506
Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci 1 , Sara Mattia 1 and Paolo Ventura 1 1 IASI - CNR, Via dei Taurini 19, 00185 Roma, Italia f tiziano.bacci,sara.mattia,paolo.ventura [email protected] August 1, 2018 1

Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Computational results of the Bounded BeamSearch algorithm

Tiziano Bacci1, Sara Mattia1 and Paolo Ventura11IASI - CNR, Via dei Taurini 19, 00185 Roma, Italia

{tiziano.bacci,sara.mattia,paolo.ventura}@iasi.cnr.it

August 1, 2018

1

Page 2: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Contents

1 Description of the data set 3

2 group 1 4

3 group 2 14

4 group 3 73

5 group 4 75

6 group 5 89

7 group 6 205

8 lbri 385

Page 3: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name Authorsgroup 1 Wan et al. (2009)group 2 Wu and Ting (2010)group 3 Lee and Lee (2010)group 4 Caserta et al. (2011)group 5 Unluyurt and Aydin (2012)group 6 Zhu et al. (2012)

Table 1: Test beds used in the literature of the BRP

1 Description of the data set

In this document we report the computational results obtained by means of theBounded Beam Search (BBS) algorithm. For all the tests we use a machine witha CPU Intel Core i7-3632QM at 2.2GHz and with 1 GB RAM under a Linuxoperating system. We set one second as time limit for the solution of each instance.

We considered several sets of instances presented in the literature, divided into sixgroups that are resumed in Table 1. In the following, w is the number of stacks,h the height of each stack and n the number of blocks in a yard.

group 1 is defined by the instances presented in Wan et al. (2009), all with sixstacks of height between two and five. The storage densities of the stacks areclassified as light (L), medium (M), and heavy (H), according to the percentageof operating capacity taken up. In particular, an instance with w stacks of heighth is light if then number n of blocks is 0.2 × ((w − 1) × h + 1), is medium ifn = 0.5× ((w− 1)× h + 1), and heavy if n = 0.8× ((w− 1)× h + 1). In total, 12combinations of stack sizes and storage densities are considered, each composedby 50 instances.

The instances of group 2 (Wu and Ting (2010)) are grouped according to thenumber of stacks 3 ≤ w ≤ 12 and height 3 ≤ h ≤ 12. Therefore, we have 100problem classes, each with 40 instances. For each instance, the number of blocksn = w × h− (h− 1).

The instances of group 3 (Lee and Lee (2010)) are defined on multiple bays yards.Here, we consider only the subset of the 70 Individual ones, i.d. those where theblock have distinct priorities. The instances can be Random (R), when the blocksare randomly located in the available slots, or Upside down (U), when blocks withhigher retrieval priority are located in the lower slots of the stacks. All of themhave up to 10 bays, 3 ≤ w ≤ 16 and h ∈ {6, 8}, and 70 ≤ n ≤ 720. Here we allowreshuffle of blocks between different bays: therefore, an instance with 10 bays and16 stacks is equivalent to an instance with 1 bay and 160 stacks.

group 4 includes a set of 880 instances introduced in Caserta et al. (2011). Suchinstances are randomly generated with w ∈ {3, 4, 5, 6, 10, 100}, h ∈ {5, 6, ..., 12, 102}and n = w × (h− 2).

The 8000 instances of group 5 (Unluyurt and Aydin (2012)) are generated withw ∈ [3, 7], h = [4, 7] and different densities of the blocks. They can be balanced

Page 4: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

(b), if the stacks have the same number of stored blocks, or unbalanced (u).

In group 6, we consider the 12500 instances described in Zhu et al. (2012). Suchinstances are grouped into 125 classes of size 100, according to the values of w ∈[6, 10], h ∈ [3, 7], and n ∈ [(w − 1)× h,w × h− 1].

We also introduce a new set of instances, lbri. The procedure implemented togenerate the new instances follows the scheme introduced in Zhu et al. (2012).Here the authors show that it is always possible to retrieve all the blocks of ayard with w stacks of height h and n blocks if any block i is located in a slotti ≤ h such that h − ti ≤ w · h − n + (i − 1). Then, for any triple (w, h, n), withn ≤ w × h, the instance generation procedure is the following: we first randomlyorder the n blocks and then, according to this order, we iteratively assign eachblock to the first available slot of an available randomly selected stack. If the yardgenerated this way does not fit the feasibility condition defined above, then it isdiscarded and regenerated. The set lbri consists of 8400 instances, 100 for eachtriple w ∈ {50, 100, 500, 1000}, h ∈ {4, 7, 10} and n ∈ [w · (h− 1), w · h− 1].

For each set of instances, we report a table with detailed results. In the tables,Name denotes the name of the instance, w indicates the number of stacks, h thenumber of available slots for each stack, n the number of blocks, and #i is thenumber of instances of the group. Resh and Time denote the number of reshufflesand the computing time obtained by means of our BBS algorithm, respectively.

2 group 1

Page 5: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata62L1.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0017data62L2.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0014data62L3.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0016data62L4.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0016data62L5.txt 6 2 3 1 0.0016data62L6.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0016data62L7.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0016data62L8.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0015data62L9.txt 6 2 3 1 0.0015data62L10.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0015data62L11.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0017data62L12.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0020data62L13.txt 6 2 3 1 0.0015data62L14.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0015data62L15.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0015data62L16.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0015data62L17.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0015data62L18.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0015data62L19.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0014data62L20.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0014data62L21.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0014data62L22.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0014data62L23.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0014data62L24.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0014data62L25.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0014data62L26.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0014data62L27.txt 6 2 3 1 0.0014data62L28.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0013data62L29.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0014data62L30.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0014data62L31.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0014data62L32.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0021data62L33.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0014data62L34.txt 6 2 3 1 0.0013data62L35.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0013data62L36.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0013data62L37.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0013data62L38.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0013data62L39.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0013data62L40.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0013data62L41.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0013data62L42.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0013data62L43.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0013data62L44.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0013data62L45.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0013data62L46.txt 6 2 3 1 0.0013data62L47.txt 6 2 3 1 0.0013data62L48.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0013data62L49.txt 6 2 3 1 0.0013data62L50.txt 6 2 3 0 0.0013data63L1.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0012data63L2.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0013data63L3.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0013data63L4.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0014data63L5.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0020data63L6.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0014data63L7.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0013data63L8.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0013data63L9.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0013data63L10.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0013data63L11.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0013data63L12.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0013data63L13.txt 6 3 4 2 0.0013data63L14.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0013data63L15.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0013data63L16.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0013data63L17.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0013data63L18.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0012data63L19.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0012data63L20.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0012

Table 1: Computational results on the set group 1

Page 6: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata63L21.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0012data63L22.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0012data63L23.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0013data63L24.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0012data63L25.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0012data63L26.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0013data63L27.txt 6 3 4 2 0.0012data63L28.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0019data63L29.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0012data63L30.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0012data63L31.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0013data63L32.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0012data63L33.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0012data63L34.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0013data63L35.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0012data63L36.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0012data63L37.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0012data63L38.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0012data63L39.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0012data63L40.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0013data63L41.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0012data63L42.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0012data63L43.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0012data63L44.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0012data63L45.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0012data63L46.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0012data63L47.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0013data63L48.txt 6 3 4 0 0.0012data63L49.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0012data63L50.txt 6 3 4 1 0.0012data64L1.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0014data64L2.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0019data64L3.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0013data64L4.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0013data64L5.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L6.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L7.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L8.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0013data64L9.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0013data64L10.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L11.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0013data64L12.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0013data64L13.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L14.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0013data64L15.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0013data64L16.txt 6 4 5 2 0.0013data64L17.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L18.txt 6 4 5 2 0.0013data64L19.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L20.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0013data64L21.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0014data64L22.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0014data64L23.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0014data64L24.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0020data64L25.txt 6 4 5 2 0.0014data64L26.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0016data64L27.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L28.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0013data64L29.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L30.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L31.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L32.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L33.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0013data64L34.txt 6 4 5 2 0.0013data64L35.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0013data64L36.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L37.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L38.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0013data64L39.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L40.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013

Table 2: Computational results on the set group 1

Page 7: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata64L41.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L42.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0013data64L43.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0013data64L44.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0013data64L45.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0020data64L46.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L47.txt 6 4 5 1 0.0013data64L48.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L49.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data64L50.txt 6 4 5 0 0.0013data65L1.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0014data65L2.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0014data65L3.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0014data65L4.txt 6 5 6 2 0.0014data65L5.txt 6 5 6 2 0.0014data65L6.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0014data65L7.txt 6 5 6 2 0.0014data65L8.txt 6 5 6 2 0.0014data65L9.txt 6 5 6 2 0.0014data65L10.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0014data65L11.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0014data65L12.txt 6 5 6 2 0.0014data65L13.txt 6 5 6 0 0.0014data65L14.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0014data65L15.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0016data65L16.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0019data65L17.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0014data65L18.txt 6 5 6 0 0.0014data65L19.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0014data65L20.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0014data65L21.txt 6 5 6 3 0.0014data65L22.txt 6 5 6 2 0.0014data65L23.txt 6 5 6 0 0.0014data65L24.txt 6 5 6 2 0.0014data65L25.txt 6 5 6 0 0.0014data65L26.txt 6 5 6 2 0.0014data65L27.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0014data65L28.txt 6 5 6 3 0.0014data65L29.txt 6 5 6 2 0.0014data65L30.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0014data65L31.txt 6 5 6 4 0.0014data65L32.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0014data65L33.txt 6 5 6 2 0.0014data65L34.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0015data65L35.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0016data65L36.txt 6 5 6 2 0.0018data65L37.txt 6 5 6 2 0.0014data65L38.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0014data65L39.txt 6 5 6 3 0.0014data65L40.txt 6 5 6 3 0.0014data65L41.txt 6 5 6 2 0.0014data65L42.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0014data65L43.txt 6 5 6 2 0.0014data65L44.txt 6 5 6 3 0.0016data65L45.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0015data65L46.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0016data65L47.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0015data65L48.txt 6 5 6 1 0.0014data65L49.txt 6 5 6 2 0.0015data65L50.txt 6 5 6 0 0.0014data62m1.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0015data62m2.txt 6 2 6 0 0.0014data62m3.txt 6 2 6 0 0.0014data62m4.txt 6 2 6 2 0.0017data62m5.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0019data62m6.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0014data62m7.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0014data62m8.txt 6 2 6 0 0.0014data62m9.txt 6 2 6 2 0.0014data62m10.txt 6 2 6 0 0.0014

Table 3: Computational results on the set group 1

Page 8: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata62m11.txt 6 2 6 2 0.0014data62m12.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0014data62m13.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0015data62m14.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0014data62m15.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0014data62m16.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0014data62m17.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0014data62m18.txt 6 2 6 2 0.0015data62m19.txt 6 2 6 0 0.0014data62m20.txt 6 2 6 0 0.0014data62m21.txt 6 2 6 2 0.0014data62m22.txt 6 2 6 0 0.0014data62m23.txt 6 2 6 2 0.0014data62m24.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0015data62m25.txt 6 2 6 0 0.0020data62m26.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0014data62m27.txt 6 2 6 2 0.0015data62m28.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0014data62m29.txt 6 2 6 2 0.0014data62m30.txt 6 2 6 2 0.0014data62m31.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0014data62m32.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0014data62m33.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0014data62m34.txt 6 2 6 0 0.0014data62m35.txt 6 2 6 0 0.0014data62m36.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0015data62m37.txt 6 2 6 0 0.0014data62m38.txt 6 2 6 0 0.0014data62m39.txt 6 2 6 2 0.0014data62m40.txt 6 2 6 0 0.0014data62m41.txt 6 2 6 2 0.0014data62m42.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0014data62m43.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0014data62m44.txt 6 2 6 1 0.0014data62m45.txt 6 2 6 2 0.0015data62m46.txt 6 2 6 2 0.0020data62m47.txt 6 2 6 2 0.0014data62m48.txt 6 2 6 0 0.0014data62m49.txt 6 2 6 0 0.0014data62m50.txt 6 2 6 0 0.0014data63m1.txt 6 3 8 3 0.0016data63m2.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0016data63m3.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0016data63m4.txt 6 3 8 3 0.0016data63m5.txt 6 3 8 1 0.0016data63m6.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0016data63m7.txt 6 3 8 1 0.0016data63m8.txt 6 3 8 3 0.0016data63m9.txt 6 3 8 4 0.0016data63m10.txt 6 3 8 1 0.0017data63m11.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0023data63m12.txt 6 3 8 0 0.0018data63m13.txt 6 3 8 0 0.0026data63m14.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0027data63m15.txt 6 3 8 1 0.0023data63m16.txt 6 3 8 1 0.0018data63m17.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0019data63m18.txt 6 3 8 0 0.0022data63m19.txt 6 3 8 3 0.0020data63m20.txt 6 3 8 1 0.0028data63m21.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0028data63m22.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0029data63m23.txt 6 3 8 0 0.0028data63m24.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0028data63m25.txt 6 3 8 1 0.0028data63m26.txt 6 3 8 3 0.0028data63m27.txt 6 3 8 1 0.0028data63m28.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0028data63m29.txt 6 3 8 1 0.0028data63m30.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0028

Table 4: Computational results on the set group 1

Page 9: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata63m31.txt 6 3 8 4 0.0028data63m32.txt 6 3 8 1 0.0028data63m33.txt 6 3 8 1 0.0028data63m34.txt 6 3 8 0 0.0028data63m35.txt 6 3 8 3 0.0028data63m36.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0029data63m37.txt 6 3 8 0 0.0028data63m38.txt 6 3 8 0 0.0028data63m39.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0026data63m40.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0018data63m41.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0018data63m42.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0018data63m43.txt 6 3 8 3 0.0017data63m44.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0017data63m45.txt 6 3 8 1 0.0017data63m46.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0018data63m47.txt 6 3 8 1 0.0018data63m48.txt 6 3 8 4 0.0017data63m49.txt 6 3 8 2 0.0017data63m50.txt 6 3 8 4 0.0017data64m1.txt 6 4 11 2 0.0021data64m2.txt 6 4 11 3 0.0021data64m3.txt 6 4 11 6 0.0021data64m4.txt 6 4 11 2 0.0021data64m5.txt 6 4 11 5 0.0020data64m6.txt 6 4 11 2 0.0021data64m7.txt 6 4 11 4 0.0020data64m8.txt 6 4 11 3 0.0020data64m9.txt 6 4 11 4 0.0021data64m10.txt 6 4 11 4 0.0020data64m11.txt 6 4 11 3 0.0021data64m12.txt 6 4 11 4 0.0020data64m13.txt 6 4 11 3 0.0021data64m14.txt 6 4 11 3 0.0021data64m15.txt 6 4 11 3 0.0021data64m16.txt 6 4 11 4 0.0021data64m17.txt 6 4 11 4 0.0021data64m18.txt 6 4 11 3 0.0021data64m19.txt 6 4 11 4 0.0021data64m20.txt 6 4 11 4 0.0021data64m21.txt 6 4 11 6 0.0020data64m22.txt 6 4 11 3 0.0020data64m23.txt 6 4 11 2 0.0021data64m24.txt 6 4 11 2 0.0020data64m25.txt 6 4 11 4 0.0020data64m26.txt 6 4 11 5 0.0020data64m27.txt 6 4 11 1 0.0023data64m28.txt 6 4 11 2 0.0021data64m29.txt 6 4 11 3 0.0022data64m30.txt 6 4 11 4 0.0020data64m31.txt 6 4 11 1 0.0020data64m32.txt 6 4 11 5 0.0022data64m33.txt 6 4 11 4 0.0020data64m34.txt 6 4 11 3 0.0020data64m35.txt 6 4 11 3 0.0020data64m36.txt 6 4 11 3 0.0020data64m37.txt 6 4 11 4 0.0021data64m38.txt 6 4 11 1 0.0020data64m39.txt 6 4 11 3 0.0020data64m40.txt 6 4 11 5 0.0020data64m41.txt 6 4 11 2 0.0020data64m42.txt 6 4 11 3 0.0020data64m43.txt 6 4 11 5 0.0021data64m44.txt 6 4 11 3 0.0021data64m45.txt 6 4 11 3 0.0021data64m46.txt 6 4 11 5 0.0020data64m47.txt 6 4 11 3 0.0021data64m48.txt 6 4 11 3 0.0020data64m49.txt 6 4 11 5 0.0020data64m50.txt 6 4 11 2 0.0020

Table 5: Computational results on the set group 1

Page 10: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata65m1.txt 6 5 13 5 0.0022data65m2.txt 6 5 13 4 0.0022data65m3.txt 6 5 13 5 0.0022data65m4.txt 6 5 13 5 0.0022data65m5.txt 6 5 13 6 0.0023data65m6.txt 6 5 13 5 0.0022data65m7.txt 6 5 13 6 0.0024data65m8.txt 6 5 13 8 0.0024data65m9.txt 6 5 13 6 0.0024data65m10.txt 6 5 13 6 0.0022data65m11.txt 6 5 13 5 0.0022data65m12.txt 6 5 13 4 0.0023data65m13.txt 6 5 13 3 0.0022data65m14.txt 6 5 13 3 0.0023data65m15.txt 6 5 13 2 0.0022data65m16.txt 6 5 13 6 0.0022data65m17.txt 6 5 13 6 0.0023data65m18.txt 6 5 13 6 0.0022data65m19.txt 6 5 13 6 0.0022data65m20.txt 6 5 13 3 0.0022data65m21.txt 6 5 13 4 0.0025data65m22.txt 6 5 13 3 0.0024data65m23.txt 6 5 13 5 0.0023data65m24.txt 6 5 13 5 0.0022data65m25.txt 6 5 13 3 0.0022data65m26.txt 6 5 13 2 0.0022data65m27.txt 6 5 13 8 0.0022data65m28.txt 6 5 13 7 0.0022data65m29.txt 6 5 13 5 0.0022data65m30.txt 6 5 13 4 0.0023data65m31.txt 6 5 13 5 0.0022data65m32.txt 6 5 13 5 0.0022data65m33.txt 6 5 13 6 0.0021data65m34.txt 6 5 13 8 0.0026data65m35.txt 6 5 13 2 0.0024data65m36.txt 6 5 13 5 0.0022data65m37.txt 6 5 13 9 0.0022data65m38.txt 6 5 13 5 0.0023data65m39.txt 6 5 13 2 0.0023data65m40.txt 6 5 13 5 0.0023data65m41.txt 6 5 13 3 0.0022data65m42.txt 6 5 13 3 0.0022data65m43.txt 6 5 13 4 0.0023data65m44.txt 6 5 13 4 0.0022data65m45.txt 6 5 13 5 0.0022data65m46.txt 6 5 13 3 0.0022data65m47.txt 6 5 13 2 0.0025data65m48.txt 6 5 13 5 0.0024data65m49.txt 6 5 13 6 0.0022data65m50.txt 6 5 13 3 0.0022data62h1.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0017data62h2.txt 6 2 9 1 0.0017data62h3.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0017data62h4.txt 6 2 9 3 0.0017data62h5.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0017data62h6.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0017data62h7.txt 6 2 9 1 0.0017data62h8.txt 6 2 9 1 0.0017data62h9.txt 6 2 9 1 0.0017data62h10.txt 6 2 9 4 0.0017data62h11.txt 6 2 9 1 0.0017data62h12.txt 6 2 9 3 0.0019data62h13.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0019data62h14.txt 6 2 9 0 0.0019data62h15.txt 6 2 9 1 0.0017data62h16.txt 6 2 9 1 0.0017data62h17.txt 6 2 9 1 0.0017data62h18.txt 6 2 9 0 0.0018data62h19.txt 6 2 9 3 0.0017data62h20.txt 6 2 9 1 0.0017

Table 6: Computational results on the set group 1

Page 11: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata62h21.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0017data62h22.txt 6 2 9 1 0.0017data62h23.txt 6 2 9 1 0.0017data62h24.txt 6 2 9 1 0.0018data62h25.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0017data62h26.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0018data62h27.txt 6 2 9 0 0.0017data62h28.txt 6 2 9 3 0.0017data62h29.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0019data62h30.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0019data62h31.txt 6 2 9 1 0.0018data62h32.txt 6 2 9 3 0.0018data62h33.txt 6 2 9 3 0.0018data62h34.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0017data62h35.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0017data62h36.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0017data62h37.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0018data62h38.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0017data62h39.txt 6 2 9 1 0.0017data62h40.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0017data62h41.txt 6 2 9 1 0.0017data62h42.txt 6 2 9 1 0.0017data62h43.txt 6 2 9 1 0.0018data62h44.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0017data62h45.txt 6 2 9 1 0.0017data62h46.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0018data62h47.txt 6 2 9 3 0.0017data62h48.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0017data62h49.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0017data62h50.txt 6 2 9 2 0.0017data63h1.txt 6 3 13 5 0.0022data63h2.txt 6 3 13 6 0.0021data63h3.txt 6 3 13 5 0.0022data63h4.txt 6 3 13 6 0.0022data63h5.txt 6 3 13 4 0.0021data63h6.txt 6 3 13 4 0.0022data63h7.txt 6 3 13 6 0.0022data63h8.txt 6 3 13 4 0.0021data63h9.txt 6 3 13 3 0.0022data63h10.txt 6 3 13 5 0.0025data63h11.txt 6 3 13 5 0.0024data63h12.txt 6 3 13 2 0.0022data63h13.txt 6 3 13 7 0.0022data63h14.txt 6 3 13 4 0.0021data63h15.txt 6 3 13 7 0.0021data63h16.txt 6 3 13 7 0.0022data63h17.txt 6 3 13 5 0.0021data63h18.txt 6 3 13 6 0.0022data63h19.txt 6 3 13 6 0.0022data63h20.txt 6 3 13 1 0.0021data63h21.txt 6 3 13 6 0.0021data63h22.txt 6 3 13 5 0.0022data63h23.txt 6 3 13 4 0.0023data63h24.txt 6 3 13 3 0.0022data63h25.txt 6 3 13 3 0.0021data63h26.txt 6 3 13 3 0.0022data63h27.txt 6 3 13 2 0.0022data63h28.txt 6 3 13 6 0.0022data63h29.txt 6 3 13 5 0.0021data63h30.txt 6 3 13 5 0.0021data63h31.txt 6 3 13 7 0.0022data63h32.txt 6 3 13 3 0.0021data63h33.txt 6 3 13 4 0.0021data63h34.txt 6 3 13 5 0.0022data63h35.txt 6 3 13 7 0.0021data63h36.txt 6 3 13 5 0.0024data63h37.txt 6 3 13 6 0.0024data63h38.txt 6 3 13 5 0.0023data63h39.txt 6 3 13 3 0.0022data63h40.txt 6 3 13 5 0.0021

Table 7: Computational results on the set group 1

Page 12: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata63h41.txt 6 3 13 2 0.0022data63h42.txt 6 3 13 7 0.0022data63h43.txt 6 3 13 6 0.0021data63h44.txt 6 3 13 3 0.0022data63h45.txt 6 3 13 3 0.0021data63h46.txt 6 3 13 3 0.0021data63h47.txt 6 3 13 5 0.0021data63h48.txt 6 3 13 6 0.0022data63h49.txt 6 3 13 2 0.0022data63h50.txt 6 3 13 2 0.0025data64h1.txt 6 4 17 5 0.0029data64h2.txt 6 4 17 8 0.0031data64h3.txt 6 4 17 11 0.0026data64h4.txt 6 4 17 7 0.0026data64h5.txt 6 4 17 4 0.0026data64h6.txt 6 4 17 9 0.0028data64h7.txt 6 4 17 9 0.0027data64h8.txt 6 4 17 9 0.0026data64h9.txt 6 4 17 10 0.0026data64h10.txt 6 4 17 6 0.0027data64h11.txt 6 4 17 4 0.0029data64h12.txt 6 4 17 9 0.0029data64h13.txt 6 4 17 9 0.0028data64h14.txt 6 4 17 7 0.0026data64h15.txt 6 4 17 13 0.0025data64h16.txt 6 4 17 8 0.0026data64h17.txt 6 4 17 10 0.0027data64h18.txt 6 4 17 5 0.0026data64h19.txt 6 4 17 3 0.0026data64h20.txt 6 4 17 3 0.0026data64h21.txt 6 4 17 7 0.0028data64h22.txt 6 4 17 8 0.0027data64h23.txt 6 4 17 6 0.0028data64h24.txt 6 4 17 3 0.0027data64h25.txt 6 4 17 5 0.0026data64h26.txt 6 4 17 8 0.0026data64h27.txt 6 4 17 5 0.0026data64h28.txt 6 4 17 5 0.0026data64h29.txt 6 4 17 9 0.0026data64h30.txt 6 4 17 8 0.0027data64h31.txt 6 4 17 7 0.0026data64h32.txt 6 4 17 9 0.0028data64h33.txt 6 4 17 11 0.0150data64h34.txt 6 4 17 9 0.0027data64h35.txt 6 4 17 6 0.0027data64h36.txt 6 4 17 9 0.0027data64h37.txt 6 4 17 5 0.0026data64h38.txt 6 4 17 5 0.0027data64h39.txt 6 4 17 8 0.0030data64h40.txt 6 4 17 9 0.0038data64h41.txt 6 4 17 7 0.0028data64h42.txt 6 4 17 8 0.0026data64h43.txt 6 4 17 10 0.0026data64h44.txt 6 4 17 5 0.0026data64h45.txt 6 4 17 9 0.0027data64h46.txt 6 4 17 12 0.0033data64h47.txt 6 4 17 8 0.0026data64h48.txt 6 4 17 9 0.0026data64h49.txt 6 4 17 7 0.0029data64h50.txt 6 4 17 12 0.0039data65h1.txt 6 5 21 12 0.0034data65h2.txt 6 5 21 14 0.0037data65h3.txt 6 5 21 13 0.0045data65h4.txt 6 5 21 14 0.0046data65h5.txt 6 5 21 11 0.0032data65h6.txt 6 5 21 8 0.0032data65h7.txt 6 5 21 16 0.0060data65h8.txt 6 5 21 14 0.0035data65h9.txt 6 5 21 9 0.0032data65h10.txt 6 5 21 12 0.0035

Table 8: Computational results on the set group 1

Page 13: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata65h11.txt 6 5 21 11 0.0031data65h12.txt 6 5 21 13 0.0031data65h13.txt 6 5 21 13 0.0032data65h14.txt 6 5 21 7 0.0033data65h15.txt 6 5 21 10 0.0036data65h16.txt 6 5 21 7 0.0033data65h17.txt 6 5 21 13 0.0050data65h18.txt 6 5 21 13 0.0064data65h19.txt 6 5 21 11 0.0032data65h20.txt 6 5 21 10 0.0033data65h21.txt 6 5 21 15 0.0044data65h22.txt 6 5 21 13 0.0036data65h23.txt 6 5 21 9 0.0035data65h24.txt 6 5 21 11 0.0044data65h25.txt 6 5 21 7 0.0032data65h26.txt 6 5 21 10 0.0032data65h27.txt 6 5 21 13 0.0032data65h28.txt 6 5 21 12 0.0032data65h29.txt 6 5 21 15 0.0033data65h30.txt 6 5 21 8 0.0037data65h31.txt 6 5 21 11 0.0037data65h32.txt 6 5 21 15 0.0132data65h33.txt 6 5 21 10 0.0032data65h34.txt 6 5 21 16 0.0169data65h35.txt 6 5 21 10 0.0033data65h36.txt 6 5 21 9 0.0033data65h37.txt 6 5 21 12 0.0032data65h38.txt 6 5 21 9 0.0032data65h39.txt 6 5 21 11 0.0033data65h40.txt 6 5 21 13 0.0169data65h41.txt 6 5 21 10 0.0032data65h42.txt 6 5 21 16 0.0039data65h43.txt 6 5 21 14 0.0036data65h44.txt 6 5 21 13 0.0032data65h45.txt 6 5 21 7 0.0032data65h46.txt 6 5 21 13 0.0049data65h47.txt 6 5 21 14 0.0033data65h48.txt 6 5 21 12 0.0034data65h49.txt 6 5 21 15 0.0039data65h50.txt 6 5 21 10 0.0032

Table 9: Computational results on the set group 1

Page 14: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

3 group 2

Page 15: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-3-1 3 3 7 1 0.0026data3-3-2 3 3 7 5 0.0021data3-3-3 3 3 7 6 0.0024data3-3-4 3 3 7 3 0.0023data3-3-5 3 3 7 4 0.0023data3-3-6 3 3 7 3 0.0023data3-3-7 3 3 7 2 0.0023data3-3-8 3 3 7 1 0.0021data3-3-9 3 3 7 5 0.0022data3-3-10 3 3 7 5 0.0021data3-3-11 3 3 7 2 0.0021data3-3-12 3 3 7 2 0.0023data3-3-13 3 3 7 6 0.0021data3-3-14 3 3 7 3 0.0021data3-3-15 3 3 7 1 0.0021data3-3-16 3 3 7 4 0.0020data3-3-17 3 3 7 3 0.0020data3-3-18 3 3 7 1 0.0019data3-3-19 3 3 7 2 0.0019data3-3-20 3 3 7 4 0.0019data3-3-21 3 3 7 3 0.0019data3-3-22 3 3 7 4 0.0019data3-3-23 3 3 7 4 0.0018data3-3-24 3 3 7 5 0.0018data3-3-25 3 3 7 3 0.0019data3-3-26 3 3 7 4 0.0019data3-3-27 3 3 7 4 0.0018data3-3-28 3 3 7 5 0.0018data3-3-29 3 3 7 2 0.0017data3-3-30 3 3 7 3 0.0018data3-3-31 3 3 7 2 0.0018data3-3-32 3 3 7 6 0.0018data3-3-33 3 3 7 4 0.0018data3-3-34 3 3 7 3 0.0017data3-3-35 3 3 7 1 0.0017data3-3-36 3 3 7 3 0.0017data3-3-37 3 3 7 1 0.0017data3-3-38 3 3 7 5 0.0017data3-3-39 3 3 7 4 0.0017data3-3-40 3 3 7 3 0.0017data4-3-1 3 4 9 4 0.0017data4-3-2 3 4 9 6 0.0020data4-3-3 3 4 9 5 0.0019data4-3-4 3 4 9 7 0.0020data4-3-5 3 4 9 4 0.0020data4-3-6 3 4 9 5 0.0018data4-3-7 3 4 9 7 0.0020data4-3-8 3 4 9 3 0.0019data4-3-9 3 4 9 5 0.0019data4-3-10 3 4 9 7 0.0018data4-3-11 3 4 9 5 0.0019data4-3-12 3 4 9 6 0.0018data4-3-13 3 4 9 3 0.0019data4-3-14 3 4 9 6 0.0020data4-3-15 3 4 9 8 0.0019data4-3-16 3 4 9 9 0.0020data4-3-17 3 4 9 5 0.0020data4-3-18 3 4 9 3 0.0020data4-3-19 3 4 9 3 0.0019data4-3-20 3 4 9 5 0.0020data4-3-21 3 4 9 3 0.0019data4-3-22 3 4 9 11 0.0020data4-3-23 3 4 9 4 0.0019data4-3-24 3 4 9 8 0.0019data4-3-25 3 4 9 5 0.0019data4-3-26 3 4 9 7 0.0018data4-3-27 3 4 9 5 0.0019data4-3-28 3 4 9 6 0.0018data4-3-29 3 4 9 1 0.0018data4-3-30 3 4 9 6 0.0017

Table 1: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 16: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-3-31 3 4 9 8 0.0017data4-3-32 3 4 9 7 0.0018data4-3-33 3 4 9 7 0.0018data4-3-34 3 4 9 4 0.0018data4-3-35 3 4 9 7 0.0018data4-3-36 3 4 9 6 0.0018data4-3-37 3 4 9 8 0.0018data4-3-38 3 4 9 5 0.0017data4-3-39 3 4 9 7 0.0018data4-3-40 3 4 9 6 0.0017data5-3-1 3 5 11 8 0.0019data5-3-2 3 5 11 12 0.0019data5-3-3 3 5 11 13 0.0020data5-3-4 3 5 11 7 0.0019data5-3-5 3 5 11 6 0.0019data5-3-6 3 5 11 9 0.0019data5-3-7 3 5 11 5 0.0020data5-3-8 3 5 11 11 0.0020data5-3-9 3 5 11 10 0.0020data5-3-10 3 5 11 16 0.0020data5-3-11 3 5 11 9 0.0019data5-3-12 3 5 11 1 0.0018data5-3-13 3 5 11 6 0.0018data5-3-14 3 5 11 6 0.0019data5-3-15 3 5 11 6 0.0019data5-3-16 3 5 11 6 0.0019data5-3-17 3 5 11 9 0.0018data5-3-18 3 5 11 9 0.0018data5-3-19 3 5 11 9 0.0018data5-3-20 3 5 11 9 0.0018data5-3-21 3 5 11 9 0.0018data5-3-22 3 5 11 10 0.0018data5-3-23 3 5 11 9 0.0018data5-3-24 3 5 11 9 0.0018data5-3-25 3 5 11 9 0.0018data5-3-26 3 5 11 13 0.0018data5-3-27 3 5 11 8 0.0018data5-3-28 3 5 11 9 0.0018data5-3-29 3 5 11 7 0.0018data5-3-30 3 5 11 9 0.0018data5-3-31 3 5 11 8 0.0017data5-3-32 3 5 11 6 0.0018data5-3-33 3 5 11 9 0.0018data5-3-34 3 5 11 9 0.0018data5-3-35 3 5 11 7 0.0017data5-3-36 3 5 11 6 0.0018data5-3-37 3 5 11 7 0.0019data5-3-38 3 5 11 7 0.0019data5-3-39 3 5 11 9 0.0018data5-3-40 3 5 11 9 0.0018data6-3-1 3 6 13 14 0.0022data6-3-2 3 6 13 11 0.0021data6-3-3 3 6 13 8 0.0020data6-3-4 3 6 13 9 0.0020data6-3-5 3 6 13 15 0.0021data6-3-6 3 6 13 14 0.0019data6-3-7 3 6 13 13 0.0019data6-3-8 3 6 13 8 0.0020data6-3-9 3 6 13 18 0.0029data6-3-10 3 6 13 12 0.0020data6-3-11 3 6 13 7 0.0019data6-3-12 3 6 13 16 0.0025data6-3-13 3 6 13 10 0.0021data6-3-14 3 6 13 19 0.0020data6-3-15 3 6 13 11 0.0021data6-3-16 3 6 13 10 0.0020data6-3-17 3 6 13 12 0.0019data6-3-18 3 6 13 14 0.0021data6-3-19 3 6 13 11 0.0019data6-3-20 3 6 13 9 0.0018

Table 2: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 17: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-3-21 3 6 13 12 0.0019data6-3-22 3 6 13 12 0.0019data6-3-23 3 6 13 8 0.0018data6-3-24 3 6 13 10 0.0018data6-3-25 3 6 13 10 0.0020data6-3-26 3 6 13 16 0.0021data6-3-27 3 6 13 7 0.0019data6-3-28 3 6 13 10 0.0020data6-3-29 3 6 13 9 0.0018data6-3-30 3 6 13 16 0.0021data6-3-31 3 6 13 7 0.0019data6-3-32 3 6 13 11 0.0019data6-3-33 3 6 13 13 0.0019data6-3-34 3 6 13 10 0.0019data6-3-35 3 6 13 12 0.0019data6-3-36 3 6 13 13 0.0019data6-3-37 3 6 13 9 0.0019data6-3-38 3 6 13 11 0.0018data6-3-39 3 6 13 13 0.0020data6-3-40 3 6 13 10 0.0022data7-3-1 3 7 15 15 0.0025data7-3-2 3 7 15 17 0.0025data7-3-3 3 7 15 20 0.0023data7-3-4 3 7 15 6 0.0022data7-3-5 3 7 15 11 0.0022data7-3-6 3 7 15 14 0.0027data7-3-7 3 7 15 16 0.0022data7-3-8 3 7 15 12 0.0022data7-3-9 3 7 15 14 0.0022data7-3-10 3 7 15 17 0.0024data7-3-11 3 7 15 15 0.0023data7-3-12 3 7 15 11 0.0022data7-3-13 3 7 15 10 0.0025data7-3-14 3 7 15 15 0.0024data7-3-15 3 7 15 17 0.0023data7-3-16 3 7 15 11 0.0021data7-3-17 3 7 15 23 0.0024data7-3-18 3 7 15 19 0.0032data7-3-19 3 7 15 20 0.0059data7-3-20 3 7 15 19 0.0023data7-3-21 3 7 15 14 0.0021data7-3-22 3 7 15 20 0.0033data7-3-23 3 7 15 14 0.0027data7-3-24 3 7 15 14 0.0027data7-3-25 3 7 15 20 0.0023data7-3-26 3 7 15 19 0.0034data7-3-27 3 7 15 15 0.0031data7-3-28 3 7 15 13 0.0024data7-3-29 3 7 15 14 0.0030data7-3-30 3 7 15 13 0.0021data7-3-31 3 7 15 10 0.0023data7-3-32 3 7 15 14 0.0022data7-3-33 3 7 15 18 0.0028data7-3-34 3 7 15 16 0.0029data7-3-35 3 7 15 19 0.0032data7-3-36 3 7 15 11 0.0021data7-3-37 3 7 15 13 0.0022data7-3-38 3 7 15 13 0.0022data7-3-39 3 7 15 14 0.0023data7-3-40 3 7 15 15 0.0025data8-3-1 3 8 17 12 0.0024data8-3-2 3 8 17 23 0.0028data8-3-3 3 8 17 29 0.0267data8-3-4 3 8 17 22 0.0037data8-3-5 3 8 17 19 0.0030data8-3-6 3 8 17 15 0.0026data8-3-7 3 8 17 16 0.0029data8-3-8 3 8 17 25 0.0074data8-3-9 3 8 17 14 0.0030data8-3-10 3 8 17 23 0.0032

Table 3: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 18: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata8-3-11 3 8 17 18 0.0029data8-3-12 3 8 17 18 0.0031data8-3-13 3 8 17 14 0.0030data8-3-14 3 8 17 21 0.0047data8-3-15 3 8 17 26 0.0070data8-3-16 3 8 17 21 0.0034data8-3-17 3 8 17 11 0.0026data8-3-18 3 8 17 16 0.0027data8-3-19 3 8 17 26 0.0126data8-3-20 3 8 17 17 0.0029data8-3-21 3 8 17 20 0.0028data8-3-22 3 8 17 16 0.0028data8-3-23 3 8 17 21 0.0027data8-3-24 3 8 17 17 0.0025data8-3-25 3 8 17 15 0.0025data8-3-26 3 8 17 12 0.0024data8-3-27 3 8 17 14 0.0029data8-3-28 3 8 17 17 0.0031data8-3-29 3 8 17 15 0.0027data8-3-30 3 8 17 18 0.0032data8-3-31 3 8 17 24 0.0030data8-3-32 3 8 17 15 0.0027data8-3-33 3 8 17 15 0.0024data8-3-34 3 8 17 22 0.0057data8-3-35 3 8 17 16 0.0029data8-3-36 3 8 17 20 0.0024data8-3-37 3 8 17 21 0.0030data8-3-38 3 8 17 16 0.0025data8-3-39 3 8 17 25 0.0141data8-3-40 3 8 17 20 0.0099data9-3-1 3 9 19 20 0.0046data9-3-2 3 9 19 30 0.0139data9-3-3 3 9 19 25 0.0694data9-3-4 3 9 19 21 0.0041data9-3-5 3 9 19 24 0.0044data9-3-6 3 9 19 33 0.0233data9-3-7 3 9 19 29 0.0099data9-3-8 3 9 19 25 0.0060data9-3-9 3 9 19 28 0.0340data9-3-10 3 9 19 18 0.0037data9-3-11 3 9 19 18 0.0053data9-3-12 3 9 19 18 0.0053data9-3-13 3 9 19 23 0.0105data9-3-14 3 9 19 29 0.0064data9-3-15 3 9 19 31 0.0047data9-3-16 3 9 19 25 0.0091data9-3-17 3 9 19 20 0.0034data9-3-18 3 9 19 27 0.0038data9-3-19 3 9 19 27 0.0659data9-3-20 3 9 19 20 0.0035data9-3-21 3 9 19 20 0.0033data9-3-22 3 9 19 19 0.0062data9-3-23 3 9 19 24 0.0170data9-3-24 3 9 19 28 0.0186data9-3-25 3 9 19 31 0.0036data9-3-26 3 9 19 21 0.0033data9-3-27 3 9 19 28 0.0050data9-3-28 3 9 19 27 0.0149data9-3-29 3 9 19 27 0.0048data9-3-30 3 9 19 25 0.0036data9-3-31 3 9 19 18 0.0033data9-3-32 3 9 19 18 0.0041data9-3-33 3 9 19 20 0.0235data9-3-34 3 9 19 20 0.0051data9-3-35 3 9 19 24 0.0078data9-3-36 3 9 19 24 0.0560data9-3-37 3 9 19 25 0.0032data9-3-38 3 9 19 25 0.0319data9-3-39 3 9 19 21 0.0045data9-3-40 3 9 19 23 0.0103

Table 4: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 19: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-3-1 3 10 21 25 0.0045data10-3-2 3 10 21 27 0.0433data10-3-3 3 10 21 28 0.0116data10-3-4 3 10 21 22 0.0038data10-3-5 3 10 21 32 0.1087data10-3-6 3 10 21 27 0.0564data10-3-7 3 10 21 26 0.0518data10-3-8 3 10 21 26 0.0034data10-3-9 3 10 21 20 0.0053data10-3-10 3 10 21 35 0.0081data10-3-11 3 10 21 25 0.0090data10-3-12 3 10 21 28 0.0840data10-3-13 3 10 21 34 0.0392data10-3-14 3 10 21 26 0.0130data10-3-15 3 10 21 32 0.1043data10-3-16 3 10 21 22 0.0113data10-3-17 3 10 21 21 0.0053data10-3-18 3 10 21 27 0.0424data10-3-19 3 10 21 30 0.0440data10-3-20 3 10 21 27 0.0104data10-3-21 3 10 21 25 0.0064data10-3-22 3 10 21 29 0.0811data10-3-23 3 10 21 31 0.0131data10-3-24 3 10 21 38 0.0129data10-3-25 3 10 21 29 0.0392data10-3-26 3 10 21 32 0.1198data10-3-27 3 10 21 32 0.1847data10-3-28 3 10 21 32 0.0890data10-3-29 3 10 21 29 0.0515data10-3-30 3 10 21 29 0.0606data10-3-31 3 10 21 28 0.0194data10-3-32 3 10 21 23 0.0328data10-3-33 3 10 21 34 0.0076data10-3-34 3 10 21 25 0.0051data10-3-35 3 10 21 26 0.0398data10-3-36 3 10 21 35 0.0618data10-3-37 3 10 21 26 0.0596data10-3-38 3 10 21 29 0.0318data10-3-39 3 10 21 27 0.0847data10-3-40 3 10 21 29 0.0031data11-3-1 3 11 23 34 0.0070data11-3-2 3 11 23 42 0.1958data11-3-3 3 11 23 32 0.0885data11-3-4 3 11 23 39 0.1418data11-3-5 3 11 23 29 0.0037data11-3-6 3 11 23 31 0.0140data11-3-7 3 11 23 42 0.2284data11-3-8 3 11 23 35 0.0141data11-3-9 3 11 23 28 0.0859data11-3-10 3 11 23 35 0.0846data11-3-11 3 11 23 28 0.0317data11-3-12 3 11 23 31 0.0126data11-3-13 3 11 23 26 0.0074data11-3-14 3 11 23 33 0.0854data11-3-15 3 11 23 40 0.0117data11-3-16 3 11 23 28 0.0290data11-3-17 3 11 23 36 0.1454data11-3-18 3 11 23 30 0.0089data11-3-19 3 11 23 28 0.0376data11-3-20 3 11 23 29 0.0787data11-3-21 3 11 23 25 0.0802data11-3-22 3 11 23 39 0.2496data11-3-23 3 11 23 38 0.0193data11-3-24 3 11 23 35 0.0206data11-3-25 3 11 23 42 0.1663data11-3-26 3 11 23 39 0.0358data11-3-27 3 11 23 39 0.1027data11-3-28 3 11 23 34 0.0281data11-3-29 3 11 23 32 0.0140data11-3-30 3 11 23 31 0.0950

Table 5: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 20: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata11-3-31 3 11 23 34 0.1257data11-3-32 3 11 23 30 0.1084data11-3-33 3 11 23 29 0.0248data11-3-34 3 11 23 34 0.1542data11-3-35 3 11 23 25 0.0058data11-3-36 3 11 23 28 0.0107data11-3-37 3 11 23 28 0.0714data11-3-38 3 11 23 42 0.1340data11-3-39 3 11 23 28 0.0118data11-3-40 3 11 23 22 0.0307data12-3-1 3 12 25 36 0.1907data12-3-2 3 12 25 38 0.1018data12-3-3 3 12 25 41 0.2747data12-3-4 3 12 25 26 0.0072data12-3-5 3 12 25 57 0.2471data12-3-6 3 12 25 29 0.0512data12-3-7 3 12 25 39 0.0175data12-3-8 3 12 25 39 0.0890data12-3-9 3 12 25 34 0.0959data12-3-10 3 12 25 37 0.0404data12-3-11 3 12 25 42 0.0822data12-3-12 3 12 25 38 0.1306data12-3-13 3 12 25 26 0.0046data12-3-14 3 12 25 41 0.1604data12-3-15 3 12 25 38 0.0876data12-3-16 3 12 25 32 0.0876data12-3-17 3 12 25 33 0.1534data12-3-18 3 12 25 33 0.0528data12-3-19 3 12 25 30 0.0062data12-3-20 3 12 25 44 0.1303data12-3-21 3 12 25 35 0.0068data12-3-22 3 12 25 37 0.0945data12-3-23 3 12 25 44 0.1405data12-3-24 3 12 25 38 0.0421data12-3-25 3 12 25 31 0.1154data12-3-26 3 12 25 38 0.0191data12-3-27 3 12 25 31 0.1014data12-3-28 3 12 25 25 0.0058data12-3-29 3 12 25 35 0.0417data12-3-30 3 12 25 38 0.1236data12-3-31 3 12 25 34 0.1561data12-3-32 3 12 25 49 0.0341data12-3-33 3 12 25 39 0.1669data12-3-34 3 12 25 36 0.0900data12-3-35 3 12 25 29 0.0848data12-3-36 3 12 25 34 0.0385data12-3-37 3 12 25 43 0.0327data12-3-38 3 12 25 30 0.0799data12-3-39 3 12 25 42 0.0786data12-3-40 3 12 25 36 0.1467data3-4-1 4 3 10 5 0.0017data3-4-2 4 3 10 2 0.0016data3-4-3 4 3 10 4 0.0016data3-4-4 4 3 10 6 0.0017data3-4-5 4 3 10 3 0.0016data3-4-6 4 3 10 5 0.0017data3-4-7 4 3 10 6 0.0018data3-4-8 4 3 10 4 0.0017data3-4-9 4 3 10 4 0.0017data3-4-10 4 3 10 8 0.0016data3-4-11 4 3 10 4 0.0016data3-4-12 4 3 10 5 0.0017data3-4-13 4 3 10 5 0.0016data3-4-14 4 3 10 3 0.0017data3-4-15 4 3 10 4 0.0019data3-4-16 4 3 10 4 0.0018data3-4-17 4 3 10 5 0.0016data3-4-18 4 3 10 3 0.0017data3-4-19 4 3 10 5 0.0016data3-4-20 4 3 10 6 0.0017

Table 6: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 21: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-4-21 4 3 10 5 0.0016data3-4-22 4 3 10 8 0.0017data3-4-23 4 3 10 2 0.0017data3-4-24 4 3 10 6 0.0017data3-4-25 4 3 10 4 0.0016data3-4-26 4 3 10 3 0.0016data3-4-27 4 3 10 6 0.0017data3-4-28 4 3 10 6 0.0016data3-4-29 4 3 10 4 0.0017data3-4-30 4 3 10 6 0.0016data3-4-31 4 3 10 7 0.0016data3-4-32 4 3 10 6 0.0019data3-4-33 4 3 10 6 0.0018data3-4-34 4 3 10 2 0.0017data3-4-35 4 3 10 5 0.0017data3-4-36 4 3 10 5 0.0016data3-4-37 4 3 10 8 0.0017data3-4-38 4 3 10 4 0.0017data3-4-39 4 3 10 6 0.0016data3-4-40 4 3 10 4 0.0016data4-4-1 4 4 13 11 0.0020data4-4-2 4 4 13 10 0.0020data4-4-3 4 4 13 12 0.0021data4-4-4 4 4 13 8 0.0019data4-4-5 4 4 13 10 0.0020data4-4-6 4 4 13 10 0.0020data4-4-7 4 4 13 6 0.0022data4-4-8 4 4 13 5 0.0022data4-4-9 4 4 13 12 0.0021data4-4-10 4 4 13 10 0.0021data4-4-11 4 4 13 7 0.0019data4-4-12 4 4 13 8 0.0020data4-4-13 4 4 13 9 0.0019data4-4-14 4 4 13 12 0.0019data4-4-15 4 4 13 4 0.0020data4-4-16 4 4 13 4 0.0020data4-4-17 4 4 13 6 0.0020data4-4-18 4 4 13 9 0.0020data4-4-19 4 4 13 14 0.0020data4-4-20 4 4 13 12 0.0023data4-4-21 4 4 13 6 0.0022data4-4-22 4 4 13 8 0.0021data4-4-23 4 4 13 10 0.0021data4-4-24 4 4 13 10 0.0020data4-4-25 4 4 13 9 0.0019data4-4-26 4 4 13 9 0.0021data4-4-27 4 4 13 9 0.0020data4-4-28 4 4 13 10 0.0019data4-4-29 4 4 13 6 0.0019data4-4-30 4 4 13 8 0.0020data4-4-31 4 4 13 10 0.0019data4-4-32 4 4 13 5 0.0020data4-4-33 4 4 13 8 0.0020data4-4-34 4 4 13 6 0.0019data4-4-35 4 4 13 7 0.0020data4-4-36 4 4 13 8 0.0022data4-4-37 4 4 13 7 0.0020data4-4-38 4 4 13 6 0.0020data4-4-39 4 4 13 6 0.0020data4-4-40 4 4 13 10 0.0020data5-4-1 4 5 16 14 0.0024data5-4-2 4 5 16 9 0.0037data5-4-3 4 5 16 13 0.0024data5-4-4 4 5 16 13 0.0024data5-4-5 4 5 16 17 0.0023data5-4-6 4 5 16 12 0.0025data5-4-7 4 5 16 10 0.0027data5-4-8 4 5 16 17 0.0031data5-4-9 4 5 16 17 0.0026data5-4-10 4 5 16 13 0.0026

Table 7: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 22: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-4-11 4 5 16 17 0.0027data5-4-12 4 5 16 12 0.0024data5-4-13 4 5 16 11 0.0024data5-4-14 4 5 16 4 0.0023data5-4-15 4 5 16 8 0.0023data5-4-16 4 5 16 19 0.0025data5-4-17 4 5 16 17 0.0023data5-4-18 4 5 16 19 0.0030data5-4-19 4 5 16 11 0.0030data5-4-20 4 5 16 9 0.0026data5-4-21 4 5 16 7 0.0023data5-4-22 4 5 16 10 0.0024data5-4-23 4 5 16 14 0.0023data5-4-24 4 5 16 11 0.0024data5-4-25 4 5 16 11 0.0023data5-4-26 4 5 16 13 0.0024data5-4-27 4 5 16 19 0.0024data5-4-28 4 5 16 13 0.0025data5-4-29 4 5 16 14 0.0026data5-4-30 4 5 16 8 0.0024data5-4-31 4 5 16 7 0.0027data5-4-32 4 5 16 7 0.0025data5-4-33 4 5 16 15 0.0025data5-4-34 4 5 16 13 0.0024data5-4-35 4 5 16 13 0.0024data5-4-36 4 5 16 8 0.0023data5-4-37 4 5 16 7 0.0023data5-4-38 4 5 16 14 0.0056data5-4-39 4 5 16 9 0.0023data5-4-40 4 5 16 15 0.0025data6-4-1 4 6 19 12 0.0028data6-4-2 4 6 19 20 0.0033data6-4-3 4 6 19 17 0.0030data6-4-4 4 6 19 13 0.0027data6-4-5 4 6 19 17 0.0027data6-4-6 4 6 19 14 0.0034data6-4-7 4 6 19 15 0.0029data6-4-8 4 6 19 13 0.0028data6-4-9 4 6 19 10 0.0028data6-4-10 4 6 19 16 0.0028data6-4-11 4 6 19 14 0.0031data6-4-12 4 6 19 19 0.0050data6-4-13 4 6 19 17 0.0133data6-4-14 4 6 19 20 0.0044data6-4-15 4 6 19 23 0.0070data6-4-16 4 6 19 14 0.0033data6-4-17 4 6 19 11 0.0029data6-4-18 4 6 19 16 0.0040data6-4-19 4 6 19 15 0.0043data6-4-20 4 6 19 14 0.0028data6-4-21 4 6 19 24 0.0031data6-4-22 4 6 19 15 0.0030data6-4-23 4 6 19 13 0.0030data6-4-24 4 6 19 11 0.0033data6-4-25 4 6 19 17 0.0038data6-4-26 4 6 19 15 0.0031data6-4-27 4 6 19 12 0.0029data6-4-28 4 6 19 12 0.0027data6-4-29 4 6 19 12 0.0030data6-4-30 4 6 19 15 0.0028data6-4-31 4 6 19 17 0.0066data6-4-32 4 6 19 17 0.0052data6-4-33 4 6 19 15 0.0033data6-4-34 4 6 19 12 0.0035data6-4-35 4 6 19 17 0.0038data6-4-36 4 6 19 24 0.0043data6-4-37 4 6 19 12 0.0030data6-4-38 4 6 19 14 0.0038data6-4-39 4 6 19 22 0.0039data6-4-40 4 6 19 19 0.0038

Table 8: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 23: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-4-1 4 7 22 27 0.0050data7-4-2 4 7 22 25 0.0931data7-4-3 4 7 22 21 0.0039data7-4-4 4 7 22 20 0.0268data7-4-5 4 7 22 21 0.0489data7-4-6 4 7 22 26 0.0050data7-4-7 4 7 22 19 0.0415data7-4-8 4 7 22 30 0.0089data7-4-9 4 7 22 28 0.0060data7-4-10 4 7 22 15 0.0036data7-4-11 4 7 22 19 0.0101data7-4-12 4 7 22 29 0.0329data7-4-13 4 7 22 25 0.0920data7-4-14 4 7 22 22 0.0550data7-4-15 4 7 22 29 0.1660data7-4-16 4 7 22 15 0.0032data7-4-17 4 7 22 23 0.0054data7-4-18 4 7 22 24 0.0043data7-4-19 4 7 22 25 0.0107data7-4-20 4 7 22 27 0.0064data7-4-21 4 7 22 23 0.0085data7-4-22 4 7 22 20 0.0040data7-4-23 4 7 22 17 0.0037data7-4-24 4 7 22 17 0.0035data7-4-25 4 7 22 23 0.0177data7-4-26 4 7 22 18 0.0038data7-4-27 4 7 22 20 0.0070data7-4-28 4 7 22 19 0.0051data7-4-29 4 7 22 23 0.0245data7-4-30 4 7 22 22 0.0049data7-4-31 4 7 22 13 0.0034data7-4-32 4 7 22 24 0.0111data7-4-33 4 7 22 29 0.0064data7-4-34 4 7 22 31 0.1417data7-4-35 4 7 22 25 0.0061data7-4-36 4 7 22 24 0.0056data7-4-37 4 7 22 25 0.0048data7-4-38 4 7 22 21 0.0126data7-4-39 4 7 22 21 0.0042data7-4-40 4 7 22 19 0.0076data8-4-1 4 8 25 29 0.0254data8-4-2 4 8 25 24 0.0425data8-4-3 4 8 25 25 0.0046data8-4-4 4 8 25 29 0.0088data8-4-5 4 8 25 31 0.0725data8-4-6 4 8 25 29 0.0980data8-4-7 4 8 25 29 0.0205data8-4-8 4 8 25 23 0.0583data8-4-9 4 8 25 22 0.0063data8-4-10 4 8 25 25 0.0059data8-4-11 4 8 25 30 0.0206data8-4-12 4 8 25 34 0.1696data8-4-13 4 8 25 26 0.0082data8-4-14 4 8 25 25 0.0215data8-4-15 4 8 25 28 0.0286data8-4-16 4 8 25 33 0.0430data8-4-17 4 8 25 21 0.0081data8-4-18 4 8 25 25 0.0294data8-4-19 4 8 25 37 0.0838data8-4-20 4 8 25 24 0.0053data8-4-21 4 8 25 33 0.0902data8-4-22 4 8 25 31 0.0243data8-4-23 4 8 25 27 0.1996data8-4-24 4 8 25 32 0.0774data8-4-25 4 8 25 23 0.1052data8-4-26 4 8 25 32 0.1241data8-4-27 4 8 25 30 0.0587data8-4-28 4 8 25 25 0.0410data8-4-29 4 8 25 23 0.0450data8-4-30 4 8 25 27 0.0094

Table 9: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 24: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata8-4-31 4 8 25 35 0.0178data8-4-32 4 8 25 31 0.0417data8-4-33 4 8 25 24 0.0063data8-4-34 4 8 25 27 0.0470data8-4-35 4 8 25 22 0.0614data8-4-36 4 8 25 31 0.0130data8-4-37 4 8 25 29 0.1622data8-4-38 4 8 25 24 0.0408data8-4-39 4 8 25 26 0.0893data8-4-40 4 8 25 27 0.1227data9-4-1 4 9 28 27 0.1406data9-4-2 4 9 28 32 0.1530data9-4-3 4 9 28 33 0.3401data9-4-4 4 9 28 27 0.0541data9-4-5 4 9 28 35 0.0358data9-4-6 4 9 28 25 0.0764data9-4-7 4 9 28 34 0.2127data9-4-8 4 9 28 32 0.2128data9-4-9 4 9 28 33 0.1615data9-4-10 4 9 28 39 0.1106data9-4-11 4 9 28 35 0.2506data9-4-12 4 9 28 31 0.2730data9-4-13 4 9 28 29 0.0054data9-4-14 4 9 28 31 0.0590data9-4-15 4 9 28 43 0.4803data9-4-16 4 9 28 30 0.2271data9-4-17 4 9 28 31 0.2874data9-4-18 4 9 28 27 0.1578data9-4-19 4 9 28 34 0.1485data9-4-20 4 9 28 30 0.0393data9-4-21 4 9 28 37 0.1995data9-4-22 4 9 28 30 0.1043data9-4-23 4 9 28 39 0.1871data9-4-24 4 9 28 37 0.1315data9-4-25 4 9 28 28 0.1397data9-4-26 4 9 28 30 0.0425data9-4-27 4 9 28 33 0.2605data9-4-28 4 9 28 27 0.1529data9-4-29 4 9 28 33 0.1026data9-4-30 4 9 28 31 0.1435data9-4-31 4 9 28 34 0.3210data9-4-32 4 9 28 41 0.1269data9-4-33 4 9 28 32 0.1457data9-4-34 4 9 28 38 0.1390data9-4-35 4 9 28 32 0.2182data9-4-36 4 9 28 32 0.3138data9-4-37 4 9 28 30 0.0312data9-4-38 4 9 28 33 0.2854data9-4-39 4 9 28 34 0.0492data9-4-40 4 9 28 28 0.1911data10-4-1 4 10 31 44 0.4505data10-4-2 4 10 31 45 0.4429data10-4-3 4 10 31 34 0.0891data10-4-4 4 10 31 43 0.1937data10-4-5 4 10 31 46 0.5877data10-4-6 4 10 31 46 0.4014data10-4-7 4 10 31 52 0.3940data10-4-8 4 10 31 39 0.2636data10-4-9 4 10 31 36 0.2028data10-4-10 4 10 31 36 0.3144data10-4-11 4 10 31 41 0.3875data10-4-12 4 10 31 40 0.1344data10-4-13 4 10 31 38 0.2329data10-4-14 4 10 31 30 0.0817data10-4-15 4 10 31 38 0.4503data10-4-16 4 10 31 40 0.3079data10-4-17 4 10 31 41 0.1184data10-4-18 4 10 31 36 0.3508data10-4-19 4 10 31 35 0.1641data10-4-20 4 10 31 35 0.1494

Table 10: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 25: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-4-21 4 10 31 44 0.2414data10-4-22 4 10 31 36 0.2046data10-4-23 4 10 31 43 0.4201data10-4-24 4 10 31 45 0.1173data10-4-25 4 10 31 37 0.2878data10-4-26 4 10 31 44 0.1379data10-4-27 4 10 31 42 0.5095data10-4-28 4 10 31 44 0.5655data10-4-29 4 10 31 38 0.0960data10-4-30 4 10 31 48 0.0657data10-4-31 4 10 31 39 0.2832data10-4-32 4 10 31 38 0.2139data10-4-33 4 10 31 48 0.3568data10-4-34 4 10 31 44 0.4093data10-4-35 4 10 31 47 0.5188data10-4-36 4 10 31 33 0.2116data10-4-37 4 10 31 36 0.3079data10-4-38 4 10 31 38 0.2512data10-4-39 4 10 31 33 0.2756data10-4-40 4 10 31 34 0.2805data11-4-1 4 11 34 45 0.3992data11-4-2 4 11 34 49 0.4151data11-4-3 4 11 34 44 0.2510data11-4-4 4 11 34 40 0.1288data11-4-5 4 11 34 38 0.3381data11-4-6 4 11 34 59 0.7133data11-4-7 4 11 34 44 0.2880data11-4-8 4 11 34 41 0.2997data11-4-9 4 11 34 41 0.5747data11-4-10 4 11 34 46 0.3860data11-4-11 4 11 34 45 0.5489data11-4-12 4 11 34 46 0.1990data11-4-13 4 11 34 47 0.3121data11-4-14 4 11 34 44 0.2548data11-4-15 4 11 34 44 0.2773data11-4-16 4 11 34 50 0.2991data11-4-17 4 11 34 51 0.2690data11-4-18 4 11 34 38 0.1985data11-4-19 4 11 34 39 0.3210data11-4-20 4 11 34 49 0.3986data11-4-21 4 11 34 57 0.2417data11-4-22 4 11 34 42 0.3491data11-4-23 4 11 34 43 0.5248data11-4-24 4 11 34 37 0.3976data11-4-25 4 11 34 48 0.3686data11-4-26 4 11 34 49 0.6224data11-4-27 4 11 34 58 0.7722data11-4-28 4 11 34 45 0.6652data11-4-29 4 11 34 41 0.4274data11-4-30 4 11 34 50 0.4931data11-4-31 4 11 34 37 0.1802data11-4-32 4 11 34 47 0.4075data11-4-33 4 11 34 59 0.4486data11-4-34 4 11 34 43 0.4739data11-4-35 4 11 34 41 0.4260data11-4-36 4 11 34 49 0.3542data11-4-37 4 11 34 47 0.3399data11-4-38 4 11 34 52 0.3863data11-4-39 4 11 34 38 0.1601data11-4-40 4 11 34 46 0.4214data12-4-1 4 12 37 61 0.6904data12-4-2 4 12 37 64 0.4936data12-4-3 4 12 37 44 0.5274data12-4-4 4 12 37 57 0.9622data12-4-5 4 12 37 55 0.8251data12-4-6 4 12 37 43 0.4777data12-4-7 4 12 37 47 0.4064data12-4-8 4 12 37 55 0.4432data12-4-9 4 12 37 57 0.4026data12-4-10 4 12 37 52 0.4989

Table 11: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 26: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata12-4-11 4 12 37 59 0.4981data12-4-12 4 12 37 56 0.6203data12-4-13 4 12 37 55 0.4149data12-4-14 4 12 37 57 0.8108data12-4-15 4 12 37 47 0.4905data12-4-16 4 12 37 62 0.7954data12-4-17 4 12 37 55 0.9208data12-4-18 4 12 37 54 0.6282data12-4-19 4 12 37 51 0.4807data12-4-20 4 12 37 50 0.3863data12-4-21 4 12 37 57 0.4881data12-4-22 4 12 37 51 0.4466data12-4-23 4 12 37 68 0.7760data12-4-24 4 12 37 48 0.5719data12-4-25 4 12 37 53 0.7930data12-4-26 4 12 37 47 0.5662data12-4-27 4 12 37 48 0.3371data12-4-28 4 12 37 57 0.6677data12-4-29 4 12 37 62 0.7273data12-4-30 4 12 37 46 0.8451data12-4-31 4 12 37 60 0.4207data12-4-32 4 12 37 57 0.7796data12-4-33 4 12 37 62 0.5491data12-4-34 4 12 37 69 0.7592data12-4-35 4 12 37 50 0.4153data12-4-36 4 12 37 55 1.0032data12-4-37 4 12 37 54 0.6481data12-4-38 4 12 37 62 0.8776data12-4-39 4 12 37 38 0.5092data12-4-40 4 12 37 50 0.5130data3-5-1 5 3 13 5 0.0021data3-5-2 5 3 13 7 0.0021data3-5-3 5 3 13 8 0.0020data3-5-4 5 3 13 3 0.0020data3-5-5 5 3 13 2 0.0022data3-5-6 5 3 13 8 0.0023data3-5-7 5 3 13 3 0.0021data3-5-8 5 3 13 10 0.0020data3-5-9 5 3 13 2 0.0021data3-5-10 5 3 13 9 0.0021data3-5-11 5 3 13 7 0.0020data3-5-12 5 3 13 2 0.0022data3-5-13 5 3 13 3 0.0022data3-5-14 5 3 13 5 0.0021data3-5-15 5 3 13 3 0.0022data3-5-16 5 3 13 3 0.0020data3-5-17 5 3 13 7 0.0021data3-5-18 5 3 13 7 0.0021data3-5-19 5 3 13 7 0.0021data3-5-20 5 3 13 6 0.0021data3-5-21 5 3 13 5 0.0021data3-5-22 5 3 13 7 0.0021data3-5-23 5 3 13 6 0.0020data3-5-24 5 3 13 6 0.0021data3-5-25 5 3 13 6 0.0022data3-5-26 5 3 13 8 0.0022data3-5-27 5 3 13 6 0.0022data3-5-28 5 3 13 5 0.0022data3-5-29 5 3 13 6 0.0021data3-5-30 5 3 13 5 0.0021data3-5-31 5 3 13 4 0.0020data3-5-32 5 3 13 5 0.0020data3-5-33 5 3 13 11 0.0020data3-5-34 5 3 13 9 0.0020data3-5-35 5 3 13 8 0.0021data3-5-36 5 3 13 3 0.0020data3-5-37 5 3 13 6 0.0020data3-5-38 5 3 13 4 0.0020data3-5-39 5 3 13 7 0.0023data3-5-40 5 3 13 6 0.0023

Table 12: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 27: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-5-1 5 4 17 11 0.0027data4-5-2 5 4 17 6 0.0027data4-5-3 5 4 17 9 0.0027data4-5-4 5 4 17 13 0.0028data4-5-5 5 4 17 12 0.0025data4-5-6 5 4 17 10 0.0024data4-5-7 5 4 17 13 0.0026data4-5-8 5 4 17 12 0.0025data4-5-9 5 4 17 12 0.0027data4-5-10 5 4 17 10 0.0029data4-5-11 5 4 17 14 0.0028data4-5-12 5 4 17 11 0.0029data4-5-13 5 4 17 10 0.0029data4-5-14 5 4 17 6 0.0029data4-5-15 5 4 17 10 0.0027data4-5-16 5 4 17 16 0.0028data4-5-17 5 4 17 13 0.0027data4-5-18 5 4 17 13 0.0028data4-5-19 5 4 17 9 0.0025data4-5-20 5 4 17 7 0.0029data4-5-21 5 4 17 12 0.0029data4-5-22 5 4 17 12 0.0026data4-5-23 5 4 17 15 0.0025data4-5-24 5 4 17 12 0.0027data4-5-25 5 4 17 14 0.0026data4-5-26 5 4 17 12 0.0024data4-5-27 5 4 17 13 0.0026data4-5-28 5 4 17 11 0.0024data4-5-29 5 4 17 13 0.0025data4-5-30 5 4 17 9 0.0025data4-5-31 5 4 17 8 0.0029data4-5-32 5 4 17 8 0.0028data4-5-33 5 4 17 16 0.0028data4-5-34 5 4 17 11 0.0026data4-5-35 5 4 17 12 0.0026data4-5-36 5 4 17 7 0.0025data4-5-37 5 4 17 7 0.0026data4-5-38 5 4 17 9 0.0025data4-5-39 5 4 17 9 0.0025data4-5-40 5 4 17 12 0.0025data5-5-1 5 5 21 15 0.0034data5-5-2 5 5 21 15 0.0050data5-5-3 5 5 21 14 0.0038data5-5-4 5 5 21 15 0.0140data5-5-5 5 5 21 21 0.0033data5-5-6 5 5 21 15 0.0031data5-5-7 5 5 21 17 0.0037data5-5-8 5 5 21 7 0.0034data5-5-9 5 5 21 18 0.0127data5-5-10 5 5 21 15 0.0031data5-5-11 5 5 21 11 0.0032data5-5-12 5 5 21 14 0.0032data5-5-13 5 5 21 17 0.0037data5-5-14 5 5 21 12 0.0087data5-5-15 5 5 21 13 0.0031data5-5-16 5 5 21 16 0.0032data5-5-17 5 5 21 14 0.0031data5-5-18 5 5 21 16 0.0034data5-5-19 5 5 21 20 0.0035data5-5-20 5 5 21 16 0.0033data5-5-21 5 5 21 13 0.0036data5-5-22 5 5 21 20 0.0033data5-5-23 5 5 21 17 0.0051data5-5-24 5 5 21 15 0.0032data5-5-25 5 5 21 18 0.0056data5-5-26 5 5 21 17 0.0041data5-5-27 5 5 21 17 0.0038data5-5-28 5 5 21 15 0.0036data5-5-29 5 5 21 20 0.0166data5-5-30 5 5 21 17 0.0037

Table 13: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 28: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-5-31 5 5 21 18 0.0051data5-5-32 5 5 21 14 0.0045data5-5-33 5 5 21 14 0.0033data5-5-34 5 5 21 16 0.0047data5-5-35 5 5 21 17 0.0042data5-5-36 5 5 21 16 0.0035data5-5-37 5 5 21 13 0.0035data5-5-38 5 5 21 7 0.0030data5-5-39 5 5 21 18 0.0037data5-5-40 5 5 21 20 0.0034data6-5-1 5 6 25 22 0.0051data6-5-2 5 6 25 17 0.0037data6-5-3 5 6 25 17 0.0040data6-5-4 5 6 25 13 0.0039data6-5-5 5 6 25 25 0.1953data6-5-6 5 6 25 21 0.0476data6-5-7 5 6 25 13 0.0037data6-5-8 5 6 25 24 0.0122data6-5-9 5 6 25 19 0.0043data6-5-10 5 6 25 23 0.0856data6-5-11 5 6 25 24 0.0934data6-5-12 5 6 25 19 0.0047data6-5-13 5 6 25 28 0.0729data6-5-14 5 6 25 16 0.0040data6-5-15 5 6 25 19 0.0038data6-5-16 5 6 25 24 0.0542data6-5-17 5 6 25 19 0.0339data6-5-18 5 6 25 23 0.0728data6-5-19 5 6 25 15 0.0037data6-5-20 5 6 25 22 0.0535data6-5-21 5 6 25 19 0.0048data6-5-22 5 6 25 18 0.0045data6-5-23 5 6 25 24 0.0287data6-5-24 5 6 25 26 0.0083data6-5-25 5 6 25 22 0.0038data6-5-26 5 6 25 20 0.0047data6-5-27 5 6 25 18 0.0053data6-5-28 5 6 25 20 0.0057data6-5-29 5 6 25 27 0.0786data6-5-30 5 6 25 32 0.0901data6-5-31 5 6 25 28 0.0145data6-5-32 5 6 25 20 0.0045data6-5-33 5 6 25 23 0.0305data6-5-34 5 6 25 19 0.0037data6-5-35 5 6 25 18 0.0213data6-5-36 5 6 25 28 0.0072data6-5-37 5 6 25 16 0.0040data6-5-38 5 6 25 24 0.0255data6-5-39 5 6 25 16 0.0040data6-5-40 5 6 25 21 0.0070data7-5-1 5 7 29 24 0.1108data7-5-2 5 7 29 29 0.0083data7-5-3 5 7 29 25 0.0753data7-5-4 5 7 29 29 0.1354data7-5-5 5 7 29 27 0.1485data7-5-6 5 7 29 26 0.0060data7-5-7 5 7 29 28 0.0069data7-5-8 5 7 29 31 0.0294data7-5-9 5 7 29 25 0.0059data7-5-10 5 7 29 34 0.2508data7-5-11 5 7 29 29 0.1381data7-5-12 5 7 29 27 0.0295data7-5-13 5 7 29 32 0.2416data7-5-14 5 7 29 25 0.0054data7-5-15 5 7 29 23 0.0177data7-5-16 5 7 29 27 0.0474data7-5-17 5 7 29 34 0.1984data7-5-18 5 7 29 23 0.0098data7-5-19 5 7 29 25 0.2927data7-5-20 5 7 29 23 0.0070

Table 14: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 29: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-5-21 5 7 29 26 0.0157data7-5-22 5 7 29 33 0.0813data7-5-23 5 7 29 30 0.0581data7-5-24 5 7 29 20 0.0066data7-5-25 5 7 29 29 0.0940data7-5-26 5 7 29 30 0.1647data7-5-27 5 7 29 33 0.3684data7-5-28 5 7 29 32 0.2960data7-5-29 5 7 29 25 0.1836data7-5-30 5 7 29 28 0.0403data7-5-31 5 7 29 34 0.3136data7-5-32 5 7 29 22 0.0060data7-5-33 5 7 29 26 0.1967data7-5-34 5 7 29 27 0.0156data7-5-35 5 7 29 23 0.0561data7-5-36 5 7 29 28 0.1220data7-5-37 5 7 29 29 0.1019data7-5-38 5 7 29 31 0.1150data7-5-39 5 7 29 27 0.0496data7-5-40 5 7 29 23 0.0047data8-5-1 5 8 33 37 0.5416data8-5-2 5 8 33 45 0.5869data8-5-3 5 8 33 28 0.1026data8-5-4 5 8 33 39 0.3274data8-5-5 5 8 33 36 0.2867data8-5-6 5 8 33 38 0.4916data8-5-7 5 8 33 40 0.2789data8-5-8 5 8 33 38 0.1505data8-5-9 5 8 33 32 0.1748data8-5-10 5 8 33 32 0.4060data8-5-11 5 8 33 37 0.3636data8-5-12 5 8 33 36 0.2477data8-5-13 5 8 33 34 0.1010data8-5-14 5 8 33 28 0.0760data8-5-15 5 8 33 38 0.5941data8-5-16 5 8 33 39 0.3735data8-5-17 5 8 33 44 0.0135data8-5-18 5 8 33 36 0.2483data8-5-19 5 8 33 39 0.3233data8-5-20 5 8 33 38 0.2870data8-5-21 5 8 33 39 0.0956data8-5-22 5 8 33 30 0.1829data8-5-23 5 8 33 26 0.1319data8-5-24 5 8 33 44 0.2223data8-5-25 5 8 33 49 0.5598data8-5-26 5 8 33 38 0.5660data8-5-27 5 8 33 30 0.2926data8-5-28 5 8 33 31 0.0375data8-5-29 5 8 33 30 0.1698data8-5-30 5 8 33 40 0.1126data8-5-31 5 8 33 32 0.0301data8-5-32 5 8 33 40 0.7894data8-5-33 5 8 33 43 0.3181data8-5-34 5 8 33 28 0.1201data8-5-35 5 8 33 36 0.4474data8-5-36 5 8 33 34 0.2596data8-5-37 5 8 33 28 0.3696data8-5-38 5 8 33 34 0.2946data8-5-39 5 8 33 35 0.5828data8-5-40 5 8 33 32 0.5033data9-5-1 5 9 37 36 0.3034data9-5-2 5 9 37 41 0.4459data9-5-3 5 9 37 48 0.3164data9-5-4 5 9 37 40 0.3083data9-5-5 5 9 37 39 0.0068data9-5-6 5 9 37 42 0.5172data9-5-7 5 9 37 37 0.4328data9-5-8 5 9 37 52 0.4467data9-5-9 5 9 37 36 0.1875data9-5-10 5 9 37 41 0.5717

Table 15: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 30: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata9-5-11 5 9 37 45 0.2203data9-5-12 5 9 37 40 0.5504data9-5-13 5 9 37 34 0.4131data9-5-14 5 9 37 42 0.3739data9-5-15 5 9 37 38 0.2118data9-5-16 5 9 37 41 0.6978data9-5-17 5 9 37 44 0.3742data9-5-18 5 9 37 35 0.5516data9-5-19 5 9 37 41 0.2426data9-5-20 5 9 37 52 0.4972data9-5-21 5 9 37 53 0.5309data9-5-22 5 9 37 39 0.3125data9-5-23 5 9 37 46 0.6436data9-5-24 5 9 37 39 0.2533data9-5-25 5 9 37 43 0.6672data9-5-26 5 9 37 42 0.4289data9-5-27 5 9 37 36 0.2407data9-5-28 5 9 37 55 0.4769data9-5-29 5 9 37 42 0.1764data9-5-30 5 9 37 45 0.3667data9-5-31 5 9 37 39 0.7983data9-5-32 5 9 37 35 0.5955data9-5-33 5 9 37 40 0.4858data9-5-34 5 9 37 39 0.3206data9-5-35 5 9 37 43 0.2998data9-5-36 5 9 37 35 0.4604data9-5-37 5 9 37 35 0.5012data9-5-38 5 9 37 42 0.3296data9-5-39 5 9 37 35 0.0910data9-5-40 5 9 37 49 0.5092data10-5-1 5 10 41 46 0.2644data10-5-2 5 10 41 53 0.2786data10-5-3 5 10 41 49 0.5750data10-5-4 5 10 41 48 0.4705data10-5-5 5 10 41 53 0.5679data10-5-6 5 10 41 45 0.5844data10-5-7 5 10 41 53 0.3332data10-5-8 5 10 41 55 0.3307data10-5-9 5 10 41 46 0.5329data10-5-10 5 10 41 49 0.4154data10-5-11 5 10 41 59 0.4344data10-5-12 5 10 41 49 0.3767data10-5-13 5 10 41 60 0.7013data10-5-14 5 10 41 42 0.3262data10-5-15 5 10 41 56 0.5515data10-5-16 5 10 41 51 0.3431data10-5-17 5 10 41 48 0.4014data10-5-18 5 10 41 44 0.4321data10-5-19 5 10 41 51 0.4630data10-5-20 5 10 41 43 0.2760data10-5-21 5 10 41 55 0.3776data10-5-22 5 10 41 50 0.6084data10-5-23 5 10 41 47 0.4686data10-5-24 5 10 41 49 0.3983data10-5-25 5 10 41 51 0.2824data10-5-26 5 10 41 45 0.6026data10-5-27 5 10 41 51 0.1403data10-5-28 5 10 41 52 0.2909data10-5-29 5 10 41 49 0.4239data10-5-30 5 10 41 51 0.3800data10-5-31 5 10 41 42 0.3753data10-5-32 5 10 41 59 0.4271data10-5-33 5 10 41 59 0.5411data10-5-34 5 10 41 49 0.4782data10-5-35 5 10 41 39 0.3519data10-5-36 5 10 41 56 0.4852data10-5-37 5 10 41 47 0.4511data10-5-38 5 10 41 50 0.2612data10-5-39 5 10 41 49 0.3451data10-5-40 5 10 41 57 0.5161

Table 16: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 31: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata11-5-1 5 11 45 56 0.6954data11-5-2 5 11 45 51 0.5769data11-5-3 5 11 45 49 0.5226data11-5-4 5 11 45 63 0.4991data11-5-5 5 11 45 66 0.6780data11-5-6 5 11 45 49 0.6006data11-5-7 5 11 45 59 0.8563data11-5-8 5 11 45 75 0.8809data11-5-9 5 11 45 56 0.4958data11-5-10 5 11 45 55 0.5864data11-5-11 5 11 45 57 0.5180data11-5-12 5 11 45 56 0.6676data11-5-13 5 11 45 63 0.5343data11-5-14 5 11 45 49 0.9278data11-5-15 5 11 45 63 0.6893data11-5-16 5 11 45 61 0.6022data11-5-17 5 11 45 62 0.5594data11-5-18 5 11 45 54 0.4941data11-5-19 5 11 45 52 0.7092data11-5-20 5 11 45 50 0.5887data11-5-21 5 11 45 65 0.6439data11-5-22 5 11 45 58 0.5206data11-5-23 5 11 45 64 0.6183data11-5-24 5 11 45 47 0.3375data11-5-25 5 11 45 59 0.8534data11-5-26 5 11 45 58 0.4402data11-5-27 5 11 45 58 0.4849data11-5-28 5 11 45 62 0.6783data11-5-29 5 11 45 59 0.5889data11-5-30 5 11 45 53 0.6500data11-5-31 5 11 45 68 0.6669data11-5-32 5 11 45 62 0.7875data11-5-33 5 11 45 56 0.5219data11-5-34 5 11 45 53 0.7353data11-5-35 5 11 45 61 0.8609data11-5-36 5 11 45 63 0.4377data11-5-37 5 11 45 57 0.3307data11-5-38 5 11 45 49 0.4375data11-5-39 5 11 45 55 0.4691data11-5-40 5 11 45 58 0.5071data12-5-1 5 12 49 72 0.9952data12-5-2 5 12 49 72 0.6398data12-5-3 5 12 49 75 1.0137data12-5-4 5 12 49 70 0.9877data12-5-5 5 12 49 75 0.4992data12-5-6 5 12 49 75 0.8659data12-5-7 5 12 49 73 1.0183data12-5-8 5 12 49 66 0.9111data12-5-9 5 12 49 65 0.6161data12-5-10 5 12 49 59 0.4258data12-5-11 5 12 49 59 0.5872data12-5-12 5 12 49 70 0.9211data12-5-13 5 12 49 70 0.8636data12-5-14 5 12 49 72 0.7776data12-5-15 5 12 49 56 0.9075data12-5-16 5 12 49 69 0.9293data12-5-17 5 12 49 63 0.5378data12-5-18 5 12 49 88 1.0268data12-5-19 5 12 49 71 0.7959data12-5-20 5 12 49 48 0.5591data12-5-21 5 12 49 62 0.5750data12-5-22 5 12 49 65 1.0062data12-5-23 5 12 49 72 0.7919data12-5-24 5 12 49 76 1.0265data12-5-25 5 12 49 66 0.8627data12-5-26 5 12 49 59 0.7467data12-5-27 5 12 49 72 0.9095data12-5-28 5 12 49 70 0.7590data12-5-29 5 12 49 60 0.8329data12-5-30 5 12 49 71 1.0297

Table 17: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 32: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata12-5-31 5 12 49 54 0.5569data12-5-32 5 12 49 75 0.9290data12-5-33 5 12 49 65 0.9984data12-5-34 5 12 49 60 0.7720data12-5-35 5 12 49 81 1.0317data12-5-36 5 12 49 70 0.7757data12-5-37 5 12 49 69 0.5130data12-5-38 5 12 49 73 0.7385data12-5-39 5 12 49 60 0.7964data12-5-40 5 12 49 78 0.7318data3-6-1 6 3 16 10 0.0051data3-6-2 6 3 16 4 0.0048data3-6-3 6 3 16 4 0.0049data3-6-4 6 3 16 5 0.0049data3-6-5 6 3 16 7 0.0042data3-6-6 6 3 16 9 0.0048data3-6-7 6 3 16 7 0.0046data3-6-8 6 3 16 7 0.0043data3-6-9 6 3 16 11 0.0042data3-6-10 6 3 16 6 0.0039data3-6-11 6 3 16 5 0.0039data3-6-12 6 3 16 9 0.0037data3-6-13 6 3 16 10 0.0040data3-6-14 6 3 16 10 0.0040data3-6-15 6 3 16 6 0.0037data3-6-16 6 3 16 8 0.0035data3-6-17 6 3 16 13 0.0037data3-6-18 6 3 16 7 0.0035data3-6-19 6 3 16 9 0.0034data3-6-20 6 3 16 8 0.0034data3-6-21 6 3 16 12 0.0035data3-6-22 6 3 16 10 0.0034data3-6-23 6 3 16 7 0.0033data3-6-24 6 3 16 7 0.0033data3-6-25 6 3 16 9 0.0034data3-6-26 6 3 16 11 0.0032data3-6-27 6 3 16 6 0.0033data3-6-28 6 3 16 5 0.0032data3-6-29 6 3 16 5 0.0031data3-6-30 6 3 16 9 0.0033data3-6-31 6 3 16 6 0.0033data3-6-32 6 3 16 10 0.0030data3-6-33 6 3 16 6 0.0030data3-6-34 6 3 16 4 0.0030data3-6-35 6 3 16 4 0.0030data3-6-36 6 3 16 10 0.0028data3-6-37 6 3 16 6 0.0029data3-6-38 6 3 16 7 0.0029data3-6-39 6 3 16 11 0.0029data3-6-40 6 3 16 6 0.0029data4-6-1 6 4 21 13 0.0037data4-6-2 6 4 21 19 0.0036data4-6-3 6 4 21 16 0.0035data4-6-4 6 4 21 11 0.0035data4-6-5 6 4 21 16 0.0041data4-6-6 6 4 21 13 0.0040data4-6-7 6 4 21 16 0.0043data4-6-8 6 4 21 11 0.0041data4-6-9 6 4 21 13 0.0038data4-6-10 6 4 21 13 0.0036data4-6-11 6 4 21 8 0.0035data4-6-12 6 4 21 14 0.0036data4-6-13 6 4 21 11 0.0034data4-6-14 6 4 21 14 0.0036data4-6-15 6 4 21 16 0.0039data4-6-16 6 4 21 11 0.0035data4-6-17 6 4 21 9 0.0034data4-6-18 6 4 21 9 0.0033data4-6-19 6 4 21 11 0.0033data4-6-20 6 4 21 9 0.0033

Table 18: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 33: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-6-21 6 4 21 14 0.0032data4-6-22 6 4 21 12 0.0031data4-6-23 6 4 21 13 0.0040data4-6-24 6 4 21 9 0.0034data4-6-25 6 4 21 12 0.0034data4-6-26 6 4 21 10 0.0033data4-6-27 6 4 21 10 0.0032data4-6-28 6 4 21 11 0.0031data4-6-29 6 4 21 9 0.0031data4-6-30 6 4 21 9 0.0030data4-6-31 6 4 21 9 0.0030data4-6-32 6 4 21 11 0.0035data4-6-33 6 4 21 12 0.0035data4-6-34 6 4 21 9 0.0033data4-6-35 6 4 21 13 0.0032data4-6-36 6 4 21 15 0.0033data4-6-37 6 4 21 10 0.0031data4-6-38 6 4 21 9 0.0032data4-6-39 6 4 21 14 0.0031data4-6-40 6 4 21 17 0.0032data5-6-1 6 5 26 22 0.0073data5-6-2 6 5 26 14 0.0042data5-6-3 6 5 26 16 0.0043data5-6-4 6 5 26 14 0.0042data5-6-5 6 5 26 23 0.0384data5-6-6 6 5 26 22 0.1305data5-6-7 6 5 26 13 0.0042data5-6-8 6 5 26 22 0.0049data5-6-9 6 5 26 16 0.0042data5-6-10 6 5 26 31 0.0055data5-6-11 6 5 26 21 0.0050data5-6-12 6 5 26 16 0.0049data5-6-13 6 5 26 22 0.0043data5-6-14 6 5 26 19 0.0044data5-6-15 6 5 26 23 0.0634data5-6-16 6 5 26 18 0.0046data5-6-17 6 5 26 14 0.0040data5-6-18 6 5 26 20 0.0060data5-6-19 6 5 26 12 0.0041data5-6-20 6 5 26 17 0.0251data5-6-21 6 5 26 20 0.0103data5-6-22 6 5 26 19 0.0061data5-6-23 6 5 26 22 0.0052data5-6-24 6 5 26 25 0.0062data5-6-25 6 5 26 19 0.0085data5-6-26 6 5 26 21 0.0045data5-6-27 6 5 26 19 0.0095data5-6-28 6 5 26 24 0.0159data5-6-29 6 5 26 22 0.0064data5-6-30 6 5 26 21 0.0049data5-6-31 6 5 26 23 0.0082data5-6-32 6 5 26 14 0.0042data5-6-33 6 5 26 14 0.0043data5-6-34 6 5 26 18 0.0051data5-6-35 6 5 26 20 0.0088data5-6-36 6 5 26 25 0.0058data5-6-37 6 5 26 16 0.0041data5-6-38 6 5 26 21 0.0077data5-6-39 6 5 26 14 0.0043data5-6-40 6 5 26 21 0.0054data6-6-1 6 6 31 26 0.0681data6-6-2 6 6 31 26 0.0068data6-6-3 6 6 31 21 0.0075data6-6-4 6 6 31 18 0.0048data6-6-5 6 6 31 29 0.0106data6-6-6 6 6 31 22 0.0182data6-6-7 6 6 31 24 0.0081data6-6-8 6 6 31 31 0.1760data6-6-9 6 6 31 29 0.0138data6-6-10 6 6 31 28 0.1175

Table 19: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 34: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-6-11 6 6 31 28 0.0422data6-6-12 6 6 31 21 0.0251data6-6-13 6 6 31 26 0.0215data6-6-14 6 6 31 24 0.0773data6-6-15 6 6 31 33 0.2740data6-6-16 6 6 31 24 0.1107data6-6-17 6 6 31 25 0.0362data6-6-18 6 6 31 21 0.0058data6-6-19 6 6 31 20 0.0057data6-6-20 6 6 31 31 0.1254data6-6-21 6 6 31 26 0.0060data6-6-22 6 6 31 24 0.0124data6-6-23 6 6 31 30 0.0109data6-6-24 6 6 31 33 0.3439data6-6-25 6 6 31 19 0.0124data6-6-26 6 6 31 23 0.0204data6-6-27 6 6 31 26 0.0927data6-6-28 6 6 31 20 0.0058data6-6-29 6 6 31 27 0.0657data6-6-30 6 6 31 29 0.2315data6-6-31 6 6 31 28 0.1020data6-6-32 6 6 31 39 0.0262data6-6-33 6 6 31 26 0.0171data6-6-34 6 6 31 30 0.1142data6-6-35 6 6 31 23 0.0122data6-6-36 6 6 31 23 0.2195data6-6-37 6 6 31 26 0.0057data6-6-38 6 6 31 27 0.1689data6-6-39 6 6 31 33 0.2082data6-6-40 6 6 31 20 0.0262data7-6-1 6 7 36 35 0.2031data7-6-2 6 7 36 39 0.2650data7-6-3 6 7 36 30 0.1107data7-6-4 6 7 36 36 0.2679data7-6-5 6 7 36 32 0.1506data7-6-6 6 7 36 36 0.4689data7-6-7 6 7 36 38 0.3608data7-6-8 6 7 36 34 0.8454data7-6-9 6 7 36 35 0.1607data7-6-10 6 7 36 28 0.1119data7-6-11 6 7 36 40 0.4896data7-6-12 6 7 36 31 0.4782data7-6-13 6 7 36 35 0.1587data7-6-14 6 7 36 43 0.6023data7-6-15 6 7 36 38 0.4731data7-6-16 6 7 36 30 0.4851data7-6-17 6 7 36 38 0.3633data7-6-18 6 7 36 43 0.3745data7-6-19 6 7 36 37 0.3144data7-6-20 6 7 36 27 0.3384data7-6-21 6 7 36 39 0.5694data7-6-22 6 7 36 31 0.6065data7-6-23 6 7 36 35 0.2008data7-6-24 6 7 36 26 0.2867data7-6-25 6 7 36 33 0.2274data7-6-26 6 7 36 31 0.3042data7-6-27 6 7 36 27 0.0174data7-6-28 6 7 36 37 0.3478data7-6-29 6 7 36 40 0.0671data7-6-30 6 7 36 31 0.1809data7-6-31 6 7 36 28 0.0111data7-6-32 6 7 36 35 0.2188data7-6-33 6 7 36 32 0.1150data7-6-34 6 7 36 37 0.1728data7-6-35 6 7 36 29 0.2190data7-6-36 6 7 36 31 0.2390data7-6-37 6 7 36 40 0.3050data7-6-38 6 7 36 34 0.4803data7-6-39 6 7 36 37 0.3268data7-6-40 6 7 36 40 0.2811

Table 20: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 35: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata8-6-1 6 8 41 46 0.3684data8-6-2 6 8 41 44 0.1426data8-6-3 6 8 41 35 0.0716data8-6-4 6 8 41 42 0.1754data8-6-5 6 8 41 38 0.1958data8-6-6 6 8 41 47 0.3686data8-6-7 6 8 41 40 0.2446data8-6-8 6 8 41 43 0.3240data8-6-9 6 8 41 44 0.2520data8-6-10 6 8 41 45 0.5959data8-6-11 6 8 41 43 0.3642data8-6-12 6 8 41 43 0.2547data8-6-13 6 8 41 45 0.3211data8-6-14 6 8 41 45 0.4964data8-6-15 6 8 41 38 0.1466data8-6-16 6 8 41 54 0.3741data8-6-17 6 8 41 40 0.3513data8-6-18 6 8 41 38 0.3574data8-6-19 6 8 41 39 0.1830data8-6-20 6 8 41 48 0.1960data8-6-21 6 8 41 38 0.2507data8-6-22 6 8 41 38 0.3035data8-6-23 6 8 41 50 0.3120data8-6-24 6 8 41 46 0.3918data8-6-25 6 8 41 38 0.0925data8-6-26 6 8 41 38 0.1719data8-6-27 6 8 41 36 0.3014data8-6-28 6 8 41 37 0.1634data8-6-29 6 8 41 47 0.2900data8-6-30 6 8 41 41 0.5081data8-6-31 6 8 41 48 0.3906data8-6-32 6 8 41 42 0.1298data8-6-33 6 8 41 47 0.3317data8-6-34 6 8 41 48 0.3468data8-6-35 6 8 41 36 0.1759data8-6-36 6 8 41 47 0.6077data8-6-37 6 8 41 41 0.3653data8-6-38 6 8 41 48 0.5001data8-6-39 6 8 41 27 0.1267data8-6-40 6 8 41 40 0.2584data9-6-1 6 9 46 51 0.4069data9-6-2 6 9 46 56 0.6389data9-6-3 6 9 46 50 0.7371data9-6-4 6 9 46 52 0.6026data9-6-5 6 9 46 58 0.7166data9-6-6 6 9 46 48 0.3825data9-6-7 6 9 46 53 0.4299data9-6-8 6 9 46 51 0.3431data9-6-9 6 9 46 56 0.5295data9-6-10 6 9 46 49 0.3107data9-6-11 6 9 46 37 0.1864data9-6-12 6 9 46 49 0.5458data9-6-13 6 9 46 54 0.6104data9-6-14 6 9 46 49 0.6072data9-6-15 6 9 46 54 0.3069data9-6-16 6 9 46 47 0.7187data9-6-17 6 9 46 53 1.0152data9-6-18 6 9 46 53 0.5832data9-6-19 6 9 46 43 0.2987data9-6-20 6 9 46 41 0.3328data9-6-21 6 9 46 53 0.5769data9-6-22 6 9 46 61 0.6249data9-6-23 6 9 46 55 0.3032data9-6-24 6 9 46 53 0.5780data9-6-25 6 9 46 57 0.5671data9-6-26 6 9 46 59 0.5542data9-6-27 6 9 46 53 0.7786data9-6-28 6 9 46 45 0.5132data9-6-29 6 9 46 52 0.5166data9-6-30 6 9 46 56 0.6332

Table 21: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 36: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata9-6-31 6 9 46 58 0.4924data9-6-32 6 9 46 55 0.6807data9-6-33 6 9 46 55 0.3821data9-6-34 6 9 46 41 0.5988data9-6-35 6 9 46 48 0.3573data9-6-36 6 9 46 41 0.3689data9-6-37 6 9 46 50 0.3692data9-6-38 6 9 46 48 0.5327data9-6-39 6 9 46 55 0.4847data9-6-40 6 9 46 47 0.4188data10-6-1 6 10 51 57 0.5406data10-6-2 6 10 51 55 0.7716data10-6-3 6 10 51 65 1.0236data10-6-4 6 10 51 69 1.0223data10-6-5 6 10 51 70 0.7205data10-6-6 6 10 51 63 0.7536data10-6-7 6 10 51 61 1.0146data10-6-8 6 10 51 55 0.6892data10-6-9 6 10 51 55 0.6099data10-6-10 6 10 51 66 0.6994data10-6-11 6 10 51 58 0.7593data10-6-12 6 10 51 65 0.7676data10-6-13 6 10 51 66 0.3833data10-6-14 6 10 51 63 0.9454data10-6-15 6 10 51 54 0.7211data10-6-16 6 10 51 54 0.7756data10-6-17 6 10 51 66 1.0128data10-6-18 6 10 51 73 1.0176data10-6-19 6 10 51 68 1.0156data10-6-20 6 10 51 56 1.0324data10-6-21 6 10 51 59 1.0285data10-6-22 6 10 51 56 0.6084data10-6-23 6 10 51 55 0.4852data10-6-24 6 10 51 64 0.6948data10-6-25 6 10 51 56 0.9214data10-6-26 6 10 51 55 0.5662data10-6-27 6 10 51 60 0.8293data10-6-28 6 10 51 57 0.6713data10-6-29 6 10 51 63 0.6742data10-6-30 6 10 51 71 1.0151data10-6-31 6 10 51 55 0.6924data10-6-32 6 10 51 69 0.7442data10-6-33 6 10 51 68 0.9591data10-6-34 6 10 51 59 0.8366data10-6-35 6 10 51 68 0.6088data10-6-36 6 10 51 64 1.0185data10-6-37 6 10 51 53 0.5420data10-6-38 6 10 51 70 1.0105data10-6-39 6 10 51 58 0.9142data10-6-40 6 10 51 61 0.6408data11-6-1 6 11 56 51 0.9685data11-6-2 6 11 56 79 1.0373data11-6-3 6 11 56 66 0.8442data11-6-4 6 11 56 73 1.0188data11-6-5 6 11 56 63 1.0280data11-6-6 6 11 56 72 0.9666data11-6-7 6 11 56 77 1.0174data11-6-8 6 11 56 75 1.0387data11-6-9 6 11 56 56 0.8999data11-6-10 6 11 56 62 1.0295data11-6-11 6 11 56 65 1.0209data11-6-12 6 11 56 72 1.0110data11-6-13 6 11 56 80 0.8496data11-6-14 6 11 56 86 0.8288data11-6-15 6 11 56 77 1.0207data11-6-16 6 11 56 84 1.0214data11-6-17 6 11 56 66 1.0207data11-6-18 6 11 56 77 1.0173data11-6-19 6 11 56 77 1.0203data11-6-20 6 11 56 73 1.0189

Table 22: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 37: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata11-6-21 6 11 56 76 1.0303data11-6-22 6 11 56 85 1.0189data11-6-23 6 11 56 56 0.9206data11-6-24 6 11 56 74 0.9105data11-6-25 6 11 56 70 1.0280data11-6-26 6 11 56 71 1.0142data11-6-27 6 11 56 71 0.7760data11-6-28 6 11 56 69 0.9962data11-6-29 6 11 56 67 0.7501data11-6-30 6 11 56 71 1.0055data11-6-31 6 11 56 83 1.0305data11-6-32 6 11 56 65 0.9582data11-6-33 6 11 56 76 1.0180data11-6-34 6 11 56 70 0.9983data11-6-35 6 11 56 58 1.0197data11-6-36 6 11 56 70 0.9243data11-6-37 6 11 56 68 0.9424data11-6-38 6 11 56 71 0.7994data11-6-39 6 11 56 80 1.0230data11-6-40 6 11 56 72 1.0221data12-6-1 6 12 61 83 0.6464data12-6-2 6 12 61 71 0.6131data12-6-3 6 12 61 82 0.8216data12-6-4 6 12 61 83 0.7680data12-6-5 6 12 61 88 0.7869data12-6-6 6 12 61 93 1.0219data12-6-7 6 12 61 80 0.6832data12-6-8 6 12 61 74 0.7404data12-6-9 6 12 61 75 0.6372data12-6-10 6 12 61 75 0.5153data12-6-11 6 12 61 87 0.6956data12-6-12 6 12 61 89 0.6448data12-6-13 6 12 61 80 0.7733data12-6-14 6 12 61 98 0.6998data12-6-15 6 12 61 80 0.6567data12-6-16 6 12 61 74 0.5675data12-6-17 6 12 61 66 0.6845data12-6-18 6 12 61 95 0.9033data12-6-19 6 12 61 76 0.4494data12-6-20 6 12 61 80 0.8795data12-6-21 6 12 61 85 0.8682data12-6-22 6 12 61 80 1.0081data12-6-23 6 12 61 73 0.4429data12-6-24 6 12 61 81 0.7803data12-6-25 6 12 61 98 0.9560data12-6-26 6 12 61 96 1.0171data12-6-27 6 12 61 93 0.7077data12-6-28 6 12 61 79 0.4859data12-6-29 6 12 61 82 0.9199data12-6-30 6 12 61 76 0.6180data12-6-31 6 12 61 87 0.8985data12-6-32 6 12 61 82 0.7379data12-6-33 6 12 61 89 0.8587data12-6-34 6 12 61 78 0.6933data12-6-35 6 12 61 94 0.7719data12-6-36 6 12 61 78 0.7372data12-6-37 6 12 61 77 0.6064data12-6-38 6 12 61 80 0.7252data12-6-39 6 12 61 86 0.7499data12-6-40 6 12 61 86 0.7451data3-7-1 7 3 19 12 0.0024data3-7-2 7 3 19 12 0.0031data3-7-3 7 3 19 8 0.0029data3-7-4 7 3 19 7 0.0033data3-7-5 7 3 19 11 0.0029data3-7-6 7 3 19 9 0.0029data3-7-7 7 3 19 13 0.0031data3-7-8 7 3 19 7 0.0033data3-7-9 7 3 19 7 0.0037data3-7-10 7 3 19 8 0.0037

Table 23: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 38: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-7-11 7 3 19 12 0.0031data3-7-12 7 3 19 9 0.0032data3-7-13 7 3 19 6 0.0031data3-7-14 7 3 19 8 0.0028data3-7-15 7 3 19 7 0.0030data3-7-16 7 3 19 11 0.0029data3-7-17 7 3 19 11 0.0033data3-7-18 7 3 19 12 0.0040data3-7-19 7 3 19 8 0.0038data3-7-20 7 3 19 11 0.0031data3-7-21 7 3 19 12 0.0033data3-7-22 7 3 19 8 0.0031data3-7-23 7 3 19 7 0.0031data3-7-24 7 3 19 8 0.0030data3-7-25 7 3 19 10 0.0029data3-7-26 7 3 19 12 0.0036data3-7-27 7 3 19 8 0.0038data3-7-28 7 3 19 7 0.0034data3-7-29 7 3 19 8 0.0033data3-7-30 7 3 19 10 0.0031data3-7-31 7 3 19 8 0.0033data3-7-32 7 3 19 8 0.0031data3-7-33 7 3 19 8 0.0030data3-7-34 7 3 19 10 0.0030data3-7-35 7 3 19 6 0.0036data3-7-36 7 3 19 5 0.0036data3-7-37 7 3 19 9 0.0035data3-7-38 7 3 19 6 0.0033data3-7-39 7 3 19 11 0.0029data3-7-40 7 3 19 8 0.0030data4-7-1 7 4 25 19 0.0040data4-7-2 7 4 25 14 0.0040data4-7-3 7 4 25 13 0.0047data4-7-4 7 4 25 13 0.0045data4-7-5 7 4 25 15 0.0042data4-7-6 7 4 25 16 0.0041data4-7-7 7 4 25 10 0.0042data4-7-8 7 4 25 22 0.0043data4-7-9 7 4 25 19 0.0038data4-7-10 7 4 25 14 0.0047data4-7-11 7 4 25 11 0.0044data4-7-12 7 4 25 17 0.0041data4-7-13 7 4 25 15 0.0041data4-7-14 7 4 25 13 0.0039data4-7-15 7 4 25 16 0.0039data4-7-16 7 4 25 13 0.0041data4-7-17 7 4 25 16 0.0046data4-7-18 7 4 25 19 0.0056data4-7-19 7 4 25 19 0.0040data4-7-20 7 4 25 18 0.0041data4-7-21 7 4 25 13 0.0039data4-7-22 7 4 25 10 0.0039data4-7-23 7 4 25 16 0.0052data4-7-24 7 4 25 14 0.0048data4-7-25 7 4 25 14 0.0043data4-7-26 7 4 25 17 0.0074data4-7-27 7 4 25 11 0.0038data4-7-28 7 4 25 14 0.0042data4-7-29 7 4 25 17 0.0061data4-7-30 7 4 25 16 0.0047data4-7-31 7 4 25 11 0.0041data4-7-32 7 4 25 18 0.0041data4-7-33 7 4 25 19 0.0042data4-7-34 7 4 25 16 0.0042data4-7-35 7 4 25 20 0.0079data4-7-36 7 4 25 13 0.0047data4-7-37 7 4 25 19 0.0042data4-7-38 7 4 25 18 0.0045data4-7-39 7 4 25 18 0.0042data4-7-40 7 4 25 13 0.0041

Table 24: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 39: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-7-1 7 5 31 20 0.0154data5-7-2 7 5 31 24 0.0057data5-7-3 7 5 31 24 0.0050data5-7-4 7 5 31 22 0.0069data5-7-5 7 5 31 28 0.2871data5-7-6 7 5 31 23 0.0117data5-7-7 7 5 31 20 0.0063data5-7-8 7 5 31 18 0.0050data5-7-9 7 5 31 23 0.0176data5-7-10 7 5 31 28 0.0090data5-7-11 7 5 31 21 0.0052data5-7-12 7 5 31 22 0.0158data5-7-13 7 5 31 23 0.0067data5-7-14 7 5 31 25 0.0056data5-7-15 7 5 31 17 0.0059data5-7-16 7 5 31 22 0.0103data5-7-17 7 5 31 27 0.0061data5-7-18 7 5 31 20 0.0054data5-7-19 7 5 31 18 0.0068data5-7-20 7 5 31 16 0.0064data5-7-21 7 5 31 20 0.0050data5-7-22 7 5 31 24 0.0102data5-7-23 7 5 31 25 0.0060data5-7-24 7 5 31 21 0.0540data5-7-25 7 5 31 21 0.0051data5-7-26 7 5 31 18 0.0065data5-7-27 7 5 31 20 0.0098data5-7-28 7 5 31 16 0.0069data5-7-29 7 5 31 18 0.0066data5-7-30 7 5 31 23 0.0603data5-7-31 7 5 31 19 0.0061data5-7-32 7 5 31 16 0.0051data5-7-33 7 5 31 21 0.0081data5-7-34 7 5 31 20 0.1499data5-7-35 7 5 31 19 0.0113data5-7-36 7 5 31 21 0.0056data5-7-37 7 5 31 29 0.0066data5-7-38 7 5 31 21 0.0112data5-7-39 7 5 31 21 0.1073data5-7-40 7 5 31 20 0.0056data6-7-1 7 6 37 32 0.0322data6-7-2 7 6 37 25 0.0105data6-7-3 7 6 37 29 0.1115data6-7-4 7 6 37 35 0.0636data6-7-5 7 6 37 33 0.1017data6-7-6 7 6 37 29 0.1423data6-7-7 7 6 37 37 0.0777data6-7-8 7 6 37 34 0.8501data6-7-9 7 6 37 24 0.0059data6-7-10 7 6 37 26 0.1230data6-7-11 7 6 37 33 0.0391data6-7-12 7 6 37 30 0.4977data6-7-13 7 6 37 27 0.0178data6-7-14 7 6 37 28 0.7952data6-7-15 7 6 37 25 0.0086data6-7-16 7 6 37 29 0.0086data6-7-17 7 6 37 32 0.6705data6-7-18 7 6 37 36 0.1291data6-7-19 7 6 37 39 0.1722data6-7-20 7 6 37 28 0.2286data6-7-21 7 6 37 30 0.0138data6-7-22 7 6 37 29 0.0484data6-7-23 7 6 37 28 0.0890data6-7-24 7 6 37 25 0.1186data6-7-25 7 6 37 28 0.0866data6-7-26 7 6 37 32 0.0056data6-7-27 7 6 37 28 0.2244data6-7-28 7 6 37 37 0.0646data6-7-29 7 6 37 36 0.7043data6-7-30 7 6 37 31 0.2012

Table 25: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 40: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-7-31 7 6 37 25 0.0109data6-7-32 7 6 37 35 0.2153data6-7-33 7 6 37 28 0.2227data6-7-34 7 6 37 33 0.4446data6-7-35 7 6 37 25 0.0063data6-7-36 7 6 37 30 0.0075data6-7-37 7 6 37 39 0.1502data6-7-38 7 6 37 30 0.4470data6-7-39 7 6 37 38 0.1403data6-7-40 7 6 37 32 0.1222data7-7-1 7 7 43 46 0.3331data7-7-2 7 7 43 39 0.7194data7-7-3 7 7 43 38 0.0547data7-7-4 7 7 43 40 0.2572data7-7-5 7 7 43 36 0.0952data7-7-6 7 7 43 34 0.0578data7-7-7 7 7 43 44 0.1837data7-7-8 7 7 43 40 0.3673data7-7-9 7 7 43 40 0.3650data7-7-10 7 7 43 45 0.3785data7-7-11 7 7 43 49 0.5026data7-7-12 7 7 43 37 0.1420data7-7-13 7 7 43 34 0.3661data7-7-14 7 7 43 40 0.1515data7-7-15 7 7 43 38 0.2748data7-7-16 7 7 43 31 0.0196data7-7-17 7 7 43 35 0.4023data7-7-18 7 7 43 48 0.4075data7-7-19 7 7 43 37 0.1606data7-7-20 7 7 43 37 0.5727data7-7-21 7 7 43 39 0.2623data7-7-22 7 7 43 37 0.5082data7-7-23 7 7 43 31 0.3091data7-7-24 7 7 43 39 0.1974data7-7-25 7 7 43 36 0.1512data7-7-26 7 7 43 37 0.1381data7-7-27 7 7 43 41 0.7951data7-7-28 7 7 43 37 0.3509data7-7-29 7 7 43 42 0.1965data7-7-30 7 7 43 47 0.6625data7-7-31 7 7 43 42 0.4752data7-7-32 7 7 43 42 0.7932data7-7-33 7 7 43 41 0.1872data7-7-34 7 7 43 41 0.5527data7-7-35 7 7 43 32 0.5406data7-7-36 7 7 43 33 0.4629data7-7-37 7 7 43 38 0.1959data7-7-38 7 7 43 42 0.1652data7-7-39 7 7 43 40 0.1721data7-7-40 7 7 43 35 0.1405data8-7-1 7 8 49 45 0.7419data8-7-2 7 8 49 56 1.0159data8-7-3 7 8 49 54 0.3480data8-7-4 7 8 49 56 0.2757data8-7-5 7 8 49 49 0.7747data8-7-6 7 8 49 57 0.6028data8-7-7 7 8 49 42 0.7576data8-7-8 7 8 49 39 0.1870data8-7-9 7 8 49 47 0.4962data8-7-10 7 8 49 53 0.7186data8-7-11 7 8 49 48 0.2820data8-7-12 7 8 49 51 0.8275data8-7-13 7 8 49 47 0.7048data8-7-14 7 8 49 40 0.1329data8-7-15 7 8 49 57 0.6669data8-7-16 7 8 49 40 0.6972data8-7-17 7 8 49 45 0.5137data8-7-18 7 8 49 48 0.8074data8-7-19 7 8 49 52 0.7664data8-7-20 7 8 49 49 0.9285

Table 26: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 41: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata8-7-21 7 8 49 42 0.3080data8-7-22 7 8 49 41 0.1205data8-7-23 7 8 49 55 0.7981data8-7-24 7 8 49 56 0.7011data8-7-25 7 8 49 48 0.4799data8-7-26 7 8 49 51 0.9978data8-7-27 7 8 49 47 0.4530data8-7-28 7 8 49 44 0.5746data8-7-29 7 8 49 46 0.4509data8-7-30 7 8 49 49 0.5998data8-7-31 7 8 49 59 0.4886data8-7-32 7 8 49 47 0.1050data8-7-33 7 8 49 54 0.8477data8-7-34 7 8 49 47 0.1669data8-7-35 7 8 49 44 0.4894data8-7-36 7 8 49 50 0.6301data8-7-37 7 8 49 48 0.6118data8-7-38 7 8 49 34 0.4135data8-7-39 7 8 49 57 0.4332data8-7-40 7 8 49 60 0.4661data9-7-1 7 9 55 66 0.5772data9-7-2 7 9 55 58 1.0188data9-7-3 7 9 55 60 0.5366data9-7-4 7 9 55 61 0.4534data9-7-5 7 9 55 62 0.8598data9-7-6 7 9 55 58 0.7491data9-7-7 7 9 55 62 0.9072data9-7-8 7 9 55 63 1.0382data9-7-9 7 9 55 73 1.0190data9-7-10 7 9 55 57 0.8644data9-7-11 7 9 55 56 0.3923data9-7-12 7 9 55 58 0.7873data9-7-13 7 9 55 67 1.0179data9-7-14 7 9 55 62 0.8574data9-7-15 7 9 55 57 0.9922data9-7-16 7 9 55 55 1.0229data9-7-17 7 9 55 53 0.7546data9-7-18 7 9 55 59 0.8196data9-7-19 7 9 55 58 1.0322data9-7-20 7 9 55 61 0.6357data9-7-21 7 9 55 59 1.0381data9-7-22 7 9 55 59 0.8037data9-7-23 7 9 55 72 1.0303data9-7-24 7 9 55 53 0.4791data9-7-25 7 9 55 64 0.5307data9-7-26 7 9 55 64 0.7859data9-7-27 7 9 55 57 0.8243data9-7-28 7 9 55 65 0.7898data9-7-29 7 9 55 58 0.9956data9-7-30 7 9 55 62 1.0151data9-7-31 7 9 55 61 0.9595data9-7-32 7 9 55 69 0.7703data9-7-33 7 9 55 57 0.9798data9-7-34 7 9 55 51 1.0264data9-7-35 7 9 55 56 1.0137data9-7-36 7 9 55 79 1.0141data9-7-37 7 9 55 64 0.7802data9-7-38 7 9 55 55 0.9016data9-7-39 7 9 55 70 1.0061data9-7-40 7 9 55 60 1.0374data10-7-1 7 10 61 60 0.4628data10-7-2 7 10 61 72 0.4893data10-7-3 7 10 61 71 0.4428data10-7-4 7 10 61 75 0.8585data10-7-5 7 10 61 66 0.4677data10-7-6 7 10 61 75 0.6843data10-7-7 7 10 61 73 0.5942data10-7-8 7 10 61 67 0.6771data10-7-9 7 10 61 80 0.6057data10-7-10 7 10 61 71 0.4396

Table 27: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 42: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-7-11 7 10 61 65 0.7532data10-7-12 7 10 61 66 0.6509data10-7-13 7 10 61 70 0.6219data10-7-14 7 10 61 66 0.3514data10-7-15 7 10 61 63 0.5999data10-7-16 7 10 61 76 0.7163data10-7-17 7 10 61 73 0.7759data10-7-18 7 10 61 61 0.4447data10-7-19 7 10 61 82 0.5496data10-7-20 7 10 61 66 0.5934data10-7-21 7 10 61 66 0.7101data10-7-22 7 10 61 70 0.8198data10-7-23 7 10 61 60 0.5344data10-7-24 7 10 61 74 0.7310data10-7-25 7 10 61 59 0.4702data10-7-26 7 10 61 86 0.8008data10-7-27 7 10 61 71 0.5573data10-7-28 7 10 61 68 0.4389data10-7-29 7 10 61 74 0.4716data10-7-30 7 10 61 72 0.7639data10-7-31 7 10 61 57 0.3123data10-7-32 7 10 61 64 0.6017data10-7-33 7 10 61 74 0.7123data10-7-34 7 10 61 82 0.9382data10-7-35 7 10 61 76 0.7723data10-7-36 7 10 61 80 0.5125data10-7-37 7 10 61 76 0.5630data10-7-38 7 10 61 71 0.7174data10-7-39 7 10 61 68 0.5662data10-7-40 7 10 61 60 0.5048data11-7-1 7 11 67 72 0.8861data11-7-2 7 11 67 91 1.0224data11-7-3 7 11 67 86 1.0021data11-7-4 7 11 67 80 0.8141data11-7-5 7 11 67 93 0.9096data11-7-6 7 11 67 86 0.8682data11-7-7 7 11 67 88 0.7270data11-7-8 7 11 67 101 0.9974data11-7-9 7 11 67 85 0.8899data11-7-10 7 11 67 82 0.5702data11-7-11 7 11 67 86 1.0212data11-7-12 7 11 67 90 0.7962data11-7-13 7 11 67 75 0.9814data11-7-14 7 11 67 74 0.7822data11-7-15 7 11 67 79 0.7357data11-7-16 7 11 67 67 1.0101data11-7-17 7 11 67 90 0.8678data11-7-18 7 11 67 88 0.6568data11-7-19 7 11 67 74 0.7551data11-7-20 7 11 67 90 0.7938data11-7-21 7 11 67 99 1.0221data11-7-22 7 11 67 95 0.8098data11-7-23 7 11 67 75 0.9171data11-7-24 7 11 67 92 1.0231data11-7-25 7 11 67 73 0.6874data11-7-26 7 11 67 70 0.5291data11-7-27 7 11 67 79 0.8652data11-7-28 7 11 67 95 1.0211data11-7-29 7 11 67 71 0.7703data11-7-30 7 11 67 91 1.0075data11-7-31 7 11 67 77 0.8032data11-7-32 7 11 67 83 0.6896data11-7-33 7 11 67 79 0.9503data11-7-34 7 11 67 83 0.7932data11-7-35 7 11 67 78 0.6967data11-7-36 7 11 67 92 0.9500data11-7-37 7 11 67 85 0.8776data11-7-38 7 11 67 85 0.7487data11-7-39 7 11 67 76 0.6996data11-7-40 7 11 67 88 1.0245

Table 28: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 43: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata12-7-1 7 12 73 106 1.0301data12-7-2 7 12 73 85 1.0283data12-7-3 7 12 73 108 1.0109data12-7-4 7 12 73 86 1.0158data12-7-5 7 12 73 103 1.0201data12-7-6 7 12 73 115 1.0077data12-7-7 7 12 73 98 1.0242data12-7-8 7 12 73 97 1.0172data12-7-9 7 12 73 96 0.8514data12-7-10 7 12 73 86 0.8693data12-7-11 7 12 73 93 1.0163data12-7-12 7 12 73 98 0.7808data12-7-13 7 12 73 85 1.0169data12-7-14 7 12 73 98 1.0219data12-7-15 7 12 73 102 1.0136data12-7-16 7 12 73 91 0.8175data12-7-17 7 12 73 102 1.0213data12-7-18 7 12 73 89 0.9491data12-7-19 7 12 73 93 1.0178data12-7-20 7 12 73 94 0.9326data12-7-21 7 12 73 100 0.8935data12-7-22 7 12 73 94 1.0190data12-7-23 7 12 73 91 0.7988data12-7-24 7 12 73 95 1.0259data12-7-25 7 12 73 99 1.0032data12-7-26 7 12 73 118 1.0217data12-7-27 7 12 73 85 0.8540data12-7-28 7 12 73 115 1.0205data12-7-29 7 12 73 98 0.9453data12-7-30 7 12 73 99 1.0315data12-7-31 7 12 73 107 1.0258data12-7-32 7 12 73 110 1.0248data12-7-33 7 12 73 102 1.0237data12-7-34 7 12 73 83 0.8128data12-7-35 7 12 73 112 1.0126data12-7-36 7 12 73 93 1.0255data12-7-37 7 12 73 99 1.0119data12-7-38 7 12 73 95 1.0244data12-7-39 7 12 73 105 1.0229data12-7-40 7 12 73 97 1.0183data3-8-1 8 3 22 10 0.0036data3-8-2 8 3 22 16 0.0034data3-8-3 8 3 22 14 0.0039data3-8-4 8 3 22 11 0.0039data3-8-5 8 3 22 14 0.0035data3-8-6 8 3 22 9 0.0036data3-8-7 8 3 22 12 0.0041data3-8-8 8 3 22 11 0.0040data3-8-9 8 3 22 7 0.0038data3-8-10 8 3 22 11 0.0035data3-8-11 8 3 22 9 0.0036data3-8-12 8 3 22 12 0.0037data3-8-13 8 3 22 9 0.0037data3-8-14 8 3 22 13 0.0034data3-8-15 8 3 22 11 0.0041data3-8-16 8 3 22 10 0.0039data3-8-17 8 3 22 5 0.0038data3-8-18 8 3 22 8 0.0036data3-8-19 8 3 22 6 0.0038data3-8-20 8 3 22 10 0.0035data3-8-21 8 3 22 14 0.0034data3-8-22 8 3 22 8 0.0037data3-8-23 8 3 22 11 0.0042data3-8-24 8 3 22 8 0.0040data3-8-25 8 3 22 9 0.0037data3-8-26 8 3 22 10 0.0037data3-8-27 8 3 22 8 0.0039data3-8-28 8 3 22 6 0.0036data3-8-29 8 3 22 6 0.0035data3-8-30 8 3 22 10 0.0040

Table 29: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 44: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-8-31 8 3 22 11 0.0040data3-8-32 8 3 22 6 0.0039data3-8-33 8 3 22 9 0.0036data3-8-34 8 3 22 6 0.0038data3-8-35 8 3 22 11 0.0039data3-8-36 8 3 22 13 0.0036data3-8-37 8 3 22 5 0.0036data3-8-38 8 3 22 5 0.0042data3-8-39 8 3 22 13 0.0040data3-8-40 8 3 22 12 0.0036data4-8-1 8 4 29 22 0.1163data4-8-2 8 4 29 15 0.0048data4-8-3 8 4 29 19 0.0047data4-8-4 8 4 29 23 0.0065data4-8-5 8 4 29 19 0.0048data4-8-6 8 4 29 17 0.0055data4-8-7 8 4 29 21 0.0088data4-8-8 8 4 29 13 0.0049data4-8-9 8 4 29 15 0.0058data4-8-10 8 4 29 21 0.0057data4-8-11 8 4 29 26 0.0067data4-8-12 8 4 29 20 0.0050data4-8-13 8 4 29 15 0.0048data4-8-14 8 4 29 19 0.0049data4-8-15 8 4 29 21 0.0048data4-8-16 8 4 29 21 0.0049data4-8-17 8 4 29 14 0.0063data4-8-18 8 4 29 16 0.0051data4-8-19 8 4 29 19 0.0053data4-8-20 8 4 29 12 0.0047data4-8-21 8 4 29 23 0.0060data4-8-22 8 4 29 20 0.0053data4-8-23 8 4 29 15 0.0050data4-8-24 8 4 29 20 0.0049data4-8-25 8 4 29 13 0.0047data4-8-26 8 4 29 19 0.0053data4-8-27 8 4 29 19 0.0047data4-8-28 8 4 29 18 0.0051data4-8-29 8 4 29 16 0.0050data4-8-30 8 4 29 16 0.0047data4-8-31 8 4 29 22 0.0074data4-8-32 8 4 29 16 0.0047data4-8-33 8 4 29 14 0.0051data4-8-34 8 4 29 19 0.0052data4-8-35 8 4 29 13 0.0052data4-8-36 8 4 29 21 0.0049data4-8-37 8 4 29 17 0.0047data4-8-38 8 4 29 16 0.0051data4-8-39 8 4 29 17 0.0051data4-8-40 8 4 29 16 0.0052data5-8-1 8 5 36 28 0.0712data5-8-2 8 5 36 32 0.0064data5-8-3 8 5 36 20 0.0078data5-8-4 8 5 36 30 0.1567data5-8-5 8 5 36 27 0.0058data5-8-6 8 5 36 29 0.1108data5-8-7 8 5 36 32 0.0145data5-8-8 8 5 36 30 0.0161data5-8-9 8 5 36 23 0.0086data5-8-10 8 5 36 23 0.0078data5-8-11 8 5 36 28 0.2717data5-8-12 8 5 36 25 0.0174data5-8-13 8 5 36 24 0.0154data5-8-14 8 5 36 23 0.0141data5-8-15 8 5 36 29 0.8619data5-8-16 8 5 36 22 0.0077data5-8-17 8 5 36 33 0.0095data5-8-18 8 5 36 28 0.0377data5-8-19 8 5 36 23 0.0085data5-8-20 8 5 36 29 0.0396

Table 30: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 45: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-8-21 8 5 36 27 0.0061data5-8-22 8 5 36 23 0.0171data5-8-23 8 5 36 23 0.0060data5-8-24 8 5 36 29 0.0057data5-8-25 8 5 36 27 0.0127data5-8-26 8 5 36 28 0.0066data5-8-27 8 5 36 22 0.0086data5-8-28 8 5 36 22 0.0244data5-8-29 8 5 36 24 0.0085data5-8-30 8 5 36 24 0.0074data5-8-31 8 5 36 19 0.0067data5-8-32 8 5 36 26 0.0081data5-8-33 8 5 36 27 0.0089data5-8-34 8 5 36 20 0.0061data5-8-35 8 5 36 29 0.0074data5-8-36 8 5 36 21 0.0078data5-8-37 8 5 36 22 0.0160data5-8-38 8 5 36 24 0.0073data5-8-39 8 5 36 22 0.0087data5-8-40 8 5 36 19 0.0173data6-8-1 8 6 43 42 0.2905data6-8-2 8 6 43 41 0.0074data6-8-3 8 6 43 29 0.0716data6-8-4 8 6 43 38 0.3385data6-8-5 8 6 43 35 0.6511data6-8-6 8 6 43 34 0.0996data6-8-7 8 6 43 37 0.1724data6-8-8 8 6 43 38 0.1148data6-8-9 8 6 43 41 0.3086data6-8-10 8 6 43 38 0.1262data6-8-11 8 6 43 35 0.2039data6-8-12 8 6 43 39 0.1324data6-8-13 8 6 43 33 0.1430data6-8-14 8 6 43 39 0.0840data6-8-15 8 6 43 34 0.1194data6-8-16 8 6 43 38 0.1080data6-8-17 8 6 43 36 0.2361data6-8-18 8 6 43 30 0.1749data6-8-19 8 6 43 36 0.1895data6-8-20 8 6 43 33 0.0345data6-8-21 8 6 43 37 0.1355data6-8-22 8 6 43 33 0.2524data6-8-23 8 6 43 40 0.6022data6-8-24 8 6 43 32 0.0894data6-8-25 8 6 43 33 0.4701data6-8-26 8 6 43 36 0.1144data6-8-27 8 6 43 30 0.0111data6-8-28 8 6 43 35 0.2473data6-8-29 8 6 43 39 0.0945data6-8-30 8 6 43 32 0.3172data6-8-31 8 6 43 35 0.0291data6-8-32 8 6 43 36 0.1352data6-8-33 8 6 43 40 0.0952data6-8-34 8 6 43 45 0.1131data6-8-35 8 6 43 37 0.2886data6-8-36 8 6 43 30 0.0078data6-8-37 8 6 43 34 0.2371data6-8-38 8 6 43 36 0.0626data6-8-39 8 6 43 31 0.2388data6-8-40 8 6 43 31 0.1331data7-8-1 8 7 50 47 0.3788data7-8-2 8 7 50 50 0.1493data7-8-3 8 7 50 47 0.1255data7-8-4 8 7 50 50 0.6735data7-8-5 8 7 50 46 0.4590data7-8-6 8 7 50 58 0.5970data7-8-7 8 7 50 36 0.9376data7-8-8 8 7 50 48 0.8326data7-8-9 8 7 50 42 0.2439data7-8-10 8 7 50 48 0.4598

Table 31: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 46: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-8-11 8 7 50 52 0.7673data7-8-12 8 7 50 46 0.6975data7-8-13 8 7 50 41 0.2224data7-8-14 8 7 50 44 0.7506data7-8-15 8 7 50 47 0.5440data7-8-16 8 7 50 38 0.0536data7-8-17 8 7 50 34 0.0548data7-8-18 8 7 50 38 0.3980data7-8-19 8 7 50 47 0.5024data7-8-20 8 7 50 45 0.5853data7-8-21 8 7 50 38 0.5257data7-8-22 8 7 50 39 0.2704data7-8-23 8 7 50 53 0.7333data7-8-24 8 7 50 42 0.2933data7-8-25 8 7 50 35 0.2550data7-8-26 8 7 50 44 0.7761data7-8-27 8 7 50 28 0.0032data7-8-28 8 7 50 38 0.5609data7-8-29 8 7 50 37 0.3190data7-8-30 8 7 50 43 0.1900data7-8-31 8 7 50 47 0.4357data7-8-32 8 7 50 53 0.5547data7-8-33 8 7 50 50 0.9375data7-8-34 8 7 50 46 0.2354data7-8-35 8 7 50 44 1.0415data7-8-36 8 7 50 48 0.2754data7-8-37 8 7 50 48 0.6791data7-8-38 8 7 50 41 0.1522data7-8-39 8 7 50 51 0.2465data7-8-40 8 7 50 56 0.1234data8-8-1 8 8 57 41 0.1787data8-8-2 8 8 57 58 0.6728data8-8-3 8 8 57 64 1.0164data8-8-4 8 8 57 52 0.3889data8-8-5 8 8 57 51 0.8118data8-8-6 8 8 57 50 0.4931data8-8-7 8 8 57 52 1.0373data8-8-8 8 8 57 54 0.7769data8-8-9 8 8 57 58 0.4831data8-8-10 8 8 57 58 0.4735data8-8-11 8 8 57 53 0.5379data8-8-12 8 8 57 58 0.4067data8-8-13 8 8 57 58 0.6999data8-8-14 8 8 57 58 1.0075data8-8-15 8 8 57 53 0.6876data8-8-16 8 8 57 66 0.8150data8-8-17 8 8 57 59 1.0787data8-8-18 8 8 57 46 0.6363data8-8-19 8 8 57 45 0.1227data8-8-20 8 8 57 54 1.0177data8-8-21 8 8 57 56 0.9094data8-8-22 8 8 57 56 0.5552data8-8-23 8 8 57 51 0.4888data8-8-24 8 8 57 62 0.8267data8-8-25 8 8 57 59 1.0080data8-8-26 8 8 57 46 0.1905data8-8-27 8 8 57 59 0.5741data8-8-28 8 8 57 63 1.0347data8-8-29 8 8 57 58 1.0284data8-8-30 8 8 57 68 0.9944data8-8-31 8 8 57 52 0.8997data8-8-32 8 8 57 49 0.5777data8-8-33 8 8 57 57 1.0127data8-8-34 8 8 57 55 0.5864data8-8-35 8 8 57 57 1.0281data8-8-36 8 8 57 61 1.0451data8-8-37 8 8 57 59 0.6747data8-8-38 8 8 57 54 0.9271data8-8-39 8 8 57 64 1.0304data8-8-40 8 8 57 54 0.7893

Table 32: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 47: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata9-8-1 8 9 64 70 0.7867data9-8-2 8 9 64 62 0.5724data9-8-3 8 9 64 70 0.6816data9-8-4 8 9 64 62 0.7195data9-8-5 8 9 64 75 0.7430data9-8-6 8 9 64 75 0.7920data9-8-7 8 9 64 73 0.7586data9-8-8 8 9 64 63 0.9263data9-8-9 8 9 64 51 0.3338data9-8-10 8 9 64 66 0.6001data9-8-11 8 9 64 81 0.5858data9-8-12 8 9 64 76 0.4755data9-8-13 8 9 64 77 0.6311data9-8-14 8 9 64 71 0.8164data9-8-15 8 9 64 64 0.5630data9-8-16 8 9 64 71 0.5506data9-8-17 8 9 64 62 0.3893data9-8-18 8 9 64 71 0.6604data9-8-19 8 9 64 63 0.4456data9-8-20 8 9 64 62 0.7095data9-8-21 8 9 64 64 0.5517data9-8-22 8 9 64 77 0.8131data9-8-23 8 9 64 67 0.5350data9-8-24 8 9 64 74 0.7062data9-8-25 8 9 64 60 0.5614data9-8-26 8 9 64 79 0.4630data9-8-27 8 9 64 70 0.3551data9-8-28 8 9 64 72 0.8807data9-8-29 8 9 64 66 0.6641data9-8-30 8 9 64 74 0.7933data9-8-31 8 9 64 64 0.7040data9-8-32 8 9 64 77 0.8058data9-8-33 8 9 64 83 0.5838data9-8-34 8 9 64 62 0.2726data9-8-35 8 9 64 71 0.7437data9-8-36 8 9 64 59 0.7662data9-8-37 8 9 64 61 0.7454data9-8-38 8 9 64 62 0.4037data9-8-39 8 9 64 75 0.8629data9-8-40 8 9 64 56 0.3849data10-8-1 8 10 71 81 0.8368data10-8-2 8 10 71 84 0.9432data10-8-3 8 10 71 77 0.9799data10-8-4 8 10 71 74 0.7673data10-8-5 8 10 71 70 0.8488data10-8-6 8 10 71 99 1.0163data10-8-7 8 10 71 87 1.0143data10-8-8 8 10 71 75 0.9873data10-8-9 8 10 71 88 0.9605data10-8-10 8 10 71 93 0.9881data10-8-11 8 10 71 80 0.8147data10-8-12 8 10 71 74 0.8385data10-8-13 8 10 71 74 0.6206data10-8-14 8 10 71 70 0.9237data10-8-15 8 10 71 90 1.0123data10-8-16 8 10 71 76 0.7401data10-8-17 8 10 71 85 0.7250data10-8-18 8 10 71 83 1.0275data10-8-19 8 10 71 81 1.0138data10-8-20 8 10 71 73 0.8849data10-8-21 8 10 71 72 0.5193data10-8-22 8 10 71 82 1.0310data10-8-23 8 10 71 71 0.7248data10-8-24 8 10 71 82 0.7233data10-8-25 8 10 71 77 1.0164data10-8-26 8 10 71 85 0.9586data10-8-27 8 10 71 74 0.9272data10-8-28 8 10 71 81 0.8041data10-8-29 8 10 71 79 0.8366data10-8-30 8 10 71 88 1.0119

Table 33: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 48: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-8-31 8 10 71 87 1.0329data10-8-32 8 10 71 86 0.9306data10-8-33 8 10 71 81 0.8398data10-8-34 8 10 71 91 0.8472data10-8-35 8 10 71 80 0.7594data10-8-36 8 10 71 85 0.6223data10-8-37 8 10 71 79 0.7581data10-8-38 8 10 71 77 1.0340data10-8-39 8 10 71 75 0.9421data10-8-40 8 10 71 90 1.0305data11-8-1 8 11 78 110 0.8331data11-8-2 8 11 78 83 0.7610data11-8-3 8 11 78 104 1.0127data11-8-4 8 11 78 99 1.0390data11-8-5 8 11 78 87 0.7076data11-8-6 8 11 78 97 1.0207data11-8-7 8 11 78 96 1.0192data11-8-8 8 11 78 98 1.0183data11-8-9 8 11 78 96 1.0188data11-8-10 8 11 78 96 0.8707data11-8-11 8 11 78 113 1.0312data11-8-12 8 11 78 115 1.0098data11-8-13 8 11 78 111 1.0154data11-8-14 8 11 78 83 1.0259data11-8-15 8 11 78 92 1.0235data11-8-16 8 11 78 102 0.8821data11-8-17 8 11 78 85 0.9936data11-8-18 8 11 78 105 1.0110data11-8-19 8 11 78 103 1.0307data11-8-20 8 11 78 104 1.0171data11-8-21 8 11 78 102 1.0170data11-8-22 8 11 78 102 1.0186data11-8-23 8 11 78 97 1.0232data11-8-24 8 11 78 94 1.0141data11-8-25 8 11 78 92 1.0163data11-8-26 8 11 78 103 1.0182data11-8-27 8 11 78 95 1.0105data11-8-28 8 11 78 102 1.0242data11-8-29 8 11 78 108 0.8553data11-8-30 8 11 78 85 0.7949data11-8-31 8 11 78 87 1.0218data11-8-32 8 11 78 98 1.0179data11-8-33 8 11 78 97 1.0203data11-8-34 8 11 78 106 1.0162data11-8-35 8 11 78 102 0.8856data11-8-36 8 11 78 111 1.0149data11-8-37 8 11 78 116 1.0148data11-8-38 8 11 78 90 0.7594data11-8-39 8 11 78 98 1.0316data11-8-40 8 11 78 100 1.0138data12-8-1 8 12 85 113 0.9097data12-8-2 8 12 85 106 1.0205data12-8-3 8 12 85 123 1.0192data12-8-4 8 12 85 104 0.8453data12-8-5 8 12 85 131 1.0170data12-8-6 8 12 85 115 0.9841data12-8-7 8 12 85 118 1.0222data12-8-8 8 12 85 130 1.0155data12-8-9 8 12 85 100 1.0280data12-8-10 8 12 85 105 1.0269data12-8-11 8 12 85 101 1.0192data12-8-12 8 12 85 104 1.0158data12-8-13 8 12 85 109 1.0111data12-8-14 8 12 85 132 1.0221data12-8-15 8 12 85 115 1.0156data12-8-16 8 12 85 98 0.9003data12-8-17 8 12 85 99 1.0057data12-8-18 8 12 85 115 1.0204data12-8-19 8 12 85 115 1.0115data12-8-20 8 12 85 115 0.8976

Table 34: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 49: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata12-8-21 8 12 85 117 1.0119data12-8-22 8 12 85 115 1.0137data12-8-23 8 12 85 111 0.9911data12-8-24 8 12 85 118 1.0160data12-8-25 8 12 85 130 1.0134data12-8-26 8 12 85 120 1.0139data12-8-27 8 12 85 131 1.0170data12-8-28 8 12 85 128 1.0190data12-8-29 8 12 85 118 1.0178data12-8-30 8 12 85 110 1.0131data12-8-31 8 12 85 114 0.9506data12-8-32 8 12 85 89 0.6006data12-8-33 8 12 85 108 1.0276data12-8-34 8 12 85 114 1.0164data12-8-35 8 12 85 123 0.9827data12-8-36 8 12 85 117 1.0181data12-8-37 8 12 85 96 1.0148data12-8-38 8 12 85 107 0.7976data12-8-39 8 12 85 120 1.0205data12-8-40 8 12 85 106 1.0136data3-9-1 9 3 25 8 0.0041data3-9-2 9 3 25 12 0.0040data3-9-3 9 3 25 11 0.0045data3-9-4 9 3 25 14 0.0039data3-9-5 9 3 25 12 0.0041data3-9-6 9 3 25 12 0.0047data3-9-7 9 3 25 14 0.0042data3-9-8 9 3 25 13 0.0042data3-9-9 9 3 25 11 0.0039data3-9-10 9 3 25 7 0.0039data3-9-11 9 3 25 10 0.0041data3-9-12 9 3 25 13 0.0040data3-9-13 9 3 25 10 0.0046data3-9-14 9 3 25 13 0.0045data3-9-15 9 3 25 15 0.0042data3-9-16 9 3 25 13 0.0039data3-9-17 9 3 25 9 0.0041data3-9-18 9 3 25 13 0.0040data3-9-19 9 3 25 10 0.0041data3-9-20 9 3 25 13 0.0046data3-9-21 9 3 25 10 0.0043data3-9-22 9 3 25 11 0.0041data3-9-23 9 3 25 14 0.0042data3-9-24 9 3 25 11 0.0041data3-9-25 9 3 25 11 0.0039data3-9-26 9 3 25 10 0.0044data3-9-27 9 3 25 10 0.0046data3-9-28 9 3 25 11 0.0043data3-9-29 9 3 25 10 0.0041data3-9-30 9 3 25 13 0.0041data3-9-31 9 3 25 13 0.0040data3-9-32 9 3 25 9 0.0040data3-9-33 9 3 25 8 0.0045data3-9-34 9 3 25 14 0.0043data3-9-35 9 3 25 15 0.0043data3-9-36 9 3 25 10 0.0045data3-9-37 9 3 25 16 0.0042data3-9-38 9 3 25 10 0.0042data3-9-39 9 3 25 9 0.0042data3-9-40 9 3 25 10 0.0045data4-9-1 9 4 33 24 0.0087data4-9-2 9 4 33 22 0.0143data4-9-3 9 4 33 13 0.0063data4-9-4 9 4 33 17 0.0065data4-9-5 9 4 33 20 0.0062data4-9-6 9 4 33 15 0.0061data4-9-7 9 4 33 19 0.0056data4-9-8 9 4 33 21 0.0071data4-9-9 9 4 33 22 0.0058data4-9-10 9 4 33 20 0.0055

Table 35: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 50: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-9-11 9 4 33 21 0.0061data4-9-12 9 4 33 22 0.0066data4-9-13 9 4 33 18 0.0060data4-9-14 9 4 33 19 0.0061data4-9-15 9 4 33 16 0.0055data4-9-16 9 4 33 21 0.0059data4-9-17 9 4 33 19 0.0113data4-9-18 9 4 33 21 0.0077data4-9-19 9 4 33 19 0.0056data4-9-20 9 4 33 21 0.0058data4-9-21 9 4 33 19 0.0058data4-9-22 9 4 33 16 0.0058data4-9-23 9 4 33 16 0.0056data4-9-24 9 4 33 25 0.0112data4-9-25 9 4 33 16 0.0055data4-9-26 9 4 33 20 0.0070data4-9-27 9 4 33 17 0.0055data4-9-28 9 4 33 16 0.0054data4-9-29 9 4 33 18 0.0056data4-9-30 9 4 33 19 0.0055data4-9-31 9 4 33 21 0.0058data4-9-32 9 4 33 25 0.0060data4-9-33 9 4 33 20 0.0581data4-9-34 9 4 33 24 0.0605data4-9-35 9 4 33 18 0.0056data4-9-36 9 4 33 14 0.0059data4-9-37 9 4 33 19 0.0058data4-9-38 9 4 33 20 0.0131data4-9-39 9 4 33 16 0.0058data4-9-40 9 4 33 17 0.0056data5-9-1 9 5 41 29 0.3445data5-9-2 9 5 41 27 0.0067data5-9-3 9 5 41 34 0.0115data5-9-4 9 5 41 26 0.0259data5-9-5 9 5 41 20 0.0043data5-9-6 9 5 41 29 0.0045data5-9-7 9 5 41 21 0.0047data5-9-8 9 5 41 32 0.0054data5-9-9 9 5 41 26 0.1175data5-9-10 9 5 41 28 0.1044data5-9-11 9 5 41 28 0.1448data5-9-12 9 5 41 33 0.0494data5-9-13 9 5 41 27 0.0134data5-9-14 9 5 41 29 0.0107data5-9-15 9 5 41 30 0.1009data5-9-16 9 5 41 34 0.0278data5-9-17 9 5 41 33 0.0053data5-9-18 9 5 41 25 0.0488data5-9-19 9 5 41 31 0.0056data5-9-20 9 5 41 33 0.0744data5-9-21 9 5 41 32 0.0271data5-9-22 9 5 41 28 0.0992data5-9-23 9 5 41 32 0.0373data5-9-24 9 5 41 31 0.0326data5-9-25 9 5 41 28 0.0047data5-9-26 9 5 41 29 0.0061data5-9-27 9 5 41 27 0.0084data5-9-28 9 5 41 32 0.0184data5-9-29 9 5 41 32 0.2910data5-9-30 9 5 41 30 0.0044data5-9-31 9 5 41 24 0.0043data5-9-32 9 5 41 24 0.0049data5-9-33 9 5 41 28 0.0228data5-9-34 9 5 41 25 0.0259data5-9-35 9 5 41 24 0.0045data5-9-36 9 5 41 28 0.0061data5-9-37 9 5 41 30 0.0219data5-9-38 9 5 41 31 0.0047data5-9-39 9 5 41 24 0.1455data5-9-40 9 5 41 32 0.0389

Table 36: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 51: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-9-1 9 6 49 38 0.0626data6-9-2 9 6 49 39 0.3763data6-9-3 9 6 49 34 0.1692data6-9-4 9 6 49 38 0.7538data6-9-5 9 6 49 48 1.0554data6-9-6 9 6 49 41 0.3414data6-9-7 9 6 49 40 0.0418data6-9-8 9 6 49 42 0.3828data6-9-9 9 6 49 38 0.0170data6-9-10 9 6 49 44 0.2918data6-9-11 9 6 49 33 0.2150data6-9-12 9 6 49 39 0.1196data6-9-13 9 6 49 42 0.4811data6-9-14 9 6 49 47 0.6171data6-9-15 9 6 49 41 0.0389data6-9-16 9 6 49 38 0.3500data6-9-17 9 6 49 43 1.0177data6-9-18 9 6 49 45 0.3491data6-9-19 9 6 49 35 0.1894data6-9-20 9 6 49 33 0.0445data6-9-21 9 6 49 41 0.4341data6-9-22 9 6 49 40 0.0195data6-9-23 9 6 49 41 0.1324data6-9-24 9 6 49 40 0.1380data6-9-25 9 6 49 44 0.1917data6-9-26 9 6 49 46 0.5963data6-9-27 9 6 49 44 0.1564data6-9-28 9 6 49 39 0.1631data6-9-29 9 6 49 33 0.0285data6-9-30 9 6 49 41 0.2301data6-9-31 9 6 49 45 0.7523data6-9-32 9 6 49 42 0.5277data6-9-33 9 6 49 46 0.4238data6-9-34 9 6 49 33 0.4946data6-9-35 9 6 49 41 0.4241data6-9-36 9 6 49 30 0.1433data6-9-37 9 6 49 37 0.0886data6-9-38 9 6 49 35 0.3270data6-9-39 9 6 49 39 0.0387data6-9-40 9 6 49 33 0.1871data7-9-1 9 7 57 58 0.3938data7-9-2 9 7 57 43 0.0305data7-9-3 9 7 57 54 0.5524data7-9-4 9 7 57 56 0.6010data7-9-5 9 7 57 50 0.5077data7-9-6 9 7 57 48 1.0708data7-9-7 9 7 57 50 0.5504data7-9-8 9 7 57 51 0.6903data7-9-9 9 7 57 48 0.3390data7-9-10 9 7 57 48 0.7652data7-9-11 9 7 57 49 0.9920data7-9-12 9 7 57 46 0.9293data7-9-13 9 7 57 56 1.0368data7-9-14 9 7 57 48 0.3411data7-9-15 9 7 57 56 0.5801data7-9-16 9 7 57 47 0.8501data7-9-17 9 7 57 51 0.9499data7-9-18 9 7 57 55 1.0110data7-9-19 9 7 57 53 0.2550data7-9-20 9 7 57 49 0.8033data7-9-21 9 7 57 47 1.0442data7-9-22 9 7 57 49 0.9184data7-9-23 9 7 57 56 0.9433data7-9-24 9 7 57 50 0.1213data7-9-25 9 7 57 55 0.6919data7-9-26 9 7 57 56 0.5044data7-9-27 9 7 57 47 0.3099data7-9-28 9 7 57 45 0.5171data7-9-29 9 7 57 48 0.8217data7-9-30 9 7 57 50 1.0116

Table 37: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 52: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-9-31 9 7 57 44 0.5402data7-9-32 9 7 57 63 1.0399data7-9-33 9 7 57 55 0.5090data7-9-34 9 7 57 44 0.3077data7-9-35 9 7 57 44 0.4297data7-9-36 9 7 57 58 0.7219data7-9-37 9 7 57 53 0.6190data7-9-38 9 7 57 45 0.0225data7-9-39 9 7 57 55 0.4717data7-9-40 9 7 57 49 1.0006data8-9-1 9 8 65 70 0.4001data8-9-2 9 8 65 56 0.3951data8-9-3 9 8 65 64 0.5588data8-9-4 9 8 65 58 0.6188data8-9-5 9 8 65 58 0.6972data8-9-6 9 8 65 77 0.8176data8-9-7 9 8 65 62 0.7484data8-9-8 9 8 65 56 0.5186data8-9-9 9 8 65 62 0.7769data8-9-10 9 8 65 65 0.5261data8-9-11 9 8 65 71 0.9158data8-9-12 9 8 65 68 0.5813data8-9-13 9 8 65 71 0.6271data8-9-14 9 8 65 66 0.3987data8-9-15 9 8 65 68 0.6377data8-9-16 9 8 65 62 0.6554data8-9-17 9 8 65 59 0.5363data8-9-18 9 8 65 69 0.6377data8-9-19 9 8 65 61 0.8142data8-9-20 9 8 65 62 0.5276data8-9-21 9 8 65 63 0.5341data8-9-22 9 8 65 65 0.7969data8-9-23 9 8 65 63 0.8413data8-9-24 9 8 65 62 0.5403data8-9-25 9 8 65 56 0.4652data8-9-26 9 8 65 80 0.8532data8-9-27 9 8 65 64 0.5086data8-9-28 9 8 65 64 0.3263data8-9-29 9 8 65 58 0.5040data8-9-30 9 8 65 69 0.7952data8-9-31 9 8 65 60 0.3942data8-9-32 9 8 65 71 0.8419data8-9-33 9 8 65 74 0.5932data8-9-34 9 8 65 53 0.2645data8-9-35 9 8 65 74 0.6308data8-9-36 9 8 65 60 0.2438data8-9-37 9 8 65 59 0.6745data8-9-38 9 8 65 61 0.3810data8-9-39 9 8 65 67 0.5410data8-9-40 9 8 65 71 1.0108data9-9-1 9 9 73 90 1.0147data9-9-2 9 9 73 86 0.9092data9-9-3 9 9 73 77 0.8201data9-9-4 9 9 73 78 0.6316data9-9-5 9 9 73 60 0.9260data9-9-6 9 9 73 78 0.6395data9-9-7 9 9 73 78 0.8917data9-9-8 9 9 73 77 0.6311data9-9-9 9 9 73 88 0.9519data9-9-10 9 9 73 82 1.0303data9-9-11 9 9 73 74 0.7571data9-9-12 9 9 73 79 0.7299data9-9-13 9 9 73 82 0.6665data9-9-14 9 9 73 80 0.3846data9-9-15 9 9 73 80 0.9331data9-9-16 9 9 73 83 0.8571data9-9-17 9 9 73 83 1.0222data9-9-18 9 9 73 75 0.6368data9-9-19 9 9 73 71 0.5653data9-9-20 9 9 73 74 1.0347

Table 38: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 53: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata9-9-21 9 9 73 87 0.6200data9-9-22 9 9 73 70 0.7129data9-9-23 9 9 73 81 1.0272data9-9-24 9 9 73 79 1.0174data9-9-25 9 9 73 79 1.0279data9-9-26 9 9 73 81 0.9784data9-9-27 9 9 73 85 1.0200data9-9-28 9 9 73 89 0.9588data9-9-29 9 9 73 67 0.5967data9-9-30 9 9 73 82 1.0254data9-9-31 9 9 73 83 1.0228data9-9-32 9 9 73 79 0.9773data9-9-33 9 9 73 74 1.0041data9-9-34 9 9 73 71 0.5869data9-9-35 9 9 73 76 0.6907data9-9-36 9 9 73 71 0.6321data9-9-37 9 9 73 88 1.0311data9-9-38 9 9 73 79 1.0088data9-9-39 9 9 73 70 0.9884data9-9-40 9 9 73 84 0.9838data10-9-1 9 10 81 89 0.7254data10-9-2 9 10 81 91 0.8263data10-9-3 9 10 81 80 0.5826data10-9-4 9 10 81 98 1.0224data10-9-5 9 10 81 98 0.7398data10-9-6 9 10 81 100 1.0201data10-9-7 9 10 81 83 0.6458data10-9-8 9 10 81 98 0.8831data10-9-9 9 10 81 97 0.8780data10-9-10 9 10 81 106 0.7767data10-9-11 9 10 81 80 0.4716data10-9-12 9 10 81 97 0.9977data10-9-13 9 10 81 90 0.7228data10-9-14 9 10 81 100 0.9299data10-9-15 9 10 81 103 0.9130data10-9-16 9 10 81 99 0.8998data10-9-17 9 10 81 94 0.9080data10-9-18 9 10 81 89 0.6626data10-9-19 9 10 81 76 0.7587data10-9-20 9 10 81 82 0.9034data10-9-21 9 10 81 96 0.8561data10-9-22 9 10 81 95 0.6352data10-9-23 9 10 81 90 0.5972data10-9-24 9 10 81 99 0.8272data10-9-25 9 10 81 109 0.8178data10-9-26 9 10 81 111 0.7936data10-9-27 9 10 81 85 0.6281data10-9-28 9 10 81 89 0.8943data10-9-29 9 10 81 84 0.9142data10-9-30 9 10 81 88 0.7704data10-9-31 9 10 81 93 0.6705data10-9-32 9 10 81 101 0.8792data10-9-33 9 10 81 92 0.8708data10-9-34 9 10 81 107 0.9622data10-9-35 9 10 81 92 0.8879data10-9-36 9 10 81 106 0.8987data10-9-37 9 10 81 91 0.9463data10-9-38 9 10 81 88 0.9643data10-9-39 9 10 81 88 0.7870data10-9-40 9 10 81 98 0.5680data11-9-1 9 11 89 106 0.9450data11-9-2 9 11 89 108 1.0104data11-9-3 9 11 89 124 1.0106data11-9-4 9 11 89 107 1.0215data11-9-5 9 11 89 104 0.9892data11-9-6 9 11 89 95 1.0238data11-9-7 9 11 89 117 1.0157data11-9-8 9 11 89 124 1.0176data11-9-9 9 11 89 112 0.8412data11-9-10 9 11 89 102 1.0156

Table 39: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 54: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata11-9-11 9 11 89 116 1.0142data11-9-12 9 11 89 105 0.8898data11-9-13 9 11 89 135 1.0124data11-9-14 9 11 89 107 1.0080data11-9-15 9 11 89 105 0.9654data11-9-16 9 11 89 108 1.0115data11-9-17 9 11 89 105 1.0205data11-9-18 9 11 89 112 0.9876data11-9-19 9 11 89 96 1.0176data11-9-20 9 11 89 103 0.9760data11-9-21 9 11 89 108 1.0091data11-9-22 9 11 89 113 1.0116data11-9-23 9 11 89 114 1.0085data11-9-24 9 11 89 104 1.0143data11-9-25 9 11 89 102 0.9926data11-9-26 9 11 89 100 1.0092data11-9-27 9 11 89 102 1.0148data11-9-28 9 11 89 121 1.0221data11-9-29 9 11 89 117 1.0064data11-9-30 9 11 89 121 1.0197data11-9-31 9 11 89 110 1.0175data11-9-32 9 11 89 115 1.0052data11-9-33 9 11 89 95 1.0103data11-9-34 9 11 89 100 1.0196data11-9-35 9 11 89 101 1.0029data11-9-36 9 11 89 103 1.0045data11-9-37 9 11 89 118 1.0078data11-9-38 9 11 89 122 1.0126data11-9-39 9 11 89 92 1.0127data11-9-40 9 11 89 101 0.7851data12-9-1 9 12 97 133 0.9921data12-9-2 9 12 97 116 1.0204data12-9-3 9 12 97 129 1.0099data12-9-4 9 12 97 127 1.0090data12-9-5 9 12 97 129 1.0084data12-9-6 9 12 97 143 1.0204data12-9-7 9 12 97 133 1.0082data12-9-8 9 12 97 141 1.0112data12-9-9 9 12 97 132 1.0125data12-9-10 9 12 97 123 1.0092data12-9-11 9 12 97 131 1.0109data12-9-12 9 12 97 135 1.0188data12-9-13 9 12 97 137 1.0201data12-9-14 9 12 97 134 1.0140data12-9-15 9 12 97 127 1.0164data12-9-16 9 12 97 112 0.8514data12-9-17 9 12 97 115 1.0091data12-9-18 9 12 97 123 1.0190data12-9-19 9 12 97 104 1.0111data12-9-20 9 12 97 131 1.0138data12-9-21 9 12 97 126 1.0321data12-9-22 9 12 97 129 1.0200data12-9-23 9 12 97 130 1.0089data12-9-24 9 12 97 131 1.0243data12-9-25 9 12 97 124 1.0102data12-9-26 9 12 97 141 1.0123data12-9-27 9 12 97 131 1.0052data12-9-28 9 12 97 136 0.9914data12-9-29 9 12 97 139 1.0221data12-9-30 9 12 97 142 1.0217data12-9-31 9 12 97 111 1.0113data12-9-32 9 12 97 116 1.0127data12-9-33 9 12 97 120 1.0145data12-9-34 9 12 97 127 1.0094data12-9-35 9 12 97 123 1.0162data12-9-36 9 12 97 127 1.0131data12-9-37 9 12 97 124 1.0150data12-9-38 9 12 97 157 0.9840data12-9-39 9 12 97 124 1.0100data12-9-40 9 12 97 119 1.0057

Table 40: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 55: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-10-1 10 3 28 14 0.0048data3-10-2 10 3 28 14 0.0049data3-10-3 10 3 28 8 0.0053data3-10-4 10 3 28 6 0.0058data3-10-5 10 3 28 15 0.0060data3-10-6 10 3 28 13 0.0057data3-10-7 10 3 28 9 0.0056data3-10-8 10 3 28 12 0.0052data3-10-9 10 3 28 9 0.0050data3-10-10 10 3 28 13 0.0053data3-10-11 10 3 28 15 0.0056data3-10-12 10 3 28 12 0.0050data3-10-13 10 3 28 12 0.0048data3-10-14 10 3 28 11 0.0046data3-10-15 10 3 28 14 0.0046data3-10-16 10 3 28 12 0.0054data3-10-17 10 3 28 8 0.0052data3-10-18 10 3 28 12 0.0048data3-10-19 10 3 28 10 0.0047data3-10-20 10 3 28 12 0.0048data3-10-21 10 3 28 9 0.0048data3-10-22 10 3 28 13 0.0052data3-10-23 10 3 28 15 0.0050data3-10-24 10 3 28 15 0.0048data3-10-25 10 3 28 8 0.0047data3-10-26 10 3 28 12 0.0050data3-10-27 10 3 28 11 0.0047data3-10-28 10 3 28 12 0.0051data3-10-29 10 3 28 13 0.0048data3-10-30 10 3 28 11 0.0049data3-10-31 10 3 28 16 0.0046data3-10-32 10 3 28 13 0.0047data3-10-33 10 3 28 12 0.0048data3-10-34 10 3 28 13 0.0054data3-10-35 10 3 28 12 0.0048data3-10-36 10 3 28 15 0.0047data3-10-37 10 3 28 10 0.0048data3-10-38 10 3 28 16 0.0047data3-10-39 10 3 28 9 0.0048data3-10-40 10 3 28 9 0.0055data4-10-1 10 4 37 25 0.0066data4-10-2 10 4 37 28 0.0060data4-10-3 10 4 37 17 0.0060data4-10-4 10 4 37 24 0.0064data4-10-5 10 4 37 23 0.0063data4-10-6 10 4 37 23 0.0061data4-10-7 10 4 37 23 0.0059data4-10-8 10 4 37 25 0.0057data4-10-9 10 4 37 19 0.0060data4-10-10 10 4 37 23 0.0074data4-10-11 10 4 37 24 0.0058data4-10-12 10 4 37 21 0.0060data4-10-13 10 4 37 23 0.0057data4-10-14 10 4 37 18 0.0061data4-10-15 10 4 37 25 0.0141data4-10-16 10 4 37 24 0.0075data4-10-17 10 4 37 28 0.0329data4-10-18 10 4 37 25 0.0085data4-10-19 10 4 37 27 0.0064data4-10-20 10 4 37 27 0.0141data4-10-21 10 4 37 27 0.0069data4-10-22 10 4 37 18 0.0065data4-10-23 10 4 37 17 0.0067data4-10-24 10 4 37 26 0.0072data4-10-25 10 4 37 26 0.0110data4-10-26 10 4 37 29 0.0083data4-10-27 10 4 37 20 0.0061data4-10-28 10 4 37 19 0.0071data4-10-29 10 4 37 17 0.0062data4-10-30 10 4 37 22 0.0064

Table 41: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 56: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-10-31 10 4 37 20 0.0062data4-10-32 10 4 37 26 0.0476data4-10-33 10 4 37 24 0.0061data4-10-34 10 4 37 16 0.0150data4-10-35 10 4 37 24 0.0168data4-10-36 10 4 37 20 0.0068data4-10-37 10 4 37 20 0.0058data4-10-38 10 4 37 18 0.0060data4-10-39 10 4 37 19 0.0062data4-10-40 10 4 37 14 0.0060data5-10-1 10 5 46 36 0.0081data5-10-2 10 5 46 38 0.0286data5-10-3 10 5 46 29 0.0054data5-10-4 10 5 46 32 0.4580data5-10-5 10 5 46 40 0.0816data5-10-6 10 5 46 35 0.0055data5-10-7 10 5 46 40 0.3303data5-10-8 10 5 46 34 0.1532data5-10-9 10 5 46 25 0.2641data5-10-10 10 5 46 30 0.1896data5-10-11 10 5 46 41 0.1314data5-10-12 10 5 46 35 0.0130data5-10-13 10 5 46 36 0.6303data5-10-14 10 5 46 29 0.0199data5-10-15 10 5 46 35 0.7619data5-10-16 10 5 46 29 0.0103data5-10-17 10 5 46 32 0.0491data5-10-18 10 5 46 25 0.0593data5-10-19 10 5 46 37 0.0067data5-10-20 10 5 46 29 0.0893data5-10-21 10 5 46 33 0.0759data5-10-22 10 5 46 29 0.1223data5-10-23 10 5 46 24 0.0048data5-10-24 10 5 46 32 0.0051data5-10-25 10 5 46 35 0.1292data5-10-26 10 5 46 29 0.1881data5-10-27 10 5 46 30 0.0095data5-10-28 10 5 46 31 0.0055data5-10-29 10 5 46 33 0.1325data5-10-30 10 5 46 27 0.0709data5-10-31 10 5 46 23 0.0046data5-10-32 10 5 46 33 0.3277data5-10-33 10 5 46 35 0.0085data5-10-34 10 5 46 23 0.0070data5-10-35 10 5 46 27 0.1212data5-10-36 10 5 46 32 0.0373data5-10-37 10 5 46 26 0.0052data5-10-38 10 5 46 30 0.0062data5-10-39 10 5 46 31 0.0166data5-10-40 10 5 46 39 0.0361data6-10-1 10 6 55 43 0.0178data6-10-2 10 6 55 45 0.0293data6-10-3 10 6 55 49 0.7530data6-10-4 10 6 55 42 0.4716data6-10-5 10 6 55 41 0.0415data6-10-6 10 6 55 49 0.2550data6-10-7 10 6 55 42 0.0087data6-10-8 10 6 55 49 0.8432data6-10-9 10 6 55 37 0.1613data6-10-10 10 6 55 47 0.2965data6-10-11 10 6 55 38 0.0692data6-10-12 10 6 55 46 0.2365data6-10-13 10 6 55 46 0.5965data6-10-14 10 6 55 41 0.1472data6-10-15 10 6 55 40 0.2295data6-10-16 10 6 55 50 0.2215data6-10-17 10 6 55 39 0.4695data6-10-18 10 6 55 44 0.8074data6-10-19 10 6 55 45 0.4702data6-10-20 10 6 55 35 0.0104

Table 42: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 57: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-10-21 10 6 55 43 0.5571data6-10-22 10 6 55 37 0.2517data6-10-23 10 6 55 45 0.8213data6-10-24 10 6 55 49 0.5323data6-10-25 10 6 55 41 0.1655data6-10-26 10 6 55 43 0.2776data6-10-27 10 6 55 46 0.1972data6-10-28 10 6 55 44 0.1396data6-10-29 10 6 55 41 0.1564data6-10-30 10 6 55 47 0.1203data6-10-31 10 6 55 39 0.7089data6-10-32 10 6 55 53 0.6785data6-10-33 10 6 55 46 1.0133data6-10-34 10 6 55 40 0.0169data6-10-35 10 6 55 44 0.0536data6-10-36 10 6 55 43 0.3492data6-10-37 10 6 55 45 0.4341data6-10-38 10 6 55 42 0.2946data6-10-39 10 6 55 41 0.1728data6-10-40 10 6 55 46 0.6881data7-10-1 10 7 64 52 0.4219data7-10-2 10 7 64 56 0.4075data7-10-3 10 7 64 66 1.0212data7-10-4 10 7 64 61 0.4979data7-10-5 10 7 64 52 0.3224data7-10-6 10 7 64 59 0.6427data7-10-7 10 7 64 56 0.2258data7-10-8 10 7 64 58 0.8596data7-10-9 10 7 64 68 0.2989data7-10-10 10 7 64 67 0.6099data7-10-11 10 7 64 53 0.3954data7-10-12 10 7 64 55 0.4988data7-10-13 10 7 64 52 0.9187data7-10-14 10 7 64 57 0.5614data7-10-15 10 7 64 49 0.2698data7-10-16 10 7 64 63 0.5141data7-10-17 10 7 64 53 0.3373data7-10-18 10 7 64 56 0.3212data7-10-19 10 7 64 58 0.3364data7-10-20 10 7 64 55 0.2459data7-10-21 10 7 64 48 0.2684data7-10-22 10 7 64 61 0.6343data7-10-23 10 7 64 52 0.4266data7-10-24 10 7 64 63 0.5857data7-10-25 10 7 64 53 0.5271data7-10-26 10 7 64 68 0.6954data7-10-27 10 7 64 48 0.1684data7-10-28 10 7 64 56 0.5644data7-10-29 10 7 64 59 0.0995data7-10-30 10 7 64 53 0.4250data7-10-31 10 7 64 47 0.5681data7-10-32 10 7 64 54 0.5876data7-10-33 10 7 64 54 0.2059data7-10-34 10 7 64 56 0.3887data7-10-35 10 7 64 55 0.2010data7-10-36 10 7 64 57 0.9310data7-10-37 10 7 64 59 0.5140data7-10-38 10 7 64 57 0.6674data7-10-39 10 7 64 58 0.3656data7-10-40 10 7 64 51 0.7431data8-10-1 10 8 73 71 0.6716data8-10-2 10 8 73 76 0.4908data8-10-3 10 8 73 70 0.7766data8-10-4 10 8 73 68 0.6432data8-10-5 10 8 73 60 0.8639data8-10-6 10 8 73 65 1.0196data8-10-7 10 8 73 76 0.8033data8-10-8 10 8 73 70 0.6975data8-10-9 10 8 73 78 0.6793data8-10-10 10 8 73 74 0.9398

Table 43: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 58: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata8-10-11 10 8 73 65 0.5034data8-10-12 10 8 73 69 1.0135data8-10-13 10 8 73 79 0.7908data8-10-14 10 8 73 64 1.0208data8-10-15 10 8 73 75 0.6368data8-10-16 10 8 73 65 0.4338data8-10-17 10 8 73 66 0.7344data8-10-18 10 8 73 64 0.4652data8-10-19 10 8 73 67 0.5691data8-10-20 10 8 73 78 1.0153data8-10-21 10 8 73 75 0.5601data8-10-22 10 8 73 70 1.0189data8-10-23 10 8 73 70 0.3706data8-10-24 10 8 73 60 0.4764data8-10-25 10 8 73 67 1.0127data8-10-26 10 8 73 74 0.6345data8-10-27 10 8 73 64 0.8508data8-10-28 10 8 73 71 0.9459data8-10-29 10 8 73 66 0.9993data8-10-30 10 8 73 68 0.4182data8-10-31 10 8 73 72 0.9447data8-10-32 10 8 73 71 0.9664data8-10-33 10 8 73 74 1.0159data8-10-34 10 8 73 76 0.6965data8-10-35 10 8 73 69 0.6003data8-10-36 10 8 73 57 0.5422data8-10-37 10 8 73 69 0.6679data8-10-38 10 8 73 61 0.4424data8-10-39 10 8 73 63 0.6024data8-10-40 10 8 73 74 0.6504data9-10-1 10 9 82 79 0.8100data9-10-2 10 9 82 87 0.7408data9-10-3 10 9 82 84 0.4158data9-10-4 10 9 82 86 0.6047data9-10-5 10 9 82 90 0.7371data9-10-6 10 9 82 89 0.7976data9-10-7 10 9 82 73 0.5413data9-10-8 10 9 82 94 0.9036data9-10-9 10 9 82 86 0.9194data9-10-10 10 9 82 100 0.8295data9-10-11 10 9 82 89 0.6743data9-10-12 10 9 82 79 0.9340data9-10-13 10 9 82 86 0.6832data9-10-14 10 9 82 97 1.0150data9-10-15 10 9 82 82 0.7369data9-10-16 10 9 82 86 0.8137data9-10-17 10 9 82 71 0.7609data9-10-18 10 9 82 81 0.6932data9-10-19 10 9 82 79 0.8143data9-10-20 10 9 82 87 0.8967data9-10-21 10 9 82 89 0.8730data9-10-22 10 9 82 86 0.8153data9-10-23 10 9 82 78 0.7413data9-10-24 10 9 82 99 0.7153data9-10-25 10 9 82 99 0.9472data9-10-26 10 9 82 89 0.5539data9-10-27 10 9 82 88 0.8047data9-10-28 10 9 82 76 0.7436data9-10-29 10 9 82 79 1.0227data9-10-30 10 9 82 84 0.6232data9-10-31 10 9 82 87 0.9855data9-10-32 10 9 82 94 0.8024data9-10-33 10 9 82 90 1.0223data9-10-34 10 9 82 100 0.6713data9-10-35 10 9 82 81 0.7426data9-10-36 10 9 82 91 0.7837data9-10-37 10 9 82 77 0.7332data9-10-38 10 9 82 88 1.0174data9-10-39 10 9 82 80 0.7338data9-10-40 10 9 82 97 0.6293

Table 44: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 59: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-10-1 10 10 91 106 1.0202data10-10-2 10 10 91 111 0.9945data10-10-3 10 10 91 95 1.0110data10-10-4 10 10 91 119 1.0260data10-10-5 10 10 91 100 0.6012data10-10-6 10 10 91 114 1.0131data10-10-7 10 10 91 100 0.7136data10-10-8 10 10 91 108 0.9729data10-10-9 10 10 91 105 0.8985data10-10-10 10 10 91 101 1.0106data10-10-11 10 10 91 95 0.9114data10-10-12 10 10 91 88 1.0219data10-10-13 10 10 91 102 1.0085data10-10-14 10 10 91 112 1.0127data10-10-15 10 10 91 105 1.0128data10-10-16 10 10 91 90 0.9496data10-10-17 10 10 91 111 1.0335data10-10-18 10 10 91 111 1.0208data10-10-19 10 10 91 105 0.8436data10-10-20 10 10 91 97 1.0184data10-10-21 10 10 91 103 1.0156data10-10-22 10 10 91 85 0.9770data10-10-23 10 10 91 106 1.0212data10-10-24 10 10 91 91 1.0090data10-10-25 10 10 91 96 0.8681data10-10-26 10 10 91 100 1.0273data10-10-27 10 10 91 100 0.9065data10-10-28 10 10 91 118 1.0157data10-10-29 10 10 91 102 1.0140data10-10-30 10 10 91 100 1.0099data10-10-31 10 10 91 94 1.0152data10-10-32 10 10 91 102 1.0170data10-10-33 10 10 91 104 1.0147data10-10-34 10 10 91 93 1.0266data10-10-35 10 10 91 116 1.0134data10-10-36 10 10 91 110 1.0134data10-10-37 10 10 91 96 1.0233data10-10-38 10 10 91 102 1.0104data10-10-39 10 10 91 109 1.0203data10-10-40 10 10 91 94 1.0155data11-10-1 10 11 100 124 0.6071data11-10-2 10 11 100 117 0.8542data11-10-3 10 11 100 124 0.5997data11-10-4 10 11 100 116 0.6279data11-10-5 10 11 100 131 0.6947data11-10-6 10 11 100 119 0.4914data11-10-7 10 11 100 139 0.7548data11-10-8 10 11 100 120 0.6875data11-10-9 10 11 100 130 0.8488data11-10-10 10 11 100 114 0.7124data11-10-11 10 11 100 123 0.6273data11-10-12 10 11 100 120 0.8042data11-10-13 10 11 100 118 0.7143data11-10-14 10 11 100 135 0.8385data11-10-15 10 11 100 117 0.5859data11-10-16 10 11 100 117 0.8463data11-10-17 10 11 100 123 0.8753data11-10-18 10 11 100 118 0.6964data11-10-19 10 11 100 120 0.7348data11-10-20 10 11 100 118 0.9046data11-10-21 10 11 100 123 0.6771data11-10-22 10 11 100 120 0.6828data11-10-23 10 11 100 133 0.9361data11-10-24 10 11 100 112 0.8047data11-10-25 10 11 100 118 0.7111data11-10-26 10 11 100 118 0.6691data11-10-27 10 11 100 116 0.5168data11-10-28 10 11 100 121 0.4840data11-10-29 10 11 100 119 0.7587data11-10-30 10 11 100 126 0.8907

Table 45: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 60: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata11-10-31 10 11 100 118 0.6977data11-10-32 10 11 100 123 0.6329data11-10-33 10 11 100 126 0.9355data11-10-34 10 11 100 126 0.7511data11-10-35 10 11 100 128 0.7139data11-10-36 10 11 100 118 0.6821data11-10-37 10 11 100 126 0.7591data11-10-38 10 11 100 107 0.6751data11-10-39 10 11 100 121 0.7042data11-10-40 10 11 100 120 0.9059data12-10-1 10 12 109 146 0.8500data12-10-2 10 12 109 118 0.6985data12-10-3 10 12 109 141 0.7229data12-10-4 10 12 109 130 0.9795data12-10-5 10 12 109 121 0.6933data12-10-6 10 12 109 115 0.8065data12-10-7 10 12 109 145 1.0197data12-10-8 10 12 109 147 1.0150data12-10-9 10 12 109 140 0.7731data12-10-10 10 12 109 128 0.8448data12-10-11 10 12 109 126 0.7058data12-10-12 10 12 109 144 0.7571data12-10-13 10 12 109 112 0.8044data12-10-14 10 12 109 130 0.9510data12-10-15 10 12 109 142 1.0138data12-10-16 10 12 109 164 0.8643data12-10-17 10 12 109 145 1.0155data12-10-18 10 12 109 159 1.0145data12-10-19 10 12 109 133 0.8900data12-10-20 10 12 109 137 1.0125data12-10-21 10 12 109 143 0.8632data12-10-22 10 12 109 146 0.7818data12-10-23 10 12 109 157 1.0082data12-10-24 10 12 109 143 1.0105data12-10-25 10 12 109 157 1.0063data12-10-26 10 12 109 148 0.8358data12-10-27 10 12 109 141 0.9954data12-10-28 10 12 109 142 0.7038data12-10-29 10 12 109 119 0.8637data12-10-30 10 12 109 139 1.0127data12-10-31 10 12 109 138 0.9579data12-10-32 10 12 109 125 0.7459data12-10-33 10 12 109 141 1.0172data12-10-34 10 12 109 120 0.8453data12-10-35 10 12 109 134 0.9932data12-10-36 10 12 109 122 0.8476data12-10-37 10 12 109 149 1.0125data12-10-38 10 12 109 134 0.9151data12-10-39 10 12 109 143 0.9895data12-10-40 10 12 109 143 1.0183data3-11-1 11 3 31 18 0.0129data3-11-2 11 3 31 17 0.0062data3-11-3 11 3 31 13 0.0065data3-11-4 11 3 31 12 0.0056data3-11-5 11 3 31 13 0.0054data3-11-6 11 3 31 16 0.0052data3-11-7 11 3 31 16 0.0055data3-11-8 11 3 31 16 0.0058data3-11-9 11 3 31 12 0.0061data3-11-10 11 3 31 12 0.0056data3-11-11 11 3 31 10 0.0055data3-11-12 11 3 31 14 0.0054data3-11-13 11 3 31 15 0.0052data3-11-14 11 3 31 8 0.0065data3-11-15 11 3 31 20 0.0055data3-11-16 11 3 31 16 0.0055data3-11-17 11 3 31 13 0.0054data3-11-18 11 3 31 16 0.0055data3-11-19 11 3 31 9 0.0068data3-11-20 11 3 31 12 0.0056

Table 46: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 61: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-11-21 11 3 31 8 0.0055data3-11-22 11 3 31 14 0.0054data3-11-23 11 3 31 17 0.0055data3-11-24 11 3 31 16 0.0062data3-11-25 11 3 31 15 0.0056data3-11-26 11 3 31 18 0.0054data3-11-27 11 3 31 17 0.0055data3-11-28 11 3 31 12 0.0053data3-11-29 11 3 31 13 0.0063data3-11-30 11 3 31 14 0.0059data3-11-31 11 3 31 14 0.0056data3-11-32 11 3 31 11 0.0055data3-11-33 11 3 31 17 0.0052data3-11-34 11 3 31 15 0.0067data3-11-35 11 3 31 12 0.0060data3-11-36 11 3 31 14 0.0058data3-11-37 11 3 31 14 0.0055data3-11-38 11 3 31 19 0.0056data3-11-39 11 3 31 15 0.0063data3-11-40 11 3 31 12 0.0058data4-11-1 11 4 41 23 0.0069data4-11-2 11 4 41 30 0.1820data4-11-3 11 4 41 24 0.0046data4-11-4 11 4 41 30 0.1088data4-11-5 11 4 41 23 0.0047data4-11-6 11 4 41 25 0.0048data4-11-7 11 4 41 18 0.0046data4-11-8 11 4 41 20 0.0043data4-11-9 11 4 41 19 0.0054data4-11-10 11 4 41 21 0.0052data4-11-11 11 4 41 23 0.0076data4-11-12 11 4 41 22 0.0059data4-11-13 11 4 41 28 0.0044data4-11-14 11 4 41 22 0.0046data4-11-15 11 4 41 25 0.0052data4-11-16 11 4 41 22 0.0046data4-11-17 11 4 41 21 0.0047data4-11-18 11 4 41 27 0.0051data4-11-19 11 4 41 23 0.0077data4-11-20 11 4 41 23 0.0049data4-11-21 11 4 41 27 0.0048data4-11-22 11 4 41 25 0.0049data4-11-23 11 4 41 19 0.0045data4-11-24 11 4 41 22 0.0044data4-11-25 11 4 41 23 0.0046data4-11-26 11 4 41 28 0.0051data4-11-27 11 4 41 23 0.0049data4-11-28 11 4 41 23 0.0046data4-11-29 11 4 41 20 0.0045data4-11-30 11 4 41 18 0.0045data4-11-31 11 4 41 17 0.0065data4-11-32 11 4 41 29 0.0070data4-11-33 11 4 41 25 0.0052data4-11-34 11 4 41 23 0.0075data4-11-35 11 4 41 20 0.0045data4-11-36 11 4 41 28 0.0049data4-11-37 11 4 41 28 0.0052data4-11-38 11 4 41 26 0.0154data4-11-39 11 4 41 22 0.0047data4-11-40 11 4 41 22 0.0045data5-11-1 11 5 51 32 0.0101data5-11-2 11 5 51 34 0.2337data5-11-3 11 5 51 31 0.0054data5-11-4 11 5 51 29 0.0438data5-11-5 11 5 51 37 0.0120data5-11-6 11 5 51 39 0.2945data5-11-7 11 5 51 32 0.0139data5-11-8 11 5 51 34 0.0125data5-11-9 11 5 51 37 0.1756data5-11-10 11 5 51 43 0.1807

Table 47: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 62: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-11-11 11 5 51 39 0.3195data5-11-12 11 5 51 31 0.0052data5-11-13 11 5 51 36 0.0061data5-11-14 11 5 51 30 0.2035data5-11-15 11 5 51 37 0.1028data5-11-16 11 5 51 31 0.0986data5-11-17 11 5 51 33 0.5302data5-11-18 11 5 51 38 0.1398data5-11-19 11 5 51 33 0.0053data5-11-20 11 5 51 28 0.0882data5-11-21 11 5 51 43 0.0069data5-11-22 11 5 51 37 0.0071data5-11-23 11 5 51 39 0.1318data5-11-24 11 5 51 36 0.1612data5-11-25 11 5 51 39 0.0170data5-11-26 11 5 51 31 0.0121data5-11-27 11 5 51 35 0.0065data5-11-28 11 5 51 38 0.0104data5-11-29 11 5 51 32 0.0054data5-11-30 11 5 51 29 0.0060data5-11-31 11 5 51 36 0.1915data5-11-32 11 5 51 45 0.2816data5-11-33 11 5 51 32 0.0073data5-11-34 11 5 51 35 0.3307data5-11-35 11 5 51 34 0.0060data5-11-36 11 5 51 40 0.3768data5-11-37 11 5 51 32 0.0275data5-11-38 11 5 51 34 0.9308data5-11-39 11 5 51 31 0.2342data5-11-40 11 5 51 40 0.1848data6-11-1 11 6 61 44 0.3493data6-11-2 11 6 61 53 0.4889data6-11-3 11 6 61 51 0.2777data6-11-4 11 6 61 51 0.5448data6-11-5 11 6 61 32 0.2425data6-11-6 11 6 61 46 0.1821data6-11-7 11 6 61 44 0.0745data6-11-8 11 6 61 54 0.3824data6-11-9 11 6 61 46 0.3709data6-11-10 11 6 61 42 0.1815data6-11-11 11 6 61 48 0.4188data6-11-12 11 6 61 41 0.2504data6-11-13 11 6 61 51 0.3706data6-11-14 11 6 61 48 0.2572data6-11-15 11 6 61 51 0.6787data6-11-16 11 6 61 50 0.5234data6-11-17 11 6 61 46 0.2728data6-11-18 11 6 61 49 0.3474data6-11-19 11 6 61 54 0.2410data6-11-20 11 6 61 46 0.2096data6-11-21 11 6 61 56 0.5468data6-11-22 11 6 61 50 0.3234data6-11-23 11 6 61 45 0.3106data6-11-24 11 6 61 43 0.1796data6-11-25 11 6 61 45 0.4323data6-11-26 11 6 61 41 0.0583data6-11-27 11 6 61 44 0.3598data6-11-28 11 6 61 51 0.6280data6-11-29 11 6 61 43 0.7004data6-11-30 11 6 61 48 0.4272data6-11-31 11 6 61 48 0.1631data6-11-32 11 6 61 48 0.4916data6-11-33 11 6 61 46 0.0652data6-11-34 11 6 61 46 0.2509data6-11-35 11 6 61 42 0.0764data6-11-36 11 6 61 49 0.3139data6-11-37 11 6 61 43 0.0311data6-11-38 11 6 61 52 0.4123data6-11-39 11 6 61 52 0.3683data6-11-40 11 6 61 46 0.3689

Table 48: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 63: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-11-1 11 7 71 63 0.4828data7-11-2 11 7 71 55 0.7203data7-11-3 11 7 71 66 0.6485data7-11-4 11 7 71 62 0.7945data7-11-5 11 7 71 71 0.8417data7-11-6 11 7 71 67 0.7146data7-11-7 11 7 71 59 0.5029data7-11-8 11 7 71 72 0.6224data7-11-9 11 7 71 66 0.4162data7-11-10 11 7 71 61 0.5906data7-11-11 11 7 71 63 0.4423data7-11-12 11 7 71 68 0.3956data7-11-13 11 7 71 51 0.2003data7-11-14 11 7 71 57 0.4735data7-11-15 11 7 71 65 0.6173data7-11-16 11 7 71 59 0.3984data7-11-17 11 7 71 72 0.5000data7-11-18 11 7 71 58 0.4709data7-11-19 11 7 71 59 0.5704data7-11-20 11 7 71 64 0.7620data7-11-21 11 7 71 70 0.5260data7-11-22 11 7 71 63 0.4373data7-11-23 11 7 71 51 0.6023data7-11-24 11 7 71 59 0.3852data7-11-25 11 7 71 60 1.0369data7-11-26 11 7 71 63 0.9188data7-11-27 11 7 71 63 0.8169data7-11-28 11 7 71 58 0.4297data7-11-29 11 7 71 67 0.7539data7-11-30 11 7 71 57 0.6736data7-11-31 11 7 71 53 0.3824data7-11-32 11 7 71 56 0.2349data7-11-33 11 7 71 71 0.6835data7-11-34 11 7 71 61 0.4281data7-11-35 11 7 71 66 0.8816data7-11-36 11 7 71 58 0.6763data7-11-37 11 7 71 69 0.8285data7-11-38 11 7 71 66 0.4116data7-11-39 11 7 71 59 0.6219data7-11-40 11 7 71 65 0.4793data8-11-1 11 8 81 86 0.5649data8-11-2 11 8 81 72 0.7235data8-11-3 11 8 81 87 0.7554data8-11-4 11 8 81 80 0.4742data8-11-5 11 8 81 66 0.4897data8-11-6 11 8 81 66 0.8287data8-11-7 11 8 81 76 0.4794data8-11-8 11 8 81 76 0.5042data8-11-9 11 8 81 73 0.6134data8-11-10 11 8 81 82 0.4484data8-11-11 11 8 81 89 0.6054data8-11-12 11 8 81 91 0.7199data8-11-13 11 8 81 81 0.4180data8-11-14 11 8 81 80 0.4927data8-11-15 11 8 81 71 0.5239data8-11-16 11 8 81 78 0.5808data8-11-17 11 8 81 81 0.6446data8-11-18 11 8 81 83 0.6562data8-11-19 11 8 81 77 0.6144data8-11-20 11 8 81 83 0.9149data8-11-21 11 8 81 78 0.9266data8-11-22 11 8 81 83 0.6565data8-11-23 11 8 81 76 0.8177data8-11-24 11 8 81 75 0.5781data8-11-25 11 8 81 77 0.5607data8-11-26 11 8 81 76 0.5280data8-11-27 11 8 81 76 0.8328data8-11-28 11 8 81 79 0.8429data8-11-29 11 8 81 82 0.4763data8-11-30 11 8 81 74 0.3364

Table 49: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 64: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata8-11-31 11 8 81 75 0.3061data8-11-32 11 8 81 82 0.5383data8-11-33 11 8 81 82 0.4661data8-11-34 11 8 81 81 0.5295data8-11-35 11 8 81 89 0.9649data8-11-36 11 8 81 79 0.3975data8-11-37 11 8 81 84 0.6709data8-11-38 11 8 81 78 0.5018data8-11-39 11 8 81 81 0.5306data8-11-40 11 8 81 80 0.5185data9-11-1 11 9 91 93 1.0193data9-11-2 11 9 91 96 0.8481data9-11-3 11 9 91 95 0.9132data9-11-4 11 9 91 91 0.7746data9-11-5 11 9 91 85 0.8053data9-11-6 11 9 91 91 1.0151data9-11-7 11 9 91 98 0.9595data9-11-8 11 9 91 113 1.0236data9-11-9 11 9 91 111 0.9161data9-11-10 11 9 91 89 1.0172data9-11-11 11 9 91 105 1.0105data9-11-12 11 9 91 96 1.0117data9-11-13 11 9 91 98 0.9737data9-11-14 11 9 91 96 0.8638data9-11-15 11 9 91 102 1.0183data9-11-16 11 9 91 99 1.0103data9-11-17 11 9 91 112 0.9982data9-11-18 11 9 91 94 1.0153data9-11-19 11 9 91 90 1.0112data9-11-20 11 9 91 96 0.8336data9-11-21 11 9 91 101 0.9618data9-11-22 11 9 91 99 0.7623data9-11-23 11 9 91 91 0.8856data9-11-24 11 9 91 97 1.0135data9-11-25 11 9 91 86 1.0087data9-11-26 11 9 91 88 0.7197data9-11-27 11 9 91 100 0.6974data9-11-28 11 9 91 111 1.0215data9-11-29 11 9 91 99 1.0001data9-11-30 11 9 91 104 0.9034data9-11-31 11 9 91 97 0.7966data9-11-32 11 9 91 99 1.0126data9-11-33 11 9 91 93 1.0216data9-11-34 11 9 91 95 0.7304data9-11-35 11 9 91 90 1.0101data9-11-36 11 9 91 94 1.0260data9-11-37 11 9 91 97 0.8812data9-11-38 11 9 91 104 0.8434data9-11-39 11 9 91 85 0.5675data9-11-40 11 9 91 90 0.8287data10-11-1 11 10 101 125 0.7947data10-11-2 11 10 101 99 0.5883data10-11-3 11 10 101 117 0.6786data10-11-4 11 10 101 115 0.7411data10-11-5 11 10 101 128 0.7492data10-11-6 11 10 101 109 0.6071data10-11-7 11 10 101 120 0.5827data10-11-8 11 10 101 105 0.5604data10-11-9 11 10 101 111 0.5846data10-11-10 11 10 101 115 0.7115data10-11-11 11 10 101 137 0.8102data10-11-12 11 10 101 103 0.5317data10-11-13 11 10 101 104 0.6044data10-11-14 11 10 101 116 0.4591data10-11-15 11 10 101 111 0.6375data10-11-16 11 10 101 110 0.6571data10-11-17 11 10 101 114 0.6928data10-11-18 11 10 101 125 0.5884data10-11-19 11 10 101 132 0.7028data10-11-20 11 10 101 115 0.9599

Table 50: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 65: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-11-21 11 10 101 111 0.5997data10-11-22 11 10 101 105 0.4170data10-11-23 11 10 101 120 0.8016data10-11-24 11 10 101 106 0.5965data10-11-25 11 10 101 117 0.8039data10-11-26 11 10 101 129 0.6240data10-11-27 11 10 101 116 0.5724data10-11-28 11 10 101 113 0.5355data10-11-29 11 10 101 116 0.5306data10-11-30 11 10 101 125 0.4488data10-11-31 11 10 101 112 0.6607data10-11-32 11 10 101 116 0.5801data10-11-33 11 10 101 109 0.4590data10-11-34 11 10 101 128 0.8298data10-11-35 11 10 101 114 0.6885data10-11-36 11 10 101 112 0.6860data10-11-37 11 10 101 120 0.7043data10-11-38 11 10 101 109 0.5436data10-11-39 11 10 101 107 0.5897data10-11-40 11 10 101 110 0.6299data11-11-1 11 11 111 137 0.9652data11-11-2 11 11 111 130 0.6733data11-11-3 11 11 111 125 0.8315data11-11-4 11 11 111 121 0.7473data11-11-5 11 11 111 129 0.8716data11-11-6 11 11 111 137 0.9276data11-11-7 11 11 111 124 0.7389data11-11-8 11 11 111 127 0.8992data11-11-9 11 11 111 138 0.9944data11-11-10 11 11 111 150 1.0094data11-11-11 11 11 111 115 0.8610data11-11-12 11 11 111 134 0.9339data11-11-13 11 11 111 117 0.9138data11-11-14 11 11 111 151 1.0059data11-11-15 11 11 111 126 0.9267data11-11-16 11 11 111 131 0.9224data11-11-17 11 11 111 141 1.0124data11-11-18 11 11 111 133 0.7765data11-11-19 11 11 111 129 0.8963data11-11-20 11 11 111 125 0.8824data11-11-21 11 11 111 136 0.8325data11-11-22 11 11 111 131 0.8427data11-11-23 11 11 111 120 0.7383data11-11-24 11 11 111 139 0.8780data11-11-25 11 11 111 111 0.7755data11-11-26 11 11 111 124 0.6641data11-11-27 11 11 111 124 0.8605data11-11-28 11 11 111 129 1.0132data11-11-29 11 11 111 133 0.8765data11-11-30 11 11 111 142 0.9614data11-11-31 11 11 111 135 0.9844data11-11-32 11 11 111 147 1.0166data11-11-33 11 11 111 144 1.0201data11-11-34 11 11 111 131 0.9424data11-11-35 11 11 111 145 0.6711data11-11-36 11 11 111 141 1.0139data11-11-37 11 11 111 151 1.0204data11-11-38 11 11 111 137 1.0015data11-11-39 11 11 111 140 0.7451data11-11-40 11 11 111 141 1.0119data12-11-1 11 12 121 154 0.6766data12-11-2 11 12 121 159 0.6369data12-11-3 11 12 121 164 0.7226data12-11-4 11 12 121 158 0.6189data12-11-5 11 12 121 161 0.7710data12-11-6 11 12 121 168 0.8423data12-11-7 11 12 121 145 0.5917data12-11-8 11 12 121 160 0.6948data12-11-9 11 12 121 165 0.6292data12-11-10 11 12 121 180 0.6374

Table 51: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 66: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata12-11-11 11 12 121 143 0.6142data12-11-12 11 12 121 159 0.4461data12-11-13 11 12 121 150 0.3801data12-11-14 11 12 121 165 0.6511data12-11-15 11 12 121 145 0.6102data12-11-16 11 12 121 171 0.6381data12-11-17 11 12 121 144 0.6492data12-11-18 11 12 121 154 0.6778data12-11-19 11 12 121 163 0.5881data12-11-20 11 12 121 142 0.5299data12-11-21 11 12 121 169 0.6703data12-11-22 11 12 121 152 0.7460data12-11-23 11 12 121 162 0.7702data12-11-24 11 12 121 150 0.5977data12-11-25 11 12 121 151 0.4386data12-11-26 11 12 121 144 0.4280data12-11-27 11 12 121 154 0.5973data12-11-28 11 12 121 134 0.4736data12-11-29 11 12 121 151 0.6526data12-11-30 11 12 121 151 0.6239data12-11-31 11 12 121 152 0.4079data12-11-32 11 12 121 171 0.6538data12-11-33 11 12 121 155 0.6718data12-11-34 11 12 121 141 0.5653data12-11-35 11 12 121 160 0.6872data12-11-36 11 12 121 153 0.6017data12-11-37 11 12 121 166 0.7631data12-11-38 11 12 121 148 0.7185data12-11-39 11 12 121 163 0.7049data12-11-40 11 12 121 165 0.4446data3-12-1 12 3 34 17 0.0061data3-12-2 12 3 34 16 0.0064data3-12-3 12 3 34 14 0.0057data3-12-4 12 3 34 12 0.0057data3-12-5 12 3 34 15 0.0061data3-12-6 12 3 34 13 0.0059data3-12-7 12 3 34 15 0.0059data3-12-8 12 3 34 13 0.0058data3-12-9 12 3 34 19 0.0063data3-12-10 12 3 34 14 0.0060data3-12-11 12 3 34 16 0.0061data3-12-12 12 3 34 16 0.0060data3-12-13 12 3 34 11 0.0058data3-12-14 12 3 34 16 0.0066data3-12-15 12 3 34 19 0.0060data3-12-16 12 3 34 15 0.0058data3-12-17 12 3 34 11 0.0056data3-12-18 12 3 34 14 0.0059data3-12-19 12 3 34 11 0.0072data3-12-20 12 3 34 15 0.0066data3-12-21 12 3 34 15 0.0070data3-12-22 12 3 34 16 0.0062data3-12-23 12 3 34 16 0.0064data3-12-24 12 3 34 18 0.0063data3-12-25 12 3 34 12 0.0058data3-12-26 12 3 34 11 0.0058data3-12-27 12 3 34 19 0.0076data3-12-28 12 3 34 9 0.0070data3-12-29 12 3 34 15 0.0061data3-12-30 12 3 34 16 0.0059data3-12-31 12 3 34 17 0.0056data3-12-32 12 3 34 22 0.0057data3-12-33 12 3 34 16 0.0067data3-12-34 12 3 34 18 0.0076data3-12-35 12 3 34 11 0.0060data3-12-36 12 3 34 11 0.0058data3-12-37 12 3 34 13 0.0064data3-12-38 12 3 34 17 0.0068data3-12-39 12 3 34 17 0.0062data3-12-40 12 3 34 15 0.0060

Table 52: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 67: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-12-1 12 4 45 30 0.0084data4-12-2 12 4 45 30 0.0085data4-12-3 12 4 45 25 0.0051data4-12-4 12 4 45 30 0.1213data4-12-5 12 4 45 23 0.0049data4-12-6 12 4 45 24 0.0055data4-12-7 12 4 45 25 0.0531data4-12-8 12 4 45 22 0.0048data4-12-9 12 4 45 30 0.0050data4-12-10 12 4 45 30 0.0856data4-12-11 12 4 45 25 0.0081data4-12-12 12 4 45 29 0.0063data4-12-13 12 4 45 26 0.0047data4-12-14 12 4 45 29 0.0052data4-12-15 12 4 45 23 0.0060data4-12-16 12 4 45 30 0.0081data4-12-17 12 4 45 28 0.0049data4-12-18 12 4 45 22 0.0048data4-12-19 12 4 45 26 0.0068data4-12-20 12 4 45 28 0.0058data4-12-21 12 4 45 27 0.0052data4-12-22 12 4 45 29 0.0147data4-12-23 12 4 45 31 0.0059data4-12-24 12 4 45 30 0.0125data4-12-25 12 4 45 28 0.0872data4-12-26 12 4 45 20 0.0051data4-12-27 12 4 45 25 0.0049data4-12-28 12 4 45 27 0.0051data4-12-29 12 4 45 27 0.3246data4-12-30 12 4 45 24 0.0059data4-12-31 12 4 45 25 0.0052data4-12-32 12 4 45 27 0.0049data4-12-33 12 4 45 30 0.0049data4-12-34 12 4 45 36 0.0225data4-12-35 12 4 45 21 0.0048data4-12-36 12 4 45 29 0.0119data4-12-37 12 4 45 27 0.0053data4-12-38 12 4 45 30 0.0059data4-12-39 12 4 45 21 0.0050data4-12-40 12 4 45 23 0.0052data5-12-1 12 5 56 39 0.0088data5-12-2 12 5 56 42 0.0548data5-12-3 12 5 56 39 0.0413data5-12-4 12 5 56 42 0.2826data5-12-5 12 5 56 37 0.0528data5-12-6 12 5 56 46 0.0575data5-12-7 12 5 56 40 1.0339data5-12-8 12 5 56 37 0.3551data5-12-9 12 5 56 38 0.0715data5-12-10 12 5 56 38 0.0315data5-12-11 12 5 56 38 0.4650data5-12-12 12 5 56 37 0.0797data5-12-13 12 5 56 44 0.2560data5-12-14 12 5 56 38 1.0171data5-12-15 12 5 56 35 0.0256data5-12-16 12 5 56 34 0.0075data5-12-17 12 5 56 40 0.2626data5-12-18 12 5 56 44 0.4186data5-12-19 12 5 56 42 0.2263data5-12-20 12 5 56 31 0.0845data5-12-21 12 5 56 36 0.5498data5-12-22 12 5 56 39 0.4979data5-12-23 12 5 56 36 0.1797data5-12-24 12 5 56 42 0.0238data5-12-25 12 5 56 35 0.0074data5-12-26 12 5 56 43 0.5480data5-12-27 12 5 56 43 0.2177data5-12-28 12 5 56 33 0.0059data5-12-29 12 5 56 39 1.0111data5-12-30 12 5 56 43 0.1394

Table 53: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 68: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-12-31 12 5 56 38 0.3610data5-12-32 12 5 56 46 0.4207data5-12-33 12 5 56 39 0.1629data5-12-34 12 5 56 33 0.0192data5-12-35 12 5 56 46 0.3652data5-12-36 12 5 56 37 0.2322data5-12-37 12 5 56 37 0.8441data5-12-38 12 5 56 40 0.0061data5-12-39 12 5 56 34 0.7184data5-12-40 12 5 56 42 0.1475data6-12-1 12 6 67 57 0.8314data6-12-2 12 6 67 51 0.5204data6-12-3 12 6 67 54 0.0483data6-12-4 12 6 67 53 0.4682data6-12-5 12 6 67 51 0.3004data6-12-6 12 6 67 56 0.8610data6-12-7 12 6 67 46 0.1291data6-12-8 12 6 67 43 0.1738data6-12-9 12 6 67 46 0.0300data6-12-10 12 6 67 55 0.7704data6-12-11 12 6 67 56 0.1639data6-12-12 12 6 67 53 1.0013data6-12-13 12 6 67 55 0.1039data6-12-14 12 6 67 54 0.2226data6-12-15 12 6 67 50 0.1494data6-12-16 12 6 67 49 0.5820data6-12-17 12 6 67 49 0.1228data6-12-18 12 6 67 58 0.5317data6-12-19 12 6 67 50 0.1756data6-12-20 12 6 67 48 0.3988data6-12-21 12 6 67 48 0.2602data6-12-22 12 6 67 53 0.2803data6-12-23 12 6 67 48 0.4738data6-12-24 12 6 67 55 0.7393data6-12-25 12 6 67 49 0.2164data6-12-26 12 6 67 57 0.6788data6-12-27 12 6 67 56 0.2603data6-12-28 12 6 67 56 0.2683data6-12-29 12 6 67 50 0.3450data6-12-30 12 6 67 54 0.6879data6-12-31 12 6 67 44 0.0192data6-12-32 12 6 67 58 0.6900data6-12-33 12 6 67 53 0.1242data6-12-34 12 6 67 46 0.2416data6-12-35 12 6 67 60 0.1729data6-12-36 12 6 67 51 0.1310data6-12-37 12 6 67 46 0.3428data6-12-38 12 6 67 44 0.0778data6-12-39 12 6 67 52 0.1997data6-12-40 12 6 67 56 0.6005data7-12-1 12 7 78 75 1.0413data7-12-2 12 7 78 67 0.6501data7-12-3 12 7 78 75 0.8118data7-12-4 12 7 78 66 1.0165data7-12-5 12 7 78 72 0.6414data7-12-6 12 7 78 57 0.6771data7-12-7 12 7 78 65 0.4494data7-12-8 12 7 78 69 1.0268data7-12-9 12 7 78 64 0.8662data7-12-10 12 7 78 74 1.0252data7-12-11 12 7 78 72 1.0120data7-12-12 12 7 78 80 1.0132data7-12-13 12 7 78 61 1.0182data7-12-14 12 7 78 70 0.7746data7-12-15 12 7 78 64 0.6552data7-12-16 12 7 78 67 0.6275data7-12-17 12 7 78 80 0.7659data7-12-18 12 7 78 79 1.0212data7-12-19 12 7 78 62 0.5813data7-12-20 12 7 78 78 1.0288

Table 54: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 69: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-12-21 12 7 78 68 0.2037data7-12-22 12 7 78 61 1.0279data7-12-23 12 7 78 61 0.5129data7-12-24 12 7 78 72 1.0150data7-12-25 12 7 78 64 0.7055data7-12-26 12 7 78 69 0.8878data7-12-27 12 7 78 70 0.6678data7-12-28 12 7 78 64 0.7578data7-12-29 12 7 78 66 1.0159data7-12-30 12 7 78 67 0.7363data7-12-31 12 7 78 72 0.9594data7-12-32 12 7 78 78 0.7980data7-12-33 12 7 78 74 1.0015data7-12-34 12 7 78 67 0.8496data7-12-35 12 7 78 68 0.5303data7-12-36 12 7 78 72 0.9621data7-12-37 12 7 78 69 0.8004data7-12-38 12 7 78 64 0.6083data7-12-39 12 7 78 69 0.6033data7-12-40 12 7 78 74 1.0146data8-12-1 12 8 89 87 0.8980data8-12-2 12 8 89 92 1.0146data8-12-3 12 8 89 98 0.7757data8-12-4 12 8 89 81 0.7584data8-12-5 12 8 89 91 0.6688data8-12-6 12 8 89 86 1.0134data8-12-7 12 8 89 82 0.3834data8-12-8 12 8 89 87 1.0096data8-12-9 12 8 89 89 1.0111data8-12-10 12 8 89 82 0.5281data8-12-11 12 8 89 81 0.9749data8-12-12 12 8 89 88 0.5433data8-12-13 12 8 89 88 1.0112data8-12-14 12 8 89 92 0.7604data8-12-15 12 8 89 97 0.9976data8-12-16 12 8 89 83 1.0137data8-12-17 12 8 89 81 0.6815data8-12-18 12 8 89 90 1.0221data8-12-19 12 8 89 88 1.0095data8-12-20 12 8 89 86 0.6413data8-12-21 12 8 89 83 1.0091data8-12-22 12 8 89 87 0.5854data8-12-23 12 8 89 86 0.7009data8-12-24 12 8 89 73 0.4922data8-12-25 12 8 89 80 0.5250data8-12-26 12 8 89 93 0.5485data8-12-27 12 8 89 87 0.4264data8-12-28 12 8 89 90 0.4229data8-12-29 12 8 89 80 0.9061data8-12-30 12 8 89 85 0.9882data8-12-31 12 8 89 84 0.5757data8-12-32 12 8 89 74 0.2642data8-12-33 12 8 89 93 0.7947data8-12-34 12 8 89 92 0.5406data8-12-35 12 8 89 93 0.5272data8-12-36 12 8 89 91 1.0105data8-12-37 12 8 89 75 0.8757data8-12-38 12 8 89 90 0.6750data8-12-39 12 8 89 87 0.7552data8-12-40 12 8 89 86 0.7648data9-12-1 12 9 100 115 0.8320data9-12-2 12 9 100 102 0.4279data9-12-3 12 9 100 112 0.6570data9-12-4 12 9 100 107 0.4686data9-12-5 12 9 100 98 0.3440data9-12-6 12 9 100 118 0.7425data9-12-7 12 9 100 110 0.6382data9-12-8 12 9 100 112 0.6406data9-12-9 12 9 100 105 0.7464data9-12-10 12 9 100 91 0.4825

Table 55: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 70: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata9-12-11 12 9 100 98 0.4121data9-12-12 12 9 100 89 0.4057data9-12-13 12 9 100 127 0.6576data9-12-14 12 9 100 96 0.4204data9-12-15 12 9 100 112 0.6024data9-12-16 12 9 100 103 0.4609data9-12-17 12 9 100 85 0.4933data9-12-18 12 9 100 98 0.5087data9-12-19 12 9 100 109 0.8149data9-12-20 12 9 100 99 0.5866data9-12-21 12 9 100 107 0.6039data9-12-22 12 9 100 110 0.7545data9-12-23 12 9 100 110 0.6953data9-12-24 12 9 100 105 0.7714data9-12-25 12 9 100 97 0.4954data9-12-26 12 9 100 96 0.5758data9-12-27 12 9 100 93 0.5649data9-12-28 12 9 100 113 0.7900data9-12-29 12 9 100 107 0.5847data9-12-30 12 9 100 118 0.8155data9-12-31 12 9 100 99 0.5793data9-12-32 12 9 100 92 0.4247data9-12-33 12 9 100 107 0.6417data9-12-34 12 9 100 111 0.5315data9-12-35 12 9 100 106 0.5300data9-12-36 12 9 100 101 0.5214data9-12-37 12 9 100 100 0.5839data9-12-38 12 9 100 118 0.5021data9-12-39 12 9 100 101 0.7176data9-12-40 12 9 100 93 0.6090data10-12-1 12 10 111 121 0.5506data10-12-2 12 10 111 108 0.8693data10-12-3 12 10 111 123 0.6494data10-12-4 12 10 111 138 0.9933data10-12-5 12 10 111 123 1.0117data10-12-6 12 10 111 117 1.0045data10-12-7 12 10 111 127 0.7027data10-12-8 12 10 111 138 0.9966data10-12-9 12 10 111 129 0.8385data10-12-10 12 10 111 106 0.7118data10-12-11 12 10 111 111 0.7642data10-12-12 12 10 111 126 0.6756data10-12-13 12 10 111 115 0.6987data10-12-14 12 10 111 129 1.0115data10-12-15 12 10 111 123 0.8522data10-12-16 12 10 111 131 0.9693data10-12-17 12 10 111 123 0.7539data10-12-18 12 10 111 120 0.6305data10-12-19 12 10 111 125 1.0024data10-12-20 12 10 111 118 0.9459data10-12-21 12 10 111 118 0.7670data10-12-22 12 10 111 113 0.6383data10-12-23 12 10 111 136 0.7890data10-12-24 12 10 111 132 1.0095data10-12-25 12 10 111 115 0.9122data10-12-26 12 10 111 124 0.9820data10-12-27 12 10 111 125 1.0066data10-12-28 12 10 111 127 1.0142data10-12-29 12 10 111 104 0.7367data10-12-30 12 10 111 114 0.8107data10-12-31 12 10 111 120 0.6021data10-12-32 12 10 111 117 0.6097data10-12-33 12 10 111 119 0.9329data10-12-34 12 10 111 115 0.4908data10-12-35 12 10 111 127 0.6217data10-12-36 12 10 111 103 0.6717data10-12-37 12 10 111 121 0.8073data10-12-38 12 10 111 119 0.8481data10-12-39 12 10 111 136 0.9684data10-12-40 12 10 111 114 0.6182

Table 56: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 71: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata11-12-1 12 11 122 149 0.6112data11-12-2 12 11 122 155 0.5024data11-12-3 12 11 122 148 0.5540data11-12-4 12 11 122 152 0.5487data11-12-5 12 11 122 130 0.5217data11-12-6 12 11 122 153 0.4551data11-12-7 12 11 122 140 0.5543data11-12-8 12 11 122 131 0.4297data11-12-9 12 11 122 157 0.7641data11-12-10 12 11 122 158 0.5424data11-12-11 12 11 122 137 0.5333data11-12-12 12 11 122 158 0.5283data11-12-13 12 11 122 147 0.5565data11-12-14 12 11 122 151 0.4801data11-12-15 12 11 122 137 0.4743data11-12-16 12 11 122 164 0.5634data11-12-17 12 11 122 150 0.5413data11-12-18 12 11 122 145 0.6332data11-12-19 12 11 122 144 0.4914data11-12-20 12 11 122 160 0.8199data11-12-21 12 11 122 154 0.5659data11-12-22 12 11 122 138 0.5956data11-12-23 12 11 122 145 0.5673data11-12-24 12 11 122 151 0.7549data11-12-25 12 11 122 153 0.7500data11-12-26 12 11 122 142 0.5397data11-12-27 12 11 122 150 0.5835data11-12-28 12 11 122 141 0.6566data11-12-29 12 11 122 140 0.6494data11-12-30 12 11 122 142 0.5451data11-12-31 12 11 122 146 0.3829data11-12-32 12 11 122 152 0.5087data11-12-33 12 11 122 141 0.5663data11-12-34 12 11 122 144 0.7518data11-12-35 12 11 122 150 0.5289data11-12-36 12 11 122 158 0.6667data11-12-37 12 11 122 155 0.6416data11-12-38 12 11 122 141 0.6446data11-12-39 12 11 122 152 0.6327data11-12-40 12 11 122 141 0.5433data12-12-1 12 12 133 161 0.8335data12-12-2 12 12 133 184 0.9498data12-12-3 12 12 133 156 0.9157data12-12-4 12 12 133 155 0.7336data12-12-5 12 12 133 162 0.7945data12-12-6 12 12 133 161 0.8038data12-12-7 12 12 133 166 0.6951data12-12-8 12 12 133 182 0.6802data12-12-9 12 12 133 171 0.9707data12-12-10 12 12 133 159 0.6605data12-12-11 12 12 133 163 0.5916data12-12-12 12 12 133 162 0.7791data12-12-13 12 12 133 155 0.6240data12-12-14 12 12 133 186 0.9439data12-12-15 12 12 133 178 0.9394data12-12-16 12 12 133 164 0.8466data12-12-17 12 12 133 169 0.8457data12-12-18 12 12 133 183 0.9655data12-12-19 12 12 133 181 1.0029data12-12-20 12 12 133 166 0.7909data12-12-21 12 12 133 170 0.9823data12-12-22 12 12 133 179 0.8825data12-12-23 12 12 133 189 0.9793data12-12-24 12 12 133 175 1.0037data12-12-25 12 12 133 183 0.7798data12-12-26 12 12 133 170 0.9093data12-12-27 12 12 133 174 0.7691data12-12-28 12 12 133 164 0.7953data12-12-29 12 12 133 192 0.9282data12-12-30 12 12 133 174 0.9806

Table 57: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 72: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata12-12-31 12 12 133 160 0.7572data12-12-32 12 12 133 160 0.7540data12-12-33 12 12 133 198 0.9404data12-12-34 12 12 133 173 0.7542data12-12-35 12 12 133 165 0.8581data12-12-36 12 12 133 175 0.8929data12-12-37 12 12 133 170 0.6515data12-12-38 12 12 133 167 1.0094data12-12-39 12 12 133 196 0.9783data12-12-40 12 12 133 169 0.9710

Table 58: Computational results on the set group 2

Page 73: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

4 group 3

Page 74: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh TimeR011606 0070 001.txt 16 6 70 37 1.0361R011606 0070 002.txt 16 6 70 38 0.5819R011606 0070 003.txt 16 6 70 38 0.2272R011606 0070 004.txt 16 6 70 45 1.0657R011606 0070 005.txt 16 6 70 40 0.0747R011608 0090 001.txt 16 8 90 61 0.9818R011608 0090 002.txt 16 8 90 61 0.1728R011608 0090 003.txt 16 8 90 65 0.8709R011608 0090 004.txt 16 8 90 61 1.0269R011608 0090 005.txt 16 8 90 59 0.6843R021606 0140 001.txt 32 6 140 70 0.0022R021606 0140 002.txt 32 6 140 59 0.1953R021606 0140 003.txt 32 6 140 75 0.0013R021606 0140 004.txt 32 6 140 84 0.3492R021606 0140 005.txt 32 6 140 70 0.0012R021608 0190 001.txt 32 8 190 126 1.0029R021608 0190 002.txt 32 8 190 129 1.0029R021608 0190 003.txt 32 8 190 125 1.0033R021608 0190 004.txt 32 8 190 117 0.0016R021608 0190 005.txt 32 8 190 123 1.0027R041606 0280 001.txt 64 6 280 174 1.0018R041606 0280 002.txt 64 6 280 148 1.0009R041606 0280 003.txt 64 6 280 143 1.0007R041606 0280 004.txt 64 6 280 146 0.0026R041606 0280 005.txt 64 6 280 151 0.0025R041608 0380 001.txt 64 8 380 247 1.0018R041608 0380 002.txt 64 8 380 249 1.0016R041608 0380 003.txt 64 8 380 233 1.0017R041608 0380 004.txt 64 8 380 242 1.0018R041608 0380 005.txt 64 8 380 247 1.0012R061606 0430 001.txt 96 6 430 231 1.0027R061606 0430 002.txt 96 6 430 224 0.0039R061606 0430 003.txt 96 6 430 227 0.0035R061606 0430 004.txt 96 6 430 219 0.0040R061606 0430 005.txt 96 6 430 232 1.0024R061608 0570 001.txt 96 8 570 341 0.0051R061608 0570 002.txt 96 8 570 371 1.0030R061608 0570 003.txt 96 8 570 344 0.0108R061608 0570 004.txt 96 8 570 346 1.0025R061608 0570 005.txt 96 8 570 358 1.0023R081606 0570 001.txt 128 6 570 299 0.0047R081606 0570 002.txt 128 6 570 304 0.0049R081606 0570 003.txt 128 6 570 321 0.0049R081606 0570 004.txt 128 6 570 301 0.0047R081606 0570 005.txt 128 6 570 303 0.0050R101606 0720 001.txt 160 6 720 387 0.0066R101606 0720 002.txt 160 6 720 365 0.0062R101606 0720 003.txt 160 6 720 382 0.0064R101606 0720 004.txt 160 6 720 365 1.0029R101606 0720 005.txt 160 6 720 365 0.0061U011606 0070 001.txt 16 6 70 55 0.0043U011606 0070 002.txt 16 6 70 58 0.0025U011608 0090 001.txt 16 8 90 76 0.0028U011608 0090 002.txt 16 8 90 78 0.0022U021606 0140 001.txt 32 6 140 109 0.0014U021606 0140 002.txt 32 6 140 109 0.0013U021608 0190 001.txt 32 8 190 158 0.0016U021608 0190 002.txt 32 8 190 162 0.0022U041606 0280 001.txt 64 6 280 217 0.0024U041606 0280 002.txt 64 6 280 216 0.0023U041608 0380 001.txt 64 8 380 319 0.0031U041608 0380 002.txt 64 8 380 318 0.0030U061606 0430 001.txt 96 6 430 334 0.0034U061606 0430 002.txt 96 6 430 334 0.0035U061608 0570 001.txt 96 8 570 478 0.0044U061608 0570 002.txt 96 8 570 474 0.0044U081606 0570 001.txt 128 6 570 443 0.0054U081606 0570 002.txt 128 6 570 444 0.0049U101606 0720 001.txt 160 6 720 561 0.0061U101606 0720 002.txt 160 6 720 561 0.0061

Table 1: Computational results on the set group 3

Page 75: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

5 group 4

Page 76: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-3-1 3 5 9 6 0.0020data3-3-2 3 5 9 5 0.0013data3-3-3 3 5 9 2 0.0017data3-3-4 3 5 9 4 0.0016data3-3-5 3 5 9 1 0.0017data3-3-6 3 5 9 6 0.0017data3-3-7 3 5 9 6 0.0014data3-3-8 3 5 9 2 0.0015data3-3-9 3 5 9 7 0.0016data3-3-10 3 5 9 5 0.0019data3-3-11 3 5 9 3 0.0016data3-3-12 3 5 9 5 0.0016data3-3-13 3 5 9 8 0.0015data3-3-14 3 5 9 7 0.0015data3-3-15 3 5 9 6 0.0015data3-3-16 3 5 9 7 0.0015data3-3-17 3 5 9 5 0.0015data3-3-18 3 5 9 2 0.0015data3-3-19 3 5 9 8 0.0018data3-3-20 3 5 9 7 0.0019data3-3-21 3 5 9 7 0.0018data3-3-22 3 5 9 4 0.0018data3-3-23 3 5 9 6 0.0018data3-3-24 3 5 9 6 0.0015data3-3-25 3 5 9 4 0.0015data3-3-26 3 5 9 4 0.0015data3-3-27 3 5 9 5 0.0015data3-3-28 3 5 9 5 0.0015data3-3-29 3 5 9 7 0.0014data3-3-30 3 5 9 6 0.0015data3-3-31 3 5 9 5 0.0015data3-3-32 3 5 9 2 0.0015data3-3-33 3 5 9 3 0.0016data3-3-34 3 5 9 6 0.0014data3-3-35 3 5 9 5 0.0015data3-3-36 3 5 9 7 0.0015data3-3-37 3 5 9 5 0.0015data3-3-38 3 5 9 4 0.0015data3-3-39 3 5 9 0 0.0023data3-3-40 3 5 9 7 0.0020data3-4-1 4 5 12 5 0.0025data3-4-2 4 5 12 3 0.0027data3-4-3 4 5 12 7 0.0022data3-4-4 4 5 12 5 0.0020data3-4-5 4 5 12 6 0.0021data3-4-6 4 5 12 7 0.0019data3-4-7 4 5 12 10 0.0020data3-4-8 4 5 12 6 0.0019data3-4-9 4 5 12 4 0.0020data3-4-10 4 5 12 10 0.0019data3-4-11 4 5 12 7 0.0019data3-4-12 4 5 12 7 0.0020data3-4-13 4 5 12 3 0.0026data3-4-14 4 5 12 7 0.0023data3-4-15 4 5 12 5 0.0025data3-4-16 4 5 12 8 0.0026data3-4-17 4 5 12 6 0.0023data3-4-18 4 5 12 8 0.0021data3-4-19 4 5 12 6 0.0019data3-4-20 4 5 12 5 0.0019data3-4-21 4 5 12 7 0.0018data3-4-22 4 5 12 6 0.0019data3-4-23 4 5 12 4 0.0019data3-4-24 4 5 12 6 0.0022data3-4-25 4 5 12 7 0.0020data3-4-26 4 5 12 4 0.0025data3-4-27 4 5 12 2 0.0022data3-4-28 4 5 12 7 0.0021data3-4-29 4 5 12 9 0.0021data3-4-30 4 5 12 6 0.0020

Table 1: Computational results on the set group 4

Page 77: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-4-31 4 5 12 7 0.0023data3-4-32 4 5 12 7 0.0021data3-4-33 4 5 12 9 0.0025data3-4-34 4 5 12 7 0.0022data3-4-35 4 5 12 5 0.0021data3-4-36 4 5 12 8 0.0019data3-4-37 4 5 12 3 0.0019data3-4-38 4 5 12 5 0.0020data3-4-39 4 5 12 6 0.0020data3-4-40 4 5 12 7 0.0025data3-5-1 5 5 15 6 0.0028data3-5-2 5 5 15 7 0.0029data3-5-3 5 5 15 8 0.0030data3-5-4 5 5 15 6 0.0028data3-5-5 5 5 15 9 0.0028data3-5-6 5 5 15 7 0.0026data3-5-7 5 5 15 7 0.0024data3-5-8 5 5 15 10 0.0024data3-5-9 5 5 15 9 0.0032data3-5-10 5 5 15 4 0.0026data3-5-11 5 5 15 11 0.0032data3-5-12 5 5 15 6 0.0027data3-5-13 5 5 15 11 0.0029data3-5-14 5 5 15 4 0.0026data3-5-15 5 5 15 7 0.0029data3-5-16 5 5 15 8 0.0030data3-5-17 5 5 15 7 0.0028data3-5-18 5 5 15 4 0.0026data3-5-19 5 5 15 6 0.0025data3-5-20 5 5 15 7 0.0025data3-5-21 5 5 15 7 0.0032data3-5-22 5 5 15 7 0.0027data3-5-23 5 5 15 6 0.0030data3-5-24 5 5 15 9 0.0031data3-5-25 5 5 15 5 0.0029data3-5-26 5 5 15 9 0.0028data3-5-27 5 5 15 7 0.0025data3-5-28 5 5 15 6 0.0024data3-5-29 5 5 15 8 0.0024data3-5-30 5 5 15 5 0.0027data3-5-31 5 5 15 9 0.0026data3-5-32 5 5 15 7 0.0032data3-5-33 5 5 15 7 0.0028data3-5-34 5 5 15 8 0.0028data3-5-35 5 5 15 6 0.0028data3-5-36 5 5 15 8 0.0028data3-5-37 5 5 15 10 0.0031data3-5-38 5 5 15 3 0.0029data3-5-39 5 5 15 5 0.0026data3-5-40 5 5 15 5 0.0025data3-6-1 6 5 18 11 0.0046data3-6-2 6 5 18 7 0.0039data3-6-3 6 5 18 11 0.0037data3-6-4 6 5 18 7 0.0038data3-6-5 6 5 18 4 0.0037data3-6-6 6 5 18 10 0.0036data3-6-7 6 5 18 11 0.0032data3-6-8 6 5 18 9 0.0032data3-6-9 6 5 18 9 0.0031data3-6-10 6 5 18 7 0.0039data3-6-11 6 5 18 3 0.0033data3-6-12 6 5 18 10 0.0032data3-6-13 6 5 18 8 0.0034data3-6-14 6 5 18 8 0.0036data3-6-15 6 5 18 9 0.0033data3-6-16 6 5 18 10 0.0029data3-6-17 6 5 18 11 0.0029data3-6-18 6 5 18 6 0.0030data3-6-19 6 5 18 10 0.0038data3-6-20 6 5 18 7 0.0032

Table 2: Computational results on the set group 4

Page 78: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-6-21 6 5 18 10 0.0032data3-6-22 6 5 18 10 0.0033data3-6-23 6 5 18 11 0.0036data3-6-24 6 5 18 10 0.0034data3-6-25 6 5 18 7 0.0031data3-6-26 6 5 18 14 0.0072data3-6-27 6 5 18 9 0.0038data3-6-28 6 5 18 5 0.0033data3-6-29 6 5 18 8 0.0035data3-6-30 6 5 18 7 0.0036data3-6-31 6 5 18 9 0.0035data3-6-32 6 5 18 7 0.0032data3-6-33 6 5 18 7 0.0029data3-6-34 6 5 18 7 0.0032data3-6-35 6 5 18 4 0.0029data3-6-36 6 5 18 8 0.0037data3-6-37 6 5 18 11 0.0039data3-6-38 6 5 18 9 0.0033data3-6-39 6 5 18 7 0.0035data3-6-40 6 5 18 8 0.0034data3-7-1 7 5 21 7 0.0038data3-7-2 7 5 21 10 0.0037data3-7-3 7 5 21 9 0.0034data3-7-4 7 5 21 8 0.0047data3-7-5 7 5 21 12 0.0042data3-7-6 7 5 21 9 0.0040data3-7-7 7 5 21 12 0.0047data3-7-8 7 5 21 9 0.0040data3-7-9 7 5 21 11 0.0048data3-7-10 7 5 21 7 0.0035data3-7-11 7 5 21 9 0.0045data3-7-12 7 5 21 7 0.0043data3-7-13 7 5 21 10 0.0042data3-7-14 7 5 21 9 0.0045data3-7-15 7 5 21 6 0.0038data3-7-16 7 5 21 9 0.0038data3-7-17 7 5 21 10 0.0036data3-7-18 7 5 21 7 0.0043data3-7-19 7 5 21 11 0.0039data3-7-20 7 5 21 7 0.0042data3-7-21 7 5 21 9 0.0043data3-7-22 7 5 21 14 0.0050data3-7-23 7 5 21 8 0.0036data3-7-24 7 5 21 6 0.0037data3-7-25 7 5 21 9 0.0044data3-7-26 7 5 21 11 0.0050data3-7-27 7 5 21 13 0.0041data3-7-28 7 5 21 8 0.0043data3-7-29 7 5 21 12 0.0040data3-7-30 7 5 21 10 0.0039data3-7-31 7 5 21 8 0.0037data3-7-32 7 5 21 10 0.0053data3-7-33 7 5 21 13 0.0134data3-7-34 7 5 21 9 0.0041data3-7-35 7 5 21 11 0.0036data3-7-36 7 5 21 7 0.0035data3-7-37 7 5 21 8 0.0044data3-7-38 7 5 21 11 0.0041data3-7-39 7 5 21 6 0.0040data3-7-40 7 5 21 9 0.0041data3-8-1 8 5 24 8 0.0048data3-8-2 8 5 24 10 0.0042data3-8-3 8 5 24 9 0.0041data3-8-4 8 5 24 10 0.0053data3-8-5 8 5 24 13 0.0048data3-8-6 8 5 24 9 0.0048data3-8-7 8 5 24 13 0.0046data3-8-8 8 5 24 12 0.0043data3-8-9 8 5 24 9 0.0041data3-8-10 8 5 24 10 0.0040

Table 3: Computational results on the set group 4

Page 79: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-8-11 8 5 24 11 0.0048data3-8-12 8 5 24 11 0.0051data3-8-13 8 5 24 12 0.0061data3-8-14 8 5 24 12 0.0044data3-8-15 8 5 24 9 0.0043data3-8-16 8 5 24 8 0.0043data3-8-17 8 5 24 8 0.0047data3-8-18 8 5 24 9 0.0050data3-8-19 8 5 24 12 0.0049data3-8-20 8 5 24 11 0.0045data3-8-21 8 5 24 10 0.0043data3-8-22 8 5 24 10 0.0042data3-8-23 8 5 24 9 0.0046data3-8-24 8 5 24 9 0.0048data3-8-25 8 5 24 9 0.0047data3-8-26 8 5 24 16 0.0071data3-8-27 8 5 24 10 0.0044data3-8-28 8 5 24 11 0.0042data3-8-29 8 5 24 13 0.0046data3-8-30 8 5 24 11 0.0047data3-8-31 8 5 24 12 0.0047data3-8-32 8 5 24 12 0.0052data3-8-33 8 5 24 11 0.0043data3-8-34 8 5 24 10 0.0042data3-8-35 8 5 24 14 0.0095data3-8-36 8 5 24 10 0.0045data3-8-37 8 5 24 9 0.0048data3-8-38 8 5 24 14 0.0063data3-8-39 8 5 24 10 0.0042data3-8-40 8 5 24 10 0.0043data4-4-1 4 6 16 10 0.0031data4-4-2 4 6 16 10 0.0030data4-4-3 4 6 16 10 0.0028data4-4-4 4 6 16 7 0.0027data4-4-5 4 6 16 9 0.0028data4-4-6 4 6 16 5 0.0027data4-4-7 4 6 16 13 0.0042data4-4-8 4 6 16 11 0.0025data4-4-9 4 6 16 7 0.0026data4-4-10 4 6 16 8 0.0026data4-4-11 4 6 16 10 0.0034data4-4-12 4 6 16 8 0.0026data4-4-13 4 6 16 12 0.0026data4-4-14 4 6 16 13 0.0040data4-4-15 4 6 16 8 0.0030data4-4-16 4 6 16 12 0.0040data4-4-17 4 6 16 9 0.0026data4-4-18 4 6 16 12 0.0026data4-4-19 4 6 16 11 0.0023data4-4-20 4 6 16 8 0.0030data4-4-21 4 6 16 11 0.0030data4-4-22 4 6 16 9 0.0029data4-4-23 4 6 16 10 0.0028data4-4-24 4 6 16 9 0.0028data4-4-25 4 6 16 11 0.0032data4-4-26 4 6 16 9 0.0027data4-4-27 4 6 16 12 0.0031data4-4-28 4 6 16 9 0.0025data4-4-29 4 6 16 11 0.0023data4-4-30 4 6 16 11 0.0025data4-4-31 4 6 16 9 0.0028data4-4-32 4 6 16 8 0.0025data4-4-33 4 6 16 13 0.0031data4-4-34 4 6 16 9 0.0030data4-4-35 4 6 16 13 0.0028data4-4-36 4 6 16 13 0.0031data4-4-37 4 6 16 9 0.0024data4-4-38 4 6 16 13 0.0030data4-4-39 4 6 16 12 0.0030data4-4-40 4 6 16 14 0.0025

Table 4: Computational results on the set group 4

Page 80: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-5-1 5 6 20 16 0.0648data4-5-2 5 6 20 10 0.0033data4-5-3 5 6 20 13 0.0032data4-5-4 5 6 20 8 0.0035data4-5-5 5 6 20 16 0.0403data4-5-6 5 6 20 13 0.0035data4-5-7 5 6 20 11 0.0037data4-5-8 5 6 20 15 0.0039data4-5-9 5 6 20 12 0.0040data4-5-10 5 6 20 10 0.0037data4-5-11 5 6 20 9 0.0037data4-5-12 5 6 20 11 0.0034data4-5-13 5 6 20 9 0.0032data4-5-14 5 6 20 14 0.0031data4-5-15 5 6 20 15 0.0251data4-5-16 5 6 20 13 0.0032data4-5-17 5 6 20 17 0.0297data4-5-18 5 6 20 12 0.0034data4-5-19 5 6 20 14 0.0125data4-5-20 5 6 20 14 0.0037data4-5-21 5 6 20 15 0.0042data4-5-22 5 6 20 15 0.0044data4-5-23 5 6 20 15 0.0034data4-5-24 5 6 20 16 0.0207data4-5-25 5 6 20 11 0.0036data4-5-26 5 6 20 14 0.0046data4-5-27 5 6 20 10 0.0035data4-5-28 5 6 20 9 0.0034data4-5-29 5 6 20 13 0.0037data4-5-30 5 6 20 17 0.0049data4-5-31 5 6 20 13 0.0037data4-5-32 5 6 20 10 0.0040data4-5-33 5 6 20 13 0.0482data4-5-34 5 6 20 16 0.0047data4-5-35 5 6 20 15 0.0334data4-5-36 5 6 20 11 0.0077data4-5-37 5 6 20 14 0.0042data4-5-38 5 6 20 14 0.0052data4-5-39 5 6 20 14 0.0077data4-5-40 5 6 20 11 0.0038data4-6-1 6 6 24 17 0.3471data4-6-2 6 6 24 8 0.0041data4-6-3 6 6 24 13 0.0038data4-6-4 6 6 24 14 0.0041data4-6-5 6 6 24 15 0.0049data4-6-6 6 6 24 16 0.0039data4-6-7 6 6 24 14 0.0059data4-6-8 6 6 24 12 0.0198data4-6-9 6 6 24 13 0.0114data4-6-10 6 6 24 17 0.0907data4-6-11 6 6 24 14 0.0043data4-6-12 6 6 24 13 0.0040data4-6-13 6 6 24 14 0.0045data4-6-14 6 6 24 11 0.0042data4-6-15 6 6 24 15 0.0464data4-6-16 6 6 24 10 0.0040data4-6-17 6 6 24 16 0.0039data4-6-18 6 6 24 16 0.0043data4-6-19 6 6 24 14 0.0043data4-6-20 6 6 24 11 0.0041data4-6-21 6 6 24 14 0.0051data4-6-22 6 6 24 10 0.0071data4-6-23 6 6 24 9 0.0049data4-6-24 6 6 24 17 0.0041data4-6-25 6 6 24 18 0.0078data4-6-26 6 6 24 13 0.0040data4-6-27 6 6 24 14 0.0475data4-6-28 6 6 24 18 0.1719data4-6-29 6 6 24 14 0.0047data4-6-30 6 6 24 15 0.0680

Table 5: Computational results on the set group 4

Page 81: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-6-31 6 6 24 8 0.0044data4-6-32 6 6 24 15 0.0098data4-6-33 6 6 24 15 0.0054data4-6-34 6 6 24 15 0.0039data4-6-35 6 6 24 16 0.0870data4-6-36 6 6 24 17 0.1213data4-6-37 6 6 24 15 0.0039data4-6-38 6 6 24 14 0.0119data4-6-39 6 6 24 14 0.0082data4-6-40 6 6 24 17 0.1700data4-7-1 7 6 28 17 0.0047data4-7-2 7 6 28 18 0.0329data4-7-3 7 6 28 13 0.0053data4-7-4 7 6 28 16 0.0059data4-7-5 7 6 28 16 0.0718data4-7-6 7 6 28 21 0.0246data4-7-7 7 6 28 18 0.0584data4-7-8 7 6 28 16 0.0049data4-7-9 7 6 28 17 0.0047data4-7-10 7 6 28 13 0.0051data4-7-11 7 6 28 16 0.1708data4-7-12 7 6 28 16 0.0048data4-7-13 7 6 28 15 0.0046data4-7-14 7 6 28 20 0.3344data4-7-15 7 6 28 15 0.0077data4-7-16 7 6 28 12 0.0052data4-7-17 7 6 28 10 0.0050data4-7-18 7 6 28 19 0.0053data4-7-19 7 6 28 14 0.0052data4-7-20 7 6 28 17 0.0086data4-7-21 7 6 28 18 0.0058data4-7-22 7 6 28 17 0.0048data4-7-23 7 6 28 11 0.0050data4-7-24 7 6 28 16 0.0106data4-7-25 7 6 28 16 0.1152data4-7-26 7 6 28 17 0.0734data4-7-27 7 6 28 14 0.0092data4-7-28 7 6 28 22 0.1625data4-7-29 7 6 28 14 0.0051data4-7-30 7 6 28 13 0.0056data4-7-31 7 6 28 22 0.1325data4-7-32 7 6 28 19 0.0808data4-7-33 7 6 28 18 0.1732data4-7-34 7 6 28 14 0.0051data4-7-35 7 6 28 20 0.2356data4-7-36 7 6 28 16 0.0061data4-7-37 7 6 28 17 0.0101data4-7-38 7 6 28 13 0.0049data4-7-39 7 6 28 14 0.0049data4-7-40 7 6 28 15 0.0192data5-4-1 4 7 20 15 0.0064data5-4-2 4 7 20 19 0.0049data5-4-3 4 7 20 15 0.0080data5-4-4 4 7 20 12 0.0040data5-4-5 4 7 20 17 0.0055data5-4-6 4 7 20 14 0.0044data5-4-7 4 7 20 12 0.0044data5-4-8 4 7 20 20 0.0140data5-4-9 4 7 20 15 0.0041data5-4-10 4 7 20 11 0.0037data5-4-11 4 7 20 13 0.0037data5-4-12 4 7 20 19 0.0066data5-4-13 4 7 20 19 0.0036data5-4-14 4 7 20 16 0.0069data5-4-15 4 7 20 12 0.0037data5-4-16 4 7 20 17 0.0079data5-4-17 4 7 20 20 0.0253data5-4-18 4 7 20 7 0.0033data5-4-19 4 7 20 18 0.0032data5-4-20 4 7 20 17 0.0128

Table 6: Computational results on the set group 4

Page 82: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-4-21 4 7 20 18 0.0314data5-4-22 4 7 20 13 0.0043data5-4-23 4 7 20 9 0.0034data5-4-24 4 7 20 17 0.0051data5-4-25 4 7 20 8 0.0031data5-4-26 4 7 20 21 0.0231data5-4-27 4 7 20 14 0.0034data5-4-28 4 7 20 18 0.0048data5-4-29 4 7 20 19 0.1017data5-4-30 4 7 20 14 0.0032data5-4-31 4 7 20 11 0.0034data5-4-32 4 7 20 19 0.0064data5-4-33 4 7 20 14 0.0037data5-4-34 4 7 20 17 0.0031data5-4-35 4 7 20 15 0.0038data5-4-36 4 7 20 17 0.0033data5-4-37 4 7 20 13 0.0035data5-4-38 4 7 20 18 0.0098data5-4-39 4 7 20 18 0.0271data5-4-40 4 7 20 16 0.0038data5-5-1 5 7 25 22 0.0566data5-5-2 5 7 25 16 0.0381data5-5-3 5 7 25 22 0.0888data5-5-4 5 7 25 21 0.0857data5-5-5 5 7 25 16 0.0043data5-5-6 5 7 25 18 0.1412data5-5-7 5 7 25 19 0.0057data5-5-8 5 7 25 16 0.0052data5-5-9 5 7 25 12 0.0085data5-5-10 5 7 25 22 0.0040data5-5-11 5 7 25 22 0.1307data5-5-12 5 7 25 18 0.0350data5-5-13 5 7 25 19 0.0777data5-5-14 5 7 25 20 0.2089data5-5-15 5 7 25 21 0.1059data5-5-16 5 7 25 17 0.0143data5-5-17 5 7 25 21 0.0288data5-5-18 5 7 25 16 0.0077data5-5-19 5 7 25 21 0.0256data5-5-20 5 7 25 17 0.0062data5-5-21 5 7 25 17 0.0041data5-5-22 5 7 25 19 0.0118data5-5-23 5 7 25 17 0.0114data5-5-24 5 7 25 20 0.0121data5-5-25 5 7 25 19 0.1211data5-5-26 5 7 25 25 0.2232data5-5-27 5 7 25 19 0.0508data5-5-28 5 7 25 21 0.0041data5-5-29 5 7 25 21 0.0045data5-5-30 5 7 25 14 0.2354data5-5-31 5 7 25 24 0.3283data5-5-32 5 7 25 15 0.0058data5-5-33 5 7 25 22 0.1847data5-5-34 5 7 25 23 0.1490data5-5-35 5 7 25 17 0.0545data5-5-36 5 7 25 20 0.0094data5-5-37 5 7 25 17 0.0710data5-5-38 5 7 25 16 0.0102data5-5-39 5 7 25 15 0.0195data5-5-40 5 7 25 17 0.0048data5-6-1 6 7 30 26 0.4284data5-6-2 6 7 30 16 0.0057data5-6-3 6 7 30 24 0.3015data5-6-4 6 7 30 24 0.1698data5-6-5 6 7 30 23 0.0897data5-6-6 6 7 30 17 0.0087data5-6-7 6 7 30 20 0.2042data5-6-8 6 7 30 18 0.0050data5-6-9 6 7 30 25 0.2331data5-6-10 6 7 30 21 0.0064

Table 7: Computational results on the set group 4

Page 83: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-6-11 6 7 30 19 0.3409data5-6-12 6 7 30 22 0.0653data5-6-13 6 7 30 22 0.3719data5-6-14 6 7 30 20 0.0227data5-6-15 6 7 30 24 0.1126data5-6-16 6 7 30 24 0.0161data5-6-17 6 7 30 22 0.2462data5-6-18 6 7 30 26 0.1214data5-6-19 6 7 30 23 0.0684data5-6-20 6 7 30 20 0.0077data5-6-21 6 7 30 23 0.6360data5-6-22 6 7 30 20 0.0500data5-6-23 6 7 30 23 0.2531data5-6-24 6 7 30 21 0.0475data5-6-25 6 7 30 25 0.6854data5-6-26 6 7 30 26 0.0062data5-6-27 6 7 30 22 0.0858data5-6-28 6 7 30 23 0.1212data5-6-29 6 7 30 24 0.4746data5-6-30 6 7 30 16 0.0050data5-6-31 6 7 30 19 0.0056data5-6-32 6 7 30 24 0.1607data5-6-33 6 7 30 22 0.0052data5-6-34 6 7 30 24 0.1239data5-6-35 6 7 30 26 0.8603data5-6-36 6 7 30 23 0.2135data5-6-37 6 7 30 23 0.2010data5-6-38 6 7 30 24 0.0742data5-6-39 6 7 30 18 0.0056data5-6-40 6 7 30 21 0.0293data5-7-1 7 7 35 18 0.0065data5-7-2 7 7 35 24 0.2502data5-7-3 7 7 35 29 0.7802data5-7-4 7 7 35 22 0.0061data5-7-5 7 7 35 28 0.6352data5-7-6 7 7 35 23 0.7820data5-7-7 7 7 35 17 0.0058data5-7-8 7 7 35 25 0.0890data5-7-9 7 7 35 18 0.0066data5-7-10 7 7 35 25 0.5543data5-7-11 7 7 35 25 0.4982data5-7-12 7 7 35 25 0.2101data5-7-13 7 7 35 28 0.5865data5-7-14 7 7 35 23 0.0062data5-7-15 7 7 35 24 0.0191data5-7-16 7 7 35 23 0.0699data5-7-17 7 7 35 26 0.3692data5-7-18 7 7 35 27 1.0207data5-7-19 7 7 35 24 0.1361data5-7-20 7 7 35 29 0.3814data5-7-21 7 7 35 28 0.5931data5-7-22 7 7 35 24 0.5407data5-7-23 7 7 35 24 0.0066data5-7-24 7 7 35 23 0.8851data5-7-25 7 7 35 23 0.1758data5-7-26 7 7 35 20 0.3043data5-7-27 7 7 35 26 0.1986data5-7-28 7 7 35 25 0.0061data5-7-29 7 7 35 23 0.0079data5-7-30 7 7 35 27 0.7891data5-7-31 7 7 35 22 0.0067data5-7-32 7 7 35 22 0.0063data5-7-33 7 7 35 24 0.2042data5-7-34 7 7 35 29 0.0626data5-7-35 7 7 35 24 0.0060data5-7-36 7 7 35 22 0.0532data5-7-37 7 7 35 21 0.5154data5-7-38 7 7 35 20 0.0058data5-7-39 7 7 35 30 1.0595data5-7-40 7 7 35 30 0.8966

Table 8: Computational results on the set group 4

Page 84: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-8-1 8 7 40 25 0.0032data5-8-2 8 7 40 23 0.1824data5-8-3 8 7 40 27 0.2630data5-8-4 8 7 40 27 0.3071data5-8-5 8 7 40 34 1.0360data5-8-6 8 7 40 30 0.6533data5-8-7 8 7 40 28 0.6423data5-8-8 8 7 40 25 0.2414data5-8-9 8 7 40 30 0.2998data5-8-10 8 7 40 29 0.5667data5-8-11 8 7 40 33 1.0263data5-8-12 8 7 40 30 0.9503data5-8-13 8 7 40 29 0.2066data5-8-14 8 7 40 27 0.1920data5-8-15 8 7 40 34 0.5539data5-8-16 8 7 40 29 0.8180data5-8-17 8 7 40 22 0.0174data5-8-18 8 7 40 31 0.9057data5-8-19 8 7 40 27 0.2283data5-8-20 8 7 40 28 0.1696data5-8-21 8 7 40 29 0.4766data5-8-22 8 7 40 33 0.4126data5-8-23 8 7 40 22 0.0029data5-8-24 8 7 40 24 0.0154data5-8-25 8 7 40 23 0.0577data5-8-26 8 7 40 27 0.7175data5-8-27 8 7 40 30 0.3071data5-8-28 8 7 40 27 0.0124data5-8-29 8 7 40 24 0.1400data5-8-30 8 7 40 30 0.2328data5-8-31 8 7 40 27 0.2477data5-8-32 8 7 40 27 0.3774data5-8-33 8 7 40 30 0.1971data5-8-34 8 7 40 28 0.0028data5-8-35 8 7 40 25 0.6388data5-8-36 8 7 40 24 0.5407data5-8-37 8 7 40 30 0.4958data5-8-38 8 7 40 29 0.5958data5-8-39 8 7 40 27 0.0026data5-8-40 8 7 40 26 0.0927data5-9-1 9 7 45 33 0.9698data5-9-2 9 7 45 29 1.0484data5-9-3 9 7 45 37 1.0814data5-9-4 9 7 45 28 0.0031data5-9-5 9 7 45 31 0.9931data5-9-6 9 7 45 31 1.0471data5-9-7 9 7 45 33 1.0623data5-9-8 9 7 45 27 0.0097data5-9-9 9 7 45 27 0.9503data5-9-10 9 7 45 31 0.0061data5-9-11 9 7 45 29 0.9811data5-9-12 9 7 45 23 0.0029data5-9-13 9 7 45 28 0.3438data5-9-14 9 7 45 33 0.8535data5-9-15 9 7 45 32 0.3990data5-9-16 9 7 45 31 0.0028data5-9-17 9 7 45 32 0.8708data5-9-18 9 7 45 28 0.5133data5-9-19 9 7 45 31 0.4126data5-9-20 9 7 45 25 0.0027data5-9-21 9 7 45 30 1.0419data5-9-22 9 7 45 33 1.0139data5-9-23 9 7 45 34 1.0469data5-9-24 9 7 45 27 0.0809data5-9-25 9 7 45 35 0.3824data5-9-26 9 7 45 31 0.0032data5-9-27 9 7 45 33 0.2424data5-9-28 9 7 45 31 1.0337data5-9-29 9 7 45 30 0.6505data5-9-30 9 7 45 32 1.0229

Table 9: Computational results on the set group 4

Page 85: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-9-31 9 7 45 31 1.0620data5-9-32 9 7 45 26 0.0047data5-9-33 9 7 45 35 0.4254data5-9-34 9 7 45 32 1.0756data5-9-35 9 7 45 28 0.7873data5-9-36 9 7 45 35 1.0123data5-9-37 9 7 45 22 0.0030data5-9-38 9 7 45 30 0.4553data5-9-39 9 7 45 35 1.0586data5-9-40 9 7 45 32 0.0030data5-10-1 10 7 50 35 0.4213data5-10-2 10 7 50 35 0.8598data5-10-3 10 7 50 39 1.0176data5-10-4 10 7 50 32 0.0389data5-10-5 10 7 50 34 1.0916data5-10-6 10 7 50 34 1.0714data5-10-7 10 7 50 35 0.6314data5-10-8 10 7 50 32 0.0031data5-10-9 10 7 50 33 1.0604data5-10-10 10 7 50 31 0.0031data5-10-11 10 7 50 34 1.0096data5-10-12 10 7 50 32 0.0035data5-10-13 10 7 50 31 0.3602data5-10-14 10 7 50 37 1.0508data5-10-15 10 7 50 36 1.0852data5-10-16 10 7 50 33 1.0151data5-10-17 10 7 50 37 1.0105data5-10-18 10 7 50 28 0.0585data5-10-19 10 7 50 32 0.4073data5-10-20 10 7 50 32 0.1534data5-10-21 10 7 50 30 1.0096data5-10-22 10 7 50 33 0.4707data5-10-23 10 7 50 32 0.8310data5-10-24 10 7 50 32 0.6196data5-10-25 10 7 50 35 1.0088data5-10-26 10 7 50 27 0.0030data5-10-27 10 7 50 38 1.0806data5-10-28 10 7 50 40 1.0082data5-10-29 10 7 50 40 1.0520data5-10-30 10 7 50 35 1.0470data5-10-31 10 7 50 34 1.0309data5-10-32 10 7 50 28 0.5634data5-10-33 10 7 50 35 0.9463data5-10-34 10 7 50 34 0.7528data5-10-35 10 7 50 29 0.2259data5-10-36 10 7 50 33 1.0732data5-10-37 10 7 50 33 0.5647data5-10-38 10 7 50 34 0.6297data5-10-39 10 7 50 32 0.4070data5-10-40 10 7 50 27 0.0036data6-6-1 6 8 36 29 0.3774data6-6-2 6 8 36 31 0.4048data6-6-3 6 8 36 34 1.0655data6-6-4 6 8 36 33 0.5053data6-6-5 6 8 36 30 0.5688data6-6-6 6 8 36 36 0.6186data6-6-7 6 8 36 32 0.7584data6-6-8 6 8 36 26 0.6566data6-6-9 6 8 36 27 0.1664data6-6-10 6 8 36 29 0.8893data6-6-11 6 8 36 32 1.0252data6-6-12 6 8 36 24 0.0032data6-6-13 6 8 36 28 0.3827data6-6-14 6 8 36 28 0.3666data6-6-15 6 8 36 34 0.6251data6-6-16 6 8 36 32 0.5639data6-6-17 6 8 36 29 0.5448data6-6-18 6 8 36 31 0.9525data6-6-19 6 8 36 31 0.3196data6-6-20 6 8 36 27 0.0529

Table 10: Computational results on the set group 4

Page 86: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-6-21 6 8 36 30 0.2075data6-6-22 6 8 36 31 0.5348data6-6-23 6 8 36 35 1.0173data6-6-24 6 8 36 31 0.2786data6-6-25 6 8 36 27 0.2155data6-6-26 6 8 36 31 0.4499data6-6-27 6 8 36 35 0.5338data6-6-28 6 8 36 26 0.5615data6-6-29 6 8 36 36 1.0167data6-6-30 6 8 36 37 0.5530data6-6-31 6 8 36 35 1.0411data6-6-32 6 8 36 25 0.0590data6-6-33 6 8 36 28 0.8740data6-6-34 6 8 36 32 0.4334data6-6-35 6 8 36 32 0.4626data6-6-36 6 8 36 30 0.7581data6-6-37 6 8 36 29 0.7049data6-6-38 6 8 36 28 0.4123data6-6-39 6 8 36 36 0.6788data6-6-40 6 8 36 40 0.9999data6-10-1 10 8 60 50 1.0362data6-10-2 10 8 60 46 0.5467data6-10-3 10 8 60 47 1.0232data6-10-4 10 8 60 43 1.0152data6-10-5 10 8 60 45 0.9832data6-10-6 10 8 60 46 0.8699data6-10-7 10 8 60 53 1.0138data6-10-8 10 8 60 52 1.0166data6-10-9 10 8 60 40 1.0141data6-10-10 10 8 60 44 0.7378data6-10-11 10 8 60 44 0.9315data6-10-12 10 8 60 41 0.4056data6-10-13 10 8 60 42 0.6249data6-10-14 10 8 60 43 0.7403data6-10-15 10 8 60 51 1.0165data6-10-16 10 8 60 42 0.7366data6-10-17 10 8 60 46 1.0096data6-10-18 10 8 60 48 1.0118data6-10-19 10 8 60 51 1.0108data6-10-20 10 8 60 45 1.0306data6-10-21 10 8 60 46 1.0323data6-10-22 10 8 60 53 1.0268data6-10-23 10 8 60 44 0.3256data6-10-24 10 8 60 48 1.0403data6-10-25 10 8 60 43 0.8138data6-10-26 10 8 60 36 0.4763data6-10-27 10 8 60 44 0.6701data6-10-28 10 8 60 52 1.0272data6-10-29 10 8 60 46 0.8134data6-10-30 10 8 60 45 1.0119data6-10-31 10 8 60 48 0.0020data6-10-32 10 8 60 54 1.0240data6-10-33 10 8 60 48 0.9193data6-10-34 10 8 60 45 1.0214data6-10-35 10 8 60 36 0.0021data6-10-36 10 8 60 48 0.9838data6-10-37 10 8 60 45 0.7924data6-10-38 10 8 60 42 1.0233data6-10-39 10 8 60 50 1.0229data6-10-40 10 8 60 48 0.6288data10-6-1 6 12 60 90 1.0097data10-6-2 6 12 60 63 0.6065data10-6-3 6 12 60 81 0.8263data10-6-4 6 12 60 83 0.5325data10-6-5 6 12 60 72 0.8160data10-6-6 6 12 60 76 0.7718data10-6-7 6 12 60 85 0.9553data10-6-8 6 12 60 81 0.7132data10-6-9 6 12 60 82 0.8355data10-6-10 6 12 60 90 1.0229

Table 11: Computational results on the set group 4

Page 87: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-6-11 6 12 60 64 0.6462data10-6-12 6 12 60 83 0.9316data10-6-13 6 12 60 78 0.8799data10-6-14 6 12 60 76 0.7207data10-6-15 6 12 60 67 0.6662data10-6-16 6 12 60 67 0.7115data10-6-17 6 12 60 75 0.5500data10-6-18 6 12 60 71 0.7996data10-6-19 6 12 60 75 0.8822data10-6-20 6 12 60 84 0.8637data10-6-21 6 12 60 67 0.6908data10-6-22 6 12 60 62 0.6778data10-6-23 6 12 60 60 0.5603data10-6-24 6 12 60 82 0.6374data10-6-25 6 12 60 82 0.9989data10-6-26 6 12 60 72 0.8148data10-6-27 6 12 60 86 1.0261data10-6-28 6 12 60 76 0.7187data10-6-29 6 12 60 80 0.7414data10-6-30 6 12 60 67 0.4919data10-6-31 6 12 60 84 0.8370data10-6-32 6 12 60 88 1.0345data10-6-33 6 12 60 77 0.7251data10-6-34 6 12 60 105 1.0222data10-6-35 6 12 60 83 0.7803data10-6-36 6 12 60 88 1.0055data10-6-37 6 12 60 65 0.7571data10-6-38 6 12 60 83 1.0183data10-6-39 6 12 60 61 0.4311data10-6-40 6 12 60 81 0.8080data10-10-1 10 12 100 108 0.8049data10-10-2 10 12 100 105 0.8814data10-10-3 10 12 100 100 0.8105data10-10-4 10 12 100 108 0.8314data10-10-5 10 12 100 120 1.0077data10-10-6 10 12 100 110 0.7931data10-10-7 10 12 100 117 1.0104data10-10-8 10 12 100 115 0.9620data10-10-9 10 12 100 118 1.0078data10-10-10 10 12 100 107 0.8979data10-10-11 10 12 100 105 0.7289data10-10-12 10 12 100 125 1.0067data10-10-13 10 12 100 92 0.8125data10-10-14 10 12 100 109 0.9281data10-10-15 10 12 100 116 1.0049data10-10-16 10 12 100 116 1.0043data10-10-17 10 12 100 138 1.0055data10-10-18 10 12 100 109 0.9073data10-10-19 10 12 100 112 0.9642data10-10-20 10 12 100 118 1.0061data10-10-21 10 12 100 111 0.8763data10-10-22 10 12 100 113 0.9945data10-10-23 10 12 100 105 0.8977data10-10-24 10 12 100 109 0.9858data10-10-25 10 12 100 117 0.9204data10-10-26 10 12 100 131 1.0037data10-10-27 10 12 100 118 0.8666data10-10-28 10 12 100 115 1.0072data10-10-29 10 12 100 115 0.9708data10-10-30 10 12 100 112 0.6478data10-10-31 10 12 100 118 1.0053data10-10-32 10 12 100 104 0.9300data10-10-33 10 12 100 118 0.9483data10-10-34 10 12 100 114 0.9810data10-10-35 10 12 100 111 0.8065data10-10-36 10 12 100 98 0.7488data10-10-37 10 12 100 111 1.0036data10-10-38 10 12 100 111 1.0074data10-10-39 10 12 100 108 0.6913data10-10-40 10 12 100 112 1.0083

Table 12: Computational results on the set group 4

Page 88: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata100-100-1 100 102 10000 64947 1.1701data100-100-2 100 102 10000 63219 1.1347data100-100-3 100 102 10000 62206 1.0855data100-100-4 100 102 10000 61839 1.0820data100-100-5 100 102 10000 62356 1.0872data100-100-6 100 102 10000 63167 1.1317data100-100-7 100 102 10000 62012 1.1037data100-100-8 100 102 10000 59952 1.0627data100-100-9 100 102 10000 61703 1.0943data100-100-10 100 102 10000 63032 1.1243data100-100-11 100 102 10000 60804 1.1085data100-100-12 100 102 10000 62062 1.1092data100-100-13 100 102 10000 62458 1.1568data100-100-14 100 102 10000 60899 1.1052data100-100-15 100 102 10000 62114 1.0806data100-100-16 100 102 10000 61327 1.1050data100-100-17 100 102 10000 63585 1.1374data100-100-18 100 102 10000 62181 1.1126data100-100-19 100 102 10000 62178 1.1502data100-100-20 100 102 10000 61998 1.0975data100-100-21 100 102 10000 60510 1.0593data100-100-22 100 102 10000 62889 1.1009data100-100-23 100 102 10000 65178 1.1443data100-100-24 100 102 10000 62092 1.0991data100-100-25 100 102 10000 62797 1.0906data100-100-26 100 102 10000 62826 1.1305data100-100-27 100 102 10000 64264 1.2031data100-100-28 100 102 10000 62214 1.1075data100-100-29 100 102 10000 63182 1.1033data100-100-30 100 102 10000 61062 1.0903data100-100-31 100 102 10000 64250 1.1677data100-100-32 100 102 10000 63578 1.1133data100-100-33 100 102 10000 64049 1.1361data100-100-34 100 102 10000 63129 1.1341data100-100-35 100 102 10000 61737 1.0840data100-100-36 100 102 10000 62810 1.1017data100-100-37 100 102 10000 61720 1.0907data100-100-38 100 102 10000 59189 1.0487data100-100-39 100 102 10000 61229 1.0713data100-100-40 100 102 10000 63787 1.1344

Table 13: Computational results on the set group 4

Page 89: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

6 group 5

Page 90: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb435510 3 4 6 1 0.0012b435511 3 4 6 2 0.0010b435512 3 4 6 0 0.0012b435513 3 4 6 0 0.0012b435514 3 4 6 2 0.0012b435515 3 4 6 1 0.0012b435516 3 4 6 0 0.0011b435517 3 4 6 2 0.0012b435518 3 4 6 1 0.0011b435519 3 4 6 0 0.0011b435520 3 4 6 4 0.0011b435521 3 4 6 0 0.0011b435522 3 4 6 1 0.0012b435523 3 4 6 1 0.0011b435524 3 4 6 2 0.0011b435525 3 4 6 1 0.0011b435526 3 4 6 0 0.0011b435527 3 4 6 1 0.0011b435528 3 4 6 4 0.0011b435529 3 4 6 0 0.0011b435530 3 4 6 2 0.0013b435531 3 4 6 2 0.0012b435532 3 4 6 3 0.0012b435533 3 4 6 1 0.0012b435534 3 4 6 3 0.0012b435535 3 4 6 3 0.0012b435536 3 4 6 2 0.0012b435537 3 4 6 0 0.0011b435538 3 4 6 3 0.0012b435539 3 4 6 2 0.0011b435540 3 4 6 0 0.0011b435541 3 4 6 1 0.0012b435542 3 4 6 3 0.0011b435543 3 4 6 2 0.0011b435544 3 4 6 0 0.0011b435545 3 4 6 2 0.0011b435546 3 4 6 0 0.0011b435547 3 4 6 1 0.0012b435548 3 4 6 2 0.0012b435549 3 4 6 2 0.0012b436010 3 4 7 4 0.0012b436011 3 4 7 3 0.0013b436012 3 4 7 2 0.0014b436013 3 4 7 3 0.0014b436014 3 4 7 4 0.0014b436015 3 4 7 1 0.0013b436016 3 4 7 5 0.0013b436017 3 4 7 2 0.0013b436018 3 4 7 3 0.0012b436019 3 4 7 1 0.0012b436020 3 4 7 2 0.0013b436021 3 4 7 0 0.0013b436022 3 4 7 3 0.0013b436023 3 4 7 1 0.0012b436024 3 4 7 4 0.0013b436025 3 4 7 4 0.0012b436026 3 4 7 2 0.0012b436027 3 4 7 5 0.0012b436028 3 4 7 4 0.0013b436029 3 4 7 6 0.0013b436030 3 4 7 4 0.0012b436031 3 4 7 3 0.0013b436032 3 4 7 2 0.0013b436033 3 4 7 6 0.0012b436034 3 4 7 1 0.0014b436035 3 4 7 2 0.0013b436036 3 4 7 2 0.0013b436037 3 4 7 3 0.0013b436038 3 4 7 4 0.0012b436039 3 4 7 1 0.0013

Table 1: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 91: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb436040 3 4 7 3 0.0013b436041 3 4 7 6 0.0013b436042 3 4 7 2 0.0013b436043 3 4 7 3 0.0012b436044 3 4 7 5 0.0013b436045 3 4 7 3 0.0012b436046 3 4 7 4 0.0012b436047 3 4 7 2 0.0013b436048 3 4 7 3 0.0012b436049 3 4 7 3 0.0013b436510 3 4 7 5 0.0012b436511 3 4 7 0 0.0013b436512 3 4 7 4 0.0013b436513 3 4 7 3 0.0012b436514 3 4 7 1 0.0012b436515 3 4 7 3 0.0013b436516 3 4 7 4 0.0014b436517 3 4 7 1 0.0014b436518 3 4 7 3 0.0013b436519 3 4 7 2 0.0013b436520 3 4 7 1 0.0013b436521 3 4 7 3 0.0013b436522 3 4 7 3 0.0013b436523 3 4 7 0 0.0013b436524 3 4 7 4 0.0012b436525 3 4 7 4 0.0013b436526 3 4 7 3 0.0013b436527 3 4 7 3 0.0013b436528 3 4 7 1 0.0013b436529 3 4 7 2 0.0013b436530 3 4 7 3 0.0012b436531 3 4 7 4 0.0012b436532 3 4 7 1 0.0013b436533 3 4 7 5 0.0013b436534 3 4 7 2 0.0013b436535 3 4 7 1 0.0013b436536 3 4 7 3 0.0013b436537 3 4 7 4 0.0014b436538 3 4 7 4 0.0013b436539 3 4 7 2 0.0013b436540 3 4 7 2 0.0012b436541 3 4 7 4 0.0013b436542 3 4 7 3 0.0013b436543 3 4 7 5 0.0013b436544 3 4 7 3 0.0013b436545 3 4 7 4 0.0013b436546 3 4 7 4 0.0012b436547 3 4 7 2 0.0013b436548 3 4 7 1 0.0013b436549 3 4 7 5 0.0013b437010 3 4 8 3 0.0014b437011 3 4 8 5 0.0014b437012 3 4 8 2 0.0014b437013 3 4 8 4 0.0013b437014 3 4 8 4 0.0013b437015 3 4 8 2 0.0014b437016 3 4 8 5 0.0014b437017 3 4 8 0 0.0014b437018 3 4 8 7 0.0015b437019 3 4 8 5 0.0015b437020 3 4 8 5 0.0014b437021 3 4 8 7 0.0014b437022 3 4 8 4 0.0014b437023 3 4 8 5 0.0014b437024 3 4 8 4 0.0013b437025 3 4 8 4 0.0014b437026 3 4 8 4 0.0013b437027 3 4 8 4 0.0014b437028 3 4 8 5 0.0014b437029 3 4 8 3 0.0014

Table 2: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 92: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb437030 3 4 8 5 0.0014b437031 3 4 8 1 0.0013b437032 3 4 8 4 0.0013b437033 3 4 8 4 0.0013b437034 3 4 8 6 0.0014b437035 3 4 8 2 0.0014b437036 3 4 8 1 0.0014b437037 3 4 8 2 0.0014b437038 3 4 8 3 0.0014b437039 3 4 8 1 0.0015b437040 3 4 8 5 0.0015b437041 3 4 8 5 0.0014b437042 3 4 8 2 0.0014b437043 3 4 8 2 0.0014b437044 3 4 8 6 0.0014b437045 3 4 8 6 0.0015b437046 3 4 8 2 0.0014b437047 3 4 8 8 0.0013b437048 3 4 8 6 0.0013b437049 3 4 8 6 0.0013b437510 3 4 9 4 0.0015b437511 3 4 9 2 0.0015b437512 3 4 9 4 0.0015b437513 3 4 9 6 0.0015b437514 3 4 9 4 0.0015b437515 3 4 9 2 0.0015b437516 3 4 9 5 0.0015b437517 3 4 9 6 0.0014b437518 3 4 9 4 0.0016b437519 3 4 9 5 0.0015b437520 3 4 9 6 0.0015b437521 3 4 9 8 0.0015b437522 3 4 9 6 0.0015b437523 3 4 9 9 0.0014b437524 3 4 9 6 0.0015b437525 3 4 9 4 0.0014b437526 3 4 9 1 0.0015b437527 3 4 9 6 0.0015b437528 3 4 9 5 0.0014b437529 3 4 9 1 0.0014b437530 3 4 9 9 0.0014b437531 3 4 9 4 0.0014b437532 3 4 9 5 0.0015b437533 3 4 9 6 0.0015b437534 3 4 9 5 0.0015b437535 3 4 9 5 0.0014b437536 3 4 9 6 0.0014b437537 3 4 9 3 0.0015b437538 3 4 9 4 0.0016b437539 3 4 9 3 0.0016b437540 3 4 9 7 0.0015b437541 3 4 9 8 0.0015b437542 3 4 9 6 0.0014b437543 3 4 9 8 0.0014b437544 3 4 9 8 0.0015b437545 3 4 9 2 0.0015b437546 3 4 9 5 0.0015b437547 3 4 9 9 0.0014b437548 3 4 9 8 0.0014b437549 3 4 9 4 0.0014b445510 4 4 8 3 0.0014b445511 4 4 8 2 0.0015b445512 4 4 8 3 0.0014b445513 4 4 8 2 0.0015b445514 4 4 8 3 0.0014b445515 4 4 8 3 0.0014b445516 4 4 8 2 0.0015b445517 4 4 8 1 0.0016b445518 4 4 8 4 0.0015b445519 4 4 8 4 0.0016

Table 3: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 93: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb445520 4 4 8 4 0.0015b445521 4 4 8 3 0.0014b445522 4 4 8 4 0.0015b445523 4 4 8 2 0.0015b445524 4 4 8 1 0.0014b445525 4 4 8 0 0.0014b445526 4 4 8 3 0.0014b445527 4 4 8 1 0.0014b445528 4 4 8 0 0.0015b445529 4 4 8 1 0.0015b445530 4 4 8 1 0.0015b445531 4 4 8 1 0.0014b445532 4 4 8 0 0.0014b445533 4 4 8 2 0.0014b445534 4 4 8 3 0.0014b445535 4 4 8 4 0.0015b445536 4 4 8 4 0.0014b445537 4 4 8 3 0.0017b445538 4 4 8 2 0.0015b445539 4 4 8 2 0.0016b445540 4 4 8 5 0.0014b445541 4 4 8 3 0.0015b445542 4 4 8 1 0.0015b445543 4 4 8 2 0.0015b445544 4 4 8 3 0.0015b445545 4 4 8 1 0.0014b445546 4 4 8 3 0.0015b445547 4 4 8 1 0.0015b445548 4 4 8 2 0.0014b445549 4 4 8 4 0.0015b446010 4 4 9 3 0.0015b446011 4 4 9 4 0.0016b446012 4 4 9 6 0.0016b446013 4 4 9 3 0.0016b446014 4 4 9 4 0.0016b446015 4 4 9 1 0.0016b446016 4 4 9 3 0.0017b446017 4 4 9 3 0.0016b446018 4 4 9 4 0.0016b446019 4 4 9 3 0.0015b446020 4 4 9 0 0.0016b446021 4 4 9 4 0.0016b446022 4 4 9 5 0.0016b446023 4 4 9 3 0.0016b446024 4 4 9 1 0.0015b446025 4 4 9 3 0.0015b446026 4 4 9 3 0.0015b446027 4 4 9 6 0.0016b446028 4 4 9 1 0.0016b446029 4 4 9 4 0.0016b446030 4 4 9 5 0.0015b446031 4 4 9 3 0.0015b446032 4 4 9 3 0.0015b446033 4 4 9 3 0.0015b446034 4 4 9 2 0.0018b446035 4 4 9 1 0.0017b446036 4 4 9 2 0.0017b446037 4 4 9 3 0.0015b446038 4 4 9 3 0.0016b446039 4 4 9 2 0.0016b446040 4 4 9 3 0.0016b446041 4 4 9 4 0.0016b446042 4 4 9 4 0.0015b446043 4 4 9 2 0.0016b446044 4 4 9 2 0.0016b446045 4 4 9 2 0.0016b446046 4 4 9 2 0.0015b446047 4 4 9 4 0.0016b446048 4 4 9 1 0.0016b446049 4 4 9 7 0.0015

Table 4: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 94: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb446510 4 4 10 7 0.0016b446511 4 4 10 4 0.0017b446512 4 4 10 5 0.0018b446513 4 4 10 6 0.0017b446514 4 4 10 1 0.0018b446515 4 4 10 7 0.0017b446516 4 4 10 7 0.0017b446517 4 4 10 5 0.0016b446518 4 4 10 6 0.0017b446519 4 4 10 6 0.0016b446520 4 4 10 2 0.0017b446521 4 4 10 4 0.0017b446522 4 4 10 3 0.0017b446523 4 4 10 3 0.0016b446524 4 4 10 1 0.0017b446525 4 4 10 6 0.0016b446526 4 4 10 6 0.0017b446527 4 4 10 5 0.0016b446528 4 4 10 4 0.0019b446529 4 4 10 5 0.0018b446530 4 4 10 3 0.0018b446531 4 4 10 4 0.0016b446532 4 4 10 3 0.0017b446533 4 4 10 5 0.0016b446534 4 4 10 5 0.0017b446535 4 4 10 4 0.0016b446536 4 4 10 3 0.0016b446537 4 4 10 1 0.0017b446538 4 4 10 3 0.0016b446539 4 4 10 7 0.0016b446540 4 4 10 5 0.0017b446541 4 4 10 4 0.0017b446542 4 4 10 4 0.0016b446543 4 4 10 4 0.0017b446544 4 4 10 5 0.0016b446545 4 4 10 2 0.0018b446546 4 4 10 4 0.0018b446547 4 4 10 5 0.0018b446548 4 4 10 6 0.0017b446549 4 4 10 6 0.0017b447010 4 4 11 5 0.0018b447011 4 4 11 4 0.0018b447012 4 4 11 4 0.0019b447013 4 4 11 7 0.0018b447014 4 4 11 5 0.0017b447015 4 4 11 6 0.0018b447016 4 4 11 4 0.0018b447017 4 4 11 8 0.0021b447018 4 4 11 7 0.0018b447019 4 4 11 6 0.0018b447020 4 4 11 5 0.0020b447021 4 4 11 6 0.0019b447022 4 4 11 7 0.0020b447023 4 4 11 8 0.0019b447024 4 4 11 3 0.0018b447025 4 4 11 6 0.0018b447026 4 4 11 5 0.0018b447027 4 4 11 7 0.0017b447028 4 4 11 6 0.0018b447029 4 4 11 5 0.0018b447030 4 4 11 2 0.0018b447031 4 4 11 5 0.0018b447032 4 4 11 2 0.0017b447033 4 4 11 5 0.0017b447034 4 4 11 6 0.0017b447035 4 4 11 4 0.0017b447036 4 4 11 6 0.0020b447037 4 4 11 4 0.0019b447038 4 4 11 4 0.0018b447039 4 4 11 6 0.0017

Table 5: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 95: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb447040 4 4 11 5 0.0018b447041 4 4 11 2 0.0017b447042 4 4 11 3 0.0017b447043 4 4 11 6 0.0017b447044 4 4 11 3 0.0018b447045 4 4 11 4 0.0017b447046 4 4 11 5 0.0018b447047 4 4 11 6 0.0017b447048 4 4 11 5 0.0017b447049 4 4 11 3 0.0017b447510 4 4 12 5 0.0018b447511 4 4 12 5 0.0018b447512 4 4 12 5 0.0021b447513 4 4 12 5 0.0019b447514 4 4 12 6 0.0019b447515 4 4 12 5 0.0019b447516 4 4 12 5 0.0020b447517 4 4 12 5 0.0019b447518 4 4 12 5 0.0019b447519 4 4 12 5 0.0019b447520 4 4 12 6 0.0019b447521 4 4 12 6 0.0019b447522 4 4 12 5 0.0019b447523 4 4 12 7 0.0019b447524 4 4 12 8 0.0018b447525 4 4 12 8 0.0018b447526 4 4 12 8 0.0019b447527 4 4 12 10 0.0022b447528 4 4 12 5 0.0020b447529 4 4 12 6 0.0021b447530 4 4 12 5 0.0021b447531 4 4 12 6 0.0019b447532 4 4 12 9 0.0019b447533 4 4 12 8 0.0019b447534 4 4 12 9 0.0019b447535 4 4 12 8 0.0020b447536 4 4 12 7 0.0019b447537 4 4 12 5 0.0019b447538 4 4 12 3 0.0019b447539 4 4 12 7 0.0018b447540 4 4 12 6 0.0019b447541 4 4 12 5 0.0019b447542 4 4 12 7 0.0020b447543 4 4 12 5 0.0019b447544 4 4 12 4 0.0019b447545 4 4 12 7 0.0020b447546 4 4 12 9 0.0019b447547 4 4 12 5 0.0019b447548 4 4 12 4 0.0019b447549 4 4 12 4 0.0019b455510 5 4 11 4 0.0019b455511 5 4 11 4 0.0019b455512 5 4 11 6 0.0019b455513 5 4 11 3 0.0018b455514 5 4 11 2 0.0019b455515 5 4 11 5 0.0018b455516 5 4 11 4 0.0019b455517 5 4 11 3 0.0020b455518 5 4 11 1 0.0020b455519 5 4 11 7 0.0019b455520 5 4 11 2 0.0019b455521 5 4 11 4 0.0019b455522 5 4 11 6 0.0019b455523 5 4 11 3 0.0018b455524 5 4 11 4 0.0019b455525 5 4 11 7 0.0019b455526 5 4 11 3 0.0018b455527 5 4 11 3 0.0019b455528 5 4 11 3 0.0019b455529 5 4 11 3 0.0019

Table 6: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 96: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb455530 5 4 11 2 0.0019b455531 5 4 11 4 0.0019b455532 5 4 11 4 0.0020b455533 5 4 11 2 0.0019b455534 5 4 11 1 0.0019b455535 5 4 11 4 0.0019b455536 5 4 11 1 0.0018b455537 5 4 11 2 0.0019b455538 5 4 11 3 0.0019b455539 5 4 11 5 0.0020b455540 5 4 11 2 0.0020b455541 5 4 11 3 0.0019b455542 5 4 11 5 0.0019b455543 5 4 11 6 0.0021b455544 5 4 11 5 0.0019b455545 5 4 11 6 0.0019b455546 5 4 11 6 0.0019b455547 5 4 11 3 0.0020b455548 5 4 11 7 0.0020b455549 5 4 11 2 0.0019b456010 5 4 12 4 0.0020b456011 5 4 12 4 0.0020b456012 5 4 12 6 0.0019b456013 5 4 12 5 0.0019b456014 5 4 12 3 0.0020b456015 5 4 12 6 0.0019b456016 5 4 12 5 0.0020b456017 5 4 12 1 0.0020b456018 5 4 12 6 0.0020b456019 5 4 12 4 0.0020b456020 5 4 12 4 0.0019b456021 5 4 12 7 0.0021b456022 5 4 12 2 0.0022b456023 5 4 12 5 0.0021b456024 5 4 12 8 0.0022b456025 5 4 12 5 0.0020b456026 5 4 12 3 0.0020b456027 5 4 12 5 0.0020b456028 5 4 12 5 0.0020b456029 5 4 12 6 0.0020b456030 5 4 12 7 0.0019b456031 5 4 12 7 0.0020b456032 5 4 12 3 0.0019b456033 5 4 12 1 0.0020b456034 5 4 12 4 0.0020b456035 5 4 12 6 0.0020b456036 5 4 12 3 0.0021b456037 5 4 12 7 0.0021b456038 5 4 12 7 0.0020b456039 5 4 12 4 0.0020b456040 5 4 12 5 0.0020b456041 5 4 12 3 0.0019b456042 5 4 12 6 0.0020b456043 5 4 12 4 0.0019b456044 5 4 12 6 0.0020b456045 5 4 12 5 0.0020b456046 5 4 12 3 0.0020b456047 5 4 12 2 0.0019b456048 5 4 12 5 0.0020b456049 5 4 12 7 0.0020b456510 5 4 13 8 0.0022b456511 5 4 13 5 0.0023b456512 5 4 13 5 0.0022b456513 5 4 13 7 0.0021b456514 5 4 13 2 0.0021b456515 5 4 13 7 0.0021b456516 5 4 13 5 0.0021b456517 5 4 13 6 0.0020b456518 5 4 13 4 0.0021b456519 5 4 13 6 0.0021

Table 7: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 97: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb456520 5 4 13 5 0.0021b456521 5 4 13 5 0.0021b456522 5 4 13 6 0.0021b456523 5 4 13 3 0.0021b456524 5 4 13 4 0.0024b456525 5 4 13 8 0.0023b456526 5 4 13 2 0.0021b456527 5 4 13 7 0.0021b456528 5 4 13 5 0.0021b456529 5 4 13 6 0.0020b456530 5 4 13 5 0.0021b456531 5 4 13 3 0.0021b456532 5 4 13 2 0.0021b456533 5 4 13 5 0.0022b456534 5 4 13 4 0.0020b456535 5 4 13 8 0.0021b456536 5 4 13 4 0.0021b456537 5 4 13 7 0.0021b456538 5 4 13 5 0.0024b456539 5 4 13 8 0.0025b456540 5 4 13 3 0.0022b456541 5 4 13 6 0.0021b456542 5 4 13 7 0.0020b456543 5 4 13 4 0.0021b456544 5 4 13 8 0.0020b456545 5 4 13 7 0.0021b456546 5 4 13 7 0.0020b456547 5 4 13 3 0.0021b456548 5 4 13 2 0.0021b456549 5 4 13 5 0.0020b457010 5 4 14 8 0.0022b457011 5 4 14 9 0.0024b457012 5 4 14 5 0.0023b457013 5 4 14 5 0.0022b457014 5 4 14 6 0.0021b457015 5 4 14 5 0.0022b457016 5 4 14 8 0.0023b457017 5 4 14 10 0.0022b457018 5 4 14 4 0.0022b457019 5 4 14 4 0.0022b457020 5 4 14 7 0.0022b457021 5 4 14 6 0.0022b457022 5 4 14 5 0.0022b457023 5 4 14 6 0.0022b457024 5 4 14 3 0.0023b457025 5 4 14 7 0.0024b457026 5 4 14 6 0.0023b457027 5 4 14 7 0.0022b457028 5 4 14 6 0.0021b457029 5 4 14 2 0.0022b457030 5 4 14 7 0.0022b457031 5 4 14 4 0.0022b457032 5 4 14 6 0.0022b457033 5 4 14 9 0.0021b457034 5 4 14 9 0.0022b457035 5 4 14 3 0.0021b457036 5 4 14 8 0.0023b457037 5 4 14 9 0.0024b457038 5 4 14 8 0.0023b457039 5 4 14 12 0.0034b457040 5 4 14 4 0.0023b457041 5 4 14 5 0.0021b457042 5 4 14 5 0.0022b457043 5 4 14 5 0.0022b457044 5 4 14 7 0.0023b457045 5 4 14 4 0.0022b457046 5 4 14 3 0.0022b457047 5 4 14 8 0.0022b457048 5 4 14 9 0.0022b457049 5 4 14 7 0.0022

Table 8: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 98: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb457510 5 4 15 10 0.0025b457511 5 4 15 7 0.0025b457512 5 4 15 8 0.0025b457513 5 4 15 8 0.0024b457514 5 4 15 6 0.0023b457515 5 4 15 9 0.0022b457516 5 4 15 7 0.0023b457517 5 4 15 7 0.0022b457518 5 4 15 8 0.0023b457519 5 4 15 4 0.0024b457520 5 4 15 7 0.0023b457521 5 4 15 9 0.0024b457522 5 4 15 8 0.0026b457523 5 4 15 7 0.0025b457524 5 4 15 7 0.0022b457525 5 4 15 8 0.0024b457526 5 4 15 9 0.0024b457527 5 4 15 5 0.0022b457528 5 4 15 8 0.0023b457529 5 4 15 7 0.0022b457530 5 4 15 6 0.0022b457531 5 4 15 10 0.0023b457532 5 4 15 5 0.0024b457533 5 4 15 5 0.0023b457534 5 4 15 5 0.0026b457535 5 4 15 3 0.0025b457536 5 4 15 7 0.0024b457537 5 4 15 8 0.0024b457538 5 4 15 7 0.0023b457539 5 4 15 5 0.0023b457540 5 4 15 11 0.0023b457541 5 4 15 6 0.0022b457542 5 4 15 5 0.0023b457543 5 4 15 7 0.0023b457544 5 4 15 10 0.0023b457545 5 4 15 7 0.0023b457546 5 4 15 8 0.0024b457547 5 4 15 7 0.0024b457548 5 4 15 9 0.0025b457549 5 4 15 6 0.0024b465510 6 4 13 4 0.0021b465511 6 4 13 6 0.0021b465512 6 4 13 5 0.0022b465513 6 4 13 3 0.0020b465514 6 4 13 3 0.0022b465515 6 4 13 5 0.0021b465516 6 4 13 2 0.0021b465517 6 4 13 5 0.0021b465518 6 4 13 3 0.0021b465519 6 4 13 5 0.0022b465520 6 4 13 6 0.0025b465521 6 4 13 5 0.0023b465522 6 4 13 3 0.0023b465523 6 4 13 4 0.0022b465524 6 4 13 2 0.0022b465525 6 4 13 7 0.0021b465526 6 4 13 5 0.0022b465527 6 4 13 6 0.0022b465528 6 4 13 4 0.0021b465529 6 4 13 4 0.0021b465530 6 4 13 4 0.0021b465531 6 4 13 1 0.0022b465532 6 4 13 4 0.0022b465533 6 4 13 6 0.0024b465534 6 4 13 2 0.0023b465535 6 4 13 3 0.0022b465536 6 4 13 6 0.0021b465537 6 4 13 4 0.0022b465538 6 4 13 1 0.0021b465539 6 4 13 5 0.0021

Table 9: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 99: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb465540 6 4 13 3 0.0022b465541 6 4 13 5 0.0021b465542 6 4 13 3 0.0022b465543 6 4 13 2 0.0021b465544 6 4 13 5 0.0022b465545 6 4 13 4 0.0021b465546 6 4 13 3 0.0023b465547 6 4 13 3 0.0022b465548 6 4 13 7 0.0022b465549 6 4 13 3 0.0022b466010 6 4 14 3 0.0023b466011 6 4 14 4 0.0022b466012 6 4 14 4 0.0023b466013 6 4 14 3 0.0023b466014 6 4 14 6 0.0023b466015 6 4 14 6 0.0023b466016 6 4 14 8 0.0023b466017 6 4 14 3 0.0022b466018 6 4 14 6 0.0023b466019 6 4 14 7 0.0024b466020 6 4 14 4 0.0023b466021 6 4 14 7 0.0023b466022 6 4 14 5 0.0023b466023 6 4 14 4 0.0024b466024 6 4 14 4 0.0023b466025 6 4 14 4 0.0022b466026 6 4 14 3 0.0023b466027 6 4 14 5 0.0022b466028 6 4 14 4 0.0022b466029 6 4 14 4 0.0023b466030 6 4 14 8 0.0022b466031 6 4 14 5 0.0025b466032 6 4 14 5 0.0025b466033 6 4 14 3 0.0023b466034 6 4 14 5 0.0024b466035 6 4 14 5 0.0025b466036 6 4 14 5 0.0025b466037 6 4 14 6 0.0026b466038 6 4 14 6 0.0026b466039 6 4 14 5 0.0025b466040 6 4 14 3 0.0024b466041 6 4 14 6 0.0025b466042 6 4 14 6 0.0023b466043 6 4 14 5 0.0027b466044 6 4 14 5 0.0026b466045 6 4 14 4 0.0023b466046 6 4 14 6 0.0023b466047 6 4 14 3 0.0023b466048 6 4 14 3 0.0023b466049 6 4 14 4 0.0022b466510 6 4 15 5 0.0024b466511 6 4 15 7 0.0024b466512 6 4 15 4 0.0024b466513 6 4 15 5 0.0024b466514 6 4 15 5 0.0024b466515 6 4 15 5 0.0028b466516 6 4 15 5 0.0026b466517 6 4 15 6 0.0025b466518 6 4 15 5 0.0024b466519 6 4 15 6 0.0024b466520 6 4 15 5 0.0024b466521 6 4 15 5 0.0024b466522 6 4 15 7 0.0023b466523 6 4 15 8 0.0024b466524 6 4 15 5 0.0025b466525 6 4 15 5 0.0024b466526 6 4 15 7 0.0025b466527 6 4 15 5 0.0027b466528 6 4 15 5 0.0026b466529 6 4 15 4 0.0025

Table 10: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 100: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb466530 6 4 15 8 0.0025b466531 6 4 15 4 0.0026b466532 6 4 15 6 0.0025b466533 6 4 15 4 0.0024b466534 6 4 15 5 0.0024b466535 6 4 15 6 0.0024b466536 6 4 15 7 0.0025b466537 6 4 15 1 0.0025b466538 6 4 15 6 0.0026b466539 6 4 15 6 0.0025b466540 6 4 15 6 0.0025b466541 6 4 15 7 0.0024b466542 6 4 15 6 0.0024b466543 6 4 15 7 0.0024b466544 6 4 15 6 0.0025b466545 6 4 15 7 0.0025b466546 6 4 15 4 0.0024b466547 6 4 15 8 0.0023b466548 6 4 15 5 0.0024b466549 6 4 15 5 0.0024b467010 6 4 16 8 0.0027b467011 6 4 16 5 0.0026b467012 6 4 16 7 0.0027b467013 6 4 16 7 0.0027b467014 6 4 16 7 0.0025b467015 6 4 16 6 0.0025b467016 6 4 16 6 0.0025b467017 6 4 16 10 0.0028b467018 6 4 16 6 0.0026b467019 6 4 16 9 0.0025b467020 6 4 16 8 0.0025b467021 6 4 16 9 0.0028b467022 6 4 16 7 0.0027b467023 6 4 16 8 0.0027b467024 6 4 16 7 0.0027b467025 6 4 16 5 0.0025b467026 6 4 16 8 0.0027b467027 6 4 16 10 0.0025b467028 6 4 16 5 0.0025b467029 6 4 16 6 0.0026b467030 6 4 16 7 0.0026b467031 6 4 16 6 0.0025b467032 6 4 16 9 0.0026b467033 6 4 16 7 0.0026b467034 6 4 16 7 0.0027b467035 6 4 16 6 0.0027b467036 6 4 16 8 0.0024b467037 6 4 16 5 0.0025b467038 6 4 16 9 0.0025b467039 6 4 16 8 0.0025b467040 6 4 16 8 0.0025b467041 6 4 16 3 0.0025b467042 6 4 16 8 0.0025b467043 6 4 16 7 0.0025b467044 6 4 16 5 0.0026b467045 6 4 16 4 0.0026b467046 6 4 16 8 0.0026b467047 6 4 16 11 0.0028b467048 6 4 16 6 0.0025b467049 6 4 16 7 0.0025b467510 6 4 18 12 0.0036b467511 6 4 18 10 0.0027b467512 6 4 18 8 0.0027b467513 6 4 18 8 0.0028b467514 6 4 18 9 0.0029b467515 6 4 18 6 0.0028b467516 6 4 18 8 0.0028b467517 6 4 18 9 0.0028b467518 6 4 18 7 0.0028b467519 6 4 18 8 0.0027

Table 11: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 101: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb467520 6 4 18 8 0.0032b467521 6 4 18 11 0.0027b467522 6 4 18 11 0.0036b467523 6 4 18 13 0.0027b467524 6 4 18 12 0.0031b467525 6 4 18 7 0.0031b467526 6 4 18 11 0.0036b467527 6 4 18 4 0.0028b467528 6 4 18 6 0.0027b467529 6 4 18 6 0.0028b467530 6 4 18 10 0.0027b467531 6 4 18 10 0.0030b467532 6 4 18 6 0.0027b467533 6 4 18 9 0.0032b467534 6 4 18 8 0.0030b467535 6 4 18 7 0.0029b467536 6 4 18 5 0.0028b467537 6 4 18 10 0.0027b467538 6 4 18 11 0.0027b467539 6 4 18 8 0.0028b467540 6 4 18 10 0.0029b467541 6 4 18 9 0.0027b467542 6 4 18 11 0.0027b467543 6 4 18 7 0.0027b467544 6 4 18 10 0.0029b467545 6 4 18 9 0.0031b467546 6 4 18 9 0.0028b467547 6 4 18 10 0.0030b467548 6 4 18 7 0.0027b467549 6 4 18 10 0.0027b475510 7 4 15 5 0.0026b475511 7 4 15 4 0.0025b475512 7 4 15 5 0.0027b475513 7 4 15 5 0.0028b475514 7 4 15 5 0.0028b475515 7 4 15 3 0.0032b475516 7 4 15 4 0.0029b475517 7 4 15 3 0.0028b475518 7 4 15 5 0.0028b475519 7 4 15 5 0.0027b475520 7 4 15 4 0.0025b475521 7 4 15 3 0.0025b475522 7 4 15 4 0.0025b475523 7 4 15 1 0.0026b475524 7 4 15 3 0.0026b475525 7 4 15 4 0.0025b475526 7 4 15 6 0.0028b475527 7 4 15 6 0.0027b475528 7 4 15 2 0.0025b475529 7 4 15 7 0.0026b475530 7 4 15 4 0.0025b475531 7 4 15 6 0.0025b475532 7 4 15 3 0.0025b475533 7 4 15 6 0.0025b475534 7 4 15 3 0.0025b475535 7 4 15 6 0.0025b475536 7 4 15 7 0.0025b475537 7 4 15 4 0.0029b475538 7 4 15 5 0.0027b475539 7 4 15 7 0.0025b475540 7 4 15 2 0.0025b475541 7 4 15 4 0.0025b475542 7 4 15 5 0.0026b475543 7 4 15 5 0.0025b475544 7 4 15 2 0.0025b475545 7 4 15 7 0.0025b475546 7 4 15 6 0.0025b475547 7 4 15 4 0.0024b475548 7 4 15 3 0.0028b475549 7 4 15 5 0.0027

Table 12: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 102: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb476010 7 4 16 5 0.0028b476011 7 4 16 8 0.0026b476012 7 4 16 3 0.0026b476013 7 4 16 7 0.0026b476014 7 4 16 5 0.0026b476015 7 4 16 4 0.0027b476016 7 4 16 4 0.0026b476017 7 4 16 4 0.0026b476018 7 4 16 4 0.0026b476019 7 4 16 5 0.0028b476020 7 4 16 3 0.0027b476021 7 4 16 8 0.0028b476022 7 4 16 6 0.0027b476023 7 4 16 8 0.0026b476024 7 4 16 6 0.0026b476025 7 4 16 7 0.0026b476026 7 4 16 4 0.0026b476027 7 4 16 5 0.0027b476028 7 4 16 4 0.0026b476029 7 4 16 8 0.0026b476030 7 4 16 3 0.0028b476031 7 4 16 6 0.0027b476032 7 4 16 6 0.0028b476033 7 4 16 6 0.0028b476034 7 4 16 5 0.0027b476035 7 4 16 7 0.0026b476036 7 4 16 4 0.0026b476037 7 4 16 6 0.0026b476038 7 4 16 7 0.0026b476039 7 4 16 3 0.0027b476040 7 4 16 8 0.0026b476041 7 4 16 7 0.0028b476042 7 4 16 6 0.0026b476043 7 4 16 6 0.0027b476044 7 4 16 4 0.0026b476045 7 4 16 3 0.0026b476046 7 4 16 4 0.0026b476047 7 4 16 7 0.0026b476048 7 4 16 8 0.0026b476049 7 4 16 6 0.0026b476510 7 4 18 6 0.0029b476511 7 4 18 8 0.0030b476512 7 4 18 6 0.0031b476513 7 4 18 10 0.0030b476514 7 4 18 7 0.0029b476515 7 4 18 8 0.0028b476516 7 4 18 11 0.0029b476517 7 4 18 9 0.0029b476518 7 4 18 4 0.0028b476519 7 4 18 11 0.0028b476520 7 4 18 7 0.0028b476521 7 4 18 9 0.0030b476522 7 4 18 7 0.0031b476523 7 4 18 10 0.0030b476524 7 4 18 8 0.0029b476525 7 4 18 10 0.0034b476526 7 4 18 7 0.0029b476527 7 4 18 6 0.0028b476528 7 4 18 3 0.0028b476529 7 4 18 6 0.0028b476530 7 4 18 8 0.0028b476531 7 4 18 6 0.0032b476532 7 4 18 8 0.0030b476533 7 4 18 6 0.0030b476534 7 4 18 5 0.0029b476535 7 4 18 7 0.0028b476536 7 4 18 7 0.0030b476537 7 4 18 9 0.0029b476538 7 4 18 6 0.0028b476539 7 4 18 6 0.0028

Table 13: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 103: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb476540 7 4 18 5 0.0028b476541 7 4 18 7 0.0032b476542 7 4 18 8 0.0033b476543 7 4 18 5 0.0030b476544 7 4 18 8 0.0029b476545 7 4 18 9 0.0028b476546 7 4 18 6 0.0030b476547 7 4 18 8 0.0031b476548 7 4 18 7 0.0028b476549 7 4 18 10 0.0029b477010 7 4 19 5 0.0032b477011 7 4 19 10 0.0032b477012 7 4 19 7 0.0032b477013 7 4 19 6 0.0030b477014 7 4 19 7 0.0030b477015 7 4 19 8 0.0030b477016 7 4 19 5 0.0031b477017 7 4 19 6 0.0030b477018 7 4 19 5 0.0030b477019 7 4 19 11 0.0030b477020 7 4 19 7 0.0034b477021 7 4 19 8 0.0032b477022 7 4 19 5 0.0033b477023 7 4 19 6 0.0030b477024 7 4 19 6 0.0030b477025 7 4 19 7 0.0030b477026 7 4 19 6 0.0030b477027 7 4 19 8 0.0030b477028 7 4 19 5 0.0029b477029 7 4 19 8 0.0032b477030 7 4 19 9 0.0034b477031 7 4 19 7 0.0035b477032 7 4 19 9 0.0031b477033 7 4 19 7 0.0030b477034 7 4 19 4 0.0030b477035 7 4 19 7 0.0031b477036 7 4 19 10 0.0030b477037 7 4 19 11 0.0029b477038 7 4 19 9 0.0030b477039 7 4 19 6 0.0033b477040 7 4 19 6 0.0032b477041 7 4 19 8 0.0032b477042 7 4 19 9 0.0030b477043 7 4 19 12 0.0029b477044 7 4 19 9 0.0031b477045 7 4 19 8 0.0031b477046 7 4 19 4 0.0032b477047 7 4 19 6 0.0031b477048 7 4 19 5 0.0034b477049 7 4 19 7 0.0034b477510 7 4 21 11 0.0039b477511 7 4 21 11 0.0033b477512 7 4 21 11 0.0037b477513 7 4 21 6 0.0033b477514 7 4 21 5 0.0034b477515 7 4 21 8 0.0032b477516 7 4 21 8 0.0033b477517 7 4 21 10 0.0038b477518 7 4 21 7 0.0037b477519 7 4 21 12 0.0041b477520 7 4 21 6 0.0034b477521 7 4 21 5 0.0032b477522 7 4 21 10 0.0035b477523 7 4 21 11 0.0049b477524 7 4 21 9 0.0035b477525 7 4 21 12 0.0038b477526 7 4 21 8 0.0036b477527 7 4 21 10 0.0034b477528 7 4 21 8 0.0032b477529 7 4 21 10 0.0033

Table 14: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 104: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb477530 7 4 21 10 0.0035b477531 7 4 21 4 0.0034b477532 7 4 21 9 0.0033b477533 7 4 21 7 0.0035b477534 7 4 21 11 0.0064b477535 7 4 21 11 0.0032b477536 7 4 21 13 0.0067b477537 7 4 21 10 0.0033b477538 7 4 21 13 0.0033b477539 7 4 21 8 0.0034b477540 7 4 21 13 0.0037b477541 7 4 21 11 0.0034b477542 7 4 21 10 0.0034b477543 7 4 21 6 0.0033b477544 7 4 21 9 0.0033b477545 7 4 21 5 0.0033b477546 7 4 21 7 0.0033b477547 7 4 21 10 0.0033b477548 7 4 21 10 0.0034b477549 7 4 21 10 0.0036b535510 3 5 8 4 0.0013b535511 3 5 8 6 0.0013b535512 3 5 8 6 0.0013b535513 3 5 8 3 0.0013b535514 3 5 8 4 0.0014b535515 3 5 8 2 0.0014b535516 3 5 8 3 0.0013b535517 3 5 8 4 0.0013b535518 3 5 8 4 0.0013b535519 3 5 8 2 0.0014b535520 3 5 8 3 0.0013b535521 3 5 8 4 0.0013b535522 3 5 8 4 0.0014b535523 3 5 8 6 0.0013b535524 3 5 8 4 0.0013b535525 3 5 8 3 0.0013b535526 3 5 8 6 0.0013b535527 3 5 8 5 0.0015b535528 3 5 8 5 0.0015b535529 3 5 8 3 0.0015b535530 3 5 8 3 0.0014b535531 3 5 8 4 0.0013b535532 3 5 8 3 0.0014b535533 3 5 8 5 0.0014b535534 3 5 8 5 0.0013b535535 3 5 8 1 0.0013b535536 3 5 8 5 0.0013b535537 3 5 8 1 0.0014b535538 3 5 8 3 0.0013b535539 3 5 8 5 0.0013b535540 3 5 8 3 0.0013b535541 3 5 8 4 0.0014b535542 3 5 8 3 0.0013b535543 3 5 8 2 0.0013b535544 3 5 8 5 0.0013b535545 3 5 8 5 0.0014b535546 3 5 8 4 0.0013b535547 3 5 8 3 0.0014b535548 3 5 8 4 0.0016b535549 3 5 8 3 0.0014b536010 3 5 9 5 0.0016b536011 3 5 9 7 0.0014b536012 3 5 9 6 0.0014b536013 3 5 9 6 0.0014b536014 3 5 9 5 0.0014b536015 3 5 9 6 0.0014b536016 3 5 9 7 0.0015b536017 3 5 9 4 0.0015b536018 3 5 9 6 0.0015b536019 3 5 9 4 0.0014

Table 15: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 105: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb536020 3 5 9 2 0.0014b536021 3 5 9 6 0.0014b536022 3 5 9 6 0.0015b536023 3 5 9 6 0.0015b536024 3 5 9 5 0.0014b536025 3 5 9 4 0.0014b536026 3 5 9 6 0.0014b536027 3 5 9 3 0.0015b536028 3 5 9 5 0.0015b536029 3 5 9 9 0.0015b536030 3 5 9 3 0.0015b536031 3 5 9 3 0.0015b536032 3 5 9 5 0.0015b536033 3 5 9 6 0.0015b536034 3 5 9 6 0.0015b536035 3 5 9 5 0.0014b536036 3 5 9 6 0.0014b536037 3 5 9 4 0.0014b536038 3 5 9 6 0.0014b536039 3 5 9 3 0.0015b536040 3 5 9 5 0.0015b536041 3 5 9 9 0.0015b536042 3 5 9 6 0.0015b536043 3 5 9 6 0.0014b536044 3 5 9 9 0.0015b536045 3 5 9 3 0.0015b536046 3 5 9 7 0.0014b536047 3 5 9 3 0.0015b536048 3 5 9 4 0.0014b536049 3 5 9 4 0.0015b536510 3 5 9 3 0.0015b536511 3 5 9 5 0.0015b536512 3 5 9 6 0.0014b536513 3 5 9 4 0.0014b536514 3 5 9 6 0.0015b536515 3 5 9 2 0.0015b536516 3 5 9 5 0.0015b536517 3 5 9 3 0.0015b536518 3 5 9 8 0.0015b536519 3 5 9 8 0.0016b536520 3 5 9 1 0.0016b536521 3 5 9 3 0.0016b536522 3 5 9 7 0.0015b536523 3 5 9 6 0.0015b536524 3 5 9 4 0.0015b536525 3 5 9 5 0.0015b536526 3 5 9 4 0.0017b536527 3 5 9 4 0.0016b536528 3 5 9 5 0.0015b536529 3 5 9 7 0.0015b536530 3 5 9 6 0.0015b536531 3 5 9 6 0.0015b536532 3 5 9 4 0.0015b536533 3 5 9 6 0.0015b536534 3 5 9 3 0.0015b536535 3 5 9 7 0.0014b536536 3 5 9 5 0.0014b536537 3 5 9 4 0.0015b536538 3 5 9 5 0.0014b536539 3 5 9 4 0.0014b536540 3 5 9 6 0.0014b536541 3 5 9 3 0.0014b536542 3 5 9 7 0.0014b536543 3 5 9 5 0.0014b536544 3 5 9 3 0.0015b536545 3 5 9 6 0.0016b536546 3 5 9 5 0.0015b536547 3 5 9 7 0.0015b536548 3 5 9 5 0.0014b536549 3 5 9 5 0.0015

Table 16: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 106: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb537010 3 5 10 6 0.0016b537011 3 5 10 9 0.0016b537012 3 5 10 7 0.0016b537013 3 5 10 8 0.0015b537014 3 5 10 8 0.0015b537015 3 5 10 2 0.0015b537016 3 5 10 7 0.0015b537017 3 5 10 7 0.0015b537018 3 5 10 6 0.0015b537019 3 5 10 8 0.0017b537020 3 5 10 6 0.0016b537021 3 5 10 4 0.0016b537022 3 5 10 4 0.0016b537023 3 5 10 7 0.0017b537024 3 5 10 4 0.0016b537025 3 5 10 4 0.0016b537026 3 5 10 4 0.0016b537027 3 5 10 5 0.0016b537028 3 5 10 10 0.0016b537029 3 5 10 7 0.0015b537030 3 5 10 9 0.0015b537031 3 5 10 4 0.0016b537032 3 5 10 7 0.0015b537033 3 5 10 6 0.0016b537034 3 5 10 6 0.0016b537035 3 5 10 6 0.0016b537036 3 5 10 9 0.0015b537037 3 5 10 8 0.0016b537038 3 5 10 4 0.0016b537039 3 5 10 6 0.0016b537040 3 5 10 8 0.0015b537041 3 5 10 9 0.0018b537042 3 5 10 8 0.0017b537043 3 5 10 8 0.0017b537044 3 5 10 7 0.0016b537045 3 5 10 5 0.0016b537046 3 5 10 6 0.0015b537047 3 5 10 7 0.0015b537048 3 5 10 8 0.0016b537049 3 5 10 5 0.0015b537510 3 5 11 8 0.0016b537511 3 5 11 3 0.0016b537512 3 5 11 5 0.0016b537513 3 5 11 6 0.0017b537514 3 5 11 10 0.0017b537515 3 5 11 6 0.0017b537516 3 5 11 9 0.0016b537517 3 5 11 12 0.0016b537518 3 5 11 5 0.0017b537519 3 5 11 5 0.0018b537520 3 5 11 4 0.0018b537521 3 5 11 9 0.0017b537522 3 5 11 7 0.0016b537523 3 5 11 7 0.0016b537524 3 5 11 10 0.0017b537525 3 5 11 4 0.0017b537526 3 5 11 3 0.0017b537527 3 5 11 7 0.0016b537528 3 5 11 7 0.0016b537529 3 5 11 6 0.0016b537530 3 5 11 9 0.0016b537531 3 5 11 10 0.0016b537532 3 5 11 7 0.0017b537533 3 5 11 9 0.0017b537534 3 5 11 10 0.0017b537535 3 5 11 7 0.0017b537536 3 5 11 9 0.0018b537537 3 5 11 8 0.0017b537538 3 5 11 7 0.0017b537539 3 5 11 10 0.0016

Table 17: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 107: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb537540 3 5 11 6 0.0017b537541 3 5 11 10 0.0017b537542 3 5 11 8 0.0017b537543 3 5 11 11 0.0017b537544 3 5 11 9 0.0017b537545 3 5 11 3 0.0017b537546 3 5 11 8 0.0016b537547 3 5 11 9 0.0017b537548 3 5 11 10 0.0017b537549 3 5 11 4 0.0017b545510 4 5 11 5 0.0018b545511 4 5 11 3 0.0017b545512 4 5 11 5 0.0019b545513 4 5 11 5 0.0018b545514 4 5 11 5 0.0018b545515 4 5 11 3 0.0018b545516 4 5 11 4 0.0018b545517 4 5 11 7 0.0018b545518 4 5 11 3 0.0018b545519 4 5 11 5 0.0018b545520 4 5 11 4 0.0017b545521 4 5 11 7 0.0017b545522 4 5 11 6 0.0017b545523 4 5 11 6 0.0017b545524 4 5 11 4 0.0018b545525 4 5 11 4 0.0018b545526 4 5 11 2 0.0017b545527 4 5 11 2 0.0017b545528 4 5 11 5 0.0020b545529 4 5 11 4 0.0019b545530 4 5 11 4 0.0018b545531 4 5 11 5 0.0017b545532 4 5 11 6 0.0017b545533 4 5 11 3 0.0017b545534 4 5 11 8 0.0017b545535 4 5 11 5 0.0017b545536 4 5 11 3 0.0017b545537 4 5 11 6 0.0017b545538 4 5 11 4 0.0017b545539 4 5 11 5 0.0018b545540 4 5 11 5 0.0017b545541 4 5 11 7 0.0018b545542 4 5 11 6 0.0017b545543 4 5 11 5 0.0017b545544 4 5 11 6 0.0018b545545 4 5 11 4 0.0019b545546 4 5 11 3 0.0018b545547 4 5 11 8 0.0018b545548 4 5 11 3 0.0018b545549 4 5 11 5 0.0019b546010 4 5 12 5 0.0019b546011 4 5 12 9 0.0019b546012 4 5 12 6 0.0019b546013 4 5 12 7 0.0019b546014 4 5 12 6 0.0018b546015 4 5 12 9 0.0021b546016 4 5 12 6 0.0019b546017 4 5 12 5 0.0019b546018 4 5 12 7 0.0019b546019 4 5 12 8 0.0020b546020 4 5 12 8 0.0022b546021 4 5 12 6 0.0020b546022 4 5 12 3 0.0019b546023 4 5 12 7 0.0019b546024 4 5 12 6 0.0018b546025 4 5 12 3 0.0019b546026 4 5 12 7 0.0019b546027 4 5 12 4 0.0019b546028 4 5 12 7 0.0019b546029 4 5 12 7 0.0019

Table 18: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 108: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb546030 4 5 12 4 0.0019b546031 4 5 12 8 0.0018b546032 4 5 12 5 0.0018b546033 4 5 12 7 0.0018b546034 4 5 12 1 0.0019b546035 4 5 12 7 0.0020b546036 4 5 12 6 0.0019b546037 4 5 12 6 0.0020b546038 4 5 12 4 0.0019b546039 4 5 12 9 0.0020b546040 4 5 12 7 0.0019b546041 4 5 12 7 0.0019b546042 4 5 12 3 0.0018b546043 4 5 12 7 0.0019b546044 4 5 12 10 0.0021b546045 4 5 12 5 0.0018b546046 4 5 12 9 0.0020b546047 4 5 12 6 0.0019b546048 4 5 12 6 0.0019b546049 4 5 12 6 0.0018b546510 4 5 13 6 0.0021b546511 4 5 13 5 0.0020b546512 4 5 13 5 0.0020b546513 4 5 13 10 0.0020b546514 4 5 13 6 0.0020b546515 4 5 13 9 0.0021b546516 4 5 13 6 0.0020b546517 4 5 13 7 0.0020b546518 4 5 13 10 0.0019b546519 4 5 13 1 0.0020b546520 4 5 13 6 0.0020b546521 4 5 13 8 0.0020b546522 4 5 13 7 0.0019b546523 4 5 13 6 0.0020b546524 4 5 13 5 0.0024b546525 4 5 13 5 0.0023b546526 4 5 13 8 0.0022b546527 4 5 13 7 0.0021b546528 4 5 13 4 0.0020b546529 4 5 13 3 0.0021b546530 4 5 13 6 0.0020b546531 4 5 13 5 0.0022b546532 4 5 13 5 0.0024b546533 4 5 13 6 0.0026b546534 4 5 13 6 0.0022b546535 4 5 13 8 0.0021b546536 4 5 13 5 0.0020b546537 4 5 13 6 0.0023b546538 4 5 13 6 0.0022b546539 4 5 13 7 0.0021b546540 4 5 13 7 0.0021b546541 4 5 13 7 0.0021b546542 4 5 13 8 0.0022b546543 4 5 13 7 0.0020b546544 4 5 13 8 0.0019b546545 4 5 13 5 0.0020b546546 4 5 13 7 0.0020b546547 4 5 13 8 0.0019b546548 4 5 13 6 0.0019b546549 4 5 13 7 0.0019b547010 4 5 14 9 0.0021b547011 4 5 14 6 0.0025b547012 4 5 14 10 0.0028b547013 4 5 14 10 0.0022b547014 4 5 14 9 0.0021b547015 4 5 14 4 0.0021b547016 4 5 14 10 0.0022b547017 4 5 14 8 0.0023b547018 4 5 14 7 0.0022b547019 4 5 14 10 0.0022

Table 19: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 109: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb547020 4 5 14 11 0.0021b547021 4 5 14 9 0.0021b547022 4 5 14 7 0.0021b547023 4 5 14 6 0.0021b547024 4 5 14 5 0.0025b547025 4 5 14 9 0.0024b547026 4 5 14 8 0.0023b547027 4 5 14 8 0.0023b547028 4 5 14 10 0.0022b547029 4 5 14 5 0.0021b547030 4 5 14 5 0.0021b547031 4 5 14 8 0.0020b547032 4 5 14 7 0.0021b547033 4 5 14 11 0.0022b547034 4 5 14 8 0.0021b547035 4 5 14 5 0.0021b547036 4 5 14 9 0.0021b547037 4 5 14 9 0.0023b547038 4 5 14 8 0.0021b547039 4 5 14 7 0.0022b547040 4 5 14 6 0.0023b547041 4 5 14 6 0.0021b547042 4 5 14 13 0.0030b547043 4 5 14 9 0.0021b547044 4 5 14 9 0.0021b547045 4 5 14 12 0.0021b547046 4 5 14 5 0.0021b547047 4 5 14 7 0.0021b547048 4 5 14 12 0.0022b547049 4 5 14 9 0.0021b547510 4 5 15 9 0.0024b547511 4 5 15 13 0.0025b547512 4 5 15 11 0.0028b547513 4 5 15 4 0.0023b547514 4 5 15 10 0.0029b547515 4 5 15 7 0.0023b547516 4 5 15 9 0.0022b547517 4 5 15 8 0.0022b547518 4 5 15 7 0.0022b547519 4 5 15 11 0.0022b547520 4 5 15 11 0.0021b547521 4 5 15 12 0.0025b547522 4 5 15 12 0.0023b547523 4 5 15 9 0.0026b547524 4 5 15 14 0.0029b547525 4 5 15 12 0.0025b547526 4 5 15 10 0.0021b547527 4 5 15 9 0.0022b547528 4 5 15 5 0.0021b547529 4 5 15 4 0.0023b547530 4 5 15 9 0.0023b547531 4 5 15 10 0.0022b547532 4 5 15 13 0.0023b547533 4 5 15 7 0.0022b547534 4 5 15 14 0.0024b547535 4 5 15 8 0.0025b547536 4 5 15 11 0.0028b547537 4 5 15 10 0.0023b547538 4 5 15 11 0.0027b547539 4 5 15 9 0.0022b547540 4 5 15 10 0.0023b547541 4 5 15 9 0.0022b547542 4 5 15 9 0.0023b547543 4 5 15 10 0.0024b547544 4 5 15 10 0.0022b547545 4 5 15 8 0.0022b547546 4 5 15 17 0.0145b547547 4 5 15 5 0.0022b547548 4 5 15 10 0.0022b547549 4 5 15 9 0.0022

Table 20: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 110: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb555510 5 5 13 4 0.0022b555511 5 5 13 7 0.0021b555512 5 5 13 6 0.0021b555513 5 5 13 2 0.0021b555514 5 5 13 3 0.0021b555515 5 5 13 5 0.0022b555516 5 5 13 6 0.0022b555517 5 5 13 6 0.0021b555518 5 5 13 6 0.0022b555519 5 5 13 3 0.0021b555520 5 5 13 5 0.0023b555521 5 5 13 5 0.0020b555522 5 5 13 4 0.0021b555523 5 5 13 5 0.0021b555524 5 5 13 6 0.0020b555525 5 5 13 4 0.0021b555526 5 5 13 6 0.0020b555527 5 5 13 6 0.0021b555528 5 5 13 4 0.0021b555529 5 5 13 8 0.0023b555530 5 5 13 7 0.0023b555531 5 5 13 5 0.0022b555532 5 5 13 5 0.0021b555533 5 5 13 5 0.0021b555534 5 5 13 7 0.0021b555535 5 5 13 5 0.0022b555536 5 5 13 4 0.0021b555537 5 5 13 8 0.0021b555538 5 5 13 7 0.0020b555539 5 5 13 6 0.0021b555540 5 5 13 7 0.0020b555541 5 5 13 7 0.0021b555542 5 5 13 6 0.0021b555543 5 5 13 4 0.0021b555544 5 5 13 5 0.0023b555545 5 5 13 6 0.0021b555546 5 5 13 6 0.0021b555547 5 5 13 6 0.0021b555548 5 5 13 5 0.0021b555549 5 5 13 1 0.0021b556010 5 5 15 7 0.0023b556011 5 5 15 6 0.0023b556012 5 5 15 8 0.0023b556013 5 5 15 9 0.0024b556014 5 5 15 9 0.0023b556015 5 5 15 6 0.0023b556016 5 5 15 8 0.0025b556017 5 5 15 5 0.0026b556018 5 5 15 5 0.0025b556019 5 5 15 10 0.0030b556020 5 5 15 8 0.0023b556021 5 5 15 7 0.0024b556022 5 5 15 6 0.0023b556023 5 5 15 9 0.0024b556024 5 5 15 5 0.0023b556025 5 5 15 7 0.0024b556026 5 5 15 9 0.0023b556027 5 5 15 8 0.0024b556028 5 5 15 9 0.0025b556029 5 5 15 4 0.0024b556030 5 5 15 7 0.0023b556031 5 5 15 3 0.0024b556032 5 5 15 9 0.0044b556033 5 5 15 8 0.0028b556034 5 5 15 9 0.0023b556035 5 5 15 8 0.0022b556036 5 5 15 8 0.0023b556037 5 5 15 3 0.0023b556038 5 5 15 8 0.0023b556039 5 5 15 5 0.0024

Table 21: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 111: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb556040 5 5 15 7 0.0026b556041 5 5 15 9 0.0023b556042 5 5 15 8 0.0023b556043 5 5 15 8 0.0024b556044 5 5 15 6 0.0023b556045 5 5 15 6 0.0023b556046 5 5 15 9 0.0024b556047 5 5 15 5 0.0023b556048 5 5 15 7 0.0024b556049 5 5 15 4 0.0023b556510 5 5 16 7 0.0024b556511 5 5 16 9 0.0029b556512 5 5 16 7 0.0027b556513 5 5 16 5 0.0026b556514 5 5 16 5 0.0025b556515 5 5 16 8 0.0027b556516 5 5 16 10 0.0024b556517 5 5 16 10 0.0024b556518 5 5 16 5 0.0024b556519 5 5 16 7 0.0025b556520 5 5 16 7 0.0024b556521 5 5 16 11 0.0024b556522 5 5 16 6 0.0024b556523 5 5 16 8 0.0026b556524 5 5 16 7 0.0025b556525 5 5 16 9 0.0025b556526 5 5 16 11 0.0031b556527 5 5 16 9 0.0035b556528 5 5 16 8 0.0024b556529 5 5 16 11 0.0028b556530 5 5 16 7 0.0024b556531 5 5 16 8 0.0024b556532 5 5 16 7 0.0024b556533 5 5 16 10 0.0024b556534 5 5 16 6 0.0026b556535 5 5 16 9 0.0025b556536 5 5 16 6 0.0025b556537 5 5 16 8 0.0031b556538 5 5 16 10 0.0025b556539 5 5 16 9 0.0024b556540 5 5 16 10 0.0030b556541 5 5 16 7 0.0024b556542 5 5 16 11 0.0024b556543 5 5 16 8 0.0023b556544 5 5 16 7 0.0025b556545 5 5 16 12 0.0028b556546 5 5 16 6 0.0024b556547 5 5 16 9 0.0024b556548 5 5 16 10 0.0025b556549 5 5 16 8 0.0023b557010 5 5 17 9 0.0026b557011 5 5 17 11 0.0030b557012 5 5 17 10 0.0025b557013 5 5 17 9 0.0045b557014 5 5 17 12 0.0025b557015 5 5 17 10 0.0025b557016 5 5 17 14 0.0036b557017 5 5 17 9 0.0027b557018 5 5 17 6 0.0025b557019 5 5 17 7 0.0026b557020 5 5 17 7 0.0026b557021 5 5 17 8 0.0025b557022 5 5 17 10 0.0026b557023 5 5 17 7 0.0026b557024 5 5 17 10 0.0025b557025 5 5 17 9 0.0025b557026 5 5 17 10 0.0026b557027 5 5 17 11 0.0034b557028 5 5 17 9 0.0032b557029 5 5 17 8 0.0027

Table 22: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 112: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb557030 5 5 17 6 0.0025b557031 5 5 17 5 0.0025b557032 5 5 17 5 0.0025b557033 5 5 17 8 0.0027b557034 5 5 17 12 0.0031b557035 5 5 17 7 0.0029b557036 5 5 17 6 0.0025b557037 5 5 17 10 0.0035b557038 5 5 17 8 0.0027b557039 5 5 17 7 0.0027b557040 5 5 17 14 0.0039b557041 5 5 17 8 0.0026b557042 5 5 17 8 0.0026b557043 5 5 17 7 0.0025b557044 5 5 17 10 0.0025b557045 5 5 17 9 0.0027b557046 5 5 17 8 0.0026b557047 5 5 17 9 0.0026b557048 5 5 17 7 0.0028b557049 5 5 17 5 0.0026b557510 5 5 18 11 0.0038b557511 5 5 18 11 0.0300b557512 5 5 18 14 0.0045b557513 5 5 18 10 0.0026b557514 5 5 18 11 0.0026b557515 5 5 18 11 0.0030b557516 5 5 18 9 0.0028b557517 5 5 18 10 0.0026b557518 5 5 18 11 0.0027b557519 5 5 18 11 0.0033b557520 5 5 18 10 0.0028b557521 5 5 18 10 0.0032b557522 5 5 18 10 0.0027b557523 5 5 18 9 0.0027b557524 5 5 18 10 0.0026b557525 5 5 18 11 0.0027b557526 5 5 18 11 0.0027b557527 5 5 18 10 0.0034b557528 5 5 18 11 0.0027b557529 5 5 18 13 0.0037b557530 5 5 18 10 0.0028b557531 5 5 18 11 0.0028b557532 5 5 18 9 0.0033b557533 5 5 18 8 0.0034b557534 5 5 18 9 0.0039b557535 5 5 18 10 0.0035b557536 5 5 18 12 0.0031b557537 5 5 18 7 0.0030b557538 5 5 18 8 0.0034b557539 5 5 18 10 0.0031b557540 5 5 18 12 0.0035b557541 5 5 18 7 0.0027b557542 5 5 18 10 0.0027b557543 5 5 18 12 0.0028b557544 5 5 18 11 0.0026b557545 5 5 18 10 0.0057b557546 5 5 18 9 0.0028b557547 5 5 18 12 0.0036b557548 5 5 18 7 0.0030b557549 5 5 18 6 0.0029b565510 6 5 16 7 0.0027b565511 6 5 16 7 0.0025b565512 6 5 16 5 0.0024b565513 6 5 16 6 0.0025b565514 6 5 16 8 0.0026b565515 6 5 16 8 0.0025b565516 6 5 16 6 0.0024b565517 6 5 16 7 0.0028b565518 6 5 16 6 0.0027b565519 6 5 16 4 0.0026

Table 23: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 113: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb565520 6 5 16 8 0.0031b565521 6 5 16 6 0.0025b565522 6 5 16 8 0.0025b565523 6 5 16 7 0.0025b565524 6 5 16 3 0.0026b565525 6 5 16 2 0.0025b565526 6 5 16 5 0.0025b565527 6 5 16 8 0.0025b565528 6 5 16 6 0.0025b565529 6 5 16 4 0.0028b565530 6 5 16 7 0.0025b565531 6 5 16 8 0.0026b565532 6 5 16 9 0.0025b565533 6 5 16 6 0.0025b565534 6 5 16 6 0.0025b565535 6 5 16 6 0.0025b565536 6 5 16 7 0.0025b565537 6 5 16 5 0.0024b565538 6 5 16 6 0.0025b565539 6 5 16 9 0.0029b565540 6 5 16 7 0.0029b565541 6 5 16 7 0.0025b565542 6 5 16 4 0.0025b565543 6 5 16 8 0.0027b565544 6 5 16 6 0.0024b565545 6 5 16 4 0.0027b565546 6 5 16 6 0.0026b565547 6 5 16 7 0.0025b565548 6 5 16 8 0.0025b565549 6 5 16 6 0.0025b566010 6 5 18 9 0.0027b566011 6 5 18 13 0.0058b566012 6 5 18 8 0.0029b566013 6 5 18 4 0.0028b566014 6 5 18 6 0.0027b566015 6 5 18 9 0.0027b566016 6 5 18 5 0.0029b566017 6 5 18 7 0.0029b566018 6 5 18 10 0.0027b566019 6 5 18 5 0.0027b566020 6 5 18 8 0.0032b566021 6 5 18 7 0.0029b566022 6 5 18 5 0.0029b566023 6 5 18 8 0.0028b566024 6 5 18 9 0.0027b566025 6 5 18 9 0.0027b566026 6 5 18 8 0.0028b566027 6 5 18 8 0.0028b566028 6 5 18 8 0.0027b566029 6 5 18 9 0.0028b566030 6 5 18 9 0.0031b566031 6 5 18 8 0.0030b566032 6 5 18 7 0.0030b566033 6 5 18 9 0.0029b566034 6 5 18 6 0.0027b566035 6 5 18 10 0.0027b566036 6 5 18 6 0.0028b566037 6 5 18 8 0.0030b566038 6 5 18 11 0.0028b566039 6 5 18 6 0.0027b566040 6 5 18 7 0.0028b566041 6 5 18 9 0.0030b566042 6 5 18 11 0.0035b566043 6 5 18 6 0.0029b566044 6 5 18 5 0.0027b566045 6 5 18 10 0.0027b566046 6 5 18 8 0.0028b566047 6 5 18 10 0.0028b566048 6 5 18 8 0.0027b566049 6 5 18 9 0.0028

Table 24: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 114: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb566510 6 5 19 6 0.0030b566511 6 5 19 4 0.0030b566512 6 5 19 8 0.0030b566513 6 5 19 10 0.0030b566514 6 5 19 8 0.0029b566515 6 5 19 13 0.0042b566516 6 5 19 9 0.0028b566517 6 5 19 11 0.0029b566518 6 5 19 12 0.0115b566519 6 5 19 11 0.0033b566520 6 5 19 8 0.0029b566521 6 5 19 10 0.0032b566522 6 5 19 11 0.0032b566523 6 5 19 8 0.0029b566524 6 5 19 13 0.0029b566525 6 5 19 6 0.0028b566526 6 5 19 6 0.0028b566527 6 5 19 8 0.0034b566528 6 5 19 5 0.0031b566529 6 5 19 10 0.0030b566530 6 5 19 13 0.0029b566531 6 5 19 10 0.0033b566532 6 5 19 11 0.0033b566533 6 5 19 6 0.0033b566534 6 5 19 7 0.0033b566535 6 5 19 13 0.0033b566536 6 5 19 7 0.0033b566537 6 5 19 7 0.0033b566538 6 5 19 8 0.0030b566539 6 5 19 10 0.0029b566540 6 5 19 8 0.0028b566541 6 5 19 11 0.0029b566542 6 5 19 12 0.0030b566543 6 5 19 8 0.0029b566544 6 5 19 4 0.0029b566545 6 5 19 8 0.0030b566546 6 5 19 11 0.0030b566547 6 5 19 10 0.0032b566548 6 5 19 9 0.0030b566549 6 5 19 11 0.0029b567010 6 5 21 11 0.0050b567011 6 5 21 12 0.0033b567012 6 5 21 13 0.0032b567013 6 5 21 11 0.0032b567014 6 5 21 10 0.0035b567015 6 5 21 10 0.0033b567016 6 5 21 10 0.0035b567017 6 5 21 9 0.0033b567018 6 5 21 13 0.0121b567019 6 5 21 7 0.0031b567020 6 5 21 11 0.0045b567021 6 5 21 10 0.0035b567022 6 5 21 11 0.0034b567023 6 5 21 9 0.0032b567024 6 5 21 10 0.0033b567025 6 5 21 13 0.0031b567026 6 5 21 11 0.0032b567027 6 5 21 13 0.0031b567028 6 5 21 14 0.0332b567029 6 5 21 13 0.0093b567030 6 5 21 10 0.0033b567031 6 5 21 7 0.0032b567032 6 5 21 13 0.0032b567033 6 5 21 14 0.0065b567034 6 5 21 14 0.0032b567035 6 5 21 11 0.0035b567036 6 5 21 6 0.0037b567037 6 5 21 11 0.0033b567038 6 5 21 12 0.0154b567039 6 5 21 8 0.0032

Table 25: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 115: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb567040 6 5 21 16 0.0085b567041 6 5 21 9 0.0034b567042 6 5 21 8 0.0035b567043 6 5 21 13 0.0119b567044 6 5 21 11 0.0032b567045 6 5 21 12 0.0033b567046 6 5 21 13 0.0034b567047 6 5 21 10 0.0040b567048 6 5 21 14 0.0089b567049 6 5 21 10 0.0033b567510 6 5 22 12 0.0033b567511 6 5 22 14 0.0043b567512 6 5 22 14 0.0034b567513 6 5 22 12 0.0039b567514 6 5 22 8 0.0034b567515 6 5 22 14 0.0075b567516 6 5 22 10 0.0033b567517 6 5 22 12 0.0040b567518 6 5 22 10 0.0036b567519 6 5 22 12 0.0033b567520 6 5 22 10 0.0037b567521 6 5 22 6 0.0035b567522 6 5 22 13 0.0035b567523 6 5 22 12 0.0033b567524 6 5 22 11 0.0033b567525 6 5 22 16 0.0559b567526 6 5 22 9 0.0034b567527 6 5 22 13 0.0033b567528 6 5 22 15 0.0070b567529 6 5 22 18 0.1696b567530 6 5 22 7 0.0034b567531 6 5 22 8 0.0033b567532 6 5 22 14 0.0039b567533 6 5 22 8 0.0035b567534 6 5 22 13 0.0034b567535 6 5 22 13 0.0079b567536 6 5 22 8 0.0035b567537 6 5 22 17 0.0037b567538 6 5 22 12 0.0039b567539 6 5 22 14 0.0075b567540 6 5 22 12 0.0036b567541 6 5 22 14 0.0061b567542 6 5 22 18 0.1836b567543 6 5 22 11 0.0033b567544 6 5 22 13 0.0100b567545 6 5 22 6 0.0034b567546 6 5 22 15 0.0084b567547 6 5 22 14 0.0039b567548 6 5 22 13 0.0035b567549 6 5 22 10 0.0034b575510 7 5 19 6 0.0030b575511 7 5 19 9 0.0029b575512 7 5 19 5 0.0030b575513 7 5 19 9 0.0031b575514 7 5 19 7 0.0030b575515 7 5 19 11 0.0030b575516 7 5 19 9 0.0035b575517 7 5 19 9 0.0031b575518 7 5 19 8 0.0058b575519 7 5 19 7 0.0031b575520 7 5 19 8 0.0030b575521 7 5 19 6 0.0029b575522 7 5 19 10 0.0030b575523 7 5 19 4 0.0031b575524 7 5 19 9 0.0032b575525 7 5 19 7 0.0030b575526 7 5 19 5 0.0030b575527 7 5 19 7 0.0031b575528 7 5 19 12 0.0055b575529 7 5 19 6 0.0030

Table 26: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 116: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb575530 7 5 19 8 0.0030b575531 7 5 19 7 0.0030b575532 7 5 19 11 0.0095b575533 7 5 19 6 0.0033b575534 7 5 19 7 0.0030b575535 7 5 19 8 0.0030b575536 7 5 19 10 0.0030b575537 7 5 19 8 0.0030b575538 7 5 19 6 0.0030b575539 7 5 19 6 0.0030b575540 7 5 19 8 0.0030b575541 7 5 19 8 0.0034b575542 7 5 19 6 0.0030b575543 7 5 19 8 0.0031b575544 7 5 19 9 0.0029b575545 7 5 19 7 0.0030b575546 7 5 19 7 0.0031b575547 7 5 19 6 0.0030b575548 7 5 19 3 0.0030b575549 7 5 19 8 0.0029b576010 7 5 21 11 0.0038b576011 7 5 21 9 0.0035b576012 7 5 21 7 0.0036b576013 7 5 21 8 0.0033b576014 7 5 21 6 0.0032b576015 7 5 21 9 0.0034b576016 7 5 21 7 0.0033b576017 7 5 21 8 0.0032b576018 7 5 21 8 0.0033b576019 7 5 21 9 0.0038b576020 7 5 21 11 0.0035b576021 7 5 21 11 0.0034b576022 7 5 21 12 0.0033b576023 7 5 21 12 0.0037b576024 7 5 21 11 0.0033b576025 7 5 21 9 0.0032b576026 7 5 21 8 0.0033b576027 7 5 21 14 0.0039b576028 7 5 21 9 0.0035b576029 7 5 21 11 0.0035b576030 7 5 21 10 0.0031b576031 7 5 21 6 0.0034b576032 7 5 21 6 0.0033b576033 7 5 21 7 0.0033b576034 7 5 21 6 0.0032b576035 7 5 21 7 0.0035b576036 7 5 21 12 0.0038b576037 7 5 21 11 0.0041b576038 7 5 21 10 0.0036b576039 7 5 21 6 0.0033b576040 7 5 21 6 0.0034b576041 7 5 21 10 0.0034b576042 7 5 21 10 0.0032b576043 7 5 21 9 0.0032b576044 7 5 21 14 0.0040b576045 7 5 21 9 0.0036b576046 7 5 21 11 0.0035b576047 7 5 21 10 0.0033b576048 7 5 21 9 0.0035b576049 7 5 21 7 0.0033b576510 7 5 22 9 0.0034b576511 7 5 22 11 0.0034b576512 7 5 22 15 0.0052b576513 7 5 22 13 0.0036b576514 7 5 22 11 0.0048b576515 7 5 22 4 0.0041b576516 7 5 22 10 0.0041b576517 7 5 22 10 0.0040b576518 7 5 22 14 0.0042b576519 7 5 22 11 0.0045

Table 27: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 117: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb576520 7 5 22 13 0.0041b576521 7 5 22 9 0.0037b576522 7 5 22 11 0.0075b576523 7 5 22 11 0.0035b576524 7 5 22 14 0.0034b576525 7 5 22 11 0.0035b576526 7 5 22 12 0.0039b576527 7 5 22 11 0.0040b576528 7 5 22 12 0.0035b576529 7 5 22 13 0.0034b576530 7 5 22 8 0.0034b576531 7 5 22 10 0.0036b576532 7 5 22 7 0.0037b576533 7 5 22 5 0.0034b576534 7 5 22 10 0.0040b576535 7 5 22 10 0.0038b576536 7 5 22 10 0.0035b576537 7 5 22 7 0.0034b576538 7 5 22 14 0.0034b576539 7 5 22 6 0.0035b576540 7 5 22 10 0.0036b576541 7 5 22 12 0.0034b576542 7 5 22 11 0.0039b576543 7 5 22 13 0.0044b576544 7 5 22 11 0.0035b576545 7 5 22 15 0.0035b576546 7 5 22 5 0.0034b576547 7 5 22 8 0.0035b576548 7 5 22 6 0.0035b576549 7 5 22 14 0.0389b577010 7 5 24 12 0.0039b577011 7 5 24 19 0.0037b577012 7 5 24 9 0.0040b577013 7 5 24 14 0.0086b577014 7 5 24 12 0.0037b577015 7 5 24 8 0.0047b577016 7 5 24 12 0.0039b577017 7 5 24 14 0.0042b577018 7 5 24 13 0.0056b577019 7 5 24 11 0.0037b577020 7 5 24 18 0.2598b577021 7 5 24 14 0.0038b577022 7 5 24 10 0.0037b577023 7 5 24 10 0.0040b577024 7 5 24 9 0.0039b577025 7 5 24 13 0.0045b577026 7 5 24 14 0.0038b577027 7 5 24 15 0.0043b577028 7 5 24 15 0.0042b577029 7 5 24 15 0.0040b577030 7 5 24 9 0.0039b577031 7 5 24 10 0.0038b577032 7 5 24 9 0.0037b577033 7 5 24 12 0.0043b577034 7 5 24 12 0.0044b577035 7 5 24 12 0.0072b577036 7 5 24 12 0.0039b577037 7 5 24 14 0.0040b577038 7 5 24 9 0.0038b577039 7 5 24 10 0.0037b577040 7 5 24 14 0.0055b577041 7 5 24 10 0.0041b577042 7 5 24 10 0.0042b577043 7 5 24 12 0.0039b577044 7 5 24 16 0.0449b577045 7 5 24 12 0.0038b577046 7 5 24 12 0.0041b577047 7 5 24 16 0.0040b577048 7 5 24 11 0.0079b577049 7 5 24 13 0.0037

Table 28: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 118: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb577510 7 5 26 12 0.0074b577511 7 5 26 14 0.0053b577512 7 5 26 16 0.0175b577513 7 5 26 14 0.0040b577514 7 5 26 12 0.0041b577515 7 5 26 15 0.0105b577516 7 5 26 13 0.0042b577517 7 5 26 15 0.0056b577518 7 5 26 13 0.0041b577519 7 5 26 20 0.0289b577520 7 5 26 15 0.0282b577521 7 5 26 13 0.0041b577522 7 5 26 10 0.0050b577523 7 5 26 14 0.0049b577524 7 5 26 17 0.0052b577525 7 5 26 18 0.0524b577526 7 5 26 10 0.0044b577527 7 5 26 18 0.0173b577528 7 5 26 14 0.0041b577529 7 5 26 15 0.0040b577530 7 5 26 18 0.0571b577531 7 5 26 15 0.0041b577532 7 5 26 16 0.0041b577533 7 5 26 13 0.0119b577534 7 5 26 11 0.0041b577535 7 5 26 16 0.0045b577536 7 5 26 18 0.0385b577537 7 5 26 16 0.3094b577538 7 5 26 14 0.0041b577539 7 5 26 17 0.0201b577540 7 5 26 11 0.0046b577541 7 5 26 17 0.0363b577542 7 5 26 14 0.0041b577543 7 5 26 14 0.0326b577544 7 5 26 15 0.0041b577545 7 5 26 13 0.0041b577546 7 5 26 15 0.0078b577547 7 5 26 16 0.0087b577548 7 5 26 13 0.0041b577549 7 5 26 16 0.0041b635510 3 6 9 1 0.0014b635511 3 6 9 5 0.0014b635512 3 6 9 4 0.0014b635513 3 6 9 6 0.0014b635514 3 6 9 7 0.0014b635515 3 6 9 4 0.0015b635516 3 6 9 7 0.0015b635517 3 6 9 4 0.0014b635518 3 6 9 7 0.0017b635519 3 6 9 5 0.0015b635520 3 6 9 6 0.0015b635521 3 6 9 4 0.0015b635522 3 6 9 4 0.0016b635523 3 6 9 5 0.0015b635524 3 6 9 4 0.0015b635525 3 6 9 4 0.0014b635526 3 6 9 4 0.0015b635527 3 6 9 4 0.0014b635528 3 6 9 7 0.0015b635529 3 6 9 7 0.0015b635530 3 6 9 4 0.0015b635531 3 6 9 7 0.0014b635532 3 6 9 4 0.0014b635533 3 6 9 5 0.0014b635534 3 6 9 4 0.0015b635535 3 6 9 4 0.0015b635536 3 6 9 4 0.0015b635537 3 6 9 4 0.0017b635538 3 6 9 4 0.0015b635539 3 6 9 5 0.0014

Table 29: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 119: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb635540 3 6 9 5 0.0014b635541 3 6 9 2 0.0015b635542 3 6 9 5 0.0014b635543 3 6 9 8 0.0015b635544 3 6 9 6 0.0014b635545 3 6 9 2 0.0014b635546 3 6 9 3 0.0014b635547 3 6 9 7 0.0015b635548 3 6 9 4 0.0015b635549 3 6 9 7 0.0015b636010 3 6 10 7 0.0016b636011 3 6 10 6 0.0016b636012 3 6 10 7 0.0016b636013 3 6 10 7 0.0015b636014 3 6 10 4 0.0016b636015 3 6 10 7 0.0016b636016 3 6 10 5 0.0018b636017 3 6 10 5 0.0016b636018 3 6 10 8 0.0016b636019 3 6 10 8 0.0016b636020 3 6 10 3 0.0015b636021 3 6 10 7 0.0017b636022 3 6 10 8 0.0016b636023 3 6 10 6 0.0016b636024 3 6 10 5 0.0016b636025 3 6 10 6 0.0016b636026 3 6 10 6 0.0015b636027 3 6 10 5 0.0016b636028 3 6 10 9 0.0016b636029 3 6 10 9 0.0016b636030 3 6 10 3 0.0015b636031 3 6 10 10 0.0015b636032 3 6 10 7 0.0015b636033 3 6 10 8 0.0018b636034 3 6 10 5 0.0016b636035 3 6 10 7 0.0016b636036 3 6 10 2 0.0016b636037 3 6 10 4 0.0015b636038 3 6 10 6 0.0016b636039 3 6 10 10 0.0017b636040 3 6 10 7 0.0016b636041 3 6 10 6 0.0015b636042 3 6 10 5 0.0015b636043 3 6 10 4 0.0015b636044 3 6 10 4 0.0015b636045 3 6 10 11 0.0016b636046 3 6 10 6 0.0016b636047 3 6 10 7 0.0016b636048 3 6 10 4 0.0016b636049 3 6 10 8 0.0016b636510 3 6 11 7 0.0017b636511 3 6 11 7 0.0019b636512 3 6 11 9 0.0017b636513 3 6 11 8 0.0016b636514 3 6 11 9 0.0017b636515 3 6 11 3 0.0017b636516 3 6 11 7 0.0016b636517 3 6 11 7 0.0017b636518 3 6 11 3 0.0016b636519 3 6 11 3 0.0016b636520 3 6 11 6 0.0016b636521 3 6 11 3 0.0017b636522 3 6 11 5 0.0016b636523 3 6 11 11 0.0017b636524 3 6 11 8 0.0017b636525 3 6 11 7 0.0016b636526 3 6 11 5 0.0017b636527 3 6 11 10 0.0017b636528 3 6 11 8 0.0019b636529 3 6 11 8 0.0017

Table 30: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 120: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb636530 3 6 11 11 0.0018b636531 3 6 11 7 0.0018b636532 3 6 11 12 0.0018b636533 3 6 11 8 0.0017b636534 3 6 11 7 0.0016b636535 3 6 11 8 0.0017b636536 3 6 11 5 0.0016b636537 3 6 11 8 0.0016b636538 3 6 11 3 0.0016b636539 3 6 11 6 0.0017b636540 3 6 11 6 0.0017b636541 3 6 11 7 0.0017b636542 3 6 11 10 0.0017b636543 3 6 11 7 0.0017b636544 3 6 11 7 0.0017b636545 3 6 11 6 0.0019b636546 3 6 11 7 0.0016b636547 3 6 11 11 0.0018b636548 3 6 11 7 0.0016b636549 3 6 11 8 0.0017b637010 3 6 12 4 0.0018b637011 3 6 12 8 0.0019b637012 3 6 12 10 0.0017b637013 3 6 12 9 0.0018b637014 3 6 12 9 0.0017b637015 3 6 12 13 0.0018b637016 3 6 12 16 0.0025b637017 3 6 12 12 0.0017b637018 3 6 12 9 0.0018b637019 3 6 12 10 0.0018b637020 3 6 12 8 0.0018b637021 3 6 12 12 0.0021b637022 3 6 12 11 0.0020b637023 3 6 12 12 0.0020b637024 3 6 12 8 0.0019b637025 3 6 12 6 0.0019b637026 3 6 12 10 0.0019b637027 3 6 12 11 0.0018b637028 3 6 12 4 0.0018b637029 3 6 12 10 0.0019b637030 3 6 12 5 0.0018b637031 3 6 12 7 0.0018b637032 3 6 12 12 0.0018b637033 3 6 12 8 0.0017b637034 3 6 12 10 0.0018b637035 3 6 12 11 0.0018b637036 3 6 12 4 0.0020b637037 3 6 12 6 0.0018b637038 3 6 12 7 0.0018b637039 3 6 12 8 0.0018b637040 3 6 12 10 0.0018b637041 3 6 12 8 0.0017b637042 3 6 12 9 0.0018b637043 3 6 12 6 0.0018b637044 3 6 12 9 0.0018b637045 3 6 12 11 0.0019b637046 3 6 12 4 0.0018b637047 3 6 12 6 0.0018b637048 3 6 12 11 0.0019b637049 3 6 12 11 0.0018b637510 3 6 13 9 0.0018b637511 3 6 13 11 0.0021b637512 3 6 13 9 0.0021b637513 3 6 13 12 0.0020b637514 3 6 13 16 0.0021b637515 3 6 13 15 0.0022b637516 3 6 13 15 0.0019b637517 3 6 13 13 0.0020b637518 3 6 13 11 0.0019b637519 3 6 13 4 0.0019

Table 31: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 121: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb637520 3 6 13 9 0.0019b637521 3 6 13 10 0.0018b637522 3 6 13 11 0.0019b637523 3 6 13 6 0.0019b637524 3 6 13 6 0.0019b637525 3 6 13 10 0.0018b637526 3 6 13 16 0.0024b637527 3 6 13 16 0.0023b637528 3 6 13 5 0.0019b637529 3 6 13 14 0.0021b637530 3 6 13 15 0.0020b637531 3 6 13 10 0.0020b637532 3 6 13 8 0.0018b637533 3 6 13 10 0.0019b637534 3 6 13 19 0.0019b637535 3 6 13 14 0.0021b637536 3 6 13 12 0.0021b637537 3 6 13 14 0.0020b637538 3 6 13 13 0.0021b637539 3 6 13 16 0.0020b637540 3 6 13 11 0.0024b637541 3 6 13 15 0.0022b637542 3 6 13 11 0.0020b637543 3 6 13 12 0.0020b637544 3 6 13 8 0.0018b637545 3 6 13 10 0.0020b637546 3 6 13 11 0.0019b637547 3 6 13 8 0.0019b637548 3 6 13 12 0.0019b637549 3 6 13 11 0.0019b645510 4 6 13 3 0.0020b645511 4 6 13 7 0.0020b645512 4 6 13 4 0.0020b645513 4 6 13 10 0.0021b645514 4 6 13 6 0.0021b645515 4 6 13 6 0.0023b645516 4 6 13 12 0.0023b645517 4 6 13 10 0.0020b645518 4 6 13 3 0.0020b645519 4 6 13 10 0.0020b645520 4 6 13 6 0.0020b645521 4 6 13 9 0.0020b645522 4 6 13 6 0.0020b645523 4 6 13 5 0.0020b645524 4 6 13 5 0.0020b645525 4 6 13 8 0.0021b645526 4 6 13 7 0.0022b645527 4 6 13 7 0.0020b645528 4 6 13 9 0.0021b645529 4 6 13 8 0.0023b645530 4 6 13 4 0.0020b645531 4 6 13 8 0.0020b645532 4 6 13 8 0.0020b645533 4 6 13 7 0.0020b645534 4 6 13 8 0.0020b645535 4 6 13 7 0.0020b645536 4 6 13 7 0.0020b645537 4 6 13 10 0.0020b645538 4 6 13 7 0.0020b645539 4 6 13 1 0.0020b645540 4 6 13 6 0.0020b645541 4 6 13 6 0.0020b645542 4 6 13 11 0.0034b645543 4 6 13 4 0.0020b645544 4 6 13 6 0.0019b645545 4 6 13 4 0.0020b645546 4 6 13 9 0.0021b645547 4 6 13 7 0.0020b645548 4 6 13 7 0.0020b645549 4 6 13 6 0.0020

Table 32: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 122: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb646010 4 6 14 4 0.0021b646011 4 6 14 10 0.0021b646012 4 6 14 6 0.0021b646013 4 6 14 11 0.0022b646014 4 6 14 6 0.0021b646015 4 6 14 8 0.0020b646016 4 6 14 7 0.0024b646017 4 6 14 7 0.0021b646018 4 6 14 10 0.0023b646019 4 6 14 8 0.0021b646020 4 6 14 10 0.0024b646021 4 6 14 7 0.0021b646022 4 6 14 8 0.0022b646023 4 6 14 4 0.0021b646024 4 6 14 10 0.0022b646025 4 6 14 9 0.0023b646026 4 6 14 6 0.0023b646027 4 6 14 5 0.0023b646028 4 6 14 10 0.0029b646029 4 6 14 6 0.0026b646030 4 6 14 9 0.0023b646031 4 6 14 7 0.0023b646032 4 6 14 8 0.0022b646033 4 6 14 6 0.0023b646034 4 6 14 10 0.0023b646035 4 6 14 8 0.0022b646036 4 6 14 7 0.0021b646037 4 6 14 7 0.0022b646038 4 6 14 10 0.0023b646039 4 6 14 8 0.0021b646040 4 6 14 8 0.0021b646041 4 6 14 8 0.0025b646042 4 6 14 6 0.0022b646043 4 6 14 12 0.0025b646044 4 6 14 8 0.0021b646045 4 6 14 8 0.0022b646046 4 6 14 10 0.0025b646047 4 6 14 10 0.0024b646048 4 6 14 5 0.0022b646049 4 6 14 10 0.0022b646510 4 6 15 14 0.0022b646511 4 6 15 11 0.0022b646512 4 6 15 7 0.0021b646513 4 6 15 4 0.0023b646514 4 6 15 12 0.0025b646515 4 6 15 10 0.0022b646516 4 6 15 9 0.0024b646517 4 6 15 9 0.0023b646518 4 6 15 13 0.0030b646519 4 6 15 7 0.0024b646520 4 6 15 16 0.0026b646521 4 6 15 7 0.0023b646522 4 6 15 10 0.0023b646523 4 6 15 11 0.0026b646524 4 6 15 12 0.0023b646525 4 6 15 6 0.0022b646526 4 6 15 10 0.0025b646527 4 6 15 10 0.0022b646528 4 6 15 10 0.0024b646529 4 6 15 11 0.0023b646530 4 6 15 9 0.0022b646531 4 6 15 10 0.0022b646532 4 6 15 11 0.0022b646533 4 6 15 8 0.0022b646534 4 6 15 8 0.0022b646535 4 6 15 10 0.0024b646536 4 6 15 10 0.0022b646537 4 6 15 7 0.0023b646538 4 6 15 13 0.0029b646539 4 6 15 15 0.0024

Table 33: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 123: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb646540 4 6 15 8 0.0025b646541 4 6 15 11 0.0025b646542 4 6 15 11 0.0024b646543 4 6 15 8 0.0023b646544 4 6 15 10 0.0023b646545 4 6 15 9 0.0023b646546 4 6 15 15 0.0061b646547 4 6 15 14 0.0095b646548 4 6 15 11 0.0026b646549 4 6 15 8 0.0026b647010 4 6 16 13 0.0037b647011 4 6 16 10 0.0023b647012 4 6 16 17 0.0049b647013 4 6 16 4 0.0024b647014 4 6 16 15 0.0025b647015 4 6 16 11 0.0025b647016 4 6 16 15 0.0026b647017 4 6 16 11 0.0024b647018 4 6 16 12 0.0033b647019 4 6 16 16 0.0029b647020 4 6 16 12 0.0037b647021 4 6 16 5 0.0024b647022 4 6 16 10 0.0024b647023 4 6 16 10 0.0030b647024 4 6 16 10 0.0024b647025 4 6 16 17 0.0024b647026 4 6 16 8 0.0023b647027 4 6 16 15 0.0033b647028 4 6 16 15 0.0037b647029 4 6 16 10 0.0025b647030 4 6 16 14 0.0032b647031 4 6 16 13 0.0026b647032 4 6 16 11 0.0025b647033 4 6 16 8 0.0024b647034 4 6 16 12 0.0035b647035 4 6 16 12 0.0023b647036 4 6 16 12 0.0024b647037 4 6 16 5 0.0024b647038 4 6 16 11 0.0023b647039 4 6 16 6 0.0024b647040 4 6 16 11 0.0027b647041 4 6 16 9 0.0024b647042 4 6 16 14 0.0028b647043 4 6 16 13 0.0041b647044 4 6 16 9 0.0023b647045 4 6 16 12 0.0028b647046 4 6 16 13 0.0037b647047 4 6 16 13 0.0032b647048 4 6 16 9 0.0024b647049 4 6 16 14 0.0030b647510 4 6 18 16 0.0042b647511 4 6 18 14 0.0027b647512 4 6 18 15 0.0037b647513 4 6 18 13 0.0030b647514 4 6 18 14 0.0026b647515 4 6 18 10 0.0027b647516 4 6 18 14 0.0034b647517 4 6 18 14 0.0028b647518 4 6 18 14 0.0028b647519 4 6 18 10 0.0028b647520 4 6 18 17 0.0037b647521 4 6 18 12 0.0026b647522 4 6 18 16 0.0040b647523 4 6 18 16 0.0119b647524 4 6 18 14 0.0031b647525 4 6 18 10 0.0028b647526 4 6 18 13 0.0027b647527 4 6 18 8 0.0026b647528 4 6 18 15 0.0030b647529 4 6 18 12 0.0040

Table 34: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 124: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb647530 4 6 18 11 0.0027b647531 4 6 18 18 0.0038b647532 4 6 18 14 0.0034b647533 4 6 18 20 0.0085b647534 4 6 18 13 0.0031b647535 4 6 18 14 0.0036b647536 4 6 18 16 0.0060b647537 4 6 18 16 0.0042b647538 4 6 18 11 0.0029b647539 4 6 18 13 0.0040b647540 4 6 18 12 0.0029b647541 4 6 18 15 0.0029b647542 4 6 18 13 0.0083b647543 4 6 18 10 0.0026b647544 4 6 18 14 0.0032b647545 4 6 18 13 0.0029b647546 4 6 18 14 0.0038b647547 4 6 18 13 0.0032b647548 4 6 18 12 0.0027b647549 4 6 18 15 0.0040b655510 5 6 16 6 0.0026b655511 5 6 16 12 0.0025b655512 5 6 16 11 0.0024b655513 5 6 16 8 0.0025b655514 5 6 16 10 0.0025b655515 5 6 16 10 0.0025b655516 5 6 16 9 0.0029b655517 5 6 16 11 0.0026b655518 5 6 16 10 0.0026b655519 5 6 16 12 0.0035b655520 5 6 16 11 0.0025b655521 5 6 16 8 0.0025b655522 5 6 16 10 0.0025b655523 5 6 16 8 0.0025b655524 5 6 16 7 0.0025b655525 5 6 16 10 0.0025b655526 5 6 16 8 0.0025b655527 5 6 16 10 0.0026b655528 5 6 16 8 0.0026b655529 5 6 16 8 0.0029b655530 5 6 16 4 0.0058b655531 5 6 16 9 0.0063b655532 5 6 16 9 0.0059b655533 5 6 16 9 0.0063b655534 5 6 16 7 0.0056b655535 5 6 16 11 0.0061b655536 5 6 16 4 0.0052b655537 5 6 16 7 0.0053b655538 5 6 16 5 0.0048b655539 5 6 16 6 0.0050b655540 5 6 16 10 0.0047b655541 5 6 16 8 0.0046b655542 5 6 16 10 0.0052b655543 5 6 16 8 0.0043b655544 5 6 16 12 0.0042b655545 5 6 16 9 0.0040b655546 5 6 16 5 0.0044b655547 5 6 16 5 0.0040b655548 5 6 16 10 0.0040b655549 5 6 16 4 0.0039b656010 5 6 18 11 0.0046b656011 5 6 18 12 0.0040b656012 5 6 18 11 0.0040b656013 5 6 18 11 0.0039b656014 5 6 18 8 0.0041b656015 5 6 18 11 0.0038b656016 5 6 18 8 0.0037b656017 5 6 18 10 0.0041b656018 5 6 18 9 0.0072b656019 5 6 18 12 0.0036

Table 35: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 125: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb656020 5 6 18 7 0.0036b656021 5 6 18 10 0.0038b656022 5 6 18 12 0.0037b656023 5 6 18 13 0.0035b656024 5 6 18 14 0.0035b656025 5 6 18 7 0.0036b656026 5 6 18 10 0.0036b656027 5 6 18 12 0.0047b656028 5 6 18 11 0.0034b656029 5 6 18 7 0.0036b656030 5 6 18 6 0.0033b656031 5 6 18 9 0.0037b656032 5 6 18 9 0.0032b656033 5 6 18 10 0.0032b656034 5 6 18 7 0.0031b656035 5 6 18 12 0.0032b656036 5 6 18 10 0.0031b656037 5 6 18 11 0.0031b656038 5 6 18 13 0.0034b656039 5 6 18 10 0.0036b656040 5 6 18 11 0.0032b656041 5 6 18 14 0.0192b656042 5 6 18 9 0.0032b656043 5 6 18 10 0.0030b656044 5 6 18 11 0.0036b656045 5 6 18 9 0.0029b656046 5 6 18 11 0.0031b656047 5 6 18 10 0.0028b656048 5 6 18 9 0.0031b656049 5 6 18 13 0.0069b656510 5 6 19 9 0.0029b656511 5 6 19 12 0.0033b656512 5 6 19 12 0.0030b656513 5 6 19 11 0.0030b656514 5 6 19 9 0.0029b656515 5 6 19 12 0.0028b656516 5 6 19 13 0.0040b656517 5 6 19 11 0.0028b656518 5 6 19 10 0.0029b656519 5 6 19 12 0.0028b656520 5 6 19 9 0.0031b656521 5 6 19 15 0.0030b656522 5 6 19 11 0.0031b656523 5 6 19 9 0.0028b656524 5 6 19 10 0.0029b656525 5 6 19 9 0.0029b656526 5 6 19 10 0.0029b656527 5 6 19 14 0.0362b656528 5 6 19 16 0.0028b656529 5 6 19 9 0.0032b656530 5 6 19 7 0.0029b656531 5 6 19 15 0.0322b656532 5 6 19 10 0.0036b656533 5 6 19 10 0.0028b656534 5 6 19 14 0.0028b656535 5 6 19 13 0.0028b656536 5 6 19 10 0.0028b656537 5 6 19 11 0.0030b656538 5 6 19 14 0.0028b656539 5 6 19 9 0.0031b656540 5 6 19 12 0.0034b656541 5 6 19 14 0.0112b656542 5 6 19 10 0.0101b656543 5 6 19 12 0.0028b656544 5 6 19 9 0.0038b656545 5 6 19 12 0.0041b656546 5 6 19 12 0.0032b656547 5 6 19 12 0.0028b656548 5 6 19 13 0.0040b656549 5 6 19 9 0.0027

Table 36: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 126: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb657010 5 6 21 13 0.0034b657011 5 6 21 16 0.0036b657012 5 6 21 13 0.0039b657013 5 6 21 13 0.0036b657014 5 6 21 19 0.0416b657015 5 6 21 14 0.0152b657016 5 6 21 16 0.0212b657017 5 6 21 15 0.0098b657018 5 6 21 14 0.0058b657019 5 6 21 9 0.0033b657020 5 6 21 11 0.0033b657021 5 6 21 16 0.0031b657022 5 6 21 16 0.0030b657023 5 6 21 15 0.0032b657024 5 6 21 11 0.0034b657025 5 6 21 15 0.0050b657026 5 6 21 17 0.0067b657027 5 6 21 13 0.0032b657028 5 6 21 9 0.0036b657029 5 6 21 11 0.0040b657030 5 6 21 12 0.0031b657031 5 6 21 14 0.0031b657032 5 6 21 11 0.0033b657033 5 6 21 17 0.0036b657034 5 6 21 14 0.0060b657035 5 6 21 17 0.0082b657036 5 6 21 14 0.0044b657037 5 6 21 11 0.0034b657038 5 6 21 7 0.0031b657039 5 6 21 13 0.0044b657040 5 6 21 13 0.0032b657041 5 6 21 14 0.0040b657042 5 6 21 11 0.0033b657043 5 6 21 6 0.0030b657044 5 6 21 11 0.0031b657045 5 6 21 15 0.0052b657046 5 6 21 15 0.0030b657047 5 6 21 17 0.0870b657048 5 6 21 12 0.0032b657049 5 6 21 18 0.0581b657510 5 6 22 20 0.0830b657511 5 6 22 15 0.0288b657512 5 6 22 18 0.0045b657513 5 6 22 16 0.0036b657514 5 6 22 16 0.0042b657515 5 6 22 23 0.0910b657516 5 6 22 14 0.0033b657517 5 6 22 19 0.0685b657518 5 6 22 15 0.0181b657519 5 6 22 12 0.0032b657520 5 6 22 17 0.0138b657521 5 6 22 16 0.0222b657522 5 6 22 17 0.0228b657523 5 6 22 15 0.0061b657524 5 6 22 18 0.1189b657525 5 6 22 14 0.0034b657526 5 6 22 18 0.1290b657527 5 6 22 13 0.0058b657528 5 6 22 18 0.0053b657529 5 6 22 17 0.0061b657530 5 6 22 15 0.0034b657531 5 6 22 17 0.0143b657532 5 6 22 16 0.0396b657533 5 6 22 17 0.0214b657534 5 6 22 19 0.0040b657535 5 6 22 15 0.0033b657536 5 6 22 17 0.0165b657537 5 6 22 13 0.0043b657538 5 6 22 7 0.0034b657539 5 6 22 17 0.0698

Table 37: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 127: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb657540 5 6 22 15 0.0034b657541 5 6 22 16 0.0032b657542 5 6 22 15 0.0063b657543 5 6 22 17 0.0071b657544 5 6 22 15 0.0052b657545 5 6 22 14 0.0119b657546 5 6 22 9 0.0033b657547 5 6 22 16 0.0033b657548 5 6 22 9 0.0031b657549 5 6 22 16 0.0045b665510 6 6 19 12 0.0029b665511 6 6 19 7 0.0033b665512 6 6 19 12 0.0030b665513 6 6 19 14 0.0048b665514 6 6 19 8 0.0029b665515 6 6 19 7 0.0029b665516 6 6 19 9 0.0029b665517 6 6 19 10 0.0029b665518 6 6 19 9 0.0029b665519 6 6 19 9 0.0029b665520 6 6 19 9 0.0033b665521 6 6 19 9 0.0030b665522 6 6 19 10 0.0030b665523 6 6 19 8 0.0030b665524 6 6 19 12 0.0125b665525 6 6 19 8 0.0030b665526 6 6 19 11 0.0030b665527 6 6 19 7 0.0041b665528 6 6 19 9 0.0031b665529 6 6 19 10 0.0030b665530 6 6 19 10 0.0029b665531 6 6 19 8 0.0029b665532 6 6 19 8 0.0030b665533 6 6 19 6 0.0031b665534 6 6 19 5 0.0030b665535 6 6 19 7 0.0029b665536 6 6 19 7 0.0035b665537 6 6 19 7 0.0036b665538 6 6 19 10 0.0034b665539 6 6 19 13 0.0032b665540 6 6 19 9 0.0047b665541 6 6 19 11 0.0033b665542 6 6 19 10 0.0033b665543 6 6 19 10 0.0040b665544 6 6 19 7 0.0034b665545 6 6 19 11 0.0044b665546 6 6 19 7 0.0038b665547 6 6 19 9 0.0030b665548 6 6 19 7 0.0029b665549 6 6 19 7 0.0029b666010 6 6 21 13 0.0033b666011 6 6 21 11 0.0032b666012 6 6 21 12 0.0033b666013 6 6 21 11 0.0038b666014 6 6 21 17 0.0087b666015 6 6 21 12 0.0036b666016 6 6 21 11 0.0033b666017 6 6 21 11 0.0112b666018 6 6 21 13 0.0041b666019 6 6 21 9 0.0046b666020 6 6 21 10 0.0032b666021 6 6 21 11 0.0031b666022 6 6 21 12 0.0032b666023 6 6 21 11 0.0032b666024 6 6 21 15 0.0032b666025 6 6 21 10 0.0033b666026 6 6 21 13 0.0053b666027 6 6 21 12 0.0036b666028 6 6 21 14 0.0044b666029 6 6 21 13 0.0168

Table 38: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 128: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb666030 6 6 21 8 0.0035b666031 6 6 21 12 0.0036b666032 6 6 21 13 0.0066b666033 6 6 21 10 0.0031b666034 6 6 21 12 0.0039b666035 6 6 21 13 0.0031b666036 6 6 21 13 0.0031b666037 6 6 21 10 0.0033b666038 6 6 21 12 0.0036b666039 6 6 21 10 0.0033b666040 6 6 21 11 0.0033b666041 6 6 21 13 0.0032b666042 6 6 21 11 0.0032b666043 6 6 21 10 0.0035b666044 6 6 21 5 0.0034b666045 6 6 21 14 0.0504b666046 6 6 21 13 0.0034b666047 6 6 21 12 0.0032b666048 6 6 21 9 0.0034b666049 6 6 21 14 0.0035b666510 6 6 23 14 0.0049b666511 6 6 23 15 0.0035b666512 6 6 23 11 0.0125b666513 6 6 23 9 0.0036b666514 6 6 23 16 0.0136b666515 6 6 23 8 0.0036b666516 6 6 23 16 0.0037b666517 6 6 23 16 0.0050b666518 6 6 23 10 0.0035b666519 6 6 23 13 0.0035b666520 6 6 23 13 0.0034b666521 6 6 23 19 0.1878b666522 6 6 23 14 0.0118b666523 6 6 23 14 0.0038b666524 6 6 23 12 0.0036b666525 6 6 23 12 0.0035b666526 6 6 23 10 0.0041b666527 6 6 23 17 0.0081b666528 6 6 23 15 0.0039b666529 6 6 23 15 0.0035b666530 6 6 23 14 0.0034b666531 6 6 23 9 0.0035b666532 6 6 23 15 0.0040b666533 6 6 23 18 0.0054b666534 6 6 23 15 0.0037b666535 6 6 23 9 0.0036b666536 6 6 23 16 0.0035b666537 6 6 23 13 0.0076b666538 6 6 23 11 0.0035b666539 6 6 23 12 0.0039b666540 6 6 23 15 0.0047b666541 6 6 23 10 0.0042b666542 6 6 23 16 0.0046b666543 6 6 23 14 0.0037b666544 6 6 23 14 0.0035b666545 6 6 23 14 0.0035b666546 6 6 23 9 0.0036b666547 6 6 23 13 0.0038b666548 6 6 23 16 0.0043b666549 6 6 23 12 0.0036b667010 6 6 25 19 0.0169b667011 6 6 25 19 0.0228b667012 6 6 25 15 0.0131b667013 6 6 25 18 0.2295b667014 6 6 25 16 0.0040b667015 6 6 25 21 0.2208b667016 6 6 25 15 0.0038b667017 6 6 25 13 0.0039b667018 6 6 25 12 0.0040b667019 6 6 25 18 0.0395

Table 39: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 129: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb667020 6 6 25 13 0.0039b667021 6 6 25 11 0.0044b667022 6 6 25 15 0.0042b667023 6 6 25 15 0.0041b667024 6 6 25 17 0.0788b667025 6 6 25 16 0.0038b667026 6 6 25 14 0.0038b667027 6 6 25 14 0.0039b667028 6 6 25 18 0.0077b667029 6 6 25 12 0.0064b667030 6 6 25 22 0.0371b667031 6 6 25 16 0.1150b667032 6 6 25 16 0.0041b667033 6 6 25 15 0.0039b667034 6 6 25 21 0.0539b667035 6 6 25 14 0.0044b667036 6 6 25 13 0.0038b667037 6 6 25 19 0.0106b667038 6 6 25 17 0.1207b667039 6 6 25 15 0.0042b667040 6 6 25 14 0.0038b667041 6 6 25 16 0.0759b667042 6 6 25 19 0.0306b667043 6 6 25 14 0.0044b667044 6 6 25 14 0.0152b667045 6 6 25 16 0.0041b667046 6 6 25 7 0.0044b667047 6 6 25 13 0.0040b667048 6 6 25 16 0.0324b667049 6 6 25 17 0.0046b667510 6 6 27 20 0.1124b667511 6 6 27 20 0.0043b667512 6 6 27 19 0.0043b667513 6 6 27 14 0.0046b667514 6 6 27 15 0.0043b667515 6 6 27 17 0.2398b667516 6 6 27 20 0.0374b667517 6 6 27 21 0.0609b667518 6 6 27 17 0.0060b667519 6 6 27 21 0.0573b667520 6 6 27 19 0.0044b667521 6 6 27 27 0.0501b667522 6 6 27 14 0.0207b667523 6 6 27 19 0.0045b667524 6 6 27 23 0.0325b667525 6 6 27 18 0.0060b667526 6 6 27 22 0.1269b667527 6 6 27 19 0.4469b667528 6 6 27 15 0.0673b667529 6 6 27 16 0.0048b667530 6 6 27 13 0.0075b667531 6 6 27 22 0.1461b667532 6 6 27 14 0.0051b667533 6 6 27 21 0.0046b667534 6 6 27 18 0.0054b667535 6 6 27 18 0.0043b667536 6 6 27 20 0.0215b667537 6 6 27 16 0.0082b667538 6 6 27 14 0.0234b667539 6 6 27 14 0.0049b667540 6 6 27 22 0.0464b667541 6 6 27 24 0.3282b667542 6 6 27 22 0.0293b667543 6 6 27 16 0.0179b667544 6 6 27 19 0.0051b667545 6 6 27 18 0.0264b667546 6 6 27 18 0.0085b667547 6 6 27 19 0.2066b667548 6 6 27 19 0.0822b667549 6 6 27 19 0.0811

Table 40: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 130: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb675510 7 6 23 10 0.0036b675511 7 6 23 10 0.0035b675512 7 6 23 10 0.0039b675513 7 6 23 10 0.0039b675514 7 6 23 12 0.0037b675515 7 6 23 13 0.0585b675516 7 6 23 10 0.0037b675517 7 6 23 10 0.0036b675518 7 6 23 10 0.0037b675519 7 6 23 16 0.0036b675520 7 6 23 9 0.0036b675521 7 6 23 12 0.0036b675522 7 6 23 12 0.0057b675523 7 6 23 10 0.0040b675524 7 6 23 9 0.0037b675525 7 6 23 7 0.0036b675526 7 6 23 13 0.0035b675527 7 6 23 10 0.0036b675528 7 6 23 12 0.0229b675529 7 6 23 13 0.0036b675530 7 6 23 15 0.1086b675531 7 6 23 8 0.0036b675532 7 6 23 13 0.0036b675533 7 6 23 15 0.0052b675534 7 6 23 7 0.0038b675535 7 6 23 13 0.0037b675536 7 6 23 14 0.0036b675537 7 6 23 13 0.0174b675538 7 6 23 13 0.0038b675539 7 6 23 11 0.0067b675540 7 6 23 13 0.0037b675541 7 6 23 6 0.0041b675542 7 6 23 15 0.0039b675543 7 6 23 14 0.0037b675544 7 6 23 12 0.0035b675545 7 6 23 11 0.0037b675546 7 6 23 14 0.0046b675547 7 6 23 17 0.0680b675548 7 6 23 12 0.0058b675549 7 6 23 10 0.0036b676010 7 6 25 12 0.0240b676011 7 6 25 15 0.0046b676012 7 6 25 13 0.0041b676013 7 6 25 18 0.0039b676014 7 6 25 13 0.0038b676015 7 6 25 14 0.0040b676016 7 6 25 13 0.0045b676017 7 6 25 13 0.0811b676018 7 6 25 12 0.0158b676019 7 6 25 19 0.0040b676020 7 6 25 14 0.0039b676021 7 6 25 15 0.0043b676022 7 6 25 16 0.0042b676023 7 6 25 11 0.0063b676024 7 6 25 14 0.0038b676025 7 6 25 12 0.0041b676026 7 6 25 16 0.0039b676027 7 6 25 13 0.0174b676028 7 6 25 12 0.0040b676029 7 6 25 12 0.0039b676030 7 6 25 17 0.2979b676031 7 6 25 14 0.0059b676032 7 6 25 15 0.0040b676033 7 6 25 15 0.0156b676034 7 6 25 12 0.0045b676035 7 6 25 11 0.0043b676036 7 6 25 13 0.0039b676037 7 6 25 13 0.0039b676038 7 6 25 12 0.0039b676039 7 6 25 15 0.2766

Table 41: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 131: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb676040 7 6 25 8 0.0039b676041 7 6 25 16 0.0218b676042 7 6 25 14 0.0042b676043 7 6 25 9 0.0041b676044 7 6 25 13 0.0040b676045 7 6 25 15 0.0084b676046 7 6 25 16 0.0045b676047 7 6 25 12 0.0040b676048 7 6 25 16 0.0045b676049 7 6 25 12 0.0041b676510 7 6 27 13 0.0044b676511 7 6 27 17 0.2608b676512 7 6 27 17 0.0042b676513 7 6 27 13 0.0043b676514 7 6 27 15 0.0174b676515 7 6 27 11 0.0045b676516 7 6 27 13 0.0044b676517 7 6 27 13 0.0041b676518 7 6 27 14 0.0042b676519 7 6 27 18 0.4912b676520 7 6 27 11 0.0041b676521 7 6 27 17 0.0873b676522 7 6 27 14 0.0043b676523 7 6 27 14 0.0054b676524 7 6 27 14 0.0059b676525 7 6 27 14 0.0043b676526 7 6 27 15 0.0042b676527 7 6 27 17 0.0400b676528 7 6 27 13 0.0043b676529 7 6 27 19 0.0105b676530 7 6 27 9 0.0043b676531 7 6 27 13 0.0047b676532 7 6 27 14 0.0045b676533 7 6 27 19 0.0731b676534 7 6 27 18 0.0045b676535 7 6 27 10 0.0128b676536 7 6 27 10 0.0043b676537 7 6 27 13 0.0102b676538 7 6 27 15 0.0089b676539 7 6 27 18 0.0228b676540 7 6 27 15 0.0043b676541 7 6 27 16 0.3788b676542 7 6 27 15 0.0077b676543 7 6 27 12 0.0086b676544 7 6 27 12 0.0043b676545 7 6 27 15 0.0043b676546 7 6 27 12 0.0044b676547 7 6 27 14 0.0046b676548 7 6 27 15 0.0611b676549 7 6 27 10 0.0042b677010 7 6 29 15 0.0207b677011 7 6 29 10 0.0049b677012 7 6 29 21 0.7911b677013 7 6 29 17 0.0054b677014 7 6 29 18 0.0701b677015 7 6 29 14 0.0619b677016 7 6 29 20 0.0053b677017 7 6 29 19 0.0047b677018 7 6 29 17 0.5968b677019 7 6 29 17 0.0162b677020 7 6 29 17 0.0046b677021 7 6 29 20 0.0051b677022 7 6 29 14 0.0050b677023 7 6 29 21 0.3642b677024 7 6 29 20 0.0045b677025 7 6 29 15 0.0046b677026 7 6 29 21 0.2847b677027 7 6 29 18 0.0046b677028 7 6 29 14 0.0047b677029 7 6 29 15 0.0050

Table 42: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 132: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb677030 7 6 29 21 0.1182b677031 7 6 29 21 0.1724b677032 7 6 29 20 0.1881b677033 7 6 29 16 0.0046b677034 7 6 29 15 0.0054b677035 7 6 29 20 0.1984b677036 7 6 29 18 0.0046b677037 7 6 29 18 0.0193b677038 7 6 29 15 0.0052b677039 7 6 29 19 0.4728b677040 7 6 29 16 0.0047b677041 7 6 29 16 0.0048b677042 7 6 29 20 0.9274b677043 7 6 29 17 0.0047b677044 7 6 29 15 0.0070b677045 7 6 29 12 0.0047b677046 7 6 29 17 0.0045b677047 7 6 29 20 0.2081b677048 7 6 29 13 0.0050b677049 7 6 29 16 0.0130b677510 7 6 31 25 0.6339b677511 7 6 31 22 0.1281b677512 7 6 31 21 0.0510b677513 7 6 31 21 0.0051b677514 7 6 31 12 0.0052b677515 7 6 31 23 0.0052b677516 7 6 31 21 0.0052b677517 7 6 31 22 0.1083b677518 7 6 31 25 0.9189b677519 7 6 31 25 0.5722b677520 7 6 31 16 0.0104b677521 7 6 31 21 0.0199b677522 7 6 31 23 0.9862b677523 7 6 31 23 0.2028b677524 7 6 31 21 0.0921b677525 7 6 31 21 0.1415b677526 7 6 31 20 0.2754b677527 7 6 31 20 0.2609b677528 7 6 31 17 0.0050b677529 7 6 31 20 0.0050b677530 7 6 31 23 0.4583b677531 7 6 31 23 0.1642b677532 7 6 31 17 0.2364b677533 7 6 31 19 0.2361b677534 7 6 31 22 0.1424b677535 7 6 31 14 0.0049b677536 7 6 31 22 0.1726b677537 7 6 31 25 0.0701b677538 7 6 31 24 0.2363b677539 7 6 31 17 0.0349b677540 7 6 31 18 0.0112b677541 7 6 31 20 0.0048b677542 7 6 31 22 0.2725b677543 7 6 31 22 0.1003b677544 7 6 31 17 0.0049b677545 7 6 31 23 0.1568b677546 7 6 31 15 0.0051b677547 7 6 31 19 0.0749b677548 7 6 31 15 0.0050b677549 7 6 31 19 0.0048b735510 3 7 11 8 0.0018b735511 3 7 11 11 0.0018b735512 3 7 11 7 0.0017b735513 3 7 11 10 0.0018b735514 3 7 11 7 0.0017b735515 3 7 11 5 0.0017b735516 3 7 11 10 0.0018b735517 3 7 11 7 0.0018b735518 3 7 11 11 0.0020b735519 3 7 11 5 0.0018

Table 43: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 133: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb735520 3 7 11 5 0.0018b735521 3 7 11 8 0.0017b735522 3 7 11 8 0.0017b735523 3 7 11 8 0.0018b735524 3 7 11 14 0.0023b735525 3 7 11 10 0.0018b735526 3 7 11 8 0.0017b735527 3 7 11 5 0.0017b735528 3 7 11 8 0.0017b735529 3 7 11 12 0.0019b735530 3 7 11 5 0.0017b735531 3 7 11 9 0.0016b735532 3 7 11 10 0.0017b735533 3 7 11 9 0.0017b735534 3 7 11 6 0.0019b735535 3 7 11 9 0.0019b735536 3 7 11 9 0.0019b735537 3 7 11 8 0.0017b735538 3 7 11 5 0.0017b735539 3 7 11 8 0.0017b735540 3 7 11 9 0.0017b735541 3 7 11 5 0.0016b735542 3 7 11 6 0.0017b735543 3 7 11 7 0.0017b735544 3 7 11 9 0.0019b735545 3 7 11 4 0.0017b735546 3 7 11 6 0.0017b735547 3 7 11 8 0.0016b735548 3 7 11 6 0.0016b735549 3 7 11 9 0.0017b736010 3 7 12 8 0.0021b736011 3 7 12 7 0.0019b736012 3 7 12 11 0.0021b736013 3 7 12 6 0.0018b736014 3 7 12 7 0.0019b736015 3 7 12 9 0.0018b736016 3 7 12 10 0.0018b736017 3 7 12 8 0.0018b736018 3 7 12 11 0.0020b736019 3 7 12 12 0.0021b736020 3 7 12 11 0.0019b736021 3 7 12 12 0.0020b736022 3 7 12 3 0.0018b736023 3 7 12 10 0.0018b736024 3 7 12 8 0.0018b736025 3 7 12 8 0.0020b736026 3 7 12 10 0.0020b736027 3 7 12 10 0.0021b736028 3 7 12 10 0.0019b736029 3 7 12 10 0.0019b736030 3 7 12 10 0.0018b736031 3 7 12 14 0.0021b736032 3 7 12 9 0.0018b736033 3 7 12 9 0.0019b736034 3 7 12 6 0.0018b736035 3 7 12 9 0.0018b736036 3 7 12 9 0.0018b736037 3 7 12 12 0.0021b736038 3 7 12 10 0.0017b736039 3 7 12 11 0.0019b736040 3 7 12 8 0.0019b736041 3 7 12 8 0.0018b736042 3 7 12 10 0.0019b736043 3 7 12 6 0.0019b736044 3 7 12 10 0.0020b736045 3 7 12 8 0.0018b736046 3 7 12 10 0.0018b736047 3 7 12 8 0.0018b736048 3 7 12 9 0.0018b736049 3 7 12 10 0.0018

Table 44: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 134: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb736510 3 7 13 8 0.0019b736511 3 7 13 12 0.0020b736512 3 7 13 13 0.0021b736513 3 7 13 15 0.0025b736514 3 7 13 11 0.0020b736515 3 7 13 7 0.0021b736516 3 7 13 4 0.0020b736517 3 7 13 11 0.0019b736518 3 7 13 8 0.0019b736519 3 7 13 11 0.0020b736520 3 7 13 12 0.0019b736521 3 7 13 11 0.0020b736522 3 7 13 8 0.0019b736523 3 7 13 11 0.0019b736524 3 7 13 8 0.0020b736525 3 7 13 15 0.0022b736526 3 7 13 12 0.0020b736527 3 7 13 10 0.0019b736528 3 7 13 12 0.0020b736529 3 7 13 9 0.0020b736530 3 7 13 7 0.0019b736531 3 7 13 11 0.0020b736532 3 7 13 7 0.0020b736533 3 7 13 12 0.0020b736534 3 7 13 7 0.0019b736535 3 7 13 11 0.0020b736536 3 7 13 6 0.0019b736537 3 7 13 10 0.0021b736538 3 7 13 12 0.0021b736539 3 7 13 11 0.0019b736540 3 7 13 14 0.0024b736541 3 7 13 12 0.0019b736542 3 7 13 12 0.0020b736543 3 7 13 10 0.0020b736544 3 7 13 6 0.0019b736545 3 7 13 8 0.0020b736546 3 7 13 11 0.0020b736547 3 7 13 7 0.0020b736548 3 7 13 12 0.0020b736549 3 7 13 10 0.0019b737010 3 7 14 10 0.0020b737011 3 7 14 16 0.0024b737012 3 7 14 16 0.0023b737013 3 7 14 13 0.0023b737014 3 7 14 5 0.0020b737015 3 7 14 11 0.0021b737016 3 7 14 6 0.0020b737017 3 7 14 16 0.0023b737018 3 7 14 12 0.0022b737019 3 7 14 11 0.0021b737020 3 7 14 11 0.0020b737021 3 7 14 12 0.0022b737022 3 7 14 12 0.0021b737023 3 7 14 10 0.0021b737024 3 7 14 14 0.0022b737025 3 7 14 15 0.0021b737026 3 7 14 17 0.0023b737027 3 7 14 16 0.0025b737028 3 7 14 8 0.0020b737029 3 7 14 13 0.0021b737030 3 7 14 16 0.0024b737031 3 7 14 9 0.0021b737032 3 7 14 12 0.0021b737033 3 7 14 9 0.0021b737034 3 7 14 11 0.0022b737035 3 7 14 13 0.0020b737036 3 7 14 14 0.0021b737037 3 7 14 14 0.0022b737038 3 7 14 12 0.0022b737039 3 7 14 6 0.0020

Table 45: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 135: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb737040 3 7 14 8 0.0020b737041 3 7 14 11 0.0021b737042 3 7 14 12 0.0022b737043 3 7 14 10 0.0023b737044 3 7 14 13 0.0024b737045 3 7 14 12 0.0022b737046 3 7 14 14 0.0021b737047 3 7 14 9 0.0020b737048 3 7 14 13 0.0020b737049 3 7 14 7 0.0020b737510 3 7 15 15 0.0022b737511 3 7 15 14 0.0022b737512 3 7 15 21 0.0038b737513 3 7 15 16 0.0024b737514 3 7 15 13 0.0022b737515 3 7 15 16 0.0024b737516 3 7 15 18 0.0026b737517 3 7 15 18 0.0025b737518 3 7 15 13 0.0023b737519 3 7 15 6 0.0022b737520 3 7 15 11 0.0022b737521 3 7 15 16 0.0023b737522 3 7 15 20 0.0027b737523 3 7 15 17 0.0028b737524 3 7 15 15 0.0024b737525 3 7 15 15 0.0025b737526 3 7 15 11 0.0022b737527 3 7 15 13 0.0024b737528 3 7 15 20 0.0024b737529 3 7 15 9 0.0022b737530 3 7 15 17 0.0027b737531 3 7 15 12 0.0023b737532 3 7 15 16 0.0029b737533 3 7 15 20 0.0027b737534 3 7 15 15 0.0027b737535 3 7 15 7 0.0021b737536 3 7 15 11 0.0021b737537 3 7 15 18 0.0023b737538 3 7 15 13 0.0022b737539 3 7 15 10 0.0022b737540 3 7 15 17 0.0025b737541 3 7 15 11 0.0023b737542 3 7 15 15 0.0027b737543 3 7 15 19 0.0028b737544 3 7 15 10 0.0021b737545 3 7 15 15 0.0021b737546 3 7 15 14 0.0022b737547 3 7 15 16 0.0040b737548 3 7 15 12 0.0022b737549 3 7 15 9 0.0021b745510 4 7 15 9 0.0022b745511 4 7 15 6 0.0023b745512 4 7 15 10 0.0024b745513 4 7 15 8 0.0024b745514 4 7 15 11 0.0026b745515 4 7 15 12 0.0034b745516 4 7 15 5 0.0024b745517 4 7 15 11 0.0025b745518 4 7 15 12 0.0025b745519 4 7 15 10 0.0026b745520 4 7 15 8 0.0023b745521 4 7 15 7 0.0022b745522 4 7 15 10 0.0025b745523 4 7 15 12 0.0027b745524 4 7 15 11 0.0026b745525 4 7 15 13 0.0025b745526 4 7 15 8 0.0022b745527 4 7 15 10 0.0023b745528 4 7 15 10 0.0023b745529 4 7 15 14 0.0023

Table 46: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 136: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb745530 4 7 15 13 0.0026b745531 4 7 15 9 0.0022b745532 4 7 15 11 0.0022b745533 4 7 15 8 0.0022b745534 4 7 15 11 0.0024b745535 4 7 15 11 0.0026b745536 4 7 15 7 0.0023b745537 4 7 15 11 0.0022b745538 4 7 15 4 0.0023b745539 4 7 15 9 0.0022b745540 4 7 15 9 0.0022b745541 4 7 15 7 0.0023b745542 4 7 15 13 0.0028b745543 4 7 15 8 0.0022b745544 4 7 15 6 0.0023b745545 4 7 15 7 0.0022b745546 4 7 15 8 0.0022b745547 4 7 15 8 0.0025b745548 4 7 15 9 0.0024b745549 4 7 15 4 0.0024b746010 4 7 16 10 0.0024b746011 4 7 16 10 0.0024b746012 4 7 16 14 0.0024b746013 4 7 16 12 0.0026b746014 4 7 16 13 0.0033b746015 4 7 16 12 0.0027b746016 4 7 16 14 0.0050b746017 4 7 16 8 0.0023b746018 4 7 16 11 0.0030b746019 4 7 16 7 0.0026b746020 4 7 16 11 0.0028b746021 4 7 16 9 0.0026b746022 4 7 16 13 0.0027b746023 4 7 16 12 0.0082b746024 4 7 16 11 0.0023b746025 4 7 16 10 0.0023b746026 4 7 16 15 0.0034b746027 4 7 16 8 0.0027b746028 4 7 16 11 0.0026b746029 4 7 16 13 0.0043b746030 4 7 16 14 0.0040b746031 4 7 16 8 0.0023b746032 4 7 16 9 0.0023b746033 4 7 16 10 0.0023b746034 4 7 16 10 0.0026b746035 4 7 16 12 0.0024b746036 4 7 16 11 0.0025b746037 4 7 16 10 0.0023b746038 4 7 16 10 0.0027b746039 4 7 16 8 0.0025b746040 4 7 16 8 0.0026b746041 4 7 16 13 0.0028b746042 4 7 16 11 0.0028b746043 4 7 16 15 0.0068b746044 4 7 16 15 0.0049b746045 4 7 16 10 0.0025b746046 4 7 16 12 0.0024b746047 4 7 16 10 0.0026b746048 4 7 16 13 0.0024b746049 4 7 16 11 0.0040b746510 4 7 18 12 0.0027b746511 4 7 18 18 0.0082b746512 4 7 18 15 0.0026b746513 4 7 18 12 0.0027b746514 4 7 18 16 0.0045b746515 4 7 18 16 0.0040b746516 4 7 18 12 0.0027b746517 4 7 18 12 0.0031b746518 4 7 18 10 0.0025b746519 4 7 18 14 0.0223

Table 47: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 137: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb746520 4 7 18 16 0.0041b746521 4 7 18 13 0.0029b746522 4 7 18 18 0.0055b746523 4 7 18 13 0.0026b746524 4 7 18 9 0.0026b746525 4 7 18 15 0.0055b746526 4 7 18 16 0.0121b746527 4 7 18 12 0.0027b746528 4 7 18 14 0.0036b746529 4 7 18 14 0.0025b746530 4 7 18 14 0.0029b746531 4 7 18 15 0.0041b746532 4 7 18 16 0.0048b746533 4 7 18 17 0.0030b746534 4 7 18 12 0.0026b746535 4 7 18 14 0.0036b746536 4 7 18 9 0.0026b746537 4 7 18 13 0.0027b746538 4 7 18 14 0.0033b746539 4 7 18 14 0.0040b746540 4 7 18 14 0.0028b746541 4 7 18 11 0.0025b746542 4 7 18 11 0.0029b746543 4 7 18 16 0.0037b746544 4 7 18 13 0.0030b746545 4 7 18 12 0.0027b746546 4 7 18 10 0.0026b746547 4 7 18 10 0.0025b746548 4 7 18 12 0.0037b746549 4 7 18 16 0.0047b747010 4 7 19 12 0.0030b747011 4 7 19 15 0.0039b747012 4 7 19 13 0.0034b747013 4 7 19 16 0.0069b747014 4 7 19 17 0.0033b747015 4 7 19 14 0.0064b747016 4 7 19 19 0.0048b747017 4 7 19 15 0.0027b747018 4 7 19 14 0.0047b747019 4 7 19 13 0.0030b747020 4 7 19 15 0.0032b747021 4 7 19 13 0.0030b747022 4 7 19 14 0.0048b747023 4 7 19 18 0.0029b747024 4 7 19 13 0.0035b747025 4 7 19 18 0.0089b747026 4 7 19 13 0.0036b747027 4 7 19 17 0.0365b747028 4 7 19 16 0.0047b747029 4 7 19 15 0.0055b747030 4 7 19 17 0.0091b747031 4 7 19 12 0.0037b747032 4 7 19 14 0.0029b747033 4 7 19 16 0.0062b747034 4 7 19 15 0.0036b747035 4 7 19 17 0.0199b747036 4 7 19 16 0.0083b747037 4 7 19 11 0.0045b747038 4 7 19 12 0.0027b747039 4 7 19 10 0.0030b747040 4 7 19 13 0.0028b747041 4 7 19 16 0.0153b747042 4 7 19 17 0.0667b747043 4 7 19 12 0.0034b747044 4 7 19 14 0.0029b747045 4 7 19 16 0.0122b747046 4 7 19 17 0.0440b747047 4 7 19 13 0.0034b747048 4 7 19 11 0.0031b747049 4 7 19 15 0.0035

Table 48: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 138: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb747510 4 7 21 24 0.0186b747511 4 7 21 19 0.0042b747512 4 7 21 12 0.0035b747513 4 7 21 20 0.0316b747514 4 7 21 17 0.0032b747515 4 7 21 12 0.0030b747516 4 7 21 14 0.0038b747517 4 7 21 19 0.0040b747518 4 7 21 22 0.0662b747519 4 7 21 16 0.0032b747520 4 7 21 18 0.0037b747521 4 7 21 18 0.0155b747522 4 7 21 13 0.0031b747523 4 7 21 18 0.0051b747524 4 7 21 19 0.0208b747525 4 7 21 21 0.0041b747526 4 7 21 23 0.1721b747527 4 7 21 21 0.0171b747528 4 7 21 18 0.0071b747529 4 7 21 18 0.0041b747530 4 7 21 19 0.0181b747531 4 7 21 10 0.0030b747532 4 7 21 14 0.0030b747533 4 7 21 19 0.0448b747534 4 7 21 20 0.0060b747535 4 7 21 18 0.0756b747536 4 7 21 13 0.0030b747537 4 7 21 21 0.0268b747538 4 7 21 17 0.0037b747539 4 7 21 15 0.0032b747540 4 7 21 14 0.0029b747541 4 7 21 14 0.0036b747542 4 7 21 14 0.0031b747543 4 7 21 18 0.0067b747544 4 7 21 20 0.0087b747545 4 7 21 14 0.0035b747546 4 7 21 20 0.0033b747547 4 7 21 17 0.0031b747548 4 7 21 22 0.0349b747549 4 7 21 20 0.0044b755510 5 7 19 15 0.0029b755511 5 7 19 11 0.0031b755512 5 7 19 13 0.0031b755513 5 7 19 11 0.0038b755514 5 7 19 10 0.0031b755515 5 7 19 6 0.0029b755516 5 7 19 17 0.2587b755517 5 7 19 13 0.0030b755518 5 7 19 8 0.0028b755519 5 7 19 9 0.0034b755520 5 7 19 12 0.0031b755521 5 7 19 13 0.0030b755522 5 7 19 11 0.0033b755523 5 7 19 10 0.0029b755524 5 7 19 16 0.0897b755525 5 7 19 8 0.0028b755526 5 7 19 6 0.0029b755527 5 7 19 9 0.0029b755528 5 7 19 12 0.0029b755529 5 7 19 16 0.0060b755530 5 7 19 10 0.0029b755531 5 7 19 14 0.0111b755532 5 7 19 12 0.0030b755533 5 7 19 12 0.0028b755534 5 7 19 8 0.0029b755535 5 7 19 9 0.0029b755536 5 7 19 12 0.0040b755537 5 7 19 11 0.0028b755538 5 7 19 7 0.0028b755539 5 7 19 10 0.0033

Table 49: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 139: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb755540 5 7 19 16 0.0130b755541 5 7 19 13 0.0033b755542 5 7 19 12 0.0028b755543 5 7 19 11 0.0029b755544 5 7 19 14 0.0033b755545 5 7 19 8 0.0028b755546 5 7 19 10 0.0032b755547 5 7 19 12 0.0042b755548 5 7 19 8 0.0029b755549 5 7 19 9 0.0029b756010 5 7 21 13 0.0031b756011 5 7 21 14 0.0031b756012 5 7 21 11 0.0031b756013 5 7 21 15 0.0354b756014 5 7 21 8 0.0033b756015 5 7 21 10 0.0034b756016 5 7 21 12 0.0033b756017 5 7 21 12 0.0033b756018 5 7 21 8 0.0032b756019 5 7 21 15 0.0031b756020 5 7 21 16 0.0051b756021 5 7 21 12 0.0032b756022 5 7 21 16 0.0459b756023 5 7 21 13 0.0031b756024 5 7 21 12 0.0037b756025 5 7 21 15 0.0632b756026 5 7 21 17 0.1090b756027 5 7 21 15 0.0031b756028 5 7 21 9 0.0031b756029 5 7 21 14 0.0083b756030 5 7 21 11 0.0032b756031 5 7 21 14 0.0034b756032 5 7 21 15 0.0131b756033 5 7 21 13 0.0031b756034 5 7 21 14 0.0045b756035 5 7 21 15 0.0038b756036 5 7 21 16 0.0104b756037 5 7 21 13 0.0039b756038 5 7 21 14 0.0034b756039 5 7 21 18 0.0157b756040 5 7 21 13 0.0031b756041 5 7 21 12 0.0031b756042 5 7 21 11 0.0037b756043 5 7 21 17 0.0287b756044 5 7 21 15 0.0348b756045 5 7 21 11 0.0032b756046 5 7 21 14 0.0032b756047 5 7 21 13 0.0044b756048 5 7 21 13 0.0057b756049 5 7 21 13 0.0033b756510 5 7 22 14 0.0092b756511 5 7 22 14 0.0054b756512 5 7 22 14 0.0155b756513 5 7 22 18 0.0034b756514 5 7 22 15 0.0108b756515 5 7 22 17 0.0724b756516 5 7 22 17 0.0164b756517 5 7 22 17 0.1189b756518 5 7 22 12 0.0035b756519 5 7 22 15 0.0033b756520 5 7 22 17 0.0090b756521 5 7 22 15 0.0032b756522 5 7 22 16 0.0536b756523 5 7 22 11 0.0034b756524 5 7 22 11 0.0036b756525 5 7 22 18 0.1158b756526 5 7 22 18 0.0174b756527 5 7 22 19 0.0058b756528 5 7 22 12 0.0035b756529 5 7 22 14 0.0072

Table 50: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 140: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb756530 5 7 22 15 0.0277b756531 5 7 22 17 0.1135b756532 5 7 22 15 0.0045b756533 5 7 22 17 0.0959b756534 5 7 22 20 0.1754b756535 5 7 22 18 0.0258b756536 5 7 22 17 0.0041b756537 5 7 22 14 0.0034b756538 5 7 22 17 0.1151b756539 5 7 22 14 0.0204b756540 5 7 22 19 0.1678b756541 5 7 22 18 0.1999b756542 5 7 22 19 0.2489b756543 5 7 22 15 0.0035b756544 5 7 22 10 0.0032b756545 5 7 22 18 0.0045b756546 5 7 22 12 0.0036b756547 5 7 22 17 0.0056b756548 5 7 22 13 0.0091b756549 5 7 22 15 0.0075b757010 5 7 24 20 0.0893b757011 5 7 24 19 0.0039b757012 5 7 24 19 0.0068b757013 5 7 24 21 0.0040b757014 5 7 24 18 0.0191b757015 5 7 24 23 0.0982b757016 5 7 24 17 0.0037b757017 5 7 24 16 0.0035b757018 5 7 24 23 0.1416b757019 5 7 24 21 0.0191b757020 5 7 24 14 0.0343b757021 5 7 24 20 0.1002b757022 5 7 24 18 0.0528b757023 5 7 24 17 0.0063b757024 5 7 24 15 0.0038b757025 5 7 24 18 0.0045b757026 5 7 24 15 0.0038b757027 5 7 24 18 0.0077b757028 5 7 24 17 0.0036b757029 5 7 24 15 0.0063b757030 5 7 24 14 0.0145b757031 5 7 24 19 0.0064b757032 5 7 24 13 0.0066b757033 5 7 24 14 0.0044b757034 5 7 24 14 0.0039b757035 5 7 24 16 0.0148b757036 5 7 24 16 0.0081b757037 5 7 24 12 0.0046b757038 5 7 24 18 0.0055b757039 5 7 24 18 0.0093b757040 5 7 24 17 0.0050b757041 5 7 24 18 0.0035b757042 5 7 24 14 0.0040b757043 5 7 24 13 0.0038b757044 5 7 24 18 0.0968b757045 5 7 24 21 0.1531b757046 5 7 24 19 0.0143b757047 5 7 24 20 0.1936b757048 5 7 24 14 0.0041b757049 5 7 24 14 0.0040b757510 5 7 26 19 0.0540b757511 5 7 26 22 0.1438b757512 5 7 26 22 0.0062b757513 5 7 26 20 0.2815b757514 5 7 26 26 0.1241b757515 5 7 26 26 0.2128b757516 5 7 26 22 0.1546b757517 5 7 26 23 0.0416b757518 5 7 26 23 0.0114b757519 5 7 26 26 0.1017

Table 51: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 141: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb757520 5 7 26 19 0.0535b757521 5 7 26 21 0.0043b757522 5 7 26 19 0.0389b757523 5 7 26 24 0.1269b757524 5 7 26 20 0.0844b757525 5 7 26 18 0.0914b757526 5 7 26 14 0.0039b757527 5 7 26 22 0.1001b757528 5 7 26 25 0.3065b757529 5 7 26 19 0.0044b757530 5 7 26 24 0.1133b757531 5 7 26 22 0.0204b757532 5 7 26 23 0.2285b757533 5 7 26 19 0.0624b757534 5 7 26 18 0.1712b757535 5 7 26 15 0.0947b757536 5 7 26 23 0.0700b757537 5 7 26 22 0.0151b757538 5 7 26 26 0.4487b757539 5 7 26 23 0.0713b757540 5 7 26 20 0.0077b757541 5 7 26 20 0.1060b757542 5 7 26 20 0.0169b757543 5 7 26 21 0.0075b757544 5 7 26 19 0.0160b757545 5 7 26 21 0.0142b757546 5 7 26 25 0.1210b757547 5 7 26 19 0.0061b757548 5 7 26 20 0.1548b757549 5 7 26 24 0.0332b765510 6 7 23 11 0.0036b765511 6 7 23 13 0.0035b765512 6 7 23 14 0.0127b765513 6 7 23 12 0.0061b765514 6 7 23 12 0.0037b765515 6 7 23 13 0.0035b765516 6 7 23 10 0.0036b765517 6 7 23 9 0.0035b765518 6 7 23 16 0.0199b765519 6 7 23 13 0.0037b765520 6 7 23 12 0.0037b765521 6 7 23 16 0.0036b765522 6 7 23 13 0.0035b765523 6 7 23 13 0.0035b765524 6 7 23 14 0.0036b765525 6 7 23 18 0.1056b765526 6 7 23 13 0.0280b765527 6 7 23 10 0.0041b765528 6 7 23 13 0.0193b765529 6 7 23 17 0.0036b765530 6 7 23 15 0.0040b765531 6 7 23 11 0.0038b765532 6 7 23 8 0.0035b765533 6 7 23 15 0.0035b765534 6 7 23 11 0.0043b765535 6 7 23 11 0.0035b765536 6 7 23 12 0.0035b765537 6 7 23 14 0.0040b765538 6 7 23 10 0.0037b765539 6 7 23 13 0.0038b765540 6 7 23 15 0.0035b765541 6 7 23 17 0.0872b765542 6 7 23 12 0.0036b765543 6 7 23 11 0.0035b765544 6 7 23 13 0.0037b765545 6 7 23 14 0.0152b765546 6 7 23 12 0.0037b765547 6 7 23 12 0.0038b765548 6 7 23 15 0.0035b765549 6 7 23 13 0.0036

Table 52: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 142: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb766010 6 7 25 12 0.0037b766011 6 7 25 15 0.0307b766012 6 7 25 18 0.0038b766013 6 7 25 16 0.0088b766014 6 7 25 17 0.0099b766015 6 7 25 17 0.0381b766016 6 7 25 14 0.0095b766017 6 7 25 15 0.0043b766018 6 7 25 18 0.0045b766019 6 7 25 17 0.1246b766020 6 7 25 21 0.4059b766021 6 7 25 13 0.0039b766022 6 7 25 13 0.0038b766023 6 7 25 17 0.0045b766024 6 7 25 17 0.0316b766025 6 7 25 22 0.6678b766026 6 7 25 17 0.0172b766027 6 7 25 15 0.0038b766028 6 7 25 17 0.0409b766029 6 7 25 21 0.0043b766030 6 7 25 20 0.0040b766031 6 7 25 12 0.0040b766032 6 7 25 13 0.0042b766033 6 7 25 12 0.0038b766034 6 7 25 13 0.0071b766035 6 7 25 12 0.0067b766036 6 7 25 14 0.0216b766037 6 7 25 23 0.2821b766038 6 7 25 14 0.0272b766039 6 7 25 17 0.0526b766040 6 7 25 20 0.0038b766041 6 7 25 15 0.0055b766042 6 7 25 17 0.0041b766043 6 7 25 14 0.0040b766044 6 7 25 14 0.0038b766045 6 7 25 16 0.0116b766046 6 7 25 18 0.0040b766047 6 7 25 12 0.0044b766048 6 7 25 18 0.0075b766049 6 7 25 15 0.1515b766510 6 7 27 17 0.0055b766511 6 7 27 14 0.0041b766512 6 7 27 21 0.4661b766513 6 7 27 22 0.0365b766514 6 7 27 24 0.8766b766515 6 7 27 21 0.1199b766516 6 7 27 13 0.0063b766517 6 7 27 18 0.1133b766518 6 7 27 17 0.0095b766519 6 7 27 18 0.0384b766520 6 7 27 15 0.0042b766521 6 7 27 21 0.0042b766522 6 7 27 17 0.0828b766523 6 7 27 16 0.0205b766524 6 7 27 17 0.3826b766525 6 7 27 17 0.0041b766526 6 7 27 11 0.0042b766527 6 7 27 18 0.0533b766528 6 7 27 16 0.0072b766529 6 7 27 20 0.0048b766530 6 7 27 20 0.0160b766531 6 7 27 18 0.0414b766532 6 7 27 17 0.0049b766533 6 7 27 13 0.0042b766534 6 7 27 19 0.0119b766535 6 7 27 18 0.0044b766536 6 7 27 17 0.0043b766537 6 7 27 21 0.0137b766538 6 7 27 16 0.0042b766539 6 7 27 15 0.0049

Table 53: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 143: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb766540 6 7 27 14 0.0049b766541 6 7 27 15 0.1957b766542 6 7 27 19 0.0732b766543 6 7 27 18 0.0043b766544 6 7 27 16 0.0047b766545 6 7 27 18 0.0044b766546 6 7 27 20 0.0041b766547 6 7 27 19 0.0461b766548 6 7 27 21 0.4822b766549 6 7 27 15 0.0042b767010 6 7 29 22 0.5558b767011 6 7 29 24 0.1991b767012 6 7 29 25 0.2853b767013 6 7 29 22 0.0329b767014 6 7 29 25 0.2447b767015 6 7 29 18 0.2530b767016 6 7 29 22 0.4793b767017 6 7 29 19 0.0912b767018 6 7 29 20 0.2004b767019 6 7 29 22 0.1364b767020 6 7 29 22 0.1245b767021 6 7 29 14 0.0047b767022 6 7 29 23 0.2019b767023 6 7 29 20 0.1644b767024 6 7 29 19 0.0320b767025 6 7 29 22 0.1446b767026 6 7 29 26 0.6435b767027 6 7 29 21 0.0232b767028 6 7 29 25 0.2426b767029 6 7 29 23 0.3073b767030 6 7 29 19 0.0174b767031 6 7 29 21 0.1626b767032 6 7 29 20 0.3494b767033 6 7 29 21 0.5516b767034 6 7 29 25 0.0046b767035 6 7 29 22 0.1345b767036 6 7 29 21 0.0127b767037 6 7 29 18 0.0194b767038 6 7 29 20 0.1400b767039 6 7 29 21 0.0047b767040 6 7 29 19 0.1808b767041 6 7 29 21 0.0121b767042 6 7 29 19 0.0047b767043 6 7 29 21 0.0057b767044 6 7 29 15 0.0107b767045 6 7 29 23 0.6084b767046 6 7 29 20 0.4360b767047 6 7 29 19 0.0048b767048 6 7 29 16 0.1003b767049 6 7 29 21 0.3481b767510 6 7 31 27 0.3348b767511 6 7 31 22 0.4496b767512 6 7 31 26 0.2357b767513 6 7 31 17 0.1508b767514 6 7 31 26 0.4137b767515 6 7 31 24 0.5643b767516 6 7 31 24 0.0212b767517 6 7 31 20 0.5284b767518 6 7 31 28 0.1740b767519 6 7 31 23 0.1995b767520 6 7 31 18 0.0405b767521 6 7 31 24 0.0265b767522 6 7 31 25 0.2367b767523 6 7 31 25 0.6538b767524 6 7 31 18 0.0732b767525 6 7 31 19 0.1112b767526 6 7 31 25 0.0981b767527 6 7 31 27 0.0050b767528 6 7 31 26 0.1752b767529 6 7 31 27 0.0378

Table 54: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 144: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb767530 6 7 31 29 0.3174b767531 6 7 31 24 0.2455b767532 6 7 31 23 0.2716b767533 6 7 31 22 0.2147b767534 6 7 31 20 0.0098b767535 6 7 31 24 0.0758b767536 6 7 31 24 0.0082b767537 6 7 31 22 0.0115b767538 6 7 31 21 0.2483b767539 6 7 31 17 0.0050b767540 6 7 31 27 0.4890b767541 6 7 31 28 0.2709b767542 6 7 31 21 0.1273b767543 6 7 31 19 0.1022b767544 6 7 31 20 0.0049b767545 6 7 31 23 0.2115b767546 6 7 31 24 0.0522b767547 6 7 31 23 0.0154b767548 6 7 31 26 0.0098b767549 6 7 31 19 0.0290b775510 7 7 26 12 0.0031b775511 7 7 26 13 0.0041b775512 7 7 26 8 0.0042b775513 7 7 26 15 0.0047b775514 7 7 26 18 0.0045b775515 7 7 26 15 0.0041b775516 7 7 26 18 0.1129b775517 7 7 26 12 0.0041b775518 7 7 26 17 0.1668b775519 7 7 26 15 0.0054b775520 7 7 26 13 0.0329b775521 7 7 26 16 0.0041b775522 7 7 26 12 0.0041b775523 7 7 26 14 0.0520b775524 7 7 26 13 0.0041b775525 7 7 26 12 0.0041b775526 7 7 26 16 0.3767b775527 7 7 26 15 0.0041b775528 7 7 26 12 0.0041b775529 7 7 26 15 0.0057b775530 7 7 26 14 0.0076b775531 7 7 26 15 0.5013b775532 7 7 26 11 0.0058b775533 7 7 26 12 0.0047b775534 7 7 26 7 0.0044b775535 7 7 26 14 0.0041b775536 7 7 26 15 0.0856b775537 7 7 26 15 0.0051b775538 7 7 26 12 0.0040b775539 7 7 26 16 0.0142b775540 7 7 26 19 0.4481b775541 7 7 26 20 0.0040b775542 7 7 26 14 0.0041b775543 7 7 26 16 0.0054b775544 7 7 26 16 0.0439b775545 7 7 26 16 0.0045b775546 7 7 26 19 0.2479b775547 7 7 26 12 0.0042b775548 7 7 26 16 0.0613b775549 7 7 26 13 0.0144b776010 7 7 29 22 0.0890b776011 7 7 29 20 0.1772b776012 7 7 29 15 0.0320b776013 7 7 29 15 0.0053b776014 7 7 29 20 0.3929b776015 7 7 29 21 0.6321b776016 7 7 29 16 0.0874b776017 7 7 29 14 0.2258b776018 7 7 29 23 0.4289b776019 7 7 29 16 0.0046

Table 55: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 145: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb776020 7 7 29 14 0.0046b776021 7 7 29 20 0.0272b776022 7 7 29 19 0.0751b776023 7 7 29 15 0.0066b776024 7 7 29 11 0.0062b776025 7 7 29 20 0.0213b776026 7 7 29 15 0.0054b776027 7 7 29 19 0.3753b776028 7 7 29 19 0.4049b776029 7 7 29 19 0.4210b776030 7 7 29 17 0.0047b776031 7 7 29 17 0.0285b776032 7 7 29 18 0.0047b776033 7 7 29 14 0.1001b776034 7 7 29 15 0.0046b776035 7 7 29 15 0.0046b776036 7 7 29 18 0.0047b776037 7 7 29 17 0.0046b776038 7 7 29 16 0.0046b776039 7 7 29 22 0.6793b776040 7 7 29 20 0.0046b776041 7 7 29 20 0.4812b776042 7 7 29 20 0.0047b776043 7 7 29 16 0.0155b776044 7 7 29 19 0.0985b776045 7 7 29 19 0.0047b776046 7 7 29 18 0.1377b776047 7 7 29 22 0.3205b776048 7 7 29 20 0.0046b776049 7 7 29 19 0.1425b776510 7 7 31 21 0.1128b776511 7 7 31 19 0.1777b776512 7 7 31 23 0.0277b776513 7 7 31 18 0.0965b776514 7 7 31 22 0.2537b776515 7 7 31 16 0.0344b776516 7 7 31 23 0.0051b776517 7 7 31 22 0.2129b776518 7 7 31 21 0.0051b776519 7 7 31 20 0.0050b776520 7 7 31 18 0.0050b776521 7 7 31 21 0.1858b776522 7 7 31 22 0.0050b776523 7 7 31 24 0.3841b776524 7 7 31 14 0.0137b776525 7 7 31 21 0.3601b776526 7 7 31 20 0.1808b776527 7 7 31 19 0.3900b776528 7 7 31 19 0.1205b776529 7 7 31 28 1.0206b776530 7 7 31 22 0.0478b776531 7 7 31 15 0.0059b776532 7 7 31 21 0.3719b776533 7 7 31 14 0.0051b776534 7 7 31 19 0.0051b776535 7 7 31 17 0.6291b776536 7 7 31 18 0.0050b776537 7 7 31 22 0.1935b776538 7 7 31 15 0.0053b776539 7 7 31 21 0.1019b776540 7 7 31 11 0.0051b776541 7 7 31 20 0.1327b776542 7 7 31 16 0.0057b776543 7 7 31 18 0.0052b776544 7 7 31 20 0.0050b776545 7 7 31 20 0.0050b776546 7 7 31 21 0.0082b776547 7 7 31 19 0.0471b776548 7 7 31 18 0.0055b776549 7 7 31 19 0.0055

Table 56: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 146: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb777010 7 7 34 22 0.0237b777011 7 7 34 30 1.0177b777012 7 7 34 27 1.0627b777013 7 7 34 27 1.0141b777014 7 7 34 26 0.4426b777015 7 7 34 23 0.5308b777016 7 7 34 20 0.6193b777017 7 7 34 26 0.1758b777018 7 7 34 21 0.0054b777019 7 7 34 26 0.3669b777020 7 7 34 23 0.4545b777021 7 7 34 25 0.0053b777022 7 7 34 23 0.0065b777023 7 7 34 28 0.4795b777024 7 7 34 20 0.0055b777025 7 7 34 20 0.2505b777026 7 7 34 27 1.0545b777027 7 7 34 19 0.0100b777028 7 7 34 31 0.2868b777029 7 7 34 20 0.9104b777030 7 7 34 23 0.0548b777031 7 7 34 19 0.0055b777032 7 7 34 26 0.6489b777033 7 7 34 18 0.7816b777034 7 7 34 24 0.4754b777035 7 7 34 20 0.0068b777036 7 7 34 23 0.0116b777037 7 7 34 22 0.0060b777038 7 7 34 24 0.1145b777039 7 7 34 25 0.3082b777040 7 7 34 28 0.0640b777041 7 7 34 25 0.4220b777042 7 7 34 26 0.3917b777043 7 7 34 19 0.1146b777044 7 7 34 21 0.3933b777045 7 7 34 22 0.0058b777046 7 7 34 24 0.0058b777047 7 7 34 22 0.4357b777048 7 7 34 19 0.0097b777049 7 7 34 23 0.3258b777510 7 7 36 27 0.2485b777511 7 7 36 20 0.0056b777512 7 7 36 29 0.4181b777513 7 7 36 27 0.6116b777514 7 7 36 29 0.7770b777515 7 7 36 29 0.1134b777516 7 7 36 29 1.0030b777517 7 7 36 28 0.3212b777518 7 7 36 23 0.6701b777519 7 7 36 26 0.2117b777520 7 7 36 17 0.1066b777521 7 7 36 24 0.0117b777522 7 7 36 23 0.6811b777523 7 7 36 29 0.0058b777524 7 7 36 23 0.6265b777525 7 7 36 28 0.6991b777526 7 7 36 25 0.4137b777527 7 7 36 26 0.0058b777528 7 7 36 25 0.0619b777529 7 7 36 27 0.7743b777530 7 7 36 21 0.2909b777531 7 7 36 30 0.5184b777532 7 7 36 29 0.7150b777533 7 7 36 30 1.0161b777534 7 7 36 26 0.0061b777535 7 7 36 26 0.0057b777536 7 7 36 26 0.0064b777537 7 7 36 29 1.0935b777538 7 7 36 23 0.1261b777539 7 7 36 27 0.7877

Table 57: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 147: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeb777540 7 7 36 25 0.5064b777541 7 7 36 24 0.0058b777542 7 7 36 30 0.4911b777543 7 7 36 29 0.5321b777544 7 7 36 24 0.0058b777545 7 7 36 23 1.0535b777546 7 7 36 28 0.4749b777547 7 7 36 21 0.4836b777548 7 7 36 24 0.5282b777549 7 7 36 27 0.3386u435510 3 4 6 2 0.0011u435511 3 4 6 1 0.0011u435512 3 4 6 3 0.0011u435513 3 4 6 0 0.0011u435514 3 4 6 2 0.0011u435515 3 4 6 1 0.0011u435516 3 4 6 3 0.0013u435517 3 4 6 1 0.0012u435518 3 4 6 2 0.0012u435519 3 4 6 2 0.0012u435520 3 4 6 2 0.0011u435521 3 4 6 1 0.0011u435522 3 4 6 3 0.0011u435523 3 4 6 4 0.0011u435524 3 4 6 4 0.0011u435525 3 4 6 2 0.0011u435526 3 4 6 4 0.0011u435527 3 4 6 3 0.0011u435528 3 4 6 2 0.0013u435529 3 4 6 2 0.0012u435530 3 4 6 2 0.0011u435531 3 4 6 3 0.0012u435532 3 4 6 2 0.0011u435533 3 4 6 3 0.0011u435534 3 4 6 2 0.0012u435535 3 4 6 3 0.0011u435536 3 4 6 0 0.0011u435537 3 4 6 2 0.0012u435538 3 4 6 2 0.0011u435539 3 4 6 2 0.0011u435540 3 4 6 4 0.0011u435541 3 4 6 3 0.0011u435542 3 4 6 3 0.0011u435543 3 4 6 3 0.0012u435544 3 4 6 4 0.0011u435545 3 4 6 3 0.0011u435546 3 4 6 0 0.0012u435547 3 4 6 0 0.0012u435548 3 4 6 3 0.0011u435549 3 4 6 3 0.0011u436010 3 4 7 4 0.0013u436011 3 4 7 3 0.0013u436012 3 4 7 6 0.0014u436013 3 4 7 3 0.0013u436014 3 4 7 5 0.0013u436015 3 4 7 2 0.0013u436016 3 4 7 3 0.0012u436017 3 4 7 1 0.0013u436018 3 4 7 4 0.0013u436019 3 4 7 1 0.0013u436020 3 4 7 0 0.0013u436021 3 4 7 4 0.0013u436022 3 4 7 3 0.0012u436023 3 4 7 5 0.0012u436024 3 4 7 3 0.0013u436025 3 4 7 2 0.0012u436026 3 4 7 3 0.0013u436027 3 4 7 5 0.0012u436028 3 4 7 3 0.0012u436029 3 4 7 2 0.0013

Table 58: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 148: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu436030 3 4 7 4 0.0012u436031 3 4 7 1 0.0013u436032 3 4 7 4 0.0013u436033 3 4 7 3 0.0013u436034 3 4 7 2 0.0014u436035 3 4 7 2 0.0013u436036 3 4 7 1 0.0013u436037 3 4 7 5 0.0013u436038 3 4 7 4 0.0012u436039 3 4 7 3 0.0013u436040 3 4 7 5 0.0013u436041 3 4 7 1 0.0013u436042 3 4 7 3 0.0013u436043 3 4 7 4 0.0013u436044 3 4 7 3 0.0012u436045 3 4 7 6 0.0013u436046 3 4 7 5 0.0013u436047 3 4 7 4 0.0013u436048 3 4 7 1 0.0013u436049 3 4 7 2 0.0013u436510 3 4 7 3 0.0012u436511 3 4 7 5 0.0013u436512 3 4 7 4 0.0013u436513 3 4 7 5 0.0012u436514 3 4 7 2 0.0012u436515 3 4 7 3 0.0012u436516 3 4 7 2 0.0014u436517 3 4 7 4 0.0014u436518 3 4 7 3 0.0014u436519 3 4 7 5 0.0013u436520 3 4 7 5 0.0013u436521 3 4 7 2 0.0013u436522 3 4 7 3 0.0012u436523 3 4 7 5 0.0012u436524 3 4 7 1 0.0013u436525 3 4 7 6 0.0012u436526 3 4 7 3 0.0013u436527 3 4 7 4 0.0013u436528 3 4 7 2 0.0013u436529 3 4 7 6 0.0013u436530 3 4 7 3 0.0012u436531 3 4 7 3 0.0012u436532 3 4 7 2 0.0013u436533 3 4 7 4 0.0013u436534 3 4 7 3 0.0013u436535 3 4 7 2 0.0013u436536 3 4 7 2 0.0013u436537 3 4 7 4 0.0012u436538 3 4 7 4 0.0014u436539 3 4 7 3 0.0013u436540 3 4 7 4 0.0013u436541 3 4 7 5 0.0014u436542 3 4 7 5 0.0012u436543 3 4 7 4 0.0013u436544 3 4 7 4 0.0013u436545 3 4 7 0 0.0013u436546 3 4 7 4 0.0012u436547 3 4 7 5 0.0013u436548 3 4 7 3 0.0012u436549 3 4 7 3 0.0013u437010 3 4 8 4 0.0013u437011 3 4 8 6 0.0013u437012 3 4 8 5 0.0014u437013 3 4 8 4 0.0014u437014 3 4 8 2 0.0014u437015 3 4 8 3 0.0014u437016 3 4 8 7 0.0013u437017 3 4 8 4 0.0013u437018 3 4 8 6 0.0013u437019 3 4 8 6 0.0014

Table 59: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 149: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu437020 3 4 8 6 0.0015u437021 3 4 8 6 0.0014u437022 3 4 8 5 0.0015u437023 3 4 8 2 0.0013u437024 3 4 8 4 0.0013u437025 3 4 8 1 0.0014u437026 3 4 8 4 0.0014u437027 3 4 8 4 0.0013u437028 3 4 8 4 0.0014u437029 3 4 8 4 0.0013u437030 3 4 8 5 0.0014u437031 3 4 8 6 0.0014u437032 3 4 8 3 0.0013u437033 3 4 8 4 0.0013u437034 3 4 8 5 0.0013u437035 3 4 8 6 0.0013u437036 3 4 8 2 0.0013u437037 3 4 8 7 0.0013u437038 3 4 8 4 0.0013u437039 3 4 8 3 0.0013u437040 3 4 8 2 0.0013u437041 3 4 8 4 0.0014u437042 3 4 8 5 0.0013u437043 3 4 8 2 0.0014u437044 3 4 8 5 0.0014u437045 3 4 8 7 0.0014u437046 3 4 8 4 0.0014u437047 3 4 8 4 0.0014u437048 3 4 8 5 0.0014u437049 3 4 8 8 0.0014u437510 3 4 9 5 0.0015u437511 3 4 9 7 0.0014u437512 3 4 9 7 0.0015u437513 3 4 9 7 0.0015u437514 3 4 9 0 0.0014u437515 3 4 9 7 0.0014u437516 3 4 9 7 0.0014u437517 3 4 9 7 0.0015u437518 3 4 9 7 0.0014u437519 3 4 9 4 0.0014u437520 3 4 9 5 0.0015u437521 3 4 9 7 0.0017u437522 3 4 9 1 0.0016u437523 3 4 9 4 0.0016u437524 3 4 9 6 0.0015u437525 3 4 9 5 0.0015u437526 3 4 9 3 0.0014u437527 3 4 9 3 0.0014u437528 3 4 9 5 0.0015u437529 3 4 9 7 0.0015u437530 3 4 9 5 0.0015u437531 3 4 9 4 0.0015u437532 3 4 9 4 0.0014u437533 3 4 9 5 0.0014u437534 3 4 9 10 0.0014u437535 3 4 9 2 0.0015u437536 3 4 9 3 0.0015u437537 3 4 9 2 0.0015u437538 3 4 9 8 0.0014u437539 3 4 9 7 0.0014u437540 3 4 9 4 0.0016u437541 3 4 9 2 0.0015u437542 3 4 9 5 0.0015u437543 3 4 9 3 0.0015u437544 3 4 9 4 0.0015u437545 3 4 9 2 0.0015u437546 3 4 9 7 0.0015u437547 3 4 9 4 0.0015u437548 3 4 9 4 0.0015u437549 3 4 9 7 0.0015

Table 60: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 150: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu445510 4 4 8 3 0.0014u445511 4 4 8 3 0.0014u445512 4 4 8 6 0.0014u445513 4 4 8 2 0.0014u445514 4 4 8 1 0.0015u445515 4 4 8 2 0.0014u445516 4 4 8 4 0.0014u445517 4 4 8 0 0.0015u445518 4 4 8 2 0.0015u445519 4 4 8 2 0.0016u445520 4 4 8 3 0.0016u445521 4 4 8 5 0.0016u445522 4 4 8 4 0.0015u445523 4 4 8 1 0.0014u445524 4 4 8 1 0.0015u445525 4 4 8 1 0.0015u445526 4 4 8 1 0.0015u445527 4 4 8 3 0.0014u445528 4 4 8 4 0.0014u445529 4 4 8 3 0.0014u445530 4 4 8 3 0.0015u445531 4 4 8 4 0.0015u445532 4 4 8 4 0.0014u445533 4 4 8 2 0.0014u445534 4 4 8 2 0.0014u445535 4 4 8 3 0.0014u445536 4 4 8 3 0.0015u445537 4 4 8 2 0.0014u445538 4 4 8 4 0.0014u445539 4 4 8 3 0.0015u445540 4 4 8 3 0.0015u445541 4 4 8 5 0.0014u445542 4 4 8 3 0.0014u445543 4 4 8 4 0.0014u445544 4 4 8 3 0.0014u445545 4 4 8 3 0.0014u445546 4 4 8 3 0.0014u445547 4 4 8 4 0.0015u445548 4 4 8 2 0.0015u445549 4 4 8 2 0.0014u446010 4 4 9 5 0.0015u446011 4 4 9 2 0.0015u446012 4 4 9 5 0.0016u446013 4 4 9 4 0.0016u446014 4 4 9 1 0.0015u446015 4 4 9 5 0.0015u446016 4 4 9 5 0.0015u446017 4 4 9 4 0.0016u446018 4 4 9 4 0.0017u446019 4 4 9 4 0.0016u446020 4 4 9 1 0.0016u446021 4 4 9 1 0.0016u446022 4 4 9 1 0.0016u446023 4 4 9 1 0.0015u446024 4 4 9 4 0.0016u446025 4 4 9 4 0.0015u446026 4 4 9 3 0.0015u446027 4 4 9 6 0.0016u446028 4 4 9 4 0.0015u446029 4 4 9 5 0.0016u446030 4 4 9 2 0.0016u446031 4 4 9 4 0.0016u446032 4 4 9 4 0.0015u446033 4 4 9 2 0.0015u446034 4 4 9 3 0.0015u446035 4 4 9 6 0.0015u446036 4 4 9 3 0.0017u446037 4 4 9 4 0.0016u446038 4 4 9 3 0.0016u446039 4 4 9 5 0.0015

Table 61: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 151: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu446040 4 4 9 2 0.0016u446041 4 4 9 2 0.0015u446042 4 4 9 4 0.0015u446043 4 4 9 3 0.0016u446044 4 4 9 3 0.0016u446045 4 4 9 6 0.0016u446046 4 4 9 7 0.0016u446047 4 4 9 5 0.0016u446048 4 4 9 5 0.0016u446049 4 4 9 4 0.0016u446510 4 4 10 5 0.0017u446511 4 4 10 5 0.0017u446512 4 4 10 5 0.0017u446513 4 4 10 3 0.0017u446514 4 4 10 2 0.0019u446515 4 4 10 4 0.0018u446516 4 4 10 2 0.0018u446517 4 4 10 5 0.0017u446518 4 4 10 5 0.0017u446519 4 4 10 3 0.0017u446520 4 4 10 2 0.0017u446521 4 4 10 4 0.0016u446522 4 4 10 4 0.0017u446523 4 4 10 3 0.0016u446524 4 4 10 8 0.0017u446525 4 4 10 3 0.0017u446526 4 4 10 0 0.0017u446527 4 4 10 5 0.0017u446528 4 4 10 2 0.0017u446529 4 4 10 5 0.0017u446530 4 4 10 5 0.0018u446531 4 4 10 1 0.0018u446532 4 4 10 7 0.0018u446533 4 4 10 4 0.0017u446534 4 4 10 4 0.0017u446535 4 4 10 5 0.0017u446536 4 4 10 5 0.0017u446537 4 4 10 2 0.0017u446538 4 4 10 3 0.0017u446539 4 4 10 5 0.0016u446540 4 4 10 5 0.0016u446541 4 4 10 5 0.0017u446542 4 4 10 3 0.0017u446543 4 4 10 8 0.0016u446544 4 4 10 4 0.0017u446545 4 4 10 5 0.0017u446546 4 4 10 6 0.0016u446547 4 4 10 4 0.0017u446548 4 4 10 3 0.0019u446549 4 4 10 5 0.0018u447010 4 4 11 6 0.0017u447011 4 4 11 2 0.0018u447012 4 4 11 3 0.0017u447013 4 4 11 5 0.0018u447014 4 4 11 7 0.0018u447015 4 4 11 6 0.0018u447016 4 4 11 7 0.0017u447017 4 4 11 6 0.0017u447018 4 4 11 5 0.0017u447019 4 4 11 6 0.0018u447020 4 4 11 9 0.0018u447021 4 4 11 4 0.0018u447022 4 4 11 10 0.0018u447023 4 4 11 7 0.0018u447024 4 4 11 4 0.0019u447025 4 4 11 4 0.0018u447026 4 4 11 4 0.0018u447027 4 4 11 8 0.0017u447028 4 4 11 4 0.0018u447029 4 4 11 7 0.0018

Table 62: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 152: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu447030 4 4 11 5 0.0017u447031 4 4 11 3 0.0017u447032 4 4 11 8 0.0017u447033 4 4 11 4 0.0018u447034 4 4 11 5 0.0018u447035 4 4 11 7 0.0018u447036 4 4 11 4 0.0017u447037 4 4 11 8 0.0018u447038 4 4 11 3 0.0020u447039 4 4 11 2 0.0018u447040 4 4 11 2 0.0021u447041 4 4 11 3 0.0019u447042 4 4 11 5 0.0018u447043 4 4 11 3 0.0018u447044 4 4 11 5 0.0019u447045 4 4 11 7 0.0019u447046 4 4 11 7 0.0018u447047 4 4 11 5 0.0017u447048 4 4 11 3 0.0018u447049 4 4 11 7 0.0018u447510 4 4 12 8 0.0019u447511 4 4 12 7 0.0019u447512 4 4 12 8 0.0019u447513 4 4 12 8 0.0019u447514 4 4 12 6 0.0020u447515 4 4 12 4 0.0021u447516 4 4 12 5 0.0019u447517 4 4 12 5 0.0019u447518 4 4 12 6 0.0018u447519 4 4 12 7 0.0019u447520 4 4 12 5 0.0018u447521 4 4 12 8 0.0019u447522 4 4 12 8 0.0019u447523 4 4 12 7 0.0019u447524 4 4 12 6 0.0018u447525 4 4 12 5 0.0019u447526 4 4 12 8 0.0019u447527 4 4 12 2 0.0019u447528 4 4 12 11 0.0019u447529 4 4 12 7 0.0019u447530 4 4 12 9 0.0020u447531 4 4 12 8 0.0019u447532 4 4 12 6 0.0019u447533 4 4 12 7 0.0020u447534 4 4 12 7 0.0020u447535 4 4 12 9 0.0019u447536 4 4 12 7 0.0019u447537 4 4 12 7 0.0019u447538 4 4 12 4 0.0018u447539 4 4 12 7 0.0019u447540 4 4 12 7 0.0019u447541 4 4 12 7 0.0019u447542 4 4 12 5 0.0019u447543 4 4 12 5 0.0019u447544 4 4 12 5 0.0019u447545 4 4 12 3 0.0021u447546 4 4 12 3 0.0021u447547 4 4 12 6 0.0020u447548 4 4 12 6 0.0019u447549 4 4 12 4 0.0019u455510 5 4 11 2 0.0019u455511 5 4 11 3 0.0019u455512 5 4 11 2 0.0019u455513 5 4 11 4 0.0019u455514 5 4 11 4 0.0018u455515 5 4 11 4 0.0019u455516 5 4 11 5 0.0018u455517 5 4 11 7 0.0019u455518 5 4 11 4 0.0018u455519 5 4 11 5 0.0019

Table 63: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 153: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu455520 5 4 11 3 0.0019u455521 5 4 11 4 0.0020u455522 5 4 11 4 0.0019u455523 5 4 11 6 0.0019u455524 5 4 11 6 0.0019u455525 5 4 11 4 0.0018u455526 5 4 11 3 0.0019u455527 5 4 11 2 0.0019u455528 5 4 11 2 0.0019u455529 5 4 11 5 0.0018u455530 5 4 11 4 0.0019u455531 5 4 11 5 0.0019u455532 5 4 11 3 0.0019u455533 5 4 11 6 0.0019u455534 5 4 11 3 0.0019u455535 5 4 11 4 0.0019u455536 5 4 11 2 0.0020u455537 5 4 11 4 0.0019u455538 5 4 11 5 0.0019u455539 5 4 11 5 0.0019u455540 5 4 11 5 0.0019u455541 5 4 11 3 0.0018u455542 5 4 11 5 0.0019u455543 5 4 11 5 0.0018u455544 5 4 11 4 0.0019u455545 5 4 11 5 0.0019u455546 5 4 11 2 0.0018u455547 5 4 11 6 0.0019u455548 5 4 11 2 0.0018u455549 5 4 11 5 0.0019u456010 5 4 12 2 0.0020u456011 5 4 12 9 0.0023u456012 5 4 12 7 0.0022u456013 5 4 12 6 0.0021u456014 5 4 12 5 0.0021u456015 5 4 12 4 0.0020u456016 5 4 12 4 0.0020u456017 5 4 12 5 0.0019u456018 5 4 12 5 0.0020u456019 5 4 12 5 0.0020u456020 5 4 12 4 0.0020u456021 5 4 12 6 0.0020u456022 5 4 12 4 0.0020u456023 5 4 12 4 0.0020u456024 5 4 12 3 0.0019u456025 5 4 12 4 0.0021u456026 5 4 12 7 0.0021u456027 5 4 12 2 0.0020u456028 5 4 12 5 0.0019u456029 5 4 12 7 0.0020u456030 5 4 12 7 0.0020u456031 5 4 12 3 0.0021u456032 5 4 12 6 0.0020u456033 5 4 12 3 0.0019u456034 5 4 12 6 0.0020u456035 5 4 12 7 0.0019u456036 5 4 12 2 0.0020u456037 5 4 12 4 0.0019u456038 5 4 12 6 0.0019u456039 5 4 12 9 0.0020u456040 5 4 12 2 0.0022u456041 5 4 12 4 0.0020u456042 5 4 12 5 0.0019u456043 5 4 12 7 0.0020u456044 5 4 12 6 0.0019u456045 5 4 12 7 0.0020u456046 5 4 12 0 0.0019u456047 5 4 12 3 0.0020u456048 5 4 12 5 0.0020u456049 5 4 12 6 0.0020

Table 64: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 154: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu456510 5 4 13 7 0.0021u456511 5 4 13 3 0.0020u456512 5 4 13 7 0.0021u456513 5 4 13 6 0.0020u456514 5 4 13 5 0.0022u456515 5 4 13 8 0.0022u456516 5 4 13 5 0.0022u456517 5 4 13 7 0.0021u456518 5 4 13 7 0.0021u456519 5 4 13 6 0.0021u456520 5 4 13 6 0.0020u456521 5 4 13 8 0.0021u456522 5 4 13 5 0.0021u456523 5 4 13 6 0.0021u456524 5 4 13 8 0.0020u456525 5 4 13 5 0.0021u456526 5 4 13 5 0.0021u456527 5 4 13 6 0.0021u456528 5 4 13 5 0.0022u456529 5 4 13 9 0.0022u456530 5 4 13 5 0.0021u456531 5 4 13 7 0.0021u456532 5 4 13 5 0.0021u456533 5 4 13 7 0.0021u456534 5 4 13 5 0.0021u456535 5 4 13 6 0.0021u456536 5 4 13 7 0.0021u456537 5 4 13 5 0.0021u456538 5 4 13 7 0.0021u456539 5 4 13 7 0.0020u456540 5 4 13 10 0.0023u456541 5 4 13 4 0.0021u456542 5 4 13 5 0.0023u456543 5 4 13 4 0.0022u456544 5 4 13 6 0.0021u456545 5 4 13 6 0.0021u456546 5 4 13 3 0.0021u456547 5 4 13 8 0.0021u456548 5 4 13 7 0.0021u456549 5 4 13 9 0.0020u457010 5 4 14 7 0.0023u457011 5 4 14 5 0.0022u457012 5 4 14 8 0.0022u457013 5 4 14 4 0.0021u457014 5 4 14 6 0.0022u457015 5 4 14 4 0.0024u457016 5 4 14 7 0.0023u457017 5 4 14 10 0.0025u457018 5 4 14 6 0.0024u457019 5 4 14 8 0.0028u457020 5 4 14 8 0.0025u457021 5 4 14 7 0.0024u457022 5 4 14 5 0.0024u457023 5 4 14 6 0.0023u457024 5 4 14 3 0.0024u457025 5 4 14 9 0.0024u457026 5 4 14 4 0.0023u457027 5 4 14 5 0.0025u457028 5 4 14 3 0.0023u457029 5 4 14 8 0.0023u457030 5 4 14 10 0.0023u457031 5 4 14 3 0.0022u457032 5 4 14 8 0.0021u457033 5 4 14 5 0.0022u457034 5 4 14 5 0.0022u457035 5 4 14 6 0.0022u457036 5 4 14 6 0.0022u457037 5 4 14 8 0.0021u457038 5 4 14 7 0.0022u457039 5 4 14 6 0.0022

Table 65: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 155: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu457040 5 4 14 5 0.0025u457041 5 4 14 6 0.0023u457042 5 4 14 8 0.0022u457043 5 4 14 9 0.0024u457044 5 4 14 6 0.0022u457045 5 4 14 6 0.0022u457046 5 4 14 3 0.0022u457047 5 4 14 9 0.0022u457048 5 4 14 7 0.0022u457049 5 4 14 9 0.0022u457510 5 4 15 5 0.0022u457511 5 4 15 6 0.0022u457512 5 4 15 7 0.0023u457513 5 4 15 8 0.0027u457514 5 4 15 4 0.0025u457515 5 4 15 4 0.0024u457516 5 4 15 9 0.0025u457517 5 4 15 8 0.0023u457518 5 4 15 9 0.0023u457519 5 4 15 8 0.0023u457520 5 4 15 7 0.0023u457521 5 4 15 8 0.0023u457522 5 4 15 8 0.0022u457523 5 4 15 8 0.0023u457524 5 4 15 6 0.0023u457525 5 4 15 6 0.0026u457526 5 4 15 5 0.0025u457527 5 4 15 8 0.0023u457528 5 4 15 8 0.0024u457529 5 4 15 10 0.0035u457530 5 4 15 5 0.0023u457531 5 4 15 7 0.0022u457532 5 4 15 4 0.0024u457533 5 4 15 7 0.0024u457534 5 4 15 8 0.0023u457535 5 4 15 7 0.0024u457536 5 4 15 7 0.0024u457537 5 4 15 9 0.0027u457538 5 4 15 8 0.0039u457539 5 4 15 7 0.0024u457540 5 4 15 7 0.0023u457541 5 4 15 11 0.0024u457542 5 4 15 4 0.0024u457543 5 4 15 8 0.0023u457544 5 4 15 8 0.0023u457545 5 4 15 6 0.0022u457546 5 4 15 6 0.0023u457547 5 4 15 9 0.0023u457548 5 4 15 8 0.0024u457549 5 4 15 9 0.0024u465510 6 4 13 7 0.0022u465511 6 4 13 3 0.0022u465512 6 4 13 5 0.0021u465513 6 4 13 6 0.0021u465514 6 4 13 4 0.0021u465515 6 4 13 6 0.0022u465516 6 4 13 4 0.0021u465517 6 4 13 6 0.0022u465518 6 4 13 6 0.0021u465519 6 4 13 4 0.0021u465520 6 4 13 4 0.0022u465521 6 4 13 7 0.0022u465522 6 4 13 7 0.0024u465523 6 4 13 7 0.0022u465524 6 4 13 5 0.0021u465525 6 4 13 6 0.0023u465526 6 4 13 4 0.0021u465527 6 4 13 4 0.0022u465528 6 4 13 7 0.0021u465529 6 4 13 7 0.0021

Table 66: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 156: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu465530 6 4 13 3 0.0022u465531 6 4 13 3 0.0021u465532 6 4 13 4 0.0021u465533 6 4 13 4 0.0021u465534 6 4 13 6 0.0021u465535 6 4 13 5 0.0023u465536 6 4 13 6 0.0022u465537 6 4 13 2 0.0022u465538 6 4 13 3 0.0022u465539 6 4 13 5 0.0021u465540 6 4 13 3 0.0021u465541 6 4 13 3 0.0022u465542 6 4 13 6 0.0021u465543 6 4 13 5 0.0021u465544 6 4 13 5 0.0021u465545 6 4 13 6 0.0021u465546 6 4 13 2 0.0021u465547 6 4 13 3 0.0021u465548 6 4 13 3 0.0023u465549 6 4 13 9 0.0059u466010 6 4 14 8 0.0028u466011 6 4 14 8 0.0027u466012 6 4 14 7 0.0023u466013 6 4 14 5 0.0023u466014 6 4 14 8 0.0022u466015 6 4 14 5 0.0022u466016 6 4 14 7 0.0022u466017 6 4 14 2 0.0023u466018 6 4 14 7 0.0023u466019 6 4 14 4 0.0025u466020 6 4 14 6 0.0024u466021 6 4 14 5 0.0023u466022 6 4 14 7 0.0023u466023 6 4 14 5 0.0022u466024 6 4 14 4 0.0024u466025 6 4 14 5 0.0023u466026 6 4 14 3 0.0022u466027 6 4 14 4 0.0023u466028 6 4 14 6 0.0022u466029 6 4 14 4 0.0022u466030 6 4 14 4 0.0023u466031 6 4 14 8 0.0022u466032 6 4 14 6 0.0026u466033 6 4 14 8 0.0024u466034 6 4 14 4 0.0023u466035 6 4 14 6 0.0023u466036 6 4 14 4 0.0022u466037 6 4 14 8 0.0022u466038 6 4 14 3 0.0023u466039 6 4 14 4 0.0023u466040 6 4 14 7 0.0023u466041 6 4 14 6 0.0023u466042 6 4 14 7 0.0023u466043 6 4 14 3 0.0023u466044 6 4 14 4 0.0024u466045 6 4 14 5 0.0023u466046 6 4 14 5 0.0024u466047 6 4 14 7 0.0024u466048 6 4 14 5 0.0022u466049 6 4 14 8 0.0024u466510 6 4 15 10 0.0024u466511 6 4 15 5 0.0023u466512 6 4 15 7 0.0023u466513 6 4 15 7 0.0024u466514 6 4 15 5 0.0024u466515 6 4 15 4 0.0024u466516 6 4 15 5 0.0024u466517 6 4 15 7 0.0025u466518 6 4 15 5 0.0025u466519 6 4 15 7 0.0025

Table 67: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 157: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu466520 6 4 15 9 0.0024u466521 6 4 15 10 0.0025u466522 6 4 15 6 0.0024u466523 6 4 15 8 0.0023u466524 6 4 15 8 0.0023u466525 6 4 15 8 0.0023u466526 6 4 15 6 0.0023u466527 6 4 15 6 0.0024u466528 6 4 15 7 0.0024u466529 6 4 15 4 0.0026u466530 6 4 15 7 0.0025u466531 6 4 15 6 0.0025u466532 6 4 15 8 0.0024u466533 6 4 15 8 0.0024u466534 6 4 15 4 0.0024u466535 6 4 15 7 0.0023u466536 6 4 15 3 0.0024u466537 6 4 15 6 0.0024u466538 6 4 15 6 0.0024u466539 6 4 15 7 0.0024u466540 6 4 15 5 0.0025u466541 6 4 15 7 0.0026u466542 6 4 15 9 0.0024u466543 6 4 15 9 0.0024u466544 6 4 15 8 0.0023u466545 6 4 15 6 0.0024u466546 6 4 15 10 0.0024u466547 6 4 15 6 0.0024u466548 6 4 15 8 0.0024u466549 6 4 15 7 0.0025u467010 6 4 16 6 0.0025u467011 6 4 16 6 0.0025u467012 6 4 16 6 0.0027u467013 6 4 16 9 0.0026u467014 6 4 16 11 0.0030u467015 6 4 16 9 0.0026u467016 6 4 16 8 0.0025u467017 6 4 16 8 0.0025u467018 6 4 16 6 0.0025u467019 6 4 16 7 0.0025u467020 6 4 16 9 0.0025u467021 6 4 16 7 0.0025u467022 6 4 16 9 0.0025u467023 6 4 16 7 0.0028u467024 6 4 16 7 0.0027u467025 6 4 16 6 0.0027u467026 6 4 16 7 0.0026u467027 6 4 16 5 0.0025u467028 6 4 16 6 0.0025u467029 6 4 16 6 0.0024u467030 6 4 16 5 0.0025u467031 6 4 16 9 0.0024u467032 6 4 16 6 0.0025u467033 6 4 16 4 0.0025u467034 6 4 16 9 0.0027u467035 6 4 16 7 0.0027u467036 6 4 16 8 0.0026u467037 6 4 16 8 0.0027u467038 6 4 16 8 0.0025u467039 6 4 16 3 0.0025u467040 6 4 16 8 0.0028u467041 6 4 16 5 0.0025u467042 6 4 16 11 0.0025u467043 6 4 16 5 0.0025u467044 6 4 16 4 0.0026u467045 6 4 16 6 0.0025u467046 6 4 16 9 0.0028u467047 6 4 16 11 0.0026u467048 6 4 16 7 0.0026u467049 6 4 16 11 0.0025

Table 68: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 158: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu467510 6 4 18 8 0.0029u467511 6 4 18 7 0.0028u467512 6 4 18 8 0.0027u467513 6 4 18 11 0.0028u467514 6 4 18 8 0.0028u467515 6 4 18 9 0.0028u467516 6 4 18 8 0.0030u467517 6 4 18 6 0.0031u467518 6 4 18 10 0.0028u467519 6 4 18 7 0.0029u467520 6 4 18 10 0.0029u467521 6 4 18 9 0.0040u467522 6 4 18 9 0.0027u467523 6 4 18 10 0.0028u467524 6 4 18 9 0.0027u467525 6 4 18 8 0.0028u467526 6 4 18 10 0.0030u467527 6 4 18 8 0.0029u467528 6 4 18 8 0.0028u467529 6 4 18 12 0.0027u467530 6 4 18 11 0.0030u467531 6 4 18 11 0.0032u467532 6 4 18 10 0.0028u467533 6 4 18 11 0.0027u467534 6 4 18 9 0.0027u467535 6 4 18 8 0.0028u467536 6 4 18 8 0.0029u467537 6 4 18 12 0.0033u467538 6 4 18 14 0.0032u467539 6 4 18 9 0.0028u467540 6 4 18 12 0.0031u467541 6 4 18 9 0.0028u467542 6 4 18 11 0.0029u467543 6 4 18 6 0.0028u467544 6 4 18 5 0.0027u467545 6 4 18 11 0.0027u467546 6 4 18 8 0.0028u467547 6 4 18 6 0.0029u467548 6 4 18 8 0.0028u467549 6 4 18 6 0.0028u475510 7 4 15 8 0.0026u475511 7 4 15 3 0.0025u475512 7 4 15 3 0.0026u475513 7 4 15 5 0.0025u475514 7 4 15 7 0.0026u475515 7 4 15 4 0.0025u475516 7 4 15 4 0.0024u475517 7 4 15 7 0.0025u475518 7 4 15 5 0.0027u475519 7 4 15 5 0.0026u475520 7 4 15 7 0.0026u475521 7 4 15 8 0.0025u475522 7 4 15 5 0.0024u475523 7 4 15 5 0.0024u475524 7 4 15 6 0.0025u475525 7 4 15 6 0.0026u475526 7 4 15 6 0.0025u475527 7 4 15 6 0.0024u475528 7 4 15 4 0.0025u475529 7 4 15 6 0.0026u475530 7 4 15 4 0.0027u475531 7 4 15 3 0.0029u475532 7 4 15 6 0.0029u475533 7 4 15 6 0.0029u475534 7 4 15 5 0.0027u475535 7 4 15 7 0.0032u475536 7 4 15 7 0.0032u475537 7 4 15 5 0.0025u475538 7 4 15 5 0.0026u475539 7 4 15 5 0.0027

Table 69: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 159: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu475540 7 4 15 5 0.0029u475541 7 4 15 4 0.0029u475542 7 4 15 5 0.0025u475543 7 4 15 4 0.0025u475544 7 4 15 3 0.0026u475545 7 4 15 4 0.0026u475546 7 4 15 5 0.0026u475547 7 4 15 4 0.0025u475548 7 4 15 3 0.0025u475549 7 4 15 5 0.0024u476010 7 4 16 7 0.0026u476011 7 4 16 6 0.0031u476012 7 4 16 4 0.0029u476013 7 4 16 8 0.0027u476014 7 4 16 5 0.0025u476015 7 4 16 6 0.0026u476016 7 4 16 8 0.0026u476017 7 4 16 6 0.0027u476018 7 4 16 7 0.0027u476019 7 4 16 5 0.0026u476020 7 4 16 7 0.0026u476021 7 4 16 6 0.0028u476022 7 4 16 7 0.0029u476023 7 4 16 5 0.0028u476024 7 4 16 9 0.0030u476025 7 4 16 7 0.0026u476026 7 4 16 6 0.0025u476027 7 4 16 5 0.0026u476028 7 4 16 9 0.0026u476029 7 4 16 3 0.0027u476030 7 4 16 6 0.0027u476031 7 4 16 5 0.0026u476032 7 4 16 7 0.0029u476033 7 4 16 7 0.0029u476034 7 4 16 8 0.0027u476035 7 4 16 7 0.0028u476036 7 4 16 7 0.0027u476037 7 4 16 6 0.0026u476038 7 4 16 5 0.0026u476039 7 4 16 8 0.0026u476040 7 4 16 8 0.0026u476041 7 4 16 8 0.0028u476042 7 4 16 9 0.0026u476043 7 4 16 7 0.0028u476044 7 4 16 8 0.0027u476045 7 4 16 8 0.0027u476046 7 4 16 7 0.0027u476047 7 4 16 9 0.0027u476048 7 4 16 2 0.0027u476049 7 4 16 6 0.0025u476510 7 4 18 9 0.0029u476511 7 4 18 6 0.0028u476512 7 4 18 7 0.0030u476513 7 4 18 7 0.0029u476514 7 4 18 9 0.0033u476515 7 4 18 8 0.0030u476516 7 4 18 5 0.0030u476517 7 4 18 7 0.0029u476518 7 4 18 4 0.0028u476519 7 4 18 8 0.0031u476520 7 4 18 6 0.0028u476521 7 4 18 7 0.0029u476522 7 4 18 5 0.0029u476523 7 4 18 11 0.0033u476524 7 4 18 8 0.0030u476525 7 4 18 8 0.0029u476526 7 4 18 9 0.0029u476527 7 4 18 11 0.0031u476528 7 4 18 7 0.0030u476529 7 4 18 7 0.0029

Table 70: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 160: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu476530 7 4 18 9 0.0027u476531 7 4 18 10 0.0029u476532 7 4 18 6 0.0029u476533 7 4 18 9 0.0033u476534 7 4 18 6 0.0031u476535 7 4 18 10 0.0036u476536 7 4 18 10 0.0045u476537 7 4 18 6 0.0029u476538 7 4 18 6 0.0030u476539 7 4 18 9 0.0029u476540 7 4 18 9 0.0028u476541 7 4 18 3 0.0029u476542 7 4 18 5 0.0032u476543 7 4 18 8 0.0031u476544 7 4 18 6 0.0031u476545 7 4 18 9 0.0029u476546 7 4 18 9 0.0027u476547 7 4 18 6 0.0028u476548 7 4 18 7 0.0030u476549 7 4 18 7 0.0030u477010 7 4 19 8 0.0031u477011 7 4 19 8 0.0032u477012 7 4 19 10 0.0033u477013 7 4 19 7 0.0034u477014 7 4 19 6 0.0032u477015 7 4 19 8 0.0030u477016 7 4 19 9 0.0030u477017 7 4 19 4 0.0030u477018 7 4 19 9 0.0031u477019 7 4 19 9 0.0030u477020 7 4 19 8 0.0030u477021 7 4 19 10 0.0034u477022 7 4 19 7 0.0032u477023 7 4 19 7 0.0031u477024 7 4 19 9 0.0030u477025 7 4 19 12 0.0030u477026 7 4 19 7 0.0029u477027 7 4 19 8 0.0031u477028 7 4 19 8 0.0030u477029 7 4 19 9 0.0030u477030 7 4 19 11 0.0034u477031 7 4 19 9 0.0033u477032 7 4 19 7 0.0033u477033 7 4 19 7 0.0029u477034 7 4 19 7 0.0029u477035 7 4 19 7 0.0030u477036 7 4 19 10 0.0035u477037 7 4 19 7 0.0035u477038 7 4 19 11 0.0130u477039 7 4 19 2 0.0031u477040 7 4 19 6 0.0032u477041 7 4 19 8 0.0031u477042 7 4 19 7 0.0030u477043 7 4 19 6 0.0030u477044 7 4 19 7 0.0030u477045 7 4 19 8 0.0030u477046 7 4 19 9 0.0035u477047 7 4 19 7 0.0032u477048 7 4 19 6 0.0032u477049 7 4 19 11 0.0030u477510 7 4 21 13 0.0033u477511 7 4 21 13 0.0036u477512 7 4 21 12 0.0034u477513 7 4 21 8 0.0033u477514 7 4 21 8 0.0033u477515 7 4 21 9 0.0037u477516 7 4 21 8 0.0035u477517 7 4 21 13 0.0033u477518 7 4 21 10 0.0033u477519 7 4 21 15 0.0034

Table 71: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 161: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu477520 7 4 21 13 0.0034u477521 7 4 21 8 0.0033u477522 7 4 21 10 0.0033u477523 7 4 21 8 0.0036u477524 7 4 21 9 0.0035u477525 7 4 21 9 0.0036u477526 7 4 21 8 0.0034u477527 7 4 21 9 0.0033u477528 7 4 21 11 0.0032u477529 7 4 21 11 0.0033u477530 7 4 21 13 0.0332u477531 7 4 21 9 0.0033u477532 7 4 21 12 0.0034u477533 7 4 21 7 0.0036u477534 7 4 21 11 0.0035u477535 7 4 21 9 0.0035u477536 7 4 21 10 0.0033u477537 7 4 21 8 0.0034u477538 7 4 21 7 0.0033u477539 7 4 21 10 0.0033u477540 7 4 21 9 0.0033u477541 7 4 21 8 0.0037u477542 7 4 21 9 0.0034u477543 7 4 21 11 0.0034u477544 7 4 21 5 0.0033u477545 7 4 21 12 0.0035u477546 7 4 21 10 0.0033u477547 7 4 21 10 0.0033u477548 7 4 21 14 0.0034u477549 7 4 21 8 0.0034u535510 3 5 8 2 0.0015u535511 3 5 8 4 0.0014u535512 3 5 8 6 0.0014u535513 3 5 8 3 0.0014u535514 3 5 8 3 0.0013u535515 3 5 8 6 0.0013u535516 3 5 8 2 0.0013u535517 3 5 8 3 0.0013u535518 3 5 8 7 0.0014u535519 3 5 8 5 0.0013u535520 3 5 8 6 0.0013u535521 3 5 8 4 0.0014u535522 3 5 8 4 0.0013u535523 3 5 8 1 0.0014u535524 3 5 8 3 0.0013u535525 3 5 8 6 0.0014u535526 3 5 8 2 0.0014u535527 3 5 8 2 0.0013u535528 3 5 8 4 0.0013u535529 3 5 8 6 0.0013u535530 3 5 8 2 0.0015u535531 3 5 8 6 0.0014u535532 3 5 8 2 0.0013u535533 3 5 8 6 0.0013u535534 3 5 8 6 0.0014u535535 3 5 8 4 0.0013u535536 3 5 8 5 0.0014u535537 3 5 8 3 0.0013u535538 3 5 8 4 0.0013u535539 3 5 8 6 0.0013u535540 3 5 8 3 0.0013u535541 3 5 8 4 0.0013u535542 3 5 8 4 0.0013u535543 3 5 8 3 0.0013u535544 3 5 8 4 0.0014u535545 3 5 8 4 0.0013u535546 3 5 8 5 0.0014u535547 3 5 8 5 0.0014u535548 3 5 8 4 0.0013u535549 3 5 8 3 0.0014

Table 72: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 162: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu536010 3 5 9 7 0.0015u536011 3 5 9 8 0.0016u536012 3 5 9 7 0.0015u536013 3 5 9 7 0.0015u536014 3 5 9 6 0.0015u536015 3 5 9 3 0.0014u536016 3 5 9 6 0.0014u536017 3 5 9 8 0.0015u536018 3 5 9 6 0.0014u536019 3 5 9 3 0.0015u536020 3 5 9 5 0.0014u536021 3 5 9 7 0.0014u536022 3 5 9 6 0.0014u536023 3 5 9 6 0.0015u536024 3 5 9 5 0.0015u536025 3 5 9 6 0.0014u536026 3 5 9 4 0.0014u536027 3 5 9 4 0.0014u536028 3 5 9 8 0.0015u536029 3 5 9 5 0.0015u536030 3 5 9 7 0.0015u536031 3 5 9 1 0.0015u536032 3 5 9 2 0.0015u536033 3 5 9 7 0.0015u536034 3 5 9 4 0.0014u536035 3 5 9 6 0.0014u536036 3 5 9 8 0.0015u536037 3 5 9 3 0.0014u536038 3 5 9 7 0.0015u536039 3 5 9 5 0.0014u536040 3 5 9 4 0.0014u536041 3 5 9 3 0.0014u536042 3 5 9 4 0.0014u536043 3 5 9 6 0.0014u536044 3 5 9 3 0.0014u536045 3 5 9 4 0.0014u536046 3 5 9 3 0.0015u536047 3 5 9 4 0.0014u536048 3 5 9 8 0.0015u536049 3 5 9 8 0.0014u536510 3 5 9 7 0.0016u536511 3 5 9 5 0.0015u536512 3 5 9 3 0.0015u536513 3 5 9 4 0.0015u536514 3 5 9 1 0.0014u536515 3 5 9 10 0.0015u536516 3 5 9 7 0.0014u536517 3 5 9 5 0.0014u536518 3 5 9 5 0.0014u536519 3 5 9 6 0.0014u536520 3 5 9 8 0.0015u536521 3 5 9 4 0.0014u536522 3 5 9 2 0.0014u536523 3 5 9 4 0.0014u536524 3 5 9 6 0.0014u536525 3 5 9 8 0.0014u536526 3 5 9 6 0.0014u536527 3 5 9 4 0.0015u536528 3 5 9 5 0.0014u536529 3 5 9 6 0.0016u536530 3 5 9 8 0.0015u536531 3 5 9 7 0.0014u536532 3 5 9 4 0.0015u536533 3 5 9 5 0.0014u536534 3 5 9 6 0.0015u536535 3 5 9 4 0.0014u536536 3 5 9 6 0.0014u536537 3 5 9 4 0.0014u536538 3 5 9 4 0.0014u536539 3 5 9 6 0.0014

Table 73: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 163: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu536540 3 5 9 4 0.0014u536541 3 5 9 5 0.0014u536542 3 5 9 2 0.0015u536543 3 5 9 5 0.0014u536544 3 5 9 4 0.0014u536545 3 5 9 2 0.0014u536546 3 5 9 4 0.0014u536547 3 5 9 8 0.0014u536548 3 5 9 6 0.0014u536549 3 5 9 3 0.0016u537010 3 5 10 9 0.0016u537011 3 5 10 8 0.0018u537012 3 5 10 3 0.0017u537013 3 5 10 9 0.0016u537014 3 5 10 8 0.0017u537015 3 5 10 7 0.0016u537016 3 5 10 7 0.0016u537017 3 5 10 9 0.0015u537018 3 5 10 10 0.0016u537019 3 5 10 9 0.0016u537020 3 5 10 5 0.0019u537021 3 5 10 13 0.0018u537022 3 5 10 8 0.0017u537023 3 5 10 13 0.0016u537024 3 5 10 5 0.0017u537025 3 5 10 8 0.0015u537026 3 5 10 5 0.0017u537027 3 5 10 4 0.0016u537028 3 5 10 7 0.0016u537029 3 5 10 4 0.0016u537030 3 5 10 5 0.0015u537031 3 5 10 7 0.0016u537032 3 5 10 9 0.0016u537033 3 5 10 4 0.0016u537034 3 5 10 3 0.0016u537035 3 5 10 7 0.0016u537036 3 5 10 5 0.0016u537037 3 5 10 10 0.0016u537038 3 5 10 7 0.0016u537039 3 5 10 3 0.0016u537040 3 5 10 10 0.0016u537041 3 5 10 9 0.0016u537042 3 5 10 9 0.0016u537043 3 5 10 4 0.0016u537044 3 5 10 11 0.0017u537045 3 5 10 7 0.0016u537046 3 5 10 5 0.0016u537047 3 5 10 2 0.0016u537048 3 5 10 4 0.0016u537049 3 5 10 3 0.0016u537510 3 5 11 4 0.0016u537511 3 5 11 11 0.0016u537512 3 5 11 8 0.0017u537513 3 5 11 7 0.0016u537514 3 5 11 7 0.0017u537515 3 5 11 11 0.0017u537516 3 5 11 12 0.0016u537517 3 5 11 7 0.0016u537518 3 5 11 7 0.0016u537519 3 5 11 9 0.0017u537520 3 5 11 4 0.0016u537521 3 5 11 10 0.0019u537522 3 5 11 8 0.0017u537523 3 5 11 6 0.0017u537524 3 5 11 9 0.0016u537525 3 5 11 8 0.0017u537526 3 5 11 7 0.0016u537527 3 5 11 10 0.0016u537528 3 5 11 4 0.0016u537529 3 5 11 7 0.0016

Table 74: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 164: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu537530 3 5 11 11 0.0017u537531 3 5 11 13 0.0017u537532 3 5 11 13 0.0016u537533 3 5 11 6 0.0016u537534 3 5 11 9 0.0016u537535 3 5 11 8 0.0016u537536 3 5 11 6 0.0016u537537 3 5 11 7 0.0016u537538 3 5 11 7 0.0017u537539 3 5 11 5 0.0017u537540 3 5 11 6 0.0017u537541 3 5 11 7 0.0017u537542 3 5 11 3 0.0017u537543 3 5 11 9 0.0016u537544 3 5 11 9 0.0017u537545 3 5 11 9 0.0016u537546 3 5 11 5 0.0016u537547 3 5 11 12 0.0017u537548 3 5 11 7 0.0016u537549 3 5 11 9 0.0017u545510 4 5 11 5 0.0017u545511 4 5 11 6 0.0017u545512 4 5 11 7 0.0017u545513 4 5 11 4 0.0018u545514 4 5 11 6 0.0017u545515 4 5 11 6 0.0019u545516 4 5 11 10 0.0017u545517 4 5 11 5 0.0018u545518 4 5 11 7 0.0017u545519 4 5 11 8 0.0019u545520 4 5 11 6 0.0017u545521 4 5 11 5 0.0018u545522 4 5 11 2 0.0018u545523 4 5 11 5 0.0017u545524 4 5 11 5 0.0017u545525 4 5 11 4 0.0018u545526 4 5 11 2 0.0017u545527 4 5 11 9 0.0018u545528 4 5 11 4 0.0017u545529 4 5 11 4 0.0017u545530 4 5 11 8 0.0017u545531 4 5 11 4 0.0020u545532 4 5 11 8 0.0018u545533 4 5 11 7 0.0018u545534 4 5 11 7 0.0018u545535 4 5 11 5 0.0018u545536 4 5 11 5 0.0017u545537 4 5 11 1 0.0017u545538 4 5 11 7 0.0017u545539 4 5 11 5 0.0017u545540 4 5 11 4 0.0018u545541 4 5 11 5 0.0017u545542 4 5 11 5 0.0018u545543 4 5 11 6 0.0017u545544 4 5 11 1 0.0018u545545 4 5 11 5 0.0017u545546 4 5 11 6 0.0017u545547 4 5 11 7 0.0017u545548 4 5 11 7 0.0018u545549 4 5 11 9 0.0017u546010 4 5 12 7 0.0019u546011 4 5 12 4 0.0019u546012 4 5 12 7 0.0021u546013 4 5 12 5 0.0019u546014 4 5 12 6 0.0019u546015 4 5 12 3 0.0019u546016 4 5 12 8 0.0019u546017 4 5 12 7 0.0019u546018 4 5 12 7 0.0019u546019 4 5 12 3 0.0019

Table 75: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 165: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu546020 4 5 12 6 0.0018u546021 4 5 12 5 0.0019u546022 4 5 12 5 0.0020u546023 4 5 12 8 0.0020u546024 4 5 12 4 0.0019u546025 4 5 12 7 0.0019u546026 4 5 12 8 0.0020u546027 4 5 12 5 0.0019u546028 4 5 12 7 0.0019u546029 4 5 12 9 0.0018u546030 4 5 12 7 0.0019u546031 4 5 12 4 0.0019u546032 4 5 12 7 0.0019u546033 4 5 12 5 0.0019u546034 4 5 12 8 0.0019u546035 4 5 12 10 0.0018u546036 4 5 12 6 0.0019u546037 4 5 12 7 0.0019u546038 4 5 12 10 0.0019u546039 4 5 12 6 0.0019u546040 4 5 12 8 0.0020u546041 4 5 12 11 0.0021u546042 4 5 12 2 0.0019u546043 4 5 12 9 0.0019u546044 4 5 12 5 0.0018u546045 4 5 12 4 0.0019u546046 4 5 12 7 0.0018u546047 4 5 12 9 0.0019u546048 4 5 12 5 0.0018u546049 4 5 12 9 0.0018u546510 4 5 13 5 0.0020u546511 4 5 13 6 0.0020u546512 4 5 13 8 0.0021u546513 4 5 13 7 0.0021u546514 4 5 13 12 0.0024u546515 4 5 13 8 0.0020u546516 4 5 13 10 0.0021u546517 4 5 13 6 0.0020u546518 4 5 13 9 0.0020u546519 4 5 13 11 0.0019u546520 4 5 13 10 0.0020u546521 4 5 13 7 0.0020u546522 4 5 13 11 0.0020u546523 4 5 13 7 0.0019u546524 4 5 13 6 0.0019u546525 4 5 13 9 0.0020u546526 4 5 13 6 0.0021u546527 4 5 13 9 0.0022u546528 4 5 13 6 0.0021u546529 4 5 13 4 0.0020u546530 4 5 13 6 0.0020u546531 4 5 13 10 0.0021u546532 4 5 13 5 0.0020u546533 4 5 13 6 0.0019u546534 4 5 13 12 0.0022u546535 4 5 13 4 0.0024u546536 4 5 13 9 0.0022u546537 4 5 13 8 0.0021u546538 4 5 13 9 0.0023u546539 4 5 13 6 0.0021u546540 4 5 13 10 0.0024u546541 4 5 13 12 0.0022u546542 4 5 13 5 0.0020u546543 4 5 13 5 0.0020u546544 4 5 13 7 0.0021u546545 4 5 13 11 0.0022u546546 4 5 13 9 0.0024u546547 4 5 13 7 0.0020u546548 4 5 13 4 0.0019u546549 4 5 13 8 0.0019

Table 76: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 166: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu547010 4 5 14 10 0.0021u547011 4 5 14 6 0.0021u547012 4 5 14 6 0.0022u547013 4 5 14 9 0.0023u547014 4 5 14 9 0.0024u547015 4 5 14 6 0.0023u547016 4 5 14 7 0.0021u547017 4 5 14 10 0.0021u547018 4 5 14 5 0.0021u547019 4 5 14 4 0.0021u547020 4 5 14 9 0.0022u547021 4 5 14 9 0.0022u547022 4 5 14 9 0.0021u547023 4 5 14 12 0.0021u547024 4 5 14 8 0.0021u547025 4 5 14 10 0.0021u547026 4 5 14 8 0.0020u547027 4 5 14 8 0.0025u547028 4 5 14 10 0.0024u547029 4 5 14 9 0.0021u547030 4 5 14 7 0.0022u547031 4 5 14 10 0.0022u547032 4 5 14 8 0.0020u547033 4 5 14 5 0.0022u547034 4 5 14 5 0.0021u547035 4 5 14 7 0.0023u547036 4 5 14 7 0.0021u547037 4 5 14 9 0.0021u547038 4 5 14 9 0.0021u547039 4 5 14 5 0.0021u547040 4 5 14 12 0.0027u547041 4 5 14 8 0.0024u547042 4 5 14 5 0.0022u547043 4 5 14 5 0.0022u547044 4 5 14 7 0.0022u547045 4 5 14 4 0.0021u547046 4 5 14 11 0.0022u547047 4 5 14 9 0.0021u547048 4 5 14 7 0.0020u547049 4 5 14 9 0.0021u547510 4 5 15 13 0.0024u547511 4 5 15 11 0.0022u547512 4 5 15 8 0.0023u547513 4 5 15 6 0.0024u547514 4 5 15 7 0.0024u547515 4 5 15 11 0.0022u547516 4 5 15 10 0.0023u547517 4 5 15 11 0.0024u547518 4 5 15 11 0.0023u547519 4 5 15 9 0.0023u547520 4 5 15 8 0.0022u547521 4 5 15 13 0.0022u547522 4 5 15 11 0.0023u547523 4 5 15 12 0.0023u547524 4 5 15 5 0.0023u547525 4 5 15 8 0.0023u547526 4 5 15 10 0.0026u547527 4 5 15 13 0.0031u547528 4 5 15 12 0.0022u547529 4 5 15 7 0.0023u547530 4 5 15 10 0.0022u547531 4 5 15 8 0.0022u547532 4 5 15 7 0.0022u547533 4 5 15 9 0.0023u547534 4 5 15 9 0.0023u547535 4 5 15 7 0.0022u547536 4 5 15 14 0.0026u547537 4 5 15 9 0.0024u547538 4 5 15 16 0.0026u547539 4 5 15 10 0.0022

Table 77: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 167: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu547540 4 5 15 13 0.0024u547541 4 5 15 10 0.0023u547542 4 5 15 9 0.0022u547543 4 5 15 11 0.0022u547544 4 5 15 9 0.0022u547545 4 5 15 13 0.0025u547546 4 5 15 10 0.0022u547547 4 5 15 13 0.0022u547548 4 5 15 12 0.0022u547549 4 5 15 12 0.0023u555510 5 5 13 8 0.0021u555511 5 5 13 6 0.0024u555512 5 5 13 3 0.0023u555513 5 5 13 3 0.0022u555514 5 5 13 4 0.0021u555515 5 5 13 8 0.0021u555516 5 5 13 4 0.0021u555517 5 5 13 6 0.0020u555518 5 5 13 6 0.0021u555519 5 5 13 7 0.0020u555520 5 5 13 8 0.0021u555521 5 5 13 7 0.0021u555522 5 5 13 8 0.0021u555523 5 5 13 5 0.0021u555524 5 5 13 8 0.0022u555525 5 5 13 7 0.0022u555526 5 5 13 6 0.0021u555527 5 5 13 4 0.0021u555528 5 5 13 7 0.0021u555529 5 5 13 7 0.0021u555530 5 5 13 5 0.0022u555531 5 5 13 5 0.0021u555532 5 5 13 4 0.0021u555533 5 5 13 6 0.0021u555534 5 5 13 4 0.0020u555535 5 5 13 10 0.0021u555536 5 5 13 2 0.0021u555537 5 5 13 7 0.0021u555538 5 5 13 5 0.0024u555539 5 5 13 6 0.0021u555540 5 5 13 2 0.0022u555541 5 5 13 4 0.0022u555542 5 5 13 5 0.0021u555543 5 5 13 5 0.0021u555544 5 5 13 7 0.0020u555545 5 5 13 6 0.0021u555546 5 5 13 5 0.0021u555547 5 5 13 5 0.0021u555548 5 5 13 8 0.0021u555549 5 5 13 9 0.0021u556010 5 5 15 8 0.0024u556011 5 5 15 6 0.0026u556012 5 5 15 10 0.0026u556013 5 5 15 6 0.0025u556014 5 5 15 10 0.0026u556015 5 5 15 6 0.0025u556016 5 5 15 7 0.0024u556017 5 5 15 10 0.0026u556018 5 5 15 7 0.0025u556019 5 5 15 6 0.0024u556020 5 5 15 12 0.0024u556021 5 5 15 8 0.0025u556022 5 5 15 8 0.0027u556023 5 5 15 11 0.0028u556024 5 5 15 8 0.0025u556025 5 5 15 10 0.0023u556026 5 5 15 8 0.0024u556027 5 5 15 9 0.0025u556028 5 5 15 8 0.0023u556029 5 5 15 7 0.0024

Table 78: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 168: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu556030 5 5 15 7 0.0024u556031 5 5 15 6 0.0023u556032 5 5 15 6 0.0023u556033 5 5 15 9 0.0023u556034 5 5 15 8 0.0029u556035 5 5 15 8 0.0031u556036 5 5 15 8 0.0026u556037 5 5 15 9 0.0027u556038 5 5 15 9 0.0026u556039 5 5 15 7 0.0026u556040 5 5 15 10 0.0030u556041 5 5 15 7 0.0025u556042 5 5 15 8 0.0024u556043 5 5 15 9 0.0028u556044 5 5 15 9 0.0023u556045 5 5 15 6 0.0031u556046 5 5 15 7 0.0024u556047 5 5 15 10 0.0023u556048 5 5 15 10 0.0023u556049 5 5 15 13 0.0026u556510 5 5 16 12 0.0025u556511 5 5 16 8 0.0024u556512 5 5 16 12 0.0025u556513 5 5 16 11 0.0026u556514 5 5 16 8 0.0024u556515 5 5 16 8 0.0026u556516 5 5 16 6 0.0025u556517 5 5 16 7 0.0033u556518 5 5 16 6 0.0026u556519 5 5 16 7 0.0025u556520 5 5 16 9 0.0025u556521 5 5 16 9 0.0025u556522 5 5 16 9 0.0024u556523 5 5 16 9 0.0024u556524 5 5 16 10 0.0024u556525 5 5 16 5 0.0024u556526 5 5 16 9 0.0024u556527 5 5 16 6 0.0025u556528 5 5 16 6 0.0028u556529 5 5 16 10 0.0028u556530 5 5 16 8 0.0024u556531 5 5 16 9 0.0025u556532 5 5 16 9 0.0024u556533 5 5 16 7 0.0024u556534 5 5 16 11 0.0026u556535 5 5 16 9 0.0024u556536 5 5 16 9 0.0024u556537 5 5 16 7 0.0024u556538 5 5 16 3 0.0024u556539 5 5 16 9 0.0024u556540 5 5 16 9 0.0034u556541 5 5 16 8 0.0026u556542 5 5 16 7 0.0025u556543 5 5 16 8 0.0026u556544 5 5 16 6 0.0024u556545 5 5 16 9 0.0024u556546 5 5 16 11 0.0026u556547 5 5 16 12 0.0024u556548 5 5 16 5 0.0025u556549 5 5 16 11 0.0023u557010 5 5 17 9 0.0025u557011 5 5 17 11 0.0029u557012 5 5 17 10 0.0030u557013 5 5 17 10 0.0027u557014 5 5 17 9 0.0026u557015 5 5 17 12 0.0026u557016 5 5 17 8 0.0026u557017 5 5 17 6 0.0025u557018 5 5 17 10 0.0027u557019 5 5 17 8 0.0025

Table 79: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 169: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu557020 5 5 17 8 0.0026u557021 5 5 17 12 0.0026u557022 5 5 17 6 0.0029u557023 5 5 17 5 0.0029u557024 5 5 17 14 0.0032u557025 5 5 17 13 0.0034u557026 5 5 17 10 0.0028u557027 5 5 17 13 0.0026u557028 5 5 17 9 0.0025u557029 5 5 17 6 0.0026u557030 5 5 17 8 0.0027u557031 5 5 17 7 0.0026u557032 5 5 17 5 0.0025u557033 5 5 17 11 0.0034u557034 5 5 17 11 0.0029u557035 5 5 17 10 0.0026u557036 5 5 17 9 0.0027u557037 5 5 17 10 0.0026u557038 5 5 17 6 0.0025u557039 5 5 17 10 0.0026u557040 5 5 17 9 0.0025u557041 5 5 17 14 0.0026u557042 5 5 17 9 0.0029u557043 5 5 17 11 0.0026u557044 5 5 17 8 0.0033u557045 5 5 17 8 0.0026u557046 5 5 17 9 0.0026u557047 5 5 17 13 0.0027u557048 5 5 17 13 0.0026u557049 5 5 17 6 0.0025u557510 5 5 18 9 0.0026u557511 5 5 18 9 0.0028u557512 5 5 18 13 0.0027u557513 5 5 18 8 0.0027u557514 5 5 18 8 0.0033u557515 5 5 18 14 0.0031u557516 5 5 18 11 0.0027u557517 5 5 18 8 0.0028u557518 5 5 18 11 0.0027u557519 5 5 18 12 0.0028u557520 5 5 18 10 0.0027u557521 5 5 18 11 0.0028u557522 5 5 18 12 0.0027u557523 5 5 18 10 0.0027u557524 5 5 18 10 0.0027u557525 5 5 18 13 0.0085u557526 5 5 18 13 0.0031u557527 5 5 18 8 0.0029u557528 5 5 18 12 0.0036u557529 5 5 18 11 0.0027u557530 5 5 18 11 0.0031u557531 5 5 18 12 0.0027u557532 5 5 18 13 0.0042u557533 5 5 18 11 0.0035u557534 5 5 18 12 0.0028u557535 5 5 18 9 0.0030u557536 5 5 18 9 0.0027u557537 5 5 18 10 0.0026u557538 5 5 18 10 0.0031u557539 5 5 18 11 0.0032u557540 5 5 18 10 0.0030u557541 5 5 18 14 0.0047u557542 5 5 18 8 0.0036u557543 5 5 18 11 0.0028u557544 5 5 18 10 0.0028u557545 5 5 18 12 0.0032u557546 5 5 18 5 0.0027u557547 5 5 18 7 0.0028u557548 5 5 18 13 0.0028u557549 5 5 18 11 0.0028

Table 80: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 170: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu565510 6 5 16 6 0.0025u565511 6 5 16 6 0.0025u565512 6 5 16 8 0.0033u565513 6 5 16 6 0.0025u565514 6 5 16 3 0.0025u565515 6 5 16 7 0.0025u565516 6 5 16 9 0.0025u565517 6 5 16 9 0.0025u565518 6 5 16 11 0.0025u565519 6 5 16 7 0.0025u565520 6 5 16 8 0.0026u565521 6 5 16 7 0.0024u565522 6 5 16 8 0.0025u565523 6 5 16 7 0.0028u565524 6 5 16 5 0.0030u565525 6 5 16 8 0.0025u565526 6 5 16 4 0.0025u565527 6 5 16 8 0.0025u565528 6 5 16 5 0.0025u565529 6 5 16 7 0.0027u565530 6 5 16 3 0.0025u565531 6 5 16 4 0.0025u565532 6 5 16 6 0.0025u565533 6 5 16 6 0.0025u565534 6 5 16 5 0.0025u565535 6 5 16 8 0.0035u565536 6 5 16 6 0.0026u565537 6 5 16 7 0.0025u565538 6 5 16 6 0.0025u565539 6 5 16 7 0.0025u565540 6 5 16 8 0.0025u565541 6 5 16 7 0.0026u565542 6 5 16 5 0.0026u565543 6 5 16 6 0.0025u565544 6 5 16 9 0.0025u565545 6 5 16 12 0.0025u565546 6 5 16 8 0.0034u565547 6 5 16 8 0.0026u565548 6 5 16 6 0.0026u565549 6 5 16 7 0.0026u566010 6 5 18 8 0.0028u566011 6 5 18 10 0.0028u566012 6 5 18 10 0.0027u566013 6 5 18 13 0.0028u566014 6 5 18 9 0.0028u566015 6 5 18 9 0.0027u566016 6 5 18 9 0.0028u566017 6 5 18 7 0.0034u566018 6 5 18 6 0.0029u566019 6 5 18 8 0.0030u566020 6 5 18 8 0.0028u566021 6 5 18 11 0.0040u566022 6 5 18 8 0.0028u566023 6 5 18 8 0.0028u566024 6 5 18 6 0.0028u566025 6 5 18 8 0.0029u566026 6 5 18 7 0.0033u566027 6 5 18 10 0.0030u566028 6 5 18 9 0.0029u566029 6 5 18 7 0.0029u566030 6 5 18 9 0.0028u566031 6 5 18 9 0.0028u566032 6 5 18 11 0.0028u566033 6 5 18 10 0.0028u566034 6 5 18 8 0.0030u566035 6 5 18 8 0.0029u566036 6 5 18 8 0.0033u566037 6 5 18 7 0.0029u566038 6 5 18 9 0.0028u566039 6 5 18 5 0.0032

Table 81: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 171: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu566040 6 5 18 10 0.0029u566041 6 5 18 12 0.0029u566042 6 5 18 9 0.0028u566043 6 5 18 8 0.0028u566044 6 5 18 5 0.0028u566045 6 5 18 9 0.0028u566046 6 5 18 8 0.0032u566047 6 5 18 9 0.0029u566048 6 5 18 9 0.0028u566049 6 5 18 7 0.0027u566510 6 5 19 11 0.0028u566511 6 5 19 9 0.0030u566512 6 5 19 8 0.0029u566513 6 5 19 9 0.0029u566514 6 5 19 11 0.0029u566515 6 5 19 12 0.0028u566516 6 5 19 13 0.0035u566517 6 5 19 11 0.0030u566518 6 5 19 8 0.0030u566519 6 5 19 9 0.0031u566520 6 5 19 9 0.0029u566521 6 5 19 7 0.0029u566522 6 5 19 9 0.0028u566523 6 5 19 10 0.0033u566524 6 5 19 4 0.0030u566525 6 5 19 11 0.0030u566526 6 5 19 9 0.0053u566527 6 5 19 9 0.0031u566528 6 5 19 11 0.0029u566529 6 5 19 9 0.0030u566530 6 5 19 6 0.0030u566531 6 5 19 13 0.0075u566532 6 5 19 10 0.0029u566533 6 5 19 11 0.0032u566534 6 5 19 12 0.0032u566535 6 5 19 10 0.0035u566536 6 5 19 11 0.0030u566537 6 5 19 10 0.0030u566538 6 5 19 13 0.0029u566539 6 5 19 9 0.0029u566540 6 5 19 10 0.0028u566541 6 5 19 9 0.0030u566542 6 5 19 9 0.0029u566543 6 5 19 7 0.0029u566544 6 5 19 11 0.0035u566545 6 5 19 10 0.0032u566546 6 5 19 9 0.0030u566547 6 5 19 11 0.0031u566548 6 5 19 12 0.0036u566549 6 5 19 11 0.0034u567010 6 5 21 14 0.0039u567011 6 5 21 8 0.0038u567012 6 5 21 13 0.0104u567013 6 5 21 10 0.0037u567014 6 5 21 13 0.0041u567015 6 5 21 15 0.0055u567016 6 5 21 12 0.0033u567017 6 5 21 16 0.0033u567018 6 5 21 13 0.0033u567019 6 5 21 11 0.0039u567020 6 5 21 14 0.0034u567021 6 5 21 14 0.0033u567022 6 5 21 10 0.0032u567023 6 5 21 11 0.0033u567024 6 5 21 15 0.0047u567025 6 5 21 11 0.0031u567026 6 5 21 11 0.0032u567027 6 5 21 12 0.0043u567028 6 5 21 7 0.0031u567029 6 5 21 10 0.0034

Table 82: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 172: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu567030 6 5 21 13 0.0033u567031 6 5 21 15 0.0033u567032 6 5 21 11 0.0034u567033 6 5 21 9 0.0032u567034 6 5 21 11 0.0032u567035 6 5 21 13 0.0083u567036 6 5 21 9 0.0034u567037 6 5 21 9 0.0034u567038 6 5 21 6 0.0033u567039 6 5 21 9 0.0033u567040 6 5 21 13 0.0041u567041 6 5 21 11 0.0033u567042 6 5 21 14 0.0033u567043 6 5 21 11 0.0039u567044 6 5 21 10 0.0034u567045 6 5 21 10 0.0033u567046 6 5 21 15 0.0033u567047 6 5 21 13 0.0033u567048 6 5 21 10 0.0039u567049 6 5 21 8 0.0032u567510 6 5 22 9 0.0035u567511 6 5 22 8 0.0043u567512 6 5 22 12 0.0035u567513 6 5 22 10 0.0036u567514 6 5 22 16 0.0074u567515 6 5 22 16 0.0036u567516 6 5 22 10 0.0035u567517 6 5 22 14 0.0035u567518 6 5 22 14 0.0044u567519 6 5 22 10 0.0036u567520 6 5 22 14 0.0037u567521 6 5 22 15 0.0034u567522 6 5 22 14 0.0035u567523 6 5 22 11 0.0038u567524 6 5 22 14 0.0040u567525 6 5 22 14 0.0067u567526 6 5 22 10 0.0037u567527 6 5 22 11 0.0036u567528 6 5 22 9 0.0035u567529 6 5 22 12 0.0034u567530 6 5 22 10 0.0033u567531 6 5 22 12 0.0034u567532 6 5 22 12 0.0036u567533 6 5 22 13 0.0053u567534 6 5 22 14 0.0035u567535 6 5 22 14 0.0037u567536 6 5 22 14 0.0036u567537 6 5 22 12 0.0036u567538 6 5 22 11 0.0034u567539 6 5 22 16 0.0034u567540 6 5 22 11 0.0035u567541 6 5 22 13 0.0041u567542 6 5 22 11 0.0045u567543 6 5 22 14 0.0040u567544 6 5 22 10 0.0035u567545 6 5 22 13 0.0033u567546 6 5 22 15 0.0196u567547 6 5 22 11 0.0040u567548 6 5 22 16 0.0035u567549 6 5 22 10 0.0033u575510 7 5 19 8 0.0030u575511 7 5 19 5 0.0031u575512 7 5 19 8 0.0030u575513 7 5 19 9 0.0030u575514 7 5 19 4 0.0041u575515 7 5 19 8 0.0031u575516 7 5 19 10 0.0032u575517 7 5 19 6 0.0032u575518 7 5 19 8 0.0030u575519 7 5 19 11 0.0030

Table 83: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 173: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu575520 7 5 19 8 0.0045u575521 7 5 19 10 0.0035u575522 7 5 19 7 0.0035u575523 7 5 19 8 0.0037u575524 7 5 19 6 0.0032u575525 7 5 19 5 0.0030u575526 7 5 19 9 0.0033u575527 7 5 19 9 0.0030u575528 7 5 19 8 0.0030u575529 7 5 19 10 0.0031u575530 7 5 19 6 0.0031u575531 7 5 19 8 0.0030u575532 7 5 19 9 0.0037u575533 7 5 19 9 0.0032u575534 7 5 19 10 0.0033u575535 7 5 19 7 0.0030u575536 7 5 19 8 0.0030u575537 7 5 19 6 0.0030u575538 7 5 19 9 0.0030u575539 7 5 19 8 0.0030u575540 7 5 19 7 0.0031u575541 7 5 19 7 0.0041u575542 7 5 19 9 0.0031u575543 7 5 19 5 0.0032u575544 7 5 19 6 0.0030u575545 7 5 19 9 0.0030u575546 7 5 19 10 0.0030u575547 7 5 19 10 0.0029u575548 7 5 19 8 0.0036u575549 7 5 19 6 0.0030u576010 7 5 21 8 0.0043u576011 7 5 21 9 0.0035u576012 7 5 21 16 0.1619u576013 7 5 21 12 0.0033u576014 7 5 21 12 0.0034u576015 7 5 21 9 0.0040u576016 7 5 21 7 0.0035u576017 7 5 21 15 0.0033u576018 7 5 21 9 0.0033u576019 7 5 21 10 0.0044u576020 7 5 21 10 0.0035u576021 7 5 21 7 0.0035u576022 7 5 21 14 0.0038u576023 7 5 21 11 0.0034u576024 7 5 21 7 0.0033u576025 7 5 21 5 0.0034u576026 7 5 21 11 0.0034u576027 7 5 21 5 0.0043u576028 7 5 21 7 0.0035u576029 7 5 21 10 0.0037u576030 7 5 21 15 0.0034u576031 7 5 21 12 0.0033u576032 7 5 21 9 0.0034u576033 7 5 21 12 0.0034u576034 7 5 21 10 0.0034u576035 7 5 21 8 0.0036u576036 7 5 21 7 0.0036u576037 7 5 21 10 0.0035u576038 7 5 21 10 0.0034u576039 7 5 21 11 0.0034u576040 7 5 21 8 0.0033u576041 7 5 21 8 0.0036u576042 7 5 21 10 0.0036u576043 7 5 21 7 0.0036u576044 7 5 21 12 0.0044u576045 7 5 21 4 0.0035u576046 7 5 21 7 0.0034u576047 7 5 21 8 0.0034u576048 7 5 21 11 0.0034u576049 7 5 21 11 0.0033

Table 84: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 174: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu576510 7 5 22 10 0.0034u576511 7 5 22 9 0.0034u576512 7 5 22 12 0.0043u576513 7 5 22 9 0.0036u576514 7 5 22 12 0.0036u576515 7 5 22 9 0.0035u576516 7 5 22 12 0.0073u576517 7 5 22 8 0.0035u576518 7 5 22 12 0.0035u576519 7 5 22 13 0.0065u576520 7 5 22 10 0.0036u576521 7 5 22 12 0.0035u576522 7 5 22 10 0.0035u576523 7 5 22 16 0.0377u576524 7 5 22 12 0.0044u576525 7 5 22 11 0.0035u576526 7 5 22 15 0.0047u576527 7 5 22 11 0.0036u576528 7 5 22 11 0.0037u576529 7 5 22 8 0.0035u576530 7 5 22 9 0.0035u576531 7 5 22 12 0.0211u576532 7 5 22 14 0.0081u576533 7 5 22 12 0.0035u576534 7 5 22 13 0.0035u576535 7 5 22 11 0.0035u576536 7 5 22 8 0.0035u576537 7 5 22 8 0.0043u576538 7 5 22 8 0.0036u576539 7 5 22 12 0.0035u576540 7 5 22 11 0.0035u576541 7 5 22 11 0.0035u576542 7 5 22 9 0.0035u576543 7 5 22 15 0.0045u576544 7 5 22 11 0.0041u576545 7 5 22 14 0.0103u576546 7 5 22 11 0.0036u576547 7 5 22 11 0.0036u576548 7 5 22 11 0.0036u576549 7 5 22 7 0.0036u577010 7 5 24 15 0.0045u577011 7 5 24 10 0.0040u577012 7 5 24 11 0.0042u577013 7 5 24 8 0.0041u577014 7 5 24 11 0.0038u577015 7 5 24 12 0.0040u577016 7 5 24 14 0.0047u577017 7 5 24 14 0.0039u577018 7 5 24 11 0.0039u577019 7 5 24 13 0.0040u577020 7 5 24 14 0.0043u577021 7 5 24 15 0.0039u577022 7 5 24 12 0.0040u577023 7 5 24 8 0.0039u577024 7 5 24 17 0.0039u577025 7 5 24 13 0.0040u577026 7 5 24 12 0.0040u577027 7 5 24 13 0.0043u577028 7 5 24 14 0.0040u577029 7 5 24 9 0.0039u577030 7 5 24 16 0.0039u577031 7 5 24 12 0.0039u577032 7 5 24 11 0.0039u577033 7 5 24 15 0.0154u577034 7 5 24 15 0.0038u577035 7 5 24 9 0.0038u577036 7 5 24 15 0.0917u577037 7 5 24 9 0.0039u577038 7 5 24 12 0.0037u577039 7 5 24 13 0.0039

Table 85: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 175: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu577040 7 5 24 8 0.0039u577041 7 5 24 14 0.0039u577042 7 5 24 17 0.0038u577043 7 5 24 11 0.0040u577044 7 5 24 16 0.0393u577045 7 5 24 16 0.0038u577046 7 5 24 15 0.0038u577047 7 5 24 13 0.0043u577048 7 5 24 12 0.0038u577049 7 5 24 17 0.0042u577510 7 5 26 17 0.0061u577511 7 5 26 11 0.0044u577512 7 5 26 11 0.0043u577513 7 5 26 16 0.0092u577514 7 5 26 12 0.0042u577515 7 5 26 17 0.0043u577516 7 5 26 16 0.0043u577517 7 5 26 13 0.0041u577518 7 5 26 12 0.0042u577519 7 5 26 8 0.0041u577520 7 5 26 17 0.4850u577521 7 5 26 16 0.0133u577522 7 5 26 11 0.0041u577523 7 5 26 18 0.0041u577524 7 5 26 13 0.0047u577525 7 5 26 14 0.0044u577526 7 5 26 16 0.0042u577527 7 5 26 10 0.0041u577528 7 5 26 16 0.0042u577529 7 5 26 19 0.0178u577530 7 5 26 12 0.0042u577531 7 5 26 17 0.0047u577532 7 5 26 15 0.0578u577533 7 5 26 12 0.0042u577534 7 5 26 17 0.0054u577535 7 5 26 15 0.0078u577536 7 5 26 13 0.0048u577537 7 5 26 18 0.0044u577538 7 5 26 15 0.0063u577539 7 5 26 18 0.0042u577540 7 5 26 9 0.0041u577541 7 5 26 17 0.0041u577542 7 5 26 11 0.0041u577543 7 5 26 17 0.0625u577544 7 5 26 12 0.0305u577545 7 5 26 7 0.0042u577546 7 5 26 19 0.0042u577547 7 5 26 16 0.0043u577548 7 5 26 16 0.0267u577549 7 5 26 17 0.0994u635510 3 6 9 1 0.0015u635511 3 6 9 8 0.0015u635512 3 6 9 6 0.0014u635513 3 6 9 7 0.0014u635514 3 6 9 4 0.0015u635515 3 6 9 5 0.0015u635516 3 6 9 3 0.0015u635517 3 6 9 5 0.0015u635518 3 6 9 4 0.0014u635519 3 6 9 2 0.0014u635520 3 6 9 3 0.0015u635521 3 6 9 5 0.0015u635522 3 6 9 6 0.0014u635523 3 6 9 3 0.0014u635524 3 6 9 5 0.0014u635525 3 6 9 6 0.0015u635526 3 6 9 5 0.0015u635527 3 6 9 1 0.0015u635528 3 6 9 8 0.0015u635529 3 6 9 5 0.0015

Table 86: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 176: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu635530 3 6 9 6 0.0015u635531 3 6 9 5 0.0014u635532 3 6 9 4 0.0014u635533 3 6 9 1 0.0015u635534 3 6 9 6 0.0015u635535 3 6 9 9 0.0014u635536 3 6 9 7 0.0014u635537 3 6 9 5 0.0015u635538 3 6 9 3 0.0014u635539 3 6 9 4 0.0015u635540 3 6 9 8 0.0015u635541 3 6 9 4 0.0015u635542 3 6 9 4 0.0014u635543 3 6 9 7 0.0014u635544 3 6 9 7 0.0015u635545 3 6 9 6 0.0014u635546 3 6 9 4 0.0015u635547 3 6 9 4 0.0015u635548 3 6 9 3 0.0016u635549 3 6 9 7 0.0017u636010 3 6 10 8 0.0017u636011 3 6 10 6 0.0017u636012 3 6 10 9 0.0017u636013 3 6 10 7 0.0016u636014 3 6 10 5 0.0016u636015 3 6 10 6 0.0018u636016 3 6 10 10 0.0019u636017 3 6 10 6 0.0018u636018 3 6 10 4 0.0017u636019 3 6 10 7 0.0016u636020 3 6 10 7 0.0016u636021 3 6 10 3 0.0017u636022 3 6 10 8 0.0016u636023 3 6 10 4 0.0016u636024 3 6 10 5 0.0016u636025 3 6 10 4 0.0016u636026 3 6 10 6 0.0016u636027 3 6 10 8 0.0016u636028 3 6 10 6 0.0016u636029 3 6 10 6 0.0015u636030 3 6 10 7 0.0016u636031 3 6 10 5 0.0016u636032 3 6 10 8 0.0016u636033 3 6 10 6 0.0015u636034 3 6 10 10 0.0016u636035 3 6 10 10 0.0016u636036 3 6 10 2 0.0016u636037 3 6 10 4 0.0015u636038 3 6 10 3 0.0015u636039 3 6 10 9 0.0018u636040 3 6 10 9 0.0016u636041 3 6 10 3 0.0017u636042 3 6 10 10 0.0017u636043 3 6 10 8 0.0016u636044 3 6 10 8 0.0015u636045 3 6 10 8 0.0016u636046 3 6 10 8 0.0015u636047 3 6 10 8 0.0015u636048 3 6 10 3 0.0015u636049 3 6 10 8 0.0015u636510 3 6 11 8 0.0017u636511 3 6 11 7 0.0017u636512 3 6 11 10 0.0017u636513 3 6 11 6 0.0017u636514 3 6 11 5 0.0017u636515 3 6 11 13 0.0020u636516 3 6 11 8 0.0018u636517 3 6 11 10 0.0017u636518 3 6 11 13 0.0017u636519 3 6 11 12 0.0017

Table 87: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 177: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu636520 3 6 11 7 0.0016u636521 3 6 11 7 0.0017u636522 3 6 11 7 0.0017u636523 3 6 11 13 0.0017u636524 3 6 11 6 0.0017u636525 3 6 11 9 0.0017u636526 3 6 11 8 0.0017u636527 3 6 11 4 0.0016u636528 3 6 11 11 0.0017u636529 3 6 11 10 0.0017u636530 3 6 11 7 0.0016u636531 3 6 11 12 0.0016u636532 3 6 11 6 0.0017u636533 3 6 11 5 0.0018u636534 3 6 11 2 0.0017u636535 3 6 11 5 0.0017u636536 3 6 11 9 0.0017u636537 3 6 11 7 0.0017u636538 3 6 11 10 0.0016u636539 3 6 11 8 0.0017u636540 3 6 11 4 0.0016u636541 3 6 11 9 0.0017u636542 3 6 11 8 0.0017u636543 3 6 11 9 0.0017u636544 3 6 11 9 0.0017u636545 3 6 11 6 0.0017u636546 3 6 11 10 0.0017u636547 3 6 11 10 0.0017u636548 3 6 11 8 0.0016u636549 3 6 11 12 0.0018u637010 3 6 12 8 0.0019u637011 3 6 12 9 0.0018u637012 3 6 12 10 0.0018u637013 3 6 12 17 0.0024u637014 3 6 12 11 0.0018u637015 3 6 12 7 0.0018u637016 3 6 12 11 0.0017u637017 3 6 12 11 0.0018u637018 3 6 12 6 0.0017u637019 3 6 12 5 0.0018u637020 3 6 12 11 0.0020u637021 3 6 12 9 0.0018u637022 3 6 12 12 0.0018u637023 3 6 12 11 0.0019u637024 3 6 12 14 0.0018u637025 3 6 12 16 0.0023u637026 3 6 12 8 0.0018u637027 3 6 12 8 0.0018u637028 3 6 12 9 0.0018u637029 3 6 12 20 0.0020u637030 3 6 12 4 0.0019u637031 3 6 12 9 0.0018u637032 3 6 12 11 0.0019u637033 3 6 12 7 0.0018u637034 3 6 12 15 0.0020u637035 3 6 12 8 0.0018u637036 3 6 12 10 0.0018u637037 3 6 12 13 0.0021u637038 3 6 12 9 0.0018u637039 3 6 12 5 0.0017u637040 3 6 12 14 0.0019u637041 3 6 12 8 0.0019u637042 3 6 12 9 0.0019u637043 3 6 12 12 0.0018u637044 3 6 12 11 0.0018u637045 3 6 12 14 0.0018u637046 3 6 12 7 0.0018u637047 3 6 12 12 0.0019u637048 3 6 12 11 0.0017u637049 3 6 12 11 0.0018

Table 88: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 178: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu637510 3 6 13 15 0.0021u637511 3 6 13 11 0.0019u637512 3 6 13 13 0.0021u637513 3 6 13 7 0.0019u637514 3 6 13 8 0.0018u637515 3 6 13 7 0.0019u637516 3 6 13 9 0.0020u637517 3 6 13 11 0.0020u637518 3 6 13 10 0.0018u637519 3 6 13 12 0.0019u637520 3 6 13 5 0.0019u637521 3 6 13 7 0.0019u637522 3 6 13 15 0.0022u637523 3 6 13 15 0.0019u637524 3 6 13 4 0.0019u637525 3 6 13 14 0.0020u637526 3 6 13 11 0.0018u637527 3 6 13 16 0.0019u637528 3 6 13 12 0.0020u637529 3 6 13 11 0.0019u637530 3 6 13 9 0.0020u637531 3 6 13 13 0.0021u637532 3 6 13 10 0.0019u637533 3 6 13 5 0.0020u637534 3 6 13 12 0.0019u637535 3 6 13 11 0.0020u637536 3 6 13 11 0.0019u637537 3 6 13 13 0.0019u637538 3 6 13 9 0.0020u637539 3 6 13 17 0.0019u637540 3 6 13 8 0.0019u637541 3 6 13 13 0.0019u637542 3 6 13 11 0.0020u637543 3 6 13 8 0.0019u637544 3 6 13 14 0.0021u637545 3 6 13 16 0.0022u637546 3 6 13 14 0.0020u637547 3 6 13 11 0.0019u637548 3 6 13 14 0.0019u637549 3 6 13 8 0.0019u645510 4 6 13 10 0.0019u645511 4 6 13 8 0.0020u645512 4 6 13 6 0.0020u645513 4 6 13 7 0.0020u645514 4 6 13 7 0.0020u645515 4 6 13 9 0.0019u645516 4 6 13 10 0.0022u645517 4 6 13 10 0.0022u645518 4 6 13 6 0.0020u645519 4 6 13 9 0.0021u645520 4 6 13 9 0.0021u645521 4 6 13 11 0.0021u645522 4 6 13 9 0.0020u645523 4 6 13 4 0.0020u645524 4 6 13 10 0.0021u645525 4 6 13 8 0.0021u645526 4 6 13 8 0.0020u645527 4 6 13 8 0.0019u645528 4 6 13 8 0.0020u645529 4 6 13 8 0.0020u645530 4 6 13 6 0.0020u645531 4 6 13 9 0.0019u645532 4 6 13 5 0.0020u645533 4 6 13 7 0.0021u645534 4 6 13 8 0.0021u645535 4 6 13 13 0.0033u645536 4 6 13 8 0.0020u645537 4 6 13 5 0.0022u645538 4 6 13 5 0.0021u645539 4 6 13 9 0.0020

Table 89: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 179: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu645540 4 6 13 7 0.0020u645541 4 6 13 10 0.0021u645542 4 6 13 8 0.0024u645543 4 6 13 10 0.0026u645544 4 6 13 8 0.0021u645545 4 6 13 6 0.0023u645546 4 6 13 5 0.0023u645547 4 6 13 6 0.0022u645548 4 6 13 9 0.0023u645549 4 6 13 6 0.0021u646010 4 6 14 6 0.0025u646011 4 6 14 10 0.0021u646012 4 6 14 7 0.0021u646013 4 6 14 12 0.0021u646014 4 6 14 6 0.0021u646015 4 6 14 6 0.0021u646016 4 6 14 7 0.0021u646017 4 6 14 11 0.0020u646018 4 6 14 11 0.0023u646019 4 6 14 10 0.0022u646020 4 6 14 10 0.0022u646021 4 6 14 10 0.0022u646022 4 6 14 6 0.0020u646023 4 6 14 8 0.0021u646024 4 6 14 9 0.0021u646025 4 6 14 9 0.0021u646026 4 6 14 8 0.0023u646027 4 6 14 8 0.0021u646028 4 6 14 11 0.0021u646029 4 6 14 6 0.0021u646030 4 6 14 9 0.0021u646031 4 6 14 9 0.0021u646032 4 6 14 10 0.0023u646033 4 6 14 4 0.0023u646034 4 6 14 9 0.0023u646035 4 6 14 10 0.0021u646036 4 6 14 8 0.0021u646037 4 6 14 9 0.0021u646038 4 6 14 10 0.0021u646039 4 6 14 9 0.0021u646040 4 6 14 11 0.0025u646041 4 6 14 10 0.0022u646042 4 6 14 10 0.0022u646043 4 6 14 11 0.0023u646044 4 6 14 8 0.0021u646045 4 6 14 11 0.0022u646046 4 6 14 6 0.0023u646047 4 6 14 8 0.0022u646048 4 6 14 11 0.0023u646049 4 6 14 10 0.0021u646510 4 6 15 13 0.0025u646511 4 6 15 7 0.0023u646512 4 6 15 10 0.0026u646513 4 6 15 4 0.0022u646514 4 6 15 10 0.0022u646515 4 6 15 12 0.0023u646516 4 6 15 10 0.0022u646517 4 6 15 7 0.0023u646518 4 6 15 6 0.0025u646519 4 6 15 11 0.0024u646520 4 6 15 10 0.0023u646521 4 6 15 7 0.0023u646522 4 6 15 6 0.0025u646523 4 6 15 14 0.0031u646524 4 6 15 7 0.0023u646525 4 6 15 10 0.0022u646526 4 6 15 8 0.0023u646527 4 6 15 9 0.0022u646528 4 6 15 8 0.0022u646529 4 6 15 10 0.0024

Table 90: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 180: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu646530 4 6 15 9 0.0025u646531 4 6 15 9 0.0023u646532 4 6 15 10 0.0023u646533 4 6 15 11 0.0023u646534 4 6 15 10 0.0023u646535 4 6 15 8 0.0023u646536 4 6 15 7 0.0023u646537 4 6 15 11 0.0022u646538 4 6 15 10 0.0023u646539 4 6 15 12 0.0022u646540 4 6 15 6 0.0022u646541 4 6 15 13 0.0022u646542 4 6 15 9 0.0023u646543 4 6 15 11 0.0024u646544 4 6 15 12 0.0023u646545 4 6 15 9 0.0024u646546 4 6 15 6 0.0023u646547 4 6 15 11 0.0022u646548 4 6 15 11 0.0022u646549 4 6 15 11 0.0024u647010 4 6 16 10 0.0026u647011 4 6 16 9 0.0023u647012 4 6 16 11 0.0024u647013 4 6 16 14 0.0024u647014 4 6 16 9 0.0024u647015 4 6 16 11 0.0026u647016 4 6 16 9 0.0023u647017 4 6 16 7 0.0024u647018 4 6 16 8 0.0024u647019 4 6 16 10 0.0025u647020 4 6 16 10 0.0024u647021 4 6 16 12 0.0023u647022 4 6 16 13 0.0024u647023 4 6 16 11 0.0023u647024 4 6 16 8 0.0023u647025 4 6 16 14 0.0044u647026 4 6 16 11 0.0027u647027 4 6 16 8 0.0023u647028 4 6 16 9 0.0024u647029 4 6 16 3 0.0024u647030 4 6 16 8 0.0023u647031 4 6 16 11 0.0025u647032 4 6 16 7 0.0023u647033 4 6 16 9 0.0023u647034 4 6 16 9 0.0023u647035 4 6 16 14 0.0026u647036 4 6 16 11 0.0024u647037 4 6 16 3 0.0024u647038 4 6 16 11 0.0024u647039 4 6 16 10 0.0024u647040 4 6 16 9 0.0024u647041 4 6 16 13 0.0025u647042 4 6 16 12 0.0025u647043 4 6 16 10 0.0024u647044 4 6 16 16 0.0023u647045 4 6 16 14 0.0024u647046 4 6 16 13 0.0025u647047 4 6 16 14 0.0024u647048 4 6 16 13 0.0023u647049 4 6 16 12 0.0028u647510 4 6 18 10 0.0028u647511 4 6 18 17 0.0033u647512 4 6 18 15 0.0029u647513 4 6 18 14 0.0028u647514 4 6 18 13 0.0027u647515 4 6 18 12 0.0027u647516 4 6 18 15 0.0028u647517 4 6 18 13 0.0026u647518 4 6 18 12 0.0027u647519 4 6 18 18 0.0089

Table 91: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 181: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu647520 4 6 18 10 0.0027u647521 4 6 18 13 0.0027u647522 4 6 18 13 0.0026u647523 4 6 18 14 0.0026u647524 4 6 18 14 0.0042u647525 4 6 18 18 0.0031u647526 4 6 18 19 0.0031u647527 4 6 18 15 0.0028u647528 4 6 18 12 0.0029u647529 4 6 18 11 0.0028u647530 4 6 18 10 0.0027u647531 4 6 18 14 0.0029u647532 4 6 18 15 0.0031u647533 4 6 18 12 0.0029u647534 4 6 18 19 0.0162u647535 4 6 18 14 0.0028u647536 4 6 18 15 0.0029u647537 4 6 18 15 0.0026u647538 4 6 18 12 0.0027u647539 4 6 18 15 0.0029u647540 4 6 18 9 0.0026u647541 4 6 18 16 0.0030u647542 4 6 18 14 0.0026u647543 4 6 18 15 0.0027u647544 4 6 18 16 0.0055u647545 4 6 18 14 0.0027u647546 4 6 18 11 0.0027u647547 4 6 18 11 0.0028u647548 4 6 18 17 0.0037u647549 4 6 18 16 0.0153u655510 5 6 16 7 0.0025u655511 5 6 16 6 0.0026u655512 5 6 16 5 0.0025u655513 5 6 16 9 0.0025u655514 5 6 16 9 0.0026u655515 5 6 16 9 0.0024u655516 5 6 16 11 0.0034u655517 5 6 16 10 0.0033u655518 5 6 16 13 0.0029u655519 5 6 16 10 0.0026u655520 5 6 16 8 0.0027u655521 5 6 16 9 0.0025u655522 5 6 16 5 0.0025u655523 5 6 16 10 0.0027u655524 5 6 16 8 0.0024u655525 5 6 16 6 0.0025u655526 5 6 16 7 0.0024u655527 5 6 16 4 0.0025u655528 5 6 16 6 0.0024u655529 5 6 16 7 0.0025u655530 5 6 16 9 0.0031u655531 5 6 16 5 0.0026u655532 5 6 16 10 0.0024u655533 5 6 16 10 0.0047u655534 5 6 16 8 0.0024u655535 5 6 16 8 0.0025u655536 5 6 16 7 0.0024u655537 5 6 16 13 0.0036u655538 5 6 16 11 0.0025u655539 5 6 16 8 0.0025u655540 5 6 16 9 0.0024u655541 5 6 16 8 0.0025u655542 5 6 16 9 0.0026u655543 5 6 16 9 0.0025u655544 5 6 16 9 0.0025u655545 5 6 16 11 0.0026u655546 5 6 16 11 0.0031u655547 5 6 16 8 0.0026u655548 5 6 16 12 0.0031u655549 5 6 16 10 0.0025

Table 92: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 182: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu656010 5 6 18 9 0.0028u656011 5 6 18 13 0.0026u656012 5 6 18 9 0.0029u656013 5 6 18 14 0.0028u656014 5 6 18 13 0.0028u656015 5 6 18 11 0.0027u656016 5 6 18 14 0.0039u656017 5 6 18 9 0.0028u656018 5 6 18 11 0.0027u656019 5 6 18 11 0.0047u656020 5 6 18 8 0.0027u656021 5 6 18 9 0.0028u656022 5 6 18 11 0.0034u656023 5 6 18 10 0.0028u656024 5 6 18 13 0.0039u656025 5 6 18 10 0.0027u656026 5 6 18 9 0.0027u656027 5 6 18 11 0.0035u656028 5 6 18 11 0.0070u656029 5 6 18 8 0.0027u656030 5 6 18 7 0.0031u656031 5 6 18 8 0.0030u656032 5 6 18 8 0.0028u656033 5 6 18 10 0.0027u656034 5 6 18 11 0.0027u656035 5 6 18 14 0.0884u656036 5 6 18 11 0.0028u656037 5 6 18 10 0.0028u656038 5 6 18 9 0.0028u656039 5 6 18 12 0.0030u656040 5 6 18 11 0.0040u656041 5 6 18 9 0.0035u656042 5 6 18 15 0.0103u656043 5 6 18 9 0.0028u656044 5 6 18 11 0.0029u656045 5 6 18 14 0.0096u656046 5 6 18 12 0.0028u656047 5 6 18 11 0.0027u656048 5 6 18 8 0.0027u656049 5 6 18 13 0.0033u656510 5 6 19 8 0.0032u656511 5 6 19 15 0.0057u656512 5 6 19 14 0.0045u656513 5 6 19 17 0.0327u656514 5 6 19 13 0.0029u656515 5 6 19 9 0.0028u656516 5 6 19 8 0.0030u656517 5 6 19 10 0.0029u656518 5 6 19 10 0.0032u656519 5 6 19 13 0.0030u656520 5 6 19 6 0.0030u656521 5 6 19 12 0.0052u656522 5 6 19 10 0.0071u656523 5 6 19 7 0.0028u656524 5 6 19 13 0.0029u656525 5 6 19 15 0.0032u656526 5 6 19 15 0.0208u656527 5 6 19 12 0.0032u656528 5 6 19 14 0.0046u656529 5 6 19 13 0.0036u656530 5 6 19 14 0.0070u656531 5 6 19 11 0.0033u656532 5 6 19 13 0.0042u656533 5 6 19 15 0.0036u656534 5 6 19 12 0.0029u656535 5 6 19 9 0.0028u656536 5 6 19 14 0.0028u656537 5 6 19 11 0.0032u656538 5 6 19 10 0.0031u656539 5 6 19 11 0.0031

Table 93: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 183: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu656540 5 6 19 14 0.0038u656541 5 6 19 10 0.0029u656542 5 6 19 12 0.0029u656543 5 6 19 11 0.0029u656544 5 6 19 17 0.0053u656545 5 6 19 7 0.0029u656546 5 6 19 11 0.0029u656547 5 6 19 14 0.0028u656548 5 6 19 10 0.0030u656549 5 6 19 10 0.0029u657010 5 6 21 10 0.0031u657011 5 6 21 14 0.0035u657012 5 6 21 15 0.0035u657013 5 6 21 15 0.0057u657014 5 6 21 17 0.0038u657015 5 6 21 14 0.0044u657016 5 6 21 12 0.0035u657017 5 6 21 19 0.1674u657018 5 6 21 9 0.0032u657019 5 6 21 17 0.0775u657020 5 6 21 21 0.2427u657021 5 6 21 11 0.0034u657022 5 6 21 15 0.0098u657023 5 6 21 19 0.0390u657024 5 6 21 14 0.0082u657025 5 6 21 14 0.0036u657026 5 6 21 19 0.0044u657027 5 6 21 15 0.0034u657028 5 6 21 9 0.0033u657029 5 6 21 12 0.0032u657030 5 6 21 12 0.0031u657031 5 6 21 14 0.0092u657032 5 6 21 14 0.0034u657033 5 6 21 15 0.0053u657034 5 6 21 21 0.1098u657035 5 6 21 13 0.0155u657036 5 6 21 15 0.0032u657037 5 6 21 16 0.0040u657038 5 6 21 12 0.0033u657039 5 6 21 13 0.0038u657040 5 6 21 15 0.0034u657041 5 6 21 12 0.0032u657042 5 6 21 13 0.0032u657043 5 6 21 16 0.0567u657044 5 6 21 14 0.0032u657045 5 6 21 11 0.0032u657046 5 6 21 15 0.0043u657047 5 6 21 11 0.0034u657048 5 6 21 15 0.0033u657049 5 6 21 15 0.0031u657510 5 6 22 17 0.0137u657511 5 6 22 6 0.0033u657512 5 6 22 13 0.0038u657513 5 6 22 17 0.0048u657514 5 6 22 15 0.0038u657515 5 6 22 18 0.0063u657516 5 6 22 18 0.0037u657517 5 6 22 16 0.0036u657518 5 6 22 17 0.0033u657519 5 6 22 16 0.0041u657520 5 6 22 13 0.0033u657521 5 6 22 17 0.0034u657522 5 6 22 18 0.0065u657523 5 6 22 17 0.0481u657524 5 6 22 18 0.0056u657525 5 6 22 15 0.0033u657526 5 6 22 14 0.0033u657527 5 6 22 18 0.0038u657528 5 6 22 17 0.0037u657529 5 6 22 14 0.0036

Table 94: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 184: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu657530 5 6 22 14 0.0033u657531 5 6 22 18 0.0039u657532 5 6 22 19 0.0077u657533 5 6 22 12 0.0032u657534 5 6 22 20 0.0070u657535 5 6 22 15 0.0036u657536 5 6 22 15 0.0036u657537 5 6 22 16 0.0149u657538 5 6 22 13 0.0035u657539 5 6 22 9 0.0034u657540 5 6 22 20 0.0479u657541 5 6 22 13 0.0036u657542 5 6 22 18 0.0382u657543 5 6 22 18 0.0261u657544 5 6 22 13 0.0041u657545 5 6 22 19 0.0075u657546 5 6 22 18 0.0033u657547 5 6 22 11 0.0032u657548 5 6 22 14 0.0036u657549 5 6 22 12 0.0033u665510 6 6 19 13 0.0029u665511 6 6 19 11 0.0031u665512 6 6 19 12 0.0030u665513 6 6 19 8 0.0031u665514 6 6 19 10 0.0033u665515 6 6 19 8 0.0029u665516 6 6 19 9 0.0028u665517 6 6 19 13 0.0037u665518 6 6 19 12 0.0030u665519 6 6 19 8 0.0029u665520 6 6 19 10 0.0032u665521 6 6 19 11 0.0030u665522 6 6 19 9 0.0030u665523 6 6 19 12 0.0030u665524 6 6 19 13 0.0036u665525 6 6 19 13 0.0039u665526 6 6 19 12 0.0029u665527 6 6 19 11 0.0029u665528 6 6 19 11 0.0106u665529 6 6 19 6 0.0031u665530 6 6 19 10 0.0030u665531 6 6 19 8 0.0031u665532 6 6 19 12 0.0029u665533 6 6 19 9 0.0028u665534 6 6 19 10 0.0031u665535 6 6 19 12 0.0029u665536 6 6 19 7 0.0030u665537 6 6 19 8 0.0031u665538 6 6 19 8 0.0030u665539 6 6 19 13 0.0032u665540 6 6 19 9 0.0030u665541 6 6 19 12 0.0029u665542 6 6 19 17 0.0355u665543 6 6 19 8 0.0033u665544 6 6 19 10 0.0033u665545 6 6 19 9 0.0030u665546 6 6 19 8 0.0033u665547 6 6 19 10 0.0033u665548 6 6 19 8 0.0028u665549 6 6 19 12 0.0029u666010 6 6 21 13 0.0040u666011 6 6 21 8 0.0033u666012 6 6 21 9 0.0032u666013 6 6 21 11 0.0033u666014 6 6 21 8 0.0032u666015 6 6 21 16 0.0035u666016 6 6 21 13 0.0036u666017 6 6 21 13 0.0080u666018 6 6 21 12 0.0038u666019 6 6 21 10 0.0033

Table 95: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 185: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu666020 6 6 21 9 0.0033u666021 6 6 21 9 0.0034u666022 6 6 21 9 0.0035u666023 6 6 21 8 0.0036u666024 6 6 21 13 0.0034u666025 6 6 21 7 0.0032u666026 6 6 21 11 0.0034u666027 6 6 21 15 0.0038u666028 6 6 21 11 0.0033u666029 6 6 21 14 0.0386u666030 6 6 21 7 0.0033u666031 6 6 21 13 0.0585u666032 6 6 21 11 0.0034u666033 6 6 21 14 0.0031u666034 6 6 21 17 0.1076u666035 6 6 21 10 0.0034u666036 6 6 21 13 0.0033u666037 6 6 21 13 0.0039u666038 6 6 21 12 0.0040u666039 6 6 21 13 0.0189u666040 6 6 21 11 0.0034u666041 6 6 21 12 0.0033u666042 6 6 21 9 0.0035u666043 6 6 21 12 0.0033u666044 6 6 21 10 0.0032u666045 6 6 21 11 0.1586u666046 6 6 21 13 0.0034u666047 6 6 21 10 0.0033u666048 6 6 21 10 0.0032u666049 6 6 21 12 0.0037u666510 6 6 23 15 0.0090u666511 6 6 23 13 0.0040u666512 6 6 23 15 0.0175u666513 6 6 23 17 0.0037u666514 6 6 23 13 0.0035u666515 6 6 23 14 0.0036u666516 6 6 23 16 0.0861u666517 6 6 23 18 0.0061u666518 6 6 23 15 0.2240u666519 6 6 23 20 0.1640u666520 6 6 23 14 0.0050u666521 6 6 23 9 0.0036u666522 6 6 23 19 0.3052u666523 6 6 23 16 0.0057u666524 6 6 23 12 0.0036u666525 6 6 23 14 0.0038u666526 6 6 23 17 0.0063u666527 6 6 23 13 0.0035u666528 6 6 23 15 0.0039u666529 6 6 23 10 0.0048u666530 6 6 23 15 0.0037u666531 6 6 23 12 0.0158u666532 6 6 23 11 0.0041u666533 6 6 23 12 0.0039u666534 6 6 23 14 0.0106u666535 6 6 23 10 0.0035u666536 6 6 23 16 0.0035u666537 6 6 23 15 0.0036u666538 6 6 23 19 0.0376u666539 6 6 23 15 0.0036u666540 6 6 23 13 0.0036u666541 6 6 23 17 0.0064u666542 6 6 23 16 0.0085u666543 6 6 23 15 0.0042u666544 6 6 23 13 0.0040u666545 6 6 23 14 0.0038u666546 6 6 23 15 0.0036u666547 6 6 23 16 0.0038u666548 6 6 23 14 0.0036u666549 6 6 23 15 0.0035

Table 96: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 186: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu667010 6 6 25 15 0.0042u667011 6 6 25 14 0.0044u667012 6 6 25 13 0.0051u667013 6 6 25 16 0.0039u667014 6 6 25 14 0.0038u667015 6 6 25 22 0.0353u667016 6 6 25 13 0.0039u667017 6 6 25 14 0.0038u667018 6 6 25 20 0.0428u667019 6 6 25 20 0.0039u667020 6 6 25 17 0.0038u667021 6 6 25 12 0.0040u667022 6 6 25 16 0.0051u667023 6 6 25 19 0.0077u667024 6 6 25 17 0.0041u667025 6 6 25 12 0.0040u667026 6 6 25 18 0.0111u667027 6 6 25 11 0.0038u667028 6 6 25 19 0.0705u667029 6 6 25 14 0.0038u667030 6 6 25 22 0.0039u667031 6 6 25 17 0.0299u667032 6 6 25 20 0.0566u667033 6 6 25 19 0.0471u667034 6 6 25 13 0.0038u667035 6 6 25 14 0.0040u667036 6 6 25 18 0.0046u667037 6 6 25 20 0.1239u667038 6 6 25 18 0.0666u667039 6 6 25 17 0.0414u667040 6 6 25 13 0.0038u667041 6 6 25 14 0.0038u667042 6 6 25 20 0.0570u667043 6 6 25 15 0.0039u667044 6 6 25 11 0.0040u667045 6 6 25 12 0.0040u667046 6 6 25 19 0.0053u667047 6 6 25 20 0.0068u667048 6 6 25 15 0.0058u667049 6 6 25 14 0.0043u667510 6 6 27 18 0.0155u667511 6 6 27 16 0.0048u667512 6 6 27 17 0.2804u667513 6 6 27 20 0.0044u667514 6 6 27 20 0.0186u667515 6 6 27 20 0.0156u667516 6 6 27 17 0.0093u667517 6 6 27 18 0.0108u667518 6 6 27 20 0.0541u667519 6 6 27 14 0.0043u667520 6 6 27 18 0.0056u667521 6 6 27 21 0.0049u667522 6 6 27 17 0.0057u667523 6 6 27 23 0.1030u667524 6 6 27 16 0.0041u667525 6 6 27 20 0.0162u667526 6 6 27 21 0.1027u667527 6 6 27 19 0.0226u667528 6 6 27 16 0.0171u667529 6 6 27 18 0.0117u667530 6 6 27 18 0.0042u667531 6 6 27 22 0.1807u667532 6 6 27 15 0.0048u667533 6 6 27 19 0.0085u667534 6 6 27 18 0.0043u667535 6 6 27 12 0.0046u667536 6 6 27 23 0.0559u667537 6 6 27 14 0.0058u667538 6 6 27 19 0.0122u667539 6 6 27 20 0.0230

Table 97: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 187: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu667540 6 6 27 20 0.0119u667541 6 6 27 21 0.1532u667542 6 6 27 20 0.0438u667543 6 6 27 23 0.0046u667544 6 6 27 15 0.0044u667545 6 6 27 17 0.0197u667546 6 6 27 18 0.0045u667547 6 6 27 22 0.3441u667548 6 6 27 19 0.0049u667549 6 6 27 22 0.0300u675510 7 6 23 13 0.0040u675511 7 6 23 11 0.0036u675512 7 6 23 11 0.0036u675513 7 6 23 13 0.0066u675514 7 6 23 11 0.0039u675515 7 6 23 12 0.0040u675516 7 6 23 15 0.0630u675517 7 6 23 12 0.0037u675518 7 6 23 13 0.0037u675519 7 6 23 15 0.0038u675520 7 6 23 10 0.0037u675521 7 6 23 9 0.0037u675522 7 6 23 13 0.0037u675523 7 6 23 10 0.0042u675524 7 6 23 9 0.0038u675525 7 6 23 15 0.0038u675526 7 6 23 7 0.0036u675527 7 6 23 13 0.0036u675528 7 6 23 10 0.0040u675529 7 6 23 10 0.0036u675530 7 6 23 12 0.0038u675531 7 6 23 16 0.0039u675532 7 6 23 15 0.0038u675533 7 6 23 13 0.0036u675534 7 6 23 11 0.0036u675535 7 6 23 13 0.0040u675536 7 6 23 8 0.0036u675537 7 6 23 10 0.0036u675538 7 6 23 15 0.1008u675539 7 6 23 8 0.0036u675540 7 6 23 6 0.0037u675541 7 6 23 17 0.0039u675542 7 6 23 11 0.0043u675543 7 6 23 12 0.0041u675544 7 6 23 13 0.0078u675545 7 6 23 12 0.0197u675546 7 6 23 5 0.0047u675547 7 6 23 12 0.0048u675548 7 6 23 15 0.0047u675549 7 6 23 15 0.0950u676010 7 6 25 17 0.0047u676011 7 6 25 10 0.0045u676012 7 6 25 16 0.0077u676013 7 6 25 13 0.0052u676014 7 6 25 9 0.0053u676015 7 6 25 14 0.0041u676016 7 6 25 12 0.0041u676017 7 6 25 19 0.4438u676018 7 6 25 12 0.0115u676019 7 6 25 10 0.0097u676020 7 6 25 13 0.0076u676021 7 6 25 14 0.0077u676022 7 6 25 14 0.0073u676023 7 6 25 14 0.0071u676024 7 6 25 15 0.0064u676025 7 6 25 16 0.0318u676026 7 6 25 12 0.0061u676027 7 6 25 16 0.2301u676028 7 6 25 16 0.0042u676029 7 6 25 14 0.0040

Table 98: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 188: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu676030 7 6 25 14 0.0043u676031 7 6 25 17 0.0040u676032 7 6 25 10 0.0042u676033 7 6 25 13 0.0041u676034 7 6 25 13 0.0045u676035 7 6 25 17 0.0041u676036 7 6 25 13 0.0040u676037 7 6 25 12 0.0039u676038 7 6 25 12 0.0039u676039 7 6 25 11 0.0040u676040 7 6 25 19 0.0042u676041 7 6 25 17 0.0178u676042 7 6 25 16 0.0047u676043 7 6 25 17 0.2531u676044 7 6 25 12 0.0040u676045 7 6 25 12 0.0041u676046 7 6 25 14 0.0141u676047 7 6 25 17 0.0044u676048 7 6 25 15 0.0046u676049 7 6 25 14 0.0040u676510 7 6 27 14 0.0043u676511 7 6 27 14 0.0046u676512 7 6 27 17 0.0063u676513 7 6 27 14 0.0052u676514 7 6 27 15 0.0049u676515 7 6 27 15 0.1366u676516 7 6 27 14 0.0044u676517 7 6 27 22 0.6872u676518 7 6 27 18 0.0042u676519 7 6 27 17 0.0043u676520 7 6 27 12 0.0046u676521 7 6 27 14 0.0051u676522 7 6 27 18 0.0044u676523 7 6 27 14 0.0046u676524 7 6 27 18 0.0044u676525 7 6 27 21 0.1760u676526 7 6 27 16 0.0044u676527 7 6 27 19 0.0043u676528 7 6 27 16 0.0044u676529 7 6 27 17 0.0048u676530 7 6 27 13 0.0043u676531 7 6 27 15 0.0046u676532 7 6 27 17 0.4297u676533 7 6 27 17 0.0067u676534 7 6 27 17 0.2570u676535 7 6 27 17 0.0112u676536 7 6 27 16 0.0510u676537 7 6 27 17 0.0079u676538 7 6 27 15 0.0097u676539 7 6 27 13 0.0342u676540 7 6 27 15 0.0063u676541 7 6 27 14 0.0063u676542 7 6 27 16 0.0059u676543 7 6 27 17 0.0058u676544 7 6 27 19 0.1394u676545 7 6 27 16 0.0043u676546 7 6 27 18 0.0043u676547 7 6 27 13 0.0046u676548 7 6 27 11 0.0044u676549 7 6 27 12 0.0043u677010 7 6 29 23 0.3285u677011 7 6 29 12 0.0049u677012 7 6 29 17 0.0046u677013 7 6 29 17 0.0047u677014 7 6 29 13 0.0047u677015 7 6 29 8 0.0047u677016 7 6 29 13 0.0051u677017 7 6 29 19 0.0057u677018 7 6 29 20 0.0049u677019 7 6 29 21 0.0047

Table 99: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 189: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu677020 7 6 29 24 0.0048u677021 7 6 29 20 0.0049u677022 7 6 29 22 0.0482u677023 7 6 29 13 0.0050u677024 7 6 29 10 0.0047u677025 7 6 29 19 0.3840u677026 7 6 29 17 0.0049u677027 7 6 29 17 0.0047u677028 7 6 29 19 0.0047u677029 7 6 29 16 0.1840u677030 7 6 29 21 0.0083u677031 7 6 29 21 0.1505u677032 7 6 29 16 0.0106u677033 7 6 29 19 0.1155u677034 7 6 29 11 0.0047u677035 7 6 29 16 0.0049u677036 7 6 29 18 0.0046u677037 7 6 29 16 0.0217u677038 7 6 29 22 0.1330u677039 7 6 29 22 0.0133u677040 7 6 29 20 0.0047u677041 7 6 29 17 0.0057u677042 7 6 29 21 0.0054u677043 7 6 29 12 0.0052u677044 7 6 29 20 0.0398u677045 7 6 29 20 0.0417u677046 7 6 29 18 0.0253u677047 7 6 29 13 0.0065u677048 7 6 29 18 0.0725u677049 7 6 29 18 0.0054u677510 7 6 31 19 0.0275u677511 7 6 31 18 0.0051u677512 7 6 31 17 0.0051u677513 7 6 31 21 0.0643u677514 7 6 31 21 0.1035u677515 7 6 31 18 0.1418u677516 7 6 31 20 0.0050u677517 7 6 31 23 0.0140u677518 7 6 31 17 0.0391u677519 7 6 31 22 0.0153u677520 7 6 31 17 0.0050u677521 7 6 31 20 0.0250u677522 7 6 31 20 0.0049u677523 7 6 31 21 0.1823u677524 7 6 31 15 0.0050u677525 7 6 31 15 0.0050u677526 7 6 31 18 0.0050u677527 7 6 31 24 0.1825u677528 7 6 31 18 0.0049u677529 7 6 31 22 0.1021u677530 7 6 31 18 0.0056u677531 7 6 31 20 0.0095u677532 7 6 31 17 0.0050u677533 7 6 31 21 0.0107u677534 7 6 31 19 0.0761u677535 7 6 31 21 0.0129u677536 7 6 31 20 0.1615u677537 7 6 31 20 0.0053u677538 7 6 31 18 0.0055u677539 7 6 31 22 0.0054u677540 7 6 31 21 0.0223u677541 7 6 31 17 0.0114u677542 7 6 31 24 0.6709u677543 7 6 31 23 0.0082u677544 7 6 31 16 0.0054u677545 7 6 31 25 0.3537u677546 7 6 31 19 0.0060u677547 7 6 31 23 0.0693u677548 7 6 31 19 0.0050u677549 7 6 31 20 0.1252

Table 100: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 190: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu735510 3 7 11 8 0.0017u735511 3 7 11 4 0.0017u735512 3 7 11 6 0.0017u735513 3 7 11 8 0.0018u735514 3 7 11 9 0.0018u735515 3 7 11 8 0.0018u735516 3 7 11 5 0.0017u735517 3 7 11 6 0.0017u735518 3 7 11 6 0.0018u735519 3 7 11 7 0.0017u735520 3 7 11 5 0.0017u735521 3 7 11 8 0.0017u735522 3 7 11 6 0.0017u735523 3 7 11 8 0.0019u735524 3 7 11 7 0.0017u735525 3 7 11 4 0.0017u735526 3 7 11 7 0.0017u735527 3 7 11 7 0.0017u735528 3 7 11 8 0.0017u735529 3 7 11 6 0.0017u735530 3 7 11 8 0.0017u735531 3 7 11 6 0.0016u735532 3 7 11 9 0.0017u735533 3 7 11 7 0.0016u735534 3 7 11 9 0.0017u735535 3 7 11 10 0.0020u735536 3 7 11 3 0.0017u735537 3 7 11 6 0.0017u735538 3 7 11 6 0.0019u735539 3 7 11 8 0.0020u735540 3 7 11 8 0.0020u735541 3 7 11 8 0.0019u735542 3 7 11 9 0.0019u735543 3 7 11 11 0.0019u735544 3 7 11 7 0.0019u735545 3 7 11 10 0.0019u735546 3 7 11 6 0.0019u735547 3 7 11 10 0.0018u735548 3 7 11 12 0.0019u735549 3 7 11 9 0.0017u736010 3 7 12 9 0.0018u736011 3 7 12 12 0.0022u736012 3 7 12 11 0.0020u736013 3 7 12 7 0.0018u736014 3 7 12 9 0.0019u736015 3 7 12 9 0.0019u736016 3 7 12 9 0.0019u736017 3 7 12 11 0.0018u736018 3 7 12 9 0.0019u736019 3 7 12 14 0.0024u736020 3 7 12 8 0.0019u736021 3 7 12 7 0.0019u736022 3 7 12 7 0.0019u736023 3 7 12 12 0.0018u736024 3 7 12 10 0.0018u736025 3 7 12 11 0.0018u736026 3 7 12 9 0.0018u736027 3 7 12 8 0.0017u736028 3 7 12 10 0.0019u736029 3 7 12 12 0.0020u736030 3 7 12 8 0.0019u736031 3 7 12 6 0.0018u736032 3 7 12 10 0.0019u736033 3 7 12 12 0.0018u736034 3 7 12 11 0.0018u736035 3 7 12 7 0.0018u736036 3 7 12 11 0.0018u736037 3 7 12 6 0.0019u736038 3 7 12 5 0.0018u736039 3 7 12 13 0.0019

Table 101: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 191: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu736040 3 7 12 7 0.0018u736041 3 7 12 5 0.0018u736042 3 7 12 8 0.0017u736043 3 7 12 10 0.0020u736044 3 7 12 11 0.0018u736045 3 7 12 9 0.0020u736046 3 7 12 12 0.0021u736047 3 7 12 11 0.0019u736048 3 7 12 6 0.0018u736049 3 7 12 10 0.0018u736510 3 7 13 10 0.0019u736511 3 7 13 13 0.0021u736512 3 7 13 4 0.0019u736513 3 7 13 11 0.0019u736514 3 7 13 15 0.0025u736515 3 7 13 17 0.0025u736516 3 7 13 18 0.0020u736517 3 7 13 10 0.0020u736518 3 7 13 12 0.0019u736519 3 7 13 7 0.0019u736520 3 7 13 9 0.0021u736521 3 7 13 17 0.0023u736522 3 7 13 11 0.0020u736523 3 7 13 8 0.0019u736524 3 7 13 12 0.0021u736525 3 7 13 14 0.0025u736526 3 7 13 8 0.0019u736527 3 7 13 14 0.0021u736528 3 7 13 12 0.0020u736529 3 7 13 10 0.0019u736530 3 7 13 12 0.0020u736531 3 7 13 15 0.0022u736532 3 7 13 10 0.0020u736533 3 7 13 9 0.0020u736534 3 7 13 15 0.0023u736535 3 7 13 13 0.0020u736536 3 7 13 10 0.0020u736537 3 7 13 4 0.0019u736538 3 7 13 7 0.0019u736539 3 7 13 11 0.0021u736540 3 7 13 8 0.0019u736541 3 7 13 11 0.0020u736542 3 7 13 11 0.0019u736543 3 7 13 7 0.0019u736544 3 7 13 5 0.0019u736545 3 7 13 8 0.0019u736546 3 7 13 10 0.0020u736547 3 7 13 9 0.0019u736548 3 7 13 9 0.0020u736549 3 7 13 9 0.0020u737010 3 7 14 10 0.0021u737011 3 7 14 14 0.0021u737012 3 7 14 8 0.0022u737013 3 7 14 7 0.0020u737014 3 7 14 10 0.0021u737015 3 7 14 10 0.0020u737016 3 7 14 8 0.0020u737017 3 7 14 13 0.0022u737018 3 7 14 16 0.0021u737019 3 7 14 16 0.0022u737020 3 7 14 12 0.0021u737021 3 7 14 17 0.0025u737022 3 7 14 9 0.0022u737023 3 7 14 14 0.0021u737024 3 7 14 16 0.0023u737025 3 7 14 10 0.0021u737026 3 7 14 16 0.0023u737027 3 7 14 11 0.0021u737028 3 7 14 13 0.0026u737029 3 7 14 15 0.0026

Table 102: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 192: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu737030 3 7 14 9 0.0021u737031 3 7 14 9 0.0021u737032 3 7 14 6 0.0021u737033 3 7 14 12 0.0020u737034 3 7 14 14 0.0023u737035 3 7 14 17 0.0023u737036 3 7 14 10 0.0021u737037 3 7 14 13 0.0022u737038 3 7 14 16 0.0026u737039 3 7 14 12 0.0020u737040 3 7 14 13 0.0021u737041 3 7 14 14 0.0023u737042 3 7 14 11 0.0021u737043 3 7 14 11 0.0020u737044 3 7 14 10 0.0020u737045 3 7 14 10 0.0021u737046 3 7 14 10 0.0021u737047 3 7 14 16 0.0028u737048 3 7 14 10 0.0023u737049 3 7 14 14 0.0023u737510 3 7 15 16 0.0022u737511 3 7 15 16 0.0024u737512 3 7 15 13 0.0024u737513 3 7 15 18 0.0080u737514 3 7 15 15 0.0023u737515 3 7 15 18 0.0025u737516 3 7 15 16 0.0022u737517 3 7 15 13 0.0023u737518 3 7 15 10 0.0024u737519 3 7 15 9 0.0021u737520 3 7 15 18 0.0024u737521 3 7 15 15 0.0026u737522 3 7 15 14 0.0031u737523 3 7 15 20 0.0035u737524 3 7 15 16 0.0022u737525 3 7 15 15 0.0022u737526 3 7 15 18 0.0026u737527 3 7 15 19 0.0021u737528 3 7 15 11 0.0022u737529 3 7 15 17 0.0023u737530 3 7 15 9 0.0023u737531 3 7 15 16 0.0023u737532 3 7 15 12 0.0021u737533 3 7 15 17 0.0029u737534 3 7 15 12 0.0022u737535 3 7 15 11 0.0021u737536 3 7 15 19 0.0024u737537 3 7 15 16 0.0022u737538 3 7 15 11 0.0023u737539 3 7 15 16 0.0034u737540 3 7 15 22 0.0022u737541 3 7 15 16 0.0022u737542 3 7 15 18 0.0026u737543 3 7 15 14 0.0024u737544 3 7 15 17 0.0022u737545 3 7 15 12 0.0023u737546 3 7 15 17 0.0023u737547 3 7 15 13 0.0022u737548 3 7 15 9 0.0022u737549 3 7 15 16 0.0027u745510 4 7 15 5 0.0023u745511 4 7 15 10 0.0024u745512 4 7 15 12 0.0022u745513 4 7 15 9 0.0022u745514 4 7 15 12 0.0031u745515 4 7 15 12 0.0038u745516 4 7 15 9 0.0024u745517 4 7 15 8 0.0023u745518 4 7 15 11 0.0022u745519 4 7 15 10 0.0024

Table 103: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 193: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu745520 4 7 15 9 0.0023u745521 4 7 15 8 0.0023u745522 4 7 15 11 0.0023u745523 4 7 15 10 0.0022u745524 4 7 15 8 0.0024u745525 4 7 15 8 0.0024u745526 4 7 15 9 0.0024u745527 4 7 15 13 0.0025u745528 4 7 15 12 0.0024u745529 4 7 15 16 0.0045u745530 4 7 15 9 0.0022u745531 4 7 15 10 0.0022u745532 4 7 15 14 0.0022u745533 4 7 15 12 0.0022u745534 4 7 15 7 0.0023u745535 4 7 15 9 0.0022u745536 4 7 15 11 0.0025u745537 4 7 15 11 0.0027u745538 4 7 15 9 0.0022u745539 4 7 15 13 0.0031u745540 4 7 15 7 0.0023u745541 4 7 15 12 0.0024u745542 4 7 15 12 0.0023u745543 4 7 15 10 0.0022u745544 4 7 15 11 0.0026u745545 4 7 15 8 0.0022u745546 4 7 15 8 0.0023u745547 4 7 15 9 0.0022u745548 4 7 15 17 0.0105u745549 4 7 15 13 0.0027u746010 4 7 16 14 0.0028u746011 4 7 16 12 0.0025u746012 4 7 16 9 0.0024u746013 4 7 16 7 0.0023u746014 4 7 16 11 0.0023u746015 4 7 16 8 0.0024u746016 4 7 16 14 0.0069u746017 4 7 16 12 0.0028u746018 4 7 16 10 0.0025u746019 4 7 16 7 0.0025u746020 4 7 16 12 0.0024u746021 4 7 16 15 0.0288u746022 4 7 16 12 0.0027u746023 4 7 16 10 0.0023u746024 4 7 16 12 0.0026u746025 4 7 16 7 0.0024u746026 4 7 16 11 0.0026u746027 4 7 16 10 0.0024u746028 4 7 16 12 0.0027u746029 4 7 16 11 0.0027u746030 4 7 16 16 0.0035u746031 4 7 16 11 0.0024u746032 4 7 16 10 0.0024u746033 4 7 16 8 0.0026u746034 4 7 16 11 0.0025u746035 4 7 16 10 0.0024u746036 4 7 16 9 0.0024u746037 4 7 16 13 0.0025u746038 4 7 16 12 0.0024u746039 4 7 16 10 0.0033u746040 4 7 16 8 0.0026u746041 4 7 16 14 0.0029u746042 4 7 16 12 0.0027u746043 4 7 16 12 0.0026u746044 4 7 16 7 0.0024u746045 4 7 16 14 0.0068u746046 4 7 16 13 0.0026u746047 4 7 16 8 0.0023u746048 4 7 16 14 0.0024u746049 4 7 16 9 0.0024

Table 104: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 194: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu746510 4 7 18 15 0.0035u746511 4 7 18 13 0.0028u746512 4 7 18 12 0.0032u746513 4 7 18 13 0.0030u746514 4 7 18 16 0.0047u746515 4 7 18 12 0.0028u746516 4 7 18 16 0.0033u746517 4 7 18 10 0.0026u746518 4 7 18 12 0.0029u746519 4 7 18 12 0.0028u746520 4 7 18 14 0.0032u746521 4 7 18 13 0.0028u746522 4 7 18 12 0.0027u746523 4 7 18 8 0.0027u746524 4 7 18 16 0.0048u746525 4 7 18 10 0.0027u746526 4 7 18 12 0.0031u746527 4 7 18 14 0.0031u746528 4 7 18 13 0.0046u746529 4 7 18 13 0.0049u746530 4 7 18 16 0.0522u746531 4 7 18 12 0.0039u746532 4 7 18 14 0.0033u746533 4 7 18 17 0.0075u746534 4 7 18 17 0.0050u746535 4 7 18 14 0.0052u746536 4 7 18 12 0.0027u746537 4 7 18 13 0.0026u746538 4 7 18 14 0.0030u746539 4 7 18 16 0.0030u746540 4 7 18 11 0.0032u746541 4 7 18 12 0.0028u746542 4 7 18 15 0.0028u746543 4 7 18 14 0.0027u746544 4 7 18 12 0.0029u746545 4 7 18 14 0.0027u746546 4 7 18 11 0.0030u746547 4 7 18 8 0.0026u746548 4 7 18 12 0.0027u746549 4 7 18 10 0.0029u747010 4 7 19 19 0.0061u747011 4 7 19 11 0.0031u747012 4 7 19 16 0.0066u747013 4 7 19 14 0.0031u747014 4 7 19 19 0.0029u747015 4 7 19 16 0.0033u747016 4 7 19 13 0.0029u747017 4 7 19 18 0.0037u747018 4 7 19 15 0.0034u747019 4 7 19 10 0.0032u747020 4 7 19 15 0.0040u747021 4 7 19 16 0.0029u747022 4 7 19 14 0.0030u747023 4 7 19 16 0.0036u747024 4 7 19 16 0.0029u747025 4 7 19 14 0.0028u747026 4 7 19 12 0.0032u747027 4 7 19 14 0.0047u747028 4 7 19 10 0.0029u747029 4 7 19 18 0.0188u747030 4 7 19 16 0.0041u747031 4 7 19 18 0.0045u747032 4 7 19 17 0.0031u747033 4 7 19 16 0.0036u747034 4 7 19 15 0.0029u747035 4 7 19 15 0.0198u747036 4 7 19 16 0.0039u747037 4 7 19 15 0.0033u747038 4 7 19 17 0.0037u747039 4 7 19 12 0.0030

Table 105: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 195: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu747040 4 7 19 17 0.0037u747041 4 7 19 14 0.0049u747042 4 7 19 13 0.0034u747043 4 7 19 13 0.0034u747044 4 7 19 18 0.0061u747045 4 7 19 16 0.0030u747046 4 7 19 18 0.0110u747047 4 7 19 12 0.0028u747048 4 7 19 15 0.0041u747049 4 7 19 10 0.0030u747510 4 7 21 19 0.0035u747511 4 7 21 17 0.0031u747512 4 7 21 18 0.0044u747513 4 7 21 20 0.0061u747514 4 7 21 17 0.0049u747515 4 7 21 16 0.0036u747516 4 7 21 21 0.0068u747517 4 7 21 22 0.0034u747518 4 7 21 19 0.0070u747519 4 7 21 24 0.0737u747520 4 7 21 16 0.0037u747521 4 7 21 24 0.0265u747522 4 7 21 18 0.0042u747523 4 7 21 14 0.0031u747524 4 7 21 20 0.0037u747525 4 7 21 24 0.0482u747526 4 7 21 18 0.0031u747527 4 7 21 14 0.0033u747528 4 7 21 26 0.1330u747529 4 7 21 26 0.0753u747530 4 7 21 22 0.0476u747531 4 7 21 19 0.0040u747532 4 7 21 21 0.0063u747533 4 7 21 25 0.0165u747534 4 7 21 21 0.0036u747535 4 7 21 13 0.0031u747536 4 7 21 19 0.0036u747537 4 7 21 21 0.0055u747538 4 7 21 15 0.0037u747539 4 7 21 16 0.0037u747540 4 7 21 20 0.0061u747541 4 7 21 18 0.0035u747542 4 7 21 17 0.0041u747543 4 7 21 13 0.0031u747544 4 7 21 19 0.0123u747545 4 7 21 17 0.0073u747546 4 7 21 15 0.0031u747547 4 7 21 24 0.0416u747548 4 7 21 10 0.0036u747549 4 7 21 18 0.0054u755510 5 7 19 10 0.0029u755511 5 7 19 16 0.0117u755512 5 7 19 11 0.0029u755513 5 7 19 12 0.0028u755514 5 7 19 15 0.0094u755515 5 7 19 13 0.0030u755516 5 7 19 14 0.0029u755517 5 7 19 11 0.0030u755518 5 7 19 10 0.0032u755519 5 7 19 13 0.0048u755520 5 7 19 11 0.0038u755521 5 7 19 10 0.0031u755522 5 7 19 8 0.0032u755523 5 7 19 10 0.0031u755524 5 7 19 14 0.0030u755525 5 7 19 16 0.0564u755526 5 7 19 10 0.0032u755527 5 7 19 19 0.1728u755528 5 7 19 16 0.0041u755529 5 7 19 14 0.0034

Table 106: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 196: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu755530 5 7 19 9 0.0038u755531 5 7 19 8 0.0033u755532 5 7 19 17 0.0050u755533 5 7 19 7 0.0033u755534 5 7 19 14 0.0198u755535 5 7 19 8 0.0032u755536 5 7 19 15 0.0125u755537 5 7 19 8 0.0031u755538 5 7 19 12 0.0031u755539 5 7 19 11 0.0029u755540 5 7 19 13 0.0028u755541 5 7 19 11 0.0029u755542 5 7 19 13 0.0072u755543 5 7 19 14 0.0778u755544 5 7 19 13 0.0048u755545 5 7 19 16 0.0078u755546 5 7 19 9 0.0031u755547 5 7 19 11 0.0039u755548 5 7 19 13 0.0029u755549 5 7 19 8 0.0033u756010 5 7 21 19 0.0754u756011 5 7 21 17 0.1096u756012 5 7 21 16 0.0045u756013 5 7 21 16 0.0034u756014 5 7 21 10 0.0035u756015 5 7 21 11 0.0050u756016 5 7 21 14 0.0034u756017 5 7 21 20 0.1303u756018 5 7 21 9 0.0071u756019 5 7 21 22 0.0817u756020 5 7 21 15 0.0064u756021 5 7 21 12 0.0054u756022 5 7 21 15 0.0057u756023 5 7 21 13 0.0045u756024 5 7 21 14 0.0046u756025 5 7 21 12 0.0048u756026 5 7 21 12 0.0087u756027 5 7 21 17 0.0041u756028 5 7 21 19 0.0924u756029 5 7 21 18 0.0035u756030 5 7 21 18 0.0373u756031 5 7 21 18 0.1567u756032 5 7 21 14 0.0043u756033 5 7 21 11 0.0032u756034 5 7 21 13 0.0037u756035 5 7 21 13 0.0036u756036 5 7 21 17 0.0032u756037 5 7 21 14 0.0093u756038 5 7 21 14 0.0033u756039 5 7 21 15 0.0033u756040 5 7 21 20 0.1488u756041 5 7 21 13 0.0042u756042 5 7 21 14 0.0050u756043 5 7 21 17 0.0050u756044 5 7 21 10 0.0033u756045 5 7 21 10 0.0033u756046 5 7 21 17 0.0045u756047 5 7 21 12 0.0036u756048 5 7 21 13 0.0033u756049 5 7 21 16 0.0249u756510 5 7 22 18 0.0040u756511 5 7 22 18 0.2116u756512 5 7 22 18 0.0420u756513 5 7 22 16 0.0060u756514 5 7 22 14 0.0033u756515 5 7 22 15 0.0141u756516 5 7 22 15 0.0034u756517 5 7 22 11 0.0036u756518 5 7 22 13 0.0035u756519 5 7 22 20 0.0042

Table 107: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 197: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu756520 5 7 22 16 0.0033u756521 5 7 22 18 0.0938u756522 5 7 22 15 0.0041u756523 5 7 22 18 0.0482u756524 5 7 22 14 0.0043u756525 5 7 22 18 0.0038u756526 5 7 22 12 0.0034u756527 5 7 22 14 0.0045u756528 5 7 22 16 0.0056u756529 5 7 22 15 0.0034u756530 5 7 22 15 0.0036u756531 5 7 22 16 0.0033u756532 5 7 22 16 0.0037u756533 5 7 22 16 0.0330u756534 5 7 22 16 0.0102u756535 5 7 22 17 0.1165u756536 5 7 22 16 0.0146u756537 5 7 22 12 0.0033u756538 5 7 22 12 0.0034u756539 5 7 22 13 0.0040u756540 5 7 22 12 0.0036u756541 5 7 22 10 0.0035u756542 5 7 22 18 0.1631u756543 5 7 22 16 0.0111u756544 5 7 22 15 0.0121u756545 5 7 22 19 0.0041u756546 5 7 22 13 0.0039u756547 5 7 22 18 0.1185u756548 5 7 22 14 0.0035u756549 5 7 22 17 0.0091u757010 5 7 24 14 0.0038u757011 5 7 24 15 0.0036u757012 5 7 24 18 0.0043u757013 5 7 24 20 0.0134u757014 5 7 24 14 0.0037u757015 5 7 24 15 0.0037u757016 5 7 24 18 0.0035u757017 5 7 24 21 0.1612u757018 5 7 24 25 0.4904u757019 5 7 24 13 0.0040u757020 5 7 24 21 0.2423u757021 5 7 24 19 0.0129u757022 5 7 24 17 0.0042u757023 5 7 24 23 0.0055u757024 5 7 24 21 0.0358u757025 5 7 24 13 0.0080u757026 5 7 24 17 0.0040u757027 5 7 24 19 0.0086u757028 5 7 24 21 0.0686u757029 5 7 24 19 0.0138u757030 5 7 24 19 0.0171u757031 5 7 24 17 0.0075u757032 5 7 24 18 0.0038u757033 5 7 24 19 0.0037u757034 5 7 24 9 0.0038u757035 5 7 24 9 0.0035u757036 5 7 24 14 0.0041u757037 5 7 24 19 0.0047u757038 5 7 24 13 0.0044u757039 5 7 24 16 0.0036u757040 5 7 24 19 0.0557u757041 5 7 24 19 0.0036u757042 5 7 24 16 0.0036u757043 5 7 24 20 0.0812u757044 5 7 24 23 0.2374u757045 5 7 24 19 0.0039u757046 5 7 24 19 0.0084u757047 5 7 24 19 0.0070u757048 5 7 24 15 0.0036u757049 5 7 24 20 0.1057

Table 108: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 198: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu757510 5 7 26 22 0.1953u757511 5 7 26 20 0.0936u757512 5 7 26 19 0.0052u757513 5 7 26 19 0.0043u757514 5 7 26 18 0.0053u757515 5 7 26 20 0.0128u757516 5 7 26 16 0.0042u757517 5 7 26 22 0.0208u757518 5 7 26 23 0.0054u757519 5 7 26 19 0.0057u757520 5 7 26 24 0.0465u757521 5 7 26 21 0.1073u757522 5 7 26 19 0.0536u757523 5 7 26 16 0.0042u757524 5 7 26 22 0.0413u757525 5 7 26 19 0.0453u757526 5 7 26 21 0.0083u757527 5 7 26 27 0.1507u757528 5 7 26 26 0.0927u757529 5 7 26 22 0.0068u757530 5 7 26 16 0.0096u757531 5 7 26 16 0.0044u757532 5 7 26 24 0.0575u757533 5 7 26 21 0.2198u757534 5 7 26 17 0.0047u757535 5 7 26 16 0.0162u757536 5 7 26 24 0.0044u757537 5 7 26 21 0.1901u757538 5 7 26 24 0.0167u757539 5 7 26 22 0.2173u757540 5 7 26 21 0.1108u757541 5 7 26 21 0.0812u757542 5 7 26 21 0.0370u757543 5 7 26 26 0.2374u757544 5 7 26 17 0.0040u757545 5 7 26 28 0.1691u757546 5 7 26 19 0.0063u757547 5 7 26 25 0.0985u757548 5 7 26 22 0.0236u757549 5 7 26 16 0.0048u765510 6 7 23 14 0.0038u765511 6 7 23 16 0.0036u765512 6 7 23 11 0.0035u765513 6 7 23 19 0.0041u765514 6 7 23 9 0.0036u765515 6 7 23 12 0.0037u765516 6 7 23 12 0.0042u765517 6 7 23 14 0.0039u765518 6 7 23 14 0.0842u765519 6 7 23 13 0.0037u765520 6 7 23 20 0.4708u765521 6 7 23 14 0.0036u765522 6 7 23 16 0.0112u765523 6 7 23 15 0.0037u765524 6 7 23 14 0.0152u765525 6 7 23 14 0.0048u765526 6 7 23 12 0.0035u765527 6 7 23 10 0.0035u765528 6 7 23 6 0.0036u765529 6 7 23 12 0.0035u765530 6 7 23 15 0.0039u765531 6 7 23 16 0.0037u765532 6 7 23 17 0.0038u765533 6 7 23 17 0.0069u765534 6 7 23 14 0.0035u765535 6 7 23 17 0.0063u765536 6 7 23 14 0.0061u765537 6 7 23 12 0.0038u765538 6 7 23 11 0.0037u765539 6 7 23 9 0.0037

Table 109: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 199: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu765540 6 7 23 12 0.0037u765541 6 7 23 11 0.0036u765542 6 7 23 13 0.0035u765543 6 7 23 15 0.0038u765544 6 7 23 17 0.0058u765545 6 7 23 16 0.1089u765546 6 7 23 15 0.0137u765547 6 7 23 15 0.0036u765548 6 7 23 19 0.1711u765549 6 7 23 11 0.0037u766010 6 7 25 17 0.0134u766011 6 7 25 22 0.3837u766012 6 7 25 19 0.0038u766013 6 7 25 14 0.0040u766014 6 7 25 15 0.1736u766015 6 7 25 16 0.0522u766016 6 7 25 15 0.0094u766017 6 7 25 16 0.0045u766018 6 7 25 18 0.1526u766019 6 7 25 15 0.0463u766020 6 7 25 14 0.0065u766021 6 7 25 19 0.4152u766022 6 7 25 19 0.0640u766023 6 7 25 19 0.0760u766024 6 7 25 19 0.0082u766025 6 7 25 21 0.0042u766026 6 7 25 16 0.0041u766027 6 7 25 19 0.0040u766028 6 7 25 19 0.0125u766029 6 7 25 11 0.0044u766030 6 7 25 15 0.0045u766031 6 7 25 18 0.2814u766032 6 7 25 16 0.0040u766033 6 7 25 12 0.0043u766034 6 7 25 16 0.0067u766035 6 7 25 19 0.0040u766036 6 7 25 15 0.0040u766037 6 7 25 17 0.1235u766038 6 7 25 14 0.0075u766039 6 7 25 19 0.1142u766040 6 7 25 17 0.0554u766041 6 7 25 14 0.0047u766042 6 7 25 17 0.0060u766043 6 7 25 13 0.0039u766044 6 7 25 16 0.0043u766045 6 7 25 19 0.0040u766046 6 7 25 14 0.0042u766047 6 7 25 12 0.0041u766048 6 7 25 16 0.0040u766049 6 7 25 17 0.0042u766510 6 7 27 15 0.0043u766511 6 7 27 18 0.0058u766512 6 7 27 17 0.1505u766513 6 7 27 21 0.4087u766514 6 7 27 14 0.1257u766515 6 7 27 20 0.0323u766516 6 7 27 24 0.4610u766517 6 7 27 13 0.0044u766518 6 7 27 18 0.3100u766519 6 7 27 14 0.0101u766520 6 7 27 23 0.0044u766521 6 7 27 17 0.0042u766522 6 7 27 15 0.0042u766523 6 7 27 18 0.0067u766524 6 7 27 19 0.0046u766525 6 7 27 20 0.7197u766526 6 7 27 18 0.0042u766527 6 7 27 15 0.0042u766528 6 7 27 16 0.0046u766529 6 7 27 16 0.0043

Table 110: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 200: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu766530 6 7 27 21 0.0766u766531 6 7 27 20 0.3007u766532 6 7 27 20 0.0042u766533 6 7 27 12 0.0043u766534 6 7 27 13 0.0050u766535 6 7 27 25 0.3363u766536 6 7 27 12 0.0043u766537 6 7 27 15 0.0042u766538 6 7 27 20 0.0057u766539 6 7 27 14 0.0042u766540 6 7 27 21 0.0331u766541 6 7 27 24 0.2046u766542 6 7 27 20 0.0054u766543 6 7 27 15 0.0071u766544 6 7 27 20 0.0835u766545 6 7 27 20 0.0043u766546 6 7 27 17 0.0044u766547 6 7 27 17 0.0062u766548 6 7 27 17 0.0863u766549 6 7 27 18 0.0064u767010 6 7 29 16 0.0051u767011 6 7 29 20 0.0119u767012 6 7 29 24 0.4486u767013 6 7 29 22 0.0124u767014 6 7 29 19 0.0343u767015 6 7 29 18 0.0228u767016 6 7 29 22 0.1788u767017 6 7 29 23 0.4618u767018 6 7 29 19 0.1625u767019 6 7 29 21 0.0047u767020 6 7 29 22 0.4560u767021 6 7 29 25 0.3144u767022 6 7 29 25 0.2956u767023 6 7 29 20 0.0730u767024 6 7 29 22 0.2724u767025 6 7 29 24 0.1648u767026 6 7 29 18 0.0068u767027 6 7 29 20 0.0051u767028 6 7 29 18 0.0403u767029 6 7 29 18 0.0083u767030 6 7 29 22 0.1791u767031 6 7 29 23 0.3528u767032 6 7 29 18 0.1869u767033 6 7 29 16 0.2114u767034 6 7 29 17 0.0045u767035 6 7 29 23 0.0707u767036 6 7 29 21 0.0648u767037 6 7 29 20 0.0846u767038 6 7 29 22 0.1516u767039 6 7 29 22 0.1671u767040 6 7 29 21 0.1218u767041 6 7 29 18 0.0056u767042 6 7 29 21 0.0049u767043 6 7 29 24 0.1543u767044 6 7 29 25 0.3257u767045 6 7 29 19 0.0514u767046 6 7 29 24 0.1840u767047 6 7 29 19 0.0046u767048 6 7 29 15 0.0046u767049 6 7 29 24 0.7788u767510 6 7 31 26 0.0466u767511 6 7 31 25 0.1263u767512 6 7 31 25 0.0984u767513 6 7 31 22 0.0083u767514 6 7 31 25 0.0120u767515 6 7 31 23 0.0156u767516 6 7 31 25 0.1448u767517 6 7 31 23 0.0240u767518 6 7 31 25 0.1053u767519 6 7 31 20 0.0061

Table 111: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 201: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu767520 6 7 31 27 0.0270u767521 6 7 31 31 0.0879u767522 6 7 31 23 0.1468u767523 6 7 31 28 0.2659u767524 6 7 31 22 0.0709u767525 6 7 31 23 0.0193u767526 6 7 31 19 0.0085u767527 6 7 31 27 0.2569u767528 6 7 31 24 0.2369u767529 6 7 31 22 0.0132u767530 6 7 31 24 0.4331u767531 6 7 31 22 0.0088u767532 6 7 31 25 0.2029u767533 6 7 31 23 0.0583u767534 6 7 31 26 0.2386u767535 6 7 31 24 0.1443u767536 6 7 31 23 0.2500u767537 6 7 31 26 0.0050u767538 6 7 31 26 0.4177u767539 6 7 31 20 0.3399u767540 6 7 31 24 0.1231u767541 6 7 31 24 0.1102u767542 6 7 31 22 0.2909u767543 6 7 31 19 0.0050u767544 6 7 31 29 0.2509u767545 6 7 31 25 0.0453u767546 6 7 31 23 0.0687u767547 6 7 31 25 0.1934u767548 6 7 31 21 0.0195u767549 6 7 31 27 0.2296u775510 7 7 26 13 0.0028u775511 7 7 26 19 0.1786u775512 7 7 26 19 0.0050u775513 7 7 26 20 0.0047u775514 7 7 26 14 0.0055u775515 7 7 26 16 0.0056u775516 7 7 26 12 0.0255u775517 7 7 26 12 0.0042u775518 7 7 26 12 0.0043u775519 7 7 26 11 0.0055u775520 7 7 26 17 0.0043u775521 7 7 26 11 0.0045u775522 7 7 26 17 0.0751u775523 7 7 26 18 0.0870u775524 7 7 26 17 0.3567u775525 7 7 26 11 0.0156u775526 7 7 26 13 0.0042u775527 7 7 26 14 0.0042u775528 7 7 26 18 0.1627u775529 7 7 26 12 0.0042u775530 7 7 26 12 0.0061u775531 7 7 26 19 0.2435u775532 7 7 26 11 0.0043u775533 7 7 26 18 0.0043u775534 7 7 26 19 0.0053u775535 7 7 26 15 0.0049u775536 7 7 26 11 0.0042u775537 7 7 26 11 0.0044u775538 7 7 26 11 0.0043u775539 7 7 26 15 0.0051u775540 7 7 26 16 0.0362u775541 7 7 26 14 0.0440u775542 7 7 26 11 0.0042u775543 7 7 26 11 0.0042u775544 7 7 26 16 0.0069u775545 7 7 26 19 0.0675u775546 7 7 26 15 0.0042u775547 7 7 26 15 0.0042u775548 7 7 26 17 0.0045u775549 7 7 26 12 0.0100

Table 112: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 202: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu776010 7 7 29 15 0.1928u776011 7 7 29 19 0.0231u776012 7 7 29 22 0.3889u776013 7 7 29 24 0.5036u776014 7 7 29 14 0.0047u776015 7 7 29 19 0.2376u776016 7 7 29 19 0.0719u776017 7 7 29 19 0.0047u776018 7 7 29 19 0.0129u776019 7 7 29 19 0.0047u776020 7 7 29 17 0.0172u776021 7 7 29 18 0.0217u776022 7 7 29 16 0.0088u776023 7 7 29 20 0.2136u776024 7 7 29 17 0.0055u776025 7 7 29 16 0.0048u776026 7 7 29 15 0.0055u776027 7 7 29 17 0.1347u776028 7 7 29 22 0.0595u776029 7 7 29 18 0.1301u776030 7 7 29 20 0.0047u776031 7 7 29 16 0.0048u776032 7 7 29 21 0.1441u776033 7 7 29 20 0.1855u776034 7 7 29 23 0.6815u776035 7 7 29 18 0.0060u776036 7 7 29 20 0.0051u776037 7 7 29 20 0.3620u776038 7 7 29 15 0.0072u776039 7 7 29 15 0.0049u776040 7 7 29 14 0.0411u776041 7 7 29 19 0.0651u776042 7 7 29 19 0.0463u776043 7 7 29 17 0.0048u776044 7 7 29 16 0.0225u776045 7 7 29 17 0.1050u776046 7 7 29 20 0.0048u776047 7 7 29 19 0.0077u776048 7 7 29 18 0.0047u776049 7 7 29 15 0.0052u776510 7 7 31 22 0.0450u776511 7 7 31 15 0.0051u776512 7 7 31 21 0.0051u776513 7 7 31 19 0.0054u776514 7 7 31 14 0.0118u776515 7 7 31 19 0.1419u776516 7 7 31 15 0.0051u776517 7 7 31 29 0.6766u776518 7 7 31 18 0.0052u776519 7 7 31 19 0.0051u776520 7 7 31 19 0.5937u776521 7 7 31 15 0.0051u776522 7 7 31 19 0.1071u776523 7 7 31 22 0.1470u776524 7 7 31 20 0.5664u776525 7 7 31 23 0.2129u776526 7 7 31 19 0.3420u776527 7 7 31 26 1.0708u776528 7 7 31 18 0.0050u776529 7 7 31 14 0.0053u776530 7 7 31 21 0.0187u776531 7 7 31 18 0.0051u776532 7 7 31 17 0.0070u776533 7 7 31 19 0.0056u776534 7 7 31 23 0.4011u776535 7 7 31 15 0.0051u776536 7 7 31 23 0.2235u776537 7 7 31 23 0.0051u776538 7 7 31 22 0.1371u776539 7 7 31 17 0.0051

Table 113: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 203: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu776540 7 7 31 16 0.0052u776541 7 7 31 19 0.0570u776542 7 7 31 22 0.6085u776543 7 7 31 19 0.1946u776544 7 7 31 26 0.1570u776545 7 7 31 18 0.0144u776546 7 7 31 21 0.1377u776547 7 7 31 17 0.0079u776548 7 7 31 17 0.1571u776549 7 7 31 20 0.0052u777010 7 7 34 22 0.0087u777011 7 7 34 22 0.0054u777012 7 7 34 24 0.0057u777013 7 7 34 24 0.1572u777014 7 7 34 21 0.0055u777015 7 7 34 23 0.0077u777016 7 7 34 27 0.2716u777017 7 7 34 23 0.0208u777018 7 7 34 25 0.2997u777019 7 7 34 19 0.0389u777020 7 7 34 18 0.3319u777021 7 7 34 28 0.3789u777022 7 7 34 16 0.0060u777023 7 7 34 23 0.0166u777024 7 7 34 26 0.0059u777025 7 7 34 28 0.2517u777026 7 7 34 19 0.0069u777027 7 7 34 21 0.0107u777028 7 7 34 22 0.1636u777029 7 7 34 20 0.3509u777030 7 7 34 28 0.1044u777031 7 7 34 17 0.0067u777032 7 7 34 21 0.0213u777033 7 7 34 23 0.0933u777034 7 7 34 24 1.0067u777035 7 7 34 21 0.6617u777036 7 7 34 19 0.3346u777037 7 7 34 25 0.1974u777038 7 7 34 22 0.0074u777039 7 7 34 22 0.0057u777040 7 7 34 24 0.1111u777041 7 7 34 24 0.8639u777042 7 7 34 22 0.0057u777043 7 7 34 22 0.0059u777044 7 7 34 25 0.0895u777045 7 7 34 24 0.0084u777046 7 7 34 21 0.0327u777047 7 7 34 23 0.0101u777048 7 7 34 24 0.0391u777049 7 7 34 30 0.5206u777510 7 7 36 23 0.3808u777511 7 7 36 26 0.3294u777512 7 7 36 29 0.1689u777513 7 7 36 28 1.0623u777514 7 7 36 23 0.7292u777515 7 7 36 29 0.3114u777516 7 7 36 30 0.3088u777517 7 7 36 29 0.5720u777518 7 7 36 26 0.5575u777519 7 7 36 28 0.5607u777520 7 7 36 31 0.8745u777521 7 7 36 26 0.0055u777522 7 7 36 27 0.6137u777523 7 7 36 22 0.2886u777524 7 7 36 26 0.6422u777525 7 7 36 24 0.0134u777526 7 7 36 26 0.0063u777527 7 7 36 28 0.0195u777528 7 7 36 24 0.3018u777529 7 7 36 23 0.0406

Table 114: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 204: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timeu777530 7 7 36 26 0.2846u777531 7 7 36 22 0.0457u777532 7 7 36 20 0.0161u777533 7 7 36 19 0.1133u777534 7 7 36 34 0.4957u777535 7 7 36 28 0.4261u777536 7 7 36 25 0.0647u777537 7 7 36 33 1.0205u777538 7 7 36 28 0.8096u777539 7 7 36 28 0.5307u777540 7 7 36 31 0.8634u777541 7 7 36 22 0.2657u777542 7 7 36 23 0.0570u777543 7 7 36 29 0.3527u777544 7 7 36 27 0.1522u777545 7 7 36 27 0.2372u777546 7 7 36 27 0.7035u777547 7 7 36 26 0.0093u777548 7 7 36 29 1.0796u777549 7 7 36 21 0.0345

Table 115: Computational results on the set group 5

Page 205: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

7 group 6

Page 206: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-6-15-00001.txt 6 3 15 7 0.0032data3-6-15-00002.txt 6 3 15 7 0.0019data3-6-15-00003.txt 6 3 15 3 0.0027data3-6-15-00004.txt 6 3 15 5 0.0028data3-6-15-00005.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0035data3-6-15-00006.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0035data3-6-15-00007.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0027data3-6-15-00008.txt 6 3 15 8 0.0025data3-6-15-00009.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0029data3-6-15-00010.txt 6 3 15 7 0.0026data3-6-15-00011.txt 6 3 15 7 0.0026data3-6-15-00012.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0026data3-6-15-00013.txt 6 3 15 7 0.0025data3-6-15-00014.txt 6 3 15 5 0.0025data3-6-15-00015.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0028data3-6-15-00016.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0040data3-6-15-00017.txt 6 3 15 3 0.0031data3-6-15-00018.txt 6 3 15 5 0.0028data3-6-15-00019.txt 6 3 15 3 0.0026data3-6-15-00020.txt 6 3 15 3 0.0025data3-6-15-00021.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0025data3-6-15-00022.txt 6 3 15 5 0.0027data3-6-15-00023.txt 6 3 15 7 0.0026data3-6-15-00024.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0026data3-6-15-00025.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0025data3-6-15-00026.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0029data3-6-15-00027.txt 6 3 15 7 0.0040data3-6-15-00028.txt 6 3 15 7 0.0028data3-6-15-00029.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0028data3-6-15-00030.txt 6 3 15 3 0.0026data3-6-15-00031.txt 6 3 15 5 0.0025data3-6-15-00032.txt 6 3 15 5 0.0024data3-6-15-00033.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0024data3-6-15-00034.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0024data3-6-15-00035.txt 6 3 15 3 0.0025data3-6-15-00036.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0027data3-6-15-00037.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0032data3-6-15-00038.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0037data3-6-15-00039.txt 6 3 15 8 0.0027data3-6-15-00040.txt 6 3 15 11 0.0025data3-6-15-00041.txt 6 3 15 8 0.0024data3-6-15-00042.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0024data3-6-15-00043.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0025data3-6-15-00044.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0025data3-6-15-00045.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0024data3-6-15-00046.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0024data3-6-15-00047.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0026data3-6-15-00048.txt 6 3 15 8 0.0028data3-6-15-00049.txt 6 3 15 7 0.0041data3-6-15-00050.txt 6 3 15 7 0.0028data3-6-15-00051.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0026data3-6-15-00052.txt 6 3 15 9 0.0026data3-6-15-00053.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0026data3-6-15-00054.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0025data3-6-15-00055.txt 6 3 15 8 0.0024data3-6-15-00056.txt 6 3 15 5 0.0027data3-6-15-00057.txt 6 3 15 3 0.0025data3-6-15-00058.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0025data3-6-15-00059.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0028data3-6-15-00060.txt 6 3 15 5 0.0034data3-6-15-00061.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0028data3-6-15-00062.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0024data3-6-15-00063.txt 6 3 15 8 0.0028data3-6-15-00064.txt 6 3 15 7 0.0026data3-6-15-00065.txt 6 3 15 2 0.0025data3-6-15-00066.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0024data3-6-15-00067.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0024data3-6-15-00068.txt 6 3 15 8 0.0024data3-6-15-00069.txt 6 3 15 3 0.0025data3-6-15-00070.txt 6 3 15 7 0.0028

Table 1: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 207: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-6-15-00071.txt 6 3 15 8 0.0034data3-6-15-00072.txt 6 3 15 9 0.0030data3-6-15-00073.txt 6 3 15 5 0.0026data3-6-15-00074.txt 6 3 15 5 0.0025data3-6-15-00075.txt 6 3 15 5 0.0024data3-6-15-00076.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0026data3-6-15-00077.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0025data3-6-15-00078.txt 6 3 15 1 0.0025data3-6-15-00079.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0024data3-6-15-00080.txt 6 3 15 5 0.0024data3-6-15-00081.txt 6 3 15 7 0.0026data3-6-15-00082.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0029data3-6-15-00083.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0033data3-6-15-00084.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0030data3-6-15-00085.txt 6 3 15 7 0.0026data3-6-15-00086.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0025data3-6-15-00087.txt 6 3 15 9 0.0027data3-6-15-00088.txt 6 3 15 5 0.0025data3-6-15-00089.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0024data3-6-15-00090.txt 6 3 15 7 0.0027data3-6-15-00091.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0025data3-6-15-00092.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0026data3-6-15-00093.txt 6 3 15 7 0.0028data3-6-15-00094.txt 6 3 15 5 0.0027data3-6-15-00095.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0026data3-6-15-00096.txt 6 3 15 7 0.0028data3-6-15-00097.txt 6 3 15 4 0.0026data3-6-15-00098.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0026data3-6-15-00099.txt 6 3 15 6 0.0025data3-6-15-00100.txt 6 3 15 7 0.0024data3-6-16-00101.txt 6 3 16 9 0.0026data3-6-16-00102.txt 6 3 16 7 0.0026data3-6-16-00103.txt 6 3 16 8 0.0028data3-6-16-00104.txt 6 3 16 8 0.0031data3-6-16-00105.txt 6 3 16 7 0.0029data3-6-16-00106.txt 6 3 16 7 0.0030data3-6-16-00107.txt 6 3 16 7 0.0028data3-6-16-00108.txt 6 3 16 9 0.0027data3-6-16-00109.txt 6 3 16 8 0.0028data3-6-16-00110.txt 6 3 16 5 0.0027data3-6-16-00111.txt 6 3 16 9 0.0026data3-6-16-00112.txt 6 3 16 10 0.0026data3-6-16-00113.txt 6 3 16 9 0.0026data3-6-16-00114.txt 6 3 16 9 0.0028data3-6-16-00115.txt 6 3 16 6 0.0031data3-6-16-00116.txt 6 3 16 8 0.0032data3-6-16-00117.txt 6 3 16 4 0.0031data3-6-16-00118.txt 6 3 16 6 0.0028data3-6-16-00119.txt 6 3 16 7 0.0026data3-6-16-00120.txt 6 3 16 8 0.0025data3-6-16-00121.txt 6 3 16 5 0.0027data3-6-16-00122.txt 6 3 16 7 0.0027data3-6-16-00123.txt 6 3 16 6 0.0026data3-6-16-00124.txt 6 3 16 9 0.0026data3-6-16-00125.txt 6 3 16 6 0.0027data3-6-16-00126.txt 6 3 16 5 0.0031data3-6-16-00127.txt 6 3 16 7 0.0030data3-6-16-00128.txt 6 3 16 5 0.0030data3-6-16-00129.txt 6 3 16 6 0.0028data3-6-16-00130.txt 6 3 16 9 0.0027data3-6-16-00131.txt 6 3 16 3 0.0027data3-6-16-00132.txt 6 3 16 2 0.0026data3-6-16-00133.txt 6 3 16 8 0.0026data3-6-16-00134.txt 6 3 16 8 0.0028data3-6-16-00135.txt 6 3 16 4 0.0027data3-6-16-00136.txt 6 3 16 5 0.0030data3-6-16-00137.txt 6 3 16 8 0.0028data3-6-16-00138.txt 6 3 16 4 0.0029data3-6-16-00139.txt 6 3 16 10 0.0027data3-6-16-00140.txt 6 3 16 5 0.0031

Table 2: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 208: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-6-16-00141.txt 6 3 16 4 0.0027data3-6-16-00142.txt 6 3 16 8 0.0026data3-6-16-00143.txt 6 3 16 7 0.0026data3-6-16-00144.txt 6 3 16 6 0.0026data3-6-16-00145.txt 6 3 16 7 0.0026data3-6-16-00146.txt 6 3 16 9 0.0029data3-6-16-00147.txt 6 3 16 9 0.0031data3-6-16-00148.txt 6 3 16 6 0.0030data3-6-16-00149.txt 6 3 16 5 0.0030data3-6-16-00150.txt 6 3 16 6 0.0028data3-6-16-00151.txt 6 3 16 6 0.0026data3-6-16-00152.txt 6 3 16 10 0.0029data3-6-16-00153.txt 6 3 16 8 0.0025data3-6-16-00154.txt 6 3 16 7 0.0027data3-6-16-00155.txt 6 3 16 3 0.0026data3-6-16-00156.txt 6 3 16 10 0.0024data3-6-16-00157.txt 6 3 16 9 0.0026data3-6-16-00158.txt 6 3 16 5 0.0032data3-6-16-00159.txt 6 3 16 9 0.0028data3-6-16-00160.txt 6 3 16 4 0.0029data3-6-16-00161.txt 6 3 16 10 0.0028data3-6-16-00162.txt 6 3 16 7 0.0026data3-6-16-00163.txt 6 3 16 7 0.0024data3-6-16-00164.txt 6 3 16 6 0.0027data3-6-16-00165.txt 6 3 16 4 0.0026data3-6-16-00166.txt 6 3 16 7 0.0027data3-6-16-00167.txt 6 3 16 9 0.0025data3-6-16-00168.txt 6 3 16 8 0.0027data3-6-16-00169.txt 6 3 16 4 0.0030data3-6-16-00170.txt 6 3 16 6 0.0030data3-6-16-00171.txt 6 3 16 5 0.0031data3-6-16-00172.txt 6 3 16 9 0.0028data3-6-16-00173.txt 6 3 16 9 0.0027data3-6-16-00174.txt 6 3 16 11 0.0026data3-6-16-00175.txt 6 3 16 8 0.0026data3-6-16-00176.txt 6 3 16 5 0.0026data3-6-16-00177.txt 6 3 16 9 0.0028data3-6-16-00178.txt 6 3 16 7 0.0027data3-6-16-00179.txt 6 3 16 5 0.0028data3-6-16-00180.txt 6 3 16 11 0.0028data3-6-16-00181.txt 6 3 16 12 0.0027data3-6-16-00182.txt 6 3 16 9 0.0029data3-6-16-00183.txt 6 3 16 4 0.0029data3-6-16-00184.txt 6 3 16 8 0.0027data3-6-16-00185.txt 6 3 16 8 0.0025data3-6-16-00186.txt 6 3 16 3 0.0026data3-6-16-00187.txt 6 3 16 7 0.0026data3-6-16-00188.txt 6 3 16 10 0.0026data3-6-16-00189.txt 6 3 16 8 0.0029data3-6-16-00190.txt 6 3 16 9 0.0029data3-6-16-00191.txt 6 3 16 8 0.0030data3-6-16-00192.txt 6 3 16 6 0.0029data3-6-16-00193.txt 6 3 16 7 0.0028data3-6-16-00194.txt 6 3 16 3 0.0027data3-6-16-00195.txt 6 3 16 9 0.0028data3-6-16-00196.txt 6 3 16 8 0.0025data3-6-16-00197.txt 6 3 16 6 0.0026data3-6-16-00198.txt 6 3 16 8 0.0025data3-6-16-00199.txt 6 3 16 10 0.0026data3-6-16-00200.txt 6 3 16 11 0.0025data3-6-17-00201.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0033data3-6-17-00202.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0033data3-6-17-00203.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0031data3-6-17-00204.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0030data3-6-17-00205.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0029data3-6-17-00206.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0027data3-6-17-00207.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0030data3-6-17-00208.txt 6 3 17 10 0.0027data3-6-17-00209.txt 6 3 17 6 0.0028data3-6-17-00210.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0027

Table 3: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 209: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-6-17-00211.txt 6 3 17 5 0.0031data3-6-17-00212.txt 6 3 17 6 0.0031data3-6-17-00213.txt 6 3 17 9 0.0030data3-6-17-00214.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0031data3-6-17-00215.txt 6 3 17 4 0.0028data3-6-17-00216.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0028data3-6-17-00217.txt 6 3 17 3 0.0027data3-6-17-00218.txt 6 3 17 9 0.0029data3-6-17-00219.txt 6 3 17 4 0.0028data3-6-17-00220.txt 6 3 17 4 0.0027data3-6-17-00221.txt 6 3 17 6 0.0029data3-6-17-00222.txt 6 3 17 5 0.0030data3-6-17-00223.txt 6 3 17 10 0.0031data3-6-17-00224.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0033data3-6-17-00225.txt 6 3 17 10 0.0029data3-6-17-00226.txt 6 3 17 12 0.0027data3-6-17-00227.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0027data3-6-17-00228.txt 6 3 17 5 0.0027data3-6-17-00229.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0028data3-6-17-00230.txt 6 3 17 4 0.0027data3-6-17-00231.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0030data3-6-17-00232.txt 6 3 17 5 0.0032data3-6-17-00233.txt 6 3 17 6 0.0029data3-6-17-00234.txt 6 3 17 6 0.0032data3-6-17-00235.txt 6 3 17 14 0.0030data3-6-17-00236.txt 6 3 17 10 0.0027data3-6-17-00237.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0030data3-6-17-00238.txt 6 3 17 4 0.0027data3-6-17-00239.txt 6 3 17 5 0.0025data3-6-17-00240.txt 6 3 17 5 0.0026data3-6-17-00241.txt 6 3 17 4 0.0030data3-6-17-00242.txt 6 3 17 6 0.0033data3-6-17-00243.txt 6 3 17 5 0.0031data3-6-17-00244.txt 6 3 17 9 0.0031data3-6-17-00245.txt 6 3 17 4 0.0029data3-6-17-00246.txt 6 3 17 3 0.0028data3-6-17-00247.txt 6 3 17 4 0.0030data3-6-17-00248.txt 6 3 17 6 0.0028data3-6-17-00249.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0027data3-6-17-00250.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0027data3-6-17-00251.txt 6 3 17 11 0.0026data3-6-17-00252.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0032data3-6-17-00253.txt 6 3 17 6 0.0031data3-6-17-00254.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0032data3-6-17-00255.txt 6 3 17 5 0.0030data3-6-17-00256.txt 6 3 17 6 0.0028data3-6-17-00257.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0027data3-6-17-00258.txt 6 3 17 10 0.0030data3-6-17-00259.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0027data3-6-17-00260.txt 6 3 17 6 0.0026data3-6-17-00261.txt 6 3 17 6 0.0027data3-6-17-00262.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0030data3-6-17-00263.txt 6 3 17 9 0.0032data3-6-17-00264.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0034data3-6-17-00265.txt 6 3 17 11 0.0032data3-6-17-00266.txt 6 3 17 9 0.0028data3-6-17-00267.txt 6 3 17 11 0.0028data3-6-17-00268.txt 6 3 17 9 0.0027data3-6-17-00269.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0029data3-6-17-00270.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0028data3-6-17-00271.txt 6 3 17 9 0.0026data3-6-17-00272.txt 6 3 17 5 0.0030data3-6-17-00273.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0032data3-6-17-00274.txt 6 3 17 10 0.0030data3-6-17-00275.txt 6 3 17 12 0.0033data3-6-17-00276.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0029data3-6-17-00277.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0027data3-6-17-00278.txt 6 3 17 7 0.0027data3-6-17-00279.txt 6 3 17 5 0.0026data3-6-17-00280.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0029

Table 4: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 210: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-6-17-00281.txt 6 3 17 3 0.0029data3-6-17-00282.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0028data3-6-17-00283.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0031data3-6-17-00284.txt 6 3 17 9 0.0030data3-6-17-00285.txt 6 3 17 10 0.0030data3-6-17-00286.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0028data3-6-17-00287.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0029data3-6-17-00288.txt 6 3 17 6 0.0026data3-6-17-00289.txt 6 3 17 11 0.0027data3-6-17-00290.txt 6 3 17 6 0.0026data3-6-17-00291.txt 6 3 17 6 0.0028data3-6-17-00292.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0028data3-6-17-00293.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0032data3-6-17-00294.txt 6 3 17 5 0.0032data3-6-17-00295.txt 6 3 17 9 0.0030data3-6-17-00296.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0029data3-6-17-00297.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0028data3-6-17-00298.txt 6 3 17 5 0.0030data3-6-17-00299.txt 6 3 17 8 0.0028data3-6-17-00300.txt 6 3 17 10 0.0027data3-7-18-02501.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0023data3-7-18-02502.txt 7 3 18 6 0.0031data3-7-18-02503.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0034data3-7-18-02504.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0037data3-7-18-02505.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0034data3-7-18-02506.txt 7 3 18 6 0.0035data3-7-18-02507.txt 7 3 18 10 0.0031data3-7-18-02508.txt 7 3 18 6 0.0031data3-7-18-02509.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0032data3-7-18-02510.txt 7 3 18 6 0.0030data3-7-18-02511.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0031data3-7-18-02512.txt 7 3 18 8 0.0035data3-7-18-02513.txt 7 3 18 6 0.0034data3-7-18-02514.txt 7 3 18 4 0.0034data3-7-18-02515.txt 7 3 18 8 0.0032data3-7-18-02516.txt 7 3 18 6 0.0031data3-7-18-02517.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0030data3-7-18-02518.txt 7 3 18 9 0.0029data3-7-18-02519.txt 7 3 18 8 0.0030data3-7-18-02520.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0031data3-7-18-02521.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0032data3-7-18-02522.txt 7 3 18 4 0.0036data3-7-18-02523.txt 7 3 18 5 0.0034data3-7-18-02524.txt 7 3 18 10 0.0038data3-7-18-02525.txt 7 3 18 9 0.0033data3-7-18-02526.txt 7 3 18 6 0.0037data3-7-18-02527.txt 7 3 18 5 0.0033data3-7-18-02528.txt 7 3 18 6 0.0030data3-7-18-02529.txt 7 3 18 4 0.0030data3-7-18-02530.txt 7 3 18 6 0.0042data3-7-18-02531.txt 7 3 18 9 0.0043data3-7-18-02532.txt 7 3 18 9 0.0030data3-7-18-02533.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0030data3-7-18-02534.txt 7 3 18 8 0.0030data3-7-18-02535.txt 7 3 18 5 0.0032data3-7-18-02536.txt 7 3 18 9 0.0030data3-7-18-02537.txt 7 3 18 6 0.0029data3-7-18-02538.txt 7 3 18 6 0.0028data3-7-18-02539.txt 7 3 18 5 0.0036data3-7-18-02540.txt 7 3 18 4 0.0040data3-7-18-02541.txt 7 3 18 8 0.0031data3-7-18-02542.txt 7 3 18 6 0.0031data3-7-18-02543.txt 7 3 18 8 0.0030data3-7-18-02544.txt 7 3 18 8 0.0031data3-7-18-02545.txt 7 3 18 10 0.0031data3-7-18-02546.txt 7 3 18 8 0.0029data3-7-18-02547.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0029data3-7-18-02548.txt 7 3 18 12 0.0031data3-7-18-02549.txt 7 3 18 4 0.0048data3-7-18-02550.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0032

Table 5: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 211: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-7-18-02551.txt 7 3 18 5 0.0031data3-7-18-02552.txt 7 3 18 9 0.0030data3-7-18-02553.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0031data3-7-18-02554.txt 7 3 18 11 0.0029data3-7-18-02555.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0030data3-7-18-02556.txt 7 3 18 10 0.0029data3-7-18-02557.txt 7 3 18 9 0.0032data3-7-18-02558.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0044data3-7-18-02559.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0033data3-7-18-02560.txt 7 3 18 5 0.0031data3-7-18-02561.txt 7 3 18 9 0.0030data3-7-18-02562.txt 7 3 18 8 0.0030data3-7-18-02563.txt 7 3 18 8 0.0030data3-7-18-02564.txt 7 3 18 6 0.0029data3-7-18-02565.txt 7 3 18 6 0.0029data3-7-18-02566.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0032data3-7-18-02567.txt 7 3 18 5 0.0040data3-7-18-02568.txt 7 3 18 3 0.0035data3-7-18-02569.txt 7 3 18 8 0.0030data3-7-18-02570.txt 7 3 18 5 0.0030data3-7-18-02571.txt 7 3 18 8 0.0030data3-7-18-02572.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0030data3-7-18-02573.txt 7 3 18 11 0.0030data3-7-18-02574.txt 7 3 18 6 0.0029data3-7-18-02575.txt 7 3 18 6 0.0030data3-7-18-02576.txt 7 3 18 5 0.0037data3-7-18-02577.txt 7 3 18 5 0.0041data3-7-18-02578.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0032data3-7-18-02579.txt 7 3 18 5 0.0029data3-7-18-02580.txt 7 3 18 5 0.0029data3-7-18-02581.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0032data3-7-18-02582.txt 7 3 18 8 0.0031data3-7-18-02583.txt 7 3 18 12 0.0031data3-7-18-02584.txt 7 3 18 8 0.0029data3-7-18-02585.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0034data3-7-18-02586.txt 7 3 18 3 0.0039data3-7-18-02587.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0036data3-7-18-02588.txt 7 3 18 6 0.0030data3-7-18-02589.txt 7 3 18 4 0.0029data3-7-18-02590.txt 7 3 18 5 0.0028data3-7-18-02591.txt 7 3 18 6 0.0032data3-7-18-02592.txt 7 3 18 5 0.0031data3-7-18-02593.txt 7 3 18 9 0.0028data3-7-18-02594.txt 7 3 18 5 0.0033data3-7-18-02595.txt 7 3 18 8 0.0034data3-7-18-02596.txt 7 3 18 7 0.0035data3-7-18-02597.txt 7 3 18 5 0.0034data3-7-18-02598.txt 7 3 18 11 0.0031data3-7-18-02599.txt 7 3 18 8 0.0030data3-7-18-02600.txt 7 3 18 5 0.0030data3-7-19-02601.txt 7 3 19 10 0.0033data3-7-19-02602.txt 7 3 19 5 0.0032data3-7-19-02603.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0031data3-7-19-02604.txt 7 3 19 10 0.0036data3-7-19-02605.txt 7 3 19 5 0.0034data3-7-19-02606.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0040data3-7-19-02607.txt 7 3 19 7 0.0033data3-7-19-02608.txt 7 3 19 10 0.0031data3-7-19-02609.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0031data3-7-19-02610.txt 7 3 19 8 0.0031data3-7-19-02611.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0033data3-7-19-02612.txt 7 3 19 12 0.0033data3-7-19-02613.txt 7 3 19 7 0.0037data3-7-19-02614.txt 7 3 19 6 0.0036data3-7-19-02615.txt 7 3 19 7 0.0037data3-7-19-02616.txt 7 3 19 7 0.0033data3-7-19-02617.txt 7 3 19 11 0.0031data3-7-19-02618.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0031data3-7-19-02619.txt 7 3 19 8 0.0030data3-7-19-02620.txt 7 3 19 6 0.0033

Table 6: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 212: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-7-19-02621.txt 7 3 19 7 0.0034data3-7-19-02622.txt 7 3 19 8 0.0037data3-7-19-02623.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0034data3-7-19-02624.txt 7 3 19 4 0.0034data3-7-19-02625.txt 7 3 19 7 0.0034data3-7-19-02626.txt 7 3 19 12 0.0031data3-7-19-02627.txt 7 3 19 8 0.0030data3-7-19-02628.txt 7 3 19 5 0.0031data3-7-19-02629.txt 7 3 19 6 0.0031data3-7-19-02630.txt 7 3 19 10 0.0035data3-7-19-02631.txt 7 3 19 5 0.0037data3-7-19-02632.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0036data3-7-19-02633.txt 7 3 19 7 0.0033data3-7-19-02634.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0034data3-7-19-02635.txt 7 3 19 5 0.0030data3-7-19-02636.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0032data3-7-19-02637.txt 7 3 19 12 0.0031data3-7-19-02638.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0031data3-7-19-02639.txt 7 3 19 13 0.0037data3-7-19-02640.txt 7 3 19 7 0.0037data3-7-19-02641.txt 7 3 19 5 0.0036data3-7-19-02642.txt 7 3 19 3 0.0035data3-7-19-02643.txt 7 3 19 8 0.0032data3-7-19-02644.txt 7 3 19 10 0.0035data3-7-19-02645.txt 7 3 19 8 0.0031data3-7-19-02646.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0030data3-7-19-02647.txt 7 3 19 6 0.0031data3-7-19-02648.txt 7 3 19 7 0.0036data3-7-19-02649.txt 7 3 19 7 0.0037data3-7-19-02650.txt 7 3 19 11 0.0037data3-7-19-02651.txt 7 3 19 6 0.0033data3-7-19-02652.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0032data3-7-19-02653.txt 7 3 19 6 0.0033data3-7-19-02654.txt 7 3 19 6 0.0030data3-7-19-02655.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0031data3-7-19-02656.txt 7 3 19 12 0.0032data3-7-19-02657.txt 7 3 19 7 0.0036data3-7-19-02658.txt 7 3 19 7 0.0038data3-7-19-02659.txt 7 3 19 13 0.0037data3-7-19-02660.txt 7 3 19 8 0.0033data3-7-19-02661.txt 7 3 19 10 0.0031data3-7-19-02662.txt 7 3 19 5 0.0031data3-7-19-02663.txt 7 3 19 8 0.0034data3-7-19-02664.txt 7 3 19 11 0.0032data3-7-19-02665.txt 7 3 19 8 0.0034data3-7-19-02666.txt 7 3 19 6 0.0036data3-7-19-02667.txt 7 3 19 10 0.0034data3-7-19-02668.txt 7 3 19 8 0.0037data3-7-19-02669.txt 7 3 19 8 0.0035data3-7-19-02670.txt 7 3 19 8 0.0033data3-7-19-02671.txt 7 3 19 8 0.0030data3-7-19-02672.txt 7 3 19 6 0.0032data3-7-19-02673.txt 7 3 19 8 0.0030data3-7-19-02674.txt 7 3 19 10 0.0033data3-7-19-02675.txt 7 3 19 6 0.0037data3-7-19-02676.txt 7 3 19 7 0.0036data3-7-19-02677.txt 7 3 19 5 0.0036data3-7-19-02678.txt 7 3 19 6 0.0034data3-7-19-02679.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0032data3-7-19-02680.txt 7 3 19 12 0.0030data3-7-19-02681.txt 7 3 19 10 0.0031data3-7-19-02682.txt 7 3 19 7 0.0033data3-7-19-02683.txt 7 3 19 5 0.0036data3-7-19-02684.txt 7 3 19 11 0.0046data3-7-19-02685.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0034data3-7-19-02686.txt 7 3 19 8 0.0033data3-7-19-02687.txt 7 3 19 7 0.0035data3-7-19-02688.txt 7 3 19 5 0.0033data3-7-19-02689.txt 7 3 19 7 0.0032data3-7-19-02690.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0032

Table 7: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 213: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-7-19-02691.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0032data3-7-19-02692.txt 7 3 19 7 0.0037data3-7-19-02693.txt 7 3 19 6 0.0037data3-7-19-02694.txt 7 3 19 4 0.0035data3-7-19-02695.txt 7 3 19 10 0.0031data3-7-19-02696.txt 7 3 19 8 0.0034data3-7-19-02697.txt 7 3 19 7 0.0032data3-7-19-02698.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0032data3-7-19-02699.txt 7 3 19 9 0.0031data3-7-19-02700.txt 7 3 19 11 0.0032data3-7-20-02701.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0041data3-7-20-02702.txt 7 3 20 6 0.0040data3-7-20-02703.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0039data3-7-20-02704.txt 7 3 20 10 0.0036data3-7-20-02705.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0035data3-7-20-02706.txt 7 3 20 10 0.0034data3-7-20-02707.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0034data3-7-20-02708.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0033data3-7-20-02709.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0038data3-7-20-02710.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0041data3-7-20-02711.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0041data3-7-20-02712.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0036data3-7-20-02713.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0032data3-7-20-02714.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0034data3-7-20-02715.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0033data3-7-20-02716.txt 7 3 20 12 0.0033data3-7-20-02717.txt 7 3 20 4 0.0036data3-7-20-02718.txt 7 3 20 11 0.0038data3-7-20-02719.txt 7 3 20 10 0.0040data3-7-20-02720.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0039data3-7-20-02721.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0035data3-7-20-02722.txt 7 3 20 12 0.0032data3-7-20-02723.txt 7 3 20 6 0.0035data3-7-20-02724.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0033data3-7-20-02725.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0035data3-7-20-02726.txt 7 3 20 6 0.0039data3-7-20-02727.txt 7 3 20 13 0.0039data3-7-20-02728.txt 7 3 20 11 0.0036data3-7-20-02729.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0036data3-7-20-02730.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0034data3-7-20-02731.txt 7 3 20 11 0.0033data3-7-20-02732.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0036data3-7-20-02733.txt 7 3 20 6 0.0035data3-7-20-02734.txt 7 3 20 13 0.0039data3-7-20-02735.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0037data3-7-20-02736.txt 7 3 20 11 0.0038data3-7-20-02737.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0035data3-7-20-02738.txt 7 3 20 6 0.0034data3-7-20-02739.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0033data3-7-20-02740.txt 7 3 20 2 0.0032data3-7-20-02741.txt 7 3 20 10 0.0036data3-7-20-02742.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0037data3-7-20-02743.txt 7 3 20 10 0.0040data3-7-20-02744.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0040data3-7-20-02745.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0037data3-7-20-02746.txt 7 3 20 11 0.0035data3-7-20-02747.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0034data3-7-20-02748.txt 7 3 20 6 0.0033data3-7-20-02749.txt 7 3 20 12 0.0033data3-7-20-02750.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0036data3-7-20-02751.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0040data3-7-20-02752.txt 7 3 20 4 0.0039data3-7-20-02753.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0037data3-7-20-02754.txt 7 3 20 5 0.0038data3-7-20-02755.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0034data3-7-20-02756.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0033data3-7-20-02757.txt 7 3 20 12 0.0031data3-7-20-02758.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0035data3-7-20-02759.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0039data3-7-20-02760.txt 7 3 20 6 0.0039

Table 8: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 214: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-7-20-02761.txt 7 3 20 10 0.0037data3-7-20-02762.txt 7 3 20 4 0.0035data3-7-20-02763.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0036data3-7-20-02764.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0033data3-7-20-02765.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0033data3-7-20-02766.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0032data3-7-20-02767.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0041data3-7-20-02768.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0040data3-7-20-02769.txt 7 3 20 10 0.0039data3-7-20-02770.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0036data3-7-20-02771.txt 7 3 20 11 0.0034data3-7-20-02772.txt 7 3 20 13 0.0034data3-7-20-02773.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0033data3-7-20-02774.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0032data3-7-20-02775.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0035data3-7-20-02776.txt 7 3 20 12 0.0041data3-7-20-02777.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0040data3-7-20-02778.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0037data3-7-20-02779.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0035data3-7-20-02780.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0035data3-7-20-02781.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0033data3-7-20-02782.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0033data3-7-20-02783.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0034data3-7-20-02784.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0039data3-7-20-02785.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0040data3-7-20-02786.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0040data3-7-20-02787.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0034data3-7-20-02788.txt 7 3 20 11 0.0034data3-7-20-02789.txt 7 3 20 5 0.0036data3-7-20-02790.txt 7 3 20 11 0.0034data3-7-20-02791.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0033data3-7-20-02792.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0038data3-7-20-02793.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0039data3-7-20-02794.txt 7 3 20 10 0.0042data3-7-20-02795.txt 7 3 20 10 0.0038data3-7-20-02796.txt 7 3 20 9 0.0036data3-7-20-02797.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0033data3-7-20-02798.txt 7 3 20 7 0.0034data3-7-20-02799.txt 7 3 20 10 0.0034data3-7-20-02800.txt 7 3 20 8 0.0039data3-8-21-05001.txt 8 3 21 11 0.0039data3-8-21-05002.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0041data3-8-21-05003.txt 8 3 21 10 0.0035data3-8-21-05004.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0035data3-8-21-05005.txt 8 3 21 9 0.0036data3-8-21-05006.txt 8 3 21 9 0.0034data3-8-21-05007.txt 8 3 21 8 0.0036data3-8-21-05008.txt 8 3 21 8 0.0041data3-8-21-05009.txt 8 3 21 5 0.0040data3-8-21-05010.txt 8 3 21 10 0.0040data3-8-21-05011.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0037data3-8-21-05012.txt 8 3 21 10 0.0035data3-8-21-05013.txt 8 3 21 11 0.0036data3-8-21-05014.txt 8 3 21 5 0.0036data3-8-21-05015.txt 8 3 21 9 0.0037data3-8-21-05016.txt 8 3 21 12 0.0041data3-8-21-05017.txt 8 3 21 6 0.0040data3-8-21-05018.txt 8 3 21 9 0.0039data3-8-21-05019.txt 8 3 21 11 0.0036data3-8-21-05020.txt 8 3 21 9 0.0035data3-8-21-05021.txt 8 3 21 9 0.0035data3-8-21-05022.txt 8 3 21 10 0.0035data3-8-21-05023.txt 8 3 21 9 0.0038data3-8-21-05024.txt 8 3 21 6 0.0041data3-8-21-05025.txt 8 3 21 6 0.0040data3-8-21-05026.txt 8 3 21 6 0.0039data3-8-21-05027.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0038data3-8-21-05028.txt 8 3 21 4 0.0036data3-8-21-05029.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0036data3-8-21-05030.txt 8 3 21 8 0.0035

Table 9: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 215: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-8-21-05031.txt 8 3 21 8 0.0040data3-8-21-05032.txt 8 3 21 5 0.0042data3-8-21-05033.txt 8 3 21 4 0.0041data3-8-21-05034.txt 8 3 21 10 0.0038data3-8-21-05035.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0038data3-8-21-05036.txt 8 3 21 11 0.0035data3-8-21-05037.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0036data3-8-21-05038.txt 8 3 21 3 0.0035data3-8-21-05039.txt 8 3 21 12 0.0041data3-8-21-05040.txt 8 3 21 9 0.0041data3-8-21-05041.txt 8 3 21 13 0.0042data3-8-21-05042.txt 8 3 21 8 0.0036data3-8-21-05043.txt 8 3 21 8 0.0038data3-8-21-05044.txt 8 3 21 6 0.0035data3-8-21-05045.txt 8 3 21 10 0.0035data3-8-21-05046.txt 8 3 21 9 0.0036data3-8-21-05047.txt 8 3 21 8 0.0043data3-8-21-05048.txt 8 3 21 10 0.0042data3-8-21-05049.txt 8 3 21 10 0.0040data3-8-21-05050.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0038data3-8-21-05051.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0039data3-8-21-05052.txt 8 3 21 9 0.0035data3-8-21-05053.txt 8 3 21 6 0.0036data3-8-21-05054.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0039data3-8-21-05055.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0042data3-8-21-05056.txt 8 3 21 9 0.0041data3-8-21-05057.txt 8 3 21 10 0.0039data3-8-21-05058.txt 8 3 21 8 0.0036data3-8-21-05059.txt 8 3 21 6 0.0038data3-8-21-05060.txt 8 3 21 9 0.0036data3-8-21-05061.txt 8 3 21 6 0.0035data3-8-21-05062.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0041data3-8-21-05063.txt 8 3 21 6 0.0042data3-8-21-05064.txt 8 3 21 9 0.0042data3-8-21-05065.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0039data3-8-21-05066.txt 8 3 21 5 0.0038data3-8-21-05067.txt 8 3 21 5 0.0037data3-8-21-05068.txt 8 3 21 10 0.0036data3-8-21-05069.txt 8 3 21 8 0.0035data3-8-21-05070.txt 8 3 21 11 0.0041data3-8-21-05071.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0040data3-8-21-05072.txt 8 3 21 8 0.0041data3-8-21-05073.txt 8 3 21 10 0.0038data3-8-21-05074.txt 8 3 21 5 0.0036data3-8-21-05075.txt 8 3 21 6 0.0037data3-8-21-05076.txt 8 3 21 8 0.0035data3-8-21-05077.txt 8 3 21 10 0.0036data3-8-21-05078.txt 8 3 21 8 0.0042data3-8-21-05079.txt 8 3 21 8 0.0041data3-8-21-05080.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0040data3-8-21-05081.txt 8 3 21 5 0.0038data3-8-21-05082.txt 8 3 21 10 0.0037data3-8-21-05083.txt 8 3 21 9 0.0036data3-8-21-05084.txt 8 3 21 8 0.0035data3-8-21-05085.txt 8 3 21 10 0.0038data3-8-21-05086.txt 8 3 21 9 0.0041data3-8-21-05087.txt 8 3 21 8 0.0040data3-8-21-05088.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0041data3-8-21-05089.txt 8 3 21 9 0.0036data3-8-21-05090.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0035data3-8-21-05091.txt 8 3 21 12 0.0034data3-8-21-05092.txt 8 3 21 9 0.0037data3-8-21-05093.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0037data3-8-21-05094.txt 8 3 21 12 0.0040data3-8-21-05095.txt 8 3 21 6 0.0041data3-8-21-05096.txt 8 3 21 7 0.0041data3-8-21-05097.txt 8 3 21 10 0.0038data3-8-21-05098.txt 8 3 21 11 0.0036data3-8-21-05099.txt 8 3 21 9 0.0036data3-8-21-05100.txt 8 3 21 8 0.0039

Table 10: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 216: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-8-22-05101.txt 8 3 22 7 0.0041data3-8-22-05102.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0042data3-8-22-05103.txt 8 3 22 11 0.0044data3-8-22-05104.txt 8 3 22 6 0.0039data3-8-22-05105.txt 8 3 22 11 0.0037data3-8-22-05106.txt 8 3 22 7 0.0037data3-8-22-05107.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0038data3-8-22-05108.txt 8 3 22 12 0.0038data3-8-22-05109.txt 8 3 22 4 0.0043data3-8-22-05110.txt 8 3 22 6 0.0042data3-8-22-05111.txt 8 3 22 9 0.0042data3-8-22-05112.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0039data3-8-22-05113.txt 8 3 22 9 0.0038data3-8-22-05114.txt 8 3 22 13 0.0036data3-8-22-05115.txt 8 3 22 7 0.0038data3-8-22-05116.txt 8 3 22 13 0.0041data3-8-22-05117.txt 8 3 22 8 0.0042data3-8-22-05118.txt 8 3 22 6 0.0044data3-8-22-05119.txt 8 3 22 9 0.0041data3-8-22-05120.txt 8 3 22 11 0.0037data3-8-22-05121.txt 8 3 22 8 0.0037data3-8-22-05122.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0036data3-8-22-05123.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0037data3-8-22-05124.txt 8 3 22 11 0.0044data3-8-22-05125.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0040data3-8-22-05126.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0042data3-8-22-05127.txt 8 3 22 13 0.0039data3-8-22-05128.txt 8 3 22 12 0.0036data3-8-22-05129.txt 8 3 22 11 0.0037data3-8-22-05130.txt 8 3 22 11 0.0039data3-8-22-05131.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0043data3-8-22-05132.txt 8 3 22 9 0.0041data3-8-22-05133.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0041data3-8-22-05134.txt 8 3 22 8 0.0041data3-8-22-05135.txt 8 3 22 12 0.0038data3-8-22-05136.txt 8 3 22 7 0.0038data3-8-22-05137.txt 8 3 22 12 0.0037data3-8-22-05138.txt 8 3 22 4 0.0039data3-8-22-05139.txt 8 3 22 9 0.0044data3-8-22-05140.txt 8 3 22 8 0.0043data3-8-22-05141.txt 8 3 22 8 0.0041data3-8-22-05142.txt 8 3 22 9 0.0038data3-8-22-05143.txt 8 3 22 8 0.0038data3-8-22-05144.txt 8 3 22 6 0.0037data3-8-22-05145.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0038data3-8-22-05146.txt 8 3 22 11 0.0044data3-8-22-05147.txt 8 3 22 7 0.0043data3-8-22-05148.txt 8 3 22 7 0.0041data3-8-22-05149.txt 8 3 22 8 0.0040data3-8-22-05150.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0039data3-8-22-05151.txt 8 3 22 8 0.0035data3-8-22-05152.txt 8 3 22 6 0.0036data3-8-22-05153.txt 8 3 22 7 0.0041data3-8-22-05154.txt 8 3 22 8 0.0045data3-8-22-05155.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0040data3-8-22-05156.txt 8 3 22 11 0.0039data3-8-22-05157.txt 8 3 22 11 0.0037data3-8-22-05158.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0037data3-8-22-05159.txt 8 3 22 9 0.0037data3-8-22-05160.txt 8 3 22 6 0.0038data3-8-22-05161.txt 8 3 22 5 0.0042data3-8-22-05162.txt 8 3 22 7 0.0043data3-8-22-05163.txt 8 3 22 11 0.0042data3-8-22-05164.txt 8 3 22 11 0.0041data3-8-22-05165.txt 8 3 22 8 0.0038data3-8-22-05166.txt 8 3 22 8 0.0038data3-8-22-05167.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0035data3-8-22-05168.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0041data3-8-22-05169.txt 8 3 22 5 0.0044data3-8-22-05170.txt 8 3 22 15 0.0040

Table 11: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 217: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-8-22-05171.txt 8 3 22 9 0.0041data3-8-22-05172.txt 8 3 22 11 0.0039data3-8-22-05173.txt 8 3 22 8 0.0039data3-8-22-05174.txt 8 3 22 7 0.0036data3-8-22-05175.txt 8 3 22 9 0.0037data3-8-22-05176.txt 8 3 22 5 0.0040data3-8-22-05177.txt 8 3 22 6 0.0043data3-8-22-05178.txt 8 3 22 8 0.0043data3-8-22-05179.txt 8 3 22 14 0.0039data3-8-22-05180.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0039data3-8-22-05181.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0038data3-8-22-05182.txt 8 3 22 11 0.0037data3-8-22-05183.txt 8 3 22 8 0.0039data3-8-22-05184.txt 8 3 22 9 0.0044data3-8-22-05185.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0041data3-8-22-05186.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0040data3-8-22-05187.txt 8 3 22 7 0.0043data3-8-22-05188.txt 8 3 22 9 0.0038data3-8-22-05189.txt 8 3 22 8 0.0037data3-8-22-05190.txt 8 3 22 7 0.0037data3-8-22-05191.txt 8 3 22 12 0.0041data3-8-22-05192.txt 8 3 22 9 0.0043data3-8-22-05193.txt 8 3 22 10 0.0042data3-8-22-05194.txt 8 3 22 13 0.0039data3-8-22-05195.txt 8 3 22 12 0.0040data3-8-22-05196.txt 8 3 22 8 0.0041data3-8-22-05197.txt 8 3 22 11 0.0036data3-8-22-05198.txt 8 3 22 9 0.0039data3-8-22-05199.txt 8 3 22 9 0.0045data3-8-22-05200.txt 8 3 22 5 0.0043data3-8-23-05201.txt 8 3 23 11 0.0042data3-8-23-05202.txt 8 3 23 8 0.0041data3-8-23-05203.txt 8 3 23 14 0.0041data3-8-23-05204.txt 8 3 23 8 0.0038data3-8-23-05205.txt 8 3 23 11 0.0039data3-8-23-05206.txt 8 3 23 15 0.0045data3-8-23-05207.txt 8 3 23 7 0.0045data3-8-23-05208.txt 8 3 23 6 0.0043data3-8-23-05209.txt 8 3 23 14 0.0054data3-8-23-05210.txt 8 3 23 11 0.0042data3-8-23-05211.txt 8 3 23 7 0.0040data3-8-23-05212.txt 8 3 23 6 0.0042data3-8-23-05213.txt 8 3 23 5 0.0045data3-8-23-05214.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0046data3-8-23-05215.txt 8 3 23 11 0.0042data3-8-23-05216.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0042data3-8-23-05217.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0040data3-8-23-05218.txt 8 3 23 12 0.0038data3-8-23-05219.txt 8 3 23 9 0.0039data3-8-23-05220.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0046data3-8-23-05221.txt 8 3 23 8 0.0046data3-8-23-05222.txt 8 3 23 11 0.0043data3-8-23-05223.txt 8 3 23 7 0.0041data3-8-23-05224.txt 8 3 23 7 0.0040data3-8-23-05225.txt 8 3 23 14 0.0039data3-8-23-05226.txt 8 3 23 13 0.0045data3-8-23-05227.txt 8 3 23 8 0.0045data3-8-23-05228.txt 8 3 23 9 0.0048data3-8-23-05229.txt 8 3 23 6 0.0041data3-8-23-05230.txt 8 3 23 8 0.0043data3-8-23-05231.txt 8 3 23 7 0.0040data3-8-23-05232.txt 8 3 23 5 0.0043data3-8-23-05233.txt 8 3 23 4 0.0042data3-8-23-05234.txt 8 3 23 7 0.0045data3-8-23-05235.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0046data3-8-23-05236.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0043data3-8-23-05237.txt 8 3 23 8 0.0041data3-8-23-05238.txt 8 3 23 12 0.0041data3-8-23-05239.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0042data3-8-23-05240.txt 8 3 23 13 0.0042

Table 12: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 218: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-8-23-05241.txt 8 3 23 7 0.0045data3-8-23-05242.txt 8 3 23 9 0.0042data3-8-23-05243.txt 8 3 23 8 0.0042data3-8-23-05244.txt 8 3 23 13 0.0041data3-8-23-05245.txt 8 3 23 8 0.0041data3-8-23-05246.txt 8 3 23 9 0.0042data3-8-23-05247.txt 8 3 23 6 0.0042data3-8-23-05248.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0048data3-8-23-05249.txt 8 3 23 8 0.0042data3-8-23-05250.txt 8 3 23 7 0.0045data3-8-23-05251.txt 8 3 23 9 0.0040data3-8-23-05252.txt 8 3 23 9 0.0042data3-8-23-05253.txt 8 3 23 15 0.0043data3-8-23-05254.txt 8 3 23 8 0.0044data3-8-23-05255.txt 8 3 23 11 0.0044data3-8-23-05256.txt 8 3 23 8 0.0043data3-8-23-05257.txt 8 3 23 7 0.0044data3-8-23-05258.txt 8 3 23 9 0.0042data3-8-23-05259.txt 8 3 23 12 0.0043data3-8-23-05260.txt 8 3 23 9 0.0044data3-8-23-05261.txt 8 3 23 12 0.0043data3-8-23-05262.txt 8 3 23 8 0.0045data3-8-23-05263.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0041data3-8-23-05264.txt 8 3 23 5 0.0044data3-8-23-05265.txt 8 3 23 8 0.0040data3-8-23-05266.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0042data3-8-23-05267.txt 8 3 23 13 0.0042data3-8-23-05268.txt 8 3 23 12 0.0042data3-8-23-05269.txt 8 3 23 11 0.0044data3-8-23-05270.txt 8 3 23 15 0.0041data3-8-23-05271.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0043data3-8-23-05272.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0043data3-8-23-05273.txt 8 3 23 15 0.0043data3-8-23-05274.txt 8 3 23 8 0.0044data3-8-23-05275.txt 8 3 23 11 0.0041data3-8-23-05276.txt 8 3 23 11 0.0047data3-8-23-05277.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0041data3-8-23-05278.txt 8 3 23 8 0.0043data3-8-23-05279.txt 8 3 23 12 0.0041data3-8-23-05280.txt 8 3 23 6 0.0044data3-8-23-05281.txt 8 3 23 6 0.0042data3-8-23-05282.txt 8 3 23 14 0.0051data3-8-23-05283.txt 8 3 23 11 0.0043data3-8-23-05284.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0042data3-8-23-05285.txt 8 3 23 11 0.0042data3-8-23-05286.txt 8 3 23 9 0.0042data3-8-23-05287.txt 8 3 23 13 0.0045data3-8-23-05288.txt 8 3 23 5 0.0045data3-8-23-05289.txt 8 3 23 11 0.0047data3-8-23-05290.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0040data3-8-23-05291.txt 8 3 23 8 0.0042data3-8-23-05292.txt 8 3 23 11 0.0043data3-8-23-05293.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0040data3-8-23-05294.txt 8 3 23 8 0.0044data3-8-23-05295.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0044data3-8-23-05296.txt 8 3 23 11 0.0045data3-8-23-05297.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0041data3-8-23-05298.txt 8 3 23 14 0.0041data3-8-23-05299.txt 8 3 23 8 0.0042data3-8-23-05300.txt 8 3 23 10 0.0040data3-9-24-07501.txt 9 3 24 12 0.0043data3-9-24-07502.txt 9 3 24 11 0.0045data3-9-24-07503.txt 9 3 24 13 0.0047data3-9-24-07504.txt 9 3 24 10 0.0044data3-9-24-07505.txt 9 3 24 7 0.0045data3-9-24-07506.txt 9 3 24 9 0.0043data3-9-24-07507.txt 9 3 24 8 0.0044data3-9-24-07508.txt 9 3 24 5 0.0046data3-9-24-07509.txt 9 3 24 7 0.0047data3-9-24-07510.txt 9 3 24 9 0.0046

Table 13: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 219: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-9-24-07511.txt 9 3 24 10 0.0042data3-9-24-07512.txt 9 3 24 8 0.0043data3-9-24-07513.txt 9 3 24 9 0.0043data3-9-24-07514.txt 9 3 24 14 0.0046data3-9-24-07515.txt 9 3 24 8 0.0046data3-9-24-07516.txt 9 3 24 9 0.0044data3-9-24-07517.txt 9 3 24 11 0.0046data3-9-24-07518.txt 9 3 24 7 0.0046data3-9-24-07519.txt 9 3 24 10 0.0044data3-9-24-07520.txt 9 3 24 9 0.0045data3-9-24-07521.txt 9 3 24 11 0.0044data3-9-24-07522.txt 9 3 24 8 0.0046data3-9-24-07523.txt 9 3 24 11 0.0043data3-9-24-07524.txt 9 3 24 9 0.0047data3-9-24-07525.txt 9 3 24 7 0.0043data3-9-24-07526.txt 9 3 24 6 0.0042data3-9-24-07527.txt 9 3 24 9 0.0045data3-9-24-07528.txt 9 3 24 7 0.0049data3-9-24-07529.txt 9 3 24 12 0.0047data3-9-24-07530.txt 9 3 24 13 0.0042data3-9-24-07531.txt 9 3 24 12 0.0047data3-9-24-07532.txt 9 3 24 13 0.0044data3-9-24-07533.txt 9 3 24 12 0.0042data3-9-24-07534.txt 9 3 24 7 0.0047data3-9-24-07535.txt 9 3 24 12 0.0045data3-9-24-07536.txt 9 3 24 12 0.0045data3-9-24-07537.txt 9 3 24 8 0.0042data3-9-24-07538.txt 9 3 24 13 0.0046data3-9-24-07539.txt 9 3 24 10 0.0045data3-9-24-07540.txt 9 3 24 8 0.0040data3-9-24-07541.txt 9 3 24 9 0.0048data3-9-24-07542.txt 9 3 24 13 0.0049data3-9-24-07543.txt 9 3 24 10 0.0046data3-9-24-07544.txt 9 3 24 8 0.0045data3-9-24-07545.txt 9 3 24 14 0.0043data3-9-24-07546.txt 9 3 24 9 0.0043data3-9-24-07547.txt 9 3 24 11 0.0045data3-9-24-07548.txt 9 3 24 14 0.0050data3-9-24-07549.txt 9 3 24 9 0.0048data3-9-24-07550.txt 9 3 24 9 0.0043data3-9-24-07551.txt 9 3 24 9 0.0047data3-9-24-07552.txt 9 3 24 10 0.0046data3-9-24-07553.txt 9 3 24 10 0.0043data3-9-24-07554.txt 9 3 24 12 0.0047data3-9-24-07555.txt 9 3 24 9 0.0049data3-9-24-07556.txt 9 3 24 7 0.0045data3-9-24-07557.txt 9 3 24 10 0.0042data3-9-24-07558.txt 9 3 24 8 0.0048data3-9-24-07559.txt 9 3 24 6 0.0045data3-9-24-07560.txt 9 3 24 12 0.0045data3-9-24-07561.txt 9 3 24 8 0.0047data3-9-24-07562.txt 9 3 24 10 0.0047data3-9-24-07563.txt 9 3 24 12 0.0041data3-9-24-07564.txt 9 3 24 11 0.0043data3-9-24-07565.txt 9 3 24 10 0.0047data3-9-24-07566.txt 9 3 24 10 0.0044data3-9-24-07567.txt 9 3 24 12 0.0044data3-9-24-07568.txt 9 3 24 6 0.0049data3-9-24-07569.txt 9 3 24 11 0.0047data3-9-24-07570.txt 9 3 24 8 0.0042data3-9-24-07571.txt 9 3 24 13 0.0043data3-9-24-07572.txt 9 3 24 12 0.0046data3-9-24-07573.txt 9 3 24 10 0.0047data3-9-24-07574.txt 9 3 24 11 0.0045data3-9-24-07575.txt 9 3 24 13 0.0049data3-9-24-07576.txt 9 3 24 11 0.0043data3-9-24-07577.txt 9 3 24 9 0.0042data3-9-24-07578.txt 9 3 24 7 0.0045data3-9-24-07579.txt 9 3 24 10 0.0046data3-9-24-07580.txt 9 3 24 8 0.0047

Table 14: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 220: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-9-24-07581.txt 9 3 24 14 0.0048data3-9-24-07582.txt 9 3 24 12 0.0050data3-9-24-07583.txt 9 3 24 13 0.0043data3-9-24-07584.txt 9 3 24 10 0.0042data3-9-24-07585.txt 9 3 24 8 0.0049data3-9-24-07586.txt 9 3 24 10 0.0047data3-9-24-07587.txt 9 3 24 11 0.0044data3-9-24-07588.txt 9 3 24 5 0.0048data3-9-24-07589.txt 9 3 24 12 0.0043data3-9-24-07590.txt 9 3 24 9 0.0043data3-9-24-07591.txt 9 3 24 7 0.0042data3-9-24-07592.txt 9 3 24 9 0.0050data3-9-24-07593.txt 9 3 24 10 0.0048data3-9-24-07594.txt 9 3 24 8 0.0046data3-9-24-07595.txt 9 3 24 5 0.0049data3-9-24-07596.txt 9 3 24 7 0.0047data3-9-24-07597.txt 9 3 24 7 0.0043data3-9-24-07598.txt 9 3 24 10 0.0042data3-9-24-07599.txt 9 3 24 12 0.0049data3-9-24-07600.txt 9 3 24 10 0.0044data3-9-25-07601.txt 9 3 25 9 0.0044data3-9-25-07602.txt 9 3 25 5 0.0052data3-9-25-07603.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0048data3-9-25-07604.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0044data3-9-25-07605.txt 9 3 25 7 0.0049data3-9-25-07606.txt 9 3 25 13 0.0046data3-9-25-07607.txt 9 3 25 9 0.0046data3-9-25-07608.txt 9 3 25 8 0.0048data3-9-25-07609.txt 9 3 25 8 0.0047data3-9-25-07610.txt 9 3 25 8 0.0046data3-9-25-07611.txt 9 3 25 14 0.0046data3-9-25-07612.txt 9 3 25 9 0.0050data3-9-25-07613.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0045data3-9-25-07614.txt 9 3 25 7 0.0046data3-9-25-07615.txt 9 3 25 10 0.0050data3-9-25-07616.txt 9 3 25 8 0.0046data3-9-25-07617.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0044data3-9-25-07618.txt 9 3 25 13 0.0052data3-9-25-07619.txt 9 3 25 12 0.0049data3-9-25-07620.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0046data3-9-25-07621.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0050data3-9-25-07622.txt 9 3 25 13 0.0046data3-9-25-07623.txt 9 3 25 10 0.0044data3-9-25-07624.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0047data3-9-25-07625.txt 9 3 25 13 0.0049data3-9-25-07626.txt 9 3 25 10 0.0048data3-9-25-07627.txt 9 3 25 5 0.0044data3-9-25-07628.txt 9 3 25 7 0.0050data3-9-25-07629.txt 9 3 25 7 0.0044data3-9-25-07630.txt 9 3 25 10 0.0045data3-9-25-07631.txt 9 3 25 14 0.0049data3-9-25-07632.txt 9 3 25 13 0.0049data3-9-25-07633.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0044data3-9-25-07634.txt 9 3 25 9 0.0047data3-9-25-07635.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0049data3-9-25-07636.txt 9 3 25 13 0.0046data3-9-25-07637.txt 9 3 25 6 0.0046data3-9-25-07638.txt 9 3 25 12 0.0051data3-9-25-07639.txt 9 3 25 15 0.0045data3-9-25-07640.txt 9 3 25 10 0.0043data3-9-25-07641.txt 9 3 25 10 0.0047data3-9-25-07642.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0047data3-9-25-07643.txt 9 3 25 14 0.0048data3-9-25-07644.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0050data3-9-25-07645.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0050data3-9-25-07646.txt 9 3 25 8 0.0044data3-9-25-07647.txt 9 3 25 8 0.0044data3-9-25-07648.txt 9 3 25 8 0.0042data3-9-25-07649.txt 9 3 25 12 0.0042data3-9-25-07650.txt 9 3 25 9 0.0051

Table 15: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 221: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-9-25-07651.txt 9 3 25 13 0.0050data3-9-25-07652.txt 9 3 25 9 0.0046data3-9-25-07653.txt 9 3 25 10 0.0042data3-9-25-07654.txt 9 3 25 8 0.0043data3-9-25-07655.txt 9 3 25 8 0.0041data3-9-25-07656.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0046data3-9-25-07657.txt 9 3 25 8 0.0051data3-9-25-07658.txt 9 3 25 9 0.0047data3-9-25-07659.txt 9 3 25 12 0.0044data3-9-25-07660.txt 9 3 25 12 0.0045data3-9-25-07661.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0046data3-9-25-07662.txt 9 3 25 12 0.0042data3-9-25-07663.txt 9 3 25 15 0.0049data3-9-25-07664.txt 9 3 25 8 0.0049data3-9-25-07665.txt 9 3 25 8 0.0045data3-9-25-07666.txt 9 3 25 12 0.0043data3-9-25-07667.txt 9 3 25 8 0.0044data3-9-25-07668.txt 9 3 25 15 0.0041data3-9-25-07669.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0050data3-9-25-07670.txt 9 3 25 5 0.0048data3-9-25-07671.txt 9 3 25 6 0.0048data3-9-25-07672.txt 9 3 25 9 0.0046data3-9-25-07673.txt 9 3 25 8 0.0044data3-9-25-07674.txt 9 3 25 10 0.0045data3-9-25-07675.txt 9 3 25 12 0.0044data3-9-25-07676.txt 9 3 25 10 0.0050data3-9-25-07677.txt 9 3 25 9 0.0049data3-9-25-07678.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0046data3-9-25-07679.txt 9 3 25 12 0.0044data3-9-25-07680.txt 9 3 25 9 0.0043data3-9-25-07681.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0043data3-9-25-07682.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0048data3-9-25-07683.txt 9 3 25 5 0.0047data3-9-25-07684.txt 9 3 25 7 0.0048data3-9-25-07685.txt 9 3 25 8 0.0043data3-9-25-07686.txt 9 3 25 13 0.0044data3-9-25-07687.txt 9 3 25 10 0.0042data3-9-25-07688.txt 9 3 25 11 0.0045data3-9-25-07689.txt 9 3 25 8 0.0050data3-9-25-07690.txt 9 3 25 14 0.0048data3-9-25-07691.txt 9 3 25 10 0.0046data3-9-25-07692.txt 9 3 25 13 0.0044data3-9-25-07693.txt 9 3 25 12 0.0043data3-9-25-07694.txt 9 3 25 5 0.0045data3-9-25-07695.txt 9 3 25 6 0.0048data3-9-25-07696.txt 9 3 25 7 0.0049data3-9-25-07697.txt 9 3 25 12 0.0050data3-9-25-07698.txt 9 3 25 10 0.0046data3-9-25-07699.txt 9 3 25 12 0.0042data3-9-25-07700.txt 9 3 25 9 0.0044data3-9-26-07701.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0048data3-9-26-07702.txt 9 3 26 12 0.0050data3-9-26-07703.txt 9 3 26 12 0.0052data3-9-26-07704.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0048data3-9-26-07705.txt 9 3 26 12 0.0044data3-9-26-07706.txt 9 3 26 14 0.0044data3-9-26-07707.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0045data3-9-26-07708.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0052data3-9-26-07709.txt 9 3 26 12 0.0049data3-9-26-07710.txt 9 3 26 10 0.0047data3-9-26-07711.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0046data3-9-26-07712.txt 9 3 26 10 0.0046data3-9-26-07713.txt 9 3 26 15 0.0044data3-9-26-07714.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0051data3-9-26-07715.txt 9 3 26 15 0.0050data3-9-26-07716.txt 9 3 26 10 0.0050data3-9-26-07717.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0047data3-9-26-07718.txt 9 3 26 10 0.0046data3-9-26-07719.txt 9 3 26 12 0.0045data3-9-26-07720.txt 9 3 26 14 0.0048

Table 16: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 222: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-9-26-07721.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0053data3-9-26-07722.txt 9 3 26 10 0.0052data3-9-26-07723.txt 9 3 26 10 0.0047data3-9-26-07724.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0047data3-9-26-07725.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0045data3-9-26-07726.txt 9 3 26 7 0.0048data3-9-26-07727.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0052data3-9-26-07728.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0050data3-9-26-07729.txt 9 3 26 12 0.0047data3-9-26-07730.txt 9 3 26 14 0.0046data3-9-26-07731.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0044data3-9-26-07732.txt 9 3 26 7 0.0047data3-9-26-07733.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0053data3-9-26-07734.txt 9 3 26 10 0.0051data3-9-26-07735.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0045data3-9-26-07736.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0047data3-9-26-07737.txt 9 3 26 12 0.0043data3-9-26-07738.txt 9 3 26 8 0.0046data3-9-26-07739.txt 9 3 26 10 0.0051data3-9-26-07740.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0053data3-9-26-07741.txt 9 3 26 12 0.0048data3-9-26-07742.txt 9 3 26 10 0.0047data3-9-26-07743.txt 9 3 26 12 0.0047data3-9-26-07744.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0046data3-9-26-07745.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0054data3-9-26-07746.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0052data3-9-26-07747.txt 9 3 26 15 0.0050data3-9-26-07748.txt 9 3 26 10 0.0047data3-9-26-07749.txt 9 3 26 5 0.0047data3-9-26-07750.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0047data3-9-26-07751.txt 9 3 26 10 0.0052data3-9-26-07752.txt 9 3 26 12 0.0051data3-9-26-07753.txt 9 3 26 10 0.0051data3-9-26-07754.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0044data3-9-26-07755.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0045data3-9-26-07756.txt 9 3 26 12 0.0046data3-9-26-07757.txt 9 3 26 9 0.0052data3-9-26-07758.txt 9 3 26 9 0.0051data3-9-26-07759.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0048data3-9-26-07760.txt 9 3 26 8 0.0046data3-9-26-07761.txt 9 3 26 14 0.0046data3-9-26-07762.txt 9 3 26 16 0.0048data3-9-26-07763.txt 9 3 26 6 0.0053data3-9-26-07764.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0052data3-9-26-07765.txt 9 3 26 7 0.0049data3-9-26-07766.txt 9 3 26 12 0.0046data3-9-26-07767.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0043data3-9-26-07768.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0048data3-9-26-07769.txt 9 3 26 6 0.0051data3-9-26-07770.txt 9 3 26 12 0.0052data3-9-26-07771.txt 9 3 26 12 0.0048data3-9-26-07772.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0046data3-9-26-07773.txt 9 3 26 10 0.0044data3-9-26-07774.txt 9 3 26 9 0.0044data3-9-26-07775.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0051data3-9-26-07776.txt 9 3 26 12 0.0051data3-9-26-07777.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0048data3-9-26-07778.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0046data3-9-26-07779.txt 9 3 26 8 0.0045data3-9-26-07780.txt 9 3 26 12 0.0044data3-9-26-07781.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0049data3-9-26-07782.txt 9 3 26 9 0.0053data3-9-26-07783.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0051data3-9-26-07784.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0046data3-9-26-07785.txt 9 3 26 14 0.0046data3-9-26-07786.txt 9 3 26 10 0.0046data3-9-26-07787.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0045data3-9-26-07788.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0051data3-9-26-07789.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0050data3-9-26-07790.txt 9 3 26 16 0.0048

Table 17: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 223: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-9-26-07791.txt 9 3 26 9 0.0048data3-9-26-07792.txt 9 3 26 16 0.0045data3-9-26-07793.txt 9 3 26 8 0.0044data3-9-26-07794.txt 9 3 26 8 0.0054data3-9-26-07795.txt 9 3 26 11 0.0054data3-9-26-07796.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0048data3-9-26-07797.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0048data3-9-26-07798.txt 9 3 26 9 0.0046data3-9-26-07799.txt 9 3 26 15 0.0044data3-9-26-07800.txt 9 3 26 13 0.0053data3-10-27-10001.txt 10 3 27 14 0.0053data3-10-27-10002.txt 10 3 27 6 0.0050data3-10-27-10003.txt 10 3 27 11 0.0050data3-10-27-10004.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0047data3-10-27-10005.txt 10 3 27 14 0.0046data3-10-27-10006.txt 10 3 27 8 0.0051data3-10-27-10007.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0052data3-10-27-10008.txt 10 3 27 7 0.0048data3-10-27-10009.txt 10 3 27 14 0.0051data3-10-27-10010.txt 10 3 27 10 0.0046data3-10-27-10011.txt 10 3 27 9 0.0047data3-10-27-10012.txt 10 3 27 10 0.0054data3-10-27-10013.txt 10 3 27 7 0.0055data3-10-27-10014.txt 10 3 27 11 0.0051data3-10-27-10015.txt 10 3 27 9 0.0048data3-10-27-10016.txt 10 3 27 13 0.0047data3-10-27-10017.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0048data3-10-27-10018.txt 10 3 27 14 0.0054data3-10-27-10019.txt 10 3 27 9 0.0056data3-10-27-10020.txt 10 3 27 8 0.0050data3-10-27-10021.txt 10 3 27 9 0.0048data3-10-27-10022.txt 10 3 27 11 0.0049data3-10-27-10023.txt 10 3 27 10 0.0050data3-10-27-10024.txt 10 3 27 9 0.0054data3-10-27-10025.txt 10 3 27 7 0.0056data3-10-27-10026.txt 10 3 27 13 0.0048data3-10-27-10027.txt 10 3 27 9 0.0050data3-10-27-10028.txt 10 3 27 9 0.0049data3-10-27-10029.txt 10 3 27 8 0.0051data3-10-27-10030.txt 10 3 27 11 0.0054data3-10-27-10031.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0051data3-10-27-10032.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0047data3-10-27-10033.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0049data3-10-27-10034.txt 10 3 27 9 0.0047data3-10-27-10035.txt 10 3 27 10 0.0053data3-10-27-10036.txt 10 3 27 15 0.0054data3-10-27-10037.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0051data3-10-27-10038.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0046data3-10-27-10039.txt 10 3 27 11 0.0045data3-10-27-10040.txt 10 3 27 14 0.0045data3-10-27-10041.txt 10 3 27 11 0.0054data3-10-27-10042.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0054data3-10-27-10043.txt 10 3 27 10 0.0050data3-10-27-10044.txt 10 3 27 10 0.0048data3-10-27-10045.txt 10 3 27 6 0.0047data3-10-27-10046.txt 10 3 27 11 0.0048data3-10-27-10047.txt 10 3 27 6 0.0054data3-10-27-10048.txt 10 3 27 8 0.0054data3-10-27-10049.txt 10 3 27 13 0.0050data3-10-27-10050.txt 10 3 27 16 0.0049data3-10-27-10051.txt 10 3 27 9 0.0046data3-10-27-10052.txt 10 3 27 11 0.0048data3-10-27-10053.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0054data3-10-27-10054.txt 10 3 27 10 0.0052data3-10-27-10055.txt 10 3 27 10 0.0049data3-10-27-10056.txt 10 3 27 8 0.0045data3-10-27-10057.txt 10 3 27 13 0.0048data3-10-27-10058.txt 10 3 27 14 0.0049data3-10-27-10059.txt 10 3 27 14 0.0053data3-10-27-10060.txt 10 3 27 7 0.0053

Table 18: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 224: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-10-27-10061.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0049data3-10-27-10062.txt 10 3 27 11 0.0047data3-10-27-10063.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0046data3-10-27-10064.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0048data3-10-27-10065.txt 10 3 27 11 0.0055data3-10-27-10066.txt 10 3 27 10 0.0054data3-10-27-10067.txt 10 3 27 11 0.0050data3-10-27-10068.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0048data3-10-27-10069.txt 10 3 27 9 0.0047data3-10-27-10070.txt 10 3 27 9 0.0047data3-10-27-10071.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0056data3-10-27-10072.txt 10 3 27 11 0.0055data3-10-27-10073.txt 10 3 27 16 0.0049data3-10-27-10074.txt 10 3 27 10 0.0048data3-10-27-10075.txt 10 3 27 13 0.0047data3-10-27-10076.txt 10 3 27 11 0.0048data3-10-27-10077.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0056data3-10-27-10078.txt 10 3 27 11 0.0055data3-10-27-10079.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0049data3-10-27-10080.txt 10 3 27 10 0.0048data3-10-27-10081.txt 10 3 27 9 0.0046data3-10-27-10082.txt 10 3 27 10 0.0047data3-10-27-10083.txt 10 3 27 10 0.0054data3-10-27-10084.txt 10 3 27 9 0.0053data3-10-27-10085.txt 10 3 27 13 0.0049data3-10-27-10086.txt 10 3 27 14 0.0048data3-10-27-10087.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0048data3-10-27-10088.txt 10 3 27 11 0.0049data3-10-27-10089.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0053data3-10-27-10090.txt 10 3 27 7 0.0053data3-10-27-10091.txt 10 3 27 8 0.0050data3-10-27-10092.txt 10 3 27 8 0.0047data3-10-27-10093.txt 10 3 27 9 0.0046data3-10-27-10094.txt 10 3 27 11 0.0048data3-10-27-10095.txt 10 3 27 12 0.0053data3-10-27-10096.txt 10 3 27 9 0.0051data3-10-27-10097.txt 10 3 27 14 0.0049data3-10-27-10098.txt 10 3 27 9 0.0047data3-10-27-10099.txt 10 3 27 13 0.0047data3-10-27-10100.txt 10 3 27 11 0.0048data3-10-28-10101.txt 10 3 28 11 0.0056data3-10-28-10102.txt 10 3 28 8 0.0054data3-10-28-10103.txt 10 3 28 6 0.0051data3-10-28-10104.txt 10 3 28 11 0.0049data3-10-28-10105.txt 10 3 28 8 0.0049data3-10-28-10106.txt 10 3 28 11 0.0050data3-10-28-10107.txt 10 3 28 9 0.0054data3-10-28-10108.txt 10 3 28 9 0.0052data3-10-28-10109.txt 10 3 28 12 0.0047data3-10-28-10110.txt 10 3 28 14 0.0050data3-10-28-10111.txt 10 3 28 15 0.0048data3-10-28-10112.txt 10 3 28 9 0.0053data3-10-28-10113.txt 10 3 28 14 0.0054data3-10-28-10114.txt 10 3 28 7 0.0050data3-10-28-10115.txt 10 3 28 12 0.0048data3-10-28-10116.txt 10 3 28 13 0.0047data3-10-28-10117.txt 10 3 28 9 0.0048data3-10-28-10118.txt 10 3 28 8 0.0055data3-10-28-10119.txt 10 3 28 14 0.0053data3-10-28-10120.txt 10 3 28 13 0.0051data3-10-28-10121.txt 10 3 28 11 0.0052data3-10-28-10122.txt 10 3 28 9 0.0049data3-10-28-10123.txt 10 3 28 10 0.0050data3-10-28-10124.txt 10 3 28 12 0.0054data3-10-28-10125.txt 10 3 28 8 0.0054data3-10-28-10126.txt 10 3 28 14 0.0050data3-10-28-10127.txt 10 3 28 11 0.0050data3-10-28-10128.txt 10 3 28 7 0.0053data3-10-28-10129.txt 10 3 28 11 0.0053data3-10-28-10130.txt 10 3 28 12 0.0052

Table 19: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 225: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-10-28-10131.txt 10 3 28 10 0.0053data3-10-28-10132.txt 10 3 28 15 0.0051data3-10-28-10133.txt 10 3 28 10 0.0050data3-10-28-10134.txt 10 3 28 12 0.0052data3-10-28-10135.txt 10 3 28 15 0.0061data3-10-28-10136.txt 10 3 28 10 0.0052data3-10-28-10137.txt 10 3 28 10 0.0053data3-10-28-10138.txt 10 3 28 10 0.0050data3-10-28-10139.txt 10 3 28 11 0.0049data3-10-28-10140.txt 10 3 28 9 0.0054data3-10-28-10141.txt 10 3 28 15 0.0052data3-10-28-10142.txt 10 3 28 17 0.0050data3-10-28-10143.txt 10 3 28 15 0.0052data3-10-28-10144.txt 10 3 28 11 0.0050data3-10-28-10145.txt 10 3 28 13 0.0049data3-10-28-10146.txt 10 3 28 11 0.0053data3-10-28-10147.txt 10 3 28 15 0.0050data3-10-28-10148.txt 10 3 28 12 0.0049data3-10-28-10149.txt 10 3 28 15 0.0054data3-10-28-10150.txt 10 3 28 9 0.0050data3-10-28-10151.txt 10 3 28 10 0.0049data3-10-28-10152.txt 10 3 28 9 0.0051data3-10-28-10153.txt 10 3 28 10 0.0051data3-10-28-10154.txt 10 3 28 11 0.0051data3-10-28-10155.txt 10 3 28 11 0.0053data3-10-28-10156.txt 10 3 28 8 0.0050data3-10-28-10157.txt 10 3 28 14 0.0049data3-10-28-10158.txt 10 3 28 13 0.0052data3-10-28-10159.txt 10 3 28 14 0.0055data3-10-28-10160.txt 10 3 28 10 0.0049data3-10-28-10161.txt 10 3 28 18 0.0054data3-10-28-10162.txt 10 3 28 12 0.0051data3-10-28-10163.txt 10 3 28 11 0.0051data3-10-28-10164.txt 10 3 28 11 0.0055data3-10-28-10165.txt 10 3 28 15 0.0053data3-10-28-10166.txt 10 3 28 12 0.0048data3-10-28-10167.txt 10 3 28 9 0.0054data3-10-28-10168.txt 10 3 28 13 0.0050data3-10-28-10169.txt 10 3 28 11 0.0054data3-10-28-10170.txt 10 3 28 15 0.0055data3-10-28-10171.txt 10 3 28 11 0.0053data3-10-28-10172.txt 10 3 28 16 0.0050data3-10-28-10173.txt 10 3 28 10 0.0053data3-10-28-10174.txt 10 3 28 11 0.0055data3-10-28-10175.txt 10 3 28 17 0.0056data3-10-28-10176.txt 10 3 28 16 0.0055data3-10-28-10177.txt 10 3 28 8 0.0052data3-10-28-10178.txt 10 3 28 14 0.0052data3-10-28-10179.txt 10 3 28 10 0.0054data3-10-28-10180.txt 10 3 28 16 0.0056data3-10-28-10181.txt 10 3 28 12 0.0057data3-10-28-10182.txt 10 3 28 13 0.0051data3-10-28-10183.txt 10 3 28 12 0.0049data3-10-28-10184.txt 10 3 28 10 0.0054data3-10-28-10185.txt 10 3 28 6 0.0052data3-10-28-10186.txt 10 3 28 14 0.0054data3-10-28-10187.txt 10 3 28 14 0.0056data3-10-28-10188.txt 10 3 28 11 0.0052data3-10-28-10189.txt 10 3 28 8 0.0050data3-10-28-10190.txt 10 3 28 8 0.0055data3-10-28-10191.txt 10 3 28 7 0.0055data3-10-28-10192.txt 10 3 28 14 0.0060data3-10-28-10193.txt 10 3 28 14 0.0052data3-10-28-10194.txt 10 3 28 12 0.0050data3-10-28-10195.txt 10 3 28 15 0.0051data3-10-28-10196.txt 10 3 28 17 0.0056data3-10-28-10197.txt 10 3 28 10 0.0053data3-10-28-10198.txt 10 3 28 15 0.0052data3-10-28-10199.txt 10 3 28 14 0.0050data3-10-28-10200.txt 10 3 28 19 0.0055

Table 20: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 226: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-10-29-10201.txt 10 3 29 13 0.0057data3-10-29-10202.txt 10 3 29 17 0.0056data3-10-29-10203.txt 10 3 29 12 0.0056data3-10-29-10204.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0056data3-10-29-10205.txt 10 3 29 13 0.0054data3-10-29-10206.txt 10 3 29 16 0.0051data3-10-29-10207.txt 10 3 29 12 0.0058data3-10-29-10208.txt 10 3 29 12 0.0056data3-10-29-10209.txt 10 3 29 9 0.0053data3-10-29-10210.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0054data3-10-29-10211.txt 10 3 29 9 0.0054data3-10-29-10212.txt 10 3 29 12 0.0055data3-10-29-10213.txt 10 3 29 17 0.0055data3-10-29-10214.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0054data3-10-29-10215.txt 10 3 29 15 0.0058data3-10-29-10216.txt 10 3 29 12 0.0055data3-10-29-10217.txt 10 3 29 12 0.0052data3-10-29-10218.txt 10 3 29 10 0.0058data3-10-29-10219.txt 10 3 29 14 0.0057data3-10-29-10220.txt 10 3 29 16 0.0052data3-10-29-10221.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0056data3-10-29-10222.txt 10 3 29 9 0.0053data3-10-29-10223.txt 10 3 29 10 0.0051data3-10-29-10224.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0051data3-10-29-10225.txt 10 3 29 14 0.0055data3-10-29-10226.txt 10 3 29 10 0.0051data3-10-29-10227.txt 10 3 29 12 0.0054data3-10-29-10228.txt 10 3 29 12 0.0052data3-10-29-10229.txt 10 3 29 13 0.0055data3-10-29-10230.txt 10 3 29 8 0.0057data3-10-29-10231.txt 10 3 29 16 0.0052data3-10-29-10232.txt 10 3 29 13 0.0055data3-10-29-10233.txt 10 3 29 16 0.0053data3-10-29-10234.txt 10 3 29 10 0.0050data3-10-29-10235.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0055data3-10-29-10236.txt 10 3 29 14 0.0056data3-10-29-10237.txt 10 3 29 15 0.0050data3-10-29-10238.txt 10 3 29 13 0.0057data3-10-29-10239.txt 10 3 29 12 0.0052data3-10-29-10240.txt 10 3 29 18 0.0053data3-10-29-10241.txt 10 3 29 12 0.0056data3-10-29-10242.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0054data3-10-29-10243.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0051data3-10-29-10244.txt 10 3 29 10 0.0055data3-10-29-10245.txt 10 3 29 12 0.0052data3-10-29-10246.txt 10 3 29 14 0.0054data3-10-29-10247.txt 10 3 29 12 0.0057data3-10-29-10248.txt 10 3 29 7 0.0050data3-10-29-10249.txt 10 3 29 7 0.0053data3-10-29-10250.txt 10 3 29 15 0.0055data3-10-29-10251.txt 10 3 29 15 0.0052data3-10-29-10252.txt 10 3 29 10 0.0057data3-10-29-10253.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0053data3-10-29-10254.txt 10 3 29 15 0.0050data3-10-29-10255.txt 10 3 29 14 0.0058data3-10-29-10256.txt 10 3 29 12 0.0056data3-10-29-10257.txt 10 3 29 17 0.0053data3-10-29-10258.txt 10 3 29 10 0.0054data3-10-29-10259.txt 10 3 29 16 0.0051data3-10-29-10260.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0051data3-10-29-10261.txt 10 3 29 10 0.0055data3-10-29-10262.txt 10 3 29 14 0.0056data3-10-29-10263.txt 10 3 29 9 0.0053data3-10-29-10264.txt 10 3 29 16 0.0053data3-10-29-10265.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0050data3-10-29-10266.txt 10 3 29 13 0.0051data3-10-29-10267.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0059data3-10-29-10268.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0054data3-10-29-10269.txt 10 3 29 10 0.0055data3-10-29-10270.txt 10 3 29 12 0.0054

Table 21: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 227: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata3-10-29-10271.txt 10 3 29 12 0.0051data3-10-29-10272.txt 10 3 29 15 0.0052data3-10-29-10273.txt 10 3 29 15 0.0055data3-10-29-10274.txt 10 3 29 13 0.0053data3-10-29-10275.txt 10 3 29 13 0.0055data3-10-29-10276.txt 10 3 29 10 0.0051data3-10-29-10277.txt 10 3 29 13 0.0049data3-10-29-10278.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0059data3-10-29-10279.txt 10 3 29 12 0.0054data3-10-29-10280.txt 10 3 29 13 0.0051data3-10-29-10281.txt 10 3 29 13 0.0055data3-10-29-10282.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0050data3-10-29-10283.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0049data3-10-29-10284.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0056data3-10-29-10285.txt 10 3 29 12 0.0053data3-10-29-10286.txt 10 3 29 12 0.0053data3-10-29-10287.txt 10 3 29 6 0.0055data3-10-29-10288.txt 10 3 29 14 0.0050data3-10-29-10289.txt 10 3 29 14 0.0051data3-10-29-10290.txt 10 3 29 13 0.0058data3-10-29-10291.txt 10 3 29 15 0.0055data3-10-29-10292.txt 10 3 29 15 0.0055data3-10-29-10293.txt 10 3 29 10 0.0053data3-10-29-10294.txt 10 3 29 13 0.0052data3-10-29-10295.txt 10 3 29 10 0.0055data3-10-29-10296.txt 10 3 29 14 0.0053data3-10-29-10297.txt 10 3 29 14 0.0051data3-10-29-10298.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0052data3-10-29-10299.txt 10 3 29 11 0.0052data3-10-29-10300.txt 10 3 29 10 0.0060data4-6-20-00301.txt 6 4 20 11 0.0037data4-6-20-00302.txt 6 4 20 8 0.0036data4-6-20-00303.txt 6 4 20 12 0.0033data4-6-20-00304.txt 6 4 20 11 0.0031data4-6-20-00305.txt 6 4 20 10 0.0033data4-6-20-00306.txt 6 4 20 9 0.0034data4-6-20-00307.txt 6 4 20 15 0.0048data4-6-20-00308.txt 6 4 20 5 0.0032data4-6-20-00309.txt 6 4 20 10 0.0037data4-6-20-00310.txt 6 4 20 10 0.0035data4-6-20-00311.txt 6 4 20 8 0.0035data4-6-20-00312.txt 6 4 20 13 0.0031data4-6-20-00313.txt 6 4 20 9 0.0031data4-6-20-00314.txt 6 4 20 11 0.0033data4-6-20-00315.txt 6 4 20 11 0.0031data4-6-20-00316.txt 6 4 20 9 0.0031data4-6-20-00317.txt 6 4 20 12 0.0032data4-6-20-00318.txt 6 4 20 13 0.0038data4-6-20-00319.txt 6 4 20 8 0.0033data4-6-20-00320.txt 6 4 20 11 0.0036data4-6-20-00321.txt 6 4 20 12 0.0034data4-6-20-00322.txt 6 4 20 9 0.0031data4-6-20-00323.txt 6 4 20 13 0.0034data4-6-20-00324.txt 6 4 20 9 0.0032data4-6-20-00325.txt 6 4 20 13 0.0031data4-6-20-00326.txt 6 4 20 12 0.0033data4-6-20-00327.txt 6 4 20 12 0.0038data4-6-20-00328.txt 6 4 20 11 0.0034data4-6-20-00329.txt 6 4 20 12 0.0034data4-6-20-00330.txt 6 4 20 12 0.0032data4-6-20-00331.txt 6 4 20 9 0.0030data4-6-20-00332.txt 6 4 20 15 0.0032data4-6-20-00333.txt 6 4 20 9 0.0034data4-6-20-00334.txt 6 4 20 14 0.0038data4-6-20-00335.txt 6 4 20 10 0.0033data4-6-20-00336.txt 6 4 20 10 0.0034data4-6-20-00337.txt 6 4 20 9 0.0035data4-6-20-00338.txt 6 4 20 13 0.0037data4-6-20-00339.txt 6 4 20 11 0.0034data4-6-20-00340.txt 6 4 20 13 0.0035

Table 22: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 228: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-6-20-00341.txt 6 4 20 13 0.0033data4-6-20-00342.txt 6 4 20 11 0.0034data4-6-20-00343.txt 6 4 20 12 0.0049data4-6-20-00344.txt 6 4 20 9 0.0035data4-6-20-00345.txt 6 4 20 15 0.0032data4-6-20-00346.txt 6 4 20 10 0.0035data4-6-20-00347.txt 6 4 20 9 0.0037data4-6-20-00348.txt 6 4 20 12 0.0031data4-6-20-00349.txt 6 4 20 13 0.0031data4-6-20-00350.txt 6 4 20 7 0.0034data4-6-20-00351.txt 6 4 20 9 0.0037data4-6-20-00352.txt 6 4 20 10 0.0034data4-6-20-00353.txt 6 4 20 6 0.0034data4-6-20-00354.txt 6 4 20 5 0.0033data4-6-20-00355.txt 6 4 20 5 0.0034data4-6-20-00356.txt 6 4 20 10 0.0033data4-6-20-00357.txt 6 4 20 12 0.0030data4-6-20-00358.txt 6 4 20 10 0.0031data4-6-20-00359.txt 6 4 20 13 0.0035data4-6-20-00360.txt 6 4 20 9 0.0036data4-6-20-00361.txt 6 4 20 11 0.0035data4-6-20-00362.txt 6 4 20 9 0.0036data4-6-20-00363.txt 6 4 20 5 0.0033data4-6-20-00364.txt 6 4 20 12 0.0038data4-6-20-00365.txt 6 4 20 13 0.0039data4-6-20-00366.txt 6 4 20 10 0.0032data4-6-20-00367.txt 6 4 20 11 0.0032data4-6-20-00368.txt 6 4 20 5 0.0034data4-6-20-00369.txt 6 4 20 8 0.0037data4-6-20-00370.txt 6 4 20 14 0.0036data4-6-20-00371.txt 6 4 20 12 0.0032data4-6-20-00372.txt 6 4 20 10 0.0033data4-6-20-00373.txt 6 4 20 10 0.0039data4-6-20-00374.txt 6 4 20 13 0.0034data4-6-20-00375.txt 6 4 20 12 0.0032data4-6-20-00376.txt 6 4 20 12 0.0042data4-6-20-00377.txt 6 4 20 10 0.0038data4-6-20-00378.txt 6 4 20 9 0.0035data4-6-20-00379.txt 6 4 20 10 0.0034data4-6-20-00380.txt 6 4 20 13 0.0031data4-6-20-00381.txt 6 4 20 11 0.0039data4-6-20-00382.txt 6 4 20 13 0.0036data4-6-20-00383.txt 6 4 20 9 0.0031data4-6-20-00384.txt 6 4 20 9 0.0031data4-6-20-00385.txt 6 4 20 12 0.0033data4-6-20-00386.txt 6 4 20 6 0.0039data4-6-20-00387.txt 6 4 20 7 0.0034data4-6-20-00388.txt 6 4 20 11 0.0034data4-6-20-00389.txt 6 4 20 9 0.0033data4-6-20-00390.txt 6 4 20 14 0.0034data4-6-20-00391.txt 6 4 20 12 0.0037data4-6-20-00392.txt 6 4 20 11 0.0033data4-6-20-00393.txt 6 4 20 12 0.0031data4-6-20-00394.txt 6 4 20 13 0.0030data4-6-20-00395.txt 6 4 20 11 0.0039data4-6-20-00396.txt 6 4 20 14 0.0032data4-6-20-00397.txt 6 4 20 9 0.0033data4-6-20-00398.txt 6 4 20 10 0.0032data4-6-20-00399.txt 6 4 20 11 0.0034data4-6-20-00400.txt 6 4 20 8 0.0036data4-6-21-00401.txt 6 4 21 14 0.0098data4-6-21-00402.txt 6 4 21 15 0.0040data4-6-21-00403.txt 6 4 21 12 0.0036data4-6-21-00404.txt 6 4 21 15 0.0036data4-6-21-00405.txt 6 4 21 14 0.0035data4-6-21-00406.txt 6 4 21 12 0.0037data4-6-21-00407.txt 6 4 21 11 0.0037data4-6-21-00408.txt 6 4 21 12 0.0033data4-6-21-00409.txt 6 4 21 10 0.0031data4-6-21-00410.txt 6 4 21 15 0.0052

Table 23: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 229: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-6-21-00411.txt 6 4 21 16 0.0034data4-6-21-00412.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0036data4-6-21-00413.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0035data4-6-21-00414.txt 6 4 21 8 0.0036data4-6-21-00415.txt 6 4 21 14 0.0036data4-6-21-00416.txt 6 4 21 7 0.0033data4-6-21-00417.txt 6 4 21 15 0.0034data4-6-21-00418.txt 6 4 21 10 0.0036data4-6-21-00419.txt 6 4 21 11 0.0037data4-6-21-00420.txt 6 4 21 10 0.0040data4-6-21-00421.txt 6 4 21 10 0.0037data4-6-21-00422.txt 6 4 21 10 0.0035data4-6-21-00423.txt 6 4 21 10 0.0038data4-6-21-00424.txt 6 4 21 7 0.0033data4-6-21-00425.txt 6 4 21 10 0.0035data4-6-21-00426.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0036data4-6-21-00427.txt 6 4 21 12 0.0049data4-6-21-00428.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0038data4-6-21-00429.txt 6 4 21 18 0.0035data4-6-21-00430.txt 6 4 21 14 0.0033data4-6-21-00431.txt 6 4 21 12 0.0038data4-6-21-00432.txt 6 4 21 9 0.0035data4-6-21-00433.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0034data4-6-21-00434.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0036data4-6-21-00435.txt 6 4 21 9 0.0037data4-6-21-00436.txt 6 4 21 14 0.0039data4-6-21-00437.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0034data4-6-21-00438.txt 6 4 21 12 0.0034data4-6-21-00439.txt 6 4 21 8 0.0035data4-6-21-00440.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0035data4-6-21-00441.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0033data4-6-21-00442.txt 6 4 21 14 0.0035data4-6-21-00443.txt 6 4 21 12 0.0037data4-6-21-00444.txt 6 4 21 14 0.0042data4-6-21-00445.txt 6 4 21 15 0.0038data4-6-21-00446.txt 6 4 21 15 0.0034data4-6-21-00447.txt 6 4 21 10 0.0034data4-6-21-00448.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0038data4-6-21-00449.txt 6 4 21 15 0.0036data4-6-21-00450.txt 6 4 21 15 0.0035data4-6-21-00451.txt 6 4 21 10 0.0033data4-6-21-00452.txt 6 4 21 12 0.0040data4-6-21-00453.txt 6 4 21 15 0.0039data4-6-21-00454.txt 6 4 21 15 0.0033data4-6-21-00455.txt 6 4 21 10 0.0033data4-6-21-00456.txt 6 4 21 12 0.0036data4-6-21-00457.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0337data4-6-21-00458.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0035data4-6-21-00459.txt 6 4 21 16 0.0037data4-6-21-00460.txt 6 4 21 14 0.0034data4-6-21-00461.txt 6 4 21 12 0.0036data4-6-21-00462.txt 6 4 21 11 0.0038data4-6-21-00463.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0034data4-6-21-00464.txt 6 4 21 7 0.0033data4-6-21-00465.txt 6 4 21 11 0.0034data4-6-21-00466.txt 6 4 21 12 0.0036data4-6-21-00467.txt 6 4 21 15 0.0040data4-6-21-00468.txt 6 4 21 9 0.0032data4-6-21-00469.txt 6 4 21 18 0.0046data4-6-21-00470.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0038data4-6-21-00471.txt 6 4 21 14 0.0033data4-6-21-00472.txt 6 4 21 10 0.0033data4-6-21-00473.txt 6 4 21 18 0.0038data4-6-21-00474.txt 6 4 21 9 0.0035data4-6-21-00475.txt 6 4 21 6 0.0035data4-6-21-00476.txt 6 4 21 17 0.0034data4-6-21-00477.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0037data4-6-21-00478.txt 6 4 21 14 0.0033data4-6-21-00479.txt 6 4 21 8 0.0037data4-6-21-00480.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0033

Table 24: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 230: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-6-21-00481.txt 6 4 21 11 0.0032data4-6-21-00482.txt 6 4 21 10 0.0035data4-6-21-00483.txt 6 4 21 9 0.0048data4-6-21-00484.txt 6 4 21 15 0.0035data4-6-21-00485.txt 6 4 21 10 0.0036data4-6-21-00486.txt 6 4 21 18 0.0037data4-6-21-00487.txt 6 4 21 8 0.0037data4-6-21-00488.txt 6 4 21 10 0.0033data4-6-21-00489.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0031data4-6-21-00490.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0035data4-6-21-00491.txt 6 4 21 10 0.0034data4-6-21-00492.txt 6 4 21 12 0.0034data4-6-21-00493.txt 6 4 21 15 0.0036data4-6-21-00494.txt 6 4 21 12 0.0035data4-6-21-00495.txt 6 4 21 12 0.0033data4-6-21-00496.txt 6 4 21 15 0.0035data4-6-21-00497.txt 6 4 21 14 0.0034data4-6-21-00498.txt 6 4 21 10 0.0034data4-6-21-00499.txt 6 4 21 12 0.0034data4-6-21-00500.txt 6 4 21 13 0.0039data4-6-22-00501.txt 6 4 22 12 0.0038data4-6-22-00502.txt 6 4 22 17 0.0038data4-6-22-00503.txt 6 4 22 14 0.0035data4-6-22-00504.txt 6 4 22 16 0.0037data4-6-22-00505.txt 6 4 22 18 0.0047data4-6-22-00506.txt 6 4 22 15 0.0035data4-6-22-00507.txt 6 4 22 14 0.0040data4-6-22-00508.txt 6 4 22 11 0.0039data4-6-22-00509.txt 6 4 22 19 0.0037data4-6-22-00510.txt 6 4 22 10 0.0037data4-6-22-00511.txt 6 4 22 13 0.0036data4-6-22-00512.txt 6 4 22 15 0.0039data4-6-22-00513.txt 6 4 22 15 0.0037data4-6-22-00514.txt 6 4 22 10 0.0034data4-6-22-00515.txt 6 4 22 15 0.0037data4-6-22-00516.txt 6 4 22 17 0.0040data4-6-22-00517.txt 6 4 22 16 0.0041data4-6-22-00518.txt 6 4 22 17 0.0038data4-6-22-00519.txt 6 4 22 16 0.0035data4-6-22-00520.txt 6 4 22 14 0.0036data4-6-22-00521.txt 6 4 22 9 0.0037data4-6-22-00522.txt 6 4 22 9 0.0035data4-6-22-00523.txt 6 4 22 12 0.0036data4-6-22-00524.txt 6 4 22 18 0.0038data4-6-22-00525.txt 6 4 22 15 0.0037data4-6-22-00526.txt 6 4 22 14 0.0039data4-6-22-00527.txt 6 4 22 17 0.0037data4-6-22-00528.txt 6 4 22 11 0.0034data4-6-22-00529.txt 6 4 22 14 0.0040data4-6-22-00530.txt 6 4 22 17 0.0035data4-6-22-00531.txt 6 4 22 10 0.0037data4-6-22-00532.txt 6 4 22 12 0.0038data4-6-22-00533.txt 6 4 22 9 0.0039data4-6-22-00534.txt 6 4 22 11 0.0035data4-6-22-00535.txt 6 4 22 14 0.0038data4-6-22-00536.txt 6 4 22 10 0.0034data4-6-22-00537.txt 6 4 22 14 0.0038data4-6-22-00538.txt 6 4 22 13 0.0036data4-6-22-00539.txt 6 4 22 18 0.0042data4-6-22-00540.txt 6 4 22 13 0.0038data4-6-22-00541.txt 6 4 22 15 0.0040data4-6-22-00542.txt 6 4 22 13 0.0039data4-6-22-00543.txt 6 4 22 12 0.0036data4-6-22-00544.txt 6 4 22 15 0.0035data4-6-22-00545.txt 6 4 22 15 0.0038data4-6-22-00546.txt 6 4 22 16 0.0035data4-6-22-00547.txt 6 4 22 10 0.0037data4-6-22-00548.txt 6 4 22 10 0.0038data4-6-22-00549.txt 6 4 22 15 0.0044data4-6-22-00550.txt 6 4 22 17 0.0035

Table 25: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 231: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-6-22-00551.txt 6 4 22 11 0.0034data4-6-22-00552.txt 6 4 22 10 0.0036data4-6-22-00553.txt 6 4 22 12 0.0038data4-6-22-00554.txt 6 4 22 14 0.0039data4-6-22-00555.txt 6 4 22 14 0.0038data4-6-22-00556.txt 6 4 22 14 0.0040data4-6-22-00557.txt 6 4 22 15 0.0037data4-6-22-00558.txt 6 4 22 8 0.0036data4-6-22-00559.txt 6 4 22 15 0.0036data4-6-22-00560.txt 6 4 22 13 0.0035data4-6-22-00561.txt 6 4 22 6 0.0035data4-6-22-00562.txt 6 4 22 15 0.0036data4-6-22-00563.txt 6 4 22 15 0.0038data4-6-22-00564.txt 6 4 22 14 0.0039data4-6-22-00565.txt 6 4 22 13 0.0037data4-6-22-00566.txt 6 4 22 13 0.0035data4-6-22-00567.txt 6 4 22 11 0.0034data4-6-22-00568.txt 6 4 22 15 0.0035data4-6-22-00569.txt 6 4 22 13 0.0035data4-6-22-00570.txt 6 4 22 9 0.0035data4-6-22-00571.txt 6 4 22 16 0.0037data4-6-22-00572.txt 6 4 22 10 0.0040data4-6-22-00573.txt 6 4 22 11 0.0040data4-6-22-00574.txt 6 4 22 16 0.0038data4-6-22-00575.txt 6 4 22 13 0.0037data4-6-22-00576.txt 6 4 22 10 0.0034data4-6-22-00577.txt 6 4 22 12 0.0035data4-6-22-00578.txt 6 4 22 17 0.0036data4-6-22-00579.txt 6 4 22 14 0.0037data4-6-22-00580.txt 6 4 22 15 0.0043data4-6-22-00581.txt 6 4 22 16 0.0044data4-6-22-00582.txt 6 4 22 12 0.0037data4-6-22-00583.txt 6 4 22 12 0.0033data4-6-22-00584.txt 6 4 22 16 0.0035data4-6-22-00585.txt 6 4 22 15 0.0033data4-6-22-00586.txt 6 4 22 12 0.0034data4-6-22-00587.txt 6 4 22 17 0.0037data4-6-22-00588.txt 6 4 22 16 0.0041data4-6-22-00589.txt 6 4 22 10 0.0039data4-6-22-00590.txt 6 4 22 12 0.0035data4-6-22-00591.txt 6 4 22 20 0.0035data4-6-22-00592.txt 6 4 22 12 0.0035data4-6-22-00593.txt 6 4 22 13 0.0033data4-6-22-00594.txt 6 4 22 18 0.0034data4-6-22-00595.txt 6 4 22 16 0.0038data4-6-22-00596.txt 6 4 22 15 0.0043data4-6-22-00597.txt 6 4 22 13 0.0038data4-6-22-00598.txt 6 4 22 16 0.0036data4-6-22-00599.txt 6 4 22 14 0.0037data4-6-22-00600.txt 6 4 22 13 0.0036data4-6-23-00601.txt 6 4 23 11 0.0034data4-6-23-00602.txt 6 4 23 14 0.0034data4-6-23-00603.txt 6 4 23 11 0.0038data4-6-23-00604.txt 6 4 23 8 0.0042data4-6-23-00605.txt 6 4 23 15 0.0073data4-6-23-00606.txt 6 4 23 9 0.0039data4-6-23-00607.txt 6 4 23 8 0.0035data4-6-23-00608.txt 6 4 23 11 0.0035data4-6-23-00609.txt 6 4 23 14 0.0034data4-6-23-00610.txt 6 4 23 13 0.0040data4-6-23-00611.txt 6 4 23 13 0.0042data4-6-23-00612.txt 6 4 23 12 0.0040data4-6-23-00613.txt 6 4 23 12 0.0039data4-6-23-00614.txt 6 4 23 18 0.0038data4-6-23-00615.txt 6 4 23 8 0.0035data4-6-23-00616.txt 6 4 23 14 0.0036data4-6-23-00617.txt 6 4 23 17 0.0038data4-6-23-00618.txt 6 4 23 15 0.0042data4-6-23-00619.txt 6 4 23 12 0.0039data4-6-23-00620.txt 6 4 23 14 0.0040

Table 26: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 232: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-6-23-00621.txt 6 4 23 17 0.0036data4-6-23-00622.txt 6 4 23 12 0.0039data4-6-23-00623.txt 6 4 23 16 0.0036data4-6-23-00624.txt 6 4 23 14 0.0036data4-6-23-00625.txt 6 4 23 18 0.0049data4-6-23-00626.txt 6 4 23 9 0.0043data4-6-23-00627.txt 6 4 23 16 0.0041data4-6-23-00628.txt 6 4 23 13 0.0036data4-6-23-00629.txt 6 4 23 11 0.0035data4-6-23-00630.txt 6 4 23 15 0.0043data4-6-23-00631.txt 6 4 23 14 0.0034data4-6-23-00632.txt 6 4 23 13 0.0037data4-6-23-00633.txt 6 4 23 12 0.0041data4-6-23-00634.txt 6 4 23 13 0.0040data4-6-23-00635.txt 6 4 23 11 0.0042data4-6-23-00636.txt 6 4 23 15 0.0038data4-6-23-00637.txt 6 4 23 17 0.0035data4-6-23-00638.txt 6 4 23 17 0.0041data4-6-23-00639.txt 6 4 23 18 0.0036data4-6-23-00640.txt 6 4 23 16 0.0035data4-6-23-00641.txt 6 4 23 14 0.0043data4-6-23-00642.txt 6 4 23 11 0.0039data4-6-23-00643.txt 6 4 23 21 0.0043data4-6-23-00644.txt 6 4 23 14 0.0036data4-6-23-00645.txt 6 4 23 15 0.0036data4-6-23-00646.txt 6 4 23 12 0.0036data4-6-23-00647.txt 6 4 23 15 0.0037data4-6-23-00648.txt 6 4 23 14 0.0038data4-6-23-00649.txt 6 4 23 17 0.0043data4-6-23-00650.txt 6 4 23 19 0.0045data4-6-23-00651.txt 6 4 23 11 0.0038data4-6-23-00652.txt 6 4 23 19 0.0036data4-6-23-00653.txt 6 4 23 13 0.0036data4-6-23-00654.txt 6 4 23 14 0.0038data4-6-23-00655.txt 6 4 23 14 0.0036data4-6-23-00656.txt 6 4 23 12 0.0040data4-6-23-00657.txt 6 4 23 16 0.0042data4-6-23-00658.txt 6 4 23 11 0.0042data4-6-23-00659.txt 6 4 23 15 0.0038data4-6-23-00660.txt 6 4 23 17 0.0038data4-6-23-00661.txt 6 4 23 14 0.0035data4-6-23-00662.txt 6 4 23 13 0.0036data4-6-23-00663.txt 6 4 23 12 0.0036data4-6-23-00664.txt 6 4 23 18 0.0038data4-6-23-00665.txt 6 4 23 13 0.0040data4-6-23-00666.txt 6 4 23 15 0.0040data4-6-23-00667.txt 6 4 23 13 0.0037data4-6-23-00668.txt 6 4 23 14 0.0036data4-6-23-00669.txt 6 4 23 12 0.0036data4-6-23-00670.txt 6 4 23 14 0.0036data4-6-23-00671.txt 6 4 23 12 0.0035data4-6-23-00672.txt 6 4 23 10 0.0042data4-6-23-00673.txt 6 4 23 13 0.0039data4-6-23-00674.txt 6 4 23 13 0.0041data4-6-23-00675.txt 6 4 23 12 0.0037data4-6-23-00676.txt 6 4 23 16 0.0039data4-6-23-00677.txt 6 4 23 13 0.0037data4-6-23-00678.txt 6 4 23 11 0.0036data4-6-23-00679.txt 6 4 23 15 0.0035data4-6-23-00680.txt 6 4 23 13 0.0043data4-6-23-00681.txt 6 4 23 10 0.0041data4-6-23-00682.txt 6 4 23 17 0.0041data4-6-23-00683.txt 6 4 23 8 0.0036data4-6-23-00684.txt 6 4 23 11 0.0039data4-6-23-00685.txt 6 4 23 12 0.0035data4-6-23-00686.txt 6 4 23 13 0.0038data4-6-23-00687.txt 6 4 23 9 0.0040data4-6-23-00688.txt 6 4 23 13 0.0041data4-6-23-00689.txt 6 4 23 14 0.0040data4-6-23-00690.txt 6 4 23 14 0.0039

Table 27: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 233: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-6-23-00691.txt 6 4 23 17 0.0036data4-6-23-00692.txt 6 4 23 20 0.0039data4-6-23-00693.txt 6 4 23 11 0.0036data4-6-23-00694.txt 6 4 23 15 0.0038data4-6-23-00695.txt 6 4 23 12 0.0039data4-6-23-00696.txt 6 4 23 14 0.0040data4-6-23-00697.txt 6 4 23 11 0.0047data4-6-23-00698.txt 6 4 23 12 0.0037data4-6-23-00699.txt 6 4 23 9 0.0036data4-6-23-00700.txt 6 4 23 15 0.0035data4-7-24-02801.txt 7 4 24 12 0.0046data4-7-24-02802.txt 7 4 24 11 0.0042data4-7-24-02803.txt 7 4 24 15 0.0044data4-7-24-02804.txt 7 4 24 14 0.0042data4-7-24-02805.txt 7 4 24 13 0.0040data4-7-24-02806.txt 7 4 24 9 0.0039data4-7-24-02807.txt 7 4 24 11 0.0038data4-7-24-02808.txt 7 4 24 14 0.0038data4-7-24-02809.txt 7 4 24 19 0.0065data4-7-24-02810.txt 7 4 24 12 0.0042data4-7-24-02811.txt 7 4 24 7 0.0042data4-7-24-02812.txt 7 4 24 13 0.0044data4-7-24-02813.txt 7 4 24 15 0.0040data4-7-24-02814.txt 7 4 24 13 0.0049data4-7-24-02815.txt 7 4 24 13 0.0040data4-7-24-02816.txt 7 4 24 16 0.0046data4-7-24-02817.txt 7 4 24 15 0.0045data4-7-24-02818.txt 7 4 24 17 0.0041data4-7-24-02819.txt 7 4 24 12 0.0041data4-7-24-02820.txt 7 4 24 15 0.0047data4-7-24-02821.txt 7 4 24 13 0.0038data4-7-24-02822.txt 7 4 24 13 0.0038data4-7-24-02823.txt 7 4 24 15 0.0046data4-7-24-02824.txt 7 4 24 12 0.0041data4-7-24-02825.txt 7 4 24 8 0.0040data4-7-24-02826.txt 7 4 24 8 0.0036data4-7-24-02827.txt 7 4 24 9 0.0039data4-7-24-02828.txt 7 4 24 11 0.0038data4-7-24-02829.txt 7 4 24 12 0.0038data4-7-24-02830.txt 7 4 24 11 0.0042data4-7-24-02831.txt 7 4 24 13 0.0044data4-7-24-02832.txt 7 4 24 15 0.0043data4-7-24-02833.txt 7 4 24 17 0.0040data4-7-24-02834.txt 7 4 24 12 0.0064data4-7-24-02835.txt 7 4 24 12 0.0037data4-7-24-02836.txt 7 4 24 16 0.0038data4-7-24-02837.txt 7 4 24 13 0.0042data4-7-24-02838.txt 7 4 24 11 0.0043data4-7-24-02839.txt 7 4 24 12 0.0040data4-7-24-02840.txt 7 4 24 13 0.0040data4-7-24-02841.txt 7 4 24 11 0.0038data4-7-24-02842.txt 7 4 24 12 0.0038data4-7-24-02843.txt 7 4 24 16 0.0038data4-7-24-02844.txt 7 4 24 12 0.0041data4-7-24-02845.txt 7 4 24 17 0.0043data4-7-24-02846.txt 7 4 24 9 0.0044data4-7-24-02847.txt 7 4 24 9 0.0040data4-7-24-02848.txt 7 4 24 16 0.0304data4-7-24-02849.txt 7 4 24 16 0.0043data4-7-24-02850.txt 7 4 24 16 0.0042data4-7-24-02851.txt 7 4 24 16 0.0037data4-7-24-02852.txt 7 4 24 14 0.0038data4-7-24-02853.txt 7 4 24 15 0.0047data4-7-24-02854.txt 7 4 24 14 0.0044data4-7-24-02855.txt 7 4 24 14 0.0051data4-7-24-02856.txt 7 4 24 6 0.0039data4-7-24-02857.txt 7 4 24 11 0.0039data4-7-24-02858.txt 7 4 24 13 0.0040data4-7-24-02859.txt 7 4 24 14 0.0042data4-7-24-02860.txt 7 4 24 12 0.0044

Table 28: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 234: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-7-24-02861.txt 7 4 24 13 0.0043data4-7-24-02862.txt 7 4 24 11 0.0040data4-7-24-02863.txt 7 4 24 12 0.0037data4-7-24-02864.txt 7 4 24 7 0.0038data4-7-24-02865.txt 7 4 24 13 0.0038data4-7-24-02866.txt 7 4 24 14 0.0040data4-7-24-02867.txt 7 4 24 15 0.0046data4-7-24-02868.txt 7 4 24 16 0.0044data4-7-24-02869.txt 7 4 24 11 0.0040data4-7-24-02870.txt 7 4 24 14 0.0040data4-7-24-02871.txt 7 4 24 15 0.0038data4-7-24-02872.txt 7 4 24 14 0.0048data4-7-24-02873.txt 7 4 24 14 0.0050data4-7-24-02874.txt 7 4 24 14 0.0046data4-7-24-02875.txt 7 4 24 16 0.0046data4-7-24-02876.txt 7 4 24 17 0.0041data4-7-24-02877.txt 7 4 24 11 0.0044data4-7-24-02878.txt 7 4 24 13 0.0039data4-7-24-02879.txt 7 4 24 11 0.0039data4-7-24-02880.txt 7 4 24 11 0.0042data4-7-24-02881.txt 7 4 24 17 0.0044data4-7-24-02882.txt 7 4 24 13 0.0043data4-7-24-02883.txt 7 4 24 10 0.0043data4-7-24-02884.txt 7 4 24 13 0.0039data4-7-24-02885.txt 7 4 24 14 0.0040data4-7-24-02886.txt 7 4 24 15 0.0037data4-7-24-02887.txt 7 4 24 11 0.0043data4-7-24-02888.txt 7 4 24 14 0.0043data4-7-24-02889.txt 7 4 24 10 0.0042data4-7-24-02890.txt 7 4 24 13 0.0051data4-7-24-02891.txt 7 4 24 12 0.0039data4-7-24-02892.txt 7 4 24 14 0.0040data4-7-24-02893.txt 7 4 24 10 0.0039data4-7-24-02894.txt 7 4 24 10 0.0042data4-7-24-02895.txt 7 4 24 13 0.0043data4-7-24-02896.txt 7 4 24 13 0.0041data4-7-24-02897.txt 7 4 24 10 0.0040data4-7-24-02898.txt 7 4 24 14 0.0041data4-7-24-02899.txt 7 4 24 15 0.0039data4-7-24-02900.txt 7 4 24 10 0.0040data4-7-25-02901.txt 7 4 25 7 0.0044data4-7-25-02902.txt 7 4 25 18 0.0046data4-7-25-02903.txt 7 4 25 18 0.0047data4-7-25-02904.txt 7 4 25 20 0.0046data4-7-25-02905.txt 7 4 25 17 0.0046data4-7-25-02906.txt 7 4 25 15 0.0043data4-7-25-02907.txt 7 4 25 15 0.0041data4-7-25-02908.txt 7 4 25 13 0.0045data4-7-25-02909.txt 7 4 25 11 0.0048data4-7-25-02910.txt 7 4 25 17 0.0050data4-7-25-02911.txt 7 4 25 12 0.0040data4-7-25-02912.txt 7 4 25 16 0.0046data4-7-25-02913.txt 7 4 25 15 0.0042data4-7-25-02914.txt 7 4 25 19 0.0053data4-7-25-02915.txt 7 4 25 20 0.0046data4-7-25-02916.txt 7 4 25 15 0.0045data4-7-25-02917.txt 7 4 25 10 0.0041data4-7-25-02918.txt 7 4 25 15 0.0040data4-7-25-02919.txt 7 4 25 14 0.0048data4-7-25-02920.txt 7 4 25 11 0.0040data4-7-25-02921.txt 7 4 25 10 0.0044data4-7-25-02922.txt 7 4 25 14 0.0051data4-7-25-02923.txt 7 4 25 21 0.0172data4-7-25-02924.txt 7 4 25 16 0.0042data4-7-25-02925.txt 7 4 25 11 0.0046data4-7-25-02926.txt 7 4 25 14 0.0045data4-7-25-02927.txt 7 4 25 18 0.0046data4-7-25-02928.txt 7 4 25 14 0.0041data4-7-25-02929.txt 7 4 25 10 0.0040data4-7-25-02930.txt 7 4 25 11 0.0046

Table 29: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 235: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-7-25-02931.txt 7 4 25 12 0.0051data4-7-25-02932.txt 7 4 25 14 0.0045data4-7-25-02933.txt 7 4 25 16 0.0044data4-7-25-02934.txt 7 4 25 12 0.0044data4-7-25-02935.txt 7 4 25 15 0.0040data4-7-25-02936.txt 7 4 25 16 0.0044data4-7-25-02937.txt 7 4 25 10 0.0044data4-7-25-02938.txt 7 4 25 14 0.0046data4-7-25-02939.txt 7 4 25 15 0.0044data4-7-25-02940.txt 7 4 25 15 0.0049data4-7-25-02941.txt 7 4 25 16 0.0042data4-7-25-02942.txt 7 4 25 18 0.0042data4-7-25-02943.txt 7 4 25 16 0.0042data4-7-25-02944.txt 7 4 25 12 0.0044data4-7-25-02945.txt 7 4 25 13 0.0044data4-7-25-02946.txt 7 4 25 16 0.0043data4-7-25-02947.txt 7 4 25 11 0.0047data4-7-25-02948.txt 7 4 25 17 0.0172data4-7-25-02949.txt 7 4 25 13 0.0044data4-7-25-02950.txt 7 4 25 15 0.0043data4-7-25-02951.txt 7 4 25 12 0.0045data4-7-25-02952.txt 7 4 25 16 0.0046data4-7-25-02953.txt 7 4 25 17 0.0041data4-7-25-02954.txt 7 4 25 11 0.0044data4-7-25-02955.txt 7 4 25 15 0.0047data4-7-25-02956.txt 7 4 25 16 0.0044data4-7-25-02957.txt 7 4 25 13 0.0043data4-7-25-02958.txt 7 4 25 13 0.0050data4-7-25-02959.txt 7 4 25 12 0.0042data4-7-25-02960.txt 7 4 25 12 0.0041data4-7-25-02961.txt 7 4 25 18 0.0043data4-7-25-02962.txt 7 4 25 16 0.0045data4-7-25-02963.txt 7 4 25 13 0.0040data4-7-25-02964.txt 7 4 25 13 0.0041data4-7-25-02965.txt 7 4 25 12 0.0043data4-7-25-02966.txt 7 4 25 13 0.0044data4-7-25-02967.txt 7 4 25 15 0.0040data4-7-25-02968.txt 7 4 25 20 0.0043data4-7-25-02969.txt 7 4 25 9 0.0047data4-7-25-02970.txt 7 4 25 12 0.0046data4-7-25-02971.txt 7 4 25 18 0.0043data4-7-25-02972.txt 7 4 25 22 0.0043data4-7-25-02973.txt 7 4 25 16 0.0044data4-7-25-02974.txt 7 4 25 10 0.0040data4-7-25-02975.txt 7 4 25 18 0.0045data4-7-25-02976.txt 7 4 25 12 0.0047data4-7-25-02977.txt 7 4 25 15 0.0048data4-7-25-02978.txt 7 4 25 9 0.0042data4-7-25-02979.txt 7 4 25 15 0.0046data4-7-25-02980.txt 7 4 25 14 0.0042data4-7-25-02981.txt 7 4 25 15 0.0039data4-7-25-02982.txt 7 4 25 11 0.0044data4-7-25-02983.txt 7 4 25 13 0.0047data4-7-25-02984.txt 7 4 25 14 0.0044data4-7-25-02985.txt 7 4 25 16 0.0042data4-7-25-02986.txt 7 4 25 19 0.0046data4-7-25-02987.txt 7 4 25 15 0.0043data4-7-25-02988.txt 7 4 25 12 0.0038data4-7-25-02989.txt 7 4 25 11 0.0046data4-7-25-02990.txt 7 4 25 17 0.0050data4-7-25-02991.txt 7 4 25 13 0.0043data4-7-25-02992.txt 7 4 25 14 0.0041data4-7-25-02993.txt 7 4 25 15 0.0045data4-7-25-02994.txt 7 4 25 20 0.0043data4-7-25-02995.txt 7 4 25 10 0.0041data4-7-25-02996.txt 7 4 25 13 0.0044data4-7-25-02997.txt 7 4 25 12 0.0044data4-7-25-02998.txt 7 4 25 13 0.0041data4-7-25-02999.txt 7 4 25 15 0.0042data4-7-25-03000.txt 7 4 25 13 0.0044

Table 30: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 236: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-7-26-03001.txt 7 4 26 16 0.0047data4-7-26-03002.txt 7 4 26 20 0.0074data4-7-26-03003.txt 7 4 26 12 0.0049data4-7-26-03004.txt 7 4 26 17 0.0049data4-7-26-03005.txt 7 4 26 13 0.0045data4-7-26-03006.txt 7 4 26 11 0.0048data4-7-26-03007.txt 7 4 26 16 0.0042data4-7-26-03008.txt 7 4 26 11 0.0046data4-7-26-03009.txt 7 4 26 15 0.0047data4-7-26-03010.txt 7 4 26 17 0.0047data4-7-26-03011.txt 7 4 26 15 0.0043data4-7-26-03012.txt 7 4 26 13 0.0043data4-7-26-03013.txt 7 4 26 16 0.0046data4-7-26-03014.txt 7 4 26 14 0.0041data4-7-26-03015.txt 7 4 26 14 0.0046data4-7-26-03016.txt 7 4 26 12 0.0051data4-7-26-03017.txt 7 4 26 13 0.0046data4-7-26-03018.txt 7 4 26 20 0.0042data4-7-26-03019.txt 7 4 26 18 0.0045data4-7-26-03020.txt 7 4 26 13 0.0047data4-7-26-03021.txt 7 4 26 9 0.0046data4-7-26-03022.txt 7 4 26 13 0.0045data4-7-26-03023.txt 7 4 26 16 0.0047data4-7-26-03024.txt 7 4 26 11 0.0044data4-7-26-03025.txt 7 4 26 17 0.0045data4-7-26-03026.txt 7 4 26 13 0.0045data4-7-26-03027.txt 7 4 26 11 0.0048data4-7-26-03028.txt 7 4 26 16 0.0126data4-7-26-03029.txt 7 4 26 18 0.0048data4-7-26-03030.txt 7 4 26 12 0.0043data4-7-26-03031.txt 7 4 26 12 0.0045data4-7-26-03032.txt 7 4 26 11 0.0052data4-7-26-03033.txt 7 4 26 17 0.0046data4-7-26-03034.txt 7 4 26 18 0.0046data4-7-26-03035.txt 7 4 26 13 0.0048data4-7-26-03036.txt 7 4 26 15 0.0044data4-7-26-03037.txt 7 4 26 18 0.0044data4-7-26-03038.txt 7 4 26 12 0.0049data4-7-26-03039.txt 7 4 26 16 0.0046data4-7-26-03040.txt 7 4 26 13 0.0045data4-7-26-03041.txt 7 4 26 15 0.0046data4-7-26-03042.txt 7 4 26 8 0.0045data4-7-26-03043.txt 7 4 26 22 0.0048data4-7-26-03044.txt 7 4 26 19 0.0046data4-7-26-03045.txt 7 4 26 19 0.0049data4-7-26-03046.txt 7 4 26 11 0.0047data4-7-26-03047.txt 7 4 26 18 0.0043data4-7-26-03048.txt 7 4 26 19 0.0044data4-7-26-03049.txt 7 4 26 17 0.0043data4-7-26-03050.txt 7 4 26 11 0.0043data4-7-26-03051.txt 7 4 26 15 0.0043data4-7-26-03052.txt 7 4 26 18 0.0048data4-7-26-03053.txt 7 4 26 12 0.0048data4-7-26-03054.txt 7 4 26 16 0.0045data4-7-26-03055.txt 7 4 26 21 0.0056data4-7-26-03056.txt 7 4 26 10 0.0046data4-7-26-03057.txt 7 4 26 12 0.0045data4-7-26-03058.txt 7 4 26 11 0.0048data4-7-26-03059.txt 7 4 26 16 0.0046data4-7-26-03060.txt 7 4 26 18 0.0042data4-7-26-03061.txt 7 4 26 17 0.0044data4-7-26-03062.txt 7 4 26 23 0.0044data4-7-26-03063.txt 7 4 26 17 0.0044data4-7-26-03064.txt 7 4 26 16 0.0047data4-7-26-03065.txt 7 4 26 12 0.0043data4-7-26-03066.txt 7 4 26 15 0.0047data4-7-26-03067.txt 7 4 26 19 0.0047data4-7-26-03068.txt 7 4 26 20 0.0047data4-7-26-03069.txt 7 4 26 14 0.0046data4-7-26-03070.txt 7 4 26 13 0.0044

Table 31: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 237: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-7-26-03071.txt 7 4 26 18 0.0046data4-7-26-03072.txt 7 4 26 17 0.0048data4-7-26-03073.txt 7 4 26 11 0.0044data4-7-26-03074.txt 7 4 26 10 0.0045data4-7-26-03075.txt 7 4 26 12 0.0047data4-7-26-03076.txt 7 4 26 10 0.0044data4-7-26-03077.txt 7 4 26 19 0.0046data4-7-26-03078.txt 7 4 26 13 0.0047data4-7-26-03079.txt 7 4 26 14 0.0045data4-7-26-03080.txt 7 4 26 15 0.0045data4-7-26-03081.txt 7 4 26 22 0.0042data4-7-26-03082.txt 7 4 26 25 0.0051data4-7-26-03083.txt 7 4 26 12 0.0050data4-7-26-03084.txt 7 4 26 12 0.0044data4-7-26-03085.txt 7 4 26 11 0.0046data4-7-26-03086.txt 7 4 26 14 0.0047data4-7-26-03087.txt 7 4 26 16 0.0043data4-7-26-03088.txt 7 4 26 13 0.0046data4-7-26-03089.txt 7 4 26 16 0.0045data4-7-26-03090.txt 7 4 26 17 0.0047data4-7-26-03091.txt 7 4 26 14 0.0045data4-7-26-03092.txt 7 4 26 14 0.0045data4-7-26-03093.txt 7 4 26 9 0.0043data4-7-26-03094.txt 7 4 26 14 0.0050data4-7-26-03095.txt 7 4 26 15 0.0045data4-7-26-03096.txt 7 4 26 12 0.0048data4-7-26-03097.txt 7 4 26 12 0.0045data4-7-26-03098.txt 7 4 26 14 0.0054data4-7-26-03099.txt 7 4 26 12 0.0043data4-7-26-03100.txt 7 4 26 14 0.0044data4-7-27-03101.txt 7 4 27 16 0.0045data4-7-27-03102.txt 7 4 27 9 0.0044data4-7-27-03103.txt 7 4 27 13 0.0050data4-7-27-03104.txt 7 4 27 16 0.0047data4-7-27-03105.txt 7 4 27 17 0.0059data4-7-27-03106.txt 7 4 27 13 0.0046data4-7-27-03107.txt 7 4 27 16 0.0044data4-7-27-03108.txt 7 4 27 18 0.0044data4-7-27-03109.txt 7 4 27 16 0.0048data4-7-27-03110.txt 7 4 27 11 0.0046data4-7-27-03111.txt 7 4 27 15 0.0051data4-7-27-03112.txt 7 4 27 19 0.0043data4-7-27-03113.txt 7 4 27 17 0.0046data4-7-27-03114.txt 7 4 27 18 0.0043data4-7-27-03115.txt 7 4 27 19 0.0046data4-7-27-03116.txt 7 4 27 14 0.0049data4-7-27-03117.txt 7 4 27 15 0.0046data4-7-27-03118.txt 7 4 27 15 0.0045data4-7-27-03119.txt 7 4 27 16 0.0046data4-7-27-03120.txt 7 4 27 17 0.0061data4-7-27-03121.txt 7 4 27 12 0.0046data4-7-27-03122.txt 7 4 27 18 0.0047data4-7-27-03123.txt 7 4 27 18 0.0046data4-7-27-03124.txt 7 4 27 11 0.0045data4-7-27-03125.txt 7 4 27 10 0.0043data4-7-27-03126.txt 7 4 27 14 0.0049data4-7-27-03127.txt 7 4 27 23 0.0457data4-7-27-03128.txt 7 4 27 17 0.0043data4-7-27-03129.txt 7 4 27 16 0.0052data4-7-27-03130.txt 7 4 27 19 0.0049data4-7-27-03131.txt 7 4 27 14 0.0044data4-7-27-03132.txt 7 4 27 22 0.0048data4-7-27-03133.txt 7 4 27 18 0.0052data4-7-27-03134.txt 7 4 27 17 0.0049data4-7-27-03135.txt 7 4 27 14 0.0047data4-7-27-03136.txt 7 4 27 13 0.0044data4-7-27-03137.txt 7 4 27 14 0.0042data4-7-27-03138.txt 7 4 27 22 0.0045data4-7-27-03139.txt 7 4 27 14 0.0048data4-7-27-03140.txt 7 4 27 9 0.0046

Table 32: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 238: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-7-27-03141.txt 7 4 27 14 0.0046data4-7-27-03142.txt 7 4 27 11 0.0046data4-7-27-03143.txt 7 4 27 17 0.0042data4-7-27-03144.txt 7 4 27 16 0.0043data4-7-27-03145.txt 7 4 27 11 0.0044data4-7-27-03146.txt 7 4 27 17 0.0049data4-7-27-03147.txt 7 4 27 14 0.0048data4-7-27-03148.txt 7 4 27 16 0.0045data4-7-27-03149.txt 7 4 27 14 0.0045data4-7-27-03150.txt 7 4 27 15 0.0043data4-7-27-03151.txt 7 4 27 22 0.0044data4-7-27-03152.txt 7 4 27 19 0.0055data4-7-27-03153.txt 7 4 27 18 0.0046data4-7-27-03154.txt 7 4 27 14 0.0045data4-7-27-03155.txt 7 4 27 17 0.0044data4-7-27-03156.txt 7 4 27 19 0.0044data4-7-27-03157.txt 7 4 27 17 0.0044data4-7-27-03158.txt 7 4 27 12 0.0046data4-7-27-03159.txt 7 4 27 16 0.0048data4-7-27-03160.txt 7 4 27 19 0.0053data4-7-27-03161.txt 7 4 27 15 0.0051data4-7-27-03162.txt 7 4 27 14 0.0043data4-7-27-03163.txt 7 4 27 9 0.0044data4-7-27-03164.txt 7 4 27 14 0.0045data4-7-27-03165.txt 7 4 27 19 0.0049data4-7-27-03166.txt 7 4 27 17 0.0049data4-7-27-03167.txt 7 4 27 16 0.0047data4-7-27-03168.txt 7 4 27 24 0.0068data4-7-27-03169.txt 7 4 27 18 0.0044data4-7-27-03170.txt 7 4 27 16 0.0069data4-7-27-03171.txt 7 4 27 12 0.0046data4-7-27-03172.txt 7 4 27 13 0.0047data4-7-27-03173.txt 7 4 27 17 0.0046data4-7-27-03174.txt 7 4 27 16 0.0043data4-7-27-03175.txt 7 4 27 20 0.0043data4-7-27-03176.txt 7 4 27 15 0.0050data4-7-27-03177.txt 7 4 27 14 0.0051data4-7-27-03178.txt 7 4 27 18 0.0048data4-7-27-03179.txt 7 4 27 13 0.0046data4-7-27-03180.txt 7 4 27 21 0.0055data4-7-27-03181.txt 7 4 27 19 0.0044data4-7-27-03182.txt 7 4 27 21 0.0050data4-7-27-03183.txt 7 4 27 19 0.0051data4-7-27-03184.txt 7 4 27 13 0.0046data4-7-27-03185.txt 7 4 27 18 0.0047data4-7-27-03186.txt 7 4 27 17 0.0045data4-7-27-03187.txt 7 4 27 17 0.0045data4-7-27-03188.txt 7 4 27 14 0.0046data4-7-27-03189.txt 7 4 27 21 0.0046data4-7-27-03190.txt 7 4 27 14 0.0047data4-7-27-03191.txt 7 4 27 17 0.0045data4-7-27-03192.txt 7 4 27 14 0.0043data4-7-27-03193.txt 7 4 27 14 0.0047data4-7-27-03194.txt 7 4 27 20 0.0044data4-7-27-03195.txt 7 4 27 17 0.0050data4-7-27-03196.txt 7 4 27 17 0.0050data4-7-27-03197.txt 7 4 27 19 0.0046data4-7-27-03198.txt 7 4 27 12 0.0044data4-7-27-03199.txt 7 4 27 20 0.0046data4-7-27-03200.txt 7 4 27 17 0.0047data4-8-28-05301.txt 8 4 28 21 0.0057data4-8-28-05302.txt 8 4 28 13 0.0029data4-8-28-05303.txt 8 4 28 20 0.0659data4-8-28-05304.txt 8 4 28 20 0.0031data4-8-28-05305.txt 8 4 28 20 0.0036data4-8-28-05306.txt 8 4 28 16 0.0029data4-8-28-05307.txt 8 4 28 14 0.0030data4-8-28-05308.txt 8 4 28 12 0.0030data4-8-28-05309.txt 8 4 28 10 0.0027data4-8-28-05310.txt 8 4 28 19 0.0032

Table 33: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 239: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-8-28-05311.txt 8 4 28 11 0.0027data4-8-28-05312.txt 8 4 28 20 0.0031data4-8-28-05313.txt 8 4 28 16 0.0034data4-8-28-05314.txt 8 4 28 19 0.0037data4-8-28-05315.txt 8 4 28 16 0.0030data4-8-28-05316.txt 8 4 28 19 0.0048data4-8-28-05317.txt 8 4 28 17 0.0030data4-8-28-05318.txt 8 4 28 16 0.0028data4-8-28-05319.txt 8 4 28 13 0.0027data4-8-28-05320.txt 8 4 28 15 0.0682data4-8-28-05321.txt 8 4 28 16 0.0027data4-8-28-05322.txt 8 4 28 17 0.0028data4-8-28-05323.txt 8 4 28 14 0.0027data4-8-28-05324.txt 8 4 28 18 0.0033data4-8-28-05325.txt 8 4 28 17 0.0031data4-8-28-05326.txt 8 4 28 13 0.0029data4-8-28-05327.txt 8 4 28 20 0.0036data4-8-28-05328.txt 8 4 28 17 0.0030data4-8-28-05329.txt 8 4 28 18 0.0035data4-8-28-05330.txt 8 4 28 17 0.0035data4-8-28-05331.txt 8 4 28 12 0.0031data4-8-28-05332.txt 8 4 28 11 0.0031data4-8-28-05333.txt 8 4 28 13 0.0029data4-8-28-05334.txt 8 4 28 13 0.0028data4-8-28-05335.txt 8 4 28 15 0.0097data4-8-28-05336.txt 8 4 28 12 0.0027data4-8-28-05337.txt 8 4 28 21 0.0462data4-8-28-05338.txt 8 4 28 13 0.0027data4-8-28-05339.txt 8 4 28 17 0.0029data4-8-28-05340.txt 8 4 28 19 0.0041data4-8-28-05341.txt 8 4 28 13 0.0033data4-8-28-05342.txt 8 4 28 16 0.0031data4-8-28-05343.txt 8 4 28 20 0.0111data4-8-28-05344.txt 8 4 28 11 0.0033data4-8-28-05345.txt 8 4 28 13 0.0029data4-8-28-05346.txt 8 4 28 13 0.0033data4-8-28-05347.txt 8 4 28 16 0.0030data4-8-28-05348.txt 8 4 28 13 0.0027data4-8-28-05349.txt 8 4 28 13 0.0028data4-8-28-05350.txt 8 4 28 14 0.0028data4-8-28-05351.txt 8 4 28 19 0.0028data4-8-28-05352.txt 8 4 28 20 0.0043data4-8-28-05353.txt 8 4 28 20 0.0032data4-8-28-05354.txt 8 4 28 14 0.0033data4-8-28-05355.txt 8 4 28 21 0.0042data4-8-28-05356.txt 8 4 28 15 0.0028data4-8-28-05357.txt 8 4 28 13 0.0034data4-8-28-05358.txt 8 4 28 16 0.0029data4-8-28-05359.txt 8 4 28 19 0.0028data4-8-28-05360.txt 8 4 28 11 0.0029data4-8-28-05361.txt 8 4 28 13 0.0032data4-8-28-05362.txt 8 4 28 16 0.0027data4-8-28-05363.txt 8 4 28 13 0.0041data4-8-28-05364.txt 8 4 28 19 0.0075data4-8-28-05365.txt 8 4 28 14 0.0031data4-8-28-05366.txt 8 4 28 15 0.0031data4-8-28-05367.txt 8 4 28 15 0.0028data4-8-28-05368.txt 8 4 28 15 0.0047data4-8-28-05369.txt 8 4 28 17 0.0028data4-8-28-05370.txt 8 4 28 16 0.0031data4-8-28-05371.txt 8 4 28 11 0.0031data4-8-28-05372.txt 8 4 28 17 0.0032data4-8-28-05373.txt 8 4 28 14 0.0034data4-8-28-05374.txt 8 4 28 12 0.0031data4-8-28-05375.txt 8 4 28 20 0.0027data4-8-28-05376.txt 8 4 28 16 0.0361data4-8-28-05377.txt 8 4 28 18 0.0058data4-8-28-05378.txt 8 4 28 13 0.0027data4-8-28-05379.txt 8 4 28 18 0.0028data4-8-28-05380.txt 8 4 28 13 0.0032

Table 34: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 240: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-8-28-05381.txt 8 4 28 15 0.0031data4-8-28-05382.txt 8 4 28 14 0.0030data4-8-28-05383.txt 8 4 28 17 0.0043data4-8-28-05384.txt 8 4 28 15 0.0032data4-8-28-05385.txt 8 4 28 15 0.0027data4-8-28-05386.txt 8 4 28 16 0.0034data4-8-28-05387.txt 8 4 28 16 0.0028data4-8-28-05388.txt 8 4 28 15 0.0028data4-8-28-05389.txt 8 4 28 19 0.0038data4-8-28-05390.txt 8 4 28 12 0.0033data4-8-28-05391.txt 8 4 28 14 0.0031data4-8-28-05392.txt 8 4 28 16 0.0031data4-8-28-05393.txt 8 4 28 19 0.0038data4-8-28-05394.txt 8 4 28 19 0.0028data4-8-28-05395.txt 8 4 28 20 0.0030data4-8-28-05396.txt 8 4 28 14 0.0028data4-8-28-05397.txt 8 4 28 22 0.0045data4-8-28-05398.txt 8 4 28 14 0.0034data4-8-28-05399.txt 8 4 28 14 0.0037data4-8-28-05400.txt 8 4 28 17 0.0038data4-8-29-05401.txt 8 4 29 18 0.0740data4-8-29-05402.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0026data4-8-29-05403.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0028data4-8-29-05404.txt 8 4 29 23 0.0032data4-8-29-05405.txt 8 4 29 12 0.0031data4-8-29-05406.txt 8 4 29 21 0.0040data4-8-29-05407.txt 8 4 29 12 0.0028data4-8-29-05408.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0029data4-8-29-05409.txt 8 4 29 13 0.0030data4-8-29-05410.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0030data4-8-29-05411.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0033data4-8-29-05412.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0032data4-8-29-05413.txt 8 4 29 19 0.0028data4-8-29-05414.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0029data4-8-29-05415.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0029data4-8-29-05416.txt 8 4 29 14 0.0028data4-8-29-05417.txt 8 4 29 14 0.0027data4-8-29-05418.txt 8 4 29 14 0.0027data4-8-29-05419.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0027data4-8-29-05420.txt 8 4 29 19 0.0049data4-8-29-05421.txt 8 4 29 14 0.0032data4-8-29-05422.txt 8 4 29 13 0.0032data4-8-29-05423.txt 8 4 29 20 0.0028data4-8-29-05424.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0029data4-8-29-05425.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0038data4-8-29-05426.txt 8 4 29 12 0.0028data4-8-29-05427.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0028data4-8-29-05428.txt 8 4 29 16 0.0028data4-8-29-05429.txt 8 4 29 19 0.0032data4-8-29-05430.txt 8 4 29 16 0.0032data4-8-29-05431.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0031data4-8-29-05432.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0031data4-8-29-05433.txt 8 4 29 10 0.0029data4-8-29-05434.txt 8 4 29 13 0.0028data4-8-29-05435.txt 8 4 29 22 0.0027data4-8-29-05436.txt 8 4 29 13 0.0028data4-8-29-05437.txt 8 4 29 21 0.0027data4-8-29-05438.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0028data4-8-29-05439.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0028data4-8-29-05440.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0034data4-8-29-05441.txt 8 4 29 20 0.0034data4-8-29-05442.txt 8 4 29 14 0.0032data4-8-29-05443.txt 8 4 29 11 0.0031data4-8-29-05444.txt 8 4 29 20 0.0034data4-8-29-05445.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0028data4-8-29-05446.txt 8 4 29 19 0.0034data4-8-29-05447.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0028data4-8-29-05448.txt 8 4 29 16 0.0027data4-8-29-05449.txt 8 4 29 20 0.0028data4-8-29-05450.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0034

Table 35: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 241: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-8-29-05451.txt 8 4 29 19 0.0105data4-8-29-05452.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0029data4-8-29-05453.txt 8 4 29 19 0.0037data4-8-29-05454.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0029data4-8-29-05455.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0029data4-8-29-05456.txt 8 4 29 16 0.0028data4-8-29-05457.txt 8 4 29 14 0.0032data4-8-29-05458.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0034data4-8-29-05459.txt 8 4 29 16 0.0054data4-8-29-05460.txt 8 4 29 11 0.0032data4-8-29-05461.txt 8 4 29 12 0.0030data4-8-29-05462.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0029data4-8-29-05463.txt 8 4 29 10 0.0028data4-8-29-05464.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0028data4-8-29-05465.txt 8 4 29 16 0.0028data4-8-29-05466.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0027data4-8-29-05467.txt 8 4 29 20 0.0042data4-8-29-05468.txt 8 4 29 14 0.0034data4-8-29-05469.txt 8 4 29 18 0.0058data4-8-29-05470.txt 8 4 29 19 0.0030data4-8-29-05471.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0027data4-8-29-05472.txt 8 4 29 19 0.0028data4-8-29-05473.txt 8 4 29 19 0.0028data4-8-29-05474.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0029data4-8-29-05475.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0028data4-8-29-05476.txt 8 4 29 18 0.0029data4-8-29-05477.txt 8 4 29 14 0.0033data4-8-29-05478.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0032data4-8-29-05479.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0041data4-8-29-05480.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0030data4-8-29-05481.txt 8 4 29 21 0.0029data4-8-29-05482.txt 8 4 29 14 0.0038data4-8-29-05483.txt 8 4 29 20 0.0029data4-8-29-05484.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0029data4-8-29-05485.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0028data4-8-29-05486.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0045data4-8-29-05487.txt 8 4 29 20 0.0037data4-8-29-05488.txt 8 4 29 14 0.0031data4-8-29-05489.txt 8 4 29 11 0.0031data4-8-29-05490.txt 8 4 29 19 0.0908data4-8-29-05491.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0036data4-8-29-05492.txt 8 4 29 18 0.0032data4-8-29-05493.txt 8 4 29 19 0.0029data4-8-29-05494.txt 8 4 29 15 0.0160data4-8-29-05495.txt 8 4 29 23 0.0034data4-8-29-05496.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0031data4-8-29-05497.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0047data4-8-29-05498.txt 8 4 29 13 0.0032data4-8-29-05499.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0032data4-8-29-05500.txt 8 4 29 17 0.0028data4-8-30-05501.txt 8 4 30 18 0.0205data4-8-30-05502.txt 8 4 30 17 0.0041data4-8-30-05503.txt 8 4 30 15 0.0035data4-8-30-05504.txt 8 4 30 21 0.0030data4-8-30-05505.txt 8 4 30 16 0.0029data4-8-30-05506.txt 8 4 30 18 0.0033data4-8-30-05507.txt 8 4 30 21 0.0028data4-8-30-05508.txt 8 4 30 23 0.0033data4-8-30-05509.txt 8 4 30 18 0.0032data4-8-30-05510.txt 8 4 30 17 0.0030data4-8-30-05511.txt 8 4 30 23 0.0032data4-8-30-05512.txt 8 4 30 17 0.0029data4-8-30-05513.txt 8 4 30 17 0.0032data4-8-30-05514.txt 8 4 30 16 0.0030data4-8-30-05515.txt 8 4 30 13 0.0030data4-8-30-05516.txt 8 4 30 17 0.0034data4-8-30-05517.txt 8 4 30 23 0.0039data4-8-30-05518.txt 8 4 30 16 0.0033data4-8-30-05519.txt 8 4 30 13 0.0030data4-8-30-05520.txt 8 4 30 18 0.0035

Table 36: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 242: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-8-30-05521.txt 8 4 30 13 0.0032data4-8-30-05522.txt 8 4 30 18 0.0030data4-8-30-05523.txt 8 4 30 18 0.0037data4-8-30-05524.txt 8 4 30 20 0.0031data4-8-30-05525.txt 8 4 30 15 0.0032data4-8-30-05526.txt 8 4 30 20 0.0031data4-8-30-05527.txt 8 4 30 18 0.0032data4-8-30-05528.txt 8 4 30 19 0.0033data4-8-30-05529.txt 8 4 30 15 0.0032data4-8-30-05530.txt 8 4 30 12 0.0032data4-8-30-05531.txt 8 4 30 16 0.0031data4-8-30-05532.txt 8 4 30 20 0.0031data4-8-30-05533.txt 8 4 30 20 0.0034data4-8-30-05534.txt 8 4 30 16 0.0030data4-8-30-05535.txt 8 4 30 21 0.0031data4-8-30-05536.txt 8 4 30 19 0.0038data4-8-30-05537.txt 8 4 30 20 0.0032data4-8-30-05538.txt 8 4 30 13 0.0110data4-8-30-05539.txt 8 4 30 16 0.0033data4-8-30-05540.txt 8 4 30 23 0.0034data4-8-30-05541.txt 8 4 30 15 0.0033data4-8-30-05542.txt 8 4 30 20 0.0033data4-8-30-05543.txt 8 4 30 16 0.0033data4-8-30-05544.txt 8 4 30 11 0.0032data4-8-30-05545.txt 8 4 30 18 0.0033data4-8-30-05546.txt 8 4 30 20 0.0033data4-8-30-05547.txt 8 4 30 16 0.0033data4-8-30-05548.txt 8 4 30 16 0.0032data4-8-30-05549.txt 8 4 30 14 0.0030data4-8-30-05550.txt 8 4 30 12 0.0032data4-8-30-05551.txt 8 4 30 19 0.0037data4-8-30-05552.txt 8 4 30 20 0.0033data4-8-30-05553.txt 8 4 30 20 0.0034data4-8-30-05554.txt 8 4 30 17 0.0030data4-8-30-05555.txt 8 4 30 15 0.0035data4-8-30-05556.txt 8 4 30 19 0.0032data4-8-30-05557.txt 8 4 30 19 0.0032data4-8-30-05558.txt 8 4 30 15 0.0028data4-8-30-05559.txt 8 4 30 16 0.0029data4-8-30-05560.txt 8 4 30 20 0.0035data4-8-30-05561.txt 8 4 30 13 0.0030data4-8-30-05562.txt 8 4 30 14 0.0044data4-8-30-05563.txt 8 4 30 22 0.0033data4-8-30-05564.txt 8 4 30 14 0.0030data4-8-30-05565.txt 8 4 30 18 0.0032data4-8-30-05566.txt 8 4 30 16 0.0034data4-8-30-05567.txt 8 4 30 18 0.0031data4-8-30-05568.txt 8 4 30 11 0.0029data4-8-30-05569.txt 8 4 30 18 0.0029data4-8-30-05570.txt 8 4 30 18 0.0033data4-8-30-05571.txt 8 4 30 14 0.0031data4-8-30-05572.txt 8 4 30 16 0.0034data4-8-30-05573.txt 8 4 30 24 0.0035data4-8-30-05574.txt 8 4 30 21 0.0032data4-8-30-05575.txt 8 4 30 20 0.0108data4-8-30-05576.txt 8 4 30 16 0.0029data4-8-30-05577.txt 8 4 30 20 0.0033data4-8-30-05578.txt 8 4 30 19 0.0043data4-8-30-05579.txt 8 4 30 16 0.0034data4-8-30-05580.txt 8 4 30 23 0.0111data4-8-30-05581.txt 8 4 30 16 0.0032data4-8-30-05582.txt 8 4 30 16 0.0031data4-8-30-05583.txt 8 4 30 11 0.0030data4-8-30-05584.txt 8 4 30 22 0.0029data4-8-30-05585.txt 8 4 30 14 0.0031data4-8-30-05586.txt 8 4 30 23 0.0074data4-8-30-05587.txt 8 4 30 13 0.0033data4-8-30-05588.txt 8 4 30 10 0.0031data4-8-30-05589.txt 8 4 30 20 0.0039data4-8-30-05590.txt 8 4 30 17 0.0031

Table 37: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 243: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-8-30-05591.txt 8 4 30 18 0.0030data4-8-30-05592.txt 8 4 30 15 0.0029data4-8-30-05593.txt 8 4 30 14 0.0029data4-8-30-05594.txt 8 4 30 15 0.0033data4-8-30-05595.txt 8 4 30 14 0.0034data4-8-30-05596.txt 8 4 30 19 0.0042data4-8-30-05597.txt 8 4 30 17 0.0033data4-8-30-05598.txt 8 4 30 16 0.0044data4-8-30-05599.txt 8 4 30 10 0.0029data4-8-30-05600.txt 8 4 30 19 0.0031data4-8-31-05601.txt 8 4 31 12 0.0034data4-8-31-05602.txt 8 4 31 19 0.0894data4-8-31-05603.txt 8 4 31 22 0.0034data4-8-31-05604.txt 8 4 31 23 0.0030data4-8-31-05605.txt 8 4 31 23 0.0031data4-8-31-05606.txt 8 4 31 14 0.0033data4-8-31-05607.txt 8 4 31 21 0.0034data4-8-31-05608.txt 8 4 31 15 0.0032data4-8-31-05609.txt 8 4 31 22 0.0053data4-8-31-05610.txt 8 4 31 16 0.0032data4-8-31-05611.txt 8 4 31 15 0.0039data4-8-31-05612.txt 8 4 31 17 0.0035data4-8-31-05613.txt 8 4 31 21 0.0687data4-8-31-05614.txt 8 4 31 18 0.0031data4-8-31-05615.txt 8 4 31 18 0.0028data4-8-31-05616.txt 8 4 31 15 0.0057data4-8-31-05617.txt 8 4 31 21 0.0040data4-8-31-05618.txt 8 4 31 18 0.0030data4-8-31-05619.txt 8 4 31 17 0.0029data4-8-31-05620.txt 8 4 31 16 0.0029data4-8-31-05621.txt 8 4 31 13 0.0035data4-8-31-05622.txt 8 4 31 19 0.0033data4-8-31-05623.txt 8 4 31 13 0.0033data4-8-31-05624.txt 8 4 31 18 0.0032data4-8-31-05625.txt 8 4 31 17 0.0032data4-8-31-05626.txt 8 4 31 14 0.0036data4-8-31-05627.txt 8 4 31 16 0.0029data4-8-31-05628.txt 8 4 31 22 0.0030data4-8-31-05629.txt 8 4 31 15 0.0028data4-8-31-05630.txt 8 4 31 16 0.0032data4-8-31-05631.txt 8 4 31 16 0.0036data4-8-31-05632.txt 8 4 31 17 0.0032data4-8-31-05633.txt 8 4 31 10 0.0032data4-8-31-05634.txt 8 4 31 22 0.0031data4-8-31-05635.txt 8 4 31 17 0.0043data4-8-31-05636.txt 8 4 31 15 0.0035data4-8-31-05637.txt 8 4 31 20 0.0033data4-8-31-05638.txt 8 4 31 18 0.0029data4-8-31-05639.txt 8 4 31 12 0.0028data4-8-31-05640.txt 8 4 31 16 0.0035data4-8-31-05641.txt 8 4 31 22 0.0043data4-8-31-05642.txt 8 4 31 26 0.0151data4-8-31-05643.txt 8 4 31 14 0.0031data4-8-31-05644.txt 8 4 31 13 0.0030data4-8-31-05645.txt 8 4 31 25 0.0031data4-8-31-05646.txt 8 4 31 17 0.0034data4-8-31-05647.txt 8 4 31 19 0.0036data4-8-31-05648.txt 8 4 31 17 0.0032data4-8-31-05649.txt 8 4 31 8 0.0032data4-8-31-05650.txt 8 4 31 18 0.0034data4-8-31-05651.txt 8 4 31 19 0.0030data4-8-31-05652.txt 8 4 31 22 0.0037data4-8-31-05653.txt 8 4 31 17 0.0032data4-8-31-05654.txt 8 4 31 21 0.0070data4-8-31-05655.txt 8 4 31 21 0.0037data4-8-31-05656.txt 8 4 31 19 0.0034data4-8-31-05657.txt 8 4 31 20 0.0036data4-8-31-05658.txt 8 4 31 20 0.0031data4-8-31-05659.txt 8 4 31 19 0.0028data4-8-31-05660.txt 8 4 31 17 0.0036

Table 38: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 244: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-8-31-05661.txt 8 4 31 18 0.0030data4-8-31-05662.txt 8 4 31 18 0.0030data4-8-31-05663.txt 8 4 31 18 0.0043data4-8-31-05664.txt 8 4 31 19 0.0031data4-8-31-05665.txt 8 4 31 12 0.0034data4-8-31-05666.txt 8 4 31 15 0.0033data4-8-31-05667.txt 8 4 31 14 0.0031data4-8-31-05668.txt 8 4 31 19 0.0029data4-8-31-05669.txt 8 4 31 18 0.0029data4-8-31-05670.txt 8 4 31 14 0.0034data4-8-31-05671.txt 8 4 31 17 0.0032data4-8-31-05672.txt 8 4 31 12 0.0031data4-8-31-05673.txt 8 4 31 16 0.0029data4-8-31-05674.txt 8 4 31 18 0.0031data4-8-31-05675.txt 8 4 31 15 0.0034data4-8-31-05676.txt 8 4 31 21 0.0032data4-8-31-05677.txt 8 4 31 16 0.0028data4-8-31-05678.txt 8 4 31 16 0.0030data4-8-31-05679.txt 8 4 31 20 0.0053data4-8-31-05680.txt 8 4 31 23 0.0035data4-8-31-05681.txt 8 4 31 18 0.0041data4-8-31-05682.txt 8 4 31 18 0.0036data4-8-31-05683.txt 8 4 31 17 0.0036data4-8-31-05684.txt 8 4 31 16 0.0061data4-8-31-05685.txt 8 4 31 21 0.0029data4-8-31-05686.txt 8 4 31 16 0.0030data4-8-31-05687.txt 8 4 31 16 0.0039data4-8-31-05688.txt 8 4 31 17 0.0037data4-8-31-05689.txt 8 4 31 21 0.0035data4-8-31-05690.txt 8 4 31 18 0.0040data4-8-31-05691.txt 8 4 31 19 0.0048data4-8-31-05692.txt 8 4 31 19 0.0034data4-8-31-05693.txt 8 4 31 19 0.2264data4-8-31-05694.txt 8 4 31 15 0.0030data4-8-31-05695.txt 8 4 31 18 0.0030data4-8-31-05696.txt 8 4 31 25 0.0079data4-8-31-05697.txt 8 4 31 18 0.0034data4-8-31-05698.txt 8 4 31 21 0.0036data4-8-31-05699.txt 8 4 31 11 0.0030data4-8-31-05700.txt 8 4 31 19 0.0034data4-9-32-07801.txt 9 4 32 17 0.0042data4-9-32-07802.txt 9 4 32 18 0.0034data4-9-32-07803.txt 9 4 32 20 0.0042data4-9-32-07804.txt 9 4 32 18 0.0031data4-9-32-07805.txt 9 4 32 12 0.0031data4-9-32-07806.txt 9 4 32 20 0.0033data4-9-32-07807.txt 9 4 32 17 0.0031data4-9-32-07808.txt 9 4 32 16 0.0032data4-9-32-07809.txt 9 4 32 18 0.0034data4-9-32-07810.txt 9 4 32 16 0.0035data4-9-32-07811.txt 9 4 32 15 0.0075data4-9-32-07812.txt 9 4 32 19 0.0065data4-9-32-07813.txt 9 4 32 17 0.0031data4-9-32-07814.txt 9 4 32 15 0.0030data4-9-32-07815.txt 9 4 32 22 0.0105data4-9-32-07816.txt 9 4 32 10 0.0031data4-9-32-07817.txt 9 4 32 17 0.0035data4-9-32-07818.txt 9 4 32 12 0.0033data4-9-32-07819.txt 9 4 32 22 0.0032data4-9-32-07820.txt 9 4 32 16 0.0030data4-9-32-07821.txt 9 4 32 21 0.0652data4-9-32-07822.txt 9 4 32 17 0.0030data4-9-32-07823.txt 9 4 32 15 0.0031data4-9-32-07824.txt 9 4 32 17 0.0032data4-9-32-07825.txt 9 4 32 17 0.0033data4-9-32-07826.txt 9 4 32 17 0.0035data4-9-32-07827.txt 9 4 32 19 0.0031data4-9-32-07828.txt 9 4 32 17 0.0031data4-9-32-07829.txt 9 4 32 19 0.0032data4-9-32-07830.txt 9 4 32 18 0.0039

Table 39: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 245: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-9-32-07831.txt 9 4 32 16 0.0062data4-9-32-07832.txt 9 4 32 13 0.0033data4-9-32-07833.txt 9 4 32 18 0.0032data4-9-32-07834.txt 9 4 32 13 0.0031data4-9-32-07835.txt 9 4 32 13 0.0031data4-9-32-07836.txt 9 4 32 18 0.0032data4-9-32-07837.txt 9 4 32 15 0.0033data4-9-32-07838.txt 9 4 32 17 0.0037data4-9-32-07839.txt 9 4 32 17 0.0040data4-9-32-07840.txt 9 4 32 15 0.0038data4-9-32-07841.txt 9 4 32 21 0.0047data4-9-32-07842.txt 9 4 32 22 0.0032data4-9-32-07843.txt 9 4 32 15 0.0031data4-9-32-07844.txt 9 4 32 16 0.0030data4-9-32-07845.txt 9 4 32 15 0.0030data4-9-32-07846.txt 9 4 32 17 0.0078data4-9-32-07847.txt 9 4 32 15 0.0032data4-9-32-07848.txt 9 4 32 16 0.0049data4-9-32-07849.txt 9 4 32 16 0.0031data4-9-32-07850.txt 9 4 32 13 0.0030data4-9-32-07851.txt 9 4 32 17 0.0031data4-9-32-07852.txt 9 4 32 14 0.0030data4-9-32-07853.txt 9 4 32 17 0.0031data4-9-32-07854.txt 9 4 32 19 0.0030data4-9-32-07855.txt 9 4 32 15 0.0040data4-9-32-07856.txt 9 4 32 15 0.0032data4-9-32-07857.txt 9 4 32 18 0.0361data4-9-32-07858.txt 9 4 32 16 0.0032data4-9-32-07859.txt 9 4 32 17 0.0030data4-9-32-07860.txt 9 4 32 19 0.0031data4-9-32-07861.txt 9 4 32 21 0.0033data4-9-32-07862.txt 9 4 32 18 0.0040data4-9-32-07863.txt 9 4 32 19 0.0031data4-9-32-07864.txt 9 4 32 19 0.0046data4-9-32-07865.txt 9 4 32 15 0.0032data4-9-32-07866.txt 9 4 32 16 0.0036data4-9-32-07867.txt 9 4 32 20 0.0041data4-9-32-07868.txt 9 4 32 18 0.0029data4-9-32-07869.txt 9 4 32 11 0.0029data4-9-32-07870.txt 9 4 32 18 0.0033data4-9-32-07871.txt 9 4 32 16 0.0035data4-9-32-07872.txt 9 4 32 15 0.0031data4-9-32-07873.txt 9 4 32 9 0.0038data4-9-32-07874.txt 9 4 32 16 0.0036data4-9-32-07875.txt 9 4 32 24 0.0097data4-9-32-07876.txt 9 4 32 17 0.0030data4-9-32-07877.txt 9 4 32 18 0.0037data4-9-32-07878.txt 9 4 32 14 0.0031data4-9-32-07879.txt 9 4 32 19 0.0033data4-9-32-07880.txt 9 4 32 18 0.0035data4-9-32-07881.txt 9 4 32 16 0.0034data4-9-32-07882.txt 9 4 32 14 0.0034data4-9-32-07883.txt 9 4 32 20 0.0034data4-9-32-07884.txt 9 4 32 13 0.0031data4-9-32-07885.txt 9 4 32 19 0.0031data4-9-32-07886.txt 9 4 32 18 0.0032data4-9-32-07887.txt 9 4 32 12 0.0030data4-9-32-07888.txt 9 4 32 16 0.0031data4-9-32-07889.txt 9 4 32 16 0.0062data4-9-32-07890.txt 9 4 32 18 0.0092data4-9-32-07891.txt 9 4 32 14 0.0030data4-9-32-07892.txt 9 4 32 14 0.0043data4-9-32-07893.txt 9 4 32 12 0.0036data4-9-32-07894.txt 9 4 32 22 0.0032data4-9-32-07895.txt 9 4 32 15 0.0030data4-9-32-07896.txt 9 4 32 12 0.0032data4-9-32-07897.txt 9 4 32 18 0.0035data4-9-32-07898.txt 9 4 32 21 0.0183data4-9-32-07899.txt 9 4 32 15 0.0033data4-9-32-07900.txt 9 4 32 16 0.0031

Table 40: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 246: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-9-33-07901.txt 9 4 33 18 0.0065data4-9-33-07902.txt 9 4 33 18 0.0045data4-9-33-07903.txt 9 4 33 14 0.0035data4-9-33-07904.txt 9 4 33 14 0.0032data4-9-33-07905.txt 9 4 33 20 0.0032data4-9-33-07906.txt 9 4 33 19 0.0203data4-9-33-07907.txt 9 4 33 20 0.0035data4-9-33-07908.txt 9 4 33 22 0.0041data4-9-33-07909.txt 9 4 33 20 0.0032data4-9-33-07910.txt 9 4 33 17 0.0031data4-9-33-07911.txt 9 4 33 17 0.0031data4-9-33-07912.txt 9 4 33 17 0.0034data4-9-33-07913.txt 9 4 33 18 0.0034data4-9-33-07914.txt 9 4 33 16 0.0041data4-9-33-07915.txt 9 4 33 16 0.0036data4-9-33-07916.txt 9 4 33 19 0.0032data4-9-33-07917.txt 9 4 33 21 0.0033data4-9-33-07918.txt 9 4 33 24 0.1631data4-9-33-07919.txt 9 4 33 15 0.0032data4-9-33-07920.txt 9 4 33 22 0.0031data4-9-33-07921.txt 9 4 33 14 0.0031data4-9-33-07922.txt 9 4 33 17 0.0036data4-9-33-07923.txt 9 4 33 18 0.0033data4-9-33-07924.txt 9 4 33 18 0.0032data4-9-33-07925.txt 9 4 33 16 0.0032data4-9-33-07926.txt 9 4 33 16 0.0035data4-9-33-07927.txt 9 4 33 22 0.0037data4-9-33-07928.txt 9 4 33 23 0.0042data4-9-33-07929.txt 9 4 33 22 0.0033data4-9-33-07930.txt 9 4 33 21 0.0039data4-9-33-07931.txt 9 4 33 20 0.0739data4-9-33-07932.txt 9 4 33 21 0.0032data4-9-33-07933.txt 9 4 33 18 0.0030data4-9-33-07934.txt 9 4 33 19 0.0030data4-9-33-07935.txt 9 4 33 19 0.0035data4-9-33-07936.txt 9 4 33 21 0.0091data4-9-33-07937.txt 9 4 33 23 0.1604data4-9-33-07938.txt 9 4 33 14 0.0032data4-9-33-07939.txt 9 4 33 19 0.0030data4-9-33-07940.txt 9 4 33 22 0.0032data4-9-33-07941.txt 9 4 33 17 0.0036data4-9-33-07942.txt 9 4 33 20 0.0047data4-9-33-07943.txt 9 4 33 12 0.0032data4-9-33-07944.txt 9 4 33 19 0.0091data4-9-33-07945.txt 9 4 33 18 0.0227data4-9-33-07946.txt 9 4 33 17 0.0032data4-9-33-07947.txt 9 4 33 14 0.0041data4-9-33-07948.txt 9 4 33 21 0.0035data4-9-33-07949.txt 9 4 33 17 0.0036data4-9-33-07950.txt 9 4 33 20 0.0035data4-9-33-07951.txt 9 4 33 16 0.0032data4-9-33-07952.txt 9 4 33 19 0.0035data4-9-33-07953.txt 9 4 33 17 0.0034data4-9-33-07954.txt 9 4 33 15 0.0032data4-9-33-07955.txt 9 4 33 19 0.0206data4-9-33-07956.txt 9 4 33 19 0.0141data4-9-33-07957.txt 9 4 33 21 0.0036data4-9-33-07958.txt 9 4 33 17 0.0034data4-9-33-07959.txt 9 4 33 15 0.0037data4-9-33-07960.txt 9 4 33 23 0.0033data4-9-33-07961.txt 9 4 33 20 0.0046data4-9-33-07962.txt 9 4 33 17 0.0031data4-9-33-07963.txt 9 4 33 15 0.0032data4-9-33-07964.txt 9 4 33 18 0.0034data4-9-33-07965.txt 9 4 33 17 0.0038data4-9-33-07966.txt 9 4 33 21 0.0038data4-9-33-07967.txt 9 4 33 16 0.0035data4-9-33-07968.txt 9 4 33 17 0.0036data4-9-33-07969.txt 9 4 33 17 0.0045data4-9-33-07970.txt 9 4 33 19 0.2524

Table 41: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 247: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-9-33-07971.txt 9 4 33 18 0.0031data4-9-33-07972.txt 9 4 33 19 0.0031data4-9-33-07973.txt 9 4 33 15 0.0031data4-9-33-07974.txt 9 4 33 21 0.0038data4-9-33-07975.txt 9 4 33 19 0.0033data4-9-33-07976.txt 9 4 33 16 0.0036data4-9-33-07977.txt 9 4 33 16 0.0032data4-9-33-07978.txt 9 4 33 15 0.0034data4-9-33-07979.txt 9 4 33 16 0.0036data4-9-33-07980.txt 9 4 33 16 0.0036data4-9-33-07981.txt 9 4 33 23 0.1494data4-9-33-07982.txt 9 4 33 16 0.0031data4-9-33-07983.txt 9 4 33 17 0.0032data4-9-33-07984.txt 9 4 33 22 0.0033data4-9-33-07985.txt 9 4 33 18 0.0039data4-9-33-07986.txt 9 4 33 21 0.0032data4-9-33-07987.txt 9 4 33 25 0.0040data4-9-33-07988.txt 9 4 33 20 0.0033data4-9-33-07989.txt 9 4 33 20 0.0034data4-9-33-07990.txt 9 4 33 16 0.0062data4-9-33-07991.txt 9 4 33 22 0.0046data4-9-33-07992.txt 9 4 33 16 0.0036data4-9-33-07993.txt 9 4 33 23 0.0036data4-9-33-07994.txt 9 4 33 18 0.0032data4-9-33-07995.txt 9 4 33 16 0.0032data4-9-33-07996.txt 9 4 33 22 0.0036data4-9-33-07997.txt 9 4 33 24 0.0041data4-9-33-07998.txt 9 4 33 17 0.0033data4-9-33-07999.txt 9 4 33 22 0.0037data4-9-33-08000.txt 9 4 33 15 0.0032data4-9-34-08001.txt 9 4 34 16 0.0037data4-9-34-08002.txt 9 4 34 23 0.0033data4-9-34-08003.txt 9 4 34 17 0.0032data4-9-34-08004.txt 9 4 34 21 0.0031data4-9-34-08005.txt 9 4 34 14 0.0032data4-9-34-08006.txt 9 4 34 25 0.0038data4-9-34-08007.txt 9 4 34 28 0.0046data4-9-34-08008.txt 9 4 34 11 0.0036data4-9-34-08009.txt 9 4 34 17 0.0034data4-9-34-08010.txt 9 4 34 17 0.0034data4-9-34-08011.txt 9 4 34 20 0.0034data4-9-34-08012.txt 9 4 34 15 0.0032data4-9-34-08013.txt 9 4 34 18 0.0034data4-9-34-08014.txt 9 4 34 17 0.0034data4-9-34-08015.txt 9 4 34 16 0.0042data4-9-34-08016.txt 9 4 34 22 0.0037data4-9-34-08017.txt 9 4 34 20 0.0330data4-9-34-08018.txt 9 4 34 21 0.0035data4-9-34-08019.txt 9 4 34 23 0.0034data4-9-34-08020.txt 9 4 34 19 0.0039data4-9-34-08021.txt 9 4 34 19 0.0032data4-9-34-08022.txt 9 4 34 20 0.0035data4-9-34-08023.txt 9 4 34 22 0.0031data4-9-34-08024.txt 9 4 34 20 0.1205data4-9-34-08025.txt 9 4 34 21 0.0032data4-9-34-08026.txt 9 4 34 20 0.0037data4-9-34-08027.txt 9 4 34 13 0.0032data4-9-34-08028.txt 9 4 34 20 0.0037data4-9-34-08029.txt 9 4 34 17 0.0035data4-9-34-08030.txt 9 4 34 15 0.0032data4-9-34-08031.txt 9 4 34 22 0.0032data4-9-34-08032.txt 9 4 34 18 0.0038data4-9-34-08033.txt 9 4 34 27 0.0039data4-9-34-08034.txt 9 4 34 18 0.0037data4-9-34-08035.txt 9 4 34 16 0.0038data4-9-34-08036.txt 9 4 34 28 0.0035data4-9-34-08037.txt 9 4 34 21 0.0033data4-9-34-08038.txt 9 4 34 22 0.0069data4-9-34-08039.txt 9 4 34 22 0.0038data4-9-34-08040.txt 9 4 34 23 0.0042

Table 42: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 248: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-9-34-08041.txt 9 4 34 16 0.0035data4-9-34-08042.txt 9 4 34 21 0.0102data4-9-34-08043.txt 9 4 34 23 0.0031data4-9-34-08044.txt 9 4 34 17 0.0033data4-9-34-08045.txt 9 4 34 16 0.0031data4-9-34-08046.txt 9 4 34 17 0.0032data4-9-34-08047.txt 9 4 34 20 0.0065data4-9-34-08048.txt 9 4 34 19 0.0038data4-9-34-08049.txt 9 4 34 23 0.0044data4-9-34-08050.txt 9 4 34 20 0.0034data4-9-34-08051.txt 9 4 34 16 0.0033data4-9-34-08052.txt 9 4 34 16 0.0032data4-9-34-08053.txt 9 4 34 23 0.0033data4-9-34-08054.txt 9 4 34 20 0.0035data4-9-34-08055.txt 9 4 34 20 0.0040data4-9-34-08056.txt 9 4 34 15 0.0037data4-9-34-08057.txt 9 4 34 22 0.0047data4-9-34-08058.txt 9 4 34 19 0.0037data4-9-34-08059.txt 9 4 34 18 0.0034data4-9-34-08060.txt 9 4 34 20 0.0032data4-9-34-08061.txt 9 4 34 24 0.0043data4-9-34-08062.txt 9 4 34 22 0.0035data4-9-34-08063.txt 9 4 34 20 0.0049data4-9-34-08064.txt 9 4 34 15 0.0035data4-9-34-08065.txt 9 4 34 22 0.0047data4-9-34-08066.txt 9 4 34 16 0.0037data4-9-34-08067.txt 9 4 34 16 0.0033data4-9-34-08068.txt 9 4 34 20 0.0037data4-9-34-08069.txt 9 4 34 19 0.0032data4-9-34-08070.txt 9 4 34 21 0.0033data4-9-34-08071.txt 9 4 34 21 0.0038data4-9-34-08072.txt 9 4 34 17 0.0038data4-9-34-08073.txt 9 4 34 19 0.0039data4-9-34-08074.txt 9 4 34 20 0.0034data4-9-34-08075.txt 9 4 34 18 0.0216data4-9-34-08076.txt 9 4 34 18 0.0037data4-9-34-08077.txt 9 4 34 21 0.0035data4-9-34-08078.txt 9 4 34 21 0.0037data4-9-34-08079.txt 9 4 34 23 0.0032data4-9-34-08080.txt 9 4 34 23 0.0043data4-9-34-08081.txt 9 4 34 18 0.0125data4-9-34-08082.txt 9 4 34 20 0.0049data4-9-34-08083.txt 9 4 34 19 0.0050data4-9-34-08084.txt 9 4 34 20 0.0631data4-9-34-08085.txt 9 4 34 20 0.0033data4-9-34-08086.txt 9 4 34 22 0.0045data4-9-34-08087.txt 9 4 34 14 0.1291data4-9-34-08088.txt 9 4 34 17 0.0031data4-9-34-08089.txt 9 4 34 19 0.0031data4-9-34-08090.txt 9 4 34 22 0.0032data4-9-34-08091.txt 9 4 34 22 0.0038data4-9-34-08092.txt 9 4 34 23 0.0035data4-9-34-08093.txt 9 4 34 20 0.0031data4-9-34-08094.txt 9 4 34 19 0.0032data4-9-34-08095.txt 9 4 34 18 0.0036data4-9-34-08096.txt 9 4 34 14 0.0038data4-9-34-08097.txt 9 4 34 18 0.0038data4-9-34-08098.txt 9 4 34 18 0.0034data4-9-34-08099.txt 9 4 34 19 0.0032data4-9-34-08100.txt 9 4 34 19 0.0033data4-9-35-08101.txt 9 4 35 16 0.0036data4-9-35-08102.txt 9 4 35 14 0.0034data4-9-35-08103.txt 9 4 35 18 0.0033data4-9-35-08104.txt 9 4 35 19 0.0040data4-9-35-08105.txt 9 4 35 19 0.0035data4-9-35-08106.txt 9 4 35 21 0.0178data4-9-35-08107.txt 9 4 35 20 0.0041data4-9-35-08108.txt 9 4 35 15 0.0038data4-9-35-08109.txt 9 4 35 19 0.0040data4-9-35-08110.txt 9 4 35 13 0.0038

Table 43: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 249: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-9-35-08111.txt 9 4 35 25 0.0077data4-9-35-08112.txt 9 4 35 19 0.0034data4-9-35-08113.txt 9 4 35 25 0.0032data4-9-35-08114.txt 9 4 35 16 0.0034data4-9-35-08115.txt 9 4 35 22 0.0035data4-9-35-08116.txt 9 4 35 23 0.0040data4-9-35-08117.txt 9 4 35 20 0.0038data4-9-35-08118.txt 9 4 35 24 0.0037data4-9-35-08119.txt 9 4 35 20 0.0034data4-9-35-08120.txt 9 4 35 22 0.0033data4-9-35-08121.txt 9 4 35 21 0.0035data4-9-35-08122.txt 9 4 35 26 0.0033data4-9-35-08123.txt 9 4 35 24 0.0032data4-9-35-08124.txt 9 4 35 20 0.0037data4-9-35-08125.txt 9 4 35 13 0.0039data4-9-35-08126.txt 9 4 35 17 0.0047data4-9-35-08127.txt 9 4 35 15 0.0040data4-9-35-08128.txt 9 4 35 18 0.0034data4-9-35-08129.txt 9 4 35 18 0.0034data4-9-35-08130.txt 9 4 35 16 0.0033data4-9-35-08131.txt 9 4 35 19 0.0031data4-9-35-08132.txt 9 4 35 26 0.0032data4-9-35-08133.txt 9 4 35 25 0.0036data4-9-35-08134.txt 9 4 35 19 0.0037data4-9-35-08135.txt 9 4 35 23 0.0037data4-9-35-08136.txt 9 4 35 18 0.0035data4-9-35-08137.txt 9 4 35 16 0.0033data4-9-35-08138.txt 9 4 35 22 0.0032data4-9-35-08139.txt 9 4 35 16 0.0033data4-9-35-08140.txt 9 4 35 25 0.0081data4-9-35-08141.txt 9 4 35 21 0.0040data4-9-35-08142.txt 9 4 35 21 0.0038data4-9-35-08143.txt 9 4 35 14 0.0038data4-9-35-08144.txt 9 4 35 20 0.0035data4-9-35-08145.txt 9 4 35 23 0.0912data4-9-35-08146.txt 9 4 35 19 0.0032data4-9-35-08147.txt 9 4 35 18 0.0032data4-9-35-08148.txt 9 4 35 25 0.0035data4-9-35-08149.txt 9 4 35 19 0.0039data4-9-35-08150.txt 9 4 35 18 0.0034data4-9-35-08151.txt 9 4 35 17 0.0033data4-9-35-08152.txt 9 4 35 23 0.0037data4-9-35-08153.txt 9 4 35 20 0.0038data4-9-35-08154.txt 9 4 35 22 0.0038data4-9-35-08155.txt 9 4 35 16 0.0043data4-9-35-08156.txt 9 4 35 19 0.0035data4-9-35-08157.txt 9 4 35 18 0.0032data4-9-35-08158.txt 9 4 35 17 0.0034data4-9-35-08159.txt 9 4 35 14 0.0033data4-9-35-08160.txt 9 4 35 22 0.0035data4-9-35-08161.txt 9 4 35 19 0.0091data4-9-35-08162.txt 9 4 35 20 0.0071data4-9-35-08163.txt 9 4 35 16 0.0034data4-9-35-08164.txt 9 4 35 21 0.0038data4-9-35-08165.txt 9 4 35 18 0.0209data4-9-35-08166.txt 9 4 35 19 0.0035data4-9-35-08167.txt 9 4 35 13 0.0035data4-9-35-08168.txt 9 4 35 14 0.0032data4-9-35-08169.txt 9 4 35 19 0.0033data4-9-35-08170.txt 9 4 35 18 0.0033data4-9-35-08171.txt 9 4 35 21 0.0034data4-9-35-08172.txt 9 4 35 19 0.0040data4-9-35-08173.txt 9 4 35 22 0.0037data4-9-35-08174.txt 9 4 35 19 0.0042data4-9-35-08175.txt 9 4 35 21 0.0033data4-9-35-08176.txt 9 4 35 17 0.0032data4-9-35-08177.txt 9 4 35 25 0.1592data4-9-35-08178.txt 9 4 35 14 0.0033data4-9-35-08179.txt 9 4 35 22 0.0033data4-9-35-08180.txt 9 4 35 22 0.0037

Table 44: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 250: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-9-35-08181.txt 9 4 35 20 0.0039data4-9-35-08182.txt 9 4 35 26 0.0036data4-9-35-08183.txt 9 4 35 24 0.0058data4-9-35-08184.txt 9 4 35 18 0.0043data4-9-35-08185.txt 9 4 35 17 0.0038data4-9-35-08186.txt 9 4 35 19 0.0231data4-9-35-08187.txt 9 4 35 17 0.0036data4-9-35-08188.txt 9 4 35 18 0.0037data4-9-35-08189.txt 9 4 35 17 0.0039data4-9-35-08190.txt 9 4 35 17 0.0037data4-9-35-08191.txt 9 4 35 16 0.0036data4-9-35-08192.txt 9 4 35 23 0.0033data4-9-35-08193.txt 9 4 35 18 0.0033data4-9-35-08194.txt 9 4 35 18 0.0035data4-9-35-08195.txt 9 4 35 18 0.0035data4-9-35-08196.txt 9 4 35 24 0.0038data4-9-35-08197.txt 9 4 35 17 0.0036data4-9-35-08198.txt 9 4 35 17 0.0174data4-9-35-08199.txt 9 4 35 16 0.0034data4-9-35-08200.txt 9 4 35 21 0.0038data4-10-36-10301.txt 10 4 36 12 0.0044data4-10-36-10302.txt 10 4 36 17 0.0058data4-10-36-10303.txt 10 4 36 20 0.0038data4-10-36-10304.txt 10 4 36 18 0.0125data4-10-36-10305.txt 10 4 36 19 0.0055data4-10-36-10306.txt 10 4 36 18 0.0048data4-10-36-10307.txt 10 4 36 20 0.0039data4-10-36-10308.txt 10 4 36 21 0.0053data4-10-36-10309.txt 10 4 36 18 0.0036data4-10-36-10310.txt 10 4 36 18 0.0035data4-10-36-10311.txt 10 4 36 22 0.0267data4-10-36-10312.txt 10 4 36 19 0.0037data4-10-36-10313.txt 10 4 36 17 0.0034data4-10-36-10314.txt 10 4 36 21 0.0100data4-10-36-10315.txt 10 4 36 20 0.0040data4-10-36-10316.txt 10 4 36 15 0.0040data4-10-36-10317.txt 10 4 36 19 0.0041data4-10-36-10318.txt 10 4 36 14 0.0035data4-10-36-10319.txt 10 4 36 18 0.0061data4-10-36-10320.txt 10 4 36 18 0.0035data4-10-36-10321.txt 10 4 36 23 0.0041data4-10-36-10322.txt 10 4 36 22 0.1373data4-10-36-10323.txt 10 4 36 22 0.0042data4-10-36-10324.txt 10 4 36 15 0.0035data4-10-36-10325.txt 10 4 36 24 0.0042data4-10-36-10326.txt 10 4 36 16 0.0038data4-10-36-10327.txt 10 4 36 19 0.0049data4-10-36-10328.txt 10 4 36 20 0.0222data4-10-36-10329.txt 10 4 36 20 0.0036data4-10-36-10330.txt 10 4 36 14 0.0035data4-10-36-10331.txt 10 4 36 24 0.0038data4-10-36-10332.txt 10 4 36 22 0.0038data4-10-36-10333.txt 10 4 36 23 0.0041data4-10-36-10334.txt 10 4 36 25 0.0052data4-10-36-10335.txt 10 4 36 19 0.0036data4-10-36-10336.txt 10 4 36 19 0.0035data4-10-36-10337.txt 10 4 36 17 0.0036data4-10-36-10338.txt 10 4 36 22 0.0037data4-10-36-10339.txt 10 4 36 18 0.0034data4-10-36-10340.txt 10 4 36 19 0.0679data4-10-36-10341.txt 10 4 36 19 0.0035data4-10-36-10342.txt 10 4 36 19 0.0034data4-10-36-10343.txt 10 4 36 18 0.0034data4-10-36-10344.txt 10 4 36 21 0.0125data4-10-36-10345.txt 10 4 36 19 0.0059data4-10-36-10346.txt 10 4 36 15 0.0042data4-10-36-10347.txt 10 4 36 21 0.0053data4-10-36-10348.txt 10 4 36 18 0.0043data4-10-36-10349.txt 10 4 36 17 0.0036data4-10-36-10350.txt 10 4 36 21 0.0038

Table 45: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 251: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-10-36-10351.txt 10 4 36 20 0.0098data4-10-36-10352.txt 10 4 36 20 0.0046data4-10-36-10353.txt 10 4 36 13 0.0047data4-10-36-10354.txt 10 4 36 18 0.0038data4-10-36-10355.txt 10 4 36 16 0.0035data4-10-36-10356.txt 10 4 36 22 0.0072data4-10-36-10357.txt 10 4 36 21 0.0036data4-10-36-10358.txt 10 4 36 18 0.0040data4-10-36-10359.txt 10 4 36 15 0.0040data4-10-36-10360.txt 10 4 36 16 0.0040data4-10-36-10361.txt 10 4 36 22 0.0042data4-10-36-10362.txt 10 4 36 20 0.0056data4-10-36-10363.txt 10 4 36 15 0.0034data4-10-36-10364.txt 10 4 36 19 0.0034data4-10-36-10365.txt 10 4 36 17 0.0036data4-10-36-10366.txt 10 4 36 15 0.0041data4-10-36-10367.txt 10 4 36 20 0.0036data4-10-36-10368.txt 10 4 36 19 0.0045data4-10-36-10369.txt 10 4 36 23 0.0037data4-10-36-10370.txt 10 4 36 20 0.0038data4-10-36-10371.txt 10 4 36 19 0.0301data4-10-36-10372.txt 10 4 36 19 0.0036data4-10-36-10373.txt 10 4 36 13 0.0035data4-10-36-10374.txt 10 4 36 20 0.0035data4-10-36-10375.txt 10 4 36 18 0.0037data4-10-36-10376.txt 10 4 36 18 0.0043data4-10-36-10377.txt 10 4 36 17 0.0040data4-10-36-10378.txt 10 4 36 20 0.0037data4-10-36-10379.txt 10 4 36 25 0.1262data4-10-36-10380.txt 10 4 36 15 0.0034data4-10-36-10381.txt 10 4 36 20 0.0034data4-10-36-10382.txt 10 4 36 13 0.0034data4-10-36-10383.txt 10 4 36 22 0.0044data4-10-36-10384.txt 10 4 36 24 0.0037data4-10-36-10385.txt 10 4 36 21 0.0169data4-10-36-10386.txt 10 4 36 21 0.0038data4-10-36-10387.txt 10 4 36 17 0.0050data4-10-36-10388.txt 10 4 36 15 0.0035data4-10-36-10389.txt 10 4 36 19 0.0034data4-10-36-10390.txt 10 4 36 16 0.0034data4-10-36-10391.txt 10 4 36 18 0.0041data4-10-36-10392.txt 10 4 36 23 0.0071data4-10-36-10393.txt 10 4 36 24 0.6331data4-10-36-10394.txt 10 4 36 25 0.0061data4-10-36-10395.txt 10 4 36 23 0.0036data4-10-36-10396.txt 10 4 36 21 0.0111data4-10-36-10397.txt 10 4 36 18 0.0036data4-10-36-10398.txt 10 4 36 19 0.0048data4-10-36-10399.txt 10 4 36 19 0.0107data4-10-36-10400.txt 10 4 36 16 0.0035data4-10-37-10401.txt 10 4 37 19 0.0039data4-10-37-10402.txt 10 4 37 24 0.0036data4-10-37-10403.txt 10 4 37 25 0.0037data4-10-37-10404.txt 10 4 37 18 0.0048data4-10-37-10405.txt 10 4 37 19 0.0045data4-10-37-10406.txt 10 4 37 20 0.0046data4-10-37-10407.txt 10 4 37 22 0.0045data4-10-37-10408.txt 10 4 37 23 0.0051data4-10-37-10409.txt 10 4 37 22 0.0037data4-10-37-10410.txt 10 4 37 19 0.0035data4-10-37-10411.txt 10 4 37 21 0.0044data4-10-37-10412.txt 10 4 37 10 0.0048data4-10-37-10413.txt 10 4 37 23 0.0035data4-10-37-10414.txt 10 4 37 25 0.0148data4-10-37-10415.txt 10 4 37 19 0.0035data4-10-37-10416.txt 10 4 37 19 0.0052data4-10-37-10417.txt 10 4 37 22 0.0495data4-10-37-10418.txt 10 4 37 16 0.0035data4-10-37-10419.txt 10 4 37 17 0.0035data4-10-37-10420.txt 10 4 37 15 0.0038

Table 46: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 252: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-10-37-10421.txt 10 4 37 19 0.0047data4-10-37-10422.txt 10 4 37 19 0.0039data4-10-37-10423.txt 10 4 37 23 0.0036data4-10-37-10424.txt 10 4 37 26 0.0091data4-10-37-10425.txt 10 4 37 20 0.0036data4-10-37-10426.txt 10 4 37 15 0.0034data4-10-37-10427.txt 10 4 37 19 0.0038data4-10-37-10428.txt 10 4 37 19 0.0044data4-10-37-10429.txt 10 4 37 23 0.0056data4-10-37-10430.txt 10 4 37 20 0.0037data4-10-37-10431.txt 10 4 37 18 0.0051data4-10-37-10432.txt 10 4 37 20 0.0037data4-10-37-10433.txt 10 4 37 21 0.0036data4-10-37-10434.txt 10 4 37 23 0.0056data4-10-37-10435.txt 10 4 37 22 0.0041data4-10-37-10436.txt 10 4 37 22 0.0039data4-10-37-10437.txt 10 4 37 18 0.0037data4-10-37-10438.txt 10 4 37 20 0.0933data4-10-37-10439.txt 10 4 37 21 0.0035data4-10-37-10440.txt 10 4 37 21 0.0035data4-10-37-10441.txt 10 4 37 19 0.0035data4-10-37-10442.txt 10 4 37 21 0.0042data4-10-37-10443.txt 10 4 37 20 0.0036data4-10-37-10444.txt 10 4 37 17 0.0045data4-10-37-10445.txt 10 4 37 24 0.2973data4-10-37-10446.txt 10 4 37 14 0.0033data4-10-37-10447.txt 10 4 37 18 0.0034data4-10-37-10448.txt 10 4 37 21 0.0040data4-10-37-10449.txt 10 4 37 19 0.0044data4-10-37-10450.txt 10 4 37 19 0.0048data4-10-37-10451.txt 10 4 37 23 0.0036data4-10-37-10452.txt 10 4 37 17 0.0038data4-10-37-10453.txt 10 4 37 20 0.0045data4-10-37-10454.txt 10 4 37 25 0.0089data4-10-37-10455.txt 10 4 37 20 0.0045data4-10-37-10456.txt 10 4 37 16 0.0036data4-10-37-10457.txt 10 4 37 15 0.0038data4-10-37-10458.txt 10 4 37 18 0.0035data4-10-37-10459.txt 10 4 37 22 0.0050data4-10-37-10460.txt 10 4 37 14 0.0040data4-10-37-10461.txt 10 4 37 23 0.0040data4-10-37-10462.txt 10 4 37 16 0.0036data4-10-37-10463.txt 10 4 37 21 0.0034data4-10-37-10464.txt 10 4 37 18 0.0034data4-10-37-10465.txt 10 4 37 17 0.0041data4-10-37-10466.txt 10 4 37 21 0.0039data4-10-37-10467.txt 10 4 37 22 0.0052data4-10-37-10468.txt 10 4 37 23 0.0038data4-10-37-10469.txt 10 4 37 14 0.0039data4-10-37-10470.txt 10 4 37 20 0.0036data4-10-37-10471.txt 10 4 37 23 0.0722data4-10-37-10472.txt 10 4 37 23 0.0044data4-10-37-10473.txt 10 4 37 19 0.0036data4-10-37-10474.txt 10 4 37 24 0.0057data4-10-37-10475.txt 10 4 37 21 0.0036data4-10-37-10476.txt 10 4 37 23 0.0035data4-10-37-10477.txt 10 4 37 14 0.0035data4-10-37-10478.txt 10 4 37 21 0.0094data4-10-37-10479.txt 10 4 37 20 0.0040data4-10-37-10480.txt 10 4 37 20 0.0036data4-10-37-10481.txt 10 4 37 21 0.0035data4-10-37-10482.txt 10 4 37 20 0.0034data4-10-37-10483.txt 10 4 37 21 0.0035data4-10-37-10484.txt 10 4 37 26 0.0967data4-10-37-10485.txt 10 4 37 19 0.0034data4-10-37-10486.txt 10 4 37 18 0.0035data4-10-37-10487.txt 10 4 37 21 0.0043data4-10-37-10488.txt 10 4 37 17 0.0041data4-10-37-10489.txt 10 4 37 20 0.0041data4-10-37-10490.txt 10 4 37 17 0.0036

Table 47: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 253: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-10-37-10491.txt 10 4 37 26 0.1322data4-10-37-10492.txt 10 4 37 25 0.0042data4-10-37-10493.txt 10 4 37 21 0.0033data4-10-37-10494.txt 10 4 37 20 0.0038data4-10-37-10495.txt 10 4 37 18 0.0041data4-10-37-10496.txt 10 4 37 17 0.0037data4-10-37-10497.txt 10 4 37 17 0.0034data4-10-37-10498.txt 10 4 37 27 0.0101data4-10-37-10499.txt 10 4 37 23 0.0043data4-10-37-10500.txt 10 4 37 20 0.0036data4-10-38-10501.txt 10 4 38 23 0.0041data4-10-38-10502.txt 10 4 38 24 0.0073data4-10-38-10503.txt 10 4 38 20 0.0036data4-10-38-10504.txt 10 4 38 24 0.0051data4-10-38-10505.txt 10 4 38 19 0.0045data4-10-38-10506.txt 10 4 38 20 0.0042data4-10-38-10507.txt 10 4 38 23 0.0037data4-10-38-10508.txt 10 4 38 28 0.0037data4-10-38-10509.txt 10 4 38 22 0.0039data4-10-38-10510.txt 10 4 38 30 0.0036data4-10-38-10511.txt 10 4 38 21 0.0043data4-10-38-10512.txt 10 4 38 19 0.0055data4-10-38-10513.txt 10 4 38 24 0.0062data4-10-38-10514.txt 10 4 38 19 0.0038data4-10-38-10515.txt 10 4 38 18 0.0035data4-10-38-10516.txt 10 4 38 25 0.0037data4-10-38-10517.txt 10 4 38 21 0.0037data4-10-38-10518.txt 10 4 38 21 0.0046data4-10-38-10519.txt 10 4 38 19 0.0054data4-10-38-10520.txt 10 4 38 18 0.0043data4-10-38-10521.txt 10 4 38 10 0.0038data4-10-38-10522.txt 10 4 38 20 0.0035data4-10-38-10523.txt 10 4 38 24 0.0037data4-10-38-10524.txt 10 4 38 22 0.0038data4-10-38-10525.txt 10 4 38 16 0.0034data4-10-38-10526.txt 10 4 38 26 0.0065data4-10-38-10527.txt 10 4 38 20 0.0042data4-10-38-10528.txt 10 4 38 20 0.0041data4-10-38-10529.txt 10 4 38 26 0.1110data4-10-38-10530.txt 10 4 38 19 0.0076data4-10-38-10531.txt 10 4 38 22 0.0089data4-10-38-10532.txt 10 4 38 19 0.1799data4-10-38-10533.txt 10 4 38 19 0.0035data4-10-38-10534.txt 10 4 38 22 0.0035data4-10-38-10535.txt 10 4 38 19 0.0037data4-10-38-10536.txt 10 4 38 18 0.0043data4-10-38-10537.txt 10 4 38 23 0.0036data4-10-38-10538.txt 10 4 38 21 0.0037data4-10-38-10539.txt 10 4 38 19 0.0038data4-10-38-10540.txt 10 4 38 27 0.0054data4-10-38-10541.txt 10 4 38 16 0.0040data4-10-38-10542.txt 10 4 38 18 0.0126data4-10-38-10543.txt 10 4 38 20 0.0036data4-10-38-10544.txt 10 4 38 21 0.0039data4-10-38-10545.txt 10 4 38 22 0.0041data4-10-38-10546.txt 10 4 38 15 0.0046data4-10-38-10547.txt 10 4 38 26 0.0042data4-10-38-10548.txt 10 4 38 22 0.0040data4-10-38-10549.txt 10 4 38 14 0.0035data4-10-38-10550.txt 10 4 38 26 0.0069data4-10-38-10551.txt 10 4 38 22 0.0059data4-10-38-10552.txt 10 4 38 21 0.0051data4-10-38-10553.txt 10 4 38 30 0.0988data4-10-38-10554.txt 10 4 38 15 0.0036data4-10-38-10555.txt 10 4 38 25 0.0036data4-10-38-10556.txt 10 4 38 23 0.0271data4-10-38-10557.txt 10 4 38 18 0.0038data4-10-38-10558.txt 10 4 38 20 0.0047data4-10-38-10559.txt 10 4 38 20 0.0036data4-10-38-10560.txt 10 4 38 28 0.0753

Table 48: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 254: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-10-38-10561.txt 10 4 38 22 0.0036data4-10-38-10562.txt 10 4 38 24 0.0035data4-10-38-10563.txt 10 4 38 21 0.0038data4-10-38-10564.txt 10 4 38 20 0.0045data4-10-38-10565.txt 10 4 38 22 0.0035data4-10-38-10566.txt 10 4 38 25 0.0036data4-10-38-10567.txt 10 4 38 24 0.0039data4-10-38-10568.txt 10 4 38 19 0.0046data4-10-38-10569.txt 10 4 38 24 0.0048data4-10-38-10570.txt 10 4 38 15 0.0077data4-10-38-10571.txt 10 4 38 19 0.0037data4-10-38-10572.txt 10 4 38 28 0.0036data4-10-38-10573.txt 10 4 38 17 0.0069data4-10-38-10574.txt 10 4 38 27 0.0836data4-10-38-10575.txt 10 4 38 23 0.0046data4-10-38-10576.txt 10 4 38 14 0.0069data4-10-38-10577.txt 10 4 38 21 0.0069data4-10-38-10578.txt 10 4 38 21 0.0078data4-10-38-10579.txt 10 4 38 18 0.0067data4-10-38-10580.txt 10 4 38 25 0.0067data4-10-38-10581.txt 10 4 38 21 0.0059data4-10-38-10582.txt 10 4 38 18 0.0057data4-10-38-10583.txt 10 4 38 20 0.0055data4-10-38-10584.txt 10 4 38 22 0.0062data4-10-38-10585.txt 10 4 38 23 0.0081data4-10-38-10586.txt 10 4 38 23 0.0058data4-10-38-10587.txt 10 4 38 21 0.0050data4-10-38-10588.txt 10 4 38 17 0.0062data4-10-38-10589.txt 10 4 38 16 0.0054data4-10-38-10590.txt 10 4 38 21 0.0052data4-10-38-10591.txt 10 4 38 23 0.0051data4-10-38-10592.txt 10 4 38 25 0.0059data4-10-38-10593.txt 10 4 38 25 0.0067data4-10-38-10594.txt 10 4 38 26 0.0062data4-10-38-10595.txt 10 4 38 19 0.0050data4-10-38-10596.txt 10 4 38 17 0.0049data4-10-38-10597.txt 10 4 38 24 0.0060data4-10-38-10598.txt 10 4 38 22 0.0054data4-10-38-10599.txt 10 4 38 20 0.0065data4-10-38-10600.txt 10 4 38 23 0.0055data4-10-39-10601.txt 10 4 39 18 0.0052data4-10-39-10602.txt 10 4 39 24 0.0303data4-10-39-10603.txt 10 4 39 24 0.0051data4-10-39-10604.txt 10 4 39 23 0.0042data4-10-39-10605.txt 10 4 39 27 0.0049data4-10-39-10606.txt 10 4 39 24 0.0041data4-10-39-10607.txt 10 4 39 19 0.0041data4-10-39-10608.txt 10 4 39 22 0.0044data4-10-39-10609.txt 10 4 39 27 0.0264data4-10-39-10610.txt 10 4 39 18 0.0047data4-10-39-10611.txt 10 4 39 22 0.0054data4-10-39-10612.txt 10 4 39 27 0.0082data4-10-39-10613.txt 10 4 39 17 0.0040data4-10-39-10614.txt 10 4 39 22 0.0040data4-10-39-10615.txt 10 4 39 21 0.0043data4-10-39-10616.txt 10 4 39 18 0.0046data4-10-39-10617.txt 10 4 39 24 0.0045data4-10-39-10618.txt 10 4 39 26 0.0046data4-10-39-10619.txt 10 4 39 22 0.0041data4-10-39-10620.txt 10 4 39 28 0.0040data4-10-39-10621.txt 10 4 39 17 0.0039data4-10-39-10622.txt 10 4 39 23 0.0091data4-10-39-10623.txt 10 4 39 23 0.0049data4-10-39-10624.txt 10 4 39 21 0.0084data4-10-39-10625.txt 10 4 39 19 0.0041data4-10-39-10626.txt 10 4 39 14 0.0039data4-10-39-10627.txt 10 4 39 18 0.0048data4-10-39-10628.txt 10 4 39 28 0.0259data4-10-39-10629.txt 10 4 39 21 0.0037data4-10-39-10630.txt 10 4 39 20 0.0071

Table 49: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 255: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-10-39-10631.txt 10 4 39 19 0.0043data4-10-39-10632.txt 10 4 39 21 0.0043data4-10-39-10633.txt 10 4 39 26 0.0098data4-10-39-10634.txt 10 4 39 19 0.0146data4-10-39-10635.txt 10 4 39 22 0.0128data4-10-39-10636.txt 10 4 39 19 0.0038data4-10-39-10637.txt 10 4 39 23 0.0036data4-10-39-10638.txt 10 4 39 21 0.0037data4-10-39-10639.txt 10 4 39 21 0.0064data4-10-39-10640.txt 10 4 39 23 0.0043data4-10-39-10641.txt 10 4 39 23 0.0044data4-10-39-10642.txt 10 4 39 23 0.0041data4-10-39-10643.txt 10 4 39 24 0.0043data4-10-39-10644.txt 10 4 39 24 0.0036data4-10-39-10645.txt 10 4 39 20 0.0036data4-10-39-10646.txt 10 4 39 31 0.0037data4-10-39-10647.txt 10 4 39 24 0.0040data4-10-39-10648.txt 10 4 39 20 0.0042data4-10-39-10649.txt 10 4 39 18 0.0042data4-10-39-10650.txt 10 4 39 21 0.0040data4-10-39-10651.txt 10 4 39 23 0.0042data4-10-39-10652.txt 10 4 39 20 0.0041data4-10-39-10653.txt 10 4 39 20 0.0035data4-10-39-10654.txt 10 4 39 22 0.0036data4-10-39-10655.txt 10 4 39 21 0.0335data4-10-39-10656.txt 10 4 39 18 0.0038data4-10-39-10657.txt 10 4 39 23 0.0035data4-10-39-10658.txt 10 4 39 21 0.0035data4-10-39-10659.txt 10 4 39 23 0.0044data4-10-39-10660.txt 10 4 39 24 0.0037data4-10-39-10661.txt 10 4 39 25 0.0056data4-10-39-10662.txt 10 4 39 23 0.1048data4-10-39-10663.txt 10 4 39 23 0.0040data4-10-39-10664.txt 10 4 39 16 0.0036data4-10-39-10665.txt 10 4 39 20 0.0039data4-10-39-10666.txt 10 4 39 22 0.0043data4-10-39-10667.txt 10 4 39 19 0.0037data4-10-39-10668.txt 10 4 39 14 0.0037data4-10-39-10669.txt 10 4 39 22 0.1526data4-10-39-10670.txt 10 4 39 25 0.0046data4-10-39-10671.txt 10 4 39 26 0.0038data4-10-39-10672.txt 10 4 39 19 0.0041data4-10-39-10673.txt 10 4 39 19 0.0041data4-10-39-10674.txt 10 4 39 24 0.0036data4-10-39-10675.txt 10 4 39 26 0.0036data4-10-39-10676.txt 10 4 39 29 0.0303data4-10-39-10677.txt 10 4 39 21 0.0045data4-10-39-10678.txt 10 4 39 13 0.0044data4-10-39-10679.txt 10 4 39 28 0.0049data4-10-39-10680.txt 10 4 39 22 0.0039data4-10-39-10681.txt 10 4 39 21 0.0037data4-10-39-10682.txt 10 4 39 15 0.0036data4-10-39-10683.txt 10 4 39 19 0.0036data4-10-39-10684.txt 10 4 39 18 0.0037data4-10-39-10685.txt 10 4 39 24 0.0044data4-10-39-10686.txt 10 4 39 20 0.0042data4-10-39-10687.txt 10 4 39 24 0.0044data4-10-39-10688.txt 10 4 39 27 0.0038data4-10-39-10689.txt 10 4 39 20 0.0037data4-10-39-10690.txt 10 4 39 24 0.0040data4-10-39-10691.txt 10 4 39 27 0.1581data4-10-39-10692.txt 10 4 39 26 0.0038data4-10-39-10693.txt 10 4 39 25 0.0038data4-10-39-10694.txt 10 4 39 20 0.0039data4-10-39-10695.txt 10 4 39 19 0.0043data4-10-39-10696.txt 10 4 39 21 0.0037data4-10-39-10697.txt 10 4 39 16 0.0038data4-10-39-10698.txt 10 4 39 21 0.0042data4-10-39-10699.txt 10 4 39 22 0.0044data4-10-39-10700.txt 10 4 39 22 0.0061

Table 50: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 256: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-6-25-00701.txt 6 5 25 18 0.0043data5-6-25-00702.txt 6 5 25 19 0.0043data5-6-25-00703.txt 6 5 25 16 0.0064data5-6-25-00704.txt 6 5 25 14 0.0045data5-6-25-00705.txt 6 5 25 14 0.0047data5-6-25-00706.txt 6 5 25 16 0.0049data5-6-25-00707.txt 6 5 25 16 0.0045data5-6-25-00708.txt 6 5 25 13 0.0044data5-6-25-00709.txt 6 5 25 17 0.0040data5-6-25-00710.txt 6 5 25 12 0.0041data5-6-25-00711.txt 6 5 25 21 0.0120data5-6-25-00712.txt 6 5 25 10 0.0044data5-6-25-00713.txt 6 5 25 18 0.0041data5-6-25-00714.txt 6 5 25 16 0.0062data5-6-25-00715.txt 6 5 25 19 0.0061data5-6-25-00716.txt 6 5 25 18 0.0045data5-6-25-00717.txt 6 5 25 18 0.0053data5-6-25-00718.txt 6 5 25 15 0.0041data5-6-25-00719.txt 6 5 25 13 0.0040data5-6-25-00720.txt 6 5 25 16 0.0041data5-6-25-00721.txt 6 5 25 17 0.0049data5-6-25-00722.txt 6 5 25 19 0.0049data5-6-25-00723.txt 6 5 25 23 0.0049data5-6-25-00724.txt 6 5 25 17 0.0044data5-6-25-00725.txt 6 5 25 19 0.0114data5-6-25-00726.txt 6 5 25 18 0.0040data5-6-25-00727.txt 6 5 25 17 0.0051data5-6-25-00728.txt 6 5 25 13 0.0047data5-6-25-00729.txt 6 5 25 19 0.0049data5-6-25-00730.txt 6 5 25 15 0.0044data5-6-25-00731.txt 6 5 25 17 0.0958data5-6-25-00732.txt 6 5 25 14 0.0039data5-6-25-00733.txt 6 5 25 16 0.0041data5-6-25-00734.txt 6 5 25 18 0.0052data5-6-25-00735.txt 6 5 25 13 0.0044data5-6-25-00736.txt 6 5 25 20 0.0049data5-6-25-00737.txt 6 5 25 16 0.0042data5-6-25-00738.txt 6 5 25 18 0.0089data5-6-25-00739.txt 6 5 25 15 0.0043data5-6-25-00740.txt 6 5 25 22 0.0083data5-6-25-00741.txt 6 5 25 19 0.0047data5-6-25-00742.txt 6 5 25 12 0.0042data5-6-25-00743.txt 6 5 25 16 0.0050data5-6-25-00744.txt 6 5 25 20 0.0059data5-6-25-00745.txt 6 5 25 12 0.0043data5-6-25-00746.txt 6 5 25 13 0.0042data5-6-25-00747.txt 6 5 25 17 0.0066data5-6-25-00748.txt 6 5 25 12 0.0043data5-6-25-00749.txt 6 5 25 18 0.0045data5-6-25-00750.txt 6 5 25 20 0.0090data5-6-25-00751.txt 6 5 25 15 0.0046data5-6-25-00752.txt 6 5 25 15 0.0039data5-6-25-00753.txt 6 5 25 14 0.0044data5-6-25-00754.txt 6 5 25 16 0.0047data5-6-25-00755.txt 6 5 25 18 0.0209data5-6-25-00756.txt 6 5 25 12 0.0049data5-6-25-00757.txt 6 5 25 23 0.0127data5-6-25-00758.txt 6 5 25 13 0.0049data5-6-25-00759.txt 6 5 25 13 0.0041data5-6-25-00760.txt 6 5 25 21 0.0042data5-6-25-00761.txt 6 5 25 16 0.0039data5-6-25-00762.txt 6 5 25 20 0.0048data5-6-25-00763.txt 6 5 25 16 0.0082data5-6-25-00764.txt 6 5 25 16 0.0044data5-6-25-00765.txt 6 5 25 13 0.0041data5-6-25-00766.txt 6 5 25 13 0.0040data5-6-25-00767.txt 6 5 25 13 0.0125data5-6-25-00768.txt 6 5 25 16 0.0066data5-6-25-00769.txt 6 5 25 19 0.0051data5-6-25-00770.txt 6 5 25 19 0.0039

Table 51: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 257: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-6-25-00771.txt 6 5 25 16 0.0628data5-6-25-00772.txt 6 5 25 17 0.0041data5-6-25-00773.txt 6 5 25 20 0.0468data5-6-25-00774.txt 6 5 25 20 0.0100data5-6-25-00775.txt 6 5 25 18 0.0048data5-6-25-00776.txt 6 5 25 22 0.0064data5-6-25-00777.txt 6 5 25 19 0.0043data5-6-25-00778.txt 6 5 25 19 0.0145data5-6-25-00779.txt 6 5 25 17 0.0044data5-6-25-00780.txt 6 5 25 16 0.0061data5-6-25-00781.txt 6 5 25 18 0.0040data5-6-25-00782.txt 6 5 25 15 0.0042data5-6-25-00783.txt 6 5 25 17 0.0042data5-6-25-00784.txt 6 5 25 23 0.0046data5-6-25-00785.txt 6 5 25 15 0.0047data5-6-25-00786.txt 6 5 25 21 0.0958data5-6-25-00787.txt 6 5 25 20 0.0047data5-6-25-00788.txt 6 5 25 19 0.0070data5-6-25-00789.txt 6 5 25 15 0.0044data5-6-25-00790.txt 6 5 25 17 0.0040data5-6-25-00791.txt 6 5 25 14 0.0041data5-6-25-00792.txt 6 5 25 17 0.0048data5-6-25-00793.txt 6 5 25 12 0.0046data5-6-25-00794.txt 6 5 25 15 0.0047data5-6-25-00795.txt 6 5 25 13 0.0041data5-6-25-00796.txt 6 5 25 19 0.0041data5-6-25-00797.txt 6 5 25 19 0.0049data5-6-25-00798.txt 6 5 25 17 0.0047data5-6-25-00799.txt 6 5 25 23 0.0073data5-6-25-00800.txt 6 5 25 16 0.0049data5-6-26-00801.txt 6 5 26 20 0.0044data5-6-26-00802.txt 6 5 26 16 0.0048data5-6-26-00803.txt 6 5 26 17 0.0042data5-6-26-00804.txt 6 5 26 20 0.0278data5-6-26-00805.txt 6 5 26 18 0.0342data5-6-26-00806.txt 6 5 26 12 0.0041data5-6-26-00807.txt 6 5 26 10 0.0049data5-6-26-00808.txt 6 5 26 22 0.0047data5-6-26-00809.txt 6 5 26 17 0.0050data5-6-26-00810.txt 6 5 26 19 0.0043data5-6-26-00811.txt 6 5 26 16 0.0042data5-6-26-00812.txt 6 5 26 13 0.0041data5-6-26-00813.txt 6 5 26 19 0.0078data5-6-26-00814.txt 6 5 26 13 0.0049data5-6-26-00815.txt 6 5 26 14 0.0044data5-6-26-00816.txt 6 5 26 21 0.0050data5-6-26-00817.txt 6 5 26 15 0.0042data5-6-26-00818.txt 6 5 26 20 0.0149data5-6-26-00819.txt 6 5 26 14 0.0046data5-6-26-00820.txt 6 5 26 17 0.1205data5-6-26-00821.txt 6 5 26 15 0.0044data5-6-26-00822.txt 6 5 26 20 0.0043data5-6-26-00823.txt 6 5 26 14 0.0047data5-6-26-00824.txt 6 5 26 20 0.0052data5-6-26-00825.txt 6 5 26 16 0.0042data5-6-26-00826.txt 6 5 26 21 0.0091data5-6-26-00827.txt 6 5 26 19 0.0081data5-6-26-00828.txt 6 5 26 18 0.0171data5-6-26-00829.txt 6 5 26 18 0.0096data5-6-26-00830.txt 6 5 26 16 0.0047data5-6-26-00831.txt 6 5 26 21 0.0245data5-6-26-00832.txt 6 5 26 21 0.0181data5-6-26-00833.txt 6 5 26 16 0.0047data5-6-26-00834.txt 6 5 26 17 0.0057data5-6-26-00835.txt 6 5 26 15 0.0051data5-6-26-00836.txt 6 5 26 16 0.0047data5-6-26-00837.txt 6 5 26 19 0.0106data5-6-26-00838.txt 6 5 26 23 0.0193data5-6-26-00839.txt 6 5 26 17 0.0050data5-6-26-00840.txt 6 5 26 21 0.0046

Table 52: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 258: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-6-26-00841.txt 6 5 26 20 0.0091data5-6-26-00842.txt 6 5 26 15 0.0048data5-6-26-00843.txt 6 5 26 22 0.0718data5-6-26-00844.txt 6 5 26 24 0.0161data5-6-26-00845.txt 6 5 26 17 0.0041data5-6-26-00846.txt 6 5 26 24 0.0193data5-6-26-00847.txt 6 5 26 17 0.0046data5-6-26-00848.txt 6 5 26 20 0.0042data5-6-26-00849.txt 6 5 26 14 0.0041data5-6-26-00850.txt 6 5 26 17 0.0074data5-6-26-00851.txt 6 5 26 25 0.0170data5-6-26-00852.txt 6 5 26 23 0.0045data5-6-26-00853.txt 6 5 26 20 0.1094data5-6-26-00854.txt 6 5 26 24 0.0066data5-6-26-00855.txt 6 5 26 19 0.0053data5-6-26-00856.txt 6 5 26 16 0.0046data5-6-26-00857.txt 6 5 26 17 0.0047data5-6-26-00858.txt 6 5 26 23 0.0183data5-6-26-00859.txt 6 5 26 16 0.0053data5-6-26-00860.txt 6 5 26 15 0.0043data5-6-26-00861.txt 6 5 26 21 0.0047data5-6-26-00862.txt 6 5 26 17 0.0085data5-6-26-00863.txt 6 5 26 21 0.0051data5-6-26-00864.txt 6 5 26 19 0.0045data5-6-26-00865.txt 6 5 26 21 0.0399data5-6-26-00866.txt 6 5 26 17 0.0044data5-6-26-00867.txt 6 5 26 22 0.0057data5-6-26-00868.txt 6 5 26 17 0.0051data5-6-26-00869.txt 6 5 26 24 0.0262data5-6-26-00870.txt 6 5 26 23 0.0085data5-6-26-00871.txt 6 5 26 22 0.0061data5-6-26-00872.txt 6 5 26 19 0.0068data5-6-26-00873.txt 6 5 26 19 0.0051data5-6-26-00874.txt 6 5 26 18 0.0054data5-6-26-00875.txt 6 5 26 22 0.0090data5-6-26-00876.txt 6 5 26 20 0.0046data5-6-26-00877.txt 6 5 26 22 0.0043data5-6-26-00878.txt 6 5 26 25 0.0050data5-6-26-00879.txt 6 5 26 14 0.0048data5-6-26-00880.txt 6 5 26 19 0.0127data5-6-26-00881.txt 6 5 26 19 0.0424data5-6-26-00882.txt 6 5 26 15 0.0046data5-6-26-00883.txt 6 5 26 16 0.0051data5-6-26-00884.txt 6 5 26 19 0.0049data5-6-26-00885.txt 6 5 26 13 0.0068data5-6-26-00886.txt 6 5 26 22 0.0057data5-6-26-00887.txt 6 5 26 17 0.0586data5-6-26-00888.txt 6 5 26 21 0.0044data5-6-26-00889.txt 6 5 26 21 0.0487data5-6-26-00890.txt 6 5 26 15 0.0045data5-6-26-00891.txt 6 5 26 22 0.0175data5-6-26-00892.txt 6 5 26 20 0.0054data5-6-26-00893.txt 6 5 26 15 0.0042data5-6-26-00894.txt 6 5 26 19 0.0639data5-6-26-00895.txt 6 5 26 17 0.0055data5-6-26-00896.txt 6 5 26 23 0.0296data5-6-26-00897.txt 6 5 26 20 0.0052data5-6-26-00898.txt 6 5 26 19 0.0056data5-6-26-00899.txt 6 5 26 18 0.0043data5-6-26-00900.txt 6 5 26 22 0.0107data5-6-27-00901.txt 6 5 27 19 0.0051data5-6-27-00902.txt 6 5 27 20 0.0055data5-6-27-00903.txt 6 5 27 16 0.0044data5-6-27-00904.txt 6 5 27 20 0.0043data5-6-27-00905.txt 6 5 27 18 0.0050data5-6-27-00906.txt 6 5 27 19 0.0061data5-6-27-00907.txt 6 5 27 10 0.0050data5-6-27-00908.txt 6 5 27 14 0.0046data5-6-27-00909.txt 6 5 27 23 0.0046data5-6-27-00910.txt 6 5 27 24 0.0051

Table 53: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 259: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-6-27-00911.txt 6 5 27 17 0.0046data5-6-27-00912.txt 6 5 27 19 0.0093data5-6-27-00913.txt 6 5 27 19 0.0049data5-6-27-00914.txt 6 5 27 23 0.0089data5-6-27-00915.txt 6 5 27 19 0.0050data5-6-27-00916.txt 6 5 27 19 0.0057data5-6-27-00917.txt 6 5 27 15 0.0053data5-6-27-00918.txt 6 5 27 19 0.0051data5-6-27-00919.txt 6 5 27 26 0.0049data5-6-27-00920.txt 6 5 27 18 0.0048data5-6-27-00921.txt 6 5 27 18 0.0059data5-6-27-00922.txt 6 5 27 20 0.0057data5-6-27-00923.txt 6 5 27 19 0.0058data5-6-27-00924.txt 6 5 27 16 0.0048data5-6-27-00925.txt 6 5 27 17 0.0044data5-6-27-00926.txt 6 5 27 20 0.0046data5-6-27-00927.txt 6 5 27 21 0.0048data5-6-27-00928.txt 6 5 27 21 0.0052data5-6-27-00929.txt 6 5 27 19 0.0046data5-6-27-00930.txt 6 5 27 20 0.0049data5-6-27-00931.txt 6 5 27 18 0.0060data5-6-27-00932.txt 6 5 27 18 0.0043data5-6-27-00933.txt 6 5 27 16 0.0045data5-6-27-00934.txt 6 5 27 21 0.0060data5-6-27-00935.txt 6 5 27 16 0.0055data5-6-27-00936.txt 6 5 27 16 0.0046data5-6-27-00937.txt 6 5 27 16 0.0054data5-6-27-00938.txt 6 5 27 22 0.0049data5-6-27-00939.txt 6 5 27 18 0.0047data5-6-27-00940.txt 6 5 27 18 0.0051data5-6-27-00941.txt 6 5 27 22 0.0049data5-6-27-00942.txt 6 5 27 18 0.0047data5-6-27-00943.txt 6 5 27 13 0.0046data5-6-27-00944.txt 6 5 27 23 0.0047data5-6-27-00945.txt 6 5 27 25 0.0055data5-6-27-00946.txt 6 5 27 20 0.0270data5-6-27-00947.txt 6 5 27 19 0.0055data5-6-27-00948.txt 6 5 27 22 0.0127data5-6-27-00949.txt 6 5 27 25 0.0046data5-6-27-00950.txt 6 5 27 18 0.0048data5-6-27-00951.txt 6 5 27 20 0.0043data5-6-27-00952.txt 6 5 27 20 0.0220data5-6-27-00953.txt 6 5 27 18 0.0067data5-6-27-00954.txt 6 5 27 21 0.0248data5-6-27-00955.txt 6 5 27 25 0.0130data5-6-27-00956.txt 6 5 27 20 0.0051data5-6-27-00957.txt 6 5 27 18 0.0047data5-6-27-00958.txt 6 5 27 22 0.0044data5-6-27-00959.txt 6 5 27 18 0.0043data5-6-27-00960.txt 6 5 27 15 0.0045data5-6-27-00961.txt 6 5 27 14 0.0042data5-6-27-00962.txt 6 5 27 16 0.0051data5-6-27-00963.txt 6 5 27 15 0.0070data5-6-27-00964.txt 6 5 27 14 0.0044data5-6-27-00965.txt 6 5 27 17 0.0049data5-6-27-00966.txt 6 5 27 14 0.0048data5-6-27-00967.txt 6 5 27 17 0.0064data5-6-27-00968.txt 6 5 27 24 0.0051data5-6-27-00969.txt 6 5 27 17 0.0055data5-6-27-00970.txt 6 5 27 20 0.0046data5-6-27-00971.txt 6 5 27 20 0.0043data5-6-27-00972.txt 6 5 27 18 0.0048data5-6-27-00973.txt 6 5 27 18 0.0065data5-6-27-00974.txt 6 5 27 14 0.0054data5-6-27-00975.txt 6 5 27 19 0.0048data5-6-27-00976.txt 6 5 27 24 0.0047data5-6-27-00977.txt 6 5 27 17 0.0046data5-6-27-00978.txt 6 5 27 24 0.0885data5-6-27-00979.txt 6 5 27 25 0.0046data5-6-27-00980.txt 6 5 27 18 0.0051

Table 54: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 260: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-6-27-00981.txt 6 5 27 23 0.0049data5-6-27-00982.txt 6 5 27 18 0.0049data5-6-27-00983.txt 6 5 27 14 0.0045data5-6-27-00984.txt 6 5 27 17 0.0049data5-6-27-00985.txt 6 5 27 20 0.0085data5-6-27-00986.txt 6 5 27 14 0.0044data5-6-27-00987.txt 6 5 27 26 0.0048data5-6-27-00988.txt 6 5 27 17 0.0047data5-6-27-00989.txt 6 5 27 22 0.0403data5-6-27-00990.txt 6 5 27 21 0.0047data5-6-27-00991.txt 6 5 27 18 0.0045data5-6-27-00992.txt 6 5 27 26 0.0319data5-6-27-00993.txt 6 5 27 15 0.0046data5-6-27-00994.txt 6 5 27 14 0.0044data5-6-27-00995.txt 6 5 27 23 0.0402data5-6-27-00996.txt 6 5 27 16 0.0042data5-6-27-00997.txt 6 5 27 15 0.0060data5-6-27-00998.txt 6 5 27 19 0.0049data5-6-27-00999.txt 6 5 27 14 0.0044data5-6-27-01000.txt 6 5 27 22 0.0082data5-6-28-01001.txt 6 5 28 25 0.0058data5-6-28-01002.txt 6 5 28 12 0.0049data5-6-28-01003.txt 6 5 28 25 0.0067data5-6-28-01004.txt 6 5 28 20 0.0047data5-6-28-01005.txt 6 5 28 18 0.0048data5-6-28-01006.txt 6 5 28 20 0.0054data5-6-28-01007.txt 6 5 28 24 0.0055data5-6-28-01008.txt 6 5 28 20 0.0052data5-6-28-01009.txt 6 5 28 16 0.0049data5-6-28-01010.txt 6 5 28 18 0.0045data5-6-28-01011.txt 6 5 28 18 0.0050data5-6-28-01012.txt 6 5 28 17 0.0058data5-6-28-01013.txt 6 5 28 29 0.0063data5-6-28-01014.txt 6 5 28 17 0.0047data5-6-28-01015.txt 6 5 28 32 0.0061data5-6-28-01016.txt 6 5 28 20 0.0056data5-6-28-01017.txt 6 5 28 23 0.0101data5-6-28-01018.txt 6 5 28 17 0.0049data5-6-28-01019.txt 6 5 28 24 0.0048data5-6-28-01020.txt 6 5 28 22 0.0097data5-6-28-01021.txt 6 5 28 26 0.0061data5-6-28-01022.txt 6 5 28 19 0.0055data5-6-28-01023.txt 6 5 28 24 0.0050data5-6-28-01024.txt 6 5 28 19 0.0051data5-6-28-01025.txt 6 5 28 18 0.0046data5-6-28-01026.txt 6 5 28 25 0.0051data5-6-28-01027.txt 6 5 28 18 0.0055data5-6-28-01028.txt 6 5 28 11 0.0050data5-6-28-01029.txt 6 5 28 19 0.0055data5-6-28-01030.txt 6 5 28 19 0.0048data5-6-28-01031.txt 6 5 28 16 0.0107data5-6-28-01032.txt 6 5 28 19 0.0051data5-6-28-01033.txt 6 5 28 12 0.0051data5-6-28-01034.txt 6 5 28 20 0.0049data5-6-28-01035.txt 6 5 28 17 0.0050data5-6-28-01036.txt 6 5 28 25 0.0131data5-6-28-01037.txt 6 5 28 27 0.0186data5-6-28-01038.txt 6 5 28 23 0.0317data5-6-28-01039.txt 6 5 28 17 0.0045data5-6-28-01040.txt 6 5 28 25 0.0085data5-6-28-01041.txt 6 5 28 20 0.0053data5-6-28-01042.txt 6 5 28 24 0.0049data5-6-28-01043.txt 6 5 28 20 0.0050data5-6-28-01044.txt 6 5 28 21 0.0049data5-6-28-01045.txt 6 5 28 20 0.0051data5-6-28-01046.txt 6 5 28 13 0.0059data5-6-28-01047.txt 6 5 28 20 0.0079data5-6-28-01048.txt 6 5 28 25 0.0411data5-6-28-01049.txt 6 5 28 21 0.0049data5-6-28-01050.txt 6 5 28 20 0.0051

Table 55: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 261: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-6-28-01051.txt 6 5 28 20 0.0052data5-6-28-01052.txt 6 5 28 22 0.0050data5-6-28-01053.txt 6 5 28 15 0.0045data5-6-28-01054.txt 6 5 28 19 0.0046data5-6-28-01055.txt 6 5 28 14 0.0045data5-6-28-01056.txt 6 5 28 9 0.0052data5-6-28-01057.txt 6 5 28 26 0.0307data5-6-28-01058.txt 6 5 28 17 0.0049data5-6-28-01059.txt 6 5 28 16 0.0048data5-6-28-01060.txt 6 5 28 22 0.0049data5-6-28-01061.txt 6 5 28 22 0.0048data5-6-28-01062.txt 6 5 28 19 0.0128data5-6-28-01063.txt 6 5 28 20 0.0053data5-6-28-01064.txt 6 5 28 14 0.0047data5-6-28-01065.txt 6 5 28 26 0.0044data5-6-28-01066.txt 6 5 28 25 0.0119data5-6-28-01067.txt 6 5 28 16 0.0050data5-6-28-01068.txt 6 5 28 19 0.0172data5-6-28-01069.txt 6 5 28 22 0.0048data5-6-28-01070.txt 6 5 28 22 0.0055data5-6-28-01071.txt 6 5 28 21 0.0063data5-6-28-01072.txt 6 5 28 17 0.0050data5-6-28-01073.txt 6 5 28 17 0.0046data5-6-28-01074.txt 6 5 28 20 0.0050data5-6-28-01075.txt 6 5 28 20 0.0048data5-6-28-01076.txt 6 5 28 13 0.0051data5-6-28-01077.txt 6 5 28 20 0.0060data5-6-28-01078.txt 6 5 28 19 0.0066data5-6-28-01079.txt 6 5 28 16 0.0047data5-6-28-01080.txt 6 5 28 21 0.0047data5-6-28-01081.txt 6 5 28 19 0.0051data5-6-28-01082.txt 6 5 28 25 0.0099data5-6-28-01083.txt 6 5 28 19 0.0046data5-6-28-01084.txt 6 5 28 21 0.0056data5-6-28-01085.txt 6 5 28 17 0.0045data5-6-28-01086.txt 6 5 28 21 0.0066data5-6-28-01087.txt 6 5 28 15 0.0052data5-6-28-01088.txt 6 5 28 20 0.0047data5-6-28-01089.txt 6 5 28 16 0.0047data5-6-28-01090.txt 6 5 28 17 0.0046data5-6-28-01091.txt 6 5 28 27 0.0047data5-6-28-01092.txt 6 5 28 18 0.0052data5-6-28-01093.txt 6 5 28 17 0.0050data5-6-28-01094.txt 6 5 28 17 0.0066data5-6-28-01095.txt 6 5 28 21 0.0044data5-6-28-01096.txt 6 5 28 22 0.0052data5-6-28-01097.txt 6 5 28 20 0.0098data5-6-28-01098.txt 6 5 28 14 0.0052data5-6-28-01099.txt 6 5 28 21 0.0047data5-6-28-01100.txt 6 5 28 13 0.0058data5-6-29-01101.txt 6 5 29 22 0.0072data5-6-29-01102.txt 6 5 29 20 0.0068data5-6-29-01103.txt 6 5 29 21 0.0071data5-6-29-01104.txt 6 5 29 23 0.0055data5-6-29-01105.txt 6 5 29 27 0.0052data5-6-29-01106.txt 6 5 29 18 0.0053data5-6-29-01107.txt 6 5 29 19 0.0053data5-6-29-01108.txt 6 5 29 24 0.0078data5-6-29-01109.txt 6 5 29 22 0.0051data5-6-29-01110.txt 6 5 29 27 0.0052data5-6-29-01111.txt 6 5 29 27 0.0110data5-6-29-01112.txt 6 5 29 18 0.0085data5-6-29-01113.txt 6 5 29 20 0.0062data5-6-29-01114.txt 6 5 29 21 0.0050data5-6-29-01115.txt 6 5 29 22 0.0053data5-6-29-01116.txt 6 5 29 24 0.1636data5-6-29-01117.txt 6 5 29 22 0.0051data5-6-29-01118.txt 6 5 29 23 0.0052data5-6-29-01119.txt 6 5 29 19 0.0058data5-6-29-01120.txt 6 5 29 25 0.1331

Table 56: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 262: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-6-29-01121.txt 6 5 29 32 0.0049data5-6-29-01122.txt 6 5 29 19 0.0069data5-6-29-01123.txt 6 5 29 16 0.0049data5-6-29-01124.txt 6 5 29 21 0.0088data5-6-29-01125.txt 6 5 29 21 0.0055data5-6-29-01126.txt 6 5 29 29 0.0055data5-6-29-01127.txt 6 5 29 23 0.0643data5-6-29-01128.txt 6 5 29 18 0.0047data5-6-29-01129.txt 6 5 29 19 0.0047data5-6-29-01130.txt 6 5 29 24 0.0069data5-6-29-01131.txt 6 5 29 21 0.0309data5-6-29-01132.txt 6 5 29 20 0.0199data5-6-29-01133.txt 6 5 29 15 0.0048data5-6-29-01134.txt 6 5 29 22 0.0050data5-6-29-01135.txt 6 5 29 19 0.0046data5-6-29-01136.txt 6 5 29 19 0.0048data5-6-29-01137.txt 6 5 29 18 0.0054data5-6-29-01138.txt 6 5 29 19 0.0055data5-6-29-01139.txt 6 5 29 20 0.0050data5-6-29-01140.txt 6 5 29 19 0.0051data5-6-29-01141.txt 6 5 29 20 0.0049data5-6-29-01142.txt 6 5 29 25 0.0078data5-6-29-01143.txt 6 5 29 18 0.0054data5-6-29-01144.txt 6 5 29 15 0.0051data5-6-29-01145.txt 6 5 29 19 0.0048data5-6-29-01146.txt 6 5 29 23 0.0072data5-6-29-01147.txt 6 5 29 23 0.0051data5-6-29-01148.txt 6 5 29 21 0.0171data5-6-29-01149.txt 6 5 29 16 0.0051data5-6-29-01150.txt 6 5 29 25 0.0065data5-6-29-01151.txt 6 5 29 19 0.0602data5-6-29-01152.txt 6 5 29 22 0.0053data5-6-29-01153.txt 6 5 29 25 0.0047data5-6-29-01154.txt 6 5 29 19 0.0052data5-6-29-01155.txt 6 5 29 19 0.0066data5-6-29-01156.txt 6 5 29 19 0.0049data5-6-29-01157.txt 6 5 29 20 0.0054data5-6-29-01158.txt 6 5 29 19 0.0054data5-6-29-01159.txt 6 5 29 15 0.0049data5-6-29-01160.txt 6 5 29 20 0.0050data5-6-29-01161.txt 6 5 29 27 0.0057data5-6-29-01162.txt 6 5 29 15 0.0063data5-6-29-01163.txt 6 5 29 23 0.0059data5-6-29-01164.txt 6 5 29 22 0.0070data5-6-29-01165.txt 6 5 29 25 0.0056data5-6-29-01166.txt 6 5 29 21 0.0077data5-6-29-01167.txt 6 5 29 26 0.0242data5-6-29-01168.txt 6 5 29 18 0.0066data5-6-29-01169.txt 6 5 29 16 0.0424data5-6-29-01170.txt 6 5 29 23 0.0073data5-6-29-01171.txt 6 5 29 27 0.0049data5-6-29-01172.txt 6 5 29 21 0.0522data5-6-29-01173.txt 6 5 29 19 0.0046data5-6-29-01174.txt 6 5 29 25 0.0116data5-6-29-01175.txt 6 5 29 20 0.0055data5-6-29-01176.txt 6 5 29 25 0.0052data5-6-29-01177.txt 6 5 29 21 0.0056data5-6-29-01178.txt 6 5 29 25 0.0079data5-6-29-01179.txt 6 5 29 22 0.0050data5-6-29-01180.txt 6 5 29 20 0.0057data5-6-29-01181.txt 6 5 29 19 0.0220data5-6-29-01182.txt 6 5 29 21 0.0052data5-6-29-01183.txt 6 5 29 23 0.0046data5-6-29-01184.txt 6 5 29 22 0.0075data5-6-29-01185.txt 6 5 29 18 0.0071data5-6-29-01186.txt 6 5 29 19 0.0075data5-6-29-01187.txt 6 5 29 21 0.0101data5-6-29-01188.txt 6 5 29 22 0.0076data5-6-29-01189.txt 6 5 29 20 0.0295data5-6-29-01190.txt 6 5 29 23 0.0070

Table 57: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 263: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-6-29-01191.txt 6 5 29 23 0.0047data5-6-29-01192.txt 6 5 29 13 0.0049data5-6-29-01193.txt 6 5 29 17 0.0062data5-6-29-01194.txt 6 5 29 22 0.1808data5-6-29-01195.txt 6 5 29 21 0.0047data5-6-29-01196.txt 6 5 29 22 0.0061data5-6-29-01197.txt 6 5 29 26 0.0051data5-6-29-01198.txt 6 5 29 16 0.0059data5-6-29-01199.txt 6 5 29 21 0.0055data5-6-29-01200.txt 6 5 29 23 0.0062data5-7-30-03201.txt 7 5 30 16 0.0055data5-7-30-03202.txt 7 5 30 21 0.3196data5-7-30-03203.txt 7 5 30 19 0.0154data5-7-30-03204.txt 7 5 30 20 0.0070data5-7-30-03205.txt 7 5 30 22 0.0077data5-7-30-03206.txt 7 5 30 23 0.0083data5-7-30-03207.txt 7 5 30 22 0.0056data5-7-30-03208.txt 7 5 30 18 0.0050data5-7-30-03209.txt 7 5 30 21 0.0051data5-7-30-03210.txt 7 5 30 17 0.0085data5-7-30-03211.txt 7 5 30 21 0.0057data5-7-30-03212.txt 7 5 30 20 0.0610data5-7-30-03213.txt 7 5 30 22 0.0071data5-7-30-03214.txt 7 5 30 16 0.0052data5-7-30-03215.txt 7 5 30 16 0.0072data5-7-30-03216.txt 7 5 30 26 0.0055data5-7-30-03217.txt 7 5 30 24 0.0095data5-7-30-03218.txt 7 5 30 19 0.0052data5-7-30-03219.txt 7 5 30 25 0.0266data5-7-30-03220.txt 7 5 30 19 0.0052data5-7-30-03221.txt 7 5 30 19 0.0054data5-7-30-03222.txt 7 5 30 20 0.0209data5-7-30-03223.txt 7 5 30 19 0.1268data5-7-30-03224.txt 7 5 30 20 0.0319data5-7-30-03225.txt 7 5 30 13 0.0053data5-7-30-03226.txt 7 5 30 21 0.0076data5-7-30-03227.txt 7 5 30 15 0.0054data5-7-30-03228.txt 7 5 30 16 0.0053data5-7-30-03229.txt 7 5 30 19 0.0055data5-7-30-03230.txt 7 5 30 23 0.0060data5-7-30-03231.txt 7 5 30 21 0.0067data5-7-30-03232.txt 7 5 30 21 0.0050data5-7-30-03233.txt 7 5 30 20 0.0051data5-7-30-03234.txt 7 5 30 23 0.0168data5-7-30-03235.txt 7 5 30 24 0.0071data5-7-30-03236.txt 7 5 30 21 0.0912data5-7-30-03237.txt 7 5 30 17 0.0055data5-7-30-03238.txt 7 5 30 16 0.0050data5-7-30-03239.txt 7 5 30 18 0.0053data5-7-30-03240.txt 7 5 30 21 0.0049data5-7-30-03241.txt 7 5 30 21 0.0057data5-7-30-03242.txt 7 5 30 24 0.0429data5-7-30-03243.txt 7 5 30 19 0.0067data5-7-30-03244.txt 7 5 30 24 0.0230data5-7-30-03245.txt 7 5 30 26 0.0082data5-7-30-03246.txt 7 5 30 20 0.0431data5-7-30-03247.txt 7 5 30 21 0.0050data5-7-30-03248.txt 7 5 30 21 0.0053data5-7-30-03249.txt 7 5 30 29 0.0063data5-7-30-03250.txt 7 5 30 22 0.0490data5-7-30-03251.txt 7 5 30 18 0.0051data5-7-30-03252.txt 7 5 30 21 0.0400data5-7-30-03253.txt 7 5 30 23 0.0081data5-7-30-03254.txt 7 5 30 19 0.0054data5-7-30-03255.txt 7 5 30 19 0.0063data5-7-30-03256.txt 7 5 30 24 0.0061data5-7-30-03257.txt 7 5 30 25 0.0084data5-7-30-03258.txt 7 5 30 27 0.0119data5-7-30-03259.txt 7 5 30 16 0.0081data5-7-30-03260.txt 7 5 30 17 0.0052

Table 58: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 264: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-7-30-03261.txt 7 5 30 18 0.0136data5-7-30-03262.txt 7 5 30 16 0.0056data5-7-30-03263.txt 7 5 30 22 0.1171data5-7-30-03264.txt 7 5 30 19 0.0074data5-7-30-03265.txt 7 5 30 18 0.0118data5-7-30-03266.txt 7 5 30 16 0.0056data5-7-30-03267.txt 7 5 30 23 0.0165data5-7-30-03268.txt 7 5 30 17 0.0061data5-7-30-03269.txt 7 5 30 13 0.0050data5-7-30-03270.txt 7 5 30 20 0.0124data5-7-30-03271.txt 7 5 30 29 0.0410data5-7-30-03272.txt 7 5 30 18 0.0050data5-7-30-03273.txt 7 5 30 21 0.0573data5-7-30-03274.txt 7 5 30 23 0.0974data5-7-30-03275.txt 7 5 30 21 0.0064data5-7-30-03276.txt 7 5 30 19 0.0168data5-7-30-03277.txt 7 5 30 22 0.0128data5-7-30-03278.txt 7 5 30 14 0.0049data5-7-30-03279.txt 7 5 30 20 0.0050data5-7-30-03280.txt 7 5 30 21 0.0055data5-7-30-03281.txt 7 5 30 14 0.0056data5-7-30-03282.txt 7 5 30 16 0.0075data5-7-30-03283.txt 7 5 30 17 0.1082data5-7-30-03284.txt 7 5 30 21 0.0092data5-7-30-03285.txt 7 5 30 21 0.0156data5-7-30-03286.txt 7 5 30 18 0.0059data5-7-30-03287.txt 7 5 30 19 0.0368data5-7-30-03288.txt 7 5 30 16 0.0050data5-7-30-03289.txt 7 5 30 18 0.0187data5-7-30-03290.txt 7 5 30 15 0.0057data5-7-30-03291.txt 7 5 30 22 0.0084data5-7-30-03292.txt 7 5 30 17 0.0050data5-7-30-03293.txt 7 5 30 17 0.0047data5-7-30-03294.txt 7 5 30 22 0.0130data5-7-30-03295.txt 7 5 30 21 0.0055data5-7-30-03296.txt 7 5 30 24 0.0073data5-7-30-03297.txt 7 5 30 23 0.0056data5-7-30-03298.txt 7 5 30 22 0.0057data5-7-30-03299.txt 7 5 30 27 0.0309data5-7-30-03300.txt 7 5 30 21 0.1541data5-7-31-03301.txt 7 5 31 25 0.3448data5-7-31-03302.txt 7 5 31 18 0.0049data5-7-31-03303.txt 7 5 31 22 0.0087data5-7-31-03304.txt 7 5 31 25 0.0054data5-7-31-03305.txt 7 5 31 23 0.3459data5-7-31-03306.txt 7 5 31 22 0.0051data5-7-31-03307.txt 7 5 31 26 0.0531data5-7-31-03308.txt 7 5 31 31 0.0174data5-7-31-03309.txt 7 5 31 16 0.0052data5-7-31-03310.txt 7 5 31 19 0.0056data5-7-31-03311.txt 7 5 31 23 0.0064data5-7-31-03312.txt 7 5 31 20 0.0055data5-7-31-03313.txt 7 5 31 24 0.0057data5-7-31-03314.txt 7 5 31 23 0.0315data5-7-31-03315.txt 7 5 31 25 0.0135data5-7-31-03316.txt 7 5 31 22 0.0059data5-7-31-03317.txt 7 5 31 17 0.0057data5-7-31-03318.txt 7 5 31 28 0.0217data5-7-31-03319.txt 7 5 31 19 0.0061data5-7-31-03320.txt 7 5 31 19 0.0063data5-7-31-03321.txt 7 5 31 18 0.0053data5-7-31-03322.txt 7 5 31 20 0.0056data5-7-31-03323.txt 7 5 31 26 0.0058data5-7-31-03324.txt 7 5 31 24 0.1018data5-7-31-03325.txt 7 5 31 20 0.0418data5-7-31-03326.txt 7 5 31 17 0.0053data5-7-31-03327.txt 7 5 31 14 0.0050data5-7-31-03328.txt 7 5 31 20 0.0059data5-7-31-03329.txt 7 5 31 16 0.0058data5-7-31-03330.txt 7 5 31 26 0.1802

Table 59: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 265: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-7-31-03331.txt 7 5 31 24 0.0058data5-7-31-03332.txt 7 5 31 23 0.0056data5-7-31-03333.txt 7 5 31 25 0.0951data5-7-31-03334.txt 7 5 31 21 0.0429data5-7-31-03335.txt 7 5 31 22 0.1026data5-7-31-03336.txt 7 5 31 20 0.0051data5-7-31-03337.txt 7 5 31 23 0.0067data5-7-31-03338.txt 7 5 31 21 0.0150data5-7-31-03339.txt 7 5 31 22 0.0058data5-7-31-03340.txt 7 5 31 21 0.0053data5-7-31-03341.txt 7 5 31 17 0.0075data5-7-31-03342.txt 7 5 31 29 0.0113data5-7-31-03343.txt 7 5 31 22 0.0062data5-7-31-03344.txt 7 5 31 18 0.0099data5-7-31-03345.txt 7 5 31 22 0.0420data5-7-31-03346.txt 7 5 31 22 0.1481data5-7-31-03347.txt 7 5 31 28 0.0253data5-7-31-03348.txt 7 5 31 21 0.0062data5-7-31-03349.txt 7 5 31 20 0.0054data5-7-31-03350.txt 7 5 31 26 0.0062data5-7-31-03351.txt 7 5 31 24 0.0074data5-7-31-03352.txt 7 5 31 22 0.0093data5-7-31-03353.txt 7 5 31 21 0.1613data5-7-31-03354.txt 7 5 31 20 0.0059data5-7-31-03355.txt 7 5 31 18 0.0058data5-7-31-03356.txt 7 5 31 26 0.0060data5-7-31-03357.txt 7 5 31 24 0.0058data5-7-31-03358.txt 7 5 31 21 0.0068data5-7-31-03359.txt 7 5 31 17 0.0053data5-7-31-03360.txt 7 5 31 21 0.0066data5-7-31-03361.txt 7 5 31 27 0.2478data5-7-31-03362.txt 7 5 31 29 0.0309data5-7-31-03363.txt 7 5 31 22 0.0139data5-7-31-03364.txt 7 5 31 20 0.0382data5-7-31-03365.txt 7 5 31 23 0.0145data5-7-31-03366.txt 7 5 31 22 0.0146data5-7-31-03367.txt 7 5 31 25 0.0077data5-7-31-03368.txt 7 5 31 23 0.0061data5-7-31-03369.txt 7 5 31 20 0.0412data5-7-31-03370.txt 7 5 31 16 0.0069data5-7-31-03371.txt 7 5 31 17 0.0054data5-7-31-03372.txt 7 5 31 20 0.0069data5-7-31-03373.txt 7 5 31 15 0.0055data5-7-31-03374.txt 7 5 31 17 0.0052data5-7-31-03375.txt 7 5 31 29 0.0158data5-7-31-03376.txt 7 5 31 26 0.0216data5-7-31-03377.txt 7 5 31 18 0.0050data5-7-31-03378.txt 7 5 31 19 0.0060data5-7-31-03379.txt 7 5 31 18 0.0165data5-7-31-03380.txt 7 5 31 22 0.0058data5-7-31-03381.txt 7 5 31 23 0.2146data5-7-31-03382.txt 7 5 31 23 0.1125data5-7-31-03383.txt 7 5 31 20 0.0051data5-7-31-03384.txt 7 5 31 17 0.0059data5-7-31-03385.txt 7 5 31 22 0.0063data5-7-31-03386.txt 7 5 31 18 0.0059data5-7-31-03387.txt 7 5 31 22 0.0104data5-7-31-03388.txt 7 5 31 29 0.0707data5-7-31-03389.txt 7 5 31 22 0.0062data5-7-31-03390.txt 7 5 31 21 0.0064data5-7-31-03391.txt 7 5 31 28 0.2040data5-7-31-03392.txt 7 5 31 25 0.0488data5-7-31-03393.txt 7 5 31 21 0.0051data5-7-31-03394.txt 7 5 31 22 0.0063data5-7-31-03395.txt 7 5 31 20 0.0057data5-7-31-03396.txt 7 5 31 25 0.0052data5-7-31-03397.txt 7 5 31 25 0.0078data5-7-31-03398.txt 7 5 31 23 0.0132data5-7-31-03399.txt 7 5 31 22 0.0057data5-7-31-03400.txt 7 5 31 21 0.0053

Table 60: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 266: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-7-32-03401.txt 7 5 32 16 0.0060data5-7-32-03402.txt 7 5 32 23 0.0080data5-7-32-03403.txt 7 5 32 26 0.1948data5-7-32-03404.txt 7 5 32 22 0.0058data5-7-32-03405.txt 7 5 32 24 0.0056data5-7-32-03406.txt 7 5 32 18 0.0057data5-7-32-03407.txt 7 5 32 25 0.0062data5-7-32-03408.txt 7 5 32 25 0.0267data5-7-32-03409.txt 7 5 32 24 0.0056data5-7-32-03410.txt 7 5 32 20 0.0059data5-7-32-03411.txt 7 5 32 31 0.0106data5-7-32-03412.txt 7 5 32 20 0.0060data5-7-32-03413.txt 7 5 32 26 0.0809data5-7-32-03414.txt 7 5 32 31 0.0578data5-7-32-03415.txt 7 5 32 24 0.0307data5-7-32-03416.txt 7 5 32 17 0.0064data5-7-32-03417.txt 7 5 32 24 0.0090data5-7-32-03418.txt 7 5 32 27 0.0853data5-7-32-03419.txt 7 5 32 24 0.0493data5-7-32-03420.txt 7 5 32 17 0.0057data5-7-32-03421.txt 7 5 32 21 0.0058data5-7-32-03422.txt 7 5 32 26 0.0069data5-7-32-03423.txt 7 5 32 24 0.0057data5-7-32-03424.txt 7 5 32 21 0.0053data5-7-32-03425.txt 7 5 32 20 0.0053data5-7-32-03426.txt 7 5 32 26 0.0065data5-7-32-03427.txt 7 5 32 24 0.0691data5-7-32-03428.txt 7 5 32 27 0.2824data5-7-32-03429.txt 7 5 32 21 0.0375data5-7-32-03430.txt 7 5 32 18 0.0062data5-7-32-03431.txt 7 5 32 22 0.0053data5-7-32-03432.txt 7 5 32 20 0.0058data5-7-32-03433.txt 7 5 32 22 0.0092data5-7-32-03434.txt 7 5 32 20 0.0057data5-7-32-03435.txt 7 5 32 18 0.0085data5-7-32-03436.txt 7 5 32 27 0.2256data5-7-32-03437.txt 7 5 32 20 0.0057data5-7-32-03438.txt 7 5 32 19 0.0071data5-7-32-03439.txt 7 5 32 23 0.0059data5-7-32-03440.txt 7 5 32 28 0.0231data5-7-32-03441.txt 7 5 32 18 0.0053data5-7-32-03442.txt 7 5 32 22 0.0052data5-7-32-03443.txt 7 5 32 23 0.0062data5-7-32-03444.txt 7 5 32 28 0.0092data5-7-32-03445.txt 7 5 32 14 0.0052data5-7-32-03446.txt 7 5 32 25 0.0066data5-7-32-03447.txt 7 5 32 21 0.0058data5-7-32-03448.txt 7 5 32 23 0.0073data5-7-32-03449.txt 7 5 32 22 0.0083data5-7-32-03450.txt 7 5 32 20 0.0061data5-7-32-03451.txt 7 5 32 21 0.0054data5-7-32-03452.txt 7 5 32 28 0.0066data5-7-32-03453.txt 7 5 32 20 0.0064data5-7-32-03454.txt 7 5 32 27 0.0085data5-7-32-03455.txt 7 5 32 18 0.0057data5-7-32-03456.txt 7 5 32 26 0.0057data5-7-32-03457.txt 7 5 32 21 0.0458data5-7-32-03458.txt 7 5 32 21 0.0230data5-7-32-03459.txt 7 5 32 26 0.0063data5-7-32-03460.txt 7 5 32 20 0.0055data5-7-32-03461.txt 7 5 32 25 0.0223data5-7-32-03462.txt 7 5 32 22 0.0060data5-7-32-03463.txt 7 5 32 20 0.0055data5-7-32-03464.txt 7 5 32 30 0.2975data5-7-32-03465.txt 7 5 32 20 0.0072data5-7-32-03466.txt 7 5 32 20 0.0056data5-7-32-03467.txt 7 5 32 24 0.0703data5-7-32-03468.txt 7 5 32 25 0.0067data5-7-32-03469.txt 7 5 32 21 0.0058data5-7-32-03470.txt 7 5 32 19 0.0053

Table 61: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 267: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-7-32-03471.txt 7 5 32 27 0.0109data5-7-32-03472.txt 7 5 32 27 0.0103data5-7-32-03473.txt 7 5 32 31 0.0053data5-7-32-03474.txt 7 5 32 21 0.0265data5-7-32-03475.txt 7 5 32 24 0.0075data5-7-32-03476.txt 7 5 32 14 0.0052data5-7-32-03477.txt 7 5 32 20 0.0944data5-7-32-03478.txt 7 5 32 24 0.0051data5-7-32-03479.txt 7 5 32 21 0.0053data5-7-32-03480.txt 7 5 32 21 0.0057data5-7-32-03481.txt 7 5 32 27 0.0250data5-7-32-03482.txt 7 5 32 26 0.0272data5-7-32-03483.txt 7 5 32 21 0.0089data5-7-32-03484.txt 7 5 32 27 0.0478data5-7-32-03485.txt 7 5 32 24 0.0073data5-7-32-03486.txt 7 5 32 24 0.0059data5-7-32-03487.txt 7 5 32 24 0.0053data5-7-32-03488.txt 7 5 32 18 0.0063data5-7-32-03489.txt 7 5 32 20 0.0059data5-7-32-03490.txt 7 5 32 28 0.2456data5-7-32-03491.txt 7 5 32 21 0.0202data5-7-32-03492.txt 7 5 32 27 0.0083data5-7-32-03493.txt 7 5 32 20 0.0063data5-7-32-03494.txt 7 5 32 20 0.0085data5-7-32-03495.txt 7 5 32 29 0.0110data5-7-32-03496.txt 7 5 32 20 0.0064data5-7-32-03497.txt 7 5 32 22 0.0066data5-7-32-03498.txt 7 5 32 16 0.0054data5-7-32-03499.txt 7 5 32 25 0.0686data5-7-32-03500.txt 7 5 32 18 0.0060data5-7-33-03501.txt 7 5 33 16 0.0573data5-7-33-03502.txt 7 5 33 21 0.0095data5-7-33-03503.txt 7 5 33 22 0.0080data5-7-33-03504.txt 7 5 33 24 0.0695data5-7-33-03505.txt 7 5 33 22 0.0054data5-7-33-03506.txt 7 5 33 20 0.0057data5-7-33-03507.txt 7 5 33 25 0.0058data5-7-33-03508.txt 7 5 33 20 0.0052data5-7-33-03509.txt 7 5 33 22 0.0065data5-7-33-03510.txt 7 5 33 26 0.0076data5-7-33-03511.txt 7 5 33 29 0.0089data5-7-33-03512.txt 7 5 33 23 0.0054data5-7-33-03513.txt 7 5 33 24 0.0083data5-7-33-03514.txt 7 5 33 23 0.0118data5-7-33-03515.txt 7 5 33 20 0.0172data5-7-33-03516.txt 7 5 33 23 0.0066data5-7-33-03517.txt 7 5 33 24 0.0062data5-7-33-03518.txt 7 5 33 21 0.0056data5-7-33-03519.txt 7 5 33 27 0.0056data5-7-33-03520.txt 7 5 33 25 0.0069data5-7-33-03521.txt 7 5 33 19 0.0065data5-7-33-03522.txt 7 5 33 27 0.0138data5-7-33-03523.txt 7 5 33 22 0.0062data5-7-33-03524.txt 7 5 33 18 0.0079data5-7-33-03525.txt 7 5 33 28 0.0894data5-7-33-03526.txt 7 5 33 26 0.0055data5-7-33-03527.txt 7 5 33 20 0.0130data5-7-33-03528.txt 7 5 33 18 0.0085data5-7-33-03529.txt 7 5 33 21 0.0114data5-7-33-03530.txt 7 5 33 19 0.0058data5-7-33-03531.txt 7 5 33 18 0.0059data5-7-33-03532.txt 7 5 33 21 0.0062data5-7-33-03533.txt 7 5 33 23 0.0083data5-7-33-03534.txt 7 5 33 27 0.0546data5-7-33-03535.txt 7 5 33 23 0.0077data5-7-33-03536.txt 7 5 33 33 0.1965data5-7-33-03537.txt 7 5 33 25 0.0188data5-7-33-03538.txt 7 5 33 21 0.0056data5-7-33-03539.txt 7 5 33 18 0.0334data5-7-33-03540.txt 7 5 33 23 0.0071

Table 62: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 268: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-7-33-03541.txt 7 5 33 21 0.0060data5-7-33-03542.txt 7 5 33 27 0.0063data5-7-33-03543.txt 7 5 33 21 0.0058data5-7-33-03544.txt 7 5 33 22 0.1389data5-7-33-03545.txt 7 5 33 26 0.0057data5-7-33-03546.txt 7 5 33 27 0.1315data5-7-33-03547.txt 7 5 33 22 0.0901data5-7-33-03548.txt 7 5 33 19 0.0057data5-7-33-03549.txt 7 5 33 24 0.0060data5-7-33-03550.txt 7 5 33 29 0.0389data5-7-33-03551.txt 7 5 33 22 0.0255data5-7-33-03552.txt 7 5 33 19 0.0056data5-7-33-03553.txt 7 5 33 24 0.0060data5-7-33-03554.txt 7 5 33 18 0.0065data5-7-33-03555.txt 7 5 33 27 0.0228data5-7-33-03556.txt 7 5 33 26 0.1095data5-7-33-03557.txt 7 5 33 23 0.0071data5-7-33-03558.txt 7 5 33 30 0.0844data5-7-33-03559.txt 7 5 33 21 0.0531data5-7-33-03560.txt 7 5 33 25 0.0141data5-7-33-03561.txt 7 5 33 27 0.0058data5-7-33-03562.txt 7 5 33 29 0.0096data5-7-33-03563.txt 7 5 33 31 0.0230data5-7-33-03564.txt 7 5 33 27 0.0087data5-7-33-03565.txt 7 5 33 28 0.0081data5-7-33-03566.txt 7 5 33 19 0.0057data5-7-33-03567.txt 7 5 33 30 0.0058data5-7-33-03568.txt 7 5 33 21 0.0080data5-7-33-03569.txt 7 5 33 23 0.0102data5-7-33-03570.txt 7 5 33 23 0.0059data5-7-33-03571.txt 7 5 33 27 0.0073data5-7-33-03572.txt 7 5 33 21 0.1748data5-7-33-03573.txt 7 5 33 17 0.0056data5-7-33-03574.txt 7 5 33 21 0.0057data5-7-33-03575.txt 7 5 33 32 0.0227data5-7-33-03576.txt 7 5 33 25 0.0060data5-7-33-03577.txt 7 5 33 30 0.0059data5-7-33-03578.txt 7 5 33 26 0.0056data5-7-33-03579.txt 7 5 33 20 0.0069data5-7-33-03580.txt 7 5 33 28 0.2648data5-7-33-03581.txt 7 5 33 22 0.0090data5-7-33-03582.txt 7 5 33 23 0.0094data5-7-33-03583.txt 7 5 33 21 0.0056data5-7-33-03584.txt 7 5 33 20 0.0062data5-7-33-03585.txt 7 5 33 23 0.0059data5-7-33-03586.txt 7 5 33 26 0.0070data5-7-33-03587.txt 7 5 33 24 0.0060data5-7-33-03588.txt 7 5 33 15 0.0058data5-7-33-03589.txt 7 5 33 26 0.0063data5-7-33-03590.txt 7 5 33 23 0.5519data5-7-33-03591.txt 7 5 33 18 0.0054data5-7-33-03592.txt 7 5 33 25 0.0122data5-7-33-03593.txt 7 5 33 31 0.0109data5-7-33-03594.txt 7 5 33 23 0.0068data5-7-33-03595.txt 7 5 33 26 0.0515data5-7-33-03596.txt 7 5 33 19 0.0057data5-7-33-03597.txt 7 5 33 25 0.0056data5-7-33-03598.txt 7 5 33 18 0.0060data5-7-33-03599.txt 7 5 33 29 0.0572data5-7-33-03600.txt 7 5 33 18 0.0054data5-7-34-03601.txt 7 5 34 30 0.0073data5-7-34-03602.txt 7 5 34 28 0.0065data5-7-34-03603.txt 7 5 34 23 0.0060data5-7-34-03604.txt 7 5 34 24 0.0069data5-7-34-03605.txt 7 5 34 21 0.0059data5-7-34-03606.txt 7 5 34 21 0.0053data5-7-34-03607.txt 7 5 34 28 0.0814data5-7-34-03608.txt 7 5 34 23 0.0059data5-7-34-03609.txt 7 5 34 21 0.0060data5-7-34-03610.txt 7 5 34 21 0.0069

Table 63: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 269: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-7-34-03611.txt 7 5 34 27 0.1280data5-7-34-03612.txt 7 5 34 24 0.0149data5-7-34-03613.txt 7 5 34 30 0.0078data5-7-34-03614.txt 7 5 34 23 0.0351data5-7-34-03615.txt 7 5 34 24 0.0678data5-7-34-03616.txt 7 5 34 19 0.0056data5-7-34-03617.txt 7 5 34 18 0.0057data5-7-34-03618.txt 7 5 34 27 0.0060data5-7-34-03619.txt 7 5 34 33 0.0060data5-7-34-03620.txt 7 5 34 31 0.0070data5-7-34-03621.txt 7 5 34 27 0.0803data5-7-34-03622.txt 7 5 34 29 0.0052data5-7-34-03623.txt 7 5 34 23 0.0056data5-7-34-03624.txt 7 5 34 28 0.0135data5-7-34-03625.txt 7 5 34 19 0.0073data5-7-34-03626.txt 7 5 34 21 0.0570data5-7-34-03627.txt 7 5 34 22 0.0090data5-7-34-03628.txt 7 5 34 24 0.0086data5-7-34-03629.txt 7 5 34 25 0.0214data5-7-34-03630.txt 7 5 34 21 0.0067data5-7-34-03631.txt 7 5 34 25 0.0082data5-7-34-03632.txt 7 5 34 25 0.0203data5-7-34-03633.txt 7 5 34 26 0.0054data5-7-34-03634.txt 7 5 34 27 0.0057data5-7-34-03635.txt 7 5 34 26 0.0726data5-7-34-03636.txt 7 5 34 27 0.0080data5-7-34-03637.txt 7 5 34 20 0.0061data5-7-34-03638.txt 7 5 34 20 0.0057data5-7-34-03639.txt 7 5 34 29 0.0456data5-7-34-03640.txt 7 5 34 25 0.0099data5-7-34-03641.txt 7 5 34 30 0.0168data5-7-34-03642.txt 7 5 34 29 0.0065data5-7-34-03643.txt 7 5 34 26 0.0060data5-7-34-03644.txt 7 5 34 28 0.0140data5-7-34-03645.txt 7 5 34 21 0.0062data5-7-34-03646.txt 7 5 34 21 0.0057data5-7-34-03647.txt 7 5 34 22 0.0064data5-7-34-03648.txt 7 5 34 16 0.0056data5-7-34-03649.txt 7 5 34 22 0.0056data5-7-34-03650.txt 7 5 34 27 0.1436data5-7-34-03651.txt 7 5 34 22 0.0054data5-7-34-03652.txt 7 5 34 27 0.0057data5-7-34-03653.txt 7 5 34 28 0.0099data5-7-34-03654.txt 7 5 34 21 0.0062data5-7-34-03655.txt 7 5 34 24 0.0239data5-7-34-03656.txt 7 5 34 25 0.0071data5-7-34-03657.txt 7 5 34 30 0.0076data5-7-34-03658.txt 7 5 34 25 0.3170data5-7-34-03659.txt 7 5 34 20 0.0053data5-7-34-03660.txt 7 5 34 26 0.0057data5-7-34-03661.txt 7 5 34 28 0.0075data5-7-34-03662.txt 7 5 34 29 0.0081data5-7-34-03663.txt 7 5 34 28 0.0102data5-7-34-03664.txt 7 5 34 31 0.0057data5-7-34-03665.txt 7 5 34 23 0.0052data5-7-34-03666.txt 7 5 34 22 0.0438data5-7-34-03667.txt 7 5 34 24 0.0061data5-7-34-03668.txt 7 5 34 26 0.0057data5-7-34-03669.txt 7 5 34 19 0.0060data5-7-34-03670.txt 7 5 34 28 0.0057data5-7-34-03671.txt 7 5 34 22 0.0067data5-7-34-03672.txt 7 5 34 21 0.0062data5-7-34-03673.txt 7 5 34 24 0.0057data5-7-34-03674.txt 7 5 34 25 0.0057data5-7-34-03675.txt 7 5 34 26 0.0057data5-7-34-03676.txt 7 5 34 24 0.0076data5-7-34-03677.txt 7 5 34 24 0.0057data5-7-34-03678.txt 7 5 34 23 0.0054data5-7-34-03679.txt 7 5 34 32 0.0214data5-7-34-03680.txt 7 5 34 28 0.0060

Table 64: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 270: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-7-34-03681.txt 7 5 34 16 0.0057data5-7-34-03682.txt 7 5 34 28 0.0111data5-7-34-03683.txt 7 5 34 21 0.0975data5-7-34-03684.txt 7 5 34 30 0.0369data5-7-34-03685.txt 7 5 34 23 0.0065data5-7-34-03686.txt 7 5 34 22 0.0240data5-7-34-03687.txt 7 5 34 25 0.0054data5-7-34-03688.txt 7 5 34 28 0.0088data5-7-34-03689.txt 7 5 34 23 0.0057data5-7-34-03690.txt 7 5 34 16 0.0063data5-7-34-03691.txt 7 5 34 28 0.0070data5-7-34-03692.txt 7 5 34 26 0.0067data5-7-34-03693.txt 7 5 34 22 0.0058data5-7-34-03694.txt 7 5 34 22 0.0114data5-7-34-03695.txt 7 5 34 21 0.0071data5-7-34-03696.txt 7 5 34 17 0.0188data5-7-34-03697.txt 7 5 34 30 0.3240data5-7-34-03698.txt 7 5 34 30 0.0122data5-7-34-03699.txt 7 5 34 21 0.0062data5-7-34-03700.txt 7 5 34 23 0.0056data5-8-35-05701.txt 8 5 35 22 0.0072data5-8-35-05702.txt 8 5 35 24 0.6351data5-8-35-05703.txt 8 5 35 22 0.0032data5-8-35-05704.txt 8 5 35 27 0.3852data5-8-35-05705.txt 8 5 35 24 0.0536data5-8-35-05706.txt 8 5 35 24 0.0060data5-8-35-05707.txt 8 5 35 21 0.0276data5-8-35-05708.txt 8 5 35 22 0.0969data5-8-35-05709.txt 8 5 35 27 0.1512data5-8-35-05710.txt 8 5 35 22 0.0069data5-8-35-05711.txt 8 5 35 27 0.1061data5-8-35-05712.txt 8 5 35 16 0.0033data5-8-35-05713.txt 8 5 35 21 0.3470data5-8-35-05714.txt 8 5 35 25 0.2539data5-8-35-05715.txt 8 5 35 19 0.0032data5-8-35-05716.txt 8 5 35 27 0.0237data5-8-35-05717.txt 8 5 35 24 0.0052data5-8-35-05718.txt 8 5 35 20 0.0054data5-8-35-05719.txt 8 5 35 21 0.0033data5-8-35-05720.txt 8 5 35 21 0.0032data5-8-35-05721.txt 8 5 35 21 0.0033data5-8-35-05722.txt 8 5 35 24 0.3031data5-8-35-05723.txt 8 5 35 25 0.0048data5-8-35-05724.txt 8 5 35 26 0.5201data5-8-35-05725.txt 8 5 35 22 0.0034data5-8-35-05726.txt 8 5 35 27 0.3185data5-8-35-05727.txt 8 5 35 22 0.0035data5-8-35-05728.txt 8 5 35 23 0.0034data5-8-35-05729.txt 8 5 35 18 0.0073data5-8-35-05730.txt 8 5 35 22 0.0037data5-8-35-05731.txt 8 5 35 26 0.0037data5-8-35-05732.txt 8 5 35 22 0.0032data5-8-35-05733.txt 8 5 35 27 0.0037data5-8-35-05734.txt 8 5 35 25 0.0062data5-8-35-05735.txt 8 5 35 22 0.0102data5-8-35-05736.txt 8 5 35 20 0.0034data5-8-35-05737.txt 8 5 35 27 0.1214data5-8-35-05738.txt 8 5 35 19 0.0271data5-8-35-05739.txt 8 5 35 25 0.0068data5-8-35-05740.txt 8 5 35 31 0.2260data5-8-35-05741.txt 8 5 35 29 0.1861data5-8-35-05742.txt 8 5 35 27 0.0237data5-8-35-05743.txt 8 5 35 29 0.0134data5-8-35-05744.txt 8 5 35 24 0.0063data5-8-35-05745.txt 8 5 35 25 0.0037data5-8-35-05746.txt 8 5 35 25 0.0032data5-8-35-05747.txt 8 5 35 27 0.0292data5-8-35-05748.txt 8 5 35 25 0.0050data5-8-35-05749.txt 8 5 35 24 0.0056data5-8-35-05750.txt 8 5 35 27 0.0042

Table 65: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 271: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-8-35-05751.txt 8 5 35 22 0.0257data5-8-35-05752.txt 8 5 35 25 0.0620data5-8-35-05753.txt 8 5 35 24 0.1443data5-8-35-05754.txt 8 5 35 21 0.4464data5-8-35-05755.txt 8 5 35 22 0.0895data5-8-35-05756.txt 8 5 35 24 0.0626data5-8-35-05757.txt 8 5 35 21 0.0053data5-8-35-05758.txt 8 5 35 23 0.0930data5-8-35-05759.txt 8 5 35 27 0.1041data5-8-35-05760.txt 8 5 35 22 0.0041data5-8-35-05761.txt 8 5 35 18 0.0032data5-8-35-05762.txt 8 5 35 24 0.0320data5-8-35-05763.txt 8 5 35 21 0.0033data5-8-35-05764.txt 8 5 35 25 0.0053data5-8-35-05765.txt 8 5 35 24 0.0032data5-8-35-05766.txt 8 5 35 24 0.0097data5-8-35-05767.txt 8 5 35 26 0.0036data5-8-35-05768.txt 8 5 35 17 0.0035data5-8-35-05769.txt 8 5 35 24 0.4640data5-8-35-05770.txt 8 5 35 25 0.0034data5-8-35-05771.txt 8 5 35 23 0.0034data5-8-35-05772.txt 8 5 35 24 0.0042data5-8-35-05773.txt 8 5 35 25 0.0040data5-8-35-05774.txt 8 5 35 22 0.0034data5-8-35-05775.txt 8 5 35 25 0.0637data5-8-35-05776.txt 8 5 35 17 0.0142data5-8-35-05777.txt 8 5 35 18 0.0037data5-8-35-05778.txt 8 5 35 29 0.2159data5-8-35-05779.txt 8 5 35 25 0.0041data5-8-35-05780.txt 8 5 35 25 0.0039data5-8-35-05781.txt 8 5 35 25 0.0046data5-8-35-05782.txt 8 5 35 19 0.0036data5-8-35-05783.txt 8 5 35 23 0.0208data5-8-35-05784.txt 8 5 35 22 0.0037data5-8-35-05785.txt 8 5 35 26 0.0035data5-8-35-05786.txt 8 5 35 18 0.0096data5-8-35-05787.txt 8 5 35 27 0.0661data5-8-35-05788.txt 8 5 35 23 0.1226data5-8-35-05789.txt 8 5 35 24 0.0121data5-8-35-05790.txt 8 5 35 18 0.0037data5-8-35-05791.txt 8 5 35 19 0.0036data5-8-35-05792.txt 8 5 35 18 0.0035data5-8-35-05793.txt 8 5 35 30 0.1145data5-8-35-05794.txt 8 5 35 20 0.0035data5-8-35-05795.txt 8 5 35 17 0.0031data5-8-35-05796.txt 8 5 35 21 0.0061data5-8-35-05797.txt 8 5 35 25 0.0446data5-8-35-05798.txt 8 5 35 20 0.0035data5-8-35-05799.txt 8 5 35 22 0.0098data5-8-35-05800.txt 8 5 35 29 0.1261data5-8-36-05801.txt 8 5 36 23 0.0262data5-8-36-05802.txt 8 5 36 21 0.0062data5-8-36-05803.txt 8 5 36 21 0.0039data5-8-36-05804.txt 8 5 36 26 0.0040data5-8-36-05805.txt 8 5 36 20 0.0033data5-8-36-05806.txt 8 5 36 29 0.0410data5-8-36-05807.txt 8 5 36 27 0.0063data5-8-36-05808.txt 8 5 36 21 0.0042data5-8-36-05809.txt 8 5 36 28 0.0062data5-8-36-05810.txt 8 5 36 28 0.0037data5-8-36-05811.txt 8 5 36 25 0.0932data5-8-36-05812.txt 8 5 36 19 0.0033data5-8-36-05813.txt 8 5 36 28 0.0048data5-8-36-05814.txt 8 5 36 22 0.0037data5-8-36-05815.txt 8 5 36 26 0.0079data5-8-36-05816.txt 8 5 36 26 0.0038data5-8-36-05817.txt 8 5 36 28 0.0037data5-8-36-05818.txt 8 5 36 23 0.0666data5-8-36-05819.txt 8 5 36 20 0.0034data5-8-36-05820.txt 8 5 36 26 0.0067

Table 66: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 272: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-8-36-05821.txt 8 5 36 24 0.0092data5-8-36-05822.txt 8 5 36 18 0.0036data5-8-36-05823.txt 8 5 36 21 0.2902data5-8-36-05824.txt 8 5 36 20 0.0032data5-8-36-05825.txt 8 5 36 28 0.0887data5-8-36-05826.txt 8 5 36 30 0.1593data5-8-36-05827.txt 8 5 36 26 0.0043data5-8-36-05828.txt 8 5 36 23 0.0051data5-8-36-05829.txt 8 5 36 24 0.1163data5-8-36-05830.txt 8 5 36 26 0.0078data5-8-36-05831.txt 8 5 36 23 0.0310data5-8-36-05832.txt 8 5 36 20 0.0079data5-8-36-05833.txt 8 5 36 28 0.0158data5-8-36-05834.txt 8 5 36 25 0.0054data5-8-36-05835.txt 8 5 36 22 0.0034data5-8-36-05836.txt 8 5 36 23 0.0125data5-8-36-05837.txt 8 5 36 30 0.0473data5-8-36-05838.txt 8 5 36 26 0.0431data5-8-36-05839.txt 8 5 36 32 0.0120data5-8-36-05840.txt 8 5 36 26 0.0246data5-8-36-05841.txt 8 5 36 28 0.5503data5-8-36-05842.txt 8 5 36 26 0.0054data5-8-36-05843.txt 8 5 36 26 0.0039data5-8-36-05844.txt 8 5 36 21 0.0112data5-8-36-05845.txt 8 5 36 29 0.0159data5-8-36-05846.txt 8 5 36 22 0.0043data5-8-36-05847.txt 8 5 36 20 0.0052data5-8-36-05848.txt 8 5 36 26 0.0617data5-8-36-05849.txt 8 5 36 29 0.0039data5-8-36-05850.txt 8 5 36 28 0.0203data5-8-36-05851.txt 8 5 36 26 0.0046data5-8-36-05852.txt 8 5 36 18 0.0036data5-8-36-05853.txt 8 5 36 22 0.0077data5-8-36-05854.txt 8 5 36 31 0.0036data5-8-36-05855.txt 8 5 36 24 0.0060data5-8-36-05856.txt 8 5 36 29 0.0262data5-8-36-05857.txt 8 5 36 23 0.0121data5-8-36-05858.txt 8 5 36 26 0.0303data5-8-36-05859.txt 8 5 36 27 0.0061data5-8-36-05860.txt 8 5 36 21 0.0056data5-8-36-05861.txt 8 5 36 34 0.1077data5-8-36-05862.txt 8 5 36 23 0.0962data5-8-36-05863.txt 8 5 36 28 0.0058data5-8-36-05864.txt 8 5 36 22 0.0041data5-8-36-05865.txt 8 5 36 20 0.0046data5-8-36-05866.txt 8 5 36 30 0.0886data5-8-36-05867.txt 8 5 36 22 0.0052data5-8-36-05868.txt 8 5 36 27 0.0066data5-8-36-05869.txt 8 5 36 32 0.2775data5-8-36-05870.txt 8 5 36 17 0.0059data5-8-36-05871.txt 8 5 36 22 0.0126data5-8-36-05872.txt 8 5 36 30 0.0033data5-8-36-05873.txt 8 5 36 28 0.0040data5-8-36-05874.txt 8 5 36 24 0.0832data5-8-36-05875.txt 8 5 36 24 0.0037data5-8-36-05876.txt 8 5 36 20 0.0050data5-8-36-05877.txt 8 5 36 23 0.0506data5-8-36-05878.txt 8 5 36 21 0.0047data5-8-36-05879.txt 8 5 36 24 0.0042data5-8-36-05880.txt 8 5 36 30 0.0038data5-8-36-05881.txt 8 5 36 24 0.0110data5-8-36-05882.txt 8 5 36 22 0.0038data5-8-36-05883.txt 8 5 36 26 0.0043data5-8-36-05884.txt 8 5 36 22 0.0037data5-8-36-05885.txt 8 5 36 26 0.0089data5-8-36-05886.txt 8 5 36 24 0.0614data5-8-36-05887.txt 8 5 36 30 0.6262data5-8-36-05888.txt 8 5 36 28 0.0062data5-8-36-05889.txt 8 5 36 25 0.0122data5-8-36-05890.txt 8 5 36 21 0.0038

Table 67: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 273: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-8-36-05891.txt 8 5 36 25 0.0589data5-8-36-05892.txt 8 5 36 27 0.1215data5-8-36-05893.txt 8 5 36 25 0.1649data5-8-36-05894.txt 8 5 36 27 0.0086data5-8-36-05895.txt 8 5 36 23 0.0035data5-8-36-05896.txt 8 5 36 20 0.0037data5-8-36-05897.txt 8 5 36 29 0.0174data5-8-36-05898.txt 8 5 36 24 0.0069data5-8-36-05899.txt 8 5 36 18 0.0146data5-8-36-05900.txt 8 5 36 22 0.0280data5-8-37-05901.txt 8 5 37 25 0.0065data5-8-37-05902.txt 8 5 37 25 0.2237data5-8-37-05903.txt 8 5 37 27 0.1100data5-8-37-05904.txt 8 5 37 25 0.2127data5-8-37-05905.txt 8 5 37 24 0.0079data5-8-37-05906.txt 8 5 37 28 0.1811data5-8-37-05907.txt 8 5 37 33 0.8993data5-8-37-05908.txt 8 5 37 32 0.1281data5-8-37-05909.txt 8 5 37 24 0.0036data5-8-37-05910.txt 8 5 37 28 0.0054data5-8-37-05911.txt 8 5 37 25 0.0102data5-8-37-05912.txt 8 5 37 25 0.0036data5-8-37-05913.txt 8 5 37 33 0.0248data5-8-37-05914.txt 8 5 37 31 0.0046data5-8-37-05915.txt 8 5 37 27 0.0035data5-8-37-05916.txt 8 5 37 23 0.0044data5-8-37-05917.txt 8 5 37 26 0.0116data5-8-37-05918.txt 8 5 37 23 0.0037data5-8-37-05919.txt 8 5 37 25 0.0033data5-8-37-05920.txt 8 5 37 26 0.0040data5-8-37-05921.txt 8 5 37 41 0.0039data5-8-37-05922.txt 8 5 37 27 0.0624data5-8-37-05923.txt 8 5 37 28 0.0091data5-8-37-05924.txt 8 5 37 29 0.0088data5-8-37-05925.txt 8 5 37 32 0.0904data5-8-37-05926.txt 8 5 37 15 0.0034data5-8-37-05927.txt 8 5 37 33 0.0129data5-8-37-05928.txt 8 5 37 29 0.0221data5-8-37-05929.txt 8 5 37 28 0.0035data5-8-37-05930.txt 8 5 37 26 0.0107data5-8-37-05931.txt 8 5 37 34 0.0202data5-8-37-05932.txt 8 5 37 22 0.0034data5-8-37-05933.txt 8 5 37 22 0.0037data5-8-37-05934.txt 8 5 37 32 0.0038data5-8-37-05935.txt 8 5 37 22 0.0101data5-8-37-05936.txt 8 5 37 26 0.0045data5-8-37-05937.txt 8 5 37 24 0.0098data5-8-37-05938.txt 8 5 37 24 0.0045data5-8-37-05939.txt 8 5 37 30 0.0113data5-8-37-05940.txt 8 5 37 25 0.0048data5-8-37-05941.txt 8 5 37 32 0.3774data5-8-37-05942.txt 8 5 37 33 0.0058data5-8-37-05943.txt 8 5 37 22 0.0063data5-8-37-05944.txt 8 5 37 26 0.0085data5-8-37-05945.txt 8 5 37 27 0.0161data5-8-37-05946.txt 8 5 37 25 0.0053data5-8-37-05947.txt 8 5 37 25 0.0288data5-8-37-05948.txt 8 5 37 28 0.0098data5-8-37-05949.txt 8 5 37 23 0.0871data5-8-37-05950.txt 8 5 37 26 0.0041data5-8-37-05951.txt 8 5 37 35 0.0156data5-8-37-05952.txt 8 5 37 36 0.2354data5-8-37-05953.txt 8 5 37 31 0.0981data5-8-37-05954.txt 8 5 37 18 0.0034data5-8-37-05955.txt 8 5 37 25 0.0049data5-8-37-05956.txt 8 5 37 23 0.0037data5-8-37-05957.txt 8 5 37 21 0.0038data5-8-37-05958.txt 8 5 37 25 0.0036data5-8-37-05959.txt 8 5 37 29 0.2383data5-8-37-05960.txt 8 5 37 23 0.0037

Table 68: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 274: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-8-37-05961.txt 8 5 37 23 0.0064data5-8-37-05962.txt 8 5 37 26 0.7465data5-8-37-05963.txt 8 5 37 24 0.0046data5-8-37-05964.txt 8 5 37 25 0.0033data5-8-37-05965.txt 8 5 37 26 0.0039data5-8-37-05966.txt 8 5 37 26 0.0056data5-8-37-05967.txt 8 5 37 24 0.0040data5-8-37-05968.txt 8 5 37 28 0.0055data5-8-37-05969.txt 8 5 37 21 0.0095data5-8-37-05970.txt 8 5 37 27 0.0066data5-8-37-05971.txt 8 5 37 23 0.0060data5-8-37-05972.txt 8 5 37 28 0.0044data5-8-37-05973.txt 8 5 37 21 0.0038data5-8-37-05974.txt 8 5 37 20 0.0041data5-8-37-05975.txt 8 5 37 26 0.0142data5-8-37-05976.txt 8 5 37 26 0.0149data5-8-37-05977.txt 8 5 37 30 0.0039data5-8-37-05978.txt 8 5 37 23 0.0038data5-8-37-05979.txt 8 5 37 26 0.0266data5-8-37-05980.txt 8 5 37 32 0.0506data5-8-37-05981.txt 8 5 37 25 0.0046data5-8-37-05982.txt 8 5 37 26 0.0045data5-8-37-05983.txt 8 5 37 27 0.0051data5-8-37-05984.txt 8 5 37 22 0.0042data5-8-37-05985.txt 8 5 37 30 0.0152data5-8-37-05986.txt 8 5 37 25 0.0107data5-8-37-05987.txt 8 5 37 22 0.0985data5-8-37-05988.txt 8 5 37 31 0.0892data5-8-37-05989.txt 8 5 37 24 0.0034data5-8-37-05990.txt 8 5 37 29 0.1826data5-8-37-05991.txt 8 5 37 23 0.0277data5-8-37-05992.txt 8 5 37 23 0.0056data5-8-37-05993.txt 8 5 37 28 0.0162data5-8-37-05994.txt 8 5 37 25 0.0053data5-8-37-05995.txt 8 5 37 22 0.0043data5-8-37-05996.txt 8 5 37 27 0.0170data5-8-37-05997.txt 8 5 37 24 0.2572data5-8-37-05998.txt 8 5 37 27 0.1081data5-8-37-05999.txt 8 5 37 32 0.0048data5-8-37-06000.txt 8 5 37 28 0.0709data5-8-38-06001.txt 8 5 38 26 0.0056data5-8-38-06002.txt 8 5 38 35 0.0076data5-8-38-06003.txt 8 5 38 27 0.4544data5-8-38-06004.txt 8 5 38 33 0.1186data5-8-38-06005.txt 8 5 38 20 0.0309data5-8-38-06006.txt 8 5 38 33 0.2152data5-8-38-06007.txt 8 5 38 23 0.0052data5-8-38-06008.txt 8 5 38 26 0.0370data5-8-38-06009.txt 8 5 38 20 0.0033data5-8-38-06010.txt 8 5 38 26 0.0049data5-8-38-06011.txt 8 5 38 33 0.0037data5-8-38-06012.txt 8 5 38 25 0.0341data5-8-38-06013.txt 8 5 38 28 0.0581data5-8-38-06014.txt 8 5 38 25 0.0250data5-8-38-06015.txt 8 5 38 24 0.0056data5-8-38-06016.txt 8 5 38 28 0.0698data5-8-38-06017.txt 8 5 38 22 0.0042data5-8-38-06018.txt 8 5 38 32 0.0819data5-8-38-06019.txt 8 5 38 24 0.0047data5-8-38-06020.txt 8 5 38 29 0.0033data5-8-38-06021.txt 8 5 38 27 0.0046data5-8-38-06022.txt 8 5 38 25 0.0041data5-8-38-06023.txt 8 5 38 21 0.0244data5-8-38-06024.txt 8 5 38 31 0.3935data5-8-38-06025.txt 8 5 38 26 0.0040data5-8-38-06026.txt 8 5 38 26 0.0310data5-8-38-06027.txt 8 5 38 21 0.0063data5-8-38-06028.txt 8 5 38 21 0.0035data5-8-38-06029.txt 8 5 38 30 0.3142data5-8-38-06030.txt 8 5 38 30 0.0881

Table 69: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 275: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-8-38-06031.txt 8 5 38 32 0.0103data5-8-38-06032.txt 8 5 38 26 0.0039data5-8-38-06033.txt 8 5 38 28 0.0037data5-8-38-06034.txt 8 5 38 22 0.0078data5-8-38-06035.txt 8 5 38 26 0.0121data5-8-38-06036.txt 8 5 38 21 0.0135data5-8-38-06037.txt 8 5 38 30 0.0486data5-8-38-06038.txt 8 5 38 27 0.0037data5-8-38-06039.txt 8 5 38 32 0.0524data5-8-38-06040.txt 8 5 38 25 0.0161data5-8-38-06041.txt 8 5 38 31 0.0052data5-8-38-06042.txt 8 5 38 23 0.0135data5-8-38-06043.txt 8 5 38 29 0.0109data5-8-38-06044.txt 8 5 38 28 0.1049data5-8-38-06045.txt 8 5 38 32 0.0062data5-8-38-06046.txt 8 5 38 28 0.0203data5-8-38-06047.txt 8 5 38 23 0.0039data5-8-38-06048.txt 8 5 38 33 0.0064data5-8-38-06049.txt 8 5 38 27 0.0055data5-8-38-06050.txt 8 5 38 24 0.0036data5-8-38-06051.txt 8 5 38 27 0.0044data5-8-38-06052.txt 8 5 38 28 0.0148data5-8-38-06053.txt 8 5 38 34 0.0483data5-8-38-06054.txt 8 5 38 27 0.0041data5-8-38-06055.txt 8 5 38 22 0.0049data5-8-38-06056.txt 8 5 38 24 0.0039data5-8-38-06057.txt 8 5 38 24 0.0242data5-8-38-06058.txt 8 5 38 26 0.0056data5-8-38-06059.txt 8 5 38 32 0.0045data5-8-38-06060.txt 8 5 38 29 0.0140data5-8-38-06061.txt 8 5 38 23 0.0868data5-8-38-06062.txt 8 5 38 23 0.0073data5-8-38-06063.txt 8 5 38 28 0.0036data5-8-38-06064.txt 8 5 38 20 0.0124data5-8-38-06065.txt 8 5 38 28 0.0075data5-8-38-06066.txt 8 5 38 27 0.0040data5-8-38-06067.txt 8 5 38 24 0.0058data5-8-38-06068.txt 8 5 38 25 0.0040data5-8-38-06069.txt 8 5 38 28 0.0038data5-8-38-06070.txt 8 5 38 22 0.0037data5-8-38-06071.txt 8 5 38 26 0.0035data5-8-38-06072.txt 8 5 38 24 0.0054data5-8-38-06073.txt 8 5 38 27 0.0118data5-8-38-06074.txt 8 5 38 32 0.0039data5-8-38-06075.txt 8 5 38 26 0.0039data5-8-38-06076.txt 8 5 38 25 0.0037data5-8-38-06077.txt 8 5 38 29 0.2154data5-8-38-06078.txt 8 5 38 26 0.1589data5-8-38-06079.txt 8 5 38 30 0.1642data5-8-38-06080.txt 8 5 38 21 0.0036data5-8-38-06081.txt 8 5 38 28 0.0194data5-8-38-06082.txt 8 5 38 25 0.0066data5-8-38-06083.txt 8 5 38 25 0.0079data5-8-38-06084.txt 8 5 38 27 0.0037data5-8-38-06085.txt 8 5 38 31 0.2565data5-8-38-06086.txt 8 5 38 29 0.0053data5-8-38-06087.txt 8 5 38 32 0.0077data5-8-38-06088.txt 8 5 38 26 0.0529data5-8-38-06089.txt 8 5 38 25 0.0500data5-8-38-06090.txt 8 5 38 32 0.1370data5-8-38-06091.txt 8 5 38 21 0.0033data5-8-38-06092.txt 8 5 38 22 0.0033data5-8-38-06093.txt 8 5 38 27 0.2550data5-8-38-06094.txt 8 5 38 29 0.1411data5-8-38-06095.txt 8 5 38 36 0.0537data5-8-38-06096.txt 8 5 38 32 0.0074data5-8-38-06097.txt 8 5 38 26 0.0042data5-8-38-06098.txt 8 5 38 27 0.1629data5-8-38-06099.txt 8 5 38 27 0.0037data5-8-38-06100.txt 8 5 38 24 0.0035

Table 70: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 276: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-8-39-06101.txt 8 5 39 26 0.0053data5-8-39-06102.txt 8 5 39 19 0.0038data5-8-39-06103.txt 8 5 39 32 0.0556data5-8-39-06104.txt 8 5 39 30 0.0034data5-8-39-06105.txt 8 5 39 33 0.3687data5-8-39-06106.txt 8 5 39 20 0.0035data5-8-39-06107.txt 8 5 39 26 0.0036data5-8-39-06108.txt 8 5 39 27 0.0101data5-8-39-06109.txt 8 5 39 30 0.1487data5-8-39-06110.txt 8 5 39 26 0.0036data5-8-39-06111.txt 8 5 39 27 0.0041data5-8-39-06112.txt 8 5 39 27 0.3717data5-8-39-06113.txt 8 5 39 27 0.0057data5-8-39-06114.txt 8 5 39 31 0.0040data5-8-39-06115.txt 8 5 39 27 0.0039data5-8-39-06116.txt 8 5 39 29 0.0375data5-8-39-06117.txt 8 5 39 21 0.0039data5-8-39-06118.txt 8 5 39 29 0.0196data5-8-39-06119.txt 8 5 39 30 0.0043data5-8-39-06120.txt 8 5 39 29 0.3602data5-8-39-06121.txt 8 5 39 32 0.0042data5-8-39-06122.txt 8 5 39 35 0.4669data5-8-39-06123.txt 8 5 39 26 0.0494data5-8-39-06124.txt 8 5 39 24 0.0038data5-8-39-06125.txt 8 5 39 27 0.0041data5-8-39-06126.txt 8 5 39 25 0.0064data5-8-39-06127.txt 8 5 39 24 0.0125data5-8-39-06128.txt 8 5 39 24 0.2193data5-8-39-06129.txt 8 5 39 29 0.0037data5-8-39-06130.txt 8 5 39 30 0.0267data5-8-39-06131.txt 8 5 39 26 0.0045data5-8-39-06132.txt 8 5 39 28 0.0074data5-8-39-06133.txt 8 5 39 28 0.0190data5-8-39-06134.txt 8 5 39 26 0.0040data5-8-39-06135.txt 8 5 39 23 0.0124data5-8-39-06136.txt 8 5 39 29 0.0089data5-8-39-06137.txt 8 5 39 31 0.5220data5-8-39-06138.txt 8 5 39 26 0.0039data5-8-39-06139.txt 8 5 39 29 0.0136data5-8-39-06140.txt 8 5 39 29 0.4861data5-8-39-06141.txt 8 5 39 24 0.0039data5-8-39-06142.txt 8 5 39 24 0.0735data5-8-39-06143.txt 8 5 39 24 0.0047data5-8-39-06144.txt 8 5 39 27 0.0087data5-8-39-06145.txt 8 5 39 28 0.0051data5-8-39-06146.txt 8 5 39 30 0.0047data5-8-39-06147.txt 8 5 39 31 0.0062data5-8-39-06148.txt 8 5 39 32 0.0670data5-8-39-06149.txt 8 5 39 28 0.0046data5-8-39-06150.txt 8 5 39 25 0.0977data5-8-39-06151.txt 8 5 39 26 0.3897data5-8-39-06152.txt 8 5 39 25 0.0044data5-8-39-06153.txt 8 5 39 36 0.0078data5-8-39-06154.txt 8 5 39 27 0.0069data5-8-39-06155.txt 8 5 39 23 0.0049data5-8-39-06156.txt 8 5 39 31 0.0139data5-8-39-06157.txt 8 5 39 28 0.4810data5-8-39-06158.txt 8 5 39 23 0.0051data5-8-39-06159.txt 8 5 39 31 0.1155data5-8-39-06160.txt 8 5 39 26 0.0037data5-8-39-06161.txt 8 5 39 27 0.0052data5-8-39-06162.txt 8 5 39 25 0.6574data5-8-39-06163.txt 8 5 39 32 0.0135data5-8-39-06164.txt 8 5 39 32 0.1365data5-8-39-06165.txt 8 5 39 29 0.0043data5-8-39-06166.txt 8 5 39 23 0.0034data5-8-39-06167.txt 8 5 39 27 0.0403data5-8-39-06168.txt 8 5 39 30 0.0039data5-8-39-06169.txt 8 5 39 26 0.0352data5-8-39-06170.txt 8 5 39 26 0.0069

Table 71: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 277: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-8-39-06171.txt 8 5 39 27 0.0039data5-8-39-06172.txt 8 5 39 30 0.0043data5-8-39-06173.txt 8 5 39 21 0.0036data5-8-39-06174.txt 8 5 39 24 0.0081data5-8-39-06175.txt 8 5 39 33 0.2709data5-8-39-06176.txt 8 5 39 24 0.0034data5-8-39-06177.txt 8 5 39 22 0.0034data5-8-39-06178.txt 8 5 39 28 0.0966data5-8-39-06179.txt 8 5 39 27 0.0034data5-8-39-06180.txt 8 5 39 27 0.0035data5-8-39-06181.txt 8 5 39 34 0.0067data5-8-39-06182.txt 8 5 39 32 0.0071data5-8-39-06183.txt 8 5 39 27 0.0655data5-8-39-06184.txt 8 5 39 28 0.0035data5-8-39-06185.txt 8 5 39 25 0.0039data5-8-39-06186.txt 8 5 39 25 0.0481data5-8-39-06187.txt 8 5 39 25 0.0048data5-8-39-06188.txt 8 5 39 35 0.0188data5-8-39-06189.txt 8 5 39 34 0.0484data5-8-39-06190.txt 8 5 39 25 0.0035data5-8-39-06191.txt 8 5 39 20 0.1433data5-8-39-06192.txt 8 5 39 32 0.0094data5-8-39-06193.txt 8 5 39 24 0.0038data5-8-39-06194.txt 8 5 39 26 0.0042data5-8-39-06195.txt 8 5 39 23 0.0346data5-8-39-06196.txt 8 5 39 24 0.0079data5-8-39-06197.txt 8 5 39 32 0.2587data5-8-39-06198.txt 8 5 39 24 0.0080data5-8-39-06199.txt 8 5 39 32 0.0935data5-8-39-06200.txt 8 5 39 23 0.0056data5-9-40-08201.txt 9 5 40 28 0.2184data5-9-40-08202.txt 9 5 40 26 0.1350data5-9-40-08203.txt 9 5 40 28 0.0251data5-9-40-08204.txt 9 5 40 29 0.1103data5-9-40-08205.txt 9 5 40 26 0.0233data5-9-40-08206.txt 9 5 40 22 0.1015data5-9-40-08207.txt 9 5 40 22 0.0060data5-9-40-08208.txt 9 5 40 31 0.0494data5-9-40-08209.txt 9 5 40 23 0.0069data5-9-40-08210.txt 9 5 40 28 0.1327data5-9-40-08211.txt 9 5 40 26 0.0388data5-9-40-08212.txt 9 5 40 23 0.0035data5-9-40-08213.txt 9 5 40 29 0.0359data5-9-40-08214.txt 9 5 40 23 0.0029data5-9-40-08215.txt 9 5 40 20 0.0032data5-9-40-08216.txt 9 5 40 26 0.0065data5-9-40-08217.txt 9 5 40 20 0.0045data5-9-40-08218.txt 9 5 40 25 0.3018data5-9-40-08219.txt 9 5 40 24 0.0311data5-9-40-08220.txt 9 5 40 28 0.1533data5-9-40-08221.txt 9 5 40 26 0.0081data5-9-40-08222.txt 9 5 40 18 0.0031data5-9-40-08223.txt 9 5 40 29 0.0060data5-9-40-08224.txt 9 5 40 23 0.0180data5-9-40-08225.txt 9 5 40 22 0.0570data5-9-40-08226.txt 9 5 40 26 0.0029data5-9-40-08227.txt 9 5 40 26 0.0216data5-9-40-08228.txt 9 5 40 30 0.0135data5-9-40-08229.txt 9 5 40 24 0.0276data5-9-40-08230.txt 9 5 40 24 0.0784data5-9-40-08231.txt 9 5 40 24 0.0234data5-9-40-08232.txt 9 5 40 24 0.0427data5-9-40-08233.txt 9 5 40 23 0.0030data5-9-40-08234.txt 9 5 40 24 0.0056data5-9-40-08235.txt 9 5 40 25 0.0027data5-9-40-08236.txt 9 5 40 25 0.0026data5-9-40-08237.txt 9 5 40 30 0.0739data5-9-40-08238.txt 9 5 40 32 0.1843data5-9-40-08239.txt 9 5 40 28 0.0389data5-9-40-08240.txt 9 5 40 22 0.0035

Table 72: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 278: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-9-40-08241.txt 9 5 40 27 0.0067data5-9-40-08242.txt 9 5 40 26 0.0119data5-9-40-08243.txt 9 5 40 24 0.1983data5-9-40-08244.txt 9 5 40 25 0.0938data5-9-40-08245.txt 9 5 40 25 0.0026data5-9-40-08246.txt 9 5 40 29 0.0032data5-9-40-08247.txt 9 5 40 20 0.0043data5-9-40-08248.txt 9 5 40 29 0.2041data5-9-40-08249.txt 9 5 40 24 0.0035data5-9-40-08250.txt 9 5 40 26 0.0058data5-9-40-08251.txt 9 5 40 24 0.0027data5-9-40-08252.txt 9 5 40 24 0.0032data5-9-40-08253.txt 9 5 40 24 0.0221data5-9-40-08254.txt 9 5 40 27 0.2664data5-9-40-08255.txt 9 5 40 24 0.0027data5-9-40-08256.txt 9 5 40 33 0.2153data5-9-40-08257.txt 9 5 40 27 0.0026data5-9-40-08258.txt 9 5 40 31 0.3906data5-9-40-08259.txt 9 5 40 28 0.0036data5-9-40-08260.txt 9 5 40 29 0.0421data5-9-40-08261.txt 9 5 40 25 0.0043data5-9-40-08262.txt 9 5 40 23 0.0404data5-9-40-08263.txt 9 5 40 31 0.1458data5-9-40-08264.txt 9 5 40 26 0.1224data5-9-40-08265.txt 9 5 40 31 0.1108data5-9-40-08266.txt 9 5 40 28 0.0034data5-9-40-08267.txt 9 5 40 24 0.0094data5-9-40-08268.txt 9 5 40 31 0.2368data5-9-40-08269.txt 9 5 40 23 0.0213data5-9-40-08270.txt 9 5 40 26 0.3525data5-9-40-08271.txt 9 5 40 28 0.0038data5-9-40-08272.txt 9 5 40 30 0.0062data5-9-40-08273.txt 9 5 40 23 0.2428data5-9-40-08274.txt 9 5 40 25 0.3095data5-9-40-08275.txt 9 5 40 26 0.0107data5-9-40-08276.txt 9 5 40 28 0.0275data5-9-40-08277.txt 9 5 40 28 0.0558data5-9-40-08278.txt 9 5 40 21 0.0025data5-9-40-08279.txt 9 5 40 19 0.0025data5-9-40-08280.txt 9 5 40 33 0.0394data5-9-40-08281.txt 9 5 40 22 0.0024data5-9-40-08282.txt 9 5 40 23 0.0292data5-9-40-08283.txt 9 5 40 24 0.0028data5-9-40-08284.txt 9 5 40 26 0.0169data5-9-40-08285.txt 9 5 40 26 0.0154data5-9-40-08286.txt 9 5 40 18 0.0031data5-9-40-08287.txt 9 5 40 25 0.0032data5-9-40-08288.txt 9 5 40 27 0.0565data5-9-40-08289.txt 9 5 40 26 0.0486data5-9-40-08290.txt 9 5 40 22 0.0026data5-9-40-08291.txt 9 5 40 29 0.0036data5-9-40-08292.txt 9 5 40 23 0.0153data5-9-40-08293.txt 9 5 40 24 0.0045data5-9-40-08294.txt 9 5 40 25 0.1404data5-9-40-08295.txt 9 5 40 32 0.2078data5-9-40-08296.txt 9 5 40 25 0.0026data5-9-40-08297.txt 9 5 40 26 0.1120data5-9-40-08298.txt 9 5 40 24 0.5964data5-9-40-08299.txt 9 5 40 28 0.0188data5-9-40-08300.txt 9 5 40 26 0.0042data5-9-41-08301.txt 9 5 41 26 0.0070data5-9-41-08302.txt 9 5 41 23 0.0052data5-9-41-08303.txt 9 5 41 25 0.0031data5-9-41-08304.txt 9 5 41 30 0.0038data5-9-41-08305.txt 9 5 41 24 0.0026data5-9-41-08306.txt 9 5 41 29 0.0025data5-9-41-08307.txt 9 5 41 28 0.1013data5-9-41-08308.txt 9 5 41 23 0.0231data5-9-41-08309.txt 9 5 41 19 0.0027data5-9-41-08310.txt 9 5 41 28 0.0030

Table 73: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 279: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-9-41-08311.txt 9 5 41 29 0.1203data5-9-41-08312.txt 9 5 41 22 0.0916data5-9-41-08313.txt 9 5 41 26 0.0145data5-9-41-08314.txt 9 5 41 28 0.0070data5-9-41-08315.txt 9 5 41 30 0.0029data5-9-41-08316.txt 9 5 41 24 0.0031data5-9-41-08317.txt 9 5 41 22 0.0029data5-9-41-08318.txt 9 5 41 27 0.0071data5-9-41-08319.txt 9 5 41 29 0.1031data5-9-41-08320.txt 9 5 41 23 0.0078data5-9-41-08321.txt 9 5 41 26 0.0033data5-9-41-08322.txt 9 5 41 24 0.0049data5-9-41-08323.txt 9 5 41 29 0.0724data5-9-41-08324.txt 9 5 41 31 0.0034data5-9-41-08325.txt 9 5 41 23 0.0031data5-9-41-08326.txt 9 5 41 30 0.2758data5-9-41-08327.txt 9 5 41 26 0.0031data5-9-41-08328.txt 9 5 41 26 0.0076data5-9-41-08329.txt 9 5 41 29 0.3077data5-9-41-08330.txt 9 5 41 34 0.3641data5-9-41-08331.txt 9 5 41 26 0.0036data5-9-41-08332.txt 9 5 41 29 0.0203data5-9-41-08333.txt 9 5 41 28 0.2498data5-9-41-08334.txt 9 5 41 27 0.0372data5-9-41-08335.txt 9 5 41 28 0.0028data5-9-41-08336.txt 9 5 41 28 0.0771data5-9-41-08337.txt 9 5 41 25 0.1477data5-9-41-08338.txt 9 5 41 27 0.1449data5-9-41-08339.txt 9 5 41 28 0.0093data5-9-41-08340.txt 9 5 41 22 0.0027data5-9-41-08341.txt 9 5 41 28 0.0031data5-9-41-08342.txt 9 5 41 28 0.3888data5-9-41-08343.txt 9 5 41 25 0.0851data5-9-41-08344.txt 9 5 41 21 0.1114data5-9-41-08345.txt 9 5 41 28 0.0072data5-9-41-08346.txt 9 5 41 23 0.0054data5-9-41-08347.txt 9 5 41 28 0.0269data5-9-41-08348.txt 9 5 41 25 0.0664data5-9-41-08349.txt 9 5 41 23 0.0108data5-9-41-08350.txt 9 5 41 27 0.0036data5-9-41-08351.txt 9 5 41 22 0.0057data5-9-41-08352.txt 9 5 41 28 0.0555data5-9-41-08353.txt 9 5 41 25 0.0545data5-9-41-08354.txt 9 5 41 27 0.0029data5-9-41-08355.txt 9 5 41 29 0.0029data5-9-41-08356.txt 9 5 41 35 0.0028data5-9-41-08357.txt 9 5 41 26 0.0053data5-9-41-08358.txt 9 5 41 39 0.0685data5-9-41-08359.txt 9 5 41 31 0.0241data5-9-41-08360.txt 9 5 41 33 0.1772data5-9-41-08361.txt 9 5 41 25 0.1119data5-9-41-08362.txt 9 5 41 28 0.0027data5-9-41-08363.txt 9 5 41 22 0.0028data5-9-41-08364.txt 9 5 41 26 0.0025data5-9-41-08365.txt 9 5 41 30 0.0027data5-9-41-08366.txt 9 5 41 21 0.1010data5-9-41-08367.txt 9 5 41 36 0.0656data5-9-41-08368.txt 9 5 41 33 0.0029data5-9-41-08369.txt 9 5 41 23 0.0122data5-9-41-08370.txt 9 5 41 28 0.0037data5-9-41-08371.txt 9 5 41 26 0.0033data5-9-41-08372.txt 9 5 41 32 0.0103data5-9-41-08373.txt 9 5 41 31 0.2902data5-9-41-08374.txt 9 5 41 27 0.0845data5-9-41-08375.txt 9 5 41 25 0.0420data5-9-41-08376.txt 9 5 41 32 0.0133data5-9-41-08377.txt 9 5 41 27 0.0050data5-9-41-08378.txt 9 5 41 30 0.1443data5-9-41-08379.txt 9 5 41 29 0.0188data5-9-41-08380.txt 9 5 41 30 0.3684

Table 74: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 280: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-9-41-08381.txt 9 5 41 24 0.0025data5-9-41-08382.txt 9 5 41 31 0.0205data5-9-41-08383.txt 9 5 41 28 0.0255data5-9-41-08384.txt 9 5 41 25 0.0048data5-9-41-08385.txt 9 5 41 25 0.1674data5-9-41-08386.txt 9 5 41 25 0.1460data5-9-41-08387.txt 9 5 41 23 0.0288data5-9-41-08388.txt 9 5 41 26 0.1483data5-9-41-08389.txt 9 5 41 25 0.0958data5-9-41-08390.txt 9 5 41 24 0.0927data5-9-41-08391.txt 9 5 41 34 0.0119data5-9-41-08392.txt 9 5 41 32 0.0041data5-9-41-08393.txt 9 5 41 27 0.0510data5-9-41-08394.txt 9 5 41 22 0.0025data5-9-41-08395.txt 9 5 41 24 0.0026data5-9-41-08396.txt 9 5 41 20 0.0089data5-9-41-08397.txt 9 5 41 24 0.1006data5-9-41-08398.txt 9 5 41 28 0.1722data5-9-41-08399.txt 9 5 41 27 0.0227data5-9-41-08400.txt 9 5 41 31 0.0035data5-9-42-08401.txt 9 5 42 36 0.1390data5-9-42-08402.txt 9 5 42 25 0.0029data5-9-42-08403.txt 9 5 42 23 0.0032data5-9-42-08404.txt 9 5 42 21 0.0027data5-9-42-08405.txt 9 5 42 30 0.0029data5-9-42-08406.txt 9 5 42 32 0.0035data5-9-42-08407.txt 9 5 42 30 0.0038data5-9-42-08408.txt 9 5 42 28 0.1181data5-9-42-08409.txt 9 5 42 25 0.1045data5-9-42-08410.txt 9 5 42 39 0.0044data5-9-42-08411.txt 9 5 42 25 0.0026data5-9-42-08412.txt 9 5 42 26 0.0044data5-9-42-08413.txt 9 5 42 38 0.4109data5-9-42-08414.txt 9 5 42 31 0.0404data5-9-42-08415.txt 9 5 42 28 0.0044data5-9-42-08416.txt 9 5 42 24 0.0026data5-9-42-08417.txt 9 5 42 32 0.0410data5-9-42-08418.txt 9 5 42 36 0.0128data5-9-42-08419.txt 9 5 42 30 0.0062data5-9-42-08420.txt 9 5 42 33 0.0026data5-9-42-08421.txt 9 5 42 21 0.0026data5-9-42-08422.txt 9 5 42 33 0.0063data5-9-42-08423.txt 9 5 42 33 0.0553data5-9-42-08424.txt 9 5 42 29 0.0273data5-9-42-08425.txt 9 5 42 38 0.2677data5-9-42-08426.txt 9 5 42 30 0.2116data5-9-42-08427.txt 9 5 42 21 0.0073data5-9-42-08428.txt 9 5 42 26 0.0089data5-9-42-08429.txt 9 5 42 36 0.1544data5-9-42-08430.txt 9 5 42 28 0.0582data5-9-42-08431.txt 9 5 42 20 0.0026data5-9-42-08432.txt 9 5 42 30 0.0046data5-9-42-08433.txt 9 5 42 23 0.0145data5-9-42-08434.txt 9 5 42 37 0.2004data5-9-42-08435.txt 9 5 42 32 0.0060data5-9-42-08436.txt 9 5 42 26 0.0289data5-9-42-08437.txt 9 5 42 33 0.0539data5-9-42-08438.txt 9 5 42 33 0.0194data5-9-42-08439.txt 9 5 42 34 0.0435data5-9-42-08440.txt 9 5 42 32 0.0364data5-9-42-08441.txt 9 5 42 31 0.6251data5-9-42-08442.txt 9 5 42 26 0.0057data5-9-42-08443.txt 9 5 42 34 0.5070data5-9-42-08444.txt 9 5 42 34 0.0081data5-9-42-08445.txt 9 5 42 31 0.0047data5-9-42-08446.txt 9 5 42 28 0.0145data5-9-42-08447.txt 9 5 42 26 0.0239data5-9-42-08448.txt 9 5 42 31 0.0096data5-9-42-08449.txt 9 5 42 27 0.0033data5-9-42-08450.txt 9 5 42 38 0.0851

Table 75: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 281: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-9-42-08451.txt 9 5 42 33 0.1003data5-9-42-08452.txt 9 5 42 23 0.0043data5-9-42-08453.txt 9 5 42 32 0.1296data5-9-42-08454.txt 9 5 42 25 0.1430data5-9-42-08455.txt 9 5 42 30 0.0072data5-9-42-08456.txt 9 5 42 32 0.1947data5-9-42-08457.txt 9 5 42 30 0.0518data5-9-42-08458.txt 9 5 42 29 0.0442data5-9-42-08459.txt 9 5 42 28 0.0029data5-9-42-08460.txt 9 5 42 29 0.0148data5-9-42-08461.txt 9 5 42 26 0.0043data5-9-42-08462.txt 9 5 42 38 0.1458data5-9-42-08463.txt 9 5 42 24 0.0038data5-9-42-08464.txt 9 5 42 31 0.1885data5-9-42-08465.txt 9 5 42 28 0.0174data5-9-42-08466.txt 9 5 42 25 0.0026data5-9-42-08467.txt 9 5 42 27 0.1130data5-9-42-08468.txt 9 5 42 26 0.0029data5-9-42-08469.txt 9 5 42 26 0.1484data5-9-42-08470.txt 9 5 42 32 0.0387data5-9-42-08471.txt 9 5 42 23 0.0026data5-9-42-08472.txt 9 5 42 26 0.0032data5-9-42-08473.txt 9 5 42 26 0.0098data5-9-42-08474.txt 9 5 42 29 0.0774data5-9-42-08475.txt 9 5 42 27 0.0287data5-9-42-08476.txt 9 5 42 23 0.0035data5-9-42-08477.txt 9 5 42 32 0.0204data5-9-42-08478.txt 9 5 42 34 0.0041data5-9-42-08479.txt 9 5 42 29 0.0044data5-9-42-08480.txt 9 5 42 28 0.0073data5-9-42-08481.txt 9 5 42 26 0.0447data5-9-42-08482.txt 9 5 42 30 0.2710data5-9-42-08483.txt 9 5 42 24 0.0026data5-9-42-08484.txt 9 5 42 22 0.0030data5-9-42-08485.txt 9 5 42 24 0.1126data5-9-42-08486.txt 9 5 42 29 0.0027data5-9-42-08487.txt 9 5 42 29 0.0027data5-9-42-08488.txt 9 5 42 28 0.0114data5-9-42-08489.txt 9 5 42 29 0.0434data5-9-42-08490.txt 9 5 42 27 0.0041data5-9-42-08491.txt 9 5 42 31 0.1231data5-9-42-08492.txt 9 5 42 29 0.2326data5-9-42-08493.txt 9 5 42 31 0.0172data5-9-42-08494.txt 9 5 42 31 0.0035data5-9-42-08495.txt 9 5 42 27 0.0837data5-9-42-08496.txt 9 5 42 28 0.0222data5-9-42-08497.txt 9 5 42 28 0.0029data5-9-42-08498.txt 9 5 42 30 0.0055data5-9-42-08499.txt 9 5 42 34 0.0068data5-9-42-08500.txt 9 5 42 24 0.0043data5-9-43-08501.txt 9 5 43 38 0.2181data5-9-43-08502.txt 9 5 43 30 0.0038data5-9-43-08503.txt 9 5 43 30 0.2955data5-9-43-08504.txt 9 5 43 32 0.0297data5-9-43-08505.txt 9 5 43 31 0.5692data5-9-43-08506.txt 9 5 43 28 0.0160data5-9-43-08507.txt 9 5 43 29 0.0026data5-9-43-08508.txt 9 5 43 32 0.2157data5-9-43-08509.txt 9 5 43 23 0.0027data5-9-43-08510.txt 9 5 43 28 0.0026data5-9-43-08511.txt 9 5 43 27 0.0556data5-9-43-08512.txt 9 5 43 30 0.0454data5-9-43-08513.txt 9 5 43 29 0.0028data5-9-43-08514.txt 9 5 43 36 0.0688data5-9-43-08515.txt 9 5 43 35 0.0943data5-9-43-08516.txt 9 5 43 28 0.0622data5-9-43-08517.txt 9 5 43 35 0.1383data5-9-43-08518.txt 9 5 43 26 0.0053data5-9-43-08519.txt 9 5 43 31 0.0126data5-9-43-08520.txt 9 5 43 33 0.0262

Table 76: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 282: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-9-43-08521.txt 9 5 43 33 0.0065data5-9-43-08522.txt 9 5 43 31 0.0080data5-9-43-08523.txt 9 5 43 32 0.0527data5-9-43-08524.txt 9 5 43 33 0.0162data5-9-43-08525.txt 9 5 43 31 0.0120data5-9-43-08526.txt 9 5 43 28 0.0047data5-9-43-08527.txt 9 5 43 31 0.1035data5-9-43-08528.txt 9 5 43 25 0.0027data5-9-43-08529.txt 9 5 43 34 0.0198data5-9-43-08530.txt 9 5 43 29 0.0686data5-9-43-08531.txt 9 5 43 37 0.2278data5-9-43-08532.txt 9 5 43 24 0.0037data5-9-43-08533.txt 9 5 43 33 0.3383data5-9-43-08534.txt 9 5 43 28 0.0029data5-9-43-08535.txt 9 5 43 30 0.1902data5-9-43-08536.txt 9 5 43 24 0.0030data5-9-43-08537.txt 9 5 43 25 0.0101data5-9-43-08538.txt 9 5 43 27 0.0106data5-9-43-08539.txt 9 5 43 28 0.0040data5-9-43-08540.txt 9 5 43 33 0.0036data5-9-43-08541.txt 9 5 43 28 0.0037data5-9-43-08542.txt 9 5 43 32 0.1567data5-9-43-08543.txt 9 5 43 24 0.0027data5-9-43-08544.txt 9 5 43 37 0.0391data5-9-43-08545.txt 9 5 43 36 0.5357data5-9-43-08546.txt 9 5 43 30 0.0508data5-9-43-08547.txt 9 5 43 33 0.0027data5-9-43-08548.txt 9 5 43 35 0.0302data5-9-43-08549.txt 9 5 43 30 0.0028data5-9-43-08550.txt 9 5 43 23 0.0027data5-9-43-08551.txt 9 5 43 37 0.0622data5-9-43-08552.txt 9 5 43 26 0.1038data5-9-43-08553.txt 9 5 43 38 0.1513data5-9-43-08554.txt 9 5 43 29 0.0218data5-9-43-08555.txt 9 5 43 34 0.1079data5-9-43-08556.txt 9 5 43 28 0.0029data5-9-43-08557.txt 9 5 43 30 0.0029data5-9-43-08558.txt 9 5 43 31 0.0387data5-9-43-08559.txt 9 5 43 29 0.0761data5-9-43-08560.txt 9 5 43 31 0.0068data5-9-43-08561.txt 9 5 43 28 0.1423data5-9-43-08562.txt 9 5 43 22 0.0090data5-9-43-08563.txt 9 5 43 34 0.0029data5-9-43-08564.txt 9 5 43 28 0.0031data5-9-43-08565.txt 9 5 43 39 0.0061data5-9-43-08566.txt 9 5 43 34 0.2331data5-9-43-08567.txt 9 5 43 30 0.0170data5-9-43-08568.txt 9 5 43 31 0.0027data5-9-43-08569.txt 9 5 43 33 0.0728data5-9-43-08570.txt 9 5 43 27 0.0279data5-9-43-08571.txt 9 5 43 26 0.0539data5-9-43-08572.txt 9 5 43 29 0.0041data5-9-43-08573.txt 9 5 43 29 0.3475data5-9-43-08574.txt 9 5 43 33 0.0027data5-9-43-08575.txt 9 5 43 30 0.5096data5-9-43-08576.txt 9 5 43 34 0.0098data5-9-43-08577.txt 9 5 43 29 0.0029data5-9-43-08578.txt 9 5 43 31 0.0343data5-9-43-08579.txt 9 5 43 28 0.0026data5-9-43-08580.txt 9 5 43 32 0.0026data5-9-43-08581.txt 9 5 43 29 0.0026data5-9-43-08582.txt 9 5 43 25 0.0049data5-9-43-08583.txt 9 5 43 23 0.1455data5-9-43-08584.txt 9 5 43 36 0.0049data5-9-43-08585.txt 9 5 43 30 0.0097data5-9-43-08586.txt 9 5 43 28 0.0029data5-9-43-08587.txt 9 5 43 22 0.0027data5-9-43-08588.txt 9 5 43 31 0.0073data5-9-43-08589.txt 9 5 43 28 0.4903data5-9-43-08590.txt 9 5 43 31 0.0042

Table 77: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 283: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-9-43-08591.txt 9 5 43 30 0.0740data5-9-43-08592.txt 9 5 43 30 0.0044data5-9-43-08593.txt 9 5 43 29 0.0057data5-9-43-08594.txt 9 5 43 31 0.0031data5-9-43-08595.txt 9 5 43 31 0.0323data5-9-43-08596.txt 9 5 43 30 0.0348data5-9-43-08597.txt 9 5 43 25 0.0026data5-9-43-08598.txt 9 5 43 23 0.0181data5-9-43-08599.txt 9 5 43 32 0.3050data5-9-43-08600.txt 9 5 43 33 0.0028data5-9-44-08601.txt 9 5 44 43 0.0323data5-9-44-08602.txt 9 5 44 24 0.0984data5-9-44-08603.txt 9 5 44 29 0.0031data5-9-44-08604.txt 9 5 44 26 0.0238data5-9-44-08605.txt 9 5 44 33 0.0820data5-9-44-08606.txt 9 5 44 26 0.0033data5-9-44-08607.txt 9 5 44 32 0.1455data5-9-44-08608.txt 9 5 44 32 0.0121data5-9-44-08609.txt 9 5 44 34 0.0994data5-9-44-08610.txt 9 5 44 32 0.0240data5-9-44-08611.txt 9 5 44 35 0.1493data5-9-44-08612.txt 9 5 44 29 0.0028data5-9-44-08613.txt 9 5 44 30 0.0058data5-9-44-08614.txt 9 5 44 29 0.0044data5-9-44-08615.txt 9 5 44 29 0.0066data5-9-44-08616.txt 9 5 44 37 0.0036data5-9-44-08617.txt 9 5 44 34 0.3516data5-9-44-08618.txt 9 5 44 33 0.3051data5-9-44-08619.txt 9 5 44 32 0.0069data5-9-44-08620.txt 9 5 44 31 0.0209data5-9-44-08621.txt 9 5 44 29 0.0118data5-9-44-08622.txt 9 5 44 30 0.0251data5-9-44-08623.txt 9 5 44 23 0.1508data5-9-44-08624.txt 9 5 44 29 0.1295data5-9-44-08625.txt 9 5 44 30 0.0381data5-9-44-08626.txt 9 5 44 27 0.0027data5-9-44-08627.txt 9 5 44 32 0.0388data5-9-44-08628.txt 9 5 44 24 0.0780data5-9-44-08629.txt 9 5 44 26 0.0026data5-9-44-08630.txt 9 5 44 27 0.0317data5-9-44-08631.txt 9 5 44 34 0.0073data5-9-44-08632.txt 9 5 44 31 0.1227data5-9-44-08633.txt 9 5 44 26 0.0122data5-9-44-08634.txt 9 5 44 26 0.0536data5-9-44-08635.txt 9 5 44 29 0.0266data5-9-44-08636.txt 9 5 44 32 0.0036data5-9-44-08637.txt 9 5 44 33 0.0071data5-9-44-08638.txt 9 5 44 30 0.0089data5-9-44-08639.txt 9 5 44 30 0.0488data5-9-44-08640.txt 9 5 44 34 0.0484data5-9-44-08641.txt 9 5 44 22 0.0048data5-9-44-08642.txt 9 5 44 30 0.0057data5-9-44-08643.txt 9 5 44 27 0.0041data5-9-44-08644.txt 9 5 44 35 0.1463data5-9-44-08645.txt 9 5 44 28 0.0297data5-9-44-08646.txt 9 5 44 30 0.0119data5-9-44-08647.txt 9 5 44 28 0.0729data5-9-44-08648.txt 9 5 44 27 0.0027data5-9-44-08649.txt 9 5 44 28 0.0035data5-9-44-08650.txt 9 5 44 25 0.0035data5-9-44-08651.txt 9 5 44 33 0.0235data5-9-44-08652.txt 9 5 44 34 0.0244data5-9-44-08653.txt 9 5 44 36 0.2333data5-9-44-08654.txt 9 5 44 32 0.0374data5-9-44-08655.txt 9 5 44 24 0.0147data5-9-44-08656.txt 9 5 44 32 0.0046data5-9-44-08657.txt 9 5 44 18 0.0030data5-9-44-08658.txt 9 5 44 33 0.1921data5-9-44-08659.txt 9 5 44 30 0.0156data5-9-44-08660.txt 9 5 44 30 0.0028

Table 78: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 284: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-9-44-08661.txt 9 5 44 29 0.0055data5-9-44-08662.txt 9 5 44 25 0.0166data5-9-44-08663.txt 9 5 44 31 0.0079data5-9-44-08664.txt 9 5 44 36 0.0128data5-9-44-08665.txt 9 5 44 27 0.0030data5-9-44-08666.txt 9 5 44 31 0.0047data5-9-44-08667.txt 9 5 44 35 0.1270data5-9-44-08668.txt 9 5 44 31 0.0037data5-9-44-08669.txt 9 5 44 30 0.0793data5-9-44-08670.txt 9 5 44 27 0.0421data5-9-44-08671.txt 9 5 44 24 0.0030data5-9-44-08672.txt 9 5 44 25 0.0031data5-9-44-08673.txt 9 5 44 29 0.0210data5-9-44-08674.txt 9 5 44 30 0.5310data5-9-44-08675.txt 9 5 44 28 0.0044data5-9-44-08676.txt 9 5 44 33 0.0635data5-9-44-08677.txt 9 5 44 30 0.1451data5-9-44-08678.txt 9 5 44 30 0.0060data5-9-44-08679.txt 9 5 44 23 0.0040data5-9-44-08680.txt 9 5 44 28 0.0191data5-9-44-08681.txt 9 5 44 29 0.0033data5-9-44-08682.txt 9 5 44 29 0.1696data5-9-44-08683.txt 9 5 44 31 0.1048data5-9-44-08684.txt 9 5 44 31 0.6725data5-9-44-08685.txt 9 5 44 29 0.0640data5-9-44-08686.txt 9 5 44 35 0.0039data5-9-44-08687.txt 9 5 44 26 0.0072data5-9-44-08688.txt 9 5 44 26 0.0030data5-9-44-08689.txt 9 5 44 29 0.0030data5-9-44-08690.txt 9 5 44 26 0.0050data5-9-44-08691.txt 9 5 44 29 0.1390data5-9-44-08692.txt 9 5 44 31 0.3904data5-9-44-08693.txt 9 5 44 29 0.1754data5-9-44-08694.txt 9 5 44 35 0.0389data5-9-44-08695.txt 9 5 44 29 0.0098data5-9-44-08696.txt 9 5 44 41 0.0914data5-9-44-08697.txt 9 5 44 26 0.0784data5-9-44-08698.txt 9 5 44 24 0.0325data5-9-44-08699.txt 9 5 44 30 0.0044data5-9-44-08700.txt 9 5 44 34 0.0488data5-10-45-10701.txt 10 5 45 30 0.0138data5-10-45-10702.txt 10 5 45 28 0.0538data5-10-45-10703.txt 10 5 45 20 0.0028data5-10-45-10704.txt 10 5 45 36 0.0032data5-10-45-10705.txt 10 5 45 31 0.0384data5-10-45-10706.txt 10 5 45 28 0.1836data5-10-45-10707.txt 10 5 45 23 0.0027data5-10-45-10708.txt 10 5 45 31 0.0555data5-10-45-10709.txt 10 5 45 33 0.0921data5-10-45-10710.txt 10 5 45 31 0.0061data5-10-45-10711.txt 10 5 45 29 0.2916data5-10-45-10712.txt 10 5 45 30 0.0650data5-10-45-10713.txt 10 5 45 31 0.1385data5-10-45-10714.txt 10 5 45 30 0.3153data5-10-45-10715.txt 10 5 45 30 0.0680data5-10-45-10716.txt 10 5 45 31 0.0441data5-10-45-10717.txt 10 5 45 29 0.0052data5-10-45-10718.txt 10 5 45 33 0.2564data5-10-45-10719.txt 10 5 45 28 0.0044data5-10-45-10720.txt 10 5 45 27 0.0047data5-10-45-10721.txt 10 5 45 24 0.0039data5-10-45-10722.txt 10 5 45 24 0.0033data5-10-45-10723.txt 10 5 45 33 0.1818data5-10-45-10724.txt 10 5 45 26 0.0140data5-10-45-10725.txt 10 5 45 28 0.0128data5-10-45-10726.txt 10 5 45 32 0.0174data5-10-45-10727.txt 10 5 45 23 0.0081data5-10-45-10728.txt 10 5 45 41 0.1903data5-10-45-10729.txt 10 5 45 27 0.6841data5-10-45-10730.txt 10 5 45 28 0.0145

Table 79: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 285: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-10-45-10731.txt 10 5 45 24 0.0029data5-10-45-10732.txt 10 5 45 30 0.0037data5-10-45-10733.txt 10 5 45 30 0.0050data5-10-45-10734.txt 10 5 45 31 0.1697data5-10-45-10735.txt 10 5 45 32 0.0076data5-10-45-10736.txt 10 5 45 24 0.0183data5-10-45-10737.txt 10 5 45 23 0.0041data5-10-45-10738.txt 10 5 45 32 0.0065data5-10-45-10739.txt 10 5 45 33 0.4358data5-10-45-10740.txt 10 5 45 31 0.0071data5-10-45-10741.txt 10 5 45 26 0.1848data5-10-45-10742.txt 10 5 45 35 0.0971data5-10-45-10743.txt 10 5 45 32 0.0036data5-10-45-10744.txt 10 5 45 30 0.0389data5-10-45-10745.txt 10 5 45 32 0.0221data5-10-45-10746.txt 10 5 45 28 0.0055data5-10-45-10747.txt 10 5 45 27 0.0249data5-10-45-10748.txt 10 5 45 26 0.0064data5-10-45-10749.txt 10 5 45 34 0.0113data5-10-45-10750.txt 10 5 45 33 0.0149data5-10-45-10751.txt 10 5 45 23 0.0065data5-10-45-10752.txt 10 5 45 32 0.0225data5-10-45-10753.txt 10 5 45 26 0.0031data5-10-45-10754.txt 10 5 45 37 0.2591data5-10-45-10755.txt 10 5 45 29 0.1770data5-10-45-10756.txt 10 5 45 33 0.4560data5-10-45-10757.txt 10 5 45 29 0.4068data5-10-45-10758.txt 10 5 45 22 0.0028data5-10-45-10759.txt 10 5 45 23 0.0028data5-10-45-10760.txt 10 5 45 23 0.0028data5-10-45-10761.txt 10 5 45 29 0.0031data5-10-45-10762.txt 10 5 45 35 0.1004data5-10-45-10763.txt 10 5 45 31 0.5554data5-10-45-10764.txt 10 5 45 25 0.1378data5-10-45-10765.txt 10 5 45 31 0.2956data5-10-45-10766.txt 10 5 45 34 0.0570data5-10-45-10767.txt 10 5 45 27 0.0614data5-10-45-10768.txt 10 5 45 22 0.0619data5-10-45-10769.txt 10 5 45 33 0.0401data5-10-45-10770.txt 10 5 45 26 0.0741data5-10-45-10771.txt 10 5 45 26 0.0059data5-10-45-10772.txt 10 5 45 22 0.0027data5-10-45-10773.txt 10 5 45 28 0.7619data5-10-45-10774.txt 10 5 45 36 0.1533data5-10-45-10775.txt 10 5 45 30 0.0270data5-10-45-10776.txt 10 5 45 23 0.0338data5-10-45-10777.txt 10 5 45 30 0.0882data5-10-45-10778.txt 10 5 45 28 0.2649data5-10-45-10779.txt 10 5 45 30 0.0844data5-10-45-10780.txt 10 5 45 23 0.0094data5-10-45-10781.txt 10 5 45 29 0.0031data5-10-45-10782.txt 10 5 45 34 0.1943data5-10-45-10783.txt 10 5 45 29 0.0057data5-10-45-10784.txt 10 5 45 21 0.0079data5-10-45-10785.txt 10 5 45 28 0.1960data5-10-45-10786.txt 10 5 45 24 0.0027data5-10-45-10787.txt 10 5 45 29 0.0055data5-10-45-10788.txt 10 5 45 33 0.1834data5-10-45-10789.txt 10 5 45 34 0.0032data5-10-45-10790.txt 10 5 45 25 0.1879data5-10-45-10791.txt 10 5 45 28 0.0028data5-10-45-10792.txt 10 5 45 31 0.0079data5-10-45-10793.txt 10 5 45 26 0.1408data5-10-45-10794.txt 10 5 45 26 0.0069data5-10-45-10795.txt 10 5 45 33 0.0459data5-10-45-10796.txt 10 5 45 31 0.3875data5-10-45-10797.txt 10 5 45 22 0.0028data5-10-45-10798.txt 10 5 45 31 0.3449data5-10-45-10799.txt 10 5 45 32 0.4516data5-10-45-10800.txt 10 5 45 27 0.1279

Table 80: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 286: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-10-46-10801.txt 10 5 46 30 0.0133data5-10-46-10802.txt 10 5 46 31 0.0107data5-10-46-10803.txt 10 5 46 34 0.5130data5-10-46-10804.txt 10 5 46 36 0.0400data5-10-46-10805.txt 10 5 46 25 0.0030data5-10-46-10806.txt 10 5 46 33 0.0682data5-10-46-10807.txt 10 5 46 29 0.4560data5-10-46-10808.txt 10 5 46 29 0.0029data5-10-46-10809.txt 10 5 46 24 0.0121data5-10-46-10810.txt 10 5 46 37 0.2971data5-10-46-10811.txt 10 5 46 30 0.0293data5-10-46-10812.txt 10 5 46 30 0.0041data5-10-46-10813.txt 10 5 46 29 0.0039data5-10-46-10814.txt 10 5 46 28 0.0121data5-10-46-10815.txt 10 5 46 36 0.1720data5-10-46-10816.txt 10 5 46 34 0.0048data5-10-46-10817.txt 10 5 46 27 0.0032data5-10-46-10818.txt 10 5 46 37 0.0065data5-10-46-10819.txt 10 5 46 26 0.0049data5-10-46-10820.txt 10 5 46 32 0.0734data5-10-46-10821.txt 10 5 46 33 0.2220data5-10-46-10822.txt 10 5 46 31 0.0216data5-10-46-10823.txt 10 5 46 34 0.2311data5-10-46-10824.txt 10 5 46 31 0.0049data5-10-46-10825.txt 10 5 46 25 0.0028data5-10-46-10826.txt 10 5 46 33 0.5148data5-10-46-10827.txt 10 5 46 27 0.0974data5-10-46-10828.txt 10 5 46 31 0.0031data5-10-46-10829.txt 10 5 46 32 0.2104data5-10-46-10830.txt 10 5 46 33 0.2376data5-10-46-10831.txt 10 5 46 40 0.1046data5-10-46-10832.txt 10 5 46 23 0.1597data5-10-46-10833.txt 10 5 46 28 0.0196data5-10-46-10834.txt 10 5 46 28 0.0083data5-10-46-10835.txt 10 5 46 20 0.0433data5-10-46-10836.txt 10 5 46 23 0.1407data5-10-46-10837.txt 10 5 46 30 0.2578data5-10-46-10838.txt 10 5 46 28 0.1760data5-10-46-10839.txt 10 5 46 35 0.0050data5-10-46-10840.txt 10 5 46 34 0.4517data5-10-46-10841.txt 10 5 46 37 0.6598data5-10-46-10842.txt 10 5 46 37 0.0277data5-10-46-10843.txt 10 5 46 25 0.0041data5-10-46-10844.txt 10 5 46 28 0.0443data5-10-46-10845.txt 10 5 46 31 0.1938data5-10-46-10846.txt 10 5 46 32 0.1393data5-10-46-10847.txt 10 5 46 32 0.1523data5-10-46-10848.txt 10 5 46 30 0.0150data5-10-46-10849.txt 10 5 46 31 0.0046data5-10-46-10850.txt 10 5 46 34 0.0556data5-10-46-10851.txt 10 5 46 34 0.0681data5-10-46-10852.txt 10 5 46 35 0.0959data5-10-46-10853.txt 10 5 46 29 0.0047data5-10-46-10854.txt 10 5 46 25 0.9231data5-10-46-10855.txt 10 5 46 28 0.0920data5-10-46-10856.txt 10 5 46 33 0.0648data5-10-46-10857.txt 10 5 46 24 0.0048data5-10-46-10858.txt 10 5 46 32 0.0030data5-10-46-10859.txt 10 5 46 30 0.1254data5-10-46-10860.txt 10 5 46 29 0.1537data5-10-46-10861.txt 10 5 46 27 0.0031data5-10-46-10862.txt 10 5 46 30 0.0163data5-10-46-10863.txt 10 5 46 33 0.0051data5-10-46-10864.txt 10 5 46 35 0.1308data5-10-46-10865.txt 10 5 46 32 0.2010data5-10-46-10866.txt 10 5 46 30 0.0054data5-10-46-10867.txt 10 5 46 32 0.0028data5-10-46-10868.txt 10 5 46 27 0.0043data5-10-46-10869.txt 10 5 46 35 0.1612data5-10-46-10870.txt 10 5 46 25 0.0580

Table 81: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 287: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-10-46-10871.txt 10 5 46 34 0.6058data5-10-46-10872.txt 10 5 46 36 0.3504data5-10-46-10873.txt 10 5 46 26 0.1866data5-10-46-10874.txt 10 5 46 31 0.0976data5-10-46-10875.txt 10 5 46 35 0.3920data5-10-46-10876.txt 10 5 46 30 0.0156data5-10-46-10877.txt 10 5 46 39 0.3535data5-10-46-10878.txt 10 5 46 31 0.0889data5-10-46-10879.txt 10 5 46 32 0.0264data5-10-46-10880.txt 10 5 46 25 0.0084data5-10-46-10881.txt 10 5 46 30 0.0037data5-10-46-10882.txt 10 5 46 33 0.0128data5-10-46-10883.txt 10 5 46 36 0.6258data5-10-46-10884.txt 10 5 46 31 0.0058data5-10-46-10885.txt 10 5 46 29 0.0029data5-10-46-10886.txt 10 5 46 25 0.0035data5-10-46-10887.txt 10 5 46 26 0.0163data5-10-46-10888.txt 10 5 46 32 0.1799data5-10-46-10889.txt 10 5 46 33 0.1173data5-10-46-10890.txt 10 5 46 30 0.2439data5-10-46-10891.txt 10 5 46 39 0.0031data5-10-46-10892.txt 10 5 46 26 0.0135data5-10-46-10893.txt 10 5 46 24 0.0029data5-10-46-10894.txt 10 5 46 25 0.1253data5-10-46-10895.txt 10 5 46 32 0.3884data5-10-46-10896.txt 10 5 46 24 0.0731data5-10-46-10897.txt 10 5 46 35 0.3218data5-10-46-10898.txt 10 5 46 37 0.2163data5-10-46-10899.txt 10 5 46 27 0.0031data5-10-46-10900.txt 10 5 46 28 0.0054data5-10-47-10901.txt 10 5 47 28 0.2303data5-10-47-10902.txt 10 5 47 32 0.0717data5-10-47-10903.txt 10 5 47 36 0.0129data5-10-47-10904.txt 10 5 47 37 0.1291data5-10-47-10905.txt 10 5 47 31 0.1146data5-10-47-10906.txt 10 5 47 35 0.0030data5-10-47-10907.txt 10 5 47 30 0.0033data5-10-47-10908.txt 10 5 47 23 0.0030data5-10-47-10909.txt 10 5 47 39 0.0628data5-10-47-10910.txt 10 5 47 31 0.1572data5-10-47-10911.txt 10 5 47 29 0.0057data5-10-47-10912.txt 10 5 47 32 0.0053data5-10-47-10913.txt 10 5 47 26 0.0363data5-10-47-10914.txt 10 5 47 35 0.2137data5-10-47-10915.txt 10 5 47 33 0.0065data5-10-47-10916.txt 10 5 47 27 0.0659data5-10-47-10917.txt 10 5 47 26 0.0029data5-10-47-10918.txt 10 5 47 34 0.0335data5-10-47-10919.txt 10 5 47 24 0.0036data5-10-47-10920.txt 10 5 47 34 0.0042data5-10-47-10921.txt 10 5 47 25 0.0160data5-10-47-10922.txt 10 5 47 29 0.0050data5-10-47-10923.txt 10 5 47 36 0.0422data5-10-47-10924.txt 10 5 47 32 0.4428data5-10-47-10925.txt 10 5 47 32 0.0366data5-10-47-10926.txt 10 5 47 36 0.0033data5-10-47-10927.txt 10 5 47 32 0.0030data5-10-47-10928.txt 10 5 47 38 0.2036data5-10-47-10929.txt 10 5 47 26 0.0029data5-10-47-10930.txt 10 5 47 29 0.0714data5-10-47-10931.txt 10 5 47 26 0.0031data5-10-47-10932.txt 10 5 47 32 0.1603data5-10-47-10933.txt 10 5 47 32 0.0055data5-10-47-10934.txt 10 5 47 28 0.0102data5-10-47-10935.txt 10 5 47 29 0.0308data5-10-47-10936.txt 10 5 47 33 0.0039data5-10-47-10937.txt 10 5 47 27 0.0035data5-10-47-10938.txt 10 5 47 34 0.0696data5-10-47-10939.txt 10 5 47 37 0.0194data5-10-47-10940.txt 10 5 47 32 0.3741

Table 82: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 288: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-10-47-10941.txt 10 5 47 20 0.0031data5-10-47-10942.txt 10 5 47 31 0.0963data5-10-47-10943.txt 10 5 47 30 0.0035data5-10-47-10944.txt 10 5 47 34 0.0879data5-10-47-10945.txt 10 5 47 34 0.0030data5-10-47-10946.txt 10 5 47 29 0.2742data5-10-47-10947.txt 10 5 47 28 0.0061data5-10-47-10948.txt 10 5 47 35 0.0048data5-10-47-10949.txt 10 5 47 30 0.7377data5-10-47-10950.txt 10 5 47 39 0.0069data5-10-47-10951.txt 10 5 47 28 0.0040data5-10-47-10952.txt 10 5 47 32 0.2276data5-10-47-10953.txt 10 5 47 25 0.0029data5-10-47-10954.txt 10 5 47 31 0.0673data5-10-47-10955.txt 10 5 47 36 0.0059data5-10-47-10956.txt 10 5 47 39 0.2730data5-10-47-10957.txt 10 5 47 30 0.0844data5-10-47-10958.txt 10 5 47 25 0.0035data5-10-47-10959.txt 10 5 47 36 0.3248data5-10-47-10960.txt 10 5 47 39 0.0053data5-10-47-10961.txt 10 5 47 37 0.0260data5-10-47-10962.txt 10 5 47 26 0.0033data5-10-47-10963.txt 10 5 47 38 0.3213data5-10-47-10964.txt 10 5 47 27 0.0248data5-10-47-10965.txt 10 5 47 33 0.0628data5-10-47-10966.txt 10 5 47 30 0.0062data5-10-47-10967.txt 10 5 47 29 0.0109data5-10-47-10968.txt 10 5 47 36 0.1157data5-10-47-10969.txt 10 5 47 37 0.1391data5-10-47-10970.txt 10 5 47 36 0.1434data5-10-47-10971.txt 10 5 47 29 0.0028data5-10-47-10972.txt 10 5 47 33 0.0206data5-10-47-10973.txt 10 5 47 40 0.2116data5-10-47-10974.txt 10 5 47 28 0.1318data5-10-47-10975.txt 10 5 47 34 0.2278data5-10-47-10976.txt 10 5 47 37 0.1032data5-10-47-10977.txt 10 5 47 36 0.1883data5-10-47-10978.txt 10 5 47 29 0.0700data5-10-47-10979.txt 10 5 47 30 0.2158data5-10-47-10980.txt 10 5 47 34 0.0070data5-10-47-10981.txt 10 5 47 34 0.0031data5-10-47-10982.txt 10 5 47 33 0.0043data5-10-47-10983.txt 10 5 47 35 0.2623data5-10-47-10984.txt 10 5 47 28 0.0029data5-10-47-10985.txt 10 5 47 33 0.0555data5-10-47-10986.txt 10 5 47 36 0.0049data5-10-47-10987.txt 10 5 47 38 0.0259data5-10-47-10988.txt 10 5 47 28 0.0035data5-10-47-10989.txt 10 5 47 30 0.0051data5-10-47-10990.txt 10 5 47 30 0.1036data5-10-47-10991.txt 10 5 47 34 0.0182data5-10-47-10992.txt 10 5 47 25 0.0035data5-10-47-10993.txt 10 5 47 33 0.1304data5-10-47-10994.txt 10 5 47 28 0.0030data5-10-47-10995.txt 10 5 47 28 0.3565data5-10-47-10996.txt 10 5 47 27 0.0031data5-10-47-10997.txt 10 5 47 27 0.1195data5-10-47-10998.txt 10 5 47 31 0.0038data5-10-47-10999.txt 10 5 47 29 0.0043data5-10-47-11000.txt 10 5 47 33 0.0642data5-10-48-11001.txt 10 5 48 29 0.1139data5-10-48-11002.txt 10 5 48 32 0.0065data5-10-48-11003.txt 10 5 48 36 0.0121data5-10-48-11004.txt 10 5 48 38 0.0075data5-10-48-11005.txt 10 5 48 41 0.0090data5-10-48-11006.txt 10 5 48 30 0.0047data5-10-48-11007.txt 10 5 48 30 0.1352data5-10-48-11008.txt 10 5 48 36 0.2352data5-10-48-11009.txt 10 5 48 29 0.1518data5-10-48-11010.txt 10 5 48 30 0.0133

Table 83: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 289: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-10-48-11011.txt 10 5 48 24 0.0382data5-10-48-11012.txt 10 5 48 37 0.0437data5-10-48-11013.txt 10 5 48 36 0.0091data5-10-48-11014.txt 10 5 48 27 0.0098data5-10-48-11015.txt 10 5 48 28 0.1892data5-10-48-11016.txt 10 5 48 32 0.0108data5-10-48-11017.txt 10 5 48 29 0.1001data5-10-48-11018.txt 10 5 48 37 0.1267data5-10-48-11019.txt 10 5 48 38 0.0712data5-10-48-11020.txt 10 5 48 32 0.0035data5-10-48-11021.txt 10 5 48 24 0.0032data5-10-48-11022.txt 10 5 48 33 0.0038data5-10-48-11023.txt 10 5 48 28 0.0088data5-10-48-11024.txt 10 5 48 36 0.0067data5-10-48-11025.txt 10 5 48 33 0.0119data5-10-48-11026.txt 10 5 48 31 0.0944data5-10-48-11027.txt 10 5 48 33 0.0444data5-10-48-11028.txt 10 5 48 34 0.0051data5-10-48-11029.txt 10 5 48 29 0.0033data5-10-48-11030.txt 10 5 48 27 0.0040data5-10-48-11031.txt 10 5 48 32 0.0034data5-10-48-11032.txt 10 5 48 39 0.0047data5-10-48-11033.txt 10 5 48 33 0.0045data5-10-48-11034.txt 10 5 48 34 0.6050data5-10-48-11035.txt 10 5 48 22 0.0107data5-10-48-11036.txt 10 5 48 28 0.0069data5-10-48-11037.txt 10 5 48 30 0.0164data5-10-48-11038.txt 10 5 48 33 0.0035data5-10-48-11039.txt 10 5 48 30 0.0031data5-10-48-11040.txt 10 5 48 33 0.0676data5-10-48-11041.txt 10 5 48 24 0.0030data5-10-48-11042.txt 10 5 48 34 0.0988data5-10-48-11043.txt 10 5 48 41 0.3524data5-10-48-11044.txt 10 5 48 31 0.0091data5-10-48-11045.txt 10 5 48 39 0.4568data5-10-48-11046.txt 10 5 48 36 0.0382data5-10-48-11047.txt 10 5 48 38 0.0032data5-10-48-11048.txt 10 5 48 32 0.0060data5-10-48-11049.txt 10 5 48 29 0.1398data5-10-48-11050.txt 10 5 48 24 0.0160data5-10-48-11051.txt 10 5 48 33 0.0187data5-10-48-11052.txt 10 5 48 32 0.4932data5-10-48-11053.txt 10 5 48 30 0.0029data5-10-48-11054.txt 10 5 48 35 0.3502data5-10-48-11055.txt 10 5 48 29 0.1054data5-10-48-11056.txt 10 5 48 38 0.4667data5-10-48-11057.txt 10 5 48 33 0.3127data5-10-48-11058.txt 10 5 48 35 0.0029data5-10-48-11059.txt 10 5 48 35 0.0231data5-10-48-11060.txt 10 5 48 32 0.0076data5-10-48-11061.txt 10 5 48 29 0.0039data5-10-48-11062.txt 10 5 48 33 0.0042data5-10-48-11063.txt 10 5 48 33 0.0111data5-10-48-11064.txt 10 5 48 35 0.0029data5-10-48-11065.txt 10 5 48 31 0.0049data5-10-48-11066.txt 10 5 48 36 0.0033data5-10-48-11067.txt 10 5 48 28 0.0637data5-10-48-11068.txt 10 5 48 28 0.0896data5-10-48-11069.txt 10 5 48 32 0.0030data5-10-48-11070.txt 10 5 48 33 0.0836data5-10-48-11071.txt 10 5 48 34 0.0200data5-10-48-11072.txt 10 5 48 36 0.1087data5-10-48-11073.txt 10 5 48 36 0.1257data5-10-48-11074.txt 10 5 48 34 0.3078data5-10-48-11075.txt 10 5 48 37 0.3953data5-10-48-11076.txt 10 5 48 34 0.0415data5-10-48-11077.txt 10 5 48 30 0.2644data5-10-48-11078.txt 10 5 48 32 0.0098data5-10-48-11079.txt 10 5 48 36 0.0643data5-10-48-11080.txt 10 5 48 32 0.1009

Table 84: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 290: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-10-48-11081.txt 10 5 48 31 0.0147data5-10-48-11082.txt 10 5 48 29 0.0032data5-10-48-11083.txt 10 5 48 29 0.0144data5-10-48-11084.txt 10 5 48 33 0.4920data5-10-48-11085.txt 10 5 48 36 0.0324data5-10-48-11086.txt 10 5 48 29 0.0030data5-10-48-11087.txt 10 5 48 34 0.0127data5-10-48-11088.txt 10 5 48 28 0.0034data5-10-48-11089.txt 10 5 48 23 0.0120data5-10-48-11090.txt 10 5 48 35 0.0815data5-10-48-11091.txt 10 5 48 32 0.1144data5-10-48-11092.txt 10 5 48 34 0.0092data5-10-48-11093.txt 10 5 48 37 0.2208data5-10-48-11094.txt 10 5 48 47 0.1525data5-10-48-11095.txt 10 5 48 35 0.0041data5-10-48-11096.txt 10 5 48 30 0.0040data5-10-48-11097.txt 10 5 48 25 0.0033data5-10-48-11098.txt 10 5 48 31 0.0051data5-10-48-11099.txt 10 5 48 35 0.0052data5-10-48-11100.txt 10 5 48 31 0.2371data5-10-49-11101.txt 10 5 49 37 0.0080data5-10-49-11102.txt 10 5 49 39 0.0565data5-10-49-11103.txt 10 5 49 39 0.0980data5-10-49-11104.txt 10 5 49 37 0.0833data5-10-49-11105.txt 10 5 49 32 0.2497data5-10-49-11106.txt 10 5 49 31 0.0052data5-10-49-11107.txt 10 5 49 38 0.0813data5-10-49-11108.txt 10 5 49 35 0.0065data5-10-49-11109.txt 10 5 49 33 0.1118data5-10-49-11110.txt 10 5 49 33 0.0060data5-10-49-11111.txt 10 5 49 36 0.2896data5-10-49-11112.txt 10 5 49 27 0.0030data5-10-49-11113.txt 10 5 49 35 0.3875data5-10-49-11114.txt 10 5 49 34 0.0724data5-10-49-11115.txt 10 5 49 34 0.0290data5-10-49-11116.txt 10 5 49 32 0.0135data5-10-49-11117.txt 10 5 49 38 0.5116data5-10-49-11118.txt 10 5 49 35 0.0031data5-10-49-11119.txt 10 5 49 36 0.0231data5-10-49-11120.txt 10 5 49 32 0.0069data5-10-49-11121.txt 10 5 49 27 0.0030data5-10-49-11122.txt 10 5 49 35 0.0030data5-10-49-11123.txt 10 5 49 34 0.2017data5-10-49-11124.txt 10 5 49 42 0.0067data5-10-49-11125.txt 10 5 49 35 0.0043data5-10-49-11126.txt 10 5 49 41 0.0852data5-10-49-11127.txt 10 5 49 32 0.0064data5-10-49-11128.txt 10 5 49 31 0.0030data5-10-49-11129.txt 10 5 49 37 0.0949data5-10-49-11130.txt 10 5 49 38 0.0706data5-10-49-11131.txt 10 5 49 33 0.1454data5-10-49-11132.txt 10 5 49 30 0.0036data5-10-49-11133.txt 10 5 49 38 0.0033data5-10-49-11134.txt 10 5 49 31 0.0068data5-10-49-11135.txt 10 5 49 33 0.0714data5-10-49-11136.txt 10 5 49 42 0.0483data5-10-49-11137.txt 10 5 49 34 0.0031data5-10-49-11138.txt 10 5 49 32 0.0490data5-10-49-11139.txt 10 5 49 29 0.1279data5-10-49-11140.txt 10 5 49 33 0.0864data5-10-49-11141.txt 10 5 49 33 0.1431data5-10-49-11142.txt 10 5 49 35 0.0568data5-10-49-11143.txt 10 5 49 32 0.5950data5-10-49-11144.txt 10 5 49 27 0.0029data5-10-49-11145.txt 10 5 49 33 0.0285data5-10-49-11146.txt 10 5 49 32 0.0101data5-10-49-11147.txt 10 5 49 26 0.0037data5-10-49-11148.txt 10 5 49 32 0.0035data5-10-49-11149.txt 10 5 49 31 0.1621data5-10-49-11150.txt 10 5 49 37 0.3001

Table 85: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 291: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata5-10-49-11151.txt 10 5 49 33 0.4147data5-10-49-11152.txt 10 5 49 25 0.0029data5-10-49-11153.txt 10 5 49 35 0.0945data5-10-49-11154.txt 10 5 49 40 0.3910data5-10-49-11155.txt 10 5 49 32 0.3875data5-10-49-11156.txt 10 5 49 41 0.0038data5-10-49-11157.txt 10 5 49 33 0.0040data5-10-49-11158.txt 10 5 49 42 0.0172data5-10-49-11159.txt 10 5 49 30 0.0140data5-10-49-11160.txt 10 5 49 30 0.2195data5-10-49-11161.txt 10 5 49 36 0.0774data5-10-49-11162.txt 10 5 49 32 0.0038data5-10-49-11163.txt 10 5 49 37 0.4756data5-10-49-11164.txt 10 5 49 35 0.3991data5-10-49-11165.txt 10 5 49 27 0.0054data5-10-49-11166.txt 10 5 49 31 0.0342data5-10-49-11167.txt 10 5 49 35 0.0060data5-10-49-11168.txt 10 5 49 30 0.3904data5-10-49-11169.txt 10 5 49 29 0.0209data5-10-49-11170.txt 10 5 49 28 0.0070data5-10-49-11171.txt 10 5 49 28 0.0084data5-10-49-11172.txt 10 5 49 30 0.0148data5-10-49-11173.txt 10 5 49 36 0.0265data5-10-49-11174.txt 10 5 49 40 0.0032data5-10-49-11175.txt 10 5 49 39 0.6821data5-10-49-11176.txt 10 5 49 29 0.0061data5-10-49-11177.txt 10 5 49 41 0.6122data5-10-49-11178.txt 10 5 49 34 0.1753data5-10-49-11179.txt 10 5 49 35 0.0732data5-10-49-11180.txt 10 5 49 31 0.0041data5-10-49-11181.txt 10 5 49 38 0.0046data5-10-49-11182.txt 10 5 49 38 0.0051data5-10-49-11183.txt 10 5 49 34 0.1145data5-10-49-11184.txt 10 5 49 34 0.0165data5-10-49-11185.txt 10 5 49 33 0.4090data5-10-49-11186.txt 10 5 49 26 0.0052data5-10-49-11187.txt 10 5 49 41 0.6507data5-10-49-11188.txt 10 5 49 35 0.3602data5-10-49-11189.txt 10 5 49 34 0.0105data5-10-49-11190.txt 10 5 49 35 0.0114data5-10-49-11191.txt 10 5 49 35 0.0087data5-10-49-11192.txt 10 5 49 35 0.2251data5-10-49-11193.txt 10 5 49 23 0.0031data5-10-49-11194.txt 10 5 49 41 0.0734data5-10-49-11195.txt 10 5 49 36 0.0912data5-10-49-11196.txt 10 5 49 31 0.0040data5-10-49-11197.txt 10 5 49 36 0.0032data5-10-49-11198.txt 10 5 49 35 0.2993data5-10-49-11199.txt 10 5 49 36 0.0999data5-10-49-11200.txt 10 5 49 34 0.8643data6-6-30-01201.txt 6 6 30 20 0.0092data6-6-30-01202.txt 6 6 30 23 0.0071data6-6-30-01203.txt 6 6 30 20 0.0054data6-6-30-01204.txt 6 6 30 24 0.0123data6-6-30-01205.txt 6 6 30 25 0.1229data6-6-30-01206.txt 6 6 30 25 0.0470data6-6-30-01207.txt 6 6 30 19 0.0073data6-6-30-01208.txt 6 6 30 21 0.0066data6-6-30-01209.txt 6 6 30 24 0.0244data6-6-30-01210.txt 6 6 30 26 0.0069data6-6-30-01211.txt 6 6 30 30 0.0140data6-6-30-01212.txt 6 6 30 27 0.0130data6-6-30-01213.txt 6 6 30 26 0.1007data6-6-30-01214.txt 6 6 30 22 0.0049data6-6-30-01215.txt 6 6 30 25 0.0086data6-6-30-01216.txt 6 6 30 19 0.0047data6-6-30-01217.txt 6 6 30 29 0.0153data6-6-30-01218.txt 6 6 30 19 0.0052data6-6-30-01219.txt 6 6 30 23 0.0049data6-6-30-01220.txt 6 6 30 25 0.0058

Table 86: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 292: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-6-30-01221.txt 6 6 30 21 0.0057data6-6-30-01222.txt 6 6 30 23 0.0254data6-6-30-01223.txt 6 6 30 21 0.0186data6-6-30-01224.txt 6 6 30 19 0.0049data6-6-30-01225.txt 6 6 30 14 0.0074data6-6-30-01226.txt 6 6 30 22 0.0053data6-6-30-01227.txt 6 6 30 19 0.0083data6-6-30-01228.txt 6 6 30 29 0.4022data6-6-30-01229.txt 6 6 30 22 0.0311data6-6-30-01230.txt 6 6 30 18 0.0129data6-6-30-01231.txt 6 6 30 24 0.0916data6-6-30-01232.txt 6 6 30 29 0.0933data6-6-30-01233.txt 6 6 30 24 0.0090data6-6-30-01234.txt 6 6 30 22 0.0080data6-6-30-01235.txt 6 6 30 22 0.0067data6-6-30-01236.txt 6 6 30 22 0.0058data6-6-30-01237.txt 6 6 30 24 0.0137data6-6-30-01238.txt 6 6 30 26 0.4136data6-6-30-01239.txt 6 6 30 23 0.2340data6-6-30-01240.txt 6 6 30 20 0.0052data6-6-30-01241.txt 6 6 30 13 0.0159data6-6-30-01242.txt 6 6 30 27 0.0525data6-6-30-01243.txt 6 6 30 27 0.0376data6-6-30-01244.txt 6 6 30 27 0.0671data6-6-30-01245.txt 6 6 30 26 0.0057data6-6-30-01246.txt 6 6 30 24 0.0709data6-6-30-01247.txt 6 6 30 20 0.0047data6-6-30-01248.txt 6 6 30 26 0.0083data6-6-30-01249.txt 6 6 30 19 0.0127data6-6-30-01250.txt 6 6 30 22 0.0052data6-6-30-01251.txt 6 6 30 25 0.0067data6-6-30-01252.txt 6 6 30 25 0.0092data6-6-30-01253.txt 6 6 30 31 0.0421data6-6-30-01254.txt 6 6 30 25 0.0623data6-6-30-01255.txt 6 6 30 20 0.0054data6-6-30-01256.txt 6 6 30 20 0.0049data6-6-30-01257.txt 6 6 30 25 0.0065data6-6-30-01258.txt 6 6 30 28 0.2534data6-6-30-01259.txt 6 6 30 18 0.0052data6-6-30-01260.txt 6 6 30 21 0.0063data6-6-30-01261.txt 6 6 30 22 0.0071data6-6-30-01262.txt 6 6 30 23 0.0052data6-6-30-01263.txt 6 6 30 25 0.0182data6-6-30-01264.txt 6 6 30 18 0.0096data6-6-30-01265.txt 6 6 30 22 0.1793data6-6-30-01266.txt 6 6 30 28 0.0073data6-6-30-01267.txt 6 6 30 20 0.0080data6-6-30-01268.txt 6 6 30 20 0.0142data6-6-30-01269.txt 6 6 30 28 0.0382data6-6-30-01270.txt 6 6 30 22 0.0078data6-6-30-01271.txt 6 6 30 25 0.0054data6-6-30-01272.txt 6 6 30 23 0.0075data6-6-30-01273.txt 6 6 30 25 0.0093data6-6-30-01274.txt 6 6 30 26 0.0485data6-6-30-01275.txt 6 6 30 21 0.0252data6-6-30-01276.txt 6 6 30 22 0.0598data6-6-30-01277.txt 6 6 30 23 0.0619data6-6-30-01278.txt 6 6 30 25 0.0051data6-6-30-01279.txt 6 6 30 19 0.0214data6-6-30-01280.txt 6 6 30 25 0.0071data6-6-30-01281.txt 6 6 30 26 0.0812data6-6-30-01282.txt 6 6 30 23 0.0097data6-6-30-01283.txt 6 6 30 21 0.1585data6-6-30-01284.txt 6 6 30 25 0.0794data6-6-30-01285.txt 6 6 30 23 0.1145data6-6-30-01286.txt 6 6 30 14 0.0050data6-6-30-01287.txt 6 6 30 26 0.0103data6-6-30-01288.txt 6 6 30 19 0.0054data6-6-30-01289.txt 6 6 30 21 0.0053data6-6-30-01290.txt 6 6 30 18 0.0102

Table 87: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 293: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-6-30-01291.txt 6 6 30 19 0.0083data6-6-30-01292.txt 6 6 30 30 0.1017data6-6-30-01293.txt 6 6 30 24 0.2199data6-6-30-01294.txt 6 6 30 27 0.0606data6-6-30-01295.txt 6 6 30 19 0.0079data6-6-30-01296.txt 6 6 30 26 0.4740data6-6-30-01297.txt 6 6 30 21 0.0080data6-6-30-01298.txt 6 6 30 21 0.0053data6-6-30-01299.txt 6 6 30 21 0.0056data6-6-30-01300.txt 6 6 30 25 0.2334data6-6-31-01301.txt 6 6 31 21 0.0062data6-6-31-01302.txt 6 6 31 20 0.0065data6-6-31-01303.txt 6 6 31 23 0.0062data6-6-31-01304.txt 6 6 31 18 0.0049data6-6-31-01305.txt 6 6 31 21 0.2077data6-6-31-01306.txt 6 6 31 30 0.1425data6-6-31-01307.txt 6 6 31 25 0.0094data6-6-31-01308.txt 6 6 31 28 0.0080data6-6-31-01309.txt 6 6 31 35 0.0514data6-6-31-01310.txt 6 6 31 28 0.1800data6-6-31-01311.txt 6 6 31 27 0.0105data6-6-31-01312.txt 6 6 31 26 0.0185data6-6-31-01313.txt 6 6 31 27 0.0905data6-6-31-01314.txt 6 6 31 33 0.2343data6-6-31-01315.txt 6 6 31 28 0.1053data6-6-31-01316.txt 6 6 31 29 0.0081data6-6-31-01317.txt 6 6 31 25 0.2334data6-6-31-01318.txt 6 6 31 25 0.0053data6-6-31-01319.txt 6 6 31 24 0.0055data6-6-31-01320.txt 6 6 31 20 0.0099data6-6-31-01321.txt 6 6 31 32 0.4231data6-6-31-01322.txt 6 6 31 30 0.2801data6-6-31-01323.txt 6 6 31 20 0.0081data6-6-31-01324.txt 6 6 31 26 0.0057data6-6-31-01325.txt 6 6 31 31 0.2913data6-6-31-01326.txt 6 6 31 18 0.0079data6-6-31-01327.txt 6 6 31 19 0.0053data6-6-31-01328.txt 6 6 31 27 0.0060data6-6-31-01329.txt 6 6 31 17 0.0055data6-6-31-01330.txt 6 6 31 27 0.2120data6-6-31-01331.txt 6 6 31 22 0.0054data6-6-31-01332.txt 6 6 31 29 0.0516data6-6-31-01333.txt 6 6 31 19 0.0089data6-6-31-01334.txt 6 6 31 25 0.0291data6-6-31-01335.txt 6 6 31 30 0.0055data6-6-31-01336.txt 6 6 31 27 0.0053data6-6-31-01337.txt 6 6 31 21 0.0074data6-6-31-01338.txt 6 6 31 18 0.0074data6-6-31-01339.txt 6 6 31 27 0.0387data6-6-31-01340.txt 6 6 31 20 0.0932data6-6-31-01341.txt 6 6 31 22 0.0336data6-6-31-01342.txt 6 6 31 22 0.0301data6-6-31-01343.txt 6 6 31 24 0.0066data6-6-31-01344.txt 6 6 31 27 0.0059data6-6-31-01345.txt 6 6 31 22 0.0061data6-6-31-01346.txt 6 6 31 27 0.0408data6-6-31-01347.txt 6 6 31 29 0.0918data6-6-31-01348.txt 6 6 31 22 0.0060data6-6-31-01349.txt 6 6 31 23 0.0170data6-6-31-01350.txt 6 6 31 27 0.0150data6-6-31-01351.txt 6 6 31 28 0.0055data6-6-31-01352.txt 6 6 31 24 0.0150data6-6-31-01353.txt 6 6 31 28 0.4261data6-6-31-01354.txt 6 6 31 19 0.0049data6-6-31-01355.txt 6 6 31 25 0.0054data6-6-31-01356.txt 6 6 31 22 0.0239data6-6-31-01357.txt 6 6 31 31 0.0283data6-6-31-01358.txt 6 6 31 22 0.0058data6-6-31-01359.txt 6 6 31 17 0.0486data6-6-31-01360.txt 6 6 31 25 0.2596

Table 88: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 294: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-6-31-01361.txt 6 6 31 27 0.0556data6-6-31-01362.txt 6 6 31 20 0.0058data6-6-31-01363.txt 6 6 31 27 0.0759data6-6-31-01364.txt 6 6 31 24 0.0050data6-6-31-01365.txt 6 6 31 24 0.0335data6-6-31-01366.txt 6 6 31 20 0.0083data6-6-31-01367.txt 6 6 31 19 0.0699data6-6-31-01368.txt 6 6 31 21 0.0941data6-6-31-01369.txt 6 6 31 28 0.0057data6-6-31-01370.txt 6 6 31 24 0.0125data6-6-31-01371.txt 6 6 31 20 0.0237data6-6-31-01372.txt 6 6 31 22 0.0085data6-6-31-01373.txt 6 6 31 27 0.0167data6-6-31-01374.txt 6 6 31 31 0.0061data6-6-31-01375.txt 6 6 31 23 0.0052data6-6-31-01376.txt 6 6 31 25 0.0065data6-6-31-01377.txt 6 6 31 34 0.1677data6-6-31-01378.txt 6 6 31 24 0.0062data6-6-31-01379.txt 6 6 31 25 0.1331data6-6-31-01380.txt 6 6 31 24 0.0927data6-6-31-01381.txt 6 6 31 30 0.0911data6-6-31-01382.txt 6 6 31 20 0.0056data6-6-31-01383.txt 6 6 31 27 0.0101data6-6-31-01384.txt 6 6 31 25 0.0096data6-6-31-01385.txt 6 6 31 32 0.0175data6-6-31-01386.txt 6 6 31 24 0.0272data6-6-31-01387.txt 6 6 31 22 0.0112data6-6-31-01388.txt 6 6 31 27 0.1875data6-6-31-01389.txt 6 6 31 29 0.4296data6-6-31-01390.txt 6 6 31 20 0.0174data6-6-31-01391.txt 6 6 31 32 0.0536data6-6-31-01392.txt 6 6 31 25 0.0056data6-6-31-01393.txt 6 6 31 24 0.1231data6-6-31-01394.txt 6 6 31 25 0.2255data6-6-31-01395.txt 6 6 31 19 0.0240data6-6-31-01396.txt 6 6 31 27 0.0095data6-6-31-01397.txt 6 6 31 26 0.0317data6-6-31-01398.txt 6 6 31 27 0.0069data6-6-31-01399.txt 6 6 31 23 0.0052data6-6-31-01400.txt 6 6 31 19 0.0050data6-6-32-01401.txt 6 6 32 26 0.0083data6-6-32-01402.txt 6 6 32 31 0.1810data6-6-32-01403.txt 6 6 32 27 0.0311data6-6-32-01404.txt 6 6 32 27 0.1011data6-6-32-01405.txt 6 6 32 33 0.0072data6-6-32-01406.txt 6 6 32 24 0.0065data6-6-32-01407.txt 6 6 32 31 0.0068data6-6-32-01408.txt 6 6 32 25 0.1601data6-6-32-01409.txt 6 6 32 29 0.1521data6-6-32-01410.txt 6 6 32 28 0.2325data6-6-32-01411.txt 6 6 32 21 0.0052data6-6-32-01412.txt 6 6 32 27 0.0107data6-6-32-01413.txt 6 6 32 28 0.1313data6-6-32-01414.txt 6 6 32 25 0.0060data6-6-32-01415.txt 6 6 32 24 0.0068data6-6-32-01416.txt 6 6 32 24 0.2147data6-6-32-01417.txt 6 6 32 29 0.3697data6-6-32-01418.txt 6 6 32 23 0.0102data6-6-32-01419.txt 6 6 32 32 0.1780data6-6-32-01420.txt 6 6 32 27 0.0067data6-6-32-01421.txt 6 6 32 33 0.2082data6-6-32-01422.txt 6 6 32 29 0.0723data6-6-32-01423.txt 6 6 32 23 0.0084data6-6-32-01424.txt 6 6 32 32 0.0992data6-6-32-01425.txt 6 6 32 21 0.4655data6-6-32-01426.txt 6 6 32 29 0.0452data6-6-32-01427.txt 6 6 32 22 0.0051data6-6-32-01428.txt 6 6 32 24 0.0069data6-6-32-01429.txt 6 6 32 30 0.0157data6-6-32-01430.txt 6 6 32 26 0.0487

Table 89: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 295: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-6-32-01431.txt 6 6 32 31 0.0478data6-6-32-01432.txt 6 6 32 29 0.1318data6-6-32-01433.txt 6 6 32 24 0.0054data6-6-32-01434.txt 6 6 32 31 0.0664data6-6-32-01435.txt 6 6 32 29 0.0349data6-6-32-01436.txt 6 6 32 25 0.0062data6-6-32-01437.txt 6 6 32 28 0.0082data6-6-32-01438.txt 6 6 32 23 0.2093data6-6-32-01439.txt 6 6 32 32 0.0080data6-6-32-01440.txt 6 6 32 30 0.0968data6-6-32-01441.txt 6 6 32 23 0.0052data6-6-32-01442.txt 6 6 32 21 0.0053data6-6-32-01443.txt 6 6 32 29 0.0161data6-6-32-01444.txt 6 6 32 22 0.0720data6-6-32-01445.txt 6 6 32 21 0.0080data6-6-32-01446.txt 6 6 32 28 0.0056data6-6-32-01447.txt 6 6 32 25 0.0054data6-6-32-01448.txt 6 6 32 22 0.0064data6-6-32-01449.txt 6 6 32 26 0.1832data6-6-32-01450.txt 6 6 32 20 0.0066data6-6-32-01451.txt 6 6 32 25 0.0102data6-6-32-01452.txt 6 6 32 27 0.1195data6-6-32-01453.txt 6 6 32 30 0.3145data6-6-32-01454.txt 6 6 32 29 0.0707data6-6-32-01455.txt 6 6 32 28 0.0105data6-6-32-01456.txt 6 6 32 22 0.0120data6-6-32-01457.txt 6 6 32 30 0.1142data6-6-32-01458.txt 6 6 32 31 0.0330data6-6-32-01459.txt 6 6 32 33 0.2073data6-6-32-01460.txt 6 6 32 24 0.0192data6-6-32-01461.txt 6 6 32 29 0.2270data6-6-32-01462.txt 6 6 32 20 0.0062data6-6-32-01463.txt 6 6 32 27 0.0145data6-6-32-01464.txt 6 6 32 30 0.0083data6-6-32-01465.txt 6 6 32 25 0.0141data6-6-32-01466.txt 6 6 32 28 0.0140data6-6-32-01467.txt 6 6 32 28 0.1107data6-6-32-01468.txt 6 6 32 23 0.0678data6-6-32-01469.txt 6 6 32 31 0.0071data6-6-32-01470.txt 6 6 32 27 0.0692data6-6-32-01471.txt 6 6 32 36 0.0170data6-6-32-01472.txt 6 6 32 24 0.0636data6-6-32-01473.txt 6 6 32 22 0.0069data6-6-32-01474.txt 6 6 32 26 0.3573data6-6-32-01475.txt 6 6 32 36 0.0930data6-6-32-01476.txt 6 6 32 16 0.0052data6-6-32-01477.txt 6 6 32 23 0.0778data6-6-32-01478.txt 6 6 32 28 0.1580data6-6-32-01479.txt 6 6 32 26 0.0052data6-6-32-01480.txt 6 6 32 35 0.2371data6-6-32-01481.txt 6 6 32 23 0.0052data6-6-32-01482.txt 6 6 32 33 0.1120data6-6-32-01483.txt 6 6 32 18 0.0052data6-6-32-01484.txt 6 6 32 21 0.0066data6-6-32-01485.txt 6 6 32 19 0.0075data6-6-32-01486.txt 6 6 32 32 0.0978data6-6-32-01487.txt 6 6 32 21 0.0055data6-6-32-01488.txt 6 6 32 27 0.0474data6-6-32-01489.txt 6 6 32 25 0.0328data6-6-32-01490.txt 6 6 32 24 0.0379data6-6-32-01491.txt 6 6 32 28 0.2398data6-6-32-01492.txt 6 6 32 37 0.0163data6-6-32-01493.txt 6 6 32 24 0.0276data6-6-32-01494.txt 6 6 32 32 0.5574data6-6-32-01495.txt 6 6 32 29 0.0067data6-6-32-01496.txt 6 6 32 28 0.0557data6-6-32-01497.txt 6 6 32 32 0.0072data6-6-32-01498.txt 6 6 32 27 0.0110data6-6-32-01499.txt 6 6 32 24 0.0059data6-6-32-01500.txt 6 6 32 30 0.0224

Table 90: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 296: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-6-33-01501.txt 6 6 33 28 0.0130data6-6-33-01502.txt 6 6 33 25 0.1899data6-6-33-01503.txt 6 6 33 28 0.3450data6-6-33-01504.txt 6 6 33 35 0.0075data6-6-33-01505.txt 6 6 33 33 0.3371data6-6-33-01506.txt 6 6 33 26 0.0133data6-6-33-01507.txt 6 6 33 34 0.2169data6-6-33-01508.txt 6 6 33 33 0.0885data6-6-33-01509.txt 6 6 33 34 0.0667data6-6-33-01510.txt 6 6 33 26 0.0055data6-6-33-01511.txt 6 6 33 28 0.0055data6-6-33-01512.txt 6 6 33 34 0.0860data6-6-33-01513.txt 6 6 33 27 0.1442data6-6-33-01514.txt 6 6 33 34 0.0708data6-6-33-01515.txt 6 6 33 32 0.1012data6-6-33-01516.txt 6 6 33 27 0.0053data6-6-33-01517.txt 6 6 33 31 0.0269data6-6-33-01518.txt 6 6 33 29 0.0123data6-6-33-01519.txt 6 6 33 25 0.0956data6-6-33-01520.txt 6 6 33 30 0.1737data6-6-33-01521.txt 6 6 33 38 0.2408data6-6-33-01522.txt 6 6 33 20 0.0084data6-6-33-01523.txt 6 6 33 30 0.0571data6-6-33-01524.txt 6 6 33 33 0.0170data6-6-33-01525.txt 6 6 33 30 0.3162data6-6-33-01526.txt 6 6 33 25 0.0054data6-6-33-01527.txt 6 6 33 26 0.0059data6-6-33-01528.txt 6 6 33 20 0.0057data6-6-33-01529.txt 6 6 33 21 0.0051data6-6-33-01530.txt 6 6 33 23 0.0350data6-6-33-01531.txt 6 6 33 25 0.0052data6-6-33-01532.txt 6 6 33 31 0.0097data6-6-33-01533.txt 6 6 33 36 0.1352data6-6-33-01534.txt 6 6 33 27 0.0391data6-6-33-01535.txt 6 6 33 29 0.0163data6-6-33-01536.txt 6 6 33 32 0.0848data6-6-33-01537.txt 6 6 33 28 0.0652data6-6-33-01538.txt 6 6 33 23 0.0052data6-6-33-01539.txt 6 6 33 30 0.1360data6-6-33-01540.txt 6 6 33 25 0.0057data6-6-33-01541.txt 6 6 33 28 0.0106data6-6-33-01542.txt 6 6 33 26 0.0077data6-6-33-01543.txt 6 6 33 24 0.0061data6-6-33-01544.txt 6 6 33 27 0.0068data6-6-33-01545.txt 6 6 33 27 0.0122data6-6-33-01546.txt 6 6 33 28 0.0505data6-6-33-01547.txt 6 6 33 29 0.0184data6-6-33-01548.txt 6 6 33 35 0.0249data6-6-33-01549.txt 6 6 33 36 0.0134data6-6-33-01550.txt 6 6 33 29 0.0077data6-6-33-01551.txt 6 6 33 28 0.0568data6-6-33-01552.txt 6 6 33 26 0.0157data6-6-33-01553.txt 6 6 33 33 0.0207data6-6-33-01554.txt 6 6 33 32 0.1210data6-6-33-01555.txt 6 6 33 26 0.1184data6-6-33-01556.txt 6 6 33 27 0.0137data6-6-33-01557.txt 6 6 33 36 0.0958data6-6-33-01558.txt 6 6 33 21 0.0053data6-6-33-01559.txt 6 6 33 31 0.0132data6-6-33-01560.txt 6 6 33 26 0.0052data6-6-33-01561.txt 6 6 33 30 0.0060data6-6-33-01562.txt 6 6 33 25 0.0058data6-6-33-01563.txt 6 6 33 36 0.0590data6-6-33-01564.txt 6 6 33 24 0.0053data6-6-33-01565.txt 6 6 33 15 0.0054data6-6-33-01566.txt 6 6 33 28 0.0082data6-6-33-01567.txt 6 6 33 31 0.1716data6-6-33-01568.txt 6 6 33 34 0.0077data6-6-33-01569.txt 6 6 33 30 0.1507data6-6-33-01570.txt 6 6 33 26 0.1124

Table 91: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 297: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-6-33-01571.txt 6 6 33 30 0.0654data6-6-33-01572.txt 6 6 33 28 0.0762data6-6-33-01573.txt 6 6 33 27 0.0063data6-6-33-01574.txt 6 6 33 27 0.0115data6-6-33-01575.txt 6 6 33 28 0.0185data6-6-33-01576.txt 6 6 33 19 0.0056data6-6-33-01577.txt 6 6 33 30 0.3477data6-6-33-01578.txt 6 6 33 25 0.0115data6-6-33-01579.txt 6 6 33 21 0.0060data6-6-33-01580.txt 6 6 33 28 0.0053data6-6-33-01581.txt 6 6 33 39 0.2371data6-6-33-01582.txt 6 6 33 32 0.3907data6-6-33-01583.txt 6 6 33 24 0.0113data6-6-33-01584.txt 6 6 33 30 0.2954data6-6-33-01585.txt 6 6 33 30 0.1118data6-6-33-01586.txt 6 6 33 37 0.2475data6-6-33-01587.txt 6 6 33 28 0.0631data6-6-33-01588.txt 6 6 33 41 0.0772data6-6-33-01589.txt 6 6 33 34 0.0134data6-6-33-01590.txt 6 6 33 18 0.0054data6-6-33-01591.txt 6 6 33 33 0.2623data6-6-33-01592.txt 6 6 33 32 0.0057data6-6-33-01593.txt 6 6 33 26 0.0069data6-6-33-01594.txt 6 6 33 22 0.0197data6-6-33-01595.txt 6 6 33 30 0.0936data6-6-33-01596.txt 6 6 33 35 0.3806data6-6-33-01597.txt 6 6 33 28 0.0065data6-6-33-01598.txt 6 6 33 29 0.0489data6-6-33-01599.txt 6 6 33 23 0.0657data6-6-33-01600.txt 6 6 33 34 0.2600data6-6-34-01601.txt 6 6 34 28 0.0057data6-6-34-01602.txt 6 6 34 32 0.2387data6-6-34-01603.txt 6 6 34 29 0.0051data6-6-34-01604.txt 6 6 34 34 0.1799data6-6-34-01605.txt 6 6 34 31 0.2451data6-6-34-01606.txt 6 6 34 27 0.0091data6-6-34-01607.txt 6 6 34 30 0.1157data6-6-34-01608.txt 6 6 34 29 0.0381data6-6-34-01609.txt 6 6 34 26 0.0168data6-6-34-01610.txt 6 6 34 28 0.0507data6-6-34-01611.txt 6 6 34 33 0.1067data6-6-34-01612.txt 6 6 34 26 0.0142data6-6-34-01613.txt 6 6 34 22 0.0063data6-6-34-01614.txt 6 6 34 32 0.0065data6-6-34-01615.txt 6 6 34 24 0.0534data6-6-34-01616.txt 6 6 34 29 0.0063data6-6-34-01617.txt 6 6 34 37 0.2359data6-6-34-01618.txt 6 6 34 27 0.0708data6-6-34-01619.txt 6 6 34 29 0.0091data6-6-34-01620.txt 6 6 34 45 0.0224data6-6-34-01621.txt 6 6 34 34 0.1326data6-6-34-01622.txt 6 6 34 31 0.2208data6-6-34-01623.txt 6 6 34 28 0.0229data6-6-34-01624.txt 6 6 34 26 0.2380data6-6-34-01625.txt 6 6 34 31 0.2514data6-6-34-01626.txt 6 6 34 29 0.0264data6-6-34-01627.txt 6 6 34 31 0.0150data6-6-34-01628.txt 6 6 34 21 0.0052data6-6-34-01629.txt 6 6 34 25 0.0622data6-6-34-01630.txt 6 6 34 35 0.0940data6-6-34-01631.txt 6 6 34 36 0.1167data6-6-34-01632.txt 6 6 34 36 0.0086data6-6-34-01633.txt 6 6 34 28 0.2804data6-6-34-01634.txt 6 6 34 36 0.1186data6-6-34-01635.txt 6 6 34 29 0.0063data6-6-34-01636.txt 6 6 34 36 0.0175data6-6-34-01637.txt 6 6 34 29 0.0059data6-6-34-01638.txt 6 6 34 25 0.0289data6-6-34-01639.txt 6 6 34 30 0.2434data6-6-34-01640.txt 6 6 34 23 0.0082

Table 92: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 298: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-6-34-01641.txt 6 6 34 19 0.0059data6-6-34-01642.txt 6 6 34 36 0.0055data6-6-34-01643.txt 6 6 34 30 0.2016data6-6-34-01644.txt 6 6 34 26 0.0315data6-6-34-01645.txt 6 6 34 23 0.0066data6-6-34-01646.txt 6 6 34 23 0.0059data6-6-34-01647.txt 6 6 34 26 0.1083data6-6-34-01648.txt 6 6 34 30 0.0091data6-6-34-01649.txt 6 6 34 22 0.0060data6-6-34-01650.txt 6 6 34 31 0.0061data6-6-34-01651.txt 6 6 34 28 0.0081data6-6-34-01652.txt 6 6 34 30 0.1384data6-6-34-01653.txt 6 6 34 30 0.0236data6-6-34-01654.txt 6 6 34 38 0.0603data6-6-34-01655.txt 6 6 34 31 0.0429data6-6-34-01656.txt 6 6 34 30 0.0069data6-6-34-01657.txt 6 6 34 27 0.0967data6-6-34-01658.txt 6 6 34 29 0.0057data6-6-34-01659.txt 6 6 34 27 0.0345data6-6-34-01660.txt 6 6 34 18 0.0052data6-6-34-01661.txt 6 6 34 33 0.0089data6-6-34-01662.txt 6 6 34 22 0.0265data6-6-34-01663.txt 6 6 34 28 0.0088data6-6-34-01664.txt 6 6 34 32 0.3363data6-6-34-01665.txt 6 6 34 29 0.3166data6-6-34-01666.txt 6 6 34 34 0.0197data6-6-34-01667.txt 6 6 34 33 0.1227data6-6-34-01668.txt 6 6 34 28 0.0085data6-6-34-01669.txt 6 6 34 29 0.0061data6-6-34-01670.txt 6 6 34 31 0.0084data6-6-34-01671.txt 6 6 34 28 0.0111data6-6-34-01672.txt 6 6 34 34 0.0077data6-6-34-01673.txt 6 6 34 21 0.0892data6-6-34-01674.txt 6 6 34 24 0.0070data6-6-34-01675.txt 6 6 34 38 0.0767data6-6-34-01676.txt 6 6 34 22 0.0052data6-6-34-01677.txt 6 6 34 23 0.0094data6-6-34-01678.txt 6 6 34 33 0.0462data6-6-34-01679.txt 6 6 34 29 0.0084data6-6-34-01680.txt 6 6 34 30 0.0105data6-6-34-01681.txt 6 6 34 29 0.0714data6-6-34-01682.txt 6 6 34 32 0.0627data6-6-34-01683.txt 6 6 34 33 0.0095data6-6-34-01684.txt 6 6 34 37 0.1710data6-6-34-01685.txt 6 6 34 30 0.1352data6-6-34-01686.txt 6 6 34 28 0.0119data6-6-34-01687.txt 6 6 34 28 0.2750data6-6-34-01688.txt 6 6 34 36 0.2143data6-6-34-01689.txt 6 6 34 27 0.2521data6-6-34-01690.txt 6 6 34 29 0.1396data6-6-34-01691.txt 6 6 34 25 0.0097data6-6-34-01692.txt 6 6 34 34 0.3085data6-6-34-01693.txt 6 6 34 34 0.0153data6-6-34-01694.txt 6 6 34 32 0.0206data6-6-34-01695.txt 6 6 34 24 0.0054data6-6-34-01696.txt 6 6 34 27 0.0505data6-6-34-01697.txt 6 6 34 27 0.0098data6-6-34-01698.txt 6 6 34 25 0.0086data6-6-34-01699.txt 6 6 34 27 0.0057data6-6-34-01700.txt 6 6 34 24 0.0060data6-6-35-01701.txt 6 6 35 33 0.0074data6-6-35-01702.txt 6 6 35 38 0.1558data6-6-35-01703.txt 6 6 35 26 0.0062data6-6-35-01704.txt 6 6 35 22 0.0061data6-6-35-01705.txt 6 6 35 28 0.0060data6-6-35-01706.txt 6 6 35 22 0.0065data6-6-35-01707.txt 6 6 35 32 0.2094data6-6-35-01708.txt 6 6 35 35 0.0070data6-6-35-01709.txt 6 6 35 24 0.0064data6-6-35-01710.txt 6 6 35 29 0.2569

Table 93: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 299: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-6-35-01711.txt 6 6 35 31 0.0792data6-6-35-01712.txt 6 6 35 36 0.0662data6-6-35-01713.txt 6 6 35 28 0.0171data6-6-35-01714.txt 6 6 35 31 0.0145data6-6-35-01715.txt 6 6 35 29 0.0069data6-6-35-01716.txt 6 6 35 22 0.0059data6-6-35-01717.txt 6 6 35 24 0.0103data6-6-35-01718.txt 6 6 35 33 0.1526data6-6-35-01719.txt 6 6 35 39 0.0529data6-6-35-01720.txt 6 6 35 33 0.0223data6-6-35-01721.txt 6 6 35 30 0.0056data6-6-35-01722.txt 6 6 35 25 0.0055data6-6-35-01723.txt 6 6 35 30 0.0473data6-6-35-01724.txt 6 6 35 36 0.0215data6-6-35-01725.txt 6 6 35 34 0.0122data6-6-35-01726.txt 6 6 35 32 0.0063data6-6-35-01727.txt 6 6 35 35 0.2845data6-6-35-01728.txt 6 6 35 27 0.1248data6-6-35-01729.txt 6 6 35 29 0.0060data6-6-35-01730.txt 6 6 35 31 0.0170data6-6-35-01731.txt 6 6 35 30 0.0431data6-6-35-01732.txt 6 6 35 22 0.0055data6-6-35-01733.txt 6 6 35 24 0.0073data6-6-35-01734.txt 6 6 35 28 0.0107data6-6-35-01735.txt 6 6 35 34 0.0221data6-6-35-01736.txt 6 6 35 31 0.0278data6-6-35-01737.txt 6 6 35 19 0.0517data6-6-35-01738.txt 6 6 35 19 0.2648data6-6-35-01739.txt 6 6 35 20 0.0579data6-6-35-01740.txt 6 6 35 30 0.0572data6-6-35-01741.txt 6 6 35 30 0.0096data6-6-35-01742.txt 6 6 35 25 0.0059data6-6-35-01743.txt 6 6 35 24 0.0055data6-6-35-01744.txt 6 6 35 30 0.0082data6-6-35-01745.txt 6 6 35 26 0.0116data6-6-35-01746.txt 6 6 35 27 0.0073data6-6-35-01747.txt 6 6 35 33 0.0741data6-6-35-01748.txt 6 6 35 32 0.0100data6-6-35-01749.txt 6 6 35 28 0.0069data6-6-35-01750.txt 6 6 35 30 0.0068data6-6-35-01751.txt 6 6 35 27 0.0076data6-6-35-01752.txt 6 6 35 37 0.0833data6-6-35-01753.txt 6 6 35 34 0.0055data6-6-35-01754.txt 6 6 35 22 0.0063data6-6-35-01755.txt 6 6 35 37 0.1677data6-6-35-01756.txt 6 6 35 25 0.0064data6-6-35-01757.txt 6 6 35 24 0.0061data6-6-35-01758.txt 6 6 35 30 0.0273data6-6-35-01759.txt 6 6 35 28 0.0136data6-6-35-01760.txt 6 6 35 34 0.0102data6-6-35-01761.txt 6 6 35 30 0.0085data6-6-35-01762.txt 6 6 35 36 0.0118data6-6-35-01763.txt 6 6 35 33 0.0810data6-6-35-01764.txt 6 6 35 29 0.1297data6-6-35-01765.txt 6 6 35 24 0.0173data6-6-35-01766.txt 6 6 35 33 0.0105data6-6-35-01767.txt 6 6 35 40 0.0072data6-6-35-01768.txt 6 6 35 32 0.5129data6-6-35-01769.txt 6 6 35 25 0.0056data6-6-35-01770.txt 6 6 35 23 0.0092data6-6-35-01771.txt 6 6 35 30 0.0281data6-6-35-01772.txt 6 6 35 32 0.3596data6-6-35-01773.txt 6 6 35 34 0.2498data6-6-35-01774.txt 6 6 35 27 0.0680data6-6-35-01775.txt 6 6 35 30 0.0374data6-6-35-01776.txt 6 6 35 28 0.0094data6-6-35-01777.txt 6 6 35 37 0.0626data6-6-35-01778.txt 6 6 35 24 0.0056data6-6-35-01779.txt 6 6 35 24 0.0077data6-6-35-01780.txt 6 6 35 29 0.0058

Table 94: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 300: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-6-35-01781.txt 6 6 35 32 0.2872data6-6-35-01782.txt 6 6 35 25 0.0145data6-6-35-01783.txt 6 6 35 31 0.0158data6-6-35-01784.txt 6 6 35 28 0.0137data6-6-35-01785.txt 6 6 35 32 0.0104data6-6-35-01786.txt 6 6 35 31 0.1376data6-6-35-01787.txt 6 6 35 31 0.0072data6-6-35-01788.txt 6 6 35 34 0.0144data6-6-35-01789.txt 6 6 35 28 0.0061data6-6-35-01790.txt 6 6 35 32 0.0087data6-6-35-01791.txt 6 6 35 27 0.0058data6-6-35-01792.txt 6 6 35 23 0.0146data6-6-35-01793.txt 6 6 35 30 0.1591data6-6-35-01794.txt 6 6 35 20 0.0055data6-6-35-01795.txt 6 6 35 28 0.0319data6-6-35-01796.txt 6 6 35 36 0.1210data6-6-35-01797.txt 6 6 35 34 0.1011data6-6-35-01798.txt 6 6 35 31 0.0058data6-6-35-01799.txt 6 6 35 25 0.1510data6-6-35-01800.txt 6 6 35 27 0.0056data6-7-36-03701.txt 7 6 36 33 0.1650data6-7-36-03702.txt 7 6 36 31 0.6962data6-7-36-03703.txt 7 6 36 30 0.1419data6-7-36-03704.txt 7 6 36 30 0.1352data6-7-36-03705.txt 7 6 36 29 0.5956data6-7-36-03706.txt 7 6 36 30 0.1628data6-7-36-03707.txt 7 6 36 20 0.0202data6-7-36-03708.txt 7 6 36 21 0.0665data6-7-36-03709.txt 7 6 36 33 0.1487data6-7-36-03710.txt 7 6 36 27 0.0720data6-7-36-03711.txt 7 6 36 27 0.0109data6-7-36-03712.txt 7 6 36 31 0.2331data6-7-36-03713.txt 7 6 36 21 0.0627data6-7-36-03714.txt 7 6 36 28 0.1112data6-7-36-03715.txt 7 6 36 32 0.0996data6-7-36-03716.txt 7 6 36 30 0.0672data6-7-36-03717.txt 7 6 36 28 0.0248data6-7-36-03718.txt 7 6 36 26 0.0705data6-7-36-03719.txt 7 6 36 25 0.0060data6-7-36-03720.txt 7 6 36 30 0.0101data6-7-36-03721.txt 7 6 36 26 0.1768data6-7-36-03722.txt 7 6 36 27 0.3122data6-7-36-03723.txt 7 6 36 35 0.3385data6-7-36-03724.txt 7 6 36 32 0.2497data6-7-36-03725.txt 7 6 36 26 0.0033data6-7-36-03726.txt 7 6 36 23 0.0045data6-7-36-03727.txt 7 6 36 29 0.1299data6-7-36-03728.txt 7 6 36 29 0.0570data6-7-36-03729.txt 7 6 36 24 0.0233data6-7-36-03730.txt 7 6 36 34 0.5270data6-7-36-03731.txt 7 6 36 30 0.2983data6-7-36-03732.txt 7 6 36 24 0.0090data6-7-36-03733.txt 7 6 36 22 0.0046data6-7-36-03734.txt 7 6 36 27 0.2059data6-7-36-03735.txt 7 6 36 21 0.1521data6-7-36-03736.txt 7 6 36 26 0.0032data6-7-36-03737.txt 7 6 36 32 0.2157data6-7-36-03738.txt 7 6 36 26 0.0083data6-7-36-03739.txt 7 6 36 30 0.0888data6-7-36-03740.txt 7 6 36 26 0.1627data6-7-36-03741.txt 7 6 36 27 0.0783data6-7-36-03742.txt 7 6 36 28 0.1409data6-7-36-03743.txt 7 6 36 35 0.0743data6-7-36-03744.txt 7 6 36 32 0.5329data6-7-36-03745.txt 7 6 36 36 0.0044data6-7-36-03746.txt 7 6 36 30 0.0991data6-7-36-03747.txt 7 6 36 36 0.1108data6-7-36-03748.txt 7 6 36 29 0.0907data6-7-36-03749.txt 7 6 36 35 0.1911data6-7-36-03750.txt 7 6 36 30 0.0056

Table 95: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 301: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-7-36-03751.txt 7 6 36 22 0.3462data6-7-36-03752.txt 7 6 36 25 0.0269data6-7-36-03753.txt 7 6 36 25 0.1865data6-7-36-03754.txt 7 6 36 28 0.0063data6-7-36-03755.txt 7 6 36 33 0.4535data6-7-36-03756.txt 7 6 36 27 0.5073data6-7-36-03757.txt 7 6 36 20 0.0035data6-7-36-03758.txt 7 6 36 19 0.0039data6-7-36-03759.txt 7 6 36 34 0.1247data6-7-36-03760.txt 7 6 36 17 0.0032data6-7-36-03761.txt 7 6 36 26 0.0601data6-7-36-03762.txt 7 6 36 31 0.2474data6-7-36-03763.txt 7 6 36 26 0.2042data6-7-36-03764.txt 7 6 36 28 0.0830data6-7-36-03765.txt 7 6 36 30 0.1635data6-7-36-03766.txt 7 6 36 24 0.0069data6-7-36-03767.txt 7 6 36 24 0.0115data6-7-36-03768.txt 7 6 36 32 0.2466data6-7-36-03769.txt 7 6 36 31 0.2447data6-7-36-03770.txt 7 6 36 21 0.0090data6-7-36-03771.txt 7 6 36 31 1.0419data6-7-36-03772.txt 7 6 36 27 0.0171data6-7-36-03773.txt 7 6 36 23 0.0673data6-7-36-03774.txt 7 6 36 25 0.0459data6-7-36-03775.txt 7 6 36 23 0.0181data6-7-36-03776.txt 7 6 36 25 0.0041data6-7-36-03777.txt 7 6 36 29 0.0042data6-7-36-03778.txt 7 6 36 21 0.1734data6-7-36-03779.txt 7 6 36 26 0.4074data6-7-36-03780.txt 7 6 36 23 0.0031data6-7-36-03781.txt 7 6 36 30 0.0939data6-7-36-03782.txt 7 6 36 27 0.4677data6-7-36-03783.txt 7 6 36 28 0.5063data6-7-36-03784.txt 7 6 36 28 0.0234data6-7-36-03785.txt 7 6 36 28 0.4671data6-7-36-03786.txt 7 6 36 25 0.0703data6-7-36-03787.txt 7 6 36 25 0.0630data6-7-36-03788.txt 7 6 36 32 0.0061data6-7-36-03789.txt 7 6 36 23 0.1837data6-7-36-03790.txt 7 6 36 28 0.1067data6-7-36-03791.txt 7 6 36 21 0.0036data6-7-36-03792.txt 7 6 36 29 0.2939data6-7-36-03793.txt 7 6 36 25 0.0034data6-7-36-03794.txt 7 6 36 32 0.0674data6-7-36-03795.txt 7 6 36 25 0.0033data6-7-36-03796.txt 7 6 36 31 0.1034data6-7-36-03797.txt 7 6 36 33 0.1428data6-7-36-03798.txt 7 6 36 29 0.0595data6-7-36-03799.txt 7 6 36 30 0.1714data6-7-36-03800.txt 7 6 36 28 0.4215data6-7-37-03801.txt 7 6 37 30 0.0440data6-7-37-03802.txt 7 6 37 27 0.0192data6-7-37-03803.txt 7 6 37 31 0.2398data6-7-37-03804.txt 7 6 37 31 0.0045data6-7-37-03805.txt 7 6 37 27 0.0032data6-7-37-03806.txt 7 6 37 26 0.0037data6-7-37-03807.txt 7 6 37 31 0.4365data6-7-37-03808.txt 7 6 37 23 0.1550data6-7-37-03809.txt 7 6 37 36 0.6637data6-7-37-03810.txt 7 6 37 28 0.0071data6-7-37-03811.txt 7 6 37 35 0.1235data6-7-37-03812.txt 7 6 37 34 0.1305data6-7-37-03813.txt 7 6 37 32 0.4334data6-7-37-03814.txt 7 6 37 32 0.2425data6-7-37-03815.txt 7 6 37 28 0.3154data6-7-37-03816.txt 7 6 37 30 0.1466data6-7-37-03817.txt 7 6 37 29 0.0820data6-7-37-03818.txt 7 6 37 23 0.2071data6-7-37-03819.txt 7 6 37 30 0.0163data6-7-37-03820.txt 7 6 37 25 0.0570

Table 96: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 302: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-7-37-03821.txt 7 6 37 31 0.1952data6-7-37-03822.txt 7 6 37 22 0.3070data6-7-37-03823.txt 7 6 37 20 0.0033data6-7-37-03824.txt 7 6 37 37 0.2811data6-7-37-03825.txt 7 6 37 24 0.2665data6-7-37-03826.txt 7 6 37 28 0.0206data6-7-37-03827.txt 7 6 37 29 0.0087data6-7-37-03828.txt 7 6 37 29 0.0037data6-7-37-03829.txt 7 6 37 37 0.6388data6-7-37-03830.txt 7 6 37 32 0.1848data6-7-37-03831.txt 7 6 37 26 0.0076data6-7-37-03832.txt 7 6 37 29 0.1126data6-7-37-03833.txt 7 6 37 30 0.0080data6-7-37-03834.txt 7 6 37 27 0.0180data6-7-37-03835.txt 7 6 37 24 0.0293data6-7-37-03836.txt 7 6 37 27 0.0092data6-7-37-03837.txt 7 6 37 31 0.2869data6-7-37-03838.txt 7 6 37 34 0.1821data6-7-37-03839.txt 7 6 37 28 0.0634data6-7-37-03840.txt 7 6 37 28 0.0198data6-7-37-03841.txt 7 6 37 27 0.0755data6-7-37-03842.txt 7 6 37 35 0.1172data6-7-37-03843.txt 7 6 37 33 0.0909data6-7-37-03844.txt 7 6 37 28 0.0125data6-7-37-03845.txt 7 6 37 28 0.1257data6-7-37-03846.txt 7 6 37 31 0.4191data6-7-37-03847.txt 7 6 37 30 0.1390data6-7-37-03848.txt 7 6 37 38 0.3307data6-7-37-03849.txt 7 6 37 29 0.0158data6-7-37-03850.txt 7 6 37 25 0.2824data6-7-37-03851.txt 7 6 37 30 0.7519data6-7-37-03852.txt 7 6 37 22 0.0791data6-7-37-03853.txt 7 6 37 28 0.0417data6-7-37-03854.txt 7 6 37 26 0.1054data6-7-37-03855.txt 7 6 37 28 0.0429data6-7-37-03856.txt 7 6 37 27 0.0640data6-7-37-03857.txt 7 6 37 26 0.1015data6-7-37-03858.txt 7 6 37 32 0.0385data6-7-37-03859.txt 7 6 37 29 0.2478data6-7-37-03860.txt 7 6 37 33 0.0149data6-7-37-03861.txt 7 6 37 25 0.0037data6-7-37-03862.txt 7 6 37 33 0.4034data6-7-37-03863.txt 7 6 37 35 0.0095data6-7-37-03864.txt 7 6 37 30 0.1120data6-7-37-03865.txt 7 6 37 30 0.1508data6-7-37-03866.txt 7 6 37 28 0.0907data6-7-37-03867.txt 7 6 37 26 0.0180data6-7-37-03868.txt 7 6 37 29 0.0125data6-7-37-03869.txt 7 6 37 35 0.3226data6-7-37-03870.txt 7 6 37 28 0.6286data6-7-37-03871.txt 7 6 37 33 0.0091data6-7-37-03872.txt 7 6 37 30 0.1579data6-7-37-03873.txt 7 6 37 25 0.0040data6-7-37-03874.txt 7 6 37 34 0.1882data6-7-37-03875.txt 7 6 37 33 0.0494data6-7-37-03876.txt 7 6 37 28 0.0536data6-7-37-03877.txt 7 6 37 28 0.0913data6-7-37-03878.txt 7 6 37 26 0.1002data6-7-37-03879.txt 7 6 37 29 0.1451data6-7-37-03880.txt 7 6 37 25 0.0607data6-7-37-03881.txt 7 6 37 26 0.0486data6-7-37-03882.txt 7 6 37 32 0.2913data6-7-37-03883.txt 7 6 37 30 0.0155data6-7-37-03884.txt 7 6 37 27 0.1986data6-7-37-03885.txt 7 6 37 28 0.0436data6-7-37-03886.txt 7 6 37 30 0.0958data6-7-37-03887.txt 7 6 37 30 0.2001data6-7-37-03888.txt 7 6 37 23 0.0158data6-7-37-03889.txt 7 6 37 32 0.0902data6-7-37-03890.txt 7 6 37 29 0.1591

Table 97: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 303: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-7-37-03891.txt 7 6 37 30 0.0102data6-7-37-03892.txt 7 6 37 32 0.0586data6-7-37-03893.txt 7 6 37 31 0.2882data6-7-37-03894.txt 7 6 37 31 0.2234data6-7-37-03895.txt 7 6 37 27 0.0136data6-7-37-03896.txt 7 6 37 25 0.0364data6-7-37-03897.txt 7 6 37 27 0.0183data6-7-37-03898.txt 7 6 37 26 0.0050data6-7-37-03899.txt 7 6 37 30 0.0275data6-7-37-03900.txt 7 6 37 30 0.0937data6-7-38-03901.txt 7 6 38 29 0.2107data6-7-38-03902.txt 7 6 38 43 0.4470data6-7-38-03903.txt 7 6 38 36 0.2417data6-7-38-03904.txt 7 6 38 34 0.0038data6-7-38-03905.txt 7 6 38 27 0.0068data6-7-38-03906.txt 7 6 38 30 0.1760data6-7-38-03907.txt 7 6 38 29 0.0065data6-7-38-03908.txt 7 6 38 31 0.0092data6-7-38-03909.txt 7 6 38 26 0.0034data6-7-38-03910.txt 7 6 38 38 0.1174data6-7-38-03911.txt 7 6 38 29 0.0237data6-7-38-03912.txt 7 6 38 33 0.0119data6-7-38-03913.txt 7 6 38 26 0.1608data6-7-38-03914.txt 7 6 38 32 0.2039data6-7-38-03915.txt 7 6 38 30 0.0035data6-7-38-03916.txt 7 6 38 31 0.1033data6-7-38-03917.txt 7 6 38 30 0.7522data6-7-38-03918.txt 7 6 38 29 0.0042data6-7-38-03919.txt 7 6 38 36 0.1761data6-7-38-03920.txt 7 6 38 33 0.0807data6-7-38-03921.txt 7 6 38 37 0.0397data6-7-38-03922.txt 7 6 38 29 0.0369data6-7-38-03923.txt 7 6 38 28 0.0248data6-7-38-03924.txt 7 6 38 34 0.0176data6-7-38-03925.txt 7 6 38 36 0.1520data6-7-38-03926.txt 7 6 38 28 0.0036data6-7-38-03927.txt 7 6 38 28 0.1886data6-7-38-03928.txt 7 6 38 29 0.4250data6-7-38-03929.txt 7 6 38 29 0.0788data6-7-38-03930.txt 7 6 38 31 0.1539data6-7-38-03931.txt 7 6 38 26 0.0037data6-7-38-03932.txt 7 6 38 30 0.0684data6-7-38-03933.txt 7 6 38 23 0.0427data6-7-38-03934.txt 7 6 38 24 0.0134data6-7-38-03935.txt 7 6 38 26 0.0153data6-7-38-03936.txt 7 6 38 29 0.3157data6-7-38-03937.txt 7 6 38 32 0.0079data6-7-38-03938.txt 7 6 38 38 0.2421data6-7-38-03939.txt 7 6 38 38 0.0327data6-7-38-03940.txt 7 6 38 34 0.0671data6-7-38-03941.txt 7 6 38 32 0.0163data6-7-38-03942.txt 7 6 38 38 0.0656data6-7-38-03943.txt 7 6 38 39 0.0040data6-7-38-03944.txt 7 6 38 33 0.1939data6-7-38-03945.txt 7 6 38 35 0.0266data6-7-38-03946.txt 7 6 38 31 0.0042data6-7-38-03947.txt 7 6 38 30 0.0670data6-7-38-03948.txt 7 6 38 34 0.2347data6-7-38-03949.txt 7 6 38 29 0.0742data6-7-38-03950.txt 7 6 38 31 0.1829data6-7-38-03951.txt 7 6 38 30 0.0054data6-7-38-03952.txt 7 6 38 33 0.0767data6-7-38-03953.txt 7 6 38 34 0.1111data6-7-38-03954.txt 7 6 38 27 0.3615data6-7-38-03955.txt 7 6 38 33 0.1085data6-7-38-03956.txt 7 6 38 30 0.1424data6-7-38-03957.txt 7 6 38 33 0.0057data6-7-38-03958.txt 7 6 38 32 0.2662data6-7-38-03959.txt 7 6 38 30 0.0875data6-7-38-03960.txt 7 6 38 24 0.1218

Table 98: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 304: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-7-38-03961.txt 7 6 38 33 0.0416data6-7-38-03962.txt 7 6 38 42 0.0138data6-7-38-03963.txt 7 6 38 26 0.0091data6-7-38-03964.txt 7 6 38 29 0.1820data6-7-38-03965.txt 7 6 38 32 0.0531data6-7-38-03966.txt 7 6 38 35 0.1174data6-7-38-03967.txt 7 6 38 37 0.1284data6-7-38-03968.txt 7 6 38 29 0.0151data6-7-38-03969.txt 7 6 38 27 0.0043data6-7-38-03970.txt 7 6 38 36 0.2707data6-7-38-03971.txt 7 6 38 36 0.0363data6-7-38-03972.txt 7 6 38 29 0.0077data6-7-38-03973.txt 7 6 38 29 0.1985data6-7-38-03974.txt 7 6 38 34 0.2198data6-7-38-03975.txt 7 6 38 26 0.0413data6-7-38-03976.txt 7 6 38 27 0.0404data6-7-38-03977.txt 7 6 38 26 0.1397data6-7-38-03978.txt 7 6 38 31 0.0072data6-7-38-03979.txt 7 6 38 32 0.1005data6-7-38-03980.txt 7 6 38 34 0.2138data6-7-38-03981.txt 7 6 38 29 0.0190data6-7-38-03982.txt 7 6 38 34 0.0153data6-7-38-03983.txt 7 6 38 36 0.5083data6-7-38-03984.txt 7 6 38 33 0.0629data6-7-38-03985.txt 7 6 38 29 0.0719data6-7-38-03986.txt 7 6 38 32 0.2391data6-7-38-03987.txt 7 6 38 37 0.5497data6-7-38-03988.txt 7 6 38 38 0.2164data6-7-38-03989.txt 7 6 38 29 0.0133data6-7-38-03990.txt 7 6 38 36 0.1614data6-7-38-03991.txt 7 6 38 30 0.1179data6-7-38-03992.txt 7 6 38 27 0.0382data6-7-38-03993.txt 7 6 38 32 0.3185data6-7-38-03994.txt 7 6 38 28 0.1154data6-7-38-03995.txt 7 6 38 29 0.1003data6-7-38-03996.txt 7 6 38 32 0.0050data6-7-38-03997.txt 7 6 38 33 0.0098data6-7-38-03998.txt 7 6 38 28 0.0045data6-7-38-03999.txt 7 6 38 24 0.0065data6-7-38-04000.txt 7 6 38 31 0.0145data6-7-39-04001.txt 7 6 39 30 0.0041data6-7-39-04002.txt 7 6 39 34 0.1412data6-7-39-04003.txt 7 6 39 29 0.0035data6-7-39-04004.txt 7 6 39 38 0.0497data6-7-39-04005.txt 7 6 39 31 0.0276data6-7-39-04006.txt 7 6 39 22 0.0036data6-7-39-04007.txt 7 6 39 25 0.0092data6-7-39-04008.txt 7 6 39 35 0.1742data6-7-39-04009.txt 7 6 39 28 0.3563data6-7-39-04010.txt 7 6 39 34 0.9313data6-7-39-04011.txt 7 6 39 37 0.3291data6-7-39-04012.txt 7 6 39 32 0.0116data6-7-39-04013.txt 7 6 39 26 0.0101data6-7-39-04014.txt 7 6 39 39 0.1354data6-7-39-04015.txt 7 6 39 31 0.2833data6-7-39-04016.txt 7 6 39 36 0.0959data6-7-39-04017.txt 7 6 39 29 0.0552data6-7-39-04018.txt 7 6 39 36 0.1269data6-7-39-04019.txt 7 6 39 34 0.0048data6-7-39-04020.txt 7 6 39 29 0.1654data6-7-39-04021.txt 7 6 39 26 0.0541data6-7-39-04022.txt 7 6 39 26 0.1452data6-7-39-04023.txt 7 6 39 26 0.5612data6-7-39-04024.txt 7 6 39 28 0.0034data6-7-39-04025.txt 7 6 39 26 0.2238data6-7-39-04026.txt 7 6 39 37 0.1233data6-7-39-04027.txt 7 6 39 29 0.1088data6-7-39-04028.txt 7 6 39 23 0.0034data6-7-39-04029.txt 7 6 39 30 0.0337data6-7-39-04030.txt 7 6 39 32 0.0040

Table 99: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 305: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-7-39-04031.txt 7 6 39 31 0.2038data6-7-39-04032.txt 7 6 39 29 0.0262data6-7-39-04033.txt 7 6 39 29 0.1510data6-7-39-04034.txt 7 6 39 31 0.0892data6-7-39-04035.txt 7 6 39 34 0.2060data6-7-39-04036.txt 7 6 39 32 0.0771data6-7-39-04037.txt 7 6 39 36 0.2574data6-7-39-04038.txt 7 6 39 29 0.0041data6-7-39-04039.txt 7 6 39 34 0.0057data6-7-39-04040.txt 7 6 39 34 0.0185data6-7-39-04041.txt 7 6 39 32 0.0092data6-7-39-04042.txt 7 6 39 31 0.2345data6-7-39-04043.txt 7 6 39 31 0.0040data6-7-39-04044.txt 7 6 39 28 0.0641data6-7-39-04045.txt 7 6 39 34 0.0435data6-7-39-04046.txt 7 6 39 29 0.2381data6-7-39-04047.txt 7 6 39 39 0.2520data6-7-39-04048.txt 7 6 39 36 0.0083data6-7-39-04049.txt 7 6 39 28 0.0152data6-7-39-04050.txt 7 6 39 29 0.8424data6-7-39-04051.txt 7 6 39 33 0.0163data6-7-39-04052.txt 7 6 39 41 0.0045data6-7-39-04053.txt 7 6 39 38 0.6077data6-7-39-04054.txt 7 6 39 30 0.4636data6-7-39-04055.txt 7 6 39 39 0.2134data6-7-39-04056.txt 7 6 39 41 0.0412data6-7-39-04057.txt 7 6 39 26 0.0042data6-7-39-04058.txt 7 6 39 33 0.0729data6-7-39-04059.txt 7 6 39 32 0.0042data6-7-39-04060.txt 7 6 39 30 0.1765data6-7-39-04061.txt 7 6 39 39 0.1905data6-7-39-04062.txt 7 6 39 33 0.3445data6-7-39-04063.txt 7 6 39 32 0.1197data6-7-39-04064.txt 7 6 39 28 0.0167data6-7-39-04065.txt 7 6 39 35 0.1122data6-7-39-04066.txt 7 6 39 29 0.0460data6-7-39-04067.txt 7 6 39 37 0.1863data6-7-39-04068.txt 7 6 39 33 0.0198data6-7-39-04069.txt 7 6 39 29 0.0739data6-7-39-04070.txt 7 6 39 31 0.0121data6-7-39-04071.txt 7 6 39 25 0.0054data6-7-39-04072.txt 7 6 39 27 0.2668data6-7-39-04073.txt 7 6 39 28 0.0962data6-7-39-04074.txt 7 6 39 32 0.0702data6-7-39-04075.txt 7 6 39 27 0.0296data6-7-39-04076.txt 7 6 39 31 0.0047data6-7-39-04077.txt 7 6 39 43 0.1407data6-7-39-04078.txt 7 6 39 28 0.7908data6-7-39-04079.txt 7 6 39 27 0.0043data6-7-39-04080.txt 7 6 39 37 0.1474data6-7-39-04081.txt 7 6 39 37 0.0122data6-7-39-04082.txt 7 6 39 38 0.0541data6-7-39-04083.txt 7 6 39 27 0.0762data6-7-39-04084.txt 7 6 39 33 0.0253data6-7-39-04085.txt 7 6 39 30 0.4163data6-7-39-04086.txt 7 6 39 40 0.0234data6-7-39-04087.txt 7 6 39 29 0.6113data6-7-39-04088.txt 7 6 39 34 0.0253data6-7-39-04089.txt 7 6 39 36 0.0999data6-7-39-04090.txt 7 6 39 25 0.0077data6-7-39-04091.txt 7 6 39 35 0.0061data6-7-39-04092.txt 7 6 39 30 0.0626data6-7-39-04093.txt 7 6 39 33 0.2115data6-7-39-04094.txt 7 6 39 31 0.2467data6-7-39-04095.txt 7 6 39 39 0.2530data6-7-39-04096.txt 7 6 39 29 0.0212data6-7-39-04097.txt 7 6 39 30 0.0227data6-7-39-04098.txt 7 6 39 31 0.0071data6-7-39-04099.txt 7 6 39 31 0.0312data6-7-39-04100.txt 7 6 39 30 0.0066

Table 100: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 306: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-7-40-04101.txt 7 6 40 31 0.0046data6-7-40-04102.txt 7 6 40 29 0.0534data6-7-40-04103.txt 7 6 40 35 0.1284data6-7-40-04104.txt 7 6 40 29 0.0052data6-7-40-04105.txt 7 6 40 35 0.5787data6-7-40-04106.txt 7 6 40 27 0.0031data6-7-40-04107.txt 7 6 40 35 0.0118data6-7-40-04108.txt 7 6 40 35 0.1229data6-7-40-04109.txt 7 6 40 36 0.0039data6-7-40-04110.txt 7 6 40 30 0.0028data6-7-40-04111.txt 7 6 40 31 0.0286data6-7-40-04112.txt 7 6 40 38 0.0616data6-7-40-04113.txt 7 6 40 37 0.1589data6-7-40-04114.txt 7 6 40 31 0.0493data6-7-40-04115.txt 7 6 40 33 0.0725data6-7-40-04116.txt 7 6 40 29 0.1938data6-7-40-04117.txt 7 6 40 38 0.2747data6-7-40-04118.txt 7 6 40 23 0.0024data6-7-40-04119.txt 7 6 40 33 0.0026data6-7-40-04120.txt 7 6 40 27 0.0135data6-7-40-04121.txt 7 6 40 35 0.0558data6-7-40-04122.txt 7 6 40 28 0.0095data6-7-40-04123.txt 7 6 40 35 0.0969data6-7-40-04124.txt 7 6 40 28 0.0030data6-7-40-04125.txt 7 6 40 27 0.0487data6-7-40-04126.txt 7 6 40 33 0.1571data6-7-40-04127.txt 7 6 40 27 0.0027data6-7-40-04128.txt 7 6 40 30 0.2106data6-7-40-04129.txt 7 6 40 35 0.1179data6-7-40-04130.txt 7 6 40 35 0.0703data6-7-40-04131.txt 7 6 40 34 0.0871data6-7-40-04132.txt 7 6 40 36 0.0142data6-7-40-04133.txt 7 6 40 33 0.0043data6-7-40-04134.txt 7 6 40 30 0.0521data6-7-40-04135.txt 7 6 40 36 0.0333data6-7-40-04136.txt 7 6 40 37 0.3734data6-7-40-04137.txt 7 6 40 39 0.0187data6-7-40-04138.txt 7 6 40 28 0.0776data6-7-40-04139.txt 7 6 40 25 0.0054data6-7-40-04140.txt 7 6 40 37 0.1284data6-7-40-04141.txt 7 6 40 41 0.0741data6-7-40-04142.txt 7 6 40 31 0.0040data6-7-40-04143.txt 7 6 40 38 0.1184data6-7-40-04144.txt 7 6 40 32 0.0735data6-7-40-04145.txt 7 6 40 21 0.0033data6-7-40-04146.txt 7 6 40 26 0.0025data6-7-40-04147.txt 7 6 40 29 0.2099data6-7-40-04148.txt 7 6 40 38 0.1195data6-7-40-04149.txt 7 6 40 31 0.0287data6-7-40-04150.txt 7 6 40 31 0.0034data6-7-40-04151.txt 7 6 40 27 0.0062data6-7-40-04152.txt 7 6 40 41 0.0467data6-7-40-04153.txt 7 6 40 24 0.0025data6-7-40-04154.txt 7 6 40 27 0.0032data6-7-40-04155.txt 7 6 40 33 0.1087data6-7-40-04156.txt 7 6 40 37 0.0712data6-7-40-04157.txt 7 6 40 34 0.0048data6-7-40-04158.txt 7 6 40 36 0.0677data6-7-40-04159.txt 7 6 40 41 0.4974data6-7-40-04160.txt 7 6 40 34 0.0449data6-7-40-04161.txt 7 6 40 35 0.1228data6-7-40-04162.txt 7 6 40 35 0.4212data6-7-40-04163.txt 7 6 40 30 0.1293data6-7-40-04164.txt 7 6 40 26 0.0032data6-7-40-04165.txt 7 6 40 31 0.0383data6-7-40-04166.txt 7 6 40 37 0.0133data6-7-40-04167.txt 7 6 40 27 0.0197data6-7-40-04168.txt 7 6 40 27 0.1621data6-7-40-04169.txt 7 6 40 32 0.0928data6-7-40-04170.txt 7 6 40 38 0.4159

Table 101: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 307: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-7-40-04171.txt 7 6 40 33 0.0085data6-7-40-04172.txt 7 6 40 44 0.2563data6-7-40-04173.txt 7 6 40 24 0.0031data6-7-40-04174.txt 7 6 40 36 0.0336data6-7-40-04175.txt 7 6 40 31 0.0656data6-7-40-04176.txt 7 6 40 30 0.0337data6-7-40-04177.txt 7 6 40 37 0.0595data6-7-40-04178.txt 7 6 40 39 0.0294data6-7-40-04179.txt 7 6 40 37 0.0461data6-7-40-04180.txt 7 6 40 40 0.0251data6-7-40-04181.txt 7 6 40 34 0.0262data6-7-40-04182.txt 7 6 40 34 0.1346data6-7-40-04183.txt 7 6 40 37 0.0301data6-7-40-04184.txt 7 6 40 30 0.1268data6-7-40-04185.txt 7 6 40 32 0.0793data6-7-40-04186.txt 7 6 40 29 0.0059data6-7-40-04187.txt 7 6 40 28 0.0628data6-7-40-04188.txt 7 6 40 37 0.1193data6-7-40-04189.txt 7 6 40 35 0.0381data6-7-40-04190.txt 7 6 40 32 0.0112data6-7-40-04191.txt 7 6 40 28 0.0034data6-7-40-04192.txt 7 6 40 25 0.0026data6-7-40-04193.txt 7 6 40 38 0.2215data6-7-40-04194.txt 7 6 40 35 0.1441data6-7-40-04195.txt 7 6 40 32 0.0026data6-7-40-04196.txt 7 6 40 28 0.0029data6-7-40-04197.txt 7 6 40 37 0.0934data6-7-40-04198.txt 7 6 40 28 0.0027data6-7-40-04199.txt 7 6 40 37 0.4834data6-7-40-04200.txt 7 6 40 27 0.0077data6-7-41-04201.txt 7 6 41 32 0.1774data6-7-41-04202.txt 7 6 41 34 0.2377data6-7-41-04203.txt 7 6 41 29 0.0103data6-7-41-04204.txt 7 6 41 39 0.1473data6-7-41-04205.txt 7 6 41 31 0.0109data6-7-41-04206.txt 7 6 41 25 0.0031data6-7-41-04207.txt 7 6 41 43 0.1958data6-7-41-04208.txt 7 6 41 32 0.0355data6-7-41-04209.txt 7 6 41 25 0.0029data6-7-41-04210.txt 7 6 41 32 0.0045data6-7-41-04211.txt 7 6 41 35 0.1665data6-7-41-04212.txt 7 6 41 30 0.0689data6-7-41-04213.txt 7 6 41 35 0.1834data6-7-41-04214.txt 7 6 41 31 0.1726data6-7-41-04215.txt 7 6 41 48 0.2672data6-7-41-04216.txt 7 6 41 42 0.2433data6-7-41-04217.txt 7 6 41 33 0.0110data6-7-41-04218.txt 7 6 41 34 0.0075data6-7-41-04219.txt 7 6 41 30 0.0061data6-7-41-04220.txt 7 6 41 23 0.0090data6-7-41-04221.txt 7 6 41 29 0.0031data6-7-41-04222.txt 7 6 41 32 0.1627data6-7-41-04223.txt 7 6 41 28 0.0063data6-7-41-04224.txt 7 6 41 35 0.1507data6-7-41-04225.txt 7 6 41 28 0.0082data6-7-41-04226.txt 7 6 41 30 0.1162data6-7-41-04227.txt 7 6 41 46 0.1730data6-7-41-04228.txt 7 6 41 42 0.0169data6-7-41-04229.txt 7 6 41 37 0.3162data6-7-41-04230.txt 7 6 41 40 0.0033data6-7-41-04231.txt 7 6 41 32 0.0026data6-7-41-04232.txt 7 6 41 44 0.1887data6-7-41-04233.txt 7 6 41 40 0.0377data6-7-41-04234.txt 7 6 41 38 0.1043data6-7-41-04235.txt 7 6 41 28 0.0112data6-7-41-04236.txt 7 6 41 34 0.4421data6-7-41-04237.txt 7 6 41 33 0.1423data6-7-41-04238.txt 7 6 41 32 0.0260data6-7-41-04239.txt 7 6 41 32 0.0209data6-7-41-04240.txt 7 6 41 35 0.3371

Table 102: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 308: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-7-41-04241.txt 7 6 41 40 0.3733data6-7-41-04242.txt 7 6 41 34 0.2384data6-7-41-04243.txt 7 6 41 36 0.0147data6-7-41-04244.txt 7 6 41 35 0.0349data6-7-41-04245.txt 7 6 41 28 0.0097data6-7-41-04246.txt 7 6 41 30 0.0255data6-7-41-04247.txt 7 6 41 24 0.0029data6-7-41-04248.txt 7 6 41 26 0.0273data6-7-41-04249.txt 7 6 41 45 0.1974data6-7-41-04250.txt 7 6 41 28 0.0061data6-7-41-04251.txt 7 6 41 33 0.0280data6-7-41-04252.txt 7 6 41 34 0.0669data6-7-41-04253.txt 7 6 41 32 0.0031data6-7-41-04254.txt 7 6 41 43 0.0708data6-7-41-04255.txt 7 6 41 32 0.2345data6-7-41-04256.txt 7 6 41 38 0.0367data6-7-41-04257.txt 7 6 41 44 0.1984data6-7-41-04258.txt 7 6 41 46 0.3511data6-7-41-04259.txt 7 6 41 42 0.1122data6-7-41-04260.txt 7 6 41 30 0.3480data6-7-41-04261.txt 7 6 41 40 0.1010data6-7-41-04262.txt 7 6 41 31 0.0145data6-7-41-04263.txt 7 6 41 31 0.1591data6-7-41-04264.txt 7 6 41 31 0.3233data6-7-41-04265.txt 7 6 41 34 0.0350data6-7-41-04266.txt 7 6 41 27 0.0078data6-7-41-04267.txt 7 6 41 34 0.1426data6-7-41-04268.txt 7 6 41 29 0.0030data6-7-41-04269.txt 7 6 41 38 0.0556data6-7-41-04270.txt 7 6 41 31 0.0355data6-7-41-04271.txt 7 6 41 28 0.0161data6-7-41-04272.txt 7 6 41 31 0.0203data6-7-41-04273.txt 7 6 41 32 0.0295data6-7-41-04274.txt 7 6 41 31 0.0035data6-7-41-04275.txt 7 6 41 34 0.0851data6-7-41-04276.txt 7 6 41 40 0.0042data6-7-41-04277.txt 7 6 41 30 0.1092data6-7-41-04278.txt 7 6 41 28 0.0025data6-7-41-04279.txt 7 6 41 38 0.4440data6-7-41-04280.txt 7 6 41 27 0.0115data6-7-41-04281.txt 7 6 41 32 0.0886data6-7-41-04282.txt 7 6 41 39 0.3775data6-7-41-04283.txt 7 6 41 32 0.0584data6-7-41-04284.txt 7 6 41 40 0.1092data6-7-41-04285.txt 7 6 41 31 0.1179data6-7-41-04286.txt 7 6 41 32 0.0095data6-7-41-04287.txt 7 6 41 34 0.1870data6-7-41-04288.txt 7 6 41 38 0.0058data6-7-41-04289.txt 7 6 41 25 0.0037data6-7-41-04290.txt 7 6 41 34 0.0242data6-7-41-04291.txt 7 6 41 27 0.0877data6-7-41-04292.txt 7 6 41 32 0.0101data6-7-41-04293.txt 7 6 41 31 0.0030data6-7-41-04294.txt 7 6 41 39 0.1442data6-7-41-04295.txt 7 6 41 32 0.2089data6-7-41-04296.txt 7 6 41 30 0.0275data6-7-41-04297.txt 7 6 41 36 0.0176data6-7-41-04298.txt 7 6 41 33 0.2419data6-7-41-04299.txt 7 6 41 32 0.0379data6-7-41-04300.txt 7 6 41 31 0.2541data6-8-42-06201.txt 8 6 42 27 0.2859data6-8-42-06202.txt 8 6 42 33 0.5192data6-8-42-06203.txt 8 6 42 33 0.1094data6-8-42-06204.txt 8 6 42 27 0.0242data6-8-42-06205.txt 8 6 42 25 0.0034data6-8-42-06206.txt 8 6 42 32 0.1270data6-8-42-06207.txt 8 6 42 30 0.0028data6-8-42-06208.txt 8 6 42 28 0.0133data6-8-42-06209.txt 8 6 42 33 0.0201data6-8-42-06210.txt 8 6 42 30 0.2248

Table 103: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 309: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-8-42-06211.txt 8 6 42 29 0.1977data6-8-42-06212.txt 8 6 42 33 0.3939data6-8-42-06213.txt 8 6 42 29 0.3229data6-8-42-06214.txt 8 6 42 25 0.0052data6-8-42-06215.txt 8 6 42 33 0.3187data6-8-42-06216.txt 8 6 42 33 0.0653data6-8-42-06217.txt 8 6 42 37 0.4439data6-8-42-06218.txt 8 6 42 25 0.1280data6-8-42-06219.txt 8 6 42 27 0.1310data6-8-42-06220.txt 8 6 42 28 0.0031data6-8-42-06221.txt 8 6 42 32 0.1153data6-8-42-06222.txt 8 6 42 40 0.2874data6-8-42-06223.txt 8 6 42 29 0.0384data6-8-42-06224.txt 8 6 42 27 0.6120data6-8-42-06225.txt 8 6 42 34 0.5430data6-8-42-06226.txt 8 6 42 30 0.0035data6-8-42-06227.txt 8 6 42 27 0.0937data6-8-42-06228.txt 8 6 42 34 0.0151data6-8-42-06229.txt 8 6 42 29 0.1354data6-8-42-06230.txt 8 6 42 30 0.0027data6-8-42-06231.txt 8 6 42 34 0.2666data6-8-42-06232.txt 8 6 42 39 0.2301data6-8-42-06233.txt 8 6 42 32 0.3586data6-8-42-06234.txt 8 6 42 32 0.0454data6-8-42-06235.txt 8 6 42 37 0.2591data6-8-42-06236.txt 8 6 42 25 0.0026data6-8-42-06237.txt 8 6 42 32 0.2264data6-8-42-06238.txt 8 6 42 32 0.1119data6-8-42-06239.txt 8 6 42 36 0.5763data6-8-42-06240.txt 8 6 42 32 0.1688data6-8-42-06241.txt 8 6 42 25 0.0029data6-8-42-06242.txt 8 6 42 28 0.0735data6-8-42-06243.txt 8 6 42 31 0.1355data6-8-42-06244.txt 8 6 42 31 0.0027data6-8-42-06245.txt 8 6 42 37 0.1336data6-8-42-06246.txt 8 6 42 32 0.0443data6-8-42-06247.txt 8 6 42 34 0.5205data6-8-42-06248.txt 8 6 42 27 0.0026data6-8-42-06249.txt 8 6 42 28 0.0262data6-8-42-06250.txt 8 6 42 33 0.1719data6-8-42-06251.txt 8 6 42 32 0.0482data6-8-42-06252.txt 8 6 42 36 0.2765data6-8-42-06253.txt 8 6 42 33 0.0478data6-8-42-06254.txt 8 6 42 35 0.0263data6-8-42-06255.txt 8 6 42 31 0.2177data6-8-42-06256.txt 8 6 42 27 0.0183data6-8-42-06257.txt 8 6 42 35 0.6643data6-8-42-06258.txt 8 6 42 35 0.1027data6-8-42-06259.txt 8 6 42 29 0.0062data6-8-42-06260.txt 8 6 42 32 0.0404data6-8-42-06261.txt 8 6 42 22 0.0045data6-8-42-06262.txt 8 6 42 31 0.0148data6-8-42-06263.txt 8 6 42 29 0.0533data6-8-42-06264.txt 8 6 42 24 0.0703data6-8-42-06265.txt 8 6 42 34 0.0765data6-8-42-06266.txt 8 6 42 20 0.0025data6-8-42-06267.txt 8 6 42 36 0.0459data6-8-42-06268.txt 8 6 42 31 0.0340data6-8-42-06269.txt 8 6 42 32 0.0672data6-8-42-06270.txt 8 6 42 33 0.2001data6-8-42-06271.txt 8 6 42 31 0.2019data6-8-42-06272.txt 8 6 42 29 0.0575data6-8-42-06273.txt 8 6 42 35 0.0857data6-8-42-06274.txt 8 6 42 35 0.5780data6-8-42-06275.txt 8 6 42 32 0.0046data6-8-42-06276.txt 8 6 42 26 0.2196data6-8-42-06277.txt 8 6 42 27 0.1319data6-8-42-06278.txt 8 6 42 32 0.0219data6-8-42-06279.txt 8 6 42 27 0.0315data6-8-42-06280.txt 8 6 42 30 0.0154

Table 104: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 310: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-8-42-06281.txt 8 6 42 38 0.1810data6-8-42-06282.txt 8 6 42 35 0.0354data6-8-42-06283.txt 8 6 42 37 0.1883data6-8-42-06284.txt 8 6 42 32 0.3335data6-8-42-06285.txt 8 6 42 35 0.4413data6-8-42-06286.txt 8 6 42 31 0.0696data6-8-42-06287.txt 8 6 42 38 0.3617data6-8-42-06288.txt 8 6 42 27 0.0084data6-8-42-06289.txt 8 6 42 35 0.5445data6-8-42-06290.txt 8 6 42 34 0.3389data6-8-42-06291.txt 8 6 42 27 0.0833data6-8-42-06292.txt 8 6 42 32 0.1179data6-8-42-06293.txt 8 6 42 37 0.1359data6-8-42-06294.txt 8 6 42 39 0.3164data6-8-42-06295.txt 8 6 42 39 0.1485data6-8-42-06296.txt 8 6 42 37 0.1770data6-8-42-06297.txt 8 6 42 34 0.0888data6-8-42-06298.txt 8 6 42 24 0.0027data6-8-42-06299.txt 8 6 42 32 0.0753data6-8-42-06300.txt 8 6 42 29 0.0032data6-8-43-06301.txt 8 6 43 35 0.1028data6-8-43-06302.txt 8 6 43 34 0.0042data6-8-43-06303.txt 8 6 43 35 0.1128data6-8-43-06304.txt 8 6 43 34 0.0246data6-8-43-06305.txt 8 6 43 31 0.0035data6-8-43-06306.txt 8 6 43 40 0.3423data6-8-43-06307.txt 8 6 43 32 0.0955data6-8-43-06308.txt 8 6 43 26 0.0078data6-8-43-06309.txt 8 6 43 29 0.0028data6-8-43-06310.txt 8 6 43 38 0.1271data6-8-43-06311.txt 8 6 43 34 0.0080data6-8-43-06312.txt 8 6 43 38 0.3205data6-8-43-06313.txt 8 6 43 35 0.0568data6-8-43-06314.txt 8 6 43 35 0.2942data6-8-43-06315.txt 8 6 43 33 0.5885data6-8-43-06316.txt 8 6 43 33 0.1250data6-8-43-06317.txt 8 6 43 29 0.4111data6-8-43-06318.txt 8 6 43 31 0.2000data6-8-43-06319.txt 8 6 43 30 0.1113data6-8-43-06320.txt 8 6 43 38 0.3765data6-8-43-06321.txt 8 6 43 29 0.0307data6-8-43-06322.txt 8 6 43 33 0.2378data6-8-43-06323.txt 8 6 43 38 0.0592data6-8-43-06324.txt 8 6 43 45 0.2557data6-8-43-06325.txt 8 6 43 36 0.0031data6-8-43-06326.txt 8 6 43 35 0.4688data6-8-43-06327.txt 8 6 43 35 0.0044data6-8-43-06328.txt 8 6 43 32 0.0653data6-8-43-06329.txt 8 6 43 34 0.0028data6-8-43-06330.txt 8 6 43 39 0.0930data6-8-43-06331.txt 8 6 43 37 0.2381data6-8-43-06332.txt 8 6 43 41 0.3575data6-8-43-06333.txt 8 6 43 35 0.0489data6-8-43-06334.txt 8 6 43 33 0.6820data6-8-43-06335.txt 8 6 43 33 0.0612data6-8-43-06336.txt 8 6 43 29 0.0038data6-8-43-06337.txt 8 6 43 41 0.0794data6-8-43-06338.txt 8 6 43 36 0.3339data6-8-43-06339.txt 8 6 43 33 0.0710data6-8-43-06340.txt 8 6 43 36 0.1239data6-8-43-06341.txt 8 6 43 40 0.0317data6-8-43-06342.txt 8 6 43 28 0.2074data6-8-43-06343.txt 8 6 43 36 0.8399data6-8-43-06344.txt 8 6 43 31 0.3540data6-8-43-06345.txt 8 6 43 32 0.4772data6-8-43-06346.txt 8 6 43 31 0.1486data6-8-43-06347.txt 8 6 43 35 0.0135data6-8-43-06348.txt 8 6 43 27 0.0098data6-8-43-06349.txt 8 6 43 33 0.0097data6-8-43-06350.txt 8 6 43 38 0.1328

Table 105: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 311: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-8-43-06351.txt 8 6 43 28 0.3139data6-8-43-06352.txt 8 6 43 34 0.1235data6-8-43-06353.txt 8 6 43 36 0.1599data6-8-43-06354.txt 8 6 43 34 0.1035data6-8-43-06355.txt 8 6 43 38 0.2240data6-8-43-06356.txt 8 6 43 38 0.0690data6-8-43-06357.txt 8 6 43 45 0.1095data6-8-43-06358.txt 8 6 43 29 0.0035data6-8-43-06359.txt 8 6 43 33 0.0149data6-8-43-06360.txt 8 6 43 30 0.3267data6-8-43-06361.txt 8 6 43 27 0.1505data6-8-43-06362.txt 8 6 43 33 0.1888data6-8-43-06363.txt 8 6 43 34 0.0046data6-8-43-06364.txt 8 6 43 29 0.0614data6-8-43-06365.txt 8 6 43 27 0.0071data6-8-43-06366.txt 8 6 43 38 0.2688data6-8-43-06367.txt 8 6 43 36 0.5393data6-8-43-06368.txt 8 6 43 29 0.0092data6-8-43-06369.txt 8 6 43 44 0.6074data6-8-43-06370.txt 8 6 43 29 0.0105data6-8-43-06371.txt 8 6 43 41 0.2128data6-8-43-06372.txt 8 6 43 36 0.0359data6-8-43-06373.txt 8 6 43 39 0.1667data6-8-43-06374.txt 8 6 43 32 0.0628data6-8-43-06375.txt 8 6 43 29 0.1140data6-8-43-06376.txt 8 6 43 35 0.4900data6-8-43-06377.txt 8 6 43 29 0.0290data6-8-43-06378.txt 8 6 43 33 0.1183data6-8-43-06379.txt 8 6 43 33 0.2064data6-8-43-06380.txt 8 6 43 34 0.0934data6-8-43-06381.txt 8 6 43 39 0.2423data6-8-43-06382.txt 8 6 43 34 0.0054data6-8-43-06383.txt 8 6 43 35 0.0026data6-8-43-06384.txt 8 6 43 30 0.0135data6-8-43-06385.txt 8 6 43 34 0.0889data6-8-43-06386.txt 8 6 43 28 0.0068data6-8-43-06387.txt 8 6 43 36 0.2434data6-8-43-06388.txt 8 6 43 41 0.2713data6-8-43-06389.txt 8 6 43 36 0.0503data6-8-43-06390.txt 8 6 43 31 0.3829data6-8-43-06391.txt 8 6 43 32 0.0464data6-8-43-06392.txt 8 6 43 29 0.0097data6-8-43-06393.txt 8 6 43 33 0.0099data6-8-43-06394.txt 8 6 43 35 0.1017data6-8-43-06395.txt 8 6 43 35 0.1574data6-8-43-06396.txt 8 6 43 34 0.1531data6-8-43-06397.txt 8 6 43 36 0.0802data6-8-43-06398.txt 8 6 43 35 0.0549data6-8-43-06399.txt 8 6 43 36 0.0197data6-8-43-06400.txt 8 6 43 31 0.3209data6-8-44-06401.txt 8 6 44 43 0.2467data6-8-44-06402.txt 8 6 44 34 0.0039data6-8-44-06403.txt 8 6 44 32 0.0694data6-8-44-06404.txt 8 6 44 27 0.1312data6-8-44-06405.txt 8 6 44 42 0.2210data6-8-44-06406.txt 8 6 44 25 0.0362data6-8-44-06407.txt 8 6 44 24 0.0030data6-8-44-06408.txt 8 6 44 41 0.0920data6-8-44-06409.txt 8 6 44 26 0.0103data6-8-44-06410.txt 8 6 44 32 0.0237data6-8-44-06411.txt 8 6 44 31 0.2150data6-8-44-06412.txt 8 6 44 41 0.3303data6-8-44-06413.txt 8 6 44 35 0.1425data6-8-44-06414.txt 8 6 44 35 0.2426data6-8-44-06415.txt 8 6 44 41 0.5145data6-8-44-06416.txt 8 6 44 38 0.0197data6-8-44-06417.txt 8 6 44 24 0.0638data6-8-44-06418.txt 8 6 44 39 0.0168data6-8-44-06419.txt 8 6 44 29 0.1637data6-8-44-06420.txt 8 6 44 36 0.1175

Table 106: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 312: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-8-44-06421.txt 8 6 44 38 0.4691data6-8-44-06422.txt 8 6 44 32 0.1173data6-8-44-06423.txt 8 6 44 39 0.1681data6-8-44-06424.txt 8 6 44 28 0.0196data6-8-44-06425.txt 8 6 44 35 0.0346data6-8-44-06426.txt 8 6 44 33 0.0940data6-8-44-06427.txt 8 6 44 30 0.2641data6-8-44-06428.txt 8 6 44 33 0.0235data6-8-44-06429.txt 8 6 44 38 0.0756data6-8-44-06430.txt 8 6 44 37 0.0324data6-8-44-06431.txt 8 6 44 31 0.5282data6-8-44-06432.txt 8 6 44 36 0.1270data6-8-44-06433.txt 8 6 44 43 0.2740data6-8-44-06434.txt 8 6 44 37 0.0502data6-8-44-06435.txt 8 6 44 41 0.1286data6-8-44-06436.txt 8 6 44 25 0.0558data6-8-44-06437.txt 8 6 44 31 0.7552data6-8-44-06438.txt 8 6 44 34 0.1871data6-8-44-06439.txt 8 6 44 34 0.0077data6-8-44-06440.txt 8 6 44 36 0.0059data6-8-44-06441.txt 8 6 44 36 0.4209data6-8-44-06442.txt 8 6 44 32 0.3307data6-8-44-06443.txt 8 6 44 35 0.0858data6-8-44-06444.txt 8 6 44 30 0.0287data6-8-44-06445.txt 8 6 44 34 0.0356data6-8-44-06446.txt 8 6 44 44 0.4773data6-8-44-06447.txt 8 6 44 41 0.2247data6-8-44-06448.txt 8 6 44 37 0.6833data6-8-44-06449.txt 8 6 44 39 0.1479data6-8-44-06450.txt 8 6 44 31 0.0043data6-8-44-06451.txt 8 6 44 44 0.3013data6-8-44-06452.txt 8 6 44 38 0.0519data6-8-44-06453.txt 8 6 44 35 0.3367data6-8-44-06454.txt 8 6 44 43 0.1549data6-8-44-06455.txt 8 6 44 31 0.0959data6-8-44-06456.txt 8 6 44 37 0.0553data6-8-44-06457.txt 8 6 44 37 0.5615data6-8-44-06458.txt 8 6 44 27 0.2146data6-8-44-06459.txt 8 6 44 38 0.2583data6-8-44-06460.txt 8 6 44 33 0.4568data6-8-44-06461.txt 8 6 44 28 0.0416data6-8-44-06462.txt 8 6 44 33 0.2861data6-8-44-06463.txt 8 6 44 42 0.0797data6-8-44-06464.txt 8 6 44 27 0.3154data6-8-44-06465.txt 8 6 44 36 0.1555data6-8-44-06466.txt 8 6 44 33 0.0160data6-8-44-06467.txt 8 6 44 36 0.1127data6-8-44-06468.txt 8 6 44 35 0.0772data6-8-44-06469.txt 8 6 44 31 0.1447data6-8-44-06470.txt 8 6 44 32 0.4948data6-8-44-06471.txt 8 6 44 34 0.4076data6-8-44-06472.txt 8 6 44 35 0.0375data6-8-44-06473.txt 8 6 44 34 0.5080data6-8-44-06474.txt 8 6 44 33 0.0621data6-8-44-06475.txt 8 6 44 40 0.0044data6-8-44-06476.txt 8 6 44 40 0.0733data6-8-44-06477.txt 8 6 44 30 0.0088data6-8-44-06478.txt 8 6 44 31 0.1706data6-8-44-06479.txt 8 6 44 40 0.3062data6-8-44-06480.txt 8 6 44 36 0.0031data6-8-44-06481.txt 8 6 44 33 0.2588data6-8-44-06482.txt 8 6 44 33 0.1543data6-8-44-06483.txt 8 6 44 29 0.0254data6-8-44-06484.txt 8 6 44 35 0.3690data6-8-44-06485.txt 8 6 44 50 0.0564data6-8-44-06486.txt 8 6 44 36 0.2509data6-8-44-06487.txt 8 6 44 33 0.1040data6-8-44-06488.txt 8 6 44 30 0.3736data6-8-44-06489.txt 8 6 44 32 0.0704data6-8-44-06490.txt 8 6 44 35 0.2393

Table 107: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 313: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-8-44-06491.txt 8 6 44 43 0.2987data6-8-44-06492.txt 8 6 44 44 0.0552data6-8-44-06493.txt 8 6 44 33 0.0621data6-8-44-06494.txt 8 6 44 44 0.0156data6-8-44-06495.txt 8 6 44 47 0.3697data6-8-44-06496.txt 8 6 44 36 0.0519data6-8-44-06497.txt 8 6 44 37 0.0098data6-8-44-06498.txt 8 6 44 39 0.4747data6-8-44-06499.txt 8 6 44 33 0.3527data6-8-44-06500.txt 8 6 44 31 0.0447data6-8-45-06501.txt 8 6 45 34 0.1691data6-8-45-06502.txt 8 6 45 41 0.3572data6-8-45-06503.txt 8 6 45 31 0.0123data6-8-45-06504.txt 8 6 45 45 0.4618data6-8-45-06505.txt 8 6 45 36 0.3142data6-8-45-06506.txt 8 6 45 33 0.0302data6-8-45-06507.txt 8 6 45 27 0.0032data6-8-45-06508.txt 8 6 45 38 0.2155data6-8-45-06509.txt 8 6 45 37 0.1734data6-8-45-06510.txt 8 6 45 41 0.1060data6-8-45-06511.txt 8 6 45 33 0.1483data6-8-45-06512.txt 8 6 45 40 0.4968data6-8-45-06513.txt 8 6 45 34 0.0925data6-8-45-06514.txt 8 6 45 40 0.0040data6-8-45-06515.txt 8 6 45 37 0.0527data6-8-45-06516.txt 8 6 45 43 0.1319data6-8-45-06517.txt 8 6 45 34 0.0495data6-8-45-06518.txt 8 6 45 34 0.0796data6-8-45-06519.txt 8 6 45 41 0.4497data6-8-45-06520.txt 8 6 45 37 0.0802data6-8-45-06521.txt 8 6 45 41 0.1449data6-8-45-06522.txt 8 6 45 37 0.0759data6-8-45-06523.txt 8 6 45 37 0.0437data6-8-45-06524.txt 8 6 45 34 0.1864data6-8-45-06525.txt 8 6 45 34 0.0043data6-8-45-06526.txt 8 6 45 45 0.3126data6-8-45-06527.txt 8 6 45 35 0.1159data6-8-45-06528.txt 8 6 45 30 0.0582data6-8-45-06529.txt 8 6 45 37 0.2916data6-8-45-06530.txt 8 6 45 41 0.4586data6-8-45-06531.txt 8 6 45 36 0.0412data6-8-45-06532.txt 8 6 45 38 0.1577data6-8-45-06533.txt 8 6 45 29 0.0257data6-8-45-06534.txt 8 6 45 37 0.0790data6-8-45-06535.txt 8 6 45 46 0.4129data6-8-45-06536.txt 8 6 45 32 0.0589data6-8-45-06537.txt 8 6 45 32 0.1058data6-8-45-06538.txt 8 6 45 30 0.1834data6-8-45-06539.txt 8 6 45 40 0.0091data6-8-45-06540.txt 8 6 45 37 0.0030data6-8-45-06541.txt 8 6 45 45 0.0464data6-8-45-06542.txt 8 6 45 42 0.1562data6-8-45-06543.txt 8 6 45 40 0.1639data6-8-45-06544.txt 8 6 45 39 0.0956data6-8-45-06545.txt 8 6 45 32 0.0816data6-8-45-06546.txt 8 6 45 44 0.2713data6-8-45-06547.txt 8 6 45 40 0.0087data6-8-45-06548.txt 8 6 45 38 0.0038data6-8-45-06549.txt 8 6 45 29 0.4752data6-8-45-06550.txt 8 6 45 31 0.0520data6-8-45-06551.txt 8 6 45 27 0.0564data6-8-45-06552.txt 8 6 45 34 0.0767data6-8-45-06553.txt 8 6 45 36 0.0735data6-8-45-06554.txt 8 6 45 45 0.1416data6-8-45-06555.txt 8 6 45 33 0.0107data6-8-45-06556.txt 8 6 45 38 0.1936data6-8-45-06557.txt 8 6 45 26 0.0066data6-8-45-06558.txt 8 6 45 42 0.0349data6-8-45-06559.txt 8 6 45 32 0.3553data6-8-45-06560.txt 8 6 45 38 0.1331

Table 108: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 314: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-8-45-06561.txt 8 6 45 38 0.0261data6-8-45-06562.txt 8 6 45 40 0.0203data6-8-45-06563.txt 8 6 45 40 0.0479data6-8-45-06564.txt 8 6 45 34 0.0781data6-8-45-06565.txt 8 6 45 39 0.1362data6-8-45-06566.txt 8 6 45 34 0.4323data6-8-45-06567.txt 8 6 45 28 0.1722data6-8-45-06568.txt 8 6 45 36 0.3239data6-8-45-06569.txt 8 6 45 37 0.1942data6-8-45-06570.txt 8 6 45 32 0.1887data6-8-45-06571.txt 8 6 45 23 0.0042data6-8-45-06572.txt 8 6 45 30 0.0730data6-8-45-06573.txt 8 6 45 37 0.1685data6-8-45-06574.txt 8 6 45 35 0.2272data6-8-45-06575.txt 8 6 45 42 0.2857data6-8-45-06576.txt 8 6 45 40 0.0172data6-8-45-06577.txt 8 6 45 40 0.1334data6-8-45-06578.txt 8 6 45 37 0.0031data6-8-45-06579.txt 8 6 45 35 0.0049data6-8-45-06580.txt 8 6 45 35 0.0305data6-8-45-06581.txt 8 6 45 40 0.1342data6-8-45-06582.txt 8 6 45 39 0.0090data6-8-45-06583.txt 8 6 45 40 0.1269data6-8-45-06584.txt 8 6 45 38 0.0041data6-8-45-06585.txt 8 6 45 33 0.1673data6-8-45-06586.txt 8 6 45 30 0.1323data6-8-45-06587.txt 8 6 45 29 0.0146data6-8-45-06588.txt 8 6 45 39 0.0085data6-8-45-06589.txt 8 6 45 36 0.1767data6-8-45-06590.txt 8 6 45 37 0.0531data6-8-45-06591.txt 8 6 45 31 0.1559data6-8-45-06592.txt 8 6 45 28 0.0052data6-8-45-06593.txt 8 6 45 41 0.0992data6-8-45-06594.txt 8 6 45 32 0.2279data6-8-45-06595.txt 8 6 45 41 0.2535data6-8-45-06596.txt 8 6 45 30 0.0859data6-8-45-06597.txt 8 6 45 37 0.1243data6-8-45-06598.txt 8 6 45 36 0.2190data6-8-45-06599.txt 8 6 45 33 0.1292data6-8-45-06600.txt 8 6 45 29 0.0787data6-8-46-06601.txt 8 6 46 44 0.2379data6-8-46-06602.txt 8 6 46 42 0.0228data6-8-46-06603.txt 8 6 46 44 0.2095data6-8-46-06604.txt 8 6 46 37 0.0045data6-8-46-06605.txt 8 6 46 35 0.0034data6-8-46-06606.txt 8 6 46 32 0.1859data6-8-46-06607.txt 8 6 46 38 0.0336data6-8-46-06608.txt 8 6 46 36 0.3212data6-8-46-06609.txt 8 6 46 33 0.0039data6-8-46-06610.txt 8 6 46 33 0.0305data6-8-46-06611.txt 8 6 46 44 0.3147data6-8-46-06612.txt 8 6 46 34 0.4264data6-8-46-06613.txt 8 6 46 33 0.2642data6-8-46-06614.txt 8 6 46 31 0.1029data6-8-46-06615.txt 8 6 46 33 0.0177data6-8-46-06616.txt 8 6 46 35 0.2086data6-8-46-06617.txt 8 6 46 38 0.2469data6-8-46-06618.txt 8 6 46 42 0.0165data6-8-46-06619.txt 8 6 46 37 0.0102data6-8-46-06620.txt 8 6 46 40 0.0541data6-8-46-06621.txt 8 6 46 37 0.2135data6-8-46-06622.txt 8 6 46 35 0.3152data6-8-46-06623.txt 8 6 46 44 0.0749data6-8-46-06624.txt 8 6 46 33 0.1846data6-8-46-06625.txt 8 6 46 32 0.5081data6-8-46-06626.txt 8 6 46 33 0.2116data6-8-46-06627.txt 8 6 46 29 0.0734data6-8-46-06628.txt 8 6 46 43 0.2252data6-8-46-06629.txt 8 6 46 37 0.0041data6-8-46-06630.txt 8 6 46 32 0.0676

Table 109: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 315: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-8-46-06631.txt 8 6 46 36 0.1098data6-8-46-06632.txt 8 6 46 41 0.0673data6-8-46-06633.txt 8 6 46 35 0.0392data6-8-46-06634.txt 8 6 46 35 0.1206data6-8-46-06635.txt 8 6 46 30 0.0063data6-8-46-06636.txt 8 6 46 36 0.0950data6-8-46-06637.txt 8 6 46 38 0.3144data6-8-46-06638.txt 8 6 46 42 0.3591data6-8-46-06639.txt 8 6 46 29 0.0243data6-8-46-06640.txt 8 6 46 31 0.3729data6-8-46-06641.txt 8 6 46 36 0.1741data6-8-46-06642.txt 8 6 46 27 0.2103data6-8-46-06643.txt 8 6 46 40 0.5627data6-8-46-06644.txt 8 6 46 36 0.6943data6-8-46-06645.txt 8 6 46 35 0.0075data6-8-46-06646.txt 8 6 46 33 0.1831data6-8-46-06647.txt 8 6 46 34 0.0110data6-8-46-06648.txt 8 6 46 44 0.0925data6-8-46-06649.txt 8 6 46 34 0.0238data6-8-46-06650.txt 8 6 46 38 0.0036data6-8-46-06651.txt 8 6 46 37 0.0487data6-8-46-06652.txt 8 6 46 32 0.0255data6-8-46-06653.txt 8 6 46 36 0.3045data6-8-46-06654.txt 8 6 46 36 0.0146data6-8-46-06655.txt 8 6 46 44 0.3901data6-8-46-06656.txt 8 6 46 38 0.0520data6-8-46-06657.txt 8 6 46 42 0.0516data6-8-46-06658.txt 8 6 46 34 0.0188data6-8-46-06659.txt 8 6 46 40 0.1461data6-8-46-06660.txt 8 6 46 40 0.0560data6-8-46-06661.txt 8 6 46 29 0.0093data6-8-46-06662.txt 8 6 46 44 0.0518data6-8-46-06663.txt 8 6 46 32 0.3226data6-8-46-06664.txt 8 6 46 41 0.2273data6-8-46-06665.txt 8 6 46 44 0.0889data6-8-46-06666.txt 8 6 46 37 0.0029data6-8-46-06667.txt 8 6 46 39 0.3845data6-8-46-06668.txt 8 6 46 38 0.1693data6-8-46-06669.txt 8 6 46 45 0.8207data6-8-46-06670.txt 8 6 46 37 0.2483data6-8-46-06671.txt 8 6 46 35 0.1217data6-8-46-06672.txt 8 6 46 33 0.0029data6-8-46-06673.txt 8 6 46 36 0.0855data6-8-46-06674.txt 8 6 46 39 0.0533data6-8-46-06675.txt 8 6 46 38 0.0227data6-8-46-06676.txt 8 6 46 36 0.0053data6-8-46-06677.txt 8 6 46 32 0.0034data6-8-46-06678.txt 8 6 46 32 0.0037data6-8-46-06679.txt 8 6 46 39 0.5232data6-8-46-06680.txt 8 6 46 34 0.0033data6-8-46-06681.txt 8 6 46 35 0.0343data6-8-46-06682.txt 8 6 46 35 0.1531data6-8-46-06683.txt 8 6 46 40 0.2619data6-8-46-06684.txt 8 6 46 27 0.0848data6-8-46-06685.txt 8 6 46 33 0.0209data6-8-46-06686.txt 8 6 46 38 0.1679data6-8-46-06687.txt 8 6 46 38 0.4093data6-8-46-06688.txt 8 6 46 46 0.3437data6-8-46-06689.txt 8 6 46 34 0.0691data6-8-46-06690.txt 8 6 46 38 0.1395data6-8-46-06691.txt 8 6 46 46 0.2530data6-8-46-06692.txt 8 6 46 42 0.0034data6-8-46-06693.txt 8 6 46 33 0.3131data6-8-46-06694.txt 8 6 46 41 0.6455data6-8-46-06695.txt 8 6 46 45 0.0036data6-8-46-06696.txt 8 6 46 25 0.0056data6-8-46-06697.txt 8 6 46 43 0.0055data6-8-46-06698.txt 8 6 46 31 0.0639data6-8-46-06699.txt 8 6 46 43 0.5335data6-8-46-06700.txt 8 6 46 36 0.0600

Table 110: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 316: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-8-47-06701.txt 8 6 47 39 0.5873data6-8-47-06702.txt 8 6 47 44 0.1275data6-8-47-06703.txt 8 6 47 33 0.0116data6-8-47-06704.txt 8 6 47 44 0.0050data6-8-47-06705.txt 8 6 47 42 0.1984data6-8-47-06706.txt 8 6 47 34 0.0066data6-8-47-06707.txt 8 6 47 35 0.1703data6-8-47-06708.txt 8 6 47 29 0.0417data6-8-47-06709.txt 8 6 47 43 0.1941data6-8-47-06710.txt 8 6 47 47 0.3808data6-8-47-06711.txt 8 6 47 35 0.0067data6-8-47-06712.txt 8 6 47 39 0.2782data6-8-47-06713.txt 8 6 47 28 0.0029data6-8-47-06714.txt 8 6 47 38 0.3639data6-8-47-06715.txt 8 6 47 34 0.0064data6-8-47-06716.txt 8 6 47 33 0.1254data6-8-47-06717.txt 8 6 47 33 0.3317data6-8-47-06718.txt 8 6 47 32 0.0103data6-8-47-06719.txt 8 6 47 36 0.0775data6-8-47-06720.txt 8 6 47 33 0.1831data6-8-47-06721.txt 8 6 47 38 0.3409data6-8-47-06722.txt 8 6 47 34 0.2414data6-8-47-06723.txt 8 6 47 42 0.0039data6-8-47-06724.txt 8 6 47 43 0.0184data6-8-47-06725.txt 8 6 47 38 0.0046data6-8-47-06726.txt 8 6 47 45 0.0391data6-8-47-06727.txt 8 6 47 38 0.1211data6-8-47-06728.txt 8 6 47 37 0.3467data6-8-47-06729.txt 8 6 47 50 0.2238data6-8-47-06730.txt 8 6 47 30 0.2735data6-8-47-06731.txt 8 6 47 39 0.0120data6-8-47-06732.txt 8 6 47 33 0.0323data6-8-47-06733.txt 8 6 47 38 0.4377data6-8-47-06734.txt 8 6 47 48 0.1305data6-8-47-06735.txt 8 6 47 38 0.3589data6-8-47-06736.txt 8 6 47 38 0.2197data6-8-47-06737.txt 8 6 47 35 0.1096data6-8-47-06738.txt 8 6 47 28 0.0044data6-8-47-06739.txt 8 6 47 43 0.4125data6-8-47-06740.txt 8 6 47 46 0.1268data6-8-47-06741.txt 8 6 47 38 0.1628data6-8-47-06742.txt 8 6 47 34 0.0838data6-8-47-06743.txt 8 6 47 46 0.3524data6-8-47-06744.txt 8 6 47 32 0.4718data6-8-47-06745.txt 8 6 47 50 0.2727data6-8-47-06746.txt 8 6 47 42 0.0269data6-8-47-06747.txt 8 6 47 48 0.5044data6-8-47-06748.txt 8 6 47 38 0.0052data6-8-47-06749.txt 8 6 47 37 0.0575data6-8-47-06750.txt 8 6 47 34 0.5897data6-8-47-06751.txt 8 6 47 47 0.2938data6-8-47-06752.txt 8 6 47 36 0.0047data6-8-47-06753.txt 8 6 47 37 0.0068data6-8-47-06754.txt 8 6 47 43 0.0867data6-8-47-06755.txt 8 6 47 38 0.0117data6-8-47-06756.txt 8 6 47 42 0.1863data6-8-47-06757.txt 8 6 47 37 0.2403data6-8-47-06758.txt 8 6 47 41 0.2691data6-8-47-06759.txt 8 6 47 40 0.1426data6-8-47-06760.txt 8 6 47 30 0.0042data6-8-47-06761.txt 8 6 47 42 0.1261data6-8-47-06762.txt 8 6 47 38 0.1019data6-8-47-06763.txt 8 6 47 36 0.0931data6-8-47-06764.txt 8 6 47 50 0.7358data6-8-47-06765.txt 8 6 47 43 0.2693data6-8-47-06766.txt 8 6 47 37 0.1970data6-8-47-06767.txt 8 6 47 37 0.1607data6-8-47-06768.txt 8 6 47 32 0.0283data6-8-47-06769.txt 8 6 47 33 0.0036data6-8-47-06770.txt 8 6 47 40 0.2627

Table 111: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 317: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-8-47-06771.txt 8 6 47 39 0.0831data6-8-47-06772.txt 8 6 47 40 0.2453data6-8-47-06773.txt 8 6 47 36 0.1710data6-8-47-06774.txt 8 6 47 43 0.0681data6-8-47-06775.txt 8 6 47 32 0.0063data6-8-47-06776.txt 8 6 47 45 0.1820data6-8-47-06777.txt 8 6 47 35 0.2219data6-8-47-06778.txt 8 6 47 37 0.0575data6-8-47-06779.txt 8 6 47 36 0.2837data6-8-47-06780.txt 8 6 47 43 0.3903data6-8-47-06781.txt 8 6 47 44 0.1167data6-8-47-06782.txt 8 6 47 43 0.2823data6-8-47-06783.txt 8 6 47 42 0.3554data6-8-47-06784.txt 8 6 47 41 0.0724data6-8-47-06785.txt 8 6 47 46 0.0748data6-8-47-06786.txt 8 6 47 41 0.2337data6-8-47-06787.txt 8 6 47 34 0.3325data6-8-47-06788.txt 8 6 47 38 0.6162data6-8-47-06789.txt 8 6 47 36 0.2100data6-8-47-06790.txt 8 6 47 41 0.0753data6-8-47-06791.txt 8 6 47 36 0.0630data6-8-47-06792.txt 8 6 47 42 0.0777data6-8-47-06793.txt 8 6 47 42 0.0559data6-8-47-06794.txt 8 6 47 45 0.2080data6-8-47-06795.txt 8 6 47 42 0.2628data6-8-47-06796.txt 8 6 47 38 0.0696data6-8-47-06797.txt 8 6 47 35 0.2064data6-8-47-06798.txt 8 6 47 31 0.0041data6-8-47-06799.txt 8 6 47 40 0.5693data6-8-47-06800.txt 8 6 47 33 0.1196data6-9-48-08701.txt 9 6 48 39 0.2544data6-9-48-08702.txt 9 6 48 38 0.0030data6-9-48-08703.txt 9 6 48 33 0.4201data6-9-48-08704.txt 9 6 48 34 0.1328data6-9-48-08705.txt 9 6 48 37 0.4536data6-9-48-08706.txt 9 6 48 32 0.0291data6-9-48-08707.txt 9 6 48 32 0.1723data6-9-48-08708.txt 9 6 48 34 0.3393data6-9-48-08709.txt 9 6 48 38 0.4463data6-9-48-08710.txt 9 6 48 38 0.1264data6-9-48-08711.txt 9 6 48 38 0.2560data6-9-48-08712.txt 9 6 48 33 0.3497data6-9-48-08713.txt 9 6 48 35 0.1247data6-9-48-08714.txt 9 6 48 37 0.5165data6-9-48-08715.txt 9 6 48 36 0.0221data6-9-48-08716.txt 9 6 48 47 0.4549data6-9-48-08717.txt 9 6 48 33 0.0029data6-9-48-08718.txt 9 6 48 31 0.2330data6-9-48-08719.txt 9 6 48 35 0.1445data6-9-48-08720.txt 9 6 48 40 0.2918data6-9-48-08721.txt 9 6 48 35 0.2135data6-9-48-08722.txt 9 6 48 40 0.2863data6-9-48-08723.txt 9 6 48 41 0.2619data6-9-48-08724.txt 9 6 48 36 0.0231data6-9-48-08725.txt 9 6 48 28 0.0032data6-9-48-08726.txt 9 6 48 36 0.7246data6-9-48-08727.txt 9 6 48 33 0.0855data6-9-48-08728.txt 9 6 48 38 0.3577data6-9-48-08729.txt 9 6 48 36 0.3351data6-9-48-08730.txt 9 6 48 37 0.8790data6-9-48-08731.txt 9 6 48 31 0.0057data6-9-48-08732.txt 9 6 48 37 0.2711data6-9-48-08733.txt 9 6 48 28 0.1869data6-9-48-08734.txt 9 6 48 31 0.0081data6-9-48-08735.txt 9 6 48 37 0.1319data6-9-48-08736.txt 9 6 48 37 0.3889data6-9-48-08737.txt 9 6 48 39 0.4327data6-9-48-08738.txt 9 6 48 41 0.7651data6-9-48-08739.txt 9 6 48 29 0.0672data6-9-48-08740.txt 9 6 48 34 0.6847

Table 112: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 318: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-9-48-08741.txt 9 6 48 35 0.8577data6-9-48-08742.txt 9 6 48 35 0.1379data6-9-48-08743.txt 9 6 48 31 0.0064data6-9-48-08744.txt 9 6 48 34 0.6763data6-9-48-08745.txt 9 6 48 38 0.5776data6-9-48-08746.txt 9 6 48 33 0.1059data6-9-48-08747.txt 9 6 48 34 0.3344data6-9-48-08748.txt 9 6 48 35 0.2630data6-9-48-08749.txt 9 6 48 33 0.0032data6-9-48-08750.txt 9 6 48 29 0.1706data6-9-48-08751.txt 9 6 48 32 0.0035data6-9-48-08752.txt 9 6 48 33 0.0865data6-9-48-08753.txt 9 6 48 34 0.4935data6-9-48-08754.txt 9 6 48 36 0.2864data6-9-48-08755.txt 9 6 48 36 0.0896data6-9-48-08756.txt 9 6 48 34 0.1382data6-9-48-08757.txt 9 6 48 36 0.4850data6-9-48-08758.txt 9 6 48 35 0.1717data6-9-48-08759.txt 9 6 48 28 0.0029data6-9-48-08760.txt 9 6 48 35 0.2825data6-9-48-08761.txt 9 6 48 35 0.5788data6-9-48-08762.txt 9 6 48 37 0.1090data6-9-48-08763.txt 9 6 48 39 0.3865data6-9-48-08764.txt 9 6 48 42 0.2350data6-9-48-08765.txt 9 6 48 40 0.4598data6-9-48-08766.txt 9 6 48 32 0.2276data6-9-48-08767.txt 9 6 48 31 0.0030data6-9-48-08768.txt 9 6 48 34 0.2191data6-9-48-08769.txt 9 6 48 35 0.0098data6-9-48-08770.txt 9 6 48 34 0.4834data6-9-48-08771.txt 9 6 48 36 0.0308data6-9-48-08772.txt 9 6 48 34 0.2740data6-9-48-08773.txt 9 6 48 29 0.1241data6-9-48-08774.txt 9 6 48 36 0.5346data6-9-48-08775.txt 9 6 48 37 0.0319data6-9-48-08776.txt 9 6 48 32 0.0051data6-9-48-08777.txt 9 6 48 37 0.1978data6-9-48-08778.txt 9 6 48 29 0.1344data6-9-48-08779.txt 9 6 48 33 0.1519data6-9-48-08780.txt 9 6 48 35 0.1120data6-9-48-08781.txt 9 6 48 39 0.0973data6-9-48-08782.txt 9 6 48 29 0.1946data6-9-48-08783.txt 9 6 48 37 0.0030data6-9-48-08784.txt 9 6 48 38 0.4372data6-9-48-08785.txt 9 6 48 43 0.3192data6-9-48-08786.txt 9 6 48 36 0.1746data6-9-48-08787.txt 9 6 48 27 0.7107data6-9-48-08788.txt 9 6 48 32 0.5033data6-9-48-08789.txt 9 6 48 42 0.5948data6-9-48-08790.txt 9 6 48 37 0.0907data6-9-48-08791.txt 9 6 48 29 0.2293data6-9-48-08792.txt 9 6 48 36 0.0808data6-9-48-08793.txt 9 6 48 33 0.1908data6-9-48-08794.txt 9 6 48 34 0.4591data6-9-48-08795.txt 9 6 48 33 0.1096data6-9-48-08796.txt 9 6 48 43 0.6335data6-9-48-08797.txt 9 6 48 36 0.2993data6-9-48-08798.txt 9 6 48 32 0.2086data6-9-48-08799.txt 9 6 48 35 0.9044data6-9-48-08800.txt 9 6 48 41 0.2513data6-9-49-08801.txt 9 6 49 37 0.5544data6-9-49-08802.txt 9 6 49 41 0.2108data6-9-49-08803.txt 9 6 49 40 0.1631data6-9-49-08804.txt 9 6 49 34 0.0066data6-9-49-08805.txt 9 6 49 36 0.4087data6-9-49-08806.txt 9 6 49 32 0.0058data6-9-49-08807.txt 9 6 49 42 0.2663data6-9-49-08808.txt 9 6 49 32 0.1127data6-9-49-08809.txt 9 6 49 35 0.4336data6-9-49-08810.txt 9 6 49 35 0.0035

Table 113: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 319: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-9-49-08811.txt 9 6 49 35 0.0234data6-9-49-08812.txt 9 6 49 37 0.0771data6-9-49-08813.txt 9 6 49 35 0.1858data6-9-49-08814.txt 9 6 49 39 0.2550data6-9-49-08815.txt 9 6 49 38 0.3248data6-9-49-08816.txt 9 6 49 38 0.2337data6-9-49-08817.txt 9 6 49 37 0.0832data6-9-49-08818.txt 9 6 49 36 0.7517data6-9-49-08819.txt 9 6 49 39 0.3070data6-9-49-08820.txt 9 6 49 38 0.0035data6-9-49-08821.txt 9 6 49 38 0.1977data6-9-49-08822.txt 9 6 49 35 0.5014data6-9-49-08823.txt 9 6 49 32 0.2399data6-9-49-08824.txt 9 6 49 39 0.5685data6-9-49-08825.txt 9 6 49 32 0.0120data6-9-49-08826.txt 9 6 49 36 0.2818data6-9-49-08827.txt 9 6 49 40 0.2989data6-9-49-08828.txt 9 6 49 42 0.0405data6-9-49-08829.txt 9 6 49 31 0.0874data6-9-49-08830.txt 9 6 49 43 0.2437data6-9-49-08831.txt 9 6 49 31 0.0044data6-9-49-08832.txt 9 6 49 36 0.1513data6-9-49-08833.txt 9 6 49 35 0.1902data6-9-49-08834.txt 9 6 49 40 0.2930data6-9-49-08835.txt 9 6 49 33 0.0229data6-9-49-08836.txt 9 6 49 43 0.1186data6-9-49-08837.txt 9 6 49 32 0.0733data6-9-49-08838.txt 9 6 49 30 0.0036data6-9-49-08839.txt 9 6 49 35 0.1897data6-9-49-08840.txt 9 6 49 41 0.5916data6-9-49-08841.txt 9 6 49 39 0.0724data6-9-49-08842.txt 9 6 49 39 0.4339data6-9-49-08843.txt 9 6 49 43 0.8029data6-9-49-08844.txt 9 6 49 38 0.0191data6-9-49-08845.txt 9 6 49 44 0.2596data6-9-49-08846.txt 9 6 49 41 0.0803data6-9-49-08847.txt 9 6 49 35 0.1665data6-9-49-08848.txt 9 6 49 38 0.1533data6-9-49-08849.txt 9 6 49 39 0.0592data6-9-49-08850.txt 9 6 49 32 0.0328data6-9-49-08851.txt 9 6 49 41 0.3260data6-9-49-08852.txt 9 6 49 43 0.2977data6-9-49-08853.txt 9 6 49 39 0.2258data6-9-49-08854.txt 9 6 49 29 0.0064data6-9-49-08855.txt 9 6 49 35 0.2031data6-9-49-08856.txt 9 6 49 40 0.1677data6-9-49-08857.txt 9 6 49 30 0.0029data6-9-49-08858.txt 9 6 49 33 0.0556data6-9-49-08859.txt 9 6 49 40 0.0051data6-9-49-08860.txt 9 6 49 34 0.1620data6-9-49-08861.txt 9 6 49 35 0.1841data6-9-49-08862.txt 9 6 49 33 0.0611data6-9-49-08863.txt 9 6 49 44 0.3528data6-9-49-08864.txt 9 6 49 42 0.4223data6-9-49-08865.txt 9 6 49 34 0.9363data6-9-49-08866.txt 9 6 49 38 0.4197data6-9-49-08867.txt 9 6 49 27 0.0131data6-9-49-08868.txt 9 6 49 43 0.1099data6-9-49-08869.txt 9 6 49 38 0.1875data6-9-49-08870.txt 9 6 49 42 0.1595data6-9-49-08871.txt 9 6 49 36 0.8318data6-9-49-08872.txt 9 6 49 34 0.1644data6-9-49-08873.txt 9 6 49 42 0.2099data6-9-49-08874.txt 9 6 49 37 1.0171data6-9-49-08875.txt 9 6 49 37 0.0097data6-9-49-08876.txt 9 6 49 40 0.2012data6-9-49-08877.txt 9 6 49 35 0.0106data6-9-49-08878.txt 9 6 49 38 0.1351data6-9-49-08879.txt 9 6 49 35 0.1593data6-9-49-08880.txt 9 6 49 42 0.4615

Table 114: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 320: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-9-49-08881.txt 9 6 49 35 0.0206data6-9-49-08882.txt 9 6 49 41 1.0528data6-9-49-08883.txt 9 6 49 42 0.3337data6-9-49-08884.txt 9 6 49 34 0.0093data6-9-49-08885.txt 9 6 49 36 0.5235data6-9-49-08886.txt 9 6 49 28 0.3430data6-9-49-08887.txt 9 6 49 38 0.4021data6-9-49-08888.txt 9 6 49 33 0.4064data6-9-49-08889.txt 9 6 49 36 0.3532data6-9-49-08890.txt 9 6 49 33 0.1923data6-9-49-08891.txt 9 6 49 39 0.4751data6-9-49-08892.txt 9 6 49 24 0.0034data6-9-49-08893.txt 9 6 49 36 0.4568data6-9-49-08894.txt 9 6 49 34 0.0920data6-9-49-08895.txt 9 6 49 37 0.2570data6-9-49-08896.txt 9 6 49 38 0.2528data6-9-49-08897.txt 9 6 49 42 0.2061data6-9-49-08898.txt 9 6 49 34 0.3824data6-9-49-08899.txt 9 6 49 39 0.0723data6-9-49-08900.txt 9 6 49 43 0.2949data6-9-50-08901.txt 9 6 50 45 0.6132data6-9-50-08902.txt 9 6 50 41 0.0834data6-9-50-08903.txt 9 6 50 49 0.0436data6-9-50-08904.txt 9 6 50 35 0.0366data6-9-50-08905.txt 9 6 50 39 0.1639data6-9-50-08906.txt 9 6 50 38 0.2858data6-9-50-08907.txt 9 6 50 38 0.0429data6-9-50-08908.txt 9 6 50 41 0.0340data6-9-50-08909.txt 9 6 50 39 0.5968data6-9-50-08910.txt 9 6 50 47 0.4148data6-9-50-08911.txt 9 6 50 39 0.1273data6-9-50-08912.txt 9 6 50 38 0.1094data6-9-50-08913.txt 9 6 50 45 0.2352data6-9-50-08914.txt 9 6 50 49 0.7339data6-9-50-08915.txt 9 6 50 33 0.2293data6-9-50-08916.txt 9 6 50 39 0.0963data6-9-50-08917.txt 9 6 50 32 0.1041data6-9-50-08918.txt 9 6 50 25 0.0038data6-9-50-08919.txt 9 6 50 38 0.0059data6-9-50-08920.txt 9 6 50 33 0.0057data6-9-50-08921.txt 9 6 50 48 0.2057data6-9-50-08922.txt 9 6 50 41 0.1906data6-9-50-08923.txt 9 6 50 38 0.3835data6-9-50-08924.txt 9 6 50 35 0.0271data6-9-50-08925.txt 9 6 50 50 0.0316data6-9-50-08926.txt 9 6 50 40 0.3230data6-9-50-08927.txt 9 6 50 39 0.3217data6-9-50-08928.txt 9 6 50 39 0.2011data6-9-50-08929.txt 9 6 50 37 0.1065data6-9-50-08930.txt 9 6 50 43 0.3466data6-9-50-08931.txt 9 6 50 37 0.1443data6-9-50-08932.txt 9 6 50 49 0.8256data6-9-50-08933.txt 9 6 50 34 0.0082data6-9-50-08934.txt 9 6 50 43 0.0339data6-9-50-08935.txt 9 6 50 41 0.5434data6-9-50-08936.txt 9 6 50 41 0.4622data6-9-50-08937.txt 9 6 50 46 0.6849data6-9-50-08938.txt 9 6 50 44 0.3669data6-9-50-08939.txt 9 6 50 48 0.0467data6-9-50-08940.txt 9 6 50 38 0.1201data6-9-50-08941.txt 9 6 50 47 0.2457data6-9-50-08942.txt 9 6 50 43 0.0282data6-9-50-08943.txt 9 6 50 32 0.2409data6-9-50-08944.txt 9 6 50 36 0.1255data6-9-50-08945.txt 9 6 50 37 0.2935data6-9-50-08946.txt 9 6 50 38 0.4560data6-9-50-08947.txt 9 6 50 44 0.6921data6-9-50-08948.txt 9 6 50 39 0.0466data6-9-50-08949.txt 9 6 50 37 0.1266data6-9-50-08950.txt 9 6 50 37 0.4210

Table 115: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 321: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-9-50-08951.txt 9 6 50 41 0.0061data6-9-50-08952.txt 9 6 50 40 0.0577data6-9-50-08953.txt 9 6 50 34 0.1171data6-9-50-08954.txt 9 6 50 36 0.4527data6-9-50-08955.txt 9 6 50 40 0.0882data6-9-50-08956.txt 9 6 50 40 0.4278data6-9-50-08957.txt 9 6 50 49 0.3712data6-9-50-08958.txt 9 6 50 41 0.1614data6-9-50-08959.txt 9 6 50 37 0.4985data6-9-50-08960.txt 9 6 50 33 0.1482data6-9-50-08961.txt 9 6 50 34 0.0340data6-9-50-08962.txt 9 6 50 45 0.5096data6-9-50-08963.txt 9 6 50 41 0.4829data6-9-50-08964.txt 9 6 50 29 0.6431data6-9-50-08965.txt 9 6 50 46 0.6030data6-9-50-08966.txt 9 6 50 39 0.2062data6-9-50-08967.txt 9 6 50 36 0.1200data6-9-50-08968.txt 9 6 50 38 0.0957data6-9-50-08969.txt 9 6 50 40 0.0298data6-9-50-08970.txt 9 6 50 36 0.3022data6-9-50-08971.txt 9 6 50 40 0.7329data6-9-50-08972.txt 9 6 50 42 0.6715data6-9-50-08973.txt 9 6 50 42 0.0516data6-9-50-08974.txt 9 6 50 39 0.0119data6-9-50-08975.txt 9 6 50 41 0.1571data6-9-50-08976.txt 9 6 50 37 0.3101data6-9-50-08977.txt 9 6 50 46 0.2532data6-9-50-08978.txt 9 6 50 36 0.0164data6-9-50-08979.txt 9 6 50 35 0.4327data6-9-50-08980.txt 9 6 50 40 0.6818data6-9-50-08981.txt 9 6 50 36 0.6316data6-9-50-08982.txt 9 6 50 42 0.6507data6-9-50-08983.txt 9 6 50 40 0.4964data6-9-50-08984.txt 9 6 50 45 0.3517data6-9-50-08985.txt 9 6 50 34 0.1132data6-9-50-08986.txt 9 6 50 40 0.1616data6-9-50-08987.txt 9 6 50 42 0.1971data6-9-50-08988.txt 9 6 50 39 0.2532data6-9-50-08989.txt 9 6 50 37 0.2028data6-9-50-08990.txt 9 6 50 47 0.0467data6-9-50-08991.txt 9 6 50 38 0.0030data6-9-50-08992.txt 9 6 50 36 0.0432data6-9-50-08993.txt 9 6 50 36 0.6452data6-9-50-08994.txt 9 6 50 47 0.1521data6-9-50-08995.txt 9 6 50 49 0.6198data6-9-50-08996.txt 9 6 50 34 0.1505data6-9-50-08997.txt 9 6 50 41 0.5402data6-9-50-08998.txt 9 6 50 42 0.2693data6-9-50-08999.txt 9 6 50 39 0.1852data6-9-50-09000.txt 9 6 50 38 0.2236data6-9-51-09001.txt 9 6 51 42 0.1190data6-9-51-09002.txt 9 6 51 41 0.0793data6-9-51-09003.txt 9 6 51 34 0.0140data6-9-51-09004.txt 9 6 51 49 0.5285data6-9-51-09005.txt 9 6 51 42 0.4070data6-9-51-09006.txt 9 6 51 40 0.5797data6-9-51-09007.txt 9 6 51 36 0.0050data6-9-51-09008.txt 9 6 51 48 0.3547data6-9-51-09009.txt 9 6 51 40 0.2567data6-9-51-09010.txt 9 6 51 34 0.2137data6-9-51-09011.txt 9 6 51 39 0.2782data6-9-51-09012.txt 9 6 51 43 0.3519data6-9-51-09013.txt 9 6 51 48 0.5098data6-9-51-09014.txt 9 6 51 30 0.1101data6-9-51-09015.txt 9 6 51 35 0.1897data6-9-51-09016.txt 9 6 51 38 0.4270data6-9-51-09017.txt 9 6 51 38 0.0813data6-9-51-09018.txt 9 6 51 48 0.1296data6-9-51-09019.txt 9 6 51 50 0.1885data6-9-51-09020.txt 9 6 51 38 0.2976

Table 116: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 322: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-9-51-09021.txt 9 6 51 37 0.2533data6-9-51-09022.txt 9 6 51 44 0.0469data6-9-51-09023.txt 9 6 51 39 0.0059data6-9-51-09024.txt 9 6 51 40 0.1464data6-9-51-09025.txt 9 6 51 45 0.3876data6-9-51-09026.txt 9 6 51 31 0.1460data6-9-51-09027.txt 9 6 51 42 0.0079data6-9-51-09028.txt 9 6 51 47 0.5899data6-9-51-09029.txt 9 6 51 39 0.0245data6-9-51-09030.txt 9 6 51 47 0.0516data6-9-51-09031.txt 9 6 51 42 0.2514data6-9-51-09032.txt 9 6 51 38 0.5270data6-9-51-09033.txt 9 6 51 44 0.4012data6-9-51-09034.txt 9 6 51 43 0.6247data6-9-51-09035.txt 9 6 51 42 0.0588data6-9-51-09036.txt 9 6 51 37 0.0046data6-9-51-09037.txt 9 6 51 35 0.3402data6-9-51-09038.txt 9 6 51 40 0.0764data6-9-51-09039.txt 9 6 51 36 0.2973data6-9-51-09040.txt 9 6 51 44 0.3643data6-9-51-09041.txt 9 6 51 35 0.0705data6-9-51-09042.txt 9 6 51 45 0.2578data6-9-51-09043.txt 9 6 51 44 0.5486data6-9-51-09044.txt 9 6 51 34 0.2584data6-9-51-09045.txt 9 6 51 54 0.4122data6-9-51-09046.txt 9 6 51 36 0.1098data6-9-51-09047.txt 9 6 51 41 0.8573data6-9-51-09048.txt 9 6 51 37 0.1643data6-9-51-09049.txt 9 6 51 38 0.3104data6-9-51-09050.txt 9 6 51 46 0.7458data6-9-51-09051.txt 9 6 51 46 0.1291data6-9-51-09052.txt 9 6 51 43 0.3881data6-9-51-09053.txt 9 6 51 36 0.6410data6-9-51-09054.txt 9 6 51 37 0.0178data6-9-51-09055.txt 9 6 51 43 0.0906data6-9-51-09056.txt 9 6 51 36 0.1514data6-9-51-09057.txt 9 6 51 41 1.0445data6-9-51-09058.txt 9 6 51 40 0.6387data6-9-51-09059.txt 9 6 51 42 0.2371data6-9-51-09060.txt 9 6 51 42 0.1926data6-9-51-09061.txt 9 6 51 52 0.7852data6-9-51-09062.txt 9 6 51 44 0.1004data6-9-51-09063.txt 9 6 51 32 0.1993data6-9-51-09064.txt 9 6 51 39 0.0042data6-9-51-09065.txt 9 6 51 41 0.2682data6-9-51-09066.txt 9 6 51 43 0.0113data6-9-51-09067.txt 9 6 51 46 0.2561data6-9-51-09068.txt 9 6 51 36 0.3789data6-9-51-09069.txt 9 6 51 39 0.0157data6-9-51-09070.txt 9 6 51 45 0.2649data6-9-51-09071.txt 9 6 51 38 0.5270data6-9-51-09072.txt 9 6 51 53 0.4759data6-9-51-09073.txt 9 6 51 45 0.0691data6-9-51-09074.txt 9 6 51 33 0.0181data6-9-51-09075.txt 9 6 51 42 0.4818data6-9-51-09076.txt 9 6 51 40 0.1659data6-9-51-09077.txt 9 6 51 47 0.5646data6-9-51-09078.txt 9 6 51 42 0.4354data6-9-51-09079.txt 9 6 51 45 0.5989data6-9-51-09080.txt 9 6 51 52 0.5348data6-9-51-09081.txt 9 6 51 38 0.1279data6-9-51-09082.txt 9 6 51 39 0.0570data6-9-51-09083.txt 9 6 51 41 0.2786data6-9-51-09084.txt 9 6 51 54 1.0423data6-9-51-09085.txt 9 6 51 39 0.0036data6-9-51-09086.txt 9 6 51 44 0.0084data6-9-51-09087.txt 9 6 51 31 0.1288data6-9-51-09088.txt 9 6 51 41 0.0304data6-9-51-09089.txt 9 6 51 40 0.0977data6-9-51-09090.txt 9 6 51 44 0.4228

Table 117: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 323: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-9-51-09091.txt 9 6 51 39 0.3091data6-9-51-09092.txt 9 6 51 40 0.1829data6-9-51-09093.txt 9 6 51 50 0.7743data6-9-51-09094.txt 9 6 51 41 0.3656data6-9-51-09095.txt 9 6 51 38 0.5291data6-9-51-09096.txt 9 6 51 38 0.3742data6-9-51-09097.txt 9 6 51 42 0.1510data6-9-51-09098.txt 9 6 51 43 0.0824data6-9-51-09099.txt 9 6 51 40 0.6538data6-9-51-09100.txt 9 6 51 50 0.4816data6-9-52-09101.txt 9 6 52 45 0.5978data6-9-52-09102.txt 9 6 52 46 0.3946data6-9-52-09103.txt 9 6 52 37 0.0710data6-9-52-09104.txt 9 6 52 40 0.0970data6-9-52-09105.txt 9 6 52 50 0.3659data6-9-52-09106.txt 9 6 52 45 0.2898data6-9-52-09107.txt 9 6 52 47 0.8682data6-9-52-09108.txt 9 6 52 50 0.3389data6-9-52-09109.txt 9 6 52 40 0.0040data6-9-52-09110.txt 9 6 52 35 0.2702data6-9-52-09111.txt 9 6 52 46 0.5961data6-9-52-09112.txt 9 6 52 40 0.0210data6-9-52-09113.txt 9 6 52 50 0.5512data6-9-52-09114.txt 9 6 52 44 0.6546data6-9-52-09115.txt 9 6 52 40 0.2094data6-9-52-09116.txt 9 6 52 46 0.2614data6-9-52-09117.txt 9 6 52 41 0.2475data6-9-52-09118.txt 9 6 52 47 0.4207data6-9-52-09119.txt 9 6 52 38 0.0447data6-9-52-09120.txt 9 6 52 39 0.2261data6-9-52-09121.txt 9 6 52 40 0.0721data6-9-52-09122.txt 9 6 52 38 0.2319data6-9-52-09123.txt 9 6 52 44 0.2314data6-9-52-09124.txt 9 6 52 42 0.4891data6-9-52-09125.txt 9 6 52 35 0.2006data6-9-52-09126.txt 9 6 52 42 0.6980data6-9-52-09127.txt 9 6 52 45 0.1682data6-9-52-09128.txt 9 6 52 35 0.0917data6-9-52-09129.txt 9 6 52 41 0.9531data6-9-52-09130.txt 9 6 52 41 0.0167data6-9-52-09131.txt 9 6 52 42 0.3714data6-9-52-09132.txt 9 6 52 40 0.1491data6-9-52-09133.txt 9 6 52 48 0.6017data6-9-52-09134.txt 9 6 52 47 0.5810data6-9-52-09135.txt 9 6 52 42 0.2771data6-9-52-09136.txt 9 6 52 41 0.1366data6-9-52-09137.txt 9 6 52 41 0.1155data6-9-52-09138.txt 9 6 52 47 0.1062data6-9-52-09139.txt 9 6 52 37 0.1154data6-9-52-09140.txt 9 6 52 38 0.1029data6-9-52-09141.txt 9 6 52 41 0.4831data6-9-52-09142.txt 9 6 52 43 0.0039data6-9-52-09143.txt 9 6 52 38 0.3333data6-9-52-09144.txt 9 6 52 40 0.0451data6-9-52-09145.txt 9 6 52 44 0.1529data6-9-52-09146.txt 9 6 52 36 0.2728data6-9-52-09147.txt 9 6 52 37 0.3098data6-9-52-09148.txt 9 6 52 46 0.2972data6-9-52-09149.txt 9 6 52 35 0.1391data6-9-52-09150.txt 9 6 52 37 0.2636data6-9-52-09151.txt 9 6 52 39 0.1757data6-9-52-09152.txt 9 6 52 42 0.0174data6-9-52-09153.txt 9 6 52 39 0.2173data6-9-52-09154.txt 9 6 52 34 0.0039data6-9-52-09155.txt 9 6 52 42 0.1081data6-9-52-09156.txt 9 6 52 47 0.0996data6-9-52-09157.txt 9 6 52 52 0.3076data6-9-52-09158.txt 9 6 52 45 0.0113data6-9-52-09159.txt 9 6 52 42 0.3379data6-9-52-09160.txt 9 6 52 45 0.6355

Table 118: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 324: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-9-52-09161.txt 9 6 52 39 0.0802data6-9-52-09162.txt 9 6 52 50 0.7770data6-9-52-09163.txt 9 6 52 31 0.0036data6-9-52-09164.txt 9 6 52 43 0.0763data6-9-52-09165.txt 9 6 52 45 0.0036data6-9-52-09166.txt 9 6 52 39 0.2093data6-9-52-09167.txt 9 6 52 40 0.0332data6-9-52-09168.txt 9 6 52 47 0.3516data6-9-52-09169.txt 9 6 52 43 0.3787data6-9-52-09170.txt 9 6 52 42 0.0803data6-9-52-09171.txt 9 6 52 41 0.4290data6-9-52-09172.txt 9 6 52 45 0.1548data6-9-52-09173.txt 9 6 52 41 0.2419data6-9-52-09174.txt 9 6 52 36 0.0712data6-9-52-09175.txt 9 6 52 35 0.0043data6-9-52-09176.txt 9 6 52 39 0.0490data6-9-52-09177.txt 9 6 52 34 0.0965data6-9-52-09178.txt 9 6 52 39 0.0414data6-9-52-09179.txt 9 6 52 36 0.3535data6-9-52-09180.txt 9 6 52 46 0.8256data6-9-52-09181.txt 9 6 52 44 0.4414data6-9-52-09182.txt 9 6 52 49 0.4154data6-9-52-09183.txt 9 6 52 38 0.1781data6-9-52-09184.txt 9 6 52 50 1.0133data6-9-52-09185.txt 9 6 52 39 0.5576data6-9-52-09186.txt 9 6 52 49 0.3315data6-9-52-09187.txt 9 6 52 52 0.6759data6-9-52-09188.txt 9 6 52 33 0.5288data6-9-52-09189.txt 9 6 52 47 0.0902data6-9-52-09190.txt 9 6 52 41 0.5049data6-9-52-09191.txt 9 6 52 41 0.2583data6-9-52-09192.txt 9 6 52 52 0.5197data6-9-52-09193.txt 9 6 52 36 0.0416data6-9-52-09194.txt 9 6 52 42 0.4582data6-9-52-09195.txt 9 6 52 33 0.4762data6-9-52-09196.txt 9 6 52 52 0.1057data6-9-52-09197.txt 9 6 52 51 0.4635data6-9-52-09198.txt 9 6 52 40 0.1489data6-9-52-09199.txt 9 6 52 42 0.5299data6-9-52-09200.txt 9 6 52 45 0.1737data6-9-53-09201.txt 9 6 53 44 0.2037data6-9-53-09202.txt 9 6 53 40 0.8935data6-9-53-09203.txt 9 6 53 37 0.0339data6-9-53-09204.txt 9 6 53 43 0.0883data6-9-53-09205.txt 9 6 53 49 0.3320data6-9-53-09206.txt 9 6 53 37 0.0278data6-9-53-09207.txt 9 6 53 40 0.1241data6-9-53-09208.txt 9 6 53 51 0.8887data6-9-53-09209.txt 9 6 53 46 0.4009data6-9-53-09210.txt 9 6 53 46 0.1763data6-9-53-09211.txt 9 6 53 47 0.6625data6-9-53-09212.txt 9 6 53 44 0.4309data6-9-53-09213.txt 9 6 53 38 0.2872data6-9-53-09214.txt 9 6 53 41 0.2976data6-9-53-09215.txt 9 6 53 37 0.4936data6-9-53-09216.txt 9 6 53 36 0.1747data6-9-53-09217.txt 9 6 53 39 0.2958data6-9-53-09218.txt 9 6 53 45 0.3486data6-9-53-09219.txt 9 6 53 38 0.0074data6-9-53-09220.txt 9 6 53 48 0.2719data6-9-53-09221.txt 9 6 53 41 0.0886data6-9-53-09222.txt 9 6 53 51 0.6040data6-9-53-09223.txt 9 6 53 43 0.0370data6-9-53-09224.txt 9 6 53 49 0.7543data6-9-53-09225.txt 9 6 53 47 0.4725data6-9-53-09226.txt 9 6 53 39 0.7520data6-9-53-09227.txt 9 6 53 43 0.4389data6-9-53-09228.txt 9 6 53 50 0.6428data6-9-53-09229.txt 9 6 53 40 0.2005data6-9-53-09230.txt 9 6 53 42 0.6737

Table 119: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 325: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-9-53-09231.txt 9 6 53 47 0.7390data6-9-53-09232.txt 9 6 53 31 0.4135data6-9-53-09233.txt 9 6 53 47 0.2829data6-9-53-09234.txt 9 6 53 33 0.0064data6-9-53-09235.txt 9 6 53 41 0.3822data6-9-53-09236.txt 9 6 53 50 0.8176data6-9-53-09237.txt 9 6 53 39 0.2789data6-9-53-09238.txt 9 6 53 45 0.5599data6-9-53-09239.txt 9 6 53 43 0.4682data6-9-53-09240.txt 9 6 53 49 0.1473data6-9-53-09241.txt 9 6 53 49 0.2840data6-9-53-09242.txt 9 6 53 52 0.4937data6-9-53-09243.txt 9 6 53 39 1.0481data6-9-53-09244.txt 9 6 53 45 0.1277data6-9-53-09245.txt 9 6 53 36 0.1464data6-9-53-09246.txt 9 6 53 40 0.3587data6-9-53-09247.txt 9 6 53 42 0.1165data6-9-53-09248.txt 9 6 53 43 0.0272data6-9-53-09249.txt 9 6 53 45 0.2403data6-9-53-09250.txt 9 6 53 37 0.0370data6-9-53-09251.txt 9 6 53 47 0.5671data6-9-53-09252.txt 9 6 53 36 0.1518data6-9-53-09253.txt 9 6 53 46 0.0542data6-9-53-09254.txt 9 6 53 40 0.6292data6-9-53-09255.txt 9 6 53 36 0.3520data6-9-53-09256.txt 9 6 53 49 0.1506data6-9-53-09257.txt 9 6 53 34 0.0465data6-9-53-09258.txt 9 6 53 38 0.1014data6-9-53-09259.txt 9 6 53 35 0.4064data6-9-53-09260.txt 9 6 53 41 0.2154data6-9-53-09261.txt 9 6 53 41 1.0466data6-9-53-09262.txt 9 6 53 35 0.2070data6-9-53-09263.txt 9 6 53 50 0.3699data6-9-53-09264.txt 9 6 53 53 0.6674data6-9-53-09265.txt 9 6 53 45 0.2878data6-9-53-09266.txt 9 6 53 29 0.1598data6-9-53-09267.txt 9 6 53 45 0.2381data6-9-53-09268.txt 9 6 53 36 0.0275data6-9-53-09269.txt 9 6 53 40 0.3487data6-9-53-09270.txt 9 6 53 32 0.8189data6-9-53-09271.txt 9 6 53 35 0.0905data6-9-53-09272.txt 9 6 53 45 0.2543data6-9-53-09273.txt 9 6 53 45 0.2675data6-9-53-09274.txt 9 6 53 51 0.1529data6-9-53-09275.txt 9 6 53 42 0.1243data6-9-53-09276.txt 9 6 53 51 0.4163data6-9-53-09277.txt 9 6 53 42 0.4999data6-9-53-09278.txt 9 6 53 41 0.0088data6-9-53-09279.txt 9 6 53 43 0.4071data6-9-53-09280.txt 9 6 53 31 0.1317data6-9-53-09281.txt 9 6 53 31 0.1669data6-9-53-09282.txt 9 6 53 39 0.1931data6-9-53-09283.txt 9 6 53 45 0.2972data6-9-53-09284.txt 9 6 53 40 0.3416data6-9-53-09285.txt 9 6 53 45 0.1331data6-9-53-09286.txt 9 6 53 40 0.0523data6-9-53-09287.txt 9 6 53 34 0.0030data6-9-53-09288.txt 9 6 53 40 0.0677data6-9-53-09289.txt 9 6 53 47 0.0387data6-9-53-09290.txt 9 6 53 45 0.4285data6-9-53-09291.txt 9 6 53 41 0.1312data6-9-53-09292.txt 9 6 53 49 0.3829data6-9-53-09293.txt 9 6 53 34 0.2191data6-9-53-09294.txt 9 6 53 42 0.1466data6-9-53-09295.txt 9 6 53 47 0.1194data6-9-53-09296.txt 9 6 53 52 0.5183data6-9-53-09297.txt 9 6 53 52 0.8042data6-9-53-09298.txt 9 6 53 41 0.3581data6-9-53-09299.txt 9 6 53 44 0.1733data6-9-53-09300.txt 9 6 53 36 0.4540

Table 120: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 326: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-10-54-11201.txt 10 6 54 39 1.0575data6-10-54-11202.txt 10 6 54 47 0.8296data6-10-54-11203.txt 10 6 54 29 0.0042data6-10-54-11204.txt 10 6 54 45 0.0872data6-10-54-11205.txt 10 6 54 38 0.9275data6-10-54-11206.txt 10 6 54 45 0.2156data6-10-54-11207.txt 10 6 54 41 0.4202data6-10-54-11208.txt 10 6 54 50 0.5453data6-10-54-11209.txt 10 6 54 43 0.9843data6-10-54-11210.txt 10 6 54 34 1.0922data6-10-54-11211.txt 10 6 54 31 0.6515data6-10-54-11212.txt 10 6 54 41 0.4850data6-10-54-11213.txt 10 6 54 41 0.1900data6-10-54-11214.txt 10 6 54 32 0.1109data6-10-54-11215.txt 10 6 54 47 0.6486data6-10-54-11216.txt 10 6 54 41 0.1522data6-10-54-11217.txt 10 6 54 30 0.0049data6-10-54-11218.txt 10 6 54 42 0.3569data6-10-54-11219.txt 10 6 54 34 0.2386data6-10-54-11220.txt 10 6 54 35 0.0749data6-10-54-11221.txt 10 6 54 47 0.5271data6-10-54-11222.txt 10 6 54 38 0.2284data6-10-54-11223.txt 10 6 54 41 0.6441data6-10-54-11224.txt 10 6 54 41 1.0123data6-10-54-11225.txt 10 6 54 42 0.5174data6-10-54-11226.txt 10 6 54 45 0.6783data6-10-54-11227.txt 10 6 54 44 0.1692data6-10-54-11228.txt 10 6 54 29 0.0065data6-10-54-11229.txt 10 6 54 40 0.2029data6-10-54-11230.txt 10 6 54 42 0.6444data6-10-54-11231.txt 10 6 54 41 0.1653data6-10-54-11232.txt 10 6 54 37 0.1807data6-10-54-11233.txt 10 6 54 45 0.1636data6-10-54-11234.txt 10 6 54 43 0.4745data6-10-54-11235.txt 10 6 54 41 0.4390data6-10-54-11236.txt 10 6 54 38 0.4677data6-10-54-11237.txt 10 6 54 40 1.0435data6-10-54-11238.txt 10 6 54 36 0.1401data6-10-54-11239.txt 10 6 54 42 0.0071data6-10-54-11240.txt 10 6 54 41 0.4880data6-10-54-11241.txt 10 6 54 46 0.3535data6-10-54-11242.txt 10 6 54 38 0.6044data6-10-54-11243.txt 10 6 54 37 0.2445data6-10-54-11244.txt 10 6 54 41 0.6415data6-10-54-11245.txt 10 6 54 48 0.2302data6-10-54-11246.txt 10 6 54 43 0.7065data6-10-54-11247.txt 10 6 54 36 0.6575data6-10-54-11248.txt 10 6 54 43 0.3814data6-10-54-11249.txt 10 6 54 31 0.1280data6-10-54-11250.txt 10 6 54 36 0.5135data6-10-54-11251.txt 10 6 54 37 0.5338data6-10-54-11252.txt 10 6 54 35 0.5809data6-10-54-11253.txt 10 6 54 33 0.0977data6-10-54-11254.txt 10 6 54 44 0.6638data6-10-54-11255.txt 10 6 54 41 0.5832data6-10-54-11256.txt 10 6 54 38 0.2405data6-10-54-11257.txt 10 6 54 33 0.4795data6-10-54-11258.txt 10 6 54 35 0.3287data6-10-54-11259.txt 10 6 54 44 0.8417data6-10-54-11260.txt 10 6 54 44 0.1218data6-10-54-11261.txt 10 6 54 35 0.3574data6-10-54-11262.txt 10 6 54 37 0.0759data6-10-54-11263.txt 10 6 54 38 0.3475data6-10-54-11264.txt 10 6 54 36 0.1958data6-10-54-11265.txt 10 6 54 42 0.2375data6-10-54-11266.txt 10 6 54 42 0.8964data6-10-54-11267.txt 10 6 54 43 0.4481data6-10-54-11268.txt 10 6 54 43 0.1072data6-10-54-11269.txt 10 6 54 42 0.5426data6-10-54-11270.txt 10 6 54 35 0.0147

Table 121: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 327: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-10-54-11271.txt 10 6 54 32 0.3993data6-10-54-11272.txt 10 6 54 32 0.1678data6-10-54-11273.txt 10 6 54 38 0.0545data6-10-54-11274.txt 10 6 54 45 0.2865data6-10-54-11275.txt 10 6 54 42 1.0476data6-10-54-11276.txt 10 6 54 40 0.5157data6-10-54-11277.txt 10 6 54 41 0.1473data6-10-54-11278.txt 10 6 54 39 0.6583data6-10-54-11279.txt 10 6 54 43 0.8447data6-10-54-11280.txt 10 6 54 42 0.6290data6-10-54-11281.txt 10 6 54 41 0.1813data6-10-54-11282.txt 10 6 54 35 0.1470data6-10-54-11283.txt 10 6 54 39 0.5014data6-10-54-11284.txt 10 6 54 36 0.2069data6-10-54-11285.txt 10 6 54 36 0.9015data6-10-54-11286.txt 10 6 54 40 0.2003data6-10-54-11287.txt 10 6 54 43 1.0154data6-10-54-11288.txt 10 6 54 40 0.6201data6-10-54-11289.txt 10 6 54 43 0.1901data6-10-54-11290.txt 10 6 54 46 0.2546data6-10-54-11291.txt 10 6 54 39 0.2932data6-10-54-11292.txt 10 6 54 39 0.6672data6-10-54-11293.txt 10 6 54 38 0.6894data6-10-54-11294.txt 10 6 54 42 0.3442data6-10-54-11295.txt 10 6 54 36 0.3195data6-10-54-11296.txt 10 6 54 43 0.7599data6-10-54-11297.txt 10 6 54 33 0.4146data6-10-54-11298.txt 10 6 54 35 0.2435data6-10-54-11299.txt 10 6 54 34 0.0245data6-10-54-11300.txt 10 6 54 41 0.0987data6-10-55-11301.txt 10 6 55 40 0.5378data6-10-55-11302.txt 10 6 55 33 0.0959data6-10-55-11303.txt 10 6 55 38 0.2228data6-10-55-11304.txt 10 6 55 41 0.2164data6-10-55-11305.txt 10 6 55 43 0.5400data6-10-55-11306.txt 10 6 55 39 1.0252data6-10-55-11307.txt 10 6 55 44 0.1200data6-10-55-11308.txt 10 6 55 37 0.6252data6-10-55-11309.txt 10 6 55 40 0.3392data6-10-55-11310.txt 10 6 55 34 0.0036data6-10-55-11311.txt 10 6 55 42 0.4119data6-10-55-11312.txt 10 6 55 43 0.4354data6-10-55-11313.txt 10 6 55 43 0.4759data6-10-55-11314.txt 10 6 55 39 0.2381data6-10-55-11315.txt 10 6 55 39 0.0746data6-10-55-11316.txt 10 6 55 47 1.0370data6-10-55-11317.txt 10 6 55 41 0.3186data6-10-55-11318.txt 10 6 55 45 1.0432data6-10-55-11319.txt 10 6 55 33 0.0037data6-10-55-11320.txt 10 6 55 41 0.4040data6-10-55-11321.txt 10 6 55 35 0.8892data6-10-55-11322.txt 10 6 55 44 0.2468data6-10-55-11323.txt 10 6 55 46 0.8069data6-10-55-11324.txt 10 6 55 45 0.2629data6-10-55-11325.txt 10 6 55 38 0.4203data6-10-55-11326.txt 10 6 55 36 0.0695data6-10-55-11327.txt 10 6 55 37 0.0490data6-10-55-11328.txt 10 6 55 45 0.2577data6-10-55-11329.txt 10 6 55 47 0.0086data6-10-55-11330.txt 10 6 55 35 0.1447data6-10-55-11331.txt 10 6 55 47 0.7597data6-10-55-11332.txt 10 6 55 49 0.5449data6-10-55-11333.txt 10 6 55 45 0.0764data6-10-55-11334.txt 10 6 55 47 1.0135data6-10-55-11335.txt 10 6 55 40 0.7809data6-10-55-11336.txt 10 6 55 38 0.5213data6-10-55-11337.txt 10 6 55 36 0.1674data6-10-55-11338.txt 10 6 55 37 0.1205data6-10-55-11339.txt 10 6 55 38 1.0606data6-10-55-11340.txt 10 6 55 39 0.0730

Table 122: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 328: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-10-55-11341.txt 10 6 55 46 0.5185data6-10-55-11342.txt 10 6 55 41 0.5412data6-10-55-11343.txt 10 6 55 36 0.1862data6-10-55-11344.txt 10 6 55 45 0.5185data6-10-55-11345.txt 10 6 55 46 0.2866data6-10-55-11346.txt 10 6 55 43 1.1263data6-10-55-11347.txt 10 6 55 41 0.5329data6-10-55-11348.txt 10 6 55 38 0.0282data6-10-55-11349.txt 10 6 55 37 0.0062data6-10-55-11350.txt 10 6 55 38 0.2896data6-10-55-11351.txt 10 6 55 42 0.2691data6-10-55-11352.txt 10 6 55 31 0.1851data6-10-55-11353.txt 10 6 55 33 0.1176data6-10-55-11354.txt 10 6 55 45 0.1049data6-10-55-11355.txt 10 6 55 41 0.4112data6-10-55-11356.txt 10 6 55 41 0.0140data6-10-55-11357.txt 10 6 55 38 0.7135data6-10-55-11358.txt 10 6 55 44 0.1476data6-10-55-11359.txt 10 6 55 45 1.0377data6-10-55-11360.txt 10 6 55 40 0.0780data6-10-55-11361.txt 10 6 55 35 0.4709data6-10-55-11362.txt 10 6 55 44 0.7983data6-10-55-11363.txt 10 6 55 41 0.2372data6-10-55-11364.txt 10 6 55 36 0.4673data6-10-55-11365.txt 10 6 55 40 0.1602data6-10-55-11366.txt 10 6 55 42 0.0667data6-10-55-11367.txt 10 6 55 38 0.2182data6-10-55-11368.txt 10 6 55 33 0.1455data6-10-55-11369.txt 10 6 55 39 0.6713data6-10-55-11370.txt 10 6 55 44 0.6101data6-10-55-11371.txt 10 6 55 40 0.2317data6-10-55-11372.txt 10 6 55 38 1.0525data6-10-55-11373.txt 10 6 55 40 0.0136data6-10-55-11374.txt 10 6 55 32 0.0300data6-10-55-11375.txt 10 6 55 45 0.3400data6-10-55-11376.txt 10 6 55 46 0.2747data6-10-55-11377.txt 10 6 55 48 0.6380data6-10-55-11378.txt 10 6 55 40 0.2246data6-10-55-11379.txt 10 6 55 45 0.5583data6-10-55-11380.txt 10 6 55 34 1.0341data6-10-55-11381.txt 10 6 55 31 0.0128data6-10-55-11382.txt 10 6 55 45 0.2775data6-10-55-11383.txt 10 6 55 39 0.1543data6-10-55-11384.txt 10 6 55 46 1.0099data6-10-55-11385.txt 10 6 55 40 0.5568data6-10-55-11386.txt 10 6 55 48 0.3880data6-10-55-11387.txt 10 6 55 44 0.2614data6-10-55-11388.txt 10 6 55 43 0.6732data6-10-55-11389.txt 10 6 55 45 0.9144data6-10-55-11390.txt 10 6 55 37 0.0913data6-10-55-11391.txt 10 6 55 37 0.0728data6-10-55-11392.txt 10 6 55 43 0.1305data6-10-55-11393.txt 10 6 55 40 1.0156data6-10-55-11394.txt 10 6 55 43 0.4009data6-10-55-11395.txt 10 6 55 48 0.6724data6-10-55-11396.txt 10 6 55 40 0.0798data6-10-55-11397.txt 10 6 55 39 0.1610data6-10-55-11398.txt 10 6 55 51 0.2216data6-10-55-11399.txt 10 6 55 40 0.5546data6-10-55-11400.txt 10 6 55 46 0.5569data6-10-56-11401.txt 10 6 56 46 0.7029data6-10-56-11402.txt 10 6 56 41 0.1279data6-10-56-11403.txt 10 6 56 38 0.1169data6-10-56-11404.txt 10 6 56 34 0.5588data6-10-56-11405.txt 10 6 56 41 0.2357data6-10-56-11406.txt 10 6 56 34 0.0034data6-10-56-11407.txt 10 6 56 47 0.5928data6-10-56-11408.txt 10 6 56 40 0.2369data6-10-56-11409.txt 10 6 56 47 0.5233data6-10-56-11410.txt 10 6 56 45 0.2450

Table 123: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 329: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-10-56-11411.txt 10 6 56 46 0.1432data6-10-56-11412.txt 10 6 56 42 0.1559data6-10-56-11413.txt 10 6 56 43 0.3165data6-10-56-11414.txt 10 6 56 46 0.1257data6-10-56-11415.txt 10 6 56 40 0.0062data6-10-56-11416.txt 10 6 56 45 0.8536data6-10-56-11417.txt 10 6 56 44 0.7890data6-10-56-11418.txt 10 6 56 50 0.0119data6-10-56-11419.txt 10 6 56 44 1.0444data6-10-56-11420.txt 10 6 56 40 1.0732data6-10-56-11421.txt 10 6 56 40 0.4922data6-10-56-11422.txt 10 6 56 45 0.6756data6-10-56-11423.txt 10 6 56 36 0.2855data6-10-56-11424.txt 10 6 56 45 0.4169data6-10-56-11425.txt 10 6 56 43 0.0326data6-10-56-11426.txt 10 6 56 35 0.1351data6-10-56-11427.txt 10 6 56 37 0.1667data6-10-56-11428.txt 10 6 56 41 0.0154data6-10-56-11429.txt 10 6 56 46 0.0497data6-10-56-11430.txt 10 6 56 44 0.4002data6-10-56-11431.txt 10 6 56 46 1.0156data6-10-56-11432.txt 10 6 56 40 0.1824data6-10-56-11433.txt 10 6 56 43 0.2449data6-10-56-11434.txt 10 6 56 47 0.4844data6-10-56-11435.txt 10 6 56 42 0.2103data6-10-56-11436.txt 10 6 56 54 0.7893data6-10-56-11437.txt 10 6 56 41 0.0093data6-10-56-11438.txt 10 6 56 39 0.0069data6-10-56-11439.txt 10 6 56 47 0.1380data6-10-56-11440.txt 10 6 56 43 0.3570data6-10-56-11441.txt 10 6 56 45 1.0205data6-10-56-11442.txt 10 6 56 43 0.4802data6-10-56-11443.txt 10 6 56 50 0.2786data6-10-56-11444.txt 10 6 56 42 0.4742data6-10-56-11445.txt 10 6 56 46 0.7085data6-10-56-11446.txt 10 6 56 37 0.2697data6-10-56-11447.txt 10 6 56 46 0.8383data6-10-56-11448.txt 10 6 56 38 0.1423data6-10-56-11449.txt 10 6 56 51 1.0135data6-10-56-11450.txt 10 6 56 45 0.3111data6-10-56-11451.txt 10 6 56 39 0.1955data6-10-56-11452.txt 10 6 56 37 0.5837data6-10-56-11453.txt 10 6 56 42 0.0550data6-10-56-11454.txt 10 6 56 36 0.1940data6-10-56-11455.txt 10 6 56 47 0.3768data6-10-56-11456.txt 10 6 56 38 0.3253data6-10-56-11457.txt 10 6 56 46 0.2095data6-10-56-11458.txt 10 6 56 41 0.1738data6-10-56-11459.txt 10 6 56 47 0.0577data6-10-56-11460.txt 10 6 56 43 1.0174data6-10-56-11461.txt 10 6 56 41 0.0835data6-10-56-11462.txt 10 6 56 41 0.2456data6-10-56-11463.txt 10 6 56 38 1.0163data6-10-56-11464.txt 10 6 56 42 0.4853data6-10-56-11465.txt 10 6 56 43 0.2309data6-10-56-11466.txt 10 6 56 42 0.2895data6-10-56-11467.txt 10 6 56 44 0.7271data6-10-56-11468.txt 10 6 56 53 0.3597data6-10-56-11469.txt 10 6 56 51 0.2553data6-10-56-11470.txt 10 6 56 51 0.6577data6-10-56-11471.txt 10 6 56 41 0.1581data6-10-56-11472.txt 10 6 56 39 1.0475data6-10-56-11473.txt 10 6 56 50 0.0078data6-10-56-11474.txt 10 6 56 42 0.2608data6-10-56-11475.txt 10 6 56 49 0.7022data6-10-56-11476.txt 10 6 56 41 0.1156data6-10-56-11477.txt 10 6 56 39 0.4512data6-10-56-11478.txt 10 6 56 42 0.4808data6-10-56-11479.txt 10 6 56 53 1.0117data6-10-56-11480.txt 10 6 56 41 0.1842

Table 124: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 330: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-10-56-11481.txt 10 6 56 42 0.0372data6-10-56-11482.txt 10 6 56 46 0.2229data6-10-56-11483.txt 10 6 56 42 0.0047data6-10-56-11484.txt 10 6 56 38 0.0053data6-10-56-11485.txt 10 6 56 44 0.3999data6-10-56-11486.txt 10 6 56 40 0.2403data6-10-56-11487.txt 10 6 56 42 0.8506data6-10-56-11488.txt 10 6 56 37 0.1193data6-10-56-11489.txt 10 6 56 46 0.3729data6-10-56-11490.txt 10 6 56 45 0.0581data6-10-56-11491.txt 10 6 56 30 0.0925data6-10-56-11492.txt 10 6 56 53 0.5785data6-10-56-11493.txt 10 6 56 42 0.4810data6-10-56-11494.txt 10 6 56 38 0.7003data6-10-56-11495.txt 10 6 56 41 0.1436data6-10-56-11496.txt 10 6 56 54 1.0180data6-10-56-11497.txt 10 6 56 41 0.7223data6-10-56-11498.txt 10 6 56 47 0.2776data6-10-56-11499.txt 10 6 56 54 0.4749data6-10-56-11500.txt 10 6 56 52 0.4807data6-10-57-11501.txt 10 6 57 50 0.7339data6-10-57-11502.txt 10 6 57 51 0.3556data6-10-57-11503.txt 10 6 57 49 0.1897data6-10-57-11504.txt 10 6 57 48 0.4647data6-10-57-11505.txt 10 6 57 47 0.0723data6-10-57-11506.txt 10 6 57 38 0.0075data6-10-57-11507.txt 10 6 57 38 0.2140data6-10-57-11508.txt 10 6 57 48 0.4881data6-10-57-11509.txt 10 6 57 47 1.0123data6-10-57-11510.txt 10 6 57 46 0.6034data6-10-57-11511.txt 10 6 57 39 0.2439data6-10-57-11512.txt 10 6 57 44 0.0093data6-10-57-11513.txt 10 6 57 43 0.3376data6-10-57-11514.txt 10 6 57 56 0.1360data6-10-57-11515.txt 10 6 57 45 0.2244data6-10-57-11516.txt 10 6 57 53 0.1457data6-10-57-11517.txt 10 6 57 41 0.4946data6-10-57-11518.txt 10 6 57 50 0.0452data6-10-57-11519.txt 10 6 57 45 0.4973data6-10-57-11520.txt 10 6 57 46 0.9191data6-10-57-11521.txt 10 6 57 49 0.0084data6-10-57-11522.txt 10 6 57 43 0.2433data6-10-57-11523.txt 10 6 57 42 0.5960data6-10-57-11524.txt 10 6 57 39 0.6558data6-10-57-11525.txt 10 6 57 42 0.8669data6-10-57-11526.txt 10 6 57 42 0.3768data6-10-57-11527.txt 10 6 57 45 0.3029data6-10-57-11528.txt 10 6 57 41 0.1819data6-10-57-11529.txt 10 6 57 36 0.6005data6-10-57-11530.txt 10 6 57 47 0.6070data6-10-57-11531.txt 10 6 57 41 0.2519data6-10-57-11532.txt 10 6 57 48 0.8787data6-10-57-11533.txt 10 6 57 41 0.5726data6-10-57-11534.txt 10 6 57 42 0.0996data6-10-57-11535.txt 10 6 57 40 0.4032data6-10-57-11536.txt 10 6 57 50 1.0418data6-10-57-11537.txt 10 6 57 39 0.2395data6-10-57-11538.txt 10 6 57 37 0.3754data6-10-57-11539.txt 10 6 57 45 0.5542data6-10-57-11540.txt 10 6 57 41 0.0046data6-10-57-11541.txt 10 6 57 39 0.3061data6-10-57-11542.txt 10 6 57 44 0.3556data6-10-57-11543.txt 10 6 57 46 0.3734data6-10-57-11544.txt 10 6 57 51 0.2788data6-10-57-11545.txt 10 6 57 43 0.3405data6-10-57-11546.txt 10 6 57 35 0.0693data6-10-57-11547.txt 10 6 57 48 0.4445data6-10-57-11548.txt 10 6 57 41 0.0044data6-10-57-11549.txt 10 6 57 42 0.1345data6-10-57-11550.txt 10 6 57 43 1.0154

Table 125: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 331: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-10-57-11551.txt 10 6 57 40 0.1838data6-10-57-11552.txt 10 6 57 49 0.3979data6-10-57-11553.txt 10 6 57 43 0.0142data6-10-57-11554.txt 10 6 57 50 1.0617data6-10-57-11555.txt 10 6 57 54 0.8086data6-10-57-11556.txt 10 6 57 42 0.1455data6-10-57-11557.txt 10 6 57 43 0.2013data6-10-57-11558.txt 10 6 57 39 0.7665data6-10-57-11559.txt 10 6 57 40 0.0096data6-10-57-11560.txt 10 6 57 35 0.5189data6-10-57-11561.txt 10 6 57 49 0.4002data6-10-57-11562.txt 10 6 57 47 0.4986data6-10-57-11563.txt 10 6 57 43 0.0997data6-10-57-11564.txt 10 6 57 46 0.2182data6-10-57-11565.txt 10 6 57 38 0.0584data6-10-57-11566.txt 10 6 57 48 0.6579data6-10-57-11567.txt 10 6 57 47 0.5331data6-10-57-11568.txt 10 6 57 40 0.4648data6-10-57-11569.txt 10 6 57 38 0.0431data6-10-57-11570.txt 10 6 57 37 0.4199data6-10-57-11571.txt 10 6 57 46 0.7953data6-10-57-11572.txt 10 6 57 44 0.4741data6-10-57-11573.txt 10 6 57 44 0.9621data6-10-57-11574.txt 10 6 57 41 0.0854data6-10-57-11575.txt 10 6 57 47 0.0767data6-10-57-11576.txt 10 6 57 42 1.0164data6-10-57-11577.txt 10 6 57 46 1.0196data6-10-57-11578.txt 10 6 57 46 0.7626data6-10-57-11579.txt 10 6 57 56 0.9499data6-10-57-11580.txt 10 6 57 35 0.1699data6-10-57-11581.txt 10 6 57 46 0.5607data6-10-57-11582.txt 10 6 57 35 0.0039data6-10-57-11583.txt 10 6 57 44 0.2320data6-10-57-11584.txt 10 6 57 44 0.2485data6-10-57-11585.txt 10 6 57 49 0.4012data6-10-57-11586.txt 10 6 57 38 0.0421data6-10-57-11587.txt 10 6 57 41 0.1263data6-10-57-11588.txt 10 6 57 42 0.0047data6-10-57-11589.txt 10 6 57 39 0.1111data6-10-57-11590.txt 10 6 57 43 0.2385data6-10-57-11591.txt 10 6 57 42 1.0992data6-10-57-11592.txt 10 6 57 41 0.1170data6-10-57-11593.txt 10 6 57 47 1.0145data6-10-57-11594.txt 10 6 57 44 0.5925data6-10-57-11595.txt 10 6 57 33 0.0123data6-10-57-11596.txt 10 6 57 44 0.2753data6-10-57-11597.txt 10 6 57 42 0.0793data6-10-57-11598.txt 10 6 57 53 0.2851data6-10-57-11599.txt 10 6 57 38 0.8058data6-10-57-11600.txt 10 6 57 42 0.5813data6-10-58-11601.txt 10 6 58 40 0.2724data6-10-58-11602.txt 10 6 58 43 0.1292data6-10-58-11603.txt 10 6 58 54 0.2769data6-10-58-11604.txt 10 6 58 47 0.3811data6-10-58-11605.txt 10 6 58 40 0.7509data6-10-58-11606.txt 10 6 58 50 0.2166data6-10-58-11607.txt 10 6 58 44 0.1063data6-10-58-11608.txt 10 6 58 48 0.3967data6-10-58-11609.txt 10 6 58 42 0.0124data6-10-58-11610.txt 10 6 58 43 0.7980data6-10-58-11611.txt 10 6 58 44 0.0151data6-10-58-11612.txt 10 6 58 45 0.4125data6-10-58-11613.txt 10 6 58 42 0.2460data6-10-58-11614.txt 10 6 58 54 0.4583data6-10-58-11615.txt 10 6 58 53 0.3962data6-10-58-11616.txt 10 6 58 55 0.9748data6-10-58-11617.txt 10 6 58 51 0.4045data6-10-58-11618.txt 10 6 58 50 0.4920data6-10-58-11619.txt 10 6 58 47 0.1999data6-10-58-11620.txt 10 6 58 39 0.1847

Table 126: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 332: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-10-58-11621.txt 10 6 58 54 0.2540data6-10-58-11622.txt 10 6 58 45 0.1112data6-10-58-11623.txt 10 6 58 49 0.0784data6-10-58-11624.txt 10 6 58 48 0.6760data6-10-58-11625.txt 10 6 58 42 0.3720data6-10-58-11626.txt 10 6 58 48 0.2733data6-10-58-11627.txt 10 6 58 44 0.9923data6-10-58-11628.txt 10 6 58 50 0.3836data6-10-58-11629.txt 10 6 58 40 0.0360data6-10-58-11630.txt 10 6 58 45 0.2042data6-10-58-11631.txt 10 6 58 39 0.7426data6-10-58-11632.txt 10 6 58 47 0.0469data6-10-58-11633.txt 10 6 58 48 0.2479data6-10-58-11634.txt 10 6 58 45 0.4720data6-10-58-11635.txt 10 6 58 48 0.8118data6-10-58-11636.txt 10 6 58 42 0.1326data6-10-58-11637.txt 10 6 58 42 0.5702data6-10-58-11638.txt 10 6 58 53 1.1084data6-10-58-11639.txt 10 6 58 49 0.3931data6-10-58-11640.txt 10 6 58 31 0.0105data6-10-58-11641.txt 10 6 58 42 0.6397data6-10-58-11642.txt 10 6 58 47 0.2810data6-10-58-11643.txt 10 6 58 46 0.2087data6-10-58-11644.txt 10 6 58 46 0.2448data6-10-58-11645.txt 10 6 58 45 0.4917data6-10-58-11646.txt 10 6 58 46 0.2240data6-10-58-11647.txt 10 6 58 44 0.3086data6-10-58-11648.txt 10 6 58 45 0.0038data6-10-58-11649.txt 10 6 58 39 0.2826data6-10-58-11650.txt 10 6 58 49 0.7079data6-10-58-11651.txt 10 6 58 50 0.6220data6-10-58-11652.txt 10 6 58 43 0.2623data6-10-58-11653.txt 10 6 58 38 0.0057data6-10-58-11654.txt 10 6 58 52 0.1615data6-10-58-11655.txt 10 6 58 42 0.1844data6-10-58-11656.txt 10 6 58 50 0.3761data6-10-58-11657.txt 10 6 58 44 0.1027data6-10-58-11658.txt 10 6 58 43 0.5623data6-10-58-11659.txt 10 6 58 48 0.1618data6-10-58-11660.txt 10 6 58 45 0.1192data6-10-58-11661.txt 10 6 58 44 0.1640data6-10-58-11662.txt 10 6 58 43 0.4077data6-10-58-11663.txt 10 6 58 40 0.9551data6-10-58-11664.txt 10 6 58 37 0.3183data6-10-58-11665.txt 10 6 58 52 1.0472data6-10-58-11666.txt 10 6 58 46 0.4899data6-10-58-11667.txt 10 6 58 57 0.1499data6-10-58-11668.txt 10 6 58 51 0.4801data6-10-58-11669.txt 10 6 58 41 0.1966data6-10-58-11670.txt 10 6 58 37 0.0449data6-10-58-11671.txt 10 6 58 39 0.5024data6-10-58-11672.txt 10 6 58 44 0.2531data6-10-58-11673.txt 10 6 58 40 0.1689data6-10-58-11674.txt 10 6 58 49 0.3024data6-10-58-11675.txt 10 6 58 50 0.5045data6-10-58-11676.txt 10 6 58 52 0.0138data6-10-58-11677.txt 10 6 58 37 0.1880data6-10-58-11678.txt 10 6 58 43 0.6671data6-10-58-11679.txt 10 6 58 48 0.7274data6-10-58-11680.txt 10 6 58 45 0.5271data6-10-58-11681.txt 10 6 58 49 1.0277data6-10-58-11682.txt 10 6 58 45 0.1268data6-10-58-11683.txt 10 6 58 42 0.0184data6-10-58-11684.txt 10 6 58 37 0.0051data6-10-58-11685.txt 10 6 58 43 0.3594data6-10-58-11686.txt 10 6 58 46 0.4038data6-10-58-11687.txt 10 6 58 52 0.2399data6-10-58-11688.txt 10 6 58 46 0.3232data6-10-58-11689.txt 10 6 58 46 0.7735data6-10-58-11690.txt 10 6 58 41 0.2214

Table 127: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 333: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-10-58-11691.txt 10 6 58 44 0.6633data6-10-58-11692.txt 10 6 58 52 0.1373data6-10-58-11693.txt 10 6 58 43 0.3764data6-10-58-11694.txt 10 6 58 56 0.4416data6-10-58-11695.txt 10 6 58 52 0.4849data6-10-58-11696.txt 10 6 58 53 0.3295data6-10-58-11697.txt 10 6 58 44 0.2338data6-10-58-11698.txt 10 6 58 49 0.0965data6-10-58-11699.txt 10 6 58 42 0.1092data6-10-58-11700.txt 10 6 58 35 0.0897data6-10-59-11701.txt 10 6 59 37 0.0994data6-10-59-11702.txt 10 6 59 46 0.1453data6-10-59-11703.txt 10 6 59 52 0.2344data6-10-59-11704.txt 10 6 59 41 0.3463data6-10-59-11705.txt 10 6 59 46 0.8808data6-10-59-11706.txt 10 6 59 49 0.4445data6-10-59-11707.txt 10 6 59 47 0.6779data6-10-59-11708.txt 10 6 59 47 0.1927data6-10-59-11709.txt 10 6 59 58 0.5196data6-10-59-11710.txt 10 6 59 39 0.8209data6-10-59-11711.txt 10 6 59 51 0.0096data6-10-59-11712.txt 10 6 59 44 0.3058data6-10-59-11713.txt 10 6 59 47 0.4210data6-10-59-11714.txt 10 6 59 49 0.2303data6-10-59-11715.txt 10 6 59 48 0.4180data6-10-59-11716.txt 10 6 59 35 0.0751data6-10-59-11717.txt 10 6 59 37 0.2464data6-10-59-11718.txt 10 6 59 45 0.5596data6-10-59-11719.txt 10 6 59 63 1.0189data6-10-59-11720.txt 10 6 59 50 0.5648data6-10-59-11721.txt 10 6 59 44 0.8614data6-10-59-11722.txt 10 6 59 51 0.3182data6-10-59-11723.txt 10 6 59 48 0.4837data6-10-59-11724.txt 10 6 59 41 0.5017data6-10-59-11725.txt 10 6 59 51 0.2807data6-10-59-11726.txt 10 6 59 45 0.5159data6-10-59-11727.txt 10 6 59 44 0.0154data6-10-59-11728.txt 10 6 59 55 1.0094data6-10-59-11729.txt 10 6 59 49 0.4650data6-10-59-11730.txt 10 6 59 46 0.2961data6-10-59-11731.txt 10 6 59 50 0.2439data6-10-59-11732.txt 10 6 59 42 0.4500data6-10-59-11733.txt 10 6 59 53 0.8661data6-10-59-11734.txt 10 6 59 38 0.0127data6-10-59-11735.txt 10 6 59 49 0.5660data6-10-59-11736.txt 10 6 59 52 0.7313data6-10-59-11737.txt 10 6 59 45 0.4275data6-10-59-11738.txt 10 6 59 47 0.2927data6-10-59-11739.txt 10 6 59 48 0.0676data6-10-59-11740.txt 10 6 59 48 0.8216data6-10-59-11741.txt 10 6 59 44 0.0302data6-10-59-11742.txt 10 6 59 40 0.2057data6-10-59-11743.txt 10 6 59 40 0.0343data6-10-59-11744.txt 10 6 59 41 0.0376data6-10-59-11745.txt 10 6 59 56 0.6753data6-10-59-11746.txt 10 6 59 54 0.2785data6-10-59-11747.txt 10 6 59 53 0.9317data6-10-59-11748.txt 10 6 59 43 1.0463data6-10-59-11749.txt 10 6 59 40 0.4842data6-10-59-11750.txt 10 6 59 50 0.1878data6-10-59-11751.txt 10 6 59 49 0.0768data6-10-59-11752.txt 10 6 59 38 0.0034data6-10-59-11753.txt 10 6 59 46 0.0648data6-10-59-11754.txt 10 6 59 44 0.0037data6-10-59-11755.txt 10 6 59 53 1.0071data6-10-59-11756.txt 10 6 59 47 0.3248data6-10-59-11757.txt 10 6 59 45 0.3598data6-10-59-11758.txt 10 6 59 45 0.0125data6-10-59-11759.txt 10 6 59 41 0.0057data6-10-59-11760.txt 10 6 59 42 0.1507

Table 128: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 334: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata6-10-59-11761.txt 10 6 59 63 0.3552data6-10-59-11762.txt 10 6 59 39 0.0915data6-10-59-11763.txt 10 6 59 42 0.2488data6-10-59-11764.txt 10 6 59 52 1.0245data6-10-59-11765.txt 10 6 59 63 0.8665data6-10-59-11766.txt 10 6 59 53 0.6073data6-10-59-11767.txt 10 6 59 54 0.6987data6-10-59-11768.txt 10 6 59 42 0.7986data6-10-59-11769.txt 10 6 59 45 0.4575data6-10-59-11770.txt 10 6 59 39 0.7673data6-10-59-11771.txt 10 6 59 58 0.5528data6-10-59-11772.txt 10 6 59 42 0.1820data6-10-59-11773.txt 10 6 59 46 0.0951data6-10-59-11774.txt 10 6 59 48 0.7528data6-10-59-11775.txt 10 6 59 54 0.0393data6-10-59-11776.txt 10 6 59 51 0.1006data6-10-59-11777.txt 10 6 59 45 0.4674data6-10-59-11778.txt 10 6 59 49 0.2543data6-10-59-11779.txt 10 6 59 41 0.3626data6-10-59-11780.txt 10 6 59 57 0.7624data6-10-59-11781.txt 10 6 59 49 0.3694data6-10-59-11782.txt 10 6 59 51 0.5719data6-10-59-11783.txt 10 6 59 53 0.9735data6-10-59-11784.txt 10 6 59 46 0.1566data6-10-59-11785.txt 10 6 59 45 0.7308data6-10-59-11786.txt 10 6 59 47 0.2049data6-10-59-11787.txt 10 6 59 49 0.6316data6-10-59-11788.txt 10 6 59 49 0.8122data6-10-59-11789.txt 10 6 59 46 0.1385data6-10-59-11790.txt 10 6 59 54 0.7394data6-10-59-11791.txt 10 6 59 47 0.2948data6-10-59-11792.txt 10 6 59 39 0.0655data6-10-59-11793.txt 10 6 59 59 0.4499data6-10-59-11794.txt 10 6 59 58 0.6378data6-10-59-11795.txt 10 6 59 45 0.2202data6-10-59-11796.txt 10 6 59 47 1.0202data6-10-59-11797.txt 10 6 59 47 0.1888data6-10-59-11798.txt 10 6 59 52 0.3629data6-10-59-11799.txt 10 6 59 54 0.1138data6-10-59-11800.txt 10 6 59 41 0.0098data7-6-35-01801.txt 6 7 35 29 0.0939data7-6-35-01802.txt 6 7 35 30 0.0961data7-6-35-01803.txt 6 7 35 34 0.0848data7-6-35-01804.txt 6 7 35 33 0.6884data7-6-35-01805.txt 6 7 35 26 0.0057data7-6-35-01806.txt 6 7 35 24 0.0080data7-6-35-01807.txt 6 7 35 33 0.0155data7-6-35-01808.txt 6 7 35 31 0.5809data7-6-35-01809.txt 6 7 35 26 0.0136data7-6-35-01810.txt 6 7 35 23 0.1206data7-6-35-01811.txt 6 7 35 28 0.0420data7-6-35-01812.txt 6 7 35 34 0.3715data7-6-35-01813.txt 6 7 35 31 0.3501data7-6-35-01814.txt 6 7 35 28 0.0035data7-6-35-01815.txt 6 7 35 30 0.2330data7-6-35-01816.txt 6 7 35 25 0.0308data7-6-35-01817.txt 6 7 35 25 0.0045data7-6-35-01818.txt 6 7 35 29 0.1170data7-6-35-01819.txt 6 7 35 34 0.5170data7-6-35-01820.txt 6 7 35 25 0.0036data7-6-35-01821.txt 6 7 35 30 0.0527data7-6-35-01822.txt 6 7 35 29 0.7290data7-6-35-01823.txt 6 7 35 28 0.0659data7-6-35-01824.txt 6 7 35 36 0.6804data7-6-35-01825.txt 6 7 35 26 0.0065data7-6-35-01826.txt 6 7 35 27 0.4581data7-6-35-01827.txt 6 7 35 30 0.3392data7-6-35-01828.txt 6 7 35 28 0.1623data7-6-35-01829.txt 6 7 35 38 0.2418data7-6-35-01830.txt 6 7 35 34 0.0035

Table 129: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 335: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-6-35-01831.txt 6 7 35 28 0.2730data7-6-35-01832.txt 6 7 35 26 0.0036data7-6-35-01833.txt 6 7 35 26 0.3190data7-6-35-01834.txt 6 7 35 33 0.2229data7-6-35-01835.txt 6 7 35 38 0.3891data7-6-35-01836.txt 6 7 35 38 0.2621data7-6-35-01837.txt 6 7 35 26 0.0930data7-6-35-01838.txt 6 7 35 36 0.1850data7-6-35-01839.txt 6 7 35 19 0.0032data7-6-35-01840.txt 6 7 35 31 0.0964data7-6-35-01841.txt 6 7 35 24 0.1286data7-6-35-01842.txt 6 7 35 29 0.3353data7-6-35-01843.txt 6 7 35 36 0.3409data7-6-35-01844.txt 6 7 35 36 0.4428data7-6-35-01845.txt 6 7 35 33 0.1082data7-6-35-01846.txt 6 7 35 26 0.1707data7-6-35-01847.txt 6 7 35 32 0.1150data7-6-35-01848.txt 6 7 35 28 0.1723data7-6-35-01849.txt 6 7 35 32 0.2047data7-6-35-01850.txt 6 7 35 26 0.1447data7-6-35-01851.txt 6 7 35 38 0.5522data7-6-35-01852.txt 6 7 35 31 0.3914data7-6-35-01853.txt 6 7 35 27 0.2840data7-6-35-01854.txt 6 7 35 36 0.7929data7-6-35-01855.txt 6 7 35 32 0.0067data7-6-35-01856.txt 6 7 35 28 0.0849data7-6-35-01857.txt 6 7 35 24 0.1148data7-6-35-01858.txt 6 7 35 21 0.0160data7-6-35-01859.txt 6 7 35 33 0.3785data7-6-35-01860.txt 6 7 35 30 0.0900data7-6-35-01861.txt 6 7 35 25 0.0041data7-6-35-01862.txt 6 7 35 35 0.3210data7-6-35-01863.txt 6 7 35 36 0.5555data7-6-35-01864.txt 6 7 35 28 0.0046data7-6-35-01865.txt 6 7 35 28 0.0049data7-6-35-01866.txt 6 7 35 26 0.0057data7-6-35-01867.txt 6 7 35 25 0.0234data7-6-35-01868.txt 6 7 35 26 0.0984data7-6-35-01869.txt 6 7 35 26 0.0084data7-6-35-01870.txt 6 7 35 29 0.0052data7-6-35-01871.txt 6 7 35 29 0.1779data7-6-35-01872.txt 6 7 35 25 0.0186data7-6-35-01873.txt 6 7 35 30 0.4082data7-6-35-01874.txt 6 7 35 28 0.0052data7-6-35-01875.txt 6 7 35 25 0.0145data7-6-35-01876.txt 6 7 35 28 0.2668data7-6-35-01877.txt 6 7 35 31 0.3326data7-6-35-01878.txt 6 7 35 34 0.5126data7-6-35-01879.txt 6 7 35 34 0.2141data7-6-35-01880.txt 6 7 35 35 0.5179data7-6-35-01881.txt 6 7 35 38 0.5095data7-6-35-01882.txt 6 7 35 35 0.1959data7-6-35-01883.txt 6 7 35 30 0.1990data7-6-35-01884.txt 6 7 35 34 0.2595data7-6-35-01885.txt 6 7 35 23 0.1188data7-6-35-01886.txt 6 7 35 32 0.1305data7-6-35-01887.txt 6 7 35 29 0.0337data7-6-35-01888.txt 6 7 35 22 0.0063data7-6-35-01889.txt 6 7 35 28 0.0849data7-6-35-01890.txt 6 7 35 33 0.4162data7-6-35-01891.txt 6 7 35 28 0.7071data7-6-35-01892.txt 6 7 35 37 0.8255data7-6-35-01893.txt 6 7 35 30 0.1701data7-6-35-01894.txt 6 7 35 35 0.5036data7-6-35-01895.txt 6 7 35 30 0.0706data7-6-35-01896.txt 6 7 35 26 0.0425data7-6-35-01897.txt 6 7 35 32 0.6148data7-6-35-01898.txt 6 7 35 33 0.0245data7-6-35-01899.txt 6 7 35 38 0.4720data7-6-35-01900.txt 6 7 35 27 0.0084

Table 130: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 336: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-6-36-01901.txt 6 7 36 34 0.2528data7-6-36-01902.txt 6 7 36 25 0.0602data7-6-36-01903.txt 6 7 36 32 0.3395data7-6-36-01904.txt 6 7 36 32 0.3313data7-6-36-01905.txt 6 7 36 36 0.2431data7-6-36-01906.txt 6 7 36 37 0.3594data7-6-36-01907.txt 6 7 36 30 0.0033data7-6-36-01908.txt 6 7 36 43 0.5999data7-6-36-01909.txt 6 7 36 35 0.3218data7-6-36-01910.txt 6 7 36 28 0.0055data7-6-36-01911.txt 6 7 36 41 0.1496data7-6-36-01912.txt 6 7 36 20 0.0061data7-6-36-01913.txt 6 7 36 31 0.0056data7-6-36-01914.txt 6 7 36 36 0.2964data7-6-36-01915.txt 6 7 36 25 0.0412data7-6-36-01916.txt 6 7 36 28 0.3254data7-6-36-01917.txt 6 7 36 28 0.0132data7-6-36-01918.txt 6 7 36 34 0.3940data7-6-36-01919.txt 6 7 36 31 0.0101data7-6-36-01920.txt 6 7 36 36 0.1662data7-6-36-01921.txt 6 7 36 27 0.0088data7-6-36-01922.txt 6 7 36 35 0.2342data7-6-36-01923.txt 6 7 36 37 0.8226data7-6-36-01924.txt 6 7 36 28 0.0337data7-6-36-01925.txt 6 7 36 40 0.0122data7-6-36-01926.txt 6 7 36 27 0.1286data7-6-36-01927.txt 6 7 36 40 0.2473data7-6-36-01928.txt 6 7 36 36 0.2432data7-6-36-01929.txt 6 7 36 33 0.2205data7-6-36-01930.txt 6 7 36 31 0.1128data7-6-36-01931.txt 6 7 36 44 0.5214data7-6-36-01932.txt 6 7 36 26 0.0858data7-6-36-01933.txt 6 7 36 34 0.2559data7-6-36-01934.txt 6 7 36 42 0.6063data7-6-36-01935.txt 6 7 36 30 0.1073data7-6-36-01936.txt 6 7 36 32 0.1049data7-6-36-01937.txt 6 7 36 35 0.2700data7-6-36-01938.txt 6 7 36 22 0.0036data7-6-36-01939.txt 6 7 36 31 0.1949data7-6-36-01940.txt 6 7 36 29 0.0063data7-6-36-01941.txt 6 7 36 27 0.0812data7-6-36-01942.txt 6 7 36 38 0.2120data7-6-36-01943.txt 6 7 36 38 0.3128data7-6-36-01944.txt 6 7 36 36 0.3420data7-6-36-01945.txt 6 7 36 28 0.4031data7-6-36-01946.txt 6 7 36 28 0.0324data7-6-36-01947.txt 6 7 36 34 0.4938data7-6-36-01948.txt 6 7 36 26 0.0064data7-6-36-01949.txt 6 7 36 33 0.0593data7-6-36-01950.txt 6 7 36 37 0.2549data7-6-36-01951.txt 6 7 36 39 0.3571data7-6-36-01952.txt 6 7 36 36 0.3712data7-6-36-01953.txt 6 7 36 34 0.2562data7-6-36-01954.txt 6 7 36 29 0.2966data7-6-36-01955.txt 6 7 36 34 0.4923data7-6-36-01956.txt 6 7 36 35 0.1698data7-6-36-01957.txt 6 7 36 34 0.0352data7-6-36-01958.txt 6 7 36 43 0.8813data7-6-36-01959.txt 6 7 36 31 0.0136data7-6-36-01960.txt 6 7 36 29 0.4074data7-6-36-01961.txt 6 7 36 44 0.1080data7-6-36-01962.txt 6 7 36 30 0.1517data7-6-36-01963.txt 6 7 36 37 0.6529data7-6-36-01964.txt 6 7 36 33 0.3006data7-6-36-01965.txt 6 7 36 34 0.0742data7-6-36-01966.txt 6 7 36 31 0.0200data7-6-36-01967.txt 6 7 36 30 0.3437data7-6-36-01968.txt 6 7 36 29 0.0987data7-6-36-01969.txt 6 7 36 35 0.0095data7-6-36-01970.txt 6 7 36 33 0.5146

Table 131: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 337: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-6-36-01971.txt 6 7 36 36 0.1714data7-6-36-01972.txt 6 7 36 30 0.2104data7-6-36-01973.txt 6 7 36 37 0.3527data7-6-36-01974.txt 6 7 36 31 0.1830data7-6-36-01975.txt 6 7 36 35 0.0242data7-6-36-01976.txt 6 7 36 20 0.0531data7-6-36-01977.txt 6 7 36 38 0.6422data7-6-36-01978.txt 6 7 36 42 0.3162data7-6-36-01979.txt 6 7 36 31 0.1629data7-6-36-01980.txt 6 7 36 31 0.0043data7-6-36-01981.txt 6 7 36 28 0.3079data7-6-36-01982.txt 6 7 36 35 0.2405data7-6-36-01983.txt 6 7 36 42 0.3559data7-6-36-01984.txt 6 7 36 30 0.0087data7-6-36-01985.txt 6 7 36 29 0.3689data7-6-36-01986.txt 6 7 36 35 0.0035data7-6-36-01987.txt 6 7 36 44 0.3603data7-6-36-01988.txt 6 7 36 30 0.7230data7-6-36-01989.txt 6 7 36 31 0.2044data7-6-36-01990.txt 6 7 36 31 0.3560data7-6-36-01991.txt 6 7 36 23 0.0136data7-6-36-01992.txt 6 7 36 37 0.4219data7-6-36-01993.txt 6 7 36 35 0.1295data7-6-36-01994.txt 6 7 36 31 0.1274data7-6-36-01995.txt 6 7 36 36 0.1848data7-6-36-01996.txt 6 7 36 35 0.6989data7-6-36-01997.txt 6 7 36 34 0.0669data7-6-36-01998.txt 6 7 36 32 0.4763data7-6-36-01999.txt 6 7 36 30 0.0787data7-6-36-02000.txt 6 7 36 39 0.0542data7-6-37-02001.txt 6 7 37 46 0.2253data7-6-37-02002.txt 6 7 37 46 0.3035data7-6-37-02003.txt 6 7 37 39 0.0646data7-6-37-02004.txt 6 7 37 38 0.2980data7-6-37-02005.txt 6 7 37 49 0.3470data7-6-37-02006.txt 6 7 37 34 0.4841data7-6-37-02007.txt 6 7 37 35 0.0847data7-6-37-02008.txt 6 7 37 32 0.0237data7-6-37-02009.txt 6 7 37 33 0.2892data7-6-37-02010.txt 6 7 37 40 0.3727data7-6-37-02011.txt 6 7 37 33 0.2214data7-6-37-02012.txt 6 7 37 39 0.6941data7-6-37-02013.txt 6 7 37 38 0.0916data7-6-37-02014.txt 6 7 37 33 0.0615data7-6-37-02015.txt 6 7 37 36 0.0232data7-6-37-02016.txt 6 7 37 34 0.0131data7-6-37-02017.txt 6 7 37 32 0.0475data7-6-37-02018.txt 6 7 37 27 0.2183data7-6-37-02019.txt 6 7 37 35 0.1176data7-6-37-02020.txt 6 7 37 33 0.3604data7-6-37-02021.txt 6 7 37 38 0.0113data7-6-37-02022.txt 6 7 37 39 0.3538data7-6-37-02023.txt 6 7 37 36 0.2302data7-6-37-02024.txt 6 7 37 43 0.3277data7-6-37-02025.txt 6 7 37 41 0.0747data7-6-37-02026.txt 6 7 37 33 0.1228data7-6-37-02027.txt 6 7 37 40 0.6395data7-6-37-02028.txt 6 7 37 31 0.0870data7-6-37-02029.txt 6 7 37 31 0.0032data7-6-37-02030.txt 6 7 37 30 0.0439data7-6-37-02031.txt 6 7 37 33 0.0732data7-6-37-02032.txt 6 7 37 26 0.0114data7-6-37-02033.txt 6 7 37 31 0.0204data7-6-37-02034.txt 6 7 37 32 0.0089data7-6-37-02035.txt 6 7 37 37 0.4542data7-6-37-02036.txt 6 7 37 36 0.0767data7-6-37-02037.txt 6 7 37 34 0.5535data7-6-37-02038.txt 6 7 37 37 0.1519data7-6-37-02039.txt 6 7 37 21 0.0098data7-6-37-02040.txt 6 7 37 38 0.1169

Table 132: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 338: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-6-37-02041.txt 6 7 37 37 0.2654data7-6-37-02042.txt 6 7 37 37 0.5053data7-6-37-02043.txt 6 7 37 31 0.0201data7-6-37-02044.txt 6 7 37 34 0.4108data7-6-37-02045.txt 6 7 37 38 0.1457data7-6-37-02046.txt 6 7 37 33 0.0313data7-6-37-02047.txt 6 7 37 41 0.2284data7-6-37-02048.txt 6 7 37 33 0.0745data7-6-37-02049.txt 6 7 37 32 0.0095data7-6-37-02050.txt 6 7 37 33 0.1166data7-6-37-02051.txt 6 7 37 36 0.2219data7-6-37-02052.txt 6 7 37 38 0.2226data7-6-37-02053.txt 6 7 37 33 0.1651data7-6-37-02054.txt 6 7 37 26 0.1191data7-6-37-02055.txt 6 7 37 36 0.1876data7-6-37-02056.txt 6 7 37 39 0.2614data7-6-37-02057.txt 6 7 37 33 0.3159data7-6-37-02058.txt 6 7 37 28 0.3026data7-6-37-02059.txt 6 7 37 31 0.2030data7-6-37-02060.txt 6 7 37 36 0.0320data7-6-37-02061.txt 6 7 37 40 0.3631data7-6-37-02062.txt 6 7 37 41 0.0676data7-6-37-02063.txt 6 7 37 38 0.4667data7-6-37-02064.txt 6 7 37 40 0.1754data7-6-37-02065.txt 6 7 37 41 0.3930data7-6-37-02066.txt 6 7 37 35 0.4434data7-6-37-02067.txt 6 7 37 37 0.0852data7-6-37-02068.txt 6 7 37 39 0.2799data7-6-37-02069.txt 6 7 37 41 0.3184data7-6-37-02070.txt 6 7 37 30 0.0413data7-6-37-02071.txt 6 7 37 30 0.0733data7-6-37-02072.txt 6 7 37 35 0.1922data7-6-37-02073.txt 6 7 37 32 0.0051data7-6-37-02074.txt 6 7 37 27 0.0151data7-6-37-02075.txt 6 7 37 31 0.6338data7-6-37-02076.txt 6 7 37 25 0.0035data7-6-37-02077.txt 6 7 37 29 0.0526data7-6-37-02078.txt 6 7 37 31 0.2124data7-6-37-02079.txt 6 7 37 45 0.1769data7-6-37-02080.txt 6 7 37 32 0.3453data7-6-37-02081.txt 6 7 37 32 0.1000data7-6-37-02082.txt 6 7 37 31 0.0209data7-6-37-02083.txt 6 7 37 37 0.3824data7-6-37-02084.txt 6 7 37 34 0.4045data7-6-37-02085.txt 6 7 37 35 0.0229data7-6-37-02086.txt 6 7 37 36 0.6305data7-6-37-02087.txt 6 7 37 31 0.3870data7-6-37-02088.txt 6 7 37 40 0.1743data7-6-37-02089.txt 6 7 37 33 0.1847data7-6-37-02090.txt 6 7 37 25 0.0134data7-6-37-02091.txt 6 7 37 36 0.2294data7-6-37-02092.txt 6 7 37 35 0.2173data7-6-37-02093.txt 6 7 37 31 0.0044data7-6-37-02094.txt 6 7 37 39 0.0318data7-6-37-02095.txt 6 7 37 36 0.2657data7-6-37-02096.txt 6 7 37 36 0.1512data7-6-37-02097.txt 6 7 37 34 0.4248data7-6-37-02098.txt 6 7 37 37 0.0510data7-6-37-02099.txt 6 7 37 41 0.3025data7-6-37-02100.txt 6 7 37 34 0.4463data7-6-38-02101.txt 6 7 38 40 0.0911data7-6-38-02102.txt 6 7 38 32 0.0387data7-6-38-02103.txt 6 7 38 30 0.1873data7-6-38-02104.txt 6 7 38 47 0.0100data7-6-38-02105.txt 6 7 38 35 0.1771data7-6-38-02106.txt 6 7 38 37 0.1494data7-6-38-02107.txt 6 7 38 29 0.0440data7-6-38-02108.txt 6 7 38 37 0.2318data7-6-38-02109.txt 6 7 38 43 0.1577data7-6-38-02110.txt 6 7 38 40 0.2805

Table 133: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 339: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-6-38-02111.txt 6 7 38 42 0.3760data7-6-38-02112.txt 6 7 38 34 0.0810data7-6-38-02113.txt 6 7 38 42 0.3722data7-6-38-02114.txt 6 7 38 32 0.0652data7-6-38-02115.txt 6 7 38 38 0.0185data7-6-38-02116.txt 6 7 38 43 0.0143data7-6-38-02117.txt 6 7 38 33 0.2090data7-6-38-02118.txt 6 7 38 32 0.1293data7-6-38-02119.txt 6 7 38 43 0.3001data7-6-38-02120.txt 6 7 38 36 0.2941data7-6-38-02121.txt 6 7 38 35 0.0951data7-6-38-02122.txt 6 7 38 38 0.4045data7-6-38-02123.txt 6 7 38 45 0.4306data7-6-38-02124.txt 6 7 38 37 0.0564data7-6-38-02125.txt 6 7 38 37 0.1135data7-6-38-02126.txt 6 7 38 40 0.5077data7-6-38-02127.txt 6 7 38 37 0.1656data7-6-38-02128.txt 6 7 38 32 0.0284data7-6-38-02129.txt 6 7 38 38 0.0651data7-6-38-02130.txt 6 7 38 33 0.0156data7-6-38-02131.txt 6 7 38 39 0.5380data7-6-38-02132.txt 6 7 38 42 0.0200data7-6-38-02133.txt 6 7 38 35 0.1172data7-6-38-02134.txt 6 7 38 37 0.2639data7-6-38-02135.txt 6 7 38 27 0.0038data7-6-38-02136.txt 6 7 38 26 0.1728data7-6-38-02137.txt 6 7 38 38 0.2259data7-6-38-02138.txt 6 7 38 44 0.3186data7-6-38-02139.txt 6 7 38 34 0.1069data7-6-38-02140.txt 6 7 38 36 0.8347data7-6-38-02141.txt 6 7 38 31 0.2221data7-6-38-02142.txt 6 7 38 38 0.5392data7-6-38-02143.txt 6 7 38 29 0.0068data7-6-38-02144.txt 6 7 38 33 0.2084data7-6-38-02145.txt 6 7 38 45 0.0052data7-6-38-02146.txt 6 7 38 28 0.0414data7-6-38-02147.txt 6 7 38 36 0.1139data7-6-38-02148.txt 6 7 38 38 0.1636data7-6-38-02149.txt 6 7 38 28 0.1580data7-6-38-02150.txt 6 7 38 42 0.2381data7-6-38-02151.txt 6 7 38 34 0.0056data7-6-38-02152.txt 6 7 38 38 0.1737data7-6-38-02153.txt 6 7 38 46 0.7677data7-6-38-02154.txt 6 7 38 38 0.2569data7-6-38-02155.txt 6 7 38 39 0.2950data7-6-38-02156.txt 6 7 38 43 0.1116data7-6-38-02157.txt 6 7 38 29 0.0727data7-6-38-02158.txt 6 7 38 29 0.0965data7-6-38-02159.txt 6 7 38 34 0.1093data7-6-38-02160.txt 6 7 38 30 0.0039data7-6-38-02161.txt 6 7 38 36 0.0765data7-6-38-02162.txt 6 7 38 28 0.0067data7-6-38-02163.txt 6 7 38 34 0.4143data7-6-38-02164.txt 6 7 38 34 0.1776data7-6-38-02165.txt 6 7 38 32 0.0807data7-6-38-02166.txt 6 7 38 42 0.6478data7-6-38-02167.txt 6 7 38 33 0.0852data7-6-38-02168.txt 6 7 38 31 0.0128data7-6-38-02169.txt 6 7 38 25 0.0127data7-6-38-02170.txt 6 7 38 33 0.3607data7-6-38-02171.txt 6 7 38 29 0.0199data7-6-38-02172.txt 6 7 38 35 0.2999data7-6-38-02173.txt 6 7 38 38 0.2486data7-6-38-02174.txt 6 7 38 26 0.0098data7-6-38-02175.txt 6 7 38 33 0.2350data7-6-38-02176.txt 6 7 38 40 0.2548data7-6-38-02177.txt 6 7 38 31 0.2078data7-6-38-02178.txt 6 7 38 32 0.2374data7-6-38-02179.txt 6 7 38 42 0.2362data7-6-38-02180.txt 6 7 38 40 0.3288

Table 134: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 340: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-6-38-02181.txt 6 7 38 31 0.2629data7-6-38-02182.txt 6 7 38 49 0.5893data7-6-38-02183.txt 6 7 38 41 0.2007data7-6-38-02184.txt 6 7 38 40 0.2234data7-6-38-02185.txt 6 7 38 41 0.0580data7-6-38-02186.txt 6 7 38 31 0.3101data7-6-38-02187.txt 6 7 38 34 0.1673data7-6-38-02188.txt 6 7 38 33 0.4712data7-6-38-02189.txt 6 7 38 46 0.3250data7-6-38-02190.txt 6 7 38 36 0.1818data7-6-38-02191.txt 6 7 38 30 0.0033data7-6-38-02192.txt 6 7 38 33 0.0609data7-6-38-02193.txt 6 7 38 29 0.4816data7-6-38-02194.txt 6 7 38 34 0.0230data7-6-38-02195.txt 6 7 38 48 0.3774data7-6-38-02196.txt 6 7 38 41 0.1347data7-6-38-02197.txt 6 7 38 41 0.3263data7-6-38-02198.txt 6 7 38 34 0.3843data7-6-38-02199.txt 6 7 38 32 0.0190data7-6-38-02200.txt 6 7 38 28 0.3112data7-6-39-02201.txt 6 7 39 40 0.3868data7-6-39-02202.txt 6 7 39 40 0.1230data7-6-39-02203.txt 6 7 39 33 0.0970data7-6-39-02204.txt 6 7 39 38 0.0084data7-6-39-02205.txt 6 7 39 37 0.8665data7-6-39-02206.txt 6 7 39 38 0.5630data7-6-39-02207.txt 6 7 39 37 0.2064data7-6-39-02208.txt 6 7 39 30 0.0357data7-6-39-02209.txt 6 7 39 31 0.0038data7-6-39-02210.txt 6 7 39 48 0.0944data7-6-39-02211.txt 6 7 39 28 0.0095data7-6-39-02212.txt 6 7 39 34 0.1458data7-6-39-02213.txt 6 7 39 38 0.0973data7-6-39-02214.txt 6 7 39 40 0.1923data7-6-39-02215.txt 6 7 39 24 0.0038data7-6-39-02216.txt 6 7 39 32 0.0898data7-6-39-02217.txt 6 7 39 34 0.0068data7-6-39-02218.txt 6 7 39 35 0.0167data7-6-39-02219.txt 6 7 39 38 0.7134data7-6-39-02220.txt 6 7 39 37 0.1889data7-6-39-02221.txt 6 7 39 47 0.4827data7-6-39-02222.txt 6 7 39 31 0.1152data7-6-39-02223.txt 6 7 39 42 0.0545data7-6-39-02224.txt 6 7 39 41 0.3543data7-6-39-02225.txt 6 7 39 32 0.1787data7-6-39-02226.txt 6 7 39 34 0.2615data7-6-39-02227.txt 6 7 39 41 0.0103data7-6-39-02228.txt 6 7 39 38 0.7799data7-6-39-02229.txt 6 7 39 25 0.0034data7-6-39-02230.txt 6 7 39 35 0.2360data7-6-39-02231.txt 6 7 39 26 0.0262data7-6-39-02232.txt 6 7 39 35 0.0579data7-6-39-02233.txt 6 7 39 34 0.3660data7-6-39-02234.txt 6 7 39 39 0.0424data7-6-39-02235.txt 6 7 39 39 0.1016data7-6-39-02236.txt 6 7 39 34 0.1111data7-6-39-02237.txt 6 7 39 34 0.6625data7-6-39-02238.txt 6 7 39 28 0.0843data7-6-39-02239.txt 6 7 39 41 0.7205data7-6-39-02240.txt 6 7 39 40 0.4595data7-6-39-02241.txt 6 7 39 39 0.2239data7-6-39-02242.txt 6 7 39 34 0.4680data7-6-39-02243.txt 6 7 39 37 0.1476data7-6-39-02244.txt 6 7 39 38 0.1055data7-6-39-02245.txt 6 7 39 43 0.1011data7-6-39-02246.txt 6 7 39 29 0.2764data7-6-39-02247.txt 6 7 39 40 0.0178data7-6-39-02248.txt 6 7 39 30 0.3495data7-6-39-02249.txt 6 7 39 41 0.4948data7-6-39-02250.txt 6 7 39 46 0.1130

Table 135: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 341: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-6-39-02251.txt 6 7 39 35 0.5551data7-6-39-02252.txt 6 7 39 37 0.3089data7-6-39-02253.txt 6 7 39 44 0.4434data7-6-39-02254.txt 6 7 39 33 0.3866data7-6-39-02255.txt 6 7 39 35 0.0994data7-6-39-02256.txt 6 7 39 30 0.0053data7-6-39-02257.txt 6 7 39 29 0.0391data7-6-39-02258.txt 6 7 39 45 0.0782data7-6-39-02259.txt 6 7 39 39 0.1951data7-6-39-02260.txt 6 7 39 40 0.0071data7-6-39-02261.txt 6 7 39 38 0.2795data7-6-39-02262.txt 6 7 39 43 0.1692data7-6-39-02263.txt 6 7 39 42 1.0263data7-6-39-02264.txt 6 7 39 38 0.0550data7-6-39-02265.txt 6 7 39 42 0.2485data7-6-39-02266.txt 6 7 39 44 0.3416data7-6-39-02267.txt 6 7 39 33 0.0073data7-6-39-02268.txt 6 7 39 44 0.2544data7-6-39-02269.txt 6 7 39 40 0.4878data7-6-39-02270.txt 6 7 39 39 0.3832data7-6-39-02271.txt 6 7 39 38 0.0347data7-6-39-02272.txt 6 7 39 43 0.1566data7-6-39-02273.txt 6 7 39 26 0.2622data7-6-39-02274.txt 6 7 39 39 0.2329data7-6-39-02275.txt 6 7 39 31 0.0693data7-6-39-02276.txt 6 7 39 37 0.2758data7-6-39-02277.txt 6 7 39 45 0.1894data7-6-39-02278.txt 6 7 39 40 0.2421data7-6-39-02279.txt 6 7 39 37 0.1725data7-6-39-02280.txt 6 7 39 47 0.1209data7-6-39-02281.txt 6 7 39 44 0.3478data7-6-39-02282.txt 6 7 39 44 0.5392data7-6-39-02283.txt 6 7 39 37 0.3824data7-6-39-02284.txt 6 7 39 37 0.3288data7-6-39-02285.txt 6 7 39 29 0.4087data7-6-39-02286.txt 6 7 39 39 0.2040data7-6-39-02287.txt 6 7 39 34 0.0041data7-6-39-02288.txt 6 7 39 30 0.0552data7-6-39-02289.txt 6 7 39 41 0.1873data7-6-39-02290.txt 6 7 39 32 0.0694data7-6-39-02291.txt 6 7 39 36 0.4584data7-6-39-02292.txt 6 7 39 32 0.0291data7-6-39-02293.txt 6 7 39 40 0.1651data7-6-39-02294.txt 6 7 39 29 0.0466data7-6-39-02295.txt 6 7 39 41 0.0840data7-6-39-02296.txt 6 7 39 34 0.0034data7-6-39-02297.txt 6 7 39 37 0.3703data7-6-39-02298.txt 6 7 39 35 0.1252data7-6-39-02299.txt 6 7 39 38 0.0805data7-6-39-02300.txt 6 7 39 33 0.0834data7-6-40-02301.txt 6 7 40 46 0.3056data7-6-40-02302.txt 6 7 40 44 0.0569data7-6-40-02303.txt 6 7 40 50 0.2182data7-6-40-02304.txt 6 7 40 36 0.0876data7-6-40-02305.txt 6 7 40 36 0.1113data7-6-40-02306.txt 6 7 40 30 0.0065data7-6-40-02307.txt 6 7 40 37 0.1551data7-6-40-02308.txt 6 7 40 49 0.1943data7-6-40-02309.txt 6 7 40 33 0.0183data7-6-40-02310.txt 6 7 40 48 0.0248data7-6-40-02311.txt 6 7 40 49 0.3408data7-6-40-02312.txt 6 7 40 44 0.2748data7-6-40-02313.txt 6 7 40 43 0.1116data7-6-40-02314.txt 6 7 40 32 0.0035data7-6-40-02315.txt 6 7 40 39 0.0322data7-6-40-02316.txt 6 7 40 36 0.1605data7-6-40-02317.txt 6 7 40 35 0.0251data7-6-40-02318.txt 6 7 40 24 0.0124data7-6-40-02319.txt 6 7 40 35 0.0029data7-6-40-02320.txt 6 7 40 38 0.1069

Table 136: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 342: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-6-40-02321.txt 6 7 40 39 0.1063data7-6-40-02322.txt 6 7 40 46 0.0930data7-6-40-02323.txt 6 7 40 40 0.0094data7-6-40-02324.txt 6 7 40 43 0.1354data7-6-40-02325.txt 6 7 40 45 0.2851data7-6-40-02326.txt 6 7 40 41 0.1828data7-6-40-02327.txt 6 7 40 38 0.0168data7-6-40-02328.txt 6 7 40 37 0.0344data7-6-40-02329.txt 6 7 40 33 0.2066data7-6-40-02330.txt 6 7 40 34 0.1439data7-6-40-02331.txt 6 7 40 33 0.0102data7-6-40-02332.txt 6 7 40 43 0.2414data7-6-40-02333.txt 6 7 40 38 0.1620data7-6-40-02334.txt 6 7 40 41 0.1532data7-6-40-02335.txt 6 7 40 43 0.2095data7-6-40-02336.txt 6 7 40 43 0.1914data7-6-40-02337.txt 6 7 40 35 0.1853data7-6-40-02338.txt 6 7 40 39 0.0604data7-6-40-02339.txt 6 7 40 45 0.1628data7-6-40-02340.txt 6 7 40 29 0.0058data7-6-40-02341.txt 6 7 40 39 0.1047data7-6-40-02342.txt 6 7 40 42 0.1995data7-6-40-02343.txt 6 7 40 43 0.4207data7-6-40-02344.txt 6 7 40 39 0.1346data7-6-40-02345.txt 6 7 40 37 0.1491data7-6-40-02346.txt 6 7 40 38 0.1326data7-6-40-02347.txt 6 7 40 40 0.2748data7-6-40-02348.txt 6 7 40 42 0.3542data7-6-40-02349.txt 6 7 40 41 0.1410data7-6-40-02350.txt 6 7 40 34 0.0578data7-6-40-02351.txt 6 7 40 40 0.0993data7-6-40-02352.txt 6 7 40 35 0.1557data7-6-40-02353.txt 6 7 40 39 0.1924data7-6-40-02354.txt 6 7 40 46 0.0224data7-6-40-02355.txt 6 7 40 39 0.2873data7-6-40-02356.txt 6 7 40 33 0.0262data7-6-40-02357.txt 6 7 40 40 0.1342data7-6-40-02358.txt 6 7 40 40 0.1816data7-6-40-02359.txt 6 7 40 34 0.1107data7-6-40-02360.txt 6 7 40 36 0.1395data7-6-40-02361.txt 6 7 40 42 0.2885data7-6-40-02362.txt 6 7 40 35 0.1645data7-6-40-02363.txt 6 7 40 32 0.1145data7-6-40-02364.txt 6 7 40 42 0.1960data7-6-40-02365.txt 6 7 40 39 0.1427data7-6-40-02366.txt 6 7 40 40 0.3421data7-6-40-02367.txt 6 7 40 40 0.0024data7-6-40-02368.txt 6 7 40 35 0.1974data7-6-40-02369.txt 6 7 40 41 0.2852data7-6-40-02370.txt 6 7 40 49 0.2379data7-6-40-02371.txt 6 7 40 24 0.0050data7-6-40-02372.txt 6 7 40 46 0.2139data7-6-40-02373.txt 6 7 40 43 0.3370data7-6-40-02374.txt 6 7 40 30 0.1785data7-6-40-02375.txt 6 7 40 31 0.2592data7-6-40-02376.txt 6 7 40 40 0.2724data7-6-40-02377.txt 6 7 40 49 0.1981data7-6-40-02378.txt 6 7 40 34 0.3199data7-6-40-02379.txt 6 7 40 34 0.0032data7-6-40-02380.txt 6 7 40 38 0.3254data7-6-40-02381.txt 6 7 40 32 0.1773data7-6-40-02382.txt 6 7 40 38 0.0080data7-6-40-02383.txt 6 7 40 32 0.1986data7-6-40-02384.txt 6 7 40 39 0.0739data7-6-40-02385.txt 6 7 40 40 0.0073data7-6-40-02386.txt 6 7 40 42 0.1213data7-6-40-02387.txt 6 7 40 35 0.1288data7-6-40-02388.txt 6 7 40 43 0.2515data7-6-40-02389.txt 6 7 40 31 0.0381data7-6-40-02390.txt 6 7 40 26 0.0031

Table 137: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 343: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-6-40-02391.txt 6 7 40 37 0.1921data7-6-40-02392.txt 6 7 40 34 0.0151data7-6-40-02393.txt 6 7 40 44 0.3681data7-6-40-02394.txt 6 7 40 46 0.1224data7-6-40-02395.txt 6 7 40 42 0.0784data7-6-40-02396.txt 6 7 40 41 0.2501data7-6-40-02397.txt 6 7 40 40 0.0186data7-6-40-02398.txt 6 7 40 41 0.0835data7-6-40-02399.txt 6 7 40 39 0.1878data7-6-40-02400.txt 6 7 40 42 0.1860data7-6-41-02401.txt 6 7 41 44 0.0050data7-6-41-02402.txt 6 7 41 33 0.2129data7-6-41-02403.txt 6 7 41 43 0.0453data7-6-41-02404.txt 6 7 41 37 0.0235data7-6-41-02405.txt 6 7 41 37 0.3436data7-6-41-02406.txt 6 7 41 33 0.1338data7-6-41-02407.txt 6 7 41 44 0.4571data7-6-41-02408.txt 6 7 41 45 0.1555data7-6-41-02409.txt 6 7 41 31 0.0027data7-6-41-02410.txt 6 7 41 45 0.1428data7-6-41-02411.txt 6 7 41 32 0.0290data7-6-41-02412.txt 6 7 41 36 0.2168data7-6-41-02413.txt 6 7 41 44 0.0155data7-6-41-02414.txt 6 7 41 47 0.0939data7-6-41-02415.txt 6 7 41 31 0.0517data7-6-41-02416.txt 6 7 41 34 0.0817data7-6-41-02417.txt 6 7 41 37 0.0954data7-6-41-02418.txt 6 7 41 31 0.1856data7-6-41-02419.txt 6 7 41 43 0.1306data7-6-41-02420.txt 6 7 41 39 0.1497data7-6-41-02421.txt 6 7 41 42 0.1507data7-6-41-02422.txt 6 7 41 46 0.1928data7-6-41-02423.txt 6 7 41 40 0.2457data7-6-41-02424.txt 6 7 41 52 0.1366data7-6-41-02425.txt 6 7 41 40 0.3043data7-6-41-02426.txt 6 7 41 42 0.2040data7-6-41-02427.txt 6 7 41 49 0.2101data7-6-41-02428.txt 6 7 41 42 0.0830data7-6-41-02429.txt 6 7 41 41 0.0032data7-6-41-02430.txt 6 7 41 37 0.2802data7-6-41-02431.txt 6 7 41 49 0.3228data7-6-41-02432.txt 6 7 41 39 0.1381data7-6-41-02433.txt 6 7 41 44 0.0725data7-6-41-02434.txt 6 7 41 40 0.1548data7-6-41-02435.txt 6 7 41 44 0.1728data7-6-41-02436.txt 6 7 41 36 0.0160data7-6-41-02437.txt 6 7 41 33 0.1958data7-6-41-02438.txt 6 7 41 37 0.1807data7-6-41-02439.txt 6 7 41 43 0.1124data7-6-41-02440.txt 6 7 41 38 0.0954data7-6-41-02441.txt 6 7 41 40 0.1751data7-6-41-02442.txt 6 7 41 42 0.1930data7-6-41-02443.txt 6 7 41 44 0.0415data7-6-41-02444.txt 6 7 41 38 0.0067data7-6-41-02445.txt 6 7 41 35 0.0088data7-6-41-02446.txt 6 7 41 41 0.0254data7-6-41-02447.txt 6 7 41 35 0.0045data7-6-41-02448.txt 6 7 41 37 0.0521data7-6-41-02449.txt 6 7 41 35 0.0708data7-6-41-02450.txt 6 7 41 27 0.0767data7-6-41-02451.txt 6 7 41 37 0.1549data7-6-41-02452.txt 6 7 41 32 0.2037data7-6-41-02453.txt 6 7 41 30 0.0146data7-6-41-02454.txt 6 7 41 45 0.3049data7-6-41-02455.txt 6 7 41 42 0.0242data7-6-41-02456.txt 6 7 41 34 0.0190data7-6-41-02457.txt 6 7 41 40 0.2981data7-6-41-02458.txt 6 7 41 35 0.1500data7-6-41-02459.txt 6 7 41 37 0.4140data7-6-41-02460.txt 6 7 41 31 0.0996

Table 138: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 344: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-6-41-02461.txt 6 7 41 42 0.1430data7-6-41-02462.txt 6 7 41 43 0.0464data7-6-41-02463.txt 6 7 41 42 0.0289data7-6-41-02464.txt 6 7 41 47 0.1464data7-6-41-02465.txt 6 7 41 35 0.0395data7-6-41-02466.txt 6 7 41 31 0.2263data7-6-41-02467.txt 6 7 41 41 0.0605data7-6-41-02468.txt 6 7 41 33 0.0716data7-6-41-02469.txt 6 7 41 40 0.3863data7-6-41-02470.txt 6 7 41 33 0.0587data7-6-41-02471.txt 6 7 41 40 0.1791data7-6-41-02472.txt 6 7 41 38 0.3937data7-6-41-02473.txt 6 7 41 36 0.2033data7-6-41-02474.txt 6 7 41 44 0.0056data7-6-41-02475.txt 6 7 41 37 0.2221data7-6-41-02476.txt 6 7 41 43 0.0963data7-6-41-02477.txt 6 7 41 41 0.3583data7-6-41-02478.txt 6 7 41 48 0.2051data7-6-41-02479.txt 6 7 41 46 0.0228data7-6-41-02480.txt 6 7 41 38 0.0336data7-6-41-02481.txt 6 7 41 39 0.1478data7-6-41-02482.txt 6 7 41 43 0.1741data7-6-41-02483.txt 6 7 41 38 0.0051data7-6-41-02484.txt 6 7 41 42 0.0915data7-6-41-02485.txt 6 7 41 25 0.0035data7-6-41-02486.txt 6 7 41 41 0.0841data7-6-41-02487.txt 6 7 41 31 0.0302data7-6-41-02488.txt 6 7 41 38 0.3096data7-6-41-02489.txt 6 7 41 45 0.2431data7-6-41-02490.txt 6 7 41 30 0.0065data7-6-41-02491.txt 6 7 41 37 0.0157data7-6-41-02492.txt 6 7 41 42 0.0590data7-6-41-02493.txt 6 7 41 31 0.0563data7-6-41-02494.txt 6 7 41 38 0.1633data7-6-41-02495.txt 6 7 41 42 0.4379data7-6-41-02496.txt 6 7 41 39 0.0484data7-6-41-02497.txt 6 7 41 43 0.3072data7-6-41-02498.txt 6 7 41 40 0.0305data7-6-41-02499.txt 6 7 41 31 0.0576data7-6-41-02500.txt 6 7 41 44 0.2912data7-7-42-04301.txt 7 7 42 42 0.1401data7-7-42-04302.txt 7 7 42 37 0.2375data7-7-42-04303.txt 7 7 42 28 0.0027data7-7-42-04304.txt 7 7 42 46 0.5200data7-7-42-04305.txt 7 7 42 32 0.1001data7-7-42-04306.txt 7 7 42 40 0.0876data7-7-42-04307.txt 7 7 42 34 0.1327data7-7-42-04308.txt 7 7 42 37 0.4711data7-7-42-04309.txt 7 7 42 28 0.3888data7-7-42-04310.txt 7 7 42 33 0.2963data7-7-42-04311.txt 7 7 42 36 0.3779data7-7-42-04312.txt 7 7 42 39 0.2623data7-7-42-04313.txt 7 7 42 40 0.7239data7-7-42-04314.txt 7 7 42 28 0.0034data7-7-42-04315.txt 7 7 42 37 0.6770data7-7-42-04316.txt 7 7 42 28 0.0737data7-7-42-04317.txt 7 7 42 40 0.2213data7-7-42-04318.txt 7 7 42 34 0.3654data7-7-42-04319.txt 7 7 42 34 0.3448data7-7-42-04320.txt 7 7 42 36 0.1987data7-7-42-04321.txt 7 7 42 27 0.0074data7-7-42-04322.txt 7 7 42 40 0.5853data7-7-42-04323.txt 7 7 42 32 0.0991data7-7-42-04324.txt 7 7 42 45 0.8498data7-7-42-04325.txt 7 7 42 32 0.4482data7-7-42-04326.txt 7 7 42 38 0.5660data7-7-42-04327.txt 7 7 42 30 0.2440data7-7-42-04328.txt 7 7 42 35 0.2223data7-7-42-04329.txt 7 7 42 38 0.3398data7-7-42-04330.txt 7 7 42 42 0.4710

Table 139: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 345: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-7-42-04331.txt 7 7 42 32 0.0082data7-7-42-04332.txt 7 7 42 39 0.2667data7-7-42-04333.txt 7 7 42 37 0.2736data7-7-42-04334.txt 7 7 42 37 0.0796data7-7-42-04335.txt 7 7 42 35 0.1441data7-7-42-04336.txt 7 7 42 38 0.4490data7-7-42-04337.txt 7 7 42 32 0.2266data7-7-42-04338.txt 7 7 42 32 0.1010data7-7-42-04339.txt 7 7 42 45 0.2978data7-7-42-04340.txt 7 7 42 36 0.5656data7-7-42-04341.txt 7 7 42 42 0.2368data7-7-42-04342.txt 7 7 42 31 0.0139data7-7-42-04343.txt 7 7 42 30 0.0034data7-7-42-04344.txt 7 7 42 39 0.1332data7-7-42-04345.txt 7 7 42 37 0.1160data7-7-42-04346.txt 7 7 42 38 0.1916data7-7-42-04347.txt 7 7 42 31 0.4592data7-7-42-04348.txt 7 7 42 35 0.6280data7-7-42-04349.txt 7 7 42 37 0.1351data7-7-42-04350.txt 7 7 42 34 0.2576data7-7-42-04351.txt 7 7 42 38 0.5521data7-7-42-04352.txt 7 7 42 28 0.0342data7-7-42-04353.txt 7 7 42 33 0.0297data7-7-42-04354.txt 7 7 42 37 0.2154data7-7-42-04355.txt 7 7 42 34 0.3481data7-7-42-04356.txt 7 7 42 38 0.7506data7-7-42-04357.txt 7 7 42 35 0.1445data7-7-42-04358.txt 7 7 42 34 0.4717data7-7-42-04359.txt 7 7 42 35 0.4949data7-7-42-04360.txt 7 7 42 34 0.1029data7-7-42-04361.txt 7 7 42 36 0.2024data7-7-42-04362.txt 7 7 42 36 0.0184data7-7-42-04363.txt 7 7 42 33 0.0640data7-7-42-04364.txt 7 7 42 34 0.5997data7-7-42-04365.txt 7 7 42 33 0.5219data7-7-42-04366.txt 7 7 42 39 0.2119data7-7-42-04367.txt 7 7 42 31 0.0289data7-7-42-04368.txt 7 7 42 35 0.3453data7-7-42-04369.txt 7 7 42 41 0.4535data7-7-42-04370.txt 7 7 42 42 0.0796data7-7-42-04371.txt 7 7 42 40 0.4355data7-7-42-04372.txt 7 7 42 43 0.3676data7-7-42-04373.txt 7 7 42 33 0.1707data7-7-42-04374.txt 7 7 42 34 0.2530data7-7-42-04375.txt 7 7 42 41 0.4511data7-7-42-04376.txt 7 7 42 42 0.3229data7-7-42-04377.txt 7 7 42 29 0.0450data7-7-42-04378.txt 7 7 42 30 0.4355data7-7-42-04379.txt 7 7 42 44 0.5081data7-7-42-04380.txt 7 7 42 36 0.3935data7-7-42-04381.txt 7 7 42 29 0.2427data7-7-42-04382.txt 7 7 42 30 0.2710data7-7-42-04383.txt 7 7 42 32 0.0442data7-7-42-04384.txt 7 7 42 33 0.4064data7-7-42-04385.txt 7 7 42 31 0.2381data7-7-42-04386.txt 7 7 42 27 0.0325data7-7-42-04387.txt 7 7 42 40 0.4159data7-7-42-04388.txt 7 7 42 38 0.3008data7-7-42-04389.txt 7 7 42 34 0.2294data7-7-42-04390.txt 7 7 42 35 0.5529data7-7-42-04391.txt 7 7 42 40 0.2431data7-7-42-04392.txt 7 7 42 36 0.0180data7-7-42-04393.txt 7 7 42 34 0.2652data7-7-42-04394.txt 7 7 42 36 0.2760data7-7-42-04395.txt 7 7 42 47 0.4218data7-7-42-04396.txt 7 7 42 37 0.2300data7-7-42-04397.txt 7 7 42 40 0.2468data7-7-42-04398.txt 7 7 42 45 0.6041data7-7-42-04399.txt 7 7 42 31 0.3971data7-7-42-04400.txt 7 7 42 35 0.4479

Table 140: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 346: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-7-43-04401.txt 7 7 43 42 0.2308data7-7-43-04402.txt 7 7 43 32 0.2158data7-7-43-04403.txt 7 7 43 40 0.4430data7-7-43-04404.txt 7 7 43 40 0.5086data7-7-43-04405.txt 7 7 43 40 0.3113data7-7-43-04406.txt 7 7 43 39 0.3484data7-7-43-04407.txt 7 7 43 37 0.4482data7-7-43-04408.txt 7 7 43 46 0.1569data7-7-43-04409.txt 7 7 43 35 0.1474data7-7-43-04410.txt 7 7 43 36 0.2501data7-7-43-04411.txt 7 7 43 32 0.0026data7-7-43-04412.txt 7 7 43 39 0.3846data7-7-43-04413.txt 7 7 43 32 0.0110data7-7-43-04414.txt 7 7 43 33 0.1987data7-7-43-04415.txt 7 7 43 33 0.1039data7-7-43-04416.txt 7 7 43 30 0.6456data7-7-43-04417.txt 7 7 43 33 0.0589data7-7-43-04418.txt 7 7 43 34 0.0701data7-7-43-04419.txt 7 7 43 34 0.1019data7-7-43-04420.txt 7 7 43 36 0.2006data7-7-43-04421.txt 7 7 43 33 0.3199data7-7-43-04422.txt 7 7 43 29 0.0056data7-7-43-04423.txt 7 7 43 43 0.5158data7-7-43-04424.txt 7 7 43 39 0.0372data7-7-43-04425.txt 7 7 43 35 0.0792data7-7-43-04426.txt 7 7 43 40 0.0565data7-7-43-04427.txt 7 7 43 30 0.1273data7-7-43-04428.txt 7 7 43 36 0.1394data7-7-43-04429.txt 7 7 43 36 0.2766data7-7-43-04430.txt 7 7 43 37 0.2569data7-7-43-04431.txt 7 7 43 37 0.2882data7-7-43-04432.txt 7 7 43 46 0.0912data7-7-43-04433.txt 7 7 43 33 0.1502data7-7-43-04434.txt 7 7 43 42 0.6244data7-7-43-04435.txt 7 7 43 34 0.0241data7-7-43-04436.txt 7 7 43 36 0.2287data7-7-43-04437.txt 7 7 43 40 0.3143data7-7-43-04438.txt 7 7 43 36 0.1533data7-7-43-04439.txt 7 7 43 48 0.3272data7-7-43-04440.txt 7 7 43 42 0.2956data7-7-43-04441.txt 7 7 43 36 0.3469data7-7-43-04442.txt 7 7 43 38 0.2032data7-7-43-04443.txt 7 7 43 46 0.3156data7-7-43-04444.txt 7 7 43 36 0.4759data7-7-43-04445.txt 7 7 43 43 0.2124data7-7-43-04446.txt 7 7 43 38 0.4417data7-7-43-04447.txt 7 7 43 41 0.5710data7-7-43-04448.txt 7 7 43 32 0.5697data7-7-43-04449.txt 7 7 43 30 0.4839data7-7-43-04450.txt 7 7 43 38 0.3860data7-7-43-04451.txt 7 7 43 29 0.0945data7-7-43-04452.txt 7 7 43 37 0.2426data7-7-43-04453.txt 7 7 43 37 0.1978data7-7-43-04454.txt 7 7 43 39 0.3076data7-7-43-04455.txt 7 7 43 35 0.3531data7-7-43-04456.txt 7 7 43 46 0.3753data7-7-43-04457.txt 7 7 43 39 0.1925data7-7-43-04458.txt 7 7 43 41 0.3721data7-7-43-04459.txt 7 7 43 47 0.3029data7-7-43-04460.txt 7 7 43 37 0.2449data7-7-43-04461.txt 7 7 43 27 0.1767data7-7-43-04462.txt 7 7 43 31 0.0025data7-7-43-04463.txt 7 7 43 40 0.2718data7-7-43-04464.txt 7 7 43 37 0.0078data7-7-43-04465.txt 7 7 43 38 0.2313data7-7-43-04466.txt 7 7 43 33 0.0389data7-7-43-04467.txt 7 7 43 29 0.0027data7-7-43-04468.txt 7 7 43 35 0.1940data7-7-43-04469.txt 7 7 43 42 0.4811data7-7-43-04470.txt 7 7 43 46 0.5740

Table 141: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 347: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-7-43-04471.txt 7 7 43 32 0.3435data7-7-43-04472.txt 7 7 43 39 0.3440data7-7-43-04473.txt 7 7 43 34 0.2072data7-7-43-04474.txt 7 7 43 37 0.0136data7-7-43-04475.txt 7 7 43 31 0.0722data7-7-43-04476.txt 7 7 43 32 0.1733data7-7-43-04477.txt 7 7 43 36 0.3893data7-7-43-04478.txt 7 7 43 36 0.1485data7-7-43-04479.txt 7 7 43 42 0.1587data7-7-43-04480.txt 7 7 43 40 0.2171data7-7-43-04481.txt 7 7 43 34 0.0130data7-7-43-04482.txt 7 7 43 33 0.1236data7-7-43-04483.txt 7 7 43 45 0.1919data7-7-43-04484.txt 7 7 43 44 0.5928data7-7-43-04485.txt 7 7 43 37 0.4342data7-7-43-04486.txt 7 7 43 37 0.2146data7-7-43-04487.txt 7 7 43 34 0.2283data7-7-43-04488.txt 7 7 43 31 0.0258data7-7-43-04489.txt 7 7 43 44 0.2182data7-7-43-04490.txt 7 7 43 35 0.3188data7-7-43-04491.txt 7 7 43 38 0.3032data7-7-43-04492.txt 7 7 43 40 0.7508data7-7-43-04493.txt 7 7 43 44 0.4933data7-7-43-04494.txt 7 7 43 44 0.2534data7-7-43-04495.txt 7 7 43 36 0.2680data7-7-43-04496.txt 7 7 43 38 0.3804data7-7-43-04497.txt 7 7 43 41 0.4526data7-7-43-04498.txt 7 7 43 41 0.2044data7-7-43-04499.txt 7 7 43 39 0.3083data7-7-43-04500.txt 7 7 43 50 0.7979data7-7-44-04501.txt 7 7 44 51 0.2300data7-7-44-04502.txt 7 7 44 40 0.1015data7-7-44-04503.txt 7 7 44 38 0.4046data7-7-44-04504.txt 7 7 44 34 0.0636data7-7-44-04505.txt 7 7 44 29 0.0045data7-7-44-04506.txt 7 7 44 40 0.4992data7-7-44-04507.txt 7 7 44 47 0.2600data7-7-44-04508.txt 7 7 44 38 0.0370data7-7-44-04509.txt 7 7 44 44 0.4794data7-7-44-04510.txt 7 7 44 45 0.0561data7-7-44-04511.txt 7 7 44 44 0.1828data7-7-44-04512.txt 7 7 44 41 0.2586data7-7-44-04513.txt 7 7 44 39 0.1074data7-7-44-04514.txt 7 7 44 39 0.0695data7-7-44-04515.txt 7 7 44 43 0.2139data7-7-44-04516.txt 7 7 44 35 0.1965data7-7-44-04517.txt 7 7 44 43 0.1316data7-7-44-04518.txt 7 7 44 40 0.1087data7-7-44-04519.txt 7 7 44 46 0.5073data7-7-44-04520.txt 7 7 44 38 0.1406data7-7-44-04521.txt 7 7 44 46 0.6577data7-7-44-04522.txt 7 7 44 37 0.3672data7-7-44-04523.txt 7 7 44 42 0.2074data7-7-44-04524.txt 7 7 44 38 0.4696data7-7-44-04525.txt 7 7 44 50 0.3588data7-7-44-04526.txt 7 7 44 42 0.0421data7-7-44-04527.txt 7 7 44 43 0.1707data7-7-44-04528.txt 7 7 44 46 0.4570data7-7-44-04529.txt 7 7 44 40 0.0586data7-7-44-04530.txt 7 7 44 35 0.1253data7-7-44-04531.txt 7 7 44 41 0.3090data7-7-44-04532.txt 7 7 44 39 0.2579data7-7-44-04533.txt 7 7 44 37 0.0164data7-7-44-04534.txt 7 7 44 34 0.2767data7-7-44-04535.txt 7 7 44 54 0.4061data7-7-44-04536.txt 7 7 44 37 0.2542data7-7-44-04537.txt 7 7 44 37 0.1351data7-7-44-04538.txt 7 7 44 44 0.3479data7-7-44-04539.txt 7 7 44 49 0.3953data7-7-44-04540.txt 7 7 44 40 0.1968

Table 142: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 348: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-7-44-04541.txt 7 7 44 38 0.0923data7-7-44-04542.txt 7 7 44 40 0.0525data7-7-44-04543.txt 7 7 44 40 0.1512data7-7-44-04544.txt 7 7 44 41 0.3640data7-7-44-04545.txt 7 7 44 38 0.2383data7-7-44-04546.txt 7 7 44 39 0.2414data7-7-44-04547.txt 7 7 44 41 0.2199data7-7-44-04548.txt 7 7 44 40 0.7468data7-7-44-04549.txt 7 7 44 43 0.4924data7-7-44-04550.txt 7 7 44 42 0.5062data7-7-44-04551.txt 7 7 44 42 0.2971data7-7-44-04552.txt 7 7 44 31 0.0421data7-7-44-04553.txt 7 7 44 42 0.6738data7-7-44-04554.txt 7 7 44 47 0.4900data7-7-44-04555.txt 7 7 44 37 0.0163data7-7-44-04556.txt 7 7 44 41 0.1594data7-7-44-04557.txt 7 7 44 43 0.2112data7-7-44-04558.txt 7 7 44 49 0.6210data7-7-44-04559.txt 7 7 44 41 0.4469data7-7-44-04560.txt 7 7 44 47 0.3172data7-7-44-04561.txt 7 7 44 44 0.2636data7-7-44-04562.txt 7 7 44 31 0.2644data7-7-44-04563.txt 7 7 44 46 0.0928data7-7-44-04564.txt 7 7 44 41 0.2276data7-7-44-04565.txt 7 7 44 35 0.0049data7-7-44-04566.txt 7 7 44 46 0.2910data7-7-44-04567.txt 7 7 44 44 0.4567data7-7-44-04568.txt 7 7 44 32 0.3830data7-7-44-04569.txt 7 7 44 38 0.2321data7-7-44-04570.txt 7 7 44 38 0.1317data7-7-44-04571.txt 7 7 44 48 0.6716data7-7-44-04572.txt 7 7 44 45 0.3465data7-7-44-04573.txt 7 7 44 42 0.2077data7-7-44-04574.txt 7 7 44 47 0.1985data7-7-44-04575.txt 7 7 44 47 0.4117data7-7-44-04576.txt 7 7 44 42 0.9517data7-7-44-04577.txt 7 7 44 41 0.5094data7-7-44-04578.txt 7 7 44 38 0.5487data7-7-44-04579.txt 7 7 44 43 0.1645data7-7-44-04580.txt 7 7 44 35 0.2818data7-7-44-04581.txt 7 7 44 45 0.3301data7-7-44-04582.txt 7 7 44 42 0.4671data7-7-44-04583.txt 7 7 44 40 0.0031data7-7-44-04584.txt 7 7 44 38 0.3140data7-7-44-04585.txt 7 7 44 38 0.1707data7-7-44-04586.txt 7 7 44 43 0.5305data7-7-44-04587.txt 7 7 44 39 0.0076data7-7-44-04588.txt 7 7 44 46 0.4365data7-7-44-04589.txt 7 7 44 45 0.5317data7-7-44-04590.txt 7 7 44 45 0.3127data7-7-44-04591.txt 7 7 44 38 0.4976data7-7-44-04592.txt 7 7 44 40 0.2214data7-7-44-04593.txt 7 7 44 43 0.6514data7-7-44-04594.txt 7 7 44 43 0.2175data7-7-44-04595.txt 7 7 44 35 0.3870data7-7-44-04596.txt 7 7 44 41 0.2434data7-7-44-04597.txt 7 7 44 42 0.7092data7-7-44-04598.txt 7 7 44 40 0.2143data7-7-44-04599.txt 7 7 44 37 0.3345data7-7-44-04600.txt 7 7 44 38 0.2438data7-7-45-04601.txt 7 7 45 41 0.4616data7-7-45-04602.txt 7 7 45 37 0.0544data7-7-45-04603.txt 7 7 45 41 0.0533data7-7-45-04604.txt 7 7 45 47 0.1184data7-7-45-04605.txt 7 7 45 50 0.2510data7-7-45-04606.txt 7 7 45 52 0.4032data7-7-45-04607.txt 7 7 45 39 0.0933data7-7-45-04608.txt 7 7 45 34 0.2874data7-7-45-04609.txt 7 7 45 48 0.4592data7-7-45-04610.txt 7 7 45 36 0.0102

Table 143: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 349: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-7-45-04611.txt 7 7 45 37 0.1228data7-7-45-04612.txt 7 7 45 44 0.0872data7-7-45-04613.txt 7 7 45 44 0.4997data7-7-45-04614.txt 7 7 45 37 0.0615data7-7-45-04615.txt 7 7 45 44 0.3482data7-7-45-04616.txt 7 7 45 45 0.6422data7-7-45-04617.txt 7 7 45 34 0.0035data7-7-45-04618.txt 7 7 45 42 0.1941data7-7-45-04619.txt 7 7 45 47 0.5682data7-7-45-04620.txt 7 7 45 38 0.1835data7-7-45-04621.txt 7 7 45 42 0.4780data7-7-45-04622.txt 7 7 45 39 0.1493data7-7-45-04623.txt 7 7 45 43 0.2767data7-7-45-04624.txt 7 7 45 47 0.1087data7-7-45-04625.txt 7 7 45 53 0.4447data7-7-45-04626.txt 7 7 45 40 0.4768data7-7-45-04627.txt 7 7 45 46 0.2841data7-7-45-04628.txt 7 7 45 45 0.4026data7-7-45-04629.txt 7 7 45 40 0.3424data7-7-45-04630.txt 7 7 45 41 0.3078data7-7-45-04631.txt 7 7 45 40 0.0417data7-7-45-04632.txt 7 7 45 44 0.3543data7-7-45-04633.txt 7 7 45 42 0.3706data7-7-45-04634.txt 7 7 45 35 0.3077data7-7-45-04635.txt 7 7 45 39 0.2330data7-7-45-04636.txt 7 7 45 43 0.0973data7-7-45-04637.txt 7 7 45 40 0.2073data7-7-45-04638.txt 7 7 45 41 0.4654data7-7-45-04639.txt 7 7 45 36 0.5811data7-7-45-04640.txt 7 7 45 43 0.1510data7-7-45-04641.txt 7 7 45 48 0.3037data7-7-45-04642.txt 7 7 45 46 0.6162data7-7-45-04643.txt 7 7 45 35 0.1604data7-7-45-04644.txt 7 7 45 49 0.4359data7-7-45-04645.txt 7 7 45 43 0.5343data7-7-45-04646.txt 7 7 45 33 0.1235data7-7-45-04647.txt 7 7 45 46 0.5131data7-7-45-04648.txt 7 7 45 34 0.0121data7-7-45-04649.txt 7 7 45 40 0.1446data7-7-45-04650.txt 7 7 45 44 0.1528data7-7-45-04651.txt 7 7 45 41 0.0989data7-7-45-04652.txt 7 7 45 44 0.4563data7-7-45-04653.txt 7 7 45 44 0.0543data7-7-45-04654.txt 7 7 45 40 0.2684data7-7-45-04655.txt 7 7 45 44 0.0258data7-7-45-04656.txt 7 7 45 39 0.0312data7-7-45-04657.txt 7 7 45 39 0.1740data7-7-45-04658.txt 7 7 45 34 0.1536data7-7-45-04659.txt 7 7 45 42 0.2079data7-7-45-04660.txt 7 7 45 43 0.2607data7-7-45-04661.txt 7 7 45 37 0.2046data7-7-45-04662.txt 7 7 45 52 0.3754data7-7-45-04663.txt 7 7 45 42 0.1982data7-7-45-04664.txt 7 7 45 33 0.1322data7-7-45-04665.txt 7 7 45 43 0.4616data7-7-45-04666.txt 7 7 45 42 0.1767data7-7-45-04667.txt 7 7 45 35 0.3313data7-7-45-04668.txt 7 7 45 45 0.2631data7-7-45-04669.txt 7 7 45 39 0.5213data7-7-45-04670.txt 7 7 45 34 0.2540data7-7-45-04671.txt 7 7 45 42 0.1678data7-7-45-04672.txt 7 7 45 46 0.4797data7-7-45-04673.txt 7 7 45 45 0.5535data7-7-45-04674.txt 7 7 45 45 0.0627data7-7-45-04675.txt 7 7 45 38 0.6248data7-7-45-04676.txt 7 7 45 49 0.2541data7-7-45-04677.txt 7 7 45 45 0.3049data7-7-45-04678.txt 7 7 45 43 0.4840data7-7-45-04679.txt 7 7 45 35 0.0033data7-7-45-04680.txt 7 7 45 41 0.2006

Table 144: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 350: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-7-45-04681.txt 7 7 45 49 0.0508data7-7-45-04682.txt 7 7 45 38 0.4217data7-7-45-04683.txt 7 7 45 38 0.0031data7-7-45-04684.txt 7 7 45 51 0.3904data7-7-45-04685.txt 7 7 45 41 0.4448data7-7-45-04686.txt 7 7 45 41 0.1916data7-7-45-04687.txt 7 7 45 37 0.1520data7-7-45-04688.txt 7 7 45 37 0.2976data7-7-45-04689.txt 7 7 45 48 0.3223data7-7-45-04690.txt 7 7 45 41 0.1892data7-7-45-04691.txt 7 7 45 44 0.1807data7-7-45-04692.txt 7 7 45 39 0.3359data7-7-45-04693.txt 7 7 45 31 0.1226data7-7-45-04694.txt 7 7 45 51 0.1392data7-7-45-04695.txt 7 7 45 40 0.0958data7-7-45-04696.txt 7 7 45 44 0.4432data7-7-45-04697.txt 7 7 45 40 0.1394data7-7-45-04698.txt 7 7 45 46 0.3358data7-7-45-04699.txt 7 7 45 43 0.2695data7-7-45-04700.txt 7 7 45 50 0.2307data7-7-46-04701.txt 7 7 46 41 0.1658data7-7-46-04702.txt 7 7 46 51 0.1302data7-7-46-04703.txt 7 7 46 44 0.1975data7-7-46-04704.txt 7 7 46 33 0.0047data7-7-46-04705.txt 7 7 46 34 0.2832data7-7-46-04706.txt 7 7 46 43 0.2130data7-7-46-04707.txt 7 7 46 45 0.3973data7-7-46-04708.txt 7 7 46 32 0.0612data7-7-46-04709.txt 7 7 46 36 0.3292data7-7-46-04710.txt 7 7 46 44 0.6587data7-7-46-04711.txt 7 7 46 33 0.1948data7-7-46-04712.txt 7 7 46 48 0.6042data7-7-46-04713.txt 7 7 46 51 0.1070data7-7-46-04714.txt 7 7 46 39 0.4084data7-7-46-04715.txt 7 7 46 38 0.1919data7-7-46-04716.txt 7 7 46 43 0.2869data7-7-46-04717.txt 7 7 46 39 0.0238data7-7-46-04718.txt 7 7 46 40 0.0659data7-7-46-04719.txt 7 7 46 46 0.1996data7-7-46-04720.txt 7 7 46 38 0.4159data7-7-46-04721.txt 7 7 46 47 0.7062data7-7-46-04722.txt 7 7 46 40 0.4655data7-7-46-04723.txt 7 7 46 44 0.3719data7-7-46-04724.txt 7 7 46 47 0.1545data7-7-46-04725.txt 7 7 46 37 0.1661data7-7-46-04726.txt 7 7 46 48 0.5217data7-7-46-04727.txt 7 7 46 46 0.3082data7-7-46-04728.txt 7 7 46 49 0.2655data7-7-46-04729.txt 7 7 46 41 0.0137data7-7-46-04730.txt 7 7 46 40 0.1150data7-7-46-04731.txt 7 7 46 46 0.3924data7-7-46-04732.txt 7 7 46 37 0.2645data7-7-46-04733.txt 7 7 46 40 0.0467data7-7-46-04734.txt 7 7 46 41 0.0102data7-7-46-04735.txt 7 7 46 57 0.4701data7-7-46-04736.txt 7 7 46 41 0.1660data7-7-46-04737.txt 7 7 46 47 0.1556data7-7-46-04738.txt 7 7 46 40 0.0200data7-7-46-04739.txt 7 7 46 60 0.3122data7-7-46-04740.txt 7 7 46 39 0.1219data7-7-46-04741.txt 7 7 46 39 0.1597data7-7-46-04742.txt 7 7 46 39 0.0068data7-7-46-04743.txt 7 7 46 40 0.2943data7-7-46-04744.txt 7 7 46 32 0.3369data7-7-46-04745.txt 7 7 46 41 0.2001data7-7-46-04746.txt 7 7 46 54 0.3246data7-7-46-04747.txt 7 7 46 47 0.3701data7-7-46-04748.txt 7 7 46 45 0.5016data7-7-46-04749.txt 7 7 46 50 0.7636data7-7-46-04750.txt 7 7 46 37 0.0472

Table 145: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 351: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-7-46-04751.txt 7 7 46 34 0.2207data7-7-46-04752.txt 7 7 46 38 0.1279data7-7-46-04753.txt 7 7 46 39 0.1503data7-7-46-04754.txt 7 7 46 45 0.4269data7-7-46-04755.txt 7 7 46 35 0.0043data7-7-46-04756.txt 7 7 46 58 0.3420data7-7-46-04757.txt 7 7 46 54 0.2928data7-7-46-04758.txt 7 7 46 47 0.2604data7-7-46-04759.txt 7 7 46 42 0.2166data7-7-46-04760.txt 7 7 46 45 0.0156data7-7-46-04761.txt 7 7 46 39 0.1175data7-7-46-04762.txt 7 7 46 39 0.1046data7-7-46-04763.txt 7 7 46 44 0.1339data7-7-46-04764.txt 7 7 46 36 0.4686data7-7-46-04765.txt 7 7 46 34 0.2115data7-7-46-04766.txt 7 7 46 52 0.3459data7-7-46-04767.txt 7 7 46 47 0.2175data7-7-46-04768.txt 7 7 46 53 0.2914data7-7-46-04769.txt 7 7 46 44 0.1436data7-7-46-04770.txt 7 7 46 24 0.0130data7-7-46-04771.txt 7 7 46 52 0.4631data7-7-46-04772.txt 7 7 46 29 0.0058data7-7-46-04773.txt 7 7 46 45 0.3910data7-7-46-04774.txt 7 7 46 41 0.4210data7-7-46-04775.txt 7 7 46 43 0.2881data7-7-46-04776.txt 7 7 46 45 0.2383data7-7-46-04777.txt 7 7 46 42 0.1943data7-7-46-04778.txt 7 7 46 37 0.1515data7-7-46-04779.txt 7 7 46 45 0.5344data7-7-46-04780.txt 7 7 46 38 0.1662data7-7-46-04781.txt 7 7 46 48 0.8447data7-7-46-04782.txt 7 7 46 47 0.2238data7-7-46-04783.txt 7 7 46 45 0.3647data7-7-46-04784.txt 7 7 46 35 0.0761data7-7-46-04785.txt 7 7 46 46 0.1718data7-7-46-04786.txt 7 7 46 44 0.2256data7-7-46-04787.txt 7 7 46 30 0.0038data7-7-46-04788.txt 7 7 46 49 0.2848data7-7-46-04789.txt 7 7 46 54 0.4110data7-7-46-04790.txt 7 7 46 45 0.3236data7-7-46-04791.txt 7 7 46 42 0.0766data7-7-46-04792.txt 7 7 46 42 0.0701data7-7-46-04793.txt 7 7 46 38 0.2532data7-7-46-04794.txt 7 7 46 42 0.1192data7-7-46-04795.txt 7 7 46 41 0.1885data7-7-46-04796.txt 7 7 46 38 0.3111data7-7-46-04797.txt 7 7 46 30 0.0986data7-7-46-04798.txt 7 7 46 35 0.0392data7-7-46-04799.txt 7 7 46 42 0.3906data7-7-46-04800.txt 7 7 46 34 0.7692data7-7-47-04801.txt 7 7 47 44 0.6727data7-7-47-04802.txt 7 7 47 40 0.1728data7-7-47-04803.txt 7 7 47 44 0.2268data7-7-47-04804.txt 7 7 47 46 0.0236data7-7-47-04805.txt 7 7 47 51 0.0354data7-7-47-04806.txt 7 7 47 49 0.7807data7-7-47-04807.txt 7 7 47 51 0.3219data7-7-47-04808.txt 7 7 47 51 0.4843data7-7-47-04809.txt 7 7 47 45 0.1561data7-7-47-04810.txt 7 7 47 51 0.3758data7-7-47-04811.txt 7 7 47 37 0.3381data7-7-47-04812.txt 7 7 47 32 0.1787data7-7-47-04813.txt 7 7 47 47 0.1334data7-7-47-04814.txt 7 7 47 44 0.3801data7-7-47-04815.txt 7 7 47 49 0.1699data7-7-47-04816.txt 7 7 47 50 0.5383data7-7-47-04817.txt 7 7 47 40 0.3269data7-7-47-04818.txt 7 7 47 48 0.4922data7-7-47-04819.txt 7 7 47 46 0.2370data7-7-47-04820.txt 7 7 47 42 0.0630

Table 146: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 352: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-7-47-04821.txt 7 7 47 43 0.3475data7-7-47-04822.txt 7 7 47 36 0.0247data7-7-47-04823.txt 7 7 47 37 0.1499data7-7-47-04824.txt 7 7 47 58 0.3637data7-7-47-04825.txt 7 7 47 47 0.2385data7-7-47-04826.txt 7 7 47 45 0.1000data7-7-47-04827.txt 7 7 47 48 0.7543data7-7-47-04828.txt 7 7 47 46 0.0830data7-7-47-04829.txt 7 7 47 43 0.3061data7-7-47-04830.txt 7 7 47 42 0.2951data7-7-47-04831.txt 7 7 47 32 0.1321data7-7-47-04832.txt 7 7 47 43 0.1734data7-7-47-04833.txt 7 7 47 51 0.3051data7-7-47-04834.txt 7 7 47 47 0.3777data7-7-47-04835.txt 7 7 47 43 0.2210data7-7-47-04836.txt 7 7 47 35 0.2472data7-7-47-04837.txt 7 7 47 40 0.2262data7-7-47-04838.txt 7 7 47 44 0.1650data7-7-47-04839.txt 7 7 47 51 0.3887data7-7-47-04840.txt 7 7 47 41 0.1521data7-7-47-04841.txt 7 7 47 38 0.1581data7-7-47-04842.txt 7 7 47 46 0.3546data7-7-47-04843.txt 7 7 47 45 1.0281data7-7-47-04844.txt 7 7 47 46 0.0033data7-7-47-04845.txt 7 7 47 51 0.0839data7-7-47-04846.txt 7 7 47 46 0.4280data7-7-47-04847.txt 7 7 47 41 0.0934data7-7-47-04848.txt 7 7 47 46 0.2144data7-7-47-04849.txt 7 7 47 53 0.2407data7-7-47-04850.txt 7 7 47 44 0.2626data7-7-47-04851.txt 7 7 47 50 0.6324data7-7-47-04852.txt 7 7 47 49 0.3391data7-7-47-04853.txt 7 7 47 50 0.6131data7-7-47-04854.txt 7 7 47 45 0.2321data7-7-47-04855.txt 7 7 47 42 0.3080data7-7-47-04856.txt 7 7 47 43 0.2358data7-7-47-04857.txt 7 7 47 53 0.3728data7-7-47-04858.txt 7 7 47 44 0.1138data7-7-47-04859.txt 7 7 47 39 0.0070data7-7-47-04860.txt 7 7 47 40 0.1039data7-7-47-04861.txt 7 7 47 39 0.1414data7-7-47-04862.txt 7 7 47 50 0.1641data7-7-47-04863.txt 7 7 47 43 0.5862data7-7-47-04864.txt 7 7 47 36 0.2896data7-7-47-04865.txt 7 7 47 40 0.1831data7-7-47-04866.txt 7 7 47 38 0.0775data7-7-47-04867.txt 7 7 47 40 0.0391data7-7-47-04868.txt 7 7 47 44 0.5262data7-7-47-04869.txt 7 7 47 50 0.2346data7-7-47-04870.txt 7 7 47 44 0.2731data7-7-47-04871.txt 7 7 47 58 0.5780data7-7-47-04872.txt 7 7 47 36 0.1246data7-7-47-04873.txt 7 7 47 43 0.1369data7-7-47-04874.txt 7 7 47 51 0.1877data7-7-47-04875.txt 7 7 47 52 0.0948data7-7-47-04876.txt 7 7 47 48 1.0302data7-7-47-04877.txt 7 7 47 56 0.3639data7-7-47-04878.txt 7 7 47 49 0.3494data7-7-47-04879.txt 7 7 47 44 0.2475data7-7-47-04880.txt 7 7 47 50 0.2701data7-7-47-04881.txt 7 7 47 50 0.1887data7-7-47-04882.txt 7 7 47 42 0.6716data7-7-47-04883.txt 7 7 47 45 0.6280data7-7-47-04884.txt 7 7 47 38 0.5199data7-7-47-04885.txt 7 7 47 43 0.2842data7-7-47-04886.txt 7 7 47 48 0.2046data7-7-47-04887.txt 7 7 47 53 0.2271data7-7-47-04888.txt 7 7 47 53 0.5390data7-7-47-04889.txt 7 7 47 52 0.2614data7-7-47-04890.txt 7 7 47 44 0.1452

Table 147: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 353: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-7-47-04891.txt 7 7 47 48 0.6690data7-7-47-04892.txt 7 7 47 40 0.3013data7-7-47-04893.txt 7 7 47 47 0.2753data7-7-47-04894.txt 7 7 47 59 0.7144data7-7-47-04895.txt 7 7 47 39 0.4746data7-7-47-04896.txt 7 7 47 41 0.2359data7-7-47-04897.txt 7 7 47 42 0.3405data7-7-47-04898.txt 7 7 47 41 0.1991data7-7-47-04899.txt 7 7 47 40 0.1990data7-7-47-04900.txt 7 7 47 42 0.7921data7-7-48-04901.txt 7 7 48 52 0.0354data7-7-48-04902.txt 7 7 48 55 0.1318data7-7-48-04903.txt 7 7 48 48 0.2405data7-7-48-04904.txt 7 7 48 44 0.1983data7-7-48-04905.txt 7 7 48 45 0.1565data7-7-48-04906.txt 7 7 48 43 0.1849data7-7-48-04907.txt 7 7 48 48 0.2111data7-7-48-04908.txt 7 7 48 42 0.3426data7-7-48-04909.txt 7 7 48 53 0.4041data7-7-48-04910.txt 7 7 48 41 0.0916data7-7-48-04911.txt 7 7 48 44 0.0523data7-7-48-04912.txt 7 7 48 45 0.1791data7-7-48-04913.txt 7 7 48 46 0.1139data7-7-48-04914.txt 7 7 48 50 0.3158data7-7-48-04915.txt 7 7 48 39 0.2628data7-7-48-04916.txt 7 7 48 44 0.5090data7-7-48-04917.txt 7 7 48 40 0.5686data7-7-48-04918.txt 7 7 48 43 0.3378data7-7-48-04919.txt 7 7 48 45 0.1112data7-7-48-04920.txt 7 7 48 44 0.2174data7-7-48-04921.txt 7 7 48 50 0.3643data7-7-48-04922.txt 7 7 48 45 0.1892data7-7-48-04923.txt 7 7 48 44 0.2729data7-7-48-04924.txt 7 7 48 55 0.4244data7-7-48-04925.txt 7 7 48 38 0.3965data7-7-48-04926.txt 7 7 48 54 0.4688data7-7-48-04927.txt 7 7 48 40 0.1034data7-7-48-04928.txt 7 7 48 43 0.4642data7-7-48-04929.txt 7 7 48 41 0.1564data7-7-48-04930.txt 7 7 48 43 0.1320data7-7-48-04931.txt 7 7 48 39 0.3353data7-7-48-04932.txt 7 7 48 50 0.2380data7-7-48-04933.txt 7 7 48 52 0.1425data7-7-48-04934.txt 7 7 48 51 0.2416data7-7-48-04935.txt 7 7 48 49 0.1546data7-7-48-04936.txt 7 7 48 48 0.7482data7-7-48-04937.txt 7 7 48 37 0.2480data7-7-48-04938.txt 7 7 48 40 0.1223data7-7-48-04939.txt 7 7 48 45 0.1489data7-7-48-04940.txt 7 7 48 38 0.1623data7-7-48-04941.txt 7 7 48 49 0.5402data7-7-48-04942.txt 7 7 48 46 0.3457data7-7-48-04943.txt 7 7 48 45 0.3230data7-7-48-04944.txt 7 7 48 53 0.6472data7-7-48-04945.txt 7 7 48 46 0.2213data7-7-48-04946.txt 7 7 48 49 0.0855data7-7-48-04947.txt 7 7 48 40 0.3943data7-7-48-04948.txt 7 7 48 43 0.2235data7-7-48-04949.txt 7 7 48 46 0.0719data7-7-48-04950.txt 7 7 48 43 0.2360data7-7-48-04951.txt 7 7 48 40 0.0309data7-7-48-04952.txt 7 7 48 47 0.3027data7-7-48-04953.txt 7 7 48 45 0.2980data7-7-48-04954.txt 7 7 48 32 0.0551data7-7-48-04955.txt 7 7 48 38 0.1001data7-7-48-04956.txt 7 7 48 46 0.3527data7-7-48-04957.txt 7 7 48 35 0.0704data7-7-48-04958.txt 7 7 48 49 0.2463data7-7-48-04959.txt 7 7 48 49 0.2601data7-7-48-04960.txt 7 7 48 42 0.3509

Table 148: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 354: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-7-48-04961.txt 7 7 48 54 0.3580data7-7-48-04962.txt 7 7 48 40 0.2858data7-7-48-04963.txt 7 7 48 41 0.0207data7-7-48-04964.txt 7 7 48 44 0.4913data7-7-48-04965.txt 7 7 48 37 0.0063data7-7-48-04966.txt 7 7 48 36 0.0035data7-7-48-04967.txt 7 7 48 40 0.0707data7-7-48-04968.txt 7 7 48 51 0.3015data7-7-48-04969.txt 7 7 48 50 0.1210data7-7-48-04970.txt 7 7 48 53 0.3463data7-7-48-04971.txt 7 7 48 39 0.2740data7-7-48-04972.txt 7 7 48 37 0.3157data7-7-48-04973.txt 7 7 48 53 0.7725data7-7-48-04974.txt 7 7 48 55 0.2372data7-7-48-04975.txt 7 7 48 61 0.3017data7-7-48-04976.txt 7 7 48 43 0.3811data7-7-48-04977.txt 7 7 48 50 0.2098data7-7-48-04978.txt 7 7 48 45 0.1118data7-7-48-04979.txt 7 7 48 43 0.4865data7-7-48-04980.txt 7 7 48 44 0.0939data7-7-48-04981.txt 7 7 48 49 0.3414data7-7-48-04982.txt 7 7 48 58 0.3324data7-7-48-04983.txt 7 7 48 42 0.4449data7-7-48-04984.txt 7 7 48 43 0.2092data7-7-48-04985.txt 7 7 48 50 0.0445data7-7-48-04986.txt 7 7 48 42 0.0091data7-7-48-04987.txt 7 7 48 44 0.2465data7-7-48-04988.txt 7 7 48 39 0.1532data7-7-48-04989.txt 7 7 48 40 0.1883data7-7-48-04990.txt 7 7 48 46 0.2650data7-7-48-04991.txt 7 7 48 33 0.1788data7-7-48-04992.txt 7 7 48 39 0.2758data7-7-48-04993.txt 7 7 48 43 0.1206data7-7-48-04994.txt 7 7 48 43 0.2076data7-7-48-04995.txt 7 7 48 53 0.3752data7-7-48-04996.txt 7 7 48 44 0.3957data7-7-48-04997.txt 7 7 48 51 0.5727data7-7-48-04998.txt 7 7 48 42 0.2524data7-7-48-04999.txt 7 7 48 43 0.2479data7-7-48-05000.txt 7 7 48 42 0.0493data7-8-49-06801.txt 8 7 49 46 1.0066data7-8-49-06802.txt 8 7 49 46 0.3539data7-8-49-06803.txt 8 7 49 40 0.3774data7-8-49-06804.txt 8 7 49 28 0.4673data7-8-49-06805.txt 8 7 49 41 0.3788data7-8-49-06806.txt 8 7 49 39 0.5324data7-8-49-06807.txt 8 7 49 37 0.0051data7-8-49-06808.txt 8 7 49 41 0.2918data7-8-49-06809.txt 8 7 49 46 0.7591data7-8-49-06810.txt 8 7 49 38 0.0508data7-8-49-06811.txt 8 7 49 38 0.2832data7-8-49-06812.txt 8 7 49 40 0.3691data7-8-49-06813.txt 8 7 49 43 0.4859data7-8-49-06814.txt 8 7 49 41 0.1132data7-8-49-06815.txt 8 7 49 40 0.0777data7-8-49-06816.txt 8 7 49 42 1.0199data7-8-49-06817.txt 8 7 49 38 0.1634data7-8-49-06818.txt 8 7 49 42 0.8287data7-8-49-06819.txt 8 7 49 49 0.1786data7-8-49-06820.txt 8 7 49 37 0.3093data7-8-49-06821.txt 8 7 49 47 0.4874data7-8-49-06822.txt 8 7 49 40 0.8065data7-8-49-06823.txt 8 7 49 42 0.3531data7-8-49-06824.txt 8 7 49 44 0.3447data7-8-49-06825.txt 8 7 49 35 0.1935data7-8-49-06826.txt 8 7 49 40 0.2851data7-8-49-06827.txt 8 7 49 44 0.6098data7-8-49-06828.txt 8 7 49 43 0.3191data7-8-49-06829.txt 8 7 49 39 0.2728data7-8-49-06830.txt 8 7 49 49 0.4568

Table 149: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 355: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-8-49-06831.txt 8 7 49 37 0.6075data7-8-49-06832.txt 8 7 49 35 0.0553data7-8-49-06833.txt 8 7 49 48 0.4027data7-8-49-06834.txt 8 7 49 40 0.3636data7-8-49-06835.txt 8 7 49 39 0.0843data7-8-49-06836.txt 8 7 49 43 0.2921data7-8-49-06837.txt 8 7 49 46 0.2171data7-8-49-06838.txt 8 7 49 38 0.3266data7-8-49-06839.txt 8 7 49 40 0.3513data7-8-49-06840.txt 8 7 49 41 0.2980data7-8-49-06841.txt 8 7 49 36 0.1437data7-8-49-06842.txt 8 7 49 38 0.1947data7-8-49-06843.txt 8 7 49 44 0.6196data7-8-49-06844.txt 8 7 49 43 0.7372data7-8-49-06845.txt 8 7 49 45 0.4785data7-8-49-06846.txt 8 7 49 47 0.0252data7-8-49-06847.txt 8 7 49 32 0.0809data7-8-49-06848.txt 8 7 49 44 1.0424data7-8-49-06849.txt 8 7 49 42 1.0458data7-8-49-06850.txt 8 7 49 34 0.3559data7-8-49-06851.txt 8 7 49 38 0.7045data7-8-49-06852.txt 8 7 49 52 1.0206data7-8-49-06853.txt 8 7 49 35 0.4236data7-8-49-06854.txt 8 7 49 42 0.1821data7-8-49-06855.txt 8 7 49 39 0.1854data7-8-49-06856.txt 8 7 49 46 1.0423data7-8-49-06857.txt 8 7 49 36 0.0972data7-8-49-06858.txt 8 7 49 44 0.7129data7-8-49-06859.txt 8 7 49 39 0.5848data7-8-49-06860.txt 8 7 49 41 0.7077data7-8-49-06861.txt 8 7 49 41 0.8542data7-8-49-06862.txt 8 7 49 42 0.4943data7-8-49-06863.txt 8 7 49 44 0.4373data7-8-49-06864.txt 8 7 49 36 0.3879data7-8-49-06865.txt 8 7 49 43 0.3031data7-8-49-06866.txt 8 7 49 43 0.3097data7-8-49-06867.txt 8 7 49 35 0.0035data7-8-49-06868.txt 8 7 49 44 0.5181data7-8-49-06869.txt 8 7 49 41 0.4804data7-8-49-06870.txt 8 7 49 35 0.2620data7-8-49-06871.txt 8 7 49 40 0.4215data7-8-49-06872.txt 8 7 49 37 0.4371data7-8-49-06873.txt 8 7 49 39 0.3057data7-8-49-06874.txt 8 7 49 36 0.3109data7-8-49-06875.txt 8 7 49 43 0.3086data7-8-49-06876.txt 8 7 49 44 0.4305data7-8-49-06877.txt 8 7 49 42 0.1820data7-8-49-06878.txt 8 7 49 37 0.4973data7-8-49-06879.txt 8 7 49 36 0.0315data7-8-49-06880.txt 8 7 49 44 0.5544data7-8-49-06881.txt 8 7 49 40 0.5326data7-8-49-06882.txt 8 7 49 46 0.5092data7-8-49-06883.txt 8 7 49 41 0.2484data7-8-49-06884.txt 8 7 49 43 0.9185data7-8-49-06885.txt 8 7 49 34 0.5063data7-8-49-06886.txt 8 7 49 44 0.3313data7-8-49-06887.txt 8 7 49 40 0.1882data7-8-49-06888.txt 8 7 49 44 0.2745data7-8-49-06889.txt 8 7 49 46 0.2716data7-8-49-06890.txt 8 7 49 43 0.4969data7-8-49-06891.txt 8 7 49 39 0.2380data7-8-49-06892.txt 8 7 49 49 0.6839data7-8-49-06893.txt 8 7 49 48 0.3271data7-8-49-06894.txt 8 7 49 40 0.1695data7-8-49-06895.txt 8 7 49 45 0.4723data7-8-49-06896.txt 8 7 49 44 0.4688data7-8-49-06897.txt 8 7 49 43 0.4351data7-8-49-06898.txt 8 7 49 46 0.0031data7-8-49-06899.txt 8 7 49 46 0.1401data7-8-49-06900.txt 8 7 49 37 0.1223

Table 150: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 356: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-8-50-06901.txt 8 7 50 54 0.6520data7-8-50-06902.txt 8 7 50 42 0.6946data7-8-50-06903.txt 8 7 50 44 0.7950data7-8-50-06904.txt 8 7 50 47 0.9132data7-8-50-06905.txt 8 7 50 49 0.3736data7-8-50-06906.txt 8 7 50 48 0.2762data7-8-50-06907.txt 8 7 50 45 0.2534data7-8-50-06908.txt 8 7 50 44 0.4363data7-8-50-06909.txt 8 7 50 44 0.3428data7-8-50-06910.txt 8 7 50 43 0.5684data7-8-50-06911.txt 8 7 50 45 0.3822data7-8-50-06912.txt 8 7 50 41 0.4527data7-8-50-06913.txt 8 7 50 52 0.5426data7-8-50-06914.txt 8 7 50 47 0.2499data7-8-50-06915.txt 8 7 50 46 0.2323data7-8-50-06916.txt 8 7 50 47 0.7673data7-8-50-06917.txt 8 7 50 48 0.5789data7-8-50-06918.txt 8 7 50 43 0.4976data7-8-50-06919.txt 8 7 50 47 0.3510data7-8-50-06920.txt 8 7 50 37 0.2012data7-8-50-06921.txt 8 7 50 44 0.5789data7-8-50-06922.txt 8 7 50 53 0.3770data7-8-50-06923.txt 8 7 50 44 0.6646data7-8-50-06924.txt 8 7 50 39 0.5043data7-8-50-06925.txt 8 7 50 44 0.8499data7-8-50-06926.txt 8 7 50 42 0.5829data7-8-50-06927.txt 8 7 50 42 0.7766data7-8-50-06928.txt 8 7 50 52 0.5648data7-8-50-06929.txt 8 7 50 36 0.2846data7-8-50-06930.txt 8 7 50 48 0.9868data7-8-50-06931.txt 8 7 50 37 0.5424data7-8-50-06932.txt 8 7 50 49 0.3963data7-8-50-06933.txt 8 7 50 45 0.5408data7-8-50-06934.txt 8 7 50 47 0.6812data7-8-50-06935.txt 8 7 50 42 0.4877data7-8-50-06936.txt 8 7 50 51 0.7470data7-8-50-06937.txt 8 7 50 38 0.3225data7-8-50-06938.txt 8 7 50 37 0.1661data7-8-50-06939.txt 8 7 50 49 0.8183data7-8-50-06940.txt 8 7 50 48 0.3232data7-8-50-06941.txt 8 7 50 44 0.0801data7-8-50-06942.txt 8 7 50 52 1.0169data7-8-50-06943.txt 8 7 50 45 0.2637data7-8-50-06944.txt 8 7 50 48 0.8092data7-8-50-06945.txt 8 7 50 43 0.2061data7-8-50-06946.txt 8 7 50 42 0.7191data7-8-50-06947.txt 8 7 50 44 0.6649data7-8-50-06948.txt 8 7 50 52 0.4318data7-8-50-06949.txt 8 7 50 43 0.9289data7-8-50-06950.txt 8 7 50 47 0.4499data7-8-50-06951.txt 8 7 50 46 0.6317data7-8-50-06952.txt 8 7 50 45 0.9098data7-8-50-06953.txt 8 7 50 40 0.4340data7-8-50-06954.txt 8 7 50 47 0.9731data7-8-50-06955.txt 8 7 50 53 1.0262data7-8-50-06956.txt 8 7 50 41 0.2500data7-8-50-06957.txt 8 7 50 56 0.8608data7-8-50-06958.txt 8 7 50 50 0.3921data7-8-50-06959.txt 8 7 50 50 0.2055data7-8-50-06960.txt 8 7 50 47 0.0799data7-8-50-06961.txt 8 7 50 48 0.2388data7-8-50-06962.txt 8 7 50 37 0.6557data7-8-50-06963.txt 8 7 50 49 0.7526data7-8-50-06964.txt 8 7 50 48 0.6538data7-8-50-06965.txt 8 7 50 32 0.1284data7-8-50-06966.txt 8 7 50 44 0.3873data7-8-50-06967.txt 8 7 50 38 0.4695data7-8-50-06968.txt 8 7 50 43 0.5246data7-8-50-06969.txt 8 7 50 45 0.9811data7-8-50-06970.txt 8 7 50 55 1.0236

Table 151: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 357: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-8-50-06971.txt 8 7 50 42 0.5081data7-8-50-06972.txt 8 7 50 45 0.4947data7-8-50-06973.txt 8 7 50 40 0.6031data7-8-50-06974.txt 8 7 50 45 0.6063data7-8-50-06975.txt 8 7 50 40 0.0466data7-8-50-06976.txt 8 7 50 39 0.5958data7-8-50-06977.txt 8 7 50 46 0.4853data7-8-50-06978.txt 8 7 50 38 0.1298data7-8-50-06979.txt 8 7 50 39 0.2223data7-8-50-06980.txt 8 7 50 45 0.0103data7-8-50-06981.txt 8 7 50 43 0.1031data7-8-50-06982.txt 8 7 50 40 0.4781data7-8-50-06983.txt 8 7 50 41 0.0803data7-8-50-06984.txt 8 7 50 40 0.7695data7-8-50-06985.txt 8 7 50 40 0.2240data7-8-50-06986.txt 8 7 50 42 0.4635data7-8-50-06987.txt 8 7 50 52 0.5462data7-8-50-06988.txt 8 7 50 48 0.2195data7-8-50-06989.txt 8 7 50 47 0.2201data7-8-50-06990.txt 8 7 50 41 0.4675data7-8-50-06991.txt 8 7 50 48 0.3021data7-8-50-06992.txt 8 7 50 43 1.0174data7-8-50-06993.txt 8 7 50 47 0.8296data7-8-50-06994.txt 8 7 50 46 0.2063data7-8-50-06995.txt 8 7 50 44 0.2308data7-8-50-06996.txt 8 7 50 49 0.4303data7-8-50-06997.txt 8 7 50 46 0.4223data7-8-50-06998.txt 8 7 50 44 0.7674data7-8-50-06999.txt 8 7 50 41 0.6276data7-8-50-07000.txt 8 7 50 40 0.5873data7-8-51-07001.txt 8 7 51 47 0.3619data7-8-51-07002.txt 8 7 51 39 0.1341data7-8-51-07003.txt 8 7 51 50 0.5617data7-8-51-07004.txt 8 7 51 43 0.5835data7-8-51-07005.txt 8 7 51 38 0.4084data7-8-51-07006.txt 8 7 51 43 0.4005data7-8-51-07007.txt 8 7 51 45 0.3177data7-8-51-07008.txt 8 7 51 49 0.2627data7-8-51-07009.txt 8 7 51 57 0.3596data7-8-51-07010.txt 8 7 51 52 1.0004data7-8-51-07011.txt 8 7 51 42 0.3981data7-8-51-07012.txt 8 7 51 44 0.5387data7-8-51-07013.txt 8 7 51 48 0.5655data7-8-51-07014.txt 8 7 51 44 0.4352data7-8-51-07015.txt 8 7 51 47 0.1068data7-8-51-07016.txt 8 7 51 41 0.4477data7-8-51-07017.txt 8 7 51 47 0.4115data7-8-51-07018.txt 8 7 51 38 0.1758data7-8-51-07019.txt 8 7 51 50 0.4524data7-8-51-07020.txt 8 7 51 50 0.2446data7-8-51-07021.txt 8 7 51 49 0.1665data7-8-51-07022.txt 8 7 51 53 0.0154data7-8-51-07023.txt 8 7 51 47 0.5944data7-8-51-07024.txt 8 7 51 43 0.2496data7-8-51-07025.txt 8 7 51 47 0.5221data7-8-51-07026.txt 8 7 51 37 0.1706data7-8-51-07027.txt 8 7 51 50 0.5574data7-8-51-07028.txt 8 7 51 48 0.3203data7-8-51-07029.txt 8 7 51 41 0.0186data7-8-51-07030.txt 8 7 51 43 0.1248data7-8-51-07031.txt 8 7 51 53 0.6851data7-8-51-07032.txt 8 7 51 49 0.9118data7-8-51-07033.txt 8 7 51 40 0.4220data7-8-51-07034.txt 8 7 51 43 0.3583data7-8-51-07035.txt 8 7 51 47 0.5130data7-8-51-07036.txt 8 7 51 46 0.4075data7-8-51-07037.txt 8 7 51 54 0.5844data7-8-51-07038.txt 8 7 51 48 0.3948data7-8-51-07039.txt 8 7 51 51 0.6263data7-8-51-07040.txt 8 7 51 50 0.6217

Table 152: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 358: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-8-51-07041.txt 8 7 51 42 0.4533data7-8-51-07042.txt 8 7 51 36 0.3237data7-8-51-07043.txt 8 7 51 36 0.4147data7-8-51-07044.txt 8 7 51 49 0.8333data7-8-51-07045.txt 8 7 51 43 0.2914data7-8-51-07046.txt 8 7 51 40 0.7045data7-8-51-07047.txt 8 7 51 54 0.6460data7-8-51-07048.txt 8 7 51 49 0.5474data7-8-51-07049.txt 8 7 51 47 0.1081data7-8-51-07050.txt 8 7 51 45 0.8087data7-8-51-07051.txt 8 7 51 40 0.3264data7-8-51-07052.txt 8 7 51 56 0.8367data7-8-51-07053.txt 8 7 51 42 0.1608data7-8-51-07054.txt 8 7 51 55 0.5404data7-8-51-07055.txt 8 7 51 41 0.2454data7-8-51-07056.txt 8 7 51 40 0.4593data7-8-51-07057.txt 8 7 51 45 0.5817data7-8-51-07058.txt 8 7 51 43 0.1340data7-8-51-07059.txt 8 7 51 39 0.9670data7-8-51-07060.txt 8 7 51 47 0.2782data7-8-51-07061.txt 8 7 51 32 0.2965data7-8-51-07062.txt 8 7 51 47 0.5443data7-8-51-07063.txt 8 7 51 44 0.5155data7-8-51-07064.txt 8 7 51 44 0.1650data7-8-51-07065.txt 8 7 51 44 0.5216data7-8-51-07066.txt 8 7 51 60 1.0292data7-8-51-07067.txt 8 7 51 38 0.2827data7-8-51-07068.txt 8 7 51 41 0.2689data7-8-51-07069.txt 8 7 51 38 0.1309data7-8-51-07070.txt 8 7 51 48 0.3331data7-8-51-07071.txt 8 7 51 54 0.4509data7-8-51-07072.txt 8 7 51 40 0.2462data7-8-51-07073.txt 8 7 51 45 0.6554data7-8-51-07074.txt 8 7 51 39 0.1976data7-8-51-07075.txt 8 7 51 44 0.3469data7-8-51-07076.txt 8 7 51 50 0.3278data7-8-51-07077.txt 8 7 51 50 1.0232data7-8-51-07078.txt 8 7 51 44 0.4295data7-8-51-07079.txt 8 7 51 44 0.5548data7-8-51-07080.txt 8 7 51 37 0.2561data7-8-51-07081.txt 8 7 51 46 0.6780data7-8-51-07082.txt 8 7 51 35 0.0454data7-8-51-07083.txt 8 7 51 31 0.0047data7-8-51-07084.txt 8 7 51 47 0.3881data7-8-51-07085.txt 8 7 51 46 0.2289data7-8-51-07086.txt 8 7 51 52 0.1633data7-8-51-07087.txt 8 7 51 44 0.0890data7-8-51-07088.txt 8 7 51 40 0.4269data7-8-51-07089.txt 8 7 51 41 0.1231data7-8-51-07090.txt 8 7 51 39 0.2746data7-8-51-07091.txt 8 7 51 51 0.2362data7-8-51-07092.txt 8 7 51 45 0.3618data7-8-51-07093.txt 8 7 51 42 0.3060data7-8-51-07094.txt 8 7 51 46 0.3032data7-8-51-07095.txt 8 7 51 41 0.1271data7-8-51-07096.txt 8 7 51 42 0.8336data7-8-51-07097.txt 8 7 51 45 0.3751data7-8-51-07098.txt 8 7 51 54 0.5024data7-8-51-07099.txt 8 7 51 42 0.2757data7-8-51-07100.txt 8 7 51 52 0.7056data7-8-52-07101.txt 8 7 52 45 0.5373data7-8-52-07102.txt 8 7 52 51 0.5213data7-8-52-07103.txt 8 7 52 51 0.3304data7-8-52-07104.txt 8 7 52 44 0.5037data7-8-52-07105.txt 8 7 52 46 0.5317data7-8-52-07106.txt 8 7 52 46 0.3097data7-8-52-07107.txt 8 7 52 46 0.5393data7-8-52-07108.txt 8 7 52 49 0.1915data7-8-52-07109.txt 8 7 52 41 0.8261data7-8-52-07110.txt 8 7 52 40 0.9331

Table 153: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 359: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-8-52-07111.txt 8 7 52 49 0.3226data7-8-52-07112.txt 8 7 52 54 0.7992data7-8-52-07113.txt 8 7 52 48 0.2332data7-8-52-07114.txt 8 7 52 43 0.4961data7-8-52-07115.txt 8 7 52 44 0.4608data7-8-52-07116.txt 8 7 52 46 0.3745data7-8-52-07117.txt 8 7 52 52 0.2211data7-8-52-07118.txt 8 7 52 47 0.5363data7-8-52-07119.txt 8 7 52 41 0.1028data7-8-52-07120.txt 8 7 52 43 1.0276data7-8-52-07121.txt 8 7 52 41 0.5029data7-8-52-07122.txt 8 7 52 44 0.3505data7-8-52-07123.txt 8 7 52 41 0.2246data7-8-52-07124.txt 8 7 52 50 0.2092data7-8-52-07125.txt 8 7 52 48 0.6082data7-8-52-07126.txt 8 7 52 43 0.1990data7-8-52-07127.txt 8 7 52 39 0.3213data7-8-52-07128.txt 8 7 52 46 0.3192data7-8-52-07129.txt 8 7 52 38 0.2630data7-8-52-07130.txt 8 7 52 44 0.3046data7-8-52-07131.txt 8 7 52 42 0.2098data7-8-52-07132.txt 8 7 52 46 0.6325data7-8-52-07133.txt 8 7 52 44 0.3191data7-8-52-07134.txt 8 7 52 45 0.1991data7-8-52-07135.txt 8 7 52 51 0.5483data7-8-52-07136.txt 8 7 52 41 0.0085data7-8-52-07137.txt 8 7 52 51 0.2282data7-8-52-07138.txt 8 7 52 57 1.0467data7-8-52-07139.txt 8 7 52 43 0.4596data7-8-52-07140.txt 8 7 52 51 0.3862data7-8-52-07141.txt 8 7 52 32 0.0400data7-8-52-07142.txt 8 7 52 38 0.0216data7-8-52-07143.txt 8 7 52 53 0.4078data7-8-52-07144.txt 8 7 52 55 0.4364data7-8-52-07145.txt 8 7 52 55 1.0195data7-8-52-07146.txt 8 7 52 41 0.1256data7-8-52-07147.txt 8 7 52 51 0.1763data7-8-52-07148.txt 8 7 52 53 0.5835data7-8-52-07149.txt 8 7 52 43 0.1990data7-8-52-07150.txt 8 7 52 54 0.5757data7-8-52-07151.txt 8 7 52 48 0.6841data7-8-52-07152.txt 8 7 52 51 0.5829data7-8-52-07153.txt 8 7 52 54 0.4195data7-8-52-07154.txt 8 7 52 53 0.5341data7-8-52-07155.txt 8 7 52 42 0.0041data7-8-52-07156.txt 8 7 52 54 0.4684data7-8-52-07157.txt 8 7 52 51 0.5764data7-8-52-07158.txt 8 7 52 43 0.4001data7-8-52-07159.txt 8 7 52 41 0.4015data7-8-52-07160.txt 8 7 52 54 0.6316data7-8-52-07161.txt 8 7 52 51 0.4140data7-8-52-07162.txt 8 7 52 48 0.2331data7-8-52-07163.txt 8 7 52 46 0.5583data7-8-52-07164.txt 8 7 52 43 0.5410data7-8-52-07165.txt 8 7 52 47 0.7436data7-8-52-07166.txt 8 7 52 56 0.2641data7-8-52-07167.txt 8 7 52 50 0.2889data7-8-52-07168.txt 8 7 52 60 0.6994data7-8-52-07169.txt 8 7 52 45 0.3364data7-8-52-07170.txt 8 7 52 54 0.7241data7-8-52-07171.txt 8 7 52 56 0.7367data7-8-52-07172.txt 8 7 52 42 0.3654data7-8-52-07173.txt 8 7 52 52 0.4556data7-8-52-07174.txt 8 7 52 43 0.3690data7-8-52-07175.txt 8 7 52 47 0.1553data7-8-52-07176.txt 8 7 52 44 0.4740data7-8-52-07177.txt 8 7 52 53 0.6587data7-8-52-07178.txt 8 7 52 40 0.3402data7-8-52-07179.txt 8 7 52 50 0.8766data7-8-52-07180.txt 8 7 52 55 0.0883

Table 154: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 360: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-8-52-07181.txt 8 7 52 47 0.0238data7-8-52-07182.txt 8 7 52 54 0.6756data7-8-52-07183.txt 8 7 52 49 0.2093data7-8-52-07184.txt 8 7 52 58 0.2267data7-8-52-07185.txt 8 7 52 51 0.3017data7-8-52-07186.txt 8 7 52 51 0.4571data7-8-52-07187.txt 8 7 52 39 0.5547data7-8-52-07188.txt 8 7 52 40 0.2549data7-8-52-07189.txt 8 7 52 48 0.9517data7-8-52-07190.txt 8 7 52 47 0.2692data7-8-52-07191.txt 8 7 52 48 0.4451data7-8-52-07192.txt 8 7 52 43 0.7794data7-8-52-07193.txt 8 7 52 44 0.0120data7-8-52-07194.txt 8 7 52 49 0.4221data7-8-52-07195.txt 8 7 52 56 0.3418data7-8-52-07196.txt 8 7 52 52 0.1982data7-8-52-07197.txt 8 7 52 48 0.1594data7-8-52-07198.txt 8 7 52 51 0.6594data7-8-52-07199.txt 8 7 52 45 0.2309data7-8-52-07200.txt 8 7 52 53 0.7406data7-8-53-07201.txt 8 7 53 52 0.4394data7-8-53-07202.txt 8 7 53 40 0.6464data7-8-53-07203.txt 8 7 53 40 0.2595data7-8-53-07204.txt 8 7 53 44 0.0131data7-8-53-07205.txt 8 7 53 50 0.5911data7-8-53-07206.txt 8 7 53 47 0.3366data7-8-53-07207.txt 8 7 53 50 0.5681data7-8-53-07208.txt 8 7 53 47 0.2720data7-8-53-07209.txt 8 7 53 52 0.2667data7-8-53-07210.txt 8 7 53 42 0.2979data7-8-53-07211.txt 8 7 53 53 0.2694data7-8-53-07212.txt 8 7 53 55 0.6364data7-8-53-07213.txt 8 7 53 50 0.2989data7-8-53-07214.txt 8 7 53 52 0.7536data7-8-53-07215.txt 8 7 53 49 0.5092data7-8-53-07216.txt 8 7 53 44 0.1401data7-8-53-07217.txt 8 7 53 47 0.2659data7-8-53-07218.txt 8 7 53 39 0.4574data7-8-53-07219.txt 8 7 53 45 0.5024data7-8-53-07220.txt 8 7 53 49 0.7636data7-8-53-07221.txt 8 7 53 46 0.3885data7-8-53-07222.txt 8 7 53 39 0.4295data7-8-53-07223.txt 8 7 53 38 0.0931data7-8-53-07224.txt 8 7 53 52 0.4267data7-8-53-07225.txt 8 7 53 43 0.5939data7-8-53-07226.txt 8 7 53 50 0.4111data7-8-53-07227.txt 8 7 53 48 0.2304data7-8-53-07228.txt 8 7 53 62 0.5211data7-8-53-07229.txt 8 7 53 41 0.5337data7-8-53-07230.txt 8 7 53 49 0.4222data7-8-53-07231.txt 8 7 53 60 0.3930data7-8-53-07232.txt 8 7 53 44 0.3283data7-8-53-07233.txt 8 7 53 47 0.3021data7-8-53-07234.txt 8 7 53 49 0.2286data7-8-53-07235.txt 8 7 53 47 0.0056data7-8-53-07236.txt 8 7 53 42 0.5549data7-8-53-07237.txt 8 7 53 51 0.5771data7-8-53-07238.txt 8 7 53 47 0.3883data7-8-53-07239.txt 8 7 53 61 0.2224data7-8-53-07240.txt 8 7 53 51 0.7599data7-8-53-07241.txt 8 7 53 44 0.1357data7-8-53-07242.txt 8 7 53 51 0.6860data7-8-53-07243.txt 8 7 53 52 0.3572data7-8-53-07244.txt 8 7 53 49 0.2066data7-8-53-07245.txt 8 7 53 46 0.2330data7-8-53-07246.txt 8 7 53 43 0.1711data7-8-53-07247.txt 8 7 53 39 0.5037data7-8-53-07248.txt 8 7 53 50 0.4357data7-8-53-07249.txt 8 7 53 49 0.1562data7-8-53-07250.txt 8 7 53 47 0.2353

Table 155: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 361: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-8-53-07251.txt 8 7 53 54 0.2123data7-8-53-07252.txt 8 7 53 52 0.4282data7-8-53-07253.txt 8 7 53 45 0.3739data7-8-53-07254.txt 8 7 53 57 0.8883data7-8-53-07255.txt 8 7 53 47 0.3667data7-8-53-07256.txt 8 7 53 52 0.2689data7-8-53-07257.txt 8 7 53 44 0.7140data7-8-53-07258.txt 8 7 53 54 1.0416data7-8-53-07259.txt 8 7 53 49 0.4591data7-8-53-07260.txt 8 7 53 58 0.2361data7-8-53-07261.txt 8 7 53 44 0.1203data7-8-53-07262.txt 8 7 53 50 0.6922data7-8-53-07263.txt 8 7 53 53 0.3653data7-8-53-07264.txt 8 7 53 54 0.2770data7-8-53-07265.txt 8 7 53 44 0.2057data7-8-53-07266.txt 8 7 53 44 0.5406data7-8-53-07267.txt 8 7 53 51 0.4573data7-8-53-07268.txt 8 7 53 49 0.1322data7-8-53-07269.txt 8 7 53 51 0.5998data7-8-53-07270.txt 8 7 53 56 0.2734data7-8-53-07271.txt 8 7 53 42 0.4038data7-8-53-07272.txt 8 7 53 40 0.2457data7-8-53-07273.txt 8 7 53 49 0.5519data7-8-53-07274.txt 8 7 53 45 0.4753data7-8-53-07275.txt 8 7 53 51 0.3077data7-8-53-07276.txt 8 7 53 44 0.1533data7-8-53-07277.txt 8 7 53 43 0.3918data7-8-53-07278.txt 8 7 53 48 0.0949data7-8-53-07279.txt 8 7 53 43 0.6145data7-8-53-07280.txt 8 7 53 50 0.6621data7-8-53-07281.txt 8 7 53 63 0.9877data7-8-53-07282.txt 8 7 53 42 0.2693data7-8-53-07283.txt 8 7 53 43 0.0092data7-8-53-07284.txt 8 7 53 48 0.1441data7-8-53-07285.txt 8 7 53 45 0.2935data7-8-53-07286.txt 8 7 53 57 0.2928data7-8-53-07287.txt 8 7 53 41 0.7945data7-8-53-07288.txt 8 7 53 52 0.8463data7-8-53-07289.txt 8 7 53 50 0.2957data7-8-53-07290.txt 8 7 53 56 0.4066data7-8-53-07291.txt 8 7 53 36 0.0103data7-8-53-07292.txt 8 7 53 52 0.1637data7-8-53-07293.txt 8 7 53 36 0.2894data7-8-53-07294.txt 8 7 53 52 0.6350data7-8-53-07295.txt 8 7 53 40 0.2466data7-8-53-07296.txt 8 7 53 48 0.1599data7-8-53-07297.txt 8 7 53 52 0.3250data7-8-53-07298.txt 8 7 53 56 0.0838data7-8-53-07299.txt 8 7 53 52 0.3125data7-8-53-07300.txt 8 7 53 46 0.3075data7-8-54-07301.txt 8 7 54 46 0.6499data7-8-54-07302.txt 8 7 54 53 0.4637data7-8-54-07303.txt 8 7 54 47 0.5999data7-8-54-07304.txt 8 7 54 38 0.3395data7-8-54-07305.txt 8 7 54 50 0.5269data7-8-54-07306.txt 8 7 54 57 0.3237data7-8-54-07307.txt 8 7 54 50 0.3582data7-8-54-07308.txt 8 7 54 45 0.4041data7-8-54-07309.txt 8 7 54 45 0.1473data7-8-54-07310.txt 8 7 54 47 0.2845data7-8-54-07311.txt 8 7 54 47 0.3962data7-8-54-07312.txt 8 7 54 57 0.6670data7-8-54-07313.txt 8 7 54 41 0.4426data7-8-54-07314.txt 8 7 54 50 0.1034data7-8-54-07315.txt 8 7 54 43 0.3458data7-8-54-07316.txt 8 7 54 55 0.9906data7-8-54-07317.txt 8 7 54 56 0.4456data7-8-54-07318.txt 8 7 54 41 0.3823data7-8-54-07319.txt 8 7 54 60 0.6339data7-8-54-07320.txt 8 7 54 46 0.2706

Table 156: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 362: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-8-54-07321.txt 8 7 54 49 0.4367data7-8-54-07322.txt 8 7 54 48 0.2841data7-8-54-07323.txt 8 7 54 49 0.4373data7-8-54-07324.txt 8 7 54 47 0.6262data7-8-54-07325.txt 8 7 54 39 0.4915data7-8-54-07326.txt 8 7 54 33 0.3976data7-8-54-07327.txt 8 7 54 59 0.5226data7-8-54-07328.txt 8 7 54 51 0.1894data7-8-54-07329.txt 8 7 54 59 0.3751data7-8-54-07330.txt 8 7 54 48 0.6700data7-8-54-07331.txt 8 7 54 46 0.6405data7-8-54-07332.txt 8 7 54 51 1.0263data7-8-54-07333.txt 8 7 54 55 0.1762data7-8-54-07334.txt 8 7 54 42 0.1491data7-8-54-07335.txt 8 7 54 47 0.7991data7-8-54-07336.txt 8 7 54 52 0.9003data7-8-54-07337.txt 8 7 54 48 0.3088data7-8-54-07338.txt 8 7 54 44 0.0947data7-8-54-07339.txt 8 7 54 37 0.2601data7-8-54-07340.txt 8 7 54 48 0.4878data7-8-54-07341.txt 8 7 54 46 0.6557data7-8-54-07342.txt 8 7 54 55 0.4967data7-8-54-07343.txt 8 7 54 47 0.1743data7-8-54-07344.txt 8 7 54 46 0.6362data7-8-54-07345.txt 8 7 54 45 0.8271data7-8-54-07346.txt 8 7 54 44 0.0585data7-8-54-07347.txt 8 7 54 54 0.6268data7-8-54-07348.txt 8 7 54 51 0.8275data7-8-54-07349.txt 8 7 54 42 0.2696data7-8-54-07350.txt 8 7 54 54 0.4240data7-8-54-07351.txt 8 7 54 45 0.3048data7-8-54-07352.txt 8 7 54 41 0.5552data7-8-54-07353.txt 8 7 54 34 0.4251data7-8-54-07354.txt 8 7 54 42 0.2472data7-8-54-07355.txt 8 7 54 42 0.1850data7-8-54-07356.txt 8 7 54 44 0.7930data7-8-54-07357.txt 8 7 54 41 0.6423data7-8-54-07358.txt 8 7 54 44 0.8093data7-8-54-07359.txt 8 7 54 47 0.5085data7-8-54-07360.txt 8 7 54 50 0.2143data7-8-54-07361.txt 8 7 54 46 0.0510data7-8-54-07362.txt 8 7 54 54 0.5454data7-8-54-07363.txt 8 7 54 51 0.3979data7-8-54-07364.txt 8 7 54 51 0.5004data7-8-54-07365.txt 8 7 54 45 0.5294data7-8-54-07366.txt 8 7 54 57 0.1730data7-8-54-07367.txt 8 7 54 47 0.6953data7-8-54-07368.txt 8 7 54 45 0.0043data7-8-54-07369.txt 8 7 54 51 0.4504data7-8-54-07370.txt 8 7 54 50 0.5690data7-8-54-07371.txt 8 7 54 27 0.0197data7-8-54-07372.txt 8 7 54 51 0.5945data7-8-54-07373.txt 8 7 54 46 0.2209data7-8-54-07374.txt 8 7 54 43 0.2101data7-8-54-07375.txt 8 7 54 48 0.5320data7-8-54-07376.txt 8 7 54 39 0.0180data7-8-54-07377.txt 8 7 54 51 0.0163data7-8-54-07378.txt 8 7 54 56 0.5900data7-8-54-07379.txt 8 7 54 46 0.2724data7-8-54-07380.txt 8 7 54 52 0.3011data7-8-54-07381.txt 8 7 54 44 0.4515data7-8-54-07382.txt 8 7 54 45 0.3020data7-8-54-07383.txt 8 7 54 50 0.4911data7-8-54-07384.txt 8 7 54 47 0.1427data7-8-54-07385.txt 8 7 54 55 0.4330data7-8-54-07386.txt 8 7 54 50 0.0356data7-8-54-07387.txt 8 7 54 52 0.2530data7-8-54-07388.txt 8 7 54 50 0.1464data7-8-54-07389.txt 8 7 54 43 0.5375data7-8-54-07390.txt 8 7 54 45 0.9617

Table 157: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 363: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-8-54-07391.txt 8 7 54 51 0.5984data7-8-54-07392.txt 8 7 54 40 0.6770data7-8-54-07393.txt 8 7 54 57 0.4011data7-8-54-07394.txt 8 7 54 53 0.6561data7-8-54-07395.txt 8 7 54 59 0.3988data7-8-54-07396.txt 8 7 54 53 0.8348data7-8-54-07397.txt 8 7 54 42 0.7137data7-8-54-07398.txt 8 7 54 39 0.7281data7-8-54-07399.txt 8 7 54 44 0.2791data7-8-54-07400.txt 8 7 54 45 0.0782data7-8-55-07401.txt 8 7 55 46 0.8972data7-8-55-07402.txt 8 7 55 61 0.3615data7-8-55-07403.txt 8 7 55 52 0.2999data7-8-55-07404.txt 8 7 55 47 0.4258data7-8-55-07405.txt 8 7 55 48 0.9344data7-8-55-07406.txt 8 7 55 48 0.7048data7-8-55-07407.txt 8 7 55 56 1.0057data7-8-55-07408.txt 8 7 55 48 0.1432data7-8-55-07409.txt 8 7 55 50 0.2611data7-8-55-07410.txt 8 7 55 53 0.8414data7-8-55-07411.txt 8 7 55 52 0.3271data7-8-55-07412.txt 8 7 55 65 0.5292data7-8-55-07413.txt 8 7 55 49 0.9666data7-8-55-07414.txt 8 7 55 50 0.2547data7-8-55-07415.txt 8 7 55 44 0.2185data7-8-55-07416.txt 8 7 55 47 0.7210data7-8-55-07417.txt 8 7 55 53 0.5270data7-8-55-07418.txt 8 7 55 45 0.1277data7-8-55-07419.txt 8 7 55 64 0.6327data7-8-55-07420.txt 8 7 55 55 0.4868data7-8-55-07421.txt 8 7 55 45 0.3386data7-8-55-07422.txt 8 7 55 50 0.5874data7-8-55-07423.txt 8 7 55 56 0.4342data7-8-55-07424.txt 8 7 55 48 0.0087data7-8-55-07425.txt 8 7 55 47 0.3431data7-8-55-07426.txt 8 7 55 57 0.5668data7-8-55-07427.txt 8 7 55 46 0.2881data7-8-55-07428.txt 8 7 55 52 0.0118data7-8-55-07429.txt 8 7 55 55 0.8756data7-8-55-07430.txt 8 7 55 48 0.5057data7-8-55-07431.txt 8 7 55 54 0.1991data7-8-55-07432.txt 8 7 55 42 0.5295data7-8-55-07433.txt 8 7 55 60 0.4036data7-8-55-07434.txt 8 7 55 52 0.4923data7-8-55-07435.txt 8 7 55 50 0.5803data7-8-55-07436.txt 8 7 55 58 0.2576data7-8-55-07437.txt 8 7 55 55 0.2560data7-8-55-07438.txt 8 7 55 48 0.0181data7-8-55-07439.txt 8 7 55 44 0.2518data7-8-55-07440.txt 8 7 55 51 0.2152data7-8-55-07441.txt 8 7 55 57 0.2981data7-8-55-07442.txt 8 7 55 41 0.4323data7-8-55-07443.txt 8 7 55 48 0.2841data7-8-55-07444.txt 8 7 55 47 0.2688data7-8-55-07445.txt 8 7 55 49 0.6863data7-8-55-07446.txt 8 7 55 45 0.1905data7-8-55-07447.txt 8 7 55 52 0.1949data7-8-55-07448.txt 8 7 55 46 0.4443data7-8-55-07449.txt 8 7 55 52 0.4159data7-8-55-07450.txt 8 7 55 44 0.1827data7-8-55-07451.txt 8 7 55 53 0.4112data7-8-55-07452.txt 8 7 55 54 0.4987data7-8-55-07453.txt 8 7 55 48 0.3505data7-8-55-07454.txt 8 7 55 41 0.6162data7-8-55-07455.txt 8 7 55 48 0.2595data7-8-55-07456.txt 8 7 55 51 0.2306data7-8-55-07457.txt 8 7 55 53 0.3484data7-8-55-07458.txt 8 7 55 54 0.2730data7-8-55-07459.txt 8 7 55 52 0.4433data7-8-55-07460.txt 8 7 55 47 0.4362

Table 158: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 364: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-8-55-07461.txt 8 7 55 51 0.4966data7-8-55-07462.txt 8 7 55 49 0.7925data7-8-55-07463.txt 8 7 55 51 0.4217data7-8-55-07464.txt 8 7 55 51 0.1227data7-8-55-07465.txt 8 7 55 41 0.6420data7-8-55-07466.txt 8 7 55 45 0.5908data7-8-55-07467.txt 8 7 55 52 0.5600data7-8-55-07468.txt 8 7 55 55 0.3672data7-8-55-07469.txt 8 7 55 54 0.3255data7-8-55-07470.txt 8 7 55 52 0.4083data7-8-55-07471.txt 8 7 55 57 0.3596data7-8-55-07472.txt 8 7 55 55 0.4014data7-8-55-07473.txt 8 7 55 46 0.6662data7-8-55-07474.txt 8 7 55 54 0.1967data7-8-55-07475.txt 8 7 55 60 0.7123data7-8-55-07476.txt 8 7 55 68 1.0303data7-8-55-07477.txt 8 7 55 58 0.9335data7-8-55-07478.txt 8 7 55 55 0.9576data7-8-55-07479.txt 8 7 55 51 0.5490data7-8-55-07480.txt 8 7 55 53 0.4397data7-8-55-07481.txt 8 7 55 47 0.0995data7-8-55-07482.txt 8 7 55 50 0.5928data7-8-55-07483.txt 8 7 55 56 0.7463data7-8-55-07484.txt 8 7 55 49 0.1214data7-8-55-07485.txt 8 7 55 39 0.2051data7-8-55-07486.txt 8 7 55 40 0.2405data7-8-55-07487.txt 8 7 55 44 0.5230data7-8-55-07488.txt 8 7 55 51 0.3001data7-8-55-07489.txt 8 7 55 54 0.9203data7-8-55-07490.txt 8 7 55 40 0.1624data7-8-55-07491.txt 8 7 55 43 0.4686data7-8-55-07492.txt 8 7 55 42 0.1119data7-8-55-07493.txt 8 7 55 52 0.4349data7-8-55-07494.txt 8 7 55 46 0.1538data7-8-55-07495.txt 8 7 55 43 0.3213data7-8-55-07496.txt 8 7 55 42 0.7146data7-8-55-07497.txt 8 7 55 55 1.0194data7-8-55-07498.txt 8 7 55 44 0.2201data7-8-55-07499.txt 8 7 55 48 0.6925data7-8-55-07500.txt 8 7 55 52 0.6184data7-9-56-09301.txt 9 7 56 52 0.7163data7-9-56-09302.txt 9 7 56 55 0.5509data7-9-56-09303.txt 9 7 56 42 0.5212data7-9-56-09304.txt 9 7 56 46 0.2173data7-9-56-09305.txt 9 7 56 41 0.6816data7-9-56-09306.txt 9 7 56 43 0.4396data7-9-56-09307.txt 9 7 56 47 0.4528data7-9-56-09308.txt 9 7 56 48 0.5381data7-9-56-09309.txt 9 7 56 52 0.4891data7-9-56-09310.txt 9 7 56 49 0.6102data7-9-56-09311.txt 9 7 56 47 0.6498data7-9-56-09312.txt 9 7 56 42 0.5196data7-9-56-09313.txt 9 7 56 46 0.2675data7-9-56-09314.txt 9 7 56 42 0.0587data7-9-56-09315.txt 9 7 56 51 0.6996data7-9-56-09316.txt 9 7 56 51 1.0540data7-9-56-09317.txt 9 7 56 57 0.6605data7-9-56-09318.txt 9 7 56 44 0.6787data7-9-56-09319.txt 9 7 56 49 0.8895data7-9-56-09320.txt 9 7 56 45 0.5711data7-9-56-09321.txt 9 7 56 48 0.9522data7-9-56-09322.txt 9 7 56 43 1.0233data7-9-56-09323.txt 9 7 56 46 0.7587data7-9-56-09324.txt 9 7 56 47 0.2933data7-9-56-09325.txt 9 7 56 49 0.4367data7-9-56-09326.txt 9 7 56 47 0.9409data7-9-56-09327.txt 9 7 56 52 0.9801data7-9-56-09328.txt 9 7 56 46 0.5853data7-9-56-09329.txt 9 7 56 46 0.4617data7-9-56-09330.txt 9 7 56 44 0.6770

Table 159: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 365: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-9-56-09331.txt 9 7 56 51 0.1682data7-9-56-09332.txt 9 7 56 44 0.2917data7-9-56-09333.txt 9 7 56 43 0.3605data7-9-56-09334.txt 9 7 56 48 0.8188data7-9-56-09335.txt 9 7 56 42 1.0166data7-9-56-09336.txt 9 7 56 46 0.0759data7-9-56-09337.txt 9 7 56 46 0.3183data7-9-56-09338.txt 9 7 56 48 1.0102data7-9-56-09339.txt 9 7 56 44 0.5796data7-9-56-09340.txt 9 7 56 46 1.0519data7-9-56-09341.txt 9 7 56 47 0.6137data7-9-56-09342.txt 9 7 56 47 0.1393data7-9-56-09343.txt 9 7 56 47 0.9022data7-9-56-09344.txt 9 7 56 48 0.3129data7-9-56-09345.txt 9 7 56 45 0.6897data7-9-56-09346.txt 9 7 56 34 0.2378data7-9-56-09347.txt 9 7 56 42 0.3256data7-9-56-09348.txt 9 7 56 48 0.4787data7-9-56-09349.txt 9 7 56 43 0.8125data7-9-56-09350.txt 9 7 56 49 0.2963data7-9-56-09351.txt 9 7 56 44 0.5352data7-9-56-09352.txt 9 7 56 49 1.0136data7-9-56-09353.txt 9 7 56 50 0.8814data7-9-56-09354.txt 9 7 56 51 0.2091data7-9-56-09355.txt 9 7 56 54 0.4358data7-9-56-09356.txt 9 7 56 43 0.4864data7-9-56-09357.txt 9 7 56 44 0.4553data7-9-56-09358.txt 9 7 56 48 0.6206data7-9-56-09359.txt 9 7 56 39 0.5699data7-9-56-09360.txt 9 7 56 42 1.0190data7-9-56-09361.txt 9 7 56 44 0.4790data7-9-56-09362.txt 9 7 56 52 0.6176data7-9-56-09363.txt 9 7 56 46 0.3870data7-9-56-09364.txt 9 7 56 40 0.1116data7-9-56-09365.txt 9 7 56 48 0.3922data7-9-56-09366.txt 9 7 56 54 0.7000data7-9-56-09367.txt 9 7 56 47 0.5930data7-9-56-09368.txt 9 7 56 46 0.3993data7-9-56-09369.txt 9 7 56 46 0.8526data7-9-56-09370.txt 9 7 56 44 0.6470data7-9-56-09371.txt 9 7 56 48 1.0307data7-9-56-09372.txt 9 7 56 50 1.0470data7-9-56-09373.txt 9 7 56 48 0.6447data7-9-56-09374.txt 9 7 56 45 0.9235data7-9-56-09375.txt 9 7 56 38 0.1333data7-9-56-09376.txt 9 7 56 44 0.8521data7-9-56-09377.txt 9 7 56 45 0.8803data7-9-56-09378.txt 9 7 56 45 0.6152data7-9-56-09379.txt 9 7 56 44 0.6488data7-9-56-09380.txt 9 7 56 47 0.2750data7-9-56-09381.txt 9 7 56 46 0.5462data7-9-56-09382.txt 9 7 56 51 0.6852data7-9-56-09383.txt 9 7 56 42 0.6159data7-9-56-09384.txt 9 7 56 44 0.4355data7-9-56-09385.txt 9 7 56 49 0.5027data7-9-56-09386.txt 9 7 56 48 0.6972data7-9-56-09387.txt 9 7 56 48 1.0312data7-9-56-09388.txt 9 7 56 40 0.8209data7-9-56-09389.txt 9 7 56 46 1.0199data7-9-56-09390.txt 9 7 56 40 0.1539data7-9-56-09391.txt 9 7 56 47 0.4566data7-9-56-09392.txt 9 7 56 48 1.0671data7-9-56-09393.txt 9 7 56 49 1.0219data7-9-56-09394.txt 9 7 56 48 0.6740data7-9-56-09395.txt 9 7 56 43 0.0782data7-9-56-09396.txt 9 7 56 53 0.6516data7-9-56-09397.txt 9 7 56 45 0.0034data7-9-56-09398.txt 9 7 56 41 0.7034data7-9-56-09399.txt 9 7 56 55 1.0437data7-9-56-09400.txt 9 7 56 47 0.7989

Table 160: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 366: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-9-57-09401.txt 9 7 57 43 0.2012data7-9-57-09402.txt 9 7 57 41 0.0786data7-9-57-09403.txt 9 7 57 51 0.5423data7-9-57-09404.txt 9 7 57 39 0.4765data7-9-57-09405.txt 9 7 57 47 1.0213data7-9-57-09406.txt 9 7 57 38 0.5448data7-9-57-09407.txt 9 7 57 56 1.0312data7-9-57-09408.txt 9 7 57 44 0.4219data7-9-57-09409.txt 9 7 57 55 0.6504data7-9-57-09410.txt 9 7 57 55 0.7878data7-9-57-09411.txt 9 7 57 51 0.4158data7-9-57-09412.txt 9 7 57 48 0.5035data7-9-57-09413.txt 9 7 57 54 0.6471data7-9-57-09414.txt 9 7 57 50 1.0084data7-9-57-09415.txt 9 7 57 51 0.5159data7-9-57-09416.txt 9 7 57 50 1.0425data7-9-57-09417.txt 9 7 57 48 0.7779data7-9-57-09418.txt 9 7 57 55 0.7243data7-9-57-09419.txt 9 7 57 46 0.6032data7-9-57-09420.txt 9 7 57 48 0.9421data7-9-57-09421.txt 9 7 57 44 1.0568data7-9-57-09422.txt 9 7 57 48 0.8224data7-9-57-09423.txt 9 7 57 52 0.8362data7-9-57-09424.txt 9 7 57 54 1.0208data7-9-57-09425.txt 9 7 57 48 0.6707data7-9-57-09426.txt 9 7 57 47 1.0346data7-9-57-09427.txt 9 7 57 56 1.0580data7-9-57-09428.txt 9 7 57 38 0.0387data7-9-57-09429.txt 9 7 57 42 0.4616data7-9-57-09430.txt 9 7 57 61 1.0271data7-9-57-09431.txt 9 7 57 37 0.5889data7-9-57-09432.txt 9 7 57 44 0.1405data7-9-57-09433.txt 9 7 57 43 0.5246data7-9-57-09434.txt 9 7 57 55 0.8704data7-9-57-09435.txt 9 7 57 60 1.0089data7-9-57-09436.txt 9 7 57 47 0.3754data7-9-57-09437.txt 9 7 57 44 0.3600data7-9-57-09438.txt 9 7 57 45 0.3681data7-9-57-09439.txt 9 7 57 44 0.2601data7-9-57-09440.txt 9 7 57 45 0.1034data7-9-57-09441.txt 9 7 57 56 0.9557data7-9-57-09442.txt 9 7 57 50 0.8737data7-9-57-09443.txt 9 7 57 64 0.9714data7-9-57-09444.txt 9 7 57 50 0.7494data7-9-57-09445.txt 9 7 57 53 1.0097data7-9-57-09446.txt 9 7 57 46 0.4087data7-9-57-09447.txt 9 7 57 45 0.4075data7-9-57-09448.txt 9 7 57 45 0.7139data7-9-57-09449.txt 9 7 57 46 0.3466data7-9-57-09450.txt 9 7 57 34 0.0686data7-9-57-09451.txt 9 7 57 50 0.4315data7-9-57-09452.txt 9 7 57 47 0.2708data7-9-57-09453.txt 9 7 57 52 0.7200data7-9-57-09454.txt 9 7 57 49 0.2091data7-9-57-09455.txt 9 7 57 48 0.5284data7-9-57-09456.txt 9 7 57 47 0.5860data7-9-57-09457.txt 9 7 57 49 0.8195data7-9-57-09458.txt 9 7 57 35 0.0546data7-9-57-09459.txt 9 7 57 53 0.8689data7-9-57-09460.txt 9 7 57 53 0.3944data7-9-57-09461.txt 9 7 57 49 0.4720data7-9-57-09462.txt 9 7 57 48 0.7222data7-9-57-09463.txt 9 7 57 48 0.8420data7-9-57-09464.txt 9 7 57 44 0.8656data7-9-57-09465.txt 9 7 57 41 0.3159data7-9-57-09466.txt 9 7 57 53 0.5625data7-9-57-09467.txt 9 7 57 42 0.6611data7-9-57-09468.txt 9 7 57 47 0.5097data7-9-57-09469.txt 9 7 57 47 0.8561data7-9-57-09470.txt 9 7 57 53 1.0165

Table 161: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 367: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-9-57-09471.txt 9 7 57 47 0.0246data7-9-57-09472.txt 9 7 57 46 0.9200data7-9-57-09473.txt 9 7 57 53 0.1000data7-9-57-09474.txt 9 7 57 54 0.8975data7-9-57-09475.txt 9 7 57 49 0.3233data7-9-57-09476.txt 9 7 57 53 1.0448data7-9-57-09477.txt 9 7 57 49 0.6810data7-9-57-09478.txt 9 7 57 49 0.1194data7-9-57-09479.txt 9 7 57 45 0.7846data7-9-57-09480.txt 9 7 57 52 0.6504data7-9-57-09481.txt 9 7 57 53 0.7140data7-9-57-09482.txt 9 7 57 43 0.5830data7-9-57-09483.txt 9 7 57 46 1.0754data7-9-57-09484.txt 9 7 57 47 0.5355data7-9-57-09485.txt 9 7 57 39 0.7347data7-9-57-09486.txt 9 7 57 43 1.0312data7-9-57-09487.txt 9 7 57 50 0.9109data7-9-57-09488.txt 9 7 57 52 0.5187data7-9-57-09489.txt 9 7 57 57 0.5822data7-9-57-09490.txt 9 7 57 60 0.7158data7-9-57-09491.txt 9 7 57 47 0.6998data7-9-57-09492.txt 9 7 57 44 0.4371data7-9-57-09493.txt 9 7 57 45 0.3330data7-9-57-09494.txt 9 7 57 56 0.7966data7-9-57-09495.txt 9 7 57 58 0.9543data7-9-57-09496.txt 9 7 57 55 0.8204data7-9-57-09497.txt 9 7 57 49 0.4549data7-9-57-09498.txt 9 7 57 51 1.0297data7-9-57-09499.txt 9 7 57 41 0.8107data7-9-57-09500.txt 9 7 57 49 0.9203data7-9-58-09501.txt 9 7 58 58 1.0555data7-9-58-09502.txt 9 7 58 54 0.9886data7-9-58-09503.txt 9 7 58 55 0.6887data7-9-58-09504.txt 9 7 58 49 0.4614data7-9-58-09505.txt 9 7 58 46 0.5764data7-9-58-09506.txt 9 7 58 49 0.8037data7-9-58-09507.txt 9 7 58 61 0.7677data7-9-58-09508.txt 9 7 58 48 0.2166data7-9-58-09509.txt 9 7 58 55 0.9880data7-9-58-09510.txt 9 7 58 51 0.7351data7-9-58-09511.txt 9 7 58 50 0.6032data7-9-58-09512.txt 9 7 58 54 0.8034data7-9-58-09513.txt 9 7 58 54 0.2167data7-9-58-09514.txt 9 7 58 46 0.1191data7-9-58-09515.txt 9 7 58 47 0.4042data7-9-58-09516.txt 9 7 58 43 1.0076data7-9-58-09517.txt 9 7 58 57 1.0465data7-9-58-09518.txt 9 7 58 41 0.8547data7-9-58-09519.txt 9 7 58 50 0.4259data7-9-58-09520.txt 9 7 58 52 0.9542data7-9-58-09521.txt 9 7 58 48 0.2330data7-9-58-09522.txt 9 7 58 56 0.4234data7-9-58-09523.txt 9 7 58 51 0.6040data7-9-58-09524.txt 9 7 58 58 0.4935data7-9-58-09525.txt 9 7 58 46 0.2455data7-9-58-09526.txt 9 7 58 55 0.9688data7-9-58-09527.txt 9 7 58 54 0.6305data7-9-58-09528.txt 9 7 58 45 0.0040data7-9-58-09529.txt 9 7 58 47 0.4808data7-9-58-09530.txt 9 7 58 54 0.8933data7-9-58-09531.txt 9 7 58 52 0.7774data7-9-58-09532.txt 9 7 58 57 0.8186data7-9-58-09533.txt 9 7 58 43 0.1330data7-9-58-09534.txt 9 7 58 46 0.5959data7-9-58-09535.txt 9 7 58 45 0.6591data7-9-58-09536.txt 9 7 58 52 1.0053data7-9-58-09537.txt 9 7 58 60 0.9271data7-9-58-09538.txt 9 7 58 61 0.5010data7-9-58-09539.txt 9 7 58 50 0.4876data7-9-58-09540.txt 9 7 58 56 0.5093

Table 162: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 368: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-9-58-09541.txt 9 7 58 53 0.8708data7-9-58-09542.txt 9 7 58 52 0.9433data7-9-58-09543.txt 9 7 58 54 0.4806data7-9-58-09544.txt 9 7 58 50 0.2365data7-9-58-09545.txt 9 7 58 47 0.6978data7-9-58-09546.txt 9 7 58 50 0.3325data7-9-58-09547.txt 9 7 58 53 0.6141data7-9-58-09548.txt 9 7 58 51 0.3103data7-9-58-09549.txt 9 7 58 53 0.3846data7-9-58-09550.txt 9 7 58 45 0.1408data7-9-58-09551.txt 9 7 58 49 0.3957data7-9-58-09552.txt 9 7 58 53 0.2159data7-9-58-09553.txt 9 7 58 55 0.6406data7-9-58-09554.txt 9 7 58 49 0.4605data7-9-58-09555.txt 9 7 58 53 1.0261data7-9-58-09556.txt 9 7 58 56 0.6874data7-9-58-09557.txt 9 7 58 46 0.4958data7-9-58-09558.txt 9 7 58 46 0.3763data7-9-58-09559.txt 9 7 58 41 0.0628data7-9-58-09560.txt 9 7 58 52 0.1787data7-9-58-09561.txt 9 7 58 48 0.8823data7-9-58-09562.txt 9 7 58 49 0.2022data7-9-58-09563.txt 9 7 58 53 0.0068data7-9-58-09564.txt 9 7 58 63 0.4177data7-9-58-09565.txt 9 7 58 51 0.1568data7-9-58-09566.txt 9 7 58 47 1.0953data7-9-58-09567.txt 9 7 58 47 0.9179data7-9-58-09568.txt 9 7 58 46 0.5629data7-9-58-09569.txt 9 7 58 59 0.3953data7-9-58-09570.txt 9 7 58 45 0.7083data7-9-58-09571.txt 9 7 58 43 0.3061data7-9-58-09572.txt 9 7 58 56 1.0151data7-9-58-09573.txt 9 7 58 52 0.4498data7-9-58-09574.txt 9 7 58 56 0.8347data7-9-58-09575.txt 9 7 58 58 0.4167data7-9-58-09576.txt 9 7 58 44 0.4888data7-9-58-09577.txt 9 7 58 57 1.0357data7-9-58-09578.txt 9 7 58 53 0.7802data7-9-58-09579.txt 9 7 58 56 1.0250data7-9-58-09580.txt 9 7 58 54 0.6680data7-9-58-09581.txt 9 7 58 55 0.7079data7-9-58-09582.txt 9 7 58 52 1.0460data7-9-58-09583.txt 9 7 58 43 0.1453data7-9-58-09584.txt 9 7 58 58 0.4312data7-9-58-09585.txt 9 7 58 60 1.0486data7-9-58-09586.txt 9 7 58 57 1.0344data7-9-58-09587.txt 9 7 58 51 1.0246data7-9-58-09588.txt 9 7 58 49 0.5898data7-9-58-09589.txt 9 7 58 46 0.8985data7-9-58-09590.txt 9 7 58 41 0.5549data7-9-58-09591.txt 9 7 58 53 0.6274data7-9-58-09592.txt 9 7 58 36 0.9918data7-9-58-09593.txt 9 7 58 47 0.4828data7-9-58-09594.txt 9 7 58 50 0.4515data7-9-58-09595.txt 9 7 58 54 1.0382data7-9-58-09596.txt 9 7 58 45 0.6457data7-9-58-09597.txt 9 7 58 53 0.5648data7-9-58-09598.txt 9 7 58 42 0.5453data7-9-58-09599.txt 9 7 58 67 0.4195data7-9-58-09600.txt 9 7 58 45 0.4899data7-9-59-09601.txt 9 7 59 56 0.4254data7-9-59-09602.txt 9 7 59 53 0.2918data7-9-59-09603.txt 9 7 59 57 0.1814data7-9-59-09604.txt 9 7 59 51 1.0455data7-9-59-09605.txt 9 7 59 49 0.5847data7-9-59-09606.txt 9 7 59 55 1.0250data7-9-59-09607.txt 9 7 59 57 0.4914data7-9-59-09608.txt 9 7 59 45 0.6461data7-9-59-09609.txt 9 7 59 56 0.5376data7-9-59-09610.txt 9 7 59 55 0.6670

Table 163: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 369: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-9-59-09611.txt 9 7 59 58 1.0393data7-9-59-09612.txt 9 7 59 50 0.2937data7-9-59-09613.txt 9 7 59 54 0.3186data7-9-59-09614.txt 9 7 59 69 0.2990data7-9-59-09615.txt 9 7 59 56 0.7215data7-9-59-09616.txt 9 7 59 51 0.8777data7-9-59-09617.txt 9 7 59 55 0.0589data7-9-59-09618.txt 9 7 59 63 1.0116data7-9-59-09619.txt 9 7 59 42 0.9536data7-9-59-09620.txt 9 7 59 49 0.2843data7-9-59-09621.txt 9 7 59 65 0.6691data7-9-59-09622.txt 9 7 59 56 0.4794data7-9-59-09623.txt 9 7 59 53 0.7124data7-9-59-09624.txt 9 7 59 49 0.2188data7-9-59-09625.txt 9 7 59 59 0.9446data7-9-59-09626.txt 9 7 59 52 0.6673data7-9-59-09627.txt 9 7 59 45 1.0429data7-9-59-09628.txt 9 7 59 51 0.2581data7-9-59-09629.txt 9 7 59 59 1.0142data7-9-59-09630.txt 9 7 59 55 1.0186data7-9-59-09631.txt 9 7 59 58 0.5488data7-9-59-09632.txt 9 7 59 50 0.9431data7-9-59-09633.txt 9 7 59 61 0.4378data7-9-59-09634.txt 9 7 59 46 0.3877data7-9-59-09635.txt 9 7 59 59 1.0654data7-9-59-09636.txt 9 7 59 51 0.5837data7-9-59-09637.txt 9 7 59 56 0.1506data7-9-59-09638.txt 9 7 59 49 0.6732data7-9-59-09639.txt 9 7 59 54 0.2571data7-9-59-09640.txt 9 7 59 58 0.9359data7-9-59-09641.txt 9 7 59 43 0.4150data7-9-59-09642.txt 9 7 59 39 0.4167data7-9-59-09643.txt 9 7 59 50 0.7021data7-9-59-09644.txt 9 7 59 55 0.6852data7-9-59-09645.txt 9 7 59 51 0.4774data7-9-59-09646.txt 9 7 59 52 0.2582data7-9-59-09647.txt 9 7 59 54 1.0161data7-9-59-09648.txt 9 7 59 56 1.0328data7-9-59-09649.txt 9 7 59 53 0.6461data7-9-59-09650.txt 9 7 59 56 0.9870data7-9-59-09651.txt 9 7 59 53 1.0562data7-9-59-09652.txt 9 7 59 52 0.3189data7-9-59-09653.txt 9 7 59 57 0.4642data7-9-59-09654.txt 9 7 59 54 1.0226data7-9-59-09655.txt 9 7 59 53 0.6726data7-9-59-09656.txt 9 7 59 57 0.5942data7-9-59-09657.txt 9 7 59 53 0.5006data7-9-59-09658.txt 9 7 59 55 0.0078data7-9-59-09659.txt 9 7 59 58 1.0094data7-9-59-09660.txt 9 7 59 56 0.6170data7-9-59-09661.txt 9 7 59 55 0.3683data7-9-59-09662.txt 9 7 59 47 0.6156data7-9-59-09663.txt 9 7 59 59 0.4375data7-9-59-09664.txt 9 7 59 63 1.0445data7-9-59-09665.txt 9 7 59 60 1.0593data7-9-59-09666.txt 9 7 59 58 1.0211data7-9-59-09667.txt 9 7 59 65 0.7379data7-9-59-09668.txt 9 7 59 52 0.7981data7-9-59-09669.txt 9 7 59 48 0.6721data7-9-59-09670.txt 9 7 59 48 1.0758data7-9-59-09671.txt 9 7 59 51 1.0807data7-9-59-09672.txt 9 7 59 52 0.3809data7-9-59-09673.txt 9 7 59 52 0.8897data7-9-59-09674.txt 9 7 59 45 1.0519data7-9-59-09675.txt 9 7 59 51 0.1697data7-9-59-09676.txt 9 7 59 46 0.2809data7-9-59-09677.txt 9 7 59 52 1.0527data7-9-59-09678.txt 9 7 59 51 0.2344data7-9-59-09679.txt 9 7 59 45 0.4436data7-9-59-09680.txt 9 7 59 52 0.4642

Table 164: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 370: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-9-59-09681.txt 9 7 59 60 0.9409data7-9-59-09682.txt 9 7 59 53 1.0205data7-9-59-09683.txt 9 7 59 46 0.9622data7-9-59-09684.txt 9 7 59 61 0.2324data7-9-59-09685.txt 9 7 59 62 0.9968data7-9-59-09686.txt 9 7 59 56 0.6430data7-9-59-09687.txt 9 7 59 68 0.8733data7-9-59-09688.txt 9 7 59 64 0.9494data7-9-59-09689.txt 9 7 59 52 0.6806data7-9-59-09690.txt 9 7 59 51 1.0096data7-9-59-09691.txt 9 7 59 49 0.3485data7-9-59-09692.txt 9 7 59 54 0.7659data7-9-59-09693.txt 9 7 59 52 0.5627data7-9-59-09694.txt 9 7 59 57 0.6335data7-9-59-09695.txt 9 7 59 56 0.7941data7-9-59-09696.txt 9 7 59 47 0.0041data7-9-59-09697.txt 9 7 59 50 0.3277data7-9-59-09698.txt 9 7 59 42 0.4879data7-9-59-09699.txt 9 7 59 45 0.5288data7-9-59-09700.txt 9 7 59 41 1.0365data7-9-60-09701.txt 9 7 60 61 0.1976data7-9-60-09702.txt 9 7 60 53 0.4636data7-9-60-09703.txt 9 7 60 53 0.1112data7-9-60-09704.txt 9 7 60 55 0.0893data7-9-60-09705.txt 9 7 60 54 0.3605data7-9-60-09706.txt 9 7 60 49 0.3359data7-9-60-09707.txt 9 7 60 50 0.3289data7-9-60-09708.txt 9 7 60 45 0.1689data7-9-60-09709.txt 9 7 60 55 0.5103data7-9-60-09710.txt 9 7 60 68 0.7574data7-9-60-09711.txt 9 7 60 57 0.4086data7-9-60-09712.txt 9 7 60 53 0.5931data7-9-60-09713.txt 9 7 60 56 0.1878data7-9-60-09714.txt 9 7 60 53 0.3454data7-9-60-09715.txt 9 7 60 59 0.4908data7-9-60-09716.txt 9 7 60 46 0.0849data7-9-60-09717.txt 9 7 60 51 0.1774data7-9-60-09718.txt 9 7 60 52 0.2163data7-9-60-09719.txt 9 7 60 59 0.3376data7-9-60-09720.txt 9 7 60 47 0.4192data7-9-60-09721.txt 9 7 60 56 0.3093data7-9-60-09722.txt 9 7 60 55 0.5020data7-9-60-09723.txt 9 7 60 46 0.0338data7-9-60-09724.txt 9 7 60 50 0.4723data7-9-60-09725.txt 9 7 60 53 0.4177data7-9-60-09726.txt 9 7 60 48 0.3505data7-9-60-09727.txt 9 7 60 51 0.5271data7-9-60-09728.txt 9 7 60 60 0.3828data7-9-60-09729.txt 9 7 60 46 0.2010data7-9-60-09730.txt 9 7 60 62 0.3498data7-9-60-09731.txt 9 7 60 45 0.1428data7-9-60-09732.txt 9 7 60 50 0.1335data7-9-60-09733.txt 9 7 60 56 0.2359data7-9-60-09734.txt 9 7 60 58 0.3520data7-9-60-09735.txt 9 7 60 54 0.4684data7-9-60-09736.txt 9 7 60 45 0.0874data7-9-60-09737.txt 9 7 60 61 0.4018data7-9-60-09738.txt 9 7 60 68 0.3961data7-9-60-09739.txt 9 7 60 49 0.1186data7-9-60-09740.txt 9 7 60 50 0.5451data7-9-60-09741.txt 9 7 60 56 0.3178data7-9-60-09742.txt 9 7 60 47 0.1257data7-9-60-09743.txt 9 7 60 55 0.4419data7-9-60-09744.txt 9 7 60 51 0.1828data7-9-60-09745.txt 9 7 60 45 0.3277data7-9-60-09746.txt 9 7 60 50 0.4141data7-9-60-09747.txt 9 7 60 53 0.2367data7-9-60-09748.txt 9 7 60 55 0.2781data7-9-60-09749.txt 9 7 60 57 0.1501data7-9-60-09750.txt 9 7 60 49 0.1369

Table 165: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 371: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-9-60-09751.txt 9 7 60 56 0.3135data7-9-60-09752.txt 9 7 60 69 0.5131data7-9-60-09753.txt 9 7 60 50 0.3079data7-9-60-09754.txt 9 7 60 50 0.4985data7-9-60-09755.txt 9 7 60 68 0.9120data7-9-60-09756.txt 9 7 60 62 0.3554data7-9-60-09757.txt 9 7 60 41 0.1070data7-9-60-09758.txt 9 7 60 64 0.4993data7-9-60-09759.txt 9 7 60 56 0.3574data7-9-60-09760.txt 9 7 60 52 0.2045data7-9-60-09761.txt 9 7 60 51 0.1538data7-9-60-09762.txt 9 7 60 56 0.0838data7-9-60-09763.txt 9 7 60 58 0.6059data7-9-60-09764.txt 9 7 60 48 0.4582data7-9-60-09765.txt 9 7 60 46 0.2852data7-9-60-09766.txt 9 7 60 59 0.3071data7-9-60-09767.txt 9 7 60 55 0.3826data7-9-60-09768.txt 9 7 60 63 0.4420data7-9-60-09769.txt 9 7 60 55 0.1867data7-9-60-09770.txt 9 7 60 59 0.4673data7-9-60-09771.txt 9 7 60 60 0.1563data7-9-60-09772.txt 9 7 60 51 0.2819data7-9-60-09773.txt 9 7 60 51 0.1519data7-9-60-09774.txt 9 7 60 53 0.2407data7-9-60-09775.txt 9 7 60 50 0.3711data7-9-60-09776.txt 9 7 60 52 0.2121data7-9-60-09777.txt 9 7 60 51 0.5797data7-9-60-09778.txt 9 7 60 63 0.3491data7-9-60-09779.txt 9 7 60 57 0.2731data7-9-60-09780.txt 9 7 60 67 0.6007data7-9-60-09781.txt 9 7 60 52 0.4152data7-9-60-09782.txt 9 7 60 48 0.0071data7-9-60-09783.txt 9 7 60 56 0.5997data7-9-60-09784.txt 9 7 60 69 0.3778data7-9-60-09785.txt 9 7 60 53 0.2635data7-9-60-09786.txt 9 7 60 45 0.3244data7-9-60-09787.txt 9 7 60 65 0.5384data7-9-60-09788.txt 9 7 60 47 0.4330data7-9-60-09789.txt 9 7 60 57 0.3984data7-9-60-09790.txt 9 7 60 51 0.2909data7-9-60-09791.txt 9 7 60 60 0.3067data7-9-60-09792.txt 9 7 60 55 0.4351data7-9-60-09793.txt 9 7 60 55 0.2007data7-9-60-09794.txt 9 7 60 57 0.3269data7-9-60-09795.txt 9 7 60 50 0.4320data7-9-60-09796.txt 9 7 60 55 0.4910data7-9-60-09797.txt 9 7 60 59 0.2460data7-9-60-09798.txt 9 7 60 50 0.3541data7-9-60-09799.txt 9 7 60 62 0.2037data7-9-60-09800.txt 9 7 60 59 0.0926data7-9-61-09801.txt 9 7 61 53 0.0081data7-9-61-09802.txt 9 7 61 58 0.4702data7-9-61-09803.txt 9 7 61 63 0.3416data7-9-61-09804.txt 9 7 61 54 0.3572data7-9-61-09805.txt 9 7 61 64 0.3987data7-9-61-09806.txt 9 7 61 41 0.4390data7-9-61-09807.txt 9 7 61 70 0.4426data7-9-61-09808.txt 9 7 61 56 0.1831data7-9-61-09809.txt 9 7 61 52 0.3659data7-9-61-09810.txt 9 7 61 48 0.6594data7-9-61-09811.txt 9 7 61 54 0.5106data7-9-61-09812.txt 9 7 61 56 0.5559data7-9-61-09813.txt 9 7 61 57 0.2903data7-9-61-09814.txt 9 7 61 63 0.4708data7-9-61-09815.txt 9 7 61 47 0.2880data7-9-61-09816.txt 9 7 61 55 0.1731data7-9-61-09817.txt 9 7 61 59 0.2917data7-9-61-09818.txt 9 7 61 47 0.1695data7-9-61-09819.txt 9 7 61 56 0.5647data7-9-61-09820.txt 9 7 61 55 0.3748

Table 166: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 372: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-9-61-09821.txt 9 7 61 56 0.4329data7-9-61-09822.txt 9 7 61 56 0.1690data7-9-61-09823.txt 9 7 61 48 0.1276data7-9-61-09824.txt 9 7 61 65 0.5438data7-9-61-09825.txt 9 7 61 44 0.2703data7-9-61-09826.txt 9 7 61 56 0.3479data7-9-61-09827.txt 9 7 61 55 0.2534data7-9-61-09828.txt 9 7 61 59 0.3729data7-9-61-09829.txt 9 7 61 51 0.1762data7-9-61-09830.txt 9 7 61 45 0.1170data7-9-61-09831.txt 9 7 61 48 0.2667data7-9-61-09832.txt 9 7 61 52 0.1923data7-9-61-09833.txt 9 7 61 55 0.3034data7-9-61-09834.txt 9 7 61 44 0.2608data7-9-61-09835.txt 9 7 61 51 0.1514data7-9-61-09836.txt 9 7 61 53 0.2483data7-9-61-09837.txt 9 7 61 48 0.5571data7-9-61-09838.txt 9 7 61 48 0.4677data7-9-61-09839.txt 9 7 61 48 0.3512data7-9-61-09840.txt 9 7 61 48 0.1691data7-9-61-09841.txt 9 7 61 56 0.0336data7-9-61-09842.txt 9 7 61 63 0.3539data7-9-61-09843.txt 9 7 61 67 0.3751data7-9-61-09844.txt 9 7 61 42 0.1915data7-9-61-09845.txt 9 7 61 64 0.6257data7-9-61-09846.txt 9 7 61 52 0.4502data7-9-61-09847.txt 9 7 61 58 0.2499data7-9-61-09848.txt 9 7 61 49 0.4020data7-9-61-09849.txt 9 7 61 62 0.3768data7-9-61-09850.txt 9 7 61 59 0.4067data7-9-61-09851.txt 9 7 61 53 0.3133data7-9-61-09852.txt 9 7 61 69 0.2108data7-9-61-09853.txt 9 7 61 47 0.4517data7-9-61-09854.txt 9 7 61 60 0.6764data7-9-61-09855.txt 9 7 61 57 0.3409data7-9-61-09856.txt 9 7 61 63 0.2957data7-9-61-09857.txt 9 7 61 60 0.4903data7-9-61-09858.txt 9 7 61 63 0.2676data7-9-61-09859.txt 9 7 61 58 0.2228data7-9-61-09860.txt 9 7 61 54 0.2958data7-9-61-09861.txt 9 7 61 49 0.1822data7-9-61-09862.txt 9 7 61 59 0.7012data7-9-61-09863.txt 9 7 61 50 0.1481data7-9-61-09864.txt 9 7 61 66 0.4643data7-9-61-09865.txt 9 7 61 50 0.3488data7-9-61-09866.txt 9 7 61 55 0.3442data7-9-61-09867.txt 9 7 61 60 0.1036data7-9-61-09868.txt 9 7 61 61 0.4712data7-9-61-09869.txt 9 7 61 61 0.2602data7-9-61-09870.txt 9 7 61 51 0.3219data7-9-61-09871.txt 9 7 61 55 0.1785data7-9-61-09872.txt 9 7 61 54 0.1851data7-9-61-09873.txt 9 7 61 56 0.2490data7-9-61-09874.txt 9 7 61 54 0.1700data7-9-61-09875.txt 9 7 61 58 0.4303data7-9-61-09876.txt 9 7 61 62 0.2696data7-9-61-09877.txt 9 7 61 56 0.4883data7-9-61-09878.txt 9 7 61 48 0.3222data7-9-61-09879.txt 9 7 61 53 0.3891data7-9-61-09880.txt 9 7 61 59 0.3866data7-9-61-09881.txt 9 7 61 56 0.0937data7-9-61-09882.txt 9 7 61 63 0.2201data7-9-61-09883.txt 9 7 61 63 0.4751data7-9-61-09884.txt 9 7 61 59 0.2406data7-9-61-09885.txt 9 7 61 46 0.0553data7-9-61-09886.txt 9 7 61 68 0.7106data7-9-61-09887.txt 9 7 61 46 0.2256data7-9-61-09888.txt 9 7 61 60 0.2595data7-9-61-09889.txt 9 7 61 54 0.2111data7-9-61-09890.txt 9 7 61 60 0.7570

Table 167: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 373: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-9-61-09891.txt 9 7 61 48 0.0224data7-9-61-09892.txt 9 7 61 56 0.2795data7-9-61-09893.txt 9 7 61 57 0.4293data7-9-61-09894.txt 9 7 61 53 0.3913data7-9-61-09895.txt 9 7 61 67 0.6817data7-9-61-09896.txt 9 7 61 51 0.1199data7-9-61-09897.txt 9 7 61 56 0.6544data7-9-61-09898.txt 9 7 61 54 0.2637data7-9-61-09899.txt 9 7 61 60 0.4489data7-9-61-09900.txt 9 7 61 54 0.2598data7-9-62-09901.txt 9 7 62 55 0.2661data7-9-62-09902.txt 9 7 62 56 0.4162data7-9-62-09903.txt 9 7 62 54 0.2392data7-9-62-09904.txt 9 7 62 54 0.2297data7-9-62-09905.txt 9 7 62 53 0.4707data7-9-62-09906.txt 9 7 62 53 0.2838data7-9-62-09907.txt 9 7 62 66 0.4891data7-9-62-09908.txt 9 7 62 54 0.3528data7-9-62-09909.txt 9 7 62 59 0.2928data7-9-62-09910.txt 9 7 62 55 0.3271data7-9-62-09911.txt 9 7 62 58 0.1902data7-9-62-09912.txt 9 7 62 56 0.3488data7-9-62-09913.txt 9 7 62 63 0.1496data7-9-62-09914.txt 9 7 62 54 0.3612data7-9-62-09915.txt 9 7 62 61 0.1548data7-9-62-09916.txt 9 7 62 66 0.3970data7-9-62-09917.txt 9 7 62 61 0.1381data7-9-62-09918.txt 9 7 62 48 0.0026data7-9-62-09919.txt 9 7 62 57 0.2046data7-9-62-09920.txt 9 7 62 61 0.1861data7-9-62-09921.txt 9 7 62 42 0.1371data7-9-62-09922.txt 9 7 62 49 0.0781data7-9-62-09923.txt 9 7 62 53 0.6081data7-9-62-09924.txt 9 7 62 62 0.5748data7-9-62-09925.txt 9 7 62 58 0.8473data7-9-62-09926.txt 9 7 62 65 0.3127data7-9-62-09927.txt 9 7 62 64 0.2748data7-9-62-09928.txt 9 7 62 53 0.3902data7-9-62-09929.txt 9 7 62 58 0.2641data7-9-62-09930.txt 9 7 62 58 0.3016data7-9-62-09931.txt 9 7 62 55 0.1872data7-9-62-09932.txt 9 7 62 53 0.0023data7-9-62-09933.txt 9 7 62 52 0.0129data7-9-62-09934.txt 9 7 62 51 0.3071data7-9-62-09935.txt 9 7 62 53 0.1754data7-9-62-09936.txt 9 7 62 61 0.4061data7-9-62-09937.txt 9 7 62 55 0.1911data7-9-62-09938.txt 9 7 62 50 0.4670data7-9-62-09939.txt 9 7 62 53 0.4880data7-9-62-09940.txt 9 7 62 59 0.4219data7-9-62-09941.txt 9 7 62 66 0.3575data7-9-62-09942.txt 9 7 62 47 0.6499data7-9-62-09943.txt 9 7 62 53 0.3521data7-9-62-09944.txt 9 7 62 48 0.1424data7-9-62-09945.txt 9 7 62 56 0.6311data7-9-62-09946.txt 9 7 62 50 0.1732data7-9-62-09947.txt 9 7 62 64 0.5049data7-9-62-09948.txt 9 7 62 60 0.4201data7-9-62-09949.txt 9 7 62 52 0.3477data7-9-62-09950.txt 9 7 62 60 0.5954data7-9-62-09951.txt 9 7 62 55 0.2295data7-9-62-09952.txt 9 7 62 57 0.3713data7-9-62-09953.txt 9 7 62 58 0.3363data7-9-62-09954.txt 9 7 62 52 0.3587data7-9-62-09955.txt 9 7 62 63 0.4399data7-9-62-09956.txt 9 7 62 48 0.4814data7-9-62-09957.txt 9 7 62 56 0.5246data7-9-62-09958.txt 9 7 62 52 0.4920data7-9-62-09959.txt 9 7 62 56 0.3048data7-9-62-09960.txt 9 7 62 53 0.2561

Table 168: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 374: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-9-62-09961.txt 9 7 62 61 0.1892data7-9-62-09962.txt 9 7 62 57 0.4959data7-9-62-09963.txt 9 7 62 53 0.0837data7-9-62-09964.txt 9 7 62 50 0.3571data7-9-62-09965.txt 9 7 62 53 0.1735data7-9-62-09966.txt 9 7 62 53 0.1501data7-9-62-09967.txt 9 7 62 63 0.5298data7-9-62-09968.txt 9 7 62 44 0.3470data7-9-62-09969.txt 9 7 62 52 0.2676data7-9-62-09970.txt 9 7 62 59 0.2822data7-9-62-09971.txt 9 7 62 56 0.3753data7-9-62-09972.txt 9 7 62 54 0.1588data7-9-62-09973.txt 9 7 62 51 0.4355data7-9-62-09974.txt 9 7 62 60 0.4487data7-9-62-09975.txt 9 7 62 43 0.1032data7-9-62-09976.txt 9 7 62 51 0.5173data7-9-62-09977.txt 9 7 62 52 0.6221data7-9-62-09978.txt 9 7 62 60 0.3053data7-9-62-09979.txt 9 7 62 49 0.2269data7-9-62-09980.txt 9 7 62 65 0.3581data7-9-62-09981.txt 9 7 62 57 0.1899data7-9-62-09982.txt 9 7 62 58 0.4787data7-9-62-09983.txt 9 7 62 52 0.4710data7-9-62-09984.txt 9 7 62 55 0.2036data7-9-62-09985.txt 9 7 62 58 0.2308data7-9-62-09986.txt 9 7 62 47 0.4142data7-9-62-09987.txt 9 7 62 47 0.2606data7-9-62-09988.txt 9 7 62 65 0.4840data7-9-62-09989.txt 9 7 62 57 0.1843data7-9-62-09990.txt 9 7 62 67 0.5411data7-9-62-09991.txt 9 7 62 53 0.2364data7-9-62-09992.txt 9 7 62 60 0.2068data7-9-62-09993.txt 9 7 62 68 0.3709data7-9-62-09994.txt 9 7 62 58 0.2410data7-9-62-09995.txt 9 7 62 53 0.2617data7-9-62-09996.txt 9 7 62 51 0.1915data7-9-62-09997.txt 9 7 62 52 0.1397data7-9-62-09998.txt 9 7 62 60 0.3977data7-9-62-09999.txt 9 7 62 62 0.2712data7-9-62-10000.txt 9 7 62 60 0.4270data7-10-63-11801.txt 10 7 63 49 0.2323data7-10-63-11802.txt 10 7 63 50 0.4082data7-10-63-11803.txt 10 7 63 64 0.4974data7-10-63-11804.txt 10 7 63 50 0.1120data7-10-63-11805.txt 10 7 63 53 0.2784data7-10-63-11806.txt 10 7 63 55 0.1958data7-10-63-11807.txt 10 7 63 53 0.5236data7-10-63-11808.txt 10 7 63 52 0.4310data7-10-63-11809.txt 10 7 63 57 0.9208data7-10-63-11810.txt 10 7 63 57 0.9572data7-10-63-11811.txt 10 7 63 54 0.4183data7-10-63-11812.txt 10 7 63 59 0.5750data7-10-63-11813.txt 10 7 63 51 0.4898data7-10-63-11814.txt 10 7 63 50 0.2244data7-10-63-11815.txt 10 7 63 52 0.4392data7-10-63-11816.txt 10 7 63 49 0.6712data7-10-63-11817.txt 10 7 63 56 0.8678data7-10-63-11818.txt 10 7 63 55 0.5153data7-10-63-11819.txt 10 7 63 46 0.3323data7-10-63-11820.txt 10 7 63 51 0.6213data7-10-63-11821.txt 10 7 63 57 0.4300data7-10-63-11822.txt 10 7 63 53 0.6120data7-10-63-11823.txt 10 7 63 51 0.3509data7-10-63-11824.txt 10 7 63 52 0.6310data7-10-63-11825.txt 10 7 63 52 0.1843data7-10-63-11826.txt 10 7 63 48 0.7021data7-10-63-11827.txt 10 7 63 50 0.3453data7-10-63-11828.txt 10 7 63 53 0.1875data7-10-63-11829.txt 10 7 63 52 0.3901data7-10-63-11830.txt 10 7 63 51 0.6863

Table 169: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 375: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-10-63-11831.txt 10 7 63 51 0.0733data7-10-63-11832.txt 10 7 63 63 0.5112data7-10-63-11833.txt 10 7 63 50 0.8495data7-10-63-11834.txt 10 7 63 56 0.8369data7-10-63-11835.txt 10 7 63 57 0.5968data7-10-63-11836.txt 10 7 63 56 0.8643data7-10-63-11837.txt 10 7 63 58 0.9190data7-10-63-11838.txt 10 7 63 54 0.8727data7-10-63-11839.txt 10 7 63 51 0.3528data7-10-63-11840.txt 10 7 63 54 0.3111data7-10-63-11841.txt 10 7 63 51 0.4093data7-10-63-11842.txt 10 7 63 47 0.7843data7-10-63-11843.txt 10 7 63 61 0.6178data7-10-63-11844.txt 10 7 63 58 0.4491data7-10-63-11845.txt 10 7 63 46 0.4387data7-10-63-11846.txt 10 7 63 52 0.3624data7-10-63-11847.txt 10 7 63 49 0.3747data7-10-63-11848.txt 10 7 63 48 0.6415data7-10-63-11849.txt 10 7 63 55 0.2599data7-10-63-11850.txt 10 7 63 51 0.3006data7-10-63-11851.txt 10 7 63 47 0.6936data7-10-63-11852.txt 10 7 63 57 0.6360data7-10-63-11853.txt 10 7 63 48 0.2476data7-10-63-11854.txt 10 7 63 50 0.1066data7-10-63-11855.txt 10 7 63 53 0.9409data7-10-63-11856.txt 10 7 63 53 0.7409data7-10-63-11857.txt 10 7 63 52 0.4472data7-10-63-11858.txt 10 7 63 45 0.4294data7-10-63-11859.txt 10 7 63 49 0.6346data7-10-63-11860.txt 10 7 63 53 0.8032data7-10-63-11861.txt 10 7 63 51 0.2361data7-10-63-11862.txt 10 7 63 55 0.3525data7-10-63-11863.txt 10 7 63 52 0.6643data7-10-63-11864.txt 10 7 63 60 0.6294data7-10-63-11865.txt 10 7 63 42 0.2311data7-10-63-11866.txt 10 7 63 53 0.2126data7-10-63-11867.txt 10 7 63 44 0.1614data7-10-63-11868.txt 10 7 63 54 0.2907data7-10-63-11869.txt 10 7 63 55 0.6492data7-10-63-11870.txt 10 7 63 50 0.2920data7-10-63-11871.txt 10 7 63 54 0.2650data7-10-63-11872.txt 10 7 63 52 0.4005data7-10-63-11873.txt 10 7 63 50 0.2364data7-10-63-11874.txt 10 7 63 48 0.2370data7-10-63-11875.txt 10 7 63 60 0.3910data7-10-63-11876.txt 10 7 63 57 0.4695data7-10-63-11877.txt 10 7 63 51 0.8439data7-10-63-11878.txt 10 7 63 46 0.3706data7-10-63-11879.txt 10 7 63 67 0.7457data7-10-63-11880.txt 10 7 63 55 0.4975data7-10-63-11881.txt 10 7 63 50 0.5777data7-10-63-11882.txt 10 7 63 57 0.5484data7-10-63-11883.txt 10 7 63 53 0.5768data7-10-63-11884.txt 10 7 63 49 0.5404data7-10-63-11885.txt 10 7 63 53 0.2465data7-10-63-11886.txt 10 7 63 55 0.2545data7-10-63-11887.txt 10 7 63 42 0.4614data7-10-63-11888.txt 10 7 63 51 0.6713data7-10-63-11889.txt 10 7 63 41 0.2904data7-10-63-11890.txt 10 7 63 53 0.8904data7-10-63-11891.txt 10 7 63 44 0.6819data7-10-63-11892.txt 10 7 63 49 0.1873data7-10-63-11893.txt 10 7 63 50 0.3963data7-10-63-11894.txt 10 7 63 55 0.5039data7-10-63-11895.txt 10 7 63 55 0.4804data7-10-63-11896.txt 10 7 63 60 0.4101data7-10-63-11897.txt 10 7 63 47 0.1750data7-10-63-11898.txt 10 7 63 53 0.5892data7-10-63-11899.txt 10 7 63 46 0.5536data7-10-63-11900.txt 10 7 63 50 0.3397

Table 170: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 376: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-10-64-11901.txt 10 7 64 62 0.3858data7-10-64-11902.txt 10 7 64 53 0.5159data7-10-64-11903.txt 10 7 64 70 0.3857data7-10-64-11904.txt 10 7 64 46 0.2255data7-10-64-11905.txt 10 7 64 59 0.7385data7-10-64-11906.txt 10 7 64 51 0.3804data7-10-64-11907.txt 10 7 64 47 0.5414data7-10-64-11908.txt 10 7 64 44 0.5226data7-10-64-11909.txt 10 7 64 65 0.8705data7-10-64-11910.txt 10 7 64 53 0.2647data7-10-64-11911.txt 10 7 64 59 0.3597data7-10-64-11912.txt 10 7 64 56 0.3898data7-10-64-11913.txt 10 7 64 58 0.5311data7-10-64-11914.txt 10 7 64 52 1.0176data7-10-64-11915.txt 10 7 64 47 0.6148data7-10-64-11916.txt 10 7 64 51 0.6221data7-10-64-11917.txt 10 7 64 54 0.3532data7-10-64-11918.txt 10 7 64 46 0.2120data7-10-64-11919.txt 10 7 64 57 0.3040data7-10-64-11920.txt 10 7 64 55 0.5307data7-10-64-11921.txt 10 7 64 60 0.3083data7-10-64-11922.txt 10 7 64 58 0.2561data7-10-64-11923.txt 10 7 64 62 0.6449data7-10-64-11924.txt 10 7 64 53 0.1086data7-10-64-11925.txt 10 7 64 46 0.0838data7-10-64-11926.txt 10 7 64 61 0.2327data7-10-64-11927.txt 10 7 64 45 0.4654data7-10-64-11928.txt 10 7 64 58 0.3661data7-10-64-11929.txt 10 7 64 54 0.5442data7-10-64-11930.txt 10 7 64 60 0.3047data7-10-64-11931.txt 10 7 64 69 0.5633data7-10-64-11932.txt 10 7 64 51 0.3272data7-10-64-11933.txt 10 7 64 53 0.1638data7-10-64-11934.txt 10 7 64 61 0.4497data7-10-64-11935.txt 10 7 64 60 0.4755data7-10-64-11936.txt 10 7 64 58 0.2653data7-10-64-11937.txt 10 7 64 50 0.5015data7-10-64-11938.txt 10 7 64 56 0.3636data7-10-64-11939.txt 10 7 64 60 0.2818data7-10-64-11940.txt 10 7 64 52 0.8854data7-10-64-11941.txt 10 7 64 51 0.7244data7-10-64-11942.txt 10 7 64 49 0.3309data7-10-64-11943.txt 10 7 64 56 0.7963data7-10-64-11944.txt 10 7 64 51 0.5021data7-10-64-11945.txt 10 7 64 58 0.1861data7-10-64-11946.txt 10 7 64 56 0.6793data7-10-64-11947.txt 10 7 64 53 0.4573data7-10-64-11948.txt 10 7 64 55 0.4554data7-10-64-11949.txt 10 7 64 61 0.9783data7-10-64-11950.txt 10 7 64 65 0.5871data7-10-64-11951.txt 10 7 64 59 0.4492data7-10-64-11952.txt 10 7 64 43 0.4766data7-10-64-11953.txt 10 7 64 41 0.2900data7-10-64-11954.txt 10 7 64 48 0.1142data7-10-64-11955.txt 10 7 64 60 0.7171data7-10-64-11956.txt 10 7 64 51 0.3723data7-10-64-11957.txt 10 7 64 59 0.3188data7-10-64-11958.txt 10 7 64 54 0.5727data7-10-64-11959.txt 10 7 64 56 0.6342data7-10-64-11960.txt 10 7 64 61 0.2445data7-10-64-11961.txt 10 7 64 54 0.4341data7-10-64-11962.txt 10 7 64 48 0.4939data7-10-64-11963.txt 10 7 64 54 0.6286data7-10-64-11964.txt 10 7 64 56 0.5641data7-10-64-11965.txt 10 7 64 49 0.5494data7-10-64-11966.txt 10 7 64 51 0.3745data7-10-64-11967.txt 10 7 64 52 0.3948data7-10-64-11968.txt 10 7 64 45 0.3973data7-10-64-11969.txt 10 7 64 54 0.2137data7-10-64-11970.txt 10 7 64 53 0.5329

Table 171: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 377: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-10-64-11971.txt 10 7 64 53 0.3350data7-10-64-11972.txt 10 7 64 58 0.6189data7-10-64-11973.txt 10 7 64 47 0.2130data7-10-64-11974.txt 10 7 64 47 0.1460data7-10-64-11975.txt 10 7 64 57 0.6170data7-10-64-11976.txt 10 7 64 61 0.4851data7-10-64-11977.txt 10 7 64 56 0.4067data7-10-64-11978.txt 10 7 64 48 0.4960data7-10-64-11979.txt 10 7 64 50 0.4926data7-10-64-11980.txt 10 7 64 57 0.2745data7-10-64-11981.txt 10 7 64 52 0.2286data7-10-64-11982.txt 10 7 64 52 0.0046data7-10-64-11983.txt 10 7 64 56 0.4487data7-10-64-11984.txt 10 7 64 56 0.3849data7-10-64-11985.txt 10 7 64 59 0.3202data7-10-64-11986.txt 10 7 64 55 0.5257data7-10-64-11987.txt 10 7 64 56 0.3297data7-10-64-11988.txt 10 7 64 59 0.2148data7-10-64-11989.txt 10 7 64 45 0.1683data7-10-64-11990.txt 10 7 64 56 0.5925data7-10-64-11991.txt 10 7 64 47 0.4102data7-10-64-11992.txt 10 7 64 55 0.2925data7-10-64-11993.txt 10 7 64 44 0.4773data7-10-64-11994.txt 10 7 64 60 0.2245data7-10-64-11995.txt 10 7 64 56 0.2958data7-10-64-11996.txt 10 7 64 51 0.0629data7-10-64-11997.txt 10 7 64 56 0.1186data7-10-64-11998.txt 10 7 64 49 0.0553data7-10-64-11999.txt 10 7 64 52 0.3181data7-10-64-12000.txt 10 7 64 54 0.3838data7-10-65-12001.txt 10 7 65 49 0.3309data7-10-65-12002.txt 10 7 65 58 0.5044data7-10-65-12003.txt 10 7 65 58 0.6125data7-10-65-12004.txt 10 7 65 57 0.3695data7-10-65-12005.txt 10 7 65 51 0.3629data7-10-65-12006.txt 10 7 65 58 0.5300data7-10-65-12007.txt 10 7 65 58 0.6672data7-10-65-12008.txt 10 7 65 54 0.0135data7-10-65-12009.txt 10 7 65 52 0.5508data7-10-65-12010.txt 10 7 65 59 0.8406data7-10-65-12011.txt 10 7 65 58 0.4071data7-10-65-12012.txt 10 7 65 60 0.4728data7-10-65-12013.txt 10 7 65 59 0.4880data7-10-65-12014.txt 10 7 65 53 0.5450data7-10-65-12015.txt 10 7 65 64 0.5794data7-10-65-12016.txt 10 7 65 55 0.2762data7-10-65-12017.txt 10 7 65 63 0.6693data7-10-65-12018.txt 10 7 65 52 0.0866data7-10-65-12019.txt 10 7 65 56 0.1488data7-10-65-12020.txt 10 7 65 54 0.3080data7-10-65-12021.txt 10 7 65 57 0.6519data7-10-65-12022.txt 10 7 65 50 0.4315data7-10-65-12023.txt 10 7 65 61 0.7298data7-10-65-12024.txt 10 7 65 59 0.3458data7-10-65-12025.txt 10 7 65 64 0.2302data7-10-65-12026.txt 10 7 65 63 0.5965data7-10-65-12027.txt 10 7 65 56 0.3734data7-10-65-12028.txt 10 7 65 68 1.0095data7-10-65-12029.txt 10 7 65 52 0.4782data7-10-65-12030.txt 10 7 65 63 0.2221data7-10-65-12031.txt 10 7 65 55 0.8260data7-10-65-12032.txt 10 7 65 58 0.3605data7-10-65-12033.txt 10 7 65 50 0.2128data7-10-65-12034.txt 10 7 65 57 0.4780data7-10-65-12035.txt 10 7 65 57 0.4572data7-10-65-12036.txt 10 7 65 61 0.9380data7-10-65-12037.txt 10 7 65 50 0.5106data7-10-65-12038.txt 10 7 65 50 0.8786data7-10-65-12039.txt 10 7 65 48 0.0333data7-10-65-12040.txt 10 7 65 48 0.6150

Table 172: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 378: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-10-65-12041.txt 10 7 65 47 0.3192data7-10-65-12042.txt 10 7 65 63 0.7690data7-10-65-12043.txt 10 7 65 49 0.4672data7-10-65-12044.txt 10 7 65 61 0.4062data7-10-65-12045.txt 10 7 65 55 0.2987data7-10-65-12046.txt 10 7 65 59 0.3764data7-10-65-12047.txt 10 7 65 67 0.6250data7-10-65-12048.txt 10 7 65 50 0.9163data7-10-65-12049.txt 10 7 65 66 0.3111data7-10-65-12050.txt 10 7 65 47 0.2208data7-10-65-12051.txt 10 7 65 60 0.3503data7-10-65-12052.txt 10 7 65 54 0.3141data7-10-65-12053.txt 10 7 65 70 0.3712data7-10-65-12054.txt 10 7 65 60 0.2160data7-10-65-12055.txt 10 7 65 55 0.4327data7-10-65-12056.txt 10 7 65 65 0.4520data7-10-65-12057.txt 10 7 65 56 0.5876data7-10-65-12058.txt 10 7 65 53 0.2559data7-10-65-12059.txt 10 7 65 53 0.5833data7-10-65-12060.txt 10 7 65 59 0.5119data7-10-65-12061.txt 10 7 65 62 0.7380data7-10-65-12062.txt 10 7 65 59 0.4631data7-10-65-12063.txt 10 7 65 59 0.5748data7-10-65-12064.txt 10 7 65 61 0.5116data7-10-65-12065.txt 10 7 65 61 0.5408data7-10-65-12066.txt 10 7 65 57 0.3563data7-10-65-12067.txt 10 7 65 56 0.7918data7-10-65-12068.txt 10 7 65 56 0.3393data7-10-65-12069.txt 10 7 65 51 0.2673data7-10-65-12070.txt 10 7 65 51 0.1942data7-10-65-12071.txt 10 7 65 58 0.3768data7-10-65-12072.txt 10 7 65 64 0.4749data7-10-65-12073.txt 10 7 65 62 0.3815data7-10-65-12074.txt 10 7 65 53 0.2918data7-10-65-12075.txt 10 7 65 69 0.7213data7-10-65-12076.txt 10 7 65 50 0.4181data7-10-65-12077.txt 10 7 65 54 0.1524data7-10-65-12078.txt 10 7 65 55 0.2859data7-10-65-12079.txt 10 7 65 58 0.0160data7-10-65-12080.txt 10 7 65 46 0.7112data7-10-65-12081.txt 10 7 65 65 0.5792data7-10-65-12082.txt 10 7 65 64 0.8988data7-10-65-12083.txt 10 7 65 58 0.5201data7-10-65-12084.txt 10 7 65 60 0.7024data7-10-65-12085.txt 10 7 65 61 0.2818data7-10-65-12086.txt 10 7 65 60 0.0023data7-10-65-12087.txt 10 7 65 56 0.4936data7-10-65-12088.txt 10 7 65 56 0.5774data7-10-65-12089.txt 10 7 65 57 0.6021data7-10-65-12090.txt 10 7 65 54 0.3313data7-10-65-12091.txt 10 7 65 55 0.3063data7-10-65-12092.txt 10 7 65 55 0.4076data7-10-65-12093.txt 10 7 65 56 0.5690data7-10-65-12094.txt 10 7 65 53 0.2857data7-10-65-12095.txt 10 7 65 52 0.6939data7-10-65-12096.txt 10 7 65 56 0.3146data7-10-65-12097.txt 10 7 65 53 0.3162data7-10-65-12098.txt 10 7 65 56 0.2960data7-10-65-12099.txt 10 7 65 60 0.9528data7-10-65-12100.txt 10 7 65 58 0.4428data7-10-66-12101.txt 10 7 66 56 0.2650data7-10-66-12102.txt 10 7 66 44 0.4311data7-10-66-12103.txt 10 7 66 56 0.2716data7-10-66-12104.txt 10 7 66 59 0.3558data7-10-66-12105.txt 10 7 66 50 0.3515data7-10-66-12106.txt 10 7 66 53 0.5803data7-10-66-12107.txt 10 7 66 59 0.1685data7-10-66-12108.txt 10 7 66 61 0.1921data7-10-66-12109.txt 10 7 66 66 0.7924data7-10-66-12110.txt 10 7 66 60 0.2586

Table 173: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 379: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-10-66-12111.txt 10 7 66 51 0.2325data7-10-66-12112.txt 10 7 66 50 0.2765data7-10-66-12113.txt 10 7 66 63 0.7303data7-10-66-12114.txt 10 7 66 58 0.5623data7-10-66-12115.txt 10 7 66 54 0.6831data7-10-66-12116.txt 10 7 66 58 0.1720data7-10-66-12117.txt 10 7 66 50 0.0665data7-10-66-12118.txt 10 7 66 63 0.1247data7-10-66-12119.txt 10 7 66 58 0.2440data7-10-66-12120.txt 10 7 66 49 0.5090data7-10-66-12121.txt 10 7 66 56 0.1734data7-10-66-12122.txt 10 7 66 52 0.6324data7-10-66-12123.txt 10 7 66 64 0.6015data7-10-66-12124.txt 10 7 66 51 0.1083data7-10-66-12125.txt 10 7 66 59 0.5685data7-10-66-12126.txt 10 7 66 53 0.4726data7-10-66-12127.txt 10 7 66 51 0.5052data7-10-66-12128.txt 10 7 66 53 0.0550data7-10-66-12129.txt 10 7 66 52 0.3409data7-10-66-12130.txt 10 7 66 59 0.7321data7-10-66-12131.txt 10 7 66 59 0.6507data7-10-66-12132.txt 10 7 66 65 0.4618data7-10-66-12133.txt 10 7 66 63 0.4625data7-10-66-12134.txt 10 7 66 58 0.0183data7-10-66-12135.txt 10 7 66 57 0.3795data7-10-66-12136.txt 10 7 66 61 0.3852data7-10-66-12137.txt 10 7 66 74 0.4738data7-10-66-12138.txt 10 7 66 53 0.1613data7-10-66-12139.txt 10 7 66 62 0.6478data7-10-66-12140.txt 10 7 66 56 0.1710data7-10-66-12141.txt 10 7 66 60 0.2675data7-10-66-12142.txt 10 7 66 46 0.1644data7-10-66-12143.txt 10 7 66 56 1.0082data7-10-66-12144.txt 10 7 66 65 0.6717data7-10-66-12145.txt 10 7 66 77 0.6853data7-10-66-12146.txt 10 7 66 57 0.7022data7-10-66-12147.txt 10 7 66 59 0.4439data7-10-66-12148.txt 10 7 66 58 0.2551data7-10-66-12149.txt 10 7 66 53 0.2548data7-10-66-12150.txt 10 7 66 55 0.0505data7-10-66-12151.txt 10 7 66 56 0.4085data7-10-66-12152.txt 10 7 66 51 0.4713data7-10-66-12153.txt 10 7 66 57 0.3736data7-10-66-12154.txt 10 7 66 52 0.4015data7-10-66-12155.txt 10 7 66 59 0.8235data7-10-66-12156.txt 10 7 66 62 0.4857data7-10-66-12157.txt 10 7 66 59 0.4080data7-10-66-12158.txt 10 7 66 61 0.2771data7-10-66-12159.txt 10 7 66 53 0.3277data7-10-66-12160.txt 10 7 66 54 0.3252data7-10-66-12161.txt 10 7 66 54 0.2020data7-10-66-12162.txt 10 7 66 57 0.0038data7-10-66-12163.txt 10 7 66 60 0.1714data7-10-66-12164.txt 10 7 66 53 0.7308data7-10-66-12165.txt 10 7 66 61 0.3726data7-10-66-12166.txt 10 7 66 55 0.3782data7-10-66-12167.txt 10 7 66 48 0.2824data7-10-66-12168.txt 10 7 66 58 0.5359data7-10-66-12169.txt 10 7 66 59 0.2292data7-10-66-12170.txt 10 7 66 53 0.1213data7-10-66-12171.txt 10 7 66 61 0.8414data7-10-66-12172.txt 10 7 66 54 0.5837data7-10-66-12173.txt 10 7 66 51 0.4386data7-10-66-12174.txt 10 7 66 65 0.5163data7-10-66-12175.txt 10 7 66 59 0.4831data7-10-66-12176.txt 10 7 66 67 0.6305data7-10-66-12177.txt 10 7 66 61 0.6367data7-10-66-12178.txt 10 7 66 63 0.3700data7-10-66-12179.txt 10 7 66 59 0.0329data7-10-66-12180.txt 10 7 66 67 0.6892

Table 174: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 380: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-10-66-12181.txt 10 7 66 49 0.2442data7-10-66-12182.txt 10 7 66 63 0.1661data7-10-66-12183.txt 10 7 66 53 0.2952data7-10-66-12184.txt 10 7 66 56 0.5863data7-10-66-12185.txt 10 7 66 52 0.3693data7-10-66-12186.txt 10 7 66 56 0.6893data7-10-66-12187.txt 10 7 66 48 0.3114data7-10-66-12188.txt 10 7 66 51 0.2635data7-10-66-12189.txt 10 7 66 44 0.0516data7-10-66-12190.txt 10 7 66 45 0.1111data7-10-66-12191.txt 10 7 66 54 0.2598data7-10-66-12192.txt 10 7 66 61 0.3006data7-10-66-12193.txt 10 7 66 63 0.5545data7-10-66-12194.txt 10 7 66 50 0.2396data7-10-66-12195.txt 10 7 66 61 0.5239data7-10-66-12196.txt 10 7 66 58 0.5201data7-10-66-12197.txt 10 7 66 64 1.0213data7-10-66-12198.txt 10 7 66 48 0.2572data7-10-66-12199.txt 10 7 66 59 0.1079data7-10-66-12200.txt 10 7 66 52 0.3944data7-10-67-12201.txt 10 7 67 65 0.4052data7-10-67-12202.txt 10 7 67 61 0.5910data7-10-67-12203.txt 10 7 67 58 0.1330data7-10-67-12204.txt 10 7 67 48 0.6186data7-10-67-12205.txt 10 7 67 53 0.4810data7-10-67-12206.txt 10 7 67 66 0.4047data7-10-67-12207.txt 10 7 67 56 0.0536data7-10-67-12208.txt 10 7 67 59 0.2978data7-10-67-12209.txt 10 7 67 56 0.4510data7-10-67-12210.txt 10 7 67 75 0.9572data7-10-67-12211.txt 10 7 67 67 0.5472data7-10-67-12212.txt 10 7 67 54 0.1392data7-10-67-12213.txt 10 7 67 60 0.7088data7-10-67-12214.txt 10 7 67 48 0.1682data7-10-67-12215.txt 10 7 67 60 0.3554data7-10-67-12216.txt 10 7 67 59 0.3713data7-10-67-12217.txt 10 7 67 61 0.4224data7-10-67-12218.txt 10 7 67 61 0.4226data7-10-67-12219.txt 10 7 67 47 0.2055data7-10-67-12220.txt 10 7 67 67 0.8260data7-10-67-12221.txt 10 7 67 67 0.5179data7-10-67-12222.txt 10 7 67 51 0.0869data7-10-67-12223.txt 10 7 67 49 0.0376data7-10-67-12224.txt 10 7 67 64 0.3723data7-10-67-12225.txt 10 7 67 54 0.3932data7-10-67-12226.txt 10 7 67 60 0.3046data7-10-67-12227.txt 10 7 67 61 0.4085data7-10-67-12228.txt 10 7 67 60 0.3593data7-10-67-12229.txt 10 7 67 60 0.5522data7-10-67-12230.txt 10 7 67 57 0.2933data7-10-67-12231.txt 10 7 67 66 0.3176data7-10-67-12232.txt 10 7 67 49 0.1147data7-10-67-12233.txt 10 7 67 68 0.2900data7-10-67-12234.txt 10 7 67 67 0.5806data7-10-67-12235.txt 10 7 67 65 0.6014data7-10-67-12236.txt 10 7 67 59 0.7063data7-10-67-12237.txt 10 7 67 54 0.1993data7-10-67-12238.txt 10 7 67 55 0.6629data7-10-67-12239.txt 10 7 67 69 0.2492data7-10-67-12240.txt 10 7 67 52 0.0595data7-10-67-12241.txt 10 7 67 52 0.3261data7-10-67-12242.txt 10 7 67 58 0.5238data7-10-67-12243.txt 10 7 67 57 0.4586data7-10-67-12244.txt 10 7 67 59 0.5577data7-10-67-12245.txt 10 7 67 57 0.4350data7-10-67-12246.txt 10 7 67 63 0.3958data7-10-67-12247.txt 10 7 67 61 0.3019data7-10-67-12248.txt 10 7 67 68 0.3298data7-10-67-12249.txt 10 7 67 54 0.7512data7-10-67-12250.txt 10 7 67 47 0.1614

Table 175: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 381: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-10-67-12251.txt 10 7 67 54 0.0778data7-10-67-12252.txt 10 7 67 64 0.5697data7-10-67-12253.txt 10 7 67 64 0.2213data7-10-67-12254.txt 10 7 67 58 0.6676data7-10-67-12255.txt 10 7 67 57 0.5152data7-10-67-12256.txt 10 7 67 58 0.1253data7-10-67-12257.txt 10 7 67 55 0.9927data7-10-67-12258.txt 10 7 67 63 0.5647data7-10-67-12259.txt 10 7 67 63 0.7229data7-10-67-12260.txt 10 7 67 62 0.7265data7-10-67-12261.txt 10 7 67 65 0.3561data7-10-67-12262.txt 10 7 67 66 0.3728data7-10-67-12263.txt 10 7 67 51 0.1506data7-10-67-12264.txt 10 7 67 60 0.6168data7-10-67-12265.txt 10 7 67 56 0.8470data7-10-67-12266.txt 10 7 67 60 0.4519data7-10-67-12267.txt 10 7 67 56 0.6404data7-10-67-12268.txt 10 7 67 66 0.9429data7-10-67-12269.txt 10 7 67 60 0.3648data7-10-67-12270.txt 10 7 67 62 0.4878data7-10-67-12271.txt 10 7 67 71 0.5500data7-10-67-12272.txt 10 7 67 63 0.4227data7-10-67-12273.txt 10 7 67 63 0.4840data7-10-67-12274.txt 10 7 67 50 0.6242data7-10-67-12275.txt 10 7 67 59 0.2606data7-10-67-12276.txt 10 7 67 59 0.4264data7-10-67-12277.txt 10 7 67 67 0.5414data7-10-67-12278.txt 10 7 67 44 0.0072data7-10-67-12279.txt 10 7 67 54 0.7078data7-10-67-12280.txt 10 7 67 60 0.7174data7-10-67-12281.txt 10 7 67 56 0.6853data7-10-67-12282.txt 10 7 67 67 0.7961data7-10-67-12283.txt 10 7 67 61 0.4059data7-10-67-12284.txt 10 7 67 58 0.6232data7-10-67-12285.txt 10 7 67 57 0.2465data7-10-67-12286.txt 10 7 67 63 0.3248data7-10-67-12287.txt 10 7 67 59 0.3031data7-10-67-12288.txt 10 7 67 66 0.5010data7-10-67-12289.txt 10 7 67 55 0.2795data7-10-67-12290.txt 10 7 67 56 0.6904data7-10-67-12291.txt 10 7 67 59 0.6193data7-10-67-12292.txt 10 7 67 63 0.5509data7-10-67-12293.txt 10 7 67 65 0.8601data7-10-67-12294.txt 10 7 67 62 0.5801data7-10-67-12295.txt 10 7 67 59 0.6161data7-10-67-12296.txt 10 7 67 59 0.7144data7-10-67-12297.txt 10 7 67 59 0.2396data7-10-67-12298.txt 10 7 67 56 0.4265data7-10-67-12299.txt 10 7 67 61 0.6799data7-10-67-12300.txt 10 7 67 58 0.4122data7-10-68-12301.txt 10 7 68 68 0.3733data7-10-68-12302.txt 10 7 68 69 0.4398data7-10-68-12303.txt 10 7 68 51 0.7322data7-10-68-12304.txt 10 7 68 57 0.6566data7-10-68-12305.txt 10 7 68 54 0.4251data7-10-68-12306.txt 10 7 68 59 0.9751data7-10-68-12307.txt 10 7 68 58 0.4995data7-10-68-12308.txt 10 7 68 51 0.2988data7-10-68-12309.txt 10 7 68 51 0.2722data7-10-68-12310.txt 10 7 68 58 0.1664data7-10-68-12311.txt 10 7 68 54 0.1585data7-10-68-12312.txt 10 7 68 67 0.2161data7-10-68-12313.txt 10 7 68 60 0.3429data7-10-68-12314.txt 10 7 68 64 0.4493data7-10-68-12315.txt 10 7 68 56 0.6946data7-10-68-12316.txt 10 7 68 64 0.3623data7-10-68-12317.txt 10 7 68 55 0.3253data7-10-68-12318.txt 10 7 68 60 0.7284data7-10-68-12319.txt 10 7 68 65 0.1603data7-10-68-12320.txt 10 7 68 55 0.3312

Table 176: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 382: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-10-68-12321.txt 10 7 68 53 0.3291data7-10-68-12322.txt 10 7 68 70 0.4253data7-10-68-12323.txt 10 7 68 67 0.7796data7-10-68-12324.txt 10 7 68 60 0.3005data7-10-68-12325.txt 10 7 68 51 0.4655data7-10-68-12326.txt 10 7 68 65 0.5312data7-10-68-12327.txt 10 7 68 60 0.5478data7-10-68-12328.txt 10 7 68 54 0.4977data7-10-68-12329.txt 10 7 68 59 0.3588data7-10-68-12330.txt 10 7 68 53 0.2046data7-10-68-12331.txt 10 7 68 53 0.1681data7-10-68-12332.txt 10 7 68 63 0.3244data7-10-68-12333.txt 10 7 68 65 0.6966data7-10-68-12334.txt 10 7 68 60 0.5404data7-10-68-12335.txt 10 7 68 58 0.3448data7-10-68-12336.txt 10 7 68 63 0.4988data7-10-68-12337.txt 10 7 68 52 0.5397data7-10-68-12338.txt 10 7 68 70 0.4394data7-10-68-12339.txt 10 7 68 59 0.4317data7-10-68-12340.txt 10 7 68 51 0.2951data7-10-68-12341.txt 10 7 68 60 0.7331data7-10-68-12342.txt 10 7 68 57 0.3342data7-10-68-12343.txt 10 7 68 61 0.2391data7-10-68-12344.txt 10 7 68 58 0.3222data7-10-68-12345.txt 10 7 68 70 0.3031data7-10-68-12346.txt 10 7 68 52 0.3139data7-10-68-12347.txt 10 7 68 66 0.6585data7-10-68-12348.txt 10 7 68 64 0.3200data7-10-68-12349.txt 10 7 68 61 0.4305data7-10-68-12350.txt 10 7 68 57 0.3002data7-10-68-12351.txt 10 7 68 59 0.3074data7-10-68-12352.txt 10 7 68 66 0.3316data7-10-68-12353.txt 10 7 68 62 0.4833data7-10-68-12354.txt 10 7 68 64 0.3177data7-10-68-12355.txt 10 7 68 66 0.9228data7-10-68-12356.txt 10 7 68 57 0.5130data7-10-68-12357.txt 10 7 68 61 0.4677data7-10-68-12358.txt 10 7 68 56 0.2295data7-10-68-12359.txt 10 7 68 57 0.4660data7-10-68-12360.txt 10 7 68 61 0.4675data7-10-68-12361.txt 10 7 68 66 0.2189data7-10-68-12362.txt 10 7 68 63 0.4097data7-10-68-12363.txt 10 7 68 69 0.6448data7-10-68-12364.txt 10 7 68 55 0.1249data7-10-68-12365.txt 10 7 68 57 0.4302data7-10-68-12366.txt 10 7 68 57 0.2891data7-10-68-12367.txt 10 7 68 60 0.4564data7-10-68-12368.txt 10 7 68 68 0.4439data7-10-68-12369.txt 10 7 68 53 0.3712data7-10-68-12370.txt 10 7 68 58 0.6022data7-10-68-12371.txt 10 7 68 62 0.2180data7-10-68-12372.txt 10 7 68 66 0.6426data7-10-68-12373.txt 10 7 68 61 0.5060data7-10-68-12374.txt 10 7 68 65 0.3216data7-10-68-12375.txt 10 7 68 53 0.3885data7-10-68-12376.txt 10 7 68 58 0.6776data7-10-68-12377.txt 10 7 68 58 0.2290data7-10-68-12378.txt 10 7 68 51 0.4947data7-10-68-12379.txt 10 7 68 61 0.2642data7-10-68-12380.txt 10 7 68 58 0.4309data7-10-68-12381.txt 10 7 68 58 0.2833data7-10-68-12382.txt 10 7 68 59 0.5013data7-10-68-12383.txt 10 7 68 70 0.5636data7-10-68-12384.txt 10 7 68 51 0.1459data7-10-68-12385.txt 10 7 68 67 0.7333data7-10-68-12386.txt 10 7 68 59 0.2706data7-10-68-12387.txt 10 7 68 59 0.3637data7-10-68-12388.txt 10 7 68 64 0.3943data7-10-68-12389.txt 10 7 68 53 0.7641data7-10-68-12390.txt 10 7 68 58 0.3098

Table 177: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 383: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-10-68-12391.txt 10 7 68 62 0.3329data7-10-68-12392.txt 10 7 68 59 0.0610data7-10-68-12393.txt 10 7 68 64 0.5671data7-10-68-12394.txt 10 7 68 55 0.5948data7-10-68-12395.txt 10 7 68 62 0.7617data7-10-68-12396.txt 10 7 68 66 0.2517data7-10-68-12397.txt 10 7 68 60 0.5202data7-10-68-12398.txt 10 7 68 64 0.3157data7-10-68-12399.txt 10 7 68 57 0.4879data7-10-68-12400.txt 10 7 68 58 0.4746data7-10-69-12401.txt 10 7 69 54 0.3068data7-10-69-12402.txt 10 7 69 60 0.2581data7-10-69-12403.txt 10 7 69 62 0.5386data7-10-69-12404.txt 10 7 69 59 0.4501data7-10-69-12405.txt 10 7 69 69 0.7127data7-10-69-12406.txt 10 7 69 69 0.2229data7-10-69-12407.txt 10 7 69 70 0.6479data7-10-69-12408.txt 10 7 69 72 0.3869data7-10-69-12409.txt 10 7 69 55 0.2575data7-10-69-12410.txt 10 7 69 59 0.2978data7-10-69-12411.txt 10 7 69 53 0.5094data7-10-69-12412.txt 10 7 69 62 0.2915data7-10-69-12413.txt 10 7 69 64 0.7491data7-10-69-12414.txt 10 7 69 59 0.6815data7-10-69-12415.txt 10 7 69 45 0.2879data7-10-69-12416.txt 10 7 69 58 0.3164data7-10-69-12417.txt 10 7 69 56 0.3373data7-10-69-12418.txt 10 7 69 72 0.7272data7-10-69-12419.txt 10 7 69 71 0.3773data7-10-69-12420.txt 10 7 69 57 0.4997data7-10-69-12421.txt 10 7 69 60 0.5372data7-10-69-12422.txt 10 7 69 64 0.2233data7-10-69-12423.txt 10 7 69 67 0.7048data7-10-69-12424.txt 10 7 69 53 0.2524data7-10-69-12425.txt 10 7 69 57 0.3926data7-10-69-12426.txt 10 7 69 64 0.2654data7-10-69-12427.txt 10 7 69 68 0.6279data7-10-69-12428.txt 10 7 69 58 0.2451data7-10-69-12429.txt 10 7 69 63 0.6446data7-10-69-12430.txt 10 7 69 59 0.2021data7-10-69-12431.txt 10 7 69 61 0.6981data7-10-69-12432.txt 10 7 69 64 0.7921data7-10-69-12433.txt 10 7 69 71 0.8130data7-10-69-12434.txt 10 7 69 57 0.2575data7-10-69-12435.txt 10 7 69 55 0.2645data7-10-69-12436.txt 10 7 69 60 1.0041data7-10-69-12437.txt 10 7 69 68 0.8554data7-10-69-12438.txt 10 7 69 56 0.3840data7-10-69-12439.txt 10 7 69 65 0.6374data7-10-69-12440.txt 10 7 69 64 0.3476data7-10-69-12441.txt 10 7 69 61 0.0353data7-10-69-12442.txt 10 7 69 57 0.3951data7-10-69-12443.txt 10 7 69 60 0.7263data7-10-69-12444.txt 10 7 69 61 0.1908data7-10-69-12445.txt 10 7 69 64 0.5538data7-10-69-12446.txt 10 7 69 65 0.3544data7-10-69-12447.txt 10 7 69 62 0.3092data7-10-69-12448.txt 10 7 69 65 0.1191data7-10-69-12449.txt 10 7 69 64 0.5310data7-10-69-12450.txt 10 7 69 57 0.5917data7-10-69-12451.txt 10 7 69 61 0.3612data7-10-69-12452.txt 10 7 69 62 0.7647data7-10-69-12453.txt 10 7 69 70 0.3414data7-10-69-12454.txt 10 7 69 78 0.2266data7-10-69-12455.txt 10 7 69 57 0.0801data7-10-69-12456.txt 10 7 69 59 0.0074data7-10-69-12457.txt 10 7 69 66 0.6342data7-10-69-12458.txt 10 7 69 67 0.3502data7-10-69-12459.txt 10 7 69 55 0.4747data7-10-69-12460.txt 10 7 69 53 0.4550

Table 178: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 384: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-10-69-12461.txt 10 7 69 67 0.4756data7-10-69-12462.txt 10 7 69 64 0.4400data7-10-69-12463.txt 10 7 69 69 0.4965data7-10-69-12464.txt 10 7 69 53 0.4842data7-10-69-12465.txt 10 7 69 53 0.7028data7-10-69-12466.txt 10 7 69 53 0.2599data7-10-69-12467.txt 10 7 69 63 0.4200data7-10-69-12468.txt 10 7 69 67 0.6999data7-10-69-12469.txt 10 7 69 56 0.2062data7-10-69-12470.txt 10 7 69 69 0.2856data7-10-69-12471.txt 10 7 69 70 0.3419data7-10-69-12472.txt 10 7 69 55 0.0535data7-10-69-12473.txt 10 7 69 70 0.3005data7-10-69-12474.txt 10 7 69 55 0.3553data7-10-69-12475.txt 10 7 69 65 0.5208data7-10-69-12476.txt 10 7 69 51 0.4999data7-10-69-12477.txt 10 7 69 65 0.1151data7-10-69-12478.txt 10 7 69 62 0.6171data7-10-69-12479.txt 10 7 69 73 0.7268data7-10-69-12480.txt 10 7 69 59 0.4115data7-10-69-12481.txt 10 7 69 61 0.3779data7-10-69-12482.txt 10 7 69 66 0.1871data7-10-69-12483.txt 10 7 69 54 0.6092data7-10-69-12484.txt 10 7 69 64 0.2990data7-10-69-12485.txt 10 7 69 64 0.6937data7-10-69-12486.txt 10 7 69 56 0.8871data7-10-69-12487.txt 10 7 69 72 0.4540data7-10-69-12488.txt 10 7 69 62 0.8194data7-10-69-12489.txt 10 7 69 62 0.6421data7-10-69-12490.txt 10 7 69 72 0.9079data7-10-69-12491.txt 10 7 69 73 0.2073data7-10-69-12492.txt 10 7 69 59 0.3154data7-10-69-12493.txt 10 7 69 64 0.3582data7-10-69-12494.txt 10 7 69 71 0.3340data7-10-69-12495.txt 10 7 69 57 0.2206data7-10-69-12496.txt 10 7 69 50 0.1275data7-10-69-12497.txt 10 7 69 65 0.3777data7-10-69-12498.txt 10 7 69 53 0.2141data7-10-69-12499.txt 10 7 69 76 0.6048data7-10-69-12500.txt 10 7 69 60 0.2001

Table 179: Computational results on the set group 6

Page 385: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

8 lbri

Page 386: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-50-196-1 50 4 196 102 0.1055data4-50-196-2 50 4 196 102 0.2759data4-50-196-3 50 4 196 107 0.0804data4-50-196-4 50 4 196 95 0.0147data4-50-196-5 50 4 196 103 0.0100data4-50-196-6 50 4 196 85 0.0906data4-50-196-7 50 4 196 100 0.0748data4-50-196-8 50 4 196 83 0.0018data4-50-196-9 50 4 196 89 0.0832data4-50-196-10 50 4 196 100 0.0736data4-50-196-11 50 4 196 99 0.3936data4-50-196-12 50 4 196 98 0.0017data4-50-196-13 50 4 196 93 0.0661data4-50-196-14 50 4 196 105 0.1165data4-50-196-15 50 4 196 100 0.2279data4-50-196-16 50 4 196 85 0.1880data4-50-196-17 50 4 196 103 0.0944data4-50-196-18 50 4 196 100 0.0888data4-50-196-19 50 4 196 92 0.0591data4-50-196-20 50 4 196 98 0.4553data4-50-196-21 50 4 196 96 0.0017data4-50-196-22 50 4 196 95 0.0017data4-50-196-23 50 4 196 90 0.0431data4-50-196-24 50 4 196 96 0.9984data4-50-196-25 50 4 196 95 0.2236data4-50-196-26 50 4 196 99 0.0016data4-50-196-27 50 4 196 92 0.6482data4-50-196-28 50 4 196 107 0.2258data4-50-196-29 50 4 196 103 0.3007data4-50-196-30 50 4 196 102 0.0221data4-50-196-31 50 4 196 94 0.0439data4-50-196-32 50 4 196 97 0.0016data4-50-196-33 50 4 196 96 0.0227data4-50-196-34 50 4 196 101 0.0597data4-50-196-35 50 4 196 90 0.0048data4-50-196-36 50 4 196 100 0.3213data4-50-196-37 50 4 196 93 0.0091data4-50-196-38 50 4 196 90 0.0029data4-50-196-39 50 4 196 98 0.0058data4-50-196-40 50 4 196 102 0.1662data4-50-196-41 50 4 196 93 0.1222data4-50-196-42 50 4 196 95 0.0776data4-50-196-43 50 4 196 88 0.0017data4-50-196-44 50 4 196 98 0.0087data4-50-196-45 50 4 196 88 0.1294data4-50-196-46 50 4 196 99 0.0678data4-50-196-47 50 4 196 102 0.3279data4-50-196-48 50 4 196 87 0.0042data4-50-196-49 50 4 196 106 0.1556data4-50-196-50 50 4 196 101 0.0953data4-50-196-51 50 4 196 102 0.0018data4-50-196-52 50 4 196 97 0.0757data4-50-196-53 50 4 196 89 0.4625data4-50-196-54 50 4 196 105 0.0800data4-50-196-55 50 4 196 97 0.0019data4-50-196-56 50 4 196 94 0.3228data4-50-196-57 50 4 196 93 0.0641data4-50-196-58 50 4 196 95 0.0026data4-50-196-59 50 4 196 100 0.0016data4-50-196-60 50 4 196 101 0.0017data4-50-196-61 50 4 196 91 0.5081data4-50-196-62 50 4 196 100 0.0129data4-50-196-63 50 4 196 94 0.0717data4-50-196-64 50 4 196 95 0.0974data4-50-196-65 50 4 196 97 0.0068data4-50-196-66 50 4 196 109 0.1291data4-50-196-67 50 4 196 106 0.6073data4-50-196-68 50 4 196 79 0.0605data4-50-196-69 50 4 196 94 0.1144data4-50-196-70 50 4 196 90 0.4117

Table 1: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 387: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-50-196-71 50 4 196 96 0.2149data4-50-196-72 50 4 196 92 0.0548data4-50-196-73 50 4 196 99 0.3839data4-50-196-74 50 4 196 104 0.0017data4-50-196-75 50 4 196 95 0.0037data4-50-196-76 50 4 196 103 0.0016data4-50-196-77 50 4 196 99 0.0252data4-50-196-78 50 4 196 98 0.0299data4-50-196-79 50 4 196 103 0.0039data4-50-196-80 50 4 196 103 0.1571data4-50-196-81 50 4 196 90 0.0028data4-50-196-82 50 4 196 98 0.1104data4-50-196-83 50 4 196 95 0.0874data4-50-196-84 50 4 196 104 0.0408data4-50-196-85 50 4 196 105 0.0036data4-50-196-86 50 4 196 84 0.0326data4-50-196-87 50 4 196 102 0.0777data4-50-196-88 50 4 196 93 0.1442data4-50-196-89 50 4 196 96 0.0016data4-50-196-90 50 4 196 106 0.0050data4-50-196-91 50 4 196 99 0.3939data4-50-196-92 50 4 196 105 0.0020data4-50-196-93 50 4 196 93 0.2914data4-50-196-94 50 4 196 85 0.4070data4-50-196-95 50 4 196 96 0.0140data4-50-196-96 50 4 196 105 0.0519data4-50-196-97 50 4 196 102 0.2345data4-50-196-98 50 4 196 98 0.5903data4-50-196-99 50 4 196 103 0.5672data4-50-196-100 50 4 196 99 0.2807data4-50-197-1 50 4 197 94 0.1085data4-50-197-2 50 4 197 85 0.0403data4-50-197-3 50 4 197 93 0.0023data4-50-197-4 50 4 197 97 0.1292data4-50-197-5 50 4 197 92 0.0398data4-50-197-6 50 4 197 101 0.0465data4-50-197-7 50 4 197 101 0.1280data4-50-197-8 50 4 197 94 0.0044data4-50-197-9 50 4 197 105 0.1276data4-50-197-10 50 4 197 107 0.3345data4-50-197-11 50 4 197 95 0.0025data4-50-197-12 50 4 197 93 0.0985data4-50-197-13 50 4 197 105 0.2932data4-50-197-14 50 4 197 94 0.0027data4-50-197-15 50 4 197 92 0.1274data4-50-197-16 50 4 197 104 0.0300data4-50-197-17 50 4 197 96 0.1700data4-50-197-18 50 4 197 99 0.1132data4-50-197-19 50 4 197 97 0.0731data4-50-197-20 50 4 197 108 0.0288data4-50-197-21 50 4 197 90 0.0164data4-50-197-22 50 4 197 105 0.3142data4-50-197-23 50 4 197 98 0.0104data4-50-197-24 50 4 197 90 0.1757data4-50-197-25 50 4 197 106 0.0529data4-50-197-26 50 4 197 108 0.0971data4-50-197-27 50 4 197 98 0.2217data4-50-197-28 50 4 197 109 0.0123data4-50-197-29 50 4 197 96 0.0836data4-50-197-30 50 4 197 108 0.0833data4-50-197-31 50 4 197 110 0.5518data4-50-197-32 50 4 197 99 0.1298data4-50-197-33 50 4 197 92 0.0016data4-50-197-34 50 4 197 108 0.0621data4-50-197-35 50 4 197 101 0.1980data4-50-197-36 50 4 197 98 0.2627data4-50-197-37 50 4 197 99 0.0188data4-50-197-38 50 4 197 98 0.2004data4-50-197-39 50 4 197 108 0.0408data4-50-197-40 50 4 197 90 0.0030

Table 2: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 388: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-50-197-41 50 4 197 104 0.1073data4-50-197-42 50 4 197 102 0.2416data4-50-197-43 50 4 197 97 0.0098data4-50-197-44 50 4 197 96 0.0082data4-50-197-45 50 4 197 105 0.0017data4-50-197-46 50 4 197 93 0.0518data4-50-197-47 50 4 197 98 0.0371data4-50-197-48 50 4 197 84 0.0965data4-50-197-49 50 4 197 94 0.0204data4-50-197-50 50 4 197 97 0.0033data4-50-197-51 50 4 197 94 0.0023data4-50-197-52 50 4 197 110 0.1967data4-50-197-53 50 4 197 95 0.1493data4-50-197-54 50 4 197 100 0.0017data4-50-197-55 50 4 197 100 0.2615data4-50-197-56 50 4 197 103 0.0137data4-50-197-57 50 4 197 100 0.0837data4-50-197-58 50 4 197 107 0.0731data4-50-197-59 50 4 197 90 0.0016data4-50-197-60 50 4 197 102 0.0021data4-50-197-61 50 4 197 93 0.4759data4-50-197-62 50 4 197 90 0.0019data4-50-197-63 50 4 197 102 0.0099data4-50-197-64 50 4 197 97 0.0030data4-50-197-65 50 4 197 99 0.1307data4-50-197-66 50 4 197 100 0.3648data4-50-197-67 50 4 197 84 0.0039data4-50-197-68 50 4 197 106 0.1458data4-50-197-69 50 4 197 97 0.0898data4-50-197-70 50 4 197 97 0.0605data4-50-197-71 50 4 197 107 0.0971data4-50-197-72 50 4 197 103 0.2465data4-50-197-73 50 4 197 97 0.0223data4-50-197-74 50 4 197 97 0.0640data4-50-197-75 50 4 197 104 0.2472data4-50-197-76 50 4 197 99 0.1868data4-50-197-77 50 4 197 108 0.3647data4-50-197-78 50 4 197 85 0.0141data4-50-197-79 50 4 197 97 0.0154data4-50-197-80 50 4 197 101 0.0865data4-50-197-81 50 4 197 98 0.0021data4-50-197-82 50 4 197 101 0.3331data4-50-197-83 50 4 197 98 0.0219data4-50-197-84 50 4 197 110 0.0516data4-50-197-85 50 4 197 93 0.3003data4-50-197-86 50 4 197 99 0.0328data4-50-197-87 50 4 197 100 0.0563data4-50-197-88 50 4 197 102 0.1367data4-50-197-89 50 4 197 101 0.1342data4-50-197-90 50 4 197 102 0.0028data4-50-197-91 50 4 197 95 0.0017data4-50-197-92 50 4 197 99 0.0268data4-50-197-93 50 4 197 102 0.0051data4-50-197-94 50 4 197 107 0.1057data4-50-197-95 50 4 197 112 0.2936data4-50-197-96 50 4 197 98 0.0181data4-50-197-97 50 4 197 96 0.0925data4-50-197-98 50 4 197 105 0.1261data4-50-197-99 50 4 197 101 0.4539data4-50-197-100 50 4 197 98 0.0020data4-50-198-1 50 4 198 99 0.0025data4-50-198-2 50 4 198 112 0.1951data4-50-198-3 50 4 198 96 0.2452data4-50-198-4 50 4 198 104 0.2258data4-50-198-5 50 4 198 95 0.0481data4-50-198-6 50 4 198 96 0.0300data4-50-198-7 50 4 198 105 0.0065data4-50-198-8 50 4 198 106 0.2247data4-50-198-9 50 4 198 97 0.0024data4-50-198-10 50 4 198 101 0.1408

Table 3: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 389: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-50-198-11 50 4 198 108 0.1539data4-50-198-12 50 4 198 101 0.0466data4-50-198-13 50 4 198 98 0.0023data4-50-198-14 50 4 198 100 0.0908data4-50-198-15 50 4 198 97 0.0459data4-50-198-16 50 4 198 106 0.3065data4-50-198-17 50 4 198 95 0.1094data4-50-198-18 50 4 198 95 0.2162data4-50-198-19 50 4 198 100 0.0378data4-50-198-20 50 4 198 86 0.0021data4-50-198-21 50 4 198 95 0.2370data4-50-198-22 50 4 198 100 0.0051data4-50-198-23 50 4 198 101 0.2055data4-50-198-24 50 4 198 89 0.0028data4-50-198-25 50 4 198 104 0.3433data4-50-198-26 50 4 198 105 0.2122data4-50-198-27 50 4 198 92 0.0524data4-50-198-28 50 4 198 108 0.0026data4-50-198-29 50 4 198 94 0.0072data4-50-198-30 50 4 198 104 0.0062data4-50-198-31 50 4 198 97 0.0483data4-50-198-32 50 4 198 98 0.2033data4-50-198-33 50 4 198 102 0.0020data4-50-198-34 50 4 198 107 0.1514data4-50-198-35 50 4 198 104 0.1179data4-50-198-36 50 4 198 99 0.0104data4-50-198-37 50 4 198 108 0.1590data4-50-198-38 50 4 198 101 0.0030data4-50-198-39 50 4 198 96 0.4116data4-50-198-40 50 4 198 102 0.3119data4-50-198-41 50 4 198 95 0.2341data4-50-198-42 50 4 198 96 0.0037data4-50-198-43 50 4 198 94 0.0639data4-50-198-44 50 4 198 98 0.0027data4-50-198-45 50 4 198 98 0.0492data4-50-198-46 50 4 198 94 0.0019data4-50-198-47 50 4 198 107 0.0359data4-50-198-48 50 4 198 106 0.1080data4-50-198-49 50 4 198 94 0.0023data4-50-198-50 50 4 198 96 0.0020data4-50-198-51 50 4 198 93 0.0176data4-50-198-52 50 4 198 81 0.0028data4-50-198-53 50 4 198 99 0.0031data4-50-198-54 50 4 198 94 0.0082data4-50-198-55 50 4 198 96 0.4305data4-50-198-56 50 4 198 96 0.0274data4-50-198-57 50 4 198 101 0.1277data4-50-198-58 50 4 198 105 0.0027data4-50-198-59 50 4 198 103 0.1728data4-50-198-60 50 4 198 107 0.0472data4-50-198-61 50 4 198 94 0.1133data4-50-198-62 50 4 198 93 0.1599data4-50-198-63 50 4 198 99 0.0718data4-50-198-64 50 4 198 109 0.0031data4-50-198-65 50 4 198 90 0.0021data4-50-198-66 50 4 198 95 0.0441data4-50-198-67 50 4 198 88 0.0695data4-50-198-68 50 4 198 92 0.0438data4-50-198-69 50 4 198 95 0.0045data4-50-198-70 50 4 198 107 0.4383data4-50-198-71 50 4 198 105 0.0359data4-50-198-72 50 4 198 93 0.3118data4-50-198-73 50 4 198 105 0.1415data4-50-198-74 50 4 198 101 0.3416data4-50-198-75 50 4 198 99 0.1896data4-50-198-76 50 4 198 100 0.1231data4-50-198-77 50 4 198 100 0.0121data4-50-198-78 50 4 198 107 0.3365data4-50-198-79 50 4 198 104 0.0219data4-50-198-80 50 4 198 99 0.2319

Table 4: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 390: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-50-198-81 50 4 198 92 0.2101data4-50-198-82 50 4 198 90 0.1931data4-50-198-83 50 4 198 96 0.0684data4-50-198-84 50 4 198 107 0.1058data4-50-198-85 50 4 198 101 0.1673data4-50-198-86 50 4 198 96 0.0079data4-50-198-87 50 4 198 98 0.0158data4-50-198-88 50 4 198 98 0.0673data4-50-198-89 50 4 198 95 0.2856data4-50-198-90 50 4 198 97 0.4376data4-50-198-91 50 4 198 89 0.0267data4-50-198-92 50 4 198 103 0.3153data4-50-198-93 50 4 198 93 0.0021data4-50-198-94 50 4 198 96 0.0634data4-50-198-95 50 4 198 96 0.0290data4-50-198-96 50 4 198 103 0.2256data4-50-198-97 50 4 198 102 0.0351data4-50-198-98 50 4 198 102 0.0020data4-50-198-99 50 4 198 95 0.0059data4-50-198-100 50 4 198 89 0.0019data4-50-199-1 50 4 199 96 0.0779data4-50-199-2 50 4 199 95 0.1868data4-50-199-3 50 4 199 103 0.0220data4-50-199-4 50 4 199 101 0.0297data4-50-199-5 50 4 199 97 0.0018data4-50-199-6 50 4 199 101 0.0046data4-50-199-7 50 4 199 96 0.0056data4-50-199-8 50 4 199 91 0.0278data4-50-199-9 50 4 199 108 0.1543data4-50-199-10 50 4 199 104 0.1639data4-50-199-11 50 4 199 93 0.0025data4-50-199-12 50 4 199 104 0.0017data4-50-199-13 50 4 199 108 0.1685data4-50-199-14 50 4 199 95 0.0382data4-50-199-15 50 4 199 109 0.0506data4-50-199-16 50 4 199 108 0.0038data4-50-199-17 50 4 199 96 0.0110data4-50-199-18 50 4 199 99 0.0049data4-50-199-19 50 4 199 97 0.0584data4-50-199-20 50 4 199 108 0.0265data4-50-199-21 50 4 199 100 0.1599data4-50-199-22 50 4 199 102 0.0978data4-50-199-23 50 4 199 98 0.0733data4-50-199-24 50 4 199 99 0.0234data4-50-199-25 50 4 199 103 0.1777data4-50-199-26 50 4 199 87 0.0537data4-50-199-27 50 4 199 94 0.2170data4-50-199-28 50 4 199 107 0.0952data4-50-199-29 50 4 199 97 0.0441data4-50-199-30 50 4 199 110 0.0027data4-50-199-31 50 4 199 85 0.5150data4-50-199-32 50 4 199 98 0.2011data4-50-199-33 50 4 199 97 0.0017data4-50-199-34 50 4 199 113 0.0084data4-50-199-35 50 4 199 104 0.0047data4-50-199-36 50 4 199 100 0.1571data4-50-199-37 50 4 199 96 0.0436data4-50-199-38 50 4 199 101 0.0344data4-50-199-39 50 4 199 100 0.3250data4-50-199-40 50 4 199 99 0.0439data4-50-199-41 50 4 199 98 0.1422data4-50-199-42 50 4 199 101 0.0217data4-50-199-43 50 4 199 95 0.0017data4-50-199-44 50 4 199 106 0.0292data4-50-199-45 50 4 199 94 0.2209data4-50-199-46 50 4 199 104 0.2146data4-50-199-47 50 4 199 96 0.0027data4-50-199-48 50 4 199 105 0.0019data4-50-199-49 50 4 199 101 0.0084data4-50-199-50 50 4 199 108 0.0405

Table 5: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 391: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-50-199-51 50 4 199 105 0.0641data4-50-199-52 50 4 199 95 0.1394data4-50-199-53 50 4 199 107 0.0728data4-50-199-54 50 4 199 97 0.0789data4-50-199-55 50 4 199 101 0.0031data4-50-199-56 50 4 199 102 0.1502data4-50-199-57 50 4 199 102 0.3380data4-50-199-58 50 4 199 105 0.1140data4-50-199-59 50 4 199 98 0.0077data4-50-199-60 50 4 199 102 0.0057data4-50-199-61 50 4 199 110 0.0029data4-50-199-62 50 4 199 101 0.0107data4-50-199-63 50 4 199 97 0.0045data4-50-199-64 50 4 199 105 0.0055data4-50-199-65 50 4 199 111 0.0449data4-50-199-66 50 4 199 97 0.0036data4-50-199-67 50 4 199 99 0.0017data4-50-199-68 50 4 199 105 0.0165data4-50-199-69 50 4 199 99 0.0171data4-50-199-70 50 4 199 109 0.0338data4-50-199-71 50 4 199 90 0.0898data4-50-199-72 50 4 199 90 0.0057data4-50-199-73 50 4 199 103 0.2683data4-50-199-74 50 4 199 104 0.0476data4-50-199-75 50 4 199 104 0.0700data4-50-199-76 50 4 199 90 0.0222data4-50-199-77 50 4 199 105 0.0124data4-50-199-78 50 4 199 103 0.0031data4-50-199-79 50 4 199 99 0.0075data4-50-199-80 50 4 199 90 0.0333data4-50-199-81 50 4 199 99 0.8262data4-50-199-82 50 4 199 101 0.0103data4-50-199-83 50 4 199 96 0.0662data4-50-199-84 50 4 199 113 1.0031data4-50-199-85 50 4 199 98 0.0038data4-50-199-86 50 4 199 106 0.0935data4-50-199-87 50 4 199 108 0.0042data4-50-199-88 50 4 199 105 0.0189data4-50-199-89 50 4 199 106 0.0524data4-50-199-90 50 4 199 108 0.0409data4-50-199-91 50 4 199 100 0.4513data4-50-199-92 50 4 199 99 0.0023data4-50-199-93 50 4 199 97 0.0016data4-50-199-94 50 4 199 94 0.0019data4-50-199-95 50 4 199 98 0.6615data4-50-199-96 50 4 199 95 0.0119data4-50-199-97 50 4 199 89 0.0021data4-50-199-98 50 4 199 101 0.0345data4-50-199-99 50 4 199 99 0.0051data4-50-199-100 50 4 199 84 0.0358data7-50-343-1 50 7 343 248 1.0056data7-50-343-2 50 7 343 260 1.0058data7-50-343-3 50 7 343 236 1.0002data7-50-343-4 50 7 343 256 1.0018data7-50-343-5 50 7 343 257 1.0050data7-50-343-6 50 7 343 263 1.0016data7-50-343-7 50 7 343 277 1.0061data7-50-343-8 50 7 343 260 1.0053data7-50-343-9 50 7 343 265 1.0026data7-50-343-10 50 7 343 259 1.0032data7-50-343-11 50 7 343 268 1.0023data7-50-343-12 50 7 343 265 1.0057data7-50-343-13 50 7 343 280 0.9958data7-50-343-14 50 7 343 262 0.9958data7-50-343-15 50 7 343 242 1.0065data7-50-343-16 50 7 343 247 1.0074data7-50-343-17 50 7 343 250 1.0049data7-50-343-18 50 7 343 250 1.0042data7-50-343-19 50 7 343 245 1.0026data7-50-343-20 50 7 343 267 1.0071

Table 6: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 392: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-50-343-21 50 7 343 243 1.0017data7-50-343-22 50 7 343 249 1.0058data7-50-343-23 50 7 343 275 1.0018data7-50-343-24 50 7 343 252 0.9963data7-50-343-25 50 7 343 255 1.0025data7-50-343-26 50 7 343 281 1.0037data7-50-343-27 50 7 343 240 1.0007data7-50-343-28 50 7 343 262 1.0027data7-50-343-29 50 7 343 259 1.0023data7-50-343-30 50 7 343 260 1.0028data7-50-343-31 50 7 343 250 1.0020data7-50-343-32 50 7 343 264 1.0030data7-50-343-33 50 7 343 273 1.0018data7-50-343-34 50 7 343 252 1.0013data7-50-343-35 50 7 343 256 1.0052data7-50-343-36 50 7 343 270 0.9970data7-50-343-37 50 7 343 254 1.0057data7-50-343-38 50 7 343 252 1.0027data7-50-343-39 50 7 343 249 1.0046data7-50-343-40 50 7 343 248 1.0066data7-50-343-41 50 7 343 229 1.0056data7-50-343-42 50 7 343 241 1.0034data7-50-343-43 50 7 343 257 1.0056data7-50-343-44 50 7 343 245 1.0058data7-50-343-45 50 7 343 257 1.0055data7-50-343-46 50 7 343 260 1.0013data7-50-343-47 50 7 343 259 1.0060data7-50-343-48 50 7 343 252 1.0038data7-50-343-49 50 7 343 234 1.0058data7-50-343-50 50 7 343 258 1.0042data7-50-343-51 50 7 343 253 1.0037data7-50-343-52 50 7 343 256 1.0043data7-50-343-53 50 7 343 267 1.0037data7-50-343-54 50 7 343 254 1.0010data7-50-343-55 50 7 343 249 1.0065data7-50-343-56 50 7 343 250 1.0033data7-50-343-57 50 7 343 248 1.0045data7-50-343-58 50 7 343 259 1.0034data7-50-343-59 50 7 343 259 1.0016data7-50-343-60 50 7 343 248 1.0052data7-50-343-61 50 7 343 240 1.0052data7-50-343-62 50 7 343 270 1.0032data7-50-343-63 50 7 343 247 1.0055data7-50-343-64 50 7 343 273 1.0048data7-50-343-65 50 7 343 272 1.0044data7-50-343-66 50 7 343 271 1.0035data7-50-343-67 50 7 343 260 1.0055data7-50-343-68 50 7 343 248 1.0030data7-50-343-69 50 7 343 255 1.0047data7-50-343-70 50 7 343 247 1.0034data7-50-343-71 50 7 343 274 1.0021data7-50-343-72 50 7 343 255 1.0041data7-50-343-73 50 7 343 267 1.0018data7-50-343-74 50 7 343 263 0.9936data7-50-343-75 50 7 343 249 1.0055data7-50-343-76 50 7 343 259 1.0049data7-50-343-77 50 7 343 236 1.0049data7-50-343-78 50 7 343 258 0.9980data7-50-343-79 50 7 343 261 1.0030data7-50-343-80 50 7 343 275 1.0041data7-50-343-81 50 7 343 246 1.0051data7-50-343-82 50 7 343 260 1.0045data7-50-343-83 50 7 343 260 1.0000data7-50-343-84 50 7 343 282 1.0051data7-50-343-85 50 7 343 240 1.0061data7-50-343-86 50 7 343 247 1.0046data7-50-343-87 50 7 343 257 1.0060data7-50-343-88 50 7 343 249 1.0037data7-50-343-89 50 7 343 265 1.0008data7-50-343-90 50 7 343 264 1.0031

Table 7: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 393: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-50-343-91 50 7 343 261 1.0032data7-50-343-92 50 7 343 253 1.0031data7-50-343-93 50 7 343 271 1.0054data7-50-343-94 50 7 343 249 1.0025data7-50-343-95 50 7 343 244 1.0045data7-50-343-96 50 7 343 263 1.0028data7-50-343-97 50 7 343 275 1.0034data7-50-343-98 50 7 343 242 1.0029data7-50-343-99 50 7 343 274 1.0021data7-50-343-100 50 7 343 255 1.0039data7-50-344-1 50 7 344 261 1.0057data7-50-344-2 50 7 344 247 1.0051data7-50-344-3 50 7 344 254 0.9989data7-50-344-4 50 7 344 236 0.9992data7-50-344-5 50 7 344 256 1.0028data7-50-344-6 50 7 344 265 1.0052data7-50-344-7 50 7 344 270 1.0023data7-50-344-8 50 7 344 279 1.0050data7-50-344-9 50 7 344 265 0.9972data7-50-344-10 50 7 344 274 1.0050data7-50-344-11 50 7 344 254 1.0020data7-50-344-12 50 7 344 268 1.0053data7-50-344-13 50 7 344 245 1.0017data7-50-344-14 50 7 344 257 0.9977data7-50-344-15 50 7 344 249 1.0026data7-50-344-16 50 7 344 260 1.0043data7-50-344-17 50 7 344 237 1.0037data7-50-344-18 50 7 344 249 1.0054data7-50-344-19 50 7 344 244 0.9969data7-50-344-20 50 7 344 263 1.0068data7-50-344-21 50 7 344 266 1.0064data7-50-344-22 50 7 344 254 1.0049data7-50-344-23 50 7 344 270 1.0062data7-50-344-24 50 7 344 265 1.0028data7-50-344-25 50 7 344 274 1.0045data7-50-344-26 50 7 344 261 1.0038data7-50-344-27 50 7 344 263 1.0017data7-50-344-28 50 7 344 266 1.0029data7-50-344-29 50 7 344 248 1.0029data7-50-344-30 50 7 344 249 1.0060data7-50-344-31 50 7 344 262 1.0051data7-50-344-32 50 7 344 260 1.0059data7-50-344-33 50 7 344 240 1.0027data7-50-344-34 50 7 344 263 1.0063data7-50-344-35 50 7 344 257 1.0055data7-50-344-36 50 7 344 270 1.0032data7-50-344-37 50 7 344 253 1.0058data7-50-344-38 50 7 344 267 1.0039data7-50-344-39 50 7 344 257 1.0032data7-50-344-40 50 7 344 268 1.0040data7-50-344-41 50 7 344 256 1.0033data7-50-344-42 50 7 344 271 1.0054data7-50-344-43 50 7 344 258 1.0022data7-50-344-44 50 7 344 261 1.0049data7-50-344-45 50 7 344 245 1.0045data7-50-344-46 50 7 344 248 1.0056data7-50-344-47 50 7 344 256 1.0039data7-50-344-48 50 7 344 264 1.0030data7-50-344-49 50 7 344 257 1.0045data7-50-344-50 50 7 344 272 1.0034data7-50-344-51 50 7 344 255 1.0057data7-50-344-52 50 7 344 284 1.0048data7-50-344-53 50 7 344 259 1.0018data7-50-344-54 50 7 344 252 1.0014data7-50-344-55 50 7 344 258 1.0019data7-50-344-56 50 7 344 264 1.0016data7-50-344-57 50 7 344 269 1.0019data7-50-344-58 50 7 344 240 1.0059data7-50-344-59 50 7 344 257 0.9980data7-50-344-60 50 7 344 249 0.9959

Table 8: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 394: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-50-344-61 50 7 344 271 1.0058data7-50-344-62 50 7 344 262 1.0034data7-50-344-63 50 7 344 266 1.0028data7-50-344-64 50 7 344 256 1.0026data7-50-344-65 50 7 344 254 1.0029data7-50-344-66 50 7 344 266 1.0030data7-50-344-67 50 7 344 252 1.0036data7-50-344-68 50 7 344 237 1.0051data7-50-344-69 50 7 344 257 1.0040data7-50-344-70 50 7 344 257 1.0014data7-50-344-71 50 7 344 261 1.0021data7-50-344-72 50 7 344 262 1.0036data7-50-344-73 50 7 344 261 1.0019data7-50-344-74 50 7 344 269 1.0022data7-50-344-75 50 7 344 260 1.0060data7-50-344-76 50 7 344 259 1.0041data7-50-344-77 50 7 344 254 1.0034data7-50-344-78 50 7 344 246 1.0030data7-50-344-79 50 7 344 271 1.0044data7-50-344-80 50 7 344 261 1.0048data7-50-344-81 50 7 344 254 1.0023data7-50-344-82 50 7 344 263 1.0035data7-50-344-83 50 7 344 262 1.0015data7-50-344-84 50 7 344 250 1.0017data7-50-344-85 50 7 344 246 1.0016data7-50-344-86 50 7 344 267 1.0045data7-50-344-87 50 7 344 235 1.0063data7-50-344-88 50 7 344 266 1.0017data7-50-344-89 50 7 344 257 1.0035data7-50-344-90 50 7 344 270 1.0051data7-50-344-91 50 7 344 263 1.0029data7-50-344-92 50 7 344 244 1.0062data7-50-344-93 50 7 344 276 1.0028data7-50-344-94 50 7 344 263 1.0051data7-50-344-95 50 7 344 256 1.0050data7-50-344-96 50 7 344 269 1.0025data7-50-344-97 50 7 344 265 1.0022data7-50-344-98 50 7 344 263 1.0033data7-50-344-99 50 7 344 248 1.0037data7-50-344-100 50 7 344 245 1.0064data7-50-345-1 50 7 345 255 1.0070data7-50-345-2 50 7 345 272 1.0046data7-50-345-3 50 7 345 287 1.0055data7-50-345-4 50 7 345 268 1.0047data7-50-345-5 50 7 345 283 1.0041data7-50-345-6 50 7 345 263 1.0031data7-50-345-7 50 7 345 277 1.0044data7-50-345-8 50 7 345 280 1.0037data7-50-345-9 50 7 345 252 1.0025data7-50-345-10 50 7 345 259 1.0051data7-50-345-11 50 7 345 292 1.0045data7-50-345-12 50 7 345 284 1.0015data7-50-345-13 50 7 345 269 1.0058data7-50-345-14 50 7 345 249 1.0045data7-50-345-15 50 7 345 254 1.0037data7-50-345-16 50 7 345 298 1.0028data7-50-345-17 50 7 345 286 1.0037data7-50-345-18 50 7 345 248 1.0029data7-50-345-19 50 7 345 259 1.0041data7-50-345-20 50 7 345 247 1.0010data7-50-345-21 50 7 345 283 1.0056data7-50-345-22 50 7 345 261 1.0031data7-50-345-23 50 7 345 275 1.0018data7-50-345-24 50 7 345 258 0.9945data7-50-345-25 50 7 345 264 1.0006data7-50-345-26 50 7 345 262 1.0036data7-50-345-27 50 7 345 248 1.0033data7-50-345-28 50 7 345 276 1.0043data7-50-345-29 50 7 345 274 1.0041data7-50-345-30 50 7 345 264 1.0030

Table 9: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 395: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-50-345-31 50 7 345 264 0.9983data7-50-345-32 50 7 345 255 1.0040data7-50-345-33 50 7 345 243 1.0026data7-50-345-34 50 7 345 269 1.0036data7-50-345-35 50 7 345 272 1.0033data7-50-345-36 50 7 345 262 1.0047data7-50-345-37 50 7 345 242 1.0054data7-50-345-38 50 7 345 248 1.0044data7-50-345-39 50 7 345 277 1.0061data7-50-345-40 50 7 345 262 1.0059data7-50-345-41 50 7 345 253 1.0050data7-50-345-42 50 7 345 244 1.0064data7-50-345-43 50 7 345 258 1.0042data7-50-345-44 50 7 345 282 1.0059data7-50-345-45 50 7 345 271 1.0046data7-50-345-46 50 7 345 249 1.0050data7-50-345-47 50 7 345 256 1.0020data7-50-345-48 50 7 345 260 1.0020data7-50-345-49 50 7 345 252 1.0037data7-50-345-50 50 7 345 265 1.0042data7-50-345-51 50 7 345 258 1.0048data7-50-345-52 50 7 345 268 1.0040data7-50-345-53 50 7 345 263 1.0053data7-50-345-54 50 7 345 254 1.0006data7-50-345-55 50 7 345 250 0.9965data7-50-345-56 50 7 345 246 1.0058data7-50-345-57 50 7 345 249 1.0035data7-50-345-58 50 7 345 260 1.0062data7-50-345-59 50 7 345 246 1.0015data7-50-345-60 50 7 345 281 1.0026data7-50-345-61 50 7 345 256 1.0025data7-50-345-62 50 7 345 277 1.0041data7-50-345-63 50 7 345 254 1.0044data7-50-345-64 50 7 345 261 1.0052data7-50-345-65 50 7 345 283 1.0039data7-50-345-66 50 7 345 274 1.0052data7-50-345-67 50 7 345 247 1.0056data7-50-345-68 50 7 345 260 1.0058data7-50-345-69 50 7 345 242 1.0006data7-50-345-70 50 7 345 255 1.0004data7-50-345-71 50 7 345 254 1.0025data7-50-345-72 50 7 345 284 1.0035data7-50-345-73 50 7 345 255 1.0030data7-50-345-74 50 7 345 263 0.9998data7-50-345-75 50 7 345 269 0.9994data7-50-345-76 50 7 345 241 1.0050data7-50-345-77 50 7 345 250 1.0060data7-50-345-78 50 7 345 268 1.0034data7-50-345-79 50 7 345 266 1.0013data7-50-345-80 50 7 345 266 1.0026data7-50-345-81 50 7 345 268 1.0032data7-50-345-82 50 7 345 266 1.0024data7-50-345-83 50 7 345 255 1.0050data7-50-345-84 50 7 345 248 1.0051data7-50-345-85 50 7 345 264 1.0040data7-50-345-86 50 7 345 260 1.0028data7-50-345-87 50 7 345 276 1.0013data7-50-345-88 50 7 345 266 1.0045data7-50-345-89 50 7 345 265 1.0050data7-50-345-90 50 7 345 253 0.9978data7-50-345-91 50 7 345 253 1.0055data7-50-345-92 50 7 345 264 1.0058data7-50-345-93 50 7 345 267 1.0043data7-50-345-94 50 7 345 241 1.0041data7-50-345-95 50 7 345 268 1.0066data7-50-345-96 50 7 345 267 1.0020data7-50-345-97 50 7 345 251 1.0059data7-50-345-98 50 7 345 255 1.0040data7-50-345-99 50 7 345 276 1.0023data7-50-345-100 50 7 345 266 0.9984

Table 10: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 396: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-50-346-1 50 7 346 254 1.0065data7-50-346-2 50 7 346 282 1.0049data7-50-346-3 50 7 346 272 1.0040data7-50-346-4 50 7 346 277 1.0046data7-50-346-5 50 7 346 259 0.9936data7-50-346-6 50 7 346 260 1.0029data7-50-346-7 50 7 346 250 1.0028data7-50-346-8 50 7 346 265 1.0055data7-50-346-9 50 7 346 277 1.0003data7-50-346-10 50 7 346 281 0.9995data7-50-346-11 50 7 346 233 1.0055data7-50-346-12 50 7 346 264 1.0012data7-50-346-13 50 7 346 280 1.0040data7-50-346-14 50 7 346 276 1.0029data7-50-346-15 50 7 346 252 1.0049data7-50-346-16 50 7 346 269 1.0053data7-50-346-17 50 7 346 261 1.0017data7-50-346-18 50 7 346 262 1.0024data7-50-346-19 50 7 346 253 1.0009data7-50-346-20 50 7 346 262 1.0023data7-50-346-21 50 7 346 260 1.0025data7-50-346-22 50 7 346 259 1.0034data7-50-346-23 50 7 346 255 1.0042data7-50-346-24 50 7 346 247 1.0024data7-50-346-25 50 7 346 267 0.9981data7-50-346-26 50 7 346 242 1.0056data7-50-346-27 50 7 346 258 1.0023data7-50-346-28 50 7 346 247 1.0021data7-50-346-29 50 7 346 268 1.0054data7-50-346-30 50 7 346 247 1.0016data7-50-346-31 50 7 346 268 1.0059data7-50-346-32 50 7 346 274 1.0047data7-50-346-33 50 7 346 257 1.0025data7-50-346-34 50 7 346 257 1.0046data7-50-346-35 50 7 346 244 1.0045data7-50-346-36 50 7 346 267 1.0040data7-50-346-37 50 7 346 257 1.0038data7-50-346-38 50 7 346 275 1.0031data7-50-346-39 50 7 346 262 1.0024data7-50-346-40 50 7 346 259 1.0043data7-50-346-41 50 7 346 281 1.0049data7-50-346-42 50 7 346 263 1.0022data7-50-346-43 50 7 346 267 1.0017data7-50-346-44 50 7 346 254 1.0052data7-50-346-45 50 7 346 272 1.0026data7-50-346-46 50 7 346 261 1.0016data7-50-346-47 50 7 346 251 1.0034data7-50-346-48 50 7 346 264 1.0049data7-50-346-49 50 7 346 272 1.0032data7-50-346-50 50 7 346 279 1.0037data7-50-346-51 50 7 346 257 1.0040data7-50-346-52 50 7 346 273 0.9957data7-50-346-53 50 7 346 280 0.9981data7-50-346-54 50 7 346 245 1.0056data7-50-346-55 50 7 346 246 1.0048data7-50-346-56 50 7 346 257 1.0035data7-50-346-57 50 7 346 250 1.0028data7-50-346-58 50 7 346 283 1.0052data7-50-346-59 50 7 346 281 1.0030data7-50-346-60 50 7 346 258 1.0053data7-50-346-61 50 7 346 267 1.0073data7-50-346-62 50 7 346 258 0.9999data7-50-346-63 50 7 346 252 0.9964data7-50-346-64 50 7 346 254 1.0055data7-50-346-65 50 7 346 256 1.0071data7-50-346-66 50 7 346 246 1.0058data7-50-346-67 50 7 346 262 1.0044data7-50-346-68 50 7 346 265 1.0018data7-50-346-69 50 7 346 250 1.0035data7-50-346-70 50 7 346 270 1.0047

Table 11: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 397: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-50-346-71 50 7 346 265 1.0036data7-50-346-72 50 7 346 259 1.0023data7-50-346-73 50 7 346 261 1.0041data7-50-346-74 50 7 346 260 1.0052data7-50-346-75 50 7 346 244 1.0020data7-50-346-76 50 7 346 247 1.0028data7-50-346-77 50 7 346 253 1.0022data7-50-346-78 50 7 346 281 1.0020data7-50-346-79 50 7 346 272 1.0029data7-50-346-80 50 7 346 261 1.0025data7-50-346-81 50 7 346 260 1.0023data7-50-346-82 50 7 346 241 1.0054data7-50-346-83 50 7 346 268 1.0045data7-50-346-84 50 7 346 263 1.0039data7-50-346-85 50 7 346 274 1.0006data7-50-346-86 50 7 346 254 1.0022data7-50-346-87 50 7 346 257 1.0027data7-50-346-88 50 7 346 245 1.0049data7-50-346-89 50 7 346 264 1.0004data7-50-346-90 50 7 346 289 1.0033data7-50-346-91 50 7 346 272 0.9967data7-50-346-92 50 7 346 261 0.9983data7-50-346-93 50 7 346 261 1.0001data7-50-346-94 50 7 346 263 1.0065data7-50-346-95 50 7 346 253 1.0015data7-50-346-96 50 7 346 260 1.0033data7-50-346-97 50 7 346 268 1.0017data7-50-346-98 50 7 346 267 1.0005data7-50-346-99 50 7 346 265 1.0026data7-50-346-100 50 7 346 270 1.0033data7-50-347-1 50 7 347 254 1.0015data7-50-347-2 50 7 347 250 0.9973data7-50-347-3 50 7 347 251 1.0021data7-50-347-4 50 7 347 268 1.0050data7-50-347-5 50 7 347 284 1.0047data7-50-347-6 50 7 347 271 1.0029data7-50-347-7 50 7 347 257 1.0027data7-50-347-8 50 7 347 255 1.0060data7-50-347-9 50 7 347 275 1.0044data7-50-347-10 50 7 347 255 1.0016data7-50-347-11 50 7 347 268 1.0027data7-50-347-12 50 7 347 280 1.0026data7-50-347-13 50 7 347 255 1.0046data7-50-347-14 50 7 347 252 1.0049data7-50-347-15 50 7 347 244 1.0018data7-50-347-16 50 7 347 241 1.0048data7-50-347-17 50 7 347 270 1.0023data7-50-347-18 50 7 347 277 1.0026data7-50-347-19 50 7 347 290 1.0031data7-50-347-20 50 7 347 249 1.0057data7-50-347-21 50 7 347 254 1.0029data7-50-347-22 50 7 347 270 0.9993data7-50-347-23 50 7 347 245 0.9980data7-50-347-24 50 7 347 284 1.0017data7-50-347-25 50 7 347 280 1.0027data7-50-347-26 50 7 347 264 1.0038data7-50-347-27 50 7 347 263 1.0026data7-50-347-28 50 7 347 273 1.0043data7-50-347-29 50 7 347 257 1.0031data7-50-347-30 50 7 347 270 1.0045data7-50-347-31 50 7 347 249 1.0038data7-50-347-32 50 7 347 272 0.9977data7-50-347-33 50 7 347 272 1.0009data7-50-347-34 50 7 347 271 1.0052data7-50-347-35 50 7 347 284 1.0047data7-50-347-36 50 7 347 261 1.0033data7-50-347-37 50 7 347 263 1.0034data7-50-347-38 50 7 347 257 0.9981data7-50-347-39 50 7 347 271 1.0019data7-50-347-40 50 7 347 263 1.0040

Table 12: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 398: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-50-347-41 50 7 347 255 1.0031data7-50-347-42 50 7 347 249 1.0034data7-50-347-43 50 7 347 250 1.0015data7-50-347-44 50 7 347 250 1.0042data7-50-347-45 50 7 347 257 1.0040data7-50-347-46 50 7 347 250 1.0053data7-50-347-47 50 7 347 268 0.9980data7-50-347-48 50 7 347 264 1.0039data7-50-347-49 50 7 347 262 1.0036data7-50-347-50 50 7 347 270 1.0049data7-50-347-51 50 7 347 265 1.0028data7-50-347-52 50 7 347 267 0.9996data7-50-347-53 50 7 347 259 1.0044data7-50-347-54 50 7 347 266 1.0060data7-50-347-55 50 7 347 266 1.0019data7-50-347-56 50 7 347 263 1.0049data7-50-347-57 50 7 347 259 1.0023data7-50-347-58 50 7 347 275 1.0036data7-50-347-59 50 7 347 253 1.0050data7-50-347-60 50 7 347 256 1.0029data7-50-347-61 50 7 347 254 1.0057data7-50-347-62 50 7 347 299 1.0043data7-50-347-63 50 7 347 241 1.0022data7-50-347-64 50 7 347 257 1.0065data7-50-347-65 50 7 347 267 1.0033data7-50-347-66 50 7 347 257 1.0029data7-50-347-67 50 7 347 259 1.0017data7-50-347-68 50 7 347 276 1.0057data7-50-347-69 50 7 347 244 1.0041data7-50-347-70 50 7 347 253 1.0017data7-50-347-71 50 7 347 264 1.0044data7-50-347-72 50 7 347 252 1.0053data7-50-347-73 50 7 347 262 1.0036data7-50-347-74 50 7 347 281 1.0045data7-50-347-75 50 7 347 249 1.0021data7-50-347-76 50 7 347 252 1.0028data7-50-347-77 50 7 347 275 1.0033data7-50-347-78 50 7 347 271 1.0042data7-50-347-79 50 7 347 247 1.0024data7-50-347-80 50 7 347 262 1.0007data7-50-347-81 50 7 347 254 1.0042data7-50-347-82 50 7 347 276 1.0013data7-50-347-83 50 7 347 256 1.0048data7-50-347-84 50 7 347 247 1.0057data7-50-347-85 50 7 347 268 1.0027data7-50-347-86 50 7 347 270 1.0040data7-50-347-87 50 7 347 271 1.0038data7-50-347-88 50 7 347 265 1.0028data7-50-347-89 50 7 347 271 1.0047data7-50-347-90 50 7 347 258 1.0012data7-50-347-91 50 7 347 253 1.0035data7-50-347-92 50 7 347 272 1.0015data7-50-347-93 50 7 347 248 1.0037data7-50-347-94 50 7 347 245 1.0024data7-50-347-95 50 7 347 285 1.0073data7-50-347-96 50 7 347 277 1.0064data7-50-347-97 50 7 347 264 1.0027data7-50-347-98 50 7 347 273 1.0031data7-50-347-99 50 7 347 244 1.0034data7-50-347-100 50 7 347 235 1.0027data7-50-348-1 50 7 348 268 1.0027data7-50-348-2 50 7 348 269 1.0028data7-50-348-3 50 7 348 265 1.0030data7-50-348-4 50 7 348 278 1.0034data7-50-348-5 50 7 348 260 1.0032data7-50-348-6 50 7 348 276 1.0056data7-50-348-7 50 7 348 267 1.0015data7-50-348-8 50 7 348 268 1.0041data7-50-348-9 50 7 348 273 1.0023data7-50-348-10 50 7 348 279 1.0055

Table 13: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 399: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-50-348-11 50 7 348 267 1.0013data7-50-348-12 50 7 348 270 1.0027data7-50-348-13 50 7 348 269 1.0050data7-50-348-14 50 7 348 271 1.0039data7-50-348-15 50 7 348 267 1.0021data7-50-348-16 50 7 348 264 1.0038data7-50-348-17 50 7 348 260 1.0034data7-50-348-18 50 7 348 260 1.0035data7-50-348-19 50 7 348 276 1.0021data7-50-348-20 50 7 348 254 1.0066data7-50-348-21 50 7 348 272 1.0014data7-50-348-22 50 7 348 256 1.0040data7-50-348-23 50 7 348 262 1.0060data7-50-348-24 50 7 348 273 1.0023data7-50-348-25 50 7 348 252 1.0033data7-50-348-26 50 7 348 261 1.0057data7-50-348-27 50 7 348 258 1.0023data7-50-348-28 50 7 348 247 1.0048data7-50-348-29 50 7 348 252 1.0040data7-50-348-30 50 7 348 256 1.0043data7-50-348-31 50 7 348 260 1.0030data7-50-348-32 50 7 348 276 1.0011data7-50-348-33 50 7 348 277 1.0035data7-50-348-34 50 7 348 257 1.0055data7-50-348-35 50 7 348 260 1.0019data7-50-348-36 50 7 348 276 1.0031data7-50-348-37 50 7 348 229 1.0048data7-50-348-38 50 7 348 263 1.0053data7-50-348-39 50 7 348 258 1.0023data7-50-348-40 50 7 348 271 1.0029data7-50-348-41 50 7 348 250 0.9972data7-50-348-42 50 7 348 259 1.0069data7-50-348-43 50 7 348 285 1.0005data7-50-348-44 50 7 348 278 1.0052data7-50-348-45 50 7 348 262 1.0052data7-50-348-46 50 7 348 252 1.0027data7-50-348-47 50 7 348 245 1.0014data7-50-348-48 50 7 348 282 1.0033data7-50-348-49 50 7 348 265 1.0031data7-50-348-50 50 7 348 259 1.0059data7-50-348-51 50 7 348 267 1.0047data7-50-348-52 50 7 348 246 1.0035data7-50-348-53 50 7 348 260 1.0025data7-50-348-54 50 7 348 286 1.0034data7-50-348-55 50 7 348 263 1.0013data7-50-348-56 50 7 348 275 1.0055data7-50-348-57 50 7 348 260 0.9991data7-50-348-58 50 7 348 269 0.9970data7-50-348-59 50 7 348 273 0.9990data7-50-348-60 50 7 348 269 1.0014data7-50-348-61 50 7 348 271 1.0013data7-50-348-62 50 7 348 270 1.0032data7-50-348-63 50 7 348 256 1.0030data7-50-348-64 50 7 348 269 1.0035data7-50-348-65 50 7 348 278 1.0017data7-50-348-66 50 7 348 300 1.0014data7-50-348-67 50 7 348 252 1.0050data7-50-348-68 50 7 348 272 1.0045data7-50-348-69 50 7 348 266 1.0018data7-50-348-70 50 7 348 254 1.0034data7-50-348-71 50 7 348 274 1.0026data7-50-348-72 50 7 348 245 1.0024data7-50-348-73 50 7 348 269 1.0029data7-50-348-74 50 7 348 274 1.0059data7-50-348-75 50 7 348 275 1.0051data7-50-348-76 50 7 348 269 1.0040data7-50-348-77 50 7 348 273 1.0017data7-50-348-78 50 7 348 251 1.0037data7-50-348-79 50 7 348 253 1.0036data7-50-348-80 50 7 348 268 1.0014

Table 14: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 400: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-50-348-81 50 7 348 262 1.0034data7-50-348-82 50 7 348 279 1.0033data7-50-348-83 50 7 348 261 1.0024data7-50-348-84 50 7 348 263 1.0029data7-50-348-85 50 7 348 259 1.0026data7-50-348-86 50 7 348 293 1.0011data7-50-348-87 50 7 348 253 1.0027data7-50-348-88 50 7 348 279 1.0035data7-50-348-89 50 7 348 244 1.0040data7-50-348-90 50 7 348 255 1.0063data7-50-348-91 50 7 348 258 1.0074data7-50-348-92 50 7 348 271 1.0016data7-50-348-93 50 7 348 250 1.0055data7-50-348-94 50 7 348 262 1.0040data7-50-348-95 50 7 348 276 1.0050data7-50-348-96 50 7 348 268 1.0060data7-50-348-97 50 7 348 255 1.0028data7-50-348-98 50 7 348 267 1.0054data7-50-348-99 50 7 348 286 1.0042data7-50-348-100 50 7 348 266 1.0028data7-50-349-1 50 7 349 277 1.0026data7-50-349-2 50 7 349 240 1.0041data7-50-349-3 50 7 349 265 1.0051data7-50-349-4 50 7 349 245 1.0061data7-50-349-5 50 7 349 269 1.0034data7-50-349-6 50 7 349 252 1.0039data7-50-349-7 50 7 349 250 1.0035data7-50-349-8 50 7 349 257 1.0028data7-50-349-9 50 7 349 254 1.0060data7-50-349-10 50 7 349 259 1.0030data7-50-349-11 50 7 349 257 1.0024data7-50-349-12 50 7 349 278 1.0047data7-50-349-13 50 7 349 283 1.0043data7-50-349-14 50 7 349 263 1.0056data7-50-349-15 50 7 349 257 1.0042data7-50-349-16 50 7 349 255 1.0040data7-50-349-17 50 7 349 277 1.0033data7-50-349-18 50 7 349 271 1.0053data7-50-349-19 50 7 349 245 1.0047data7-50-349-20 50 7 349 253 1.0015data7-50-349-21 50 7 349 272 1.0036data7-50-349-22 50 7 349 289 1.0033data7-50-349-23 50 7 349 278 1.0047data7-50-349-24 50 7 349 250 1.0039data7-50-349-25 50 7 349 275 1.0031data7-50-349-26 50 7 349 259 0.9964data7-50-349-27 50 7 349 297 1.0050data7-50-349-28 50 7 349 271 1.0032data7-50-349-29 50 7 349 248 1.0058data7-50-349-30 50 7 349 242 1.0030data7-50-349-31 50 7 349 251 1.0061data7-50-349-32 50 7 349 283 0.9983data7-50-349-33 50 7 349 256 0.9974data7-50-349-34 50 7 349 266 1.0024data7-50-349-35 50 7 349 245 1.0051data7-50-349-36 50 7 349 256 1.0031data7-50-349-37 50 7 349 265 1.0017data7-50-349-38 50 7 349 264 1.0034data7-50-349-39 50 7 349 258 1.0039data7-50-349-40 50 7 349 280 1.0025data7-50-349-41 50 7 349 268 1.0054data7-50-349-42 50 7 349 243 1.0051data7-50-349-43 50 7 349 280 1.0044data7-50-349-44 50 7 349 286 1.0026data7-50-349-45 50 7 349 267 1.0057data7-50-349-46 50 7 349 293 1.0020data7-50-349-47 50 7 349 254 0.9948data7-50-349-48 50 7 349 266 1.0027data7-50-349-49 50 7 349 246 1.0037data7-50-349-50 50 7 349 264 1.0049

Table 15: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 401: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-50-349-51 50 7 349 266 1.0017data7-50-349-52 50 7 349 274 1.0033data7-50-349-53 50 7 349 256 1.0025data7-50-349-54 50 7 349 291 1.0030data7-50-349-55 50 7 349 276 1.0015data7-50-349-56 50 7 349 271 1.0036data7-50-349-57 50 7 349 263 1.0052data7-50-349-58 50 7 349 263 1.0026data7-50-349-59 50 7 349 248 1.0032data7-50-349-60 50 7 349 275 1.0042data7-50-349-61 50 7 349 275 1.0008data7-50-349-62 50 7 349 263 1.0043data7-50-349-63 50 7 349 271 1.0025data7-50-349-64 50 7 349 263 1.0017data7-50-349-65 50 7 349 244 1.0017data7-50-349-66 50 7 349 263 1.0033data7-50-349-67 50 7 349 264 1.0063data7-50-349-68 50 7 349 261 1.0028data7-50-349-69 50 7 349 251 1.0023data7-50-349-70 50 7 349 256 1.0030data7-50-349-71 50 7 349 264 1.0031data7-50-349-72 50 7 349 254 1.0020data7-50-349-73 50 7 349 274 1.0026data7-50-349-74 50 7 349 270 1.0024data7-50-349-75 50 7 349 275 1.0041data7-50-349-76 50 7 349 250 1.0037data7-50-349-77 50 7 349 261 0.9988data7-50-349-78 50 7 349 267 0.9969data7-50-349-79 50 7 349 250 1.0033data7-50-349-80 50 7 349 268 1.0042data7-50-349-81 50 7 349 280 1.0045data7-50-349-82 50 7 349 286 1.0001data7-50-349-83 50 7 349 258 0.9974data7-50-349-84 50 7 349 249 1.0026data7-50-349-85 50 7 349 257 1.0028data7-50-349-86 50 7 349 271 1.0016data7-50-349-87 50 7 349 285 0.9989data7-50-349-88 50 7 349 264 0.9993data7-50-349-89 50 7 349 259 1.0039data7-50-349-90 50 7 349 275 1.0079data7-50-349-91 50 7 349 264 1.0059data7-50-349-92 50 7 349 274 0.9965data7-50-349-93 50 7 349 269 0.9965data7-50-349-94 50 7 349 280 1.0036data7-50-349-95 50 7 349 254 1.0068data7-50-349-96 50 7 349 274 1.0034data7-50-349-97 50 7 349 260 1.0011data7-50-349-98 50 7 349 257 0.9970data7-50-349-99 50 7 349 264 1.0044data7-50-349-100 50 7 349 249 1.0020data10-50-490-1 50 10 490 482 1.0039data10-50-490-2 50 10 490 472 1.0010data10-50-490-3 50 10 490 488 1.0018data10-50-490-4 50 10 490 512 1.0036data10-50-490-5 50 10 490 511 1.0037data10-50-490-6 50 10 490 452 1.0058data10-50-490-7 50 10 490 451 1.0025data10-50-490-8 50 10 490 476 1.0034data10-50-490-9 50 10 490 496 1.0021data10-50-490-10 50 10 490 503 1.0029data10-50-490-11 50 10 490 490 1.0015data10-50-490-12 50 10 490 533 1.0027data10-50-490-13 50 10 490 508 1.0018data10-50-490-14 50 10 490 492 1.0035data10-50-490-15 50 10 490 488 1.0035data10-50-490-16 50 10 490 436 1.0026data10-50-490-17 50 10 490 513 1.0010data10-50-490-18 50 10 490 482 1.0021data10-50-490-19 50 10 490 494 1.0028data10-50-490-20 50 10 490 486 1.0023

Table 16: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 402: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-50-490-21 50 10 490 492 1.0061data10-50-490-22 50 10 490 501 1.0035data10-50-490-23 50 10 490 497 1.0051data10-50-490-24 50 10 490 474 1.0041data10-50-490-25 50 10 490 492 1.0018data10-50-490-26 50 10 490 511 1.0027data10-50-490-27 50 10 490 464 0.9984data10-50-490-28 50 10 490 496 1.0009data10-50-490-29 50 10 490 483 1.0030data10-50-490-30 50 10 490 514 1.0035data10-50-490-31 50 10 490 545 1.0046data10-50-490-32 50 10 490 480 1.0021data10-50-490-33 50 10 490 500 1.0031data10-50-490-34 50 10 490 448 1.0057data10-50-490-35 50 10 490 466 1.0033data10-50-490-36 50 10 490 483 1.0052data10-50-490-37 50 10 490 496 1.0026data10-50-490-38 50 10 490 474 1.0044data10-50-490-39 50 10 490 495 1.0070data10-50-490-40 50 10 490 494 1.0055data10-50-490-41 50 10 490 492 1.0038data10-50-490-42 50 10 490 538 1.0074data10-50-490-43 50 10 490 479 1.0011data10-50-490-44 50 10 490 436 1.0038data10-50-490-45 50 10 490 493 1.0062data10-50-490-46 50 10 490 514 1.0075data10-50-490-47 50 10 490 472 1.0031data10-50-490-48 50 10 490 505 1.0060data10-50-490-49 50 10 490 495 1.0049data10-50-490-50 50 10 490 455 1.0059data10-50-490-51 50 10 490 508 1.0028data10-50-490-52 50 10 490 466 1.0013data10-50-490-53 50 10 490 469 1.0028data10-50-490-54 50 10 490 522 1.0027data10-50-490-55 50 10 490 495 1.0029data10-50-490-56 50 10 490 454 1.0028data10-50-490-57 50 10 490 494 1.0043data10-50-490-58 50 10 490 506 1.0034data10-50-490-59 50 10 490 507 1.0042data10-50-490-60 50 10 490 429 1.0038data10-50-490-61 50 10 490 493 1.0028data10-50-490-62 50 10 490 480 0.9988data10-50-490-63 50 10 490 471 1.0022data10-50-490-64 50 10 490 506 1.0051data10-50-490-65 50 10 490 514 1.0048data10-50-490-66 50 10 490 484 1.0033data10-50-490-67 50 10 490 475 1.0053data10-50-490-68 50 10 490 532 1.0032data10-50-490-69 50 10 490 484 1.0041data10-50-490-70 50 10 490 511 1.0034data10-50-490-71 50 10 490 490 1.0069data10-50-490-72 50 10 490 488 0.9992data10-50-490-73 50 10 490 498 1.0019data10-50-490-74 50 10 490 499 1.0035data10-50-490-75 50 10 490 484 1.0075data10-50-490-76 50 10 490 487 1.0030data10-50-490-77 50 10 490 448 1.0041data10-50-490-78 50 10 490 491 1.0054data10-50-490-79 50 10 490 498 1.0041data10-50-490-80 50 10 490 478 1.0045data10-50-490-81 50 10 490 483 1.0049data10-50-490-82 50 10 490 470 1.0021data10-50-490-83 50 10 490 477 1.0046data10-50-490-84 50 10 490 513 1.0049data10-50-490-85 50 10 490 479 1.0045data10-50-490-86 50 10 490 512 1.0032data10-50-490-87 50 10 490 478 1.0021data10-50-490-88 50 10 490 499 1.0032data10-50-490-89 50 10 490 517 1.0034data10-50-490-90 50 10 490 489 1.0074

Table 17: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 403: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-50-490-91 50 10 490 530 1.0035data10-50-490-92 50 10 490 506 1.0025data10-50-490-93 50 10 490 493 1.0053data10-50-490-94 50 10 490 488 1.0053data10-50-490-95 50 10 490 461 1.0032data10-50-490-96 50 10 490 492 1.0037data10-50-490-97 50 10 490 496 1.0062data10-50-490-98 50 10 490 500 1.0064data10-50-490-99 50 10 490 490 1.0033data10-50-490-100 50 10 490 477 1.0025data10-50-491-1 50 10 491 473 1.0031data10-50-491-2 50 10 491 498 1.0027data10-50-491-3 50 10 491 515 1.0059data10-50-491-4 50 10 491 493 1.0035data10-50-491-5 50 10 491 512 1.0053data10-50-491-6 50 10 491 500 1.0056data10-50-491-7 50 10 491 502 1.0020data10-50-491-8 50 10 491 478 1.0032data10-50-491-9 50 10 491 503 1.0037data10-50-491-10 50 10 491 467 1.0028data10-50-491-11 50 10 491 479 1.0022data10-50-491-12 50 10 491 474 1.0022data10-50-491-13 50 10 491 543 1.0023data10-50-491-14 50 10 491 486 1.0037data10-50-491-15 50 10 491 479 1.0038data10-50-491-16 50 10 491 482 1.0031data10-50-491-17 50 10 491 440 1.0037data10-50-491-18 50 10 491 466 1.0053data10-50-491-19 50 10 491 465 1.0035data10-50-491-20 50 10 491 541 1.0048data10-50-491-21 50 10 491 479 1.0034data10-50-491-22 50 10 491 479 1.0072data10-50-491-23 50 10 491 529 1.0040data10-50-491-24 50 10 491 454 1.0027data10-50-491-25 50 10 491 502 1.0043data10-50-491-26 50 10 491 491 1.0053data10-50-491-27 50 10 491 507 1.0007data10-50-491-28 50 10 491 497 1.0026data10-50-491-29 50 10 491 509 1.0004data10-50-491-30 50 10 491 533 1.0043data10-50-491-31 50 10 491 502 1.0055data10-50-491-32 50 10 491 457 1.0037data10-50-491-33 50 10 491 488 1.0032data10-50-491-34 50 10 491 486 1.0037data10-50-491-35 50 10 491 501 1.0056data10-50-491-36 50 10 491 507 1.0067data10-50-491-37 50 10 491 481 1.0068data10-50-491-38 50 10 491 512 1.0028data10-50-491-39 50 10 491 473 1.0030data10-50-491-40 50 10 491 509 1.0055data10-50-491-41 50 10 491 514 1.0020data10-50-491-42 50 10 491 484 1.0027data10-50-491-43 50 10 491 501 1.0038data10-50-491-44 50 10 491 475 1.0064data10-50-491-45 50 10 491 473 1.0058data10-50-491-46 50 10 491 506 1.0055data10-50-491-47 50 10 491 474 1.0023data10-50-491-48 50 10 491 547 1.0043data10-50-491-49 50 10 491 499 1.0025data10-50-491-50 50 10 491 461 1.0022data10-50-491-51 50 10 491 446 1.0017data10-50-491-52 50 10 491 508 1.0061data10-50-491-53 50 10 491 493 1.0029data10-50-491-54 50 10 491 492 1.0058data10-50-491-55 50 10 491 463 1.0042data10-50-491-56 50 10 491 458 1.0047data10-50-491-57 50 10 491 461 1.0044data10-50-491-58 50 10 491 503 1.0045data10-50-491-59 50 10 491 508 1.0053data10-50-491-60 50 10 491 501 1.0049

Table 18: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 404: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-50-491-61 50 10 491 481 1.0037data10-50-491-62 50 10 491 510 1.0029data10-50-491-63 50 10 491 538 1.0028data10-50-491-64 50 10 491 441 1.0036data10-50-491-65 50 10 491 518 1.0017data10-50-491-66 50 10 491 475 1.0063data10-50-491-67 50 10 491 485 1.0027data10-50-491-68 50 10 491 495 1.0037data10-50-491-69 50 10 491 481 1.0061data10-50-491-70 50 10 491 518 1.0054data10-50-491-71 50 10 491 483 1.0044data10-50-491-72 50 10 491 475 1.0036data10-50-491-73 50 10 491 526 1.0049data10-50-491-74 50 10 491 506 1.0036data10-50-491-75 50 10 491 493 1.0047data10-50-491-76 50 10 491 518 1.0053data10-50-491-77 50 10 491 491 1.0041data10-50-491-78 50 10 491 471 1.0024data10-50-491-79 50 10 491 499 1.0038data10-50-491-80 50 10 491 473 1.0037data10-50-491-81 50 10 491 488 1.0021data10-50-491-82 50 10 491 520 1.0068data10-50-491-83 50 10 491 507 1.0040data10-50-491-84 50 10 491 508 1.0020data10-50-491-85 50 10 491 479 1.0021data10-50-491-86 50 10 491 500 1.0047data10-50-491-87 50 10 491 481 1.0041data10-50-491-88 50 10 491 524 1.0027data10-50-491-89 50 10 491 482 1.0038data10-50-491-90 50 10 491 497 1.0053data10-50-491-91 50 10 491 460 1.0048data10-50-491-92 50 10 491 488 1.0027data10-50-491-93 50 10 491 490 1.0023data10-50-491-94 50 10 491 486 1.0049data10-50-491-95 50 10 491 495 1.0048data10-50-491-96 50 10 491 505 1.0047data10-50-491-97 50 10 491 460 1.0040data10-50-491-98 50 10 491 463 1.0046data10-50-491-99 50 10 491 476 1.0062data10-50-491-100 50 10 491 499 1.0036data10-50-492-1 50 10 492 490 1.0047data10-50-492-2 50 10 492 479 1.0052data10-50-492-3 50 10 492 470 1.0046data10-50-492-4 50 10 492 506 1.0064data10-50-492-5 50 10 492 491 1.0063data10-50-492-6 50 10 492 510 1.0050data10-50-492-7 50 10 492 501 1.0027data10-50-492-8 50 10 492 534 1.0068data10-50-492-9 50 10 492 474 1.0017data10-50-492-10 50 10 492 469 1.0055data10-50-492-11 50 10 492 515 1.0054data10-50-492-12 50 10 492 476 1.0022data10-50-492-13 50 10 492 514 1.0003data10-50-492-14 50 10 492 485 1.0024data10-50-492-15 50 10 492 482 1.0056data10-50-492-16 50 10 492 537 1.0069data10-50-492-17 50 10 492 496 1.0008data10-50-492-18 50 10 492 492 0.9945data10-50-492-19 50 10 492 520 1.0026data10-50-492-20 50 10 492 499 1.0029data10-50-492-21 50 10 492 502 1.0038data10-50-492-22 50 10 492 493 1.0026data10-50-492-23 50 10 492 519 1.0052data10-50-492-24 50 10 492 461 1.0052data10-50-492-25 50 10 492 481 1.0041data10-50-492-26 50 10 492 499 1.0064data10-50-492-27 50 10 492 496 1.0013data10-50-492-28 50 10 492 502 0.9962data10-50-492-29 50 10 492 513 1.0043data10-50-492-30 50 10 492 492 1.0057

Table 19: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 405: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-50-492-31 50 10 492 489 1.0038data10-50-492-32 50 10 492 494 1.0044data10-50-492-33 50 10 492 515 1.0016data10-50-492-34 50 10 492 473 1.0077data10-50-492-35 50 10 492 510 1.0049data10-50-492-36 50 10 492 502 1.0041data10-50-492-37 50 10 492 453 1.0019data10-50-492-38 50 10 492 502 0.9938data10-50-492-39 50 10 492 467 1.0069data10-50-492-40 50 10 492 456 1.0050data10-50-492-41 50 10 492 496 1.0060data10-50-492-42 50 10 492 497 0.9950data10-50-492-43 50 10 492 506 1.0052data10-50-492-44 50 10 492 544 1.0056data10-50-492-45 50 10 492 485 1.0061data10-50-492-46 50 10 492 490 1.0060data10-50-492-47 50 10 492 462 1.0046data10-50-492-48 50 10 492 462 1.0028data10-50-492-49 50 10 492 468 1.0030data10-50-492-50 50 10 492 474 1.0066data10-50-492-51 50 10 492 495 1.0054data10-50-492-52 50 10 492 494 0.9976data10-50-492-53 50 10 492 511 1.0027data10-50-492-54 50 10 492 467 1.0051data10-50-492-55 50 10 492 496 1.0064data10-50-492-56 50 10 492 480 1.0032data10-50-492-57 50 10 492 481 0.9985data10-50-492-58 50 10 492 511 0.9971data10-50-492-59 50 10 492 497 1.0023data10-50-492-60 50 10 492 494 1.0057data10-50-492-61 50 10 492 478 1.0050data10-50-492-62 50 10 492 488 1.0065data10-50-492-63 50 10 492 531 1.0023data10-50-492-64 50 10 492 474 1.0032data10-50-492-65 50 10 492 474 1.0038data10-50-492-66 50 10 492 531 1.0057data10-50-492-67 50 10 492 480 0.9966data10-50-492-68 50 10 492 489 1.0021data10-50-492-69 50 10 492 502 1.0045data10-50-492-70 50 10 492 471 1.0050data10-50-492-71 50 10 492 456 1.0053data10-50-492-72 50 10 492 530 1.0049data10-50-492-73 50 10 492 523 0.9997data10-50-492-74 50 10 492 506 1.0034data10-50-492-75 50 10 492 507 1.0007data10-50-492-76 50 10 492 502 1.0027data10-50-492-77 50 10 492 465 1.0031data10-50-492-78 50 10 492 494 1.0061data10-50-492-79 50 10 492 528 1.0051data10-50-492-80 50 10 492 501 1.0074data10-50-492-81 50 10 492 475 1.0021data10-50-492-82 50 10 492 469 1.0011data10-50-492-83 50 10 492 501 1.0018data10-50-492-84 50 10 492 505 1.0065data10-50-492-85 50 10 492 472 1.0060data10-50-492-86 50 10 492 517 1.0059data10-50-492-87 50 10 492 467 1.0056data10-50-492-88 50 10 492 484 1.0045data10-50-492-89 50 10 492 450 1.0021data10-50-492-90 50 10 492 492 1.0057data10-50-492-91 50 10 492 507 1.0043data10-50-492-92 50 10 492 510 1.0029data10-50-492-93 50 10 492 494 1.0010data10-50-492-94 50 10 492 444 1.0033data10-50-492-95 50 10 492 490 1.0049data10-50-492-96 50 10 492 480 1.0041data10-50-492-97 50 10 492 484 1.0025data10-50-492-98 50 10 492 525 1.0025data10-50-492-99 50 10 492 479 1.0037data10-50-492-100 50 10 492 471 1.0044

Table 20: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 406: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-50-493-1 50 10 493 501 1.0066data10-50-493-2 50 10 493 484 1.0032data10-50-493-3 50 10 493 454 0.9952data10-50-493-4 50 10 493 512 1.0031data10-50-493-5 50 10 493 488 1.0041data10-50-493-6 50 10 493 483 1.0015data10-50-493-7 50 10 493 511 1.0058data10-50-493-8 50 10 493 488 1.0056data10-50-493-9 50 10 493 479 1.0057data10-50-493-10 50 10 493 511 1.0051data10-50-493-11 50 10 493 513 1.0023data10-50-493-12 50 10 493 505 1.0034data10-50-493-13 50 10 493 491 1.0024data10-50-493-14 50 10 493 489 1.0043data10-50-493-15 50 10 493 466 1.0024data10-50-493-16 50 10 493 490 1.0029data10-50-493-17 50 10 493 463 0.9999data10-50-493-18 50 10 493 544 1.0033data10-50-493-19 50 10 493 492 1.0060data10-50-493-20 50 10 493 519 1.0041data10-50-493-21 50 10 493 487 1.0034data10-50-493-22 50 10 493 482 1.0030data10-50-493-23 50 10 493 486 0.9979data10-50-493-24 50 10 493 465 1.0048data10-50-493-25 50 10 493 522 1.0071data10-50-493-26 50 10 493 477 1.0052data10-50-493-27 50 10 493 508 1.0058data10-50-493-28 50 10 493 479 1.0030data10-50-493-29 50 10 493 520 1.0071data10-50-493-30 50 10 493 490 1.0030data10-50-493-31 50 10 493 515 1.0051data10-50-493-32 50 10 493 468 0.9970data10-50-493-33 50 10 493 475 1.0021data10-50-493-34 50 10 493 476 1.0062data10-50-493-35 50 10 493 512 1.0057data10-50-493-36 50 10 493 498 1.0023data10-50-493-37 50 10 493 487 1.0037data10-50-493-38 50 10 493 493 1.0018data10-50-493-39 50 10 493 514 1.0033data10-50-493-40 50 10 493 530 1.0061data10-50-493-41 50 10 493 492 1.0074data10-50-493-42 50 10 493 505 1.0019data10-50-493-43 50 10 493 452 1.0067data10-50-493-44 50 10 493 479 1.0054data10-50-493-45 50 10 493 492 1.0023data10-50-493-46 50 10 493 532 1.0058data10-50-493-47 50 10 493 483 1.0036data10-50-493-48 50 10 493 472 1.0039data10-50-493-49 50 10 493 502 1.0039data10-50-493-50 50 10 493 481 1.0052data10-50-493-51 50 10 493 480 1.0058data10-50-493-52 50 10 493 511 0.9990data10-50-493-53 50 10 493 496 1.0014data10-50-493-54 50 10 493 509 1.0062data10-50-493-55 50 10 493 508 1.0057data10-50-493-56 50 10 493 499 1.0040data10-50-493-57 50 10 493 488 1.0019data10-50-493-58 50 10 493 506 1.0029data10-50-493-59 50 10 493 464 1.0076data10-50-493-60 50 10 493 514 1.0037data10-50-493-61 50 10 493 504 1.0020data10-50-493-62 50 10 493 516 1.0046data10-50-493-63 50 10 493 493 1.0027data10-50-493-64 50 10 493 498 1.0061data10-50-493-65 50 10 493 473 1.0026data10-50-493-66 50 10 493 472 1.0039data10-50-493-67 50 10 493 472 1.0024data10-50-493-68 50 10 493 486 1.0045data10-50-493-69 50 10 493 492 1.0053data10-50-493-70 50 10 493 444 1.0072

Table 21: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 407: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-50-493-71 50 10 493 507 1.0057data10-50-493-72 50 10 493 517 1.0009data10-50-493-73 50 10 493 516 1.0031data10-50-493-74 50 10 493 516 1.0030data10-50-493-75 50 10 493 499 1.0023data10-50-493-76 50 10 493 503 1.0075data10-50-493-77 50 10 493 487 1.0030data10-50-493-78 50 10 493 513 1.0045data10-50-493-79 50 10 493 523 1.0051data10-50-493-80 50 10 493 476 1.0053data10-50-493-81 50 10 493 498 1.0063data10-50-493-82 50 10 493 483 1.0059data10-50-493-83 50 10 493 488 0.9962data10-50-493-84 50 10 493 478 1.0056data10-50-493-85 50 10 493 516 1.0050data10-50-493-86 50 10 493 527 1.0031data10-50-493-87 50 10 493 492 1.0044data10-50-493-88 50 10 493 511 1.0023data10-50-493-89 50 10 493 535 1.0072data10-50-493-90 50 10 493 521 1.0037data10-50-493-91 50 10 493 553 1.0046data10-50-493-92 50 10 493 505 1.0022data10-50-493-93 50 10 493 484 1.0023data10-50-493-94 50 10 493 447 1.0073data10-50-493-95 50 10 493 480 1.0029data10-50-493-96 50 10 493 476 1.0085data10-50-493-97 50 10 493 489 1.0082data10-50-493-98 50 10 493 482 1.0044data10-50-493-99 50 10 493 507 1.0029data10-50-493-100 50 10 493 476 1.0033data10-50-494-1 50 10 494 509 1.0028data10-50-494-2 50 10 494 492 1.0045data10-50-494-3 50 10 494 515 1.0038data10-50-494-4 50 10 494 508 1.0065data10-50-494-5 50 10 494 457 1.0036data10-50-494-6 50 10 494 502 1.0032data10-50-494-7 50 10 494 464 1.0057data10-50-494-8 50 10 494 505 1.0064data10-50-494-9 50 10 494 462 1.0031data10-50-494-10 50 10 494 480 1.0058data10-50-494-11 50 10 494 468 1.0031data10-50-494-12 50 10 494 531 1.0036data10-50-494-13 50 10 494 527 0.9982data10-50-494-14 50 10 494 531 1.0024data10-50-494-15 50 10 494 499 1.0068data10-50-494-16 50 10 494 517 1.0015data10-50-494-17 50 10 494 503 1.0037data10-50-494-18 50 10 494 485 0.9985data10-50-494-19 50 10 494 499 1.0052data10-50-494-20 50 10 494 497 1.0056data10-50-494-21 50 10 494 470 1.0033data10-50-494-22 50 10 494 509 1.0043data10-50-494-23 50 10 494 489 1.0062data10-50-494-24 50 10 494 505 1.0030data10-50-494-25 50 10 494 477 1.0044data10-50-494-26 50 10 494 498 1.0035data10-50-494-27 50 10 494 477 1.0035data10-50-494-28 50 10 494 497 1.0023data10-50-494-29 50 10 494 473 1.0024data10-50-494-30 50 10 494 517 1.0069data10-50-494-31 50 10 494 494 1.0016data10-50-494-32 50 10 494 513 1.0071data10-50-494-33 50 10 494 527 1.0070data10-50-494-34 50 10 494 514 1.0070data10-50-494-35 50 10 494 498 1.0052data10-50-494-36 50 10 494 539 1.0037data10-50-494-37 50 10 494 483 1.0036data10-50-494-38 50 10 494 467 1.0036data10-50-494-39 50 10 494 499 1.0066data10-50-494-40 50 10 494 492 1.0052

Table 22: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 408: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-50-494-41 50 10 494 459 1.0065data10-50-494-42 50 10 494 467 1.0035data10-50-494-43 50 10 494 466 1.0039data10-50-494-44 50 10 494 493 1.0050data10-50-494-45 50 10 494 485 1.0033data10-50-494-46 50 10 494 487 1.0057data10-50-494-47 50 10 494 463 1.0046data10-50-494-48 50 10 494 466 1.0035data10-50-494-49 50 10 494 519 1.0057data10-50-494-50 50 10 494 493 1.0068data10-50-494-51 50 10 494 507 1.0070data10-50-494-52 50 10 494 539 1.0029data10-50-494-53 50 10 494 485 1.0035data10-50-494-54 50 10 494 523 1.0039data10-50-494-55 50 10 494 490 1.0041data10-50-494-56 50 10 494 514 1.0064data10-50-494-57 50 10 494 510 1.0053data10-50-494-58 50 10 494 513 1.0038data10-50-494-59 50 10 494 504 1.0052data10-50-494-60 50 10 494 481 1.0045data10-50-494-61 50 10 494 546 1.0023data10-50-494-62 50 10 494 497 1.0020data10-50-494-63 50 10 494 510 1.0055data10-50-494-64 50 10 494 497 1.0079data10-50-494-65 50 10 494 527 1.0028data10-50-494-66 50 10 494 471 1.0054data10-50-494-67 50 10 494 504 0.9949data10-50-494-68 50 10 494 534 1.0001data10-50-494-69 50 10 494 491 1.0023data10-50-494-70 50 10 494 496 1.0080data10-50-494-71 50 10 494 496 1.0022data10-50-494-72 50 10 494 506 1.0033data10-50-494-73 50 10 494 473 1.0027data10-50-494-74 50 10 494 498 1.0079data10-50-494-75 50 10 494 485 1.0030data10-50-494-76 50 10 494 490 1.0037data10-50-494-77 50 10 494 513 1.0003data10-50-494-78 50 10 494 533 1.0040data10-50-494-79 50 10 494 492 1.0048data10-50-494-80 50 10 494 544 1.0035data10-50-494-81 50 10 494 498 1.0052data10-50-494-82 50 10 494 488 1.0041data10-50-494-83 50 10 494 505 0.9954data10-50-494-84 50 10 494 523 1.0042data10-50-494-85 50 10 494 491 1.0066data10-50-494-86 50 10 494 503 1.0030data10-50-494-87 50 10 494 527 0.9967data10-50-494-88 50 10 494 545 0.9978data10-50-494-89 50 10 494 499 1.0034data10-50-494-90 50 10 494 546 1.0024data10-50-494-91 50 10 494 533 1.0027data10-50-494-92 50 10 494 514 0.9992data10-50-494-93 50 10 494 501 0.9974data10-50-494-94 50 10 494 479 1.0064data10-50-494-95 50 10 494 497 1.0024data10-50-494-96 50 10 494 511 1.0046data10-50-494-97 50 10 494 492 1.0025data10-50-494-98 50 10 494 545 1.0024data10-50-494-99 50 10 494 488 1.0042data10-50-494-100 50 10 494 491 1.0063data10-50-495-1 50 10 495 525 1.0033data10-50-495-2 50 10 495 526 1.0036data10-50-495-3 50 10 495 486 1.0037data10-50-495-4 50 10 495 528 1.0049data10-50-495-5 50 10 495 528 1.0036data10-50-495-6 50 10 495 474 1.0041data10-50-495-7 50 10 495 507 1.0055data10-50-495-8 50 10 495 506 1.0063data10-50-495-9 50 10 495 516 1.0035data10-50-495-10 50 10 495 467 1.0032

Table 23: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 409: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-50-495-11 50 10 495 511 1.0055data10-50-495-12 50 10 495 478 1.0053data10-50-495-13 50 10 495 498 1.0044data10-50-495-14 50 10 495 508 1.0055data10-50-495-15 50 10 495 488 1.0045data10-50-495-16 50 10 495 558 1.0043data10-50-495-17 50 10 495 547 1.0041data10-50-495-18 50 10 495 485 1.0042data10-50-495-19 50 10 495 480 1.0050data10-50-495-20 50 10 495 506 1.0035data10-50-495-21 50 10 495 499 1.0049data10-50-495-22 50 10 495 507 1.0058data10-50-495-23 50 10 495 499 1.0040data10-50-495-24 50 10 495 491 1.0040data10-50-495-25 50 10 495 532 1.0045data10-50-495-26 50 10 495 458 1.0030data10-50-495-27 50 10 495 504 1.0039data10-50-495-28 50 10 495 492 1.0053data10-50-495-29 50 10 495 495 1.0046data10-50-495-30 50 10 495 496 1.0048data10-50-495-31 50 10 495 508 1.0050data10-50-495-32 50 10 495 490 1.0030data10-50-495-33 50 10 495 514 1.0028data10-50-495-34 50 10 495 503 1.0048data10-50-495-35 50 10 495 466 1.0058data10-50-495-36 50 10 495 522 1.0024data10-50-495-37 50 10 495 538 1.0032data10-50-495-38 50 10 495 496 1.0052data10-50-495-39 50 10 495 521 1.0049data10-50-495-40 50 10 495 477 1.0037data10-50-495-41 50 10 495 476 1.0046data10-50-495-42 50 10 495 477 1.0063data10-50-495-43 50 10 495 488 1.0049data10-50-495-44 50 10 495 501 1.0078data10-50-495-45 50 10 495 564 1.0074data10-50-495-46 50 10 495 519 1.0060data10-50-495-47 50 10 495 503 1.0036data10-50-495-48 50 10 495 554 1.0063data10-50-495-49 50 10 495 510 1.0052data10-50-495-50 50 10 495 498 1.0041data10-50-495-51 50 10 495 470 1.0068data10-50-495-52 50 10 495 523 1.0046data10-50-495-53 50 10 495 479 1.0043data10-50-495-54 50 10 495 544 1.0090data10-50-495-55 50 10 495 475 1.0060data10-50-495-56 50 10 495 504 1.0030data10-50-495-57 50 10 495 555 1.0065data10-50-495-58 50 10 495 485 1.0054data10-50-495-59 50 10 495 468 1.0015data10-50-495-60 50 10 495 525 1.0023data10-50-495-61 50 10 495 527 1.0049data10-50-495-62 50 10 495 509 1.0017data10-50-495-63 50 10 495 547 1.0038data10-50-495-64 50 10 495 484 1.0026data10-50-495-65 50 10 495 502 1.0016data10-50-495-66 50 10 495 490 1.0017data10-50-495-67 50 10 495 526 1.0027data10-50-495-68 50 10 495 521 1.0047data10-50-495-69 50 10 495 481 1.0025data10-50-495-70 50 10 495 489 1.0013data10-50-495-71 50 10 495 491 1.0047data10-50-495-72 50 10 495 483 1.0039data10-50-495-73 50 10 495 497 1.0043data10-50-495-74 50 10 495 496 1.0047data10-50-495-75 50 10 495 484 1.0063data10-50-495-76 50 10 495 545 1.0062data10-50-495-77 50 10 495 462 0.9957data10-50-495-78 50 10 495 479 0.9929data10-50-495-79 50 10 495 505 1.0028data10-50-495-80 50 10 495 546 1.0048

Table 24: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 410: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-50-495-81 50 10 495 490 1.0056data10-50-495-82 50 10 495 495 0.9954data10-50-495-83 50 10 495 496 0.9990data10-50-495-84 50 10 495 506 1.0049data10-50-495-85 50 10 495 532 1.0041data10-50-495-86 50 10 495 485 1.0040data10-50-495-87 50 10 495 495 1.0009data10-50-495-88 50 10 495 493 0.9991data10-50-495-89 50 10 495 473 1.0039data10-50-495-90 50 10 495 493 1.0019data10-50-495-91 50 10 495 486 1.0053data10-50-495-92 50 10 495 495 0.9986data10-50-495-93 50 10 495 487 1.0001data10-50-495-94 50 10 495 496 1.0052data10-50-495-95 50 10 495 528 1.0050data10-50-495-96 50 10 495 497 1.0024data10-50-495-97 50 10 495 552 0.9980data10-50-495-98 50 10 495 488 0.9975data10-50-495-99 50 10 495 499 1.0040data10-50-495-100 50 10 495 470 1.0046data10-50-496-1 50 10 496 517 1.0056data10-50-496-2 50 10 496 495 1.0058data10-50-496-3 50 10 496 523 1.0014data10-50-496-4 50 10 496 473 1.0038data10-50-496-5 50 10 496 500 1.0052data10-50-496-6 50 10 496 506 1.0043data10-50-496-7 50 10 496 510 1.0039data10-50-496-8 50 10 496 483 0.9966data10-50-496-9 50 10 496 525 1.0060data10-50-496-10 50 10 496 483 1.0038data10-50-496-11 50 10 496 481 1.0055data10-50-496-12 50 10 496 514 0.9998data10-50-496-13 50 10 496 480 1.0016data10-50-496-14 50 10 496 533 1.0039data10-50-496-15 50 10 496 506 1.0048data10-50-496-16 50 10 496 505 1.0056data10-50-496-17 50 10 496 491 0.9994data10-50-496-18 50 10 496 511 0.9988data10-50-496-19 50 10 496 521 1.0022data10-50-496-20 50 10 496 507 1.0051data10-50-496-21 50 10 496 508 1.0027data10-50-496-22 50 10 496 490 1.0004data10-50-496-23 50 10 496 536 1.0034data10-50-496-24 50 10 496 520 1.0035data10-50-496-25 50 10 496 505 1.0048data10-50-496-26 50 10 496 514 1.0055data10-50-496-27 50 10 496 495 1.0006data10-50-496-28 50 10 496 537 1.0045data10-50-496-29 50 10 496 521 1.0039data10-50-496-30 50 10 496 489 1.0051data10-50-496-31 50 10 496 476 1.0028data10-50-496-32 50 10 496 493 0.9971data10-50-496-33 50 10 496 525 1.0028data10-50-496-34 50 10 496 498 1.0052data10-50-496-35 50 10 496 500 1.0037data10-50-496-36 50 10 496 524 1.0050data10-50-496-37 50 10 496 521 1.0063data10-50-496-38 50 10 496 507 1.0037data10-50-496-39 50 10 496 478 1.0031data10-50-496-40 50 10 496 476 1.0039data10-50-496-41 50 10 496 516 1.0030data10-50-496-42 50 10 496 508 1.0027data10-50-496-43 50 10 496 485 1.0050data10-50-496-44 50 10 496 526 1.0062data10-50-496-45 50 10 496 505 1.0007data10-50-496-46 50 10 496 540 1.0020data10-50-496-47 50 10 496 530 1.0057data10-50-496-48 50 10 496 513 1.0034data10-50-496-49 50 10 496 499 1.0060data10-50-496-50 50 10 496 462 1.0020

Table 25: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 411: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-50-496-51 50 10 496 512 1.0051data10-50-496-52 50 10 496 525 1.0013data10-50-496-53 50 10 496 496 1.0009data10-50-496-54 50 10 496 538 1.0033data10-50-496-55 50 10 496 520 1.0012data10-50-496-56 50 10 496 526 1.0011data10-50-496-57 50 10 496 473 1.0038data10-50-496-58 50 10 496 497 0.9978data10-50-496-59 50 10 496 487 1.0068data10-50-496-60 50 10 496 506 1.0026data10-50-496-61 50 10 496 480 1.0045data10-50-496-62 50 10 496 513 1.0025data10-50-496-63 50 10 496 529 0.9939data10-50-496-64 50 10 496 485 1.0051data10-50-496-65 50 10 496 465 1.0025data10-50-496-66 50 10 496 507 1.0058data10-50-496-67 50 10 496 499 0.9997data10-50-496-68 50 10 496 457 1.0003data10-50-496-69 50 10 496 474 1.0030data10-50-496-70 50 10 496 502 1.0026data10-50-496-71 50 10 496 523 1.0069data10-50-496-72 50 10 496 474 1.0050data10-50-496-73 50 10 496 430 1.0042data10-50-496-74 50 10 496 475 1.0041data10-50-496-75 50 10 496 525 1.0024data10-50-496-76 50 10 496 507 1.0025data10-50-496-77 50 10 496 527 1.0036data10-50-496-78 50 10 496 465 1.0073data10-50-496-79 50 10 496 498 1.0047data10-50-496-80 50 10 496 498 1.0049data10-50-496-81 50 10 496 492 1.0043data10-50-496-82 50 10 496 464 1.0025data10-50-496-83 50 10 496 553 1.0034data10-50-496-84 50 10 496 482 1.0030data10-50-496-85 50 10 496 518 1.0034data10-50-496-86 50 10 496 507 1.0039data10-50-496-87 50 10 496 541 0.9994data10-50-496-88 50 10 496 487 0.9918data10-50-496-89 50 10 496 510 1.0053data10-50-496-90 50 10 496 496 1.0009data10-50-496-91 50 10 496 514 1.0019data10-50-496-92 50 10 496 516 1.0037data10-50-496-93 50 10 496 504 1.0035data10-50-496-94 50 10 496 531 1.0049data10-50-496-95 50 10 496 511 1.0046data10-50-496-96 50 10 496 526 1.0044data10-50-496-97 50 10 496 503 1.0023data10-50-496-98 50 10 496 507 1.0018data10-50-496-99 50 10 496 484 1.0044data10-50-496-100 50 10 496 487 1.0039data10-50-497-1 50 10 497 507 1.0040data10-50-497-2 50 10 497 507 1.0033data10-50-497-3 50 10 497 501 1.0034data10-50-497-4 50 10 497 502 1.0053data10-50-497-5 50 10 497 507 1.0041data10-50-497-6 50 10 497 527 1.0032data10-50-497-7 50 10 497 540 1.0035data10-50-497-8 50 10 497 508 0.9998data10-50-497-9 50 10 497 488 1.0045data10-50-497-10 50 10 497 529 1.0066data10-50-497-11 50 10 497 522 1.0056data10-50-497-12 50 10 497 479 1.0014data10-50-497-13 50 10 497 492 1.0022data10-50-497-14 50 10 497 517 1.0024data10-50-497-15 50 10 497 499 1.0032data10-50-497-16 50 10 497 492 1.0013data10-50-497-17 50 10 497 543 0.9991data10-50-497-18 50 10 497 503 1.0006data10-50-497-19 50 10 497 558 1.0013data10-50-497-20 50 10 497 494 1.0038

Table 26: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 412: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-50-497-21 50 10 497 500 1.0015data10-50-497-22 50 10 497 460 1.0033data10-50-497-23 50 10 497 512 1.0057data10-50-497-24 50 10 497 538 1.0041data10-50-497-25 50 10 497 502 1.0031data10-50-497-26 50 10 497 518 1.0031data10-50-497-27 50 10 497 479 1.0005data10-50-497-28 50 10 497 522 0.9976data10-50-497-29 50 10 497 504 1.0063data10-50-497-30 50 10 497 490 1.0040data10-50-497-31 50 10 497 529 1.0038data10-50-497-32 50 10 497 520 1.0000data10-50-497-33 50 10 497 523 1.0019data10-50-497-34 50 10 497 486 1.0045data10-50-497-35 50 10 497 546 1.0018data10-50-497-36 50 10 497 482 1.0060data10-50-497-37 50 10 497 532 1.0040data10-50-497-38 50 10 497 495 1.0027data10-50-497-39 50 10 497 530 1.0037data10-50-497-40 50 10 497 480 1.0052data10-50-497-41 50 10 497 491 1.0055data10-50-497-42 50 10 497 510 1.0042data10-50-497-43 50 10 497 513 1.0011data10-50-497-44 50 10 497 492 1.0054data10-50-497-45 50 10 497 513 1.0047data10-50-497-46 50 10 497 501 1.0061data10-50-497-47 50 10 497 507 1.0011data10-50-497-48 50 10 497 535 1.0004data10-50-497-49 50 10 497 501 1.0033data10-50-497-50 50 10 497 493 1.0047data10-50-497-51 50 10 497 477 1.0027data10-50-497-52 50 10 497 512 1.0056data10-50-497-53 50 10 497 527 1.0035data10-50-497-54 50 10 497 501 1.0014data10-50-497-55 50 10 497 540 1.0034data10-50-497-56 50 10 497 497 1.0033data10-50-497-57 50 10 497 531 1.0035data10-50-497-58 50 10 497 470 0.9964data10-50-497-59 50 10 497 521 1.0074data10-50-497-60 50 10 497 545 1.0062data10-50-497-61 50 10 497 503 1.0013data10-50-497-62 50 10 497 492 1.0045data10-50-497-63 50 10 497 475 1.0056data10-50-497-64 50 10 497 503 1.0046data10-50-497-65 50 10 497 491 1.0063data10-50-497-66 50 10 497 515 1.0013data10-50-497-67 50 10 497 519 1.0036data10-50-497-68 50 10 497 487 0.9960data10-50-497-69 50 10 497 513 1.0028data10-50-497-70 50 10 497 504 1.0057data10-50-497-71 50 10 497 472 1.0042data10-50-497-72 50 10 497 485 1.0042data10-50-497-73 50 10 497 523 1.0023data10-50-497-74 50 10 497 475 1.0059data10-50-497-75 50 10 497 514 1.0043data10-50-497-76 50 10 497 507 1.0040data10-50-497-77 50 10 497 512 1.0035data10-50-497-78 50 10 497 508 1.0018data10-50-497-79 50 10 497 517 1.0041data10-50-497-80 50 10 497 492 1.0053data10-50-497-81 50 10 497 532 1.0014data10-50-497-82 50 10 497 498 1.0049data10-50-497-83 50 10 497 498 1.0022data10-50-497-84 50 10 497 485 1.0040data10-50-497-85 50 10 497 519 1.0038data10-50-497-86 50 10 497 521 1.0025data10-50-497-87 50 10 497 471 1.0033data10-50-497-88 50 10 497 528 0.9958data10-50-497-89 50 10 497 508 1.0024data10-50-497-90 50 10 497 557 1.0026

Table 27: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 413: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-50-497-91 50 10 497 519 1.0045data10-50-497-92 50 10 497 515 1.0030data10-50-497-93 50 10 497 499 1.0015data10-50-497-94 50 10 497 490 1.0032data10-50-497-95 50 10 497 540 1.0036data10-50-497-96 50 10 497 521 1.0061data10-50-497-97 50 10 497 533 0.9990data10-50-497-98 50 10 497 479 0.9993data10-50-497-99 50 10 497 491 1.0037data10-50-497-100 50 10 497 523 1.0023data10-50-498-1 50 10 498 510 1.0050data10-50-498-2 50 10 498 527 1.0060data10-50-498-3 50 10 498 496 1.0034data10-50-498-4 50 10 498 522 1.0012data10-50-498-5 50 10 498 500 1.0039data10-50-498-6 50 10 498 515 1.0017data10-50-498-7 50 10 498 503 1.0003data10-50-498-8 50 10 498 490 0.9980data10-50-498-9 50 10 498 500 1.0009data10-50-498-10 50 10 498 516 1.0031data10-50-498-11 50 10 498 479 1.0031data10-50-498-12 50 10 498 556 1.0011data10-50-498-13 50 10 498 512 0.9972data10-50-498-14 50 10 498 494 1.0021data10-50-498-15 50 10 498 515 1.0052data10-50-498-16 50 10 498 489 1.0045data10-50-498-17 50 10 498 517 1.0068data10-50-498-18 50 10 498 516 0.9991data10-50-498-19 50 10 498 525 1.0036data10-50-498-20 50 10 498 510 1.0022data10-50-498-21 50 10 498 484 1.0037data10-50-498-22 50 10 498 485 1.0038data10-50-498-23 50 10 498 493 1.0036data10-50-498-24 50 10 498 469 1.0041data10-50-498-25 50 10 498 520 1.0066data10-50-498-26 50 10 498 513 1.0034data10-50-498-27 50 10 498 534 1.0009data10-50-498-28 50 10 498 500 1.0014data10-50-498-29 50 10 498 483 1.0027data10-50-498-30 50 10 498 499 1.0071data10-50-498-31 50 10 498 483 1.0052data10-50-498-32 50 10 498 484 1.0024data10-50-498-33 50 10 498 454 1.0034data10-50-498-34 50 10 498 540 1.0043data10-50-498-35 50 10 498 478 1.0016data10-50-498-36 50 10 498 475 1.0044data10-50-498-37 50 10 498 519 1.0025data10-50-498-38 50 10 498 524 0.9944data10-50-498-39 50 10 498 523 1.0048data10-50-498-40 50 10 498 538 1.0057data10-50-498-41 50 10 498 482 1.0039data10-50-498-42 50 10 498 505 1.0021data10-50-498-43 50 10 498 517 1.0044data10-50-498-44 50 10 498 533 1.0028data10-50-498-45 50 10 498 527 1.0027data10-50-498-46 50 10 498 497 1.0079data10-50-498-47 50 10 498 470 1.0031data10-50-498-48 50 10 498 499 1.0048data10-50-498-49 50 10 498 508 1.0034data10-50-498-50 50 10 498 500 1.0027data10-50-498-51 50 10 498 463 1.0048data10-50-498-52 50 10 498 495 1.0044data10-50-498-53 50 10 498 526 1.0035data10-50-498-54 50 10 498 477 0.9999data10-50-498-55 50 10 498 488 1.0015data10-50-498-56 50 10 498 505 1.0049data10-50-498-57 50 10 498 471 1.0055data10-50-498-58 50 10 498 512 1.0022data10-50-498-59 50 10 498 490 1.0016data10-50-498-60 50 10 498 518 1.0029

Table 28: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 414: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-50-498-61 50 10 498 515 1.0046data10-50-498-62 50 10 498 511 1.0034data10-50-498-63 50 10 498 493 1.0005data10-50-498-64 50 10 498 508 1.0027data10-50-498-65 50 10 498 483 1.0029data10-50-498-66 50 10 498 497 1.0031data10-50-498-67 50 10 498 493 1.0027data10-50-498-68 50 10 498 512 1.0049data10-50-498-69 50 10 498 554 1.0067data10-50-498-70 50 10 498 512 1.0045data10-50-498-71 50 10 498 491 1.0035data10-50-498-72 50 10 498 481 1.0029data10-50-498-73 50 10 498 514 0.9961data10-50-498-74 50 10 498 468 1.0021data10-50-498-75 50 10 498 479 1.0042data10-50-498-76 50 10 498 470 1.0029data10-50-498-77 50 10 498 498 1.0031data10-50-498-78 50 10 498 489 1.0040data10-50-498-79 50 10 498 512 1.0056data10-50-498-80 50 10 498 509 1.0018data10-50-498-81 50 10 498 499 1.0043data10-50-498-82 50 10 498 536 0.9990data10-50-498-83 50 10 498 515 1.0035data10-50-498-84 50 10 498 481 1.0038data10-50-498-85 50 10 498 516 1.0031data10-50-498-86 50 10 498 477 1.0039data10-50-498-87 50 10 498 510 1.0061data10-50-498-88 50 10 498 492 1.0017data10-50-498-89 50 10 498 508 1.0045data10-50-498-90 50 10 498 579 1.0024data10-50-498-91 50 10 498 512 1.0043data10-50-498-92 50 10 498 496 1.0015data10-50-498-93 50 10 498 494 1.0020data10-50-498-94 50 10 498 518 1.0038data10-50-498-95 50 10 498 500 1.0031data10-50-498-96 50 10 498 550 1.0033data10-50-498-97 50 10 498 528 1.0047data10-50-498-98 50 10 498 489 1.0045data10-50-498-99 50 10 498 568 1.0069data10-50-498-100 50 10 498 526 1.0022data10-50-499-1 50 10 499 544 1.0020data10-50-499-2 50 10 499 506 1.0058data10-50-499-3 50 10 499 517 0.9995data10-50-499-4 50 10 499 489 1.0028data10-50-499-5 50 10 499 481 1.0034data10-50-499-6 50 10 499 484 1.0025data10-50-499-7 50 10 499 508 1.0057data10-50-499-8 50 10 499 520 0.9995data10-50-499-9 50 10 499 481 1.0053data10-50-499-10 50 10 499 490 1.0052data10-50-499-11 50 10 499 495 1.0054data10-50-499-12 50 10 499 494 1.0039data10-50-499-13 50 10 499 497 1.0040data10-50-499-14 50 10 499 532 1.0050data10-50-499-15 50 10 499 535 1.0018data10-50-499-16 50 10 499 498 1.0057data10-50-499-17 50 10 499 506 1.0034data10-50-499-18 50 10 499 501 1.0059data10-50-499-19 50 10 499 491 1.0031data10-50-499-20 50 10 499 528 1.0047data10-50-499-21 50 10 499 494 1.0056data10-50-499-22 50 10 499 527 1.0050data10-50-499-23 50 10 499 479 1.0055data10-50-499-24 50 10 499 532 1.0013data10-50-499-25 50 10 499 514 1.0054data10-50-499-26 50 10 499 513 1.0055data10-50-499-27 50 10 499 482 1.0041data10-50-499-28 50 10 499 493 1.0044data10-50-499-29 50 10 499 490 1.0066data10-50-499-30 50 10 499 516 1.0067

Table 29: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 415: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-50-499-31 50 10 499 493 1.0013data10-50-499-32 50 10 499 551 1.0040data10-50-499-33 50 10 499 489 1.0022data10-50-499-34 50 10 499 521 1.0052data10-50-499-35 50 10 499 506 1.0050data10-50-499-36 50 10 499 512 1.0051data10-50-499-37 50 10 499 517 1.0056data10-50-499-38 50 10 499 518 1.0052data10-50-499-39 50 10 499 514 1.0040data10-50-499-40 50 10 499 455 1.0043data10-50-499-41 50 10 499 491 1.0057data10-50-499-42 50 10 499 523 1.0055data10-50-499-43 50 10 499 519 1.0043data10-50-499-44 50 10 499 520 1.0061data10-50-499-45 50 10 499 492 1.0071data10-50-499-46 50 10 499 504 1.0041data10-50-499-47 50 10 499 514 1.0037data10-50-499-48 50 10 499 507 1.0034data10-50-499-49 50 10 499 489 1.0039data10-50-499-50 50 10 499 515 1.0046data10-50-499-51 50 10 499 491 1.0057data10-50-499-52 50 10 499 512 1.0049data10-50-499-53 50 10 499 505 1.0019data10-50-499-54 50 10 499 500 1.0038data10-50-499-55 50 10 499 508 1.0065data10-50-499-56 50 10 499 499 1.0032data10-50-499-57 50 10 499 572 1.0055data10-50-499-58 50 10 499 478 1.0059data10-50-499-59 50 10 499 534 1.0030data10-50-499-60 50 10 499 495 1.0031data10-50-499-61 50 10 499 529 1.0003data10-50-499-62 50 10 499 474 1.0036data10-50-499-63 50 10 499 477 1.0073data10-50-499-64 50 10 499 505 1.0036data10-50-499-65 50 10 499 535 1.0031data10-50-499-66 50 10 499 491 1.0022data10-50-499-67 50 10 499 485 0.9957data10-50-499-68 50 10 499 522 1.0015data10-50-499-69 50 10 499 462 1.0044data10-50-499-70 50 10 499 511 1.0076data10-50-499-71 50 10 499 524 1.0041data10-50-499-72 50 10 499 516 1.0052data10-50-499-73 50 10 499 500 1.0014data10-50-499-74 50 10 499 507 1.0023data10-50-499-75 50 10 499 502 1.0055data10-50-499-76 50 10 499 503 1.0040data10-50-499-77 50 10 499 519 1.0026data10-50-499-78 50 10 499 483 1.0042data10-50-499-79 50 10 499 549 1.0047data10-50-499-80 50 10 499 485 1.0034data10-50-499-81 50 10 499 518 1.0021data10-50-499-82 50 10 499 486 1.0013data10-50-499-83 50 10 499 517 0.9981data10-50-499-84 50 10 499 481 1.0017data10-50-499-85 50 10 499 506 1.0063data10-50-499-86 50 10 499 522 1.0047data10-50-499-87 50 10 499 474 1.0018data10-50-499-88 50 10 499 506 1.0013data10-50-499-89 50 10 499 507 1.0026data10-50-499-90 50 10 499 474 1.0047data10-50-499-91 50 10 499 486 1.0043data10-50-499-92 50 10 499 527 1.0008data10-50-499-93 50 10 499 533 1.0020data10-50-499-94 50 10 499 520 1.0021data10-50-499-95 50 10 499 498 1.0042data10-50-499-96 50 10 499 498 1.0034data10-50-499-97 50 10 499 546 1.0035data10-50-499-98 50 10 499 506 1.0022data10-50-499-99 50 10 499 541 1.0056data10-50-499-100 50 10 499 496 1.0016

Table 30: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 416: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-100-396-1 100 4 396 200 0.0032data4-100-396-2 100 4 396 202 1.0045data4-100-396-3 100 4 396 179 0.5323data4-100-396-4 100 4 396 201 0.1373data4-100-396-5 100 4 396 180 0.5458data4-100-396-6 100 4 396 196 0.1418data4-100-396-7 100 4 396 189 0.0036data4-100-396-8 100 4 396 192 1.0043data4-100-396-9 100 4 396 197 1.0050data4-100-396-10 100 4 396 181 0.2084data4-100-396-11 100 4 396 191 0.0305data4-100-396-12 100 4 396 194 0.5956data4-100-396-13 100 4 396 185 0.0036data4-100-396-14 100 4 396 182 0.0091data4-100-396-15 100 4 396 192 0.2805data4-100-396-16 100 4 396 194 0.6269data4-100-396-17 100 4 396 201 0.1782data4-100-396-18 100 4 396 196 0.6116data4-100-396-19 100 4 396 192 0.4306data4-100-396-20 100 4 396 187 0.0137data4-100-396-21 100 4 396 191 0.0653data4-100-396-22 100 4 396 183 1.0035data4-100-396-23 100 4 396 184 0.0090data4-100-396-24 100 4 396 211 0.4909data4-100-396-25 100 4 396 193 0.0033data4-100-396-26 100 4 396 200 0.4751data4-100-396-27 100 4 396 192 0.1451data4-100-396-28 100 4 396 206 0.5959data4-100-396-29 100 4 396 194 1.0028data4-100-396-30 100 4 396 187 1.0020data4-100-396-31 100 4 396 186 0.5089data4-100-396-32 100 4 396 191 0.0181data4-100-396-33 100 4 396 203 0.9226data4-100-396-34 100 4 396 176 0.0033data4-100-396-35 100 4 396 181 0.0910data4-100-396-36 100 4 396 178 0.0034data4-100-396-37 100 4 396 197 0.2510data4-100-396-38 100 4 396 214 0.2296data4-100-396-39 100 4 396 198 0.0328data4-100-396-40 100 4 396 205 0.1039data4-100-396-41 100 4 396 182 1.0037data4-100-396-42 100 4 396 186 1.0048data4-100-396-43 100 4 396 208 0.3823data4-100-396-44 100 4 396 188 0.9672data4-100-396-45 100 4 396 181 0.0033data4-100-396-46 100 4 396 195 1.0028data4-100-396-47 100 4 396 190 0.0364data4-100-396-48 100 4 396 180 0.2088data4-100-396-49 100 4 396 201 0.4785data4-100-396-50 100 4 396 183 0.8695data4-100-396-51 100 4 396 197 0.9975data4-100-396-52 100 4 396 189 0.0036data4-100-396-53 100 4 396 199 0.1434data4-100-396-54 100 4 396 194 0.2613data4-100-396-55 100 4 396 200 0.2323data4-100-396-56 100 4 396 190 1.0024data4-100-396-57 100 4 396 196 0.5919data4-100-396-58 100 4 396 212 0.4877data4-100-396-59 100 4 396 183 0.1173data4-100-396-60 100 4 396 184 0.0711data4-100-396-61 100 4 396 192 0.1758data4-100-396-62 100 4 396 189 0.1929data4-100-396-63 100 4 396 197 0.3294data4-100-396-64 100 4 396 195 0.4895data4-100-396-65 100 4 396 178 0.6823data4-100-396-66 100 4 396 195 0.5608data4-100-396-67 100 4 396 193 0.4149data4-100-396-68 100 4 396 194 0.0412data4-100-396-69 100 4 396 196 0.1803data4-100-396-70 100 4 396 197 0.2157

Table 31: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 417: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-100-396-71 100 4 396 184 0.2875data4-100-396-72 100 4 396 196 1.0032data4-100-396-73 100 4 396 183 0.0032data4-100-396-74 100 4 396 195 0.0031data4-100-396-75 100 4 396 204 0.2012data4-100-396-76 100 4 396 206 0.1846data4-100-396-77 100 4 396 186 0.0035data4-100-396-78 100 4 396 195 0.0032data4-100-396-79 100 4 396 209 0.6411data4-100-396-80 100 4 396 204 0.3398data4-100-396-81 100 4 396 195 1.0044data4-100-396-82 100 4 396 181 0.0036data4-100-396-83 100 4 396 184 0.0242data4-100-396-84 100 4 396 203 1.0039data4-100-396-85 100 4 396 174 0.1179data4-100-396-86 100 4 396 205 0.2725data4-100-396-87 100 4 396 183 0.4287data4-100-396-88 100 4 396 205 0.5425data4-100-396-89 100 4 396 181 0.1020data4-100-396-90 100 4 396 199 0.0142data4-100-396-91 100 4 396 190 0.0394data4-100-396-92 100 4 396 200 0.2454data4-100-396-93 100 4 396 200 0.0032data4-100-396-94 100 4 396 201 0.5324data4-100-396-95 100 4 396 195 0.3919data4-100-396-96 100 4 396 186 0.0037data4-100-396-97 100 4 396 203 0.0073data4-100-396-98 100 4 396 207 0.9034data4-100-396-99 100 4 396 201 0.0136data4-100-396-100 100 4 396 189 0.7053data4-100-397-1 100 4 397 191 0.9741data4-100-397-2 100 4 397 183 0.8574data4-100-397-3 100 4 397 198 0.0084data4-100-397-4 100 4 397 196 1.0011data4-100-397-5 100 4 397 209 0.8546data4-100-397-6 100 4 397 201 0.1897data4-100-397-7 100 4 397 190 0.2372data4-100-397-8 100 4 397 187 0.3120data4-100-397-9 100 4 397 185 0.6990data4-100-397-10 100 4 397 183 0.0135data4-100-397-11 100 4 397 186 0.0278data4-100-397-12 100 4 397 209 1.0050data4-100-397-13 100 4 397 193 0.8690data4-100-397-14 100 4 397 200 0.3688data4-100-397-15 100 4 397 194 0.3488data4-100-397-16 100 4 397 195 0.5253data4-100-397-17 100 4 397 191 0.0829data4-100-397-18 100 4 397 195 0.0739data4-100-397-19 100 4 397 212 1.0027data4-100-397-20 100 4 397 182 0.0577data4-100-397-21 100 4 397 199 0.2781data4-100-397-22 100 4 397 201 0.0472data4-100-397-23 100 4 397 194 0.0112data4-100-397-24 100 4 397 204 0.3267data4-100-397-25 100 4 397 188 0.1173data4-100-397-26 100 4 397 202 0.2276data4-100-397-27 100 4 397 190 0.0810data4-100-397-28 100 4 397 194 0.0928data4-100-397-29 100 4 397 197 0.3897data4-100-397-30 100 4 397 190 1.0026data4-100-397-31 100 4 397 210 0.4367data4-100-397-32 100 4 397 210 0.0132data4-100-397-33 100 4 397 206 0.2597data4-100-397-34 100 4 397 197 0.2489data4-100-397-35 100 4 397 184 0.2879data4-100-397-36 100 4 397 189 1.0030data4-100-397-37 100 4 397 215 0.3609data4-100-397-38 100 4 397 182 0.0567data4-100-397-39 100 4 397 201 0.0204data4-100-397-40 100 4 397 189 0.1580

Table 32: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 418: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-100-397-41 100 4 397 203 0.0885data4-100-397-42 100 4 397 198 0.0069data4-100-397-43 100 4 397 197 0.0033data4-100-397-44 100 4 397 200 0.4255data4-100-397-45 100 4 397 202 0.1789data4-100-397-46 100 4 397 196 0.6906data4-100-397-47 100 4 397 203 0.1739data4-100-397-48 100 4 397 195 0.2119data4-100-397-49 100 4 397 198 0.0081data4-100-397-50 100 4 397 199 0.0501data4-100-397-51 100 4 397 198 0.4497data4-100-397-52 100 4 397 190 0.4105data4-100-397-53 100 4 397 203 0.5618data4-100-397-54 100 4 397 192 0.3068data4-100-397-55 100 4 397 193 0.0809data4-100-397-56 100 4 397 197 0.2375data4-100-397-57 100 4 397 204 0.4861data4-100-397-58 100 4 397 186 0.2357data4-100-397-59 100 4 397 204 0.1426data4-100-397-60 100 4 397 198 0.0074data4-100-397-61 100 4 397 190 0.0083data4-100-397-62 100 4 397 200 0.5055data4-100-397-63 100 4 397 190 1.0027data4-100-397-64 100 4 397 185 0.6647data4-100-397-65 100 4 397 186 0.2614data4-100-397-66 100 4 397 207 0.1791data4-100-397-67 100 4 397 202 0.9477data4-100-397-68 100 4 397 203 0.1313data4-100-397-69 100 4 397 196 1.0025data4-100-397-70 100 4 397 200 0.0032data4-100-397-71 100 4 397 186 0.3617data4-100-397-72 100 4 397 187 0.0064data4-100-397-73 100 4 397 195 0.0035data4-100-397-74 100 4 397 188 0.0036data4-100-397-75 100 4 397 203 0.3515data4-100-397-76 100 4 397 191 0.0113data4-100-397-77 100 4 397 189 0.7732data4-100-397-78 100 4 397 205 0.4777data4-100-397-79 100 4 397 185 0.1929data4-100-397-80 100 4 397 192 0.8365data4-100-397-81 100 4 397 186 0.0032data4-100-397-82 100 4 397 209 0.1818data4-100-397-83 100 4 397 195 0.2070data4-100-397-84 100 4 397 207 0.0730data4-100-397-85 100 4 397 202 0.5960data4-100-397-86 100 4 397 203 0.1234data4-100-397-87 100 4 397 196 0.0142data4-100-397-88 100 4 397 183 0.1726data4-100-397-89 100 4 397 212 0.6657data4-100-397-90 100 4 397 184 0.0036data4-100-397-91 100 4 397 184 0.3129data4-100-397-92 100 4 397 186 0.1833data4-100-397-93 100 4 397 199 0.3449data4-100-397-94 100 4 397 173 0.6406data4-100-397-95 100 4 397 187 0.0681data4-100-397-96 100 4 397 176 0.0704data4-100-397-97 100 4 397 184 0.2160data4-100-397-98 100 4 397 204 0.0957data4-100-397-99 100 4 397 200 0.0523data4-100-397-100 100 4 397 195 0.8255data4-100-398-1 100 4 398 189 0.2748data4-100-398-2 100 4 398 194 0.2146data4-100-398-3 100 4 398 178 0.0406data4-100-398-4 100 4 398 199 0.2579data4-100-398-5 100 4 398 198 0.0554data4-100-398-6 100 4 398 188 0.4878data4-100-398-7 100 4 398 185 1.0022data4-100-398-8 100 4 398 203 0.1068data4-100-398-9 100 4 398 205 0.4549data4-100-398-10 100 4 398 197 1.0041

Table 33: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 419: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-100-398-11 100 4 398 180 1.0038data4-100-398-12 100 4 398 200 0.1841data4-100-398-13 100 4 398 185 0.3243data4-100-398-14 100 4 398 201 1.0007data4-100-398-15 100 4 398 195 0.0945data4-100-398-16 100 4 398 206 0.2677data4-100-398-17 100 4 398 209 0.2499data4-100-398-18 100 4 398 205 0.0149data4-100-398-19 100 4 398 197 0.0166data4-100-398-20 100 4 398 198 0.0329data4-100-398-21 100 4 398 192 0.3415data4-100-398-22 100 4 398 201 1.0042data4-100-398-23 100 4 398 201 0.0109data4-100-398-24 100 4 398 200 1.0048data4-100-398-25 100 4 398 207 0.0123data4-100-398-26 100 4 398 197 0.2997data4-100-398-27 100 4 398 191 0.1308data4-100-398-28 100 4 398 203 0.0423data4-100-398-29 100 4 398 191 1.0022data4-100-398-30 100 4 398 187 0.2692data4-100-398-31 100 4 398 213 0.0720data4-100-398-32 100 4 398 190 0.9541data4-100-398-33 100 4 398 185 0.9969data4-100-398-34 100 4 398 186 0.8147data4-100-398-35 100 4 398 204 1.0034data4-100-398-36 100 4 398 197 0.3316data4-100-398-37 100 4 398 182 0.0032data4-100-398-38 100 4 398 210 0.8433data4-100-398-39 100 4 398 194 0.0646data4-100-398-40 100 4 398 200 0.6534data4-100-398-41 100 4 398 206 0.9040data4-100-398-42 100 4 398 196 1.0036data4-100-398-43 100 4 398 193 0.3232data4-100-398-44 100 4 398 173 0.3679data4-100-398-45 100 4 398 196 0.2862data4-100-398-46 100 4 398 186 0.0677data4-100-398-47 100 4 398 196 0.0088data4-100-398-48 100 4 398 195 1.0029data4-100-398-49 100 4 398 203 0.2828data4-100-398-50 100 4 398 207 0.2875data4-100-398-51 100 4 398 195 0.2529data4-100-398-52 100 4 398 182 0.0031data4-100-398-53 100 4 398 202 0.3081data4-100-398-54 100 4 398 200 0.3052data4-100-398-55 100 4 398 191 0.0985data4-100-398-56 100 4 398 201 0.0033data4-100-398-57 100 4 398 203 0.4725data4-100-398-58 100 4 398 203 0.4553data4-100-398-59 100 4 398 199 0.7434data4-100-398-60 100 4 398 198 0.0032data4-100-398-61 100 4 398 204 1.0028data4-100-398-62 100 4 398 201 1.0030data4-100-398-63 100 4 398 203 0.0036data4-100-398-64 100 4 398 202 0.3986data4-100-398-65 100 4 398 192 0.1431data4-100-398-66 100 4 398 195 0.5715data4-100-398-67 100 4 398 188 0.3475data4-100-398-68 100 4 398 180 0.1874data4-100-398-69 100 4 398 207 0.3296data4-100-398-70 100 4 398 198 1.0032data4-100-398-71 100 4 398 197 1.0027data4-100-398-72 100 4 398 182 0.1143data4-100-398-73 100 4 398 197 0.2002data4-100-398-74 100 4 398 205 0.8042data4-100-398-75 100 4 398 189 0.7399data4-100-398-76 100 4 398 180 0.0764data4-100-398-77 100 4 398 188 0.0431data4-100-398-78 100 4 398 187 0.6432data4-100-398-79 100 4 398 181 0.7092data4-100-398-80 100 4 398 216 0.7249

Table 34: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 420: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-100-398-81 100 4 398 194 0.2039data4-100-398-82 100 4 398 189 0.3200data4-100-398-83 100 4 398 190 0.7621data4-100-398-84 100 4 398 204 0.3524data4-100-398-85 100 4 398 194 1.0048data4-100-398-86 100 4 398 206 0.6590data4-100-398-87 100 4 398 193 0.0033data4-100-398-88 100 4 398 195 1.0050data4-100-398-89 100 4 398 200 1.0039data4-100-398-90 100 4 398 203 0.0612data4-100-398-91 100 4 398 187 1.0053data4-100-398-92 100 4 398 196 0.0043data4-100-398-93 100 4 398 196 0.2747data4-100-398-94 100 4 398 207 0.6994data4-100-398-95 100 4 398 169 0.0042data4-100-398-96 100 4 398 194 0.0032data4-100-398-97 100 4 398 186 0.0492data4-100-398-98 100 4 398 187 0.6576data4-100-398-99 100 4 398 198 0.2699data4-100-398-100 100 4 398 211 0.0424data4-100-399-1 100 4 399 202 0.0837data4-100-399-2 100 4 399 198 0.5248data4-100-399-3 100 4 399 199 0.0071data4-100-399-4 100 4 399 188 1.0022data4-100-399-5 100 4 399 210 0.2801data4-100-399-6 100 4 399 191 1.0048data4-100-399-7 100 4 399 195 0.5811data4-100-399-8 100 4 399 192 0.0354data4-100-399-9 100 4 399 209 1.0004data4-100-399-10 100 4 399 200 0.7057data4-100-399-11 100 4 399 195 0.1194data4-100-399-12 100 4 399 207 0.5283data4-100-399-13 100 4 399 206 0.5313data4-100-399-14 100 4 399 185 0.2860data4-100-399-15 100 4 399 185 0.0087data4-100-399-16 100 4 399 203 0.7446data4-100-399-17 100 4 399 190 0.5142data4-100-399-18 100 4 399 210 0.0220data4-100-399-19 100 4 399 194 1.0026data4-100-399-20 100 4 399 203 0.9038data4-100-399-21 100 4 399 204 0.0146data4-100-399-22 100 4 399 193 1.0025data4-100-399-23 100 4 399 187 0.1810data4-100-399-24 100 4 399 187 0.6463data4-100-399-25 100 4 399 183 0.7119data4-100-399-26 100 4 399 193 0.0583data4-100-399-27 100 4 399 199 0.3446data4-100-399-28 100 4 399 210 0.0897data4-100-399-29 100 4 399 190 0.0406data4-100-399-30 100 4 399 200 0.0209data4-100-399-31 100 4 399 193 0.0375data4-100-399-32 100 4 399 208 0.2023data4-100-399-33 100 4 399 196 0.4317data4-100-399-34 100 4 399 195 0.1139data4-100-399-35 100 4 399 207 0.2001data4-100-399-36 100 4 399 188 0.3425data4-100-399-37 100 4 399 205 0.0036data4-100-399-38 100 4 399 199 0.1254data4-100-399-39 100 4 399 197 0.0163data4-100-399-40 100 4 399 201 0.0176data4-100-399-41 100 4 399 184 0.4377data4-100-399-42 100 4 399 203 0.0912data4-100-399-43 100 4 399 177 1.0032data4-100-399-44 100 4 399 194 0.9994data4-100-399-45 100 4 399 200 0.4341data4-100-399-46 100 4 399 198 0.9056data4-100-399-47 100 4 399 192 0.0036data4-100-399-48 100 4 399 193 0.0178data4-100-399-49 100 4 399 190 0.6425data4-100-399-50 100 4 399 184 0.5025

Table 35: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 421: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-100-399-51 100 4 399 212 0.3337data4-100-399-52 100 4 399 200 0.0126data4-100-399-53 100 4 399 199 0.0640data4-100-399-54 100 4 399 197 0.0039data4-100-399-55 100 4 399 201 0.1439data4-100-399-56 100 4 399 201 0.1301data4-100-399-57 100 4 399 191 1.0042data4-100-399-58 100 4 399 188 0.4905data4-100-399-59 100 4 399 193 0.0036data4-100-399-60 100 4 399 203 0.0032data4-100-399-61 100 4 399 182 0.5420data4-100-399-62 100 4 399 192 0.0130data4-100-399-63 100 4 399 198 0.7952data4-100-399-64 100 4 399 193 0.0034data4-100-399-65 100 4 399 207 0.6220data4-100-399-66 100 4 399 204 0.0198data4-100-399-67 100 4 399 205 0.6958data4-100-399-68 100 4 399 203 1.0030data4-100-399-69 100 4 399 210 0.0062data4-100-399-70 100 4 399 182 0.0136data4-100-399-71 100 4 399 203 0.1686data4-100-399-72 100 4 399 201 0.3655data4-100-399-73 100 4 399 189 1.0033data4-100-399-74 100 4 399 212 0.0120data4-100-399-75 100 4 399 208 1.0052data4-100-399-76 100 4 399 194 0.0036data4-100-399-77 100 4 399 197 0.1386data4-100-399-78 100 4 399 205 1.0039data4-100-399-79 100 4 399 197 1.0031data4-100-399-80 100 4 399 201 0.9937data4-100-399-81 100 4 399 196 0.0862data4-100-399-82 100 4 399 184 0.0162data4-100-399-83 100 4 399 197 0.0054data4-100-399-84 100 4 399 210 0.8570data4-100-399-85 100 4 399 181 0.6233data4-100-399-86 100 4 399 198 0.1543data4-100-399-87 100 4 399 195 0.0053data4-100-399-88 100 4 399 210 1.0035data4-100-399-89 100 4 399 192 0.4520data4-100-399-90 100 4 399 189 0.0168data4-100-399-91 100 4 399 191 0.4055data4-100-399-92 100 4 399 203 0.5612data4-100-399-93 100 4 399 194 1.0030data4-100-399-94 100 4 399 195 0.2989data4-100-399-95 100 4 399 189 0.8783data4-100-399-96 100 4 399 190 1.0039data4-100-399-97 100 4 399 197 0.6282data4-100-399-98 100 4 399 192 0.1174data4-100-399-99 100 4 399 195 1.0036data4-100-399-100 100 4 399 189 0.0035data7-100-693-1 100 7 693 498 1.0052data7-100-693-2 100 7 693 461 1.0030data7-100-693-3 100 7 693 520 1.0032data7-100-693-4 100 7 693 523 1.0065data7-100-693-5 100 7 693 490 1.0047data7-100-693-6 100 7 693 496 1.0050data7-100-693-7 100 7 693 488 1.0031data7-100-693-8 100 7 693 483 1.0021data7-100-693-9 100 7 693 491 1.0040data7-100-693-10 100 7 693 515 1.0029data7-100-693-11 100 7 693 459 1.0022data7-100-693-12 100 7 693 487 1.0055data7-100-693-13 100 7 693 516 1.0023data7-100-693-14 100 7 693 490 1.0026data7-100-693-15 100 7 693 536 1.0046data7-100-693-16 100 7 693 459 1.0047data7-100-693-17 100 7 693 519 1.0045data7-100-693-18 100 7 693 507 1.0051data7-100-693-19 100 7 693 498 1.0038data7-100-693-20 100 7 693 480 1.0059

Table 36: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 422: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-100-693-21 100 7 693 521 1.0030data7-100-693-22 100 7 693 502 1.0055data7-100-693-23 100 7 693 520 1.0025data7-100-693-24 100 7 693 506 1.0011data7-100-693-25 100 7 693 498 1.0012data7-100-693-26 100 7 693 485 1.0060data7-100-693-27 100 7 693 516 1.0022data7-100-693-28 100 7 693 497 1.0022data7-100-693-29 100 7 693 470 1.0067data7-100-693-30 100 7 693 494 1.0049data7-100-693-31 100 7 693 464 1.0025data7-100-693-32 100 7 693 497 1.0023data7-100-693-33 100 7 693 511 1.0042data7-100-693-34 100 7 693 489 1.0048data7-100-693-35 100 7 693 492 1.0033data7-100-693-36 100 7 693 452 1.0052data7-100-693-37 100 7 693 499 1.0031data7-100-693-38 100 7 693 490 1.0040data7-100-693-39 100 7 693 501 1.0050data7-100-693-40 100 7 693 504 1.0028data7-100-693-41 100 7 693 506 1.0058data7-100-693-42 100 7 693 493 1.0048data7-100-693-43 100 7 693 505 1.0040data7-100-693-44 100 7 693 484 1.0025data7-100-693-45 100 7 693 496 1.0034data7-100-693-46 100 7 693 485 1.0073data7-100-693-47 100 7 693 482 1.0043data7-100-693-48 100 7 693 481 1.0053data7-100-693-49 100 7 693 515 0.9999data7-100-693-50 100 7 693 478 0.9991data7-100-693-51 100 7 693 507 1.0028data7-100-693-52 100 7 693 472 1.0054data7-100-693-53 100 7 693 482 1.0043data7-100-693-54 100 7 693 508 1.0045data7-100-693-55 100 7 693 483 1.0057data7-100-693-56 100 7 693 489 1.0044data7-100-693-57 100 7 693 486 1.0074data7-100-693-58 100 7 693 471 1.0043data7-100-693-59 100 7 693 491 1.0033data7-100-693-60 100 7 693 497 1.0036data7-100-693-61 100 7 693 481 1.0046data7-100-693-62 100 7 693 502 1.0056data7-100-693-63 100 7 693 513 1.0030data7-100-693-64 100 7 693 497 1.0057data7-100-693-65 100 7 693 478 1.0080data7-100-693-66 100 7 693 526 1.0054data7-100-693-67 100 7 693 504 1.0057data7-100-693-68 100 7 693 506 1.0060data7-100-693-69 100 7 693 510 1.0027data7-100-693-70 100 7 693 502 1.0043data7-100-693-71 100 7 693 477 1.0045data7-100-693-72 100 7 693 491 1.0038data7-100-693-73 100 7 693 515 1.0055data7-100-693-74 100 7 693 476 1.0045data7-100-693-75 100 7 693 507 1.0051data7-100-693-76 100 7 693 507 1.0047data7-100-693-77 100 7 693 490 1.0059data7-100-693-78 100 7 693 492 1.0026data7-100-693-79 100 7 693 492 1.0025data7-100-693-80 100 7 693 481 1.0044data7-100-693-81 100 7 693 515 1.0054data7-100-693-82 100 7 693 494 1.0056data7-100-693-83 100 7 693 523 1.0038data7-100-693-84 100 7 693 519 1.0044data7-100-693-85 100 7 693 541 1.0064data7-100-693-86 100 7 693 486 1.0046data7-100-693-87 100 7 693 490 1.0031data7-100-693-88 100 7 693 497 1.0053data7-100-693-89 100 7 693 508 1.0053data7-100-693-90 100 7 693 524 1.0065

Table 37: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 423: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-100-693-91 100 7 693 499 1.0056data7-100-693-92 100 7 693 496 1.0051data7-100-693-93 100 7 693 477 1.0042data7-100-693-94 100 7 693 483 1.0051data7-100-693-95 100 7 693 487 1.0050data7-100-693-96 100 7 693 491 1.0054data7-100-693-97 100 7 693 502 1.0030data7-100-693-98 100 7 693 505 1.0049data7-100-693-99 100 7 693 521 1.0058data7-100-693-100 100 7 693 498 1.0052data7-100-694-1 100 7 694 486 1.0045data7-100-694-2 100 7 694 486 1.0036data7-100-694-3 100 7 694 505 1.0053data7-100-694-4 100 7 694 498 0.9992data7-100-694-5 100 7 694 517 1.0037data7-100-694-6 100 7 694 486 1.0042data7-100-694-7 100 7 694 511 1.0045data7-100-694-8 100 7 694 490 1.0067data7-100-694-9 100 7 694 457 1.0049data7-100-694-10 100 7 694 523 1.0064data7-100-694-11 100 7 694 482 1.0057data7-100-694-12 100 7 694 518 1.0034data7-100-694-13 100 7 694 507 1.0052data7-100-694-14 100 7 694 453 1.0053data7-100-694-15 100 7 694 498 1.0052data7-100-694-16 100 7 694 546 1.0030data7-100-694-17 100 7 694 504 1.0057data7-100-694-18 100 7 694 486 1.0057data7-100-694-19 100 7 694 519 1.0052data7-100-694-20 100 7 694 524 1.0046data7-100-694-21 100 7 694 523 1.0046data7-100-694-22 100 7 694 496 1.0032data7-100-694-23 100 7 694 508 1.0042data7-100-694-24 100 7 694 504 1.0048data7-100-694-25 100 7 694 528 1.0032data7-100-694-26 100 7 694 498 1.0053data7-100-694-27 100 7 694 489 1.0061data7-100-694-28 100 7 694 519 1.0052data7-100-694-29 100 7 694 513 1.0033data7-100-694-30 100 7 694 488 1.0023data7-100-694-31 100 7 694 495 1.0042data7-100-694-32 100 7 694 487 1.0041data7-100-694-33 100 7 694 526 1.0034data7-100-694-34 100 7 694 526 1.0057data7-100-694-35 100 7 694 510 1.0058data7-100-694-36 100 7 694 456 1.0026data7-100-694-37 100 7 694 496 1.0041data7-100-694-38 100 7 694 494 1.0040data7-100-694-39 100 7 694 534 1.0033data7-100-694-40 100 7 694 496 1.0043data7-100-694-41 100 7 694 503 1.0064data7-100-694-42 100 7 694 502 1.0059data7-100-694-43 100 7 694 506 1.0034data7-100-694-44 100 7 694 502 1.0022data7-100-694-45 100 7 694 482 1.0031data7-100-694-46 100 7 694 488 1.0068data7-100-694-47 100 7 694 486 1.0066data7-100-694-48 100 7 694 485 1.0041data7-100-694-49 100 7 694 522 1.0063data7-100-694-50 100 7 694 530 1.0060data7-100-694-51 100 7 694 473 1.0038data7-100-694-52 100 7 694 489 1.0046data7-100-694-53 100 7 694 482 1.0063data7-100-694-54 100 7 694 474 1.0083data7-100-694-55 100 7 694 500 1.0049data7-100-694-56 100 7 694 481 1.0073data7-100-694-57 100 7 694 498 1.0038data7-100-694-58 100 7 694 509 1.0063data7-100-694-59 100 7 694 533 1.0030data7-100-694-60 100 7 694 513 1.0065

Table 38: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 424: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-100-694-61 100 7 694 505 1.0056data7-100-694-62 100 7 694 511 1.0044data7-100-694-63 100 7 694 463 1.0028data7-100-694-64 100 7 694 499 1.0036data7-100-694-65 100 7 694 507 1.0036data7-100-694-66 100 7 694 480 1.0069data7-100-694-67 100 7 694 479 1.0024data7-100-694-68 100 7 694 515 1.0023data7-100-694-69 100 7 694 510 1.0025data7-100-694-70 100 7 694 521 1.0021data7-100-694-71 100 7 694 503 1.0040data7-100-694-72 100 7 694 519 1.0027data7-100-694-73 100 7 694 512 1.0053data7-100-694-74 100 7 694 528 1.0021data7-100-694-75 100 7 694 527 0.9998data7-100-694-76 100 7 694 505 1.0028data7-100-694-77 100 7 694 508 1.0040data7-100-694-78 100 7 694 506 1.0053data7-100-694-79 100 7 694 530 0.9987data7-100-694-80 100 7 694 510 1.0033data7-100-694-81 100 7 694 522 1.0060data7-100-694-82 100 7 694 487 1.0061data7-100-694-83 100 7 694 520 1.0062data7-100-694-84 100 7 694 525 1.0045data7-100-694-85 100 7 694 531 1.0045data7-100-694-86 100 7 694 519 1.0062data7-100-694-87 100 7 694 507 1.0031data7-100-694-88 100 7 694 517 1.0045data7-100-694-89 100 7 694 491 1.0021data7-100-694-90 100 7 694 477 1.0031data7-100-694-91 100 7 694 482 1.0033data7-100-694-92 100 7 694 485 1.0023data7-100-694-93 100 7 694 510 1.0026data7-100-694-94 100 7 694 473 1.0006data7-100-694-95 100 7 694 497 1.0038data7-100-694-96 100 7 694 515 1.0042data7-100-694-97 100 7 694 477 1.0057data7-100-694-98 100 7 694 527 1.0046data7-100-694-99 100 7 694 518 0.9990data7-100-694-100 100 7 694 513 1.0001data7-100-695-1 100 7 695 522 1.0058data7-100-695-2 100 7 695 493 1.0040data7-100-695-3 100 7 695 513 1.0041data7-100-695-4 100 7 695 486 1.0039data7-100-695-5 100 7 695 497 1.0011data7-100-695-6 100 7 695 487 1.0043data7-100-695-7 100 7 695 515 1.0060data7-100-695-8 100 7 695 493 1.0046data7-100-695-9 100 7 695 514 1.0016data7-100-695-10 100 7 695 504 1.0016data7-100-695-11 100 7 695 531 1.0073data7-100-695-12 100 7 695 492 1.0071data7-100-695-13 100 7 695 508 1.0036data7-100-695-14 100 7 695 502 1.0047data7-100-695-15 100 7 695 511 1.0052data7-100-695-16 100 7 695 507 1.0038data7-100-695-17 100 7 695 496 1.0028data7-100-695-18 100 7 695 478 1.0023data7-100-695-19 100 7 695 525 1.0053data7-100-695-20 100 7 695 523 1.0056data7-100-695-21 100 7 695 500 1.0067data7-100-695-22 100 7 695 494 1.0039data7-100-695-23 100 7 695 526 1.0042data7-100-695-24 100 7 695 491 1.0004data7-100-695-25 100 7 695 499 1.0038data7-100-695-26 100 7 695 513 1.0051data7-100-695-27 100 7 695 506 1.0062data7-100-695-28 100 7 695 483 1.0043data7-100-695-29 100 7 695 514 0.9999data7-100-695-30 100 7 695 515 0.9998

Table 39: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 425: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-100-695-31 100 7 695 481 1.0031data7-100-695-32 100 7 695 467 1.0041data7-100-695-33 100 7 695 517 1.0045data7-100-695-34 100 7 695 516 1.0035data7-100-695-35 100 7 695 508 1.0046data7-100-695-36 100 7 695 537 1.0035data7-100-695-37 100 7 695 479 1.0038data7-100-695-38 100 7 695 511 1.0056data7-100-695-39 100 7 695 487 1.0033data7-100-695-40 100 7 695 522 1.0032data7-100-695-41 100 7 695 529 1.0038data7-100-695-42 100 7 695 504 1.0040data7-100-695-43 100 7 695 484 1.0052data7-100-695-44 100 7 695 476 1.0036data7-100-695-45 100 7 695 510 1.0038data7-100-695-46 100 7 695 541 0.9994data7-100-695-47 100 7 695 497 1.0065data7-100-695-48 100 7 695 471 1.0044data7-100-695-49 100 7 695 514 1.0042data7-100-695-50 100 7 695 509 1.0027data7-100-695-51 100 7 695 510 1.0047data7-100-695-52 100 7 695 519 1.0030data7-100-695-53 100 7 695 530 1.0041data7-100-695-54 100 7 695 496 1.0061data7-100-695-55 100 7 695 532 1.0034data7-100-695-56 100 7 695 495 1.0066data7-100-695-57 100 7 695 492 1.0047data7-100-695-58 100 7 695 476 1.0028data7-100-695-59 100 7 695 497 1.0025data7-100-695-60 100 7 695 530 1.0030data7-100-695-61 100 7 695 493 1.0059data7-100-695-62 100 7 695 503 1.0049data7-100-695-63 100 7 695 520 1.0037data7-100-695-64 100 7 695 522 1.0061data7-100-695-65 100 7 695 496 1.0029data7-100-695-66 100 7 695 485 1.0050data7-100-695-67 100 7 695 503 1.0044data7-100-695-68 100 7 695 492 1.0024data7-100-695-69 100 7 695 538 1.0051data7-100-695-70 100 7 695 507 1.0046data7-100-695-71 100 7 695 511 1.0041data7-100-695-72 100 7 695 529 1.0052data7-100-695-73 100 7 695 485 1.0024data7-100-695-74 100 7 695 484 1.0001data7-100-695-75 100 7 695 515 1.0041data7-100-695-76 100 7 695 498 1.0060data7-100-695-77 100 7 695 503 1.0071data7-100-695-78 100 7 695 519 1.0044data7-100-695-79 100 7 695 497 1.0038data7-100-695-80 100 7 695 504 1.0060data7-100-695-81 100 7 695 512 1.0076data7-100-695-82 100 7 695 495 1.0046data7-100-695-83 100 7 695 504 1.0024data7-100-695-84 100 7 695 523 1.0043data7-100-695-85 100 7 695 474 1.0056data7-100-695-86 100 7 695 501 1.0053data7-100-695-87 100 7 695 524 1.0064data7-100-695-88 100 7 695 478 1.0055data7-100-695-89 100 7 695 518 0.9998data7-100-695-90 100 7 695 502 0.9998data7-100-695-91 100 7 695 508 1.0043data7-100-695-92 100 7 695 505 1.0042data7-100-695-93 100 7 695 507 1.0053data7-100-695-94 100 7 695 509 1.0045data7-100-695-95 100 7 695 486 1.0058data7-100-695-96 100 7 695 522 1.0032data7-100-695-97 100 7 695 548 1.0068data7-100-695-98 100 7 695 510 1.0030data7-100-695-99 100 7 695 527 1.0055data7-100-695-100 100 7 695 498 1.0028

