22
!"# "%&'() *'( !'+,(%--  !"#$%" #& ()" *#+,#"- %. & /)++011##- )( /).2"#-- ./()0(/,0) !/)/1%+-0/& 2+3%( )0% 45 )0  67%+37%+) '* 8%(-'+- .'(+ /+ )0% 2+/)%3 #)9)%- )' 6:/%+ 89(%+)- ;9(,9(%) ;/<=>+, ?%% !"#$%&'($)" +((,-."/  0'.1'-/ 234 53 25 !'+,(%--/'+9: "%-%9(@0 #%(A/@% 678633 999:;-%:#,) <!==36>

Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 1/22

!"# "%&'() *'( !'+,(%-- !"#$%"#& ()" *#+,#"- %.& /)++011##- )( /).2"#--

./()0(/,0) !/)/1%+-0/& 2+3%( )0%

45)0 67%+37%+) '* 8%(-'+- .'(+

/+ )0% 2+/)%3 #)9)%- )' 6:/%+ 89(%+)-

;9(,9(%) ;/<=>+, ?%%!"#$%&'($)" +((,-."/

 0'.1'-/ 234 5325

!'+,(%--/'+9: "%-%9(@0 #%(A/@%

678633

999:;-%:#,)

<!==36>

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 2/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

#>779(=

"#$% &'$ ()*& +$,)+$ -% *-. ,-/,$%/ )0-1& 233$4)3 25524%)&2-/ ')* 3$+ *-5$ 3$42*3)&-%* &-

%$$6)52/$ &'$ 3-/47$*&)032*'$+ &$/$& -8 9:;: ,2&2<$/*'2( &')& ) ($%*-/ ='- 2* 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+

;&)&$* )/+ *10>$,& &- 2&* >1%2*+2,&2-/ 2* ) ,2&2<$/ -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* %$4)%+3$** -8 &'$ %),$.$&'/2,2&?. -% )32$/)4$ -8 &'$ ()%$/&*: @'2* ,-/,$(& -8 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2( 2* ,-+282$+ 2/ &'$A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$ -8 &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& -8 &'$ 9:;: A-/*&2&1&2-/ )/+ ;$,&2-/ DEFG)H -8&'$ I5524%)&2-/ )/+ J)&2-/)32&? C,& GIJCH G,-+282$+ )& K 9:;:A: LFMEFG)HH: @'$ =)% -/ &$%%-% )/+

&'$ ,)*$ -8 N)*$% O*)5 P)5+2. ) 9:;:7;)1+2 +1)3 /)&2-/)3 ,)(&1%$+ 2/ C84')/2*&)/ 824'&2/4 =2&'@)320)/ 8-%,$*. 81%&'$% '$24'&$/$+ )&&$/&2-/ &- )/+ 2/&$%$*& 2/ %$*&%2,&2/4 )1&-5)&2, 02%&'%24'&

,2&2<$/*'2(: C3&'-14' P)5+2Q* ()%$/&* =$%$ ;)1+2 /)&2-/)3* 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* -/ /-/25524%)/&=-%R #2*)*. P)5+2 =)* ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/ 0? %24'& -8 '2* 02%&' 2/ S-12*2)/) )/+ )%41)03? $/&2&3$+ &-%24'&* /-& )#)23)03$ &- 8-%$24/ $/$5? ,-50)&)/&*: I/ &'$ FFT&' )/+ %$,$/& A-/4%$**$*. *-5$

U$50$%* ')#$ *1((-%&$+ 2/&%-+1,2/4 3$42*3)&2-/ &')& =-13+ %$#2*$ -% %$2/&$%(%$& &'$ A2&2<$/*'2(A3)1*$ )/+ %$3)&$+ ,2&2<$/*'2( *&)&1&$: @'2* %$(-%& &%),$* &'$ '2*&-%? -8 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2( 1/+$%

9:;: 3)= )/+ +2*,1**$* *-5$ -8 &'$ 3$42*3)&2-/ 2/ %$,$/& A-/4%$**$* 2/&$/+$+ &- )3&$% 2&:

@'$ &%)+2&2-/)3 O/432*' ,-55-/73)= 8-33-=$+ &'$ +-,&%2/$ -8 34- -)50. 1/+$% ='2,' ($%*-/* 0-%/=2&'2/ &'$ +-52/2-/* -8 )/+ =2&' )33$42)/,$ &- &'$ O/432*' *-#$%$24/ =$%$ *10>$,&* -8 &'$

*-#$%$24/ %$4)%+3$** -8 &'$ )32$/)4$ *&)&1* -8 &'$2% ()%$/&*: @'$ $6,$(&2-/* &- &'2* %13$ )%$ ($%*-/* 0-%/ &- +2(3-5)&*. ='- )%$ 0-%/ *10>$,&* -8 &'$ *-#$%$24/ ='-5 &'$ ()%$/&* %$(%$*$/& )0%-)+. )/+

 ($%*-/* 0-%/ &- ,2&2<$/* -8 ) '-*&23$ -,,1(?2/4 8-%,$. ='- )%$ 0-%/ *10>$,&* -8 &'$ 2/#)+2/4*-#$%$24/: C3&'-14' &'$ *&)&$* )/+ ,-1%&* 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )(()%$/&3? )+-(&$+ &'$ 34- -)50 

+-,&%2/$. &'$%$ *&233 =)* ,-/81*2-/ )0-1& ='$&'$% ($%*-/* 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* &- )32$/ ()%$/&* =$%$ 9:;: ,2&2<$/*: @'2* 1/,$%&)2/&? $62*&$+ ()%&3? 0$,)1*$ ,2&2<$/*'2( 0? 02%&' 2/ &'$9/2&$+ ;&)&$* =)* /-& +$82/$+ 2/ &'$ -%242/)3 A-/*&2&1&2-/ /-% 2/ &'$ $)%3? 8$+$%)3 *&)&1&$*:C++2&2-/)33?. C8%2,)/ C5$%2,)/* =$%$ /-& ,-/*2+$%$+ ,2&2<$/* -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. $#$/ 28 &'$?=$%$ 8%$$: J)&2#$ C5$%2,)/* )3*- =$%$ /-& ,-/*2+$%$+ 9:;: ,2&2<$/* 0$,)1*$ &'$? =$%$ 5$50$%*

-8 +$($/+$/& *-#$%$24/ I/+2)/ /)&2-/*:

@'$ A2#23 V24'&* C,& -8 FKWW )/+ &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/&. %)&282$+ 2/ FKWK. +$82/$+ 02%&'%24'&,2&2<$/*'2(. $6&$/+2/4 2& &- C8%2,)/ C5$%2,)/* )/+ )3*- &- 5-*& ($%*-/* 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*:

I/ )/ FKXK +$,2*2-/. 6.01#& 71%1#- 89 :).2 ;0+ <"= . &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* ;1(%$5$ A-1%& 5)+$ ,3$)%&')&. 1/+$% &'$*$ 3)=*. 9:;:70-%/ ,'23+%$/ -8 )32$/* =$%$ 9:;: ,2&2<$/* %$4)%+3$** -8 &'$ )32$/)4$)/+ /)&2-/)3 -%242/ -8 &'$2% ()%$/&*. =2&' /)%%-= $6,$(&2-/* 8-% &'$ ,'23+%$/ -8 8-%$24/ +2(3-5)&*)/+ '-*&23$ 2/#)*2-/ )/+ -,,1()&2-/ 8-%,$* -8 ) 8-%$24/ /)&2-/: P-=$#$%. 2/ &'$ FKKM +$,2*2-/  >5=

89 :05=0.-. &'$ ;1(%$5$ A-1%& '$3+ &')& J)&2#$ C5$%2,)/* =$%$ /-& 9:;: ,2&2<$/* 1/+$% &'$ &$%5*

-8 &'$ A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$: J)&2#$ C5$%2,)/* =$%$ 9:;: ,2&2<$/* 0? &%$)&2$* -% *&)&1&$* 4%)/&2/49:;: ,2&2<$/*'2( &- 5$50$%* -8 *($,282, &%20$*: I5524%)&2-/ )/+ /)&2-/)32&? *&)&1&$* $/),&$+ 2/FXTM. FXME. )/+ FXYT 4%)/&$+ 9:;: ,2&2<$/*'2( &- )33 J)&2#$ C5$%2,)/*:

I/ &'$ FFT&' A-/4%$**. P:V: FME. ;$,&2-/ DEF -8 P:V: FFXW. ;: ZTD. )/+ ;:[:V$*: T =-13+ )5$/+&'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/ )/+\-% &'$ IJC &- $6,31+$ 8%-5 ,2&2<$/*'2( )& 02%&' ($%*-/* 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+

;&)&$* ='-*$ ()%$/&* )%$ 1/3)=8133? (%$*$/& 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* -% )%$ /-/25524%)/& )32$/*: @'2*%$(-%& =233 0$ 1(+)&$+ )* /$,$**)%?:

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 3/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

!'+)%+)-

I/&%-+1,&2-/:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: F 

P2*&-%2,)3 ]$#$3-(5$/& ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: T 

 ?4- 7)50 ]-,&%2/$ ̂ $8-%$ &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::T @'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& )/+ &'$ A2#23 V24'&* C,& -8 FKWW ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: W 6.01#& 71%1#- 89 :).2 ;0+ <"=  )/+ >5= 89 :05=0.- ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: K 

S$42*3)&2#$ _%-(-*)3*:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::FE 

A-/*&2&1&2-/)3 )/+ ;&)&1&-%? C5$/+5$/&* :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: FE A-/*&2&1&2-/)3 C5$/+5$/&* )/+ V$3)&$+ ;&)&1&-%? C5$/+5$/&*::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: FF ;&)&1&-%? C5$/+5$/&* 2̀&'-1& V$3)&$+ A-/*&2&1&2-/)3 C5$/+5$/&*:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: FD "&'$% ;&)&1&-%? C5$/+5$/&* ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::FY 

A-/4%$**2-/)3 C,& 2̀&'-1& A-/*&2&1&2-/)3 C5$/+5$/&:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: FY 

!'+)9@)-C1&'-% A-/&),& I/8-%5)&2-/::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: FX 

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 4/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

B+)('3>@)/'+

"#$% &'$ ()*& +$,)+$ -% *-. ,-/,$%/ )0-1& 233$4)3 25524%)&2-/ ')* 3$+ *-5$ 3$42*3)&-%* &-

%$$6)52/$ &'$ 3-/47$*&)032*'$+ &$/$& -8 9:;: ,2&2<$/*'2( &')& ) ($%*-/ ='- 2* 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+

;&)&$* )/+ *10>$,& &- 2&* >1%2*+2,&2-/. 2* ) ,2&2<$/ -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* %$4)%+3$** -8 &'$ %),$.$&'/2,2&?. -% )32$/)4$ -8 &'$ ()%$/&*: @'2* ,-/,$(& -8 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2( 2* ,-+282$+ 2/ &'$A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$ -8 &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& -8 &'$ 9:;: A-/*&2&1&2-/ )/+ LDEFG)H -8 &'$I5524%)&2-/ )/+ J)&2-/)32&? C,& GIJCH:F @'$ =)% -/ &$%%-% )/+ &'$ ,)*$ -8 N)*$% O*)5 P)5+2. )

9:;:7;)1+2 +1)3 /)&2-/)3 ,)(&1%$+ 2/ C84')/2*&)/ 824'&2/4 =2&' @)320)/ 8-%,$*. 81%&'$% '$24'&$/$+)&&$/&2-/ &- )/+ 2/&$%$*& 2/ %$*&%2,&2/4 )1&-5)&2, 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2(: C3&'-14' P)5+2Q* ()%$/&*

=$%$ ;)1+2 /)&2-/)3* 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* -/ /-/25524%)/& =-%R #2*)*. P)5+2 =)* ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/ 0? %24'& -8 '2* 02%&' 2/ S-12*2)/) )/+ )%41)03? $/&2&3$+ &- %24'&* /-& )#)23)03$ &- 8-%$24/ $/$5?,-50)&)/&*: @'2* %$(-%& &%),$* &'$ '2*&-%? -8 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2( 1/+$% 9:;: 3)= )/+ +2*,1**$*

*-5$ -8 &'$ 3$42*3)&2-/ 2/ %$,$/& A-/4%$**$* 2/&$/+$+ &- )3&$% 2&:

I/ &'$ ,1%%$/& )/+ %$,$/& A-/4%$**$*. *-5$ U$50$%* ')#$ *1((-%&$+ 2/&%-+1,2/4 3$42*3)&2-/ &')&

=-13+ %$#2*$ -% %$2/&$%(%$& &'$ A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$ &- )++%$** ,-/,$%/* &')& GFH ,'23+%$/ 0-%/ &-1/)1&'-%2<$+ )32$/* 0$,-5$ )/ )#$/1$ &- 3$4)3 *&)&1* 8-% &'$2% ()%$/&* )/+ *2032/4* ='$/ &'$? &1%/TF ?$)%* -3+. )/+ GTH )8831$/& (%$4/)/& 8-%$24/$%* ,-5$ &- &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* -/ &-1%2*& #2*)* &-

42#$ 02%&' &- &'$2% ,'23+%$/ )/+ &'1* (%-#2+$ &'$5 =2&' 9:;: ,2&2<$/*'2(:T ;1,' 3$42*3)&2-/ )3*-

%$*(-/+* &- 5-%$ 4$/$%)3 (1032, ,-/,$%/ )0-1& &'$ 3),R -8 5-#$5$/& -/ ,-5(%$'$/*2#$ 8$+$%)3

25524%)&2-/ %$8-%5 3$42*3)&2-/:D 

I/ &'$ FFT&' A-/4%$**. P:V: FME. LDEF -8 P:V: FFXW. ;: ZTD. )/+ ;:[:V$*: T =-13+ )5$/+ &'$

A-/*&2&1&2-/ )/+\-% &'$ IJC &- $6,31+$ ($%*-/* 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* 8%-5 ,2&2<$/*'2( )& 02%&'28 &'$2% ()%$/&* =$%$ 1/3)=8133? (%$*$/& 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* -% =$%$ /-/25524%)/& )32$/*: I/-%+$% 8-% ) ,'23+ &- 0$ ) ,2&2<$/ )& 02%&' 1/+$% &'$*$ (%-(-*)3*. )& 3$)*& -/$ ()%$/& =-13+ ')#$ &- 0$

) 9:;: /)&2-/)3. ) 3)=813 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/& GS_VH ='- %$*2+$* 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. -% )/ )32$/*$%#2/4 -/ ),&2#$ +1&? 2/ &'$ 9:;: C%5$+ B-%,$*: J- 3$42*3)&2#$ ),&2-/ 0$?-/+ ,-552&&$$ %$8$%%)3')* -,,1%%$+ -/ )/? -8 &'$*$ 5$)*1%$*:

B1%&'$%5-%$. *-5$ *&)&$ 3$42*3)&-%* ')#$ #-2,$+ *1((-%& 8-% *&)&$ 3$42*3)&2-/ &')& =-13+ +$82/$*&)&$ ,2&2<$/*'2( )* $6,31+2/4 ($%*-/* 0-%/ &- 1/+-,15$/&$+ )32$/* )/+ 8-% ) *&)&$ ,-5(),& 1/+$%

='2,' *&)&$* =-13+ 2**1$ ) +288$%$/& &?($ -8 02%&' ,$%&282,)&$ &- *1,' ($%*-/*: ;&)&$ 3$42*3)&-%* 8%-5C%2<-/) )/+ FD -&'$% *&)&$* 1/#$23$+ 5-+$3 3$42*3)&2-/ 2/ [)/1)%? TEFF. 2/&$/+2/4 &- *$& &'$ *&)4$

8-% ) 9:;: ;1(%$5$ A-1%& %$#2$= -8 &'$ A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$:M ;1,' 3$42*3)&2-/ ')* 0$$/ 2/&%-+1,$+

F A-+282$+ )& K 9:;:A: LFMEFG)H:T ;$$. 8-% $6)5(3$. ])/2$3 a-/<b3$<. c^2%&'* 0? 9:;: #2*2&-%*d C %$)3 2**1$e ])&) 2/+2,)&$ f02%&' &-1%2*5Q 2* /-& )=2+$*(%$)+ (%),&2,$.g <"0@).% A#$4,50B. C141*& FZ. TEFF. '&&(d\\===:)<,$/&%)3:,-5\/$=*\)%&2,3$*\TEFF\EK\FZ\TEFFEKFZ02%&'*70?71*7#2*2&-%*7*5)33$%72**1$:'&53h V-0 P-&)R)2/$/. cf^2%&'%24'& A2&2<$/*'2(Q ̀ 233 ̂ $ @)%4$& -8 P-1*$

a"_ U)>-%2&?.g *B/5%1BCD E#F-$%$#"-. J-#$50$% FK. TEFE. '&&(d\\===:5,,3)&,'?+,:,-5\TEFE\FF\FK\FEDXMW\ 02%&'%24'&7,2&2<$/*'2(7=23370$:'&53i:D [: @)?3-% V1*'2/4 )/+ ^-0 A1*),R. GH! 5#%&#" *B/)..#55I J)4"1##.1C <+#.&+#.1 0- 0. .##& )( "#80#F . @PO PISS.C141*& T. TEFEh U2%2)5 [-%+)/. [$)/ a1$%%$%-. S)1%) U$,R3$%. 6979 K++02"%10). J02C1 :0&#.- 1) E%108# L)".. `CSS

;@: [:. [13? DE. TEFE. )& CY:M ;&)&$ V$(: ])%?3 U$&,)38$. ;&)&$ S$42*3)&-%* 8-% S$4)3 I5524%)&2-/. c;&)&$ S)=5)R$%* A-/#$/$+ 2/ ]:A: &- ]$32#$%P2*&-%2,. J)&2-/=2+$ A-%%$,&2-/ -8 FM&' C5$/+5$/& U2*)((32,)&2-/.g [)/1)%? Y. TEFF.'&&(d\\===:*&)&$3$42*3)&-%*8-%3$4)325524%)&2-/:,-5\J$=*I&$5:)*(6eJ$=*I]jFEFXYh <--)B0%1#& !"#--. cS)=5)R$%*

2/ FM ;&)&$* A%)8& ^233 &- ]$/? A2&2<$/*'2( &- fC/,'-% ^)02$*.Qg ",&-0$% FX. TEFE. 32*&$+ &'$ FD -&'$% *&)&$* )*G,-/&2/1$+:::H

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 5/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

2/ *-5$ *&)&$* 01& ')* /-& 0$$/ $/),&$+:Y O#$/ 28 *1,' 3$42*3)&2-/ =$%$ $/),&$+. *-5$ 3$4)3*,'-3)%* &'2/R 2& 2* 1/32R$3? &')& &'$ ;1(%$5$ A-1%& =-13+ '$)% *1,' ) ,)*$:W 

V$,$/&3?. &'$ C5$%2,)/ ^)% C**-,2)&2-/ GC^CH )+-(&$+ ) %$*-31&2-/ 1%42/4 A-/4%$** )/+ *&)&$.&$%%2&-%2)3. )/+ 3-,)3 3$42*3)&2#$ 0-+2$* &- %$>$,& )/? %$#2*2-/ -8 &'$ FM &' C5$/+5$/& A2&2<$/*'2(

A3)1*$ -% )/? -&'$% )&&$5(& &- %$*&%2,& &'$ )0232&? -8 ) ($%*-/ &- ,3)25 9:;: ,2&2<$/*'2( 1/+$% &'$FM

&' C5$/+5$/& 0$,)1*$ -8 &'$ ,2&2<$/*'2( -% 25524%)&2-/ *&)&1* -8 &'$ ()%$/&*:

C/-)'(/@9: D%A%:'&7%+)

 >?, ;47# D'@)(/+% .%*'(% )0% E'>()%%+)0 67%+37%+)

@'$%$ )%$ &=- 0)*2, +-,&%2/$* 8-% +$&$%52/2/4 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2(:  ?4- -)50 2* &'$ (%2/,2(3$ &')& ) ($%*-/ ),k12%$* ,2&2<$/*'2( 2/ ) /)&2-/ 0? #2%&1$ -8 '2* 02%&' 2/ &')& /)&2-/ -% 2&* &$%%2&-%2)3 (-**$**2-/*:K  ?4- -%.240.0- 2* &'$ (%2/,2(3$ &')& ) ($%*-/ ),k12%$* &'$ ,2&2<$/*'2( -8 '2* ()%$/&*.

c,2&2<$/*'2( -8 &'$ 03--+:g

X

 @'$ O/432*' ,-55-/ 3)= &%)+2&2-/ (%2-% &- &'$ ]$,3)%)&2-/ -8I/+$($/+$/,$. ='2,' =)* &'$ 0)*2* -8 &'$ ,-55-/ 3)= 2/ &'$ -%242/)3 FD ,-3-/2$* )/+ ='2,' =)*)+-(&$+ 0? 5-*& -8 &'$ *&)&$* )* &'$ (%$,$+$/& 8-% *&)&$ ,-55-/ 3)=.

