Collective Border Policy in the European Union- Analysis of the S

8/12/2019 Collective Border Policy in the European Union- Analysis of the S

1/95

THE FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY

COLLEGE OF SOCIAL SCIENCES AND PUBLIC POLICY

COLLECTIVE BORDER POLICY IN THE EUROPEAN UNION:

ANALYSIS OF THE SCHENGEN AGREEMENT

By

LEXIA C. ARTHER

A Thesis su!i""e# "$ "he

De%&'"!e(" $) P$*i"i+&* S+ie(+e

i( %&'"i&* )u*)i**!e(" $) "he 'e,ui'e!e("s )$' -'u&"i$( i"h

H$($'s i( "he M&/$'

De-'ee A&'#e#: B&+he*$' $) A'"s i( I("e'(&"i$(&* A))&i's0 B&+he*$' $) A'"s i( F'e(+h1Busi(ess

Su!!e'0 2345


2/95

The !e!e's $) "he De)e(se C$!!i""ee &%%'$6e "he "hesis $) Le7i& C. A'"he' #e)e(#e# $( A%'i* 480

2345.

999999999999999999999999999999

P'$)ess$' &(# Ch&i'0 De%&'"!e(" $)

P$*i"i+&* S+ie(+e0 D'. D&*e L. S!i"h

Thesis Di'e+"$'

999999999999999999999999999999

A#/u(+" P'$)ess$'0 De%&'"!e(" $)

M$#e'( L&(-u&-es0 D'. M&'ieF'&(+e

P'$s%e'Ch&'"ie'

Ou"si#e C$!!i""ee Me!e'

999999999999999999999999999999

Ass$+i&"e P'$)ess$'0 De%&'"!e(" $)

P$*i"i+&* S+ie(+e0 D'. Se&( D. Eh'*i+h

C$!!i""ee Me!e'


3/95

T&*e $) C$("e("s

Ch&%"e' 4: I("'$#u+"i$( "$ "he S+he(-e( A-'ee!e("

Ch&%"e' 2: The O'i-i(s &(# I!%*e!e("&"i$( $) S+he(-e(

The$'ies $( Eu'$%e&( I("e-'&"i$( &(# Eu'$%e&( E(*&'-e!e("

The S+he(-e( A-'ee!e(" ; A( I("e'-$6e'(!e("&* A%%'$&+h

The Si(-*e Eu'$%e&( A+" ; E!e'-e(+e $) "he I("e'(&* M&'


4/95

The$'e"i+&* M$#e*s De"e'!i(i(- A""i"u#es T$&'# S+he(-e(

D&"& A(&*ysis

E!%i'i+&* A(&*ysis Resu*"s

C$(+*usi$(s

Ch&%"e' ?: C$(+*usi$( &(# I!%*i+&"i$(s

A%%e(#i7: Ch'$($*$-y $) S+he(-e( E(*&'-e!e("

Re)e'e(+es

?@

4

@

@5

@>

@

@8


5/95

Ch&%"e' O(e

I("'$#u+"i$( "$ "he S+he(-e( A-'ee!e("

=he( 'e6$*u"i$( '$+


6/95

issues i( Eu'$%e&( %$*i"i+s. C*i!i(- "he '&(


7/95

i(+*usi6e "e'!s $) EU Me!e'shi%. T$#&y0 The S+he(-e( &'e& is +$!%$se# $) 2 +$u("'ies: 22

EU &(# > ($(EU !e!e's see Fi-u'e 4.4.

Fi-u'e 4.4: M&% $) S+he(-e( &(# N$(S+he(-e( C$u("'ies

4

Si(+e 23440 "he S+he(-e( A-'ee!e(" h&s ee( u(#e' 'e6ie y "he Eu'$%e&(

C$!!issi$( #ue "$ "he e7"e(si6e #e&+*e e7&+e'&"e# y "he e6e("s #u'i(- "he A'& S%'i(-. The

A'& S%'i(- se'6e# &s & &


8/95

4

M&% $) S+he(-e( C$u("'ies "&


9/95

us"i+e &(# H$!e A))&i's0 Ce+i*i& M&*!s"'!0 ($"e# "h&"0 i" &s +*e&' "h&" "he "'us" &(#

sus"&i(&i*i"y $) "he sys"e! h ee( se6e'e*y "es"e#J M&*!s"'! 2342. Dis%u"e $6e' "he

S+he(-e( A-'ee!e(" +$("i(ues "$ e & #i6i#i(- )$'+e e"ee( EU !e!e' s"&"es0 (&!e*y

F'&(+e0 u" &*s$ De(!&'


10/95

"&


11/95

Ch&%"e' T$

The O'i-i(s &(# I!%*e!e("&"i$( $) "he S+he(-e( A-'ee!e("

The$'ies $) Eu'$%e&( I("e-'&"i$( &(# Eu'$%e&( E(*&'-e!e("

T$ +$!%'ehe(# "he $'i-i(s &(# #e6e*$%!e(" $) "he S+he(-e( A-'ee!e("Ks +$!%*i+&"e#

i("e-'&"i$( %'$+ess0 i" is )i's" (e+ess&'y "$ u(#e's"&(# s$!e &+


12/95

$) (&"i$(&* s$6e'ei-("y Nu-e(" 2343.

The +$(+e%" $) su%'&(&"i$(&*is! is #e)i(e# &s s"&"es $' +$u("'ies $'


13/95

The 'esu*" e+&!e "he )i's" i("e-'&"i$( e))$'" ; "he es"&*ish!e(" $) "he Eu'$%e&( C$&*

&(# S"ee* C$!!u(i"y ECSC i( The T'e&"y $) P&'is i( 48?4. The ECSC u(i)ie# "he !$s"

i!%$'"&(" s$u'+es $) %$e' &(# e+$($!i+ +&%&i*i"y &" "he "i!e e"ee( si7 Eu'$%e&( +$u("'ies

; Be*-iu!0 F'&(+e0 =es" Ge'!&(y0 I"&*y0 Lu7e!$u'-0 &(# "he Ne"he'*&(#s EUROPA ECSC

T'e&"yJ. The %u'%$se $) "he ECSC "h$u-h" "h&" y *i(


14/95

&+"$'s e+$!e *ess i()*ue("i&* &(# "he i(+'e&si(- i!%$'"&(+e $) i("e-'&"i$( )$' %$*i"i+&* +$("'$*

&(# &++$u("&i*i"yJ is %*&+e# &" "he su%'&(&"i$(&* *e6e* Nu-e(" 2343.

F'e(+h "he$'is" e&( M$((e"0 h$se i#e&s e'e "$ )$+us !$'e $( "he se+'e"&'i&" $'

'e-i$(&* u'e&u+'&"s "h&" *e i(#i6i#u&* i(s"i"u"i$(s "$ e e))e+"i6e0 e!e**ishe# (e$)u(+"i$(&*is"

"he$'y0 hi+h su%%$'" "he i#e& $) & #u&* e+$($!i+ &(# %$*i"i+&* i("e-'&"i$( %'$+ess. I( 'e-&'#s "$

%$*i"i+&* s%i**$6e'0 M$((e" e*ie6e# i( -'e&"e' i("e-'&"i$( %$e' i"h "he i(s"i"u"i$( '&"he' "h&(

i"h se%&'&"e !e!e' s"&"es &" "he (&"i$(&* *e6e*. He !$#e*e# "h'ee )&+"$'s "h&" $u*# i("e'&+"

i"h e&+h $"he': e+$($!i+ i("e'#e%e(#e(+e0 $'-&(i&"i$(&* +&%&+i"y0 &(# su%'&(&"i$(&* !&'


15/95

s"&"es &(# %'$6i#e# )'ee#$! $) !$i*i"y $) -$$#s0 %e's$(s0 &(# se'6i+es i"hi( "he Be(e*u7

"e''i"$'y.

The EEC +$("i(ue# "$ e(*&'-e "h'$u-h & se'ies $) )$u' e(*&'-e!e(" '$u(#s See T&*e 2.4

Be*$.

T&*e 2.4: The E(*&'-e!e(" R$u(#s

E(*&'-e!e(" R$u(#

F$u(#i(- Me!e' S"&"es

The Fi's" E(*&'-e!e(" R$u(#

The Me#i"e''&(e&( R$u(#5

D&"e $) A++essi$(

48?@

4 &(u&'y 48@5

4 &(u&'y 484

4 &(u&'y 48

The EFTAN R$u(#>

The 43 2 R$u(#?

4 &(u&'y 488?

4 M&y 233>

Me!e' S"&"es A++e#i(-

Be*-iu!0 F'&(+e0 I"&*y0 Lu7e!$u'-0

The Ne"he'*&(#s0 &(# =es" Ge'!&(y

De(!&'


16/95

"'ies &(# "he $"he' "$ e'e Me#i"e''&(e&(.

Re)e''e# "$ "he Me#i"e''&(e&( '$u(# e+&use $) "he Me#i"e''&(e&( +$u("'ies h$ &++e#e#.>

EFTA( 'e)e's "$ "he Eu'$%e&( F'ee T'e Ass$+i&"i$(0 $) hi+h &** &%%*i+&("s e'e !e!e's.?

432 'e)e's "$ "he E(*&'-e!e(" '$u(# he'e "e( &%%*i+&("s e'e Ce("'&* &(# E&s"e'( Eu'$%e&(


17/95

e(*&'-e!e(" %'$+ess0 =es"e'( Eu'$%e&( +$u("'ies &*s$ e7%e'ie(+e# &( i()*u7 $) i!!i-'&("s

i(6i"e# )'$! (ei-h$'i(- 'e-i$(s "$ he*% $$s" *$+&* &(# 'e-i$(&* $' #u'i(- "he P&'is Su!!i" &$u" &$*ishi(- %&ss%$'" +$("'$*s. This #is+ussi$(

)u'"he' *e# "$ "&*< $) & s"&(#&'#i&"i$( $) %&ss%$'"s )$' +i"ie(s i"hi( "he EEC The Eu'$%e&(

P&ss%$'"J. I( 4840 Eu'$%e&( C$!!u(i"y !e!e' s"&"es $%"e# & u(i)$'! %&ss%$'" #esi-( &(#

i( 48> "he C$u(+i* &(# -$6e'(!e("s $) "he !e!e' s"&"es &%%'$6e# )'ee %&ss&-e &+'$ss "he

C$!!u(i"yKs i("e'(&* )'$("ie's )$' !e!e' s"&"esK (&"i$(&*sJ The Eu'$%e&( P&ss%$'"J.

These %'eS+he(-e( e7&!%*es $) Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$( ; )'$! "he &se*i(e +$(+e%" $) &

)'ee !$6e!e(" $) %e's$(s0 )$**$e# y "he #e6e*$%!e(" $) "he E+$($!i+ U(i$( e"ee(

Be(e*u70 &(# )i(&**y i"h "he i(+'e&se# +'$ss $'#e' !$6e!e("s &ss$+i&"e# i"h Eu'$%e&(

e(*&'-e!e(" &(# "he &$*ish!e(" $) %&ss%$'" +$("'$*s ; se'6e &s "he e-i((i(- )'&!e$'< )$'

h&" *&"e' e+$!es 'e&*ie# i( "he S+he(-e( A-'ee!e(". I" is e6i#e(" &se# $( "hese e7&!%*es

"h&" "he s%i**$6e' e))e+" $) (e$)u(+"i$(&*is!Ks i(s"i"u"i$(&* &%%'$&+h "$ 'e-i$(&* i("e-'&"i$(

%'$6es "$ e "'ue. The'e)$'e0 (e$)u(+"i$(&*is! is i#e*y &++e%"e# &s "he #$!i(&(" "he$'y

e7%*&i(i(- S+he(-e(Ks i("e-'&"i$( %'$+ess i( "he Eu'$%e&( U(i$(.


18/95

The S+he(-e( A-'ee!e(" ; A( I("e'-$6e'(!e("&* A%%'$&+h

As s"&"es &"+he# "he su++ess $) "he Be(e*u7 e+$($!i+ u(i$(0 $"he' (&"i$(s e-&( "$

'e+$-(ie "he %$"e("i&* e(e)i"s $) & )'ee !$6e!e(" $) %e's$(s &'e& e"ee( +$u("'ies.

The'e)$'e0 $( u(e 4?0 48?0 i( "he s!&**0 %i+"u'es,ue "$( $) S+he(-e(0 Lu7e!$u'- )i6e

+$u("'ies ; The Ne"he'*&(#s0 Be*-iu!0 Lu7e!$u'-0 F'&(+e &(# Ge'!&(y ; -&"he'e# "$ si-( &(

&-'ee!e(" +&**e# The S+he(-e( A-'ee!e(" The S+he(-e( A'e& &(# C$$%e'&"i$(J. The

S+he(-e( A-'ee!e(" se" )$'"h $"h sh$'" "e'! &(# *$(- "e'! !e&su'es "h&" &i!e# &" e*i!i(&"i(-

$'#e' +he+


19/95

I("e'-$6e'(!e("&*is! 'e)e's "$ "he +$$%e'&"i$( e"ee( (&"i$( s"&"es $( !&""e's $) +$**e+"i6e $'

+$!!$( i("e'es" "h&" "he s"&"es +&( +$("'$*. The e*e!e(" $) +$("'$* e(&*es %&'"i+i%&"i(- s"&"es "$

#e+i#e $( "he *e6e* &(# e7"e(" $) +$$%e'&"i$(0 !e&(i(- "h&" (&"i$(&* s$6e'ei-("y is ($" #i'e+"*y

u(#e'!i(e#J Nu-e(" 2343.


