Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
0
P r e s e n t a t i o n UFSIA, March 2, 2001
McKinsey&Company
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
1
AGENDA
Migration from GSM to UMTS: What is UMTS, and what will really happen?
What will UMTS be used for?
UMTS Licenses: trick or treat?
How will it change the industry?
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
2
153290
106
93
182
195
93
69
4940
98159
135
44
78
96
103
21
Source: 1999 OVUM Ltd. report
MOBILE MARKET SUBSCRIBER AND REVENUE GROWTH WILL BE SIGNIFICANT
17
20
28
18
CAGRPercent
CAGRPercent
13
7
20
5
1999 2003
W. Europe
Rest of Asia
South & Central AmericaNorth America
1999 2003
Japan
9
Total 428
842
300
43418 10
Almost twice
Almost 1.5 times
Total subscribersMillions; 1999-2003
Mobile revenuesUSD Billions; 1999-2003
The global mobile market will grow significantly (18% CAGR from 1999~2003 in terms of total subscribers), and Western Europe and Asia are likely hot spots in terms of subscriber and mobile revenue growth
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
3
82 95
69
5073
73
3845
52
21
3
DATA WILL BE THE MAIN DRIVER OF GROWTHRevenue by service levelUSD Billions
Source: OVUM Ltd.
1999 2005
2
5
16
0
50
44
6
42
3
54
2
13
0 641
78
41
1999 2005
73
Total
55-4
Almost 10 times
CAGRPercent
CAGRPercent
Total subscribersMillions; 1999-2003
Mobile revenuesUSD Billions; 1999-2003
W. Europe
Rest of Asia
South & Central AmericaNorth America
Japan
273
325
161
44
17
Data will be the main driver of growth and increase ten times by 2005 from today’s levels
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
4
* e.g. For i-mode, WAP
UMTS WILL BRING SIGNIFICANT CHANGES IN VARIOUS BUILDING BLOCKS
Allows access to internet-based content
SIMPLIFIED
ApplicationsMiddleware & gatewayCore networkRadio access
network
Legacy Network Management
Dedicated applications tailored for the mobile market
Historic permanent highly sensitive customer data
• Network Mgmt• Security
Web servers
Application servers
• Transcoding gateways*• Localization, etc.
• Billing• Customer data filters
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
5
EVOLUTION IN RADIO ACCESS NETWORK TDMA to CDMA and New Spectrum
• 1x9.6/14.4 kbs• Circuit switched• TDMA• 900- 1800 Mhz
Practical data speedkbs
GSM
• Packet switched• Up to 8x14.4 kbs• TDMA• 900- 1800 Mhz
GPRS
• Up to 8x48 kbs• Packet switched• TDMA• 900- 1800 Mhz
EDGE
• CDMA• 1900-2200 Mhz• Up to 2Mbs• Packet switched
UMTS
• Up to 4x14.4 kbs• Circuit switched• TDMA• 900- 1800 Mhz
HSCSD
Today 2000-02 2001-03Availability
9.6
28.8
43.2
144
384
HSCD = High Speed Circuit Switched DataGPRS = General Packet Radio ServiceEDGE = Enhanced Data rates for GSM EvolutionUMTS = Universal Mobile Telephony System, also called IMT-2000 (International Mobile Telephony 2000)
• Different evolution path for 2G operators
• All operators go directly from GPRS to UMTS
• Possibility of green-field for new entrants
APSRAN C/N MW
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
6
THE EUROPEAN OPERATORS WILL GO FROM GSM TO GPRS TO WCDMA
DiscontinuedHighLow
?
Market share by
technology Key implication
?GSM W-CDMA IP
2G 2.5G 3G 4G
Europe
U.S.
Asia
Japan
• Most European and Asian incumbent operators will transition from GSM to GPRS*, and then to W-CDMA
• The challenge is to meet their needs at each stage
?CDMA One?CDMA
?GSM
?GSM
?CDMA
?CDMA One
?D-AMPS
?PDC
?CDMA One
GPRS
EDGE
GPRS
EDGE
CDMA2000
W-CDMA
CDMA2000
W-CDMA
CDMA2000
W-CDMA
?
IP
IP
IP
IP
IPIP
?
?
?
* European operators will most likely not invest in Enhanced GPRS for GSM (EDGE), but transition instead toW-CDMA directly, due to high costs and limited timescales
Source: Operator interviews
?D-AMPS
APSRAN C/N MW
In order for vendors to be successful in 3G with incumbent operators, there is a need to master each step of the technology transition.
