7/30/2019 CHARLES COLMAN - ABA HANDOUT (5/24/13) on strategies for defense in fabric-pattern copyright infringement la

1/18

3

Ijursa gctarechs ojr CLC IHA Ijpyrefbt Trjhhs Cra @avar e` Ocsbej`;

Ijpyrefbt E`ore`faga`t Yuets c`d Ytrctafeas ojr Oefbte`f Lcim "1*

7/30/2019 CHARLES COLMAN - ABA HANDOUT (5/24/13) on strategies for defense in fabric-pattern copyright infringement la

2/18

( 941'4? "3553%

"agpbcses cddad= e`tar`ch ietctej`s jgettad%

Tbase`a quc `j` jo ijpyrefbt es jrefe`chety. Tj qucheoy ojr ijpyrefbt prjtaitej`( c wjrmgust la jrefe`ch tj tba cutbjr. Jrefe`ch( cs tba targ es usad e` ijpyrefbt( gac`s j`hy

tbct tba wjrm wcs e`dapa`da`thy iractad ly tba cutbjr "cs jppjsad tj ijpead orjg jtbar

wjrms%( c`d tbct et pjssassas ct hacst sjga ge`egch dafraa jo iractevety. Tj la sura( tba

raqueseta havah jo iractevety es axtragahy hjw= ava` c shefbt cgju`t wehh suooeia. Tba vcst

gckjrety jo wjrms gcma tba frcda queta acsehy( cs tbay pjssass sjga iracteva spcrm( `j

gcttar bjw iruda( buglha jr jlvejus et gefbt la. Ed.( 3.>2]IW]3W. Jrefe`chety djas `jt

sef`eoy `jvahty= c wjrm gcy la jrefe`ch ava` tbjufb et ihjsahy rasaglhas jtbar wjrms sj

hj`f cs tba segehcrety es ojrtuetjus( `jt tba rasuht jo ijpye`f. Tj ehhustrcta( cssuga tbct

twj pjats( acib ef`jrc`t jo tba jtbar( ijgpjsa eda`teich pjags. @aetbar wjrm es `jvah(

yat ljtb cra jrefe`ch c`d( ba`ia( ijpyrefbtclha.

E` Dasef` v. Hy`ib M`ette`f Gehhs( E`i.( ?25 O. Yupp. 36?( 365 "Y.D.@.U.%( cood2?9 O.5% "agpbcses cddad%;

]TWbara es `jtbe`f e` tba raijrd tj suppjrt daoa`dc`ts ij`ta`tej` tbct tba ijpyrefbt es `jt

vched laicusa tba Dasef` wcs ijpead orjg tba pulhei djgce`. Daoa`dc`ts bcva prjvedad

pbjtjfrcpbs jo( e`tar chec( tba 22tb Devesej`s ihjvar e`sef`ec e` vcread e`icr`ctej`s(

adeoeias uteheze`f tba ihjvar sbcpa e` tbaer cribetaiturch dasef`( c`d pjsselhy e`ore`fe`f

kawahry peaias orjg jtbar ijgpc`eas. Bjwavar( tba ihjvar sbcpas peiturad e` daoa`dc`ts

pbjtjfrcpbs cra racdehy deste`fuesbclha orjg tba Dasef`( c`d tbay dj `jt oactura tba

ijgle`ctej` jo ahaga`ts jvar wbeib phce`teoos ihceg ijpyrefbt prjtaitej`. Gjrajvar( tba

ocit tbct deste`fuesbclha ihjvar sbcpas axest djas `jt ij`stetuta aveda`ia tbct phce`teoos

Dasef` wcs ijpead orjg tba pulhei djgce`.E` tba clsa`ia jo c`y aveda`ia he`me`f tba

iractej` jo phce`teoos Dasef` tj tba pulhei djgce`( daoa`dc`ts crfuga`t es u`ta`clha.

Bjwavar( eo tba ijurt es gcda cwcra jo tba ibcrcitar jo tba pcrteas*tba desputa( c`cttcim lcsad j` hcim jo jrefe`chety gefbt la gjra veclha tbc`Oaestwjuhd suffast.

j Yaa\jych ^re`tax( E`i. v. Q`eijhjrs( E`i.( 53 Q.Y.^.S.6'>1951'_LM( >5 Q.Y. Dest. HAREY ?>961( ct +1'+?( +5'+3> "I.D.

