Case Number: 3:2011cv00856 Filing 36 Memorandum in Opposition re 7 Emergency MOTION

8/3/2019 Case Number: 3:2011cv00856 Filing 36 Memorandum in Opposition re 7 Emergency MOTION

1/34

Lgzgi Cltgak Ka+= > Oc|t Hcgk \tpoot

Pglbhakd) ZC 04' 52:(04


2/34

gg

TC@IO AJ LAKTOKT\

^ceo

G+ IOECI \TCKDCPD C^ÎGLC@IO TA ^POIGHGKCPW GKM_KLTGAK\ +++++++++++++++++++3GG+ CPE_HOKT +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++0

C+ Kuhopgl Posugpohokt| ( Igfoigbaad aj \ullo|| ak tbo Hopgt|+ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++0@+ îcgktgjj ckd Gktopzokap| Iclf \tckdgke+ +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++4L+ Tbo Hatgak jap c poighgkcpw Gkmukltgak g| @cppod w Iclbo|+ +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++:D+ Tbo Hatgak jap c ^poighgkcpw Gkmukltgak Cecgk|t tbo Po|gdoklw!Zatop

Oigeg`gigtw Posugpohokt| Jcgi| _kdop tbo C~~iglcìo Jcltap|+ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++23+ îcgktgjj ckd Gktopzokap| Lckkat Dohak|tpcto tbo Posug|gto Igfoigbaad aj\ullo|| ak tbo Hopgt|+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++2

0+ îcgktgjj ckd Gktopzokap| Lckkat Dohak|tpcto Gppo~cpcìo Bcph3?


3/34

TC@IO AJ C_TBAPGTGO\

Lc|o|

Ch+ ^cptw aj Tor+ z+ Ubgto) 43? _+\+ 5:5 3754'++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 37

Chopglck ^cptw aj Torc| z+ Ubgto) 43? _+\+ 5:5 3754' ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 4

Ckdop|ak z+ Loio`po}}o) 4:> _+\+ 52> 372 D+ Cpg}+ 0>>?'++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 00

@aecopt z+ Ickd) ?50 J+\u~~+ 22< U+D+ Hglb+ 0>>2' ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 33) 3:

@ulfiow z+ Chopglck Lak|tgtutgakci Ic Jaukdctgak) ?0? _+\+ 320 3777' ++++++++++++++++++++++++ ~c||gh

Lcizcpw Lbpg|tgck Loktop z+ Lgtw aj Jpodopglf|`upe) 0>33 _+\+ Dg|+ IORG\ 55427 O+D+ Zc+

0>33' +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 3

Lc~uta z+ Bait) 035 Zc+ 0) ?) 002 \+O+0d 304) 30' +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 33

Lapkcii z+ \clb|) 77 J+\u~~+ 0d :7? O+D+ Zc+ 0>>>' +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0

Da`|ak z+ Dukic~) ?5: J+ \u~~+ 0d 323 D+ Ho+ 0>>2' +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 3>

Dufo ^aop La+ z+ Lcpaigkc Okzgpakhoktci \tudw Epau~) Gkl+ ) 4

Jg|bhck z+ \lbcjjop) 407 _+\+ 302 5tb Lgp+ 377>'+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 7

Epook ^cptw z+ Uogkop)Ka+ >>LGZ::>> _+\+ Dg|t+ IORG\ 307:>>' +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 00

ETO Lap~+ z+ Ugiigch|) 5tb Lgp+ 3724' ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0

Bcp~op z+ Zc+ Do~%t aj Tcrctgak) 0?> Zc+ 324) 374) 4:0 \+O+0d 270) 272 377?' ++++++++++++++++++++++++ 05

Bcpt z+ \olpotcpw aj \tcto) 53? C+0d 3:? Ho+ 3772' +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 3 J+0d 355 4tb Lgp+ 372


4/34

ggg

Gktopcltgzo Hodgc Okth%t * Echgke C||%k z+ Baidop) Ka+ >7(33) 0>33 _+\+ Dg|t+ IORG\ 07 :tb Lgp+ 372>' +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 7

Fock z+ Licpf) ?: J+\u~~+0d 537 \+D+ Hg||+ 3777' ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 3>' ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 33) 35) 32

Iogetak z+ Hcupw) 5: Zc+ 2:?) 25> 3220'++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0?

Iophck z+ @d+ aj Oioltgak| gk tbo Lgtw aj Ko Wapf) 0


5/34

gz

Powkaid| z+ \gh|) < \+O+0d 0>?) 0>2 37?2' ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0?

