26
By Bradley Coyne, Kushal Chukkapalli (KC), Hari Vijayan. November 6, 2014

By Bradley Coyne, Kushal Chukkapalli (KC), Hari Vijayan. November 6, 2014

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

By Bradley Coyne, Kushal Chukkapalli (KC), Hari Vijayan.

November 6, 2014

Agenda

Introduction

Business

Recent Financial Performance

Macroeconomic Review

Management Philosophy

Financial Analysis

Financial Valuation

Recommendation

Introduction

Leading global innovator, manufacturer and marketer of tools and equipment, diagnostics and repair, and system solutions for professional users performing critical tasks.

Head-quarters in Kenosha, WI. Employee strength of 11300 people.

Products and services include hand and power tools, tool storage, diagnostic software, information and management systems, shop equipment, vehicle repair solutions and services in various Industrial segments.

Presence in more than 130 countries with 64% of sales in US.

Has never skipped a dividend since 1939.

Holdings : We hold 100 shares purchased at $85.20 on April 2013.

Currently valued at $134.35 per share with a market value of $13,435 as of yesterday.

Source: 2013 10-K Page 4

Basic Business Segments of the company

Snap-on Tools Group

Repair Systems & Information Financial Services

Commercial & Industrial

Source: 2013 10-K Page 27

Basic Business Segments Snap-on Tools Group supports professional automotive

service technicians with innovative products and financing solutions.

The Repair Systems & Information Group provides professional vehicle repair customers with a wide range of diagnostics, undercar equipment and repair information and systems solutions through both direct and distributor channels.

Financial Services consists of the business operations of Snap-on Credit, Snap-on's wholly owned finance subsidiary in the U.S. They provide financing option to franchisees, direct and indirect customers.

The Commercial & Industrial Group serves professionals in critical industries and emerging markets with a broad range of productivity solutions delivered through both direct and distributor channels. 

Industries served include aviation and aerospace, agriculture, construction, military and government, mining, natural resources, and power generation.

Source: 2013 10-K Page 27

Business

Distribution channels: mobile van, company direct sales, distributors, e-commerce.

Major products and services: Snap-on, ATI, BAHCO line of tools, Blackhawk collision repair equipment, CDI torque tools, etc.

Depends heavily on steel as the raw material.

Owns 7.2 million sq.ft of facilities, 74 % of which is owned.

Owns about 700 patents in U.S and 1500 patents internationally.

Main competitors : Genuine Parts Company, Stanley Black and Decker, W.W. Grainger, Inc., Emerson Electric Co., etc.

Source: 2013 10-K Page 6,7,8,10

Recent Financial Performance

Revenues of $3056.3 million in 2013.

Net earnings of $359.3 million in 2013.

Last quarter revenues: $806.3 million, a 9% increase from 2013.

Last quarter earnings: 106.7 million, a 22% increase from 2013.

58,115,776 shares of common stock are outstanding.

Potential headwinds could result from the European economy and fluctuating US military spending

Growth drivers include enhancing the franchise network, expanding repair shop owners and managers, extending to critical industries and building in emerging markets

Source: CEO Nick Pinchuk’s statement in 2014 Q3 “Comments call”

Source : Bloomberg : SNA US Equity

Operating Earnings

37%

28%

30%

5%Snap-on ToolsRepair Systems & InformationCommercial & IndustrialFinancial Services

20%

28%34%

18%

Contribution of business segments

Net Sales

Source: 2013 10-K Page 26

Product and geographical diversity

57%21%

22%

Tools Diagnostic & RepairEquipment

64%

20%

16%

USA Europe All others

Geographical PresenceProduct Diversity

Source: 2013 10-K Page 5

Macroeconomic review

The company has secured an ample supply of both bar and coil steel (its principle raw materials) from its suppliers, for the near future to meet with material demands.

Steel pricing and availability issues are not going to create any significant impact in 2014.

The company holds over 700 patents in US and 1500 patents internationally.

No single patent represents a significant portion of the company’s revenue.

The company does not foresee any environmental protection laws affecting it in the near future

Energy and fuel prices can significantly affect the company’s revenue generation. Higher fuel prices might slow down growth.

36% of revenues come internationally. Revenue generation can be significantly affected by the economic conditions in non-US markets.Source: 2013 10-K Page 10,11, wikiwealth.com/sna

Porter’s 5 forces

Power of Suppliers : LowDoes not depend on any significant

customerRaw materials are elastic in demand

Substitutes : MediumMany products are highly specialisedDiagnostic and Repair is Vulnerable

Barriers to entry : MediumPatent Protection

Medium to High cost of entryGlobal market can pose threat

Competition : MediumFew strong competitors do exist

No competitor that scales all operations or products

Power of Buyers : MediumNumerous options are available

Inelastic nature of demand

SWOT analysis

StrengthsTechnological Prowess – R&D investments

Customer LoyaltyCost Advantages in many niche productsFinancing segment helps in maintaining

franchisees

WeaknessesBad acquisitions in past

Operations are diversified but not scalingSeasonal sales fluctuations

Inefficient foreign currency management

OpportunitiesEmerging markets and Geographical

DiversificationInvest more in R&D to maintain advantage

ThreatsInternational competition is intensifying

Product costs are reducing globallyUncertainty about the U.S military spending

Changes in economic policiesWeak European economy

Management Philosophy

CEO -Nicholas T. Pinchuk 

No new changes in management in the past 3 years

Implementing a value-creation process throughout the company focusing on safety, quality, customer connection, innovation and rapid continuous improvement

Executive compensation is competitive to the industry peers, with a higher percentage of pay-at-risk compensation.

