Central Administrative Tribunal Principal Bench

OA No.305/2014

New Delhi, this the 8th day of August, 2018

Hon’ble Mr. Justice L. Narasimha Reddy, Chairman

Hon’ble Ms. Praveen Mahajan, Member (A)

1. Niraj Tirkey, S/o Late Sh. Nelson Tirkey, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, AIR, New Broadcasting House, New Delhi. R/o 34/11B, Pocket-11B, Vinayak Apartment, Sector-23, Rohini, Delhi-110085.

2. B. Jeyavendhan, S/o Sh. A. Baluchamy, Working as Engineering Assistant, AIR, Srinagar (J&K). R/o 177-A, Pocket-F, Mayur Vihar-2, Delhi-91.

3. Sushil Kumar, S/o Late Sh. N. P. Gupta, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, AIR, Patna (Bihar). R/o C/19, Phase-II, Akashvani Colony, Chhajjubagh, Patna-800001 (Bihar).

4. Jalandhar Ram, S/o Late Sh. Gudari Ram, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, AIR, Patna (Bihar). R/o D/5, Phase-I, Akashvani Colony, Chhajjubagh, Patna-800001 (Bihar).

5. Faizan Ahmad, S/o Late Mohd. Muslehuddin, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, AIR, Patna (Bihar). R/o D/4, Phase I, Akashvani Colony, Chhajjubagh, Patna-8000001 (Bihar).

6. Shatrughan Rai, S/o Late Sh. Parmeshwar Rai, Working as Engineering Assistant, AIR, CBS, Patna (Bihar). R/o Before & Opp. Health Institute, Beur, Patna-8000002 (Bihar).

7. Arvind Kumar Sahu, S/o Sh. Mahesh Sahu,

Working as Engineering Assistant, AIR, Patna (Bihar).

2

R/o C/o R. N. Ojha, Road No.9, Sanjay Gandhi Nagar, Hanuman Nagar, Patna-800020 (Bihar).

8. Binod Kumar Ram, S/o Late Sh. Fullan Ram, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, AIR, Patna (Bihar). R/o D/10, Phase I, Akashvani Colony, Chhajjubagh, Patna-8000001 (Bihar).

9. Shrinath Ram, S/o Late Sh. Duduli Ram, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, AIR, Patna (Bihar). R/o Vill-Rupaspur, Ganganagar Colony, Post-Dhanaut, Patna-801506 (Bihar).

10. Vinay Shankar Sharma, S/o Late Sh. S. N. Sharma, Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, Patna (Bihar). R/o 261A, North Patel Nagar, Road No.4 Patna-800024 (Bihar).

11. K. Pandu, S/o Sh. C. Kadaiyan, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Puducherry. R/o 157, 21st Street, Kalpakkam-603102 (Tamilnadu).

12. S. Pazhani Thayappan, S/o Sh. S. P. Subraminapillai,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), DMC, Puducherry. R/o Plot No.100, No. 39, 2nd Main Road, Netasan Nagar, Puducherry-605005.

13. P. Booshanam, S/o Sh. S. N. Paramasivam Pillai, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DMC, Puducherry. R/o 64, Nehru Nagar Extn, Venkatanagar PO, Puducherry-605011.

14. A. Mani, S/o Sh. N. Annamalai, Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, Puducherry. R/o 45, 3rd Cross, Anandha Ranga Pillai Nagar, Puducherry-605008.

15. Jonas Ambroise, S/o Sh. Jean Ambroise, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, TVRC, Villupuram (under DMC, Puducherry). R/o 131, Annamalaiar Street, MGR Nagar, Mudaliar Pet, Puducherry-605004.

3

16. T. Veera Narayana, S/o Sh. T. Venkataiah, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Hyderabad (AP). R/o 3-11-44, Flat No. G4, Sri Sai Apartments, Ramanthapur, Hyderabad-500013(AP).

17. A. Basheer Ahmad, S/o Sh. A. Abdul Lattif, Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, FM, Karaikal. R/o 5/139, Kumaran South Street, Manjakollai, Nagapattinam-611106 (Tamilnadu).

