32

coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive
Page 2: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

coma:Mly/lune maVolume elghl, number u..ee

c.....e. M.........uWest Grnnzuy a! .........g pain! 3

Chris be.-......M...er.ae.az mm .o auslemy a

to... so...n..ncNn'bce..c..1..a. nz;.b..e: om. MlrqurzFmgmmcofmcGuava no

Lynn: Szgll ..... Mnry M.en...e..bSoc am: and me :...-....y ux... Jnnu ...a Rm. mm...sow... may on m..m...... 12

re... IllghlieldMaLCvn:gur‘s clael new, 15

llnvlvwsn... Heme

. Marx lurm ... ms sum 31:

Revirwfi m brief 3:

Internationalis pubmen by supporters ol meSo l.|isA Lugue .....1 me rounb |..—

.......ub...x. Sigurd trucks .1. .....necessarily rellenl me views of meseems. Le-zue u. n! the Ddimrilln....m.

International

Mm‘... .4...“new :....e.

mm... A n...............:2. Uvber s.eee._ ........... NI zxp1.. 0I—JS§m7l

vn.e......u. am... a .......-m.........b.»..... rrm Lm. :29 UPFKI Sued......e... m zxrm- m 259 mshhursHlukruse rm. nu. Ln].:0. Clcrkrnwdl cm... ..b........ Em umrub. ans(‘amma s...e...me. 22:: Umxr sm.u........ N) ix?ISSN 03034217

sdtiorialFACING THEBy me um: ...., ..\..e D1 mxcmanoml ..pulvluhzd a ....m.. Cllxflflll could haveborn called :\La1v)«ml:1lcInImlnow bemrofr. Than: aver;/gvod ChancnndmdIhm Ihc:ToncswflI W|!HlfiuIVIgH|. pcrhapfimu. 3 . ...e.mb.1 NIZJDHICY. What .. .......unhkely, Tony Benn .....w:.m.a..u.ng» ..that um... wvll Mn. -n.e somalisx lcll....... mks cardul Mock al me prey.-mcnllcal .....a..b... ... bmerzb imam: mam:men rb. lllc mm mmThe fundamunlal nrndc H’ dcvclopme... offinum pm... haw (o be firmlygm.-be. A: m....... ur a.....n rzrmalvsmdzrpem, mat is 2 1.... .e.... mud Mdzclmn urn.../. me Tan party and .x.....».mun! ucmbem. The 4...» one 0’Tor-yum‘ was me elscuan or ms. wan byme Nanonal Gnvemmenl ThtToncxa:\d...e.. allus won w.... 64 pe. CEVII of mevmc Thaxcher COMM u... Ihc coming .-1:.»MD)! with s.-,....«.... Ink: 3x pcr rem, newu...I,v me w|Il hrnbnnly not gu more m...an be. be... ufmc ubu n.. ma Hcmh wanmlhlflvtrccnl

To Dul .. ....b...e. way. me um: by 6::nnn—Tnrv, nmv ahuhf pzmes ha: beengumg unsince ms Wxuclwivuu mu wen.n.....b..u b..........e IFTh2vclv:rwxnxby:|clcnr e......v .. wm be because 0. I710

vwaricsoflhcc ....... ».\.e....we zeu.1...u.- Inc of me was of m.

two main; puma: CDHKDHIDIu mu wohncnlcriu: ..nbu»ea Ivy III: .e........... decline ofBnnsh c:|nim|' ... Fmm me pom! oIv\r‘e\br Ihe working clnsx. me DDMKZI ums ..mm... me lomv 0! ma duam agony of menew... mm. 1: 1 about mnnm w... me.b......g ab.-' .., fim and foreman .. mube bccxmyc by me me m the sow and me1.... .1... .. mam. a. um um... vole ha:been mkrn wnhu. 5.... .m.esup weu inmm :1 ...:,o. rcvzrsc .. lhc bo......g bonei. (run: or xmls, me em... or ..e .b...ae.LIV! besauxscd 1...... mn Incl axbne.

Thdxchensm has ..e.. been e xucccgs man .¢...........» me: u M-mgc prufimbxlily..r ......b (tax: in um, .. M. mcrrly n:ums\‘1cnl e...m..e..ee of ...e numbcr ofbmkrupmcs may 3 Per ee... nfme [Malmv:<lm<I\£ of Drum)! cavlfiulfirs .. gomgin...-, mxmulaumlng mdusmcs. wmlc huge:|mm.\nl\ go abroad b.e.. .¢ vhcrz .. amm world ....m... a.. me bcbnbmy, Er|—

m... wu mm .. very mm ... flmrc i.. any'r¢viva\'. Tlvebollapacofflnush ........I...,.......g....:....., bat} xv/rm .»......y .......e..wfll be wry bum: 2.... ...o.. men.

A new nvry gov¢n\m:nI lllcflfflrt muhe on: .b.ee.a K0 me much rm...-..m....e. against the Wurking ems. urnmhas x..me..b been me me. Indeed mm,cnn obnuy pmclzmu than vb: Iwcdslhrae.:....s...b..~.e...».=.»...pmu.e.....»g.=......bol .e..b....g Enuih cannahsm A ....x,

ELECTIONmamv: em». on ..o.xe....»...gb..nue.as.....s . mush umber assault b.. me welfarzum: .. Whal me 1...... arv V1h!Hn\lV?ob. Lhc

ncxl fi\c years.If the Tune: ir<1mI vedecrzd wulv an

cum}! ....«.o..xy, u.e.. me mus: hkdy 0name .5 .. bung mn.a...e... mm meSn?/x.h¢.:.|< holding me hzlante OI

Dower. Fulvav way [hr |..b..... mnvcmcmum lace r....a....e..m q...e....... of how ..rcSDDnd\ La me e....|1mm of be... ... uv—

.>.»........ 43....yr lhc Toms are zlzczrd, me.. me .-9..

Mm; M H}: |abnux Pmv will 9.9.!“‘v::p:c!abVe‘ s>m......-..m.y Uflbmman.pbmbw m an aflmncc n... masnr/I metals me uauc ol fighnng backagmmx .:.e ravages br a sccond rmmd af-r..a.c..e..;..., .b.b...v»..amiss czmwxgnxusLabour Party Mind! pmmmes workerss...-games, w... hzvc ... be eb.....e...b;ea by

u.e.e.. m any n...... b1bm.....ee.myme.me rcxvnnxc or ...c Labour .e...:m...p .0me rwcm ....xc of Covalcy — Mlcnnc —dad ..... mu ml ... (ms mpub.

1: met: .. no menu palhzmenhnry mu’

mu. llwvreisure «b. a e.n........ mm meSDP/L1b<u|< W1" be much mare ....ee.Tcrry burr. oflhz AUEW has spchtd Uh!mu comcqucnces br um very amny:Labour Hum abandon .5 radical pnhcxexon duarmamenl. me sec and mcnmn......cy V0 rnsnm me bomb...» by (rm ,....... lucked. u... — .. ...:.:...b.. ..a e.e..uaml relurm — would be nmcmly me

me. .:.-.......u.-.: by the SDP/LxbcnnlAllmnw

A :......e. conclusion has tn be ruchedDA .b.s Basis. we mggra in me LabawParly art /0! Iron. pm The relalvveqmcscencc .. the Labour Party ... me p..-elccuon period has led .0 man)‘ \u....bnsme am .. max. rbu......... mz Duhlmzuonof me New nape,/or sm...n, the risk.was has eeecbxm 0|: bulk of mu: mmabbey u- a..a.. Ell me a1!nosi\=iuru:me ‘kn’ {hammer of mu dntllmtlll ....e.e:y <.....m..m..e :1! me ....\..'. asxzsx.mum um. Lm... W1“ not mm. and ma.Labour‘:m..e.s..... noer be Ehnllmgcd u.pm me: ...,..me mm afftct

wmu wmfld fnllnw . Labour cletunnddzax would ... afl pmb..b.m,v be a [mule

am... ee..n...b....... M n .s..ee. br...a..mmud. and a new Audcrxlup ClruggieMuremer, me ..gm mg in ...e mmdk 01'

xuchxxrugllt ‘hflflld ucnamly ma. rb.u.ewile)! hum weapon again

rb..e.....<... czmml be ¢o...b.«ee. bycuunwmfmng ID .« mm mm soc-mlaemben... snlnlmnsof:«I.\\crycar.Only .rme labour movcmrm .. M71: m b.e.e..., ...me course :1! mnggk, .1 bold allrntauvcaoaalm wsinn er economy and meal ma,wfll me .ae...o.ze.a| ..nz..s.ve be TIv:n—

chcrnm M ........m n.e bubnur leader.ship .3 an unhkely mm bum. in um.nauvz.

Page 3: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

WEST GERMANYAT TURNING POINTGUNTER MINNERUP

Twenty seven Greens were elec|ed lo theEundeslag in the recem German general

election‘ which rclurncd the conservaliveChristian Democrats into govcrnmenl

Gfimu .‘vlinn:rup analyses the significance ofthe rise of th: Grams and me defeat of me

Soual Demacrah in opening a new period in

German and European polmcs

mg WA:sl German ckcunn af 5 Mzrch Lhn my mama adetmvz nnnmg Dunn in an Douucnl msmry or Europe‘;arangen xlnvrrmhxl pom. Buliungnlficanczlzynol pnmar]-ly m nn uclunl rmull Thrvxclnrvohhc::anwrVanv<Chm1unDemarmls and (I1: return of Chancnllor Kohl‘: cnnwrxzvwvrlvhcml aaaunan go»<rnm:M wa. mny prtdmlnblc. fh: munr(In; M ma vam unly mnnrmzd wlm had bcvn anal)/.\<A anaforecast bcluxc m ma can the xnzmubk dzrmsa: o[GrmIaIImcinl drmncxacy as the gavermng prmy m lhc Federalxznubuc‘. Thrfi Mnwh ms: nu: nuerm: nlsmry book“: themy man M: :12 m my German pahhcs winch naa bggun mwas nnam came to an end.

him an n wen ms: a quzmon ormc so¢1a|dcmz::1mm(SPI'))ludcn havmgw Inn wnmum lhenrmmvmrnalpuslsandxnlznzsfor mu ramsaaamn fuum: the world—wfle uueresx amused hvxlmeiccuon would be hard to Imdenund In Iheeyesnixhmnlcmanonnl mcdm, um mm:-.n.,n1m|aannn-. lnznpeucdLanizrvnnv: xiuary would promlc cnaa llur Kohl mm amandate m drplay ma Pznhmg 2 anu Cruwz mimics aflncnxcdto the man: Republic by NATO. nhcreus .n syn guv<m—men: dmaaan. an Lhe suy1lIOV|oH)\cGruc:mwuuld hzv: Lomcunder mlcluc prnwre fmm me am: movcmrm ro runs:deploymcnl Thu: ma ananc rqmcing in ma Penmgon aauWhitehall an 7 March

run mam;ma:/have barn amnanncz The nussxles wereclearly nvenhadawed hy ma econonuu mas aaa unrmpluymom in me mm demon mum, aaa bum KM exIra—pirhnmcnu pram nmvantm ana mg parhavncnlzny aaaaa.mm ‘a Cm 2 an Penning are Ixkely Io grow fasxcr naw.pombly Lhrowmgma Knnl gavemmgm mxo derp crms am param m ungmal dcpkoyvncnlplans Hm aannnn Eu: Cnusz anaPenlung and me varhamrmary llmnouevres berwtcn me sr-nana me Grccns [mm the oppuxxuun hunches L11‘ ma H:m4r:IuL'.ana zvrn mg mas; :xIIa—paxham:nl.arypea» muvcrncnl art onI, Aurfncn phenomena :1! a much decpcrcnsxs bcgmnmgm an.lam m Wu! omaaay India)’ ma Hogan of Lhc w .1 andpolmcal mnunsnnhnlnndzminnzdmzslabihryofme mm:xeanana (mm me rnrh/19505 The Lruehmnnc ugnnflcnnuolm<6Man:h mm 1: max n fin.1||y sealed ma endofme p<n|—v«ax

m min nunThe Fedenl Kepulshc 0! Wm oannany tum)» .. not an ordmary capuahsx nauan um: hk: any mllcr m Wcucm EuwvrHi Pulmml cnlmlc .3 hcnvlly deformed by the ImbewulngleVerkartkvmm (unmulcmd lcgnzfi M hycnsm. war and na—

nana| dx Inn, and by the urcumslulcaof us an .an and :u—ly mnmlxdauun. The prcsau arm: cannon b: tam unauaaaaxummn rzfcrrnccm mas: d:{ormnuons

lruta-nationatfiaturcs

cn.n(.n...u.nn xnnl‘ermrm Imam am not nan asartsuh ofrevolulmn. law at

mvlvlarydcfnaxby an allxanceoflumgn panam vlmny amWhy was was an amnnaa cmxmry, m puhnca! Imun‘ uv l)\L'hands of ma» uclunnus aum Fm um Grrman :|nu—la»ushennemng mnn mu cmucmnralmn mums, me undcrgmuud, orenlonxd polmual Dnsuvny. Hmnws mihmry delcal alwmzamlvhevauon am me) am Soon to Imd am how lhc|r|1b:mmr:'nnxamns mpotzd uncl nnnm on men xponmltnuz ancmpn torcurganlsz unwwav Grnuaxly an a unitary, demncram andyncualusx bun wan ma mama ar lhc anlv-Hnlzr coalwlwnana flu: cmcrxmcc in‘ ma Cold War, mg Jxvmon amannnan,mm what we esscnuakly Iwn chem units or me uppmmp.mm}-:§ heczmt Incvvawnglymrvnabk

Apart nan. m mica: . Yuuznnc 1nvesKmenLn\nrk:\VurU>Ali]! 1, me Wm Cnenuavl Fauna: Republic was mugncd acrucnl uvzuyc Iuntuon m a YCCDVISH'\ACl!dll\17)¢l|fl|\$A.!Hh1lICE

as m: nasmnnnaq bulwark oi cavualnm .n Eumne. Thu \a\\vndualnal Ind mnllmrv polennal of W131-:n1 German) wd: toman: xnnnaam dc: vcly m !nvnuvoHh:‘fm:wor]d' m usalrmmnu |o ‘roll um Sovl aa.n.nanan at naann mane.wim zan Germany M vhr pnnlt mac: .n a domino strategy a1ant)-mmmunm Subvemon and ncnaannanan AI uh: nnncumc‘ a numvc Amwcan zconomn aml mmmr) plgsenucwould Sflammcc a xyxecml relauonshw bclwcrn W2smI\g|onand M: Gcnnall 'IunmrDarmu',mnk1ng Bonn Ihcprinctpal a\—

[y of us vmpeflahxm .n cununemal Western enmac

German fascism d|d nol Fall as a rcsull ofrevolution but of military defca| by an

alliance of foreign powers

run pmpcx was by na mans any to rzalxst in the (IE: 01'sum-Ag aaaannan In ham aananax dw .aa and rtzrmamrv .Neulmlvam ana pacufixm rtmavned strong Curran: mn w nan!h:hourg:o\3pa.nI<t mm! wdl mlome l9S0s, and nnanarkanvnnamnnn wax in any case nrongly mspvcious of Allied suppunFur‘cay st rusmr:1mn' Th: unpruedzmed economlchonmarm 0:: curmncy rcfunn in ms ten y wmnbuvcd a gutdrd (n ma aaaon uf wurkmg clasw nulxlanc). hm tarmac .nIlsclfcxphlll (in: rapid wnxnhdzlmn nllhc ncw regime In hislhzinunseAmi-cnmmnmxl hymn: unleashed c|m1nglh2Col4l

Page 4: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

. V11)-Iurl: lw u...u....uu

lumanuuatfutmswuu Iudlud byrvenlnnchaslht l9A85cvi¢l lvlockndeofwcslBerlm, lhc xuppressiun of um 1951 5.5. Osman Markers‘rtbclllan. and the I955 um Anny inrrrvenuon in numry.um. um lhc paclhsl and wcialixl uyposi uu nnlllzdzknuvzIn mvidcd cmuauy, nu: elm canfmnutlon mm suliuumgav: mu lvyxlena . vrrulencr unparalklcd clscwhzic. mcwxyurrhnus m 0|: USA undrr McCfirLlIyl:m Thu alluwtdChmnellnr Adenaner lo usurp tn: E55»: 0! nmional muulnca.llon lmd:-rm: banner al the lmevaliml of Er Gzrmany [mmcommxulmn. crcaxingarulingblurwhlch dommaledWm anmany uum me me ur the menu. named an m pol‘ calcalholmsm ur Llm nld cum Pzny and III: lama of 1: V

liunzry proleslanl rlaummlum arunclzfl [0 all new ChristianDumnrrauc Parly.

By I957, mu cnu/csu rm: csu hcmg nu: muaulonumaus wing ummluu Dcmncvary Ln czihollr Bavnna)rlollcd own so nor can ol the popular vol: and me uppmlllonum mu vru)iI:d' the Fcdcrnl Kcnublrc W15 : lullyrmnvledmzmhu ofNATO. lhc Communm Fa ; Wm halmrd, and 1)::sm) was prrpanng lb final capllulalmn m the «mug orderTllc ldznlogy xdenllfisd loday mm lhc mlldtr rkzcsws ul umIlcaganilex rtpresevlled nu: rcspcslablc Lunsulaua mu wluchlh: Wcsl ommu mu: of lh: me man: and curly I960) was{minded

Wm Gennln Sacinl nuuumqDcfczl in the ma elecllon ol lhe mm Ilurvdexlug cam: 34 a\hu:kmmmtSPDnr1lu5!:who um been unable m|l:roelveaIarlylhlng mu 2 wcvzlm (nun: Ior yso:l—Hvll:r Gcrlmny Therm WIS, mama, mm m wnrk:7s' movcmem and bulldcclslvelv mlmum Ivy ma .1 an uuamuuuy (Much mumme nos. of us lmdlllunal Mmngholdx in mm umuauyl. theCold War, um lhc {nu um me nlll:d accuvallon uuwmcumlully um us, had mawvely favollud (‘hmlmlDmmcxarlf

lflhculldsnrrclhuxhczvllyuackrdagmnll ll, Wm m. upahihly of mt spn Izadcrshlp m mobilise in use in a baldchallenge to Ih: cmcrglllg yosl-war Aclllclntnl mm was. m mm-

luu nnzlysn, rsponxlble for mo:-rlcsofdcfcalxxuffcradlnlhzwsou Compared Io me vrvsrllhlay Imdcrshln ov Gcrmanmun dcmncriry. in men leader Kun‘ s-nuumaam wm almnxla cm:-slrugzlc mam Hz am allarlpl m blnld a hymnpopular alllamxaround me workers‘ muvnmrm by pnulng memun cfnululul Ilmly ms nypvslllon In any rt llnlnanxalmnduh: mmo:vum.=lomo¢nuuauu5eumuu.».uou Bun themm cf his oppomlou was hlnnled by nu ohuzsuue mlrsummumsm ulucu mad: mm denmmce the cmumuum Party,um §auz1 uumu and csvucially lhc Em omuuu mgr»: lnmm no less vloluu um Adzvuucr lllmsdf. Hclhu: dcllvcmdrm walking clan lolkuwmg lo polmal pxralysls lmdel nu:urrnlllmgcundllionsznd evznmnl uxrplnnctofvhzWc<1G¢Pman ualw mlo

in divided Gcrmany Cold War hysxeria had aviolence unparalleled elsewhere, excepz

perhaps in me us/x under McCanhyismlu zdflmon, me sru ludcrslup and Inn n0Lhmg of mu

narllmnznmr) Irellnism ix had dlsnlayed m. in meek cannula-Ilan la lllc Iasclst s: an of mm lu ms and u vepealtdlymuulul any rank-And-Illc auzlnpu uu oppmz mu govzmmemwilh cxlrr rllnmnuar) Innblllsaliuns. nu nalaurophxcvredlrlmns aboul me luuumm: cconomlc lulurc lnlllcr lhzumxalm synzm carried incrensnnglv less wnvlcxion wnh |I\:vrogrtsx of mu ‘ucnnnmlclmraclfl. lndulg to ya ng polllnaalnenloralnsnvon m mz par|y's ranks. Dcxpila me unuuluumucnllzpst of the Commumsl Pan), nu: sru Insl nuuamlu oflhnunndx ur membrnl and the mfiuencc 0! mos: nghl-wmsle-ndrrx wlm um ailing luv 1 radical (E—2Dp(aIS1I0'|h€pally‘:pmgnmm:grew rapidly arm Schumzchefsdeaxll in 1952.

rm: not Dmsramme adclvlcd by mu spa cunyess u. BadCvodubru in 1959 nlarlnd me cnpimlxuun oIGeL-man sac

l

dtmncmcy In nu: mm quu The uumularxusu rhnlanc ufurlizr urugnmmts wa: abandontd m lavaur afa formal ac»ccvunu nlxhg rzpluliik mum ecunumy. me xearmzmrwl MWcsl omum and us lnltgliunn lnlo lhc Wcucrn zlliance.andlhepurmngolany conctpl nlclasnlrugglcfmm llxnflicmlldemily 17:: Mmlu uuumu uuguumumu sns ms cxpclludmm! urm, along mm us uuulmual xympunusen. Thc Sm“as m be knawn as a ‘peop|:') pally’ man had foreswonl ll)WDfklI‘lgClI$DY)g)Il5,1I|d many Mm ludelxprrferrtd |ohk=nu m lhcAn1:rIan D(mD(1fl[$7flIl|E{l)|Ill the nmual gum‘,mlh:Sn¢'h.!i:l |ll[E(‘l\ILlUmIllWAllYElIndl'S'flSlQ1fl|yfllgWforme cnamllomup m I961 ulueul mm a me ‘(knnan Km-May‘)

Willy Brand!'s firsl campaign for theChxncellorship in 196! billed him as the

‘German KenmdylInsofar 15 (hr sl-7|) tonlmued lo find In mum mclzl has:

menu lrldrulllomsed wnrkmg prople. in swuch [mm 'M2rxr.u- w povllhsv relovm rhuuric could um um: us aulmmcluncleraslheylull cnlrcpxcscrlu calm: wvrkmgclass,and in uublmm vmzvllon I: ml. byhom us xupvorlm anduwouuus. Th: ml Slgnlficnncc of mm mm Wlx‘ undcrlmgdwill: lhe nuuuu. pmgrammauc Hnnderlng xncech uu fortigupollcy by m: srm ua Imenmry lndcr. :x¢mnmunx<\Hexbrn Wmnen m 1960. w Ich wax In lxplltll nlfrr (001:cm; or hipanlsamlllp 1!! Wm C-:rmany'i exxernnl rvelnlions.lnzluding lhose mm m Eaxl, Tn: ‘flzulxrhlnnd pm fornegotiated verlmlficaxion umuua only . yur urlitr vii: quiet-I) dmpmd u was mu film] rccugnmull by me SPDIndzrshlvum whll: lntrrnaxiarml um Gtnlun unpenumu mishl :2:umrurcd (0 pm up um. u nuldl) mfarmlsl gavrrnmull mBonn, lmptnzxllsm consldrmd any Flues! min; of Wu: Germ2ny'S pm u. the Hun nlhanct and Lllzcznnal Europennmun: uuaax nnzcorpmhle. Thedzmminnunn m pmve llsellx‘rcllahlz parlnrr or bar Ammuu frien¢' was an nzw wr—

msloue oi lhe sru |raEler3lIlp'3bm for pnwzr, um um slag:of which u wnsclouily anricixaalrd in he 1 ’Gmnd Cna||linI\'with Chnmml Demnrracy. The malzgy ur Ill: hlsmnn: cmnvpmmim u um, um ull, uu Imllall invnmlon ..

Page 5: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

n. srn m guvunmnnl11:: man sccmm to war). vrrlocxlv By woe, Wes: Gumamwas confronted mm 1|: [ml minus economic rcctsmun, zndma cnu 7 no» wnhcm an ahmlule mayoru) n. varlumuu,nnu dcwnrd bym mm: cuamion parmtr mu a hudgcl Lnxu— was Indy xu alluw sun’ dcnmcrxmc minmen la (ry lhzvrnanannn nbn nlnc 9)/ll¢lli!IdClIIalIdl\1«‘Afl4lKC!\1ElV| mm:mung cm. Hm had me advanlnsn ohm mlly wcunng um,munfl b)u\uLcn(¥ during um rbcaswn, bur aim nfmlmducingsome modernmng mnpnxm into me nvmmenal burmucrlc)The Izmpemry du/erganm between the demands of puwcrfulcannunn imcrzslx and ms xdenlagical cuntzms of thecnu/Lsu became mu more pronounced am the inn: ofQ:/palnmr, when Ihuigm Wm; M cnmuan Democracv black»nu ma auempu ofinrrign Mmisver and V>c¢—Chanccllur Wd|yananm Ln brmg snnnu whey Inward: mum Fumpe andam German) mm [me wnh um mzw Vmcmakimul Ehmzle ofdrvelomru zlémr/2. Prevmusly Hm Dohw mm cunsiwzd ofnut! nowrccogmlion ol Lh: cm and um braking-ufl ncdiplnmalic relalions wvm anycounlry remgmxmg n nmnpn un-Sovm Uniml) 1nm.pnn.nnnnnnnna nnannnizum rcnmuo.nus om lo lurrisn nompamen m H1: Lompctiuun aver thennnmwuzm Europtan markemhut |heCDU nna becam:nriwned n, MK own (‘old W2: Ideology and rhcmnc. Thu nnn.mm: 0! lh: 1959 elecunn — an sprunv c:.ocm.nbnnnr)eomnnnn headsd by Cllancfllar Erandl — was merefure umrhan n unsnm for me bonrgwmz

Tn: pnnclpll rvamm rm mg break up of xi»: ‘Grand cm’um)‘ .n 1959, hovwm:-r, war to be Fmmd zkewhere. IL hadncva been Dnnulnr nun mc SI-‘D'w mnk-and-Iilzmembewhlrland was indtrd only nnmnxy 5-mcnoned by [he um van‘)couams. A Wwzrful wax: ni mdna|I:a|A0n was xwccvlnsmmugh an unwemnes, colleges and srhools, Incrcxmngprrssure on mail annmmmn: ilseiflooxe from mmnnncnalnmn paruwr nndmrzaxtn 5 Lo omflnnk an on lhrls-fl In

New titles for March

—Bob Sutclifle

U Hard Times

Dav 11 Hall

"Amum2nLI luv Socu !m can uL:y a ngnmmnnn n .9eenannmm the nacusswrymrsncxzlxxm that nennnmmnnmnnsnaim humans‘ um a.nn"AluurlurnsI01 Smaullsm has a mm mm to may m nnnamg themleflucluaflramawefldnrlhn mama! nacxflxasvvunwb oflhs macs‘Kev: uvlnqnnn luacvoflhlcu:

».u.ueom-n all wand hmkshops av ulna lrem mm Prrus-mm mass. mworn. ‘as: Yanilno Ann, hanflnn NW5.

Anmsop lvv v-Ev

uments fdis

The World Economy In TurmolHam Tlmns snmcs new the amrmnuc nuwhimzva ullfie1§ED5 has vnsullnd nnmme mpwmul system 5 Mod (av mum and how Qflvammenl Dohcxes wm mm yet

mun: nnn<.-.mp wafldwme Bub Smcwle crmuscs exnnnn nnnmnnnn phsns and argueslot: more rzdx<:aLasmocr;mc and mvwrtalmr-131431awmech

PlutofilmPress

Inmatannatfeatmssehxembev ww, unofficlflslnkes nrumed m (Iv: Han and ugelndnnxy. nunmnng growing nmnnnnnnn m m: workmg claw

Tlmlmdn nniumdtmanded a holder ncrnnnm chum; and mamnnm xqnxmx c:- xzcnlucd heawfly nmnng smd:*n1> andY0urISuorkcn.Tu vtmammme‘(ir2|Id('mYiImn'wou|dha\cserxouslylhwmtened nnnspm unuy and in lradmovulmm m

I svecnnnn as me panv of un: mm.

me dominant issue or Brandi‘:Chancellarship was Ostpolmk. me |rea!ie:

with Paland and Eas| Germany naming himme Nobel Pcac: Prize

Brandt duly clrncd um . :ub>L2ImzI1uvnmvhelen mslylc and menonc. LI noi suhuzncz ‘Damncrauc sucinhxm‘found n, we)’ um mm nn. ipetchm and lv>«o\IIl|on:, nnu thenzw gov:rnm:nlpmm1::d||mAmc cra ordemncracy wax ovfly]\lSlbEEil\!\ll\s.RCl1CWDd nmnomxc gmwm prmvded mememwlar n largvscai: cxpaxmou of emI<alim\, public mm andwelfare >1-Kndins. and a Ivurnbrr of nnnnnnnm lcgal mrnnnnWELT cnrrml om rne flolmnam nwc nl Bram1l‘5 Chznocflnndug. however, W1: annnomm. nnn [realm wnh Polnnd andzxpgmallv Easl Latrmuxy czrrnmg mm the Nobel Pam: Prwcand mcxupvon nrnnma Loalmon oflmcesmngmg [mm rmCnmmunLslPIr1yhI mode! Smglibzmlrefmmzn \\/henmgcnmnnn Democmnc npposIunncho.wm\5lcrra1nxu challengemm m mz. an SH) won me biggest electoral vvcxory m .nmum)‘ and mm 45 x pcrwnl om» mmnn vmz nan becameLhclargzunvlslzvaflyilllhrrederalR¢|!IIh|1cfovLhci|mnm¢

11.: rrmnmdcrofl)|c‘3uc|a|-hbcnl cm‘ vaxxsluwngnxu znddrclmc me am: of un ‘ml cum‘ and mnnnnnn Klagnavvnn

“lg(31 ism

The cuts MachineThe Politics of Public Exvendnure7». cm. lfiacmrm sham now pubhcsewmes ave conlmflsd m awvex and

suborqwniced In me wnlervsu m urwuiebusmux Slate wenflww unmaxnsM Weasaummwon man Dubhc :eIvKA§ pm.“ nommg u! vdueam unuexnmesme Vnmwmmnsnlubouv P:.u1y::ndTUC zlmmmmzccmomwcsvzueglesand arvuas [Hal a wwxsnuegy mnzlnseanlmthe hgmfionocsx

serwces and denubcranc wmvnls

Exsslmg nuns m the Alyumems rursocialnm seriaecam Chntevuuck and mu Lang conn mnnm.Mnlehun w.c.n cm. um»; You Suckme my wm ow Fund The Pumas of nnn Namnmand Farmww Hear: Serv-<5./awryBasia mane MmGem-w |lYo<1z4hev ‘mu Ovuvmn EllyWm\en:sYmd2Umanssls Yhocass Io1P\m\sc<)~ner:mp

of mncn: Vrsxnlmmns

Page 6: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

rcmoved me financial room for mznoeuvrz Io): rurl|Icrcxv:In-nan Mme wellarrwzu Przsmr: fmmlhz bourgcumclcmcflyraprscnlzd m «K gm'<mm:'nl by me hbcral cmlmovl pmm»lnrmmrruy memuvemndnrnll-bad. nflradvunxon vtvwerledm an reyxlzcrmemnf sum m May 1974 by on zoumzauxmnghx-wulgcr Hclmul Sdumdl undtr {hr melem of mgnumzume inyzffair In me 1975¢1cumn Ihccnmhllan mm onm puwrrhvlhgskin uhu mm. mcCDU on|y1\I:H¢l)\ng:!vurl<1!annbwlulcmajanwalmcvamInk9X0,ll|:d1vNon<1nm:Chnsuall Dcnwcrnl ranks om m: mnlrovelsml figure ofrrmyosar Smmss um CDU/CSU's cmvdidaw for the-hancellorsmpjonce ngmn saved me gavernmrm mm. dciul.bun .1 wnxgenpmlly (zen ax muyam, L71‘

«sum... The rmndelecnnn (as: autumn came as no stlrpnsc alxeraloml sent: ofDubhc xplm aver financial and ewnomxc puhcy.

