1
390 6eoJ~mal 14.3/1987 Book reviews Peesi, M. (ed.): Environmental and dyna- mic geomorphology (Studies in Geography in Hungary 17) 220 pp., Akademiai Kiado, Budapest 1985. These twenty-two papers by Hungarian scientists were presented to the First International Geomorphological Confe- rence in Manchester. There is the expec- ted concern with soil erosion and with active slope processes (here landslips in the loess of the Danube bluffs). Alongside the papers on process-form relationships are two other groups, one concerned with longer-term landform evo- lution or analysis, the other with the mapping and interpretation of landforms. Given the marvellous alluvial forms of the Tisza valley it is good to see a well-illustrated paper by Loezy, though by the time his geomorphological map is interpreted in terms of agriculural potential, most of the detail has disap- peared. The papers on planation surfaces are an interesting group, for the fre- quent burial of such in the Pannonian Basin means that dating is often possi- ble. Indeed Pecsi and Mezosi boldly subtitle their piece "Explanation of geomorphological surfaces", though more detail is found in the following paper by Juhasz and Kertesz which foeusses on surfaces on horsts buried by subsidence during the Late Tertiary and now either remaining buried, or uplifted again complete with remnants of their Eocene or Oligocene cover. Overall these essays are easy to read (the English transla- tion is usually smooth and clear), but they-are nearly all a little brief for a full exposition of their material, and almost all of them could do with fuller illustration. Photographs would perhaps have been difficult to provide on this budget (though reference to those avai- lable in other books might have helped the serious student), but we do need more, and more detailed, maps. Thus IVIarosi writes on erosion hazard around Lake Balaton, and later with Szilard he describes the Balaton Riviera, but nei- ther of these has a map of any kind. Pecsi has some excellent maps in his introductory essay he should have encouraged the others to use them. When geomorpholgists have to deliver maps or tables on which decisions of land use or management may be based, they must pro- duce a simple classification of areas which the non-specialist can use in his decision-making. Some of these are pro- duced by the amalgamation of categories on geomorphological maps as in the case of Loczy's work on the Tisza. In two cases included here, quite varied cha- racteristics are brought together in a scoring technique; thus Marosi scores surface resistance to erosion, litholo- g-y, slope angle, soil surface cover, and land use to derive values to guide deci- sions designed to minimise soil loss. He does not explain the basis of the tech- nique, comment on its success, nor com- pare the approach with the USLE. If Environmental Geomorphology is to be turned into Applied Geomorphology (for unlike Pecsi I cannot regard them as the same thing) techniques such as these deserve greater elaboration, discussion and justification. Perhaps a second international conference could justify a volume "Applying Geomorphology" and then we could be told how it is done. Keith Clayton, Norwich, UK Klug, H.: Flutwellen und Risiken der Kfiste. 122 pp. F. Steiner, Stuttgart 1986. This textbook on a basic level is dea- ling with catastrophic sea waves and coastal hazards. It is intended to form a link between genera] and systematic textbooks on the one hand, and more specialized papers on the other. Three types of catastrophic waves are recognized: Seismically induced tsuna- mis, mainly occurring in the Pacific, waves generated by tropical cyclones, mainly occurring in the Caribbean, the Indian Ocean and the Northwest Pacific, and finally waves associated with extra- tropical storms, which are most frequent in the North Sea and the Baltic. This regionality of the phenomena is being stressed throughout the book. The contents are as follows: A short introduction on wave generation and travel, as well as elements (the tide, storm surges, etc.) influencing the extent of the catastrophe. In the follo- wing chapters, the three phenomena are described separately. Their regional distribution and geographical dissimila- rities, their generation and character is being traced, as well as the conse- quences and resulting damage. Finally, countermeasures, prognoses and warning systems are touched upon. Major cata- strophic waves and their consequences are listed as far back as records permit and several specific examples are des- cribed. In the last two chapters (two pages each), the risk to human life and property in connection with the occur- rence of catastrophic sea waves is esti- mated, and new methods whereby these risks can be minimized are described. The text is concise and well-structured, the figures are clear and pedagogical. The book incorporates oceanographic and coastal research, human geography as well as engineering aspects. All in all, this provides an easily read and comprehensive text on the subject with many interesting details, although quantitative descriptions of the pheno- mena have been omitted. Troels Aagaard, Copenhagen Klug, H. (ed.): Ktiste und Meeresboden, Kieler Geogr. Schriften. Bd. 62, Kiel 1985. This volume consists of a collection of papers presented at the annual meeting of the "Deutscher Arbeitskreis f[ir Geo- morphologie" and the "Arbeitskreis ftir Kfisten- und Meeresgeographie", held in Kiel 1985. The theme for the symposium was the geographical region as related to coastal and submarine geomorphology, periglacial geomorphology and applied geomorphology. The first two papers are dealing with coastal geomorphology in antarctic viz. subarctic environments, with the main emphasis on description. In papers 3 through 7, studies on sea-level history and tectonics are reported from as wide- ly differing localities as Spain, the Canary Islands, the Middle East, Sri Lanka and Namibia. The last five papers are dealing with as diverse themes as the relation between present coastal configuration and climate during the Quaternary; research methods and map analysis in the Wadden Sea; morphodyna- mics and cliff erosion in the Baltic; evolution of Turkish rivers in the Midd- le Ages, and finally studies on the topography of sea-mounts. The quality of photos and figures is generally good, although a bit variable. Furthermore, it would have been an ad- vantage had these been incorporated in the text pages. The main strength of the book lies in its regional approach and the descrip- tions of little-known localities, as the vast majority of studies dealing with the coastal environment are being con- ducted in North America, Britain and Australia. Although fragmentary with small consis- tency in research objects and methods, ~he book adds to our knowledge of the World's coastlines, as well as it pre- sents new data on sea-level fluctuations during the Quaternary and Holocene. Troels Aagaard, Copenhagen

