Upload
others
View
9
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC® Part ❶
Financial Skills
Chapter 1: Financial Ratios
Chapter 2: Cash Flow Analysis
Chapter 3: Lease vs. Buy Equipment Analysis
Notice
The topics mentioned in this book are considered to be basics and a starting point, as the candidate is supposed to expand
his research and reading these topics from the available sources via the internet and others, where the questions were
developed in a way that aims to exam the understanding of applicant to the subject.
The exam for this section includes 50 questions that vary between multiple choice questions (4 options) and true / false
questions.
The full period of the exam for the 50 questions is an hour and 15 minutes only, during which the applicant can move
between questions, meaning that there is no commitment to a specific time for one question.
The system will automatically end the exam at the end of the period (an hour and 15 minutes) and calculate the questions
that have been answered. And questions that have not been answered, the system will calculate them as questions that
were answered incorrectly.
Please pay attention to the time counter on the exam page, and it is advised to answer all questions even if there are
questions that have not been confirmed.
If you weren’t successful in this exam, it’s not considered the end of the world. You can re-apply the exam at any time after
re-studying and understanding your subject.
With our best wishes for all to success
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
2 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Contents Chapter 1: Financial Ratios .................................................................................................................. 3
Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 3
Interpreting Key Financial Ratios ......................................................................................................... 4
Purpose and Types of Key Financial ratios ............................................................................................ 5
Solvency Ratios .................................................................................................................................. 6
Profitability Ratios .............................................................................................................................. 7
Performing Ratios ............................................................................................................................ 10
Investment Ratios ............................................................................................................................ 13
Chapter 2: Cash Flow Analysis ........................................................................................................... 17
Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 17
Cash Flow Definition ......................................................................................................................... 18
Importance of Managing working Capital ........................................................................................... 18
Cash Flow Forecast ........................................................................................................................... 22
Cash Flow Statement ........................................................................................................................ 23
Understanding the Changes in Cash ................................................................................................... 25
Direct Format Cash Flow Statement ................................................................................................... 26
Indirect Format Cash Flow Statement ................................................................................................ 28
Adjustments .................................................................................................................................... 30
Cash for Investing ............................................................................................................................. 32
Capital Expenditures ......................................................................................................................... 33
Short-Term Investments Sold ............................................................................................................ 33
Cash from Financing ......................................................................................................................... 34
Chapter 3: Lease vs. Buy Equipment Analysis ...................................................................................... 35
Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 35
What Is a Lease? .............................................................................................................................. 35
Types of Leases ................................................................................................................................ 35
Kinds of Lessors ............................................................................................................................... 36
Advantages of Leasing ...................................................................................................................... 36
Disadvantages of Leasing .................................................................................................................. 37
Accounting Treatment of Leases ........................................................................................................ 37
Cost Analysis of Lease v. Loan/Purchase ............................................................................................. 37
Look Before You Lease ...................................................................................................................... 39
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
3 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Chapter 1: Financial Ratios
Introduction
The ability to evaluate the financial position of the organization is a valuable skill for any manager to have,
whether you are choosing a supplier, considering a strategic partnership, or trying to work out how much
credit to extend to a customer. Many organizations can appear successful despite deep structural
problems with the way they are financed and managed. Just think for a moment about the consequences
of working with a supplier or partner organization who goes bust, or who, despite appearing credible,
never seems able to deliver on their promises because of hidden financial problems within their own
organization.
Very few managers take the time and trouble to learn how to make a simple financial assessment of
another organization, even though doing so is straightforward and the necessary information can usually
be obtained online either free of charge or for only a few dollars.
This eBook explains the tools used to assess the financial performance of an organization. These are known
as ‘key financial ratios’ and they help you interpret financial information in a way that can aid you in
making the right decisions when choosing who to work with or sell to. This information can also give you
valuable insight into how well an organization is managed at the highest level.
A key financial ratio is calculated by comparing certain values taken from an organization’s financial
statements, including the income statement, balance sheet, and cash flow statement.
Generally, financial ratios are not useful unless they are benchmarked against something else, for example
past performance or another organization in the same business area. Whilst you can compare the ratios of
organizations in different industries, this is usually of limited value because of differences in market
conditions, capital requirements, and competition.
Key financial ratios allow for useful comparisons between:
Organizations in the same industry sector
Different time periods for the same organization
An organization and its industry average
Comparing ratios for different industries can be interesting from a purely academic point of view or can
help with investment decisions, but is of limited use to you as a manager. However, comparing ratios for
potential suppliers, partners, acquisitions, or competitors can provide you with useful data to help with
decision making.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
4 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Interpreting Key Financial Ratios
Key financial ratios may not be directly comparable between organizations that use different accounting
methods. Most public organizations are required by law to use generally accepted accounting principles for
their home countries, but private organizations, partnerships, and sole proprietorships generally have
more freedom in reporting their accounts.
Before you start your calculations you will need to make sure that the accounting treatments are the same
when making comparisons. This is not only between the organizations you wish to compare but also for
each year you wish to compare. For example, an organization may change policy and decide to capitalize
research and development, holding it in the balance sheet as having a long-term value or it may consider
development costs as overheads as soon as they are incurred.
Either treatment is perfectly reasonable, but comparing figures that have been arrived at in these two
different ways would be pointless.
When you need to make comparisons with global organizations it is important to re- member that there is
no international standard. How an organization calculates the summary data presented in all financial
statements, as well as the terminology used, is not always consistent between organizations, industries,
countries, and time periods.
If you are trying to make global comparisons then you need to appreciate how operational differences
within each industry or country can impact the validity of such a comparison. These differences include
such things as seasonal conditions and traditional industry practices.
Ensure your investigation in this area is thorough; as such operational differences are so predictable that
people in these industries take them as read and rarely mention them. If you remain ignorant of such
issues then your ratios will give you misleading information.
