Between Life and Death Fr. Scott Binet MD, MI CTF-SOS D RS Sao
Paulo, Brazil - October 20, 2011
Slide 2
Inform you about cholera and what the Camillians are doing to
respond to the signs of the times through disaster relief Sensitize
you to the suffering of those affected by man- made and natural
disasters such as cholera Inspire you to get involved and dialogue
amongst yourselves and with me about how we might collaborate in
disaster relief
Slide 3
Cholera Between Life and Death
Slide 4
Presentation Outline 1.Summary of Cholera 2.Introduction to the
Camillian Task Force (CTF) 3.A Convergence Camillians, Disasters
and Risk 4.Disasters and Cholera - the World, Brazil 5.Cholera
Cause, Symptoms, Treatment, Prognosis 6.The Cholera Epidemic in
Haiti 7.Questions/Comments
Slide 5
Cholera - Summary Cholera is an infection of the small
intestine that is caused by the bacterium Vibrio cholerae.
Transmission occurs primarily when drinking water or food is
contaminated by the diarrhea from an infected person or by the
feces of an infected but asymptomatic person. The main symptoms are
profuse watery diarrhea and vomiting. The severity of the diarrhea
and vomiting can lead to rapid dehydration and electrolyte
imbalance. Primary treatment is with oral rehydration solution
(ORS) and if this is not tolerated, intravenous fluids. Antibiotics
are beneficial in those with severe disease. Worldwide it is
estimated to affect 35 million people and causes 100,000130,000
deaths a year as of 2010. Cholera was one of the earliest
infections to be studied by epidemiological methods.
Slide 6
Camillians and Disasters
Slide 7
Core Ministers of the Infirm (Camillians) CTF Central SOS D RS
*Missionaries of Mercy* Camillian Task Force A Network Caritas
Archdiocese of Miami, USA Archdiocese of Port au Prince, Haiti
Misericordiae CRS Missionaries of Charity ? Church and State
Italian Episcopal Conference ?
Slide 8
CTF - SOS D RS A Vision To be Jesus merciful presence to the
neediest of the needy who are suffering from man-made and natural
disasters. To respond globally through a community-based,
Eucharist-centered, Marian-inspired disaster relief
organization.
Slide 9
CTF - SOS D RS A Mission To witness the merciful love of Christ
for the poor and the sick in word, deed, and sacrament To serve the
medical, pastoral, educational and humanitarian needs of people
affected by man-made and natural disasters regardless of race,
religion, or ethnicity.
A Convergence - Camillians, Disasters, Risk Camillians A Family
Ready to Respond
Slide 12
A Convergence - Camillians, Disasters, Risk People at Risk -
Globally People are Underprepared for Disasters Urbanization
Increasing Numbers of Slums Underdeveloped Social Factors
Spiritual, Societal and Family Deterioration Decreased Resilience,
Mans Inhumanity to Man Global Warming - Deteriorating Environment
People Live in Risk by Necessity and By Choice Lack of Early
Warning Signs and Unpredictable Weather Increasing Number of
Refugees and Internally Displaced
Slide 13
The Signs of the Times People at Risk Urbanization - The United
Nations projected that half of the world's population would live in
urban areas or cities at the end of 2008 2008 50%
Slide 14
The Signs of the Times People at Risk Increasing Numbers of
Slums - The number of people living out their days in the squalor
of a slum is almost one billion, the United Nations says -
one-sixth of the world's population. By 2050, the UN says, there
may be 3.5 billion slum dwellers, out of a total urban population
of about six billion. Kibera Slum in Nairobi, Kenya
Slide 15
The Signs of the Times People at Risk Underdeveloped Social
Factors - The earthquake in Chile was 1,000 times more powerful
than that in Haiti where 230,000 people died, many more than in
Chile. Social factors are much more important than geological when
determining the vulnerability of people to a disaster like an
earthquake. Haiti - January 12 Presidential PalaceChile February
27, 2010 Pelluhue
Slide 16
The Signs of the Times People at Risk Social factors include :
1. The economy of a country 2. The healthcare infrastructure 3.
Presence of integrated emergency management system 4. Previous
experience of handling disasters 5. Emergency plan 6. Educational
level of the population 7. Availability of basic necessities: clean
water, housing, etc. 8. The government effectiveness,
trustworthiness
Slide 17
The Signs of the Times People at Risk People in Risk by
Necessity and by ChoicePeople in Risk by Necessity and by Choice
[:00-35; 6:15-7:10] Pakistan Floods 2010
Slide 18
The Signs of the Times People at Risk - Increasing Number of
Refugees and Internally Displaced Tent City in the Slum of Solino,
Port au Prince, Haiti
Slide 19
A Convergence - Camillians and Disasters Increasing Incidence
and Severity of Disasters Disaster A serious disruption of the
functioning of a community or a society causing widespread human,
material, economic, or environmental losses that exceed the ability
of the affected community or society to cope using its own
resources.
Slide 20
Disasters Increasing in Incidence and Severity
Slide 21
Cholera Between Life and Death Seven Cholera Pandemics 1.In the
past 200 hundred years, seven cholera pandemics have killed
millions across the globe. 2.The seventh pandemic is still going on
since 1961, but advancements in medical science have greatly
reduced the number of people who die from it. 3. Modern-day sewage
and water treatment systems have largely eliminated cholera from
developed countries. But it continues to be a concern in the
developing world, especially in areas ravaged by war and natural
disasters such as earthquakes and hurricanes that leave people
without access to clean drinking water.
Slide 22
The first epidemic in Brazil? Cholera Between Life and Death
Black Death in Brazil - 1855-1856 (Part of the 3 rd Cholera
Pandemic) Cholera Strikes Brazil Again - 1991-1998 The last
epidemic in Brazil? Brazil and Cholera ( Part of the 7 th Cholera
Pandemic)
Slide 23
Cholera 1 st Pandemic 1817-1823 1817 First known pandemic of
cholera originated in the Ganges River delta in India. The disease
broke out near Calcutta. Hundreds of thousands died.
