1
U(D54G1D)y+&!?!.!#!_ Voters appear ready to give populism a push and elect the conservative Sebas- tian Kurz as chancellor. PAGE A4 INTERNATIONAL A4-8 Austria Poised to Shift Right Harvey Weinstein’s company fired him after accusations of harassment and abuse. Now the Oscar winner may be kicked out of an exclusive club. PAGE A14 Academy to Meet on Weinstein Bret Stephens PAGE A19 EDITORIAL, OP-ED A18-19 Revising a changing account, the Las Vegas police said the killer shot a secu- rity guard and fired on a crowd around the same time. PAGE A13 NATIONAL A9-15 Killing Timeline Shifts Again WASHINGTON — President Trump announced on Friday his decision to disavow the Iran nu- clear agreement, threatening to leave the deal altogether if it was not amended to permanently block Tehran from building nucle- ar weapons or intercontinental missiles. But even as he delivered a fire- breathing indictment of the Irani- an government’s activities around the Middle East, he stopped short of unraveling the agreement reached by President Barack Obama two years ago. “We will not continue down a path whose predictable conclu- sion is more violence, more chaos, the very real threat of Iran’s nucle- ar breakout,” Mr. Trump declared at the White House in a speech that was intended to define a broad strategy for confronting Iran. Mr. Trump’s decision not to cer- tify that Iran was complying with all terms of the agreement came after a fierce debate inside the ad- ministration, according to a senior official familiar with the discus- sions and who agreed to describe them on the condition of ano- nymity. Secretary of State Rex W. Tiller- son and Defense Secretary Jim Mattis argued that it was in the na- tional security interests of the United States to keep the deal’s constraints on Iran. The two men succeeded, over time, in persuad- ing Mr. Trump not to immediately scrap the accord, despite his cam- paign promise to do so. Mr. Trump, in declaring his in- TRUMP DISAVOWS ACCORD WITH IRAN ON NUCLEAR ARMS ASKS CONGRESS TO ACT Issues New Threat to Exit While Stopping Short of Undoing Pact By MARK LANDLER and DAVID E. SANGER Continued on Page A7 WASHINGTON — President Trump’s decision to cut off critical payments to health insurance companies ratcheted up the pres- sure on Congress on Friday to take action to protect consumers from soaring premiums, while also adding a combustible new is- sue to negotiations to avert a gov- ernment shutdown this year. Mr. Trump’s move, announced Thursday night, could cause cha- os in insurance markets, sending insurers fleeing from the Afford- able Care Act’s marketplaces, raising the federal government’s costs and pricing out some con- sumers. It came just hours after he signed an executive order that also undermined the health law by encouraging the development of lower-cost insurance policies not subject to the Affordable Care Act’s rigorous coverage stand- ards. But the president suggested on Friday that he was trying to get Democrats to the negotiating ta- ble. “If the Democrats were smart, what they’d do is come and negoti- ate something where people could really get the kind of health care that they deserve,” Mr. Trump told reporters, insisting that the subsi- dies were “making insurance companies rich.” The subsidies, known as cost- sharing reduction payments, go to insurance companies to offset the cost of reducing out-of-pocket ex- penses like deductibles and co- payments for low-income customers. Under the Affordable Care Act, insurers will still have to help those customers, but without the help of Washington, they say, they will increase premiums. And with their profits squeezed, they could abandon the marketplaces. Even before Mr. Trump’s deci- sion, Senators Lamar Alexander, End of Subsidy Puts Congress In a Tight Spot Fear of Chaos as Trump Cuts Into Health Act By THOMAS KAPLAN and ROBERT PEAR Continued on Page A10 Francis Blake has not held a permanent position in a New York City public school in at least five years. At his last job, in a Bronx el- ementary school, records show he was disciplined for incompetence, insubordination and neglect of du- ties — he had been caught sleep- ing in a classroom when he was supposed to be