18. V. Kumaraguru, S/o Sh. A. Viswanathan, Working as Assistant Engineer, TVRC, Karaikal. R/o 9, Nehru Nagar Extension, Karaikal (Pondicherry U.T.).

19. M. Ponmudi, S/o Sh. P. Muniamuthu, Working as Assistant Engineer, HPT, DDK, Kumbakonam. R/o 2/581, Jeyankondam Road, Min nagar, Ariyalur-621704 (Tamilnadu).

20. Rajesh Pal, S/o Sh. Jairam Pal, Working as Senior Engineering assistant, TVRC, Nagda (under DMC, Indore). R/o 26A, Gordhandham Nagar, Ujjain-456010 (MP).

21. Prahlad Singh Sisodia, S/o Sh. M. S. Sisodia, Working as Assistant Engineer, TVRC, Ujjain (MP). R/o 183, Mahashweta Nagar, Dewas Road, Ujjain-456010 (MP).

22. Pankaj Pandit, S/o Sh. Girdhari Lal, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, TVRC, Ujjain (MP). R/o B24/22, Basant Vihar Colony, Ujjain-456010 (MP).

23. Mrs. Kiran Bang, D/o Sh. M. L. Gupta, Working as Engineering Assistant, AIR, Ujjain (MP). R/o 3, Tripti Parisar, Nanakheda, Ujjain-456010 (MP).

24. Vijaykumar C. Savagunji, S/o Sh. C. M. Savagunji,

4

Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, AIR, Ujjain (MP). R/o LIG-40, F/6, Vardhman Enclave, Kotrasultanabad, Bhopal-462003 (MP).

25. Veer Singh Kain, S/o Late Sh. Lala Ram, Working as Assistant Engineer, HPT, Doordarshan, Pitampura, New Delhi. R/o 404, SFS, DDA Flats, Pocket-10, Sector-11, Rohini, Delhi-85.

26. Smt. Meena Kain, D/o Late Sh. Swaran Singh, Working as Assistant Engineer, O/o ADG(E), R&D, AIR &DD, New Delhi. R/o 404, SFS, DDA Flats, Pocket-10, Sector-11, Rohini, Delhi-85.

27. Amarjit Singh Bajwa, S/o Sh. Sohan Singh Bajwa, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DG:AIR, P&D Unit, Sansad Marg, N.Delhi. R/o B-220, Kendriya Vihar, Sector-56, Gurgaon-122011 (Haryana).

28. Lalit Chander, S/o Sh. Thakur Dass, Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, Hamirpur (HP). R/o 405, Nayanagar, Ward No.8, Hamirpur-177001 (HP).

29. Tej Singh, S/o Sh. Yad Ram, Assistant Engineer (Retired), O/o ADG(E), R&D, AIR &DD, New Delhi. R/o F-13/24, Sector-15, Rohini, Delhi-110089.

30. Satish Kumar Bajaj, S/o Late Sh. R. N. Bajaj, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DG:AIR, P&D Unit, Sansad Marg, N.Delhi. R/o H. N. 1156, Sector-10A, Gurgaon-122001 (Haryana).

31. Vishwa Vimohan, S/o Late Sh. K. S. Kulshreshtha, Assistant Engineer (Retired), HPT, AIR, Kingsway, Delhi. R/o S-13, Vinayak Apartments, 762 Main Road Burari, Sant Nagar, Delhi-84. 32. C. Thyagarajan, S/o Sh. N. C. Subramaniam Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Chennai.

5

R/o Plot No.9, Balakrishnapuram, 1st Street, Adambakkam, Chennai-600088. 33. Sudhir Kumar Dhingra, S/o Sh. I. N. Dhingra,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), DG:AIR, P&D Unit, Sansad Marg, N.Delhi. R/o 431D, Wellington Estates, Dhokoli, Zirakpur-160104 (Punjab).

