32
Demonstration Locations 3.11 SECTION 3 – CHAPTER 1 Demonstration Locations Prior chapters have reviewed design guidelines and developed policies and strategies for addressing the future transportation challenges facing the City of Norwalk. These efforts, combined with an extensive outreach efforts and analysis of development criteria, led to the development of a series of “Demonstration” projects for the City to consider. This chapter summarizes how the demonstration locations were selected, provides a brief discussion of the locations and why they are representative of many of the common issues and challenges facing the city, and provides guidance on how these various projects would compare against one another. 1.1 Overview The city of Norwalk undertook this Plan in conjunction with the South Western Regional Planning Agency (SWRPA) and the Connecticut Department of Transportation (CT DOT) to develop a Transportation Management Plan that would serve as a blueprint for identifying a project’s needs, developing context sensitive/multimodal solutions to those identified needs, and ultimately creating a process for prioritizing the project for the City. The ultimate goals of this Plan is intended to provide guidance and direction for the City and provide templates for transportation resources that are planned, designed, and constructed; all with the goal of: Providing for the safety and convenience of all users of the roadway system including: o Pedestrians (including those who need assistance with mobility) o Bicyclists o Transit Users o Emergency Service Operators o Automobile Drivers o Commercial Vehicle Operations

Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

  • Upload
    lequynh

  • View
    216

  • Download
    2

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

  Demonstration Locations  3.1‐1 

SECTION 3 – CHAPTER 1

Demonstration Locations 

PriorchaptershaverevieweddesignguidelinesanddevelopedpoliciesandstrategiesforaddressingthefuturetransportationchallengesfacingtheCityofNorwalk.Theseefforts,combinedwithanextensiveoutreacheffortsandanalysisofdevelopmentcriteria,ledtothedevelopmentofaseriesof“Demonstration”projectsfortheCitytoconsider.Thischaptersummarizeshowthedemonstrationlocationswereselected,providesabriefdiscussionofthelocationsandwhytheyarerepresentativeofmanyofthecommonissuesandchallengesfacingthecity,andprovidesguidanceonhowthesevariousprojectswouldcompareagainstoneanother.

1.1 Overview 

ThecityofNorwalkundertookthisPlaninconjunctionwiththeSouthWesternRegionalPlanningAgency(SWRPA)andtheConnecticutDepartmentofTransportation(CTDOT)todevelopaTransportationManagementPlanthatwouldserveasablueprintforidentifyingaproject’sneeds,developingcontextsensitive/multimodalsolutionstothoseidentifiedneeds,andultimatelycreatingaprocessforprioritizingtheprojectfortheCity.TheultimategoalsofthisPlanisintendedtoprovideguidanceanddirectionfortheCityandprovidetemplatesfortransportationresourcesthatareplanned,designed,andconstructed;allwiththegoalof:

Providingforthesafetyandconvenienceofallusersoftheroadwaysystemincluding:

o Pedestrians(includingthosewhoneedassistancewithmobility)

o Bicyclists

o TransitUsers

o EmergencyServiceOperators

o AutomobileDrivers

o CommercialVehicleOperations

Page 2: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

3.1‐2  Demonstration Locations  

Facilitatingmulti‐modaluseofthesystem.

Providingconsistencywithtransportationplansandpolicies,environmentalregulations,thecommunity,theregion,thestate,andtheFederalgovernment.

Beingcosteffectiveforthefiscallyconstrainedrealitiesofthecurrenttimesweliveinandforsettingthegroundworkforprioritizingfuturecapitalspending.

WhilethePlanitselfisguidedbytheprinciplesofMultimodalConsiderations,ContextSensitiveDesign,andprovidingaClearDevelopmentProcess;theCityultimatelyrequestedthataseriesofprojectsalsobedevelopedthatwouldconsidertheseguidelinesandadvancethemthroughtheprocessas“Demonstration”efforts.Thefollowingsectiondiscussestheprojectdemonstrationlocations.Itincludesadiscussionofhowspecificlocationswereselected,whichlocationswereselected,describeseachlocationinsomedetailandpresentstheuniquechallengesassociatedwiththeprojectlocationandultimatelypresentsapotentialsolutionforthelocationusingthecriteriapresentedinthePlan.

1.2 Selection of Demonstration Locations 

Attheoutsetofthisprocess,theprojectteammetwithresidents,businessowners,citystaffanddepartmentheads,andotherstakeholderstogatherextensiveinputontherealandperceivedchallengesandissuesfacingthetransportationsystemintheCityofNorwalk.Throughthisoutreacheffort,aconsistentsetofchallengesandconcernswereraisedbyallpartiesthatultimatelyformedthebasisforselectionoftheDemonstrationlocations.Acompletesummaryoftheoutreachefforts,thecommentsreceived,andtheoveralldiscussionisprovidedintheAppendixtothisdocument.Afterreviewingallthecommentsanddiscussionsthattookplace,therewerefivegeneralissuesthattendedtore‐appearintheoutreachefforts.Withoutreferringtospecificlocations,thesetrendswerebrokendownintothefollowinggroupings:

Operations–thisincludesintersectionsandlocationsthatexhibitexcessivedelays,congestion,andgenerallypoormobilityforvehiculartraffic.Thesearelocationswherethepublicperceivedthatimprovementscouldbemade,althoughinsomecasestheimprovementswerenotobvious.Italsoincludeslocationswherevehiclesarebeingenticedtotravelalongroadwaysthatarenotintendedtoserveasthroughroutes(cut‐throughtraffic).

Safety‐related–thisincludeslocationsthathavedemonstratedunsafesafetystatistics(highcrashlocations)orthroughperceivedissues(includinganecdotalcommentssuchas,“carsaretravelingatexcessivespeedsalongacorridor”),andthroughlocationsthathavehistoricallybeenchallengingtotransportationprofessionals(includinglocationswithpoorsightlines,etc…).

Page 3: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

Section 3 – Chapter 1

  Demonstration Locations  3.1‐3 

Maintenance–thisincludeslocationsthatwerehighlightedasinneedofrepair,upgrade,orenhancementtosomedegree.Inmanycases,thepavementconditionwasthenumberonesourceofconcern,butsidewalkandsignagewerealsohighlightedinthesecases.

Bicycle/Pedestrian–thisincludeslocationsthatareeitherperceivedtobepoorlyservedbybike/pedamenities,havethepotentialtooffergrowthorenhancementtothepedestrian/bicyclecommunity,and/orhavetraditionallybeenignoredingeneral.

Parking–thisincludeslocationswhereparkingdemandisperceivedtobeunderservedforthearea,and/orinappropriatelyprovided.