FE 8-33-=$+ &'$ 34- -)50 

+-,&%2/$:FF _$%*-/* 0-%/ =2&'2/ &'$ +-52/2-/ -8 &'$ *-#$%$24/ )/+ 1/+$% &'$ (%-&$,&2-/ )/+

G:::,-/&2/1$+H

C3)0)5). ]$3)=)%$. I+)'-. I/+2)/). U2,'24)/. U2**2**2((2. U-/&)/). J$0%)*R). J$= P)5(*'2%$. "R3)'-5).

_$//*?3#)/2). @$6)*. )/+ 9&)'. )& '&&(d\\===:8-6/$=*:,-5\(-32&2,*\TEFE\FE\FX\3)=5)R$%*7*&)&$*7,%)8&7+$/?7,2&2<$/*'2(7)/,'-%70)02$*\e&$*&j3)&$*&/$=*: ;-5$ 3$4)3 *,'-3)%* &'2/R 2& 2* 1/32R$3? &'$ ;1(%$5$ A-1%& =233 '$)% *1,' ),)*$: l)3$%2) B$%/b/+$<. c^2%&'%24'& A2&2<$/*'2(Q* 9/32R$3? V-)+ &- ;1(%$5$ A-1%&.g E#F <+#"0B% *#&0%. ]$,$50$%TT. TEFE. '&&(d\\/$=)5$%2,)5$+2):-%4\TEFE\FT\02%&'%24'&7,2&2<$/*'2(*71/32R$3?7%-)+7&-7*1(%$5$7,-1%&:('(:Y B-% $6)5(3$. ;:^: FDEK. YE&' S$4:. F*& V$4: ;$**: GC%2<: TEFFH. 8)23$+ &- ()** 2/ &'$ ;&)&$ ;$/)&$ -/ U)%,' FZ. TEFF:"&'$% *&)&$* ')#$ 2/&%-+1,$+ 3$42*3)&2-/. #929. P:^: FMFD. FFZ&' a$/: C**$50:. F*& V$4: ;$**: GI/+: TEFFHh P:^: FEDT.

TEFF V$4: ;$**: GU+: TEFFHh P:^: TEXT. YD%+

 S$4:. F*&

 ;$**: G"R3): TEFFHh ;:^: KXZ. YD%+

 S$4:. F*&

 ;$**: G"R3): TEFFHhP:^: DTEZ. KE&' S$4: G`: l): TEFFH: I/ @$6)*. ) 0233 =)* 2/&%-+1,$+. /-& 2/#-3#2/4 )/ 2/&$%*&)&$ ,-5(),&. &- %$*&%2,&

2**1)/,$ -8 ) 02%&' ,$%&282,)&$ &- ) ,'23+ ='- ')+ )& 3$)*& -/$ ()%$/& ='- =)* ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/. 9:;: /-/,2&2<$/ /)&2-/)3. -%) 3)=813 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/& %$*2+2/4 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*h ) &$5(-%)%? %$(-%& -8 02%&' =-13+ 0$ 2**1$+ &- -&'$% ,'23+%$/:P:^: TXT. KT/+ S$4: G@$6: TEFFH: B-% ) 32*& -8 25524%)&2-/7%$3)&$+ *&)&$ 3)=* $/),&$+ 2/ TEFF. *$$ J)&2-/)3 A-/8$%$/,$-8 ;&)&$ S$42*3)&1%$*. I5524%)&2-/ _-32,? V$(-%& -/ TEFF I5524%)&2-/7V$3)&$+ S)=* )/+ V$*-31&2-/* 2/ &'$ ;&)&$*

G[)/1)%? Fm]$,$50$% Z. TEFFH. '&&(d\\===:/,*3:-%4\+$8)13&:)*(6e@)0I+jTDXWE:W l)3$%2) B$%/b/+$<. c^2%&'%24'& A2&2<$/*'2(Q* 9/32R$3? V-)+ &- ;1(%$5$ A-1%&.g E#F <+#"0B% *#&0%. ]$,$50$% TT.TEFE. '&&(d\\/$=)5$%2,)5$+2):-%4\TEFE\FT\02%&'%24'&7,2&2<$/*'2(*71/32R$3?7%-)+7&-7*1(%$5$7,-1%&:('(. ,2&2/4 0-&'*,'-3)%* ='- 0$32$#$ 2/&$%(%$&)&2-/ -8 &'$ A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$ ')* 0$$/ *$&&3$+ &- ,-#$% &'-*$ 0-%/ &- 1/)1&'-%2<$+ )32$/

 ()%$/&* )/+ &'-*$ ='- 0$32$#$ 2& ')* /-& 0$,)1*$ (%2-% ,)*$* +2+ /-& $6(%$**3? ,-/*2+$% ='$&'$% &'$ A3)1*$Q* *,-($2/,31+$+ 1/)1&'-%2<$+ )32$/ ()%$/&*: ̂ -&' ,-/*2+$% &')& )/? *&)&$ 3)= (1%(-%&2/4 &- +$82/$ 8$+$%)3. /)&2-/)3 ,2&2<$/*'2(

=-13+ 0$ 1/,-/*&2&1&2-/)3:Z C& 2&* )//1)3 5$$&2/4 2/ C141*& TEFF C^C P-1*$ -8 ]$3$4)&$* )+-(&$+ %$*-31&2-/ DED. )#)23)03$ )&

'&&(d\\===:)0)/-=:-%4\TEFF\EZ\TEFF)5DEDh *$$ )3*- &'$ %$(-%& ),,-5()/?2/4 &'$ %$*-31&2-/ )&'&&(d\\===:)0)/-=:-%4\=-%+(%$**\=(7,-/&$/&\823$*n831&&$%\FDFTXXWFXKV$*-31&2-/DEDV$(-%&:(+8:K ^3),RQ* S)= ]2,&2-/)%? ZZY GY&' O+: FXZXHh $/&%? 8-% c>1* *-32:gX  K& :h $/&%? )& c>1* *)/412/2*:gFE  MD.BC 89 /5%"=#. F ;)/+8-%+ A': YKD. WMW GJ:N: FKMMHh M APCVSO; a"V]"J. ;@CJSON UCISUCJ o ;@O_POJ NCSO7S"OPV . IUUIaVC@I"J SC` CJ] _V"AO]9VO LXT:EDpFqp0q GTEFFHh I*2+-% ^315. K- G)89 G#)"2# A)+.#D >5020,5# 1) ,#

 !"#-0&#.1N O$%"1 1F)P. J$= N-%R S)= [-1%/)3. (: F. ,-3: Y G",&-0$% FZ. FXWZH:FF M a"V]"J. UCISUCJ o NCSO7S"OPV . -4$"% 8--&/-&$ FE. )& LXT:EDpFqp) o 0qh [233 C: _%?-%. QC# E%14"%5RL)".

/010@#. /5%4-# %.& !"#-0&#.10%5 >5020,0501DI <. <$$")%BC ()" A#-)580.2 QF) S4.&"#& T#%"- )( 6.B#"1%0.1D. XZ N)3$G,-/&2/1$+:::H

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 6/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

324$)/,$ -8 &'$ *-#$%$24/ =$%$ *10>$,&* -8 &'$ *-#$%$24/ )/+ ,2&2<$/* -8 O/43)/+h &'2* 2/,31+$+ ($%*-/* 0-%/ &- c)32$/* 2/ )52&?g ='- -=$+ &$5(-%)%? )33$42)/,$ &- &'$ *-#$%$24/ ='23$ 2/ '2*

&$%%2&-%?:FT @'$ $6,$(&2-/* =$%$ ($%*-/* 0-%/ &- 5$50$%* -8 ) '-*&23$ -,,1(?2/4 8-%,$ -% &-+2(3-5)&* %$(%$*$/&2/4 )/-&'$% *-#$%$24/:

FD @'$ %$)*-/ =)* &')& &'$ ,'23+%$/ -8 ) '-*&23$

-,,1(?2/4 8-%,$ +2+ /-& -=$ )33$42)/,$ &- /-% =$%$ 0-%/ 1/+$% &'$ (%-&$,&2-/ -8 &'$ (%-($%

*-#$%$24/ -8 &'$ -,,1(2$+ &$%%2&-%?: @'$ ,'23+%$/ -8 +2(3-5)&*. )3&'-14' $/>-?2/4 &'$ &$5(-%)%? (%-&$,&2-/ -8 &'$ *-#$%$24/ ='23$ 2/ '2*\'$% +-52/2-/*. ),&1)33? -=$+ )33$42)/,$ &- )/+ ')+ )

,3)25 &- &'$ (%-&$,&2-/ -8 &'$ *-#$%$24/ ='-5 &'$2% ()%$/&* %$(%$*$/&$+ )& &'$ ,-1%& -8 &'$*-#$%$24/ 2/ ='-*$ +-52/2-/* &'$? =$%$ 0-%/: C33 ,2#232<$+ /)&2-/* %$,-4/2<$ )/+ )**$/& &- &'$2551/2&? -8 8-%$24/ +2(3-5)&* 8%-5 &'$2% >1%2*+2,&2-/. =2&'-1& ='2,' ) 8-%$24/ )50)**)+-% 524'&/-& 0$ )03$ &- $88$,&2#$3? %$(%$*$/& &'$ *$/+2/4 *-#$%$24/. 01& 2& =-13+ 0$ c2/,-/#$/2$/& )/++)/4$%-1* &- *-,2$&? ::: 28 p(%2#)&$ 2/+2#2+1)3 )32$/*q +2+ /-& -=$ &$5(-%)%? )/+ 3-,)3 )33$42)/,$.

)/+ =$%$ /-& )5$/)03$ &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 &'$ ,-1/&%?:gFM 

@'$ -%242/)3 8%)5$%* -8 &'$ 9:;: A-/*&2&1&2-/ +2+ /-& +$82/$ ,2&2<$/*'2( -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*.

)3&'-14' &'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/ %$k12%$+ &')& ) ($%*-/ ')#$ 0$$/ ) ,2&2<$/ -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* 8-% *$#$/?$)%* &- 0$ ) V$(%$*$/&)&2#$ )/+ 8-% /2/$ ?$)%* &- 0$ ) ;$/)&-%.FY )/+ &')& ) ($%*-/ 0$ ) /)&1%)37

 0-%/ ,2&2<$/ -% ) ,2&2<$/ )& &'$ &25$ -8 &'$ )+-(&2-/ -8 &'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/ 2/ -%+$% &- 0$ $324203$ &- 0$_%$*2+$/& G)/+ &'$%$8-%$. l2,$ _%$*2+$/&H:FW @'$ J)&1%)32<)&2-/ C,& -8 FZXE )/+ *10*$k1$/& ),&*1/&23 &'$ A2#23 V24'&* C,& -8 FKWW )/+ &'$ %)&282,)&2-/ -8 &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& +2+ /-& +$82/$

,2&2<$/*'2( 0? 02%&' =2&'2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*:FZ @'$*$ /)&1%)32<)&2-/ ),&* *($,282$+ &')& -/3? 8%$$='2&$ ($%*-/* ,-13+ 0$ /)&1%)32<$+: C* ) %$*13& -8 &'$ )0*$/,$ -8 )/? +$82/2&2-/ 2/ &'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/

-% 8$+$%)3 *&)&1&$* -8 9:;: ,2&2<$/*'2( 0? 02%&' 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. ,2&2<$/*'2( 0? 02%&' 2/ &'$9/2&$+ ;&)&$* 4$/$%)33? =)* ,-/*&%1$+ 2/ &'$ ,-/&$6& -8 &'$ O/432*' ,-55-/ 3)=: FK @'2* (%-#2+$+&'$ 8%)5$ -8 %$8$%$/,$ )/+ +$82/2&2-/ -8 c,2&2<$/*'2(g &')& &'$ 8%)5$%* -8 &'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/ =-13+

')#$ 1/+$%*&--+ )/+ )3*- (%-#2+$+ &'$ (%$72/+$($/+$/,$ (%$,$+$/& 8-% *&)&$ ,-55-/ 3)=*: @'$),k12*2&2-/ -8 ,2&2<$/*'2( 0? 02%&' )/+ 0? /)&1%)32<)&2-/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* +$($/+$+ -/ *&)&$

3)=*. 0-&' *&)&1&-%? )/+ ,-55-/ 3)=. 1/&23 &'$ $/),&5$/& -8 &'$ /)&1%)32<)&2-/ 3)= 2/ FZXE:FX

 @'$

G:::,-/&2/1$+HS:[: KKF. KKW o /: TM GFXKKH:FT 6.01#& 71%1#- 89 :).2 ;0+ <"= . FWX 9:;: WMX. WYY7WWK GFKXKHh MD.BC 89 /5%"=#. F ;)/+8-%+ A': )& WZEh /%580.U-/%-#. Z A-R$Q* V$(-%&* F. K7TF GFWEZHG)* %$(%2/&$+ 2/ #-3: M -8 &'$ FKTW $+2&2-/ $+2&$+ 0? [-'/ P: @'-5)* o [-'/ B:B%)*$%H:FD 6.01#& 71%1#- 89 :).2 ;0+ <"= . FWX 9:;: )& WZY. WKT7WKKh /%580.U- /%-#. Z A-R$Q* V$(-%&* )& FE7FF:FM 6.01#& 71%1#- 89 :).2 ;0+ <"= . FWX 9:;: )& WKD7WKK. ,2&2/4 &'$ ,)*$ -8 @'$ O6,')/4$. Z A%)/,': FFW GFKFTH:FY 9:;: A-/*&: )%&: I. LT. ,3: T GV$(%$*$/&)&2#$*H. 9:;: A-/*&: )%&: I. LD. ,3: D G;$/)&-%*H:FW 9:;: A-/*&: )%&: II. LF. ,3: Y:FZ C,& -8 U)%,' TW. FZXE. F ;&)&: FEDh C,& -8 [)/1)%? TX. FZXY. F ;&)&: MFMh C,& -8 C(%23 FM. FKET. T ;&)&: FYDh C,& -8B$0%1)%? FE. FKYY. FE ;&)&: WEM:FK  MD.BC 89 /5%"=#. F ;)/+8-%+ A': )& WMW. WYKh I*2+-% ^315. -4$"% 8--&/-&$ FE. )& (: F. ,-3: Y:FX

 "/$ *'-13+ /-&$ &')& &'$ +$&$%52/)&2-/ -8 9:;: ,2&2<$/*'2( 0? /)&1%)32<)&2-/ )3*- +$($/+$+ -/ *&)&$ 3)=* (%2-% &- &'$$/),&5$/& -8 &'$ 82%*& 8$+$%)3 /)&1%)32<)&2-/ ),&: @'$ $3$,&2-/ -8 C30$%& a)33)&2/ &- &'$ 9:;: ;$/)&$ 2/ FZXD =)**1,,$**8133? ,')33$/4$+ -/ &'$ 4%-1/+* &')& '$ ')+ /-& 0$$/ ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/ 8-% /2/$ ?$)%* )* %$k12%$+ 0? &'$A-/*&2&1&2-/: M C JJCS; "B A"JaVO;;. D%+ A-/4: MZ7YY. YZ7WT Ga)3$* o ;$)&-/ FKMXr&'$%$ 5)? 0$ *-5$ +288$%$/,$ 2/&'$ ()42/)&2-/ 0$&=$$/ +288$%$/& (%2/&2/4* -8 &'$ *)5$ ,-/4%$**2-/)3 +$0)&$*H G,-#$%2/4 ($%2-+ -8 B$0%1)%? TE7TK.

FZXMH: P$ ,3)25$+ &')& '$ ')+ 0$,-5$ ) ,2&2<$/ -8 $2&'$% l2%42/2) -% U)**),'1*$&&* )& 3$)*& /2/$ ?$)%* 0$8-%$ '2*$3$,&2-/: ̂ 1& ) 5)>-%2&? -8 &'$ ;$/)&$. 1(-/ )/ $6)52/)&2-/ -8 &'$ l2%42/2) )/+ U)**),'1*$&&* ,2&2<$/*'2( 3)=*. +$,2+$+&')& a)33)&2/ ')+ /-& *)&2*82$+ &'$ %$*2+$/,? -8 $2&'$% *&)&$ (%2-% &- 5-#2/4 &- _$//*?3#)/2). ='$%$ '$ 13&25)&$3? *$&&3$+)/+ =)* $3$,&$+ &- A-/4%$**: P$ ')+ /-& 0$$/ %$*2+$/& 2/ _$//*?3#)/2) 8-% /2/$ ?$)%* (%2-% &- $3$,&2-/: @'2* $6)5(3$

)3*- 2331*&%)&$* &'$ (%$7A-/*&2&1&2-/ (-*2&2-/ &')& 9:;: ,2&2<$/*'2( ,-13+ /-& $62*& =2&'-1& *&)&$ ,2&2<$/*'2(. ='2,' *-5$G,-/&2/1$+:::H

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 7/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

 J)&1%)32<)&2-/ C,& -8 FZXE. $/),&$+ (1%*1)/& &- &'$ A-/4%$**Q* (-=$%* 1/+$% &'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/.TE ,3$)%3? $*&)032*'$+ &'$ +$82/2&2-/ -8 ,2&2<$/*'2( 0? /)&1%)32<)&2-/. 01& A-/4%$**Q* *23$/,$ -/ &'$

2**1$ -8 ,2&2<$/*'2( 0? 02%&' 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* ,)1*$+ *-5$ ,-/81*2-/ )/+ +2*)4%$$5$/& )* &-=')& &'$ )((%-(%2)&$ +$82/2&2-/ =)*: B-% $6)5(3$. *-5$ ($%*-/* %$>$,&$+ &'$ 2+$) &')& O/432*',-55-/ 3)= (%-#2+$+ &'$ (%-($% %13$ 8-% ,2&2<$/*'2( 0? 02%&' 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*:TF C/+ 1/&23 &'$

A2#23 `)%. *-5$ $52/$/& >1%2*&* )/+ 3$4)3 *,'-3)%* 0$32$#$+ &')& &'$%$ =)* /- %$)3 ,2&2<$/*'2( -8&'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* *$()%)&$ 8%-5 ,2&2<$/*'2( 2/ ) *&)&$h &')& 2*. ) ($%*-/ =)* ) ,2&2<$/ -8 ) *&)&$

='2,' =)* ()%& -8 &'$ 9/2-/. &'$%$8-%$ ) ($%*-/ =)* ) ,2&2<$/ -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* 0? #2%&1$ -8 '2*,2&2<$/*'2( 2/ ) *&)&$:TT 

C3&'-14' &'$ O/432*' ,-55-/ 3)= )& &'$ &25$ -8 &'$ )+-(&2-/ -8 &'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/ ,-/*2+$%$+ ) ($%*-/ 0-%/ 2/ &'$ O/432*' +-52/2-/* &- )32$/ ()%$/&* &- 0$ )/ O/432*' ,2&2<$/ 1/3$** &'-*$ )32$/ ()%$/&* 82& 2/&- &'$ $6,$(&2-/* +$*,%20$+ )0-#$. )/+ )3&'-14' C5$%2,)/ 3)= )(()%$/&3? 4$/$%)33?),,$(&$+ &'2* (-*2&2-/. &'$%$ /$#$%&'$3$** )(($)%$+ &- 0$ *-5$ 1/,$%&)2/&? )* &- ='$&'$% ($%*-/*

 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* &- )32$/ ()%$/&* =$%$. 2/ 8),&. ,2&2<$/* -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*: ;-5$

*,'-3)%* )*,%20$ &'2* 1/,$%&)2/&? &- &'$ +$*2%$ -8 C5$%2,)/* &- $50%),$ 0-&' ) c,-/*$/*1)32*&g+-,&%2/$ -8 ,2&2<$/*'2(.TD 0? ='2,' ) ($%*-/ )/+ ) 4-#$%/5$/& ,-/*$/& &- 0$ 51&1)33? -0324)&$+.

G:::,-/&2/1$+H

3$4)3 *,'-3)%* ,-/&2/1$+ &- $*(-1*$ 1/&23 &'$ A2#23 `)%: C3&'-14' a)33)&2/ ')+ %$*2+$+ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* 8-% FD ?$)%*.'$ ')+ /-& *)&2*82$+ )33 &'$ %$k12%$5$/&* 8-% ,2&2<$/*'2( 2/ &'$ *&)&$* ='$%$ '$ ')+ %$*2+$+ /2/$ ?$)%* 0$8-%$ $3$,&2-/:

a)33)&2/ &%2$+ &- )%41$. 0.1#" %50%. &')& 9:;: ,2&2<$/*'2( =)* /-& +$($/+$/& -/ *&)&$ ,2&2<$/*'2( 3)=* ='2,' ')+ $62*&$+ 0$8-%$ 2/+$($/+$/,$ 0$,)1*$ 9:;: ,2&2<$/*'2( +$($/+$+ -/ )33$42)/,$ &- &'$ /$= /)&2-/ )/+ $#$/ ($%*-/* ='- ')+ 0$$/ /)&1%)370-%/ ,2&2<$/* -8 &'$ *&)&$* =$%$ /-& ,-/*2+$%$+ ,2&2<$/* -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* 28 &'$? ')+ /-& *'-=/)33$42)/,$ &- &'$ /$= 4-#$%/5$/& )/+ /)&2-/:TE 9:;: A-/*&: )%&: I. LK. ,3*: M o FK:TF 7##. $:4:. MD.BC 89 /5%"=#. F ;)/+8-%+ A': )& WYZh M a"V]"J. UCISUCJ o NCSO7S"OPV . -4$"% 8--&/-&$ FE. )&LXT:EDpFqp0q: /: Xh _O@OV P: ;AP9As o V "aOV; U: ;UI@P. AI@ItOJ;PI_ `I@P"9@ A"J;OJ@d ISSOaCS CSIOJ; IJ @PO

CUOVIACJ _"SI@N. YE7YM GFXKYH:TT 75%42C1#"RS)4-# /%-#-. FW `)33),$ DW. ZT GFKZDHh S$-/)%+ `: S$#?. s$//$&' S: s)%*& o ]$//2* [: U)'-/$?.