\tapop z+ @pak) 43? _+\+ 504 3754' ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 4) 37

\u~opz|+ aj @atotaupt Lktw+ z+ Lcbaak) 303 Zc+ 5:2) 553) 3770 _+\+ C~~+ IORG\ :0:2 4tb Lgp+ C~p+

:) 3770' ~op lupgch' ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 0

_kgtod \tcto| z+ Ci`optgkg) 450 _+\+ :5?) :27 372?'' ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 37

Zcioktg z+ Hgtlboi) 7:0 J+0d 022) 072(0 7 _+\+ 30


6/34

G+ IOECI \TCKDCPD C^ÎGLC@IO TA ^POIGHGKCPW GKM_KLTGAK\Tbo apdgkcpw |tckdcpd eazopkgke tbo ccpd aj c ~poighgkcpw gkmukltgak g| gt|oij sugto bgeb+

Ugktop z+ KPDL) Gkl+) ??? _+\+ 5 0>>2'+ C| tbo UgktopLaupt katod= "C ~poighgkcpw gkmukltgak

g| ck ortpcapdgkcpw pohodw kozop ccpdod c| aj pgebt+" Gd+ ct 04+ Ta ò oktgtiod ta tbo

ortpcapdgkcpw pohodw aj c ~poighgkcpw gkmukltgak) ~icgktgjj "hu|t o|tcìg|b tbct bo g| igfoiw ta

|ullood ak tbo hopgt|) tbct bo g| igfoiw ta |ujjop gppo~cpcìo bcph gk tbo c`|oklo aj ~poighgkcpw

poigoj) tbct tbo `cicklo aj osugtgo| tg~| gk bg| jczap) ckd tbct ck gkmukltgak g| gk tbo ~uìgl

gktopo|t+" Gd+ ct 0>+

Ubgio jap poc|ak| dg|lu||od gk epoctop dotcgi òia ~icgktgjj lckkat hoot tbo Ugktop

|tckdcpd) bg| ùpdok gk tbg| lc|o g| ozok bgebop tbck tbct+ Citbaueb lc|t c| c toh~apcpw)

~pabg`gtapw gkmukltgak) ~icgktgjj| ckd gktopzokap|% hatgak| cpo) gk |u`|tcklo) cttoh~t| ta po|aizo

tbo hopgt| aj tbo ukdopiwgke |ugt| ckd clbgozo ~poighgkcpgiw cii aj tbo poigoj tbow auid ò oktgtiod

ta gj tbow opo ta ~pozcgi ct tpgci+ Ugtbgk tbo pocih aj toh~apcpw gkmukltgak|) |ulb hatgak| cpo

~cptgluicpiw dg|jczapod ckd posugpo c bogebtokod |bagke aj igfoigbaad aj |ullo|| ak tbo hopgt|+

\oo) o+e+) Lcizcpw Lbpg|tgck Ltp+ z+ Lgtw aj Jpodopglf|ùpe) Ka+


7/34

0

Lapkoii z+ \clb|) 77 J+ \u~~+ 0d :7?) 5>4 O+D+ Zc+ 0>>>' "c ~poighgkcpw gkmukltgak tbct

cjjapd| tbo hazckt |u`|tcktgciiw cii tbo poigoj bo hcw polazop ct tbo lakliu|gak aj c juii tpgci ak

tbo hopgt|" g| "dg|jczapod+" suatgke Tgjjckw z+ Japò| Lu|tah @act|) Gkl+) Ka+ 73(>3) 3770

_+\+ C~~+ IORG\ :0:2) ct -03 4tb Lgp+ C~p+ :) 3770' ~op lupgch'''+ \oo ci|a) Iur z+

Padpgeuo|) 33>' Paòpt|) L+M+) Lgplugt Mu|tglo' c~~iwgke ck "gkdg|~utcìw

liocp" |tckdcpd ta ck ohopeoklw hatgak jap gkmukltgak gktokdod ta ~iclo ~icgktgjj ak `ciiat'6 ETO

Lap~+ z+ Ugiigch|) 5tb Lgp+ 3724' "Tbo ùpdok ak tbo ~cptw |oofgke c

~poighgkcpw gkmukltgak g| o|~olgciiw boczw bok tbo poigoj |auebt auid gk ojjolt epckt ~icgktgjj c

|u`|tcktgci ~cpt aj tbo poigoj gt auid a`tcgk cjtop c tpgci ak tbo hopgt|+"'+ @olcu|o bo g| hazgke

jap bct chaukt| ta c ~poighgkcpw) hckdctapw gkmukltgak tbct |oof| ta citop pctbop tbck hcgktcgk

tbo |tctu| sua) gt g| gk|ujjglgokt jap ~icgktgjj ta hopoiw dohak|tpcto tbo igfoigbaad aj |ullo|| ak

tbo hopgt|+ Ta |ctg|jw tbo bogebtokod |tckdcpd) bo hu|t dohak|tpcto tbct bo g| zgptuciiw loptcgk ta

~pozcgi+ Tbg| bo |gh~iw lckkat da+

GG+ CPE_HOKTC+ Kuhopgl Posugpohokt| ( Igfoigbaad aj \ullo|| ak tbo Hopgt|+

Citbaueb ~icgktgjj ckd gktopzokap| haukt c ~opjukltapw lbciiokeo ta tbo kuhopgl

posugpohokt| aj Zc+ Lado Ckk+ 04+0(?4?@ gk Laukt GG aj tbogp Lah~icgkt| Dal+ 3 ct :6 Dal+

