(Bouchard v. CCFD) Memo Re_Declaratory Relief 01-08-16 FINAL

8/19/2019 (Bouchard v. CCFD) Memo Re_Declaratory Relief 01-08-16 FINAL

1/20

A A A AA

A A, AA A .. . 20121150 A

A ,

.

A ,

A A A

AA

C C F D (CCFD)

C:

AA

1. T CBA U S R CCFD. S: 1, CCFD F A C, C I.

2.

T CCFD , , B D. S: 1, C II.

3.

T CCFD , , , , , , / EMS CCFD. S: 1, CII.

T . A

:1. W B D

(2) CBA U S R?2. M CCFD , ,

B D?

D C, , EMS CCFD?


2/20

2

A

CCFD G A

1959. CCFD , ,

T C. S: 2,

C BL.

O O 15, 2012, CCFD B D

. O O 16, 2012, S C

R J. L, E. (A L) T S M J

R N 13, 2012, A L PS M. P O C N 13, 2013, P

S M, C CCFD . S:

3, O A P S M, 13, N 12, 2013.

O M 6, 2014 G A R.I.G.L. 4591

( F S A FSA) CCFD

S FSA (S R). S T.

H (R H) R CCFD

. O D 23, 2014, R H C 9 B P (C

1:1412785, C 9 C) CCFD . O

J 5, 2015, M A. P (R P) R.

A , R P (

B C) (CBA)

CCFD ( B D) IAFF,


3/20

3

L 3372 (U).

D C 9 C,

CBA, R P U (2)

: , CCFD CBA F 2015 E A,

B, C, D, F S: 5, 2015 CBA A 19, 2015 A 31,

2015; , , CCFD CBA F 20162020 E A, B, C, D, F S:

6, 20152020 CBA S 1, 2015 A 31, 2020.

A CBA R P

U, , B C. T BC CBA

5 P (P).

O S 17, 2015, A D D R, D M.

S (D S) R P

S R S 30, 2015. S: 7, D

S L S 17, 2015. O S 18, 2015, R P

M D C 9 C ( ),

CCFD () B D (B) O 1,

2015. T B CCFD CCFD ,

S R C 9 C,

. T, S C.

T CBA CCFD U J 24, 2011,

A 1, 2012 M 31, 2015. S: 4, 20122015 CBA. N S R P R 20122015 CBA, M 31, 2015 .


4/20

4

O N 25, 2015, J S ( ) S C ,

8213 8214 C

. S:

8, D O, N 25, 2015.

T CCFD B

U, S R,

C ,

, , EMS

( ) .

AA

A

. . . . N T C. . B. R T W,

899 A.2 517, 520, .6 (R.I. 2006) ( N A C. . M, 92 R.I. 51,

53, 166 A.2 216, 217 (1960)). T U D J A

(UDJA) . B

A. . R.I. D. P, 772 A.2 485, 489 (R.I. 2001) ( ). T,

UDJA S C , ,

. S 9301; S

. C, 703 A.2 748, 751 (R.I. 1997) (

UDJA ). O S C

. T N K . I


5/20

5

A F, L 1651 AFLCIO, 107 A.3 304, 319 .14 (R.I. 2015).

T UDJA S C

. C . C, 752 A.2 476, 479 (R.I. 2000) ( R .

H, 419 A.2 827, 830 (R.I. 1980)). T, C

. T E C, LLC 3 ( P

. T W, 121 R.I. 781, 786, 403 A.2 252, 255 (1979)). T ,

, . S, 703 A.2 751 (

). N,

. I. 752.

I ,

. A

. B .

M, 945 A.2 314, 317 (R.I. 2008). T

, . I. ( R I O S .

C, 113 R.I. 16, 22, 317 A.2 124, 128 (1974)). S,

, . R .

R, 119 R.I. 398, 401, 380 A.2 960, 962 (1977).