/010@#.-C0$ VS0-1)"0B%5 W#8#5)$+#.1X. O/,?,3-($+2) -8 &'$ C5$%2,)/ A-/*&2&1&2-/ TYK GFXKWH:TD A)*$* )%-*$ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* &'%-14' &'$ $)%3? /2/$&$$/&' ,$/&1%? ,-/,$%/2/4 &'$ 2**1$ -8 ,2&2<$/*'2( -8 /)&1%)37

 0-%/ *&)&$ ,2&2<$/* ='-*$ )33$42)/,$ &- &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* =)* 2/ k1$*&2-/: a$/$%)33?. *1,' ,2&2<$/* ')+ 3$8& &'$ 9/2&$+;&)&$* 8-% O/43)/+ -% O/432*' +-52/2-/* 0$8-%$ -% +1%2/4 &'$ V$#-31&2-/)%? `)% )/+ /- ),& 0? &'$5 -% &'$2% '-5$ *&)&$

')+ )882%5$+ &'$2% )33$42)/,$ &- &'$ 2/+$($/+$/& *&)&$ -% &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*: B),&-%* %$3$#)/& &- &'2* ,-/*$/*1)3,2&2<$/*'2( 2/,31+$+ ='$&'$% &'$ ($%*-/ =)* 0-%/ 0$8-%$ -% )8&$% [13? M. FZZWh ='$&'$% &'$ ($%*-/ 3$8& 8-% O/43)/+

 0$8-%$ -% )8&$% [13? M. FZZWh ='$&'$% &'$ ($%*-/ =)* ) 52/-% )& &'$ &25$ -8 +$()%&1%$ 8-% O/43)/+h ='$&'$% &'$ ($%*-/$3$,&$+ &- )882%5 9:;: )33$42)/,$ 1(-/ )&&)2/2/4 5)>-%2&?h )/+ ='$&'$% &'$ ($%*-/ =)* 0-%/ -% %$*2+2/4 2/ &$%%2&-%?

+1%2/4 2&* -,,1()&2-/ 0? &'$ ^%2&2*' -/ -% )8&$% [13? M. FZZW: B-% $6)5(3$. 28 ) ($%*-/ =)* 0-%/ ) ^%2&2*' *10>$,&. 2:$:. 0$8-%$ [13? M. FZZW. )/+ )* )/ )+13& +2+ /-& )+'$%$ &- &'$ 2/+$($/+$/& *&)&$* )8&$% [13? M. FZZW. '$ %$5)2/$+ ) ^%2&2*'*10>$,&: a$/$%)33?. 28 '$ =)* 0-%/ )8&$% [13? M. FZZW. '$ =)* ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/. 1/3$** '$ =)* 0-%/ 2/ ^%2&2*'7-,,1(2$+&$%%2&-%?. 3$8& 8-% O/43)/+ )* ) 52/-%. )/+ +2+ /-& $3$,& &- )882%5 '2* 9:;: ,2&2<$/*'2( =2&'2/ ) %$)*-/)03$ &25$ )8&$%

)&&)2/2/4 '2* 5)>-%2&?: 7## K.250- 89 7%05)"U- 7.42 S%",)" . TK 9:;: GD _$&$%*H XX GFKDEH: L41 -## *BK58%0.# 89 /)Y. K9:;: GM A%)/,'H TEK GFKEKH. ='$%$ &'$ A-1%& '$3+ &')& ) ($%*-/ ='- >-2/$+ &'$ ^%2&2*' C%5? )/+ 3$8& 8-% O/43)/+ *&233')+ 2/'$%2&)/,$ %24'&* 0$,)1*$ 2/2&2)33? '$ ')+ %$5)2/$+ 2/ J$= [$%*$? )8&$% [13? M. FZZW. )/+ )8&$% J$= [$%*$? ')+

 ()**$+ 3$42*3)&2-/ +$,3)%2/4 2&*$38 )/ 2/+$($/+$/& )/+ *-#$%$24/ *&)&$ )/+ 2&* %$*2+$/&* &- 0$ ,2&2<$/* -8 &'$ 2/+$($/+$/&*&)&$. )/+ &'1* '$ ')+ 0$,-5$ ) ,2&2<$/ -8 2/+$($/+$/& J$= [$%*$?: 7## %5-) 7C%.=- 89 W4$).1 . TK 9:;: GD _$&$%*H TMTGFKDEH. '-3+2/4 &')& ) =-5)/ 0-%/ 2/ ;-1&' A)%-32/) 0$8-%$ [13? M. FZZW. )/+ %$5)2/2/4 &'$%$ )8&$%=)%+. =)* ) ,2&2<$/-8 2/+$($/+$/& ;-1&' A)%-32/) )/+ '$% *10*$k1$/& 5)%%2)4$ &- ) ^%2&2*' *-3+2$% +1%2/4 &'$ -,,1()&2-/ -8 '$% '-5$&-=/+2+ /-& ,')/4$ &'2* *&)&1*: P-=$#$%. '$% *10*$k1$/& %$5-#)3 &- O/43)/+ =2&' '$% '1*0)/+ 2/ FZKT %$/+$%$+ '$% )

^%2&2*' *10>$,& =2&'2/ &'$ 5$)/2/4 -8 &'$ &%$)&? -8 FZXM ='2,' %$,-4/2<$+ 2/'$%2&)/,$ %24'&* 8-% ^%2&2*' *10>$,&* =2&' (%-($%&? 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*: B-% ) +2*,1**2-/ -8 ,)*$ 3)=. 3$42*3)&2#$ '2*&-%? -8 &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/&. )/+ )&'$-%? -8 ,2&2<$/*'2( 0)*$+ -/ 8)2%/$**. %$,2(%-,2&?. )/+ ,-/*$/&. *$$ `2332)5 @? U)?&-/. L0"1C"02C1 /010@#.-C0$ <.&

QC# /080B *0.0+4+. TT a$-: I5524%: S:[: TTF GTEEKH G)%412/4 &')& 8)2%/$** +2,&)&$+ &')& &'$ ,'23+%$/ -8 3)=8133?

 (%$*$/& )32$/* *'-13+ 0$ 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/* 1/+$% &'$ A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$. 01& +2+ /-& +2,&)&$ &')& ,'23+%$/ -8 1/3)=8133?G,-/&2/1$+:::H

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 8/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

)/+ )/ c)*,%2(&2#$g +-,&%2/$ 0? ='2,' ) ($%*-/ 2* )*,%20$+ ,2&2<$/*'2( 0? #2%&1$ -8 ,2%,15*&)/,$* 0$?-/+ '2* ,-/&%-3. *1,' )* 02%&' =2&'2/ ) ()%&2,13)% &$%%2&-%? -% 02%&' &- ()%$/&* =2&' ) ()%&2,13)%

,2&2<$/*'2(:TM 

C(()%$/&3?. MD.BC 89 /5%"=#. )/ FKMM J$= N-%R ,)*$.TY =)* &'$ 82%*& ,)*$ &- +$,2+$ &'$ 2**1$ -8

='$&'$% &'$ 9:;:70-%/ ,'23+ -8 )/ )32$/ =)* ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/:TW

 I& '$3+ &')& &'$ 9:;:70-%/ ,'23+ -8 )/I%2*' %$*2+$/& -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* ='- %$&1%/$+ &- I%$3)/+ )8&$% &'$ ,'23+Q* 02%&' )/+ +2$+ =2&'-1&$#$% +$,3)%2/4 $#$/ )/ 2/&$/& &- 0$ /)&1%)32<$+ =)* ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/: I& '$3+ &')& &'$ %24'& -8,2&2<$/*'2( =)* ) /)&2-/)3 %24'& /-& ($%&)2/2/4 &- &'$ 2/+2#2+1)3 *&)&$*hTZ &')& *&)&$ 3)=* ,-13+ /-3-/4$% +$82/$ 9:;: ,2&2<$/*'2(hTK )/+ &')& /)&2-/)3 3)=* 2/*&$)+ +$&$%52/$+ ,2&2<$/*'2(:TX I/

+$&$%52/2/4 &'$ )((%-(%2)&$ /)&2-/)3 3)=. &'$ ,-1%& %$>$,&$+ &'$ ,-/*$/*1)32*& +-,&%2/$ 2/ 8)#-% -8&'$ &%)+2&2-/)3 O/432*' ,-55-/73)= +-,&%2/$ -8 34- -)50:DE I& %$>$,&$+ &'$ )%415$/& &')& &'$)((32,)&2-/ -8 &'$ ,-55-/73)= +-,&%2/$ =)* 0)*$+ -/ 8$1+)3 (%2/,2(3$* 2/)((%-(%2)&$ &- &'$9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. ='2,' ')+ 0$$/ 8-1/+$+ -/ &'$ (%2/,2(3$* -8 ,-/*$/& 0$&=$$/ &'$ 4-#$%/5$/& )/+&'$ ($-(3$ &- 0$ 4-#$%/$+. )/+ 8-1/+ 2/*&$)+ &')& &'$ *23$/,$ -8 &'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/ )/+ &'$ 8$+$%)3

*&)&1&$* 2/+2,)&$+ &')& A-/4%$** )((%-#$+ &'$ )+-(&2-/ -8 &'$ &%)+2&2-/)3 ,-55-/73)= (-*2&2-/:DF @'$ ,-1%& )3*- 0$32$#$+ &')& $#$/ 28 8$+$%)3 3)=* +2+ /-& 2/+2,)&$ ),k12$*,$/,$ 2/ ,-55-/73)=

+-,&%2/$. &'$ ,-55-/73)= %13$ (%-#2+$+ ) =$337+$82/$+. 1/)50241-1*. %$32)03$ %13$ =2&'-1&,-/81*2/4 %$,-1%*$ &- &'$ *&)&1* -8 &'$ ()%$/&*:DT I& '$3+ &')& &'$ /)&2-/)3 3)= +$82/$+ )/? ($%*-/ 0-%/ =2&'2/ &'$ +-52/2-/* )/+ )33$42)/,$ -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )* ) ,2&2<$/. %$4)%+3$** -8 &'$ *&)&1*

-8 &'$ ()%$/&*:DD J-&=2&'*&)/+2/4 &'$ 4$/$%)3 ),,$(&)/,$ -8 34- -)50. 2/ &'$ 52/+* -8 5)/? ($%*-/*. &'$ 2**1$ -8 )1&-5)&2, ,2&2<$/*'2( 1(-/ 02%&' 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* &- )32$/ ()%$/&* =)*

*&233 /-& &- 0$ +$,2+$+ +$82/2&2#$3? 8-% 5)/? ?$)%*. ()%&2,13)%3? ='$%$ &'$ ()%$/&* =$%$ -8 )52/-%2&? %),$ -% $&'/2,2&?:

9/&23 &'$ A2#23 V24'&* C,& -8 FKWW )/+ &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/&. C8%2,)/ C5$%2,)/* =$%$ /-&,-/*2+$%$+ ,2&2<$/* -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*: I/ &'$ ,)*$ -8 W"#& 7B)11 89 7%.&()"& .DM &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*;1(%$5$ A-1%& '$3+ &')& C8%2,)/ C5$%2,)/* ,-13+ /-& 0$ ,2&2<$/* -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. $#$/ 28

&'$? =$%$ 8%$$. 0$,)1*$ &'$? =$%$ +$*,$/+$+ 8%-5 ($%*-/* 0%-14'& &- &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )* *3)#$*h

&'$ &$%5* -8 &'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/ +$5-/*&%)&$+ &')& *3)#$* =$%$ /-& ,-/*2+$%$+ ) ,3)** -8 ($%*-/*2/,31+$+ 2/ &'$ (-32&2,)3 ,-551/2&? )* ,2&2<$/*hDY

 )/+ &'$ #)%2-1* *&)&$ 3)=* 2/+2,)&$+ &')& C8%2,)/C5$%2,)/* ')+ /-& 0$$/ ,-/*2+$%$+ &- 0$ *&)&$ ,2&2<$/* )/+ &')& 2& =)* =2+$3? ($%52&&$+ &- &%$)&

G:::,-/&2/1$+H

 (%$*$/& )32$/* 51*& 0$ 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*H:TM ;AP9As o ;UI@P. -4$"% 8--&/-&$ TF. )& MT7WT:TY F ;)/+8-%+ A': YKDTW ;AP9As o ;UI@P. -4$"% 8--&/-&$ TF. )& YZ:TZ F ;)/8-%+ A': )& WMF:TK F ;)/8-%+ A': )& WMD7Y:TX  K&9 DE F ;)/+8-%+ A': )& WYW7WWD:DF  K&9 DT F ;)/+8-%+ A': )& WYK:DD F ;)/+8-%+ A': )& WWD:DM WE 9:;: GFX P-=:H DXD GFKYWH:DY WE 9:;: GFX P-=:H )& MFF:

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 9/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

&'$5 )* (%-($%&? )& &'$ &25$ -8 &'$ )+-(&2-/ -8 &'$ 8$+$%)3 A-/*&2&1&2-/:DW @'$ +$*,$/+)/&* -8*3)#$* ,-13+ /-& ')#$ ) ,2&2<$/*'2( %24'& ='2,' &'$2% )/,$*&-%* ')+ /-& ')+ 1(-/ &'$ 8-%5)&2-/ -8

&'$ 9/2-/ )/+ ='2,' /- 3)= ')+ *10*$k1$/&3? 4%)/&$+ &'$5 )& &'$ &25$ -8 &'$ W"#& 7B)11  +$,2*2-/:

F0% E'>()%%+)0 67%+37%+) 9+3 )0% !/A/: "/,0)- 6@) '* 4GHH

C3&'-14' &'$ (%25)%? )25 =)* &- *$,1%$ ,2&2<$/*'2( 8-% C8%2,)/ C5$%2,)/*. &'$ +$0)&$* -/ &'$,2&2<$/*'2( (%-#2*2-/* -8 &'$ A2#23 V24'&* C,& -8 FKWW )/+ &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& 2/+2,)&$

&')& &'$? =$%$ 2/&$/+$+ &- $6&$/+ 9:;: ,2&2<$/*'2( &- )33 ($%*-/* 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )/+*10>$,& &- 2&* >1%2*+2,&2-/ %$4)%+3$** -8 %),$. $&'/2,2&? -% )32$/)4$ -8 &'$ ()%$/&*:

DZ @'$ A2#23

V24'&* C,& -8 FKWW +$,3)%$+ &')& c)33 ($%*-/* 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )/+ /-& *10>$,& &- )/?8-%$24/ (-=$%. $6,31+2/4 I/+2)/* /-& &)6$+. )%$ '$%$0? +$,3)%$+ &- 0$ ,2&2<$/* -8 &'$ 9/2&$+;&)&$*:gDK @'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& +$,3)%$+ &')& cp)q33 ($%*-/* 0-%/ -% /)&1%)32<$+ 2/ &'$

9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )/+ *10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ &'$%$-8. )%$ ,2&2<$/* -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )/+ -8 &'$;&)&$ ='$%$2/ &'$? %$*2+$:g

DX @'$ A2#23 V24'&* C,& -8 FKWW +288$%* 8%-5 &'$ B-1%&$$/&'

C5$/+5$/& 0? 1*2/4 &'$ &$%5* c/-& *10>$,& &- )/? 8-%$24/ (-=$%g )/+ c$6,31+2/4 I/+2)/* /-&&)6$+:g

]1%2/4 &'$ +$0)&$* -/ &'$ ),&. ;$/)&-% @%150133 -8 I332/-2*. ,')2%5)/ -8 &'$ ,-552&&$$ &')&%$(-%&$+ &'$ ,2#23 %24'&* 0233. 5-#$+ &- )5$/+ &'$ 0233 *- &')& &'$ 82%*& *$/&$/,$ %$)+. cC33 ($%*-/*

 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. )/+ /-& *10>$,& &- )/? 8-%$24/ (-=$%. )%$ '$%$0? +$,3)%$+ &- 0$ ,2&2<$/*

-8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* =2&'-1& +2*&2/,&2-/ -8 ,-3-%:gME ;$/)&-% A-=)/ -8 _$//*?3#)/2). ='- -((-*$+ 0-&' &'$ A2#23 V24'&* C,& -8 FKWW )/+ &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/&. )*R$+ c='$&'$% 2& =233 /-& ')#$

&'$ $88$,& -8 /)&1%)32<2/4 &'$ ,'23+%$/ -8 A'2/$*$ )/+ a?(*2$* 0-%/ 2/ &'2* ,-1/&%?eg ;$/)&-%@%150133 %$(32$+. c9/+-10&$+3?:g @'$ &=- +2*)4%$$+ )* &- ='$&'$%. 1/+$% &'$ 3)= 2/ $62*&$/,$

 (%2-% &- &'$ $/),&5$/& -8 &'$ A2#23 V24'&* C,& -8 FKWW. A'2/$*$ C5$%2,)/* =$%$ ,2&2<$/* -8 &'$

9/2&$+ ;&)&$*: A-=)/ %)2*$+ &'$ *($,&$% -8 1/8$&&$%$+ A'2/$*$ 25524%)&2-/ &- A)328-%/2). %$*13&2/4$88$,&2#$3? 2/ *-5$&'2/4 &)/&)5-1/& &- ) &)R$-#$% -8 A)328-%/2) 0? &'$ A'2/$*$ $5(2%$. 28 &'$

 (%-(-*$+ 3)/41)4$ =$%$ )+-(&$+: @%150133 )*R$+ A-=)/ ='$&'$% &'$ ,'23+%$/ 0-%/ 2/_$//*?3#)/2) &- a$%5)/ ()%$/&* =$%$ /-& 9:;: ,2&2<$/*. &- ='2,' A-=)/ %$(32$+ &')& a$%5)/*=$%$ /-& A'2/$*$. C1*&%)32)/* -% P-&&$/&-&* -% &'$ 32R$: @%150133 %$(32$+ &')& &'$ 3)= 5)+$ /-

+2*&2/,&2-/ 0$&=$$/ &'$ ,'23+%$/ -8 a$%5)/* )/+ C*2)&2,* c)/+ &'$ ,'23+ -8 )/ C*2)&2, 2* >1*& )*51,' ) ,2&2<$/ )* &'$ ,'23+ -8 ) O1%-($)/:g S)&$% 2/ &'$ +$0)&$*. ;$/)&-% [-'/*-/ -8 U)%?3)/+

1%4$+ ;$/)&-% @%150133 &- +$3$&$ &'$ ('%)*$ c=2&'-1& +2*&2/,&2-/ -8 ,-3-%g 0$,)1*$ 2& =)*

DW WE 9:;: GFX P-=:H )& MEZ7MFW:DZ B-% )++2&2-/)3 )/)3?*$* -8 &'$ 3$42*3)&2#$ '2*&-%? -8 &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/&Q* A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$. *$$ &$*&25-/?-8 =2&/$**$* %$(%$*$/&2/4 -((-*2/4 (-*2&2-/* )& &'$ ?)0.1 S#%"0.2 L#()"# 1C# 74,B)++011## ). K++02"%10). %.& /5%0+-%.& 1C# 74,B)++011## ). 1C# /).-101410). )( 1C# /)++011## ). 1C# ?4&0B0%"DZ S)4-# )( A#$"#-#.1%108#- . ;$%2)3 J-: YE.FEM&' A-/4: GFXXYH G'$%$2/)8&$% ?)0.1 S#%"0.2 Hh *$$ )3*-. a)%%$&& O((*. QC# /010@#.-C0$ /5%4-#I < [M#20-5%108#

 S0-1)"DZ\ G[1/$ TE. TEFEH. )#)23)03$ )& ;-,2)3 ;,2$/,$ V$)%,' J$&=-%R =$0*2&$. '&&(d\\**%/:,-5\)0*&%),&jFWTZWWYh[)5$* A: P-. W#(0.0.2 [<+#"0B%.\I L0"1C"02C1 /010@#.-C0$ %.& 1C# H"020.%5 6.&#"-1%.&0.2 )( 1C# ]^1C <+#.&+#.1 .)/+ O32<)0$&' ̂ : ̀ ?+%). W#,4.=0.2 *)&#". <"24+#.1- <2%0.-1 L0"1C"02C1 /010@#.-C0$. 2/ I5524%)&2-/ _-32,? A$/&$%.