Usingthesefivegroupings(alongwitha“miscellaneous”categorytocoverrandomcommentsunrelatedtothesefivegroupings),theprojectteamreviewedeachofthecommentsprovidedattheoutreachsessionsandlocatedtheissuesonamapoftheCityofNorwalk.Thegraphicindicatesthatthesechallengesarelocatedallthroughoutthecityandwhenreviewedinadetailedfashionrevealthatcharacterofacertainneighborhoodorportionofthecityhasalottodowiththeperceivedissue/concernraisedaspartofthePlan.Usingthisinformation,theProjectAdvisoryteamidentified11candidateroadwaycorridorsand13candidateintersectionswithintheCitylimitsthatexhibitoneormoreoftheabovetransportationchallenges.Usingthislisting,theProjectTeamthenreviewedeachoftheroadwaycorridorandintersectiontoprovideageneralcross‐sectionofgeographicdiversitythroughouttheCity,differentcontextstotheenvironmentthatitexistswithin,andthoselocationsthatofferuniquechallengestotheCommunityasawhole.Ultimately,thisreducedthe11candidateroadwaylocationsdownto2demonstrationcorridorsand5demonstrationintersections.Thefulllistingofcandidateroadwaysalongwiththeselecteddemonstrationlocationsisprovidedbelow:

1.2.1 Candidate Roadways 

AttachedattheendofthissectionisafigureshowingwhereeachofthespecificcandidateroadwaysandintersectionsarelocatedwithintheCity.Thefollowingwerelocationswereselectedand/orconsideredfordemonstration‘status’:

WestRocksRoad[SELECTEDASADEMONSTRATIONROADWAY]

WashingtonStreet/FairfieldAvenue[SELECTEDASADEMONSTRATIONROADWAY]

o MainStreet/MainAvenue

o RichardsAvenue/RowaytonAvenue

o TaylorAvenue/NorthTaylorAvenue/FillowStreet

o FlaxHillRoad

Page 4: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

3.1‐4  Demonstration Locations  

o MLKDrive/WestAvenue/BeldenAvenue

o Route1/ConnecticutAvenue/WestportAvenue

o EastAvenue[Note:thislocationisunderdesignalreadyandwillbescoredinthePNF/PIFratingsattheendofthischapter]

o StrawberryHillAvenue

o CalfPastureBeachRoad

1.2.2 Candidate Intersections  

AttachedattheendofthissectionisafigureshowingwhereeachofthespecificcandidateintersectionsarelocatedwithintheCity.Thefollowingwerelocationswereselectedand/orconsideredfordemonstration‘status’:

Route123/NewCanaanAvenueatBartlettAvenue/EllsStreet[SELECTEDASADEMONSTRATIONINTERSECTION]

Route53/NewtownAvenueatMurrayStreet/DryHillRoad[SELECTEDASADEMONSTRATIONINTERSECTION]

WestAvenueatBeldenAvenue/MottAvenue[SELECTEDASADEMONSTRATIONINTERSECTION]

TaylorAvenueatFlaxHillRoad[SELECTEDASADEMONSTRATIONINTERSECTION]

FlaxHillRoadatRichardsAvenue/RowaytonAvenue[SELECTEDASADEMONSTRATIONINTERSECTION]

o GristMillRoadatBeldenHillRoad/NorthSeirHillRoad

o RichardsAvenueatWestCedarStreet

o NorthTaylorAvenueatBenedictStreet

o MapleStreetatRoute1(VanBurenAvenue)/StevensStreet

o HighlandAvenueatSoundviewAvenue/DevilsGardenRoad

o Route123/MainStreetatRoute1/NorthAvenue

o EastAvenue/ParkStreetatWallStreet/HubbellsLane

o StrawberryHillRoadatTierneyStreet

1.3 Demonstration Location Screening 

Thetransportationimprovementstrategiesoutlinedinpart1ofthePlanwereusedtoscreeneachoftheselectedDemonstrationlocations.Inthisprocess,eachlocationwas

Page 5: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

Section 3 – Chapter 1

  Demonstration Locations  3.1‐5 

screedthroughtheevaluationprocessonthebasisofitstechnicalchallengesandcross‐referenceditwiththepubliccommentarythatwasreceivedduringouroutreachefforts.Thelaterwasespeciallyimportantinthatitidentifiedthe“perceived”issuewitheachlocation~whichwasthencomparedtothetechnicalreviewoftheintersectiontodetermineiftheperceptionmettherealityofthesituation.Inrareinstances,estimateswereusedtoassignascoreonthePNFformsastheinformationwasnotreadilyavailable(fundingsources,forexample,werenotexploredingreatdetail).Similarly,someanswersinthePIFformswerealsoestimatedbasedonlackofrealdata(costofimprovements,forexample).Inthesecases,thescoresarehighlightedinorange(insteadofyellow)tocallouttheassignedscoreforeachlocation.Thefollowingisasummaryofthescreeningperformedateachofthelocations.Wherenoted,alternativeshavebeendevelopedandarepresentedattheendofhitssectionforeachofthecorridorsandintersectionsselected.

1.3.1 Demonstration Corridors 

1.3.1.1  Corridor 1: West Rocks Road/France Street/Park Street  

ThiscorridorformsamajorconnectionbetweenDowntownNorwalktoRoute7andthentoeitherI‐95ortheMerrittParkway.LandusesalongthecorridorareprimarilysinglefamilyresidentialwiththeWestRocksMiddleSchoolandAllSaintsCatholicSchoolalsofrontingthecorridor.Asacommuterroute,vehicularspeedstendtobehighandoutofcontextwiththelandusesalongthecorridor.Manygapsexistinthesidewalks,crosswalksarenotwellmarkedorinastateofdisrepairwheretheyexist,andbicyclefacilitiesarenonexistent.Thecorridorisalsoatransitroute,withbusserviceandtransitstopsalongthecorridor.Duetothepresenceoftheschools,residences,andtransitriders,pedestrianusageinthecorridorisexpectedbutnotadequatelyaccommodated.AProjectNeedFormwascompletedfortheWestRocksRoad/FranceStreet/ParkStreetcorridorasameansofmeasuringthetransportationneedsofthislocationalongsideotherdemonstrationprojects.Basedonavailableinformation,thiscorridorscoreda48.Thespeedingissuesalongthecorridor,lackofadequatepedestrianandbicycleaccommodations,transitservices,trafficvolumes,anddegreeofpublicsupportcontributedtothisscore.Objectivesalongthecorridorincludedthefollowing:

Createseamlesspedestrianfacilities;

Createbicycleconnectionalongcorridor;

Enhancethepedestrianrealmthroughcrosswalksandpedestriansignalheads;

Page 6: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

3.1‐6  Demonstration Locations  

Enhancethetransitridersrealmwithfurnishingsatstops;and

Tamevehicularspeedstobemoreincontextwiththeneighborhoodandexpectednon‐motorizedtravelers.

Exacerbatingtheissuesarethetopographyandunderlyinggeologyofthecorridor;hillyterrainandthepresenceofrockmaymakeimprovementsinfeasibleincertainlocations.Inthoseinstances,facilitiesmaybeconsolidatedononesideoftheroadwayandasafecrossingprovidedtoconnectthesides.InaccordancewiththeobjectiveslistedaboveandthegoalsoftheTMP,thefollowingrecommendationsweredeveloped:

Establishcontinuousbicyclelanesonthecorridorthroughacombinationof

lanedietsandselectivewideningwherefeasible;

Fillingapsinsidewalkcoveragetocreatecontinuoussidewalksonbothsidesoftheentirecorridorlengthwherefeasible;

Enhancepedestriancrossingsatintersectionswithestablishmentofhigh‐visibilitycrosswalksandinstallationofpedestrianheads;and

Enhancetransitstopswithbenchesandpulloutsandshelterswherefeasible.

Byfollowingtheaboverecommendations,thecorridorcanberebalancedtoaccommodatefootandbicycletrafficwithnegligibleadditionaldelaytothemotorvehicletraffic.AProjectInitiationFormwascompletedfortheWestRocksRoad/FranceStreet/ParkStreetcorridortoevaluatetheeffectivenessoftheproposedsolution(shownpreviously)ataddressingidentifiedneeds/issuesfromtheProjectNeedForm,assessthereadinessleveloftheproject,andevaluateprojectdetails.CompletionoftheProjectInitiationFormresultsinanumericalscorethatcanbecomparedtothescoresofotherdemonstrationprojectsinordertorankconceptualsolutionsagainsteachother.Basedontheconceptualplansdevelopedtodate,theproposedimprovementsforthiscorridorscoreda67.Improvementstosafetyandpedestrian/bicycleaccommodationscoupledwithnoright‐of‐wayimpactsandminimalimpactedtosurroundingresourcescontributedtothisscore.

