Upload
blaise09
View
227
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
1/23
!"#$"% '"#()*"$"% )#+ ,#(-*-./
0)1-2 3"14
5-64 7#89"6$8(/% :-6-#(-
;2$(6)1(" #$%&' $( )*&'&+,-,.$+ -*& $(,&+ )$'.,&% ,$ -//$00$%-,& 1*&2&3' )4556&7
89.6$'$)9&*' %.((&*: 9$;&& ,9&0 ,$ ?& ($*0-66= .+%.+$; ,9-, #-*> 1&6, ;-' R&&) N9*$-,: -+% +&.,9&*
%.% ,9& )4?6./ 4+,.6 KFFZ: &6&
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
2/23
K
N9*$-, ;-' - ,*-.,$* -+% ,9-, #-*> 1&6, ;-' +$, - ,*-.,$*7 N9.' 04/9 X ,->& ,$ ?& (-.*6=
4+/$+,*$& CDEEKI: -+% B4*2& CKFFZI7 X, .%&+,.(.&' 0$%&'
$( )*&'&+,-,.$+ ;.,9 %$*%$%: -?',*-/, '&0-+,./ &+,.,.&' ,9-, '&*' ,$ ?-+.'9 '&+'&' .+ (-
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
3/23
a
@2*-')A '&+'&': #-*2$6.' -+% J-4*&+/& ;$**= ,9-, ,9&*& -*& +$ )6-4'.?6& -//$4+,' $( ;9-, ,9&
2*-').+2 *&6-,.$+ /$46% ?&7 B= /$+,*-',: ?&/-4'& #&+,-6&'& '=0?$6' &V.', -' ,$>&+' .+ ,9.+>&*'3
?*-.+': ,9&= 0-.+,-.+ ,9-, ,9&*& .' +$ /$**&')$+%.+2 )*$?6&0 -?$4, 9$; ,9.+>&*' -*& *&6-,&% ,$
#&+,-6&'& '=0?$6'7 N94': #-*2$6.' -+% J-4*&+/& /$+/64%& ,9-, '&+'&' -*& 4+'4.,-?6& ,$ '&*
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
4/23
]
1*&2& (-0$4'6= 0-.+,-.+&% ,9-, '&+'&' -*& -?',*-/, $?O&/,' &V.',.+2 .+ +&.,9&* ,9& )9='./-6 *&-60 $(
@,9.+2'A +$* .+ ,9& 0&+,-6 *&-60 $( @.%&-'A C:")%+$44/*;$*I: ?4, .+ - @,9.*% *&-60A ,9-, .' *&0.+.'/&+,
$( 86-,$3' 9&- $( - ,9.*% *&-60
%.'/$0(.,.+27 W$; /$46% ,9&*& ?& ,9&'& ,9.+2': '&+'&': ;9./9 &V.', $4,'.%& $( ')-/& -+% ,.0&: .+
+&.,9&* ,9& 0.+% +$* ,9& )9='./-6 ;$*6%c X( ;& -%0., ,9& &V.',&+/& $( '&+'&': -*&+3, ;& /$00.,,&%
,$ &&*.& &+,.,.&'c
X, .' .0)$*,-+,: 9$;&
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
5/23
Z
,9&*& .' ,$ '4))$'& ,9-, && +40?&*' $* 86-,$+./ ($*0'A CKFFL: ZHFI7 X+
,9&.* 7 B4, ,9.' 2*-').+2 *&6-,.$+ /-+ -))&-* 0=',.(=.+27 P' #-*2$6.' -+%
J-4*&+/& ;*.,&:
e6&-*6=:;),%(-*; .' - 0&,-)9$* ($* - /$2+.,.