 *%&# 0. <+#"0B%I *D1C- _ J%B1- <,)41 L0"1C"02C1 /010@#.-C0$ G;$(&$50$% TEEXHh A')%3$* `--+. M)-0.2 /).1")5 )(

 <+#"0B%U- J414"#I 1C# /#.-4-Z L0"1C"02C1 /010@#.-C0$Z %.& K55#2%5 <50#.-. TT P)%#: [: S: o _10: _-3Q? MWY. YEM7YFXGFXXXHh A'%2*&-('$% S: O2*4%10$%. L0"1C"02C1 /010@#.-C0$ %.& 1C# /).-101410).. T J:N:9:S: V$#: YM GFXXZH:DK A: DF. LF. FM ;&)&: TZ:DX V)&282$+ [13? X. FKWK:ME A-/4: a3-0$. DX&' A-/4:. F*& ;$**: MXK GFKWWH:

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 10/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

1//$,$**)%? *2/,$ $#$/ =2&'-1& &'$ ('%)*$ '$ 1/+$%*&--+ &')& @%150133Q* (%-(-*$+ )5$/+5$/&c,-5(%$'$/+* )33 ($%*-/*. =2&'-1& )/? %$8$%$/,$ &- %),$ -% ,-3-%. ='- 5)? 0$ *- 0-%/:g @%150133

8$3& &')& 2& =)* 0$&&$% &- %$&)2/ &'$ ('%)*$ &- $3252/)&$ )/? +-10& -% +2*(1&$ )* &- &'$ 5$)/2/4 -8'2* )5$/+5$/&:

MF 

@'$%$ =)* )3*- ) +$0)&$ -#$% ='$&'$% I/+2)/* *'-13+ 0$ 2/,31+$+ -% $6,31+$+ 8%-5 &'$ ,2&2<$/*'2( (%-#2*2-/:

MT @%150133 0$32$#$+ &')& 28 &'$ I/+2)/* =$%$ *$()%)&$+ 8%-5 &'$2% &%20$* )/+

2/,-%(-%)&$+ 2/&- &'$ 5)2/*&%$)5 ,-551/2&? &'$/ &'$? )3%$)+? =$%$ 9:;: ,2&2<$/* 1/+$% &'$ 3)=:;$/)&-% S)/$ -8 s)/*)* +2*)4%$$+ )/+ 8$3& &')& ) 5-%$ $6(32,2& 0233 =)* /$$+$+ &- $6&$/+,2&2<$/*'2( &- I/+2)/*. ='2,' '$ 8)#-%$+: "&'$% ;$/)&-%* =2*'$+ &- $6,31+$ I/+2)/* /-& &)6$+.

='2,' )(()%$/&3? =)* 2/&$/+$+ &- $6,31+$ 1/)**2523)&$+ I/+2)/*. ='- =$%$ +$$5$+ &- 0$ 5-*&3?32#2/4 2/ )/ 1/,2#232<$+ ,-/+2&2-/ 2/ &'$2% &%20$*:MD ̀ '$/ &'$ $6,31*2-/ =)* )+-(&$+. ;$/)&-%P$/+$%*-/ -8 U2**-1%2 -0>$,&$+ &')& &'$ ,2&2<$/*'2( -8 ='2&$ ($%*-/* +2+ /-& +$($/+ -/ ='$&'$%-% /-& &'$? =$%$ &)6$+ )/+ &')& 2& =)* 1/8)2% &- 5)R$ *1,' ) +2*&2/,&2-/ 8-% I/+2)/*. ()%&2,13)%3?*2/,$ &'$ 2**1$ -8 &)6)&2-/ =)* 2%%$3$#)/& &- &'$ 2**1$ -8 )**2523)&2-/:MM 

]1%2/4 &'$ +$0)&$* -/ &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/&. ;$/)&-% P-=)%+ -8 U2,'24)/ 5-#$+ &- )5$/+

2& 0? )++2/4 &'$ 82%*& *$/&$/,$ 2/ 2&* (%$*$/& 8-%5. 52/1* &'$ ('%)*$ c-% /)&1%)32<$+:g

MY

 ;$/)&-%A-=)/ )4)2/ -0>$,&$+ &- 3)/41)4$ &')& '$ 8$3& =-13+ 2/,31+$ %),$* *1,' )* &'$ A'2/$*$ )/+ (%$#$/& A)328-%/2) 8%-5 +$)32/4 =2&' &'$ 5)**2#$ A'2/$*$ 25524%)/& (-(13)&2-/ )* 2& *)= 82&:MW P$)4)2/ 2/#-R$+ &'$ 8$)% &')& A)328-%/2) =-13+ 0$ -#$%%1/ 0? A'2/$*$. _$//*?3#)/2) 0? a?(*2$*: P$

 0$32$#$+ &')& &'$ ($-(3$ -8 +288$%$/& %),$* )/+ ,13&1%$* ,-13+ /-& 52/43$: ;$/)&-% A-//$** -8A)328-%/2) %$(32$+ &')& '$ ')+ *1((-%&$+ &'$ A2#23 V24'&* C,& -8 FKWW )/+ ')+ /- (%-03$5 =2&'

,-/*&2&1&2-/)33? 41)%)/&$$2/4 &'$ 9:;:70-%/ ,'23+%$/ -8 U-/4-32)/ ()%$/&* ,2#23 %24'&* )/+ $k1)3 (%-&$,&2-/. '2* *1((-%& )(()%$/&3? 2/831$/,$+ 0? '2* 0$32$8 &')& &'$ (-(13)&2-/ -8 /-/7O1%-($)/25524%)/&* )/+ &'$2% +$*,$/+)/&* =-13+ /-& 2/,%$)*$ *24/282,)/&3?:

MZ 

@'$%$ =)* )3*- +$0)&$ )* &- ='$&'$% I/+2)/* *'-13+ 0$ $6,31+$+ 8%-5 &'$ *,-($ -8 &'$ A2&2<$/*'2(A3)1*$ -8 &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& )/+ ='$&'$% &'$? =$%$ $6,31+$+ 0? &'$ ('%)*$ c*10>$,& &-&'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ &'$%$-8:gMK C(()%$/&3? 5-*& -8 &'$ ;$/)&-%* *1((-%&$+ &'$ 2+$) -8 $6,31+2/4I/+2)/* 01& +2*)4%$$+ )* &- ='$&'$% &'$ ('%)*$ c$6,31+2/4 I/+2)/* /-& &)6$+g *'-13+ 0$ 2/*$%&$+)* 2& ')+ 0$$/ 2/ &'$ A2#23 V24'&* C,& -8 FKWW: ;$#$%)3 ;$/)&-%* )%41$+ &')& c*10>$,& &- &'$

 >1%2*+2,&2-/g 5$)/& &'$ 8133 )/+ ,-5(3$&$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. )/+ &'$ I/+2)/* ')+)3=)?* 0$$/ ,-/*2+$%$+ *10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 &'$2% &%20$*. ='2,' =$%$ k1)*278-%$24/

/)&2-/*hMX

 *-5$ )3*- 8$3& &')& &'$ &)6)&2-/ %$k12%$5$/& =)* (%-03$5)&2,: ;-5$ ;$/)&-%* )%41$+&')& c$6,31+2/4 I/+2)/* /-& &)6$+g =)* 4--+ $/-14' 8-% &'$ A2#23 V24'&* C,& *- 2& =)* )((%-(%2)&$8-% &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/&h &'$? )3*- )%41$+ &')& I/+2)/* =$%$ *10>$,& &- 9:;: >1%2*+2,&2-/ 8-%

MF A-/4: a3-0$. DX&' A-/4:. F*& ;$**: YZD7YZM GFKWWH:MT A-/4: a3-0$. DX&' A-/4:. F*& ;$**: MXK7MXX GFKWWH:MD

 A-/4: a3-0$. DX

&'

 A-/4:. F

*&

 ;$**: YZF7YZD GFKWWH:MM A-/4: a3-0$. DX&' A-/4:. F*& ;$**: YZF GFKWWH:MY A-/4: a3-0$. DX&' A-/4:. F*& ;$**: TKXE GFKWWH:MW A-/4: a3-0$. DX&' A-/4:. F*& ;$**: TKXE7TKXF GFKWWH:MZ A-/4: a3-0$. DX&' A-/4:. F*& ;$**: TKXF7TKXT GFKWWH:MK A-/4: a3-0$. DX&' A-/4:. F*& ;$**: TKXE7TKXZ GFKWWH:MX A-/4: a3-0$. DX&' A-/4:. F*& ;$**: TKXE. TKXD. TKXY. TKXZ GFKWWH G%$5)%R* -8 ;$/)&-% P-=)%+ -8 U2,'24)/. ;$/)&-%

@%150133 -8 I332/-2*. ;$/)&-% `2332)5* -8 "%$4-/H:

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 11/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

) #)%2$&? -8 (1%(-*$* *- &'$ c*10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/g 3)/41)4$ =)* 2/*1882,2$/&3? ,3$)%:YE 93&25)&$3?. &'$ ;$/)&$ %$>$,&$+ &'$ 2/*$%&2-/ -8 c$6,31+2/4 I/+2)/* /-& &)6$+.g )3&'-14' )& 3$)*&

-/$ ;$/)&-% *)2+ '$ #-&$+ )4)2/*& &'2* 2/*$%&2-/ 0$,)1*$ '$ 8)#-%$+ $6&$/+2/4 ,2&2<$/*'2( &-I/+2)/* )/+ /-& 0$,)1*$ '$ 0$32$#$+ &')& &'$ c*10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ 3)/41)4$g $6,31+$+I/+2)/* )3%$)+?:YF 

.+#%*/ ;%8%*, <E F4+' G#3 2$H 9+3 I7H <E F#7H#+, 

]$*(2&$ &'$ ,3)%282,)&2-/ 2/ &'$ +$0)&$* &')& %),$. $&'/2,2&?. )/+ )32$/)4$ -8 ()%$/&* =-13+ /-&

)88$,& &'$ %24'& &- ,2&2<$/*'2( 0? 02%&' 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. &'$ 2**1$ ,-/,$%/2/4 &'$ 5$)/2/4 -8&'$ A2#23 V24'&* C,& -8 FKWW )/+ &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& =)* /-& *$&&3$+ 1/&23 &'$ FKXK ,)*$ -86.01#& 71%1#- 89 :).2 ;0+ <"= :YT C* &'$ +$0)&$* )0-1& &'-*$ 3)=* 2/+2,)&$. )/ 1/+$%3?2/4 (%-03$5)(($)%* &- ')#$ 0$$/ &'$ )&&2&1+$ &')& ,$%&)2/ )32$/ %),$* )/+ J)&2#$ C5$%2,)/*. 32R$ &'$ C8%2,)/C5$%2,)/* 2/ W"#& 7B)11 . ,-13+ /-& 0$ 5$50$%* -8 &'$ C5$%2,)/ (-32&2,)3 ,-551/2&? 0$,)1*$

&'$? ')+ /-& 0$$/ 5$50$%* -8 &'$ ,-551/2&? &')& ?2$3+$+ &'$ ]$,3)%)&2-/ -8 I/+$($/+$/,$ )/+&'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/: @'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* ;1(%$5$ A-1%& +2*,1**$+ &'$ ,-/4%$**2-/)3 +$0)&$* +$*,%20$+)0-#$. /-&2/4 &')& )3&'-14' &'$? =$%$ /-& )+52**203$ )* $#2+$/,$ &- ,-/&%-3 &'$ 5$)/2/4 -8 &'$B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/&. &'$? =$%$ 25(-%&)/& )* )/ 2/+2,)&2-/ -8 &'$ ,-/&$5(-%)/$-1* 3$4)3

-(2/2-/ -8 >1%2*&* )/+ 3$42*3)&-%* )/+ *'-=$+ &')& A-/4%$** ')+ $6(32,2&3? ,-/*2+$%$+ &'$)((32,)&2-/ -8 &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& &- &'$ A'2/$*$ G)/+ -&'$% 9:;:70-%/ ,'23+%$/ -8)32$/*H:YD 

@'$ A-1%& &%),$+ &'$ '2*&-%? -8 &'$ *&)&1&-%? )/+ ,-55-/ 3)= %$4)%+2/4  34- -)50 2/ O/43)/+ )/+C5$%2,)YM )/+ +2*&2/412*'$+ )/-&'$% ,)*$ 2/ ='2,' )/ )33$4$+ A'2/$*$ C5$%2,)/ ')+ 0$$/ 8-1/+

/-& &- 0$ ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/. /-&2/4 &')& &'$ 2**1$ ')+ 0$$/ &'$ 2/*1882,2$/,? -8 (%--8 &')& &'$ ,3)25)/&')+ 0$$/ 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*:YY ^1& ='$%$ 02%&' 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* =)* ,3$)%. ) ,'23+ -8A'2/$*$ ()%$/&* =)*. 2/ &'$ A-1%&Q* -(2/2-/. +$82/2&$3? ) ,2&2<$/ 1/+$% &'$ B-1%&$$/&'

C5$/+5$/&. $#$/ &'-14' A'2/$*$ )32$/* =$%$ 2/$324203$ &- /)&1%)32<$ 1/+$% &'$/7$62*&2/4 3)=:YW @'$ A-1%& %$>$,&$+ &'$ )%415$/& &')& &'$ ,'23+ =)* 0-%/ *10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 &'$ A'2/$*$

$5($%-% )/+ -1&*2+$ &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* 0$,)1*$ '2* )33$42)/,$ )/+ ,2&2<$/*'2(+$%2#$+ 8%-5 '2* ()%$/&*Q %$5)2/2/4 *10>$,&* &- &'$ A'2/$*$ $5($%-% 1/+$% &%$)&2$* 0$&=$$/ &'$9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )/+ A'2/) )/+ &'$ /)&1%)32<)&2-/ 3)=*:YZ I& /-&$+ )/+ %$>$,&$+ &'$ 75%42C1#"RS)4-# 

A-1%&Q* 2/),,1%)&$ *&)&$5$/& &')& &'$ $6,$(&2-/* &- 34- -)50 2/,31+$+ &'$ ,'23+%$/ -8 ,-/*13* )/+-&'$% )32$/* 4$/$%)33? 2/ )++2&2-/ &- &'$ ,'23+%$/ -8 )50)**)+-%2)373$#$3 +2(3-5)&* )/+ &'$

,'23+%$/ -8 '-*&23$. -,,1(?2/4 8-%,$*:YK

 @'$ +$,2*2-/ )331+$* &- ) ,-/&$5(-%)/$-1* J$= [$%*$?,)*$ &')& '$3+ &')& ) 9:;:70-%/ ,'23+ -8 ;,-&&2*' ()%$/&* +-52,23$+ 01& /-& /)&1%)32<$+ 2/ &'$9/2&$+ ;&)&$* =)* 0-%/ *10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* =2&'2/ &'$ 5$)/2/4 -8 &'$

YE A-/4: a3-0$. DX&' A-/4:. F*& ;$**: TKXT. TKXD. TKXY GFKWWH G%$5)%R* -8 ;$/)&-% ]--32&&3$ -8 `2*,-/*2/. ;$/)&-%

[-'/*-/ -8 U)%?3)/+. ;$/)&-% P$/+%2,R* -8 I/+2)/)H:YF A-/4: a3-0$. DX&' A-/4:. F*& ;$**: TKXZ GFKWWH G%$5)%R* -8 ;$/)&-% ;)13*01%? -8 ]$3)=)%$H:YT FWX 9:;: WMX GFKXKH:YD FWX 9:;: )& WXZ7WXX:YM FWX 9:;: )& WYY7WZY:YY FWX 9:;: )& WXW7WXZ:YW FWX 9:;: )& ZEY:YZ FWX 9:;: )& WXM7ZEY:YK FWX 9:;: )& WZY. WKT7WKK:

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 12/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& )/+ /-& *10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 ) 8-%$24/ ,-1/&%? =2&'2/ &'$ 5$)/2/4-8 &'$ A2#23 V24'&* C,& -8 FKWW:YX @'$ A-1%& '$3+ &')& &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& )882%5$+ &'$

&%)+2&2-/)3 34- -)50 %13$. 2/,31+2/4 &'$ $6,$(&2-/* -8 ,'23+%$/ 0-%/ &- 8-%$24/ +2(3-5)&*. &- '-*&23$-,,1(?2/4 8-%,$* -% -/ 8-%$24/ (1032, *'2(*. )/+ )++$+ ) /$= $6,$(&2-/ -8 ,'23+%$/ -8 I/+2)/*-=2/4 +2%$,& )33$42)/,$ &- &'$2% &%20$*:WE I& 81%&'$% '$3+ &')& &'$ cB-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& ::: ')*

,-/8$%%$+ /- )1&'-%2&? 1(-/ A-/4%$** &- %$*&%2,& &'$ $88$,& -8 02%&'. +$,3)%$+ 0? &'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/ &-,-/*&2&1&$ ) *1882,2$/& )/+ ,-5(3$&$ %24'& &- ,2&2<$/*'2(gWF )/+ &')& 2& 2* c&'%-14'-1& )882%5)&2#$

)/+ +$,3)%)&-%?. 2/&$/+$+ &- )33)? +-10&* )/+ *$&&3$ ,-/&%-#$%*2$* ='2,' ')+ )%2*$/. )/+ /-& &-25(-*$ )/? /$= %$*&%2,&2-/* 1(-/ ,2&2<$/*'2(:gWT 

O#$/ )8&$% &'$ A2#23 V24'&* C,& -8 FKWW. &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& )/+ &'$ :).2 ;0+ <"=  +$,2*2-/ *$,1%$+ )1&-5)&2, 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2( 8-% )33 ($%*-/* 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )/+*10>$,& &- 2&* >1%2*+2,&2-/. J)&2#$ C5$%2,)/* =$%$ /-& ,-/*2+$%$+ &- 0$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/&,2&2<$/* 0$,)1*$ &'$ 9:;: ;1(%$5$ A-1%& +$&$%52/$+ &')& &'$? =$%$ /-& 0-%/ c*10>$,& &- &'$

 >1%2*+2,&2-/g -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*: B-33-=2/4 $)%32$% ,)*$* &')& ')+ '$3+ &')& I/+2)/ &%20$* )/+ &'$2%

5$50$%* =$%$ /-& *10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. )/+ 3)/41)4$ 2/ &'$A-/*&2&1&2-/ )/+ &'$ A2#23 V24'&* C,& -8 FKWW &')& 2/,31+$+ -/3? cI/+2)/* /-& &)6$+.g &'$ A-1%& 2/

 >5= 89 :05=0.-

WD

 '$3+ &')& I/+2)/* =$%$ /-& ,2&2<$/* -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* 1/3$** &'$? ')+ 0$$//)&1%)32<$+ 0? &%$)&? -% 0? ) 8$+$%)3 ,-33$,&2#$ /)&1%)32<)&2-/ *&)&1&$. -% &)6$+ -% %$,-4/2<$+ )* ),2&2<$/ 0? &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* -% ) *&)&$: C& &'$ &25$ -8 &'$ +$,2*2-/. J)&2#$ C5$%2,)/* =$%$ /-&

$324203$ &- 0$ /)&1%)32<$+ -/ )/ 2/+2#2+1)3 0)*2* ),,-%+2/4 &- &'$ 1*1)3 /)&1%)32<)&2-/ (%-,$+1%$*)/+ =$%$ -/3? /)&1%)32<$+ 0? &%$)&? -% *&)&1&$:WM @'$ A-1%& 8-1/+ &')& J)&2#$ C5$%2,)/* ='- ')+

/-& 0$$/ &)6$+ -% /)&1%)32<$+ *&233 -=$+ 255$+2)&$ )33$42)/,$ &- &'$ &%20$ )/+ =$%$ 5$50$%* -8 )/2/+$($/+$/& (-32&2,)3 ,-551/2&? )/+ &'1* =$%$ /-& *10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*)/+ =$%$ /-& ,2&2<$/* -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*:WY @'$ )%415$/& $,'-$* &'-*$ 2/ &'$ +$0)&$* )0-1& &'$

B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/&: [-'/ O3R ')+ *$()%)&$+ 8%-5 '2* &%20$ )/+ 32#$+ c1/+$% &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 J$0%)*R)g )/+ ')+ )**2523)&$+ 2/&- 5)2/*&%$)5 *-,2$&?: ]$*(2&$ &'$*$ 8),&*. &'$ A-1%& '$3+ &')& '$

=)* /-& ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/ /-% ,-13+ '$ 0$,-5$ -/$ 2/ &'$ )0*$/,$ -8 &%$)&? -% 8$+$%)3 *&)&1&-%? ),&2-/%$4)%+2/4 '2* &%20$: J)&2#$ C5$%2,)/* )%$ *&233 /-& B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& ,2&2<$/*hWW &'$? )%$

,2&2<$/* 0? #2%&1$ -8 -/$ -8 &'$ #)%2-1* *&)&1&$* )/+ &%$)&2$* /)&1%)32<2/4 *($,282, &%20$*. &'$A2&2<$/*'2( C,& -8 FXTM G='2,' =)* )50241-1* %$4)%+2/4 &'-*$ 0-%/ )8&$% &'$ ),&H.WZ &'$

YX FWX 9:;: )& WXT:WE FWX 9:;: )& WXD:WF FWX 9:;: )& ZEDh -## %5-) <(")D0+ 89 A4-= . DKZ 9:;: TYD. TWW7TWZ GFXWZH. ='2,' /-&$+ )& 8--&/-&$ TK &')& *-5$ ')#$%$8$%%$+ &- &'2* *&)&$5$/& )* ) '-3+2/4 )/+ -&'$%* ')#$ %$8$%%$+ &- 2& )* -02&$% +2,&15. 01& ='2,' +$$5$+ 2& $/&2&3$+ &-4%$)& =$24'& %$4)%+3$** -8 ='$&'$% 2& =)* +2,&15 -% ) '-3+2/4:WT FWX 9:;: )& WKK:WD FFT 9:;: XM GFKKMH:WM C//) ̀ 2332)5* ;')#$%*. < /#.14"D )( W#8#5)$0.2 /010@#.-C0$ M%F %.& 1C# E#,"%-=% K.(54#.B#I < /#.1#..0%5 >--%D.