Page 7: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

Section 3 – Chapter 1

  Demonstration Locations  3.1‐7 

1.3.1.2 Corridor 2: Washington Street/Fairfield Avenue  

TheWashingtonStreet/FairfieldAvenuecorridorservesmultipleroles:itisaprimarycommuterrouteintoDowntownNorwalk,itservesasacommercialcorridorofferinggoods,services,andemploymenttoNorwalkresidentsanditservesasa“frontdoor”forDowntownNorwalktopeoplearrivingbybothcarandMetroNorth.Forthesereasons,itisimportantthatthecorridorbebalancedbetweenmotorizedandnon‐motorizedtravel,asthereisahighexpectationofpedestrianandcyclistactivitywithinthiscorridor.Furthermore,thiscorridorshouldbedesignedasa“gateway”intoDowntown,withsignaturestreetscapeelementsthatnotonlyenhancetheaestheticsofthecorridor,butalsoserveatrafficcalmingpurposeinchangingdriverbehaviortoslowdownduetothepresenceofnon‐motorizedtraffic.AProjectNeedFormwascompletedfortheWashingtonStreet/FairfieldAvenuecorridorasameansofmeasuringthetransportationneedsofthisprojectalongsideotherdemonstrationprojects.Basedonavailableinformation,theWashingtonStreet/FairfieldAvenuecorridorscoreda44ontheProjectNeedForm.Thetrafficvolumesandaccesstotransitservices,activitycenters,andcommercialareasalongthecorridorcontributedtothisscore.Specificobjectivesforthedesignofthiscorridorincludedthefollowing:

Createapedestrianscaleandfeeltothecorridorthroughtheuseofmaterials

andlighting,similartothecharacterof“WashingtonHistoricEast;”

Developatransitionzonebetweenthecar‐orientedareastothewestandthepedestrian‐orientedDowntown;

ReactivatethestreetinthisgatewayareaofDowntown;

DevelopabikefacilitytoconnecttoFlaxHillRoad;and

Capitalizeonopenspaceopportunitiestocelebratethe“art”ofthedistrict.

Toaddresstheseobjectivesandtomakethecorridorattractivetoallusersregardlessoftheirmodeoftravel,thefollowingrecommendationsweredevelopedasillustratedintheconceptsketch:

Createatwo‐way‘cycletrack’connectionalongFairfieldAvenuetoFlaxHill

RoadthroughalanediettofacilitateabicycleconnectiontoFlaxHillRoad;

InstallspecialtylightingundertheMetroNorthBridgetostrengthentheconnectionbetweentheartsdistrictinSoNotothewesternsideofthebridge;

Reconfigureplazainfrontof50WashingtonStreettowertoaccommodateafarmersmarket,foodvendorsetc.,creatingagatheringspaceandcenterforthe

Page 8: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

3.1‐8  Demonstration Locations  

District;InstallpublicartinreclaimedpavementareastoserveasagatewayandanextensionwestoftheSoNoArtsDistrict;and

Installpedestrianscalelightinganddecorativesidewalksthroughoutthecorridor.

ThesemeasuresestablishtheareaasagatewaytoDowntownandanextensionoftheSoNodistrict,reenergizingthiscorridorwhilerebalancingthetravelmodestosafelyandefficientlycarrycars,buses,pedestrians,andcyclists.AProjectInitiationFormwascompletedfortheWashingtonStreet/FairfieldAvenuecorridortoevaluatetheeffectivenessoftheproposedsolution(shownpreviously)ataddressingidentifiedneeds/issuesfromtheProjectNeedForm,assessthereadinessleveloftheproject,andevaluateprojectdetails.CompletionoftheProjectInitiationFormresultsinanumericalscorethatcanbecomparedtothescoresofotherdemonstrationprojectsinordertorankconceptualsolutionsagainsteachother.Basedontheconceptualplansdevelopedtodate,theproposedimprovementsfortheWashingtonStreet/FairfieldAvenuecorridorscoreda41ontheProjectInitiationForm.Improvementstosafetyandpedestrian/bicycleaccommodationscoupledwithminimalimpactstoright‐of‐wayorthesurroundingresourcescontributedtothisscore.

Page 9: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

Section 3 – Chapter 1

  Demonstration Locations  3.1‐9 

1.3.2 Demonstration Intersections 

1.3.2.1 Intersection 1: West Avenue at Belden Avenue/Mott Avenue 

LocatedinDowntownNorwalk,thisintersectionisthemosturbanofthedemonstrationintersections.AdjacentusesincludetheCityofNorwalkLibrary,CityTransitCenter,andamixofretailandcommercialuses.WallStreetisahistoricretail“mainstreet”corridor,completewithanintactstreetwallofbuildingsandonstreetparking;thisstreetiscurrentlyunderutilizedfromaretailstandpointduetorelocationofmanyofthebusinesses,butthepotentialforredevelopmentisstrong.Giventheseuses,thepedestrianactivityinthisareaisheavy,andexpectedtoincreaseshouldWallStreetredevelop;however,thegeometriccharacteristicsandexcesscapacityofthestreetsencouragehighvehicularspeedsandcreateanenvironmentthatisnotnecessarilypedestrian‐friendly.Additionally,thereisalocalperceptionofalackofparkinginthearea,duetothefactthatthestreetsaredifficultforpedestriantocross.Theconfluenceoftheroads,presenceofhigh‐speedsliplanes,onewaystreets,andexcesspavementworktogethertoconfuseboththepedestrianandmotorist,whiletheunderutilizationoftheexistinggreenspaceintheislandsanddeficientconditionofthesidewalksandcrosswalksaddtothefeelingthattheareaisnotreallycomfortableforpedestrianuse.AProjectNeedFormwascompletedfortheintersectionofWestAvenueatBeldenAvenue/MottAvenueasameansofmeasuringthetransportationneedsofthislocationalongsideotherdemonstrationprojects.Basedonavailableinformation,theintersectionofWestAvenueatBeldenAvenue/MottAvenuescoreda55ontheProjectNeedForm.Thehighpedestrianvolumescoupledwithalackofaccommodations,accesstotransitservices,activitycenters,andcommercialareasalongthecorridor,andthedegreeofpublicsupportstatedattheTMPpublicmeetingsandduringtheoutreacheffortscontributedtothisscore.Specificobjectivesforthisintersectionwereasfollows:

Reduceconfusionformotoristsandpedestrians;

Reducetheperceptionofaparkingproblembyextendingthewalkshed;

Enhancepedestriansafety;

Enhancetheconnectionforbothmotoristsandpedestrianstoandfromtheexistingparkinggarage;

Preservevehicularoperationsthroughadditionofturnlaneswherenecessary;and

Right‐sizethestreets.

Thisintersectionhadthepotentialtobea“signature”projectduetotheconfluenceofusesandcontextgearedtowardawalk‐friendlyurbancoreandtheabilityfortravelers

Page 10: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

3.1‐10  Demonstration Locations  

tochooseamongvariousmodesoftransportavailablewithinthearea.Specificrecommendationsforthisintersectionareasfollows:

ShortTermActions

o ImplementCompleteStreetsprinciplesonallstreetstorebalancetravelmodes;

o Elicitaroaddiet(4lanesto3laneswithspotmedians)onWestAvenuethroughthecorearea,addbikelanesandmedian/leftturnlanes;

o Reclaim/increasegreenspacethrougheliminationofrightturnchannelsonWallStreetandWestAvenue;

o Enhancesidewalkwidthandrepairsidewalkswithinarea;and

o Addpedestrianamenitiessuchashigh‐visibilitycrosswalksandmid‐intersectionrefuges.