6/20

6

T

, . 1 A, A

D J 4 (2 . 1951). T . B A., I., 114 R.I. 746, 748,

339 A.2 266, 267 (1975); P H. . I I. C., 109 N.H. 53, 242 A.2

398 (1968); D . S, 183 M. 385, 37 A.2 880 (1944). I

;

. S M I. I. . D,

I., 512 F.2 724 (8

C. 1975); B C. C. . M E. C., 521 F.2 392 (2

C. 1975); B . S, 113 N.H. 559, 311 A.2 310 (1973). N,

. M . P, 114 R.I. 399, 404, 333 A.2 420, 423 (1975); G

L C. . L, 107 R.I. 629, 269 A.2 542 (1970); L . P, 101 R.I. 538, 225

A.2 521 (1967). T

. L . P

AA

A. A

.

CCFD B

CBA R P U

.

F , CBA , ,

2015 CBA A 31, 2015 , PT . P S B, 689 A.2 388, 393 .2 (R.I. 1997) (


7/20

7

I, B (2) CBA ;

CCFD; CBA

B C

C 9 ; , CBA R

P D S. I , CBA () ,

CCFD , .

T CCFD

U

N 17, 2015. S: 9, P A W ( ).

T CBA S R

S R

FSA. T S C FSA (2)

: M . F, 15 A.3 565 (R.I. 2011) S . M, 119 A.3 1

). F, B 20162020 CBA , R P CBA, S R . I B

S M M 17, 2016 . P, R.I.G.L. 289.117, CCFD U, , CCFD U. A, C CCFD A S

F() AAA, () ( ) U R.I.G.L. 289.18, .


8/20

8

(R.I. 2015). P M , C , A

, M,

119 A.2 577. F, C , T

, ...

,

, . S 4591. I. T C

FSA , FSA

.U FSA, S R

; , N

,

, ,

. ... R.I.G.L. 4599. M ,

U S R C 9

, CBA B J

R P 5 P.

W D S S R S 17, 2015

, , 2% , P

. T CCFD

( ) ()


9/20

9

. T

R P CCFD . F

, D S :

•

R P D S P D A. ... 7, 1, .

•

T P, B C, CCFD D P B T. 7, 1, .

•

( ) CBA. 7, 2, .

• S P . 7, 2.

• T FSA

P. ... 7, 2.

• I C 9 CCFD B . ... 7, 4.

I , , D S

S R P

CBA . G D S ,

S R

B CBA, P . I

, B C CBA D

S R.I.G.L. 4599, CBA

T B C B D C 9

C; T C P.


10/20

10

. I ,

.

D , B ( )

CBA 20152016 20162017 . A,

,

EMS , 20162020 CBA .

A, CCFD B

CBA R P

U ..

, ,

.

CCFD

EMS ,

B D

.

1.

A ,

.

T

. A

. R I S L A . NELS, I., 550 A.2 624,626

(R.I. 1988) ( ); V . J B C, 91 RI. 350, 163 A.2


11/20

11

18 (1960); P . W H A, 87 R.I. 444, 143 A.2 146 (1958);

C DM, I. . R, 763 A.2 607, 610 (R.I. 2000) ( P

.)

S 3() CCFD C D

:

C 2007 , M S, 7:00 P.M. D B , : (1)

B D; (2) D; (3) , S 6 ; (4) , , , , D; (5) F B D .

T, B, C

(1) . T : D

CCFD ; , , ,

(, , )

.

A

,

.

E U

, U ,

: ,


12/20

12

CCFD CBA

S R. A ,

( ) , . T

U CCFD

,

CCFD .

N CCFD ,

S 3 C D,

... ,

D.

T C CCFD 2012 2013

CBA, ,

, G A.

. , ,

, , , ,

/ .

CCFD

EMS CCFD,

, (.. ),

, .

J , S C

, .


13/20

13

F M C. . N L R B, 441 U.S. 488, 498, 99 S.C. 1842, 60

L.E.2 420 (1979) ( F P P C., 379 U.S. 223 (S, J.,

)). W ,

.