ZE J$0%)*R) S: V$#: MWT. MKZ7MKX GFXXFH:WY FFT 9:;: )& FET. FEX:WW 9/+$% A)2#"- 89 L#55#0. MEF 9:;: KFY GFXZFH. &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* ;1(%$5$ A-1%&Q* ,1%%$/& (-*2&2-/ )(($)%* &- 0$ &')&

&'$%$ )%$ &'%$$ &?($* -8 ,2&2<$/*'2(d &'$ &=- +$82/$+ 2/ &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/&. 02%&' )/+ /)&1%)32<)&2-/ 2/ &'$9/2&$+ ;&)&$* ='$/ *10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ &'$%$-8. )/+ /-/7B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& *&)&1&-%? ,2&2<$/*'2(. $:4:. &'$,2&2<$/*'2( -8 J)&2#$ C5$%2,)/*. ($%*-/* 0-%/ )0%-)+ &- 9:;: ,2&2<$/*. )/+ ($%*-/* 0-%/ 2/ _1$%&- V2,-. a1)5 )/+ &'$l2%42/ I*3)/+*: 7## [: U2,')$3 U$+2/). QC# !"#-0&#.10%5 `4%50(0B%10). /5%4-# 0. 1C0- L0B#.1#..0%5 T#%"I QC# E##& 1)

 >50+0.%1# 1C# E%14"%5 L)". /010@#. A#a40"#+#.1 . FT "R3)'-5) A2&? 9/2#: S: V$#: TYD. TWY GFXKZH:WZ C,& -8 [1/$ T. FXTM. ,: TDD. MD ;&)&: TYD:

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 13/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

 J)&2-/)32&? C,& -8 FXME G='2,' 82/)33? )/+ 1/)50241-1*3? +$,3)%$+ )33 J)&2#$ C5$%2,)/* 0-%/ 2/&'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* &- 0$ 9:;: ,2&2<$/*H.WK -% &'$ I5524%)&2-/ )/+ J)&2-/)32&? C,&:WX 

?%,/-:9)/A% 8('&'-9:-

!'+-)/)>)/'+9: 9+3 #)9)>)'(= 67%+37%+)-

I/ %$,$/& A-/4%$**$* &'$%$ ')#$ 0$$/ #)%2-1* (%-(-*)3* )25$+ )& $6,31+2/4 &'$ ,'23+%$/ -81/)1&'-%2<$+ )32$/* )/+ $#$/ /-/25524%)/& )32$/* 8%-5 )1&-5)&2, 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2(. ()%&3? &-%$5-#$ )/ 2/,$/&2#$ 8-% )32$/* &- $/&$% &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* 233$4)33?. -% $/&$% 3$4)33? -/ )/-/25524%)/& #2*) )/+ &'$/ 233$4)33? *&)? 0$?-/+ &'$ #2*) ($%2-+:ZE @'$*$ (%-(-*)3* &)R$ &'$ 8-%5-8 )5$/+5$/&* &- &'$ A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$ -8 &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& -% &- &'$ *&)&1&-%?

 (%-#2*2-/* -/ 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2( )/+ ,-5(%2*$ #)%2-1* )((%-),'$*:ZF C3&'-14' *1,' (%-(-*)3*')#$ 0$$/ 2/&%-+1,$+ 2/ &'$ FFT

&' A-/4%$**. /-/$ -8 &'$5 ')#$ (%-4%$**$+ 0$?-/+ 2/&%-+1,&2-/:

ZT 

WK A: KZW. LTEFG0H. YM ;&)&: FFDZ. FFYK:WX A: MZZ. LDEFG)HGTH. WW ;&)&: FWD. TDY GFXYTHh ,-+282$+ )* )5$/+$+ )& K 9:;:A: LFMEFG0H:ZE C32$/* )%$ *$$/ )* =2332/4 &- $/&$% &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* 233$4)33? 2/ -%+$% &- ')#$ ) ,'23+ '$%$. 0$,)1*$ &'$? %$)32<$ &')&

='$/ &'$ 9:;:7,2&2<$/ ,'23+ %$),'$* '2*\'$% 5)>-%2&?. '$\*'$ 5)? 0%2/4 255$+2)&$ %$3)&2#$* -#$% &- &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*.$#$/ 28 &'$ 25524%)&2-/ $/8-%,$5$/& )1&'-%2&2$* +$,2+$ &- +$(-%& &'$ ()%$/&*. -% &'$? ,'--*$ &- 3$)#$. 2/ &'$ 2/&$%25: ;-&'$ )1&-5)&2, 02%&'%24'& 42#$* 1/)1&'-%2<$+ )32$/* ) 8--& 2/ &'$ +--% &- &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )/+ 2&* 0$/$82&*: FYF A-/4 V$,:OKFW G+)23? $+: C(%23 TK. TEEYH GV$(: _)13Hh FMX /).29 A#B9 OYMZ G+)23? $+: U)%,' TF. TEEDH G*&)&$5$/& -8 V$(: _)13HhFMD /).29 A#B9 PZDYM7W G+)23? $+: ;$(&$50$% FW. FXXZH G*&)&$5$/&* -8 V$(: ;52&' -8 @$6)* )/+ V$(: ^230%)?Hh FMT

/).29 A#B9 PTMKZ G+)23? $+: U)%,' TE. FXXWH G*&)&$5$/& -8 V$(: ]$)3Hh FMF /).29 A#B9 OFTZ7K G+)23? $+: [)/1)%? FX.FXXYH G*&)&$5$/& -8 V$(: ^$23$/*-/Hh FME /).29 A#B9 OMYW G+)23? $+: U)%,' FW. FXXMH G*&)&$5$/& -8 V$(: @)?3-%Hh FDX/).29 A#B9 ;FFXXZ G+)23? $+: ;$(&$50$% TE. FXXDH G*&)&$5$/& -8 ;$/: V$2+H. O TFWK7TFWX G+)23? $+: ;$(&$50$% FY.FXXDH G*&)&$5$/& -8 V$(: a)33$43?H. ;FEDZK G+)23? $+: C141*& M. FXXDH G*&)&$5$/& -8 ;$/: V$2+H. PMMDZ G+)23? $+: [13?

F. FXXDH G*&)&$5$/& -8 V$(: a)33$43?H. PFEEY G+)23? $+: U)%,' D. FXXDH G*&)&$5$/& -8 V$(: a)33$43?H. OMEX G+)23? $+:B$0%1)%? TD. FXXDH G*&)&$5$/& -8 V$(: ^$23$/*-/Hh FDK /).29 A#B9 OTYZT7D G+)23? $+: ;$(&$50$% FE. FXXTH G*&)&$5$/&-8 V$(: a)33$43?H. OFKMZ G+)23? $+: [1/$ FW. FXXTH G*&)&$5$/& -8 V$(: a)33$43?H. OMMF G+)23? $+: B$0%1)%? TW. FXXTHG*&)&$5$/& -8 V$(: a)33$43?Hh FDZ /).29 A#B9 PKFKE G+)23? $+: ",&-0$% TT. FXXFH G*&)&$5$/& -8 V$(: a)33$43?H. PZZKK

G+)23? $+: ",&-0$% FE. FXXFH G*&)&$5$/& -8 V$(: ]-%/)/H:

;$/)&-% I/'-8$ ,2&$+ &'$ A$/&$% 8-% I5524%)&2-/ ;&1+2$* GAI;H. ) /-/(%-82& 25524%)&2-/ %$8-%5 -%4)/2<)&2-/. )/+ &'$ J)&2-/)3 A$/&$% 8-% P$)3&' ;&)&2*&2,* 8-% &'$ *&)&2*&2, &')& 2/ TEET &'$%$ =$%$ )0-1& DKD.EEE 0)02$* 0-%/ &- 1/)1&'-%2<$+)32$/*. ='2,' %$(%$*$/&$+ )0-1& X:Yu -8 )33 9:;: 02%&'* 2/ TEET: FYT /).29 A#B9 ;TYKT G+)23? $+: U)%,' DE. TEEWHh *$$

)3*- ;&$#$/ C: A)5)%-&). AI;. L%B=2")4.&#"I L0"1C- 1) K++02"%.1- 0. <+#"0B%Z ]bcd 1) edde. )& F. Y. TW. )/+ TK G[13?TEEYH:

A-5()%$ &'$*$ *&)&2*&2,* =2&' ) 5-%$ %$,$/& *&)&2*&2,)3 )/)3?*2* +-/$ 0? &'$ _$= P2*()/2, A$/&$%. ) _$= V$*$)%,'A$/&$% _%->$,&. $*&25)&2/4 &')& )0-1& DME.EEE 0)02$* =$%$ 0-%/ &- 1/)1&'-%2<$+ )32$/* 2/ TEEK. %$(%$*$/&2/4 )0-1& Ku

-8 )33 9:;: 02%&'* 2/ TEEK. )/+ &')& )0-1& M 52332-/ 9:;:70-%/ ,'23+%$/ -8 1/)1&'-%2<$+ )32$/ ()%$/&* %$*2+$+ 2/ &'$9/2&$+ ;&)&$* 2/ TEEX: [$88%$? ;: _)**$3 )/+ _)13 @)?3-%. _$= P2*()/2, A$/&$% V$(-%&. 6.%41C)"0@#& K++02"%.1- %.&QC#0" 6979RL)". /C05&"#. GC141*& FF. TEFEH. )#)23)03$ )& '&&(d\\($='2*()/2,:-%4\%$(-%&*\%$(-%&:('(eV$(-%&I]jFTY:ZF @'$ 3$42*3)&2#$ (%-(-*)3* +2*,1**$+ 2/ &'2* %$(-%& =$%$ *144$*&$+ 2/ ;,'1,R o ;52&'. -4$"% 8--&/-&$ TF. )& FFW7FME.

)* ) 5-%$ )((%-(%2)&$ 3)= -8 ,2&2<$/*'2(: @'$2% (%-(-*)3 2* &- $6,31+$ ,'23+%$/ -8 1/)1&'-%2<$+ )/+ /-/25524%)/&)32$/*. 0$,)1*$ &'$ /)&2-/ ')* /-& ,-/*$/&$+ &- &'$ ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/,$ -8 &'$ ()%$/&*: @'$ ,'23+%$/ -8 3$4)3 %$*2+$/&*.2:$:. ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/& )32$/*. =-13+ 0$ (%-#2*2-/)3 ,2&2<$/* )& 02%&' )/+ 1/&23 &'$2% 5)>-%2&?: @'$? /-&$ &')& &'$ 9/2&$+s2/4+-5. ='2,' *')%$* ,-55-/ -%242/* =2&' -1% ,-55-/ 3)= -8 ,2&2<$/*'2(. ')* )+-(&$+ 3)=* ='2,' +- /-& $6&$/+

 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2( &- ,'23+%$/ -8 1/)1&'-%2<$+ -% /-/25524%)/& )32$/*: B-% ) ,-/&%)%? )/)3?*2*. *$$ &'$ +2*,1**2-/ -8+288$%$/& (%2/,2(3$*\0)*$* 8-% 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2(. 2/,31+2/4 ) %$*(-/*$ &- ;,'1,R o ;52&' )/+ ) ,-/*2+$%)&2-/ -8 &'$+$&%25$/&)3 %$($%,1**2-/* -8 %$*&%2,&2/4 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2(. 2/ O2*4%10$%. -4$"% 8--&/-&$ DZ:ZT I/ &'$ FFT&' A-/4%$** &'%$$ 0233* ')#$ 0$$/ 2/&%-+1,$+ &')& =-13+ )5$/+ IJC LDEF GK 9:;:A: LFMEFH: @'$*$ 2/,31+$

P:V: FME. LDEF -8 P:V: FFXW. )/+ ;: ZTD: "/$ 0233. ;:[:V$*: T. ')* 0$$/ 2/&%-+1,$+ &')& =-13+ )5$/+ &'$ A2&2<$/*'2(G,-/&2/1$+:::H

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 14/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

@'$ 3$42*3)&2-/ +2*,1**$+ 2/ &'2* *$,&2-/ 2* 2/&$/+$+ &- +2*,-1%)4$ 1/3)=813 $/&%? )/+ (%$*$/,$ -8)32$/* 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )/+ &'$ ($%,$2#$+ )/-5)3? -8 )1&-5)&2,)33? 4%)/&2/4 ,2&2<$/*'2( &-

 ($%*-/* ='-. +$*(2&$ 02%&' 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. )%$ /-& %)2*$+ )/+ +- /-& ),& 2/ ),,-%+)/,$ =2&')33$42)/,$ &- &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*:

ZD I& 5)? ),,-5(32*' &'2* 01& 5)? )3*- &'%-= 2/&- k1$*&2-/ &'$

13&25)&$ *&)&1* -8 5)/? 0-%/ '$%$. &')& 2*. ($%*-/* ='-*$ ()%$/&* )%$ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* 2/2&2)33?

-/ &$5(-%)%? #2*)* 01& 13&25)&$3? -0&)2/ 3)=813 ($%5)/$/& *&)&1*: C3*-. &'$ )++2&2-/)3 %$,-%+7R$$(2/4 /$,$**)%? &- +-,15$/& ='- 0$,-5$* ) ,2&2<$/ )1&-5)&2,)33? 1(-/ 02%&' 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+

;&)&$* 5)? (%$*$/& 01%$)1,%)&2, ,')33$/4$*. ()%&2,13)%3? *2/,$ 02%&' %$,-%+* )%$ ) 5)&&$% 8-% *&)&$3)=*:ZM 

!'+-)/)>)/'+9: 67%+37%+)- 9+3 "%:9)%3 #)9)>)'(= 67%+37%+)-

"#$% &'$ %$,$/& A-/4%$**$* &'$%$ ')#$ 0$$/ *$#$%)3 #)%2)&2-/* -/ (%-(-*)3* 8-% ,-/*&2&1&2-/)3)5$/+5$/&*: @'$ #$%*2-/* +288$% 2/ +$82/2/4 =')& *&)&1* ) ()%$/& 51*& ')#$ &- $/)03$ )1&-5)&2,

 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2( 8-% ) ,'23+ 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*:ZY

 _%-(-*)3* =-13+ #)%2-1*3? 3252& 34-

 -)50 ,2&2<$/*'2( 1/+$% &'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/ &- ($%*-/* 0-%/ &-

 ()%$/&* ,)1C -8 ='-5 )%$ $2&'$% ,2&2<$/* -% 3)=813 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/&* G+-$* /-&$6(%$**3? %$($)3 &'$ ,1%%$/& A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$Hh

ZW 

!  ) 5-&'$% ='- 2* ) 3$4)3 %$*2+$/& G$6(%$**3? %$($)3* &'$ ,1%%$/& A2&2<$/*'2(

A3)1*$HhZZ 

!  ) 5-&'$% ='- 2* ) ,2&2<$/ -% 3$4)3 %$*2+$/& G$6(%$**3? %$($)3* &'$ ,1%%$/&

A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$HhZK

 

!   ()%$/&* -/$ -8 ='-5 2* ) ,2&2<$/ G+-$* /-& $6(%$**3? %$($)3 &'$ ,1%%$/&

A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$HhZX

 

!   ()%$/&* -/$ -8 ='-5 2* ) ,2&2<$/ -% ($%*-/ ='- -=$* ($%5)/$/& )33$42)/,$ &- &'$

9/2&$+ ;&)&$* G+-$* /-& $6(%$**3? %$($)3 &'$ ,1%%$/& A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$HhKE

 

 ()%$/&* -/$ -8 ='-5 2* ) 3$4)3 %$*2+$/& G$6(%$**3? %$($)3* &'$ ,1%%$/& A2&2<$/*'2(

A3)1*$HhKF 

G:::,-/&2/1$+H

A3)1*$ -8 &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& -8 &'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/:ZD B-% )++2&2-/)3 +2*,1**2-/ -8 &'$ +$&%25$/&)3 $88$,& -8 &'$ ,1%%$/& 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2( 3)=*. *$$ `--+. -4$"% 

8--&/-&$ DZ. )& MXD7YED: ;$$ )3*- ?)0.1 S#%"0.2 . -4$"% 8--&/-&$ DZ:ZM B-% )++2&2-/)3 ,%2&2,2*5 -8 (%-(-*)3* &- %$*&%2,& 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2( )/+ &'$ (-**203$ +$&%25$/&)3 $88$,& -8 *1,'3$42*3)&2-/. *$$ O%2, ̀ )%+. < E#F E%1080-+I <.10RK++02"%10). !)5010B- %.& 1C# J)4"1##.1C <+#.&+#.1 . )/+ U)%4)%$&]: ;&-,R. !)50BD <"24+#.1- 0. J%8)" )( A#1%0.0.2 <+#"0B%U- L0"1C"02C1 /010@#.-C0$ M%F. 0-&' 2/ *%&# 0. <+#"0B%I

 *D1C- _ J%B1- %,)41 L0"1C"02C1 /010@#.-C0$. -4$"% 8--&/-&$ DZ: ;$$ )3*- ?)0.1 S#%"0.2 . -4$"% 8--&/-&$ DZ:ZY

 "/$ *'-13+ /-&$ &')& &'$ ,-/*&2&1&2-/)3 A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$ (%-#2+$* &'$ 0)*$32/$ 8-% 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2(rA-/4%$**,)/ (%-#2+$ 8-% 0%-)+$% 0)*$* 0? *&)&1&$:ZW  >929. P:[:V$*: M. FEY&' A-/4: GFXXZHh P:[:V$*: FXE. FEM&' A-/4: GFXXWH:ZZ  >929. P:[:V$*: DYZ. FET/+ A-/4: GFXXTH:ZK  >929. P:[:V$*: WM. FEM&' A-/4: GFXXYHh P:[:V$*: FTX. FED %+ A-/4: GFXXDH:ZX  >929. P:[:V$*: WE. FEY&' A-/4: GFXXZHh P:[:V$*: KK. FEM&' A-/4: GFXXYHh P:[:V$*: DXW. FED %+ A-/4: GFXXMH:KE  >929. P:[:V$*: MW. FFE&' A-/4: GTEEZHh P:[:V$*: MW. FEX&' A-/4: GTEEYHh P:[:V$*: MT. FEK&' A-/4: GTEEDH:KF  >929. P:[:V$*: YW. FEM&' A-/4: GFXXYHh P:[:V$*: FFZ. FED %+ A-/4:. F*&: ;$**: GFXXDH:

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 15/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

!   ()%$/&* -/$ -8 ='-5 2* ) ,2&2<$/ -% 3)=813 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/& G+-$* /-& $6(%$**3?%$($)3 &'$ ,1%%$/& A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$HhKT 

!   ()%$/&* -/$ -8 ='-5 2* ) ,2&2<$/. 2* 3)=8133? 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. -% ')* 3)=813*&)&1* 1/+$% &'$ 25524%)&2-/ 3)=* -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* G+-$* /-& $6(%$**3? %$($)3

&'$ ,1%%$/& A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$HhKD 

!   ()%$/&* -/$ -8 ='-5 2* ) ,2&2<$/. ) 3)=813 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/& ='- %$*2+$* 2/ &'$9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. -% )/ )32$/ ($%8-%52/4 ),&2#$ +1&? *$%#2,$ 2/ &'$ 9:;: C%5$+

B-%,$* G+-$* /-& $6(%$**3? %$($)3 &'$ ,1%%$/& A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$H:KM 

O#$/ )* ) 0)*$32/$ 8-% +$82/2/4 ,2&2<$/*'2(. *-5$ -8 &'$ +2*&2/,&2-/* +%)=/ )%$ 1/,3$)%: @'$ &$%5c3$4)3 %$*2+$/&g 1*$+ 2/ *-5$ -8 &'$ (%-(-*)3* =-13+ )(($)% &- 25(32,2&3? 2/,31+$ ,2&2<$/*.