20/95

I"Ks %u*i(- "$ ($"e "h&" "hese +$u("'ies ; Be(e*u70 F'&(+e0 &(# Ge'!&(y ; e'e &**

su%%$'"e's $) "he i("e-'&"i$( e))$'"s "&


21/95

@N&"i$(&* s$6e'ei-("y is #e)i(e# &s "he %$e'0 &u"h$'i"y0 i(#e%e(#e(+e0 &(# e7e'+ise $) i**

*yi(- i"h "he (&"i$( s"&"e. I" is !$s"*y use# i( si"u&"i$(s 'e)e''i(- "$ #e+isi$(!&


22/95

e"ee( "he "e*6e !e!e' s"&"es i( "he Eu'$%e&( C$!!u(i"y. Be*-iu!0 De(!&'


23/95


24/95


25/95

F$'ei-( &(# Se+u'i"y P$*i+y CFSP &(# 5 C$$%e'&"i$( i( "he )ie*#s $) us"i+e &(# H$!e

A))&i's HA Eu'$"'e&"ies Te7" $) "he T'e&"y $( Eu'$%e&( U(i$(.


26/95

T&*e 2.2: Ti"*es $) "he S+he(-e( C$(6e("i$(

TITLE I

TITLE II

Ch&%"e' 4

Ch&%"e' 2

Ch&%"e' 5

Se+"i$( 4

Se+"i$( 2

Ch&%"e' >

Ch&%"e' ?

Ch&%"e'

Ch&%"e' @

TITLE III

Ch&%"e' 4

Ch&%"e' 2

Ch&%"e' 5

Ch&%"e' >

Ch&%"e' ?

Ch&%"e'

Ch&%"e' @

TITLE IV

Ch&%"e' 4

Ch&%"e' 2

Ch&%"e' 5

Ch&%"e' >

TITLE V

TITLE VI

TITLE VII

TITLE VIII

W T&*e

De)i(i"i$(s

A$*i"i$( $) +he+

A'"i+*e 2?

A'"i+*e 2 2@

A'"i+*e 2 5

A'"i+*e 58 84

A'"i+*e 58 >@

A'"i+*e > ?5

A'"i+*e ?> ?

A'"i+*e ?8

A'"i+*e @ 8

A'"i+*e @3 @

A'"i+*e @@ 84

A'"i+*e 82 448

A'"i+*e 82

A'"i+*e 85 434

A'"i+*e 432 44

A'"i+*e 448

A'"i+*e 423 42?

A'"i+*e 42 453

A'"i+*e 454 455

A'"i+*e 45> 4>2

&%"e# )'$! si!i*&' !$#e* &": h""%:11.h'i.$'-1#$+s1S+he(-e(831.


27/95

The )i's" %i**&' $) Eu'$%e&( C$!!u(i"ies &s$'e# "he Eu'$%e&( C$!!u(i"y0 The

Eu'$%e&( C$&* &(# S"ee* C$!!u(i"y0 &(# Eu'&"$!. O) "he "h'ee %i**&'s "he )i's" is "he $(*y $(e

"h&" is su%'&(&"i$(&*. I" es"&*ishe# "he *e-&* %'$+ee#i(-s $) #e+isi$(!&


28/95

The Eu'$%e&( A"$!i+ E(e'-y C$!!issi$( EURATOM &s es"&*ishe# i( 48? "$

+$$'#i(&"e Eu'$%e&( +$u("'iesK (u+*e&' %'$-'&!s.


29/95

s%e+i)ie# *e-is*&"i$( "h&" !e!e' s"&"es e'e $(*y &**$e# "$ 'ei("'$#u+e +he+


30/95

Eu'$%e&( U(i$(0 %'$-'ess &s &*s$ !e i( /u#i+i&* +$$%e'&"i$(. O(e $) "he -$&*s $) "he

S+he(-e( C$(6e("i$( &s "$ 'e#u+e "he e7%u*si$( $' 'e%&"'i&"i$( $) !i-'&("s h$ #i# ($" h$*# &

S+he(-e( Vis&. The S+he(-e( A-'ee!e(" &**$e# !i-'&("s "$ &%%*y )$' & $(e"i!e &sy*u!

+*&i!0 he'e i) &%%'$6e#0 "hey +$u*# e issue# & S+he(-e( 6is&. I) ($"0 %$*i+e &u"h$'i"y $) &(y

%&'"i+i%&"i6e s"&"e i"hi( "he S+he(-e( &'e& &s "he( &*e "$ i(i"i&"e e7"'i"i$( EUROPA

P'ess Re*e&ses S+he(-e(: B&si+ F&+"s.

> HA C$$%e'&"i$( A'e& C$("'$* $) "he C$!!u(i"yKs E7"e'(&* B$'#e's

Fu'"he'!$'e0 S+he(-e( &*s$ +$("'iu"e# "$ "he )$u'"h HA +$$%e'&"i$( &'e&0 +$("'$* $)

"he C$!!u(i"yKs e7"e'(&* $'#e's0 y &""e!%"i(- "$ &**e6i&"e "he +h&**e(-i(- issue $) #'u-

"'&))i+


31/95

I(+$'%$'&"i$( $) The S+he(-e( C$(6e("i$( i("$ "he Eu'$%e&( U(i$(

G'u&**y0 &s "he EU i("e-'&"e# i"h "he es"&*ish!e(" $) "he "h'ee %i**&'s $) "he

M&&s"'i+h" T'e&"y0 s$ #i# "he S+he(-e( C$(6e("i$(. The !e&su'es #e)i(e# i( "he S+he(-e(

C$(6e("i$( +&!e i("$ )$'+e )$' "he $'i-i(&* )i6e si-(&"$'y s"&"es i( Se%"e!e' 4885 &(# *&"e' i(

De+e!e' 488>0 #e# S%&i( &(# P$'"u-&* H$!e A))&i's P$*i+ies B$'#e's S+he(-e(

C$(6e("i$(. The $))i+i&* i!%*e!e("&"i$( #&"e $) "he S+he(-e( C$(6e("i$( &s M&'+h 20 488?

i( hi+h "he se6e( s"&"es ; Be*-iu!0 The Ne"he'*&(#s0 Lu7e!$u'-0 Ge'!&(y0 F'&(+e0 S%&i(0

&(# P$'"u-&* ; i!%*e!e("e# &** ei-h" "i"*es se" )$'"h i( "he S+he(-e( C$(6e("i$( The

I!%*e!e("&"i$( $) "he C$(6e("i$( A%%*yi(- i( "he S+he(-e( A-'ee!e(".

A ye&' *&"e'0 i( M&'+h 4880 !e!e' s"&"es !e" &" "he I("e'-$6e'(!e("&* C$()e'e(+e

IGC i( Tu'i(0 I"&*y "$ #is+uss se6e'&* (e-$"i&"i$(s0 $(e $) hi+h &s +$(+e'( )$' "he

i("e-'&"i$( $) "he S+he(-e( C$(6e("i$( i("$ "he $))i+i&* *e-&* )'&!e$'< $) "he Eu'$%e&( U(i$(

The I!%*e!e("&"i$( $) "he C$(6e("i$( A%%*yi(- i( "he S+he(-e( A-'ee!e(". The IGC

#is+usse# &( $u"*i(e0 hi+h %'$%$se# S+he(-e( i("e-'&"i$( i("$ "he EU i( "h'ee %&'"s. H$e6e'0

!e!e' s"&"es h$ h ($" %&'"i+i%&"e# i( "he #e6e*$%!e("&* %'$+ess $) S+he(-e( su+h &s "he

U0 I'e*&(#0 &(# De(!&'< h #i))i+u*"y u(#e's"&(#i(- "he +$!%*i+&"e# s"'u+"u'e $) S+he(-e(.

They ,ues"i$(e# "he *&(-u&-e $) "he "e7"s 'i""e( i( "he S+he(-e( C$(6e("i$( &(# e'e hesi"&("

"$ e6e( +$(si#e' "he +$(+e%" $) )'ee !$6e!e(" $) %e's$(s e"ee( i("e'(&* )'$("ie's -i6e( "he

(&"u'e $) "he #e&"e "h&" "he se+u'i"y $) & +$u("'yKs $'#e's sh$u*# e & (&"i$(&* +$!%e"e(+y &(#

($" u(#e' C$!!u(i"y *& The S+he(-e( A'e& &(# C$$%e'&"i$(J. Su+h "e+h(i+&* ,ues"i$(s

*e# S+he(-e( (e-$"i&"i$( &(# "he )$'!&* i("e-'&"i$( $) "he S+he(-e( C$(6e("i$( i("$ "he

Eu'$%e&( U(i$( )'&!e$'< "$ e %u" $( h$*#.


32/95

The T'e&"y $) A!s"e'#&! &(# "he

I(+$'%$'&"i$( $) "he S+he(-e( &+,uis i("$ "he Eu'$%e&( U(i$(

A)"e' !u+h #e&"e &(# +$!%'ehe(si6e #is+ussi$(0 &( &-'ee!e(" $( S+he(-e( &s )i(&**y

'e&*ie# #u'i(- "he A!s"e'#&! Su!!i" i( u(e 488@ T'e&"y $) A!s"e'#&! A!e(#i(- "he

T'e&"y $( Eu'$%e&( U(i$(. A )$'!&* s"'u+"u'e "$ *e-&**y i(+$'%$'&"e "he S+he(-e( C$(6e("i$(

i("$ "he i(s"i"u"i$(&* )'&!e$'< $) "he Eu'$%e&( U(i$( &s #e)i(e# i( "he T'e&"y $) A!s"e'#&!

es"&*ishe# i( O+"$e' 488@ &(# &s e("e'e# i("$ )$'+e i( M&y 4888 Eu'$%&: SCADP*us. The

A!s"e'#&! T'e&"y. The &++$'#s &(# %'$6isi$(s #e"e'!i(e# i( "he S+he(-e( C$(6e("i$( e+&!e

"he S+he(-e( &+,uis.8 The S+he(-e( &+,uis +&**e# )$' "he 'e%*&+e!e(" $) "he S+he(-e(

E7e+u"i6e C$!!i""ee y "he C$u(+i* $) "he Eu'$%e&( U(i$(. The C$u(+i* &s -i6e( *e-&*

&u"h$'i"y "$ se" "he s"&(#&'#s $) S+he(-e( )$' !e!e' s"&"es &++$'#i(- "$ "he &+,uis &(# e+&!e

"he $))i+i&* i(s"i"u"i$(&* $#y i( +h&'-e $) +$(#u+"i(- i(s%e+"i$(s &" "he e7"e'(&* $'#e's $) "he

Eu'$%e&( U(i$( The S+he(-e( A+,uis &(# i"s I("e-'&"i$( i("$ "he U(i$(J. Fi(&**y0 "he &+,uis

i(+$'%$'&"e# "he S+he(-e( Se+'e"&'i&" i("$ "he Ge(e'&* Se+'e"&'i&" $) "he C$u(+i* EUROPA0

The S+he(-e( A'e& &(# C$$%e'&"i$(J.

The S+he(-e( &+,uis 'e+$-(ie# "hi'"ee( EU Me!e' S"&"es ; Be*-iu!0 Lu7e!$u'-0

The Ne"he'*&(#s0 Ge'!&(y0 F'&(+e0 S%&i(0 P$'"u-&*0 G'ee+e0 I"&*y0 Aus"'i&0 De(!&'


33/95

8

The S+he(-e( &+,uis is "he )$'!&* #$+u!e("0 %'e%&'e# y "he Ge(e'&* Se+'e"&'i&" $) "he

C$u(+i* "h&" se'6es &s "he *e-&* %'e!ise $) "he !e&su'es #e)i(e# i( "he S+he(-e( C$(6e("i$(. I"

&s %u*ishe# i( "he O))i+i&* $u'(&* $) Eu'$%e&( C$!!u(i"ies i( Se%"e!e' $) 2333 &(# &(y

'e6isi$(s $' !$#i)i+&"i$( u%#&"es &'e %$s"e# "$ "he Eu'$%& esi"e.


34/95


35/95

&ss$+i&"i$( i"h "he S+he(-e( &+,uis y ($(EU +$u("'ies is &( &-'ee!e(" &se# $( "he

+$!!$( %'i(+i%*e $) "he )'ee !$6e!e(" $) %e's$(s e"ee( "h$se s"&"es &(# "he EU.J

EUROPA0 The S+he(-e( A'e& &(# C$$%e'&"i$(J This is es"&*ishe# i( "he A-'ee!e(" $( "he

Eu'$%e&( E+$($!i+ A'e& &(# %'$6i#es )$' "he +&ses $) I+e*&(#0 N$'&y &(# Lie+h"e(s"ei( &(#

"he &-'ee!e(" $( "he )'ee !$6e!e(" $) %e's$(s i( Si"e'*&(#Ks +&se.

F$' %&'"i+i%&"i6e ($(EU s"&"es0 "hei' i(6$*6e!e(" i( S+he(-e( &**$s "hei' %&'"i+i%&"i$(

i"hi( "he #esi-(&"e# S+he(-e( &'e& i"h$u" i("e'(&* $'#e' +he+


36/95

T$#&y0 "he S+he(-e( &'e& i(+*u#es (e&'*y e6e'y +$u("'y i( "he Eu'$%e&( U(i$(.