For example:
If you were investigating the European car industry then you would need to be aware that in the United
Kingdom new vehicle sales peak in March and September. In fact, there are typically five times as many
cars sold in March as in the previous month. If you did not allow for this, because you were not aware of
the operational practices of the UK automotive industry, then some of your calculations could be
meaningless.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
5 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Purpose and Types of Key Financial ratios
There are several different key financial ratios and they are categorized according to the financial
characteristic they measure. These are:
Solvency
Profitability
Performance
Investment
Solvency
An organization is considered to be solvent when it can pay its debts as they fall due. In day-to-day terms,
this means that an organization has enough working capital to pay its suppliers.
Profitability
These ratios measure the organization’s use of its assets and control of its expenses to generate an
acceptable rate of return. You can see if an organization is profitable simply by looking at an income
statement, but you need to put that profit into perspective.
To do this you need to ask yourself:
Is the profit growth in proportion to the size of the organization?
Is the organization making as much profit on new sales as on existing sales?
Is the organization as profitable as others in the same sector?
Performance
Is the organization making the sort of profit that it has in the past or that others in the same sector are
making? By looking at individual parts of the organization you can gain more insight into their profitability
and efficiency.
Investment
These ratios measure investor response to owning an organization’s stock and also the cost of issuing
stock. They are concerned with the return on investment for shareholders, and with the relationship
between return and the value of an investment in an organization’s shares.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
6 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Solvency Ratios There are two key ratios that can help you to determine whether an organization is a solvent:
Current Ratio
The current ratio looks at the relationship between current assets and current liabilities. The word ‘current’
implies short-term assets or liabilities, which are payable or receivable within one year.
These figures are always shown on the balance sheet. To calculate this ratio you would divide current
assets by current liabilities.
Example:
This ratio of 2:1 would be considered a healthy result as it shows that the organization has sufficient
current assets to pay its current liabilities as soon as they are due.
Quick Ratio
The quick ratio, or acid test ratio, measures liquidity more precisely than the current ratio. It does not
include the value of stock within current assets because turning stock into cash takes time since payment
terms are usually anything between 30 and 90 days.
You can calculate the quick ratio by dividing current assets (excluding stock) by current liabilities. You can
find the stock or inventory figure on the balance sheet.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
7 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Example:
This example shows that an apparently healthy level of current assets might hide the fact that a large
proportion of the current assets is made up of stock. Whilst this can usually be turned into cash, it will take
time and to do it quickly might require heavy discounting.
When you need to review the liquidity of an organization, it is common practice to calculate both the
current ratio and quick ratio. This is so that you are aware of the extent to which stock held influences its
current assets. These calculations will quickly show you if the level of stock an organization holds is too
great and also whether it matches your expectations of the industry.
You must always be careful when drawing conclusions from these ratios. It is quite possible that an
organization may appear to be desperately short of working capital, but if it sells goods for cash and
purchases with a long credit line, then it may be that it is being very well managed.
It is vital that you understand what the organization actually does and the industry it operates in before you
draw any conclusions from these ratios.
Profitability Ratios You can see if an organization is profitable by looking at the income statement, but you need to put that
profit into perspective. This can be done by looking at various ratios that compare profit as a percentage of
sales or assets.
There are three ways this can be achieved:
Gross profit margin
Net profit margin
Return on assets
Gross Profit Margin
One of the most commonly used ratios is the gross profit margin, which looks at a gross profit as a
percentage of turnover (sales). You will find both of these figures in the income statement.
Example:
The formula used is gross profit divided
QUICK
RATIO
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
8 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
by turnover, multiplied by a hundred to turn it into a percentage.
Many people are often confused by the terms ‘gross profit margin’ and ‘mark-up.’ The definition of each
term shows how they differ and also shows that you use a different formula to arrive at a figure for each.
Gross profit margin: expresses gross profit as a percentage of total sales.
Mark-up: is the figure or percentage added by management to cover the cost of goods and the
required profit margin for a product or service.
From these definitions, you can see that the key difference is that management has control over and
define what they require as a mark-up, whereas gross profit is dependent on how many sales are made
and their value, which management can set targets for, but cannot control directly.
Industries often have what is considered an acceptable range for their mark-up, without which an
organization would not be able to operate. You should investigate whether the sector you are interested in
has such a range.
The formula for calculating mark-up is:
Mark-up = (total revenue - cost of sales) / cost of sales
This is then multiplied by 100 to give a percentage.
Net Profit Margin
This ratio is similar to the gross profit margin but looks at a net profit as a percentage of turnover. Net
profit is shown on the income statement and is defined as follows:
Net profit is the figure left after all operating and non-operating expenses have been deducted from total
revenue or income.
To calculate the net profit margin of an organization as a percentage you would divide net profit by total
revenue or income and multiply the answer by a hundred to turn it into a percentage.
Example:
You need to be mindful that your net profit is calculated after taking account of all costs and therefore can
be affected by a variety of things, such as:
Declining gross profit
Increased selling
Rising administration costs
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
9 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
If your net profit percentage is declining it is worth looking at your costs on an individual basis to see what
you can do about those that have increased the most as a proportion of sales.
It is important to look at the trend that emerges over several accounting periods, as opposed to individual
figures. The ratios can be used to measure periods other than a full year, as long as you have the relevant
income statements.
Return on Assets
You can also measure the level of profit compared to the value of net assets invested in an organization.
The assets are the major items that need to be in place for the organization to operate. These include such
items as:
Fixed assets ….. (Buildings, Vehicles, Computers, etc.)
Current assets ….. (Stock, Debtors, Cash)
The organization’s total net assets are calculated by taking total liabilities from the total assets. This
represents the amount of capital invested in the organization. Your net assets figure can be taken directly
from the balance sheet. You can, therefore, look at the net profit as a percentage of capital employed.
The return that an organization can expect depends on the industry sector and the economic cycle.
However, it remains a good measure of operational efficiency for an organization.
The ratio is calculated by dividing net assets by net profit and then multiplying it by a hundred to turn it
into a percentage, as this is the usual way it is expressed.
Capital employed is the net amount invested in the organization by its investors or owners and is taken
from the balance sheet. Many people consider this the most important ratio overall and it is useful to
compare the results with a return that can be obtained outside of the organization. The organization’s
return on assets can be improved either by increasing profitability or decreasing the capital employed.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
10 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Performing Ratios There are several ratios that you can use to measure how an organization is performing in terms of both
profitability and efficiency.