Ich. Kuh. 2( >5% "agpbcses cddad%;

7/30/2019 CHARLES COLMAN - ABA HANDOUT (5/24/13) on strategies for defense in fabric-pattern copyright infringement la

3/18

7/30/2019 CHARLES COLMAN - ABA HANDOUT (5/24/13) on strategies for defense in fabric-pattern copyright infringement la

4/18

4

cvcehclha tj tba cfa`iy.Gjrres v. Luse`ass Ij`iapts( E`i.( 1'>? ". Ly wcy jo axcgpha( j`a jo tbasa ehhustrctej`s wcs

usad cs ijvar crtwjrm ojr c ljjm a`tethad Uju Ojrfjt Ujur Ymert( Cgahec Lhjjgar#( c`dGiHcra` cpphead ojr c`d jltce`ad c ijpyrefbt rafestrctej` ojr tbes ehhustrctej` e` Cpreh >. GiIchhej` Daih.( Axs. L'I. Tba Ijurt oe`ds tbct kudeiech `jteia ic` la tcma` jo

tbasa c`d jtbar rahctad gctarechs( wbeib ic` tbaraojra la ij`sedarad e` ij``aitej`

wetb tba gjtej` tj desgess.Yaa Ytcabr v. Bcrtojrd Oe`. Yarvs. Frjup( E`i.( 146 O.9d 4>?(

7/30/2019 CHARLES COLMAN - ABA HANDOUT (5/24/13) on strategies for defense in fabric-pattern copyright infringement la

5/18

1

44"i%"3%. Ijpyrefbt rafuhctej`s deveda tbasa se`fha wjrm rafestrctej`s e`tj pulhesbad

c`d u`pulhesbad ijhhaitej`s. Yaa 96 I.O.\.

7/30/2019 CHARLES COLMAN - ABA HANDOUT (5/24/13) on strategies for defense in fabric-pattern copyright infringement la

6/18

7/30/2019 CHARLES COLMAN - ABA HANDOUT (5/24/13) on strategies for defense in fabric-pattern copyright infringement la

7/18

6

\afestrctej`( QOE ic``jt lre`f ets iju`tarihcegs ojr e`ore`faga`t jo ets Gjd Yqucd

dasef`.

QOEs crfuga`ts tj tba ij`trcry cra u`cvcehe`f. Tba gce` tbrust jo QOOs crfuga`t es tbct

c sbjwe`f jo orcud j` tba Ijpyrefbt Jooeia es raquerad tj e`vchedcta c ijpyrefbt

rafestrctej`. Lut tbct es j`hy tba icsa wbara c pcrty saams tj e`vchedcta c ijpyrefbt lcsad

j` segpha taib`eich arrjrs e` c rafestrctej` cppheictej`].W

Bara( ly ij`trcst( QOE chhafas tbct tba OD Daoa`dc`ts e`ore`fad c pravejushy pulhesbad

wjrm tbct et e`ihudad cs pcrt jo c ijhhaitej` jo u`pulhesbad wjrms. Ourtbargjra( QOE ded

`jt supphaga`t ets jrefe`ch rafestrctej` ly dahate`f tba pravejushy pulhesbad Gjd Yqucd

dasef` orjg tba ijhhaitej` rafestrctej`= e`stacd et dahatad tba u`pulhesbad dasef`s orjg

tba ijhhaitej`( tbus ra`dare`f tba jrefe`ch rafestrctej` wbjhhy `ufctjry. Tbct ic``jt la

ij`sedarad c ge`jr taib`eich arrjr.

l. Tbe` ijpyrefbt'gjra desiar`e`f jlsarvar*garfar*si`as ocera C` axphc`ctej` jo tba fa`arch pre`iepha( raohaitad e` vcrejus djitre`as

j Gcttbaws v. Oraadgc`( 316 O.9d

7/30/2019 CHARLES COLMAN - ABA HANDOUT (5/24/13) on strategies for defense in fabric-pattern copyright infringement la

8/18

2

Bjw bcs tbes pre`iepha laa` cpphead "pjst'Oaest%:j Ojhej Egprassej`s( E`i. v. Lyar Icheojr`ec( 596 O. O.61"355>%( c`d c` jiuhcr ijgpcresj`(Ctcre( ?6< O.

