191

BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    12

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

!#"$% !&'( ) *+& , -$.!& /0 123&4&40/5/$ 6! #78/09:/<;= ?>@A

BDCE(FGIHJE(KML5NOFKQPSRTNTUVRTW C

X HOY[Z\Y^]_)`M`abG^RTKQZNOc/deRTfgNOc/GIHihi]?j5F/klLWnm$WMG^UVRiFhG^c C ]oOpVprqj$Y X Y^]_)`M`aIG^RTKtsud C h/GIHihi]?v<kraIwMf B GINm)WG^UVRiFh/G^c C ]oOpVpex

y deRTh/GIhX w B f8G^c#c#RTKtGIWt`NOFc/GINVa!zwa^|aIaIf8RTWc5kVz~c/dMRSF/RTDwMG^F/RTf4RTW=c/h<zkVF

c/dMRS)RiVFRiRkVz$kDHc#kVF$kVzsudMGIa^krh/kV`d CGIWtc/deRJG^UGIh/G^krW'kVz_)`M`aIG^RTKQZNOc/deRTf8NOc/GIHih)NOcj5F/kL)Wnm)WG^UVRiFh/G^c C

ZN C oOpVpr

Page 2: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

H v5kV` C FG^rd=coOpVprBDC

E(FGIHJE(KML5NOFKQPSRTNTUVRTW C

Page 3: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

y dGIh KMGIh/h/RiF/c/NOc/G^krW BDC E(FGIH E(KML5NOFKQPSRTNTUVRTW C GIhNVHiHRi`Mc#RTK+GIWQG^c/h<`MFRTh#RTWcz kVFf B=Cc/deRSJG^UGIh/G^krWtkVz._``aIG^RTKQZNOc/deRTf8NOc/GIHih)NVhh/NOc/GIh/z C GIWec/deR

KMGbh/h#RiF/c/NOc/G^krWtFRT=wMGIF/RTf4RTW=c5zkVFc/deRKeRiVF/RiRSkVz)kHc#kVFkVzsudMGIa^krh#kV`?d C

JNOc#R YTYYYYYiY YYYYY YiYYYYY YYiYYYY Y YYYYiYY YYYYYiY YYYYY YiYYYYY YYiYYYY YYYiYYY YYYYiYY YYYYY YiYYYYY YZNOF/c/GIWY?ZNR C ]?JG^FRTHc#kVF

RTHkrf8f8RTWMKeRTKQc#k8c/dMR$FNVKMwNOc#Rv5krwMWMHiGIa

JNOc#R YTYYYYYiY YYYYY YiYYYYY YYiYYYY Y YYYYiYY YYYYYiY YYYYY YiYYYYY YYiYYYY YYYiYYY YYYYiYY YYYYY YiYYYYY Y$RikVF/VR E(f PNOFWMGINVKMNGIhi]RTNVKeRiF

JNOc#R YTYYYYYiY YYYYY YiYYYYY YYiYYYY Y YYYYiYY YYYYYiY YYYYY YiYYYYY YYiYYYY YYYiYYY YYYYiYY YYYYY YiYYYYY Yy dekrf8NVhYskL5RiFhi]RTNVKeRiF

_)`M`MFkUVRTK BDC c/deR$FNVKwMNOc#R v5krwMWHiGIa

JNOc#R YTYYYYYiY YYYYY YiYYYYY YYiYYYY Y YYYYiYY YYYYYiY YYYYY YiYYYYY YYiYYYY YYYiYYY YYYYiYY YYYYY YiYYYYY YX deRTGbaINjukrWKeR$RTNVWnkVz.c/deR$FANVKMwMNOc#R X HAdekDkra

GbGIG

Page 4: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

y deRJG^c/N4kVz.EFGbH E(KeL<NOFKQP RTNUVRTW C

EFAGIHnE(KML5NOFK P RTNTUVRTW C L<NVh B kVFAW krWklUVRTf B RiFnD]Sx GIW c/deRUDGbaIaINOVRnkVzSskVF/cnv<deRTh#c#RiF'GIW RTh#c/HAdeRTh#c#RiF+v5krwWc C ]RiLkVF Y _)z c#RiF'VF/klLGIWe we` GIW c/deR9WeRTNOF BDC c#kLW kVz $NOF/FGIh#krW NVWMKNOc#c#RTWMKMGbWe )NOF/FAGIh#krW )GIrd X HdekDkraJzF/krf x?x=]deR HkrW=c/GIWDweRTKdMGIh'h#c/wMKG^RThQNOcv5kraIwMf B GINm$WMG^UVRiFh/GIc C hwekrwMWMKMNOc/GIkrW X HdekDkrakVzuEuWerGIWeRiRiFGbWe NVWMK9_)`M`aIGIRTK X HiG^RTWHRGbW)RiLkVF ]YJweFGIWMc/dMGbhc/Gbf4RQdeRtL5NVh8h/RTa^RTHc#RTK c#k `NOF/c/GbHiG^`NOc#RQGIW c/deRQ$Ri`NOF/c/f4RTW=c4kVz$EuWeRiF/ C h)NOc/GIkrWMNVam$WMKeRiF/VFNVKwMNOc#ReRTaIaIkLh/dG^`nsF/kVVFANVf GIWnsuaINVh/f8Ngs(d C h/GbHihNVWMKMwh/G^krWEuWeRiF/ C X HiG^RTWMHRThz kVF)c/deRh/wMfgf4RiFkVz(oOpVpVpY WoOpVpexO]deRSVFANVKMwMNOc#RTK"!$#&%('*)#,+.- zF/krf v<kraIwMf B GIN4NOc#c/NVGIWMGbWegNgj$Y X YGIWn_)`0/`aIGIRTK sud C h/GIHihiY1 )RJc/deRTWtc#kDk 'N32#k B NVh N4HiNOF/`!RTWc#RiF L5kVF GIWe4NOch#`!kVc/h<NVa^krWe4c/deR $wMKMh#krW )G^UVRiFT]zF/krfZNVWMdMNOc#c/NVW\c#k JF/RiRTWeR'v5krwWc C Yg_zc#RiFKekrGbWetc/dMGIhJzkVFSkrWeR C RTNOFT].deR B RirNVW\dMGIh$VFNVKwMNOc#Rh#c/wMKG^RThJGIWc/dMR8$GIUDGIhG^krWkVz5_``aIG^RTK+ZNOc/deRTfgNOc/GIHihNOc j5F/kL)W m)WMGIUVRiFh/G^c C GIW9sFkUGIKeRTWMHRV] GIWX Ri`Mc#RTf B RiF8oOpVproRiUVRTW=c/wMNVaIa C RTNOFWMGbWeNVW X HOY[Z YGIW _)`M`abG^RTK ZNOc/deRTf8NOc/GIHih8GbW oOpVprqDY4*dMGIa^R'NOcj5F/kL)W]deR L5NVh NL5NOFKMRTK N5 E6eRTaba^kLhdMG^`7 oOpVpro8/ oOpVp9;:SNVWMK9N X GIf8krW=<Jh/c#FNVHd $FNVKwMNOc#ReRTaIaIkLh/dG^`>7 oOpVp.:AY

?@BADCFEHGI0JKEMLNPOQ

xOYEY EYPSRTNTUVRTW C NVWMKZ Y SYZNDR C Y ZnkKeRTaIGbWec/deRSf8NOrWeRic/GIHGIWc#RiFANVHc/G^krWMh B Ric L5RiRTWn`?NOFNVfR/NOrWMRic/GIH B RTNVKMhGIWQfgNOrWeRic#kVFdeRikra^kVrGbHiNVaSwMGbKMhiYUTV#XWY%RZF[\[]-^+_[a`5b&cedf`%ghcikj.lKT$c

oDYEY EY P RTNUVRTW C NVWMKZ\Y YZNR C Ym Wc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMh B Ric L5RiRTWHk/ f4kUGIWe f8NOrWeRic/GbH+fgGIHF/k/h/LGIf8f4RiFAhiYnikj.lKTYco-YpKcq ]r;s p9Mxxip] oOpVprDY

DYEY EYP RTNUVRTW C NVWMK Z\Y YZNR C Y X `G^FNVa~h#LGIfgf8GIWe8kVzuNVW+NOFc/G^|HiGINVa~f8GIHF/k/ h#L)GIf8f4RiFTYtb&cun'v#&ZF+xwy-^!Yj&cI]XzVs[o8/|xD] oOpVprDY

9eYEY EYrP RTNUVRTW C ]; AY Yrs(GIU GIW]VZ\YZNR C NVWMK Y EYrPSNOFWMGbNVKMNDGbhiY~_ Hkrf4`NOFNOc/G^UVRh/c/wMK CSB RY/c LuRiRTWtKMGbh/h/G^`NOc/GIUVR5`?NOF/c/GIHia^RK C WMNVfgGIHihNVWMK f4kra^RTHiwMaINOFuK C WNVf8GIHihzkVFuh/Gbf4`a^RY/ NVWMK Hkrf4`a^R /VRikrf8Ric#F C SMkL)hiYb0cedBj&-Y%xcikj;l8T$cI]~xTosIxip9Mxip.=] oOpVpzDY

G^U

Page 5: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

GNBL5C &NJO

y dMGbh<c/deRTh/GIh GIhKeRTKMGIHiNOc#RTKQc#kgc/deRSf4RTf4kVFGIRTh kVzE(KeL<NOFK X NUDGINVWMk8NVWMKZNOFG^k X NVW=c/NVWeVRTa^keY L5krwMaIKg|MFh#c(abG VRc#k c/dMNVW8f C c/deRTh/GIhuNVKeUGIh#kVFus(F/kVzRTh/h#kVF ZNOF/c/GbW'ZNDR C YUeF/krf c/deRkrWh#RicukVz

f C VFNVKMwMNOc#RHiNOF/RiRiFJc#k'c/deR Hkrf8`a^Ric/G^krWkVzc/dMGIh)c/deRTh/GIhT]?dMGIh)KeRTKMGIHiNOc/GIkrW]rwMGbKMNVWMHRV]!NVWMKRTWHkrweF /NOVRTf4RTW=c dMNTUVR B RiRTWgGIW=U NVabwMN B a^RVYD NVaIh#kR D`MFRTh/hVFNOc/GIc/wMKeRc#ksFkVz RTh/h/kVF $RikVFVR$PSNOFAWMGINVKMNGIhzkVFh#RiF/UGIWe4NVh N4FRTNVKeRiF kVz~c/dGIh5c/deRTh/GIh NVWMKQdGIh<NVHc/G^UVRS`NOF/c/GbHiG^`NOc/G^krWtGIWtf C F/RTh/RTNOFHdYn 5NVaIh/k L)GIh/d'c#kc/dMNVWtsFkVz RTh/h/kVF y dekrf8NVhs~klLuRiFAhzkVFdMGIh h#RiFUDGIHRSNVhN4F/RTNVKeRiFNVWKtz kVFdGIh f8NVW C DweRTh#c/G^krWhNVWMKHkrf8f4RTW=c/hklUVRiF)c/dMRHkrweFh#R kVz.c/dMGbh<LukVF Y

)LukrwMabK+abG VRc#kQc/dNVWsFkVz RTh/h/kVFS$NUDGbK $kVc#c/aIG^R B zkVF `MF/klUDGIKGIWe f8R L)G^c/dc/dMR4kV`M`!kVF/c/wMWMG^c Cc#k+UDGIhG^cs.NOFGIhNVWMK c/dMR aIN B kVFNOc#kVF C L)deRiF/R8c/deR'f8GIHF/k/ h/LGIf8f4RiFR D`!RiFGbf4RTWc/hLuRiFRg`!RiF/zkVFf4RTKY NVaIh#kc/dMNVW sF/kVzRTh/h#kVFEFAGIH v<aIGbf4RTWcSNVWK ZGIHdeRTabGIWeRg_ BMB NVhz kVFc/deRTG^FfgNVW C KMGbh/HiwMh/h/GIkrWMh NVWMKdekrh#c/GbWe8f4RSKMweFAGIWef C UGIh/G^c<c#k y krwMa^krwMh/RVY

L5krwMaIKaIG VRuc#k)c/dMNVW Sc/deR<h#c/NgkVzMc/deR<JG^UGIh/G^krW kVz?_`M`?aIG^RTKZNOc/deRTf8NOc/GbHihiY LukrwMabKRTh#`!RTHiGINVaba CaIG VR$c#k4c/dMNVWtZNVKMRTaIGIWeRJj5F/RiLh#c#RiFzkVF NVaIakVzdMRiF<dMRTa^`tLG^c/d'F/RTHkrf8f4RTWKMNOc/G^krWQa^Ric#c#RiFh KweFGIWe f C2#k B h#RTNOFHAdNVWMKnz kVFfgNDGIWM4c/deR#j5F/RiLh#c#RiF B F/RiLc/dNOc)dMNVh z weRTa^RTKQfgNVW C f4kVFWGIWec/dekrwerd=c/hiYn L5krwMaIKtNVaIh#k8aIG VR$c#kgR Dc#RTWMKtc/dNVWDhc#kVRTNVW )NVKMGIHiNVWtzkVFNVaIa!kVzdMRiFdeRTa^`] B wec f4kVFRSGIf4`!kVF/c/NVW=c/a CzkVF B FGIWerGIWMf4R$z kDkDKtNVWMKtf4RTKGIHiGIWeR)LdeRTW5 L5NVh Nh/GbH 8`MFkrh#`!RTHc/G^UVR$h/c/wMKeRTW=c B RTK'FGIKMKMRTWgNOc<c/deR_)FaIGIWeVc#krWQdMkrwMh#RVY

5LukrwaIKQaIG VRJc#k8c/dMNVW c/deRVFNVKMwMNOc#RSh#c/wKeRTWc/hkVzc/dMR VF/RTNOc#RiFSwGIKtf4RTHdMNVWGIHih VF/krwe`GIWtc/deRJG^UGIh/G^krWYP kRiFh/`RTHiGI|Hc/dMNVW Dh~c#k VkVFsuG^U GIWNVWMKNVh/f8GIWMRUekDk z kVFc/deRTG^Ff8NVW C HkrW=UVRiFh/NOc/G^krWhNVWMK zFG^RTWMKMhdMG^`Y NVaIh#k9L5krwMaIK aIG VR'c#k+c/dNVW zFG^RTWMKhSzF/krf f C RTWc#RiFGbWe HiaINVh/h$s'P RiUDGbW RTKeRiFT]y dekrfgNVh$RTNVWNVWMKnsRic#RiF<Jf8NVWnNVWMKnLGIh/d'c/deRTf c/deR B RTh#c krWQc/deRTG^Fzwec/wMF/RJRTWMKeRTNTUVkVFAhiY

5LukrwaIKQaIG VR c#k8c/dNVWgc/deRf8NVW C zFG^RTWMKMh5c/dMNOc 5dMNUVRf4RicklUVRiF)c/dMR C RTNOFh B RizkVF/R B RirGIWMWMGIWMVFNVKMwNOc#Rh/HdekDkraRTh#`!RTHiGINVaIa C v<deFGbh#c#kV`deRiF.j5kVF/rGIN]j5RTWK2/NVf8GIWR.G^RiFGIWMe]ZGIHAdMNORTaej<weF B NVW ?]rRiF/RTf CZGIa^VFGIfn]ONVWK8EUVRPa^RTGIWYB NO`M`F/RTHiGINOc#RNVaIakVz!c/deRTG^FR!kVF/c/h(c#k VRiRi` GIW c#krwMHAdYf .NVf NVaIh#kGbWMKeR B c#RTKc#kQc/deR4zFG^RTWMKh)c/dNOc $dMNUVRgf8NVKeR8dMRiF/R4GIW sF/klUDGbKeRTWMHRV]RTh#`!RTHiGINVaba C j<NOF B NOFN G^kUONVWMWekrWeRV] <Ja^rNkrh/dMGTwMf8G ]JZNOF C MNOFWh#LukVFc/dNVWMKj5RTWK2/NVf8GIW*JNTUG^RThNVa^krWM LG^c/d*f C F/kDkrf8f8NOc#RTh X c#Ri`deRTWZGIaIa^RiFNVWMK y dekrf8NVh(s~krabaINOFKYD .c/dMNVW C krwgNVaIaMz kVFuVF/RTNOcuf4RTf8kVFG^RTh(NVWK dekV`!R c/deRTh#RzFG^RTWKMh/dMG^`?hHkrW=c/GIW=wMRklUVRiF C RTNOFAh c#k Hkrf4RVY 4rG^UVR9h#`!RTHiGINVac/dMNVW Dh c#k~GIh/N krWerNOc#keY GIc/dekrwec dMRiFT] c/deRR `RiFAG^RTWMHRkVz aIk=k GIWe zkVFuRTf8`a^k C f4RTW=cuNVWMK LFGIc/GIWe c/dMGIh(c/deRTh/GIh(LukrwaIKgWekVc5dMNTUVR B RiRTW WMRTNOFa C NVh

U

Page 6: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

RTWK2#k C N B aIRVY1 (LGbh/d dMRiF c/deR B RTh/c<NVWKtkRiFf C hwe`M`!kVF/cuNVWKQa^kUVRSNVh h/dMRJHkrW=c/GIWDweRThdeRiF<VFNVKwMNOc#RL5kVF ?Y

.GIWMNVaba C ]WekrWeR8kVz5c/dMGIhJL5krwMaIK B R`!krh/h/G B a^R LG^c/dekrwec c/dMR8HkrWc/GIWDweRTK\hwe`M`!kVF/c NVWMK\a^klUVR8kVz f Cz NVf8GIa C YZkrfQ]JNVKNVWMKQPSRTG^c/d55 uaIkUVRSRTNVHAdkVz C krwnNVWMKnNO``MF/RTHiGINOc#R RiUVRiF C c/dMGIWM4c/dMNOc C krwdMNUVRKekrWeR zkVFf4RVY

y dGIhJLukVF +L<NVhSh/wM`M`!kVF/c#RTK9|WMNVWMHiGbNVaIa CnBDC NVW4 X 3 E eRTaIa^klLh/dMGI`] N X Gbf4krW><Jh#c#FNVHAd$FNVKwMNOc#ReRTaIaIkLh/dG^`nNVWMK BDC c/dMR X wWMKeRiF<VFNVW=c)WDwMf B RiF)v y X / pVoVq proDY

UDG

Page 7: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

GNBL5C &NJO

NJKL @PGJKEMLN

yL,J8EHLrN LBIKI yI rN ;J8EHG A ;I BO EFNPEHOGLr@BOf@DE oDYIx Wc#F/kKMwMHc/GIkrWYSYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY 9oDY[o C KeFkDK C WMNVf8GbHMkVFHRTh YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY z

oDY[oDYIx X kraIUDGIWM c/dMRf4k B GIabG^c C `F/k B a^RTf sfekVFAHRY/ Hkrwe`aIGIWMgf4Ric/dekK YSY YYSYSY YSY oDY ZNOrWeRic/GIHMkVFHRTh YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY oDY9 X weFzNVHRSNVWMK+v5krWc/NVHc)z kVFAHRTh Y YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xipoDY z NVWKekrf j5F/kL)WMGINVWekVFAHRTh YY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xTooDY[q v5krWMHiabwMh/G^krWMh YSYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xY9

L CHO|L ;J EFNBEFN J yEFNJ !BI8J8EHG.C >I N ;J8EHG"]L#8G;OA .J &N$DIKI&%yI rN ;J8EHGA I BO 'DYIx Wc#F/kKMwMHc/GIkrWYSYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xz

DYIxOYIx .G RTKnJG^`!kra^RSZnkKeRTaY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xDYIxOY[o Zwec/wMNVaJG^`!kra^RSZkDKMRTa YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xT

DY[o .GIWMG^c#R =JG^`!kra^RSZkDKMRTa Y YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY oxDY[oDYIx .GIWMGIc#R =$GI`kraIR ZkKeRTa\s X GIWMra^R sNOFc/GIHia^R*YSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY oxDY[oDY[o Zwec/wMNVa.GIWG^c#R =JG^`!kra^RSZnkKeRTa YSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY oDY[oDY v5krf8`wec/NOc/G^krWMNVaRkVF/cgY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY x

DY WMHkVF/`!kVFNOc/GIWex $G^rdeRiFZwMa^c/GI`kraIRTh Y YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY DY DYIx X krabwec/G^krWtc#k8c/deR y Luk/ B kK C s(F/k B a^RTf YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY DY DY[o WMHiaIwMhG^krW'kVz y Luk/ j5kK C R!RTHc/h$GIWc#k $GI`kraIR ZkKeRTaIh YSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY

UGIG

Page 8: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

DY DY E NVf4`?a^R F/RTh/wMaIc/h YSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY DY9 X wMfgf8NOF C YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY 9.z

PNBI EHGOxLO C % I,OO =ADC O$J K@BGJ8@ OxL# BI8I yI N ;J8EHG A I BOxEFN O@BO % &NBOEHLrNBO 9eYIx Wc#F/kKMwMHc/GIkrWYSYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY 9;9eY[o $krw B a^Ric)K C WNVf8GIHih GIWQN4FkVc/NOc/GIWe4|MRTaIK YSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY 9.9eY $Riz kVFAf8NOc/G^krWNVWKQz FANVHc/weF/R kVzHdMNVGbWMhGIWQh/dMRTNOFSMkL)hNVWMKQF/kVc/NOc/GbWe8|MRTaIKh YSY YSY zK9

9eY DYIx v<dNVGIWQGIWQN8h/dMRTNOFSMkL6Y YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY zK99eY DY[o v<dNVGIWQh/w B 2#RTHc c#kgN4FkVc/NOc/GIWe8|MRTabK YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY qx

9eY9 X wMh/`RTWh/G^krWMhukVz.`NOFNVf8NOrWeRic/GbH `NOF/c/GIHiaIRTh GIWtF/kVc/NOc/GIWeg|MRTaIKMhYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY qVq9eY z v5krWMHiabwMh/G^krWMh YSYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY Dx

' I8J8EDG;EMIrC yEHG KL % O E IrN >L &CMO]L ;OG KEHA EFN J &CHI,O$J8EHG4G.Lr@ % CFEHN A .J &N DI8J8EHG.C;O EFN >I rN .J8EHGfCHI &NJO zDYIx Wc#F/kKMwMHc/GIkrWYSYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY zDY[o X wMfgf8NOF C kVz.c/deRZGIHF/k/ h/LGIf8f4RiFE D`!RiFGbf4RTWc/h Y YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY 89zDY ZkDKeRTabGIWec/deREuaINVh#c/GIH / Hkrwe`?aIGIWe YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY Oq

zDY DYIx v<NVh/R Vs*p Y YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xzDY DY[o v<NVh/R ^ s p YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xzDY DY v<NVh/R ^ ^ s pYSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY VozDY DY9 .GIaINVf8RTWcMNVabaIGIWe8m$WMKeRiF $FANTUG^c C Y YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY Vo

zDY9 X GIf wMaINOc/GIkrWMh5kVz.suaINVWMNOF_$Hc/wMNOc/G^krWkVzc/dMRS_F/c/GI|HiGINVa X LGbf8f4RiF4Y YSYSY YYSYSY YSY VqzDY9eYIx v5krf8`NOFGIh#krWtL)G^c/dQE `!RiFGIf4RTW=c/h Y YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY

zDY z v5krWMHiabwMh/G^krWMh YSYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY x

O E 8IXCkO E EHN L3IXN IJKE G.EHIXC EMG 8L% O 5E qDYIx Wc#F/kKMwMHc/GIkrWYSYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY VoqDY[o X GIf wMaINOc/GIkrWRTh/wMaIc/h YSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY qDY RThGIh#c/G^UVRMkVFHRZkDKeRTa YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xipVp

qDY DYIx C KMF/kDK C WMNVfgGIH ekVFHRTh$NVWMK y kVFA=weRTh YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xipVpqDY DY[o ZNOrWeRic/GIH y kVFDweR YSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xipexqDY DY j5krwMWMKNOF C v<krWMKMG^c/G^krWh YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xip

UDGIGbG

Page 9: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

qDY DY9 )krWMKMGIf8RTWMh/G^krWMNVa!Eu=wMNOc/GIkrWMh YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xipqDY9 X LGbf8f8GIWeNOc kL MF/RT=wMRTWMHiG^RTh YSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xip9

qDY9eYIx ZNOrWeRic/GIHz kVFHRTh YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xipqDY9eY[o X L)GIf8f4RiF VRikrf4Ric#F C YY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xVx

qDY z E `MF/RThh/G^krWQGIWtc/deR X LGIf8fgGIWe X `RiRTK YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xVxzqDY[q X wMfgf8NOF C NVWKv5krWMHiaIwh/G^krWMh YY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xVxz

=EFNJ 8I,GJ8EHLrNBOxA ;J &N G.L % yL PEFN yI N ;J8EHG yEHG KL % O 5E KO =YIx Wc#F/kKMwMHc/GIkrWYSYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xVx=Y[o X LGbf8f4RiF / h#L)GIf8f4RiF<GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMh YSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xVxT

=Y[oDYIx X GbKeRY/ B=C / h/GIKMRJHkrWM|MrweFNOc/G^krW:Y YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xVxT=Y[oDY[o v5krWh#RTHiwec/G^UVRHkrWM|MrweFNOc/G^krW:Y YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xToVo=Y[oDY Wc#RiF^/ X LGIf8f8RiFZNOrWeRic/GbH Wc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMh Y YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xToK9

=Y JG^`!kra^RS$RTHkrf4`!krh/G^c/G^krW YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xToz=Y9 X wMfgf8NOF C NVWKv5krWMHiaIwh/G^krWMh YY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xTo

A I PEHL L3IXN IJ8E G.EHIXCkO 5E N ;I5I E E O@ !]I,G DYIx Wc#F/kKMwMHc/GIkrWYSYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xToDY[o WMHkVF/`!kVFNOc/GIWe4c/dMRSd C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIH)RRTHc/h)kVz.c/deR L<NVaIa Y YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xOpDY X GIf wMaINOc/GIkrWMh5kVzc/dMRSNOF/c/G^|HiGINVah/LGIf8f4RiFWMRTNOFN8h/weFzNVHR8Y YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xVq

DY DYIx v<dNVWeVRThGIWtc/dMR X LGIf8fgGIWe X `!RiRTKtkVzN8suaINVWMNOF X L)GIf8f4RiF4YSY YYSYSY YSY xVDY DY[o Ri`wMaIh/GIkrW zF/krf c/dMR \NVaIa$YSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xY9rpDY DY kraIaIGIWe4f4kVc/GIkrWQkVzNgh#`G^FNVabGIWeh#LGIf8f8RiF Y YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xY9Mx

DY9 v5krWMHiabwMh/G^krWMh YSYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xY99

DIPJ8I0J8EHLrN LJ O@DE >L &C1JL DYIx Wc#F/kKMwMHc/GIkrWYSYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xY9qDY[o _ X GIWeraIR X =wMGIFf4RiF YSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xY9;DY X DwMG^Ff8RiF / X DwMG^Ff4RiFU W=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWh YSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xY9DY9 RThwMa^c/h5YSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xY9.

DY9eYIx Wc#RiFANVHc/G^krWMh B Ric LuRiRTWN8h/DwMG^Ff4RiF NVWMKN8h#`deRiFR YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xzxDY9eY[o y FN82#RTHc#kVFG^RThkVz.c Luk'GIWc#RiFANVHc/GIWe8h/DwMG^Ff8RiFh YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xzxDY9eY X RTaIz / KMG !wMhG^krWgkVzN8h=wMGIFf4RiF YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xzVo

G

Page 10: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

DY z v5krWMHiabwMh/G^krWMh YSYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xzz

tLNPG;CH@ EHN >IhO ' xipYIx X wMfgf8NOF C kVz RTh/wMa^c/h Y YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xzVqxipY[oMwec/wMF/RJG^F/RTHc/G^krWhtYSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xzV

Page 11: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

DYIx y deRf8NOrWMG^c/wMKMRQkVz$c/dMRf8NOrWeRic/GIHKMG^`!kra^RQf4krf4RTW=ci] ]5zkVFgRTNVHd B RTNVK GIW NVWRTG^rd=c / B RTNVKnHdMNVGbWQLG^c/d'c/deRSHAdMNVGIWnNeGIh NVaIG^rWMRTKtLG^c/d'c/deRSNO`M`abG^RTK'|MRTaIK] xNVWMK 3xOY y dMRKMG^`!kra^Rf4krf4RTW=c/hQNOF/R Hkrf4`wec#RTK*wMh/GbWe\c/deR f wec/wMNVa$KMG^`!kra^Rf4Ric/dekKnNVWMKnc/deRS|WMGIc#R =KMG^`!kra^R)f8Ric/dekDKnLG^c/dtUONOFG^krwMh UONVaIweRTh<kVz.Y YYSYSY YSY Op

DY[o y deRQf8NOrWMRic/GIH'z kVFHRThT]O]krW RTNVHAd B RTNVK GbW NVW RTG^rd=c / B RTNVK HdMNVGIW L)G^c/d c/dMRHdNVGIW NeGIh NVaIG^rWeRTK\LG^c/d\c/dMR'NO`M`?aIG^RTK9|MRTaIK] x'NVWMK ,xOY y deR z kVFHRThNOF/RHkrf8`wec#RTKQwMh/GbWec/deRSfwMc/wMNVaKMG^`!kra^R$f4Ric/dekKQNVWMKQc/deR |WG^c#R =KMG^`!kra^R$f4Ric/dekKLG^c/dnU NOFGIkrwMh<U NVabweRTh kVz !.YMYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY Op

DY y deR'F/RTh/wa^c/NVWc f8NOrWeRic/GIH'zkVFHRThi]"O]krW RTNVHd B RTNVK GIW NVW RTGIrdc / B RTNVK HdMNVGbWLG^c/dc/dMRHdMNVGbW4NGIh(NVaIG^rWeRTKLGIc/d4NVW8NO`M`aIGIRTK|RTaIKkVzwWMG^cf8NOrWMG^c/wKeRV]# @xOYy deRQzkVFHRTh NOF/RHkrf4`wMc#RTK wMh/GIWM9KG RiFRTWc8f4kKeRTaIh4KMRTh/HFG B RTK deRiF/RVY< WMa C c/dMRzkVFHRTh krW B RTNVKhxV.9)NOF/R(`MF/kUGIKeRTKh/GIWMHRc/deR(z kVFHRTh krWzDNOFR(RTDwMNVarNVWMK kV``krhG^c#Rc#kgc/dMRTh#R U NVabweRThiY+Y YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY 9.

9eYIx y deRSHFAG^c/GIHiNVa ZNVh#krWWDwMf B RiFT]%$&('*),+.-)0/1- ]z kVFRTNVHAdnUONVaIweR kVz2 )0354 HkrWMhGIKeRiF/RTKY Y YSY zK9

DYIx NVaIweRThkVz<z kVFc/deR8`!kra C Wekrf8GINVa ~v Z FRTh/GIh#c/NVWMHR f8NOc#FG 768:90;=<>6 9@?<>68AB9 A <6 ; 9C<D68E KeRic#RiFf8GIWMRTKtz F/krf%|c/hc#kgh/GbfwMabNOc/G^krWtKMNOc/NYYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xK9

DY[o NVaIweRTh)kVzc/deRWMkVFf8NVaIG iRTKHiwec / k KMGIh/c/NVWMHRSzkVFc/deR aIw B FGbHiNOc/G^krW B NOF/FGIRiFNVWMKnc/dMRF 7*9 :NVWMK F 7 x:HkVF/F/RTHc/G^krWMhc#k c/deRaIw B FAGIHiNOc/G^krWF/RTh/GIh#c/NVWHRf8NOc#FG B NVh#RTKkrW4c/deRTh/RHiwec / k\UONVaIweRThiY YY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xz

G

Page 12: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

DYIx NVaIweRTh$kVzc/deR GIW=c#RiF B RTNVKzkVFHRzkVF$c L5k B RTNVKMh)GIWN'wMWMGIz kVFf |MRTaIK 7 pTx/p.:LG^c/dC oDYDYIx7 N.:Vs=4NVh$N8z wMWMHc/G^krWQkVzh/Ri`NOFNOc/G^krWY y dMRSU NVabweRThkVz NOFRWekVFfgNVaIG iRTK BDC c/dMR4U NVaIwMR4kVz gkVz<c/deRgR NVHc h#kraIwec/G^krW NOch#Ri`NOFNOc/G^krW oDYDYIx7 B :Vs 'NVh Ntz wMWMHc/GIkrWkVz<h#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrWY y deR UONVaIweRThJkVz tNOF/R8WekVFf8NVabG iRTK BDCc/deRU NVaIwMR kVz 8kVz.c/deRSR eNVHcJh#kraIwec/G^krWQNOc$h#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrW 6oDYk WQc/deR`a^kVc/h$s37 &:<|DRTKKMG^`!kra^R7 x&: f wec/wMNVaKG^`!kra^R76:uR eNVHc)h#kraIwMc/G^krWY YYSYSY YSY x

DY[o NVaIweRTh$kVzc/deR GIW=c#RiF B RTNVKzkVFHRzkVF$c L5k B RTNVKMh)GIWN'wMWMGIz kVFf |MRTaIK 7 pTx/p.:LG^c/dC zDYDYIx7 N.:Vs=4NVh$N8z wMWMHc/G^krWQkVzh/Ri`NOFNOc/G^krWY y dMRSU NVabweRThkVz NOFRWekVFfgNVaIG iRTK BDC c/dMR4U NVaIwMR4kVz gkVz<c/deRgR NVHc h#kraIwec/G^krW NOch#Ri`NOFNOc/G^krW oDYDYIx7 B :Vs 'NVh Ntz wMWMHc/GIkrWkVz<h#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrWY y deR UONVaIweRThJkVz tNOF/R8WekVFf8NVabG iRTK BDCc/deRU NVaIwMR kVz 8kVz.c/deRSR eNVHcJh#kraIwec/G^krWQNOc$h#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrW 6oDYk WQc/deR`a^kVc/h$s37 &:<|DRTKKMG^`!kra^R7 x&: f wec/wMNVaKG^`!kra^R76:uR eNVHc)h#kraIwMc/G^krWY YYSYSY YSY oOp

DY RTHc#kVF5`kVc#RTW=c/GINVaeHkrW=c#krweFhzkVF(NJ`!krGIW=cKMG^`!kra^R76:NVWMK4NJ|WMGIc#RY/ KMG^`!kra^RuHiwMF/F/RTW=cKMGIh/c#FG B wec/GIkrW 7 x &:5LG^c/d xOY1 W B kVc/dnHiNVh/RTh 7 pTx/p.:AYYSYSY YYSYSY YSY oK9

DY9 sFkV|a^RThkVz z kVF5NVW8GIh#kraINOc#RTK B RTNVK4LG^c/d 9 C(? D]! 7 pTx/p.:A]MNVWK 1xOYnDY9X7 N.:Vs NVa^krWe c/deR ,/ NeGIhuLdeRiF/R)c/deR)UONVaIweRThukVz NOF/RJWekVFfgNVaIG iRTK BDCc/deR4UONVaIweRkVz!8kVz5c/deR4c#FweR4KMG^`!kra^R NOc" xOYxDY9X7 B :Vs" NVa^krWeQc/deR#;/ NGIhLG^c/d c/deR'U NVaIwMRThSkVz$tWekVFf8NVabG iRTK BDC c/deRgUONVaIweR kVz$'kVz c/deR c#FAweRgKMG^`!kra^R8NOc x Y Wc/deR `a^kVc/hs7 %% % := @o&n7 5 &: ! &176: 9'7)( :5`!krGIW=cKMG^`!kra^RVY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY oz

eGIG

Page 13: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

DY z NVaIweRThgkVz NVh8N z wMWMHc/G^krW kVzJh#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrW z kVFgc L5k B RTNVKMh4GIW N\wMWG^z kVFAf:|RTaIK 7 pTx/p.:tNVWMK C oDY DY z07 N.:Vs X Ri`?NOFNOc/G^krW*NVa^krWe c/deRX/ NGbhiY y deRUONVaIweRTh'kVz \NOF/R WekVFAf8NVaIG iRTK B=C c/deR9U NVabweRkVz 9kVzc/deR f wec/wMNVaJKMG^`!kra^RNOch#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krW oDY DY z07 B :Vs X Ri`?NOFNOc/G^krW9NVa^krWetc/deR#;/ NGIhTY y deR UONVaIweRThJkVz NOF/R WekVFfgNVaIG iRTK B=C c/dMR5UONVaIweRukVz <kVzc/dMR5f wec/wMNVaKMG^`!kra^RuNOc.h/Ri`NOFNOc/G^krW % *oDY WQc/deRS`aIkVc/h$s7 Y^Y^Y^Y : o&B7M/n/f/1/ : 6&B76:! 9'B7)( :u`!krGIW=cKMG^`!kra^RVY oV

DY[q NVaIweRTh~kVzGIW=c#RiF/`NOFc/GIHia^RzkVFHRuzkVF c Luk B RTNVKMh~GIWSN$wMWMG^zkVFf|MRTabK 7 pTx/p.:NVWKCoDYnDY[q07 N.:Vs y deRUONVaIweRThkVz SNVhuNzwWMHc/G^krW4kVzh#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krWgWekVFAf8NVaIG iRTK BDCc/deR4UONVaIweR kVz kVzuc/deR4fwMc/wMNVa.KMG^`!kra^RNOcSh/Ri`NOFNOc/G^krW oDY DY[q07 B :Vs NVaIweRThkVz 8UVRiFAh/wMhJh#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrW WekVFf8NVaIGiRTK BDC c/dMR UONVaIweR kVz 8kVzuc/deR4fwMc/wMNVa.KMG^`!kra^RNOc h#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrW % oDY1 Wgc/deR$`a^kVc$s7 : o&7 R &:" 6&P7 : 9'B7)( :<`krGbWc KMG^`!kra^RVY YY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY o

DY v5krf4`?wec/NOc/G^krWMNVaJc/GIf8RzkVFQkrWeR\dDwMWMKeF/RTK c/GIf4R h#c#Ri`?h47 xipVp^:tNVh/h/kDHiGINOc#RTKLG^c/d c/deRgf wec/wMNVa(|WMG^c#R =KMGI`kraIR f4kKeRTauNVhNnz wMWMHc/GIkrW kVz c/deRgWDwMf B RiFkVz B RTNVKhiY7 : f8RTNVh/weF/RTKQL<NVaIa!c/GIf8RP7 &: F 7=:AY Y YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY Vo

DY[ y deR c Luk B kDK C `MF/k B aIRTfQY YSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY DY RThwMa^c/GIWe9NOc#c#FNVHc/G^UVRz kVFHRnNVh4N+z wMWMHc/G^krW kVz)c/deRQW=wMf B RiFkVz)f wMa^c/G^`!kra^RThiY y deR

|MRTaIK+GIh$NVaIG^rWeRTKLG^c/dc/deRaIGIWeRSkVzuHRTWc#RiFh NVWK xOYDY 07 N.:Vs C 1o NVWKDY 07 B :Vs C6zDYYSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY Vq

DYIxipekVFHR4krW N B RTNVK+KMweR c#ktNtKekrw B a^RicL)G^c/d C oDY y deRKMNOc/NtNOF/R4WekVFf8NVabG iRTKBDC c/dMR8U NVabweR8kVz<c/deR8R eNVHch#krabwec/G^krW NOcHkrW=c/NVHciYDYIxip,7 N.:Vs y deR8NO`M`?aIG^RTK9|MRTaIK Gbh`!RiF/`!RTWMKMGIHiwaINOF c#kc/deRth#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krW NeGIhiY DYIxip,7 N.:Vs y deR'NO`M`aIG^RTK\|MRTaIK GbhS`NOFNVaba^RTac#kQc/deRh#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrW NGIhTY W+c/deR`a^kVc/h$s 7 % % :c Luk B kK C HiNVaIHiwMabNOc/G^krW17 _ &:f wec/wMNVaKMGI`kraIRh76:5GIWMHiaIwh/G^krWtf4kKeRTa 7)( :5R eNVHc)h#krabwec/G^krWYY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY 9rp

DYIxVx"ekVFHR4krW N B RTNVK+KMweR c#ktNtKekrw B a^RicL)G^c/d C mzDY y deRKMNOc/NtNOF/R4WekVFf8NVabG iRTKBDC c/dMR8U NVabweR8kVz<c/deR8R eNVHch#krabwec/G^krW NOcHkrW=c/NVHciYDYIxip,7 N.:Vs y deR8NO`M`?aIG^RTK9|MRTaIK Gbh`!RiF/`!RTWMKMGIHiwaINOF c#kc/deRth#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krW NeGIhiY DYIxip,7 N.:Vs y deR'NO`M`aIG^RTK\|MRTaIK GbhS`NOFNVaba^RTac#kQc/deRh#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrW NGIhTY W+c/deR`a^kVc/h$s 7 % % :c Luk B kK C HiNVaIHiwMabNOc/G^krW17 _ &:f wec/wMNVaKMGI`kraIRh76:5GIWMHiaIwh/G^krWtf4kKeRTa 7)( :5R eNVHc)h#krabwec/G^krWYY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY 9o

GIGbG

Page 14: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

DYIxToekVFHR krWN B RTNVKGbWN$c#FGINVWMrwMaINOF~NOFFNVWeVRTf4RTW=ciY y deR5HkrWe|MrweFNOc/GIkrW Gbh~KeRi`?GIHc#RTKGbWc/deRKeFANTLGIWM)LGIc/dc/deR B RTNVK4GbW DweRTh#c/GIkrW4GIWMKMGIHiNOc#RTKY y deR KMNOc/N NOFRWekVFf8NVaIGiRTK BDCc/deR UONVaIweR5kVzc/deR R eNVHch#kraIwMc/G^krWNOc.HkrW=c/NVHciY y dMR5R eNVHcHkrf4`wMc/NOc/G^krW4GIh`MF/klUDGIKMRTKBDC o YR W9c/deR4`a^kVc$sx7 :)c Luk B kK C HiNVaIHiwaINOc/G^krWU7 &:$fwec/wNVaKMG^`!kra^R76: GIWMHiaIwMhG^krWtf4kDKMRTa 7)( :5R eNVHc)h#kraIwMc/G^krWY YSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY 99

9eYIx X VRic/HAdkVz.N8HdNVGIWQkVz z B RTNVKMh KeRizkVFf8GIWe4GIWtFRTh#`!krWMh#R c#kgN4h/dMRTNOFSMklLSYYSY 99eY[o _ `NVG^FgkVz `NOFNVf8NOrWeRic/GbH B RTNVKMhgGbW N Hia^kH DLGIh/RnF/kVc/NOc/GIWe |MRTaIK L)G^c/dD$ )0/5-

$ '*),+.-)0/5- Y y deRGIf8NOVRTh h/dMkL1c/deR B RTNVKMhklUVRiFSc/deR4HkrweFh/RkVzukrWeRkrhHiGIaIaINOc/G^krWY y deRNOF/F/klLhGIWMKMGbHiNOc#Rgc/deRtKMG^F/RTHc/GIkrW kVzc/dMR'NO`M`?aIG^RTK\|RTaIKY W7 H:NVWMK67 Kr: c/deRtz kVFAHRB Ric L5RiRTWnc/deR B RTNVKhGIh<F/Ri`waIh/G^UVRVY@YSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY zOp

9eY <Jh/HiGbaIaINOc/G^krWMh)GIWnc/dMRKMGIh/c/NVWMHR B Ric LuRiRTW+`NOF/c/GbHia^Rh/weFzNVHRTh$zkVF$NVWkrh/HiGIaIabNOc/GIWegKekrw0/B a^RicJNVh$rG^UVRTW BDC 7 N.:R D`!RiFGIf8RTWc/h)kVz V ]17 B :~v Z h/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWhLG^c/d+aIw B FGIHiNK/c/G^krWQHkVF/FRTHc/G^krWMh<NVWMK7 H:5h#c/NVWMKMNOFAK v Z,h/GbfwMabNOc/G^krWMhL)G^c/d'c/deR HkraIaIGIh/GIkrW B NOF/FAG^RiF7 ),3,4 1x pz ' / NVWMK 2 )03,4 oIx 0:AY1 W8c/deRR `!RiFGIf4RTW=c/hc/deRHFAG^c/GIHiNVaMzF/RTDweRTWMH CL<NVh KeRic#RiFAf8GIWeRTK c#k B R ' )5+.- p [oz NVWMK 9 Y W 7 B :NVWMK 7 H:A] c/dMRKMNVh/dMRTK aIGbWeRgHkVF/F/RTh/`krWKMhSc#k p [o GIW c/deR'R D`!RiFGIf8RTWc/hLdMGIa^R4c/dMR'h#krabGIKaIGIWMRJHkVFF/RTh#`!krWMKMh<c#k p 9eYYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY zVo

9eY9 )kVFf8NVaIG iRTKgHkraIaIGIh/GIkrW B NOF/FG^RiFzkVFHR ' / NVhuN z wMWMHc/G^krWkVz!h#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrW8KMGIh#c/NVWHRzkVF2 ),3,4 o proz 7 h#krabGIK4aIGIWeR8:A]2 )03,4 oIx 7 KMNVh/deRTK4aIGbWeR8:A]2 ),3,4 o[o 7 KekVc#c#RTKaIGIWMR8:5NVWMK 2 ),3,4 o 47 KMNVhd&/ KekVc#c#RTKabGIWeR8:AY(YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY z

9eY z ZNOrWMG^c/wMKeRJkVzc/deRJkrh/HiGIaIabNOc/G^krWMhuUVRiFh/wMh=$ )0/5- $ ' )5+.-)0/5- 7 N.:5NVWMKQNOrNVGIWQGIWta^kV/ aIkVh/HiNVa^RR7 B :AY y deRh/kraIGIK4aIGIWMR LG^c/d4c/deR)HiG^FHiwMaINOFuf8NOF VRiFhuHkVF/F/RTh#`!krWMKMhc#k 2 )0354 o[oD]c/deR8KMNVhdeRTK aIGIWeR LG^c/d+kV`!RTW h/DwMNOF/R4f8NOF VRiFAh 2 ),3,4 oIxO]~NVWMK9c/dMR8KMNVh/d&/ KekVc#c#RTKaIGIWMR$L)G^c/dtc#FGINVWeraIRTh=2 ),3,4 o prozDY Y YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY z

9eY[q eF/RTDweRTWMH C kVz$c/deRQkrh/HiGIaIabNOc/G^krWMhKMG^UGIKeRTK B=C c/deRQzF/RT=wMRTWMH C kVz)c/deRnNO`M`aIGIRTK |RTaIKUVRiFh/whR7 N.: $ )0/5- $& '*),+.-)0/5- NVWMK"7 B :$& )0/5- $ '*),+ -),/5- Y y deR h#kraIGIKaIGIWeRSL)G^c/dc/dMRHiG^FHiwaINOFf8NOF VRiFhuHkVF/F/RTh#`!krWMKh.c#k2 ),3,4 o[oD]Dc/deRKMNVh/dMRTK8aIGIWeR<LGIc/dkV`RTW4h=wMNOFRf8NOF VRiFAh 2 )0354 oIxO]NVWMKQc/deRSKNVh/d&/ KekVc#c#RTKaIGIWeR$LG^c/dtc#FGbNVWera^RTh=2 )0354 o prozDY Y zz

9eY _$WnGIaIaIwh#c#FNOc/G^krW'kVz.NVWnRTaIaIGI`h#krGIKMNVa`NOF/c/GIHiaIRSGIWQN8aIGIWMRTNOFh/deRTNOFSMklLSY8YSY YYSYSY YSY zz

GIU

Page 15: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

9eY[ E(DwMGIabG B FGIwf h/dNO`RgkVzNHAdMNVGIW\kVz ,xip B RTNVKMh GIW\N+h/deRTNOFtSMkL LG^c/d KMG !RiF /RTW=c UONVaIweRTh kVz$ 3@) Y y deRtNO`M`aIGIRTK f8NOrWeRic/GbH |RTaIK GbhGIW c/deR'UVRiF/c/GIHiNVa KMGIF/RTH /c/G^krWY>7 N.: $ 3@) p pVpVpD]37 B : $ 3@) p pVpexTD]37 H: $ 3@) %p pVpro=]7 Kr: $& 3 ) p pVpVqD]x7R8: $ 3@) p pVp9.zD]7zV: $& 3 ) p pVpzK9e]7;:$ 3@) *p pVprqD] 7R8: $& 3 ) p pVp.Oo YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY zV

9eY y deRNVWMra^R B Ric L5RiRTW8c/deR)HdMNVGIWgNGIh(GIWc/deRHRTW=c#RiF(kVz!c/deRHAdMNVGIW8NVWK4c/deRNO`M`abG^RTK|MRTaIKtklUVRiF$N8FNVWeVRSkVz$& 3 ) zkVFN8HAdMNVGIWQkVz 1xip B RTNVKMhiY'Y YSYSY YYSYSY YSY z

9eYIxip 7 N.:.ZNGIf wMf1WDwMf B RiFkVz B RTNVKMh GIWN$HdMNVGIWNVhN$z wMWMHc/G^krWkVz $ 3@) NVh.rG^UVRTWBDC ~v Z LGIc/d4c/deR| DRTK KMG^`!kra^Rf4kKeRTaB7 KNVh/d&/ KekVc#c#RTK'aIGIWeR L)G^c/dgh/DwMNOF/R)f8NOF VRiFhV:A]c/deRJfwMc/wMNVa?KG^`!kra^Rf4kKeRTaB7 KNVh/deRTK'aIGIWeRL)G^c/dgkV`!RTW c#FGINVWerwaINOFuf8NOF VRiFhV:(NVWMKgc/dMRz wMaIaf8NOrWeRic/GIHf4kDKMRTa 7 h/kraIGIK4aIGIWMRuLGIc/d4HiG^FHiwMaINOFfgNOF VRiFhV:AY7 B :.ZNGbfwMf WDwMf B RiFkVz B RTNVKMh GIW4NSHAdMNVGIW8NVhuN zwWMHc/G^krW4kVz $& 3 ) NVhrG^UVRTW BDC ~v Z LG^c/d8c/deR zwaIaf8NOrWeRic/GbHf4kKeRTaP7 h#krabGIK4aIGIWeR<LGIc/d8HiG^FHiwMabNOFf8NOF VRiFhV:A] X c#k VRTh5KeFNOabNTL LGIc/d4|RTKKMG^`!kra^R f4kKeRTa17kV`!RTWnh/DwMNOF/RSfgNOF VRiFhV:<NVWKQc/deRSHdNVGIWnf4kKeRTa17H9eYIxY9;:t7 KMNVh/deRTKnabGIWeR8:AY8qOp

9eYIxVx ZNGIf wMf WDwMf B RiF$kVz B RTNVKMh GIW+NtHdMNVGbW+NVhJN'z wMWMHc/G^krWkVz8$ 3@) NVhJrG^UVRTWBDC ~vZL)G^c/dtc/deR z wMaIa!f8NOrWeRic/GIHf4kDKMRTa17 h#kraIGIKtaIGIWMR$L)G^c/dQHiG^FHiwMabNOF<fgNOF VRiFhV:<NVWKc/deRHkVFF/RTHc#RTKHAdMNVGIWnf4kKeRTan7H9eY[ox:7 KMNVh/deRTKaIGIWeR8:AY1YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY qVo

9eYIxTo E(DwMGIabG B FGIwf HdMNVGIW*HkrWe|rweFNOc/G^krWMhtNVWMK kVFGIRTWc/NOc/G^krWh zkVFnN HdMNVGbW kVz xipB RTNVKMh~F/RTaINOc/G^UVRuc#k$N$Hia^kH DLGIh#RuF/kVc/NOc/GIWe)|MRTaIKSL)G^c/dKMG RiF/RTW=c UONVaIweRTh~kVz $ )0/5- Y y deRKMG^FRTHc/G^krWQkVz.c/deRNO`M`?aIG^RTKQf8NOrWeRic/GbH |MRTaIKQGIWnRTNVHd+GIf8NOVRGIhh/dekL)W B=C c/deRNOF/F/kLY7 N.:$ )0/5- *p pD]B7 B : $& )0/1- p pzD] 7 H: $& )0/5- *p p.=]B7 Kr: $ )0/5- *p pD]B7R8:$ )0/5- *p IxVxO]f7zV: $& )0/1- p IxD]D7;:=$ ),/5- *p IxzD] 7R8:$ )0/5- *p Ix YSY YSY qK9

9eYIx y deRNVWMra^R B Ric L5RiRTW8c/deR)HdMNVGIWgNGIh(GIWc/deRHRTW=c#RiF(kVz!c/deRHAdMNVGIW8NVWK4c/deRNO`M`abG^RTK|MRTaIKtklUVRiF$N8FNVWeVRSkVz$& )0/5- z kVFNgHdMNVGIWnkVz 1xip B RTNVKMhTY YSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY qz

9eYIxY9m7 N.: ZNGbfwMf%WDwMf B RiF<kVz B RTNVKh :GIWtNHdMNVGIWQNVh N z wMWMHc/G^krW'kVz $& )0/1- NVh<rG^UVRTWBDC ~v Z LGIc/d4c/deR| DRTK KMG^`!kra^Rf4kKeRTaB7 KNVh/d&/ KekVc#c#RTK'aIGIWeR L)G^c/dgh/DwMNOF/R)f8NOF VRiFhV:A]c/deRJfwMc/wMNVa?KG^`!kra^Rf4kKeRTaB7 KNVh/deRTK'aIGIWeRL)G^c/dgkV`!RTW c#FGINVWerwaINOFuf8NOF VRiFhV:(NVWMKgc/dMRz wMaIaf8NOrWeRic/GIHf4kDKMRTa 7 h/kraIGIK4aIGIWMRuLGIc/d4HiG^FHiwMaINOFfgNOF VRiFhV:AY7 B :.ZNGbfwMf WDwMf B RiFkVz B RTNVKMh GIWnN8HAdMNVGIWnNVh)N4zwWMHc/G^krWtkVz"$& )0/5- NVhrG^UVRTW BDC ~v Z:LG^c/dnc/deR zwaIaf8NOrWeRic/GbHf4kKeRTaP7 h#krabGIK4aIGIWeR<LGIc/d8HiG^FHiwMabNOFf8NOF VRiFhV:A] X c#k VRTh5KeFNOabNTL LGIc/d4|RTKKMG^`!kra^R f4kKeRTa17kV`!RTWnh/DwMNOF/RSfgNOF VRiFhV:<NVWKQc/deRSHdNVGIWnf4kKeRTa17H9eY[oV:t7 KMNVh/deRTKnabGIWeR8:AY8qz

U

Page 16: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

9eYIxz*ZNGIf wMf WDwMf B RiF kVz B RTNVKMh GIWQN4HAdMNVGIWnNVh)N4z wMWMHc/G^krWtkVz$& )0/5- NVhrG^UVRTW BDC~v Z,LG^c/dgc/deR)z wMaIaf8NOrWeRic/GIH$f4kKeRTaD7 h/kraIGIKgabGIWeRLGIc/dgHiG^FHiwaINOFuf8NOF VRiFhV:(NVWMKgc/dMRHkVF/F/RTHc#RTK+HdNVGIWnf4kKeRTa17H9eY Op.:t7 KMNVh/deRTKnabGIWeR8:AY YSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY qVq

9eYIxTq _)VVF/RirNOc/G^krW kVz`?NOFNVf8NOrWeRic/GIH'`NOFc/GIHia^RTh h/w B 2#RTHcc#k N+F/kVc/NOc/GIWe9f8NOrWeRic/GbH |RTaIKLG^c/d$ ),/5- p [os 7 N.: 0 4B+ 3 p OqK9e]e7 B :@ 4 +.3 x zVqOp] 7 H: 0 4B+ 3 o zVqJNVWMK 7 Kr: @ 4 +.3 6Ixzx5LG^c/d 4B+ 3 B RTGbWec/deRu`RiFAG^kDKSkVzec/deRuNO`M`?aIG^RTK |MRTabKY W c/deRTh#RgGbf8NOVRThi] c/dMR B RTNVK GIh Hkra^kVF/RTK B aIweR4G^z5G^cSGIh Nnf4RTf B RiF kVz NVW\NOVVF/RirNOc#RNVWMKQFRTKnG^c F/RTf8NVGbWMh wMWMNOc#c/NVHAdeRTKY1YSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY qV

9eYIx _)VVF/RirNOc/G^krW kVz`?NOFNVf8NOrWeRic/GIH'`NOFc/GIHia^RTh h/w B 2#RTHcc#k N+F/kVc/NOc/GIWe9f8NOrWeRic/GbH |RTaIKLG^c/d $ )0/5- 1o p&s 7 N.: @ 4B+ 3 [qD]n7 B : @ 4B+ 3 xz z=]k7 H: @ 4B+ 3 o zzzQNVWMK"7 Kr: 0 4B+ 3 x zx'LG^c/d 4B+ 3 B RTGIWe8c/deR `!RiFG^kKnkVzc/deRNO`M`abG^RTK|MRTaIKY W*c/deRTh#R\Gbf8NOVRThi]Jc/deR B RTNVKGIhQHkra^kVFRTK B aIweR G^z G^cQGIhQN f4RTf B RiFQkVz NVWNOVVF/RirNOc#R4NVWMKQFRTKQG^c F/RTf8NVGIWh wMWMNOc#c/NVHdMRTKY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY q

9eYIxT X c/N B aIR HiaIwMh/c#RiFhzkVFf4RTK GIW N+h/wMh/`RTWh/G^krW kVz `NOFANVf8NOrWeRic/GIH B RTNVKMhhw B 2#RTHcc#k9NF/kVc/NOc/GIWM8f8NOrWeRic/GIHJ|MRTabK L)G^c/d $& )0/1- o p&s37 N.: ' 6D]P7 B : ' 9e]B7 H: ' zD]7 Kr:a7;: ' q4NVWMK>7 d:a7 2 : ' =Y YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY p

9eYIx X GIf wMaINOc/GIkrWFRTh/wMa^c/h7 B aIwMR HiG^FAHia^RThV:)NVhSHkrf4`NOFRTK LG^c/d+c/deR8KMGbHdeF/krGbh/f KNOc/NQz Fkrf Y YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY Oo

zDYIx X VRic/HAdkVzc/deRNOF/c/GI|HiGINVaf8GIHFk/ h#LGIf8f8RiFTY)Y YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY zzDY[o X VRic/HAd\kVz(c LukWeRTG^rd B kVFAGIWeg`?NOF/c/GIHia^RTh$kVz(c/dMR4|aINVf4RTW=ciY y deR4aIGbWQR DRiFc/hSNtz kVFAHR

3 krW B RTNVK xNVWMKgNVW8RTDwMNVaMNVWMKgkV`M`!krh/G^c#R zkVFHRkrW B RTNVK Y y dMRh/dMNO`!R kVzc/deR aIGIW'GIhHdNOFNVHc#RiFG iRTK BDC c/dMRHk=kVFAKMGIWMNOc#R h C h/c#RTf 7HJ P: c/dNOcU NOFAG^RThNVa^krWMc/deRaIRTWeVc/d8NVWMK8NOc#c/NVGbWMhUONVaIweRTh7HJ :.NOcc/deRaIRiz cNOc#c/NVHAdMf4RTW=cu`!krGIW=ci]NVWMK>7HJ :<NOcc/deRSkV``krhG^c#RJRTWMKY YSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY

zDY X VRic/HAd9kVzN h#RTHc/GIkrWkVzc/dMR|abNVf4RTWc)c/NVGIa hdekLGbWegc/deR`!krh/G^c/G^krW] ]?FANVKMGIwMh ]NVWMK+c/deRwMWMG^c)UVRTHc#kVF J zkVF B RTNVKY y deR UVRTHc#kVF J `!krGIW=c/hzF/krf c/deR`NOF/c/GIHiaIR hHRTW=c#RiF)c#kgNOc#c/NVHAdMf4RTW=c)`!krGIW=c<kVz.c/deRSaIGIWYgY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY

zDY9 E(DwMGIabG B FGIwf h/dMNO`!RTh<kVz c/deRJ|abNVf4RTWc<zkVFKMG !RiF/RTW=c5UONVaIweRTh5kVz7 N.: 9.z[q7 B : 9.zz 7 H: 6VqK9; Ix YY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY z

DUG

Page 17: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

zDY z 7 N.:ZNOrWMG^c/wKeRkVz!c/deRKeRizkVFf8NOc/GIkrW4F/RTaINOc/G^UVRc#kSc/deRa^RTWMVc/d4kVz!c/deR|aINVf8RTWci] ]UVRiFh/wh 7 B : v<dMNVWMVRThGIWtc/deRRRTHc/G^UVR`!RiF/`!RTWMKMGIHiwMabNOFuKeFNO Hk=RgHiGIRTWc kUVRiFN8FANVWeVRkVz 'Y<$NOc/N zF/krf .NOF/RSc/deR aIGIWeRThLG^c/dQc/deRh C f B kraIh LdGIa^R c/deRv Zh/GIf wMaINOc/GIkrWMh`F/RTh#RTW=c#RTK+dMRiF/R NOFRc/deR B abNVH HiG^FAHiwMaINOFJf8NOF VRiFhJNVWMKkrweF X c#k VRTh/a^Rich/GIf wMaINOc/GIkrW4NOF/Rc/deR B aIweR h/DwMNOF/RThiY y deRGbWMh#RicGIf8NOVRTh(kVz!c/deR|aINVf8RTWcRTDwMGIaIG B FGIwMfh/dMNO`!RThNOFRSc/NVRTWnzF/krf Y Y YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY z

zDY[q y deR h/HiNVaIRTK h/LGIf8f8GbWeh#`!RiRTK UVRiFh/wh zkVFN$`aINVWMNOF.h#LGbf8f4RiFLG^c/d $ 1xipNVWMK 1x pY YY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY V

zDY y GIf8RHkrf8`krhG^c#R4GIf8NOVRThJkVz(c/dMRf8kVc/G^krW9kVz5N'`abNVWMNOF h#LGIf8f8RiF)klUVRiFc/deR4HkrweFh/RkVz krWeR `RiFAG^kDK9L)G^c/d7$ xip]% x pNVWMK 7 N.: x zy7 B : py7 H:9 z 7 Kr: 6z z YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY

zDY[ X HiNVa^RTK4h/LGIf8f8GbWe)h#`!RiRTK kVzN h/GIWeraIR5h#L)GIf8f4RiFNVhNJz wMWMHc/G^krW kVz?h/`RiFAf@WDwMf B RiFY y deRf8kVc/G^krW GIh8VRTWeRiFNOc#RTK B=C c/deRf8NOrWeRic/GIH|MRTaIK 7\zDYIx:8LG^c/dD$ xTqD] xIxTqD]NVWK 2 1p IxToDY y deR h#kraIGIK+aIGIWeRLG^c/dc/deR h=wMNOFRf8NOF VRiFAh$hdekLhc/deR h/HiNVa^RTKh/LGIf8f8GbWe h/`RiRTKh k B c/NVGIWeRTKwMh/GIWM4krWMa C ~v Z f4krWekV`!kra^RThc#kgF/RTh#kraIUVRc/deR8d C KMF/kDK C WMNVfgGIHihiY y deR4h#krabGIK9aIGIWeRLG^c/d+c/deR8HF/krh/h/RTh L5NVhJk B c/NVGIWeRTK wMh/GbWe c/dMRz wMaIad C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIH)f4kDKMRTa Y y deR$c#FGINVWera^RJf8NOF VRiFAh NOF/RJc/deRJR D`!RiFGIf8RTWc/NVa?F/RTh/wMaIc/hzF/krf L)dMGIa^R$c/deRKMNVhdeRTKnaIGIWMR)L<NVhk B c/NVGbWeRTK BDC 99 YQYYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY Op

qDYIx E(WKQkrWnNVWMKQk B aIGIDweR)UG^RiLhkVz~c/deRc/GIf4RSHkrf4`!krh/G^c#R GIWeRTfgNOc/GIHih kVzc/deRf8NOrWeRic/GbHf8GIHFk/ h#LGIf8f8RiFSkUVRiF4c/deR'HkrweFh#R kVz krWeRg`!RiFGIkDK L)G^c/d72 p IxTD] x pNVWMK $ xipY7 N.:NVWMK 7 B :HkVFF/RTh#`!krWMK8c#k1x zNVWMK 7 H:NVWMK 7 Kr:.c#k pYtK9

qDY[o E(WKQkrWnNVWMKQk B aIGIDweR)UG^RiLhkVz~c/deRc/GIf4RSHkrf4`!krh/G^c#R GIWeRTfgNOc/GIHih kVzc/deRf8NOrWeRic/GbHf8GIHFk/ h#LGIf8f8RiFSkUVRiF4c/deR'HkrweFh#R kVz krWeRg`!RiFGIkDK L)G^c/d72 p IxTD] x pNVWMK $ xipY7 N.:NVWMK 7 B :HkVFF/RTh#`!krWMK8c#k9 zNVWMK 7 H:NVWMK 7 Kr:.c#k z zDYtz

qDY X HiNVa^RTK'h#LGbf8f8GIWe h#`!RiRTK*UVRiFAh/wMh(h/`RiFAf W=wf B RiFTY7 N.: X HiNVa^RTK h/LGIf8f8GbWe h#`!RiRTKHkrf4`wMc#RTK wMh/GbWetzwMabad C KeF/kK C WNVf8GIH f4kDKMRTa Y y deR8KMkVc#c#RTK aIGIWMR L)G^c/d9c#FGINVWerwaINOFf8NOF VRiFAh$HkVFF/RTh#`!krWMKnc#k $ zD]!c/deR h#kraIGIKaIGIWeRSL)G^c/dnc/deR HiG^FHiwMabNOF)f8NOF VRiFAh$NOFRc/deR $ xip KNOc/NNVWMK c/deRJKMNVh/deRTK'aIGIWMRLG^c/dgc/deR$h=wMNOFR)f8NOF VRiFAh5Gbh(c/deR $

xz9HiNVh#RVY 7 B : X HiNVa^RTK h#LGIf8fgGIWeh#`!RiRTK zkVF $ xip+z kVF8KMG RiF/RTW=ch#c#FNOc#RirG^RThiYy deRh#kraIGbKaIGbWeRSLG^c/d+HiG^FHiwaINOF$fgNOF VRiFhJHkVF/F/RTh#`!krWMKhc#k'c/deRF/kVc/NOF C hHdeRTf4R7 qDYIx:NVWMKQc/dMRKMNVh/deRTKQabGIWeRJLG^c/dQh/DwMNOF/RSfgNOF VRiFhc/dMR `aINVWMNOFh#c#FANOc#Ri C 7\zDYIx:AYYSYSY YSY Vq

UGIG

Page 18: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

qDY9 y deR)U NOFAGINOc/G^krW kVzU7 N.:k7:A]h7 B : ;7:A]P7 H:7:A]eNVWMK 7 K: D7K:LG^c/d NOFHia^RTWeVc/dtLGIc/d $ :xipY y dMR UONVaIweRThkVzk7K:NVWMK D7K:NOF/R'rG^UVRTW F/RTaINOc/GIUVR'c#k9c/dekrh/RkVz5c/deR B RTNVK NOc c/deR4zF/RiR4RTWMK zkVF LdMGIHAd ]k7 0: p]~NVWK B7 0: .Y y deRHiweF/UVRTh GbW RTNVHAdQ`a^kVc<NOF/RJzkVFKMG !RiF/RTWc QLdMGbHd B RirGIW NOc 1x zNVWMKtGIWMHF/RTNVh/RBDC GbWMHF/RTf4RTW=c/h kVz.p z4c#k q pY\Y YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY V

qDY z X HiNVa^RTK h#L)GIf8f8GIWMh#`!RiRTKMhNOc4a^kL zkVFU NOFGIkrwMh $ Y y deRtKMNOc/N9NOF/Rt`a^kVc#c#RTKGIW B kVc/d abGIWeRTNOF / aIGbWeRTNOF NVWMK a^kV/ a^kV h/HiNVaIRThiY y deR9h#kraIGIK aIGIWMRTh8LG^c/d c/deR HiG^FHiwaINOFf8NOF VRiFAh(HkVF/F/RTh/`krWKc#kSc/deR~vZ / Z h/GbfwMabNOc/G^krWMh ~v Z/ f4krWekV`!kra^RNVWK4c/deRh#krabGIKaIGIWMRTh(LGIc/dgc/deRJc#FGbNVWerwMaINOF5f8NOF VRiFh NOF/R$c/deR~v Z/ Z@hGIfwaINOc/G^krWMhiY y deRJKMNVh/dMRTKaIGIWMRGbhJc/deR8h/HiNVa^RTK\h/LGIf8f8GbWe h#`!RiRTK rGIUVRTW B=C 7 qDY O:AY W 7 N.:JNVWMK 7 K: $ z7 6 9 pz:7 B :(NVWMK 7R8:8$ 1xip 7 6 IxVxz:A]NVWK=7 H:uNVWMK=7zV: $ 1xz7 6 xToIxOo:AY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xVxip

qDY[q 7 N.: NVh4N+z wMWMHc/G^krW kVz 6 rG^UVRTW BDC 7 qDY O: 7 B : kV/ a^kV `a^kVc kVz UhiY 6 7 h#kraIGbKaIGIWMR8:5GIWMHiaIwMKGIWe c/deRUONVaIweRNOc 6 p 7 qDY :)NVWMKnc/deR NVh C f4`Mc#kVc/GIHU NVaIwMRThNVh 6 7 qDY[Op.:t7 KMNVh/deRTKaIGIWeRThV:AY W47 N.: NVWMKy7 B :82 *p IxT NVWMK 1x pY xVxVx

qDY 7 N.: NVhNtzwMWHc/G^krW+kVz zkVF$ mz7 6 m9 pz:7 h#kraIGbK+abGIWeR8:A]$ xip7 6 IxVxz: 7 KMNVh/deRTK aIGIWMR8:A]$ xz7 6 xToIxOo: 7 KMkVc#c#RTK aIGIWeR8:A]NVWK$ oOp>7 6 xTq[o: 7 KMNVh/d&/ KekVc#c#RTK aIGIWeR8:LG^c/d 2 p IxTDY 7 B : kV/ a^kV`a^kVckVz 7 h#kraIGIK aIGIWeR8:NVWMK c/deRtNVh C f4`Mc#kVc/GIH'UONVaIweRTh z kVF p9NVWMK

7 qDY[x:t7 KMNVh/deRTKnabGIWeRThV:(LG^c/d $ 1xip8NVWK 2 *p IxT YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xVxToqDY[ 7 N.:1NVh)N8z wMWMHc/G^krWtkVz"2 z kVF $ z7 h#krabGIKnaIGIWMR8:A] $ xip7 KNVh/deRTKnaIGbWeR8:A]

$ xz 7 KMkVc#c#RTK aIGbWeR8:A]5NVWKD$ oOp 7 KMNVhd&/ KekVc#c#RTK abGIWeR8:LG^c/d x pY7 B : kV/ a^kV `?a^kVc8kVz 7 h/kraIGIK aIGbWeR8: NVWMK c/deRNVh C f8`Mc#kVc/GIHnUONVaIweRTh8z kVF 2 p7 qDY[:NVWMK 2 7 qDY[z: 7 KNVh/deRTKnaIGbWeRThV:(LG^c/d $ 1xip8NVWMK %1xOY1Y YSY xVx

=YIx 7 N.: X LGIf8f8GbWeuh#`!RiRTKSNVh N zwWMHc/G^krWJkVzeh#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrWSKMGIh#c/NVWHRz kVF h/c/NVH VRTK h#LGIf8f8RiFhKeFGIUVRTW B=C c/deRSNO`M`abG^RTKg|RTaIK47\zDYIx:AY7 B : y deRJF/Ri`wMaIhG^krWgUVRTaIkDHiG^c C L)G^c/dtc/deRSKMNVh/dMRTKaIGIWMR `MF/kUGIKeRTK B=C 7a=YIx:AY y deRGIWMh/Rich/dekL)h(c/deR)f4kVc/G^krW8kVzc/dMRc L5kh/LGIf8f4RiFAhkUVRiFkrWeR)`RiFAG^kDKkVz!c/deR$NO`M`aIGIRTK|MRTaIKYe7 B : kV/ a^kV`?a^kVckVz!c/deRF/Ri`?wMaIh/G^krWUVRTaIkDHiG^c C kUVRiFNnFANVWeVR8kVz h#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrW KMGIh/c/NVWMHRThiY y dMRgKMNVh/deRTK aIGIWeRTh GIhS`MF/kUGIKeRTK BDC 7a=YIx:SNVWKKeRTHiN C h$NVh A YeYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xVx

DUGIGIG

Page 19: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

=Y[o _$W RTWMK0/ krW UG^RiLkVzc/deR f8kVc/G^krW kVzc L5k9hGIKeRY/ BDC / h/GbKeRgh#`GIFNVaIGIWeQh#L)GIf8f4RiFhkUVRiFkrWeR8`!RiFGIkDKkVzuc/dMR8NO`M`aIG^RTK+|MRTabKY y deR4f4kVc/G^krW kVz5c/deR4c/NVGIaIh NOFR8Hkrwe`a^RTK BDC c/dMRNO`M`abG^RTKt|MRTaIKtc/dMNOc)GIh<F/kVc/NOc/GIWe HkrwMWc#RiF$Hia^kH DLGIh#RVY*YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xToOp

=Y 7 N.: X L)GIf8f8GIWM h#`!RiRTKNVhnN zwWMHc/G^krW*kVzh/Ri`NOFNOc/G^krWKMGbh#c/NVWMHR9z kVFh/GIKeRY/ BDC / hGIKeRh#LGbf8f4RiFh KeFAG^UVRTW B=C c/deRNO`M`aIG^RTK'|MRTabK>7 qDYIx:AY 7 B :<sF/RTHRThh/G^krWQUVRTa^kHiG^c C ] ]NVWKF/Ri`waIh/G^krW UVRTa^kDHiGIc C ] i]UVRiFh/wMh4h/Ri`NOFNOc/G^krW KMGIh/c/NVWMHRVY y deRtKMNVh/deRTK NVWMK KekVc#c#RTKaIGIWMRThNOF/Rt`MFkUGIKeRTK B=C RTDwMNOc/G^krWh7a=Y[o: NVWMK67a=Y :F/RTh#`!RTHc/G^UVRTa C Y y dMR'GIWh#Ric/hGbWc/deR c Luk8|rweF/RTh h/deklLc/deR f4kVc/G^krWnkVz~c/deRJc Lukgh/LGIf8f4RiFAhuklUVRiFkrWeR `!RiFGIkDK kVz~c/dMRNO`M`abG^RTKt|MRTaIKY YY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xTox

=Y9 kV/ aIkVQ`a^kVc$kVz(c/deR`MF/RTHRThh/G^krW+NVWMK+F/Ri`wMaIhG^krWnUVRTa^kHiG^c/G^RTh$klUVRiFN'FNVWeVRkVzuh#Ri`?NK/FNOc/G^krW9KMGbh#c/NVWMHRThiY y deRKNVh/deRTK+GIhrGIUVRTW BDC 7a=Y[o:$NVWMKc/deRKekVc#c#RTK9aIGIWeR BDC 7a=Y[o:AYj5kVc/dKeRTHiN C aIG VR A Y Y YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xTox

=Y z _ c#kV`,/ UDG^RiL kVzc/dMR5f4kVc/GIkrWkVzc L5kJHkrWh#RTHiwec/G^UVR<`aINVWNOFh#L)GIf8f4RiFh kUVRiFkrWeR5`!RiFG^kKkVz.c/deRNO`M`?aIG^RTK'|MRTaIKYuYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xTo

=Y[q 7 N.: X LGIf8fgGIWeQh#`!RiRTKMhSzkVFc Luk9h#LGbf8f4RiFhSNOFFNVWeVRTK HkrWMh#RTHiwec/G^UVRTa C NVWK KeFGIUVRTWBDC NO``aIG^RTKt|MRTabK47\zDYIx:AY7 B : kV/ a^kV `a^kVckVz.c/deRKMG !RiF/RTWMHRSGIWnh/LGIf8f8GbWe h/`RiRTKhLG^c/d9c/dMR8KMNVh/deRTK aIGbWeR B RTGbWe zF/krf =Y9LG^c/d9c/deR4UONVaIweRkVz zkVFSc/deR4`aINVWNOFh#LGbf8f4RiFTY1YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xTo

=Y 7 N.: y deR F/Ri`wMaIhG^krW UVRTa^kHiG^c C NVhNzwWMHc/G^krW\kVz)h#Ri`NOFNOc/G^krWYy7 B : y deRgc Luk9h#LGbfR/f8GIWM)h#`!RiRTKMh z kVF.HkrWMh#RTHiwec/GIUVR5`?aINVWMNOF~h/LGIf8f4RiFAhiY y deR5h#kraIGIKaIGIWeRL)G^c/dSc/deR<HiG^FHiwaINOFf8NOF VRiFAhNOF/R8zF/krf,hGIfwaINOc/G^krWMhJLdMRiF/R4c/deR8f8NOrWeRic/GbHgGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhNOF/RgGIWMHiabwMKeRTKLdMGba^Rc/deR4KMNVhdeRTK aIGIWeRLG^c/dc/deRc#FGINVWerwaINOF f8NOF VRiFh HkVF/FRTh#`!krWMKMh)c#kQc/deR4h/GIf w&/aINOc/G^krWh LdeRiF/R c/dMRSf8NOrWeRic/GIHSGbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMhNOF/RGIrWekVF/RTKY,YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xToz

=Y[ v5krf4`!krWeRTW=c/h4kVz)c/deRQz kVFAHRnKMG^`!kra^R'kVz)c/deRQ`?aINVWMNOF4h#LGIfgf4RiFs7 N.: y deRnWekrW&/ iRiFkHkrf4`!krWeRTW=c/h(kVzc/dMRc#FNVHRTa^RTh/h5h#c#F/RThh/a^Ric+ kUVRiF<c/deR)HkrweFh#R)kVzkrWeR`!RiFG^kK4krW8c/dMRNO`M`abG^RTKg|RTaIKY7 B : y deR WekrW&/ iRiFkHkrf8`krWMRTWc kVz~c/deR NVWc/G / h C f8f8Ric#FGIH$`NOF/c<kVz c/dMRzkVFHRKMG^`!kra^RV] A YgYSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xToVq

G

Page 20: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

=Y v5krf4`!krWeRTW=c/h kVzSc/deR+z kVFHR9KMG^`!kra^RQkVzc/deR+h/`G^FNVah/LGIf8f4RiFs7 N.: y deR9WekrW&/ iRiFkHkrf4`!krWeRTW=c/h(kVzc/dMRc#FNVHRTa^RTh/h5h#c#F/RThh/a^Ric+ kUVRiF<c/deR)HkrweFh#R)kVzkrWeR`!RiFG^kK4krW8c/dMRNO`M`abG^RTK9|MRTaIKY y deR8aIGbWeRThJLG^c/dekrwMcSc/deRgf8NOF VRiFhh/dMkL c#k+KMGINOVkrWMNVa(Hkrf4`!krWeRTWc/hLG^c/d+c/deR8h/kraIGIK+aIGIWeR B RTGIWe ]c/deR8KMNVh/dMRTK+abGIWeR A0A NVWMK9c/deR4KekVc#c#RTK\aIGbWeR ?0? Yy deR aIGIWeRThLG^c/dQc/deR f8NOF VRiFh$NOF/Rc/deRk KGINOVkrWMNVa Hkrf8`krWMRTWc/h)LdeRiF/Rc/deRh#krabGIKaIGIWMR LG^c/dnHiG^FAHiwMaINOFf8NOF VRiFAhGIh A ]c/deRKNVh/deRTKnaIGbWeR LG^c/dQc#FAGINVWerwMaINOFfgNOF VRiFhGbh ? NVWK c/deRgKekVc#c#RTK aIGIWeRLGIc/d9c/deRgh/DwMNOF/RgfgNOF VRiFhSGIh A ? Y 7 B : y deRgWekrW&/ iRiFkHkrf4`!krWeRTW=ckVz.c/deRSNVW=c/G / h C f8f4Ric#FGIHJ`?NOF/c kVz.c/deRSzkVFHRSKMG^`!kra^RV] A ] ? ]MNVWMK A ? YJxToVq

DYIx y deR f4kVc/G^krW\kVz Nh/GIWera^R8h/`deRiF/R8WeRTNOF NnFGIrGIK9`aINVWeR4rGIUVRTW BDC c/dMR5~v Z GIf8NOVRh C h#c#RTf 7 HiG^FAHiwMaINOF<f8NOF VRiFhV:5NVWK c/dMR MNRTWHkVF/F/RTHc/G^krWMh 7 KNVh/deRTKQaIGIWMRThV:AY 7 N.: s~RiF^/`!RTWMKMGIHiwaINOF f8kVc/G^krW 7 DYIxTo: 7 B : s.NOFNVaIaIRTa5f8kVc/G^krW 7 DYIx: 7 H: kVc/NOc/G^krWMNVa f4kVc/G^krW7 DYIxY9;:t7 Kr: kVc/NOc/GIkrW&/ y FANVWMh/aINOc/G^krWHkrwe`aIGIWM_7 DYIxz: YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY x

DY[o y deRSf8kVc/G^krWnkVz.N8h/GIWMra^R h#`deRiF/RSWMRTNOFN4FG^rGbK `?aINVWeRVY y dMRJh/kraIGIKQHiG^FHiwaINOFf8NOF VRiFhGIWMKGIHiNOc#R<c/deR~v Z/ GIf8NOVR$NO`M`MF/krNVHAd]rc/deR c#FGbNVWerwMaINOFf8NOF VRiFAhNOF/R c/deR R eNVHcuh#krabw&/c/G^krWMh c#kc/deR X c#k VRTh~RT=wMNOc/GIkrWMh`MFkUGIKeRTK BDC 9.zDNVWMK xT=NVWMKc/deR(h#krabGIKSaIGIWMRThh/dekLc/deRk~v Z/ GIf8NOVR5LG^c/d c/deR5aIw B FAGIHiNOc/G^krW HkVF/F/RTHc/GIkrWY 7 N.:sRiF/`!RTWMKMGIHiwMabNOFf4kVc/G^krW57 B :s.NOFNVaIa^RTa f4kVc/G^krW>7 H: kVc/NOc/G^krWMNVa~f4kVc/G^krW>7 Kr: kVc/NOc/G^krW&/ y FNVWMhaINOc/G^krWnHkrwe`?aIGIWe YSY x

DY 7 N.: X HiNVaIRTK h#LGIf8fgGIWegh#`!RiRTK9UVRiFhwMh z kVFSh/RiUVRiFNVadeRTG^rd=c/hiY_7 B : X HiNVa^RTK9h#LGbfR/f8GIWM8h#`!RiRTKtUVRiFh/wMh c/dMRSF/RTh/HiNVa^RTKh#`!RiFf W=wf B RiF lYnY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY x