Looking forward to developing and expanding customer base in adjacent markets and additional geographies.

Trying to enter new and riskier industries in future.

Source: 2014 Proxy statement Page 20,26, 2013 10-K Page 26

Expectations ForwardThe Commercial & Industrial Group

Invest in emerging market growth initiatives.

Reduce structural and operating costs through RCI and restructuring.

Tools

Improve franchisee productivity, profitability, and commercial health.

Expand market coverage and penetration;

Invest in new product innovation and Increase operational flexibility.

The Repair Systems & Information Group

Upgrade technology, expand product range, integrate solutions and increase market penetration

Financial Services

Deliver products and services that attract and sustain profitable franchisees, improve productivity levels, and maintain a healthy portfolio performance.Source: 2013 10-K Page 26,27

Financial Analysis- RatiosLiquidity Ratios

  2009 2010 2011 2012 2013Current Ratio 2.27  2.00  2.62  2.83  2.51 Quick Ratio 1.89  1.63  1.96  2.15  1.90 

Leverage Ratios  2009 2010 2011 2012 2013Debt/Assets 30.95% 31.39% 26.79% 25.00% 23.65%Interest Coverage 5.26  6.05  7.76  9.25  10.45 Debt/EBITDA 3.28  2.90  1.79  1.64  1.47 Debt/Capitalization 0.45  0.45  0.39  0.35  0.31 

Turnover Ratios  2009 2010 2011 2012 2013A/R Turnover 5.39  6.11  6.30  6.11  5.94 Days Sales Outstanding 67.72  59.76  57.98  59.72  61.47 Inventory Turnover 4.12  4.66  4.24  3.92  3.78 Inventory Days  88.66  78.30  86.15  93.21  96.64 A/P Turnover 10.62  10.59  11.20  11.59  10.62 Days Payable Outstanding 34.38  34.46  32.58  31.49  34.35 Cash Conversion Cycle 121.99  103.60  111.55  121.44  123.76 Fixed Asset Turnover 6.96  7.80  8.44  8.26  8.25 Total Asset Turnover 0.70  0.72  0.81  0.79  0.79 

Financial Analysis- Ratios

2009 2010 2011 2012 20130

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.3

Greenblatt’s Ratios

EBIT/Tangible Assets EBIT/EV

Profitability Ratios  2009 2010 2011 2012 2013Operating Profit Margin 10.36% 12.36% 15.95% 16.66% 18.11%Net Margin 5.80% 7.05% 8.80% 10.08% 11.22%ROA 4.17% 5.18% 7.73% 8.06% 8.75%ROE (Book Value) 11.01% 13.74% 18.34% 17.30% 16.88%

Greenblatt Numbers  2009 2010 2011 2012 2013EBIT/Tangible Assets 16.99% 17.82% 21.49% 21.66% 23.10%EBIT/EV 2.83% 3.69% 5.40% 5.88% 6.68%

DuPont Analysis

2009 2010 2011 2012 2013Tax Burden  70.37% 70.39% 69.51% 68.75% 68.38%Interest Burden 81.45% 82.74% 85.94% 88.61% 89.73%Operating Profit Margin 10.36% 12.36% 15.95% 16.66% 18.11%Asset Turnover 0.70 0.72 0.81 0.79 0.79Leverage 2.64 2.66 2.37 2.15 1.93ROE 11.01% 13.74% 18.34% 17.30% 16.88%

DuPont Analysis

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 20140.00%

10.00%

20.00%

30.00%

40.00%

50.00%

60.00%

70.00%

80.00%

90.00%

100.00%

0.00   

0.50   

1.00   

1.50   

2.00   

2.50   

3.00   

Tax BurdenInterest BurdenOperating Profit MarginROEAsset TurnoverLeverage

Source : Bloomberg : SNA US Equity

Recent Stock Performance

2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 20140

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

-20.00%

-10.00%

0.00%

10.00%

20.00%

30.00%

40.00%

50.00%

60.00%

70.00%

Close Price as of Beginning of Year

Close Price as of End of Year or Current Date

Yearly Dividend Paid

Return

Source : http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=SNA+Interactive#

Yearly Stock Returns  2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014Close Price as of Beginning of Year 30.18 42.86 57.97 51.24 80.86 108.55Close Price as of End of Year or Current Date 42.26 56.58 50.62 78.99 109.52 134.35Yearly Dividend Paid or Dividend Paid Year to Date 1.2 1.22 1.3 1.4 1.58 1.32Return 44.00% 34.86% -10.44% 56.89% 37.40% 24.98%