LongTermActions

o Addstreetnetworktoenhancecirculationandreduceblocklength,suchasaneweast‐westconnectionbetweenWestAvenueandRiverStreet;

o ExtendpedestrianconnectionstotheRiver;and

o ReconstructWallStreetasa“festivalstreet”(flushsectionbetweenbuildingswithbrickpavers)thatcandefinethecorridorasalocal“mainstreet”andwalkablearea.

Byelicitingthisslateofrecommendations,thisintersectionandareahasthepotentialtonotonlyrebalancemovementamongthevariousmodesoftravel,butalsotorepositiontheareaforreinvestmentwitha“signature”infrastructureprojectleveragingpublicinvestment.AProjectInitiationFormwascompletedfortheWestAvenueatBeldenAvenue/MottAvenuetoevaluatetheeffectivenessoftheproposedsolution(attached)ataddressingidentifiedneeds/issuesfromtheProjectNeedForm,assessthereadinessleveloftheproject,andevaluateprojectdetails.CompletionoftheProjectInitiationFormresultsinanumericalscorethatcanbecomparedtothescoresofotherdemonstrationprojectsinordertorankconceptualsolutionsagainsteachother.Basedontheconceptualplansdevelopedtodate,theproposedimprovementstotheintersectionofWestAvenueatBeldenAvenue/MottAvenuescoreda62ontheProjectInitiationForm.Improvementstosafetyandpedestrian/bicycleaccommodationsandprojectedreductionsinvehicularspeedstogetherwithminimalimpactstoright‐of‐wayorthesurroundingresourcescontributedtothisscore.

Page 11: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

Section 3 – Chapter 1

  Demonstration Locations  3.1‐11 

1.3.2.2 Intersection 2: Taylor Avenue at Flax Hill Road  

Whilelocatedinapredominatelyresidentialare,thisintersectionservesnotonlylocalvehiculartrafficbutalsoahealthyamountof“cutthrough”trafficasitisacontinuousroutethatroughlyparallelsI‐95andUS1.Additionally,theintersectionisproximatetotheSouthNorwalkMetro‐NorthStationaswellasFlaxHillPark,whichisattractivetobothpedestrianandbicycletravelalongthesecorridors.Currently,theintersectionistwooffset“T”intersections,causingqueuingissuesbetweentheoffsetnorth‐southlegswhenopposingvehiclesdesiretomakealeftturnontoLoweStreet.Characterizedbylargecornerradii,theintersectionsencouragehighvehicularspeedsbyturningvehiclesattheexpenseofthepedestrianandbicyclingenvironment.Furthermore,excesspavementcouldbereclaimedforplantingopportunitiesto“green”theintersectionarea,whichfeelsmuchwiderthanitactuallyis.AProjectNeedFormwascompletedfortheintersectionofFlaxHillRoadatTaylorAvenueandFlaxHillRoadatLoweStreetasameansofmeasuringthetransportationneedsofthisprojectalongsideotherdemonstrationprojects.Basedonavailableinformation,theintersectionsofFlaxHillRoadatTaylorAvenueandFlaxHillRoadatLoweStreetscoreda40ontheProjectNeedForm.Vehicularspeeds,lackofadequatepedestrianandbicycleaccommodations,trafficvolumes,andheavyvehiclevolumescontributedtothisscore.Specificobjectivesconsideredindevelopingaprogramofenhancementsforthisdemonstrationprojectareasfollows:

Implementbicyclefacilityoncorridor;

Increasesafetyforvehicles,pedestrians,andcyclists;

Rebalanceroadwaystoaneighborhoodscale;

Createsafepedestriancrossings;and

Installstreettreeswhereappropriatetocreateshadecanopy.

Tworecommendedoptionsweredeveloped:

BothoptionsnormalizetheLoweStreetintersectionintoa90‐degreeT‐intersectionandreclaimsomeofthepavementonthenortheastquadrantforagreenplantedarea,

Elicitlanedietstoaddbikelanes,and

Enhancethepedestriancrossingsthroughhighvisibilitycrosswalks.

TheoptionsvaryinthetreatmentoftheTaylorRoadintersection:

Thefirstconsidersatrafficsignal,while

ThesecondoptionincorporatesaroundaboutatTaylorRoadandFlaxHillRoad.

Page 12: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

3.1‐12  Demonstration Locations  

Thevarioustreatmentshelprebalancetheroadwaytomakeitmoreuser‐friendlyforpedestriansandcyclists,whileimprovingthetrafficoperationsbynormalizingtheintersectionsandmitigatingtheopposingleft‐turnblockagethatcurrentlyoccurs.AProjectInitiationFormwascompletedfortheFlaxHillRoadatTaylorAvenueandFlaxHillRoadatLoweStreetintersectiontoevaluatetheeffectivenessoftheproposedsolution(attached)ataddressingidentifiedneeds/issuesfromtheProjectNeedForm,assessthereadinessleveloftheproject,andevaluateprojectdetails.CompletionoftheProjectInitiationFormresultsinanumericalscorethatcanbecomparedtothescoresofotherdemonstrationprojectsinordertorankconceptualsolutionsagainsteachother.BasedontheconceptualplansdevelopedforOption1andOption2,theproposedimprovementstotheintersectionsofFlaxHillRoadatTaylorAvenueandFlaxHillRoadatLoweStreetscoreda70ontheProjectInitiationForm.Improvementstosafetyandpedestrian/bicycleaccommodationscoupledwithminimalimpactstoright‐of‐wayorthesurroundingresourcescontributedtothisscore.

Page 13: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

Section 3 – Chapter 1

  Demonstration Locations  3.1‐13 

1.3.2.3 Intersection 3: Flax Hill Road at Rowayton Avenue and Richards Avenue  

SimilartotheFlaxHillRoaddemonstrationintersectionlocatedtotheeast,thisareathatencompassestwointersectionsandfrontsprimarilysinglefamilyresidentialuses.Theroadwayservesasignificantamountoftrafficnotrelatedtotheneighborhood,andmustbalancethatmovementwithpedestrianandbicycledemand.Theintersectionconfigurationandangleisnot90‐degrees,whichcompoundsvehicularspeedingasanissue;furthermore,theexistingtriangleconfigurationoftheRowaytonAvenueintersectionlendstopotentialmotoristconfusion.AProjectNeedFormwascompletedfortheintersectionofFlaxHillRoadatRowaytonAvenueandFlaxHillRoadatRichardsAvenueasameansofmeasuringthetransportationneedsofthisprojectalongsideotherdemonstrationprojects.Basedonavailableinformation,theintersectionsofFlaxHillRoadatRowaytonAvenueandFlaxHillRoadatRichardsAvenuescoreda41ontheProjectNeedForm.Thelackofadequatebicycle,trafficvolumes,anddegreeofpublicsupportcontributedtothisscore.Objectivesforthisdemonstrationprojectwerearticulatedasfollows:

Increasetheamountoflightingattheintersection;

Makesafetyforallmodesoftravelthepriority;

Enhanceandcreatenewgreenspacewherepossible,andincorporategreeninfrastructurewherecontextuallyconsistent;

Createabicyclefacilitytoenhancecyclistsafety;

Calmtrafficspeeds;and

Returntheroadwayandintersectiontoaneighborhoodscale.