A%%e(#i7 4 ($"es "he Ch'$($*$-y $) S+he(-e( e(*&'-e!e(" &(# #i"i$( $) !e!e' s"&"es $6e'

"i!e. The i(i"i&* si-(&"$'ies i(+*u#e Be*-iu!0 The Ne"he'*&(#s0 Lu7e!$u'-0 F'&(+e &(#

Ge'!&(y. The 'e!&i(#e' $) S+he(-e( e(*&'-e!e(" $++u''e# -'u&**y. I"&*y si-(e# "he

&-'ee!e("s $( N$6e!e' 2@0 4883 i"h S%&i( &(# P$'"u-&* /$i(i(- sh$'"*y &)"e' $( u(e 2?0

48840 &(# G'ee+e )$**$i(- $( N$6e!e' 0 4882 A$*i"i$( $) B$'#e' C$("'$*sJ. The (e7"

&6e i(+*u#e# +e("'&* Eu'$%e i"h "he /$i(i(- $) Aus"'i& $( A%'i* 20 488? &(# "he i(+*usi$( $)

"he N$'#i+ S"&"es: De(!&'


37/95

The (e7" +h&%"e' 'e6isi"s S+he(-e(Ks i(i"i&* si-(i(- &(# "&


38/95

Ch&%"e' Th'ee

S"&"is"i+&* A(&*ysis $) De"e'!i(&("s )$' S+he(-e( P&'"i+i%&"i$(

I("'$#u+"i$(

=i"hi( "he )ie*# $) i("e'(&"i$(&* 'e*&"i$(s *i"e'&"u'e0 s"u#ies $( "he S+he(-e( A-'ee!e("

$' "he S+he(-e( &'e& !&i(*y e7is" &s %&'" $) & -'e&"e' #is+ussi$( 'e-&'#i(- Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$(

$' i( & se+"i$( &++$!%&(yi(- "he #e6e*$%!e(" $) "he "h'ee %i**&'s $) "he Eu'$%e&( U(i$(. =hi*e

s$!e s"u#ies i(+*u#e S+he(-e( &s & %$*i+y e7&!%*e he( e7%*&i(i(- $%"$u" eh&6i$' &!$(-

!e!e' s"&"es0 6e'y )e *$$< &" S+he(-e(Ks e&'*y #e6e*$%!e(" &(# hy "he'e e'e +e'"&i( s"&"es

h$ +h$se "$ %&'"i+i%&"e he( $"he's #i# ($" A#*e'Niss&( 23380 2344 $**i


39/95

This +h&%"e' e-i(s y *i(


40/95

si!i*&' i("e-'&"i$( e))$'"s &*$(- S+he(-e(Ks %$*i+y *i(es i( $"he' 'e-i$(&**y i("e-'&"e# &'e&s

$u"si#e "he E.U. ; i( L&"i( A!e'i+& )$' e7&!%*e0 i"h MERCOSUR &(# $"he' 'e*&"e# e))$'"s.

The$'y $) Di))e'e("i&"e# I("e-'&"i$(:

V&'i&*e Ge$!e"'y

M$s" Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$( !$#e*s h&6e ee( &se# $( "he s%i**$6e' !e"h$#$*$-y

es"&*ishe# i( (e$)u(+"i$(&*is" "he$'y R$s&!u(# 233. S+he(-e(Ks u(i,ue +$!%$si"i$(0

&**$i(- $"h EU &(# ($(EU s"&"es "$ %&'"i+i%&"e0 &s e** &s i"s #e6e*$%!e(" $u"si#e "he

Eu'$%e&( C$!!u(i"y )'&!e$'


41/95

e"ee( !u*"is%ee# &(# *& +&'"eJ S"u 488. I( his &(&*ysis0 S"u %i$(ee'e# "he

+&"e-$'i&"i$( $) #i))e'e("i&"e# i("e-'&"i$( %e--i(- "he "h'ee !&i( +&"e-$'ies $) #i))e'e("i&"e#

i("e-'&"i$( i"h +$''es%$(#i(- 6&'i&*es: "i!e0 s%&+e &(# !&""e' 'es%e+"i6e*y ; s%&+e ei(-

&ssi-(e# "$ 6&'i&*e -e$!e"'y.

The'e &'e +$!%e"i(- e7%*&(&"i$(s0 h$e6e'0 $( he"he' S+he(-e( )&**s u(#e' & "e''i"$'i&*

s%&+eJ #i))e'e("i&"i$( S"u 488 $' & se+"$'&* !&""e'J #i))e'e("i&"i$( H$*i(-e' &(#

Shi!!e*)i((e- 2342. H$*i(-e' &(# Shi!!e*)i((e- &'-ue "h&" s%&+e &(# !&""e' y #e)i(i"i$(

&'e %'ese(" i( &** "y%es $) #i))e'e("i&"i$(. I(he'e("*y0 "he'e is &*&ys & "e''i"$'i&* &s%e+" "$

#i))e'e("i&"i$( e+&use +e'"&i( +$u("'ies $' 'e-i$(s $%" $u" $) %&'"i+i%&"i(- i( i("e-'&"i$(0 &(#

"he'e is *i


42/95

S"uKs !&i( #is"i(+"i$( "h&" +*&ssi)ies S+he(-e( &(# "he +&"e-$'y $) 6&'i&*e -e$!e"'y

&s ei(- #i))e'e(" )'$! !u*"is%ee# $' *& +&'"e i("e-'&"i$( !e"h$#s0 is "h&" 6&'i&*e -e$!e"'y

e7e!%*i)ies & +e'"&i( $%"i( $' $%"u% "$ & +$(-*$!e'&"i$( $) Me!e' s"&"es hi+h h&6e &*'ey

%u'sue# #ee%e' i("e-'&"i$( i( & s%e+i)i+ %$*i+y &'e& S"u 488.J By #e)i(i"i$(0 S+he(-e(Ks

e(&*i(- 6&'yi(- *e6e*s $) %&'"i+i%&"i$( e"ee( !e!e's &s e** &s "he $%"i$( )$' ($(EU

!e!e' s"&"es "$ %&'"i+i%&"e &++u'&"e*y )i" S"uKs +*&ssi)i+&"i$( &s S+he(-e( u(#e' 6&'i&*e

-e$!e"'y $) #i))e'e("i&"e# i("e-'&"i$(.

H$*i(-e' &(# Shi!!e*)i((e- &'-ue "h&" S"u (e-*e+"e# "$ i(+*u#e %u'e*y )u(+"i$(&*

+$(+e%"i$(s i( his &(&*ysis &(# "h&" his "h'ee -'$u%s #$ ($" #is"i(-uish e"ee( )i7e# &(#

)*e7i*e !e!e'shi% i( 'e-i!es. As & 'esu*"0 "hei' &(&*ysis su--es"s "h&" "he'e &'e ($" $(*y "he

"h'ee 6&'i&*es $) "i!e0 s%&+e0 &(# !&""e' "h&" &%%*y "$ #i))e'e("i&"e# i("e-'&"i$( !$#e*s0 u"

'&"he' #i))e'e("i&"i$( e7is"s &*$(- & se'ies $) si7 #i!e(si$(s:

4 %e'!&(e(" 6s. "e!%$'&'y #i))e'e("i&"i$(

2 "e''i"$'i&* 6s. %u'e*y )u(+"i$(&* #i))e'e("i&"i$(

5 #i))e'e("i&"i$( &+'$ss (&"i$(s 6s. !u*"i*e6e* #i))e'e("i&"i$(

> #i))e'e("i&"i$( "&


43/95

#i))e'e("i&"e# i("e-'&"i$(0 su%%$'" !y &'-u!e(" ehi(# hy "he'e is i(#ee# 6&'i&"i$( e"ee(

!e!e' s"&"esK su%%$'" )$' S+he(-e(. H$*i(-e' &(# Shi!!e*)i((e- )i(# "h&" "he #i))e'e("i&"i$(

)$' S+he(-e( &s "e''i"$'i&* su%%$'"i(- !y &'-u!e(" "h&" -e$-'&%hi+ *$+&"i$( !&""e's i( &

+$u("'yKs #e+isi$( "$ %&'"i+i%&"e i( S+he(-e(. Fi(&**y0 H$*i(-e' &(# Shi!!e*)i((e-

+h&'&+"e'ie "h&" S+he(-e( #i))e'e("i&"i$( $++u''e# &" "he (&"i$(s"&"e *e6e*. This su%%$'"s !y

"he$'y ehi(# hy +$u("'y *e6e* 6&'i&*es $) %&'"is&(shi% &(# e&*"h i"hi( & %&'"i+u*&' (&"i$(

s"&"e &'e 6&*i# !e&su'es "$ #is"i(-uish #i))e'e("i&"i$( e"ee( %&'"i+i%&"i$( i( S+he(-e(.

R&"i$(&*is" A%%'$&+hes "$ Di))e'e("i&"e# I("e-'&"i$(

O(e $) "he !&i( &%%'$&+hes "$ "he +$(+e%"u&* #e6e*$%!e(" $) #i))e'e("i&"e# i("e-'&"i$( is

& '&"i$(&* $(e0 he'e +$**e+"i6e -$$#s &(# e7"e'(&*i"ies %*&y & '$*e i( Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$(

i#e$*$-y. E&'*y s"u#ies $( S+he(-e( i(+*u#e Geh'i(-Ks 488 &(&*ysis $) h$ #i))e'e("i&"e#

i("e-'&"i$( +&( e )u(+"i$(&* "$ $6e'+$!e #e*$+< y e(&*i(- !e!e' s"&"es &(# ($(!e!e'

s"&"es "$ s$!eh$ +$$%e'&"e &" 6&'yi(- *e6e*s $) i("e-'&"i$( Dys$( &(# Se%$s 2343 H$*i(-e'

2344 M&/$(e 2338 S"u 488@ =&'*ei-h 2332. S+he(-e( #e6e*$%e# $u"si#e "he EEC

)'&!e$'< i( &""e!%" "$ $6e'+$!e & #e*$+


44/95


45/95

e("i+i(-0 u" "hei' -e$-'&%hi+ *$+&"i$( hi(#e'e# i(i"i&* !e!e'shi% &++e%"&(+e i("$ S+he(-e(.

Be*-iu!0 F'&(+e0 Ge'!&(y0 Lu7e!$u'-0 &(# "he Ne"he'*&(#s $%%$se# $%e(i(- "hei' $'#e's

+$!%*e"e*y "$ G'ee+e0 I"&*y0 P$'"u-&*0 &(# S%&i( &se# $( "he u(#e's"$$# &ssu!%"i$( "h&"

Me#i"e''&(e&( +$u("'ies e'e i(+&%&*e $) e()$'+i(- "hei' $'#e' 'e-u*&"i$(sJ Di(&( 2343

e(se( &(# S*&%i( 2344. Due "$ "he %*&+e!e(" $) "hese s$u"he'( Eu'$%e&( s"&"esK $'#e's0 "hese

s"&"es h&6e "'i"i$(&**y h %'$*e!s i"h +$("'$**i(- i**e-&* i!!i-'&("s &(# se+u'i(- "hei'

+$&s"*i(es. I"&*y0 #u'i(- "he A'& S%'i(- )$' e7&!%*e0 &""'&+"e# "h$us&(#s $) N$'"h A)'i+&(

!i-'&("s )'$! "he Tu(isi&( +$&s"*i(e h$ s$u-h" 'e)u-e $( I"&*yKs is*&(# $) L&!%e#us& I"&*y

&(# I!!i-'&"i$(: T&


46/95

"h&" +$u*# h&'! "he i("e'(&* &*&(+e $) %e$%*es i( "he U. As & 'esu*"0 "hey +h$se "$ &s"&i( )'$!

S+he(-e( !e!e'shi%.

A++$'#i(- "$ e(se( &(# S*&%i( i( "hei' s"u#y $( !u*"is%ee# i("e-'&"i$( i( "he Eu'$%e&(

U(i$(0 "hey #e6e*$%e# & !$#e* "$ e7%*&i( $%"$u"s $) "he S+he(-e( A-'ee!e(" &se# $( &(

&''&(-e!e(" $) %'e)e'e(+es. S+he(-e( is & %$*i+y #ee%*y i("e'"i(e# i"h i!!i-'&"i$( %$*i+ies

Huys!&(s 2333. The'e)$'e0 S+he(-e(Ks )'ee !$6e!e(" $) %e$%*es &(# &$*i"i$( $) $'#e'

+$("'$*s +&use# +$!%*i+&"i$(s )$' i!!i-'&"i$( %$*i+ies )$' "he !e!e' s"&"esJ e(se( &(#

S*&%i( 2344. As & 'esu*"0 "he %'e)e'e(+e $) s"&"es #e+isi$(s "$ /$i( S+he(-e( &*i-(s i"h 'e+e("

"he$'e"i+&* &(&*yses $) EU i!!i-'&"i$( %$*i+y hi+h %*&+es "he U &" "he *&--&'# e(# $) "he

s%e+"'u! &(# Ge'!&(y &" "he !$s" i("e-'&"i$(is" Gi6e(s &(# Lue#" e(se( &(# S*&%i(

2344.

