44
Chapter 3 83 CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE INDIAN PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY SINCE 1991 3.1: INTRODUCTION:- The Indian pharmaceutical industry is one of the developing world’s largest and most developed industries in the global sense. India ranks 4th worldwide accounting for 8 percent of the world's production (in terms of volume) and 13th in terms of value. It is estimated that by the year 2010, the Indian pharmaceutical industry will have the potential to achieve over Rs1, 00,000 crores in formulations and bulk drug production 1 . In addition, in the year 2005 Indian pharmaceutical companies captured around 70 percent of the domestic market. In the year 2006-2007 India's gross domestic product (GDP) grew at an impressive 9.2 percent. The growth rate of industrial sector was 10.6 percent in the first nine months of the year 2006-07. The share of industrial sectors of the economy in India's gross domestic product is 26.4 per cent, of which pharmaceutical industry contributed 1.3 percent to gross domestic product in 2006-2007. 2 The pharmaceutical sector value of output grew more than tenfold from Rs. 5700 crores in 1991 it has grown to Rs.51471crores in 2006-07. 3 Indian pharmaceutical industry has growing number of pharmaceutical units, increased knowledge skills, improved quality and increasing national as well as international demand; India is now recognized as a leading global pharmaceutical player. According to the Economic Survey (2006-07), the Indian pharmaceuticals industry had achieved a turnover of about US$12 billion in 2005-06 and is expected to grow by 13 percent in 2007. Its pharmaceutical export value reached about US$ 4.7 billion during 2005-06. Pharmaceutical industry accounts for about 2.91percent of total foreign direct investment into the country. The foreign direct investment in pharmaceutical sector is estimated to have touched US$ 172 million, thereby showing a compound annual growth

CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

83

CHAPTRE – 3

GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE INDIAN

PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY SINCE 1991

3.1: INTRODUCTION:-

The Indian pharmaceutical industry is one of the developing world’s

largest and most developed industries in the global sense. India ranks 4th

worldwide accounting for 8 percent of the world's production (in terms of

volume) and 13th in terms of value. It is estimated that by the year 2010, the

Indian pharmaceutical industry will have the potential to achieve over Rs1,

00,000 crores in formulations and bulk drug production1. In addition, in the

year 2005 Indian pharmaceutical companies captured around 70 percent of the

domestic market. In the year 2006-2007 India's gross domestic product (GDP)

grew at an impressive 9.2 percent. The growth rate of industrial sector was 10.6

percent in the first nine months of the year 2006-07. The share of industrial

sectors of the economy in India's gross domestic product is 26.4 per cent, of

which pharmaceutical industry contributed 1.3 percent to gross domestic

product in 2006-2007.2 The pharmaceutical sector value of output grew more

than tenfold from Rs. 5700 crores in 1991 it has grown to Rs.51471crores in

2006-07.3 Indian pharmaceutical industry has growing number of

pharmaceutical units, increased knowledge skills, improved quality and

increasing national as well as international demand; India is now recognized as

a leading global pharmaceutical player.

According to the Economic Survey (2006-07), the Indian

pharmaceuticals industry had achieved a turnover of about US$12 billion in

2005-06 and is expected to grow by 13 percent in 2007. Its pharmaceutical

export value reached about US$ 4.7 billion during 2005-06. Pharmaceutical

industry accounts for about 2.91percent of total foreign direct investment into

the country. The foreign direct investment in pharmaceutical sector is estimated

to have touched US$ 172 million, thereby showing a compound annual growth

Page 2: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

84

rate of about 62.6 percent. Drugs and pharmaceuticals sector is at 8th rank in

India's top 10 foreign direct investent attracting sectors. According to the

Economic Survey for the year 2006-07, the value of pharmaceutical output has

increased ten times over the last 15 years.

At present India is one of the leading global players in pharmaceutical

sector. India holds fourth position in terms of volume and thirteenth position in

terms of value of production in pharmaceuticals. Thus, the pharmaceutical

industry is a sun-rise industry with vast opportunities for both the domestic and

foreign players. With the changes in the regulatory environment regarding

patent laws, the spotlight is now on India for contract research, joint ventures

and alliances.4

Indian multinational companies like Dr.Reddy's Lab, Cipla, Ranbaxy, etc

have created awareness about the Indian market prospects in the international

pharmaceutical market. Approvals given by Foods and Drugs Administration

(FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug Master File

(DMF) have played an important role in making India a cost effective and high

quality product manufacturer5. Furthermore, the changes that took place in the

patent law, change of process patent to product patent, have helped in reducing

the risk of loss of intellectual property.

Now a day’s tremendous progress has been seen in the pharmaceutical

industry related to infrastructure development, technology base creation and the

wide range of products manufactured. Demand from the exports market has

been growing rapidly due to the capability of Indian players to produce cost-

effective drugs with world class manufacturing facilities. Bulk drugs of all

major therapeutic groups, requiring complicated manufacturing processes are

now being produced in India.

3.2: AN OVERVIEW OF INDIAN PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY:-

Indian Pharmaceutical sector is a highly fragmented industry. The

Indian pharmaceutical industry is estimated to have over 10000 manufacturing

units, as given by Organisation of Pharmaceutical Producer of India. The

Page 3: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

85

organized sector accounts for just 5 percent of the industry with around 300

players, while a huge 95 percent is in the unorganized sector. A large number

of players in unorganized segment are small and medium enterprises and this

segment contributes 35 percent of the industry turnover. There are also 5

Central Public Sector Units that manufacture drugs. These units produce

complete range of pharmaceuticals, which include medicines ready for

consumption by patients and about 350 bulk drugs, i.e., chemicals having

therapeutic value and used for production of pharmaceutical formulations.

India is largely self sufficient in case of formulations. More than 85 percent of

the formulations produced in the country are sold in the domestic market. Some

life saving, new generation under-patent formulations are imported, by

multinational companies which they market in India. Over 60 percent of India's

bulk drug production is exported. The balance is sold locally to other

formulators.

The Indian pharmaceutical industry is valued at US$5.3 billion in 2005,

which is less than one percent of the global pharmaceutical industry (US$550

billion) 6. In early days Pharmaceutical industry had faced tight price controls as

well as weak patent laws. While price regulation has restricted profitability,

weak patent laws facilitate growth in the industry. In fact, the industry has been

competing on its capability of reverse engineering patented product that are

produced by foreign companies and then selling them at lower price.

India’s pharmaceutical industry is one of the fastest growing segments

of the Indian economy with an average annual growth rate of 14 percent during

2002-2005. Over all, the Indian market for pharmaceuticals is projected to

grow at an average annual growth rate of between 15 and 20 percent during

2005 - 2010. The surge in production has been driven by legislative reforms,

the growth in contract manufacturing and outsourcing, value added foreign

acquisitions and joint ventures, India’s mastery of reverse engineering of

patented drug molecules, and India’s efforts to comply with its World Trade

Organization (WTO) Trade Related Intellectual Property Agreements (TRIPS)

obligations.7

Page 4: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

86

When India joined the World Trade Organization in 1995, its

pharmaceutical exports were valued at less than US$600 million. By 2005, its

exports had grown to US$ 3.7 billion and accounted for more than 61 percent

of industry turnover. Currently, Indian pharmaceutical companies produce

between 20 and 22 percent of the world’s generic drugs (in value terms) and

offer 60,000 finished medicines and nearly 400 bulk drugs used in

formulations.8 With changes in Indian patent laws in the early 1970s, Indian

drugs Producers have become experts in ‘reverse engineering’ and have

increased the supply of less expensive copies of the world’s best-selling patent

protected drugs. Reverse engineering means process of recreating a design by

analyzing a final product; and is common in pharmaceutical. Whether reverse

engineering is legal or not depends on whom you ask. The courts have not yet

made a definite ruling. India’s pharmaceutical industry grew and prospered in a

highly regulated environment with government price controls on a significant

number of formulations and bulk drugs. In January 2005, India amended its

patent laws governing pharmaceuticals, bringing them into conformance with

the World Trade Organization and Trade Related Intellectual Property

Agreements. Under the new patent law, Indian drug makers can no longer

manufacture and market reverse engineered versions of drugs patented by

foreign drug producers. To replace sales lost to Trade Related Intellectual

Property Agreements compliance, many of India’s leading pharmaceutical

producers have increased their exports of generic drugs to the United States and

Western Europe and entered into research and development agreements,

undertaken mergers and acquisitions and entered into other alliance with

foreign pharmaceutical firms.