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
7
Fast relayATM / circuit-switched
IP over SDH
Associated type of operator
THE CORE NETWORK WILL CHANGE FROM CIRCUIT TO PACKET SWITCHED
• Legacy operator with network optimized for voice
• Legacy operator with non-aggressive data strategy (e.g., Proximus , TIM)
• Attacker operator with aggressive data strategy (e.g., Infostrada, TIW)
• Legacy operator with aggressive data strategies (BT, Vodafone, Telefonica)
Pure IP
ATM+IP
Fast Relay /ATM
4
Voice
Data
4
Public telephone network
Internet/LAN
4
Voice
Data
4
Public telephone network
Internet/LAN
IP CORE
4
Voice/data
Public telephone network
Internet/LAN
Radio access network Core network
Source: Team analysis
GPRS/IP
APSRAN C/N MW
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
8
FROM GSM TO GPRS : PHASE 1 GPRS nodes are key as a first step
* Private Local Managed NetworkSource: Team analysis
APSRAN C/N MW
Mobile core networkRAN
Signaling path
Key features of GPRS
Services • Point-to-point transfer
of data• Point-to-multi point
transfer• Call forwarding
Service levels• QOS with 3 priority
levels (H, M, L) which are billed accordingly
• Delay parameters are also defined for the mean and 95 percentile delay
The BSC is altered to route traffic to both the MSC and SGSN
MSC GMSC
SGSN GGSN
VLR HLR AUC EIRSMSMSC
GPRS-IPspecific
Single mode
MS
4
SIMGSM GPRS
BTS BSC
BSS
Global IP network
Open IP
PSTN/ISDN
PLMN*
Terminals
IN + applications
Data/voice data path
The SGSN switches data and performs charging and management functions. It also stores location data locally
A GPRS specific IP-based system allows the SGSN/GGSN node to set up interfaces with each other and perform layer 2 and 4 functions
The GGSN interfaces between GPRS backbone and external networks. It also converts from “GPRS IP”(GTP) to open IP or X.25
GSM data/voice
GPRS data
Key GRPS nodes
Old GSM 2G C/N domain
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
9
Source: Team analysis
APSRAN C/N MWFROM GPRS TO 3G IP BASED CORE NETWORK : PHASE 2
IP core networkRAN
Key comments
Particularly for legacy operators, it is important at this stage to interwork and reuse as much of the 2G and 2.5G hardware as possible
Ideally, should be built on existing SGSN but with open IP rather than closed IP
Ideally all IP link and internal network
M-GGSN filters and interfaces to data networks
MSC GMSC
M-SGSN M-GGSN
VLR HLR AUC EIRSMSMSC
QOS openIP
Single mode
SIM
4
GSM GPRSBTS BSC
BSS
Global IP network
PSTN/ISDN
PLMN
Terminals
IN + applications
Dual mode
3G Handset
4
Gradually evolving to carrier – class to take advantage of QOS upon IP
Node-BRNC
Node-B
Signaling pathData/voice data path
Built on 2.5G nodes
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
10
FROM 3G IP NETWORKS TO 3.5G AND 4G ALL IP CORE NETWORKS: PHASE 3
Source: Team analysis
APSRAN C/N MW
IP core networkRAN
Media gateways replace MSGSN/MGGSN (or evolve on top of them) to allow access to a unified IP backbone
Single mode
IPV6 address (?)
4
Global IP network
PSTN/ISDN
PLMN
Terminals
Node-BRNC
UTRANNode-B
Manage-ment Data
Media gateway
QoS IP backbone
Applications and services
Media gateway
Media gateway
Media gateway
Media gateway
Built on 3G nodes
Many of the core network decisions in UMTS will be the same as in the fixed line business. As a result, the discussion of
saving cost on CAPEX by addressing convergence emerges
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
11
SEVERAL CHALLENGES UNDERLYING CAPABILITIES REQUIRED
Source: McKinsey anaylsis
Wireless network
Unified messaging
E-mail Paging Fax
Voicemail
Instant messaging
Surf StocksNews,
etc. IntranetData-bases Calendar
PersonalfinancialContacts
Public info Company info Private info
Op
erator cu
stom
er care and
billin
g
Content &
Apps
Gateway &
middleware
Network
equipment
Network
operators
End-user
devices
Location
Identify Share info
Data network management
Load balancing Roaming Quality of service Caching Commerce Security
Promos
Ads
Clearing
Credit
Device
Encryp -tion
Authentic-ation
VPN
Content re-purposing and re-formatting
Tiny HTML WML XML VoXMLHDML OFXOther ML
Device management
Identify Provision UpdatesInventory
Synch
Inter-device
Fixed -mobile
Wireless updates
Click streams
Prefer -ences
Rules
Affiliation
Profiles
Personalization
End-user devices/embedded browsers
Voice notification Voice portal
APSRAN C/N MW
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
12
C-HTML
• Sub-set of HTML, used by I-mode in Japan• Similarity to HTML allows easy conversion of
existing web site
XML • Uses style sheets to adapt data to different devices• Microsoft pushes XML over WAP
Web clipping
• A format for delivering web based information to Palm devices
• Used on the Palm Network in the US
• Used for fixed web pages• A text-based protocol describing how web pages
should be displayed by web browser
HTML
WAP • Adaptations of fixed Internet standards, e.g.,HTTP, SSL, HTML, to work better with mobile devices
• Supported by major telecom players• Compatible with GSM, CDMA and TDMA
Fromfixed Internet
Tomobile Internet
WAP IS ONLY ONE OF SEVERAL PROTOCOLS FOR MOBILE INTERNET APSRAN C/N MW
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
13
DON'T UNDERESTIMATE i-MODE PUSHING C-HTML