The ratios for measuring performance are:
Gearing
Number of days credit granted
Number of days credits taken
Stock turnover
Overheads as a percentage of turnover
Gearing
This ratio looks at total borrowings divided by net worth of the business. Ideally, the equity should be
significantly higher than debt.
If an organization’s net worth was $60,000 and the borrowings came to $20,000 (made up of a bank loan
and overdraft), then the borrowing ratio would be 1:3. In this example the equity is higher than its debt,
but to understand the implications of this you would need to look at the expected gearing figure within the
industry.
The purpose of this ratio is to compare the finance provided by lenders with the finance invested by
shareholders. Generally speaking, banks do not like to see the amount of debt exceed the amount of
equity. The ratio is usually expressed as a proportion (as in 1 to 1), although it can sometimes appear as a
percentage. Gearing is said to be high when borrowing is high in relation to equity.
Number of Days Credit Granted
This ratio is used to measure the effectiveness of an organization’s debt collection. It sets out the
relationship between debtors and the sales that have been made on credit and also shows how quickly
customers are paying their invoices.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
11 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
The calculation for this ratio is trade debtors (this figure is taken from the balance sheet) divided by annual
sales and then multiplied by 365 days. This ratio gives a rather broad- brush calculation.
If you wanted to use a more detailed calculation you would look at how many days’ turn- over it took to
make up the debtor total.
Example:
Current debtors = $50,000
Sales in current month = $30,000
Sales in previous month = $40,000
The current debtors ($50,000) therefore represent all of the current month’s sales ($30,000) and half of
the previous month’s sales ($20,000).
Therefore the number of debtor days in this example is calculated by adding debtor days from the current
month (31 days) and the previous month (30 days).
Current month has 31 days
Balance from previous month: $20k ÷ $40k x 30 days = 15 days
Total debtor days = 31 days + 15 days = 46 days
If this figure began to increase you would need to look carefully at the debt collection routines of the
organization. The sort of queries you would want to be answered are:
Are customers taking longer to pay?
Are a few customers building up a large debt?
Either of these factors may give cause for concern because the older a debt becomes, the more likely it is
to go bad.
Number of Days Credit Taken
This ratio sets out the number of days the organization takes to pay its suppliers. This is arguably less
important than the ‘debtor day’ figure, as in this case, the control over the payment of suppliers is in the
organization’s own hands.
When assessing another organization—for example, one that is asking you for increased credit—this ratio
can give a useful pointer as to whether the organization is operating within the accepted norms of the
industry and (using historic data) whether or not it is taking increasingly longer to pay people.
This ratio is calculated by dividing the figure for trade creditors by the annual purchases and then
multiplying this answer by 365 days. The figure for trade creditors normally comes from the closing balance
sheet and care should be taken that it is typical for the whole year.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
12 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
These calculations give a profile of the organization to potential suppliers looking for details about how
efficiently the business is being run.
Stock Turnover
This ratio looks at how quickly the organization turns over stock into sales and is, therefore, another good
measure of efficiency. The higher the stock turned the more efficiently the business is being run. It is
important that the terms are completely understood and there are no abnormal factors. Normally the
definition of stock includes all of the following:
Finished goods
Work in process
Raw materials.
The stock value would usually be taken from the closing balance sheet but you need to consider if it is a
typical figure. For example, an organization involved in the retail industry may have a seasonal influence on
its operations so you may need to make allowance for this.
The stock turnover ratio is calculated by dividing the cost of goods sold by the stock value. For example:
A quick turnover suggests that the organization is efficient in holding the minimum stock used within its
operation. Again, this ratio is most informative when looked at over time. If the stock turn is slowing, this
may highlight a problem with slow-moving lines that require discounting to sell through.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
13 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Operating Expenses as a Percentage of Turnover
Examples of operating expenses are:
Rent
Utility bills
Wages, etc.
This is a useful tool in assessing whether or not this area of expense is growing more rapidly than the
turnover. This ratio is calculated by dividing operating expenses (overheads) by turnover and then
multiplying by a hundred to make the figure into a percentage.
The calculation has little meaning on its own, but when reviewed over several periods it can provide useful
information on the trend over that time span.
As an organization grows this percentage should fall. If it doesn’t, then the organization needs to review its
operating expenses carefully to understand why this is happening and see what management can do to
correct it.
Investment Ratios The accounting ratios that focus on the investment potential an organization offers include:
Price/earnings ratio
Price-to-book ratio (P/B)
PEG (price/earnings to growth) ratio
Dividend yield
These ratios are most useful when the data behind them is from regularly produced management
accounts. They are concerned with the return on investment for shareholders, and with the relationship
between return and the value of an investment in a company’s shares.
These figures are a constant focus of senior management’s attention, which is a good reason for
understanding how they are derived and what they mean.
Price/Earnings (P/E) Ratio
This is one of the most helpful of the investment ratios and is often abbreviated to P/E ratio. It can be used
to compare an organization to:
Other organizations
Industry sector
Overall market
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
14 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
This ability to make such comparisons is one of the reasons it is widely used by management. It also offers
the flexibility to use either quarterly or annual data.
In commercial organizations, a significant proportion of management personnel receive stock or options on
the stock as part of their benefits package and this drives their personal interest in the P/E ratio. The belief
is that by aligning the interests of management with the interests of other stockholders the former are
more committed to the organization.
A P/E ratio can be thought of as how long a stock will take to pay back the investment if there is no change
in the business. Whilst stock can go up in value without significant earnings increases, it is the P/E ratio
that decides if it can stay up. Without earnings to back up the price, a stock will eventually fall back in
value.
The P/E ratio can be calculated by dividing the current share (stock) price by the earnings per share (often
referred to as EPS) for the previous 12 months
There are key issues that must be acknowledged when using a P/E ratio and they are that this ratio:
Uses historic earnings. This is because of the nature of how EPS is calculated using the previous 12-
month earnings. (In most cases, the four most recent reported quarterly net earnings per share are
totaled.)