DY9 v<dMNVWMVRTh'GbW c/deR9KeFNO `!RiF wMWMGIcga^RTWeVc/d krW*N |abNVf4RTWc'HkrWMh/GIh/c/GIWe kVz xzB RTNVKMhiY y dMRh#kraIGbK B abweRaIGbWeRLGIc/dc/deR4h/DwMNOF/Rf8NOF VRiFAh$GbWMKMGIHiNOc#RTh$c/deRHk=R HiG^RTWczkVFf4kVc/GIkrW`NOFANVaIa^RTaVc#k$c/deR<NGIh kVzec/deR5|aINVf4RTW=c NVWMKc/deRuh/kraIGIK B aINVH SaIGbWeRGIWMKMGbHiNOc#RThc/deR KeFNO8`!RiF/`!RTWMKMGbHiwMaINOF5c#kgc/deRNeGIhiY y deRSKNVh/deRTKabGIWeRTh NOF/Rc/deRSUONVaIweRTh kVzc/deRTh/RHkDRgHiG^RTW=c/h)GIWQwW B krwMWMKMRTK SwGIKY YSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xY9rp

DY z Ri`?wMaIh/G^krW h#`!RiRTK kVz c/deR`aINVWMNOFgh/LGIf8f4RiFgz kVF p NVWMK 9 z NVh'Nz wMWMHc/G^krWQkVzc/deRdMRTG^rdc zF/krf%c/deRh/wMF/zNVHRVY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xY9Mx

DY[q krabaIGIWegh/`RiRTKzkVF p NVWMK 9 z NVhJN'zwMWHc/G^krWnkVzc/dMR deRTGIrdc +z Fkrfc/deRhweF/z NVHRVY YSYY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xY9o

Page 21: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

DYIx 7 N.: ) ]37 B : ]37 H: ](NVWMK 7 K: ( kVz)NVW GIWeRiFc h#`?deRiF/RtNVh4Nz wMWMHc/GIkrWkVzKMGbh#c/NVWMHR'z F/krf N9h/DwMG^Ff4RiFY y deR'aIGIWeRThh/dekL%c/deR'z NOF / |MRTaIK NVWMNVa C h/GIh NVWMK c/dMRHiG^FHiwaINOF h C f B kraIhuc/deRSj<EuZ,hGIfwaINOc/G^krW F/RTh/wMa^c/h z Y y deRJh/=wNOF/RTh NVWMK'c#FGINVWeraIRThNOF/RSc/dMRSU NVabweRTh KeRic#RiFf8GbWeRTKQwMh/GIWM c/dMR~v Z:zkVFfwaINOc/G^krWY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xzOp

DY[o MkVz(NVW+GIWeRiF/c$h#`deRiF/R NVhJNgz wMWMHc/G^krWkVzKMGIh/c/NVWMHRzF/krf N h=wMGIFf4RiFTY y deRaIGbWeRThh/deklL,c/deR z NOF / |MRTaIKNVWNVa C hGIhtNVWMKc/deR\HiG^FAHiwMaINOFQh C f B kraIhtc/deR\j<E5Z h/GbfwMabNOc/G^krWF/RTh/wa^c/h z Y y deR4h/DwMNOF/RTh NVWMK9c#FGbNVWera^RTh NOF/Rc/deR4UONVaIweRTh KeRic#RiFAf8GIWeRTK9wMh/GbWe c/dMR~v Z zkVFf wMaINOc/G^krWY,YSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xzx

DY y FN82 RTHc#kVFAG^RThSkVz<c L5kh=wMGIFf4RiFh$LG^c/d 7 z: f4kUGIWenGIW 7 N.: kV`M`!krh/G^c#R4NVWMK 7 B :c/deRhNVf4RnKMG^F/RTHc/GIkrWMhiY" W RTNVHd `?a^kVci](c/deRh C f B kraIh4NOF/RQ`MFkUGIKeRTK BDC c/deRv Zh/GIf wMaINOc/GIkrWMh<LdMGIaIR)c/deRaIGIWeRTh<NOF/RSc/dMRSF/RTh/wMaIc/h<kVz z Y YSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xzVo

DY9 EUVkrabwec/G^krW+kVzuNth/wMh/`RTWh/G^krWnkVz oOpVpVpQh/DwMG^Ff4RiFAhGIWMGIc/GINVaIa C h#LGbf8f8GIWe GIWc/dMR`!krh/G^c/G^UVR ,/ KMG^FRTHc/G^krWY>7 N.: p ! 7 B : x 7 H: o [ 7 K: 9Mx ! YY YSYSY YSYSYY YSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSYSY YYSYSY YSY xz

DY z y FNVWMh/aINOc/GIkrWMNVa h#RTaIz / KMG !wMhG^krWQHk=R HiG^RTWc$kVzNgh=wMGIFf4RiFt7 z:NVh$N8z wMWMHc/GIkrWnkVz Y_ HkrWh#c/NVWc(U NVaIwMRGIWMKMGIHiNOc#RTh(N KMG wMh/G^UVR f4kKeRVY y deR~vZ FRTh/wMa^c/hNOF/R)h/dekL)WNVh B aINVH h/DwMNOF/RTh NVWMK HkVFF/RTh#`!krWMK\c#k N+h/GIf wMaINOc/G^krW\kVz oOpVpVp9NVWMK UVkraIwMf8RzFNVHc/G^krW *p p9oDY y deRSabGIWeRTh5z kVF*p proz p IxSNOF/RSzF/krf zz Y Y YYSYSY YSY xzK9

eG

Page 22: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

X we`!RiF/`?NOFNVf8NOrWeRic/GIH`NOF/c/GIHiaIRThi]?FANVWerGIWe z F/krf p xip GIWKMGINVf4Ric#RiF]!hwMh#`!RTWMKeRTKGIWN'aIGIDwMGIKLGIaba~NOVVF/RirNOc#R'c#knzkVFf HdNVGIWMh LdMRTW NVW GIWMG^c/GINVaba C FNVWMKekrf KGIh#`!RiFh/G^krW+GIhJ`abNVHRTK GIW NQwMWMG^zkVFfQ]h#c/NOc/GIH4fgNOrWeRic/GIH |MRTaIKY y deRz kVFfgNOc/G^krW+kVz(c/deRTh#R4| B F/krwMh$h#c#FwMHc/wMF/RThJHdMNVWeVRThSc/deR B wMa nFAdeRikra^kV/GIHiNVa<`MFkV`RiFc/G^RTh kVz)c/deRQf4RTKGIwMf NVWMK NVh8h/wHd c/deRTh#RnhwMh#`!RTWMh/G^krWhNOF/RQc C `?GIHiNVaIa C FRiz RiF/FRTK c#k NVhf8NOrWeRic#kVFAdeRikra^kVrGIHiNVa3SwMGIKh_7 Z : q Y y FNVKG^c/G^krWMNVaIa C ]5Z (SwGIKMh4dMNUVR B RiRTW RTf4`?a^k C RTK GIW NUONOFG^Ric C kVz~KMNVf4`?GIWeNVWMKth/dMkDH gN B h#kVF B GIWeKeRiUGIHRTh5LdeRiFR)c/deR$`NOF/c/GbHia^RUVkraIwf4R)zFNVHc/G^krWhuzkVF<c/deRh/wMh/`RTWh/G^krWMhFNVWeVRnzF/krf oOpK/a9rptY W c/dMGIh8HkrW=c#R ci] c/deRQ`NOF/c/GIHiaIRTh8NOF/RwMhwMNVaIa C HiNOF B krW C a G^F/krW`!kLKMRiFh h/wMh#`!RTWMKMRTKGIW9krGbaNVWMK NOF/R8h/w B 2 RTHc c#knh#c#FkrWenf8NOrWeRic/GIH8|MRTaIKMhi]GbWR eHRTh/hkVz$xip E YX wMHAd8Z SwMGbKMh~KG RiFzF/krf zRiF/F/kS?wMGIKMh xiprMc/dMNOcuHkrWMh/GIh#ckVz!HkraIa^krGbKMNVah/wMh#`!RTWMh/GIkrWMh kVzWMNVWMkrh/HiNVa^RzRiF/F/krf8NOrWeRic/GbH8`NOF/c/GbHia^RThi] c C `?GIHiNVaIa C h/GIWeraIR8Kekrf8NVGIW\fgNOrWeRic/G^c#RtHF C h/c/NVaIhgxip GbW\KMGINVf4Ric#RiFY WzRiF/F/kSwMGbKMhi]Oc/deR `NOF/c/GbHia^RThdMNTUVR)NSh/weF/z NVHc/NVW=cHkrNOc/GIWeSc/dMNOc(`MF/RiUVRTW=c/h`!RiFf8NVWeRTW=cNOVVF/RirNOc/G^krW'NVWMKj5F/kL)WMGINVWnf4kVc/GIkrWnGIh<UVRiF C h/G^rWG^|HiNVW=ci]GbWMdMG B GIc/GIWec/dMR z kVFfgNOc/G^krWQkVz.`NOF/c/GIHiaIRJh/c#FwMHc/weF/RThTY

ZkVF/RF/RTHRTW=c/a C ]h/we`!RiF/`NOFANVf8NOrWeRic/GIH5`NOF/c/GbHia^RThNVWMK4c/dMRh#c#FwMHc/weFRThc/dMNOcc/deR C zkVFf dMNUVR B RiRTWRTf4`aIk C RTKGIW*N UONOFG^Ric C kVzf8GIHF/kS?wMGIKMGIHKeRiUGIHRThiY y deRTh#R\f4krWMkDKMGbh#`!RiFh#R`!kra C f4RiFGbHh#`?deRiFGIHiNVa`NOF/c/GbHia^RTh HkrWc/NVGbWMGIWetFNVWMKMkrf8a C kVFGIRTWc#RTK\fgNOrWeRic/G^c#R8HF C h#c/NVaIhSNOFR VR C Hkrf4`!krWeRTW=c/hSGIW9FRTHRTWc/a CKeRiUVRTa^kV`!RTKt )_ h#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrW'HAdMG^`h VoNVWMK'f8GIHF/k/ fgG DRiFAh xipz Y X f8NVaIaVF/krwe`h5kVz`NOFc/GIHia^RTh<HiNVWB RQf8NVWMG^`waINOc#RTK c#k zkVFf f8GIHFk/ `wMf4`h GIW N HdNVWMWeRTa x ]ukVF2 krGIWMRTK c#kVVRic/dMRiFgc#k N9`MF/kKMwMHRf8NOrWeRic/GbH|aINVf4RTW=c 9]xVx c/dMNOcS`MFkUGIKeRTh$c/deR4`MF/kV`?wMaIh/G^UVR f4RTHdNVWMGIh/f zkVFSNVW NOF/c/G^|HiGbNVafgGIHF/k/h#LGbf8f4RiF Y

_$KMKMG^c/GIkrWMNVa!R D`!RiFGbf4RTWc/NVah/c/wMKMG^RThdNTUVRzkHiwMh#RTKQkrWc/deR B NVh/GbH `d C h/GbHih<kVzc/deRTh#Rh/wh#`!RTWMh/G^krWMhNVWMKc/deRh#RTa^zM/ NVh/h#RTf B a^RTKh#c#FwMHc/weFRThiY y deRiF/RdMNUVR B RiRTWnWDwMf4RiF/krwhh#c/wMKG^RTh F/RirNOFKGIWe4c/deRNOVVFRY/

x

Page 23: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

o

rNOc/G^krW `MF/kHRTh/h#RThSNVWMK\c/deR8VF/klLc/d\FNOc#RThkVz<c/deRgHdNVGIW\h#c#FwHc/weF/RThSGIW hwMh#`!RTWMh/G^krWh$hw B 2#RTHc c#kNwMWMGIz kVFf |MRTabK xipro]rxO]rOpe]Xz Y y deR h#c#F/RTWMVc/dnNVWMKnGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWh B Ric L5RiRTWnc/deRSGIWKMG^UGIKMwMNVa?aIGIWeRTNOFh#c#FwHc/weF/RTh4dMNVh4NVaIh/k B RiRTW GIW=UVRTh#c/G^rNOc#RTK 9MxV] 9.]f9o Y _VVFRirNOc/G^krW wMWKeRiFF/kVc/NOc/GIWe |MRTabKMhdMNVhNVaIh#k B RiRTW9HkrWMh/GIKeRiFRTK ]xVxzNVWMK9GIabaIwMh#c#FNOc#RTKdekL1c/deR4GIW=c#F/kKMwMHc/G^krWkVz(UGIh/HkrwMh$h#c#F/RThh#RTh HiNVWKeFNVfgNOc/GIHiNVaIa C HdMNVWeVRc/deRSh/dMNO`!R kVzc/deRSF/RThwMa^c/GIWeh#c#FwHc/weF/RThiY

*dMGIa^Rc/deRiF/R)dNVh B RiRTWgNVW R c#RTWMh/G^UVR)R D`!RiFGIf8RTWc/NVaRkVF/c5c#kDwMNVW=c/G^z C hwMh#`!RTWMh/G^krW8`MF/kV`!RiF/c/G^RThNVWMK h#c#FwMHc/wMFNVa(K C WMNVf8GbHihi] c/deRtWDwMf B RiFkVz c/deRikVF/Ric/GIHiNVaukVF4W=wMf8RiFGIHiNVah#c/wKMG^RThGbW\c/dMGIhNOF/RTN+dMNVhB RiRTW abGIf8G^c#RTKY_)KKMG^c/G^krWMNVaba C ]rc/deRJNVWMNVa C h#RThuc/dMNOc5dNVh B RiRTW `RiFz kVFf8RTK8RTf4`aIk C h/GIf8`a^RKeFANOf4kK&/RTaIh c#kg`MF/kUGIKeR c/dMRSd C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIH$zkVFHRThNVWMKn|DRTKt`!krGIW=cKMG^`!kra^RJf4kKeRTaIh<c#k rG^UVRSc/deRSf8NOrWMRic/GIHGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMh K9]P]~q Y y deRTh#R f4kDKMRTaIh NOF/R8UONVaIGIK9krWMa C GIW9c/dMRgaIGIf8GIc)kVz<UVRiF C KMGIabwec#RV]wMWMG^zkVFfh/wMh/`RTWh/G^krWMhNVWMK LGIabaezNVGbaMc#k `MF/kUGIKeR$NHkVFF/RTHc5KMRTh/HFG^`Mc/GIkrW8kVzc/deR$GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhuLdeRTW c/deR$`NOF/c/G /Hia^RTh B RirGIW8c#kNOVVF/RirNOc#RwWMKeRiF(c/dMR$GIW,SweRTWMHRkVz c/deR$NO``aIG^RTK4|RTaIKYn<JWeR)kVzc/deR$`MFGIf8NOF C VkrNVabhukVzc/dMGIhuc/deRTh/Gbh5Gbh(c#kRTh#c/N B abGIh/d'N hGIfwaINOc/G^krW8c#RTHAdMWMGIDweR N B a^R$c#kRgHiG^RTW=c/a C NVWMKtNVHiHiweFANOc#RTa C dMNVWKMa^RkVzRTWMh#RTf B a^RThkVzc#RTWMh)c#kgc/dekrwMhNVWMKMhkVz`?NOF/c/GIHia^RThiYk Wnc/deRTh#R h/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWhi]Mc/deR d C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIHJGIW=c#RiF /NVHc/G^krWMh$NOF/RS`F/kUGIKeRTK BDC c/deRzkVFHRY/ Hkrwe`?aIGIWe8f4Ric/dMkDK 7F~v Z=:AY~vZ dMNVh B RiRTWwh#RTKQ`MF/RiUG^krwMha Cc#kQh#c/wMK C NOVVF/RirNOc/G^krW GbWNtwMWMGIz kVFf NO`M`abG^RTKn|MRTabK oz Y y deR4f8NOrWeRic/GIHGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWh$NOFRKMRic#RiF /f8GIWMRTK8wMh/GIWMSNf4Ric/dekK8KeRiUVRTaIkV`RTK deRiF/R)c/dMNOcuHkrf B GIWeRThuN |WMGIc#RY/ KMG^`!kra^R f4kKeRTaMNVWMKgc/deRF/RThwMa^c/GIWef wMa^c/G^`!kra^RThz F/krf c/deRR eNVHc c L5k B kDK C HiNVabHiwMaINOc/G^krWY y dMGIh$f4Ric/dekK+Gbh$KMRTh/HFG B RTKNVWK9UVRiFG^|MRTK+GIWv<dMNO`c#RiFRDY W v<dMNO`Mc#RiFt9e]LuR U NVaIGbKMNOc#Rgc/deRtHkrf4`aIRic#R h/GIf wMaINOc/GIkrW\NVWMK R D`aIkVF/Rgc/deR RRTHc/hkVzh/dekVFc / FNVWeVR h#kraIGIK HkrWc/NVHc B NOF/FG^RiFh BDC HkrWMh/GIKMRiFGIWeSc/dMR$K C WMNVf8GbHih(kVz N `NVGIFukVz`?NOF/c/GIHia^RTh5h/w B 2#RTHcc#kNFNO`GIKa C F/kVc/NOc/GbWe|MRTabKY5 RtNVaIh#kHkrWMh/GIKeRiF f4kVF/R8VRTWMRiFNVaIa C c/deR'K C WNVf8GIHih kVzh/wh#`!RTWMh/G^krWMhkVz(`?NOFNVf8NOrWeRic/GIH B RTNVKMhJh/w B 2 RTHcJc#kQh/deRTNOFSMklLhJNVWMK9F/kVc/NOc/GIWM'|RTaIKMh)LdeRiF/R c/deR4d C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIHzkVFHRThHiNVWnKMRiz kVFf NVWMKQFwe`c/weF/RJc/deRSHdNVGIWMhiY

<JWMR'kVz)c/deRQKeRiUGIHRThHkrWMh#c#FwMHc#RTK z F/krf h/wM`RiF`NOFNVf8NOrWeRic/GbH B RTNVKMhGIh c/deRQNOF/c/G^|?HiGINVaufgGIHF/k/h#LGbf8f4RiFc/dNOcHkrWh/GIh#c/h kVzN9HdNVGIW kVz B RTNVKMhabGIWVRTK c#kVVRic/deRiF4c#k9z F/krf NVW NOF/c/G^|?HiGINVa1SNOVRTabaIwMfNVWMK NOc#c/NVHdMRTK c#k NdDwMf8NVW F/RTK B a^kDkK HRTaIa Y= W NVKKMG^c/G^krW c#k+`F/kUGIKMGIWMN`d C h/GIHiNVa5f4kKeRTaLG^c/dLdMGbHdnc#kQh#c/wK C c/deR zwMWKMNVf4RTW=c/NVa~NVh#`!RTHc/h$kVz(a^klL R C WekraIKMh)W=wMf B RiF)`F/kV`wMaIhG^krWQNVWMK+c/deRh#LGbf8f8GIWekVzf8GIHF/kDkVF/rNVWMGbh/f8hi]c/dMGIh B G^krf8Gbf4Ric/GIHgKMRiUDGIHRtGIhc/deRt|MFh#c h#c#Ri` c#kL<NOFK RTWerGIWMRiRiFGIWeHkrW=c#F/kraIaIN B aIRf8GIHF/k/ h/LGIf8f4RiFAhiY R NOF/RN B a^Rc#k `MFkUGIKeRN'h/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWnkVzc/dMGIhKMRiUDGIHR wMh/GIWM8c/deRf4Ric/dekKMhGIW=c#F/kKMwMHRTK c#kSKeRTh/HFAG B Ruc/deRGbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMh B Ric L5RiRTW4`NOFNVfgNOrWeRic/GIH<`NOF/c/GbHia^RThGIWHkrWK2/wMWMH /c/G^krW LG^c/d\NVW NVKMKMG^c/G^krWNVaf4kDKMRTaKeRiUVRTa^kV`!RTK\deRiFRgc#kHiNO`c/weF/R8c/deRgRTaINVh#c/GIH8HkrwM`aIGIWenN!kVFKeRTK B=Cc/deR3SMR G B a^RHdMRTf8GIHiNVaabGIWh B Ric L5RiRTWgc/deR B RTNVKMhiY y dMGIh(f4Ric/dekKgGIhKMRTh/HFG B RTK8GIW'v<dMNO`Mc#RiFezSNVh5NOF/R

Page 24: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

c/deRJF/RTh/wa^c/GIWeh#LGIfgf8GIWe h#`!RiRTKMh5kVz c/deRSKeRiUGIHR KeRic#RiFfgGIWeRTK B=C c/deR h/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWhiY y deRJkVFG^rGIWNVaIa C`MF/kV`!krh#RTK+h#LGbf8f8GIWe8h/c#FNOc#Ri C RTf8`a^k C RTK+krh/HiGbaIaINOc/GIWe'f8NOrWeRic/GIH|MRTaIKhc#k'VRTWeRiFNOc#R8N c#FNVWMh#UVRiFAh#RB RTNOc/GIWe9f4kVc/G^krW kVz)c/deR5S?NOVRTaIaIwMfQ]hGIf8GIaINOFc#k c/deRQf4kVc/G^krW kVz)N9h#`!RiFfgNOc#k ikrNY> W v dMNO`Mc#RiF8qD]L5R`MF/kV`!krh#RNVWMKKeRTf8krWMh#c#FNOc#R c/deRR!RTHc/G^UVRTWeRThh)kVzNVWNVa^c#RiFWMNOc/GIUVR h#c#FANOc#Ri C c/dMNOc)wh#RThFkVc/NOc/GIWe|MRTaIKh c#kJz NVHiGIaIG^c/NOc#R NJh#LGIfgf8GIWeNVWNVa^kVVkrwMh.c#kJc/deR deRTaIGIHiNVa;SNOVRTaIabwMf f8kVc/G^krW R dMG B G^c#RTK B=C HRiFc/NVGIWB NVHc#RiFGbNY WNVKMKG^c/G^krWnc#k'`MF/klUDGbKMGIWe8h/GbfwMabNOc/G^krWMhkVz(c/dMGIh B RTdMNUDGIkVFT]L5R`!RiF/zkVFf NVWMNVa C h/GIh B NVh#RTKkrW9N'F/RTh/GIh#c/GIUVRzkVFHR HkrWc/GbW=wekrwhJRTaINVh#c/GIHiNtf4kKeRTa~c#k'R `a^kVFRc/deR4KeRi`!RTWMKeRTWHRkVzc/deR4h#L)GIf8f8GIWMh#`!RiRTKQkrWQc/dMRSh#LGIf8f8RiF VRikrf4Ric#F C NVWMKQf8NOrWMRic/GIH |MRTaIKQGbWtc/deRa^klLz FRT=weRTWH C aIGbf8G^ciY

_$h8c/deRf8NOrWeRic/GIHnfgGIHF/k/ h#LGbf8f4RiF8f8N C h/RiF/UVRNVhgN\`d C h/GIHiNVaf4kDKMRTa<z kVFgN h#LGIfgf8GIWe9f8G /HF/kDkVF/rNVWMGIhfQ] L5R8`!RiF/zkVFf NQUONOFG^Ric C kVz h/GIf wMaINOc/GIkrWMhJc#kwMWMKMRiFh#c/NVWMK deklL c Luk+NOF/c/G^|HiGINVafgGIHF/k/h#LGbf8f4RiFhLGIaIaGbWc#RiFNVHc$LG^c/dRTNVHd+kVc/deRiFY y dMRTh#RFRTh/wMa^c/h)NOF/R`F/RTh#RTW=c#RTK+GbW+v<dMNO`c#RiF gNVWMKc/deRWMNOc/weFR kVzc/dMR'd C KMF/kDK C WMNVfgGIH8NVWMK f8NOrWeRic/GbH GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWh B Ric LuRiRTW c/deRth#LGbf8f4RiFhNOF/R'KMRic#RiF /f8GIWMRTKYn_)KKMG^c/G^krWMNVaba C L5R'GbWMKMGIHiNOc#RgNOc LdMNOcFNVWeVR'kVzh#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krW KGIh#c/NVWMHRThN`!krGIW=cSF/Ri`MFRTh#RTW&/c/NOc/G^krW kVzuc/deR8h#LGbf8f4RiFhJf8N CB R4NO`M`MF/kV`FGINOc#RVY R8NVabh#kn=wNVWc/G^z C c/deR8GbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMh B Ric L5RiRTW Nh/GIWMra^Ruh#L)GIf8f4RiF.NVWMKN$FG^rGIKh/weF/z NVHRVY y deRuz NOF / |MRTabKR!RTHc/h.kVzc/dMR<hweF/z NVHR5NOF/R<k B c/NVGbWeRTKwMh/GIWe)c/deRGIf8NOVR h C h#c#RTf8hzkVFU NOFAG^krwMh~zwMWKMNVf4RTW=c/NVaDhGIWerwMaINOFAG^c/G^RThzkVFc/deR X c#k VRTh.RTDwMNOc/G^krWMh.NVWMKaIw B FGIHiNOc/G^krWzkVFHRTh NOF/R NVKMKeRTK'c#kF/RTh#kra^UVRJc/deRJ`NOFc/GIHia^R)f8k B GIaIG^c C WeRTNOF HkrWc/NVHciYk*G^c/d'c/dMGIhuF/Ri`MF/RTh#RTW=c/NOc/G^krW]L5RR eNVf8GIWeR c/deRHdMNVWeVRThGIWh/LGIf8f8GbWe8h#`!RiRTK9NVWMK9f4kVc/G^krWMh$NTL<N C zF/krf c/dMRhweF/z NVHRzkVF N `?aINVWMNOF /c C `!Rh#L)GIf8f4RiF$NVWMKnc/deR F/kraIabGIWe4f4kVc/G^krWkVz(Ngh/`G^FNVah/LGIf8f4RiFY y deRd C KMF/kDK C WMNVfgGIHJL5NVaba f4kKeRTaNVWMKQc/dMRSh/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWtF/RThwMa^c/h NOF/RS`F/RTh#RTW=c#RTKnGIWv<dMNO`c#RiF)DY

_$a^c/dekrwerdc/deRuf8Ric/dekDKhKeRiUVRTa^kV`!RTKNVWKSRTf4`aIk C RTK GIW c/dMGIh c/deRTh/GIh NOF/RuGIW=c#RTWMKeRTKc#k)KeRThHFG B Rc/deRK C WMNVf8GIHih5kVz`NOFNVf8NOrWMRic/GIH B RTNVKMh NVWMKt|aINVf8RTWc/hi]eGIWnv<dNO`Mc#RiF kVz~c/dGIh<c/deRTh/GIh5L5RSKeRTf4krWMh/c#FNOc#Rc/deRTh#RSf8Ric/dekDKhHiNVW B RJR Dc#RTWMKMRTKQc#kgNVKMKeFRTh/h NVWnNVKMKMGIc/G^krWMNVa!HiaINVh/h<kVz.`MF/k B a^RTf8hiY X `!RTHiG^|HiNVaIa C ]=L5RNVKMNO`Mc c#k5~v Zc/deR[h/DwMG^Ff8RiF f8kDKeRTa!zkVFN8h#L)GIf8f8GIWMf8GIHFk=kVF/rNVWGIh/f%KeRiUVRTa^kV`!RTK BDC h/dMG ONTL<N-$[)'*c z Y y dMRh=wMGbf4RiF f4kDKMRTaGIh NO`M`MF/kV`FGINOc#Rz kVFSHiGbaIGINOc#RTK f8GIHFk=kVF/rNVWGIh/f8h$kVFNVhSNVW GIWMG^c/GINVaf4kKeRTazkVFSNOVRTaIabwMfR/ `MF/kV`!RTaIaIRTK h#L)GIf8f4RiFh<klUVRiF)c/Gbf4RThh/HiNVaIRTha^krWe8Hkrf8`NOF/RTKnc#kgc/deRSFNO`GbK_SNO/RTaIaIwf krh/HiGIabaINOc/G^krWMh 7 xipVp4kVFf4kVF/R8:AYf RSKeRTf8krWMh#c#FNOc#RJc/dMNOc<c/deR ~v Z/ h/DwMGIf4RiF<zkVFfwaINOc/G^krWF/Ri`MFkDKMwHRTh B kVc/d'c/deR h/DwMG^Ff8RiFuc#FN82#RTHc#kVFG^RTh z NVWMKth/wMh#`!RTWMh/GIkrWgh#RTa^zM/ KMG wMh/GIkrWgHkDRgHiG^RTW=c/h zzNVWMKQNVaIaIkLh5zkVFNOca^RTNVh#cNVWtkVFKeRiF^/ kVz / f8NOrWG^c/wMKeR GIWMHFRTNVh#R GIW'c/deR W=wMf B RiF<kVzh/DwMG^FAf4RiFhuc/dMNOcHiNVWB RSHkrWMh/GIKMRiF/RTKQGIWQN8h/GbfwMabNOc/G^krWY

Page 25: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

$!S28!)

s.NOFNVf8NOrWeRic/GbH B RTNVKh$hwMh#`!RTWMKeRTKGIWN'UGIh/HkrwMh3SwMGbKR `!RiFG^RTWMHR d C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIHz kVFHRThT] @),/ ]

GIW=c#RiF/`NOF/c/GbHia^R f8NOrWeRic/GIHJzkVFHRV] ]?h/dekVF/c / FNVWMVRTKnGIW=c#RiF/`NOF/c/GIHiaIRJhweF/z NVHR z kVFHRTh )04 NVWKtFNVW&/Kekrf j5F/klLWMGINVW'zkVFHRTh ) Y y deRJK C WMNVf8GIHih5kVz~c/deRTh#RJFG^rGIK'h#`dMRiFGIHiNVa?`NOF/c/GIHia^RTh5kVzf8NVh/h NVWMKFNVKMGbwMh 'NOFRSrG^UVRTW BDC )RiLc#krW hRT=wNOc/G^krWQkVzf4kVc/G^krWQL)deRiF/R

0)0/ < < )@4 < ) 7 oDYIx:

zkVF B RTNVK Y><JW c/deRta^Riz cdMNVWMK h/GIKMR kVzt7 oDYIx:A] GIhc/deR B RTNVK hc#FANVWMh/aINOc/G^krWNVa(UVRTa^kHiG^c C Y y deRc/GIf4RQh/HiNVaIRtNVhh#kDHiGbNOc#RTK LG^c/d `NOF/c/GIHiaIR'FRTaINNOc/GIkrW GbhrGIUVRTW B=C &7 q ,: LdeRiFR GIh c/deRUGIh/Hkrh/G^c C kVzc/deR4h/wMF/F/krwMWMKGIWeRSwMGIKY)m$h/GIWe'F/Ri`MF/RTh/RTWc/NOc/G^UVRUONVaIweRTh)kVz(c/deR FNVKMGbwMh xB ]!c/deRUGIh/Hkrh/G^c C kVzc/deRSwGIK x A NVWKf8NVh/h z xip E! ]c/deRF/RTabNNOc/G^krWc/GIf4RhHiNVa^RzkVFc/deR$`NOFNVf8NOrWMRic/GIH`?NOF/c/GIHia^RThuGIhuNO``MF/k eGIf8NOc#RTa C" o #Qxip %$ rY X GbWMHRc/dMGbhc/GIf4RJh/HiNVa^R$GIh5fwMHAdh/dekVFc#RiF5c/dNVWtc/dMNOc NVh/h#kHiGINOc#RTKtLG^c/d c/deRJ`NOF/c/GIHiaIR)f4kVc/G^krW '& x r]eL5RJf8N C WeRira^RTHc<c/deRJR!RTHc/hkVz.`NOF/c/GIHiaIRJGbWeRiF/c/GIN Vo~NVWKnNOcRTNVHdGIWMh#c/NVW=cGIWtc/GIf8RSc/deR zkVFHRThkrWQRTNVHAd B RTNVK LGbaIa B NVaINVWMHR

< )04 < 0)0/ < ) 7 oDY[o:

9

Page 26: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

z

X GIWHRc/deRJd C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIHz kVFHRTh5LGbaIaKeRi`!RTWMKgkrW'c/deR)UVRTaIkDHiG^c C kVzc/dMR)`NOFc/GIHia^RTh5NVWMKgc/dMRTG^F5HkrWM|M/weFNOc/GIkrW]7 oDY[o:<RTh#c/N B abGIh/deRTh<N4f4k B GbaIG^c C `MF/k B a^RTf c/dMNOcf wMh#c B R h#kra^UVRTKQc#k8KMRic#RiFf8GIWeRJc/deR `?NOF/c/GIHia^Rf4kVc/G^krWY

W c/deRzkraIa^klLGIWe h#RTHc/G^krWMhT]LuR KeRThHFG B Rc/deR+R eNVHcnHiNVaIHiwMaINOc/G^krW kVzc/dMRTh#RzkrweFtzkVFHRThQNVWMKGIW=c#F/kKMwMHR'c/deRQf4kDKMRTaIh LuRQRTf4`?a^k C c#k `MF/kUGIKeRtNVW NVHiHiweFNOc#RKeRTh/HFG^`c/G^krW kVz)c/deRQ`d C hGIHihwh/GIWeHkrf4`wMc/NOc/G^krWMNVaIa C RgHiG^RTW=cNVa^VkVFGIc/dMf8hiY

%242 ) y deR SwMGIK9LGbaIa.R DRiFcc/deR z kVFHR

0)0/ krW B RTNVK HRTW=c#RiF/RTK NOc f4kUGIWeLG^c/d UVRTaIkDHiG^c C NVWMK4FkVc/NOc/GIWeL)G^c/d8NVWerwMabNOFUVRTa^kHiG^c C Y y dMGIh.zkVFHR)HiNVW B R)KeRic#RiFf8GIWMRTK B=C h#kra^UGIWe c/dMR)NUDGIRiF /X c#k VRThRT=wMNOc/GIkrWMh zkVF)N4GIWMHkrf8`MF/RTh/h/G B a^RSwMGIK D]z

@ <67\@ : @ < A @ 7 oDY :

@ p 7 oDY9;:

h/w B 2 RTHc c#k8c/dMRWek/ h/aIGI` B krwMWKMNOF C HkrWKMG^c/G^krWtkrWnhweF/z NVHRTh kVz.c/deR B RTNVKMh

@ < >7 :5NOc > 7 oDY z:

<JWMHR)c/deRSMklL |RTaIK @9dMNVh B RiRTWgz krwWMK]rc/deR)z kVFAHRkrW B RTNVK HiNVW B Rz krwMWK4z Fkrf c/deR3SwMGIK4h#c#FRTh/h

@),/

N 7 oDY[q:

N < "! @ <67 @ :$#&%(' ) 7 oDY :

LdeRiFR SGIhuc/deRJwMWMG^c(UVRTHc#kVFWekVFf8NVa?c#kc/dMR$h/wMF/zNVHR$kVzc/deRJh#`dMRiF/RVY X GIf8GIabNOFa C ]Vc/deRJd C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIHc#kVFDweRSkrWQc/dMR `NOF/c/GIHia^RSGbh

* 0)0/ + 7 : N 7 oDY[:

Page 27: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

q

JG^UVRTWtN HdMNOFANVHc#RiFGIh#c/GIHSwGIK8UVRTa^kHiG^c C ]L5R$f8N C WekrW0/ KMGIf4RTWMhG^krWMNVaIG iR c/dMR)RTDwMNOc/G^krWMh5kVz f8kVc/G^krWzkVFc/deR SwGIK'`dMNVh#R

@ <67\@ : @ < A @ 7 oDY :

@ p 7 oDYIxip.:

y deRnDwMNVW=c/G^c C GIh4c/deRo-Ylr`'*+KTX#% WV- NVWMK DwMNVW=c/G^|MRTh4c/dMRGIf4`!kVF/c/NVWMHRQkVzJc/deR SwMGIKGIWeRiFc/GIN'F/RTaINOc/G^UVR4c#kQc/deR4UGIh/Hkrwh h#c#F/RTh/h#RThTY y deR R C WekraIKMh WDwMf B RiFJNVhh#kDHiGbNOc#RTK\LG^c/d+c/deR8f8kVc/G^krWkVz(`?NOFNVf8NOrWeRic/GIH `NOFc/GIHia^RGIhc C `?GIHiNVaIa C krW+c/deRkVFKMRiF$kVz R xip E xip ? Y y dMGbhNVaIa^klLhJwMh$c#kF/RTKMwHR c/deR$NTUG^RiF / X c#k VRTh)RT=wNOc/G^krWMh c#k8c/dMRSaIGIWeRTNOF X c#k VRTh)RTDwMNOc/G^krWMh

< A @ p 7 oDYIxVx:

@ p 7 oDYIxTo:

Ldekrh/R`MF/kV`!RiF/c/GIRThNOF/RKeRTh/HFG B RTKc/dekVF/krwerda C GIW qze]zOp Y y deR X c#k VRTh$RT=wMNOc/GIkrWMh C G^RTabKN'aIGIWeRTNOFF/RTaINOc/GIkrWMh/dMG^` B Ric LuRiRTWc/dMRud C KeFkDK C WMNVf8GbHz kVFAHR5NVWMK c/deR5`NOF/c/GbHia^R(UVRTa^kHiG^c C Y MkVF.N$h/GIWMra^Ruh#`?deRiFGIHiNVa`NOF/c/GbHia^R c/dMGIh<F/RTabNOc/G^krWMh/dMGI`tGbh

q (! 7 oDYIx:

LdeRiFR$c/dMRSHk=RgHiGIRTWcq !tGIh DWeklLWQNVh c/deR X c#k VRThKeFNO8aINLSY X GIWHR)c/deRSabGIWeRTNOF<F/RTaINOc/G^krWh/dMG^`tGIhN F/RTh/wMaIc(kVzc/deR$VkUVRiFAWMGIWeRTDwMNOc/G^krWMhi]G^c5R Dc#RTWKMh5c#k `?NOF/c/GIHia^RThukVz NOF B GIc#FNOF C h/dMNO`!R$NVWMKtNO`M`aIG^RThuGIWf4kVF/RVRTWeRiFNVah/GIc/wMNOc/G^krWMh<LdMRiF/R c/deRiF/RGbh NVWQRTWMh#RTf B a^R kVz :c#FNVWMh/aINOc/GbWe4NVWMKQF/kVc/NOc/GIWM8`NOF/c/GIHiaIRTh

0)0/ @),/

7 oDYIxY9;:

LG^c/d 0)0/ B RTGIWMc/deR +xJUVRTHc#kVF$HkrWc/NVGbWMGIWe4NVaIac/deR GIWezkVFf8NOc/GIkrW FRirNOFKMGIWec/deR d C KMF/kDK C /

WMNVf8GbH z kVFAHRTh(krW'NVaIaMc/dMR B RTNVKMhiY X GIf8GbaINOFa C ] 0)0/ ] NVWMK NOF/R txUVRTHc#kVFh<dekrabKMGIWeSNVaIac/deR

UGIh/HkrwMh$c#kVFDweRV]UVRTa^kHiG^c C NVWMK NVWerwMabNOF$UVRTaIkDHiG^c C GIWMz kVFfgNOc/G^krWzkVF NVaIac/deR`NOF/c/GIHiaIRTh)FRTh#`!RTHc/G^UVRTa C Yy deR5VFNVWMKFRTh/GIh#c/NVWMHR<f8NOc#FG ] ]rGIh.WekL N q Jq f8NOc#FG c/dMNOcKeRi`!RTWMKMh~krWc/deR HkrWe|MrwMFNOc/G^krWkVz.c/deR B RTNVKMhNVWMKQHkrwM`a^RTh c/deRf4kVc/G^krWQkVzkrWeRS`NOFc/GIHia^RJLG^c/dQc/dNOckVzNVWMkVc/deRiFTY

_$h$c/deR d C KeF/kK C WNVf8GIH zkVFHRTh$krW+c/deR`?NOFNVf8NOrWeRic/GIH B RTNVKMh B NVaINVWMHR c/deR c/deF/RiR kVc/deRiFJz kVFAHRThkrWQc/deR`NOF/c/GIHia^RThT]

< < )@4 < ) *p 7 oDYIxz:

Page 28: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

LdeRiFR ] )@4 NVWMK ) NOF/R +xJUVRTHc#kVFdekraIKMGbWec/deRSfgNOrWeRic/GIH$z kVFAHRThi]Mh/weF/z NVHRJz kVFAHRThNVWMK juFkLWMGbNVW8zkVFHRThzkVF5NVabaec/deR`?NOF/c/GIHia^RThFRTh#`!RTHc/G^UVRTa C Y y deRf8kVc/G^krW8kVzc/deR B RTNVKMhNOc5RTNVHd c/GIf4RGIWMh/c/NVWcGIh<c/dMRTWnrG^UVRTW BDC

7 < )@4 < ) : 7 oDYIxTq:

LdeRiFR GIh<c/deR VFNVWKnf4k B GIabG^c C fgNOc#FG !Y)Ric#RiFAf8GIWMGIWM c/dMRSf4kVc/G^krWQkVz.f8NVW C `NOFANVf8NO/WeRic/GIH B RTNVKMhJFRT=wMGIF/RTh$c/dMNOc krWeR4|MFh/cJHkrf8`wec#R8c/deR4R c#RiFWMNVa.zkVFHRTh krW\c/deR4`NOF/c/GIHiaIRVY<JWHR4c/dMGIhdMNVh B RiRTW Hkrf4`?a^Ric#RTK]c/deR'F/RTh/GIh/c/NVWMHR f8NOc#FAG WeRiRTKMh c#k B R z kVFAfwMabNOc#RTK NVWMK c/deRtaIGIWeRTNOF h C h#c#RTfh#kra^UVRTKnc#k8k B c/NVGIW Y "!#$% &'(*),+$.-//01-/ 2# 3%4<JWMHRc/deR9WekrW&/ d C KeFkDK C WMNVf8GbHtz kVFHRTh'krW c/deR+`NOF/c/GIHia^RTh NOF/R9KeRic#RiFf8GIWMRTK]<c/deR`?NOF/c/GIHia^RHkrWM|M/weFNOc/GIkrW KeRi`!RTWMKeRTW=c8F/RTh/Gbh#c/NVWMHRf8NOc#FAG WeRiRTKh8c#k B RKMRic#RiFf8GIWeRTK c#k Hkrf4`wMc#Rnc/deR`?NOF/c/GIHia^RUVRTa^kHiG^c/G^RTh)NVWMKNVWMrwMaINOFUVRTa^kHiG^c/G^RThTY y dMGIhGbWUVkra^UVRTh$h#kra^UGIWe4c/dMR X c#k VRTh$RTDwMNOc/G^krWMh$h/w B 2#RTHcc#k'c/deRWek/ h/abG^` B krwMWKMNOF C HkrWMKMGIc/G^krWMh$krW+RTNVHd\`?NOF/c/GIHia^RVY ekVFNQh C h/c#RTf kVzuf8NVW C `NOFc/GIHia^RThi]!`!RiF/zkVFf8GIWec/dMGIh.c/NVh KMGIF/RTHc/a C GbhWMkVcc#FNVHc/N B a^RVYf Rc/dMRiF/Riz kVFR RTf4`a^k C NJc#RTHAdMWMGIDweRHiNVaIa^RTKc/dMR5Y` !V-16 !V`#8gr'vZ 87% -$[Hj`+y7F~vZ : xV]x c#kgh/kra^UVRSc/deRSf4k B GIaIG^c C `MF/k B a^RTfQY

~vZ GIhN9c Luk h/c#Ri` f4Ric/dekK LdeRiF/Rtc/deRt|MFh/ch/c#Ri` `MF/kUGIKeRTh c/deRQFRi`MF/RTh#RTW=c/NOc/G^krW kVz$`NOF/c/G /Hia^R'`dMNVh#R'c#k9c/deR_SwMGIK `dMNVh#RVY y dGIhGIhNVHAdMG^RiUVRTK c/deF/krwMrd N+a^klL kVFAKeRiF|WMG^c#R z kVFHRQf wMa^c/G^`!kra^RR `NVWMh/G^krWtc#FAwMWMHiNOc#RTKNOcc/deRSKMG^`!kra^R$c#RiFf

A @ 9: 3 - 7 : <;9:

3< >= 7 : 7 oDYIx:

@ p 7 oDYIxT:

LdeRiFR

7B: 7 o A8? @ : ?BAA R %)DC A ADE CGF H 7 oDYIx:

= 7B: 7 o A8? I : ?BAA R %) CJA ADE C"F K 7 oDY[oOp.:

y deR `NOFNVf4Ric#RiFAh .? @ NVWK .? I NOF/Rth#Ric B=C fgNOc/HdMGIWMc/deRtHkrWMKMG^c/GIkrWMhSzkVF`NOF/c/GIHia^R'f4kVc/G^krW GIWX c#k VRTh SMklL NVWKNOF/R5F/RTaINOc#RTK c#k$c/deR B RTNVKFNVKMGbwMh NVh .? @ L 'NVWMK 8? @ &7 q%L P: A,?VY 3 - )@4 < < ) GIhc/deR c#kVc/NVa.R c#RiFWMNVa~z kVFHRkrW B RTNVK Y zc/dMRiF/R GbhNVW+R Dc#RiFAWMNVa

Page 29: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

c#kVFDweRkrW c/deR`NOF/c/GIHiaIRThi] c/deRNVW=c/GIh C f8f4Ric#FAGIHn`NOFcgkVz c/deRc#RTWMh#kVF < GIhi]GbW GIWMKMR WekVc/NOc/GIkrW] + A 9 + 3 - ? Y y deRSh C f8f8Ric#FGIHJ`NOF/c kVzc/dMGIhc#RTWMh#kVFGIh HAdekrh#RTWh#k

xo ! @ < 7 @ :% = 7 : ? 7 oDY[ox:

y dMR8h#RTHkrWMK h/c#Ri` RTW=c/NVGIaIhSKeRic#RiFAf8GIWMGIWM c/deRgUVRTa^kDHiGIc C NVWMK\NVWerwaINOFSUVRTa^kHiG^c C kVz B RTNVK zF/krfc/deRSFRTh/wMa^c/GIWMtSMklL|MRTaIKtc/dMF/krwerd

@k7B: 7 : ? 7 oDY[oVo:

xo 7B: = 7 : ? 7 oDY[o:

LdeRiFR1Gbh<c/deRSUVkVF/c/GIHiGIc C kVz~c/dMR SwMGIKY~vZ dMNVh B RiRTW9wMh#RTK9h/wMHiHRThh#zwaIa C GIW+N'U NOFGIRic C kVz5W=wf4RiFGIHiNVa.h#c/wMKG^RThFANVWerGIWe'z Fkrf wWMKeRiF /

h#c/NVWMKGIWe`aINOc#RTa^Ric NOVVF/RirNOc/GIkrWGIWQHiNO`?GIaIaINOFGIRTh xipVp c#k4kV`Mc/GIf8G TGbWec/dMR `RiFz kVFfgNVWMHR kVzHkraba^krGIKMNVaf8GIHFk/ `wMf4`h Op Y ~vZ`MFRTh#RiF/UVRTh NtHkrWMh/GIh/c#RTWc B NVaINVWHR B Ric L5RiRTW c/deR UGIh/HkrwMhJKMGIhh/G^`NOc/G^krWGIWc/deRSkL NVWK c/deRnFANOc#RkVzJLukVF B=C c/deRn`?NOF/c/GIHia^RQ`dNVh#RNVWMK c/dMRR c#RiFWMNVazkVFHRThiY c8zwMF/c/deRiFHiNO`Mc/weFRThuc/dMR$HkVF/FRTh#`!krWMKMGIWeKeRiVRTWeRiFNOc#R f wMa^c/G^`!kra^RHkrW=c#FG B wec/G^krWMh(c#k c/dMR3SMklLNVWMK GbWMHiaIwMKeRTh(c/deRMNRTW HkVF/F/RTHc/GIkrWMh z kVF`NOF/c/GbHia^R'f8kVc/G^krW GIW N9h#`?NOc/GINVaIa C UONOF C GIWe SMkL%|MRTaIK qz Y>)RTNOF8HkrW=c/NVHcSMklL z RTNOc/wMF/RTh4WekVc4F/RTh#kraIUVRTK B=C ~v Z HiNVW B RQGIWMHiaIwMKMRTK wMhGIWe9N aIw B FGbHiNOc/G^krW zkVFHRnHiNVaIHiwaINOc/G^krW oV Y _$KMKMGIc/G^krWMNVaIa C ] ~v Z HiNVW B R RTf4`?a^k C RTK c#k\KeRTh/HFAG B R8`NOF/c/GIHiaIR'f4kVc/GIkrW NOc4|?WMG^c#R R C WMkraIKMhWDwMf B RiFh Voe]?oK9 we`Qc#k 2 oOp]MkVF$f4kKMG^|MRTK'c#kgHkrWMhGIKeRiF RTaIaIGI`h#krGIKMNVa?`NOF/c/GbHia^RTh Y

-)./ ) *deRTWhw B 2#RTHc)c#ktNtwMWMG^zkVFf NO`M`?aIG^RTKn|RTaIK]RTNVHAd B RTNVKLGbaIaNVHiDwMG^F/R N f8NOrWMRic/G TNOc/G^krW+c/dMNOcJLGIaIaGIW c/weFW VRTWeRiFNOc#RnNVW NVKKMG^c/G^krWMNVa(|MRTaIKY y dMR'f wec/wMNVa<GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhc/dMRTW rGIUVR'c/dMRtGbWc#RiF/`?NOF/c/GIHia^Rf8NOrWeRic/GbHzkVFHRThiY )RiF/RV]LuRHkrWMHRiFWkrweFh/RTa^UVRThL)G^c/dnc/deR f8NOrWeRic/GIH GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMh B Ric L5RiRTW+`NOFNK/f8NOrWeRic/GbH`NOFc/GIHia^RThc/dNOc)dMNUVR N'a^kL1f8NOrWeRic/GbHh/wMhHRi`Mc/G B GIabG^c C NVWMKR edMG B G^cf8GIWMGbf8NVad C h#c#RiF/RThGIhiY Rnz weF/c/deRiF8abGIf8G^c krweFgKMGbh/HiwMh/h/GIkrW c#k HiNVh#RTh8LdMRiF/Rtc/deRf8NOrWeRic/GTNOc/G^krW kVz N9`NOF/c/GIHiaIRQF/RTh#`!krWMKMhaIGIWMRTNOFa C c#k4c/deRNO`M`aIG^RTK |MRTaIK] C LdMRiF/R GIh<c/deR `NOF/c/GbHia^R f8NOrWeRic/G TNOc/G^krW]% GIh<c/dMR `NOF /c/GIHia^Rf8NOrWeRic/GbHh/wh/HRi`Mc/G B GbaIG^c C NVWMK GIh)c/deRa^kDHiNVaf8NOrWeRic/GbH|RTaIKY3MkVFSf8NVW C kVz`NOFNVf8NOrWMRic/GIH`NOF/c/GbHia^RThi]c/dMRf8NOrWeRic/GIH$h/wMhHRi`Mc/G B GIabG^c C xOY y deR)aIGIWeRTNOFFRTh#`!krWMh#RNVh/hwMf4`Mc/G^krWgh/w gHRTh(z kVF5c/deRf8NOrWMGIc/wMKeRThJkVz<NO`M`aIG^RTK+|MRTabKD xip ; c/dMNOcNOFR4RTf4`a^k C RTK\GIW f8GIHFkSwMGIKMGbHNO`M`abGIHiNOc/G^krWMh

Page 30: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

f4RTW=c/G^krWeRTK8GbW v<dMNO`Mc#RiF)xO]zkVFuaIN B / krW0/ NK/ HdMG^`'KeRiUGIHRTh zkVF5h#c#FwMHc/wMF/RTK8f8NOc#RiFGbNVaIh zVo ]DNVWMK8klUVRiFN8HRiF/c/NVGbWQFNVWeVRSzkVFh#c/NVWKMNOFKnZ SwGIKMh qV Y

v5krWh/GIKeRiF h/`deRiF/RThukVzFNVKMGIwh"4NVWMK8`!RiFf8RTN B GIaIG^c C 7 x< f:a^kHiNOc#RTK 1x ]NVWMKh/w B 2#RTHc c#k N wMWMG^zkVFf f8NOrWeRic/GbH |MRTaIK Y X GbWMHR c/deRS?wMGIKt`dMNVh/RSGIhNVh/hwMf4RTKQc#k'dMNTUVR iRiF/kh/wMhHRi`Mc/G B GIabG^c C ]Vc/deR)`!RiFf4RTN B GIabG^c C kVzhSwMGIK4Gbhc/dMNOc5kVzz FRiR)h#`NVHRV]( Y1MweF/c/dMRiFT]=G^z!c/deRiFR)NOF/R$WekzF/RiRHiweF/FRTWc/hGbWtc/deRh C h#c#RTfQ]ZNDL5RTaIa hRT=wNOc/G^krWMh z NOFR

p 7 oDY[oK9;:

7 oDY[oz:

LG^c/d8c/deR)f8NOrWMRic/GIHS?w KMRTWMh/G^c C GIW8c/deRSwGIK8NVWMK GbW4RTNVHdth#`dMRiF/RVYE(DwMNOc/G^krW7 oDY[oz:JNVaIaIkLh)c/deR4GIW=c#F/kDKwMHc/G^krWnkVzuc/deRh/HiNVaINOF `!kVc#RTWc/GbNVaIh)hwMHd+c/dMNOc / - GIWc/deR SwMGIK`dMNVh/R NVWMK + GIWh/GIKeRh/`deRiF/R zkVF %x Y eF/krf c/deRF/RTaINOc/GIkrWMh/dMG^`?h B Ric L5RiRTW

NVWMK NVWMK47 oDY[oK9;:A]LuRNOFFG^UVRSNOc~NO`aINVHR hRTDwMNOc/G^krWnz kVFc/dMR SwMGIKtNVWMKn`NOF/c/GIHia^RJ`dNVh#RThi]

A / - p 7 oDY[oVq: A + p 7 oDY[o:

ekVF(NHk=kVFKGIWMNOc#R h C h#c#RTf Ldekrh/R kVFG^rGIWGIha^kHiNOc#RTK8NOc ]LuRKeRi|?WeR LG^c/d NVWMK Y(_<cc/deRh/weFzNVHR kVz.RTNVHdh#`deRiFRV]ec/deRHkrWMKMGIc/G^krWMh

p 7 oDY[oV:

p 7 oDY[o:

F/RTDwMG^F/RJc/deR`kVc#RTW=c/GINVah/NOc/Gbh#z C

+ / - 7 oDY Op.:

+ / - 7 oDY x:

NOc 'z kVF 1x Y(_)KKMG^c/G^krWMNVaba C ]DNVh

/ - 7 oDY Vo:

Page 31: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

xip

_)z c#RiFh/kra^UDGbWez kVF c/deR `!kVc#RTW=c/GINVaNVWMKQHkrf8`wec/GIWec/deR |RTaIK]c/deRZNDL5RTaIah#c#F/RThh c#RTWMh#kVFT]erGIUVRTWnGIWGIWMKMR 'WekVc/NOc/G^krW B=C

+ + o + 7 oDY :

GIh<zkVFf4RTKQzF/krf c/dMRSR Dc#RiFAG^kVF|MRTaIKQNVWKQc/deR F/RTh/wa^c/NVWc zkVFHRSkrW B RTNVK \GIhKeRic#RiFfgGIWeRTKtzF/krf

) ) 7 oDY K9;:

y dMR(VRTWeRiFNVa=h#kraIwec/GIkrWSc#k7 oDY[oVq: HiNVW]OGbWS`MFGbWMHiG^`a^RV] B RLFG^c#c#RTWKMkLW NVh~N)h/wMf6kVzec/deR(`!kVc#RTW=c/GINVaKMweRJc#k4c/deRJR c#RiFWMNVafgNOrWeRic/GIHJ|MRTaIKtNVWMK'c/deRShwMf kVz :h#`deRiFGbHiNVadNOFf4krWMGIH)R `NVWMh/G^krWhi]=L)deRiF/Rc/deR R D`NVWh/G^krW\zkVF c/deR Q`NOF/c/GIHia^R dMNVhc/dMRgkVFG^rGbW a^kHiNOc#RTK NOc Y y dMR Hkrf4`abGIHiNOc/G^krWMhSNOFAGIh#Rc/deF/krwMrdNO`M`abGIHiNOc/G^krWQkVzc/deR B krwMWMKMNOF C HkrWMKMGIc/G^krWMh7 oDY Op.:)NVWMK"7 oDY x:LdeRTWnkrWMRf wMh#cc#FwWMHiNOc#Rc/deR4R `NVWMh/GIkrWMhJF/Ric/NVGIWMGbWe fwa^c/G^`!kra^RTh$NVWMK F/RTaINOc#R4c/dMR8KMG !RiF/RTWc HkDkVFKMGIWNOc#R8h C h/c#RTf8h c#knRTNVHAdkVc/deRiFTY+EUVRTW G^z<c/dMGIhGIh KekrWeR hwMHiHRTh/h#z wMaIa C ]krWeRtGIhaIRiz cLG^c/d].GIW\VRTWMRiFNVa ]NVW GIWc#FANVHc/N B a^RtaIGIWeRTNOFh C h#c#RTf kVzRTDwMNOc/G^krWMh c#k KeRic#RiFf8GIWMR c/deRSwMWWekL)WQHk=RgHiGIRTWc/h)GIWtRTNVHdR D`?NVWMh/G^krWY

Wv<dMNO`c#RiF3L5RS`MF/RTh#RTW=c c/deRKG^`!kra^R$f8kDKeRTabh<`MF/RiUG^krwMh/a C wMh#RTKnNVWMKN8WeRiL|WG^c#R KMG^`!kra^R NVWMKdMG^rdMRiFgfwa^c/G^`!kra^RtGIWMHiaIwMhG^krW f4Ric/dekK LuR+GIW=c#F/kDKwMHRQc#k KeRic#RiFfgGIWeRnc/deRGIWc#RiF`NOF/c/GIHia^RQf8NOrWMRic/GIHzkVFHRThiY_)abac/deRf4kKeRTaIh`MF/RTh#RTW=c#RTK4c/deRiFRNOF/RV]GIW4h#krf8R L5N C ]=NJF/RTKMwHc/G^krWkVz?c/dGIh.VRTWeRiFNVa`MFk B a^RTfQYE(NVHAdf4kKeRTaGIhtHiaINVhh/G^|MRTK WekVc krWa C B=C c/deR+KMRiVF/RiR9c#k L)dMGIHd c/deR+`NOF/c/GIHiaIRTh GIW=c#RiFNVHc7 KMG^`!kra^RV]DwMNVKeFNO`!kra^RV]Ric/HOY : B wecNVaIh#k B=C dekL f8NVW C `?NOF/c/GIHia^RThNOF/RQGIW=UVkra^UVRTK GIW RTNVHd GbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrW 7c L5k/B kDK C ]Dc/dMF/RiRY/ B kDK C ]Ric/HOY :AY

T 2 )J T

Wh/wh#`!RTWMh/G^krWMh HkrW=c/NVGIWMGbWe `!kra C f4RiFGbHJ`NOF/c/GIHia^RThT]rNVW9KeRiF\NVNVaIh$z kVFAHRTh$HiNVW9a^RTNVKc#kQwMW=L5NVW=c#RTKHiaIwMf8`GIWekVz~`NOFc/GIHia^RThi]kVFWekrW&/ FRiUVRiFh/G B aIR$f8NOrWMRic/GIH NOVVF/RirNOc/G^krWGIW'LdMGIHAd c/dMRTh#R z kVFAHRTh `MF/RiUVRTW=cNSFRTaINNOc/GIkrWgc#kNwMWG^z kVFAf h/wMh#`!RTWMhG^krWLdeRTW c/deR)NO``aIG^RTK4|RTaIK8GIh(F/RTf4kUVRTKY y k `MF/klUDGbKeRNh/c/N B a^RHkraIa^krGbKMNVauKGIh#`!RiFh/G^krW\LdeRiF/R c/deRTh#RtRRTHc/hgNOF/RQWekVc N+`MFRTh#RTWci]N9h/wMF/zNVHc/NVW=c4GIhc C `GIHiNVaIa C NVKMKeRTKc#k c/dMR SwMGbK `dMNVh#RVYekVFth/wMh#`!RTWMh/GIkrWMhkVzJ`kra C h#c C FRTWeRn`NOFNVfgNOrWeRic/GIHn`?NOF/c/GIHia^RTh8GbW L5NOc#RiF]c/deRh/weFzNVHc/NVW=c$h/kDKMGbwMf KekKeRTH C a h/wa^zNOc#R_7 X X :GIhwMh/RTKNVh$c/deRh#c/N B GIabG TGIWe8NOVRTW=c NOc$HkrWMHRTW=c#FNOc/G^krWhkVzSNO`M`MFk eGIf8NOc#RTa C \f Z 9.] x Y y deRhweF/z NVHc/NVWc B kVc/d B GIWKMh4c#k c/dMR+h/wMF/zNVHRkVz c/deR`NOF/c/GbHia^R f8kDKMGIz C GIWe4c/deR4h/wMF/zNVHRHdNOFNVHc#RiFGIh#c/GbHih NVWMK+F/RTf8NVGIWMh$GIW+h#kraIwec/GIkrWNVaIaIkLGIWMgzkVFJKMkrw B a^RY/aIN C RiFF/Ri`waIh/G^krW B Ric L5RiRTW\c/deRg`NOF/c/GIHia^RThTYxekVF Nn`aINVWMNOFSh/wMF/zNVHR4L)G^c/d `!kVc#RTWc/GbNVal]~c/deRg$R BDC RY/

Page 32: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

xVx

$wMH VRTa~NO`M`MF/k GIfgNOc/G^krWtc#k8c/deRskrGIhh#krW&/ j5kra^c Tf8NVWMWnRT=wMNOc/GIkrW xip]rzVrG^UVRTh

7 : R 7 oDY z:

zkVF4c/deRQ`!kVc#RTWc/GINVa zF/krf c/deRnh/weFzNVHRtLdeRTW N B GIWMNOF C x /xnRTa^RTHc#F/kra C c#RQkVz$HkrWHRTWc#FNOc/GIkrW GIh`MF/RTh/RTWciY1 W47 oDY z:A] GIh c/dMRS)R BDC RaIRTWeVc/dQrG^UVRTW BDC

9 o A A A 7 oDY Vq:

LdeRiFR GIhgj5kra^c Tf8NVWW hgHkrWMh/c/NVWci] GIh4c/deRc#RTf4`!RiFNOc/weF/RV]=9 GIh4c/deR+KMG^RTa^RTHc#FAGIHQHkrWMh#c/NVW=c kVzc/deR SwMGIK NVWMK tGIhc/deRtHdMNOF/VR'kVzNVW RTa^RTHc#F/krWY y deRg$R BDC RQa^RTWeVc/d `MF/kUGIKeRThc/deRta^RTWeVc/d h/HiNVa^RNVh/h#kHiGINOc#RTK LG^c/d c/deRKMkrw B a^RY/ aIN C RiF'GbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMhiY ekVFtc Luk h#`dMRiF/RThgkVzSHkrWh#c/NVWct`!kVc#RTW=c/GINVa Ldekrh/RhweF/z NVHRThSNOF/R8h#Ri`NOFANOc#RTK B=C c/deR8KMGIh/c/NVWMHR c/dMNOcSGIh f wMHd h/f8NVaIa^RiFJc/dMNVW9c/dMR4FNVKMGIGkVz.c/deRh#`?deRiF/RThi]MN8$RiFF2/NOrGIwMWNO`M`MF/k Gbf8NOc/G^krWQHiNVaIHiwMabNOc/G^krWQF/RiUVRTNVaIhc/deRf8NOrWG^c/wMKeR kVz.c/deRKMkrw B a^RaIN C RiFF/Ri`waIh/G^UVR$z kVFAHRGIh rG^UVRTW B=C xip

7 r: o9 A % A R x < R 7 oDY :

ekVF(NVW X X HkrWMHRTW=c#FNOc/G^krW $ GIW L<NOc#RiF37*9 C Op9 : NOc 6OpVp ]c/deR $R B=C R)a^RTWeVc/dGIh 6 z ,LdMGbHdQGIh UVRiF C h/fgNVaIa!F/RTaINOc/G^UVRc#k8c/deR FNVKMGbwMh<kVz.c/deR `NOF/c/GIHiaIRVY

y dMRGIWMHiaIwh/G^krWtkVzh/wMHAdNghdekVF/cFNVWMVRTKzkVFHRGbWnNgh/GbfwMabNOc/G^krWtLukrwaIKnF/RTDwMG^FR c/deRSF/RTh#krabwec/G^krWkVz Nc/GIf4R$h/HiNVa^R$UVRiF C h/f8NVabaHkrf4`NOFRTK c#kK C WMNVf8GIHih(kVz GIW=c#RiF/RTh#ciYf RJc/deRiF/RizkVF/R$RTf4`a^k C NVRTWMRiFGIH`NVG^FLGIh#RJHkraIaIGIhG^krW B NOF/FG^RiF kVz.c/deR zkVFf

)@4 )0354o

2 A),3,4 A 2 A)03,4 9A ; 7 oDY V:

B Ric L5RiRTW B RTNVKMh NVWMK L)deRiF/R" NVWMK Y W\c/deR8Hkrf4`wec/NOc/GIkrWMhi]c/dMGIhz kVFAHRNVaIh#k'h#RiF/UVRTh)c/deRWMkrW&/ `d C h/GbHiNVa`weF`krh/R kVz`MF/RiUVRTW=c/GIWe8`NOFc/GIHia^RSklUVRiFaINO` NVhc/dMR C Hkrf4RGIW=c#k4HkrWc/NVHcNVhNFRTh/wMa^c5kVz~f8NOrWMRic/GIHJNOc#c#FNVHc/G^krWYU W'krweFh/GbfwMabNOc/G^krWMhi](2 )03,4 o[o 'NVWMK )03,4 x pz ' / LdeRiF/R8 ' / GIh c/deRuf8NOrWG^c/wMKeRkVzec/dMRuNOc#c#FNVHc/G^UVR<zkVFHRuNOc.HkrW=c/NVHcrGIUVRTW BDC c/deRuf8NOrWMRic/GIHf4kKeRTaRTf8`a^k C RTK GIW c/deR'h/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWY W v<dMNO`Mc#RiF 9e]L5R R eNVf8GIWeR'c/deR'RRTHc/hkVz c/dMR'HkraIabGIh/G^krWB NOF/FAG^RiFukrW'c/deRJkrh/HiGbaIaINOc/G^krW K C WNVf8GIHihukVz~N B RTNVKg`NVGIF5GIW'N F/kVc/NOc/GIWe|MRTabKYs(F/RiUG^krwMh/a C ]Dc/deRJR!RTHc/hkVz.c/dMGIh c C `!RSkVzGbWc#RiF/`?NOF/c/GIHia^RJzkVFHRkrWc/deRf4RTNVWh#Ric#c/aIGIWegUVRTa^kDHiGIc C NVWMKnUVRTaIkDHiG^c C SwMHc/wMNOc/G^krWhGIW

Page 33: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

xTo

h#RTKMGbf4RTWc/GbWe4h/wMh#`!RTWMh/GIkrWMh(L5RiF/RGbWUVRTh#c/GIrNOc#RTK o Y

24$ u>@4 _$hQN F/RTh/wMa^c'kVzHkrabaIGIh/G^krWhgLGIc/d c/deR\f8kra^RTHiwMa^RTh'c/dMNOcnHkrf4`!krh#R N h/wMF/F/krwMWMKGIWe4SwGIK f8RTKMGIwMfQ]f8GIHFkrW&/ h/G iRTKQ`?NOF/c/GIHia^RTh L)GIaIa!`!RiF/zkVFf N8FANVWMKekrf L<NVa tc C `GIHiNVaIa C HiNVaIaIRTKj5F/kL)WMGINVWnf4kVc/GIkrWY y dMGIhB RTdMNTUG^kVFSa^RTNVKhJc#kQc/deR8KMG wMh/G^krWkVz(`?NOF/c/GIHia^RThJzF/krf F/RirG^krWhJkVz5dMGIrd+HkrWHRTWc#FNOc/GIkrW\c#kna^klL HkrW&/HRTW=c#FNOc/G^krWY8_<c c/deR4`?NOF/c/GIHia^R4a^RiUVRTa ]~juFkLWMGbNVW f4kVc/G^krW\HiNVW B Rc#F/RTNOc#RTK NVhSNQh#c#kHdMNVh#c/GbH`MF/kHRTh/hLdekrh/RSh#c/NOc/GIh#c/GIHihF/Ri`MF/kKMwMHR c/deRSHkVFF/RTHc)KMG !wMhG^UVR B RTdMNUDGIkVFTY

RJ|MFh/c(HkrWMh/GIKMRiFuN HkraIa^RTHc/G^krW kVz`NOF/c/GIHiaIRTh(LGIc/dgHkrWMHRTW=c#FNOc/G^krW D7 :uNVWMK h/w B 2#RTHc(c#k zkVFHR ]DLdeRiF/R GIh5c/deR$`kVc#RTW=c/GINVaRTWeRiF/ C Yn W RT=wGIaIG B FAGIwMfQ]Vc/deRJHkrWMHRTW=c#FNOc/G^krWQL)GIaIa B R$rG^UVRTWBDC N8j5kra^c TfgNVWMWnKMGIh/c#FG B wec/GIkrW

3 + 7B: / A # 7 oDY :

_$KMKMG^c/G^krWNVaIa C ]c/dMR4c#kVc/NVa Sw kVz5`NOF/c/GIHiaIRTh$NVHFkrh/h NVW C h/weF/z NVHR4GIh iRiF/knNVWMK9c/deRRSwkVz(`NOFc/GIHia^RThNVhNFRTh/wMa^c kVz.NVW C R c#RiFWMNVazkVFHRTh)GIh B NVaINVWMHRTK B=C c/deR Sw kVz.`NOF/c/GIHiaIRTh KMweR c#kgKMG !wMhG^krW 9

3 + < 3 + 7 oDY9rp.:

eF/krf 7 oDY :JNVWKc/deR F/RTaINOc/GIkrWMh/dMG^` B Ric LuRiRTW9c/dMRzkVFHRNVWMKc/dMR`!kVc#RTW=c/GINVa ]!c/deRKMG wMh/G^krWQc#RTWh#kVFGIh<zkrwMWMKtc#k B R

7 oDY9Mx:

ekVFN UVRiF C KMGIaIwMc#R$h/wh#`!RTWMh/G^krW]c/deR f4k B GIaIGIc C kVz~RTNVHdQ`NOFc/GIHia^RJGIh<NO`M`MF/k GIfgNOc#RTa C &7 q ,:LdeRiFR GIhc/deRJGIKeRTW=c/G^c C fgNOc#FG 8LdMGbHd8rGIUVRTh(c/deR X c#k VRTh / EuGIWMh#c#RTGbW K9 !F/RTaINOc/G^krWgz kVF5c/deRJKMG wMh/G^krWHkDRgHiG^RTW=cGIWtc/deRKGIaIwec#RJaIGIf8GIc

q 7 oDY9o:

R'NOF/RV]dMkL5RiUVRiFT]GIWc#RiFRTh#c#RTK GIW KeRic#RiFf8GIWGIWetc/deRgf4kVc/GIkrW\kVz GIWMKMGIUDGIKwMNVa`NOFc/GIHia^RThSNVWMK NVH /HkVFKMGbWera C L5krwMaIKaIG VR<c#kSGIW=c#F/kKMwMHR<zkVFHRThkrWc/deR `NOFc/GIHia^RTh.c/dMNOcLGbaIa ] kUVRiF(c/Gbf4RV]rrG^UVR c/deRHkVFF/RTHcKMG wMh/GIkrW8kVz c/dMR$`?NOF/c/GIHia^RThiY y dGIhuGbh5NVHAdMG^RiUVRTK BDC GIWHiaIwMKMGIWMN FNVWMKekrf zkVFHR ) GIWc#k c/deRJzkVFHRB NVaINVWHR z kVFN8rG^UVRTWn`NOFc/GIHia^R xip

< ) 7 oDY9.:

Page 34: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

x

LdeRiFR ) GIh N4FNVWKekrf JNVwMh/hGINVWQUVRTHc#kVF$c/dMNOcdMNVh iRiFkgf4RTNVWnNVWMKGIhwMWMHkVFF/RTaINOc#RTKQGIWtc/GIf8R

) 7 ^: 7 oDY99;:

) 7 ^: ) 7 *: 7 *: 7 *: 7 oDY9.z:

y deR B FNVH VRic/h GbWMKMGIHiNOc#R c/deRNTUVRiFNOVRkUVRiFJNVWnRTWh#RTf B a^RSkVz.`NOF/c/GIHiaIRThiY y deRc#RTWMh#kVF*WeRiRTKh c#kB RgHdMkrh#RTW h/wMHd c/dMNOc c/deRgklUVRiFc/GIf4RV].c/deRg`F/kV`!RiFKMG wMh/GIkrW Hk=RgHiGIRTWcGIhSFRTHkUVRiF/RTKY Rtf8N CGIf8f8RTKMGINOc#RTa C LFAG^c#R)KeklLW'c/deR h#kraIwec/GIkrWgc#k7 oDY9.:5NOc<c/GIf4R uNVWMK'GIW=c#RiVFNOc#R z weF/c/deRiF5c#kk B c/NVGIW'c/deR`!krh/G^c/G^krW

>7 ^: 7 ^: ) 7 ^: 7 oDY9q:

7 ^: -

7 : ) 7 : 7 oDY9;:

*G^c/d4c/dMGIhR `MF/RTh/hG^krWz kVF(c/deR `!krh/G^c/G^krW]Vc/dMR `krhG^c/G^krWNVwec#kHkVF/F/RTaINOc/G^krWgGIW4GIWMKeR WekVc/NOc/G^krW8Gbh.rG^UVRTWBDC

+ 7 ^: 7 : -

-

+ 7 : 7 : ) ? 7 *:5 ) ? 7 : 7 oDY9:

LdMGbHdtc/deRSc/Gbf4RSHkVF/F/RTaINOc/GIkrWQF/RTaINOc/G^krWtzkVFc/dMR z kVFHRThF/RTKMwMHRThc#k

+ 7 ^: 7 : -

-

+ 7 : 7 *: 7 *: 7 : 7 oDY9.:

RfgN C GIW=c#RiVFNOc#RSc/deRSR `MF/RThh/G^krWtkVzc/deRSFG^rd=cdMNVWMKQhGIKeRJkUVRiF c#k8k B c/NVGIW

+ 7 : 7 ^: -

+ 7 : 7 *: 7 *: 7 oDY zOp.:

LdMGbHdQwe`!krWQKMG !RiF/RTW=c/GINOc/G^krWtrG^UVRTh

+ 7 : 7 ^: + 7 ^: 7 ^: 7 ^: 7 oDY zx:

<$LGbWec#k8c/deRSz NVHcc/dMNOcc/dMRSKMG wMh/G^krWtHkDRgHiG^RTW=cGIh rG^UVRTW B=C

+ xo

+ 7 : 7 ^: 7 oDY zVo:

Page 35: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

xY9

NVWMK LuRNOF/FG^UVRSNOcc/dMRSR D`F/RTh/h/G^krWtzkVF +

+ o + 7 oDY z:

y dMRF/RTaINOc/GIUVR)GIf4`!kVF/c/NVWHRkVzj5F/kL)WMGINVW'f4kVc/G^krW krWgc/deR$f4kVc/G^krW kVz`NOFNVfgNOrWeRic/GIH)`NOF/c/GIHia^RThuGIh`MF/klUDGbKeRTK B=C

? A A

7 oDY zK9;:

LdMGbHd GIh c/deRQFNOc/G^k9kVz)c/deRnf8NOrWeRic/GIHtKMGI`kraIR GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krW RTWeRiF C c#k c/deRtc/deRiFAf8NVa<RTWeRiF/ C xiproe]oz Y*deRTW xc/deRgRRTHc/hkVz5j5F/klLWMGINVW\f8kVc/G^krW NOF/RgKekrfgGIWMNOc#RTK BDC c/deR8NO``aIG^RTK+|MRTaIKY WR `RiFAGIf4RTW=c/hi]Oc/deR U NVabweRThkVz HiNVWFANVWeVR z Fkrf x zOpVpVp xipro].xV]]9.]9o YD Wc/dGIhLukVF ]L5RuNOF/Ru`MFGIf8NOFAGIa C HkrWMHRiFAWeRTKSLGIc/dSwMWMKeRiFAh#c/NVWMKMGIWM5c/dMR(GIW=c#RiF/`aIN C$B Ric LuRiRTWc/deR(d C KMF/kDK C WMNVfgGIHNVWMKGIW=c#RiF/`NOF/c/GbHia^Ruf8NOrWMRic/GIH(zkVFHRThNVWMKzkVF.hGIf4`aIGbHiG^c C ] LuR<G^rWekVFR5Hkrf4`?a^Ric#RTa C c/deR5R!RTHc/h.kVz?j5F/kL)WMGINVWf4kVc/G^krWY W9R NVf8GbWMGIWe'c/deR B RTdMNTUG^kVF kVzuhwMh#`!RTWMh/G^krWh)h/w B 2 RTHcJc#kQF/kVc/NOc/GbWeQ|MRTaIKMhT]!GIc$L<NVhJzkrwMWMKc/dMNOc$c/deR F/RTh/wMa^c/hLuRiFR WekVc$NRTHc#RTK9zkVF$U NVaIwMRThkVz zOp K9 Y y deRiF/RizkVF/RV]RiUVRTW+c/dekrwerdLuRKekG^rWekVFRuj5F/kL)WMGINVW f4kVc/G^krW]VF/RThwMa^c/hzF/krf krweFh/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWhf8N C h#c/GIaIa B R5Hkrf4`NOF/RTK LGIc/dN$f8N82#kVFG^c CkVz.c/deR R `RiFAGIf4RTW=c/hiY

*)0 !/$

WQc/dMGIh HAdMNO`Mc#RiFT]ML5RKeRThHFG B RTK'c/deRSc/deRikVF/Ric/GbHiNVa B NVH =VF/krwWMKnNVh/h#kHiGINOc#RTKLG^c/dtc/deR zkVFHRThR `!RiFG /RTWMHRTK BDC `NOFANVf8NOrWeRic/GIH `NOF/c/GbHia^RThJGIW9h/wMh#`!RTWMh/GIkrWY W9NVKMKMGIc/G^krW]LuR`MF/RTh/RTWc#RTK f4kKeRTaIh$c/dMNOcJL5RGIW=c#F/kKMwMHRc#k `MF/klUDGbKeR)NVW RRTHc/GIUVRSh/GIf wMaINOc/G^krW4kVz RTWMh#RTf B a^RThuFNVWerGIWez Fkrf c#RTWMh5c#k c/dekrwMh/NVWKMh(kVzB RTNVKMhiY W8c/deR)z kraIaIkLGIWMHdMNO`c#RiFT]LuR)`MF/kUGIKeR)NKeRic/NVGba^RTKgNVHiHkrwMW=c<kVzc/deR)f8kDKeRTabh(KeRiUVRTa^kV`!RTK'NVWMKRTf4`aIk C RTK z kVFc/deRgf8NOrWeRic/GbH8zkVFHR HiNVaIHiwaINOc/G^krW KMRTh/HFG B RTK GIWAoDY DY y deRTh#Rgf8kDKeRTabh `MF/klUDGIKMR8c/deRB NVh/Gbh<z kVFkrwMFW=wf4RiFGIHiNVah#c/wKMG^RTh<kVzh/wMh#`!RTWMhG^krW K C WMNVfgGIHih NVWMKQc/deRNOF/c/G^|HiGINVa!f8GbHF/k/ h#LGIfgf4RiFTY

Page 36: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

$!S28!)

ekVFNtaIGbWeRTNOFa C h/wh/HRi`Mc/G B aIRf8NOc#RiFGbNVa ]NVW9R NVHcHkrf4`wec/NOc/G^krW9kVzuc/deR4f8NOrWeRic/GIH4GbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMh GIW&/UVkra^UVRThVRTWeRiFNOc/GIWec/deRgh#kraIwMc/G^krW+c#k NO`?aINVHR h RTDwMNOc/G^krW hw B 2#RTHc c#knc/deRgNO`M`F/kV`MFGINOc#R B krwMWMKNOF CHkrWMKMGIc/G^krWMh z Y y dMR z kVFHRkrWN8rG^UVRTW B RTNVKnGbh c/deRTWKMRic#RiFf8GIWeRTK B=C zkVFf wMaINOc/GIWe4c/dMRZNL5RTaIah#c#F/RThh c#RTWMh#kVFz F/krf,c/deR8F/RTh/wa^c/NVWc |RTaIK NVWMK\GIW=c#RiVFNOc/GIWMQc/deRgWekVFfgNVa`MF/kK2#RTHc/G^krW kVz5c/dMGIh c#RTWh#kVFkUVRiF c/deR B RTNVK hShweF/z NVHRVY y dMGIhJ`MFkDHRTh/hGIhJFNOc/deRiFHiwf B RiFh#krf8R8NVWMK\GIhJkrWMa C UGIN B a^RLdMRTW HkrW&/h/GIKMRiFGIWeQh C h#c#RTf8hkVz<UVRiF C z RiL`NOF/c/GIHiaIRThSGIW\h C f8f4Ric#FAGIH8HkrWe|MrwMFNOc/G^krWMh o YQ_)hNnF/RTh/wa^ci] krWMa CKMG^`!kra^R =KG^`!kra^RGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWhSNOF/RgwMhwMNVaIa C HkrWMh/GIKeRiFRTK GIW h/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWh NVWMK\GIW9c/deRikVFRic/GIHiNVa(h#c/wKMG^RThkVz Z S?wMGIKMh K9M]&]Doze]Dq Y X wMHAd8`!krGIW=c(KMG^`!kra^Rf8Ric/dekDKhF/RTDwMG^F/R c Lukh#c#Ri`hTY1GIFh#ci]c/dMRUONVaIweRThkVz.c/deRGIWKMwMHRTKQKMG^`!kra^RJf4krf4RTW=c/h)z kVFRTNVHAd`?NOF/c/GIHia^RSWeRiRTKc#k B RSKeRic#RiFf8GbWeRTKY($Ri`!RTWMKMGIWM krWc/deRWDwMf B RiF kVz.`NOF/c/GbHia^RThi]ec/dMGIh HiNVabHiwMaINOc/G^krWnHiNVWF/RTDwMG^F/R h#kra^UGIWe4N8abNOF/VRh C h#c#RTf kVzaIGIWMRTNOF RT=wMNOc/GIkrWMhiY<JWMHRc/deRKMG^`!kra^R f4krf8RTWc/h$NOF/RHkrf4`?wec#RTK]c/dMRSF/RTh/wMaIc/GIWe4GIW=c#RiF/`NOF/c/GIHiaIRSf8NOrWeRic/GIHz kVFHRTh)HiNVW B RRiUONVaIwMNOc#RTKY y dMGIhJHiNVaIHiwMabNOc/G^krW+F/RT=wG^F/RThJKeRi`a^Ric#RTK9h/wf8h$c#knNTUVkrGIK\h/RTa^z / hGIWerwMaINOF)c#RiFf8h NVWMK hHiNVa^RThGIWMdMRiF/RTWc/a C NVh F 7 A :uLdMRiF/R GIh<c/deRWDwMf B RiF kVz`NOF/c/GbHia^RThiY

