Upload
sipadhuri
View
216
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
1/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Recovery Boiler
Modeling
Process Simulation Ltd.
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
2/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Develop modeling tools toimprove existing designs
and operating procedures,and to lower carry overand environmental impact
Analyse performance ofdifferent air systems andliquor firing strategies
Objectives
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
3/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Introduction
Process and equipment designwas, until recently, based onexperience
Advances in numerical methodsand computer speed andmemory
increased possibility of usingmore scientific methods,
called mathematicalmodeling, for process designand optimization
Computing Hardware Trends
0.1
1
10
100
1000
10000
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000
Memory(MB)
0.1
1
10
100
1000
S eedMIPS
Memory
Speed
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
4/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Mathematical Modeling Applications
in Other Industries
Computer
Jet engines Weather
Automotive
Harrier jet
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
5/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Equipment Modeling Capabilities:
MatureDevelopingPreliminary
Time
Bark Boiler
BFB Bark Boiler
Hydrocyclone
Head box
DigesterLime kiln
Gasifier
Recovery Boiler
We have active projects on this equipment
>306411
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
6/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Client List
Weyerhaeuser USA
Weyerhaeuser Canada
Canfor
Kvaerner
Scott Paper
Anthony Ross Weldwood
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
7/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Why Use Modeling?
Recovery Boiler environment is too severe formeasurement
The model provides comprehensive information
throughout the entire boiler at relatively low cost Can evaluate what if scenarios to improve
operation/design
Supplements steam chief and operator knowledge
of recovery boiler operations Assists mill managers in making informed decisions
regarding boiler refits/replacements
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
8/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Details of the Recovery Boiler Model
Liquor Combustion Model
Advanced and verified solution algorithm
Black liquor combustion modelDryingPyrolysis CO, CO2, CH4, H2, H2O
Char gasification Gas phase combustion model
Advanced radiation model
Convective section model
Char bed model
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
9/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Issues Addressed by the Model
High excess air
CO, CO2, and other emissions Mechanical carryover & plugging
Bed blackouts
Superheater and waterwall tube thermal
stress failures
Boiler stability and capacity
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
10/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Input Data Required
Boiler geometry Bed shape
Convective section layout
Air temperature and flow rate at each port
Liquor characteristics
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
11/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Model Predictions
Gas species (e.g. H2,O2,N2,CO,CO2,H2O,CH4)
distributions
Gas flow velocity fields
Temperature distributions and heat transferto wall surfaces
Liquor spray combustionand droplettrajectories.
Carryover characteristics
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
12/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Model Validation
Water Model Measurements
Full Scale Measurements
Isothermal flow validation
Hot flow validation
Temperature measurements at bullnose
Carryover prediction trends CO emission trends
Velocity measurements
CE Boiler Model
B&W Boiler Model
Different aspects of model resultshave been validated against datafrom operating boilers
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
13/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Recovery Boiler Refit Example
High plugging rates High gas temperature
at superheater
Bed growth control
The Issue:
The Objective:
To recommend modifications toair system
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
14/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Tertiary Air Ports (20%)
Secondary Air Ports (30%)
Primary Air Ports (50%)
Base Case Modified Air System
Test Case Geometries
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
15/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Secondary Air System Problem and Solution
Jets collide
Carryover
Core forms
Secondaryjets
Liquor guns
Jets Interlace
Uniform flow
Secondary
jets
Base Case Modified Air System
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
16/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Primary
V = 30 m/s
50% Air
T = 423 K
M = 46 kg/s
z = 1.2 m
Liquor Guns
HV=15000 kJ/kg
T = 400 K
M = 18 kg/s
z = 7 m
Base
Case
Secondary
V = 85 m/s30% Air
T = 423 K
M = 27.6 kg/s
z = 3 m
Tertiary
20% Air
V = 50 m/s
T = 423 K
M = 18.4 kg/s
z = 10 m
Modified
Air
SystemTertiary
20% Air
V = 50 m/s
T = 423 K
M = 18.4 kg/s
z = 10 m
Secondary
V = 85 m/s30% Air
T = 423 K
M = 27.6 kg/s
z = 3 m
CommonAir/Liquor
System
Data in
Plan View
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
17/24
www.psl.bc.ca
1600
1500
1400
1300
1200
1100
1000
900
800
700
600
T[K]
Base Case
1600
1500
1400
1300
1200
1100
1000
900
800
700
600
T[K]
Modified Air System
Temperature Profiles
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
18/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Velocity Profiles
16
14
12
10
8
64
2
0
-2
-4
20m/s
UpwardvelocityW [m/s]
Base Case
16
14
12
10
8
64
2
0
-2
-4
20m/s
UpwardvelocityW [m/s]
Modified Air System
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
19/24
www.psl.bc.ca
X
Y
Z
X
Y
Z
---- drying
---- pyrolysis
---- char
---- smelt
Fuel Particle Trajectories
Base Case Modified Air System
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
20/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Y
Z
X
200
160
140
120
10080
60
40
20
5
0Modified Air S ystem
Total Carryoverat Superheater0.03%
Carryovermass flux[g/s/m
2]
Y
Z
X
200
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
5
0
Carryovermass flux[g/s/m
2]
Base Case
Total Carryoverat Superheater4.06%
Carryover Mass Flux
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
21/24
www.psl.bc.ca
0
2
46
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
Base Case
Modified Air System
Water SmeltPyro. Char
Wall
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Water SmeltPyro. Char
InFlight
0
1
2
3
4
5
Water SmeltPyro. Char
Carryover
0
3
6
9
12
15
Water SmeltPyro. Char
Bed
Black Liquor Particulate Distribution
(% of total liquor input)
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
22/24
www.psl.bc.ca
X
Y
Z
O2
0.16
0.14
0.12
0.1
0.08
0.07
0.06
0.05
0.04
0.02
X
Y
Z
O2
0.16
0.14
0.12
0.1
0.08
0.07
0.06
0.05
0.04
0.02
Oxygen Concentration Distribution
Base Case Modified Air System
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
23/24
www.psl.bc.ca
X
Y
Z
CO
0.10.05
0.01
0.005
0.003
0.001
0.0005
0.0001
5E-05
X
Y
Z
CO
0.10.05
0.01
0.005
0.003
0.001
0.0005
0.0001
5E-05
Carbon Monoxide Concentration Distribution
Base Case Modified Air System
8/10/2019 black liquir Recovery
24/24
www.psl.bc.ca
Conclusions
The modified air system:
Larger air ports provides better jet penetration.
Increases gas mixing
Breaks up the vertical air core
Significantly reduces plugging rates.
Reduces gas temperatures at superheater
In general, modeling:
Provides detailed data to facilitate efficientoperation of Recovery Boilers.
Helps mill managers make informed decisions
regarding boiler refits/replacements