The #u&* *i(< e"ee( i!!i-'&"i$( %$*i+y "$ "he %e')$'!&(+e s%e+"'u! &(# i!!i-'&"i$(

%$*i+y "$ S+he(-e( su%%$'"s !y &'-u!e(" "h&" "he -e$-'&%hi+ *$+&"i$( 6&'i&*e !&""e's &(# i**

%e')$'! si!i*&'*y &+'$ss "he s%e+"'u!. I &'-ue "h&" !e!e' s"&"es i"h & *&'-e' %'$%$'"i$( $)

+$u("'y $'#e's &*s$ ei(- e7"e'(&* EU $'#e's0 *i


47/95

P&'"is&(shi% =i"hi( "he C$u("'y

The %$*i"i+&* +*i!&"e i( & +$u("'y &(# & +$u("'yKs +$!!i"!e(" "$ "he $/e+"i6es $) "he

EUKs su%'&(&"i$(&* %$e' se'6e# &*s$ &s & +$("'iu"i(- )&+"$' i( hy s"&"es +h$se $' #i# ($"

+h$$se "$ /$i( S+he(-e(. I" is %&'"i+u*&'*y e6i#e(" i( "he #e+isi$(s $) i(i"i&* si-(&"$'ies0 Ge'!&(y

&(# F'&(+e.

Ge'!&(y h&s ee( $(e $) "he )'$("'u((e' s"&"es i( i(i"i&"i(- "he +'e&"i$( $) "he Eu'$%e&(

U(i$( &(# #e6e*$%i(- "he i("e-'&"i$( %'$/e+" si(+e i"s i()&(+y. Be*ie6i(- i( "he e(e)i"s $) &

%$*i"i+&* &(# e+$($!i+ +$**e+"i6e u(i$( *e# Ge'!&(y "$ e &


48/95

+&**e# )$' F'&(+eKs %&'"i+i%&"i$( i( Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$( e))$'"s. I" &s "he +$!%'$!ise e"ee(

Mi""e''&(# &(# "he F'e(+h P&'*i&!e(" $( "he i(se'"i$( $) "he )$**$i(- +*&use i("$ "he S+he(-e(

A-'ee!e(": "h&" "he'e i** e ($ *&'-e "'&(s)e' $) 'es%$(sii*i"ies $) F'&(+e "$ "he

su%'&(&"i$(&* *e6e*J "h&" s$*i#i)ie# F'&(+eKs i**i(-(ess "$ /$i( S+he(-e(. As & 'esu*"0 i) F'&(+e

h ($" e*e+"e# su+h & %'$Eu'$%e su%%$'"e' #u'i(- "he "i!e $) S+he(-e(Ks #e6e*$%!e("0 F'&(+e

!&y h&6e &s"&i(e# )'$! %&'"i+i%&"i$(.

The'e)$'e0 i" is e6i#e(" "h&" & +$u("'yKs %$*i"i+&* +*i!&"e h &( e))e+" $( & +$u("'yKs

#e+isi$( he"he' $' ($" "$ %&'"i+i%&"e i( S+he(-e(. T'i"i$(&**y0 -$6e'(!e("s "$ "he 'i-h" e(# $)

"he %$*i"i+&* s+&*e &'e !$'e +$(se'6&"i6e i"h & s"'$(- (&"i$(&* )$+us &(# "e(# "$ 'e)'&i( )'$!

e(-&-i(- i( %$*i+y &" "he su%'&(&"i$(&* *e6e* Dys$( &(# Se%$s 2343. G$6e'(!e("s "h&" *e&(e#

!$'e +e("e' $' "$ "he *e)" e(# $) "he s%e+"'u!0 h$e6e'0 &s #e%i+"e# y "he +&se s"u#ies $)

Ge'!&(y &(# F'&(+e &$6e0 "e(# "$ $%" & !$'e $%e(0 +$**e+"i6is" i#e$*$-y Dys$( &(# Se%$s

2343. Gi6e( "hese s"u#ies0 "he !$'e *e)" & -$6e'(!e(" is0 "he !$'e *i


49/95

)&!i*y0 "$ h&6e "he +&%&+i"y "$ $( $' 'e(" & h$!e. By "his 'e-&'#0 "he S+he(-e( &'e& $%e(s u%

"he %'$s%e+" $) see


50/95

D&"& A(&*ysis

The u(i" $) &(&*ysis is "he i(#i6i#u&* !e!e' s"&"e i( "he Eu'$%e&( E+$($!i+

C$!!u(i"y EEC i( "he ye&' 48?0 si(+e "his s"u#y +$(si#e's hy !e!e' s"&"es 6&'y i( "hei'

#e+isi$( "$ %&'"i+i%&"e $' ($" i( "he S+he(-e( &'e&. I( 48?0 "e( +$u("'ies h /$i(e# "he EEC:

Be*-iu!0 De(!&'


51/95

T&*e 5.4. C$u("'y B$'#e's0 C$#e# y I(+'e&si(- P'$%$'"i$( $) E7"e'(&* EEC B$'#e's

V&*ue

4

2

5

>

L&e*

N$(e

P&'"i&*

M&/$'i"y

A**

Des+'i%"i$(

N$ si#es $) "he (&"i$(&*0 +$u("'y $'#e's &'e e7"e'(&* EEC $'#e's ; &**

si#es &'e $'#e'e# y &($"he' +$u("'y.

O(e si#e $' *ess $) "he (&"i$(&*0 +$u("'y $'#e' is &( e7"e'(&* EEC $'#e'

; Re!&i(i(- si#es &'e $'#e'e# y &($"he' +$u("'y.

T$ $' "h'ee si#es $) "he (&"i$(&*0 +$u("'y $'#e' &'e e7"e'(&* EEC

$'#e's u" $(e si#e is $'#e'e# y &($"he' +$u("'y.

A** si#es $) "he (&"i$(&*0 +$u("'y $'#e' &'e e7"e'(&* EEC $'#e's.

P&'"is&(shi%

T$ #e"e'!i(e %&'"is&(shi% i( & +$u("'y0 I u"i*ie The I#e$*$-i+&* C$!%*e7i$( $)

G$6e'(!e(" &(# P&'*i&!e(" CPG s+$'e +$!%i*e# y =$*#e(#$'%0 e'!&(0 &(# Bu#-e i( "hei'

'ese&'+h $( %&'"y -$6e'(!e(" i( %$*i"i+&* #e!$+'&+ies =$*#e(#$'%0 .0 e!&(0 H.0 Bu#-e0 I.

4885. The CPG s+$'e is &( i(#i+&"$'0 hi+h i("'$#u+es & !$'e ,u&*i"&"i6e &s%e+" "$ -$6e'(!e("

+$!%$si"i$(. I" &""e!%"s "$ &++$u(" )$' "he 'e*&"i6e s"'e(-"h $) %&'"ies i( -$6e'(!e(" i"h

'e)e'e(+e "$ "he Le)"Ri-h" #i!e(si$(0 "h'$u-h & )i6e%$i(" s+&*e i( hi+h "he %'$%$'"i$(&* sh&'es

$) "he Ri-h"0 Ce("'e &(# Le)" &'e "'&(s)$'!e# i("$ s+$'es 4 "$ ? 'e%'ese("i(- "he #e-'ee $)

#$!i(&(+e $) ei"he' %&'"y $"h i( %&'*i&!e(" &(# -$6e'(!e(". I" is !$s"*y use# "$ 'e*&"e "he

#e-'ee $) %&'"y+$("'$* $) & -$6e'(!e(" "$ i"s %$*i+y-ui#e# &+"i$(s. T&*e 5.2 i(#i+&"es h$

e&+h s+$'e &s $%e'&"i$(&*ie#.


52/95

T&*e 5.2. The I#e$*$-i+&* C$!%*e7i$( $) G$6e'(!e(" &(# P&'*i&!e(" CPG0 C$#es

V&*ue

4

2

5

>

?

IPG L&e*

Ri-h"i(- #$!i(&(+e sh&'e $) se&"s i( G$6e'(!e(" &(# su%%$'"i(- %&'"ies i(

P&'*i&!e(" *&'-e' "h&( . %e' +e("Ri-h"Ce("'e +$!%*e7i$( sh&'e $) se&"s $) Ri-h" &(# Ce("'e %&'"ies i( G$6e'(!e("

&(# su%%$'"i(- %&'"ies e"ee( 55.5 &(# . %e' +e(" e&+h

B&*&(+e# si"u&"i$( sh&'e $) Ce("'e *&'-e' "h&( ?3 %e' +e(" i( G$6e'(!e(" &(# i(

P&'*i&!e(" $' i) Le)" &(# Ri-h" )$'! & -$6e'(!e(" "$-e"he' ($" #$!i(&"e# y $(e

si#e $' "he $"he'

Le)"Ce("'e +$!%*e7i$( sh&'e $) se&"s $) Le)" &(# Ce("'e %&'"ies i( G$6e'(!e(" &(#

su%%$'"i(- %&'"ies e"ee( 55.5 &(# . %e' +e(" e&+h

Le)"i(- #$!i(&(+e sh&'e $) se&"s i( G$6e'(!e(" &(# su%%$'"i(- %&'"ies i(

P&'*i&!e(" *&'-e' "h&( . %e' +e("

=e&*"h

Si(+e "his 6&'i&*e &""e!%"s "$ !e&su'e "he e&*"h $) e&+h !e!e' s"&"e 'e*&"i6e "$ i"s

+i"ie(s0 I +h$se "$ use #&"& )$' GDP %e' +&%i"& "&0 hi*e "he 'e!&i(i(-


53/95

43[ )e** i( +&"e-$'y 4. Gi6e( "h&" "he 6&'i&*e is +$#e# &++$'#i(- "$ '&(0 i(#i+&"i(- & *e)"+e("e' sh&'e.


54/95

Fi-u'e 5.4: Dis"'iu"i$( $) C$u("'ies A++$'#i(- "$ P&'"is&(shi% CPG S+&*e

Dis"'iu"i$( $) P&'"is&(shi%0 48?

?

?3[

Ne"he'*&(#s

Be*-iu!

I'e*&(#U(i"e# i(-#$!

De(!&'

53[

I"&*y

Lu7e!$u'-

Ge'!&(y

2

23[

F'&(+e

G'ee+e

3

4

Ri-h"Ce("e' 2 B&*&(+e# Ce("e' 5 Le)"Ce("e' >

I#e$*$-i+&* C$!%*e7i$( $) G$6e'(!e(" &(# P&'*i&!e(" C$#es CPG S+&*e

As )$' e&*"h0 GDP %e' +&%i"& )$' e&+h +$u("'y '&(-e# )'$! \>0?83 "$ \4205@> i"h &(

&6e'&-e $) \0@22 &(# & s"&(#&'# #e6i&"i$( $) &$u" \2058. T$ &*i-( !e&su'e!e(" $) GDP %e'

+&%i"& i"h "he $"he' +&"e-$'i+&* 6&'i&*es0 I +$(6e'"e# "he 6&'i&*e )'$! &( i("e'6&* *e6e* "$ &

+&"e-$'i+&* !e&su'e. I #i6i#e# "he +&ses &" "he !e#i&( \0>.? i("$ "$ +&"e-$'ies0 *$ &(#

hi-h GDP %e' +&%i"&0 &(# &ssi-(e# *$ "he 6&*ue $) 3 &(# hi-h "he 6&*ue $) 4.


55/95

Fi-u'e 5.2: Dis"'iu"i$( $) GDP %e' +&%i"&

GDP %e' +&%i"&0 48?

GREECE

IRELAND

ITALY

\>0?83

\?028

\@088

\0243UNITED INGDOM

BELGIUM

GERMANY

\0>>

\8042?

\8048?NETHERLANDS

FRANCE \80?

\44088DENMAR

LUXEMBOURG \4205@>

3 \?0333 \430333GDP %e' +&%i"&0 Cu''e(" I("e'(&"i$(&* \

\4?0333

Be+&use "he #e%e(#e(" 6&'i&*e $) S+he(-e( Me!e'shi% is & +&"e-$'i+&* !e&su'e0 I

%'e)$'!e# & se'ies $) +his,u&'e# "es"s i( +$("i(-e(+y "&*es )$' e&+h i(#e%e(#e(" 6&'i&*e

&-&i(s" "he #e%e(#e(" 6&'i&*e "$ see i) -e$-'&%hi+ *$+&"i$(0 %&'"is&(shi%0 $' GDP %e' +&%i"& h

&( e))e+" $( & !e!e' s"&"eKs +h$i+e "$ %&'"i+i%&"e i( S+he(-e(. T$ #e"e'!i(e '$us"(ess &(# "he

#i'e+"i$( $) &ss$+i&"i$(0 I 'e%$'" "he +hi s,u&'e 6&*ue &*$(- i"h "he %'$&i*i"y 6&*ue "h&" "he

(u** hy%$"hesis is "'ue. The "&*es e*$ #is%*&y "he 'esu*"s )$' e&+h 6&'i&*e.


56/95

T&*e 5.>: A(&*ysis $) S+he(-e( Me!e'shi% &(# Ge$-'&%hi+ L$+&"i$(

Ge$-'&%hi+ L$+&"i$(0 I(+'e&si(- P'$%$'"i$(

$) E7"e'(&* EEC B$'#e's

S+he(-e(Me!e'shi%

N$" & Me!e' $) S+he(-e( 3

Me!e' $) S+he(-e( 4

T$"&*

N$(e 4

3

4

P&'"i&* 2

3

5

M&/$'i"y 5

2

4

A** >

5

3

T$"&*

?