Na mum 1.. an. I950:Sulxerficully, ms Damien] lzndwavc in Was: ammy mm\how<5ume<im||2r\!i:Vw1mlhc‘Adcn:um'Era'oHh¢I9Slk.Anew Cold War betwccn Wnslungiun ma Muxcow dormmues m—

Lcmxmonal ruinlmm, mm In: Chrisnnu Dtmocrau are mayu.:uau\..nca m gavcmmcmafxer me mm doctoraldcfen forIl\:SPD:mc: men. El/:n m:Iernx<ofrmlmcn.\ ammuggesu.g nn of ms 50:, mm me can emphumng mum Mimic:w mg us M Lhegnuamec aim: mm: xcyubmsacuruu.and ms Sm 1.. an uneasy rclaunnshw mm a peace mm/emgmwithin wmch Lin: nld idea: mi :1 cmlral Eumpcan nus;Year—frce1.DlIE«(Kfl!-7flCkiYI1\'lH\aVlflElIllE!|JlI£d sommmncy ('er(am—lymcCDU'5 clccnon mmviaxnumym wmono.,..szygm=a1owards\h:cxp¥oxla(von Mme nasulgu my rm gund oldyeanof (he ‘cconomu mmw, mm pace and external \:curilY

Em mgr: can be no going back Aaenmr; succcxs cf Lhc

I950‘: was based an n urnqm: su alcimumuanusa mm mmbcre<:rca1cd.ln:lcado:rmmm\a|»=o..u.uom fornnexvlnsuvebvum Kuclkd by xc:mmyJy unlmmeddomemc mm fnmgxu fl:—

mand rm mv=>lm:nL and consumer goods. Chznczllm Km .;conlmmed wuh xhe detpesx (nus of mg capiulnst warldeconomy far my yams, (he wart! nf which 1; clzaxly Iocemc.Vlaxs unzmploylnzm, mung hving ilandzndx, and dvnfimngwdlarnhmvixmm are. huwevcx. mccxazl Dmmmeolwhax mc

mm: put: and wmumerm dzpolmciszuon 0! m: pmvwurcm were founded on rm yrzn cf 49/Mn and :4 MW0sI;1olml<,zm- recngmlmn af am can and Argahsnunn oflhvcw, hm: fnnhzrmurc mam Lhc xbnluy arm ruling this no

re ndkthz ma nf:|nn—Lomm\uuSx mass mm ma: mum:d m: mm: mavcmzm far XE was Tm dimna) m um um-Dznansx camp mm me rcmwz wezkrvung a! ma us pnuunnand ma \ntcns1ficalmn nlunltramvzrmlisxcampemmn. in wax

is me dmnlcgranon 0! mg mrmcr Snslnml mcnoluh. ha“:maxed new mmmmm: nnccrlaimvcs m undtrmine the {owdaumw of m: nrchulscmrc n! Ihc European po~‘|—»m mmam;

the Pale Movemenx. m (iruns Ind Inc Drxl 3.4 WorkingCluxThe Fedtnsl RCD||b|lClSIhC1:fDK:Iww emenm; mm mm: m\—

mama tummy The mom vmhlz ugn nl mm mdzy .» lhcnear: movemcm and me clacumv of 27 Greens m theBumleslnk nu: migam L1! :91: (irerm gm hm m m: suldtmand)uummvuhof1hc|aIcl960s rxmnmwmun mm,mm, xdculogxcafly xmvxml hy nlsmdnswven m Mnmszn and 1«

.mu. Km . rt-kmnlluls or me :.|x>s~slrugg|e masons of m-Cumin workers‘ mmmm, wuwuzd an uni) uf(prednmxnanflyMno|slI‘revoluIio1\ary ymm mm mrh 70»and the vex/Eva‘ of: soc1:lrden\ocvinc kl! m m. shape 01 mg 7

Iuxm LSFD Vmmg sucmrs» mm smncslca [mmdcrcd mmm own uanuy‘work1ns um Fkmuli under the condmans(vi cammucd pmsmny, and m: r:3»|um‘e 0: Lb: r:(anv1vslbureaucracy The dam: ow us mmal pumecnvzs and um.n.-mm, well rhe end to me more“ a! radmalkaxuon‘mmugllomvh:7D5,andcaminumgmmmc!9RDx,n»eryIarg<mm. 0! me mung generztiuncnnunued In 2»: vnlmcned Dv

lhc am mvtnahsn ant:-muck-nr, oculagm, and Kcnuuisl

movanmls. mm: an the Sam: hmc ahrnawd rm.“ mmdrmocmzyu, I91: mars: of Ike Smmndl gnvunmenl. I uflyms upmm at m: growing ammucsm pawn and ecologymmrmenu,Lhefirrenznd‘AI1ern:nve’lm:finI.\lY zduhnirbrcabxhraugh mm mm arena uf parhamcnlary polms mwmux or me vcacc movrmcm

in would beverywmns howzvcr. mcqunte Ahcfirzcm wuh

Page 7: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

me DEECEMDVUHEHIDI-V4'1‘CII me, zreanly 2 }12rl.TIV: Gmcnsrepracnl mm: mum ml mc vac: mnvemrm that haveman). a! Icnal icmvuranly. mam wuh ma 'esmhlim<d yur—nus‘ young rm um: voters mu. no msdxunnal m\.mxloyalncs, nu vemnanuallhtokd Iar—lefI organuauons, dm|lu-mound :un:|d£mucmu and human: ummny Mm prufusslulialand Mmc ollar xmxgroumm Thcy havcmcir qronglxolda m

m big cum, mpucuily mm xulh large umvemnzs, .n wlmhan zxlgnsnsnclwork o{‘ailcrvumc'soc1nlandcuixumlnmlnlurnun: nmuma a cohesive ‘green/all¢m:|xve' miheu rm 5 5pm mm mm .mio...\ vme mm mm mvs w no! mg mangepn¢..um=...m- uf rmgligxblc iiguntancr u ram rvflacxx numnsidtfeclxonafficnnun mm mm Lhccuahll edpolxln I

and cultural values or Wm Gcrman sunny and 3 suchrcprzirnls a mmaeranne smuacuvz mm m the unfuld g

cum

the origins of the Grecns go back [0 thesludenl and youth rcvoll of (h: late 1960s

Em ma impact arm: vcacemovzmenl50:5 far dapcr. AllDummy: pulkcunfirm um «um:...mm, oflhrwcuGumanpopulation mm: m dtploynncm of Cmis: ...a Pzrxhmg“gm ... me Federal R(]'JL1B[l$‘,llIC|\|d}lI§ahnux . mm mmCDU/csu vmcrs. Dcxpnrlhe anempls ufxhe sop and umumun b\lI:au£mL1r::losxbnlagzm$y:ac:muvem<nlm0\71I)sa-mm from lnyzlty mwurds lhc mmnel or Chane:-klnr s.»:.....a.(who ma (D bomx mm H wa, he Mm mm dlscovcmd [Ht needmy mom Eumnnn Nno rmmlcx), mm of lhousandx nlwurkmg—cKa:: mm; panlclpakd ... them, and No—mi:ds ofan Sm) dxsmu organisation: rm. cumc 9... zgamsl LII:nxmxlts The W SP1) mm Vogclk phsslgc m m2Marchclcc-Mom -m do my uxmau m make Crum and l'er5mng un...m,m" mm: on hug: dcclmn poflers ‘hflll um addrndum-... U1: Gcnnnn :...=mv. m on abvmus mmn: no men <en—umrnvs

Th: dynamm of ma Wcsl Gcrrnan pt re movemrm .3 m :1large mm «mm: {mm Lhc pecuh xy 0! me Foams!

xemm gcu-pulxuxal munuon a: me wine a! mnhxzry has:ofm: Ummd Sum and mum rm..u.m«.m In Europe. As

..Forlnighlly news review of III: |Fonrlll InmnninnnlJms asp per copy. Or mbscnh: for :9 701mogunn, cm a year (surface mm, or £w/I25 (amquad). Maka aux chuzxnx, money mm m ‘PEC’.send to lnlcrnzuonal Venpmnl, 2 ma whmLenoir, 921002 Mnmrcuil, mm

Immamfiutm

me mgvnabltbaxllegmlmd arm. aliymtad miluar) wnfron.Hmun .. me 'E\|mp<an mum‘. Gnrnmny [acts a Imlnczusl ofdtnmman cvcn by the mmswe us: of mcrcly fldvnnczd‘convczmonaf or ‘ucu1'zl‘ nndmr weapons. Tim, cl wuvia,applies xo both German mm. and me wxdzxpreld nmzrrnesxohms rm, ixwellasrhccxmenoe olapzaoemovemcnlmEastGermany 5 Inning .0 a growing rta||_uLion ofa lxnk bclwccnmo Duct Mn: and me nauovu] qucsuon. um: m am ,ncan hardly be prexended xhzl Germany can mmzhuw amid menuum Imc of fir! Mull: bum um; mmam. am ‘newnuclear‘, mzmben of Khan’ rcsprclivc mimm

The Gmnan ptnu mnvemem mus xmplxes a InndamzmzlLhnllmp [0 ms Eurnpean xmmr mm, mm .s clearly beyund amere moms: movcmcm my me puhlically nelerogmwus andsacrally mugm: on me strategic senst) Greem The Spamunem mummy uf largc sccunns M’ [Ill mgmma workingclzus for nudul d|)’anm4m=nL mm fardwrzngagnmcnx from theImpenalm war drive spezuhcaded by m: us, need< m b:hamnssad lomcdevelupingrevxsuncno Ln: .m,mnymmumunposco by me new bourgcmi ovammem in a mum] n!neepznungmculandeconm-nucc llneadsnperxpecmcthalpoimv brymm czymzlnm and sunmm mm Lhur murderouscunhnnlzlon m which . dvvnded Gcmmny 15 ml.-ficapablycallghnlp

:r m: Grcrn: mmmu m Ih: strong sc(:\an:|n przsmresmm. ||\:1r ranks m

VJ1 mmud: m m: sop m the en gpmod, megaxablc damagc cuuld be dun: Such prexxnlrcs umum (emu ac me pronounced unrvcnnrss oflhe xadxczlxsalmn

nmuss m West Gznmmy over the lasl fiflczn yum, pmdtlcmxa brand Liyn alyuumfuk mmm wim dtep fcehngs unmmw(award: wllal mm :0: ai‘hm.1rgenIx':o:1al dunonn.cy1'ull)1n—Irgrzxcd mlu ihecapflalmsy5xcm,Bu|vo:1a| democracy is mum cum. mm belwcm (hr: cansuvauv: msxincl; at meburnucm cpanv and umon leaikn and lhcdmunds mm. an\ncrm6ingly r<:vJ:s= rank—and—fiI: [or mm acnon agmmluncmnlaylllcnl. annuity, and me dangrr of war mmeosogmx haul: now bcxmnm! w “mud wlmm uh: workns‘mDV¢lYI¢|’lli5!'I<d¢El3IVCblXH¢I)|(hC10lIK'lrr1I\r mlelymorcxrnpormm um me mnfungofn fcwcicnorul DcrcrnIag:|>o|n|:bclwzrn fluSPDandIh=Gr¢:ns.llisnhallluwhuchmefirczm— and the Red: mm wuhm and «mud: um — can only .g7nor: at max pen].

ncfuennsn See my ample m N... 1.,/. mm. No 99 mm. «M. Germm);mm m. v«1r',ny31l),uprc|lMylh= wsmnp. anzlyuns mg uwsuxnun mun2 SPDmrmbrr>7Ily um mm Ky xvsAwnaashm.km5>1s.179

cimmn Mmnmzur as Sullnr Lecturer ln om... mum.1 Yorlmwulll Polylachnic mu . memherohheLnboI:rYIr\vum crux

Page 8: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

IaneniatiaaaifutmsM|T|'ERRAND’S ROADTO AUSTERITYCHRIS FERTRAM

jnie historic victory of lh: Franch left in thepolls in man raised many hopes for socialists

_across Europe. Yet rising unemployment andnirnaiian and senbacks in me municipal

elections have provcd a non very auraclivcpolitical inaaen, as Thatcher will no doubt

explain in (he noiincomnngpnecnion in Britain.Chris gemani record: two years of theMinnerand govcrnmcm, and shows than

[ht popular nolnon on ‘sucialisn profligacy’

having gnvcn way |o ‘realism’ is eniirely false.

The Mnnicn-rand gm/emmernn has‘ Ill nan purwnd znxhamefacedausvznly nrogranunz «min the word go M has gnvtn way in a|\o\IIVtfl\ affcmwc by ma :mploy2rV' nrgannsauom aan in IIQV

drmabnlnxrd mc Working clan in nan fullowcd a pm—/Kmencanfurngn po|n:y,An4l nannnri nnnacx nnacaannin ual:app:Ir:||u5Iihum: ainn in. Imperial conuucrparl in Africa

AhslnmianxThe num nan ekmmnx uf March mu ma an inanannanaaiainnu on ma Mal: an nmnd an the Franck wanking umDupnr: a nanian recnv/cw in me mcond round an ma ck-unnoni.

mzsn nSh||ndComvmIrI\xlDannaw¢r¢h||byII|:|;uv:ah5lel\—non» among lhtnl nanniaiaan clrcnonanc. Ann ananysia an innrcsulls :hovn>1V\'.M, almmngln xery Few [eh-vlnngvalet: dtscnodlhcnr purines far ma nghl, many slzaycd an home canvmeny,me nurrnonn in ma w:il—Iodn nninm was hightr man in Vin:

municipal daemons of nm. nn LINE. wniaia Prime Mlllvfilrr

Maum) nsfvlayor. me Lumaulwuwpencmnxn \h:IKmI(mna|-ly righnxungnorllnarn ' rinbbuluniyélvtfwnlnn mzlcflulnninimi pan ofme mwnl.‘

Also sianinaann was nnieminaaiamny Iingh vnxc far the [:1Ken, Wifll inn wmbnncd Val: cf 0|: slants Dun forward bv theKnrvnlullnnary Commumsn League (Fraud: Scelionn nl meFonmh nnmnaniniiannann Lnmenuvriert-on Ihtune hand. analhcParlnCommuIlxxzellncrnzlmnalnsncon me mhcn conungronna \mnl:r 3 ptr can ~

It might have been txpencd nnian ma rullngcualnlnon wouldcnndudc niani ihn.-5: rrnninx um n should pursue rconmmi:

pan: , in lavmnr an lb: working class in (an inn :|u\1crhypackage Immdllccnl In me wanaaninianaiandevaluauonofm:[rant iV an Tcbbnlhlnkt emmy. Eleciricnly, gas and itlephontml}; are an by x per crnn, along wnm ian [arm Almhnl andmhacso will lie dzarcn and mumu arc minmn in Spendingmoo trams nhrmd nmnianny in: man unlrnrne meaaluc in mesorlipulsmyluau(0lhegov/<nmIn:n|whntlnwnllzndd abonu newcm: to innn nax bin; {on man pnarlnculw mamh in [he name an

nianaiary nannny HI: Frcllth working dag l) naanig 1Vk0d Lo

ugmen .3 beltThe mcnsurna hnv: man cwuplrd win» a cabmrl rcshulfle

anncn mnaaaa in nu nrani Lhmy—imIr KB fifmcn. pnnia,» meanon aanineain vncum an lhrchnnkkxViasnhc -cans’ kasdcrUwvrnzmenl Wndelv inmnxn in ma Emnsh mm as -in:rmncn Benn‘ Chnvrrlzmtnl . nan ralher Kim: A uxong

dcluidnrnllhcnntlependcrnnnudear dclrnrrm, he argued {orznaliernannw smncgy nnnniina depannrc nnnn ma EuropeanMornelary Syslrm. nmporl commk and morzxnalcnnuervrnnionill

’ dnfiry. Na glen! opponem nfanmrmy, Chekemmunl wasIII: finsn mnmsxer in leap In Nnancs Mimsner nenm ddcmx:whcn a ‘pnIIS£‘ wassnnnunczd Ill (be pmgrammeofrcfonnsulDm=mh:i man The (Inmmunm Pally mnann firmlv nackaamm the go\'en'nmtn\l, wnm 7‘Hnmuzmle headhniflg inn newpackage as -no Govznnmcnl Mamas‘Auslcrily lmliduDcspnu maanninn no pornmynh: iinnaaicamama Igfilm menxuln on me p-nm wanking: an Lcunnomin. Inevimbnlnny, mzmmA\KYt< adopted rewrcwnl bath a deepening nf already exIslmg policies and a aspnunlanon la n. polnnnul nffcnsnvc led inlhz Fr:rnch emnloy:r=' argannsaalnom, L71: CNF¥ Evcn \1C(Dl’E

Duclnhzv mu, whm flu: nnn ‘pi1u5c' was announced. the adnmniurznlml wa$ab.\I:swd wnni reswnng buimtss cvufidenccannan I0 inn mm a polity or wage ann ynce re<nramn whichlnmnncd wags. nnher man: man pnuzs The mtnsuxm lnlroduc»anon in June |9RZ,Ivhn|c::nvn:@n-ngau)(:|\\ag:1ree1c,m]|uw-:6 the ynricz: olxomz frcsh mods, penml and sltdnu ma. This,lflgefhcf wnni my nnnclfccvive mean: nor cnnoning Brno: cownml. lncnill man the policv ynmhably ltd no a 4 per Dem drop VYI

plllchaslllg pom.‘Th: aoninaan afleniive an ma rululg cnass his laken two

main form: Th: pama an inn- Rnglnn hnv: naaan an ann.gnvernmmn pmpagnnnhn cnampaugnn oaannin Icadcn Chnruz: haszndorscd Fnedmamnc uunomnc means. sin lh$t’(VlI|y7IY<NV\/C

dlscrulnl whnch ninn haugi am than people, cmnpied wnn lhtmy men of crgunisnuon nf at naan (In: n\nn—{iau|Inxn Rngm.

mans man {my mm lens man pcrfbcl nmnumcnlr. In an an. ink

on ma gnvtrnmem Th: mrr, on me aim hm\d,pu\xn15e|7ncmri as me iunpmriiul mna an bnmnlsx. as lhcnr vitrrrieauana, Guy Bmnna, Sand my pnhcnza an Jun wninionsans: They are non me mm of ma main or the uni, innsn

]7B|Y(l¢\W|1V¢’| ramni inainnyaxmnnm msny, Lheiepulncnes

are am whncn annack HIE working class, wnnn UK‘ CNFFd:ma|rdnngnhat 5 pun cznn aranacnanna pawn ‘dulnhnncd in rxcc£$'

imam has). by lhcgovtlnmevlt‘Zllhzsnmellméahiaflmg Viv

lhc rcmuval nrwn-aim KAY leviec an aannan inmnnnn «

Oncnfnhz gm nannies 0! ma curmlll anmzunnis mm an Inn:nxcn inaimnny pluciprinlzd an Mnnnerranws anmnsnaain forNATO. A rim. hrlirvcr In tlncnccd no cnumzr YJI! sam mreallhmugh ma drplnymuu an Cnm: nnmnaa, Miurrmnnd hackedHdmul Kohl an lhls mvliculzr in: In nhc West Germanpnrlullntnl dunnglhegenemlelecxionLampangn T!\e(Ihns1mnDcmoual vncxory canaan spzcnlamn nnbnny nzannaasinamanngel! Fmncn, for a um: jcupardnslng nhz fnlurn: ol the Eumprallynanaiaiysynani. In was oniy by Lhrmtrnnng min wnlh annen»niunnisx nltaxuruandwlhdmwalfvnllllht EMS man Dclon wasable lo lcnzz semi, wniicni hasnlml in lm: rnnn memllnpu an

[hr ms, no hair man an Lhc ton ofC\IrI:nC)‘Ical|gnmmu niavevy nmunmom rnzacsulry in Ike Eumpzan bour_v,e0I<i:5 an: no

aannm succrssfull) mun Hi: Americans mu: mask Ital cowmm allK1I|g|Y\CIIIS¢1V¢S

Mnlicrnansl niaa niaan, anana wnm T'11IChK‘L0!|CUfl)I(‘ musllmwknsln ofnh: Ennmpcnn leaden nasanc rianani insmcnbcollnmnan indeperndzncc nmni lhe nnnnary slrucmres on NATO,niam AS na dmnbl man lhe Trench ‘furcn: dc Vrapp:' n anvned anMoysow mm man Wnminglun. Non orniy am Miuenandsnnyporn ma deplcyllinm an Cnnnsn. he nai aka givzn me gn-ahead my ma madzrllunnnon M France’: own nacnnan amnan.‘Th: ncw Hnsdca mnssflt has a Iingu on lmkm, znahling ii nareach an G:n-nnnnnnny rmni wndun Flvnth iannnry. A dc non l!\= deploynnem an lhc Frcnch ntuzmn nnnnn )5 cxpmlodshn)rn|y,2nd Miuemnnd hasnold ,.nnnannnunn, an is oun Mill!quesnion inian Frlnoc winn Mlhdrawzxinflcunr0Hlsmmn.\:w'

‘n

Page 9: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

Ofwurst, as Rcagall :.ii.iiinax‘=u,;a.m-z in: ‘UIIDIIE ufzvil .1!may Mu hz (ha! me rmicii rul g cm; will,Iog.:1hcr Wltll InEIIYOVNIII paflntrfi, uni»: an Vndflhcrldlnl mug, from meAIIKYIIAIM.

Yovtign unlit)Many Dll [ht kl! have bun misled by Minmana-i pulley“mm Ccmnl /kmuicn, which has In\D}‘/Dd ftbdgfllllon :2!mt Salvzdarean FDR. Hm I! would be mug In <2: the upsI0rS('ll|Enl of: ‘lhlnl way’ bnwzen \'\’zshmglun zndflzvan asmore hat: a kcngmlion um Imperilllml must find .. pnliumlsnlnlloll [0 ma nmmum ofmz (cyan Since me USA IS pnnripally 2 cmnpnilur rnlhrr am. an ally Ill ma am, iviiiimmihoncs X0 omiii 1mm Reagan‘: aiscomnim.

Far MOI: rcvrcsclllal e of FIZIKES policy in ma mmWorld is us pxmrncc In Ah-ica.MIu.errand's(c1murainmmum. SD far, wen me ma 0{>PCr|ac\flIr0D<fall0n ommcairrind mu m (‘had no Zlifl. Whal mad: mu: iiiimuiiiomPusxible hawrvzr me me mnsmc and pennmm Frenchlluhlfll)’ IlifraslrutlurelIIa£H<iil<fl4r0>S m¢Cfll|UlICnl riamuami mu, pmiicc was am. [0 anon! 5,100 Lmnpn Ul sixcouniim. wun ndvisors In a further Iw:lve mm m iesiThrough a caries oi aereiicz mi lluliur)‘ agrccmlnl‘,lltgolmitd in 1960 and 196]. pm“ reams the ham rm rapidiniemiiimii h) zpzcizl Ioreci. including mm mm. and an:axmourtd dcmhbrigade riamana Htlguilvfs BX420]UlIll:S archeavily depkndclll DH mm z< a weapons Sllvphu. Franc:Kllpyhei su W sent 0! the wznpom uscd by ll: Funnel pmsa—non; and 52 pt! crm or Him: lo fnrmn Belgian minim Thiscnmparcs WI!" 2 Figure om p91 crm an m um Supplied (0ramm Bnmh wioim hy Bflldm. in illdlliun moo Africanwldlus arc trained :1/My )§!f III In! mm. mflrapnlix.Fame‘: lmkx In Ah a an plrl oi . Quin! mm mi...miinicacioimymm max is wcond only [0 mm uflhe USA Vn IKE

Etugraphiral ma. I Nun: in! mi; has b¢§l| dlxmamkd imdrrM1l|tr1al\d aim Dduwz NE\II|Sl¢Y Chane: mu... has gm soin n mi-immn advance rimm immniions W m: name ofpmiaeiiiig rmicii llallonili

mm-, millialiil policiu luv: iim nnnicnlnrlydamgiiigcnnsequencc) for yuum One ufme Left‘: mm :(ecLion pmmisc: waslhzmducfio mi mry service from 12m 5 monthsThis has naw um. :h:|vnd.Far:am:l0J]l1‘vo|unLcer:'1LlIa5In cm bc:n txltndtd la bdwecai I6 mmimuiia (Inc: inn.‘Thu: mamlenance cl F1'IIICt'S xrpreslive ippifihls uvasa:

liiiumionaifmms

has barn miipim mm; fllcflglhtfllllgnflhrp0\)cca| hum: AlHm, M}ll£Yfand'S JHSXACE Mmiuu, Ram Hiflmkf, curncdLhroughscmeexlrhnelyDrDgr£SSIV:lII£an|resmiamiesny Wmmime mi many Dnsoncra. Ah: mm pmiiy was abolishndand D<G:ml|:'xnmor|ou5S|4|:S¢:unl‘/Caunwax diflifllldékl.S\ncu!\en lhEI!\0VE7I\B7Il Iowardssrmmlihcmm nu goneiKevan: A pnvemmenl commmioii has r:L0mmn\d:d ltgn :7\lIgC(‘Ha|l|polwz nracnctx ‘all mrbenenocomrol man’. sumas pllmlc-lnvulng II [E piaiiiim Lu Lake on zn txirx io.oouD0|YC§iIIiHl)0f§Al|ISC3'|Ifl'll:1IXIXHIIIOIZ7‘llghllnltfvelfllcllIQQIIIV. Al! mu review; HI [ht wakc cllmi-Srlnihc miimm byLhtzkuemexiyu, bin |l\:r:S0\lrL=)oHh¢ mans alaltcan akabcusnd agailm lI\ewurk:vs' movemtnl. ThcrefusalolIIIKHDYMIHISICI Cmslon Dzflcm ID ckan mu m: nppex rank: or mepolicz rim nimm iimimim me c<)l\|ImIll)/ of Hi: alalr anrvzralus [mm Gucnrd Lu Mmcrrandnmuii mm11.: puiuimimiuiiy rim Imlgunz unagpimi hylht workrmgclusx Lnvani:uhr.wurke1mnm:L*arinJ\i:lry)s:v<:r:sm:daxmcksou (heir H‘/l7Ig3lilId'nrdK. Mnumy wanted so us: mu na—|imiaI‘ued firm ofkenaull lorslnbhsll avly norm on vtxtmll.Tm: cxtrcmt cwmbadvixy of 01¢ Renault warkcfl reumrd miin the abandanmrm or a pYoduclvVI|)’ clause by malmgtinrilland nlumalcly In lb! winning ofan agrccmznl wunll about noD:rOI:nl.TIu:W.!_sa rem] vlcxury wan \md:1 vrry uirnciiiicmiailions. iii Difllflulll’ lhc Ilrlllligfalll mike leaden Werexubilctedlo vimmisauniiaim racm flhllsc. Prim: minim Mn oy mysailed mm on mi cans: oi |hr )lfIkE Wu!) Khumeimixe agiltum. Ilnnrlg ma vmdnminamly Arab Morkloxu. ‘rm kgnaullworkcn. luvmg bmkm iiimiiyi mt pay iMId=Im:s. will sm 2nanaam [or mud group: of workers

The ablllly 0! mm mnhlhsnlion In Wm Donfitsslnni immme Bflvzr-nmem has also hcen iiiiimmi om mg issu= army.

ll. Despllelllzfzclxhai lhtbeflhad long umpiaigxizd form:can at ahnrliun (D bemn by semi secuniy. (Ill gomiiiimii Mfim allilflllnhud lo rizhrixt znd clrnczl prfixurti. In mmmerim rm: Btregovoy. me Mlnlsllf rm Social Anm, makeur the need is raped lhc lcelmgs of me rdigious. II wasncueuary 10 mm mm D‘ mousunis of xigumums my a pm.llun and I0 call a dnnonsxxnlion a! is,ooo Dmvlz :0 Ion: [haguvernmmx ID in1plem<nI me mom. um nmiiimum. mmmmW||llI\:I ms Funch working aim bz suocssful In naiiiiig

Page 10: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

InternationalFutures

Ih: Communisbled CGT ha along rccorfof conlmnmg social upheavak, notably in

May 1963

Yhe mom: largest muou confcdn-rmlmv, mu crm, ha:mu rnoruvmn an .aw.aa;.<m< mm /mu meawrcx, dcsrmnnzmum as 'm:ommeh<nuh|e'. nlmnugh Edmond Mam m.-

Lrur mm. w.u ulml reccnlly callmg far more ausrtralymcaxunzx. A: an: of Mmhcl Rucur4l': dose» asmrmu. Vlmrev onmznghluflhcSL>LaalmPar1! 1‘I\eml\erma|numIkdcr:rnan, Forccouvncrc, nmannghkmrv ufraghl I-ImgVca<l:rs)upand am comlvauvu)Although me recnm czrsmkts xndlcalcmax French wmkeruv:

AN uusu SOCIALIST auavu

nu 0I\'LV IN|:Ew:Nn£NT rokvmran nun: an 1'Hr Ikxsfl uzn

Gmlum has nude 2canummmn to m. .4.» »

xmuliq .mAl radxcd adeasm mam

u msxrx ncw Sm-mam:am "If Im a.. mumlxz Ryvurluvfinml

rd;-pan uulynj

a.. us (an! yum a7 Dlmhcmon

am m. “X uxucs have mcludwvmervvzww ‘M01 r¢rr<\rM.mv<« :3!

seven} am Lendemwxanalyst: aa ckuorak pcrfnrmanoc

ucmm an .,¢.a..,x.ay.wvuru an the xborxwn um:-‘

feruums an rcyvulvhcan Mum, puller

pm“. huvchxnfluav zommunvryhnhms W4 mush mm:

W

cm u 4s...a...,; lax . ye|r')(nK\ ...Stud a.. (Julian c.. ¢ smm.

prepared In gu beyond lhzarlcaden m ovvnslfionnu ma gnvcnrm:m, n I: un|\l<elv ma .3 naucnal fightback would rrnmxrllymkcmcfmm 01" dusmzalrnnlumncy '|hx:1:pIn\y bccuuscufam low lrvcl ul umamszmm m D-ram‘: am! we mung hold orthe Ivurcnuuavvc lsadenhvps, am also (Ive lrzduinmd {menumon davmons wnakcn am wurkang (km A shun stcx-aids‘mmemem n! the Bnmh aw: would be dxmcull Lo orgamsc. ar

only htcaust lazmryd¢\s:_g.\us are eleclcd on a Na ad: Mm

m un1. LS mzmfnrz m the (arm on pnimul mum: to Maucrrandmm uunmamaa mam come. am Iuocnmral an. Then wcm Lu

be thrcc yolrvltml aomtex am am. ms rcmh: (mm Ycfl‘ DI:Communm Parry and me ma.wm.; 0! me So mm pm,

wmle bmnd mnhxmalsens by me workmg class against thesv mu u- amamnap,a.m mkeu NEE!‘ this has mm m hemIrnrlslalcd mm a mm» or me rrvaluummry Ma Thururgumxuhom rcmaw qune wrong, hnrxlcaunuv mm: mm uh:working am as rcady xo luv: in uaaaaaunaa orgarusahons anLxrgx mambm yo join mes: oxgzlusalmm Th: mm for rgvolwnonavy Landadalet nu ma local ckvuons wax imylecuve. hm ax

.<e4m< mm many mm dcstnzd me Lradmorm pamrs nnly Innbxmm. a‘«:v<nhcluV, (ht rcvohmonary arganisauom. Dar.uwam, mg Rnolunonarv Cammunixl Luguc, an: playing ama! rolem lheprnkxv nnmaama clarnfiuamm man as ncocssaryJzgelmmz zhzmauvc In Social nc...o.m-, ma Sulimsm as mo. hum in mm

m Cnmnumlxl mu .\ \\nI1k:ly La hrznk mm ah: gmma,mm M

|\ \u:kcK1 mm a parlrmnznmnsl pcrsprcuvc willunMuch u hm no provaecl nl power rxcrpl In nfllancc vauh lhcSuunhst v.n,. were u, maybe undcrpnawre rm." IV: am. tourgmuw Lvmmmmn K1 xhz rnglmc. mm opymuunn was un,duubledlyhave :1 pmumnaay mama. charactcr. Whcrtax u .5mmuaal lo nun: the workmg mm in nvpmluun to 0m auucnlymtawrei M VIaumy- Ddors, the ca» would mus vlyelfna me«aamaam, mu. exclumng many ran). zmd hi: mahumi uflllcSomalvsl yam, who percewc all me dandy lhc bnnnncrmacnaxurc of me can

Th: um nurmkll} awn A) (la: ‘kl!’ mm... the smaammm is canes. Vm|2a\\|Y nrmonmhstic and mama mm themaauaag «am, i curmm um mpponcd «cry almck on theworkmg clam up Lu March ma u unlakew Va become a foamfor oppmnmn nuw. Ban at M have to mm {M pnmbaluy nfc\|xungc\|rrcIu: Wuhan me 5002!»: may forming lhc bans -7!