3.3: BRIFE HISTORY OF INDIAN PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY

AND GROWTH UNDER PATENT REGIME:-

The Indian Pharmaceutical Industry is now nearly a century old.

Allopathic medicines were introduced several decades earlier mainly to provide

medical relief to the Britishers. Indigenous production of these medicines was

Page 5: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

87

however started in 1901 with the establishement of Bengal Chemical and

Pharmaceutical Works due to the pioneering efforts of Acharya P.C.Ray. The

unit began with the production of simple galenicals. At the turn of the century,

the British set up several pharmaceutical research institute like the institute of

tropical disease: the King Institute of Preventive Medicine, Madras, in 1904;

the Central Drug Research Institute, Kasauli, in 1905; and the Pasteur Institute,

Conoor, in1907.In 1907 Alembic Chemical Works was established at Baroda

jointly by T.K.Gajjar and Rajmitra B.D.Amin. However, these units faced

several problems like competition from overseas, lack of support from the

Government and prejudice against allopathic medicines at that time. During the

first half of the twentieth century despite modest efforts on the part of the

colonial government. India remained largely dependent on the UK, France and

Germany for medicine supply and had limited technological capabilities. The

Indian Pharmaceutical Industry in pre 1947 started as importer of medicines, in

those days Industrialization aimed at to achieve self reliance and this led to

heavy investment in pharmaceutical and curbon importers, for which the

Government did not discourage foreign firms from competing in India. In

other sectors, self - reliance was pursued at high cost, but pharmaceutical

policies emphasized national health. As there was no substitute for

multinational companies technology, therefore the government did not

discourage them. Between 1947-57, 99 percent of the1704 drugs and

pharmaceutical patents in India were held by foreign multinational companies,

which controlled 80 percent of the market.9 Patent law protection hold on

technology, financial resources and foreign brand names gave them distinct

monopolistic advantages in India. They made high profits while drug prices in

India were amongst the highest in the world. Its inroads into the Indian market.

Up to1970 therefore the Indian pharmaceutical industry consisted almost

entirely of multinational companies, most of which maintained minimal

physical operation in India. Steps to achieve self reliance in pharmaceutical

production started with the establishment of Hindustan Antibiotics Ltd.(HAL)

at Rishikesh and Hyderabad in 1954 and Indian Drugs and Pharmaceutical

Page 6: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

88

Ltd. (IDPL) at Pimpri, Pune, in 1961. In the establishment of the public

sector pharmaceutical enterprise, Russia supplied machinery, personal and

technical know how to produce antibiotics. The Indian Drugs and

Pharmaceutical Ltd development programme helped self reliance in several

ways. It was possible to produce in India at competitive costs, but the Indian

Drugs and Pharmaceutical Ltd programme was insufficient to give boost to

domestic pharmaceutical sector growth. The Indian Patent Act 1970.This act

recognized patent on process and not on products gave boost to growth

domestic pharmaceutical industry. As a result and this, local firms started

legally producing compounds that were patented elsewhere. Consequently,

number of Indian pharmaceutical companies shifted focus to reverse

engineering and cheap sale of copies of all major drugs. Developed country

writers criticized the 1970 Patent Act on ethical grounds.Legislation also

helped to develop the Indian pharmaceutical industry, as it helped the

growth of Indian pharmaceutical industry in the sense that local drugs

manufacturers through adoption of reverse engineering process produced

bulk drug which were processed for the simple formulations or sold at

wholesale level. Meanwhile, multinational companies reluctant to expose their

Intellectual Property in such a lawless market limited their exposure to

India. By 1970 multinational companies had come to account for 30

percent of bulk drugs and 20 percent of locally produced formulations.

Most multinational companies did the bare minimum needed to stay in the

Indian market while awaiting the arrival of stronger patent protection regime.

Even without strong patent protection, The Indian pharmaceutical

industry matured during the 1980. In particular, local companies grew less

reliant upon reveres engineering for revenues. Post 1991 scenario changed with

the establishment of World Trade Organisation and World Intellectual

Property Organisation and nearly all developing countries including India

agreeing to sign on the Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights

agreement. Indian Patent Act 1970 was also modified and made more

harmonious with Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights and

Page 7: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

89

World Intellectual Property Organisation. After the proposed changes to

which India agreed by singing the Agreement on Trade Related Aspects of

Intellectual Property Rights, after which India carried out three amendments

in March 1999, June 2000 and April 2005 to the Patent Act 1970. The third

and final amendment Act ( 2005 ) came into force on 4th April 2005 and

introduced product patent in drugs , food and chemical sector . The

terms of patenting also increased to 20 years. Change in the Patent Laws

also were accompanied by step by step decontrol in the Drug Policy

of the country and drugs were decontrolled leading to market price

determination of price of drugs in the market. These changes in the

policy regime in the 1990s thus started a new chapter in the Indian

Pharmaceutical sector where free imports, foreign investment and

technological superiority determined the structure of the Indian pharmaceutical

industry which viewed globalization as both a challenge and opportunity for

growth.

Under the new patent regime many multinationals are making a come

back on the Indian centre stage; the attractions being India’s traditional

strengths in contract manufacturing and as an outsourcing location for research

and development, particularly for clinical trials and other service.

3.4: STRUCTURE OF INDIAN PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY: -

The Indian Pharmaceutical Industry is currently one of the largest and

most fragmented in the world. The industry certain to grow increasingly

efficient and productive in the coming years. It has shown tremendous progress

in terms of infrastructure development, technology base creation and a wide

range of production. According to the Economic Survey (2006-07), the

pharmaceuticals industry had achieved a turnover of about US$ 12 billion in

2005-06, and is expected to grow by 13 percent in 2007. Its pharmaceutical

export value reached about US$ 4.7 billion during 2005-06. Pharmaceutical

industry accounts for about 2.91 percent of total foreign direct investment into

the country. The foreign direct investment in pharmaceutical sector is estimated

Page 8: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

90

to have touched US$ 172 million, thereby showing a compounded annual

growth rate of about 62.6 percent. Drugs and pharmaceuticals sector is at 8th

rank in India's top 10 foreign direct investment attracting sectors. According to

the Economic Survey for the year 2006-2007, the value of pharmaceutical

output has increased ten times over the last 15 years.

The Pharmaceutical Industry can be broadly divided into Organised

and Unorganised sectors. There are around 300 manufacturing and

formulation units in the organised sector and it accounts for 70 percent of the

total sales of the industry. Around 100 players in the organised sector account

for about 90 percent of the total industry turnover. The market is concentrated

at the top with the top 30 players controlling about 70 percent of the market

share. Moreover, the growth rate of the top 30 players is around 18 percent per

annum as compared with the industry growth rate of about 15 percent. The

organised sector can be classified into Multinational companies and Indian

companies based on management control. The multinational companies, which

had dominated the industry until 1970, began to lose market share following

the failure of the IPA to recognize product patents. The share of multinational

companies declined from about 90 percent in 1970 to about 20 percent in 2000.

Consequently, the market share of the Indian companies increased steadily

from low levels of about 10 percent in 1970 to over 80 percent in 2000.10

The organized sector of the pharmaceutical industry has played a key

role in promoting and sustaining development in this vital field. International

companies associated with this sector have stimulated assisted and spearheaded

this dynamic development and helped to put on the pharmaceutical map of the

world. The pharmaceutical industry in India consists of Government owned

public sectors companies, private sector companies and foreign companies.