Slide 24
Cholera 1 st Pandemic 1817-1823 1820 Based on the 10,000
recorded deaths among British troops, researchers estimate that
hundreds of thousands across India, Southeast Asia, Central Asia,
the Middle East, Eastern Africa, and the Mediterranean coast
succumbed to the disease. 1820 - 100,000 people died on the
Indonesian island of Java alone. 1823 -Cholera had disappeared from
most of the world, except around the Bay of Bengal.
Slide 25
Cholera 2 nd Pandemic 1829-1849 1829 - The 2 nd pandemic starts
in India and reaches Russia by 1830 before continuing into Hungary
(100,000 dead), Finland, Poland, Paris (100,000 dead). 1831 -1849
Epidemic goes from Ireland to Quebec to the US to Mexico. Hundreds
of thousands die.
Slide 26
Cholera 2 nd Pandemic 1829-1849 -EXTRA 1832 - Irish immigrants,
fleeing poverty and the potato famine, carried the disease from
Europe to North America. On their arrival 1,220 died in Montreal
and another thousand across Quebec. 1833 - The disease entered the
U.S. through Detroit and New York and reached Latin America. It
claimed 200,000 victims in Mexico. It is believed more than 150,000
Americans died during the two pandemics between 1832 and 1849. 1848
- Another outbreak across England and Wales began killing 52,000
over two years.
Slide 27
Cholera 3 nd Pandemic 1852-59 1852 - The third pandemic,
generally considered the most deadly, originated once again in
India. It devastated large swaths of Asia, Europe, North and South
America and Africa mainly affecting Russia with over 1 million
deaths (1,000,000). 1854 - British physician John Snow succeeded in
identifying contaminated water as the transmitter of the disease
1860 - Deaths in India between 1817 and 1860 are estimated to have
exceeded 15 million people.
Slide 28
Extra 1854 - The worst year, 23,000 died in Britain alone. 1854
- British physician John Snow succeeded in identifying contaminated
water as the transmitter of the disease. Snow mapped the cases of
cholera in the Soho area in London and traced the source to a water
pump. After removing the pump handle, the number of cholera cases
in the area immediately declined.
Slide 29
3 rd Cholera Pandemic Black Death in Brazil - 1855-1856 Cholera
Epidemic - Black Death in Brazil - 1855-1856 1. This map represents
the movement of the first terrible cholera epidemic in Brazil as it
spread in 1855 and 1856. 2. Red indicates confirmed areas of
disease.
Slide 30
Extra 1. Red lines indicate sporadic cases, 2. Red points are
areas where cholera was probably infecting people, but this was not
confirmed by the presidential reports
Slide 31
Extra 1. Rivers facilitated the spread of cholera 2. It did not
cross mountain ranges 3. It always struck larger urban population
centers on the coast before spreading inward; 4. the Brazilian
North and Northeast were affected much more than the southern and
south-central parts of Brazil. 5. A set of larger (.pdf) maps are
available here.here
Slide 32
Cholera 4th Pandemic 1863-1879 1863 - The fourth pandemic began
in the Bengal region of India from which Indian Muslim pilgrims
visiting Mecca spread the disease to the Middle East, Russia,
Europe, Africa and North America
Slide 33
Extra 1863 - At least 30,000 of the 90,000 Mecca pilgrims fell
victim to the disease. 1866 - Cholera claimed 90,000 lives in
Russia. 1870 - From Mecca, Saudi Arabia cholera migrated to Europe,
Africa and North America
Slide 34
Cholera 5th Pandemic 1881- 1896 1881 - The fifth pandemic
originated in the Bengal region of India and swept through Asia
[Russia, Japan], Africa, South America and parts of France and
Germany. US and Britain Spared [Quarantine] 1892 - Waldemar
Haffkine, a Ukrainian bacteriologist who worked mostly in India,
developed a human vaccine for cholera.
Slide 35
Extra 1883-84 Cholera claimed 200,000 lives in Russia 1887-89
Cholera claimed 90,000 lives in Japan 1890 - Quarantine measures
based on the findings of John Snow kept cholera out of Britain and
the United States. 1892 Last epidemic in a European city (Hamburg,
Germany) claims some 8,000 lives.
Slide 36
Cholera 6th Pandemic 1899-1923 1899- The sixth pandemic killed
more than 800,000 in India before moving into the Middle East,
northern Africa, Russia, parts of Europe and Asia. 1910 11 - The
last outbreak in the United States 1917 An estimated 23 million
people in India died of cholera between 1865 and 1917. Russian
deaths during a similar time period exceeded 2 million. 1923 -
Cholera had receded from most of the world, although many cases
were still present in India.
Slide 37
Cholera The 7 th Pandemic - 1961 to present 1961 - The seventh
pandemic originates in Indonesia, not India. Vibrio Cholerae
Biotype El Tor is the dominant strain/causative agent [ El Tor
first identified in El Tor, Egypt in 1905 and then again in 1937,
but it does not produce an epidemic until 1961]. El Tor is
distinguished from the classic strain at a genetic level, although
both are in the serogroup O1 and both contain Inaba, Ogawa and
Hikojima serotypes. El Tor is also distinguished from classic
biotypes by the production of hemolysins and the fact that it can
remain in the human system longer allowing for a longer carrier
state. 1971 - It ravaged populations across Asia and the Middle
East, eventually reaching Africa by 1971. The 7 th Pandemic -
Cholera in the World 1970- 2010The 7 th Pandemic - Cholera in the
World 1970- 2010
Slide 38
Cholera The 7 th Pandemic - 1961 to present 1973 - The pandemic
had spread to Italy. There were also small outbreaks of the same
strain El Tor in Japan and the South Pacific late in the same
decade. 1991 - 100 years after cholera was vanquished from South
America, there was an outbreak in Peru that spread across the
continent, killing 10,000 people. It was a similar strain to the
seventh pandemic that petered out more than a decade earlier.