02 ct 2(7') tbo zcigdgtw aj |ulb posugpohokt| g| c||uhod gk tbo zopw lc|o| tbow lgto gk Laukt G+

Dal+ 3 ct ?(:) 0?(0:6 Dal+ 02 ct 5(2)


8/34

>> |gekctupo|'6 Mokko|| z+

Japt|ak) 4>< _+\+ 4)>>> zcigd |gekctupo| g| akiw ?:/

aj tbo czopceo posugpohokt jap eokopci oioltgak `ciiat cllo|| jap cii jgjtw |tcto| c| po~aptod gk tbo

hgd(377>|+ Iog|(@olf * \sugpo) 0? @+M+ âi+ \+ ct 40>+

Egzok bg|tapw ckd ~polodokt) ~icgktgjj ckd gktopzokap| cpo ukcìo ta dohak|tpcto tbo

posug|gto igfoigbaad aj |ullo|| ak tbo hopgt|+ Gkdood) tbo lbciiokeo g| taa gk|u`|tcktgci ta cppckt

lak|gdopctgak aj tbo atbop Ugktop jcltap| òcpgke ak oktgtiohokt ta ck gkmukltgak cecgk|t tbo

kuhopgl posugpohokt|+


9/34

4

Ugtb po|~olt ta tbo po|gdoklw!zatop oigeg`gigtw lbciiokeo) tbg| Laupt |bauid kat ozok poclb

tbo Ugktopjcltap| ak tbo ~pgklg~ci poigoj |auebt àtb òlcu|o aj iclf aj |tckdgke ckd tbo `cp aj

iclbo|+

@+ îcgktgjj ckd Gktopzokap| Iclf \tckdgke+Cptglio GGG aj tbo Lak|tgtutgak ighgt| tbo mudglgci ~aop aj tbo _kgtod \tcto| ta cltuci lc|o|

ckd laktpazop|go|+ _+\+ Lak|t+ cpt+ GG) 0) li+ 3+ Ck o||oktgci oiohokt aj tbo lc|o ap laktpazop|w

posugpohokt g| gkdgzgduci |tckdgke+ ôp|akci |tckdgke posugpo| 3' tbo dohak|tpctgak aj c

"%dg|tgklt ckd ~ci~cìo gkmupw)%" 0' "c %jcgpiw tpclocìo% lcu|ci lakkoltgak òtook tbo licghod

gkmupw ckd tbo lbciiokeod lakdult)" ckd


10/34

?

Ugtb po|~olt ta tpcloc`gigtw) ~icgktgjj ckd gktopzokap| cpo kat ògke dokgod c ~iclo ak tbo

`ciiat òlcu|o aj tbo lgpluictap po|gdoklw!zatop oigeg`gigtw posugpohokt+ Tbow cpo ògke dokgod c

~iclo ak tbo `ciiat òlcu|o tbow dgd kat hoot tbo lak|tgtutgakciiw |aukd posugpohokt aj

|u`hgttgke 3>)>>> zcigd |gekctupo| `w tbo lak|tgtutgakciiw zcigd docdigko+ Tbg| lgpluh|tcklo ci|a

hcfo| tbo licgh| aj ~icgktgjj ckd gktopzokap| kakpodpo||cìo+ \oo Hgpckt âtahcl Pgzop) IIL z+

O^C) ?55 J+7' Ka |tckdgke òlcu|o gkmupw "jiaVodX jpah Zgpegkgc%|

Kakcttcgkhokt ^pazg|gak|" ckd boklo lauid "kat ò jcgpiw tpclod ta O^C%| c~~pazci aj Zgpegkgc%|

LCGP \G^"'6 Huktcsgh z+ Laahò) 447 J+7(33) 0>33 _+\+ Dg|t+ IORG\ 0


11/34

:

L+ Tbo Hatgak jap c ^poighgkcpw Gkmukltgak g| @cppod `w Iclbo|+îcgktgjj ckd gktopzokap| opo ~ophgttod ta laiiolt |gekctupo| jap `ciiat cllo|| òtook

Muiw 3) 0>33) ckd Dolohòp 00) 0>33+ Dal+ 3) 33(306 Dal+ 033) îcgktgjj dgd kat |gek

"bg| Dolicpctgak aj Lckdgdclw jap tbo Lahhakocitb aj Zgpegkgc" uktgi Altaòp 33+

Dal+ 3 ct 4) 3:(356 Dal+ 0< ct 33) io||

tbck ta oof| òjapo tbo docdigko jap ~pgktgke `ciiat|+ Dal+ 36 Dal+ 00 ct 0'+

Gktopzokap| Egkepglb) Bukt|hck ckd \cktapuh ckkauklod jap tbo ~po|gdoklw ak Hcw 33)

Muko 03 ckd Muko :) 0>33) po|~oltgzoiw+ Dal+ 02 ct ?) 37(03'+ Tbow jgiod tbogp po|~oltgzo

|tctohokt| gtb tbo Jodopci Oioltgak Lahhg||gak ak Hcw 3:) Muko 02) ckd Muko :) 0>33+ Dal+

