126
Description of document: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the Office of the Governor in the paper files of State of Alaska Department of Fish and Game Commissioner Denby S. Lloyd, Deputy Commissioner David Bedford, Director Tom Lawson, Director Doug Larson, and Director Jim Marcotte, 2007-2008 Requested date: 04-October-2008 Released date: 03-November-2008 Posted date: 08-November-2008 Source of document: ADF&G Headquarters 1255 West 8th Street P.O. Box 115526 Juneau, Alaska 99811-5526 The governmentattic.org web site (“the site”) is noncommercial and free to the public. The site and materials made available on the site, such as this file, are for reference only. The governmentattic.org web site and its principals have made every effort to make this information as complete and as accurate as possible, however, there may be mistakes and omissions, both typographical and in content. The governmentattic.org web site and its principals shall have neither liability nor responsibility to any person or entity with respect to any loss or damage caused, or alleged to have been caused, directly or indirectly, by the information provided on the governmentattic.org web site or in this file.

Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

Description of document: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the Office of the Governor in the paper files of State of Alaska Department of Fish and Game Commissioner Denby S. Lloyd, Deputy Commissioner David Bedford, Director Tom Lawson, Director Doug Larson, and Director Jim Marcotte, 2007-2008

Requested date: 04-October-2008 Released date: 03-November-2008 Posted date: 08-November-2008 Source of document: ADF&G Headquarters

1255 West 8th Street P.O. Box 115526 Juneau, Alaska 99811-5526

The governmentattic.org web site (“the site”) is noncommercial and free to the public. The site and materials made available on the site, such as this file, are for reference only. The governmentattic.org web site and its principals have made every effort to make this information as complete and as accurate as possible, however, there may be mistakes and omissions, both typographical and in content. The governmentattic.org web site and its principals shall have neither liability nor responsibility to any person or entity with respect to any loss or damage caused, or alleged to have been caused, directly or indirectly, by the information provided on the governmentattic.org web site or in this file.

Page 2: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description
Page 3: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

- 2 - November 3,2008

(internal predecisional deliberative documents), and thus not subject to a disclosure requirementunder AS 40.25.120(a)(4) and 2 AAC 96.335(a)(4). We identified 29 documents, totaling 96pages, subject to disclosure requirements in whole or in part. Enclosed is a privilege/productionlog identifying both the documents produced and the documents withheld and identifying thespecific privileges asserted with regard to each document withheld in whole or in part. Under adelegation of authority from the Commissioner of the Department of Fish and Game I amproviding these 96 pages of documents.

To the extent this response constitutes a denial of a public records request you may appealpursuant to 2 AAC 96.335 and 2 AAC 96.340 (copies enclosed), you may also obtain immediatejudicial review by seeking an injunction from the superior court under AS 40.25.125. An electionnot to pursue injunctive remedies in the superior court shall not have adverse effects on yourrights before the department of Fish and Game. An administrative appeal from a denial of arequest for public records requires no appeal bond.

Sincerely,

lai:::::elorAdministrative Services DivisionAlaska Department of Fish and Game

Enclosures: Responsive documents (96 pages); privilege/production log; 2 AAC 96.335 - 2 AAC96.350; copy of delegation of authority.

cc: Denby Lloyd, CommissionerDavid Bedford, Deputy CommissionerJim Marcotte, Executive Director Boards Support SectionDoug Larsen, Director, Division of Wildlife Conservation

Page 4: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

2 AAC 96.335. Denial of request

(a) A request for a public record that complies with this chapter may be denied only if

(1) the record is not known to exist after the public agency makes a diligent search for it;

(2) the record is not in the public agency's possession, and after a diligent search thepublic agency does not know where thc record is to be found;

(3) the record has been destroyed in accordance with an applicable record-retentionschedule;

(4) nondisclosure of the record is authorized by a federal law or regulation. or by statelaw; or

(5) the record is believed to be in the agency's possession but has not yet been located, inwhich case the public agency shall proceed under (f) of this section.

(b) A request may be denied by the public agency head or by an agency employee towhom denial authority has been delegated by the public agency head.

(c) An initial denial of a written request must be in writing; must state the reasons for thedenial, including any specific legal grounds for the denial; and must be dated and signedby the person issuing the denial. If a request is denied by a public agency employee towhom denial authority has been delegated, the notice of denial must reflect thisdelegation. A copy of2 AAC 96.335 - 2 AAC 96.350 must be enclosed with the denial.

(d) A denial ofa written request, in whole or in part, must state that

(1) the requestor may administratively appeal the denial by complying with theprocedures in 2 AAC 96.340;

(2) the requestor may obtain immediate judicial review of the denial by seeking aninjunction from the superior court under AS 40.25.125 ;

(3) an election not to pursue injunctive remedies in superior court shall have no adverseeffects on the rights of the requestor before the public agency; and

(4) an administrative appeal from a denial of a request for public records requires noappeal bond.

(e) A denial of a written request is considered to be issued at the time the denial is eitherdelivered to the United States Postal Service for mailing, or hand-delivered to therequestor by an employee or agent of the public agency.

Page 5: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

(f) If a written request is denied because a record has not yet been located and the recordis believed to exist in the agency's possession, the office in the public agency responsiblefor maintaining the record is believed to exist in the agency's possession, the office in thepublic agency responsible for maintaining the record shall continue to search until therecord is located or until it appears that the record does not exist or is not in the publicagency's possession. The public agency shall periodically inform the requestor of itsprogress in searching for the requested record.

(g) A record that is the subject of a public records request that has been denied shall notbe destroyed or transferred from the public agency's custody, except that records may betransferred to state archives and records management services as providcd by AS 40.21and rcgulations adopted under AS 40.21. A public agency may not destroy or transfercustody of a record to which access has been denied or restricted until at least 60 workingdays after the requestor is notified in writing that the rcquest has been denied, or if thereis an administrative or judicial appeal or other legal action pending at the end of the 60­working-day period, until the requestor has exhausted those actions.

History: Eff. 11/6/94, Register 132

Autbority: AS 40.25.110

AS 40.25.120

AS 40.25.123

AS 40.25.125

o 2 AAC 96.340. Appeal from denial; maDner of making

o (a) A requestor whose written request for a public record has been denied, in whole orin part, may ask for reconsideration of the denial by submitting a written appeal to theagency head.

(b) An appeal under (a) of this section must be mailed or hand-delivered to the agencyhead within 60 working days after the denial is issued and must include the date of thedenial and the name and address of the person issuing the denial. The appeal must alsoidentify the records to which access was denied and which are the subject of the appeal.If an appeal is from the failure oftbe agency to respond to the records request within theappropriate time limit Wlder 2 AAC 96.325, the appeal must so state, must identify therecords sought, and must identify the public agency to which the request was directed andthe date of the request.

(c) The 60 working days within which an appeal must be filed begins to run upon theissuance of the denial or, if no denial is issued, upon the expiration of the time periodwithin which the public agency should have responded.

Page 6: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

<> History: Eff. 11/6/94, Register 132

<> Authority: AS 40.25.110

AS 40.25.120

AS 40.25.123

AS 40.25.125

2 AAC 96.345. Appeal determinations; time allowed; bv whom made

(a) As soon as practicable, but not later than the 10th working day after the close of therecord on appeal, the agency head shall issue a written determination stating which of therecords that are the subject of the appeal will be disclosed and which records will not bedisclosed. The written determination must comply with 2 AAC 96.350.

(b) The agency head may extend the lO-working-day period for a period not to exceed 30working days upon written request from the requestor, or by sending a written notice tothe requestor within the basic IO-warking-day period.

(e) The agency head may delegate authority and duties under (a) and (b) of this section toa full-time employee of the public agency not involved in the denial and not subordinateto the employee responsible for the denial. The employee delegated this authority maynot subdelegate to another employee.

History: Eff. 11/6194, Register 132

Authority: AS 40.25.110

AS 40.25.120

AS 40.25.123

AS 40.25.124

2 AAC 96.350. Contents of determination denYing appeal

A detennination under 2 AAe 96.345 responding to an appeal must be in writing, mustspecify the specific statute, regulation, or court decision that is the basis for the denial,and must state briefly the reason for the denial. A denial under this section is the finalagency decision. A denial must further state that, as provided by AS 40.25.124 , therequestor may obtain judicial review of the denial by appealing the denial to the superiorcourt.

Page 7: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

History: Err. 1116/94, Register 132

Autbority: AS 40.25.110

AS 40.25.120

AS 40.25.123

AS 40.25.124

AS 40.25.125

Page 8: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of 11/03/08 6:00 PM

Modified Public Records Requests of October 3-6To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson)

Privilege/Production Log

Page I of 22

Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description Privilel!e1/15107 001-012 D. Lloyd M. Morris Copy submined to Lener w/attached resume and 2 None

R. Somerville Governor's ofiice. articles

doJim Marcolle

1119/07 013-016 K. Rehfeld Conunissioners, Letter slanached list & chan ExecutivcfDcl iberatAdministrative ive ProcessServices, Directors

1124/07 017 T. Lawson K. Rehfeld G. Winegar Memo re: Commercial Fishing DeUberativeThru: S. Thomas Revolving Loan Fund ProcessD. Lloyd P. Nelson

1129/07 018-019 K Spencer A. Kreitzer K. Clifton 12: 17 pm Email re: message from NoneJ. Schmidt R. Michalsky governor (InS/O? message attached)

R. Sampson C. HolbertL. Hartig E. HaidaD. Lloyd D. KnuthK. Jackson C. Fishwick-T. Colberg LeonardC Campbell M. SchlosserM. Rutherford L. TaylorW. Monegan 8. WeimerP. Galvin N. KortingK. Rehfeld S. GalanopoulosL. Schebcn C. ByrneS. Parnell L. Wilcox

Page 9: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of 11/03/08 6:00 I'M Page 2 of 22

Date Doc. # Author Recipient Cross Copy Document Description PrivilegeJ. Katz T. VeaseyJ. Biuley T. BoscIaM. Tibbles 1'. SprelerM. Nizich L. CastleM. Stapleton J. MasonS. Leighow S. DevonC. Fedullo. S. BuschA. Kim K. MallyR. Kelly K. ProvostL. Smith E. FagerstromC. Clark, A. Mills

2/12/07 020 S. Palin M. Stapleton 7:08 p.m. Email Re: Slogs NoneM. Tibbie'1. BitneyD. L10vd

3/15/07 021-022 M. Stapleton S. Palin S. Leighow 11:27 a.m. Email Re: Fish Executive!D. Lloyd M. Stapleton Inten,jews DeliberativeM. Nizich processM. Tibbles

3/29/07 023-025 String email: DeliberativeProcess

M. izich D. Lloyd 5:04 p.m. Email re: Campbell visit

D. Lloyd J. Hilsinger P. Nelson 7:37 p.m. Email re: Campbell visit

D. BedfordT. BarryS. KelleyM. Nizich

3/30/08 S. Kellev 1. Hilsinl!er 8:59 a.m. Email rc: Campbell visit

Page 10: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of 11103/086:00 PM Page 3 of 22

Date Doc. # Author Recipient Cross COpy Document Description PrivileeeP. NelsonD. BedfordT. Barry

4/4/07 026-027 String email: ExecutivelDeliberative

S. Palin M. Tibbles 4:39 p.m. Email re: predator control ProcessM. NizichM. StapletonS. LeighowD. LloydJ. Bitney

M. Stapleton S. Palin Time not indicated -Email re:predator control

S. Palin M. Stapleton 5:11 p.m. Email re: predatorcontrol

M.. Slapleton S. Palin Time nOI indicate - Email re:predator control

4/5/07 S. Palin M. Stapleton7:03 a.m. re: Dredator control

414/07 028-030 String email: Anomey Client!Deliberative

M. Stapleton M Nizich M. Tibbles 5:44 p.m. Email re: airborne hunting ProcessD. Lloyd language

D. Lloyd K. Saxby 5:53 email re past initiatives

41;/07 K. Saxby D. Lloyd [0:45 a.m. Email re: airbome hmlling[an~ua.ll:e

Page 11: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of 11/03/086:00 PM Page 4 of 22

Date Doe. # Author Recipient Cross COpy Document Description Privilel!e4/5/07 031 K. Saxby D. Lloyd II :41 a.m. Email re: airborne hunting Attorney Clicntl

language ExecutivDeliberati\'e

D. Lloyd S. Palin M. Nizich 12:23 a.m. Email re: airborne ProcessM. Tibbles hunting language

M. Stapleton

4/16/07 032-037 D. Lloyd M. Nizich K. Taylor I:09 p.m. Email re: predator Email 032-033:M. Tibbles M. Robus control. Attachment: Wolf Attorney

J. Bitney Reduction Programs·Evaluation ClientlExecUli\'eIDK. axby of Program Status dated 4/16/07 eliberative ProcessK. Titus

Attachment: 034-037: None

4120/07 038 M Tibbles D. Lloyd T. Lawson Memo re: Approval for Deliberativeappointment Process

4/23/07 039-048 T. Cunning M Nizich Memo re: Staffing & funding DeliberativeThru: Attachment: 2 draft chans ProcessD. Lloyd

4/25/07 049 String email None

C. McCarty H. Brandon 9:03 a.m. Email re governor'sattendance

H Brandon D. Lloyd 9: 14 a.m. Email re: governor's811endance

4/25/07 050 C. McCarty H. Brandon 10:19a.m. Governor attendance None

H. Brandon D. Lloyd M. Nizich 10:26 a.m. Governor attendanceK. Sooncer

4/25/07 051 D. Lloyd K. Spencer M. Nizich II :38 •.m. Governor attendance Deliberative

Page 12: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FI AL of 11103/08 6:00 PM Page 5 of 22

Date Doc. # Author Recipient Cross Copy Document Description Pr;"ilel!eH. Brandon ProcessD. Demaster

Undated 052 W. Hoganh S. Palin Draft Lener re: meeting of NoneInternational Whaling Comm 'n

5/8/07 053-055 M. Nizich D. Lloyd Fax: anaching 513/07 letter from PartiallRedactM. Baffrey to M. Nitzch re: Delibenltiveapproval to recruit. Approval ProcessIPersonnelsigned

5/9/07 056-060 D. Lloyd M. Nizich K. Taylor 12:25 p.ol Email re: talking 056-057H. Brandon. poims. 057 Attachment: Talking DeliberativeD. Bedford points. 059-60 Attachment ProcessJ. Katz Background Information 059-060

None5123/07 061-063 C. Crame B. Weimer 4:58 Email re: meeting agenda. Deliberati,'c

B. Allen Agenda anached. ProcessC. HolbertC. BishopD. Bedford0 .. MansD. LloydE.OydnaE. toti

J. KatzL. HartigM. NizichP. ScaveraS. BishopS. Aspelund

5/24/07 D. Bedford C. Creme 5:22 p.m. EmaiL re: meetingB. Weimer agendaB. Allen

Page 13: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of 11/03/08 6:00 PM Page 6 of 22

Date Doc. # Author Recipient Cross Copy Document Description Privilc~c

C. HolbertC. BishopD.MallSD. LloydE.OydnaE. NOlliJ. KatzL. HartigM. NizichP. ScaveraS. BishopS. Asoelund

Sm/07 064 D. Lloyd L. Hartig L. Von Scheber 3:36 p.m. Email re: Alaska Ocean DeliberativeR. LeFebvre C. Campbell Observing system Process

M. NizichC. CrameT. IrvinM. Tibbles

6/13/07 06S-069 String Email: 5: 11 p.m. Email re: orphan calves NoneAttached: Oregon Live article

G. Olson M Nizich

6/14/07 D. Lloyd M. Robus K. Titus 8:22 a.m. Email re: orphan cah-es NoneR. Clarke

R. Clark D. Lloyd K. Titus I :00 p.m. Email re: orphan calves Redact:M. Robus Deliberative

Process6114/07 070 L. Perez D. Lloyd Ethics Disclosure Form (siRned) None6118/07 071-072 D. Lloyd K. Reinfcld T. Lawson 3:23 p.m. Email re: Capital Executive!

Recommendations. Attached: DeliberativeChart Process

Page 14: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of 11/03/08 6:00 PM Page 7 of 22

Date Doc. # Author Recipient Cross Copy Document Description Privilege6128/07 073-074 D. Lloyd M. Nizich K. Taylor Memo re: permission to recruit Deliberative

T. Lawson Process6/28/07 075-076 D. Lloyd M. Nizich K. Taylor Memo rc: permission to recruit. Partial Redact

T. Lawson Approval 'igned 7/2/07 DeliberativeProcess

7/19/07 077 L. Perez D. Lloyd Ethic Disclosure Fonn (siQ.ned) None7119/07 078-079 D. Lloyd K. Rehfeld K. Hepler Memo re: Revised Program Deliberati\'e

T. Lawson Reauest Process7120/07 080-082 String email: Attorney Client!

Executive!M. Robu, D. Lloyd K. Saxby 5:42 p.m. Email re: Unit 13 Tier Deliberative

K. Titus II scoring Process

D. Lloyd S. Palin M. Tibbie' 6:20 p.m. Email re: Unit 13 TierM. izich II scoringT. Colberg

D. Lloyd S. Palin M. Tibbie' 6:30 p.m. Email re: Unit 13 TierM. Nizich II scoringT. Colberg

7/20107 083-084 String email: Anorney Client!Executive/

D. Lloyd S. Palin M. Tibbie' 18:30:23 Unit 13 Tier II scoring DeliberativeM. izich ProcessT. Colberg

S. Palin D. Lloyd M Tibbie' 6:35 a.m. Email Re: Unit 13 TierT, Colberg M. Nizich II scoring

T, ColbergK, Perry

Page 15: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of 11/03/08 6:00 PM Page 8 of 22

Date Doc. # Author Reeinient Cross Cony Document Deserintion Privilel!e7121/07 s. Palin D. Lloyd M. Tibbles 6:35 a.m. Email Re: Unjt 13 Tier

T. Colberg M. Nizicb n scoringT. ColbergK. Perry

D. Lloyd S. Palin M. Tibbie, 10:08 a.m. Email Re: Unit 13 TierM Nizich II scoringT. ColbergK. Perry

7120/07 085·088 String email: Anomey CI icm/Executive!

M. Robus D. Lloyd K. Saxby 5:42 p.m. Email Re: Unit 13 Tier DeliberativeK. Titus II scoring Process

D. Lloyd S. Palin M. Tibbie, 6:20 p.m. Email Re: Unit 13 TierM. Nizicb II ScoringT. Colberg

D. Lloyd S. Palin M. Tibbie, 18:30:23 Email Re: Unh 13 TierM. Nizich II ScoringT. Colberg

7121/07 s. Palin D. Lloyd M. Tibbie, 6:35:46 Email Re: Unit 13 TierM. izich II ScoringT. ColbergK.PeTT)'

M. Nizich S. Palin 7:46:45 Email Re: Unil 13 Tiern Scoring

S. Palin M. Nizich 7:50:56 Email Re: Unit 13 TierII ScorinlZ.

Page 16: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of I 1/03/08 6:00 PM Page 9 of 22

Date Doc. # Author Recipient Cross Copy Document Description Privilege

M. 'izich S. Palin 13:44:07 Email Re: Unit 13 TierII Scoring

S. Palin D. Lloyd 13:46:07 Email re: Unit 13 TierII Scoring

D. Lloyd S. Palin 14:41:44 Email re: Unit 13 TierII Scoring

7126/07 089-093 D. Lloyd M. Tibbles K Taylor Memo re: Pennission to hire. DeliberativeT. Lawson Attached: Resume Process!

Personnel7126/07 93a D. Lloyd M. Tibbles K. Tal'lor Memo re: Pennission to hire Deliberative

T. Lawson Process!Personnel

7126/07 094-098 D. Lloyd M. Tibbles K. Taylor Memo re: Pennission to hire Redact Memo:T. Lawson (approval signed): Attached: Deliberative

Resume Process!Personnel

Resume: Personnel7131/07 99 D. Lloyd M. Tibbles T. Colberg 8:36 p.m. Email Re: Nelchina Attorney Client!

M. Nizich Tier II actions DeliberativeProcess

7/31/07 100-101 String Email: Altomey Client!Exceuo\'

D. Lloyd S. Palin 20:14:04 Email re: Veteran hunt DeliberativeC Campbell extension ProcessT. ColbergK. PerryA. MillsJ. Mason

Page 17: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of 11/03/08 6:00 PM Page 100f 22

Date Doc. # Author Recioient Cross COO" Document Description Pri"ile!!eM. TibblesM. izichS. Leighow

S. Palin D. Lloyd K. Perry 9: II p.m. Email re: Veteran huntC. Campbell A. Mills extensionT. Colberg J. Mason

M. TibblesM. NizichS. Leighow

8/2/07 C. Campbell S. Palin 12:36 p.m. Email re: VeteranD. Lloyd hunl extensionT. ColbergK. PerryA. Mills1. MasonM. TibblesM. NizichS. Leighow

8/6/07 102 D. Lloyd Press Release re: appOintment None816107 103-104 K. Rehfeld Commissioners Re: Budget meeting Executive!

Administmlive DeJiberati\'eSen i e Directors Process

8m07 lOS D. Lloyd M. Nizich T. Lawson Re: approval for appointment Redacted:(approval Signed) Personnel!

DeliberativeProcess

8115/07 106-107 C. Crome D. Lloyd 11 :57: 19 Email re: Fishery issues DeliberativeProcess

D. L10vd C. Creme M. Schlosser 12:48 D.m. Email re: Fishe,,'

Page 18: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of 11/03/08 6:00 PM Page II of 22

Date Doe. # Author Recipient Cross Copy Document Description Privilel!eissues

C. Crome D. Lloyd 5: 15 p.m. EmaiJ re: Fishery issues8117/07 108 K. Rehfeld Commissioners. M. TibbIe, Memo re: 09 Budget Executivel

Legislative C. Clark DeliberativeLiaisons. ProcessAdministrativeServices Directors

8128/07 109-110 J. Marcone D. Lloyd 11:30 a.m. Email re: Bd. of Executive!Fisheries Deliberative

ProcessD. Lloyd F. Bailey C. Crome 12:57 p.m. Email re: Bd. of

M Nizich FisheriesJ. Marcotte

08/28/07 111-115 String email: Email: ExecurivclDeliberative

J. Marcotte D. Lloyd II :30 a.m. Email re: Board of ProcessFisheries. Attached: 6 0/071euerFrom J. Campbell 10 J. Marcotte Attachments 113-& copy of Alaska statll1e I 14: None

D. Lloyd F. Bailey C. Crome 12:57 p.m. Email re: Board ofM. Nizich FisheriesJ. Marcone

J. Marcone C. Crome M. izich 2:37 p.m. Email re: Board ofD. Lloyd FisheriesF. Bailey

9/07 116 Fa, copy ofOMB calendar None

Page 19: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of 11103108 6:00 PM Page 120f 22

Date Doc. # Author ReeiDient Cross CODY Document DeseriDtion Privilcl!cDrinted 9120107 10:23 a.m.

917107 117-118 Sam Bishop J. Katz 11 :04 a.m. Email re: forward of NoneD. Lloyd USGS news releaseM. Nizich

9113107 119-123 C. Crome D. Lloyd M. Savland 10:11 a.m. Email re: Gov's Executivelbriefing w handwritten notes DeliberativeAttached: Briefing documents w Processhandwritten notes

9125107 124-125 S. Bishop B. Sharpton J. Benson 1:02 p.m. congressional briefing ExecutiveClaire Fish~<jck C. HolbertC. Adler E. NelliD. Lloyd J. MurphyF. Richards L. Von SchebenK. Taylor M. SchlosserT. Leonard S. JoyT. Irwin T. VeaseyJ. Katz T. Bosela

T. ChaDDle9126107 126 String email: None

1. Tracy S. Leighow 11 :40 a.m. Email re: Questions

S. Leighow D. Lloyd A. Mills 11:41 a.m. Email re: KTUUJ. Bluhm

9126/07 127-128 String email: None

1. Tracy S. Leighow 12: II p.m. Email re: morequestions

S. Leighow D. Lloyd A. Mills 12:14:19 Email re: moreJ. Bluhm questions

Page 20: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of 11/03/08 6:00 PM Page 130f22

Dale Doc. # Aulhor ReciDienl Cross CODY Dncument DescriDlion Privilel!eA. Mills T.Barry 12:15 p.m. email re: morc

Questions

10/10/07 129-134 T. Colberg M. Tibbles Draft Memo re: Exxon Valdez DeliberativeD. Lloyd Oil Spill Trustee Council w Process PrivilegeL. Hartig handwritten notes

10110/07 135-161 C. Tillery T. Colberg Draft Memo re: Use of Settlement Attorney ClientJR.Lovett D. Lloyd funds Deliberative

L. Hanig Process10/19/07 162-177 J. Katz T. Colberg S. Parnell 7:28 a.m. Email re: Annette Email 162:

D. Lloyd L. Persily Island Reserve; Attachments Executive!M. Nizich C. Crome Metlakatla documents (proposal, DeliberativeC. Tillery justification, map) Process

Attachments 163-177: None

12103/07 178-186 T. Lawson K. Rehfeld D. Lloyd 2:51 p.m. Email and attachment ExecutiveJJ. Brown D. Bedford re: Federal funding DeliberativeK. Mauseth J. Hoover Process

1/4/08 187 String email: 3:23 p.m. Email re: Dept. Executive!infonuation Deliberative

B. Leschper A. Kreitzer ProcessE. NottiJ. SchmidtB. TIlompsonL. HanigD. LloydK. JacksonC. BishopT. ColbergC. CampbellT. Irwinw. MoneganP. Galvin

Page 21: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of 11/03108 6:00 PM Page 14 of 22

Date Doc. # Author Recipient Cross Copy Document Description PrivilegeL. Von Scheben

D. Lloyd B. Leschpcr M. Nizich 9:35 a.m. Email re: ADF&GC. Crome

1/11/08 188-200 String email: None

T.Barry D. Lloyd M. Schlosser 11 :32 a.m. Email with no subjectline

D. Lloyd M. Tibbles T. Barry 12:07 p.m. Email re: ADF&GM. Nizich R. Kelly license fees. Attachments:

K. Taylor (1)1/11/08 Draft Memo to D.D. Larsen Lloyd re: Military Licenses; (2)T. Lawson 4/2107 Fiscal note: (3) CY206M. Schlosser Military License & Tag

Comparison. (4) Legislative Bill,

1/12/07 201-202 String email: Attorney ClientPrivilege!

