKaltenengersKaltenengersKaltenengersKaltenengers
KausenKausenKausenKausenKausen
KettigKettigKettigKettigKettig
KleinmaischeidKleinmaischeidKleinmaischeidKleinmaischeidKleinmaischeid
KoblenzKoblenzKoblenzKoblenzKoblenz
KuemmelbergKuemmelbergKuemmelbergKuemmelbergKuemmelberg
KurtscheidKurtscheidKurtscheidKurtscheidKurtscheid
MelsbachMelsbachMelsbachMelsbachMelsbach
MiesenheimMiesenheimMiesenheimMiesenheimMiesenheim
Muelheim-KaerlichMuelheim-KaerlichMuelheim-KaerlichMuelheim-KaerlichMuelheim-Kaerlich
NauortNauortNauortNauortNauort
NeuwiedNeuwiedNeuwiedNeuwiedNeuwied
NiederbreitbachNiederbreitbachNiederbreitbachNiederbreitbachNiederbreitbach
NiederwerthNiederwerthNiederwerthNiederwerthNiederwerth
OberbieberOberbieberOberbieberOberbieberOberbieber
OberhaidOberhaidOberhaidOberhaidOberhaid
Ransbach-BaumbachRansbach-BaumbachRansbach-BaumbachRansbach-BaumbachRansbach-Baumbach
RengsdorfRengsdorfRengsdorfRengsdorfRengsdorf
RodenbachRodenbachRodenbachRodenbachRodenbach
RuescheidRuescheidRuescheidRuescheidRuescheid
Selters (Westerwald)Selters (Westerwald)Selters (Westerwald)Selters (Westerwald)Selters (Westerwald)
SessenbachSessenbachSessenbachSessenbachSessenbach
Siedlung IsenburgSiedlung IsenburgSiedlung IsenburgSiedlung IsenburgSiedlung Isenburg
SimmernSimmernSimmernSimmernSimmern
St.SebastianSt.SebastianSt.SebastianSt.SebastianSt.Sebastian
StebachStebachStebachStebachStebach
StrombergStrombergStrombergStrombergStromberg
ThalhausenThalhausenThalhausenThalhausenThalhausen
TorneyTorneyTorneyTorneyTorney
UrbarUrbarUrbarUrbarUrbar
UrmitzUrmitzUrmitzUrmitzUrmitz
Urmitz-BahnhofUrmitz-BahnhofUrmitz-BahnhofUrmitz-BahnhofUrmitz-Bahnhof
VallendarVallendarVallendarVallendarVallendar
WeissenthurmWeissenthurmWeissenthurmWeissenthurmWeissenthurmWeitersburgWeitersburgWeitersburgWeitersburgWeitersburg
WirscheidWirscheidWirscheidWirscheidWirscheid
WolfenackerWolfenackerWolfenackerWolfenackerWolfenacker
Reporting obligations
high aggregated high aggregated
Report levelReport level
high detailed
Work level
INSPIRE
INSPIRE is a Framework Directive
INSPIRE lays down general rules to establish an infrastructure for spatial information for the purposes of Community environmental policies and Policies/activities which may have an impact on the environment
INSPIRE does not require collection of new data (electronic format)
INSPIRE covers 34 Spatial Data Themes laid down in 3 Annexes
Spatial data held by or on behalf of a public authority operating down to the lowest level of government when laws or regulations require their collection or dissemination
INSPIRE
Data objects
Metadata
Semantic
Data sharing
Delivery mechanism
Data sercices
FD - WISE - INSPIRE
Geometric consistencyHigh level semantic and logical consistency
Topological consistencySemantic consistencyLogical consistency
Harmonised spatial data specifications
Common system of unique identifiers for spatial objects
Relationship between spatial objects Key attributes and multilingual thesauri How to exchange the temporal
dimension of data Updates exchange Consistency between items referring to
the same location Consistency between information
referring to the same object at different scales
FD – Process of planning
20122018
20132019
20132019
20152021
Map
Doc.