Theproposedreconfigurationoftheintersectionaddressestheaboveconcernsasshownintheillustration.

Crosswalkswereenhancedatbothintersectionsusinghighvisibilitymarkings;

TheintersectionofRichardsAvenuewasrealignedtobringitintoFlaxHillRoadata90‐degreeangleandreclaimgreenspacefromtheexcesspavement;and

AroundaboutwasdevelopedtoreplacetheawkwardtriangleconfigurationoftheRowaytonAvenueintersectionwhilepreservingthetreesinthecenterisland.

Twoconfigurationsforbicyclefacilitiesweredeveloped:thefirstwidenstheroadwayslightlytoa32‐footsectioninordertoaccommodatededicatedbicyclelanes.Thesecondoptionmaintainsthe24‐footsectionwhileusingsharrowstodesignatethesharedconditionofthebicyclefacilityandtoalertmotoriststothepotentialpresenceofcyclists.

Page 14: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

3.1‐14  Demonstration Locations  

Eitheroptionmeetstheobjectivessetforthforthedemonstrationproject.OneotherconceptalternativedevelopedwouldincorporateasecondroundaboutattheRichardsAvenueintersection,providingatandemsetofroundaboutsinthislocation.AProjectInitiationFormwascompletedfortheFlaxHillRoadatRowaytonAvenueandFlaxHillRoadatRichardsAvenueintersectiontoevaluatetheeffectivenessoftheproposedsolution(attached)ataddressingidentifiedneeds/issuesfromtheProjectNeedForm,assessthereadinessleveloftheproject,andevaluateprojectdetails.CompletionoftheProjectInitiationFormresultsinanumericalscorethatcanbecomparedtothescoresofotherdemonstrationprojectsinordertorankconceptualsolutionsagainsteachother.BasedontheconceptualplansdevelopedforOption1,theproposedimprovementstotheintersectionsofFlaxHillRoadatRowaytonAvenueandFlaxHillRoadatRichardsAvenuescoreda70ontheProjectInitiationForm.Improvementstosafetyandpedestrian/bicycleaccommodationscoupledwithminimalimpactstoright‐of‐wayorthesurroundingresourcescontributedtothisscore.BasedontheconceptualplansdevelopedforOption2,theproposedimprovementstotheintersectionsofFlaxHillRoadatRowaytonAvenueandFlaxHillRoadatRichardsAvenuescoreda64ontheProjectInitiationForm.ThedifferencebetweenthetwooptionsisthatOption2providessharrowstoassistinthebicycleroutes,whileOption1providesfullbicyclelanes.Otherwise,theimprovementsareidentical.

Page 15: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

Section 3 – Chapter 1

  Demonstration Locations  3.1‐15 

1.3.2.4 Intersection 4: Route 53 (Newtown Avenue) at Dry Hill Road and Murray Street 

TheintersectionofRoute53(NewtownAvenue)andDryHillRoad/MurrayStreetissurroundedandfrontedwithsinglefamilyresidentiallanduses.Theintersectionischaracterizedbyasignificantamountofpavement,andalmostconstitutesan“intersectionwithinanintersection”asbothMurrayStreetandDryHillRoadaccessRoute53throughasharedintersection.Thecurrentconfigurationisconfusingformotoristsandperceivedasunsafe,withsignificantconfusionastowhohastherightofwayattheintersectionbetweentheMurrayStreetandDryHillRoadapproaches.Exacerbatingtheissueisthepotentialforpedestrianscrossingtheintersectionandencounteringturningvehiclesonapproachesthatareextremelyclosetogether.AProjectNeedFormwascompletedfortheintersectionofNewtownAvenue(Route53)atDryHillRoadandMurrayStreetasameansofmeasuringthetransportationneedsofthisprojectalongsideotherdemonstrationprojects.Basedonavailableinformation,theintersectionofNewtownAvenue(Route53)atDryHillRoadandMurrayStreetscoreda33ontheProjectNeedForm–thelowestscoreofalldemonstrationprojects.Contributingtothislowscorearealackofactivityorcommercialcentersinthevicinitycoupledwithlowpedestrianandbicyclevolumes.Objectivesindevelopingthedesignconceptforthisintersectionweretwofold:

reworktheintersectiontoenhancesafetyforallmodes(perceivedandreal);

keepinganyenhancementincharacterandscalewiththesurroundingneighborhood.

Asshownintheillustration,tworecommendedoptionsweredeveloped,withbothclearingtheconfusingconfigurationattheintersectionwithRoute53:

Option1createsasquareattheintersection,separatinginboundandoutboundtrafficintotwoapproaches.Thesquareactsasaninternal“roundabout”anddistributestraffictoandfromDryHillRoadandMurrayStreetbymovingtheconflictpointbetweentheroadstotheeast,outsideoftheconflictareaofthemainlineRoute53.Thisconfigurationalsoaffordsanopportunitytocreateagatewayandplantingareafortheneighborhood.

Option2simplifiestheintersectionbyteeingDryHillRoadintoMurrayStreetjusteastoftheRoute53intersection.ItrequiresathreelaneapproachontheRoute53intersectiontoalleviatequeuingfromturningvehiclesblockingtheadjacentintersection,andmayrequirefuturesignalizationoftheintersectionwithRoute53.LikeOption1,reclaimedexcesspavementcanbeplantedandutilizedasagatewayoropenspaceopportunityfortheneighborhood.

BothoptionsaddressthedesignobjectivesandareinkeepingwiththeoverallguidingprinciplesoftheTrafficManagementPlan.

Page 16: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

3.1‐16  Demonstration Locations  

AProjectInitiationFormwascompletedfortheNewtown Avenue (Route 53) at Dry 

Hill Road and Murray Street intersectiontoevaluatetheeffectivenessoftheproposedsolution(attached)ataddressingidentifiedneeds/issuesfromtheProjectNeedForm,assessthereadinessleveloftheproject,andevaluateprojectdetails.CompletionoftheProjectInitiationFormresultsinanumericalscorethatcanbecomparedtothescoresofotherdemonstrationprojectsinordertorankconceptualsolutionsagainsteachother.BasedontheconceptualplansdevelopedforOption1andOption2,theproposedimprovementstotheintersectionofNewtownAvenue(Route53)atDryHillRoadandMurrayStreetscoreda48ontheProjectInitiationForm.Improvementstosafetyandpedestrian/bicycleaccommodationscoupledwithminimalimpactstoright‐of‐wayorthesurroundingresourcescontributedtothisscore.

Page 17: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

Section 3 – Chapter 1

  Demonstration Locations  3.1‐17 

1.3.2.5 Intersection 5: Route 123 (New Canaan Avenue) at Bartlett Avenue and Ells Street 

Route123connectsbetweentheMerrittParkwaytothewestandRoute7totheeast,andthisintersectionatBartlettAvenueandEllsStreetisaneighborhoodcommercialnode,withsmallretailandrestaurantusesadjacent.Geometrically,theintersectionis5legs,andoffsetwithBartlettAvenueintersectingataskewedangle.Drivewaystothebusinessesconsistofelongatedaprons,contributingtotheoveralllackofaccessmanagementintheintersectionarea.ThereisalsoabusstoponthewestapproachoftheintersectionalongRoute123,andpedestriansutilizingtransitmustnavigatethisconfusingintersectionwithvehicleconflictsinmultipledirections.Additionally,thecorridordoesnothavededicatedbicyclelanes,whichcouldbeutilizedbyresidentsandcommuters.AProjectNeedFormwascompletedfortheintersectionofNewCanaanAvenue(Route123)atBartlettAvenue/EllsStreetasameansofmeasuringthetransportationneedsofthisprojectalongsideotherdemonstrationprojects.Basedonavailableinformation,theintersectionofNewCanaanAvenue(Route123)atBartlettAvenue/EllsStreetscoreda51ontheProjectNeedForm.Thehighpedestrianvolumescoupledwithalackofaccommodations,accesstocommercialareasalongthecorridor,andhightrafficvolumescontributedtothisscore.