_$a^c/dekrwerd KMG^`!kra^R8hGIfwaINOc/G^krWMhSGbaIaIwMh#c#FANOc#R8c/deR'VRTWeRiFNVa B RTdNTUG^kVFkVz c/dMR'NOVVF/RirNOc#RThT]uN+f4kVF/RKeRic/NVGIaIRTK+KMRTh/HFG^`Mc/GIkrWkVzuc/deR4f8NOrWeRic/GIHGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMh Gbh$WMRTHRTh/h/NOF C c#knNVHiHiweFNOc#RTa C =wMNVW=c/G^z C HdNVGIW

xz

Page 37: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

xTq

KeRizkVFf8NOc/G^krWNVWMK C G^RTaIKQh#c#F/RTWMVc/dMhGIWQf8GbHF/kSwMGIKGIH)KMRiUDGIHRThTY(j5R C krWMKnc/deR `!krGIW=c =KMG^`!kra^RTh<KeRThHFG^`0/c/G^krWf4RTW=c/G^krWeRTK4N B kUVRV] C RicNVa Y K9 dNTUVR RTf4`aIk C RTK4NJHkrf B GIWMNOc/G^krWkVz?zNVh#cf wMa^c/G^`!kra^R5f4Ric/dekKMh7FZZ=:(NVWMK B krwMWKMNOF C GbWc#RiVFNVaHkrf4`wMc/NOc/G^krWMhuc#kF/RTh#kraIUVRc/deR$f8NOrWeRic/GIH$GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhuGIW8c LukKMG /f4RTWMhG^krWMNVah C h#c#RTf8hiYfMNOF / |RTaIK8GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhHiNVW B R dMNVWKMa^RTK RgHiG^RTW=c/a C B=C .Z+Z 9. ]rLdMRiF/R c/deRKekrf8NVGbW'Gbh KMG^UGIKeRTKgGbWc#k8HRTaIabh5NVWKtc/deR RRTHc/hkVzh#krwMFHRJc#RiFf8hGIWtN4KMGbh#c/NVWc HRTaIa!NOF/R FRi`MF/RTh#RTW=c#RTKBDC Ngh/wMfgf4RTKf wMa^c/G^`!kra^RSh/RiFG^RTh B NVh#RTKkrWc/deR f4krf4RTW=c/hkVzc/dMRTh#Rh#krwMFHRc#RiFfghiY<$c/deRiF$f4kKeRTaIhdMNUVR B RiRTWQKeRiUVRTa^kV`!RTKQc#k'h/GIf wMaINOc#RJc/deRGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWh B Ric L5RiRTWKMG^RTaIRTHc#FGIHJ`NOF/c/GbHia^RTh GIWtRTa^RTHc#F/kVFAdeRY/kra^kVrGIHiNVa37 E : SwMGIKMhTYPaIGIWeVRTW B RiF/tRiciY NVa Y qVqM]B puKeRic#RiFfgGIWeRTK9c/deR8|RTaIK9F/RTh/wMaIc/GIWetz Fkrf c L5kKMG^RTaIRTHc#FGIH h#`dMRiF/RThGIW4NwMWMG^zkVFf@|MRTaIK4zF/krf L)dMGIHd8c/deR C HkrWMh#c#FwMHc#RTK NVWgGIW=c#RiF/`NOFc/GIHia^R zkVFHRz wMWMH /c/G^krWY G^c/dc/dMGIhzwWMHc/G^krWMNVa z kVFf kVzc/deR z kVFAHRV]N'f4kra^RTHiwMabNOF)K C WMNVf8GIHihc C `!RkVzh/GbfwMabNOc/G^krWnL<NVh`!RiF/zkVFf4RTKYj5krWMWMRTHiNiRNVWKj5FNVK C xY9]xz].xTq.NO`M`MF/krNVHAdeRTK+c/deR`F/k B a^RTf B=C HkrWMh/c#FwMHc/GIWe'NVWNO`M`MFk eGIf8NOc#R VFNVWMKHiNO`NVHiG^c/NVWMHR f8NOc#FG !Y y deRSf8NOc#FAG F/RTabNOc#RThc/deRf wMa^c/GI`kraIR$f4krf8RTWc/h kVz.RTNVHAd`NOF/c/GbHia^R<c#kSc/deR RTa^RTHc#FGbH `!kVc#RTWc/GINVaeNVWK8G^c/hKeRiFGIU NOc/G^UVRThRiU NVaIwNOc#RTK8NOcc/deR `NOFc/GIHia^RTh a^kHiNOc/G^krWMhT]NVWMKNVGIf8hSc#kHiNO`Mc/weFR B kVc/d c/deR'f8NVW C B kDK C ]~KMG^`!kra^R4GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWhNVWMK c/deRga^kHiNVac LukK B kK C ]dG^rdeRiFf wMa^c/G^`!kra^R<GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhiY eF/krf c/dMGIhf8NOc#FAG ]c/deR RTa^RTHc#F/krh#c/NOc/GbH RTWeRiF/ C KeRTWMhG^c C GIhKeRic#RiFf8GbWeRTK4NVWMKKMG !RiF/RTW=c/GINOc#RTKQc#k8k B c/NVGIWQc/deRSGIW=c#RiF/`NOFc/GIHia^RJz kVFAHRThiY

)RiF/RV]rL5R |MFh#cKeRiUVRTaIkV`8N WeRiL f4kKeRTaDc#kSNVHiHRTa^RiFNOc#Rc/dMR<HiNVabHiwMaINOc/G^krWkVzf8NVW C B kDK C KMG^`!kra^R5GIW&/c#RiFNVHc/G^krWhiY W c/dMGIh.f4kKeRTa ]ORTNVHAd B RTNVK h.f8NOrWeRic/G TNOc/G^krW4Gbh~FRi`MF/RTh#RTW=c#RTKNVhN)|?WMG^c#R<KMGIh#c#FG B wec/G^krW kVzHiweF/FRTWc.KeRTWMh/GIc C Y y dMGIh RTaIGIf8GbWMNOc#RTh c/dMR<WMRiRTKz kVFKeRi`aIRic#RTK hwMf8h~c#kSNTUVkrGIK4h/GbWerwMaINOFh#RTa^zM/ GIWc#RiFANVHc/G^krWc#RiFf8hTY ekVFSN hw gHiG^RTW=c/a C aINOF/VR4WDwMf B RiF$kVz`NOFc/GIHia^RTh$c/deRHkrf4`wec/NOc/G^krWNVaHkrf8`a^R eG^c C hHiNVa^RTh NVhF 7:uLdeRiFR GIh<c/deR WDwMf B RiF kVz`NOF/c/GbHia^RThiY y deRJ|WMGIc#RJWNOc/weF/RJkVz~c/dMRSKMGIh#c#FG B wec/G^krWMhuNVaIa^klLh<c/deRf4kKeRTac#k B R GIf8`a^RTf4RTW=c#RTK\LGIc/d NU NOFGIRic C kVzWDwMf4RiFGbHiNVa(NVa^VkVFGIc/dMf8hSkVF4GIW Hkrf B GIWMNOc/G^krW LG^c/dZZ h#kraIUVRiFhiY X RTHkrWMK] LuR8`F/RTh#RTW=c c/deR4R NVHc h#kraIwec/GIkrWc#kc/deR4c L5k/ B kDK C `MF/k B a^RTf NVWMK GIW=c#F/k/KMwMHR Ngc#RTHAdMWMGIDweRc#k B a^RTWMKQc/dMGbhF/RThwMa^cLGIc/dN'f8NVW C / B kDK C KMG^`!kra^RSHiNVaIHiwMabNOc/G^krWY y dGIhGIWHiaIwMh/G^krW`MF/kHRTKMweFR<Gbh.VRTWeRiFNVaMNVWMKgHiNVW B R<wh#RTK8GIWHkrWK2/wMWMHc/G^krW8LG^c/d c/deR|WG^c#R KMG^`!kra^Ruf8Ric/dekDK8`MF/RTh#RTW=c#RTKdeRiF/R kVF$NVW C kVc/deRiF$KMG^`!kra^R$kVFdMG^rdeRiF^/ kVFKeRiFf wMa^c/G^`!kra^RJf4Ric/dekKY

WQc/dMGIhHdMNO`Mc#RiF]L5Rh/wMfgf8NOFG iRSNVWMKKeRTh/HFG B R c/deR`krGbWcKMGI`kraIRJf8kDKeRTabh Hkrf8f4krWMa C wMh/RTKnGIWZ SwMGIK h/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWMhTY y dMR)GIW=c#RiF/`NOF/c/GbHia^RzkVFHRTh<rG^UVRTW BDC c/deRTh#RJKMG^`!kra^Rf8Ric/dekDKhuNOF/R Hkrf4`?NOF/RTKc#kR eNVHc<HiNVaIHiwMaINOc/G^krWhiYB R$c/deRTWgz kVFf wMaINOc#R)NVWMK8`MFRTh#RTWc(c/deR|WG^c#R =KMG^`!kra^R f4kKeRTaec/deFkrwerd4R eNVHch#kraIwMc/G^krWMh8c#k ZNL5RTaIa h RT=wMNOc/GIkrWMh NVWK RTh#c/N B aIGIh/d NVW G^c#RiFNOc/GIUVR+f4Ric/dMkDK c#k h#kraIUVRzkVF `?NOF/c/GIHia^RGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhTY y dMR'R eNVHc8c LukK B kK C HiNVabHiwMaINOc/G^krW GIh4KMRTh/HFG B RTK NVWMK z Fkrf c/dMGIh4HiNVaIHiwMabNOc/G^krW c/deRz NOF |MRTaIK f8kDKMGI|HiNOc/G^krW `MF/kHRTKMweFRnGIhR D`?aINVGIWeRTK NVWMK GIf4`aIRTf4RTWc#RTK GbW N h#RiFGIRTh4kVzJc/deF/RiR B kDK C

Page 38: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

x

`MF/k B a^RTf8hiY

+ 4>'# ' 4 y deR)h/GIf4`aIRTh#cNVWMKgf8krh#c(Hkrf8f4krWa C wMh#RTKgf8kDKeRTa?GIhc/deR)|RTKgKMG^`!kra^R f4kKeRTa YD W8c/dMGIh(f4kDKMRTa ]krWMa Cc/deR$f8NOrWeRic/G TNOc/G^krWtGIWKMwMHRTK BDC c/deR)R c#RiFWMNVa|MRTaIK GIh(HkrWMhGIKeRiF/RTKY y dDwMhi]=c/deR B NVhGIhkVzc/dMGbh(f4kKeRTaGIh4c/dMRnh#kraIwec/G^krW c#k\c/deRnVRTWeRiFANVa `MF/k B aIRTf KeRTh/HFG B RTK zkVFgN\h/GbWera^RV]uGbh#kraINOc#RTK `?NOF/c/GIHia^R47 x:AYy deR8HkDkVFKMGbWMNOc#R4h C h/c#RTfGIh NVaIGIrWeRTK h#k Y X C f8f4Ric#F C HkrWMKMG^c/GIkrWMhJGIf4`!krh#Rc/deR8aINVH +kVzNTGIf wec/dMNVaKMRi`RTWKeRTWMHRkVz<c/deR8h#kraIwec/GIkrW NVWMK c/deR B krwMWMKNOF C HkrWMKG^c/G^krWMh$RTaIGIfgGIWMNOc#Rc#RiFf8hkVc/deRiFc/dMNVWQc/dMR 7 Hkrh;:uc#RiFf GbWtc/deRh#`dMRiFGIHiNVa!dMNOFf4krWGIH$R D`NVWh/G^krWY y dMRSh#kraIwec/G^krWQGbhi]eh#RiR z ]

+

< o .Hkrh 7\DYIx:

/ - .Hkrh < B ? < oHkrh A 7\DY[o:

ekVFNQabGIWeRTNOFa C hwMh/HRi`Mc/G B a^R fgNOc#RiFGINVa ]c/deR8GbWMKMwMHRTK+f8NOrWeRic/GIH4KG^`!kra^RKeRTWh/G^c C C + ]LG^c/d C xOY y deRSKG^`!kra^R$f8krf4RTWci] ]MGIh<c/dMRiF/Riz kVFR

31)03

? 31)03 C + ? 9 ? 3,4:4 7\DY :

LdeRiFR 3,4:4 ( &7 < :AY y deRg|RTaIK F/RTh/wa^c/GIWeQzF/krfh/RTHkrWMK c#RiFAf:GIW 7\DY[o:GbhSRTDwMNVac#kc/dMNOcKMweRc#k'N `!krGIWc)KMG^`!kra^RJkVz(h#c#F/RTWMVc/d a^kHiNOc#RTKNOc$c/deR h#`deRiF/R h)HRTWc#RiFY y deRiFRiz kVF/RV]!GIWQc/dMR|RTKKMG^`!kra^RJf4kKeRTa ]ec/deR |RTaIKQKMweR c#k B RTNVK \Gbh

0+ 7 :

x9 7 :

E 7 :

? 7\DY9;:

LG^c/d Y y deR zkVFHRSkrWnc/deRS`!krGIW=c<KG^`!kra^R KMweR c#kg|MRTaIK Gbh<rG^UVRTW BDC z

7 =: 7\DY z:

y dDwMhi]z kVFSNVW+RTWMh/RTf B aIRkVz h#`deRiFRThRTNVHAd\dMNTUGIWetKMG^`!kra^Rf4krf4RTW=c ]!c/deR F/RTh/wMa^c/GbWegzkVFHRkrWB RTNVK \KMweRJc#k8c/dMRSkVc/deRiF B RTNVKMh Gbh

9: ? @+ 7 : 7\DY[q:

Page 39: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

xT

)kVc#Rc/dMNOcGIW7\DY z:.N KMRi`a^Ric#RTK4h/wMfgf8NOc/G^krW4WeRTHRTh/hNOF C c#kSNUVkrGIK8h#RTaIz / h/GbWerwMaINOFc#RiFf8hiY y dMR<NO``aIG^RTK|MRTaIK] ]=GIc/h#RTa^z!Kek=RThuWekVcR RiF/c(NVW C z kVFAHRkrW8c/deR B RTNVKMhh/GIWHR c/deRVFNVKMGIRTWckVz!c/dMGbh|MRTaIK8Gbh iRiF/keY

2%2 ># ' 4 Wc/dMR4|DRTK&=KMG^`!kra^Rf4kKeRTa ]krWa C c/deRR c#RiFWMNVa.|MRTaIK+L<NVh HkrWMh/GIKMRiF/RTK9GIW+c/deR4HiNVaIHiwMaINOc/G^krW+kVz5c/deRKMG^`!kra^Rf4krf4RTW=c/hSkVz<c/deR B RTNVKhiY y deR8f wec/wMNVaKG^`!kra^R f8kDKeRTaNVaba^kLhSz kVFc/deR4|MRTaIKMhJkVz<c/deRgkVc/deRiFB RTNVKMh8c#k HkrW=c#FG B wec#Rc#k c/deR+f8NOrWeRic/G TNOc/GIkrW kVz c/deR B RTNVK wMWKeRiFgHkrWMh/GbKeRiFNOc/G^krWY y dGIh8f4kKeRTaGIhtRTDwMG^UONVa^RTW=c'c#k `MF/kUGIKMGbWe N h/kraIwec/G^krW*kVz c/deR / h#`deRiF/R `F/k B a^RTf LG^c/dh/`deRiFGIHiNVaJdMNOFAf4krWMGIHR `NVWMh/G^krWhc#FwWMHiNOc#RTK NOcc/deRQKMG^`!kra^Rga^RiUVRTa ] x z Y y deRiFRiz kVF/RV]RTNVHAd h#`dMRiF/R B RTdMNUVRTh4NVhc/dekrwerd GIh#krabNOc#RTK NVWMK GIf8f4RiFAh#RTK GIW N|RTaIK\LdMkrh#R h#c#FRTWeVc/d GbhSRTDwMNVa(c/dMR'h/wf,kVzc/deR R Dc#RiFAWMNVa|MRTaIKNVWMKnc/dMR|MRTabKMhKMweRc#k c/dMRkVc/deRiF B RTNVKMhRiUONVaIwMNOc#RTK+NOc$c/deRh#`?deRiF/R h$HRTWc#RiFTY v5krWMh#RTDweRTW=c/a C ]c/deRKG^`!kra^R$f8krf4RTWckVz B RTNVK \GIh

9 ? 3,4:4

< 9:

? 0+ 7 : 7\DY :

_$hc/deRKG^`!kra^R f4krf4RTW=c/hkVz.c/deR B RTNVKMh)f8N C WeklL KMG RiFT]LuRabN B RTac/deRKMG^`!kra^RJ|MRTabKnGIW47\DY :LG^c/dNhwe`!RiFh/HFG^`c$c#k+KeRTWekVc#R c/deR KMGI`kraIRf8krf4RTWc`MF/kKMwMHiGIWMQc/deR8|MRTaIKY y dMRgKMG^`!kra^R8f4krf8RTWc/h NOF/RwMWWeklLW DwMNVW=c/G^c/G^RThNVWK RTDwMNOc/G^krWMh_7\DY9;:NVWMK 7\DY :`MFkUGIKeR8c/deR 4 aIGIWeRTNOFh C h/c#RTf:kVzRTDwMNOc/G^krWMhSWMRiRTKeRTK9c#kKeRic#RiFfgGIWeRc/deRgKMGI`kraIR f4krf8RTWc/hiY5< WMHR4c/deR8KMG^`!kra^Rf4krf4RTW=c/hSdMNUVR B RiRTWzkrwMWMKtc/deRSzkVFHRSkrWh#`deRiF/R \GIhc/deRTW

9:

? 0+ 7 : 7\DY[:

y kKMGIhHiwMh/hJc/deRgNVHiHiwMFNVH C kVzuc/dMR8|RTK\NVWMK\f wec/wMNVaKG^`!kra^R f8kDKeRTabhi]L5RgHkrf4`NOF/R c/deR4zkVFHRB Ric L5RiRTWnc Lukgh/`deRiF/RTh GIWQNgwMWMG^zkVFf|MRTaIKtrG^UVRTW BDC c/deRTh#Rf4kKeRTaIh<L)G^c/d'c/deRSR eNVHch#kraIwec/GIkrWY y deRR eNVHc$h#krabwec/G^krWGbh `MF/klUDGIKMRTK BDC c/dMRHiNVaIHiwMabNOc/G^krWKeRThHFG B RTKnGIWh#RTHc/G^krW=DY DY W.G^rweF/RtDYIx7 N.:A]!L5R`a^kVc<c/deRJzkVFHRSNVhNz wMWMHc/G^krW'kVzh#Ri`NOFNOc/G^krWKMGIh#c/NVWMHRJLGIc/d c/dMRJNO``aIG^RTK |MRTaIK'`NOFNVaba^RTac#k4c/deRSaIGIWeRkVz)HRTW=c#RiFhiY W".G^rweF/R DYIx7 B :A](c/dMR'NO`M`?aIG^RTK\|RTaIK Gbh`!RiF/`!RTWMKGIHiwMaINOF c#k9c/deRQaIGIWMR8kVz)HRTW=c#RiFhiY4 WB kVc/d kVzc/deRTh#Rtc L5k9`a^kVc/h C oNVWK7 xOY= ch/dekrwMabK B R WekVc#RTK c/dMNOc LdeRTW c/deR'|MRTaIK GIhNVaIG^rWMRTK\LG^c/d c/deRtaIGIWeR4kVzHRTW=c#RiFhi]c/dMR zkVFHR GbhNOc#c#FNVHc/GIUVR'L)deRiF/RTNVhLdeRTW G^cGIh`!RiF/`!RTWMKMGIHiwMabNOFT]c/deR4zkVFHR8GIhJF/Ri`?wMaIh/G^UVRVY _)hSkrWeR4R D`!RTHc/hi] c/deR8fwMc/wMNVaKMG^`!kra^Rf4kKeRTa`RiFz kVFfgh B Ric#c#RiFSc/dNVW c/deR

Page 40: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

x

2 2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8 3 3.2 3.4 3.6 3.8 40

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

y/a

Fy

H0

Fy

2 2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8 3 3.2 3.4 3.6 3.8 40

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

x/a

Fx

H0

Fx

.G^rweF/R_DYIxs NVaIwMRThkVzc/deR'GbWc#RiF B RTNVK z kVFAHR zkVFc L5k B RTNVKMh GIW NwMWG^z kVFAf,|MRTaIK 7 pTx/p.:LG^c/dC oDY DYIx7 N.:Vs QNVh Nnz wMWMHc/G^krW\kVz<h/Ri`NOFNOc/G^krWY y dMRgUONVaIweRTh kVz= 'NOFR WekVFfgNVaIG iRTKBDC c/dMRgUONVaIweR4kVz= kVz<c/deR R NVHc h#kraIwec/G^krW NOch#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krW% oDY DYIx7 B :Vs nNVh NQzwWMHc/G^krWkVzh#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krWY y dMRSU NVabweRThkVz" NOF/RWekVFfgNVaIG iRTK BDC c/deRUONVaIweRkVz" kVzc/deRR eNVHc h#kraIwec/GIkrWnNOch#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krW oDYD W8c/dMR`a^kVc/h$se7 &:|RTK8KMG^`!kra^Rr7 t&:fwec/wNVaMKMG^`!kra^Rr76:R eNVHch#kraIwMc/G^krWY

Page 41: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

oOp

2 2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8 3 3.2 3.4 3.6 3.8 40

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

y/a

Fy

H0

Fy

2 2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8 3 3.2 3.4 3.6 3.8 40

0.5

1

1.5

x/a

Fx

H0

Fx

.G^rweF/R_DY[os NVaIwMRThkVzc/deR'GbWc#RiF B RTNVK z kVFAHR zkVFc L5k B RTNVKMh GIW NwMWG^z kVFAf,|MRTaIK 7 pTx/p.:LG^c/dC zDY DYIx7 N.:Vs QNVh Nnz wMWMHc/G^krW\kVz<h/Ri`NOFNOc/G^krWY y dMRgUONVaIweRTh kVz= 'NOFR WekVFfgNVaIG iRTKBDC c/dMRgUONVaIweR4kVz= kVz<c/deR R NVHc h#kraIwec/G^krW NOch#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krW% oDY DYIx7 B :Vs nNVh NQzwWMHc/G^krWkVzh#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krWY y dMRSU NVabweRThkVz" NOF/RWekVFfgNVaIG iRTK BDC c/deRUONVaIweRkVz" kVzc/deRR eNVHc h#kraIwec/GIkrWnNOch#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krW oDYD W8c/dMR`a^kVc/h$se7 &:|RTK8KMG^`!kra^Rr7 t&:fwec/wNVaMKMG^`!kra^Rr76:R eNVHch#kraIwMc/G^krWY

Page 42: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

ox

|RTKKG^`!kra^Rf4kKeRTa Y$j5kVc/d f4kDKMRTaIhi]!dekL5RiUVRiFT] B FRTNKekL)WNVhJc/deR `NOF/c/GbHia^RTh)Hkrf8RGbWc#kQHkrW=c/NVHcNVWMK'c/deRJWeRira^RTHc#RTKQdMGIrdeRiF fwMaIc/G^`!kra^RTh B RTHkrf4R GIf4`!kVF/c/NVW=ciYfGIrweF/RTheDY[o07 N.:<NVWMK DY[o07 B :uh/deklLc/deRh/NVf4R4HkrWe|rweFNOc/G^krWMh$LGIc/dC zDYS_$hJHkrf4`NOF/RTK9L)G^c/dc/dMR C ogHiNVh#RThT]c/deRKMG !RiF/RTWMHRGIW9c/deR4zkVFHR8rGIUVRTW B=C c/deRgKG^`!kra^R f8kDKeRTabh NVWMK9c/deR8R eNVHcHiNVaIHiwaINOc/G^krW GIh f wMHd f4kVF/R8h#RiUVRiFRgNOch#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krWMha^RThh c/dMNVWQc/deFRiR FNVKMGIG Y

<$c/dMRiFR NVf8`a^RThGIW=UVkra^UGIWe4h#Ric/hkVzc/dMF/RiR `NOF/c/GIHiaIRTh kVFRTG^rd=c`NOF/c/GbHia^RTh NOF/RKMGbh/HiwMh/h#RTKQabNOc#RiFGIWVDY DY[oDY

\A4 %&')0 S24(0

RdMNTUVR`MF/RTh/RTWc#RTKc L5k'KG^`!kra^RSf4kKeRTaIhHkrfgf4krWMa C wMh/RTKnc#ktdMNVWMKMa^Rc/deRf8NOrWMRic/GIHGbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMhB Ric L5RiRTW `?NOFNVf8NOrWeRic/GIH B RTNVKMhiY j5kVc/d c/deRn|RTK&/ KMGI`kraIRtNVWK fwMc/wMNVaKMGI`kraIRtf8kDKeRTabh4F/RTDwMG^F/RTKNVW F 7 A :$`?NVG^F/LGIh/RHiNVabHiwMaINOc/G^krW c#k+KeRic#RiFf8GbWeRc/deRgGIW=c#RiF/`NOF/c/GbHia^R4z kVFAHRThNVWMK c#k+KeRic#RiFf8GbWeR4c/deRKMG^`!kra^R f4krf8RTWc/hi]GIWQc/deRHiNVh#RkVzc/deRfwec/wNVaKMG^`!kra^R f4kKeRTa YU WQc/dGIhh#RTHc/G^krW]L5R`MF/RTh/RTWcNgWeRiLKMG^`!kra^R<f4kKeRTa B NVh/RTK4krW4|WMGIc#R<KGIh#c#FG B wec/G^krWMh~kVzHiweF/F/RTW=cKeRTWMh/GIc C Y X wMHAd8N f4kKeRTaMGIh.RTNVh/Gba C dNVWMKMa^RTKBDC f8NVW C W=wf4RiFGIHiNVa~c#RTHdMWGI=wMRTh$NVWKFRTNVKMGIa C NVKMNO`Mc/hJc#kQHkrWe|?WeRTKVRikrf8Ric#FG^RThJLdeRiFR B krwMWMKNOF CHkrWMKMGIc/G^krWMhkrWgc/deR)f8NOrWMRic/GIH|MRTabK8WeRiRTK c#k B RGIf4`!krh#RTKY_$aIh#ke]=c/deR|WG^c#RWMNOc/weF/RkVzc/deRF/RThwMa^c/GIWe|MRTaIK RTaIGIfgGIWMNOc#RTh5c/deR WeRiRTK'z kVF R eHiaIwMhG^UVR$hwMf8h5c/dMNOc NOF/RJ`MF/RTh#RTW=c GIW'c/deRJkVc/deRiFf4kKeRTaIh5KMweR$c#k4c/deRh#RTa^zM/ GIWMKwMHRTKth/GIWerwMabNOF5c#RiFAf8hiY

+ ' >'# ' 4 B) ' $%-3'y k B RirGIW]L5R4KMGIh/Hiwh/h)dMkL c#ktF/Ri`MF/RTh/RTWc N'rG^UVRTW f8NOrWeRic/GTNOc/G^krW B=C NtKMGIh#c#FG B wec/G^krWQkVz5HiweF/F/RTW=ciY.G^Fh#ci]MHkrWh/GIKeRiFNgKMGIh#c#FG B wec/G^krW kVzHiwMF/F/RTW=ch#krweFHRThGIWnN4UONVHiwMwMfQY1MkVF)c/dMGbh h/G^c/wMNOc/G^krW]ZNLuRTaba hRTDwMNOc/G^krWMh z~NOF/R

p 7\DY :

7\DYIxip.:

7\DYIxVx:

E(DwMNOc/G^krW 7\DY :NVaba^kLhwMhc#k'GIWc#FkDKMwHR c/deRSUVRTHc#kVFJ`!kVc#RTWc/GINVa ] ]?h/wMHAdnc/dMNOc Y y deRHdMkrGIHRnkVzJc/deR+v5kraIkrwMf B rNVwMVRV] p] NVWMK c/deRnF/RTf8NVGbWMGIWe+c L5k RTDwMNOc/G^krWMhT] 7\DYIxip.:gNVWMK

Page 43: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

oVo

7\DYIxVx:A]F/RiUVRTNVa A 7\DYIxTo:

)kLS]DHkrWMh/GIKeRiFuNSh C h#c#RTf N B h/RTWckVz!NVW C HiwMF/F/RTW=ch#krweFHRThi] B wecLdMRiF/RNVWgGIWKMwMHRTKf8NOrWeRic/G TNOc/GIkrW] GIh<`MFRTh#RTWciYU RiF/RV]ZNLuRTaba h RTDwMNOc/G^krWMh rGIUVR z

p 7\DYIx:

7\DYIxY9;:

f7* < : 7\DYIxz:

RtNOrNVGIW GIWc#FkDKMwHR8c/deRgUVRTHc#kVF4`!kVc#RTW=c/GINVa ] NVWMK h/w B h#c/G^c/wec#R8c/dMRgR `MF/RTh/h/GIkrW\zkVF GIWc#kc/deRN B kUVRRT=wMNOc/GIkrWMhNVWMKt|WK A 7\DYIxTq:

j C Hkrf4`NOFAGIWe 7\DYIxTo:NVWMK7\DYIxTq:A]L5R HiNVW F/Ri`MF/RTh/RTWcc/deR f8NOrWMRic/G TNOc/G^krW B=C NHiweF/F/RTW=cKMGIh/c#FG B wec/GIkrW BDC F/RTDwMG^FGbWe Y y deR$HiweF/F/RTW=c<KeRTWMh/G^c C KMGIh/c#FG B wec/GIkrW8NVh/h#kHiGINOc#RTKtLG^c/d'N`!krGIW=c<KG^`!kra^R a^kDHiNOc#RTKNOcc/deRSkVFGIrGIWQGIh

7B: 7B: 7\DYIx:

R4LGIhdnc#ktc#ktF/RTf4kUVR4c/dMRhGIWerwMaINOFAG^c C LdMGba^Rf8NVGIW=c/NVGIWMGbWegc/deRa^kHiNVaIG iRTK9WMNOc/weFRkVzc/dMRKGIh#c#FG /B wec/GIkrWY y k'Kekgc/dMGbhi]ML5RF/Ri`?aINVHRc/deR JG^FNVHKMRTa^c/N4z wMWMHc/G^krWLG^c/dN h/f4kDkVc/dMa C UONOF C GbWe JNVwMhh/GINVWz wMWMHc/G^krW

7B: 7 o A : ?BA A R `B7 A Oo A : 7\DYIxT:

y deRiFRiz kVF/RV]ekrwMFHiweF/F/RTW=cKeRTWMhG^c C GIh WeklL

@ 7B: 7\DYIx:

NVWMKQL5RNOF/RSaIRiz c LGIc/dnh#kra^UGIWe A @ @ 7\DY[oOp.:

y deRSh/kraIwec/G^krWtc#k7\DY[oOp.:GIh @

7.: 7\DY[ox:

Page 44: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

o

LG^c/dtc/dMRSzwWMHc/G^krWMh 7.:<NVWKQG^c/hKeRiFGIU NOc/G^UVR 7.:urG^UVRTW B=C ]?h#RiR x ]

x7: x9 RiF/z

L o 7\DY[oVo:

7: x

9 ARiF/z

L o o A A R D`D7 A Oo A : 7\DY[o:

y dMRSf8NOrWeRic/GIH |RTaIK GIh<c/dMRTWQRiU NVabwMNOc#RTKNVhi]

@ 7B: 7B: 7 7.: : 7\DY[oK9;:

kVFT]MR `aIGbHiG^c/a C ]

@ 7B: x9

E

? RiF/z L o

< A <

A A 7B: 7\DY[oz:

Wy7\DY[oz:A]!c/deR h#RTHkrWMKc#RiFf KeRTHiN C h$R `!krWeRTWc/GbNVaIa C z NVh#ci]!NVWMKQc/deR KMG^`!kra^RJ|MRTaIKGIhNVHAdMG^RiUVRTKkrWMHR Gbh aINOF/VR5RTWekrwerdc/dMNOcRiF/z 7 L o:Gbh Hia^krh#R5c#kJkrWeRVY y deR(UVRTHc#kVF`!kVc#RTW=c/GINVaDHkrWc#krweFAhNVhh#kDHiGbNOc#RTKLG^c/d 7\DY[oz:uNVWMKgc/dMkrh#R)HkVF/FRTh#`!krWMKMGIWe c#kNS`!krGIW=cuKG^`!kra^R NOF/R$KMRi`GIHc#RTKgGbW .G^rweF/R DY DYf R WekVc/GIHRc/deR4|WG^c#R =KMG^`!kra^R HiweF/F/RTW=c KMGIh#c#FG B wec/G^krWh/f4kDkVc/deRThJkrwec c/deR4|MRTabK+GbWc/dMR4F/RirG^krW WeRTNOF c/deR4kVFAG^rGIWYs(d C h/GIHiNVaIa C ]Dc/deR |WG^c#R =KMG^`!kra^R$HiweF/F/RTW=c KMGIh#c#FG B wec/G^krW8HiNVW B RJc/dekrwMrdc kVzNVhN4HiweF/F/RTW=c a^kDkV`'L)dekrh#R|WMGIc#R$FANVKMGIwMh GIh<FRi`MF/RTh#RTW=c#RTK BDC c/dMRSh/G iRSkVzc/deRJNVwh/h/GINVWtRTW=UVRTa^kV`!RV] .Y

X GbWMHRuc/dGIhf4kKeRTaGIhc#k B R NO`M`?aIG^RTKc#k `NOF/c/GIHia^RThkVz|WMG^c#R<h/G iRV]c/deR<FNOc/G^k kVz tLGIaba=KeRic#RiFAf8GIWeRdeklL L5RTaIa=c/deR<|MRTaIKe2#wMh/c~krwec/hGIKeR(c/dMR B RTNVK GIhF/RTh#kra^UVRTKYB Wt.G^rwMF/RThfDY9X7 N.:NVWMKDY9X7 B :A]rL5R5Hkrf4`?NOF/R`MF/kV|?a^RTh kVzc/deR f8NOrWeRic/GIH|MRTaIKnVRTWMRiFNOc#RTK BDC |WMGIc#R =KMG^`!kra^R HiweF/F/RTW=c)KGIh#c#FG B wec/G^krWMh5kVzKMG !RiF/RTW=c LG^c/d c/dekrh/RkVzNJ`!krGIW=cKMG^`!kra^Ru|MRTaIKY )NOc/wMFNVaIa C ]Vc/deRNO``MF/k eGIf8NOc/GIkrWkVz?c/deR `!krGIW=cKMG^`!kra^R5GIf4`MF/klUVRThNVh.L5R5KeRTHFRTNVh#R c/deR<h/G iR5kVzc/deRJNVwMh/hGINVW RTWUVRTa^kV`!RV]VLGIc/dc/deR h/GiRuFNOc/GIk 9JF/RTh#kraIUDGIWM)WeRTNOFa CNVaIa!c/deR |RTaIKtNOcNVW C KMGIh/c/NVWMHR z Fkrf%c/deRSh/weF/z NVHR kVzc/deRSh#`deRiFRVY_)aIh/ke]eLuR k B h/RiF/UVR c/deR F/RTh#krabwec/G^krWkVz.c/deR |MRTaIKQNVaIkrWe4c/deR"X/ NGIhz kVFN8rG^UVRTW \GIh L5kVFh#RSc/dNVWnNVa^krWe4c/deR ./ NeGIhiY

2%2 + & '# 4 X k+zNOF]LuRQdMNUVRQ`MF/RTh#RTW=c#RTK c/deRtF/Ri`MF/RTh/RTWc/NOc/G^krW kVz$NhGIWera^RtKMG^`!kra^R8zF/krf N+|WMG^c#RtKMGIh/c#FG B wec/GIkrWkVzuHiwMF/F/RTW=ciYJj<NVh#RTK9krW9c/dMRTh#RF/RTh/wMa^c/hT]?L5R4WekL1zkVFfwaINOc#R4NVW+GIc#RiFNOc/G^UVR4f4Ric/dekK+c#ktHkrf8`wec#Rc/deRf8NOrWeRic/GbH GIWc#RiFANVHc/G^krWMh.kVz?NJHkraIaIRTHc/G^krWkVz`NOFANVf8NOrWeRic/GIH h#`?deRiF/RThiY .G^Fh#ci]rh/wM`M`!krh#R(c/deR B RTNVKMhdMNUVR

Page 45: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

oK9

−8 −6 −4 −2 0 2 4 6 8−5

−4

−3

−2

−1

0

1

2

3

4

5

x

y

.G^rweF/RDY s RTHc#kVFS`!kVc#RTWc/GbNVaHkrW=c#krweFhJzkVFSN'`!krGIWcJKMG^`!kra^R 76:)NVWMK9N'|WMG^c#RY/ KMGI`kraIRHiweF/F/RTW=cKMGIh/c#FG B wec/GIkrW 7 x &:5LG^c/d 1xOYn W B kVc/dnHiNVh/RTh m7 pTx/p.:AY

Page 46: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

oz

1 1.5 2 2.5−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

x/a

Hy

1 1.5 2 2.50

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

y/a

Hy

.G^rweF/RDY90sJsF/kV|aIRTh)kVz z kVFSNVW9GIh/kraINOc#RTK B RTNVK+LGIc/d 9 C ? D] 7 pTx/p.:A].NVWMK xOYfDY9X7 N.:Vs NVa^krWe c/deR!,/ NeGIh.LdMRiF/R<c/deR<U NVaIwMRTh.kVz NOFR<WMkVFf8NVaIG iRTK BDC c/deR UONVaIweR<kVz kVzc/deR)c#FweR$KMG^`!kra^RNOc 1xOYnDY9X7 B :Vs NVaIkrWec/deR ;/ NGIhuLG^c/dgc/deR$U NVaIwMRThkVz WekVFfgNVaIG iRTKBDC c/deRUONVaIweRkVzkVzc/deRc#FweRKMG^`!kra^RSNOc xgY3 Wc/deR `a^kVc/h$s 7 % %% := @o&n7 5 &: 6&B7 : ! 9'B7)( :u`!krGIW=cKMG^`!kra^RVY

Page 47: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

oVq

GIWMGIc/GINVaKMG^`!kra^R4f4krf4RTW=c/h 8? z kVF x Y y deRTh#RgGbWMG^c/GINVaKMGI`kraIRf8krf4RTWc/h f8N C B R4c/dMkrh#RKMweRc#k c/dMRR c#RiFWMNVa~|MRTaIKkVF$c/dMkrh#RzF/krf N8`MFRiUDG^krwhc/GIf4RTh/c#Ri`+kVFJG^c#RiFNOc/GIkrWY3)kLS]!c#ktf4kVc/G^UONOc#Rc/deRf8Ric/dekDK]eLuR F/RTHiNVaban7\DY : NVWMKnF/RiLFG^c#RSGIcNVh

9 ? 3,4:4

< 9:

?

0+ 7 : 7 : ? 7\DY[oVq:

WQc/deRSf wec/wMNVa|WG^c#RY/ KMG^`!kra^R$f4kDKMRTa ]ec/deRSKMG^`!kra^R f4krf8RTWckVz B RTNVK \GIh<rG^UVRTW B=C

9 ? 3,4:4

< 9:

? @ 7 : 7 : ? 7\DY[o:

W 7\DY[o:A]c/deR |MRTaIKhkVzc/deR kVc/deRiF B RTNVKMh)NOFR GIWKMwMHRTK BDC f4krf4RTW=c/h 8? SNVWMKrG^UVRTW B=C 7\DY[oz:AY_$h$N F/RTh/wa^cRiUVRiF C c/dMGIWMgkrW+c/deR FG^rd=c)dMNVWMK+h/GIKMRSkVz37\DY[o:$GIh DWMkLWYJ_$aIh#ke]c/deR KMRTa^c/N8zwWMHc/G^krWGIWc/deRHkrWUVkraIwMc/G^krW9GIh$F/Ri`aINVHRTK B=C c/deR JNVwMh/h/GbNVWKMGbh#c#FG B wMc/G^krW>7\DYIxT:AY y dMRiF/Riz kVFRV]FANOc/deRiFJc/dMNVWwMh/GbWe c/dMR4U NVaIwMR kVz5c/deR4|MRTabK+NOcNt`NOF/c/GIHia^R h HRTW=c#RiFT]NQa^kDHiNVaba C h#`NOc/GbNVaIa C NUVRiFNOVRTK UONVaIweRkVz5c/deR|MRTaIKQGbh HkrWMh/GIKeRiFRTKnGIWtc/deRSHkrf4`?wec/NOc/G^krWnkVzc/dMNOc`?NOF/c/GIHia^R hKG^`!kra^R$f8krf4RTWciY

W4HkrWc#FANVh#cc#kN h/GbWerwMaINOF.`!krGIW=cKMGI`kraIRV] c/dMR |MRTaIKkVz!NJ|WMG^c#R =KMGI`kraIRuGIh.|WG^c#R5NVWKLuRTaIaeKMRi|WeRTKNOcc/deRKMG^`!kra^R h<a^kHiNOc/G^krWYf RfgN C c/deRTWQLFAG^c#R

9 ? 354:4 - /5- 7B: @ 7 : 7 : ? 7\DY[oV:

LdeRiFR - /5- 7B: < 9:

@ 7 : 7\DY[o:

X GIWHR$c/dMRSUVkraIwMf4RSNUVRiFNOVR kVz.N`?NOF/c/GIHia^R h klLWQ|MRTabKQGIh

@ 7 : 7 : ? .? xTo07 A : ?BA A 7\DY Op.:

L5RNOF/FG^UVRSNOc

9 ? 354:4 - /5- 7B: 7 : ? .?

xTo07 A : ?BA A 7\DY x:

Page 48: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

o

m$h/GIWe4c/dMR |WMG^c#RSHiweFF/RTWcKMRTWMh/G^c C F/Ri`MFRTh#RTWc/NOc/GIkrW]Mc/deRSzkVFHRSkrW B RTNVK 9Gbh

@ >7 - /5- @ 7 : ? 7\DY Vo:

RfgN C RTaIGIf8GbWMNOc#R)c/dMRWeRiRTKQc#kghw B c#FNVHcc/dMRSh#RTa^z =GIWMKMwMHRTK'zkVFHRThhGIWMHRV]MGIWtz NVHci]

@ @ ? *p 7\DY :

y deRiFRiz kVF/RV]ec/dMRSz kVFAHRSkrW B RTNVK \GIh h/Gbf4`a C

@ - /5- ? 7\DY K9;:

X wf8f8NOFG TGbWe4c/deRN B klUVRF/RTh/wMa^c/hT]c/deR W=wMf8RiFGIHiNVa`F/kDHRTKweF/RL)G^c/dnc/deRf wec/wMNVa~|WMG^c#R =KMGI`kraIRf4kKeRTaGIhNVhz kraIaIkLh$s

xOYm$h/GIWM'c/dMR4U NVaIwMRThJkVzuc/deR8KG^`!kra^Rf4krf8RTWc/h zF/krf Nt`MFRiUDG^krwh)c/Gbf4RTh#c#Ri`\kVFGIc#RiFNOc/G^krW] .? zkVF 1x MHkrWh#c#FwMHcc/dMRHiweF/F/RTW=cKeRTWMhG^c C KMGIh#c#FAG B wec/G^krW 9

@ 7 :

oDY X kra^UVR A 9 @ 7 :JzkVFc/deR UVRTHc#kVF`kVc#RTW=c/GINVa NVWMK Hkrf8`wec#R Y

DY$Ric#RiFfgGIWeRSc/deRSWMRiL6KMG^`!kra^RJf4krf4RTW=c/h

9 ? 3,4:4 y7B: 7 : ? 8?

xTo07 A : ?BA A 7\DY z:

zkVF 1x

9eY$v deRTH KG^`!kra^R f4krf4RTW=c/h)zkVFJHkrWUVRiF/VRTWHRVY z .? 9)c/deRTW+h#Ric 8? NVWMKVkgc#k X c#Ri` xOY

zDY z= 8? 9 c/deRTWnRiU NVaIwNOc#RSc/deRSzkVFHRThkrWnc/deR B RTNVKMh

@ 7 : 7 : ? 7\DY Vq:

zkVF 1x Y

y dMRhHdeRTf4R8KMRTh/HFG B RTK9N B kUVR8HiNVW B R4GIf4`aIRTf4RTWc#RTK9GIW+UONOFG^Ric C kVzuL5N C hSKMRi`RTWKMGIWe krW c/deRWDwMf B RiFkVz`?NOF/c/GIHia^RThNVWKnc/deR B krwMWKMNOF C HkrWMKMG^c/G^krWhiYUekVFJGIh#krabNOc#RTKHkrWe|MrwMFNOc/G^krWMhkVzzRiL@`NOF/c/G /

Page 49: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

oV

2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 31

1.005

1.01

1.015

1.02

1.025

x/a

my

2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 30.955

0.96

0.965

0.97

0.975

0.98

0.985

0.99

0.995

1

y/a

my

.G^rweF/R4DY zs NVabweRThQkVz \NVhN z wMWMHc/G^krW kVzh#Ri`NOFNOc/G^krWz kVFQc Luk B RTNVKMhQGbWN wMWMG^zkVFf |MRTaIK 7 pTx/p.:tNVWK C oDY DY z07 N.:Vs X Ri`NOFANOc/G^krW NVaIkrWe c/deRX/ NGbhiY y deR+U NVabweRThgkVz NOF/RnWekVFAf8NVaIG iRTK BDC c/deRtUONVaIweRtkVz kVz)c/dMRtf wec/wMNVa KG^`!kra^R'NOc8h/Ri`NOFNOc/G^krW oDY"DY z07 B :VsX Ri`NOFANOc/G^krW NVa^krWMc/deR ./ NeGIhiY y dMR8U NVabweRThSkVz tNOF/R WMkVFf8NVaIG iRTK B=C c/deR'UONVaIweR8kVz 'kVz c/deRf wec/wMNVaKMG^`!kra^RNOcSh#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krW % oDYR W c/deR4`aIkVc/h$sR7 Y^Y^Y^Y : ! o&k7M//e/e/ : & 76: 9'B7)( :<`krGbWc KMG^`!kra^RVY

Hia^RThi]?krWeRHiNVWHkrWMh#c#FwHc)NgaIkDHiNVa VFGIKQzkVF)RTNVHAd`?NOF/c/GIHia^RNVWKnLG^c/dnc/deRF/RThwMa^c/h7\DY[oOp.:)NVWMK 7\DY[ox:Hkrf4`wMc#RSc/deRGbWc#RiVFNVabhGIWnh#c#Ri`?ht7\: NVWKy7\z:AY y dMGIh f8Ric/dekDKLGIaIa ]DdeklLuRiUVRiF]h/HiNVaIRHkrf4`wMc/NOc/G^krW&/NVaIa C NVh F 7 A :AY1 W hG^c/wMNOc/G^krWMh(LdeRiF/RJf8NVW C `NOF/c/GbHia^RThuWMRiRTKgc#k B R)HkrWMhGIKeRiF/RTK]=kVF B krwWMKMNOFG^RThuNOF/R`MF/RTh/RTWci]N |DRTK+f4RTh/d+klUVRiF c/deRRTW=c/G^F/RKekrf8NVGbWHiNVW B RHkrWMh/c#FwMHc#RTK9NVWMK9N WDwMf4RiFAGIHiNVa h#krabwec/G^krWzkVF(c/deR)UVRTHc#kVF `kVc#RTW=c/GINVaD7 h#c#Ri`=7 o: :(HiNVW B R)KeRic#RiFf8GIWMRTKY y deRGIW=c#RiVFNVaIhuGIWgh#c#Ri`?h37\:(NVWMK7\z:(HiNVWc/deRTW B RHkrf4`wec#RTKwMh/GIWe4UONVaIweRThkVz - /5- krWWeRTNOF BDC f8RTh/dn`!krGIW=c/hiY y deRHkrh#c$kVzHkrf4`wec/GIWM8c/deRc#kVc/NVaf8NOrWeRic/GIH)|MRTaIK8HiNVW B RHkrWMh/GbKeRiF/RTK4|RTKY y deR)Hkrh#cukVzNVW NVKMKMG^c/GIkrWMNVae`NOF/c/GbHia^RGIhNVhh#kDHiGbNOc#RTKLG^c/dc/deRNVKMKMG^c/GIkrWMNVah#krweFAHR c#RiFAf NVWMK+c/deR R c#FN KG^`!kra^RNVWMKz kVFAHRGbWc#RiVFNOc/GIkrWMhi]!LdMGIHAdnF/RThwMa^c/hGIWQN8f8Ric/dekDKc/dMNOch/HiNVaIRThHkrf4`wMc/NOc/G^krWMNVaIa C NVh F 7=:AYU G^c/dc/deR |RTKf4RThdnNO`M`MF/krNVHAd]Mc/deRiFRGIhc/deRJF/RTh#c#FAGIHc/G^krW'c/dMNOc<c/deRJVFGIKth#`NVHiGbWe B RJh/f8NVaIaRTWekrwMrd'Hkrf8`NOF/RTKtc#k4c/deR HdNOFNVHc#RiFGIh#c/GbH a^RTWeVc/dh/HiNVa^RkVz~c/deRKMGIh#c#FG B wec/G^krW]( NVhKMGbh/HiwMh/h#RTKtGIWtc/dMRSz kraba^kLGbWe`NOFNOVFNO`dY

WnkVFKMRiF)c#k'NVWMNVa C iRc/deR dekL@L5RTaIac/deR fwMc/wMNVa|WG^c#R =KMG^`!kra^R f4kKeRTaFRi`MF/RTh#RTW=c/hc/dMRf wec/wMNVaKMG^`!kra^RJf4kKeRTa ]L5RHkrWMh/GIKMRiF |MFh#c<c L5k GbWc#RiFNVHc/GbWe8h#`deRiFRTh GIWQN4wMWMG^zkVFf%f8NOrWeRic/GbH |MRTaIKY W.G^eYDY z07 N.:A]LuRS`?a^kVc c/deRKMGI`kraIRJf8krf4RTWc/hz Fkrf c/deRf wec/wMNVaKMGI`kraIRJf8Ric/dekDKNVWMKQc/deRf wec/wMNVa|WMG^c#R

Page 50: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

o

2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 3−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

x/a

Fx

H0

Fx

2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 30.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

y/a

Fy

H0

Fy

.G^rweF/RDY[qskNVaIweRThkVzGIWc#RiF`NOF/c/GIHia^RJzkVFHRzkVFc Luk B RTNVKhGIWnN8wWMG^zkVFf |MRTaIK m7 pTx/p.:)NVWMKC oDY DY[q07 N.:Vs y deRgUONVaIweRThkVz= NVh Nz wMWMHc/G^krW kVzh#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krW WMkVFf8NVaIG iRTK B=C c/dMRgUONVaIweRkVz tkVz(c/dMR8fwec/wNVaKMG^`!kra^RNOcSh/Ri`NOFNOc/G^krW oDYxDY[q07 B :VsNVabweRTh kVz 8UVRiFAh/wMh h#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krWWekVFfgNVaIG iRTK BDC c/dMRSU NVabweR kVz kVz.c/deRf wec/wMNVaKMGI`kraIR$NOc$h#Ri`NOFNOc/G^krW oDYU Wnc/deRS`a^kVc$s7 : o&D7 xx&: 6&B76: 9'B7)( :u`!krGIW=cKMG^`!kra^RVY

Page 51: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

Op

KMG^`!kra^R5f4kKeRTaewMh/GIWM$h#RiUVRiFANVaMKMG !RiF/RTW=cUONVaIweRTh.kVz#!nLG^c/d c/deRNO`M`abG^RTK|RTaIK `RiF`RTWKMGIHiwMaINOF c#kSc/deRNeGIh(kVz~h#Ri`NOFNOc/G^krWY1GIrweF/RDY z07 B :(hdekLh5c/deRJKMG^`!kra^R)f4krf4RTW=c/huL)deRTWgc/dMR)|MRTabKgGIhu`NOFNVaIaIRTaMc#kc/deRaIGIWMR kVz!HRTW=c#RiFhiY1.G^rwMF/RThUDY[q07 N.:uNVWMK DY[q07 B :h/dMkL c/dMRzkVFHRHkrf4`wMc#RTKgzF/krf(7\DY K9;:uNVh5N zwWMHc/G^krWkVzh#Ri`?NOFNOc/G^krW z kVF c/deR'`RiF`RTWKMGIHiwMaINOFJ|MRTabK NVWMK c/deRg`?NOFNVaIa^RTa(|MRTaIK\FRTh#`!RTHc/G^UVRTa C Ys(F/kUGIKeRTK c/deR|WMGIc#RSHiweF/F/RTW=cKMGIh#c#FAG B wec/G^krWhuNOF/Rh/w gHiG^RTW=c/a C a^kHiNVaIG iRTK]ec/deRKMG^`!kra^R f4krf4RTW=c/hNVWMKnc/deRSzkVFHRThzkVFB kVc/d HkrWe|MrweFANOc/G^krWMh NOF/R8WeRTNOFAa C GIKeRTW=c/GIHiNVa.c#kQc/dekrh/R4rG^UVRTW BDC c/deR8f wec/wMNVaKMGI`kraIRf4Ric/dekKY RNVaIh#k WekVc/GIHR)c/dMNOc(RiUVRTW'c/dekrwerdgc/deR|RTaIKgWeRTNOF5c/deR$h/weF/z NVHRkVzN h#`deRiF/R)GIh(WekVcuzwaIa C FRTh#kra^UVRTK LdeRTW 6D]c/deR$`NOF/c/GIHia^RJGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMh<NOF/R$L5RTaIa?NVHiHkrwWc#RTKQzkVFTY y deR$F/RTh/wa^c/h(`F/RTh#RTW=c#RTK'dMRiF/R$NOFR)zkVFC oDY )G^rdMRiF `RiFAf4RTN B GIaIGIc C FNOc/G^krhJL5RiF/R8NVaIh/knHkrWMh/GIKeRiFRTK B wec WekVcJ`a^kVc#c#RTK\deRiFRhGIWMHRc/deRF/RTaINOc/GIUVR RiF/F/kVFzkVF)N4HAdekrGIHRkVz \GIhWekVcN!RTHc#RTK B=C c/dMGIh FANOc/G^keY

y N B a^RtDYIxs y dMRf8NOrWMG^c/wKeRSkVzc/deR f8NOrWeRic/GIHKMG^`!kra^RSf4krf4RTW=ci]" ]?z kVF)RTNVHd B RTNVKGIWNVWnRTG^rd=c /B RTNVK HAdMNVGIW\L)G^c/d c/deR'HdMNVGIW NGbhNVaIGIrWeRTK LG^c/d\c/deR NO`M`?aIG^RTK |MRTabK] x NVWK ,xOY y deRKMG^`!kra^Ruf4krf4RTW=c/hNOF/R5Hkrf8`wec#RTKwMh/GIWMc/deR f wec/wMNVaDKMG^`!kra^R(f4Ric/dMkDKNVWMK c/deR5|WMG^c#R =KG^`!kra^Rf4Ric/dekKLG^c/dtUONOFG^krwh<U NVaIwMRTh kVz!.Y

j5RTNVK Zwec/wMNVaJG^`!kra^R 6Oo *o 6zOo x DY9MxTozV DY zVOp9o DY9rpVpzOpVp DY9MxVxipV DY9MxToK9qo DY[qVo p. DY zVoK99rp DY[qOp9V DY[qVoK9; DY[qVo89V DY[qVqOoVOp DY zzVxY9.z DY[qK9.Opr DY[qVqK9MxTz DY[qVq p.899 DY[qOoK9; DY zVqVqVOp DY[qzVoOqK9 DY[q89MxVxz DY[q pexTo

y N B a^RtDY[os y deRSf8NOrWMRic/GIHSzkVFHRThi] ]MkrWnRTNVHAd B RTNVKGbWQNVWnRTG^rd=c / B RTNVKHdNVGIWnLGIc/dtc/deRHdNVGIWNeGIh NVaIG^rWeRTK'LGIc/d c/dMRJNO``aIG^RTK |MRTaIK] 1xJNVWMK 1xOY y deRJz kVFAHRTh NOF/RSHkrf4`wec#RTKQwh/GIWe c/deRf wec/wMNVaKMGI`kraIR$f4Ric/dMkDKnNVWKtc/deRS|WMGIc#R =KMG^`!kra^RJf4Ric/dekKtLG^c/dQUONOFG^krwMh<UONVaIweRThkVz .Y

j5RTNVK Zwec/wMNVaJG^`!kra^R 6Oo *o 6zOo x pY VV pY[oxTo pz pY VVOpz pY VVVzK9 pY VOqVoo pY pzVVo pY p9MxToVVo pY pzVVq pY pzVVOp. pY pzVo pY pexY9.z pY pexip9oz pY pexxVx pY pexY9MxTo pY pexY9.xz9 pY pVpxVx pY pVproVo pY pVproV89 pY pVpOp.O pY pVpxVxz

_$KMKMG^c/GIkrWMNVaIa C ]ML5RdMNTUVR4HkrWMh/GbKeRiF/RTKdMkL1LuRTabac/deRfwMc/wMNVa |?WMG^c#R =KMG^`!kra^RSf8kDKeRTa~F/RTHklUVRiFhJc/deRKMG^`!kraINOF)GIWc#RiFANVHc/G^krWMhJGIW+N aIGbWeRTNOF$HAdMNVGIWkVz`NOF/c/GbHia^RThiY Wc/dMGIh)R NVf8`a^RV]!h/wMHiHRTh/h/GIUVR `?NOF/c/GIHia^RTh$NOF/RGIW4HkrW=c/NVHc5NVWK4c/deRHAdMNVGIW8GIhNVabG^rWeRTKLG^c/d8c/deRNO`M`aIGIRTK|MRTaIK]VLGIc/d CoJkVF" 1xOY y N B a^RDYIxh/deklLh~c/deR5KG^`!kra^R(f4krf4RTW=c/hz kVFRTNVHd B RTNVK GIWSc/dMR5HAdMNVGIWz kVF.NFANVWeVRukVzU NVaIwMRTh zkVF .YfekVFUONVaIweRTh

Page 52: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

x

kVz o)c/deR5F/RTh/wMaIc/GIWeKMGI`kraIR(f4krf4RTW=c/hHkrf4`NOF/R<L5RTaIa=LG^c/dc/dekrh#R5rG^UVRTW B=C c/dMR<f wec/wMNVaDKMG^`!kra^Rf4kKeRTa Y y k4k B c/NVGIWQNVWQNVHiHiweFNOc#R=wMNVW=c/G^|HiNOc/GIkrW kVz.f8NOrWeRic/GbH)zkVFHR krWtRTNVHAd B RTNVK]eh#RiR y N B a^R DY[oD]F/RTDwMG^F/RThNgf4kVF/R a^kHiNVaIG iRTKKGIh#c#FG B wec/G^krW'LG^c/dQUONVaIweRThkVz"! o z C G^RTaIKGIWeVk=kKnRTh/c/GIf8NOc#RThiY ch/dekrwaIK B R WekVc#RTKtc/dNOcc/deR fwMc/wMNVaKMG^`!kra^RJf4kKeRTa!wMWMKeRiF/RTh/c/GIf8NOc#RTh<c/deRSNVHc/wMNVa GIWc#RiFANVHc/G^krWtz kVFAHRThB Ric L5RiRTW4c/deR `NOFc/GIHia^RThKMweR<c#k c/deRWMRira^RTHckVzdG^rdeRiF / kVFKMRiF.GbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWRRTHc/hiY y dMGIh.GIhKMGIhHiwMh/h#RTKGIWtc/deRWeR Dch/RTHc/G^krWY

W ~vZ\]=c/deRFNOc/G^k !GIh(HAdekrh#RTW8c#kR D`?a^krG^cc/deR)h#RTa^z =GIWMKMwMHRTKUVRTaIkDHiG^c C kVzNS`NOF/c/GbHia^Rh/w B 2#RTHcc#k NVWR Dc#RiFAWMNVa B kDK C zkVFHR BDC f8NOc/HdMGbWe8c/deRaIkDHiNVa~h#`NOc/GINVaNUVRiFNOVR kVzc/dGIh |MRTaIKnc#k8c/deRh/Ric#c/aIGIWeUVRTa^kHiG^c C kVz(c/deR`NOFc/GIHia^R x Y y dMGbhh#`!RTHiG^|H HdMkrGIHRzweFc/deRiFJrG^UVRThJc/deR`MF/kV`!RiF B NVaINVWMHR B Ric L5RiRTWc/deR$LukVF gKekrWeR)krW c/dMR3SwGIK8NVWMK c/deR$UDGIhHkrwMhuKGIh/h/G^`?NOc/G^krWYBMkVF c/deR$f wec/wMNVa?|WMGIc#R =KMG^`!kra^Rf4kKeRTa ]c/deR h#RTa^z =GIWMKMwMHRTKQf8krf4RTWc$HiNVWWMkVc B RSR D`?a^krG^c#RTKNVWKf wMh#ci]?GbWQzNVHci] B R F/RTf4klUVRTKY_)h$N8FRTh/wMa^ci]c/deRiF/RGIhJWek'`MF/RizRiF/F/RTK+HdekrGbHR kVz ! NVWMK9G^c/h$UONVaIweRfgN CB RHdekrh/RTW9z kVF WDwMf4RiFGIHiNVaNVHiHiweFNVH C kVFRgHiG^RTWH C Y_)h GIWMHFRTNVh#RThi]!c/deR4KMG^`!kra^R f4krf4RTW=c/h NVWMK+c/deRz kVFHRThJrGIUVRTW B=C c/deR|WMG^c#R =KMGI`kraIRf4kKeRTa B RTHkrf4R'f4kVF/R NVHiHiwMFNOc#RV]dekL5RiUVRiFT]c/deR h#`NOc/GINVa(VFGIK\h/GiR f wMh#cKeRTHFRTNVh#R c#kF/RTh#kra^UVR c/deRf4kVF/RSaIkDHiNVaIGiRTK JNVwMh/hGINVWY y deRJVkrNVa~GIh c#kgHAdek=krh/RN4UONVaIweR c/dMNOcHkVFF/RTHc/a C F/Ri`MF/kKMwMHRTh<c/deR`krGbWcKMG^`!kra^R)GIWc#RiFANVHc/G^krWMh<we`'c#k NHRiF/c/NVGIWtKMGbh#c/NVWMHR B wecuFRT=wMGIF/RTh(N F/RTNVh#krWN B a^R)WDwMf B RiFukVzVFAGIKg`!krGIW=c/h`!RiF8`NOF/c/GbHia^RnFNVKMGbwMhiY W c/deR`MF/RiUG^krwMh8h#RTHc/GIkrW]<LuR+h/NTL c/dMNOcgc/dMRnz kVFAHRHkrf4`wMc#RTK wMh/GbWe c/deRf wec/wMNVaKMG^`!kra^Rf8kDKeRTa B RirGIWMhc#ktKG^UVRiF/VR z F/krf c/deRR eNVHc HiNVaIHiwMaINOc/G^krW9NOc N'h#Ri`NOFNOc/G^krW+kVzuc/deF/RiRFNVKMGbG Yn*G^c/dnUONVaIweRTh! o z p]c/dMRf wec/wMNVa|WG^c#R =KMG^`!kra^R f4kKeRTaF/RTh/kra^UVRThc/dMRzkVFHRNOc)c/dMGIhh#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krWY_)abh#ke]=L)G^c/d4c/dMGIh(FNVWeVR)kVzU NVaIwMRTh(kVz.]=c/dMRF/RTh/wa^c/GIWeSKMGI`kraIRf4krf4RTW=c/huNOVF/RiR DwMG^c#RL5RTaIaL)G^c/dgc/dMR$f wec/wMNVaKMG^`!kra^Rf8kDKeRTaNOc<NVW C h#Ri`NOFNOc/G^krWY y dMGIhuGIhuGbf4`!kVF/c/NVWcuz kVF<c/deRJGIWMHiabwMh/G^krW4kVzdMG^rdMRiFuf wMa^c/G^`!kra^RTh.c#k B RR!RTHc/G^UVR)L)deRTWgwMhGIWeSc/deR)`MF/kHRTKMweF/Rc/dMNOcuL)GIaIa B RKeRTh/HFAG B RTK8GIW X RTHc/G^krWDY DY[oDY

#&2 %' $ W4c/deRh#c/NVWMKNOFK8f wec/wMNVaMKMGI`kraIR5f4kKeRTa ]c/deRW=wf B RiFkVzRT=wNOc/G^krWMhGIW7\DY :.VF/klLh(NVh(c/deRW=wf B RiFkVz(`?NOF/c/GIHia^RThJGIWMHFRTNVh#RThiY_$W9NVKeU NVW=c/NOVR8kVzuc/deR|WMG^c#R =KMGI`kraIRf4kKeRTa.GIhJG^c/hJHkrf4`wec/NOc/G^krWNVahHiNVaINK/B GIabG^c C Y y kGbWMHiaIwMKeR4NVKMKG^c/G^krWMNVa B RTNVKMhi]~krWeRgWeRiRTKhSkrWMa C c#kNVKK c/deRgNVh/h/kDHiGINOc#RTK HiweF/FRTWcKMRTWMh/G^c CKMGIh/c#FG B wec/GIkrWkVzc/deRR c#FN B RTNVK4c#kSc/dMR RT=wMNOc/GIkrW8zkVFc/deR UVRTHc#kVF5`kVc#RTW=c/GINVa Y y kGIaIabwMh#c#FNOc#R<dekL c/deRHkrf4`wMc/NOc/G^krWMNVaHkrh#c$GbWMHF/RTNVh#RTh$NVh$LuRGIWMHF/RTNVh/Rc/deRW=wf B RiFkVz`?NOF/c/GIHia^RThi]?LuRHkrWMKMwHc#RTK+h/RiUVRiFNVah/GIf wMaINOc/GIkrWMhkVzc/deRJNOVVF/RirNOc/G^krWnkVz`NOFNVf8NOrWeRic/GbH B RTNVKMhuz FkrfN dekrf4kVVRTWeRikrwh<FNVWMKekrf h/wMh#`!RTW&/h/G^krW4GbWF/RTh#`!krWMh#R c#kNVW8R Dc#RiFWNVaMf8NOrWeRic/GIH|MRTaIKYD WgNVKMKMG^c/G^krW c#kSc/dMRf8NOrWeRic/GIHz kVFHRThLuRGbWMHiaIwMKeR

Page 53: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

Vo

100

101

102

103

104

100

101

102

103

N

Wal

l tim

e (s

econ

ds)

.G^rweF/RxDY ;sv5krf4`?wec/NOc/G^krWMNVac/GIf4RzkVF krWeR4d=wWMKeF/RTKc/GIf4R4h#c#Ri`hx7 xipVp :JNVhh#kDHiGbNOc#RTK9LG^c/dc/deR'fwec/wNVa|WMGIc#R =KMG^`!kra^R8f4kKeRTaNVhNnz wMWMHc/GIkrW\kVz c/deR'W=wMf B RiFkVz B RTNVKMhiY47 :f4RTNVh/wMF/RTK\L<NVaIac/GIf4RP7 x&: F 7:AY

d C KeFkDK C WMNVf8GbH)NVWMKh#kraIGIK B kK C HkrW=c/NVHczkVFHRTh

0)0/ < < )@4 7\DY :

_$hSKeRTh/HFG B RTK+c/deR8GbW`F/RiUDGIkrwMh HdMNO`c#RiFT]c/deRghweF/z NVHR zkVFHRgNOFR8KeRic#RiFf8GIWMRTK wMh/GIWe'c/deR4`NVGIF/LGIh#RHkraIaIGbh/G^krW B NOF/FG^RiFJNVWMK+c/deR4d C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIHGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhJNOF/R`MF/klUDGbKeRTK BDC v Z\Yh W+c/dMGIh$h/GIf wMaINK/c/G^krW]c/deR B krwMWMKMNOF C HkrWMKMG^c/GIkrWMhGIWRTNVHd'KMG^FRTHc/G^krW4NOF/R`!RiFG^kKMGIH5h#kNMkrweFG^RiF(Hkraba^kDHiNOc/GIkrW8f4Ric/dekKLG^c/dxY99 ? VFGIK8`!krGIW=c/h5GIh(wMh/RTKgc#k4h#kra^UVR$zkVFuc/deRJf8NOrWeRic/GbHUVRTHc#kVF`!kVc#RTW=c/GINVa Y y deR$d C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIHGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMh)NOF/RSrG^UVRTW B=C ~vZ NVWMKNxMkrweFG^RiF$HkraIa^kHiNOc/G^krWf4Ric/dMkDKQL)G^c/d Vq ? VFGbKQ`!krGIWc/h`MF/k/UGIKeRThc/dMR)h#kraIwMc/G^krW8c#k c/deR X c#k VRTh5RT=wMNOc/GIkrWMhiY_KMG !RiF/RTW=c(VFGIK h#`NVHiGIWMGIh5wMh#RTK8zkVF5c/deR)f8NOrWMRic/GIH|MRTaIKNVhkV`M`!krh#RTKQc#k c/deR SMklL6|MRTabKnh/GIWMHR c/dMRa^RTWeVc/dh/HiNVa^RSkVz.c/deR JNVwMh/h/GbNVWnGIWtc/deR|WMG^c#R =KMGI`kraIRf4kKeRTa!GIh5c L5kKc/dMG^FKh<c/dMNOc kVzB~vZ\Y_$h<c/deR B NOF/FAG^RiF<z kVFHRTh<UONVWMGIhd B R C krWMKth#Ri`?NOFNOc/G^krWQKMGIh/c/NVWMHRThkVz 2 )03,4 ]N'abGIWVRTK+aIGIh#c$NVa^VkVFG^c/dMf GIh$RTf4`?a^k C RTK9c#kQdMNVWMKa^RR HiG^RTWc/a C c/deR`NVG^F/L)GIh#RGbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMhiYy deR h/GbfwMabNOc/G^krW Gbh<FwMW'z kVFSxipVp8c/GIf4RTh#c#Ri`h<krWtc Luk'oDY9 t W=c#RTa$RikrWQ`MF/kHRTh/h#kVFh NVWKtc/deRJc/GIf4RWeRiRTKeRTK c#k we`KMNOc#R c/dMRnKMG^`!kra^R f8krf4RTWc/hgGIhF/RTHkVFKeRTKYy W c/deRQ|WMGIc#R =KMG^`!kra^R Hkrf8`wec/NOc/G^krWMhT](G^c

Page 54: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

x

z

µ

0H

µ µ0

a

ac

.G^rwMF/RDY[s y dMR c L5k B kDK C `MF/k B aIRTfQY

c C `GIHiNVaba C F/RTDwMG^F/RTKgo8/| G^c#RiFANOc/G^krWMhu`RiF5c/GIf4RTh/c#Ri`'zkVF5c/deR$fgNOrWeRic/GIH$KMG^`!kra^Rf4krf8RTWc/h5c#k4HkrWUVRiFVRVYy dMGbh(c/GIf8RJGbh(`aIkVc#c#RTKQGIW5.G^eYkDY =Y1 dMRTWtc/deRiF/R NOF/RJz RiL*`NOFc/GIHia^RThi]c/deR h/GIf wMaINOc/GIkrWgc/GIf8R)F/RTfgNVGIWMhHkrWMh#c/NVW=cJNVhc/deRc/GIf4RSFRT=wMGIF/RTKQc#k KGIh#c#FG B wec#R c/deRHiwMF/F/RTW=ch#krweFHRTh)krWnc/dMRVFGIKGIha^RThhc/dMNVWc/deR|RTKnc/GIf8RNVh/h#kHiGINOc#RTKLG^c/dnh/kra^UDGbWe8c/deRRT=wMNOc/GIkrWMhiY_$hL5R GIWHF/RTNVh#RSc/deR W=wf B RiFkVz B RTNVKMh)NVWMKc/deR Hkrf4`wMc/NOc/G^krWMNVac/GIf4R5F/RTDwMG^F/RTKc#kSKMGIh/c#FG B wec#R(c/deR h#krweFHRTh.R eHRiRTKMhc/deR h#kraIUVR5c/Gbf4RV]VLuR<k B h/RiF/UVRc/dMNOcc/dMRHkrf4`wec/NOc/GIkrWMNVaL5kVF 'hHiNVa^RThNVh F 7=:AY

)& )5!A- - 40 &')0

m$Wc/GIaeWMkLS]rL5RdMNUVRKMGIhHiwMh/h#RTK UONOFG^krwMhKMGI`kraIR5f4kKeRTaIh.c#kNVHiHkrwMWc(z kVFc/dMRf8NOrWeRic/GIH GbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMhkVz<`NOFNVf8NOrWMRic/GIH B RTNVKMhiYg_$hhdekLW GIW9|MrweF/RThtDYIx7 N.:SNVWMKyDY[o07 N.:A]c/deRgKMG^`!kra^Rf4kKeRTaIh `F/kUGIKeRF/RTaIGbN B a^RQRTh#c/GIfgNOc#RThgzkVF c/dMRGIW=c#RiF / `NOF/c/GbHia^RnzkVFHRTh NOc'aINOF/VRiFth#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrW KMGIh/c/NVWMHRTh B wMc B RTHkrf4RGIWMNVHiHiwMFNOc#R L)deRTW\c/deR'rNO` B Ric LuRiRTW `NOFc/GIHia^RTh GIha^RThhc/dMNVW dMNVa^z NFNVKMGIwhiY W c/dMGIhh#RTHc/G^krW].L5R`MF/RTh/RTWc5c/deR$R NVHc<c L5k/ B kDK C HiNVaIHiwMaINOc/GIkrWgzkVFuc/dMR)`NVGIF/LGIh#R)GIWc#RiFANVHc/G^krWgkVz `NOF/c/GIHia^RThTY y deRF/RThwMa^c/hLGIaba B Rc/deRTW9wMh#RTKc#ktGIWMHiaIwMKMRSc/deR RRTHc/hJkVz(dG^rdeRiF / kVFKMRiF$f wMa^c/G^`!kra^R c#RiFAf8hJGIWN F/Ri|WeRTK+KMG^`!kra^Rf4kKeRTa Y

2%' * % 0 4! $% ' v5krWMhGIKeRiFJc/deRVRTWeRiFNVa`F/k B a^RTf KeRTh/HFAG B RTKGIW AoDY tL)G^c/d oD] (7 p/p :A] A (7 p/p/p.:NVWMKc/deRNO``aIG^RTKnfgNOrWeRic/GIH|MRTaIKnFRTh#kra^UVRTK+GIWc#k'Hkrf4`!krWeRTW=c/h)`?NOFNVaIa^RTac#ktNVWMKkVF/c/dekVVkrWMNVac#k'c/deRaIGIWMRkVz HRTW=c#RiFhi]% < Y y deR$`MF/k B a^RTfGIh<KeRi`GIHc#RTK'GIW .G^eYUDY[ NVWMKtGIh B NVh#RTK'krW'c/dMNOc`!RiF/zkVFf4RTKgGbW qx Yf cuGIh5NVaIh#k Nh/`RTHiGI|HHiNVh#RJHkrWMh/GIKMRiF/RTKgGIW o Y_$h5h/c/NOc#RTK RTNOFAaIG^RiFT]=c/deR)h#krabwec/G^krW

Page 55: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

K9

c#k8c/dMGbh<`MF/k B a^RTf Gbh rG^UVRTW BDC Ngh/wMf%kVzh#`deRiFAGIHiNVa!dMNOFf4krWMGbHihiY1ekVFc/dGIh<`MF/k B aIRTf%LuRdNTUVR

+ :

:

7 Hkrh :DHkrh 7\DY V:

/ - <A:

:

:

7 Hkrh :

Hkrh 7\DY :

LdeRiFR 7 :)NOF/R c/deR h#`deRiFGbHiNVa HkDkVFKMGIWMNOc#RTh)kVz(N'h C h#c#RTf Ldekrh#RkVFG^rGIWHkrGIWMHiGIKeRTh)LG^c/dc/deRHRTW=c#RiFkVzh#`deRiFR Y y deRSNVh/h#kHiGINOc#RTK RiVRTWMKeF/RzwMWHc/G^krWMh NOF/RKMRi|WeRTKQNVh

7 Hkrh ;: 7 x:

7 x Hkrh A ;: A A

7 Hkrh ;: 7 Hkrh;: 7\DY9rp.:

WnkVFKMRiF)|WKQc/deRHkDRgHiG^RTW=c/h NVWMK

c/dMNOc)hNOc/GIh#z C'B krwMWKMNOF C HkrWMKMG^c/G^krWh7 oDY Op.:$NVWMK

7 oDY x:A]<LuRnf wMh#cR `MF/RTh/h c/deRQVRTWMRiFNVa h#kraIwec/GIkrW GbW c#RiFfghkVz$N9h/GIWMra^R'HkDkVFKMGbWMNOc#RQh C h/c#RTfQY y kNVHiHkrf4`abGIh/dtc/dMGIh<c/NVh ?]?LuR RTf4`?a^k C c/deR )k B h#krWQzkVFf wMaIN qxV]oLdMGIHAdQh#c/NOc#R

7 Hkrh :

: 7 x: 7 x:

< <

A

7 HkrhA: 7\DY9Mx:

7 HkrhA: A

: 7 x:

< <

7 Hkrh V: 7\DY9o:

<JW h/w B h#c/G^c/wec/GIWMnc/deRtVRTWeRiFNVa h#krabwec/G^krW GIWc#k9c/deR B krwMWMKNOF C HkrWMKMG^c/GIkrWMhi]NO`M`a C GIWec/deR k B h#krWzkVFfwaIN]MNVWMKQRTaIGbf8GIWMNOc/GIWM

L5RS|WMKtc/dNOcz kVFRTNVHd pTx

< <*x

<

A 7 x: ! % C' (? x ! %7\DY9.:

< <*x A

<

7 x: 7 x: ! % C' (? x ! %7\DY99;:j C GbWMHiaIwMKMGbWeSkrWMa C N|WMG^c#R WDwMf B RiF<kVz~f wMa^c/GI`kraIRThi]

*p ]7\DY9.: NVWK47\DY99;:<RTh#c/N B abGIh/d'c L5k

Page 56: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

z

o no aIGbWeRTNOFh C h#c#RTf8h kVz.RTDwMNOc/G^krWMhiY X `RTHiGI|HiNVaIa C ]zkVFRTNVHd *pTxSL5RWeRiRTKQc#k h#kra^UVR

A

7\DY9.z:

LdeRiFR

A 7\DY9q:

A A A A A 7\DY9;:

! ? 7 x C: /p /p % 7\DY9:

! ? 7#x C: /p /p % 7\DY9.:

NVWMKQc/dMR f8NOc#FGIHRTh)NOF/R

+ + < <*x 7\DY zOp.:

+ 7 x: + < < A + + 7\DY zx:

+ 7 x: + + 7\DY zVo:

_)z c#RiF$h#kra^UGIWezkVFc/deR ]ec/deRHkrW=c#FG B wMc/G^krWtkVz~c/dMRS|MRTaIKtzF/krf c/deR `?NOF/c/GIHia^RThGbWtc/deRSwMGIKtGIh

) :

:

7 <*x: 7 Hkrh : A

A :

7 x:

< <

7 Hkrh : Hkrh 7\DY z:

:

:

A 7 Hkrh V:

< A :

7 x:

< <

7 Hkrh : Hkrh 7\DY zK9;:

:

A h/GIW 7 Hkrh :< A

:7 x:

< <*x h/GbW 7 Hkrh : h/GIW 7\DY zz:

Page 57: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

Vq

5 10 15 20 250.34

0.36

0.38

0.4

0.42

0.44

0.46

L

F/µ

0

5 10 15 20 25 30 352

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

5

5.5

L

F/µ

0

.G^rweF/R DY sRTh/wMaIc/GIWe8NOc#c#FNVHc/G^UVRzkVFHRNVh$N zwMWHc/G^krWQkVzc/deR W=wMf B RiFkVzf wMa^c/G^`!kra^RThTY y deR|MRTaIKGIh NVaIGIrWeRTKQLG^c/dtc/dMRSaIGIWeRJkVz.HRTWc#RiFh$NVWMK % 1xOYUDY 07 N.:Vs8CoNVWMK DY 07 B :VsC6zDY

LG^c/d 7 Hkrh :

Hkrh 7 Hkrh ;: 7

< :

7 Hkrh;:

h/GbW 7\DY zVq:

W 7\DY z:a7\DY zz:A])c/dMRnHk=kVFKGIWMNOc#Rh C h#c#RTfGbh 7 :A] B wec8wh/GIWe9c/deR )k B h#krW zkVFf wMaIN]5c/deR|MRTaIKtHiNVWnNVabh#k B RJR `MF/RTh/h/RTKQGIW'c#RiFf8h kVz 7 A A :AY1*G^c/dtc/deR |RTaIK DWeklLW]c/deRZNDL5RTaIah#c#FRTh/hc#RTWMh#kVF]B7 oDY :A]HiNVW B R zkVFf4RTKNVWMKQc/deR zkVFHRGIhc/deRTW

) ) 7\DY z:

p 7\DY zV:

) ) 7\DY z:

y deRhGIf4`a^R5zkVFf1kVz?c/dMRNTGIf wec/dMNVaeKeRi`!RTWMKeRTWHR5kVzc/deR|RTaIKNVaIa^kL)hc/deRGIW=c#RiVFNOc/G^krW4klUVRiF gc#k B RRiUONVaIwMNOc#RTK4NVWMNVa C c/GIHiNVaIa C LdMGIaIR(c/deR<`!kra C Wekrf8GINVa=KeRi`!RTWMKeRTWMHR5kVzc/deR<|MRTabKkrW4HkrhJf8NVRTh JNVwMhh/GINVWGIW=c#RiVFNOc/G^krWQUGIN B aIR z kVFc/dMRSGIWc#RiVFANOc/G^krWnklUVRiF eY

W c/deR(HiNVabHiwMaINOc/G^krW]lc/deRuGbWe|WMG^c#R.h/wMfgf8NOc/G^krWSGIhc#FwMWMHiNOc#RTKNOc N |WMGIc#RU NVaIwMRV]YP c GIhGIf8`kVFc/NVWcc/dMNOc$c/dMGIhU NVaIwMR B RaINOF/VRRTWekrwerdc#k'GbWMHiaIwMKeR c/dMRGIf4`!kVF/c/NVW=c)f wMa^c/GI`kraIRThi] B wecWMkVc$h#k'aINOF/VRc/dMNOcc/deRJf8NOc#FG 'GIWUVRiFAh/G^krW B RTHkrf4RTh Hiwf B RiFh#krf8RVY .G^rwMF/RTheDY 07 N.:5NVWMK DY 07 B :5h/dekL*c/deR$UONVaIweR$kVzc/deR

Page 58: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

zkVFHRSNVhNz wMWMHc/G^krW'kVz B Ric L5RiRTWQc L5kgh#`dMRiF/RTh GIWtHkrWc/NVHc)LG^c/d'c/deRSNeGIh<kVz.h#Ri`NOFNOc/G^krWt`?NOFNVaIa^RTac#k9c/deRtNO`M`aIG^RTK |MRTaIK LG^c/d C o+NVWMK C zF/RTh#`!RTHc/G^UVRTa C Y *deRTW C oD]dNTUGIWe xipnF/RTh#kraIUVRThWeRTNOFAa C NVabac/deRgzkVFHR LdeRiF/R8NVh NnUONVaIweR4kVz oOpGIhWeRiRTKeRTK\c#k`MF/klUDGIKMR8c/deRh/NVf4Ra^RiUVRTakVz.NVHiHiweFNVH C G^zCC6zDY

-32 ' 0 4!* - ># ' 4 RdMNTUVRNVa^F/RTNVK C h#RiRTWc/dMNOcJNVhc Luk B kDKG^RTh Hkrf4RGIWc#k'HkrWc/NVHci]c/dMRSU NOFAG^krwMhKG^`!kra^RSf4kKeRTaIh z NVGIac#knrG^UVR NVW\NVHiHiweFNOc#R F/Ri`MF/RTh#RTW=c/NOc/G^krW kVzuc/deR f8NOrWeRic/GIHzkVFHR B Ric L5RiRTW Nn`NVG^F kVz<`NOF/c/GIHiaIRThiYR RV]c/deRiF/RizkVF/RV]uLukrwMabK aIG VR c#k\GIWHkVF/`!kVFNOc#R'dG^rdeRiFkVFKeRiF4f wMa^c/G^`!kra^RThc#k C G^RTabK HkVF/FRTHc4RTh#c/GIf8NOc#RTh4kVzc/deRSWeRTNOFHkrW=c/NVHczkVFHRVYk< WeR L5N C c#k NVHiHkrf4`aIGIhd c/dGIh GIh5c#kgHkrf4`wMc#R c/deR `NVG^F/L)GIh#R)GbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMhwMh/GbWeSNSdMG^rdMRiF(fwa^c/G^`!kra^R<F/Ri`MF/RTh/RTWc/NOc/G^krWgkVzc/deRGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWh p Yf*dMGIa^RHkrf8`wec/GIWe c/dMRz kVFAHRThc/dMGIhSL5N C LGIaIa.rG^UVR'Nnf4kVF/R'NVHiHiweFNOc#R'RTh#c/GIf8NOc/GIkrW kVz c/deRgWeRTNOFHkrW=c/NVHczkVFHRV].c/dMGIhSf8Ric/dekDK LGIaIaWekVc`MF/kKMwMHR4c/deR'HkVF/F/RTHcNVh C f8`Mc#kVc/GIH8FRTh/wMa^c/hz kVF Nf8NVW C / B kK C `MF/k B aIRTf LdeRiF/Rgc/deRg`NOFc/GIHia^RThNOF/R LGIKeRTa C h#Ri`?NOFNOc#RTKY$v5krWh#RT=wMRTWc/a C ]L5Rh#RiR nc#ktKeRiUVRTa^kV`9N'f4Ric/dekKnc/dMNOc B a^RTWMKhNVW B kDK CKMG^`!kra^R HiNVaIHiwaINOc/G^krW8c#kKeRic#RiFfgGIWeRc/deR)f8NVW C4B kK C GIWc#RiFANVHc/G^krWMh5NVWMK8c Luk/ B kK C ]DdG^rdeRiF(f wMa^c/G^`!kra^RHiNVaIHiwMabNOc/G^krWMh B Ric L5RiRTW `?NOF/c/GIHia^RTh4c/dNOcgNOF/Rh/w gHiG^RTW=c/a C HiaIkrh#RVY X wHd N\f8kDKeRTaLGIaIa5`MF/klUDGbKeRQc/deRWeRTHRTh/hNOF C NVK2#wMh/c/f4RTWc/hzkVF4c/deRnWeRTNOF8HkrW=c/NVHc GbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMhLdMGIaIR `MFRTh#RiF/UGIWe+c/deRQHkVF/F/RTHc8z NOF /|MRTaIKzkVFHRThJrG^UVRTW BDC c/deR4KMG^`!kra^RHkrf8`wec/NOc/G^krWY y deR f8Ric/dekDK+L5R`MF/kV`!krh#R c#ktGbWMHiaIwMKeRc/deR4WeRTNOF|MRTaIKf8NOrWeRic/GIH GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMh$GIh$KeRTh/HFG B RTKdeRiF/RHkrWMh/GIKeRiFAGIWe8NVW+RTWMh#RTf B a^RkVz h#`deRiFRThRTNVHd9kVz`!RiFf4RTN B GbaIG^c C \NVWMKQFNVKMGbwMh Y

J Q BI% &C E nLrCtIXCHG.@DCMI,J8EHLrN.G^Fh#ci]krWeRfwh#c)`!RiF/zkVFf c/deR/ B kK C KMG^`!kra^RHiNVaIHiwaINOc/G^krWk B c/NVGIWMGIWMgc/deR F/RTh/wMaIc/GIWegKMGI`kraIRSf4k/f4RTW=c/h NVWMK f8NOrWMRic/GIH8zkVFHRTh krW RTNVHd B RTNVK Y y dMGIh Hkrf8`wec/NOc/G^krW HiNVW B RgdNVWMKMa^RTKwMh/GbWeRTG^c/deRiF c/deRSf wec/wMNVaKMGI`kraIR)kVFc/dMRfwMc/wMNVa!|WMG^c#RY/ KG^`!kra^R)f4Ric/dMkDKQKeRi`!RTWMKGIWe krWQc/deRSHdMkrGIHRkVzc/deRwMh#RiFY y dMR`MF/kHRTKMweFRc#kQGIWMHiaIwKeRSc/deRdMG^rdeRiF)kVFKeRiF f wMa^c/G^`!kra^RThGbhVRTWeRiFANVaNVWK+NU NVGbaIN B a^Rc#k B kVc/dnf4Ric/dMkDKMhTY

J Q ;J EFN E 2 'X GIWHR<dG^rdeRiFf wMa^c/G^`!kra^RTh B RTHkrf4RGIf8`kVFc/NVWckrWMa C WeRTNOF(HkrW=c/NVHci]LuR)GIWc#FkDKMwHR=2 ' L)dMGIHd4KMRi|WeRThc/deR f8NeGIf wMf GbWc#RiF / B RTNVKh#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krWKMGIh#c/NVWMHR<LdMRiF/R5dG^rdeRiF.fwMaIc/G^`!kra^RThLGbaIa B R<GIWMHiaIwMKMRTKSGIW c/deRzkVFHRHiNVaIHiwaINOc/G^krWMhiY y dMRiF/Riz kVFRV]?NOzc#RiF$Hkrf4`?wec/GIWe8c/dMRKMG^`!kra^R GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWhi]krWeR fwh#c)KeRic#RiFAf8GIWeR

Page 59: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

V

G^z.N4`NVG^FkVz~`NOFc/GIHia^RThNOF/RHia^krh#RRTWMkrwerdnh/wMHAdnc/dMNOc)dMG^rdeRiFf wMa^c/GI`kraIRTh5hdekrwMaIK B RSHkrWMh/GbKeRiF/RTKY1 WkrweFJh/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWhc/dMGIh)GIh$dMNVWMKMa^RTKwMh/GIWMgN abGIWVRTKabGIh#c)NVaIVkVFG^c/dMf x c#ktNTUVkrGbK9`NVG^F/LGbh#RSHdeRTH DGbWekUVRiFJNVaIa :`NOF/c/GIHiaIRThNVWMKQHdMRTH GIWe GIz c/deRSh#Ri`?NOFNOc/G^krWKGIh#c/NVWMHR GIh a^RTh/hc/dMNVW 2 ' Y

J Q L D@PJ E L @BCMJ8E 1LC;OekVFRTNVHAd8`NVGIFL)dekrh#Rh#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krW4KMGIh#c/NVWHR<Gbha^RTh/h.c/dMNVW 2 ' LuR `!RiF/zkVFf@c/deR c Luk B kK C HiNVaIHiwaINOc/G^krW7\DY9.z:Sc#kKeRic#RiFfgGIWeR4c/deR8UVRTHc#kVFAh NVWMK A zkVF pTx8LdMGbHd\dekrabK c/deRgHkDRgHiG^RTW=c/hSzkVFc/deR fwa^c/G^`!kra^RThiYD Wnc/deR c L5k B kK C HiNVaIHiwaINOc/G^krW]ec/deRSNRThNOFRNVaIG^rWeRTKQhwMHdQc/dNOc

7\DY[qOp.:

7 : 7 : 7\DY[qx:

7\DY[qVo:

7\DY[q:

h#k

7\DY[qK9;:

7\DY[qz:

y dMGbh8HiNVaIHiwMaINOc/GIkrW HiNVW `RiFz kVFf8RTK krW c/dMR S C NOcgRTNVHAd c/GIf4Rh#c#Ri` ]NVh WeRiRTKMRTK]h/GIWMHRkrWMa C c L5ko o aIGIWeRTNOF(h C h#c#RTfgh(WeRiRTK4c#k B Rh#kra^UVRTK8zkVFRTNVHAdg`NVGIFT]NVWMK 1xip zkVFCo NVWMK oOpzkVF=C6zDY

J Q @BO$JxJ L% A1L DE 1LC yL NJORJ8L>EFNPG.CF@ |I % &C ;GJ8O

j5Riz kVFRHkrf4`wec/GIWM$c/dMRGIWc#RiF`NOF/c/GIHia^R5zkVFHRV]rL5R |MFh#cf4kKMG^z C c/deR KMG^`!kra^R<HkDRgHiG^RTW=c/hz Fkrf1c/deR c L5kB kDK C HiNVaIHiwMaINOc/G^krWh ? A NVWMK ? A c#k GIWMHiaIwKeR8z NOF / |MRTaIK RRTHc/hTY y dMGIhNVaIa^klLhGIWezkVFf8NOc/G^krWzF/krf c/deR z NOF / |MRTaIKnc#kgGIW0SwMRTWMHR)c/dMRSc L5k/ B kDK C zkVFHRHiNVaIHiwaINOc/G^krWY *G^c/dQc/deRSFRTaINOc/G^krWMh

? 0+ 9 ? 7\DY[qVq:

? 0+ 9 ? 7\DY[q:

Page 60: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

L5RKeRic#RiFf8GbWeRJc/deRWeRiL6KG^`!kra^R$HkDRgHiG^RTW=c/h

? A < ? 0+ ?A 0+ 7\DY[qV:

zkVFgRTNVHd pTxOY6 W 7\DY[qV:A] ? A @+ GIh4rG^UVRTW BDC N KMG^`!kra^RQHiNVaIHiwMaINOc/GIkrW LdeRiFRQkrWMa C c/deRGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMh.kVz?c/deR<c L5k B kDKMGIRTh~NOF/RHkrWh/GIKeRiF/RTKY y dMGbh UONVaIweR HkVF/F/RTh/`krWKMh c#k c/dMR5krwMc#RiFR D`NVWh/G^krWkVzc/dMRGIWMWeRiF.h#kraIwec/GIkrW NVWK Gbh~c/dMR kUVRiFaINO`4kVzc/deR<c L5kh#krabwec/G^krWMh~c/dMNOcf wMh#c B R5h/w B c#FNVHc#RTK4c#k NTUVkrGbKG^c B RTGIWe4HkrwMW=c#RTKnc LGIHRVY

J ' Q ;J EFN J ;O8@BCMJ8EFN C

*G^c/d\c/deR'f4kKMG^|MRTK HkDRgHiG^RTW=c/h L5R WMkL%KeRic#RiFf8GIWMR8c/deR8|MRTabK GIW c/dMR SwMGbK9`dMNVh#R7\DY z:a

7\DY zz:AYk WtVRTWeRiFANVa ]ekrWeRSWeRiRTKMhc#k8NVKMKtc/deR krweckVz`aINVWMR$Hkrf4`!krWeRTW=c kVzc/deRS|MRTaIKtKMwMR$c#kgc/deR krweckVz.`aINVWeR Hkrf4`!krWeRTW=ckVzc/deRKMGI`kraIR$f4krf8RTWczF/krf c/dMR zNOF / |RTaIKQHiNVaIHiwMaINOc/GIkrW

9 ?