Cholera Bar Graph 1989-2010Cholera Bar Graph 1989-2010.
Slide 39
Cholera in Brazil (1991-1998) Socioeconomic Characterization of
Affected Areas 1. Cholera reappeared in Latin America in January
1991 and spread rapidly. 2. Vibrio cholerae O1 El Tor caused the
disease. 3. Peru was the first country affected, with an explosive
outbreak. 4. The high incidence of cholera in the Peruvian rain
forest area in 1991 was probably the cause of emergence of cholera
in Brazil through this unexpected route. 5. During this period in
Brazil - 161,432 cases and 1,296 deaths from cholera were reported.
6. The most severely-affected regions of the country were the North
and Northeast regions, accounting, respectively, for 7.0% and 92.2%
of the cases and 6.6% and 90.5% of the deaths. Both the regions
presented similar case fatality rates (0.79% and 0.76%
respectively). 7. In both the regions, the most affected areas were
small villages with a predominantly rural population, characterized
by deprivation, low HDI ranking, poverty, high rates of infant
mortality and illiteracy, and lack of sanitation. 8. During
1991-1996, Latin America reported 1.4 million cases and nearly
10,000 deaths.
Slide 40
Cholera in Brazil (1991-1998) Socioeconomic Characterization of
Affected Areas 1. During this period, 161,432 cases and 1,296
deaths from cholera were reported. The most severely-affected
regions of the country were the North and Northeast regions,
accounting, respectively, for 7.0% and 92.2% of the cases and 6.6%
and 90.5% of the deaths. Both the regions presented similar case
fatality rates (0.79% and 0.76% respectively). 2. After almost 100
years of absence from Latin America, cholera re-appeared in January
1991 and spread rapidly. Vibrio cholerae O1 El Tor caused the
disease. Peru was the first country affected, with an explosive
outbreak. There were 420,000 cases and 3,300 deaths during the
first 15 months of the epidemic. During 1991-1996, Latin America
reported 1.4 million cases and nearly 10,000 deaths (1). The high
incidence of cholera in the Peruvian rain forest area in 1991 was
probably the cause of emergence of cholera in Brazil through this
unexpected route.
Slide 41
Slide 42
1. In both the regions, the most affected areas were small
villages with a predominantly rural population, characterized by
deprivation, low HDI ranking, poverty, high rates of infant
mortality and illiteracy, and lack of sanitation.
Slide 43
1. After 1995, the incidence of cholera fell sharply and
quickly in the North and Northeast regions. This trend reflects the
reduction of susceptible subjects among the vulnerable population
and the improvement of cholera control programs. It also probably
reflects the favorable evolution of some health and social
indicators.
Slide 44
During the first half of the nineteenth century, there is
little evidence of major epidemic activity beyond smallpox,
measles, and scarlet fever in Brazil. Much of South America appears
to have been spared from the cholera and influenza pandemics that
killed millions in Asia, Europe and North America. Yellow
Fever,Cholera, Small Pox, Bubonic Plague, Influenza
Slide 45
Extra 1994 - an outbreak among Rwandan refugee camps in the
Democratic Republic of Congo killed tens of thousands in 1994. 2008
- the World Health Organization reported that nearly 500 people had
died in an outbreak in Zimbabwe in the last few months of 2008. The
outbreak affected most parts of the country and has so far involved
almost 12,000 cases.. 2010 - October - an outbreak kills thousands
of people in Haiti almost 10 months after a major earthquake
devastated the country, killing more than 200,000 people
Slide 46
Cholera Between Life and Death The Evolving 7 th Pandemic 1980s
- in the early 1980s, death rates are believed to have been greater
than 3 million a year. [Lancet - Cholera 2004]Lancet - Cholera 2004
1989 -2010 - Reported Cases - Cholera Bar Graph 1989-2010Reported
Cases - Cholera Bar Graph 1989-2010 2010 - It is estimated that
cholera affects 3-5 million people worldwide, and causes
100,000-130,000 deaths a year as of 2010. [2010 WHO position
paper]. This occurs mainly in the developing world.2010 WHO
position paper 2010 - Number of reported cases - 317, 534 cholera
cases were reported to WHO in 2010. 2010 Number of reported deaths
-7,543 deaths due to cholera were reported globally in 2010 This
represents a 52% increase compared to 2009 2010 Reported case
fatality rate - The overall case fatality rate for cholera was
2.38%
Slide 47
Extra -Cholera 1 Cause Organism, Susceptibility and
Transmission 2 Signs and symptoms 3 Mechanism - Genetic structure 4
Diagnosis - Enrichment media, Plating media 5 Prevention Hygiene,
Surveillance and Vaccine 6 Treatment - Fluids, Electrolytes,
Antibiotics 7 Prognosis 8 Epidemiology 9 History
Slide 48
Cholera Cause Organism Etymology Vibrio \Vib"ri*o\, noun;
plural English Vibrios, from Latin expression Vibriones. [New Latin
expression, from the Latin expression vibrare to vibrate, to move
by undulations.]. Cholera - The word cholera is from Greek: kholera
from khol "bile". Latin Cholera means bilious disease.Greek Light
Microscopy Electron Microscopy
Slide 49
Cholera Cause Organism Groups, Strains: Biotypes and Serotypes
Vibrio cholerae is a gram-negative, rod-shaped bacterium with a
single, polar flagellum which renders them motile. and surface O
antigens which form the basis of classifying the bacteria into more
than 130 groups. Two of the groups, O1 and O139 (O for O antigen),
have been known to cause epidemics of diarrhea. O1 causes the
majority of outbreaks, while O139 first identified in Bangladesh in
1992 is confined to South-East Asia O1 strains fall into two
biotypes (or biovars), called classical and El Tor, that are
distinguished by their different hemolytic activity, relative
resistance to the antibiotic polymyxin B, and their different
susceptibilities to bacteriophage. The classical biotype is further
divided into two serotypes (or serovars), based on the antisera
that recognize them, and named after the place where they were
first isolated: Inaba and Ogawa. Thus, any pathogenic strain of
Vibrio cholerae has a name that reflects both the biotype and the
serotype; for example, strain 569B has a classical biotype and the
Inaba serotype.