?

434 5 5 5

Pe&'s$( +hi2 5 ] @.5555 P' ] 3.32

T&*e 5.?: A(&*ysis $) S+he(-e( Me!e'shi% &(# P&'"is&(shi%

I#e$*$-i+&* C$!%*e7i$( $) G$6e'(!e("

&(# P&'*i&!e(" I(#i+&"$'s

S+he(-e(

Me!e'shi%

N$" & Me!e' $) S+he(-e( 3

Me!e' $) S+he(-e( 4

T$"&*

Ri-h"Ce("e'

C$!%*e7i$(

2

5

2

B&*&(+e#

Si"u&"i$(

5

4

2

Le)"Ce("e'

C$!%*e7i$(

>

4

4

T$"&*

?

?

43? 5 2Pe&'s$( +hi2 2 ] 3.?555 P' ] 3.@

T&*e 5.: A(&*ysis $) S+he(-e( Me!e'shi% &(# =e&*"h GDP %e' +&%i"&

=e&*"h ; GDP %e' +&%i"&

S+he(-e(

Me!e'shi%

N$" & Me!e' $) S+he(-e( 3

Me!e' $) S+he(-e( 4

T$"&*

L$ GDP %e' +&%i"& 3

>

4

Hi-h GDP %e' +&%i"& 4

4

>

T$"&*

?

?

43? ?

Pe&'s$( +hi2 4 ] 5.33 P' ] 3.3?


57/95

T&*e 5.@: Re-'essi$( $) Si-(i)i+&(" De"e'!i(&("s $) S+he(-e( P&'"i+i%&"i$(0 48?

Bi6&'i&"e A(&*ysis:

GDP %e' +&%i"&

;

3.3

3.2W

3.2

3.2

3.5

>.?

3.3@

43

C$e))i+ie("s SE

Mu*"i6&'i&"e A(&*ysis: Ge$-'&%hi+

L$+&"i$( &(# GDP %e' +&%i"&

3.5@

3.4>WW

3.4

3.2@

4.>?

3.>8WW

3.

@.?5

3.32W

43

Re-'ess$'

Ge$-'&%hi+ L$+&"i$(

GDP %e' +&%i"&

C$(s"&("

R2

FR&"i$

Nu!e' $) C&sesW De($"es si-(i)i+&(+e &" "he 8?[ +$()i#e(+e *e6e* $(e"&i*e# "es"0 WW"$ "&i*e# "es"

W Be+&use P&'"is&(shi% h & hi-h +hi s,u&'e %'$&i*i"y $) .@ "h&" "he'e &s ($ 'e*&"i$(shi% e"ee( %&'"is&(shi%

&(# S+he(-e( %&'"i+i%&"i$(0 I +h$se "$ e7+*u#e %&'"is&(shi% )'$! "he 'e-'essi$( &(&*ysis.

Fi(#i(-s &(# I!%*i+&"i$(s

My )i(#i(-s i(#i+&"e si-(i)i+&(" 'esu*"s )$' "$ $) "he 6&'i&*es: -e$-'&%hi+ *$+&"i$( &(#

e&*"h GDP %e' +&%i"&0 su--es"i(- "h&" "he *$+&"i$( $) "he +$u("'y &(# e&*"h $) i"s %$%u*&"i$(

!&""e' i( & +$u("'yKs +h$i+e "$ %&'"i+i%&"e i( "he S+he(-e( &'e&.

Tes"i(- -e$-'&%hi+ *$+&"i$(0 "he 'esu*"s s"'$(-*y su%%$'" !y hy%$"hesis ; sh$i(- "h&"

+$u("'ies i"h & -'e&"e' %'$%$'"i$( $) "hei' +$u("'y $'#e's &*s$ ei(- e7"e'(&* EU $'#e's i**

e *ess *i


58/95

%'e#i+"e# %'$&i*i"y "h&" & !e!e' s"&"e i** %&'"i+i%&"e i( S+he(-e(. The +$e))i+ie(" is &*s$

s"&"is"i+&**y si-(i)i+&(" ey$(# "he 8?[ +$()i#e(+e *e6e*0 &(# "he'e)$'e0 "he (u** hy%$"hesis i(

hi+h -e$-'&%hi+ *$+&"i$( h&s ($ e))e+" $( #e"e'!i(i(- & !e!e' s"&"eKs i**i(-(ess "$

%&'"i+i%&"e i( S+he(-e( !&y e 'e/e+"e#.

O) "he "$ +$u("'ies i"h &** +$u("'y $'#e's &*s$ ei(- e7"e'(&* EU $'#e's U(i"e#

i(-#$! &(# I'e*&(#0 $"h #i# ($" %&'"i+i%&"e i( S+he(-e(. T$ "h&" e(#0 $) "he )$u' +$u("'ies

i"h "he !&/$'i"y $) "hei' $'#e's &*s$ ei(- e7"e'(&* EU $'#e's +&"e-$'y 50 @?[ #i# ($"

%&'"i+i%&"e i( S+he(-e(. C$(6e'se*y0 )$' +&"e-$'ies i"h %&'"i&* &(# ($ +$u("'y $'#e's ei(-

e7"e'(&* EU $'#e's0 &** +$u("'ies i( "hese +&"e-$'ies #i# %&'"i+i%&"e i( "he S+he(-e( &'e&. =i"h &

Pe&'s$(Ks +hi s,u&'e 6&*ue $) @.555 &(# $(*y .2[ %'$&i*i"y "h&" "he (u** hy%$"hesis i( hi+h

-e$-'&%hi+ *$+&"i$( h&s ($ e))e+" $( & +$u("'yKs +h$i+e "$ %&'"i+i%&"e $' ($" i( "he S+he(-e( &'e&

is "'ue0 e +&( +$(+*u#e "h&" -e$-'&%hi+ *$+&"i$( #$es i(#ee# !&""e' i( S+he(-e( %&'"i+i%&"i$(.

My hy%$"hesis )$' e&*"h &*s$ &s su%%$'"e# "h&" +$u("'ies i"h hi-h GDP %e' +&%i"&

e'e !$'e *i


59/95

"he s"'$(- si-(i)i+&(+e $) GDP %e' +&%i"& i( "he i6&'i&"e !$#e* su--es"s "h&" e&*"h #$es i( )&+"

!&""e' )$' #e"e'!i(i(- S+he(-e( %&'"i+i%&"i$(.

Fi(&**y0 &*"h$u-h !y 'esu*"s )$' %&'"is&(shi% #i# ($" %'$6e si-(i)i+&(" i"h & Pe&'s$( +hi

s,u&'e 6&*ue $) 3.?55 &(# @.[ %'$&i*i"y "h&" %&'"is&(shi% h&s ($ e))e+" $( S+he(-e(

%&'"i+i%&"i$(0 "he "'e(#s &+'$ss "he +$("i(-e(+y "&*e 'e6e&* s*i-h" i(#i'e+" su%%$'" )$' !y

hy%$"hesis. The "&*e is '&"he' i&se# i( "h&" ?3[ $) "he +$u("'ies i#e("i)y i"h "he 'i-h"

i#e$*$-i+&* +$!%*e7i$(0 +$!%&'e# "$ & !e'e 23[ i#e("i)yi(- i"h "he *e)"0 hi+h is %$"e("i&**y

%'$*e!&"i+ i( )'&!i(- & hy%$"hesis &'$u(# "he +$(#i"i$( $) *e)" i(- -$6e'(!e("s. O) "he

!e!e' s"&"es i#e("i)yi(- i"h "he *e)"0 "he'e is e6e( #is"'iu"i$( e"ee( ei(- & S+he(-e(

!e!e' &(# ($" ei(- & S+he(-e( !e!e'0 i"h $(e !e!e' s"&"e i( e&+h +&"e-$'y. This ($"i$(

"he'e)$'e #$es ($" su%%$'" !y hy%$"hesis "h&" !e!e' s"&"es i"h *e)" i(- -$6e'(!e("s &'e

!$'e *i


60/95

I( 'e&*i"y0 "he'e &s ($" %u'e*y $(e )&+"$' "h&" #i'e+"*y +&use# & +$u("'y "$ /$i( S+he(-e(0 u"

'&"he' & +$!%i*&"i$( $) !&(y )&+"$'s %$"e("i&**y 'e*&"e# "$ "he "h'ee 6&'i&*es i( "his &(&*ysis:

-e$-'&%hi+ *$+&"i$(0 %&'"is&(shi% &(# e&*"h. Ne6e'"he*ess0 I &'-ue "h&" i"hi( "he +$("e7" $)

)$'e+&s"i(- %&'"i+i%&"i$( i( )u"u'e i("e-'&"i$( %'$/e+"s ($" $(*y i"hi( "he EU0 u" &*s$ $"he'

'e-i$(&**y i("e-'&"e# &'e&s &s e**0 & +$u("'yKs -e$-'&%hi+ *$+&"i$( &(# GDP %e' +&%i"& sh$u*#

e "&


61/95

Ch&%"e' F$u'

S"&"is"i+&* A(&*ysis $) Pu*i+ A""i"u#es "$&'# "he S+he(-e( &'e&

I("'$#u+"i$(

=hi*e #i))e'e("i&"e# i("e-'&"i$( !$#e*s h&6e su++ess)u**y &""e!%"e# "$ e7%*&i(

S+he(-e(Ks &(+e!e("0 s+h$*&'s h&6e ee( 'e*&"i6e*y ,uie" $( "he %u*i+Ks &""i"u#es "$&'#s

"he S+he(-e( &'e&. A De+e!e' 2344 Eu'$&'$!e"e' %u*i+ $%i(i$( su'6ey0 h$e6e'0 'e6e&*e#

"h&" 2[ $) i(#i6i#u&*s 'esi#i(- i( $(e $) "he 2@ EU !e!e' s"&"es )e*" "h&" "he )'ee !$6e!e("

$) %e$%*e0 -$$#s0 &(# se'6i+es "h&" S+he(-e( %'$6i#es '&(


62/95

=hy Pu*i+ O%i(i$( T$&'#s S+he(-e( M&""e's

P$*i"i+&* s+ie(+e *i"e'&"u'e h&s his"$'i+&**y %&i# +$(si#e'&*e &""e("i$( "$ "he i!%$'"&(+e

$) Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$( i( &(+i(- "he )u"u'e $) Eu'$%e0 %&'"i+u*&'*y i( "he '$*e "h&" %u*i+

$%i(i$( %*&ys i( "he i!&-e $) %$*i+y!&


63/95

)$'! $%i(i$(s &$u" $"he' %$*i+ies "h&" "hey &'e *ess )&!i*i&' i"h. B&se# $( "his &ssu!%"i$(0 i" is

(e+ess&'y "$ e-i( y &ssessi(- &""i"u#es "$&'# 'e*&"e# %$*i+y &'e&s &ss$+i&"e# i"h S+he(-e(

he( see0 )$' e7&!%*e0 e7&!i(es "he i!%&+" $) i!!i-'&"i$( i(

"he Eu'$%e&( U(i$( $( %u*i+ $%i(i$(0 )i(#i(- "h&" i!!i-'&(" )*$s &'e +*$se*y 'e*&"e# "$ EU

C$$%e'&"i6e A-'ee!e("s S+he(-e( ei(- $(e $) "he! "h'$u-h &$*ishi(- i("e'(&* $'#e'

+$("'$*s e"ee( %&'"i+i%&"i(- !e!e' s"&"es. A*$(- si!i*&' *i(es0 M+L&'e(Ks $'< $( &""i"u#es

"$&'# Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$( )i(#s "h&" &""i"u#es "$&'# "he Eu'$%e&( U(i$( &'e &se# *&'-e*y i(

%&'" y & -e(e'&* h$s"i*i"y "$&'# $"he' +u*"u'esJ M+L&'e( 2332. I( *i(e i"h $"he' *i"e'&"u'e

&$u" h$ %u*i+ $%i(i$( "$&'# Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$( is )$'!e#0 M+L&'e( &'-ues "h&" "he

Eu'$%e&( U(i$( is & "h'e&" "$ & s"&"eKs (&"i$(&* i("e-'i"y &(# "h&" i("e-'&"i$( %$ses -'e&"e' "h'e&"

"$ "he (&"i$(s"&"e '&"he' "h&( "he i(#i6i#u&* M+*&'e( 2332 G&e* &(# A(#e's$( 2332

e'e'-e( 2333. S+h$e( )u'"he' #'esses %u*i+ $%i(i$( $( +$!!$( Eu'$%e&( %$*i+ies i(

)$'ei-( &))&i's &(# #e)e(se ; & %$*i+y s&i# "$ +$6&'y i"h S+he(-e( ; )i(#i(- "h&" &""i"u#es &'e &

'esu*" $) "e''i"$'i&* i#e("i"ies &(# #'i6e( y #$!&i(s%e+i)i+ e6&*u&"i$(s $) "he Eu'$%e&( U(i$(Ks

%e')$'!&(+e S+h$e( 233.