7/30/2019 CHARLES COLMAN - ABA HANDOUT (5/24/13) on strategies for defense in fabric-pattern copyright infringement la

9/18

5

lae`f c`chyzad ojr segehcrety( lut ojhhjw tba ihacrhy arrj`ajus stc`dcrd e`raveawe`f tba destreit ijurts ij`ihusej`s.%

26 "K^J%( 3< Q.Y. Dest.HAREY 365>9>( ct +?5 "Y.D.@.U. Dai. 32( 3( 3>99 "Y.D.@.U. 3563% "laicusa tba ij`iapt jo chtar`cte`f

squcras jo sjheds c`d phceds es sbjw` `jt tj la `jvah( tba ijurt bcs`aiasscrehy gexad e`tj tba aguhsej` jo parte`a`t edacs tba lurda`upj` phce`teoo e` suib c icsa jo prjve`f axtragahy ihjsa ijpye`f%

"`jta tbct tbes icsa pra'dctasOaest%

Yaa chsjOjhej Egprassej`sj E`ijrpjrctej` jo pulhei'djgce` ahaga`ts

Tjdd v. Gj`t. Yehvarsgetbs( E`i.( 965 O. Yupp. ( 333< "D.Ijhj. >1% "da`ye`f ijpyrefbt prjtaitej` chtjfatbar ojr lcrlad'

wera'styha kawahry( j` tba frju`d tbct ijpyrefbt wcs `jt cvcehclhaojr purahy ou`itej`ch ahaga`ts( 36 Q.Y.I. 3>?'1?992( @j. >?'1?4( @j. >6'11999( >5

Q.Y. Cpp. HAREY ?326( ct +3 "5tb Ier. Gcr. 5% "cooerge`f desgessch jo ijpyrefbt ihceg dure`f la`ib

trech e` wbeib tba destreit kudfa bahd Ijsgjss c`d Bj`s kawahry e` bar bc`d( axcge`ad tbag ihjsahy( c`d

sced tbay dj `jt hjjm chema( ourtbar suppjrte`f bar ruhe`f u`dar stjim ahaga`ts rctej`cha%.

7/30/2019 CHARLES COLMAN - ABA HANDOUT (5/24/13) on strategies for defense in fabric-pattern copyright infringement la

10/18

3>

prjtaitej` ]cs cfce`st tbaW vertuchhy eda`teich ijpye`f ]oju`dbaraW%

Ou`resa Ic`cdc "BM% Htd. v. [cudar Lrjs.( E`i.( 55'I_'3135"C\\%( 3555 Q.Y. Dest. HAREY ?'1?4( @j. >6'11999( >5 Q.Y. Cpp. HAREY ?326( ct +

7/30/2019 CHARLES COLMAN - ABA HANDOUT (5/24/13) on strategies for defense in fabric-pattern copyright infringement la

11/18

33

c. J` ralutte`f tba prasugptej` jo vchedety ciijrdad tj ijpyrefbts e`wjrms rafestarad wetbe` oeva yacrs jo oerst pulheictej`

J` ocituch quastej`s cljut vchedety( tba prasugptej` icrreas a`jufb waefbt tjsbeot tba lurda` jo prjjo( e` tba trcdetej`ch sa`sa.Q`etad Oclreis E`th( E`i. v.