7 Hkrh;:Dh/GIW A 7\DY[q:

J Q BL IrN 0IXCF@BI0J J I CFCUO$J;OOxJ NBOL#<JWMHR c/dMRSHkrf4`!krWeRTWc/hkVzc/dMR |MRTaIKQNOF/R zkrwMWMK]c/deRZNLuRTaIa h#c#F/RTh/h c#RTWh#kVFt7 oDY :HiNVW B RJKMRic#RiF /f8GIWMRTKQNVWMKtRiU NVabwMNOc#RTKnklUVRiF)c/deRShweF/z NVHRSkVz~RTNVHAd`?NOF/c/GIHia^RJc#k8k B c/NVGbWQc/deRSzkVFHR57 oDY K9;:A] ? A Y

J rQ L!GJxJ JL,JIrC yI rN ;J8EHG ]LKG y deRJc#kVc/NVaf8NOrWMRic/GIHJz kVFAHR$krWQNrGIUVRTWt`NOF/c/GIHia^RJf wMh#c WekL B RJNVKK2/wMh#c#RTK'c#k4F/Ri`aINVHRJc/deR f8NOrWMRic/GIHzkVFHR B Ric L5RiRTWn`NOFc/GIHia^RTh NVWMKL)G^c/dtc/deRHkVF/FRTHc#RTKnzkVFHR ? A Y y deR c#kVc/NVazkVFHRGIh

0+ <

A 0+ :A 7\DY p.:

0+

A < 0+ :A 7\DY Dx:

LdeRiFR 0+ :A GIh<c/dMRKMG^`!kraINOF<zkVFHR B Ric L5RiRTWn`NOFc/GIHia^RTh NVWMK=Y

#&'$% 2&y k4c#RTh#c c/deRJRRTHc/GIUVRTWeRTh/h kVz~c/dMGIh5`MF/kHRTKMweF/RV]L5R HkrWMh/GIKeRiF h#RiUVRiFANVac/deF/RiRY/ `NOFc/GIHia^R HkrWe|MrweFANOc/G^krWMhLG^c/dtKMG RiF/RTW=c<U NVabweRTh<kVzCC Y y L5k/ `NOF/c/GbHia^R `MF/k B aIRTf8huNOFRSWekVcHkrWMh/GIKMRiF/RTKth/GIWMHRJc/deRSGIWHiaIwMh/G^krW

Page 61: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

9rp

2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 30.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

1.1

1.2

x/a

F

H0

F

2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 30.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

1.1

z/a

F

H0

F

.G^rweF/R DYIxip&sekVFAHRgkrW N B RTNVK\KMweR4c#k+NnKekrw B aIRic LG^c/d C %oDY y deR8KMNOc/NNOF/RgWekVFfgNVaIG iRTKBDC c/deRgU NVaIwMR4kVz5c/dMR8R NVHc h#kraIwec/GIkrW NOcHkrWc/NVHciYDYIxip,7 N.:Vs y deR8NO``aIG^RTK+|MRTaIK Gbh `!RiF/`!RTWMKMGIHiwMabNOFc#k'c/deR h/Ri`NOFNOc/G^krW+NGbhiYDYIxip,7 N.:Vs y deR NO`M`aIG^RTKn|MRTaIK+GIh`NOFANVaIa^RTac#k'c/deRh#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrWNeGIhiY3 Wc/deR`a^kVc/hs57 :$c L5k B kK C HiNVaIHiwaINOc/G^krWe7 &:Sfwec/wNVaKMG^`!kra^RU76:JGIWMHiabwMh/G^krW9f4kKeRTa e7)( :R eNVHc)h#kraIwMc/G^krWY

Page 62: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

9Mx

`MF/kHRTKMweFRV]KeRThHFG B RTKN B kUVRV]~NVa^F/RTNVK C rG^UVRThJR eNVHc F/RTh/wa^c/hzkVFJc/deRGIWc#RiF`NOF/c/GIHia^Rz kVFAHRVY ekVF c/deRc/deF/RiR B kK C `MFk B a^RTf8hi]=c/deR GIW=c#RiF/`NOF/c/GIHiaIR)zkVFHRTh NOF/R Hkrf4`wMc#RTKQGIWgc/wMFW'z F/krf c/deR f wec/wMNVa!KMG^`!kra^Rf4Ric/dekK]N Hkrf B GIWMNOc/G^krW kVzhGIf4`a^R`NVG^F/LGbh#Rnc L5kK B kDK C HiNVaIHiwMabNOc/G^krWMh pJNVWK c/dMR+GIWHiaIwMh/G^krWf4kKeRTa Y y dMRTh#R F/RTh/wMaIc/hQNOF/R Hkrf4`NOFRTKc#k c/deR\R eNVHcnzkVFHRThiY y deR9F/RTh/wMaIc/hQkVzc/dMR\c L5kK B kDK CHiNVaIHiwMabNOc/G^krWgNOF/R)k B c/NVGIWeRTK B=C hwMf8f8GIWM c/deRzkVFHRThuz F/krfc/deR)c L5k/ B kK C HiNVaIHiwaINOc/G^krW8zkVF(RTNVHAd'`NVG^FGIW c/weFW p Y1.G^rweF/RTh DYIxip,7 N.:<NVWMK_DYIxip,7 B :5h/dMkL c/deRJz kVFHR$krWtN B RTNVK'KMweR$c#k NHkraIabGIWeRTNOF(`?NVG^FukVzB RTNVKMh(GbW8HkrWc/NVHciY y deRNeGIhkVzh/Ri`NOFNOc/G^krW GIhNVaIG^rWMRTK8LG^c/d8c/deRNeGIhkVzc/deR)Kekrw B a^Ric(`NVG^F(NVWMKgc/deRNO`M`abG^RTK f8NOrWeRic/GIH8|MRTaIK GIh c/NVRTW GIW9c/weFAW c#k B R4`!RiF/`!RTWMKMGIHiwMabNOF$NVWMK\`NOFNVaIa^RTa.c#kc/dMGIhSKMGIF/RTHc/G^krWYy deRfgNOrWeRic/GIH h/wMhHRi`Mc/G B GIabG^c C GIh" 1x NVWMK C oDYf deRTW8c/deRf8NOrWeRic/GIH|MRTaIKGIhNVaIG^rWMRTKLG^c/dc/deRgNeGIhkVz5c/dMRgc/deF/RiRY/ `?NOF/c/GIHia^RgHAdMNVGIW c/dMRgF/RTh/wa^c/h kVz<c/deRgGIWHiaIwMh/G^krW9f4kKeRTaNOVFRiR L5RTaIaLGIc/d c/deRR eNVHcUONVaIweRThiY_ W\c/dMGbhSHkrWe|MrweFANOc/G^krW]c/deRgzkVFHRTh NOF/R NOc#c#FNVHc/GIUVRtNVWK\c/deR'NOVF/RiRTf4RTW=c GIWKMGIHiNOc#RThdeklL6L5RTaIac/deR f4kKeRTaIhHiNVWHdMNOFNVHc#RiFAG iRc/dMR C G^RTaIK B RTdMNUDG^kVFkVzc/deRHAdMNVGIWh/c#FwMHc/weF/RThHkrf8f4krWMa CzkrwMWMK+GIW+Z SwMGbKMhiY*deRTW+c/deR|MRTaIKGIh$`RiF`RTWKMGIHiwMaINOF c#k'c/deR4HdNVGIW]c/deRz kVFHRThJNOF/RF/Ri`?wMaIh/G^UVRNVWMK c/deRg`NOFc/GIHia^RThSc#RTWK\c#k9h#Ri`NOFNOc#RVY y deR8RiF/F/kVF zF/krf,c/deR'GIWMHiaIwh/G^krW f4kKeRTaGIhh/f8NVaIauNVWMK GbhNh/G^rWG^|HiNVW=cGIf4`MF/klUVRTf4RTW=c kUVRiF$c/deRSRTh#c/GIfgNOc#RThzF/krf c/deRSkVc/dMRiF)f4Ric/dekKMhiYn Wt|MrwMF/RThDYIxVx7 N.:)NVWMKDYIxVx7 B :A]?c/deRh/NVf4R B RTNVKQHkrWM|MrweFNOc/G^krWhNOF/RwMh/RTK] B wec WeklL&C 6zDY

y dMR'c#FRTWMKMh4GIW c/deRnKGIh/HF/Ri`NVWHiG^RThGIW c/deRnKMG !RiF/RTWMHRTh B Ric L5RiRTW c/dMRnf4kDKMRTaIhNVWMK c/deRQR eNVHcHkrf4`wMc/NOc/G^krWMh NOF/R4c/deR8hNVf4Rz kVF B kVc/d9`!RiFf4RTN B GbaIG^c C FANOc/G^krh B wec f4kVF/R8KMFNVf8NOc/GIHGIW+c/deR4HiNVh#R8kVzC6zLdeRiFR$c/dMRSdMG^rdeRiF f wMa^c/G^`!kra^RThuNOF/RSf4kVF/RSGIW,SweRTW=c/GINVa YP WtRTNVHdHiNVh#RV]Mc/deRSf wec/wMNVa!KMG^`!kra^Rf4Ric/dekK4`!RiF/zkVFf4RTKL5RTaIaeNOc(aINOFVRh#Ri`NOFNOc/G^krWhi] B wMc.KG^UVRiF/VRTK4zF/krf c/deR R eNVHc(zkVFHRWMRTNOF(HkrWc/NVHciYX GIf8`a C NVKMKMGIWMc/deR'z kVFAHRThz F/krf `NVGIF/LGIh#Rgc L5kK B kK C HiNVaIHiwMaINOc/G^krWhrGIUVRTh N B Ric#c#RiF4RTh#c/GIfgNOc#R'kVzc/deR4zkVFHR8WeRTNOFHkrW=c/NVHcNVWK NtVk=kK RTh#c/GIfgNOc#R8NOcSNVW C h#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrW LdeRTW9c/deR8HAdMNVGIW NeGIh GIhJ`!RiF /`!RTWMKMGIHiwaINOFc#kQc/deRNO`M`aIGIRTK|MRTabKY y dMGIh$f4Ric/dekK+KMk=RThi]deklLuRiUVRiF] h/w !RiFJz F/krf WekVc B RTGIWe'N B a^R c#k`MF/klUDGbKeRgNVW NVHiHiweFNOc#RQHdMNOFANVHc#RiFG TNOc/G^krW kVz c/deR'zNOF^/ |MRTaIK zkVFHR'LdeRiF/R c/deR HAdMNVGIW NGIhGIhNVabG^rWeRTKLG^c/d c/deRtNO`M`aIGIRTK |MRTaIKY ekVF4c/deRtdMG^rdeRiF`!RiFf4RTN B GIabG^c C FNOc/G^ke]c/dMR F/RTabNOc/G^UVR RiFF/kVF NOc4HkrW=c/NVHc8GIhh#c/GIabaaINOF/VRgNOcgxz 7F.G^rweF/R DYIxVx7 B : :AY_ W RTNVHAd kVz c/dMRTh#R8c/deF/RiR `?NOF/c/GIHia^RgHkrWM|MrweFNOc/G^krWhSNVWMK zkVFB kVc/d+`RiFAf4RTN B GIaIGIc C FNOc/G^krhi]L5R h/RiR c/dMRGbWMHiaIwMh/GIkrWQkVzc/deR4dMG^rdMRiF$f wMa^c/G^`!kra^RThz Fkrf c/deRc Luk B kK CHiNVaIHiwMabNOc/G^krW LG^c/d c/deRQf8NVW C / B kDK C KMG^`!kra^Rgf8kDKeRTa5`MFkUGIKeRThc/deRtz kVFHRQRTWdMNVWMHRTf4RTW=c4WeRiRTKeRTK c#kF/RTh#kraIUVR'c/dMR'WeRTNOF8HkrW=c/NVHc8GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhL)dMGIa^RgNVabh#kRTWh/weFGIWMc/deR'`MF/kV`!RiFNVh C f8`Mc#kVc/GIH B RTdMNTUG^kVFNVhJc/deRh#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrW+GbWMHF/RTNVh#RThiY<$z(c/deRzkrweF HiNVh#RTh HkrWMhGIKeRiF/RTK+deRiF/RV]!c/deR4aINOF/VRTh/c$FRTaINOc/G^UVR RiF/F/kVF GIhNO`M`MFk eGIf8NOc#RTa C z 7F.G^rweF/RDYIxVx7 B : :AY

y dMR GIWHiaIwMh/G^krWf4kDKMRTa~f8N CnB R NO``aIG^RTKc#k'c/dMRR eNVf4`a^R kVz(NtHkraIaIGbWeRTNOF)HAdMNVGIW+kVzRTG^rd=cJ`NOFNK/

Page 63: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

9o

2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 30.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

x/a

F

H0

F

2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 30

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

z/a

F

H0

F

.G^rweF/R DYIxVxsekVFAHRgkrW N B RTNVK\KMweR4c#k+NnKekrw B aIRic LG^c/d C zDY y deR8KMNOc/NNOF/RgWekVFfgNVaIG iRTKBDC c/deRgU NVaIwMR4kVz5c/dMR8R NVHc h#kraIwec/GIkrW NOcHkrWc/NVHciYDYIxip,7 N.:Vs y deR8NO``aIG^RTK+|MRTaIK Gbh `!RiF/`!RTWMKMGIHiwMabNOFc#k'c/deR h/Ri`NOFNOc/G^krW+NGbhiYDYIxip,7 N.:Vs y deR NO`M`aIG^RTKn|MRTaIK+GIh`NOFANVaIa^RTac#k'c/deRh#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrWNeGIhiY3 Wc/deR`a^kVc/hs57 :$c L5k B kK C HiNVaIHiwaINOc/G^krWe7 &:Sfwec/wNVaKMG^`!kra^RU76:JGIWMHiabwMh/G^krW9f4kKeRTa e7)( :R eNVHc)h#kraIwMc/G^krWY

Page 64: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

9.

y N B a^R DY s y dMRF/RTh/wa^c/NVWc$f8NOrWeRic/GIHz kVFAHRThi]# O]krWRTNVHd B RTNVKGIWNVWRTG^rd=c / B RTNVKHAdMNVGIWLG^c/dc/deR'HdMNVGIW NGbhSNVaIG^rWeRTK LG^c/d\NVW NO`M`aIGIRTK9|MRTaIK kVzwMWG^cSf8NOrWMG^c/wKeRV] xOY y deR8zkVFHRTh NOF/RHkrf4`wMc#RTK wMhGIWeKMG RiF/RTW=cuf8kDKeRTabh(KeRTh/HFAG B RTK8deRiF/RVYn<JWMa C c/dMR)zkVFHRThukrW B RTNVKMh)xV.94NOF/R`MFkUGIKeRTKh/GIWHR c/deR z kVFAHRThkrW zDgNOF/RSRTDwMNVaNVWMKtkV`M`!krh/GIc#R c#k8c/deRTh#RSUONVaIweRThTY

juRTNVK G DRTKnJG^`!kra^R Zwec/wMNVaJG^`!kra^R y L5kgj5kDK C WHiaIwMh/G^krWQZRic/dekK E eNVHcx pY xTzK9rp pY VV pY9q pY zxY9.zK9. pY zOp.o pY proVV pY pzVVo pY proK9o pY prqK9.Op pY pzVqVoK9 pY pVpzVozV pY pexY9.z pY pVpzVo pY pexzOpz pY pexVqOp9 pY pVpexVxzOp pY pVpxVx pY pVpexVxz pY pVpVoVqOp pY pVpOpzVo

f8NOrWeRic/GbH B RTNVKMh4GIW HkrW=c/NVHci] `MF/RiUG^krwMh/a C HkrWMh/GIKeRiFRTK GIW h#RTHc/G^krW DY[oDY[oD] L)G^c/d c/deRnNO`M`abG^RTK |MRTaIKNVaIG^rWMRTK LG^c/d c/deRnHdNVGIWY y deRtF/RTh/wa^c/NVWc4f8NOrWMRic/GIHQzkVFHRTh4krW RTNVHAd `NOF/c/GbHia^RQGIW c/deRnHdMNVGbW NOF/RRiUONVaIwMNOc#RTKnwMhGIWe c/deRSKMG !RiF/RTW=cf4Ric/dekKMh NVWMKQaIGIh/c#RTKQGIW y N B aIRDY DY y deRJF/RTh/wa^c/h NOF/RSHkrf4`NOFRTKQc#kc/deR R NVHcUONVaIweRThiY y dMRgGIWMHiaIwh/G^krW9`MF/kHRTKMweFR8`MF/klUDGIKMRThNVk=kK DwMNVW=c/G^|HiNOc/G^krW kVz c/deRgzkVFHR'krWRTNVHd`NOF/c/GIHiaIR$FRTh#kra^UGIWe c/deRSwMWMKeRiFRTh#c/GIf8NOc#R NVh/h#kHiGINOc#RTKQL)G^c/d'c/deRSfwMc/wMNVaKMG^`!kra^R$f4Ric/dekKQNOcc/deRRTWMK]NVWMK c/deRg`NVG^F/LGbh#Rc L5k/ B kK C HiNVaIHiwMabNOc/G^krW\GIW c/dMRgf8GIKMKa^RVY y deR8NOc#c#FNVHc/GIUVR'f8NOrWMRic/GIH4zkVFHRB Ric L5RiRTWNVW C c Luk B RTNVKMh GIWtc/deRSHAdMNVGIWnGIh<rGIUVRTW B=C h/wMfgf8GIWe c/deR F/RTh/wa^c/NVWc zkVFHRThz F/krf%c/dMRSRTWMKkVz c/deR'HdMNVGIWY y deRgNOc#c#FNVHc/GIUVR'zkVFHR'GIhh#c#FkrWeVRTh#c B Ric LuRiRTW c/deR c L5k B RTNVKMhT]~WDwMf B RiFh9NVWMK zD]NOc c/deR'HRTW=c#RiF4kVzc/deRtHdNVGIW NVWK KMGbf8GIWMGIhdeRThJc#kL<NOFKMhc/deR RTWMKMhiY ch/dekrwaIK B R WMkVc#RTK c/dNOczkVFc/dMGIh(h#`!RTHiG^|HHkrWe|rweFNOc/G^krWgc/deRF/RThwMa^c/NVW=cz kVFAHR)GIW4c/dMR)f8GIKKMa^R<kVzc/deR)HAdMNVGIW GIh(KekrfgGIWMNOc#RTK BDC c/deRKMG^`!kra^RJGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhTY

y dMR5GIWHiaIwMh/G^krWf4kDKMRTa`!RiF/zkVFf8h R HRi`Mc/GIkrWMNVaIa C L5RTaIa=LdeRTWc/deR5`NOF/c/GIHia^RThNOF/R KMGIh/c#FG B wec#RTKNVa^krWeN aIGIWMRVYsFk B a^RTf8hQNOFGbh#RV]$dMkL5RiUVRiFT] LdeRTW c/deR\HkrWe|rweFNOc/G^krWGIhQWMk a^krWeVRiFnHkraIaIGbWeRTNOFTY y deRTh#RHkrWe|MrwMFNOc/G^krWMhJNOF/R `MF/RTh#RTW=c NOc dMG^rdUVkraIwMf4R z FANVHc/G^krWMh kVFJLdeRTW+c/deRh/wMh#`!RTWMh/GIkrWGIh$h/w B 2#RTHcc#k9NnFNO`GbKMa C F/kVc/NOc/GIWe|MRTaIK Y W .G^rweF/R DYIxToD](Nc#FAGINVWerwMaINOFHkrWe|MrweFNOc/GIkrW GIhh/w B 2#RTHcc#k9NwMWMGIz kVFf:|MRTaIKY y deRtz kVFAHRTh4NOF/RQNOc#c#FNVHc/G^UVRVY y deRtF/RTh/wa^c/hNOFRnHkrf4`NOF/RTK LGIc/d c/dMR'R eNVHc4zkVFHRc/NVRTWz F/krf o Yk Wc/dMGIhHiNVh#RV]c/deR 9rp RiF/F/kVF$GIWtc/deRz kVFHRNOc)HkrW=c/NVHcJGbh F/RTKMwMHRTKc#kxip LG^c/dc/deRGbWMHiaIwMh/GIkrW'f8kDKeRTa Yu_$a^c/dekrwerdQc/dMRGIWMHiaIwh/G^krWtf4kKeRTa`MF/klUDGbKeRThN B Ric#c#RiFJNO`M`MF/k GIfgNOc/G^krWQkVz.c/deRzkVFHR c/dMNVWtc/deR kVc/deRiFf8kDKeRTabhi]eG^c/h<`!RiF/z kVFAf8NVWMHRJGIh WekVc NVh VkDkDKQNVhGIc5L<NVh GIW'c/deR `MFRiUDG^krwh5HiNVh/RThiYE c#RTWMKMGbWe)c/dMR5z NOF / |MRTabKHiNVaIHiwaINOc/G^krW c#kSGIWMHiaIwKeRuDwMNVKeFwM`kraIR(f4krf4RTW=c/hf8N CB R5NJL<N C c#kSGIf4`MFkUVRc/dMGIh<FRTh/wMa^ciY

Page 65: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

99

2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 30

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

c/a

F

H0

F

.G^rweF/RDYIxTosUMkVFHR krWQN B RTNVK'GbW'N c#FGbNVWerwMaINOF<NOF/FNVWeVRTf8RTWciY y deR HkrWe|MrweFNOc/GIkrW'Gbh5KMRi`GIHc#RTKtGIWc/deRKMFNTLGbWe8LG^c/dnc/deR B RTNVKGIW=weRTh/c/G^krWnGIWMKGIHiNOc#RTKY y deRKMNOc/N NOF/RWekVFAf8NVaIG iRTK BDC c/deRSUONVaIweRSkVzc/deRJR eNVHch#kraIwec/G^krW'NOc HkrWc/NVHciY y deR$R eNVHcHkrf4`wec/NOc/G^krWtGIh5`MFkUGIKeRTK B=C o Yf W'c/deRJ`aIkVc$se7 :c L5k B kDK C HiNVaIHiwMabNOc/G^krWh7 tt&:f wec/wMNVaKMG^`!kra^Rr76:GbWMHiaIwMh/GIkrW4f4kDKMRTa 7)( :R NVHc h#krabwec/G^krWY

Page 66: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

9.z

4:, !

y deR$`weF`krh/R)kVz~c/dMGIh<h#c/wMK C GIh5c#kKMRiUVRTa^kV`nNf4Ric/dekKtc#k RTh/c/GIf8NOc#RSNVHiHiweFNOc#RTa C NVWMK'RgHiGIRTWc/a C c/deRf8NOrWeRic/GbH)zkVFHRTh B Ric L5RiRTWt`NOFNVf8NOrWMRic/GIH$`NOF/c/GIHia^RThuc/dMNOc GIh5NO`M`aIGbHiN B a^RzkVF h C h/c#RTf8h<kVzc/dekrwMhNVWMKMhkVz `?NOF/c/GIHia^RThiY_$WtNVHiHiweFNOc#RSDwMNVWc/GI|HiNOc/G^krW'kVz c/deR GIW=c#RiF/`NOFc/GIHia^RzkVFHRTh GIh<WeRTHRThh/NOF C c#k4KeRic#RiFAf8GIWeRc/deRFdeRikraIkVrGIHiNVa.`MF/kV`!RiF/c/G^RTh$kVz<Z SwMGIKMhkVFSc/deR`!RiF/zkVFf8NVWMHR kVz5fgGIHF/k/aSwMGbKMGIHSKeRiUGIHRThi]L)deRiF/RwMWMh/c#RTNVK C f8NOrWeRic/GIH|MRTaIKhgkVFth/deRTNOF_SMklLh GbWc#F/kKMwMHRUDGbh/HkrwMh'h#c#F/RTh/h#RTh krW c/deR9h#RTa^zM/ NVh/h#RTf B a^RTKHdNVGIWMhiY _)HiHiwMFNOc#RTa C KeRTh/HFG B GIWe+c/deR C GIRTaIK h#c#F/RTWeVc/d NVWK KeRiz kVFAf8NOc/G^krW kVz$c/deRnh#c#FwMHc/wMF/RtLdMGIa^RHkrWMh/GbKeRiFGIWe9N aINOF/VRnWDwMf B RiF4kVz)`NOFc/GIHia^RThNOF/RWeRTHRThh/NOF C c#k KeRic#RiFf8GbWeR c/dMRn`MF/kV`!RiF/c/G^RTh kVz$c/deRB wMa h/wMh/`RTWh/G^krWY

Wtc/deR `MF/RTHRTKGIWe4h#RTHc/G^krWMhT]eLuRSdMNUVRS`MF/RTh/RTWc#RTKQNVWMKQKMRTh/HFG B RTKtN|WMG^c#R =KG^`!kra^R)f4kKeRTaLdMGbHdF/RTh#kraIUVRThc/deR f8NVW C / B kK C KMG^`!kra^RSGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMh$GIW+Z SwMGbKMhiYk Wc/dMGIhf8kDKeRTa ]c/deR GIWMKMwMHRTKf8NO/WeRic/G TNOc/GIkrWkVz(N `NOF/c/GbHia^RGIh)F/Ri`MF/RTh/RTWc#RTK+NVhJNga^kHiNVaIG iRTK JNVwMh/h/GbNVWKMGbh#c#FG B wMc/G^krWtkVzHiweF/F/RTW=ci]LG^c/dHdNOFNVHc#RiFGIh#c/GbHQa^RTWeVc/d h/HiNVa^R .]uc/dMNOcgGIh c/deRTW N h/krweFHRQc#RiFfGbW c/dMRns~krGbh/h#krW RTDwMNOc/G^krW zkVF8c/deRUVRTHc#kVF$`kVc#RTW=c/GINVakVz.c/deRSfgNOrWeRic/GIH |MRTabKY y dMGIh<RTDwMNOc/G^krWHiNVW B R h#kra^UVRTKwh/GIWe4NVW C h/c/NVWMKMNOFKQWDw&/f4RiFGbHiNVaeh#kra^UVRiFT]=LdeRic/deRiF(GIc B RNS|WMG^c#R KMG !RiF/RTWMHR kVFuh#`!RTHc#FNVaMHkKeRV]=NVWMKgf8N C NVaIh#kSNVHiHkrfgf4kDKNOc#RKMG !RiF/RTW=c B krwMWKMNOF C HkrWMKMG^c/GIkrWMhkrW'c/deR Kekrf8NVGbWYfMweF/c/deRiF]=c/deRJF/RThwMa^c/hu`MF/RTh#RTW=c5dMRiF/R$HiNVW B RJwMh#RTKGIW+c/deR4zkVFf wMaINOc/G^krW9kVz<Nt`NOF/c/GIHiaIRY/ f4RTh/d9EL<NVaIK f4Ric/dekK oG^zukrWeR8GIh GIW=c#RiF/RTh#c#RTK GIW+F/RTHkUVRiFGbWec/deR4`!krGIW=c =KMG^`!kra^R f4kDKMRTa Y y dMRHkrf8`wec/NOc/G^krWMNVa.L5kVF 9NVh/h#kHiGINOc#RTK LGIc/dc/dMR4|WMG^c#R =KMGI`kraIRf4kKeRTaHkrf4`MFAGIh#RTh NQ|RTK\Hkrh#cNVh/h#kHiGINOc#RTK\LGIc/d h#kra^UGIWeQc/deR8skrGIh/h/krW RT=wNOc/G^krW\NVWMK\NVW F 7:)VF/kLc/dNVh/h#kHiGINOc#RTK L)G^c/d KMGIh#c#FG B wec/GIWec/deRQHiweF/F/RTW=c4h#krweFHRTh4klUVRiF8c/deRQVFGbK `!krGIW=c/hiY _ |RTK W=wMf8RiFGIHiNVaf4RTh/dGIhHkrf8f8krWMa C wMh#RTKQzkVF)hGIfwaINOc/GIWe4c/deRSwMGIKQK C WMNVf8GbHih kVzN8h/wMh/`RTWh/G^krWtkVz.`NOFNVf8NOrWMRic/GIH`NOF/c/GbHia^RTh NVWMKtc/deRSR c#FN4Hkrh#ckVz.h/kra^UDGbWec/dMRSNVKMKMG^c/G^krWNVaskrGIhh#krWQRTDwMNOc/G^krWQF/Ri`F/RTh#RTW=c/hN4f4kKeRTh#cGIWMHFRTNVh#R GbWc/deR kUVRiFANVaIa.Hkrf4`wec/NOc/G^krWNVa~R!kVF/ciY y dMR HAdekrGIHRkVz Gbh)KMGbh/HiwMh/h#RTKGIWc/deR HkrW=c#R ckVz`MFkUGIKMGIWe NVW+NVHiHiwMFNOc#R4KeRTh/HFG^`c/G^krWnkVzuc/deRzkVFHR B Ric L5RiRTW9`krGbWc$KMG^`!kra^RThL)dMGIa^RSRTWh/weFGIWM8c/deRWDwMf B RiF)kVzVFGIKn`!krGIW=c/hGbWN `NOF/c/GIHia^RFNVKMGIwMhGIh)WMkVcc#kDk'aINOFVRVY_)aIc/dekrwerdnkrWa C c/deRGbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMhB Ric L5RiRTW'`NOF/c/GIHia^RTh(kVzc/deRJh/NVf4R$h/G iRJNVWMKgf8NOrWMRic/GIH`F/kV`!RiF/c/G^RTh(NOFR$HkrWMhGIKeRiF/RTK]=c/deR$|WMG^c#R =KMGI`kraIRKeRTh/HFAG^`Mc/G^krWnHiNVW+F/RTNVKGIa CtB RSR Dc#RTWKeRTK+c#k'HiNVh#RTh$kVz`!kra C KMGIh#`!RiFhG^c C GIWnc/deR `NOF/c/GbHia^RSFNVKMGbwMh kVFJc/deRf8NOrWeRic/GbHSh/wMh/HRi`c/G B GIaIGIc C Y

WQkVFKeRiF)c#k HiNO`Mc/wMF/RSc/deRWMRTNOF / |MRTaIKnGbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMhkVz.`NOF/c/GbHia^RThi]Mc/deRfwec/wNVa KMG^`!kra^R NVWMKn|WMG^c#RKMG^`!kra^Rf4kDKMRTaIh)dNTUVR B RiRTWf4kKMG^|RTKnc#kQGIWMHiaIwKeRa^kHiNVaIa C dMG^rdMRiF / kVFKeRiFJfwa^c/G^`!kra^RSc#RiFfgh)c/dMF/krwerdNn`?NVG^F/LGIh/RgGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krW h/HdeRTf8RVY y dMGIhGIh B NVh#RTK\krW c/deR'R NVHch#kraIwec/GIkrW\zkVFc Luk+`NOFNVf8NOrWMRic/GIH

Page 67: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

9q

`NOF/c/GbHia^RTh5`aINVHRTKtGIW'N aIkDHiNVaIa C wMWMG^zkVFf fgNOrWeRic/GIH$|MRTaIKY y dGIhuGbWMHiaIwMh/GIkrW8h/HdMRTf4R GIh<h#RTa^zM/ HkrWMh/GIh#c#RTW=cGIWc/dMNOcJG^c)`F/RTh#RiF/UVRTh B kVc/dc/dMR HkVF/FRTHc zNOF / |RTaIKNVWMK9WeRTNOF^/ |MRTaIKR D`NVWh/G^krW+aIGIf8G^c/hT]NVWMK+F/RTf4klUVRThc/deR$kUVRiFabNO`M`GIWe c#RiFf8h5kVzc/dMR)R `NVWMh/GIkrWMhiY_)aIc/dekrwerd c/deR$GbWMHiaIwMh/GIkrW8h/HdMRTf4R GIhuGbWc#RTWMKMRTKgzkVF wMh#RLG^c/d8c/deR|WG^c#R =KMG^`!kra^R f4kKeRTa ]GIc/hzkVFfwaINOc/G^krWMhGbhVRTWeRiFNVa?NVWMKgNU NVGbaIN B a^RzkVFuwh#R)GIWgHkrWK2#wWMHc/G^krWLG^c/d kVc/deRiF8KG^`!kra^RgkVF8dMGIrdeRiF / kVFKeRiF4f wMa^c/G^`!kra^R'f4kKeRTaIhiY y deR `F/kDHRTKweF/R C GIRTaIKMhUVRiF C NVHiHiweFANOc#Rh#kraIwMc/G^krWMh.c#kHkrabaIGIWeRTNOFc/deFRiRY/ B kK C `MF/k B aIRTf8hiY y deRh/HAdeRTf4R)GbhWekVc(NVh5NVHiHiweFNOc#RL)deRTW8HkrWMh/GbKeRiFGIWekVc/deRiF HkrWe|MrwMFNOc/G^krWMh B wecFRi`MF/RTh#RTW=c/hJN h/GIrWMG^|HiNVW=cGIf4`F/kUVRTf4RTW=c$kUVRiF R eGIh#c/GIWe f4Ric/dekKMhiY3weF /c/deRiFGbf4`MF/klUVRTf4RTWc/hf8N C9B R`!krh/h/G B aIR BDC GbWMHiaIwMKMGbWe f4kVFRgGIWezkVFf8NOc/G^krW+zF/krf c/deRgzNOFS|RTaIK7 G Y RVYDwMNVKeFwe`!kra^Rf8krf4RTWc/h :AYf W=c#F/kKMwMHiGIWe)WekrW=wWMG^zkVFff8NOrWeRic/GbHu|RTaIKMh GbWc#k$c/deR5c L5k/ B kK C ]rWeRTNOF^/ |MRTaIKf4kKeRTa!L5krwMaIKQh/G^rWG^|HiNVW=c/a C GIWHF/RTNVh#R c/deRHkrf8`a^R eG^c C kVz~c/dMRS`NVG^F/L)GIh#RJHkrf4`wec/NOc/G^krWhiY

Page 68: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

8

$!S28!)

WN U NOFGIRic C kVzc/deR f8GIHF/kSwGIKMGIHJNVWMK+Z SwMGbKnKeRiUGIHRTh)KGIh/HiwMh/h/RTKnGIWv<dNO`Mc#RiFxO]!N hwMh#`!RTWMh/G^krWkVF(N h/fgNVaIaVF/krwe`4kVz!`NOFNVfgNOrWeRic/GIH<`NOF/c/GbHia^RThGIhh/w B 2 RTHcc#kNJc/Gbf4RY/ KeRi`!RTWMKeRTW=cNO`M`aIGIRTK|MRTabKkVF(NVWR c#RiFWMNVa SMklL|MRTaIKY W c/dMRTh#RSh/G^c/wMNOc/GIkrWMhi]Dc/deRSf4kVc/G^krWtkVz~c/deR h#c#FwMHc/weFRTh a^RTNVKMh5c#k8d C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIHzkVFHRThgc/dNOc f8N C KMRiz kVFf kVF B FRTN c/deRNOVVF/RirNOc#RThiY _ aIGIWeRTNOF8h/dMRTNOF SMklLS] z kVF R NVf8`a^RV]<LGIaIaF/kVc/NOc#R8NtHdNVGIW9NVWMK9NO`M`a C h/c#FNVGIWMGIWM8z kVFAHRThJc/dMNOcSf8N C `wMaIa~G^cJNO`NOF/cx7F.G^rweF/R 9eYIx:AY X Gbf8GIaINOFa C ]?NHdNVGIW h/w B 2 RTHcc#k+NF/kVc/NOc/GIWe|MRTaIK LGIaIa.R `!RiFG^RTWMHRgd C KeF/kK C WNVf8GIHzkVFHRThc/dMRg`MF/RiUVRTW=cG^cSzF/krfF/RTf8NVGbWMGIWe'NVaIG^rWeRTK+LG^c/dc/deR4NO`M`abG^RTK|RTaIKY y deR w>)KTY` ,#&% W - ]C$ ]`F/kUGIKeRThJNtf4RTNVh/weFR kVzc/deR4F/RTabNOc/G^UVR8h#c#F/RTWeVc/d9kVz5c/deR4UGIh/HkrwMhJzkVFHRThSNVhHkrf4`NOF/RTK c/dMR4c#kQc/deR8f8NOrWeRic/GIHzkVFHRThSNVWK\G^c/hKeRi|WG^c/G^krWQKeRi`!RTWMKMhkrWnc/deR h/G^c/wMNOc/G^krW B RTGbWe8HkrWMh/GIKMRiF/RTKY ekVF$N h/deRTNOFSMkL]c/deRZNVh#krW+W=wf B RiFGIh<c C `GbHiNVaIa C KeRi|WeRTKQNVh V

$ 3@)

o A A 7H9eYIx:

LdeRiFR 9GIh5c/deRSh/deRTNOF FANOc#RV] GIh<c/dMRSwMGIK UDGbh/Hkrh/G^c C ]$Gbhuc/dMR `RiFAf4RTN B GIaIGIc C kVzz F/RiRY/ h/`NVHRV] JGIhc/deR5f8NOrWMG^c/wMKMRkVzec/deR<NO`M`aIG^RTKJ|RTaIK]ONVWMK &7 < : LG^c/d B RTGIWec/deR(`NOFc/GIHia^R(h/wh/HRi`Mc/G B GbaIG^c C Y

9;

Page 69: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

9

H

u

u

0

FhydroFmag

.G^rweFR9eYIxs X VRic/HAdkVz.N8HdNVGIWQkVz 6z B RTNVKhKeRizkVFf8GIWe4GIWtFRTh#`!krWMh#RJc#kgN8h/dMRTNOFSMkLY

*deRTWnN4F/kVc/NOc/GbWegNO`M`abG^RTK'|MRTaIKQGIh HkrWMhGIKeRiF/RTK]ec/dMRSwMh/wMNVaKeRi|?WMG^c/G^krW B RTHkrf4RTh

$& )0/5- xY99'

A3,4:4 A kVF

xTq A A 7H9eY[o:

LdeRiFR 3,4:4 &7 <: *NVWMK6GIhSc/dMRgNVWerwMaINOFz FRT=weRTWH C kVz<c/deR'NO`M`aIGIRTK9|MRTaIKY y deRRTDwMGIaIG B FGIwMf a^RTWeVc/dMh NVWMK h/dMNO`!RThJkVz HdMNVGIWh kVzu`?NOFNVf8NOrWeRic/GIH8`NOF/c/GIHia^RTh GbW\h/deRTNOF SkLhSNVWK F/k/c/NOc/GIWeQ|RTaIKMh$LGIaIa B R4NRTHc#RTK B=C c/deR4UONVaIweRkVz $ 3@) NVWMK$ )0/5- YekVFNQHdNVGIW9kVz B RTNVKMhkrWeR HiNVWQGIW=c#F/kKMwMHRJN HFAG^c/GIHiNVaZNVh/krWQW=wMf B RiFT]%$& '*),+.- 3 ) kVF $ '*),+.-)0/5- ]c/dMNOcGIh<KeRi|WeRTK'NVh<c/deRSf8N/GIf wMf%UONVaIweRJkVz"$& 3 ) kVF$ )0/5- zkVFLdMGIHAdtc/deRSHdNVGIWQLGIaba?WekVc B F/RTN?Y y deR UONVaIweRJkVz $ 3@)kVF $ )0/5- LGIaIa5NVaIh#k N!RTHc8c/deRQ`MF/kV`!RiF/c/GIRThkVzJh/wMh#`!RTWMhG^krWMhSkVz$`NOFNVfgNOrWeRic/GIH B RTNVKMhh/w B 2#RTHcc#kSMklL@|RTaIKMhkVF$c/GIf4RY/ KMRi`RTWKeRTWc$NO`M`aIGIRTKQ|MRTaIKMhTYekVFJR NVf8`a^RV]c/deRUONVaIweRkVzc/deR $& )0/1- HiNVW9KeFNK/f8NOc/GIHiNVaba C N!RTHcc/dMRh#c#FwMHc/wMF/RThzkVFf4RTK BDC `NOF/c/GIHiaIRThGIWQh/wMh/`RTWh/G^krWMh<h/w B 2 RTHcc#kgF/kVc/NOc/GIWe8|RTaIKMh Y<_<c)a^klLUONVaIweRThkVz"$ )0/5- ]Mc/deR`NOF/c/GIHia^RThLGIaIa!NOVVF/RirNOc#Rc#kgzkVFf HAdMNVGIWMhc/dMNOcF/kVc/NOc#RWeRTNOFa CNVaIG^rWMRTK8LG^c/dgc/deRJNO`M`aIG^RTK8|MRTaIKY_$h8$ )0/5- GbWMHF/RTNVh#RThi]DUGIh/HkrwMh5h#c#F/RTh/h/RThuL)GIaIa B RirGIWgc#k KeRizkVFfc/deRHdNVGIWMh HiNVwMh/GbWetc/deRTf c#k B F/RTN+KeRTHF/RTNVh/GbWetc/deR8NTUVRiFNOVR'HdMNVGbW\a^RTWeVc/dYt dMRTW7$& )0/5- xO]~c/deRh/wMh/`RTWh/G^krW+h#c#FwMHc/weFR8HdMNVWeVRThN B Fwe`c/a C c#kQLdeRiFR4krWeR8WekL k B h#RiF/UVRThkrh/HiGIaIaINOc/GbWe B GIWMNOF C `?NVG^FhNVWMKnhf8NVaIa ]`aINVWNOFHiaIwMh#c#RiFhTY

m$h/GIWec/deRth/GIf wMaINOc/G^krW c#RTHdMWMGb=weRTh KeRTh/HFAG B RTK GIW c/deR `F/RiUDGIkrwMhc Luk HAdMNO`Mc#RiFh L5R'dMNUVRQHkrW&/KMwMHc#RTK NnUONOFG^Ric C kVz<hGIfwaINOc/G^krWMhJc#k+wMWMKeRiFh/c/NVWMK c/deR B RTdNTUG^kVFSkVzHkraIa^RTHc/GIkrWMh kVz B kVc/d Nnhf8NVaIaVF/krwe`kVzh#RiUVRiFNVa NVWKnh/wMh#`!RTWMhG^krWMh<kVz.c/dekrwMh/NVWKMh kVz.`NOF/c/GIHiaIRThiYn R|MFh#cHkrWMhGIKeRiFc/deRK C WNVf8GIHih

Page 70: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

9.

kVzN4`NVG^F kVz.`NOFc/GIHia^RThGIWQN8F/kVc/NOc/GIWe8|RTaIKY_ B klUVRN8HFAG^c/GIHiNVa!zF/RT=wMRTWMH C kVz.c/deRNO`M`aIG^RTK'|MRTabK]ec/deRh#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krW KMGbh#c/NVWMHR B Ric LuRiRTW c/deR`?NOF/c/GIHia^RThgLGIaIa wMWKeRiF/Vk\zF/RTDweRTWMH C KeRi`!RTWMKeRTW=c4krh/HiGIaIabNOc/G^krWMhiYj C HkrWMKMwHc/GIWeth/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWMhkVz(c/dMGIh B RTdMNTUG^kVFT]LuR4DwMNVW=c/G^z C c/dMRR!RTHc/h kVzc/deRHkraIaIGbh/G^krW B NOF/FG^RiFkrWnc/dMRF/RTh/wa^c/GIWe4K C WMNVf8GIHihTYn R c/deRTWnR eNVf8GIWeRc/deRSRTDwMGIaIG B FGIwMf h/dMNO`!RThNVHAdMG^RiUVRTK B=C HdNVGIWMhkVz`NOFNVfgNOrWeRic/GIH<`NOF/c/GbHia^RThGIWh/deRTNOFfSMklLhNVWMKFkVc/NOc/GIWe |MRTaIKhiYP WRTNVHd HiNVh#RV]L5R k B c/NVGIWc/deRHFAG^c/GIHiNVaZNVh#krW9W=wMf B RiFklUVRiFSNgFNVWMVRkVz(HAdMNVGIW+a^RTWeVc/dMhiY y kth/deklL c/deRGIf4`!kVF/c/NVWHRkVzHkVF/F/RTHc/a C F/RTh#kra^U;/GIWec/deRSd C KeF/kK C WNVf8GIHGbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMhNVa^krWec/deRSaIRTWeVc/dtkVz~c/dMRSHdMNVGIW]ec/deR h/GIf wMaINOc/G^krW'F/RTh/wa^c/h NOF/RHkrf4`NOFRTKL)G^c/dUONVaIweRTh$kVzc/dMR HFGIc/GIHiNVaZNVh#krW WDwMf B RiF$k B c/NVGIWMRTK BDC Nth/GIf4`?a^R X c#k VRTh KeFANO'aINLHdNVGIWnf4kKeRTa V]rK9 Yn.GIWMNVaIa C ]DL5RHkrWMh/GIKMRiFc/deR B RTdMNTUG^kVFkVz.N8h/wh#`!RTWMh/G^krW kVz.`NOF/c/GIHia^RTh NVaba^kL5RTKc#ktNOVVF/RirNOc#R8wMWMKeRiFc/deRGIW,SweRTWMHRSkVzN F/kVc/NOc/GIWMg|MRTaIKNVWMKHkrf8`NOF/R c/deRTh#RFRTh/wMa^c/hLG^c/dhGIf8GIaINOFR `RiFAGIf4RTW=c/h Y

)40.12 / 1 5-:78(0/2

RHkrWMhGIKeRiF<|MFh#c5c/deRSK C WMNVf8GbHihukVz.NVWQGIh#krabNOc#RTK B GIWMNOF C `?NVG^F<kVz~`NOFANVf8NOrWeRic/GIHJ`NOFc/GIHia^RTh<h/w B 2#RTHcc#k8NF/kVc/NOc/GIWM |RTaIKY y deRJUGIh/HkrwMh<zkVFHRThHF/RTNOc#RN`?dMNVh#R aINO8GIW'c/deRJc/weFWGIWe kVz c/deRSKekrw B a^Ric5F/RTaINK/c/G^UVR c#kSc/dMRNO`M`aIG^RTK f8NOrWeRic/GbH |MRTaIKYj5RTa^kL NHFG^c/GIHiNVaeZNVh#krWgWDwMf B RiF"$ ' )5+.-)0/5- ]rc/deR UVRTHc#kVFP2#krGIWMGIWec/deRHRTWc#RiFAhJLGIaIa B R NOcJN |RTKNVWMra^R F/RTaINOc/G^UVR c#k'c/deR NO``aIG^RTK|MRTaIKhwMHd+c/dMNOc$c/deRGIWc#RiF`NOF/c/G /Hia^RgfgNOrWeRic/GIH8zkVFHRThLGIaIaF/RTfgNVGIW NOc#c#FNVHc/GIUVR'HiNVwMhGIWenc/deRgc L5k`NOFc/GIHia^RTh c#kF/RTf8NVGIW\GbW\HkrWc/NVHciY_ B klUVR $&('*),+.-)0/1- ] QLGIaIa?GIWMHF/RTNVh#R$c#k LdeRiF/R$c/deRJf8NOrWeRic/GIH$zkVFHRTh<HdMNVWeVR zF/krf B RTGIWeNOc#c#FANVHc/G^UVR c#kF/Ri`waIh/G^UVRVY5 W c/dGIhSF/RirGbf4RV]~c/dMRgh#Ri`NOFNOc/GIkrW KMGIh/c/NVWMHR B Ric L5RiRTW c/dMRg`NOF/c/GbHia^RTh krh/HiGIabaINOc#RThGIW\c/GIf4R7F.G^rweF/R39eY[o:AY y deRz F/RTDweRTWMH C NVWKgf8NOrWMGIc/wMKeRkVzc/deR$krh/HiGIabaINOc/G^krWMhL)GIaIaeKeRi`!RTWMK4krW c/deR)z F/RTDweRTWMH CkVz.c/deRNO`M`?aIG^RTKt|MRTaIKy7H9eY :<LG^c/dnc/deRf8NOrWMGIc/wMKeRSKeRTHF/RTNVhGIWegNVWMKnc/deRSzF/RT=wMRTWMH C GIWMHF/RTNVh/GbWeLG^c/d$ )0/5- Y y deRJR `RiFAGIf4RTW=c/h BDC )RTa^VRTh#RTW -$[n)'*c zx HkrWMHRiFWGIWeN`NVG^F<kVzWMkrWMf8NOrWeRic/GIH$`NOFc/GIHia^RThGIW NzRiF/F/kSwGIKLuRiFR)c/deR)|MFh#cuc#kk B h#RiF/UVR$c/deRTh#R)K C WMNVfgGIHihiY dGIa^R zx R NVfgGIWeRTK'HdMNVWeVRTh<GIWgc/deRWekrW&/ HkrWh#c/NVWc F/kVc/NOc/G^krWNVa(zF/RTDweRTWMH C kVz c/deR'Kekrw B a^RicNGIhT]f4kVFRgF/RTHRTW=c h/c/wMKMG^RTh=wMNVW=c/G^|MRTK c/deRzF/RT=wMRTWMH C NVWMKtf8NOrWMGIc/wMKeRkVz~c/deR$krh/HiGIaIaINOc/GIkrWMh VNVWK c/dMR)R!RTHc/h kVz~hweF/z NVHR)F/krwMrdMWeRTh/hukrWtc/deRF/RTh/wa^c/GIWeK C WMNVf8GIHih q Y

_$a^c/dekrwerdc/deRklUVRiFNVaIaK C WMNVf8GIHihNOFRVklUVRiFWeRTK B=C c/deR d C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIH NVWKf8NOrWeRic/GbHGIW=c#RiF /NVHc/G^krWMhT]DKMG RiF/RTWHRTh(GIW4c/dMR)WeRTNOF / HkrW=c/NVHc K C WMNVf8GIHihuHiNVW N!RTHcuc/dMR)f8NOrWMGIc/wMKeRNVWMKgz FRT=weRTWH C kVzc/deRSkrhHiGIaIaINOc/G^krWh q Yk W.G^rwMF/R 9eY D]LuRHkrf8`NOF/RFRTh/wMa^c/h zF/krf c LuktKMG !RiF/RTW=ch/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWh<LG^c/dc/deR)R D`!RiFGIf8RTWc/NVaIa C f4RTNVhweF/RTK8krhHiGIaIaINOc/G^krWhc/NVRTW'z F/krf V Yf W8c/deR)|MFh#c(hGIfwaINOc/G^krW]VL5R)FRTh#kra^UVR

Page 71: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

zOp

.G^rweF/Re9eY[os_ `NVG^FkVz`NOFNVf8NOrWMRic/GIH B RTNVKMhGIW4NSHiaIkDH =LGbh#R F/kVc/NOc/GIWe |RTaIKLG^c/d $ )0/5- $ ' )5+.-)0/5- Yy deRnGbf8NOVRThgh/dMkL c/deR B RTNVKh4kUVRiF'c/deRHkrweFAh#RnkVz$krWeRnkrh/HiGIabaINOc/G^krWY y dMRnNOF/F/kL)hgGIWMKGIHiNOc#RQc/deRKMG^FRTHc/G^krWtkVz.c/deRSNO`M`aIGIRTK |RTaIKYf W47 H: NVWMK47 Kr:<c/deRSzkVFHR B Ric L5RiRTWc/deR B RTNVKMhGIh<F/Ri`wMabh/G^UVRVY

Page 72: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

zx

Hkrf4`aIRic#RTa C c/deR d C KeFkDK C WMNVf8GbHGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMh B Ric L5RiRTWQc/deR$`NOF/c/GIHiaIRTh5wh/GIWec/deR$abw B FGIHiNOc/GIkrW8zkVFHRHkVF/F/RTHc/GIkrW zkVF v Z oV Y W\c/deR'h#RTHkrWMK h/GIf wMaINOc/G^krW] L5R'G^rWMkVF/R8c/deR'aIw B FGbHiNOc/G^krW9RRTHc/hT] B wecRTf4`aIk C c/deRgh/dMkVF/c / FNVWeVRgHkrabaIGIh/G^krW B NOF/FG^RiF 7 oDY V:AY *deRTW\krWa C abw B FGIHiNOc/GIkrW9RRTHc/h NOF/R HkrWh/GIK&/RiF/RTK]c/deR F/RTh/wMaIc/GIWekrh/HiGIaIabNOc/G^krWMh<NOF/RSkrWMa C NzFNVHc/G^krWkVz~c/dekrh/RKeRic#RiFf8GbWeRTKtR D`!RiFGbf4RTWc/NVaba C Y y deRh/GIf wMaINOc/GIkrW RTf4`?a^k C GIWe9c/deRQHkraIaIGbh/G^krW B NOF/FG^RiF]dekL5RiUVRiFT]5`MF/kUGIKeRtkrh/HiGbaIaINOc/G^krWMhc/dMNOc8NOF/RnHkrf8`NK/FN B aIR c/dekrh/RQz krwMWK BDC V Y y dMRTh#RtF/RTh/wMa^c/h4GbWMKMGIHiNOc#R'c/dMNOc4`NOF/c/GbHia^R'hweF/z NVHRQF/krwerdMWeRThh NVWK kVFGIW=c#RiF/`NOF/c/GbHia^Rh/wMF/zNVHR zkVFHRThJNOF/R`MF/RTh#RTW=c$NVWKNOF/RHiNO`Mc/weFRTK BDC c/deR VRTWeRiFGbHHkraIabGIh/G^krW B NOF/FG^RiF$GIWc/deRhGIfwaINOc/G^krWMhiY

MwMF/c/deRiFT]L5Rgf8N C R NVf8GbWeR8dekL c/deR4krh/HiGIaIabNOc#kVF C K C WMNVfgGIHih$LGIaIa.HdNVWeVR8LG^c/d9UONOFGINOc/GIkrWMh GIW2 )0354 Y y dMR B NVaINVWMHR B Ric L5RiRTW c/deRHkraIaIGIh/GIkrW B NOFFG^RiF4zkVFHRNVWMK c/deRf8NOrWeRic/GIHQNOc#c#FNVHc/GIUVRzkVFHRRTh#c/N B abGIh/deRTK N f8GIWGIfwfh#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krW KMGIh#c/NVWHR B Ric LuRiRTW c/deRt`NOF/c/GIHia^RThTY y dMGbh h/Ric/h8NVW RRTHc/GIUVRd C KeFkDK C WMNVf8GbHFNVKGIwMhJkVz<c/deR8`NOFc/GIHia^RTh NVWMK\Nf8NGbfwMf,U NVaIwMR4kVzuc/deR GIWc#RiF`NOF/c/GIHia^R4f8NOrWMRic/GIHzkVFHRThiY y kR NVf8GbWeR)c/dMRTh#R RRTHc/hT]MLuRJUONOF C c/dMRJHiwMc / kFNVKMGbwMh(klUVRiFc/deRJFNVWMVR o proz 2 )03,4 o ?YnekVFN B RTNVK LG^c/d'NFNVKMGIwMh(kVz 1xB ]c/dMGIhuFNVWeVRJHkVF/F/RTh#`!krWMKMh(c#kc/deR)zkVFHRTh<NVHc/GIWeklUVRiFoz OpVp zF/krf c/deRghweF/z NVHR8kVz<c/deR8`NOF/c/GbHia^RVY y deR B NOFFG^RiF zkVFHR8zkVFc/deRgKG RiFRTWc UONVaIweRTh kVz2 )0354 NOF/Rh/dekL)WnGIW .G^rweF/R9eY9eY

W U NOF C GIWe 2 )0354 kUVRiFc/dMR5FANVWeVR HkrWMh/GIKeRiFRTKdeRiFRV]VLuR<zkrwMWMK c/dMNOc.c/deR HFG^c/GIHiNVaZNVh#krW4W=wf B RiFLGIaba GIWMHFRTNVh#R BDC NO`M`F/k eGIf8NOc#RTa C oOp 7 y N B aIRt9eYIx:AYMkVFSa^kL5RiF U NVabweRTh$kVz2 ),3,4 ]!c/deR4f8GIWMGbfwMfh#Ri`NOFANOc/G^krWtKMGIh#c/NVWMHR GIhuF/RTKMwHRTK'NVWK c/dMRJd C KeF/kK C WNVf8GIHNVWMKtf8NOrWMRic/GIH$z kVFHRTh VRiRi`?GIWe c/deRJ`NOF /c/GIHia^RTh<GIWtHkrW=c/NVHcGIWMHFRTNVh#RVY y deR f8NOrWMGIc/wMKeR$kVz c/deRJkrh/HiGIabaINOc/G^krWMh5NOF/R KeRic#RiFf8GbWeRTK'kUVRiFN FNVWeVR kVz$ )0/5- N B klUVR $& '*),+.-)0/5- NVWK NOFRh/dekL)W GbW .G^rwMF/RU9eY zDY_ B kUVR c/deR HFGIc/GIHiNVaDz F/RTDweRTWMH C ]LuR<zkrwMWMK c/deRf8NOrWMGIc/wMKeRSkVzc/deR krh/HiGIabaINOc/G^krWMhNOFRF/RTKMwHRTKLdMRTWnc/deRU NVaIwMRkVz"2 )0354 GIhKeRTHFRTNVh#RTKY$RTHF/RTNVh/GbWe2 )0354 L)GIaIa!wMWMG^zkVFf8a C h/dMG^zc c/deRfgNOrWMG^c/wMKeRThc#k a^klLuRiF)U NVaIwMRThi] B wec c/dMRh/HiNVaIGbWe4LG^c/dtzF/RTDweRTWMH C GIhNVaIh#kz krwMWK8c#k B RhaIG^rd=c/a C f4kKMG^|RTKY_$a^krWeLG^c/d4c/deR$f8NOrWMG^c/wKeRV]rL5R|WMK8c/dMNOc(c/deR)z FRT=weRTWH C kVzc/deRJkrh/HiGIabaINOc/G^krWMh(c#k B RJN!RTHc#RTK B=C c/deRJU NVaIwMR)kVz2 )03,4 7F.G^rwMF/R39eY[q:AY y deR$FNOc/G^k kVz c/deRJkrh/HiGbaIaINOc/G^krWzF/RT=wMRTWMH C c#k c/dMRzF/RTDweRTWMH C kVzc/deRNO`M`abG^RTKQ|MRTaIKGIh$a^kL5RiFJz kVFJa^kL5RiFJU NVabweRThkVz 2 )03,4 Y3 )RiF/RV]!c/deRUONVaIweRTh kVzc/dMGIh FANOc/G^k8Kek8HkraIaINO`?h#R krWc#k'N4h/GIWeraIRJHiwMF/UVRSLdeRTWt`?a^kVc#c#RTKNOrNVGIWh#c $& )0/5- $& '*),+.-)0/5- Y

Page 73: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

zVo

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18−0.2

−0.1

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

t (sec)

D(µm

)

6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24

−0.4

0

0.4

0.8

1.2

1.6

2

2.4

t (sec)

D(µm

)

.G^rweF/R9eY se<JhHiGIaIaINOc/G^krWh5GbWQc/deRKMGbh#c/NVWMHR B Ric L5RiRTW`NOF/c/GIHia^RShweF/z NVHRThzkVF)NVWnkrhHiGIaIaINOc/GIWMKMkrw B a^RicNVh$rG^UVRTW B=C 7 N.:R `!RiFGIf4RTW=c/hkVz V ]f7 B :e~v Z h/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWh LG^c/d+aIw B FAGIHiNOc/G^krWnHkVF/FRTHc/G^krWMhJNVWMK7 H:h/c/NVWMKMNOFK5~v Z h/GIf wMaINOc/GIkrWMhLG^c/d8c/deRHkraIaIGbh/G^krW B NOF/FAG^RiF37 ),3,4 1x pz ' / NVWMK 2 )03,4 oIx 0:AY Wc/deR5R `RiFAGIf4RTW=c/h c/deR<HFG^c/GbHiNVarzF/RT=wMRTWMH C L<NVhKMRic#RiFf8GIWeRTKc#k B R '*),+.- p [oz NVWMK 9 Y W 7 B :NVWMK 7 H:A]c/dMR KMNVh/dMRTK aIGbWeR8HkVF/F/RTh#`!krWMKhSc#k p [o GIW c/deR'R `RiFAGIf4RTW=c/hSLdMGba^R4c/deRh#kraIGbKQaIGIWeRJHkVF/F/RTh#`!krWMKh<c#k *p 9eY

Page 74: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

z

2 2.05 2.1 2.15 2.2 2.25 2.30

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

r/a

F/F

con

.G^rweF/RR9eY90s)kVFf8NVabG iRTK HkraIaIGIhG^krW B NOF/FG^RiFJzkVFHR ' / NVhNtzwMWHc/G^krW9kVz5h/Ri`NOFNOc/G^krW KMGbh#c/NVWMHRzkVF 2 )03,4 o proz 7 h#krabGIK abGIWeR8:A] 2 )03,4 oIx 7 KNVh/deRTK aIGIWeR8:A]2 )0354 o[o 7 KekVc#c#RTK aIGIWeR8:SNVWMK2 )0354 o 47 KNVh/d&/ KekVc#c#RTKaIGIWeR8:AY

−0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 20

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

Marot −Macritrot

D/a

10−1

100

10−1

100

Marot −Macritrot

D/a

.G^rweF/R 9eY zsgZNOrWMGIc/wMKeR8kVz c/deR krh/HiGIaIabNOc/G^krWMh UVRiFhwMh $ )0/5- $& '*),+.-)0/5- 7 N.:NVWMK NOrNVGIW GIW\aIkV/ a^kVh/HiNVa^R7 B :AY y deR5h#kraIGIKaIGIWeR(LG^c/dc/deR5HiGIFHiwMaINOFf8NOF VRiFh.HkVF/F/RTh/`krWKMh c#k 2 )0354 o[oD]Vc/deR KMNVh/deRTK aIGIWeRLG^c/d8kV`RTWgh/=wNOF/Rf8NOF VRiFAh2 )0354 oIxO]NVWMK4c/dMRKMNVh/d&/ KMkVc#c#RTK aIGbWeR<LG^c/dc#FGINVWMra^RTh2 )0354 o prozDY

Page 75: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

zK9

2 )03,4 $&('*),+.-)0/5-oDY prozON xOY[ozoDY pzON xOY[ooDYIxiN xOYIxzoDYIxzON xOYIxzVoDY[oON xOYIxTooDY[ozON xOY poDY ON xOY p9.z

y N B a^R9eYIxs y dMRJHFAG^c/GIHiNVa ZNVh#krWWDwMf B RiFT]%$&('*),+.-)0/1- ]z kVFRTNVHAdnUONVaIweR kVz2 )0354 HkrWMhGIKeRiF/RTKY

T),5!) 2 T ! 8u> 2

5!A- 78(0/24

y deR'wMWMGIDweR4FdMRikra^kVrGIHiNVau`MF/kV`!RiF/c/G^RThkVzZ SwGIK\NOF/R `MF/kUGIKeRTK B=C c/dMR'aIGbWeRTNOFh#c#FAwMHc/weF/RThc/dMNOczkVFf `NOFNVaIaIRTa(c#k c/deRnNO``aIG^RTK |MRTaIK NVWMK F/RTh/Gbh#c4KeRiz kVFAf8NOc/G^krW NVh4N9F/RTh/wa^ckVzJNVW NO`M`abG^RTK hdeRTNOFTY WNVKMKG^c/G^krW]DwMNVW=c/G^z C GIWM8c/deR C G^RTaIKkVzc/deR HdMNVGIWh)GIWNO`M`aIGIRTK SMkL1|MRTabKMh kVF GIWnc/Gbf4RKeRi`!RTWMKMRTWc|MRTaIKh4GIh8GIf4`!kVF/c/NVW=c4c#k\c/deRkV`RiFANOc/G^krW kVz f8GIHF/kS?wMGIKMGIH'KeRiUGIHRTh4RTf4`?a^k C GIWe c/deRh#RTa^zM/ NVh/h#RTf B a^RTKh#c#FwHc/weF/RThiY m$WMKeRiFAh#c/NVWMKMGIWM+c/dMR B RTdMNTUG^kVF8kVz N\HAdMNVGIW kVzJ`NOF/c/GbHia^RTh8GIW N\abGIWeRTNOFgh/dMRTNOFxSMkL kVFN9F/kVc/NOc/GIWM\NO`M`aIG^RTK |MRTaIK `MFkUGIKeRTh4GIWezkVFf8NOc/GIkrW RThh#RTWc/GbNVa<c#k\=wMNVW=c/G^z C GbWeFAdeRikra^kV C `MF/kV`!RiF/c/G^RThNVWMKQc/dMR`!RiF/zkVFf8NVWMHR kVzf8GIHFkDKeRiUGIHRThiYU RHkrWMKwMHc)h/GbfwMabNOc/G^krWMh<kVz B kVc/dQc/deRTh#R h/HRTWMNOFG^krh)NVWMKGIW RTNVHd HiNVh#RtNVh/HRiF/c/NVGIW c/deR'HFG^c/GIHiNVa<ZNVh#krW W=wMf B RiFzkVF N+HdNVGIW\kVz B RTNVKMhTY y dMGIh B RTdMNTUG^kVFdMNVh B RiRTWt`MF/RiUG^krwMha C R NVfgGIWeRTKtwMh/GIWM KeFANO B NVh#RTKQHdMNVGbWQf4kDKMRTaIh V],K9M]X Yf RHkrf4`?NOF/RJkrweFF/RTh/wa^c/hLGIc/dc/deRTh/R5f4kKeRTaIh~NVWMK KeRTf4krWMh#c#FANOc#Ruc/deR<GIf4`!kVF/c/NVWHRkVzMc/deR<d C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIHGbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMhNVa^krWe4c/dMRa^RTWeVc/dQkVzc/deRHAdMNVGIWY

$& W xVoVoD] VR!RiF C qOp KeRTf4krWh#c#FNOc#RTKQc/dMNOcNc#kVFA=weRY/ zF/RiRSh#`?deRiF/krGIKMNVa`NOFc/GIHia^R GIW'c/deRSaIGIWMRTNOF<hdeRTNOFSMklL

@ 7H9eY :

c/dMNOcdNVhG^c/hNeGIh kVz.h C f8f4Ric#F C R HiabwMh/G^UVRTa C GIWtc/deR" ./ `?aINVWeRV]eLGIabaF/kVc/NOc#RLG^c/dQN4`!RiFGIkDK

o < x

7H9eY9;:

Page 76: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

zz

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 30

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2

Marot

ωosc/ωfield

−0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 20

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2

Marot −Macritrot

ωosc/ωfield

.G^rweF/Re9eY[qs1MF/RT=wMRTWMH C kVz?c/deRkrh/HiGIaIaINOc/GIkrWMhKMG^UGIKeRTK BDC c/deRz F/RTDweRTWMH C kVz!c/deRNO`M`?aIG^RTK |MRTaIKUVRiFhwMh7 N.: $ )0/5- $&('*),+.-)0/1- NVWMKm7 B : $ ),/5- $ '*),+.-)0/5- Y y deR h#krabGIK abGIWeR+LG^c/d c/deR HiG^FHiwMaINOFQf8NOF VRiFhHkVF/F/RTh/`krWKMhc#k 2 )0354 1o[oD]c/deRKMNVh/dMRTKaIGbWeRLGIc/dnkV`!RTW9h/=wNOF/Rf8NOF VRiFh 2 ),3,4 1oIxO]NVWMK+c/deRKMNVh/d0/ KekVc#c#RTKaIGbWeR)L)G^c/dtc#FGINVWeraIRTh=2 ),3,4 o prozDY

y

φ

x

γu= y

a

b

GIrweF/R9eY ;su_$WnGIabaIwMh#c#FNOc/GIkrWgkVzNVWQRTaIabG^`h#krGIKNVa`NOFc/GIHia^RSGIWQN4aIGbWeRTNOFh/deRTNOFSkLSY

Page 77: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

zVq

LdeRiFR c/deRSNVWera^R 7F.G^rweFR 9eY :<NVhN8zwMWHc/G^krWtkVz~c/Gbf4RSGIh rG^UVRTW B=C

c/NVW c/NVW o 7H9eY z:

LdeRiFR 9GIh c/deRgh/`deRiF/krGIKNVaNeGIh FANOc/G^keY!GbN]v5k \NVWMK ZNVh#krW xToVouKMRTf4krWMh#c#FNOc#RTK\c/dMNOcNVW C NeGIh C f8f4Ric#FGIH B kDK C ]DGIWHiaIwMKMGIWMNHdMNVGIW'kVzh#`deRiFGbHiNVa`NOFc/GIHia^RThi]LGIaba B RTdMNTUVR GIW'c/dMGbh5fgNVWMWeRiFLG^c/dQNVW -- ![FZHp-h#`deRiFkrGIKMNVa!NGbh FNOc/G^k 3 Y

y dMRn`!RiFG^kK kVzSN VR!F/R C kVF B G^c8HiNVW B RKMFNVf8NOc/GIHiNVaIa C NVa^c#RiFRTK BDC GIWc#FkDKMwHiGIWe\NVW NO``aIG^RTKc#kVFDweRnkrW c/deRnk B 2#RTHciY $kraIKMhf8G^c/d NVWMK ZNVh#krW 9q$R NVf8GbWeRTK c/deR B RTdNTUG^kVF8kVzSN\KMGIRTa^RTHc#FGIHh#`dMRiF/krGIK+h/w B 2#RTHcJc#ktNth/dMRTNOFSMkL(7H9eY :JNVWK+NVW9RTaIRTHc#FGIH |MRTaIK+GIW+c/deR#./ KG^F/RTHc/G^krWY y deR C zkrwMWMKc/dMNOc B RTa^klL*N4HFAG^c/GIHiNVaU NVabweR)kVz~c/deRSf8NOrWMGIc/wMKeR$kVz c/deRSNO`M`?aIG^RTK |MRTaIK]Dc/deRJ`NOF/c/GIHiaIR)LGbaIa?h/c/GIaIaf8NVRNnHkrf4`?a^Ric#R8kVF B GIci] B wec c/dMR8c/GIf4R8h#`!RTW=cSGIW c/deRg|MFh#cSNVWMK\c/dMG^FK DwMNVKeFNVW=c/hSGIha^RTWeVc/deRTWeRTK\LdMGIa^Rc/deR8c/Gbf4R8GIW c/deR h#RTHkrWMK NVWK z krwMF/c/d\DwMNVKeFNVW=c/hSGIhSKGIf8GIWMGbh/deRTKY_ B klUVR NnHFGIc/GIHiNVaUONVaIweR4kVz<c/deRNO`M`abG^RTK'|MRTaIK]ec/deRh#`deRiF/krGbKtLGIaIa!WekVc B RSN B aIR c#kgHkrf4`a^Ric#RG^c/h kVF B GIcNVWMKQLGIaba?FRTNVHdRT=wMGbaIG B FGbwMfNOcN4| DRTKnNVWMra^R 3 + f4RTNVhweF/RTKQzF/krf c/deR ;/ NeGIhiY

y dMRJhG^c/wMNOc/G^krWtf8N CgB RJzweFc/deRiF f4kDKG^|MRTK'G^zc/deR h#c#FwHc/weF/R GIh<Wek4a^krWeVRiF FGIrGIK NVWK'NVaba^kL5RTKtc#kKeRizkVFf kVFSFwM`Mc/weF/RVY4_ HdMNVGIW9kVz5`NOFNVfgNOrWeRic/GIH4`NOFc/GIHia^RTh h/w B 2 RTHc c#k B kVc/d NQh/dMRTNOF SMkLNVWMK\NHkrWMh#c/NVW=cuNO``aIG^RTK4f8NOrWMRic/GIH|MRTabK8GIhc/deR)HiNVh#R)L5RNOF/R$GIW=c#RiF/RTh#c#RTKgGbW8deRiF/RVY y dMGbh.`MF/k B a^RTf dMNVh B RiRTWNVWMNVa C iRTK'`MF/RiUG^krwMh/a C GbW VwMh/GbWeh/Gbf4`a^RKMFNO/ B NVh#RTKtHdNVGIW f8kDKeRTabhiY W c/deR h/GIf4`?a^RTh#c(h#c/NVWKMNOFKHdNVGIW f4kDKMRTa ]c/deRQGIW=c#RiF/`NOF/c/GbHia^R'fgNOrWeRic/GIH'z kVFAHRTh4NOF/RQ`MF/klUDGIKMRTK BDC |RTK `!krGIW=c KMGI`kraIRThSLdMGbHdrG^UVRThJc/deRzkVFHR B Ric L5RiRTW9c L5k B RTNVKh)L)G^c/dc/dMRTG^F aIGIWeRkVz(HRTWc#RiFAhSNOc NVW NVWera^R c#k'c/dMRNO``aIG^RTK|MRTaIKQNVh

]7\.Hkrh A x: < h/GIW7 o : 7H9eY[q:

LdeRiFR 6Hkrh < h/GIW GIhc/deRwMWMG^cUVRTHc#kVF c/NVWMVRTWc$c#k c/dMR HAdMNVGIW+NGIhT] h/GIW Hkrh GIh<c/deRwMWMG^c<UVRTHc#kVF$`RiF`RTWKMGIHiwMaINOFuc#k8c/deRHAdMNVGIWnNeGIhNVWK

A $ 3@)

7H9eY :

y deRQd C KMF/kDK C WMNVfgGIHgzkVFHRQkrW B RTNVK HRTWc#RiFRTK NOc NVh4N9F/RTh/wa^ckVz)c/deRQh/dMRTNOFxSMkL 7H9eY :8GIh`MF/klUDGbKeRTK B=C c/deR X c#k VRTh(KeFANONO`M`MF/k Gbf8NOc/G^krW]

0) q ! f7 : Y z?L5RHkrWMh/GbKeRiFNSHdNVGIW

Page 78: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

z

kVz B RTNVKMhT]ec/deR c#kVc/NVa d C KMF/kDK C WMNVfgGIH$z kVFHRkrW B RTNVK \GIh

@),/ 9:

0) 7H9eY[:

zL5RNOF/RGIWc#RiFRTh#c#RTKGbWQNVh/HRiF/c/NVGIWMGbWe8c/deRfgNGIf wMf NVWMra^RNVWMKnfgNGIf wMf WDwMf B RiFkVz B RTNVKhGIWc/deR'HdMNVGIW zkVF NrG^UVRTW $ 3@) L5R WMRiRTK krWMa C c#k9HkrWMh/GbKeRiFc/dMGbh B NVaINVWHR GIW c/deR HRTW=c#RiFkVzc/deRHdNVGIW4LdeRiFR c/deRc#kVc/NVad C KeF/kK C WNVf8GIHuz kVFHRLGIaIa B Rf8NeGIfwfQY y deR z kVFAHR B NVaINVWMHR B Ric LuRiRTWgc/deRc/NVWeVRTW=c/GINVa<NVWMK\FANVKMGINVa(Hkrf8`krWMRTWc/h kVz c/deRtd C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIH4NVWK f8NOrWeRic/GbHgzkVFHRThNOcc/dMR HdNVGIWHRTW=c#RiF)NOF/R

xTo A Hkrh A 9 AA

:

A $& 3 )

hGIW7 o : 7H9eY :

xTo A JHkrh )h/GIW 9 AA

:

A $& 3 )

7\.Hkrh A x: 7H9eYIxip.:

m$h/GIWe4c/deR FRTaINOc/G^krWMh/dG^` 9 AA

7 <*x Oo:0OD]c/deR zkVFHR B NVaINVWHR C GIRTaIKMh

o $& 3 ) "7 <*x Oo: c/NVW 7H9eYIxVx:

9 $& 3 ) "7 <*x Oo: .Hkrh A xHkrh )h/GIW 7H9eYIxTo:

rG^UGIWec/deRfgNGIf wMf NVWeraIRSNVWMKnWDwMf B RiF kVz B RTNVKMh

c/NVW o 7H9eYIx:

x9 <

xxTq <

oo $ 3@)

7H9eYIxY9;:

y dMR'HAdMNVGIW f4kDKMRTauG^rWMkVF/RTh B kVc/d c/deRtd C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIH8GbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMh B Ric LuRiRTW c/deR B RTNVKMhNVWMKdMG^rdMRiF / kVFKeRiF'HkVF/F/RTHc/G^krWMh'c#k c/deR9f8NOrWeRic/GIH+GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhTY y k GbWMHiaIwMKeRc/deRTh#R+RRTHc/hi])LuR9`!RiF /zkVFf,h/GIf wMaINOc/GIkrWMh$kVz<NHdMNVGIW\kVz `NOFNVfgNOrWeRic/GIH B RTNVKMh L)G^c/d f8NOrWeRic/GIHgh/wMh/HRi`Mc/G B GIaIG^c C x7 3,4:4 p z:GIWc/deRh/dMRTNOFSMklL 7H9eY :LG^c/dQc/dMRNO`M`abG^RTKQ|MRTaIK (Y y dMRh/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWhNOF/RHkrWMKMwHc#RTKRTf4`?a^k C GIWe8c/dMRc#RTHdWMGIDweRTh)KMRTh/HFG B RTKnGIWc/deR`F/RiUDGIkrwMhHAdMNO`Mc#RiFh)LG^c/dc/deRd C KMF/kDK C /WMNVf8GbHGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMh(`MF/kUGIKeRTK BDC ~v Z ]=c/dMRf8NOrWeRic/GIH)GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhuNOF/R`MF/klUDGbKeRTK BDC c/dMR)f wec/wMNVaKMG^`!kra^R f4Ric/dekK NVwerf4RTW=c#RTK BDC c/deR4dMG^rdMRiF / kVFKeRiF f wMa^c/G^`!kra^R GIWMHiaIwMhG^krWf4Ric/dMkDKYt W+c/deR B NOF/FG^RiFzkVFHRV] 2 )0354 o[o QNVWMK ),3,4 1x pz ' / , WMG^c/GINVaIa C ]=c/deRHdMNVGIWNGIhGIhNVaIG^rWMRTKtLG^c/dtc/deRNO``aIG^RTK

Page 79: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

zV

.G^rweF/Rf9eY[sE(DwMGIaIG B FGIwMf h/dMNO`!RkVzeNHdNVGIWSkVz 1xip B RTNVKMhGIWNh/deRTNOFBSMkL LG^c/d KMG !RiF/RTW=cUONVaIweRThkVz $ 3@) Y y deRNO`M`?aIG^RTKfgNOrWeRic/GIH|MRTaIKGbh)GIWc/deR UVRiF/c/GIHiNVa.KMG^FRTHc/G^krWYt7 N.: $ 3@) @p pVpVpD]7 B :$ 3@) p pVpexTD]17 H:=$ 3@) p pVpro=]17 Kr:=$& 3 ) p pVpVqD]n7R8:=$ 3@) p pVp9.zD]7zV:$ 3@) *p pVpzK9e]f7;:$& 3 ) p pVprqD] 7R8: $& 3 ) *p pVp.Oo

Page 80: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

z

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

x 10−3

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Mashear

φ(d

egre

es)

.G^rweF/Rt9eY s y deR NVWera^R B Ric L5RiRTWc/dMR HAdMNVGIW+NGIh$GIWc/deRHRTW=c#RiF kVzc/deRHdMNVGIW+NVWMKc/deRNO``aIG^RTK|MRTaIKtklUVRiF$NFANVWeVRSkVz"$& 3 ) zkVFN8HAdMNVGIWtkVz 1xip B RTNVKMhiY

|MRTaIKNVWMKNVh$c/GIf8RRiUVkra^UVRTh$c/deRh/deRTNOFSMkL@F/kVc/NOc#RThi]KeRizkVFf8h$NVWMK]G^zh#c#F/krWMgRTWekrwerd] B FRTNDh)c/deRHdNVGIWY.G^rwMF/Rx9eY[+h/deklLhc/dMR RTDwMGIaIG B FGIwMf h/dNO`RgkVzNHAdMNVGIW kVz ,xip B RTNVKMhkUVRiF8NFNVWeVRkVz(ZNVh#krW9W=wMf B RiFh B RTa^klL6c/deRHFG^c/GbHiNVaUONVaIweR 7*$ '*),+ - 3@) 6p pVp.89oz:AY y deRh/dMRTNOF3SMklL R RiF/c/hJNc#kVFDweR8krW c/deRgHAdMNVGIW\L)dMGIHd HF/RTNOc#RThNVW NVWera^R B Ric LuRiRTW c/deRgHAdMNVGIW NGIhNVWMK\c/dMRgNO`M`aIGIRTK9|MRTaIKYy dMGbhuR!RTHcGIh<R edMG B GIc#RTK NOcNVaIa$ 3@) 7F.G^rweF/R 9eY[:AY y dMGIh5NVWera^R f4RTNVh/weF/RTKQNOc c/dMRJHRTW=c#RiFkVzc/deRHAdMNVGIWnGbhh/deklLWQNVhN4z wMWMHc/GIkrWQkVz.ZNVh#krWW=wMf B RiFGIW .G^rweFR9eY DYu_<c)aIkL $ 3@) ] VF/kL)haIGIWMRTNOFa C LGIc/dtc/deRSh/deRTNOFFANOc#RNVWMKQNOcdMGIrdeRiF $& 3 ) VFkLh)h#c#RiRi`a C c#k8c/deRS`!krGIW=c NOcLdMGIHAdtc/deRHdNVGIW9z FANVHc/weF/RThiY W9NVKMKMG^c/GIkrWc#ktc/deR4VFkLc/d9kVz ] LuR4h#RiR4c/dMNOc NOcSdMGIrd+hdeRTNOF FNOc#RThJc/deR4HdNVGIWLGIabaKMRiUDGINOc#R zF/krf GIc/haIGIWeRTNOFhdMNO`!RJGbWc#kgNVW X / h/dMNO`!Rx7F.G^rweF/RThe9eY[07R8:]/a9eY[07 d: :AY

RS`!RiF/zkVFf%N4h#RiFGIRTh<kVzh/GbfwMabNOc/G^krWMhuc#kgKeRic#RiFf8GbWeRJc/deR f8NGbfwMf ZNVh#krWnWDwMf B RiF$ '*),+ - 3@)c/dMNOc(NHdMNVGIW8kVz B RTNVKMhL)GIaIaWekVc B FRTN?Y y deRTh/Rh/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWMhNOFR`!RiF/z kVFAf4RTKz kVFuHdMNVGIWhHkrWc/NVGbW&/GIWe4we`c#k xz B RTNVKMhiY y deR WDwMf B RiF kVz B RTNVKMh GIh<`a^kVc#c#RTKNVhNz wMWMHc/G^krWtkVz.c/deRSf8NeGIf wMfZNVh#krWQW=wf B RiF5rG^UVRTW B=C c/deRJzwMabah/GIf wMaINOc/GIkrWMhuGbW5.G^rweFRThU9eYIxip,7 B :5NVWMK 9eYIxip,7 N.:AY y dMR$f8NeGIf wMfWDwMf B RiFkVz B RTNVKMhuGIW8NSHAdMNVGIWgKMRTHF/RTNVh#RThuLG^c/d4c/deRJZNVh/krWgWDwMf B RiF(hGIWMHRc/deR)d C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIH5zkVFHRkrW c/deR+HAdMNVGIW GIWMHF/RTNVh/RThgLGIc/d c/deR9HdMNVGbW a^RTWMVc/dY6_$h'Hkrf8`NOF/RTK c#k c/deR9HdNVGIW f8kDKeRTa ]7H9eYIxY9;:NVWMK c/deRtKMNVh/deRTK aIGIWeR GIWy.G^rwMF/R 9eYIxip,7 B :A]uc/deRth/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWMh`MF/RTKMGbHcN+VF/RTNOc#RiF8HdMNVGbW a^RTWMVc/d zkVF$ 3@) p p9eYn WQNVKMKMG^c/GIkrW]DNOc)a^kL&$ 3@) ]ec/deR h/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWh C G^RTaIKtN4KeRTHiN C GIWtHdMNVGIWa^RTWeVc/dz NVh#c#RiFc/dMNVWnc/dMNOcrG^UVRTW BDC c/deRHdNVGIWnf4kKeRTa17>$ A A 3@) :AY

Page 81: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

qOp

10−2

100

101

Mashear

N

10−3

10−2

10−1

100

101

Mashear

N

.G^rweF/R39eYIxip&s37 N.:5ZNeGIf wMf%W=wf B RiF(kVz B RTNVKh ,GbW N HdMNVGbW NVh<N zwWMHc/G^krW8kVz $& 3 ) NVh5rG^UVRTWBDC v Z LG^c/d c/deRg|DRTK KMG^`!kra^Rf4kDKMRTa7 KMNVh/d&/ KMkVc#c#RTK aIGIWMR L)G^c/d\h/DwMNOF/R8f8NOF VRiFhV:A]c/deRgf wec/wMNVaKMG^`!kra^R f4kKeRTaP7 KNVh/deRTKgabGIWeR LG^c/d8kV`RTWgc#FGINVWerwaINOF(f8NOF VRiFAhV:NVWMK8c/deRz wMaIaef8NOrWMRic/GIHf4kKeRTaP7 h/kraIGIKaIGIWMRLG^c/d+HiG^FHiwaINOF)f8NOF VRiFhV:AY 7 B :$ZNGIf wMf W=wf B RiF$kVz B RTNVKMh GIW+N'HAdMNVGIW9NVhJN'zwMWHc/G^krWkVz$ 3@) NVhrGIUVRTW BDC ~v Z LGIc/dQc/deRz wMaIa f8NOrWeRic/GIHf4kDKMRTan7 h#kraIGIKaIGIWeR L)G^c/dnHiG^FHiwaINOFf8NOF VRiFAhV:A]X c#k VRThKMFNO4aINTLLGIc/d | DRTKtKMG^`!kra^R$f4kKeRTaf7kV`RTWth/DwMNOF/R f8NOF VRiFhV:5NVWMK'c/deR HdNVGIWQf4kKeRTaf7H9eYIxY9;:7 KMNVh/dMRTKnaIGIWeR8:AY

y k wMWMKeRiFh/c/NVWMKSc/deR<F/RTNVh/krW B RTdGIWMK c/deR KMG RiF/RTWHR B Ric L5RiRTWc/deR HdMNVGbW f8kDKeRTaDNVWMK c/deR<h/GIf wMaINK/c/G^krWMh(F/RTh/wMaIc/hi]rL5R`!RiF/z kVFAf NVKMKMG^c/GIkrWMNVaeh/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWh.LdeRiF/RL5R|Fh#cRTf4`aIk C c/deR| DRTK8NVWKgf wec/wMNVaKMG^`!kra^R4f4kKeRTaIhJzkVFc/dMRgf8NOrWeRic/GIH GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMh B Ric LuRiRTW c/deR B RTNVKMh B wecSF/Ric/NVGIW NnHkrf4`a^Ric#R'KeRY/h/HFGI`Mc/G^krW'kVz.c/deRSd C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIH$GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhTY y deRTh#R FRTh/wMa^c/h NOF/RShdekLWGIW .G^rweF/R 9eYIxip,7 N.:AY Rh#RiR4c/dMNOcc/deR4GIWMHiaIwMhG^krWkVz5c/deR8dMGIrdeRiF fwMaIc/G^`!kra^RTh)hdMG^zc/hJc/deR8HFG^c/GIHiNVaZNVh#krW\WDwMf B RiF c#kndG^rdeRiFUONVaIweRThi] B wec4Kek=RTh4HAdMNVWeVRnc/dMRnh/HiNVaIGIWe9kVz LGIc/d $ 3@) Y W N h#RTHkrWMK h#Ric4kVz$hGIfwaINOc/G^krWMhi]GIW+NVKMKMG^c/GIkrWnc#ktwMh/GIWe krWMa C `!krGIW=c)KMGI`kraIRThc#k'F/RTh#kra^UVRc/deRf8NOrWeRic/GIH GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhT]L5RG^rWekVF/R c/deRd C KeFkDK C WMNVf8GbHGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMh B Ric L5RiRTW c/deR B RTNVKMhiY Rk B c/NVGbW9F/RTh/wMa^c/hR7kV`!RTW h/DwMNOF/RThJGIW GIrweF/R9eYIxip,7 B : :(c/dMNOc<HkVF/F/RTh#`!krWMKgLuRTabaMLG^c/dgc/deRUONVaIweRThu`MF/RTKGIHc#RTK BDC c/deR)HAdMNVGIW'f4kKeRTa Y y deRiF/RizkVF/RV]DRTfR/`a^k C GbWeN X c#k VRTh KeFANO NO`M`F/k eGIf8NOc/G^krW'GIW=c#F/kKMwMHRTh5NVW'wWMKeRiF/RTh#c/Gbf8NOc/G^krW kVzc/deRJf8NGbfwMf HdNVGIWa^RTWeVc/dNVWMKQz NVGIaIh5c#kgF/RTHklUVRiF)c/dMR `MF/kV`!RiFh/HiNVaIGIWM4kVz~c/dMGbh<U NVaIwMR LG^c/dtc/deRZNVh#krWW=wMf B RiFTY

y dMRJd C KeF/kK C WNVf8GIH)RRTHc/hNVaIkrWe4c/deRSa^RTWeVc/dtkVz~c/deRSHdNVGIWQf8N C'B R GIWMHiaIwMKMRTK GIW=c#k4c/deR HdNVGIW

Page 82: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

qx

f4kKeRTawMh/GbWe4N8h/a^RTWMKMRiF B kK C NO``MF/k eGIf8NOc/GIkrWQLdMGIHAdtrG^UVRKeFANO8Hk=RgHiGIRTWc/h`RiF)wMWMG^c<a^RTWeVc/dnNVh

o

aIkVr7 8Oo 0: x Oo7H9eYIxz:

9

aIkVr7 8Oo 0:<*x Oo 7H9eYIxTq:

y deRiFRiz kVF/RV]Dc/deR$KeFNO krW N B RTNVK'GIWgc/deR / KMG^FRTHc/G^krWgGIh5o NVWMKto Gbh(c/dMNOc5GIW8c/dMR / KMGIF/RTHc/G^krWYy deRTh/RSf4kDKG^|HiNOc/G^krWMh GbWtc/deRSKeFNO C G^RTaIK'c/deRF/RiUDGbh#RTKQHdMNVGbWnf4kKeRTa!RT=wNOc/G^krWMh

9 A $HkrhA 9 A

A:

A $ 3@)

h/GIW7 o : 7H9eYIx:

9 A Hkrh )h/GbW 9 AA

:

A $ 3@)

7\.Hkrh A x: 7H9eYIxT:

LdMGbHdtLG^c/d o :rGIUVR

$ 3@) "7 <*x Oo:

a^kV <x Oo c/NVW 7H9eYIx:

$ 3@) "7 <*x Oo:

a^kV x Oo

.Hkrh A xHkrh hGIW 7H9eY[oOp.:

ekVF$a^krWe8HdNVGIWMha^kV < x Oo a^kV x OoD]NVWMK 9.zJNVWMK

7 <*x Oo:a^kV <*x Oo

$& 3 )

7H9eY[ox:

W.G^rweF/R9eYIxVxLuR`a^kVc c/deRSFRTh/wMa^c/h zF/krf c/dMRSzwaIah/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWh NVWMKQc/deRSUONVaIweRThrG^UVRTW BDC 7H9eY[ox:AY_$a^c/dekrwerdc/deRUONVaIweRTh)h#c/GIaIaKMG RiF B=C NgzNVHc#kVF$kVz x9e]!c/deR NOVF/RiRTf4RTW=c$Gbhf wMHd B Ric#c#RiF$NVWMKc/deRh/HiNVaIGbWegGIh)LuRTabaF/Ri`MFkDKMwHRTKY_ h/GIf8GbaINOFf4kKMG^|HiNOc/GIkrWQc#k c/dMR HAdMNVGIWf8kDKeRTadMNVh B RiRTWHkrWMh/GbKeRiF/RTK V ] B wec~c/dMR<aIkVrNOFG^c/dMf8GbHc#RiFf8hGbWc/deR KeRTWMkrf8GIWMNOc#kVFhkVz?c/deR KeFNO Hk=R HiG^RTWc/hc/dMNOcNOF/R<RTh/h#RTW=c/GINVac#k8F/Ri`F/kDKwMHRJc/deRHkVF/F/RTHc)h/HiNVaIGIWe4L5RiF/RGIrWekVF/RTKY

2 - $% % 4rwh#c NVhL5RQKMGIK GIW NVWMNVa C TGIWe+c/deR B RTdNTUG^kVFkVz)N9HdMNVGbW GIW N9h/dMRTNOFSMkLS](LuRt|MFh/c KMGbh/HiwMh/hc/deRRTDwMGIaIG B FGIwMf kVzN8HAdMNVGIWQkVz`NOFNVfgNOrWeRic/GIH `NOFc/GIHia^RThGIWtc/dMR F/kVc/NOc/GIWe8|RTaIK

7 h/GIW7 ^: /Hkrh7 : /p.: 7H9eY[oVo:

Page 83: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

qVo

10−3

10−2

10−1

100

101

102

Mashear

N(N

+1/2)/

(log(N

)+

1/2)

.G^rweF/R 9eYIxVxsgZNeGIf wMfWDwMf B RiFkVz B RTNVKh 3GIW\NHdMNVGIW NVhNzwWMHc/G^krW kVz $ 3@) NVhrG^UVRTWBDC ~v Z LGIc/dQc/deR zwMabaf8NOrWeRic/GIH f4kKeRTaU7 h#krabGIKnaIGIWMRSLG^c/dnHiGIFHiwMaINOF$f8NOF VRiFhV:NVWMKc/deRHkVF/FRTHc#RTKHdNVGIWnf4kKeRTa17H9eY[ox:t7 KMNVh/deRTKnabGIWeR8:AY

wMh/GbWe c/deRHAdMNVGIWgf8kDKeRTaNVh(`MFRTh#RTWc#RTK GIW K9 YD RJf8N C F/RiLFG^c#R c/dMR)h#c#F/RTWMVc/d8kVzc/deRGbWc#RiF/`?NOF/c/GIHia^RKMG^`!kra^R$zkVFHR $GIWQc#RiFfgh kVz $ ),/5- NVh

xTo A $& )0/1-

7H9eY[o:

NVWMK NVKekV`McuNF/RizRiF/RTWMHRzFNVf4R|DRTKgLG^c/dgF/RTh#`!RTHcc#k c/deRF/kVc/NOc/GIWM|MRTaIKY y NDGbWec/deR X c#k VRTh<KeFNONO`M`MFk eGIf8NOc/G^krW]ec/dMRSKeFNO4zkVFHRSkrW B RTNVK \GIhrG^UVRTW BDC

0) q ! 7H9eY[oK9;:

LdeRiFR L NVWMK GIhc/dMR)wMWMGIcUVRTHc#kVF GIW8c/deR ,/ KMG^F/RTHc/G^krW GIWgNH C abGIWMKeFGbHiNVaeHk=kVFKGIWMNOc#Rh C h#c#RTf HRTW=c#RiF/RTKnNOc c/deR kVFGIrGIWYfekVFN4aIGIWMRTNOF<HAdMNVGIW]c/dMGbhuzkVFHR LGbaIa B R GIW'c/deR KMG^F/RTHc/GIkrW `!RiF/`!RTW&/KMGIHiwaINOFJc#kQc/deR8HdMNVGbW NGIhTYm$WMaIG VR c/dMR8HiNVh#R4kVzuc/dMR8h/deRTNOF SMklLS]L5R8WeRiRTK krWMa C c#knHkrWMh/GbKeRiF c/deRzkVFHR B NVaINVWHRSNOcc/deRHAdMNVGIWnHRTW=c#RiF)GIWtc/dMRKMG^F/RTHc/GIkrWt`RiF`RTWKMGIHiwMaINOFuc#k8c/deRHAdMNVGIWnNeGIh

xTo A 9 AA

:

xTo A $ )0/5-

h/GIWh7 o : 7H9eY[oz:

Page 84: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

q

LdMGbHd B RTHkrf4RTh

$ )0/5- < x

o hGIW7 o : 7H9eY[oVq:

X GIWHRc/deRiF/R$GIh5Wek d C KeF/kK C WNVf8GIH<zkVFHR$GbW8c/deRJKMG^F/RTHc/GIkrWgkVzc/deRJHdNVGIW NeGIhi]Dc/deRJHdMNVGbWgLGbaIa B F/RTNkrWMHRSc/dMRGIW=c#RiF/`NOF/c/GIHiaIRJfgNOrWeRic/GIH zkVFHRThGIWnc/dMGIh KMG^FRTHc/G^krW B RTHkrf4R iRiF/keY y dMGIh<kHiHiweFh LdMRTW

.Hkrh A x *p 7H9eY[o:

kVFJLdeRTW+Hkrh x =7 zK9 :AY dMGba^RSc/dMGIh$GIh)c/deRNVWera^RNOc$L)dMGIHdc/deRHdMNVGIW+LGbaIa B F/RTN]c/deRJGIW=c#RiF/`NOF/c/GIHiaIRf8NOrWeRic/GIH$zkVFHR$`RiF`RTWKMGIHiwMaINOFc#k c/deRJHdMNVGbW'NeGIh5GIh5f8NGbfwMf LdeRTW 9.z Yy deRiFRiz kVF/R$G^zNHAdMNVGIW'NOc 9.z c#k c/deR$NO``aIG^RTK4|RTaIKgGIh5WekVc5N B a^Rc#k B NVaINVWHR)c/deR$d C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIHzkVFHRThi]G^c$LGIaIaGbWeRiUDGIc/N B a C F/kVc/NOc#R4c#k c/dMRHFAG^c/GIHiNVaUONVaIweR kVz zK9 NVWMK B F/RTN K9 Y j<NVh#RTK+krWc/dMGIhT]eLuRSc/NVRc/deR UONVaIweR kVz 9.z c#kgHiNVabHiwMaINOc#RSc/deRf8NGbfwMf WDwMf B RiF kVz B RTNVKMhGIWtc/deRSHdNVGIWrG^UGIWec/deRfgNGIf wMf WDwMf B RiF kVz B RTNVKMh NVh

x9 <

xxTq <

$ )0/5-

7H9eY[oV:

eFkrf c/deR `NOFc/GIHia^RY/ B NVh#RTKQhGIfwaINOc/G^krWMhi]DL5Rh#RiR c/dMNOcN4HAdMNVGIWnhw B 2#RTHc c#k8N4F/kVc/NOc/GIWe4|RTaIKtLGIaIaB RTdMNTUVR8GbW+NQfgNVWMWeRiF h/GIf8GbaINOF)c#knNQHAdMNVGIW GIW9NQh/dMRTNOFSMkLSY_<cSa^klL U NVaIwMRThJkVz $ )0/5- ]c/deR4HdNVGIWLGIabaF/RTf8NVGIW aIGIWeRTNOF B wecc/deR UGIh/Hkrwhh#c#F/RThh#RTh LGIaIaRTh/c/N B aIGIh/d NVW NVWMra^R B Ric LuRiRTW c/deR'HdMNVGIW NeGIhNVWMKgc/deR)NO`M`?aIG^RTK4|MRTabKY_<c<dMG^rdMRiF(UONVaIweRThkVz$ ),/5- ] B wecuh/c/GIaIa B RTa^kL c/deR$HFG^c/GIHiNVaU NVaIwMRV]c/deR$NVWera^RB Ric L5RiRTWgc/dMRHdMNVGbWgNeGIhNVWMKgc/deRNO`M`abG^RTK|MRTaIKLGbaIaeGIWMHF/RTNVh/RNVWMK4c/deR$HdMNVGbW4LGIaIaeKMRiUDGINOc#Rz F/krfG^c/haIGIWMRTNOF5h/dNO`R$NVWMKtKeRiUVRTa^kV`QGIW=c#k NHiweFUVRTK X / h/dMNO`!RVY y deR)KG RiFRTWc5RT=wGIaIG B FAGIwMf h/dMNO`!RThuR dG B G^c#RTKBDC NHAdMNVGIW8kVz 1xip B RTNVKMh(GbW8c/dMGIh(F/RirGIf4R$NOF/RJh/dekL)WgGIW5GIrweF/R9eYIxToDY y deR)NVWMra^R B Ric L5RiRTW'c/deRNO`M`abG^RTK'|MRTaIKQNVWMKQc/dMRSHdMNVGIWNGIhNVhN4z wMWMHc/G^krWtkVz$ )0/5- GIhh/dMkLWQGIW .G^rwMF/R9eYIxDY

_$h L)G^c/dSc/deR5h/deRTNOFDSMkL] L5R5`RiFz kVFf6`NOF/c/GIHiaIRY/ B NVh#RTKhGIfwaINOc/G^krWMhkVzec/dMR5HAdMNVGIWwh/GIWeN)UONOFG^Ric CkVz f8NOrWeRic/GIH4NVWK\d C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIH f4kKeRTaIhJc#knk B c/NVGIW c/deRgHFAG^c/GIHiNVaZNVh#krW WDwMf B RiF zkVFHAdMNVGIWMh kVzwe` c#k B RTNVK W=wf B RiF xzDY9_)h B Riz kVF/RV]f8kDKMGIz C GIWeQc/deR'f8NOrWeRic/GIH'GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhh/dG^z c#RTK c/deRf8NeGIf wMf NVaIaIkL<N B a^RWDwMf B RiFkVz B RTNVKMh)c#k'a^klLuRiF$UONVaIweRThi] B wec`F/RTh#RiF/UVRTKc/deRhHiNVaIGIWe kVz LG^c/d$ )0/5- 7F.G^rweF/Rx9eYIxY9X7 N.: :AY_*deRTW c/deR d C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIHGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMh B Ric LuRiRTW c/deR8`NOFc/GIHia^RThJL5RiF/RG^rWekVFRTK]c/deR h/HiNVabGIWe HdMNVWeVRTK6NVWMK c/deR `MF/RTKMGbHc/G^krWMh kVzc/deR aIGIWMRTNOFtHAdMNVGIW*f4kKeRTa7H9eY[oV:'L5RiF/RF/Ri`MFkDKMwHRTK 7F.G^rweF/R9eYIxY9X7 B : :AYn RJNOrNVGIWgGIWHkVF/`!kVFNOc#Rc/deR$d C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIH5R!RTHc/h5GbWc#kc/deRHdNVGIW

Page 85: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

qK9

.G^rweF/R9eYIxTos E(DwMGIaIG B FGIwMf HAdMNVGIWHkrWM|MrweFNOc/G^krWhQNVWMKkVFG^RTW=c/NOc/G^krWMhnz kVFN HdMNVGIW*kVz xipB RTNVKMhF/RTaINOc/G^UVR c#k+N+Hia^kH DLGIh#R F/kVc/NOc/GIWe+|MRTaIK LG^c/d KG RiFRTWcU NVaIwMRThkVz$ ),/5- Y y deR KMGIF/RTHc/G^krWkVz(c/dMRNO``aIG^RTK+f8NOrWeRic/GIH |MRTabK+GbWRTNVHAd\GIf8NOVR4GIhJh/deklLW BDC c/deR4NOF/F/klLSY 7 N.: $ )0/5- p pD] 7 B :$ )0/5- *p pzD]f7 H:$& )0/5- *p p.=] 7 K: $& )0/1- *p pD]D7R8: $& )0/1- p IxVxO]D7zV:$ )0/5- p IxD] 7;:$ )0/5- *p IxzD]D7R8: $& )0/5- p Ix

Page 86: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

qz

0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12 0.14 0.16 0.180

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Marot

φ(d

egre

es)

.G^rweF/R 9eYIxs y deRSNVWera^R B Ric L5RiRTWnc/deRSHAdMNVGIWQNeGIh GIWtc/deRSHRTW=c#RiFkVzc/deRSHAdMNVGIWQNVWMKtc/deRSNO``aIG^RTK|MRTaIKtklUVRiF$NFANVWeVRSkVz"$& )0/5- z kVFNgHdMNVGIWtkVz 1xip B RTNVKMhiY

10−1

100

100

101

Marot

N

10−1

100

100

101

Marot

N

.G^rweF/Rt9eYIxY90s 7 N.:$ZNGIf wMf W=wf B RiF$kVz B RTNVKMh GbWN'HdMNVGbWNVhJN zwMWHc/G^krWkVz8$& )0/1- NVh$rG^UVRTWBDC v Z LG^c/d c/deRg|DRTK KMG^`!kra^Rf4kDKMRTa7 KMNVh/d&/ KMkVc#c#RTK aIGIWMR L)G^c/d\h/DwMNOF/R8f8NOF VRiFhV:A]c/deRgf wec/wMNVaKMG^`!kra^R f4kKeRTaP7 KNVh/deRTKgabGIWeR LG^c/d8kV`RTWgc#FGINVWerwaINOF(f8NOF VRiFAhV:NVWMK8c/deRz wMaIaef8NOrWMRic/GIHf4kKeRTaP7 h/kraIGIKaIGIWMRLG^c/d+HiG^FHiwaINOF)f8NOF VRiFhV:AY 7 B :$ZNGIf wMf W=wf B RiF$kVz B RTNVKMh GIW+N'HAdMNVGIW9NVhJN'zwMWHc/G^krWkVz$ )0/5- NVh rG^UVRTW BDC ~v Z L)G^c/d\c/deR'z wMaIa(fgNOrWeRic/GIH'f4kDKMRTa37 h#kraIGbK aIGbWeR8LG^c/d HiG^FHiwMabNOFf8NOF VRiFAhV:A]X c#k VRThKMFNO4aINTLLGIc/d | DRTKtKMG^`!kra^R$f4kKeRTaf7kV`RTWth/DwMNOF/R f8NOF VRiFhV:5NVWMK'c/deR HdNVGIWQf4kKeRTaf7H9eY[oV:7 KMNVh/dMRTKnaIGIWeR8:AY

Page 87: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

qVq

10−1

100

100

101

102

Marot

N(N

+1/2)/

(log(N

)+

1/2)

.G^rweF/R 9eYIxzsZNGIf wMf WDwMf B RiFJkVz B RTNVKMh GbW+NtHAdMNVGIW NVh N'zwWMHc/G^krW+kVz8$ )0/5- NVhJrG^UVRTW B=C~v Z LG^c/dc/deR<z wMaIaDf8NOrWeRic/GIH<f4kKeRTah7 h#kraIGIKaIGbWeR(LGIc/dHiG^FAHiwMaINOFf8NOF VRiFh : NVWKc/dMR<HkVFF/RTHc#RTK8HdNVGIWf4kKeRTa17H9eY Op.:t7 KMNVh/deRTKnabGIWeR8:AY

f4kKeRTa BDC wMh/GbWeNha^RTWMKeRiF B kK C NO`M`MFk eGIf8NOc/G^krWgz kVF5c/deR)KMFNO`!RiF5wMWMG^ca^RTWMVc/dg`!RiF/`!RTWMKMGbHiwMaINOF.c#kc/deRHAdMNVGIWQNeGIh Y1*G^c/dQc/dMGbh f4kDKG^|HiNOc/G^krW]c/deR FRTh/wMa^c/GIWM `!RiF/`!RTWMKGIHiwMaINOFuz kVFHR B NVaINVWMHRSGIh

9 A 9A A:

xTo A $ ),/5-

h/GIWh7 o : 7H9eY[o:

LdMGbHd B RTHkrf4RThL)G^c/d 9.z 7 <*x Oo:a^kV <*x Oo

q$& )0/1-

7H9eY Op.:

.G^rweF/RU9eYIxz$h/dekL)hk7H9eY Op.:~Hkrf4`NOFRTKL)G^c/dSc/deRuF/RTh/wMaIc/hzF/krf6c/dMRuz wMaIarhGIfwaINOc/G^krWMhiYB RiF/RV]VR eHRTaIa^RTW=cNOVF/RiRTf4RTW=cGIhJzkrwMWMK9GIWKMGIHiNOc/GIWe c/deR8GIf4`!kVF/c/NVWHRkVz5c/deR8d C KeFkDK C WMNVf8GbHGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhJc#kQk B c/NVGIWc/deRHkVFF/RTHc`MF/RTKGIHc/G^krWMh<kVz.HdMNVGbWQz FANVHc/weF/RVY

!&'( ) @ & -)./ & /0 !5!A-:78u0/24

_,FRTHRTWch/RiFG^RTh'kVzR `!RiFGIf4RTW=c/NVaJh#c/wMKMGIRTh e]JxVxz R NVf8GbWeRTK*c/deR9RiUVkraIwec/G^krW*kVz NVWGIWMG^c/GbNVaIa Cdekrf4kVVRTWMRikrwMh h/wh#`!RTWMh/G^krW$kVz`NOFNVf8NOrWMRic/GIH`NOF/c/GbHia^RThh/w B 2 RTHcc#kNVWNO`M`aIGIRTK)FkVc/NOc/GIWe|MRTabKY y deR Ck B h#RiFUVRTK c/dNOczkVF aIkL U NVaIwMRThkVz $ )0/5- ].c/deR'`NOF/c/GIHia^RThNOVVF/RirNOc#Rnc#k+z kVFAf:aIGbWeRTNOFHAdMNVGIWMhc/dMNOcF/kVc/NOc#RL)G^c/dc/deR zF/RT=wMRTWMH C kVzc/deR NO`M`aIGIRTK|RTaIKY y deRNTUVRiFNOVR$a^RTWeVc/dkVzc/deRHdNVGIWMh.LGIaba=KeRTHFRTNVh#RLG^c/d $& )0/1- wMW=c/GIaNgHFGIc/GIHiNVaUONVaIweRGbhF/RTNVHAdeRTKY y dMGbhHFG^c/GIHiNVaU NVaIwMRHkVF/F/RTh#`!krWMKh LG^c/dc/deRSUONVaIweR

Page 88: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

q

kVz$& )0/1- NOc LdGIHdQN4Kekrw B a^Ric5LGIaIa?|MFh#c<R edMG B GIcukrh/HiGbaIaINOc/G^krWMh<GIW'c/deRSh/Ri`NOFNOc/G^krWQKMGbh#c/NVWMHRVYf*dMGIa^Rc/deRHdMNVGbW+h/c#FwMHc/weF/RGIh$Wekta^krWeVRiF h#c/N B a^RLdeRTW $ )0/5- $&('*),+.-)0/5- ]!NOVVFRirNOc/G^krW\h#c/GIabakHiHiweFhJNVWMKGIWMh/c#RTNVK9krWeR4k B h#RiF/UVRThSc/deR4z kVFAf8NOc/G^krW kVz<h/f8NVaIa`abNVWMNOF h#c#FwMHc/weFRThiY y knh/GbfwMabNOc#R c/dGIh B RTdMNTUG^kVFT]L5R9HkrWh/GIKeRiFQNVWGIWMGIc/GINVaIa C dekrf4kVVRTWMRikrwMhQKMGIh#c#FAG B wec/G^krW kVz`NOFANVf8NOrWeRic/GIH+`NOF/c/GbHia^RThtGIW*N c/dMF/RiRY/KMGIf8RTWMh/G^krWMNVaKekrf8NVGIWLG^c/d`RiFAG^kDKGIH B krwMWMKMNOF C HkrWMKG^c/G^krWMh~GIWRTNVHAd4KMG^F/RTHc/GIkrWY y deR<f wec/wMNVa=|WMG^c#RY/KMG^`!kra^Ruf4kDKMRTakVz VDY[oDY[oSh/we`M`aIRTf4RTWc#RTK B=C c/deR fwMaIc/G^`!kra^R(GIWMHiabwMh/G^krWSf8kDKeRTa=`MF/klUDGbKeRTh c/dMR5f8NOrWMRic/GIHGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhLdMGIaIR v Z:F/RTh#kra^UVRThc/deRd C KeFkDK C WMNVf8GbH$GbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMhiY y deRSHkraIaIGIhG^krW B NOF/FGIRiF LG^c/d ),3,4 x pro ' / NVWMK 2 ),3,4 o[o `MFkUGIKeRTh'c/deR\h#kraIGbK B kK C HkrW=c/NVHciY%_<cQRTNVHAdc/GIf8RTh#c#Ri`]c/deR X c#k VRThRTDwMNOc/G^krWMhNVWMK c/deR'RT=wNOc/G^krWMh z kVF c/deRQf8NOrWeRic/GbHg|MRTabK NOF/Rth#kra^UVRTK wMhGIWeN ekrweFAG^RiFHkraIa^kHiNOc/G^krW f4Ric/dMkDK9LdMRiF/RRVK9 ? `!krGIW=c/hJNOF/R8wMh#RTK9GIW+c/deR8fgNOrWeRic/GIH |MRTaIK9HiNVaIHiwMabNOc/G^krW NVWMK ozVq ?NOF/R+wMh#RTK c#k h#kra^UVRnc/dMR X c#k VRTh RT=wNOc/G^krWMhiY y deRh/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWMh4NOFR`!RiF/zkVFf4RTK wMhGIWe\N\`?NOFNVaIa^RTaHkKeRFwW8krW_VoS`MFkDHRTh/h/kVFh(NVWMK c/deR$_)KMNVfgh / j<NVh/dezkVF/c/d h/RTHkrWMKgkVFAKeRiF5hHdeRTf4RJGIhuwMh#RTK8c#kwe`KMNOc#Rc/deRS`?NOF/c/GIHia^RS`!krh/GIc/G^krWMhiY y deRh/GIf wMaINOc/GIkrWnHkrWc/NVGbWMh xVoOpg`NOFc/GIHia^RThL)dMGIHdHkVF/F/RTh#`!krWMKMhc#k NUVkraIwMf8R z FNVHc/GIkrWQkVz p pVp.=Y

RnHkrWMhGIKeRiFc L5k U NVabweRTh kVz $ )0/5- ] $ )0/5- p [o+LdMGIHAd Gbh B RTa^klL%c/deRQHFG^c/GIHiNVa5UONVaIweRQNVWMK$ )0/5- o pgLdMGIHAdnGIhN B klUVRc/deR HFG^c/GIHiNVaUONVaIweRVY5_)h)GIWQc/deRR D`!RiFGIf8RTWc/hi]eL5Rh/RiRc/dMNOcGIz $ )0/5-GIh B RTaIkL c/deR5HFAG^c/GIHiNVarUONVaIweRV]VHAdMNVGIWMhKekzkVFf@NVWMKF/kVc/NOc#R<LG^c/dSc/dMRuNO`M`abG^RTK |MRTaIK_7F.G^rweF/RU9eYIxTq:AYf RNVaIh#k4k B h#RiF/UVRSc/deRSKMRiz kVFfgNOc/G^krWnNVWMKQzFNVHc/weFR kVz~c/deRNOVVF/RirNOc#RThJNVh c/deR C F/RTNVHdN4HFG^c/GIHiNVaaIRTWeVc/dYj<NVh#RTK krW c/dMR F/RThwMa^c/hSkVz c/dMR `MFRiUDG^krwhh#RTHc/G^krWhi].c/deR f8NeGIf wMf HdMNVGIW a^RTWeVc/d z kVF c/dMGIh HiNVh#RtGIh xipY<_ B klUVRc/deRHFAG^c/GIHiNVaZNVh#krWWDwMf B RiFT]eLuRk B h#RiF/UVRNgU NOFAG^Ric C kVzh#c/N B a^Rc L5k KMGIf8RTWMh/G^krWMNVah#c#FwHc/weF/RTh 7F.G^rweF/R 9eYIx:GIKeRTW=c/GIHiNVac#k4c/dekrh#RSh#RiRTWnGbW c/dMR$R `!RiFGIf4RTW=c/hiYf*deRTWQHkrf4`NOFRTKQc#k4c/deR$ )0/5- *p [oJHiNVh#RV]rzRiL5RiF`NOF/c/GIHia^RThL5RiF/R<z krwWMK c#kJNOVVFRirNOc#RVY y deR<HiaIwMh/c#RiFhz kVFf8RTK wM` c#kSHiabwMh#c#RiFh/G iR ' pNOFR)h/deklLWgGbW .G^rweF/R9eYIxTDY(m)WaIG VRaIGbWeRTNOF(NOVVF/RirNOc/G^krW]eLuR$h#RiRc/dMNOc<N B kUVR ' zD]c L5ktKMGIf4RTWMhG^krWMNVa!HiaIwMh#c#RiFAhkVzN8HRiF/c/NVGbWh/GiRHiNVWdNTUVRKG RiFRTWchdMNO`!RThiY y deR B RTdMNTUG^kVF)kVzc/dMRTh#Rc C `!RTh kVzNOVVF/RirNOc#RThJGIWQh/deRTNOFSMkLh)dMNVh B RiRTWQGIW=UVRTh#c/G^rNOc#RTKR D`!RiFGIf8RTWc/NVaIa C GIW xToVo Y

y kgR eNVf8GIWeR c/dMRHdNVWeVRGIWQhdMNO`!RNVWMKnWDwMf B RiFkVz.HiabwMh#c#RiFh zkVFf4RTKN B kUVR $ '*),+ -),/5- ]?ZRTaIa^R_-$[)'*c .HkrWMKMwMHc#RTKKMGIHAdeF/krGIh/f R D`!RiFGIf8RTWc/h L)deRiF/RSc/deR C f4RTNVhweF/RTKnc/dMRKMG !RiF/RTWMHR GIWnaIGIrdcR c/GIWMHc/G^krW `?NOFNVaIa^RTa NVWMK `RiF`RTWKMGIHiwMaINOFc#k\c/deRNeGIh4kVzJc/deRHiaIwMh#c#RiFhTY y deRQzkrwMWMK c/dMNOc B RTaIkLc/deRgHFAG^c/GIHiNVa(ZNVh#krW W=wMf B RiFT] F/RTf8NVGIWMhHkrWMh#c/NVW=ch/GIWHR8c/deRgHAdMNVGIW h/c#FwMHc/weF/R8Gbhh#c/N B aIRgNVWMKHkrf4`NOFAN B a^RuWDwMf B RiFh kVz`NOF/c/GIHia^RTh~HiNVW4NOVVF/RirNOc#RVY(_ B kUVR5c/deR5HFAG^c/GIHiNVa=U NVaIwMR(LdeRiFR(zRiLuRiFT]V`?aINVWMNOFh#c#FwHc/weF/RTh zkVFfQ] >$& 7F.G^rweFR9eYIx:AY y kgHkrf4`?NOF/RLGIc/dtc/deRTh#RFRTh/wMa^c/hi]eL5RKeRic#RiFAf8GIWeR

Page 89: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

qV

.G^rweF/R 9eYIxTqs9_)VVF/RirNOc/G^krW kVzJ`NOFNVfgNOrWeRic/GIHn`?NOF/c/GIHia^RTh h/w B 2#RTHc8c#k N F/kVc/NOc/GIWe f8NOrWeRic/GIH|MRTaIKLG^c/d$ ),/5- p [os 7 N.: 0 4B+ 3 p OqK9e]7 B :@ 4 +.3 x zVqOp] 7 H: 0 4B+ 3 o zVqNVWMK 7 Kr:@ 4B+ 3 Ixzx LG^c/d 4B+ 3 B RTGbWec/dMR `RiFAG^kDK kVzc/deR NO`M`aIG^RTK |MRTaIKYD Wtc/deRTh#RSGbf8NOVRThi]ec/deR B RTNVKGIh Hkra^kVFRTK B aIwMRJGIz~G^cGIh Ngf4RTf B RiFkVz.NVWNOVVFRirNOc#R NVWMKnF/RTKnG^c F/RTfgNVGIWMh wMWMNOc#c/NVHAdeRTKY

Page 90: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

q

.G^rweF/R 9eYIx;s9_)VVF/RirNOc/G^krW kVzJ`NOFNVfgNOrWeRic/GIHn`?NOF/c/GIHia^RTh h/w B 2#RTHc8c#k N F/kVc/NOc/GIWe f8NOrWeRic/GIH|MRTaIKLG^c/d $& )0/1- o p&s7 N.: @ 4B+ 3 [qD]f7 B : @ 4 +.3 xz z=]f7 H: 0 4B+ 3 6o zzzgNVWMK 7 Kr:@ 4B+ 3 x zxSLGIc/d 4 +.3 B RTGbWe c/deR`!RiFG^kKkVz!c/deRNO`M`?aIG^RTK|MRTaIKYB W4c/deRTh#R)GIf8NOVRThi]=c/deR B RTNVKGIh Hkra^kVFRTK B aIwMRJGIz~G^cGIh Ngf4RTf B RiFkVz.NVWNOVVFRirNOc#R NVWMKnF/RTKnG^c F/RTfgNVGIWMh wMWMNOc#c/NVHAdeRTKY

Page 91: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

p

.G^rweF/R 9eYIxTs X c/N B a^RnHiabwMh#c#RiFhzkVFf4RTK GbW N\h/wMh#`!RTWMhG^krW kVzJ`NOFANVf8NOrWeRic/GIH B RTNVKMh4hw B 2#RTHc4c#k NF/kVc/NOc/GIWM f8NOrWMRic/GIH|RTaIK8LGIc/d $ )0/5- o p&s7 N.: ' 6D]h7 B : ' 9e]7 H: ' 6zD]7 Kr:a7;: ' qNVWMK>7 d:a7 2 : ' =Y

Page 92: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

Dx

c/deRSUONVaIweR

+

9:

+ < + 7H9eY x:

L5RiF/R GIhuc/deR WDwMf B RiF5kVz `NOFc/GIHia^RThuc/dMNOc dMNTUVRSNOVVF/RirNOc#RTK] ' GIhuc/deRJc#kVc/NVaWDwMf B RiF5kVz~HiaIwh#c#RiFhNVWMK NVWMK + NOF/R c/dMRf8NeGIfwf NVWMKnf8GIWGIfwf RTG^VRTW=UONVaIweRSkVzc/deRSc#RTWMh/kVF

+ :

7 ' : + 7 ' : A 7H9eY Vo:

zkVFNVW8GIWMKMGIUDGIKwMNVarHiaIwMh/c#RiF 'kVz ' `NOF/c/GIHiaIRTh.LG^c/d ' ' Y WR9eY xO]=c/deR c#RiFf NVHiHkrwMW=c/hzkVF c/deR W=wf B RiF<kVz `NOFc/GIHia^RTh<NOVVF/RirNOc#RTK+NVWMK47 + :0&7 < + :NVHiHkrwMW=c/hzkVFSc/deR HiaIwMh#c#RiFhdMNO`!RV] h/GIWMHR4zkVFNQHAdMNVGIW c/deR4U NVabweR4kVz<c/dMGIh FNOc/GIknGIh8x4LdMRiF/RTNVh zkVFNHiG^FHiaIR G^c GIhpY+_)h c/deRTh/R R `!RiFGIf4RTW=c/NVa(f4RTNVhweF/RTf4RTW=c/h LuRiF/R'`!RiF/zkVFf4RTK\krWHR c/deRtNOVVF/RirNOc/G^krWdMNVhSh/c#kV`M`!RTK]LuR8f wMh#c FAwMW9c/deR8h/GIf wMaINOc/GIkrWMhJwMWc/GbaNVW\RT=wMGbaIG B FGbwMf GIhJF/RTNVHAdeRTKY RV]~c/deRiF/RizkVF/RV]`!RiF/zkVFf1c/deF/RiRhf8NVaIah/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWh7 6zOp.:NOc *p pVp.Sz kVFRTNVHAd8UONVaIweR kVz$ )0/5- o&9e]q NVWMKHkrWMh/GbKeRiF/RTKY y dMR$UONVaIweRThkVz + zkVF RTNVHd $& )0/1- NOF/RNTUVRiFNOVRTKkUVRiF)c/deRSc/deF/RiRShGIfwaINOc/G^krWMhiYy deRTh/RJNUVRiFNOVRTKU NVaIwMRTh5NOFRSh/dekL)WQNVh<c/deR B aIweRJHiG^FHiaIRTh5GbW .G^rwMF/R 9eYIx4NVWMKtRiUVRTWQLGIc/d c/dMRJhf8NVaIaWDwMf B RiF kVz5`NOF/c/GIHiaIRTh$HkrWh/GIKeRiF/RTK]NOVF/RiRTf4RTW=cLG^c/d B Ric LuRiRTW c/dMR8h/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWMhJNVWMK9R `!RiFGIf4RTW=c/hGIh<zkrwMWMKY

*)0 !/$

W9c/dMGIhJHdMNO`c#RiFT] L5R4R NVfgGIWeRTK9c/deR8K C WMNVf8GbHih)kVz<h/f8NVabaNVWK aINOF/VR4RTWMh#RTf B a^RThJkVzu`NOFNVf8NOrWMRic/GIH`NOF/c/GbHia^RThGIWQh/GIc/wMNOc/G^krWMh L)deRiF/RSNVWQR c#RiFWMNVaPSMkL@GIh<`MF/RTh#RTW=ci]MkVF)c/deRNO`M`abG^RTK'|MRTaIKnGIh<c/Gbf4RKeRi`!RTW&/KeRTW=ciYf RS|MFh/c5a^kDk VRTKQNOc<c/deR krh/HiGIabaINOc#kVF C K C WMNVf8GbHih(R edMG B GIc#RTK BDC N`NVGIFukVz B RTNVKh GIW NFkVc/NOc/GIWe|MRTaIK NVWMK c/dMR'R!RTHc/h8kVz$c/deRQHkraIaIGbh/G^krW B NOF/FG^RiFkrW c/dGIh B RTdNTUG^kVFTY> RnKMRTf4krWMh#c#FNOc#RTK c/dMNOc8GIW&/HiaIwMKGIWegc/dMRHkrabaIGIh/G^krW B NOF/FAG^RiF HiNO`Mc/weF/RThJ`d C h/GIHiNVaIa C FRTa^RiU NVW=c R!RTHc/hSh/wMHAd NVhSh/weF/z NVHRz kVFAHRThSNVWMK`NOF/c/GbHia^R(F/krwMrdMWeRTh/hiYB RKeRic#RiFf8GbWeRTKSc/deR<KeRTHF/RTNVh/R<GbW $ ' )5+.-)0/5- NVWMKc/dMR5GIWHF/RTNVh#R<GIWc/dMR5f8NOrWG^c/wMKeRkVz(c/dMR krhHiGIaIaINOc/G^krWhNVh N'F/RTh/wMaIc)kVz5GIWMHF/RTNVh/GbWe 2 )0354 Y y deR B RTdMNUDGIkVF$kVz5NtHdMNVGIW+kVzu`NOF/c/GIHia^RTh$GIW9Nh/deRTNOF SMklL NVWMK GIW NF/kVc/NOc/GbWe|MRTabK\L5RiF/R c/dMRTW HkrWMhGIKeRiF/RTKY W RTNVHd HiNVh#RV]c/deR'd C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIHGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMh NVa^krWe+c/deRta^RTWeVc/d kVz c/deRtHdMNVGIW NOF/RtWeRiRTKeRTK c#kFRi`MF/kKMwMHRgc/dMR'HkVF/FRTHcc#kVFDweR'krWc/deR'HdMNVGIWY kVcGIWMHiabwMKMGIWetc/deRTh/R R!RTHc/h LGIaIa C G^RTaIK\c/deR'GbWMHkVF/F/RTHc h/HiNVaIGIWekVz LG^c/d $ 3@)kVF $& )0/1- NVWMKwMWKeRiF/RTh#c/GIfgNOc#RSc/deRf8NeGIf wMf HAdMNVGIWa^RTWeVc/dnc/dNOc)HiNVWR GIh/cNOc$NgrG^UVRTW $ 3@)kVF$ )0/5- Y y dMR z kVFfgNOc/G^krWQkVz.NOVVF/RirNOc#RTh GIWQh/wMh/`RTWh/G^krWMhukVz.`NOFNVf8NOrWeRic/GbH `NOF/c/GIHiaIRTh h/w B 2#RTHc c#k

Page 93: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

Oo

.G^rweF/R 9eYIxs X GIf wMaINOc/G^krW F/RTh/wMa^c/h 7 B abweR HiG^FAHia^RThV:NVh4Hkrf4`NOF/RTK LG^c/d c/deRQKMGIHAdeF/krGIhfKMNOc/N+zF/krf Y

F/kVc/NOc/GIWM'|RTaIKMhi]NVWMK NVh GIW+c/deRR `!RiFGIf4RTW=c/h ]xVxz ]L5Rz krwMWKc/dNOc B RTaIkL $& '*),+.-)0/5- HAdMNVGIWMhJkVz`NOF/c/GbHia^RThJz kVFAf4RTK9c/dMNOc F/kVc/NOc#RTK LG^c/d9c/deR8NO`M`?aIG^RTK|MRTaIK]LdMRiF/R4NVhSN B kUVR $ ' )5+.-)0/5- `aINVWNOFJNOVVFRY/rNOc#RThSL5RiF/R4k B h/RiF/UVRTKY4$Ric#RiFf8GIWMGbWetc/deR8W=wf B RiF NVWMK\h/dNO`RkVzuc/deRTh#R8`abNVWMNOF HiaIwMh#c#RiFh NVaba^kL5RTKzkVFN4z NTUVkVFN B aIRHkrf4`NOFGbh#krWQLG^c/dtc/dMR F/RTh/wMa^c/h<zF/krf KGIHdeFkrGIh/f%R `RiFAGIf4RTW=c/h Y

Page 94: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

& 8

8

$!S28!)

Wtv<dNO`Mc#RiFoD]DL5R KMGIh/Hiwh/h#RTKgdMkL B kVc/d S?wMGIKgNVWK `?NOF/c/GIHia^R$GIWeRiF/c/GINHiNVW B R)G^rWekVFRTKgLdMRTW'HkrWh/GIK&/RiFGIWM c/deR4f4kVc/GIkrWkVz5h/f8NVaIa~k B 2#RTHc/hSGIW+N'UDGIhHkrwMhSwMGIKNVWMK NVhJNtF/RTh/wMa^ci]!a^klL R C WekraIKMh$W=wf B RiFSMklLhJNOF/R DGIWMRTf8NOc/GIHiNVaIa C F/RiUVRiFAh/G B a^RVY y k'VRTWMRiFNOc#R8NtWeRic)c#FANVWMh/aINOc/G^krW+Ntf8GIHF/k/ h/LGIf8f4RiF hH C HiaIGIHh#c#FNOc#Ri C fwh#cc/deRiFRiz kVF/R B RkrWeR c/dMNOcJGIhWMkrW&/ F/RTHiG^`MFkDHiNVa xip Y$ZNVW C kVzc/deR h/GIWera^R HRTaIa fgGIHF/k/kVF/rNVWMGbh/f8hc/dMNOc(`MF/kV`!RTac/deRTf8h#RTaIUVRTh(GIW4c/dGIhRTW=UDG^FkrWMf4RTW=cwec/GIaIG iR NSaIkrWe SNOVRTaIabwMf1c/NVGIaMHkrWMWMRTHc#RTKc#k c/deR HRTaIa B kDK C Y~s(wMFHRTaIaDHiNOc#RiVkVFG iRThc/dMR<fgN82 kVFGIc C kVz?c/deRTh#R SNOVRTaIabN)kVFkrWMRY/ NOFf4RTK4h#LGbf8f4RiFhNVhRTG^c/deRiF c/dMkrh#R c/dMNOc wMh#R N SMR eG B a^R$krNOF 4h#c#FANOc#Ri C ]kVFN #HkVF h/HF/RiLgh#c#FNOc#Ri C Y y deR SMR G B a^R$krNOF h#LGbf8f4RiFhi]~h/wMHd NVhh#`!RiFf8NOc#k ikrN]h#L)GIf B=C `MFkV`NOrNOc/GIWe B RTWMKMGbWetL5NUVRThKeklLW\c/dMRga^RTWeVc/d kVzc/deRTG^FkSNOVRTaIabwMf c/NVGIa ]DLdMGba^Rh#LGIfgf4RiFh(NO``a C GIWe c/deR #HkVF h/HF/RiLh#c#FNOc#Ri C ]MhwMHd'NVhqcP!V`'vZ B NVH /c#RiFGIN]=F/kVc/NOc#R$c/deRTG^F(deRTabGIHiNVaIa C hdMNO`!RTKSNOVRTaIaIwf1kVFnSNOVRTaIabNOF B wMWMKa^RTh.LdMGIHAd8N!kVFK4c/deR$HkrWUVRiFhG^krWkVz.F/kVc/NOc/G^krWMNVac#k8c#FNVWMh/abNOc/G^krWMNVaf4kVc/G^krWY

j5RirGIWMWGIWetLG^c/d YP AY y N C a^kVF hh#c/wMK C kVz5Nh#LGIf8fgGIWeth/deRiRic xVx5NVWMK h/w B h/RT=weRTW=cSNVWMNVa C /h/GIhHkrWMHRiFWMGIWMf4kVc/G^krWMhNVh/h#kHiGINOc#RTK L)G^c/d L<NTUVRTh VRTWeRiFNOc#RTK NVa^krWeNH C abGIWMKeFGbHiNVa~c/NVGba xVxY9 ]c/deR

Page 95: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

89

KeRiUVRTa^kV`?f4RTWcJkVz<f4kKeRTa.h C h/c#RTf8h dMNVh B RiRTW9RTh/h#RTW=c/GINVac#knwMWMKeRiFh/c/NVWMKMGIWe c/deRzwWMKMNVf4RTW=c/NVa`MFGIW&/HiG^`aIRTh5hweF/F/krwMWKMGIWeSc/dMRSh#LGIf8fgGIWeSkVz.f8GIHF/k/ kVFrNVWMGIh/f8hTY RTHRTWc)GIWUVRTh/c/G^rNOc/G^krWMh<c/dMNOc VRiRi`LG^c/dc/dMGIhgNO`M`MF/krNVHAd GIWMHiabwMKeRQh#c/wMKMGIRThkVzJsuweFHRTaIa h4c/deF/RiRabGIW h/LGIf8f4RiF xipM]Uz )NVWMK c/deRf4RTNVhweF/RY/f4RTW=c/h$kVz(c/deRaINOc#RiFNVazkVFHRVRTWMRiFNOc#RTK BDC |aINVf4RTW=cL)deRTWkrWMR RTWKGIh$KMGIh/`aINVHRTKnc#FANVWMh#UVRiFh#RTa C GIWNVW9krh/HiGIabaINOc#kVF C fgNVWMWeRiF xVxTqe]xVxD]xToxV]POq Y_ `F/krf8GIh/GbWe HiNVWMKGIKMNOc#Rz kVFSNVW NVKKMG^c/G^krWMNVaf4kKeRTah C h#c#RTf GIhc/deR'NOFc/G^|HiGINVa5f8NOrWeRic/GIH'f8GIHFk/ h#LGIf8f8RiF`MF/kKMwMHRTK B=C )FR C z wMh -$[ )'*c Y *dMGIa^RkVFG^rGbWMNVaIa C GIW=c#F/kDKwMHRTKnc#ktR `RiFAGIf4RTW=c/NVaIa C R NVf8GbWeRc/dMR`MFRTKMGIHc/G^krWQkVzuNVWkV`c/GIf8NVa~z F/RTDweRTWMH C kVzc/deR)`MF/kV`wMabh/G^UVR<z kVFAHRzkVFuN SR G B a^RkrNOF h#LGIf8f8RiF xVxTq]&Oo ]=c/deR)NOF/c/G^|HiGINVah#LGIf8f8RiF(f8N C h/RiF/UVRNVhN`?d C h/GIHiNVa5f4kKeRTac#k9R `a^kVF/R kVc/deRiF4NVh#`!RTHc/hkVz)a^kL R C WekraIKhWDwMf B RiFh#LGIfgf8GIWenh/wHd NVhNVa^c#RiFWNOc/G^UVRS`MF/kV`?wMaIh/G^krW'h#c#FNOc#RirGIRThNVWMKnh/LGIf8f4RiF^/ h#LGIf8f8RiF5GIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWhiY

Wnc/dMGbhHdNO`Mc#RiFT]L5R |MFh#cKMGbh/HiwMh/h c/dMR|WMKGIWerh<kVzc/deR NOF/c/G^|HiGINVa h#LGIf8f8RiFR D`!RiFGbf4RTWc/h Y Rc/dMRTWGIW=c#F/kKMwMHRSNVWnRTabNVh#c/GIHSHkrwe`?aIGIWe8h/HAdeRTf4RSc#k F/Ri`MF/RTh/RTWcc/dMRRTaINVh#c/GbH `MF/kV`!RiF/c/G^RTh<kVzNgf8NO/WeRic/GIH|aINVf4RTW=cNVWMK RTf4`?a^k C c/dMGIh f4kDKMRTaOc#kR eNVf8GIWeRc/deRuKeRiz kVFAf8NOc/G^krWMhkVzeN)f8GIHF/kV|abNVf4RTWch/Ric#c/aIGIWeGIW+N'UDGIhHkrwMhSwMGIKY X GIf wMaINOc/G^krWhkVz(c/dMR NOF/c/GI|HiGINVaf8GIHF/k/ h#L)GIf8f4RiFJNOF/R c/deRTW9`MF/RTh#RTW=c#RTK9NVWMK+c/deRF/RTh/wa^c/GIWeh#LGIfgf8GIWeh#`!RiRTKMhNOF/RSHkrf8`NOF/RTKnL)G^c/dtc/deR R `RiFAGIf4RTW=c/hNVWMKQkVc/deRiF)h/GIf wMaINOc/G^krWMh 99 Y

4:, ! )9 / ;= >1:, &'A,($!

y deR9NOF/c/G^|?HiGINVa)h/LGIf8f4RiFtHkrWMh/Gbh#c/h'kVzNySMR G B a^RfgNOrWeRic/GIH SNOVRTaIaIwfR/ aIG VRc/NVGIaJHkrWMWeRTHc#RTK*c#k NdDwMf8NVWQF/RTK B a^kDkDKtHRTaIa ]Mh/RiRt.G^rweF/RzDYIx Y y dMRSf8NOrWeRic/GIH |?aINVf4RTW=cGIh Hkrf4`MFGbh#RTKQkVz.f4krWekKMGIh /`!RiFh#R4`NOFANVf8NOrWeRic/GIH B RTNVKMhSkVz5FANVKMGIwMh p z c/dMNOcNOF/RgfgNVW=wez NVHc/weF/RTK z kVFc/deR8`weF`krh/R kVzB G^kHdMRTf8GIHiNVa5h#Ri`NOFNOc/G^krWY y deRth/weFzNVHRThkVz)c/deRTh#R B RTNVKMhNOF/Rtc#F/RTNOc#RTK LG^c/d c/deRQNVHc/G^UVR B GIWMKMGIWMNOVRTW=cSh#c#F/Ri`Mc/NUDGIKGIW+c/dMNOcJF/RTNVKMGIa CB krWKMhL)G^c/dc/dMRHAdeRTf8GIHiNVa B G^kVc/GIWY y ktz kVFf c/deR8fgNOrWeRic/GIH |a /NVf4RTW=ci]c/deR4h#c#F/Ri`c/NTUGIKMGIW+HkrNOc#RTK B RTNVKMhJNOF/R|MFh#cJNVaIa^klLuRTK+c#knNOVVF/RirNOc#R'wMWMKeRiF$c/deR4GIW0S?weRTWMHRkVzNQwMWMGIz kVFf f8NOrWMRic/GIH|MRTaIK]!zkVFf8GIWMtHAdMNVGIWMh NVabG^rWeRTK+LG^c/d9c/deR8NO``aIG^RTK|MRTaIK 7 xipro H:AY_ SMR eG B a^RB G^kVc/GbW&/ RTWMKeRTKn $_ f4kra^RTHiwa^RThNOF/R c/deRTW+GIW=c#F/kDKwMHRTKnNVWMK+G^F/F/RiUVRiFAh/G B a C aIGIW'c/deR B RTNVKMhc#kVVRic/deRiFYy deR<F/RThwMa^c/GIWeSMR eG B a^R<f8GIHFk/ |aINVf4RTW=cHiNVW4c/deRTW B Rf8NVWMGI`wMaINOc#RTK B=C NVKK2/wMh#c/GIWM)R c#RiFWMNVaMNO``aIG^RTKf8NOrWeRic/GbHu|RTaIKY y deRuRTabNVh#c/GIHu`MF/kV`!RiF/c/G^RTh~kVzh/wMHAd|aINVf4RTW=c/hdMNTUVR B RiRTWh#c/wMKMGIRTK BDC 9eNVWMK MNVWMKwMh#RTKgNVh(N VR C Hkrf4`!krWeRTW=ckVzNSf8G eGIWe KeRiUGIHR BDC xip Y y deR F/RTK B a^k=kK4HRTaIae`F/kUGIKeRThNWeRTHRTh/h/NOF CHkrf4`!krWeRTW=c4NVhc/dMRtfgNOrWeRic/GIH'|aINVf4RTW=ci]G^zdekrf8kVVRTWeRikrwMh4GIW RTaINVh#c/GIHtNVWMK f8NOrWeRic/GbH `F/kV`!RiF/c/G^RThi]aINVH DhJc/deRNVh C f8f4Ric#F C WeRTHRTh/h/NOF C c#kt`MF/kKMwMHRNtWeRic$c#FNVWMhaINOc#RVY y deRGIWMHF/RTNVh#RGIW+d C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIHKeFNO NOc4c/deRtc#Ric/deRiFRTK RTWMK NVaIa^klLh z kVF B RTWMKGIWeL<NTUVRThgc#k9`MF/kV`NOrNOc#RnzF/krf c/deRQc/G^` kVz)c/deRQc/NVGIa

Page 96: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

z

.G^rweF/RzDYIxs X VRic/HdkVz~c/dMRNOF/c/G^|HiGbNVaf8GIHF/k/ h#L)GIf8f4RiFTY

c#kL<NOFKc/deRSF/RTK B a^k=kKtHRTaIaLdGIHdtF/RThwMa^c/h GIWtc/NVGIa|MFh#c h#LGbf8f8GIWeeY W ]Mc/dMRSf4kVc/G^krWQkVz.c/deRSh#L)GIf8f4RiFKeFAG^UVRTW B=C NVWnkrhHiGIaIaINOc/GIWM f8NOrWMRic/GIH |MRTaIKtkVz.c/deR zkVFf

K7 x Hkrh /p.: 7\zDYIx:

LdeRiFR Ntc C `GbHiNVa~zF/RTDweRTWMH C kVz(c/deR4NO`M`abG^RTK|RTaIKGbh qVo[ FNVK rY *G^c/d9c/deRUGIh/Hkrh/GIc C kVzuc/deRh/weFF/krwMWMKMGbWeSwMGbK] ?] B RTGIWM)c/dMNOckVz?L5NOc#RiF]c/deRR C WekrabKMh.W=wMf B RiFHkVF/F/RTh#`!krWMKMGbWec#kSc/dMR<f8kVc/G^krWGIh=2 " A xip E xip. YUMweFc/deRiFT]Mc/deR C GIKeRTW=c/G^|MRTKtc/dMF/RiRKMGIf8RTWMh/G^krWMaIRTh/h(`?NOFNVf4Ric#RiFhc/dMNOcVkUVRiFAWtc/deR$K C WMNVfgGIHihkVzc/dMR$h#L)GIf8f4RiFTY y deR$|MFh/cuGIh %c/deR$FNOc/G^k kVzc/deR$c#FNVWMh#UVRiFh/R)|MRTabK8c#kc/deRHkrWMh#c/NVW=c|RTaIKY y deRSh#RTHkrWKQ`NOFNVf4Ric#RiF$GIhGIh<c/dMRTag0- V% ,#&% W - A] ]erG^UVRTW BDC

9 ; A5; 7\zDY[o:

LdeRiFRGbh)c/dMRaIRTWeVc/d9kVz(c/deRc/NVGIa.NVWMK )Gbh)c/dMR R!RTHc/G^UVR B RTWMKGIWegf4kKMwMabwMhkVzuc/deR|aINVf4RTW=ciYy deRh#`!RiFf WDwMf B RiFrGIUVRThc/deRFNOc/G^k8kVz.c/deRUDGIhHkrwMh c#kgRTabNVh#c/GIH zkVFHRTh$NVWMKn`MFkUGIKeRTh c/deRFNOc/G^kgkVzc/deR$a^RTWeVc/d4kVzc/deR|aINVf4RTW=cc#kc/dMRRTaINVh#c#krd C KeF/kK C WNVf8GIH a^RTWeVc/d

7 89 U: A5; xVxTq ?klUVRiF

LdMGbHd B RTWMKMGIWMLGbaIakDHiHiweFY y deR c/dMG^FAKt`NOFNVf4Ric#RiF$GIh<c/deRx%x)"7 -$[a`-$' )T [FZ\!,#&% W - ] $

$ 7 354:4 : A

q 7 x 3,4:4 Oq:Y7 x< 3,4:4 DxTo: 7\zDY :

LdMGbHd `MF/klUDGIKMRThNJf4RTNVhweF/R<kVz?c/dMR<h/c#F/RTWeVc/dkVzc/dMRf8NOrWeRic/GIH5zkVFHRThF/RTaINOc/GIUVR5c#k c/dMR5RTabNVh#c/GIH5z kVFAHRThiYy deRh/HiNVa^RTK+h#LGIf8fgGIWe4h#`!RiRTKkVzc/dMRKeRiUGIHR &8&7 U:L5NVh)c/deRTW+f4RTNVh/weF/RTKkUVRiF N8FANVWeVRkVz

Page 97: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

Oq

LG^c/d c/deRt`NOFANVf4Ric#RiFh%tNVWMK $ | DRTKY X `!RTHiG^|HiNVaIa C ].c/deRtR `!RiFGIf4RTW=c/h LuRiF/RQHkrWMKwMHc#RTKkUVRiF$c/deRFNVWeVRgx q 8z kVF $ 69 z&TxVx 'NVWMK\xTq8LG^c/d x p. xIxTqDY y deR C zkrwMWMKc/dMNOc c/deR hHiNVa^RTK h#LGIf8fgGIWeQh#`!RiRTK GbWMG^c/GINVaIa C GIWMHFRTNVh#RThL)G^c/d ~Y y deR'h/HiNVa^RTK h#LGIf8fgGIWenh#`!RiRTKc/deRTWnNOc#c/NVGbWMhN`!RTNtU NVabweR NOz c#RiF)LdMGIHAdQG^cKeRTHiN C h$f4krWekVc#krWMGIHiNVaba C LGIc/d Y

<JwMF~VkrNVaGIh~c#k)`F/kUGIKeR5NVWR!RTHc/G^UVRh/GIf wMaINOc/GIkrW kVzMc/dMGIhKeRiUGIHR B NVh#RTKkrWc/deR<f4Ric/dekKMhNVa^F/RTNVK CKeRiUVRTa^kV`!RTKgc#k h#c/wK C GIWc#RiFANVHc/GIWeS`NOFANVf8NOrWeRic/GIH)`NOF/c/GIHiaIRThiY y deR)HAdMNVaIa^RTWeVR)deRiF/R)Gbhc#kGbWMHkVF/`!kVFNOc#Rc/deRSRTabNVh#c/GIHJ`MF/kV`!RiF/c/GIRTh<kVz~c/deR$_1f4kra^RTHiwMaIRTh aIGIWGIWe c/deR B RTNVKMh<c#kVVRic/deRiFY

S24(0A- 0/ !~;=)4&40A-

y deR8K C WMNVfgGIHih kVz f8NOrWeRic/GIH8|aINVf4RTW=c/hdMNUVR B RiRTW\NVKMKMF/RTh/h#RTK\wh/GIWeQc Luk+KMG !RiF/RTWcSNO``MF/krNVHdMRThiYy deR |Fh#c NO`M`MF/krNVHAdG^rWMkVF/RTh<c/deRKMGbh/HF/Ric#R WMNOc/weF/R kVz.c/deR |?aINVf4RTW=cNVWMKtc#F/RTNOc/h$G^c NVhN4HkrW=c/GIW=wMkrwMhRTaINVh#c/GbH F/kK4LG^c/d4N B RTWMKGIWe f4kKMwMaIwMh AY y dMGIh.c C `!RkVzf4kKeRTaIGIWeJdMNVh B RiRTWgGIWMh#c#Fwf4RTWc/NVaeGbW4c/deRwMWMKMRiFh#c/NVWMKMGbWekVz?c/deRK C WMNVf8GIHihkVzRTaINVh#c/GIH5|aINVf8RTWc/hGIWNJUGIh/HkrwMh S?wMGIK xVxTqe]exVxTe]rqMNVWMK4h#c/wKMG^RThkVz a^klL R C WMkraIKMh5W=wMf B RiF(`MFkV`wMaIh/GIkrW xVxTq],Oq]&z Y y deR)d C KMF/kDK C WMNVfgGIH zkVFHRTh<NOF/R$GbWMHkVF/`!kVFNOc#RTKwMh/GbWeh/GIf8`a^R8KeFNO+aINTL)h B NVh/RTK krW h/a^RTWMKMRiF B kDK C c/deRikVF C LdeRiF/Rgc/deR'KMFNOHkDRgHiG^RTW=c`!RiF wMWMG^ca^RTWeVc/d GIhc/dMNOcgzkVFgN\abGIWeRtkVz X c#k VRTh/a^Ric/h c#FNVWMh/aINOc/GbWe9c/deF/krwerdS?wMGIK qz Y y k GIWHkVF/`!kVFNOc#RQc/deRR!RTHc/h(kVz!c/deRNO`M`?aIG^RTK|MRTaIK]rf8NOrWeRic/GIH c#kVFA=weRThuNVa^krWeSc/dMRa^RTWeVc/d4kVz!c/deR|?aINVf4RTW=cNOF/RHkrWMh/GbKeRiF/RTKY W9c/deR8HkrWc#R ckVz<f8NOrWeRic/GbH4|aINVf4RTW=c/hi]RTaINVh/c/GIHF/kK f4kDKMRTaIh dMNTUVR B RiRTW9c/dMR B NVh/GIhJkVz<NQW=wf B RiFkVz.h#c/wMKMG^RTh<GIWHiaIwMKMGIWM c/deRSKMGIh/Hiwh/h/G^krW B=C kVz c/dMRTG^F R D`!RiFGbf4RTWc/h5LGIc/d c/dMRSNOF/c/G^|HiGINVah#LGbf8f4RiFT]RTaINVh#c/GbHKeRizRTHc5KMFG^UVRTWgh/LGIf8f8GbWeSGIW xip. ]DNVWKgc/deR$K C WMNVf8GIHih(kVz f8NOrWeRic/GIH)|aINVf8RTWc/h5GIW8FkVc/NOc/GIWe|MRTaIKh NVWMKnh/deRTNOFSMkLhHkrWMh/GIKeRiFRTKQGIW oOpe]?oxV]x Y

m$h/GIWenNVW NVa^c#RiFWMNOc/G^UVR NO`M`MF/krNVHAd] JNVwMVRiF_-$[)'*c 99 RTf4`a^k C Nn`NOF/c/GIHia^RY/ B NVh#RTK\KeRTh/HFAG^`Mc/G^krWkVzc/deRtf8NOrWeRic/GbHg|abNVf4RTWcc/NVGIa5GIW\c/deRTGIF h/GbfwMabNOc/G^krWMhSkVz c/dMR'NOF/c/GI|HiGINVa(h/LGIf8f4RiFY RiFRV]c/deR B RTNVKMhtHkrf4`MFGbh/GIWe\c/dMR+c/NVGba$GbWc#RiFNVHc#RTK6f8NOrWeRic/GIHiNVaIa C c/deF/krwerd |RTK*KMG^`!kra^RGbWc#RiFNVHc/GIkrWMhQNVWMKR `RiFAG^RTWMHRTKSwGIKz kVFAHRTh B NVh/RTK8krW c/deR kVc/WMRY/ sFNOVRiF f4k B GbaIG^c C Y._$KMKMG^c/G^krWNVaIa C ]Vc/deR)F/RTh/GIh#c/NVWHRc#kB RTWMKMGIWM L<NVh$F/Ri`MF/RTh/RTWc#RTK B=C NgLukVFfgaIG VRHAdMNVGIW]h#RiR e] ]?c/dMNOc)FRi`MF/kKMwMHRTh c/deR B RTWMKMGIWe4kVzN8HkrW=c/GIWDwekrwMh RTaINVh/c/GIHJF/kKQGIWQc/deRSaIGbf8G^c Y

*dMGIa^RQc/dMRTh#Rf4kKeRTaIhgdMNTUVR B RiRTW GIWMh/c#FwMf4RTW=c/NVa GIW c/dMRwMWMKeRiFAh#c/NVWMKMGIWM+kVz c/dMR B RTdMNTUG^kVFgkVzf8GIHFkV|aINVf4RTW=c/huGbWgUGIh/HkrwMhUSwMGbKMhi]h/Gbf4`aIG^|?HiNOc/G^krWMhkVzc/dMR$K C WMNVf8GbHihuGIW=c#F/kKMwMHRTK B=C8B kVc/d'f4kKeRTaIhaIGIfgG^cc/deRTG^F N B GbaIG^c C c#k8KeRThHFG B RNVHiHiweFNOc#RTa C c/deR K C WMNVf8GIHihukVz~fgNOrWeRic/GIH$|aINVf4RTW=c/hiY W c/dMR$HiNVh#R kVzc/deR$HkrWc/GIWDwekrwMh(RTaINVh#c/GIHF/kDKgf4kDKMRTaIhi]rc/deR$d C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIH5zkVFHRTh5NVa^krWeSc/deR$a^RTWeVc/d4kVzc/dMR|aINVf4RTW=c

Page 98: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

n−1

n

n

n−1

n

n−1

elas

2= (λ , λ , λ )

31

= −

elas

elas

t

t

q

p

p

q

Fn

q t

p

F

F

n−1

n−1

.G^rweF/RzDY[os X VRic/Hd kVz$c L5k WMRTG^rd B kVFGbWe`NOFc/GIHia^RThkVz$c/deRQ|aINVf4RTW=ciY y deRnaIGbW\R RiF/c/h8N9zkVFHR 3 krW B RTNVK xtNVWMK NVW RTDwMNVa5NVWMK kV`M`!krh/G^c#R z kVFHRtkrW B RTNVK Y y deR'hdMNO`!RgkVzc/dMR'aIGbWGIhHAdMNOFNVHc#RiFGiRTK BDC c/deRHkDkVFKMGIWMNOc#Rh C h/c#RTf 7HJ P: c/dNOcU NOFAG^RThNVa^krWM8c/deRa^RTWMVc/dnNVWMKNOc#c/NVGbWMhUONVaIweRTh 7HJ :NOc5c/deR$a^Riz c5NOc#c/NVHdMf8RTWc `!krGIW=ci]=NVWMK=7HJ :NOcuc/deR$kV`M`!krh/G^c#RRTWMKY