=i"hi( "he )'&!e$'< $) *i"e'&"u'e 'e*&"e# "$ S+he(-e( +$!%e"e(+ies0 I &%%'$&+h

#e"e'!i(i(- &""i"u#es "$&'# "he S+he(-e( &'e& "h'$u-h u"i*ii(- & !e"h$# si!i*&' "$ S+h$e(Ks

s"u#y $( Eu'$%e&( %u*i+ $%i(i$( $( )$'ei-( &(# se+u'i"y %$*i+y. I e-i( y #is+ussi(- "h'ee

+$!%e"i(- "he$'e"i+&* !$#e*s "h&" #'i6e Eu'$%e&( %u*i+ $%i(i$( $) Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$(


64/95

%$*i+ies "$ &ssess h$ %u*i+ &""i"u#es "$&'# "he S+he(-e( &'e& &'e #e'i6e#. I "he( %'$#u+e &(

&(&*ysis $) %u*i+ su%%$'" "$&'# "he S+he(-e( &'e&0 #'&i(- )'$! Eu'$&'$!e"e' #&"&0 "$

e7&!i(e "he e7%*&(&"$'y %$e' $) "he "h'ee !$#e*s i( e))$'" "$ )i(# "he #e"e'!i(&("s $) su%%$'"

)$' S+he(-e(. The %&%e' +$(+*u#es i"h "he )i(#i(-s &(# i!%*i+&"i$(s )$' )u"u'e 'ese&'+h $(

%u*i+ $%i(i$( $) "he S+he(-e( &'e& ($" $(*y i"hi( "he Eu'$%e&( U(i$(0 u" &*s$ s%e&


65/95

Si(+e ($ %'i$' %u*i+ $%i(i$( s"u#ies h&6e ee( +$(#u+"e# $( "he S+he(-e( &'e&0 "he *i(


66/95


67/95

H2: The !$'e )&6$'&*e &( i(#i6i#u&* )ee*s &$u" "he '$*e $) Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$(

i( "he Eu'$%e&( U(i$(0 "he !$'e *i


68/95


69/95

+$#e# &s !issi(- 6&*ues &(# #$ ($" &%%e&' i( "he &(&*ysis.43 I" is &ssu!e# "h&" "he !$'e

i!%$'"&(" & 'es%$(#e(" )ee*s &$u" ei(- &*e "$ "'&6e* i"hi( "he EU i"h$u" i("e'(&* $'#e'

+$("'$*s "h&" he1she $u*# e i( -'e&"e' su%%$'" )$' "he S+he(-e( &'e&. As see( )'$! Fi-u'e 4

e*$0 "he !&/$'i"y $) +&ses @3[ )ee* "h&" i("e'(&* $'#e's &'e i!%$'"&(" i"h %'&+"i+&**y e,u&*

#is"'iu"i$(s e"ee( +&"e-$'ies )&i'*y i!%$'"&("J &(# 6e'y i!%$'"&(" &$u" 5?[ $) +&ses

e&+h.

4.3e3> Fi-u'e 4: A""i"u#es T$&'# S+he(-e(

F'e,ue(+y

>333

333

333

804

5>.@[

803>

5>.5[

?02>2

2333

20822

44.3?[

48.5[

N$" &" &** i!%$'"&("3

N$" 6e'y i!%$'"&(" )&i'*y i!%$'"&("

A""i"u#es T$&'# I("e'(&* B$'#e' C$("'$*s

6e'y i!%$'"&("


70/95

43

I" is $'"h ($"i(- "he *i!i"&"i$(s $) "his %'$7y !e&su'e &s & !e&(s "$ %'$%e'*y !e&su'e

&""i"u#es "$&'# S+he(-e(. Eu'$&'$!e"e' #&"& is "he !$s" 'e+e(" su'6ey &6&i*&*e $( %u*i+

$%i(i$( i( "he EU0 u" "he ,ues"i$( #$es ($" s%e+i)i+&**y #e($"e &""i"u#es "$&'# S+he(-e(0 $(*y

&""i"u#es "$&'# i("e'(&* $'#e' +$("'$*s. H$e6e'0 -i6e( "he ,ues"i$(s &6&i*&*e i( "he su'6ey

&(# S+he(-e( ei(- "he $6e'&'+hi(- %$*i+y 'e-&'#i(- i("e'(&* $'#e' +$("'$*s0 I &! +$()i#e("

"h&" "his !e&su'e is 6&*i# "$ &ssess &""i"u#es "$&'# "he S+he(-e( &'e&.


71/95

The I(#e%e(#e(" V&'i&*es

The i(#e%e(#e(" 6&'i&*es &'e: &""i"u#es "$&'# i!!i-'&"i$( i( "he Eu'$%e&( U(i$(0

&""i"u#es "$&'# "he Eu'$%e&( I("e-'&"i$(0 &(# "he i(#i6i#u&*Ks &""&+h!e(" "$ his1he' (&"i$(&*

i#e("i"y.

A""i"u#es "$&'# i!!i-'&"i$( &'e !e&su'e# y "he ,ues"i$(0 A$u" >[ $) "he %e$%*e

*i6i(- i( "he EU +$!e )'$! & ($(EU +$u("'y. The'e &'e #i))e'e(" 6ies 'e-&'#i(- "hei'

i("e-'&"i$( i( Eu'$%e&( s$+ie"ies. T$ h&" e7"e(# #$ y$u &-'ee $' #is&-'ee i"h "he )$**$i(-

s"&"e!e(" &$u" i("e-'&"i$( I!!i-'&"i$( e('i+hes OUR COUNTRY e+$($!i+&**y &(#

+u*"u'&**y.J I" is & +&"e-$'i+&* 6&'i&*e0 &*s$ !e&su'e# $( &( $'#i(&* s+&*e '&(-i(- )'$! 4 "$ >

&++$'#i(- "$ i(+'e&si(- *e6e* $) &-'ee!e(". Res%$(se +h$i+es &'e &s )$**$s: 4 "$"&**y #is&-'ee

2 "e(# "$ #is&-'ee 5 "e(# "$ &-'ee > "$"&**y &-'ee. A** #$(K"


72/95

333

4.3e3>Fi-u'e 2: I(#e%e(#e(" V&'i&*e 4 A""i"u#es "$&'# I!!i-'&"i$(

8035@

5?.2[

@0@2?

53.>?[

F'e,ue(+y

>333

333

>0@>

4.@2[ 50?

4?.24[

"$"&**y #is&-'ee3

2333

"e(# "$ #is&-'ee "e(# "$ &-'ee

A""i"u#es "$&'# I!!i-'&"i$(

"$"&**y &-'ee

A""i"u#es "$&'# Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$( &'e !e&su'e# y "he ,ues"i$(0 As 'e-&'#s "he

i#e& $) & T=O SPEED EUROPE0 hi+h $) "he )$**$i(- +$!es +*$ses" "$ y$u' %e's$(&*

%'e)e'e(+es Th$se +$u("'ies hi+h &'e 'ey "$ i("e(si)y "he #e6e*$%!e(" $) & +$!!$(

Eu'$%e&( %$*i+y i( +e'"&i( i!%$'"&(" &'e&s... 4 Sh$u*# &i" u("i* &** Me!e' S"&"es $) "he EU

&'e 'ey )$' "his 2 Sh$u*# #$ s$ i"h$u" h&6i(- "$ &i" )$' "he $"he'sJ A** #$(K"


73/95

S"&"es &'e 'ey. A*"h$u-h ??[ is & !&/$'i"y0 "he #i))e'e(+e e"ee( "he "$ +&"e-$'ies is 6e'y

s*i-h"0 y $(*y 43[. This #e($"es "h&" "he'e is s"i** -'e&" 6&'i&"i$( i( $%i(i$( $( EU +i"ie(s

6ies $( Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$(. As & 'esu*"0 usi(- "his !$#e* "$ e7%*&i( &""i"u#es "$&'#

S+he(-e( !&y e )&i'*y #i))i+u*" "$ #e"e'!i(e #ue "$ "he *&'-e 6&'i&"i$( i( &""i"u#es "$&'#

Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$(.

Fi-u'e 5: Dis"'iu"i$( $) T$ S%ee# EU ues"i$(

Sh$u*# N$" =&i" F$'&** Me!e' S"&"es

Sh$u*# =&i" F$'&** Me!e' S"&"es

??[>?[

A""i"u#es "$&'# (&"i$(&* i#e("i"y &'e !e&su'e# y "he ,ues"i$(0 I( "he (e&' )u"u'e0 #$

y$u see y$u'se*) &s...J I" is & +&"e-$'i+&* 6&'i&*e0 !e&su'e# $( &( $'#i(&* s+&*e '&(-i(- )'$! 4

"$ > &++$'#i(- "$ i(+'e&si(- )ee*i(-s $) Eu'$%e&( i#e("i"y. Res%$(se +h$i+es &'e &s )$**$s: 4

NATIONALITY $(*y 2 NATIONALITY &(# Eu'$%e&( 5 Eu'$%e&( &(#

NATIONALITY > Eu'$%e&( $(*y. A** #$(K" >[ i( e&+h

+&"e-$'y. These 'esu*"s &'e i!%$'"&(" "$ 'e+$-(ie &s e !$6e )$'&'# i"h e!%i'i+&* &(&*yses

; "h&" i(#i6i#u&*s s"i** %'e#$!i(&"e*y i#e("i)y i"h "hei' (&"i$(&*i"y !$'e s$ "h&( ei(- Eu'$%e&(.


74/95

4.?e3> Fi-u'e >: Dis"'iu"i$( $) Res%$(#e("^s I#e("i"y

440>44

F'e,ue(+y

4.3e3>440>8

>5.84[ >>.24[

?333

2042?

.4[

NATIONALITY $(*y3

8>

5.@4[

Eu'$%e&( $(*yNATIONALITY Eu'$%e&( Eu'$%e&( NATIONALITY

Res%$(#e(" I#e("i"y

The C$("'$* V&'i&*es

C$("'$*s &'e &s )$**$s &se# $( %'i$' 'ese&'+h $) "hese 6&'i&*es ei(- $u"si#e )&+"$'s

"h&" e7%*&i( %u*i+ $%i(i$( i( Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$(: i(#i6i#u&*sK %e'+e%"i$( $) e+$($!i+

i("e-'&"i$(0 -e(#e'0 &-e0 e!%*$y!e(" s"&"us0 &(# he"he' "he i(#i6i#u&* is %&'" $) "he +$'e si7

EU !e!e's440 L&h&6 2332 L&h&6 233> M+L&'e( e("!e( 234342.

The e+$($!i+ i("e-'&"i$( !e&su'e is "& T$"&**y &-'ee. Ge(#e' is


75/95

A%%e(#i7 2 )$' #es+'i%"i6e s"&"is"i+s $) +$("'$* 6&'i&*es.

C$'e Si7 EU Me!e's &'e "he )i's" )$u(#i(- !e!e's $) "he Eu'$%e&( C$&* &(# S"ee*

C$!!u(i"y. They &'e: Ge'!&(y0 F'&(+e0 I"&*y0 Lu7e!$u'-0 The Ne"he'*&(#s0 &(# Be*-iu!.42


76/95

&*s$ & #i+h$"$!$us !e&su'e +$#e# 4 )$' M&*e &(# 2 Fe!&*e0 hi*e A-e is & +$("i(u$us

!e&su'e. E!%*$y!e(" S"&"us is "&


77/95

45

This !e&su'e is %$"e("i&**y %'$*e!&"i+ -i6e( "he )&+" "h&" Eu'$&'$!e"e' #&"& $(*y 'e%$'"s

#&"& )$' +$u("'ies "h&" &'e i( )&+" !e!e's $) "he EU. Si(+e s$!e S+he(-e( !e!e's N$'&y0

Si"e'*&(#0 &(# I+e*&(# &'e ($" EU !e!e's u" &'e S+he(-e( !e!e's0 "he #&"& )&i*s "$

&++$u(" )$' 'es%$(#e("s i( ($(EU0 S+he(-e( Me!e' +$u("'ies.


78/95


79/95

T&*e >.4: A(&*ysis $) A""i"u#es T$&'# "he S+he(-e( A'e&

A'-u!e("

I!!i-'&"i$(

Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$(

N&"i$(&* A""&+h!e("

C$("'$*s

V&'i&*e

Fee*i(-s "$&'# I!!i-'&("s

T$ S%ee# EU

N&"i$(&* I#e("i"y

E+$($!i+ I("e-'&"i$(

Ge(#e'

A-e

E!%*$y!e(" S"&"us

S+he(-e(

C$'e Si7

C$(s"&("

R2

FR&"i$

Nu!e' $) C&ses

WW%_.34 W%_.3?0 "$"&i*e# "es"s0 ` $(e "&i*e# "es"4

S"&(#&'# E''$'s &'e +*us"e'e# y +$u("'y.

B

"'&"i$

[email protected]

.3>38

4.@?

.2424

8.83

.42>4

@.55

.3>5

2.>8

.33?

.43

.348

4.3@

.434

3.>

.32

3.>3

2.?2

4>.35

3.33?

>>.?

2403@8

SE4

.32?

.3255

.324>

.348

.3485

.3344

.34?

.428

.3@2>

.4@8 WW

WW

`

WW

WW

WW

WW


80/95

M$'e$6e'0 "he &'-u!e(" )$' (&"i$(&* &""&+h!e(" %'$6e# "$ e "he !$s" "e**i(- i(

#e"e'!i(i(- "he *e6e* $) su%%$'" $' $%%$si"i$( )$' "he S+he(-e( &'e&. As hy%$"hesie#0 "he

-'e&"e' "he &""&+h!e(" &( i(#i6i#u&* he*# "$ Eu'$%e $' & Eu'$%e&( i#e("i"y0 "he -'e&"e' su%%$'"

he1she -'&("e# S+he(-e(. The !$#e* sh$s "h&" )$' e&+h u(i" i(+'e&se $( "he i#e("i"y s+&*e )'$!