Valuation - WACC

Equity Risk Premium Source: Aswath Damodaran, Stern School of Business, NYU

Discount Factor Calculation

Capital Structure   Shares Outstanding  58.107602 Current Stock Price  134.35 Total Market Value of Equity  7,807  Total Debt  972  Total Capitalization 8,779     Debt-to-Total Capitalization  11.07% Equity-to-Total Capitalization  88.93%

 Beta  1.00 Risk-Free Rate  2.31% Stock Market Return  7.34% Market Risk Premium  5.03% E[R] (CAPM) 7.34% ROE Averaged over past 5 years 32.54%

 Cost of Debt  5.85%   Weight put on E[R] Calculation 90% Tax Rate  32%   Weight put on Return Calculation 10% After-tax Cost of Debt 3.98% Cost of Equity 9.86%

  WACC 9.21% Risk Premium 1.00% Discount Rate 10.21%

Discounted Cash Flow

($ in millions) 2014E 2015E 2016E 2017E 2018E EBIT             687             801             930          1,085          1,276  Less: Income Taxes @ 32%            (198)           (233)           (273)           (321)           (380) EBIAT             489             567             657             764             896  Add: Depreciation                61                65                70                75                80  Less: Capital Expenditures              (78)             (84)             (90)             (96)           (103) Less: Increase In NWC            (135)           (140)           (154)           (166)           (181)      Unlevered Free Cash Flow 336 409 483 577 692  Terminal Growth Rate  3.50% Terminal Value 10,673  Discount Rate    10.21%       PV of Free Cash Flow             305             337             361             391          6,990 

Implied Enterprise Value 8,384

 Enterprise Value              8,384  Less: Debt             972  Add: Cash                 218  Implied Equity Value          7,630     Shares Outstanding        58.108 

 Current Stock Price        $134.35   

Total Fair Value Stock Price       $131.30

Enterprise Value Price NTM Enterprise Value

Company Name EBITDA EBIT EPS Tangible BV Forward Total Revenue

Forward EBITDA

NTM Forward P/E

     Snap-on Incorporated (NYSE:SNA) 11.7x 12.9x 19.5x 6.2x 2.5x 10.7x 17.6x         Blount International Inc. (NYSE:BLT) 8.9x 13.9x 43.6x 4.0x 1.2x 7.8x 15.8xARI Network Services Inc. (NasdaqCM:ARIS)

28.7x 125.9x NM NM 1.3x 8.1x 32.8xDover Corporation (NYSE:DOV) 7.9x 10.3x 14.3x NM 1.8x 8.3x 15.4xDanaher Corp. (NYSE:DHR) 12.7x 16.1x 21.0x 36.3x 2.7x 11.9x 20.4xEmerson Electric Co. (NYSE:EMR) 9.9x 11.9x 18.0x 39.5x 1.9x 9.1x 16.1xSPX Corporation (NYSE:SPW) 9.7x 12.6x 8.1x NM 1.0x 9.1x 15.1xGenuine Parts Company (NYSE:GPC) 12.9x 14.7x 21.7x 7.3x 1.0x 11.6x 20.0xW.W. Grainger, Inc. (NYSE:GWW) 11.1x 12.5x 21.7x 6.0x 1.6x 10.0x 18.8xPentair plc (NYSE:PNR) 10.0x 12.0x 19.7x NM 2.1x 11.4x 15.6xStanley Black & Decker, Inc. (NYSE:SWK) 11.0x 15.1x  21.5x NM  1.6x 10.6x  15.6x

High 28.7x 125.9x  43.6x 39.5x  2.7x 11.9x  32.8xLow 7.9x 10.3x 8.1x 4.0x 1.0x 7.8x 15.1xMean 12.3x 24.5x 21.1x 18.6x 1.6x 9.8x 18.6xMedian 10.5x 13.3x  21.0x 7.3x  1.6x 9.6x  16.0x

 LTM

EBITDA LTM EBIT

LTM Diluted

EPS

LTM Tangible

BV/Share NTM Revenue / ShareNTM

EBITDA NTM EPS Snap-On Inc. (NYSE: SNA)      647.27      586.20            6.10            36.66  $56.28      748.15  7.30

 Implied Price_Mean   $  136.79  $  247.16   $  128.41  $     682.67  $                               90.78   $  126.23   $      135.36 

 Implied Price_Median   $  116.96  $  133.67    $  128.00  $     267.64   $                               90.62   $  123.28    $      116.45 

Implied SNA Stock Price  $  139.52 

STRENGTHS

Strong recent financial performance due restructuring

Stable supply of short-term raw materialsContinuous quarterly dividend for past 74 years

Promising growth prospectsDiverse and loyal customer base

CONCERNS

Changes in economic policiesUncertainty in U.S military spending

Declining European economy

Recommendation :

HOLD

Stock Price as of 11/5/14 : $134.35Stock Price according to DCF : $131.30Stock Price according to Comparable Analysis: $139.52

Q&A