Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
Building and Managing IP Portfolio
SuryaRaghuAdvancedFluidicsLLC&ETCubeInternational
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLankaSept.17-21,2018
©S.RaghuWIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018
OUTLINE
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 2
CreatingExploitableIPPatentScapeandTechScapeManagingRisksDiscussionandConclusion
YearlyPatentsforLargeIndustry
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 3
https://medium.com/@IBMResearch/why-we-patent-66ce5a986331
CreatingExploitableIP
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 4
IndustryPatentstrategies:OffensiveandDefensiveOffensive Defensive
Blockcompetitorsfromgainingentryintoyourtechnologyandbusinesssector
Onlydefendyourbusinessarea
Filepatentsforallreasonableinventionsinthatfieldoftechnology
Fileforpatentsonlynecessaryforyourbusiness
Createaggregatedpatentportfolioforlicensingorsale
Notinterestedinsellingpatents
Patenttrolls??
UniversityStrategy
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 5
ExploitableIP• Wecannotaffordindustry-styleoffensiveor
defensivestrategies
• ChangingIPtrends:Itisnotonlypatentsbutalsocopyrights(software+others),designs,innovations,Apps,Clinicaltesting,EducationalmethodsandTrainingtools.
UniversityStrategy
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 6
Inventions:Developastrategyformarketinghighestvalue-addedIPInventionshouldhave(near-term)application(insight)HigherTRLforastrongpatentMarketsizePotentiallicensingpath–contactsandrelationshipswiththerightindustry
CreatingaIPPortfolio
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 7
CreatingaportfolioofrelatedpatentsandotherIPwillprovideabetterpackageformarketingExample:Chemicalcompound+methodofextraction+optimizedprocessingtechnology+processcontrolmethods+possiblereactions+catalysts+applications+softwarealgorithms(?)+designsMayneedlotofinterdisciplinarywork
Technology-needmapping
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 8
ElectricityAccessRenewableEnergy
TransportationAgriculture,Horticulture,Foodprocessing,Dairy
Healthcare
OverlaythiswiththeUniversityIPMap
PatentsSoftwareDesigns
OtherIP
Note:PossiblecommonIPtodifferentsectors!
PatentPortfolioMapping
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 9
PatentportfoliomapofFranhaufferInstitute(https://heronscientific.com)
Morecontinuousspectrum?
ManagingIPCosts
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 10
Cannotpatentallinventionsreceived–onlydemand-based?Pre-patentmarketingofinventions-technologybriefs(Shouldyoupublishrestoftheinventionssothatotherscannotpatent?–thismayhelpincreasetheUniversityreputationanddrawattentionfromIndustryinthefuture)
Protectbycopyrights(andotherformsofIP??)–somechallengesofcopyrighting??
Managingthe“un-groupables”
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 11
ElectricityAccessRenewableEnergy
TransportationAgriculture,Horticulture,Foodprocessing,Dairy
Healthcare
PatentsSoftwareDesigns
OtherIP
Maybeahigh-valueIP?Shouldwegetasecondopinion?
MovinguptheTechnologyLevel
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 12
Investseedfundingtoadvancethetechnologytoastagewhereitcanbemarketed–industry“needssolutions,nottechnologies”Encouragestart-upsfromUniversity–theycanactastechnologydevelopersfromexternalfundingandbeboughtoutbylargecompaniesdowntheroad.
IPDonations
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 13
SolicitandmanageIPdonationsCompaniesgettaxbenefitsbypatentdonationCompaniesdonatepatentsordofree-licensing(Patentmaintenancefeesmayalsobedonated)
IPDonationbyCompanies
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 14
Company Whatwasdonated Receivedby Year
Dupont 257Patents DEDO 2007
Dupont Patentsforanewpapermakingtechnology
UniversityofMaine 2001
Dupont $64Millionworthofpatents
PennStateU.ofIowaVPI
1999
Boeing PatentsforMedicalapplications
U.Penn 2001
ProctorandGamble 196patents Vanderbilt 2000
Shell >$83.5Million U.Texas
DonationbyFree-Licensing
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 15
Company Whatwaslicensed Receivedby
Syngenta technologytoproducevitaminAenrichedrice
GoldenRicePatentPool
BoehringerIngelheim
Grantedfree-licensesofpatentscoveringaHIVdrugforaperiodof5yearstoAspenPharmacare
Aspen(SACompany)
Novartis,Roche Donotfileorenforcepatentsinleastdevelopedcountries
WatchyourownIPuse
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 16
UniversitiesshouldalsobeawareofIPuseandinfringement
Getpermissionwheneveritisnecessary–thisestablishestrustandgoodreputationandmaypreventpunitivedamages!
ManagingRisks
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 17
WhataretherisksinvolvedinIPmanagement?PrematuredisclosuresLicensingtothewrongcompanyUnder-valuationoftechnologyNon-profitableand/orunworkabledealsExclusivelicensedealswithnoreturns-shouldtheTTOstilllicensesuchIP??
Summary
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 18
SomeactionitemsforTTOtobuildandmanageIPportfolio“TechnologyMapping”GreaterRisktaking–getUniversityapprovalforthis–howdoyousharetheriskwiththecompany??Developseed-fundsforfurtherdevelopmentoftechnology–helpsbroaderclaimsinpatentsEncourageUniversityStart-upsSolicitandmanageIPdonations
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018
©S.Raghu 19
ThankYou!
Creatinga“PatentScape”(Innography.com)
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 20
https://www.innography.com/
“PatentScapes”or“TechScapes”forHealth/AgriculturalSciences?
WIPOEIEWorkshopIIColombo,SriLanka,Sept.17-21,2018 ©S.Raghu 21
Area2
Area1Area3
Area7
Area6
Area4
Area8Area5
Companies
Area2Area5Area8
Start-upSpaces?