Book reviews

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

390 6eoJ~mal 14.3/1987

Book reviews

Peesi, M. (ed.): Envi ronmenta l and dyna - mic geomorphology (Studies in Geography in Hungary 17) 220 pp., Akademiai Kiado, Budapes t 1985.

These twen ty - two papers by Hungar ian scientists were presented to the First In ternat ional Geomorphological Confe- rence in Manches te r . There is the expec- ted concern with soil erosion and with active slope processes (here landslips in the loess of the Danube bluffs). Alongside t he papers on process- form relat ionships are two o ther groups, one concerned with longe r - t e rm landform evo- lut ion or analysis, t he o ther with the mapp ing and in terpre ta t ion of landforms. Given t he marvel lous alluvial forms of the Tisza valley it is good to see a well- i l lustrated paper by Loezy, though by the t ime his geomorphological m a p is interpreted in t e rms of agriculural potential , mos t of the detail has d isap- peared. The papers on p lana t ion surfaces are an interes t ing group, for t he fre- quent burial of such in the P a n n o n i a n Bas in m e a n s t ha t da t ing is often possi- ble. Indeed Pecsi and Mezosi boldly subt i t le thei r piece "Explanat ion of geomorphological surfaces", though more detail is found in the following paper by Juhasz and Kertesz which foeusses on surfaces on hors t s buried by subsidence during the Late Ter t iary and now ei ther remaining buried, or uplifted again complete with r e m n a n t s of their Eocene or Oligocene cover. Overall these essays are easy to read (the English t rans la - tion is usually smoo th and clear), bu t t h e y - a r e nearly all a little brief for a full exposit ion of their material , and almost all of t h e m could do with fuller i l lustration. Pho tog ra phs would perhaps have been difficult to provide on this budget ( though reference to those avai- lable in o ther books might have helped the serious s tudent ) , bu t we do need more, and more detailed, maps . T hus IVIarosi writes on erosion hazard around Lake Bala ton , and later with Szilard he describes the Ba la ton Riviera, bu t nei- ther of these has a m a p of any kind. Pecsi has some excellent m a p s in his in t roductory essay he should have encouraged the others to use them. W hen geomorpholgists have to deliver m a p s or tables on which decisions of land use or m a n a g e m e n t may be based, they must pro- duce a simple classification of areas which the non-specia l is t can use in his decis ion-making. Some of these are p ro- duced by the ama lgama t i on of categories on geomorphological m a p s as in the case

of Loczy's work on the Tisza. In two cases included here, quite varied cha - racteristics are brought toge ther in a scoring technique; thus Maros i scores surface resis tance to erosion, l i tholo- g-y, slope angle, soil surface cover, and land use to derive values to guide deci- sions designed to minimise soil loss. He does not explain the basis of the tech- nique, commen t on its success, nor com- pare the approach with the USLE. If Envi ronmenta l Geomorphology is to be tu rned into Applied Geomorphology (for unlike Pecsi I cannot regard t h e m as the same thing) techniques such as these deserve grea ter elaboration, discussion and justif ication. Perhaps a second in ternat ional conference could just ify a volume "Applying Geomorphology" and t hen we could be told how it is done.