These include foreign companies and 5 units in the public sector. Public sector

units are;

1 – Indian Drugs and Pharmaceutical Limited (IDPL)

2 – Hindustan Antibiotics Limited (HAL)

3 – Bengal Chemical and Pharmaceutical Limited (BCPL)

Page 9: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

91

4 – Bengal Immunity Limited (BIL)

5 – Smith Stainstreet Pharmaceuticals Limited (SSPL)

The major multinational players in the organised sector of the industry

are E Merck (India), Parke-Davis (India), Pfizer, Rhone-Poulenc (India),

Glaxo-Wellcome, Novartis, and SmithKline Beecham Pharmaceuticals. The

main Indian bulk drugs and formulations manufacturers in the organised sector

are Dr.Reddy's Laboratories, Ipca laboratories, J B Chemicals &

Pharmaceuticals, Nicholas Piramal India, Ranbaxy, Cipla, Sun

Pharmaceuticals, and Wockhardt.

With the reduced role of the state under globalisation, the public sector

drug companies are faced with serious problems including imminent closures.

Public sector drug companies like Indian Drugs and Pharmaceuticals Ltd.

(IDPL), Hindustan Antibiotics Ltd. (HAL), Bengal Chemicals and

Pharmaceuticals Ltd. (BCPL), Bengal Immunity (BI) and Smith Stanistreet

Pharmaceuticals Ltd. (SSPL) played an important role in the production of

essential drugs at affordable prices. Under the globalisation process, the role of

the public sector has been marginalised and they have been made sick.

Attempts either have been made to privaties or close them. The Penicillin Plant

in HAL, the biggest in the country, has been handed over to private hands. Its

Streptomycin plant also has been leased to a private company for manufacture

of other drugs. Indian Drugs and Pharmaceutical Ltd which is having the

biggest pharmaceutical plant in Asia, is closed from 1996 for want of proper

financial assistance from the government. The public sector drug companies

used to supply raw materials to the small-scale sector companies. Now, these

companies are facing difficulties in procuring raw materials. Similar is the fate

of Bengal Chemical and Pharmaceutical Limited , Bengal Immunity Limited

and Smith Stainstreet Pharmaceuticals Limited . These three units were taken

over by the government after the private owners made them sick. Proper

utilization of their capacity could not be made due to lack of will on the part of

the government, mismanagement at the administrative level and high level

corruption.11

Page 10: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

92

It is not because of any inherent weakness but due to the lack of

political will, deliberate efforts to destroy them, corruption and

mismanagement that these public sector units have been rendered

commercially unviable. Moreover, the numbers of workers engaged in these

units have been reduced drastically. When Indian Drugs and Pharmaceutical

Limited was established it had strength of more than 15000 workers, today it

has been reduce to less than 7000.

With the pharmaceutical industry taking, a leap towards a

biotechnology development worldwide, only the public sector drug companies,

with the backing of the Central Government, could have faced the challenge

effectively from the multinational companies in the new situation. Even while

undergoing restructuring, it has established its presence and determination to

flourish in the changing environment. The industries now produce bulk drugs

belonging to all major therapeutic gropes. Strong scientific and technical work

force and pioneering work done in process development have contributed to

this.

In 2006-07 the pharmaceutical industry had a capital investment of Rs.

7100 crore. It produced bulk drugs worth Rs.13600 crore in 2006-07, and

formulation worth Rs.21107 crore in 2001-02. The annual turnover Rs.35800

crore in 2005-06.the research and development expenditure Rs. 2350 in 2006-

07.12

The sector is strong technologically and the following form the basis of

the technological strengths of the Indian pharmaceutical industry;

1- Self reliance displayed by the production of 70 percent of bulk drugs and

almost the entire requirement of formulation within the country.

2 – Cost advantage in terms of drug production, maintenance of high standards

in terms of purity, stability and international safety, health and environment

protection

3 – Low research and development costs

4 – An excellent centre for clinical trials

5 – World class national laboratories in process development

Page 11: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

93

6 – Increasing balance of trade in pharmaceutical sector

7 - Knowledge based industry

8 – Increasing balance of trade in the sector

9 – Strong scientific and technical manpower

10 – Major driver of growth in the future

11 – Tremendous export potential

12 - Developing cost effective technologies for drug intermediaries and bulk

actives without a compromise on quality.

India has a significant share in the global generics market and is ranked

third. In recent years, this segment has been facing stiff competition, which

makes the scale of production important to improve profitability. India has pre-

dominantly been a generic player and has the potential to gain a global

presence for the following key developments:

Multiple branded drug patent expirations in the short term. According to

IMS Health, in 2006 and 2007 a total of US$ 28 billion and US$ 20

billion, respectively of branded sales were likely to become susceptible

to the entry of generic equivalents.

Increasing confidence of consumers in generics in the developed

markets.

A pro-generic sentiment from healthcare authorities driven by the

pressure of containing rising healthcare costs.

An aging population across the world, leading to increasing demand for

low cost therapies.

• Global healthcare crisis like AIDS in the developing world,

necessitating affordable medication for the masses.

Generic companies in India are recognizing the importance of

patent expiriy and are making significant incremental investments in research

and drug development.

Page 12: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

94

3.4.1: PRODUCTION:-

The Indian pharmaceutical industry today is in the front rank of

India’s science based industries with wide ranging capabilities in the complex

field of drug manufacture and technology. The industries produce two kinds of

products bulk drugs and formulations. Bulk drugs are active chemical

substances in powder form, the main ingredient in pharmaceuticals.

Formulations are final preparation, such as tablets, capsules, injectables and

syrups, sold as a brand or generic product. Eighty one percent of industry sales

are formulations. The industry produces about 60000 finished medicines and

roughly 400 bulk drugs, which are used in the formulations.

• On the basis of formulations, the pharmaceutical industry can

further be classified into:

1: Prescription medicines:

Also known as ethical formulations. They can be dispensed

only on the prescription from a qualified medical practitioner.

2: Over-the-counter medicines:

Also known as Over The Counter formulations. They can be

dispensed even in the absence of prescription e.g. analgesics, cough drugs, etc.

PRODUCT STRUCTURE

Bulk Drugs Formulations

Generic Branded

Patented Off -

Patented

Pharmaceutical Products

Page 13: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

95

TABLE NO: 3.1

COMPOSITION AND GROWTH PRODUCTION OF BULK DRUGS

AND FORMULATIONS (Rs. in crore)

Source: Organization of Pharmaceutical Producer of India (various issue)

• Figures in brackets show the percentage to Total Production

Years

Bulk

Drugs Formulations Total

1991-1992 900 (15.78)

4800 (84.21)

5700 (100)

1992-1993 1150 (16.08)

6000 (83.91)

7150 (100)

1993-1994 1320 (16.05)

6900 (83.94)

8220 (100)

1994-1995 1518 (16.05)

7935 (83.94)

9453 (100)

1995-1996 1822 (16.64)

9125 (83.35)

10947 (100)

1996-1997 2186 (17.23)

10494 (82.76)

12680 (100)

1997-1998 2623 (17.85)

12068 (82.14)

14691 (100)

1998-1999 3148 (18.48)

13878 (81.51)

17026 (100)

1999-2000 3777 (19.13)

15960 (80.86)

19737 (100)

2000-2001 4533 (19.80)

18354 (80.19)

22887 (100)

2001-2002 5440 (20.49)

21107 (79.50)

26547 (100)

2002-2003 6500 (21.18)

24185 (78.02)

30685 (100)

2003-2004 7800 (21.97)

27692 (78.02)

35492 (100)

2004-2005 9400 (23.21)

31092 (78.02)

40492 (100)

2005-2006 11300 (24.76)

34324 (57.23)

45624 (100)

2006-2007 13600 (26.42)

37871 (73.57)

51471 (100)

C.G.R (1991-92 to

2006-07) 19.65 14.68 15.66

CORREL (1991-92 to

2006-07) 0.993681 0.999155 -

Page 14: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

96

FIGURE NO: 3.1

DISTRIBUTION OF PRODUCTION OF BULK DRUGS AND FORMULATIONS: 1991-91

AND 2006-07 IN %

Year 1991-92

16%

84%

Bulk Drugs

Formulation

Year 2006-07

26%

74%

FIGURE NO: 3.2

COMPOSITION AND GROWTH OF PRODUCTION OF BULK DRUGS AND

FORMULATIONS

(Values in Rs.crore)

0

10000

20000

30000

40000

50000

60000

19

91

-92

19

92

-93

19

93

-94

19

94

-95

19

95

-96

19

96

-97

19

97

-98

19

98

-99

19

99

-20

00

20

00

-01

20

01

-02

20

02

-03

20

03

-04

20

04

-05

20

05

-06

20

06

-07

Year

Va

lues

in R

s. c

ro

res

Bulk Drugs

Formulation

Total

Page 15: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

97

• On the basis of formulations patent, pharmaceutical industry can be

classified as:-

1: Branded formulations: -

They are ethical formulations prepared using a bulk drug under

product patent and are marketed by a single pharmaceutical company.