Slide 50
Cholera is caused by the Gram-negative, rod-shaped bacterium
Vibrio cholerae, which on first isolation may appear curved, and is
shown in Figure 3.1. The bacteria have a single, polar (at one end)
flagellum, which renders them motile. Based on the properties of
their O antigens (Book 2, Section 2.2), more than 130 groups have
been identified, but only two of them, O1 and O139 (O for O
antigen), have been known to cause epidemics of diarrheal disease.
Until very recently, however, only O1 Vibrio strains were known to
cause disease. These O1 strains fall into two biotypes (or
biovars), distinguished by their metabolic activities in this case,
their different hemolytic activity, relative resistance to the
antibiotic polymyxin B, and their different susceptibilities to
bacteriophage. The two biotypes are called classical and El Tor.
The classical biotype is further divided into two serotypes (or
serovars), based on the antisera that recognize them, and named
after the place where they were first isolated: Inaba and Ogawa.
(You will learn more about the use of serum to identify microbes in
Book 4.) Thus, any pathogenic strain of Vibrio cholerae has a name
that reflects both the biotype and the serotype; for example,
strain 569B has a classical biotype and the Inaba serotype. Two
serogroups of V. cholerae O1 and O139 cause outbreaks. V. cholerae
O1 causes the majority of outbreaks, while O139 first identified in
Bangladesh in 1992 is confined to South-East Asia. Non-O1 and
non-O139 V. cholerae can cause mild diarrhea but do not generate
epidemics.
Slide 51
Cholera Susceptibility Societal and Individual Risk Factors
Societal - Peri-urban slums Societal - Camps for IDPs or refugees
Societal - Post-disaster disruption of water/sanitation Individual
- Ingestion of 100,000,000 bacteria in healthy adult. Individual -
Lower gastric acidity Individual - Children two to four years of
age Individual - O blood type Individual - Lower immunity (AIDS,
malnourished children) Individual - Cholera
workers/unprotected
Slide 52
Extra Cholera transmission is closely linked to inadequate
environmental management. Typical at-risk areas include peri-urban
slums, where basic infrastructure is not available, as well as
camps for internally displaced people or refugees, where minimum
requirements of clean water and sanitation are not met. The
consequences of a disaster such as disruption of water and
sanitation systems, or the displacement of populations to
inadequate and overcrowded camps can increase the risk of cholera
transmission should the bacteria be present or introduced.
Epidemics have never arisen from dead bodies.
Slide 53
Extra About one hundred million (100,000,000) bacteria must
typically be ingested to cause cholera in a normal healthy adult.
This dose, however, is less in those with lower gastric acidity
(for instance those using proton pump inhibitors). Children are
also more susceptible with two to four year olds having the highest
rates of infection. Individuals' susceptibility to cholera is also
affected by their blood type, with those with type O blood being
the most susceptible. Persons with lower immunity such as persons
with AIDS or children who are malnourished are more likely to
experience a severe case if they become infected. [H owever, it
should be noted that any particular person, even a healthy adult in
middle age, can experience a severe case. About 75% of people
infected with V. cholerae do not develop any symptoms, although the
bacteria are present in their feces for 714 days after infection
and are shed back into the environment, potentially infecting other
people. [ Among people who develop symptoms, 80% have mild or
moderate symptoms, while around 20% develop acute watery diarrhea
with severe dehydration. This can lead to death if untreated.
People with low immunity such as malnourished children or people
living with HIV are at a greater risk of death if infected.
Slide 54
Cholera Cause - Transmission Transmission is primarily due to
the fecal contamination of food and water due to poor sanitation.
This bacterium can, however, live naturally in any environment,
particularly water reservoirs.
Slide 55
Cholera Prevention Halting Spread, Surveillance, Vaccination,
Preparedness to Respond Cholera may be prevented by halting spread
(remember diagram): Disposal and treatment (fecal
waste/contaminated materials) Sterilization with bleach/hot water
of contaminated materials Sterilization of hands (antimicrobial
soap, water); Antibacterial treatment of sewage before it enters
water supply Post warnings about possible cholera contamination
around contaminated water sources with directions on how to
decontaminate the water (boiling, chlorination etc.) Water
purification: Water used for drinking, washing, or cooking should
be sterilized by either boiling, chlorination, ozone water
treatment, ultraviolet light sterilization or antimicrobial
filtration. Cholera Prevention - Animated Video
Slide 56
Extra Sterilization: Proper disposal and treatment of infected
fecal waste water produced by cholera victims and all contaminated
materials (e.g. clothing, bedding, etc.) is essential. All
materials that come in contact with cholera patients should be
sterilized by washing in hot water, using chlorine bleach if
possible. Sterilization: Hands that touch cholera patients or their
clothing, bedding, etc., should be thoroughly cleaned and
disinfected with chlorinated water or other effective antimicrobial
agents. Sewage: antibacterial treatment of general sewage by
chlorine, ozone, ultraviolet light or other effective treatment
before it enters the waterways or underground water supplies helps
prevent undiagnosed patients from inadvertently spreading the
disease.
Slide 57
Extra - Cholera Diagnosis In epidemic situations, a clinical
diagnosis may be made by taking a history and doing a brief
examination. Treatment is usually started without or before
confirmation by laboratory analysis. Stool and swab samples
collected in the acute stage of the disease, before antibiotics
have been administered, are the most useful specimens for
laboratory diagnosis. A rapid dip-stick test is available to
determine the presence of V. cholerae. In those that test positive,
further testing should be done to determine antibiotic resistance.