/)&2-/)3*. )/+ 3)=813 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/&*. 01& 2& 5)? )3*- 0$ 2/&$%(%$&$+ &- 2/,31+$ ,$%&)2/,)&$4-%2$* -8 /-/25524%)/&* ='- &?(2,)33? %$*2+$ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* 8-% *$#$%)3 ?$)%* )/+ -&'$%)32$/* ($%5)/$/&3? %$*2+2/4 1/+$% &'$ ,-3-% -8 3)=: "&'$% (%-(-*)3* %$8$% &- ,2&2<$/*. 01& /-& &-/)&2-/)3* ='- )%$ /-& ,2&2<$/* G$:4:. C5$%2,)/ ;)5-)/*H: "/$ &?($ -8 (%-(-*)3 %$8$%* &- ($%*-/*='- -=$ ($%5)/$/& )33$42)/,$ &- &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. ='2,' 2* '-= &'$ IJC +$82/$* /)&2-/)3*:

@'$%$8-%$. 8-% &'$ *)R$ -8 ,3)%2&?. (%-(-*$+ 3)/41)4$ &')& 2/,31+$* )/ $6(32,2& $/15$%)&2-/ -8 &'$)((32,)03$ ,)&$4-%2$* -8 ()%$/&*r,2&2<$/*. /)&2-/)3*. 3)=813 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/&*. /-/25524%)/&*G28 )/?H 5)? 0$ (%$8$%)03$ &- 3)/41)4$ &')& -/3? $6(32,2&3? %$8$%* &- ()%$/&* ='- )%$ 3$4)3 %$*2+$/&*-% &- ,2&2<$/* =2&'-1& 5$/&2-/2/4 /)&2-/)3*: ;-5$ (%-(-*)3* 8-,1* -/ &'$ 5-&'$% )* &'$ ,-/+12&8-% 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2(. $6,31+2/4 ) 8)&'$% ='- 2* ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/ -% 3$4)3 %$*2+$/& 8%-5 0$2/4 &'$

,-/+12& 8-% *1,' ,2&2<$/*'2(: C33 -8 &'$*$ (%-(-*)3* =-13+ -/3? )((3? (%-*($,&2#$3? &- &'-*$ 0-%/)8&$% &'$ +)&$ -8 &'$ %)&282,)&2-/ -8 )/ )5$/+5$/& 0? &'$ 3$42*3)&1%$* -8 &'%$$78-1%&'* -8 &'$ *&)&$*=2&'2/ *$#$/ ?$)%* -8 2&* *1052**2-/ 8-% %)&282,)&2-/ )/+ *$#$%)3 $6(%$**3? (%-#2+$ &')& A-/4%$***')33 ')#$ &'$ (-=$% &- $/8-%,$ &'$ )%&2,3$ 0? )((%-(%2)&$ 3$42*3)&2-/:

;-5$ -8 &'$ )0-#$ (%-(-*)3* &- )5$/+ &'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/ ')+ -% ')#$ ()%)33$3 (%-(-*)3* &- )5$/+&'$ IJC &- ,-/8-%5 &- &'$ /$= 0)*$32/$ -8 &'$ A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$ -/,$ 2& 2* )5$/+$+. 2/,31+2/4.)5-/4 -&'$%*. 3$42*3)&2-/ &- 3252& ,2&2<$/*'2( 0? 02%&' 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* &- ($%*-/* 0-%/ &-

!  5-&'$%* ='- )%$ 3$4)3 %$*2+$/&*KY

 -%

!  5-&'$%* ='- )%$ ,2&2<$/* -% 3$4)3 %$*2+$/&*:KW 

^? &'$2% -=/ &$%5*. &'$*$ &?($* -8 *&)&1&-%? )5$/+5$/&* =-13+ /-& &)R$ $88$,& 1/&23 ) %$3)&$+,-/*&2&1&2-/)3 )5$/+5$/& ')+ 0$$/ %)&282$+ )/+ =-13+ -/3? )((3? &- &'-*$ 0-%/ )8&$% &'$ +)&$ -8%)&282,)&2-/: @'$*$ *&)&1&-%? (%-(-*)3* %)2*$ &'$ *)5$ 2**1$* )* &'$ ()%)33$3 ,-/*&2&1&2-/)3)5$/+5$/&*:

KT  >929. P:[:V$*: MF. FEX&' A-/4: GTEEYHh P:[:V$*: MM. FEK&' A-/4: GTEEDH:KD  >929. P:[:V$*: YX. FEZ&' A-/4: GTEEFHh P:[:V$*: FE. FEW&' A-/4: GFXXXHh P:[:V$*: TW. FEY&' A-/4: GFXXZHh P:[:V$*: XD.FEM&' A-/4: GFXXYHh P:[:V$*: DME. FED%+ A-/4: GFXXMH:KM  >929. ;:[:V$*: T. FFT&' A-/4: GTEFFHh ;:[:V$*: W. FFF&' A-/4: GTEEXHh ;:[:V$*: DF. FFE&' A-/4: GTEEKH:KY  >929. P:V: DWEY. FET/+ A-/4: GFXXFH:KW  >929. P:V: FTW. FFF&' A-/4: GTEEXHh P:V: ZEY. FEM&' A-/4: GFXXYHh P:V: FFXF. FED%+ A-/4: GFXXDH:

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 16/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

#)9)>)'(= 67%+37%+)- I/)0'>) "%:9)%3 !'+-)/)>)/'+9: 67%+37%+)-

"/$ &?($ -8 (%-(-*)3 =-13+ 3252& 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2( 2/ ) =)? &')& 2&* (%-(-/$/&* 0$32$#$ =-13+/-& /$,$**2&)&$ ) ,-/*&2&1&2-/)3 )5$/+5$/& G*$$ +2*,1**2-/ 2/ &'$ 8-33-=2/4 *$,&2-/H: I& $**$/&2)33?

=-13+ -1%141)"05D +$82/$ ='- 2* 0-%/ c*10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/g -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* 1/+$% &'$

A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$ /-&=2&'*&)/+2/4 &'$ 9:;: ;1(%$5$ A-1%& '-3+2/4* 2/ 6.01#& 71%1#- 89 :).2 ;0+ <"= : _%-(-*)3* 2/ &'2* ,)&$4-%? #)%2-1*3? +$82/$

!   ($%*-/*. ='-*$ 02%&' 5-&'$%* )%$ /-& ,2&2<$/*. /)&2-/)3*. -% 3)=813 ($%5)/$/&%$*2+$/&* -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* %.&  ='- )%$ ,2&2<$/*\/)&2-/)3* -8 )/-&'$% ,-1/&%?-8 ='2,' ) /)&1%)3 ()%$/& 2* ) ,2&2<$/\/)&2-/)3. )* /-& 0$2/4 0-%/ *10>$,& &- &'$

 >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* =2&'2/ &'$ 5$)/2/4 -8 &'$ B-1%&$$/&'C5$/+5$/&. 01& %)&'$% )* 0$2/4 0-%/ *10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 &'$ -&'$%

,-1/&%?hKZ

 

!   ($%*-/*. ='-*$ 02%&' 5-&'$%* )%$ /-& ,2&2<$/* -% 3)=813 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/&* -8

&'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* %.&  ='- )%$ ,2&2<$/*\/)&2-/)3* -8 )/-&'$% ,-1/&%? -8 ='2,' )/)&1%)3 ()%$/& 2* ) ,2&2<$/\/)&2-/)3. )* /-& 0$2/4 0-%/ *10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8

&'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* =2&'2/ &'$ 5$)/2/4 -8 &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/&. 01& %)&'$% )* 0$2/4 0-%/ *10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 &'$ -&'$% ,-1/&%?hKK 

!   ($%*-/* 0-%/ *10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )* 2/,31+2/4 ($%*-/*

 0-%/ 0. F#&5)B=  &- ) 5-&'$% -% 8)&'$% ='- 2* ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/. ) 9:;: /)&2-/)3. -% )3)=813 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/& ='- 5)2/&)2/* (%25)%? %$*2+$/,$ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*.-% ($%*-/* 0-%/ )41 )( F#&5)B=  &- ) 5-&'$% ='- 2* ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/. ) 9:;: /)&2-/)3.

-% ) 3)=813 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/& ='- 5)2/&)2/* (%25)%? %$*2+$/,$ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+;&)&$*hKX 

!   ($%*-/* 0-%/ *10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )* 2/,31+2/4 ($%*-/* 0-%/ 0. F#&5)B=  &- ) 5-&'$% -% 8)&'$% ='- 2* ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/. ) 9:;: /)&2-/)3. -% )3)=813 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/& ='- 5)2/&)2/* (%25)%? %$*2+$/,$ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*.

-% ($%*-/* 0-%/ )41 )( F#&5)B=  &- ) 5-&'$% ='- 2* ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/. ) 9:;: /)&2-/)3.-% ) 3)=813 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/& ='- 5)2/&)2/* (%25)%? %$*2+$/,$ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+;&)&$*. -% &- ) 8)&'$% ='- 2* ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/. ) 9:;: /)&2-/)3. -% ) 3)=813 ($%5)/$/&%$*2+$/& ='- 5)2/&)2/* (%25)%? %$*2+$/,$ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. 01& -/3? 28

 ()&$%/2&? ')* 0$$/ $*&)032*'$+ 0? ,3$)% )/+ ,-/#2/,2/4 $#2+$/,$ )/+ &'$ 8)&'$%')* *)&2*82$+ ,$%&)2/ %$k12%$5$/&*hXE 

KZ  >929. P:V: FXE. FEZ&' A-/4: GTEEFHh P:V: DFX. FEW&' A-/4: GFXXXHh P:V: DMW. FEY&' A-/4: GFXXZHh P:V: DZY. LDEF.

FEM&' A-/4: GFXXYH: @'$*$ 0233* *($,28? &')& &'$ ($%*-/* 2/ k1$*&2-/ )%$ $2&'$% 0-%/ ,2&2<$/*\/)&2-/)3* -8 )/-&'$% ,-1/&%?-8 ='2,' $2&'$% -8 '2*\'$% /)&1%)3 ()%$/&* 2* ) ,2&2<$/\/)&2-/)3 -% #.1015#&  1(-/ )((32,)&2-/ &- 0$,-5$ ) ,2&2<$/\/)&2-/)3-8 &')& -&'$% ,-1/&%?:KK  >929. P:V: TFWT. LZEF. FEM&' A-/4: GFXXYHh P:V: MXDM. LZEF. FED%+ A-/4: GFXXMHh P:V: DKWT. LMEF. FED%+ A-/4:

GFXXMHh ;: FDYF. LFEEF. FED%+

 A-/4: GFXXDH: @'$*$ 0233* *($,28? &')& &'$ ($%*-/* 2/ k1$*&2-/ )%$ $2&'$% 0-%/,2&2<$/*\/)&2-/)3* -8 )/-&'$% ,-1/&%? -8 ='2,' $2&'$% -8 '2*\'$% /)&1%)3 ()%$/&* 2* ) ,2&2<$/\/)&2-/)3 -% #.1015#&  1(-/)((32,)&2-/ &- 0$,-5$ ) ,2&2<$/\/)&2-/)3 -8 &')& -&'$% ,-1/&%?:KX  >929. P:V: DXDK. LZEF. FEX&' A-/4: GTEEYHh P:V: MDFD. LDTT. FEX&' A-/4: GTEEYHh P:V: WXK. FEX&' A-/4: GTEEYHh P:V:

FYWZ. FEK&' A-/4: GTEEDHh P:V: ZD. FEW&' A-/4: GFXXXHh P:V: Z. FEY&' A-/4: GFXXZHh P:V: FDWD. FEM&' A-/4: GFXXYH: C33 01& &'$ 3)*& -8 &'$*$ +$82/$* c=$+3-,Rg )* /-& 2/,31+2/4 ,-55-/73)= 5)%%2)4$:XE  >929. P:V: FDD. FFE&' A-/4: GTEEZH: @'$ %$k12%$5$/&* &')& 51*& 0$ *)&2*82$+ 0? &'$ -1&7-87=$+3-,R 8)&'$% )%$ &'$ *)5$)* &'$ %$k12%$5$/&* &')& 51*& 0$ *)&2*82$+ 8-% &%)/*52**2-/ -8 ,2&2<$/*'2( &- ) ,'23+ 0-%/ )0%-)+ )/+ -1&7-87=$+3-,R &- )

9:;: ,2&2<$/ 8)&'$% 1/+$% IJC LDEXG)H GK 9:;:A: LFMEXG)HH:

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 17/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

!   ($%*-/* 0-%/ *10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )* 2/,31+2/4 ($%*-/* 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* &- ) 5-&'$% -% 8)&'$% ='- 2* ) /)&2-/)3 -8 &'$ 9/2&$+;&)&$* G&'2* =-13+ 2/,31+$ ,2&2<$/* )/+ /-/7,2&2<$/ /)&2-/)3*H -% ) 3)=813

 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/& ='- 5)2/&)2/* '2* -% '$% %$*2+$/,$ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*hXF 

!   ($%*-/* 0-%/ *10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )* 2/,31+2/4 ($%*-/*

 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* &- ) 5-&'$% -% 8)&'$% ='- 2* ) ,2&2<$/ -% /)&2-/)3 -8 &'$

9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. ) 3)=813 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/& ='-*$ %$*2+$/,$ 2* 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+;&)&$*. -% )/ )32$/ ($%8-%52/4 ),&2#$ +1&? *$%#2,$ 2/ &'$ 9:;: C%5$+ B-%,$*:

XT 

@'$ 82%*& &=- -8 &'$*$ (%-(-*)3* =-13+ )#-2+ &'$ (%-03$5 -8 %$/+$%2/4 ) ($%*-/ *&)&$3$** 0?

 ($%52&&2/4 ($%*-/* 0-%/ &- 1/)1&'-%2<$+ )32$/ -% /-/25524%)/& 5-&'$%* &- 0$ ,2&2<$/* )& 02%&' 28&'$? ')#$ /- #2)03$ ,3)25 &- ,2&2<$/*'2( 2/ )/-&'$% ,-1/&%?:XD @'$*$ &=- (%-(-*)3* ,-13+ %$*13& 2/

) *,$/)%2- 2/ ='2,' ) ($%*-/ 5)? 0$ 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* &- ) 5-&'$% ='- 2* ) /-/25524%)/&-% 1/)1&'-%2<$+ )32$/ )/+ ) 8)&'$% ='- 2* ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/. /)&2-/)3 -% 3)=813 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/& G2/-% -1& -8 =$+3-,RH )/+ /-& 0$ 0-%/ ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/ 0$,)1*$ &')& ($%*-/ ')* ) ,3)25 &- ,2&2<$/*'2( 2/

&'$ 5-&'$%Q* ,-1/&%?: @'$ &'2%+ (%-(-*)3 +-$* /-& ($%52& ) ($%*-/ 0-%/ -1& -8 =$+3-,R &- ) 8)&'$%='- 2* ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/. /)&2-/)3 -% 3)=813 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/& &- 0$ ,-/*2+$%$+ 0-%/ *10>$,& &- &'$

 >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )/+ +-$* /-& (%-#2+$ 8-% &'$ ),k12*2&2-/ -8 9:;: ,2&2<$/*'2( 0?*1,' ) ($%*-/ &'%-14' ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/ 8)&'$%: `2&'-1& ,-/8-%52/4 )5$/+5$/&* &- LDEX -8 &'$ IJC.&'2* (%-(-*)3 =-13+ 5$)/ &')& ($%*-/* 0-%/ )0%-)+ -1& -8 =$+3-,R &- ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/ 8)&'$% )/+ )/

)32$/ 5-&'$% =-13+ ')#$ ) (%-,$** 0? ='2,' &'$? ,-13+ 0$ +$$5$+ 9:;: ,2&2<$/* )& 02%&' )/+. ()%)+-62,)33?. ($%*-/* 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* -8 *2523)% ()%$/&)4$ =-13+ /-&: @'$*$ (%-(-*)3*

)%$ )33 &'$%$8-%$ )%41)03? 1/,-/*&2&1&2-/)3 -/ +1$ (%-,$**\$k1)3 (%-&$,&2-/ 4%-1/+* )* =$33 )*A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$ 4%-1/+*:XM @'$ 8-1%&' (%-(-*)3 )#-2+* *1,' 2**1$* 0? (%-#2+2/4 8-% &'$

 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2( -8 ) ($%*-/ 0-%/ -1&7-87=$+3-,R &- ) 8)&'$% ='- 2* ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/. /)&2-/)3.

XF  >929. ;: FTWX. LYED. FFE&' A-/4: GTEEZHh ;: TFFZ. @2&3$ l. FEX&' A-/4: GTEEYH:XT  >929. P:V: FME. FFT&' A-/4: GTEFFHh P:V: FFXW. LDEF. FFT&' A-/4: GTEFFHh ;: ZTD. FFT&' A-/4: GTEFFHh P:V: XXM.

LDEF. FFF

&'

 A-/4: GTEEXHh P:V: FKWK. FFF

&'

 A-/4: GTEEXHh P:V: YEET. LZ. FFF

&'

 A-/4: GTEFEHh P:V: FXME. FFE

&'

 A-/4:GTEEZHh P:V: WZKX. LDEF. FFE&' A-/4: GTEEKH:XD I/&$%/)&2-/)3 3)= 4$/$%)33? #2$=* *&)&$3$**/$** )* 1/+$*2%)03$ )/+ *$$R* &- (%$#$/& -% +2*,-1%)4$ 3$)#2/4 ($%*-/*

1/(%-&$,&$+ 0? )/+ 1/)332$+ =2&' )/? /)&2-/: @'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )(()%$/&3? 2* /-& ) ()%&? &- )/? ,-/#$/&2-/* -%)4%$$5$/&* =2&' 02/+2/4 -0324)&2-/* &- (%$#$/& *&)&$3$**/$**: I& 2* 1/,3$)% ='$&'$% *1,' )/ -0324)&2-/ $62*&* 1/+$%,1*&-5)%? 2/&$%/)&2-/)3 3)=. )3&'-14' *-5$ )1&'-%2&2$* )%41$ &')& 2& +-$*. 42#$/ &'$ /$)%71/2#$%*)3 ,-/+$5/)&2-/ -8*&)&$3$**/$** 2/ &'$ 3)=* -8 5)/? /)&2-/* )/+ 2/ #)%2-1* 2/&$%/)&2-/)3 )4%$$5$/&*: 7## K a-%+-/. U)235)/ o N)3$7

S-$'%. -4$"% 8--&/-&$ FE. )& LLXF:EFpDqp$q )/+ FEE:EDpTqp$qh [:U ;($,&)%. Q) L%. )" E)1 1) L%. %. <+#"0B%. Q%50,%.N A#8)B%10). )( /010@#.-C0$ _ 71%1#5#--.#-- 0. % 71%1#B#.1"0B 7D-1#+. DX A)3: `: S: V$#: TWD. TXW7DEF GTEEDHh A'%2*&2/$^2)/,'$%2). A#-1)"0.2 1C# A02C1 1) S%8# A02C1-I 71%1#5#--.#-- %.& <50#.%2# ?4"0-&0B10). 0. M02C1 )( <,4R@#0.#C f9

 J#&#"%5 M%,)"%1)"0#-Z K.B9. FF C5: 9:[: I/&Q3 S: o _-3Q? FXY. FXK7TET GFXXWHh U23&-/ A: S-%$/<. [%:. E)1#I <50#.-g 

 A#.4.B0%10). )( E%10).%501D M#%8#- K.&080&4%5 71%1#5#-- %.& >YB54&%,5# %- <.D <50#.. MW @13: S: V$#: XKM. XKX7XXEGFXZTH:XM @'$ 9:;: ;1(%$5$ A-1%& ')* 1('$3+ &'$ %$k12%$5$/&* 8-% &%)/*52**2-/ -8 ,2&2<$/*'2( 0? ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/ 8)&'$% &- ),'23+ 0-%/ -1& -8 =$+3-,R -1&*2+$ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )* ,-/*2*&$/& =2&' ,-/*&2&1&2-/)3 $k1)3 (%-&$,&2-/ +$*(2&$ &'$ 8),&

&')& &'$2% %$k12%$5$/&* )%$ 5-%$ *&%2/4$/& &')/ &'-*$ 8-% &%)/*52**2-/ 0? ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/ 5-&'$% &- ) ,'23+ 0-%/ 2/ &'$*)5$ ,2%,15*&)/,$*: J5)"#-Rf055%" 89 6.01#& 71%1#-. nnn 9:;: nnn. FDF ;: A&: TDFTh FKE S: O+: T+ TTT GTEFFH G)882%5$+3-=$% )(($33)&$ ,-1%&Q* +$,2*2-/ =2&'-1& -(2/2-/H. )/+ E24D#. 89 K++02"%10). %.& E%14"%50@%10). 7#"80B#. YDD 9:;: YDGTEEFH: I/ J5)"#-Rf055%" &'$ A-1%& 1('$3+ %$k12%$5$/&* &')& &'$ 9:;: ,2&2<$/ 8)&'$% 51*& 0$ (%$*$/& 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*

8-% *($,282, ($%2-+* -8 &25$ 0$8-%$ &'$ 8-%$24/70-%/ ,'23+Q* 02%&': I/ E24D#. &'$ A-1%& 1('$3+ -&'$% &%)/*52**2-/%$k12%$5$/&* *1,' )* 8-%5)3 3$42&25)&2-/ 1/+$% *&)&$ 3)= )/+ 02-3-42,)3 &$*&* $*&)032*'2/4 ()&$%/2&? &')& )%$*10*&)/&2)33? %$3)&$+ &- &'$ ,-/4%$**2-/)3 (1%(-*$ -8 %$k12%2/4 ) +$5-/*&%)03$ 0-/+ 0$&=$$/ &'$ 9:;: ,2&2<$/ 8)&'$% )/+,'23+: I/ ,-/&%)*&. 3$42*3)&2-/ &')& $3252/)&$* )/? (-**20232&? -8 0)*2/4 ,2&2<$/*'2( -/ &'$ 8)&'$%Q* ,2&2<$/*'2(. /)&2-/)32&?.