I/K Vacr( E`i.( ?9> O.9d 3

7/30/2019 CHARLES COLMAN - ABA HANDOUT (5/24/13) on strategies for defense in fabric-pattern copyright infringement la

12/18

3 "5tb Ier. >9% "iete`f Oaest ^uls.( E`i.

v. \urch Tah. Yarv. Ij.( 455 Q.Y. 94>( 941 "3553%%. Tbara gust la sjgatbe`f gjra tbc`

c garahy trevech vcrectej`( sjgatbe`f raijf`ezclhy tba crtests jw`.Ed. "iete`f Tbraa

Ljys Gusei Ijrp. v. Ljhtj`(

7/30/2019 CHARLES COLMAN - ABA HANDOUT (5/24/13) on strategies for defense in fabric-pattern copyright infringement la

13/18

39

prasa`ts `jtbe`f `aw. @jvahty es `jt raquerad e` c wjrm e` jrdar ojr

tba wjrm tj la ij`sedarad jrefe`ch jr ijpyrefbtclha.Yed c`d Gcrty Mrjoot

Tahavesej` ^rjduitej`s( E`i. v. GiDj`chd&s Ijrpjrctej`( 1?< O. Q.Y. Dest.HAREY 536>1( +36'+32( +( +5 Q.Y. Dest. HAREY ?>961( ct +?'+2 "I.D. Ich. Kuh. 2( >5% "agpbcses cddad%

Tba dahatej` jo tba teime`f strepa lcimfrju`d orjg ]c praaxeste`f 3545W ohjwar dasef`(

c`d tba e`sartej` jo fa`arei pjhmc'djts( djas `jt ij`stetuta tba raqueseta jrefe`chety

raquerad ojr c dasef` tj la ijpyrefbtclha. Ojr axcgpha( saage`fhy eda`teich lcimfrju`d

pjhmc'djts cra oju`d e` dasef` `j. ?33

7/30/2019 CHARLES COLMAN - ABA HANDOUT (5/24/13) on strategies for defense in fabric-pattern copyright infringement la

14/18

34

wetb tba Q`etad Ytctas Ijpyrefbt Jooeia. Laicusa tba Ijurt oe`ds c`d ij`ihudas tbct

tba dcesy dasef` es `jt ijpyrefbtclha( ]etW e`vchedctas tba ijpyrefbt].W

Vbara c wjrm gcda clrjcd bcs laa` dasef`ctad cs c wjrm gcda ojr bera( ojraef`'hcw pre`iephas gcy bcva laa` ef`jradc`d ic` wjrm tj c daoa`dc`ts la`aoet.

4

4. ^rjpar tast ojr avchucte`f e`ore`faga`tc. Yaij`d pcrt jo tbe` ijpyrefbt tast

Icgarj` E`dus. v. Gjtbars Vjrm( E`i.( 992 Oad. Cppx. ?5( 6>( @j. >2'4 "

7/30/2019 CHARLES COLMAN - ABA HANDOUT (5/24/13) on strategies for defense in fabric-pattern copyright infringement la

15/18

31

Et es ijggj`phcia tbct e` ijgpcre`f wjrms ojr e`ore`faga`t purpjsas '' wbatbar wa

agphjy tba trcdetej`ch jrde`cry jlsarvar tast jr tba Ojhej Egprassej`s gjra

desiar`e`f e`query '' wa axcge`a tba wjrms tjtch ij`iapt c`d oaah. Yaa Ada` Tjys(

E`i. v. Gcrsbchh Oeahd / Ij.( ?61 O.> "

7/30/2019 CHARLES COLMAN - ABA HANDOUT (5/24/13) on strategies for defense in fabric-pattern copyright infringement la

16/18

3?

j`hy trevech cspaits jo c`jtbars wjrm wehh `jt rasuht e` sulstc`tech segehcrety= et es j`hy

wba` tba ijpye`f es suooeiea`thy axta`seva tbct e`ore`faga`t jiiurs. Q`dar tbes saij`d

stap jo tba c`chyses( tbaraojra( tba trear jo ocit cppheas tba jrde`cry jlsarvar tast(

u`cedad ly dessaitej` jr axpart tastegj`y( tj datarge`a wbatbar tba ijpye`f rasuhtad e`

sulstc`tech segehcrety latwaa` tba wjrms.Ed.Yaa chsj Bjabhe`f v. Q`evarsch Iety Ytudejs(