If an epidemic of cholera is suspected, the most common causative
agent is Vibrio cholerae O1. If V. cholerae serogroup O1 is not
isolated, the laboratory should test for V. cholerae O139. A number
of special media have been employed for the cultivation for cholera
vibrios: Enrichment media and Plating media. Direct microscopy of
stool is not recommended, as it is unreliable. Microscopy is
preferred only after enrichment, as this process reveals the
characteristic motility of Vibrio and its inhibition by appropriate
antisera. Diagnosis can be confirmed, as well, as serotyping done
by agglutination with specific sera.
Slide 58
Surveillance - Prompt reporting allows for containing epidemics
Surveillance - Cholera is seasonal in many endemic countries
(rainy) Vaccine - Is additional control in cholera-endemic
countries Vaccine - High-risk such as 2-4 year olds, pregnant,
HIV-infected, healthcare workers. Vaccine - Pre-emptive vaccination
should be considered Vaccine - Two types of safe and effective oral
vaccines that are whole-cell killed, one with a recombinant B-sub
unit (Dukoral), the other without (Shanchol). Both have sustained
protection of over 50% lasting for two years in endemic settings.
Vaccine Dukoral is WHO prequalified and licensed in over 60
countries. Dukoral has been shown to provide short-term protection
of 8590% against V. cholerae O1 among all age groups at 46 months
following immunization. Vaccine Shanchol provides longer-term
protection against V. cholerae O1 and O139 in children under five
years of age. Vaccine - Both vaccines are administered in 2 doses
given between 7 days and 6 weeks apart. Dukoral is given in 150 ml
of safe water. Vaccine Immunization should be used in conjunction
with the usually recommended control measures. Cholera Prevention
Halting Spread, Surveillance, Vaccination, Preparedness to
Respond
Slide 59
Vaccines There are two types of safe and effective oral cholera
vaccines currently available on the market. Both are whole-cell
killed vaccines, one with a recombinant B-sub unit, the other
without. Both have sustained protection of over 50% lasting for two
years in endemic settings. One vaccine (Dukoral) is WHO
prequalified and licensed in over 60 countries. Dukoral has been
shown to provide short-term protection of 8590% against V. cholerae
O1 among all age groups at 46 months following immunization. The
other vaccine (Shanchol) is pending WHO prequalification and
provides longer- term protection against V. cholerae O1 and O139 in
children under five years of age. Both vaccines are administered in
two doses given between seven days and six weeks apart. The vaccine
with the B-subunit (Dukoral) is given in 150 ml of safe water. WHO
recommends that immunization with currently available cholera
vaccines be used in conjunction with the usually recommended
control measures in areas where cholera is endemic as well as in
areas at risk of outbreaks. Vaccines provide a short term effect
while longer term activities like improving water and sanitation
are put in place. When used, vaccination should target vulnerable
populations living in high risk areas and should not disrupt the
provision of other interventions to control or prevent cholera
epidemics. The WHO 3-step decision making tool aims at guiding
health authorities in deciding whether to use cholera vaccines in
complex emergency settings.
Slide 60
Extra People infected with cholera often have diarrhea, and if
this highly liquid stool disease transmission may occur. The source
of the contamination is typically other cholera sufferers when
their untreated diarrheal discharge is allowed to get into
waterways or into groundwater or drinking water supplies. Vibrio
cholerae can lie dormant in an environment and become the source of
infection when people are exposed, e.g. through it entering the
water supply. The main reservoirs of V. cholerae are people and
aquatic sources such as brackish water and estuaries, often
associated with algal blooms. Recent studies indicate that global
warming creates a favorable environment for the bacteria.
Slide 61
Cholera Cause - Transmission Primarily due to the fecal
contamination of food and water due to poor sanitation when
diarrhea from those with cholera enters waterways or groundwater or
drinking water. Vibrio cholerae can lie dormant in an environment
and become the source of infection when people are exposed, e.g.
through it entering the water supply. Main reservoirs of V.
cholerae are people and aquatic sources such as brackish water and
estuaries, often associated with algal blooms.
Slide 62
Cholera Vaccine A number of safe and effective oral vaccines
for cholera are available. Dukoral, an orally administered,
inactivated whole cell vaccine, has an efficacy of 85%, with
minimal side effects. It is available in over 60 countries. Dukoral
March 2010 WHO Position Paper on Vaccines Cholera is a rapidly
dehydrating diarrheal disease caused by ingestion of
toxin-producing strains of serogroup O1, or less commonly,
serogroup O139, of the bacterium Vibrio cholerae. The disease is
spread mainly by fecal contamination of water and food and is
closely linked to poor sanitation and lack of clean drinking water.
All age groups may be affected. The actual global disease burden is
estimated to be 35 million cases and 100 000130 000 deaths per
year. The emergence of more virulent strains of V. cholerae O1 in
large parts of Africa and Asia and the spread of
antibiotic-resistant mutants are causing concern. Currently, only
the oral cholera vaccines DukoralM and ShancholM/mORCVAXM are
available*. Dukoral is based on killed bacteria of serogroup O1
plus the cholera toxin B-subunit. (Toxin B induces short-term
protection against enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli (ETEC), an
important cause of travelers diarrhea). Shanchol and mORCVAX are
almost identical vaccines based on V. cholera O1 and O139, but
without toxin B. Dukoral is widely available internationally,
Shanchol is intended for both the Indian and international markets,
whereas mORCVAX is currently intended for use in Viet Nam. These
vaccines are all safe and induce adequate short-term protection
(see below). The manufacturers recommend a primary series of two
doses and, for those at continued risk of infection, a booster dose
at intervals of about 2 years. Work is under way to investigate the
role of mass vaccination. The World Health Organization (WHO)
recommends immunization of high risk groups, such as children and
people with HIV, in countries where this disease is endemic. [3] If
people are immunized broadly, herd immunity results, with a
decrease in the amount of contamination in the environment.