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
6/23
d
'4))$'&% ,$ (-66 $4,'.%& ,9& *&-60 $( )9='./-6 /-4'&' -+% &((&/,'7 B4, .( .,3' +$, /-4'-6: ,9& +-,4*& $(
,9& *&6-,.$+ *&0-.+' 4,,&*6= 0=',&*.$4'7 CKFFL: ZHFI
X ,9.+> ,9-, #-*2$6.' -+% J-4*&+/& -*& 0$,.&+&% .+ ,9& ?*-.+7 X+ &-/9 /-'& ,9& ,$>&+ ;.66 ?& 6$/-,&% .+ ')-/& -+% ,.0&:
,9$429 ;9&*&-' - ,$>&+ $( ,9& ;$*% @*&%A 0.29, /$+'.', $( -+ -**-+2&0&+, $( .+> 0-*>.+2': - ,$>&+
$( ,9& #&+,-6&'& '=0?$6 T[R0.29, /$+'.', $( - )-,,&*+ $( +&4*-6 (.*.+2'7
Q9.6& ,9& \4&',.$+ $( 9$; #&+,-6&'& '=0?$6' -*& *&6-,&% ,$ ,9&.* *&(&*&+,' .' 0$*&
/$+,*$&+&%7a1$* *&%4/,.&*' /$46% ?& *&6-,&% ,$ ,9&07 U$* ;$46% ,9&*& ?& -+= /$+/&*+ .(
'&+'&' ;&*& 6.>& #&+,-6&'& '=0?$6' .+ -%0.,,.+2 $( - ,=)&M,$>&+ *&6-,.$+7 N9& ;$**= &V&*/.'.+2
aN9.' .' -+ $& $(
-*240&+,: ,9-, '$0&,9.+2 6.>& 1$%$*3' -'=00&,*./ %&)&+%&+/& ,9&$*= /-+ ?& 0-%& ,$ ;$*>: -+% ,94' ,9-,
*&%4/,.&*' -*& *&6-,&% ,$ *&(&*&+,'7
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
7/23
L
#-*2$6.' -+% J-4*&+/& .' ,9-, ,9.+>&*' -*& +$, *&6-,&% ,$ '&+'&' .+ &.,9&* $( ,9&'& ;-='7 N9&
@2*-').+2A *&6-,.$+ ,9-, ,9.+>&*' -*& -66&2&% ,$ ',-+% .+ ,$;-*%' '&+'&' ,94' *&0-.+' @4,,&*6=
0=',&*.$4'A7
1$66$;.+2 1$%$* CDEEH: DLMKDI: #-*2$6.' -+% J-4*&+/& .'$6-,& - /$+'&\4&+/& $( ,9& (-.64*&
,$ &V)6./-,& ,9& 2*-').+2 *&6-,.$+7 N9&= -*24& ,9-, 1*&2&-+' 9-&+.+2 ,9&0: ,9& ;$**= ,9-, ,9&*& 0.29, ?& %.((&*&+, ;-=' $( 2*-').+2 - 0$%& $(
)*&'&+,-,.$+ +&& ., -' $? 6.>&7
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
8/23
H
@= A)68"(8"$ -B '8#+CD#+"E"#+"#1"
P' ;& 9- !-*#C-*#$($*#$*+O4', .+ /-'& ., .' )$''.?6& ($* 0$*& ,9-+ $+& 0.+%
,$ ?& &).',&0./-66= *&6-,&% ,$ i7 N94': ,9& ;&-,9&*: ,9& 6-;' $( )9='./': -+% 0-,9&0-,./-6 ,9&$*&0'
-*& -66 &).',&0./-66= 0.+%M.+%&)&+%&+, '.+/& 0$*& ,9-+ $+& )&*'$+ /-+ >+$; -?$4, ,9&07
e$++$; ;9-, =$4* $;+ '&+'-,.$+' -*& 6.>&7
1*&2& /6&-*6= 0-.+,-.+' ,9-, 0$', '&+'&' -*& &).',&0./-66= 0.+%M.+%&)&+%&+,: ,->.+2 /-*& ,$
/$+,*-', ,9&0 ;.,9 .%&-' C*$4296=" 0&+,-6 .0-2&'I: ;9./9 9& & 4'
&* 9-' - 4+.\4& ;-= $(
,9.+>.+2 -?$4, 9&*'&6( ,9-, .' 4+-
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
9/23
E
(-.6' ,$ %.',.+24.'9 '&+'&' (*$0 #&+,-6&'& '=0?$6': -+% '$ /-++$, ?& ;9-, 0->&' '&+'&' 4+.\4&6=
)*$?6&0-,./7
?@? E,/%,4 2-*#CD*#$($*#$*8$
P+$,9&* ,=)& $( 0.+%M.+%&)&+%&+/& .' /-4'-6: ;9&*& i .' 8,/%,44> !-*#C-*#$($*#$*+O4', .+ /-'& i
/-++$, &+,&* .+,$ /-4'-6 *&6-,.$+' ;.,9 -+=,9.+2 0&+,-67 B&/-4'& '&+'&' -*& -?',*-/, $?O&/,': -+%
,94' +$, 6$/-,&% .+ ,9& /-4'-6 (*-0&;$*> $( ')-/& $* ,.0&: ., .' 4+/$+,*$&+' $* ,=)&'I7
#$', 1*&2&-+' 9$6% ,9-, '&+'&' -*& *"+-+-6=,./-66= 0.+%M.+%&)&+%&+, &.,9&*7 P' B4*2&
;*.,&' $( '&+'&': @N9&.* -?',*-/, .%&+,.,.&' -*& +$, .+%&)&+%&+, $( )-,,&*+' $( -/,.&*' .+
,.0&A CKFFZ: ZHI7 Y4* ?&', -+-6='.' $( ;9-, '&+'&' -*& -))&-6' ,$ ,9.+>&*' -+% ,9&.* -/,.