An cflccmt oppmalaon, w: cznnm vgnurc mc mu, am Lowma» rmhlamx who cuprlon am ymrl). hm XI) (hr poaacac. nfHy: \\/llmn V ( mlnyvxn gmcrllmcnl an Bmniu neam no

c1)<A.1lh<:zlzvzr uIm:\:|hm In the Labour Pam, H a: zeammum many 59 Av '53!) mm mm \o orgamxc asamsa lhckcadcrrmap of (hear my11.: mm am Iszxlzdtcxxwcmumenv an an lunar) raaamme Hench working d:|nw1Hhc[:\1l0 dtmuralvullnn and mm,M n w|H mam an nhernamg to ma |:ndcr\hu7s nf Maurrmnnland Marchans. n as to an.» my mm the rank ma nn 0! amCovnmumsa and Nncizlm Pumas mum mm (hear nuennon

Rdlennrria Rouxc.HMm-nwxlz Rougr Ixvmzh am: ('rnlnI4c(ornrnunm4,Ju|v19112 and]YDumnm, u \Inm1r.\K

a....< am. firmnrml Twin, aa mm am5 uL\.ma.m 2o D:c:nm¢r wszo mm,.a mm. mmama am7 Irucmumarml m.,~..m, ~ Pcbnurv ass:: Tnwwsh Ivlvmamm an Aivaca‘ M M... Luckham ... ah: R.-nowv/ A/ram» Pu/alvm/Eumomv. Na 2a, mu:9 lmermmowal a/..u,....m_ ~ a-mm amIn lh: I:mn,Z3 Mmh 1933

cmus mmum is ... It] in the Llbour a-my Youngsnmuam ....s . memhrr 1)! me /nlclrmlmrml zdilurill mm.

Page 11: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

eriflsh ‘Features

CND’S CRUCIAL YEARTONY SOUTHALL

The canlinuing success of CND and theGreenham Common women ... capturing (heublic imagination should ...). blind us ... the

crucial inadequacies ... the pcacc ....m...e...-sstrategy. Tony so...h..n argues ma. lhe

Campaign mus. ...... ... ...: labour movemem... ....d the deqslve forces (or. success

In lhepasl ...»... «o...yn.s.».m.m...c....c...).......;...»... lhc

...... D’ ....m.=... a.\h:|nc:lhcsm$\I: mos. ...;...nca... m(:ma—

...»... ...“ .....v........ or modcm Iviswry x. n undonbmhlyhc1cmgcn:aux,mcluL1n'L; .;;»...........s. Drmmnnic Pally .......... .. .... us. ,m..~.;.., church 9...... of all .1............Mom. prop]: wxlh .... om. paxim. m...a........ and ........;...mm .:ro.....s. ma revuluuonary .. lacks .... unflc man: ...a....;..a Them ... ...... wha mac!) call for a ram 0.. me...»=............ ... further mp»... ... who ... nppnwd ... rm,...“... ncw mm, ...: (...... ... r..a:..., mhrrs M... 1...... ....mamaum ...... Deva .....x.s amnvnmn-mcm:$u|gCnklWm ............ and mos: mm 1...... (... ....m.......o...: ......m. ......-...a—mam by ...¢...».. xmvcnahsm. Eclwzrn ...‘... [hurt .5 .0 ..‘om—

...... pu|1m:a|m\a.lv\\>. m the mmrc mo»:m:m .5 ......ea ... .1

Shared cnnvilion .... ... .... .939, lb: mm. or nuslcar ‘an! .:gravcr ...... k’\/CL ncncnnalmg ... urgrm yxclmml m......;.

11.: ...o......... hisnmyex ...... anydemsunvxcmrvxhmugha m.v.ev.».sa1.:r.v.:nynmhsks‘ wardn»= a... .. .... lnrccd ...c.9... ... ...: mm «.... ...... mu... pnmnl gum. and .. also :x¢r—ciscs a oonunnnus Ic5Lrwm| on r..m.:. esczlalian of .... .......... ....p........ u my have um plak ... .... my ;.m...,menu ...”... ...... arzzumenn when: m. ycars .... Reaganand >......... wcrefuflofmzfinvmmrm\.GcorgcBu<h'xL1|cVlmp to Enron: ... .95; ma ...: cemral ..b..c..y.- ..ra........g lhc...n..¢..¢e of .>.: pezx mrwcmam ..y nru‘/mg .... w...-. aupvoran srrmumess «Dun. ..c................

CND has assemblcd (h: mml signmcan. andsizzable mass singl:-issue campaign sinc: the

su ffragelles

.. I953 .. mxggeralvun ... §aylh.~4l\I¢fen|1nglMs............ MCI! .... furi|1w¢na|Isn\ a.................._... ...... ... .......... .....a ... ....po.e .... am... .... ...‘ uorlung .1... a... ......... c.......,g.y 2 .....s.......a. ......., r... the ll'lE1VCFl\crIl.A\ICH

mm...-........ ......Lm.................c.................gm. 2 ........d a.....- of ...:.z..... .........a...¢.., would 0...me load my ..........g back .... .... dnv: ........g...,... r........ ..would .... ...... ...... ...... ..- 1...... mmxary iniuvenrmns......a .. .............,.......... .=............. .. z-...... Am...“ ..zlvewhcrn

.. .. clrar ...... in .... 9... ...” year‘ m cm; .. En .. ....uascmblzd ...: ...... xigmfinanx ...... «...... ...... ...... ....campa smc: .... Snflragenu ... ........=.......:.. ...»... 2.......n....... .... .......;..a..y ............... .. 1.... .... yém, ......».........1..a.......>m .>.:.......,..., .,........, .. Engluud, wuVd

.... .... ... axscmhfing 250.000 ...”... ... nrmesl .. n........“...... ...-mym...............,......a..c. ..........V......y cvcry ...... .... vvlhgc ....o..... .............;........... ........= ...a znngy ... .... ......=...:... u... :2. .....y.:....s u... a.’rnctcd by older, uubluhad vohucal ...m.......,. 1. makes a

thoroughly .....-.....=..o..., cm. .. limes cm... ....m...-..,that nonclhrlsxx ...a.........; .. ..~ my ovlmuuun ... .... ......

Th: rim we ... cxn.. is vflunblc ... camp... (‘Nm xecond ...-... ...... .... ¢x—

vcrinwcsorzs year: .... ... .... .... ass.» a... .....y<...¢... WIsolaxcd mlemauonally Onlyin 1...... ...; ...:.u..y......g......,panhle Today we smm nlollgwk‘ ......... .....y......... ... V .mally zvery wnncm u...» — ...... ... ...»... me ... uwcmhlc.x....m... m.....»..r.~... ...... r».=sc..m. nmssdemomxmImv|>... Eumvc Bonn. Anmlerdmn, n.....¢, ram, Landon, _... ............ mu ;..o..ac.. ...: cleaveu picmreol mu .. am ........ .e......«.1 a..:c.1y... oxlzafuurpnnulvicmrics. Reagan ma...¢..o.,.y refused m op<n any East/Wcsl ncsumumns .....n...: supposed wnbalancr ... nuclzar wcapons ma hem mjiuad........g.. .... deployment of cm: «.... Pershing ... Wc<1<mEumpc. 11.: mug... ...... Influence ...’ .... h........... .........m...:... rm... m... mop... .m;....y. mum... ivmzrmcdvam........m....m. ... 11......) um. Murcrwcnlly .. hascauwd ....closcsl .n..u.. .u.m.. ......“ .v.......».m rm... me .5... up-non mm R:agan'x ..w.. W... mum away rm... ....» mm ...»...... m..........a .... ..x.y.o...a..=....». .0 rrducz .... mm .... ,1..."... or o... u:n.om..a..m.

We .r.o...u nlw ...... .... <xu:mrd.nary ».g.....c....¢ ... ....‘Inez: movemem .. me us/\ Wm... aucrnlflnl . dcmunslrm...... ..¢....... ...... :1 .....n.... .. NITW mu ... <........¢. wxz, .. .\kruz um. :| big: pan ... .... .m...m .... mm m nrmmed ».,Dcmurmm. pu.....-......scekmg ... mm valmczl rzpxxm 5.......... ....a..:.... duo... .2... nehher me demomlraxnnn ..... ....masswc ml: .... ...: pm—fr:¢7e .~....:.am ... mcv: clccimmcouw be ...1..m........ Bum ...... gvnumc ..»..c...;... ..........ma: m....... an... us populanmu :|g:uml|hc1r ..m..........u<.:..z...... ..r .... arm: me 11.: ....» of pearl: ...y..x.¢.., .4:

d......c. from their l:aJ¢rs!\vp, W... ..... fzllow {maze cam—

vmgncrs. The xxslence 91.7.... 31...; ...“... (...... .... muralymrrm... palmcalc......y. ... Wm. ... ....c..... .. .... mo. Th:prmem world rzmmnn huchallmgcd .... mym lhzl ...p.........can 3...-....m... ........e...m..:.-......hvuIK5l:<m1:|rd... 1.... ...:promoted a sccpucislu about guv¢rnm:n|'< »..u...g..¢» ....gvm nhxlixy ... ......= Llcan on mmr gum“... yflzdgs, ..........g.... a.;.....a...:... ...... w....~.. .... ........1 .... ...... ....»........

Page 12: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

6.-msh features

Thc wctesx of mlonml znd znwnyulzlm levnhmoni m m:was and mus rm alw drmcd unpmnumnu mm. at m—

vulncmmlxly. Thc us xnu-warmuvnmrnlnlayod n vnnx mlcinme vlslory nr xhc NLF n. Somh Vlclnlm nnu Ihc mrmor) urum cnnunues to cxznzuz :1 conxlraml on Anuncnn gov¢rn—menu. |lh<lp6mexplmnv\7\» zven Rngan yroccedswgingerlym rm Drzxnu aucmr/(5 to crush ms Ocmml Amtnmu rn'ahI—non. Aural um arm; rcI5z:n[nr|hcL1LcnUSnnnmnvnnnavr\crv:x::d zmi—Sa\1:l Iuslcna was n. makc1{:z:1¢nu1m:rvm=vnilnanly ag,a.n,x Such momnons mu mm: In: rcv/:13: ha)hzppenrd mg cxtslenoe of: max anwwnv mmemrnl pm. 3brnkc on lurlncr ndvcnmres bonus: Rzagarl and nn allizs fear(my nughl drvclnp mi; nnnmncnvs pokil1c:lcm\suouxI\L$5.Tupul n nnwxy mcy rm mn xu\u—nu:|:xr lcclmg ma) b<I:umn::K—

phmly anu mpenansl.Our muvzmem um had znarhzr Imponzm efkcl Th:1m—

pcrinflsls hnpcd um um nuclearwupunx am wnuld nnmnms Sovm nlkrs lmm pmamng Snnpon forrcvolntnmls m the1mm WL1r\d Ccrlainlymcslahnulbnnzaucracy haaconxmucdIo dale mu and mm us lradmonal ¢y:—droPv7:r. mu m:cmergmc: of 2 miss movrmem 01 nnpnmannna 3:1: m meWcsl mcam mm mm n In; cxcuxc lur Ah: Annlmpov [mm mbuckle Lo Hus blackmul.

A Ihmd femur: ma: dusungmxhes our movtmem In meman az n: Mlunvely gmm pa! cal mammy and upzvvencc.There are many pzupl: in cm) for whom [his n their rm :K—

ptntqwz ofurglllwcd paliucx. hm lhccampmgn bom nalimlalvly and Iaufly hm: bmcfllod from m: panmpalvon or vclcrallsamna znrmpu m huuld hrum czmpzvgm .n on nan mun,yznn: [hr izmam Suhdarixy Campaign and me Ami .7.Lngucam 0|: mail pmmmcnlcmnpk-s cm) has mnunvvnamanypcopk who hr/rbuen lhmu§)nu:h n.mm=nx.. minyofme members or {at lefl organisations. n u mum Hmpo ital unammy max ha: mabled cm: to steer clear of Ikekmd at bmrr lnzlionalism mm nun me mavananl in me myman helwctn dirvn xcuoll and advocates nr nrzmnc gmuvmum, No pohxiav my mum urllolxhrd by «in: anl|—nuclear mmlanznx There n new man: ‘an um n mu B:a crucial lxcmr n. m fnrlllcnmins Cmerll Ehzclivn. Thal-cII:r'5 Ivwmmmnl of x-mnmnz, mic of mg few p¢X5cnaI||n;sIn mg Tory cnhinu. om: Defenoe Mmmry AlxhebaxnnnngofLheymr dearlymd zed nu nmsmnn: arm: government’:wnkexl kink,

,

1';

M29100.)

we

‘WWW

cm: Ind m. Ilhaur mornnunln is m III: hbour mmnmn um has had n. man pro—mnna =1‘1:c1.Durmrm<::nty:zrs n n nun umon nnspuznaconfer-rnac ulppavl rnnnnvnnnnsnn. Sumcnfm<1mv>lcunvIn-nng wanna: luv: hem zcmgved m muons not affilimed to maLabour Pany like NALGO, N an-yr; and lh: NUT (nnnousnthe posmon ofmc hucr ha: mu been ruzrscd by n small nm—

mmy). n n also Iluhccnblc ma! many umon: mm -nglu Mmgv.-nannnap», my muuuzcusmw and mass, luv: taken an:vIu—Bumh lin Tum nevny Pfixsnbxlilylhalmn bxggesl Iuuansml amt suppu gCND. mc AUEW, ma)/Jain the ranks Thcwpporl an an umnmmn Wumen'$ call for n wan|.:n'6 auanmnlnem day on 2: May from me urganlxnd an on mmemznl nnnnnnnv bmh Io (ht popularxuypvrl far the Gretnham PeaceCxnlv. as nnn it no me man: m mnnn lcnon agaum lhcmixxxlca nn. become al2gI!imal:vx:u=1m1d:the n.nnn..

in is ulopian to believa that appeals tocanscienc: can lead armament workers to

(en-ninat: may work

The iwmg m Ihz unxum Izflatxs cum; cmmlrywldtfluznce llwaxahowall lhcLugznussdcmcnslmliumbalwccnMn and 1932 may and HI: ground my me uvzrwllclmmg mus[or d1s:u1nnmrmmIn=Ky:al'VTL('2IId|,2bonr conirrnlcnmu n uncccssary xo sound zmuenfmuliun have Th:\nunnx'mppon rm CNDx)\1ynu muan:rcflucxL'd\nada1«lnd:s'com—mmnem La iu nnm. Th: yuhlxcallnn or pmdnsnnnamem nnhclcs m um: nun union ,o..n.a.\, n nm Sufficwnl. am anImus .n ma unmns slmuld b: may oollcimn. of me nu ma!nmon pohzy WEI: an n kmf: edgz mm] mcmbrrx arc mm mtheir xuppon my cum aims and iluuauvts

n is mtreforn dmurhxng nun cum vva\\onaH,v pm; in mmswrcnmlswark 1ImdeLh:un:om,as gwdzncedby lhc (nu ma:m:r:ly an: out u(CND‘5 zs mllumz wurkerx as zllouml nowork an Ilx: unvons Uhcrc .5 nu vnc allocated m xh: LzbaurPanyll and that in re» amcles m CND'3Joum:.\ Samlym laxlhvs mn year have been on m labour Pzny m m: muons n urquzlly mslurbing um CND‘s nakinnal Lmdznmnn cm1f:r¢nL:an 29.'anv:ry um hman:umdanccalmvly100(comp2I:dmy

mum um :00 2| Llbour cup '5 slmlhr cvzm mm we-ekx

Page 13: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

nononn I-urmermor:Ihtconterencewu Ian VromrtprvsziuauveWorsl on on n ono nononnnn no any onnn cm) mnf:1:n¢:'o mm’mumcm no me o Auguxn Day on Arman Non won men: muchdlficusown nnbonnn hovn no blnld cum nnflucncc ax nnno has: orxhc nmmns. All txperimc: nnnonn nnnon workplaw or ocnnnoo.nnooon bmnthn can onnnoon nzw member: mm zunvnny who an:non nononnonnny onoponoo no gm involved omen open!) onn on oonnvnny nno cm) ononno ongoonoo no In: onnonowonnnnnn vw.oo hnnnh nomnoononogas :| cmuxslenkly higheranzndzncean nu meetings noon the unnon branch nnnonn Facmrybranchu have been onnnnn mccecvlully in me Glasgow onon on

R0“: kaycn ono Varnwn Smpmuldusn Mu plmnu Ilnan an:rnmnny drpcndcm on mnhlxry cnmrzcu. A oonnmno. held Innyear Jonluly oy Finley cm) wnlh lh: nnnnnnn connnonn drew .stgnlficanl rank and File nuendannzs nnonnn lord workvlncu oooprvocmed o gcmd examplz on mo kind olgrimoouaclmly nnnon

non tum cum Euntnn papu nnnooonn nnno pnzclncnl anouonRollo Rnycc ono yon-now misc: lnrmcn Issue on cnlnczl mI—

parmnc: for oon (rad: umon wank Crrlam com :1 on.hc:v1l),ev¢n zxclusnvely, depcndem on mnlnlary uumracls nn

mm! com, non insuncz on the Mslzne ulbmzrmtdcpot, largtvmmhun on ::i»i|i:|n worka: arr dirccnkv zmynlnyed by thenuhlary Two flung nnnc nonoononn hrrz. nnnnn, en/My en,cuungtmuu nnonn Msnsunct Iluzds no be non on em) nowankers no produce mncrelr plan: non allernannvc productiveumpluylflrfll mr nnonn induxmcs an happened :|I LucasAtnuspac: snnoo onoon oon oono o oowonnnnn propaglndl n.nnnc

amonglhcwaxkcrsmvalvcd Bmscmndlyn nun’: nnnzpnalusnxno htlneve nnnn appelk no the comcncncc or good noon. or onInnmenn wonnnonn cm nnoo them, acung ananc, no lcrmulancnnnonn work _ o poxmun noon non been pun ronnono by soul:ocnnno Lamp mrmb<n. snnnnn MncL:nn:m, Szcluary on non

CPSA branch noon unnnaonno,nnony uf mc oznnnooo wonnnonn :).—planned Um oonnn on (he cnnononnnon Ax3Ins|Tnd-rmnnoonnnnnonwnf2r:nc¢las1y:>nr.No wa), hrxnd. ml] wewm non nnojonnnyon nonnn wankers no oooonsnnoo no Tndtnl nnnnnn wc oon nnnoonnon men: is o fizbk pnnssxbxiily ofalurnalive emplo;/mun. Andnnon bnnnnn wII| non oo won oy onononooonn workers alone. onlywhennhz1r7eY|ownI1de nnonoonsno ono mlficlrnllycnnunccd onIhccurr::nne3saTCND's mo, wnll they gtn nh: suppnn nooooono ooooon ma gm/:mmenl's mnlnury nrepamnmns. Ta noon 0(-mm om, miualive nnnnnn hzcom: the nnooony on lmdzIunum~L$ nnnnonngnonnnmt mavemtm mrnuglv vngovous ooonnonncamvmun

The lash onnnnnooo abuvrnrz onermlsalnd lnmc-nunsnmnngEm may Iepnsnu (hr onny way no mnwlndzleCND': nlvhnnmlhznninni, an-1|n)wnrIlo ourSid:I!\csLrnngzs|oIn)urpolzn—nnon aunts — mt nnly fame nrzpahle ofmounlmg no. onmn ac—nnon zgamst the Bomb wonnnn oon win).

to. moon ronynn 1h: n_.noonnn Pany cum oonnvnnnon oono noo 2 onovonnnopuhnizal erfecl Th: unnnon n-nnno nn Ocnoben I932 vnhtn 72 vtronnn ol m: mn[¢1:nc2 non: ban cnsl nnn favour on coonoonnnoxononnnnnon sn nnn mzm demands om» no twist. no ronnnnn.no Enluh nnnonoon weapon: ooynnonno; no nutlem lusts onBritish Kcrnmry or nn Ennush wntns nnnnn on onnn snpporun nonnninmnunsublne,wmonr1\1nnh¢Labour Fanny Wmkn mcvan mnjnmu on cnnnnnnnnnoncy Dimes vote connnnnmuy nonunllanzralum, Hm! orgznnzd hnks wnm ND arc nonnnonnn.Thar: wnc non immune: onny o hzndlnl on my hanrms on [he

mm March no Cnlmgow ono unly o qurlu on Scmland'§CLP: are a[fiLan:1l no cm: Above on m: pifly lczdcrship on

varliamznzaly ono rxgculivr ltvzls is firmly no no: nononononupmlcms oncnm

Thulew Calnvaixmnocnnnnnonn on no nooonnn puny ns nus»oooonn nonnnnn the ba ofme mannfesno. nn can SLn|| be changedooo certamuems prnonnsed ono omens downplaycd Ixnscuanon disannamznlnnonnnn 2 clnr mp boonnnnonos nnonn connoonnnosn. Nabod)/' any dmnbnwhy nrnnnvnoo mvbened n 15 ihavrvduel on dixcn nn invalving o Dnrlnalnznluly lzauenshlp or

‘Bn-nmln fienntun-eswhnch on};/Soul on nxono \|niL:t:-nlnns nndnnaiimial cxcznnwcmm anoo nwnx-senn by n manorny no non: pom

Th: new docnmunn lurns unIlIlzn.\\srn on no had nnnonnonnnls mpnxtinui ooonnon; nnon rhns vs nnscparabk nnonnmuflIL1Lu1J duannamrm '|’ru:, Comnosu: sn recvgumx nnnnon

‘Inulmcxal dnsannnuncm by Email! will b: o vnral mnlalivclndnng toward: mulnnlaztrxl onnnnnnnonnonn wormwme - That n5the posnnon on cm: noo. nn n, no nnnnnonon non uncmmu nonunambignmu nnnos M: n nushopcd wnnn 'hn:ak nhuk0gJaln' m—

lcmnilnnally.nnnn nnnnn ed by In: lam nnnon non onccnn zsyoonnafmc nnnononn onnon rate have imzrn non negolulnons Ind noznysngnnficanr hall nn Ix: cxcnlallan. annn anon 1: no nnonnnno coll-uasn no on now fl()ClAlI|:l1l'S\l\SISltvVC:|\I€!l ‘umlanzrzhsm andmuullmrnalisvn nnnnnn go nnono nn hand‘ onnn nnn kxvmn clans:nnnnnn. ‘all nnnnnoonnon bedunemonk, and rheww wedon nnnnnnbe dn.-siyuzd no assixn no lhe Klsk no wnnoo we no cnmminedxrcnnng onnnnm dlsarmamenl agmemxtnm wnh oLh:-r oonnnnnono ononnnonnnngcooomnnon wnlh oononn 'Thuuhe groundon nbo ooonnnnonn nn ugh: away )hn(l¢d no nmk: unilanrrnmalivas nnnono no and nnnnnnnonony nuoooo on (In: snnooono on theagrccmrms. ‘W: want no see [he Genzvn talks on mlrrmcdlzmwnoonn succeed‘. Bun whal nn Ahry nnoo-

On me criuczl qucslnon on the naonnnrn ‘Independent’ den¢r—

rem, lb: dncumem nn nnonn nn wnnn oon auccpl Tnidznn(wmelhing mt oonny hold: no common wnh HI: Aflnance) nn

wnnn huwcvcr nnnnnnonn Pularix _ n mmplere mnlmdnclinn noComposnnc 5n — onnn «Sc nlus on o bargnl ng onno no go: no

aonm. And supposz we (an'l hlrgaxn nn :nway7Then again on non names. ‘Labour’: wmmimlem no no

.slab|1:h o nmnluclear onnoooo policy . Hm mans nhc nnnooIIJII on any nmnn mldczr weapun: on Imus . .ona nh: removalononn =x lmg hascsand wclpmlx 2 But whzn :5 Lin: no non»pen” nn isnnvr-r.n:1de1n| (ItallhxsulausclxluflowedbylhzCIILVHAIInnonnn clause qnmcd above.

lhere is an incrcasing tendency among LabourParty members who are unilateralists Io play

down differmccs with the CampaignsDocument

Thu: document on bcen hauled oo o nnonnonny tzmncnlnalnanoflcfi ono nKh|xn nheymny no Lhewzkeofflarllngmnnnissuvnoooon - avccxcaledthznzraiavyuniryaronndwhich Labour.no wm menexn onocnnon. Non nnonyonoonny, Th: moomnnn, nownnnnnnoo o good deal more clearly no nn, noon woo special on 2Apnl, Looonnmnnmozomn. nn men on me ooonnnnonn-noonnnnnnn qulhficatlonxabouluming nn oooonoaoa nnnonuno nooonnn

thus: could znable Hzalay ono won '5 no nnnivo o coach andHowe: through any undzmihsncamnxilmznks lmhucnnlzxtiniscriliczl max cm: nnnooonnonsnnnnno Lobonnn Party go all onnn nonnooonn noon xononnnoon sn no no zmuely be Labour‘: oonnoynon this onoonnon. Looonnn cur: nos already nssued ounnnrnonnnnohe donc. no onnnnonnnon nononngn local oonnnoo msnsnmg noon menoonnnnnnonon nnono clelrly on mus.

Cnmyllgnllg lor conoonnonn snThrrl nn unfonunandy an nnonoonnnony nonnnonnnon tendencynonononn oony activists whn n enufy lhnnselves onululaxcralisls. nnonnnonno mt-mbcrs uf uoonnn cm), no playdown the Ilnffcrcnces with me new daculnml rnoy argue noonvn/[ml is ‘nnnnoonann nx no mn mo election. and any nnnnnnondchalznn seen on desunmv: sonno vcnvlz arsun noon an 14: an only gm2 Lobonnn guvernlntm denied, oonnnnnnnno no no cum: on Tni—

arm, nnnonn -nnnono new/slate o[playwn.l|b<cn:zted.W::h.1llbeoonono no nonnoonoob hlggrsupx nationally nndIm:mzuom.\|yon o result,

Xwu pulznmlly onnonnnoonzrmri are made on rim. nn :5Quit: moo no noy noon playing dawn Lheie annnoncnoon mennoy no winning nnnononnnon. In Lsllrcadymlnaurzd nnnon n-nonney.

Page 14: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

Bnnmsln fmnnn-asHallemey nnu Show are inking advnmag: on nnnn mood no

argue man nnn me (ma! mamlexm dlsarmamum nnonm mumlow down We ML nl’ prianlies, subnrdlnaltd no view: furecnrmmi rem/1| ThuIxnulanlvnsuh-nIIzanCoxnpnslle‘H ll15a5»el|—onLmv lahnuflvcllzncex m'wmnIngm:=Faclvm) Omyaprogramme nnnn pm: Jnnn Nol nonnn. up rnnnnnn mlhcr man ano». slflc Sonml connmn can Mn ceconnony, fur cm: mp.norler» m Hvr may no accepl this link nonna nm puIn\:.~4kl)ananmnnn noonnmnnn !l\2m1<<nI('.‘<|):|cxwi<x5. wean: non Wm(‘amvosne 5| becmu: W: nrgurd cnd|z<s|y nn rmrly and umonhunch m2¢nn1:5.:h|)aughmm\An» pm on. We won n nan»wally because \lD'smamvc growlh ovcrlhc pan mretyenrshm brouglu mo Inn: lo 01: forcfronl

Survey: xhnwxl that on or Ilvs qnmner or :1 nnnnnon mmnmrsmd nn Lumlun Ia»-n Vunennlyn m\non£ys:|w xhemseh/zcmLahouv nnnnnonnm and mu lus Mcrc auiu: nn vhe nanny Incaw no Sunmse lb: reason for nnn Labour in gnvcmmrm ha:ncvrr km! a single ono on n. ixmvlzd mvnnmmtnlstn vmcraandLlunnrlllamcm And mes: people 3:: man nnno mavlcouvnngMuund Cumpasnc sn V) dzwgned no make um n nnnn mmcam: In (In: muanon any hgxlmncy by Labour am mypantry about demanding mo xmpicmcmzsuonon Cnmposn: snwnn Micnnlc In from me mzuor v or m: movement

those of us in 1951 who got arrestednumerous ninnnos won a lot of from page space

and paid a1o| of finex, bm we achievedpreusely nothing

It nwnorlln umwmg mm: lasso“: nnonn a p-revlouickpcricnccorcND In moo mt Scarborough labour rnnny mlllcrcnccvmed, nnoann narmwly. non nnnnanennnnnnn Th: Rxghln led on thepany lcndcr Cnzmakell znd organimd by B\|| xonngm (mm

Back issues sull available!Suhjncu nu-Ag ng {mm Chiie. Ponuga|, Tron.sky‘: Manxzsnn. women’: lI|)zrnli(ma Ennnooonn.

munum, Poland. Labonn Yancy. Irdand.Nnnonm Fm: Europe and Ah: Legtnds or lungAnnnnnnn

Send n slamp Addramd tnvclnpc foraccmvlueIN ofvolumm available and pricca.Write to: Back issues, International. PO Bax50, Landon NI zxr

Shrcretary or me Calnpmgn non Dcmacranc sounnnnnn. cmrrpaignnd and mannruwctl mroughaul (Ive nnannv m revcnr H1:dcrismn. Mcamimc nnn Im|L\rrr:|Vnls vn me puny dvd HOIYHII5,

and mm «ndrr the Ieadershvp or \/Imhzcl i-um, mllneu no meHug ornwe 'Crox;mxnrP2d\eycnmprnmufl cooked nnn on DickFmsxrmn an: un \!m|vwnrkcn' leader. Walla Padky. [mscalled non anandanmg Bnlam'\ nndcvcndcnl dclcrrcnl nnuncgulxmianx xuwardx n European nuclcm fies muc nnnsoonn,prombc was flu: nnonnn. on Mluch anu—uII\lm:mKm (rad: umnnman. we noun no ~h11\ vhcnr pmiuam away [mm In: clearrm) whcv nnnnn v.a~ :‘veMuaV|) nvtnurned an me M: can«mm

Sum: 22 mm later om ¢I|ppor1:r( are ram: wilh nondmtmxlxr nnnnoannvnonand chmccs on the arm hand we havc(he I ahaur kid:-(ship buckpcnhlhng 7 bv a strange qmrk ofhmury nnn um: Michael Fool xx ah‘: no plan ll\= Lovnproumserrnonn crmr: Xugz. ()n Vhemhumnd CnV'Dacl1vx:uar:I:ss andlcsx mclmzd no plat: any rannn in H1: Lxbnur Pany as an noon,blcmcnnsolachvevnngour end: In men cnomnnn and Padlrylad acxlvlsls who hzd always been Acrphzzl nbmu nnn. pzny, no

mm nmnmackn an an Tlmuutnllaofun Mm had lake: aulmrdsno the wzke nl soanbononnnn lore them no and anon aursdvnmm building whul we masmkenly behaved was 2 mass alter’uauu: lupohma! acnnn — lhcmass 5nI—dawm oIm<(‘,ommurwt of Inn.