Only provides a snapshot based on the current share price. The very nature of stocks means that their
value is constantly fluctuating. (P/E ratio rises with share price and vice versa.)
The Price-to-Book (P/B) Ratio
The price-to-book (P/B) ratio represents the value of the company if it is broken up and sold. The book
value usually includes equipment, buildings, land, and anything else that can be sold, including stock
holdings and bonds.
To calculate this ratio the market price of an organization’s shares (share price) is divided by its book value
of equity. The latter is also known as the ‘price-equity ratio’ and is found on the balance sheet by
subtracting the book value of liabilities from the book value of assets.
Where an organization has a very high share price relative to its asset value it is likely that it has been
earning a very high return on its assets.
You may also find instances where an organization is trading for less than its book value (P/B <1) and this
tells an investor that either:
The asset value is overstated—meaning there is a chance that the asset value will face a downward
correction by the market, leaving investors with negative returns.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
15 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Return on assets is genuinely poor—indicating that new management or a new operating environment will
prompt a turnaround in prospects and give strong positive returns.
The P/B ratio is really only useful when you are looking at capital-intensive businesses or financial
businesses with plenty of assets on the books.
It is not meaningful for service-based organizations because due to accounting rules intangible assets such
as intellectual property (brand name, goodwill, patents, and trademarks) are ignored in calculating the
book value of equity.
The PEG (Price/Earnings to Growth) Ratio
This ratio illustrates the relationship between stock price, earning per share, and an organization’s
expected growth rate. This ratio is often used in management discussions, especially those where strategic
growth is being considered.
PEG is a widely used indicator of a stock’s potential value. Many people favor it over the price/earnings
ratio because it also accounts for growth. Similar to the P/E ratio, a lower PEG means that the stock is more
undervalued.
The PEG ratio is calculated by dividing the Price to Earnings (P/E) ratio by an organization’s annual EPS
(Earnings per Share) growth. The growth rate is expressed as a percentage and should use real growth
only, to correct for inflation.
It is assumed that by dividing the P/E ratio by the earnings growth rate, the resulting ratio is better for
comparing companies with different growth rates.
In general, the P/E ratio is higher for a company with a higher growth rate. Using just the P/E ratio would
make high-growth companies appear overvalued relative to others and this is why the PEG ratio is more
widely used.
A lower ratio is cheaper and a higher ratio is more expensive. For example, it is considered that an
organization with:
PEG < 1 is undervalued
PEG around 1 is fairly valued
PEG > 1 is overvalued.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
16 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Dividend Yield
The dividend yield is used to calculate the earnings on investment (shares) considering only the returns in
the form of total dividends declared by an organization during the year. By dividing the stock’s annual
dividend by the stock’s price and multiplying by a hundred, you get a percentage.
You can think of that percentage as the interest on your money, with the additional chance at growth
through the appreciation of the stock.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
17 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Chapter 2: Cash Flow Analysis
Introduction
Cash flow is simply the flow of cash through the organization over time. In the case of businesses that are
run for profit, cash is paid out in return for the labor and materials that are used to provide goods and
services that can be sold. The revenues received provide cash that can then be used to finance further
production and sales as well as increasing the organization’s economic value.
Cash flows are also essential for nonprofit organizations such as charities, schools, and hospitals that need
to meet the various ongoing expenses associated with providing their services.
As a manager, you need to understand how cash flows are generated and what factors impact those flows.
This knowledge is an integral part of making financial decisions that increase a firm’s economic value or the
capabilities of a nonprofit organization.
The management of cash flow is one part of a larger management responsibility known as the
management of working capital, which refers to the operating liquidity available to an organization.
An organization can have assets and profitability, but find itself short of liquidity if its assets cannot readily
be converted into cash.
Working capital is required to ensure that the organization is able to continue its operations and that it has
sufficient funds to satisfy operating expenses and any maturing short-term debt. The management of
working capital involves managing the four following aspects of an organization’s operations:
Inventories (stock, work-in-progress and finished goods)
Accounts receivable (debts that are owed to the organization)
Accounts payable (money the organization owes to its suppliers)
Cash
Effective management of working capital will increase the profitability of the organization. It also enables
managers to concentrate on their jobs without worrying too much about the potential for insolvency.
It can also reduce the amount of capital needed to run the enterprise, so even if you work in the nonprofit
sector it is still an important consideration.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
18 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Cash Flow Definition
Cash flow is a generic term that can be used differently depending on the context. It can refer to actual
past flows or projected future flows. It can refer to the total of all flows involved or a subset of them - for
example, net cash flow, operating cash flow, and free cash flow.
These terms will be defined later, but for now, we will concern ourselves only with actual cash flows for a
period of time in the past. It is important to define what is meant by ‘cash’:
Cash includes all of the money that the organization has in bank accounts and short-term investments that
can quickly be turned into available cash.
It is common for a balance sheet to show only a tiny amount for cash because businesses often operate
with an overdraft and only petty cash is included.
Importance of Managing working Capital
Many organizations that fail are profitable at the time, and
their demise often comes as a surprise to managers and staff
who can see that there are a full order book and plenty of
satisfied customers. In these circumstances, the reason for the
failure is usually down to a shortage of working capital.
This shortage of working capital can cause a company to not be able to pay its workers or suppliers even
though there are sufficient sales and profits. Even in cases where these short-term liabilities can be met,
the deterioration of cash flow critically undermines a company’s ability to reinvest in the business and,
ultimately, to survive.
The four factors that affect the amount of working capital available within an organization are:
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
19 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
WAYS TO MINIMIZE DEBT
NOTE: goods or service have
been received
Focus on largest debts first
Agree payment terms in advance
Ask for payment early & often
Give high priority to credit control
Prompt sending out of invoices
etc.
Resolve queries quickly
Have comprehensive credit policies
The management role that you perform may only influence one of these areas directly, but having a clear
understanding of them all will give you an insight into how well your organization controls its working
capital, and by extension how well it is managed financially.
Debtors
These are entities that owe your organization money. Many organizations have problems caused by the
slow payment of invoices and this, in turn, affects working capital and, in particular, and liquidity.
