37
Eective Areas Herman L. Marshall Nov. 17 , 2014 1

ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

Effective AreasHerman L. Marshall

Nov. 17, 2014

1

Page 2: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

Effective Area Overview• Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

• Two mirror bounces (RIr2)

• Grating Dispersion Efficiency (TTG)

• ACIS/HRC Optical Blocking Filter (TAl * Tlexan)

• ACIS detector quantum efficiency (TcontamQACIS) • Absorption by SiO2 dead layer, gate structure (FI) • Interaction probability in 1 micron thick Si

• HRC detector quantum efficiency (QHRC) • Result: Aeff = Ag RIr2 [TTG ]TAl Tlexan [QACIS ][QHRC] • Also: HRMA overlayer, PSF, OSIP, chip gaps, bad pixels

2

Page 3: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

Mirror Reflectivity (CXRO)

3

http://henke.lbl.gov/optical_constants/

Page 4: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

Mirror Reflectivity (CXRO)

3

http://henke.lbl.gov/optical_constants/

Page 5: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

HRMA Calibration• Measured at MSFC

• Calibrated SSD and Prop. counters used

• Emission line source with various materials

• Empirical correction needed, still not understood

• See POG for details

4

Page 6: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

ACIS EA (with contamination)

5

Page 7: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

ACIS EA (with contamination)

5

Ir-M

Si-K

Al-K

F-K

O-KC

-K

Page 8: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

HETG Schematic• Two types of gratings on HETGS

• Au bars stand on plating base, on polyimide

6

Page 9: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

HETGS Effective Area

7

Page 10: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

HETGS Effective Area

7

Ir-M

Si-K

F-K

O-K Au

-M

Chi

p G

ap

Page 11: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

Internal Cross-cal of HETGS

8

Page 12: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

HRC Effective Area

9

Page 13: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

HRC Effective Area

9

Ir-M

Al-K

Cs-

L

N-K O

-K

C-K

Cs-

L

I-L

I-L

Page 14: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

Cross-Cal with XMM

10

Page 15: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop11

IACHEC: International Astronomical

Consortium for High Energy Calibration

Defining High Energy Calibration Standards

and Procedures

Page 16: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

IACHEC

12

• Annual international meetings• Started by 2 largest X-ray groups (Chandra & XMM)• First meeting in Iceland in 2006• Support comes from projects (XMM, Suzaku, etc.)• Next meeting: Beijing, PRC

• Meetings involve reports and working groups• All major X- & gamma-ray missions represented• 35-45 attendees/meeting, 70% give talks• 9 papers published (2008-14), several in progress• URL: http://web.mit.edu/iachec/ with Wiki

Page 17: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

What IACHEC Does• Reviews ground calibration plans for new missions

• Previous meetings: NuSTAR, Swift, • This year: Astro-H, eROSITA

• Reviews flight calibration plans and results• Investigate optics and detector physics• Examine methods, systematic errors

• Define new calibration standards• Characterize sources physically• Compare & publish results from different missions

• Arrange coordinated observations• Consider infrastructure: statistics, archives

13

Page 18: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

Cross-Cal with 1E0102

14

Page 19: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

ContaminationHerman L. Marshall

Nov. 17, 2014

15

Page 20: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

Contamination Overview• 1999: Chandra Launch!• 2000: Anomalous C-K edge — LETG only?!• 2001: Contaminant thickens!• 2002: Composition determined (COF), edge

NEXAFS indicates C-C single bonding!• 2003: Spatial variation found: thin at FoV

center!• 2004: Fluffium invented as LETG/ACIS and

cal source disagree; new model released!• 2010: Deposition accelerates, Gaussium

replaces fluffium16

Page 21: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

The Anomalous C-K Edge

173/00

Page 22: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

ACIS External Cal Source

18

700e

V / 5

.9ke

V

Page 23: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

The Model

19

NC/NO = 12NC/NF = 14

Page 24: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

The Model

19

NC/NO = 12NC/NF = 14

Page 25: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop20

Page 26: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

As it is now…m = +1m = +1

21

Page 27: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

As it is now…m = +1m = +1m = -1

21

Page 28: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

Cluster Measurements

22

Page 29: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

Spatial Variation

23

Row

Optical Depth

at 700 eV

Bottom half Top half

Page 30: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

Composition Changes

24

Page 31: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

Constant Fluorine/Carbon

25

Page 32: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

ACIS Fits to 1E0102

26

Ne

X

Ne

IX

O V

IIIO

VII

Page 33: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

ACIS Fits to 1E0102

26

Ne

X

Ne

IX

O V

IIIO

VII

Page 34: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

1E0102 Line Fluxes

27

Page 35: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

1E0102 Line Fluxes

27

Page 36: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

Possible Edge Residuals

Overcorrected Edges

28

Page 37: ciao cal Workshop - cxc.cfa.harvard.edu · HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop Effective Area Overview • Geometric Area (entrance annuli - strut area = Ag)

HLM— EA & Contamination /29 Chandra ciao/cal Workshop

Contamination Summary• It is mostly made of C, smattering of F & O

• Origin is unknown, composition doesn’t match any on-board substance

• About the same on ACIS-I and ACIS-S

• Thicker at detector edges

• Optical depth at 700 eV is now about 1.5 and climbing

• Effect at 1 keV is noticeable

• Time dependence is not predictable

• Model is not completely physical

• Uncertainties in exact shape of correction remain29