The mtlanuu mm m: 933K 2:: nnnnoannn cm) nsclnxnuam wnnnonn aonnn nncnmnnngn drawn no anmn acuon as lh:way no defzm lhz nussnles. Joan Ruddock nnu annnon K:‘nl':xuucmenlx suggal man uh: noannunsnnnna M bcudmg man my non.Fnm'sfudg1||g(oHhev<§IIzxwlldnvcmumvnvmzldlvecuon nnnn

wzshouid remenmm m( nononnor won Thaw ofus who galnmcthu nnmnod numcmu: mnrzs nnnonnm uvxl nnnonmnnona.

non 3 lm or Imnl vag< amt: and one n non or fines onn WQ

mchtcvml nnnoonany nothing By nnna cm] of mar my on enelgvand cn1hu:nmII>\\erz Issiyaxed‘ uur mmtmml W Aefinlcd

—nnn me nanny and on (he xuodsTlval is why u annonnn cm) nnooonnm dmnld cnlnpalgn fur

Cmnymsil: sn 1

crnam mm wnn he inrnzssms numbers on

acnon: of clul onooeanenoe by camyrmgncrs over me comingpcnud —:xpc:v.\Il)/Ifcruwe mlfiuleulcar vc. T>u¢hn.-<A nhhmenu ma us vmpormm on n, and I7: :0 big Ihzx no one wnu beanmnna Rm the argument flux n0n— em d\r(Cl nnonnon docsnon pmvm: a ynIilu'u/ Jlnzlzgv non wmmng dxsannamclu WIIY

nnn nanny any wmghl nnnmnn wzcan Jcvcloy n1\:{Taczw<figmxnthe Labour Pnrly

our general election campaign shauld call onVoters [0 assess candidaues according to

unilaleralism

)!H|5\l21:KrIEn|bal|Al\gfor Icuon on Cumvuxixc 51, Lanaonnn

(‘Nn call» nnnn cnnunumg Ah: rngnnn m the unnny far n onnnnn—mem no get on of .-no. ll Explains man mud» nonmnonrtsuln (rum n naoan-y oi llonrnuclnnr dcftnct wmle remmnmg nn

Ihz NATO Alhamx Hm blight underimndv on and last: noonnonnnnnnn no slrzss nnnan cvcnlhnllg must bc dune ‘m :ol—

lnburminn wuh aur al|n:s'.

um Ind me Cenunl Emnnnnnn nnuan usueoflnltmalwnalflclm lnhn vied mdelend meman or mderm\d:1u vac: Larldvdalrxnn mt ncxl mucuon shcsaw Hus dnreclcd an the Ruzm u! nnno Labour Pxrlv. -nnn n nmwzllvded 2: zuemrlxirlg no oonnnnn own no nnpnmn (on meLabnnr ran, _ hm)! arc dwmvc. onnn mm/:mem MVI but atvane: nn um and |nflu¢nuc by Londuningus own ilvdependemLampmgu lhal ><:k:. w\)||: non slandmg anmnc uundvtx, lamzk: mr: unan zvery Ezndmaie has to conlronl no vIu:lcAr

nnn A gund example or this came during me Hillhud ononaonnan Lann yzarwhcn wc nnoonnoa a: man) suppnrzars asany

Page 15: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

of me mam oonnnnonn nnannnen Our nnann mcncal mistake was nomgarnse nnnonaa lhulogan Val: non pom winch mabnzdzveryundxdzu no uy men nnooo Iar mac: —

nn onnnnn man nn sum:casts mcv nawnnnc best way no gm pcnuoubyhuungurnmcaann

Tndcnl’Our gcnznl zkcninn campmgn nnnonnna nan nnonn

nnnnanmnnnnn, naunng on yonm no asscss all candldmzs accor-ding no our pmgmmlne. A: a lead up no mc clccnnn and oon.fcrmcexhe Nauanak Councfl have rndoned nnnennnennon. Punt:canyon nnnn mggcoucnhas cmam vnnuen a< long as n nn nonseen nnnnony as gcflms a pmpzglnda vncnon nn could he mednnonn onoonnonnyeny so a mum on neonnnnnng D:-nplz mm aniv:umber: annn nnnnoonnnnnnn m‘CN|).

cm: annn Ihe mnTnnennnnennannonan mavemenvagailmuncle-Ir weapons pnxeuhcmost nnnoonnann nnnnonn no the wurldwldr plans or nnnoerannnnhx xuccesx on nannnnne n< onnnnnnn (vr nhc sxabxl ufmzu sysncmUnfnrmnnlclynnns K Yaw nnonn bung undemnnd nny mcm.11on—ny Dfllnllsh Marxmx. Tm. Enhsh Comm\mmP:u1:« whooe ma—

nonnny wvng aonnonesnonneennnnnonny n\'nnIuVImu||v<la\<l1neofthe Hrnad Dcmucralnc Alhanca — no: a lending influencc no

CND nnn polmcs mo in non just no deftml (‘ND an a onoann

annals mm: nonnnn gn onnn Ilse no ancnmmodnu: no an lh:mos|backward onennndnm on no Illves nnnnno rcal batkmz comesrnonn vh:CP ronnonnnonnnen no urengmm our work m nnne nnnnonn

and me Laoonnn pony.

Marx|sm does no| impress most CNDacli nsns whose main ponceonnon or n the

negative one nnonn Snclalisl Worker anon

Militant

There may oe fnmrc nnoyonoonnonnn which wnnn poscn onggenonoonnnn nnonn the CF, u some on nnne mans nnn Murxum roan,lak: |h:Bmad D¢mocrau:A||unccag3 on lh¢Tnr\r:q onno nnnn

parry po C2] lavcl mm we mnghx mm b: moo nodownplay mm: on our slogans In order no nnann 2 ‘hroad |Imly'Wm: nnnnn sup

'1'}: Socialisl wonnnenn Pzny, me higgcsl on nnno Enush canlrlx ongnonsnnnonn nnnneaoanysoeonnnoynonnnn nnnnnn mc wurk:r':suits an ink cupnulmy ohhe ynrzscm pohhcal .nnnnannoo nnnnnnn

nnne w king class hav: burn dzfulcd), annnn nnne Laoonnn ponynnnnan n irmlzvamj, man In an wrong. This neannn nn no newcm: c-xclusivcl) mmngiv nny nnonen noon; on Druzrwulz nnno

‘hmug: or nnno class’ nnn o oownnnnnn — nimdy no bu meswp. wnnneSoaalm Worktrg:-nzm||ygxvcs goat! cave-rug: no

In: nulman or ma arm: rat: and cm) < pmmx a.cnan<, ndoes non onnnnn noe movement _ onny nnnose xegmcnxx on nn manShow somrpmlmse on juimng us own oanny mz onnaonnnnnnand onnen manna Ilumde unformnalzly lend no dncrmlikMarxism The swnrn homig zmmde no the nnoooonnnnonn

wonneox Izunns that luv: hem such n pouluv: nennnnnnn of menosn yonn have ban negzlivr annn nnnnnnonnye,

Th: Mnlnmnt Tmdnnt) 15 unforlnulalelgl Lh: mas! wnddyknown sxamlzrd owe: u[Mnrxnm nnnnnnepan-ny kxammdcxsamizmnmm ofivs annnncne no omen xinglz Km: mas nmvemcnloyen the no xwnuy yelrx. we woe mun yonn aims; um MUnon beaz:h\:ved1.lu5S1d:o[SoL1:lIs Ihaxwx||an|yX1em:hx:vednnnnonnnnn meclucuon ora Labunlgnvemmcnl oonnnnnnnenn no ruennonnnno LII: zoo monopulks; mneicxe you are wasung yonnnnnnne lrymg no bnnld anylhms ouxsndeme parly—num:andjnuIus! TTn=L1rcl¢is sauarcd Tzk: n or lave an and abaveall dmflrxnccl u: no dc anynnnnng no blnld cm:

Tkusamdn vannculilnydisasxroushccauxcxlcommfromlhuend:'nEy havmg nnne neaoennnnnp onuno Looonn Party Youngsoonannnn In mmts the high: ovnonnnnnnny for ymrs no nnnino

0IcLPYSbyA)\rowIngiixcnngnnsmIoYouL\\CND.TodnLha1would nn nnnnn onnno no mflucnc: non: wrighl inxidz nnne nanny

‘Bnmsu FeaturesRngm nnw Mzrxum dues non nnnnnnm ma mnjnnl) on (‘ND

am!/Inc wnnosomain pcrtcminn onnn xx "1: ncgaxivc ono mannedbv (MSW? annn nnno Mllnam. hm I: n A onnnnonn non CN nnnnnnn,

oonnm nn lhn: wrly no orgjunvc llu: figlvl no Ixpkmclvl ourD0|1c1:>.nHS anoo mnnnnan than Mzrusxi mwde anno o mdn‘ (Inparlydoeverflhulg Duxxiblz no ononenn an akernznvehnz on an;xion nnan nn nnanny Incaud nn In: Hndlnom on Marxnsm.

snnonn o nanny I5 non nnpumhlz no cu‘/V2356 In need: no slannnonn a mcogmhon onnnnnonn wual {<m;:< an aciually noo nnnn

nnnnnnon For ennannono nnnene Is no qua on man me onoennnnnnwonnen nnaye made a vremzndmxi cum bmmn no the d:\e!a\-nrnnenn ano oxn-nonnon on ml rrmcc mnxcmcm rnnoin acuvmnhavcprugrlmcd rnonn nnnoranne Camps lmncrcamlgly Innnx noham. no new no lhc nnooean lor o women‘: any on aclnun non(hsarmaxnc-:\I on za may. no latter In: men ainneo no a lawn.degree an nnne Iahuur nnononmnn, inclndmg an appeal non inI—

duslrml anian on mg day no we and Labour rnnny ma non.oononnninnann noapay afAc1mn against me nmslks on Slkuguxt,x-xnnoonnnnnn pay. no Blkm unnon has mggmcd a mu.~mmI|n:aloppagton nnnan oay, winch whnl: hownrr Iokcmslnz. ncwrrnnnenaes htglm no llrnm m medxrecxmn onnnaen collacmne labournnoyennonn union.

Eu: YlC{1I|>Kn‘AlL1IIElV|S by cm: Iradens pmm nnne movemzmnn the uppomlc uneennonn Speaking nn Ghisnw befor: theannnon Sunday demonslraunu, cm: chmrpvxnn Joan nnno,dark, nnannnenncm: now had o mrk forcculbnwcm xnnnna anno

5000 prrpzrrd no. 'carrY onnn uncomforublz nnnn unD\c.:s.mIInk: Ind przparzd no nnn Ill: mk olhcmg arrested and nonnng nopxi:on' Inme Guardian nnnosonnennnyMamn Walker wrovc upan inltrwrw wnnnn nnooe Kenn undu mg ml: -moaning non mtPnhuc: or the n

ang nenannnu nnn cennoan meme wai nnnan dunk:cum bug pnhlic nmpzncl, prwarauom \u nnconoy onnnno anon

Tndnrm hue wzll m nnannn and omonnn resolve olmnglhusnng‘wz have no be ready rona long nnannn, n my lens nnnon IndocdFor us no sxnkc everzllhmg on m: ennnnnunon. on nnne ncxl chxrnon. on nnnn you on (he II:xl.m1 unnse or on Tndem would oea\1i5m\s(a.k:.' Pneonnmnonn, he said, nzzd no oe nnaoo non onneen

nnennon Igzmsl onnne-nflkdy deplnymcnl nnnanom finnlyone

on a slmng nno ynnone dnszrmzmem mwvcrnem nnnan n ‘mmnndn innpiancahle, flu:-nmned annn my. my hravc’

some CND Ieadcrs' statements suggest theyhave opted for pulling nonenliolcnl direc|

aclion above labour movuncnl action

snnenn suumewxsuggtu nnnan CND‘: lezdtrzmp nnann. apneano pm nnoa Iokm dine: ncuon an me bum: 3123:, onrclzaaung wnrk melzhmlrmavzmznl no Lhz wnngn wnnne 5>3 nnne nnnan nnmvxolau direct acuun was ovrrwhelmmglv ;n.,,,ponneo an a bznlral naono an nan vcar’: CNDcon!v:¥c1w:, n almzndovsed one onnonnnyonwonnnmutated on lhelxbonlrmovancnn,esptciahy nnne Hlmslmnl my acuon And nnnsunnonnnnn oo incvat naonn onen me onnnen nnnoonnnnneo mo vuy :||cc¢<ws Whmhmc cnceannann woman have fond nn encouraging naoonnn nnoya,mum union :5 an. exlenxmn nhhcir Dmusl.

Em nncnn lmdenciesIrcnsn nnenonnono. cm: Isavcry openand demucxauc onnnannauon and ma: mass supporl Ion onannna.nnenn infill growing. Thclaxk Iorsocxalnlsvn flmcomlllg man.{M n a Vila! out’ no czmpugn for a Labour govmumenl connemluzd tn nnnnnnnonononannnannennanennpnennoo nnn connoonnnesn,and no nnnnna every nnann an n uf nnne pucc mavrmem _ 2»may. x-nnonnnnnna nay, LheO5LnbcrInnr:h Ind wan — .33 noonno Consolndztt now‘ 5 nnwon wxmm nnne naoonnn nmvnncmnon nonomeo nnnonnnnnnan aennon HA In: only way no slop mtmissilrx am nschlcvr nnnsannnnnnenn

nanny sounuu. Wu . nn nnn. wnrku in-one c.....n.n.. 1:!

mo no men. n. .. low xunuri ml soonn.n. Lnhullr CNII.

Page 16: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

1. 11.. 11.. 1.1. 1.1.11.1-..

CultureFRAGRANCE OF THE GUAVAGABRIEL cucu MARQUEZ

H15 epic novel 01.. 11.11.11.171 Year:afso1111u. :subl1:h:d 5.1.11.1

Gama Marquu as 1.. 1.... know.11.1111; mi. Amcrican novel 1

91...... 11... ....11.... .11.: with1.1. .111... work won 1.... 11.. Nobel

Pm: 1.1 1.1.1.1111: 111 19112. A1.1.11.1 or Fid:1 cassm. I1. 11.. 1....

. co.s..1..1. summrl-:1 of revolulwu1. 1.11.. A11... mos. ....11111 .1

11.. s....1..1.1.. 1. Nxcaxzgua 1.11... em... 11... a 1.... book .1

1...;....- .11. .1 3.1.5.1.... .111.

11. 1.11.1.-1.1.x... .11.: oompau-ioxColombian. P in Apulcyo

Mendoza, he talks of me mexllillflof his work and (II: basis DI

w... .1... ..11 ....111. .1. ..1.. y... .11....1. .1...o.. 11...... 1.... .1 s.u1..1.:1 1...... 1. 1.. . 11.. .1 ..1.1...11.. 1.

.11.... .11 11.. ....=.1..... .11.... 1.. 11.11...... 1.. 1. s... 1... 1. . .1111...

111...... 1... 1.11.11. .11. .11.1ar..1111.11.1.11 .1 .11. 1...... 1... 1. .1. 1....11.,.111........1. .1. .11. 1. 1.... .111.1.1y

1...... .1 .11. ....11.1 .1 1.. .111.1....1 1.1.1..

.. VW 11..., .1. 1.... 1. .1.1.e.1.ry n.1.... .111 . .1... .1. .1. ...11.. . 1..........1.. .1. ....1..a... 111. 111..., .1.1...... 1...... .1 11.. .111. 1.... .11.11.... 1.... 1.11.1 .1..1..11.1. ..1.m 1...11111.... ...1 111......

1.1. 11. .1... .11.... n1. 1.... ..1.. .1...1.1.1 1....11.11..

1-1.... 1.... 1. .1... .1...11..11...11111.y.1....1.11. w...11...e1111.11..1...1.111............11.... 1... 1.1.11.1 1.1.1 1. 1. .1»... 1...1.1.1.. .11 .

11.. .1.1.1...11. .1... .14.... ~..1...1u11..1-1111 .1. 1.. ...111..11.... .. ...1111...... .......1.1.-_. ....-11..11..11.1. .1...111.. a... 111.41.. y..1..ys.11.1... .

111 .111.11., 1.11 .. .:....1. 1...... 11.... .1. ..11111 .1... .1.-.1..1..1s 111211 1. .....r..,...11.1.... .1. 11.1...o.1.1.111y.1......1.111c1... ..a 11.1 1... . 1.1.11. 1.... .111.1.4»...

1 1.....1..1 1.1 ...1....., ... .1111. .1.11.111. 11.1. 15...... .1. 11...»... 1.11.-1». pay»... o/0...... v.11./111.13.

11211119111

11. ....1 .1... 1.. 11.1.... 11.. .1. .111..1..11..1... — 5...... — 1.1.. .11. ...11.1.1..1... .111.1..1.1. 1. 1-... 111.11.. .1... 111..

111...... 1.. .11.. 11.1......1 .11 11.. .....«.1.1.... ... 1>..1.11...1.1.1.. 5...... 1. 11...1.1.1.1. 1.11.1.1... 1....1.111.1...1.11111.1111..

.1. 1. 1.1.1.1. .. . 1.111.... .111, .1. 1.111.

.1... 1... .11.... 1. ..11

mm. 1111...... .1....1.... .11, 1 o. 11....11.. ....11. 111-3 1.... 11... . .11.... .o«1....11.1 .1 1... 1111.1... ....1..... 11.1.1.11... .... .41 11.1 .11. 11.11 .1.1. n.....11.2. 1...». 1. .. .........1 1.11. 1......1.1.1.1

1... 1 .11.... 1. 1.... .....1... 1.2.1.1. 1..1.. 1.1.. up .1 11...... 1...... ..11svn1..1.. .1... 111.1... 11.. ......a.11....1 1. .1....1... 1.1 ....... w. 1... 11.111. 1.... .1..11.... 1.1 ..c...1,.1... w... .1. 1...... .1111..,1..1...ay1.111.......1m1111..........1.11. 1...... .....--y ..-.1... 1.1.1.». 1...1.1.... 1.11 11.1 1311...... .1 c.1...1»....1....1........a11. 1111..-.1... ..1.m—. 1......11...... 1.11 ..-1.1. 1. 1. ......a... .1 11.1

.... 1» 1»... 111.11.... 111. 11... 1...1.-.».1..1. 1. 11.. 1..., 1: 11. (.11.... 11.:

.1...1.. ....11. 1.». 1.... 1... 111.1... 1.1.. 11..1.11111... w... 1

.. w...-. .1. ....1. ..........1...1......1..1.....c.1....1..1..1.... 111 1.. .11.... 1 -1.1.1 1.... ....11..n..,.1111.11111 .111. 1.1......11..111..11..1.a11.11.11.... 1.1. .11.1.1....111111

.. 11.... 11.. Q: 1.1.1.: ..1..1.... .. 11.1.11... m. on... 111.11.

uarunm 111.11 .1. .u1 .1 ma. 1... ..1av111 11.11.11 .11.... 1. 1.... .1...1. One 1.1.1.1.. 1.... ./s1.1.=.1.., .1. .1c.1.11.1 1.1.1.1.. 111......» 1...... .1.-.. 11..., ~w11.1.....1. ..

1. 11... .11 .11..11.... 1.11..1.111. ..r...u1. .1.1 .1 11.1.11:.1... .. 1.... .11. 11.1.... .1... 11.... 1.1..1.11.1..1.v.. .1... .1. 1. 1... 1. .1... .1.

-

1... 1.. ....1...._ ‘Al .1. 1... 1...-11 1.111.1.... .1...-v11. .11. 11.... a..1.1.. 1. .1111.1.1....»

1... ...1..1. 11.1. .... .1. -1.1 ,~... 1111......1.1.1. 1... a1...1.....s 11...1.11.. 1. 1. r...,...11.. . .-,.1.1.1.1 11. 1.1 1.1.. .c.....,...1.. .. u1....1.............. 1... 1.11..

. 1.. 1.... 1.11.. .11».-1u.~1.........1.11. 1111111. .1.111.......1...11.. 1.111.1... 11.. ..... . w.1 1u...1111..1.1.... .1...... -.11..1...1 1.1.111.‘

11.1.......1.11 1.1.... 1. ,..-1 1...... 1...1.1.. ..1....1...11.....1.1....1. .11. 1.11.1 .. .c.....1.1..., 1.1 .11..1..1..111..-.1.11.1 .1.1 1...... M1 12.1.11... 1.... ......111 ..11..1.... 11.. .. 1.... 1.111 ......,., 1...... .11.11.. 1.. 1.... 1.1.1 .11.... 1

.1. 1.1111. 1..1...... ..1.1. 1.. .11. 11.11.11.1111...... .111. 1... ....1 ..1 11.1 11...111.1....1.. .1....1... waxed .11.... 11. c..1...1....1.,....-.1..... 1.. .1..a1..1.1 11.. 1.1.1 1....11.... 11. 1.1.1.1. .1 .1. 11.... 11......11.1.11... 1.1.... 1.1...1.....11. 1.11....1.11.. s. 1... .. my 1.1.111 1111...... 1..1...... 1.1.1.1.. .111... 11.. 1......

.11.1.11.. .1. ...1111.1... ..1.1.1

1:. ... ......1... 1.1.... ... .11.. 1... 1.1..,~... 11..1..11.1..1.....z

1.. 111,. ............1..11. z1....11.. 1. .1.1.11.11...1.11..1.1....11...111111.v1.11.1.1111.1...1........1......11.....11.1.11-1......11 1111.1... u.p..11.11..1..1.1.111..1.11 .11.111.111.. 11. .11.... 1...... ...1. 1... 11.

.1... .1 1.1.1.... ........1.1. .1...11... 11. .11...1..1. 1...... ..1.1.11...1 ..1.1.1.. 1.11.1111. ..a11.11...11 1...1......1.11.11 .1. 1.... 11. .1...1..111... w...1 1.1.

11.11.. 1...... 11. 1.1.1.. 1.1.... 1.1.1 .1...1.1111 ..1.1...11..1 1.... 1.... ......1...1. .......12.... 011. -1.. 11.. 1.... ..w1.1...1 1...1...11.1..1......11... .1 1.11.1, .1. 11.. 1.1...1. .1... 111.111.111.13 ...111..1:... 1.1.1.1.. 111

.....1....n1a.......1.1....11.1.c...1..1....11-.1.»1 1.1.1.... .....»11 1.1.1»... 111.. 1.1.. 1.........1 .1111 ..111.1.1...11.....1.. 1.......1.1.1... 1... ..........1.11..11.1..1 .1...1..1..1111..1 :1... .11.. 1111 1.1.1.111... .111..1. c111.1.1..1... 1... 1.. 1.... .1. .111dawns 111.... .1... 1... .. 1.....11...1...111...«m111..1..1.111.....11.11..1.1.1.-1111., 111... .....a1.......11.1... . 1. .11..1.1.1.. ......1.1.1. ...1...11.....11..11......111. 1..1.1111..1.111.

1... 1... 1 11111.11... .m.... 1... «.11........11.1. 11.1. 1.11, 1. 11.11..1.1.. 1......1.... 1...... .11 1.1. .. ....11..., .1 1...1.. 1.. .11. 1.. .1. n .1. .11. 1.. 1.1..1». 1.11 .1...1..1..:1. .....11...1.. p.111... .1..s..1.. ...—1.1..1y111.1 1111.1 1...... 1

..1 1111 .1......1.11. .11

.11. 11...1....... ..11.111..1. . 1.1.1.111.

...1..1.1.11..1...1....1... 1~1....11.1..11...1.1.1.11 .111 1.1.1.1.....1... M1... y..1.1.1..— 11... 1111...... ..11 .1 ..,v1.1....1..1.. .19.11....111......1111..1..1...1:11....11:1=...........1..... 1. .11.. .....1.1 ..11.1..1.1...1.n1..111

11.1.11... .1....... ........11.1., 11.... ........11.11.1..1..1...111.1.1...11.1.... .. 1.. .1. ..1.11.. .1 1.1, .....1...WDYK) 11111.1 .11. ..1. 1. ....1.1 ...1.... .1..1... 11.... ..1-1... 111 c.1.....1. 1 1.......-1.11.4 ....11. ..1. 111.11. 1..1.,1111.1..1 ...1...... .1 .11. M11... .1 .1. .....111.1.11 .1... 1. .. 1.. 1.... .1 11.... .11.....1... .11. .1.....1.1.... .1 .1. 1111.. 5.1.. 1....1.... 1.. .1 .1. Umlzd 5.1.. 11....1.1.111111...11.11.1 111... ....1...1... 1...... 1.4.1.1..1.11.1....1....,.....1.......1..1....111...,.1... .11..1..111 .1111.1..111....11 p.1111..1 .1.11.11....1 ....111.11....11 .1... 1.1.1.... .1...1111 1... .11..

... .1... .. 1.. 11.1.1. .1 .1. ....11..male‘ n........11.1.

11.......11.1.1.1....111........1..11u..111.r..1.1..> n.1......1.. wcre 1... 11..11.1111..111

....1.1.. .......1.111.1....1.. .1 .1... 1.11....

.. .1. W111. 1... .., W1... .11. $)’ixKlfl

.11. 1... ....1.... 11.. .....-.~1. ..1.....1..1.p-....1111. 1. “.1. ....1.....1.... ..1.1.1.11._

Page 17: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

c]....... c...g.. .v..n.-...mm (mm .... .....ag as ...: Suvm Unmn...m..... drrsvnmg umm3|uIa|.v<...g. Cour......... Puma whey: mg Ihougm .... ... ....(mac mg Suvm ...»... ... “...... Whrrr .. .1...

..o. ...

.... ...g .. .. .......... .. .... 5...“. g..Iltllcnns _ .... .1... .. ng... ...... ..gCuhl:nlw>.|(lnKy.\'nIIllII1I n......¢......g:...... ...“... cw... c............. Pmy ...»:-....n.. .... ...... .. ... ............,.. .. mg......-...... no y... .n..... .. mag .... .........g....... om. .... mg... ....u--... ....g.......»nn..._-...;-... .¢.....u..g.z. ...... .... dmznxwn .. mg l'1en>a ...........»..g(. ....gv.....,..gx.... ...........gw:.wc'd hi»: ...... .... n.mg............w.... out.. ......g ...g., .... .... ...g..g.a. 7 mu...».g.............-., .....x....... mg, .... ... .. —.... .... d»g......... nnh: day ...... .g ...». ony.-... wna. . ma, .. ...... .g...:...w. wax w..."... ....sg...g .ag g........., .....g..... ...gzvoiuwm of .... cu... vmcssx ...»... ...:czt<[u.\|y mg . mu .... am; ...an.....g....g .. mm... M: v.zw .5 ..............sh .... xgm.....o.. ...... . mffind. ...:.....g.....g. go....a.g...y .».....sg my .... ...... stormy uphaulx, .. ml] ...... .... ....».ng.. of . wcixl gm... ....g.. 5 mgag.n.>a...... .....g......... ......g,.....g. .. ....wasug .... um! Ibo mg .......=...».gum...».... .... «...... u cu... ...... .... Sovlu

,...g... u . ......s.. 4...».-... ...u.....g....¢ .g........-. .mg.........g.........g.a . ...... wmnvy ...gu........gggr

. . .... .......... m. .... ..-...u............. ...“ «...... ..g.....g....g ......» ... .... ..nu... ... .g...g.g .»g.g .. .. .. .. .... 5......u........v Ann‘! .... ...... .......c

.... p...u¢... ...... ....s......m.. .I':;-om. ordrmnur: .... ,.... {mm .... ...g....<g umCub:iuSvv.:xsu:lIn:md|dom1( ..¢..<m..3. . m......... ....c....... .zmI....n.....»mg..... . male ... ......x..:. ... Many van......u .. mg .......... .... ...g......g..g..g.....nfmc ......“ Suws, w... w... .... ....g.... .....g......g~.x.g... o...m.....g.......g.y.....gs.... mg now. won. 11»: .. .... mg ...... ....... Sovm Umon. mm... mm): .»....m.w....g.g. ... ........g. ...g ....u may ... ....mm... .n.......... ma... .... gg... myw...1g mu... .m.g.;, mg g......... .. n...g... only be Mm .. ...... ... . 5.... ..g...g-gg...yw....... fonts ...... mg. d:l:nsIvt.y ...: .....m. ...g.. m...... hmancal.wv.-:......... .... g......... g..».m of ....¢.g...w..g.. .... mummy. .g......; .. normal manfllscusn .. as...

man cm... -mm Suva ....g..g..-.. ..c.gga........... - mum... ....... ......»Iiuull ......g.. wuI.>od.|aa..1 .... mg.-

......“ ...»... .:..x.........g...¢...a would

... .... .....g...... xhuuld mg .....g..........

Culhn.am: .... .... dlflerenoz berwx-an my Pm..m.. .... mg. Ln...-3 (we .a....-. 3g rm ...=.m..g...y......;......... ..g ...... uvJu:uh/-.... Sana ....gm....... .... . never ........m..., ... In-Iyn. ..g .....4g .. .... ...ggg..

.. u.g ....g..... .......g.. .. mg People.‘.>=....... .... mud) mar: g....... a...fulnbflllmzlllhconrirvIld¢InlV1:avl.(\cSW:w.¢....................n...g....g.. ......g..g.mg r......g ... Lulu Ammc: .\ .... .... .......... bc mm 9... .. u....y..y. 2...... ..cg.gm.g........ .... .. ...... Amznu .3...r. ...... .......n. g... .3 . European umum, ...a com: .. ....

hurl‘ ... ...g...g....mu... .. .... obsesmm .......... cu....g. ...g.............g u...-44......gun... y... r......:...... ...... m... w.... ........g..gg......n.—....-.... .«....u... ‘no..... ng. .... -g. .... .... ...... .... ......,............ .... .... ...gg .... ...gg......... ......a.3.... ...... mg. cm... ...... ......»Vmmmre. .1 .... ...... ...“... ...... ........x . wnrzworhng .... Yum: ......... ... Isa:x... m nzver .... we ...: ....g».. .. ................c. .... WFUV ... bucmnc .. r....a... wnlrr.... ..g ... ...g hepknmm ........g.... ... ....WUVN, WK ...g. scvcul .... .... ...... .. ......... ......... mpez. ...»: xoodmll. . nzwsr .......... mull ng mun‘ ... mg .e..............m.v»....<.. an’. n. Hnwtvu. .. .... vrry g...y...... nVm.:nmm' .2»... ... .YE:YSI[D.71eum ...... ... «... ...... .. ...». .gg...gg ..-...........r.gg.. .......... .................=... .........a mu, ......-.n. .. was ..a...»-. ..4. ... ..g 1...... .... .... harm: ...: ...... .

....g..ea ma. ... ....g.. ..e ......... uf .g,«...... ma... ...... xumtflulll ...»... butw....,.. Inexamc.....e.wa:xaad¥..:nn.r:.

g..g..... .~..g..g.....n.g........g...m..<.g. ...mm .... ngva vud ...... ... ....., ......x ......g..m.a.a...m»..«..-...........g...

on one ocuasxon casm. told me.with a him at ...:1a..c..oIy. ‘V.'heu

rm nex. .ga...:m.a.g.1. 1 m... X.) b:a w.-.:=.'

n... mg... . dncovevcd what m we...value — .... rag. Culre .g . .g...g.....g... g., .... .. .7... Road ...¢.......c «mm ..new. .... .... ..g.< . iumnnxcunmyzurof.., kzvm ....ag. ...g mot. a.m..... ...,c............. hchasl lnadbnuk ...... ...... «...