2: Generics:-

They are formulations that do not contain any patented bulk drug

and can be manufactured by more than one company.

The industry now produces bulk drugs belonging to all major

therapeutic groups requiring complicated manufacturing process and has

developed Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP) facilities for the production

of different dosage forms. The pharma industry exports drugs and

pharmaceuticals worth over US$ 4.5 billion. It ranks 17th in terms of export

value of bulk actives and dosage. Indian exports cover more than 200 countries

including the highly regulated markets of USA, Europe, Japan and Australia.

As the manufacture of most bulk drugs is neither capital intensive nor

technology intensive, process reverse engineering encouraged the growth of

production bases. There are a large number of bulk drug manufacturers in

India, including many small scale industries. This has increased competition,

leading to a drop in prices and consequently lower margins. Most bulk drugs

under the drug price control order sell below the government administered

prices due to stiff competition and lower import tariffs.

Table No 3.1 shows the production figures of bulk drugs and

formulations from 1990-91 to 2006-2007. The Table No. 3.1 presents the

annual production of bulk drugs and formulations shows that the drugs and

pharmaceuticals sector has continued to maintain steady growth in terms of

production of bulk drugs and formulations. Several proposals for foreign

collaboration for joint venture, research and developments, expansion of

existing units have been received. The present table clearly states that

Page 16: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

98

production of the Indian Pharmaceutical Industry shows increasing trends since

1991-1992 to 2006-2007.

The domestic pharmaceutical industry output exceeds Rs.51471crore of

this around 74 percent is formulations and 26 percent is bulk drugs. Production

of both bulk drugs and formulations increased at a very rapid pace between

1991-1992 to 2006-2007.

Table No.3.1 shows growth of bulk drugs of Indian Pharmaceutical

Industry. The data in table indicates that since 1991-1992 to 2006-2007. The

production of bulk drugs was Rs.900 crore in 1991-92, Rs. 1822 crore in 1995-

96, Rs.5440 crore in 2001-02, and Rs. 13600 crore in 2006-07 and registering a

growth about 15.11 times over the study period.

The bulk drug industry in India has grown considerably over the past

twenty years from Rs. 480 crore in 1987-88 to Rs. 13600 crore in 2006-07,

however, the share of bulk drugs range between 15.97 percent to 26.42 percent

within the total production of pharmaceutical industry. The domestic

pharmaceutical output has increased from Rs.730 in 1990-91 to Rs.13600 crore

in 2006-07. Bulk drug however, maintained the same growth of 16.05 percent

in 1993-94 as in 1994-95. In 1994-95 the compounded annual growth rate of

bulk drug of Indian pharmaceutical industry for the period 1991-92 to 2006-07

is approximately 19.65 percent.

The production of formulations has also increased over the past few

years. It has increased from Rs. 4800 crore in 1991-92 Rs. 9125 crore in 1995-

96, Rs.21107 crore in 2001-02, and Rs. 37871 crore in 2006-07 and registering

a growth about 7.88 times over the study period. Formulation however,

maintained the same growth of 83.94 percent in 1993-94 as in 1995-96. In

1995-96 the production of bulk drugs and formulation were valued at Rs.1822

crore and Rs.9125 crore respectively. The compounded annual growth rate of

formulation of Indian pharmaceutical industry for the period 1991-92 to 2006-

07 is approximately 14.68 percent.

However the share of bulk drugs range between 84.02 percent

to73.57percent within the total production of Pharmaceutical Industry. The

Page 17: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

99

domestic pharmaceutical output has increased from Rs.3840 crore in 1990-91

to Rs.37871 crore in 2006-07. The production of Drugs and Pharmaceutical

Industry is growing constantly. Just before seven years from now in 1999-2000

the production of bulk drug was worth Rs 3777 crore and formulation was at

Rs.15960 crore which has been estimated to grow at Rs. 11300 crore for bulk

drugs production and Rs. 34324 crore for formulations production in 2005-06.

Indian production both bulk drugs and formulations, initially both bulk

drugs production has also been greater than in terms of value production of

formulations since 1994-95.

Before 1991, the focus of most Indian companies was mostly on

consolidating Indian market. This gave way to an emphasis export led growth

in the 1990s. The growth after 1991 has therefore been higher than earlier

period. The Industry manufactures bulk drugs belonging to several major

therapeutic groups requiring various manufacturing processes and has

developed excellent facilities for production of all dosage forms like tablets,

capsules, liquids, ointments, orals and injectibles. This achievement is

strengthened by an assurance with regard to quality of the products. Over the

last several years, policy inputs have been directed towards promoting the

growth of the industry and in helping it to achieve a broad base in terms of the

large range of the products and technologies needed to produce them from as

basic stage as possible.

3.4.2: CAPITAL INVESTMENTS:

The capital investment in the pharmaceutical industry over the sixteen

years is presented in Table No.3.2. The investment follows a steady pattern

over the period 1991-92 to 2006-07 growing from Rs. 950 crore in 1991-92 to

Rs. 6000 crore in 2005-06. With the current government policies and rate of

return prevalent in the pharmaceutical industry, the investment can be accepted

to grow further in the coming years 13.

The current capital investment in the industry is estimated at Rs.7100

crore against Rs.24 crore in 1952 and Rs. 56 crore in 1962 and Rs. 600 crore in

Page 18: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

100

TABLE NO: 3.2

GROWTH OF CAPITAL INVESTMENT IN PHARMACUTICAL

INDUSTRY IN INDIA

(Rs. in crore)

Source: As of Table No. 3.1

1982. The capital investment has also increased over the past few years. It has

increased from Rs. 950 crore in 1991-92 Rs. 1380 crore in 1995-96, Rs.3400

Years Investment

1991-1992 950

1992-1993 1000

1993-1994 1060

1994-1995 1200

1995-1996 1380

1996-1997 1600

1997-1998 1840

1998-1999 2150

1999-2000 2500

2000-2001 2941

2001-2002 3400

2002-2003 3900

2003-2004 4500

2004-2005 5200

2005-2006 6000

2006-2007 7100

C.G.R (1991-92 to

2006-07) 15.07

Page 19: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

101

crore in 2001-02, and Rs. 7100 crore in 2006-07 and registering a growth of

about 7.47 times over the study period.

However, the share of bulk drugs range between 2.03 percent

to15.51percent within the capital investment of pharmaceutical Industry. The

compounded annual growth rate of capital investment of Indian pharmaceutical

industry for the period 1991-92 to 2006-07 is approximately 15.07 percent.

Capital investment of Indian pharmaceutical industry 7.4 fold over the 1991-

92.