02 ct ?) 00(04'+ Egkepglb ckd \cktapuh ciioeo tbct tbow |gekod tbogp Zgpegkgc Dolicpctgak| aj

Lckdgdclw ak Dolohòp 00) 0>33 Dal+ 02 ct ?) 0?') citbaueb \cktapuh%| dolicpctgak c|

kozop jgiod gtb tbo \tcto @acpd aj Oioltgak|+ Dal+


13/34

2

Da`|ak z+ Dukic~) ?5: J+ \u~~+ 0d 323) 325(22 D+ Ho+ 0>>2' dokwgke c hatgak jap

~poighgkcpw gkmukltgak ta bczo c lckdgdcto%| kcho c~~ocp ak tbo `ciiat jap tbo _kgtod \tcto|

\okcto òlcu|o tbo lbciiokeo ta tbo kahgkctgak ~otgtgak ~palo|| c| `cppod `w iclbo| bok

~po|oktod kocpiw ta haktb| òjapo tbo oioltgak) cjtop "tbo ~pgktop bcd cipocdw òeuk tbo `ciiat

~pgktgke ~palo||"'6 |oo ci|a) Bopkdak z+ K+L+ \tcto @d+ aj Oioltgak|) 53> J+0d 355) 320 4tb Lgp+

3722'6 Kcdop z+ @poop) ?>2'6 Lbckdiop z+ Lgtw aj Cpzcdc) 070 J+>0'6 Iophck z+ @d+ aj

Oioltgak| gk tbo Lgtw aj Ko Wapf) 0


14/34

7

tbo |cho lc|o cutbapgtw gk lbciiokegke tbo posugpohokt aj Zc+ Lado Ckk+ 04+0(?>: tbct

lakepo||gakci ~otgtgak lgpluictap!gtko||o| ò zatop sucigjgod gk tbo Lakepo||gakci dg|tpglt ct

g||uo+ Iur ia|t gk tbo dg|tpglt laupt òlcu|o tbo Jauptb Lgplugt bcd u~boid |ghgicp posugpohokt| gk

Igòptcpgck ^cptw aj Zc+ z+ Dczg|) 5:: J+0d 2:? 4tb Lgp+ 372?') ak tbo epaukd tbct tbo

posugpohokt ok|upo| c hadgluh aj cltgzg|t |u~~apt gk tbo poiozckt mupg|dgltgak+ Iur) 547(?>+ Iur tbok jgiod ck Ohopeoklw Hatgak jap ^poighgkcpw Gkmukltgak gk tbo Jauptb

Lgplugt+ Lc|o= 3>(3775) Dal+ 2'+ Ubok tbct hatgak c| dokgod Lc|o= 3>(3775) Dal+ 00') Iur

|auebt poigoj jpah Lbgoj Mu|tglo Paòpt| c| Lgplugt Mu|tglo jap tbo Jauptb Lgplugt+

Lbgoj Mu|tglo Paòpt| dokgod tbo hatgak hcfgke tbpoo ~agkt| aj |gekgjglcklo jap tbo

~po|okt lc|o+ Jgp|t) bo jaukd tbct ck oiozctod "gkdg|~utcìw liocp" ioeci |tckdcpd c~~igod ta

gkmukltgak| jpah c lgplugt mu|tglo+ Iur) 33'

u~baidgke |tcto po|gdoklw posugpohokt' lgtgke Fock z+ Licpf) ?: J+ \u~~+ 0d 537) 502(07) 5


15/34

3>

pctgakcio aj eucpcktoogke c hadgluh aj cltgzg|t |u~~apt c| ka iakeop laktpaiigke+ Iur z+ Mudd)

:?3 J+33'+ Ozok |a) tbo Jauptb Lgplugt dgd kat jgkd tbct Iur%|

lbciiokeo c| |a liocp c| ta oktgtio bgh ta poigoj cecgk|t tbo gk(dg|tpglt gtko|| posugpohokt ak

c~~oci+ Gkdood) gt |cgd tbo a~~a|gto=

Aup polaekgtgak tbct Dczg|% c``pozgctod po|gdoklw(posugpohokt ckciw|g|bc| òok |u~op|odod |bauid kat ò lakju|od jap c dotophgkctgak tbct tbo ~pazg|gak

lbciiokeod bopo ajjokd| Iur%| lak|tgtutgakci pgebt|+ Kogtbop Howop kap @ulfiow

cddpo||od tbo ~cptgluicp gtko|| po|gdoklw posugpohokt ct g||uo gk tbg| lc|o+Hapoazop) o da kat pocd ogtbop dolg|gak c| japolia|gke tbo ~a||g`gigtw tbct

|ahotbgke hapo tbck c tbpo|baid |gekctupo posugpohokt hcw) gk |aho

lgpluh|tcklo|) ò lak|tgtutgakciiw ~ophg||gìo c| c hock| aj ok|upgke ~a~uicp

|u~~apt ap clbgozgke ckatbop |tcto gktopo|t+

Gd+ ct 4>4+ Tbo Jauptb Lgplugt juptbop katod tbct ak pohckd "V`Xatb ~cptgo| cpo jpoo ta cdzcklo

cddgtgakci cpeuhokt| gk igebt aj aup baidgke+" Gd+

\ujjglgokt poc|ak| jap tbo |tcto po|gdoklw!zatop oigeg`gigtw posugpohokt ct g||uo bopo cpo kat

bcpd ta jgkd òlcu|o tbow bczo òok ~a|gtod `w tbo \u~poho Laupt gt|oij+ Gk Chopglck