34. A. Thangaraj, S/o Sh. Andi Udaiar, Assistant Engineer (Retired), O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR &DD, Chennai. R/o G1-Seven Hills Residency, Ramakrishna Nagar, Kallukuzhi, Tiruchirappalli-620020 (Tamilnadu).

35. C. Rajendran, S/o Sh. R. Chellaiya, Working as Assistant Engineer, O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR & DD, Chennai. R/o 56/3, Aruna Flat, Kavarai Street, West Saidapet, Chennai-600015.

36. Smt. Rani Kalaimaran, W/o Sh. R. Kalaimaran, Working as Assistant Engineer, O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR & DD, Chennai. R/o 14, Rajiv Gandhi Street, Santhoshapuram, Chennai-600073.

37. A. Anuradha, D/o Sh. A. Suba Rao,

Working as Assistant Engineer, O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR & DD, Chennai. R/o 56/3, Aruna Flat, Kavarai Street, West Saidapet, Chennai-600015.

38. R. Alagarsamy, S/o Sh. K. Ramasamy, Working as Assistant Engineer, O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR & DD, Chennai. R/o 35/3, CPWD Quarters, Besant Nagar, Chennai-600090.

39. Smt. Usha Narayanan, W/o Sh. P. V. Narayanan,

Working as Assistant Engineer, O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR & DD, Chennai. R/o 109 (old No.45), 4th Main Road, Gandhi Nagar, Adyar, Chennai-600020.

40. Smt. R. Vasumathi, W/o Sh. R. Raghavan, Working as Assistant Engineer, O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR & DD, Chennai. R/o 40 (Old No.9), Flat No.7, Raja Street, Mandaveli Chennai-600028.

6

41. Smt. A. Mahalakshmi, W/o Sh. T. Shanmugaraju,

Working as Assistant Engineer, O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR & DD, Chennai. R/o 301, Block-I, Doshi Etiopia II, 3rd Panchayat Link Rd, Perungudi, Chennai-600096.

42. Smt. Chandrakala Ravindran, W/o Sh. G. Ravindran, Working as Assistant Engineer, O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR & DD, Chennai. R/o 19, Pandia Street, Swarnambigai Nagar, Virugambakkam, Chennai-600092.

43. P. Lajapathi, S/o Sh. S. Packiyanathan, Working as Assistant Engineer, O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR & DD, Chennai. R/o 2/22, Narayana Rajapuram, V. R. Pillai Street, Triplicane, Chennai-600005 (Tamilnadu).

44. A. Francis Xavier, S/o Sh. S. Arokiya Swamy, Working as Assistant Engineer, O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR & DD, Chennai. R/o 4B, Shri Krishna Apartments, No.7, V. K. Iyer road, Mandaiveli, Chennai-600028 (Tamilnadu).

45. G. Brahma Nayaki, S/o Sh. P. Ganesan, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR & DD, Chennai. R/o 17, Pallavan Nagar Ext, 1st Street, Maduravoyal, Chennai-600095.

46. Dhanam Ravi, S/o Sh. G. Ramanujam, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR & DD, Chennai. R/o D-6, Jawahar Flats, Karaneeswarar Kovil Street, Mylapure, Chennai-600004.

47. Smt. M. Chandralekha, W/o Sh. V. Muthu Raja, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR & DD, Chennai. R/o S-4, Bhoopathy Flats, 47, Kandasamy Street, Pallipet, Taramani, Chennai-600113.

48. A. Jerome, S/o Sh. V. Ambrose, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR & DD, Chennai. R/o 43, Bazaar Road, Karuppiah Pharmacy, Mylapure, Chennai-600004.

49. B. Shaji, S/o Sh. Basheer,

7

Working as Engineering Assistant, O/o ADG(E), South Zone, AIR & DD, Chennai. R/o 933, Dream Villa, Dharmasala, Kanul PO, Kannur-670562 (kerala).

50. Smt. Anita Vats, D/o Sh. H. S. Kaushik, Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Chennai (Tamilnadu). R/o 1930 (New No.4), Z-Block, 13th Cross Street, 5th Avenue, Anna Nagar (West), Chennai-600040.