FIGURE NO: 3.3

GROWTH OF CAPITAL INVESTMENT IN PHARMACUTICAL

INDUSTRY IN INDIA

(Values in Rs.crores)

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

7000

8000

1991-

1992

1992-

1993

1993-

1994

1994-

1995

1995-

1996

1996-

1997

1997-

1998

1998-

1999

1999-

2000

2000-

2001

2001-

2002

2002-

2003

2003-

2004

2004-

2005

2005-

2006

2006-

2007

Year

Va

lues

in

Rs.

cro

res

Investment

Page 20: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

102

3.4.3: RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT EXPENDITURE:-

In international trade theory many studies have shown that growth

performance and competitive advantages of countries is always related to the

extent of activities of technological innovation and even imitation. Technology

developments measured by the patent and the amount of research and

development expenditure have great impact on trade performance of

countries.14 The same logic can also be used for growth of a particular industry

or firm. This applies very correctly in case of the pharmaceutical industry as it

is technology based and innovations through research and development can

held in new novel drug discovery leading to new drugs entering the market.

Process and technological change leading to improve production of drugs and

formulations can take place through improvements in products, production

process, and raw material and also through increase in efficiency of the

management system. Technology based improvements through innovations can

be measured by the amount of research and development expenditure made by

pharmaceutical firms, growth of research and development in pharmaceutical

industry in various countries during the period 1997-2001 shows that this

growth in percentage terms was as high as 94 percent in finland, 23 percent in

UK, research and development expenditure as percent of sales in 2002 was

19.7 percent in France, 17.7 percent in Germany, 37.1 percent in Korea.15

India’s pharmaceutical industry did not invest heavily in research and

development. One of the major reasons for this was that there were no product

patent laws in place for pharmaceutical products in India. Without product

patents, domestic Indian firms have grown their indigenous market through the

creation of different processes. In 1999, Indian firms spent only 1.8 percent of

sales in research and development. This trend, however, was changing with

major players such as Ranbaxy, Dr. Reddy’s, and Torrent, recognizing that to

remain viable once product patent laws took effect, they must begin developing

their own molecules to compete effectively in India and abroad.

The investment in research and development is also on the rise as it has

become important for Indian companies to start innovating new drugs in order

Page 21: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

103

to ensure long term sustainable growth and remain competitive at the global

level. Indian companies have invested in New Chemical Entity (NCE) research

and are scouting for global partners for pursuing collaborative research. The

availability of large patient base, skilled manpower and lower costs of carrying

out clinical trials has made India a favorable destination for research and

development outsourcing.

Investment in research and development by industry as a whole in India

has been low only around 0.6 percent of the turnover. In the Indian

pharmaceutical industry, the average research and development expenditure is

around 2 percent of the turnover contributed by around 150 companies. The

low investment in research and development is due to the low levels of

profitability and comparatively small size of the companies. However, the

scenario is now changing. Some pharmaceutical companies now spend nearly 5

percent of their turnover on research and development .

The research and development expenditure by the Indian pharmaceutical

industry is around 1.9 percent of the industry’s turnover. This obviously, is

very low when compared to the investment on research and development by

foreign research based pharmaceutical companies. They spend 10 to 16 percent

of the turnover on research and development. However, now that India is

entering into the Patent protection area, many companies are spending

relatively more on research and development. Indian Pharmaceutical Industry,

with its rich scientific talents, provides cost effective clinical trial research. It

has an excellent record of development of improved, cost-beneficial chemical

syntheses for various drug molecules. Some multinational companies are

already sourcing these services from their Indian affiliates.

Pharmaceutical research and development can be broadly classified

into three categories:

1. New chemical entities (NCEs);

2. Modification of existing NCEs (new chemical derivatives, new

formulations, and new combinations) and

3. New processes for manufacturing drugs.

Page 22: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

104

Until recently, the research and development activities in India

focused on the third category, namely, new process of manufacturing of

drugs. Research and development on analogues, i.e. modified versions of

the original molecules, has been an area of intensive activity by the Indian

companies.

Driven by the imminent change to a product patent regime at home

from 2005 and the opportunities offered in the international market, the

mindset of Indian companies towards research has altered. The new mindset is

to have a strong foothold in regulated markets and shift from business-driven

research-to-research-driven business. Indian companies are shifting their focus

to innovative research, that is, developing non-infringing processes, New

Chemical Entities (NCEs), Novel Drug Delivery Systems (NDDS),

biopharmaceuticals etc.

The leading pharmaceutical companies in India have been increasing

their research and development budgets over the years. The research and

development expenditure of the Indian pharmaceuticals industry had increased

from Rs.12 crore in 1977 to Rs.400 crore in 2001. During 1996-2002, the top

10 Indian pharmaceutical companies annual recurring research and

development expense jumped 32.3 percent on a year-on-year basis. These

companies made a total capital investment of US$ 116 million over the same

period. The average research and development expenditure of the major Indian

companies has increased to nearly 6 per cent of sales during the financial year

2004 from nearly 2 per cent, two to three years ago. Indian pharmaceutical

companies are likely to double their expenditure on research and development

over the next 2 years.

In the year 2006, research and development erpenditure grew by 12

percent. There are as many as 18 New Chemical Entities (NCEs) developed by

different pharmaceutical companies currently undergoing various phases of

clinical trials. Major domestic players namely Ranbaxy, Dr. Reddy’s Labs,

Cipla, Nicholas Piramal and Wockhardt are aggressively investing in research

and development. DrReddy’s Labs, Ranbaxy and Wockhardt have achieved

Page 23: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

105

some early breakthroughs in New Chemical Entities (NCEs). In some cases,

these companies have out licensed their molecules to global pharmaceutical

leaders, which speak highly of their research capabilities

Source: SSKI

The following table shows the research and development expenditure of

Indian pharmaceutical industry from 1991-92 to 2006-2007.

The Table No. 3.3 shows that the research and development expenditure

has continued to maintain steady growth. The present table clearly states that

research and development expenditure of the Indian Pharmaceutical Industry

shows increasing trends since 1991-1992 to 2006-2007.

The research and development expenditure in India has grown

considerably over the past twenty years from Rs. 50 crore in 1987-88 to Rs.

Speciality Generics

Indian

Pharmaceutical

R and D Initiatives Improved Chemical

Entities

NCE

Generics in

Developed

Countries

NDDS

Biopharmaceuticals

Chemical Synthesis

Page 24: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

106

TABLE NO: 3.3

RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT EXPENDITURE OF INDIAN

PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY

(Values Rs. In Crore)

Source: As of Table No. 3.1

Year Sales

R and D

Expenditure

R and D Expenditure

as percentage of sales

1991-1992 9624 70 0.642716

1992-1993 12136 78 0.73336

1993-1994 14181.3 104 0.823529

1994-1995 17000 140 0.780488

1995-1996 20500 160 0.820305

1996-1997 22552.6 185 0.982582

1997-1998 22390 220 1

1998-1999 26000 260 1.155235

1999-2000 27700 320 1.380818

2000-2001 26433.6 365 1.377558

2001-2002 29036.9 400 1.704586

2002-2003 32265.9 550 1.73544

2003-2004 38030.7 660 2.953448

2004-2005 39953.3 1180 2.827609

2005-2006 43146 1220 6.564246

2006-2007 35800 2350 6.564246

C.G.R (1991-92 to 2006-

07) 9.19 23.46

CORREL (1991-92 to 2006-07) 0.72

Page 25: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

107

FIGURE NO: 3.4

TRENDS OF RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT EXPENDITURE OF

INDIAN PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY

(Values in Rs. Crore)

0

5000

10000

15000

20000

25000

30000

35000

40000

45000

50000

1991

-199

2

1992

-199

3

1993

-199

4

1994

-199

5

1995

-199

6

1996

-199

7

1997

-199

8

1998

-199

9

1999

-200

0

2000

-200

1

2001

-200

2

2002

-200

3

2003

-200

4

2004

-200

5

2005

-200

6

2006

-200

7

Year

Valu

es in

Rs.

crore

Sales

R&D

Expenditure

FIGURE NO: 3.5

DISTRIBUTION OF RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT

EXPENDITURE OF INDIAN PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY: 1991-92 AND 2006-07 (IN %)

Year 2006-2007

94%

6%

Year 1991-1992

99%

1%

Sales R and D Exp.