-% %$*2+$/& *&)&1* 5)? 0$ 1/,-/*&2&1&2-/)3:

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 18/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

-% 3)=813 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/& )* 3-/4 )* %$k12%$5$/&* 32R$ &'-*$ -8 IJC LDEX )%$ *)&2*82$+: @'$828&' )/+ *26&' (%-(-*)3* 32*&$+ )0-#$ =-13+ /-& %)2*$ &'$*$ ,-/*&2&1&2-/)3 2**1$* 0$,)1*$ &'$?

5)R$ /- +2*&2/,&2-/* 0)*$+ -/ &'$ 4$/+$% -8 &'$ ()%$/&:

J)0%( #)9)>)'(= 67%+37%+)-

"/$ &?($ -8 (%-(-*)3 2/ &'$ FFE&' )/+ FEX&' A-/4%$**$*. =2&'-1& *&)&1&-%23? +$82/2/4 c0-%/ *10>$,&

&- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/g -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. =-13+ ')#$ (%-#2+$+ &')&. =2&' %$*($,& &- ) ($%*-/ 0-%/)8&$% &'$ +)&$ -8 &'$ $/),&5$/& -8 &'$ (%-(-*)3. &'$ ($%*-/ *')33 /-& 0$ ) /)&2-/)3 -% ,2&2<$/ )& 02%&'1/+$% LDEF -8 &'$ IJC GK 9:;:A: LFMEFH 1/3$** )& 3$)*& -/$ -8 &'$ ()%$/&* 2*. )& &'$ &25$ -8 02%&'. ),2&2<$/ -% /)&2-/)3 -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* -% )/ )32$/ 3)=8133? )+52&&$+ 8-% ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/,$:XY 

S)*&. ) (%-(-*)3 2/ &'$ FEK&' A-/4%$** =)* -40 2#.#"0-h 2& +2+ /-& (1%(-%& &- 0$ ) ,-/4%$**2-/)3

2/&$%(%$&)&2-/ -8 &'$ A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$ 01& =-13+ ')#$ 25(-*$+ ) *&)&1&-%? 3252&)&2-/ -/ P7#2*)'-3+$%* )/+ &'$%$8-%$ =-13+ ')#$ 0$$/ 1/,-/*&2&1&2-/)3 1/+$% &'$ A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$: 9/+$% &'2*

 (%-(-*)3. ,'23+%$/ 0-%/ &- ) ()%$/& ='- 2* ) /-/25524%)/& $5(3-?$$ 1/+$% LFEFG)HGFYHGPH -8 &'$

IJC =-13+ /-& 0$ ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/ 0? 02%&' 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* 1/3$** &'$ -&'$% ()%$/& =$%$ ) 9:;:

,2&2<$/ -% 3)=813 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/&:XW 

!'+,(%--/'+9: 6@) I/)0'>) !'+-)/)>)/'+9: 67%+37%+)

C* /-&$+ )0-#$. (%-(-/$/&* -8 ,$%&)2/ (%-(-*)3* &- )5$/+ &'$ IJC )%41$ &')& ,-/4%$**2-/)32/&$%(%$&)&2-/ -8 &'$ A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$ &- 3252& )1&-5)&2, 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2( 5)? 0$

 ($%52**203$ =2&'-1& )/ ),,-5()/?2/4 ,-/*&2&1&2-/)3 )5$/+5$/& 0$,)1*$. 1/+$% LY -8 &'$B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/&. A-/4%$** ')* &'$ (-=$% &- c$/8-%,$. 0? )((%-(%2)&$ 3$42*3)&2-/. &'$

 (%-#2*2-/* -8 &'2* )%&2,3$:g I/ ) *&233 $#-3#2/4 )%$) -8 3)=. &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* ;1(%$5$ A-1%& ')*'$3+ &')& A-/4%$** ')* *-5$ (-=$% &- +$82/$ &'$ *10*&)/,$ -8 &'$ %24'&* &')& )%$ (%-&$,&$+ 1/+$%&'$ )5$/+5$/& )/+ 5)? $#$/. 1/+$% *-5$ ,2%,15*&)/,$*. 3$42*3)&$ ,-/&%)%? &- >1+2,2)3 +$,2*2-/*

 0? 4-2/4 0$?-/+ >1+2,2)3 +$,2*2-/* +$82/2/4 *1,' %24'&* 2/ -%+$% &- $/8-%,$ &'$ )5$/+5$/&:

I/ ;%1@#.,%BC 89 *)"2%..XZ &'$ A-1%& 8-1/+ &')& A-/4%$** ,-13+ +$82/$ &'$ *10*&)/&2#$ *,-($ -8

$k1)3 (%-&$,&2-/ 8-% &'$ (1%(-*$ -8 +$&$%52/2/4 ='$&'$% *&)&$ 3)=* #2-3)&$ $k1)3 (%-&$,&2-/: @'$A-1%& %$>$,&$+ &'$ +2**$/&Q* ,-/,$%/ &')& A-/4%$** ,-13+ 3$42*3)&$ &- +231&$ &'$ $k1)3 (%-&$,&2-/)/+ +1$ (%-,$** +$,2*2-/* -8 &'$ A-1%&. *)?2/4 &')& A-/4%$** 5)? )+-(& 5$)*1%$* -/3? &- $/8-%,$B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& %24'&*. /-& &- %$*&%2,&. )0%-4)&$ -% +231&$ &'$5:XK P-=$#$%. A-/4%$** ')*

 ()**$+ 3$42*3)&2-/ &')& (1%(-%&$+ &- -#$%%13$ &'$ A-1%&Q* $6()/*2-/ -8 &'$ %24'& )4)2/*& *$387

2/,%252/)&2-/ )/+ &'$ %24'&7&-7,-1/*$3 )/+ $6(%$**3? %$32$+ -/ ;%1@#.,%BC 89 *)"2%.. )3&'-14'&'$ A-1%&. ,-/&$5(-%)/$-1*3? =2&' &'$ 3$42*3)&2-/. ,')/4$+ ,-1%*$ &- )+-(& ) #2$= 2/ )324/5$/&

XY

 P:V: MFXT. LTEF. FFE

&'

 A-/4: GTEEZHh P:V: DZEE. LTEF. FEX

&'

 A-/4: GTEEYH:XW P:V: DYDM. LTFDG0H. FEK&' A-/4: GTEEDH:XZ DKM 9:;: WMF. WYM7WYW GFXWWH: 7## %5-). /01D )( A0BC+).& 89 ?9<9 /")-). /)9. FEX ;:A&: ZEW. ZFZ7TE. ZTW7ZTZGFXKXHh J45505)8# 89 ;[email protected]= . MMK 9:;: MMK. MZW7K. MKT7M GFXKEHh /01D )( A)+# 89 6.01#& 71%1#-. MMW 9:;: FYW GFXKEHh

H"#2). 89 *01BC#55 . MEE 9:;: FFT GFXZEHh @PO A"J;@I@9@I"J "B @PO 9 JI@O] ;@C@O; "B CUOVIACd C JCSN;I; CJ]

I J@OV_VO@C@I"J. ;: ]-,: J-: FEK7FZ. TEMF7TEMZ GTEETH G[-'//? P: s2332)/. a$-%4$ C: A-*&$33- o s$//$&' V: @'-5)*$+*:H )/+ ;: ]-,: J-: FFF7DX GTEFE ;1((:H Gs$//$&' V: @'-5)*. O+: 2/ A'2$8. o S)%%? U: O24. U)/)42/4 O+:Hp'$%$2/)8&$% A"J;@I@9@I"J C JJ"@C@O]q:XK DKM 9:;: )& WYF. /: FE: 7## %5-) *0--0--0$$0 6.089 ()" :)+#. 89 S)2%.. MYK 9:;: ZFK. ZDF7ZDD GFXKTH:

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 19/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

=2&' &')& -8 A-/4%$**:XX A-/4%$**2-/)3 )0-%&2-/ -((-/$/&* ')#$ &%2$+ &- 2/2&2)&$ 3$42*3)&2-/%$*&%2,&2/4 &'$ %24'& &')& &'$ A-1%& ')* +$%2#$+ 8%-5 &'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/:FEE "&'$% 5-%$ %$,$/& ,)*$*

*'-= &')& &'$ A-1%& =233 /-& )3=)?* +$8$% &- A-/4%$**Q* +$&$%52/)&2-/ )* &- =')& 3$42*3)&2-/ 2*)((%-(%2)&$ &- $/8-%,$ &'$ (%-#2*2-/* -8 &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/&:

FEF 

@'1*. &'$%$ 5)? 0$ )/ 2**1$ )* &- ='$&'$% A-/4%$** ,-13+ +$82/$ c*10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/&'$%$-8g 2/ ) 5)//$% &')& =-13+ ,1%&)23 ) 3-/47)**15$+ %24'& -8 ($%*-/* 0-%/ &- )32$/* 2/ &'$9/2&$+ ;&)&$* &- 0$ 9:;: ,2&2<$/* %$4)%+3$** -8 &'$ 25524%)&2-/ *&)&1* -8 &'$2% ()%$/&*: "/$ ,-13+)%41$ &')& A-/4%$** ')* /- (-=$% &- +$82/$ c*10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/g )/+ &'$ &$%5* -8,2&2<$/*'2( 2/ ) 5)//$% ,-/&%)%? &- &'$ A-1%&Q* 1/+$%*&)/+2/4 -8 &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& )*

$6(%$**$+ 2/ :).2 ;0+ <"=  )/+ >5= . ()%&2,13)%3? *2/,$ &')& 1/+$%*&)/+2/4 2/,31+$* ) '-3+2/4 &')&&'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& +2+ /-& ,-/8$% -/ A-/4%$** ) %24'& &- %$*&%2,& &'$ $88$,& -8 02%&' -/,2&2<$/*'2( )* +$,3)%$+ 0? &'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/: I/ -&'$% =-%+*. &'$%$ 5)? 0$ ) +2*&2/,&2-/ 0$&=$$/ &'$$62*&$/,$ -8 ) %24'& 1/+$% &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& G$:4:. ,2&2<$/*'2(H. ='2,' +$($/+* -/ &'$&$6& )/+ >1+2,2)3 2/&$%(%$&)&2-/. )/+ &'$ 25(32,)&2-/* -% *,-($ -8 &'$ %24'&. ='2,' 2* *10>$,& &-

*-5$ +$4%$$ -8 ,-/4%$**2-/)3 %$413)&2-/: P-=$#$%. *2/,$ A-/4%$** ')* 0%-)+ (-=$% &- ()**/$,$**)%? )/+ (%-($% 3$42*3)&2-/ &- %$413)&$ 25524%)&2-/ )/+ /)&1%)32<)&2-/ 1/+$% &'$

A-/*&2&1&2-/. C%&: I. LK. ,3*: M o FK.

FET

 )%41)03? A-/4%$** ')* &'$ (-=$% &- +$82/$ c*10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ &'$%$-8g 8-% &'$ (1%(-*$ -8 %$413)&2/4 25524%)&2-/:

@'$ 8$+$%)3 ,-1%&* )%41)03? *1((-%& )/ 2/&$%(%$&)&2-/ -8 &'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/ &')& =-13+ 8-23 &'-*$='- )&&$5(& &- 4)2/ )/ 25524%)&2-/ )+#)/&)4$ 0? 0%$)R2/4 9:;: 3)=*. )3&'-14' :).2 ;0+ <"=  5)+$ /- +2*&2/,&2-/ 0$&=$$/ 3)=8133? )/+ 1/3)=8133? (%$*$/& )32$/ ()%$/&*. /-% 0$&=$$/ 3$4)3

%$*2+$/& )/+ /-/25524%)/& )32$/*: P-=$#$%. &'$ :).2 ;0+ <"=  A-1%& +2+ /-& ')#$ &- 5)R$ *1,'+2*&2/,&2-/*. 0$,)1*$ `-/4Q* ()%$/&* =$%$ 3$4)3 %$*2+$/& )32$/*: B$+$%)3 )(($33)&$ ,-1%&* ')#$1('$3+ &'$ %$81*)3 0? &'$ 25524%)&2-/ $/8-%,$5$/& )1&'-%2&2$* &- *&)? &'$ +$(-%&)&2-/ -81/)1&'-%2<$+ )32$/* 5$%$3? -/ &'$ 4%-1/+* &')& &'$? ')#$ 9:;:7,2&2<$/. 52/-% ,'23+%$/. 0$,)1*$ &-+- *- =-13+ 0$ 1/8)2%3? &- 4%)/& )/ )+#)/&)4$ &- )32$/* ='- *1,,$**8133? 83-1&$+ 9:;:

25524%)&2-/ 3)=* 3-/4 $/-14' &- ')#$ ) ,'23+ 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* -#$% &'-*$ )32$/* ='-

8-33-=$+ &'$ 3)=. )/+ =-13+ &1%/ &'$ 25524%)&2-/ *&)&1&$ -/ 2&* '$)+:

FED

 C3&'-14' &'$ 5$%$ 8),& -8&'$ $62*&$/,$ -8 9:;:7,2&2<$/. 52/-% ,'23+%$/ =-13+ /-& 0$ *1882,2$/& &- (%$#$/& &'$ +$(-%&)&2-/ -81/)1&'-%2<$+ )32$/ ()%$/&*. $6&%$5$ ')%+*'2( &- &'$ ,'23+%$/ ,)1*$+ 0? &'$ +$(-%&)&2-/ -8 &'$

 ()%$/&* 2* ) 8),&-% &- 0$ ,-/*2+$%$+ 2/ &'$ +2*,%$&2-/)%? *1*($/*2-/ -8 +$(-%&)&2-/:FEM @'$ 9/2&$+

XX A"J;@I@9@I"J C JJ"@C@O]. -4$"% 8--&/-&$ XZ. )& TEMT7D. /: FXXE:FEE  K& : )& TEMM. /: FXXX:FEF  K& : )& TEMM7Z:FET  J0%55) 89 L#55 . MDE 9:;: ZKZ. ZXT GFXZWHh *%1C#F 89 W0%@ . MTW 9:;: WZ GFXZYH:FED 7##Z #929. S#".%.&#@RA08#"% 89 K9E979. WDE B:T+ FDYT. FDYW GX&' A2%: FXKEHh G).@%5#@R/4#8%- 89 K9E979. YFY B:T+FTTT. FTTM GY&' A2%: FXZYH: 7## 2#.#"%55D C//-&)&2-/. K.(%.1 /010@#. %- >.1015#& 1) 71%D )( <50#. !%"#.1-U W#$)"1%10).H"&#" . MT C:S:V: B$+: XTM GFXZX o ;1((: TEEX7FEH. )/+ C//-&)&2-/. :C%1 /).-10141#- [>Y1"#+# S%"&-C0$\ )"[>YB#$10).%5 %.& >Y1"#+#5D 6.4-4%5 S%"&-C0$Z\ 6.&#" he^^V%X )( K++02"%10). %.& E%10).%501D <B1 Vi 6979/979

 h]ej^V%XXZ <55)F0.2 <11)".#D G#.#"%5 1) 74-$#.& W#$)"1%10). )( <50#. %.& <55)F <&+0--0). ()" !#"+%.#.1 A#-0&#.B#.ZT C:S:V: B$+: FDD LLZ7FT GFXKY o ;1((: TEEX7FEH:FEM 6",%.) &# *%5%54%. 89 K9E979. YZZ B:T+ YKX. YXM GX&' A2%: FXZKH: @'2* ()%&2,13)% ,)*$ ),&1)33? '$3+ &')& *1*($/*2-/-8 +$(-%&)&2-/ (%-,$$+2/4* *'-13+ 0$ %$-($/$+. )/+ 2& +2*&2/412*'$+ ,-/*2+$%)&2-/ -8 &'$ ,'23+%$/Q* $62*&$/,$ 8%-5 )

,-/*2+$%)&2-/ -8 $6&%$5$ ')%+*'2( 1/+$% (%-,$$+2/4* 8-% &'$ *1*($/*2-/ -8 +$(-%&)&2-/. 0$,)1*$ &'$ 3)&&$% (%-,$$+2/4*%$k12%$+ ) *$#$/7?$)% ,-/&2/1-1* (%$*$/,$ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*: P-=$#$%. 3)&$% ,)*$*. ='23$ ),R/-=3$+42/4 $6&%$5$')%+*'2( )* ) *&)&1&-%? 8),&-%. 3252&$+ %$#2$= -8 &'$ 25524%)&2-/ ,-1%&Q* +2*,%$&2-/ &- 4%)/& *1*($/*2-/ -8 +$(-%&)&2-/)/+ +2+ /-& *$$5 &- ,-/*2+$% *$#$/7?$)%* ,-/&2/1-1* (%$*$/,$ &- 0$ ) *24/282,)/& %$+1,&2-/ -8 )/? 3--('-3$ 0)*$+ -/

9:;:7,2&2<$/ ,'23+%$/: 7## 0.("% 8--&/-&$ FEY )/+ 8--&/-&$ FEW )/+ ),,-5()/?2/4 &$6&: 7## %5-) C//-&)&2-/. -4$"% G,-/&2/1$+:::H

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 20/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

;&)&$* ;1(%$5$ A-1%& ')* 1('$3+ &'$ +2*,%$&2-/ -8 &'$ C&&-%/$? a$/$%)3 )/+ &'$ 25524%)&2-/$/8-%,$5$/& )1&'-%2&2$* &- +$82/$ c$6&%$5$ ')%+*'2(g 1/+$% (%-,$$+2/4* 8-% &'$ *1*($/*2-/ -8

+$(-%&)&2-/FEY )/+ &- +$/? *1*($/*2-/ -8 +$(-%&)&2-/ )/+ %$81*$ &- %$-($/ (%-,$$+2/4* 8-% &'$*1*($/*2-/ -8 +$(-%&)&2-/ $#$/ 28 ) (%25) 8),2$ ,)*$ 8-% *1*($/*2-/ 2* +$5-/*&%)&$+:

FEW @'$ A-1%&

'$3+ &')& ) ,-1%& ,-13+ /-& *10*&2&1&$ ) 320$%)3 +$82/2&2-/ -8 c$6&%$5$ ')%+*'2(g 8-% ) /)%%-= -/$

 (%$8$%%$+ 0? &'$ C&&-%/$? a$/$%)3 )/+ &'$ 25524%)&2-/ $/8-%,$5$/& )1&'-%2&2$*. /-&2/4 &')&-&'$%=2*$ c)/? 8-%$24/ #2*2&-% ='- ')* 8$%&232&?. 5-/$?. )/+ &'$ )0232&? &- *&)? -1& -8 &%-103$ =2&'

&'$ (-32,$ 8-% *$#$/ ?$)%* ,)/ ,')/4$ '2* *&)&1* 8%-5 &')& -8 &-1%2*& -% *&1+$/& &- &')& -8 ($%5)/$/&%$*2+$/& =2&'-1& &'$ 2/,-/#$/2$/,$ -8 25524%)&2-/ k1-&)*: @'2* *&%)&$4? 2* /-& 8)2% &- &'-*$=)2&2/4 8-% ) k1-&):gFEZ C 9:;:7,2&2<$/ ,'23+ 51*& 0$ TF ?$)%* -3+ &- 0%2/4 )32$/ ()%$/&* 2/&- &'$9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )* 25524%)/&*:FEK B$+$%)3 ,-1%&* ')#$ 8-1/+ &')& &'2* %$k12%$5$/& 2* 5$)/& c&-

 (%$#$/& ='-3$*)3$ ,2%,15#$/&2-/ -8 &'$ 25524%)&2-/ 3)=* 0? ($%*-/* ='- $/&$% &'$ ,-1/&%?