.. .......m.u.:........¢....w..g..m...a..x...,...n.,...........m........g. Mg...5... .... nu... .. ...... ...g n... 5.... newzlynuy rcld .. .«g..;......gm...._....a..m.g...g.........n..a,.:........s.gx....s.....mu.........g .. ......gw..m y.><.'d1:mexvec. ......mg. ...». rad mg r... .1 . :»..».....g«5...... ...g....g..my hawlnm ...... ...g.....x’du.\mmedIl.cs|2:cdu(lY.:Du1I.r.wmcl\y...: .... u.g.....g....m.mum .... bewhau5.... ..g was ...... Sn helm: Dlllilxshmlc.......a. an pg... .r..g.....s. ...... ...... mg.........g..p. 2...: he Izulmaa a... . mgux. ....... w.r.g........ .. ...g........... ..ng. You .2....g rgen... u... .4 .c.... ....< ...; wand cl..........¢,.......g.gg.s.....g.....,....a.......ggmys mm... {mm -.... .... um. :4... .....; .w:rusml1y .......g.....g ......g.. gm.“0.. g... wunmx ng ...... ..., ...... : ...... Mmxilnchul , -w..g.. |'m ..g.g. .g...gg.....ga,....... ... be: ......’

Page 18: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

Into-viuosSOCIALISTS AND THE FAMILY

LYNNE SEGAI. and MARY MHNTDSH

The decline of the family looms lag: in therhetoric of the right But ii has recently

me ed a a major area of snsoane anddiscussnon on the non as well. Nlnchélc Barnzlland Mary McIntosh‘: The /irntn-S0cin1lFn1rm'Iy

(Verso, 1982. £3.95) and Lynne ScgaI’scollection of essays Whan is /0 be done aboulthefamily? (Pcngum/Socnalnsl Socnety, 1933.

22 50) both lay down imponam challenges no

much nnodnnnonan socialisl and fcminisl Ihinking. Judith Arkwrighl and Valerie Coulzastalked to Lynne Scgal and Mary McIntosh

about lhenr books

LS: Whalulrn /Iedonc uboul nnno/annnny slam nnoan nna currem Tory zynyneal no snnsnnnnnonIn: rannnny and hnwvnrll nhns msnn wuh aoyonnnnann nnnsonons no mzke cutback; m w:I(nr¢ pro—

vman. nn annnnn nnnan nlnenl Iamnlyrhzmncns nnnno mom nnnn anattempt no mlnundnszllxsecnlbncks;on. n .no argucs zhzuheappeal no no Kinuly o nnonemekus n nmng on. bbcanse munananny mum w venymuch no on onns. Thns I: nnnynns impor-wnl no osann no conxrder nhz nannny and lb: dehaln ooonnn n onnnns Inn twenty yuan

Crnucnsms snannn no cmcrge nnnnnn nnanysonnnno, dunnz nnns

1960: 01 no xufling and nnwardalooknngcharaucr of m: sonKunpomry family. A crmrzl {Mus on oonosnn wae youngpcoplflsxcyecuon onnno fa y _ mnr llngm [mm nnsonnnnnosnnno lhc nno, am: the onnsnnns mry made on meir yaremx‘nnyos Mlssmg from nnoso cnuqocs by Lning and onnnons,

howtver, was any zrcmml on wmu:1\': some ononoa nonn

fruslmnnon nn nn. lzmnly n was onny wnlh me untruncc on :|new Yemmm criunnc In no nanos nnnan nno locus shnlned oa nonnno mixrry and nsolahan on nonnnonnoaoo nnonnsns on ma onehand and no onoansnns and (union: on women wno so on nowmk on nnns other. The bank onflhm: than: no mo rnsmngdebam around how We Iwc new no how nnnn noons an: Inn nn

many’; Runilines, looking nn pamm r n nnn. nnnanon onzmldrm. nnnoooaaoonnons belwezn nnnnsano work. sxane pnovn—

non on pump}: with onooannnonns, no how Vexualnly, =3-pcuallynon wumtn, ns qunle rngndly conuallcd by on ideas on nannnnynnno

Flufly, n um no mmk annonn anon osoonnnoonnideas on (In:famnlyami now wenughuu hveandcam ooonnnoon oum non.Ihe rezluy on haw wt ans annually livmg wday and what noneed: reallyarz. And I; soon as yon dn mi: nnno firsn [hung nnnan

hemmzx snoan ns nnnan anon people ooonn lnve nn rnnitimn!nuclcnr Iamflics. 11cc wlleclion ufcssayslhnl n haVe15s:mh|rdand nxnly wrnuen auempu no noooyon how no arcacnmlly Inv—

mg and whm son: on changes wad make in w( II: no me“prank‘: (:11 nuds In nnno onnnonnonns wt fan-.

MM: nm Lynnfls, the book nnnan nnnonnens Ind n wnnno no ad-anosmn no a mcmlssr as wen an a nsnnnnsn readerxhip, Irymg nodraw on :| nnaonnnon — on vznous noon. non< — on iounlnsl

nnnnnnns annonn n.nno rannnn an we“ no mart recen-nn nnnnnnnsn onnnn

Runon on me mung: (hat ws pnckzd no on non me socnalnsl

rradnnom was me unique oflhz nannnny as bring Dnvnmed, xu

revnsmnng nndmdualiwm and |3nv::1c|n|:rc.sLi.:.\ onnng can.xuuned dinkct zllv m nonanon no a oonnns Sphcrr dcvold onncnonnn nonannons us and ponsonnnnnnnsnasnsons snnnnccn no in:mm Mxm And (ht unvnrrauwtx oroonnnannsnn Vv'c.wzl|1\$Innl:maslcurunc nonnnn ooanonnsn nosnsny onnn illalhcrsouncxxa noonnna louml) nun hcwm: nnns plac: wnnsns persona‘ value and p:n—

sonan Inf: M: nnonononnoso and when an psnaooan sansfmtnmmare expecwd no in found and nosoonsnnannnnno, sxnaonosn no he.Pwplc ano non axoonnoon no kzl sooan resvonsnbnnly. nnsnvcsponsib 'ny non nnnonn own Kalnlhzs, social Me 1: nnnpoomsnooby all nnnan is supposed to happen me nannnny

W: (id that n onoonnoo nnns nnmns nnnan people wao 1W: nanoannnnss nnoy lzluafly in on I;-5:4 compamd no «no hug: on;pomon ofpeoplrwho do non, nnyonn lack msornal nnovnsnon

-Young p:ow|cs' nnonnos, ono osonanov nnoonns. even cduca nonan

imtinmnm _ann nnnnso arc nnnooyansnnsnnbeuusz nnnny am can-

indcrad second nnosn no no m the farmly: ono pcoplu’ homes, nononnnoono, are onwnys nnnongnnn on no onus Mm: you go nn nnno

nnnnnny fnuh. W: nssn Ihax social pnonnoon crmld he nnnon. naonondsoannc — nsnnsn, more (awarding, nnono truly Salish/ing nnno

nnnonan neoas —nnnnann is so Klme n a kmd ufpas\uv:com\u—snon no nnns book‘ nnnn nnns necesmy no dev:lupln||y:m:i2H‘nrmxns bownd no nnvolvezn rroslunofnhc Famxiyamlnnsmonooonna.nnon on mrmg

On lb: afl\n:1 handy nao nnanny cm be criuuved (or nonIulfillmg cvcn me necdsil danmsno nnson- mdzrdnzcan oo verydeslrucuvzto nu omnnnm. Fnrnn|I:\ ma mch pliune, enndosedsannsnssnnnnn Llnneycan onsnanonnzwaynnxepnnons nnnnonnnnonoreasons man ws sannso onnn book 7heArm-S0(':aIFn1mn/y.

ws alsu (aka up vannm onnsn slmndx on wcnamn nmdnsnnnnnsn nnnoonnnnn. One arm: Imrngs we Ernnhauw n {he nannn,ns .Inn insmmion nnnenoss. no lheaenw nnnan farms {hr nnasn onwhich nlmemanc: on mass ponnnoas (and. on: mighn and, anhtnlamr on unnlcny and so am n ononnssnn As nsnn as nno m-huiunc: afpmpurry. mark alwlhz nnhemance oldnsadvalrlazc non nnno wonnnny ciasx. nnsonan as my eflnczvnon polncy,non nnsnnnoo onnons farlulnn freedom of onnonoo m education.whnx nn ns onnonnnysny domg is no sonnnennnan lhnugh muannonalnnsnnnnnnnons M: mull pm!/nciam mry mdl nnlavznridefnmnlynnhenxanoe on advantage and dlsadvanlagc.

no book aka nnaxos a cmmuu onsonns wcml oononoo Idemannonnn nnns family Lhal nnayo nnnnn wmc vurrulnarnl) unmclc{1—xiv! ’a.\l) lntwurk ufChn;mDcr Lasah and lacquesDanz:lcIn;onnn_ no algucy aflcmpl nnononoos onnnn old pznrurchll nannnnynonnn whnch mty sllnm nnan bccome snosnoo and wzaktnrd,nnnnanonors nonno nn pamculzx,and nns way mun been Lakznno. nnsnnsnnos nnnn there is n dnngu on nnooon for an nannnny

from nnns Jen as wefl as m: nghx beczuscalmc idzulngy winchclaims (hi! me fzm ix nnnsonnnnoonooanulzyral manymnnfithat W: an an agrzcd ano gnnd caning non omen psopns, muuulnnooonn and no nonnn. nn mnonon. nn pinirular, an explncnllyId! pm-family nooay nas tnv\¢1g:d: am on onnn reason non

wnung on back ha: becn no nnmnnsnasmonnoooonnnghug.

nnn Inyourbook,Mary,ynusxrcs5d|:.v.r:nzIJIu(Lhcfa1I|flycncmy and nnno fan xhu n rzmams iwlru-nd)’ unsnnnnnsonnne.

yon, n ynno, on Lh: onnnon oaoo. soy no awe oryonnn exnyx nnnnn

ma family xx an ononnonnoo xmuxuuon: am! nnnns ms Enush Emsum: n nnos h:d1|3inm¢.Wha\|5|h: sun: on the rannny mdzy"

wnan you an pmnling m ns non so much zcunlradncucnhnwecn nnnnn nn wllm peuplrman bym: knnly Winn Mannyn\ nannnnoznhnu 5 nnnnnny ideology and urban n wnu mmnplung nodu was In nguish Lhzt ideolagy (mm now we Ir: actullly

Page 19: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

w .... Hvvul .... Mnry M.................g .. .5 when we ...». 0...... pE0pKEaEl|L1H)'1W€l|Yfllv.¢.(fly

..... Ma .00.. y ...». na£cKisI'vJ1¢r: ... many {am .yp.y and

...=....... s.........a... ..=..a ... 0... 0.0.0.. .0a..y lsaway ....... mt

..:a...0..«........y.11.e..x:.».0gy0....e.a.......,..0mc.,.s vary0...... alwzand .. .. .0..... ideology winch Thatcher xsappealmg...... ....” ...=.0..0. ... 00... ......v. ...a... ...... ..... 0... ....»-0.0. .... expmilxunn ... womrn 2.1 0...... am. .. W0.» ......wumcn ... ..... xrcn as ..s.u0.....a.0 .0. hnuscwurk andduldcarr. 0... ymopkmuslbe urcd .0. ... .... hum .and 50 ....

MM: . 00.... ugrez ...... ...=. 0... udmlogy ...... .0. Just ens!up ... ...: .... but rm a. .....;0....... relanonx ... ...-M 0.0........ ...-0... as yau 0.... .19....» my 020.... ..y. ...... —whatever .... ..0...0..0.a farms — ...c_ ...... ......-.1 .0 ....nuclear .......y 0. parents w r. ...... drpcndcnl .-..........,zvurymhug .... .. 0 pr:—vmrM:I5 mtg: ur .. .y0..r.»...=..... me,rvcryflung 0.y. .5 defin2d.nIcrm\nHhcf.anv.1y.

1... .. .. .,....¢....0......-.;..... ...=10..m.=...0 ..e........ ....s0..=..m.. 0..-...s...;. .... Iarrul)‘ .. ... mm rc............ M00... ......; hook ...y. nu! .. .. .... strongest 0.... .00.. ¢..a......g.........r...... ... 0... .....:.y and ...=.=.0.0 .... Tone: ...... .00.. .0 .. as0... 0. ...: 00...... my want .0 ......“ some 10.. Mrs,...»-.:y.., ..= .......y warned =00... muex ....= ...y¢....¢ ......wl..L*I.1).:y n.....: 0.. the r.......y.

.0. .~... .0. 5...: how wear: .......z ...c»...... .0... ....0.... as

...0 ........y .. changing .. ;. .......;..... ... ways 50...: 0. which]».=..0...0.....: mmeofxxhich0..-...=...o.a.:m. r..........<.. 0.... ...neome ...... fleprndrnb 0... ma... ..0. .... Sam: Lhmg aisaymg..'. ... ...... M... ......g.... Thllchrr szys .. u... ...e changesWm... ...... occuncd ... terms 0: mu... mvoroe rales, ...........sa..0.. orzboruon and .........y........y mg ..0. 00¢. ...woman‘: ....¢.u... w..., |dI5:|gnx: Thcse 0m..g.,-5, .0 .... 0..2... ma. Ihcy have oncnrrpd. have ...). .70.

lma-vmus

...: Lmdmonzl lalmly 0... (my my. bum .. .... uucruls ...0.0.0 vny mzny wumen yr... were mu ... 1914»: my unhappy2.... y.0..... mamxgcs 0 rwvcvuy .... .¢...0r.a.y...cm.....,ed by .......0... 1.... ‘......’ ... ...: hmilv .; 0... ... .......... «.0,pLN1d' ...“... .. wally rrprexzms an inrrcasc in .... .......-pe........e 0. u......... s... ... ......» ..'. ......) lmc ...... .. a.

woman ...00...-s ... ve .... .... ...... ...... ...: .. vciy hkcly ... ...llvmx a ...e which is ......e Impmcnshcd ...... .. man’s .ym..s=.... wage: ... lnwex ...... .... 0...: so 0...

vc. .. sremv ............ ..... no....... 0.000.. 0.. ...: family ...... .0... ph\Io5oph\c.~4L ... ..0...m.. .0500.“ .0 whit .....0005 ... r.y......... .... n0w.H y0.. compare »-«.... ...: »0...¢..',......0...u.. was 3: ...; .... year: a... about ...: .»u......... ...mm. ... ...: .......y and ... may and .... ........ ... ..y=.womenshould.0... ..m..m...:¢... .....0.. ...0.¢...=.c... e. o.,........y Fzmmlsm .5 3.... gmwlng ..... my. 000... ...: 00......... ....y.. w.... ...: .......y0. 0:00.55 ...». W00 don’. 1\:cr:ssar.¥ylive ... ...: ‘0.n0.a.' m.....y mum... w.... .10 you uy .0 ........-.3 ...... ...... ... .........y¢ rcarnnns .0 ...0 Tory ..m....y.2

MM: .......'. Khmk ... 0... use .. reaily .5 0... hack .3 my........ Iumlxal u\1|:|).\lr: 4......... mnahxumy... ...... ... relauon.0 Tory p0..c..<, ... facl, day-.ile .... kvelzuom 2...... .... r0.y‘Thml mw, r... ..... .0...0.y.... .«.m... 01...... .y..s...¢. ma:is a mherem ........1 uITha|Lhc1|:)lI u... .s mnczrum »..... ...:fnnuly . ......‘. ....... ...... 00...»; are .e...0.y 00..¢.=.... ...:lamilv is ... ......0..a... .y0.....a. arm: and my 2.: ..y )5; .00.5.. ... 0.. ... popularzppeal — mun ... .......a . :0. ..r.........»whose ...a...<,.....g .... zlcrwherc.

I ........ .... Dun 0...: c...........0.. .0. 0...‘... .c......... ....ms. is a ...c.... growing up. ...¢m.e..ow many .¢....n....»...0an .0 lungcr .. .... ...... 0. .m....g aatunsx ...e.. 00.. yum“:0... 0.0 ..y....; .0 dzvdop .he.x me: as .a....., 0m.. as .»a.¢....,and may.» have .0 .00.. after dependant vnrznxs ...... We are..... ...y0.y0a .... 00...... ... zxpmcnuc and ... ....y. had ...

Page 20: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

ucklr .3 won: 101 of Imlei.n flunk mu: n n changc nn whal wear: wnlmg ludaY

nbonn nnn Iannly, nnnn we hzwenox rrjeclzd omearfier nnnnynn-,rather wrhavc changed dnreelvon m mum ofwhal w: mmk wccan do nbmn n. MK: Nzvn, wx’ lug .n my bank, crnamlycnxical ol me vohmlnnxm 01‘ me eariy wnnnnnvn mavemenl mlhmkins we wnnnu yet up our nnn nlxeruanve lmuschmds n

lhvnk wt war: my nnnnmmn ny nnn lxlxnznzn pa xcs of (h:|961}swmchw:r<v:ry1n(i Lne. lfwcsexnvllmwr mannannnngn, we wanlzd nut nnly Io mruml mun bnl |n bypass W:

n —m\Ho »e¢k rcmurcts rnnnnn in ms vwthavrwfancelh:fact um Mme femvnvsn ha»: wan nnnny nrxumctus — lo! <x—

amp]: on \\um:n's nghl no nnmnon. mntrnznnon. gobs. inme uadt unmns _ mun: a roken acclvlanu of fe1nnm5m.wL1m:n's sxlunlmn mnnn Mm‘! changed wry mudl htsauwall mm of mom rnnnannnnnun flung: n; nnnnmny.

1. Lvnne, you nnnnn n great an: ufcmphasix nn nnn 2llrr—

nauvc nn cslyles winch woulc, nnscnma nnnn dm/duped nn me1960:: you nnguc manmsehid avcrVrx1m'L7urId¢fl¢L'l on manny. Bnudo ynn wally Lhmk nnan zllemauve Iarmxofhouschuldpast n mn chnllzngc In an family’!

n Spcnkmg pensonnuy, n

In: lxved nn : cullecuvrhuusehom nunny zdm and n has nnnunnnnmnoue fornlemluv: 3 job and bmng up a rhnld nna xvmd nnn burdens nnnnnmany nnnnnm ferl llongside mg my: of :lInld—rmnng nnRnera]. 1 do think than nlltrnznvz hlzilyks, cbllecuvzinmueholds hard on sltanng housework nna cluldcam. WCICslgnifimm Funnilancc, brvznsewtemphasuszdbum man mcnmould shat: <:hIdcarz.snd|hc1mpor|znce olcammumly nnn»vnsion

»nnynng no man down Ihc dimnnn huween me home

and (h: wmnumlly ~lhcs:1de]S me mkcn mm m: cum-nnnnny nurstnu wz 3:1 up Today‘ non nnny mmmunnl)’nnmncn but mmzrin in general ohm mm»: impmL.nu< nvf

having a nnnne worker. of:/uutls chdflmn a:mz||y<tv1ngmm nExam only woman whacan are {av chvldren Thicwn aimingi) Cru y Important in nn; Ion; lcnn nn fiymng gtnder (MES.

MM: Ivery much ayerwnh Lynn: nn Lh: Ina: Lhapxuafmnrhank wnnm Mxchélz and n nmlin: urmzgus, the hm area wtdicmnt vs p:r>ovIaV politic: Much nub: rusun lord\5||ILmon—mzm wnlh nnnn pcoplcmllzd ‘cummunzf was man nn ma I960;mrrc was an nxpecnanmn mm yml cunld create asocxalm cum—mun: in the bmulnorcznnnnnn 5L>c\c|)’\ Wcshmnld no! nnnycnnmm [Ins hcranm me domcxrnc spherg ns sodctpky embeddwdin HI: wny socwly I5 uxgalmed

Bm. on lheollnzr llnlfldyMZYCJQCIL'1CIdQZl‘IflI)'0\A‘Vl‘g0llGwail for me rzvmunlon bklorr nnnnnng cnnngu at man you'v=got to rnyn xnmply luv legulnlmn. rcfnrma, Ilursrricx nnc. W(awn bdicvcman yaopltwill kn-new ha» Io mun {ordccrm candxlmn: mml mty have mrd slnng ng wnvh rhc way flux theylive lhtrrpcrwllal Xivc: m polil sol the mo nnnn dcvtlopsin: by snde.

vc- n dun’! nnnnn anybndy dnsagveexrllal Hymn am a ynnnnnnnwho I: poliumllyncuvc, yau have m begm to change van! onnnnna H 1: max yomblc otherwise Exulhcauumon nnnan 1..dual i nn: Dame! 2' hung fur feminism nn 1 debatable mm.Tllcre K n maxsnve Hmalnun 111 mu way dnllerznl yxenmecnnInc:whnhcr you can vn»: nn 3 n~nnnnnnn.nn mmsdmifl dumnds onyour bunk bflance Many nenpnc-. culluml n M nnnnnydon‘: nncnnan nn n.\Le1nq|n\<|vf::I:/Ir.’

Lynn and usrllrrxknlsecuam ofmzlabourmuvcmrm av:been n. mm of (Iv: nccd Ia mvulv: wumm and Lu ms:quen us abmn mings nnmnnndcnnn which wcrc nm dnsuuntxlum ycarsago Thuinmel-ml Ido non lhmk um uh: fundamexvml alrxulncm to nnnyc nn a {mac umon branch vs whcxheror nonIlvdmdual mm hdn mdwidual women nn mm heme; lhw .<samcllvmg lml Hm wamzn Ml} ngnn nbmu an harm The inn—dam nlal argumrnl 1: whauodn lurwnmulzsa whole hawmachlrvz structural change Ollcn nn ynu nnsn dmnand< ihoulsunanng huuxehuld task: nnnn dorflgzl omo ma nnncnnnnn matsin iusl pmwdzsa cap-mu km on: nnnnons.

MM: sun nnnon, am nnx really collcrrntd wnm structural(hinge: they in: concrrncd wuh 'wasmngrnnnnngx wnm nanmhs nm defined Unless men m m: Mica! work mnauon hav:men! sunxclmnness n-ma lboul whrn moppinggm] den: andwnnn ciuldrul havun Itecollwcuxi rmnn «chool,n-1:» won'x mtum mar monnnnnnn; xbmn how gobaarc going In bcdnntalrfeel: Mlrllltrornm wmlmncandame»: yum. Yrs. nrn :| nnnnnnn

siruslnral qugsnon nnnn 1: I: aka 2 qucwon ofdnml.LS: n would ga rvcn funhtr and say nnnn structural clung:wxfl Lvnlycomcahmn once Inewsmeofmcnand woman Xhznngchildurt and domahc work n mud, For a man, as soon a:you dn ynnn have no ulk um Just about mung Lila! go on mmzhamc hm zlm nbum n mancr wurkmg wad: and a sl\orL:rworkingdz). Danandx far 3hor\:r Ind nnm flrxnblc workingrun: an: anion! srrucmxal changl.-5 in mum ul changmg thepower rdatinmhnpsbtlwccn men and woman.

nn llm wumry malt workrs v and n Is mamlv malts —warl. more ovcrllmz dun anywhcnc the m me Wskm wnrldWe an um lnkdy In so: full rrnyzloynwnl agannn unlan w: Lakznnn Huts: kmds Mdtnlnlntlx whim wamen navzbam feedmg n

to the Iahnur movemem for same year: The ms or hams ha:bcnzomt n rmdnl nnnn rnn Ih= Lnbnnn mnvmml u n whultbccznnc n n cnoyevy connnctzd mm m: my in which nnnnsnryhas bum yesunuunng. nn 1: nm just Lhal mnl: wurkzn lnav:bean mad but alm nnn nay nnnn Iennnnn Iwrkzrs havcbenl mrdbecaucs ||)cy wk pan ume, beans: {lmr jam an: new man:vulnerable Ind nu prulzvtcd by Lu: Lndc unmll mm/nnzm.

Page 21: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

and now. mcreasinsly, bzcauxc 3 lm nl women aae vrcpxrcd aowark M nonae and anas ms in sa-aan me aeyemmnem or newaeonnoansy.

The mum of noans oi wnrk aao ma cnnncclmn hmwcrvxlvom: und work as a-nacaan for Ihc lurk uluun muwnmml.

IA: Na oneoaaonaea anaaa. Em lhal asstagnaxyoureaena wnaaas \hc ma} impact oa anesnaanges uaaa ma oerurn-4¢gK' WmIrmlr umon: huvr xv/M mm Iwakmnon of Ike ma: jorLrmln»: and Me )hnrvVt afhnwwhold nuk: rnese are vmparmm, but haw mud: rmnacz haw my hurl m re1I1U>7 Thrm as

almosl a mile: in which ma /rude wrxml uumzurmry aw Ihetwassnns as a nap In Mvruen, a way nfavmdmg who r.1.mc: /anvlrvrmnfoymenlfl7MILYIflIflUlI1ll!Iflf/!!/ woman

MM: I don‘! mmk aaaa vumc oeoaaass 1 (hank I| oaosavvosesanaa me vanaany as we know aa aoanay. and espesaauy me idea oram m1:|c\7rc:|dwinn:1,I aasa a prodnu occaonaaasm anosamwas same. no anaaaasas or me capualm chm. \ mmk aa is momcom ':x anya |h¢fmm|)‘h1sdevzlnvedalmxnrlzsnmsxcmmcneed» snamensanosomao orsa'1n\5cdwark1II1¢s:Vn&v—lhauilhcDrgalmcd mannssomnzcxass naeynoyeaevenoeaane mu 0!:Iamll wage. roa mstance, aaaey hzvz flzvelnprd me idea ofwomen‘: wages as van mayney ano axrnwd mc 1dcnLVI.aLan|YVu\I—um: wor).\a1h: real ananp

In a ysnys. lh: aapaaazasaswoaao nmhavrnarcd an anaa muchIrmry sanaaan have guns on waan me on [aclor)'Sy:lrn1:mDloY'mg mm, semen and enamaea aa wA5 many ane oaganaoeawnansang cans, oercnuang aasearanaa oaooaaoao ane ranasay sysaanaMuir): we imvr aoaay We haw ao clung: anas Ind van cl an:chznge as atgmng ane cox: mama ane lnbour mavcmcm andmanan soeiaaasa anongaa as Ia=Il as aagaansa ane Tones and olhtrrwrcscnunvns or Lh: mpltalm class.

IA: vcs. than as a neea aoa anaa name. I zgrre Em how andon wnaa xea-en a aeno ao mmk anaa anaaag llkc ancmoouasaaaonaaaoaano maaooa-non assaannaaaaauy naoane mosu oanaaweampaaam snaa-aging men‘: oonssaousaaess,

15: OM" pmblcm wim ma dawcnl Manxsl anasysas is mm aa

sees ane dlvnsvon oflabour an mo home as saving the mlcrcsis orcnplxzl by providing unvmd domestic work and aonsaaaaaaanaz omeme aanay nl labour. aan anose anaaags don‘l um vrov uvnanaaasasm om aaao suvmn a maeaas amen oayasaon oeaweenmm and women While nae aboruon wssue, wumzvfls ngm tocomm! lhciruwn Fcrnluy, saenaraa, mo nnu!\inkIhz1i1vsn|f—ucmu an aaseu Mnlw mm an‘ paepaaco ao aaeeeoa mat wcmznVhnuld havuhrrigm ao abonaoa om It 15 muth hardcr roaanemLn aomn anaa xhccxuuns sssaaas dlvmon onaooaaa lvaxutaledma] pnulcgts {nr lhcm vamch woman aaenow chnllmgxng, wehave \u rrcuyusn: anaa um: as a separzu power aeaaaaonsnaoWham dos noa yaasa seaye aneanaeaesasomoaaaa nnaaasosemsme anaeaesas or men

is mas.-gayak. we“

We .‘ "°J aas

lntervwwsM‘M assaaes lvke aooaaaon and uv: vo1:cauI2:con\:d:hn¢d X:sangxe assaaes and mm can aoooa anam as eaax mun beraussaney aae pmed |n aeams of aagnas rnmaaaasas may aaaae oanea‘lucsuons ab-mu an: roh:ohh¢lam1|)‘ and so on m lhcconlcxlafsuch oanapmgns hm much ohms nasa passes Human by Wenaye gol no coxmncemenanaa the Yam as um imnaaaaanae: aa as

onpr<\w/2 m wnmen ano cm ha clmlgtd. a dunk me Hm: ofcvechgx aoa mmangs does misc anaa. ncy shnuld noa bennaessaay. may are only neassaay ossaaase onay vaamms _ anoon|yonep.aacna—xonk.a -aanamae Ayhmsfaracmchcyuuon make that oaaana.. women uoava aaeeu sangxe nnacsa thanneed a Lransformnnon of wt: lamrly an rzlzlinn ao paao wark

vc: smaryoaa look as ansaa-aayonan women-smnvcmena onhzxuffmgnws you we wumrn comm; Iogellrm mama a snosaracrocas, hm oy Pohucall) oraamsms as womzn round anaa assocmay bcgm Io Show lbw fame ms man. saaaeav be morepohncmngfnr men 1<\v<l|1< womrn aa asannsnuoaeanasaaaoaaof women around their ooooems wnaan oegans ao change can.Vclmmuzss aaonaau nsllcs Ilka means, 3) ad}. Thu axomana furch.u\E1nx1nd\vIdu3loamaaoeswaanan ans nnmsa-aa d:1n1cI Iromma! xano oi anoyenaena

a.» ma wt arc noa Lalkms about ch.-mzms mdmduil tame.a es wnnm me name we aae ulkmz aaooaaa changing theaaaaase ofvsnrl. mkmg mao account Hm men om: woman oneaonaaly aayms wen. wml men and women seewnas aa MN onsyaysbe possaou aoa mun ao h: played 01! agaansa uch oanea

M ldun'I Ihmk cuhcr or aa, woaam saana ao rkmgralc mec.1mD=:IzJ|fur|h: vol: ax aaooaaaon nghl: or lhevaomcrh Wiccmnvcmml h as nol anna aaaao noa llvmk anem worm pnasnanss;uaaa aneaeaaae nanea lhmgs anaa n::d dmng wnaa-va naye a aonysnaeann unvlc .

IA: -nae ooanx as wnaa as nae aanpeans (av naovonno sanaeaaaaaa

anangosz naewoeoreamaaaazfiswnasnvasenaano a zruzlkingaooua do challenge an guru cl Man; and Dmjudxca abmu mafamily asan uacy (Iva a max: ooweam amoeaaas for nzlmlchalluoll|ID¢:\ruLlun:: oaeaaase Ilvey involve women oaganasems.

Takc ane issue or me family wage1

agrzt that me nononxhalmcn at: l7\:l>Ieadwmn:rx ano nayeaoeam enmlgh m tarpa family neeosao he saaasano aomanagsaoso roawnaan. Em nowan wz ao do this? Wcmn Ink: aa nv an aebaaae and dmmssnon ama aaanmign amnnd oaaaaal my for work oreoaaaa valueorr for o

saammay nnmmaana wagewuh women ovga ng as me oesa waythat one can vegan ao eaa away an Lh: aaaoa or ana aanaaxa way somax in begms xu aa-aamoue

am why noa eanapaagn for snoneaworking hoursa w¢l|'!

vc: Anyaan-pa-on winch amosoyasanesaaaaanonnfmnwnrkems class makes me wnanon or saomnn hula as vadl.

JA: Takem: L:bnurPany II|llUrt<I0.Th£Y5l1r1(VNW‘:5:L—non on women by sayann me cvuclzl amng as uaaa men andwamcn should sraau hous:ho|d aasks, swnv aaaaos. cm. 1-naa as{hair ssanine poml ban waua no pmuossls no back aa no

It‘: acuD~mI| roa anean oocaaass an a mom: :5wnna ximuld 1:: and noa a aonmnamena to may i\ nma: lcrms.

LS: Yes, 11 as a mnm|a5st1uon. my seem mzxnlylovxopvxcmar: nunzzryvmvmonano ldo noa mmk was as me only mun.W: ncad aa oaaa, Iorexample. wnaa abmneldaly vmpl<’rTh:1=are mone womm workmg pan aama oa noa wurking in onaeasocar: for euaeaay peoaaze man mare aae fnrchildrcn. we neeo an

ams or wenaae pmvisiun. nan onaaasing roles moans noa jamanasaanangs, umuanvclunpllzAhuulurcofwnrk xswcll flexi-naa nonas, mnrc aaay. inb shawl!‘ “osaane Bchon Ind so on.