[4]HIVendemic [3]herd immunity [4]
Slide 63
Cholera Mechanism of Infection Vibrio cholera bacteria are
ingested and survive the acidity of the stomach. The bacteria exit
into the small intestine, produce protein flagellin to make
flagella, Flagella that rotate allow the bacteria to propel
themselves through the mucus of the small intestine. Upon reaching
the intestinal wall, V. cholerae stop producing flagellin and start
producing the toxic proteins that give the infected person a watery
diarrhea. The cholera toxin (CTX or CT) is an oligomeric complex
made up of protein subunits. Upon binding, the complex is taken
into the cell via receptor- mediated endocytosis. This in turn
leads to secretion of H 2 O, Na +, K +, Cl , and HCO 3 into the
lumen of the small intestine and rapid dehydration. The chloride
and sodium ions create a salt-water environment in the small
intestines, which through osmosis can pull up to six liters of
water per day through the intestinal cells, creating the massive
amounts of diarrhea. The diarrhea carries the multiplying new
generations of V. cholerae bacteria out into the drinking water of
the next host if proper sanitation measures are not in place.
Slide 64
Extra Vibrio cholera bacteria are ingested and survive the
acidity of the stomach They exit into the small intestine, produce
protein flagellin to make flagella, Flagella that rotate allow the
bacteria to propel themselves through the mucus of the small
intestine. On reaching the intestinal wall, V. cholerae stop
producing flagellin and start producing the toxic proteins that
give the infected person a watery diarrhea. The cholera toxin (CTX
or CT) is an oligomeric complex made up of protein subunits. Upon
binding, the complex is taken into the cell via receptor- mediated
endocytosis. This in turn leads to secretion of H 2 O, Na +, K +,
Cl , and HCO 3 into the lumen of the small intestine and rapid
dehydration. The chloride and sodium ions create a salt-water
environment in the small intestines, which through osmosis can pull
up to six liters of water per day through the intestinal cells,
creating the massive amounts of diarrhea. This carries the
multiplying new generations of V. cholerae bacteria out into the
drinking water of the next host if proper sanitation measures are
not in place.
Slide 65
Cholera Diagnosis and Treatment Rice Water Stools
Slide 66
Cholera Diagnosis and Treatment In epidemic situations, history
and doing a brief examination are the basis for a clinical
diagnosis. Treatment is usually started without or before
confirmation by laboratory analysis. For laboratory analysis, stool
and swab samples of diarrhea collected in the acute stage of the
disease, before antibiotics have been administered, are the most
useful specimens. A rapid dip-stick test is available to determine
the presence of V. cholerae. In those that test positive, further
testing can be done to determine antibiotic resistance. A number of
special media have been employed for the cultivation for cholera
vibrios: Enrichment media and Plating media. Direct microscopy of
stool is not recommended, as it is unreliable. Microscopy is
preferred only after enrichment, as this process reveals the
characteristic motility of Vibrio and its inhibition by appropriate
antisera. Diagnosis can be confirmed, as well, as serotyping done
by agglutination with specific sera. If an epidemic of cholera is
suspected, the most common causative agent is Vibrio cholerae O1.
If V. cholerae serogroup O1 is not isolated, the laboratory should
test for V. cholerae O139.
Slide 67
Extra Cholera Genetic Structure Amplified fragment length
polymorphism fingerprinting of the pandemic isolates of Vibrio
cholerae has revealed variation in the genetic structure. Two
clusters have been identified: Cluster I and Cluster II. For the
most part, Cluster I consists of strains from the 1960s and 1970s,
while Cluster II largely contains strains from the 1980s and 1990s,
based on the change in the clone structure. This grouping of
strains is best seen in the strains from the African continent.
[13] [13]
Slide 68
Cholera Diagnosis and Treatment First steps for Managing an
Outbreak of Acute Diarrhea The First Days THE FIRST TWO QUESTIONS
ARE: 1. Is this the beginning of an outbreak? 2. Is the patient
suffering from cholera or shigella? A. Is this the beginning of an
outbreak? - You might be facing an outbreak very soon if you have
seen an unusual number of acute diarrheal cases this week and the
patients have the following points in common: 1. They have similar
clinical symptoms (watery or bloody diarrhea) 2. They are living in
the same area or location 3. They have eaten the same food (at a
burial ceremony for example) 4. They are sharing the same water
source 5. There is an outbreak in the neighboring community 6. You
have seen an adult suffering from acute watery diarrhea with severe
dehydration and vomiting 7. If you have some statistical
information from previous years or weeks verify if the actual
increase of cases is unusual over the same period of time.