K. Wright T. Barry M. Schlosser 11: 18 a.m. email re Military DeliberativeD. Larsen hunting and fishing licenses, Process PrivilegeR. Clarke Attachment Draft cy2006 MilitaryL. Nelson License and Tag Comparison \V

handwritten notations

2:55 p.m. email1/1 0/07 TBarry D. Larsen M. Schlosser

R. ClarkeK. WrightL. Nelson

II: 10 a.lll. email partial header1/1 0/07 C. Huggins D. Lloyd

Page 22: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of 11/03/08 6:00 PM Page 150f22

Date Doc. # Author Recioient Cross CoOy Document Descriotion Privilel!eM. Schlosser

2/221008 203-205 D. Lloyd S. Palin M. Tibbles 3:42 p.m. Email Re: Attorney Client!M. Nizich wolves/caribou. Attached F&G Executive!K. Saxby draft proposal DeliberativeJ. Katz Process

2122108 206-210 D. Lloyd S. Palin M. Tibbles 3:42p.m. Email re: Anomey Client!M. Nizich wolveslcaribou. Al1ach F& G ExecutivelK. Saxby draft proposal DeliberativeJ. Katz Process

D. Lloyd S. Palin M. Tibbles 3:46 p.m. Email re:M. izich wolves/caribou. Attach F& GK. Saxby draft proposal1. Katz

3/4/08 211-217 L. Hanig M. Tibbles D. Lloyd 5:15 p.m. Email re: EVOS Executive!T. Colberg briefing. Attached: 3/6/08 Memo DeliberativeT. Irwin from M. Tibbles to T. Colberg, D. ProcessR. Lefebvre Lloyd, L. Hanig; & 10/12107

Memo from R. LeFebvre. C. Friesto T. Colberg; D. Lloyd, L. Hanig

3/17/08 218-222 String email: None

John Sodrel K Tibbles aoe 1:55 p.m. Emal re: predatorWolf comments aocpac control.K. Taylor hunterheritagefouD. Lloyd ndationakJ. Soukup info(gproteclmoosD. Larsen e.tomR. Clark Office@alaskaK TilUS prohulltcr.orgG. Hilderbrand J. KutschG Delfrate Kelly

Page 23: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of 11/03/08 6:00 PM Page 160f 22

Date Doe. # Author Recipient Cross COpy Document Description Priyilel!ePubinfor3 R. FithianD. James N. WebsterR. Nowlin akpenE. Becker N. WebsterM.NcNay AlaskanateB. Bell T. HeperrinsC. Fleener M. LitzenC. Judkins HuntingT. Spraker WildsueJ. Cliff InfoB Grussendorf L. LewlsR. Burley M BurdickC. Fleener FishartB. Bell CredilcardmikeB. Lewis AdminGovernor PresidentS. Palin Akhunter

VicepresidcntMmmanTreasurerB. Wanamike

B. Bell J. Sodrel Time nol indicated. Email rc:predator control

J. Sodrel K Tibbles ane 9:56 a.m. Email re: predatorWolfcomments aocpac controlK. Taylor hunterheritagefouD. Lloyd ndationakJ. Soukup info@protectmoosD. Larsen e.comR. Clark Office@alaska

Page 24: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of 11/03/08 6:00 PM Page 17 of 22

Date Doe. # Author Recipient Cross Copv Document Description Privilel!eKTitus prohunler.orgG. Hilderbrand J. KutschG Delfrale KellyPubinfor3 R. FithianD. James N. WebsterR. owlin akpenE. Becker N. WebsterM. NcNay AlaskanateB. Bell T. I-IeperrinsC. Fleener M. LitzenC. Judkins HuntingT. praker WildsueJ. Cliff [nfa8 Grussendorf L. LewisR. Burley M BurdickC. Fleener FishartB. Bell CreditcardmikeB. Lewis AdminGovernor PresidentS. Palin Akhunter

VicepresidenlMtnmanTreasurerB. Wanamike

Eddie B. Bell Not indicated Time not indicated. Email to B.<mtnman Bell re: predator control

J. Sodrel Same list as above Same list as above 9:56 a.m. Email re: predatorcontrol

3/18/08 B. Bell J. Sodrel K. Tibbles 10:49 a.m. Email rc: Dredator

Page 25: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of 11103/08 6:00 PM Page 180f 22

Datc Doc. # Author Rccinicnt Cross Con" Document Descrintion Pri"i1cecDFO, DWC Wolf control

CommentsK. TaylorOFO, COlllm'rD. LloydJ.SoukupD. LarsenR. ClarkeK. TitusO. HilderbrandO. Delfrate, DFO,DWC Public

InformationRegion 3

D. JamesR. NowlinE. BeckerM. McNayC. FleenerC. JudkinsT. SprakerC. Judkins8. GrussendorfR.BurieyC. FleenerB. BellB. LewisS. PalinAocAocpacHunterheritagefou

Ndationak

Page 26: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of 11/03/08 6:00 PM Page 19 of 22

Date Doc. # Author Recioient Cross Coov Document Descriotion Privileoeinfo@proteclmoos

e.comofficeJ. KlutschKellyR. FithianAkpenN. WebsterAlaskanateT. HeperrinsM. LitzenHuntingWildsueInfoL. LewisM. BurdickFishartCreditcardmikeAdminPresidentAkhunterVicepresidentTreasurerB. Wanamike

S. Palin S. Cayce S. Parnell 10:59 a.m. Email re: predalOrcontrol

S. Cayce M. Nizich 11:09a.m. Email re: predatorcontrol

M. Nizich D. Lloyd I:24 p.m. Email re: predatorcontrol

Page 27: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of \1/03108 6:00 PM Page 20 of 22

Date Doc. # Author ReeiDient Cross CODY Document DeseriDtion Privilel!e

3122107 223-225 M. Tibbles D. Lloyd Requests to Recruit. Attached 223 Deliberativesigned approvaJ Process

224-225 RedactedDeliberativeProcess

3/30/07 226-227 1996 Election PamDhlet None412108 228-229 M. Baffrey K. Rehfeld Memo re; Request for Deliberative

Thru: T. Reorganization of positions. ProcessLarsen Attached: or12anizational chart

5/6/08 230 M. Schlosser K. Mauseth AlE NoneThru:C. O'Sullivan

5/23/08 231 L. Perez D. Lloyd Ethics Disclosure Fonn (sil!ned) None5/27/08 232-233 Slring email: None

1 Zencey S. Leighow \8:15:4\ Email re: Polar Bear

S. Leighow M. Zencey 6:23 p.m. Email re: Polar Bear

M. Zencey S. Leighow 6:29 p.l11. Email re: Polar Bear

5/28/08 S. Leighow M. Zencey 11:21 a.m. Email re: Polar Bear

M. Zencey S. Leighow \1 :28 a.l11. Email re: Polar Bear

S. Leighow M. Zenec)' \1 :32 a.l11. Email re: Polar Bear

7/30/08 234 Unknown Unknown Unknown f-Iandwritten notes of Cabinet ExecUlive/Briefing Deliberative

Process

Page 28: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FrNAL of 11/03/08 6:00 PM Page 21 of 22

Date Doc. # Author ReciJ);en! Cross Copy Document Description Privile"e7130108 235 Meeting A~enda Executive7130108 236-237 D. Lloyd S. Palin M. Nizieh 4:00 p.m. Email rc: Fisheries Executivel

presentation summary DeliberativeProcess

8/4/08 238-243 String email None

M. Schlosser D. Lloyd II :16 a.m. Email re: Ballotmeasure. Attached Ballot info

D. Lloyd M. Nizich C. Crome 3:13 p.m. Email Ie: BallotD. Larsen MeasureT.BarryK. Saxby

8/5/08 R.orM. D. Lloyd 11 :52 p.m. Email re: radio spotsBishop D. Larson

8/6/08 D. Lloyd S. Palin C. Crome 12:56 p.m. Email re: radio SpOlSM. NizichS. Leie.how

8129/08 244-245 J. Hilsinger K. Rehfeld Memo fe: Request for DeliberativeThru: T. Reclassification of position ProcessLarsen

915/08 246-247 C. S,vanton K. Rehfeld Memo fe: request for new long- DeliberativeThnl tenn nonpermanent position ProcessT. Lawson

9/6/07 248-251 D. Lloyd M. Tibbles T. Lawson Memo re: Approval to appoint. Deliberati"eAttached: Resume Process!

Personnel9/8/08 252-253 M. Baffrey K. Rehfeld Memo re: Reclassification Deliberative

Thnl: T. Request. Auached: Chan ProcessLawson

Page 29: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

FINAL of 11103/08 6:00 PM Page 22 of 22

Date Doc. # Author Recipient Cross COpy Document Description Privileee9/9/08 254 D. Lloyd D. Saddler Memo re: Wood Tikchik State None

Park Delegation9/26/08 255-256 String Email: Attorney Client!

DeliberativeJ. Tracy S. Leighow 11 :40 a.m. Email re: Questions Process

S. Leighow D. Lloyd A. Mills 11 :41 a.m. Email re: QuestionsJ. Bluhm

D. Lloyd R. Clarke II :44 a.m. Email re: QuestionsT. BarryK. Saxby

K. Saxby D. Lloyd, R. R. 11 :53 a.m. Email re: QuestionsClarkeT. Barry

9/30/08 257 M. See K. Rehfeld A. Lewis Memo re: Requesl for New long- DeliberativeThru: T. term non-penn position ProcessLawson

10/7/08 258 M. See K. Rehfeld A. Lewis Memo re: Request for New 10ng- DeliberaliveThru: T. term non-perm position ProcessLawson

Page 30: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND GAME

OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER

SARAH PALIN, GOVERNOR P.O. BOX 115526 JUNEAU, AK 99811-5526 PHONE: (907) 465-4100 FAX: (907) 465-2332

M E M O R A N D U M

TO: Tom Lawson Director of Administrative Services

FROM: Denby S. Lloyd Commissioner DATE: July 2, 2007 SUBJECT: Denial Authority ______________________________________________________________________________ Effective immediately, you are delegated denial and appeal denial authority to persons pursuant to 2 Alaska Administrative Code 96.335(b) and 96.345(c), respectively, with regard to requests for the State of Alaska agency records under Alaska Statute 40.25.100 - 40.25.220 (Alaska Public Records Act).

Page 31: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

.....,

DENBY S. LLOYD

January 15, 2007

Mr. Mel Morris, ChairAlaska Board ofFisheries

Mr. Ron Somerville, ChairAlaska Board of Game

c/o Jim Marcotte, Executive DirectorBoards Support SectionAlaska Deparbnent ofFish and GameP.O. Box 115526Juneau, AK 99811-5526

Dear Mr. Moms, Mr. Somerville, and Joint Board Members:

2660 Fritz Cove Roa.d.h.I.neau, AK 99801

(907) 523-0560

Please accept this letter. and attachment as my letter ofinterest, list ofreferences, statement ofresource management philosophy, statement ofpersonnel management philosophy, and resumein response to yoursolicitation for the position of Commissioner of the Alaska Department ofFish and Game.

I am very interested in the position ofleading and administering the management, protection, anddevelopment of the fIsh and game resources for the Stale ofAlaBka. My entire career has beendevoted to various aspects ofresource management in Alaska, and I view the possibility ofperforming the role of Commissioner with ADF&G as an exciting culmination ofmy efforts.

The job requires and challenges a variety ofskillE including leadership. administration, policydevelopment, scientific analysis, legal interpretation, planning and, getting down to basics,public relations. Combining these challenges with the breadth of.fish and game resourceconservation (development and protection) issues in Alaska results in a truly invigoratingopportunity. I would like very much to work with you, the Governor's Office, the AlaskaLegislature, local authorities, non-governmental organizations and individuals. even the federalgovernment, to best manage and promote wise use of our fish and wildlife legacy.

Resource Management Philosophy

Oftentimes resource philosophies are reduced to sound bites, such as: l'the resource comes first","best available science", or "optimum yield." While I believe in essence with each of thesesentiments, I also realize that their interpretation and importance relies upon context

The meaning of l'the resource comes first" actually depends upon what the overarching use andexpectations are. For example, ·in national parks. WIlderness areas or some strict marine

ADF&G CommfJsionel'Application January 2007

001

Page 32: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

, .DENBY S. £rom 2660 Fritz Cove Road

Juneau, AI{ 99801f907} 523-0560

protected areas, humans are intended to be visitors and generally our harvests offish or wildlifeare intentionally severely limited. Placing the resource first in this instance would mean assuringthat populations are left in as natural a state as possible without the effects ofhuman disturbance.On many other lands and in many waters, putting the resource first means assuring that humanharvests and land use are promoted rather than prohibited, but they are also controlled so thatongoing levels of sustainable yield can be assured. And, in those areas slated fOl" intensivemanagement of galnc animals, or those waters D.-om which maximum sustainable yield isintended from fish stocks, putting the resource first means promoting very high harvest levels,but still within bounds that will not result in diminished yields over time:

Similar consideratiml could be brought to the application of the "best available science." It islaudable to pursue and apply the best research that money and expertise can buy, but there arealso instances where decisions will need to be made that can't wait for, Or the system cannotprovide the funds for, extensive or intensive research programs. We constantly have to balancethe need for good, solid information against the hazards of a ''paralysis by analysis" and anunending quest forresearch for its own sake. The decisions that we make should indeed bebased upon a strong analysis ofthe best information that can be obtained, but we must realizethat there will always be more that we can learn; this should not keep us from maldng decisionswhen those decisions need to be made.

AB for the term "optimum yield", this on its face requires interpretation; what is meant byoptimum? Various social and economic values contribute to our definition of "optimum" in anyparticular situation. Public resource management policy needs constantly to come to grips withthis concept. In some cases, the optimum use will be derived from maximum sustainable yields,which is a common reference in commercial fisheries management. In other cases, maximumyield would be foregone in the interest ofproviding for ahigh density of, say, salmon in adrainage in order to promote a vigorous sport fishery. In some cases, optimum will beconsidered to be zero yield to humans and the least disturbance to wildlife while, in others,intensive management including predator control will be brought to bear in order to maximizeharvest opportunities. Optimum yield will depend upon public policy choices ofwhat use willbe made ofwhich resources in any particular place or time.

In this regard I am encouraged that we have the wise words ofour state constitution to guide us.In Article VITI, reference is rn.ade to fish and wildlife, sustained yield, maxinmm benefit, people,and the State ofAlaska. There is explicit acknowledgment that our fish and wildlife are intendedto benefit the people of Alaska, that there are a number ofways that these resources can providethose benefits and economic well-being, and that the resources must be safeguarded within thebounds of sustained yield while providing those benefits.

In sum, I believe that we manage our resources for people. And, people have a wide variety ofpurposes, ideals, and expectations for the use of our fish and wildlife. Within the paradigmprovid~d by our constitution, we can assure continued existence and production of fish andwildlife while providing for a wide variety ofbenefits to the people ofAlaska. It is up to thepeople ofAlaska, through various institotions like tho Alaska Boards ofFisheries and Game, todetermine what those uses should be and where. It is up to the Alaska Department ofFish and

002ADF&G CommissionerAppl~n -2- January 2007

Page 33: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

DENBY S. LLoYD 2660 Fritz Cove RoadJuneau, AK 99801

(907) 523-0560

Game, with the ..,i,lance oflmowledgeable public involvement, to provide the information fromwhich those policy choices can be prudently made and then to effect their implementation.

Personnel Management Philosophy

Management ofour fish and wildlife, as public resources, is a public responsibility. Theresearch, administration, harvest control, and public education associated with such managementrequire the best effOlts of a dedicated group ofprofessionals. We must be able to attract,motivate, support, promote, and reward these public servants in order to fulfill Alaskans'expectation that our resources will be well managed.

1don't have a singular personnel management philosophy. At various stages in my career I havebeen responsible for greater or lesser numbers ofstaff at different levels of authority. At theproject level, I focused on motivating subordinates to perform immediate tasks in a safe, efficientmanner to provide reliable results. Atthe mid-supervisory level, I had a personal mantra of"buffer, promote, and defend" that guided me in providing my subordinates the tools, support,and motivation necessary for them to fully carry out their responsibilities. At the senior level, itbecomes increasingly important to provide leadership and policy direction, to provide solidadministrative and budgetary planning, and to provide for training, publication, and presentationopportunitie, that belp motivate staff to perfonn independentiy at their be,t. At all levels ·thereis, at times, the need for discipline or corrective action, When needed, however, these actionsmust be clear, fair,and designed to lead toward improved performance rather than simply topunish bad behavior.

No supervisor can perform all the work of their subordinates nor possess all the expertiseencompassed by their staff. The challenge becomes one ofproviding a productive, comfortable,challenging, and rewarding environment, and then to provide the leadership and directionnecessary so that staff carry on the good work expected of the organization. I personally havevery high expectations ofprofessional staff and high standards for their performance. 'While notsevere in my corrections, I do find that consistently applied expectations result in greater prideand higber expectations by ,tafffor themselves.

In tbe end, of cour,~ tbe work sbonld be fun. Leading by example, loving the work, and ,baringthe enthusiasm go a long way toward promoting the best perfonnance from an organization, andtbat i, a ,tyle that I particularly enjoy.

Summary

There is not likely to be a candidate for your consideration that has extensive background in allof the various aspects offish and wildlife management in Aiaska: commercial fisheries, sportfisheries, wildlife management, non-consumptive uses, personal use, subsistence, and habitatprotection. I do offer for your consideration, however, a background that is intensive withincommercial fisheries management and resea.rch, as well as one with broad exposure elsewhere:with seabird, marine mammal, and oceanographic research; with federal fishery man.gemen~

with state and federal resource policy, regulatory, and legislative development; and with habitat

003ADF&G Commissioner Application -3- January 2007

Page 34: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

DENBY S. LLOYD 2660 Fritz Cove RoadJuneau, AK 99801

(907} 523-0560

protection and land-use permitting experience. I have worked directly for and with federal. state,and local govemments in Alaska and have had to deal effectively with resource managementissues at all those levels ~lus in the interests of individual users and NGOs.

I feel blessed with the opportunities that I have been offered in Aiaska, and I would hope to bringthe benefits ofmy experience, plus a energetic level of enthusiasm, to the administration oftheAlaska Department ofFish and Game. In that vein, I would hope also to establish and continuestrong working relationships with the Alaska Board of Game and the Alaska Board of Fisheries,the various constituent groups with interests in our manageinent of fish and wildlife, and thenumerous Ioeat state and federal authorities involved, For those issues with which I have nothad broad exposure, I will specifically be looking for the assistance and guidance ofstaff;members of the boards, and knowledgeable constituents statewide.

Attached is a resume of my education, work experience, associated activities, and publications.Below is a list ofreferences with phone numbers and email addresses, as requested. Finally, Ihave included copies oftwo magazine articles that I have written, both coincidentally whileserving as Director ofthe Division of Commercial Fisheries. The fIrst is from the department'sAlaska's Wildlife magazine in 1992, the second is from the current issue ofNational Fisherman.Much bas remained the, same over the intervening fifteen years, while many things have changed(not the least of which is my hair color).

Thank you for your considemtion, and best ofIuck.

Attachments: resume, articles

References:

Doug Baily, previous Attorney Genml, State ofAlaskaLanda Baily, previous Executive Director, Alaska Board of Game907-586-2266; [email protected]

Jim Branson, previous Executive Director, North Pacific Fishery Management Council907-235-2114; [email protected]

Jim Balsiger, current Alaska Regional Administrator, National Marine Fisheries Service907-301-7777; [email protected]

004

ADF&G Commissioner Applicatirm January 2007

Page 35: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

DENBY S. LWYD

EDUCATION AND CERTIFICATES

2660 Fritz Coue RoadJuneau, AX 99801

(907) 523-0560

B.S. 1977.

M.S. 1985.

University of Alaska-Fairbanks. Magna cum laude; major inBiological Sciences. Emphasis in fisheries; secondary focus ineconomics.

University ofAlaska-Fairbanks. Biological Oceanography from theInstitute of Marine Science; additional work in management.

Certified Fisheries Scientist - American Fisheries Society, 1988.Associate -American Institute of Fishery Research Biologists, 1987.

PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE

Sept 2005to

Present

Director - Division of Commercial FisheriesAlaska Department of Fish and GameJuneau, Alaska

Direct the operations of the largest division in the Alaska D~artmentof Fish andGame, with 300 permanent full-time employees and another 300 seasonal workers,annual budget of approximately $60 million, 24 area and regional offices, some 80field camps, five major research vessels and a number of aircraft. Responsible forthe management of all commercial fisheries, as well as subsistence and personaluse fisheries, within state waters, plUS several in adjacent federal waters. Overseeapplied research programs to assess abundance and distribution of salmon,herring, groundfish, and shellfish. Direct policy development and interaction withthe Alaska Board of Fisheries, the North Pacific Fishery Management Council, theAlaska Legislature, federal resource and land management agencies, as well aswith public interest and industry groups.

Oct 2000to

Sept 2005

Regional Supervisor - Div. of Commercial FisheriesAlaska Department of Fish and GameKodiak, Alaska .

Administered all fishery management and research functions for the Division ofCommercial Fisheries in the Westward Region, including areas around KodiakIsland, Chignik, the Alaska Peninsula, the Aleutians Islands and the Bering SeaSupervised 55 permanent full-time employees, administered an annual budget ofapproximately $ 11.5 million, oversaw one regional and six area offices, andsupported two research vessels and fOUT aircraft. Implemented management andresearch programs for salmon, herring, groundfish, and shellfish within statewaters, plus in federal waters for specific species under delegation or direction.Duties involved significant interaction with local government and industryinterests, the Alaska Board of Fisheries, and the North Pacific Fishery ManagementCouncil process.

005

Page 36: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

DENBY S. LwYD

June 1998to

Oct 2000

Regional Finfish Research SupervisorAlaska Department of Fish and Gam.Kodiak, Alaska

2660 Fritz Cove RoadJuneau. AK 99801

(907) 523-0560

Administered the salmon and herring research programs for the Westward Regionof the Division of Commercial Fisheries, involving projects in the Kodiak, Chignik,Alaska Peninsula, and Aleutian Islands areas. Supervised ten pennanentemployees, administered bUdgets of approximately $2.5 million, and establishedgoals and objectives for projects to estimate the distribution and abundance ofjuvenile and adult salmon and spawning herring. Research included not onlyestimating abundance, but also establishing spawner-recruit relationships,escapement goals, and forecasting future run strength. Worked under a variety offunding sources, which required close coordination with state, federal, and localgovernments as well as regional non-profit aquaculture associations, nativecorporations, and industry groups.

May 1992to

June 1998

Chief Resource AnalystAleutians East BoroughAnchorage/Juneau, Alaska

Compiled and analyzed biological and socioeconomic information on naturalresources, and regulatory issues, important to residents and fishermen·in theeastern Aleutian Islands/lower Alaska Peninsula. Promoted and defended regionalcommercial fishing1 subsistence hunting and fishing, and recreational activities.Represented local interests to the Alaska Board of Fisheries, the North PacificFishery Management Council, the state administration and legislature, and thefederal government. Assisted with loca11and use and coastal zone issues,including planning and approval of port, harbor, and airport construction andseafood processing.

Nov 1990to

May 1992

Director - Division of Cominercial FisheriesAlaska Department of Fish and GameJuneau, Alaska

Responsible for administration and supervision of a division with a permanent staffof 200 employees and a.budget of $29 million per year, operating 50 specificprograms to manage the commercial and subsistence salmon, herring, crab,groundfish and other fisheries of the State of Alaska, with a commercial exvesselvalue of over $1 billion per year. Set policy and direction, and provided budgetaryoversight, for management and research activities; oversaw personnel andadministrative functions. Represented the division and the department to theAlaska Legislature, the Alaska Board of Fisheries, the North Pacific FisheryManagement Council1 and the public.

2 006

Page 37: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

DENBY S. LLOYD

Jan 1989to

Nov 1992

Special Assistant for Natural ResourcesOffice of the GovernorJuneau, Alaska

2660 Fritz Cove RoadJuneau, AK 99801

(907) 523·0560

As Special Assistant for Natural Resources, was the Governor's direct liaison withthe departments of Fish and Game, Natural Resources, EnvironmentalConservation, and Revenue, Chaired the Govern.or's Resource Cabinet: lednegotiation ofpolicy positions among, resolved disputes between, and relatedGovernor's directions to agency commissioners. Represented the Governor onresource issues to the public, industry, legislature, and federal agencies. Acted asthe Governor's personal advisor on natural resource issues, including fisherymanagement and development, the Exxon Valdez oil spill, subsistence fish andgame management, oil and gas leasing, and land use and coastal zone planning.

Dec 1986to

Jan 1989

Plan Coordinator/Management AnalystNorth Pacific Fishery Management CouncilAnchorage, Alaska

As Plan Coordinator/Management Analyst, coordinated mu1ti~agencyteams ofbiologists, economists, statisticians, and regulatory specialists to support regionalcouncil management of groundfish fisheries in the Bering SealAleutian Islandsunder provisions of the Magnuson Fishery Conservation and Management Act(MFCMA). Duties required derivation, analysis, and presentation of regUlatorymeasures and estimates of acceptable harvest levels for 13 species groups in thetwo-million ton per year fishery. Also, coordinated development of managementplans for king and Tanner crabs, high seas salmon fisheries, and the allocativeaspects ofAlaskan halibut fisheries.

Mar 1983to

July 1986

Habitat Biologist ill - Habitat DivisionAlaska Department of Fish and GameAnchorage, Alaska

As Projects Review Coordinator for Habitat Division, Region IV, was responsible forthe department's review and permitting ofprivate and public development projectsin western and southwestern Alaska. Decisions required evaluation ofconstruction and industrial projects (such as ports and harbors, mining, roads,timber harvests, seafood processing) in relation to state and federal environmentalrequirements, research of natural resources at risk, and negotiation of terms withindustry and agency personnel to mitigate impacts to fish and wildlife. Alsoreviewed and analyzed state and federal land use plans and prepared departmentalposition papers on water quality issues.

3 007

Page 38: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

DENBY S. LLOYJJ

Jan 1982to

Mar 1983

Habitat Biologist IIAlaska Department of Fish and GameAnchorage, Alaska ..

2660 Fritz Cove RoadJuneau, AK 99801

(907) 523-0560

Evaluated potential impacts of development projects, most specifically coal mineproposals, on fish, wildlife, and their habitat. Recommended mitigation measuresto industry planners and agency permitters. Also prepared departmentalcomments on surface mining regulations, coastal zone consistency determinations,and oil spill contingency plans. Routinely negotiated with consultants on designand execution of aquatic habitat and fisheries baseline studies.