4 N&"i$(&*i"y $(*y "$ > Eu'$%e&( $(*y0 "he'e is &( #i"i$(&* .24 i(+'e&se i( "he i(#i6i#u&*Ks

*e6e* $) su%%$'" )$' S+he(-e(. This 6&*ue is &*s$ hi-h*y si-(i)i+&(" &" "he .34 *e6e*0 &(# %'$6es

"h&" & %e's$(Ks i#e("i"y is %e'h&%s "he s"'$(-es" 6&'i&*e i( #e"e'!i(i(- "he *e6e* $) su%%$'" )$'

S+he(-e(.

C$("'$* A(&*ysis Resu*"s

The +$("'$*s i( "he !$#e* 'e6e&*e# ,ui"e i("e'es"i(- &(# &" "i!es0 su'%'isi(- 'esu*"s. O)

"he )$u' +$("'$*s "h&" %$*i"i+&* s+ie(+e *i"e'&"u'e h&s %'e6i$us*y ($"e# %*&y & '$*e i( #e"e'!i(i(-

%u*i+ $%i(i$( i( "he Eu'$%e&( U(i$( &""i"u#es "$&'# e+$($!i+ i("e-'&"i$(0 -e(#e'0 &-e0 &(#

e!%*$y!e(" s"&"us0 &** u" e!%*$y!e(" s"&"us %'$6e# "$ e s"&"is"i+&**y si-(i)i+&(" i( "his

&(&*ysis. I" is "$ ($ su'%'ise "h&" "he !$'e )&6$'&*e &( i(#i6i#u&* )ee*s "$&'# e+$($!i+

i("e-'&"i$(0 "he -'e&"e' "he *e6e* "h&" he1she i** su%%$'" S+he(-e(. The !$#e* sh$s & 3.42

i(+'e&se i( su%%$'" )$' S+he(-e( )$' e&+h u(i" i(+'e&se i( "he *e6e* $) &-'ee!e(" )$' )u'"he'

e+$($!i+ i("e-'&"i$(.

B$"h -e(#e' &(# &-e +$("'$*s h$e6e'0 #e%i+" (e-&"i6e 'e*&"i$(shi%s i"h su%%$'" )$'

S+he(-e(. Re-&'#i(- -e(#e'0 *i"e'&"u'e h&s sh$( "h&" $!e( &'e "'i"i$(&**y !$'e hesi"&(" "$

sh$ "hei' su%%$'" )$' %$*i+ies &" "he Eu'$%e&( *e6e* M+L&'e( L&h&6. I( *i(e i"h "he

*i"e'&"u'e0 "his !$#e* 'e6e&*s "h&" $!e( $( &6e'&-e i** su%%$'" S+he(-e( 3.3? u(i"s *$e' "h&(

!e( $( "he 4 "$ > s+&*e $) i!%$'"&(+e "$ "'&6e* i"h$u" i("e'(&* $'#e's i( "he EU. The !$#e*


81/95

)u'"he' sh$s "h&" &-e (e-&"i6e*y %*&ys & '$*e i( #e"e'!i(i(- su%%$'" )$' S+he(-e(. F$' e&+h ye&'

$*#e' &( i(#i6i#u&* is0 "he'e is & 3.33@ #e+'e&se i( his1he' su%%$'" )$' "he S+he(-e( &'e&.

I( %&s" s"u#ies0 &( i(#i6i#u&*Ks e!%*$y!e(" s"&"us h&s %'$6e( "$ e & si-(i)i+&(" )&+"$'

#'i6i(- his1he' -e(e'&* &""i"u#es. I( "his &(&*ysis h$e6e'0 e!%*$y!e(" s"&"us #$es ($" see! "$

&))e+" &( i(#i6i#u&*Ks su%%$'" )$' S+he(-e(. =hi*e "he 'e*&"i$(shi% i( "he !$#e* sh$s "h&"

e!%*$y!e(" s"&"us is (e-&"i6e*y 'e*&"e# "$ su%%$'" )$' S+he(-e(0 !e&(i(- "h&" u(e!%*$ye#

$'


82/95

i(+e%"i$( $) "he Eu'$%e&( C$&* &(# S"ee* C$!!u(i"y he'e "he +$'e si7 EU !e!e's e'e )i's"

#e)i(e#. F$' e7&!%*e0 "he e+$($!i+ u(+e'"&i("y su''$u(#i(- "he eu'$ *e&6es !&(y Eu'$%e&(s0

%&'"i+u*&'*y "h$se i( "he +$'e si7 +$u("'ies0 "$ ,ues"i$( "he su++ess $) Eu'$%e &s & h$*e.

Fu'"he'!$'e0 "he 'ise $) %$*i"i+&* u(+e'"&i("y "h&" &++$!%&(ies "he %$"e("i&* #e+*i(e $) "he eu'$

i("'$#u+es !u+h s%e+u*&"i$( $( "he )u"u'e $) Eu'$%e. Pe'h&%s su+h s%e+u*&"i$( $( "he su++ess $)

Eu'$%e is &))e+"i(- i(#i6i#u&*Ks 'esi#i(- i( & +$'e si7 +$u("'y y +&usi(- "hei' &""i"u#es "$ shi)"

"$&'# hesi"&"i$( i( "hei' i**i(-(ess "$ su%%$'" Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$( %$*i+ies0 *i


83/95

i( & S+he(-e( !e!e' s"&"e h&s $( &( i(#i6i#u&*Ks i**i(-(ess "$ su%%$'" "'&6e*i(- i"h$u"

i("e'(&* $'#e' +$("'$*s0 $' )$' %u'%$ses $) "his &(&*ysis0 "he S+he(-e( &'e&.

C$(+*usi$(s

O6e'&**0 "his s"u#y )i(#s "h&" &** "h'ee !$#e*s: "he u"i*i"&'i&( !$#e* u(#e' '&"i$(&* +h$i+e

"he$'y0 "he %e')$'!&(+e !$#e* u(#e' (e$)u(+"i$(&*is" "he$'y0 &(# "he (&"i$(&* i#e("i"y !$#e* "he

"he$'y $) #$u*e &**e-i&(+e %'$6e "he hy%$"hesie# #i'e+"i$( $) 'esu*"s. The U"i*i"&'i&( &(# "he

N&"i$(&* I#e("i"y M$#e*s %'$6e# "$ e s"&"is"i+&**y si-(i)i+&(" i( )&6$' $) "he e7%e+"e#

hy%$"heses &" "he "$"&i*e# "es" hi*e "he Pe')$'!&(+e M$#e* si-(i)i+&(" i( & $(e"&i*e# "es". I"

is e6i#e(" "h&" &""&+h!e(" "$ (&"i$(&* i#e("i"y is "he s"'$(-es" &%%'$&+h i( #e"e'!i(i(- su%%$'" )$'

S+he(-e(0 u" "he 'esu*"s &*s$ sh$ s"'$(- i(#i+&"i$( "h&" & !$'e )&6$'&*e &""i"u#e "$&'#

i!!i-'&"i$( &(# -'e&"e' su%%$'" )$' Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$( i** i(+'e&se su%%$'" )$' "he S+he(-e(

&'e&. The !$#e* )u'"he' i(#i+&"es "h&" %e'+e%"i$( "$&'#s e+$($!i+ i("e-'&"i$(0 -e(#e'0 &(# &-e

&** %'$6e "$ &*s$ &))e+" &( i(#i6i#u&*Ks *e6e* $) su%%$'" )$' "he S+he(-e( &'e&.

=i"h "his &(&*ysis0 i" is i!%$'"&(" "$ ($"e h$ &""i"u#es "$&'# "he S+he(-e( &'e& &'e

#e'i6e# i( 6ie $) )u"u'e %$*i+y!&


84/95

Ch&%"e' Fi6e

C$(+*usi$( &(# I!%*i+&"i$(s

O( Fe'u&'y 30 23420 Eu'$%e&( C$!!issi$(e' 'es%$(si*e )$' us"i+e &(# H$!e

A))&i's0 Ce+i*i& M&*!s"'!0 'e*e&se# & %'ess s"&"e!e(" )'$! "he Eu'$%e&( P&'*i&!e(" SD

C$()e'e(+e i( B'usse*s0 Be*-iu! $( "he i!%$'"&(+e $) s&)e-u&'#i(- S+he(-e(0 e("i"*e#

U%h$*#i(- F'ee#$! $) M$6e!e(" ; A( I!%'$6e# S+he(-e( G$6e'(&(+eJ M&*!s"'! 2342.

As $) "his 'e%$'"0 "he Eu'$%e&( C$!!issi$( es"i!&"es "h&" "he'e &'e &%%'$7i!&"e*y >23 !i**i$(

%e$%*e "h&" 'esi#e i( "he S+he(-e( &'e&0 &++$u("i(- )$' &$u" 4.2? i**i$( /$u'(eys "'&6e*e#

i"hi( "he EU e6e'y ye&' e+&use $) S+he(-e( M&*!s"'! 2342. =i"h su+h !&-(i"u#e0 i" is "$

($ su'%'ise "h&" M&*!s"'!Ks 'e)*e+"i$( $( "he i!%$'"&(+e $) S+he(-e( &s %$si"i6e ; s&yi(-

"h&"0 "he +'e&"i$( $) "he S+he(-e( &'e& is u(#$u"e#*y $(e $) "he !$s" "&(-i*e0 %$%u*&'0 &(#

su++ess)u* &+hie6e!e("s $) "he EUJ M&*!s"'! 2342.

I(#ee#0 S+he(-e( +&( e #ee!e# su++ess)u* #es%i"e i"s +$!%*i+&"e# i("e'-$6e'(!e("&*

#e6e*$%!e("0 +$!%*e7 %$*i+y s"'u+"u'e0 &(# +$()usi(- !e!e' s"&"e $%"$u" $%%$'"u(i"ies &s

%'ese("e# i( +h&%"e' "$. O6e'&**0 S+he(-e( #$es e(&*e %e's$(s "$ e(/$y "he )'ee#$! $)

"'&6e*i(- $u"si#e "hei' h$!e +$u("'y i"h$u" "he $''y &(# h&ss*e $) $'#e' +he+


85/95

%'&ise# )$' "hese %'$-'essi6e #e6e*$%!e("s &(# i"s +$!%'ehe(si6e *e-&* )'&!e$'< $6e' "he

%&s" #e+e0 hi+h -u&'&("ees "he i("e-'i"y &(# sus"&i(&i*i"y $) "he S+he(-e( &'e& J

M&*!s"'! 2342.

Ye" #es%i"e M&*!s"'!Ks 'e&ssu'i(- $'#s "$ "he P&'*i&!e(" &$u" S+he(-e( su++ess0 i"

is +*e&' "h&" "he %$s" A'& S%'i(- 'e&


86/95

*$e' i( +$u("'ies i"h *$e' GDP %e' +&%i"&. This )&+" is e6i#e(+e# y "he +$u("'ies h$ &'e

+h&**e(-i(- S+he(-e(Ks e))i+ie(+y &(# sus"&i(&i*i"y: F'&(+e0 De(!&'


87/95

Ne6e'"he*ess0 &si#e )'$! e!%h&sii(- "he (ee# "$ ee) u% e7"e'(&* $'#e' +$("'$*s0 $"he'

'e6isi$( %*&(s )$' S+he(-e( i(+*u#e: 'e6isi"i(- "he i#e& $) i(s"i"u"i(- "e!%$'&'y $'#e' +$("'$*s

i( +&se $) e!e'-e(+y0 'e6isi(- "he *e-&* -ui#e*i(es $) issui(- "'&6e* #$+u!e("s su+h &s

"e!%$'&'y 'esi#e(+e %e'!i"s0 &(# i!%'$6i(- S+he(-e(Ks e6&*u&"i$( !e+h&(is!sJ "h&" see< $u"

"he #e)i+ie(+ies i( +$u("'iesK $'#e' +$("'$*s e)$'e +'isis &'ises BBC: A The S+he(-e(

A-'ee!e(". The !$s" i!%$'"&(" i!%*i+&"i$( )$' "he )u"u'e $) S+he(-e( is ($"&*y "he (e+essi"y

)$' i(+'e&se# %$*i"i+&* #i&*$-ue e"ee( ($" $(*y !e!e' s"&"es &(# "he EU 'e%'ese("&"i6es0 u"

&*s$ e"ee( "he EU i(s"i"u"i$(s "he!se*6es Eu'$%e&( C$u(+i*0 Eu'$%e&( P&'*i&!e("0 &(#

Eu'$%e&( C$!!issi$(0 e"+.

As $) 23450 "he S+he(-e( s&-& +$("i(ues i"h R$!&(i& &(# Bu*-&'i& 6yi(- )$' !issi$(

i("$ "he S+he(-e( &'e&0 u" "hey &'e u()$'"u(&"e*y ei(- )&+e# i"h h&'# *i(e 6e"$es )'$!