NOF/R5c#F/RTNOc#RTKwMh/GIWMN)KMFNO)f4kKeRTa=c/dMNOc.GIhkrWMa C U NVaIGbKSGIWSc/dMRuFGIrGIKSaIGIfgG^cLdeRiFR(c/deRu|aINVf4RTW=c F/RTfgNVGIWMhh#c#FNVGIrdciYD WNVKMKMG^c/G^krW]c/deRTh#RuKeFNO B NVh/RTKf4kKeRTaIhHiNVWWekVcF/RTHklUVRiFc/dMR VR!F/R C kVF B G^c B RTdNTUG^kVFkVzeNVWNeGIh C f8f4Ric#FGIH B kDK C GIWtNh/deRTNOFeSMklL qkVFF/Ri`MF/kKMwMHR$c/deR KeRizkVFf8NOc/G^krWtR edMG B G^c#RTK BDC N4h/Ric#c/aIGIWe|aINVf8RTWc Y*dMGIa^RSc/dMR`NOF/c/GbHia^R B NVh/RTKNO`M`F/krNVHd+NVKekV`Mc#RTK B=C 99 .NVaIaIkLhz kVFJd C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIHGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhNVa^krWeQc/deRgaIRTWeVc/d kVz5c/deR4|aINVf4RTW=ci]~GIcSHkrf4RThNOcSc/dMR4R D`!RTWMh#R4kVz5c/deR8FRTh#kraIwec/G^krW9kVzc/deR)RTaINVh#c/GIH `F/kV`!RiF/c/G^RThkVz|abNVf4RTWc(c/dMNOc5WMkL NOFc/G^|HiGINVaIa C KeRi`!RTWMK4krW c/deR$W=wMf B RiFkVz B RTNVKMhGIWgc/deR|aINVf8RTWc 99 ] Y

y k'f8kUVR `NVh#c$c/deRTh#RabGIf8G^c/NOc/G^krWhi]ML5RGIW=c#F/kKMwMHRNVWRTaINVh#c/GIH Hkrwe`abGIWe8f4kKeRTa h/`RTHiGI|HiNVaIa C KeRY/h/G^rWMRTK zkVFf8NOrWeRic/GbHJ|aINVf4RTW=c/hiYf RSRTf4`?a^k C N`NOF/c/GIHia^R B NVh#RTKQf8kDKeRTa!L)deRiF/RJc/deR d C KeF/kK C WMNVf8GIHGIW=c#RiFNVHc/G^krWMhgNOF/RQ`MF/klUDGIKMRTK BDC ~v Z AoDY[oDYIxNVWMK fgNOrWeRic/GIHnKMGI`kraIRTh VDYIxOY[o NOF/RnwMh#RTK c#k FRi`MF/k/KMwMHR c/deR4GIW=c#RiF/`NOF/c/GbHia^Rf8NOrWMRic/GIHGIWc#RiFANVHc/G^krWMhiY y deR RTaINVh#c/GbHHkrwe`?aIGIWe B Ric LuRiRTW9c/dMR `?NOF/c/GIHia^RTh$GIhNVHdG^RiUVRTK B=C FRi`MF/RTh#RTW=c/GIWeSRTNVHAdQHdeRTfgGIHiNVa?abGIW4NVh<NVW GIWMR Dc#RTWMhG B a^R RTaINVh/c/GIHF/kKYj C c#F/RTNOc/GIWMRTNVHAdaIGIW th/Ri`NOFNOc#RTa C ]!L5R dMNUVRF/RTf4kUVRTK9c/dMR GIW,SweRTWMHRSkVz(c/deR WDwMf B RiF)kVz`?NOF/c/GIHia^RkrWc/deR F/RTh#krabwec/G^krWkVz.c/deR RTaINVh#c/GbHJz kVFHRThTY

y dMR HdMRTf8GIHiNVaIa C zkVFf4RTK aIGIW Dh`MF/kKMwMHR8RTaINVh/c/GIHgzkVFHRThNVWMK B RTWMKMGIWenf8krf4RTWc/h c/dMNOcNVHcc#kF/Ric/weFAW4N B RTW=c.|aINVf4RTW=cc#kSG^c/h.kVFGIrGIWMNVaaIGIWeRTNOFHkrWe|rweFNOc/G^krWY y dGIh R!RTHcuGbhHiNO`Mc/weF/RTK BDC c#FRTNOc/GIWe

Page 99: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

O

RTNVHd aIGIW NVh NVW GIWeR c#RTWMh/G B a^RV] B wecSR G B a^R4F/kK kVz a^RTWeVc/dY W h/wMHd NnKeRTh/HFAG^`Mc/G^krW] c/deR8zkVFHR

NVWMKnf8krf4RTWc B NVaINVWMHR 89 ~z kVFNgaIGIWgNOFR

< 7\zDY9;:

< J < * 7\zDY z:

y7:gGIh8c/deR+F/RTh/wa^c/NVWc'GIW=c#RiFWMNVah/c#F/RTh/h'krW N HF/krh/h / h#RTHc/G^krW*NVWMK 7:gGIh8c/deR9f4krf4RTW=c'kVzSc/deRGIW=c#RiFWMNVah#c#F/RTh/h/RTh)krW+c/deRHF/krh/h / h#RTHc/G^krWY j5kVc/dy7:NVWK 7:UONOF C L)G^c/dNOFHiaIRTWeVc/d9p

NVWMK B NVaINVWMHR c/deRNO`M`aIGIRTKnzkVFHRTh$`RiFJwMWMGIca^RTWeVc/d NVWMK+c#kVFDweRTh$`RiF$wMWMG^c$a^RTWeVc/d * Y W"7\zDY z:A]JSKeRTWekVc#RThc/deR UVRTHc#kVFc/NVWeVRTW=cc#k4c/deRSHRTW=c#RiFaIGbWeRJkVz~c/deR aIGbW?Y y dMRJf8krf4RTWc GIh<F/RTabNOc#RTKtc#k8c/deRKeRizkVFf8NOc/G^krWnkVz~c/deRaIGIW8c/dMF/krwerdQc/deRSHkrWh#c/G^c/wec/G^UVRaINTL

0J J

<D6 J

7\zDY[q:

LdeRiFR GIh<c/dMR B RTWMKMGIWe f4kKMwMaIwMhT]6 c/deRSc L)GIh#cf4kKMwMaIwhi]DNVWK@c/deR c LGIh#cNVWMra^RVYv5krWh/GIKeRiF<c/deRabGIWgHkrWMWMRTHc/GIWe B RTNVKMh x NVWMK HRTW=c#RiF/RTKNOc NVWMK FRTh#`!RTHc/G^UVRTa C Y

E(NVHAd B RTNVK+dNVh$aIkDHiNVa B kDK C NRTh 7HJ :)NVWMK7HJ :AY y deR abGIWt2 krGbWMGIWe8c/dMRTh#RB RTNVKMh B RirGIWh 7 p.:NOcc/deR`krGbWc < J krWnc/deR h/weF/z NVHRSkVz B RTNVK xNVWMKRTWMKMh7

: NOc J krW c/dMR h/weFzNVHR8kVz B RTNVK NVh h/dekL)W GIW4.G^rwMF/R5zDY[oDY_<c c/deRg`!krGIW=c/hSkVz

HkrW=c/NVHci]c/deRgHRTW=c#RiFaIGIWMR8kVzaIGIW+GIhSc/NVRTW c#k B Rg`RiF`RTWKMGIHiwMaINOF$c#kc/dMR h/weFzNVHRThkVz c/deR h#`?deRiF/RThHkVF/F/RTh/`krWKMGIWetc#knc/deR HiaINVf4`!RTK&/ RTWMK B krwMWMKNOF C HkrWMKG^c/G^krWMh J J NOc pnNVWMKJ J NOc

Y y deRSaIGIW GIh GIWMR Dc#RTWMhG B a^RJNVWMKQc/deRiFRSGIh c/deRSHkrWMh/c#FNVGIW=c

7 : J J

J 7\zDY :

krW+c/deRHkrf4`!krWeRTWc/h$kVzc/dMRUVRTHc#kVFS`!krGIW=c/GIWegz F/krf c/deRNOc#c/NVHdMf8RTWchG^c#RkrW B RTNVK x c#k'c/dMNOckrW B RTNVKY_$h/h#kHiGINOc#RTKLG^c/dnc/dGIh)HkrWh#c#FNVGIW=c)NOF/R c/deRz kVFHR krW B RTNVK xO]

3 J <

A < ? NVWMK c/deRRT=wMNVa$NVWMK kV`M`!krh/G^c#RzkVFHRkrW B RTNVK ] 3

3 Y y deRTh#RzkVFHRTh$LGIaIa`F/kDKwMHRSkV`M`!krh/G^c#Rz kVFAHRTh)c/dNOc$NVHcJkrWc/deRRTWKMhkVz(c/deRaIGbWQNVWMKh/RiF/UVR NVh B krwMWMKNOF CHkrWMKMGIc/G^krWMhzkVF$c/deRzkVFHR B NVaINVWMHR_7\zDY9;:AY$_$h$LuRKek'WekVc)HkrWMhGIKeRiFJNVW C kVc/deRiFJzkVFHRTh7 :krWc/deRabGIW] 7\zDY9;: B RTHkrf8RTh

7\zDY[:

Page 100: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

NVWMK+zF/krf c/deR B krwWMKMNOF C HkrWMKG^c/G^krWMh 3 Y X GIWMHR c/deRiF/R4NOF/R4Wek'R Dc#RiFAWMNVa.c#kVFDweRThJkrW9c/deRaIGIW ?] * NVWMKQc/deRSf4krf8RTWc B NVaINVWMHR57\zDY z: F/RTKMwMHRTh c#k

< J 3 7\zDY :

cJF/RTf8NVGIWMh)c#kQKeRic#RiFf8GbWeRc/dMR FRTh/wMa^c/GIWM aIGIW thdMNO`!R BDC h#kra^UGIWe=7\zDY :$LG^c/dc/deR4HkrWMh#c/GIc/wec/G^UVRaINL 7\zDY[q:AYum)h/GbWec/deRJE(wa^RiFuNVWeraIRTh 7 7K: 7: 7: :(c#kKMRTh/HFG B Rc/deRJHkrW=c/GIW=wMkrwMhuKMRiz kVFfgNOc/G^krWkVz<c/deR8aIGIW B Ric L5RiRTW\c/deRgc L5knRTWMKMhi]~c/deR4kVFG^RTW=c/NOc/G^krW kVzuc/deR Hk=kVFKGIWMNOc#R8h C h#c#RTf 7HJ P:SNVa^krWec/deRabGIW8F/RTabNOc/G^UVR c#k8c/deRHkDkVFKMGbWMNOc#RSh C h#c#RTf NOc *p7HJ :<GIh

J

7K:

J

7\zDYIxip.:

LG^c/d

Hkrh Hkrh Hkrh h/GIW h/GIW h/GIW 9Hkrh h/GIW h/GIW Hkrh hGIW 9h/GIW hGIW < Hkrh Hkrh h/GIW 9Hkrh Hkrh Hkrh 9h/GIW < h/GIW 9h/GbW Hkrh 9h/GIW hGIW h/GIW Hkrh Hkrh 9Hkrh

7\zDYIxVx:

m$h/GIWeSc/dGIhR `MF/RTh/h/GIkrW4z kVFUJ)GIW7\zDY[q:NVWMK 7\zDY :NVWK8F/RTHkVrWMGTGIWe NVhc/deR)c LGIh/c(NVWera^R)LuRk B c/NVGIWc/deRKG RiFRTWc/GINVaRTDwMNOc/G^krWMh

6 A

A p

A A < Hkrh h/GIW A < 69Hkrh

Hkrh hGIW

< %A!h/GIW h/GIW < ? Hkrh Hkrh A A ohGIW

6

Mh/GIW A Hkrh 7\zDYIxTo:

W c/deR4R `!RiFGIf4RTW=c/hi]c/deR8aIRTWeVc/d kVz5c/deR8 )_%f4kra^RTHiwa^RThSaIGIW DGIWMgc/deR B RTNVKMh NOFRgNtz FANVHc/G^krW7 xipx: kVz<N B RTNVK hKMGINVf8Ric#RiF 5NVWK]c/deRiF/RizkVF/RV]LuR'KeknWekVcR D`!RTHcNnabNOF/VR8UONOFGINOc/G^krW\GbW c/deRFNVKMGbwMhJkVz HiweF/UONOc/weF/RgNVa^krWMnc/deRga^RTWMVc/d kVz<c/deR aIGbW?Y R'NOF/R8c/deRTW 2#wh#c/G^|MRTK GIW HkrWMh/GIKeRiFAGIWetc/deR

Page 101: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

Op

aIGIWMRTNOFG iRTK'UVRiFh/G^krWnkVze7\zDYIxTo:

6 A

A p 7\zDYIx:

A A < ? 7\zDYIxY9;:

A A A 7\zDYIxz:

.GIWMNVaba C ] c#k k B c/NVGIW c/deR h/dMNO`!RkVzc/deR9aIGIW] LuR h#kraIUVR+RTDwMNOc/G^krWh=7\zDYIx:]/V7\zDYIxz:h/w B 2 RTHc'c#kHiaINVf4`!RTKtRTWMK B krwWMKMNOF C HkrWKMG^c/G^krWMh

7 : 7 p/p/p.:NOc *p7 : 7 :<NOc

7\zDYIxTq:

y deRSh/kraIwec/G^krWtc#k7\zDYIx:LG^c/dtc/dMRTh#R B krwMWMKMNOF C HkrWMKMG^c/GIkrWMh GIh

7: 6 7\zDYIx:

y deRSh/kraIwec/G^krWMh<c#kgc/deR B RTWMKMGIWe RTDwMNOc/G^krWMh7\zDYIxY9;:NVWMK>7\zDYIxz:KeRi`!RTWMK'krWQc/deRh/G^rWtkVz NVWKnNOF/R`MF/klUDGbKeRTK B RTa^kLSY

WNVKKMG^c/G^krWc#k$c/dMRuzkVFHRTh 3 NVWMK 3 ]Vc/deR<aIGIWJR RiF/c/hRTaINVh#c/GIHuc#kVFDweRThkrWc/dMRu`NOFc/GIHia^RThi]

* 3 7 p.:< 7HJ 3 :* 3 7: 7HJ 3 : 7\zDYIxT:

c/dMNOcNOFR B NVaINVWMHRTK B=C c/deR UGIh/HkrwMh c#kVFA=weRThkrWnRTNVHd B RTNVK

* 0)0/ < * 3 *p 7\zDYIx:

y deRUONVaIweR(kVzDR!RTHc/G^UVR B RTWMKMGIWe<f4kKMwMaIwh!kVzDc/dMR|aINVf4RTW=ci] ] GbhF/RTaINOc#RTKc#kc/deR B RTWMKGIWe f4kKMwMaIwMhkVzc/deR$aIGIWc/deFkrwerd 7 o 8<

:

Y y dMGIhuGIh(NF/RTh/wMaIckVzF/RTDwMG^FGbWe c/dMNOc5c/deR B RTWMKMGbWeSf4krf4RTW=c

kVzN4HkrWc/GbW=wekrwh |aINVf4RTW=c kVzHkrWMh#c/NVW=cFNVKGIwMh5kVzHiweF/UONOc/weF/RSNVWMKnaIRTWeVc/do <B R RTDwMNVac#kgc/dMNOc

VRTWeRiFNOc#RTK BDC N hdekVF/c)abGIW'kVza^RTWeVc/dHkrWMWeRTHc/GIWMgc L5ktFG^rGIKh#Rirf4RTW=c/h)RTNVHAd+kVz(a^RTWeVc/d nG^z.c/deR

B RirGIWMWMGbWe NVWKtRTWMKQ`!krGIW=c/h GIWtc/deRSc Luk'h/HRTWMNOFG^krhNOF/RHkrGIWMHiGbKeRTWciY

Page 102: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

x

8) WQc/dMGIh HiNVh#RV] 7\zDYIxY9;: NVWMKy7\zDYIxz: F/RTKwMHR c#k

A A %A 7\zDY[oOp.:

A A ? 7\zDY[ox:

LdMGbHdQNOzc#RiF)NO`M`a C GIWMc/deR B krwWMKMNOF C HkrWKMG^c/G^krWMh dNTUVRh/kraIwec/G^krWMh

7: Ao 7

: < 7\zDY[oVo:

7: ?o 7

: < 7\zDY[o:

8) WQc/dMGIh h/GIc/wMNOc/G^krWtL5RdMNTUVR

A A < %A 7\zDY[oK9;:

A A < ? 7\zDY[oz:

LdMGbHdQdMNUVRVRTWeRiFNVa h#kraIwec/G^krWh

7K: Hkrh 0 < A h/GIW @ A 7\zDY[oVq:

7K: ? Hkrh 0 < ; h/GIW @ < ? 7\zDY[o:

m)`krWQNO``a C GIWec/deRSHiaINVf4`!RTKtRTWMK B krwWMKMNOF C HkrWKMG^c/G^krWMhT]eLuRSh#RiR

%A: 7\zDY[oV:

A A Hkrh 0

x h/GIW

7\zDY[o:

? ? 7\zDY Op.:

; < ? Hkrh 0

x h/GIW 0

7\zDY x:

Page 103: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

Vo

8) )RiF/RV]

A A %A 7\zDY Vo:

A A ? 7\zDY :

y deR VRTWMRiFNVah#kraIwMc/G^krWMh NOF/R

7: Hkrh/d 0 < AhGIWMd 0 < %A: 7\zDY K9;:

7: ? Hkrh/d 0 < ; hGIWMd 0 ? 7\zDY z:

NVWMKQc/dMR B krwWMKMNOF C HkrWMKMG^c/G^krWh GIf4`a C

A 7\zDY Vq:

A < A: Hkrhd 0

x h/GIWMd @

7\zDY :

? ? 7\zDY V:

; ? Hkrhd 0

x h/GbWMd 0

7\zDY :

+ + >4 $ $ 3"! ! #"%$!&%"%('*)+-,%./102."34,3"5"%$!4+,3"%)6)87!9:+! ;,%)<$!4=?>@':,3"A)8B,%C! ##D)%':+4E"A,3"3"%+ #7:C!F <4G("H>IJ;G,%)87:,FK*7CML5NO$!P':+4E"5,("%++(>,3"3 8$E"PCQ,%7=RS4)"T"3J)8:,3"%E"P U)D9VT7:("W+(4 "%$X O,3"3%4 "%$Y [Z \ "%$&"6,9V3B9V4C)7:+&]"3P"%$!F'*+4^"_`,ab!, c,3>"3%>L]NO$:,]9=:+(4d.e,e("%++(>6)8,%C!4CD `f&g 49:+1>! hi9:&"%)+(=:,34CQ?C4+j./("%$Xi.6BH+(k)$XC!4,%)9"%(8I e"%$!4+,%"%)6 <)4,mlg n0:Y 3 0::Ch7,% o?"3k4,+("%,O"39:%1GC!5"%$!$^>C!%C!>?:)E"3<)"%(8,LpN/$!5"%(8i U4)$[9:&%"%)+(5,e"%$!% U%

Z Y ( < ql : Y

<rY ? sut?Lmv8wEx

Page 104: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

lg

an

Yn

t n

O

j( 87!%At?L g o?k"%)<$; -T,34)"%8; M"%$F':+4E"a"%+2,%$!1.F! W"%$F9V8,%("%8M0 0?C7:, 0!C"%$!7("jG4)"3 a=24C L NO$!OG4)"3 9V8E"%,] %8 "%$!O9:&"%)+(_`,p)4^"3"3P&"3"%)<$4^"9V8^" j"%$!+!k2L

./$! , "%$!W?7T=2 j=V4C,0% Z Y 3 <Y 8 0:C !5, "%$!TC!& )?D)(4^"/ UF,% 8+(A=24CcL

9V4C ;8J"%$!& 8:("%7C!P p"%$!6 1G?"%&"%(8+j U)%4+&"%(G6"3i=V4C! U)4, Z?B b"%$!':+4^"-.F++EC ^"3C:24E"j,%$&9V4, , " ,3"3"%+4,L!]+(1.G&+7!4,- #0"%$!':+4E" =V4C, ,+( 8$^"%+(>WC"%$O9:+("%7:C!e *"%$, C! <&"%(8 % ./,p+!4&+(>W./("%$6"%$!#Le"C!&"3TGb+74,O #0:"%$!WC D&"%(8@;!8+4& % 84% 4,LONO$!W':+4^"O"%&k4,8 T_,$&9VA:C;"%$!" C!& )^;)(4E"0 Z '& 0!./$!% & ,"%$!A?7+(=:7d,%"3"%+! G4+()("H>0c)<$! 4,&=:7!9"%+(>Le"5$( 8$[Gb+7!4,/ #02"%$T':+4E"',%"F U, "%,3"%&=:+( _,%$&9V./$)<$#G4E"%7++(>D%4+b?4,e"3 $!,%4,%$!?_,$&9VL #"%$,% 80"%$!9:+"%7C!/ -"%$!C! U&"%(8@Ci"%$!!"FC!& )?D)(4^"/&%W:C!9V4C!4^"a )$:! 4,/ #L

SI87!W,%T7+&"%(8,F "%$:,=24$:4G(40c.)8,%Ci)$X Z g q =V4C,Lp)<$X=V4C Z q )4^"3%4C&" $,D+()+O=VC!>b4,Is x6C , AC7:, 0.F$!% Z @ Z q QLNO$P7:("/G4)"3 ,FC':!4CJ,%7)$I"%$:&""%$P+()&"%(8, a928E"%,F8"%$!W,7!% ) ],39:$! X./$!%5"%$"H.#+!k, &%W&"3"%)$4CJ& ! #"$" t?L g L NO$+(4! "%$h "%$!+!k, =V"H.4#"%$!/=V4C,a.,,3""3

Z w&%'(DCD"%$/"3"%+V+(4! "%$D c"%$!/'*+4^"a,p"%&k4

"3#=2 Z*) s+'(-,x.

LFNO$!T4+,3"%)W <)4,:C@"3/?7!4,8[4)$I=V4C[,/C!"3D!4C@7:,%!

"%$!P4+,3"%)P)87!9:+! D"%$?CIC!4,%)<(=V4Ch["%$!T9:%G?87,F,%4)"%(8IC@"%$P=*+(" >i9%=:+(4 ,,38+(G4CQ7,%! "%$! 7++02143 UP7+&"%(8 s 8!9V8+(CXC(9V8+( xO"3h="% 5"[C "*L

Page 105: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

l v

"%$!4h?7<)++(>DE"3 &"3T"%$!5?7&"%(8, "%8

" Z " sut?Lmv q x " Z -" " sut?Lmv#'8x " Z -" " sut?Lmv g x " Z -" " sut?Lmvv^x

U4)<$i=V4CI7:,%! P ?9:+)("0^,%"%>^BH,3"%&=:+(Bn=:,%4C;':,3"C! ,%)$4 ' M./$)<$;,4)4,SB,%&%>A"3CC!%4,%,c"%$!a?7)++(>F,%"%9%=:+(4 E"3%C7)4C=^>A4+,3"%)])87!9:+! !L , "%$!p928,("%(8,C#(4^"%&"%(8,e&%57!9MC&"34Cc0^"%$!5?"34,(=:+"H>6)8,3"3^"%, e4)<$h+!khsut?L f xe&G<('4CML,T!4)4,,%&%>0j"%$!DG&+7!4,W Ws x5 6h 8G4+!k[&%#CbR%7,3"34CX=?>Xh9V4+"H> ,%)$4"3Jk9 "%$;C!G&"%(8Q+(4 "%$X=V4+(1. "%$!#,3"3)"T"38+() '% t q w L ("%$X"%$!#9V4+(" >,%)<$!40M"%$!P <)4,5&%7!9MC&"34C[@ ("3&"%GT ,%$(8J,%7)<$J"%$&"5( "%$!P%4,%7+("%! ;"%8[ "%$!#=V4C,WC!?4,P!"P)89:+(>I./("%$Q"%$!#,%"T O)8,%"3^"%,0j"%$&"T"%4,3"39r, RS4)"34CC"%$!4+,3"%) U)4,F&TC('4C@i9%9V%"%8i"3;"%$TC!G&"%(8@ %8 "%$!T)8:,3"3^"LONO$!W"%(8,j"%$!4D%4)89:7"34C./("%$6"%$!F!. 4+,3"%)e )4,40E=:7!" U]"%$!F,% 9:&%"%)+(O)8!' 87!<&"%(8MLjNO$!9%)4,%,e,%9V4&"34CM0!( 4)4,%,%&%>0C#"%$!"%4,%"39h,a))9:"34Ci8+(>8:)"%$A)8:,3"3^"%, &%,%&"%,%'4CML

F "3 F"3,%4E" 9V(CM01"%$!G,%)87, ,3"3%4,%,%4, :CW"%$!4+,3"%)p U)4,j+(8! "%$!e+(4! "%$T "%$!':+4E"O=*+)WC[h?7+=7 ,%$&9VW,/)$(G4CcLeN/$!W& 8"%7C! j"%$!WC D&"%(8 0!"%$!CV%4)#"%$!EBH)89V8!4^" =V"H.4i"%$!WDCC+(F=V4CiCi"%$!54C =V4C,40:Ci"%$!!"C!& T)?D)(4^" ! Z #"%$ '&'&a&F"%$!4#)+)7+&"34CD GeT! F c"%$!F 4G("%&"%(8+* U)q)(+*,( g wwwL

,5- f&g n0M.a6'::C@"%$&"5C!9V4C:! D7!9V8["%$!6& 8("%7CT * 0V"%$!P':+4E"A./++cC! U^"3QCV%4^"[s j( 87!%@t?Lmv^x<L N/$!iGb+7!4, $ &%J,%$! ./ ,"%$@=:+)kr)()+(4, 87!%t?L t!s ExWCX)%%4,%928:C .a4++ ./("%$I"%$!8,%D ) f&g nL;N/$!G&+7!4,5 e"%$! V4)"%(G#C!& @)?D)(4^"%4+&"%GO"3"%$! 8CC!& )?D)(4^". ! /0! &%/C!"3<!4C6=?>PC:(G?C! F"%$!O"3"%+ U)O8D"%$!':+4E" =?>;"%$G4+()("H># j"%$!)4E"3 j,%,O)<$(G4C@i("%, ':+V?7+(=7:d,3"%&"3LaN/$!4,3G&+7!4,A)%%4,39V8C["3 "%$!6=:+)k@)()+(4,A j( 87!%t?L t!sU=2x<L ,A)89:&%4CI"31 f&g n0M.P':C["%$&""%$!"3<,%("%(8X"3@@+( .aT 24)"%G#C!<& @)^;)(4E"W?))7!<,W&"T@$( 8$!G&+7! * CX"%$&""%$!<&"%(2 ! / !0 , $( 8$!/ 87!O),3W=?> &99%1D&"34+(> q w3 L

Page 106: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

l t

j( 87!%Dt?Lmv ?7+=7 ,%$&9V4,5 e"%$!':+4E"5 UTC 2%4^"5G&+7!4,5 * s Ex * Z vEt% sU=2x* Z vEtt% s )1x * Z g bv f % q

j( 87!%t?L t s Ex3@& 8:("%7C!6 p"%$6C D&"%(8J%4+&"%(G6"3i"%$!+(4! "%$J a"%$!':+4^"0 $ 0G,%7:, * sU=2x 1e$! 4,i"%$W V4)"%(G692924:C)7+& C!<& ;)?D)(4^" ! 1G<! W * LA&"%@ U%8 f&g a&%D"%$D+!4,A.F("%$ "%$!D,%>?T=V8+,A./$+P"%$ 21 3 ,%T7+&"%(8,A9%4,%4E"34C$!%&%A"%$!A=:+)k;)(<)7+&e&%k, C#87!/o?"3k4,+("O,%P7+&"%(8#&%A"%$!A=:+7,?7&%4,4LjN/$!5,3"& 4,O "%$':+4^" ?7+(=:7d,$&9V4,O&%5"%&k4[ %8 f&g nL

Page 107: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

l

N-WC!48:,3"3&"3/"%$/CV%4)4,]"%$!/C&"%T, 4,%7+(" V"%$!/$^>C!%C!>?:)?C4+! !0.)8C7:)"34CXi,34)8C,3"5 ,T7:+&"%(8,./$!.a49*+(1>J"%$!#o?"3k4,+("SBn"H>?9VD$E>C!%C!>)^"3)"%(8,Asut?Lmv8wEx7,34C; f&g *./"%$"%$!=V4C U)"%(8;)^D)4E"e 8(G4;=^>2 0 Z Ms q %`w8tt(x<LNO$!i4,%7+("%, U%8 "%$4,3@,%P7+&"%8,&%@,%$1./ ,D"%$!h=:+7!h,?7&%4, j( 87%4,;t?L t!s ExDCt?L t!sU=2x<L "%$,6),30J=2"3"3& 44E"D./("%$"%$! %4,%7+("%,P f&g O,W U87CcL h!"3 "%$&""%$!!)"W$^>?C%?C>?D)6?C4+j f&g p)Q!"5=V%9?C7:)4C ,%)"%$!G&+7! 0 ,!"9% G?C!4CML]&(87,G&+7!4, 0 .%6"3(4CJCJ 87:C@"3i V4)""%$P'*+4^"C!<& #)?D)(4^"9&+(> "%$!( 8C#+("L

"!#$%& ' "($*)+!, .-/10

'

N-6)8:C7)" ,%P7+&"%(8:,] "%$&%"%':)+2)%&BH,3.Fe)"%7&"34Ci=?>"%$!A9:+:&a'4+C#t?L q 0!."3%4&"F"%$!T& 8"%),3.//,FD,34, ) , q ( 8Ci,39:$!%4,/./$!%5"%$W',%" ) =V4C,F&%9:&D& 8!"%)p:C)89,3]"%$!]'*+4^"c"%+uL a4C ) , q ,cF+&% 0&!8Bn9:&D& 8!"%)p,%9:$!%C691GC!4,j%9%4,34^"%&"%(86 2"%$! &%"%(':)+?,%./1_`, %4C6=*+(^CP)4++)&% gg nL0 $+("%$!+&% ,39*$!%W.F++ "AD)W)"%+(>["%$!P%4,39V8,3P p"%$!6!8BH,%9:$!)+n02!8!Bn( 8C@%4CJ=:+(??C)4++u0 "%$!;9:7!%9V8,3D,W!"T"3[91GC!D)"6C!4,%)<(9"%(8 "%$:,W,3.F=*7!"W&"%$T>(4+C#,%P7+&"%(8@"%$&"))7&"34+(>[C4,%)(=V4,O"%$:,O U ]9%9:7:+,%(8ML4a)$J=V4C Z q % % % ) , q)4^"3%4CX&" "h$,5+()+ =2C!>@b4,s" " "xFC , aC7, $":0M./$!-$" Z h U5"%$!9:&D& 8!"%)W,%9:$!%4, Z q % % % ) C 324 Z65 U"%$!T+& T,39:$%L ["%$!W9V4^"%,0"%$!;&"%( 5 87 %`w gg nLiNO$!;7("G4)"3"I,TC!':!4CX,7)$Q"%$&"W"%$!#+()&"%(8, 9V8^"%,8I"%$!,%7! U)P a,39*$!% .F$!%P"%$!6"H.h+!k,F&6&"3"%)<$!4CQ& " #"$"L CC"%(8++(>0& 8!"%)A=24C:,)89,%! W"%$!A"%+M$:4G& 8!"%)F9V4&=:+(" >9 L]NO$!A9V4&=:+("H>6 "%$!,%7!%87C! @4C7 ,6"%&k4r"3X=V "%$&" %h,%9:):9 0 L NO$h+(4! "%$ /"%$h+!k&& 4,,

Z w&%'(C;)%%4,39V8C:, "3T"%$F+(4! "%$D M"%$! <; 8+(4)7+4,]=::C! 5CbR%)4E"a=V4C,pD"%$!92<4^"%, gg nL]NO$/"3"%+2':+4^"p+(4 "%$;,aC!':!4C;, $Z ) s+'( ,

x .

Z s+'%' ) .iw&%'8x *L

NO$!& 8:("%7C!6 "%$!& 8!"%)6':4+CM0$= 0 0 CI"%$! U%?7!4)>[ a"%$!D& 8!"%)6'4+Cc0 0 &%)$8,34h"3>(4+C "%$C!4,%(%4C G&+7!4,O -"%$!?> XCA@CB L

Page 108: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

l8f

NO$5^7&"%8, "%(8i UO4)<$h=V4Ch&% 8G4i=^>#"%$! U)=*+)&"O4)<$[:,3"%E"

Y " ,Y " ,Y " & Z w sut?LmvEt8x

" , " & Z w sut?Lmv8x

U Z q % % % ) L N/$! )h:C"3/^7i=:+) U Z ) , q ,6"%$!i,%i)9"D"%$!%&% !I& 8!"%)# U)4,P"3I)8:,%C!4LINO$!#& 8!"%)# U)4,6&% 8(G4 =^>Q"%$!#P7!"%7+C(9V8+("%$!CM0c"%$4+,3"%))879:+! i,9%1GC!4CI=?>J"%$!DC!4+ C!4,%)<(=V4C I"%$,5)<$&9"34L 21 3 ,7,34C "3;,38+(G5"%$!=*+(" >9%=:+4 :C "%$!59:&%"%)+9V8,%"%(8,eC (4^"%&"%(8,/&%7!9MC&"34C7,%! D"%$!?7)+ ,)$!4CJ9V4+(" >["%$?CJ49:+1>4CI U"%$6,T7:+&"%(8,F a# ++! ':+4E"L

':,3"5)8,%C"%$),3./$!> Z q wiC 0 Z q %`w 1GP ! @CBQ&%'!4CML) Z q t#=V4C,5)89,3P"%$!4)<$X,3./D4_`,':+4^"A"%+j 8(G! +(4! "%$ $ Zdg '% l *LNO$!C7, "%$"3"%$!%4Ch,%9:$!%, 5 Z %`w :02Ci"%$!% U% 5 $Z w&% q lg L

S j( 87!#t?L ?0 .;,%$! . "%$#,%)+4CQ,3./! h,%924CQ "%$! C!G?)D,6h 7)"%(8Q @CB L87:,3"5,I"%$!9V4^"%,0M.':CI"%$&"5"%$!,)+(4CX,39V4CI./++-:("%++(> % . ./"%$ @(BQ"3@9V4&kiGb+7!02& U"3A./$)<$h"%$!6,39V4Ch.F++c8"38)++(>hC4)4>h./"%$@)4,%! :@CB L/N-#7:C!3B,3"%C#"%$,p=V4$1G?(10?.5,%$! ."%)8928,("3& 4,e "%$!A,3./1GO"%$!A)87!,% -8!9V(C FCV%4E"/Gb+74, @CBs j( 87!Tt?L f x<L e"F+( . @CB 0:"%$! V4)"%,/ j"%$!TG?,)87,O,3"3%4,,34,&%i:+u0 C "%$! %4,%7+("%! @"%(8 F"%$!#,%./6,P!4&+(>XJ 8CX%"%&"%8 s 87!%t?L f s Ex3x<L 18,3?7!4^"%+(>0M"%$!6"3,+&"%(8J p"%$!,3.FA,A+"34CML!F, @CBX:)%4,34,0M.,3 j( 87!%ht?L f sU=2x6"%$!hC! U&"%(8 F"%$!i':+4^"6=V4)84,,%( 8:(':)^"0pC"%$!h,3.F ,39V4CD)%4,34,L0 0$! .aG40 @CB ,]"3?P %4&"0"%$!/G,%)87,a,3"3%4,%,%4,p=V4)81G%.F$!4+ WCCD,%$I"%$;9:+("%7C! /"%$!#C D&"%(8:CQ"%$! ,3./! h,%924C ,6 87!%4,6t?L f s )1xC@t?L f s C2x<L

"!$# %& '#)(+* -,.0/1!$# /2&3(

NO$!,3./D! ,39V4C,a4,%7!4CD=?> gg VC;)89:7!"34C;=^> vv 2&%A+,36,%$! ./; j( 87!%At?L l L!6"%$! ),3i)8,%C%4CM0 > " Z q ?0 0 Z q % q ?0p:C 5 $ Z w&% q ' L NO$!;,%./! h,39V4C, 8(G4I=?>[,%T7+&"%(8,CI"%$!8,36=:,3G4C J"%$!6?9V4E"%,A&%)89*&&=:+(0M4,39V4)++(>h&"$( 8$&@CB L;N/$!C,%)9:)(4,A=V"H.4"%$!D,%P7+&"%8 C 92<4^"%+ %4,%7+"%,5&"T+( .a@CB&%A&"3"3(=:7"34CD"36"%$!9%4,34:)F P!4&%=?>D,%7% U)A;"%$!?9V4E"%,C;"%$!C D&=:+(" >

Page 109: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

ll

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 70

1

2

3

4

5

6

7x 10

−3

Sp

U

j( 87!%Pt?L NO$!T,)+(4C@,3.F ,39V4C G,%7,<@CBI D9:+&/,3./O./"%$ > Z q wC 0 Z q %`wL

Page 110: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

l

j( 87!%t?L f$ NO6)89V8,%("36& 4,A ]"%$6"%(8J a#9:+&A,3./1G5"%$!)87!,%P 8! 9V(CP./("%$> Z q w0 0 Z q %`wChs Ex,@(B Z q % tsU=2x @(B Z g %`wDs )1x,@CB Z v % ts C*x @CB Z t% t

Page 111: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

w

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 80

5

10

15

Sp

U

j( 87!%6t?L l o)+(4CJ,3./D! ,39V4C aD,% 8+(W,3./F,; U7:)"%(8h ],39V ^7:W=V@?L@NO$;"%(8,T 4!&"34C =^> "%$;& 8!"%)'4+Csut?L q xW./("%$ > Z q ?0 0 Z q % q ?0pC5 $ Z w&% q ' LiNO$!,%8+C +P.F("%$I"%$!D,?7&%D&%k,W,$!1./,"%$!D,%)+(4C,3./D! ,39V4C,="%4Cr7,%! [8+(> 21 3 8!9V8+(4,6"3 %4,38+(G "%$!h$^>C!%C!>?:),LXNO$#,38+C+!;./("%$"%$!)%8,,34,O.e, ="%4Ch7,% T"%$!W U7++2$^>C!%C!>?:)?C4+uL NO$!5"3 8+(5&%k,O&"%$!92<4^"%+V%4,%7+("%,e U%8 gg ./$+F"%$!TC,%$!4Ci+!A.,/="%!4Ci=?> vv% nL

Page 112: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

q

CQ=:+&"3;,$&9V "%$!%4CQ=:+(??CQ)4++uL@o7)<$Q)8C"%(8,)<$! #"%$!DC!& [8X"%$!;':+4^"CQ"%$!DC!& [CXG,%)87,"3/^7D8X"%$"3"%$!%4C=V?C!>L F,W.a;./++j,3# 1e$:&9"3 ?0j"%$!$^>?C!?C!>)p U)4,p:C"3/?7!4,p$1G/=V4,%$1./"3W %4&"%+(> 24)"a"%$!/:("%+? %1./"%$ V"%$!,3./! ,%924CcL/NO$!T"H. ,T7:+&"%(8h"%$?C,C!;9%C7)T)8:,%,3"34^"F4,%7+("%,F+("%$!87! 8$["%$!%4,%7:+("%,e 87:Ci$!%CC#"O%?7(%A%4,%)+! , "%$!>iCC 1 vv nL ,%G%T+("%&"%(8# "%$!4(C!4+2,p"%$!4C#"3$1GA+&% ,%9:&&"%(8 C,%"%)4,=2" .a4 "%$F9:&"%)+(4,L NO$,p,39:&<&"%(8C,%"%)P,F8J"%$!6C8J8!6=V4C[C7,CI,T7:)$ +&% A"%$J"%$!+!k?,F7,34CI["%$!92<4^"%,L NO$,a+(4C,"3P 7:C!%4,3"%D&"%(8 -"%$!D& 8("%7C!F c"%$!A& 8!"%)"3/?7!8"%$! ':+4E" "%+uL >67,% F87!a+!k! F9%)4C7!%0"%$! =V4C, &4^7"3e)+8,3 "%$!O!"]& 8"%)"3/?7!W,e.4++V%4,%8+(G4CML

!,

S "%$,e)$&9:"340.C!G4+(9V4Ci,%P7+&"%(8#"34)<$ ?7!A"3,3"%7C!>;"%$!&%"%('*)+V)%&BH,3.F49:+1>! 21 3Q0"%$!5T7"%7+MC(9V8+(?C4+2:Ci 4+,3"%)A)87!9:+! 6?C4+*9:%4,34^"34Ci<t?L g LNO$,WC!4+]"34&"%,T4)<$)$!4)++!kIX"%$!;':+4^"W"%+a,39*&&"34+(> =:,34C8 ,38+7!"%(8Q"3+4&4C=V4 ^7:&"%(8,L]N-T"34,%""%$:,a?C!4+n0^.)8:,%C!%4C;"%$!A)$ A;,%$:&92C#C!& FJ)':+4^"T ++! @7CT 1G?"H>L "%$!4)8C:7)"34Cr,%P7+&"%(8:, /"%$#&%"%':)+,3./5)"%7&"34C=^>Ji9:+&A'4+C CI 87:C & %44^"W./"%$["%$?9V4E"%,5&"$:( 8$! U%^74)(4,L0 ("%$#"%$!,T7:+&"%(8D"%$!?C:,aC!G4+924Cc0^.54>#!1. !!F"%$!A=24$:4G(a "%$!/&"%(':)+./$4,%7!=R34)"]"3P+("3&"%(G/'4+C,j,%("%7&"%(8:, ./$!% " .a6,3./]&%/++(1.4C"3D^"3)"L

Page 113: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

"! #

$&%(' )* +),- $./ 0

1 32 4 $65+!# Sr"%$,)<$&9"340e.@C!48:,3"3&"3@"%$@&%"%(':)+ )%&BH,3.F) +,3X=Vh7,34C "3,3"%7C>)%k,%)%. Bn" >^9VW,%./! !L ,% P"%$59:&%"%)+(Bn=*,34Ci,%P7+&"%(8 "34)<$ ?7!4, C!4,)(=V4C "%$!9%G(87, )<$&9"340:.a'*C "%$&"O./$4iC!(G4 =?>;"%$'4+C

7 Z .= 0 s q 0 ,%+8 0 )8,98 x % s ?L q x

"%$! =:+)e *"%$! & 8"%)&0EG,%)87,jC64+,3"%)e U)4, )7,3 "%$!O,%./j"35"%&kO85,%9:(+,%$&9VL CC("%8++(>0c"%$;,3././++j%"%&"3i&"W"%$!#,%# ^7!4:)>I,T"%$!#&99:+(4CX'4+CM0CD"%$!% U%0"3,%+&"3F"%$!%87! 8$D"%$!K:7CML NO$!F%4,%7+("%,] %8 "%$!4,3A,%P7+&"%8,]&%F9%4,34^"34C ?L'W U%8 ./$)<$"%$!Fk?!4&"%),p c"%$!F,%./1_`,p"%(8#&%AC!4C7)4C;C#+(> 4CML NO$!G&&&"%(8i "%$!W,%./! T,39V4Ci.F("%$ "%$! U%?7!4)>D j"%$!T&99:+(4C#'4+Ci,eD!4CML

+(8! ./("%$["%$!69:&%"%)+(Bn=:,34CIC!4,%)<(9"%(8[CI,%P7+&"%(8,40*.)8,%C!A"%$!+("3<&"%(GC!4+M./$%"%$!P& 8!"%)5'*+4^"O"%+ , "3%4&"34CI,/;)8E"%?7!87,/4+,3"%);,%7!=R34)"O"3#& &B!"%)]"3/^74, CT$E>C!%C!>)jC!& !L NO$!4,3a,%9:+(':)&"%(8,2>(4+C5FC!4,%)(9:"%(8A"%$&" :)+7C!4,"%$!# 4&"%7%4,P4,%,34^"%+"3["%$! "%(8c0 =:7!"T,T,3"%++p))4,%,(=:+(;"3I:+(>?,,L[N/$,W++(1./,P7,T"39:+(%A 7!%"%$! "%$!59*&"3, G "%$!,3./! P,39V4CiCi&kW)89:&,38:,e./("%$"%$!#%D4+,3"%)9:&%"%)+(Bn=*,34CQ,%T7+&"%(8,L5S ?L g 0].D"34C "%$!;?C!4+p q w f 7,34C"%$!4D,3"%7C!> A& 8!"%)++> C!<(G4r4+,3"%) ':+4^"%,"3)+7C!# 7++(>X"%$%BHC4:,%(8+

'

Page 114: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

g

"%(8 C#P$( 8$!e+(G4+2%9%4,%4E"%&"%(8# c"%$& 8"%)FE"3)"%8,L ;+>?,%,p ,%9:(+,3./! 6&"/+( . U%^74)>#,e"%$!4i 8(G4[ ?Lmv!L

1 '

,%! X"%$@9:&%"%)+(Bn=:,34C,%P7+&"%(8 #"%$![&"%(':)+O,%./#C!4,%)=24Cr "%$![9%G(87,)$:&9"340 .a9V% U ,%T7+&"%(8, h,3./D5./("%$ ) Z q tiC 5 Z %`w C!(G4I=?>I"%$!& 8!"%)/'4+C[s ?L q xa"36C!"3/"%$!,%)+(4C ,3./D! ,39V4CM0 T0?1G "%$!! q @(B U#> Z t?0 q wFC q t?LjNO$!]4 9*&"3,-&%pC!4^"%)+"%$8,3p7,34CW5"%$!p,T7:+&"%(8, j"%$!59:+:&O)"%7&"34C[&"%(':)+M,3.F C!4,%)<(=V4Ci "%$!59%G(87, )<$&9"34L

j( 87!4,)?L q C1?L' ,%$! .d"%$!6k!4&"%),A "%$!"%(8X1G8!9V?C[ WGb&87,.@CB./("%$ > Z q wLTN/$!T4,%7+("% ;,%)+(4CI,3.F ;,39V4C,F1G"%$:,! 6 @CBX&%691GC!4C j( 87!% ?L g s Ex<L- J4)$Q),30c"%$!C(4)"%(8J a,3./! ;,A,%7)$J"%$&"A"%$!6"3"%$!4C 4CI,&"6"%$! %4& O"%$!i,3.F6,("6,3./,`"%+',%"L(_ e"6+1.@CB 0 "%$#'*+4^"T"%+%4D,+( 84CX./("%$X"%$!;&99*+(4C '4+CM0 :CX"3 "%$!6"%$!;"%+pC )4++a$!4CQ"%&"3#,P@<( 8C =VC!>s j( 87!%4,.?L q s Ex]C ?L q sU=2x3x<Lo!7)$5"%8,j%4)(9?)+u0&]"%e%G,%(=*+(08C))C! 8+(>0C!?4,p!"a$:(=:("]T!"p"3:,%+&"%(8 q w g nL F+,3!0^&"e+(1. ^7!4:)(4,0E"%$%F,a,%( 8':)E"]"%(8 /"%$ +&% #,%9:$!% &""%$!#"3"%$!%4Cr4C,P"%$!i,3./P9:(G"%,&=V87!"6[9V8^"P./("%$Q"%$!"%+uL F,"%$!PC!(G! D %?7!4)>h,/)4,34CM02G?,)87,F,%"3%4,%,34,=V4)86,%( 8('*)E")7,%! ;"%$!':+4E" "3rC! U ^"3 r,39*(+,%$&9Vs j( 87%4, ?L q s )1x C ?L q s C*x3x<LGi"%$,;! U%^74)(4,P.ai,3i"%$ ,%./! [,39V4C)4,3i,6"%$!i,%7!=:,3?7!4^"T"%&"%(8r /"%$ ,%9:(+,%$&9VA++( ./,p Ue"%$!5,3./D4_`,a"3,%+&"%8D"%$!87! 8$#"%$!FK*7CML @CBh,a)%4,34C#=V>8C#"%$!G&+7!D)%4,39V8C! i"3J"%$!;924&k ,3.F h,39V4CM0 "%$!#,3./D! h,39V4C,%4C:7)4CQ,T"%$!9:+("%7C! p"%$!C! <&"%(8J,FC:,%$!4C =?>h"%$!P1G%./$4+! #G,%)87,,3"3%4,%,%4,6s j( 87%4,?L'!s )1x5:C1?L'!s C*x3x<LDNO$!6G&&&"%(8I e,%)+(4CQ,3./D! ;,%924CI.F("%$ @CBX U9:+&5)"%7&"%8=V4$4G4,Fi,%+&e! vv% nL

Sj( 87!% ?L g s Exj.O,3 "%$&"])%4,% > i+(4C,j"3A %4&"3a9V4&kT,3./! ,39V4C,L0e"+( . @CB-0E"%$!F&"3&"./$)$"%$F,3./! 5,39V4CD %1./,eC!4)4,34,p.F("%$D:)%4,%! ?> L NO$,],T%4,%7+("a "%$!':+4E""%+u_`,&=:+"H>"36%4#,3"3 8$E"eC#+( 8!4C;./("%$;"%$!'4+C#&" 4&"3'4+CP,3"3%4 "%$,L0 87!% ?L g sU=Vx )89:&%4, "%$!e,%)+(4C6,3./! O,%924C:,-)<$(G4C6 U%8 "%$!7:,3a "%$!8,%)++&"%! '4+C[sut?L q xp"36"%$!8,39%C7)4C=?>"%$!%"%&"%! P'4+CD./("%$ > Z q wLaNO$!F,)+(4C,3./! P,39V4C,%4,%7+"%! P %8 9*+& )"%7&"%(8h&)89:7!"34Ci7,! P"%$!A9%4,34^"O"%$!C,

Page 115: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

v

j( 87!% ?L q p:CQ8 C=:+ ?7!G(./,T O"%$!;"% )89V8,%("3Dk!4D&"%),W /"%$!;& 8"%))&BH,3./F GW"%$!)87!<,36 a8!69V(CJ./("%$ 5 $ Z w&% q lg 0. 0 Z q %`whC8> Z q wLs ExeCsU=2xe)%%4,%928:C "3 @CB Z q % tCQs )1x :CXs C*x"3 @CB Z g %`wL

Page 116: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

t

j( 87!% ?L' p:CQ8 C=:+ ?7!G(./,T O"%$!;"% )89V8,%("3Dk!4D&"%),W /"%$!;& 8"%))&BH,3./F GW"%$!)87!<,36 a8!69V(CJ./("%$ 5 $ Z w&% q lg 0. 0 Z q %`whC8> Z q wLs ExeCsU=2xe)%%4,%928:C "3 @CB Z v % tCQs )1x :CXs C*x"3 @CB Z t% t?L

Page 117: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 70

0.002

0.004

0.006

0.008

0.01

0.012

Sp

U

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 70

0.002

0.004

0.006

0.008

0.01

0.012

Sp

U

j( 87!%?L g o)+(4CX,%./! ;,39V4C G,%7,W,39V ^7:W=V4L@s Exo!)+(4CX,3./! ,39V4C)89:7"34CJ7:,%! 7++ $E>C!%C!>)?C!4+nLFNO$!PC!"3"34C +./("%$@"3! 87+&F&%k<,)%B,39V8C@"3:> Z t?0V"%$!6,38+C[+!T./("%$h"%$P)(<)7+&A&%k,A&%P"%$!> Z q w C&"%#CJ"%$!C,%$4C@+./("%$@"%$!T,?7&%P&%k,A,/"%$!?> Z q tD),3L6sU=2x/o!)+(4C[,%./! ,39V4Ch U> Z q wi UCV%4E",%"3&"3 8(4,LNO$6,%8+CI+!6./"%$J))7+&&k,)%%4,%928:C,"3h"%$!%"%&%>i,%)<$!4;s ?L q xOCi"%$!C:,%$!4Ch+!A./("%$i,?7&%&k, "%$!9*+&O,3"3&"3 >Qsut?L q x<L

Page 118: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

f

Ch&W)8,%,%"34E" ./"%$ "%$!8,3 gg -:C1 vv nL $+(5"%$!,%./! P,%924C:, &%W)89:&<&=:+(&"A+(1. @(B 0*"%$T,39V4C[ "%$!T,3.Fh"%$!T9:+&F8,%)++&"%! '4+C@%4)$4,"%,Fb!P7G&+7! ./$+D"%$&" "%$!h,39:+a,%./)8^"%?7!4,6"3 %1.WLN/$!ibT7 ,39V4C U"%$!,3./5I"%$!"%&"%! h& 8!"%)'4+CI,&w3 %4&"3T"%$: "%$&"I"%$!D9:+&58,%)++&"%! '4+CcLDNO$!& 8:("%7C! e"%$!"%&"%! @':4+C s ?L q x54,)8:,3"%E"T=:7!"5"%$!D8,%)++&"%! '4+Csut?L q xeK*7)"%7&"34,/i& 8("%7CA:Ci8h4G<& P,/,%++(1L

!8 "%$!O,%P7+&"%8,0(" ,j=:,3G4C6"%$&"]% 8&C:+(4,%,j :"%$ Gb+7 @CB 0E"%$!e=:+) 2"%$!G,%)87,0b& 8!"%)pC4+,%"%)j <)4,-:C7)4,MO)%k,%)%. ,%$&9V ./$!8,%]9:("%)<$CC,3"%) U%8"%$!:BHb, Gb&>#+(8 "%$!+(4! "%$h "%$5':+4^"Ws j( 87!%4, ?L q C ?L'8x<LNO$!5%4,%7:+("%! ,%$&9V%"%&"34,6&=V87!"5"%$!BHb!,./"%$ "%$!D,%D U%^74)>J,T"%$!D&9:9:+(4CI'4+CML o7:)$X[,3"%&"%(8&%>,%$&9VA,+,36$:(=:("34CD=^>#T!8!BH& 8!"%)4+,3"%)/':+4E"e./"%$;P"3/?7!A&99:+(4C;"368!A4C l8f nL +("%$!87! 8$ a"%$!/),34,)8,%C%4C$!%F"%BHC!9V4C!4^" ,%$&9V .,p$:(=:("34C=?>6"%$!,3./40E&=V GAT)("%)+: ^7!4:)> M"%$!&9:9:+(4C':4+CM08"%$,p1>D!"=2/"%$!F),3A4,39V4)++(>( 0 q L "%$:, % 80!"%$!9:$,%,%$( U"e./++V)4,3W "%7E"%+u0G4E"%7++(>0"%$!W&9:9:+(4C"3/?7!#./++ G,3 ("%,TC:(%4)"%(8 +(4C h"3J[%G,+X"%$!#%"%&"%(8 O"%$!#':+4E" ' q nLNO$,]=V4$4G(,p4+&"34CD"3P"%$&"$:(=:("34CD=^>T9:(a c!8BH& 8!"%)/9:&"%)+(4,p;W %K:7C,%7!=!RS4)" "3D%"%&"%! ':4+C1mt q nL

NO$,3"34C!>i,3"%&"3W9V8,%"%(8 +(8! "%$!'*+4^"O&)+(4! "%$T&"O"% D4> =VAC4,%)(=V4Ci,

js x Z s&x0. s ?L'8xMs x Z .bs&x?,%Ms 8 , s&x3x s ?L g x

s x Z .bs&x?)8, s 8 , s&x3x s ?Lmv^x

./$! s&xA,A"%$!:BH)89V8!4E"T&" Z w0&sbx,A"%$C,3"%) U%8 "%$!:BHb,0 C s&x,"%$!P9:$,3P,%$( U" f&l nLNO$T&)+(4 "%$J,/4,%7%4CJ%4+&"%(GT"3#"%$T U%P4CML AV%4^"%&"%! #"%0!"%$%4,%7+"%! PG4+(?)"H>i,

Z s . w wEx2, s . 8 w wExQs x % s ?L t8x

Page 119: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

l

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 10

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

s/L

α(s

)/L

Sp

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

0.7

0.75

0.8

0.85

0.9

0.95

1

s/L

dα/ds

Sp

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 10

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

s/L

b(s)/L

Sp

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

s/L

φ(s

)

Sp

j( 87!%?Lmv NO$!AG&&&"%(8i Os Ex s&x<0-sU=2x ^s&x<0 s )1x&s&x<0:CQs C2x-s&x./"%$i&)+(4! "%$./("%$A> Z q wLANO$!WG&+7!4,/ sbx/C -s&x/&%T 8G4@%4+&"%(GT"3#"%$!8,3P "%$!P=V4C[&""%$! U%4Ci U/.F$)$ Z :0 s !x Z w02C s !x Z jLNO$!W)7%G4,/ 4)<$@9*+("/&% U/C 2%4^"@[email protected]$)$ =V 8i&"<@CB Z q % tDCi)%4,%=^> )44E"%,O w&% t"3 @CB Z %`wL

Page 120: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

("%! Z 8 , sbx<0"%$G4)"3F"% 4E"F"3"%$!)7!%GT,e 8(G4h=?> Z s bx

Z . , . )8, . )8, , ,% s ?L 8x

Ch!?"34:,%(=:+("H> "%$!':+4E"O9:+(4,

,

,

Z q % s ?L f x

j( 87!Is ?Lmv^x6,$!1./,P"%$! 9:&<"3,,J 7)"%(8 F&)+4! "%$1GDJ # @CB L S"%$!4,3F9:+("%,0?T)8^G4^"%(8 ,pC!9:"34CD./$%&sbx wTC s x Z @C s !x Z wW./$!% Z )%%4,%928:C, "3P"%$!/)4^"3 M"%$O=V4CD&""%$!O U%/4CcL0,@(B :)%4,34,0^"%$!/9bRS4)"%(8D M"%$!':+4E"+(8 #"%$BHb!,)4,34,Ds j( 87!% ?Lmv:s Ex3x<L 87!%?Lmv:sU=2xA,$!1./,A"%$BH)89V8!4^" 80 #, 7)"%8I p"%$!D&<)+(4! "%$MLo) 0 Z q %`w0 ;&"T+(1. @(BQ$,i!4&+>)8,3"%^"G&+7!6 e)8,1s v^xA./$:)$I)%%4,%928:C,"3h ( 8CJ%"%&"%(8Q+( 8!4CJ./("%$J"%$!&9:9:+(4C'4+CcL :)%4,%! "%$!6 U%?7!4)>@ "%$!&99:+(4CJ'4+CIC7:)4,F G&&&"%(8 D+8! i"%$!+(4! "%$ T"%$!I':+4^"0./$)<$ "%$I+("; WG%> +&% I U%^74)(4, ./++O%4+( 8!4C./("%$Q"%$! BHb!,0 Z q LXo+&+(>0 j( 87!% ?Lmv:s )1x<0].i,3;"%$#C,3"%)D U%8 "%$! Bb!,0 0aC4)%4,3@,6"%$!i U%?7!4)> ,6)%4,34CcL j++>0p j( 87!% ?Lmv:s C*x<0.ah,%i"%$&",@CB )%4,34,40QGb&&"%(8 "%$![9:$,3h,$( U"&,34,0./$)$ +(4C:,"3Q"%$![!K4)"%(8 928E"&99V4& 6&" $ 7 w&% lg &"/+1./@CBJ1G! "3 $ 7 w&% t&"/$ 8$ @CB L

N-X"%(i"%$,9:&"3<4&"%(8r"3"%$!i=:,3%G4C ,%)+(4C ,%./! J,%924C:,C ,3.F C(4)"%(8,0e.[49*+(1> "%$[!8BHC:4,%8+ G,%8 "%$@%4,%,3"%(G@ U)IC!4+/.F$)$ ,9%4,%4E"34CP"%$! U8++( ./! A,34)"%(8cL ("%$6"%$, ?C!4+C6"%$9*&"34&"%8 :"%$!O"%(8M09%4,%,(86)=VeC(G4CP p"%$!O,%)+(4C,3.F F,39V4C6=?>T^"3 &"%! 5"%$ ) =*+)s ?L' x# "%$! :BHC(%4)"%8 C&99:+(>! Q"%$!@=V87C:&%>r)8C("%(8:,[s ?L g v^x#C s ?L g 8x<L NO$!%4,%7:+("%! P?9:%4,%,%(8@,

Z s q . x 0 & & ,5, s q . x 0 & s ?L l x

./$!! "C#$ "a&%A"%$!A%4,,3"%)A)^;)(4E"%,e4,39V4)"%(G4+(> U "%(8#"%! 4^"e:C#+"3X"%$!i"%+uL 4C&"34+(>0(",)+(4&"%$:&" ,3"39:) C!& U)s%'&Z q xP,D!4)4,%,%&%>"3 ="%I!8B X,3./D! @,39V4C mt0 f nL "%$!6%?7(%44^"%,6)+7:C!;I!8B B)89V8!4^" 80 &Z w0-@!8B %@C:,3"%) U%8 "%$!:BHb,0 &s&x<0-CXhGb&&"%(8

Page 121: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

q ww

"%$!;9:$,3D,$( U"0 sbx<0 +(8 @"%$!#+(4! "%$ML CC("%(8:++(>0M"%$!#C!9V4C!4)8 "%$!;,)+(4C,3./! ,39V4C,#)8:,%,3"34^"i./("%$ "%$! %4,%7:+("%,D T"%$!X+(>,%,; U87C f nL !8 "%$!!"34,%=:+(" >)8C("%8M0"%$!WC!4!8D&"3 j"%$!&=V1GT?94,%,%(8i,e9V8,%"%(G

5 " $ , q , s% . q x 0

,

0

w s x

5. q weo w w ( w Js '8x! "!$#(% &' ##V" (!"!% ! )'* (%$+ (,-1 /. ' 0 '21 $! '43 65 ' 5#(,6 7!98 : %#(; $<!$#= !8 ! , -!>,? @!,@ $# BA % &! U:7$#8 $B3$C ED%FBG H*@F3$!$C!%I3 ##( UJ!% $ (, #K! U: ) (, ML>!5?!%6 N %58%! O!$P 8*#( 8*8%46 3Q! # R> $#, #$!VS!T & @U !$#= % *#(3V $! 3 #& P% @# 3W,78*#($$? S,8 % ,@!>@: #V @#& L95$B (" ,!% QX*# $B; O#- 3% 3$ 9Y 6 &*#(6 !3$ *#(%Z05%: O6 ,#&! $ #] U: [,$?\ # *?@ (, P]=^ `_?a ]=^ ^ a # % 88*#! b &VF $ 3: #M U: c (3/@! ,VJX*# $? : "*@!Q3!"8 $ M! @!%,@ O6 Y @* 88*#O ($( ,!% JX:$#-ed8V$% &X* ##

Bf ,hgji k l ] D%FBa

?m ,on f , i , k l % ] DDRa

!pgWiP p3 # (, #K! ; :I8Vc@* &>#($6 Z i< !\! ,@ 3:q@!\8V5@ &#($6 !\ ,!% J3:q@!J8V>@* &;#($6 ,SJX*# $?%rts. u[vNw !+HwNv.&ex #zy[.!By /*|Sx &w~ !BM /*| !9X*# $BNR! %,@6 ,7! Y @ -, & ##^8V: ($* ! 5 U:O% 6 5!> (,- 6 % &!5 U:"!:3 %,@BF >! U: , &!

gji\k .c ] D',a

Page 122: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D%F6D ! !\X*# $?;!$#(% &' (!\3$ 5 , &!$V

k " ] n$n , ] . n$n aa % ] D,aL9!7! S^P% $B #,6 V!7 6 $? #N %$+ (, " C!! 3%8C, ? %" U # F ed3$#(% 3 # 6 !%,@6 , Y @ ] ^ a

" k ' #( ] $ a2, ]] # ] $ 6aa a ] D+_?a k % ] D ^ a

! $ \#($6 i !"X # $?% !W @ MX*# $B9% :> $+ (, UV $q@ #*3! O@ 8 ,!% 5V -HL9!%% ?3%*@$% &!/ U:Q! : J!"!$# : @ $ 6*@69" 78V ?#& *n D #(,6 (!J3 # (, #-! 66 Y @ #O#* e% (, M!JX*# $? V,@6 n] EDD a

i\k . ] n a?n ] D ,a &

k " n , n n ] DRGaV$ 6 ! ,@# ;!$#(% &' k _ !\?P% ($?O >!"! ,@ 3:q@!rts. x 3& / (+#'y !BM /!/WI8 %#(p $ !$#= !7 ,!% ?3 + (, V% $ pV 8%@$j ?3)8 O%#( : *@IS ,!% V3Uq?@!i, : 8 %#( %6 7 ## !S ,% U: V% $!c2 e %F$q?@ # D88V &3B>3 # ,!% / UF,P!>X*# $B %6NL99 B3:8 %#(; ,% U: N O##=! %!$8%@ !%H3Uq?@!/, : % ,$? H!IX*# $?9 # ,@ I! P8Vc@* &9#($6 j %3: !$ ?S, !: O6 < : ( ed3 #(% 3: &*@63$ #(, # O! !8 ,!% "3Uq?@!p$# !%J\3:q@!8V9@ &;#($

k 9 0 #" ] a 7%$ ] D,a ! k&0,(')*%% 8V, 3" , # O!; 3: *@6 (,W 8V, ?H &8V,#( +! !;X*# $? Q 3 ,B%Z X* &3$#&V#(, CIV ,78:: P & % %8 3$C,*-,' -!7 &8V,#(

Page 123: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D%F,$?O j : V S

" k _

i$i 7 , D_ n ] n " a

. " % ] D aL9 V U%, !/8% (,P!U &!$ ED%FBG !c#$6 D -c# I %#@*!$7 !9 ?38 : %#( %8 (,7* #(,6 p9 ,!% ; ?3 + (, ##!;8 : %#( h!@ \ $?78 ($CL9!( %#O@ (, 9! V!% O# p ( O78V BI3 q@ B &!7,78 : , & Op@# (, Q@!3 %3h N! 3 & ,BQ: HV > *V!p#O ! O%$# (, 8V2% $W!I &8V,#(",$? 5 S! 88*# ($SX$#- ($,78V "! "q@ ? & ( OB37!$ # (3 ! #Z,78V,!$?

" k ] " n a?n ] n$n a " ] FBa7 k ] 7 n an ] Cn$n a 7 % ] DRa

c82, @6 &@ (,V ?3 ] D a;!58% : (," k i$iD! "#" ] ,a n ] n 7Ca$ i$iD%! "#"&(' ] ,a ] n$n a 7 % ] ,a

!$ %W*)c ($ % @*+ (, 8% +3 ] ,a k,+ - & D . 7 D(% L9!% @*#& 6 88*# $(3:q?@ ] D,a9 $ k 90/21 ' iRi ] ,a3 4 D5 ] i$i a ] 3 a ] ,a76 4 D ] iRi D,a ] 3 a ] ,a76 ] n 7jazn 7 % ] ,aL95 : S,$?9 # %"!$

f k ] _?a n f m k ' ] n a?n ] ^ a

L9!", &@6 &!"# $ U>! 3% ,$B> m k98;:/n n <8>= @? n ] a

! V U%A8;: !A22$+ &!JV$* 6 \@#O@ e B8;=M !A2V$+ &!J ;@#@

Page 124: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D%F M!JX*# $B%rts.ts K&ewex"!v&ew # (+#)&| I!D U%D$*-Vk F D U: [,$B p@ \! f k l m k lZ !(3%!%$$*- Wk>N!# : 7 * ,$? 7 %( # $ !(3 # (, # % (, #Z! ! 8 !%NL 7!"X*# $B %# 78V$(3! 8 !%!"V,@ , (, ; %

f 1 5 ] 5 n a k l ] ,Ga m 5 n f 1 5 k l % ] ,arts. &w# /2&| #)&ex7MNx (+#)&|L9! U: *P,$?N # O$q@ (, N >!, O$ (, # $p?7 ?3%@% 6 5!9 %%$! : *#( c @U k 8; \k 7 k = / 7[ * f k 8;: f ' Q @6 &@6 I ! : *#( OB37!W$q?@ , i$R! 6 7!\

f k n$n ] n$n a ] ,a ' " ' +!"/n k ] n 7jazn 7 n ' n ' ] 8;= 8;::a n ] FBa

! k 90/ 1 ] ,a ] i$i =>/ a '3 8;: 4 D ] iRi a ] 3 a ] ,a 6 4 D ] i$iD,a ] 3 a ] ,a 6 ] DRa k " 8 8;: % ] ,a

L9! Pq?@ B & \ %$# 3$[3 @CB * >"! B3@*$ !;8V: O$B # @ ( <] a S : &V$( (!"8:%%! ,@ ; $+ (,-d82$% X* ##&jk " @CB _ 1 ] ,a

# kTF&% DD >"!H L9!"* 2$Q2% $$ >"! ; % @#&e M!5%%X !$$? !\ ,!% Q3:q@!\!$#8 $B3$W!%

Page 125: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D%F _L9J2,@* P,* & (, O(3: !\* $ ,#( ! U *#( ; %

f ] FBa k l ] _?am ] FBa k l ] ^ af ] DRa k & ] DRa 5n ] DRa ] a

m ] DRa 5 n f ] DRa k ' V] DRa ] ,Ga !

& k 1 5 " ] ,a ' k 1 5 " ] ,a

1 .- - 1$'' ! 'T &(!5 U: S,$B; # 5$q?@ (, U%, % &!A :\! ,@*#(# Q3@ W! ! P 6 8V$j 5 2$+3$ S!I! #@! ]%$#(%! B58 %3 % *#(Q3 ,Q8% % O<* %% :(<, O!: 6 p!J ! q@ &3J#( !/( %% , ! O ##2%$ V%#( $#& # & ,!$ &(! 88*#O ($X$# S@*! ! :#PU & , % ,-e78 #(R 6 "/% &!/ U:QB!%6 ; p!$#*3 @*6 %% , J 88%8U 3 *n D W3 X* V ,#@6 ,[8 $-Z j8V N V,@6p!;U & , V6I% (, EDD DDRG6D%FBG ! !%, ! I@# (, " #8V$+I! ,#@ (,In93"Ve ! U: ] aU # 6 ;! @+ , * ; 9 %82$*!$B% & @#"P 3X**(! ,#@6 , /,! 8V$% &X c O G* eL>?@ HkTF*!8 (,V

3 3 k 3 /3 3 &3 B ] ' aNk D] D '/ a &%$' 3 &3 ] ' a ] `_,FBa3 3 k 3 /3 3 &3 ] ' aNk /] D '/ a &%$' 3 &3 B ] ' a ] `_DRa3 3 k 3 &3 B ] ' a ] `_ ,a * & (,I3 3 ? 3 Qk ]3 ? & 3 a ] ' aUHL !, P!9 ,? @ &zp 3 / 3 , ,B!$6) (, ! ] a9 Q ## $W3(VI2W8V & &! C!% &! 5 !83$Z"L9 c # %$!

Page 126: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D%F ^! @78V eL>! #($ O6 82$ ] ,a; !$

k ] D5 a & & 4 &/ '/ 3 & B & & 4 B ] ' aNk B ] ' a % ] `_ ,a

!,4 8% ,-^,"!e,#& ,V!%! (,# , U & , <26P (,(! O 6 8V$C ] MaUZ*@6 # V &J P @#&A e ] ac! : ,j OW78* tR!5!"#($ i M!JX*# $?%eL9Q O!3$ &* #O &',* & (, ] Ga ] Ma 78*#

3 &3 k / 3 &3 % ] `__?a%X* /ck

& 4 & * ! kbF k & ] ' a W kD ] ' aU!W8 (, U9! #$VX*# $?;!$#(% &' S!" 6 $?9!$+3 % k / & B ] ' a ] `_ ^ ak ] F$ /*$FBa $F$ / & ] ' a ] `_ an k n / n & B ] ' a ] `_?Gak 4 D ] D '/ a &%$' $F$ / ] D /Ra &%$' 6 / 3 &3 $ 3 ] / & a3 $ 3 &3 ] ' a % ] `_ ,a

d * ] DRaA (, \ V,@6\n %P!T8V$+3$- ! 8*8%8: 38 (,I U\!P* $) (,*#( ; 6 ,@# ;!$#(% ' ] DRGa9 k / & ] ' a ] `_ ,ak '/D '/ $F$ /D '/ F$ D] D '/ a &%$' 3 ] / & a3 $F !" & n / ] ' a % ] ^ FBa

L9P U:7 # ] ,aJ * 3 "!6% @#& ?" B3U # 3% f ] ac3 X 8846 (,- U & 6 f k f & f ' ' ] aU6! U:" # ] a 3 &3 k / ] ^ DRa

Page 127: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D%F ! f & k ] F$ & $FBaUL9J $! # ,#O@6 (,V

& k 3 / ' ] D '/ a &%$' & ' % ] ^ ,a

L9!D %;$ , & (, ] _?a$q?@ % ' k F ! !<3%!%$$[,* & (, ] a + 3 & k & ] D 5 a *

& /] D /Ra &%$' k98 /] D /Ra &%$' % ] ^ ,aL9!",$B> # ] FBa ] Ma

] n / 7Can & 7 hn f & n / 3 ' n &3 ' ] 8;= 8;::azn / 3 ' ? &3 ' k l % ] ^ _?aL9* 8:% (,( ($# "!%\ O!%8V$!$?a$q@ (,

3 &3 ' 3 &3 k F ] ^^ a3 ] / & a3 ' 3 ] / & a3 k & ] ^! a3 ' ? &3 ' k F ] ^ Ga ! ' k ] D '/ a NL9J (:#$q@ (, (!5 U%5$V,$B>2,@* ,* & (,] ^ aJ O78*#&V J% ! ] Mac 6 6M 3 ? & 3 k FIL9I $ # ,#@ (, 3V!%$ O 6 I D$q@ (, > %

3 &3 k & & * ] ^ ,a3 ] / & a3 k ' ' * & ' 3 /

] D '/ a &%$' % ] ^ ,aL9! ] a V,@* P,* & (, ; 95 %W$Qk F %

3 ' &3 ' k F ] FBa3 ' ] / & a3 ' k F&% ] DRa

Page 128: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D%FBG O#( >!"3%!%$@$5k DJ!% %

3 ' &3 ' k F ] ,a3 ' ] / & a3 ' 5 & k ' /] D '/ a &%$' % ] ,a

L9! %!,\!$@ & k & k F 3 & 3 Jk F # ! ' k

/] D '/ a &%$' 8 ] _?a ' k /] D '/ a &%$' 8

' D ' 5 D

' D5 ' ] ^ a

U%"8%$ \ OB3%@ ] a k 3 ] / & a3 ] ! a ] a k

] a 3 ] Ga

= ] a k ] a 3 ] ,a

/ & k ] a0 d8V$% &X ##&! @+ (, ; % ] a k ' ' &

' 3 / ] D '/ a &%$' ] ,a

] a k ' ' D

' 3 / D '/ &%$' 8 3 / ' ] D '/ a &%$' D

3 / ] D '/ a &%$' ] G FBa= ] a k '

' ' ' D ' 3 /

_ D '/ &%$' 8 3 / 6] D '/ a &%$' D 3 / '

] D '/ a &%$' % ] GDRaL95 :\ # ] ' a

3 f '3 k ] D5 azn / ] n & / n / & a0 & ] G*,a

Page 129: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D%F O:V V U &3$ 3 f '3 k ] D azn / 3 ] / ] ] a0 aa3 /] D '/ a &%$' ] ] a0 a D] D /$a &%$' & %] G*,aL9!@ ,## 8 (, f ' k ] ' $F$ ' a %[ !$ ? OB3% O6 ! 2!$q@ (, 88*#& 6 I! U%5$VV,@* P,* & (, ' k ' kTF p !

' k DD '/ / ] D Ma D '/ D ] D '/ a &%$' / ] a ] a ] FBa ] FBa /] D '/ a &%$' ] = ] a 8= ] FBaa ] G_?a ' k ] D5 a /D '/ '/ ] D5 a D '/ ] = ] a 8= ] FBaa / ] D5 a] D '/ a &%$' / ] a ] a ] FBa ] FBa /] D '/ a &%$' ] = ] a 8= ] FBaa % ] G ^ a

L-P!%3: O! p 88 #&P!\2,@* P,* & (, ; >!"3%!%$h$ ' ] DRa k & ] G a ' ] DRa k & ] DRa ] DRa 5 % ] GGa

\$ %: &! >!58:% (,h 9 #($ 8V$ k B ] ' aek / ] DRa] & TDRa ] & !Ka ] D '/ a 4 & 5 ] ] DRa ] ] DRa ] FBaa ] & a ] D ] ] DRa ] FBaa ] = ] DRa 8= ] FBaaa76 ] ' a % ] G*,a

!/ M & ,@!% ^ *! O 6 8V$( , &!$ ? ] G*,a #,6 &(!p%% 8V, O6 ) 8V$ O!$ , I@# (, %Q8*#(3$Z ! !Q8*# " *%#@! I@# (,% @*#& !%Q!J?!6 O> ?3 + (, %J3:@* 3$ t3>!5 UQ,!8V,#(Q3:] S)Ca #(,6 &! Q O%#@ O6 "V(,!8V,#( V &8V,#( 5] S) "aU ! V(! 783 h% @#& P ! I@# (, @ ! P#( @CB ! #($ 8V$ ! : ( \ @CB SL9 783 P8%$ + , %% 8V, J & S) % @#& L9 ! (,7 M 3: &*@3$3J!e% ! U: 88:%46 (,V$ c!;! : % 3$ & # O!F Nd3 #% eL9!"* 2$ ! I@# ,< V) V) ! !<%%$+ (, , !P ,!)n:!"?!%6 P22$+ !/ (,--! +)

Page 130: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D%F $? 2% $S! I@# (, ! 783 ,#O@6 (,( 78R! >"!C ; ! 783 #& ; @* #bD T &p!a8% : (, ] G*,aU W ! ! ! 8 %3 R!: O6 c ,%

U: 2 / VJ ,%3: \8 %3 5 V$+c#( @CB 6r x 3& / (+#'y !By /*| M & ,@!% 6] a ! > !c^ "P% $Be O ] G*,aj Ue! #($ 8V$- p @*+ (, eI8 %3 R!U 6 V!6%$# &! 3%$6 I !7 ,!% P U: \L9P$# &! 78*#O &@! 9<3 ! ( ,!% <X$#Z / M p %P$q@ #e3hD F L9! P 6 8V$,!3,* ##&!$% ; & T!$ k F UV%% 8V, 3 $5 88*#O ($( ,!% JX:$#-! 8V$V X* &3 S !J! #@!

k ] * DRa '/] & TDRa ] & a ' ] D '/ a $' & &D F 5 & D%F &

5 ' & _ ] G & a 5

' & ' ] & Ma &D & 5 _ % ] G ,a

L9 @#&Z $ # :P 6 6$*@Z A8 6 ! ,#@6 (,J & Z @$J D S! % F<!W 6 W R! * : ] G*,a> ! # SV$, ! O6 ,#& #O# ] ED%FBG aU -! O 6 8V$ !$% \J % @#& e % $C ,% 3:q@! %8* O6 7!JX*# $B # ,!$ &(JX$# %$+ (,- !/(!\# O & ] * DRa '/

&%$' ] & TDRa ] & a ' ] D '/ a ' & 5 & 5 D 5 ' ] & a ] FBa 6 >"! $&%$' !/! ,@!% 6] ac!! #O@!T 8*#(3$ J @*+ (,@ , &!$ ] G*,a #(,6 (!"! #@! k F V! 83 Q! #@! !W%$# &! 8*# &@F M!"3 ! p ,!% JX:$#-2 / % ! 8V$ ##c % W3 8V ! #@!j %%@ ( /&7 D @6 $q?@$B#& $ S / ] M & ,@!% G ] aaU L9!"#O &0 / FP%% 8V, 3P!\ , @!A M!J3 ! X$# 8*8% :* 6 %6 ! # O &Q! O## %$ #O & ,!$ & ! ) 6

Page 131: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

DD%F

0 1 2 3 4 50

0.002

0.004

0.006

0.008

0.01

0.012

Sp

U

0 1 2 3 4 50

0.002

0.004

0.006

0.008

0.01

0.012

Sp

U

0 1 2 3 4 50

0.002

0.004

0.006

0.008

0.01

0.012

Sp

U

1 2 3 4 510

−4

10−3

10−2

Sp

U

1 2 3 4 510

−4

10−3

10−2

Sp

U

1 2 3 4 510

−4

10−3

10−2

Sp

U

M & ,@!% ^ d #($ O6 8V$ \ I#( @CB I! U (,@ > !HVL9! %8*#(3$o V7# ! )'# ! #( )'# #( HL9! ,# # ! !9% (:%@# M % 8V,3! S) I@# , S)',!8V,#( ,#O # H &P!>3: 6 ,@# e %! S) I@# , 9L9!I !$W# !p ! #($ O 6 82$W , &!$W? ] G*,aU!/ ] a ] a> !Wk ^S] k _ % F ^ Ga ] a ] a>"!Ck D%F ] k %DD ^ aU ] Ra * ] Ua> !Wk D ^S] k~D%DRG*,aU

Page 132: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

DDD

0 5 10 15 200.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4x 10

−3

Cm

U

10−2

100

102

104

10−6

10−5

10−4

10−3

10−2

Cm

U

M & ,@!% J] a > @*+ (,i , &!$ ? ] G*,a ] ac )'# P8*#(/ ! ] ,# # a; %#O@ 6 7p! #@! k F ] G ,a W! 83 p! #@ 5 ] FBa] $S# ! aU !/ ] a * ] a 5 hkTF&%D ' / k D(% F ] aU (, $q?@!$?#& ##! -Hd6 C!5! #O@! Z!A @*+ (, # 3$ 88V$ ^ ## #(\#O ! :#&< / eL>!% U%! , ] G*,aU \ ! '/ 95!O3%$ $ / 6J3 ! JX$#V I@:V 3c V ,* &@! T! , BVX$#O- ! +%5! , &@[ I!C3 #JX$# V$, @?V,@!$-L9! % O<* # %?! O##:$ (%#( $#& # & ,$ &(! 88*#O ($PX:$# % 3 c : & , S26 # 6 O"! 88*# ($SX$#S $? ##&(#( # $ 3P! ) 8 # !3 3 #O#6V %6 !;! A% , I & , &X* ? O6 8V$ <8V$+3$ # P & $ &$ L-5 I! 78*3 8 (,- %$ , / * H @#&

] DRaa] & TDRa ] & !Ka '/ & 5 8 5 D5 ' ] DRa

L9 #( O6 D:53U U%, ] DRac ] G*,aU UW 5 % 3$ S!P UI # V,@ :<, (,V3: 5 np O ] D%FBaU ! ,@!% G ] a \8*#( > @+ ,i / #(,6 &C! 783 O! #@ L9! / F 783 ! #@ #O%@# 3$ j@ 6 k C

Page 133: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

DD

0 1 2 3 4 50

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5x 10

−3

h0

U

10−2

100

101

102

10−8

10−7

10−6

10−5

10−4

10−3

10−2

h0

U

M & ,@!% G j] a @+ (, /; U> !bk ^o] k _ % F ^ Ga ] ,#O o#O !aU,>"!bk D%F] k %DD ^ a ] !$b# aU<> ! k D ^b] k D%DRG*,a ] !3$ #O !aU > ! k F] k D % ,a ] )'!3$j# !a & 5 k F&%D ] a c )'#( 8*#(O ] ,#O S# a ! 83 7! #@! / F / ] DRa ] $[# a & > ! k2D%F 5 k F&%D

Page 134: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

DD

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1−0.02

0

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

0.14

R/L

U

10−3

10−2

10−1

100

101

10−6

10−4

10−2

100

102

R/L

U

M & ,@!% V] a \ @+ , 5 U?> ! k ^[] ,# # O!aU > ! k D%F ] !$[# !aU> !Ck D ^ ] !3$j# !aU > !Ck F ] )'!3$j# !a & /Qk D(% F ] a c )'#( 8*#(O ] ,#O (# !a (! 783 Oc! #@! U 5 F ] ,a 5 ] ^ a ] !$# a & > !Wk D%F />k D r # /1! /1 / ( !vL9!#( @CB P 6 82$C *% ,!3, O ##& 5 > !/W* Z!! # &z !" #%@# ,V # 3$<3 &@ (, !% 5 ^ $ 5 ] DRaUT & 6 *\ #%@# , * 3 9p# 5 \ !p! U (,h !"X # $? U-6 (@!:-68:%*@ & ,! O6 82$ c# 5 ! %!$ !! 2$, 6 &! !,@# @ P! P 6 8V$ 3W$% VL9 22$+ !" 8@%$C?j #%@*# (,- $ 5 bk F < !58V$+3$ *Z C! $*W H! 8*!% !p ,!% "X # $?>, %$ !\ >< %3: "26;L9 %$!%$S< 78*3 ,#@6 ,-#! J $! # % 6*! %!$! : , (! ,!% O @ %8 &* O# &' ?; PF$# >8:%8V ( !5#O c] ED%FBG a #(,6 I!5X*# $? (8%@5! %3:< !QV$ !\!$ : 37 $! 3 !% 3 # (,( ! $5 BV 6

!/V!"# O &e 5 F 8 D & ] ,a

Page 135: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

DD+_ V"^ "P% $B U9! 8V$V !"# P &

] DRaa '/] D /Ra $' & DD ' D

D O % ] ,a

L9! % 5 > QV!5!5 - 5 T8 5

% ] _?a

T &V ! #@!5 U 8 !\#O & \! #@!5 U ] DRa '/] D /%a $' ' ] 5 a &

D ' $ ] ^ a

V@ ] 5 a M & ,@! ] a > @+ , 5 #(, P! 783 c! #@! 8% $?3$ VR! W 5 17 F&%D >!j!%8V$!$WV% , 3 3 & (, U%, # ! <3%@6* O $ 5 ## H! 8*!% 3 # (, # ! C 3P h & % , #! 6cL9!% U%*p! U: (,[ H!pX*# $?> 5#( 3 O6 7 > % @#O H! %3 @ $ h!S3 # (,r Q! 8*!%/ %!RO, 5 V$, #

$!,@6 ,Z?!% (, # ! #O#6Vc# <!53 # , #*! 6 Z %:* 6 ,#&!!%8V$!$* H! U: , % 3$ & P 6 ## V ] 5 a

Page 136: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

DD ^1 .- 5!/S!T8 (,S: &!$h U> ] Ma 82$ 88V >!p! #O@! H!W @*+ (, ] aU ] aU - = ] a 9! U% S3%!%$h$* NL9!Q! #@! M! @*+ (, %

] DRa k 3 /] D '/ a &%$' D O 8 8 5

D5 ' D

' D 8 D '

D ' ] a

= ] DRa 8= ] FBa k 3 /] D '/ a &%$' D O 8 5

8

' D ' D

5 ' D

' D _ 8 D

] ,Ga ] DRa k 3 /

' ] D '/ a &%$' 8 5 D ' D

D5 D ' ] ,a

] FBa k 3 / ] D '/ a &%$' 8 % ] ,a

1 1 5

@##&5!%+)' O$ (, # I@# (, :$ V$"8:% $?3$\ M! U &V ! 6 : I %%378 ,% V V,!$j3 %!\ ! Y 6 &*#(# 3i U: # U!$ 3 # 8*!: O #N8 O%#(;! -CL9! U!$( 8@!% !% #!2V$+ e ,!% O Y @ J$# P U: 5 & !X*# $?% !zJ V$C!$, 3 3$ 9" ,!% J O% ) P; B3@*$< &(8*# +@ (,S S2"@ $ !$#Z3 @ % U: O6 66!: &!$V % O6 P ,!% O"X$#Z !/ % \X$#Z,! ##6! U: B3 \ 8 ( # 82> p% 3 V,@6 6 P! ($+ (, O6 6KL9 !$ Z!Q (, %F3 +3$ <8 %3: $? !%8V$$BA @+ (, ! : & 6 V!<8* &:ZK! *D U%, ! %3 W!\8 ( #(,6 <!p#($ @ N\ #= *@!!$ !I%% 8V,!$*\V% $j 8 %3: (, (! !$ O 6 I!$#(% &' # !$Z 8*8%46 3! : 8 (, ;! (, 8%! $ % &! U:($#N O:<!QX*# $? O# 3% 3$ ; ,? @!,@ $# @AS$+ 3 3: *@63$ ,% 3:q@!\8VQ@ &9#$6 - 78*3 # U5#( U%$q@!$+i% , 8:%$ +3$ ! P 6 8V$p % c & #O#& @CB ML9!p%X*!$$? 3c!% &! : !$#! U &V$" %p : $B #? W:! 35 :I! p@*# (,5% @#& Qe* Z !,!