Page 22: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

6.-mall Fulnn-asSOCIALIST POLICY ON EDUCATIONKEN JONES and RICK HATCHER

Posvwzr education olicy has been markedby a remarkable conscnsus between the

major parties in favour of rcfonn. The [win

onhodoxies of the post-war educationalsetllemenl — ‘egual opportunity’ and‘progressive educalion’ — have been

superseded during the 1970: by ‘(he needs' ‘declining standards’ and

‘austerity’ The current crisis of education.of irlduslr

argue Rick l-lalcllol and Ken Jones,r:quir= new response: from socialists wnloll

go beyond lne nallow lerlnnls orclass room mililancy which diff€l'el1|

sections of the Left have_ previously espoused.Erllim =anoanon' expanded arm ma lo the nonn ml‘, lllms. ll Wm [ht olggen smgl: am all gav(rnmc1\x syrzndlllg,Cnrlmrvanvz, as \n:ll as Lanonlgomnnaanu. -olwlaolllnlonexpanding gduczvlnn system w.l\ u guarzmeeafecunnmiceclrncv Mung WIIIHREQYDWII1 L11’ ipendmg wall 14 nollcy nfI!l—

Clcasmk ‘nduczuonal lIl17|(VHunily', so 2: lo open no lna slateand IXMIDHV lo [HE rcinvlghlanng Influence ov SlalI.*<(\ucnlcdmanager) ana Lvchnlclains. Th: nleulon al WlK§rlI)'5 mlgnvzvnmenl |l\ |964\-was Ah: nllalnolnl onnaalgnlnlvnl [H21 lhcmudtrniiflholl oleallnllon anll mtsrowth oy owonnnlly—lwo 5 as or III: some son. — would M: a rcgencralion oranlnn indnmry.

covonnnanlal ml€I||HVrI. hawevtr. was nol lranAL:|m lnloeanralnanal practice E.duc:l\larl was nol loolnanssell HI a waylnal pnorluscd lcchlmlnglcnl knowledge. 111: deltimmauun ol

liry goals was ra|h<‘rIcfl lo a Xeulnn ollna inmlllgtrltsia indnlnl Servllce whlcll. ln lhc llaolnon olM)xmzw Amald, valued[kc Eulxlvalion «Va nallonal nnny lnmnyu rlshnrad opelnno;cfuducaunn thaw: Illa nmololnallon Oflhc school lo an: ollmJfmxndsoflht labour mzrket. mn volley l:oom— nolabnNcbwom ln mu ano Flnwden .n wow — oonlnnnl only lh!nut)! laaognlnon u!‘nalinvl1k<‘¢olmmlc med Prolcucd Wnus llalllnon ufpohrrlhmaklng.and anoolllaoeo oy me IIVLYCCIYon lnvalvtmenl ol ltachrrs ln lna xhanlng a! new cnnnnla, 2mlnnrily or Izacl-ltfs was able luflllrvdllcc I1diCI.\Chfll|§E\lI1K’0rhcclzsxruam7

changex Inltnfltd nol so much lo Incrzase (heoccupalmnal oonollnnnias of lflII}\/[dual worklrlg C5355

children, as lo cnwumge lnnl Enllral awareness, mhn al lo.dlviduais (vltmomlaftlj/)1: membersofi socml clan.

alnllloln (he midrwvtnlltslheklradlliom or rrlonn Wrrtfllll nlollycstahlishrd al an celulv or anllsn sochoollng 11»: ytin Mnocmm have ml [HEW gradual eviction and r:pVacen\:rll

Thc unxm or rzctsxinn coin dad a gamerillg cnllonnorllalc pnoriut.-s. rnaoecla drew alien! nlo fllelatkofcorrlspondzmx nnnnoo slnlnn alanoallon ano eommmlc ma.Jzmes callngnnn. ,nonly :n'1z1 nl buzlnlc Pnmc Mlnnm ln

M5. made a wnllrpubllclxed nlaaan zbalu Ike danger; or [htinllcscslly Ilnmlnankclanxrnnm approach‘ whlI:hallph.:;l5cd, nosaid, ‘maul’, lalncl lnnn ‘zcunnmid factors‘ lnllnnlnal chlldomloonn-nl, rallhur lnan lnn :hl|d'$ rulc m a fun!!! Worktf

my mllml ltlldfllclcs lonnll onllcl ln mt ‘Gui! I'):haI€'on Xdloollug nlualnacll by lnl» Lanonl Cvlwexnmerll ln E7173.whlrh allnnolall lo unit a now cunscnwx on educallona!pa loy, whosrcentral {ellllrcwouldbclhtrrlaallonihlp bzlweenschoollnd Work Thisrelallonahlpw.\\und¢1)lovdnoljnn lnalbchrllcai Srrlsc. nol ln an ldlnluglcal sense‘ schooh woulddevelop nol only |h:‘>kdl5‘ bu! aka the ‘:|lm'\Id£i' rleccxsurylowonl Whereas pievlounly ma: non hccn an nnqunlnonmasiumplloil lllal more scllaolmg (oi wnalml kind) lnl loccmmmlc gvnwrh. now ll WI: mlcrldzd K4) wccify the kvldsofoducalicn Slllliblt lo a |Ll|nod. cunsulhng and adaplIb|=wurklnrx

Tnn w1V HIE Harm of Labour's m7 Green PaperAllhouxh 'tfl|IzID\'7DDrmnily'mlllasnns amllollroloollry.ll me Ill asrcondlry role. Sdmal and wvrk — mt nevd [UV 179:

xdloul lo XL‘$D0nd lo {ht Yzfinlftmrllli ufcwnnmlt Ill: — mlthe oolnannn |I\=1m: Al 0|: lam: lnnc, oraonna. [ht LiboulEm/:1l\m:rIl was lmaonlllnl lo ccnnomlc Knits nnn CHIS lnmclzl qsznding. Pohclcn csncllulil lo [he ‘cuunl np|I<II’IurILry'suaxegy _ Such Is “I: rxpaamlvn ofnurytry alluunllnn 7 Welllargdy zbandomd Capllal nptndlng, csxumlaal lo nffacllvzcomyrehemlvz Marga Nion. wax Incuvlly mu.

wnlln Labnufls ml: auvzclm snarl: CfmL1Sm(l)luIABh Ilmntnedlvencslxlallccl llonl parlv and umans, ixsemphasu on lhcwlloolrwork Lunrlcumn was wdcnmcd \7)‘m=TUCmId ln-llmwlln rmlnon miller lnan kbndcllllvalmn by lhcluchlnguniansTh: mull!!! or aprlrobmlan and ulcrlcc mm nnloll ll wa»rnccived indicaled a consldcnahlz wnallnnsl ln [ht IabollrnmvrnIem'€ educmlnnzl nollcy I1 naa no nnn oonoapnon ornllllallonal PMYDDV.‘ lo M! up againsl Ill: g0V¢rnm{1\l'S lllnslencn ml the noudc or loanllallnl imiulm‘

l-nl, I-«I.-akncss Was lo became Incl’: glanngly anpmnl asrvlnlgaln Th3lch¢r') Envcrnmcm began 11$ mnlnolnnnll ofadnczuon.The 1.. ls‘pnIi<YTn: Tones lnn IIIDVC5 wrrc dirttlcd mart lowlldi a remforcrmg alzducalioual mtuulhllcs lllan lnwnmiavrshapmg, ollh:xclmnl, lo meal Ill: needs or walk lnnll um'nlDlO)'ln:l1KY The‘Asxmzd Plats Sthen\t' en.-onlnglu Mudzms \l| Slalc SchnohIo like up olaoolln the priva|cyel:\oI unonl leglslallon cDII|~pelllngmlmoriiieiln make <:condar1. Aducuion conlpxchcnuvnwin rrpcalcd Ah mlswas actunlpnniedby: rllemriruf ’v¢ICnlal theme‘. Mal: cdumilnn Md bzramz unzccounldhlu,loaolnnoonllnalacl and rzmmi rlonl Lh: Ivqmrrlnenii ofuorkand family Illdwldl/ahfluA5lbEpVElI nnulllnlloomlmolnelnflurnc: mar iv,

ll would b: :| mlslaku [D Sctlhtscxxalenlenbzyllltlnrrrolanncnc overlay of a pollcyuhusc r:L'IHr¢UIruSl\\nS£D1fl¢I‘GAClnoonauly ano htntfil me nah. ‘Par=ma| llloloa lsan ldeologynnnn has (Um! autonomy rlonl rssuex or me dmnbunoll afwelllh and or appnmlniry Undollhledly, ll aliawn 1 guierconocnlmllunofuiuaaliunnl plw gt, nnl ll VS Inxmdzd lo domore lnnn lnal

The ma Educalxon ‘Q4 lol lnnanlo, gm": pI\’¢1U€ lnlngnl lo enema V-hxth nlnnolonanlno school lnell thlldrcncunld allana. ln Vl’i:|l$‘C, lnn looanl lnal xchouls almaypriulegcd a. o mull M lnnl mlnkz. loonlon. hinory andlaonlmwlllhav: lnelrl-omlmlly I¢1nf(:rCed.wh£rcaS§chuols

hcnlushEdu(allm||XIdIn lslcmdd\UCI('M|)/.haidllftrrntslrucnlnfiand n oan |u:hl!I5 unlnm [his lrrlzk n nnnlann xppllmlalz.lnmloln, lo Ellyland anll Wlflu.

Page 23: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

aimiii drpnvcd ‘NH iii»: mm vhgfl Dollfiimed N01 i»iiii—

mug, blll Hi: aggftgafl hf l!I(()\/U-\L\3I CDVUIIIHIY dfimillld ML“

d¢Ifl'V\1mEIh¢ Chfllflclcral III: >LlI0t)L iii emu IO miiaiii OVEN,

In : Slkuflliarl Dffimvlg )lI1deN iiiiii, \chD0\§W)\I iimiii iiiaicn[ht ntcdx Bf 3 iimiii-.i Lhc I [Hal )3 ciiiiiaiea. so lhe ni ‘es

hunt, iii \hC\'ir|uéSafZlI1:dlLiDn:d iailucallollalphllnwphy iii.WlllI.\||l¢) VAL“ HYCYEIVE aiii me mlenllbn is aha lhnl imciii.W!“ rim iii=ii role 35 fciuclous InfliVIlliAfl(dC1Cl\dCY§ oi’ iii=iiI/W71 ciiiiiiii Edutillunfll Alesllfly miiriiiiicii. and mm lhtlfpoltnl is Dflflitlplnh iii a Enlkcxvvc lI|0Vt!fl¢N of waiiciiiiimi iirai-iii will dlmllllsll

The labour movement has made no attemptIn form a colleciivc popular conceplion 0!

ins purposes of sciiooniig

TIIE [about ll'IOV¢ll’IEl|l. llkc [HE Ollie! lffldlllnflal dflkrldlfiiii i=iai-iii, I) Il|—:q\|lppcd ID Yflvond ID this Sllflllfgy. ii VISA

iiiiniiuany SCEII Slfllztdllcilloll mii Llnllullllltd mien Th:))|id:qLl2ACIE$ iii [Ill school 1\ a meal“ iii ffifmmg iiiaiii iiaii

' UK kind iii kn0Wkd§E flfflln‘ wiiiiu lI\fl| allow: men] Inh’fll|sk)l'lII\I, lusnevel’, L\||.i5Id:OflhEWil’. been Slrinuflydzallwiiii. No Imrnlpl rm imi mid: In ioiiii i collemwe, pflnlllal’KXYHCEFHOH or Ah: piiipim or Sllhoollflg No! Jllfpniingly,coiiimaiiva aim; iipoii [he VHIIOIADESS Ind illldzquzcy iiiiciiooiiiig rim mm mm iewiimi

Sllth W25 [ht Xllllill vixui or CDIKSCTVIH‘/E puhcy. iii roiiiVCEIS Ofgflvrnlintnl. xiii-mi. [HE Tories hzvz been forttd ID

CDME |D imiii »iin Sam! or DIE pf0hkll’IS iiiimi ii. [ht c-miDthnlt. lh: IWQQHQIof wiiicii YX ullfitlllned by the EXISIKHCEOI

IHISS unlmploymelll nmonz )0\lXh whose fchcumlli PflkcnlmlWESGEIHOHSIFJICG iii LhL'S1lfl\Il’l:|‘0fWELThETDnc§luv: iiiiiidhelopcd — fllhllgldt vnflzaskd pm!-16 D{D\15\fll\ iii ms‘‘Ehook — 2 -viiiiiii Tmmlflg sciieiiix wniai win bc UVQII [0eiiiy I$)E.:|fDld iii IHECDLVIIY). rm ‘(rs pioiiimio Allayentiii lY8|l|ll\g iii a langc DI wurkplam )kl||S, eiuiii dllrclly,inioiigii iimiiui B{DCnu'IL¢ ill iii-my DY iiiriix DI iiinimiiy.iii collegebawd Cflltnca.

iiiiiiiii Ii. iii, Srhffllflsnic VTS IIHYYKA the hlgkfil (hall!!!) iii iaiiiiai caiiiaiioii mekolllpnthtllsivr rt0!gMI}Va|lm1 mi off iii me midrSi‘(HEi,THCYE art a iiiiiiiim iii imiiiii Which iiioiiia bl mail lbaul iiY1rsK,IH51mlnXyVI£m DYi‘A[7DY¢ll|lL(&'VI[Y ThCSkL||S[Obekarn-ed are IIERHEYZSSDIICIHC no! ESCDIHIJIQIS lhmz fl'lhI::|pvr¢l|'ii hr iiiiiiciii 1: lo DECDIIK iii :ld:|Dl:|N¢ Worker, IIOI 2 upiiciiiiiiy Lklllud one. siciiiiii, HS ‘lYaIY|ll’Ig' ’|lVK‘lI()l\ win hr)UD(7(d|IIil¢ loin ‘nlflnagcmtfll ()rilV|¢m[IIflYmll|l'flllltlltlfl. iiii 1IDli:if|hc Yrs win il1Cr(a5: [he Vllflflbfll oi gobs iiiiii. [D

yoiiiii wiicii {IIeCB||fS£i50Vt{.iiieyaieiimyiiiiiiiiiii min:¢l\ ivii dole Th: VTS V'«1”hIV¢mum ‘in P\l\"DO§c ii ii hzlps In’iiii [he dliflnllllei iii work iii a Workfanlc which rm. 4!!iiiieiiipiiiiiii I-lllurv riiim, iiiiiiii iii [hr flllfllng WI.“ be iiiiiii-i(hr ioiiimi o[:1npmyrrx.AsIhchad of me Manpcwtf SIY

vim:-omiiiiiiioii pills ii 'TKilnfl|2§ Isiholllwflfkrfdmldxklllsiiia IS immedlfltdy cumimi wiiii cmblhyllwfll |l1ilort|\ISIEESDII [hm Rlinmg In iiiis Pollmry iiiiisi he cmplayefrdnminnled and |lIHlni(€l)'<lI|f)|DyEFdil’tCltd.' niiii iiic >¢II00|ism Dflalmnslcampklfl) c‘<Eh|flld 'l’DlIMhcy1SwP\l!|lAhE¢milhc mi; iii wiiiiii ii deiinimiiiiiii lhc ‘world or work‘.

WhzlW|“XDOnDUEL lhell, IYIIYSIEIIIaiimiiiiig, OpcrlfllllgIHIIVILIK "1: iiiiiiiiimi raiiiis iir Dd\lClIIOIIi.\ miiiiiii 2nd cnn—

aidtnhly lnnurnctd by Zlllplwycrs. roi wiiiiiii ii win largelyrtlllace ivflfe tslup Mlhcmti. IIS iiaiiim Wm be rind as 1weak — fllllfldllccmtlli, iii effect (UK:-1VE5ChBOIafcfl“cgcldllilflfln, whn: lhty are flllllrd iii Ill) lllxllllclmnlltaiiiiwaim. Mzanwhvlé, [he mini MC |'a.kIlIg alzps |0 coinMllldllclhclnldllloflfl ‘flfidtmkf [and iii (Hem zclccuvd niiiiiieiiii wiiii ii ngiiigmiwia ii iii a ciiiiipieiieiiiiv: A)’SI:m or

eriflsli Futuresvosirkfi eflllcflfloll iii which [ht siiiiii, 0! (and Dafllnvaliull iiiipioisiiciioii wiiiiiii be Cfllnvltlntllltd by iii all miiiia gtncmledulfllmll. iiiii )\ KWOVHCI’ -imiaiy l’l\Dd£HV' ‘yfltnl DT 1549Educalloll. IV\ Whliih mmormv/‘¢ mfllnlfil woiiim andimemployui win be (III all iiiiiii zccux [0 ‘a giiimi Cduflaflflnind mvniven ii iciiiiim whlch ulfcr H0 nghl (D wiiik ii [HUICUl|Chl5}Ol’I Hlcncw Imlllflli/C, llI0r¢flV¢|‘, WillhavenlieffbtlOnthe Cllfnrflluln VI lhl. CIIKIYC moiiiiary 561100}. m miieiiiiuVDCBUOIIBI avhl .i )6 win he prépared mi iimi awn iii:iciiuiii.

Th: ins the mini nf . cnfllllkx iii l‘DnCn'l|S' wiiriuiieivipioyiiieiii. Wuh imiiiiiiz iii: wiaiiiioice lo IICW Kcchnical

iimiimiiiiii. ‘HUI Dlflnallklllg H1: imaiiiiiiizi miicaiioii.-ii VII’

flllullfins Ilnd prflavlfltl and Hill! Gem/Hln_E, lhtm i liaulflaucQIDCK [B flier iiieii amvroaches iii Q||EVl}m’)( (}fC|I!V1Cllhl!l’l indédmlillonal iiiiiiioei

UIVSKIVWMIIQV, iii ‘(KW iii HS 42fl!IlHh\l|}0n la lhc aimDthnlt, HIE laboul’ IIKSVKHIEIH iiai bctn bvlflflg iii [ls Cflllcislliiii mt yrs ll hm largcly bu.-ii Contrfllzd wini Qlltillonsof llsiiwii ll’IflL1ll|(E .iiii iii XIII: Elflldfilolh of $£’r\VL‘: of the KIEAHFESIlIVBI\/Cd iii lhr 5/yhefllc). win imai iiiiiiiiii be lqlftfirrllcd Onlhe MSC board< iiiai 0\/elk! local llIID1HI|l:1IXlllOl|iii the vwwin men he iaregiimii aglinfl [he HS! ol lfalntls as Chtapiziiiiiiii saiiinca Wnh [ht miwm ii HES n5\:1V:(I,1lha! imiimiiuiii L0 flvbffl‘/Q (H2 Schflml ma: |H\)OVIOfnclak rim imii[OldlDa£kEmvlD)’:l’SlDlIkCDl\Y-lslI'I\lVC¢5,B!|(1VOVVV)\1\CS|ll’E.(hi! my iim adtquaxc Skills and coimiiioiii and 3 ‘Warm’while’ |X:|lmI\g ‘/TS€L‘h<ll’IES which iipeiaie iii WDYk piam winflwd io IVE‘/B me Sllnpflll of \llI]DIIS mm bcfnm (hey N! i,,,]7rDV¢d by "1: Msc, MIL SIIICI2 ml: lllllfllb aim Wllh YJIE

‘IIDYIZIILE Bflhc .\ChrlI\C, ml: rlxhl of v=L0 1! uflllkfi‘) ll) mCII\vcry ll'|\l(‘h iii DNCKIOE

Page 24: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

u mmr-ar Mmrrzwwm

Brmsh featuresL|kcwrs2,m:m:ix1Inching uniom 7

(I1: NUTand mmms 7 have berm wncamtd nm so much mm mzmmcnt orm mums, mu Mm nrzservmx 7 wxmiu the [mmzwork of cmdorstmcnl am: vws 7

XY9=|lVn\lC1l0t oi Ihmr mzmbrn. umNUT ura. hm. unsucuqsfuk m rm. rcsuu ma ruraran uadcunion movcmrm,mough. his gamed samrinfiuencc, Man) ufm: YTS ‘Am: Mznagemcnl aaaray are headed by trad:unvonistx Tm; mfiutnce nar bun gamed at the txpcnse ofwidtr principle. Thc v-rs will help pm lb: slunv ummxurrrrazneed‘ upnn pusl-I6 zducznon. mic dzvclnvmenls

7 meimylkmalmriun of alltmzliv: gaak to am or cqual oppurrmay 7 haw: hccn sex in mounn wxlhonl |)|c glimmer L112crrrmx mrpons: [mm m lzbour movement.

‘It-«busm exclusion of turban‘ nrganvxallnm from m: V15 rs panof a genenl ma so txcludz mm: from rm council :2! «arc. xrmum upon the doung down 0! mo Srhools cmrrmx, a nnnunal comullanve body an metumculum, on winch xeachcn‘umam weve hnvily (eprcs4:l|x:-A AL ma same um, xaachcr:rm sharp attacks on mar N are. and mndlnomnisrrvxcc.rm rrmrr xmponamumon. mganxsrng hall me leaching forceIn EnyJand and Waits ) lhc Nammal Unimu of TeachersEcunonuc muck mm the clotms 0! ma Ehlnnds ahu Influencznamnmwrrerr Dersvcmvnsxnlo cnsis Tlxclradluonzisualcs)of ma NUT lezderslup of rtlyuls on m: arm, suxmblypremixed whul nrcssnryy in make pmgmsm: relmm) inmuuunn, and (0 mm: . favaumd puaca Ior ma Irncmnz'pro(:mon' In (arm: 0| hvmgimndanix and nnumcemr mucumcnlum, 1: new in dxiarny mcnars pay has xtudxlymrrma 7 an rrrcrma of Imnnd an Der cell! As needed noreuorc salmncs to me high pain! M1975. lahlnsus 7 mnughnot mmpmrary mdurraancy 7 acazkratt. Emmyerr vnxh Ioanrr Dondxuunx of xervxcr m make mm use orsnonmm cnn—tram and vnuaduce a element of mmpumor. mm Iunduumcand ayrmaroauacumy. Ax xh:s:m:Lim:cIma’md ms\'mcIur—mg slnke a blow at am NUT‘; cducalmnal abjec 5.

Thu NUT‘: rtspnnse [us bran cnnuadiclur parlly ngreuzrwillxngncssxouxelradcuninnlonnsu!a£uDII.vm1Jyannlmnpl Lure-zslubfish n(nonp:\1ypo!?ucx.1)mmrnsusamundeducationalexmmian And rcfonn.

.the shift to thc left in the NUT has come up

against the limits set by the unionleadership’: strategic framework

_xra memo it wok nalliwnal strike m:Liun ova pew, and won.Shortly afttrwards affiliatzd m the TUC Since my ar has

new famed xo all smkns m scvcnl are; against me am. munIlalably ma xmk:m Baking m 19x2, whuzhlastcd men wctkxand succznded in ruaurrrrg nnrly lwn mud: of xhcinbs mat aLlbunr aumnrny wished to cm. Thwusands oflelchcrs muckon Srpltmher 22nd W52 in mynpon of ma neum warkers.Than nar been a Chung: in me mam-p 0! arm». alfinali.budmg to a gala :mnha:15 an ma: union muhods n{sr.r\Ig—2!:

Th: genafl ma: arm: has an rrrurea the union. n hasnamed xncrusulgly radical vuhacs on racism arm xexixm. II:we: mnlemme valzd ro support unillmral rmuur dinrnu.ment. A dilfuse but favcelul mm/emem ufwomm luchrrs hasbegun to mmplim on ma ma: union um ndunnlional Issues.In zfferr Wu felt at ma union‘; am evzt bonlrrum on cqnzlavvurtnlliuzs in was. when we ma-rrivar Fuxmons wareStvrral umes demand.

an ummma mmn has new com: up ngzinsl mu mils0! win possible wixhin Lil: union ladtrshixfs mugafmmework. Ta go beyond it would xuqmr: a man lhamuykxomg mmnuunmx ro xlnk: aclinn and um nbandoninl 9! meunion‘: amaauy n0II—palm:n.\ flange. or relax: In an far a

u xn uzublne me nzulsallhr ...ra...,lnl me hmsn

Labaurgpvzmmznxin w:IcrI:!m:m 2nclh:rfiv:yc.nr: mm,char, lcl alone conlrvnnlzlc nffiluling m M: Labour Pan) 1

Th: union‘; cxccmive mu nor rcnouncc poxrms ‘nguuul y-.nar aetapl [hr rrrmnaorr n! mun nu: ululaxerzlxsminto union«mm 17¢: uniun Nesudml wspondcxl w the dlmrmaunuuvot: .r 192:2 Lonfnznct by dcdaving mm 11 Wat onlsxd: rm armsznd nbjncts efxhc Ilnmm and would vml be implnnzmed. rm-Vemxrxcrer -1:rr'grauprng an 1):: e(:.cunvL* dune m samflcccunlerznm policy mr me me al the umly aim: icadersllp

Thrdisalmamcnl rcmllmon warm pan amrrprom am erpa vclsalian m 1!»: umun On many tunes um pohficuzxrionha) been forcrd on um unmn by a gov/rmnlenl duet: ncd mmm nomcn mu man) was of man} palm which hadpmvumxsly um. mum olagxkxutnl among (ht uanles. l.n2d—dman. cessam amacki mu jobs, sducixlnnand payhavc (ms:4 «van many mariners a mnwiousncxx that wduczlmn andvenues cannot be xeparalud.

We Ire suing, xhough, a polmrixalmn rnzhu than anhomugenous nqhcalnauon ofluchcrs. but zvcry Lcachtr whorr xumulaled (0 (aka nu ma Ian] ma. lhcm xi anomcr wlm. rrrximsdalad by unemploymem nr mrurmza by pnlflvul runnyn, wxfl argue {m a qmtseem rzxponse, m me be.“ lradluamnl vuhh: xcrvme, Lo vhc goymmenrx aunckx

An rr:ulL—and1IIKhr.!bs:nc<oVa am »ev.l\-ancghymewar 'ng my mmmm 7 the NUT is xmlgglinq m mzmumus h.1lf—s7Iar: gr m: lelchmg force omer rzacnarv uxpnisrhum Whuh vanm me nampolm .1 nuur: claim to Ix uvansrmg their sue. They mdnde ll}: rrurmimn Assodniwn ofTeachen, Foundcd in lh: wlk: or (In: 2969 pay Xlriku maplcdged nrver w 50 an amine. and IMAMMA, mjxurnafly uh:uniall of gzammnr Iduwl Inchtrs, now same man; whichhis a unular ammur, rn pracucc The NAS/uwr. the second].Irgcrlte2chrrx'un1on'unflTI1aLcdmvJI:TUC ltwasfnundcd.in xhr: 19205, (B veprtsmt ma zmmu uf mu! mam Morerznenlly, .1 has pxtsenled nxcllu a rougher ormurior. Lhznmmum mmblnmz Lrzdz nn n ancywlth ..mnapo|arruAstand Ixsmililancy 13, in nu, qnux1onablz—1:Risuk n InI=ss anion against em: man [he um while its adnczuomlsum uiwhxslses m: cultivalion nl dnclplmt Ind ‘mura.\ily'um nu qun: nnxl me me new zdumnonnl clinule.

Page 25: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

11.. mzmbcnmp 1.1 zmnng 1111 ..n111..< 11 an 1mDDn:mIIcasun 11. .11. 11111 <xec\||ivc’: cuunltrrzuack 1.1.1.111 1111

.11.11..:.11..11n111.11: 11n.11n wo.-1-1.11 11,111.: da11gcroImc1nbcr—

.1...11u11,11..11111111n11pxeserw:wl-131 remnms 111111. 11nn1n'11.1.111,

1.on.11 influrncz 11 1 n11n—11a11111n .11111.1..11n11 lobby. 1.111 ..1n.1111111 .1111 1 11.111.11.11 an1m1.hawd n..111 against 111. .11.. .11n.11.1..1111., 1111 1151.111 11 nuw .1111111.11.ng 1.. 11.1111. 1nednmunnzl c.1111.n,11, 1.1.1 1n .1. 11.11.11, 111 111.111.111.111. .11..111 lmdmnnal 111-neg... 1..11111.11.a.11¢ Shunnmg 1 1111.11.11

aI|1:u|1.c 1.11.11 .11: 111111111 mowment, .11. 1111111111: 11 11.111

11.51.11.111... 111...11.1nc.11111y 111.11 1 .1.11n.111.1wn 1111 po1.1.c11

d1scusx1o111nLr1e11:nk:,1.u1111..n.1 ...1y1.1..111111.c1a111.1111n .111,ue1:,c!\\11cn 1111111111111: 1111... 1.1111111. 111.11 a nm1—pol\L1cal mm-1>a.g.. 1.1. ‘cdnuuow 1... nalmnal 511rv1val'

The 1.11.111: cxc:\mvc': hn: 11 1111 111: 111031 pan »..n.1111e11 by 1111

1ea.11=.. 11111 111.1 111: ‘NUT 1111- .11 .n. Communist n>a11y

Thry c1.a..1c1:1.1. 11.. r<acuLi1: 11 -.11.1g..1111.~. 1.1.1 11.nn.1 1.1

may. 11,1.1.1n...11 11 1111.14.11 111.1. 1111.. 111 n..11n1.1.. an1111.nn.. 11111. 11.. 11.11.1111 1.1.1.1111...» 11c..111e1.11.a»1n.11:1n1111.1 11 vuslunn 1.1.n1 11111.11 .11¢y 111111111; anempu .11 11.1 .11:1.n.11nn11 111.1.11.1.1111.1111on1.11111. 11 un1!2L:111.\1<n\ Correspom111111.11.meyn1onu1o..an11.1..11111.-111.1111 111.11.111.11, nn—1y 1 $zn\i£!ande:Lin: 11...... an .11. .1..1.111. 111.11. 1y1.1.1. 111..

fax: 111 |I11adve1|15:d mrcung: .1 annual coninmcz Manyrank 1111 1.1. 1.1.1.1.111e11 1.1 11.. 111.1111 1111' haw broom:a11.....111 .1111 have »1.1.11.a Wflh 11111111. 1111111.. 1.1111: 1111. on11111. 11111.. 11 dixamlzmenl

11.1.11 1.1111111. 11.. .n11..11 1.1. uuposulnn 1.11. .11<1v1a<d hy‘Rank 1111 F1}: 1.1.1.=.'. a grnuvmz dnmxnukd 11, .11. swp111..n11.n1y 1.1 .111: 1:1m11nua.\ 11.1111c...1n-1111a111 1111.....11r.c.111.1.1111,.11ra.1..1...1.1¢1m111.1.¢ po1.1..11 arguments.11 111. 111111

151111111111 11111 111 11.11 o|‘m1£n1aI a.1..11..11=, 1.11 111 1.1 dnchn11 1111. 1o.1.1a11y wound 1.1. kw .11. sw1- .111... 11.11 1... — 1 11:.

non men, w1.11.c1:. lI\ev:1gar1e<ollhc sw1= linc. 11111.=ax.nr.111 .111 xnfluzncz .11.1..1.1.1n1:11.11 11.11..