Page 26: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

108

2350 crore in 2006-07. The compounded annual growth rate of research and

development expenditure of Indian pharmaceutical industry for the period

1991-92 to 2006-07 is approximately 23.46 and registering a growth of about

33.37 times over the study period.

The current research and development expenditure in the industry is

estimated at Rs.2350 crore against Rs.5.86 crore in 1972 and Rs. 29.3 crore in

1981 and Rs. 48 crore in 1985.

The research and development expenditure has also increased over the

past few years. It has increased from Rs. 70 crore in 1991-92 Rs. 160 crore in

1995-96, Rs.365 crore in 2000-01 and Rs. 2350 crore in 2006-07.

The Indian pharmaceutical industry spends about 1.8 per cent, on

average, of its sales on research and development. This is higher than the

average for Indian industry, which is around 0.7 percent.

A key aspect of technological change in the pharmaceutical sector in

India is the close interaction between private sector firms and publicly funded

laboratories of the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR). The

three laboratories that are most active in drugs research are the National

Chemical Laboratory (NCL) located in Pune; the Central Drug Research

Institute (CDRI) located in Lucknow; and the Indian Institute of Chemical

Technology (IICT) located in Hyderabad.

The Government offers various incentives in the form of tax

concessions and exemptions of specific products from the purview of price

controls to encourage firms to engage in research and development . The

pharmaceutical industry is eligible for weighted deduction for research and

development expenses up to 150 percent. Three categories of drugs are exempt

from price controls for specific periods. These are:

(a) Drugs using processes developed through indigenous research and

development effort for a period of five years;

(b) Drugs using a new drug delivery system developed indigenously and

approved for marketing, for a period of five

Page 27: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

109

(c) New products developed in India, for a period of 10 years

Amount of research and development expenditure in pharmaceutical

industry is very important for the growth of the industry. Research in

laboratories in drugs needs to always increase so that new industrial application

of the same can be clinically tested and then drugs for commercial sales

manufactured. The amount of research and development made holds the key

for the future growth of this industry. Experience in Western countries has

proved that multinational companies have from brining put more money in

research and development and this has helped their growth in future. Private

sector imitative in this regard is more positive. Ploughing back of profits into

research and development helps the future growth and this was done by private

multinational companies. It is only after 1990s that this trend has been noticed

in India. Further new research and development initiatives are protected well

under new post World Trade Organisation and intellectual property rights

regime and therefore more research and development is neassary for Indian

pharmaceutical future growth. This also calls in for more university industry

Inter-action in areas of applied science research University departments in

science need to go in for more research that the need of industry so that this

collaborative research helps industries. Pharmaceutical industry can also fund

specific research projects so that novel drug discovery is facilitated with

infrastructure of Universities in India.

3.4.4: FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT IN PHARMACEUTICAL

INDUSTRY IN INDIA:-

The pharmaceutical industry has been selected as one of the sunrise

areas where concerted efforts are being made to attract foreign direct

investment (FDI). The Government of India has not only abolished industrial

licensing for bulk drugs, intermediates and formulations but has allowed

automatic foreign direct investment approvals up to 100 percent foreign

ownership. During 1991-2004, the drugs and pharmaceutical sector attracted

nearly Rs 35 billion in foreign direct investment inflows hitherto, the fear of

Page 28: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

110

not recognizing product patents in India made multinational companies shy

away from comprehensive technology transfer to their Indian affiliates.

Controls over the operations of foreign enterprises that were imposed

largely through the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act (FERA) in 1973, were

rapidly reduced through the 1990s.

In 1994, the Government allowed foreigners to hold up to 51 per cent of

the equity capital of enterprises registered in India. This change in policy led

many firms, which had reduced their foreign shareholdings in the 1970s to 40

per cent or less to meet the requirements of Foreign Exchange Regulation Act ,

to increase the foreign share to 51 per cent (for a list of firms which increased

their foreign equity to 51 per cent).

However, apart from the increase in foreign

stakes of some of the major firms operating in India, the pharmaceutical sector

was not among the major beneficiaries of foreign direct investment inflows

during the 1990s; it accounted for only 0.4 percent of total foreign direct

investment approvals during the period 1991-1999, amounting US$ 260

million.

The real interest of foreign firms in the Indian market will be better

assessed only after India starts giving product patents in pharmaceuticals from

2005. Reporting on disinvestments in the pharmaceutical sector by the firms,

Nicholas, Merind, Roche, and Searle, the Government of India Annual Report,

1993-94 gives the following reasons: the pricing system, lack of patent

protection, advantages in entering into licensing arrangements with local India

firms rather than direct investment.

The benefits for the Indian pharmaceutical industry resulting from the

policy environment change since the beginning of the 1970s also are important.

It is clear that the instruments of policy introduced by the Government during

this phase suited the industry, a fact borne out by its performance over time.

While the more protected environment in the 1970s and 1980s helped the

domestic enterprises to establish their presence in the industry, the adoption of

an open economy framework in the 1990s encouraged the leading firms to

Page 29: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

111

TABLE NO: 3.4

FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT INFLOWS INTO INDIA

(Rs in. million)

Year All sector Pharmaceutical Share of

pharmaceuticals

(%)

Aug1991-Dec

1999

576821.15 8221.75 1.43

2000 123537.34 2079.88 1.68

2001 167777.54 4081.79 2.43

2002 181955.56 2510.52 1.38

2003 116171.7 2793.28 2.40

2004 172665.2 15711.08 9.10

2005 192990.9 5107.25 2.64

Total 1531920 40505.55 2.64

CORRE

(2000 to 2005)

- 0.27 -

C.G.R(2000 to

2005)

5.48 28.00 -

Source: Government of India, Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion, Ministry of

Commerce and Industry, Secretariat for Industrial Assistance, SIA Newsletter, Various Issues

of related years.

Page 30: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

112

expand their overseas operations. The latter aspect can be best understood by

analyzing the performance of the leading firms in the industry.

The Table No.3.4 shows that the all sector investment and

pharmaceutical sector investment has continued to maintain steady growth. The

present table clearly states foreign direct investment that of the Indian

Pharmaceutical Industry shows increasing trends since 1991-1992 to 2006-

2007.

The above table shows the foreign direct investment of Indian

pharmaceutical industry from 1991-92 to 2006-2007.The present table clearly

states that foreign direct investment of the Indian Pharmaceutical Industry

shows increasing trends since 1991-1992 to 2006-2007.

The foreign direct investment in India has grown considerably over the

past seventeen years. The compounded annual growth rate of foreign direct

investment of Indian pharmaceutical industry for the period 2000 to 2005 is

approximately 28 and registering a growth about 2.45 times over the study

period.

The current foreign direct investment in the pharmaceutical industry is

estimated at Rs.40505.55 million against Rs.2079.88 million in 2000 and Rs.

2793.28 million in 2003. The foreign direct investment has also increased over

the past few years. The share of foreign direct investment 2.64 percent within

the total investment of all sectors. In 2005, foreign direct investment was low

compare to previous year.

The percentage of foreign direct investment approved increased sharply

in the year 2000. It could be in part due to amendment in the Patent Act 1970.

The modified act came into force in 1999. Besides, at the beginning of 2000 the

Indian government announced a change in policy regarding the level of

investment by foreign multinationals in their Indian subsidiaries and new joint

ventures. Foreign companies can now have equity stakes of up to 100 per cent

previously it was 51 percent. In the late 1990s, a number of multinational

companies had applied to India’s Foreign Investment Promotion Board for

setting up 100 per cent owned subsidiaries.

Page 31: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

113

3.4.5: SALES:-

Table No 3.5 shows sales figures of pharmaceutical production. Indian

pharmaceutical industry sale bulk drugs, formulations and generic drugs in

domestic as well export market from 1990-91 to 2006-2007.