helping with dis- missal. Felicia Alterescu, a special-edu- cation teacher, has been without a permanent post since 2010, de- spite high demand for special edu- cation teachers. According to records, in addition to getting a string of unsatisfactory ratings, she was disciplined for calling in sick when she actually went to a family reunion. She also did not tell the Education Department that she had been arrested on har- assment charges. This month, Mr. Blake, Ms. Al- terescu and hundreds of other teachers who are part of a pool known as the Absent Teacher Re- serve could be permanently back in classrooms, as the city’s Educa- tion Department places them in jobs at city schools. The reserve is essentially a parking lot for staff members who have lost their positions, some be- cause of school closings and budg- et cuts, others because of disci- plinary problems, but cannot be fired. It grew significantly as a re- sult of a 2005 deal between the Bloomberg administration, which wanted to give principals control over hiring, and the teachers’ un- Caught Sleeping or Worse, Idled Teachers Head Back to Class By KATE TAYLOR Continued on Page A17 BRYAN ANSELM FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES Despite grappling with dwindling open land and criticism from animal-rights groups, Golden’s Bridge Hounds, founded in 1924, still holds fox hunts in Westchester County. Page A16. Riding to Hounds in a New York Suburb SANTA ROSA, Calif. — With towering flames bearing down, one victim delayed escape in hopes of saving his new truck — but he could not find the keys. An elderly couple slept as danger erupted, not waking until it was too late to flee down their one-lane road. Another couple, who barely missed their chance to drive away, huddled in a pool, surrounded by fire and choking smoke; he sur- vived, but she did not. As widely varied stories emerged of how people died in the wind-driven fires that have rav- aged Northern California, the ele- ment common to each tragedy — and to many of the tales of people who got out alive — was how quickly it happened. Advance warning was measured in min- utes or seconds, or never came at all. Hesitation was lethal. “My dad’s best friend was call- ing and calling my parents, but they were completely asleep,” said Trina Grant, whose parents, Arthur and Suiko Grant, died at their hilltop property just outside Santa Rosa. “By the time my dad finally picked up and his friend said ‘You’ve got to get out,’ it was probably already too late.” The confirmed death toll reached 35 on Friday night, mak- ing this the deadliest wildfire out- break in California history, and the figure is likely to climb. Thou- sands of homes and businesses have been destroyed, hundreds of people who have been reported missing remain unaccounted for, and emergency workers have barely begun the grim work of combing through the blackened, smoking ruins of houses, cars, forests and businesses. On Sunday night and Monday, 50-mile-per-hour winds propelled the fires faster than people could run. Embers leapfrogged hun- dreds of yards, even jumping across Highway 101, six lanes wide, which ordinarily would have served as an ideal, built-in fire break. Search and rescue teams from around Northern California con- verged on the incinerated remains of Journey’s End on Friday, a mo- bile home park for seniors in Santa Rosa. They came with shov- els, rakes and a cadaver-sniffing As California Fires Raced, Waiting Meant Dying By THOMAS FULLER and RICHARD PÉREZ-PEÑA Search and rescue teams canvassed the scorched ruins of Santa Rosa, Calif., on Friday, looking for any sign of those still missing. JIM WILSON/THE NEW YORK TIMES Many Residents Were Told of Danger With No Time to Spare Continued on Page A15 BEIJING — Having conquered world markets and challenged American political and military leadership, China has set its sights on becoming a global pow- erhouse in a different field: scien- tific research. It now has more lab- oratory scientists than any other country, outspends the entire Eu- ropean Union on research and de- velopment, and produces more scientific articles than any other nation except the United States. But in its rush to dominance, China has