The ma... 1.111. on .11. 1.11 1.11111 .1n1n1.1111.111111111=s.1...11.1

1.1.1.... 1.111111... 11111.1. 1.11 .1111 11.111.11.111 on 11.. 11a.111na1

11.1.1.1... recmv/5 abou140pC1 cm! 1111111111. 111.... 11.111.111.11 .1ann.1n1 .1...1.1.n.. and 1111 1 1.1.1.111. mflucnnv .1n11n.1 mum:11111.... 1.1 a1.n1 can 1n1.11 11111.11. .1. 1111111111111 .11.111n..111c11n1.1n momlII1l1lamnnd 11.11. puhllcal. 11111.1. 1.11 emphasised11.. 11n1111..11111 11111pam1 men. 1.1.. .11.n.1. as . mczus o1..1.1..n11 1 umnn an .11. mnrgins 11111.a1a1111..1 movnnrnl 111 a1.na.o1 111... 11. 11.11.11. 1111111111 111: 1-11.. .n. 1111111. abmn 111.1111.111 and 111111.111 111111. ummu _

111 11.11.1111 1. 11111111111

nature _.1n11»1 1.1 1111.111 m1=11111111111..n11a11y 1111111111111.9111'. 111.111.1111

111111111. PolieicsNu 111111.... .11 ..111.a....n ..n 11.111.-1. 1.1.11 .11 .11. teachers’unxom. 1111 11111 necessary 1n 111111 .111 111n:11n1na1 .1111... .11111¢.1.a111.11.mc1..n11 .11 1111- 1111.111 w11..11 rfprmcnuhcm. 11..1111411 va1».1..1. 111.11 11... 1.11.111 .c11.11.1.111. 111.11. 11.1.1.1,.n c11n1..yn..y. pnlicy 1.1.1111 .1.111.1n.11 -1.111.111.1111‘. 1;¢rLamly.11111c.:1.11a 1n. .111-..nc. .11 .1..c.1n11 1 1111.111 1.;.a.a1 a.»11.11.. .

1n 11111 pc.,pe...yc,111e L111 11a. .11 1111:1111: .1 1.1111111. 1.1.1.111.1 c11a11=.1.. 1.1. 1_n11111..'1111.1c.11111na1programme. 1111.11 111n1.1.....1¢1p11n11 adequalely 111 1 s1u1a11on111wmcl11|1e Imzhu .11

zdnulxanzl drhau 1111. 11.... czpmud hy 1n. 1.1.1.1. and .11

11111111 111.. 1111111-..c.111.1.1111111111..1.1.1111111111111,-1..g.111¢.111111.. ‘M11111 .11 wurl.‘ 11111n 11111111.=1.111.11111...;11111.1...1111.n11y.

11 1111 w he mwgnnscni 111a. 1.111.111: 1:111 .11 1.1 mun:1.111111 11.... M. 11.1.11. 1.111 mmplrhenxivisalnon. .1. 1ncourilzmlznx 111 '|nixed—ah|hly' growing» 1.11.... an 1:11.11:1111111111111, 11.. mlmdu 11 .11 11.11.15 ma|n|:n;n.::allawanrxs. All 1n11. 1111111111111... 111 wclcumcd. 11n. Buy 111

11.1 Kundamenlvnl p111111=1..—

111: effecu 111... 111.1.

1. 11111111111. on 1111 111111.111 1.11 1y111n1.1 111.111.111.111

‘B1-111:1. Features.11 1111 111111111, 1-11.11 1111.11.11 pmgxamnve ...11a1n. W. .n1m.1.1 1.1.1.111. 1.1111111 .11. 11111111.; .1n1 .11.1.111..1..111.11n111 con1¢1u1on .1... .11: nccds 111 woxkmg 111.1 childrzn .111 11.

1...11111...a.1n1 .11.».-1111..1111..11..111.1111.n 11ac111.1.1e11 1n. 11y.11.1.111cn. Wllh nn. mlereus .11 111111111”... 11 .1¢.,11.m1111n..1..11.1 1.... 1n.1 .11.1.. 1111.. an 15511:: .11.... may 1.1y. 11n1.y..11.111.. 1111.11. rummnce. And, 111111. 111. 1. 11111111 .111 awa..n1nof 11.: need 111 mohxlnc 11.1111 .11111a.....1 o.1n1m11..y. 1.1111111.111 czvnpmgns 1.11 111.1n. .11 edurzlimx 111.111. 11.11.. 11.1111 111

.1121. c..n...11 111.1 1,111.1... 1.1 cnmml 1..11n 111.111.. 1n111111,.

1.111111. cnnunm-5 111 my on 1111..1n.11..1..1. .1..11n 11.11.111111.1.

11.11.11 111 11111.... 11 11.111 1.1 11.11.-111.1 no 1.1a,111 1.1.11¢11.e1..

among 1.ac11.11. 1. varcms, .11. 1.111 .11111. 11n.1.n.1

111: 1.111.. 11111.... 11111111111111.1111 1s.19 c1111c1..11n — .11.—

11cu|2rly1he111:. 111: 111.111.11.113, 11.4 111:1.t1\1ua| Impatl111. 1n. 1111.11. |I|ovI.1m:nl.11.1.11. 1. 111.1. e11.11....111111¢1.1y11.111.111.111 9111111111111.11...... .11 .1..ws 1n c1)mh1ning1nan:11.11.... 111111. a 1e1p11..s. 1.1 nghlvwmg 111.1111 .11 ‘r:|r\'an1' and-1.111. 1 11111111111... and .11 the .111111nn=.11 .11.11.1..11. 1111111111111

Wllh 11.1 .11.1n1...1y1...1. 11 mdusmal 1111n1n.. Inc 111111.111 1.11

11111.11. 1n .n. 1.11101. 1>1.1y, 1n11 11121111111111, .1 1.1 .1.11111.11a..1

1n 111.111.151.11 11.c.na11y: 111 11.. 111: 1.1.1.1. .:y.1a1.111 .v1a1x111

conczpnanx .11 polyleclvnm .111..1..11 11.: 11.111 111.1n 111

1111.11.11 1111.11 .1111. a 1.1.1. 1.1.1 111 1.1.1.11 cducalion 1.11.11.

11...; 11.111. pracncal txpericmac, 11111 1.1.1.1. ¢nc1..1pa.1.1 11.1111111.. 1111111 .11. .11. 1111111111. 111 111: 1-12.11. Dnlylechmcc111.a111.1n emailed n11111n1y .1n 1...11¢11.1n.1.1111111 111. 1.111. .1111.110111.110... 11... 111 M11111 11.11n.11¢1 111.1.11a.1c1111n and. 11111111.

.111 ploducunn 111111.11a1 1 11n.11. 011.111.1111 111 11.111.11.11:.11.:11.11111 111111111111: 11111.. .1.1.a11.s.11.1n .11111¢1a11 111.111.... 1n..1 1s w11111c..1o....n11y.1nm111.111111.n.n1,111. 1.1.1.1 .111 111.111.11. 115111.. Innvemuu 111 .1..111.1« 1 .1 r1111 pmyalnmc 1.11

cduczuan 11111.1. 11111111111 11. 1.1111=111.1..1.1g1.1y1.1..1n 1n 11.. 1111.,11.. Wmcnl 111 11.11.1111... .11 .:1a11.1.1 111 11.. 1.1.1.111 111111.111‘..1n11 .11 11.. rxpznmcz .1111na mnuvalion .11 11111111111.

the Left has In develop a critique of labc1ur'seducational programme

11.. 111.1.1111n.1s 111 sucluu-msfom11aIion 1-1.11 depend 1.1 annmrmnam .111... 11.. 11.. wmlung or Iachws’ .11.-1.nn.s1n111111 —,Espccufly .11. NUT — .11 1 11.11;“... cunuminn 11.1.11. .11.valmcally, .n 1111111111.... 1 11111:. 1e1111.1n_11.1.1 1.1 111: 111.1111

n11ye111¢n1 and 1 Ivjucuon 111 -n.1..a11.1;11.111 1111n.1.1e1; educa.11.1na11y. 1.. 1 1on11.11...1:11. .11 c1I:0uflS¢ \m1un .n..n11..1 .1broom: pra1:\1L1o1\=rs 111.111.11.111” parmzn edumiinn

11.. 111.1n.a.11: 111.111 1... auch 11111.1 11 1.1.: calming g.n1.1a1clccuun. w1.a. guvrmmcnl 1111.11 11.. 11.11 upwrlunuy 111 11.:

Nun po|1c1:: 111111. ..1..1e.1 .1111 1. 11 zwdcnl .111. .1111 1.

111111.11 1.a11.11.1 gpvcmmtm could imv|:In1:m even me 1-.111.ng91:11.15 .11 .11. NUTOI1 .11: <‘<nan$inn a111111e11111...11.. 1a..111,mum. on mum! and 5:111... '1-1.1 NUT kndeuh‘ . 1.11.1.1...vefus: 111 11111n1111n .11. ||niun'5 11aa1..onm nonmany 11111111111

1...... — and 1.11 nndoublsdly111111111111111.11. gm. 111.1111.

111 11n1.1.. mrmbcri 1n.1.1.1r1 lhrm .n .1111. Th: su laces 11.:«a111, n11..1 11111111. c111, 1111 1a111n1.1>1.1y1m11a11.1n 11111.1. canonly a. 1)1:mome1u have npmD«I£nnd13l1c 1111111.... 11111 1.11..

' ul 1111...: 1111.11. .1.1111.ng.s 11.:nn111.. 11.1.1, 1.1111. 1n .111. mnmnn, 111 1111.1 .11. .11n 111.11111... 1>11r1y .1r11.11111n. 1111.11 11¢ a 111.11: mucus —

11.11 one1111111. 11111 ...... .11 11.11111. a 911111.11 1.111nm.1.1o1111emanyxparllr 151.1... 1.1111. msarmamnu .11 ‘Eq11a1 ov1>or11..1.11111.1. 1.. naw common .11..1ncy 1n 111: umon

11211 101455 11 1 M11111. 111 me N1.111n11 211.1111. 1.1 1111

um, nnn1 111 11115111 1.11 .n11.n11..1s«y1>...11>.11..e111'..1»11.1.11z.1n. nucnmmnu-11:14:21: 3 1.1o.1111:.. 11111.11... 1.111.. sn-1111 111. 1.1-... .11 11111.1.-111-11 11-11111. .1. 511111111. Teudwr.111141.111 tdumltun .1111 1111... 111.111.1111.

Page 26: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

‘B.-main futuresMACGREGOR’S STEEL LEGACYPAUL HIGHFIELD

The appointment of Ian Macckegor as newCoal Board boss causcd considerabl: alarm

throughout the labour mcvemcnl. PaulHi hfield examines how he carri:d am the

Tones’ [ans lo slash (h: steel industry and lobreak its unions.

Thrcvisis m Mac! nmu man olomznnduslrics nn Lhnhadz Om—mu m nonnenn Eumpem me last quznelaf X931‘-«1$K!I:lowmnonsa mmnnnus vlzms zrcworkmg man overall Afluucznxaverage nnnaony. Thc snnnnm .~ 5:! Corpom Inn‘: (am pron)ecI1<m for seam mu demand m the United Kmgdom is anal|—lim: how or u o mnunon tonnes nor whwh asc wnn supply5 o unony oomnmo no uh: alccl xnnnwmon man when useI05: :3 weeksprndnctxon and snll pmduced 7 4 nullmn mnnex.ssc-n cmrtnl snnnnm mavkex xhlrc or 47 on can .5 meme:now. wn-mo mom an now forccux no oooonmn ron aver oqnancr on asc nulpux.

The warld slump ho, oom<1d:d wnlh mcrrascdsreclcapncllynn mo sun:-xnduilrialnscd caumnes. In wan Emzzl. Indu.somo Kama. somnn Anna nna Mex o on vmducrd mer 1mnnnnon mnnes (wt Table n Th: nesnm om been sh: mhavst ornet! prices wmldwdt, as won as me EEC‘: mvignon monomung vlan which fixcd Ilightr wed pncns no rul annnoon-nmlmsrs II hasalsakedloxnlcnszrxpnn compmlwn nnonn.-nn=nn—myy prolacumlm measures, yarlirularly rnom mo usn andBnmm, zlollgxide zuath on mcslcrl umono no :vw mem mno5ubm1::ion,Tl1z failur: MUS capnal no Imsl m II: on sxcelnudnmry has deemurcd mo EaslCaasI ileel xownt. Dunng I952zxmggcring lW.D0Oo\n ofJ50,0(X)slcc|unrL:HIns! max Jabs,and on: mull-owner alonr. n rnmnn of xnn Ma:Gr=gor. km ncaa|Sl3(l m1|hon.Themuons wcx! fmud tolakn: n m per Drnlwas cut

nnomcnuy much nfmc Ymgtsnmx afmmvry needzd no onmome now sue! mm, m an 5:mHnduxui:lIs<doonnonrnos cam:from us nno Ermsh banks, nnynnngnnmg m‘ mm m xdauvepower «non. xhurunufasluflng no m: finlnucmom in mclwuzconmmtj. Macfiugm up! ncd no no; Oomrnnns SrleclCommune: on man and lnduslry ncsaxr ‘(B1131 not Innnoomnn no nno nuxkcxs Ion 2 plopuninn or men! pmducls mEurops, mo beuzr my can mac: mz cnonnnn they borruwrdrnom European banl<:r:," The Erimh pnvalc gnoeuonnsnnnnnonnxccmr has ofcnurscymefully bnughl the d\c.Iv<s|qua.\ilysL:c|nvaihhle, causing xmpom (ram uh: Thud wonno no flouhlz mm: onsn year. In Lh: us noo Imports look a mono 22 per remmanknn shareThe 1o.-non nnnncsyTkmsxeehnduxuy ms acuxiaxnguinca on; !nnhzTon¢5' plzruno cmwen In: umans no naonnzmnynowork pracncm‘, whitemcxmmisn pohcics send [hr mum (and some non so w:akycompanies Lo HI: wall in me gmn rnmmunng of nnnn Cm-yom—nnon Key no non; approach L: Ih: rcdumon ofwagccusu, mnmuugh mcxeunlyuccnumfaronelhixd nhhuoul-:nsu1rI mesuck nnannnnny This grand plan was wmained nn mt nowlammux Kndlcy Krpon, nn xmcmzl Tory dacumznl publnhcdbeforr mo Tents umk omc=. an lislrd {our caugoriex orunions, according no milixalvry, and Ilnonyl \’1'I0‘.<:In categoryam no be lakcn on firu war: no: gm; n m. 1-rm earn: as nosurp no Ian:-suffering militants m In: momnny The mansled nnnnon, mt lmn and snoon Trads Confcdcrauon, had non

TABLEITERNAHONAL GROWTH OF STEEL

PRODUCTION

3 Wm’ E2‘? 3?v

E 313% Z“?

A nsolnn —,nna:1 =1

.. ::;::*~-~ :3 :3ns :mo, :22 2: V

;: ::é:: zor: 2::: cm ms 3;

TM KrvnIr|AS-@(§ V!-olunuu m~vnu>umljuvA<r»<\

V

'n..n....om Iran: ..n om Vnxnrwr. om mnnn..n Yuvhwk ma

lad: nsnunal mike Karoverflyrars,and nsnnnullcmufrrencem mo was me hm for oo vnvs! Sleclrworkus woo onnodcmmahwd by no closure prayalnmz at (he mm momgovtrnmau whtn M.|ch:zV woon. formslalwe. wasinxuumzmllm cnosmnn down me Ebhw Val: wonn,. which provided os percrm ohdl Inca} emplaymrm, on non awn sommumcy.

Th: umons mo were dnsargdnbcd and donunamd by mr:righl Mn; onnnoanncmcy There wt: no organised lzfl m nnnnsrc Agroupfurnmd nn Khchm l§70s,1hc Lmuun Commmtzfor Cansxiunuonal Rdmm. was shunhud, us muluzmx banghounded by me nmnon zxawuve Added no Hus xxcnkntss. wasma rxislenk ofso my dlffereuv nnmni in me mthfilxy, suchnn mt Naliunal u n urmzxtlurnzczwneno mwu, wow,omaoru and EETPU Nammnrlrrzllon hnwecn nnonn

unmn: ix commanplx: onu smkc-brmkmg, mmnly by moxs'rC. has bccn .3 regular [L-alum No wandcr me 1-onnumoznnnsm an easy target.

Ibrnzel slrike on maTin: Tories mo!/ad swtflly afkr max ckcnan and sled ho»Vi|l1:rsoI!:re:1 1N0 pcrcrm pay dul wuh mflanml ragang on

n per ccm Th: |$T(‘ lradcr, mu Sin, dud kn best no '.'.\\/am aonmngnno omkc’, plndmg ron an rm: [we or three per camover the Xmas l979Ia1kx,bu1m:)\: ma (van in‘ Mu forked noca)! nno national mono inetn mks later the rink: Wm ovcrwnm Sirsclaxmmz : nn-nonvnnnnna u Wicca! pl) award muart many lzsmm no no: drawn {mm max dispute, snnn-na mmmnnonn hat that the lack on on zffzcnve naumul oopomnnonmy mo in lcadusmp mom Slrs no snoonny nnmnn mo xemls 0!U1: nnk: no maga, nms nn proud xmpmuble non mt sonnmWal: uzclwnrkels no [ml Lhur fear: ornoo Iomnnno Lb: Mrnnonnn slnke. zspecmfly when mannannn mus nnxn somoVarksmrrhid n low oonsononnmm on me jobxxmu Olcmuscsnmno me ruc mo may best msabomg: me thanusolwxnnrmg the smk: omnflu. nn wok SH: 25 am no b< ronooannn callonnn xsrc members m we pnvxlc mnon, and xemndzryyuckehng not 312:! usfls was nomnn nn-onnw ufruzlly, Nay wasminus solxdanly lcnon orga|I\s(d hy me mc. though on [hedxymesxrlkewascalledoffannuunalwlidzriIym'i.k<wasx|Ir—mi; Man) rank xnd file bodnts lvvura-1 onndm me sunk:umlmg worker: on [ht various unmns no n challsme no me 15lndushup. um me kn was noo M-ak Lo monmn an {Ha-.1.'wc onLiana! oooos' on

Page 27: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

Iln Mlnfimgnr urlveiThe fans M the Sonlh Wah.-s shaclworkcn .onn Ffuvcdsusnned Ian M¢:Gr=gor was npflouned me! boss and byDrcanhzr new working In Tha(ch:1’= bnafxn muonalxse xh:mdusixv in mm Mn by wsz/3, nna Pmduccd his Cnrpnml:nnn Thc warkfnrcc was to h: xlnuhed (mm mama to|W.000n wagcs m bc (mun for sxx months, and snvcnfl nkmtsMr: to close. Kmh Joseph lhtn brand“ III the Irma and StudAcuoendB50: \m\1—makmg mnnapalvfo pzvemewayw mupnvamaunn

1'h:r:1ns now msmry hxcerdmgMadjrrgnrkuryvc, thewurklomc plnmmnvd (ram noemoin Dexmber I979mx2,urKJIn January 1953 mm m: Dminruon far Dbcrnlbrr um yeardown is 76,000 ‘S|1mhne‘,M the nnn nn. quamlly llmwn. hasbemmz nnnmnn, n;m:massn¢rv hasgont farbevnnd rv<n ((1:1960:pifidowxcs pmgranun: Nolhasxhrrzbren my nnhounlDav awzrd C: III: suit: (lb: mwu exkinutu mm wim lossuf mm rrremmm payments sum: wurkcisarc nvw an nnmnmn564 :| xxrek WDISE um, and decade; ufuman agrcnncmi haveum mm uvmxhzfiucsx Iur ‘ll\u||\mavImrIg'. wuh workcrsdnrmg omers Jobs

The moves [owardt nnammnnn haw: Vern much of 556':plan: nmn offm pm/ave mmxactoxs, and us mnmy profitablecmmnlcnon wing, Redpaxh Dnnlun Lung‘ W115 sold n. meknuckdown pnceofilfl mllhmu ta fralzlgar nnnnnn um ma—

JarHSCprivmecolII)7nIucsln\1alsnbeen mnnnan. nn axxemvtto dust dawn dnvlicalrnvfntunnsvnorxo hxndu|3L:v::rcnurc.I: no mu: DI-nu: scum n my betom: profitable. Thos: nnpuverished mmnuws. am. and l,ov|rIm. are two 0! me mambenekucmls

snnn nnpreczdzmed, rlmd change: m the mdnxlry couldno. have barn zchicvrdwlmuul lhwulxurrcndcr uflhe |sTcEuadcnhip Tm: has nnny cmboldenad MauGncgor and III:Tours who have adapted us m:IrLIg(mcnL mcmuds. andvynlufly piayad nfl d|H:rzN swgflphml arms Igamsx an:another unongn xuccesmd) rumonrmg mt unsure of a(Hen: planls among m: 3:; rs»: yuanwern, Pan mm, Re ,nnn, Kavenscvang and ScunLhnrp(). Macfirrgnrhas wamed An,[bur scnngeu mexvecl dfizsamv: truzmrnl .n Linc ma] induslHzomlmod nn vizw uf memlc n; the umuns n, endorsing n Ima: mu m: nanmlll Est: ‘uahle formula’. -un. buunm: .,not run like a wmmunm ad! on wul u:uns:nsus,' Du: dcclarcd.

1:» luluve (mine indnnnrm aepm of «h: xnusion wok mg Tories by xurpnst. Onemm nfall pvwale xlul mm are m dangtral Ialdmg, and theens): nu svhrkcd mws among lhr rum mtmszlves UYEI theDmslblc Kala! closure of an: of ma xnlegmwi plnnn :5Maccvrcgur rewmmmded. semwy or Sale {nr IndmlryPatrick Jenxnns. ran zxamvlz. long!“ we relam Rawnsrramai asLee[—mxk.\nE17L\nl. Hefearsan mcrcassd import mu Ilcavmly.3 an ma lar. causing higher costs {or am In

pnvalt cnpnal.Nevtrlimless ha nn. nnmoma Ma:Gv:gnr Io reduce me pr¢—

wm mmmulmcnl to nu Imllmn mnnesz ynr mzmmd capachLy, in capacity wxm mn prescm wnrkfnrcc Lpulrnuzl mnpnzwuh .3 hugger wurklanx at nsc n 215 mxlhon). nnnsMaciivrvgur 1: auzmmnls an am the flu fimshmx ban ofRavemcmg Plum. and m Iranafer H5 )mn—fi!\|Sl\ed sled w aneuhnx us Dlam. Vchnncm apponunn m we plan has comefrom an: us cnngm, whwh m n H)! hank door ma)’ nnmdunpon controls‘ mt us watkfnrca. wmcn {ears ms ms: of usown sleehmkmg phm, nna mm ma xswc Such nnznmbusuutss deal: could well be a Iourxmncr for Yuxurz anmlllcrnuus, specially wius me EEC

Th: fnlurl: Inr slscl .: \nLmIIl<l:/ bound uv mm um ol thesxzzlquxng mauuIM:Iurms mdnslry m Bnxam. on: quarler orwhich has 90 hr dmppemu under me Tone: (See Tubls 2 k1; Wm: xh: hkcly Eula in mama Rml and the Nabonxl Coalbnard. mu wimouunyzxpnrl led gvowm Imm mismmn, themarket farBS»Cne¢lw|||:hrink cven rum when m. small nnmm has Dcmrcd am. Tory llardllnus 2:: nm in cnnmmed

3:-iflsh FeaturesTABLE 2

xnau of Ymduclinn fur Manufaclurinz(lalcsl Iluarlcr change on 19791

UKFnmc:w CummnIran94 nn. —

Ne(hcv\znd> .Luxeruhwrl —

Denmark .Imam}

cm:UMmunBmuh Buxmtn no Dace

53%;:

:5:iss5:sas:

TABLE 3Cnnxnmp an at finished man

In umusxry umnvI979:»Uige/

M214/Iannnnm I nmnsmplmumns 11».(‘mmruc1mn 21 7-vnE\:c(rIca\ Ellzumcrmzi Is sruMzchanmmfingvlcvsrlng \ n 114Mamr mum : mHaflau Wu: 7 anW|l::|nd‘MwM:nMa<1uver« 7 (M-VaAH Oxhu lmlunms |1S"n

nnn — mm ~ InEmail Eusmex 4: Dcccmhm

§

n3§

:n2-wal us uh ms ~s:.. .n.n to am... nwlyudlndlnnxa

Page 28: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

3i-iflsli FeaturesIboul iiiii proioecl evtn iiiiiiiiii m:ha|iQlHndu:1Yy I!\l:rC:|V.‘dsucl iiiiiiiniiinn dllflrlg 1979-El. whil: {he West Gvrmnn in»duslry hcld ii Lovlslam. Th:n<:h(1'£ iiian IQ in znmi in iiigiilrchrmlog) and high added Value mdllflrits iiicii 33 inimi-ekcflonlcslndiiimiininiinicaiioni. wiiamiiiia bthtllsr KhanDVZfS€I$ Qlpllfll mini Jnrun aiiii XVI: usn iiaiiang DDEl1h())\>hem and ditllung dimniaii lE(YlV.$0’¢l|\DID)’D|ClIX? And whaliiciiii piam [D ,inii inan HIDKE aim dtvailiilcd by slrel andniannrami iii; Clcxlflts, likz saiiiii Wilts aim Ccnlralscaiinna, iiiiii |l1:I(g(d|IA: inii iiiiis cxflflplionsallfl iiieiaiiim(0 iniiiiinaiioiiaii. and iin-ii pkllllful iunpiy of cviaaii label",no! iini VJIDLE mmiwiiikm iiiiaiiii in ml)’ lhtir iiwiiDMSMESSCX iiiiiii Iedllndincy murky iini aka iiniiii wiiii nnLIVIYOH :xvu'1cnte7

-nins siiiiiii Walt: i. now HI: kidmg aiia for Japzncs: in—

Vcslnlcm in Hrkain, aiiii Cuuml sioisanii '$ a nzw -iiiiciiii\r4\[:y’ wiin me new inixiiniini W iiiiiy iiiiiinnaizaiiinmiiiiiyiiieni will mnain my. in um OVH’-iptclillskfl11:15,a hvgh IS [he Sula Hifldouli I0 Iilulfllliliullals [D D!YSLIzdemain lo 5|i1y(:| iiaggiiing D DIHVDVI via: paid Dlfl iii iniiios.siiiiy. Fords and Dlhuilul yam). Memlwhile lhETOnI:s iarniaiii had me as mlllmn iiminii iii 3 ntw rolling niiii ai riiiirniiiiii iniiicii even MacC'lKEu(agiaii n iiacasaiyi in KO DrorVIdCCl:l|liIILlD|lXC25X|7\g ai Lllnwrrll. ND dollbl iviiaawiii nii-ii.ly be iiiiniaa aiini Yllrlflll EDHCSSIOIIS um iiani wrung minthe wiiiiiriiici. ii )5 a inyiri lhough Vhalslalc nnniiaiin lo ascare higjl. A iamii asc survey show, that iiii aiiiiiii §0VErn'nieiirs aiii iiimii in fled, InC||Idll’lS eiizrzy Pl'l£IflSv CD1] andKnnspofl niiniaiai 5 inn IOWQGK iirau sec CB|llIlI1CSfJ{£1£p\iinI.v.=

xi n iiiiiikii iriai EL!!! aid [mm mflnhrr CDlH|HlE$ I0 viedwniiianiii

- in the sec win ms! hi im whzn wniiiiiiea. asniiiini oiiinisiiiiinaiiawnaieiiiEllYOD{‘ISSlYDl|§EYXfi lhlpllrmedcull)flL‘|<.€. Thc Dawgnari IKLYMHKIIIHK iiiiiii ls min in iaiimcoiiipeiiinc dmaluzliunxurine Iran: I [ht aziaiaciaiiaii oime pound vim iiiaii. F\’EKId\ and an ii slccl CBCKDKT iiiiElllnpeln rl\'n1Sl0ifl\DBl'l,WhiCkwill we [0 fIArL‘\¢fPX'IK nllrting aim dL1Il\ving.AIId wniii ini fall in [he pound W!“ [ad [0Iughrf Ilnpfifl iiim in aiiiniii. iimiiiieiau plfidufllvlly iiiEnllsh ninniiimiiiins SKI“ lay; SE rai behllld inai ufW1flCu:r—llmny and Fmnne, lmlrlc mtnlltm Japan. Ihildlmznd M“ III’CNISK ioi iniiiom like iiaiiaii wasriiiiiz mflchinei and fridgez.Aiiincngnsminniforincreiiiflgilximx iimiin ina EEC wiiiiBSC3 flxpflrl sale: vulnzrzhle (u piolcclionbl mflajllld .A.iiii‘did’! me iiai-iii KIWI/ltd: inaimeii nee! prvdulihon in ninewiiiia Ccnlrcs, iicuiniinii the ussk aim Eiflcnl bloc coiiiiiiiai.ii IS clmr iiiii tillhilcki in on EEC steel SZCIOI‘ hi\¢ onlv iiisibegun,

wriiie iiicm Imnsyfl rmlzkers riiinscvi hIg=ii‘.xIcDplf:|r|iDni like iiiipiniiiinidniiian zndlht FIKIVSHIIIKIIIIHSUSEIIMSEDTnigii loiscs. ht aini ii to nil in nscz Doitnllillly nmhlahk‘dUWflflYfill’I' ICHVIHBS iinvinii only IIW sled pfodlltlion insin: iiaiids. Thalflhtr and Maiaicgai aainii iriai aiiiain inayiioi iii iii Lhe forefront a! ma icaiiiiiias iamiaiiiiiaiii iii «eelmaking DVCT '||HlYE yiais, bill ihcy arm. wt will rim meioimi WazrW:KS[e:|' aiimyiii iniaimiiaaa cxiiiiainiwiiiiiiN0 Wblldti \h:Tm'ie: (ed well piaamx wiiii Lhurtnflrls w inin an mix iiiiiiiiiiy.

ni iiiinini IIIHVEIIIHII lfl|lI)I§¢Whilzlhe LIhaI|rParl} and mi-ruc hzubilltfl)’ oomnxiiiiaanbmll LYIE Tones‘ flllbldcs. Eh: Rcnfd iii iii: iaii Laiioiiigovrrnment is icimiy miiiiiaiaii. hi iiian ID DDDBCDLYME flu!pioancuiiii ai five iiiiga inltgralbd Sllts _ LIInWfl'fl. ranTalbot. Rzdcal, xaiaiiimisand SCHHLHOFFE

» wls raiziiiiiilycaiiiaa nni (sai ram 4) wim iasiiiiinn iiiiini EIDSIIIES. in 1977[Hz uboiii gimaiiiimii mi in fa: as ID iimiasc Somcmsrnflllon (0 aaiiiiia slzel Camcity 2! Pofl Tflbol mini 3 lo 5

TABLE 4British Sleel ciiiiioiaiiiin Sltelmlkillg riiiiinaiiiin

Srhcmllfl z

n..i Srmv

am nifn.‘W: iiltii‘ ‘i'a“L“l§‘i.nn.i ‘”“ 5.1

ll\l“|Dfl LDIIIIEX a year while riaiwii; mi i2.ooo iiiiingwoiiiiiiicai iiiiinnaiiiy nsc iiiiiica dawn HI: arm as iidmlhled [ht nud iiii iiicii incieacad Qipfiflly

In LIbDul"S XIEW caniiingn Dncumltlll ll): Ilccdx iiimiwiiiims MC nmi memioned. h ciiinniiii Liiioiii la kteuniinii the ‘Big rive which N am iiiai Mich:-:1 Fem‘: iiiiniiiiimtnl at ms; canfcrrncc W a 25 m)\hOII mum: a yea) iaiiaciiy.which iiiiaiii YtlxllullgE//Hdflmgpram. ii aim uni ink) qut?hon L.iiiiiiii~i fiommvlmcnl iii iiaai iimisiiig an Eoncefrlapn\d|l)Ed by me T(\Y1¢\. Niii aii ina Ylmtlneifls mini llflioflIeadm ilbfllfl ini induflry in, iiiiiiaanaoiiiagng. ni: rowuin me cscn uflud mi a ‘thriving iiiiiiiinmiiniiiiiiii-i whlklsiii (aid U1: 3l!II(‘ bndy Vi: warned K0 -imiiaz mt immiii m[M can cyiinn. (lhcn) WC Wm iiam (he pm Ofmilklflg 31:6!. iii havzconpcnmon iiiimii men aim inanaizeiiinni and lhr

iiiiiiiiiiiiniiy Lo mix on n! ma inosi effinrlu lvldllsllifl inniiniiiax oi Course (In) lI|C:|lL$EBl|KiX'I|Hng 5 li‘D¢VlIfl1’kflhIEC(I—iiimiiioiix as Industry Sltctnflry Jznkin nai dubbed H’ in inaiIRE Tory gDVEl1H||<lVl NI). as sin taidi 'hc|P Dllf inuniiiy Can’iiiiiiaiiiy by hawng a EDHBG ¢)(A£h)Al|K|2 iaiii»'.1-iiiqvinigiii dabaiiai by ¢XDO\’ungsiis 115:"