51. Adya Prasad, S/o Sh. Sita Ram Sah,

Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Patna (Bihar). D/15, Phase-I, Akashvani Colony, Chhajjubagh, Patna-800001 (Bihar).

52. Jairam Prasad Bharti, S/o Late Sh. Rewat Mahto, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o Ratan Chudhary, Saket Nagar, Lohia Path, Jagdev Path, Patna-800014.

53. Sanjay Kumar Verma, S/o Late Sh. S. P. Verma, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o 201, Gangadarshan Appt, Gosala, Kurji, Patna -800010 (Bihar).

54. Ram Pravesh Singh, S/o Sh. R. B. Singh, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o Mahavirnagar, Road No.1, Saristabad, Patna-800002 (Bihar).

55. Ram Autar Chaudhary, S/o Late Sh. Bakhori Chaudhary, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o 302, Mahavir Enclave, Maurya Path, Khajpura, Patna-800014 (Bihar).

56. Pradeep Kr. Mallik, S/o Sh. R. B. Mallik, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o MIG-193, Kankarbagh, Lohianagar, Patna-800020 (Bihar).

57. Ashok Kr. Sinha, S/o Late Sh. B. N. Sinha, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Patna (Bihar).

8

R/o 10, Chandra Flat, New Punai Chak, Patna-800002 (Bihar).

58. Jagdish, S/o Late Sh. Ram Nath, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o C/o B. B. Singh, Adarsh Colony, Road No.3, Khemini Chowk, Patna (Bihar).

59. Suresh Kumar Singh, S/o Late Sh. R. L. Singh, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o 38, Block-C, Devasthali Apartment, North S. K. Puri, Patna-800013 (Bihar).

60. Deepak Prasad, S/o Sh. R. K. Gupta, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o Road No.8, Sanjay Gandhi Nagar, Hanuman Nagar, Patna (Bihar).

61. Himanshu Kumar, S/o Sh. Sadanand Prasad, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o C/o Sadanand Prasad, Power House Road, Begusarai-851101 (Bihar).

62. Rajeev Kumar Singh, S/o Sh. D. C. Singh,

Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o B-104, Sita Apartments, Near Shiv Mandir, Khajpura, Patna-800014 (Bihar).

63. Khalid Ahmad, S/o Late Sh. Wajahat Karim, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o 134, Grand Shiva Apartments, New Patliputra Colony, Patna-800013 (Bihar).

64. Rashid Jamal, S/o Late Mohd. Anis, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o C/o Late R. N. Singh, Sheikhpura, Shastri Nagar, Patna-800014 (Bihar).

65. Mohd. Nasim Ahmad, S/o Late Mohd. Nurul Hoda, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o 305, Sharf Apartments, Fraser Road, Patna-800001 (Bihar).

9

66. Ravindra Kumar, S/o Late Sh. S. N. Prasad Sinha,

Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o Parvati Kunj, Yarpur Rajputana, New Jakhanpur, Patna-800001 (Bihar).

67. Ashok Kumar, S/o Late Sh. H. L. Patwa, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o 404, Mahavir Enclave, Ambedkarpath, Khajpura, Patna-800014 (Bihar).

68. Nand Kumar Ram, S/o Late Sh. Prabhu Ram, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o Anand Villa, Gandhipuram, East Rupaspur, Jagdev Path, Patna (Bihar).

69. Shankar Sharma, S/o Late Sh. H. L. Sharma, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o MIG-360, Colony More, Kankarbagh, Patna-800020 (Bihar).

70. Bal Krishna Sahay, S/o Sh. H. N. Sahay, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o 201, Block-A, Sumit Enclave, Rupaspur, Bailey Road, Patna-801503 (Bihar).

71. Ram Kumar Prasad, S/o Late Sh. J. N. Prasad “Shashi”, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o Vishawavasini Niwas, Vidyapuri, Yogipur, Kankarbagh, Patna-800020 (Bihar).

72. Vidya Sagar Prasad Sinha, S/o R. P. Sinha, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o D-1, Phase-I, AIR Colony, Chhajjubag, Patna-800001 (Bihar).