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
10/23
DF
(*$0 k^k $+6= .+ ,9& '4?',.,4,.$+ $( N ($* ^ -, $+& $* 0$*& )6-/&'I7 N94': '.+/& ., .' )$''.?6& ,$
*-,.$+-66= ?&6.&& 9$6%' ,9-, 2*-').+2 ,9& '&+'& ,*#.'
- 0-,,&* $( (.+%.+2 ,9& ($66$;.+2 .+(&*&+/&' )*.0.,.&*' (.+% )*.0.,.
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
11/23
DD
^.+/& +&.,9&* '&+'&' +$* #&+,-6&'& '=0?$6 ,=)&' -*& -+-6=,./-66= 0.+%M.+%&)&+%&+,: ;&
9-' -+% ,*&&'7 B4, ,9&*& -*& -6'$ 0-+= -?',*-/, $?O&/,' ,9-, -*&
)6-4'.?6= $+,$6$2./-66= 0.+%M.+%&)&+%&+,: '4/9 -' ,9& +40?&* ,;$7 X+ (-/,: &&*7 N*4& ,9$429,' -*& #-%8"9$)$#: +$, .+&;.'&: 86-,$+.',' ;.66 0-.+,-.+
,9-, #&+,-6&'& '=0?$6 ,=)&' -*& $+,$6$2./-66= 0.+%M.+%&)&+%&+, ?&/-4'& ,9&= /-+ &V.', ;.,9$4,
?&.+2 .+',-+,.-,&%b-+% -' ;& 9-
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
12/23
DK
$+,$6$2./-66= 0.+%M.+%&)&+%&+,7 N9.' /-,&2$*= -66$;' 4' ,$ %*-; - %.',.+/,.$+ ?&,;&&+ ,;$ ,=)&' $(
$+,$6$2./-66= 0.+%M.+%&)&+%&+, -?',*-/, $?O&/,'7
Y+ ,9& $+& 9-+%: ,9&*& -*& -?',*-/, 4+.& #&+,-6&'& '=0?$6 ,=)&' .+ ?&.+2
',*$+26= $+,$6$2./-66= 0.+%M.+%&)&+%&+,7 P' - *&'46,: 2*-').+2 - '&+'& /-++$, ?& - 0-,,&* $(
,$>&+.+2 - ,=)& $* .+',-+,.-,.+2 - )*$)&*,=: 6&-
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
13/23
Da
CDIX( '&+'&' -*& ?$,9 /-4'-66= 0.+%M.+%&)&+%&+, -+% ',*$+26= $+,$6$2./-66= 0.+%M.+%&)&+%&+,:
,9& 2*-').+2 *&6-,.$+ ,9-, ,9.+>&*' -*& -66&2&% ,$ ',-+% .+ ,$;-*%' '&+'&' .' 0=',&*.$4'7
CKI^&+'&' -*& /-4'-66= 0.+%M.+%&)&+%&+,7
CaI
^&+'&' -*& ',*$+26= $+,$6$2./-66= 0.+%M.+%&)&+%&+,7
N94':
C]IN9& 2*-').+2 *&6-,.$+ ,9-, ,9.+>&*' -*& -66&2&% ,$ ',-+% .+ ,$;-*%' '&+'&' .' 0=',&*.$4'7
N9& -*240&+, .' /6&-*6= & )*&0.'& CKI ,$ ?& 4+/$+,*$&+.+2h.+',-+,.-,.$+ 0$%&67 X( '&+'&': -'
-?',*-/, $?O&/,': -*& /-4'-66= 0.+%M.+%&)&+%&+,: ,9& (.*', 0$%&6 /-+3, -))6= ,$ ,9&0G -+% .( '&+'&':
-' -?',*-/, )-*,./46-*': -*& ',*$+26= $+,$6$2./-66= 0.+%M.+%&)&+%&+,: ,9& '&/$+% 0$%&6 /-+3, -))6=
,$ ,9&07 N94': .( '&+'&' -*& ?$,9 /-4'-66= -+% ',*$+26= $+,$6$2./-66= 0.+%M.+%&)&+%&+, ;& -*& 6&(,
+$ &V)6-+-,.$+ $( ;9-, 2*-').+2 - '&+'& /$46% ?&7
N9&*& .': 9$;&&, /$46%+3, )$''.?6= ,$,-6 (.&, -*& +$, /-4'-66= *&6-,&% ,$
,9& +40?&* (..+ ,$ ,9-, ?&,;&&+ - 4+.