Jan 1979to

Dec 1981

Research Assistant - Institute of Marine ScienceUniversity of Alaska - FairbanksFairbanks, Alaska

As a graduate research assistant, participated in projects investigating theoceanography and ecology of the Bering Sea and Prince William Sound. Primarilyresponsible for a project relating seabirds to their ocean environment. Conductedmiscellaneous field work at Pt. Barrow, Chukchi Sea, Bering Sea, Pribilof Islands,Bristol Bay, lzembek Lagoon, Aleutian Islands, and Prince William Sound.

Apri11978to

Dec 1978

Fiabery BiologistNational Marine Fisheries ServiceJuneau, Alaska

Within the Environmental Assessment Division, reviewed permit applications andproposals for development projects and prescribed mitigation for marine andwetland organisms and their habitats. Coordinated permitting decisions with stateand federal agencies and justified policy positions of the NMFS. Conducted fieldassessments ofhabitat quality and species distribution at several locations insoutheast Alaska.

1973 to 1978 Fishery Technician/Biologist (seasonal)ADF&G/University ofAlaska

Held several positions involving field work in fisheries and oceanography, andlaboratory work in environmental chemistry. Assisted in projects throughoutmuch of the coastal zone and waters of Alaska.

4 008

Page 39: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

.-.,

DENBY S. £WID

COMMI'ITEE APPOINTMENTS/AsSIGNMENTS

2660 Fritz Cove RoadJuneau, AK 99801

(907) 523-0560

NMFS Steller Sea Lion Reccwery TeamNPFMC Steller Sea Lion Mitigation CommitteeADF&G Marine Protected Area (MPA) Task ForceAlaska Steller Sea Uon Restoration TeamADF&G Technical Panel for the Sustainable Salmon Fisheries PolicyAlaska Board of Fisheries Public Panel for the Sustainable Salmon Fisheries PolicyNPFMC IR/IU (Improved retention/improved utilization of ground:fi.sh) CommitteeAlaska Scientific Review Group (ASRGJ for marine mamma1s-advisory to NMFS

and USFWS under provisions of the MMPASWAMC (Southwest Alaska Municipal Ccnference) Fisheries CommitteeScientific AdvisoryIManagement Committees-North Pacific Universities Marine

Mammal Research ConsortiumNPFMC Halibut Bycatch Cap CommitteeChair, Governor's Resource CabinetCoordinator, NPFMC Bering SealAleutian Islands Groundfish Plan TeamCoordinator, NPFMC Halibut Regulatory Amendment Advisory GroupResource Development Council (RDC) Fisheries Committee

SCIENTIFIC CRUISE/COMMERCIAL FISHERY PARTICIPATION

UA~F and UW oceanographic cruises (R/V Acona, Alpha-Helix, T. G. ThompsonJ inthe Bering Sea, Aleutian Islands, PWS, SE Alaska

USCG icebresker cruise (USCGC Polar Sta~ to Bering/Chukchi SeasUniv. Hokkaido (R/V Oshoro Maru) high seas salmon/sqnid gillnetting, Kodisk to

SeattleNOAA (R/V Mlller Freeman) peiagic/demersal fishery survey, Gnif of AlaskaNMFS/USFWS (R/V Tigla.xj sea lion/prey assessment, western GOAADF&G (R/V Resolution) shellfish/groundfish surveys, GOA/Aleutian IslandsADF&G/OCSEAP (R/VYankee Clipper and others) nearshore fish surveys, lower

Cook Inlet/Kodiak IslandNMFS Delta submarine surveys, SE Alaska

Bristol Bay salmon drift and set gillnetNorth Peninsula salmon drift and set gillnetDutch Harbor herring purse seineSouth Peninsula salmon purse seineEastern Bering Sea pollock trawlWestern GOA pollock and cod trawlChignik salmon purse seineKodiak salmon set gillnetPrince William Sound herring purse seine

5 009

Page 40: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

.,DENBY S. LwYD

SELECTED PUBLICATlONS

2660 Fritz Cove RoadJuneau, AIr 99801

{907} 523-0560

Nelson, P.A. and D.S. IJoyd. 2001. Escapement goals for Pacific salmon in theKadiale, Chignik, and Alaska Peninsula/Aleutian Islands areas 6£AlaskaAlaska Department of Fish and Game, Division of Commercial Fisheries,Regional Information Report 4KOl-66, Kodiak

Kruse, GR, M. Crow, KK Krygier, D.S. Uoyd, KW. Pitcher, LD. Rea, M. Ridgway,R.J. Small, J. Stinson, and K.M. Wynne. 2001. A review of proposed fisherymanagement actions and the decline of Steller sea lions Eumetopias jubarusin Alaska: a report by the Alaska Steller Sea Lion Restoration Team. AlaskaDepartment ofFish and Game, Division of Commercial Fisheries, RegionalInformation Report SJO 1-04, Juneau.

lloyd, D.S. 1996, Relative effects of mixed stock fisheries on specific stocks ofconcern: a simplified model and brief case study. Alaska Fishery ResearchBulletin 3: 21-31-

lloYd, D.S. 1996. Relative effects of mixed stock fisheries on specific stocks ofconcern: application to fixed escapements and Norton Sound chum salmon.Alaska Fishery Research Bulletin 3: 32-44.

Martin, P,C. and D.S. Lloyd. 1996. Aspects of sockeye salmon smolt production inthe Egegik River system ofBristol Bay; Alaska. Alaska Fishery ResearchBulletin 3: 59-63.

Lloyd, D.S. and S.K. Davis. 1989. Biological information required for improvedmanagement of walleye pollock: offAlaska. In: Proceedings of theInternational Symposium. on the Biology and Management of WalleyePollock Alaska Sea Grant Report No. 89-1- pp. 9-31-

Smith, T.P. and D.8. Lloyd. 1989. Effects of bycatch allocations to trawl fisheriesfor groundfish in the Bering Sea. Presented to annual meeting of theAmerican Fisheries Society, Anchorage, AK.

Lloyd, D.S., J.P. Koerdugs, and J.D. LaFerriere. 1987. Effects of turbidity in freshwaters ofAlaska. North American Joumal of Fisheries Management 7: 18­33.

Lloyd, D.S. 1987. Turbidity as a water quality standm:d for salmonid habitats inAlaska. North American Journal of Fisheries Management 7: 34-45.

Uoyd, D.S., RB. Smith, and KA. SUndberg. 1987. introduction of European wildboar to Marmot Island, Alaska. The Murrelet 68: 57-58.

Springer, AM., D.G. Roseneau, D.S. Uoyd, C.P. McRoy, and KC. Mmphy. 1986.Seabird responses to fluctuating prey availability in the eastern. Bering Sea.Marine Ecology Progress Series 32: 1-12.

Lloyd, D,S. 1985. Relation of breeding performance in lrittiwakes to oceanographicand meteorologic conditions in the southeastern Bering Sea. Presented toannual meeting of the Pacific Seabird Group/Colonial Waterbird Group, SanFrancisco, CA.

McRoy, C.P. and D.S. Lloyd. 1981. Comparative function and stability ofmacrophyte-based ecosystems. In: Analysis of Marine Ecosystems (A.R.Longhurst, ed.J. Academic Press, London. pp.473-489.

Uoyd, D.S., C.P. McRoy, and RH. Day. 1981- Discovery of northern fur seals(Callorhinus ursinus) breeding on BogoslofIsland, southeastern Bering Sea.Arctic 34: 318-320.

6010

Page 41: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description
Page 42: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

The hail

Senior Editor Line Bedn:>fan does­

n\ get hb photogl"llflh in !he magMWne every month. but ha~ a

crucial part of thII pic:tunl at NlIt/QnaJ-.He's our longest 1ervU1g editor, hav-

Ing signed on lnJ994, whr;n we VNI!

stllll" Rockland, Maine, and he directsmum of cur CCNl!rllB"'.

As if that wersn'l enough to keephim buoy. Ltnc: went to Boston to covet

the symposium on flshIng In thII 21stcentury. """tad by the InternationalCouneU for the Exploration oJ the Sea(p. 26).

NaIiDrlal Flthllrman was a proud spon­sor of the Ilve-day conferenc;:e, whichfoaaed on Imesratln& IllhIng amiecosystem conJeIVoItlon.

u=_In on the finalday of theconference ­'llIkehalder day

- w""'"brousht l'l9ber­men Md lei­....._~10 mull over

UK BedrosIaa the question,·Whar8 do we go ttom here?"

TWOUldn't SiIY we're posltlwiIy giddy

lamund here, but we do ellJoy 8J1dtab! prlde in what WI! do.

And never has that been more trueIbr me than this month, as we -=m­bled our fInt-ever =w shott album.

We put the word out, and your8sp0ndad. We trlBd to use ;'methlngfroin I!Vl!lrytmll who took l:hIl time tosubmit photos (p. 20).

It's easy to fo~ on lJ1llI18g8Illsnt, butthese crew shoD remind us hew muchu.s. flshermen ,cherish !he ure they.....

Thanks to ill you shutterbugs. andto the r=st of you, It'.! not too =rl)'ro start shooting for next January'siBue.

T Ike LIne, Hoyt Chllders, our.L,(;u1flSouth Atlantic bureau chief.has been on the beat a 101lg time, andhi! has; a network of flshennen hekeeps In touch with. So lti no .urprisehe got word early on the dbcontent of

FIorlda reeff1sh &herrnl!f'lat a mandateto l!qulp thelrboalS with vez­...1 monitoringsystems, and hedeliveR atimely rep:>rt

on the contro­versy (p. 24),

My apologis to Rob Morns, whowrote and phOlqj;l"Iphed Jast

months &tmy on rebuJldlng the SaimJanet: 1n Decemberi Hail, I attr1butedaLZthonhlp to BOiIlS & Gear EdltorMlchael CrowIay. Mike edited the 5lO~

-lffl)'Fns«

Northel'!Il Ughts

Several shades of sustainabilityhand, we\'1 helped give away the velue of those publicresources, lI1tered important subtleties in 1evel'll8ebatween liar'vesttn and processoR, and not fully recog­nned that comnumt\1e$ bava legitimate InteftStS In thedlsposltlon of fish in thaIT allIIIS.

Pollc.ymaker. will need to grapple with ewrmoresophlstIated mechan1lm& for the distributIOn of SC>CIaIand aconomlc bene!ltl. Managers and sclentillts wlllneed 10 continually assess tha comfortable fietlon ofMSY In the conl8Xt of rxooystem function. We all wruneed to keep In mind the publlc's righII of ownershipwhile llmltlng ~ea to the resOW'CS among Yllrlous~m.

But just whit Is II that we BIB trying to sustain? It 15

cartalnly notJult yield. It 11 notJu$I: tha lIsh themselves.We 8I'Il promotlng posslhUlI1es for human endeal'Or: theopportunity to catch fish, to eat fish. to ba tInancJally

and cultunlly enriched by these resources, to I!I1Joy thabenefits of haalchy ecosystems. In this regerd, Aiask:a.'.constitutional framan had It light, using ~eemlnglysim­pia and Inn<X:llDUll la1J8ll8ie: fish, suHlllned yield, maxI­mum bene1lt, people. So long lIS we learn our lelI!onswell" restrain ouroelves from the temptltlons of overhar­vest, and wisely shan! tha baneftts of these rl!lilources,fisheries can iustaln many of our UVlllj5 and our ways oflife far Into the fUCu1e.

In the end, perhaps all we need do II sustain anappropriate attitude: to aw>ld complacency; to challengeour lI!lSUJnpdo.... to evaluate the COJ'lSBquances of ouractlOl15. M1

Denby Lloyd 15 serving a mzmd stint lIS dIrf%Ior r;{ Comtner­dB! Fbherlt:s fo; 1MA/Bslu Dtputmcnt af FJsh and Game

. fk has worked fur tho Amka IfMJfflI'f'S oIJJ(1J, the A/wtlamEm &w,il, Bnd 1M Nath Padflt FJshefy~CoondJ. Sooo h. wJD Jl:!W"n hllil1ll 10 KrmlBk ID managII B

I1shr!ty rr=JIfh lBbo1<J~

By Denby Lloyd

For Alaskans, it. begins rlght in our connttution, JDeIIliUI1l of prtde, howewr, sometimes crepIIll'l 1mCOJn-

"F1oh.. .. belonging to the Stale•.. shall be utilized, fortahle degree at self-congratulation. Often we givedeYeloped, and maintained on the sustained yield prin- insufficient <:redlt, for' example. to the favorable envJTon-dple· and, Hke all other tIlltUrai resoun:es. "for the max~ mental conditions that have promoted deeades oi strongImum benUit of Its people." The fight for A185Ita'1 salmon rt!tUIJU, or to the ftu::t that our grounclflJh &h-statehood YIllS C8I'1mred on the need to~ Pacl6c erles are relaUwly new and uncomplicated compared to

satmon runs and 10 protect othen around the cou.nir:l<flsbermen and com- Perhaps the mo.It 1mpDl't8nt adwntage we eJIlqymunltles alongOU~inAlaska Is a shart modem hlsrmy. Much of ourlengthy COBSI- habitat is stlll prilltlne and produd:lYe. And os OW'

line. Flfry years .... fisheries have deYe1oped, there hos been anlater, we enjoy ..~ . abundance Dl hlstory from more exploitedrecord~letting VIEW" parts of the world against whIch we haveharvNtI and,.. from Alaska been able to evaluale OW'msnagement pro-·for the most posals. We have been abJe to learn frompart. continued JOclel and other peoplei mistakes.

economic vltallry sup- But that advantBp can be an toO quickly lost.ported by \:he!lI! wonderful There are readily apparent dlfficulties In deriYIng&h. maximum sustainable yle1l1l. or MSY. from more than

Fisherman, proc:essors, one neighboring nock of flsh at a time. There illIl1iII»pll, reseII~,.......,POlttlcllllS In A1aslta tend to growing concern that we lLI1! eliminating older, andshare a common view thai: puts tha healtli of our flsh- mora facund, fL,h In our pursuit oflarga harvests. Andery resources flrst. We rarely argue over the need to there is nO 1SS1llaI1Ce that beavily fished populationsallow mll\lal.salmon escapements to piISf lllImDlBlled to provide sufflclent pray for their natural predatol"'..t!Ie1r spawning grounds. 01" to malnlaln sufflcl&nt bJo- Almost 30 year>; ago. a notable fishery 5e1entlst wroteml5l of groundflsli and shellfish to produce rutura an "epitaph for the concept of maximum sustainedrecrultmant. yield.· Recently, anoth... sc:lentlst of nota revlslted the

We'walro taken difficult steps to procec:t thehealth Dl topic In a vIew on "th! lUltainabJUty myth."Yet, MSYthe s!afood Industry. through various forms nf affOrt stantlr; as a pillar or our state and national fIIhery poU~

control, and we've implemented Innovatlve prog= to ele•. This pose. an Interestlng conundrum for theprotect the ·Interests of c:oastal communities In the· emerg·lng pursuit of acosyste.m-basatl fishery manage-n!IOW'CllS surl'Ollnding them. We hava a strong reeord of ment.designing these programs wlth broad public partlclpa-- In establi,hlng large-so::ale individual fishIng qUOtal!lon, throUgh the Alaska Board of F1sher)es and the and othel" types of rationalized fisheries, wa'w reaped

North PadRc PElleI)' Mmtagement Council. thl! benlIfllS of Jonger seasons, more Pfllcl:il= QII0ta man-Inde$d, much has baen made, locsUy and natlonally, of agament, and the ability of fisherman to better choose

Alaska" l'lshery managelJlllrlt. Along with a reasonable thair most effective maMS Df harvest. On the other

2 NATIONAl. ASIIERw.N • JANUARY 2007

012

Page 43: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

'.'-

Denby Lloyd

Page J of2

(C(Q)lPY

Cc:

From:

Sent:To:

Kari Spencer [[email protected]]Monday, January 29.200712:17 PM

Kreilzer, Annetie E (DOA); 'Emil Notil'~Schmidt, Joseph D(DOC);[email protected]; [email protected]; Lloyd, Denby S (DFG); 'Jackson, Karleen';[email protected];'Campbell, 9raig AK TAG NGAK'; Rutherford, Martha K (DNR);Manegan, Walt C COPS); Galvin, Patrick S (OCR); 'Karen Rehfeld'; [email protected];sr.J)[email protected];'John Katz'; 'John Bitney'; 'MIchael Tibbles'; 'Mike Nizjch'; 'MeghanStapleton'; Leighow, Sharon W (GOV); 'Charles Feduflo'; 'Anna Kim';[email protected]; 'Lynne Smith'; 'Christopher Clark'

'Kelly Clifton'; Michalsky, Rosezella L (DOA); 'Carolyn L Holbert'; 'Erin H. Haida'; Knuth, DorothyK (EED); Fishwick-Leonard, Claire L (DEC); 'Mary A Schlosser'; Taylor, Usa M (HSS); 'BeckyWeimer'; Korting, Nancy A (LAW); Galanopoulos, Sharon (MVA); 'cassandra byrne';[email protected]; [email protected]; Bosela, Tina M (DNR);Spreter, PaUla G (GOV); 'Lynn Castle'; 'Janice Mason'; 'Shannon Devon'; 'Sharon Busch';'Kathy Mally'; 'Katie Provost'; 'Erika Fagerstrom'; 'Andy Mills'

Subject: Message from Governor attached AND Notice of CabInet Meeting AND Notice of Lunch!!

Importance: High

Dear Cabinet: Governor Palin sent the attached email on Sunday, January 28, and wanted to be sure all Cabinetmembers were sent a copy. (Executive Secretaries: please print this for your boss !fyou think they didn't see it byemail!)

The next Cabinet meeting has been scheduled for Wednesday, February 7 from 10:00am to Noon, and the Chiefof Staff requests all Commissioners attend in person. To start off the agenda for this Cabinet meeting, all newCommissioners will administer their Oath of Office. If those Commissioners care to bring family members for aphoto, orJust to have them there when being sworn in, they are more than welcome to join the swearing inceremony and then exit when the actual Cabinet meeting begins.

Following the Cabinet meeting, the Governor is inviting Commissioners to lunch at the Mansion. The followingpeople are also invited to lunch: Lt. Governor Sean Parnell, Mike Tibbles, Karen Rehfeld, Mike Nizich, JohnBitney, and Meg Stapleton.

Kari SpencerGovernor's Scheduler907-465-3986 phone; 907-465-3889 fax------------------_._-From: Sarah PalinSent: Sunday, January 281 2007 9:23 AMSubject: Speaking from Departments

Good morning all:

'There was a quip in this moming's ADN re: a "ban" from me on anyone voicing their opinions onmatters before us. The lEar wrote ofmy supposed instruction to not allow cabinet members/staff to takepositions on some issues.

Since this is totally false, and leaves me at a loss as to how a reporter would have ever receivedword ofsomething that is the opposite of what Jive expressed to all of you, Jill clarify again what has alreadybeen expressed by me as my desire to see you all have ilie freedom to communicate with the public andpress in any and all manner you deem appropriate. The goal is for the public to be able to trust that ouradministration is transparent and trustworthy, so you all personally communicating views and opinionsis very important and would NEVER be banned.

0182/6/2007

Page 44: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

- , Page 2 of2

I have NEVER. banned any of our team members from voicing opinions on anything. In fact, Pve statedthat the more information and communication efforts put forth on behalfof your departments anddivisions, the better. live asked that you all share your opinions, speak freely to press, public, legislators,one another, etc. (In other words, don't do what past administrations have done. I have faith that werre onthe right path going a new direction here:with freedom in information sharing... Alaskans deserve..betterthan the tried and failed efforts ofpast administrations' withholding information and expressed opinionsby decisions makers.)

I will write to the 'Ear reporter and clarify for her also.

K.ari - would you please send to all Commissioners? I don't have some new addresses here.

Thank you!

Also, last nighes Valley ball was lots of fun. At the eveot we got to wisb Happy 25th Anniversary toTalis Colberg!!!

The Lt. Governor and I are off to Kodiak today. Then Hooper Bay tomorrow.

Thanks for everything, everyone! I appreciate you all very much and look forward to more cabinetmeetings where we're all together in one room. It will be great to have Leo on board at DOT next week.Let's make the next swearing-in ceremony of our new Commissioners a great event and letrs try for acabinet luuch/dinner afterwards.

Bitney - remember to invite the different groups ofLegislators for lunches/dinners this week and next.The more the merrier. Thanks for working with Kari and Erika on this.

Have a great Sunday~ rUsee most ofyall on Tuesday.Sarah

Dou't be flakey. Get Yahoo! Mail for Mobile andalways stay Connected to friends.

01921612007

Page 45: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

Page 1 ofl

Denby Lloyd

From:Sent:

To:

Sarah Palin [[email protected], February 12, 2007 7:06 PM

[email protected]!.us; [email protected];[email protected];[email protected]

Subject: blegs

Meg-

Shoot. I made the mistake of looking at the ADN blog to find out about today's "Sarah Palin theBloggertr issue... Iknew I shouldn't have looked through it!

The first entry I looked at was a slam ofyou or your answer to the blog issue. The rant sounded familiar-like someone we may know. It was ridiculous and offensive.

The other entry I looked at was a question about my ethics... it said I Was trying to get mylIDad's best friend the deputy job at F & Gil. (Obviously referring to the Mat-Su guy. Corey Rossi,whom alot of game guys were lobbying for - my dad passed on a few comments from guys he washearing from that were favorable to Corey.) I just called my dad, he confirmed that I.) Corey Rossi isnot his best friend 2.) he's not lobbying for anything for Corey, he was passing on comments fromAlaskans who wanted to make sure I heard their input 3.) he would never tty to sway me to hire anyone4.) he knows I'm not micromanaging Denby and the choice ofDenby's teammernbers is in Denby'sbands.

It was another offensiveblog entry.

And it sure leaves me puzzled as to the nnnors that are able to spread like wildfire. Kind ofmakes mystomach turn over.

Looking at that blog was also my reminder to NOT waste my time and energy peeking at it to :find outwhat's on readerst minds.

Tibbles - where is Denby on putting together his F & G team? Until he gets his deputy(ies) in there,weIll keep hearing controversy re: who's doing what

Looking for earth-friendly autos?Browse Top Cars by "Green Rating" at Yahoo! Autos' Green Center.

2/13/2007020

Page 46: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

~ ,.

WolfReduction ProgramsEvaluation of Program Status

April 16, 2007

Wolf Control Program Summary- Despite a difficult winter, theSDA permit programcombined with regular trapping and hunting harvest have managed to achieve the wolfmanagement objective in three of the five areas where active wolf control is currentlyauthorized. Poor snow conditions and flying weather prevented the program from beingmore effective in the remaining two areas by interrupting attempts to locate wolfpacksby following their tracks. Under such circumstances no change in either personnel (i.e.,ADF&G staff) or equipment (e.g., helicopters) will make an appreciable difference in theresult.

y' Unit 13- Spring wolfpopulation objective achieved - Program suspendedy' Unit 16- Upper limb of spring wolfpopnlation objective achieved - Program

continues on a day-by-day basis to move closer to lower end ofmanagementobjective range

Unit 19A- Pennittee effort limited by snow conditions, which will Dot allowsuccessful wolf tracking by any method - Program continues; snow conditionspreclude effective operations; SDA permits expire on April 30.

y' Unit 19D East- Spring wolfpopulation objective in EMMA essentially achieved­current conditions preclude effective tracking by any method - Programcontinues; snow conditionspreclude effective operations; SDA permits expire onApril 30.

Upper YukonITanana- Low snow accumulations and windblown terrain prevented'effective effort throughout the winter, currently snow conditions deterioratingrapidly; ADF&G chartered spotting flights to little effect - Program continues;snow conditions preclude effective operations; SDA permits expire on April 30.

The following is a briefreview ofwolfreduction programs conducted by the AlaskaDepartment of Fish and Game during the winter of2006-2007. Division ofWildlifeConservation staffhave been closely monitoring each area and networking with trappers,wolfcontrol permittees, big game guides, and other outdoor users to estimate remainingwolfnumbers with as much accuracy as possible. Wolf control programs will be shutdown ifnecessaryto prevent wolfnumbers from dropping below the regulatorymanagement objectives, and will close in any case when same day airborne wolf controlpenults expire on April 30.

Unit 13 (Nelchina Basin)• Current SDA take:• Estimated trapping/hunting take:• Estimated total take:• Post-Control Wolf Population Objective:

33§.l94

135 -165 ACHIEVED

Status: SDA wolf control program snapended at the end ofMarch (trapping seasonremains open through end ofApril).

034

Page 47: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

WolfControl Program Summary -2- April 15, 2007

Through a combination of wolves taken by Same Day Airborne (SDA) wolf controlpermittees and under normal trapping regulations the wolfpopulation within this controlarea has been reduced to within the management objective range established inregulation. Accordingly, SDA efforts were suspended as of the end ofMarch, while weintend to allow the trapping season to terminate Ii'orma11y at the end ofApril.

The moosepopulation is responding well in Unit 13, as judgedfrom observations madein our standard count areas. Based on standard moose survey routes, counts between2000 and2006 reveals 14% more total moose, 110% more calves, and 176%yearlingbulls (a measure ofhow well young moose are surviving to recruit into the herd). Whileolder aged cows are still dyingfaster than they are being replaced, the newflush ofyoung animalsjoining the herdshould soon more than make up for this artifact ofpoorcalfsurvivalfor 80 many years.

Unit 16 (West Side of Cook Inlet)

• Current SDA take:• Estimated trappinglhunting take:• Esthnated total take:• Post-Control WolfPopulation Objective:

30Q

3622 - 45 (Unit 16B) ACHIEVED

Status: SDA program continues on day-to-day basis to work carefully towards the lowerend ofthe management objective.

Poor snow and bad weather affected tracking conditions and hampered wolf controlefforts in this area for much of the winter. However, SDA pemrittees worked the area asopportunity offered and we have seen high participation since fresh snowfalls and betterweather in March. Between SDA take and estimated take by trappers, we believe thewolfpopulation has been reduced to the level called for in the predation control plan. OnApril I0 we estimated 32-64 wolves using Unit 16(B), compared to the managemontobjective nmge of22-45. Staff is comparing observations with SDApilots, bear guides,and others to develop accurate current intelligence regarding wolfnumbers and locations,and we will allow the SDA and Donna! 'trapping seasons to remain open on a day-to-daybasis to carefully remove a few additional wolves while staying within the requiredmanagement objective range.