DoCoMo is planning to aggressively enter Europe with i-mode as an alternative to WAP
Direct investment
Indirect support
(Netherlands)
Hutchinson UK (UK)
Vivendi (SFR) or Bouygue, TelecomFrance
(Germany)
(Belgium)
Andala(Italy)
APSRAN C/N MW
Vendors need to adapt from being pure infrastructure suppliers and become total solution providers
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
14
OUR VISION OF MOBILE HANDSET WILL CHANGE
Today
• Limited data transfer• Limited memory• Not convenient for
input• Small screen
New standard allowing• Efficient data
transfer• Growing memory
capacity• M-commerce
capabilities through Internet access
• … and telephony
UMTS equipment will be included in many types of devices
Laptop‘Nokia inside’Cars, e.g., positioning
Mobile phones
PDA
• Low penetration• Different
standards
Mobile handsets will become personal devices
Video phones MP3 playerPDA with camera
Tomorrow
APSRAN C/N MW
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
15
VENDORS ARE FORCED TO ENTER OTHER AREAS IN THE VALUE CHAIN
• In the past, NTT DoCoMo and NEC had complementary and highly valuable business models
• Elsewhere a complex global value chain has emerged of which the DoCoMo model represents only a small part
DoCoMo-oriented value chain
Global m-commerce value chain
Termi-nal
Content and appli-cations
Gateway M/WInfra-struc-ture
O/S
System integration and maintenance
Mainte -nance
Opera-tions
Manufac-turing
R&D
R D
RF terminal+
What manufacturer must deliver
Network infrastructure
Total m-commerce solutions
Before
Now
2G
2.5G! 3G
APSRAN C/N MW
Vendors need to adapt from being pure infrastructure suppliers and become total solution providers
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
16
SOME VENDORS WILL TRY TO TIE-IN ALL COMPONENTComponents sold at or below operating cost
• In the more mature 2Gmarketplace, different vendors could often sell separate parts of the infrastructure profitably due to high levels of standardization
Service and maintenance
RANMiddleware and C/N Terminals
Service and maintenance
System integration
RAN Terminals
Applications
Gateway
Middleware
C/N
ImplicationStrategy of leading edge venders
Standardized unbundled solutions
Proprietary bundled solutions
• In the current 3Gmarketplace, vendors are Selling components below cost which are technically or logically tied into high value parts of the infrastructure
Before
Now
2G
2.5G! 3G
APSRAN C/N MW
Some vendors are providing components below cost which are tied into high value service-based parts of the network
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
17
HIGHEST REVENUE GROWTH WILL COME FROM MIDDLEWARE Mobile internet revenue growth by enabling technology
* Includes O/S sales** CAGR based on smallest to largest values within each range
Source: McKinsey
20032000
Estimated U.S. and European mobile data revenueUSD billions
4–6
11–20
<1
5–8
0
7–10
2
7–12
InfrastructureGateway and M/W
Application software
End user devices*
16–50%
46–64%
105–123% 37–57%
Products
Value-added
services
• This estimate shows a market growth in the U.S. and Europe of at least 34 bnUS$ by 2003
Security consulting
IT consulting and system integration
• Additional revenuecan be generated for players with local system integration and consulting resources
Key implications
CAGR**
Highest CAGRs
APSRAN C/N MW
The largest value to be captured lies in the middleware and application software. This can be supplemented and maximized through the provision of sales & maintenance and system integration
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
18
AGENDA
Migration from GSM to UMTS: What is UMTS, and what will steadily happen?
What will UMTS be used for?
UMTS Licenses: trick or treat?
How will it change the industry?
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
19
UMTS WILL INCREASE THE AVAILABLE CAPACITY, MAKING ROOM FOR MORE USERS AND MORE USAGE
Capacity availabilityMbps/cell
~12
2,3
0,7
0,7
0
100
200
300
400
0 50 100 150
Capacity/userKbps
Simultaneous users per base station
EDGE*
GPRS*GSM*
UMTS**
* Assuming 8 timeslots/TRX and 12TRX/BTS (high for GSM today, could be as high as 20TRX/BTS in the future), also assuming 14.4Kbpsper time slot for GPRS and 48Kbps for EDGE. EDGE is very sensit ive to the speed at which the user moves
** Assuming three directional cell with 3 times 4Mbps (12Mbps for one BTS)Source: GSM Association, ITU, Ericsson
GPRS
EDGE
UMTS
ESTIMATE
GSM
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
20
80 s
17 s
4.2 s
56 min
39 h
926 h
18 s
3.8 s
1 s
8.7 h
206 h
2.1 s
0.4 s
0.1 s
59 min
23 h
* Assumed size of email = 5 KB, web page = 20 KB, picture = 100 KB, MP3 song = 4 MB, MTV video = 170 MB, Movie = 4 GB; 8 bits per byte** Assumed 9.6kbps*** Assumed 43.2kbps, but GPRS will only support “best effort” speed in the beginning meaning that users will not be guaranteed a certain speed
**** Assumed 384kbps, standard for walking speed
Live casting speed requiredKbps
1,000
28
128
4,000
500
Audio
Video conferencing
Video (high resolution)
GPRS 43kbps
EDGE 144kbps
UMTS384kbps
28
UMTS WILL ENHANCE MOBILE DATA SERVICES THROUGH ITS ACCESS SPEED
Reduction due to lower quality acceptable on mobile device – e.g., smaller screen
Acceptable on mobile device
Downloading time*
MTV video
Movie
Audio song
Picture
Web page
GSM**
?