Lak|tgtutgakci Ic Jaukdctgak) tbo \u~poho Laupt |tpulf dak c zatop poeg|tpctgak posugpohokt

òlcu|o ck uklbciiokeod |tcto po|gdoklw posugpohokt hapo kcppaiw |opzod tbo |cho ~utctgzo

|tcto gktopo|t) |cwgke "VgXk |uh) c||uhgke tbct c po|gdoklo posugpohokt auid ò u~boid c| c

koodjui gktoepgtw ~aiglgke hoc|upo (( c suo|tgak o) igfo tbo Toktb Lgplugt) bczo ka allc|gak ta

dolgdo òlcu|o tbo ~cptgo| bczo kat ~iclod tbo hcttop aj po|gdoklo ct g||uo (( tbo cddod

poeg|tpctgak posugpohokt g| kat cppcktod+" ?0? _+\+ ct 375 gktopkci lgtctgak ahgttod'+ Tbo

\u~poho Laupt gk dgltc ci|a c~~pazod aj c zatop oigeg`gigtw posugpohokt c| c hapo kcppa

|u`|tgtuto jap c zatop poeg|tpctgak posugpohokt) |~olgjglciiw katgke tbct c zatop oigeg`gigtw

posugpohokt lauid ò u|od c| c ~parw ta ood aut joiak|) hgkap| ckd giioeci cigok|+ Gd+ ct 37?

k+3: "ôp|ak| oigegìo ta zato) o kato) auid kat gkliudo %lakzgltod dpue joiak| ba bczo òok

dokgod tbo jpcklbg|o c| ~cpt aj tbogp ~ukg|bhokt) + + + + Ozok hapo ghcegkcpw g| tbo dg||okt%|


16/34

33

|ueeo|tgak tbct gj tbo hopoiw zatop oigegìo cpo gkliudod chake ~otgtgak lgpluictap|) lbgidpok ckd

lgtg}ok| aj japogek ickd| gii kat ò jcp òbgkd+"'+

Gk igebt ajChopglck Lak|tgtutgakci Ic Jaukdctgak) ckd tbo tpocthokt aj tboIur lc|o gk

tbo Jauptb Lgplugt ckd gk tbo \u~poho Laupt) gt g| |gh~iw kat ~a||gìo jap ~icgktgjj ap tbo

gktopzokap| ta dohak|tpcto tbo kocp loptcgktw aj |ullo|| posugpod aj tboh+ Gkdood) tbow lckkat

ozok |ctg|jw tbo apdgkcpw Ugktop |tckdcpd+ Kat akiw bc| tbo \u~poho Laupt gktghctod tbct

po|gdoklw!zatop oigeg`gigtw posugpohokt| cpo zcigd) ùt Chopglck Lak|tgtutgakci Ic Jaukdctgak

ckd gt| ~podolo||ap)Howop z+ Epckt) 42: _+\+ 434 3722') cpo `ciiat gkgtgctgzo lc|o|+ Ckd gk |ulb

lc|o| "VtXbo lgpluictgak aj ck gkgtgctgzo ~otgtgak aj kolo||gtw gkzaizo| àtb tbo or~po||gak aj c

do|gpo jap ~aigtglci lbckeo ckd c dg|lu||gak aj tbo hopgt| aj tbo ~pa~a|od lbckeo+" Howop) 42:

_+\+ ct 403+ Tbg| dg|tgkltgak hcttop|+

Gkgtgctgzo(~otgtgak lgpluictap|) tbo Toktb Lgplugt polaekg}od) po|ohìobckd`gii dg|tpgùtap|) gk tbct àtb |oof ta ~pahato ~uìgl |u~~apt jap c ~cptgluicp

g||uo ap ~a|gtgak+ Gkgtgctgzo(~otgtgak lgpluictap| ci|a po|ohìo lckdgdcto(~otgtgak

|gekctupo ectbopop|) baozop) jap àtb |oof `ciiat cllo||+

Chopglck Lak|tgtutgakci Ic Jaukdctgak) ?0? _+\+ ct 37>(73 gktopkci lgtctgak ahgttod'+ Ugtb

po|~olt ta tbo icttop c|~olt|) "\tcto| ciiagke `ciiat gkgtgctgzo| bczo lak|gdopcìo ioocw ta

~patolt tbo gktoepgtw ckd poigc`gigtw aj tbo gkgtgctgzo ~palo||) c| tbow bczo gtb po|~olt ta oioltgak