Moose research studies indicate that after three winters ofwolfreductions in Unit 16 themoose population has slowed its decline and appears to be stabilizing.

035

Page 48: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

Wolf Control Program Summary

Unit 19A (Mtddle Kuskokwim)

-3- April 15, 2007

• Current SDA take:• Estimated trappinglhunting take:• Estimated total take:• Post-Control WolfPopulation Objective:

3

14

30-36

Status: SDA program remains in effect, although lack ofsoow prevents effectivetracking and pursuit ofwolves .in this area.

Poor snow cover prevented effective predator control in this area all winter. Withoutgood tracking conditions there is no feasible method to find and remove wolves. Thisdemonstrates why such programs must be sustained over multiple winters, so that ifnatural conditions inteIfere (e.g., deep snow kills most of the moose calves one year, orlack of snow prevents tracking ofwolves in another) the effects will be "evened out'" bythe effects ofwolfreductions in years before and after the problem winter. We expectthat wolfpredation rates were lower in this area than in previous winters because wewere able to reduce the Unit 19(A) wolves to the predator cootrol plan objective level theprevious winter, so wolf densities should have remained lower than normal this winter.

Unit 19D (McGrath)

• Current SDA take: 3• Estimated trappinglhunting take: ~

• Estimated total take: 7• EMMA Objective (reduce wolfnumbers to minimom) ACHIEVED• Post-Control WolfPopulation Objective: 40

Status: SDA program remains in effect, although lack of snow prevents effectivetracking and pursuit ofwolves in this area.

The management objective here ever since this was the first new predator controlprogram implemented in 2003 has been to reduce wolfpredation within a small 528square mile "Experimental Micro Management Area" to as Iowa level as possible. Itwas hoped that byrerooving wolfpredatioo from this small but important piece ofhabitat, and by also reducing bear predation, moose calfsurvival would be improved andwould contribute to moose herd growth and higher harvestable surpluses. Althoughconditions have been difficult this winter, persistent effort by trappers and SDA pilotshave succeeded in essentially removing wolfpredation within tha EMMA. In addition,the department expanded the SDA control zone this year in order to try to increase thetake ofwolves in Unit 19(D) East, but outside the EMMA. The reasoo for this is thatlocal hunters have been required to travel outside the E1\.1MA, where they usually hunt, inorder to help allow the moose herd to begin growing. As aresult the hunters are in directcompetition with wolves for the moose living in low densities out')ide the ElY.1J\.1A. Bytaking additional wolves outside the EMMA we are in effect trying to reallocate a fewmoose outside the EMMA from predators to people, while the moose within the E1v.fMAbuild up in numbers to support future use. .

036

Page 49: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

" .

Wolf Control Program Summary -4- April 15, 2007

The moosepopulation in and around the E.MMA is responding. very well to predatorreductions, even though we have experiencedone winter with very deep snow during theduration ofthe program. Our studies show that between 2001 and 2006 the moosepopulation increased by about one-third, with moose density climbingfrom about 1.0 to1.3 moose per square mile. Moose calfsurvival in the treated area to the beginning iJfApril was an extraordinary 65%, with yearling survival at about 90% and adult cowsurvival at 97%. Ifsustained, such input to the moose herd will supportfUrther growthand an increasedharvestahle surplus which can begin to be utilized immediately.

Upper YukonITa.ana

• Current SDA take:• Estimated trapping/hunting take:• Estimated total take:• Poat-ControI WolfPopnlation Objective:

141.

1788 -103

Status: SDA program remains in effect. A recent snow is melting quickly but presentsmarginal tracking conditions in a portion of the area.

This area suffered from windblown, snow-free conditions that prevented efficient wolftracking for the entire winter. This predation control plan was expanded in May 2006 toinclude improving the Fortymile Caribou Herd as one ofthe plan's main goals. As aresult, the area involved and number ofwolves to be removed increased greatly at a timewhen very little effective work was possible due to natural conditions. After a springsnowfall ADF&G made additional efforts, inclnding chartering skilled wolf tracker pilotsand using staffas spotters to locate wolfpac.ks, but few additional wolves could be taken.With conditions currently badly deteriorated there is no feasible way to take largenumbers ofwolves as the winter comes to an end. It will be important to devotesubstantial effort to reducing wolfnumbers in this plan area in future winters ifconditions allow.

037

Page 50: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

Denby Lloyd

From:Sent:To:Subject:

Heather Brandon [[email protected], April 25, 2007 9:14 AM'Denby Uoyd'FW: Govemor attendance

Denby - Below is the IWC information you were asking for.I just sent an email to the Gov's office asking for confirmation on her attendance at theIWC opening ceremony, ble NMFS is asking for confirmation AND I heard that she brought itup at yesterdaY's cabinet meeting. hb

-----Original Message-----From: Cheri Mccarty [mailto:[email protected]]Sent: Wednesday, April 25, 2007 9:03 AMTo: Heather BrandonSubject: Re: Governor attendance

Thanks Heather. The opening ceremony will be at 10:.00 on Monday, May 28th.The reception that evening begins at 7:00 and will be held at the Native Cultural HeritageCenter. Thanks so much for following up on this.cheri.

1 049

Page 51: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

Denby Lloyd

From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:

Attachments:

dignItary Inviteletters,doc (...

Heather Brandon {[email protected], AprJl25, 200710:26 AM'Uoyd, Denby S (DFG)'; Spencer, Karl L (GOV)'MIke Nizlch'FW: FW; Governor attendance

dignitary invite letters,doc

Here is more info from NMFS on IWC.

-----Original Message-----From: Cheri Mccarty [mailto:[email protected]]Sent: Wednesday, April 25, 2007 10:19 AMTo: Heather BrandonCc: Douglas DemasterSubject: Re: FW: Governor attendance

Heather:The speakers at opening plenary are:

Opening prayer - Anchorage elderSecretary Gutierrez (not yet confirmed)Senator StevensGovernor PalinMayor EagiehNative dance troupe

We only have about 40 minutes for the opening ceremony, so we need to limit the speakersto about 5-7 minutes. I think the Governor's general message should be one of welcomingthe member countries to Alaska and reiterating the importance of the IWC as anorganization. We don't have an agenda for the meeting that is broken out by day. Hopethis helps.Cheri

1 050

Page 52: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

· .

The Honorable Sarah PalinOffice ofthe GovernorBox 110001Joneau, Alaska 99811

Dear Governor Palin:

The United States Government will be hosting the 59fu anoual meeting oftheInternational Whaling Commiasion (!WC) in Anchorage, Alaska in May. The IWC wasformed in 1946 to provide for the proper conservation ofwhale stocks to make possiblethe orderly development ofthe whaling industry.

This will "be avery exciting time for Anchorage as there will be delegates and otherparticipants from more than 70 different countries attending the !We meeting, includingmany foreign dignitaries and media. This meeting is also very important to the AlaskanEskimo Whaling Commission. The United States' 5-year catch limits for bowheadwhales will be voted on at this meeting.

The meeting will occur May 28" -31", 2007, at the Captain Cook Hotel. I wonld behonored ifyou would attend the meeting and also provide opening remarks to the plenaryon Monday, May 28th

.

Ifyou are interested in attending, I would be grateful ifyou could contact Dr. DougDeMaster, Research and Science Director, Alaska Region, NOAA Fisheries, at907-789-6617.

Sincerely,

William T. Hogarth, Ph.DU.S. !WC Connoissioner

052

Page 53: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

p.l

",

CC(O)[P)fOmCE OF~()01@WOR

.pO.liOX.';,lOQAJ"'~'EAV; ~AK>'9.'9.$rl'4;';Q'OOl

' ' ' .. , '..

SlB 2007 '4: 47PM

S'l'A'l'E'OlF 'AI!ASII!AOFFICEOF'lJ$GO~OR, ,'," --'",'.'.:"'....',; ',' "",

:",~'t~fii"GoVEIDi"'R:,.

. -, ;';:,:;-:-:-',' .......

'SEA;1'f;F~llli'LiEtrrlolt~'(f~?tm

".,"

..'(",,0"'''1''': "'/"',,'"'~<":"' :;~'" '",i:· ," ,

FAX TRANSMITTAL. '. : .

ro.~~!~~,--".:,..,~..:".:..c''-i''--'·..'--',.,'--'".""""0, .'. iC,Z~'$rZf:.'

, ,," "':";::-:;'.~ ,

~s,-', "

Ii-

,"',-,'

.,,"

.~........~~

"." ..,

.-" ..,. ",.'.,

'."

"'-' ,''-;':;-'',->:

',"""-.,:'

053

Page 54: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

08 2007 4:47PM

May. 3" 2007 1~:24P.M P.l

p.2

lEi*(jnValaezQfrS:pill'rmsfee,C(i)uilcil.44lWi'.~AV..;,S.·"6Do 't'~~'AK OO5o';,ozMD" "wZitiBCt1:' fa)!~~.m.'iits

~., :' ' ..'.: .,. .' , " '.' ' . . '. . , . , ...

~ ':hOO1 .,. ,yl ....

• jTJ!ia.~:~~f~O!&iiOflll<:_

i~[l~~~fI~OOl, ,'}",:,.' ,\,:: '.

S#ivJi;!'" 19m405-3532

, , .. ,...'

, ,~.,., ,\ ..

'.. ' '''~'I''

.- \',-.--""'-..:,.::,, ,- '-,-

-

p

MAY 03 2DD1Office olthe Governor

. ;r,'

'.-'"• ','"0," .,.... , ..,"

054

Page 55: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

<,ps 2007 4: 47PM

May, 3, 2m 12,24PM No, 0651 P, 2

p.3

~w.''.., ..... ',.,.,- '5£€J 2001-;",:,.~.

'-',"~' - ,c. ,,,_,;.,,.; .... " '"" ".-

, :;;"':':";':;<~'"':;"':"'"'~~;:'::;--<c:'-,--~---:T~~:---"-;-'-"-O;-7-'".,.

(

':,''...,- '"., .

,'.' :.:J -',-,,' "'"

-,--.: ;, :,;"

2

055

Page 56: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

".

Background Information on Bowhead Whales offAlaska

Zeh and Punt (2005) report the 2001 population was 10,545. Between 1978 and 2001,the estimated population growth rate was 3.4% per year. According to the 2006Westem~Arctic Stock Assessment Report the current minimum. pbpulation estimate is9,472 (Angtiss and Outlaw, 2006, http://www.nmfs.noaa.govlprlpdfslsarsJak2006 whbb­arw.pdf).

Scientists estimate the population number between 14,000 and 27,000 whales prior toextensive conunercial whaling between 1848 and 1915. It may have dropped as low as1,500 whales following the conunercial whaling era. (NMFS NMML website:http://www.afsc.noaa.govlNMMUbowbead iwc.php)

10 whaling villages belong to the Alaaka Eskimo Whaling Conunission (AEWC). Notall villages catch whales each year.

• Kaktovik,• Nuitsut,• Barrow,• Wainright,• Point Hope,I Kivalina,• Diomede,• Wales,• Gambell, and• Savoonga.

There is no annual catch limit, but rather an annual strike limit and a 5 year cumulativecatch limit. The bowhead harvest is managed by quota in a 5 yr block which expires in2007. The new quota will be decided opon at tbis meeting in Anchorage.

The current catch linrit was for a total of255 bowheads landed between 2002 and 2007with a total strike quota of280. This quota includes an allowance ofS animals to be takenannually by Chukotka Natives in Russia. (Western Arctic Stock Assessment Report,Angliss and Outlaw (2006) http://www.nmfs.noaa.gov/prIpdfslsarsJak2006 whbh­arw.pdf)

Annually, 67 strikes are allowed, plus 15 strikes may be carried over from the previousyear. The Alaska Eskimo Whaling Conunission divides up the strikes among the Alaskawhaling villages and a few are shared with Russia. Ifavillage does not use its strikes itcan pass them to another village in the same year. (Western Arctic Stock AssessmentReport, Angliss and Outlaw (2006)http://www.nmfs.noaa.gov/pr/pdfslsarslak2006 whbh-arw.pdf)

059

Page 57: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

...

For example in:2002; 50 strikes, 39 landed2004; 44 sttikes, 371anded2005; 68 strikes, 55 landed

• 2006; 39 strikes, 311anded

The average number ofwhales landed betweeo 1995 and 2004 was 41 per year.

Eskimo whalers are prohibited from taking either bowhead calves or whales accompaniedby a calf. Only licensed whaling captains or crew under the control of those captains mayengage in whaling. They may not receive money for participating in the hunt. (NMFSNMML website: http://www.afsc.noaa.govlN1vfMLlbowhead iwc.phP)

Contact:

Lori QuakeobushArctic Marine Mammal Program LeaderAlaska Dept ofFish and Game1300 College RoadFairbanks, AK 99701Ph# (907)-459-7214; Fax# (907) 452-6410Lori [email protected]

060

2

Page 58: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

't bregonLive.com's Printer-Friendly Page

Denby Lloyd

Page 1 of5

From: Clarke, Ronald G(DFG) [ron.clarke@ala,ka.gov] ~(Q)~~Sent: Thursday,June14,20071:00 PM .

To: DenDy Lloyd; Matthew H Robus

Cc: Kimberly TitusSubject: RE: AMF _Other states and countries at work helping their orphaned calves

••

,1

0656/14/2007

Page 59: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

. 'OregonLive.com's Printer-Friendly Page

,

From: Denby Lloyd [mailto:[email protected]]Sent: Thursday, June 14, 2007 8:22 AMTo: Matthew H Robusee: Kimberly Titus; Clarke, Ronald G (DFG)Subject: FW: AMF - other states and countries at work helping their orphaned calvesImportance: High

Comments? DL.

Denby S. UoydCommist!kJmuAJeska Department ofFish end GameP.O. Box 11fJ526Juneau. AK 99811-5526907-465-471fJ

From: Nizich, Michael A (GOY) [mailto:mike.nizjcM@a[aska.gov]Sent: Thursday, June H, 2007 8:06 AMTo: Uoyd, Denby S (DFG)

6/14/2007

Page 2 of 5

,

066

Page 60: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

·Or;gonLive.com's Printer-Friendly Page

Subject: fIN: AMF - Other states and countries at work helping their orphaned calvesImportance: High

FYI

From: Gary Olson [mailto:[email protected]]Sent: Wednesday, June 13, 2007 5:11 PMTo: Nizich, Michael A (GDV)Cc: Nlzich, Michael A (GOV)Subject: AMF - Other states and countries at work helping their orphaned calvesImportance: High

Hello Mike,

Page 3 of5

Here are some of the examples that are going to be used regarding orphaned calves and why they keep saying,"it can't be done". The first link is of a calf rescue in Canada just a couple of days ago. Another is a rescue of a 7month old calf in Washington. Today (June 13th ) on Animal Planet at 3pm is 'Growing Up - Moose' which detailsazoo in Canada that takes in orphans and returns them to a wildlife reserve (that even has black bears). Therealso was a show on Animal Planet called 'Growing Up - Sitka Deer' which detailed a orphaned sitka deer thatWas rescued from a beach in Prince William Sound in 2006 after a bear had killed its mother down the beach.The deer was 2 days old and the boaters took it to Big Game Alaska in Portage. The show depicted the rescue,rehabilitation and RELEASE TO THE WILD OF THE DEER as stated on the Discovery Channell

It is also being discussed that the 'secret calf disposal site', as quoted from Rick Sinnet, ADF&G in June 9, 2005Daily News article City wildlife a blend of beauty, danger,. is now known for its location here in Anchorage. All thecalves that are killed after the car collisions that take their mothers are dropped off at this location. PlUS, retiredslate troopers and others that dispatched calves at ADF&G's direction are coming forward as well. Tyonek legalis working every day and, as this continues to be drug out, forks are getting angrier now because the urgentrequest because of the spring time window regarding the orphan calf plan from the AMF continues to gounanswered.

The primary reason behind this passion is because of the tactic that ADF&G took last year with Tyonek. Lastspring, a couple of weeks of dialogue went back and forth via email between Commissioner Campbell andTyonek CEO Tom Harris stating that ADF&G does not kiJJ calves. A number of folks have come forward aboutthis one. Read this article from a 12 year old child in Homerhttp://www.homemews.cortllstoriesJ061406/1etters 20060614016.shtml.

I, since the beginning, have wanted a decision on the orphan calf plan based on biology and science alone. Ihope ADF&G does not say again that our orphaned calf plan appears to be written by a high schOOl drop out asper the Anchorage Press from 2006, paragraph #5 http://208.109.242.1421archiveslarchives­2006/f1ashlightvof15ed28.html. Make sure you read this one. The same folks that are in charge today are theones who have overseen the decline in moose for the past 20+ years that are now counseling Governor Palin onwhano do. Heck, if they were consistent, they woufd say since they transplanted bears out of McGrath to helpmoose calves there, you would think they would be all over approving the pilot project to take orphaned calves outto Northern 168 to begin helping the local moose to outnumber the bears there. I know that everything is politicalbut it is being viewed that the 'Ignore them for 1 more month then the calves don't need help anymore' is not avery wise tactic if that is the tactic being used.

Imagine if our Troopers and wildlife enforcement would do this again (call CliffJudkins, head oftheBoard ofGame who used to help theselcinds ofcalves as well as in favor ofthe plan):

bttp:llwww.goodnewsblog.comI2007/05/23/poJice~rescue-moDse-calf

Or how about the below story from Oregon?

Gary

0676/14/2007

Page 61: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

· 'OregonLive.com's Printer-Friendly Page

td..OregrmLive,com

EverythJng Ontgon

Agents rescue moose on the Palouse

The 7-month-old calf is found by his dead mother's sIde in a treeless area 60 mfles south ofSpokane

Thursday, February 8, 2001

By Nicholas K. Geranlos of The Associated Press

SPOKANE - The moose found loose on the Palouse is recovering.

The 7--month-old moose was found last week alongside his dead mother in a wheat field near the town ofDusty, about 60 miles south ofSpokane. A Spokane veterinarian will care for the moose, dubbed Dusty, untilhe can be returned to the wild.

''The Palouse Is the weirdest place in the world for a moose," said Madonna Luers, spokeswoman for thestate Department of Fish and Wildlife in Spokane.

Moose do not eat the wheat stubble that covers the rolling, treeless hills between Spokane and Pullman.There are few of the broadleaf plants the animals need to survive, she said. .

"He was in the middle of a moose desert,· Luers said. "HS"would have to have traveled a long ways to gat toforage."

The moose catfwas captured Feb. 1 by wildlife agents after a farmer reported the animal.

The body of the moose's mother was found nearby and taken to Washington State UniVersity for a necropsyto determine the cause of death. Luers said there was no gunshot wound or obvious trauma.

Dusty was refusing to leave his mother's side, and he was trying to SUckle, Luers said.

"It was pretty pathetic," she said,

Dusty stands about 4 feet tall and weIghs about 200 pounds.

Moose in the wild live with their mothers untll they are about a year old, then are left to fend for themselves.

Veterinarian Luther McConnell Is caring for the moose on his property near the town of Colbert, just north ofSpokane.

His goal is to keep the moose alive for a month or so and then release him back into the wild near MountSpokane when spring arrives, Luers said.

McConnell preViously raised an OlPhaned female moose from the age of about 1 week and released hersuccessfUlly into the wild, Luers said. That female has produced six calves.

The trick is to prevent Dusty from becoming too familiar wIth humans, she said. McConnell is keeping the

6/14/2007

Page 4 of5

068

Page 62: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

'~Om'gonLive.com's Printer-Friendly Page

moose in a pen surrounded by tarps, so Dusty cannot see humans or farm animals. The tarp also preventsthe moose from tJyIng to escape, she said.

Wildlife officials asked for donatrons of food for the moose, and truckloads of leaves from willow, aspen andfruit trees pourad in, along with donated apples and woody stems and buds. Food or money donations canbe sent to the Inland Northwest Wildlife Council office, 6116 N. Markel Street, Spokane, WA 99207, withchecks written to "INWC for Dusty."

Chopped apples are being mixed with Purina moose chow, a special mixture of food intended for moose Inzoos, Luers said.

"They make a chow for anything," she said.

Wildlife experts think the moose wandered onto the Palouse from Moscow Mountain in Idaho, about 25 miteeast.

After Dusty is released, wildlife agents will continue to provide him some food until he gets used to finding hisown. They don't expect that to take too long.

"Dusty is a boy. When his hormones start stirring, he's going to want to go," Luers said.

@20070regonLive.comAlIRfghtsReserved.

61I4/2007

Page 5 of5

069

.,

Page 63: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

ETHICS DISCLOSURE FORM

Outside Employment or Services Notification

Designated Ethics SupervisorTo: I--'N'>'t r6Gt'<.-(Departm~t or Agency)

n accordance with AS 39.52.l70(b).1 am providing notice afmy employment or provision ofservice'or compensation outside the 4U1Si<A .:».cPT_ ef r;~1{ iGdIfE(agency).

Note: You are not required to disclose volunteer work unless it is a potential conflict with your state duties or you recci"oy type ofcompensation, including travel or meals,

This employment or service consists of the following (describe in detail, attach separate sheet as needed);lI<>l.OAJrM,Y A "S'''>IINCJ5 As: »€c);H/lN» eN P'A;e;nvo,eS <;:",'-'N" QI~,,-TEJe.

V<::.s<"-L 'CAl AA.t JA/F>ee'lcJ<WT, CASUAL. 7r"SIS.,Hours and days of the week <)- :S.bfyou work as an independent contractor or a consultant, please attach a list ofyeur clients.

Note: If your outside job duties are the same or similar to your State service, or if you will be dealing with people orentities with whom you deal or may deal as part of your official duties. you must explain why no potential conflict existsetween yoU! outside employment and your official duties. If II potential conflict exists, you must refrain from taking anyction until it is appr?ved by your designl!1ed ethics super.visor. See AS 39.52.210.

certify that 1 will not use or allow the use of any State owned/operated facilities, supplies, equipment,fvehicles. or personnel time and effort for any employment outside State service, and that my outside duties will

at affect my llSUal State duties or duty hours in this Department. I certiry to the best ofmy knowledge that mytatement is true, correct, and complete. In addition to any other penalty or punishment that may apply, theubmission ofa false statement is punishable under AS 11.56.200 -AS 11.56240..

~~/ /~Q"'"Date)

b~o\l!?y :::. W>'iJ) I/bf'l§(Printed Name) (Division, Agency)

Cc:,HH/S<'~ J>JN6'lV(position Title) (Location)

Kecomrnendation: __Approve Disapprove

(Work Supervisor's Signature) (Date)

__Approved __ Disapproved

(Designated Ethics Supervisor's Signature) (Date)

D.signated Ethics Supervisor: Provide a copy of tile approval or disapproval to the employee. Ifthe employment isisapproved or other action is necessary under AS 39.5221 0 please attach a detennination. A copy ofthe determination mustesent to the attorney general at the following address; State Ethics Attorney. Office of the Attorney General, Department of

L,w, lOJ] West 41h Avenue, Suile200 Anchorage, Alaska 99501-1994

Updated December 2006070

Page 64: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND GAME

OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER.

MEMORANDUM

TO: Mike Nizicb, Deputy Chiefof Staff

FROM: rDeobYUoyd, Commissioner~"""DAlE: June 28, 2007

SUBJECT: Permission to Recruit PCN llTOlO Request

SA~AH PALIN, GOVERNOR

P.O. BOX 115526JUNEAU, AX 99811.-5526PHONE: (907)465-4100FAX: (907) 485-2332

Thepurpose ofthis memo is to request permission· to recruit:fur PCN 11TOIO as dUlly beoefitedposition. This fully exempt position under lbe autbority ofAS 39.25.110(9) was establishedeffective July 1, 2007, as the Endangered Species Act (ESA) Response Coordinator, Range 23.

As described in lbe a.tteched position esteblisbment memo, lbe ESA Response Coordinator willlead the ESA response teem comprised ofa full·time attorney in the Department ofLew end aWildlife Biologist. The teem will be responsible for:

• drafting and responding to pre-listing decisions, proposed federal: rules, revisions orameodmeots ofStete Wildlife Action Pleos, end bandHng oversight ofdepartmentinvolvement in liSted species' recoveryplans;

• seeking g:rants or :funding opportunities to conduct research oli candidate and listedThreatened and Endangered species;

• monitoring court cases, preparing legal actions; assuring state correspondence is legallydefulsible, end legal consultation wilb federel agencies end effectedparties;

• monitoring congressional actions, includingparticipating in possible re-writes ofthe ESAj• coordination with other states, e.g., involvement in committees ofthe Association ofFish and

Wildllfe Agencies (AFWA) end the Western Association ofFish and Wildllfe Agencies(JI'AFWA) responsible for Threetened end Endangered species, climate chenge, endinternaticnal re1etions; end

• coordination wilb lbe Convention on Tntemetional TOOe in Endangered Species ofWildFllllI1a. end Flore (CITES), en internetionalagreernent between governmeots whose purpose isto ensure that intemational trade in specimens of wild animals end plants does not !breatenlbeir survival, end other international organizations/activities.

075

Page 65: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

Mike Nizich 2 June 28, 2007

This is a policy level position, with the authority to formulate and represent the state'spositionsin various high-level settings.

j.

I request your approval to recruit tbr tllls !Ul1y oenenu::u PU/:iHlUll.

Thank you for your co:b.sideration.

J-?-o~Date

Attachment

co: Ken Taylor, Deputy Commissioner, ADF&GTom Lawson, Director, Division ofAdministrative Services, ADF&G

076

Page 66: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

To'

ETffiCS DISCLOSURE FORM

I Notification ofReceipt of Gift ]

/.. 1.Nb,.9 /te0' 'Designated Ethics Supervisor

In accordance with AS 39;52.130(b), I am providing notice ofmy receipt ofa gift given to meor amember ofmy family with a value in excess of$150.00.

