Chelsye Bond Jennifer FougereJessica MacLean Joseph Ratnasothy

Refusing Administration Refusing Administration

ofof

Blood ProductsBlood Products

Seminar Objectives1. Define indications of blood products.2. Identify reasons for refusal of blood products. 3. Demonstrate the historical influences of blood transfusion. 4. Illustrate the current present day influences of blood

transfusion. 5. State the policy surrounding the administration and refusal

of blood products. 6. Distinguish supporting and opposing arguments in regards

to refusal of administration of blood products. 7. Explain the health care provider’s role in terms of caring for

the patient who refuses a blood tranfusion.

Relevant Terms Competency Incompetency Right to autonomy and self-determination Principle of do no harm Advanced directive Bioethics Bill Informed Consent

Purpose

…to review refusal of blood products as a pertinent nursing health issue, and to discuss the ethical and legal implications of blood product administration refusal for client and for nurse as health care provider

Issue Statement The ethical dilemma arises when a

competent, informed patient in need of a blood transfusion, refuses.

Further, the ethical dilemma becomes more difficult when a the patient is incompetent, or a child is involved.

An Ethical Dilemma for Nurses

… a situation arising when equally compelling ethical reasons both supporting and opposing a particular course of action are recognized

(CNA, 2008)

Competency vs. Incompetency Competency: Ability to express a choice Understand choices of treatment/ no treatment Appreciate implications of treatment/ no treatment

Incompetency: Substitute Decision-Maker (NOK) Power of Attourney

(McInroy, 2005)

What is a blood transfusion

Receive a blood component intravenously

Components are red blood cells, platelets, plasma, albumin, and clotting factors

(Capital Health, 2007)

Why might a blood transfusion be needed

1. To increase red blood cells

2. To replace clotting factor or platelets in your blood

3. To replace blood loss

4. To replace blood loss resulting from treatment or procedure

(Capital Health, 2007)

Why might a person refuse a blood transfusion

Religious, spiritual beliefs

Individual preference

(Capital Health, 2007)

To the Jewish nation He repeatedly said,

‘The life of every living creature is the blood, and I have forbidden the Iraselites to eat the blood of any creature, because the

life of every creature is its blood’(Leviticus 17:14)

(Wade, 2005)

Jehovah Witnesses

Refuse the following:

Whole blood, RBCs, WBCs, PLTs Preoperative autologous blood donation

(The Watchtower Bible and Tract Society, 2010)

Jehovah's Witnesses Con’tWill accept the following:

Blood conserving methods

Most diagnostic and therapeutic procedures

Non-blood volume expanders

Pharmacologic agents that do not contain blood components or fractions

(The Watchtower Bible and Tract Society, 2010)

Jehovah’s Witnesses Con’tThe following is treatment made by personal decision

(acceptable to some, declined by others):

Blood cell salvage

Hemodialysis

Transplants

Acute normovolemic hemodilution (ANH)

(Capital Health, 2007)

Historical Influence William Harvey (1578-1657)

English physician, first to describe in detail the properties of blood and the systemic circulation

Jean-Baptiste Denys (1640-1704) French physician, administered the first fully documented human

blood transfusion (the 15-year-old patient subsequently died) The French Parliament, the Royal Society, and the Catholic

Church issues general prohibitions on blood transfusion James Blundell (1791-1878)

English physician, in 1818 performed the first successful transfusion of blood to a patient for treatment of a hemorrhage

Historical Influence Dr. Charles Drew (1904-1950)

Revolutionized the understanding of blood plasma, and a system for the long-term preservation of blood plasma

Invention of blood banks (first director for the Red Cross’ system of blood banks)

CPDA-1 (anticoagulant preservative) Introduced in 1979, which increased the blood supply and

facilitated resource-sharing among blood banks

Current Influence

Treatment refusals by: Competent adults

Incompetent adult with advance directive

Incompetent adult without advance directive

Mature minors/minors

Current Influence

Legal precedents… Cases presented to the courts regarding children and regarding competent adults guide current practice

Medical Decisions Facilitations Act Protecting physicians

The Supporting Arguments Choice

Dignity

Justice

Advocacy

Professional misconduct

(CNA, 2008)

(Effa-Heap, 2009; McInroy, 2005)

The Opposing Arguments

Code of Ethics

Best care possible and at the same time advocate

Saving lives

(CNA, 2008)

Alternatives

Preoperative Period: Iron therapy

Vitamin B12

Folate

Erythropoietin

Autologous Donation of own blood

(Capital Health, 2007)

Alternatives Con’t

Intra-operative Period:

Antifibrinolytic drugs

Acute normovolemic Hemodilation

Volume Expanders

Hypotensive Anesthesia

Hypothermia

Cell Salvage Device

Endoscopic and Laparoscopic Surgery

(Capital Health, 2007)

Perioperative Blood ManagementProgram (PBMP)

Purpose: To decrease and/or eliminate the need for blood transfusion

during elective or scheduled surgery 

To educate patients about the risks and benefits of blood transfusions

Educate about available blood alternatives available

(Capital Health, 2007)

New Technologies Blood Substitutes Preventing Bleeding Replacement Fluids Intra-operative Blood Collection Autologous RBC

Nursing Role

Keep in mind that blood is not always needed

Remember that transfusion carries risks as well as benefits

Seek to understand the patient and develop good rapport

Access available resources

(Effa-Heap, 2009; McInroy, 2005; Rogers, Kendall, & Crookston, 2006)

Nursing Role

Limit blood draws and consider alternatives to blood products

Explore the treatment possibilities

Ensure confidentiality

Document carefully

Make contingency plans in advance

(Effa-Heap, 2009; McInroy, 2005; Rogers, Kendall, & Crookston, 2006)

Nursing Role Respect patient’s individual choices

Practice in coordination with Nursing Code of Ethics and Standards of Practice

Obtain informed consent prior to procedure or treatment

Be trustworthy; advocate on behalf of patients’ wishes

(McInroy, 2005)

Nursing Role Consider that quality of life is ‘subjective’

Consider that the values of patients, relatives, and healthcare staff, may differ

Encourage fair, non-judgemental decisions

Lobby for clearer policies

(McInroy, 2005)

Discussion

Can a patient demand a PARTIAL treatment that the doctor considers futile and could even cause them harm?

Patients have the right to refuse a treatment, but does he have a right to refuse part of it?

If the patient’s wishes are paramount, is the emotional impact on the nursing staff as important?

Should a patient, on religious grounds or otherwise, have the right to more expensive treatment than others?

Questions