Specificobjectivesindevelopingapaletteofdesignsolutionsincludedthefollowing:

Provideaccessmanagementwithintheareaoftheintersection;

Increasepedestriansafetyandenhancecrosswalks;

Reduceconflictsforallmodesoftravel;and

Provideadedicatedbicyclefacility.

Asshownintheconceptillustration,allobjectivesweremetwithaseriesofconstructionandpolicyinitiatives/recommendations:

TheintersectionofEllsStreetwouldbe“T’ed”uptomeetarealignedBartlettStreetatanormal90‐degreeintersection.

Bartletttothesouthwouldalsoberealignedintoa90‐degreeapproach.

Considerationofanall‐redpedestrianphasewouldsimplifycrossingsoftheintersection,andenhancedcrosswalkswouldbeincorporatedtoincreasemotoristawarenessofpedestrians.

Abikelanecouldbedevelopedthroughright‐sizingthetravellanesto11feet,andchannelizingtheturnlanes.

Finally,drivewayconsolidationshouldbeaccomplishedthroughredevelopmentofthefrontingparcelstobetterdefinerealmsforthevehiclesaccessingthebusinesses.

Page 18: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

3.1‐18  Demonstration Locations  

ThecomprehensiveapproachadherestotheprinciplesofCompleteStreetsinmakingthefacilitiessafeandefficientforallusers,andaffordingtruealternativesabouttravelchoicewithinthearea.AProjectInitiationFormwascompletedfortheNewCanaanAvenue(Route123)atBartlettAvenue/EllsStreetintersectiontoevaluatetheeffectivenessoftheproposedsolution(attached)ataddressingidentifiedneeds/issuesfromtheProjectNeedForm,assessthereadinessleveloftheproject,andevaluateprojectdetails.CompletionoftheProjectInitiationFormresultsinanumericalscorethatcanbecomparedtothescoresofotherdemonstrationprojectsinordertorankconceptualsolutionsagainsteachother.Basedontheconceptualplansdevelopedtodate,theproposedimprovementstotheintersectionofNewCanaanAvenue(Route123)atBartlettAvenue/EllsStreetscoreda70ontheProjectInitiationForm–thehighestscoreofalldemonstrationprojects.Improvementstosafety,pedestrian/bicycleaccommodations,andvehicularoperations;projectedreductionsinvehicularspeeds;andminimalimpactstoright‐of‐wayorthesurroundingresourcescontributedtothisscore.

Page 19: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

Section 3 – Chapter 1

  Demonstration Locations  3.1‐19 

1.4 Evaluation Summary 

Basedontheevaluationsofeachdemonstrationlocation,theresultingProjectNeedFormandProjectInitiationFormratingsaresummarizedbelow(actualformsareintheAppendixtothissection).Asthisinformationisreviewed,it’simportanttoconsiderthateachlocationisfirstratedonneedandthentheactualconceptplanthathasbeendevelopedisratedonitsabilitytoaddressthatneed.Projectlocationsthatdonothaveawelldefinedneedwilllikelynotgetcontinueintothedesignprocess.Conversely,projectlocationsthathaveawelldefinedneedandhaveahighscoreattachedtothemwillmorelikelyadvanceintothedesignstage.TheEastAvenueprojectwasnotincludedasademonstrationlocationbecausethedesignprocesshadadvancedfurtherthanotherprojectsselectedanditwasagreeduponthatthiscorridorwouldnotbenefitbyallocatingprojectresourcesto‘redesign’theplan.However,itshouldbenotedthatthisprojectisseenasavitalsteptoimprovemobilityforallmodesoftransportationwithinthisareaoftheCity.Thisprojectiscurrentlyunderdesign,hasfundingallocatedtoit,andincludesthefollowingimprovements:

WideningoftheEastAvenuerailroadunderpassfrom2‐lanesto4‐lanesandincreasingtheheightofthecrossing;

WideningofEastAvenuewithassociatedintersectionimprovementsfromWinfieldStreet(Route136)totheI‐95Exit16ramps;and

Sidewalkandstreetscapeimprovements.

1.4.1 Project Need 

Ofthefiveintersectionsandtwocorridorsreviewed,theprioritizationofeachlocationsneedsaredefinedinExhibit1‐1below.FullProjectNeedFormsareincludedasanattachmenttothisdocument.

Page 20: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

3.1‐20  Demonstration Locations  

Exhibit 1‐1  Project Need Form Score Summary 

Location Project Need Form Score Notes

Roadway Corridors

West Rocks Rd / France St / Park St

48 Speeding; transit services; lack of ped/bike facilities; high traffic volumes; public support.

Washington St / Fairfield Ave 44 High traffic volumes; transit services; access to activity centers/commercial areas.

East Ave 54 Ped/bike crashes; transit access; high traffic volumes; access to commercial areas; funding.

Intersections

West Ave @ Belden Ave/ Mott Ave

55 Adjacent to priority development site; high ped volumes; transit, parking needs; public support.

Flax Hill Rd @ Taylor Ave/ Lowe St

40 Speeding; lack of ped/bike facilities; high traffic and heavy vehicle volumes.

Flax Hill Rd @ Rowayton Ave/ Richards Ave

41 Lack of ped/bike facilities; high traffic volumes; public support.

Newtown Ave (Rt 53) @ Dry Hill Rd / Murray St

33 Safety; lack of ped/bike facilities.

New Canaan Ave (Rt 123) @ Bartlett Ave / Ells St

51 Lack of ped/bike facilities; high traffic volumes; access to activity centers/commercial areas.

AsExhibit1‐1indicates,whencomparingthefivedemonstrationintersections,theWestAvenueatBeldenAvenue/MottAvenuelocationscoredthehighest(55)withrespecttoprojectneed.ThislocationisfollowedcloselybyNewCanaanAvenue(Route123)atBartlettAvenue/EllsStreet(51).ThelowestscoringlocationwasNewtownAvenue(Route53)atDryHillRoad&MurrayStreet(33).Similarly,theroadwaycorridorsincludedEastAvenue(54),followedbytheWestRocksRoad/FranceStreet/ParkStreetcorridor(48)andthentheWashingtonStreet/FairfieldAvenuecorridor(44).AssumingtheseprojectsweretheonlyprojectsinfrontoftheCity(thefulllistofprojectisincludedintheAppendix),itwouldindicatethattheintersectionofWestAvenueatBeldenAvenue/MottAvenueshouldbeprioritizedfromaCityresourceperspectiveasithasthegreatestneedforimprovement.