1. Wu the gift giyeD. to you because you are a state employee or a member ofa stateboardorccmmissian? ~ Yes 0 No

2. I can take official action that may affect the person who gave me the gift?ll'I Yes 0 No

!rfthe answer to both ofthese questions is no, you do not need to report this gift. Ifthe answer .to either question is yes, or ifyou are not sure, you must complete this fonn and provide it to

.your designated ethics supervisor.

fhegiftis :6?1Cr O{' dss~e.1> 'Ten$' (.eol'1 vlI~IE'l'y' d' 'c"wnvK4

Grl1€oITO"IlJ-.fh<;r'"-II'IIAJrS iN /s.GNAr jj~ D..4SSI"-, 1'1..",:> ~4I.S,

My estimate of its vaIuo is $ ~\"7'~· C~~" ~~ 1.1S'")

received it from K!;:N"o1 &~ S"f'btCr='fIW>Utt Assce. (US",),I,.,.e date ofroceiptwas JuL1 S- b ;;:gy;,7I"ll' I

can take or withhold the following official action that affects the ~ver:

/ cAN T41;1i ,frtfOl<.o..€NC-Y ()96~l9ct""'" ,~-0,,1l~ """

i:rhegiftwasreceivedbyamomberofmyfamily 0 Yes 0 No - .f€l.f'.

certify to the best afmy knowledge that: my Btatementis true, correct, and complete. In addition to!my other penalty ot punishment that may apply, the submission ofa false statement is pwiishable~AS 11.56.200-AS 11.56.240,

L*'~(t 11J;;;aZ"1l>~Nll'Y 'S'. U", ,

(printed Name)

e,"'NI ~S/ONe.e. J"'''''''<lJ(Location)(position Title) .

~M ~.-~>! >iN~ 'i",!1'o

(Divi~O"I~onIBOard/C~~on) , 7-Z-3-(Designa~ervis~ L/APprOVod:$mitialS) , ~'3(~[faction is necessary under AS 39.52~10 or AS 39.52.220 please attach explanation."· _i\

(7/07)JUL 24 2007 077

DEPT. OF FISH & GAMEr.nMMISSIONER'S C!'F!Cr.

Page 67: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

SARAH PALIN, GOVERNOR

TO:

FROM:

DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND GAME

OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER.MEMORANDUM

Mike Tibbie., Chief ofStaff .

Denby S. Lloyd, Commissioner

P.O. BOX 115528JUNEAU, AK 99811.:i526PHONE: (907) 4654100 ~FAX" (907) 465-2332

~.

{§) ,~'

~)

DATE: July 26, 2007

SUBJECT: Pomrill,ion to hire PCN I j -2001, Director, Division ofWildlife Conaervation.

The DepartmOD:! ofFish and Game requeam approval to.hlre Doug Llll1<en for the position ofDirector, Division ofWilcllife Conservation. •

The Diree:tprm~ a statewide division with over 250 positions located in 23 offices. Theposition is partially~exempt at :Range 27. It is cUII'ently located:iu Juneau.

• Under general admiDistrative direction oftb.e commis~oner, thepositionplan~ cooxdiD.ates,and administers the state's management and research prG),gramson wildlife xosouxoes inconf=cewith state and fedcrallHws and state and department policy.

• The position plans, prop""",,, and de:t'e1lds the division budgotrequest to the commissioner,govemor, and LegisJoture. The inclll:nbOD:! """urea state compliance with the requiremenm of:federal wildlife restoration :timdiJ)g and ensures complience with state laws regarding theeA.'}>6nditure ofstate hunting licensing rev.enue.

• Represents the Division ofWildlife Conservation inmatters before the Board ofGame.

• Delegates to subordinates re$ponsibility and authority sufficient to ensure effectiveaccomplishment of division programs.

This is apolicy level position, with the authoritv to .formulate and remesent the state's 'Dositionsin various high-level settings. f

.

Thank you fox your consideration ofthis request. Ifyou have any questions or require additionalinformation, please contactme.

~"=--Governor's Office Approval

cc: Ken Taylor, Deputy Commissioner, ADF&GTom Lawson, Director, Division ofAdministrative Services, ADF&G

094

Page 68: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

·COMMISSIONER'S OFFICE

Contact: Tbn Barry, Communications Director, (907) 465-6137

###

No. 07-18

{Q)4Doug Larsen Appointed Director of Wildlife Conservation for the Alaska ~..

Department ofFish and Game r?'C::

(Juneau) - Commissioner Deohy Lloyd today announced the appointment ofD~'usLarsen as Director ofthe Division of Wildlife Conservation for the Alaska Department ofFish and Game (ADF&G). Currandy, Larsen is the Southeast Regional Supervisor forthe Division, working out ofthe Douglas office.

"J am extremely pleased that Doug has chosen to step up and lead the WildlifeDivision;' said Commissioner Lloyd in announcing the appointment "His broadexperience, his expertise and his enthusiasm for game management in Alaska will servethe Division well."

Larsen holds degrees from the University ofidaho and the University ofAlaska­Fairbanks. He served with the Cooperative Wildlife Research Unit at the University ofAlaska Fairbanks and, since 1984, in various positions around the state with the DivisionofWildlife Conservation. Most recently, Doug served five years as the Division'sAssistant Director and four years as the Southeast Regional Supervisor.

Lf!rsen replaces outgoing Wildlife Conservation Director Matt Robus, whoserved in that role for four and ahalfyears. Rebus leaves the Department after adistioguished 26-yesr career at ADF&G. ''Matt will certainly be missed," Lloyd said."But I'm confident thet Doug will ably carry on our state's legacy ofworld-class wildlifemanagement, providing some ofthe best opportunities for hunting and wildlife viewinganywhere." L,arsen's first day as Division Director will be August 171h

The-Division of Wildlife Conservation is responsible for Alaska's wildlife stockassessment and management, development ofpublic access for hunting,~~___management programs, and planning) information and education se . .....employs more than 160 full-thne and seasonal employees and h. -more than $20 million. /

!

/

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASEAugust 6, 2007

102

Page 69: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND GAME

OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER

'SARAH PAL-IN, GOVERNOR

P.O. BOX 115526JUNEAU. AK 99811-5526PHONE: (907) 4135-4100FAX: (SOn 465·2332

TO,

FROM:

PATE:

SUBJECT,

MEMGRANDliM

Mik~Nizicb, De.pl.lty Chi~ofSi.affOffice :ofthe Govemor

;

Denby Lloyd, Commis~r\tAu..,nusl 7, 2007

Approval 10 AppoiIrt.Kelly Hepler

The Department ofFish mil:] Gijllle (.ADF&G) .requesr.s .tlPproval to appoint 1V1r. Kelly Hepler IO the Spc::cisJFrojeclB Coo:n1inatm- Positio:t1 (peN] 1- TDJ l,),.e,tfeotive AugllSl J1, 2007, The Anebamge hased. parI-time. !lon~benemed,I1lIIge 23 position i5 established unclm: the authority ,ofAS 39 ?5.1 ] 0(9).." - -,

•The position is nec.easary to s!wport the Department's~atiOD OIl the Joint F4d!S1'allState r ask For.ce{lTFj on Feder.,I Aid Polioy, .the ~acia:lie:n GfFish and WildlifeA~~ (AFWA) National ·FishHa]:>itat Iniiiati:ve, and serve 0,1> the Depll1tm.ent'5 Pla~g Gornmit«:e ChaiT for W.estem AmiociatiOll -ofFish and Wildlife Agencies (9,1AJiWA) roee:Ling held in .o\1asl<;a July, 2010. III addition. this posil;icm willwork,on developing the Alaska Fish and Game FOIm¢ltioD and ooorrlinating the division's effam withthe HUIlter &rita.$C Founchlti-on.

~

•~'----------

,,_...,,_........., -Thank you for your COllsideration ofthis mquest. Please contact roe ifyou have any questions or requireadditional infonnation~

~Y~-Governor's OfiiceApproval

AtUlchmel11

cc: Tom Lawson. Director, Administrative Service& Dh'J,sioll

Dale

105

Page 70: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

Jeremiah D. CampbellP.O. Box 1586

Seward. AK 99664907-491-2665

6120/07

run,

This letter is afollow up to our phone conversation in regards to aticket I received on6110/07 for violating 12AAC75.400(c)(4), Unlawful act by Transporter. The complaintstates !bat I signed a transporter report when I did DDt actually provide the transportationservices, but that my brother did actuallyprovide the transportation services.

I explained to the judge that this was an oversight on my part and certainly notintentional. I explained that the funns bad changed since 2003, when they used to say."Operator" under the signature 1ioem-d ofwhat the new fun:n says which is "personproviding transportation services". I was under the assumption that as an owner ofthebusiness I could signthe report. Needless to say after reading the exactworclli1g inthe·statute it was pretty clear to me that I waS in violation I plead: no contest and received a500.00 do1lllr fine with 250.00 suspended

This incident was brought to light after one ofourc~ bad come to Alaska and-, harvested a black bear in the fall of200S, and then came back again in the spring of2006

with her family at wilicb time the harvested another bear. My baotber was also cited inthis case for faiIiog to report a crime. He has plead DDt guilty as he did not kaow a crimebad been committed.

In light ofreceiving these tickets and after thoroughly reviewing the regulations andshrtu:tes a few things have come to light whichwere also explained to~ judge and thetrooper involved.

The first issue that I pointed out was that I believe the form for transporters to sign isInconsistentwith the regulation requbements of 12AAC7S.400(c)(4). It States that thesignature and printed name ofthe Person who transported the client to and from the fieldmust be filled out hnmediateIy after transporting the client out ofthe field. When youlook at the fann there is only one signature block: and it says I'Signature of:indM.dualtransporting the Big Game Hunter(s)." There is nowhere to state who transported whatportion ofthe trip. With companies like ours there are often times when. 1:b..e'same captaindoes not transport both loB" ofthe trlp for a drop-offbnut Sometimes as much as 10 daY"can go by between the drop-olfand the pick-up. This is definitely an oversight, andIbelieve the formneeds to be fixed immediately as th6re are a lot ofpoterrtial tickets to bewritten for both the past and the future, as I beliove you will most likely only find onesignature on the form even ifth.ere are multiple operators.

113

Page 71: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

The .econd ;"ue, ofwhich my brother and myselfplllIl. to sobmit aproposal to theBoard ofGame. It is absolutely absurd to me that aperson can go out and harvest aBlack Bear in 6D in May and then harvest another bear in Septembar (63 day. later), yetyou can not harvest a Black Bear in September andtlien come back the nextyear,almost 9 months later (265 days) and harvest a Black Bear, especially when the state willgladly sell you another hunfulg license and another tag, hoth for different years. We werejust as confused as our clients were over this issue. I cannot think ofone reason for thisregulation not to say one bear per annual year, just like every other llllimal we huntCertainly there can not be any conservation reason for this regu1a:ti.on the way that it isworded now pertaining to bag limits. I personally balleve this is a had regulation and isresponsible fOI making honest hunters think twice about coming back to hunt in A1as1caafter receiving a ticket for something like this.

I would appreciate a copy ofthia being forwarded to someone in the department to'review my viewpoint on the first issue. The second. issue will have to be handled throughthe hoard regulatoryprocess, although I would he curious to find out the thou&!!! processon the bag limit issue.

In closing ignorance ofthe law is no excuse, like most cfus we get busy and it's easy tobecome complacent when it comes to paperwork. I apologize for 1he infraction andcertainly meant no disservice to the state ofAlaska. or the Board on which I serve.certainly up UIItil this point my record has been perfectly cl_ withoo infractions ofanykind. My iin:nily and I are law abiding citizens, and strive to follow the law in our everyday lives.

Ifthis needs to be forwarded to the Govemor's office please feel free to forward thisletter. Ifsomeone in Dept ofLaw or the Governor's office needs to speak to me the bestnumber to be reached !!tis my cell phone, 907-491-2665.

Sincerely,

JeremillhD. Campbell

114

Page 72: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

33

115

FISH AND GAME CODE § 16.05.320

NOTES TO DECISIONS

for boards and comnUS13J.OIlS under M 39.20.180.(§ B art I ell 94 SLA 1959; am § 6 ch 206 SLA.1975;am § 1 ch 81 SLA 1980; am § 4 ch 121 SLA 1992)

Sec. 16.05.800. Board meetings. (a) Eachboard shall hold at least one meeting a year and asmany other meetings as it considers necessary. Eachboard shall select the time and place in the state forthe transaction of business. Each board shall main·tain its office at the principal office of the depart-- .ment.

(b) In addition, the Board of Fisheries shall holdat least one meeting or heariDg a year in each rrf thefollowing general areas:

{ll Upper Yukon - Kuskokwim - Arctic(2) Western Alaska (including Kodiak)(3) Southcentral(4) Prince William Sound (including Yakutat).

(§ 9 art r ch 94 8LA 1959; am § 1 ch 82 SLA 1968·am § 7 cll 206 SLA 1975) ,

Sec. 16.05.305. Clerical assistance forboards. The Board of Fisheries and the Board of~ame are authorized to hire and set the compensa~

tion for one clerical assistant for each hoard. (§ 8 ch206 8LA 1975)

Sec. 16.05.310. SpecW board meetings. Aboard may meet at any time upon the call of thecommissioner or upon the request of two boardmembers. (§ 6 art I ch 94 SLA 1959' am § 9 ch 206SLA1975) ,

Sec. 16.05.315. Joint board meetings. TheB~a;d ofF:is?eries and the Board of Game may holda Jomt meeting upon the call of the commissioner ora board to resolve any conflicts in regulations of theboards a.D;d J:O consider matters, as determined bythe COmmISSIoner or a board that require the con­sideration of both OOards. (§ '10 ch 206 SLA 1975)

Sec. 16.05.820. Quo~. A majority of themembers of a board constitutes a quorum for thetransaction of business, for the performance of anyduty, and for the exercise of any power. However amajority of the full hoard membership is required'tocarry all motions, regulatiODB and resolutions. Amajority of the members of tlL~ boards of fisheriesand game constitute a quorum for the transaction ofbusiness n: a joint board meeting. A majority of the~~bel'SJ:rip of the bo~d.s is required to carryallJOInt motions, regulations, and resolutions of theboards. (§ 10 art I ch 94 SLA 1959; am § 3 ch 71SLA 1973; am § 11 ch 206 SLA 1975)

Valid bonrd decision. - Although the BlUlrd of Fi6he';M mayhave 'IOted three to two to dellY dlum cap reduction, it volet! live to%Iml I:AI ~pprove the managcn1ent plan rOl: t.he 1994 f'i\lse .P~

liaherYlVlthout a chum cap l'Sduction; thUll, there was II deci6ion by

NOTES TO DECISIONS

Sec:. 16.05.281. !Renumbered as AS 18.05.259.]

tis@wereregulationswhicllshould b.'lVe beeu adoptcrl plIrsuant tothe provisions uflbeAdminlstrative 1'ro<::edlJre Act, AS 44.62.010­44.62.650. Kena; Peninsula Fishlll1uan's Coop. Kenai PeninsulaFisherman's Co~ Ass'n v. State, 628 P.2d 8!r1 IA1a&Jal1981).

Cited in Stale v. Tanana Valley Sp<.lrt8men's AlWn 583 P.2d 8M(AlllSka 1978). '

Sec. 16.05.270. Delegation of authority tocommissioner. For the purpose of administeringAS 16.05.25~ and 16.05.255, each board may dele­gate authonty to the commissioner to act in itsbehalf. If there is a conflict between the board andthe ~ommissioner on proposed regulations, publicheanngs shall be held concerning the issues inquestion. If, after the public hearings, the board andthe commissioner continue to disagree, the issueshall be certified in writing by the board and thecommissioner to the governor who shall make a .decision. The decision of the governor is :final. (§ 6art I ch 94 SLA 1959; am § 5 cb. 206 SLA 1975)

TIrls seetiun only appliell where the BolU'd ofFi5heriss baadelegated its rule-makbig authority to the Commissioner af the"Department ofFJsll and Game aru:lleter disai:reea with the use thecommlssion~makes of thia delegated authority. Peninaula Mki:g.AmJ.'n v. RosJBJ:, BOO P.2d 567 (Alaska 1995/.

:Sec. 16.06.280. Removal of board members.'The governor may only remove a board member forinefficiency, neglect of duty, or misconduct in office,or because the member while serving on the board iscenyicted ofa misdemeanor for violating a statute orregulation related to fulh or game or of a felony, andshall do so by delivering to the member a writtencopy of the charges and giving the member anopportunity to be heard in person or through counselat a public hearing before the governpr or a designeeupon at least 10 days'notice by registered mail. Themember may Ct:lnfront and cross~examine adversewitnesses. Upon removal, the governor or a designeeshall file in the proper state office the findings and acomplete statement of all charges made against themember. (§ 7 art I ch 94 SLA 1959; am § Bch 121SLA1992) ..

Sec. 16.05.290. Compensation ofboard mem­bers. Each member ofa board is entitled to compen­sation at a rate e.'lual til Step A, Range 20, of thesalary schedule ill AS 39.27.011(a) for JuneauAlaska, for each day going to and from and for eachday in actual attendance at board meetings. Forother meetings or conferences authorized by a boarda member shall receive compensation at a rate equalto one-half of Step A, Range 20, of the salaryschedule in AS 39.27.011(a} for Juneau Alaska foreach day going to and from and for ~ach da~ inactual attendance. Each memb&· of a board is alsoentitled to travel expenses and per diem authorized

• !

I

J

Page 73: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

· ,'f, -'.,

.~.•.. ". '. "....••... • """WIr"'.. ; ' .... ··r .-:''' - I ,," , , -' "_ " j , ..,", ,,(.,.., ••. ,'l' -' ',' " ,.' -' -.- .• , - •.•

". '.'

I-"';.'" .

-,.,-.'--1 .' .- ......, .

....•."-.'., "i'

-'::==:J'~'r======:l:I:=====:J,t===.=':::::::':.2~·t·:.:.-:::-:::-,._.,---- "'--..---_'.. .__ _."•. ,.-=-._....,. ..,..N. :..,..~.,"

iI

GOV OMBDEPARTMENTALSUDGEFMEEFINGS

I

IjII,

I.i

", - -~ ,,"'~ ..

,BJ2(tt2'007'10:ll»l

116

Page 74: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

'...,I. ........

Lloyd, Denby S (D:::F~G;;l) _

From:Sent:10:Subject:

Sam Bishop [[email protected]] f{Friday. September 07, 2007 11;04 AM /'~:

Kalz, John W (GOV); Uoyd, Denby S (DFG): Nizich, MiChaetC~A~\6)Here's the USGS news release ,~) \f'

.

Future Retreat of Arctic Sea Ice Will Lower Polar Bear Populations and Limit TheirDistributionReleased: 9/7/2007 2:48:28 PM

Contact Information:O.S. Department of the Interior, 0.8. Geological Survey Office of Communication119 National CenterReston, VA 20192 Mike GauldinPhone: 703-648-4460

Karen WoodPhone: 703-648-4447

Future reduction of sea ice in the Arctic could result in a loss of 2/3 of the world'spolar bear population within 50 years according to a series of. studies released today bythe U.S. Geological Survey.

Last December, Secretary of the Interior Dirk Kempthorne announced that the U.S. Fish andWildlife Service (Service) was proposing to list the polar bear as a threatened speciesunder the Endangered Species Act. In January 2008, following a one-year review period, theService is expected to mak~ a recommendation to Secretary Kampthorne on whether or not tolist the polar bear as threatened. To assist the Service in making that recommendation,Secretary Kempthorne requested USGS leadership in studies to inform the Service'sdeliberations on polar bear status. This information Bumrnarizes and integrates the resultsfrom a series of studies on polar bear populations, range-wide habitats and changing seaice conditions in the Arctic.

In making the announcement last December, Secretary Kempthorne said: "I am directing theU.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the O.S. Geological Survey to aggressively work withthe public and the scientific community over the next year to broaden our understanding ofwhat is happening with the species. This information will be vital to the ultimatedecision on whether the species should be listed."

Specifically the USGS has improved knowledge on the status of three polar bear sub­populations, projected numbers of polar bears into the future in relation to sea ice andintegrated the information into a range-wide assessment of polar bear status underscenarios of future climate change.

The newly-released USGS information, presented to the Service in the form of nineadministrative reports to be open for public comment, will now be considered within thecontext of the Fish and Wildlife Service's one-year review. The Service will analyze itand other information provided by scientists, government agencies and the public in orderto arrive at an informed and scientifically justifiable decision. That decision is due inJanuary.

The team investigating the future of polar bears and their habitat included scientistsfrom the USGS, other American and Canadian government agencies, academia and the privatesector.

"This team has done a tremendous job in furthering polar bear· science through the use oflong-term observational measurements on polar bears, their habitats, and many other

1

117

Page 75: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

,f'ac1!ors integrated into a range of new and traditional models," said Mark Myers, Directorof the U.S. Geological Survey.

During a six-month perioctof intensive analysis of both existing and new data, the teamdocumented the direct relationship between the presence of Arctic' sea -ice ancl,-the survivaland health of polar bears. Polar bears depend on sea ice as a platfoPm to hunt seals rtheir primary food. But sea ice is decreasing throughout their Arctic range due to climatechange. Models used by the USGS team project a 42 percent loss of optimal polar bearhabitat fro~ th~J801ar Basjp during summer, a vital hunt!ng and breeding period, by mid­century.

In addition to forecasts, declines in habitat have been recorded throughout the PolarBasin over the past 20 years of observations. To project future sea ice conditions, USGSscientists used 10 general circulation models that best approximated observed trends insea-ice loss and could be expected to do the best ·job of simulating future conditions.Scientists characterize their conclusions as conservative because even the best availablemodels are believed to underestimate the actual decline in Arctic sea ice.

The reports are available to the public at Polar Bear Finding Web page.

USGS provides science for a changing world. For more information, visit www.usgs.gov.

Subscribe to USGS News Releases via our electronic mailing list or RSS feed.

**** www.usgs.gov ****

Links and contacts within this release are valid at the time of publication.

2 118

Page 76: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

,. "

Message

Lloyd, Denby S (DFG)

From: Leighow, Sharon W (GOV)

Sent Wednesday, September 26, 200711:41 AM

To: Lloyd, Denby S(DFG) •

Co: Mills, Andy J (GDV); Bluhm, Jason R (GOV)

SUbject: FW: Questions for Commissioner Lloyd

Page I of!

Folks the interview is scheduled for 12:30 at Commissioner Lloyd's officeJohn Tracy's number is 762 9223

From: John Tracy [mailto:[email protected]]sent: Wednesday, september 26, 2007 11:40 AMTo: Leighow, Sharon W (GOV)Subject: Questions for Commissioner Lloyd

Questions from John Tracy~ KTUU for Commissioner Lloyd

1- Congressman Miller referred to Alaska's predator Control Program as -illegal and inhumaneR, Your response.

2- The Act says that yoU,BS Commissioner, must determine, based upon the best scientific data available, that abiological emergency exists, in order to legally conduct predator control. How would such a requirement impactthe State's current wolf control program?

3- Is the State's Predator Control Program working as intended?

Thank you,

John Tracy

9126/2007 126

Page 77: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

,.'Bury. TImothy III (DfGI

---­r.-a..;po........ (OOV)T-.: 1JoJ'II, Dd!t' S (DFGJCc: Millo, """'" I (OOV); B-.__ It (OOV)s.: "cd Sop:lli 12.1. 1'2«11.w.-rwl ~

r""", JoIld T,.."..!maIho;jln<y@l:.lW.<»III]Sent: W.......,.. Scpanba-l6, 2IlO7 12;11 PMTo:~.5_W(OOVISIqett; 2 ",_

,..._ '-JolIo T<OCJ'"nuu ....ro_.._~,.

,. <c.,....._ Min.. _toAIoIb) predaI<Ir ComrcI,,-."iIl<pI ODd ioob_". Your •••••_

1_ Tho ACl 110.\'1 thal you.. Ccmmi.......... mUJI &Ietmine, bu<d "I"'" tho beoc O<ientifi< _ .voil.obl<. lblt.bi<lJ~ '""<fI<l\<l' oxiJU, ill order .. l<JlIlr COIldu<:l~ 0<l<llr<Il. How """-lld .Il<h •""l~l ""PO«"'" Swo'. _ '0<1/1"__1

'"

Page 78: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

4_ Vi< VOll Bal/cnberiI>< """. l'lI<7 etl<OW"i~ 11>0 Sto.te to~ wildlif, t-d 01' "'ba1 b<- <:a1lod sci""",_

bated~ '""""" t!IaD f<woina "" «rlOrtDlI """"" Ill:Ill <:an1lolJ~ It ,.... tigoed by """'" t!IaD200 bioJogi... and !,ient;~ Yo..-.-:Iion to tho I......

, ".

Page 79: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

,I

,I!

I•,

'. ;

!' .' I I '!' !.... l ~ ~. !l ils ~; ;

• ~., ~j!nll;, Fol l iii'"'h ~1 f iilgil' ~ ,Il( .. j l'tiiI{~!fj~ll IIlliliilJ!zf {Ifi

UlIiliU!liliiIh HfiiW!IUU UiiIH!I'~f;Wm mUhf~iHHz !! z b.ll ;-"i hJll ~t". " .. -

•• 1'" • I' Ii ' ~. L<-"'1" ••'11'10 1 "'I" :!," ." :1,f i t 1",;;" Ii~I ttlj~lt{~ ,Ii' I ;,;!II"111,,i ~ltf

Page 80: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

,..,".... ,,,. ~, - .

Iolelllbtll'llliolory 04".-, lrod ""","",,1<;.-__ l ... ,..".. bo<>o/ItI""'" ....... _ CIono-..." A.cllo'J"CSA,) In 1871. 43 U.S.C.Klec1.,ez.l~ Il U._•• _ ......._ .. lie ". ·~<l.C.... , ..'" TNr_1o_ __._, ...,"Y....~-.. TNy__..,._... ..,o; wl~Ify__~ _"'8(.)01 ....""'_ "'-10__'":10__In ..M':I_ 1nCI" _"'I'll ......- IMInd__be IlIIt>Iolot-. ......,.... WI NIl .1.-1'I flO 1Mb'"*-_ In ANCSA.~,"_~"'_ _ -*I__ eIllbli II _ "'*" In • 001''''''''''......__.~Il'P'~._..... of ......... "'"I.<><i n """""' ...... __ • _ .. '" Mt.r!t' • ..", _,.. Ilul, .11llOo ~_111. fill"" .... ~OI'I VI. C''''''''''''ly'' -..r;p, .""""""" ,",,"~<Ily",_lid,

ThI~IO_-...lun~II_"'ll_l<><l8)'D;/lhlMel;hl_,,*IIII'Wt_"'''_''. ilIIIl'~' '01" 'ir._1r.ll:lO_.r ,. , t_,.",..._... *...-.......,01_Ign",.. otIII__I'll _,,"*,-00__...­

ANCSA. ..""'__ ' ."_fO In= 101"'" ._"". I r",-,-'foaii\Iln""T__ 'cx.c._1J~Io"'_"""I'IICl_l!le~-...Of_""..T_"_II • n.~ pr;I!lIIlllI I:lI

_10_......'_•• _ ..... CCOl Caofm\JnIyoubl_ ......In .rod~_, _ ro ...". flo 250 IW tn., ""'~

9-r1ns iotII ""~_,.. Millo""""" 01 olIlIo" rt'IlIi!\l "P"'"t!OtII In__~" _ 10 ......,HrninIIInlI'''Y """"I klt MI\III<lIlIII', <>wn _._ ..... /'I01't'f.uflfllier\lil_fIO~'mIling--'''''' "" .... Fl...........