~palo||o| eokopciiw+" Gd+ ct 373+ Ckd tbo Laupt c||uhod) gtbaut dolgdgke) tbct tbo kood ta bczo

lgpluictap| gtbgk tbo |tcto |u`~aokc ~aop jcii| gtbgk tbct `pacd ioocw+ Gd+ ct 37:(75+ Ozok

gtb po|~olt ta tbo bckd`gii tw~o c|~olt| aj `ciiat gkgtgctgzo ~otgtgakgke) tbo \u~poho Laupt bc|

|cgd tbct "%ka igthu|(~c~op to|t% gii |o~cpcto zcigd `ciiat(cllo|| ~pazg|gak| jpah gkzcigd

gktopcltgzo |~oolb po|tpgltgak|6 o bczo laho u~ak %ka |u`|tgtuto jap tbo bcpd mudehokt| tbct

hu|t ò hcdo+%" Gd+ ct 370 suatgke \tapop) 43? _+\+ ct 5'+


17/34

30

@olcu|o tbo \u~poho Laupt bc| kozop gkzcigdctod c |tctogdo po|gdoklw!zatop oigeg`gigtw

posugpohokt ckd bc| kozop gkzcigdctod c lgpluictap posugpohokt aut|gdo aj gkgtgctgzo lc|o|) tbo

iaop laupt lc|o| u~ak bglb ~icgktgjj ckd gktopzokap| poiw bglb poicto ta gkgtgctgzo ap io|| tbck

|tcto(gdo po|gdoklw!zatop oigeg`gigtw posugpohokt| cpo pocdgiw dg|tgkeug|bc`io+ \oo Wo| ak Toph

Ighgt|) Gkl+) ??> J+0< `ciiat gkgtgctgzo'6 Lbckdiop) 070 J+


18/34

3 _+\+ 52>) 522

372


20/34

3?

@poop lckkat |ctg|jw ~icgktgjj%| `updok aj dohak|tpctgke tbo posug|gto igfoigbaad aj

|ullo|| ak tbo hopgt|+ Gk tbo jgp|t ~iclo) gt g| dgpoltiw laktpcdgltod `w c dolg|gak jpah tbo Ogebtb

Lgplugt c| @poop gt|oij polaekg}o|+ @poop) ?


21/34

3:

33tb Lgp+ 0>>>'+ Ubopo tbo ~cptw |oofgke ~poighgkcpw poigoj bc| kat |bak c igfoigbaad aj

|ullo|| ak tbo hopgt|) tbct tbopo hcw `o ck gppo~cpc`io gkmupw ta tbo ciioeod pgebt) ozok c

lak|tgtutgakci ako) dao| kat mu|tgjw ~poighgkcpw poigoj+ \oo Dufo z+ Lioickd) 7?4 J+0d 3?0:) 3?07)

3?


22/34

35

Lgp+ 0>> D+ Cpg}+ 0>>?'6 Epook ^cptw z+ Uogkop)Ka+ >>LGZ::>> _+\+ Dg|t+ IORG\ 307:>>'6 Lcpdakc z+ Acfickd _kgjgod

\lb+ Dg|t+) 52? J+ \u~~+ 0d 2


23/34

32

3?c'3'C') tbo chokdhokt g| laktpcpw ta tbo iottop ckd |~gpgt aj tbo lah~po||od |lboduio

eazopkgke tbg| ~poighgkcpw gkmukltgak ~paloodgke) bglb kogtbop okzg|gak| kap cllahhadcto|

ckw |ulb jgigke+

Laukt 0 aj tbo Jgp|t Chokdod Lah~icgkt ciioeo| tbct tbo japh u|od jap |gekctupo

laiioltgak) \@O(?4?) c| zagd `olcu|o gt c| kat ~po(liocpod ukdop \oltgak ? aj tbo Zatgke

Pgebt| Clt aj 37:?) c| chokdod+ 40 _+\+L+ 375?l+ Citbaueb tbg| Laupt g| cutbapg}od ta "epckt

c toh~apcpw po|tpcgkgke apdop ak c |~olgjgl jgkdgke) `c|od ak ozgdoklo |u`hgttod) tbct |~olgjgod

gppo~cpc`io dchceo gii po|uit gj tbo apdop g| kat epcktod)" tbct apdop) ukio|| ~pozgau|iw pozafod

`w tbo dg|tpglt mudeo) |bcii pohcgk gk japlo akiw uktgi tbo bocpgke ckd dotophgkctgak `w tbo dg|tpglt

laupt aj tbpoo mudeo| aj ck c~~iglctgak jap c ~poighgkcpw gkmukltgak+" 02 _+\+L+ 0024`'


24/34

37

~padulo ck c`|upd po|uit+ Dal+ ct 2) Laukt 3'+ Tbo jclt tbct ~icgktgjj ka tbgkf| tbct tbg| g|

bg| ò|t cpeuhokt hopoiw |opzo| ta giiu|tpcto tbo ~cpiau| |tcto aj bg| lc|o+

Zgpegkgc ic ~pazgdo| tbct "VcXkw ~op|ak |oofgke tbo kahgkctgak aj tbo kctgakci ~aigtglci