73. Raj Kumar, S/o Late Sh. Pitambar Nath, Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o A-202, Kamla Apartments, Shanti Vihar, Baily Road, Patna-800014 (Bihar).

74. Anuj Pratap Singh, S/o Late Sh. S. B. Singh,

10

Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o Vill- Saraideoray, Post- Katragulab Singh, Pratapgarh-230146 (UP).

75. Arun Kumar Srivastava, S/o M. P. Srivastava, Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o 105, Sarbanand Apartments, Mazar Gali, Sheikhpura, Patna-800014 (Bihar).

76. Sharafat Ullah Ansari, S/o Sh. A. S. Ansari, Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o C/o Adv. Md. Kalam Ansari, UCO Bank Building, Raja Bazar, Baily Road, Patna-800014 (Bihar).

77. Anuj Kumar, S/o Sh. L. N. Singh, Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o C/o Kishor Kumar, Pragati Path, Kishan Colony-II, Anisabad, Patna (Bihar).

78. Ranjeet Kumar Ambasta, S/o Sh. S. K. Prasad,

Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o Indiranagar Road-2, Postal Park, Jakhanpur, Patna-800001 (Bihar).

79. Bindu Kumari, D/o Sh. K. P. Singh, Working as Engineering Assistant, DDK, Patna (Bihar). R/o Rajendra Nagar Road No. 13B, Patna-800016 (Bihar).

80. Arup Kumar Basu, S/o Late Sh. A. B. Basu, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Shantiniketan (WB). R/o 28/1, Chatterjee Para Lane, Post-Baidyabati, Hooghly-712222 (WB).

81. Sushil Chandra Deb, S/o Late Sh. R. K. Deb, Assistant Engineer (Retired), O/o ADG(E), East Zone, AIR & DD, Kolkata. R/o 33/1/A, B. M. Banerjee Road, Belgharia, Kolkata-700056 (WB).

82. Dipak Nath, S/o Late Sh. J. M. Nath, Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, Kolkata (WB).

11

R/o 71, Biren Roy Road, Kolkata-700061 (WB).

83. Kalyan Kumar Roy, S/o Sh. K. K. Roy, Assistant Engineer (Retired), HPT, Doordarshan, Kurseong (WB).

R/o 6/2-C, Naktala Road, Kolkata-700047 (WB).

84. Animesh Dasgupta, S/o Late Sh. A. M. Dasgupta, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Kolkata (WB). R/o Flat IIC, No. 4/5, Thakurpukur Phase-II Co-op. Housing Society Ltd, Kolkata-700104 (WB).

85. Samar Sadhan Mukherjee, S/o Late Sh. S. Mukherjee, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Kolkata (WB). R/o 294, Parvasree Pally, Uttarayan, Flat-2A, Kolkata-700060 (WB).

86. Jokh Narayan Singh, S/o Late Sh. Halkhori Lal, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, TVRC, Buxar (under DMC, Gaya), Bihar. R/o Mukteshwari Sadan, Maharaja Hata, Ram Motar Gali, Ara-802301 (Bihar).

87. Subodh Kumar Pal, S/o Late Sh. J. L. Pal, Working as Assistant Engineer, AIR, Ranchi (Jharkhand). R/o 23, Old Commissioner’s Compound, Ranchi-834001 (Jharkhand).

88. Marshall Purti, S/o Late Sh. Hardugan Purti, Working as Engineering Assistant, AIR, Daltonganj (Jharkhand). R/o Chetan Toly, Harmu, Post-Doranda, Ranchi-834002 (Jharkhand).

89. Jitendra Bahadur Singh Kushwaha, S/o Sh. R. B. S. Kushwaha, Working as Engineering Assistant, AIR, Daltonganj (Jharkhand). R/o C/o S. K. Sahu, Puran Vihar, Opp.- Road No.5, Ashok Nagar, Post-Doranda, Ranchi-834002 (Jharkhand).