.........1O_~_e. of_~_ .........___ ./01>0 -.I _ &--. _ Of C1IWIOIlIII'*_. •....""d"""__~'.lLi ~ _ .... _ I ",.. ....__ •_~I; t ' ""_; _.InAloiob,_.eV'C.",._::__~p. ,...... ..-...'*"*'II~.~----,.'( .AlPC «tot • ...lIool <QIll """'- !'t* .• /rwofl ,..,..ua on! aoet_lD.:o-..." ..-.P'b. II.pruIIl. '" M :111 muol M bJ _ Of __of........... '--1wd"'_.... I*"b,_,.._ .•-.Of""""'"VfIoI,·_m........ forN_ -...·._10"""'_I."" ••f IN .T"" II rolC/llod Il\ri'lg lK'Il..r_.

p_Z.I. '._Como,rIIyh _.~_,... r .1

,w

Page 81: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

""."., ,... - ..., - .

scorcQfItCPBM.·' n.. --.,__of ..... booI""..... of ... Mn.....__ lDb<Iudo_--'" 01~_. The moo! a'ld<:*1 MpOOCI of ..... _ooion _II! ... IhoIInolut~ or! "'&WI .....t .......1lI" 0Qf00d __ling p<>!otIIW In~,

_.NI~_~ .. ...,.,....,mool~oIftJ1tirgtD-,. or_II>. poi'o:__dh-.:rwn_-""ofDlD-. n.~ "'lDlN_fIIlliIIlIo 10 .... ...... fllDub- .......,--_...- ......-_._-....,.,.". ... """'" 1M _ 0fl0"ft of !hi _._ 01 Dub urd

p""" ~_loW 1·"-Oor!-..ly~ E>ooaMloo ".,.,_,

'"

Page 82: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

- .• _ dn<:IIy bolooo l!IO otIOm _polrIl d lho~~ ..,. 11_..... ...:enG ""'" IO .-v boo...,.".

HEWOP!'O!!D!H!!lEI fOR.m ...·nA n. "-.~_I0_~._d_ ~..-

'- I"II.-Ia .._ ...... ,..,.'.... _.lalho1 ; II~~_ oar. 1II1tMl'.""""i'Iet>N"'~. _l!IO~'" n:r ..-r.,ThI 6<p*fiI"'" ..._ "'''!IF oPl'O,lLmllj',~ """". WI1n ll, "'. Mr,;....,"'lrIII""",e.<o '"_!lit. haft. 10 __ lII!IciallC)/lIIal_ ...__ IlIr....,...,the~_..' 15

: 1... ...-- ___ __.... d ... _ .. IIt ___

,..

Page 83: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

- ._ The ' n, of ~ """--.:t .o.irIXI'I1D prMlI ...__ !>ol , I od rr.~ II)o-oLI_om""<;lllboodl.' .

OTHER llrreml,~_"'"__ lOtI mlM ltIIt "_ooioo'l_J In • ......n btooder .-. !tIM I""~'_IS to 1Mt_ In_I,~ _ boo I'O<IlQod .......!lor~ """'i!lno'Ol\ Ind........'""""""ICI-..LCu1IfI"" EqtzlA P'"," TheIlClUldl,,--... hI<>_ ...._ .. ofr.or---ofecro'" , , ' ....... 1__... ,n._._dotilM"'.of"" ..., .. , " 1oroII-_'_of..-. ~~ Tho""" "'--of"" '_',IIoIl:lWr _OL 1Ionotlt _ ... ~ N c--. a-- ....••pt.w_olOo,opoo."'....-IO_", So I ,I, _.,~.. ,S~ID_..~, , ..e-unly__ fIO"'d_1D"",omICI~.IO' • , __

Ilf!l!! M.".,,,,,,,,,,, lad fJ)forpo1noM, T" pam.........1d~~m.'lIQ......,' IJ'Id _",.,Il ~ .......... oomi>.... '"""""""0 ,_, thin* ___ . Und.... l.-,Nt -",IIIII,,-",",lllld .ofDo_",,, luln<loity_ bo DfaUIIIIIID """'_lIw__01..11_ 101-.. !l'oOSoc_, C1 ... --'I<iolirc I'IgUIIIIicnogo•• ,io .. fIt.""'lI_'"__... I >0II ..__0II .....-..0II_1n.....". 9 ..c. 0, 1 ,""",In2$C.F)U·W1141 _~'.1.~1.0,..0 _,_~"''''''''''''''OII-''''''____ _11Dr"'_,_,__"'__ ' 'I.....w>g ..... _ .... _ ...._~Ins.:.............. Qolatow__.. &-.__ Q , -.. Thuo.IIIO_..".ICI..... in __ """""_ U , 'IIOd,

lNlfBEIITS rp BE PROJECTEO S<amo .......... in ..._ 01""""""'.,..oIQnf;oont."""", 10 lie __red .... opo<lf;; mention In tNI So<:I....."'•• --"')uo/iII<otIon. R__.. modlt,~11\0 Soao!orl"O I",","",~ l'O\}WIIFo; IItIWl; "" t>o .......... "' prftlcll'l,d __ IIIII'lI'IO....~~.... TfIo ....... I _._10_""""'-.__-. -._ ....I - __._ )uriI'y .._"" --.-.t>__ , ..-_ ; ___ ;; n IDr~C1~'"

Cg"'+"SI!ll.,.... fIIrtI The_.........,. __.......t>oA .... /II'lIIIV__~ Tho '.'c:IoIlln-ga,o,_......._ _ _ <1""'_, oIrtlpI)'__~ lOW>oro "01 .bIo to MoI_ -....... &me Ii__1IoIItv .,.........~ ~_lollm._~·, .110,,_ ""1 In..... MotIoUt!<O·. _I~ tJ>o .-00",", The """"'"" __ "'_ LIU/l:od by .........

..,

Page 84: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

,.......' II". • ~ - .-........ IIIJ1 """-"'l _ l<> b& l)ItIIeCWd, no. _ ....""'11~ hod _

iooII""~. aroun<l C~, 1&J.o1'l<l" ..".r ton "'111 """ lKIl ""'" In ...,.n, ,.......u 01 Ihio tn_ "",-"'<I Oy _ '"" """'III bop~by_~._•..- n-.....e. "", ..CII>IIIicn afl/>o 000'., .....__""'".......__.cl>joo:bonlra'n .... fIoI;"g -.y,'

eqm.,;WP... f!Mt n-_Inl!lo.... 1*""' .... j I,____.....,...,,-........ _01_' • ThIo __

...-oUIIjocIlO_,..., -. .... I I : d"'-¥'n_-'"__'-"" _ "'" upatIIIlon,_, 00\1111 M. avnor;cambocon 10

trlhI ..".ct 01Il'ol "''''hen! .............",T_... M.""". _In "'" eO<iot!."'t""""'"__... "" ddtmoa_"" _ ...CIl* _IIIIt_n...-. williIi ...._-.. __ ~~1ha_""""0III.

IWrirW _ .... _ b:WV11_bI' .. _ .. ""'" ""-'lI 0l'lI0"

__"_19m ~_..,-""...-.",.<10 '1'.. afT__•• noo. __ <iuo :0 dlI\a,III_.,_ JI.Iatt<lIr<n! lCalonbn ."., • _ '"h>rtol~, WIll Iha.,.,."pIJlIondlha~ P'*'tR-,~n:wDll,_~llUpoltllUoro"lho PHIlO« wII ". IV.l.oI>le, malnll ~. pn;><irrIlIy 10 1loll1n;.....,.,....s. • .-IIll_, AlIo.""'''''''' ""'l'0I_1IN",_1O"'" InmIIlll' .. _ ~ of "'"__, -..._ II>

.... .... .".,e 'j I_"",_""", .._hholtlor

... _ i'l:IO N __'"""'"__ ....' I

"'.=.""'''' •__ '-oriI'.n ......__,rany,.·.I. »ClIljo<Ib'l to IHllU _ ",.~ -... :0~._ "" """""""'NCO>'eiY rac~~ tho po"""1 ""rm 10 • ." lelI-I<> """....to In u,.~. Funn..br_i .,.,.,....__ ilia sacrr.-(o axlo:l"ll~ .....'_.__.... ".a-.cl 0l!'Ir _.".....9_""-"..""'_~1'10_ ......_'*"'•••• , •• _ ....·,Po..__.."'t ..__.

'""'~'- .......--_ ..._..~ .....-'"_...._--_....-..._.....*_.._-_ _....-- ........_-_.._- ------. _--_..- .,,----__ lor _ ... _ ...._._._.. •-_. -_._-P8Qe8-'j' ,,,,_~-"-"'f'C'"',P i ..

,..

Page 85: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

- .Dw' WaS!''' n

f« II. 'r ow i of "" !nlMt!Irtg( "O",Me;; .'7 ",pI'h,,,,,,,, i' 'plndllr n

.. 'rtTiM ..-tIJco.v-hlI81''''_...

1.,.,..,-..1" c ' .._1_.... '__~ ... ,.1, __ ,,'.'5 ...,.. SM__J1Iha"'t.~""248U_S.78.

BII(101a)("TIw_dllltMolllIllllWlaI>~ION-', _ "'wi I' 'i

... lncIiItl -,.-. -*I ~ ... , ..'a' *'li.n The~-.. !of w:IlioYIng

~ the __ d IIIIl1 """"""I_ltle..-no .. ""pPy'_1'Ioh. 11'l11, h S C<>un '" AAoWo f>o,e/1fc__\/MIl, Ie IICtO/I1PIIOI' 1M

PvlWOI __ by~,lI1.-..ryolthlt~I$I'nd'_.....t

_N'~ftol*9~f'lCI'" 1<l.1Il1l\l. Qvarm. ..... lluMrwdplu.r-s,MoI_-: '''ly_... gc.-oICong_n_ ...._1........ ..-s __ Todoy,N_- .-

_d _dConv-Io .. J--:dy.

TI>e' _,of"'~_1!w_l:>todJJ'...-. n.s _"_ ,_ "br*~_', ' •• lIl'~"luII'Ilbrl;' \.10<

"--~~-"-~I>_"""""9' ~","""._7" ........,... pLCO. 'tom_"'_br.., =l'lf 25 usc f4'5. ... " • $ , _ C' • t. £;oor!, _ U.a.~

~(l\11S2),"S; C<>un,- C· '_ .. , _ ~__.,....--' _ -...~ .'20""" ......-.. _.- .,........._fl_._.. ~

_Ad .....__........... _"""""",....,..,.,. •........ -.,-,.,." """.-"'..._-----.", ' _""-...I,'1I1,"""__ _e.-..-. """ .. ...,."'" """,,,1>0 J,. _!II''''''.............-.....,"""'-~ _.."""',-_., .._..---_ .._.,. ...-. _.

,..

Page 86: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

- ..-~~--- .............~~ .... ...-'"" : ... ",.F r, iCIII"'~"_,_""'_,""'.'.j••oI"'_deorv-.,...,.-.~~ '" 191&.""'*~ ""thorfly, ", ••IJlm

Wbon loIuK. ~...-..Ib/I_1oIq an &!tlIIraIy lIooondOty of3.000 IHI~

aflhl....,.,.,"'''l:..ndiolotlafcn..-...-Ialmm_. Thop' ' , f ..'-w._,...__.._ ...-.af....... _)or~afl!le

" .' =m ...., lloII II> """",,","**_alIofd._..p-. t." r __ lie~u .""rw_.. '~r r ..: • ., .... Pt ; __po,n: l>J"C'o ....e 'al

"'_.........,,__ -.._....__ ... ','2 ,ot..

~'Ifl\:iIll'"proIKt.,. """ lnltuoiot"&; S- Jd, • M."1lCIun<!ary_ol:>nlOr If>t!<melle1_Roo_ 10 mad. _li'i l!le

_nc>rr*> _!llrl ~I<ri...." C<oMuIlIy 10~ Tho C>'lolo r..~ t>roug/lI

...... '" porI!Il' 1M lnaDlIlllr aI~rl-.u_ II> '*'*'.......,;l'l _ No

-.g,~Jan:l-'Y"'''_I)_''__ ' ..__ F'8cI*V~,"_pouII ,. OnIl'''~d.. ' ..l\f;II_d.-.,d ~_.... = ..

~olztvd_OoIDv ...._~ " $' ? .. ......-v__'.~_••"__-..,.....d_ flo ...-yll>"",*",- ..~ •

...~b".. lIbo<td loItt:.... lbl'!trmt" -pt.""'......... In'-~. Nen. oenCW 01_.'. _ ... !he,ortJlllillH opooatioll at lIlO~Corn!>Afl)' .... <llI'IliIIi.oe Ie _ *_1lioI .. ~lI!IaIoI~.'1 _, ....'ok... III

~ flO plonl._II.._ <:onllnIIOuOIl' _ _'lKIoe ill ,,.,.,

e.urw,..._1Il;tI..-...... <II '- j' Woe 8I.l, _ 0'lCll"""""","~."~I>olIndor)r-.lr_" __ al__",.,,,._b-' _ 7 ' '-.: J~_"OCII'IIft>o

.. _lho....._d.._~_·~.."..,__,..

,_.._.._..., ..._- .""',--....-..""' ..-____....__TIIo_" ......___10"""",,_.' _"...., .-.,..______oaewo ..._· .....,.....~ ..........--------...,.",--_..-._-,," ="_..........._.__....-._.- ...-- ..-,,-l." ' .. _~LaooIJ' .... iforac.._,~

'" I

Page 87: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

,...,".... II,"" muo.' -.Sooc:nUIy_ t, 0 ~eonar-"""","~_m; 7""~'"

~&do"'oiIll"'oWj:_ll...... _iz:a~'. :ze USCf.ce5.n., !IpwJlIry'I !Wltt<Wlb' to Adm,g"IIW'nfy """"II lhe M.rttlmz 'QUOd.,.,

Tho r...>d-.I _ k>r!'ll So<:nlaIY. _ II>""mlniI~ -.... I!lo

-.._I)'of.._,..... II.-. lillie ....,..,..,. ....... '''''' 11Im

_1485. ThlIl"I'"""""_..","'_d"~""",,,,-,__",,-""_lne"; .,.C<>wr.. ii' ~ ."'0 dio'V"_d~io 1SIb..... _

Huh ect.-:e.",,, u ' "'W II!!, Ie "!I'mIn.. fnl--..". "$ •••CtuI_ bIl<nl:~ _lot

_,,-,_.I6:w,_ ·........ ...., ... lOOJWof .. ;rw1I""-"' ,d ..'n Aluk! P.;JIJe I'kIlItIu, ... eo... 1ddrII__ r. -.", ctM:Id lJli!heIII::!. of leo1 (:I! USC 1 £\l5)"omtne. 0I'Ily !Ill upIo" "" 1n<;:Ldu .. _I till~_"" __.w ;.t""',"1Il 1181. Tho e-.,,-,,-,"'.,.qo • 11",, __

Cl:w1CIfIM IwCIlhI~"""""''' "4J , __..bh."""--e..... tIlI ..-IlIrt, ,.,"11I.." ._un.... ,.,..:::':'~l._""iI'l"'_"',~ .,..c.!lI.I ~-......."",••lw"-D\'..;d' \ 'PU!ok-" , ;_1IUlIIo__111I"'_17" db .._td_....... dz;: _~ ~ ........_ ... Un/IId _. Itt II •.

Tho OoIln 1tI\,oI\I.bood lf1.1 'tw _ ""_11II """'"' lo:lan<lo R_

_ .-ollld _ .........,_, _ If1d~ ... ""'.... In ..... ..-run tu trI/n_ .. _ '" """*'Y. l>I<UIIW-.0--'" ...., _ .. 1M _ ul

_-"11I. ThlCcuI'-I1Il.. ll ~ , r ._""..1IoIwo"., __ .... """ ..... _ .......ot_w , .. .._ •• ~fucIlIolllUt_~, 'M ~ .......... ___.~_d.t "" _..~Itlr _

__",*clIIJ. 1$ ,..... //1. ThlOiulPD"*6U<11............. _ftOl

~s ~c..goo".~~.·m'...1Ioi _iF $ .....

no

Page 88: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

- .IIUtllIin lliitwol_ """' ..._"'h~"'I4I"".no. _ Ill... •• •~___......., olloi,' III.

n.Caul ....I' _ ..c:o.v- ~~ f.&Gr5, .......... lId_lfIIt-.o

"'-1rI~_II> ~.oIf : ill.. ("E-'.'~ -..- .. ........." .._"~-"'_M:l_'SMId.... ThilClaAIt _

_ e.v-"dilnol_.....,.....« ~ lIIIrldOl' .........,,_-..IlUlIlle,.,...Of_Io_ ~ __......-ve-rd-.· III.~.__."tI...CouIl'.'81a ....~ ... (;oq< _ "" _ ..... t810 _,,*011oI~ '" III OIlY

......... '"' ... _ "'tie _ Nl-. ...., trf .... 6otI1rlv 1JIIIII"Ol' d ... ......­

l...-m RaN,.",. Tlw~ <II IniI "100"''' omIIoIof1 11..-_, 1Iy'"

Coull In ilI_ OP'nlon.

IIItlif!<alla!nd.!M CQCII!'I....l'n _ Jllg U.S .0 me:21TM S_CioUIl oploIIDn dwlt dir8<:lIy""" ...~ <f/,.

~"' _" ;__25USCi_. "T"-C«o!__1IIo>

000......1"-""'''' $ _, .... l"'>' ...., IrI t 411$1hol ~

__"10 ouctl .... _"'l1? .. _....;oct.. """" _kAb ~

""/liweS l ......_ID_!lr _,af --":" t! .... _

~~.E;otI._U.s TlIIt_:; g Ccul-. _-"'!-...a.I;J -.rIO"""_ rJf 0>1.... III

TIIII__ c..r._IC .. Ily......._"'_..

"'II'5! ..... \ '!Il''''~INI__ t' '7 _w-.__"- .... ...-. .... 5 'J~-_ n.,ee..t _

_ ...~nv' i~_I' '. 11I_c.....r /1:1•• 53.~ eo..t_-v-t ,."..IWll" t' __Ily

.. S. .:00, b' .. I1", i ..~d..__ ~ 1815._.....

_ po<.a.&." )fi U.I.~u Sb........"..... CW<t<llci /hcI""'I~ II... s.::r.to""," M!lIICItyIlUl Wt6ill$1""lIt<*!aIJ-,.

van*lbyf.~,1_-'~"'_01""~;'!'OI*I'*" til'Co!>g.... '!tMo SI<nIaty Mol arM*' IIMI1 of MIf-9o'<om.-.t let II.- _""'"

1leIl ..~ It>o~ ... \I&IIoqId.I..... ond~alnlo~, III.

I

Page 89: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

,"'"/"",, lO," ..",,,,,"" - .11154. Tho Coull .,timllely I>aIO 111.\ tno wl!l:lr'ly ",.:ItDd_ s.cm...,. Lond.. § 4!l5

_ """~d rIlto'to~.t- ti>o d>ollo"l/9<l~. wI!"oout _ 01

."yotrlW~tlon. /(j.IIl~,

T/Io .....'. OPPO.mon l:> tno s.cn..ry. "'!,NIotiono CII0t_ tAl onP_W\I$<>:l'. t~lB _motion, 3G S.. 1777, .... liIoIl "'" m. _ '" Corvo... lI>e

.-JawS~Acl, 12 St.l33~... Il!I"Io!If\dOd ..... 13 SIal 141. ""bII< LrN 280. 1&

USC § lle2. 2~ usc § 1300.od lI>o WhIlo Jw;l, 43 S"HIJ.\ ••o """'_, 4lI USC Sf2Z1-221l. Tho'CouIl found,.....,."'1twa~"'",. _Ie be ~,,"..... I<J. o>l

,,~

Tho ..... Grgvod "'''' ltMo Prt!oIo"","'" _ IlUfl'O'led to ,oil::"'" lI>e Annlllt,

Io&tndI ROHMl to 1M 'g,8II6IW-.. ,od~ gt ltMo Urllted Slat<>o ..

__by ItIII Sec18lary 1)/ Cotmwoo- 1'ltIlnded Ie '""led t/ltI AMootle

lafJl'ldo Reoarvo l<llll~ llol>elln _. 1l'llI<1l_A/;eskll , .._. In_ 11>8

bOo ... ftO~lroplI. /d. $154. ThoCoon ...u.dlMl~.lK>Iditlll!hltl. the ,UItIortty

IlItheS~oy "'111, lr:ter1<>r ......... § 4i<l1_lI'>Io ~"""''''and "_red~lolOfy~ ...., tno~ 1SIan:!. R...-. /d." 5!!. _.",. c",m c..1"""__til on 1M !ItIlIlOr1Iy<ll .....~"l '" r.- !h.~ notIvl!".-t 1n)o otIitu1Dry ou'o'l<>til)'!Dr ....__ (;!led." /d. Tho Coun Gioia poInliod

OIJI tMt b ltl~ OPillDn In"" AI&&l:II ".,,;t;o FIshorlN ca.. ll>O_"""""""*'R""~ loIand........ i*l o! trIO R--..o wlth<>Jlvr, ......._ '" """~ kI. a14~. Tho C<lurI_ 11M ""II' ptocli<:aI purpoee OIl h Proc!omllilon

_10""- "IMIC"OaCIlmonl III "",,-indian ns.""",,*, Into -.ua. Will...... /d.1l!

55, Trill Cclurt 001<l11ll11 <:lui 11111 PnIIl:lenl Wiloon .....11I!tI<llplfnJj to _III In<!

P"""k*!tIe i>l1I'IS '" lila S&<totart "' .... I~to dtowI<'l' ltla ......... undeilliliUltllO<}' __!Y, "'" to _or~ l/'lat,,"lI»rtfy." /d.

The Cclurt~, thera/<>ra, \helM Pn>damatl<>n'1 ref_ to""~1II_IoWI ard~.at Iha S...".ltIY of Cormlarca "did "'" moke _ ......

and~ aupertorto 'eguloliona d\lle S8cnololy or the wMot.' /d. Indo-.d. lflt

Court nekI It.- .... .,.. and r8ljLl!a\J:Ino oi Ct> ", ... ""' _ "1'P!l' III Mellakallo or1Iy I~

I••• lI'Iey....,. ."'" In oon!I<:l willlOllle, ""'- adOpIed I>y""~ 01 ""~1-

m

Page 90: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

'''1''211. ,..,.. .......... - ..........",.bt'.-__N_.....'*"~I.I~f~·

•__1flJl*l .". fol d k S ~-. _ t..o 2lIO... .". """""AcI__ "_d~ t _,d~"'_

.. , • ,,__ T!llCocuI ••", r.., 5 U 1 ~...".".e-t_lie__fIllO'UOII _ d CorocIr- _ ~k,.,.~",.".--. IfI. II su.

T!llCoIo"«l..:r' .... '_lMW!l"-,_pw..-tly"o.S _,It>_......... .....-.._ Ill" ),wlodbb .. apodica3)

iii"'" '.....s...-y'"""'~ I .."IS"..... 11/;=511I. TlIioea.t_,_,ltI8l .....s.croca.y._""' .. ;' ",,,,,'~ ..... n"'OIIlMAnMllOl__ <lid 1'10I 01'110110 ..........~~ Ii>r 1M _ • ..-; _ [lI>o

"v"'l .... p«I 01'" MO'UIIld (brf4$5]'" ISflllr /<j,.t ~,nOCowl_ • Ill t>t ItIe 1leIelhet. """'"'-'gn f'ubIlc UIw

2300--'1~~_~·ot~"",,!IIeeIelUlIotJIy,on:ll.e<:le

1leNng!lltllo gnnlod t>t ""-lr'Mt). *_,..... Of _Ill,' 11/. The ._lr-.d,l>I' .""....,_ ..__ did 1'10I rw-1bI»'Ig <lg/oIo;r...eedl>I'~. /d.

ThitCow1t1t Il'lAheh., 1iI""'_,~""r...,q... '" ' -..h_b\OOId_• ..,.. .... 1.R>I*"d_ ....___·//t.rR II .. ...,._ ..... ,.-t -114851--

-..--.d_rl;t/: dIM'I' .... "'1oIt. .... ""~ ""110' ... lit.

T!IIc:...._~_""" dO...._'.__....... - '"

"d~ .. sec:...,d........ R> _ 1M hp I'OlI' I • .. fbe Ccutv-_...__~1l__"'*"0II_- _""'" ')'~ l>I''' loCI tu__" po ~...... ",_lndIon IiIl'*ljIIil1llIh,.-.,__........-__ TlIio e-t

-. "...., .....,.,_It>d;edIn" 5eaeiWy h lSflI. _ 1_1'10I .? ?o<' l>I'

lhe 91 , 1_ "'=I. III. II su.'

''''''_.I;I<''--'''~--''-'''-''''''-___..._y. ,.,." _sWo__..... _ ... _lOol ... _ ...*"'I' ......__ -_"'-'-,"'-'_""__._.'"'"_,.... It>o__"'", ..... .~

"" oi .....,._· • w__, ,.".-_ .......,. ..• 0$ • .---.....-..--.....,---- -

'"

Page 91: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

,....,...-. ,"'., .. _.. - .Tho "".i{I,~~ lhl~ -.crtlycfnt S«:nll&ty

III~ Ine ~.II_*1Odby.kl~ "1'O'I1lt_1NI

~ ... i ..,.""__PMNdIO_I_ ThM_"",,*- • .as ...• -..,_,._In_dr: II 7 lIoo_lIIoII._ 'g M ,If:y._......_""Ilt_. -.... 11_.. 4QOu.s.1M.l__ (1V5~ _ •...~- ._by...CoIII'lIn ... AlIlob ......r............ 3CII

U.5. M.C9'5'I "kl'" t; l!l! OrftnSil< ~."...y .. d.- 1n:>M Il. ",....,....~ Court-,-"" .......-_~. .."..,...._,

I. II 1 tf V._~-.eav-~.............-.,_•••, for _ br'" I'........__..... lP>* lIII>Irr. -..~...._-_.. ".~

2. crarv-__ __"'~"""'"""

_10_....__-. __• 's'.3. Tho s.. _y _ ut-IbtDrclllllhotill'lO ............:'ICI,...........

b lhl 1'1.........~ Ihr _ 0IdJ-Il. tIIIr'flo. '0 -.. tt.t tl:Ir lrItrnt d---'. ,., .. .,..1 ....__... :, '\··.or__eoIhw

I' ''''$ _,dqoll ..-.otI\I 7:; 'lI)l'c:or- ........ -.;50 n.~T It _d""'"""' 25U.s.C.!