Chasing up unpaid invoices can be very time consuming and there is a fine line between maintaining a
good working relationship with your customers and upsetting them by demanding payment too
aggressively.
Whatever your organization’s policy is in the area of debt collection you will need to set expectations
appropriately with customers and be polite but assertive in following through with requests for payment.
This is a key area you need to monitor closely to ensure problem payers are identified as soon as possible.
There are some things you as a manager may be able to do to help:
Make sure that the payment terms are agreed in advance
Send out invoices and statements promptly
Deal with queries quickly and efficiently
Ask early and ask often, preferably by telephone
Remember you are only asking for something that has been previously agreed
Give credit control the highest status and priority
Have comprehensive credit policies
Concentrate on the biggest debts first
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
20 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Inventory/Stock
Your aim should always be to keep stock as low as realistically possible and to achieve a high rate of stock
turnover. In this way, you are minimizing the impact on your organization’s working capital. In theory, this
is ideal to work towards, but in practice, it is more difficult to achieve because you have to meet the
commitments you have given to customers.
There are three components to what accountants refer to as inventory:
Raw materials—these are the materials required to produce goods.
Work in process (WIP)—includes partly finished goods and those raw materials and components
already committed to production.
Finished goods—are all those goods ready to be sold.
Many large and successful manufacturing companies use the just-in-time technique of arranging deliveries
from suppliers frequently and in small quantities. This is not easy to achieve and can cause problems if just
one vital component is missing when it is required.
Many organizations have sophisticated stock control systems, which keep track of stock levels. Once a pre-
determined level of stock is reached, an order is automatically generated so that items are never entirely
out of stock. In this way, minimum levels of stocks are held and supply is replenished often overnight.
Creditors
Many organizations adopt a policy of delaying the payment of suppliers as long as possible. There is an
obvious advantage in adopting such a policy as the purchaser is effectively getting an interest-free loan
from the supplier.
If your organization adopts this policy then your cash balance will be higher than would otherwise be the
case even though slow payments do not affect the net balance of working capital. However, there are also
some disadvantages in a policy of slow payment:
Suppliers will be reluctant to give discounts
They may treat you as a problem customer and make all of your requests the lowest priority
If you are always a slow payer there will be less scope for taking longer to pay in response to a crisis
Within your industry you will quickly gain a reputation as a poor payer and many suppliers may refuse
to work with you, making it hard to change suppliers if the need arises.
For these reasons, it is often unwise to adopt a consistent policy of slow payment, at least with important
suppliers. It is often better to take only a few days longer than the deadline stipulated in the contract and
to ensure that this is rewarded with keen prices, timely service, and prompt payment discounts.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
21 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
If your organization is relatively small you may be able to obtain the same price as your larger competitors
by agreeing with an immediate payment plan with the supplier. This is because many large corporations
use their extensive purchasing power to justify paying suppliers after an unreasonably long time.
This sort of policy can leave many manufacturers and suppliers with serious cash flow problems. In these
circumstances, many suppliers are prepared to offer the maximum possible discount in exchange for
guaranteed quick payments, irrespective of the size of the order.
Cash
It is quite common for an organization to be profitable but short of cash. There are several reasons why
this can happen:
An expanding organization will have to spend money on materials (items for sale and salaries) before it
completes sales and gets paid. It is a fact of business life that purchases and expenses usually come
before sales and profits.
Capital expenditure, in the form of buying equipment, has an immediate impact on the cash available.
Even if the equipment is bought on credit, the monthly payments may exceed the monthly
depreciation figure.
Sales taxes and taxes on profit can both take cash out of an organization and can- not normally be
deferred without incurring a penalty of some sort.
Money may be collected from customers more slowly than expected. This often happens when
salespeople are motivated to bring in revenue but have no responsibility for, or interest in, enforcing
the payment terms.
To avoid your organization becoming ‘cash insolvent,’ it is essential that you and all the company’s
managers accurately forecast and monitor their area’s cash receipts and payments.
As a manager, you need to plan for the known costs and to allow some contingency for unanticipated
problems, e.g. late payment by a customer or a supplier withholding raw materials until payment has been
processed.
This type of planning is usually referred to as a cash flow forecast and should be part of your overall
budgeting management process.
As you plan and prepare your cash flow forecast it will highlight areas where improvements or savings can
be made. It also has the additional benefit of identifying potential problem areas.
For example, the figures for cash payments from trade debtors will be based on an estimate of the average
number of days’ credit that will be taken. This will pose the question of whether or not payments can be
speeded up
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
22 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Cash Flow Forecast Includes
known costs
Plus an allocation for
unexpected costs
Your contingency plans could involve deferring an investment for a few weeks or negotiating an additional
overdraft with the bank. Either way, a well-planned cash flow forecast document helps you to be proactive
and to avoid the crises that usually result from running out of cash.
Cash Flow Forecast
There are two completely different
accounting documents that have the
words ‘cash flow’ in the title and it is
important to avoid confusing the two
of them. These documents are a ‘cash
flow forecast’ and a ‘cash flow
statement.’ A cash flow forecast,
which has already been mentioned, is
an internal document produced on an
ad hoc basis to help with budgeting. In contrast, a cash flow statement is one of the principal financial
reports that an organization publishes each year in accordance with international accounting standards.
As a manager, you may be asked to produce a cash flow forecast to show your known and anticipated cash
expenditure for some future period of time, usually the next budgetary period or the remainder of the
current one. You will usually be expected to add an element of contingency into your cash flow forecast to
cater for any unexpected costs that may arise.
This forecast is an important aspect of your planning and is an essential part of budgeting as it helps you to
identify potential areas where a lack of cash may become an issue. It also offers you the opportunity to
review and where necessary amend your planned expenditure.
Regular monitoring and reviewing of your cash flow forecast are essential because you never know when
your budget may be threatened or cut. You will be able to protect your original budget better if you
already have arguments for why your budget should not be affected and exactly what the consequences
will be if it is.
The better prepared you are, the more protected your budget will be in such circumstances. It also enables
you to communicate accurately and objectively to senior management of the consequences of any
budgetary changes.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
23 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Cash Flow Statement
In order for a set of financial statements to be complete, the accounting profession includes a cash flow
statement. Like all other financial statements, it has to adhere to accepted accounting principles.