90. P. V. Somadasan, S/o Sh. P. N. Vasudevan, Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, TVRC, Thalassery (under DMC, Kannur). R/o Puthuvelil, Vazhoor P.O., Kottayam-686504 (Kerala).

12

91. Rajendra Kumar Arora, S/o Late Sh. J. R. Arora

Working as Engineering Assistant, AIR, Hazaribag. R/o G3 & G4, Ganga-5, Trivenipuram, Post-Buty Basti, Ranchi-835217 (Jharkhand).

92. Paikas Kindo, S/o Late Sh. Juliyas Kindo, Working as Engineering Assistant, AIR, Hazaribag. R/o Upper Toli, Harmu, Ranchi (Jharkhand).

93. Sarita Kindo, D/o Late Sh. Alois Purty, Working as Engineering Assistant, AIR, Hazaribag. R/o Upper Toli, Harmu, Ranchi (Jharkhand).

94. Bhaskar Chandra Samantaray, S/o Late Sh. Nakaphudi Santarai,

Working as Senior Engineering Assistant, TVRC, Balasore (Orissa). R/o Gudipada, Balasore-756001 (Orissa).

95. Ram Krishna Swain, S/o Sh. Sarbeswar Swain, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Bhubaneswar (Orissa). R/o M-4/39, C/o P. K. Acharya, Acharjya Bihar, Bhubaneswar-751013 (Orissa).

96. Bijay Kr. Chahataray, S/o Late Sh. Raghunath Chahataray, Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, Berhampur (Orissa). R/o Mangala Nagar, 4th Line, Khurda-752055 (Orissa).

97. J. Chellan, S/o Sh. Joseph, Assistant Engineer (Retired), TVRC, Nagercoil (under DMC, Tirunelveli). R/o 32B, Antony Street, Christu Nagar, Vetturnimadam P.O., Nagercoil-3 (Tamilnadu)

98. Ashok Kumar, S/o Late Sh. Bhagwan Prasad, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Varanasi (UP). R/o N12-406A-230, Lane No.16, Sriram Nagar Colony, Lekhra, P.O.-Bajardiha, Varanasi-221109 (UP).

99. Kashi Nath Patel, S/o Late Sh. Bhaggu Ram,

13

Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Varanasi (UP). R/o SH-9/154, K-15, Sudhipur, Aschhar Dham Colony, Shivpur, Varanasi-221003 (UP).

100 . Ch. Janardana Rao, S/o Late Sh. Sankara Rao, Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Hyderabad (AP). R/o 2-2-58, Flat No. 508, Prashanthi Residency, Amberpet, Hyderabad-500013 (AP).

101 . M. J. Venkata Ramana, S/o Sh. M. Jayaram Naidu,

Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Gulbarga (AP). R/o B-1/4, Doordarshan Quarters, Humnabad Road, Gurbarga (AP).

102. Maya Shankar Pandey, S/o Late Sh. Mahatam Pandey,

Assistant Engineer (Retired), AIR, Varanasi (UP). R/o C-32/32A-1, Saraswati Nagar, Vidyapith Road, Varanasi-221002 (UP).

103. Indradeo Prasad Singh, S/o Late Sh. G. N. Singh, Assistant Engineer (Retired), TVRC, Buxar (Bihar). R/o Singh Colony, Bazar Samiti, Ara, District-Bhojpur (Bihar).

104. K. Rama Chandran, S/o Sh. K. Kesavan, Assistant Engineer (Retired), DDK, Trivandrum. R/o CRRA 14A, Nangachi Veettil, Chalakkuzhi Road, Pattom Palaca PO, Trivandrum-695004 (Kerala).

105. V. Sathish Babu, S/o Sh. G. Vasudevan, Assistant Engineer (Retired), TVRC, Changanacherry (under DMC, Adur).. R/o Sukumara, H. No. ARRA-42, Auittom Road, Kumarapuram, Trivandrum-695011 (Kerala).

106. Dukhi Shyam Behera, S/o Late Sh. H. H. Behera, Assistant Engineer (Retired), TVRC, Koraput (Orissa). R/o Matru Kutir, Side of District Hospital, Pujariput, Koraput-764020 (Orissa).