4Illtllu...._in_Ilt ' :,' %_.II>f>o_'II--,IN:_-.II

'ii"'~O' Mflllllbivull' ...... tII_In_.. froa;-.cI

e. Tn> _"""""'" Ilt .... S_'Y 11-."""IIII 0<1._..."..qy~ IIlol II-. -..y. 10 "'"Y """ hII 0Il>IiI) 10 ll>II o<1gjnrj_d~lIw~lD~Il._IrI_""" II..,'.,..., ...

1iolI, .. 1on;__ 1 _. ..,1o __"'_eorv-'&lnlrr7.

............__..._h.. : ... ...--.._'*_.....--.-.-.._ __ ..-_.._._,,_e--~ __ _

m I

Page 92: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

- .Tho f .... ",!ltI ,..........,

Iftloo<l!>ob, f ...... ' _,h_~"_"''''~"

_--'__"_""'d' ....-.n ••• -! Ol.' Tn.logIIlIlIJOll*o ....~11_.. _ : f 'wcf ill "-" II; t.Wioct-. 71)1u.a._(1_} ",~ c..n_ ...e....- ..........__...JIIIor rWll _k>lft ... ._1II----. ... ' 111.• 575. _"'~b oiI.. ____ "~', tt s..__f;jo_~_SIBIu.

248U.s.1I.illlllll1'}~IlU_d~""'."r ,_"'., _,__ ~"""'lr"""'lnlh*eIb1lO__ID_Clf~.

_ ........~ ....._"'..~ol~...'

Tho _ ,""",In~ 101 _ m<dI oddillonal blI _MIY to~

lIIiI~~Df eongIN', K-.Id be lneII'.eti\fl Inappropriat• .. .-Imply

-"" 1M _ <II lho~ bo<IncltIy D)' • ....., "" 0( 8ddllDr\ll -. The

anIy_-.yIO..... '....N_of... "Y~__-'d bo.t__~<tf.......Iraz , _1IoIL

TWI_ Ii od_ ."'_"'_'"'__"'_' '_

ft_"l<i"g"'_"_~b". '_"

• ....__.._ .. II.CMPwl""'. II .... _ .. ,___.......--,. -------.,..--~..-... __.;..__ ......_ _--..,.. :._.._...." .... '_""'P-"... :n iiol..... 1I'>o____Of

• ....__.._""".....i* _,...-..~:tOCl'·t:!<'.a.M_ .. ·_ ..__.._ ..Cl"'Z<'-'l.1. ~_.'''' ' .... ... 'I'Ir _..._~ ....-.-...,---_..---_ -...__... ..,...-.

'"

Page 93: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

'OI,sr-. ,.". -= .,Annette Islands Reserve

Proposed Boundary Expansion

•--

••••-.•-.. ,..--••

---

,.. ",.

••

•l--~

~r~. =.,R .. , .".... ... . .. /.... .. ....... • 1 -.,_.'. .. .. ..._ .. ..s.::' ... ... ....-. .-.. ---- .. ..--- ..-... ... -,~ ...- -- - ....... -....~ - ~ "'". ~'":.:.. _'~.. .,~'~~- ..:~~... -7 .- .,... ". n" oJ-:.... .. "'.'" ..--_. - .... ....... ""- ... I.,. '.... ...

.. .p_... ;~,.~._--.....~ - ..........-'""'~"'... ... "''''''''''' ......-......-...... ... 0_"__- - - .. -. .,., ....... ... -----...""'........ OR,..,.....'\. ",:._.. "' ... ",- ......

.. ---":"'-;':...~~--,"-,. ,

on

Page 94: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

N,z

, ~

1 ~I '[ I}, J.~ ~

f< !WI!!< "jl .,r I-

!iblll~~h!l'~

~ HI in!i~ HilUil! ll" II

i I ,I II 'I~ i,l fill! 'i Iil iill j!!'J if I'i l'l .If! I{ .

If ,!!~ liI'. Ii iI ,11f ~l'l II ,

!. {hi {Jii!l; jIi !'ii[ i!j!; it ,1'f iii "".! !t i'n d!'l i 1!!l Ii!! }1!i11

Jj il IIf." -'fl . ,I !

I 61'i~~ 1ft I"jll' !'" ~l! i !IIIi ill i

Ii ~~,l In if ,11 " ,i jll Iji l 'l'~'~ II! II '~ ~§r 2 J! ~!il&~ al! l ~

II

! !!Il!!·I fH!

,,•

il .- .... -K'"'-j{-

!l"fIf I!"!~l~CO··oil ':if.. oll .. tl

~s

Page 95: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

,.' l'qolof2

Alllci>od io lho mom<> 10 J"" I<gm!ina lI'IiIi:uy )"'._~ .101\il witll lbo.~oeI on<! (lJQl ""'"ref"""<l ., .. Ir.

ron II.."!)' • •Special .....imnI OJ tho: Commi..,...... fo<Ccmm..i""liOfls .Dd LqlSlati"" "If"",Awn D<pItUn..'orFisb and Gam,P.O.!laJ; 1113261w>oau, AJ( 99!l11(ro7) ~6S.fj137 office(907) 3:lJ -m. eell

llJlJ2CQI ,"

Page 96: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

•.,

,

""",ro

"''''''"

MEMORA,....."DUM

T• ....,..~ ..~0=,. u..,.d.e--,. 11.:llIOI~~

_ .........~ ..... _ •• 0oס1 .. Ik,'.,__.....w IooI1l,lOO pet _. III ....MIIdl. 11oo_.~e.- _I dilf"""'bill, Hou. 8;ll1)1._ulbylh<

_ SpoclIOl CcmlIiUo< "" 10 iDc_1b:~ rr- H:862. 0... 0Itlmak oflb<:

CoalmI_ owoi1inJ odlodWinl b'. fIoor-..

"'"-.S--a-lio H.....F-flloilS- Bill214, _ -.1<1_

MIIOIl'--'__} ..·........._. ..... IIiII)'d.""

........ ilwiIl_.......... .. (f"" _ Gomo"" <JlUl,tllJ pot,.....

_ ••__..~.r.linI~............ _ ...._"'__

-.....u, .......

humlntI~ for tb; .,ilIWy 0Il1"" I "military "","I _"11muo, INI ...... m.oo per

'"

Page 97: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

both "<moll" mol "t'1" pm<. Bi, pm<"" ll'!<>s< 0p<>0i.. roo -.tIiclI """:«0 ",0<1 ro boy.

"P"'ioJ "i in o<lditioo co • hunti.. lk<.... Mili...,._I wbo WIlllIO hunt bill_ in

Ibtir_~.. tllOl'tbo '" AlasI:. o=Yy hi"" 10 I"'y U~.OO tacll for. ooo-~<klll _

oDd buy. Uil fi:>T~spodco !boy WIIlll "'!nuIf. M.."b<rI ctftb< militmy~ .. _ ... II

holflhopi~ poId by mn-=id<:Ilo. while reside<>t 1"'1~ for tho to,g~ AI tho.~

!ho~ ill 20015 (Ibo .- rt>c<nl year WI: """ .....\Im fur~ 179 p«>pk ill tb< mili'llJ' bought

til' o.od tho "",,-rnidcrJ' 11<"",". Of00""", we have no way ill~ how """')' oddicoo.ol

......cepoopl< <night lui! big _ill thoit forn '"",Ive-n" ifit ...... "*~•• to dO 00.

'"

Page 98: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

STAn OJ' Al.'SM>l'II7 U:GISLATlV& S&551011

FISCAL NOn:--­.­('<1--

,Clihi! ,lIfI,MI-

(tilil I.-itiln (tUil

" " •

-,."",

'_''-._.-In''''''''''''' ~•......__1>')._..._..,._.....,..........__ ...-.0

_._-~,,-----_.._..... ,,-.._""""',..,... , ---__.._...-..... _(AH<»__.-.__•.""" __...... '"--,.,.. ....."""-.-._-_ __.-.---,T............ _ .. '''''_llano ....._'__ _ .... .,...,~'''_

,,- ......_ ..__ ""&<''0'''0 "'. ""' '" _ ._'_m_e- ._...._ .._ .._ _....,_ .--_.._..,...-_.."'--_ ,"'''' '''---"'-""',..,_ .."""' .....,_..--....."-_....".-JO."""._"'_"'_="r rr.~;;. ......._._-

'"

Page 99: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

JtI

Ifg

II

I

II

'"

Page 100: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

CS FOR HOUS,; DILL NO. ]]7(1'1.."1)

LNnJE WlG!SUTURE Of TIlE S'T'ATE OF ...t ...Sv.

., T1I£~ .m"""" co..,,,,n&

""""', .....,~......,-

... BIL"

FOR ""......cr lNlTTJ.lD

........« p...idl•• for ".. ~oolioc ..d .port 1II1lb1. 11«_ for .d.......I>on .r ,I.

J .-.. for ..,.rllllhlo•• holla...d 'npp!l•••It•••,. U..... IIy ....d••,. .11. 0" ~

• ~..n .rq. or ...., ..<I p....,I•• for •••ff",tIn datL"

6 • _. I. AS 1~I».J4D!.Xl7l ~ arnondod to rood:

1 (17) W.oIrrio.1 """"""...... "'lI ' __ ___., 5

I (.4.) A pe.- may "'" _ In w_1 ilIlnu.., wlthoul

9 h'~'I""'_ ydto _wi..,"' ""'pttIOO'• ....w 1""'''''''' wUeso

"""""

(;i) ;.. _'undeo-lho .. ofli:

[riij ~ 60 ycatI of... Of oid....... ~. I'ISi<lom;

"N"70 .,.......... ' ...... _ , ..". oo.«oTaOI

'"

Page 101: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

I rlY) ill [A DISAlIU!D VIIT£RANj <liJiW< lOr. f;..,

2 I"""'" """" ~s 16.i\J~I.

l (8) Tho fl<>onl of Gam< >hajl by !<I"!al;'" ,.-pt t!><

~ _ilOlll<ll' of. _ .. I """""...."" Tal fur ",-_I ~..,..r., la ...... of

l tbo IIlII< no< rokcly I<l _~, li<lm <b:f;.... in A.l 1M" 1J00bX2) •

6 (I).

7 • Soc. 2. AS U.uS.l<O(a)(2lj i../lI",oal .. IUd:

I (23) ROIlid<m ""'""""'" l:ini:""""'''' ., , __ _.. 10

9 A In""", !nO)' DOt .,,_ In JPO<l fiJI".. lOr~ <in.g """"'"

10 "".tna QJmnI )W>~ ki"-l _ .., '" dI< _0<', ,""w

11 _1"' lno .... _

""

(A) qualiro.. !'of. 1.1 «n< 11:<0>0< Il>e u""'" (I) 01 dli.

I~ (H) 1s""""""""",ofl6;

II (e) Is 61) y<ar> of III" or older Illd bas boon a _ideo, of Iho

16 _. for II !em """,.r;

17 (1') is fA D1SADLf.O VETER.AN) .I~"" fur. """ iIo:<tlso

II '-AS 16.Dl.l'lI:or

I~ (E) quoiif... fils-. 51 I"""'" r.. UDder (6) ofthis~.

lO • s"". J. AS 16_01..l~11s_ .,,...s,2l Soc. IUUoII. F... Ib.., ror disobled -.n.. lid 'cd" ".mM .r12 lb...lub ~·aljp..! G..rd. A _ ""l' _i'<. ",>i<l<ul b""''''l: IltIO sport

21 ~>h"'II"","", WI.i<t AS I6.0BIO(.I){l) wllbollt clws< ift!>< pe.>OII

2~ (I) bas -. ilj",1\atp;ed Ii<>oI m;!itor) ><tVicc IInd!r~

21 ""fIIH'iono, is <IWole fu<. loon unl<, AS 11.}6.!Ol.... i. «r.Ji.... by tho U,;,.,j

:l6 S_ ~'ofV".,.". Atriin .. "-virq~ , l'O I'""=' or_27 dissbilily dllinl mililaty ....1«, [OR]

11 (2) """'" ill "'" AI_ T...,.;""ial GuanI, is "iii""' fo.. loon ",dot

29 AS IIJ6.101. Illd~. j(l _, or polItO. d"<IOl>ilily ~ilo _loIi irI "'"

1Il AlaI.. T<ITil",iol GLW'IliJl[

)! Ql liM .niummboutlb...... "" Nod...! G"rd,

C'SHI1J7(rn<j ••It! ru, _ ...... (wun:o ..... _

'"

Page 102: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

2HSOltlIF

.5«." AS i'm.4OO(ll) ~...,..r.. ,..j """"""" .. .-I,2 (~) A >po<! r........ _I. or ~<winf; lie..... i< nOl "",.trod of I ...ido,.

1 ...00 " 611 ]<&1"' of.,. or 1llO«_ 11 _ who " /;0 ".,." Of ... or"""" ~ toqtIm

4 .. _ • valid IdmIif""'loro~ '" "'i'F io -'P"" fitJlj"*' "'"""'J. or~

l _ • 1K:au<. Tho_"'~ sW! 1<,lt;tIcali<>\ eud .._ clIarv, ... pu>OO """ quOIjfl<f by 'I' ond ,...;,;r= wllo """,pl=a lh< _ ""l'Jtrod

7 by !h< oornrTti>sia><f. To oIItain or ......... 00101 _fl<ol1Qn <at<!, tho po_ .....

I flo.. IrwlUIIy ""or..,;. _ lim;! di.id<al """"I .... ""'" ""onl d1v1<l<rtd

~ dlabursal or m"" ........~ .."fO<lOry to tho dof'l"l<><nllhal "'" P""'" 10..

10 In "'" ..~.. b .. _ 115 daY' oIIirioa lh<,...,...... ca1erdo<..--_ A P"'""" who I,

II InoocI .. __<.tid .-.- tJti< .-rooo <i:aItl ha.. ;t in I' iM wbll.

12 >p;M'l~~ or~ 7110 _fi«lion...t ....... 1>0 ,.,..-.. ...ry

13 l!I=)'<a'>.

14 • S«. ~ liS IUIMOS(b} i..mond.d .. mol:

II (b) ""'....ItIto<ondm. liS lHIM10(,~ • ""idool llol<!lAt. ' valid reticloot

16 ~"."iog I"""", ..., <ok< _ .. t>dI&lf or. _ """ 1. bl!r><I" penal ..ill>

17 phy)i<aI 'iIaJI;lRi<o, 'It' P"""" wbo is 6.'! J"'&l'" of 'II" '" ,1:Iu If lh< "'''''tIS _onIh....i<I<nl'spo"""

T~ (I) ,-'t siJllOd by "'" _ on ...- b<h,lf "'" po< is

1ll !Koo, _ ........ "'" r<5id<nt -= Ih< _', ...,ti" I....'" or u!i!!21 (PERMA.~ENT] __ ...t in .,...... "',.., pm< "" _ oflhol p..-.o'i..o

12 ('l) 'I,._~

1) (II) midont hootiq licmse r.-o ....... AS 16.0l-4Cl or

14 !dlI (PERMANEI<T] idorojlicalion '"'"__ AS IMs.&OOfb); .....

21 (B) ""'- tOA '''10 --. or olII<.- dDt"..o." "G";"d by

16 ~..... ".,.,.;,;e" of"'" tho pm<> 1>0;'1_27 ·So<."ASIMM05(,);,~",~;

1.1 Col N<!tn!>l"........ liS I6.0M7lI(o~ • ""iobll !loki.......rOl

1~ """""",""""'*l fl"I"III_ "'"'1 ..... 6$h on bthalr.r. """"" ..!In" bl;nd..

1O _ '"" pO)'OQJ ~....,..i<a, or. pc_ "'"" io 6.'! J="I of ... or oIol<t If "'"

}I midmlpoll<M<llon""'_"'_~

,.... ..... '....00'... (~ I'U'!' """""'"

'"

Page 103: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

(I) '_rI"..o ~ tit< "",""",," -... behalflbOf"" ~ ......

2 ~ ..., .... resident poaetoeo!fle po"""" ""'" IWU"I~~ full'"3 permit. por>oo.ll ...~ pettn;1, <>t nIJ!I {PEJlMAND/TJ id<ntili<0Il0n OM! '"

• "'*'" to I>k< I'i.oIl on b<llorfoftbol p<r>Oll;

3 ('l) tI>< _',

g (A) ""idenI,p<>t1 tWo... li«nx _ ,"",AS 16.03.003 tit

1 ~ (I'l;1lMANENT] Ol<atirlCltion conl _ LIIIdcr AS 16.03.0/:10(0),

I (B) ~ -IUboi"""'< fuIlr>ll poem" wood ......9 .o.516.01..oo);<>t

10 (l;) _,~ ... ~-Ihinl """", Iuwd ._

11 AS 16.01..003; .....

12 (3) .n othcf-... ~<UOd .. Iho _ ""'"'" ""l"~ I»' 10....

1) ..,""".0. oflOl<'"1 II>< fuh "=I pum>od.

I' • _ 7. Tho _rOO<! 10... of "'" S,,", of Alo>U io -.de<l by ""'Ii••• ""'"_~ 10

II .... :

16 TRANSmON. t1l< 00"'''''''_ of fuh ..... "",,!IloI1 no<iti' ill '" ._iol<17 bm~l<U<Tm<p" ,.."'ldontin<_ '"'" Iloldcr:<oflb<""l~".rAS lMMOOIb~

11 .. ~",," 1<d~..... of<IW Ad. oncI pto>'id<~~ _;..... "I>lld

19 id<ntifo<ot;on '" "'P""" II« pennoa<ot i<len<llieI,iOrt cord .......... 1)' ,"tlIo<<u.l ~ .....

~ 0IIb0e0l......

21 .50<. I. AS 1&.03')o1{)) 10 I'<f"L'e:I J_JCl, 2010.

12 • s... ,. S=!o. • .,r"'io ....,,_ <!I'm 10...,. 1,200&.

($\10 1J'(f'I1"l ~

......' _ .... 1-....<> I'DT 0IIAd2ft0)u..,,""

'"

Page 104: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

srAn:OI'At.W<A"'" LlGl~''''TIVI SUSJON

FlSCALNOTE---'-.--~-- ,CSIiiI'>I[f11-

_.... lib

11..11

•.....-

peA;m>;L i:tkiiiri\l...

iC@iG!!liiUlitiL4li { I... I

-'--'-----_.-.....__ ......, _~.......,----_..__ ......_-_.- _.,""'''''''----_..__""""...""""""'_. 211"-"'_.__,.... _ ... "fioI\'" """'" _ ...__...... _ to .. JJ~""'"___ ,,_.. _ADI'w• ..., •• PI"IJ.....__.. _ .-,-,.,_ __...._--,,_ .._ _""-~ .--"""' .._..,-"""'_........-- .,., _",....., _ ... 01,000""_ • """I:l'" _'"-'''_ ..__ "._>0.""''''_''_'"'__.-_.---- ... ,..,

".

Page 105: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

-

IN THE lEGlSUlTtllE Of nlE STA.TI! oF AI..A$KA

TWDm'.flFTH 1£GlSUlnJllt:·$SCOl«D~

-,---

. ·_I.....,I'M~ol)io_._, (<ll _ of ""' ......, ..moo 00 .rI.. ilIII)r _ or<~

, _Io .......... _ ...~ ... dro ..~.__

7 MII.t'l,flS...,. "C ..wo.,.UIlla/SMAlLOAM£)_• ......~_ _IOr _ _._' ...... ,...,._.......&t " ' :,.,', .=h!"-',,,

10 0 L Bl1l1..,. .. _ .... _ ~ .... ,.._'... lal lr '.<IIlmII .' I!Klf)"...... _ ,......,. ,..-.. • (UGIl..AJ.

11 ~ Ht;Sl!1«i~ ,o.Hl) ,4.j ••' .. [ _

lJ ......_1Of. _."_pi fOt<e-HAl.J'Of'THli tomIR£'llOENl"] ....

lO _lIllHll(oj(U)jof..._

., ._-.... ""', _ "'ot -.... -... '0001

n,

Page 106: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

,,,,••""""""""""•"uu

"•»v

Ql IW t.,,!Iot T ' ...... oqtv!f!!y .....

"" .... ff .. "'!I"'PSw

w,.......,_~br

10\11<1]1._ ..... _ •

m1(A1i • ...- ••""".~fi-'••• _,....__ASOU.... _ ........... to,_ ..... _... • __..,_ ". '<It

!lIl(B)) ........ __ ~ p'4o

_ ASOlI.~ .... _10~ b1' _ __"'.

....-~ who "'" • _ .. p<DVMo bill ...... IulIirIc_..",,~ ..til ((l)l ...._ ""'" '9,...of. >olio 10

m[WI ... ......,Gl d .....

11I((1>] _., = II _ ...~

...- .......,~""--. ..-."50<.1. AS 1"'-«110010 _

f'I I ., M 5 -I ,.II! If" .... U ("'li]

.......... or .. _ .. b o(._~Io.(aI.,..-_.._...__._--......._..--..

....~ ... ""F' '_~.,..__ iII

....... _ ..._Oif/AlalN"'..-.... • __

_1o"-'''~_ASI1~

• Soc. 4.~ IvA_'"-., l.lro.I.

.,... II!( _dl-t ~"..,.......

".

Page 107: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

P~ I Drs

Uoyd, De~by S (DFG)

From; '-'_~{GOVI

_ r~, _ 'Il. ~D081"" ~r", Uoyd,I:>ool>yS[OI'G)

l<JOjooc fW. rha-i< j<>UI

fro."~ s-rr c (GO{)Sont; Tuoodoy, M_ I!, XlDIIll:O'l AMro<~ _ ~(GO>'J

s.m;O<t IW: Tho</I: rwI

Mil«, tbU awean lO bo r<ttini <JUt ofhoo<!..

Fhl",~Sor.JI1_(GOY~

So"t:T~. _ 18, T.<l8 1ll:5'I AMTo, ca~. 5!>Il"I C(GO.')SubJ_IW,~~I

.- Ora~ tI'J-* tD" "" ,.... """ a.., ""IIII'IOUJ/lIWl ",",a,." on .... ...-, 1

.. a.......,. ri bo dio<:>.-.i", <>Jf n",I..-Irq,1_...,... _11'>0 _lIYoWn)'DO _ fO"'SO/l"

............ tIul ","", I tho ...-1..,1 """'"- _ "'" __cIoI<t1FtJona t: moor__• ...."___.... ""bo.............. "'" _ 9j <I'!to_. .»hn, I_......_lho_I"\'OIT<TIOtlt _. p:_ «>IOnIl prognm In Y'I"" _ _ 11'-1 _ _ ""'"~ ..... _ '*""• oolson _"'" "" _'1Iopo ""' .. nDIlD tou>r -.; LI'l" 1<>:* illO_ ..~ '"~_~ "1"" .- "'7 _ lot LI'l_ Youn "'"", 800

&'ll12OO!l

Page 108: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

, .......

.... 11"'"_.<>d><o-...,Iim! """" ""'*' !veI ODd beuJ ., bo~ borbonoally frncn <be

....... ""' ••>aJot. or _c· or "1)nIIl,' .r." proud ., ""OtlO, ...... Ibe .... -.;orily of_ JIOCIPI. ill !hi< i""" =-ryl

.... Allwina <be~ of""",,", ODd boon Imm pi..... booo.- olldful ofpoopl••et!boorjoIllM'- it Itul opw. b: .._ ofo...JCl'IIYof .....-. .too ..... _ ""'.. ., boll <be~,II dlo "-1_ or "lop:aI' or" '!r'"

.... V,. c:olI_ looIpIooo rna pa,.,.portofloo-.t -w..•"p_) *iII.'

...........,q ' 1 _ .. •__ lIIm· 101I...._bIiacIIlo.....~l f'rm -.. _ of_1IioIIlltiIl Y_., nIIII ....

'I II _ ....... IocoIlI ... I .......

.... h1 V' J ..........Ioan~.. _ ... fioc.., ..... IoPU'l"'.. _

_ "OoIlhploo""¢".'I ._..-_.-W--w.-"'?I_1!d:q......do......,..,. _ .,..1I04J A1JJ;r_ .........-..bo ....... iII.IlolI •--.... : ._,: .lo........~' .....O¥il._.. ..<11_ _ ~ oopoao:I)' _ pI-.;' 'JOCId woot"'1'Il'IICt,..

~_ <k-. i11ho1.-,. JII-~ ill ¢,;" a""""""bl< "-.arorut. 0Ild bImo.-. tao_1!Ia~"'~' •·... ...,~·,.,.I:)V_·I~"·&""l"'.""'...,U'h <.>[email protected]> ......:~

......__0\'_ ,., ~_pIIo;lt1~ __.... _oI ...__.... _oI _J__.....-'dio • '-. _ -r-_.....,Iqjlc., __<&'1_ ..__.....", _~, ....... _JIIo"..__

'"

Page 109: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

--..._--"", -.... .....,...."._"""__....._(._ ...______C%IftOt""llI=' ,_ ,IllIII__"'-'O__""__.,_ T.-_ =...,.....,. "" .._~ ...._......__ _ _._ .""'__10..,...... _.....__ .._.-..,_-.-.0__''''_'_._'" .p,.. ......_,..... --_..__.... _ ... ...,..__Ior.> .. --. _"' ___io .., .._ _,..__......_ ..._Cllol__....... _ ...._-.

~....__'.._...._.._.....-" ..,._ ..,.,.--.......-­-..._,....----_.._-"'-___[__ 1 'oIO,oI-.-.J-._, ....... 11. llI:lI';05 ""T"8oII~"""_ Il1Jl p l "I~~'-:''''''''''''WI O' l'p;_to,., M.p; .... "," aI' I _;OOO'by.lo\<,' ' ... v-. ............,•• ' bp;doug,'"' .... 'h....p;~p;........,...."b<p<;~.d." \'g'N;

glrIo._ .' h""" ~",*""",,:.o-qOY;_.jio, r' ",P'; "'I'J<>".' :'''' P;..-.-._~~,••' ±'P; tr.w .......~ <;jldIdi",_oIi•. ...c;~"'''''''_.'~;~''''I:o''p;d'I'.I'''? 0 t I p,l&'I,!I" _II! ¢o.1iiO"i_.luI " . liiO"iaalil' WI'" .000;_' "_IiiO"i" ".1:"'.10 I I p;" ••,; _.'~',,:ol' , r " lIC"CIt: I'I t'4I; ; ._"'"'0;.....,.'0_ .. '.am;"I. """;'A II """""'"1;"1 4'b: )_~,"~_." oJutwav;.. I Il; 10'i'Ail:'I' ......1IIwA".,1.. 1; .... ,_11 I .....

, ;1 ... 10."""," I I I I Ail; ,. I_.....,.J lioIp .....__ I . ..;_1" :el '" an; ...., II "'e"'a;P • I 'o' ••"'Il:"u_11 • '-0_ • 1._,,,.•••• ' Ail;• • I __ ._

...... lIIf:~ '"""

_(.ut).

0) V,. .... 00 riP""-P' (l.c"_l__lIlIifo._dDoo _ ...b)ClM.ot p-..., ........__...... io· 'IIc) ...... .., ..... I:ilIq__ conlieo.collod-.J'O'l' .iII~..,·- '_.. J'O'l ........-._.._ ....~ .... -..-..j 1110 "" pniItIooo _ poopIo ..... _ &III coriboII,.,,.... ..... adoacilo"Sok~_ io 1>: <rod< ofJhol.I) The .,'l poapIo~ _ oool '*""" fl:o- food. Tbo ioooIe it _ AIo.ou. .""'iullr••lIIario, ...-<.-:l .....)IDlllyq olioIrI .... _ whylII Yoo IO>Cl """" immonI, _I.~ ..-.oIIlbis ill <lit<ICI~~ of fod-onJ low oocl opinsI1be """'"" of. mojorily of~l&l o,ti.... In )'O\lt ow..

So, '0 f\l(k yourwf nd hove luo rOltID,ln Hellll_.--

Page 110: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

....... ..-11 3' • _ .. ...-

:::==,...;,'".:::'d-::..::..'";..·......:.:::.:::=..-.......... _,... ......_~d...__..__.... ......__iIo<x:IIIO ...,...._' Wl __ ...._ ....,...IIol_I__JlN ... .., ......._JlN-.... _.1__., 1 _,..._ .....'.__._d.... ·· __--_ _---..,.--._.~ .....,--"'_.-C ., _ .... "'__.l__,..__..,..._ _d .. _toe_____ .,. ....,.._. d ..

____""... ' $ 1 'd..._I_""'__ I .. ' _I._,.._.-..,~

11oסi...._,... .. -....,. h _ ..ot~I_,.-r_.. _ .._.__.~-'~""looo.......,..u.tLy_.~::~'~:,.:.:' ....01__"u_ ¢ __.. clo ... _ ..~i1j... ......*"_lIIdwill...._.,. ot '

1.... 11 ~ .... _bopo, ....................of - '''-P''P'''''''''Jora' 1RfIlIy1lld ......~"""'.>iIe, 1 I 10<*. _ .... <>OIlId""""'" .r_..11<4* io a.dI. twt.i<, I... 1 """'" lbo IoolI ti-,.,.. tIIo ri.....ar\II"""17 ..-.<>IlIa _ """'It .. ,,'I"-olocun,. • lbolIIll

O.foramalOll ....... ~.. lo • ",,"oct -w. buI if_d.:I"r:- id-.ol......_~.. <J!lbo.. lloc:itioDI """"" ailI<r Ibo _ tIoc u """' lo beillI; audl,o lo1liclOd "" yiP!< ...~ """,_Il<Xl lan. Altboucll ['m .... n:liik>uo-.J.... ..- """,fott i. kDow'iq lhol oJ! ofYC<I will ....day"" I:Nn>£nI 10 H.U for""" <ViI ..uon.1

no I

Page 111: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

8<._&-, .... ' :...__iHII.,. YoII<>ol NoIOIc. Irr ....

m

Page 112: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

.,.. II.. _.....:>no --

D.lf'AllT.Id.:E..'oT OF FISH "-'iD G.UIII:

...-oFOF'Qi'_

_.~-_.,,,.__.~.­---------

M'MBUnN---_...-._---

"W*"tI\o_ ..~_1'OI11_,.."tooo.~c.e" ~:IO... .b.-n Tlro__otlllolOl ...

"~"_I'C/C.

TWo,... d ...-il* 10<~.._!' ·.....-- l"Bl_._...,..-...otllool...._ m_-.;,p,aooo-ol ADl'4J;i _lioi__~lolo ~ M1l.CJ,.,..u.,. .... -.,' STl'1d< ""'__ ! .. -.l~IIJI<dqAllFQ.

~_......_F ;, ,II .._""~___ :

., _r _ol6j, .. wlloWo__"""," cn...._ .........,._ol6oII _."'.. .UOU____ ........_ 0(_ -..... 'S'O';"Io.-,_' ',..,.,_io".- .. _ ...._ ,........J, ..........___..rw____ ""' -;;",,.._ n:..--.....-... .Io_ot :."'_......... nio__ io __ ot ; ________oLaO__ .. _ ..

'. • __... J ..._otf"*''''_~~

I

Page 113: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

__ ....._ ... Spo<t"''' e--.ioI ".,.".,.s....~,..d Vf,~,

=-"""'~' t "'" ..........~.... iSS nloLod~

•,,

1• I

S'(I<i""_...ll'... ... .nlIloo .... ""-.... ' ......",.,..". ",.am~"'11.0 b '" """ .. "'WOl.IolmIS"1:>0__1. ~,~ f .. <lo. ANll.CA'" r.;".J tloo """ ~ ~nIISbi<th<~,..

~---Tho ""'''0"",.-.. tIU ....~.... AS ".1<,1 10 [9). Tl>< ......"' .... of"';',.d"';!ko<i", ~ _ UOO6. _

.,.",

OMS APPROVED

IX J A!'"WVEll

tbrtuf~

22S

Page 114: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

_,.;ii....•.....;.:;·.'.",;'·;;.·iiii =,.••_- ,. "'''- _ •••

ICflr.,Alaska Official Election Pamphlet.

.- <OIlI<o.J_PoqIWol---\'tUb DMliM oC£l«tlons

BALLOT ME.4SURE NO.3: BiD ProbibiiiDg Same DiyAirborne HUDting

,.~

BALLOT LAHOU"'CE:nYlill_'*' '•w&I Wlilf;....-. .... Of 11"1' m...-dO)' •__~~ ..._._ooolt-=-"""r,H_i!ll:o.Cqn,"·· f1lH*_GuN...-."): J • i _ ••.-i!k__....... lu.. " ..d,

"'"'~no _ 'l"l'Jll:1. poopIo oidaK.... _dor""":', .be ''''~I&lmpu.BtootitII; tho__~ bo • rmmoa-. '1"0<..,011)' _ be jail_'ll' .._ )';IC, , lao '" to11,0llQ.1IlIl~ atIirwal Of~ tit1l>I:..lI'cr1>o.s-.. _

(I, v... fl.),0

nrunnOJ'J'IlOPOKDL.\W, \

"~""'lo!'''~fl''_'''''-Soc. 11.llS.n1.~ OF lo''4I.(lAYA!UOL~IUmMJ.WA,-.___ ..._iII V,..a;oool .......~ ... _...,.&..por-...-.*tIom<._, _a(_...,.~. ~ ....I!looCiqj 0/ _ !Iooo ill< air If

(1)"'= oI....._<Joo<._ _.~_',,,,,.,r,," _, _;0._.......ol!lof lban_ -..I 1OIl!!mIoo-.!II<.~ci 1_."'"(2)1llIIl""JI'f'lI .. ...,..."'oalybyD; • ·oI'iol>..ala-~

f)J"'_io'-"Ibo.-lto<:~_""''''IIiI'lIi; ,

Page 115: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

---"""""'_.'0(_ oaarijoN.._.o.. oI..-v................ Thh-:.1 ......_10' '!pm 01"_" , 1otI.~~................~ -.oc,llaob. -Jw p ...., (or lilt tJ.I,..~_.

• ___., ' i ] .. Gonno,...~e-.I.~.............. ....Jlio<_..-.n-wIC;,.~ir. IE _II&<-. .....' "_.....-

.r' S" ., _ I' ' .... .....,. ...o:l."*- __......- _........

,..

-­WcoI<71oUi111Slooo... + •~.,,-

n61 ..........~_._.... 010, ........Alo>/oo..

~

Blllltli MelJlln Ii·Rtr~te.DdumAD Act RelatiIlg 10 MJlDagemeol ure.flIe

.JALL01' ...........GU...GI

V... .,.1lIbd II> oiI/loo" _lIfr<joc:.1ow olloWc _ .... olrI'~"11lld••<:I?~.Ibool 'Olll.."" \III ..,.., llaru,.,l!Y. Tho I.... aIloWl "'ll' ....- wliI..~ '" lnpJII.,.lIooooo .. latrd Ofd oloooI '" ~oi:I!ol:.!bo~ "ro-., "" .Mj' ! ponnil...,..bo noqYrod. Too J,,,,oJoo oll lbo ........ n.,=! rl of'Jd,.."j a-lo .... _Ia, .....ott......,...,...., III b> -.do;r """""'" "'lolwol_ ... )'U V\IU njedllht law .....__ ....IHOUlJ) THIS t.l.WIll; J.EJECreUIY.or No

r-._ 20of... _ La... ., ,.JOOO .._-lto__ tIIo~-_._ _'? 1 5 l~dIo:".

...,~ _ _~ ... ""'__--.0011 • ...s.l __ ._ 11 _. .""_&1(_..__ .....Mo ~_.'--'.·po ," ...._ ...._•..._4Iq ,...__l1Io..-MI "1 'b'",-_otllw_D I otl'illl ...a-.. _ ......I0--........... · ......11-

m

Page 116: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

·,~"""- ,~,-",,,,,-,,- .."_._~_!L.--..

c

",C

$W~W~ @w £~~$m£__x

",-"-- 'oa_IlUAIftID,']' 01" PI:SII "-"iD G6IIB

_M_,00_'"=:.r:= 0. __

OFFICE Of' 1M"COt • '. 0H9 ,......-...00",_",'00,..-

M'MOUnD. ,.._-.0.._

~~ho_lIuIl.,<~loo_

m 00-0!lI00 o:I"lIIo a.:..- ' ....I···00.- ~Q'llallioDD,.-~ ~ OfPCEot

joo .._of"tl '._ 100 .....

.,,-.--,.~-'WIJ,~I'..M:;HT.IIIJDGET oo~- m ...

lO~

OIIoo"'M c •

- ...,-~ .... - opaoq.OIpiIoIl

--- ... -r _l;MI'i"pol<Tll!lo<DIw_Z2,:J:lID, u,.-.c._or 4 - •••--.~_~....~ il pi .. ' AM.o...--",,,_tJO,eIS.n1o

~(~..==,"~~.:J..!1':::~=t:lldS;"Tbic 1toI_~ -..&!,J''*-Pl'''c .., .. 0lII00 n" :I .... _.. """ -....e '.0lII00,.,.cl__........,.,... no_1o...... _ ..... 1OIl I 1 _ ... ...,.... 0 ' I ..--1110_...... 1

1

..........-.1'tr,---- ~~1f~,J,.lIlIo_---. ..C : F "0lll004F ' [ ., ... [ . t b'l;2P.....u.. 1$ .... I I ......._ ..__ot....._ • • P'"__¥i..~.,._or1l",","Iot__..-' ..,.--....-_...til I

• OMS "'PPRO~O

.Il>'DO

Page 117: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

ETHICS DISCLOSURE FORJ\-I

INolifie.ttioo of R"""f?! of GiIlI

" Lindo. P= .~ Et!rics Suporn....

I:Il«<ll'Iloocow:llbASl9.nllO(b~l...~_ol"'Y"""""of·IiftFooo"""or._of"'lI!aIIliI)'",6 • nloo!ll "'_ofll ~.OO,

,",,!b< &id IiV<ll~ booo"",)'OO ""' • ....." ""J'l0'J"<'" 'I><flJbor of. "'"'" boml ..""".,,;...... 'fe. No 0

1"",___llWlllOyall'o<lk....-._p..mo1b<1iI:"., NoD

Iftho"",_ .._of_ que<!iom is "". "'" <lo ...,,,.... "roport 11lio ll!. !fib<_to'-~.)'<O,orif)W...""'=0,1'"om! """'l'1<ul!Il< form-.Ipn>villo~ "'1"""do<ip.... _

-~

Th>pll< T ..h n.,lA "'''W11l9!IAn~::,/ ~oIlyl!J> 911!~""liq,,,,~ ,t~v~~...,;."" (i"'<Lv~,"1j ~ FLU$. o'If"C/'JlI;I, . .ro f'9UoJ)S Of "¥len.-." ..

My_ofill"wo;,s ~$""Q:"'o ~I_~- 'WH G:ll!li.J • "'-...,."."A 8l.A£Y

'lb<al< o£rooeijlI .... HI,. le-~ , -1_.....__ llof~ofl>::iaJ.w.__1ho1ior.

"Y;';;'~;i'j:~;:j%~,:;~' P,'Thor;lll"'.. "',....,".,. • .-ofmyf'>mily Or.. I:!I No If r,.d'

I~ .."'''''01..,._Jodp"",."..._tlt _ """'" oed~ 10....-.... "_""""-,,,or, , 1lIor..,. "I'M: ..._;,.. of.__is I -. "'"","I18I1.56',:roo·

~""'4L~¥.Iolay2J,2OOI...,

DenIl)' s. LloydihiiII' Namaj-- -(htilioo TllIt) ......,- ..........."'_ ..... """"

(Djyioj<nI.......~_1oa)

(lloolrm<_'-) , __(ioitioloj

"'"If_• ..,..,. ...... AS J9S2.2I~ .. Ali !~-'I,21111'1-_~

,~

Page 118: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

· KelPO"'*~Q.' .$C:h~.1Iary It (DFG)

~_ ~._W(OOV)--

_ ZliIocllt',_(~l-='" ';,,..__ 11:211"'"T_~_.(GOlIl

~-=...__o

--;"\ _ , Pogo 1 ofl

Jll""'D I Nip';" ..,JJ~ -In oJJ

2-"9-1'1'13

_.

...,. I _ Com" I ',. llDyll callI""" ... Inllll T'Iwe If .., ""*""" -.g wltnI>elO - he_bo"""'.t .....~_,

f,o"" ZOr!otI'. _lrnolto:Mh>occ) II' I i.a>m]_: TIIol<Io!, ""'" 17, 2001 '~PI'!To: 1..oIil/IOW. _ W (Gl1Ii)SuDIoot: 11(: lIOIo< _Idor<:e Q

_· ...... _.""".,...,.,..."J'lI"-*'v,)lol~lOpoI........ OWl ......'.. '.....~.I--~-,

_ ........ _W(GDY)[_=-OOI" OJ Il' ' "pI_ ro.lOf. ""'" U. lid; 6;D POIT_z.-,,_......."" ...--Q-....1..._.... ,

---<;;;;....~~__._<Hl • ' __

Page 119: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

,.,. uw-. _ If (OOY)_ n. :n JLI>;.'_..,...,..., --Q-_"' -._Itidt_ _ ...__a.--.-,.."'6o_-_ ,.-.....,_ __ .._--_......_. "_-l1II"__"", _10 ...__...__ ,nlo_....__., · .._.....,.._.._10 _ ,-__.._ ___ ...__1060_'"M__ E $ __.. _ ......--.-... _.. ."'_,....--._..Io....,~

Page 120: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

I'ai!' 1 or 1

I.IoJ'd, o-nby S (OFGJ---VOlt_..... ..... _.'_"' ~_IO_I!oo____ :=. Illdl .......~ """"",,,,__III_s-Iof_.......-......._"' -_.. ..---""'*_.. ,._..._____ _..._b_ '...__ Wt_ ...._,

-"---~"' -'''''''''''__'''''__.'''_1_..... ...__"'~

r"" .....--,,--­~......,,--"'''''­,"'-""

__",..,-....r_, I'll ....j_ ,..,...".-...1&,210 11:S1'"T.. u.,a, ClOIoOt' $ (DR;);~ ca,.IoolI(lIf'G)1lIIfooz:_.- __ A~,.~.~...._ ':uNJRi ... '_'IOIu*'V"'__~"""'ner.. 'fOIl

Page 121: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

Pag. I of 2

•lloyd, Donby S (DFG)

F.-, lJo)<l.~SiNGl

So.t T_.y, I\Iq.oot D5. 200S 3'.13 Pl\l

To: _ ~~ IGOY)

Co: Ctomo. C",. J IGOV~ uoo-; ~"(DR>~1Io<~,~ M IOfGt Soxby, K"" M (lAW)~:FW:__ 2

Wo__ ~.,"'I'w_.IOIo>,.a.""_-"'2~_VNT:·NI"""

~!no0I>0CiIIrlil oI_.no~ Ooon. _ ....... 01_1. _ ... ""I'... IIoI/lo;«Or~I pompIots '" too u""""*'ll~ _ on~ 26 ...-DO "'" L' Go, .. ,...~01_..-.... 8<lolin_. ....".,..lIyt...~orollo ~.k<-....y"'Io_

Tho 'pro.__._10JooI_ ono ""'" opono::n 01 O5IIlINT.

lho ."",'_. 0IlI'b.1Od 10 Woyoo R07"'h _ CoItIo. _loIorJ NoiOOrI. WO .......... """'"""hi""'''''_ a:taIIrpropotood ond _ .,. PM;IWo"-/_"""",,__~~ .,. trIO---I·lho ~LUIQO10 !tIo """_10 '""""'"".. -...", .. Woyoo 10 I-io~ .0""';";"'" _ "'"lJoo>-"•• 01 Filii ofIO Go<To 10 0<l0t'y 00

-rn;o .ornpjy., FYI, 0ir100 .....~ 10 no~_10-'

~

-'-c _

'..,m: _ ........,. A (0fG)Soot: 1WidoI'.~ 0'1, .lOOlIll:16 A>ITo, LlIml. Dontoi S (Elfli)s.l>jo<t: Ill: Z

_ !\leo."", 2 p""

ht.d/yn: sh-'iroy dUMmDoom;""/~ _.pdf

..­-.,-.......~.'F ... _GomoOfWoI...c ' ..

Page 122: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

':lSI 'I' "_/Po. a.. ,,»311......AIC_'C"ll46U'''_(lIGl)~

Page 123: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

" YES"* on a-__2 _ prtI/IIIIhllllootl1Q 01~ _ grW:Iy-._ .. oil' ""~ 1IIt1Il ..... 10 _ nllllOol, .1*\""~<:onI'III~_IhioCci ..," l.oIFIoh_o.m.d ",II__on "I'·.... -.""*'Qi".. --V-"'Y_.

A '•• ~ ........'" ..d_•• CI> ""-. ...... ' G' _ --"'" 10. poInI"" r -...._.~,,,_ sl ~._...",.----.-v-_i,. ....TrIlI .... _."'oI'. ,hol .. , a"'....,iliG""'IIDrill'oI_~1¥~nl-.bJl_·I I 1t)_~"'1'" _w._•.IIIIjgrtIjr of 0' , ••"4'J6! .... _ ... '*' I by,,"klf657.ooo, II .t9*I_........ IoS1Il1 ..~_-=x..o-._-..a~II nn1_

1lIIol_2.. _.... .. nI, I .". , •••~_....,._~""*"' .. p I •_-.._ I, lsIm1on ..crv*G_»olIO~oarn-I. I' .11:0'_ .... I .......-of~ .......... _ ...... _cawLoQ.'.II ~ B1-,.,lInIodsknll 1Ia'.g11 I " I .. luIirQ .......__ I 'qQII...._I I 100._ ...

lfllllol _ 2 _ sdI ....... logoiIlO ..... _Ilunl ....... on blta bl' .o."madllilf,." ....,pilylll.- /Ill wen ll)I fleee "ditid> •..-fhe~ .... ,......... YES ......on BsIalIAMsLft 2. __lotWId&. 10 '""''''- III Ionll-l&m olalO"__ sei:IYIIy flunlllJ! be!q.... _ on Ihio .... cl8lr>:tsft b' t>Nrllf'ld wolf _ .... -.oIIY_"' ......... lrM;itIIsd wIlllll1lo lype d 1hooIIrol. am..,.."dJmaAllos _!~.~ C\onot '" Ihio iIn8O<t d~ gsms rnIIlSQIII'TlS/ ., AI_."'"-*..h. nbltod 1MI.,,-~ l'O"ll'_ ......._.,..

odf lis ~ Ihiol' _ ~)JslIllal. ~S(:6,; *"" \1""'_., btDIil ~_'I ~ 10 I"CII.

~_YES,",__2..goWlldol.__.... _

~." OQII '" Ihio...-~ Ihsl__• ""'''' ,...,.~ lIIs__ pl&::IIg S«ioas_ ......0" , ,I,. t '""*"""'" """"'"""'Nh_

--_ond ....... C<>"'I ~

I

Page 124: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

........2_.r•• 1I) ......U _ .._~•• , _ Ia_Ilf _ OlIOIo _¥IlIO _...._-...Thio..-..Io~ _h._"'_·_._d ...__ 10 ....._11_..~

of, ; I "'_A. , .• Roo' ....OO·__•• , ......"""I'_~__• ., .....

II _ .._ We , .P "'JI6-• -.;__........ _' , .labo I " : 2 ...

__....__diopoIdon _

V<* NO OII"-'" 2:uri bo_.PNdolO<~ 10 ..... _"II .... faOo_-*Odo ....1IlPI\I,.Io._..... ' '."1OOl, poorIod. Pnd__". g i.~ __.......- ...__ II> ~ p<IIlI.Il-.o_ ....-.".,... _ ......... _ 10 food-. I'redoiof..........,.,.. .. no! Ita/!

~ OIl~ -..t- • "' ......" •• __ ..... ",o<_lIIO _rim II,,-V... NO lII\ 1.1....... 2:

AIMUnI .. _Ihoo _ llr.oo -.at'-""'" Ihoo ktIi'III porwwd """""".eo...- clop __ ...Ibcl."" 1dI'-d .... _ pooplo __fI_ by_.n.. oIlIII Wody. They lIM I'llltM Ihll

, :, " ....d_4'U~pnp ......

VoIo NO "" w-. 2:"'-_.... "'__: 4 ," _oyl:opo"hIrJlIII.--.g1uologcr.a- ~Iftll*l'_ .... u ... 0nII' .......__CIIlIkNIII_.._ _"'_~, ".c._._Iol'...-_l, ", 'ocI.OI'ktl\r"... • ~~-.g~_ ; ,••_1>_ 5 ..<rif.I'lII.-......_In ,.. ... ...,....... : No_h. ' .-.","' .......,..

....... N() "" _ 2:_"_"__2_. $1 ..._" ..... <11 ..•.......410 III iWillXl.._lIS'''_ ..__"'"_ to-'-ID.......~_t b ...I_......_ .• Io.__...G••__

.... !ll' out 04 """.i· I$,

Vole NO ""-.. 2:n.~ lUll bI''' _ ~ 0>11_ JU;ljlDIllng 1hIo ...-n 10 <\aoV1e<l10 IIg It JOUr~ IleIont i'O\I .... i'O\Ir _dedobl,~ODIIJIder_~~Meaouro :l

Page 125: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

. .

• Pi 1M •• , _lInotlluntlnll_lIoNt_....__lD_ \a~_,r ..

• Pi' _, '••II~_""__ " ' • __Ilh__1O .~.._~• __~,_ 0 _c. "",,,,, ...... _-__NO ..._2

SIio,_".~_

F....... AIo.rb.~ Q/ a.n.o~

...,­S1IIt.~_

Page 126: Communications to or from Governor Palin or the …...To ADF&G (Lloyd, Bedford, Lawson) Privilege/Production Log Page I of 22 Date Doc. # Autbor Recipient Cross Copy Document Description

~._-----

DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND GAME

OFFiCE OF mE COMMISSIONER

MEMORANDUM

o..;"j -.llopl(y~_...."""";-W\ood1ho<3<Mom<:<

_,..,. \tCo 'n..

I do/ep1o JUOIl {)yo 10 bo 1h< AiaIb lleporImom ofl'ioll!Old0- (ADFolOj ' ...._ •• 011tho WOO<! TJk:dllI< SlIID I'llk MODOP'""" C<r.mciI (CwD::il). It 10~ rOD" ADFo 10 110 ...!b< Couocil b<oooooo th= .,., lil'tif«<lllob ""'" ooiIdIi!;,-..ODd lIS<O> witllio 1h<pci'.!Old by IIIDJ' bolmpoaod by lb. pori< 010'" "' pltn wIliclI1h<""""'"'I tlcvolopo.

'Ibo CouDdl de>oIops the 01_, 01 'plD<I blbopott wlllI.oosl«*DOe It<>o> tho AnNa-ODd_otIIlmr_ .ftllo plllL Tho C=iJ comist> oil memb... oppointoll by theGovorn« _~ local oi!I&so mombcn, 1ari.uollloy NOll... II_odon _ba'. I ADNRo>emIIOr. ODd 1ADFW m<mbcr. Thoy=opproximatoly l tilrn pu yoM.

11>< _ .... """".-JIly""_ by C!lorlDtto Westioll(_OlNi"" ofe--clalFiIbttioo Ilril!Olllo.y AJs«lD"I""" M'"'i"""'l BIoIott>t)!Old V.z.~ Iw ,oha:Ioerod to beOOOlod .. tboooxtADFdt.O, .... _ ••_~ 1bo00vioiooofSportFioIINuMt- g orBioloi'a M.. Dyt _ J'D'CYid< valuob1o iopulimo tho~ o.od lmpl=onlDti.. ofl!l<

-""J Ql '"plIll.

a:: a.IJo~ DlrooIor. Olvioioo ofSpon F"h, ADF&n.r",,&-. ReKio<>ol Soporv!.oor, lJivlolon otSp:rt F!JIl, ADFoI:OJ&><D:1!)yo, F'~ BioloPoi m, I.>ms;on ofSpott FWI, ADF&OWill... &rkIIoIIIl, r.u~ II, A1ubo DopulmtDfotNItIln! R==eo

".