Page 137: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

DD !% 9 ^V%% 82,*!$QV% $V!Q U;! P 6 9#( $q?@!$*+NL9! 783 #& @!!p !$? &X$C% *#&W22$+ ! O6 V!!I8 %3 R!U 6 " ,!% JX:$# V!\ ,%3 Q P U & 6 6 !% 2$C!#82U $? #K!$, 3 (,[ 8 ( # ) / X*% #BP % ) O$ L9!e8:% $? @#& !,@6 , * 3e @*: (, 8V &*# D2V$+ &! * & (, ##, &p8V$ !Qq?@! (, 3 p 8*8*# ($7X:$# & ,?\V!%! $ 3C $! 3V<,78*#o6 * &3$ [ ^ * 78*#( &X*% # O## R!p O<" (%$+ (, !", B5,78V,!$B ! 8*8*# ($X$#O-!> %$+ (, X$#7 V>U 6 $DR! 93" ($# !$# # ) 8 O# c3 5 @!:U 8V: @!U 6 (:!$ 6 _,F 7L9! 8*@# (, P8%8*@# (,6 &X % #* O% ) P H @ 3 ,!% >X$# 8%R! ! & ,? ?3!"%Q $! #q?@! (, %% : O6 P 6 pP % )n ; @! ##&D%%@!: 6 8* # K @U +3: c % VW U:+)n U% I3:q@!+)n &"3:q@!?:3$ % Y* $##@ ,@?3) # $7\!;! ,@ 3:q@! !9,@?3)n% 6 p! -L9!9 ,!% N U:+)n U%> @6 @6A3$+H3 %N3:q@!O U%,~! 3: #*X$#- L9! ,!% OQ #-!,@6 ,V : % 8V, Q3$# Y @* D U: c (?@ !$, 3 3 !;% 8V, I VP: +3: OD 9P $! # 3$ ! [8 %@# $ X*% # O pV9@ $358*#(;!9,78*#(6 & ( P) OM B3 + (, N 6 O 6 6 * ! V,@ @!% Wc OS!p8% $T p* ($? Y L9!( %%3(8 %#((! U &8 (, >! Op@# (, #($ & $#( >3j &@ , \ !%% &!5 U:\!$# (2J %%@! 393?<,8*#((3 #&

Page 138: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

% $) % %

), . *%+)

+),- $./ 0

2 4# 65 !%, $# O)n * $! O c)',6X !$ @!U: 8V: ED%F 3IP ## %3N#(,6 \3 ?\,@ 8V: ,39@! @#($+)'# 3U@+@!% U:$"? : 6 +3U F ! ?3 + (, V% $ P 6 9 O% )n ! V$W !$I3Q# \3 : :p! : (%' K,#O#($+ &!52$ ! ( )O$$?9 +) !$V?!6 O e @* ( EDD * p@*# (, pU & , #&(,!$+3$C8V, ? ,@!: ^ _ $#( t)'#(, 6 #% EDD%F N#($ O & ,?c ?3(! * # & !$ " F * & (, #O#&N! @ ( #,6 &" ^ G F *# !$h! V%$ V% $ @ 8V$ (, 8 @ ! ) z?8V " %<<!U@ p $! 3$V$ <!Q8 &!5$#($$? ! 8 @##( ) z?8V P !%J!Q!U@ ; W %,? 6!8 &! ,78V,!$B% 88% UT U6!$!% # ,U 6 ! !$ ; V!" ) X$#V?% P c OB3 + , V$,\ 82: B ^! !$ 3 V %,@B3$ RQ@ ? ( @82U $? ##& ! %$# , &8oV% $! c6 H @ 8V$ ,\882: ( B O7 $! #=q?@* &39 "P%@*#&%KL9 &X*% #6P % ) O ?2 ,?3%,## *#(e!$# 3$ JVe@ $\ J8 # ] ^ * 38%R! !p & ,?> ?3P* %$# (, 8Z !/S* ! V%$ !$W3<V\q@ ? &X$V% $S 3: ##&(!: &!$ 3$ *V! $# O)'!U &!$ UV &9 O

DDRG

Page 139: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

DD!/I : 8*3$ 9! @ ! 8 : %#( $6%%8 $B ,3 OB3 + , V% $V P O% ) P ( )'R! 6 ,6X* ,@! (, d@6 6 p!" ?3 + (, ) &X*% #? O% ) P !%% ##\8%! O! M 6 78 #(a P) OK OB3 + , !>!5!% # ,: "!Q!: &! 6 A U: P, &@6 &!5# $> % $#O#*! U &V$ V %, @* ( 9 %\! !$ : !Q W!!: &! 6 U: 2 N! O %p8% : 2$ EDD6KD%F _ * & (, ##% @# 8% $B3$W!% ## U>W%! #@ ) (,D -! %%@! + !%% # !$# N !%9!5!% # ,: PN8%8 @# (, % & ,%$ ^ GHDD6 ^ _NDD%F !/B3 + , $%@6 V2 Y $##@ V 6 @% 6 % 3 3% , ( Q %\, O!%$- L9!\% # ,*: 6 7p @! H! ?3 + (, O%#@ O6 !T,#(T e!I OB3) 5 ,!% [ ) X$#jB!%6

U: %8%R! !$Z %, % @*#& \ o,78 : , " & !;%$$?pV,@ $#($$? I@# , 8 (e K ?3 + I +3: ^! J (q?@ B ( !52V$+ &!$! : 63: #O#&\!: !$ 3$ H !$#? U 7 B3U ##&J!: !$ O6 > ^ * V

L9!p B3 + (, V% $j < )'R! 6 &X*% # % ) ; W !$- I,) / U,@!5 c !%\ > %I: &!$SSVWX$# ]=^ DRa ] DRaU * W V%$?\,6X ,@ (, P Uh,6X ,@! ,-M! 82$o ,8*@63$R! 6 D %8 (, ! P , !%$ZCk D%FVk % F /k D(% F %X!$ P 6 P W!!% &!*)' (%$+ (,Z k D ^ 2 ,78:: p!T U O X*# $B; # , ! #$6 k% * L>!5 @ !J3%!$ 8*!Q k % F* !% U% bk~F&%DL>!6%$ O6 P8 %3 " %7 $B # 3V! $78*#($ j! ,#( @ ( 8:% $?3$S (!"8:%%! ,@ <: 83 w v+| w y ,x"! !/ WX < %8 (, !$+3 $# k ] F$F$% a !C (,T !: &!$ !8*# 88 # ($ X$#O ]=^ DRaU F%! %8 (, (%$+ (, 88 # ($ ,% 3:q@! % # & ,!$- L>!S (,r Q! # % *:!%,* $h? ! 8*8*# ($X$#Z P !C! #($ 8V$ : V '& #( [! ,#( #($ 82$Z( k F&% FF ^^ !/ * & (,C3 P (, O ! O 6 J %$+ (,-?! R! 8 a , U; #(, \! %8 (,

Page 140: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

DD

5 10 15 20 25 30

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.3

h/R

Uz/U∞

Uz

10

110

−3

10−2

10−1

100

h/R

Uz/U∞

M & ,@!%pG?D 5] a>d O 6 8V$ > @+ ,; %8 (,S 5 U $ O !: !$S 88 # ($(X$# ]=^ DRaU ] a9L9!T%%8*@# (,(!$#(% &' S!I !$W# !J8R! !$ ] G?DRaU"L9!I % ! > (,@ e!p R!5,p8V: (h e! 8*8*# ($X$#Z ] a )'#( V8*#(A !%%8*@# (,W!$#(% 'JR! 6 %8 (, IL9! $S# ! 8%R! !$( ] G?DRa S$ > ' ] M & ,@!% G?D ] a G?D ] aaUWL9! #($Q%%8*@# (, 8V$-( O p 6 I@ ! #@!D ( F&% D ( )',B +% P!$ N %8 (,ZML>!; (, ! # % :!, $W?S 88 # ($VX$#O %! :#&S O!$B O #3!I2 58 3: e # M P, $%@ &!\8*# P , %$V# 3/, V%\% # ] M & ,@!%pG? ^ aUL- #& !X ) X$#O B3 + (, S $ !$T! %8 (, p@U % 3 !9#($6 6 ! $' (' >, !M! Y X$#I $! 3$ #( :!j8 (,6 ! 26 U:9 3: &*@ (, % 3$ & 7 ,# 3$ V,@6"!P82 & (,I !3%!$ 8*% & ] d? 88V$ aU \ #O#H!P ?3V U: ; %A$q?@ # #88V &3!Q3 #M U + &

& ] aNk F @6 %3: ! ] aU ? %3U #"! ] aU 8 J!@ :j &8V,#( %$! ] a C!,) ! #O@! L '& ( & k ] F$F$% aU !#% @# 6 S ! $r,@6P 98*# Y %U 6 j3] G? ,a; ) ] aNk +* -,1 ' ] G?DRa

! * , !p,) %P O ! I! #@!5 L9\ !$W# ! O M & ,@!% G?D ] a CG?D ] a %\8R! !$S ] G?DRaU %8 (, D(% ^6] '=aU !T%%8*@# (, 8V$8%@$W ! I@# , !? $W% 8V, 3VP ) X$#OW @! * Y 8% )

Page 141: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D F

M & ,@!%G? @$)n,S! ( H!p ,h H !+) B) ! 8* # 6 R!A,!8V: ( M! 88*#O ($(X$#-L9!\ ,h M!" # 9 %p,@8*#($V(! 88*#O ($(X$#( 5 % P,@?3c%#( @$?! U:c* &8V,#( : % 3$ & " 6 ,# R L9* %%8*@# (, N % @#& ! ,8% * # &z Y @ Z Q!"!P,@! e,!78V: (--!P (, ! C! ?) 8*# !$?3 "Y @ #(, V! ) ?) ? p U !$X :$Q,@6 #(, S! ) 6 L9P$@+ (, O6 82$ *!JV8*# !$j?j J #& J ) k F * " & kTF & & & kTF #(,6 &P8*# P ?!5 OB3 + , !: !$P!5X$# ] DRa % , %$-KL>! ,W O R!H! ,@! ,! 8V: (" ! I ,@!%G? V %! %8 (,(!$+3> # k ] F$F$% a *@6 !$+3c 8V8V$ %@# N3! %$+ (,J 8*8*# ($j3:q@! M & ,@!%<G? ] a ! c !% @# 6 #($ 8V$ Up! 8* # O ,6X ,@ (,- L>!P! #@! I %(!: # $ !< ,# 3$! #@!5 ( k F&% F6D%F -*!" * & ! 8V$- O:V B %8 (,-6#( !Q! #@! ( ,# 3$ $ ! ,Q OB37,? +!%5 e 88%$% *#(>!$ c P! O6 8V$ & ! ,B + ! #@!O ZF&% ( L9! ; & (, ##&! 8 & #($h%%8*@# (, 8V$ ( " S8%$ 9 ,@ :Q! C8%$ , 8V$ ( ] ,@!%<G? ] aaUPL> J [ ,@!%G?`_P #( )'#( #( P,8 %!78:% $?5% @#& 3V ! * R ^! !%7!73 S$+3: % %3: !$ @ 6 CV,@ :Q$#($$? Op@# (, P o!$#; +3U h!

Page 142: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

DD

5 10 15 20 25 300.75

0.8

0.85

0.9

0.95

1

1.05

h/R

U/U∞

U

2 5 10 15 20 25 30

0

0.25

0.5

0.75

1

1.25

1.5

h/R

U∗ /U∞

U⊥

U‖ ω

U∗ = U⊥U∗ = U‖

M & ,@!%\G? c] a;d O6 8V$ ; @+ (,# %8 (,V A !+) B) O! ) !U &!$SS! 88*# $SX$# ] DRaU ] a]%$ : (,W!$#(% ' ( J%%8*@*# (,V!$#% &z( "%B! @ H %8 (,7 HL9!; !$ *7!3$# ;8%R! !$IT$q@ (, 9] G? ,a ] G? ,aO% 8V$+ &!$#L9!" O % (" PX ,@% > !p (,h M!\ O R!,!J8V: (# M! 88*#O ($X$#-

101

10−3

10−2

10−1

100

101

h/R

U∗ /U∞

U∗ = U⊥

U∗ = U‖

M & ,@!%cG?`_ )'#( \8 #( !98%$ : (, *%%8*@# (,I!$#(% & ( ! 6 O %8 (, NL9!" !$S , !$V? ] G? ,a V!"!3$W# !Q ] G? ,aU !$ V# '

Page 143: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D,6X ,@ (,, !$<! ! ##& c +3U !%8%$ :; 2,@p :h! !W ?3) %8 (, * $% 5! ;! %!R9! +3: : 6 C!$ ( O6 (%$+ , P O $ U%, U!$ /% jX* ! 8* ( # O6 : &X*% #9P % ) O 6 &* I8:%$ (, *@6P! 8 : % VL9 V%$> O6 : %, !c!$# +3: 2$ O6 8*@ P! X*% # O V$ 8*@## (L9!<,82,$BT ;! 3% #(%T%$# 3$o3 !#%%8*@*# (, [! &X % # O\ 88V &3 & , ; I !< +3: # # @#O 7! +3: >! &X*% # P ##c!(: 6 C!$ O6 (%$+ , O @: %: $B (, !;VJ8V: &3$(! 88*#O ($X$#- V U% [,8*@63PD2V$+ &!; U:( &8V,#( %$! I! 8* ( # #& >/ ) X$# OB3 + , ! c! #O@! -!5,78V,!$? !F22$+ &! U: &8V,#( * ] G? ,a & & & k ] F$F$% aUQ![ ) X:$# Y VW%3: !$ZbL9! @! Y %$# 3$S3!%%8 @# (,!$#(% &z(

) " ] aNk * ,1 ' ] G? ,a O#(c"8%$ (,(!$#(% &'V , !$V?

) ] aNk #"' 1 ' % ] G? ,aL9!P! #@ 8%! O!$ C! D$q@ (, p % ! !$ [3$o# O! ,@!% G? ] a G?`_ [ U[ I@# (,C! #@! \ p# %8 , " & !8 # O$Z ) X$# %%8 @# (,C 8%@$ ! ,78V,!$?W ! 3% #%%L978%+) , %$# 3$C3V! Y $! 3$ , ?53: #H ,!% 3:q@!,I U O$ $e| *y6! hy ,x"! L9! @#& 8V$ U ,X ,@! (, !%H! %8 (,J!$+3M # k ] 3 $F$FBa %78 $B3$Z !/j ,6X* ,@! (,-- Q %78*# $I,!7V$ O !$L9! (,XR!P,!78V: ([ U"8*# P C ,6X ,@! , J ! M & ,@%<G? ^ !V !V8*# ] M & ,@!%jG? 6] aa 8* ( # N! 8V$r A% P % 35 Sp ,# 3$V! #O@! O#(Q! 8V$i M!T ,B 9 #( L9 22$+Q # P &3$ P!5 F 8* ( # +@ (, !%c!F$* $$? O 8V$ !/%

Page 144: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D

M & ,@!%G? ^ 386) ! H!I (,h H (, $%@ &!p8 # R!A,!\8V: M! 88*#O ($X$#-

2 4 6 8 10

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

1.1

1.2

2d/(L + l+ 2R)

U∗ /U∞

U∗ = U2

U∗ = U1

U1

U2

2 5 10

10−2

10−1

100

2d/(L + l+ 2R)

(U2−U

1)/U∞

M & ,@!%G? 7] a5d O6 8V$ Q c % 6 $ , $%@6 &!$#& C!: &!$W? 88*#O ($SX$#O ]=^ DRaU ] a c )'# V8*#(/ ! V%$p O 8V$ c &S !$# 5V$ P U%, G?`_ &(!"! #@!5 * & & , U>J8*# $

Page 145: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D _ V%$@+ ,V 8V$ M! U%,? P % > ^ & !\ ,# 3$V! #@! V '8V O - ! (! #@! ! 8V$ Up! :# ## %8 (, !p! #@\ V!I ,# 3$W M & ,@! G? 6] a ! > \ V%$I V! P 6 8V$ 5 @+ (,@ %8 (,W *W U>8*# O !%, ] G? ,a Sp,78V,!$? $ ! 6!W ) X:$#V @ Y %% 8V,* 6 I ?3 + (,W

) ] 3 ak * & & ,1 ' % ] G?`_?aL9! V%$ 8V$ 5 %8%! $ S ! ,#@63I! #@!P ] G?`_?a % ! !V !$ # M & ,@!% G? 6] aU L9; ) X$#o! #@! I % !$ %8 (, 8846 3$#&h #( OP#($ # 6;! P%3r J!j B3 + (, %! !$? !i ) X$# ?3 + (, O##@ 3 3 ( & ] 3 ak ( ) ] 3 a ] (8a ( ' ] 3 a<k( ) ] 3 a ] 8aU s ! x ! y ! ,x-y ! | #(,6 &J! B!%6 M ?3 + (, K #( 6" %@ $- B3) ,!% p U %"8:% $? V$+>!5 @#& P NL9!" ,!% " ?3 + (, 9 % V3 : SV% $ $#( t) $p*#($ : @ 8V$ (, J8 ,!% V _ L-q@ B t"$ (-2V$+% ;,@+ I@# , !% ! OB3) M ,!% O OB3 + , %V & ,!$- # @#& W (, I ( X$[[?% P P ?3 + (, 7 #(,! !$[,78 %$[3 ! (, U%, ! @## I@# , !P 82: !P ,% ?3 + (, V !$-HL9* ,78 : , !,! M8*# p! $ S, $%@6 &!\,X ,@! (, M & ,@! G? G ] a ! c !@%8*@# ,o!$#% &z <! $ ,X ,@! (,Z L9!W! ),? +O%%8*@# (,!$#% &z! %!$* %#( U#&P!%8V$!$? @68V,P!J# 3 # ,!% Q ?3 ) (, ! %8 (,< % ?!Q ,!% O> ?3 + (, !$ D 8* O#& *P!F ) X$#?!6 O !, O 3\!6 cL9! # ,B5!$% 7 P 6 8V$[ ,@*h U8*# O O ,6X ,@! , V$+3$ ![%$R! #F J!W ,% ?3 + (, !, $%@6 &!,6X ,@! (,- !< ,% 3 + ,[V+) $<!>X*# $B !? $ c! 8V$D O% #(; O!: 5 ] -!

U%,B P$;L9 $ $$?%-! %!$- % W!IB!%6 9 8*82 c3!, O 3!%!$ ## %8 (,

Page 146: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D ^

5 10 15 20 250

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

h/R

Uz/U∞

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

1.1

1.2

2d/(L + l+ 2R)

U/U∞

M & ,@!% G? G ] a<L9![%%8*@# (, !$#(% &' @+ (, %8 (,Z ] aL9!W ) 82$ >, $%@6 &!p8*# L9 ,# V# O! &(!\% (U%@# ; c % U%, I@# (, > %p ,!% 7 ?3 + (, J O%#@!$ #\! !$C# ! &!"3U 6 ,@# 9 % 8V, 3<! Op@# (, !J!\ ,!% O\ ?3 + (, c % & ,!$- .

L- #& "!5 ) X$#V ?3 + (, 9 !$ !$(! %8 (,S " I@:V 3 j!7#($6 J ! $ ' 7, !5! Y X$#O $! 3$ ? #( :8 (,@ !V6i U:7 3: &*@6 , % 3$ & ,# 3$ V,@6;!"8V (,# J3%!%$ 8*!% & + &

& ] &* a + & & !

4 + & & 6 ] &* & a 4 + &

& ! ] & a 6

%] G? ^ ad *jV ! ?3V ,!% O $# J U: $q?@ # * 88V &3> 3 # U: + 6 ,C! P ?W BJ W %6 + &

& k~l-pL9!,$? ;!# U I * !# U 82,# K! %!R %,) %6 [8%R! !<!<# 6 hU!,?3: &*@6 ,V3< Y 5%X* 6 %$! k + &

& ! ] & $6a $,78V 6

Page 147: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

−1

−0.75

−0.5

−0.25

0

0.25

0.5

0.75

1

tω/2π

GS ij/(4πχa

3H

2 0/3)

GS12

GS11

GS22

GS33

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

−1.25

−1

−0.75

−0.5

−0.25

0

0.25

0.5

0.75

1

1.25

tω/2π

GA 12/(4πχa

3H

2 0/3)

M & ,@!%oG? ,78V,!$? p!Q : * &8V,#([ I! 8 # P b] a(L9! !,6) %,78V,!$? J3 $#( 9 3% #(% ! !>!",@ A -,J82U (;,(! 88 # ($<X$#-] a L>!J!,) %P,82,$BO M! ? E) %3U Q8 M!5 U:\ 82,# " &('

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0−1

−0.75

−0.5

−0.25

0

0.25

0.5

0.75

1

tω/2π

GS ij/(4πχa

3H

2 0/3)

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0

−1

−0.75

−0.5

−0.25

0

0.25

0.5

0.75

1

tω/2π

GA ij/(4πχa

3H

2 0/3)

GA23

GA13

GA12

M & ,@!%7G? ,78V,!$? H!T U: &8V,#(5 N 8* # J] a>L9!p,) %(,)8V,!$? -!c3 $#( 3 #(% ! !;!c,@ / ,!>8V: (,<! 8*8*# ($7X:$#-ML9!# 9 &,@69! Q 3(* , #,82,$B 5 & ! ,# W# !"V$ & & ! $j#O ! ' ' j!!3$ # O! IL9I# O! 5 &j!7 \ %!h* , #,78V,!$? J !I ,# C# j% :%@# J &(' Z !$ # C3: ) ,@# 9 & *(!J!3$ # O! (! q?@ %" ' ] aL9!J!,6) %,78V,!$?O ! ? E) %3: Q8 M!5 U\ &8V,#( " &(' " & "'

Page 148: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D,G 3$ c ?3 & 3 $#( %3: Q8 ] 3% #(%Ua

! k D ] $ ! $ a D

$ -2- ! ] G? a S 9 B P%3: 58 "! k D

] $ ! $ a $ ] G? Ga!\# 6 6:! Y X:$#V V O! (,- , &!$S?

) ] & & a k D1 4 ] & & a

"! ] & & a ] & & a ] & & a -

- 6 ] G? ,a ! k ] & & a ?] & & aU !9!58*# RB!A U,@! ,) %,78V )!$? P%3: p8 AR!T,!78V: ( ! j O ,@!%G? ] a C!7!,6) %,78V,!$?p -! B P%3: ;8 e 8% $?3$< O M & ,@!%5G? ] aU M & ,@!%5G? ] a > !,78V,!$? ! M & ,@!%QG? ] a > !>,78V,!$? #"! ! 8* #6 F%!5, ? ! #@! #"' O 3 !> +)' !%8V$!$?H3:q@!,P! Pe8@*$7?! 8*8*# ($X$#Z 5 !/" @6 8 O%#(N $p%! @ $"3c,*@+ Op@# (, 6! : &X*% #,P % ) O$VL9 8 %# $ %![3 3$o< ,!% O O I : ( : & , 8*% ,!$+3$ !3$ *#( Y & #(W% JL9 ,!% P U Q %3% 3$[@ 6 8V, ? &8V,#( 88 :- p! OB3V "?!%6 H ?3 + (, K %e8R! !$J [ M ( % I@# (, 6 ,#( O ,@+3$Z L9!i% @*#& 6 P 6 8V$ %J, 3$? &<8%%! (,@ I@# (, ,78 $ ! *#& &<!A8V: $B & , [L>!;2V$+ ? @!% (!$h3C2( %#O@!$[ OU!3 :h!V#( ;8V: O$B # % @#& pd Op@# (, e S )'! &X*% # 5 %8V% U:$- I %(, %$ %! P " %(!: !$ ? Vo8*# X X$# V%$?p,6X ,@ (, ! !!! #@ * /<@ $ [ p@*# (, ! % @*#& 6 #($ 8V$ O6 ,#( ( k2F&% FF ^^ 78 #

Page 149: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D +@ (, * ( k F&% F6D%F 8 ( # +@ (,- L9! W! #@! #O# [ J #($ 8V$ K )n e * :-? U 78*# % (bkTF&% FF6 U +3: ( k F&% F6D; 5*@## 82U ( kbF&% F ^ # U @:: O 8V: EDRG !Q! +) ??) !* $ ,6X* ,@! (, ! O 6 82$j ! : T UA : # !S! #@!i U ,# 3$ O$ L9i%$@+ (, 8V$ 3; U! 8* ( # '8V P #!/ & ,<3< (, O(! P 6 (%$+ ,-! O ! 8 W %, :! ! 8* # P Q # S8:%$ \ ,@I :!$ # %8 (, !Q B3 + (, !$ # ' %:* 6 I3p! ) X$#< @!: Y 8%@$ O$ , $%@6 &! O R!W,#&P ! O6 \ ($+ (,-*@6!% PJR! 3$ * #(I! U%,B " J #( $ B3 + (, V# %8 (, 8%R! !$ !J UC* &8V,#( % 3$ & L-@ !h,#(i c ,!% B3 + (, I@# (, p % ,*@+3$ %V! ?3) O< ,!% [ : < %j *%#@!$- ,78 : 6 o! J% @#& 3o U%,~!O @## p@*# (, & U,@ ],*#&p>! ) X$#O%%8*@# (,P $ O ; , &X* ?#&D2V$+3$W?!\ ,% A U #&!,@6 ,!Q6 ?3 + (, !R!$#-%! %A K OB3% <!$ (e : & ,?% !p% @#& O 3H !e OB3 + , V% $p!p3: #O#&J!: &!$ : &X*% #,P % ) O% $p*#(Q!J ?3 + (, V% $ p ^ !O 78*# !5 ,!% >X$# !p!%p :F, p PN!O ) X$#OP?!6 O OB3 + , !$ ' U c F,!T8V$+ 2% $j U:+)n W3:q@!+)n U% $#( t)'!: &!$ O $#,PF% @#& 8% $?3$<% !% U%% , *#>3 @> % 3J %8 (, %,@* Q#($6 !P ) X$#jB!%6 > ## # P8%R! ! ? 88%1 (,h H!pB!%6 J ?3 + (, V% $WP %? ) (, ##&! D @#& $,@! @! # 9 ! X*% # V$ ! ! A: , @% J%$# 3 3(! (,[ O%^: ! @!% GG V,78 : & Op@# (, N!$# +3: ^! \ @ 8V$ (, X*% # ) e ## ! * &* &a%: ($? (,i9! Q: !\ , 9 %+) @#] Z!QB!%6 ; OB3 + , NL9! c# P & (, % 3: +!582 : &* #O &'T @6 6 %Q $! ##&8*$!,$ @U !Q +3: #@*@#($* F !;!5 U: ,; 8V:! ED%F &X*% #

Page 150: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

" ! $&%(' )

0 0$ !6$),

2 4# 65 L9! 8% $e Q @!% ##BVI O% !;B!%6 ! A82U ($$p? ?8 O%#( b,@8*#( !o8 %# 3 # (, # % (, #I (, ^ F6 ^ 2L>! : 6 o!VB!%6 % 8V, 2$+7V$ ! P P 6 P % )n C ( SV P 6 8V$ %$+ (,- !W 78 #( +3: Q8% )8V$# !$ $#&! % 6 C!$ ( ) 8V$ Y* $## 7 @#( p #O# !8 % :%@# O 6 8 !% 8*8% : @% GG G 5 % @*#&%! # -@ (, j% (:%@# c8* 82 ,@*W!Q3( % ,!3, #O#& &W!@6Vp %3 pd? @!:U 82U 3 ( %W U,@ 3<V 3 +3$C3 @!% \!,@6 , ?% P J ?3 ) (, KDD ## # #&35!$ (>V c8 3:j#( 6 P3 O 6 O % :%@# 8 V!T : (,i $#( t)n $ 8V:4! O ED%F L9! P 6 8V$i H! ,#& Y* $## 3$W +3: U,@-:, ! -3V % & !8%1 O &'i H @% ,@ i$#$$B I@# , N! p +3U _?G @ 9" % " O O6 82$V ; % @# O 6 6 ,#J3! @! !/ !! @66L #( !% # #& 7 P 6 % EDD 3$$ _ -3 %#O@!I!2V$+ W! :? @!% " ! O 6 8V$ U,@C3 *% &(\,6X*!$$B%

!/ : 8*3$ c8% $?]% @*#& U%, 8 : %#(9 $ I@# , ! : &X*% # )D

Page 151: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D F> : & , @% L 8@%J!\?% P O2V$+ ! @% " ?3%@ ! !$# $78*#( O , @*+ (, &hS 3$ @ $? # ,@# : & 9!Sd3 $q@ (, 3 %! o#@: (,X : 2V$+ I@# 3!;V$ ! ( V8*# * 8* ( # +@ 3$ O M O 6 c8 ##$#?3\! @!% U%@ ,@!> %@ ,;,S!": 8V$-65%%8*@# (,# %, ! @!% 6 &* &3$I\! 8*# P$ I! %,##O 6 c (,6 J 8* ( # PH! J @!% 4# 5 65

]%! (,@ #&B3 :82 39!QB!%6 e2V$+ U & , @% 5 ?3 [!Qd3 $q@ (, ; &(! 88:%8: 3QX** &3A :pp@# &8V,#(F8 (,

' k & = ] & a$

& ] & 6a ] DRa

k F ] ,a U P$ $p*#(a 8 O%#( V$ ,#&!$I?@: ##& D &" ! ) # &8\,* & (,

] F$ $ ak l ] ,a ;! @% SkTF t3>%3: O6 p Y X$#O-?" (, !J8 %#c8* " VP!%3:P !$ %,@6 , @ @ # !,#@ ! V ?3% (,- O#( p 88% U X ! ! ) # 8\, & ,5 +#, & ?3%@ $ U X!?$p,78*@6 , #, : O-Md@*: ,78*@6 (, #O#!$ & (, #V,@ O6 @!% A 82U (* V,@ , (, I I! 2! 22$+ &!9 !M * :p3 I@# 3 5 #O#8$ $p*#( 8 : %#( "! %J!%!$#8 #&3U &! 88:% :- 8*#(, & o!o# ! : ' I! d3 $q@ (, \ : &3 ! @ %8 3 Y c

k % ] `_?a!/ ] `_?aU ! Y 8:%*@$"\! U:; 3: *@6 (, ] DRaM O @?V,@!$ Y @ -L9 %3: !$W , ! #& ,#@6 (, 3c!;d3 $q?@ (, DD ML-5!%3U !! Y X$# ?3%*@$C3[%8% $?"!;22$+ !DU & , @% D$78*#R %! *W ,#@ (, : &!$S # ED- U5!T @ $B # 6 ,@*# : & (

Page 152: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

DD3!d3 $q@ (, 9L9 %! 8%! >P ,#@6 (, 3P!7d3 $q?@ , > &!,@6! :p 3: *@6 (,

' k l ] ^ a k F ] a

8*8%46 3$# X !",* & (, ] F$ $ a ] F$ $ a ] Ga

Q!6: & , @!% ] k FBaU"L>!I O 3$ U 82, OBF : ] d3 #(%UaF ,* &@! S* (%$+ (, #( 3$ k ] $F$FBa9 EDD%F6D k

1 !

] .> - a -

] ,a O#(c\ 3$ 9%#(%O M , @! ED k

1 ! - -

- - - - - ] ,a

! k & & & k & k % !6 : 8 : %#(< O ! I@# (,- %#@\VC! Y X$# (,j3V! Y X$#[ 8V3$? #H &8V,#( , &!$ ED L9! 3%$6 c!S (8V3$? # &8V,#(< ' *j3 # (!%% 82,* 6 3U % @#& O6 U%, !I,!8V,#(I* 3: & @6 (,-9L9 @* ! Y >, @63 eL>!" (,i M!J8 %#(J8* " !$S%3: !$ U%, k

/ ] a ] & 6a 3 & ] D%FBa k D

/ ] a ] & 6a 3 &% ] DDRa

!J!" ?3% (, 82 :$ R!5!" #( t) 8 %%@68* $(?! Y @* ] FBaUL9 Y X$# ! !% O6 ,@# : ( 8%R! !7 $h%$+ (, O !

Page 153: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D ) X$# ^ *_ ^

& 1 B & k D D

4 6 $& ] D,a ' 1 B ' k D D D

4 6 $& ] D,a 1 k D ^D 4 6 ] D+_?a

1 ' ' k D 4 6 ] D ^ a

U c8 : %#(c (, !$< O8V 3$ B3 [! M & ,@!% D J,78 %cF% @#& U%, ! ? p@*# (, O6 ,#( 8*!% & ! ! #@! , !$T? $q?@ , ] D,a ] D ^ aU ! h :C ! $ %%$+ (, c %W$R!%$C VW ) X$# !%"!% ($# % , *#( O 3 !"8 O%#(J* # 'd O %$# ,P U: * 3: & @6 (, - I!,#@* ! Y !;! H,? +8 O%#(+) 8 %# *8 %#(+) @!% 9B!%6 a22$+ #O#?!e2e% ,#&!$- @6:: (, U: 2( ?3%@$ I S3: #J U:V o! #O%@# (,o3I%%8% $?!@! ,#&!$ Y @3J%#( ,? + F%3U >!;#( #?#O@6: , U: %$q?@* (% X N,78*@6 J!> (,D !98 O%#( 7>@ @ # ! 8 : %#(9 N @ "P% ($?#&%#( 3C! #O#=H! & (, ##@: (,Q U($ 3jV !$ 3C!V,!8V,#(3: 3%%$+c & (,-eL> :" 3$ U%, #@6:: (,!$#2 7 8 !%Q!(%#( 3 7 @! eL>!A: & , # U:I@# (,# #%@# , @$( ;!% %"!3: #M3:q@! ,C!78 %#( T &C! &X % # $!$# # O 3:q@! , !J8 %# 9 (! pp@ 9V %,@*B3$[ c (!\#@: (,(%$+ (,-

, ! P ,#( 8*%W * @ S# 3$ % k ] $F$FBa : & , OV8*# @!% ok F <%X*!!P!U # $j 8[V% $[! @!% !8 O%#( ! ## k ] 6a * #@: (,W! #%@*# (,C ($# !P,82,$B !P* # &z

Page 154: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D

1 2 3 4 51

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

h/a

F1/(6πηaU

1)

1 2 3 4 5

1.1

1.2

1.3

1.4

1.5

1.6

1.7

1.8

1.9

2

h/a

F2/(

6πηaU

2)

1 2 3 4 51

1.05

1.1

1.15

1.2

1.25

1.3

1.35

1.4

h/a

τ 3/(

8πηa3

Ω3)

1 2 3 4 5

0

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

0.14

h/a

8πηa

3/F

2

- M & ,@!% D L>! (,W c O6 ,#( 8*!% ! : & , O"8*# e , &!$I"! A O 3$] % (:%@*# a \! $7%%$+ , ] !$\#O ! aU ] a 8V$ %@*# - (, ] D,a] a ##($#M , ] D,a ] Ra )O (, #H (, ] D+_?a ] a)O ,)'L # (, ,@8*# 6 ] D ^ a

Page 155: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D _)/ ^ "<% ($B / & ' & & F ^ _,F ) `__D _6 G F ) ^ F6DD _6 G ^

' ' F ^ F _ ):D ^ ^ FF ):D ^^ DD D ,G* _ ' )'F F ,G* ):D F ^ F D ^! )'FDRGG_ ' )'F ^! D ^!! ):D ^ F ^ D )'F F6D F ^ F ):D `_ D G* __ ):D FD D G_ & & F ,G ) `_ D ^ D ) ^ `_ F _6 _ F ' ' F _ ):D _ ,GG ):D _?G ^ D ' )'F ^ _ _ D ^ F ^ ):D ^! F _ )'F ,GD ' )'F ^ FF D GG D ):D ^ D F ,G ^ )'F D F G*D ) F F ^! ):D !^ D `_DL *#( D N #O@! : UM! 82,#!,P # % 3: / & ' ' !%3:P !$ U%,4X 3 I@# (,(

3: (( ("# & D & & k D

D^ #( D

D #( ] DRa ] a ] D a ' ' k D ^ #( _

,G ^ #( ] DRa0 ] a ] DRGa ' k D ^ #(

,G ^ #( ] DRa ] a ] D,a ' k _ ' ] D ,a & & k D

#( ] DRa0 ] a ] FBa k ^ #( !D ^ #( ] DRa0 ] a ] DRa

! & k 1 & & & ] ,a ' k 1 ' ' ' 1 ' ' ] ,a k 1 ' ' 1 ' ' ' ] _?a & k 1 & & & ] ^ a ' k 1 ' ' 1 ' ] a k 1 ' ' 1 % ] ,Ga

O # %T 9!$ & ,?\!%8V$!$?"^ "<% ($B o2D ,@* S)' 88% U-

Page 156: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D ^)/ * ? "P% ($?

= ] a ] DRa & & F )'F ^ )'F`_ ' ' F G )'F ^ F )'F ^ _D ' F G F ,GGG

)'F ,GG

' F G F FF )'F F F F G )'F GG ^ )'F ,GGG & & F )'F ^ ,G_ )'F`_ _ ' ' F G )'F ^ D,G )'F ^^ G ' F G F ,G*

)'F ,G*

' F G FD ^ )'F F6DD F G )'F GG*,G

)'F ^ _L *#( N #@ !5!: # $%@6/)nW O Ue!5#@6U (, %U ( P! ] a ] DRa %%$+ , 3"#@6: O (,#% *\ 3: $i, ! "%@6/)n ! #@!

L9! @#& U%, 6 ,#(8 O%#( I@# (, 8V% U:$ p V%$B"$ & ,B p %X3$ & U,@!A:!82,#!,P # / & ' ' @ 6 !N8V,#&XV @*+ (,J L 5L9! \^ "<% ($B c %"8R! !$S VL *#( D T &V! S)' I! #@ M!% 3: (C ] DRa ] aJ3: ] D a ] DRa <!%3:P !$ :* 6 @ U $B3 >i% *( 3: : &! &! 7!V!: # $ * U%, ! #O# = !IP#@6U (,j%%$+ (, X: J!$ 3 2 88 # ($- &C ! #@! !%3:P !$-!\#O@6: ,<%$+ (, (2J8V% U:$V O(!5 ,#O#( O6 7 ! D 3N!%3: * 6 9! !$#(% & ( 6 ,@# !$#% & 5 j :8 %#( !@ 6 S)' 88:% :-H!%3U !P ! %8 %# #( <!: # $#O@6: ,%@/)n * = U%,4! ##= p! P8 O%#( % @ "<% ($B#j%#( P3 @!% PI@ p!%3: !@* WB!%6 A U: 7 S3Uq?@! #,W8 O%#( !o*@!"3!\8 $ M!5>8 O%#( 7

k

] ,a !% ! S)' A% c 3U P!%3: O!$ U%, !>X*3$<8V,#&! )P #

T &I! ! #O@! 7 ! (%$\8 %#( !$#(% &' : 6 ,@# !$#(% &'

Page 157: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D : 98 %#(! % U,@ U%, :

: k : 7 % ] ,a

!% :ek $& : * : !"#@: (,#% " 3U ] D a ] ,GaU_6 JJ!"! %$!$#(% ( ; % ! ZJ %: (e U: : (3:q@! : !c (, # 68*@ 3P! #%@*# (, ,@* : : k

: :

7 % ] FBa

^ M ##& ! !$#(% ( M 6 ,@# !$#(% & ( M % ,78*@63$@ 6 > V)' O 8*8% : &<!J 68*@6a U 3:q?@,(8 %#( ! ! , &!$ : : % 8V$+ &!$#

!/ !#@6: O (, %%$+ ,- ( %,@?6 ! \X:$#[U 6 & & P 3: ! 6 ,@# R # 6K C!<%%$+ (, :!$ D$78 #(R$o V%$BJ! #@! = Uc!I (, 8V8V$ %@*# 8 ##($#-3! @!% >L9* ; 8V &*#( O"!I (, 9 %\ *!%8V$!$?%

!/ M & ,@% C,78 %J% @# U%, S)' 88:% : & &!,@6!#@6U (, %$+ (,j3 +A% @*#& _ ^ D JL9 * & (,h e!I#O@6: , %#( :#8%! O! V%3 (,@ H!\8 %#(\* # &z c! @!% 9L9!p# 5 V%$V% $(! + % @#& e *<5%$+3$ I@# (, ,J <!F!:# 8i%% , ,-NL9 8V$% ##T%! !$?e M & ,@% ] aUeL>!>%% 82,*!$9V% $<!> 7 %% , (,< V 78R!$ %#@* 6 * & (, #H 3$ U\! 3% #%%L9* Q ##M8:%R! !!; ) X:$# ,#O@6 (, & V%3T O 3 O !#R!)'# 8 % , (,-H!$ : 3W882U#& U &(\ !;#@: (, ,#O@6 (,- .

8V 3! !$#?! : 2$\ "!8%%! (,@ K $+ (,I3 %,@*Bj UK! B!%6 2V$+ Z! @!% J ?3p! &X % # !$#! : &V$< ; 83 ^ J@ 5 3 ,*@+ I@# (, ! J! : & , @% D O!7!V$ ! (5

Page 158: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D,G

1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 20

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

h/a

F1/(6πηaU

1)

1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

h/a

F2/(6πηaU

2)

1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 21

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2

2.2

2.4

2.6

2.8

3

h/a

τ 3/(

8πηa3

Ω3)

1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2

0

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

0.14

0.16

0.18

h/a

aΩ3/U

2

- M & ,@!%( L>!P (,Q O6 ,#( 8*%! : & , OC8*# !(L9! ,# % (U%@# \ * 3P! S)' 8*8% :ZH!<3U 6 ,@# I <!# + ,#@6 (, 3C!d3 $q?@ (, 8:%R! !$C _ ^ ED ,# O # ! J S)' &!j#@6: O (, %%$+ (,Z ] a 8V$ %@# (, ] a ##($#> (, ] Ra;)O , # (, ] a )O ,)'L # (, ,@68*#

Page 159: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D O!: &!$o?[2 !8*# 8 ( # +@ (, :$ 3 P !!<8 # O : P 6 8V$-V%%8 @# (,W@!I3(! ## j! `%,##O 6 (, M! 8* # $ s Nx | ! w "x x ex"

X !PU 6 82$Q ;! X*% # \: &!$ !8*# \X$# ^ D O6 V8 ##$#H3W @% WL9! I # 3$ !$ & ,? U%, @% !j3 ! W3 , B(X$# (h / k D(% F L>!W#($ O # k % * W ,78U $ k~D ^ V eL9!5 * @ M!"3%!$ 8*%< k , &! 6 ,%3: # ( k F&%D !7!V , !%$o! ,!%3?$# Op@p2c X!$ ! k D%F S #$ O 6 82$( !%3:P !$ U , &!$ R! 6 O HL9 % @#& O6 O6 82$ H % ! M & ,@! ] aU !J U9!J!$ & ,? , O!%$(!% >#( $q?@!$*% ( ! 8*8*# ($X$# ] #( aM! O 6 8V$ ##6 > *O , ! ##$% NL9O88V &3%%@! 9 >* & ,! U%$q?@$% ( \] , aUL9 *% 8V$ H#( U%$q@!$% ( @!:8: O6 a,!e8V$+ !5! 88 :! ! #O#=?5 *% Q P! O## @ 5! 8V$P37!$ L9 N #O#6V>!Q #(,6 !58%8 @# &! U:A%$ O , B%eL> P!%%@! & *\! ! (,W $! 3$ W!I # ,@8*#($W3<!7! D,j!PAS$+%JL- %,@?; UP : ! Q, !SX*# $BP #= j* ( t ! %X* & (, 3 %#O@!5!2V$+ !$ & ,?9!%8V$!$?;! P? "P% ($?93 , !

;k " 8 8;: % ] DRaL9!P! #@ "+M!< 8Vp@* &"#($6 [8 ##$#H3WPX*# $B I <!%3:P !$ U%, Op@# (, M & ,@% `_6

!/IX ,@!% ] aK! O 6 8V$I 8 #(3$ H @+ ,W M!; ,## 8 3 j 6 ,#P%@!!( #( %$q@!$+ #O & #( !,)',3, !%8V$!$, !S$ & ,B !$r UP ,!7! #O@! L9!S,## 8 c!W h!S#( U%$q?@$+# N 3 !c *% c OP! #(,6 p!5#$6 Z> # 8V, &*# U>!\ O% \ O P 6 8V$-L> ; @6 c!"88*@# ! U:\ O% > &!\ O% " V #(,6 JX*# $?%

Page 160: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D

1 2 3 4 5 60

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8x 10

−3

Sp

U

h/R = 1.17

h/R = 2.0

h/R =∞

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 40

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8x 10

−3

Sp∗

U

h/R =∞h/R = 2.0

h/R = 1.17

M & ,@!% Q] a9d #($ 8V$(! @ @ U %! #Z!$ ,B ] a;d #($ 8V$V! @ !% #($ 8V:4@p2

Page 161: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D+_,F

0 10 20 30 40 502

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

h/a

ζ/η

ζ‖

ζ⊥

M & ,@!% `_ 6 S!\! P825@ &;#($ h, X*# $?>, 6 k~D ^ V L9! ,# S*#@!\#O ! S! q?@ %p O 3 !I? "P% ($? Q (,W8 ##$#-3! 6 !>X*# $? 7! ,# *# 7# !; * 3 !c! J8V8V$ %@*# K3\! 6 L9!" !$V# ; %"!J! #@! M! "^ "P% $B S@?V,@!$ Y @ ZL9@ $,#&<!J! ,(!J # , O!%$-*@6 !J! ,(!J3%!%$ 8*!% #O# # ": 6 ! 88:% :! ! @! !eO 6 !$ & ,? , O!%$!%5! ! r,T! 3%!%$ 8*!% ,@#-5 ( p ,# 3$-Q!,@6*#( * 22$+W ! %,@?3$Q U\ ! # (, %@!:!K!78:%8*@# &!T U: 88V 3 P C882: (,C3 !<: 6 ! @, !3%%$ 8 !% P#( %$q@!$+# P &%

s z| ' ! x !/ (,3I: 6 , O6 \! O 6 8V$-B!%6 ; OB3 + , e ## @ >!c8*# ) 3"R! $ 6 , ! @!% HL9 %%8*@*# (,I !N @ $ : ($? (, ! 5 %$+ (, O;!> ,% ;X$#%8 !>2 O6 O6 c8 ##($#3J! @! ML9!%%8*@# (,I K @#&- *! &X % # KV$ 6 8*@##( & M !X*# $BN O#*#( 7! P 6 78 @## H #(, \!c8 &!c 6NL9 $! 3 "Y 9 * (%$+3$(3 :V #,6 P 6 ; * 7S$+3$ #,6 78V8V$ %@# ($+ (, 3 : *,78% &* # 'HL9!5,@6 U Y I@ t!\ ) # &8S,* & (, 9! (, @!% NL9 8%@ (, # Y ;8*@ ! P $ U%, ! @!% * I U%, ! @!% I O% -P%8*@# ,V!$#(% &' ##

Page 162: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D+_D

2 4 6 8 10 12 14 160

0.01

0.02

0.03

0.04

0.05

0.06

0.07

0.08

h/R

Urep/U∞

Sp = 3.0

Sp = 4.5

M & ,@!% ^ )O%8*@*# (, 8V$D -!c8 # a (k% F (k _ % ^p @*+ (, M!"!$ & ,? @ %, ! @!% !$ S# ' * :V% 8V, !"3 Y X:$#( $! 3$W?!\ O 3% #(% ^ s s ! px | ,x |

!/< Q 3: O 8% $?3$ VR! ] D a ] DRaU R ; & ,P37: 6 ) 6 W , @!i Q!W [? "P% ($? ;! ##9,@68 #($ ! 8*!% % (, # 3 # (, #; , ] ' &k FBaUTL9! 8* # 6 O O:% 3 ( V,@67! ) I %$+ (, ##=?# 5! 8*!%6 &* %,## p (,ZNL9 % @#& 3 # (, # (,[ \ 82:82$* %@# 53 & \ P 6 V (%$+ , @ 6 V 8* ( # 6 PJ33 !$#* J 3 ,BN# O! 6 ,#( 3\ & H c ($+ (, @BV,@*!$ Y @ - ,@!% ! ! #($ O6 8V$ 5 @+ (,@ e!$ & ,?F UQ!I ( c !% jk % F k _ % ^ PL9 #($ 8V$ : # $jW P 6 P! #@! ! %! $Bp \!#% (, A 3 # ,o,@68 # 6 S q?@* &3 3%, j pD%,##O 6 8V$V$, ,78 *#93\! P 6 8V$! ,B +% * & (, ##!O%,##O 6 Q!$#(% &' ,@* 3V!$ W# ' W!P QX$#ZQL> $ J 37 I@U #( J j! !$ !W!$#(% &'r A% 8*% ^ bL-o@*! h* V$ ! (<, !<! &@ (, !% : & , 8 !%A j @ : &!$(<!W : k 8 +8 &H

Page 163: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D+_

0 5 10 150

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

h/R

U⊥/U∞

Sp = 4.5

Sp = 3.0

∼ h−2

M & ,@!% )O,##O 6 8V$ (k% F * k _ % ^P9 @+ (, M!"!$ ,B @ ,4! @! @ O6 ! 8*!W @ "P% $B#&r $ %, ! @!% k F D c! B !,@ !$#(% &' M! 8*%" , &!$ ? ^

" k D 1 D5 D 8 0 4 6 ] ,a k D 1 D5

+8 0 4 6 ] ,a

!J!"!$ & ,?O U%,4! @% W , !$V? ] aNk =/ ] a 3 #% ] _?a

k ] FBaUNL-5 8 (,P UH!; ! $P!$#(% &z\8 #O#($#3J! @!% * " , k 81 ' $/ " ] a 3 $ ] ^ a

Page 164: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D+_ "X ;!$ 3P!%3:P !Q!\!$ ,B 9 @+ (, M )O : 6 ] ,a

k D 1 D5

DD =/ ] a 3 $ ] a : @ =/ ] a 3 D #O#U X** W ? # q@ ,

D 1 D5

D =/ ] a 3

% ] ,Ga) p ,#&! 6 V +#& ?! P @*78 , =/ ] a 3 D & , ? #- :,V : ,B9 * J : &! "

D 1 D5 ] ,a

O:( , &! $ 9 @*+ ,K O ] aNk D 1 D5

] D5 a % ] ,a

OB !@ # 6 # #"" k D 1 D5

% ] `_,FBa

: & ! #% &z8 ## # p @! "%$ k D 1 D D

DD " ] D5 a ] `_DRa - : @ =/ ] a 3 D : & D ] D " ] D P a Ca 8 ! : $ O %$ D 1 D D '& D "

] D5 a)( % ] `_ ,a

!/B O6 p c ! V! #% &zP,78, ?8 ## # I Q @! * X*P ,#&< : ,B : *@6 $ + %$ , k

1 '-, $/ D 1 D "[ ' 3 $ ] `_ ,a

Page 165: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D+__ O: ! #@ W + $ , k D 1

" ' % ] `__?a

!/( 8 $ ,- *\! ; O J ! 8 ## # ! # % &zV ( ) X #V# ' (L9 " , q?@ ; 8 %# R! 6 8 ;X & O@ p 8*#&! 6pL9 , : 6 < 7 Q $ V @! 8 , OBQ :q@ 8 $ B ,S @ "P% ?; 8 !! O ! + # 6

!/<* : 8 R *" # ( ! K J &X*% # $ : & , @ NL 6 * 8 W \ ?!6 5 #%c 8*# @! ? V $: S! + W ,S@ O6 #@6 U , U $ L9* + &! \ 88 :( ? !@% 6 p + 7 ,# > ## ,# % 8 : %# $ I Q , M ,@* ",* & , K B @* - I8 !: I@# , 9 8 # * 8 # +@ $ I < @ ! o8 $ ? $ @*#& , : O6 C : h S 8 - W # ! #O@ S # U t$ , j @! < 8*# !,##O 6 , * & 8* # $ # j : 6 O6 8 C # q@ +W# & : 6 $ ( 8 8*@# ! : @ : 6 V ,V O#=NL9 8 @# , V ) X #S # ' S # \Y X #H \ P : J8, ?> 8 ,# !/S H !,## O6 7 ,- * ,@V 5 ,@68*# P q@ & p !,6 V S Q 5 ,78 *# < 7 8 C #O ' * :j # * c 8 + - L9 " # 9 @688 ( < # S P ,78, ? J O ; R! 6 #,6 V% :%@# 8 -N5# 8*@# ,-? !,## 8 ; # V \ 7 O6 ,@# : ' I ? tJ O\ ! , I?J &X % # K , & ,? 8 +\ S # ! B\ O $ ; @ # * 78*# K 8 @# , !, S ##; h 6 & & ? 8*@#O# ) '8 ! P 6 # $: # \ j8 !8 #N # SL9 < , * 6jL9 P 8* # O6 P #O# !,## & @ 6 S " C ! W & ,?p# P 6 ,# j p + ,C W@*B,@ Y @ O- + U @V- * ! $ ## % :%@# c8 C8 ## # P \ @! GG @ ,@B ! P ##Z $ Y* #O# 9*@*# $ 8* &

Page 166: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

D+_ ^ & ,? 8 +7 S ' h B ,@ ! #% ' 8 :8 * %@# p O 6 + ,-

Page 167: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

"! # ! %$

& ' (

) +* ,.- 0/2143576 0891 -

:<; >=@?BA DCFE@GIHKJLHKE@E GI?BHM= ONQP>?R= ; = ; SA =@? UT = ; SV ! VXW.JYE@?RZ[A OG ; H T ?BE@A H\A?YG !9] H T ?BE@A^ `_ % _ba Mcd?YEe=FfgVX?BGIHKJBJBfhAhW.G ; E ; = = ; H T Hi=@?BA DCFE@GIHKJ ] ?RZ Tj f7= ; >EkP>?YAA? Tb] EkV ON2l (nm+oqp a sr : V ! Zt?BNuHvE@?YA\W.JYHM=@? UT GIHMVXH j J ; H T N.JB? Tb] AH T f? T = HKGD=@? Tb] @] H T ?BE@AwE Z J UTb]=@?BA OEOl UT GIH T Wb=@?BJY? xHyA N OJs= ; HM=nN OE T =zG UT E9?BN = ; A =@? UT = ; E@P>?BAA EIOV ! V|W.JBE@?RZOJOA T =@E j Wb=V ! Zt?BNOE~= ; x=@?YA HZ H ] = ; JOHKN.? Tb] N z P ] T HM= ON j f OHKG ; EkP>?YAA r HKAV|JKlb= ; V ; H T = A H ] OJBJBW.AN.W.A j.j OJBJA NOJdqKHKGIG AVXJY?BE ; OE[= ; ?BE j fG UT E@?YN ? Tb]=FP V ? T =[E W GOESHKGD=@? Tb] ? T VXV E9?R= 4N.? OGD=@? UT E[E IVXH HM= ON j fHN.?YEk=@H T G OgW.HKJ2= = ; \J Tb] = ; = ; EkP>?BAwA P ; ?BJu= ; E OJ CFJ G A =@? Tb] ! NA NOJ aKaI_ iWb=@?YJB? OEEk= OE@E OEV ! N.W.GON`HM=E IZ HKJV ? T =@E>HKJ UTb] HE!OGD=@? UT H T OJ UTb] HM= ON Kjb OGD=Ir :<; 4E@gW.? A A NOJ HwEkPS?BAA? T.]A?BG @] H T ?BE@AlUHKE? T = N.WXGON j fhE ; ?RMHOPH SUql?BEdHiE OJ CFJ G A =@? Tb] EkV ; [= ; HM=E@P>?BAE? T OEkV UT E d= H<=@H Tb] T =@?BHKJZOJ GI?R=Ff ] T HM= ONhHM=z?R=@EzE@W ! HKGKrntWXG ; H T A NOJs?YEHMV.V ! V ?BHM= @] H T ?YE@AEe= ; HM= OAVXJ f7GI?YJB?BHy= 4] T HM= LE@W HKG[PHOZOEHKExHiA OH T E V ! V|W.JBE@? UT ^ K q MS¡~¢ Ml I=@Gc+r T = ; ?BEG ; HMV.= lLP*N OA UT Ek= HM= £= ; j ! HKN ?BAVXHKGD= = ; AI= ; NXENIZOJ VONH T NOAVXJ fON¤? T = ; ?BE\= ; OE@?BE j fvHKN.HMV.=@? Tb] = ; E@gW.? A A NOJx= = ; ~¥[¦ A\W.JYHM=@? UT r¨§ = Wb=@JB? T ? Tb] = ; wE@gW.? A A N OJeP>?R= ; ? T = ; ~¥[¦ HKA IP |l~P*QG UT N.W.GD=4E@?YA\W.JYHM=@? UT E =FP

? T = HKGD=@? Tb] E@gW.? A E>H T NuH ; A K] T W.EE9W.EkV T E@? UT x©«ª­¬ _K_K_ E9W.? A EIr : HKAw? T a s®

Page 168: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a

= ; HKGIGIW HKGDf = ; T IP AhW.JBHM=@? UT leP*G AV|H = ; = H OGD= ?OE = ; =FP ? T = HKGD=@? Tb]E@gW.? A EiH T Nv= ; E OJ CFN.?2W.E@? UT G wGI? T = = ; E@gW.? A E@WXEkV T E@? UT N I= A? T ON j f= ; ~¥[¦ CFE@gW.? A A N OJ2P>?R= ; = ; E! ] ?RZ Tj fQ= ; ? ] ? T HKJE9?BA\WXJBHM=@? UT E4UglXKMr) 8 - 589/ / H EkV ; ?BGIHKJ j NbfKl[=@H Tb] T =@?BHKJE@W ! HKGuP HZOEGIH T&j V|H T NON? T = AwE H T ? TXT ?R= E ? OE = ; EkV ; ?BGIHKJ ; H A UT ?BGIE = ; g= OE OgW.HM=@? UT EOlxE §>VXV T N.? §#? T U r :<; E@gW.? A A N OJ I=@HK? T E UT JRfh= ; Ek=d= P = AE = ; ?BEE ?OEIr :<; Ek=e= A ?BEHiN ] T HM= gW.HKN HMV J4P ; E \E@= Tb] = ; ?BE OJBHM= ON = = ; hZOJ GI?R=Ff = ; hE@gW.? A H T Nu?BE>N I= A? T ON j f= ; GDC wG UT N.?B=@? UT r :<; E OG UT N= AV ! Zg?YNOEHEk= OE@E9JI=4H T N£G ! OE@V UT N.EL= N ?RZt? Tb]A OG ; H T ?BE@A = ; 7EkP>?BAA r :>; OE V OE9E@? UT ESGIH T j IP ?R=k= T ? T = A E@? Tb] WXJBH ?R=@?OE = ; ht= OE OgW.HM=@? UT E

ª m! & ^ & c! #" ® ^ c $ ( m ^ c $ ^&% r a c

ª _(' ^&% r ¬ cP ;

m) ª *,+ " ^ * - - ! c/. ^&% r * cm)0 ª

* + "/1 .2 - 0 ' ^&% rcH T N7P ; - 0 ?BEn= ; <EkP>?BAAw? Tb] NX? OGD=@? UT H T N " ?BEz= ; HKN.?YW.E HE@gW.? A r :<; [VXH HKA I= . 2?BE OJBHM= ON = = ; hEkP>?BAAw? Tb] EkV ON43 m = ; ! W ] ; 3 m[ª ¬ . 2 o * r :<; 4VXH HKA I= . ?BE>A OHKE9W ONP>?R= ; OE@V OGD=[= .2[= ; W ] ; = ; VXH HKAI= 65¨ª . o .72Ore 85:9 _ lX= ; 4E@gW.? A j ; HOZOESHKE<H

VXW.JYJ gP ; OHKES? !5:; _ l.= ; iE@gW.? A V HM= OE>HKE>H V|W.E ; Rr< OG K]UT ?>= £= ; HM== ; OE £E@? Tb] W.JBH ?B=@?OEwGIH T`j ¨HKN.HMV.= ON`= = ; ~¥[¦ HKA IP |r :<;

Ek= OE9E@JI=e= A ? T ^&% r a cd?YE WXEk=e= ; P&E@? T.] W.JBH ?R= f\EkftEk= OA H4E9? Tb] J[EkV ; <W T N H T I= GKlN.? T =@?BHM= ONP>?B= ; OEkVOGD=<= (? r Tz¥[¦ l|= ; ?BE<G OEkV UT N.E[= HA UT V [email protected]@E@?BH T = Al ^CB c+ldN.?> T =@?BHM= ONvP>?R= ; OEkVOGD=i= /? rED T JB?RQ= ; Ek= OE@E@J I=i= Ale= ; Q?BE T =7H T HM=@W HKJG ; ?BG ~~¥[¦ @LHKW.E@E9?BH T = ; N ] T HM= 4W.HKN HMV JKr :>; yJ Tb] = ; E@GIHKJ = ; N ] T HM= gW.HKN HMV [email protected]@E@?YH T GIH T = ; Thj G ; E T = V ! Zg?BN H T wGI? T =zE9?BA\WXJBHM=@? UT PS?R= ; HyE@WQGI? T =@JBf

Page 169: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a HKGIGIW HM= IV OE T =@HM=@? UT = ; P4r < OAVXJ fQ= ; ~¥[¦ G4N.?RV J>N.?YEk= ? j W.=@? UT ^CB c = ; ?BEd= A E@? T G<?R=x?BExE ; = OEk=J Tb] = ; E9GIHKJ>? T E@=@H T N.H N z¥[¦ r :<; Kl H4E@? Tb] J <E@WX? A l= ; ht= OE OgW.HM=@? UT E[PS?R= ; = ; ~¥<¦ E9W.? A GiN.?BEk= ? j Wb=@? UT H ] ?RZ T j f

0 0 ª m)0 ? ^CB c/? m)0 ^CB c $ ^&% r Uc ?(? ª _ % ^&% r ®Uc

) 589/ / 58@/ / ,.- /[6 28@1 -< £H ? T = OE@= ON? T W.E@? Tb] = ; ¨E@gW.? A A N OJ<= E@?BAhW.JBHM= E9W.EkV T E@? UT E = ; W.E@H T N.E ? T = HKGD=@? Tb] EkPS?BAA? T.]@] H T ?BE9AEIr :<; # ?BEk=@? Tb]~¥[¦ AHKG ; ? T f AHMOE= ; ?BES=@HKEk OJBHM=@?RZOJBfE@?BAVXJKr :<; JB? T OH ?R=Ff = ; vg= OE OgW.HM=@? UT E HKJBJ PSE= ; E@gW.? Aw? Tb] H T N ; ftN ! Nbf T HKA?BG? T = HKGD=@? UT E= ij Klg? T E ASE T E!Kl= OHM= ONE IVXH HM= OJRfKr < Klg= ; KlbG UT E@?BN xj = ; = ; [email protected]~¥[¦ E W GOEyHKE@E GI?BHM= ONuP>?R= ; ? ] ?BNE@V ; OESHKJ UTb] PS?R= ; = ; 7E@gW.? Aw? Tb] GhN.?YEk= ? j W.=@? UT E? T= ; ht= OE OgW.HM=@? UT E

0 0 ª 0 ^CB c 0 ? ^CB c(?

m0 ? ^CB c ?

m0 ^CB c $ ^&% r Kc ?/? ª _ % ^&% rUc f=@HMg? Tb] Z JYW.A HZ H ] OE = ; [email protected]=@? Tb]£ P OJYN2lP*¨AHOf N I= A? T = ; G ; H Tb] ¨? T

E@gW.? A E\A =@? UT HKEH [email protected]= = ; ; ftN ! Nbf T HKA?BGw? T = HKGD=@? UT E7P>?R= ; = ; = ; VXH =@?BGIJOEIr< ; T V ! A? Tb] = ; ?BELGIHKJBGIW.JYHM=@? UT l UT AhW.Ek=4AHMQE@W h= ; HM= P>E ] T HM= ON j f OHKG ; VXH C=@?BGIJK E P T E@gW.? A? Tb] A NOE\N T =ifg?OJYNH T f£E OJ CF? T N.W.GON OGD=@EIr < OG K]UT ?>= w= ; HM=\= ; ? T = ] HKJBE

0 ? m? ^CB c! 1 B ^&% r % cH T N

a¬#" %$ 0 ? $ m? $& %$'& ? $ m)? $ 0 ( ^CB c! 1 B ^&% r aI_ c

Page 170: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a %

P>?BJYJ j T UT C = ! H T NhP>?BJBJH =@? GI?BHKJYJRfG UT = ? j Wb= = HyVXH =@?BGIJK EzZOJ GI?R=FfhH T N7J GIHKJ HM= E@= HK? T OEkVOGD=@?RZOJBfKre T ^&% r % c+l= ; = T E 0 ? ?BE ] ?RZ T j f£ % a 0 ? ^CB c ª a

+ 1 0 ? * 0 /? ! " ^ ¬ c ( ^&% r aKa c

a 0 ? 0 ? & 0 ? * 0 ? ( ^CB c ^&% r a ¬ cH T N= ; V OE@E@? UT $ 0 ? $ ?BE ] ?RZ T ? T A ; JR=H T N ¦ H If£ a r $ 0 ? $ OJYHM= OE= ; E@WX? A? T.]Ek= OE9E@JI=[= ?R=@E P OJBN

m0 ª $ 0 ? $ m? $ % ^&% r a

*c

E9?BA\WXJBHM=@? UT ESP ; 7= ; ? T = HKGD=@? UT EH NI= A? T ON V|HK? P>?BE!\W.E@? Tb] H T HKJRf=@?YG V OE@E9? UT E = ; P OJBN.E\ % a l a nH T N J GIHKJ2V|H =@?BGIJDC ! ON AOE ; OEIlE@?BAVXJBfQ? ]UT ? Tb] = ; OE \= AESP>?BJBJ OA Z= ; E OJ CF? T N.WXGON A =@? UT r < ; T P t? Tb] P>?R= ; H ! ON T W.A ?BGIHKJ ] ?BN2l ; P*IZ l~= ; E OJ CF? T NXW.GON OGD=@E T ON= j LE@W j = HKGD= ON ! A= ; L= =@HKJ2Z JBW.ALHZ H ] OEIr :<; A =@? UT HE@gW.? A ?YE[= ; T] ?RZ Tj f

0 ª 3 m - 0 0 ^CB c! 1 B

0 ? m)? ^CB c! 1 B ^&% r a c 0 ª a¬

0 ? $ $ ? ^CB c! 1 B ^&% r a Uc 0 ? ªa¬ & 0/? ? 0 ( ^CB c! 1 B

a¬ & $ 0 & $ m& $(? $ ? & $ m& $ 0 ( ^CB c! 1 B ^&% r a ®Uc

) 5 < ?R= ; = ; ~¥[¦ E@WX? A A NOJ lMP*[V ! A E@?BAhW.JBHM=@? UT E= NI= A? T = ; [A =@? UT# HE@V ; ? T = ; [V OE T G HE@WX? A E P OJBNlK= ; [= H OGD= ?OE HLVXHK? E@gW.? A EIlKH T N7= ; <E OJ CN.?2W.E@? UT G wGI? T = ? T H ; A K] T W.E [email protected] T E9? UT E@WX? A EOr :<; OE >GIHKE OEP* >V IZt? W.E9JRfG UT E@?YN ON? T U XH T NKMXW.E@? Tb]Lj W T NXH f OJOA T =dH T NQg= OE9?BH T Nbf T HKA?BGIEeE@?YA\W.JYHM=@? UT EIr fG AVXH ? Tb] P>?R= ; = ; O? [email protected]=@E~= ; HM=eHKJBE ? T GIJYW.N OGD= |T OH C OJBN ; ftN ! Nbf T HKA?BGd? T = HKGD=@? UT EIlPiAHOfHKE@E!OE@E[= ; iHKGIGIW HKGDf = ; ~¥[¦ CFE@gW.? A AhW.JBHM=@? UT r

Page 171: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a _

? ] W % r a ^ Hsc 3 l ^ j c 3 l ^ Gc ldH T N ^ N|c H T ? T =iEkV ; QHKE7H W T GD=@? UT N.?BE@=@H T G ! A H\E@gW.? A r :<; >JB? T OExE ; P= ; H C OJBNH T HKJRftE@?BEH T N= ; SGI? GIWXJBH EkftA j JBEx= ; ¦ E@?YA\W.JYHM=@? UT [email protected]=@E>U r :<; <E9W.H OExH T Nw= ?BH Tb] JOExH <= ; SZqHKJBW OEdNI= A? T ONW.E@? Tb] = ; ~¥[¦ AhW.JBHM=@? UT r

Page 172: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a a

? ] W % r ¬ H T ? T =\EkV ; QHKE7H W T GD=@? UT N.?BE@=@H T G ! A H¨E@WX? A r :<; JB? T OEE ; P­= ; H C OJYN H T HKJBfgE@?YE>H T Nu= ; 7GI? GIW.JYH EkftA j JBES= ; ¦ E9?BA\WXJBHM=@? UT [email protected]=@EhUqr :<; [email protected] OE<H T N= ?BH Tb] J OE[H 4= ; 4ZMHKJBWOE[N I= A? T ONWXE@? Tb] = ; z¥[¦ AhW.JBHM=@? UT r "!#$%&'(*)+$,.-/&0.1$

< E@=nG UT E@?BN = ; ; fgN ! N.f T HKAw?BG OGD=@E HyE9W.? A UT H T OH @j f\EkV ; Kr :>; [E@WX? A? T.]VXH HKAI= E<H iE!I=<= 5¨ª a H T N . 2 ª

*oM¬ r :<; V|H =@?BGIJG UT.] W HM=@? UT E<G UT E@?BN ON ; 4H

NOE@G ? j ON? T ? ] W \ U r :<; iE@gW.? A ?BE>J GIHM= ON HM=y= ; ? ] ? T H T N ? T = ON E9W.G ; = ; HM=23 ª 2B r :>; EkV ; L?BEJ GIHM= ON? T = ; 4 CVXJBH T LHM=<HNX?BEk=@H T G ! A= ; 4E9W.? A HM=<H T H Tb] J5 A OHKE@W ON? T H ? ] ; =C ; H T NONE T E ! A = ; CFH ?BEIr :<; [ZMHKJBWOE = ; >EkV ; K EnZOJ GI?R=FfKl 3 H T N 3 lXH Tb] W.JBH ZOJ GI?B=FfKl lXH T NEk= OE@E@JI=Il tH T N lXH iNI= A? T ON H H Tb] P>?R= ; 56 ª + o H T N 56 ª

* + o 7 ON2r :<; [email protected]=@? Tb] ZqHKJBW OEH wE ; P T ? T¨ ? ] W OE % r a H T N% r ¬ r

< E! £= ; HM= ~¥[¦ fg? OJBN.EQ= ; G ! OGD=ZMHKJBWOE Z H¤JBH @] H T.] E IVXH HM=@? UT EIr :<; ~¥[¦ IV OE T =@HM=@? UT N OE j ] ? T = 4j OHMN P TwT OH G UT =@HKGD= P ; T JBW j ?YGIHM=@? UT# GOE j OG A ?BAV =@H T =IlOEkVOGI?BHKJBJRf? T = ; GIHKE = ; HKN.?BHKJ~ZOJ GI?R=Ff 3 rh A ?BAV ! ZOA T =@EG W.JYN j AHKN j f4HKJYJ P>? Tb] = ; J Tb] = ; E@GIHKJ = ; N ] T HM= GWXHKN HMV J @LHKWXE@E@?BH T = Sj xE@AwHKJBJ lj Wb=y= ; ?BEyP W.JBN OgW.? hHA XT ON A OE ; [email protected]=@? Tb] ? T HA G AV|Wb=@HM=@? UT HKJBJBf ? T = T E@?RZE@?BAhW.JBHM=@? UT r98 :;$< =>?@AB "!#&C $*D CFE&'(*)+$*

<HG GJIUAVXWb= G = ; G =LK9H LG GD=LIK9? G EMIN<= P.I£E@gW.?OK9A G K9E4H T N¤GJIUAVXHK G = ; G A P>?B= ; = ; IUE G N G = G K9Aw? T G NW.E@? Tb] HwNXHM=@H j HKE G INeVXHK?OK@P>?YE G N9IK+G G EyH T N=LIK9gW G EyGIHKJBGIW.JBHM= G N,N9KPIUA j IUW T NXHK@f G J G A GOT =yE@?BAhW.JBHqC

Page 173: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a ¬

? ] W K G % r * : K9H LG GD=LIK9? G E INe=FP IE@WX?OK9A G K9EPS?R= ; ^ 5 ª Uc[A I Zg? T.] ? T ^ HscIKV.VDIUE@?R= G H T N ^ j c[= ; GE@HKA G N.?OK G GD=@?OI T EIrn T@G HKG ; V|JOIK=Ilb= ; G EkftA j IUJYE[HK G V$K I Zg?YN G N j f= ; Giz¥[¦ E@?BAhW.JBHM=@?OI T E P ; ?BJ G = ; GJB? T$G E[HK G = ; G K G E9W.JR=@E IN<U r

=@?OI T EU r T = ; G GIHKE G EhGJI T E@?BN G K G Nl= ; G E@WX?OK9A G K9EAwHOfGJIUJBJB?YN G H T NP G = ; G K G N9IK G ? T GIJYW.N G HGJIUJBJB?YE@?OI T£j HKPK9? G K ^ ¬ r

* Uc\=LIuV$K G Z GOT =h= ; G E9W.?K9A G K9E N K IUA IZ G K9JYHMV.VX? Tb] r :<; G K9Ek=\GIHKE G GJI T E@?BNtCG K G N¨?BEy=FP IE@gW.?OK9A G K+E ^ 5¤ª UcI T$G A IZt? Tb] ? T = ; G VDIUE@?R=@?BZ G CFN.?OK G GD=@?OI T H T Nu= ; G IK= ; G K4? T = ; GT GI] HM=@?RZ G CFN.?K G GD=@?OI T r :<; G fHK G ? T ?R=@?BHKJYJRf aI_ " HMVXHK@=>? T = ; G CFNX?OK G GD=@?OI T l.H T N= ; G 4 E G VXHK9HM=@?I T EGJI T E@?YN G K G NHK G a " l ¬ " l[ " H T N aI_ " r :>; G~¥[¦ K G [email protected]=@EH T N¤= ; IUE G N K IUA U >GJIUAVXHK G P G JBJHKE7E ; I P T ? T ? ] W K G % r * ^ Hsc+l GJ7 G G V.=7? T = ; G [email protected]=@?OI T P ; G K G H GJIUJYJB?BE@?OI T IgGIGIW K+EIr §yE7E@WX?OK9A G KK G IK9? GOT =@HM=@?OI T ?YEi= ; G G f N HKGD=LIK? T N G = G K+A? T ? T.] = ; G XT HKJ=LK9H LG GD=LIK@fKlx= ; G GJIUJBJY?BE@?OI T Nbf T HKA?BGIET G G N£=LI j GMGJ7 HKGD=@JRf¨= ; G E@HKA G ? T IK9N G K N IK4= ; G K G [email protected]=@? T.] =LK9H LG GD=LIK9? G Ei=LI jDG E@?BA?BJYHKOr <HG HKJBELIGJIUAVXHK G = ; G GIHKE G P ; G K G = ; G = P.IE@gW.?OK9A G K9ExEkPS?BA ? T = ; G VDIUE@?R=@?RZ G CFN.?OK G GD=@?OI T ^ ? ] W$K G % r * ^ j ckc+r T G G H ] HK? T = ; Gi~¥[¦ K G E9W.JR=@E<GJIUAV|HK G P G JBJ2P>?B= ; = ; IUE G INzE ; ?BqHP H>? T HKJBJ j Wb=[= ; G GIHKE GINJYHK ]G Ek=4E G VXHK+HM=@?OI T r :<; G IK+? ] ? T INx= ; G N.?YE@GJK G VXH T GDf?YEyW T T IP T E@? T G G = ; G ? T = G K9HKGD=@?I T EHK GP G JBJDK G ELIUJRZ G N j f ~¥[¦ HM=<= ; ?BE[N.?BEk=@H T G G lXE G Gi ? ] W K G E % r a H T N % r ¬ r ?A - (.?/=A &'(?>)&

<HG GJI T N.WXGD=<E@?BAhW.JBHM=@?OI T E.INnH ; IUA I ]GOT G IUW.E<E9W.EkV GOT E@?OI T IN~E9W.?K9A G K9E W.E@? T.] H IUW$K9? G K[GJIUJBJOItGIHqC=@?OI T HKJ ] IK+?R= ; A­=LIiELIUJBZ G ^&% r Kce? T HLV G K9?OItN.?BGN IUAHK? T H T N I j =@HK? T = ; G[ IP ^ ' 4 ' cI T a % ¬ 1 ] K9?BN

Page 174: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a *

? ] W K G % r ZIUJBWb=@?OI T INLH£[email protected] GOT E9?OI T IN © ª¬ _K_K_ E9W.?K9A G K9Eh? T ?R=@?YHKJBJRf£EkP>?BAwA? Tb] ? T = ; GVDIUE@?R=@?RZ G CFN.?OK G GD=@?OI T r ^ Hsc ª _ " o 3 m ^ j c ª a

*% % " o 3 m ^ Gc ª¬ % " o 3 m ^ N|c ª a % " o 3 m

Page 175: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a q

? ] W K G % r : K9H T E@JBHM=@?I T HKJXE G JNYCFN.?>0W.E9?OI T GJI G QGI? GOT = INHhE@gW.?OK9A G K ^ 5¨ª UcxHKEH N W T GD=@?I T IN r§ GJI T Ek=@H T =LZqHKJYW G ? T NX?BGIHM= G E>HN.?2W.E@?RZ G A IgN G r :<; Gi~¥<¦ K G [email protected]=@E>HK G E ; IP T HKE j JBHKG9E@WXHK G EH T NuGJIK K G EkVDI T N =LIHQE@?YA\W.JYHM=@?OI T IN ©«ª­¬ _K_K_ H T N ZIUJBWXA G N K9HKGD=@?OI Tª _ % _ ¬ r :>; G JB? T G EN IK>ª _ % _ ¬ _ % a HK G N9K IUAKqr

VDIU? T =@EIr :>; G GJIUAVXWb=@HM=@?I T EHK G V G K N IK9A G N I THG ? ] ; = T = G J G I T ¬ r _ @=V$K ItG G E@ELIK9EIr7 T = ; GE@?BAhW.JBHM=@?I T l2P G GJI T E@?BN G K ©ª ¬ _K_K_ ? T N G V GOT N GOT =yE9W.?K9A G K9EyP ; ?YG ; GJIK K G EkVDI T N.EL=LI HZIUJYW.A GN K9HKGD=@?OI T IN <ª _ % _ ¬ r :<; G E@gW.?OK9Aw? Tb] VXHK+HKA G = G KN9IK G HKG ; E@gW.?OK9A G K?BEE G ==LI 5¨ª gr : I jDGI] ? T= ; G E9?BA\WXJBHM=@?OI T lU= ; G E@gW.?OK9A G K+EeHK G N.?BE@=LK9? j Wb= G N7W T ?ON9IK+AJRf\? T = ; G>j I 7 l j Wb=e= ; G fHK G HKJYJ IK9? GOT = G N? T = ; G E9HKA G NX?OK G GD=@?OI T P>?R= ; 23

ª 2B N IK ª a ' % % % ' © r :<; G G ZIUJBWb=@?I T INe= ; G [email protected]@V GOT E@?OI T I Z G K=@?BA G ?YEE ; IP T ? T£ ? ] W K G % r P ; G K G = ; G E9W.?K9A G K9EL? T ?B=@?BHKJBJRf? T = ; G JOIP G K ; HKJON IN = ; Gj I 7 HK GE ; HKN G N ] K9Hf P ; ?BJ G = ; IUE G ? T = ; G WbV.V G K ; HKJNdHK G P ; ?R= G r <HG E G G = ; HM=y= ; G ? T ?R=@?YHKJGJI T.] W$K9HM=@?OI TIN<HKJBJE@WX?OK9A G K9EiEkP>?BAAw? Tb] ? T = ; G E@HKA G N.?OK G GD=@?I T ?BE\W T Ek=@H j J G aKa ¬ l aKaI_ lnqKH T N I Z G K7=@?BA GA? 7 ? Tb] INz= ; G = P.I ; HKJRZ G EItGIGIW K9EIr

:<; G Aw? 7 ? Tb] E G GOT ? ] W$K G % r?YE K G JBHM= G N¤=LI£= ; G#G G GD=@?BZ G N.?2W.E@?OI T IN>= ; G E9W.?K9A G K9Ei= ; HM=ItGIGIW K9EHKE~HK G E@WXJR=DIN ; ftN K ItNbf T HKA?BGn? T = G K9HKGD=@?OI T E2PS?R= ; T G ? ] ; j IK9? Tb] VXHK@=@?YGIJ G EIr :>; G E G JON CFN.?2W.E@?OI TGJI G wGI? GOT =IZ G Ky=@?BA G GIH T j G N G = G K+A? T G N#N K IUA

0 0 ^ @c ª ^ 0 ^ ! @c 0 ^ @ckc ® ^&% r a KcP ; G K G = ; G [email protected]/I Z G K ?YEd?BAVXJY? G N2r :<; G ZMHKJBW G IN= ; G E@gW.?OK+A G KdE G JON CFN.?2W.E@?OI T GJI G wGI? GOT =FN9KPIUA/IUW K

Page 176: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a K

E@?BAhW.JBHM=@?I T E~HKJI Tb] P>?R= ; = ; IUE G V$K I Zg?YN G N j fKq.HK G VXJOIK=k= G N? T7 ? ] W K G % r gr G EkVX?R= G ? ]UT IK9? Tb] = ; GT G HKkC G JBN\JYW j K9?BGIHM=@?I T N IK9G G EeH T N G AVXJOI fg? Tb] = ; G GJIUJBJY?BE@?OI Tij HK K9? G Kl = ; G E G JNYCFN.?>0W.E9?OI T GJI G wGI? GOT =@EHK G K G AwHK@qH j JRf\E@?YA?BJBHKnP ; GOT P G GJIUAVXHK G IUW KFK G E9W.JR=@EN IK >ª _ % _ ¬ N IKd= ; IUE G HM= >ª _ % _ N K IUAKqr T HKN.N.?R=@?OI T l2P G E G G = ; HM=\P>?R= ; = ; Gwz¥[¦ CFE9W.?K9A G KiA ItN G JeP G GIH T ; H T N.J G H E@?BAhW.JBHM=@?OI TP>?R= ; T$G HK9JRf=FP I IK9N G K9EINnAwH ]UT [email protected] G A IK G E@gW.?OK9A G K+E= ; H T = ; G4© ª¬ 7GJI T E9?BN G K G N? T KMr

`1 - 6 5 8@1 - T = ; ?YE\G ; HMV.= G KOleP G VK G E GOT = G N H T¤~¥<¦ N9IK+A\W.JYHM=@?OI T IN>= ; G E9W.?K9A G KiA ItN G J.N9IK7H¨A?BGJK IIKkC] H T ?BE9Ar f GJIUAVXHK9? Tb] P>?R= ; K G [email protected]=@EBN K IUA j IUW T NXHK@f G J G A GOT =U H T N¤t=LIK G E@?BH T Nbf T HKA?BGIEE@?BAhW.JBHM=@?I T E4KMl|P G N9IUW T N= ; HM=>= ; G\~¥[¦ N IK9AhW.JBHM=@?OI T EK G V$K ItN.W.G G ESWX?R= G P G JBJ2= ; G E@WX?OK9A G KkCE@gW.?OK9A G K? T = G K9HKGD=@?OI T E[H T NQVK IZt?BN G E H T HKGIGIW K9HM= G G Ek=@?YAHM= G IN~E@gW.?OK9A G K E@WXEkV GOT E@?OI T VK IKV G K@=@? G EIr T HKN.N.?R=@?OI T ld= ; G ~¥<¦ N IK9AhW.JBHM=@?OI T INy= ; G E@gW.?OK+A G KA IgN G J[?BEGIHMVXH j J G INE@?YA\W.JYHM=@? Tb] AH T fA IK G E@WX?OK9A G K9E = ; H T = ; G g=LIK G E@?BH T Nbf T HKA?BGIE[HMV.VK IUHKG ; r

Page 177: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

( $ [ %!