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
14/23
D]
+40?&* KH .' +$, ,$>&+&% $* $,9&*;.'& .+',-+,.-,&% .+ ,9& -.*: +$* .' ,9& (*-/,.$+ ,;$M,9.*%'
.+',-+,.-,&% .+ 0= +.29,',-+%7H^$ ,9&*& 9-' ,$ ?& '$0& ;-= $( ?&.+2 *&6-,&% ,$ -?',*-/, )-*,./46-*'
,9-, .' +$, - 0-,,&* $( /-4'-,.$+ $* .+',-+,.-,.$+7 N9& \4&',.$+ ,94' -*.'&'" /$46% ,9.+>&*' +$, ?&
*&6-,&% ,$ '&+'&' .+ ,9& '-0& ;-= ,9-, $?O&/,' -+% 0-2+.,4%&' -*& *&6-,&% ,$ +40?&*'c
N9& -+';&* ;.66 '4*&6= %&)&+% $+ 9$; ;& 4+%&*',-+% ,9& *&6-,.$+ ?&,;&&+ $?O&/,' $*
0-2+.,4%&' -+% +40?&*'7 N9.' .' - ' $4, ,9-, ,9&*& .' -+ $*%&*6= 0-)).+2 ?&,;&&+ ,9&.* ',*4/,4*&'7 P' - *&'46,: ;&
/-+ -*#$P$?O&/,' -+% 0-2+.,4%&' ,$ +40?&*' $+/& ;& '&,,6& $+ - /*.,&*.$+ $( .+%.&;.'& $)&+ ,$ ,9& )*$)$+&+, $(
'&+'&' ,$ 0-.+,-.+ ,9-, ,9& 0.+%' $( ,9.+>&*' 9-&, 0.29, .+',-+,.-,&
- )-*,./46-* /-*%.+-6.,=: ,9&= %$ +$, .+',-+,.-,& ,9& +-,4*-6 +40?&* ,9-, ;& -''$/.-,& ;.,9 ,9-, /-*%.+-6.,=7 X+
-+= /-'&: +$,9.+2 ,4*+' $+ ,9.' .''4&7 [
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
15/23
DZ
$,9&*'c #.29, ,9&*& ?& /$+'.%&*-?6& .+%&,&*0.+-/= .+ 9$; '&+'&' -*& .+%&V&% ,$ ,9.+>&*'c #=
)*&'&+, )$.+,: 9$;&& +40?&*': -+% +40?&*' /-+ ?& 9&6)(466= .+%&V&% ,$ $?O&/,' -+% 0-2+.,4%&': ,9&
\4&',.$+ -, 6&-', %&'&*.+2 ;9&,9&* ,9.+>&*' /-+ ?& 9&6)(466= .+%&V&% ,$ '&+'&'7 Y+6= .( ;&
;&*& /$+(.%&+, ,9-, ,9& -+';&* .' @+$A ;$46% ;& 9-& )-.+(46+&''
-+% #&+,-6&'& '=0?$6 ,=)&': -+% '$ ,9&*& ;$46% ?& +$ ')&/.-6 $?',-/6& ,$ &V)6-.+.+2 ,9& 2*-').+2
*&6-,.$+7 N$ 2*-') - '&+'& ;$46% O4', ?& ,$ .+',-+,.-,& - 4+.&*
/-+ 2*-') - '&+'& -, +&
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
16/23
Dd
P '&/$+% )$''.?.6.,= ,->&' '&+'&' ,$ ?& /-)-/.,.&' $* -?.6.,.&': -+% ,9& 2*-').+2 $( - '&+'& ,$
?& ,9& .+',-+,.-,.$+ $( - /-)-/.,= $* -?.6.,=7ECP2-.+: ,9& .+',-+,.-,.$+ $( -+ -?.6.,= .' ,$ ?&
%.',.+24.'9&% (*$0 ,9& &V&*/.'& $( -+ -?.6.,=7 P, ,9& )*&'&+, 0$0&+, =$4 9-' ,9-, f$9+ .' 9-))= -+% ,9-, W-**= .' 9-))= &V&*/.'&' $+ ,;$ $//-'.$+' ,9&
/$+/&),4-6 -?.6.,= ;9./9 ;& /-66 n)$''&''.+2 ,9& /$+/&), $( 9-)).+&''37 P+% '.0.6-*6= '$0&$+& ;9$
,9.+>' ,9-, f$9+ .' 9-))= -+% ,9-, f$9+ .' '-% &V&*/.'&' $+ ,;$ $//-'.$+' - '.+26& -?.6.,=: ,9& -?.6.,= ,$
,9.+> $(: $* ,9.+> -?$4,: f$9+7 C[
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
17/23
DL
4+&\4. $( ., -' ,9& '4//&''$* $( $+&: -' ,9& $+6= &
DF8&*9-)' B4*2& CKFFZ: KE`aFI /$0&' ,9& /6$'&',7 T&)6=.+2 ,$ ,9& ;$**= ,9-, ,9& 2*-').+2 *&6-,.$+ .'