233$4)33? )/+ (%-5(&3? ')#$ ,'23+%$/ &- )#-2+ +$(-%&)&2-/.gFEX )/+ +-$* /-& #2-3)&$ $k1)3 (%-&$,&2-/ 0? +2*&2/412*'2/4 0$&=$$/ 9:;:7,2&2<$/ ,'23+%$/ ='- )%$ 52/-%* )/+ &'-*$ ='- ')#$

)&&)2/$+ 5)>-%2&?:FFE

 

@'$ ,-1%&* )(()%$/&3? ')#$ /$#$% %13$+ -/ &'$ *($,282, 2**1$* -8 ='$&'$% &'$ /)&2#$70-%/ ,'23+ -8

1/)1&'-%2<$+ )32$/* )* -((-*$+ &- &'$ ,'23+ -8 3)=8133? (%$*$/& )32$/* 5)? 0$ ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/ -%='$&'$% &'$ /)&2#$70-%/ ,'23+ -8 /-/25524%)/& )32$/* )* -((-*$+ &- 3$4)3 %$*2+$/& )32$/* 5)? 0$ )9:;: ,2&2<$/:FFF P-=$#$%. :).2 ;0+ <"=  *($,282,)33? '$3+ &')& 1/+$% &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& )

,'23+ 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* &- ()%$/&* ='-. )& &'$ &25$ -8 '2* 02%&'. =$%$ *10>$,&* -8 &'$A'2/$*$ $5($%-%. 01& ')+ ) c($%5)/$/& +-52,23 p -0Bq )/+ %$*2+$/,$ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*gFFT )/+

=$%$ /-& +2(3-5)&* -8 &'$ $5($%-%. =)* 0-%/ ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/: @'$ '-3+2/4 +-$* /-& 5)R$ )+2*&2/,&2-/ 0$&=$$/ 233$4)3 )/+ 3$4)3 (%$*$/,$ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. 01& -/$ ,-13+ )%41$ &')& &'$'-3+2/4 2* 3252&$+ &- ,-/*&%12/4 &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& 2/ &'$ ,-/&$6& -8 ()%$/&* ='- )%$

3$4)3 ($%5)/$/& %$*2+$/&*: P-=$#$%. &'$ A-1%&Q* -=/ +2*,1**2-/ -8 &'$ ,-55-/ 3)= +-,&%2/$ -8 34- -)50 )/+ &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& )* )/ )882%5)&2-/ -8 2& 2/+2,)&$* &')& &'$ '-3+2/4. )& &'$

3$)*&. =-13+ /-& 0$ 3252&$+ &- ($%5)/$/& 3$4)3 %$*2+$/&* )* -((-*$+ &- /-/25524%)/&. &%)/*2$/&.3$4)3 )32$/*FFD )/+ ,1%%$/&3? ),,$(&$+ 3)= =-13+ )3*- =$24' )4)2/*& &'2* )%415$/&:FFM 

G:::,-/&2/1$+H

8--&/-&$ FED. ZT C:S:V: B$+: )& FDD. LLZ7FT: @'$ )//-&)&2-/ 32*&* )/+ *155)%2<$* ) /150$% -8 ,)*$* ='2,' +- )/+ +-/-& 82/+ $6&%$5$ ')%+*'2(. 2/,31+2/4 ,)*$* 2/#-3#2/4 9:;:7,2&2<$/ 52/-% ,'23+%$/: @'$ *($,282, 8),&* 2/ *-5$ ,)*$*

%$*13&$+ 2/ ) 82/+2/4 -8 $6&%$5$ ')%+*'2(:FEY  K9E979 89 ?).2 S% :%.2 . MYE 9:;: FDX. FMY GFXKFH:FEW  K9E979 89 A0)-R!0.#&%. MZF 9:;: MMM. MMW. MYF GFXKYH:FEZ MYE 9:;: )& FMY:FEK ;$,&2-/ TEFG0HGTHGCHGIH -8 &'$ I5524%)&2-/ )/+ J)&2-/)32&? C,&. ,-+282$+ )* )5$/+$+ )& K 9:;:A: LFFYFG0HGTHGCHGIH:FEX  S#".%.&#@RA08#"% 89 K9E979. WDE B:T+ )& FDYW. ,2&2/4 6",%.) &# *%5%54%. 89 K9E979. YZZ B:T+ )& YXM:FFE  S#".%.&#@RA08#"% 89 K9E979. WDE B:T+ )& FDYW:FFF ;AP9As o ;UI@P. -4$"% 8--&/-&$ TF. )& FFZ: B-% -&'$% +2*,1**2-/* -8 ,)*$ 3)= )/+ 3$42*3)&2#$ '2*&-%? %$4)%+2/4 &'$

B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/&. *$$ W4%5 /010@#.-C0$Z L0"1C"02C1 B010@#.-C0$Z %.& 1C# *#%.0.2 )( 7)8#"#02.1DZ S#%"0.2 L#()"#1C# 74,B)++011## ). K++02"%10).Z L)"&#" 7#B4"01DZ %.& /5%0+- )( 1C# /)++011## ). 1C# ?4&0B0%"DZ S)4-# )(

 A#$"#-#.1%108#-. ;$%2)3 J-: FEX7WD. FEX&' A-/4: GTEEYHh S#%"0.2 L#()"# 1C# 74,B)++011## ). K++02"%10). %.& /5%0+-)( 1C# /)++011## ). 1C# ?4&0B0%"DZ S)4-# )( A#$"#-#.1%108#-Z ). S9A9 cZ /010@#.-C0$ A#()"+ <B1 )( ]bbcZ %.& S9A9

]^eiZ f)1#" >5020,0501D f#"0(0B%10). <B1 . ;$%2)3 J-: TD. FEY&' A-/4: GFXXZH:FFT FWX 9:;: )& ZEY:FFD 6.01#& 71%1#- 89 :).2 ;0+ <"= . FWX 9:;: )& WXD7WXM: @'$ A-1%& )3*- *&)&$*d

@'$ %$)3 -0>$,& -8 &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& -8 &'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/. 2/ k1)328?2/4 &'$ =-%+*. cC33

 ($%*-/* 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*.g 0? &'$ )++2&2-/. c)/+ *10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ &'$%$-8.g =-13+G,-/&2/1$+:::H

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 21/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

B1%&'$%5-%$. &'$ ,)*$* 2/#-3#2/4 &'$ +$(-%&)&2-/ -8 1/)1&'-%2<$+ )32$/* *25(3? &)R$ 8-% 4%)/&$+&')& &'$2% 9:;:70-%/ ,'23+%$/ )%$ 9:;: ,2&2<$/* 2/ ,-/*2+$%2/4 ='$&'$% &'$ $62*&$/,$ -8 $6&%$5$

')%+*'2( &- 9:;:7,2&2<$/. 52/-% ,'23+%$/ *'-13+ *&)? &'$ +$(-%&)&2-/ -8 &'$ ()%$/&*:FFY @'2* 2* &%1$%$4)%+3$** -8 ='$&'$% &'$ ,'23+%$/ =$%$ 0-%/ +1%2/4 &'$ ($%2-+ -8 )/? 3)=813 *&)? 0? &'$ ()%$/&*.+1%2/4 &'$ ($%2-+ -8 )/? 1/3)=813 *&)?. -% )8&$% )/ 25524%)&2-/ ,-1%&Q* 82/+2/4 -8 +$(-%&)0232&? -8

&'$ ()%$/&*: P-=$#$%. *-5$ *,'-3)%* )%41$ &')& &'$ A2&2<$/*'2( A3)1*$ -8 &'$ B-1%&$$/&'C5$/+5$/& *'-13+ /-& )((3? &- &'$ ,'23+%$/ -8 1/)1&'-%2<$+ )32$/* 0$,)1*$ &'$ (%-03$5 -8

1/)1&'-%2<$+ )32$/* +2+ /-& $62*& )& &'$ &25$ &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& =)* ,-/*2+$%$+ 2/A-/4%$** )/+ %)&282$+ 0? &'$ *&)&$*:FFW 

C3&'-14' &'$ >5=  +$,2*2-/ ,-/*&%1$+ &'$ ('%)*$. c*10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ &'$%$-8.g &'$ *2&1)&2-/-8 J)&2#$ C5$%2,)/* 2* 1/2k1$. *- )/? 2/&$%(%$&)&2-/ &')& &'$ 9:;:70-%/ ,'23+%$/ -8 1/)1&'-%2<$+)32$/* )%$ /-& 0-%/ c*10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/g -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )%41)03? ,-13+ /-& %$3? -/ &'$ >5=  +$,2*2-/:

G:::,-/&2/1$+H

)(($)% &- ')#$ 0$$/ &- $6,31+$. 0? &'$ 8$=$*& )/+ 82&&$*& =-%+*. G0$*2+$* ,'23+%$/ -8 5$50$%* -8 &'$

I/+2)/ &%20$*. *&)/+2/4 2/ ) ($,132)% %$3)&2-/ &- &'$ J)&2-/)3 a-#$%/5$/&. 1/R/-=/ &- &'$ ,-55-/3)=.H p -0Bq &'$ &=- ,3)**$* -8 ,)*$*r,'23+%$/ 0-%/ -8 )32$/ $/$52$* 2/ '-*&23$ -,,1()&2-/. )/+,'23+%$/ -8 +2(3-5)&2, %$(%$*$/&)&2#$* -8 ) 8-%$24/ ;&)&$r0-&' -8 ='2,'. )* ')* )3%$)+? 0$$/

*'-=/. 0? &'$ 3)= -8 O/43)/+. )/+ 0? -1% -=/ 3)=. 8%-5 &'$ &25$ -8 &'$ 82%*& *$&&3$5$/& -8 &'$O/432*' ,-3-/2$* 2/ C5$%2,). ')+ 0$$/ %$,-4/2<$+ $6,$(&2-/* &- &'$ 81/+)5$/&)3 %13$ -8 ,2&2<$/*'2(

 0? 02%&' =2&'2/ &'$ ,-1/&%?: pA2&)&2-/* -52&&$+:q

FWX 9:;: )& WKT:FFM ;')#$%*. -4$"% 8--&/-&$ WM. )& MKX:FFY 7##Z #929. K9E979 89 A0)-R!0.#&%. MZF 9:;: )& MMWh L"%4. 89 K9E979. XXT B:T+ FEFW. FETE GX&' A2%: FXXDHh S#".%.&#@R

 A08#"% 89 K9E979. WDE B:T+ )& FDYWh :%.2 89 K9E979. WTT B:T+ FDMF. FDMK GX&' A2%: FXKEHh6",%.) &# *%5%54%. 89 K9E979.YZZ B:T+ )& YXMh G).@%5#@R/4#8%- 89 K9E979. YFY B:T+ )& FTTM:FFW ;AP9As o ;UI@P. -4$"% 8--&/-&$ TF. )& XY7XK: ;$$ )3*- S2/- C: a%)432). L0"1C"02C1 /010@#.-C0$ ()" /C05&"#. )(

 K55#2%5 <50#.-I %. K""%10).%5 !4,50B !)50BD. FM @$6: V$#: S)= o _-3: F GTEEXH G)%412/4 &')& &'$ 8$+$%)3 ,-1%&* *'-13+%$,-4/2<$ &'$ 2%%)&2-/)32&? -8 2/&$%(%$&2/4 &'$ A-/*&2&1&2-/ )* 5)/+)&2/4 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2( 8-% ,'23+%$/ -81/)1&'-%2<$+ )32$/* )/+ ($%52& A-/4%$** &- 3$42*3)&$ 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2( 0)*$+ -/ (1032, (-32,? +2*,-1%)42/4 &'$+$&%25$/&)3 $88$,&* -8 $6()/*2#$ 02%&'%24'& ,2&2<$/*'2(H: @'2* )%&2,3$ ,2&$* [1+4$ V2,')%+ _-*/$%Q* ,-/,1%%2/4 -(2/2-/ 2/

H()"30 89 <-CB")(1 . DYM B:D+ WEX. WTE7TF GZ&' A2%: TEEDH. 2/ ='2,' '$ )%41$*d

::: A-/4%$** *'-13+ %$&'2/R ::: )=)%+2/4 ,2&2<$/*'2( &- $#$%?-/$ 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* G=2&' ) 8$=#$%? 52/-% $6,$(&2-/*. ::: p,2&)&2-/ -52&&$+qH. 2/,31+2/4 &'$ ,'23+%$/ -8 233$4)3 25524%)/&* ='-*$ *-3$5-&2#$ 2/ 25524%)&2/4 =)* &- ,-/8$% 9:;: ,2&2<$/*'2( -/ &'$2% )* ?$& 1/0-%/ ,'23+%$/: @'2* %13$. &'-14'

&'-14'& 0? *-5$ ,-5($33$+ 0? *$,&2-/ F -8 &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/&. ='2,' (%-#2+$* &')& c)33 ($%*-/* 0-%/ -% /)&1%)32<$+ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. )/+ *10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ &'$%$-8. )%$ ,2&2<$/* -8&'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )/+ -8 &'$ ;&)&$ ='$%$2/ &'$? %$*2+$.g )/+ 2/ )/? $#$/& ,-+282$+ 2/ K 9:;:A: LFMEFG)H.='2,' (%-#2+$* &')& c&'$ 8-33-=2/4 *')33 0$ /)&2-/)3* )/+ ,2&2<$/* -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )& 02%&'d G)H )

 ($%*-/ 0-%/ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*. )/+ *10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ &'$%$-8.g 5)R$* /- *$/*$::::

`$ *'-13+ /-& 0$ $/,-1%)42/4 8-%$24/$%* &- ,-5$ &- &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* *-3$3? &- $/)03$ &'$5 &- ,-/8$%9:;: ,2&2<$/*'2( -/ &'$2% 81&1%$ ,'23+%$/: ̂ 1& &'$ =)? &- *&-( &')& )01*$ -8 '-*(2&)32&? 2* &- %$5-#$ &'$2/,$/&2#$ 0? ,')/42/4 &'$ %13$ -/ ,2&2<$/*'2(.:::: C ,-/*&2&1&2-/)3 )5$/+5$/& 5)? 0$ %$k12%$+ &-

,')/4$ &'$ %13$ ='$%$0? 02%&' 2/ &'2* ,-1/&%? )1&-5)&2,)33? ,-/8$%* 9:;: ,2&2<$/*'2(. 01& I +-10& 2&:pA2&)&2-/ -52&&$+:q @'$ (1%(-*$ -8 &'$ %13$ =)* &- 4%)/& ,2&2<$/*'2( &- &'$ %$,$/&3? 8%$$+ *3)#$*. )/+ &'$$6,$(&2-/ 8-% ,'23+%$/ -8 8-%$24/ +2(3-5)&* )/+ '$)+* -8 *&)&$ *'-=* &')& A-/4%$** +-$* /-& %$)+ &'$,2&2<$/*'2( ,3)1*$ -8 &'$ B-1%&$$/&' C5$/+5$/& 32&$%)33?: A-/4%$** =-13+ /-& 0$ 83-1&2/4 &'$

A-/*&2&1&2-/ 28 2& )5$/+$+ &'$ I5524%)&2-/ )/+ J)&2-/)32&? C,& &- (1& )/ $/+ &- &'$ /-/*$/*$:

P-=$#$%. &'$ -(2/2-/ -8 &'$ ,-1%& 5)>-%2&? 2/ &'$ H()"30 ,)*$ )**$%&*. c@'$ 3)= 2* ,3$)% &')& ,2&2<$/ 8)523? 5$50$%* -8233$4)3 )32$/* ')#$ /- ,-4/2<)03$ 2/&$%$*& 2/ (%$#$/&2/4 )/ )32$/Q* $6,31*2-/ p,2&)&2-/* -52&&$+q: 9/+$% &'$ (%$*$/& 3)= )=-5)/ ='- 2* -&'$%=2*$ ) +$(-%&)03$ )32$/ +-$* /-& ')#$ )/? 2/,$/&2#$ &- 0$)% ) ,'23+ G='- )1&-5)&2,)33? 0$,-5$* )

,2&2<$/H ='-*$ %24'&* &- *&)? )%$ *$()%)&$ 8%-5 &'$ 5-&'$%Q* -0324)&2-/ &- +$()%&:g DYM B:D+ )& WFK:

7/25/2019 Birthright Citizenship Under the 14th Amendment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/birthright-citizenship-under-the-14th-amendment 22/22

$% $ ' % % )*+, - + *$ % * 3*+ 3*+% 4 *$,4+, 4$+ %4 *+ 8$*+%,

^$,)1*$ -8 &'$ ;1(%$5$ A-1%& 2/&$%(%$&)&2-/* -8 9:;: ,2&2<$/*'2( 3)=* )/+ ,-/*&2&1&2-/)3 (%-#2*2-/*. -/$ ,-13+ )%41$ &')& ) ,-/*&2&1&2-/)3 )5$/+5$/& 2* /$,$**)%? &- ,3)%28? &'$ 5$)/2/4

-8 c*10>$,& &- &'$ >1%2*+2,&2-/ -8 &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$*:g "/ &'$ -&'$% ')/+. %+0B4- B4"0%# G8%2$/+ -8&'$ ,-1%&H 0%2$8* *1052&&$+ 0? *$#$%)3 2/&$%$*&$+ -%4)/2<)&2-/* &- &'$ 9:;: ;1(%$5$ A-1%& 8-%,-/*2+$%)&2-/ +1%2/4 &'$ ,)*$ -8 S%+&0 89 A4+-(#5& 

FFZ )%41$+. )5-/4 -&'$% &'2/4*. &')& &'$

;1(%$5$ A-1%& 2/&$%(%$&)&2-/* /$#$% ,-/&$5(3)&$+ -% 2/&$/+$+ &- 2/,31+$ &'$ 4%)/&2/4 -8)1&-5)&2, ,2&2<$/*'2( 0? 02%&' 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* &- ($%*-/* ='-*$ ()%$/&* =$%$ )32$/* ='-

$/&$%$+ -% *&)?$+ 2/ &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* 1/3)=8133? -% ='- =$%$ &%)/*2$/&3? (%$*$/&: J-&=2&'*&)/+2/4 *1,' )%415$/&*. &'$ A-1%& 2&*$38 5)+$ 2&* +$,2*2-/ 2/ &'$ S%+&0 ,)*$ 0)*$+ -/&'$ )**15(&2-/ &')& P)5+2 =)* ) 9:;: ,2&2<$/: U-*& -&'$% 34- -)50 ,-1/&%2$* ')#$ 3252&$+,2&2<$/*'2( 0? 02%&' 2/ &'$2% &$%%2&-%2$*:FFK 

6>)0'( !'+)9@) B+*'(79)/'+

U)%4)%$& U2R?1/4 S$$S$42*3)&2#$ C&&-%/$?

553$$v,%*:3-,:4-#. Z7TYZX

FFZ YX S: O+: T+ YZK. FTM ;: A&: TWDD GTEEMH:  <+0B4- /4"0%# 0%2$8* )++%$**2/4 &'$ 2/&$%(%$&)&2-/ -8 &'$ A2&2<$/*'2(

A3)1*$ =$%$ *1052&&$+ 0? GFH &'$ O)43$ B-%15 O+1,)&2-/ )/+ S$4)3 ]$8$/*$ B1/+h GTH &'$ A3)%$5-/& I/*&2&1&$ A$/&$%8-% A-/*&2&1&2-/)3 [1%2*(%1+$/,$h )/+ GDH &'$ A$/&$% 8-% C5$%2,)/ 9/2&?. B%2$/+* -8 I5524%)&2-/ S)= O/8-%,$5$/&.

 J)&2-/)3 A$/&$% -/ A2&2<$/*'2( )/+ I5524%)&2-/. )/+ V$(%$*$/&)&2#$* ;&$#$ s2/4. ])/) V-'%)0),'$%. S)5)% ;: ;52&'.@'-5)* a: @)/,%$+-. V-*,-$ ̂ )%&3$&&. U), A-332/*. [-$ ^)%&-/. )/+ [-'/ [: ]1/,)/. [%: 93&25)&$3?. P)5+2 =)*

%$3$)*$+ 0? &'$ 9/2&$+ ;&)&$* )/+ )33-=$+ &- %$&1%/ &- ;)1+2 C%)02) -/ &'$ ,-/+2&2-/ &')& '$ %$/-1/,$ '2* 9:;:,2&2<$/*'2(: O%2, S2,'&03)1. 6979Z L)F0.2 1) /)4"1Z 1) J"## k>.#+D /)+,%1%.1ZU  J:N: @IUO; G;$(&$50$% TD. TEEMH:FFK ;$$ A-/*&)/,$ C: [-'/*-/. S)= S20%)%? "8 A-/4%$** V$(-%& TEFE7EEMWEM. L0"1C"02C1 /010@#.-C0$ K. GRed/)4.1"0#- GC141*& TEFEH. )#)23)03$ )& '&&(d\\===:3-,:4-#\3)=\'$3(\%$(-%&*\(+8\TEFE7EEMWEMna7TEn,')%&:(+8h 9:;:

A2&2<$/*'2( )/+ I5524%)&2-/ ;$%#2,$*. /010@#.-C0$ 0. 1C# 6.01#& 71%1#-. )& Y )/+ C(($/+26 II )& WX GTEEMH: