10
ARTICLE PEDIATRICS Volume 138, number 5, November 2016:e20160491 Childhood Victims of Snakebites: 2000–2013 Joann Schulte, DO, MPH, a Kristina Domanski, MD, a Eric Anthony Smith, MS, a Annelle Menendez, MD, a Kurt C. Kleinschmidt, MD, b Brett A. Roth, MD a,b abstract BACKGROUND: Snakebites are not a reportable condition (to state health departments), and 1 major assessment of US children with snakebites was published 50 years ago. Increasing urbanization, population shifts south and west, newer antivenom therapy, and the importation of exotic snakes may have changed snakebites. Poison control centers are often consulted on treatment and collect surveillance data. METHODS: Generic codes for venomous, nonvenomous, and unknown snakebites were used to characterize victims aged 18 years reported to US poison control centers between 2000 and 2013. Data included demographic characteristics, snake types, and outcomes. RESULTS: Callers reported 18 721 pediatric snakebites (annual mean, 1337). Two-thirds were male ( n = 12 688 [68%]), with a mean age of 10.7 years. One-half of the snakebites were venomous ( n = 9183 [49%]), with copperheads ( n = 3602 [39%]) and rattlesnakes ( n = 2859 [31%]) the most frequently identified. Reported copperhead bites increased 137% and unknown crotalids (venomous) increased 107%. Exotic (nonnative) exposures were reported in 2% of cases. All 50 states reported snakebites, but one-quarter occurred in Texas and Florida. Rates for total snakebites and venomous snakebites were highest in West Virginia, Oklahoma, and Louisiana. One-fifth required ICU admission. Limited data for 28% of bites for antivenom treatment suggests increasing use. Four victims died. CONCLUSIONS: The epidemiology of pediatric snakebites is changing. One-half of the reported exposures were venomous, and copperhead bites and exotic species are being reported more frequently. Although snakebite-related deaths are rare, ICU admission is common. Antivenom treatment is incompletely reported, but its use is increasing. a North Texas Poison Control Center, Parkland Health & Hospital System, Dallas, Texas; and b Division of Medical Toxicology, Department of Emergency Medicine, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, Texas Dr Schulte conceptualized and designed the study, obtained institutional review board approval, obtained the data, performed the data analysis, interpreted the data, and drafted the initial manuscript and revisions; Mr Smith performed data analysis and helped draft the initial manuscript and revisions; Dr Domanski assisted in interpretation of data, helped draft the initial manuscript, and critically revised the manuscript for important intellectual content; Dr Menendez assisted in interpretation of data and helped draft the initial manuscript; Dr Kleinschmidt assisted in design of the study, assisted in interpretation of data, and critically revised the manuscript for important intellectual content; Dr Roth assisted in design of the study, oversaw data analysis, helped draft the initial manuscript, and critically revised the manuscript for important intellectual content; and all authors approved the final manuscript as submitted and agree to be accountable for all aspects of the work. DOI: 10.1542/peds.2016-0491 Accepted for publication Aug 24, 2016 Address correspondence to Joann Schulte, DO, MPH, North Texas Poison Control Center, Parkland Hospital, 5201 Harry Hines Blvd, Dallas, TX 75235. E-mail: [email protected] To cite: Schulte J, Domanski K, Smith EA, et al. Childhood Victims of Snakebites: 2000–2013. Pediatrics. 2016;138(5): e20160491 WHAT'S KNOWN ON THIS SUBJECT: Few comprehensive assessments of pediatric snakebites have been published. WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS: Reported snakebites average 1300 annually. One-half of the 18 721 snakebites reported were venomous, and 2% involved exotic snakes. Antivenom treatment of bites from copperheads and unknown snake types has increased. About 20% required ICU admission, and 4 deaths were reported. by guest on May 19, 2018 http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/ Downloaded from

Childhood Victims of Snakebites: 2000–2013pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/pediatrics/early/...SCHULTE et al Snakebites are not a reportable condition (to state health departments),

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Childhood Victims of Snakebites: 2000–2013pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/pediatrics/early/...SCHULTE et al Snakebites are not a reportable condition (to state health departments),

ARTICLEPEDIATRICS Volume 138 , number 5 , November 2016 :e 20160491

Childhood Victims of Snakebites: 2000–2013Joann Schulte, DO, MPH, a Kristina Domanski, MD, a Eric Anthony Smith, MS, a Annelle Menendez, MD, a Kurt C. Kleinschmidt, MD, b Brett A. Roth, MDa, b

abstractBACKGROUND: Snakebites are not a reportable condition (to state health departments), and 1

major assessment of US children with snakebites was published 50 years ago. Increasing

urbanization, population shifts south and west, newer antivenom therapy, and the

importation of exotic snakes may have changed snakebites. Poison control centers are often

consulted on treatment and collect surveillance data.

METHODS: Generic codes for venomous, nonvenomous, and unknown snakebites were used to

characterize victims aged ≤18 years reported to US poison control centers between 2000

and 2013. Data included demographic characteristics, snake types, and outcomes.

RESULTS: Callers reported 18 721 pediatric snakebites (annual mean, 1337). Two-thirds

were male (n = 12 688 [68%]), with a mean age of 10.7 years. One-half of the snakebites

were venomous (n = 9183 [49%]), with copperheads (n = 3602 [39%]) and rattlesnakes

(n = 2859 [31%]) the most frequently identified. Reported copperhead bites increased 137%

and unknown crotalids (venomous) increased 107%. Exotic (nonnative) exposures were

reported in 2% of cases. All 50 states reported snakebites, but one-quarter occurred in

Texas and Florida. Rates for total snakebites and venomous snakebites were highest in West

Virginia, Oklahoma, and Louisiana. One-fifth required ICU admission. Limited data for 28%

of bites for antivenom treatment suggests increasing use. Four victims died.

CONCLUSIONS: The epidemiology of pediatric snakebites is changing. One-half of the reported

exposures were venomous, and copperhead bites and exotic species are being reported

more frequently. Although snakebite-related deaths are rare, ICU admission is common.

Antivenom treatment is incompletely reported, but its use is increasing.

aNorth Texas Poison Control Center, Parkland Health & Hospital System, Dallas, Texas; and bDivision of Medical

Toxicology, Department of Emergency Medicine, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, Texas

Dr Schulte conceptualized and designed the study, obtained institutional review board approval,

obtained the data, performed the data analysis, interpreted the data, and drafted the initial

manuscript and revisions; Mr Smith performed data analysis and helped draft the initial

manuscript and revisions; Dr Domanski assisted in interpretation of data, helped draft the initial

manuscript, and critically revised the manuscript for important intellectual content; Dr Menendez

assisted in interpretation of data and helped draft the initial manuscript; Dr Kleinschmidt

assisted in design of the study, assisted in interpretation of data, and critically revised the

manuscript for important intellectual content; Dr Roth assisted in design of the study, oversaw

data analysis, helped draft the initial manuscript, and critically revised the manuscript for

important intellectual content; and all authors approved the fi nal manuscript as submitted and

agree to be accountable for all aspects of the work.

DOI: 10.1542/peds.2016-0491

Accepted for publication Aug 24, 2016

Address correspondence to Joann Schulte, DO, MPH, North Texas Poison Control Center, Parkland

Hospital, 5201 Harry Hines Blvd, Dallas, TX 75235. E-mail: [email protected]

To cite: Schulte J, Domanski K, Smith EA, et al. Childhood

Victims of Snakebites: 2000–2013. Pediatrics. 2016;138(5):

e20160491

WHAT'S KNOWN ON THIS SUBJECT: Few

comprehensive assessments of pediatric snakebites

have been published.

WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS: Reported snakebites

average 1300 annually. One-half of the 18 721

snakebites reported were venomous, and 2%

involved exotic snakes. Antivenom treatment of bites

from copperheads and unknown snake types has

increased. About 20% required ICU admission, and

4 deaths were reported.

by guest on May 19, 2018http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/Downloaded from

Page 2: Childhood Victims of Snakebites: 2000–2013pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/pediatrics/early/...SCHULTE et al Snakebites are not a reportable condition (to state health departments),

SCHULTE et al

Snakebites are not a reportable

condition (to state health

departments), and few

comprehensive surveillance

assessments exist. One often-

cited study assessing snakebites

among US children was published

in 1965 (50 years ago) and used data

from individual hospitals in

10 states. 1 Since that date, increasing

urbanization, population shifts to the

southern and western states, 2, 3

development of new antivenom

treatments, 4 and the emergence

of exotic snakes as an industry5, 6

have altered the population and the

circumstances in which snakebites

may occur. Increasing numbers of US

households are estimated to own a

snake, 5 which can lead to bites and

even death. 7, 8

The main objective of the present

study was to characterize snakebites

to children and adolescents aged

≤18 years reported to US poison

control centers between 2000 and

2013. We investigated the trends in,

and epidemiologic characteristics of,

pediatric snakebites and the resulting

consequences, including hospital

admissions and possible antivenom

treatment.

METHODS

Data Sources

This study was based on data

collected in the National Poison Data

System (NPDS), which is maintained

by the American Association of

Poison Control Centers. Poison

control centers offer 24-hour advice

and consultation for individuals

and hospitals using an 800 number,

with calls routed on the basis of

the caller’s area code. The collected

documentation for each call includes

exposure (in this study, type of

snake), basic demographic data on

the exposed person, subsequent

medical information related to the

exposure, and other information

regarding the incident. 9 US

Census Bureau data were used to

calculate population-based rates

for total snakebites and venomous

snakebites. 10

Data Selection and Conditions

NPDS data were obtained for all

single snakebite exposures among

persons with a known age of ≤18

years that were reported to any

US poison control center between

calendar years 2000 and 2013. 9

Cases were limited to those in which

the victim was in or referred to a

health care facility (HCF).

As a condition of obtaining the

national data, we agreed not to

contact any individual poison

control center to request free text or

charts at any poison control center.

We were able to obtain the death

abstracts of the 4 cases because such

cases are forwarded to American

Association of Poison Control Centers

and are reviewed and published in

annual reports. 9

Snakebite Variables

Snakebites are defined with NPDS

generic codes 9, 11 identifying

venomous, nonvenomous, and

unknown snakes, both species

indigenous to the United States

and exotic varieties that are

nonnative to the United States. 9

Specific codes for the domestic

snakes are unknown types of snake

envenomation (13700); unknown

or known nonpoisonous snakebites

(137102); rattlesnake envenomation

(137103); coral snake envenomation

(137104); copperhead envenomation

(137106); cottonmouth/water

moccasin envenomation (137107);

and unknown crotalid envenomation

(137105). Rattlesnakes, copperheads,

and cottonmouths/water moccasin

are all pit vipers and are classified as

unknown crotalids if not specifically

identified.

Codes for the exotic snakes,

nonnative to the United States,

include exotic snake poisonous

(137108), exotic snake nonpoisonous

(137109), and exotic snake unknown

if poisonous (137110).

Antivenom Therapy

During the study period, antivenom

therapy for domestic snakebites

evolved. Before 2000, the major

antivenom used for all domestic

venomous snakes (except coral) was

a polyvalent product of equine origin

manufactured by Wyeth (US Food

and Drug Administration, personal

communication, 2016). The last lot

of that antivenom expired in March

2007, and it was generally only used

in severe envenomations because

it could produce serious adverse

effects, including anaphylaxis and

serum sickness. 12, 13 Concurrent

use of epinephrine to treat possible

anaphylaxis was common. A separate

Wyeth antivenom, specific to coral

snakes, had been available in

limited supply with an expiration

date of May 2016 (US Food and

Drug Administration, personal

communication, 2016).

The Fab antivenom that has become

the therapeutic cornerstone for many

US snakebites, including those to

children, 4 was granted approval by

the US Food and Drug Administration

in 2000. This Fab antivenom

(CroFab [BTG International Inc,

West Conshohocken, PA]) is derived

from sheep and is considered less

antigenic because it lacks the Fc

antibody fragment. 4, 13 In this article,

the newer antivenom is referred to

as Fab antivenom. The older Wyeth

antivenoms are called polyvalent

antivenom and coral snake

antivenom and, collectively, as older

antivenoms.

Collected information on antivenoms

is coded as recommended,

performed, recommended and

performed, and recommended,

known not performed. We

consolidated those categories into

treated and any consideration of

antivenom on use.

2 by guest on May 19, 2018http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/Downloaded from

Page 3: Childhood Victims of Snakebites: 2000–2013pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/pediatrics/early/...SCHULTE et al Snakebites are not a reportable condition (to state health departments),

PEDIATRICS Volume 138 , number 5 , November 2016

Defi nition of Treatable Envenomation

Most snakebites, whether venomous

or not, will have some type of

local tissue effect, including minor

pain and erythema. Venomous

snakebites may cause a variety of

symptoms, including pain, swelling,

tissue necrosis, low blood pressure,

convulsions, hemorrhage, respiratory

paralysis, kidney failure, coma, and

death. 1, 3, 9 However, not all venomous

snakes are identified as such, and

unknown snakes can be venomous

but unrecognized.

The decision to treat a specific bite

with antivenom is made by a treating

provider, often in consultation with

a poison control center. Antivenom

treatment may be administered for

victims bitten by known venomous

snakes or bites in which an unknown

snake type produces serious

complications in the provider’s

judgment.

A potentially treatable envenomation

was defined as one in which a bitten

patient was at risk for complications

because the bite involved an

identified domestic venomous snake

or an unknown domestic snake

(n = 15 422) ( Fig 1). The domestic

venomous snakes considered

included rattlesnakes, copperheads,

cottonmouths, coral snakes, and

unknown crotalids.

Other Variables

Geographic location is the state

where the snakebite occurred. 11

Exposure site was collapsed to

residence (either the child’s own

home or another) versus all other

sites. In NPDS, level of treatment

at an HCF is categorized as seen at

HCF, no HCF treatment, and patient

refused referral/did not arrive at

the HCF. The description of being

seen at HCF includes admission to a

critical care unit (ICU), admitted to

a noncritical care unit (floor), being

treated/evaluated, and released

(<24-hour stay).

Additional variables analyzed

included children’s sex, age, and

month and year of exposure. 11

Exposure, case, and call were used as

interchangeable terms.

Statistical Analysis and Ethical Considerations

SAS version 9.3 (SAS Institute, Inc,

Cary, NC) and Epi Info (Centers for

Disease Control and Prevention,

Atlanta, GA) were used for data

analysis. The institutional review

board at UT Southwestern approved

this study.

RESULTS

Demographic Characteristics of Bitten Children and Adolescents

Poison control centers received 18 721

reports of snakebites to children and

adolescents aged ≤18 years during the

study period. More than two-thirds

of those bitten were male (n = 12 688

[68%]), with a mean age of 10.7 years.

Bite numbers were highest among

children aged 3 to 9 years (n = 6717

[36%]) and 10 to 14 years (n = 5917

[32%]). Four deaths were reported.

Exposures were reported in all

months, with one-third in June

and July (n = 6461 [33%]). Most

exposures were in residential home

settings (n = 14 824 [89%]). Calls

were distributed equally among the

7 weekdays, and more than one-

quarter of calls (n = 5048 [27%])

were made between 7:00 and

10:00 PM. Most patients (n = 14 980

[80%]) were in an HCF when the

poison control center was called.

Deaths

Four separate deaths of children

were reported; 3 by rattlesnakes

(Texas, Georgia, and Florida) and

1 by an unknown type of snake

(Florida). All deaths were considered

directly related to the snakebites.

A 2-year-old girl who died in Texas

in 2010 had 2 bites on her ankle;

a rattlesnake was found at the

lake where she visited. She had a

generalized seizure before transport

to a hospital 2 hours away where she

was given 6 vials of Fab antivenom

and admitted to the ICU. She was

started on vasopressor agents but

became hypotensive and pulseless.

She died 5 hours after being bitten.

A 3-year-old boy was bitten in

Georgia in 2000 by a rattlesnake,

received 36 vials of polyvalent

crotalid antivenom, and developed

disseminated intravascular

coagulopathy. He died within several

hours of the envenomation.

In 2000, a 2-year-old boy from

Florida was bitten on the knee by a

rattlesnake and received 90 vials of

polyvalent crotalid antivenom. He

had only 1 fang mark and bled from

a cutdown site, oral orifices, and the

gastrointestinal tract. He received

3

FIGURE 1Pediatric snakebite study fl owchart.

by guest on May 19, 2018http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/Downloaded from

Page 4: Childhood Victims of Snakebites: 2000–2013pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/pediatrics/early/...SCHULTE et al Snakebites are not a reportable condition (to state health departments),

SCHULTE et al

vasopressor agents and transfusions

but had had no response to pain

within 24 hours and was declared

brain dead.

A 17-year-old female, bitten on the

right hand by an unknown type of

snake in 2001 in Florida, was initially

seen at a fire station. She was thought

to be having an allergic reaction and

given epinephrine. She had 2 puncture

marks on her right hand, with no

local swelling or ecchymosis. She had

a seizure en route to the emergency

department and became hypotensive.

She was intubated, received a total of

34 vials of Fab antivenom, and had no

response to vasopressor agents. She

died on day 5 of hospitalization.

Geographic Distribution of All Snakebites

An annual mean of 1337 snakebites

were reported (range, 1184–1527).

One-half of all the reported

snakebites (domestic and exotic)

were venomous (n = 9182 [49%]).

Other totals were nonvenomous

(n = 3156 [17%]) and unknown type

of snake (n = 6382 [34%]). Among

the venomous snakes, copperheads

(n = 3602 [39%]) and rattlesnakes

(n = 2859 [31%]) were most common.

Lower numbers were reported for

unknown crotalids (n = 1853 [20%]),

cottonmouths (n = 511 [6%]), coral

snakes (n = 232 [3%]), and exotic

venomous snakes (n = 126 [1%]).

Snakebites were reported in 50

states, Washington, DC, and Puerto

Rico, but 39% (n = 7238) were

reported by 4 states: Texas (n = 2627

[14%]), Florida (n = 2199 [12%]),

Georgia (n = 1237 [7%]), and North

Carolina (n = 1174 [6%]). Prevalence

rates per 1 million population ( Fig 2)

for all snakebites were highest in

West Virginia (762.3), Louisiana

(625.5), and Oklahoma (557.5).

Geographic Distribution of Venomous Snakebites

Venomous snakebites were reported

in 48 states, Washington, DC, and

Puerto Rico. Forty percent (n =

3789) of snakebites were reported

in 4 states: Texas (n = 1431 [16%]),

Florida (n = 895 [10%]), North

Carolina (n = 815 [9%]), and California

(n = 648 [7%]). Texas and North

Carolina reported one-third of the

copperhead bites (n = 1203). Arizona

and California reported 40% (n =

1154) of the rattlesnake bites. Florida

reported 60% of coral snake bites

(n = 160) and 25% of cottonmouth

bites (n = 124). Prevalence rates per

1 million populations for venomous

bites ( Fig 3) were highest in West

Virginia (421.4), Oklahoma (383.2),

and Louisiana (354).

Trends in Reported Snakebite Exposures and Antivenom Use

Use of any antivenom therapy was

considered in 5279 (28%) reported

snakebites and administered in 4817

(25.7%) exposures. During the study

period, Fab antivenom use increased

298%, spiking after the last lot of

polyvalent antivenom expired.

4

FIGURE 2Rates of total snakebites per 1 million according to state, ages 0 to 18 years, 2000 to 2013.

FIGURE 3Rates of venomous snakebites per 1 million population according to state, ages 0 to 18 years, 2000 to 2013.

by guest on May 19, 2018http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/Downloaded from

Page 5: Childhood Victims of Snakebites: 2000–2013pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/pediatrics/early/...SCHULTE et al Snakebites are not a reportable condition (to state health departments),

PEDIATRICS Volume 138 , number 5 , November 2016

Figure 4 shows trends in reported

exposures for domestic snakes

(venomous and unknown) that might

be treated with antivenom therapy

(as discussed in the Definition of

Treatable Envenomation section).

Between 2000 and 2013, copperhead

reports increased 137% and

unknown crotalid reports increased

107%.

Figures 5, 6, and 7 show trends in

reported snakebites and antivenom

use for rattlesnake, copperhead,

and unknown crotalid bites,

respectively. In each case, the

Fab antivenom drove most of the

increase and increased markedly

starting in 2007.

Level of Health Care and Treatment

Almost 40% (n = 7106 [38%]) of

pediatric cases caused hospital

admissions, and 1 in 5 reported

cases were admitted to ICUs

(n = 3541 [19%]). One-half of the

patients (n = 9397) were treated

and released, and <1% (n = 11)

were admitted to a psychiatric

facility.

Antivenom use ( Table 1) was highest

for rattlesnake bites (n = 1181

[41%]). More than one-third of bites

by copperheads (n = 1278 [34%]),

cottonmouths (n = 175 [35%]), and

unknown crotalids (n = 684 [37%])

were treated with antivenom. Lower

treatment percentages were reported

for coral snakes (n = 36 [20%]) and

unknown types of snakes (n = 1816

[28%]).

Among 15 422 patients with

potentially treatable snakebites,

rattlesnake victims were 3.8 times

(odds ratio, 3.80 [95% confidence

interval, 3.48–4.13]) more likely

to be admitted to an HCF than

those patients bitten by all other

types of snakes. Children bitten by

rattlesnakes were 3.9 times (odds

ratio, 3.92 [95% confidence interval,

3.53–4.35]) more likely to be

admitted to an HCF than those bitten

by copperheads.

Exotic Snakes

Two percent (n = 368) of the

exposures reported involved exotic

snakes. Almost one-half of the exotic

snakes were boa constrictors (n =

182 [49%]), and 31 different exotic

venomous species were reported.

Nine percent of children (n = 76)

with exotic snake encounters were

admitted to the hospital, and 4%

(n = 37) were ICU admissions.

DISCUSSION

The last comprehensive assessment

of epidemiology of snakebites among

children and adolescents of which

we are aware was published in 1965

when inpatient hospital records

5

FIGURE 4Pediatric snakebites reported to US poison control centers, 2000 to 2013.

FIGURE 5Reported rattlesnake bites and antivenom use, 2000 to 2013.

by guest on May 19, 2018http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/Downloaded from

Page 6: Childhood Victims of Snakebites: 2000–2013pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/pediatrics/early/...SCHULTE et al Snakebites are not a reportable condition (to state health departments),

SCHULTE et al

in 10 states were reported. 1 The

present study provides data from 50

states, Puerto Rico, and Washington,

DC, and finds both similarities

and differences. Copperheads

and rattlesnakes remain the most

common domestic venomous snakes

reported; most snakebites are

reported during summer months;

and few deaths occurred. More

than 1100 children and adolescents

are bitten each year, and ∼20%

of victims require ICU admission.

Almost 50% of the reported

snakebites were venomous, but 84%

of all domestic snakebites could

have been potentially treated with

antivenom therapy.

Every state reported snakebite

victims, but copperhead reports

were focused in the southeastern US

and rattlesnakes in the west. Three

states (West Virginia, Oklahoma,

and Louisiana) had the highest

prevalence rates of both total bites

and venomous bites. These findings

suggest the potential benefit of

prevention efforts tailored to

states reporting large numbers of

snakebites (Texas, Florida, Georgia,

North Carolina, Arizona, and

California) or have high prevalence

rates (Oklahoma, West Virginia, and

Louisiana).

We found that the use of antivenom

for rattlesnake, copperhead, and

unknown crotalid bites increased

during the study period, especially

after 2006. This finding is

similar to those of earlier studies

examining the use of antivenom

for briefer time periods. 4, 14 Much

of the augmented use is driven by

copperhead bites, which increased

107% during the study period; use

of Fab antivenom for those bites

increased 775%. Traditionally,

antivenom treatment of copperheads

was less common because their

venom is less toxic, producing

milder symptoms than bites by

rattlesnakes or cottonmouths. 15, 16

More recent studies have found

that residual copperhead venom

effects, including swelling, pain, and

functional disability, may persist for

13 days.17 Treatment with the newer

Fab antivenom has become more

common and can be expensive. Initial

treatment requires at least 4 to 6

vials of antivenom, and the patient’s

charges for just the antivenom can be

almost $100 000. 18

Our study also prompts questions

concerning the data regarding

antivenom treatment. We had data on

antivenom therapy for only 28% of

pediatric reports, but up to 83% of all

domestic snakebites were potentially

treatable with antivenom according

to our estimates. The seeming

discrepancy may be explained by

the variation in bites and symptoms

that the bites produce. Up to 20% of

venomous snakebites are dry, 19, 20 and

the amount of venom injected varies

among bites. Dry bites occur because

a specific snake may have hunted

and used all venom supplies. The

severity of clinical manifestations can

vary greatly, with minimal symptoms

6

FIGURE 6Reported copperhead bites and antivenom use, 2000 to 2013.

TABLE 1 Characteristics and Treatment of Venomous and Unknown Snakebites, 2000 to 2013

Patient Characteristic Rattlesnake

(n = 2859)

Copperhead

(n = 3602)

Cottonmouth

(n = 511)

Coral (n = 232) Unknown Crotalid

(n = 1853)

Unknown Snake

(n = 6382)

Mean age, y 10.6 10.8 12.2 12.2 10.7 10.6

Male 2035 (71) 2325 (65) 396 (78) 187 (81) 1194 (64) 4289 (67)

HCF admit 1361 (48) 798 (22) 123 (24) 98 (42) 466 (25) 634 (10)

ICU admit 500 (17) 363 (10) 121 (24) 29 (13) 566 (31) 944 (15)

Antivenom treatment

Fab antivenom 958 (34) 1110 (31) 135 (26) NA 571 (31) 823 (13)

Older antivenoma 223 (8) 168 (5) 40 (8) 36 (16) 113 (6) 993 (16)

Any antivenom 1181 (41) 1278 (36) 175 (34) NA 684 (37) 1816 (28)

Data are presented as n (%) unless indicated otherwise. NA, not applicable.a Either polyvalent crotalid or monovalent coral snake.

by guest on May 19, 2018http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/Downloaded from

Page 7: Childhood Victims of Snakebites: 2000–2013pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/pediatrics/early/...SCHULTE et al Snakebites are not a reportable condition (to state health departments),

PEDIATRICS Volume 138 , number 5 , November 2016

to life-threatening complications,

and they may not develop or

progress slowly or rapidly. Systemic

manifestations, usually attributed to

venomous bites, can include rapid

swelling, ecchymosis, and progression

to hypotension, altered sensorium,

tachycardia, respiratory distress, and

severe coagulation abnormalities

and require admission to the ICU. In

many exposures, the exact snake is

unidentified. This fact can complicate

decisions about whether to use

antivenom.

We found only 4 pediatric victims

who died during the study period.

This finding is consistent with earlier

assessments that ∼5 persons of all

ages die each year of snakebites in

the United States. 21

The type of snakebites that poison

control centers are consulted about

is also changing. Fifty years ago,

no exotic species were reported. 1

In our report, only 2% of pediatric

exposures were exotic species, but

pet industry groups have estimated

that 846 000 households own

snakes. 4 Some exotic species (all

of them constrictors) have been

restricted from further importation

and from interstate transport by

the federal government. 22 It is

reasonable to expect that the

calls to poison control centers about

exotic snakes will become more

common.

The present study has a number of

limitations. Our assessment was based

on described exposures reported to US

poison control centers by voluntary

callers, which does not capture all

incidents. The NPDS also does not

capture detailed information on the

anatomic site of the bite, the degree

of envenomation, or the amount of

antivenom used in treatment.

HCFs may treat snakebites and

not consult with a poison center,

especially if the treating physician

chooses not to use antivenom. Some

data may be miscoded. In addition,

our data likely do not completely

reflect the time of day when the

snakebite occurred. The national

data collection includes time of

call but no data regarding time of

exposure.

In addition, snakes may be

improperly identified or not

identified at all. NPDS data use

voluntary self-reporting from

health care providers, patients,

and friends and family who have

varying levels of knowledge, and

the follow-up of cases may not

be complete. However, NPDS

data are the most comprehensive

and accurate database for such

exposures.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study found changes in the

venomous snakebites reported, with

increased numbers of copperhead bites

reported, an increased use of newer

antivenom therapy for species beyond

rattlesnakes, and the emergence of

exotic species. Educational prevention

efforts should focus on states reporting

large numbers of snakebites or high

prevalence rates.

7

ABBREVIATIONS

HCF:  health care facility

NPDS:  National Poison Data

System

PEDIATRICS (ISSN Numbers: Print, 0031-4005; Online, 1098-4275).

Copyright © 2016 by the American Academy of Pediatrics

FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE: Dr. Kleinschmidt has received funding for the North American Snakebite Registry that is supported by the American College of Medical

Toxicology through an unrestricted grant from BTG Pharmaceuticals. This registry has no relationship to the National Poison Data System (the data source for

the study). The other authors have indicated they have no fi nancial relationships relevant to this article to disclose.

FUNDING: No external funding.

POTENTIAL CONFLICT OF INTEREST: The authors have indicated they have no potential confl icts of interest to disclose.

FIGURE 7Reported unknown crotalid bites and antivenom use, 2000 to 2013.

by guest on May 19, 2018http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/Downloaded from

Page 8: Childhood Victims of Snakebites: 2000–2013pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/pediatrics/early/...SCHULTE et al Snakebites are not a reportable condition (to state health departments),

SCHULTE et al

REFERENCES

1. Parrish HM, Goldner JC, Silberg SL.

Comparison between snakebites

in children and adults. Pediatrics.

1965;36:251–256

2. Gold BS, Wingert WA. Snake venom

poisoning in the United States: a

review of therapeutic practice. South

Med J. 1994;87(6):579–589

3. Bellman L, Hoffman B, Levick NR, Winkel

KD. US snakebite mortality, 1979-2005.

J Med Toxicol. 2008;4(1):45

4. Otterman SR, Bush SP, Moynihan JA,

Clark RF. Crotaline Fab antivenom

for the treatment of children with

rattlesnake envenomation. Pediatrics.

2002;10(5):968–971

5. Collis A, Fenili R. The modern US

reptile industry. Washington, DC:

Georgetown Economic Services,

LLC. Available at: www. whitehouse.

gov/ sites/ default/ fi les/omb/assets/

oira_1018/1018_04182011-3.pdf.

Accessed December 1, 2015

6. Warrick BJ, Boyer LV, Seifert SA. Non-

native (exotic) snake envenomations

in the US, 2005-2011. Toxins (Basel).

2014;6(10):2899–2911

7. Wolf BC, Harding BE. Fatalities

due to indigenous and exotic

species in Florida. J Forensic Sci.

2014;59(1):155–160

8. Humane Society of United States.

Constrictor snake incidents. Available

at: www. humanesociety. org/ assets/

pdfs/ wildlife/ captive/ captive-

constrictor- snake- incidents. pdf.

Accessed January 21, 2016

9. Mowry JB, Spyker DA, Cantilena LR

Jr, McMillan N, Ford M. 2013 Annual

report of the American Association

of Poison Control Centers’ National

Poison Data System (NPDS): 31st

annual report. Clin Toxicol (Phila).

2014;52(10):1032–1283

10. US Census Bureau. 2010 Census

data. Available at: www. census. gov/

2010census/ data/ . Accessed November

10, 2015

11. National Poison Data System (NPDS).

NPDS System Manual (April 2014).

Alexandria, VA: American Association

of Poison Control; 2014

12. Jurkovich GJ, Luterman A, McCullar

K, Ramenofsky ML, Curreri PW.

Complications of Crotalidae

antivenin therapy. J Trauma.

1988;28(7):1032–1037

13. Clark RF, McKinney PE, Chase PB, Walter

FG. Immediate and delayed allergic

reactions to Crotalidae polyvalent

immune Fab (ovine) antivenom. Ann

Emerg Med. 2002;39(6):671–676

14. Spiller HA, Bosse GM, Ryan ML. Use of

antivenom for snakebites reported

to United States poison centers. Am J

Emerg Med. 2010;28(7):780–785

15. Walter FG, Stolz U, Shirazi F, Walter

CM, McNally J. Epidemiology of the

reported severity of copperhead

(Agkistrodon contortrix) snakebite.

South Med J. 2012;105(6):313–320

16. Dart RC, McNally J. Effi cacy, safety,

and use of snake antivenoms in

the United States. Ann Emerg Med.

2001;37(2):181–188

17. Roth B, Sharma K, Onisko N, Chen

T. Prospective evaluation of pain,

swelling and disability from

copperhead envenomation. Clin Toxicol

(Phila). 2016;54(3):271–276

18. Ingraham C. This $153, 000 rattlesnake

bite is everything wrong with American

health care. Available at: https://

www. washingtonpost. com/ news/

wonk/ wp/ 2015/ 07/ 20/ this- 153000-

rattlesnake- bite- is- everything- wrong-

with- american- health- care/ . Accessed

January 21, 2016

19. Kitchens CS, Van Mierop LH.

Envenomation by the Eastern coral

snake (Micrurus fulvius fulvius).

A study of 39 victims. JAMA.

1987;258(12):1615–1618

20. Gold BS, Dart RC, Barish RA. Bites

of venomous snakes. N Engl J Med.

2002;347(5):347–356

21. Langley RL, Morrow WE. Deaths

resulting from animal attacks in the

United States. Wilderness Environ Med.

1997;8(1):8–16

22. US Fish and Wildlife Service.

Service lists four nonnative, large

constrictor snakes as injurious

wildlife: protections for native

wildlife and sensitive US ecosystems

strengthened through prohibitions on

importation and interstate transport.

Available at: www. fws. gov/ news/

ShowNews. cfm? ID= F0464D00- 9BCE-

0156- C88E1ADECD13395B. Accessed

November 15, 2015

8 by guest on May 19, 2018http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/Downloaded from

Page 9: Childhood Victims of Snakebites: 2000–2013pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/pediatrics/early/...SCHULTE et al Snakebites are not a reportable condition (to state health departments),

originally published online October 20, 2016; Pediatrics Kleinschmidt and Brett A. Roth

Joann Schulte, Kristina Domanski, Eric Anthony Smith, Annelle Menendez, Kurt C.2013−Childhood Victims of Snakebites: 2000

ServicesUpdated Information &

016-0491http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/early/2016/10/18/peds.2including high resolution figures, can be found at:

References

016-0491.full#ref-list-1http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/early/2016/10/18/peds.2This article cites 15 articles, 1 of which you can access for free at:

Subspecialty Collections

_subhttp://classic.pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/toxicologyToxicologyogy_subhttp://classic.pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/pharmacolPharmacologyexposure_subhttp://classic.pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/hazardous_Hazardous Exposureence_-_poison_prevention_subhttp://classic.pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/injury_violInjury, Violence & Poison Preventionfollowing collection(s): This article, along with others on similar topics, appears in the

Permissions & Licensing

https://shop.aap.org/licensing-permissions/in its entirety can be found online at: Information about reproducing this article in parts (figures, tables) or

Reprintshttp://classic.pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/reprintsInformation about ordering reprints can be found online:

. ISSN:60007. Copyright © 2016 by the American Academy of Pediatrics. All rights reserved. Print

American Academy of Pediatrics, 141 Northwest Point Boulevard, Elk Grove Village, Illinois,has been published continuously since . Pediatrics is owned, published, and trademarked by the Pediatrics is the official journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics. A monthly publication, it

by guest on May 19, 2018http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/Downloaded from

Page 10: Childhood Victims of Snakebites: 2000–2013pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/pediatrics/early/...SCHULTE et al Snakebites are not a reportable condition (to state health departments),

originally published online October 20, 2016; Pediatrics Kleinschmidt and Brett A. Roth

Joann Schulte, Kristina Domanski, Eric Anthony Smith, Annelle Menendez, Kurt C.2013−Childhood Victims of Snakebites: 2000

http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/early/2016/10/18/peds.2016-0491located on the World Wide Web at:

The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is

. ISSN:60007. Copyright © 2016 by the American Academy of Pediatrics. All rights reserved. Print

American Academy of Pediatrics, 141 Northwest Point Boulevard, Elk Grove Village, Illinois,has been published continuously since . Pediatrics is owned, published, and trademarked by the Pediatrics is the official journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics. A monthly publication, it

by guest on May 19, 2018http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/Downloaded from