GPRS***
??
12.5 min
UMTS****
83 s
????
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
21
… FOUR KEY CHARACTERISTICS WILL MAKE MOBILE DEVICES AN ESSENTIAL PART OF DAILY LIFE (1/4)
Reachability
• Get e-mails immediately and wherever you are
• Monitor stock price movements and trade online
Microsoft 5$
Microsoft 5$
Microsoft 5$
Microsoft 5$
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
22
FOUR KEY CHARACTERISTICS WILL MAKE MOBILE DEVICES AN ESSENTIAL PART OF DAILY LIFE (2/4)
Reachability
• Buy while on the move
• Book return flight and rental car
• Compare prices when shopping
Mobility
Milan-StockholmSAS 1425 290200
13°° No delayLevis 501 at $30at wap.levis.com
Milan-StockholmSAS 1425 290200
13°° No delayLevis 501 at $30at wap .levis.com
Milan-StockholmSAS 1425 290200
13°° No delayLevis 501 at $30at wap .levis.com
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
23
FOUR KEY CHARACTERISTICS WILL MAKE MOBILE DEVICES AN ESSENTIAL PART OF DAILY LIFE (3/4)
Reachability
• Find your friends
• Locate closest gas station, shop or pharmacy
• Pay your car insurance per mile, time and location
Mobility
Positioning
Closest gas station 5 Km ahead
McDonald’s on route 95 has promotion
Closest gas station 5 Km ahead
McDonald’s on route 95 has promotion
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
24
FOUR KEY CHARACTERISTICS WILL MAKE MOBILE DEVICES AN ESSENTIAL PART OF DAILY LIFE (4/4)
Reachability
• Easily pay for Internet content
• Use as password or key card
• Replace cash or credit card
Mobility
Positioning
Identification
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
25
Choose 1
Source: DoCoMo
M Y M E N U
1.Weather2.Gourmet Navi.
3.News Express
4.Mobile Banking
Push Content Delivered
Choose 3 Choose 1 Choose 4
Choose 1 Choose 2 Choose 1
Beep!
Setting by User Operation
EXAMPLE OF I -MODE SERVICE: WEATHER FORECAST
WELCOME toWeather news1.Today's Forecast2.Weekly Forecast3.Rainfall Alarm
Warn you when rainfall probabilitygoes over your setting percentage.1.Choose AREA2.Your AREA
Area Choice1.Saitama2.Ibaragi3.Chiba4.Tokyo5.Kanagawa
Area Choice1.Downtown2.East Tama3.West Tama4.Izu Islands North5.Izu Islands South
Thank you for paying for RainfallAlarm
1.OK, Next2.Cancel
Trigger Settings1.1 02.9 %3.8 %4.7 %5.6 %
1998/4/7 12:00pmRainfall Alarm
Rainfall Probabilityin Tokyo
OVER 60 %
PAY INFOYou’ll be chargedfor getting this Info.1.Cancel2.$3.00 per month
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
26
MOBILE INTERNET IS HERE - AMAZON GOES WIRELESS!
Fixed
• Buy books through internet with amazon.Com
Mobile
• Act on a book or music tip immediately• Confirm the status of auction items• Order anything, anywhere, anytime!
EXAMPLE: US
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
27
AGENDA
Migration from GSM to UMTS: What is UMTS, and what will steadily happen?
What will UMTS be used for?
UMTS Licenses: trick or treat?
How will it change the industry?
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
28
NUMBER OF UMTS LICENSES IN SELECTED COUNTRIES
* Main terms already set** Plus over 200 local GSM operators
*** 2000 forecastsSource: ING Barings; Bear Steanus
Countries where licenses have been already issued
Country
FinlandFrance*UKSpain
Mobile penetration
70%40%50%48%
Number of GSM operators
3343
Number of licenses
4454
Awarded licenses formula
n + 1n + 1n + 1n + 1
BelgiumDenmarkGreecePortugal
32%52%50%48%
3433
4544
n + 1 n + 1 n + 1n + 1
SwedenSwitzerland TurkeySloveniaEgyptAustriaGermanyIrelandRussiaIsrael
57%43%18%35%***2%
52%43%37%11%60%
33322442
2**1
44433
5-66444
n + 1 n + 1 n + 1n + 1n + 1n + 1/ n + 2n + 2n + 2n + 2n + 3 (exception)
NetherlandsNorwayCzech Republic HungaryItaly
52%62%28%23%53%
53334
5333
4-5
n nnnn + 1
(national GSM licenses)
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
29
LICENSE PRICES (EXPECTED AND ACTUAL) IN VARIOUS COUNTRIES ARE MAJOR
* Forecasts for 2000** Governments' forecasts
*** Based on reserve price per license (min. budget revenue)Source: Press releases; analysts' reports; team analysis
Country
Total budget revenueUSD mln
Price per licenseUSDmln
Price per capitaUSD
Price per subscriberUSD
Price per USD of ARPUUSD mln
Spain
Italy
UK
France
Finland
Netherlands
Germany
Austria
450
10,000***
32,000
18,000
2
2,250
45,000
2,000**
3,300*
110
2,000
6,400
4,500
0.5
450
7,600
400
660-825
10
180
540
320
0.4
140
560
250
85
20
330
1,090
790
0.6
280
1,290
490
500Poland
GDP per capitaUSD
Price /GDPPercent
16,068
22,698
24,980
27,029
27,939
28,074
28,451
28,944
4,100
1
17
49
23
0.004
4
69
n/a
9
0.1%
0.8%
2.2%
1.1%
0.001%
0.5%
1.9%
0.9%
2.1%
German license cost was 4 times the cost of the Euro tunnel
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
30
AUCTIONS HAVE CAUSED MAJOR COST INCREASES FOR MOST OPERATORS
* Out of 72 operators, 13 (5 in U.K., 4 in Spain, 4 in Finland) have been selectedSource: McKinsey analysis
Number of operators bidding for 3G in EuropePercent
60
5
35
“Auction”
Undecided
“Beauty contest”
100% = 72*
500
22,000
Total license cost (U.K. example) GBP Millions
Originally expected
price
Final auctions
price
44 times higher
Typically used in scandinavian countries and Southern Europe; keeps value with the operators which allows investments to become a Pan-European player
Typically used in U.K., Germany, Belgium; gives value to the government and makes investments more difficult
Regulatory influence has caused licensing cost for UMTS to be much higher than originally expected
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
31
HIGH LICENSE PRICING CAUSED DECLINE IN SHARE PRICES OF DT, BT AND KPN
Source: Team analysis
BT KPN
UK
Netherlands
Germany
5.90
0.40
7.70
14
DT
5.90
0.35
7.80
14
–
0.50
5.80
6
Amounts spent by BT, DT and KPN on licenses in the UK, Netherlands and GermanyUSD billion
40.0
60.0
80.0
100.0
120.0
140.0
160.0
03
/01
/20
00
10
/01
/20
00
17
/01
/20
00
24
/01
/20
00
31
/01
/20
00
07
/02
/20
00
14
/02
/20
00
21
/02
/20
00
28
/02
/20
00
06
/03
/20
00
13
/03
/20
00
20
/03
/20
00
27
/03
/20
00
03
/04
/20
00
10
/04
/20
00
17
/04
/20
00
24
/04
/20
00
01
/05
/20
00
08
/05
/20
00
15
/05
/20
00
22
/05
/20
00
29
/05
/20
00
05
/06
/20
00
12
/06
/20
00
19
/06
/20
00
26
/06
/20
00
03
/07
/20
00
10
/07
/20
00
17
/07
/20
00
24
/07
/20
00
31
/07
/20
00
07
/08
/20
00
14
/08
/20
00
21
/08
/20
00
28
/08
/20
00
DTKPN
BT
British auction begins
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
32
* License already issuedSource: NEC, McKinsey analysis
LICENSING HAS FORCED COMMERCIALIZATION OF UMTS AS EARLY AS Q1, 2002
License issue
Most major countries will issue licenses by Q1, 2001 in western Europe, with Asia not far behind
Most of Western Europe and South Korea, Hong Kong will launch their
services around Q1, 2002
Commercial availability
There are 6 to 12 months because vendors tend to select before and after license issues
South KoreaHong KongTaiwanThailandSingaporeChina
03
Eu
rop
e A
sia
4321432143Q2
02012000
UKFranceGermanySpain*ItalyNetherlandsBelgium Finland*SwedenNorwaySwitzerland
?
Or
?
? ?
In addition, the early use of the spectrum (January 1, 2002) has become essential. Consequently, vendor selection in Europe has been brought forward to as early as Q2, 2000~ Q1, 2001. Asia’s expected vendor selection starts in earnest in Q1, 2001
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
33
HOWEVER, THERE REMAIN MANY UNCERTAINTIES OVER THE ROLL OUT OF UMTS
Issue Impact on 3G
• Availability and price• 3G - 2.5G - 2G / saving
• Hold back market development• Provide 3G coverage only
Terminals
• Timing• Degree of standardization
• Delay infrastructure deployment• Increase equipment cost
Standards
• Coverage requirement• Roaming requirement• Licensing process
• Increase network investment• Impact competitiveness• Delay deployment and increase cost
Licenses
• Deployment of 2.5G• Availability of 3G equipment • Delay in need and resources for 3G
deployment
Networks
• Readiness for mobile data• Willingness to pay• Competing access
technologies
• Delay market take up• Reduce expected margins
Customer demand
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
34
ALL THIS IN THE MIDDLE OF MANY MORE UNCERTAIN TECHNOLOGY CHOICES TO BE MADE BY OPERATORS
GatewaysServiceService
SwitchingSwitching
TransportTransport
PhysicalPhysical
Value-addedwholesale
Connectivity wholesale
Capacity wholesale
Infrastructure wholesale
Value-addedvoice / data
Leased lines
Not applicable
Backbone Edge Access
Radio
FTTC
PON
IP
MPLS
ATM
PSTN
VPN
IN
Caching
WDM
SDH
PDH
ADSL
LMDS
VDSL
UMTS
Offices
Fiber infrastructure
Local loop
Servers
CORBA
Frame relay
Connectivity retail / VPN
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
35
250 120-150
120–180
490-580
NEVERTHELESS, INCREMENTAL COSTS OF UMTS WILL REMAIN HIGH DRIVEN BY THE NEED FOR NEW SPECTRUM, NEW NETWORK AND NEW HANDSETS
Average cost per UMTS subscriber*USD / year
Handset(only if terminal
subsidy)
Network cost (Capex and
Opex)
Licence cost (assumed as 6–
9b for U.K., probably upper
limit)
Total cost
* Assuming network investment of 2 billion USD depreciated over 8 years, license cost 6-9 billion USD and depreciated over 10 years and average 5 million subscribers per operator. Also assuming a handset price of 500 USD with a 2 year lifetime.
Source: Ovum; Radio Spectrum International Consulting Ltd.; press search; Mckinsey analysis
ESTIMATE
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
36
AS A RESULT, UNDER CURRENT ASSUMPTIONS, HIGH LICENSE FEES COULD SIGNIFICANTLY INCREASE THE FINANCIAL RISKS
Source: RA 3G auction Web site; McKinsey analysis
Assumptions
• Licence fee: 7 billion USD
• Total capex over 10 years: 2.5 billion USD
• Average revenue/subscriber: 60 USD per month (currently ~40 USD)
• EBIT margin 30% at Year 10
• 90% of population within reach of service
PRELIMINARYESTIMATE
• Breakeven market penetration needed per licence 15-20%
• Marginal operators at risk under those assumptions
Need to consider other sources of value creation
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
37
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020
GERMAN UMTS MARKET: BREAK-EVEN "BACK OF THE ENVELOP"(ARPU= 49 EUR)
Years
Cumulated discounted cash-flow(b EUR)
30%
17%
10%
5%
Market share
Consolidation will be inevitable among mobile operators
EXAMPLE
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
38
AGENDA
Migration from GSM to UMTS: What is UMTS, and what will steadily happen?
What will UMTS be used for?
UMTS Licences: trick or treat?
How will it change the telecom industry?
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
39
Part of pan -European strategy
• Economies of scale • Drive to build scale in face of increasing
consolidation of operators
Important part of fixed-mobile substitution
strategy• Capacity needed to aggressively drive fixed
mobile substitution
Revenues from new sources and integration in
value chain
• Machine to machine• Fleet management (e.g., for trucks and taxis) • M-commerce
OTHER SOURCES OF VALUE CREATION NEED TO BE CONSIDERED BY THE BIDDERS
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
40
ACCELERATING CONSOLIDATION AND BECOMING PAN -EUROPEAN IS THEREFORE A NATURAL CONSEQUENCE
North America
Verizon Wireless (U.S.,45%,1999)
Voicestream(U.S.,100%,2000)
Rogers CantelMobile (Canada,33%,99)
* Still subject to regulatory approval** Subsidiary of SK Telecom*** Under discussion
Source: Team analysis
UK
One to One(100%,99)
Orange(100%,00)
Hutchison 3G UK (20%,00)
Hutchison 3G UK (59%,00)
Germany France
Mannesman (99%,99)
Viag (45%,99)Cegetel (SFR)(26%,96)
Cegetel (SFR)(20%,94)
Mobicom(29%,00)
DeutcheTelekom
E–Plus (23%,99)
Support KPN/E Plus
Support a new*** operator with Vivendi
Others
Asia – Pacific
Japan Others
Omnitel (76%,Italy)Airtel (55%,Spain,00*) Libertel (70%, Nether -lands, 95) etc.
J-Phone (25%,99)
Vodafone(91%,Australia,96)Vodatone NZ (10%,NZ,98)Shinsegi** (12%,S.Korea,94) etc.
Blutel (21%,Italy,94)Telfort(100%,Nether -land,96)Airtel(45%,Spain,00*)***
SmarTone(20%,HongKong,99)LGTelecome(24%,S.Korea,98)Maxis (33%,Malaysia,98) etc.
Maxmobile(100%,Austria,95)Radio Mobile (61%,Czech,99)PTC (45%,Poland,00)
Dutchtone (50%,Netherlands,98)Wind (25%,Italy,98)Mobistar (51%,Belgium, 95) etc. BPL Mobil
(26%,India)
SK Telecom (15~20%,S.Korea,00)***Hutchison (19%,Hong Kong,99) etc.
KPN (15%,Netherlands, 00)
DoCoMo
DMT(46%,Denmark)
Hutchinson
Investment (% share, year of deal)
Support (no direct investment)
J-Phone (20%,94)BT
Vodafone
Europe
France Telecom
Bell South
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
41
OTHER SOURCES OF VALUE CREATION NEED TO BE CONSIDERED BY THE BIDDERS
Part of pan -European strategy
• Economies of scale • Drive to build scale in face of increasing
consolidation of operators
Important part of fixed-mobile substitution
strategy• Capacity needed to aggressively drive
fixed mobile substitution
Revenues from new sources and integration in
value chain
• Machine to machine• Fleet management (e.g., for trucks and taxis) • M-commerce
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
42
FIXED – MOBILE SUBSTITUTION POTENTIAL IS VERY HIGH IN TERMS OF TRAFFIC VOLUME...
Average outgoing traffic per user 1998, (European cellular market) Minutes
70
100100
170
Mobile Fixed Mobile + Fixed
Source: Clippings, Financial reports
EXAMPLE
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
43
… AND IN TERMS OF VALUE
100
280
Value if migrating 50% of fixed traffic into mobile with current tariffs
Value with today’s traffic and tariffs
Source: Salomon Brothers, McKinsey analysis
Index (European cellular market)
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
44
TRANSITION MANAGEMENT IS CRITICAL TO MAXIMIZE THE VALUE CAPTURE
Source: Salomon Brothers, McKinsey analysis
Index (European cellular market)
100
75
180
Prices drop 70%(price level equal to current fixed price)
Current market capitalization: prices drop 55% comparedto today’s level
Value if migrating 50% of fixed traffic into mobile
Value with today’s traffic and tariffs
280 Maximum value potential
Transition management critical to value capture• Brand and non- price elements of
value proposition• Focus on “cutting the wire” in
selected segments, e.g., youthand power users
• Careful price management
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
45
Part of pan -European strategy
• Economies of scale • Drive to build scale in face of increasing
consolidation of operators
Important part of fixed-mobile substitution
strategy• Capacity needed to aggressively drive fixed
mobile substitution
Revenues from new sources and integration in
value chain
• Machine to machine• Fleet management (e.g., for trucks and taxis) • Mobile Portals
OTHER SOURCES OF VALUE CREATION NEED TO BE CONSIDERED BY THE BIDDERS
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
46
ROLES IN THE MOBILE INTERNET SERVICES INDUSTRY
Creation Delivery
Content service provider Portal Transaction
platform
ISP/content adapter
Transport and access
End user
SIMPLIFIED
Role Provides• Standard
information services (news, weather, etc.)
• Interactive applications (messaging, entertainment, e.g., games etc.)
• Commercials and push information
Facilitates navigation• Search engine• Personali-
zation
• Makes it possible to bill customers for purchases
• Provides connection from mobile network to Internet
• Adapts fixed Internet content to mobile
• Provides the mobile network
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
47
PLAYERS ARE FIGHTING TO CAPTURE NEW SOURCE OF REVENUE IN THE VALUE CHAIN
Media players
Internet portals
Content service provider Portal Transaction
platformISP/content adapter
Transport and access
Banks
Online retailers
Start-ups
Telecom operators
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
48
THE BATTLE FOR CUSTOMER OWNERSHIP WILL INVOLVE THE FOLLOWING PLAYERS
Internet portalsTelecom operators
Media players Start-ups Online retailers and banks
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
49
TELECOM OPERATORS WANT TO BE PORTALS
Starting position Examples of moves
Strengths
Weaknesses
• Established customer base
• Billing relationship• Customer knowledge• Control SIM card
settings• Location information
• Weak content skills• Limited in-house content• Slow organization• Difficult to use stock as
acquisition currency• Limited experience with
alliances
• ZED closed mobile portal and wireless payment applications
• MyDof open portal (No 1 mobile portal of Sweden)
• DJuice open WAP portal • Purchase cinema tickets with
regular phones
• ItiAchat is a payment system where the GSM is used as payment terminal
• Offers travel services, shopping, traffic information etc.
• Genie - Offers the latest news headlines, information on sport, updates on finance , reviews on films, plays and restaurants etc.
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
50
INTERNET PORTALS WANT TO ENSURE ACCESS TO THE CUSTOMER
Starting position Example of moves
Strengths
Weaknesses
• Large content base• Established advertiser
base• Strong brands• Stock can be used for
acquisition• Large experience with
alliances• Fast-moving
organizations
• No billing relationship with customers
• Banner advertising may not work on small screen
• No location information
• Alliances to secure access to consumers in the mobile world– Device manufacturers, e.g.,
• Siemens• Motorola• Palm• Hewlett-Packard
– Operators, e.g.,• Telenor (Norway)• Sprint (US)• BellMobility (Canada)• D2 Mannesman (Germany)• Radiolinja (Finland)• Telecom Italia Mobile (Italy)• New World Mobility (Hong-Kong)
• Partnerships with Ericsson and Nokia to make a WAP portal
• Recently acquired Cellphone Warehouse (GEAB)
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
51
CONTENT PROVIDERS WANT TO BECOME PORTALS
Starting position Examples of moves
• The Schibsted WAP portal with the latest news headlines, information on sport etc.
• CNN offers all kinds of news
• Financial Times offers financial news
• Strong brands• Large content base and
content relationships
• Slow, conservative organizations
• Difficult to use stock as acquisition currency
Strengths
Weaknesses
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
52
START-UPS TRY TO ESTABLISH THEMSELVES AS CONTENT PROVIDERS OR PORTALS
Starting position Examples of moves
Strengths
Weaknesses
• No existing business models to cannibalize
• Specifically developed for mobile
• Lack of professional management talent
• Usually technology focused with limited content expertise
• Cash poor
• Room 33 – offers news, city guides, weather forecasts etc.
• Breathe (UK) – offers information about sport, lifestyle, journey, commerce and news
• iobox - offers ring tones and logos for Nokia phones
• 12snap - offers wireless online auctions through cell broadcast and SMS in Germany in cooperation with D2 and Nokia
• iwirelessgames.com - develops games for the mobile Internet
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
53
ONLINE RETAILERS AND BANKS WANT TO ENSURE ACCESS TO THE CUSTOMER
Starting position Examples of moves
Strengths
Weaknesses
• Customer base• Strong relationship with
customers (especially banks)
• Financial resources
• Incumbents have slow organizations and face cannibalization issues
• Limited technology experience
• Limited in-house content
• Solo - electronic banking system
• Offers the possibility to buy books using an Internet-ready phone
• Customers can trade on eBay using Sprint Internet-ready mobile phones
• Barclays Bank – mobile banking on the Cellnet’s network since 1997. Special handset used. 150,000 loyal customers
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
54
THE BATTLE HAS STARTED
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
55
LIKELY WINNERS
Likely winner(s)
Rationale
Content service provider
Portal Transaction platform
ISP/content adapter
Transport and access
• Media players + startups
• Media players can relatively easy convert standard information from fixed Internet content
• However, truly innovative interactive applications are likely to come from startups
• Mobile operators control the SIM settings
• Internet portals are more nimble, have brands and can harmonize fixed and mobile interfaces
• With their current network infrastructures, mobile operators completely dominate transport and access
• Mobile operators + Internet portals
• Mobile operators
• Mobile operators
• Closely related to mobile network
• Mobile operators + banks
• Mobile operators can bill subscribers on behalf of third parties
• Banks have established relationships with transaction parties and are more secure
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
56
BUSINESS PORTFOLIO OF AN INTEGRATED TELCO
High
Low
Low High
Growth
EBITDA Contribution
• Integrated telcos have a very balanced portfolio of businesses…
• The driver of the business is wireless telephony
• …but the big challenge is how to reinvent the traditional business of wireline telephony
Internet Wireless Telephony
Wireline Telephony
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
57
DEBT LEVELS OF LEADING TELCOS HAVE INCREASED DRAMATICALLY…
4
70
13
33
60
2
50
22
24
2
18
64
AT&T
End 1998
End 2000*
France Telecom
Deutsche Telekom
BT
WorldCom
Vodafone
* ForecastSource: The Economist
US $ billions
• Costly expansion strategies will be difficult to finance
• Operators will have to reduce level of debt by all means
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
58
S&P rating 01/2000
S&P rating 01/2001
Downgraded by
France Telecom AA A 3 notches British Telecom AA+ A 4 notches Sonera A+ A 1 notch Deutsche Telekom AA- A- 3 notches Vodafone A A - AT&T AA- A 2 notches KPN AA BBB+ 5 notches Wolrdcom A- A- - SBC AA AA- 1 notch Telefonica A+ A+ -
… AND ON TOP OF THAT LEADING TELCOS HAVE SEEN THEIR RATING DOWNGRADED
Rating downgrades reduces access to the bond market and pushes up borrowing costs (approximately 20 basis points increase for a downgrade by 1 notch). For these companies, this means additional interest charges of USD 1.8bn per annum.
Rating downgrades reduces access to the bond market and pushes up borrowing costs (approximately 20 basis points increase for a downgrade by 1 notch). For these companies, this means additional interest charges of USD 1.8bn per annum.
* FootnoteSource:Sources
Note: borrowing cost difference between AA and A is about 60-70 bp. Net debt is estimated to be 50% above December 99 level ie about USD 300bn.Source: McKinsey analysis .
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
59
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70Sales (1999)
Billions of USD
Source:Datastream/Bloomberg
Exodus
Vodafone
Level 3
Qwest
Global CrossingSonera
Equant
PT
T.Dan
KPNTelefónica TI
BT
FT
Verizon
DT
Worldcom SBC AT&T
Focused operators
Bellsouth
“Small” integrated operators “Large” integrated operators
Market value January 2000/Sales 1999
CHANGES IN THE STRATEGIC CONTROL MAPSituation as of January 1st, 2000
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
60
* Sales as of 31/3/2000Source:Datastream/Bloomberg/Media General Financial Services
0
15
30
45
60
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18
Larger players have held their positions, consolidating their growth expectations
Qwest
SalesBillions of USD
January 1st, 2000
September 30 th, 2000
Major corrections for smaller players due to doubts on their potential for growth and/or income
Exodus
Level 3
Global CrossingSonera
Vodafone*
Value/Sales
CHANGES IN THE STRATEGIC CONTROL MAPFocused operators: two groups emerging?
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
61
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
STRATEGIC CONTROL MAPSmall integrated players
“Wait and see”
Efforts to gain focus unsuccessful (?) and penalized
Value/Sales
Source: Bloomberg
Portugal Telecom
Swisscom KPN
January 1st, 2000
September 30th, 2000
Tele Denmark
SalesBillions of USD
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
62
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
0 10 20 30 4 0 50 60 70
Telefónica
* Sales as of 30/6/2000Source:Datastream/Bloomberg/Operator reports
FT*
TI
AT&T
BT
DT
Integrated operators“meeting expectations”
Integrated operators “under scrutiny”
Worldcom
Value/Sales
SalesBillions of USD
SBCVerizon
STRATEGIC CONTROL MAPLarge integrated players
January 1st, 2000
September 30 th, 2000
BRU_ZXR395_20000929_KGB
63
END