The cash flow statement goes beyond what you include in your regular reports showing what cash has
come in and what cash went out.
A Cash Flow statement is a reconciliation of the differences between the:
Accrual basis balance sheet and
Income statement and
Cash flow.
This statement uses historic data and is usually dated at the end of an organization’s financial year. In
simple terms it shows how the final cash balance occurred, how much money flowed in and from where
and how much went out and why.
The cash flow statement reflects a firm’s liquidity. It includes only inflows and outflows of cash and
excludes transactions that do not directly affect cash receipts and payments. Being a cash basis report,
these financial statement details three types of financial activities: operating activities, investing activities,
and financing activities.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
24 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
This statement is extremely valuable to management and investors because it is intended to:
Provide information on an organization’s liquidity and solvency and its ability to change cash flows in
future circumstances.
Provide additional information for evaluating changes in assets, liabilities, and equity.
Improve the comparability of different organizations’ operating performance by eliminating the effects
of different accounting methods.
Indicate the amount, timing, and probability of future cash flows.
The valuable information and data a cash flow statement provides ensure it plays a key role in an
organization’s decision making. This is why it is essential for managers to have an appreciation of how it is
compiled and how to interpret it.
The cash flow statement has been adopted as a standard financial report because it eliminates some of the
problems that occur when trying to compare accounts that have been prepared using different accounting
methods, such as various timeframes for depreciating fixed assets.
It is this compilation and integration of facts that draw savvy managers and investors to utilize this often
overlooked financial statement. It is important to remember that all the figures in a cash flow statement
can be found somewhere in the income statement, balance sheet, statement of shareholders equity, or
anyone of the financial statement notes provided.
If you looked at an income statement prepared using the accrual basis of accounting you could see a figure
for reported revenues, but you would not know if they have been collected yet. Similarly, the expenses
reported on the income statement might or might not have been paid.
Alternatively, you could review the balance sheet changes to determine the facts, but the cash flow
statement has already integrated all that information.
There are many ways you can utilize the information a cash flow statement presents. For example, if an
organization’s cash generated from operations is consistently above its net income or earnings they are
referred to as ‘high quality.’ In circumstances where the opposite is true then the organization’s earnings
have a ‘red flag’ raised against them. This informs anyone looking into the organization that they need to
investigate further why its reported earnings are not turning into cash.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
25 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Where an organization consistently generates cash in excess of what it needs on a day-to-day basis, it has
the ability to offer its investors a higher dividend or buy back some of its own shares. Such an organization
is considered to have ‘good stockholder value’ by investors. This is not the only option and they may
choose to use this excess cash to reduce debt or acquire another organization. In the case of nonprofit
organizations, a positive cash flow allows them to expand their operations and offer additional or
improved services.
Understanding the Changes in Cash
The way in which the ‘cash account’ is used in published accounts is to some extent counter-intuitive. To
help you understand it we will use an example for a fictitious company.
The following is a statement showing the balance of the cash account for Gary’s Garden Furniture business
in the first two months of trading.
From this table you can see that for a change in:
Assets (other than cash)—the change in the cash account is in the opposite direction.
Liabilities and owner’s equity—the change in the cash account is in the same direction.
The following table provided an explanation for each of the above items and reflects the change that
occurs in the column of each key financial area.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
26 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
This can be summarized as follows:
When the owner’s equity increases, the cash account increases
When an asset (other than cash) increases, the cash account decreases
When a liability increases, the cash account increases
Conversely:
When the owner’s equity decreases, the cash account decreases.
When an asset (other than cash) decreases, the cash account increases.
When a liability decreases, the cash account decreases.
Direct Format Cash Flow Statement
It would be possible for you to create a report that listed all of the individual cash transactions as shown in
Gary’s cash account for January and February. But it does not really add to what you can already see on the
bank statement because it doesn’t show inflows and outflows in any meaningful way.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
27 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Grouping cash payments together and showing a total movement in cash over a particular period is much
more useful. The report below shows Gary’s Garden Furniture cash receipts and disbursements for July:
By applying the resulting net cash flow ($6,000) to the balance of cash at the beginning of the period
($8,000), it is possible to obtain the cash balance for the end of the month ($14,000).
Showing the flow of cash into and out of the organization in this way provides a summary of the cash
account. Unfortunately, it does not show net income or make any attempt to explain the difference
between any net income and net cash flow.
As well as these shortcomings, it is difficult to analyze these figures in any meaningful way. Consequently,
published accounts always use what is known as the indirect method of presentation.
This is the format that appears in all published financial reports of public companies and is the same
format as the report produced by most accounting software.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
28 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Indirect Format Cash Flow Statement
This statement begins with net income and adjusts for changes in account balances that affect available
cash. It is slightly more difficult to understand initially but has far more potential for analysis.
It also serves to answer the important question, what is the difference between net profit and net cash
flow? A statement prepared using this method has four distinct sections:
Operations
Investing
Financing
Supplemental information
Operations
When you look at the example below of Gary’s Garden Furniture you will see that the first entry is net
income. This figure has been taken from the Income Statement for the period. The idea is that net income
is presumed to be equal to net cash flow except for the adjustments that make up the details of this
statement.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
29 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Operations are the process of running the organization with all of the related cash flows such as buying
and selling goods, services, manufacturing, and paying employees. The entries under this title effectively
convert the items reported on the income statement from the accrual basis of accounting to cash.
Investing
This reports the purchase and sale of long-term investments and property, plant, and equipment.
Financing
This reports the issuance and repurchase of the organization’s own bonds and stock and the payment of
dividends.
Supplemental information
This reports the exchange of significant items that did
not involve cash and reports the amount of income
taxes paid and interest paid.
The report below is an indirect format cash flow
statement for Gary’s Garden Furniture.
To appreciate the information this indirect format
statement provides you with, you need to work through
the line descriptions, one line at a time. The
explanations below will help you to understand exactly
what the above cash flow statement tells you.
The first line under the Operations title is Net Income
because the prime objective of this report is to show
the differences between net income and net cash flow.