Slide 69
Cholera Diagnosis and Treatment First steps for Managing an
Outbreak of Acute Diarrhea The First Days 2. Is the patient
suffering from cholera or shigella? - If so, it is an emergency
Cholera = acute watery diarrhea Shigella dysentery = acute bloody
diarrhea 1. Both transmitted by contaminated water, unsafe food,
dirty hands and vomit or stools of sick people. 2. Cholera and
shigella produce outbreaks which represent an immediate threat to
the community. 3. Symptoms/Signs differentiate them (stool
[amount/character]; fever; abdominal cramps; vomiting; rectal pain]
4. Establish clinical diagnosis for patient, family members with
acute diarrhea, take stool samples/send for analysis or
refrigeration; Dont wait for lab to start treatment; estimate
supplies needed; protect community; collect patient data
Slide 70
Cholera Diagnosis and Treatment First steps for Managing an
Outbreak of Acute Diarrhea The First Days What are the next 3
questions to ask if you suspect an outbreak? Who do I inform and
ask for help from? How do I protect the community? How do I treat
the patients? What 3 things not to forget? 1. PROTECT YOURSELF FROM
CONTAMINATION Wash your hands with soap before and after taking
care of the patient Cut your nails 2. ISOLATE CHOLERA PATIENTS
Stools, vomit and soiled clothes of patients are highly contagious
Latrines and patients buckets need to be washed and disinfected
with chlorine Cholera patients have to be in a special ward,
isolated from other patients 3. CONTINUOUS PROVISION OF NUTRITIOUS
FOOD is important for all patients, especially for those with
shigella dysentery Provide frequent small meals with known foods
during the first 2 days Provide food as soon as the patient is able
to take it Breastfeeding of infants and young children should
continue
Slide 71
Check the supplies you have and record available quantities IV
fluids (Ringer Lactate is the best) Drips Nasogastric tubes Oral
Rehydration Salt (ORS) Antibiotics (see Table 2) Soap Chlorine or
bleaching powder Rectal swabs and transport medium (Cary Blair or
TCBS) for stool samples Safe water is needed to rehydrate patients
and to wash Cholera Diagnosis and Treatment First steps for
Managing an Outbreak of Acute Diarrhea The First Days
Slide 72
PROTECT THE COMMUNITY: Stool and vomit are highly contagious
Isolate the severe cases Provide information on how to avoid
cholera through simple messages and on the outbreak Disinfect water
sources with chlorine Promote water disinfection at home using
chlorine Avoid gatherings PRECAUTIONS FOR FUNERALS Disinfect
corpses with chlorine solution (2%) Fill mouth and anus with cotton
wool soaked with chlorine solution Wash hands with soap after
touching the corpse Disinfect the clothing and bedding of the
deceased by stirring them in boiling water or by drying them
thoroughly in the sun GIVE SIMPLE MESSAGES TO AVOID
CHOLERA/SHIGELLA Wash your hands with soap: after using toilets and
latrines; before preparing food; before eating Boil or disinfect
the water with chlorine solution Only eat freshly cooked food Do
not defecate near the water sources Use latrines and keep them
clean In case of acute diarrhea Start oral rehydration with ORS
before going to the health centre Go to the health centre as soon
as possible Cholera Diagnosis and Treatment First steps for
Managing an Outbreak of Acute Diarrhea The First Days
Slide 73
Summary of the treatment 1. Rehydrate with ORS or IV solution
depending on the severity 2. Maintain hydration and monitor the
hydration status 3. Give antibiotics for severe cholera cases and
for shigella cases Cholera Diagnosis and Treatment First steps for
Managing an Outbreak of Acute Diarrhea The First Days
Slide 74
BOX 1. HOW TO PREPARE HOME-MADE ORS SOLUTION If ORS sachets are
available: dilute 1 sachet in 1 liter of safe water Otherwise: Add
to 1 liter of safe water: Salt 1/2 small spoon (3.5 grams) Sugar 4
big spoons (40 grams) And try to compensate for loss of potassium -
for example, eat bananas or drink green coconut water Cholera
Diagnosis and Treatment First steps for Managing an Outbreak of
Acute Diarrhea The First Days
Slide 75
When is it useful to give antibiotics? For cholera cases with
severe dehydration only. Ideally for all of Shigella dysenteriae
cases, but as a priority for the most vulnerable patients: children
under five, elderly, malnourished, patients with convulsions.
Cholera Diagnosis and Treatment First steps for Managing an
Outbreak of Acute Diarrhea The First Days
Slide 76
Which antibiotics? Cholera Adults doxycycline - 1 dose 300 mg
or tetracycline 12.5 mg/kg 4 times a day for 3 days; Young
children: erythromycin liquid 12.5 mg/kg 4 times a day for 3 days
Shigella Adults: ciprofloxacin 500 mg twice a day for 3 days
Children: ciprofloxacin 250 mg/15kg twice a day for 3 days For
children below 6 months of age: add zinc 10 mg daily for 2 weeks
For children 6 months to 5 years of age: add zinc 20 mg daily for 2
weeks Cholera Diagnosis and Treatment First steps for Managing an
Outbreak of Acute Diarrhea The First Days
Slide 77
About 75% of people infected with V. cholerae do not develop
any symptoms, although the bacteria are present in their feces for
714 days. Among people who develop symptoms, 80% have mild or
moderate symptoms that can be treated with ORS; while around 20%
develop acute watery diarrhea with severe dehydration. With
untreated cholera, the mortality rate rises to 5060%. In an
outbreak, the fatality rate should be around 1% For certain genetic
strains of cholera, such as the one present during the 2010
epidemic in Haiti and the 2004 outbreak in India, death can occur
within two hours of the first sign of symptoms. Cholera Prognosis
Between Life and Death
Slide 78
Cholera - Research 1855 - The bacterium originally isolated by
Italian anatomist Filippo PaciniFilippo Pacini 1900 - The
Russian-born bacteriologist Waldemar Haffkine developed the first
cholera vaccine around 1900.Waldemar Haffkine 1854 - Physician and
pioneer medical scientist John Snow (18131858), found a link
between cholera and contaminated drinking water. [41] He was able
to demonstrate human sewage contamination was the most probable
disease vector in two major epidemics in London in 1854.John Snow
[41]sewage 1885 - Robert Koch identified V. cholerae with a
microscope as the bacillus causing the disease..Robert 1947 - The
province of Bengal in British India was partitioned into West
Bengal and East Pakistan in 1947. Prior to partition, both regions
had cholera pathogens with similar characteristics. After 1947,
India made more progress on public health than East Pakistan (now
Bangladesh). As a consequence, [clarification needed] the strains
of the pathogen that succeeded in India had a greater incentive in
the longevity of the host. They have become less virulent than the
strains prevailing in Bangladesh. These draw upon the resources of
the host population and rapidly kill many victims.British IndiaWest
East PakistanBangladeshclarification needed 2002 - Alam, et al.,
studied stool samples from patients at the International Centre for
Diarrheal Disease (ICDDR) in Dhaka, Bangladesh. Researchers found a
correlation between the passage of V. cholerae through the human
digestive system and an increased infectivity state. Bacteria
create a hyperinfected state where genes that control biosynthesis
of amino acids, iron uptake systems, and formation of periplasmic
nitrate reductase complexes were induced just before defecation.