TABLE NO: 3.5

SALES OF INDIAN PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY

(Rs. in crore)

Source: Industry, Market Size & Shares (CMIE Reports), Aug 2000, Aug 2001, June 2007

Years Sales

1991-92 9624

1992-93 12136

1993-94 14181.3

1994-95 17000

1995-96 20500

1996-97 22552.6

1997-98 22390

1998-99 26000

1999-2000 27700

2000-01 26433.6

2001-02 29036.9

2002-03 32265.9

2003-04 38030.7

2004-05 39953.3

2005-06 43146

2006-07 35800

C.G.R(1991-92 TO 2006-07) 9.19

Increase in 2007 over 1991 3.71

Page 32: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

114

The Table No. 3.5 presents the annual sales of bulk drugs, formulations

and others shows that the drugs and pharmaceuticals sector has continued to

maintain steady growth in terms of sales.

Table No.3.5 shows growth of sales of Indian Pharmaceutical Industry.

The data in table indicates that since 1991-1992 to 2006-2007. the sales of

pharmaceutical product was Rs.9624 crore in 1991-92, Rs. 20500 crore in

1995-96, Rs.29036.9 crore in 2001-02, and Rs. 35800 crore in 2006-07 and

registering a growth about 3.71 times over the study period. The compounded

annual growth rate of sales of Indian pharmaceutical industry for the period

1991-92 to 2006-07 is approximately 9.19%. Bulk drug however, maintained

the same growth of 16.05 percent in 1993-94 as in 1994-95.In 1994-95.

FIGURE NO: 3.6

SALES OF INDIAN PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY

(Values in Rs.crores)

0

5000

10000

15000

20000

25000

30000

35000

40000

45000

50000

1991

-92

1992

-93

1993

-94

1994

-95

1995

-96

1996

-97

1997

-98

1998

-99

1999

-200

0

2000

-01

2001

-02

2002

-03

2003

-04

2004

-05

2005

-06

2006

-07

Year

Va

lues

in R

s. c

rore

Sales

Page 33: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

115

3.4.6: DOMESTIC CONSUMPTION:-

Domestic pharmaceutical consumption means use of total production by

domestic population. The following table shows domestic consumption of

Indian pharmaceutical industry from 1991-92 to 2006-07.

TABLE NO: 3.6

DOMESTIC CONSUMPTION OF INDIAN PHARMACEUTICAL

INDUSTRY

(Rs. In Crore)

Source: As of Table No. 3.5

Years D. Consumption

1991-92 8632.4

1992-93 11416.2

1993-94 12980.1

1994-95 15424.9

1995-96 18449.2

1996-97 21747.4

1997-98 22027.8

1998-99 25359.1

1999-2000 22086.1

2000-01 23304.3

2001-02 24191.9

2002-03 24039.1

2003-04 25244.8

2004-05 23311.5

2005-06 24536.3

Increase in 2005-06 over 1991-92 2.84

C.G.R(1991-92 to 2006-07) 6.5

Page 34: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

116

FIGURE NO: 3.7

DOMESTIC CONSUMPTION OF INDIAN PHARMACEUTICAL

INDUSTRY

(Values in Rs.crores)

0

5000

10000

15000

20000

25000

30000

1991-92

1992-93

1993-94

1994-95

1995-96

1996-97

1997-98

1998-99

1999-2000

2000-01

2001-02

2002-03

2003-04

2004-05

2005-06

Year

Va

lue

s in

Rs.

cr

or

e

D. Consumption

The Table No.3.6 shows the annual domestic consumption of bulk

drugs, formulations and others. During the study period domestic consumption

has increased from 1991-92 to 2006-07.

Page 35: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

117

The data in table indicates that since 1991-1992 to 2006-2007. The

domestic consumption of pharmaceutical product was Rs.8632.4 crore in 1991-

92, Rs. 18449.2 crore in 1995-96, Rs. 24191.9 crore in 2001-02, and Rs.

24536.3 crore in 2006-07 and registering a growth about 2.84 times over the

study period. The compounded annual growth rate of domestic consumption of

Indian pharmaceutical industry for the period 1991-92 to 2006-07 is 6.5

percent.

With the onset of economics reforms, the growth of the Indian economy

has increased and has also become steady. Industrial and service sector growth

rates have increased and this has resulted in rise in per capita incomes more so

in urban and semi-urban areas. Rise in per capita incomes has increased the

capacity of people to spend more on health and hug genie care of the family

and with this rise sales of the pharmaceutical industry and health care and even

cosmetic industry is rising, leading to more domestic sales of the

pharmaceutical industry in India. A large population with growing per capita

income leads to increase in domestic sales.

As sales both domestic and foreign increase the production of

pharmaceutical industry has also increased and the turnover of this industry

increased during the period under study.

This can be measured by the size of the market for the period under the

study. The rise in market size of the pharmaceutical industry during the post

reforms period is depicted in Table No.3.7. The market size which was

Rs.1018.5 crore in 1991-92 increased to Rs.29316.2 crore in 1999-2000 and

further rose to Rs. 46115.2 crore by the year 2005-06. Compound Growth Rate

rise was 11.14 percent and this adequately reveals that the overall market size

depicting the sales of the pharmaceutical industry has grown at an impressive

rate during the period under the study.

Page 36: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

118

TABLE NO: 3.7

MARKET SIZE OF INDIAN PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY

(Rs. In Crore)

Source: As of Table No. 3.5

Years Market Size

1991-92 10182.5

1992-93 12949.2

1993-94 14989.8

1994-95 17937.2

1995-96 21858

1996-97 26089.2

1997-98 2447.1

1998-99 31615.2

1999-2000 29316.2

2000-01 32061.8

2001-02 34026.6

2002-03 36865.2

2003-04 40458

2004-05 41169.3

2005-06 46115.2

Increase in 2007 over

1991 4.52

C.G.R(1991-92 to

2005-06 11.14

Page 37: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

119

FIGURE NO: 3.8

MARKET SIZE OF INDIAN PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY

(Values in Rs.crores)

0

5000

10000

15000

20000

25000

30000

35000

40000

45000

50000

1991

-92

1992

-93

1993-

94

1994-

95

1995-

96

1996-

97

1997-

98

1998-

99

1999-

2000

2000-

01

2001-

02

2002-

03

2003-

04

2004-

05

2005-

06

Year

Va

lues

in R

s.C

ro

re

Market Size

3.4.8: HEALTH INFRASTRUCTURE:-

The government, public sector and private sector provide healthcare

services in India. The size of the Indian healthcare delivery market is estimated

at US$18.7 billion. The private sector provides for sixty three percent of the

healthcare market. With only fifteen percent of the population covered by

insurance, a large proportion of the healthcare spending is out of pocket

spending.

The government healthcare infrastructure includes primary health

centers and sub centers in the villages that are the first point of contact that

provide basic drugs for minor ailments. At the secondary level, the district

hospitals and the community healthcare centers, and finally, at the tertiary level

are the government owned hospitals and medical colleges. The private

healthcare providers consist of private practitioners, for profit hospitals and

nursing homes, and charitable hospitals. They are numerous and fragmented.

Page 38: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

120

TABLE NO: 3.8

HEALTH INFRASTRUCTURE

Source: As of Table No. 3.1

Years

No. of

Doctors

No. of

Nurses Hospitals

M.