This Net Income figure should be the same as that
shown on the income statement for the same period.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
30 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Adjustments
Then you need to work through the meaning of each of the items listed under the heading ‘Adjustments.’
These are all the operating items that had an impact on cash that was not included in the income
statement.
Depreciation
Accounts Receivable
Prepaid Expenses
Inventory
Accounts Payable
Depreciation
Because the cash was all paid out when Gary’s bought the asset, the monthly charge for depreciation
expense must be removed from reported net income. In other words, it should be added back in to
increase the net income.
Remember, depreciation is the gradual charging of the cost to expense over the useful life of the item. It is
recorded each month after the asset is put into use yet no cash changes hands as a result of these
depreciation entries.
Accounts Receivable
At the beginning of the period, Gary’s Garden Furniture was owed money by customers who had bought
on credit. Some of this would have been collected during the month, which would increase the cash figure
but decrease the accounts receivable figure.
However, Gary’s would also make additional credit sales during the period, some of which would remain
unpaid. These must also be allowed for. This can be done using the following formula:
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
31 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
This calculation effectively converts sales to cash collections by comparing the balances of Accounts
Receivable from the beginning of the month and the end of the month. The following examples will help
ensure that you understand this aspect of the statement.
Prepaid Expenses
Prepaid Expenses represent an upfront cost for things like insurance. As with accounts receivable, the net
change in the balance of prepaid expenses on the balance sheet from the beginning to the end of the
period is a quick way to calculate the net effect of this adjustment on cash flow.
Basically, if the net figure of prepaid expenses has decreased over the month, there will be a corresponding
increase in the cash balance and vice versa.
Inventory
Most companies need some inventory on hand and the change in inventory balances works on the cash
account in the same way as Accounts Receivable.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
32 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Remember that the income statement includes the cost of all inventory sold in the month. The cash flow
statement must deduct the cash cost of any inventory added during the period. This can be done using the
following formula:
Conversely, the cash flow statement must add the cash cost of any inventory deducted during the period.
Accounts Payable
The Accounts Payable figure represents those amounts owed to creditors. The cash flow statement must
add the cash cost of any increase in accounts payable during the period as this represents money
effectively borrowed from creditors.
This can be done using the following formula:
Cash for Investing
This reports the purchase and sale of long-term investments and property, plant, and equipment. This
includes:
Capital expenditures
Short-term investments sold
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
33 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Capital Expenditures
This describes the amount spent for all fixed assets that are not charged to expense when purchased but
are recorded on the organization’s balance sheet. That is, they are capitalized and then depreciated over
the amount of time they are used for.
The cash flow statement considers the purchasing of equipment and borrowing the money for the
purchase as two separate things.
Although the organization might have recovered the purchase cost by borrowing the money, the decision
to purchase the equipment represents a commitment of cash and appears as a deduction on the cash flow
statement. If the organization financed the purchase, an offsetting item would appear in the financing
section of the cash flow statement.
Short-Term Investments Sold
An organization can invest excess cash so that the money is gaining interest until it is needed for
operations. This type of investment is usually short term and uses vehicles like bank certificates or
securities, which the organization sells when it needs the cash.
When such an investment is purchased it appears as a cash expenditure that would be shown in this
section as a reduction in cash. When the investment is sold the net proceeds of the sale, except for the
gain or loss on sale (which appears in the income statement), become an additional source of cash.
Companies that have undergone a successful IPO (Initial Public Offering) often raise a lot of cash before
they are ready to use it. Short-term investments are a way to earn income from these otherwise idle cash
balances.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
34 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Cash from Financing
Financing activities include the inflow of cash from investors such as banks and shareholders, as well as the
outflow of cash to shareholders as dividends as the organization generates income.
Other activities that impact the long-term liabilities and equity of the organization are also listed in this
section. These include:
Bank Debt: The net amount of any increases or decreases in monies borrowed from the bank.
Dividends: a profitable organization may elect to pay a distribution of profits to its owners. This is
usually done in the form of a dividend on the shares held by its stockholders.
These distributions are almost always in cash and the cash flow statement is the only place such payments
can appear.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
35 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Chapter 3: Lease vs. Buy Equipment Analysis
Introduction
Businesses have difficulty raising capital - that's no secret. This difficulty (among other reasons) has caused
many to look at leasing as an alternative financing arrangement for acquiring the use of assets. All types of
equipment leasing-from motor vehicles to computers, from manufacturing machinery to office furniture-
have become more and more attractive.
This guide describes various aspects of the lease/buy decision. It lists the advantages and disadvantages of
leasing and provides a format for comparing the costs of the options.
What Is a Lease?
A lease is a long term agreement to rent equipment, land, buildings, or any other asset. In return for most-
but not all-of the benefits of ownership, the user (lessee) makes periodic payments to the owner of the
asset (lessor). The lease payment covers the original cost of the equipment or other asset and provides the
lessor a profit.
Types of Leases
There are three major kinds of leases: the financial lease, the operating lease, and the sale and leaseback.
Financial leases are most common by far. A financial lease is usually written for a term not to exceed
the economic life of the equipment. You will find that a financial lease usually provides that: Periodic
payments are made, Ownership of the equipment reverts to the lessor at the end of the lease term, the
lease is noncancellable and the lessee has a legal obligation to continue payments to the end of the
term, and the lessee agrees to maintain the equipment.
The operating lease, or "maintenance lease," can usually be canceled under conditions spelled out in
the lease agreement. Maintenance of the asset is usually the responsibility of the owner (lessor).
Computer equipment is often leased under this kind of lease.
The sale and leaseback is similar to the financial lease. The owner of an asset sells it to another party
and simultaneously leases it back to use it for a specified term. This arrangement lets you free the
money tied up in an asset for use elsewhere. You'll find that buildings are often leased this way.
You may also hear leases described as net leases or gross leases. Under a net lease, the lessee is
responsible for expenses such as those for maintenance, taxes, and insurance.
The lessor pays these expenses under a gross lease. Financial leases are usually net leases.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
36 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Finally, you might run across the term full payout lease. Under a full payout lease the lessor recovers the
original cost of the asset during the term of the lease.