Ge'!&(y &(# Fi(*&(# L.C. 2345. B$"h +$u("'ies h&6e ee( see


88/95

( EU S"&"es: I+e*&(#0+h"e(s"ei(0'&y0

A%%e(#i7

A%%e(#i7 4: Ch'$($*$-y $) S+he(-e( C$$%e'&"i$(

48? A-'ee!e(" $) -'u&* &$*i"i$( $) Eu'$%e&( $'#e' +$("'$*s

? N&"i$(s /$i( S+he(-e(: Be*-iu!0 F'&(+e0 Ge'!&(y0 Lu7e!$u'-0 The Ne"he'*&(#s

S+he(-e( I!%*e!e("&"i$( C$(6e("i$(0 S+he(-e(0 Lu7e!$u'-: %$*i+y -&i(e# "he )$'!&* "i"*e

4883 S+he(-e(

Ne P'$%$s&*s:

4 C$((e+"i$( $) P$*i+e F$'+es &(# Cus"$!s Au"h$'i"ies e"ee( "he S+he(-e( $(e

2 S+he(-e( I()$'!&"i$( Sys"e! SIS

I"&*y i("e-'&"e# i("$ S+he(-e( A-'ee!e("

4884 P$'"u-&* &(# S%&i( i("e-'&"e# i("$ S+he(-e(

4882 G'ee+e i("e-'&"e# i("$ S+he(-e(

Aus"'i& i("e-'&"e# i("$ S+he(-e(

Ne P'$%$s&*:

488? 4 SIS II

488 De(!&'


89/95

Re)e'e(+es

A#*e'Nisse(0 R. 2338 QBehi(# "he s+e(es $) #i))e'e("i&"e# i("e-'&"i$(. Ci'+u!6e("i(- (&"i$(&*

$%"$u"s i( /us"i+e &(# h$!e &))&i'sK0 $u'(&* $) Eu'$%e&( Pu*i+ P$*i+y 44: 2;3.

A#*e'Nisse(0 R. 2344 QO%"i(- $u" $) &( e6e' +*$se' U(i$(: "he i("e-'&"i$( #$7& &(# "he

!&(&-e!e(" $) s$6e'ei-("yK0 =es" Eu'$%e&( P$*i"i+s 5>?: 4382;445.

A*!$(#0 G&'ie* G. 48?3. The A!e'i+&( Pe$%*e &(# F$'ei-( P$*i+y. Ne Y$'. S%e+i&* issue $( "he %$*i"i+s $)

i!!i-'&"i$( i( =es"e'( Eu'$%e. =es" Eu'$%e&( P$*i"i+s0 4@2.

B&'ea0 E.0 C$s"&0 O.0 He''&(0 A. &(# N&"$'s.:488?. 85885.

De L$. I("e'-$6e'(!e("&* C$$%e'&"i$( i( "he Fie*# $) Mi-'&"i$( ; )'$! "he

Si(-*e Eu'$%e&( A+" "$ M&&s"'i+"J. I( M$(&'0 . &(# M$'-&(0 R. e# The Thi'# Pi**&' $) "he

Eu'$%e&( U(i$(. C$$%e'&"i$( i( "he Fie*#s $) us"i+e &(# H$!e A))&i's B'usse*s: Eu'$%e&(

U(i6e'si"y P'ess0 %%. 88422.


90/95

Di(&(0 D. 2343 E6e' C*$se' U(i$(: A( I("'$#u+"i$( "$ Eu'$%e&( I("e-'&"i$(0 B$u*#e'0 CO:

Ly((e Rei(e'.

Di'e+"$'&"e Ge(e'&* )$' C$!!u(i+&"i$(. A( O%%$'"u(i"y &(# & Ch&**e(-e: Mi-'&"i$( i( "he

Eu'$%e&( U(i$(.J Eu'$%e&( C$!!issi$(. Ge'!&(y. M&y 2338.

Dys$(0 . &(# Se%$s0 A. 2343 QThe %$*i"i+&* #i!e(si$(: #i))e'e("i&"i$( &s #esi-( %'i(+i%*e &(#

&s & "$$* $) %$*i"i+&* !&(&-e!e(" i( Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$(K0 i( . Dys$( &(# A. Se%$s e#s0

=hi+h Eu'$%e The P$*i"i+s $) Di))e'e("i&"e# I("e-'&"i$(0 B&si(-s"$


91/95

Eu'$%&: EURLe7. The S+he(-e( A+,uis.J C$u(+i*. O))i+i&* $u'(&* $) "he Eu'$%e&(

C$!!u(i"ies. 22 Se%"e!e' 2333.

_h""%:11eu'$%&.eu.i("1eu'*e71%'i1e(1$/1#&"123331*92581*925823333822e(33343>@5.%#)c.

Eu'$%&: EURLe7: T'e&"ies. C$(s$*i#&"e# Ve'si$( $) "he T'e&"y Es"&*ishi(- "he Eu'$%e&(C$!!u(i"y.J O))i+i&* $u'(&* C 52? 2> De+e!e' 2332.

h""%:11eu'$%&.eu.i("1eu'*e71*e71e(1"'e&"ies1#&"142332E1h"!142332E.h"!*.

Eu'$%&: R&%i#: P'ess Re*e&ses. A$*i"i$( $) B$'#e' C$("'$*s: S+he(-e( G'$u% M$6es i("$ T$%

Ge&'. 48 u(e 4883. 4 M&'+h 233.

_h""%:11eu'$%&.eu.i("1'&%i#1%'essRe*e&sesA+"i$(.#$'e)e'e(+e]IP1831>82)$'!&"]HTML&-e#

]4*&(-u&-e]EN-uiL&(-u&-e]e(c.

Eu'$%&: SCADP*us. The A!s"e'#&! T'e&"y: & C$!%'ehe(si6e Gui#e. 4 M&'+h 233.

_ h""%:11eu'$%&.eu.i("1s+%*us1*e-1e(1*61&44333.h"!d&44343c.

Eu'$%&: SCADP*us. The Si(-*e Eu'$%e&( A+". 54 &(u&'y 233?. 4 M&'+h 233.

_ h""%:11eu'$%&.eu.i("1s+%*us1"'e&"ies1si(-*e&+"9e(.h"!c.

EUROPA. T'e&"y $) M&&s"'i+h" $( Eu'$%e&( U(i$(. Eu'$%e&( C$!!issi$(0 4? O+". 2343.

=e. 4> A%'. 2345.

Eu'$%e&( N&6i-&"$'. The Eu'$%e&( P&ss%$'". 25 Fe'u&'y 233. 4 M&'+h 233.

_ h""%:11.e(&.*u1eu'$%e1e(*&'-e!e("si(-*e&+"1eu'$%e&(%&ss%$'".h"!c.

Eu'$"'e&"ies. Te7" $) "he T'e&"y $) R$!e. 233>. Eu'$"'e&"ies Me(u B&'. 4 M&'+h 233.

Eu'$"'e&"ies. Te7" $) "he T'e&"y $( Eu'$%e&( U(i$(. 233>. Te7" $) "he M&&s"'i+h" T'e&"y. 4

M&'+h 233.

Eu'$%e&( U(i$(: The e))e+" $) e*i"es &(# "he EU $( i(#i6i#u&**e6e* $%i(i$(s 'e-&'#i(-

Eu'$%e&( &(# ($(Eu'$%e&( i!!i-'&("s. Eu'$%e&( $u'(&* $) P$*i"i+&* Rese&'+h0 580 443.

Fe"e'0 $e*. 2333. Pu*i+ &""i"u#es "$&'# i!!i-'&"i$( i( "he U(i"e# S"&"es0 F'&(+e0 &(#

Ge'!&(y. C&!'i#-e0 U: C&!'i#-e U(i6e'si"y P'ess.

F'&(. U(+$'


92/95

G&e*0 M&""he . &(# Ch'is"$%he' . A(#e's$( 2332 QThe S"'u+"u'e $) Ci"ie(

A""i"u#es &(# "he Eu'$%e&( P$*i"i+&* S%&+eK0 C$!%&'&"i6e P$*i"i+&* S"u#ies 5?:

85;845.

Ge##es0 A(#'e. 2333. I!!i-'&"i$( &(# Eu'$%e&( i("e-'&"i$(: T$&'#s F$'"'ess Eu'$%eM&(+hes"e'0 U: M&(+hes"e' U(i6e'si"y P'ess.

GDP %e' +&%i"& D&"& Z =$'*# De6e*$%!e(" I(#i+&"$'s. D&"& Z The =$'*# B&(?;?.

G$6e'(!e("s $) "he S"&"es $) "he Be(e*u7 E+$($!i+ U(i$(0 "he Fe#e'&* Re%u*i+ $) Ge'!&(y

&(# "he F'e(+h Re%u*i+ $( "he -'u&* &$*i"i$( $) +he+48;>5.

Huys!&(s0 . 2333 QThe Eu'$%e&( U(i$( &(# "he se+u'i"i&"i$( $) !i-'&"i$(K0 $u'(&* $)

C$!!$( M&'


93/95

The I!%*e!e("&"i$( $) "he C$(6e("i$( A%%*yi(- i( "he S+he(-e( A-'ee!e(".J Eu'$%&: R&%i#:

P'ess Re*e&ses. 2> M&'+h 488?. 4 u(e 233.

_h""%:11eu'$%&.eu.i("1'&%i#1%'essRe*e&sesA+"i$(.#$'e)e'e(+e]MEMO18?1?@)$'

!&"]HTML&-e#]4*&(-u&-e]EN-uiL&(-u&-e]e( c.

I"&*y &(# I!!i-'&"i$(: T&.

e("!e(0 Ci-#e!. 2343 QB&ses $) Su%%$'" )$' "he EUKs C$!!$( F$'ei-( &(# Se+u'i"y P$*i+y:

Ge(#e'0 A""i"u#es "$&'# E+$($!i+ I("e-'&"i$(0 &(# A""&+h!e(" "$ Eu'$%eK0 I("e'(&"i$(&*

P$*i"i+&* S+ie(+e Re6ie0 545: 2?288.

$**i


94/95

P'$"$+$*.JAsy*u!0 I!!i-'&"i$( &(# S+he(-e( P$s"A!s"e'#&!: A Fi's" Assess!e(". M&&s"'i+h":

Eu'$%e&( I(s"i"u"e $) Pu*i+ A#!i(si"'&"i$(.

N$'#i+ P&ss%$'" U(i$(Ks S+he(-e( Me!e'shi% C$()i'!e#.J Eu'$%e&( Re%$'". 5 M&'+h @.

2334. %. >@4.

Nu-e("0 Nei**. The G$6e'(!e(" &(# P$*i"i+s $) "he Eu'$%e&( U(i$(. @"h e#. B&si(-s"$;8. L$(#$(: T&u'is.

R$s&!$(#0 Be(. The U(i"i(- $) Eu'$%e &(# "he F$u(#&"i$( $) EU S"u#ies: Re6isi"i(- "he

Ne$)u(+"i$(&*is! $) E'(s" B. H&&s. $u'(&* $) Eu'$%e&( Pu*i+ P$*i+y 42.2 233: 25@?>.

P'i(".

S+he(-e(: F'&(+e S&ys N$ "$ O%e( B$'#e's.J F$'"'ess Eu'$%eJ ;Ci'+u*&'Le""e'. FECL 4

u(e 4885. 4 u(e 233._h""%:11.)e+*.$'-1+i'+u*&'1434.h"!c.

The S+he(-e( A+,uis &(# i"s I("e-'&"i$( i("$ "he U(i$(.J SCADP*us. 45 u(e 233?. 4 u(e

233. _h""%:11eu'$%&.eu1s+%*us1*e-1e(1*61*55323.h"! c.

S+h$e(0 H.0 233. I#e("i"y0 i(s"'u!e("&* se*)i("e'es" &(# i(s"i"u"i$(&* e6&*u&"i$(s: e7%*&i(i(-

%u*i+ $%i(i$( $( +$!!$( Eu'$%e&( %$*i+ies i( )$'ei-( &))&i's &(# #e)e(+e. Eu'$%e&( U(i$(

P$*i"i+s 8 40 ?;28.

S"u0 A.C. 488 QA +&"e-$'i&"i$( $) #i))e'e("i&"e# i("e-'&"i$(K0 $u'(&* $) C$!!$( M&'2: 25;8?.

S"u0 A.C. 488@ QThe 488 I("e'-$6e'(!e("&* C$()e'e(+e &(# "he !&(&-e!e(" $) )*e7i*e


95/95

i("e-'&"i$(K0 $u'(&* $) Eu'$%e&( Pu*i+ P$*i+y >4: 5@;??.

T'e&"y $) A!s"e'#&! A!e(#i(- "he T'e&"y $( Eu'$%e&( U(i$(0 "he T'e&"ies

Es"&*ishi(- "he Eu'$%e&( C$!!u(i"ies &(# Re*&"e# A+"s: P'$"$+$* i("e-'&"i(-

"he S+he(-e( &+,uis i("$ "he )'&!e$'< $) "he Eu'$%e&( U(i$(J O))i+i&* $u'(&* C5>3 43

N$6e!e' 488@. 4 M&'+h 233._h""%:11eu'$%&.eu.i("1eu'*e71*e71e(1"'e&"ies1#&"14488@D1h"[email protected]"!*d338534333>c.

Tu'&+?4883fP&'"y -$6e'(!e(" i(

23 #e!$+'&+ies. Eu'$%e&( $u'(&* $) P$*i"i+&* Rese&'+h0 2>0 4423.

Documents

Collective Border Policy in the European Union- Analysis of the S