B S C, 120 R.I. 479, 388 A.2 1375. A,

. S: P H .

N L R B, 93 F.3 1012, 1018 (1 C. 1996). T

. I. N, ,

,

,

. B S C, 120 R.I. 47980, 388 A.2 1375. T ,

,

. T N K . I A

F, L 1651 AFLCIO, 107 A.3 304, 31314 (R.I. 2015); T

N P . D, C.A. PC20095835 (S C R.I., J 29, 2010)

(S, J.) ( T

); L 2334 I A F . T N

P, C.A. PC20096883 (S C R.I., D. 31, 2009) (L, J.) (T

. D

F D


14/20

14

. I F

D ,

. T T

,

.). I , CCFD

, , , ,

, , / EMS

CCFD.

M, , R.I. C G A :

, , , , . R.I. C. . 6, . 12.

T S C :

W L. E . TA J, 104 R.I. 630, 634, 247 A.2 850, 853 (1968).T , L , L . N G L C. . N, 114 R.I.696, 699, 338 A.2 536, 538 (1975). I G A . B,593 A.2 49, 52 (R.I. 1991).

T , L. I W F C, 39 R.I. 1, 1213, 97 A.21, 25 (1916).

T G A CCFD. T

G A ,

. T


15/20

15

D . T C CCFD :

S. 7. TAING AUTHORIT TA ASSESSOR () S

, ; ; , , ; ; P.L. 2006 . 405 7.

T CCFD . F,

EMS , G

A

EMS

D

. I CCFD, ,

,

. I ,

, EMS ,

. S G V F C. . D, 64 R.I. 368, 371

72 (1940) (

W , . S: B . C N, 68 RI. 280, 285, 27 A.2 317, 320 (1942) ( ... ); F . K, 433 A.2 172, 175 (R.I. 1981) ( ); N. T B, 102 R.I. 729, 734, 232 A.2 775, 778 (1967) ( , ).


16/20

16

); D . O

B V F C., 70 R.I. 446, 450 (1944) (

). A

, ( ),

G A ,

CCFD . A,

EMS

, . T

,

.

T , ,

:

,

. T R.I. C ,

G A , .

A S . . A 4, 2013 C, G A, , ( ), . S ..EW. G R S. D. . EW. G T A, 489 A.21010, 1016 (R.I. 1985). F , A 6 11 C :

11. V . T .


17/20

17

1. A ..

..,

.

I 2004 A IV 1 R I

C A VI 10 . T ,

100

G A

:

U U S C, R I GA S C

. I A O H R, 485A.2 553; P & B 31 R.I. 316, 77 A. 154.A, G A . . . . N . C E P 103 R.I. 518,52526, 238 A.2 758, 762 (1968). I A O G, 732 A.2 55, 6263 (R.I. 1999) ( E C ).

T A VI 10, 2004 R

I

. I. 64. T G A,

, ,

, R I. T

E C ,

. A I 24 :

S 24. R S . T . T C


18/20

18

C U S.

T R I . I

( ) , CCFD

G A P.L. 2006 . 405,

, . T

2004 CCFD C

(CCFD)

CCFD C. T

,

() EMS S. W

, C

A I 24 , . A ,

C,

CCFD , ,

G A, A 1 24,

CCFD.

F , CCFD

.


19/20

19

CENTRAL COVENTR FIRE DISTRICTBOARD OF DIRECTORS

B A S,

// David M. D’Agostino, Esq.

D M. DA, E. #6288 N G, E. #4136GORHAM & GORHAM, INC.25 D P N S, RI 02857(401) 6471400 T(401) 6471446 F


20/20

20

A

I J 8, 2016:

√ I

: A . T / R I J E F S.

I :

T / R I J E F S.

I □ .

// David M. D’Agostino

Documents

(Bouchard v. CCFD) Memo Re_Declaratory Relief 01-08-16 FINAL