stood out in another, less boastful way. Since 2012, the country has retracted more scien- tific papers because of faked peer reviews than all other countries and territories put together, ac- cording to Retraction Watch, a blog that tracks and seeks to pub- licize retractions of research pa- pers. Now, a recent string of high- profile scandals over questionable or discredited research has driven home the point in China that to be- come a scientific superpower, it must first overcome a festering problem of systemic fraud. “China wants to become a global leader in science,” said Zhang Lei, a professor of applied physics at Xi’an Jiaotong Univer- sity. “But how do you achieve that and still preserve the quality of science? We still haven’t figured out how to do that yet.” In April, a scientific journal re- tracted 107 biology research pa- pers, the vast majority of them written by Chinese authors, after evidence emerged that they had faked glowing reviews of their ar- ticles. Then, this summer, a Chi- nese gene scientist who had won celebrity status for break- CHINA TARNISHED BY SCIENCE FRAUD Scandals Impede Goal of Research Dominance By AMY QIN Continued on Page A8 is turning to executive power to accomplish what lawmakers will not, in this case erasing the lega- cy of the Obama years. If the routes are similar, the intended destinations are radi- cally different. Where Mr. Obama sealed a deal with Iran on his own, Mr. Trump on Friday took a step toward unraveling that agreement. Where Mr. Obama used executive power to bolster his health care program, Mr. Trump this week used it to un- dercut it. Where Mr. Obama created a legal status for immi- grants brought illegally as chil- dren, Mr. Trump undid that. WASHINGTON — The presi- dent was frustrated. Lawmakers were not passing what he wanted. They were “obstruction- ists,” he complained. So he took out his pen, signed his name to an order and took action on his own. “We’re taking a little differ- ent route than we had hoped because getting Congress — they forgot what their pledges were,” he said. The chief executive attacking Congress was President Trump, but his words might have been spoken by President Barack Obama. Mr. Trump has con- cluded that he cannot wait for a polarized Congress to act, so he President Trump with the first lady, Melania Trump, on Friday. DOUG MILLS/THE NEW YORK TIMES Continued on Page A11 WHITE HOUSE MEMO Trump Takes Obama Approach As He Tries to Erase a Legacy By PETER BAKER The prospects for opening the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge to oil and gas exploration are better than they have been in years. PAGE A9 New Push for Arctic Drilling The roundups in Azerbaijan, Egypt and Indonesia raised alarms over the vio- lation of basic rights. PAGE A4 U.N. Condemns Arrests of Gays A lawyer for the Chelsea bombing sus- pect all but conceded he set off one blast, but said he changed his mind about detonating a second bomb. PAGE A16 NEW YORK A16-17, 20 A Change-of-Heart Defense The Smithsonian’s claim that it has the original sketch of the Laffer Curve, a key to G.O.P. tax cuts, doesn’t add up. PAGE B1 BUSINESS DAY B1-6 Mystery of a Famous Napkin Evolving social attitudes and competi- tion for talent are leading companies to be more welcoming. PAGE B1 Japan’s Gay-Friendly Shift Jonas Kaufmann shines in a cinema- influenced update of Verdi’s work at the Opéra Bastille in Paris. PAGE C1 ARTS C1-7 A Starry ‘Don Carlos,’ in French Led by Ali Wong, a generation of wom- en is earning laughs with blunt talk on pregnancy and motherhood. PAGE C1 Mom Comedy on the Verge Dallas Keuchel threw seven shutout innings in Game 1 of the American League Championship Series. PAGE D1 SPORTSSATURDAY D1-5 Astros Stifle Yankees, 2-1 A Chargers lineman urged fellow N.F.L. players to focus on injustice rather than criticism of anthem protests. PAGE D1 Player’s Plea: Defy the Owners Late Edition VOL. CLXVII . . . No. 57,750 + © 2017 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, SATURDAY, OCTOBER 14, 2017 Today, mostly cloudy, showers, high 71. Tonight, mostly cloudy, fog devel- oping late, low 65. Tomorrow, be- coming partly cloudy, high 80. Weather map appears on Page C8. $2.50

BY SCIENCE FRAUD CHINA TARNISHED · City public school in at least five years. At his last job, in a Bronx el-ementary school, records show he was disciplined for incompetence, insubordination

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: BY SCIENCE FRAUD CHINA TARNISHED · City public school in at least five years. At his last job, in a Bronx el-ementary school, records show he was disciplined for incompetence, insubordination

C M Y K Nxxx,2017-10-14,A,001,Bs-4C,E2_+

U(D54G1D)y+&!?!.!#!_

Voters appear ready to give populism apush and elect the conservative Sebas-tian Kurz as chancellor. PAGE A4

INTERNATIONAL A4-8

Austria Poised to Shift RightHarvey Weinstein’s company fired himafter accusations of harassment andabuse. Now the Oscar winner may bekicked out of an exclusive club. PAGE A14

Academy to Meet on Weinstein

Bret Stephens PAGE A19

EDITORIAL, OP-ED A18-19

Revising a changing account, the LasVegas police said the killer shot a secu-rity guard and fired on a crowd aroundthe same time. PAGE A13

NATIONAL A9-15

Killing Timeline Shifts Again

WASHINGTON — PresidentTrump announced on Friday hisdecision to disavow the Iran nu-clear agreement, threatening toleave the deal altogether if it wasnot amended to permanentlyblock Tehran from building nucle-ar weapons or intercontinentalmissiles.

But even as he delivered a fire-breathing indictment of the Irani-an government’s activities aroundthe Middle East, he stopped shortof unraveling the agreementreached by President BarackObama two years ago.

“We will not continue down apath whose predictable conclu-sion is more violence, more chaos,the very real threat of Iran’s nucle-ar breakout,” Mr. Trump declaredat the White House in a speechthat was intended to define abroad strategy for confrontingIran.

Mr. Trump’s decision not to cer-tify that Iran was complying withall terms of the agreement cameafter a fierce debate inside the ad-ministration, according to a seniorofficial familiar with the discus-sions and who agreed to describethem on the condition of ano-nymity.

Secretary of State Rex W. Tiller-son and Defense Secretary JimMattis argued that it was in the na-tional security interests of theUnited States to keep the deal’sconstraints on Iran. The two mensucceeded, over time, in persuad-ing Mr. Trump not to immediatelyscrap the accord, despite his cam-paign promise to do so.

Mr. Trump, in declaring his in-

TRUMP DISAVOWSACCORD WITH IRANON NUCLEAR ARMS

ASKS CONGRESS TO ACT

Issues New Threat to ExitWhile Stopping Short

of Undoing Pact

By MARK LANDLERand DAVID E. SANGER

Continued on Page A7

WASHINGTON — PresidentTrump’s decision to cut off criticalpayments to health insurancecompanies ratcheted up the pres-sure on Congress on Friday totake action to protect consumersfrom soaring premiums, whilealso adding a combustible new is-sue to negotiations to avert a gov-ernment shutdown this year.

Mr. Trump’s move, announcedThursday night, could cause cha-os in insurance markets, sendinginsurers fleeing from the Afford-able Care Act’s marketplaces,raising the federal government’scosts and pricing out some con-sumers. It came just hours afterhe signed an executive order thatalso undermined the health law byencouraging the development oflower-cost insurance policies notsubject to the Affordable CareAct’s rigorous coverage stand-ards.

But the president suggested onFriday that he was trying to getDemocrats to the negotiating ta-ble.

“If the Democrats were smart,what they’d do is come and negoti-ate something where people couldreally get the kind of health carethat they deserve,” Mr. Trump toldreporters, insisting that the subsi-dies were “making insurancecompanies rich.”

The subsidies, known as cost-sharing reduction payments, go toinsurance companies to offset thecost of reducing out-of-pocket ex-penses like deductibles and co-payments for low-incomecustomers. Under the AffordableCare Act, insurers will still have tohelp those customers, but withoutthe help of Washington, they say,they will increase premiums. Andwith their profits squeezed, theycould abandon the marketplaces.

Even before Mr. Trump’s deci-sion, Senators Lamar Alexander,

End of SubsidyPuts CongressIn a Tight Spot

Fear of Chaos as TrumpCuts Into Health Act

By THOMAS KAPLANand ROBERT PEAR

Continued on Page A10

Francis Blake has not held apermanent position in a New YorkCity public school in at least fiveyears. At his last job, in a Bronx el-ementary school, records show hewas disciplined for incompetence,insubordination and neglect of du-ties — he had been caught sleep-ing in a classroom when he was

supposed to be helping with dis-missal.