Map
Doc.
Map
Doc.
Map
Doc.
Sp
atia
l pla
nnin
g -
Lan
d u
se p
lan
nin
g -
Ris
k p
reve
ntio
n -
Wa
ter
ma
nag
emen
t -
Da
ta -
Re
por
ting
sh
ee
ts -
Fo
rma
t fo
r re
po
rtin
g/e
xch
ang
eV
isu
alis
ato
n o
f flo
od
map
s
FD - WISE - INSPIRE
2010
2011
2013
2015
2018
2019
2021
CA/UoMReportingSheet Hazard/Risk.Maps
Areas of floodrisk
2012 Entwurf XML-Schnittstelle FD
Flood hazard/risk-mapsImplementing rule (Risk Zones)
Reporting of geographical InformationWeb-Links to MS with detailed maps
Flood risk management plan
Areas of floodrisk
Flood hazard/risk-maps
Flood risk management plan
FD
– I
NS
PIR
E u
ntil
2015
slig
htly
cro
sslin
ked
FD
– I
NS
PIR
E f
ull h
arm
onis
atio
n
Deadline
Data servicesDelivery mechanism
WISE shared and distributed systemSyncronisation of data bases
In line with the INSPIRE Directive
Compatible with EIONET and Reportnet
Draft Implementing rule
WISECOM
ICxx
...
Member State
National Level
ReportingInterface
BL
FD - WISE
Regional Level
IKSRIKSMS
NationalWG
NationalWG
Dat
a, W
eb-L
inks
RS
, X
ML
-Sch
ema
Tem
pla
teC
od
e L
ist
Tem
pla
te
cons
olid
atio
n
WFD, UWWT,...CorinneGMES...
EU level
National level
Regional level Data managementData management
FD - WISE - INSPIRE
DatabaseDatabase DatabaseDatabase
Data managementData management Data managementData management
RS
Tem
pla
tes
XM
L-S
chem
a
Member State
2015 from 2016 2020
Member State Member State
WISECOM
WISECOM
WISECOM
Inte
rop
erab
ility
ReportingInterface
RS
Tem
pla
tes
XM
L-S
chem
a
INS
PIR
E D
ata
serv
ices
Del
iver
y m
echa
nism
INSPIREInterface
Data managementData management
INSPIREInterface
INS
PIR
E D
ata
serv
ices
Del
iver
y m
echa
nism
INS
PIR
E D
ata
serv
ices
Del
iver
y m
echa
nism
DatabaseDatabaseDatabaseDatabase
Data managementData management
INSPIREInterface
Formal requirements acc. INSPIRE Directive potential for providing datasets
Requirements Art.4 are fulfilled
Reporting obligation of directive oragreement
Member StateCross border
dataset
Nationaldataset
Regionaldataset
Coherence and
adequate crosslinking
with Implementing
Rule
dataset relevant for EU level
Provide INSPIRE compliantFirst priority•Directives / agreements•Cross Border (MS involved more than 1)•National (nationwide)-----------------------------------------------•National (subdivision)•regional
Yes Yes Yes Yes
No No No No
Yes
Yes
Updating Data Specification
Coordination in the maintenance process
No
datasetINSPIRE compliantdemand
(Required)
(EU)MSregionallocal
NoProvide INSPIRE compliant
Second priority
Yes
first no priority
No
Coordination-International / National Identification of the data set field of application• Information• Enforcement• Planning Interoperability• Taxonomies synonym classes• Scale level, ... Privacy requirements etc.
requirements from
Provide of standardized Web services (W3C, OGC)
da
tas
ets
acc
. Th
eme
s A
nn
ex I
- II
I
Flowchart for classification and evolution the datasets for INSPIRE-compliant providing
Providing via standardized web services (OGC, W3C) are not affected
FD – INSPIRE full harmonisation – Deadline 2020
FD - WISE - INSPIRE
FD - WISE - INSPIRE