~cptw jap tbo ajjglo aj ^po|gdokt aj tbo _kgtod \tcto|) ap ckw epau~ apeckg}od gk tbg|

Lahhakocitb ak òbcij aj) ckd gtb tbo lak|okt aj |ulb ~op|ak) hcw jgiod gtb tbo \tcto

@acpd ~otgtgak| |gekod `w ct ioc|t 3>)>>> sucigjgod zatop|) gkliudgke ct ioc|t 4>> sucigjgod zatop|

jpah oclb lakepo||gakci dg|tpglt gk tbo Lahhakocitb) ba ctto|t tbct tbow gktokd ta ~cptglg~cto

gk tbo ~pghcpw aj tbo |cho ~aigtglci ~cptw c| tbo lckdgdcto jap bah tbo ~otgtgak| cpo jgiod+"

Lado 04+0(?4?@+ îcgktgjj c`|updiw laktokd|) jalu|gke ak tbo apd "hcw" ta tbo orliu|gak aj

tbo pohcgkdop aj tbo |tctuto) tbct |gekctupo laiioltgak g| hopoiw a~tgakci+ Dal+ ) ct 2(3>'+

îcgktgjj ~po||o| tbg| ortpczceckt lak|tpultgak do|~gto tbo liocp ickeuceo aj tbct |u`|oltgak tbct

dgpolt| tbo "|tcto lbcgphck aj tbo Vlckdgdcto%|X ~cptw" ta "jupkg|b ta tbo \tcto @acpd tbo kcho| aj

cii lckdgdcto| ba bczo |ctg|jgod tbo posugpohokt| aj tbg| |oltgak)" ckd) cecgk) ~pazgdo| tbct)

"VXbokozop akiw ako lckdgdcto jap c ~cptw%| kahgkctgak jap ^po|gdokt aj tbo _kgtod \tcto| bc|

hot tbo posugpohokt| ta bczo bg| kcho ak tbo `ciiat) bo gii ò dolicpod tbo gkkop ckd ka

~po|gdoktgci ~pghcpw jap tbct ~cptw gii ò boid+" Lado 04+0(?4?@ oh~bc|o| cddod'+

Citbaueb gt g| |upoiw lappolt tbct "tbo apd %|bcii% g| ~pghcpgiw hckdctapw gk gt| ojjolt ckd tbo

apd %hcw% g| ~pghcpgiw ~ophg||gzo)" Pa|| z+ Lpc) 0:) 030) Zc+ 324) 374) 4:0 \+O+0d 270) 272

377?'6 Lc~uta z+ Bait) 035 Zc+ 0) ?) 002 \+O+0d 304) 3


25/34

0>

2:?) 25> 3220'+ \oo ci|a \u~opz|+ aj @atotaupt Lktw+ z+ Lcbaak) 303 Zc+ 5:2) 55


26/34

03

okclthokt) ckd bcphakg}o| gtb gt| laktort) ckd |u`|oltgak @%| pojopoklo ta tbo "posugpohokt| aj

tbg| |oltgak)" gt |bauid `o cda~tod+

Tbo hckgjo|t ~up~a|o aj tbo ioeg|ictupo gk okcltgke tbo |tctuto oktgtiod "^po|gdoktgci

~pghcpw" c| ta ~pazgdo c hock| `w bglb ~op|ak| lauid baid tboh|oizo| japtb jap "tbo

kahgkctgak aj VcX kctgakci ~aigtglci ~cptw jap tbo ajjglo aj ^po|gdokt aj tbo _kgtod \tcto|)" Lado

04+0(??@) ckd clbgozo tbo "gh~aptckt |tcto gktopo|t VajX posugpgke |aho ~poighgkcpw |bagke aj c

|gekgjglckt hadgluh aj |u~~apt `ojapo ~pgktgke tbo kcho aj c ~aigtglci apeckg}ctgak%| lckdgdcto

ak tbo `ciiat (( tbo gktopo|t) gj ka atbop) gk czagdgke lakju|gak) dolo~tgak) ckd ozok jpu|tpctgak aj

tbo dohalpctgl ~palo|| ct tbo eokopci oioltgak+" \tapop) 43? _+\+ ct 5


27/34

00

~op|ak| |a do|gpo ta da |a) tbow "hcw jgio gtb tbo \tcto @acpd ~otgtgak| |gekod `w ct ioc|t 3>)>>>

sucigjgod zatop|) gkliudgke ct ioc|t 4>> sucigjgod zatop| jpah oclb lakepo||gakci dg|tpglt gk tbo

Lahhakocitb) ba ctto|t tbct tbow gktokd ta ~cptglg~cto gk tbo ~pghcpw aj tbo |cho ~aigtglci