Kinds of Lessors
As the use of leasing has increased as a method for businesses to acquire the use of the equipment and
other assets, the number of companies in the leasing business has increased dramatically.
Commercial banks, insurance companies, and finance companies do most of the leasing. Many of these
organizations have formed subsidiaries primarily concerned with equipment leasing. These subsidiaries are
usually capable of making lease arrangements for almost anything.
In addition to financial organizations, there are companies that specialize in leasing. Some are engaged in
general leasing, dealing with just about any kind of equipment. Others specialize in particular equipment,
such as trucks or computers.
For example, Equipment manufacturers are also occasionally in the leasing business. Of course, they
usually lease only the equipment they manufacture.
Advantages of Leasing
The obvious advantage to leasing is acquiring the use of an asset without making a large initial cash outlay.
Compared to a loan arrangement to purchase the same equipment, a lease usually:
Requires no down payment, while a loan often requires 25 percent down.
Requires no restriction on a company's financial operations, while loans often do.
Spreads payments over a longer period (which means they'll be lower) than loans permit.
Provides protection against the risk of equipment obsolescence since the lessee can get rid of the
equipment at the end of the lease.
Leasing has the further advantage that the leasing firm has acquired considerable knowledge about the
kinds of equipment it leases. Thus, it can provide expert technical advice based on experience with the
leased equipment.
Finally, there is one further advantage of leasing that you probably hope won't ever be of use to you. In the
event of bankruptcy, claims of the lessor to the assets of a firm are more restricted than those of general
creditors.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
37 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Disadvantages of Leasing
In the first place, leasing usually costs more because you lose certain tax advantages that go with
ownership of an asset. Leasing may not, however, cost more if you couldn't take advantage of those
benefits because you don't have enough tax liability for them to come into play.
Obviously, you also lose the economic value of the asset at the end of the lease term, since you don't own
the asset. Lessees have been known to grossly underestimate the salvage value of an asset. If they had
known this value from the outset, they might have decided to buy instead of lease.
Further, you must never forget that a lease is a long-term legal obligation. Usually, you can't cancel a lease
agreement.
So, if you plan to end an operation that used leased equipment, you might find you'd still have to pay as
much as if you had used the equipment for the full term of the lease.
Accounting Treatment of Leases
Historically, financial leases were "off the balance sheet” financing. That is, lease obligations often were
not recorded directly on the balance sheet but listed in footnotes, instead.
Not explicitly accounting for leases frequently resulted in a failure to state operational assets and liabilities
fairly.
In 1977 the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB), the rule-making body of the accounting
profession, required that capital leases be recorded on the balance sheet as both an asset and a liability.
This was in recognition of the long-term nature of a lease obligation.
Cost Analysis of Lease v. Loan/Purchase
You can analyze the costs of the lease versus purchase problem through discounted cash flow analysis. This
analysis compares the cost of each alternative by considering: the timing of the payments, tax benefits,
and the interest rate on a loan, the lease rate, and other financial arrangements.
To make the analysis you must first make certain assumptions about the economic life of the equipment,
salvage value, and depreciation.
A straight cash purchase using a firm's existing funds will almost always be more expensive than the lease
or loan/buy options because of the loss of use of the funds. Besides, most small firms don't have large
amounts of cash needed for major capital asset acquisitions in the first place.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
38 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
To evaluate a lease you must first find the net cash outlay (not cash flow) in each year of the lease term.
You find these amounts by subtracting the tax savings from the lease payment. This calculation gives you
the net cash outlay for each year of the leases.
Each year's net cash outlay must next be discounted to take into account the time value of money. This
discounting gives you the present value of each of the amounts.
The present value of an amount of money is the sum you would have to invest today at a stated rate of
interest to have that amount of money at a specified future date.
Say someone offered to give you $100 five years from now. How much could you take today and be as well
off?
Common sense tells you could take less than $100 because you'd have the use of the money for the five
year period.
Naturally, how much less you could take depends on the interest rate you thought you could get if you
invested the lesser amount. For example, to have $100 five years from now at six percent compounded
annually, you'd have to invest $74.70 today.
At 10 percent, you could take $62.10 now and have the $100 at the end of five years.
Fortunately, there are tables that provide the discount factors for present value calculations. There are
also relatively inexpensive special-purpose pocket calculators programmed to make these calculations.
Why bother with making these present value calculations? Well, you've got to make them compare the
actual cash flows over the time periods. You simply can't really compare methods of financing without
taking into account the time value of money. It may seem confusing and complex at first, but if you work
through an example, you'll begin to see that the technique isn't difficult-just sophisticated.
Evaluation of the borrow/buy option is a little more complicated because of the tax benefits that go with
ownership, loan interest deductions, and depreciation.
As noted earlier, the salvage value is one of the advantages of ownership. It must be considered in making
the comparison. Naturally, it is possible that salvage costs for real assets could be very high or be next to
nothing. Salvage value assumptions need to be made carefully.
Thus, while this sort of analysis is useful, you can't make a lease/buy decision solely on cost analysis
figures. The advantages and disadvantages discussed earlier, while tough to qualify, may outweigh
differences in cost-especially if costs are reasonably close.
Advanced Institute for Professional Certifications
Certified Financial Consultant - CFC®
Part ❶ – Financial Skills
39 Copyright © by aipc.ae. All rights reserved Be Certified ….. Be at the top
Look Before You Lease
A lease agreement is a legal document. It carries a long term obligation. You must be thoroughly informed
of just what you're committing yourself to. Find out the lessor's financial condition and reputation. Be
reasonably sure that the lease arrangements are the best you can get, that the equipment is what you
need and that the term is what you want. Remember, once the agreement is struck, it's just about
impossible to change it.
The lease document will spell out the precise provisions of the agreement. Agreements may differ, but the
major items will include:
The specific nature of the financing agreement
Payment amount
Term of agreement
Disposition of the asset at the end of the term
Schedule of the value of the equipment for insurance and settlement purposes in case of damage or
destruction
Who is responsible for maintenance and taxes.
Renewal options
Cancellation penalties
Special provisions