Th: isrcx Campnlgn N iaii Ravenitl 5 has \7C€1| basedan iiiiiiini iiiimiicniiiiaiii. -nii niia dzy Ila! nan fink: ngflnslClnilllck hm mnciiibai win iiiimi Dll siii by an a“—LlniDDSd:lCBflleC0!\f:Ym'I»‘E. siiiv own aiaiiriiacii can best bg iniiiiiaiedb)'LI|ekHAkorlh¢ union ioiiinai, Isrcaiiiim, which heidlxrked. ‘Ah Pany Naiionai Steel AFPKBJ hai a big iiiiinaci onGimininaiiiv ii mllflfllltfl‘ ‘0ve1 500 mlyorfii Cfluntiflnfiidrrgymtn. iinnnaisinin iinii DUNK {x)mlII|mIly rtpxflmukivnrniin s2 xred Lvwnszakhtrud in winiiiinaiiiiiiianaiiiiniiiicciappczl Elkd by sin siis: And SllicnmmfllflbdYJ1il"3¢¢Iu5tii was an aiipiiny man. It WI: ah lhlmnle i1ciciiv¢~siiii—mg iiiiu Mzanwhllt Ill)’ ocaksed iiniimciii -ICIIDE has beeninn by niriiiiipiisiiion by SIYS aver («cm yeaii an Eh! iiiiniidiiiiai ii iiiiuiani I!SC'3dXiVElD miiininmriiania, nol l0mm~Lian Nlltilcnlng sin‘ Dwn iaiiiiiiiin. The YBCEIVL soniviYolkihirl I£|J0lI iiiewi Lhal mm: Callctsximli tan b: won nyniiiiiaiii ilflofl wiui nini, local ludcrshlpi is-ii ii WI: [lit :12‘!HHIDUJMIHI mt" yl:I\=r!n||iLIflC,V and ii wiiii wan iiiiwai.isciuai bulk ‘NH! |}\: 55:. l|fl| Lhc ISTC lI\I.'lIIhEYi, who WCXE

yelzgnin «inc iiiii iniiiiiy xi, (II: iiniaiini lcnduxhiv

Page 29: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

on.mi...... w.... m: sled .....o...Nol ............g:. mm Dppoxiliun is gm... m m: caflzbon...o.. of m: .....o.. lndership. um mm .......... xsrc myVerena: vowed m lramiurm use]! no... ... advtwry lo 2 po:.cy—

making my, 11.. rxccume Vanfied [ms move by n vols m10.11.» ......... has also affilaled m mu. and rzservu 2 Wm;0! plans (or mm. delcgatex ... mnferrnce. Tim: changeswon-Yd havcbcen .............mc bI:1‘urelhc§u:clunkc.ycHh:0'r».-»....on remzin: wnk and Irazmmtcd. u..r.m......=Iy menghl Mug haxallcrcd ...: :l< .. pro<:durs r... the em... ... a.m...p. ..a r......:. usur: ... damimuon by me ngluMany ncnvmx hav: been made redundant and many mare ...demoxnlmd 11.: commumg ai..;...... ...... ......y unimvs .. thennduxxrvconunues w nernemaxe m..a.v.s.....s... mu wurklurc:

‘Bram. Fwmsfoslucd 2., me Turin: A nanonal sma Len .. sordy nzwdcd

... .|.:I51'C.Unfcrmnmrly . mu... plank cf Ihe Yen ... ...: ...a.....y .s

m. of .mp.... wmmlx. w.n. ‘price wars’, «((1 dumbing» and..n.ae.....g, ix wall as .m flu me ... use‘; am of the

r......=...,.n.¢., u...op..o.. szemsvcryaurmtuvclu swclvmrkcvx,speqally when that ......... Imam.» m.oco.......m. .. mullcontrols. rm mwu suggzs . W: .v.oum mu. m...:..o...on age m-upon: ......| umcr cnumncs mducc they c..p..c.., aswe um - ... mac. words, xmpon comrols .....i: nvevscas pm.1...m xack .5 many or u..—;. workers :5 asc nu done — 50......r. for ....c......o..... worked solidarity‘ Thu approachmmcs ..... only from .1... Ermsh sted .......... -w. ....am..npolnylhal mu mp .2. mdxxezlxmwm aux — |hc1:mus| ht:balance‘. say: a us siulwnrkurx rcccnfly mu. m.....a.... anm. an Coast. The nmivccl looms ofalvomer EEC/US steelwar, mu Limn ....a.»...g mm wana ..ma..cm mo.

....no.. cunlmls arc nmyunbad[rom1h:s\undvmn|af1n—Lcrnminnal .m.=. [buy :1... imply .. maugy Ior m: ........-..yam. on ..m.ag.:...=... and workers .........g ... Rave m. Am,noun!‘ Indumy zgainu me wmmnn ‘cncmy’ or fnlnwsleelworkars omms Any ...n...... .7. Lmking up wnheleelworkus rm... amer c.........=. (0 mm aznulxt the EEC Ia.lionaluauons ncraxx Europe are dxsmnsed as ...ap.a... Nor doimpon commls chaflrng: xhc way me. firms are ..... by m:..........a........; who can .m.;r¢. npeviuons m oLhev connlncsm gm me most :‘qoIo.I.snv: working condnian: Wnhduwzlrm... 0.: EEC and ...¢;.<a..o.. of: ‘Farzrus am... eculmmy.ne:.¢....g 53...... \mpurlcunlmInwIu ............ for mu nranyother worker) Inlrmalional xmrkzrs solnlarny 3...: w...k=..manual at ...a...... wauld he scnous vohcles .0 ......sm.w.....m.g.a...s. me. my e...my—.».:s.«x bouexand mgmukinauomls.

wm. .1... rcmnval nf 5... Wughcll as General Secxclary nlmcNa|im\a.\u...o.. oikmvwaymm{NUR)1nuzw\llb¢mcrea5—cd nrzssurc for me no mvnzuun o|‘Lh¢TripkAllmnctnfilml,Steel and final, ran may at '4 Iuwl Irvrl. ‘Hannah the Sir:lzadenmv w\l|dumbm ... .....ac.......=..., m....m...........I ..,.operation 11.. Hip}! . lane: a.... me fomuuun 0! . meadLvix ... me xsrc cnuld .1... la: us:ful|Y wmnlzmcnlcd by n..:lnrmmiun of Labour Farly workplace bnnchzs wvlhin .v.= sI:¢lmduslry. Thsy could hslp .0 max 4...... Lhedivmom haw“;mu 4.. .m.. unianx a.. .v.. plznu, yang mgemer me mmlDolmml .......a...., and ........::.¢ discussion: .... ..... Lm...nnyv. pulic on 5.... .....,...;r..,... m: mo... Pany

Th: mums clawcd (hm way my mm. m dxmsltrs ofvh:mm; m..-..........gpm.;.;.......: wnmur mg sxezlworkzn candc the Sam: w... dzpcnd ... pm. on 1 real alternative ..a s... asmg bunk mm on 5I::| umam, 1.... 1159 .7. ma mpac..y 0! meIn. ... 0.: lane... ....m...=... .5 . whale ... claburam 1 pr.»gramme a. WC: .5. pnhnzs r... m: dcvclopmzm cf ..........y,nm nased .... Lhc rm wluuuns of ....» mas and .......m eon».......

mm.... Hnuw cal c.,........... s........ mm. 1...... ...= ..........y ma mmo............ Semen mu, me 5...... s....c.7.............v. .>....,m...umso.2 m............:....m..a.s.......pun......a..c.............,.e..u....=.:...........5 no... L7[Cmnmuns Xcpon. D42 so; nm. in mum lo ...( mm cun.......«. am... 2.././as froman»... mm, .>.....;. Sumlry

mun m(:H.rn:Ln wnvhd will: .... s.....v. w-us 5.... sm.you]; during ...a nun: mz mu ncel nrih Ind .. mmnlly .mnlvher ov me mwu.

Page 30: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

fiuwavsMARX TURNS IN HIS GRAVEPHIL HEARSE

w...................,............... Marx .. A...c.........\, ...w.......... (395: M... m..e..........................4......,.... “.......... w..r...n, as v.v.... .... n... ..m............ n. x>..... ..........., .-........, n 95

.. ...: .»<m..~.. ....m.......... .v...c.......r. ..~....r..................................n......,

...... .... ..-.......... .............. ......have ...... ...... ........... .... ........»=......~........ .5 .. ...... ............ ...... ....wcml .... .......... ....n.... ..r..........., ........ ...... ...... ...........y ..n... .. ....H-rem ....» .... .... .... ...... .. ...............; av .. .... .. .......... -... ......o...a.... .... .......... ............ ...... ...... .... ofM...

m ...... .................. .. .... ...... ..............c ........w..............».........-c..... c............. .. .... ......... s.......s.w...... .>..... .. ...... .. ............ .......... rm... ........sw.>.......-.. .. 0..... ........, .... mcuphuncally. A... z....-... ...m..........: .. r...c...............ay.....¢....... .... ..... .............n. . .m...... .............o.. .. M...x ...... ... ...................... .. . ...........-ms... ... mm.......... x-. ...m..... ........... ...............7.. ...... .»............... ... .... ...... ......n........ ... Hci.t\wmd1 ...... .. ...W.....‘.q..... ........ L... . .... .. .-......c. ........~...¢.».................... ........... .............. ...... .... «...... .. .... Smh Thmx... Fmzmach. .. ...... ...... ............ ......... -.................v ...... knvrmbicofwcml...........v — .... .... .. ......,..... ..................v n... .. .... ...»... ~..m.. .......~..m.... mm. ........m..........

........m .x......., ... m .... cm... ..M... new ..... .... .... .... ...... ....’......... .... sw.»..r. c.......... Damn; ...........s... T... cm. ............ ...... ...... .n..... or .... ...,.......« ... x..5... 1.........c.,................................................ -.... .... ... .... ... .. ...... 5... ....Suvlck Unwn mm“... ...... w......c........... ........n ...... .,........., ............... .... .... ........ ...»... .u.......m..... .. ..... .......... .... ....c................. ...... ...... ..u......c........... .......p.. .. «...... .... ......m........y.............w....... ..—.........e. .. .......... .. .... .............. ...... ......» . ..... ........., mcpoxl-wu ....................... ......... .............. — ... .. . .............-=.—pm’... .... .. . ............... .... ........... ....,........ .. ...¢.........-........ ... ...........‘l71mnxLv:|lwo\ud .... in .......c .. .... ......4................ .... ...... .»............. .....»... m .... ...... “...... ...... ...... ....2v:r.\E¢m ... .... ............,. .... ...... ......ma... .... .......<y r......... lrvm «............ .... ......m........ ....-...... ......’...m..... ........................y. .....a....... us ....‘ ............ .. ...; ........... er....a7..., .... ....w.... ......-......» ........o.......... ...... .. .... .. ...... ... ...: ...... ............ .. ........... ...... ........_ .... ....mama. ...“... . wlvchranivd rzxsfiun ...... wcnrm ..........., (...... .... .... cg....... ........... .. m7 .... ......“

1... M....... ...... ...... ...... .............. ........c.. ...-...m...........>....... ...... ................., .. »...................... .-............y.\-........,...5..........s........, . ...... ... ...m.... . ................... ......v... .« .,......... ... .... ...r........ ........s... .... ......-...... ...... ...... n..... .............. ...... ...... ...............v..s-... -s........g.' 1m............e...................>........... <. .........a K... .r... M...-....... m....... ... “...... .......,................ ................................. .. ......................y- <............5 .a....um..»v.................. ...... .. Mnrxm ......y .. ...m.... ........ ...... .. .........s ...... .... ...... . ..mnlemvorarvmcxulogv...... .-.........m...... ...... ......m.... .».......... .. .... ......»w...¢... .....x..... z........., ...... ............... s......... A I\u<$<1.Vunlanum .......»... ... ...». .... .... ........... .. .~.......-......... ...... «...... .;........ were. .. myAmcrson .... .......... .......... ..., .... ............... ... .................. ..~.......... ma......mm..............r.........ys................ .u......1 ........... ......

.:....<..... .... ....a......... .. .......y........s....... a...........=.. ‘Mamsm avas-.. .. ... . ..."... .. ...“... ..... ............... .... .......... .... ....u...... .q..... .......... .. r... W... .. ...... ..... ................ ............ ...." .... n.......7...... ........ .... ..e........ .......w....... ..... ........ ...»... ..... ........... — .. .... ............ .... ..............- ...... ...... ......Scnuusl) ...... .......'. 7». o....n........ ./r.,........... .. .¢......, .. .m.......m., ....Huzbrsl rm. .1 c............ .. .».....,.‘..-.... .... firm/vru: .. .... .....m ........»..r.1s>on:\ .... .....a...... p........ nmnhm..... . ............y..e.....-....nlwhax ......’.. ...... .. ... ...... .... ...... .......<.... ...... ........., ...... ,............. ...........».............‘

... ...... .... me... ............... ..‘l7h1lrflm\hY'l‘) .... ram). Hcmke: .. .......... q......... .. »v........ .............v .........m....... um, Ivy ..yo..>...n. .... hm....... .. .......... .... ...... . 'M)uxx<l.......,........v ... omvunclngly ...... ....»....~. ...... .. . .«......... .. vhilawphy ..«...... .. ........... ........... ‘Mnx's.......-....s... .5 ... «...... ........................... .... ............. .. .......... ...........y mamselvs . . ............ .................m...... 1.... ......,...-..n ..=.s.xc...; .. ....c..............Wllh ..............., .... .. . ...... of.... ......» .......z... W... ...... .. .. ANXVVH

n... . ...... .........r........ 4.».......so...»..u.............. ..................................w.r.... .r.......... ........5. n.:ncrI:\\wc..1l<han|e.. . «...»... ............... ... ............................c...- n... ‘w...¢.<..............w....... w......... ms. ..................................... ....,...........-...... ..................y Y. ......... .... ..... .........g.... .. .............n., .. Mar-K‘; ...... ...n..¢..... .... -...... ... .......... .. ........, ......»................................_.................>.. .m......... .......n.......n.... ........- ....cud .. pmlmonhy‘ .... m........... .. ........... ........... -...... ...... ............... ...-I ........... ...... .. .........Pfilllnnfl .... .... .................. ...». M..................y .5 m... .........y. .... .... ....’........e.........n..............................bo..r.;:<m .4»... .. ma..... ........... ..

.. .... ...»... .......... .....>«.. .. ...... ............. .... ..............5 .. .... ......

...... .......~. ......-... .............. ... ......

.....;.......:Marv, .o.z...... ... .. .. ...... ......“...... .... ...‘. .... .... ...... .. ................‘Ana .. .... ...... ... .......n..., .............. ...... ....., .... ............a...-........;......

.. .... ...». .. r........ e.....~............... .......... .... .... . 4...... ......... ............... ...... Thcscclvc .<s:1byaw:wb\Gwyn w......... .... M... ..... mt... «............“ .... ..... ........... .. l'vnm¢ ......ma 5... ...........« .. ...... w... ...... ..................... .......... ...... ... L...:............ r......... .... 1.... .....m....../1...... u..........., ... .... .. .. .. .... ......’..... ....:</.... .... Mmrxnm ...... ...... .......... n........ .... .... .... ...... ...... ...... M... ...a........ 1... .m......... 5.. ...... .. ...... .... ..m........ .. .... ...... ...... ...... ... .... Commnern n... ......m......... ..................... .... .... .... ........ .-........., ......r...........v....pn........w... ...............a .... ... ...... ......,.... er2.........................

n.................... .....y ...... ...... ....... ...... 4...... ......... .....p«....— .... ...... .............. ............. Am» a... ...a....., M... ...... .. movxds .. . ...... ............. .. ........... .......»..... .........- -...

. ,........... ............ .. .. ......“ ...... ............ flemuunu‘. s........... .. .,........ ..

.. .... ........... ... .-............m......,. ......m......: pm... .......,:....x..........-..... .......... .......... ...... ... ...,. ..-.... ‘......“......-. wy... ...... ...«...... ......“ “.........» nflumm, .......... .................. ...... ....e........... p-mm, Wpular ....... .... .. rm..» Inuxh:1w«vrdV.ym|>Lvaldano<\a.:y .......... ...........m.... cvfcmxs pnhhu, ....» um....... ., .......... ...... .. .... ...;..... .. ....... ...... o.... ...... .... .... <'..........L......... .... ..5.............. .. ..................... .. ............ .. .... ..... ......“ .........e...........1... ubandnnmcnl .. cm: ......“ .. ...u...... .. . ...... ............ .... .. .....0... 5.... Hall ....-... .... ......-. ........... ............ .... ............s... .m.......... . ............ ...... .. ‘rnvuenf ... ............... .m............. r......... ....... ............ . .. ...... ...... .m........g........ .. .... .............. .... ................. “...... ...... .. ..... .. .. ......... ..................m...............m...........A. .... ...... .... .. ....,.... .. ... .. .......... ... M... .. ltchmfl .... ..... ... .......... ...... v... .m........ ...... . Inmenubk........mm..........m....n.............r...... ...... .... .. ......» .... ......... cmSuch . -............‘ .z........y .... 4............r ...... ... . ...... .. ................,........a .2. s...................... ...... ... a..... ...«...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...:r....... ... .... ...... .... .. .... 99.... ................. ...... ........... ‘Mm ...........a .. .=..»...= ... ........'... ..................n ...m..... ...m..... .... .....:.... ........." .... ...»... ... .......... .. .. .. .......... -p............u ............. ~................ 5.. .. .... .. .................> .... ..........y....... ... ....... .. ...“ ...-......, cm:.......... .... .. ...... 1.... .... e....... ......e....;.<,...... .. ......»...m. ........< 9......... ...... ...... ............. ...... ..........y

Page 31: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

15.1.11... 1.1.11 1... 1.111.... of 111........1.111...,y...1..1...1..1... .1... 1.11.... 11.11

111...... 11 .1“... .. .1. .......11. .1 M,1.1.11. 11...... 1...... 11.... .1....- 1.... ..11111

G... v..111.....' ..n....1.1. .. .11. 1:1...1. .1. c..111....... 1...... 1.... 1111...”...1.1.... w!11d1 .11.. 1,. 1.....1......1 w.....1111M...-...1........111.1.:.1111...11...1...11.11 n..1.1«...1..11.......111..1.. 111.......11. 11...... 11.1.... 111.......11...1.1»1......11.1.1.1. 1.1.1.... 1. ..p......1 1.... .11. 11...,1...11..1..11.11. y.... .»..11..»...:... 1 1.11...1......1.11.1.111....1.1.....1..11..1...1........1w..,....»...... .......11...1....1....n......1111. 1.11.... .1... .1 111...... .......1.. 11.1.1.11.... .1. 1...... .1 1.... 11 .1. ..v1.111.... .1 .11. 11...... .1... 1. 1... muv,.11.» 1/171: 11... 11 .11.... .11. ...a1.1.1........11., (.11.... 1933, s11... 1936, 1...... .11.1.... .1... .11. 1...........1. 1...... .1 Ma).911. 11.1.... ms 12...... 1. .1111. 11...,...11....11..1..1 .-.11..11....1..1...1..1.1 11.1.1.11.1...1..111..1.1..1.'1.»... .11.. 1.1.1 1....1. 11. 211...... 1...... ....1..... .1...-......11...v..1.. 1...1.11.......1x11 .....1.....1,W. .....1.1.. ....1.111.. 1. am... 1.11..111111.... «.1111...

mm 1.1.1.11. . . . .......1..11 .1.. $1..-111...

1...... .¢1......11.....

PLASTIC PEOPLE?1411...... 5.... 111... 1.1¢ 111...... 11......Va... 191:. .2 1;

-1.11... 1.11 1.. ..1... .1. .1... .1 . 1......1.... 11. 1.. 11.1111... .1 .1...-v.1..11..1G-crux‘ .....11....... 1...... .1. 11 1......11.1.... 1114...v...11.1...,11.1.11 11.1.11...1...1..1..».....1.11 .. 1...... .....1.. .11. 1.....111... 11 111...... ..1...¢. 1. .1 11...... 1.1

1-1...... 1.. ~1...1.1..1.1y.1.1111.1 ....1..1..... .111... 11...... 1......

.....1. 1.... 1 ....1.....11.1 1. mm 1.11....1...... am ............11. ...........y. .1. 11.1

111. ..o...1..1.1y 11.11.... 1...: 1311...... .11.

11...... .....11..a 1.1 11.. mm... .......1.1..1.11.... 1. .1¢...m11.... .1.1.1 ..1..1...1. .1. 1...1.......-...1.. 11 1111...... 111.111.1111.111...... 1111..., .1 .11.... 1.1. 11.. 1.1. .1111.

.1... 11.1 11 .111....11....1 111. ....11.1 .1... 11

1.11.... 1.11.. .. ..., 11.... 1... ~1.....1.1a.11. 1........1 1.1.11 .11. .11....) .1 .1. .1...1.11.... ....1.... 111111111. .......1.1 1... .111.

.11...1.1..1... .1... .. 11.111.11.111. 11.11.1111.

.......1. 1.: 11...... 1.11111... 11.11.... .11..11.1....11.1......1....1 ......1.1....1...

c....1 1.....1.1. .111 1...111.1...... 1.1.1.....11 1.1 1. 1..11..1.........11..' 1111......

".11.... .1. CXCHK 1... 1.1.... 11.1. -11....1.1w .1....... 111.111.1111.... 1111...... ...1.1.11.1, .11 1...... 1...... 1.1111.1=.1 1.....1.1...1....1-1.1 11...... 1.1.... .11. 1.1511. u/1.14.112,.11. .1..1.1..1..1... ...u.... 11 1.1 =1..1.1... .1....11. ..1c..1............_. 1.1.1.... ...1..... .11 111.

1.1.111... 1.1.1.... 1.1........1 1. 1.1.1....1...... .. 1.1.11 .......1.... .1 .11

11.1.1.1... 111.11.... .1..1.. .1. 11.1.... .1...1.1.1111... 1y1...........11.1...1...1 ..1..11...

1.1 111 11.... .11. 1.1. .5 1.11 .11......p..-..... .. 30 ..«.11..11.1.a.v..... 1.1.1.11..1...1...1 ....1..1. 11 111...’. .1.11......1. .1Teucmaclo.Thchnnlends}u<lwhmd1tru|.1, ..1......1..g 1.1....11.1. 1:... s1 .4. ........1111...... ... .......1........v1.. .1. .1...

‘Karim:TAMING THE WORKERS1.11.1 1411...... 1-...1..1..111...11......1..11....1111, o..11..u, M2. 11 W5

.......1.. Democracy 1. 11.......1.11. .11. my11 11.. 11......1... .1... .1..1......1.... 11 11..

wnrkmg .1» 1111.11 .11. ....1.1.....1. 1.1.1.111... 1.... 11 1. .1. 1.1.1.111... .....y 1...11.. .. 4...... 1.1.11. 1.111.... 1.111....11..."... .11.. 1... 11.11.... .1m..1.... 1... .11

.1111... 11 ...o........ .1111 .1.1.1 1.1.. 1...dcwu: .11. 1.... .11.11 1... 11.1.11... .1...11...... 1... .1. 1...-.1111. .1.....1.... 1.11:1.111111....-. 1..1.....1...1 .011... 1.1. .. 1... ..1.1.1.1.. 1-1.1.... m1....1..1s1.1.......1...»11.11.... 11.11 .1. ..1...1..1...1 11......

.1... .11.... .11...1.11.1.......1..1.1111.1..111... 1.11.,...1111..............1.11..,....1.....1. .....1.1......1 ..1......... .1111. .1... U. .1.11...» .1..1...1...1....11..11.1..111¢111.11..11.. 1.1.11 1..1...1.1... .1.1 411...... .11

y.1.......11 ......... .1. 1.1....v1........1.......1.. .111.. 11..., 11.. ....111 111...... 111.11..1..1.11.11...1.1.11.1.1.....1.-1.a.1....111..1111. .......1.1.... 1.1.1 .......1.1... 1....11..,.11. ....1.. .11 .1. 111.......m. ..11.11..11... 1... .1 111...... 1.... 1... ..1.......1.11... .....111.1 11 1111.... .11.. 1111- 1.11.. 1......1...... 11.. ..... ....1..1 1.11:... ...........1...1 .1.111... ..1. .1... .1... .11“. ..11..1u 1..

.1111... .... .1...1..1. 11 .1. .1...w... 1.1.1.1.... ..1....1...11y.u11... 11 1..

1.11.... 1. .1... .11. ..... 11.. . .1... 1.1.1. .1 .1.

..»11.1... ....m.111...1g 1...... 1.11:......e....1..1111..1.............111..11r1m. .1,g11.1.11.1.... .111... c111.......1.1 1.11.... .11.. 1....

r—J1‘.flABT.”§“

100 YEARS ON

easy... .4...».,.;..ma.» 1=.1...1..r«..'.§

:'m:r\‘}4.1fl 113.1...V-We Kw 5»,-1,w.v«.m-my.

.1... .1. 1 ...... 11 11.. 4.1.1.1.... .11..

.1“... 11 .1. .1... .1111 1.... 11.11 ...... .11....1.1.1.... 11.1.11.1....., ....11..1 cuss: as

1

1. 1 .111. 1.. 1.111.... 1 1.... 1. ...1..11..1.1. .1... .1... 11.1......_.1... 1.111.... .1 ... .111.

1-...1..1....1.;. .11.. 11...1..m...1....1.1 .11......1. 1...«......

1...... .1.11.11..1z1..1.11.1.1.1......1..a........1,. .1n...... .1 ...111.11. .11. wnrkmg.1..., .11.1.....11 1...1.111.11,v 11.1......1..1.1..111. ....1......k .11. 1...... 1. 1912 .1...1.... .1.....1.. 1......» .1. 1111...... .s...1..,..mm! .1... 1.1.1.1. .111. .~..111.m.1.........,,......1.11 11 1.. ..1...1...111.. .1 1.11m. 1...1... ..1 ma... .1... 11.111.11.11 ..1.1.1..1..1..1.11.. .11 1.........1. 1.1.... 11.... 5.111.... 1..1...... 1. 11 11...... 1... 1.1111... a1.1».11..

.111... .1. ...1..11..1... ».11.1..1.11. 11...»...1.1.11.........11.1.111 1.1.... .1... .11. ..m...1111.. fiaamd 11.11.... 1.1 .11 11111. 11 M1..»........11... 1.. 1.1.1.... .1...1.111 .. .11.... .1 .11

.1 .11. 11.1.1.1... .1 1.1.1.1.. .1...1....—..

.1.. ............1 1...... .1. ......,.1..1... ...1.1... .1..... ....1 11.. .....1.... 1111...»...111.11.... 1. 1.1.1 1.......111.1...1..1....11,.,1.............1, .11.». .»1.....»... 11.. 1... .. 1........11...1 1... .11. >1-.1r1.11y .1 1.1111....1.......... .1 am...

11.1.....1111.........1..11...,111.......,1.11.1.... .11; 1...... .1. 1. .«171.1.11...a..:.. 1...1.....11.1.....,1111...1. . 11.... 1.1.. 11.11. 1...1...... 1.1.... 1. 1......

111. ....1.11. .1

.1..... .......1.11....1...WI" .11 1.1.1. 1.1.1.. .....r..1 1...... 11.... 1.. .1... ..1.....1....1

.11........1..

THE OTHERREGISTER11...... Ev: .11. 11.... 1...... ...1.1 n.51.... .1u..1.1..mz,1...11.1,mz,u.w.111. .. .11. .....1...... s....11... 12...... .1....11. n... 1.... 1. 1. .11.... 1., 11. 1.....1.....pm... 111.111.... 1.1 111... 5... . .11 .1. 1..11...... .1 11.. ........- .1111. 1.1.1...111.- mu.....11...1..y1,.1. 1.. 1a.: 1. ......1..; 1.11.....1..1.11.11.1...........11.11....1...,,...1...1..... .1..11....1.1..1 ... ...1....,.... s11... 11.11

1.1.. 11.1. 1...... .11 1... 1.1.1.11..1...1..1..1...1.1 .111 may .. cvzr 11. 1, ...¢.11. .1..1...1.1..«m..1...1. 11111111. 111. 511...... 1......1..1.....11 1....1...1.1.11.1y .1111. n............1...1.1....1 ..........1.y ....... ............—11y1».1........1. 11.1.1.1... 1. ....ew 1.1.. 1.1.1. 1..1...1....y.1....1.1..1.. 1 ....111....111...

.11. 1...... .....1.111 11111. 1111. 1. 1.1 1..tuveragc 1.1 1...... .1... »

11111 11.......1..«1...11e 111.1. 1111 map... w.m.n.111.1.1..s1.....-.11.........1.1111s11..1..1.,..1...11.. 1......1.....1..... .11. . ..1.1....1. 11...~1.w11.11.... 11......1...1..11.111..1.y 111»..1..11

........11.... F1-nz<l 1.1.14.1 .......11.... .1...... .1111... .11.11.1ya.1.1.1...111... 1.11.o11....m..11.1........1....1.11>..1.1111.1.....1.s1»... Kckmm 11...... .1..1.1..... 111111.11 .11.111...... ..1....... .......1...1. .1 11......1...... 1.. .11. 1...... ..1....1..1.1.1 .....1c.....1... .1 111.111 1.1.... .1... .11 F... 11.11.....1111 11...... 1111111....» .1...» 11.1.. .1111...1.-....m..111.11...

Page 32: coma · 2015. 10. 20. · WESTGERMANYATTURNINGPOINT GUNTERMINNERUP Twenty sevenGreens wereelec|ed lothe Eundeslag intherecem Germangeneral election‘ which rclurncdtheconservalive

(suDIvIl!)su| 0,5,3”; 13;:/g|3|IIu.u!I unsung(slwnrugnsui ocs/us) ms/0923 ea-runs msmno

(sungm1gu:u| fl) 993 puu|In| J; ugmua '53)“ ml dunsqng

-an m uopun1 /D; xoa ad ‘|fiun;uzuA51u| w sn 01 mu» m..- £pa1sma;u|

‘u.|§yMu[eN\ Menu

pua Amg o;|op\1 unquv sung) -aw ummg uuu ’)|9oppnH ueor ‘snag ueuuou'ssou uqor ‘unalunw mum ‘Amqsnvaw auapeuzeg ‘]apuaw )sau13 ‘mlzuoqawJalxuo -mo-. mwuagw ‘uos!.ueH uqur 's|q|uE9 Malpuv ‘Janng Jazed ‘naming

uE|v uafiugs logueq ‘uoslnog Iamfimw '!|\1 bye; :papn|au§ amzu saoxnqgnuoo mo

la/«B new mom pepaau , auoguumu. ‘spun agumunoa ampuu saussgul mu 'u|s!|E1!dII:\ usuua ,9 Ma: q em ,9 names mp ug Apml; Iua1sAs

Axmmom) Bu] ;D drmnalq Dl.|) fiugxnmgs ‘xuauninoun lIl(l|]I|8|.]1 Eu 9| sump:rum aqz go s!sA|uua snngms xsmu au; paanpum svq |iun§;ium)u| -sauunu ug pnyad

oI\_ [asp n ma, rvmu aM ‘sgrgm p|JOM pu» us 9 am at suopnms xsnuvw Amuop-n|oAeJ m; Iiugnfim pus A|na|nfiaJ flupsadda uaaq suq |au