Kei th Clayton , Norwich, UK

Klug, H.: Flutwellen u n d Risiken der Kfiste. 122 pp. F. Steiner, S tu t tga r t 1986.

This textbook on a basic level is dea- ling with ca tas t rophic sea waves and coastal hazards . It is in tended to form a link between genera] and sys temat ic textbooks on the one hand , and more specialized papers on the other. Three types of ca tas t rophic waves are recognized: Seismically induced t s u n a - mis, mainly occurring in the Pacific, waves genera ted by tropical cyclones, mainly occurring in the Caribbean, the Indian Ocean and the Northwest Pacific, and finally waves associated with ext ra- tropical s torms, which are most frequent in the Nor th Sea and the Baltic. This regionality of the p h e n o m e n a is being stressed th roughout the book. The con ten t s are as follows: A short in t roduct ion on wave generat ion and travel, as well as e lements ( the tide, s to rm surges, etc.) influencing the extent of the ca tas t rophe . In the follo- wing chapters , the three p h e n o m e n a are described separately. Their regional d is t r ibut ion and geographical dissimila- rities, their generat ion and charac ter is being traced, as well as the conse- quences and resul t ing damage . Finally, countermeasures , prognoses and warning sys tems are touched upon. Major ca ta - s t rophic waves and their consequences are listed as far back as records permit and several specific examples are des - cribed. In the last two chapters (two pages each), the risk to h u m a n life and proper ty in connect ion with the occur- rence of ca tas t rophic sea waves is esti- ma ted , and new me thods whereby these risks can be minimized are described.

The text is concise and wel l -s t ructured, the figures are clear and pedagogical . The book incorporates oceanographic and coastal research, h u m a n geography as well as engineering aspects . All in all, th is provides an easily read and comprehensive text on the subject with m a n y interes t ing details, a l though quant i t a t ive descr ipt ions of the p h en o - m e n a have been omit ted.

Troels Aagaa rd , Copenhagen

Klug, H. (ed.): Ktiste u n d Meeresboden, Kieler Geogr. Schriften. Bd. 62, Kiel 1985.

This vo lume consis ts of a collection of papers presented at the annual mee t ing of the "Deutscher Arbeitskreis f[ir Geo- morphologie" and the "Arbeitskreis ftir Kfis ten- u n d Meeresgeographie", held in Kiel 1985. The t h e m e for the s y m p o s i u m was the geographical region as related to coastal and submar ine geomorphology, periglacial geomorphology and applied geomorphology. The first two papers are dealing with coastal geomorphology in antarc t ic viz. subarc t ic envi ronments , with the ma in emphas i s on description. In papers 3 through 7, s tudies on sea-level h is tory and tectonics are reported from as wide- ly differing localities as Spain, the Canary Islands, the Middle East , Sri Lanka and Namibia. The last five papers are dealing with as diverse themes as the relation be tween present coastal configuration and cl imate during the Quaternary; research me thods and m a p analysis in the W a d d e n Sea; morph o d y n a - mics and cliff erosion in the Baltic; evolution of Turkish rivers in the Midd- le Ages, and finally s tudies on the topography of s ea -moun t s . The qual i ty of photos and figures is generally good, a l though a bit variable. Fur the rmore , it would have been an ad- van tage h a d these been incorporated in the text pages. The main s t reng th of the book lies in its regional approach and the descrip- t ions of l i t t le-known localities, as the vast major i ty of studies dealing with the coastal env i ronment are being con- ducted in North America , Bri tain and Austral ia. Al though f ragmenta ry with small consis- tency in research objects and methods , ~he book adds to our knowledge of the World's coastlines, as well as it pre- sents new d a t a on sea-level f luctuat ions dur ing the Qua te rna ry and Holocene.

Troels Aagaard, Copenhagen