0=',&*.$4': 9& /$00&+,' ,9-, ,9& @*$6&A $( '&+'&' .' ,$ @,=)&M.%&+,.(= &V)6-+-,$*= >.+%'A: .+/64%.+2
)'=/9$6$2./-6 /-)-/.,.&': ',-,&': -+% &.+% -+% .,' .+',-+/&'7
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
18/23
DH
-?$4, ,9& '&+'& ,*#b.7&7: 9& 6-/>' ,9& %.')$'.,.$+ $* -?.6.,= ,$ ,9.+> -?$4, ,9& %.')$'.,.$+ $* -?.6.,=
,$ %*-; ,9& .+(&*&+/&' -''$/.-,&% ;.,9 ,9& .+,*$%4/,.$+ -+% &6.0.+-,.$+ *46&' ($* /$+O4+/,.$+7 Y+/&
,9.' %.',.+/,.$+ ?&,;&&+ 2*-').+2 - '&+'& -+% ,9.+>.+2 -?$4, - '&+'& .' >&), (.*06= .+ 0.+%: ,9&*& .'
+$ $?',-/6& ,$ 4'.+2 '&+'&' ,$ %.',.+24.'9 /$M*&(&*&+,.-6 /$+/&),'7
N*&-,.+2 '&+'&' -' -?',*-/, 4+.&+ %.',.+/,.$+A CKFFL: ZHE: +7
LG '&& -6'$ ^4,,$+ KFF]I7 ^$ )&*9-)' ,9&= *&-'$+ ,9-, ,9&*& .' +$,9.+2 6&(, ($* '&+'&' ,$ ?& ?4,
-?',*-/, )-*,./46-*'7 X( ,9.' .' ,9&.* *&-'$+.+2: 9$;&
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
19/23
DE
*&6-,.$+7 ^$ )&*9-)' #-*2$6.' -+% J-4*&+/& -*& 0$,.
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
20/23
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
21/23
KD
)9='./-6 $?O&/,'7 N9& +-,4*-6+&'' $( ,9& (.*', 0$%& $( .+%.& ., )*.0-*=: ?4, ,9&
'&/$+% 0$%& $( .+%.+$; &+$429 -?$4, ,9&0 .+ $*%&* ,$ &V)6./-,& ,9&.*
+-,4*&' &V/&), ?= *&6-,.$+ ,$ $4* $;+ 0.+%'7 B4, -, ,9& '-0& ,.0&: +$* /-+ X ,9.+> $( -+= *&-'$+ ,$
,->& ,9.' )$''.?.6.,= '&*.$4'6=7
J.>& #-*2$6.' -+% J-4*&+/&: X 9-
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
22/23
KK
4+%&*',-+%.+2 $( '&+'&' /$0&' (*$0 ,9& 0&+,-6 -/,.&*'7 X+ $,9&* ;$*%': ,9& )*$?6&0 .'
+$, 9$; '&+'&' -' -?',*-/, )-*,./46-*' /-+ ?& 2*-')&%: ?4, ;9= ,9& &+,.*&,= $( $4* >+$;6&%2& $(
,9&0 %&*. ,$ +40?&*' ($* ,9&.* 0$%&6 $( 0&+,-6 /$+,&+,': ?4, ,$
-?.6.,.&': %.')$'.,.$+': $* $,9&* 4+.&*' .+ 04/9 ,9& '-0& ;-=: -' - 4+." YV($*% S+." YV($*% S+.
8/11/2019 Beck. Sense, Mentalese, And Ontology
23/23
Ka
_*.)>&: ^7 DELK7 U-0.+2 -+% U&/&''.,=7 X+ G$!,*+-8% "' T,+/),4 S,*;/,;$: &%.,&% ?= R7 R-