Felicia Alterescu, a special-edu-cation teacher, has been without apermanent post since 2010, de-spite high demand for special edu-cation teachers. According torecords, in addition to getting astring of unsatisfactory ratings,she was disciplined for calling insick when she actually went to afamily reunion. She also did not

tell the Education Departmentthat she had been arrested on har-assment charges.

This month, Mr. Blake, Ms. Al-terescu and hundreds of otherteachers who are part of a poolknown as the Absent Teacher Re-serve could be permanently backin classrooms, as the city’s Educa-tion Department places them injobs at city schools.

The reserve is essentially a

parking lot for staff members whohave lost their positions, some be-cause of school closings and budg-et cuts, others because of disci-plinary problems, but cannot befired. It grew significantly as a re-sult of a 2005 deal between theBloomberg administration, whichwanted to give principals controlover hiring, and the teachers’ un-

Caught Sleeping or Worse, Idled Teachers Head Back to ClassBy KATE TAYLOR

Continued on Page A17

BRYAN ANSELM FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

Despite grappling with dwindling open land and criticism from animal-rights groups, Golden’sBridge Hounds, founded in 1924, still holds fox hunts in Westchester County. Page A16.

Riding to Hounds in a New York Suburb

SANTA ROSA, Calif. — Withtowering flames bearing down,one victim delayed escape inhopes of saving his new truck —but he could not find the keys. Anelderly couple slept as dangererupted, not waking until it wastoo late to flee down their one-laneroad. Another couple, who barelymissed their chance to drive away,huddled in a pool, surrounded byfire and choking smoke; he sur-vived, but she did not.

As widely varied storiesemerged of how people died in thewind-driven fires that have rav-aged Northern California, the ele-ment common to each tragedy —and to many of the tales of peoplewho got out alive — was howquickly it happened. Advancewarning was measured in min-

utes or seconds, or never came atall. Hesitation was lethal.

“My dad’s best friend was call-ing and calling my parents, butthey were completely asleep,”said Trina Grant, whose parents,Arthur and Suiko Grant, died attheir hilltop property just outsideSanta Rosa. “By the time my dadfinally picked up and his friendsaid ‘You’ve got to get out,’ it wasprobably already too late.”

The confirmed death tollreached 35 on Friday night, mak-ing this the deadliest wildfire out-break in California history, and thefigure is likely to climb. Thou-

sands of homes and businesseshave been destroyed, hundreds ofpeople who have been reportedmissing remain unaccounted for,and emergency workers havebarely begun the grim work ofcombing through the blackened,smoking ruins of houses, cars,forests and businesses.

On Sunday night and Monday,50-mile-per-hour winds propelledthe fires faster than people couldrun. Embers leapfrogged hun-dreds of yards, even jumpingacross Highway 101, six laneswide, which ordinarily would haveserved as an ideal, built-in firebreak.

Search and rescue teams fromaround Northern California con-verged on the incinerated remainsof Journey’s End on Friday, a mo-bile home park for seniors inSanta Rosa. They came with shov-els, rakes and a cadaver-sniffing

As California Fires Raced, Waiting Meant DyingBy THOMAS FULLER

and RICHARD PÉREZ-PEÑA

Search and rescue teams canvassed the scorched ruins of Santa Rosa, Calif., on Friday, looking for any sign of those still missing.JIM WILSON/THE NEW YORK TIMES

Many Residents WereTold of Danger With

No Time to Spare

Continued on Page A15

BEIJING — Having conqueredworld markets and challengedAmerican political and militaryleadership, China has set itssights on becoming a global pow-erhouse in a different field: scien-tific research. It now has more lab-oratory scientists than any othercountry, outspends the entire Eu-ropean Union on research and de-velopment, and produces morescientific articles than any othernation except the United States.

But in its rush to dominance,China has stood out in another,less boastful way. Since 2012, thecountry has retracted more scien-tific papers because of faked peerreviews than all other countriesand territories put together, ac-cording to Retraction Watch, ablog that tracks and seeks to pub-licize retractions of research pa-pers.