107. R. C. Panigrahi, S/o Late Sh. S. Panigrahi, Assistant Engineer (Retired), TVRC, Rayagada (Orissa).

14

R/o Goutam Nagar, 6th Line, Rayagada-765001 (Orissa).

108. Rajeev Arya, S/o Sh. Krishan Kumar, Working as Assistant Engineer, HPT, Doordarshan, Pitampura, Delhi. R/o B-5/254, Sector-8, Rohini, Delhi-110085.

109. Renu Girdhar, D/o Sh. D. V. Arora, Working as Assistant Engineer, HPT, Doordarshan, Pitampura, Delhi. R/o 26/21, West Patel Nagar, New Delhi-110008.

110. Kailash Kumar, S/o Sh. Mukandi lal, Working as Assistant Engineer, HPT, Doordarshan, Pitampura, Delhi.

R/o 72-D, Jhang Apartments, Sec-13, Rohini, Delhi-110085. 111. Virender Kumar Chaudhary, S/o Sh. R. C. Chaudhary,

Working as Assistant Engineer, HPT, Doordarshan, Pitampura, Delhi.

R/o A-31/2, Majlis Park, Delhi-110033. 112. P. K. Abdul Lateef, S/o Sh. P. Mohamed, Working as Assistant Engineer, TVRC, Malappuram (Kerala). R/o Ward No.12, House No.3, Mankada Road, Makkaraparamba-676507 (Kerala). 113. Tarkeshwar Rai, S/o Sh. Vishwa Nath Rai, Working as Engineering Assistant, TVRC, Gopalganj (under DMC, Motihari), Bihar. R/o 15, Himadri Apartment, West Boring Canal Road, Anandpuri, Patna-800001 (Bihar)

114. Malhar S. Chinchwade, S/o Sh. S. G. Chinchwade,

Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Pune (Mh).

R/o 21/39, S. No.60/2, Bijalinagar, Chinchwad, Pune-411033 (Mh). 115. Shrikrishna Waman Marathe, S/o Waman,

Working as Assistant Engineer, DDK, Pune (Mh). R/o 2/15, Mukund Nagar, Pune-411037 (Mh).

15

116. Sunil Kumar Nandy, S/o Sh. S. C. Nandy, Assistant Engineer (Retired),

O/o ADG(E), West Zone, AIR & DD, Mumbai. R/o Flat No.53, Building No.2, Om Trimurti CHS, Eastern Express Highway, Sion (East), Chunabhatti, Mumbai-400022 (Mh). ----- APPLICANTS

(By Advocate : Shri Yogesh Sharma)

Versus

1. Union of India , through the Secretary, Ministry of Information & Broadcasting, Govt. of India, Shastri Bhawan, Dr. R. P. Marg, New Delhi-110001.

2. Prasar Bharati (Broadcasting Corp. of India),

Through Chief Executive Officer, PTI Building, Sansad Marg, New Delhi-110001.

3. Director General, Akashvani, Akashvani Bhawan, Sansad Marg, New Delhi-110001.

4. Director General, Doordarshan, Doordarshan Bhawan Wing-A, Copernicus Marg, New Delhi-110001. ----- RESPONDENTS

(By Advocate : Shri S. M. Arif)

: O R D E R (ORAL) : Justice L. Narasimha Reddy, Chairman:

The only relief claimed in this OA is that the applicants be extended

the relief in terms of order dated 07.09.2009 passed by the CAT, Patna Bench

of this Tribunal in OA No.514/2002.

2. In all fairness, learned counsel for the applicants submitted that during

the pendency of this OA, the respondents considered the cases of the

16

applicants in terms of the order of CAT Patna Bench in OA No.514/2002, and

passed an order dated 13.10.2015 declining the relief.

3. In view of this development, the OA is disposed of, leaving it open to

the applicants to work out the remedies vis-a-vis the order dated 13.10.2015.

There shall be no order as to costs.

(Praveen Mahajan) (Justice L. Narasimha Reddy) Member (A) Chairman /pj/