* * 5 [/ 1 5 Z G Ky= ; G GJIUW$K9E G INx= ; ?BE[= ; G E9?BEIlXP G N G Z G JOIKV G N T G P = G G ; T ?BgW G E<=LIA ItN G J G wGI? GOT =@JRf= ; G N9IK+G G EGJ7 V G K+? GOT G G N j f VXHK9HKAH ]UT$G =@?BGhVXHK@=@?BGIJ G E ^ ¥ ; HMV.= G K ¬ cSH T N G AVXJOI f G N¨= ; G E G A ItN G JBEL? T E@?BAhW.JBHqC=@?OI T E N IK= ; G V ; ftE@?BGIE.IN~E@WXEkV GOT E@?OI T EFINVXHK9HKAwH ]UT G =@?BGSVXHK@=@?BGIJ G EH T N= ; G Nbf T HKA?BGIE.INHK@=@? GI?BHKJA?BGJKPIMCFEkP>?BAA G K9EIr :<; GA K9Ek=;INd= ; G A ItN G JBEy?BEyV$K I Zg?BN G N ? T£¥ ; HMVX= G K * H T N¨GJI T G G K T Ey= ; G AH ] CT G =@?BGQ? T = G K9HKGD=@?OI T E j G = P G GOT = ; GQjDG HKN.EIr <HG ? T =LK ItN.W.G G N H XT ?B= G CFN.?RVDIUJ G A ItN G Jd=LI K G ELIUJRZ G = ; GN HKkC $G JBNAwH ]UT G =@?BG<? T = G K9HKGD=@?OI T EdP ; G K G = ; G AH ]UT$G =@?>=OHM=@?OI T IN G HKG ; V|HK@=@?BGIJ G ?BEFK G V$K G E GOT = G NwWXE@? Tb]H @HKW.E@E@?BH T N.?BEk=LK+? j Wb=@?OI T IN4GIW KPK GOT =QN GOT E@?R= f? T = ; G,G W.HM=@?I T E N IKQ= ; G AH ]UT G =@?YG $G JBNr D T CJB?R G V IU? T =CFN.?BV IUJ G HMV.VK IUHKG ; G E\P ; G K G = ; G GJIUAVXWb=@HM=@?OI T HKJxP.IK9? T GJK G HKE G EiP>?R= ; = ; GQT W.A jDG KBINVXHK@=@?YGIJ G [email protected] G N2l= ; G GJIUAVXW.=@HM=@?OI T HKJ[P IK@¤HKE@ELItGI?BHM= G N P>?B= ; = ; G XT ?R= G CFNX?RVDIUJ G A IgN G J[E9GIHKJ G EJB? T$G HK9JRfP>?R= ; = ; G\T W.A jDG K INeVXHK@=@?BGIJ G EOr>§SJI Tb] P>?B= ; = ; ?BESA IgN G J lXP G VK IZt?BN G N H ; ? ] ; G KSAhW.JR=@? CVDIUJ G ? T GIJBW.E@?I T A G = ; ItN j HKE G N INd= ; GMGJ7 HKGD=LE IUJBWb=@?OI T =LI= ; G = P.IMC j ItNbf VK I j J G A#=LI K G ELIUJRZ G = ; GT G HKkC G JBN? T = G K9HKGD=@?OI T EOr :<; G ? T GIJBW.E@?I T V$KPIgG G N.W$K G ?BE ]GOT G K+HKJH T NAwHOf jDG W.E G N? T GJI Tq W T GD=@?OI TP>?R= ; G ?R= ; G K>= ; GXT ?B= G CFN.?RVDIUJ G A ItN G JIKLH T fVDIU? T =>N.?RVDIUJ G K G VK G E GOT =@HM=@?OI T r :<; KPIUW ] ; HwE G K9? G EINAhW.JR=@? C j ItNbfV$K I j J G AEIl2P G N9IUW T N¨= ; HM=iHNX?RVDIUJ G A IgN G J GOT ; H T G G N j f = ; G ? T GIJBWXE@?OI T V$K ItG G N.W K Gft? G JBN.EyH T HKGIGIW K9HM= G G Ek=@?BAwHM= G INd= ; G ? T = G K@VXHK@=@?BGIJ G AH ]UT$G =@?BG N9IK9G G l G E@V G GI?YHKJBJRf? T H 7 ?YEkfgAwA G =LK9?BGGJI T.] W$K9HM=@?OI T EIr

Th¥ ; HMV.= G K~blMP G V$K G E GOT = G N K G E@WXJR=@EN K IUA E9?BA\WXJBHM=@?OI T E G AVXJOIft? Tb] = ; G T G P AH ]UT G =@?BG? T = G K9HKG C=@?OI T A IgN G J.GJIUWbVXJ G NwP>?R= ; z¥[¦ =LIiVK IZt?BN G = ; G ELIUJBWb=@?I T =LIi= ; G JOI P! G f T IUJBNXE T WXA jDG KA I j ?BJB?R= fV$K I j J G Ar :<; G E@W$K N HKG G N9IK+G G EH T NQELIUJB?BN j ItNbf7GJI T =@HKGD=[HK G ? T =LK IgNXW.G G N= ; K IUW ] ; H ]GOT$G K9?BG>E ; IK@=CK9H Tb]GLj HKPK9? G K N9IK9G G ^#" ¬ rc+r :<; G;G G GD=@EIN= ; ?BE.N9IK9G G I T = ; G IUE@GI?BJYJBHM=@?OI T E GJ7 ; ? j ?R= G N j fQH\V|HK?OK.IN

a K®

Page 178: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a U

VXHK9HKAwH ]UT G =@?BG jDG HKN.E[? T HMK IK=@HM=@? T.]$G JBNP HKE>GJI T E@?BN G K G N? T " br ¬ H T NGJIUAVXHK+?BELI T EP>?B= ; GJ7 V G KkC?BA GOT =<? T NX?BGIHM= G = ; G V$K G E GOT G G INzHE9?BA?BJBHK K G VXWXJBE@?RZ G N9IK+G G4jDG =FP G GOT = ; G VXHK@=@?YGIJ G EIr <HG V$KPIZt?BN G NE@?BAhW.JBHM=@?I T E;IN G ; HK? T E4E9W jtLG GD=y=LI K IK=@HM=@? Tb] G JBN.ELH T N£E ; G HK IP>EiH T N? T G HKG ; GIHKE G GIHKJYGIW.JBHM= G= ; G JOIP G Ek=ZMHKJBW G IN= ; GL¦ HKELI TT W.A j G Kl " IK " m ltHM= P ; ?YG ; H\G ; HK? T IN ©jDG HKN.EP>?BJBJ K9E@= j K G HMr fGJIUAVXHK+? Tb] = ; G E G K G [email protected]=@E[P>?R= ; = ; IUE G N G = G K9Aw? T G NW.E9? Tb] H ; fgN$K IgN.f T HKAw?BGLN K9H ]H T N¨VDIU? T =yNX?RVDIUJ G\j HKE G N£G ; HK? T A IgN G J Ml % KdP G N G A I T Ek=LK+HM= G N¨= ; G ?BAVDIK@=@H T G G IN = ; G ; fCN K ItNbf T HKA?BGS? T = G K9HKGD=@?OI T E[HKJOI T.] = ; G J GOTb] = ; INz= ; G G ; HK? T r < ; GOT P G A ItN.? $G N= ; G G ; HK? T A ItN G J=LI\? T GIJBW.N G = ; G E G G G GD=@EIlt= ; G E@?BAhW.JBHM=@?I T K G [email protected]=@EdHK G P G JBJ$K G V$K ItN.W.G G N2rz§SN.NX?R=@?OI T HKJBJBf\? TQ¥ ; HMV.= G KblsP G GJI T E9?BN G K G NH T ? T ?R=@?BHKJYJRf ; IUA I ]GOT G [email protected]@V GOT E@?OI T E@W jtLG GD=d=LIiHBK IK=@HM=@? Tb] HMVXVXJB? G N $G JBNrz§yE? T = ; G GJ7 V G K9?BA GOT =@E> % * lsP G N9IUW T N7= ; HM= jDG JOI PH4GJK9?R=@?YGIHKJbZqHKJYW G IN " kl= ; G<jDG HKN.EeH ]K] K GI] HM= G N=LI N IK9A G ; HK? T Ee= ; HM=KPIK=@HM= G NQPS?R= ; = ; G HMVXVXJB? G N $G JYN2lUP ; ?YJ G H j I Z G " 0 lgE@AHKJBJbV|JBH T HKxGIJBWXEk= G K9EP G K G I j E G K9Z G N2r :<; G>T W.A j G K IN0VXHK9=@?BGIJ G Ee= ; HM=HK G A G A jDG K9E IN2GIJBW.Ek= G K+EdH T N= ; G E ; HMV G IN|= ; G E GGIJBW.E@= G K9E<GIH TjDG K G JBHM= G N=LI= ; G K G E9W.JR=@E N K IUAN.?BG ; K IU?BE9A GJ7 V G K9?BA GOT =@EIr

§yJOI Tb] P>?R= ; = ; G E@?BAhW.JBHM=@?OI T E IN GOT E G A j J G E INdV|HK9HKAH ]UT G =@?BGhVXHK9=@?BGIJ G EIlP G GJI T NXW.GD= G N¨E@?BA7CW.JBHM=@?I T E INS= ; G HK@=@? GI?YHKJA?YGJK IMCFEkP>?BAwA G K * * r :<; ?BEhN G Zt?BG G ?BE\GJI T Ek=LK9W.GD= G N N K IUA H¨G ; HK? T ING ; G A?BGIHKJBJRf7JB? T G N\V|HK9HKAH ]UT G =@?BG<VXHK@=@?BGIJ G ExGJI T.T G GD= G N=LI\H K G N j JI>ItNG G JBJ r : I N HKGI?BJY?R=@HM= G E@?BAhW.JBHqC=@?OI T EIN~= ; ?YE[N G Zg?YG G l.P G ? T =LK ItN.W.G G NH TG JBHKEk=@?BGGJIUWbV|JB? Tb] A ItN G J2N G E@GJK+? jDG N? T ¥ ; HMV.= G KShP ; G K GG HKG ; ? T N.?RZt?BN.WXHKJKG ; G A?YGIHKJgJY? T 4?BE~=LK G HM= G NHKEeH T ? T GJ7 = GOT E@? j J GxGJ7 ? j J G K ItN2r :<; ?BEzA ItN G J?YE~Z G K+? $G Nj fGJI T E@?BN G K9? Tb] = ; G G gW.?BJY? j K9?BWXA E ; HMV G H T N G G GD=@?RZ G N$K9H ] GJI G wGI? GOT = INeH JBHKA GOT =>E G =k=@JB? T.] ? [email protected] W.?BN2r < ?B= ; = ; G G JBHKEk=@?YGGJIUWbVXJB? T.] VK IgG G NXW K G l2= ; G [email protected]?RVDIUJ G A IgN G JeH T N ~¥[¦ lP G V G K N IK9A G NE@?BAhW.JBHM=@?I T EFIN= ; G HK9=@? GI?BHKJA?BGJK IMCFE@P>?BAA G K N K9?RZ GOTQj f= ; G IK9? ] ? T HKJYJRf7V$K IKVDIUE G NIUE@GI?BJYJBHM=@? Tb] AH ]UT G =@?BG $G JBN7gr a H T N N9IUW T Ni= ; G E9GIHKJ G N7EkP>?BAAw? Tb] EkV G G N.EzHK G GJIUAVXHK+H j J G =LIy= ; IUE GGJ7 V G K+?BA GOT =@HKJBJRf A G HKE9W K G N2l G EkV G GI?BHKJYJRf HM= ; ? ] ; ~rh T¥ ; HMV.= G Ki®gl~P G N G A I T Ek=LK9HM= G N= ; HM== ; GA?BGJKPIMCFEkP>?BAA G K4AHOf jDG V$K IKV G JBJ G N£W.E@? Tb] H T HKJR= G K T HM=@?BZ G HMV.VXJB? G N $G JBNEk=LK+HM= GI] fKr gV G GI? GIHKJBJRfKlP G E ; I P G N = ; HM=yW.E@? Tb] KPIK=@HM=@? Tb] G JBN.E[= ; G EkP>?BAwA G K<P>?BJYJ2N G N9IK+A#? T =LIQHQGJIK@gE9GJK G P E ; HMV G = ; HM=K IK=@HM= G ELP>?B= ; = ; G E@HKA G N K G W GOT GDfHKEy= ; G HMVXVXJB? G N G JBN H T N EkV|?OK9HKJBE<?B=@E>PHOf = ; K IUW ] ; = ; Gh W.?BN2r K IUA = ; G E9?BA\WXJBHM=@?OI T EIl2P G GJ7 =LK9HKGD= G N¤HVXHK9HKA G = G K9?>=OHM=@?OI T IN = ; G EkP>?BAwA G Kg? T G AHM=@?BGIE4W T N G K= ; ?BEhA ItN G IN IKV G K9HM=@?OI T leH T N W.E@? T.] HuGJI T =@? T W IUW.E G JBHKE@=@?BGIH K G E@?BE@=@?RZ G N IK9G G N G E@GJK+?RV.=@?OI T IN<= ; G JBHKA GOT =Q=@HK?BJ l<P G,GJ7 HKA? T$G N= ; G K G JBHM=@?I TjDG =FP G GOT = ; G EkP>?BAAw? Tb] EkV G G NH T N= ; G AH ]UT$G =@?BGN IK9G G EH T N£EkP>?YAA G K ]G IUA G =LK@f¨? T = ; G JOIP N K G gW GOT GDf JB?YA?R=IrL T¥ ; HMV.= G K\l2P G WXE G Nu= ; G E@?BA7CW.JBHM=@?I T = G G ; T ?BW G =LI gW.H T =@?ON fu= ; G ? T = G K9HKGD=@?OI T E jDG =FP G GOT = P.I¨GJIUA IZt? Tb] HK@=@? GI?BHKJdEkP>?YAA G K9EIrDyE@? Tb] HQJOI P/IK9N G K;N9IK9G G AhW.JR=@?RVDIUJ G GJ7 VXH T E9?OI T N IKL= ; G N9IK9G G N.?BE@=LK9? j Wb=@?I T = ; G E@P>?BAA G K GJ7G K9=@E

Page 179: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a I T = ; G\ W.?BN2l.P G N G A I T Ek=LK+HM= G N = ; G ; fgN KPIgNbf T HKA?YG? T = G K+HKGD=@?OI T EyN G GIHOfuHKE P ; G K G u?BES= ; GE G VXHK+HM=@?OI T NX?BEk=@H T G G rS T [email protected] G gW.H T =@? $G N= ; GhjDG ; HOZt?OIK;INd= ; G EkP>?BAA G K T G HKHK9? ] ?YNuE9W K N HKG G W.E@? Tb] H T ?BAwH ]G qJBW j K9?YGIHM=@?OI Tuj HK K9? G KA G = ; IgN£N G E9GJK9? jDG N¨? T ¥ ; HMV.= G K gr <HG K9Ek=HKN.N K G E@E G N£= ; G G ; H Tb]G Eh? T EkP>?YAA? Tb] EkV G G NHIN[HVXJYH T HK4EkP>?BAwA G K4EkP>?BAwA? Tb] VXHK9HKJBJ G J~=LI = ; GE@W KPN HKG G r §=SJOI P N K G W GOT GI? G EIl.= ; G E@GIHKJ G NE@P>?BAA? Tb] EkV G G N? T GJK G HKE G NHKE<= ; G N.?BEk=@H T G G N9K IUA#= ; GE@W KPN HKG G N G GJK G HKE G N2re T = ; ?BExJY?BA?R=eP G E9HOP= ; HM=.N IK = ; G K+H Tb]G IN ; G ? ] ; =@E GJI T E@?YN G K G N2l= ; HM=.K G E@GIHKJ C? Tb] u=LI? T GIJYW.N G = ; G G ; H Tb]G EL? T N K9H ] I T = ; G7 JBHKA GOT =>=@HK?YJGJIUJBJBHMV|E G N= ; G N.HM=@H I T =LIHwE9? Tb] J GGIW K@Z G r§SNXN.?R=@?OI T HKJYJRfKl2= ; G VXJYH T HKiEkP>?YAA G KPHKEBK G V G JBJ G N N K IUA= ; G E@W K N HKG G E@? T G G ?R= ]GOT G K+HM= G EH VXW.JBJ G K C=FfgV G Ek=LK G E@E@J G =Ir <HG HKJBELIQE9HOP­= ; HM=yP>?R= ; HEkVX?K9HKJEkP>?YAA G KOl.= ; G N G Zt?BG G P>?BJBJKPIUJBJHKEy?R=EkP>?YAE[A IZt? Tb] ? T HwEk=LK+HK? ] ; =SJB? T G HM=>H T H Tb] J G =LI?R=@E T HM=@W K+HKJEkP>?BAwA? Tb] N.?OK G GD=@?I T r :<; G KPIUJBJB? Tb]EkV G G N¤N G GIHOf G N&HKE K9HM= ; G K= ; H T r :<; ?YE\N.?> G K GOT G G PHKE GJ7 VXJBHK? T G N j fvGJI T E@?YN G K9? Tb] H TH T HKJOI ] IUWXE<V$K I j J G A INnHwEkV ; G K G N IK9G G N=LIQA IZ G ? T HGI?OK9GIJ GLT$G HK>HE@W KPN HKG G r

< ; ?BJ G = ; G A G = ; ItN.ELN G Z G JOIKV G N ? T = ; ?YE>= ; G E9?BEyP G K G IK9? ] ? T HKJBJRf? T = GOT N G N,N9IKN G E9GJK9? j ? T.] = ; GA IK=@?OI T IN.VXHK+HKAH ]UT G =@?BGxVXHK@=@?BGIJ G ? T E9W.EkV GOT E@?OI T lO= ; G fiGIH T\jDGGJ7 = GOT N G N7H T NiHKNXHMV.= G Nh=LIyHKN.N$K G E@EIK= ; G KV$K I j J G AEx? T [email protected]@V GOT E@?OI T V ; ftE@?BGIEIre§yE H T GJ7 HKAVXJ G lt? T¥ ; HMV.= G K % ltP G HKN.HMV.= = ; G E@WX?OK9A G KA ItN G JDN IK<HEkP>?BAAw? Tb] Aw?BGJK IIK ] H T ?BE@AU ? T =LI= ; G4z¥[¦ N IK9AhW.JBHM=@?OI T r < ; ?YJ G = ; ?BE[HMV.V$K IUHKG ;N I G E T IK=K G ELIUJRZ G = ; G E ; IK9=C?K9H Tb]G JBW j K9?BGIHM=@?OI T ? T = G K9HKGD=@?I T EHKGIGJIUW T = G N N9IKz? T = ; G IK+? ] ? T HKJKEk=@WXN.? G EIl?R=K G VK IgNXW.G G E2? T = G K9HKGD=@? Tb] E9W.?K9A G K0=LK9H LG GD=LIK9? G EzH T N= ; G E G JONYCFNX?0WXE@?OI T GJI G wGI? GOT =N9IKH>E@WX?OK9A G K? T HE9W.EkV GOT E@?OI T r

* 5 057/ 8@/ 6 28@1 - T = ; ?BEw= ; G E@?BEIl<P G G Ek=@H j JB?YE ; G NE@?BAhW.JBHM=@?OI T = G G ; T ?YW G E=LI ; H T NXJ G = ; G AH T fC j ItNbf AH ]UT$G =@?BG? T = G K9HKGD=@?OI T E jDG =FP G GOT VXHK+HKAH ]UT G =@?BG jDG HKN.E ¦ W.?BN.ESH T NuP>?R= ; ~¥[¦ l2P G K G H j J G =LIGJI T N.W.GD=E@?BAhW.JBHM=@?I T EIN GOT E G A j J G ES= ; IUW.E@H T NXE INxVXHK@=@?BGIJ G EOr < ; ?BJ G P G N ItGIW.E G N,IUW [email protected].? G E I T ? T ?R=@?YHKJBJRf; IUA I ]GOT$G IUW.EVXHK@=@?BGIJ G EE@W jt G GD= =LI7H KPIK=@HM=@? Tb] HMV.VXJB? G N $G JBN2lgW.E@? T.] = ; G E@HKA G A G = ; ItN.EIlI T G GIH TGJI T N.WXGD=>E@?BAhW.JBHM=@?OI T E IN ¦ W.?BNXE[? T PHKJBJ j IUW T N G NG ; H T.T G J IPSEIKS? T W T ?ON IK9A E ; G HK I P>EIrtW.G ; E@?BAhW.JBHM=@?OI T E IN = ; IUW.E@H T N.E;INVXHK9=@?BGIJ G EHM== ; ?BELJ G Z G JFINN G =@HK?BJ ; HOZ GwT IK= jDG GOT V G K N IK9A G NH T N¨P IUW.JBNuV$K I Zg?YN G ? T N IK9AHM=@?OI T ZMHKJBW.H j J G =LI A?YGJK I W.?BNX?BG4N G E@? ]UT H T N ¦ W.?BN K ; G IUJI ] fKrh T= ; G GIHKE G IN<= ; G JBHM= G KOl T G P JYW j K9?BGIHM=@?I Tj HK K+? G K9E4VK IZt?BN.? T.] Ek=LK G E@E9J G =h? T N9IK+AHM=@?OI T a ¬ _ [GJIUW.JBNjDG ? T GIJBW.N G N =LIHKJBJIP N [email protected].? G E INZ G K@f ; ? ] ; ZIUJBW.A G N K9HKGD=@?OI T E9W.EkV GOT E@?OI T EIr :<; G K G ; HKEHKJBELIjDG GOT H ] K G HM=[N G HKJ IN GJ7 V G K9?BA GOT =@HKJ|NXHM=@HhA G HKE@W K9? T.] = ; Gy] K IP>= ; K+HM= G E ING ; HK? T E? T E@WXEkV GOT E@?OI T E

Page 180: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a %

?BAA G K9E G N? T HwW T ?ON9IK+A HMV.VXJB? G N $G JBN2r§ JBHK ]G E@GIHKJ G E9?BA\WXJBHM=@?OI T INe= ; ?YE<V$K ItG G E@E>= ; HM=S? T GIJBW.N G E= ; G ; ftN K ItNbf T HKA?BGe? T = G K9HKGD=@?I T E j G = P G GOT VXHK9=@?BGIJ G E ; HKE~f G =z=LI jDG V G K N IK9A G N2lMH T NhGJIUW.JBN jDG N I T GW.E@? Tb] = ; G E G A G = ; ItN.EIr IKLHQV$K IKV G KyGJIUAVXHK9?BE I T l ; I P G Z G Kl2= ; G K I P T ?BH T N9IK+G G E>P>?YJBJ T G G N =LIjDG =@HM GOT ? T =LI\GJI T E@?BN G K+HM=@?OI T rz T H T ? T ?B=@[email protected] KPIP T ?YH T A IK=@?OI T GIH TjDG ? T GIJBW.N G N7W.E@? Tb] = ; GHMV.V$KPIUHKG ; HKN$IKV.= G N j f ¥ JB?BA GOT = ¬ MP ; G K G = ; G E@=@HM=@?BEk=@?BGIE K GI] HK9N.? T.] = ; G K9H T N$IUA N IK9GI? Tb]? ]UT IK G = ; G ; fgN KPIgNbf T HKA?YGS? T = G K9HKGD=@?OI T E

^ kc ª ^ aI_ r a c

^ kc

^ Yc ª a ¬ + " 0 ?

^ Bc ^ aI_ r ¬ c

< ?R= ; = ; G E G Ek=@HM=@?BEk=@?BGIEOlb= ; G K G E@WXJR=@? Tb] N.?2W.E@?OI T = GOT E IK>?BE 0 ? ª ® + " 0 $ ^ kc ? $ ^ @c ^ aI_ r

*c

K9HM= ; G Ky= ; H T 0 ? ª 0 ? r : I I j =@HK? T HwA IK G HKGIGIW$K9HM= G ZqHKJBW G IN 0 ? K G gW.?OK G E>= ; G N G = G K+A? CT HM=@?OI T IN 0 ? rd§yGIG G J G K9HM= G N g=LIK G E@?YH T N.f T HKAw?BGIES ¬ 2H T NQVXHK@=@?BGIJ G A G E ; PHKJBNA G = ; ItN.E * G AVXJIfHhA G = ; ItNw? T =LK ItN.W.G G N j f ? 7 AH T

* M|=LI7HKN.N K G E@Ex= ; ?BE ?BE@E@W G rz§ T HKJB= G K T HM=@?RZ G HMV.V$K IUHKG ;A? ] ; = jDG = ; HM=4W.E G N j f£ ; HK9AHH T N nHM=@H T MHK aKaKa xH T N HKN.N a eP ; G K G H#K9H T N IUAl W.GD=@WXHM=@? Tb] Ek=LK G E@Ew?BEQ? T =LK IgNXW.G G N ? T = ; G W.?YN¤V ; HKE G Mqr I 7 H T N D ; J GOTjDG G@

* % yE ; IP G N= ; HM=<= ; G GJIK K G GD=SVXHK@=@?BGIJ G N.?>0W.E9?OI T ?BEK G GJI Z G K G N ?N= ; GiT IMCFE@JB?RV j IUW T NXHK@fwGJI T N.?B=@?OI T ?BE<E@HM=@?YE $G NGJ7 HKGD=@JRfKr :<; ?BE7HMV.V$KPIUHKG ; GJIUW.JYN K G HKN.?BJRf jDG HKN.HMV.= G N =LI ~¥[¦ l ; IP G Z G KOlGIHK G AhW.Ek= jDG =@HM GOTE@? T G G = ; GLT IMCFE@JB?BV j IUW T N.HK@fGJI T NX?R=@?OI T ?YE T IK= E@HM=@?BE G N GJ7 HKGD=@JRfwH T NQ= ; Gy [email protected]=@? Tb] Ek=LK G E@E G EHK G? T N G V GOT N GOT = INnVXHK@=@?BGIJ G GJI T.] W K9HM=@?OI T r

<HG HKJYELIV$K G E GOT = G N HA ItN G JL= ; HM=?YE G G GD=@?RZ G ? T E@?BAhW.JBHM=@? T.] = ; G£jDG ; HZg?IK@INhAH ]UT$G =@?BG JBHKA GOT =@EyGJI T Ek=LK9WXGD= G N N9K IUA%G ; G A?BGIHKJBJRfJY? T G N VXHK9HKAH ]UT G =@?YGiVXHK9=@?BGIJ G EIr :<; ?BESA G = ; ItN GIH T¨jDGW.E G Nu=LIV$K I Zg?YN G E@?YA\W.JYHM=@?OI T E IN T G P>JRf@K G HKJB?>= G N j ?OIUA?YA G =@?BGiN G Zg?BG G ELWb=@?YJB?>=O? Tb] = ; G E G JBHKA GOT =@EIr fHM=k=@HKG ; ? T.] I T GBGOT NINz= ; G JBHKA GOT =[=LIQHG ; H T.T G J2PHKJBJ l GJ7 V G K9?BA GOT =@HKJB?BE@=@E ; HOZ G4jDG GOT H j J G =LIGJK G HM= G HK K9HOftE IN[HK@=@? GI?BHKJnGI?BJB?BH£ * x= ; HM=iGIH T£jDG W.E G N¨=LIV|W.AVHIKiA? 7 W.?YNu? T = ; G G ; H TXT G J rt?BAhW.JBHM=@?I T E IN[= ; G E G HK9=@? GI?BHKJdGI?YJB?BHGIH Tvj G GJI T N.W.GD= G NvW.E@? Tb] = ; G A G = ; ItN.E\N G E@GJK9? jDG N£? T = ; ?BE= ; G E@?YE[=LI K G Z G HKJIKV.=@?BAHKJ2HMV.V|JB? G N $G JBNEk=LK+HM= GI] ? G EIKyHK K9HOfVXHM=k= G K T EIr

? T HKJYJRfKl<P G N G A I T Ek=LK9HM= G N= ; G ?BAVXHKGD= IN\= ; G A G = ; ItN.E jDG fI T N`[email protected] GOT E@?I T E INiV|HK9HKA7CH ]UT G =@?BGVXHK9=@?BGIJ G EhH T N¤HK@=@? GI?BHKJ A?BGJKPIMCFEkP>?BAA G K9E j f HKN.HMV.=@? Tb] = ; G E9W.?K9A G K\A IgN G J=LI ~¥[¦

Page 181: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a ® _

GOT H j JY? Tb] JBHK ]G E@GIHKJ G E@?BAhW.JBHM=@?OI T [email protected] GOT E9?OI T E INdA?BGJKPI>IK ] H T ?BE@AEIr :<; ?BE<A ItN G JGIH T jDG N W KkC= ; G K GOT ; H T G G N =LIQ? T GIJBW.N G = ; G G G GD=@E;INdG ; G A?BGIHKJ ] K+HKN.? GOT =@E>=LI GJ7 VXJIK G G ; G A IK=@HKGD=@?BG jDG ; HOZt?OIKIKA IgNX? $G N=LI7GJI T E@?BN G K G JBJB?BVXELIU?BN.HKJtE@gW.?OK+A G K9E> % r :>; G6 JBHKA GOT = A IgN G JXGIH TQj G G AVXJOI f G NQ? T HZMHK9? G =Ff INE9G GOT HK9?OIUEIr IK GJ7 HKAVXJ G l j f? T GIJBW.NX? Tb] = ; G G G GD=@E IN K IP T ?BH T A IK=@?I T = ; GSjDG ; [email protected] GOT E@?I T E IN j ?OI JYHKA GOT =@EGIH Tj GMGJ7 HKA? T G Nr\ T IUW K4E@?BAhW.JBHM=@?I T EIl0= ; G VXJBHKG G A GOT = IN = ; GJB? T gEI T = ; G E@W K N HKG G IN= ; GyjDG HKN.E P HKE[HKJRPHOftE<E@WXG ; = ; HM=[? T = ; G H j E GOT G G INzH T fHMV.VXJB? G N N9IK+G G EIl= ; G7 JBHKA GOT =>P IUW.JBN@K G JBH 7 =LIHQJB? T G HKSGJI T.] W K9HM=@?I T r :<; G HM=k=@HKG ; A GOT =LVDIU? T =@E INe= ; G JY? T tE<GIH TjDG N.?BEk=LK+? j Wb= G N7? T IK= ; G KP HfgE ] ?RZt? Tb] = ; G6 JYHKA GOT =dH4V$K G N GXT$G NGIW K@ZMHM=@W K G r IK GJ7 HKAVXJ G l jDG HKN.EGIH TjDG IU? T G N=LI ]G = ; G KyHKJI Tb] H ; G JB?BGIHKJ0VXHM= ; =LIwV$K I Zg?YN G HGJIK@tE@GJK G P[CFE ; HMV G N H ]G JBJYW.A=@HK?BJ=INHA ItN G J j HKGD= G K+?BHtr

Page 182: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

$

a ¦ r zre§SJBJ GOT H T N hrbr : ?BJBN G E@J G fKr MS¢ !#"$%&+r ¥ JBHK GOT N$I T FK G E@EIla % % br

¬ \§\rbr H T G ; ?IwH T N'.r r K+HKNbfKr §yGIG G J G K9HM= G NuEk=LIK G E@?YH T Nbf T HKA?BGIE K IP T ?BH T A IK=@?OI T r)( +* D *-,.&Bl aKa ^ ¬K¬ c BaI_ * ¬ *0/ aO_ * * ¬ l ¬ _K_ * r

*@7r21r HM=@G ; G JOIKOr4357689:%<; ='> ?@#%'AB, M#;C&+r ¥ HKA j K9?BN ]G D T ?RZ G K9E@?B=Ff FK G E@EIla % ®Ur

M@7r21r HM=@G ; G JOIKOr K I P T ?BH T N.?2W.E@?OI T IN[VXHK9=@?BGIJ G E4PS?R= ;; fgN KPIgNbf T HKA?YG? T = G K+HKGD=@?OI T rD( > ?$% E F;C* Bl| Ba / ¬ % l a % M®gr

r r .G G9 G KOlr §\r1 I G ; J G KOl|H T N \r §ir2g=LI T G r T E G JON CV$K IKVXW.JYE@?OI T INeA?BGJK IMCFAHKG ; ? T G ESHM=JIP! G f T IUJBN.E T W.A jDG K xW K+G G JBJ En= ; K G G CFJY? T \E@P>?BAA G KrG( <> ?$%HE F;C* BlU % _ Ba //* gl ¬ _K_ * r

® r r G G@ G K H T N ¦ rbr> ; G JBJ G fKr­ T Ek=@H j ?BJB?B=Ff IN G JBHKE@=@?BG JBHKA GOT =@E? T E ; G HK IPft? G JBN.E K9Ek=C T IK9AwHKJ CFEk=LK G E@E>N.? G K GOT G G EIr *-,.&JI I J YlU Ba % * _ba l ¬ _K_ba r

\r ¥ r G K ] r I P"=LIw=LK+HKG@ j HKGD= G K9?BHtrKI D!;G68L& 8t BlX ¬ K® / U a l a % a r \r ¥ r .G K ] H T N r : W K T G Kr ¥ ; G A IK=@H 7 ?YEIN j HKGD= G K9?BHQ? T] JBHKE9E>GIHMVX?BJYJBHK@fHK K9HOftEIrNMN ¢*O,P& ( YlX % a % / % * _ l a % % _ r

% 70r r ?BEkPHKJH T N§\r zr @LHKEk=Ir ¦ G G ; H T ?YGIE IN~E G A? $GJ7 ? j J G G ; HK? T E N IK9A G N j fwVDIUJRf ^ G = ; ftJ GOT G] JBfgGJIUJ cFCFJY? T G NVXHK9HKAwH ]UT G =@?BGVXHK9=@?BGIJ G EIr *O,P& JI I JQ[lX® _ ¬ a _ ¬ l ¬ _K_ * r

aI_ 0r r ?BEkPHKJ.H T Nw§ir zr(@HKEk=Ir ¦ ?BGJKPIUA? 7 ? Tb] P>?R= ; JB? T G NG ; HK? T E IN0VXHK9HKAH ]UT$G =@?BG<VXHK9=@?BGIJ G EIr3R )+* D YlM® ®qK / ®qsKgl ¬ _K_ br

aKa 0r r ?BEkPHKJbH T N§\r zr(@LHKE@=Ir IK=@HM=@?OI T HKJXN.f T HKAw?BGIEIN2E G A? $GJ7 ? j J G VXHK+HKAH ]UT G =@?BG[V|HK@=@?BGIJ GG ; HK? T EOr *O,P& +I DJQlX® %b^ _ a _ ®Uc+l ¬ _K_ br

a ® a

Page 183: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a ® ¬

a ¬ .r 4r JYHM G H T N §\r : r ¥ ; PH Tb] r W T NXHKA GOT =@HKJSE@? Tb] WXJBHK9?R=@? G E [email protected] IP4r ( QK E * Yl ^ a c ¬ *0/ ¬ % l a % br

a*0r J G ?YJ l \r < r ¦ r ¦ HK KOlH T N ¥ r G G ; ? Tb]G KOr ¦ ?YGJK IUE@GJIKVX?BG7HK@=@? GI?BHKJnEkP>?BAwA G K9EIr $ Il* K® ¬ / K®Kgl ¬ _K_ gr

a M ir : r I TXT G GIH = G H T N.r r K9HKNbfKr~§ A G = ; ItN N IKN G = G K9A? T ? Tb] = ; G G G GD=@?BZ G GJI T N.W.GD=@?RZt?R= fINeN.?YEkV G K9E@?OI T E.INzVXHK@=@?BGIJ G EOr 9:; JI !:; JG % +34lb * _ ¬ K //* a * l a % % _ r

a ir : r I T.T G GIH = G H T N .r r K9HKNbfKr :<; G;G G GD=@?RZ G GJI T N.W.GD=@?BZg?R= f INK+H T N [email protected] GOT E9?OI T EFINE@V ; G K9?BGIHKJ0V|HK@=@?BGIJ G EIr 0; JI :; +G% +34lb * ¬ Ks / s®Kgl a % % a r

a ® ir : r I T.T G GIH = G H T N .r r K9HKNbfKr yf T HKA?BGE9?BA\WXJBHM=@?OI T INH T G J G GD=LK IK ; G IUJOI ] ?BGIHKJ W.?BN2r( +* I *O,P&Bl % ® ^ * c ¬ a *0/ ¬K¬ _ ¬ l a % % ¬ r

a ¥ r K GOT.T GOT H T N \r < ? T G =Ir JBW.?BNA G G ; H T ?BGIE INnV$K IKVXWXJBE@?OI Tj fGI?BJB?BHH T N H ]G JBJBHtrN35< I D +> ?$% E F;C* Bl % * * % //* % gl a % Kr

a \r K GOT.T G Kr :<; G E@JOI PA IK=@?OI T INSH£EkV ; G K G = ; K IUW ] ; H¨[email protected] W.?YN =LI P HK9NXEH¨VXJBH T GE9W K N HKG G r +* D JQ ;Bl a ® ¬ ¬ / ¬ a l a % ® a r

a % h§\r ¥ GIjDG K9EIr J GJ7 ? j J G AH ]UT G =@?BG JBHKA GOT =@EQ? T HvE ; G HK IP4r ( NE NE NE Yl*_K_ ®U

/ _ l ¬ _K_ ®gr

¬ _ h§\r ¥ GIjDG K9EeH T N+rOsHOZMHK?R=@?BEIr GOT N.? T.] IN $GJ7 ? j J G AH ]UT$G =@?BGK ItN.EIr *O,P& I DQl _ _ ¬ a _ bl¬ _K_ br

¬ a h§\r ¥ GIjDG K9EH T N\ rsHOZMHK?R=@?BEIr Sf T HKA?YGIEIN.H $GJ7 ? j J G AwH ]UT G =@?BG G ; HK? T ? T H K IK=@HM=@? Tb] AH ]UT$G =@?BGG JBN2r *-,.&GI DJQlX® % _ ¬ a _ bl ¬ _K_ br

¬K¬ 0r ¥ ; HM=k=LIKVXHKN ; fUHfKl 4r ¦ IUJBN I ZqH T l ¥ r G W Tb] l[H T N \r rxW2rgP>?BAwA? Tb] G wGI? GOT GDf INj HKGD= G K9?BW.A QK&C;* C ;*O r 53H.l aI_ * ^ * Kc Ba * a ¬ / a * a l ¬ _K_ ®gr

¬* \rbr \r ¥ J G K9G 7 H T NE@hr IUE@E9?BEIr ¦ H T fsC j ItNbf G J G GD=LK IUEk=@HM=@?BGh? T = G K9HKGD=@?OI T E<? T@G J G GD=LK IK ; G IUJOI ] C?YGIHKJ W.?BNXEIr *O,P& JI D +Qlb ^ c ¬ ¬ a / ¬ * gl a % % * r

¬ M r ¥ JB?BA GOT =LH T N ¦ r 4r ¦ H 7G fKryW.A G K9?YGIHKJzE9?BA\WXJBHM=@?OI T INK9H T N [email protected] GOT E9?OI T EyHM= XT ?R= GK G f T IUJYN.E T WXA jDG K9EIr 68 ( GE ¢* P& H> el ¬ % U % / ® _ba l ¬ _K_ * r

Page 184: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a ®*

¬ r ¥ JY?BA GOT =Il ¦ r ir ¦ H 7G fKlbH T N @hr r@14HK T ?BHKNXHMg?BEOr yf T HKA?BGIEFIN2E G JNYCFHKE@E G A j J G NG ; HK? T ? Tb]? T AH ]UT G =LIK ; G IUJI ] ?BGIHKJ W.?BN.EIr $ l ¬ _ ^ ¬ c _ / a * l ¬ _K_ br

¬ ® .r ¥ IUE@ELI T l zryW.?R=LIK G J ldH T N ¥ r @LH ]UT I T r I PEkV G K9AHM=LI = IUH£GJIUA G =LI jDG GJI TXT G Nv=LIE9W K N HKG G EIr E4 ? , % * , =P& =.lq K® / ® * l ¬ _K_ * r

¬ 0r r LH T G G l r ¥ JB?BA GOT =Il2H T N ¦ r 4r ¦ H 7G fKr ¥ IUJBJY?BE@?OI T j HK K9? G K G G GD=@E I T = ; Ghj W.JR I P? T H K9H T N IUA#[email protected] GOT E@?I T r *O,P& G> ?@#%P& l a ® ¬ / * a l ¬ _K_ br

¬ 0r r LH T G G H T N ¦ r 4r ¦ H 7 G fKr T GJIK@VDIK9HM=@?OI T IN7JYW j K9?BGIHM=@?I T&G G GD=@Eu? T =LI= ; G N IK9G G CGJIUW.VXJB? Tb] A G = ; IgN@N IK<VXHK9=@?BGIW.JBHM= G = P.IMCV ; HKE Gi I P4r ( MS¢ *O,P& Yl a % ¬ a ¬ / ¬ * gl ¬ _K_ * r

¬ % : r LHK9N GOT l hr FIK@lH T N r G N G K9ELI T r nHK@=@?BGIJ G A G E ; G PHKJBN C<H TuT JOI ] ^ T c>A G = ; ItN N IKG PHKJBNE9W.AE<? T JYHK ]G EkftEk= G AEIr)( +* I *O,P& Yl % ^ a ¬ c BaI_K_ % / aI_K_ % ¬ l a % % * r

*_ ¥ r ;IUA j K IPSEkg?l r ¥ ?BE T G K IUEOler ¥ ; HM=kMH G P4l 4r r @;IUJYN.Ek= G ? T leH T N br r+1 G E@E9J G KOru G JNYCGJI T G GOT =LK9HM=@?I T H T N JYHK ]G CFE@GIHKJ G GJI ; G K GOT G G ? T j HKGD= G K9?YHKJ\Nbf T HKA?YGIEIr *-,.& I I B Yl% * ^&% c _ % aI_ * l ¬ _K_ br

*a zr ;IUA Tb] W G =DC @HK9G Htl~r ¦G JBJ G l .r ¦ r nHKEk=LIKOlH T N ¦ r §\r >W j ?OIbrytGIHKJB? Tb] ? T = ; G H ]K] K G C] HM=@?I T Nbf T HKA?BGIE INeHAH ]UT$G =LIK ; G IUJOI ] ?BGIHKJ W.?YN2r *O,P& JI D GQ[lM® _ a _ * l ¬ _K_ r

*¬ zr r ;IftJ G l-.r ? jDG =k= G lU§ir H T GIHKW.N2lUH T N .r C ry?OI ZfKr. G JON CFHKE@E G A j J G NhAH ]UT G =@?YGAHM=LK+?BG G E

N IK y§ E G VXHK9HM=@?OI T G ; ?RV|EIrK; C; Dl ¬ % ¬K¬ * l ¬ _K_ ¬ r* * ir K G f>N W.EIl br HKW.N K@fKl ¦ r r IKV G Kl ¦ r G K9A? ] ? G KOl ir §\rg=LI T G l2H T NDbr ? j G =k= G r ¦ ? CGJKPIUE@GJIKVX?BG4HK9=@? GI?BHKJ2EkPS?BAA G K9EOr $Dl. * K® ¬ / K®Kgl ¬ _K_ gr

*Mh§\r ? T E@= G ? T r 68. & <& * J* 8,'9 * MN E4M D C r ;IZ G K W j JB? CGIHM=@?I T EIl. T GMrRl a % K®gr

* nr ir H T H T N 4rG14WXAHKOr ?OIUJI ] ?BGIHKJeHMV.VXJB?YGIHM=@?OI T E INVXHK+HKAH ]UT G =@?BG7VXHK9=@?BGIJ G E? T G ; ?RVXEIr T br ¥ ; H Tb] H T N r!1 K9?BG9qHtl G NX?R=LIK9EIl MN0;C*O ¢ F;*O ,Ml VXH ]G E ¬ % a //* _ r yHK9NbP I>ItN§yGIHKN G A?YG xW j JB?BE ; G K+EIl ¬ _K_ba r

*® rbr HKW.GI?H T N §ir ¦ G ;I T HKJYN2r£tV G K+A A IK=@?BJB?B=Ff? T = ; G VK G E GOT G G IN j IUW T N.HK9? G EIr'M) E * JMN# Bl|U ®U % / ® % % l a % % gr

* ¦ r G K+A? ] ? G KOr G K9E I T HKJGJIUAAhW T ?BGIHM=@?I T r ¬ _K_ r

Page 185: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a ®q

* ¦ r ? 7 AwH T r ¥ I T E@=LK9W.GD=@?OI T INJBH Tb]G Zt? T N9IK+G G E ? T = ; G E@?BAhW.JBHM=@?I T IN ; fgN$K IgN.f T HKAw?BG<? T = G KkC

HKGD=@?I T rE O;9M ; &+l a % Ba ¬ _ / a ¬ _ l a % K®gr* % ir r I 7 H T NE@hr r D ; J GOTjDG G@r ¥ I T =LK9? j W.=@?OI T E =LI T I T C G W.?YJB? j K9?YW.A = ; G K+A IgN.f T HKAw?BGIEIrb? r

= ; G IK@f#IN ; fgN$K IgN.f T HKAw?BGIHKJ [email protected]=@?OI T EIr *O,P&J> $#%P&+l a * ^ Uc Ba % *0/ a % _ ¬ l a % _ r _ r ¦ r K9? G N K+?BG ; H T N rW.JY?BG ; G Kr ¥ ; G A IK=@H 7 ?BE IN>EkV G K9A G G JYJBEIr :; 3 ; % );:

@34l aI_ Ba * ¬ K® / a * ¬ ® a l ¬ _K_ r a r ¦ r W K+Ek=yH T N §\r zr @LHKE@=Ir ¦ ?BGJK IUA G G ; H T ?BGIE;INdN.?RVDIUJBHKSG ; HK? T ESW.E9? Tb] IKV.=@?YGIHKJ= P G G = G K9EOr

*O,P& JI D + Yl ¬ ^ ¬ _ c a * _ / a * * l a % % % r ¬ r ¦ r W K+Ek=xH T N§ir zr@LHKEk=Ir yf T HKA?BGIEH T NwJBHM= G K+HKJ|? T = G K9HKGD=@?OI T EFINN.?RVDIUJBHKG ; HK? T EIr *O,P&

I D +QlX® ¬ ^ Uc ® % a ® / ® % ¬ tl ¬ _K_K_ r * r ¦ r W K+Ek=H T N§\r ~r@LHKEk=Ir ¦ ?YGJK IUA G G ; H T ?BGIE.INAH ]UT G =LIK ; G IUJI ] [email protected] GOT E@?I T EIr *O,P& I D +QlX® a ^ ®Uc ®U * ¬ / ®U * % l ¬ _K_K_ r

KM r @LHKW ]G KyH T N \r|g=@[email protected] G [email protected] INeHA?BGJK IUE9GJIKVX?BGHK@=@? GI?BHKJ0EkP>?BAA G KOr *O,P& I D +Ql| _ ¬ a % _ l ¬ _K_ ®gr

s h§\rbr!@;IUJYN.AH T l 4r @7r ¥ I 7 lH T Nir K GOT.T G KOritJIP­[email protected] IK=@?OI T INxHEkV ; G K G V|HK9HKJBJ G J=LIuHVXJYH T G P HKJYJ

/?dA IK=@?OI T = ; K IUW ] ; H gW.? G E@G GOT = W.?YN2r7+* I QK ;Yl ¬K¬ ® * / ®K a l

a % ®Ur s® \r r!@;IUJYN.E@A?R= ; H T Nr @hr ¦ HKELI T r :<; G A?BGJK IK ; G IUJOI ] fINNX?BEkV G K9E@?OI T EIr> T¨ r ir ?OK9?YG ; l

G NX?R=LIKOlI)* F , J* F 8, %3 ¢s¢ #; <&+lXZIUJYW.A G bl.VXH ]G E K / ¬ _ r§SGIHKN G A?BG FK G E@EIla % ®Ur

: r @;IK=LIblG1r yHMqHM=@HtlG1r H j Htl ¦ r y?BE ; ?BA\W$K9HtlXH T N hr ¦ H ] HK9?RfUHKAHtr§ W.?BNtCFNbf T HKA?YG? T = G K@VK G =@HM=@?OI T IN2= ; G HKE@fgAA G =LK9?BG>A IK=@?OI T INE9? Tb] JRf H ]G JBJBHM= G N j HKGD= G K9?YH\EkPS?BAA? T.] GIJOIUE G=LIQH j IUW T N.HK@fKr MN#+¢*O,P& ( Yl% % * K a //* K % l ¬ _K_ gr

¥ r @;IUW j HKWXJR=Il zrIKVl ¦ r G K9A? ] ? G KOl.r HKWXN K@fKl r G K@=LK9H T NlXH T N'.r ? jDG =k= G r J GJ7 ? j J GAwH ]UT G =@?BG JBHKA GOT =@EeHKEnA?BGJK IUA G G ; H T ?YGIHKJgE GOT ELIK9EIr *O,P& <I I < Bl % a ^ ¬ ®Uc ¬ ® _ _ ¬ l ¬ _K_ * r

% r @;K G GOTb] HK9N H T N hr IK ; JB? T rw§ N HKE@=\HKJ ] IK9?B= ; A N IKiVXHK@=@?YGIJ G E@?BAhW.JBHM=@?I T EIr ( HMS¢ *O,P& Yl * * ¬ //* gl a % Ur

Page 186: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a ®K

_ .r yHMV.V G J[H T N ir K GOT.T G KOr J I , %P& Hg CH, % :% ,P M;&+r FK GOT =@?BG G yHKJBJ la % ®Kgr

a @7r G J ]G E GOT l zr x? G K9H T Ekg?lgH T N§\r : r|g G JB=LIK@Vr yf T HKA?BG jDG ; HZg?OIKINzE@?BAV|J G AH ]UT$G =@?BG; IUJ G EkftEk= G AEIr *O,P& JI D G34l. ¬ ^ a ¬ c ¬ a / ¬ _ l a % % _ r

¬ r r G JYE G = ; r G JNYCFHKE@E G A j JBf+INQGJIUJBJOIU?BN.HKJiVfK9HKA?YN.E ? T AH ]UT G =@?BG $G JBNXEIr $ l¬ a ¬ M®

/ ¬ % l ¬ _K_ gr

*.r zr G K T H T N G =DC K@=@?>=Kl .rbrXN G nH j JOIbl|H T N ¦ r \r @;K9H ; HKAr HKEk=yGJIUAVXWb=@HM=@?OI T INdAH T fCV|HK@=@?BGIJ G ; ftN K ItNbf T HKA?BGH T N G J G GD=LKPIUEk=@HM=@?BG? T = G K9HKGD=@?OI T Eh? T H GJI T|T G N ]G IUA G =LK@fKr *O,P& I D + Yl % Ba _ ® _ ¬ l ¬ _K_ r

qM.r zr G K T H T N G =DC K@=@?>=Kl ¥ r @hrg=LIUJR==Kl2H T N ¦ r hr @;K+H ; HKAr : K9H T EkVDIK@=yH T N¨GJIUJBJ G GD=@?RZ G NbfCT HKA?BGIE? T [email protected] GOT E9?OI T E IN.GJI TXT G N\EkP>?BAwA? Tb] VXHK@=@?BGIJ G EIr *O,P&@I I @ Yl % ^ ¬ _ c ¬ _ s _ba l¬ _K_ gr

K : rE ; ?RMHOPH H T N : rbr G N.J G fKr L?0WXE@?OI T INiEkP>?BAwA? Tb] A IgN G JyA?BGJKPIMC?IK ] H T ?BE@AwEQ? T HE G A? CFN.?BJYWb= G E9W.EkV GOT E@?OI T r( G> $#% E F;* YlX * / s® ¬ l ¬ _K_ r

K® : r E ; ?BqHP Htl @hrS G t?RfUHtl hrAHK? lLH T N : r xHKAH ] W.G ; ? r SftN K ItNbf T HKA?BG ? T = G K9HKGD=@?I T EjDG = P G GOT =FP IQEkP>?YAA? Tb]hj HKGD= G K9?YHtrMN+¢*O,P& ( Yl % * ¬K¬ a / ¬K¬K¬ gl ¬ _K_ r

U : rE ; ?RMHOPHtl ¦ r zrSt?BAA I T N.EIl[H T N : rbr G N.J G fKr >ftN K ItNbf T HKA?BG? T = G K9HKGD=@?I T IN\=FP IE@P>?BAA? Tb] A IgN G J2Aw?BGJK IMC?IK ] H T ?YE@AEIr ( G> $#%E F;* BlK® BaKa % / a ® _ l ¬ _K_ ®gr

.r irqELK9H G JBHKG ; Zt?BJB? rL68 C F; %H<$ O; >G9; C&+rb§SGIHKN G A?BG FK G E9EIl ¬G N.?B=@?OI T l a % % ¬ r % .r hrUHKG9gELI T r & &8#; Q F; 0%, M;&+r)I ; T < ?BJ G fQH T N I T EIlb T GMrRl * G N.?R=@?I T l a % % % r® _ @7r r< G G K@fKr :<; G A IK=@?OI T IN G JBJB?RV|ELIU?BN.HKJbV|HK@=@?BGIJ G E?BAA G K9E G Nw? T HiZt?BE@GJIUWXE WX?BN2r 9:; I

:; JJ% 3l aI_ ¬ Ba ® a / a % l a % ¬K¬ r® a hr.r G K G fKr ¥ I T N.W.GD=@?I T = ; KPIUW ] ; H;K9H T N IUA­[email protected] GOT E@?I T IN|EkV ; G K G EIr 9:; <I :; <J%

34l * * * K //* ®Ul a % * r® ¬ @7r rG14HK T ?BHKN.HMt?BEIl ¦ r2ELK9H G JY? lH T Nr §\r K9E=OH ] r y? ] ; C?IK9N G K4E@VXJB?R=k=@? T.] A G = ; ItN.E;N IK4= ; G

? T GJIUAV$K G E9E@? j J G yHOZt? G KkC g=LIK G E G WXHM=@?OI T EIr ( MS¢ *O,P& Yl % a / K * l a % % a r

Page 187: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a ®K®

®* r!14HKE ; G ZtEkgf£H T N hr §ir 14W=OA? T r nHK?OKh? T = G K9HKGD=@?OI T ? T AH ]UT G =@[email protected]@V GOT E@?OI T ELW T N G K\HKPIK=@HM=@? Tb] $G JYN = ; G ? Tb W GOT G G INVXHK9=@?BGIJ G E@W K N HKG G GJI T N.?B=@?OI T EIr( *O,P& A 3 ¢s¢ *O,P& Yl¬ % ¬ U %

/¬ Kgl a % % ®gr

®qM hr r 14HM==Kr T = ; G V$K IKVXW.JYE@?OI T INyA?YGJK IMC?IK ] H T ?BE9AE T G HKwELIUJB?YN j IUW T N.HK9? G EIr ( K> $#%E F;* Bl®q * *0/ _ l a % br

®K 0r@14?YA H T Nr<.r@14HKPK9?BJBHtr E ;:*O, %0%, M;& ; ¢ C& % F; % 3¢U¢ ?#; #L& r;I Z G KW j JB?BGIHM=@?I T EIlt T GMrRl ¬ _K_ gr

®K® hr.r 14JB? T.]GOTsjDG K ] H T N ¥ r r 0W.IUEkg? hr [email protected].? G E I T = ; G E@= G HKNbfsCFE ; G HK jDG ; HZg?OIK ING J G GD=LK IK ; G IUJOI ] [email protected]@V GOT E@?OI T EIr $ l|® Ba / ¬ bl a % % _ r

®U hr.r@14JY? Tb]GOTj G K ] r ¦ H ]UT G =LIK ; G IUJI ] f §SV.VXJY?BGIHM=@?OI T EdH T NQG ; HKJBJ GOTb]G EOr+3 6+*Q( Yl ¬ s® /¬ % l ¬ _K_ba r

® hr.r 14JY? Tb]GOTj G K ] lbr ¥ r DSJB?YG T fKlH T N ¦ r §ir@;IUJBN GOT r ¦ HKELI TuT W.A jDG K9E N9IKyAH ]UT G =LIK ; G IUJ CI ] fKr ( GI)* Bl| M % / K gl ¬ _K_ r

® % hr.r 14JY? Tb]GOTj G K ] l K9H T ZMH T tP.IUJ lH T N ¥ r r 0WbIUE@g? r :>; G E@AHKJYJE ; G HK;K9HM= G K G EkVDI T E GIN G J G GD=LK IK ; G IUJOI ] ?BGIHKJ[[email protected]@V GOT E@?OI T EIr+rxt?BAhW.JBHM=@?I T ? T = ; G VDIU? T =CFN.?RVDIUJ G JB?YA?R=Ir ( +* D *O,P& Yl % ^&% c ® a ® _ / ® a ® % l a % % a r

_ hr.r 14JB? Tb]GOTjDG K ] l K9H T \ZqH T gP.IUJlUH T N ¥ r r 0WbIUEkt? r :<; G E@AwHKJBJE ; G HK K9HM= G K G EkVDI T E G ING J G GD=LK IK ; G IUJOI ] [email protected] GOT E9?OI T EIrg r 7 = GOT E@?OI TjDG fI T N= ; G V IU? T =CFN.?BV IUJ G JB?BAw?R=Ir( K+* D *O,P& Yl % ^&% c ® a _ / ® a tl a % % a r

a h§\rbr ¥ r HKN.Nr ; IK@=7=@?BA G A IK=@?OI T INGJIUJBJIU?BN.HKJ VXHK@=@?BGIJ G E T W.A G K9?BGIHKJE@?BAhW.JBHM=@?OI T Zt?BH£H [email protected]=@? Tb] JYHM=k=@?BG G

/j IUJR==OAH T.T@G gW.HM=@?OI T r *O,P& +I DJ Bl _ ^&% c Ba * * % / a * ¬ l a % % * r

¬ ¦ r ¥ r H ] IUAHK9E@? T Ibl r ¥ HMVXWXH T ? lbH T N ¥ r zr IP G r§­E@?BAhW.JBHM=@?I T E@[email protected] INz= ; G Nbf T HKA?BGIEINeHN$K9?RZ GOT JBHKA GOT =<? T H T HK9?BEk=LIK= G JB?YH T W.?BN2rK( J* F M)# Bl ¬K¬ ¬ a / ¬K¬ bl ¬ _K_ * r

* ¦ r ¥ r H ] IUAHK9E9? T Ibl r nH ] I T H j HK K+H ] HtlH T N ¥ r zr I P G r SfgN KPIgNbf T HKA?YG ? T N.W.G G NN G N9IK9AwHM=@?OI T H T N/IK9? GOT =@HM=@?OI T INHA?BGJK IUE@GJIKV|?BG G JYHKEk=@?BG JBHKA GOT =Ir *O,P& I D Yl% ^ a c Ba aI_ bl ¬ _K_ gr

M r hr H T N.HKWH T N r ¦ r ?ON E ; ?R==Kr J* F , Q P& ;: ,Mr G K ] HKA I T FK G E@EOlU= ; ?OK9N G NX?R=@?OI T la % K®gr

Page 188: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a ®U

M r hr H T NXHKWH T N r ¦ r ?ON E ; ?R==Kr > $#% E F;* <#;C& r G K ] HKA I T l a % % r M® r HKW ] Htr JOIKVXVfEkP>?BAAw? Tb] y?BE9GJIUW.E[JOItGJIUA IK=@?OI T [email protected]= G N G JBHKE@=@?BGIHtr *O,P&GI DGQl

M _ a % a ®gl ¬ _K_ r K r HKW ] Htl < r iry? W=O?OIbl @7r ¦ r < ; ?R= G E@?YN G EIldH T N \r §irg=LI T$G r gP>?BAwA? Tb] ? T GI?K9GIJ G E

¦ IK=@?OI T IN j HKGD= G K9?BH T G HKyELIUJB?BN j IUW T N.HK+? G EIr M)#+¢*-,.&( Bl % _ _K_ / a ¬ l ¬ _K_ ®gr .r ? ] ; = ; ?BJBJ r JBH ]G JYJBHK ; fgN$K IgN.f T HKAw?BGIE :<; G I ; T ZI T G W.AH T.T J G GD=@W K G l a % MgrH@6935E

I D0 el a ^ ¬ c Ba ® a / ¬ * _ l a % M®gr % hr ?BW2l r rG1 G HOZ GOT fKl ¦ r ir ¦ H 7 G fKlnH T N:@hr r+14HK T ?BHKNXHMg?BEOri§ E@V G GD=LK+HKJ G J G A GOT =iH T N

N IK9G G CFGJIUWbV|JB? Tb] A G = ; ItN N IK IP%VXHKEk=*N G JBJY?RVXELIU?BNXHKJVXHK@=@?BGIJ G EOr = '& I % = (

K>¢ *-,.&Bl ¬ _K_ gr _ hr ?YW2l ¦ r 4r ¦ H 7G fKlH T N4@7r r 14HK T ?YHKN.HMg?YEIr ¦ IgN G JB? Tb] H T N IKVX=@?BA?>=OHM=@?OI T INGJIUJYJOIU?BN.HKJ

Aw?BGJK IMCVXW.AVXEIrK( GE ;:K ;C* +ED#;9 C Bl a K®U / UMgl ¬ _K_ br a 0r IUA ; IUJR=SH T N ¦ r 4r ¦ H 7 G fKr IK9G G CFGJIUW.VXJB? Tb] A G = ; ItNN IKyVXHK@=@?BGIW.JYHM= G =FP IMCV ; HKE G7 I P

t=LIK G E I P4r ( MS¢ *O,P& Yl a q * a / _ gl ¬ _K_ * r ¬ 0r IUA ; IUJR=Il rg= GOT WXAl[H T N ¦ r 4r ¦ H 7 G fKr F7 V G K9?YA GOT =@HKJZ G K+? GIHM=@?OI T E INL= ; G N IK9G G

GJIUW.VXJB? Tb] A G = ; IgN@N IK<VXHK9=@?BGIW.JBHM= G I P>EIr68 ( GE ¢* P& H> el ¬ ¬K¬ / ¬ s®gl ¬ _K_ ¬ r * ¥ r ~r IP G ryf T HKAw?BGIE IN JBHKA GOT =@E A ItN G JBJB? T.] = ; G Nbf T HKA?BGIE INnN K9?RZ GOT A?YGJK I JBHKA GOT =@EIr

*O < L& I !0; JJ% M<l * Ba q *0/ a K _ l ¬ _K_ * r qM \r hr fKl r G ?B=@?BG ; l ¦ r 4r IUJBJBfKl \r : r H T gEIl<H T N 1r =LIbr b?BA\WXJBHM=@?OI T E INV|HK@=@?BGIJ G

N.f T HKAw?BGIE[? T AH ]UT G =LIK ; G IUJOI ] ?BGIHKJ W.?BNXEIr( MS¢ *O,P& Yl a K Ba ® _ / a Kl a % % % r K \r ¦ H H T N ¦ r \r @;K9H ; HKAr :<; G IK@f IN7E ; G HKkCF? T N.W.G G N`A? ] K+HM=@?OI T ? T N.?BJYWb= G VDIUJRftA G K

E IUJBWb=@?OI T E T$G HK>ELIUJB?BN j IUW T N.HK9? G EIr *-,.&J> $#%P&+l a _ * aI_ * l ¬ _K_ gr K® 7r ¦ H ] HK9?RfUHKAwHtl ¦ rG ; ? j Htl!1r yHMqHM=@Htl 1r H j Htl : rRl~H T N hr ¦ H ] HK9?BfUHKAHtr§ W.?BNtC

N.f T HKAw?BGS? T = G K@VK G =@HM=@?OI T IN= ; G HKE@fgAA G =LK9?BGLA IK=@?OI T INnE@? Tb] JRf H ]G JBJBHM= G N j HKGD= G K9?YHhE@P>?BA7CAw? Tb] GIJOIUE G =LIQH j IUW T N.HK@fKr MN#+¢*O,P& ( Yl% * ®q //* ®K gl ¬ _K_ gr

U ¦ r ¦ H T.] ; ? lhr hrxtG ; JYH ]Kj G K ]G KOleH T N 4r G ==Kr FK IKVXWXJBE@?OI T PS?R= ; H K IK=@HM=@? Tb],G JYHKEk=@?BGT H T IK ItN2r *O,P&JI DG Bl % ® _ ® aI_ba l ¬ _K_ ®gr

Page 189: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a ® .r r ¦ HK@=@? T H T N 4r §\r~§ T N G K+ELI T r ¥ ; HK? T A ItN G JFIN G J G GD=LK IK ; G IUJOI ] fKr7( B+* D *O,P& Yl

aI_ ^ a ¬ c a / ¬ gl a % % ®gr % .r r ¦ HK9=@? T l 1r ¦ r y?BJBJl H T N ¥ r zr : ? ]K]G EIr ¦ H ]UT$G =@?BG C $G JBNtCF? T N.W.G G N IKV.=@?BGIHKJg=LK9H T E@Aw?R=k=@H T G G

? T GJIUJBJOIU?BN.HKJ2E9W.EkV GOT E@?OI T EIr *O,P& GI I JQ[lX %b^ Uc K®UM®KK® % ¬ l a % % % r % _ r ¦ HK@= T$G =DC G N$K G K Ibl ¦ r : ?OK+HKN IMC ¦ ?K9H T N.HtlL§irLtG ; Aw?R=k=IlH T N br ¥ HKJBJ G HKEC G K T H T N G =Kr

bGIHKJB? Tb] ? T = ; G H ]K] K GI] HM=@?I T Nbf T HKA?BGIE INH AwH ]UT G =LIK ; G IUJOI ] ?YGIHKJ W.?BN2r *O,P& NI D QlM® _baKa _ gl ¬ _K_ r

% a ¦ r 4r ¦ H 7 G fH T N r21r nHM= G J r ItGIHKJB?>= G N N IK9G G K G V$K G E GOT =@HM=@?OI T N IKVXHK@=@?BGIJ G E E G N.?BA GOT =@? Tb]? T g=LIK G E IP4r68 ( GE ¢* P& H> el ¬ Ba ® _ *0/ a ® ¬ ®gl ¬ _K_ba r

% ¬ ¦ r 4r ¦ H 7 G fH T N br.r >?BJ G fKr gW.HM=@?OI T IN~A IK=@?OI T N9IK>HE9AHKJBJ K9? ] ?BNEkV ; G K G ? T H T I T W T ? CN IK9A IP4r *O,P& J> ?$%P& l ¬ ® ^ c *0/ % l a % * r

% * 0r ¦ G JBJ G l r @hr ¥ HKJBN G K I T l ¦ r §\r SW j ?OIblH T N @7r @hr W.JBJ G KOr ¦ ?BGJK IUEk=LK+W.GD=@W K G&G ZIUJBWtC=@?I T ? T AH ]UT$G =LIK ; G IUJOI ] ?BGIHKJ[E9W.EkV GOT E@?OI T E ] IZ G K T$G N j f AwHKELI TT WXA jDG KOr *O,P& KI I KQl® ^ _ a _ * c+l ¬ _K_ * r

% M0r ¦ G JBJ G H T N .r r ¦ HK@=@? T r ¥ ; HK? T A ItN G J;IN\HAH ]UT G =LIK ; G IUJOI ] ?BGIHKJ4E9W.EkV GOT E@?OI T ? T HKPIK=@HM=@? Tb] $G JYN2rK( +* I *O,P&Bl aKa ^ ¬ a c % UM / % a l ¬ _K_ * r

% 0r ¦G JYJ G l ¦ r §ir >W j ?Ibl.H T NE@hr @hr W.JBJ G KOr : ?BA G E@GIHKJB? Tb] K GI] ?BA G E>? T H ]K] K GI] HM=@?OI T INeAH ] CT$G =@?BGN.?RVDIUJBHK VXHK@=@?BGIJ G E tGIHM=k= G K9? Tb] NX?BG ; KPIU?BE@A K G [email protected]=@EIr *O,P& JI D G Yl%U ^ aKa c BaKa K _ba l¬ _K_ba r

% ® \r ¦ IIK G l<1r yZIK9HMIZMHtl|H T N < r K G G N2r 7 G G V.=@?OI T HKJ0EkV G K9A GJI>IKV G K9HM=@?OI T ? T = ; G P I>ItNA IUW.E G r $ Il. a Ba / a Kl ¬ _K_ ¬ r

% hr SHKA?YHKEIr<§>VXVXJB?BGIHM=@?OI T INe= ; G L?OK+HKGiN G JR=@H N W T GD=@?OI T =LI G J G GD=LK9?YGiGIW K K GOT =yH T N AH ]UT$G =@?BGAhW.JR=@?BV IUJ G N.?YEk=LK9? j W.=@?OI T EIr3y ( *O,P& Yl. ^&% c _ *0/ _ ®gl a % % r

% zr ;IUA? T.] W G =DC @LHK9GI?BHtldr ¦ G JBJ G l r @7r ¥ HKJBN G K I T l0H T N ¦ r §\r >W j ?OIbr ;IUW j J G =Nbf T HKA?BGIEINAH ]UT$G =@?>=OH j J G V|HK@=@?BGIJ G EW T N G K N K G W GOT GDfA IgNXW.JBHM= G N K IK=@HM=@? T.] $G JBN.EOr #%P& %@ ; C&R3 *O,P&8#:;C* D +Q G3 &¢ ; & l ¬ _ C ¬ a ¬ _ / ¬ M®gl ¬ _K_ gr

Page 190: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a ® %

% % \ r G =LIUW.E9?BEIl r IUA j W$K ] l ir G K@gEOl|H T N §ir y? G == G J r : K9H T E@? GOT = jDG ; HOZt?OIUW KINeAH ]UT$G =@?BGAw?BGJK I

/jDG HKNG ; HK? T EK IK=@HM=@? T.] ? T H W.?BN j f GJ7 = G K T HKJ $G JYN.EIr +*O ¢|l Ba s® / a M a l

¬ _K_ r aI_K_ \ r hrx?BZt? T l zr \r >?BG ; HK9N.E I T lH T N @hr rN14HK T ?BHKN.HMt?BEIr JOIIgN IPZ G JOIgGI?B=Ff G G GD=@E

H T N K IUJ G INSHKGD=@?RZMHM=@?OI T N G JBHOfv=@?BA G I T] K I P<= ; H T N N IK9A IN>VXJYHM= G J G == ; K IUA j ? r 3H.laI_* ^ s®Uc Ba a ®q

/a a ® % l ¬ _K_ ®gr

aI_ba ¥ r I = K9?Rt?BN.?YEIr M5$% , % &8 , *$:%P& C ? F%0 &C; -&K er¥ HKA j K+?BN ]G D T ?RZ G K9E@?B=Ff K G E@EIl a % % ¬ r

aI_ ¬ .r ir r FK IUA?YE@JOIPilM§\r zr @LHKEk=IlsH T N ¦ r G K9A? ] ? G KOrb§ ]K] K GI] HM=@?I T g? T$G =@?BGIE IN.VXHK9HKAH ]UT$G =@?BGGJIUJYJOIU?BN.HKJ0VXHK9=@?BGIJ G EIr ( +* D *O,P& Yl aI_ ¬ ^ a * c q % ¬ / q % gl a % % gr

aI_* r ¦ r xW K9G G JYJ r ?ON G HM=>JOI P G f T IUJBN.E T W.A jDG KOr 3y ( *O,P& Ylbs ^ a c *0/ aKa l a % Kr

aI_ M ¦ r >HKA?YHtl hr r : W.JBJOItG@lH T N \r ; H T C :<; ? GOT r :<; G K IUJ G IN ; ftN K ItNbf T HKA?BGi? T = G K+HKGD=@?OI T? T = ; G JOItGJIUA IK=@?OI T INeA?YGJK I>IK ] H T ?BE@AEOrMN#+¢*O,P& ( Yl|®K MK / K gl a % % * r

aI_ h§\r >?BN.H H T N ¦ r §ir ¦ r @L? EIr ¦ H T ?RVXW.JYHM=@?OI T INiE G JON CFHKE@E G A j J G N&Ek=LK9W.GD=@W$K G E IN4AH ]UT$G =@?BGjDG HKN.EN9IK>Aw?BGJK I W.?YN.?BG>Aw? 7 ? Tb] H T NHKE@E@Hfg? T.] r35 )+* I BlM® ® ¬

* % / ® ¬ s®gl ¬ _K_ br aI_ ® \ r \r >? G N G J lL1r<1 K9W.E G ltH T N'br IPHK9N2rx§ E G JON C?IK ] H T ? = G NZIK@= GJ7 HK K9Hf IN ; ftN K ItNbf T HKA7C

?YGIHKJBJRf GOT =LK9HK? T$G NEkV G K9A G G JBJBEOr ; C; Dl * _ %b^ U * ¬ c * _K_ //* _ * l ¬ _K_ gr aI_ ¦ r IKV G KOl ir ;K G f>N W.EIl br HKW.N$K@fKl ¦ r G K+A? ] ? G KOl br ? jDG =k= G l0H T N \r §irg=LI T G r T = ; G

N.f T HKAw?BGIEINAwH ]UT G =@?BGIHKJBJRfN$K9?RZ GOT G JYHKEk=@?BG JBHKA GOT =@EIr( > ?@#% E F;* BlbKq Ba ®U / a % _ l ¬ _K_ ®gr aI_ ir r IUE GOT EkP G ? ] r> C *O, %0%, M;&+r ;I Z G KW j JB?BGIHM=@?I T EIlg T GMrRl a % % r aI_ % < r r >W.E9E G J l \r §\rtHOZt?BJBJ G lH T N < r 4rtG ; IPHKJR= G KOr' % +AH &¢ C8&8#L&+r ¥ HKA j K9?BN ]G

D T ?RZ G K+E@?R=Ff FK G E@EIl a % % r aKaI_ hr|tHK? T =@?BJYJBH T H T N ¦ rbr| ; G JBJ G fKr K+? GOT =@HM=@?I T HKJ IK9N G K<H T N? T E@=@H j ?BJB?R=@? G Ed? T [email protected] GOT E9?OI T EFIN

E G JONYCFJIgGJIUA IK=@? Tb] K ItN.EIr *-,.&GI DJ Bl % %b^ Uc _ aI_ ¬ l ¬ _K_ r aKaKa \rs ; HK9AwHSH T N \r §\r nHM=@H T MHKOr L?OK G GD= T W.A G K+?BGIHKJE9?BA\WXJBHM=@?OI T INX= ; Gj K I P T ?BH T A IK=@?OI T IN

V|HK@=@?BGIJ G E j fW.E@? Tb] [email protected]=@? Tb] ; ftN K ItNbf T HKA?BG G gW.HM=@?OI T EOr ( MS¢ *-,.&Bl ¬ _ba s®K® / K®gl¬ _K_ br

Page 191: BDC - Brown University · 2017-09-13 · 4 >< bdc x y

a _

aKa ¬ ir §ir~b?BA ; HQH T Nr >HKAHKEkPHKA\fKr SfgN$K IgN.f T HKAw?BG W.GD=@WXHM=@?OI T ELH T N£? T E@=@H j ?BJB?R=@? G E<? T IKkCN G K G [email protected]@V GOT E@?OI T E.INeE G JON CV$K IKV G JBJ G NQVXHK@=@?BGIJ G EIr *O,P&JI DG Bl %b^ Uc _ aI_ba l ¬ _K_ ¬ r

aKa*@7rs r : HfgJIKOr§ T HKJRftE@?BEIN0= ; G EkP>?BAAw? Tb] IN0Aw?BGJK IUE@GJIKVX?YGIK ] H T ?BE9AEIr 0; I :; J% 34l ¬ _ % K / s® a l a % a r

aKa M@7r r : HfgJOIKr :<; G HKGD=@?OI T INtP HZg? T.] GDfgJY? T N K9?YGIHKJ =@HK?YJBE? T V$KPIKV G JYJB? Tb] A?BGJK IUE@GJIKV|?BG IK ] H T ?YE@AEIr 0; +I :; G % J34l ¬ aKa ¬K¬ / ¬ * % l a % ¬ r

aKa h§\r21r dW.V.VXW2lb§\r §ir @HK9GI?BHtlXH T N ¦ r §\r yHOf G EIr y?BN G IA?BGJK IUE@GJIKVgf#INzN.f T HKAw?BGIHKJBJRfwH ]K] K G C] HM= G N¨V|HK9HKAH ]UT G =@?BG\VXHK@=@?YGIJ G G ; HK? T Ey? T H T HMV.VXJB? G N@K IK=@HM=@? Tb] AH ]UT G =@?YG $G JYN2r $ la % K®qs® / K®K * l ¬ _K_ * r

aKa ® ¥ r ir < ? ]K] ? T EH T N 4r r8@;IUJBNXEk= G ? T r J GJ7 ?RZ G H T N¨V$K IKV|W.JBE@?RZ G Nbf T HKA?BGIE IN G JBHKE@=@?BGIHHM=JIP G f T IUJYN.E T W.A jDG KOr *O,P& JI I J Yl _ ^ a Kc * U % //* ¬ l a % % gr

aKa ¥ r ir < ? ]K] ? T EIl hr S?RZ G JB? T$G l §\r =k=IlSH T N ir r @;IUJBNXEk= G ? T r : K9HMV.VX? T.] H T N P>? ]K] JB? Tb] JBHKEk=LI ; fgN$K IgN.f T HKAwGI?BE INzN$K9?RZ GOT A?BGJKPI JBHKA GOT =@EIrMN ¢*O,P& ( Yl| BaI_ *0/ aI_ ® _ l a % % gr

aKa ¥ r < r < IUJ ]G A\W.= ; l : r 4r IP G K9EIltH T N ir r @ IUJBN.Ek= G ? T r : P>?K9JB? Tb] H T NP ; ?OK9JB? Tb] y?BE9GJIUW.EN.f T HKAw?BGIE INK IK=@HM=@? Tb] G JYHKEk=@?BG JBHKA GOT =@EIr *O,P& JI D + Ylq ^ Kc Ba ® ¬ *0/ a ® ¬ ®gl ¬ _K_K_ r

aKa % hr ¦ r < I>IUJBJ G fKr ¦ IK=@?YJB?R=Ff IN~EkV G K9AHM=LI = IUHhHM= E@W$K N HKG G EOr I ¢ :% L; .l a ¬ ® ¬ % / ¬ _ l ¬ _K_ * r a ¬ _ 1C ¦ r G Ibr G K9ELI T HKJGJIUAwA\W T ?BGIHM=@?OI T r ¬ _K_ gr a ¬ a : r<0r xW2l r HKW ] HtlyH T N`§\r r IUE IU? r 7 V G K9?BA GOT =@HKJy? T Z G E@=@? ] HM=@?OI T E IN G JYHKEk=@?BGu=@HK?BJ

VK IKVXW.JBE9?OI T HM=>JOIP G f T IUJBN.E T W.A j G Kr *O,P& J> ?$%P& l a _ % a _ba l ¬ _K_ ®gr a ¬K¬ \ r 7r zr 0?BHtl ir @hr ¥ I 7 l.H T N 0r @hr ¦ HKELI T r K9N G K G NH ]K] K GI] HM= G E INzVXHK@=@?BGIJ G E[? T E ; G HK I P4r

0; +I :; G % J34l * _K_ ¬ a / K a l a % ®Ur