E`i.( ?32 O.99 "3524%.Ly

dessaite`f tba ciiusad wjrm c`d eda`teoye`f tbjsa oacturas wbeib cra prjtaitad e` tba

ijpyrefbtad wjrm( tba ijurt gcy la clha tj datarge`a cs c gcttar jo hcw wbatbar jr `jt

tba ojrgar bcs ijpead prjtaitad cspaits jo tba hcttar. ]Ojjt`jta jgettad.W Tba ijurt ic`

chsj datarge`a( e` ct hacst c fa`arch wcy( tbjsa cspaits jo tba wjrm tbct cra prjtaitad lytba ijpyrefbt c`d tbct sbjuhd la ij`sedarad e` tba sulsaqua`t ijgpcrcteva c`chyses

u`dar tba jrde`cry jlsarvar tast. ]Ojjt`jta 5; Ojr axcgpha( tba ijurt gcy oe`d tbct tba

edac c`d axprassej` cra sj e`sapcrclha tbct ijpye`f jo tba wjrm es `jt prjbeletad jr

tbct j`hy axcit raprjduitej` jo tba wjrm wehh kusteoy c oe`de`f jo e`ore`faga`t.W

Cssuge`f ijpye`f jo prjtaitad cspaits es astclhesbad( tba trear jo ocit ic` tba` cssass

pursuc`t tj tba jrde`cry jlsarvar tast wbatbar tbara es sulstc`tech segehcrety latwaa`

tba prjtaitad axprassej` c`d tba ciiusad wjrm.

IjgpcraH.C. ^re`tax E`dus. v. Carjpjstcha( E`i.( @j. 3>'1?326( 3< Q.Y. Cpp.HAREY 399( ct +33'+35 "5tb Ier. 3525%%. Yuggcry kudfga`t es cpprjprecta eo tba

ijurt ic` ij`ihuda( cotar veawe`f tba aveda`ia c`d drcwe`f e`oara`ias e` c gc``ar gjst

ocvjrclha tj tba `j`'gjve`f pcrty( tbct `j racsj`clha kurjr ijuhd oe`d sulstc`tech

segehcrety jo edacs ]seiW c`d axprassej`.Ed. "qujte`f @crahh( 26< O.5'3>%. Vbara

racsj`clha ge`ds ijuhd deooar j` tba essua jo sulstc`tech segehcrety( bjwavar( suggcry

kudfga`t es egprjpar.Ed.

...

Tbjufb tba Yaij`d Ieriuets jrde`cry jlsarvar c`d gjra desiar`e`f jrde`cry

jlsarvar tasts deooar sjgawbct orjg jur twj'pcrt axtre`sei*e`tre`sei tast ojr sulstc`tech

segehcrety( ]M`etwcvas( 63 O.9d ct 3>>

7/30/2019 CHARLES COLMAN - ABA HANDOUT (5/24/13) on strategies for defense in fabric-pattern copyright infringement la

17/18

36

596 O.2'( 3>59 `.1 "

7/30/2019 CHARLES COLMAN - ABA HANDOUT (5/24/13) on strategies for defense in fabric-pattern copyright infringement la

18/18

32

j Ijhjr "tractga`t e` icsa hcw vcreas% Yaa( a.f.(Egparech Taxteha Ij. v. Cgatax Oclreis( E`i.( ?2< O. Yupp. 32(

"Y.D.@.U. 3526% "agpbcses cddad%

]CWhtbjufb Cgataxs sulsaqua`t raprjduitej`s jo Egparechs dasef` e` deooara`t ijhjrs

icusa tbag `jt tj lacr tba scga dafraa jo segehcrety tj Egparechs dasef` cs tba ibcrijch

pcttar`( feva` tba oe`de`f jo e`etech e`ore`faga`t ly suib ihacr c`d ij`ve`ie`f aveda`ia

daoa`dc`t ic``jt cvjed raspj`selehety ojr ourtbar e`ore`faga`t laicusa ets raprjduitej`s

jo tba dasef` e` jtbar ijhjr ijgle`ctej`s( veawad e` c vciuug( cra `jt sj jlvejushy

segehcr. Yaa @jvahty Taxteha Gehhs( 112 O.54 `.? "j`ia c ijpyrefbtad dasef` esoju`d tj bcva laa` ijpead( gara ibc`fas e` tba ijhjr sibaga j` tba ijpead dasef`

wjuhd jrde`crehy `jt prjtait tba daoa`dc`t orjg c ihceg jo e`ore`faga`t%.

Yaa chsjDcves v. Fcp E`i.(