1.4.2 Project Initiation 

Conceptualimprovementsweredevelopedtoaddressthedemonstratedneedsidentifiedforeachofthefiveintersectionsandtwocorridorsreviewed.AProjectInitiationFormwascompletedforeachlocationtoevaluatetheeffectivenessoftheprojectataddressingidentifiedneeds/issuesfromtheProjectNeedForm,assessthereadinessleveloftheproject,andevaluateprojectdetails.CompletionoftheProjectInitiationFormresultsinanumericalscorethatcanbecomparedtothescoresofother

Page 21: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

Section 3 – Chapter 1

  Demonstration Locations  3.1‐21 

demonstrationprojectsinordertorankconceptualsolutionsagainsteachother.AsummaryoftheProjectInitiationscoresisincludedinExhibit1‐2below.FullProjectInitiationFormsareincludedasanattachmenttothisdocument.Exhibit 1‐2  Project Initiation Form Score Summary 

Location Project Initiation

Form Score Notes

Roadway Corridors

West Rocks Rd / France St / Park St

67 Improved safety; ped/bike accommodations; minimal impact to ROW/resources.

Washington St / Fairfield Ave 41 Improved safety; ped/bike accommodations; minimal impact to ROW/resources.

East Ave 69 Improved safety; ped/bike accommodations; vehicular operations; funding; project plan development; minimal impact to resources.

Intersections

West Ave @ Belden Ave/ Mott Ave

62 Improved safety; ped/bike accommodations; speed reduction; minimal impact to ROW/resources.

Flax Hill Rd @ Taylor Ave/ Lowe St

70 Improved safety; ped/bike accommodations; minimal impact to ROW/resources.

Flax Hill Rd @ Rowayton Ave/ Richards Ave

70 Improved safety; ped/bike accommodations; minimal impact to ROW/resources.

Newtown Ave (Rt 53) @ Dry Hill Rd / Murray St

48 Ped/bike accommodations; minimal impact to ROW/resources.

New Canaan Ave (Rt 123) @ Bartlett Ave / Ells St

70 Improved safety; ped/bike accommodations; vehicular operations; speed reduction; minimal impact to ROW/resources.

AsExhibit1‐2indicates,whencomparingthedemonstrationintersections,conceptualimprovementforthreeofthefivelocationsscoredveryhighly(70):

FlaxHillRoadatTaylorAvenue/LoweStreet;

FlaxHillRoadatRowaytonAvenue/RichardsAvenue;and

NewCanaanAvenue(Route123)atBartlettAvenue/EllsStreet.

WestAvenueatBeldenAvenue/MottAvenuelocationfollowedclosely(62).Similartotheprojectneedevaluation,thelowestscoringlocationwasNewtownAvenue(Route53)atDryHillRoad&MurrayStreet(48).TheroadwaycorridorsincludedEastAvenue(69),followedbytheWestRocksRoad/FranceStreet/ParkStreetcorridor(67)andthentheWashingtonStreet/Fairfield

Page 22: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

3.1‐22  Demonstration Locations  

Avenuecorridor(41).AsEastAvenueiscurrentlyunderdesignandhasfundingalreadyallocatedtoitfromStateandlocalresources,itscoredhighly.AssumingtheseprojectsweretheonlyprojectsinfrontoftheCity,itwouldindicatethatimprovementstotheintersectionsofFlaxHillRoadatTaylorAvenue/LoweStreet;FlaxHillRoadatRowaytonAvenue/RichardsAvenue;andNewCanaanAvenue(Route123)atBartlettAvenue/EllsStreetshouldbeprioritizedfromaCityresourceperspectiveastheseprojectswouldaddressidentifiedneeds.Whencomparedwiththeotherprojectsdevelopedaspartofthiseffort,theEastAvenueprojectcontinuestobethepriorityprojectfortheCity.

1.4.2.1 Cost Estimates 

Inadditiontotheactualscores,theCityrequestedthatconceptualcostestimatesbeprovidedforeachoftheAlternatives.Thesecostestimateswerebasedontheconceptualalternativesdevelopedfortheproject(shownlaterinthischapter)andarebasedonConnecticutDOTstandardpricingformulasandincludeescalationfactorsforengineeringcost(8%oftotalestimatedconstructioncosts),contingencies(10%),incidentalitems(25%),andutilities(2%).Rightofwayacquisitionwasnotincludedinthesecosts.Exhibit 1‐3  Cost Estimate Summary 

Location Project Cost Estimate Notes

Roadway Corridors

West Rocks Rd / France St / Park St

$19,375,000 Assumes $1,250 per linear foot of corridor (total corridor length = 15,500 ft)

Washington St / Fairfield Ave $4,521,000

Intersections

West Ave @ Belden Ave/ Mott Ave

$6,265,000

Flax Hill Rd @ Taylor Ave/ Lowe St (alt 1)

$2,147,000

Flax Hill Rd @ Taylor Ave/ Lowe St (alt 2)

$1,881,000

Flax Hill Rd @ Rowayton Ave/ Richards Ave (alt 1)

$2,436,000 As shown in the graphic

Flax Hill Rd @ Rowayton Ave/ Richards Ave (alt 2)

$675,000 As shown in the graphic

Newtown Ave (Rt 53) @ Dry Hill Rd / Murray St (alt 1)

$1,523,000

Newtown Ave (Rt 53) @ Dry Hill Rd / Murray St (alt 2)

$940,000

New Canaan Ave (Rt 123) @ Bartlett Ave / Ells St

$1,494,000

Page 23: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

Vanasse Hangen Brustlin, Inc.

West Rocks Rd

Fairfield Ave

Washington St

Main Ave

Main St

Richards Ave

Rowa

yton

Ave

Fillow StN Taylor Ave

Taylor Ave

Flax Hill Rd

Marti

n Lut

her K

ing D

r

Wes

t Ave

Belden Ave

Connecticut Ave

Westport Ave

East Ave

Strawberry

Hill Av

e

Calf PastureBeach Rd

North Ave

Cross St

§̈¦95

§̈¦95

§̈¦95

£¤7

£¤7

£¤1

£¤1

£¤1

UV106

UV136

UV136

UV136

UV136

UV57

UV814

UV53

UV53

UV123

UV118

UV33

UV33

UV124

UV123

UV15

UV15

Darien

NewCanaan

Westport

Wilton

2

3

1

4

5

1

6

7

4

3

2

8

5

11

10

9

TMP Roadways and IntersectionsNorwalk Transportation Management PlanNorwalk, Connecticut

\\ctmiddat\projects\41706.00\graphics\FIGURES\Demonstration_Roadway11x17.indd p1 01/06/12

0 1500 3000 Feet

Demonstration Roadway

Other TMP Roadway

Demonstration Intersections

Other TMP Intersections

1. Grist Mill Road at Belden Hill Road/North Seir Hill Road2. Richards Avenue at West Cedar Street 3. North Taylor Avenue at Benedict Street4. Maple Street at Route 1 (Van Buren Avenue)/Stevens Street5. Route 123/Main Street at Route 1/North Avenue6. East Avenue/Park Street at Wall Street/Hubbells Lane7. Strawberry Hill Road at Tierney Street8. Highland Avenue at Soundview Avenue/Devils Garden Road9. East Avenue at I-95 Ramps (Exit 16)10. East Avenue at St. John Street/Raymond Terrace/Olmstead Place11. Calf Pasture Beach Road/Ludlow Manor at Fifth Street/Marvin Street

1. Route 123/New Canaan Avenue at Bartlett Avenue/Ells Street2. Route 53/Newtown Avenue at Murray Street/Dry Hill Road3. West Avenue at Belden Avenue/Mott Avenue4. Taylor Avenue at Flax Hill Road5. Flax Hill Road at Richards Avenue/Rowayton Avenue

Page 24: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

N

.

M

A

I

N

S

T

W

.

W

A

S

H

I

N

G

T

O

N

S

T

D

R

M

A

R

T

I

N

L

U

T

H

E

R

K

I

N

G

J

R

D

R

S. M

AIN

ST

HAVIL

AN

D S

T

WASH

ING

TO

N ST

146 HARTFORD ROADMANCHESTER, CONNECTICUT 06040860.646.2469www.fando.com

NORWALK, CT.

W WASHINGTON ST

OPTIONS

FARMER'S MARKET

FOOD VENDORS

PUBLIC ART SPACE

TWO-WAY CYCLE TRACK

OBJECTIVES

PEDESTRIAN FEEL/SCALE

- SIMILAR TO WASHINGTON

HISTORIC "EAST"

(MATERIALS/LIGHTING)

TRANSITION ZONE

REACTIVATE STREET

BIKE LANE CONNECTION TO FLAX HILL RD

CELEBRATE THE "ART"

PUBLIC ART SPACE

FUTURE DEVELOPMENT

FARMER'S MARKET

VENDORS

PERFORMANCE STAGE

SPECIALTY LIGHTING

Page 25: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

M

O

T

T

A

V

E

B

E

L

D

E

N

A

V

E

B

U

R

N

E

L

L

B

L

V

D

R

I

V

E

R

S

T

W

A

L

L

S

T

W

E

S

T

A

V

E

146 HARTFORD ROADMANCHESTER, CONNECTICUT 06040860.646.2469www.fando.com

NORWALK, CT.

WEST AVE @ BELDEN & MOTT AVE

OPTIONS

COMPLETE STREET

LANE REDUCTION

WIDER SIDEWALKS

PEDESTRIAN AMENITIES

LONG-TERM

NETWORK ADDITIONS

WALL ST AS "FESTIVAL STREET"

(LEONARD TO ISAACS ST)

RIVER FRONT ACCESS

OBJECTIVES

REDUCE CONFUSION

REDUCE PARKING PROBLEM

PERCEPTION

SIGNATURE PROJECT

PEDESTRIAN SAFETY

ENHANCE PUBLIC/PEDESTRIAN

TO/FROM PARKING GARAGE

TURN LANES

OPPORTUNITY AREAS

WITHIN ROW (TYP.)

2 LANE WITH CENTER

MEDIAN/TURN LANE,

BIKE LANES/SHARROW

WOONERF/

FESTIVAL STREET

ANGLED PARKING

Page 26: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

T

A

Y

L

O

R

A

V

E

F

L

A

X

H

I

L

L

R

D

F

L

A

X

H

I

L

L

R

D

HAM

ILTO

N A

VE

LO

W

E ST

146 HARTFORD ROADMANCHESTER, CONNECTICUT 06040860.646.2469www.fando.com

NORWALK, CT.

TAYLOR AVE @ FLAX HILL RD OPTION 1

OBJECTIVES

BIKE LANE

SAFETY

NEIGHBORHOOD SCALE

STREET TREE PROGRAM

PEDESTRIAN CROSSINGS

OPPORTUNITY AREAS

WITHIN ROW (TYP.)

Page 27: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

T

A

Y

L

O

R

A

V

E

F

L

A

X

H

I

L

L

R

D

F

L

A

X

H

I

L

L

R

D

HAM

ILTO

N A

VE

LO

W

E ST

146 HARTFORD ROADMANCHESTER, CONNECTICUT 06040860.646.2469www.fando.com

NORWALK, CT.

TAYLOR AVE @ FLAX HILL RD OPTION 2

OPPORTUNITY AREAS

WITHIN ROW (TYP.)

Page 28: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

F

L

A

X

H

I

L

L

R

D

F

L

A

X

H

I

L

L

R

D

R

I

C

H

A

R

D

S

A

V

E

R

O

W

A

Y

T

O

N

A

V

E

W

O

O

D

C

H

U

C

K

L

N

146 HARTFORD ROADMANCHESTER, CONNECTICUT 06040860.646.2469www.fando.com

NORWALK, CT.

FLAX HILL ROAD @ ROWAYTON AVE & RICHARDS AVE OPTION 1

OPTIONS

32' DEDICATED BIKE LANE

24' SHARROWS

SECOND ROUNDABOUT

OBJECTIVES

LIGHTING

SAFETY PRIORITY

GREEN SPACE

BIKE LANE

TRAFFIC CALMING

NEIGHBORHOOD SCALE

GREEN INFRASTRUCTURE

CROSSWALKS (TYP)

FOCAL POINT

POTENTIAL DRIVE

RELOCATION

OPPORTUNITY AREAS

WITHIN ROW (TYP.)

Page 29: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

F

L

A

X

H

I

L

L

R

D

F

L

A

X

H

I

L

L

R

D

R

I

C

H

A

R

D

S

A

V

E

R

O

W

A

Y

T

O

N

A

V

E

W

O

O

D

C

H

U

C

K

L

N

146 HARTFORD ROADMANCHESTER, CONNECTICUT 06040860.646.2469www.fando.com

NORWALK, CT.

FLAX HILL ROAD @ ROWAYTON AVE & RICHARDS AVE OPTION2

OPPORTUNITY AREAS

WITHIN ROW (TYP.)

Page 30: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

M

U

R

R

A

Y

S

T

R

E

E

T

D

R

Y

H

I

L

L

R

D

R

T

E

5

3

(

N

E

W

T

O

W

N

A

V

E

)

R

T

E

5

3

(

N

E

W

T

O

W

N

A

V

E

)

A

L

L

E

N

R

D

CLARA DR

146 HARTFORD ROADMANCHESTER, CONNECTICUT 06040860.646.2469www.fando.com

NORWALK, CT.

ROUTE 53 @ DRY HILL RD & MURRAY ST OPTION 1

OBJECTIVES

SAFETY - PERCEIVED & REAL

NEIGHBORHOOD SCALE

OPPORTUNITY AREAS

WITHIN ROW (TYP.)

Page 31: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

M

U

R

R

A

Y

S

T

R

E

E

T

D

R

Y

H

I

L

L

R

D

R

T

E

5

3

(

N

E

W

T

O

W

N

A

V

E

)

R

T

E

5

3

(

N

E

W

T

O

W

N

A

V

E

)

A

L

L

E

N

R

D

CLARA DR

146 HARTFORD ROADMANCHESTER, CONNECTICUT 06040860.646.2469www.fando.com

NORWALK, CT.

ROUTE 53 @ DRY HILL RD & MURRAY ST OPTION 2

OPPORTUNITY AREAS

WITHIN ROW (TYP.)

Page 32: Chapter 3-1 - Demonstration Locations - · PDF fileThis chapter summarizes how the ... identifying a project’s needs, developing context ... raised as part of the Plan. Using this

E

L

L

S

S

T

B

A

R

T

L

E

T

T

A

V

E

R

T

E

1

2

3

(

N

E

W

C

A

N

A

A

N

A

V

E

)

R

T

E

1

2

3

(

N

E

W

C

A

N

A

A

N

A

V

E

)

B

A

R

T

L

E

T

T

A

V

E

146 HARTFORD ROADMANCHESTER, CONNECTICUT 06040860.646.2469www.fando.com

NORWALK, CT.

ROUTE 123 @ BARTLETT AVE & ELLS ST

OPTIONS

LANE CHANNELZATION

SIGNAL TIMING

POLICY/ACCESS MANAGEMENT

TEE UP BARTLETT

(THROUGH TRAFFIC CONTINGENT)

OBJECTIVES

ACCESS MANAGEMENT

PEDESTRIAN SAFETY CROSSWALKS

REDUCED CONFLICTS

BIKE CORRIDOR

OPPORTUNITY AREAS

WITHIN ROW (TYP.)