Now, a recent string of high-profile scandals over questionableor discredited research has drivenhome the point in China that to be-come a scientific superpower, itmust first overcome a festeringproblem of systemic fraud.

“China wants to become aglobal leader in science,” saidZhang Lei, a professor of appliedphysics at Xi’an Jiaotong Univer-sity. “But how do you achieve thatand still preserve the quality ofscience? We still haven’t figuredout how to do that yet.”

In April, a scientific journal re-tracted 107 biology research pa-pers, the vast majority of themwritten by Chinese authors, afterevidence emerged that they hadfaked glowing reviews of their ar-ticles. Then, this summer, a Chi-nese gene scientist who had woncelebrity status for break-

CHINA TARNISHEDBY SCIENCE FRAUD

Scandals Impede Goal ofResearch Dominance

By AMY QIN

Continued on Page A8 is turning to executive power toaccomplish what lawmakers willnot, in this case erasing the lega-cy of the Obama years.

If the routes are similar, theintended destinations are radi-cally different. Where Mr. Obamasealed a deal with Iran on hisown, Mr. Trump on Friday took astep toward unraveling thatagreement. Where Mr. Obamaused executive power to bolsterhis health care program, Mr.Trump this week used it to un-dercut it. Where Mr. Obamacreated a legal status for immi-grants brought illegally as chil-dren, Mr. Trump undid that.

WASHINGTON — The presi-dent was frustrated. Lawmakerswere not passing what hewanted. They were “obstruction-ists,” he complained. So he tookout his pen, signed his name toan order and took action on hisown. “We’re taking a little differ-ent route than we had hopedbecause getting Congress — theyforgot what their pledges were,”he said.

The chief executive attackingCongress was President Trump,but his words might have beenspoken by President BarackObama. Mr. Trump has con-cluded that he cannot wait for apolarized Congress to act, so he

President Trump with the first lady, Melania Trump, on Friday.DOUG MILLS/THE NEW YORK TIMES

Continued on Page A11

WHITE HOUSE MEMO

Trump Takes Obama ApproachAs He Tries to Erase a Legacy

By PETER BAKER

The prospects for opening the ArcticNational Wildlife Refuge to oil and gasexploration are better than they havebeen in years. PAGE A9

New Push for Arctic Drilling

The roundups in Azerbaijan, Egypt andIndonesia raised alarms over the vio-lation of basic rights. PAGE A4

U.N. Condemns Arrests of Gays

A lawyer for the Chelsea bombing sus-pect all but conceded he set off one blast,but said he changed his mind aboutdetonating a second bomb. PAGE A16

NEW YORK A16-17, 20

A Change-of-Heart Defense

The Smithsonian’s claim that it has theoriginal sketch of the Laffer Curve, a keyto G.O.P. tax cuts, doesn’t add up. PAGE B1

BUSINESS DAY B1-6

Mystery of a Famous Napkin

Evolving social attitudes and competi-tion for talent are leading companies tobe more welcoming. PAGE B1

Japan’s Gay-Friendly Shift

Jonas Kaufmann shines in a cinema-influenced update of Verdi’s work at theOpéra Bastille in Paris. PAGE C1

ARTS C1-7

A Starry ‘Don Carlos,’ in French

Led by Ali Wong, a generation of wom-en is earning laughs with blunt talk onpregnancy and motherhood. PAGE C1

Mom Comedy on the Verge

Dallas Keuchel threw seven shutoutinnings in Game 1 of the AmericanLeague Championship Series. PAGE D1

SPORTSSATURDAY D1-5

Astros Stifle Yankees, 2-1

A Chargers lineman urged fellow N.F.L.players to focus on injustice rather thancriticism of anthem protests. PAGE D1

Player’s Plea: Defy the Owners

Late Edition

VOL. CLXVII . . . No. 57,750 + © 2017 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, SATURDAY, OCTOBER 14, 2017

Today, mostly cloudy, showers, high71. Tonight, mostly cloudy, fog devel-oping late, low 65. Tomorrow, be-coming partly cloudy, high 80.Weather map appears on Page C8.

$2.50