These induced characteristics allow the cholera vibrios to survive
in the "rice water" stools, an environment of limited oxygen and
iron, of patients with a cholera infection. [43]International
Centre for Diarrheal DiseaseDhaka, Bangladeshgenesamino acidsiron
[43]
Slide 79
A Case Study of Convergence - Haiti Camillians, Signs of the
Times, Disasters Cholera is a New ThreatCholera is a New Threat
[October 2010] Earthquake - Moments After The Cathedral [1:30 ] [
January 2010] Hurricane ThomasHurricane Thomas [November 2010]
Slide 80
Slide 81
Haiti Epidemic - Summary 1. The epidemic is ongoing and has a
history: 2 On October 21, 2010 the US Centers for Disease Control
and Prevention (CDC) confirmed that the cases of diarrheal illness
first seen at hospitals in the Artibonite region had been receiving
had been identified as cholera. 3. The rural Artibonite Department
of Haiti, [3] about 100 kilometers (62 mi) north of the capital,
Port-au-Prince, Artibonite (Gonaves) 1 Centre (Hinche) Grand'Anse
(Jrmie) 3 Nippes (Miragone) Nord (Cap-Hatien) Nord-Est
(Fort-Libert) Nord-Ouest (Port-de-Paix) Ouest (Port-au-Prince) -8
Sud-Est (Jacmel) Sud (Les Cayes)
Slide 82
Haiti Epidemic - Summary 1. By November 2010 the epidemic
spread to the Dominican Republic and there was a single case in
Florida, United States; 2. By the first 10 weeks of the epidemic to
all of Haiti's 10 departments or provinces (December 2011). 3. By
January 2011 a few cases were reported in Venezuela. 4. By March
2011 the epidemic had killed 4672 people and hospitalized thousands
more. Some 252,640 cases had been reported by March 2011. 5. By
late September 2011, some 6,435 deaths have been reported and this
number is expected to increase
Slide 83
Haiti Cholera Epidemic Background in the World During the
1900s, six major cholera pandemics had spread around the world. At
the time of this Cholera outbreak in Haiti, the world was
experiencing the seventh, caused by a new strain of the Vibrio
cholerae bacterium, El Tor.Vibrio choleraeEl Tor Epidemics
involving this El Tor strain started in 1961 in Indonesia, and
spread rapidly elsewhere in eastern Asia and then to India and
Bangladesh, the USSR, Iran and Iraq. This was the first Cholera
outbreak in Haiti in over 50 years.
Slide 84
Haiti Cholera Epidemic Background the Source The suspected
source for the epidemic was the Artibonite River, from which some
of the affected people had drunk water.Artibonite River A UN team
investigated samples of a suspected sewage spill from a Nepali
peacekeeping base that may have infected the river system.Nepali
Vincenzo Pugliese of MINUSTAH confirmed that the tests were
positive for cholera. [14] The US CDC said its tests of "DNA
fingerprinting" showed various samples of cholera from Haitian
patients were identified as Vibrio cholerae serogroup O1, serotype
Ogawa, a strain found in South Asia.MINUSTAH [14] The Swedish
ambassador to Haiti said the epidemic had strains originating in
Nepal. However, Nepal's representative to the United Nations
"categorically refuted" the hypothesis that Nepali peacekeepers
were the source of the outbreak. Following the claims the UN said
it would investigate the source of the cholera strain. [23] [23] UN
peacekeepers from Nepal brought the strain of cholera to Haiti
responsible for an epidemic that has killed 5,500 people, according
to a study published by the US Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention (CDC). The study is the first to establish a direct link
between the arrival of the Nepalese UN battalion near the small
town of Mirebalais and the cholera epidemic that erupted in
mid-October 2010. [citation needed]citation needed
Slide 85
Haiti Epidemic -Domestic Response On 15 November, a riot broke
out in Cap-Hatien following rumors that the outbreak was caused by
U.N. soldiers from Nepal.Cap-Hatien At least 5 people were killed
in the riots, including 1 UN personnel. [28] [28] Riots then
continued for a second day. [29] Following the riots the UN said
the outbreak was being staged for "political reasons because of
forthcoming elections", as the Haitian government sent its own
forces to "protest" the UN peacekeepers. [30] [29] [30] During a
third day of riots UN personnel were blamed for shooting at least 5
protestors but denied responsibility. [31] On the fourth day of
demonstrations against the UN presence, police fired tear gas into
an IDP camp in the capital. [32] [31]IDP [32]
Slide 86
Haiti Epidemic - Source On 15 March 2011, a report was issued
by the University of California that predicted total infections
would number up to 779,000 and total deaths up to 11,000 by
November 2011, compared with earlier UN estimates that around
400,000 people would end up infected. The revised numbers were
based on more factors than the UN's estimates, which assumed a
total infection rate of between two and four percent of the
population. [6] In a statement released at the same time, the WHO
said total deaths thus far had reached 4,672, with 252,640 cases
reported. [6]University of California [6]
Slide 87
Interactive Map of Cholera Epidemic in Haiti
Slide 88
First Mission Artibonite October, 2010
Slide 89
Slide 90
Slide 91
Slide 92
Slide 93
Slide 94
Second Mission Grand Anse December- February, 2010
Slide 95
Slide 96
Slide 97
Cholera Bed
Slide 98
Slide 99
Slide 100
Slide 101
Most Recent News jedi, 20 oktb 2011 Ayiti: Depatman Sante
Piblik ak Popilasyon Pral Lanse yon Kanpay Vaksinasyon kont Kolera
Ayiti: Depatman Sante Piblik ak Popilasyon Pral Lanse yon Kanpay
Vaksinasyon kont Kolera madi, 11 oktb 2011 20 Moun Mouri anba
Maladi Kolera nan Depatman Grand' Ans 20 Moun Mouri anba Maladi
Kolera nan Depatman Grand' Ans