~cptw c| tbo lckdgdcto jap bah tbo ~otgtgak| cpo jgiod+" Lado 04+0(?4?@+ Ckd akiw "tbo

kcho| aj cii lckdgdcto| ba bczo |ctg|jgod tbo posugpohokt| aj tbg| |oltgak" "|bcii c~~ocp ak tbo

`ciiat" aj tbo "~po|gdoktgci ~pghcpw jap tbct ~cptw+" Lado 04+0(?4?@ ckd L oh~bc|g| cddod'+

Cllapdgkeiw) gj tbo Laupt lbaa|o| ta lak|gdop tbo ioeci tboapw ~icgktgjj bc| |a ictoiw jc|bgakod) gt

|bauid lakliudo tbct ~icgktgjj bc| jcgiod ta hcfo tbo posug|gto |bagke aj igfoigbaad aj |ullo||

ak tbo hopgt|+ Bo ci|a jcgi| ta dohak|tpcto gppo~cpcìo bcph ap tbct tbo `cicklo aj osugtgo| ckd

tbo ~uìgl gktopo|t jczap bg| ~a|gtgak jap tbo poc|ak| dg|lu||od ct ioketb càzo+

LAKLI_\GAK

Gk tbg| lgplugt) ~icgktgjj g| posugpod ta |ctg|jw cii jaup ~poighgkcpw gkmultgak jcltap| gk apdop

ta sucigjw jap c ~poighgkcpw gkmultgak+ Tbo Poci Tputb Càut A`chc) ?0? J+ Toio~bako2>4' 0>> Jcl|ghgio

deotlboiiNace+|tcto+zc+u|


30/34

H+ J+ Lakkoii Huiigk|) Mp+) O|sugpo

Bueb H+ Jcgk) GGG) O|sugpoOdcpd Ozopott @cekoii) Mp+) O|sugpo

\~att| Jcgk ^+L+

433 Oc|t Jpckfigk \tpoot) \ugto :>>

Pglbhakd) Zgpegkgc 04' :75(0>4>

Jcr= 2>4' :75(034>

lhuiigk|N|~att|jcgk+lahbjcgkN|~att|jcgk+lah

o`cekoiiN|~att|jcgk+lahLauk|oi jap Tbo Bakapcìo Pglf ôppw

Ma|o~b H+ Kgrak) O|sugpo ~pa bcl zglo'

Mcho| O+ Tpcgkap) GGG) O|sugpo ~pa bcl zglo'

Hcptgk D+ @ogpko) O|sugpo ~pa bcl zglo'

@ogpko) Hcwkcpd * ^cp|ak|) I+I+^+3> â|t Acf @auiozcpd) \ugto 0?>>

Bau|tak) TR 55>?:^bako= 53(3?05

mkgrakN`h~ii~+lah

ttpcgkapN`h~ii~+lahhògpkoN`h~ii~+lahLauk|oi jap Tbo Bakapcìo Pglf ôppw

Lbcpio| Hglbcoi \gh|

IoLicgpPwck) C ^pajo||gakci Lap~apctgak

^+A+ @ar 0477

Pglbhakd) ZC 04' 52> K+ Uc|bgketak \t+) \ugto 4>?

Ciorckdpgc) ZC 00?> Lakkoltglut Czokuo) KU

Uc|bgketak) DL 0>>>Jcr= 0>0(2?5(:


31/34

Liotc Hgtlboii) O|sugpo ~pa bcl zglo ta `o jgiod'

Jaiow * Icpdkop II^>> F \tpoot) K+U+

\ugto :>>

Uc|bgketak) DL 0>>>5(?3>7

Toi= 0>0(:50(?>Jcr= 0>0(:50(?


32/34

G juptbop loptgjw tbct |aho aj tbo ~cptglg~ckt| gk tbo lc|o cpo kat poeg|topod LH!OLJ u|op|+

G bczo hcgiod ako la~w aj tbo japoeagke daluhokt `w Jgp|t(Lic|| Hcgi ta tbo jaiiagke kak(

LH!OLJ ~cptglg~ckt=

Ioo Oitak Eaadhck) O|sugpo

IoLicgpPwck) ^+L+33>3 Lakkoltglut Czokuo) KU

\ugto :>>

Uc|bgketak) D+L+ 0>>0' :?7(434>

Lauk|oi jap ^ct Huiigk|) gk bg| ajjglgci

lc~clgtw c| Lbcgphck aj tbo Po~u`iglck ^cptw aj Zgpegkgc

!|!O+ Duklck Eotlboii) Mp+

\aiglgtap Eokopci aj ZgpegkgcZ\@ Ka+ 343?:'

Ajjglo aj tbo Cttapkow Eokopci

7>> Oc|t Hcgk \tpoot

Pglbhakd) Zgpegkgc 04' 52:(504> Toio~bako

2>4' 0>> Jcl|ghgio

deotlboiiNace+|tcto+zc+u|Lauk|oi jap Dojokdckt| Mudd)

@aop| ckd ^cihop


33/34


34/34

Documents

Case Number: 3:2011cv00856 Filing 36 Memorandum in Opposition re 7 Emergency MOTION