Colleges

Primary

Health

Centers

1991-92 394068 264504 11571 128 22243

1992-93 405253 340208 11571 146 22243

1993-94 410825 385410 13692 146 22243

1994-95 489189 559896 13692 162 21854

1995-96 489189 559896 13692 162 21854

1996-97 489189 559896 13692 162 21854

1997-98 498689 565696 15097 162 22291

1998-99 498689 565696 15097 162 22291

1999-00 498689 565696 15097 162 22291

2000-01 498689 565696 15097 162 22291

2001-02 498689 565696 15097 162 22291

2002-03 498689 565696 15097 162 22291

2003-04 605840 832000 16000 171 164000

2004-05 625130 836000 17300 171 164000

2005-06 625130 836000 17300 171 164000

2006-07 625130 836000 17300 171 164000

Page 39: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

121

FIGURE NO: 3.9

DISTRIBUTION OF HEALTH INFRASTRUCTURE

Year 1991-92

394068264504

11571

128

22243

No. of Doctors No. of Nurses Hospitals M. CollegesPrimary Health Centers

Year 2006-07

62513

0

83600

0

17300

171

16400

0

The above table present health infrastructure of Indian pharmaceutical

industry, health infrastructure in terms of no of doctors, no of nurses, hospitals,

medical colleges and primary health centre. The data in table indicates that

since 1991-1992 to 2006-2007.The no of doctors of India 65000 in 1955-56,

and 625130 in 2006-07. The no of doctors in India has grown considerably

over the past twenty years from 330755 in 1987-88 to 605840 in 2003-04. The

no of doctors has also increased over the past few years. It has increased from

394068 in 1991-92, 499189 in 1995-96, 605840 in 2003-04, and 625130 in

2006-07 and registering a growth about 1.58 times over the study period.

The no of nurses in India has grown considerably over the past

seventeen years from 264504 in 1991-92 to 836000 in 2006-07. No of nurses

maintained the same growth of 559896 in 1993-94 as in 2002-03 and 836000 in

2004-05 as in 2006-07. It has increased from 264504 in 1991-92 559896 in

Page 40: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

122

1995-96, 832000in 2003-04, and 836000 in 2006-07 and registering a growth

about 3.16 times over the study period.

During the year of 1991-92 the no of hospitals of this industry was

11571 and in 2006-07 it increased to 17300 and registering a growth about 1.49

times over the Study period. . No of colleges maintained the same growth of

146 in 1992-93 as in 2002-03 and 171 in 2003-04 as in 2006-07. It has

increased from 128 in 1991-92 and 171 in 2006-07 and registering a growth

about 1.33 times over the study period. During the year of 1991-92 the no of

primary health centers of this industry was 22243 and in 2006 – 07 it increased

to 164000 and registering a growth about 7.37 times over the study period.

3.4.9: HEALTH INDICATORS:-

In spite of the progress made, a high proportion of the population,

especially in rural areas, continues to suffer and die from preventable diseases,

pregnancy and childbirth related complications as well as malnutrition. In

addition to old unresolved problems, the health system in the country is facing

emerging threats and challenges. The rural public health care system in many

States and regions is in an unsatisfactory state leading to pauperization of poor

households due to expensive private sector health care.

Healthcare has emerged as one of the largest service sectors in India. In

2004, national healthcare spending equaled about 5.2 percent of nominal gross

domestic product or about US$ 34.9 billion. Healthcare spending in India is

expected to rise by 12 percent per annum through 2005-09 (in rupee terms) and

scale up to about 5.5 percent of gross domestic product or US$ 60.9 billion, by

2009. Other estimates suggest that by 2012, healthcare spending could

contribute 8 percent of gross domestic product and employ around 9 million

people. A survey by NCAER, an independent economics research agency,

suggests that per-capita expenditures on healthcare rise with higher education

levels. Households that have higher education levels tend to spend more per

illness than households with lower education levels. In the domestic market,

Page 41: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

123

TABLE NO: 3.9

HEALTH INDICATORS

Source: As of Table No. 3.1

Years

Birth

Rate

(per1000

)

Death

Rate

(per1000)

Infant

Mortalit

y rate

(per1000

live

births)

Life

Expectanc

y (years)

Hospital

Bed

1960-61 41.7 22.8 146 41.2 125000

1981-82 33.3 12.4 131 52.09 466677

1984-85 32.6 11.9 106 56.6 514989

1987-88 32.6 11.1 96 58.6 585889

1989-90 30.5 10.2 91 59 637604

1990-91 29.9 9.6 80 59 806409

1991-92 29.3 9.8 80 59.9 810548

1992-93 29 10 79 61 810548

1993-94 29 10 80 61 596203

1994-95 28.6 9.2 70 62 596203

1995-96 28.3 9 74 62 870161

1996-97 28.3 9 74 62 870161

1997-98 27.2 8.9 71 62.4 N/A

1998-99 26.4 8.9 69 62.9 N/A

Page 42: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

124

health spending will be sustained by two demographic trends: increased life

expectancy and an ageing population.

Life expectancy, which averaged 63.3 years in 2000-04, is expected to

increase to 65.1 years in 2005-09 and to 66 years in 2006-10. The proportion of

the population aged 65 years and over is also on the rise, and will increase from

4.7 percent in 2000 to 5.3 percent in 2005 and 5.8 percent in 2010. Although

the rate of ageing in India is slower than the developed world, the large

population makes any increase significant in terms of absolute numbers, and

therefore also in terms of market potential.

The contribution of the private healthcare sector is on the rise, with

investments from the corporate sector steadily growing since the mid1990s. In

the last few years a number of new players have entered the healthcare delivery

sector, and set up specialty and super speciality centers. In the government

sector, the States provide the bulk of healthcare.

3.5: CONCLUSION:-

The Indian pharmaceutical industry has made good progress during

the period under the study. Stages of growth reveals that this industry has

grown from being merely an import depend to emerge today as a self- reliant

industry. Today the Indian pharmaceutical industry is also making technology

based improvements and its strength lies in its competitive ability. In the early

period the Government policy was to protect the domestic sector from foreign

multinational companies and develop the public sector. However, in the 1970s

due to the introduction of New Patent Regime the domestic pharmaceutical

firms became more technology driven and this led to development of new cost

effective process and new drug developing systems also emerged. This

technological growth has led to growth of scientific managerial and general

skills in the pharmaceutical industry. The Indian pharmaceutical industry has

emerged today to be a major competitor in global market and is also in the

position to produce drugs at a cheaper price and this change in noticed during

the period under study.

Page 43: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

125

References:-

1 – Organisation of Pharmaceutical Producer of India, Annual Report-2006-07

and TIP Division, Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India 12/5/2007

2– Government of India, Economic Survey, 2006-07

3 – Organisation of Pharmaceutical Producer of India, Annual Report-1991-92

& 2006-07 and TIP Division, Ministry of External Affairs, Government of

India 12/5/2007

4 - Ibid

5 - http://www.naukrihub.com/india/pharmaceutical/overview/

6 -“India gears up for unprecedented manufacturing growth, in Pharma

Technologist.com, 8th August 2006

7- Cuts Drug Prices, Else Face Action, Paswan Tells Industry,” The Associated

Chambers of Commerce and Industry of Industry, Nov. 29, 2006

8 – Organisation of Pharmaceutical Producer of India, Annual Report-2006-07

and TIP Division, Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India 12/5/2007

9 - Nayar 1983Nayar, B.R. 1983. India’s Quest for Technological

Independence, Lancers Publishers,New Delhi

10 -Ajit Ranade and Gaurav Kapur, SECTORAL REPORT:

PHARMACEUTICALS INDUSTRY, 12 April 2001

11 - Key Statistics of pharma industry (2004). Retrieved on 20th October 2005

from http://www.indiaoppi.com/keystat

12 – Organisation of Pharmaceutical Producer of India, Annual Report-2006-

07 and TIP Division, Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India

12/5/2007

13 - Govindaraj Ramesh & Chellaraj.(2002), The Indian Pharmaceutical

Sector,Issue and Options for Health Sector Reform, World Bank Discussion

Paper No 437, Washington.

14 – Pradhan J.P, (2006), Global competitives of Indian Pharmaceutical

Industry: Trends Strategies, ISID, Working Paper No: 2006/05, June 2006,

P.17

Page 44: CHAPTRE – 3 GROWTH AND CHANGING PROFILE OF THE …shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/4320/9/09... · 2015. 12. 4. · (FDA) and Abbreviated New Drug Application(ANDA),Drug

Chapter 3

126

15 – (A) – Fergerberg J.(1987), A Technology Gap Approch to Why Growth

Rate Differ : Research Policy, 16 pp.87-99.

(B) - Verspangen.B.(1991), A New Empirical Approch to Catching Up or

Falling Behind, Structural Change and Economic Dynamics, 2 page – 359-380.