Table 40: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 426: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-100-696-1 100 7 696 512 1.0031data7-100-696-2 100 7 696 500 1.0023data7-100-696-3 100 7 696 520 1.0050data7-100-696-4 100 7 696 494 1.0049data7-100-696-5 100 7 696 516 1.0028data7-100-696-6 100 7 696 482 1.0036data7-100-696-7 100 7 696 475 1.0055data7-100-696-8 100 7 696 534 1.0051data7-100-696-9 100 7 696 500 1.0038data7-100-696-10 100 7 696 524 1.0024data7-100-696-11 100 7 696 482 1.0048data7-100-696-12 100 7 696 515 1.0035data7-100-696-13 100 7 696 505 1.0020data7-100-696-14 100 7 696 522 1.0025data7-100-696-15 100 7 696 531 1.0042data7-100-696-16 100 7 696 508 1.0031data7-100-696-17 100 7 696 520 1.0037data7-100-696-18 100 7 696 495 1.0042data7-100-696-19 100 7 696 476 1.0048data7-100-696-20 100 7 696 510 1.0023data7-100-696-21 100 7 696 480 1.0041data7-100-696-22 100 7 696 532 1.0066data7-100-696-23 100 7 696 504 1.0051data7-100-696-24 100 7 696 501 1.0009data7-100-696-25 100 7 696 514 1.0030data7-100-696-26 100 7 696 479 1.0056data7-100-696-27 100 7 696 485 1.0033data7-100-696-28 100 7 696 513 1.0027data7-100-696-29 100 7 696 508 1.0069data7-100-696-30 100 7 696 509 1.0034data7-100-696-31 100 7 696 520 1.0024data7-100-696-32 100 7 696 500 1.0024data7-100-696-33 100 7 696 492 1.0062data7-100-696-34 100 7 696 515 1.0022data7-100-696-35 100 7 696 503 1.0054data7-100-696-36 100 7 696 500 1.0024data7-100-696-37 100 7 696 504 1.0025data7-100-696-38 100 7 696 514 1.0052data7-100-696-39 100 7 696 500 1.0059data7-100-696-40 100 7 696 477 1.0055data7-100-696-41 100 7 696 507 1.0024data7-100-696-42 100 7 696 515 1.0048data7-100-696-43 100 7 696 501 1.0036data7-100-696-44 100 7 696 529 1.0043data7-100-696-45 100 7 696 552 1.0039data7-100-696-46 100 7 696 526 1.0022data7-100-696-47 100 7 696 468 1.0030data7-100-696-48 100 7 696 497 1.0028data7-100-696-49 100 7 696 516 1.0028data7-100-696-50 100 7 696 498 1.0048data7-100-696-51 100 7 696 506 1.0030data7-100-696-52 100 7 696 540 1.0037data7-100-696-53 100 7 696 486 1.0067data7-100-696-54 100 7 696 515 1.0011data7-100-696-55 100 7 696 487 1.0017data7-100-696-56 100 7 696 491 1.0024data7-100-696-57 100 7 696 517 1.0030data7-100-696-58 100 7 696 496 1.0037data7-100-696-59 100 7 696 513 1.0054data7-100-696-60 100 7 696 513 1.0027data7-100-696-61 100 7 696 509 1.0056data7-100-696-62 100 7 696 515 1.0063data7-100-696-63 100 7 696 526 1.0061data7-100-696-64 100 7 696 489 1.0047data7-100-696-65 100 7 696 516 1.0055data7-100-696-66 100 7 696 503 1.0073data7-100-696-67 100 7 696 503 1.0022data7-100-696-68 100 7 696 520 1.0038data7-100-696-69 100 7 696 521 1.0017data7-100-696-70 100 7 696 540 1.0066

Table 41: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 427: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-100-696-71 100 7 696 505 1.0029data7-100-696-72 100 7 696 519 1.0043data7-100-696-73 100 7 696 521 1.0038data7-100-696-74 100 7 696 505 1.0053data7-100-696-75 100 7 696 515 1.0048data7-100-696-76 100 7 696 502 1.0043data7-100-696-77 100 7 696 504 1.0059data7-100-696-78 100 7 696 532 1.0024data7-100-696-79 100 7 696 550 1.0027data7-100-696-80 100 7 696 519 1.0021data7-100-696-81 100 7 696 539 1.0046data7-100-696-82 100 7 696 517 1.0042data7-100-696-83 100 7 696 512 1.0021data7-100-696-84 100 7 696 511 1.0030data7-100-696-85 100 7 696 517 1.0043data7-100-696-86 100 7 696 510 1.0024data7-100-696-87 100 7 696 542 1.0028data7-100-696-88 100 7 696 519 1.0071data7-100-696-89 100 7 696 490 1.0011data7-100-696-90 100 7 696 512 1.0012data7-100-696-91 100 7 696 488 1.0068data7-100-696-92 100 7 696 508 1.0049data7-100-696-93 100 7 696 523 1.0030data7-100-696-94 100 7 696 525 1.0029data7-100-696-95 100 7 696 542 1.0029data7-100-696-96 100 7 696 506 1.0039data7-100-696-97 100 7 696 481 1.0026data7-100-696-98 100 7 696 513 1.0040data7-100-696-99 100 7 696 486 1.0026data7-100-696-100 100 7 696 499 1.0037data7-100-697-1 100 7 697 530 1.0047data7-100-697-2 100 7 697 485 1.0038data7-100-697-3 100 7 697 488 1.0050data7-100-697-4 100 7 697 484 1.0056data7-100-697-5 100 7 697 513 1.0035data7-100-697-6 100 7 697 484 1.0052data7-100-697-7 100 7 697 509 1.0049data7-100-697-8 100 7 697 499 1.0059data7-100-697-9 100 7 697 518 1.0046data7-100-697-10 100 7 697 499 1.0056data7-100-697-11 100 7 697 505 1.0029data7-100-697-12 100 7 697 515 1.0063data7-100-697-13 100 7 697 507 1.0015data7-100-697-14 100 7 697 522 1.0027data7-100-697-15 100 7 697 514 1.0037data7-100-697-16 100 7 697 525 1.0024data7-100-697-17 100 7 697 521 1.0052data7-100-697-18 100 7 697 485 1.0044data7-100-697-19 100 7 697 530 1.0046data7-100-697-20 100 7 697 530 1.0050data7-100-697-21 100 7 697 512 1.0068data7-100-697-22 100 7 697 510 1.0034data7-100-697-23 100 7 697 510 1.0037data7-100-697-24 100 7 697 494 1.0008data7-100-697-25 100 7 697 498 1.0014data7-100-697-26 100 7 697 510 1.0028data7-100-697-27 100 7 697 512 1.0025data7-100-697-28 100 7 697 509 1.0034data7-100-697-29 100 7 697 445 1.0019data7-100-697-30 100 7 697 475 1.0045data7-100-697-31 100 7 697 510 1.0023data7-100-697-32 100 7 697 483 1.0037data7-100-697-33 100 7 697 528 1.0066data7-100-697-34 100 7 697 492 1.0046data7-100-697-35 100 7 697 522 1.0026data7-100-697-36 100 7 697 506 1.0041data7-100-697-37 100 7 697 481 1.0050data7-100-697-38 100 7 697 497 1.0049data7-100-697-39 100 7 697 496 1.0048data7-100-697-40 100 7 697 541 1.0039

Table 42: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 428: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-100-697-41 100 7 697 472 1.0026data7-100-697-42 100 7 697 521 1.0023data7-100-697-43 100 7 697 503 1.0055data7-100-697-44 100 7 697 538 1.0053data7-100-697-45 100 7 697 542 1.0024data7-100-697-46 100 7 697 507 1.0037data7-100-697-47 100 7 697 514 1.0055data7-100-697-48 100 7 697 485 1.0050data7-100-697-49 100 7 697 527 1.0041data7-100-697-50 100 7 697 510 1.0031data7-100-697-51 100 7 697 497 1.0028data7-100-697-52 100 7 697 510 1.0056data7-100-697-53 100 7 697 481 1.0054data7-100-697-54 100 7 697 505 1.0030data7-100-697-55 100 7 697 498 1.0024data7-100-697-56 100 7 697 517 1.0021data7-100-697-57 100 7 697 518 1.0025data7-100-697-58 100 7 697 517 1.0046data7-100-697-59 100 7 697 481 1.0036data7-100-697-60 100 7 697 520 1.0031data7-100-697-61 100 7 697 471 1.0030data7-100-697-62 100 7 697 504 1.0034data7-100-697-63 100 7 697 510 1.0036data7-100-697-64 100 7 697 512 1.0048data7-100-697-65 100 7 697 534 1.0030data7-100-697-66 100 7 697 496 1.0049data7-100-697-67 100 7 697 502 1.0047data7-100-697-68 100 7 697 520 1.0038data7-100-697-69 100 7 697 526 1.0049data7-100-697-70 100 7 697 487 1.0030data7-100-697-71 100 7 697 510 1.0017data7-100-697-72 100 7 697 517 1.0026data7-100-697-73 100 7 697 505 1.0027data7-100-697-74 100 7 697 515 1.0019data7-100-697-75 100 7 697 498 1.0046data7-100-697-76 100 7 697 492 1.0037data7-100-697-77 100 7 697 470 1.0036data7-100-697-78 100 7 697 471 1.0074data7-100-697-79 100 7 697 518 1.0044data7-100-697-80 100 7 697 475 1.0051data7-100-697-81 100 7 697 480 1.0059data7-100-697-82 100 7 697 484 1.0039data7-100-697-83 100 7 697 505 1.0039data7-100-697-84 100 7 697 512 1.0046data7-100-697-85 100 7 697 489 1.0044data7-100-697-86 100 7 697 522 1.0059data7-100-697-87 100 7 697 514 1.0030data7-100-697-88 100 7 697 503 1.0047data7-100-697-89 100 7 697 501 1.0026data7-100-697-90 100 7 697 544 1.0028data7-100-697-91 100 7 697 505 1.0053data7-100-697-92 100 7 697 502 1.0036data7-100-697-93 100 7 697 504 1.0028data7-100-697-94 100 7 697 512 1.0035data7-100-697-95 100 7 697 549 1.0037data7-100-697-96 100 7 697 500 1.0038data7-100-697-97 100 7 697 515 1.0057data7-100-697-98 100 7 697 524 1.0020data7-100-697-99 100 7 697 497 1.0033data7-100-697-100 100 7 697 529 1.0025data7-100-698-1 100 7 698 481 1.0059data7-100-698-2 100 7 698 521 1.0029data7-100-698-3 100 7 698 501 1.0052data7-100-698-4 100 7 698 495 1.0077data7-100-698-5 100 7 698 516 1.0051data7-100-698-6 100 7 698 509 1.0026data7-100-698-7 100 7 698 517 1.0042data7-100-698-8 100 7 698 491 1.0021data7-100-698-9 100 7 698 497 1.0037data7-100-698-10 100 7 698 505 1.0026

Table 43: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 429: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-100-698-11 100 7 698 476 1.0044data7-100-698-12 100 7 698 509 1.0026data7-100-698-13 100 7 698 513 1.0053data7-100-698-14 100 7 698 501 1.0027data7-100-698-15 100 7 698 532 1.0057data7-100-698-16 100 7 698 494 1.0042data7-100-698-17 100 7 698 528 1.0027data7-100-698-18 100 7 698 492 1.0049data7-100-698-19 100 7 698 539 1.0047data7-100-698-20 100 7 698 508 0.9998data7-100-698-21 100 7 698 549 1.0065data7-100-698-22 100 7 698 508 1.0075data7-100-698-23 100 7 698 491 1.0039data7-100-698-24 100 7 698 491 1.0038data7-100-698-25 100 7 698 511 1.0034data7-100-698-26 100 7 698 524 1.0018data7-100-698-27 100 7 698 517 1.0023data7-100-698-28 100 7 698 515 1.0032data7-100-698-29 100 7 698 511 1.0043data7-100-698-30 100 7 698 495 1.0044data7-100-698-31 100 7 698 475 1.0062data7-100-698-32 100 7 698 506 1.0049data7-100-698-33 100 7 698 516 1.0047data7-100-698-34 100 7 698 535 1.0016data7-100-698-35 100 7 698 497 1.0006data7-100-698-36 100 7 698 480 1.0047data7-100-698-37 100 7 698 517 1.0031data7-100-698-38 100 7 698 528 1.0064data7-100-698-39 100 7 698 538 1.0049data7-100-698-40 100 7 698 500 1.0046data7-100-698-41 100 7 698 528 1.0046data7-100-698-42 100 7 698 488 1.0038data7-100-698-43 100 7 698 508 1.0046data7-100-698-44 100 7 698 522 1.0032data7-100-698-45 100 7 698 487 1.0044data7-100-698-46 100 7 698 528 1.0033data7-100-698-47 100 7 698 523 1.0039data7-100-698-48 100 7 698 499 1.0037data7-100-698-49 100 7 698 518 1.0042data7-100-698-50 100 7 698 496 1.0013data7-100-698-51 100 7 698 495 1.0043data7-100-698-52 100 7 698 543 1.0028data7-100-698-53 100 7 698 522 1.0076data7-100-698-54 100 7 698 525 1.0013data7-100-698-55 100 7 698 524 0.9998data7-100-698-56 100 7 698 505 1.0027data7-100-698-57 100 7 698 504 1.0031data7-100-698-58 100 7 698 548 1.0040data7-100-698-59 100 7 698 511 1.0035data7-100-698-60 100 7 698 502 1.0034data7-100-698-61 100 7 698 519 1.0053data7-100-698-62 100 7 698 532 1.0037data7-100-698-63 100 7 698 524 1.0024data7-100-698-64 100 7 698 495 1.0020data7-100-698-65 100 7 698 485 1.0030data7-100-698-66 100 7 698 523 1.0024data7-100-698-67 100 7 698 506 1.0060data7-100-698-68 100 7 698 488 1.0042data7-100-698-69 100 7 698 520 1.0026data7-100-698-70 100 7 698 494 1.0029data7-100-698-71 100 7 698 498 1.0041data7-100-698-72 100 7 698 492 1.0040data7-100-698-73 100 7 698 521 1.0049data7-100-698-74 100 7 698 524 1.0021data7-100-698-75 100 7 698 516 1.0030data7-100-698-76 100 7 698 522 1.0039data7-100-698-77 100 7 698 502 1.0047data7-100-698-78 100 7 698 507 0.9966data7-100-698-79 100 7 698 532 1.0034data7-100-698-80 100 7 698 493 1.0019

Table 44: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 430: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-100-698-81 100 7 698 530 1.0042data7-100-698-82 100 7 698 469 1.0023data7-100-698-83 100 7 698 514 1.0026data7-100-698-84 100 7 698 498 1.0005data7-100-698-85 100 7 698 500 1.0009data7-100-698-86 100 7 698 502 1.0031data7-100-698-87 100 7 698 532 1.0043data7-100-698-88 100 7 698 474 1.0038data7-100-698-89 100 7 698 497 1.0044data7-100-698-90 100 7 698 489 1.0025data7-100-698-91 100 7 698 548 1.0041data7-100-698-92 100 7 698 497 1.0022data7-100-698-93 100 7 698 496 1.0049data7-100-698-94 100 7 698 517 1.0033data7-100-698-95 100 7 698 515 1.0037data7-100-698-96 100 7 698 498 1.0029data7-100-698-97 100 7 698 515 1.0049data7-100-698-98 100 7 698 480 1.0031data7-100-698-99 100 7 698 535 0.9994data7-100-698-100 100 7 698 479 0.9993data7-100-699-1 100 7 699 481 1.0054data7-100-699-2 100 7 699 514 1.0028data7-100-699-3 100 7 699 520 1.0023data7-100-699-4 100 7 699 535 1.0011data7-100-699-5 100 7 699 510 1.0019data7-100-699-6 100 7 699 508 1.0018data7-100-699-7 100 7 699 511 1.0050data7-100-699-8 100 7 699 498 1.0030data7-100-699-9 100 7 699 498 1.0020data7-100-699-10 100 7 699 536 1.0062data7-100-699-11 100 7 699 504 1.0063data7-100-699-12 100 7 699 497 1.0031data7-100-699-13 100 7 699 499 1.0025data7-100-699-14 100 7 699 489 1.0010data7-100-699-15 100 7 699 539 0.9995data7-100-699-16 100 7 699 524 1.0027data7-100-699-17 100 7 699 491 1.0024data7-100-699-18 100 7 699 537 1.0036data7-100-699-19 100 7 699 496 1.0014data7-100-699-20 100 7 699 516 1.0028data7-100-699-21 100 7 699 529 1.0035data7-100-699-22 100 7 699 509 1.0048data7-100-699-23 100 7 699 513 1.0026data7-100-699-24 100 7 699 498 1.0042data7-100-699-25 100 7 699 519 1.0005data7-100-699-26 100 7 699 479 1.0044data7-100-699-27 100 7 699 503 1.0036data7-100-699-28 100 7 699 495 1.0022data7-100-699-29 100 7 699 486 1.0020data7-100-699-30 100 7 699 545 1.0031data7-100-699-31 100 7 699 503 1.0045data7-100-699-32 100 7 699 496 1.0020data7-100-699-33 100 7 699 535 1.0037data7-100-699-34 100 7 699 494 1.0023data7-100-699-35 100 7 699 544 1.0007data7-100-699-36 100 7 699 532 1.0039data7-100-699-37 100 7 699 484 1.0071data7-100-699-38 100 7 699 515 1.0026data7-100-699-39 100 7 699 534 1.0038data7-100-699-40 100 7 699 517 1.0068data7-100-699-41 100 7 699 492 1.0036data7-100-699-42 100 7 699 514 1.0041data7-100-699-43 100 7 699 507 1.0040data7-100-699-44 100 7 699 507 1.0053data7-100-699-45 100 7 699 476 1.0053data7-100-699-46 100 7 699 495 1.0061data7-100-699-47 100 7 699 504 1.0041data7-100-699-48 100 7 699 515 1.0025data7-100-699-49 100 7 699 528 1.0008data7-100-699-50 100 7 699 484 0.9994

Table 45: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 431: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-100-699-51 100 7 699 528 1.0035data7-100-699-52 100 7 699 525 1.0066data7-100-699-53 100 7 699 484 1.0033data7-100-699-54 100 7 699 533 1.0006data7-100-699-55 100 7 699 490 0.9988data7-100-699-56 100 7 699 500 1.0032data7-100-699-57 100 7 699 547 1.0036data7-100-699-58 100 7 699 506 1.0039data7-100-699-59 100 7 699 532 1.0031data7-100-699-60 100 7 699 463 1.0030data7-100-699-61 100 7 699 530 1.0033data7-100-699-62 100 7 699 481 1.0042data7-100-699-63 100 7 699 502 1.0054data7-100-699-64 100 7 699 518 1.0057data7-100-699-65 100 7 699 504 1.0050data7-100-699-66 100 7 699 510 1.0057data7-100-699-67 100 7 699 517 1.0031data7-100-699-68 100 7 699 506 1.0035data7-100-699-69 100 7 699 532 1.0010data7-100-699-70 100 7 699 503 1.0033data7-100-699-71 100 7 699 518 1.0057data7-100-699-72 100 7 699 491 1.0037data7-100-699-73 100 7 699 465 1.0050data7-100-699-74 100 7 699 482 1.0025data7-100-699-75 100 7 699 526 1.0030data7-100-699-76 100 7 699 493 1.0046data7-100-699-77 100 7 699 504 1.0037data7-100-699-78 100 7 699 559 1.0032data7-100-699-79 100 7 699 529 1.0044data7-100-699-80 100 7 699 502 1.0028data7-100-699-81 100 7 699 515 1.0018data7-100-699-82 100 7 699 502 1.0034data7-100-699-83 100 7 699 514 1.0041data7-100-699-84 100 7 699 532 1.0036data7-100-699-85 100 7 699 507 1.0041data7-100-699-86 100 7 699 500 1.0067data7-100-699-87 100 7 699 497 1.0026data7-100-699-88 100 7 699 527 1.0038data7-100-699-89 100 7 699 527 1.0061data7-100-699-90 100 7 699 502 1.0036data7-100-699-91 100 7 699 492 1.0033data7-100-699-92 100 7 699 510 1.0049data7-100-699-93 100 7 699 500 1.0049data7-100-699-94 100 7 699 498 1.0024data7-100-699-95 100 7 699 517 1.0051data7-100-699-96 100 7 699 504 1.0046data7-100-699-97 100 7 699 519 1.0031data7-100-699-98 100 7 699 498 1.0034data7-100-699-99 100 7 699 537 1.0057data7-100-699-100 100 7 699 527 1.0054data10-100-990-1 100 10 990 930 1.0061data10-100-990-2 100 10 990 955 1.0048data10-100-990-3 100 10 990 928 1.0031data10-100-990-4 100 10 990 940 1.0036data10-100-990-5 100 10 990 957 1.0021data10-100-990-6 100 10 990 918 1.0062data10-100-990-7 100 10 990 897 1.0054data10-100-990-8 100 10 990 937 1.0047data10-100-990-9 100 10 990 870 1.0059data10-100-990-10 100 10 990 942 1.0061data10-100-990-11 100 10 990 947 1.0041data10-100-990-12 100 10 990 979 1.0034data10-100-990-13 100 10 990 956 1.0035data10-100-990-14 100 10 990 935 1.0037data10-100-990-15 100 10 990 949 1.0040data10-100-990-16 100 10 990 959 1.0066data10-100-990-17 100 10 990 915 1.0069data10-100-990-18 100 10 990 917 1.0046data10-100-990-19 100 10 990 1014 1.0032data10-100-990-20 100 10 990 877 1.0016

Table 46: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 432: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-100-990-21 100 10 990 950 1.0033data10-100-990-22 100 10 990 912 1.0055data10-100-990-23 100 10 990 1007 1.0035data10-100-990-24 100 10 990 906 1.0036data10-100-990-25 100 10 990 895 1.0052data10-100-990-26 100 10 990 953 1.0048data10-100-990-27 100 10 990 942 1.0031data10-100-990-28 100 10 990 954 1.0071data10-100-990-29 100 10 990 929 1.0066data10-100-990-30 100 10 990 947 1.0057data10-100-990-31 100 10 990 944 1.0065data10-100-990-32 100 10 990 926 1.0055data10-100-990-33 100 10 990 954 1.0068data10-100-990-34 100 10 990 927 1.0029data10-100-990-35 100 10 990 923 1.0040data10-100-990-36 100 10 990 904 1.0062data10-100-990-37 100 10 990 921 1.0047data10-100-990-38 100 10 990 937 1.0045data10-100-990-39 100 10 990 954 1.0022data10-100-990-40 100 10 990 956 1.0022data10-100-990-41 100 10 990 954 1.0040data10-100-990-42 100 10 990 937 1.0060data10-100-990-43 100 10 990 986 1.0062data10-100-990-44 100 10 990 901 1.0033data10-100-990-45 100 10 990 953 1.0049data10-100-990-46 100 10 990 896 1.0062data10-100-990-47 100 10 990 929 1.0071data10-100-990-48 100 10 990 884 1.0054data10-100-990-49 100 10 990 1006 1.0050data10-100-990-50 100 10 990 963 1.0041data10-100-990-51 100 10 990 951 1.0060data10-100-990-52 100 10 990 899 1.0043data10-100-990-53 100 10 990 922 1.0061data10-100-990-54 100 10 990 857 1.0050data10-100-990-55 100 10 990 901 1.0053data10-100-990-56 100 10 990 936 1.0040data10-100-990-57 100 10 990 942 1.0054data10-100-990-58 100 10 990 936 1.0043data10-100-990-59 100 10 990 992 1.0037data10-100-990-60 100 10 990 960 1.0066data10-100-990-61 100 10 990 979 1.0066data10-100-990-62 100 10 990 977 1.0064data10-100-990-63 100 10 990 924 1.0040data10-100-990-64 100 10 990 931 1.0035data10-100-990-65 100 10 990 924 1.0053data10-100-990-66 100 10 990 907 1.0035data10-100-990-67 100 10 990 931 1.0044data10-100-990-68 100 10 990 901 1.0047data10-100-990-69 100 10 990 959 1.0045data10-100-990-70 100 10 990 976 1.0044data10-100-990-71 100 10 990 941 1.0029data10-100-990-72 100 10 990 909 1.0042data10-100-990-73 100 10 990 916 1.0051data10-100-990-74 100 10 990 1000 1.0043data10-100-990-75 100 10 990 918 1.0046data10-100-990-76 100 10 990 961 1.0057data10-100-990-77 100 10 990 924 1.0034data10-100-990-78 100 10 990 1025 1.0049data10-100-990-79 100 10 990 975 1.0050data10-100-990-80 100 10 990 977 1.0053data10-100-990-81 100 10 990 882 1.0032data10-100-990-82 100 10 990 954 1.0060data10-100-990-83 100 10 990 934 1.0028data10-100-990-84 100 10 990 940 1.0063data10-100-990-85 100 10 990 922 1.0039data10-100-990-86 100 10 990 946 1.0066data10-100-990-87 100 10 990 919 1.0040data10-100-990-88 100 10 990 982 1.0038data10-100-990-89 100 10 990 941 1.0035data10-100-990-90 100 10 990 940 1.0078

Table 47: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 433: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-100-990-91 100 10 990 952 1.0039data10-100-990-92 100 10 990 893 1.0050data10-100-990-93 100 10 990 966 1.0048data10-100-990-94 100 10 990 988 1.0045data10-100-990-95 100 10 990 959 1.0048data10-100-990-96 100 10 990 951 1.0066data10-100-990-97 100 10 990 957 1.0051data10-100-990-98 100 10 990 973 1.0039data10-100-990-99 100 10 990 898 1.0061data10-100-990-100 100 10 990 924 1.0032data10-100-991-1 100 10 991 955 1.0033data10-100-991-2 100 10 991 940 1.0101data10-100-991-3 100 10 991 935 1.0059data10-100-991-4 100 10 991 956 1.0058data10-100-991-5 100 10 991 914 1.0056data10-100-991-6 100 10 991 908 1.0062data10-100-991-7 100 10 991 952 1.0072data10-100-991-8 100 10 991 906 1.0033data10-100-991-9 100 10 991 933 1.0030data10-100-991-10 100 10 991 928 1.0063data10-100-991-11 100 10 991 905 1.0046data10-100-991-12 100 10 991 944 1.0044data10-100-991-13 100 10 991 943 1.0046data10-100-991-14 100 10 991 932 1.0054data10-100-991-15 100 10 991 985 1.0034data10-100-991-16 100 10 991 969 1.0075data10-100-991-17 100 10 991 994 1.0033data10-100-991-18 100 10 991 910 1.0065data10-100-991-19 100 10 991 986 1.0045data10-100-991-20 100 10 991 953 1.0049data10-100-991-21 100 10 991 897 1.0036data10-100-991-22 100 10 991 926 1.0064data10-100-991-23 100 10 991 926 1.0038data10-100-991-24 100 10 991 956 1.0054data10-100-991-25 100 10 991 914 1.0068data10-100-991-26 100 10 991 956 1.0054data10-100-991-27 100 10 991 907 1.0048data10-100-991-28 100 10 991 897 1.0041data10-100-991-29 100 10 991 972 1.0028data10-100-991-30 100 10 991 944 1.0012data10-100-991-31 100 10 991 960 1.0039data10-100-991-32 100 10 991 985 1.0047data10-100-991-33 100 10 991 942 1.0034data10-100-991-34 100 10 991 975 1.0037data10-100-991-35 100 10 991 893 1.0070data10-100-991-36 100 10 991 982 1.0056data10-100-991-37 100 10 991 944 1.0061data10-100-991-38 100 10 991 909 1.0054data10-100-991-39 100 10 991 961 1.0045data10-100-991-40 100 10 991 937 1.0061data10-100-991-41 100 10 991 941 1.0016data10-100-991-42 100 10 991 910 1.0056data10-100-991-43 100 10 991 938 1.0071data10-100-991-44 100 10 991 992 1.0050data10-100-991-45 100 10 991 940 1.0060data10-100-991-46 100 10 991 937 1.0058data10-100-991-47 100 10 991 983 1.0045data10-100-991-48 100 10 991 970 1.0042data10-100-991-49 100 10 991 929 1.0071data10-100-991-50 100 10 991 933 1.0052data10-100-991-51 100 10 991 962 1.0068data10-100-991-52 100 10 991 933 1.0072data10-100-991-53 100 10 991 949 1.0035data10-100-991-54 100 10 991 962 1.0031data10-100-991-55 100 10 991 930 1.0052data10-100-991-56 100 10 991 976 1.0031data10-100-991-57 100 10 991 931 1.0075data10-100-991-58 100 10 991 941 1.0036data10-100-991-59 100 10 991 915 1.0052data10-100-991-60 100 10 991 879 1.0035

Table 48: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 434: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-100-991-61 100 10 991 1000 1.0040data10-100-991-62 100 10 991 982 1.0063data10-100-991-63 100 10 991 909 1.0035data10-100-991-64 100 10 991 933 1.0049data10-100-991-65 100 10 991 882 1.0082data10-100-991-66 100 10 991 969 1.0070data10-100-991-67 100 10 991 942 1.0037data10-100-991-68 100 10 991 922 1.0052data10-100-991-69 100 10 991 945 1.0062data10-100-991-70 100 10 991 927 1.0060data10-100-991-71 100 10 991 984 1.0053data10-100-991-72 100 10 991 952 1.0051data10-100-991-73 100 10 991 949 1.0042data10-100-991-74 100 10 991 939 1.0038data10-100-991-75 100 10 991 982 1.0032data10-100-991-76 100 10 991 913 1.0050data10-100-991-77 100 10 991 915 1.0047data10-100-991-78 100 10 991 923 1.0048data10-100-991-79 100 10 991 943 1.0049data10-100-991-80 100 10 991 899 1.0047data10-100-991-81 100 10 991 963 1.0061data10-100-991-82 100 10 991 940 1.0047data10-100-991-83 100 10 991 1004 1.0069data10-100-991-84 100 10 991 917 1.0037data10-100-991-85 100 10 991 940 1.0049data10-100-991-86 100 10 991 972 1.0042data10-100-991-87 100 10 991 991 1.0044data10-100-991-88 100 10 991 930 1.0042data10-100-991-89 100 10 991 963 1.0059data10-100-991-90 100 10 991 987 1.0060data10-100-991-91 100 10 991 964 1.0058data10-100-991-92 100 10 991 972 1.0055data10-100-991-93 100 10 991 932 1.0082data10-100-991-94 100 10 991 904 1.0058data10-100-991-95 100 10 991 885 1.0034data10-100-991-96 100 10 991 942 1.0045data10-100-991-97 100 10 991 962 1.0058data10-100-991-98 100 10 991 949 1.0033data10-100-991-99 100 10 991 957 1.0048data10-100-991-100 100 10 991 919 1.0061data10-100-992-1 100 10 992 979 1.0052data10-100-992-2 100 10 992 927 1.0055data10-100-992-3 100 10 992 970 1.0047data10-100-992-4 100 10 992 910 1.0064data10-100-992-5 100 10 992 940 1.0058data10-100-992-6 100 10 992 997 1.0032data10-100-992-7 100 10 992 945 1.0038data10-100-992-8 100 10 992 947 1.0031data10-100-992-9 100 10 992 929 1.0066data10-100-992-10 100 10 992 1016 1.0059data10-100-992-11 100 10 992 904 1.0068data10-100-992-12 100 10 992 938 1.0037data10-100-992-13 100 10 992 901 1.0068data10-100-992-14 100 10 992 955 1.0033data10-100-992-15 100 10 992 936 1.0026data10-100-992-16 100 10 992 923 1.0036data10-100-992-17 100 10 992 968 1.0065data10-100-992-18 100 10 992 965 1.0036data10-100-992-19 100 10 992 900 1.0038data10-100-992-20 100 10 992 937 1.0049data10-100-992-21 100 10 992 923 1.0084data10-100-992-22 100 10 992 957 1.0052data10-100-992-23 100 10 992 961 1.0035data10-100-992-24 100 10 992 989 1.0045data10-100-992-25 100 10 992 901 1.0047data10-100-992-26 100 10 992 952 1.0034data10-100-992-27 100 10 992 994 1.0045data10-100-992-28 100 10 992 913 1.0049data10-100-992-29 100 10 992 923 1.0045data10-100-992-30 100 10 992 903 1.0032

Table 49: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 435: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-100-992-31 100 10 992 1008 1.0055data10-100-992-32 100 10 992 928 1.0060data10-100-992-33 100 10 992 966 1.0056data10-100-992-34 100 10 992 936 1.0037data10-100-992-35 100 10 992 938 1.0034data10-100-992-36 100 10 992 881 1.0081data10-100-992-37 100 10 992 905 1.0078data10-100-992-38 100 10 992 952 1.0061data10-100-992-39 100 10 992 963 0.9996data10-100-992-40 100 10 992 912 1.0024data10-100-992-41 100 10 992 948 1.0039data10-100-992-42 100 10 992 928 1.0034data10-100-992-43 100 10 992 984 1.0038data10-100-992-44 100 10 992 949 1.0034data10-100-992-45 100 10 992 930 1.0011data10-100-992-46 100 10 992 922 1.0029data10-100-992-47 100 10 992 950 1.0043data10-100-992-48 100 10 992 931 1.0043data10-100-992-49 100 10 992 934 1.0030data10-100-992-50 100 10 992 931 1.0063data10-100-992-51 100 10 992 946 1.0042data10-100-992-52 100 10 992 918 1.0053data10-100-992-53 100 10 992 956 1.0042data10-100-992-54 100 10 992 916 1.0032data10-100-992-55 100 10 992 907 1.0039data10-100-992-56 100 10 992 928 1.0055data10-100-992-57 100 10 992 960 1.0059data10-100-992-58 100 10 992 979 1.0054data10-100-992-59 100 10 992 949 1.0047data10-100-992-60 100 10 992 975 1.0027data10-100-992-61 100 10 992 946 1.0069data10-100-992-62 100 10 992 928 1.0063data10-100-992-63 100 10 992 963 1.0061data10-100-992-64 100 10 992 892 1.0034data10-100-992-65 100 10 992 936 1.0030data10-100-992-66 100 10 992 914 1.0040data10-100-992-67 100 10 992 916 1.0093data10-100-992-68 100 10 992 994 1.0037data10-100-992-69 100 10 992 924 1.0047data10-100-992-70 100 10 992 981 1.0051data10-100-992-71 100 10 992 914 1.0050data10-100-992-72 100 10 992 1002 1.0053data10-100-992-73 100 10 992 937 1.0057data10-100-992-74 100 10 992 926 1.0060data10-100-992-75 100 10 992 1006 1.0058data10-100-992-76 100 10 992 969 1.0039data10-100-992-77 100 10 992 905 1.0064data10-100-992-78 100 10 992 916 1.0040data10-100-992-79 100 10 992 979 1.0047data10-100-992-80 100 10 992 904 1.0052data10-100-992-81 100 10 992 915 1.0059data10-100-992-82 100 10 992 951 1.0041data10-100-992-83 100 10 992 946 1.0068data10-100-992-84 100 10 992 930 1.0026data10-100-992-85 100 10 992 969 1.0051data10-100-992-86 100 10 992 1000 1.0054data10-100-992-87 100 10 992 946 1.0060data10-100-992-88 100 10 992 987 1.0028data10-100-992-89 100 10 992 944 1.0038data10-100-992-90 100 10 992 975 1.0032data10-100-992-91 100 10 992 953 1.0069data10-100-992-92 100 10 992 984 1.0033data10-100-992-93 100 10 992 947 1.0046data10-100-992-94 100 10 992 953 1.0043data10-100-992-95 100 10 992 953 1.0045data10-100-992-96 100 10 992 961 1.0054data10-100-992-97 100 10 992 900 1.0035data10-100-992-98 100 10 992 976 1.0048data10-100-992-99 100 10 992 986 1.0054data10-100-992-100 100 10 992 911 1.0050

Table 50: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 436: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-100-993-1 100 10 993 924 1.0060data10-100-993-2 100 10 993 965 1.0068data10-100-993-3 100 10 993 912 1.0041data10-100-993-4 100 10 993 962 1.0037data10-100-993-5 100 10 993 1011 1.0037data10-100-993-6 100 10 993 975 1.0071data10-100-993-7 100 10 993 893 1.0072data10-100-993-8 100 10 993 992 1.0056data10-100-993-9 100 10 993 999 1.0032data10-100-993-10 100 10 993 943 1.0053data10-100-993-11 100 10 993 921 1.0053data10-100-993-12 100 10 993 972 1.0058data10-100-993-13 100 10 993 921 1.0075data10-100-993-14 100 10 993 919 1.0060data10-100-993-15 100 10 993 972 1.0060data10-100-993-16 100 10 993 915 1.0049data10-100-993-17 100 10 993 1002 1.0062data10-100-993-18 100 10 993 941 1.0056data10-100-993-19 100 10 993 937 1.0036data10-100-993-20 100 10 993 973 1.0039data10-100-993-21 100 10 993 904 1.0045data10-100-993-22 100 10 993 973 1.0032data10-100-993-23 100 10 993 976 1.0041data10-100-993-24 100 10 993 943 1.0017data10-100-993-25 100 10 993 997 1.0012data10-100-993-26 100 10 993 914 1.0051data10-100-993-27 100 10 993 1006 1.0039data10-100-993-28 100 10 993 969 1.0047data10-100-993-29 100 10 993 958 1.0058data10-100-993-30 100 10 993 952 1.0042data10-100-993-31 100 10 993 934 1.0052data10-100-993-32 100 10 993 951 1.0038data10-100-993-33 100 10 993 953 1.0049data10-100-993-34 100 10 993 958 1.0043data10-100-993-35 100 10 993 1002 1.0071data10-100-993-36 100 10 993 957 1.0046data10-100-993-37 100 10 993 1005 1.0065data10-100-993-38 100 10 993 949 1.0045data10-100-993-39 100 10 993 933 1.0066data10-100-993-40 100 10 993 891 1.0051data10-100-993-41 100 10 993 978 1.0037data10-100-993-42 100 10 993 974 1.0065data10-100-993-43 100 10 993 887 1.0078data10-100-993-44 100 10 993 969 1.0009data10-100-993-45 100 10 993 945 1.0046data10-100-993-46 100 10 993 940 1.0030data10-100-993-47 100 10 993 964 1.0082data10-100-993-48 100 10 993 889 1.0049data10-100-993-49 100 10 993 1035 1.0033data10-100-993-50 100 10 993 994 1.0013data10-100-993-51 100 10 993 979 1.0050data10-100-993-52 100 10 993 949 1.0036data10-100-993-53 100 10 993 945 1.0059data10-100-993-54 100 10 993 980 1.0057data10-100-993-55 100 10 993 961 1.0052data10-100-993-56 100 10 993 901 1.0088data10-100-993-57 100 10 993 929 1.0075data10-100-993-58 100 10 993 978 1.0046data10-100-993-59 100 10 993 993 1.0043data10-100-993-60 100 10 993 921 1.0020data10-100-993-61 100 10 993 948 1.0067data10-100-993-62 100 10 993 883 1.0067data10-100-993-63 100 10 993 951 1.0071data10-100-993-64 100 10 993 964 1.0039data10-100-993-65 100 10 993 956 1.0042data10-100-993-66 100 10 993 964 1.0041data10-100-993-67 100 10 993 896 1.0059data10-100-993-68 100 10 993 925 1.0038data10-100-993-69 100 10 993 951 1.0020data10-100-993-70 100 10 993 889 1.0040

Table 51: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 437: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-100-993-71 100 10 993 934 1.0064data10-100-993-72 100 10 993 953 1.0036data10-100-993-73 100 10 993 975 1.0039data10-100-993-74 100 10 993 965 1.0059data10-100-993-75 100 10 993 874 1.0067data10-100-993-76 100 10 993 934 1.0059data10-100-993-77 100 10 993 973 1.0065data10-100-993-78 100 10 993 958 1.0069data10-100-993-79 100 10 993 993 1.0059data10-100-993-80 100 10 993 889 1.0064data10-100-993-81 100 10 993 928 1.0055data10-100-993-82 100 10 993 943 1.0060data10-100-993-83 100 10 993 936 1.0056data10-100-993-84 100 10 993 984 1.0047data10-100-993-85 100 10 993 947 1.0046data10-100-993-86 100 10 993 877 1.0037data10-100-993-87 100 10 993 886 1.0058data10-100-993-88 100 10 993 902 1.0056data10-100-993-89 100 10 993 944 1.0037data10-100-993-90 100 10 993 944 1.0040data10-100-993-91 100 10 993 999 1.0038data10-100-993-92 100 10 993 913 1.0052data10-100-993-93 100 10 993 962 1.0055data10-100-993-94 100 10 993 962 1.0068data10-100-993-95 100 10 993 957 1.0039data10-100-993-96 100 10 993 932 1.0059data10-100-993-97 100 10 993 949 1.0043data10-100-993-98 100 10 993 973 1.0072data10-100-993-99 100 10 993 986 1.0054data10-100-993-100 100 10 993 921 1.0045data10-100-994-1 100 10 994 942 1.0066data10-100-994-2 100 10 994 903 1.0091data10-100-994-3 100 10 994 956 1.0058data10-100-994-4 100 10 994 942 1.0018data10-100-994-5 100 10 994 960 1.0045data10-100-994-6 100 10 994 991 1.0050data10-100-994-7 100 10 994 954 1.0043data10-100-994-8 100 10 994 936 1.0056data10-100-994-9 100 10 994 909 1.0048data10-100-994-10 100 10 994 960 1.0031data10-100-994-11 100 10 994 976 1.0065data10-100-994-12 100 10 994 961 1.0034data10-100-994-13 100 10 994 970 1.0043data10-100-994-14 100 10 994 936 1.0038data10-100-994-15 100 10 994 933 1.0036data10-100-994-16 100 10 994 930 1.0037data10-100-994-17 100 10 994 1029 1.0056data10-100-994-18 100 10 994 969 1.0043data10-100-994-19 100 10 994 983 1.0028data10-100-994-20 100 10 994 968 1.0017data10-100-994-21 100 10 994 968 1.0032data10-100-994-22 100 10 994 949 1.0049data10-100-994-23 100 10 994 937 1.0054data10-100-994-24 100 10 994 928 1.0047data10-100-994-25 100 10 994 912 1.0064data10-100-994-26 100 10 994 923 1.0074data10-100-994-27 100 10 994 991 1.0043data10-100-994-28 100 10 994 952 1.0065data10-100-994-29 100 10 994 920 1.0056data10-100-994-30 100 10 994 934 1.0053data10-100-994-31 100 10 994 997 1.0043data10-100-994-32 100 10 994 966 1.0042data10-100-994-33 100 10 994 961 1.0049data10-100-994-34 100 10 994 979 1.0043data10-100-994-35 100 10 994 947 1.0037data10-100-994-36 100 10 994 911 1.0081data10-100-994-37 100 10 994 940 1.0039data10-100-994-38 100 10 994 978 1.0040data10-100-994-39 100 10 994 993 1.0045data10-100-994-40 100 10 994 926 1.0023

Table 52: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 438: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-100-994-41 100 10 994 985 1.0062data10-100-994-42 100 10 994 977 1.0050data10-100-994-43 100 10 994 954 1.0059data10-100-994-44 100 10 994 901 1.0041data10-100-994-45 100 10 994 972 1.0068data10-100-994-46 100 10 994 927 1.0066data10-100-994-47 100 10 994 946 1.0035data10-100-994-48 100 10 994 979 1.0040data10-100-994-49 100 10 994 954 1.0038data10-100-994-50 100 10 994 953 1.0083data10-100-994-51 100 10 994 915 1.0062data10-100-994-52 100 10 994 961 1.0041data10-100-994-53 100 10 994 970 1.0035data10-100-994-54 100 10 994 963 1.0055data10-100-994-55 100 10 994 928 1.0037data10-100-994-56 100 10 994 984 1.0036data10-100-994-57 100 10 994 968 1.0050data10-100-994-58 100 10 994 994 1.0042data10-100-994-59 100 10 994 922 1.0069data10-100-994-60 100 10 994 934 1.0078data10-100-994-61 100 10 994 908 1.0031data10-100-994-62 100 10 994 901 1.0055data10-100-994-63 100 10 994 999 1.0046data10-100-994-64 100 10 994 950 1.0036data10-100-994-65 100 10 994 955 1.0055data10-100-994-66 100 10 994 996 1.0049data10-100-994-67 100 10 994 902 1.0049data10-100-994-68 100 10 994 969 1.0052data10-100-994-69 100 10 994 977 1.0042data10-100-994-70 100 10 994 951 1.0057data10-100-994-71 100 10 994 975 1.0065data10-100-994-72 100 10 994 943 1.0051data10-100-994-73 100 10 994 956 1.0043data10-100-994-74 100 10 994 943 1.0048data10-100-994-75 100 10 994 890 1.0046data10-100-994-76 100 10 994 955 1.0035data10-100-994-77 100 10 994 946 1.0035data10-100-994-78 100 10 994 988 1.0034data10-100-994-79 100 10 994 921 1.0099data10-100-994-80 100 10 994 939 1.0039data10-100-994-81 100 10 994 921 1.0053data10-100-994-82 100 10 994 1011 1.0038data10-100-994-83 100 10 994 930 1.0047data10-100-994-84 100 10 994 913 1.0044data10-100-994-85 100 10 994 1002 1.0047data10-100-994-86 100 10 994 938 1.0068data10-100-994-87 100 10 994 875 1.0048data10-100-994-88 100 10 994 970 1.0044data10-100-994-89 100 10 994 960 1.0043data10-100-994-90 100 10 994 950 1.0016data10-100-994-91 100 10 994 924 1.0053data10-100-994-92 100 10 994 986 1.0033data10-100-994-93 100 10 994 1008 1.0070data10-100-994-94 100 10 994 967 1.0042data10-100-994-95 100 10 994 932 1.0068data10-100-994-96 100 10 994 985 1.0073data10-100-994-97 100 10 994 967 1.0071data10-100-994-98 100 10 994 939 1.0045data10-100-994-99 100 10 994 955 1.0026data10-100-994-100 100 10 994 936 1.0026data10-100-995-1 100 10 995 954 1.0033data10-100-995-2 100 10 995 971 1.0032data10-100-995-3 100 10 995 938 1.0071data10-100-995-4 100 10 995 973 1.0066data10-100-995-5 100 10 995 996 1.0064data10-100-995-6 100 10 995 928 1.0060data10-100-995-7 100 10 995 983 1.0071data10-100-995-8 100 10 995 976 1.0042data10-100-995-9 100 10 995 944 1.0044data10-100-995-10 100 10 995 965 1.0016

Table 53: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 439: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-100-995-11 100 10 995 970 1.0039data10-100-995-12 100 10 995 924 1.0044data10-100-995-13 100 10 995 937 1.0045data10-100-995-14 100 10 995 933 1.0064data10-100-995-15 100 10 995 938 1.0054data10-100-995-16 100 10 995 999 1.0060data10-100-995-17 100 10 995 936 1.0041data10-100-995-18 100 10 995 940 1.0049data10-100-995-19 100 10 995 930 1.0045data10-100-995-20 100 10 995 949 1.0054data10-100-995-21 100 10 995 960 1.0048data10-100-995-22 100 10 995 955 1.0062data10-100-995-23 100 10 995 947 1.0039data10-100-995-24 100 10 995 933 1.0057data10-100-995-25 100 10 995 941 1.0045data10-100-995-26 100 10 995 954 1.0050data10-100-995-27 100 10 995 953 1.0052data10-100-995-28 100 10 995 935 1.0037data10-100-995-29 100 10 995 964 1.0046data10-100-995-30 100 10 995 963 1.0031data10-100-995-31 100 10 995 967 1.0032data10-100-995-32 100 10 995 931 1.0052data10-100-995-33 100 10 995 950 1.0055data10-100-995-34 100 10 995 986 1.0058data10-100-995-35 100 10 995 975 1.0041data10-100-995-36 100 10 995 938 1.0076data10-100-995-37 100 10 995 992 1.0042data10-100-995-38 100 10 995 962 1.0052data10-100-995-39 100 10 995 936 1.0050data10-100-995-40 100 10 995 965 1.0063data10-100-995-41 100 10 995 953 1.0046data10-100-995-42 100 10 995 989 1.0035data10-100-995-43 100 10 995 932 1.0052data10-100-995-44 100 10 995 983 1.0049data10-100-995-45 100 10 995 971 1.0070data10-100-995-46 100 10 995 977 1.0041data10-100-995-47 100 10 995 961 1.0032data10-100-995-48 100 10 995 942 1.0049data10-100-995-49 100 10 995 981 1.0064data10-100-995-50 100 10 995 937 1.0044data10-100-995-51 100 10 995 962 1.0054data10-100-995-52 100 10 995 974 1.0049data10-100-995-53 100 10 995 979 1.0039data10-100-995-54 100 10 995 1053 1.0051data10-100-995-55 100 10 995 965 1.0076data10-100-995-56 100 10 995 930 1.0066data10-100-995-57 100 10 995 912 1.0044data10-100-995-58 100 10 995 926 1.0048data10-100-995-59 100 10 995 935 1.0041data10-100-995-60 100 10 995 944 1.0047data10-100-995-61 100 10 995 932 1.0055data10-100-995-62 100 10 995 977 1.0058data10-100-995-63 100 10 995 914 1.0077data10-100-995-64 100 10 995 948 1.0034data10-100-995-65 100 10 995 897 1.0038data10-100-995-66 100 10 995 969 1.0059data10-100-995-67 100 10 995 999 1.0056data10-100-995-68 100 10 995 1011 1.0033data10-100-995-69 100 10 995 971 1.0059data10-100-995-70 100 10 995 901 1.0062data10-100-995-71 100 10 995 936 1.0060data10-100-995-72 100 10 995 996 1.0046data10-100-995-73 100 10 995 939 1.0029data10-100-995-74 100 10 995 924 1.0038data10-100-995-75 100 10 995 992 1.0044data10-100-995-76 100 10 995 913 1.0050data10-100-995-77 100 10 995 939 1.0036data10-100-995-78 100 10 995 993 1.0047data10-100-995-79 100 10 995 989 1.0045data10-100-995-80 100 10 995 907 1.0029

Table 54: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 440: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-100-995-81 100 10 995 946 1.0044data10-100-995-82 100 10 995 942 1.0041data10-100-995-83 100 10 995 988 1.0071data10-100-995-84 100 10 995 979 1.0055data10-100-995-85 100 10 995 939 1.0035data10-100-995-86 100 10 995 949 1.0030data10-100-995-87 100 10 995 979 1.0063data10-100-995-88 100 10 995 984 1.0052data10-100-995-89 100 10 995 938 1.0034data10-100-995-90 100 10 995 892 1.0057data10-100-995-91 100 10 995 933 1.0076data10-100-995-92 100 10 995 921 1.0031data10-100-995-93 100 10 995 935 1.0034data10-100-995-94 100 10 995 910 1.0038data10-100-995-95 100 10 995 954 1.0020data10-100-995-96 100 10 995 1015 1.0044data10-100-995-97 100 10 995 938 1.0086data10-100-995-98 100 10 995 936 1.0079data10-100-995-99 100 10 995 918 1.0026data10-100-995-100 100 10 995 988 1.0059data10-100-996-1 100 10 996 968 1.0066data10-100-996-2 100 10 996 977 1.0031data10-100-996-3 100 10 996 955 1.0075data10-100-996-4 100 10 996 965 1.0042data10-100-996-5 100 10 996 963 1.0041data10-100-996-6 100 10 996 998 1.0039data10-100-996-7 100 10 996 964 1.0047data10-100-996-8 100 10 996 993 1.0050data10-100-996-9 100 10 996 969 1.0049data10-100-996-10 100 10 996 945 1.0013data10-100-996-11 100 10 996 969 1.0046data10-100-996-12 100 10 996 958 1.0037data10-100-996-13 100 10 996 952 1.0074data10-100-996-14 100 10 996 936 1.0015data10-100-996-15 100 10 996 953 1.0038data10-100-996-16 100 10 996 977 1.0070data10-100-996-17 100 10 996 978 1.0035data10-100-996-18 100 10 996 942 1.0060data10-100-996-19 100 10 996 979 1.0043data10-100-996-20 100 10 996 975 1.0037data10-100-996-21 100 10 996 974 1.0052data10-100-996-22 100 10 996 970 1.0041data10-100-996-23 100 10 996 953 1.0060data10-100-996-24 100 10 996 927 1.0072data10-100-996-25 100 10 996 961 1.0065data10-100-996-26 100 10 996 976 1.0046data10-100-996-27 100 10 996 982 1.0053data10-100-996-28 100 10 996 993 1.0076data10-100-996-29 100 10 996 998 1.0070data10-100-996-30 100 10 996 977 1.0037data10-100-996-31 100 10 996 951 1.0060data10-100-996-32 100 10 996 930 1.0055data10-100-996-33 100 10 996 954 1.0036data10-100-996-34 100 10 996 972 1.0058data10-100-996-35 100 10 996 939 1.0055data10-100-996-36 100 10 996 1011 1.0029data10-100-996-37 100 10 996 939 1.0034data10-100-996-38 100 10 996 933 1.0032data10-100-996-39 100 10 996 957 1.0032data10-100-996-40 100 10 996 996 1.0031data10-100-996-41 100 10 996 960 1.0033data10-100-996-42 100 10 996 960 1.0036data10-100-996-43 100 10 996 908 1.0079data10-100-996-44 100 10 996 993 1.0031data10-100-996-45 100 10 996 954 1.0051data10-100-996-46 100 10 996 924 1.0042data10-100-996-47 100 10 996 959 1.0046data10-100-996-48 100 10 996 959 1.0039data10-100-996-49 100 10 996 954 1.0024data10-100-996-50 100 10 996 955 1.0050

Table 55: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 441: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-100-996-51 100 10 996 889 1.0050data10-100-996-52 100 10 996 939 1.0064data10-100-996-53 100 10 996 920 1.0052data10-100-996-54 100 10 996 943 1.0078data10-100-996-55 100 10 996 996 1.0065data10-100-996-56 100 10 996 974 1.0035data10-100-996-57 100 10 996 963 1.0057data10-100-996-58 100 10 996 951 1.0039data10-100-996-59 100 10 996 911 1.0032data10-100-996-60 100 10 996 931 1.0039data10-100-996-61 100 10 996 900 1.0036data10-100-996-62 100 10 996 979 1.0041data10-100-996-63 100 10 996 974 1.0029data10-100-996-64 100 10 996 1005 1.0092data10-100-996-65 100 10 996 957 1.0030data10-100-996-66 100 10 996 950 1.0049data10-100-996-67 100 10 996 923 1.0043data10-100-996-68 100 10 996 979 1.0051data10-100-996-69 100 10 996 974 1.0045data10-100-996-70 100 10 996 887 1.0005data10-100-996-71 100 10 996 946 1.0032data10-100-996-72 100 10 996 969 1.0035data10-100-996-73 100 10 996 993 1.0059data10-100-996-74 100 10 996 942 1.0030data10-100-996-75 100 10 996 1012 1.0028data10-100-996-76 100 10 996 1015 1.0059data10-100-996-77 100 10 996 968 1.0062data10-100-996-78 100 10 996 1000 1.0044data10-100-996-79 100 10 996 886 1.0028data10-100-996-80 100 10 996 975 1.0009data10-100-996-81 100 10 996 952 1.0063data10-100-996-82 100 10 996 984 1.0036data10-100-996-83 100 10 996 1009 1.0040data10-100-996-84 100 10 996 975 1.0042data10-100-996-85 100 10 996 1002 1.0041data10-100-996-86 100 10 996 912 1.0042data10-100-996-87 100 10 996 941 1.0048data10-100-996-88 100 10 996 934 1.0051data10-100-996-89 100 10 996 929 1.0068data10-100-996-90 100 10 996 1008 1.0028data10-100-996-91 100 10 996 995 1.0043data10-100-996-92 100 10 996 979 1.0078data10-100-996-93 100 10 996 932 1.0028data10-100-996-94 100 10 996 955 1.0037data10-100-996-95 100 10 996 990 1.0048data10-100-996-96 100 10 996 980 1.0049data10-100-996-97 100 10 996 895 1.0073data10-100-996-98 100 10 996 904 1.0039data10-100-996-99 100 10 996 966 1.0066data10-100-996-100 100 10 996 923 1.0050data10-100-997-1 100 10 997 981 1.0041data10-100-997-2 100 10 997 965 1.0038data10-100-997-3 100 10 997 988 1.0067data10-100-997-4 100 10 997 925 1.0024data10-100-997-5 100 10 997 983 1.0039data10-100-997-6 100 10 997 910 1.0046data10-100-997-7 100 10 997 952 1.0056data10-100-997-8 100 10 997 981 1.0072data10-100-997-9 100 10 997 936 1.0069data10-100-997-10 100 10 997 955 1.0061data10-100-997-11 100 10 997 949 1.0038data10-100-997-12 100 10 997 922 1.0048data10-100-997-13 100 10 997 972 1.0058data10-100-997-14 100 10 997 935 1.0039data10-100-997-15 100 10 997 986 1.0043data10-100-997-16 100 10 997 943 1.0034data10-100-997-17 100 10 997 947 1.0039data10-100-997-18 100 10 997 969 1.0067data10-100-997-19 100 10 997 956 1.0049data10-100-997-20 100 10 997 975 1.0077

Table 56: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 442: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-100-997-21 100 10 997 929 1.0061data10-100-997-22 100 10 997 936 1.0059data10-100-997-23 100 10 997 972 1.0047data10-100-997-24 100 10 997 961 1.0019data10-100-997-25 100 10 997 987 1.0053data10-100-997-26 100 10 997 913 1.0047data10-100-997-27 100 10 997 966 1.0033data10-100-997-28 100 10 997 982 1.0050data10-100-997-29 100 10 997 925 1.0040data10-100-997-30 100 10 997 911 1.0052data10-100-997-31 100 10 997 886 1.0071data10-100-997-32 100 10 997 966 1.0053data10-100-997-33 100 10 997 965 1.0035data10-100-997-34 100 10 997 988 1.0054data10-100-997-35 100 10 997 968 1.0046data10-100-997-36 100 10 997 935 1.0061data10-100-997-37 100 10 997 959 1.0049data10-100-997-38 100 10 997 970 1.0040data10-100-997-39 100 10 997 970 1.0053data10-100-997-40 100 10 997 988 1.0047data10-100-997-41 100 10 997 977 1.0076data10-100-997-42 100 10 997 974 1.0047data10-100-997-43 100 10 997 951 1.0053data10-100-997-44 100 10 997 979 1.0056data10-100-997-45 100 10 997 953 1.0067data10-100-997-46 100 10 997 983 1.0047data10-100-997-47 100 10 997 945 1.0045data10-100-997-48 100 10 997 961 1.0070data10-100-997-49 100 10 997 932 1.0074data10-100-997-50 100 10 997 963 1.0047data10-100-997-51 100 10 997 1003 1.0040data10-100-997-52 100 10 997 918 1.0043data10-100-997-53 100 10 997 913 1.0033data10-100-997-54 100 10 997 987 1.0050data10-100-997-55 100 10 997 962 1.0049data10-100-997-56 100 10 997 957 1.0041data10-100-997-57 100 10 997 998 1.0084data10-100-997-58 100 10 997 1015 1.0065data10-100-997-59 100 10 997 955 1.0052data10-100-997-60 100 10 997 943 1.0033data10-100-997-61 100 10 997 938 1.0027data10-100-997-62 100 10 997 897 1.0050data10-100-997-63 100 10 997 973 1.0048data10-100-997-64 100 10 997 968 1.0047data10-100-997-65 100 10 997 955 1.0041data10-100-997-66 100 10 997 976 1.0034data10-100-997-67 100 10 997 949 1.0040data10-100-997-68 100 10 997 916 1.0039data10-100-997-69 100 10 997 955 1.0017data10-100-997-70 100 10 997 974 1.0054data10-100-997-71 100 10 997 994 1.0036data10-100-997-72 100 10 997 944 1.0033data10-100-997-73 100 10 997 968 1.0034data10-100-997-74 100 10 997 955 1.0020data10-100-997-75 100 10 997 941 1.0043data10-100-997-76 100 10 997 933 1.0058data10-100-997-77 100 10 997 1032 1.0056data10-100-997-78 100 10 997 974 1.0036data10-100-997-79 100 10 997 957 1.0046data10-100-997-80 100 10 997 964 1.0052data10-100-997-81 100 10 997 956 1.0038data10-100-997-82 100 10 997 960 1.0044data10-100-997-83 100 10 997 980 1.0027data10-100-997-84 100 10 997 935 1.0020data10-100-997-85 100 10 997 964 1.0047data10-100-997-86 100 10 997 962 1.0069data10-100-997-87 100 10 997 937 1.0045data10-100-997-88 100 10 997 923 1.0043data10-100-997-89 100 10 997 984 1.0037data10-100-997-90 100 10 997 944 1.0031

Table 57: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 443: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-100-997-91 100 10 997 938 1.0058data10-100-997-92 100 10 997 989 1.0050data10-100-997-93 100 10 997 959 1.0038data10-100-997-94 100 10 997 967 1.0041data10-100-997-95 100 10 997 975 1.0051data10-100-997-96 100 10 997 958 1.0068data10-100-997-97 100 10 997 943 1.0050data10-100-997-98 100 10 997 956 1.0067data10-100-997-99 100 10 997 998 1.0051data10-100-997-100 100 10 997 1023 1.0020data10-100-998-1 100 10 998 923 1.0034data10-100-998-2 100 10 998 961 1.0057data10-100-998-3 100 10 998 953 1.0045data10-100-998-4 100 10 998 996 1.0077data10-100-998-5 100 10 998 983 1.0044data10-100-998-6 100 10 998 923 1.0081data10-100-998-7 100 10 998 908 1.0050data10-100-998-8 100 10 998 914 1.0031data10-100-998-9 100 10 998 964 1.0055data10-100-998-10 100 10 998 971 1.0081data10-100-998-11 100 10 998 962 1.0042data10-100-998-12 100 10 998 955 1.0033data10-100-998-13 100 10 998 940 1.0054data10-100-998-14 100 10 998 1026 1.0032data10-100-998-15 100 10 998 954 1.0035data10-100-998-16 100 10 998 965 1.0043data10-100-998-17 100 10 998 986 1.0054data10-100-998-18 100 10 998 939 1.0059data10-100-998-19 100 10 998 1018 1.0034data10-100-998-20 100 10 998 983 1.0066data10-100-998-21 100 10 998 967 1.0044data10-100-998-22 100 10 998 951 1.0049data10-100-998-23 100 10 998 952 1.0068data10-100-998-24 100 10 998 953 1.0057data10-100-998-25 100 10 998 902 1.0061data10-100-998-26 100 10 998 939 1.0066data10-100-998-27 100 10 998 977 1.0067data10-100-998-28 100 10 998 1009 1.0035data10-100-998-29 100 10 998 1053 1.0055data10-100-998-30 100 10 998 1012 1.0051data10-100-998-31 100 10 998 935 1.0042data10-100-998-32 100 10 998 1003 1.0017data10-100-998-33 100 10 998 965 1.0039data10-100-998-34 100 10 998 980 1.0023data10-100-998-35 100 10 998 998 1.0021data10-100-998-36 100 10 998 927 1.0032data10-100-998-37 100 10 998 972 1.0045data10-100-998-38 100 10 998 1007 1.0056data10-100-998-39 100 10 998 976 1.0035data10-100-998-40 100 10 998 948 1.0053data10-100-998-41 100 10 998 994 1.0044data10-100-998-42 100 10 998 962 1.0041data10-100-998-43 100 10 998 961 1.0076data10-100-998-44 100 10 998 964 1.0048data10-100-998-45 100 10 998 973 1.0041data10-100-998-46 100 10 998 955 1.0041data10-100-998-47 100 10 998 972 1.0072data10-100-998-48 100 10 998 987 1.0049data10-100-998-49 100 10 998 985 1.0069data10-100-998-50 100 10 998 959 1.0055data10-100-998-51 100 10 998 935 1.0059data10-100-998-52 100 10 998 920 1.0057data10-100-998-53 100 10 998 946 1.0052data10-100-998-54 100 10 998 956 1.0042data10-100-998-55 100 10 998 939 1.0038data10-100-998-56 100 10 998 974 1.0053data10-100-998-57 100 10 998 1009 1.0036data10-100-998-58 100 10 998 958 1.0041data10-100-998-59 100 10 998 981 1.0061data10-100-998-60 100 10 998 978 1.0039

Table 58: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 444: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-100-998-61 100 10 998 974 1.0049data10-100-998-62 100 10 998 975 1.0028data10-100-998-63 100 10 998 1022 1.0054data10-100-998-64 100 10 998 985 1.0031data10-100-998-65 100 10 998 1012 1.0041data10-100-998-66 100 10 998 931 1.0048data10-100-998-67 100 10 998 938 1.0050data10-100-998-68 100 10 998 940 1.0038data10-100-998-69 100 10 998 961 1.0052data10-100-998-70 100 10 998 915 1.0043data10-100-998-71 100 10 998 938 1.0088data10-100-998-72 100 10 998 963 1.0054data10-100-998-73 100 10 998 1001 1.0035data10-100-998-74 100 10 998 1049 1.0026data10-100-998-75 100 10 998 945 1.0015data10-100-998-76 100 10 998 921 1.0050data10-100-998-77 100 10 998 967 1.0053data10-100-998-78 100 10 998 935 1.0063data10-100-998-79 100 10 998 993 1.0048data10-100-998-80 100 10 998 931 1.0058data10-100-998-81 100 10 998 977 1.0053data10-100-998-82 100 10 998 1019 1.0061data10-100-998-83 100 10 998 904 1.0050data10-100-998-84 100 10 998 979 1.0059data10-100-998-85 100 10 998 978 1.0059data10-100-998-86 100 10 998 917 1.0039data10-100-998-87 100 10 998 966 1.0042data10-100-998-88 100 10 998 934 1.0047data10-100-998-89 100 10 998 937 1.0031data10-100-998-90 100 10 998 951 1.0027data10-100-998-91 100 10 998 964 1.0064data10-100-998-92 100 10 998 970 1.0040data10-100-998-93 100 10 998 955 1.0054data10-100-998-94 100 10 998 917 1.0047data10-100-998-95 100 10 998 977 1.0078data10-100-998-96 100 10 998 935 1.0065data10-100-998-97 100 10 998 1022 1.0048data10-100-998-98 100 10 998 919 1.0033data10-100-998-99 100 10 998 909 1.0038data10-100-998-100 100 10 998 981 1.0043data10-100-999-1 100 10 999 926 1.0059data10-100-999-2 100 10 999 1011 1.0034data10-100-999-3 100 10 999 956 1.0040data10-100-999-4 100 10 999 994 1.0032data10-100-999-5 100 10 999 994 1.0055data10-100-999-6 100 10 999 1013 1.0044data10-100-999-7 100 10 999 952 1.0035data10-100-999-8 100 10 999 964 1.0043data10-100-999-9 100 10 999 1008 1.0075data10-100-999-10 100 10 999 971 1.0052data10-100-999-11 100 10 999 905 1.0043data10-100-999-12 100 10 999 951 1.0030data10-100-999-13 100 10 999 967 1.0065data10-100-999-14 100 10 999 934 1.0025data10-100-999-15 100 10 999 956 1.0056data10-100-999-16 100 10 999 956 1.0072data10-100-999-17 100 10 999 931 1.0044data10-100-999-18 100 10 999 945 1.0032data10-100-999-19 100 10 999 971 1.0065data10-100-999-20 100 10 999 936 1.0037data10-100-999-21 100 10 999 960 1.0038data10-100-999-22 100 10 999 951 1.0057data10-100-999-23 100 10 999 937 1.0039data10-100-999-24 100 10 999 1011 1.0032data10-100-999-25 100 10 999 1014 1.0045data10-100-999-26 100 10 999 974 1.0031data10-100-999-27 100 10 999 968 1.0047data10-100-999-28 100 10 999 962 1.0039data10-100-999-29 100 10 999 905 1.0056data10-100-999-30 100 10 999 998 1.0041

Table 59: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 445: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-100-999-31 100 10 999 938 1.0039data10-100-999-32 100 10 999 994 1.0034data10-100-999-33 100 10 999 979 1.0037data10-100-999-34 100 10 999 952 1.0053data10-100-999-35 100 10 999 901 1.0033data10-100-999-36 100 10 999 925 1.0050data10-100-999-37 100 10 999 958 1.0043data10-100-999-38 100 10 999 967 1.0040data10-100-999-39 100 10 999 985 1.0060data10-100-999-40 100 10 999 945 1.0029data10-100-999-41 100 10 999 1002 1.0045data10-100-999-42 100 10 999 948 1.0048data10-100-999-43 100 10 999 948 1.0051data10-100-999-44 100 10 999 1017 1.0059data10-100-999-45 100 10 999 930 1.0045data10-100-999-46 100 10 999 957 1.0062data10-100-999-47 100 10 999 936 1.0032data10-100-999-48 100 10 999 956 1.0046data10-100-999-49 100 10 999 952 1.0040data10-100-999-50 100 10 999 882 1.0058data10-100-999-51 100 10 999 1002 1.0048data10-100-999-52 100 10 999 976 1.0066data10-100-999-53 100 10 999 1010 1.0049data10-100-999-54 100 10 999 935 1.0031data10-100-999-55 100 10 999 972 1.0036data10-100-999-56 100 10 999 900 1.0058data10-100-999-57 100 10 999 963 1.0038data10-100-999-58 100 10 999 975 1.0075data10-100-999-59 100 10 999 904 1.0032data10-100-999-60 100 10 999 995 1.0043data10-100-999-61 100 10 999 958 1.0029data10-100-999-62 100 10 999 914 1.0032data10-100-999-63 100 10 999 957 1.0040data10-100-999-64 100 10 999 982 1.0041data10-100-999-65 100 10 999 926 1.0032data10-100-999-66 100 10 999 981 1.0069data10-100-999-67 100 10 999 959 1.0042data10-100-999-68 100 10 999 986 1.0033data10-100-999-69 100 10 999 964 1.0043data10-100-999-70 100 10 999 987 1.0029data10-100-999-71 100 10 999 1021 1.0040data10-100-999-72 100 10 999 960 1.0034data10-100-999-73 100 10 999 891 1.0023data10-100-999-74 100 10 999 962 1.0033data10-100-999-75 100 10 999 931 1.0027data10-100-999-76 100 10 999 919 1.0049data10-100-999-77 100 10 999 970 1.0044data10-100-999-78 100 10 999 958 1.0038data10-100-999-79 100 10 999 946 1.0045data10-100-999-80 100 10 999 972 1.0032data10-100-999-81 100 10 999 981 1.0037data10-100-999-82 100 10 999 1014 1.0041data10-100-999-83 100 10 999 983 1.0035data10-100-999-84 100 10 999 997 1.0041data10-100-999-85 100 10 999 926 1.0027data10-100-999-86 100 10 999 926 1.0044data10-100-999-87 100 10 999 1006 1.0037data10-100-999-88 100 10 999 984 1.0071data10-100-999-89 100 10 999 968 1.0034data10-100-999-90 100 10 999 934 1.0049data10-100-999-91 100 10 999 1012 1.0053data10-100-999-92 100 10 999 965 1.0053data10-100-999-93 100 10 999 944 1.0039data10-100-999-94 100 10 999 919 1.0037data10-100-999-95 100 10 999 962 1.0030data10-100-999-96 100 10 999 962 1.0060data10-100-999-97 100 10 999 976 1.0061data10-100-999-98 100 10 999 952 1.0047data10-100-999-99 100 10 999 1006 1.0040data10-100-999-100 100 10 999 955 1.0038

Table 60: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 446: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-500-1996-1 500 4 1996 973 1.0078data4-500-1996-2 500 4 1996 949 1.0083data4-500-1996-3 500 4 1996 965 1.0077data4-500-1996-4 500 4 1996 936 1.0085data4-500-1996-5 500 4 1996 955 1.0066data4-500-1996-6 500 4 1996 942 1.0114data4-500-1996-7 500 4 1996 957 1.0067data4-500-1996-8 500 4 1996 982 1.0083data4-500-1996-9 500 4 1996 973 1.0079data4-500-1996-10 500 4 1996 945 1.0072data4-500-1996-11 500 4 1996 972 1.0110data4-500-1996-12 500 4 1996 935 0.0321data4-500-1996-13 500 4 1996 946 1.0099data4-500-1996-14 500 4 1996 964 1.0092data4-500-1996-15 500 4 1996 930 1.0116data4-500-1996-16 500 4 1996 953 1.0094data4-500-1996-17 500 4 1996 945 1.0089data4-500-1996-18 500 4 1996 931 1.0096data4-500-1996-19 500 4 1996 954 1.0081data4-500-1996-20 500 4 1996 963 0.3549data4-500-1996-21 500 4 1996 964 1.0069data4-500-1996-22 500 4 1996 946 1.0071data4-500-1996-23 500 4 1996 946 1.0071data4-500-1996-24 500 4 1996 934 0.0792data4-500-1996-25 500 4 1996 966 1.0088data4-500-1996-26 500 4 1996 944 1.0066data4-500-1996-27 500 4 1996 938 1.0087data4-500-1996-28 500 4 1996 981 1.0084data4-500-1996-29 500 4 1996 952 1.0088data4-500-1996-30 500 4 1996 944 1.0086data4-500-1996-31 500 4 1996 965 1.0085data4-500-1996-32 500 4 1996 964 0.0174data4-500-1996-33 500 4 1996 970 1.0075data4-500-1996-34 500 4 1996 947 0.3053data4-500-1996-35 500 4 1996 943 0.5218data4-500-1996-36 500 4 1996 943 1.0121data4-500-1996-37 500 4 1996 952 1.0106data4-500-1996-38 500 4 1996 933 0.1833data4-500-1996-39 500 4 1996 959 1.0076data4-500-1996-40 500 4 1996 924 1.0070data4-500-1996-41 500 4 1996 973 1.0080data4-500-1996-42 500 4 1996 957 0.5052data4-500-1996-43 500 4 1996 968 0.3733data4-500-1996-44 500 4 1996 955 1.0090data4-500-1996-45 500 4 1996 956 1.0080data4-500-1996-46 500 4 1996 946 1.0067data4-500-1996-47 500 4 1996 974 1.0063data4-500-1996-48 500 4 1996 982 1.0075data4-500-1996-49 500 4 1996 989 0.8303data4-500-1996-50 500 4 1996 920 1.0098data4-500-1996-51 500 4 1996 923 0.3736data4-500-1996-52 500 4 1996 948 1.0095data4-500-1996-53 500 4 1996 1025 1.0068data4-500-1996-54 500 4 1996 990 1.0078data4-500-1996-55 500 4 1996 989 0.2915data4-500-1996-56 500 4 1996 970 1.0084data4-500-1996-57 500 4 1996 939 1.0092data4-500-1996-58 500 4 1996 979 1.0068data4-500-1996-59 500 4 1996 962 1.0085data4-500-1996-60 500 4 1996 959 1.0070data4-500-1996-61 500 4 1996 954 0.0207data4-500-1996-62 500 4 1996 978 0.1101data4-500-1996-63 500 4 1996 963 1.0083data4-500-1996-64 500 4 1996 959 1.0083data4-500-1996-65 500 4 1996 979 1.0081data4-500-1996-66 500 4 1996 963 1.0086data4-500-1996-67 500 4 1996 920 1.0068data4-500-1996-68 500 4 1996 978 1.0100data4-500-1996-69 500 4 1996 934 0.0816data4-500-1996-70 500 4 1996 971 1.0079

Table 61: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 447: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-500-1996-71 500 4 1996 972 1.0096data4-500-1996-72 500 4 1996 984 1.0082data4-500-1996-73 500 4 1996 985 0.0178data4-500-1996-74 500 4 1996 957 1.0065data4-500-1996-75 500 4 1996 968 1.0095data4-500-1996-76 500 4 1996 949 0.0413data4-500-1996-77 500 4 1996 969 1.0074data4-500-1996-78 500 4 1996 936 1.0087data4-500-1996-79 500 4 1996 991 0.0470data4-500-1996-80 500 4 1996 978 1.0091data4-500-1996-81 500 4 1996 987 1.0072data4-500-1996-82 500 4 1996 956 0.7996data4-500-1996-83 500 4 1996 974 1.0099data4-500-1996-84 500 4 1996 947 1.0097data4-500-1996-85 500 4 1996 970 1.0074data4-500-1996-86 500 4 1996 977 0.7792data4-500-1996-87 500 4 1996 960 1.0061data4-500-1996-88 500 4 1996 975 1.0088data4-500-1996-89 500 4 1996 967 1.0062data4-500-1996-90 500 4 1996 955 1.0067data4-500-1996-91 500 4 1996 956 1.0072data4-500-1996-92 500 4 1996 957 1.0074data4-500-1996-93 500 4 1996 959 1.0078data4-500-1996-94 500 4 1996 966 1.0078data4-500-1996-95 500 4 1996 947 1.0109data4-500-1996-96 500 4 1996 993 1.0075data4-500-1996-97 500 4 1996 947 1.0107data4-500-1996-98 500 4 1996 965 1.0075data4-500-1996-99 500 4 1996 985 1.0087data4-500-1996-100 500 4 1996 955 1.0082data4-500-1997-1 500 4 1997 946 0.1197data4-500-1997-2 500 4 1997 965 0.6821data4-500-1997-3 500 4 1997 975 1.0075data4-500-1997-4 500 4 1997 986 1.0078data4-500-1997-5 500 4 1997 925 1.0097data4-500-1997-6 500 4 1997 954 0.0177data4-500-1997-7 500 4 1997 984 0.2114data4-500-1997-8 500 4 1997 979 1.0065data4-500-1997-9 500 4 1997 954 1.0081data4-500-1997-10 500 4 1997 930 0.4206data4-500-1997-11 500 4 1997 989 1.0071data4-500-1997-12 500 4 1997 967 1.0077data4-500-1997-13 500 4 1997 930 0.0430data4-500-1997-14 500 4 1997 944 1.0095data4-500-1997-15 500 4 1997 951 1.0085data4-500-1997-16 500 4 1997 983 1.0093data4-500-1997-17 500 4 1997 963 0.0174data4-500-1997-18 500 4 1997 943 0.0677data4-500-1997-19 500 4 1997 964 1.0083data4-500-1997-20 500 4 1997 979 1.0075data4-500-1997-21 500 4 1997 992 1.0079data4-500-1997-22 500 4 1997 965 0.2764data4-500-1997-23 500 4 1997 974 1.0067data4-500-1997-24 500 4 1997 958 1.0071data4-500-1997-25 500 4 1997 986 1.0089data4-500-1997-26 500 4 1997 966 1.0091data4-500-1997-27 500 4 1997 961 1.0088data4-500-1997-28 500 4 1997 959 0.5909data4-500-1997-29 500 4 1997 983 1.0080data4-500-1997-30 500 4 1997 1011 0.1007data4-500-1997-31 500 4 1997 971 1.0071data4-500-1997-32 500 4 1997 961 1.0091data4-500-1997-33 500 4 1997 947 1.0081data4-500-1997-34 500 4 1997 957 1.0082data4-500-1997-35 500 4 1997 973 1.0105data4-500-1997-36 500 4 1997 984 1.0089data4-500-1997-37 500 4 1997 980 1.0106data4-500-1997-38 500 4 1997 974 1.0087data4-500-1997-39 500 4 1997 965 1.0084data4-500-1997-40 500 4 1997 958 1.0079

Table 62: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 448: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-500-1997-41 500 4 1997 957 1.0084data4-500-1997-42 500 4 1997 980 1.0084data4-500-1997-43 500 4 1997 962 1.0080data4-500-1997-44 500 4 1997 957 1.0067data4-500-1997-45 500 4 1997 968 1.0096data4-500-1997-46 500 4 1997 972 1.0072data4-500-1997-47 500 4 1997 975 1.0087data4-500-1997-48 500 4 1997 948 1.0093data4-500-1997-49 500 4 1997 944 1.0079data4-500-1997-50 500 4 1997 949 1.0080data4-500-1997-51 500 4 1997 972 1.0082data4-500-1997-52 500 4 1997 954 1.0075data4-500-1997-53 500 4 1997 969 1.0081data4-500-1997-54 500 4 1997 929 0.0415data4-500-1997-55 500 4 1997 974 0.6763data4-500-1997-56 500 4 1997 943 1.0073data4-500-1997-57 500 4 1997 954 1.0079data4-500-1997-58 500 4 1997 978 1.0087data4-500-1997-59 500 4 1997 936 1.0094data4-500-1997-60 500 4 1997 978 1.0074data4-500-1997-61 500 4 1997 979 1.0080data4-500-1997-62 500 4 1997 958 1.0070data4-500-1997-63 500 4 1997 950 1.0086data4-500-1997-64 500 4 1997 953 1.0069data4-500-1997-65 500 4 1997 963 1.0076data4-500-1997-66 500 4 1997 982 1.0078data4-500-1997-67 500 4 1997 940 1.0087data4-500-1997-68 500 4 1997 1007 0.5532data4-500-1997-69 500 4 1997 978 1.0094data4-500-1997-70 500 4 1997 970 0.3045data4-500-1997-71 500 4 1997 963 1.0067data4-500-1997-72 500 4 1997 941 1.0092data4-500-1997-73 500 4 1997 982 1.0082data4-500-1997-74 500 4 1997 977 1.0091data4-500-1997-75 500 4 1997 961 1.0088data4-500-1997-76 500 4 1997 979 1.0083data4-500-1997-77 500 4 1997 972 1.0085data4-500-1997-78 500 4 1997 927 1.0094data4-500-1997-79 500 4 1997 964 1.0076data4-500-1997-80 500 4 1997 986 1.0100data4-500-1997-81 500 4 1997 960 1.0083data4-500-1997-82 500 4 1997 965 1.0070data4-500-1997-83 500 4 1997 958 1.0093data4-500-1997-84 500 4 1997 952 1.0073data4-500-1997-85 500 4 1997 967 1.0103data4-500-1997-86 500 4 1997 957 0.9136data4-500-1997-87 500 4 1997 951 1.0078data4-500-1997-88 500 4 1997 968 1.0095data4-500-1997-89 500 4 1997 962 1.0093data4-500-1997-90 500 4 1997 962 1.0102data4-500-1997-91 500 4 1997 951 0.0691data4-500-1997-92 500 4 1997 943 1.0108data4-500-1997-93 500 4 1997 996 0.1142data4-500-1997-94 500 4 1997 974 1.0072data4-500-1997-95 500 4 1997 957 1.0079data4-500-1997-96 500 4 1997 977 0.0613data4-500-1997-97 500 4 1997 978 1.0067data4-500-1997-98 500 4 1997 970 1.0084data4-500-1997-99 500 4 1997 940 1.0075data4-500-1997-100 500 4 1997 943 1.0084data4-500-1998-1 500 4 1998 961 1.0093data4-500-1998-2 500 4 1998 998 1.0066data4-500-1998-3 500 4 1998 965 0.8836data4-500-1998-4 500 4 1998 998 1.0082data4-500-1998-5 500 4 1998 982 1.0078data4-500-1998-6 500 4 1998 953 0.8504data4-500-1998-7 500 4 1998 993 1.0075data4-500-1998-8 500 4 1998 959 1.0086data4-500-1998-9 500 4 1998 969 0.1528data4-500-1998-10 500 4 1998 982 1.0090

Table 63: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 449: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-500-1998-11 500 4 1998 928 1.0086data4-500-1998-12 500 4 1998 970 0.0180data4-500-1998-13 500 4 1998 983 1.0097data4-500-1998-14 500 4 1998 951 1.0083data4-500-1998-15 500 4 1998 974 1.0086data4-500-1998-16 500 4 1998 955 1.0092data4-500-1998-17 500 4 1998 960 0.0181data4-500-1998-18 500 4 1998 945 1.0089data4-500-1998-19 500 4 1998 968 0.0291data4-500-1998-20 500 4 1998 966 1.0096data4-500-1998-21 500 4 1998 951 1.0065data4-500-1998-22 500 4 1998 956 0.0474data4-500-1998-23 500 4 1998 956 1.0081data4-500-1998-24 500 4 1998 981 1.0077data4-500-1998-25 500 4 1998 941 1.0059data4-500-1998-26 500 4 1998 962 1.0099data4-500-1998-27 500 4 1998 927 1.0088data4-500-1998-28 500 4 1998 954 1.0074data4-500-1998-29 500 4 1998 957 1.0085data4-500-1998-30 500 4 1998 961 1.0086data4-500-1998-31 500 4 1998 961 1.0097data4-500-1998-32 500 4 1998 974 1.0091data4-500-1998-33 500 4 1998 964 1.0070data4-500-1998-34 500 4 1998 960 1.0082data4-500-1998-35 500 4 1998 1011 1.0081data4-500-1998-36 500 4 1998 941 1.0089data4-500-1998-37 500 4 1998 951 1.0094data4-500-1998-38 500 4 1998 972 0.7821data4-500-1998-39 500 4 1998 960 1.0085data4-500-1998-40 500 4 1998 961 1.0067data4-500-1998-41 500 4 1998 971 1.0081data4-500-1998-42 500 4 1998 984 0.1118data4-500-1998-43 500 4 1998 957 0.7792data4-500-1998-44 500 4 1998 928 0.0172data4-500-1998-45 500 4 1998 994 1.0096data4-500-1998-46 500 4 1998 952 1.0104data4-500-1998-47 500 4 1998 997 1.0106data4-500-1998-48 500 4 1998 962 1.0066data4-500-1998-49 500 4 1998 948 1.0073data4-500-1998-50 500 4 1998 962 1.0096data4-500-1998-51 500 4 1998 992 1.0102data4-500-1998-52 500 4 1998 947 1.0072data4-500-1998-53 500 4 1998 994 1.0116data4-500-1998-54 500 4 1998 953 0.1068data4-500-1998-55 500 4 1998 948 1.0067data4-500-1998-56 500 4 1998 962 1.0062data4-500-1998-57 500 4 1998 959 0.3371data4-500-1998-58 500 4 1998 978 1.0119data4-500-1998-59 500 4 1998 972 1.0076data4-500-1998-60 500 4 1998 945 0.0173data4-500-1998-61 500 4 1998 978 1.0075data4-500-1998-62 500 4 1998 971 1.0073data4-500-1998-63 500 4 1998 968 1.0086data4-500-1998-64 500 4 1998 964 1.0082data4-500-1998-65 500 4 1998 969 1.0090data4-500-1998-66 500 4 1998 936 0.2273data4-500-1998-67 500 4 1998 957 1.0094data4-500-1998-68 500 4 1998 955 1.0096data4-500-1998-69 500 4 1998 982 1.0084data4-500-1998-70 500 4 1998 934 1.0077data4-500-1998-71 500 4 1998 930 0.3123data4-500-1998-72 500 4 1998 992 1.0080data4-500-1998-73 500 4 1998 962 0.0375data4-500-1998-74 500 4 1998 952 1.0069data4-500-1998-75 500 4 1998 969 1.0081data4-500-1998-76 500 4 1998 955 1.0085data4-500-1998-77 500 4 1998 950 0.1717data4-500-1998-78 500 4 1998 960 1.0084data4-500-1998-79 500 4 1998 985 1.0069data4-500-1998-80 500 4 1998 937 0.5944

Table 64: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 450: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-500-1998-81 500 4 1998 938 0.2061data4-500-1998-82 500 4 1998 965 1.0093data4-500-1998-83 500 4 1998 971 1.0086data4-500-1998-84 500 4 1998 966 0.3856data4-500-1998-85 500 4 1998 943 1.0086data4-500-1998-86 500 4 1998 948 1.0072data4-500-1998-87 500 4 1998 978 0.3347data4-500-1998-88 500 4 1998 955 1.0086data4-500-1998-89 500 4 1998 967 1.0075data4-500-1998-90 500 4 1998 971 1.0096data4-500-1998-91 500 4 1998 927 0.0176data4-500-1998-92 500 4 1998 974 1.0092data4-500-1998-93 500 4 1998 973 1.0082data4-500-1998-94 500 4 1998 959 1.0068data4-500-1998-95 500 4 1998 974 1.0084data4-500-1998-96 500 4 1998 978 1.0090data4-500-1998-97 500 4 1998 945 0.4687data4-500-1998-98 500 4 1998 949 0.6560data4-500-1998-99 500 4 1998 947 0.0250data4-500-1998-100 500 4 1998 998 1.0094data4-500-1999-1 500 4 1999 960 1.0072data4-500-1999-2 500 4 1999 953 1.0074data4-500-1999-3 500 4 1999 959 1.0090data4-500-1999-4 500 4 1999 995 0.0225data4-500-1999-5 500 4 1999 980 0.0174data4-500-1999-6 500 4 1999 967 0.5089data4-500-1999-7 500 4 1999 982 1.0077data4-500-1999-8 500 4 1999 971 0.9751data4-500-1999-9 500 4 1999 977 1.0096data4-500-1999-10 500 4 1999 959 1.0086data4-500-1999-11 500 4 1999 965 1.0069data4-500-1999-12 500 4 1999 966 1.0086data4-500-1999-13 500 4 1999 979 0.0457data4-500-1999-14 500 4 1999 957 1.0101data4-500-1999-15 500 4 1999 976 0.2780data4-500-1999-16 500 4 1999 955 1.0071data4-500-1999-17 500 4 1999 947 1.0074data4-500-1999-18 500 4 1999 953 0.0518data4-500-1999-19 500 4 1999 955 1.0110data4-500-1999-20 500 4 1999 930 1.0076data4-500-1999-21 500 4 1999 966 1.0109data4-500-1999-22 500 4 1999 950 1.0075data4-500-1999-23 500 4 1999 948 1.0087data4-500-1999-24 500 4 1999 952 1.0090data4-500-1999-25 500 4 1999 972 1.0089data4-500-1999-26 500 4 1999 1008 1.0081data4-500-1999-27 500 4 1999 915 1.0066data4-500-1999-28 500 4 1999 985 1.0067data4-500-1999-29 500 4 1999 947 0.3750data4-500-1999-30 500 4 1999 1002 1.0070data4-500-1999-31 500 4 1999 961 1.0074data4-500-1999-32 500 4 1999 939 0.0171data4-500-1999-33 500 4 1999 960 1.0097data4-500-1999-34 500 4 1999 930 0.1898data4-500-1999-35 500 4 1999 965 1.0069data4-500-1999-36 500 4 1999 972 1.0085data4-500-1999-37 500 4 1999 985 1.0082data4-500-1999-38 500 4 1999 961 1.0101data4-500-1999-39 500 4 1999 950 1.0084data4-500-1999-40 500 4 1999 981 1.0090data4-500-1999-41 500 4 1999 949 1.0083data4-500-1999-42 500 4 1999 979 1.0084data4-500-1999-43 500 4 1999 971 1.0077data4-500-1999-44 500 4 1999 955 0.2685data4-500-1999-45 500 4 1999 966 1.0099data4-500-1999-46 500 4 1999 942 1.0079data4-500-1999-47 500 4 1999 999 0.0847data4-500-1999-48 500 4 1999 1016 1.0081data4-500-1999-49 500 4 1999 958 1.0085data4-500-1999-50 500 4 1999 955 1.0085

Table 65: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 451: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-500-1999-51 500 4 1999 991 1.0071data4-500-1999-52 500 4 1999 974 0.0201data4-500-1999-53 500 4 1999 967 0.8173data4-500-1999-54 500 4 1999 973 1.0078data4-500-1999-55 500 4 1999 961 1.0066data4-500-1999-56 500 4 1999 936 1.0086data4-500-1999-57 500 4 1999 1003 0.4779data4-500-1999-58 500 4 1999 933 0.1320data4-500-1999-59 500 4 1999 950 1.0092data4-500-1999-60 500 4 1999 984 1.0090data4-500-1999-61 500 4 1999 948 1.0078data4-500-1999-62 500 4 1999 942 1.0071data4-500-1999-63 500 4 1999 950 1.0090data4-500-1999-64 500 4 1999 963 1.0081data4-500-1999-65 500 4 1999 983 1.0078data4-500-1999-66 500 4 1999 996 0.0175data4-500-1999-67 500 4 1999 964 1.0074data4-500-1999-68 500 4 1999 977 1.0091data4-500-1999-69 500 4 1999 958 0.1045data4-500-1999-70 500 4 1999 979 1.0083data4-500-1999-71 500 4 1999 943 1.0081data4-500-1999-72 500 4 1999 979 1.0096data4-500-1999-73 500 4 1999 984 1.0091data4-500-1999-74 500 4 1999 957 0.0177data4-500-1999-75 500 4 1999 964 1.0098data4-500-1999-76 500 4 1999 941 1.0082data4-500-1999-77 500 4 1999 981 1.0078data4-500-1999-78 500 4 1999 996 1.0100data4-500-1999-79 500 4 1999 985 0.1840data4-500-1999-80 500 4 1999 927 0.1278data4-500-1999-81 500 4 1999 1007 1.0072data4-500-1999-82 500 4 1999 977 0.0813data4-500-1999-83 500 4 1999 975 0.0583data4-500-1999-84 500 4 1999 968 1.0069data4-500-1999-85 500 4 1999 961 1.0083data4-500-1999-86 500 4 1999 984 1.0096data4-500-1999-87 500 4 1999 978 0.4203data4-500-1999-88 500 4 1999 938 1.0089data4-500-1999-89 500 4 1999 968 1.0089data4-500-1999-90 500 4 1999 966 1.0089data4-500-1999-91 500 4 1999 999 1.0071data4-500-1999-92 500 4 1999 983 1.0085data4-500-1999-93 500 4 1999 960 1.0098data4-500-1999-94 500 4 1999 993 1.0075data4-500-1999-95 500 4 1999 985 1.0096data4-500-1999-96 500 4 1999 1008 1.0102data4-500-1999-97 500 4 1999 976 1.0070data4-500-1999-98 500 4 1999 929 1.0077data4-500-1999-99 500 4 1999 926 0.7425data4-500-1999-100 500 4 1999 987 1.0073data7-500-3493-1 500 7 3493 2339 1.0163data7-500-3493-2 500 7 3493 2317 1.0128data7-500-3493-3 500 7 3493 2322 1.0110data7-500-3493-4 500 7 3493 2328 1.0136data7-500-3493-5 500 7 3493 2327 1.0104data7-500-3493-6 500 7 3493 2379 1.0103data7-500-3493-7 500 7 3493 2359 1.0143data7-500-3493-8 500 7 3493 2394 1.0124data7-500-3493-9 500 7 3493 2346 1.0126data7-500-3493-10 500 7 3493 2333 1.0156data7-500-3493-11 500 7 3493 2350 1.0142data7-500-3493-12 500 7 3493 2363 1.0103data7-500-3493-13 500 7 3493 2374 1.0117data7-500-3493-14 500 7 3493 2272 1.0134data7-500-3493-15 500 7 3493 2348 1.0133data7-500-3493-16 500 7 3493 2324 1.0102data7-500-3493-17 500 7 3493 2361 1.0154data7-500-3493-18 500 7 3493 2349 1.0146data7-500-3493-19 500 7 3493 2261 1.0106data7-500-3493-20 500 7 3493 2289 1.0136

Table 66: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 452: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-500-3493-21 500 7 3493 2363 1.0125data7-500-3493-22 500 7 3493 2308 1.0097data7-500-3493-23 500 7 3493 2328 1.0142data7-500-3493-24 500 7 3493 2302 1.0146data7-500-3493-25 500 7 3493 2352 1.0127data7-500-3493-26 500 7 3493 2313 1.0142data7-500-3493-27 500 7 3493 2319 1.0116data7-500-3493-28 500 7 3493 2345 1.0155data7-500-3493-29 500 7 3493 2321 1.0120data7-500-3493-30 500 7 3493 2316 1.0131data7-500-3493-31 500 7 3493 2362 1.0150data7-500-3493-32 500 7 3493 2306 1.0111data7-500-3493-33 500 7 3493 2316 1.0142data7-500-3493-34 500 7 3493 2345 1.0125data7-500-3493-35 500 7 3493 2303 1.0159data7-500-3493-36 500 7 3493 2301 1.0110data7-500-3493-37 500 7 3493 2336 1.0138data7-500-3493-38 500 7 3493 2325 1.0144data7-500-3493-39 500 7 3493 2362 1.0106data7-500-3493-40 500 7 3493 2330 1.0101data7-500-3493-41 500 7 3493 2318 1.0154data7-500-3493-42 500 7 3493 2280 1.0155data7-500-3493-43 500 7 3493 2338 1.0165data7-500-3493-44 500 7 3493 2352 1.0131data7-500-3493-45 500 7 3493 2397 1.0098data7-500-3493-46 500 7 3493 2293 1.0112data7-500-3493-47 500 7 3493 2407 1.0135data7-500-3493-48 500 7 3493 2318 1.0136data7-500-3493-49 500 7 3493 2281 1.0124data7-500-3493-50 500 7 3493 2291 1.0112data7-500-3493-51 500 7 3493 2341 1.0106data7-500-3493-52 500 7 3493 2381 1.0160data7-500-3493-53 500 7 3493 2402 1.0110data7-500-3493-54 500 7 3493 2223 1.0153data7-500-3493-55 500 7 3493 2310 1.0186data7-500-3493-56 500 7 3493 2327 1.0182data7-500-3493-57 500 7 3493 2272 1.0136data7-500-3493-58 500 7 3493 2249 1.0165data7-500-3493-59 500 7 3493 2337 1.0129data7-500-3493-60 500 7 3493 2304 1.0112data7-500-3493-61 500 7 3493 2306 1.0126data7-500-3493-62 500 7 3493 2299 1.0117data7-500-3493-63 500 7 3493 2355 1.0139data7-500-3493-64 500 7 3493 2319 1.0138data7-500-3493-65 500 7 3493 2325 1.0143data7-500-3493-66 500 7 3493 2325 1.0158data7-500-3493-67 500 7 3493 2252 1.0133data7-500-3493-68 500 7 3493 2335 1.0140data7-500-3493-69 500 7 3493 2326 1.0116data7-500-3493-70 500 7 3493 2323 1.0150data7-500-3493-71 500 7 3493 2359 1.0104data7-500-3493-72 500 7 3493 2284 1.0189data7-500-3493-73 500 7 3493 2332 1.0169data7-500-3493-74 500 7 3493 2262 1.0179data7-500-3493-75 500 7 3493 2293 1.0155data7-500-3493-76 500 7 3493 2310 1.0181data7-500-3493-77 500 7 3493 2319 1.0174data7-500-3493-78 500 7 3493 2276 1.0114data7-500-3493-79 500 7 3493 2289 1.0150data7-500-3493-80 500 7 3493 2301 1.0137data7-500-3493-81 500 7 3493 2373 1.0157data7-500-3493-82 500 7 3493 2317 1.0102data7-500-3493-83 500 7 3493 2302 1.0132data7-500-3493-84 500 7 3493 2360 1.0160data7-500-3493-85 500 7 3493 2245 1.0129data7-500-3493-86 500 7 3493 2368 1.0111data7-500-3493-87 500 7 3493 2271 1.0129data7-500-3493-88 500 7 3493 2342 1.0151data7-500-3493-89 500 7 3493 2307 1.0137data7-500-3493-90 500 7 3493 2296 1.0199

Table 67: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 453: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-500-3493-91 500 7 3493 2265 1.0125data7-500-3493-92 500 7 3493 2331 1.0151data7-500-3493-93 500 7 3493 2328 1.0109data7-500-3493-94 500 7 3493 2363 1.0149data7-500-3493-95 500 7 3493 2279 1.0144data7-500-3493-96 500 7 3493 2353 1.0123data7-500-3493-97 500 7 3493 2370 1.0149data7-500-3493-98 500 7 3493 2323 1.0126data7-500-3493-99 500 7 3493 2294 1.0127data7-500-3493-100 500 7 3493 2300 1.0155data7-500-3494-1 500 7 3494 2327 1.0170data7-500-3494-2 500 7 3494 2309 1.0121data7-500-3494-3 500 7 3494 2310 1.0138data7-500-3494-4 500 7 3494 2330 1.0135data7-500-3494-5 500 7 3494 2359 1.0160data7-500-3494-6 500 7 3494 2400 1.0123data7-500-3494-7 500 7 3494 2319 1.0123data7-500-3494-8 500 7 3494 2325 1.0132data7-500-3494-9 500 7 3494 2241 1.0140data7-500-3494-10 500 7 3494 2320 1.0116data7-500-3494-11 500 7 3494 2237 1.0111data7-500-3494-12 500 7 3494 2382 1.0144data7-500-3494-13 500 7 3494 2299 1.0104data7-500-3494-14 500 7 3494 2327 1.0173data7-500-3494-15 500 7 3494 2373 1.0115data7-500-3494-16 500 7 3494 2380 1.0171data7-500-3494-17 500 7 3494 2309 1.0135data7-500-3494-18 500 7 3494 2378 1.0115data7-500-3494-19 500 7 3494 2315 1.0126data7-500-3494-20 500 7 3494 2368 1.0178data7-500-3494-21 500 7 3494 2388 1.0114data7-500-3494-22 500 7 3494 2328 1.0135data7-500-3494-23 500 7 3494 2320 1.0120data7-500-3494-24 500 7 3494 2321 1.0123data7-500-3494-25 500 7 3494 2292 1.0147data7-500-3494-26 500 7 3494 2362 1.0169data7-500-3494-27 500 7 3494 2296 1.0121data7-500-3494-28 500 7 3494 2291 1.0123data7-500-3494-29 500 7 3494 2270 1.0109data7-500-3494-30 500 7 3494 2328 1.0163data7-500-3494-31 500 7 3494 2333 1.0173data7-500-3494-32 500 7 3494 2381 1.0109data7-500-3494-33 500 7 3494 2297 1.0144data7-500-3494-34 500 7 3494 2329 1.0125data7-500-3494-35 500 7 3494 2298 1.0153data7-500-3494-36 500 7 3494 2328 1.0150data7-500-3494-37 500 7 3494 2340 1.0185data7-500-3494-38 500 7 3494 2319 1.0126data7-500-3494-39 500 7 3494 2382 1.0133data7-500-3494-40 500 7 3494 2350 1.0123data7-500-3494-41 500 7 3494 2379 1.0167data7-500-3494-42 500 7 3494 2330 1.0109data7-500-3494-43 500 7 3494 2357 1.0159data7-500-3494-44 500 7 3494 2320 1.0169data7-500-3494-45 500 7 3494 2338 1.0161data7-500-3494-46 500 7 3494 2305 1.0104data7-500-3494-47 500 7 3494 2368 1.0168data7-500-3494-48 500 7 3494 2352 1.0152data7-500-3494-49 500 7 3494 2280 1.0106data7-500-3494-50 500 7 3494 2320 1.0132data7-500-3494-51 500 7 3494 2397 1.0128data7-500-3494-52 500 7 3494 2309 1.0140data7-500-3494-53 500 7 3494 2274 1.0167data7-500-3494-54 500 7 3494 2321 1.0148data7-500-3494-55 500 7 3494 2337 1.0100data7-500-3494-56 500 7 3494 2321 1.0136data7-500-3494-57 500 7 3494 2340 1.0109data7-500-3494-58 500 7 3494 2341 1.0153data7-500-3494-59 500 7 3494 2312 1.0124data7-500-3494-60 500 7 3494 2308 1.0121

Table 68: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 454: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-500-3494-61 500 7 3494 2388 1.0113data7-500-3494-62 500 7 3494 2329 1.0138data7-500-3494-63 500 7 3494 2316 1.0116data7-500-3494-64 500 7 3494 2235 1.0092data7-500-3494-65 500 7 3494 2349 1.0147data7-500-3494-66 500 7 3494 2297 1.0140data7-500-3494-67 500 7 3494 2283 1.0142data7-500-3494-68 500 7 3494 2328 1.0146data7-500-3494-69 500 7 3494 2343 1.0159data7-500-3494-70 500 7 3494 2353 1.0107data7-500-3494-71 500 7 3494 2340 1.0141data7-500-3494-72 500 7 3494 2388 1.0128data7-500-3494-73 500 7 3494 2268 1.0148data7-500-3494-74 500 7 3494 2385 1.0155data7-500-3494-75 500 7 3494 2346 1.0133data7-500-3494-76 500 7 3494 2367 1.0128data7-500-3494-77 500 7 3494 2293 1.0113data7-500-3494-78 500 7 3494 2321 1.0161data7-500-3494-79 500 7 3494 2403 1.0170data7-500-3494-80 500 7 3494 2283 1.0166data7-500-3494-81 500 7 3494 2343 1.0144data7-500-3494-82 500 7 3494 2293 1.0129data7-500-3494-83 500 7 3494 2366 1.0104data7-500-3494-84 500 7 3494 2364 1.0159data7-500-3494-85 500 7 3494 2285 1.0145data7-500-3494-86 500 7 3494 2377 1.0146data7-500-3494-87 500 7 3494 2384 1.0100data7-500-3494-88 500 7 3494 2273 1.0113data7-500-3494-89 500 7 3494 2350 1.0177data7-500-3494-90 500 7 3494 2298 1.0104data7-500-3494-91 500 7 3494 2296 1.0147data7-500-3494-92 500 7 3494 2301 1.0157data7-500-3494-93 500 7 3494 2289 1.0114data7-500-3494-94 500 7 3494 2394 1.0122data7-500-3494-95 500 7 3494 2325 1.0156data7-500-3494-96 500 7 3494 2339 1.0155data7-500-3494-97 500 7 3494 2314 1.0159data7-500-3494-98 500 7 3494 2284 1.0122data7-500-3494-99 500 7 3494 2284 1.0161data7-500-3494-100 500 7 3494 2291 1.0115data7-500-3495-1 500 7 3495 2348 1.0105data7-500-3495-2 500 7 3495 2387 1.0112data7-500-3495-3 500 7 3495 2323 1.0095data7-500-3495-4 500 7 3495 2287 1.0138data7-500-3495-5 500 7 3495 2388 1.0113data7-500-3495-6 500 7 3495 2344 1.0125data7-500-3495-7 500 7 3495 2363 1.0145data7-500-3495-8 500 7 3495 2333 1.0152data7-500-3495-9 500 7 3495 2363 1.0105data7-500-3495-10 500 7 3495 2277 1.0207data7-500-3495-11 500 7 3495 2344 1.0130data7-500-3495-12 500 7 3495 2327 1.0193data7-500-3495-13 500 7 3495 2322 1.0142data7-500-3495-14 500 7 3495 2389 1.0147data7-500-3495-15 500 7 3495 2309 1.0134data7-500-3495-16 500 7 3495 2316 1.0142data7-500-3495-17 500 7 3495 2296 1.0124data7-500-3495-18 500 7 3495 2316 1.0127data7-500-3495-19 500 7 3495 2396 1.0122data7-500-3495-20 500 7 3495 2322 1.0164data7-500-3495-21 500 7 3495 2376 1.0125data7-500-3495-22 500 7 3495 2297 1.0273data7-500-3495-23 500 7 3495 2309 1.0151data7-500-3495-24 500 7 3495 2260 1.0121data7-500-3495-25 500 7 3495 2315 1.0091data7-500-3495-26 500 7 3495 2279 1.0182data7-500-3495-27 500 7 3495 2379 1.0146data7-500-3495-28 500 7 3495 2347 1.0135data7-500-3495-29 500 7 3495 2346 1.0155data7-500-3495-30 500 7 3495 2308 1.0102

Table 69: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 455: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-500-3495-31 500 7 3495 2354 1.0190data7-500-3495-32 500 7 3495 2397 1.0129data7-500-3495-33 500 7 3495 2358 1.0130data7-500-3495-34 500 7 3495 2340 1.0124data7-500-3495-35 500 7 3495 2332 1.0138data7-500-3495-36 500 7 3495 2346 1.0144data7-500-3495-37 500 7 3495 2283 1.0123data7-500-3495-38 500 7 3495 2326 1.0148data7-500-3495-39 500 7 3495 2383 1.0119data7-500-3495-40 500 7 3495 2344 1.0159data7-500-3495-41 500 7 3495 2310 1.0164data7-500-3495-42 500 7 3495 2331 1.0109data7-500-3495-43 500 7 3495 2300 1.0113data7-500-3495-44 500 7 3495 2341 1.0219data7-500-3495-45 500 7 3495 2339 1.0146data7-500-3495-46 500 7 3495 2309 1.0098data7-500-3495-47 500 7 3495 2281 1.0155data7-500-3495-48 500 7 3495 2404 1.0166data7-500-3495-49 500 7 3495 2318 1.0103data7-500-3495-50 500 7 3495 2233 1.0120data7-500-3495-51 500 7 3495 2361 1.0119data7-500-3495-52 500 7 3495 2345 1.0173data7-500-3495-53 500 7 3495 2331 1.0118data7-500-3495-54 500 7 3495 2305 1.0130data7-500-3495-55 500 7 3495 2356 1.0116data7-500-3495-56 500 7 3495 2394 1.0122data7-500-3495-57 500 7 3495 2280 1.0110data7-500-3495-58 500 7 3495 2307 1.0147data7-500-3495-59 500 7 3495 2321 1.0151data7-500-3495-60 500 7 3495 2366 1.0127data7-500-3495-61 500 7 3495 2368 1.0145data7-500-3495-62 500 7 3495 2372 1.0157data7-500-3495-63 500 7 3495 2334 1.0158data7-500-3495-64 500 7 3495 2327 1.0115data7-500-3495-65 500 7 3495 2305 1.0107data7-500-3495-66 500 7 3495 2303 1.0167data7-500-3495-67 500 7 3495 2341 1.0166data7-500-3495-68 500 7 3495 2332 1.0109data7-500-3495-69 500 7 3495 2362 1.0116data7-500-3495-70 500 7 3495 2304 1.0107data7-500-3495-71 500 7 3495 2316 1.0131data7-500-3495-72 500 7 3495 2347 1.0168data7-500-3495-73 500 7 3495 2303 1.0103data7-500-3495-74 500 7 3495 2319 1.0275data7-500-3495-75 500 7 3495 2361 1.0103data7-500-3495-76 500 7 3495 2341 1.0122data7-500-3495-77 500 7 3495 2360 1.0141data7-500-3495-78 500 7 3495 2353 1.0125data7-500-3495-79 500 7 3495 2323 1.0194data7-500-3495-80 500 7 3495 2350 1.0111data7-500-3495-81 500 7 3495 2335 1.0098data7-500-3495-82 500 7 3495 2349 1.0097data7-500-3495-83 500 7 3495 2285 1.0128data7-500-3495-84 500 7 3495 2363 1.0164data7-500-3495-85 500 7 3495 2309 1.0154data7-500-3495-86 500 7 3495 2349 1.0158data7-500-3495-87 500 7 3495 2300 1.0170data7-500-3495-88 500 7 3495 2351 1.0115data7-500-3495-89 500 7 3495 2375 1.0132data7-500-3495-90 500 7 3495 2333 1.0133data7-500-3495-91 500 7 3495 2271 1.0164data7-500-3495-92 500 7 3495 2397 1.0133data7-500-3495-93 500 7 3495 2399 1.0103data7-500-3495-94 500 7 3495 2376 1.0116data7-500-3495-95 500 7 3495 2321 1.0154data7-500-3495-96 500 7 3495 2398 1.0140data7-500-3495-97 500 7 3495 2327 1.0130data7-500-3495-98 500 7 3495 2285 1.0177data7-500-3495-99 500 7 3495 2355 1.0153data7-500-3495-100 500 7 3495 2354 1.0105

Table 70: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 456: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-500-3496-1 500 7 3496 2317 1.0143data7-500-3496-2 500 7 3496 2306 1.0147data7-500-3496-3 500 7 3496 2351 1.0099data7-500-3496-4 500 7 3496 2277 1.0200data7-500-3496-5 500 7 3496 2341 1.0151data7-500-3496-6 500 7 3496 2361 1.0168data7-500-3496-7 500 7 3496 2296 1.0101data7-500-3496-8 500 7 3496 2356 1.0125data7-500-3496-9 500 7 3496 2314 1.0091data7-500-3496-10 500 7 3496 2261 1.0099data7-500-3496-11 500 7 3496 2317 1.0139data7-500-3496-12 500 7 3496 2359 1.0151data7-500-3496-13 500 7 3496 2355 1.0171data7-500-3496-14 500 7 3496 2406 1.0150data7-500-3496-15 500 7 3496 2269 1.0155data7-500-3496-16 500 7 3496 2258 1.0145data7-500-3496-17 500 7 3496 2324 1.0122data7-500-3496-18 500 7 3496 2347 1.0149data7-500-3496-19 500 7 3496 2359 1.0121data7-500-3496-20 500 7 3496 2287 1.0123data7-500-3496-21 500 7 3496 2334 1.0113data7-500-3496-22 500 7 3496 2411 1.0115data7-500-3496-23 500 7 3496 2337 1.0136data7-500-3496-24 500 7 3496 2299 1.0180data7-500-3496-25 500 7 3496 2315 1.0151data7-500-3496-26 500 7 3496 2318 1.0109data7-500-3496-27 500 7 3496 2361 1.0216data7-500-3496-28 500 7 3496 2341 1.0157data7-500-3496-29 500 7 3496 2291 1.0098data7-500-3496-30 500 7 3496 2284 1.0180data7-500-3496-31 500 7 3496 2411 1.0114data7-500-3496-32 500 7 3496 2354 1.0097data7-500-3496-33 500 7 3496 2364 1.0149data7-500-3496-34 500 7 3496 2399 1.0167data7-500-3496-35 500 7 3496 2302 1.0103data7-500-3496-36 500 7 3496 2362 1.0125data7-500-3496-37 500 7 3496 2402 1.0145data7-500-3496-38 500 7 3496 2355 1.0102data7-500-3496-39 500 7 3496 2327 1.0156data7-500-3496-40 500 7 3496 2291 1.0119data7-500-3496-41 500 7 3496 2308 1.0207data7-500-3496-42 500 7 3496 2312 1.0112data7-500-3496-43 500 7 3496 2368 1.0140data7-500-3496-44 500 7 3496 2374 1.0161data7-500-3496-45 500 7 3496 2307 1.0107data7-500-3496-46 500 7 3496 2358 1.0103data7-500-3496-47 500 7 3496 2310 1.0102data7-500-3496-48 500 7 3496 2353 1.0110data7-500-3496-49 500 7 3496 2367 1.0168data7-500-3496-50 500 7 3496 2324 1.0167data7-500-3496-51 500 7 3496 2361 1.0149data7-500-3496-52 500 7 3496 2260 1.0119data7-500-3496-53 500 7 3496 2329 1.0136data7-500-3496-54 500 7 3496 2275 1.0102data7-500-3496-55 500 7 3496 2263 1.0101data7-500-3496-56 500 7 3496 2296 1.0158data7-500-3496-57 500 7 3496 2387 1.0108data7-500-3496-58 500 7 3496 2324 1.0155data7-500-3496-59 500 7 3496 2339 1.0133data7-500-3496-60 500 7 3496 2292 1.0129data7-500-3496-61 500 7 3496 2316 1.0097data7-500-3496-62 500 7 3496 2287 1.0142data7-500-3496-63 500 7 3496 2328 1.0092data7-500-3496-64 500 7 3496 2246 1.0153data7-500-3496-65 500 7 3496 2319 1.0151data7-500-3496-66 500 7 3496 2295 1.0146data7-500-3496-67 500 7 3496 2281 1.0162data7-500-3496-68 500 7 3496 2338 1.0098data7-500-3496-69 500 7 3496 2407 1.0167data7-500-3496-70 500 7 3496 2290 1.0108

Table 71: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 457: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-500-3496-71 500 7 3496 2381 1.0139data7-500-3496-72 500 7 3496 2325 1.0167data7-500-3496-73 500 7 3496 2354 1.0177data7-500-3496-74 500 7 3496 2259 1.0175data7-500-3496-75 500 7 3496 2315 1.0128data7-500-3496-76 500 7 3496 2304 1.0108data7-500-3496-77 500 7 3496 2305 1.0124data7-500-3496-78 500 7 3496 2333 1.0160data7-500-3496-79 500 7 3496 2311 1.0113data7-500-3496-80 500 7 3496 2393 1.0130data7-500-3496-81 500 7 3496 2318 1.0123data7-500-3496-82 500 7 3496 2337 1.0136data7-500-3496-83 500 7 3496 2290 1.0095data7-500-3496-84 500 7 3496 2338 1.0133data7-500-3496-85 500 7 3496 2359 1.0170data7-500-3496-86 500 7 3496 2339 1.0091data7-500-3496-87 500 7 3496 2325 1.0142data7-500-3496-88 500 7 3496 2325 1.0140data7-500-3496-89 500 7 3496 2399 1.0152data7-500-3496-90 500 7 3496 2382 1.0133data7-500-3496-91 500 7 3496 2338 1.0146data7-500-3496-92 500 7 3496 2348 1.0108data7-500-3496-93 500 7 3496 2293 1.0134data7-500-3496-94 500 7 3496 2405 1.0114data7-500-3496-95 500 7 3496 2343 1.0133data7-500-3496-96 500 7 3496 2371 1.0148data7-500-3496-97 500 7 3496 2314 1.0145data7-500-3496-98 500 7 3496 2386 1.0106data7-500-3496-99 500 7 3496 2353 1.0165data7-500-3496-100 500 7 3496 2372 1.0160data7-500-3497-1 500 7 3497 2387 1.0141data7-500-3497-2 500 7 3497 2350 1.0103data7-500-3497-3 500 7 3497 2321 1.0142data7-500-3497-4 500 7 3497 2355 1.0136data7-500-3497-5 500 7 3497 2318 1.0173data7-500-3497-6 500 7 3497 2308 1.0135data7-500-3497-7 500 7 3497 2314 1.0106data7-500-3497-8 500 7 3497 2336 1.0143data7-500-3497-9 500 7 3497 2350 1.0113data7-500-3497-10 500 7 3497 2371 1.0132data7-500-3497-11 500 7 3497 2313 1.0134data7-500-3497-12 500 7 3497 2253 1.0180data7-500-3497-13 500 7 3497 2399 1.0139data7-500-3497-14 500 7 3497 2330 1.0108data7-500-3497-15 500 7 3497 2323 1.0125data7-500-3497-16 500 7 3497 2324 1.0133data7-500-3497-17 500 7 3497 2340 1.0136data7-500-3497-18 500 7 3497 2307 1.0088data7-500-3497-19 500 7 3497 2380 1.0115data7-500-3497-20 500 7 3497 2272 1.0142data7-500-3497-21 500 7 3497 2331 1.0156data7-500-3497-22 500 7 3497 2380 1.0118data7-500-3497-23 500 7 3497 2354 1.0103data7-500-3497-24 500 7 3497 2347 1.0107data7-500-3497-25 500 7 3497 2279 1.0120data7-500-3497-26 500 7 3497 2325 1.0127data7-500-3497-27 500 7 3497 2362 1.0119data7-500-3497-28 500 7 3497 2343 1.0114data7-500-3497-29 500 7 3497 2329 1.0167data7-500-3497-30 500 7 3497 2341 1.0118data7-500-3497-31 500 7 3497 2335 1.0132data7-500-3497-32 500 7 3497 2330 1.0165data7-500-3497-33 500 7 3497 2338 1.0126data7-500-3497-34 500 7 3497 2328 1.0098data7-500-3497-35 500 7 3497 2369 1.0146data7-500-3497-36 500 7 3497 2346 1.0153data7-500-3497-37 500 7 3497 2353 1.0108data7-500-3497-38 500 7 3497 2288 1.0108data7-500-3497-39 500 7 3497 2328 1.0202data7-500-3497-40 500 7 3497 2282 1.0165

Table 72: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 458: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-500-3497-41 500 7 3497 2377 1.0114data7-500-3497-42 500 7 3497 2328 1.0136data7-500-3497-43 500 7 3497 2323 1.0146data7-500-3497-44 500 7 3497 2383 1.0127data7-500-3497-45 500 7 3497 2354 1.0140data7-500-3497-46 500 7 3497 2412 1.0172data7-500-3497-47 500 7 3497 2330 1.0153data7-500-3497-48 500 7 3497 2324 1.0145data7-500-3497-49 500 7 3497 2343 1.0111data7-500-3497-50 500 7 3497 2341 1.0139data7-500-3497-51 500 7 3497 2321 1.0095data7-500-3497-52 500 7 3497 2346 1.0093data7-500-3497-53 500 7 3497 2331 1.0150data7-500-3497-54 500 7 3497 2331 1.0128data7-500-3497-55 500 7 3497 2301 1.0095data7-500-3497-56 500 7 3497 2368 1.0162data7-500-3497-57 500 7 3497 2356 1.0145data7-500-3497-58 500 7 3497 2321 1.0111data7-500-3497-59 500 7 3497 2349 1.0142data7-500-3497-60 500 7 3497 2373 1.0103data7-500-3497-61 500 7 3497 2312 1.0114data7-500-3497-62 500 7 3497 2290 1.0154data7-500-3497-63 500 7 3497 2299 1.0103data7-500-3497-64 500 7 3497 2313 1.0116data7-500-3497-65 500 7 3497 2304 1.0156data7-500-3497-66 500 7 3497 2375 1.0151data7-500-3497-67 500 7 3497 2404 1.0123data7-500-3497-68 500 7 3497 2358 1.0136data7-500-3497-69 500 7 3497 2285 1.0152data7-500-3497-70 500 7 3497 2353 1.0137data7-500-3497-71 500 7 3497 2338 1.0163data7-500-3497-72 500 7 3497 2346 1.0149data7-500-3497-73 500 7 3497 2298 1.0125data7-500-3497-74 500 7 3497 2351 1.0137data7-500-3497-75 500 7 3497 2325 1.0139data7-500-3497-76 500 7 3497 2406 1.0091data7-500-3497-77 500 7 3497 2321 1.0104data7-500-3497-78 500 7 3497 2317 1.0131data7-500-3497-79 500 7 3497 2383 1.0113data7-500-3497-80 500 7 3497 2421 1.0166data7-500-3497-81 500 7 3497 2292 1.0120data7-500-3497-82 500 7 3497 2312 1.0141data7-500-3497-83 500 7 3497 2374 1.0108data7-500-3497-84 500 7 3497 2364 1.0133data7-500-3497-85 500 7 3497 2342 1.0145data7-500-3497-86 500 7 3497 2326 1.0088data7-500-3497-87 500 7 3497 2335 1.0122data7-500-3497-88 500 7 3497 2239 1.0125data7-500-3497-89 500 7 3497 2318 1.0150data7-500-3497-90 500 7 3497 2303 1.0178data7-500-3497-91 500 7 3497 2301 1.0147data7-500-3497-92 500 7 3497 2264 1.0184data7-500-3497-93 500 7 3497 2358 1.0146data7-500-3497-94 500 7 3497 2345 1.0110data7-500-3497-95 500 7 3497 2345 1.0104data7-500-3497-96 500 7 3497 2352 1.0170data7-500-3497-97 500 7 3497 2342 1.0098data7-500-3497-98 500 7 3497 2370 1.0093data7-500-3497-99 500 7 3497 2304 1.0160data7-500-3497-100 500 7 3497 2275 1.0148data7-500-3498-1 500 7 3498 2314 1.0114data7-500-3498-2 500 7 3498 2288 1.0110data7-500-3498-3 500 7 3498 2331 1.0151data7-500-3498-4 500 7 3498 2372 1.0123data7-500-3498-5 500 7 3498 2301 1.0175data7-500-3498-6 500 7 3498 2380 1.0151data7-500-3498-7 500 7 3498 2267 1.0126data7-500-3498-8 500 7 3498 2297 1.0141data7-500-3498-9 500 7 3498 2318 1.0118data7-500-3498-10 500 7 3498 2360 1.0100

Table 73: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 459: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-500-3498-11 500 7 3498 2276 1.0121data7-500-3498-12 500 7 3498 2300 1.0135data7-500-3498-13 500 7 3498 2305 1.0111data7-500-3498-14 500 7 3498 2348 1.0110data7-500-3498-15 500 7 3498 2288 1.0100data7-500-3498-16 500 7 3498 2338 1.0107data7-500-3498-17 500 7 3498 2318 1.0159data7-500-3498-18 500 7 3498 2288 1.0124data7-500-3498-19 500 7 3498 2304 1.0152data7-500-3498-20 500 7 3498 2366 1.0163data7-500-3498-21 500 7 3498 2287 1.0128data7-500-3498-22 500 7 3498 2386 1.0159data7-500-3498-23 500 7 3498 2326 1.0099data7-500-3498-24 500 7 3498 2304 1.0101data7-500-3498-25 500 7 3498 2423 1.0108data7-500-3498-26 500 7 3498 2318 1.0121data7-500-3498-27 500 7 3498 2348 1.0138data7-500-3498-28 500 7 3498 2287 1.0107data7-500-3498-29 500 7 3498 2306 1.0132data7-500-3498-30 500 7 3498 2298 1.0147data7-500-3498-31 500 7 3498 2349 1.0182data7-500-3498-32 500 7 3498 2328 1.0116data7-500-3498-33 500 7 3498 2297 1.0173data7-500-3498-34 500 7 3498 2344 1.0117data7-500-3498-35 500 7 3498 2338 1.0112data7-500-3498-36 500 7 3498 2338 1.0102data7-500-3498-37 500 7 3498 2354 1.0101data7-500-3498-38 500 7 3498 2305 1.0097data7-500-3498-39 500 7 3498 2359 1.0149data7-500-3498-40 500 7 3498 2317 1.0146data7-500-3498-41 500 7 3498 2425 1.0096data7-500-3498-42 500 7 3498 2293 1.0114data7-500-3498-43 500 7 3498 2337 1.0161data7-500-3498-44 500 7 3498 2329 1.0155data7-500-3498-45 500 7 3498 2299 1.0154data7-500-3498-46 500 7 3498 2340 1.0123data7-500-3498-47 500 7 3498 2365 1.0139data7-500-3498-48 500 7 3498 2362 1.0112data7-500-3498-49 500 7 3498 2365 1.0126data7-500-3498-50 500 7 3498 2361 1.0111data7-500-3498-51 500 7 3498 2283 1.0113data7-500-3498-52 500 7 3498 2360 1.0155data7-500-3498-53 500 7 3498 2351 1.0132data7-500-3498-54 500 7 3498 2326 1.0128data7-500-3498-55 500 7 3498 2339 1.0109data7-500-3498-56 500 7 3498 2313 1.0120data7-500-3498-57 500 7 3498 2323 1.0110data7-500-3498-58 500 7 3498 2354 1.0130data7-500-3498-59 500 7 3498 2358 1.0144data7-500-3498-60 500 7 3498 2387 1.0123data7-500-3498-61 500 7 3498 2323 1.0114data7-500-3498-62 500 7 3498 2329 1.0137data7-500-3498-63 500 7 3498 2324 1.0109data7-500-3498-64 500 7 3498 2285 1.0179data7-500-3498-65 500 7 3498 2258 1.0147data7-500-3498-66 500 7 3498 2329 1.0119data7-500-3498-67 500 7 3498 2368 1.0137data7-500-3498-68 500 7 3498 2357 1.0141data7-500-3498-69 500 7 3498 2329 1.0151data7-500-3498-70 500 7 3498 2331 1.0145data7-500-3498-71 500 7 3498 2373 1.0122data7-500-3498-72 500 7 3498 2372 1.0144data7-500-3498-73 500 7 3498 2347 1.0123data7-500-3498-74 500 7 3498 2369 1.0126data7-500-3498-75 500 7 3498 2434 1.0131data7-500-3498-76 500 7 3498 2372 1.0162data7-500-3498-77 500 7 3498 2315 1.0153data7-500-3498-78 500 7 3498 2456 1.0117data7-500-3498-79 500 7 3498 2312 1.0137data7-500-3498-80 500 7 3498 2300 1.0091

Table 74: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 460: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-500-3498-81 500 7 3498 2366 1.0095data7-500-3498-82 500 7 3498 2337 1.0161data7-500-3498-83 500 7 3498 2375 1.0125data7-500-3498-84 500 7 3498 2375 1.0194data7-500-3498-85 500 7 3498 2312 1.0114data7-500-3498-86 500 7 3498 2326 1.0149data7-500-3498-87 500 7 3498 2300 1.0136data7-500-3498-88 500 7 3498 2293 1.0131data7-500-3498-89 500 7 3498 2284 1.0116data7-500-3498-90 500 7 3498 2263 1.0203data7-500-3498-91 500 7 3498 2315 1.0148data7-500-3498-92 500 7 3498 2300 1.0152data7-500-3498-93 500 7 3498 2250 1.0138data7-500-3498-94 500 7 3498 2323 1.0099data7-500-3498-95 500 7 3498 2355 1.0122data7-500-3498-96 500 7 3498 2320 1.0102data7-500-3498-97 500 7 3498 2355 1.0127data7-500-3498-98 500 7 3498 2312 1.0150data7-500-3498-99 500 7 3498 2348 1.0142data7-500-3498-100 500 7 3498 2329 1.0124data7-500-3499-1 500 7 3499 2269 1.0114data7-500-3499-2 500 7 3499 2362 1.0136data7-500-3499-3 500 7 3499 2325 1.0154data7-500-3499-4 500 7 3499 2306 1.0163data7-500-3499-5 500 7 3499 2390 1.0108data7-500-3499-6 500 7 3499 2439 1.0100data7-500-3499-7 500 7 3499 2284 1.0130data7-500-3499-8 500 7 3499 2315 1.0103data7-500-3499-9 500 7 3499 2370 1.0137data7-500-3499-10 500 7 3499 2356 1.0097data7-500-3499-11 500 7 3499 2289 1.0146data7-500-3499-12 500 7 3499 2342 1.0100data7-500-3499-13 500 7 3499 2307 1.0138data7-500-3499-14 500 7 3499 2334 1.0104data7-500-3499-15 500 7 3499 2311 1.0094data7-500-3499-16 500 7 3499 2327 1.0089data7-500-3499-17 500 7 3499 2363 1.0147data7-500-3499-18 500 7 3499 2390 1.0138data7-500-3499-19 500 7 3499 2439 1.0144data7-500-3499-20 500 7 3499 2289 1.0152data7-500-3499-21 500 7 3499 2302 1.0116data7-500-3499-22 500 7 3499 2319 1.0102data7-500-3499-23 500 7 3499 2290 1.0122data7-500-3499-24 500 7 3499 2350 1.0105data7-500-3499-25 500 7 3499 2311 1.0148data7-500-3499-26 500 7 3499 2347 1.0149data7-500-3499-27 500 7 3499 2320 1.0151data7-500-3499-28 500 7 3499 2267 1.0112data7-500-3499-29 500 7 3499 2308 1.0138data7-500-3499-30 500 7 3499 2323 1.0114data7-500-3499-31 500 7 3499 2380 1.0150data7-500-3499-32 500 7 3499 2359 1.0108data7-500-3499-33 500 7 3499 2339 1.0183data7-500-3499-34 500 7 3499 2354 1.0112data7-500-3499-35 500 7 3499 2299 1.0179data7-500-3499-36 500 7 3499 2308 1.0140data7-500-3499-37 500 7 3499 2285 1.0114data7-500-3499-38 500 7 3499 2327 1.0096data7-500-3499-39 500 7 3499 2342 1.0147data7-500-3499-40 500 7 3499 2383 1.0121data7-500-3499-41 500 7 3499 2342 1.0134data7-500-3499-42 500 7 3499 2332 1.0116data7-500-3499-43 500 7 3499 2332 1.0152data7-500-3499-44 500 7 3499 2324 1.0153data7-500-3499-45 500 7 3499 2301 1.0118data7-500-3499-46 500 7 3499 2336 1.0125data7-500-3499-47 500 7 3499 2301 1.0124data7-500-3499-48 500 7 3499 2296 1.0114data7-500-3499-49 500 7 3499 2307 1.0105data7-500-3499-50 500 7 3499 2316 1.0105

Table 75: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 461: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-500-3499-51 500 7 3499 2359 1.0148data7-500-3499-52 500 7 3499 2327 1.0130data7-500-3499-53 500 7 3499 2296 1.0152data7-500-3499-54 500 7 3499 2312 1.0106data7-500-3499-55 500 7 3499 2326 1.0110data7-500-3499-56 500 7 3499 2328 1.0122data7-500-3499-57 500 7 3499 2326 1.0102data7-500-3499-58 500 7 3499 2320 1.0144data7-500-3499-59 500 7 3499 2241 1.0121data7-500-3499-60 500 7 3499 2415 1.0138data7-500-3499-61 500 7 3499 2358 1.0111data7-500-3499-62 500 7 3499 2362 1.0140data7-500-3499-63 500 7 3499 2405 1.0130data7-500-3499-64 500 7 3499 2301 1.0163data7-500-3499-65 500 7 3499 2393 1.0181data7-500-3499-66 500 7 3499 2341 1.0130data7-500-3499-67 500 7 3499 2317 1.0185data7-500-3499-68 500 7 3499 2333 1.0156data7-500-3499-69 500 7 3499 2298 1.0122data7-500-3499-70 500 7 3499 2318 1.0140data7-500-3499-71 500 7 3499 2359 1.0136data7-500-3499-72 500 7 3499 2279 1.0143data7-500-3499-73 500 7 3499 2327 1.0101data7-500-3499-74 500 7 3499 2260 1.0157data7-500-3499-75 500 7 3499 2359 1.0146data7-500-3499-76 500 7 3499 2403 1.0107data7-500-3499-77 500 7 3499 2340 1.0127data7-500-3499-78 500 7 3499 2332 1.0132data7-500-3499-79 500 7 3499 2323 1.0165data7-500-3499-80 500 7 3499 2333 1.0096data7-500-3499-81 500 7 3499 2306 1.0129data7-500-3499-82 500 7 3499 2334 1.0168data7-500-3499-83 500 7 3499 2317 1.0118data7-500-3499-84 500 7 3499 2387 1.0145data7-500-3499-85 500 7 3499 2392 1.0116data7-500-3499-86 500 7 3499 2307 1.0110data7-500-3499-87 500 7 3499 2345 1.0129data7-500-3499-88 500 7 3499 2382 1.0125data7-500-3499-89 500 7 3499 2360 1.0111data7-500-3499-90 500 7 3499 2340 1.0101data7-500-3499-91 500 7 3499 2415 1.0205data7-500-3499-92 500 7 3499 2298 1.0130data7-500-3499-93 500 7 3499 2397 1.0161data7-500-3499-94 500 7 3499 2350 1.0138data7-500-3499-95 500 7 3499 2319 1.0113data7-500-3499-96 500 7 3499 2337 1.0124data7-500-3499-97 500 7 3499 2330 1.0131data7-500-3499-98 500 7 3499 2333 1.0101data7-500-3499-99 500 7 3499 2353 1.0130data7-500-3499-100 500 7 3499 2349 1.0161data10-500-4990-1 500 10 4990 4181 1.0153data10-500-4990-2 500 10 4990 4341 1.0173data10-500-4990-3 500 10 4990 4215 1.0144data10-500-4990-4 500 10 4990 4197 1.0162data10-500-4990-5 500 10 4990 4279 1.0160data10-500-4990-6 500 10 4990 4271 1.0142data10-500-4990-7 500 10 4990 4296 1.0116data10-500-4990-8 500 10 4990 4157 1.0120data10-500-4990-9 500 10 4990 4196 1.0122data10-500-4990-10 500 10 4990 4320 1.0167data10-500-4990-11 500 10 4990 4180 1.0179data10-500-4990-12 500 10 4990 4334 1.0169data10-500-4990-13 500 10 4990 4201 1.0144data10-500-4990-14 500 10 4990 4272 1.0123data10-500-4990-15 500 10 4990 4219 1.0123data10-500-4990-16 500 10 4990 4228 1.0181data10-500-4990-17 500 10 4990 4229 1.0160data10-500-4990-18 500 10 4990 4217 1.0152data10-500-4990-19 500 10 4990 4206 1.0141data10-500-4990-20 500 10 4990 4178 1.0177

Table 76: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 462: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-500-4990-21 500 10 4990 4163 1.0141data10-500-4990-22 500 10 4990 4228 1.0159data10-500-4990-23 500 10 4990 4224 1.0164data10-500-4990-24 500 10 4990 4228 1.0142data10-500-4990-25 500 10 4990 4244 1.0118data10-500-4990-26 500 10 4990 4207 1.0143data10-500-4990-27 500 10 4990 4253 1.0156data10-500-4990-28 500 10 4990 4160 1.0137data10-500-4990-29 500 10 4990 4172 1.0157data10-500-4990-30 500 10 4990 4204 1.0169data10-500-4990-31 500 10 4990 4258 1.0154data10-500-4990-32 500 10 4990 4182 1.0159data10-500-4990-33 500 10 4990 4356 1.0185data10-500-4990-34 500 10 4990 4170 1.0124data10-500-4990-35 500 10 4990 4125 1.0151data10-500-4990-36 500 10 4990 4067 1.0160data10-500-4990-37 500 10 4990 4279 1.0251data10-500-4990-38 500 10 4990 4264 1.0122data10-500-4990-39 500 10 4990 4245 1.0159data10-500-4990-40 500 10 4990 4233 1.0143data10-500-4990-41 500 10 4990 4142 1.0151data10-500-4990-42 500 10 4990 4199 1.0132data10-500-4990-43 500 10 4990 4283 1.0169data10-500-4990-44 500 10 4990 4165 1.0167data10-500-4990-45 500 10 4990 4136 1.0152data10-500-4990-46 500 10 4990 4133 1.0161data10-500-4990-47 500 10 4990 4031 1.0152data10-500-4990-48 500 10 4990 4266 1.0164data10-500-4990-49 500 10 4990 4086 1.0144data10-500-4990-50 500 10 4990 4200 1.0154data10-500-4990-51 500 10 4990 4108 1.0149data10-500-4990-52 500 10 4990 4209 1.0156data10-500-4990-53 500 10 4990 4313 1.0154data10-500-4990-54 500 10 4990 4029 1.0144data10-500-4990-55 500 10 4990 4270 1.0141data10-500-4990-56 500 10 4990 4108 1.0168data10-500-4990-57 500 10 4990 4406 1.0189data10-500-4990-58 500 10 4990 4131 1.0119data10-500-4990-59 500 10 4990 4075 1.0158data10-500-4990-60 500 10 4990 4182 1.0156data10-500-4990-61 500 10 4990 4206 1.0154data10-500-4990-62 500 10 4990 4254 1.0213data10-500-4990-63 500 10 4990 4239 1.0171data10-500-4990-64 500 10 4990 4138 1.0118data10-500-4990-65 500 10 4990 4249 1.0140data10-500-4990-66 500 10 4990 4117 1.0166data10-500-4990-67 500 10 4990 4386 1.0170data10-500-4990-68 500 10 4990 4122 1.0145data10-500-4990-69 500 10 4990 4241 1.0160data10-500-4990-70 500 10 4990 4102 1.0176data10-500-4990-71 500 10 4990 4243 1.0147data10-500-4990-72 500 10 4990 4426 1.0143data10-500-4990-73 500 10 4990 4234 1.0166data10-500-4990-74 500 10 4990 4220 1.0141data10-500-4990-75 500 10 4990 4306 1.0141data10-500-4990-76 500 10 4990 4238 1.0137data10-500-4990-77 500 10 4990 4212 1.0277data10-500-4990-78 500 10 4990 4144 1.0258data10-500-4990-79 500 10 4990 4243 1.0147data10-500-4990-80 500 10 4990 4242 1.0165data10-500-4990-81 500 10 4990 4104 1.0161data10-500-4990-82 500 10 4990 4405 1.0130data10-500-4990-83 500 10 4990 4113 1.0192data10-500-4990-84 500 10 4990 4292 1.0155data10-500-4990-85 500 10 4990 4179 1.0254data10-500-4990-86 500 10 4990 4189 1.0182data10-500-4990-87 500 10 4990 4265 1.0176data10-500-4990-88 500 10 4990 4032 1.0130data10-500-4990-89 500 10 4990 4311 1.0143data10-500-4990-90 500 10 4990 4291 1.0122

Table 77: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 463: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-500-4990-91 500 10 4990 4259 1.0176data10-500-4990-92 500 10 4990 4229 1.0148data10-500-4990-93 500 10 4990 4309 1.0136data10-500-4990-94 500 10 4990 4348 1.0218data10-500-4990-95 500 10 4990 4258 1.0119data10-500-4990-96 500 10 4990 4065 1.0145data10-500-4990-97 500 10 4990 4278 1.0196data10-500-4990-98 500 10 4990 4212 1.0157data10-500-4990-99 500 10 4990 4165 1.0166data10-500-4990-100 500 10 4990 4358 1.0143data10-500-4991-1 500 10 4991 4263 1.0197data10-500-4991-2 500 10 4991 4176 1.0145data10-500-4991-3 500 10 4991 4242 1.0127data10-500-4991-4 500 10 4991 4220 1.0142data10-500-4991-5 500 10 4991 4119 1.0198data10-500-4991-6 500 10 4991 4281 1.0192data10-500-4991-7 500 10 4991 4305 1.0168data10-500-4991-8 500 10 4991 4291 1.0165data10-500-4991-9 500 10 4991 4414 1.0179data10-500-4991-10 500 10 4991 4314 1.0140data10-500-4991-11 500 10 4991 4238 1.0162data10-500-4991-12 500 10 4991 4355 1.0125data10-500-4991-13 500 10 4991 4324 1.0120data10-500-4991-14 500 10 4991 4029 1.0166data10-500-4991-15 500 10 4991 4220 1.0165data10-500-4991-16 500 10 4991 4221 1.0190data10-500-4991-17 500 10 4991 4191 1.0152data10-500-4991-18 500 10 4991 4206 1.0168data10-500-4991-19 500 10 4991 4220 1.0170data10-500-4991-20 500 10 4991 4157 1.0136data10-500-4991-21 500 10 4991 4348 1.0169data10-500-4991-22 500 10 4991 4331 1.0143data10-500-4991-23 500 10 4991 4233 1.0142data10-500-4991-24 500 10 4991 4392 1.0138data10-500-4991-25 500 10 4991 4255 1.0146data10-500-4991-26 500 10 4991 4332 1.0183data10-500-4991-27 500 10 4991 4252 1.0156data10-500-4991-28 500 10 4991 4221 1.0135data10-500-4991-29 500 10 4991 4082 1.0164data10-500-4991-30 500 10 4991 4126 1.0120data10-500-4991-31 500 10 4991 4223 1.0186data10-500-4991-32 500 10 4991 4267 1.0148data10-500-4991-33 500 10 4991 4231 1.0162data10-500-4991-34 500 10 4991 4262 1.0189data10-500-4991-35 500 10 4991 4151 1.0181data10-500-4991-36 500 10 4991 4402 1.0182data10-500-4991-37 500 10 4991 4227 1.0143data10-500-4991-38 500 10 4991 4144 1.0164data10-500-4991-39 500 10 4991 4255 1.0178data10-500-4991-40 500 10 4991 4067 1.0248data10-500-4991-41 500 10 4991 4154 1.0140data10-500-4991-42 500 10 4991 4313 1.0178data10-500-4991-43 500 10 4991 4198 1.0162data10-500-4991-44 500 10 4991 4214 1.0148data10-500-4991-45 500 10 4991 4082 1.0164data10-500-4991-46 500 10 4991 4441 1.0146data10-500-4991-47 500 10 4991 4242 1.0166data10-500-4991-48 500 10 4991 4201 1.0193data10-500-4991-49 500 10 4991 4168 1.0137data10-500-4991-50 500 10 4991 4220 1.0137data10-500-4991-51 500 10 4991 4211 1.0156data10-500-4991-52 500 10 4991 4281 1.0151data10-500-4991-53 500 10 4991 4101 1.0158data10-500-4991-54 500 10 4991 4171 1.0123data10-500-4991-55 500 10 4991 4262 1.0130data10-500-4991-56 500 10 4991 4293 1.0159data10-500-4991-57 500 10 4991 4228 1.0155data10-500-4991-58 500 10 4991 4284 1.0130data10-500-4991-59 500 10 4991 4322 1.0152data10-500-4991-60 500 10 4991 4191 1.0163

Table 78: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 464: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-500-4991-61 500 10 4991 4345 1.0143data10-500-4991-62 500 10 4991 4253 1.0122data10-500-4991-63 500 10 4991 4078 1.0164data10-500-4991-64 500 10 4991 4149 1.0138data10-500-4991-65 500 10 4991 4330 1.0166data10-500-4991-66 500 10 4991 4368 1.0159data10-500-4991-67 500 10 4991 4096 1.0165data10-500-4991-68 500 10 4991 4203 1.0167data10-500-4991-69 500 10 4991 4183 1.0166data10-500-4991-70 500 10 4991 4270 1.0292data10-500-4991-71 500 10 4991 4142 1.0128data10-500-4991-72 500 10 4991 4239 1.0133data10-500-4991-73 500 10 4991 4183 1.0152data10-500-4991-74 500 10 4991 4165 1.0146data10-500-4991-75 500 10 4991 4342 1.0157data10-500-4991-76 500 10 4991 4250 1.0161data10-500-4991-77 500 10 4991 4342 1.0178data10-500-4991-78 500 10 4991 4063 1.0173data10-500-4991-79 500 10 4991 4254 1.0176data10-500-4991-80 500 10 4991 4198 1.0145data10-500-4991-81 500 10 4991 4217 1.0161data10-500-4991-82 500 10 4991 4258 1.0188data10-500-4991-83 500 10 4991 4177 1.0214data10-500-4991-84 500 10 4991 4130 1.0151data10-500-4991-85 500 10 4991 4351 1.0253data10-500-4991-86 500 10 4991 4378 1.0133data10-500-4991-87 500 10 4991 4206 1.0156data10-500-4991-88 500 10 4991 4169 1.0137data10-500-4991-89 500 10 4991 4153 1.0145data10-500-4991-90 500 10 4991 4184 1.0120data10-500-4991-91 500 10 4991 4208 1.0170data10-500-4991-92 500 10 4991 4192 1.0167data10-500-4991-93 500 10 4991 4369 1.0153data10-500-4991-94 500 10 4991 4224 1.0167data10-500-4991-95 500 10 4991 4309 1.0143data10-500-4991-96 500 10 4991 4247 1.0167data10-500-4991-97 500 10 4991 4239 1.0122data10-500-4991-98 500 10 4991 4284 1.0133data10-500-4991-99 500 10 4991 4393 1.0162data10-500-4991-100 500 10 4991 4174 1.0146data10-500-4992-1 500 10 4992 4203 1.0151data10-500-4992-2 500 10 4992 4363 1.0180data10-500-4992-3 500 10 4992 4476 1.0175data10-500-4992-4 500 10 4992 4241 1.0148data10-500-4992-5 500 10 4992 4322 1.0143data10-500-4992-6 500 10 4992 4393 1.0141data10-500-4992-7 500 10 4992 4273 1.0133data10-500-4992-8 500 10 4992 4240 1.0163data10-500-4992-9 500 10 4992 4173 1.0140data10-500-4992-10 500 10 4992 4163 1.0186data10-500-4992-11 500 10 4992 4283 1.0130data10-500-4992-12 500 10 4992 4109 1.0171data10-500-4992-13 500 10 4992 4277 1.0162data10-500-4992-14 500 10 4992 4219 1.0202data10-500-4992-15 500 10 4992 4257 1.0167data10-500-4992-16 500 10 4992 4200 1.0186data10-500-4992-17 500 10 4992 4296 1.0223data10-500-4992-18 500 10 4992 4173 1.0266data10-500-4992-19 500 10 4992 4360 1.0171data10-500-4992-20 500 10 4992 4273 1.0153data10-500-4992-21 500 10 4992 4177 1.0161data10-500-4992-22 500 10 4992 4164 1.0162data10-500-4992-23 500 10 4992 4278 1.0138data10-500-4992-24 500 10 4992 4128 1.0121data10-500-4992-25 500 10 4992 4176 1.0146data10-500-4992-26 500 10 4992 4445 1.0185data10-500-4992-27 500 10 4992 4327 1.0144data10-500-4992-28 500 10 4992 4249 1.0183data10-500-4992-29 500 10 4992 4449 1.0150data10-500-4992-30 500 10 4992 4272 1.0164

Table 79: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 465: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-500-4992-31 500 10 4992 4271 1.0202data10-500-4992-32 500 10 4992 4166 1.0163data10-500-4992-33 500 10 4992 4261 1.0270data10-500-4992-34 500 10 4992 4158 1.0125data10-500-4992-35 500 10 4992 4294 1.0223data10-500-4992-36 500 10 4992 4392 1.0140data10-500-4992-37 500 10 4992 4252 1.0146data10-500-4992-38 500 10 4992 4290 1.0191data10-500-4992-39 500 10 4992 4039 1.0135data10-500-4992-40 500 10 4992 4403 1.0242data10-500-4992-41 500 10 4992 4224 1.0159data10-500-4992-42 500 10 4992 4272 1.0204data10-500-4992-43 500 10 4992 4287 1.0176data10-500-4992-44 500 10 4992 4465 1.0137data10-500-4992-45 500 10 4992 4192 1.0219data10-500-4992-46 500 10 4992 4188 1.0161data10-500-4992-47 500 10 4992 4118 1.0172data10-500-4992-48 500 10 4992 4279 1.0146data10-500-4992-49 500 10 4992 4377 1.0152data10-500-4992-50 500 10 4992 4198 1.0159data10-500-4992-51 500 10 4992 4189 1.0135data10-500-4992-52 500 10 4992 4155 1.0134data10-500-4992-53 500 10 4992 4322 1.0187data10-500-4992-54 500 10 4992 4312 1.0158data10-500-4992-55 500 10 4992 4264 1.0148data10-500-4992-56 500 10 4992 4191 1.0156data10-500-4992-57 500 10 4992 4130 1.0128data10-500-4992-58 500 10 4992 4341 1.0152data10-500-4992-59 500 10 4992 4199 1.0224data10-500-4992-60 500 10 4992 4176 1.0232data10-500-4992-61 500 10 4992 4229 1.0147data10-500-4992-62 500 10 4992 4297 1.0148data10-500-4992-63 500 10 4992 4280 1.0136data10-500-4992-64 500 10 4992 4293 1.0135data10-500-4992-65 500 10 4992 4210 1.0165data10-500-4992-66 500 10 4992 4243 1.0122data10-500-4992-67 500 10 4992 4317 1.0141data10-500-4992-68 500 10 4992 4102 1.0174data10-500-4992-69 500 10 4992 4227 1.0257data10-500-4992-70 500 10 4992 4224 1.0260data10-500-4992-71 500 10 4992 4044 1.0159data10-500-4992-72 500 10 4992 4387 1.0172data10-500-4992-73 500 10 4992 4373 1.0159data10-500-4992-74 500 10 4992 4091 1.0128data10-500-4992-75 500 10 4992 4283 1.0150data10-500-4992-76 500 10 4992 4293 1.0149data10-500-4992-77 500 10 4992 4232 1.0161data10-500-4992-78 500 10 4992 4225 1.0170data10-500-4992-79 500 10 4992 4267 1.0145data10-500-4992-80 500 10 4992 4281 1.0173data10-500-4992-81 500 10 4992 4113 1.0158data10-500-4992-82 500 10 4992 4318 1.0166data10-500-4992-83 500 10 4992 4271 1.0142data10-500-4992-84 500 10 4992 4152 1.0175data10-500-4992-85 500 10 4992 4274 1.0158data10-500-4992-86 500 10 4992 4358 1.0129data10-500-4992-87 500 10 4992 4108 1.0268data10-500-4992-88 500 10 4992 4258 1.0190data10-500-4992-89 500 10 4992 4257 1.0166data10-500-4992-90 500 10 4992 4284 1.0176data10-500-4992-91 500 10 4992 4348 1.0177data10-500-4992-92 500 10 4992 4312 1.0163data10-500-4992-93 500 10 4992 4264 1.0174data10-500-4992-94 500 10 4992 4195 1.0136data10-500-4992-95 500 10 4992 4089 1.0142data10-500-4992-96 500 10 4992 4311 1.0164data10-500-4992-97 500 10 4992 4289 1.0226data10-500-4992-98 500 10 4992 4241 1.0181data10-500-4992-99 500 10 4992 4320 1.0161data10-500-4992-100 500 10 4992 4414 1.0164

Table 80: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 466: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-500-4993-1 500 10 4993 4302 1.0162data10-500-4993-2 500 10 4993 4252 1.0148data10-500-4993-3 500 10 4993 4171 1.0173data10-500-4993-4 500 10 4993 4109 1.0154data10-500-4993-5 500 10 4993 4208 1.0160data10-500-4993-6 500 10 4993 4306 1.0161data10-500-4993-7 500 10 4993 4162 1.0144data10-500-4993-8 500 10 4993 4136 1.0124data10-500-4993-9 500 10 4993 4380 1.0214data10-500-4993-10 500 10 4993 4111 1.0143data10-500-4993-11 500 10 4993 4266 1.0151data10-500-4993-12 500 10 4993 4372 1.0163data10-500-4993-13 500 10 4993 4143 1.0143data10-500-4993-14 500 10 4993 4232 1.0160data10-500-4993-15 500 10 4993 4242 1.0161data10-500-4993-16 500 10 4993 4344 1.0158data10-500-4993-17 500 10 4993 4231 1.0164data10-500-4993-18 500 10 4993 4311 1.0144data10-500-4993-19 500 10 4993 4251 1.0185data10-500-4993-20 500 10 4993 4156 1.0154data10-500-4993-21 500 10 4993 4235 1.0130data10-500-4993-22 500 10 4993 4222 1.0148data10-500-4993-23 500 10 4993 4184 1.0179data10-500-4993-24 500 10 4993 4226 1.0279data10-500-4993-25 500 10 4993 4141 1.0156data10-500-4993-26 500 10 4993 4084 1.0203data10-500-4993-27 500 10 4993 4181 1.0157data10-500-4993-28 500 10 4993 4208 1.0143data10-500-4993-29 500 10 4993 4132 1.0175data10-500-4993-30 500 10 4993 4216 1.0133data10-500-4993-31 500 10 4993 4107 1.0175data10-500-4993-32 500 10 4993 4207 1.0143data10-500-4993-33 500 10 4993 4227 1.0155data10-500-4993-34 500 10 4993 4137 1.0150data10-500-4993-35 500 10 4993 4255 1.0138data10-500-4993-36 500 10 4993 4196 1.0144data10-500-4993-37 500 10 4993 4122 1.0128data10-500-4993-38 500 10 4993 4307 1.0189data10-500-4993-39 500 10 4993 4308 1.0148data10-500-4993-40 500 10 4993 4285 1.0249data10-500-4993-41 500 10 4993 4303 1.0188data10-500-4993-42 500 10 4993 4101 1.0159data10-500-4993-43 500 10 4993 4226 1.0176data10-500-4993-44 500 10 4993 4098 1.0168data10-500-4993-45 500 10 4993 4229 1.0153data10-500-4993-46 500 10 4993 4305 1.0155data10-500-4993-47 500 10 4993 4198 1.0242data10-500-4993-48 500 10 4993 4243 1.0156data10-500-4993-49 500 10 4993 4453 1.0164data10-500-4993-50 500 10 4993 4253 1.0156data10-500-4993-51 500 10 4993 4155 1.0148data10-500-4993-52 500 10 4993 4271 1.0166data10-500-4993-53 500 10 4993 4162 1.0124data10-500-4993-54 500 10 4993 4217 1.0143data10-500-4993-55 500 10 4993 4291 1.0140data10-500-4993-56 500 10 4993 4301 1.0177data10-500-4993-57 500 10 4993 4288 1.0163data10-500-4993-58 500 10 4993 4335 1.0150data10-500-4993-59 500 10 4993 4216 1.0167data10-500-4993-60 500 10 4993 4335 1.0152data10-500-4993-61 500 10 4993 4200 1.0169data10-500-4993-62 500 10 4993 4348 1.0147data10-500-4993-63 500 10 4993 4347 1.0169data10-500-4993-64 500 10 4993 4375 1.0178data10-500-4993-65 500 10 4993 4140 1.0172data10-500-4993-66 500 10 4993 4364 1.0143data10-500-4993-67 500 10 4993 4228 1.0179data10-500-4993-68 500 10 4993 4127 1.0144data10-500-4993-69 500 10 4993 4075 1.0142data10-500-4993-70 500 10 4993 4238 1.0171

Table 81: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 467: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-500-4993-71 500 10 4993 4211 1.0159data10-500-4993-72 500 10 4993 4241 1.0149data10-500-4993-73 500 10 4993 4296 1.0138data10-500-4993-74 500 10 4993 4286 1.0158data10-500-4993-75 500 10 4993 4306 1.0179data10-500-4993-76 500 10 4993 4222 1.0162data10-500-4993-77 500 10 4993 4348 1.0254data10-500-4993-78 500 10 4993 4074 1.0148data10-500-4993-79 500 10 4993 4313 1.0178data10-500-4993-80 500 10 4993 4463 1.0226data10-500-4993-81 500 10 4993 4233 1.0121data10-500-4993-82 500 10 4993 4316 1.0175data10-500-4993-83 500 10 4993 4294 1.0184data10-500-4993-84 500 10 4993 4259 1.0207data10-500-4993-85 500 10 4993 4145 1.0188data10-500-4993-86 500 10 4993 4306 1.0163data10-500-4993-87 500 10 4993 4173 1.0149data10-500-4993-88 500 10 4993 4059 1.0167data10-500-4993-89 500 10 4993 4332 1.0187data10-500-4993-90 500 10 4993 4301 1.0161data10-500-4993-91 500 10 4993 4386 1.0149data10-500-4993-92 500 10 4993 4208 1.0147data10-500-4993-93 500 10 4993 4257 1.0197data10-500-4993-94 500 10 4993 4228 1.0122data10-500-4993-95 500 10 4993 4270 1.0186data10-500-4993-96 500 10 4993 4171 1.0170data10-500-4993-97 500 10 4993 4141 1.0166data10-500-4993-98 500 10 4993 4237 1.0141data10-500-4993-99 500 10 4993 4276 1.0172data10-500-4993-100 500 10 4993 4215 1.0140data10-500-4994-1 500 10 4994 4313 1.0120data10-500-4994-2 500 10 4994 4115 1.0148data10-500-4994-3 500 10 4994 4308 1.0164data10-500-4994-4 500 10 4994 4212 1.0152data10-500-4994-5 500 10 4994 4245 1.0250data10-500-4994-6 500 10 4994 4154 1.0153data10-500-4994-7 500 10 4994 4243 1.0157data10-500-4994-8 500 10 4994 4258 1.0162data10-500-4994-9 500 10 4994 4338 1.0143data10-500-4994-10 500 10 4994 4287 1.0160data10-500-4994-11 500 10 4994 4216 1.0158data10-500-4994-12 500 10 4994 4131 1.0176data10-500-4994-13 500 10 4994 4291 1.0182data10-500-4994-14 500 10 4994 4094 1.0119data10-500-4994-15 500 10 4994 4331 1.0169data10-500-4994-16 500 10 4994 4211 1.0154data10-500-4994-17 500 10 4994 4259 1.0173data10-500-4994-18 500 10 4994 4255 1.0174data10-500-4994-19 500 10 4994 4379 1.0166data10-500-4994-20 500 10 4994 4277 1.0148data10-500-4994-21 500 10 4994 4300 1.0153data10-500-4994-22 500 10 4994 4497 1.0166data10-500-4994-23 500 10 4994 4126 1.0142data10-500-4994-24 500 10 4994 4158 1.0237data10-500-4994-25 500 10 4994 4273 1.0160data10-500-4994-26 500 10 4994 4239 1.0144data10-500-4994-27 500 10 4994 4132 1.0199data10-500-4994-28 500 10 4994 4245 1.0180data10-500-4994-29 500 10 4994 4246 1.0227data10-500-4994-30 500 10 4994 4245 1.0167data10-500-4994-31 500 10 4994 4160 1.0157data10-500-4994-32 500 10 4994 4245 1.0136data10-500-4994-33 500 10 4994 4304 1.0147data10-500-4994-34 500 10 4994 4211 1.0139data10-500-4994-35 500 10 4994 4141 1.0163data10-500-4994-36 500 10 4994 4427 1.0165data10-500-4994-37 500 10 4994 4249 1.0261data10-500-4994-38 500 10 4994 4231 1.0130data10-500-4994-39 500 10 4994 4296 1.0142data10-500-4994-40 500 10 4994 4206 1.0170

Table 82: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 468: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-500-4994-41 500 10 4994 4149 1.0166data10-500-4994-42 500 10 4994 4179 1.0146data10-500-4994-43 500 10 4994 4258 1.0153data10-500-4994-44 500 10 4994 4225 1.0177data10-500-4994-45 500 10 4994 4309 1.0166data10-500-4994-46 500 10 4994 4255 1.0151data10-500-4994-47 500 10 4994 4334 1.0172data10-500-4994-48 500 10 4994 4277 1.0136data10-500-4994-49 500 10 4994 4382 1.0135data10-500-4994-50 500 10 4994 4276 1.0193data10-500-4994-51 500 10 4994 4169 1.0133data10-500-4994-52 500 10 4994 4162 1.0152data10-500-4994-53 500 10 4994 4216 1.0175data10-500-4994-54 500 10 4994 4257 1.0172data10-500-4994-55 500 10 4994 4378 1.0154data10-500-4994-56 500 10 4994 4325 1.0167data10-500-4994-57 500 10 4994 4300 1.0162data10-500-4994-58 500 10 4994 4308 1.0153data10-500-4994-59 500 10 4994 4316 1.0228data10-500-4994-60 500 10 4994 4289 1.0136data10-500-4994-61 500 10 4994 4437 1.0170data10-500-4994-62 500 10 4994 4270 1.0160data10-500-4994-63 500 10 4994 4366 1.0156data10-500-4994-64 500 10 4994 4380 1.0142data10-500-4994-65 500 10 4994 4115 1.0224data10-500-4994-66 500 10 4994 4233 1.0181data10-500-4994-67 500 10 4994 4204 1.0168data10-500-4994-68 500 10 4994 4371 1.0180data10-500-4994-69 500 10 4994 4134 1.0120data10-500-4994-70 500 10 4994 4150 1.0162data10-500-4994-71 500 10 4994 4131 1.0267data10-500-4994-72 500 10 4994 4164 1.0251data10-500-4994-73 500 10 4994 4417 1.0174data10-500-4994-74 500 10 4994 4374 1.0131data10-500-4994-75 500 10 4994 4094 1.0138data10-500-4994-76 500 10 4994 4245 1.0156data10-500-4994-77 500 10 4994 4257 1.0178data10-500-4994-78 500 10 4994 4386 1.0149data10-500-4994-79 500 10 4994 4279 1.0229data10-500-4994-80 500 10 4994 4308 1.0173data10-500-4994-81 500 10 4994 4196 1.0133data10-500-4994-82 500 10 4994 4225 1.0159data10-500-4994-83 500 10 4994 4317 1.0151data10-500-4994-84 500 10 4994 4319 1.0186data10-500-4994-85 500 10 4994 4051 1.0152data10-500-4994-86 500 10 4994 4382 1.0171data10-500-4994-87 500 10 4994 4199 1.0142data10-500-4994-88 500 10 4994 4325 1.0201data10-500-4994-89 500 10 4994 4156 1.0141data10-500-4994-90 500 10 4994 4363 1.0169data10-500-4994-91 500 10 4994 4253 1.0158data10-500-4994-92 500 10 4994 4197 1.0148data10-500-4994-93 500 10 4994 4285 1.0121data10-500-4994-94 500 10 4994 4187 1.0137data10-500-4994-95 500 10 4994 4367 1.0189data10-500-4994-96 500 10 4994 4261 1.0143data10-500-4994-97 500 10 4994 4214 1.0194data10-500-4994-98 500 10 4994 4287 1.0251data10-500-4994-99 500 10 4994 4362 1.0127data10-500-4994-100 500 10 4994 4246 1.0158data10-500-4995-1 500 10 4995 4243 1.0147data10-500-4995-2 500 10 4995 4298 1.0131data10-500-4995-3 500 10 4995 4200 1.0192data10-500-4995-4 500 10 4995 4388 1.0152data10-500-4995-5 500 10 4995 4270 1.0151data10-500-4995-6 500 10 4995 4299 1.0190data10-500-4995-7 500 10 4995 4436 1.0164data10-500-4995-8 500 10 4995 4243 1.0204data10-500-4995-9 500 10 4995 4439 1.0162data10-500-4995-10 500 10 4995 4189 1.0158

Table 83: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 469: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-500-4995-11 500 10 4995 4407 1.0202data10-500-4995-12 500 10 4995 4347 1.0207data10-500-4995-13 500 10 4995 4270 1.0138data10-500-4995-14 500 10 4995 4240 1.0185data10-500-4995-15 500 10 4995 4170 1.0170data10-500-4995-16 500 10 4995 4327 1.0136data10-500-4995-17 500 10 4995 4203 1.0149data10-500-4995-18 500 10 4995 4260 1.0156data10-500-4995-19 500 10 4995 4189 1.0129data10-500-4995-20 500 10 4995 4264 1.0137data10-500-4995-21 500 10 4995 4202 1.0177data10-500-4995-22 500 10 4995 4219 1.0159data10-500-4995-23 500 10 4995 4227 1.0134data10-500-4995-24 500 10 4995 4270 1.0167data10-500-4995-25 500 10 4995 4308 1.0125data10-500-4995-26 500 10 4995 4247 1.0141data10-500-4995-27 500 10 4995 4283 1.0158data10-500-4995-28 500 10 4995 4315 1.0180data10-500-4995-29 500 10 4995 4222 1.0263data10-500-4995-30 500 10 4995 4123 1.0167data10-500-4995-31 500 10 4995 4105 1.0133data10-500-4995-32 500 10 4995 4248 1.0173data10-500-4995-33 500 10 4995 4342 1.0158data10-500-4995-34 500 10 4995 4171 1.0151data10-500-4995-35 500 10 4995 4332 1.0156data10-500-4995-36 500 10 4995 4267 1.0172data10-500-4995-37 500 10 4995 4129 1.0172data10-500-4995-38 500 10 4995 4302 1.0160data10-500-4995-39 500 10 4995 4075 1.0207data10-500-4995-40 500 10 4995 4138 1.0164data10-500-4995-41 500 10 4995 4245 1.0181data10-500-4995-42 500 10 4995 4265 1.0161data10-500-4995-43 500 10 4995 4338 1.0200data10-500-4995-44 500 10 4995 4210 1.0163data10-500-4995-45 500 10 4995 4259 1.0157data10-500-4995-46 500 10 4995 4274 1.0209data10-500-4995-47 500 10 4995 4287 1.0152data10-500-4995-48 500 10 4995 3984 1.0128data10-500-4995-49 500 10 4995 4303 1.0159data10-500-4995-50 500 10 4995 4293 1.0245data10-500-4995-51 500 10 4995 4188 1.0138data10-500-4995-52 500 10 4995 4324 1.0141data10-500-4995-53 500 10 4995 4162 1.0145data10-500-4995-54 500 10 4995 4236 1.0153data10-500-4995-55 500 10 4995 4249 1.0185data10-500-4995-56 500 10 4995 4130 1.0178data10-500-4995-57 500 10 4995 4128 1.0149data10-500-4995-58 500 10 4995 4421 1.0149data10-500-4995-59 500 10 4995 4343 1.0147data10-500-4995-60 500 10 4995 4321 1.0157data10-500-4995-61 500 10 4995 4320 1.0198data10-500-4995-62 500 10 4995 4146 1.0169data10-500-4995-63 500 10 4995 4329 1.0174data10-500-4995-64 500 10 4995 4206 1.0197data10-500-4995-65 500 10 4995 4266 1.0166data10-500-4995-66 500 10 4995 4060 1.0173data10-500-4995-67 500 10 4995 4248 1.0163data10-500-4995-68 500 10 4995 4381 1.0144data10-500-4995-69 500 10 4995 4213 1.0157data10-500-4995-70 500 10 4995 4066 1.0160data10-500-4995-71 500 10 4995 4260 1.0135data10-500-4995-72 500 10 4995 4153 1.0126data10-500-4995-73 500 10 4995 4402 1.0167data10-500-4995-74 500 10 4995 4232 1.0170data10-500-4995-75 500 10 4995 4051 1.0197data10-500-4995-76 500 10 4995 4175 1.0153data10-500-4995-77 500 10 4995 4219 1.0240data10-500-4995-78 500 10 4995 4211 1.0190data10-500-4995-79 500 10 4995 4218 1.0171data10-500-4995-80 500 10 4995 4141 1.0151

Table 84: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 470: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-500-4995-81 500 10 4995 4184 1.0166data10-500-4995-82 500 10 4995 4306 1.0161data10-500-4995-83 500 10 4995 4269 1.0211data10-500-4995-84 500 10 4995 4288 1.0132data10-500-4995-85 500 10 4995 4278 1.0153data10-500-4995-86 500 10 4995 4229 1.0149data10-500-4995-87 500 10 4995 4136 1.0238data10-500-4995-88 500 10 4995 4034 1.0140data10-500-4995-89 500 10 4995 4320 1.0167data10-500-4995-90 500 10 4995 4206 1.0141data10-500-4995-91 500 10 4995 4148 1.0286data10-500-4995-92 500 10 4995 4145 1.0177data10-500-4995-93 500 10 4995 4250 1.0176data10-500-4995-94 500 10 4995 4223 1.0163data10-500-4995-95 500 10 4995 4272 1.0195data10-500-4995-96 500 10 4995 4240 1.0169data10-500-4995-97 500 10 4995 4118 1.0178data10-500-4995-98 500 10 4995 4229 1.0130data10-500-4995-99 500 10 4995 4230 1.0134data10-500-4995-100 500 10 4995 4466 1.0186data10-500-4996-1 500 10 4996 4412 1.0164data10-500-4996-2 500 10 4996 4212 1.0184data10-500-4996-3 500 10 4996 4243 1.0191data10-500-4996-4 500 10 4996 4234 1.0158data10-500-4996-5 500 10 4996 4264 1.0131data10-500-4996-6 500 10 4996 4350 1.0182data10-500-4996-7 500 10 4996 4132 1.0149data10-500-4996-8 500 10 4996 4243 1.0123data10-500-4996-9 500 10 4996 4267 1.0177data10-500-4996-10 500 10 4996 4229 1.0158data10-500-4996-11 500 10 4996 4219 1.0154data10-500-4996-12 500 10 4996 4371 1.0209data10-500-4996-13 500 10 4996 4244 1.0127data10-500-4996-14 500 10 4996 4286 1.0129data10-500-4996-15 500 10 4996 4329 1.0126data10-500-4996-16 500 10 4996 4260 1.0222data10-500-4996-17 500 10 4996 4226 1.0122data10-500-4996-18 500 10 4996 4412 1.0178data10-500-4996-19 500 10 4996 4336 1.0228data10-500-4996-20 500 10 4996 4036 1.0160data10-500-4996-21 500 10 4996 4154 1.0178data10-500-4996-22 500 10 4996 4297 1.0153data10-500-4996-23 500 10 4996 4049 1.0142data10-500-4996-24 500 10 4996 4257 1.0183data10-500-4996-25 500 10 4996 4254 1.0151data10-500-4996-26 500 10 4996 4191 1.0148data10-500-4996-27 500 10 4996 4283 1.0243data10-500-4996-28 500 10 4996 4314 1.0174data10-500-4996-29 500 10 4996 4193 1.0151data10-500-4996-30 500 10 4996 4214 1.0153data10-500-4996-31 500 10 4996 4342 1.0138data10-500-4996-32 500 10 4996 4330 1.0143data10-500-4996-33 500 10 4996 4318 1.0162data10-500-4996-34 500 10 4996 4123 1.0227data10-500-4996-35 500 10 4996 4274 1.0173data10-500-4996-36 500 10 4996 4298 1.0145data10-500-4996-37 500 10 4996 4188 1.0152data10-500-4996-38 500 10 4996 4224 1.0133data10-500-4996-39 500 10 4996 4239 1.0119data10-500-4996-40 500 10 4996 4226 1.0133data10-500-4996-41 500 10 4996 4176 1.0174data10-500-4996-42 500 10 4996 4357 1.0165data10-500-4996-43 500 10 4996 4136 1.0145data10-500-4996-44 500 10 4996 4236 1.0262data10-500-4996-45 500 10 4996 4340 1.0148data10-500-4996-46 500 10 4996 4206 1.0157data10-500-4996-47 500 10 4996 4250 1.0144data10-500-4996-48 500 10 4996 4281 1.0153data10-500-4996-49 500 10 4996 4246 1.0178data10-500-4996-50 500 10 4996 4287 1.0140

Table 85: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 471: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-500-4996-51 500 10 4996 4328 1.0165data10-500-4996-52 500 10 4996 4375 1.0163data10-500-4996-53 500 10 4996 4150 1.0147data10-500-4996-54 500 10 4996 4094 1.0161data10-500-4996-55 500 10 4996 4291 1.0119data10-500-4996-56 500 10 4996 4287 1.0167data10-500-4996-57 500 10 4996 4182 1.0162data10-500-4996-58 500 10 4996 4239 1.0150data10-500-4996-59 500 10 4996 4324 1.0142data10-500-4996-60 500 10 4996 4431 1.0172data10-500-4996-61 500 10 4996 4299 1.0148data10-500-4996-62 500 10 4996 4143 1.0120data10-500-4996-63 500 10 4996 4346 1.0172data10-500-4996-64 500 10 4996 4246 1.0175data10-500-4996-65 500 10 4996 4199 1.0153data10-500-4996-66 500 10 4996 4301 1.0184data10-500-4996-67 500 10 4996 4077 1.0216data10-500-4996-68 500 10 4996 4274 1.0154data10-500-4996-69 500 10 4996 4233 1.0149data10-500-4996-70 500 10 4996 4131 1.0169data10-500-4996-71 500 10 4996 4385 1.0140data10-500-4996-72 500 10 4996 4265 1.0216data10-500-4996-73 500 10 4996 4253 1.0189data10-500-4996-74 500 10 4996 4226 1.0190data10-500-4996-75 500 10 4996 4238 1.0145data10-500-4996-76 500 10 4996 4226 1.0148data10-500-4996-77 500 10 4996 4229 1.0136data10-500-4996-78 500 10 4996 4220 1.0142data10-500-4996-79 500 10 4996 4335 1.0241data10-500-4996-80 500 10 4996 4044 1.0151data10-500-4996-81 500 10 4996 4291 1.0156data10-500-4996-82 500 10 4996 4383 1.0201data10-500-4996-83 500 10 4996 4212 1.0183data10-500-4996-84 500 10 4996 4283 1.0127data10-500-4996-85 500 10 4996 4262 1.0224data10-500-4996-86 500 10 4996 4331 1.0135data10-500-4996-87 500 10 4996 4287 1.0156data10-500-4996-88 500 10 4996 4335 1.0159data10-500-4996-89 500 10 4996 4286 1.0121data10-500-4996-90 500 10 4996 4309 1.0126data10-500-4996-91 500 10 4996 4350 1.0121data10-500-4996-92 500 10 4996 4400 1.0248data10-500-4996-93 500 10 4996 4261 1.0153data10-500-4996-94 500 10 4996 4326 1.0142data10-500-4996-95 500 10 4996 4244 1.0144data10-500-4996-96 500 10 4996 4195 1.0194data10-500-4996-97 500 10 4996 4312 1.0175data10-500-4996-98 500 10 4996 4223 1.0168data10-500-4996-99 500 10 4996 4225 1.0166data10-500-4996-100 500 10 4996 4275 1.0166data10-500-4997-1 500 10 4997 4309 1.0134data10-500-4997-2 500 10 4997 4385 1.0173data10-500-4997-3 500 10 4997 4088 1.0162data10-500-4997-4 500 10 4997 4254 1.0137data10-500-4997-5 500 10 4997 4122 1.0154data10-500-4997-6 500 10 4997 4411 1.0131data10-500-4997-7 500 10 4997 4263 1.0139data10-500-4997-8 500 10 4997 4305 1.0134data10-500-4997-9 500 10 4997 4348 1.0135data10-500-4997-10 500 10 4997 4404 1.0136data10-500-4997-11 500 10 4997 4128 1.0168data10-500-4997-12 500 10 4997 4225 1.0118data10-500-4997-13 500 10 4997 4253 1.0160data10-500-4997-14 500 10 4997 4260 1.0164data10-500-4997-15 500 10 4997 4438 1.0146data10-500-4997-16 500 10 4997 4195 1.0157data10-500-4997-17 500 10 4997 4300 1.0134data10-500-4997-18 500 10 4997 4151 1.0131data10-500-4997-19 500 10 4997 4101 1.0164data10-500-4997-20 500 10 4997 4377 1.0143

Table 86: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 472: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-500-4997-21 500 10 4997 4299 1.0148data10-500-4997-22 500 10 4997 4311 1.0159data10-500-4997-23 500 10 4997 4324 1.0197data10-500-4997-24 500 10 4997 4373 1.0232data10-500-4997-25 500 10 4997 4314 1.0164data10-500-4997-26 500 10 4997 4286 1.0172data10-500-4997-27 500 10 4997 4377 1.0120data10-500-4997-28 500 10 4997 4271 1.0181data10-500-4997-29 500 10 4997 4252 1.0136data10-500-4997-30 500 10 4997 4202 1.0143data10-500-4997-31 500 10 4997 4400 1.0132data10-500-4997-32 500 10 4997 4338 1.0171data10-500-4997-33 500 10 4997 4187 1.0229data10-500-4997-34 500 10 4997 4112 1.0128data10-500-4997-35 500 10 4997 4101 1.0138data10-500-4997-36 500 10 4997 4134 1.0131data10-500-4997-37 500 10 4997 4170 1.0127data10-500-4997-38 500 10 4997 4317 1.0141data10-500-4997-39 500 10 4997 4126 1.0221data10-500-4997-40 500 10 4997 4173 1.0129data10-500-4997-41 500 10 4997 4213 1.0228data10-500-4997-42 500 10 4997 4273 1.0196data10-500-4997-43 500 10 4997 4146 1.0145data10-500-4997-44 500 10 4997 4348 1.0146data10-500-4997-45 500 10 4997 4296 1.0154data10-500-4997-46 500 10 4997 4267 1.0133data10-500-4997-47 500 10 4997 4281 1.0121data10-500-4997-48 500 10 4997 4271 1.0142data10-500-4997-49 500 10 4997 4186 1.0146data10-500-4997-50 500 10 4997 4212 1.0133data10-500-4997-51 500 10 4997 4348 1.0174data10-500-4997-52 500 10 4997 4215 1.0167data10-500-4997-53 500 10 4997 4185 1.0162data10-500-4997-54 500 10 4997 4371 1.0141data10-500-4997-55 500 10 4997 4192 1.0173data10-500-4997-56 500 10 4997 4265 1.0192data10-500-4997-57 500 10 4997 4201 1.0128data10-500-4997-58 500 10 4997 4115 1.0128data10-500-4997-59 500 10 4997 4242 1.0169data10-500-4997-60 500 10 4997 4262 1.0156data10-500-4997-61 500 10 4997 4345 1.0171data10-500-4997-62 500 10 4997 4193 1.0148data10-500-4997-63 500 10 4997 4327 1.0253data10-500-4997-64 500 10 4997 4247 1.0150data10-500-4997-65 500 10 4997 4373 1.0166data10-500-4997-66 500 10 4997 4221 1.0205data10-500-4997-67 500 10 4997 4231 1.0171data10-500-4997-68 500 10 4997 4203 1.0184data10-500-4997-69 500 10 4997 4208 1.0166data10-500-4997-70 500 10 4997 4199 1.0160data10-500-4997-71 500 10 4997 4264 1.0158data10-500-4997-72 500 10 4997 4226 1.0168data10-500-4997-73 500 10 4997 4294 1.0135data10-500-4997-74 500 10 4997 4207 1.0132data10-500-4997-75 500 10 4997 4417 1.0144data10-500-4997-76 500 10 4997 4312 1.0232data10-500-4997-77 500 10 4997 4181 1.0148data10-500-4997-78 500 10 4997 4323 1.0151data10-500-4997-79 500 10 4997 4214 1.0140data10-500-4997-80 500 10 4997 4227 1.0120data10-500-4997-81 500 10 4997 4275 1.0245data10-500-4997-82 500 10 4997 4312 1.0181data10-500-4997-83 500 10 4997 4358 1.0131data10-500-4997-84 500 10 4997 4340 1.0151data10-500-4997-85 500 10 4997 4307 1.0147data10-500-4997-86 500 10 4997 4238 1.0150data10-500-4997-87 500 10 4997 4252 1.0127data10-500-4997-88 500 10 4997 4254 1.0131data10-500-4997-89 500 10 4997 4245 1.0151data10-500-4997-90 500 10 4997 4206 1.0160

Table 87: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 473: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-500-4997-91 500 10 4997 4345 1.0132data10-500-4997-92 500 10 4997 4401 1.0163data10-500-4997-93 500 10 4997 4254 1.0214data10-500-4997-94 500 10 4997 4303 1.0208data10-500-4997-95 500 10 4997 4314 1.0169data10-500-4997-96 500 10 4997 4332 1.0175data10-500-4997-97 500 10 4997 4243 1.0161data10-500-4997-98 500 10 4997 4152 1.0166data10-500-4997-99 500 10 4997 4229 1.0171data10-500-4997-100 500 10 4997 4387 1.0138data10-500-4998-1 500 10 4998 4208 1.0229data10-500-4998-2 500 10 4998 4316 1.0161data10-500-4998-3 500 10 4998 4333 1.0229data10-500-4998-4 500 10 4998 4298 1.0139data10-500-4998-5 500 10 4998 4250 1.0143data10-500-4998-6 500 10 4998 4397 1.0166data10-500-4998-7 500 10 4998 4413 1.0170data10-500-4998-8 500 10 4998 4256 1.0176data10-500-4998-9 500 10 4998 4168 1.0166data10-500-4998-10 500 10 4998 4212 1.0226data10-500-4998-11 500 10 4998 4334 1.0166data10-500-4998-12 500 10 4998 4227 1.0123data10-500-4998-13 500 10 4998 4156 1.0198data10-500-4998-14 500 10 4998 4251 1.0126data10-500-4998-15 500 10 4998 4237 1.0149data10-500-4998-16 500 10 4998 4330 1.0157data10-500-4998-17 500 10 4998 4234 1.0189data10-500-4998-18 500 10 4998 4244 1.0196data10-500-4998-19 500 10 4998 4220 1.0148data10-500-4998-20 500 10 4998 4407 1.0135data10-500-4998-21 500 10 4998 4201 1.0123data10-500-4998-22 500 10 4998 4400 1.0244data10-500-4998-23 500 10 4998 4116 1.0118data10-500-4998-24 500 10 4998 4240 1.0154data10-500-4998-25 500 10 4998 4306 1.0160data10-500-4998-26 500 10 4998 4170 1.0198data10-500-4998-27 500 10 4998 4255 1.0124data10-500-4998-28 500 10 4998 4263 1.0258data10-500-4998-29 500 10 4998 4311 1.0166data10-500-4998-30 500 10 4998 4349 1.0174data10-500-4998-31 500 10 4998 4270 1.0247data10-500-4998-32 500 10 4998 4225 1.0166data10-500-4998-33 500 10 4998 4131 1.0122data10-500-4998-34 500 10 4998 4342 1.0182data10-500-4998-35 500 10 4998 4173 1.0209data10-500-4998-36 500 10 4998 4341 1.0232data10-500-4998-37 500 10 4998 4371 1.0123data10-500-4998-38 500 10 4998 4263 1.0147data10-500-4998-39 500 10 4998 4237 1.0155data10-500-4998-40 500 10 4998 4319 1.0141data10-500-4998-41 500 10 4998 4312 1.0164data10-500-4998-42 500 10 4998 4291 1.0257data10-500-4998-43 500 10 4998 4272 1.0164data10-500-4998-44 500 10 4998 4171 1.0160data10-500-4998-45 500 10 4998 4345 1.0169data10-500-4998-46 500 10 4998 4199 1.0135data10-500-4998-47 500 10 4998 4265 1.0179data10-500-4998-48 500 10 4998 4388 1.0186data10-500-4998-49 500 10 4998 4075 1.0137data10-500-4998-50 500 10 4998 4443 1.0157data10-500-4998-51 500 10 4998 4175 1.0137data10-500-4998-52 500 10 4998 4293 1.0208data10-500-4998-53 500 10 4998 4312 1.0165data10-500-4998-54 500 10 4998 4367 1.0206data10-500-4998-55 500 10 4998 4284 1.0146data10-500-4998-56 500 10 4998 4286 1.0143data10-500-4998-57 500 10 4998 4203 1.0132data10-500-4998-58 500 10 4998 4328 1.0119data10-500-4998-59 500 10 4998 4342 1.0159data10-500-4998-60 500 10 4998 4312 1.0163

Table 88: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 474: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-500-4998-61 500 10 4998 4309 1.0131data10-500-4998-62 500 10 4998 4190 1.0135data10-500-4998-63 500 10 4998 4465 1.0126data10-500-4998-64 500 10 4998 4239 1.0150data10-500-4998-65 500 10 4998 4142 1.0254data10-500-4998-66 500 10 4998 4223 1.0221data10-500-4998-67 500 10 4998 4318 1.0173data10-500-4998-68 500 10 4998 4239 1.0187data10-500-4998-69 500 10 4998 4148 1.0153data10-500-4998-70 500 10 4998 4296 1.0201data10-500-4998-71 500 10 4998 4300 1.0122data10-500-4998-72 500 10 4998 4271 1.0133data10-500-4998-73 500 10 4998 4176 1.0151data10-500-4998-74 500 10 4998 4213 1.0144data10-500-4998-75 500 10 4998 4309 1.0118data10-500-4998-76 500 10 4998 4262 1.0142data10-500-4998-77 500 10 4998 4076 1.0121data10-500-4998-78 500 10 4998 4298 1.0147data10-500-4998-79 500 10 4998 4217 1.0149data10-500-4998-80 500 10 4998 4354 1.0134data10-500-4998-81 500 10 4998 4346 1.0164data10-500-4998-82 500 10 4998 4174 1.0259data10-500-4998-83 500 10 4998 4254 1.0136data10-500-4998-84 500 10 4998 4166 1.0190data10-500-4998-85 500 10 4998 4238 1.0162data10-500-4998-86 500 10 4998 4334 1.0196data10-500-4998-87 500 10 4998 4326 1.0160data10-500-4998-88 500 10 4998 4217 1.0142data10-500-4998-89 500 10 4998 4283 1.0166data10-500-4998-90 500 10 4998 4318 1.0121data10-500-4998-91 500 10 4998 4407 1.0203data10-500-4998-92 500 10 4998 4207 1.0247data10-500-4998-93 500 10 4998 4351 1.0170data10-500-4998-94 500 10 4998 4194 1.0171data10-500-4998-95 500 10 4998 4452 1.0182data10-500-4998-96 500 10 4998 4230 1.0177data10-500-4998-97 500 10 4998 4140 1.0153data10-500-4998-98 500 10 4998 4297 1.0129data10-500-4998-99 500 10 4998 4169 1.0205data10-500-4998-100 500 10 4998 4366 1.0187data10-500-4999-1 500 10 4999 4418 1.0154data10-500-4999-2 500 10 4999 4395 1.0134data10-500-4999-3 500 10 4999 4344 1.0131data10-500-4999-4 500 10 4999 3991 1.0129data10-500-4999-5 500 10 4999 4229 1.0146data10-500-4999-6 500 10 4999 4291 1.0131data10-500-4999-7 500 10 4999 3939 1.0167data10-500-4999-8 500 10 4999 4405 1.0237data10-500-4999-9 500 10 4999 4294 1.0168data10-500-4999-10 500 10 4999 4201 1.0160data10-500-4999-11 500 10 4999 4243 1.0127data10-500-4999-12 500 10 4999 4242 1.0165data10-500-4999-13 500 10 4999 4367 1.0130data10-500-4999-14 500 10 4999 4321 1.0191data10-500-4999-15 500 10 4999 4099 1.0176data10-500-4999-16 500 10 4999 4081 1.0124data10-500-4999-17 500 10 4999 4075 1.0204data10-500-4999-18 500 10 4999 4228 1.0225data10-500-4999-19 500 10 4999 4242 1.0127data10-500-4999-20 500 10 4999 4266 1.0149data10-500-4999-21 500 10 4999 4267 1.0143data10-500-4999-22 500 10 4999 4219 1.0137data10-500-4999-23 500 10 4999 4171 1.0151data10-500-4999-24 500 10 4999 4488 1.0142data10-500-4999-25 500 10 4999 4082 1.0133data10-500-4999-26 500 10 4999 4358 1.0140data10-500-4999-27 500 10 4999 4274 1.0147data10-500-4999-28 500 10 4999 4251 1.0151data10-500-4999-29 500 10 4999 4333 1.0146data10-500-4999-30 500 10 4999 4147 1.0173

Table 89: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 475: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-500-4999-31 500 10 4999 4161 1.0153data10-500-4999-32 500 10 4999 4172 1.0247data10-500-4999-33 500 10 4999 4288 1.0151data10-500-4999-34 500 10 4999 4081 1.0230data10-500-4999-35 500 10 4999 4294 1.0148data10-500-4999-36 500 10 4999 4141 1.0212data10-500-4999-37 500 10 4999 4240 1.0133data10-500-4999-38 500 10 4999 4234 1.0207data10-500-4999-39 500 10 4999 4153 1.0230data10-500-4999-40 500 10 4999 4288 1.0185data10-500-4999-41 500 10 4999 4247 1.0129data10-500-4999-42 500 10 4999 4324 1.0180data10-500-4999-43 500 10 4999 4366 1.0141data10-500-4999-44 500 10 4999 4202 1.0227data10-500-4999-45 500 10 4999 4295 1.0122data10-500-4999-46 500 10 4999 4187 1.0185data10-500-4999-47 500 10 4999 4394 1.0151data10-500-4999-48 500 10 4999 4332 1.0121data10-500-4999-49 500 10 4999 4190 1.0127data10-500-4999-50 500 10 4999 4341 1.0118data10-500-4999-51 500 10 4999 4307 1.0176data10-500-4999-52 500 10 4999 4187 1.0139data10-500-4999-53 500 10 4999 4348 1.0144data10-500-4999-54 500 10 4999 4270 1.0170data10-500-4999-55 500 10 4999 4145 1.0256data10-500-4999-56 500 10 4999 4297 1.0162data10-500-4999-57 500 10 4999 4255 1.0150data10-500-4999-58 500 10 4999 4229 1.0120data10-500-4999-59 500 10 4999 4170 1.0174data10-500-4999-60 500 10 4999 4211 1.0149data10-500-4999-61 500 10 4999 4243 1.0155data10-500-4999-62 500 10 4999 4248 1.0146data10-500-4999-63 500 10 4999 4291 1.0180data10-500-4999-64 500 10 4999 4095 1.0162data10-500-4999-65 500 10 4999 4382 1.0180data10-500-4999-66 500 10 4999 4314 1.0233data10-500-4999-67 500 10 4999 4294 1.0135data10-500-4999-68 500 10 4999 4202 1.0183data10-500-4999-69 500 10 4999 4308 1.0135data10-500-4999-70 500 10 4999 4294 1.0162data10-500-4999-71 500 10 4999 4159 1.0154data10-500-4999-72 500 10 4999 4142 1.0225data10-500-4999-73 500 10 4999 4320 1.0136data10-500-4999-74 500 10 4999 4164 1.0187data10-500-4999-75 500 10 4999 4205 1.0165data10-500-4999-76 500 10 4999 4408 1.0128data10-500-4999-77 500 10 4999 4172 1.0185data10-500-4999-78 500 10 4999 4302 1.0130data10-500-4999-79 500 10 4999 4215 1.0183data10-500-4999-80 500 10 4999 4088 1.0217data10-500-4999-81 500 10 4999 4286 1.0151data10-500-4999-82 500 10 4999 4249 1.0128data10-500-4999-83 500 10 4999 4260 1.0157data10-500-4999-84 500 10 4999 4180 1.0143data10-500-4999-85 500 10 4999 4268 1.0189data10-500-4999-86 500 10 4999 4338 1.0118data10-500-4999-87 500 10 4999 4342 1.0138data10-500-4999-88 500 10 4999 4351 1.0140data10-500-4999-89 500 10 4999 4270 1.0125data10-500-4999-90 500 10 4999 4215 1.0142data10-500-4999-91 500 10 4999 4349 1.0161data10-500-4999-92 500 10 4999 4104 1.0197data10-500-4999-93 500 10 4999 4237 1.0141data10-500-4999-94 500 10 4999 4343 1.0184data10-500-4999-95 500 10 4999 4508 1.0142data10-500-4999-96 500 10 4999 4232 1.0158data10-500-4999-97 500 10 4999 4222 1.0180data10-500-4999-98 500 10 4999 4239 1.0121data10-500-4999-99 500 10 4999 4373 1.0181data10-500-4999-100 500 10 4999 4420 1.0154

Table 90: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 476: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-1000-3996-1 1000 4 3996 1918 1.0123data4-1000-3996-2 1000 4 3996 1935 1.0167data4-1000-3996-3 1000 4 3996 1902 1.0183data4-1000-3996-4 1000 4 3996 1932 1.0166data4-1000-3996-5 1000 4 3996 1939 1.0126data4-1000-3996-6 1000 4 3996 1924 1.0110data4-1000-3996-7 1000 4 3996 1959 0.0326data4-1000-3996-8 1000 4 3996 1882 1.0121data4-1000-3996-9 1000 4 3996 1932 1.0178data4-1000-3996-10 1000 4 3996 1917 1.0147data4-1000-3996-11 1000 4 3996 1938 1.0170data4-1000-3996-12 1000 4 3996 1937 0.0602data4-1000-3996-13 1000 4 3996 1944 1.0176data4-1000-3996-14 1000 4 3996 1883 1.0175data4-1000-3996-15 1000 4 3996 1954 1.0144data4-1000-3996-16 1000 4 3996 1932 1.0138data4-1000-3996-17 1000 4 3996 1848 1.0213data4-1000-3996-18 1000 4 3996 1937 1.0157data4-1000-3996-19 1000 4 3996 1909 0.1848data4-1000-3996-20 1000 4 3996 1942 1.0190data4-1000-3996-21 1000 4 3996 1937 1.0137data4-1000-3996-22 1000 4 3996 1926 1.0123data4-1000-3996-23 1000 4 3996 1926 1.0144data4-1000-3996-24 1000 4 3996 1883 1.0183data4-1000-3996-25 1000 4 3996 1921 1.0148data4-1000-3996-26 1000 4 3996 1922 1.0211data4-1000-3996-27 1000 4 3996 1977 0.2194data4-1000-3996-28 1000 4 3996 1904 1.0165data4-1000-3996-29 1000 4 3996 1898 1.0217data4-1000-3996-30 1000 4 3996 1890 1.0119data4-1000-3996-31 1000 4 3996 1885 1.0138data4-1000-3996-32 1000 4 3996 1924 1.0191data4-1000-3996-33 1000 4 3996 1931 1.0148data4-1000-3996-34 1000 4 3996 1932 1.0153data4-1000-3996-35 1000 4 3996 1957 1.0190data4-1000-3996-36 1000 4 3996 1904 1.0170data4-1000-3996-37 1000 4 3996 1876 1.0138data4-1000-3996-38 1000 4 3996 1893 1.0132data4-1000-3996-39 1000 4 3996 1920 1.0172data4-1000-3996-40 1000 4 3996 1913 1.0116data4-1000-3996-41 1000 4 3996 1940 1.0107data4-1000-3996-42 1000 4 3996 1876 1.0187data4-1000-3996-43 1000 4 3996 1908 1.0163data4-1000-3996-44 1000 4 3996 1916 1.0128data4-1000-3996-45 1000 4 3996 1896 1.0180data4-1000-3996-46 1000 4 3996 1953 1.0159data4-1000-3996-47 1000 4 3996 1916 1.0166data4-1000-3996-48 1000 4 3996 1919 1.0164data4-1000-3996-49 1000 4 3996 1974 1.0112data4-1000-3996-50 1000 4 3996 1952 1.0185data4-1000-3996-51 1000 4 3996 1950 1.0122data4-1000-3996-52 1000 4 3996 1937 1.0153data4-1000-3996-53 1000 4 3996 1928 1.0166data4-1000-3996-54 1000 4 3996 1916 1.0157data4-1000-3996-55 1000 4 3996 1879 1.0152data4-1000-3996-56 1000 4 3996 1935 1.0159data4-1000-3996-57 1000 4 3996 1943 1.0153data4-1000-3996-58 1000 4 3996 1902 0.0328data4-1000-3996-59 1000 4 3996 1899 1.0209data4-1000-3996-60 1000 4 3996 1952 1.0165data4-1000-3996-61 1000 4 3996 1940 1.0205data4-1000-3996-62 1000 4 3996 1932 1.0183data4-1000-3996-63 1000 4 3996 1925 1.0106data4-1000-3996-64 1000 4 3996 1952 1.0189data4-1000-3996-65 1000 4 3996 1912 1.0140data4-1000-3996-66 1000 4 3996 1941 1.0111data4-1000-3996-67 1000 4 3996 1909 1.0127data4-1000-3996-68 1000 4 3996 1935 1.0219data4-1000-3996-69 1000 4 3996 1874 0.8862data4-1000-3996-70 1000 4 3996 1922 1.0138

Table 91: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 477: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-1000-3996-71 1000 4 3996 1944 1.0166data4-1000-3996-72 1000 4 3996 1961 1.0161data4-1000-3996-73 1000 4 3996 1958 1.0171data4-1000-3996-74 1000 4 3996 1952 1.0159data4-1000-3996-75 1000 4 3996 1889 1.0172data4-1000-3996-76 1000 4 3996 1913 1.0184data4-1000-3996-77 1000 4 3996 1923 1.0162data4-1000-3996-78 1000 4 3996 1947 1.0150data4-1000-3996-79 1000 4 3996 1908 1.0191data4-1000-3996-80 1000 4 3996 1894 0.0335data4-1000-3996-81 1000 4 3996 1973 1.0191data4-1000-3996-82 1000 4 3996 1943 0.2127data4-1000-3996-83 1000 4 3996 1879 1.0154data4-1000-3996-84 1000 4 3996 1909 1.0112data4-1000-3996-85 1000 4 3996 1905 1.0162data4-1000-3996-86 1000 4 3996 1928 1.0196data4-1000-3996-87 1000 4 3996 1903 1.0178data4-1000-3996-88 1000 4 3996 1918 1.0122data4-1000-3996-89 1000 4 3996 1948 1.0155data4-1000-3996-90 1000 4 3996 1871 1.0186data4-1000-3996-91 1000 4 3996 1897 1.0155data4-1000-3996-92 1000 4 3996 1965 1.0153data4-1000-3996-93 1000 4 3996 1872 1.0166data4-1000-3996-94 1000 4 3996 1944 1.0136data4-1000-3996-95 1000 4 3996 1906 1.0192data4-1000-3996-96 1000 4 3996 1951 1.0163data4-1000-3996-97 1000 4 3996 1889 1.0205data4-1000-3996-98 1000 4 3996 1887 1.0112data4-1000-3996-99 1000 4 3996 1951 1.0185data4-1000-3996-100 1000 4 3996 1928 1.0208data4-1000-3997-1 1000 4 3997 1933 1.0163data4-1000-3997-2 1000 4 3997 1929 1.0159data4-1000-3997-3 1000 4 3997 1892 1.0185data4-1000-3997-4 1000 4 3997 1897 1.0199data4-1000-3997-5 1000 4 3997 1953 1.0183data4-1000-3997-6 1000 4 3997 1890 0.0517data4-1000-3997-7 1000 4 3997 1929 1.0108data4-1000-3997-8 1000 4 3997 1937 1.0118data4-1000-3997-9 1000 4 3997 1948 1.0154data4-1000-3997-10 1000 4 3997 1917 0.0329data4-1000-3997-11 1000 4 3997 1950 1.0193data4-1000-3997-12 1000 4 3997 1910 1.0175data4-1000-3997-13 1000 4 3997 1933 0.7730data4-1000-3997-14 1000 4 3997 1924 1.0138data4-1000-3997-15 1000 4 3997 1902 1.0110data4-1000-3997-16 1000 4 3997 1915 1.0186data4-1000-3997-17 1000 4 3997 1926 1.0171data4-1000-3997-18 1000 4 3997 1912 1.0167data4-1000-3997-19 1000 4 3997 1914 1.0121data4-1000-3997-20 1000 4 3997 1906 0.0330data4-1000-3997-21 1000 4 3997 1894 1.0199data4-1000-3997-22 1000 4 3997 1887 1.0132data4-1000-3997-23 1000 4 3997 1941 1.0156data4-1000-3997-24 1000 4 3997 1937 1.0140data4-1000-3997-25 1000 4 3997 1898 0.0328data4-1000-3997-26 1000 4 3997 1930 1.0125data4-1000-3997-27 1000 4 3997 1952 1.0210data4-1000-3997-28 1000 4 3997 1918 1.0141data4-1000-3997-29 1000 4 3997 1956 1.0151data4-1000-3997-30 1000 4 3997 1884 1.0149data4-1000-3997-31 1000 4 3997 1902 1.0177data4-1000-3997-32 1000 4 3997 1936 1.0135data4-1000-3997-33 1000 4 3997 1950 1.0116data4-1000-3997-34 1000 4 3997 1939 1.0181data4-1000-3997-35 1000 4 3997 1901 1.0158data4-1000-3997-36 1000 4 3997 1925 1.0130data4-1000-3997-37 1000 4 3997 1937 1.0168data4-1000-3997-38 1000 4 3997 1930 1.0190data4-1000-3997-39 1000 4 3997 1927 1.0128data4-1000-3997-40 1000 4 3997 1935 1.0141

Table 92: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 478: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-1000-3997-41 1000 4 3997 1969 1.0165data4-1000-3997-42 1000 4 3997 1921 1.0131data4-1000-3997-43 1000 4 3997 1920 1.0232data4-1000-3997-44 1000 4 3997 1926 1.0187data4-1000-3997-45 1000 4 3997 1958 1.0178data4-1000-3997-46 1000 4 3997 1933 0.0324data4-1000-3997-47 1000 4 3997 1927 1.0152data4-1000-3997-48 1000 4 3997 1939 0.0433data4-1000-3997-49 1000 4 3997 1923 1.0189data4-1000-3997-50 1000 4 3997 1962 1.0193data4-1000-3997-51 1000 4 3997 1904 1.0175data4-1000-3997-52 1000 4 3997 1921 1.0121data4-1000-3997-53 1000 4 3997 1897 1.0145data4-1000-3997-54 1000 4 3997 1875 1.0199data4-1000-3997-55 1000 4 3997 1935 0.0608data4-1000-3997-56 1000 4 3997 1955 1.0168data4-1000-3997-57 1000 4 3997 1895 1.0163data4-1000-3997-58 1000 4 3997 1880 1.0150data4-1000-3997-59 1000 4 3997 1917 1.0209data4-1000-3997-60 1000 4 3997 1930 0.0329data4-1000-3997-61 1000 4 3997 1926 1.0166data4-1000-3997-62 1000 4 3997 1905 1.0121data4-1000-3997-63 1000 4 3997 1924 1.0176data4-1000-3997-64 1000 4 3997 1919 1.0146data4-1000-3997-65 1000 4 3997 1910 0.0325data4-1000-3997-66 1000 4 3997 1908 1.0223data4-1000-3997-67 1000 4 3997 1921 1.0158data4-1000-3997-68 1000 4 3997 1926 1.0121data4-1000-3997-69 1000 4 3997 1952 1.0121data4-1000-3997-70 1000 4 3997 1889 1.0220data4-1000-3997-71 1000 4 3997 1917 1.0165data4-1000-3997-72 1000 4 3997 1888 1.0197data4-1000-3997-73 1000 4 3997 1947 1.0154data4-1000-3997-74 1000 4 3997 1887 1.0193data4-1000-3997-75 1000 4 3997 1932 1.0121data4-1000-3997-76 1000 4 3997 1905 1.0118data4-1000-3997-77 1000 4 3997 1924 0.5350data4-1000-3997-78 1000 4 3997 1924 1.0180data4-1000-3997-79 1000 4 3997 1915 0.0415data4-1000-3997-80 1000 4 3997 1910 1.0135data4-1000-3997-81 1000 4 3997 1936 1.0183data4-1000-3997-82 1000 4 3997 1931 1.0140data4-1000-3997-83 1000 4 3997 1945 1.0132data4-1000-3997-84 1000 4 3997 1920 1.0108data4-1000-3997-85 1000 4 3997 1961 1.0165data4-1000-3997-86 1000 4 3997 1921 1.0159data4-1000-3997-87 1000 4 3997 1917 1.0160data4-1000-3997-88 1000 4 3997 1894 1.0149data4-1000-3997-89 1000 4 3997 1895 1.0136data4-1000-3997-90 1000 4 3997 1939 1.0190data4-1000-3997-91 1000 4 3997 1942 1.0175data4-1000-3997-92 1000 4 3997 1905 1.0109data4-1000-3997-93 1000 4 3997 1907 1.0113data4-1000-3997-94 1000 4 3997 1961 1.0168data4-1000-3997-95 1000 4 3997 1972 1.0212data4-1000-3997-96 1000 4 3997 1900 0.4186data4-1000-3997-97 1000 4 3997 1919 0.0868data4-1000-3997-98 1000 4 3997 1909 1.0165data4-1000-3997-99 1000 4 3997 1918 1.0128data4-1000-3997-100 1000 4 3997 1896 1.0199data4-1000-3998-1 1000 4 3998 1951 0.0593data4-1000-3998-2 1000 4 3998 1958 1.0132data4-1000-3998-3 1000 4 3998 1920 1.0186data4-1000-3998-4 1000 4 3998 1928 1.0180data4-1000-3998-5 1000 4 3998 1913 0.1591data4-1000-3998-6 1000 4 3998 1976 1.0181data4-1000-3998-7 1000 4 3998 1922 1.0183data4-1000-3998-8 1000 4 3998 1909 1.0110data4-1000-3998-9 1000 4 3998 1925 0.0323data4-1000-3998-10 1000 4 3998 1940 1.0124

Table 93: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 479: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-1000-3998-11 1000 4 3998 1910 1.0180data4-1000-3998-12 1000 4 3998 1909 1.0204data4-1000-3998-13 1000 4 3998 1925 1.0186data4-1000-3998-14 1000 4 3998 1922 1.0174data4-1000-3998-15 1000 4 3998 1930 1.0170data4-1000-3998-16 1000 4 3998 1973 1.0212data4-1000-3998-17 1000 4 3998 2014 1.0135data4-1000-3998-18 1000 4 3998 1914 1.0138data4-1000-3998-19 1000 4 3998 1922 1.0118data4-1000-3998-20 1000 4 3998 1891 1.0185data4-1000-3998-21 1000 4 3998 1937 1.0108data4-1000-3998-22 1000 4 3998 1931 1.0148data4-1000-3998-23 1000 4 3998 1902 1.0126data4-1000-3998-24 1000 4 3998 1932 1.0198data4-1000-3998-25 1000 4 3998 1916 1.0175data4-1000-3998-26 1000 4 3998 1924 1.0187data4-1000-3998-27 1000 4 3998 1953 1.0130data4-1000-3998-28 1000 4 3998 1920 1.0159data4-1000-3998-29 1000 4 3998 1918 1.0150data4-1000-3998-30 1000 4 3998 1924 1.0140data4-1000-3998-31 1000 4 3998 1919 0.3099data4-1000-3998-32 1000 4 3998 1947 0.0328data4-1000-3998-33 1000 4 3998 1934 1.0140data4-1000-3998-34 1000 4 3998 1944 1.0149data4-1000-3998-35 1000 4 3998 1930 1.0161data4-1000-3998-36 1000 4 3998 1907 1.0191data4-1000-3998-37 1000 4 3998 1945 1.0206data4-1000-3998-38 1000 4 3998 1900 1.0113data4-1000-3998-39 1000 4 3998 1891 1.0205data4-1000-3998-40 1000 4 3998 1909 1.0163data4-1000-3998-41 1000 4 3998 1942 1.0144data4-1000-3998-42 1000 4 3998 1884 1.0136data4-1000-3998-43 1000 4 3998 1943 1.0128data4-1000-3998-44 1000 4 3998 1939 1.0195data4-1000-3998-45 1000 4 3998 1883 0.0505data4-1000-3998-46 1000 4 3998 1914 1.0162data4-1000-3998-47 1000 4 3998 1910 0.6267data4-1000-3998-48 1000 4 3998 1915 1.0159data4-1000-3998-49 1000 4 3998 1898 1.0188data4-1000-3998-50 1000 4 3998 1881 1.0190data4-1000-3998-51 1000 4 3998 1920 1.0125data4-1000-3998-52 1000 4 3998 1931 1.0180data4-1000-3998-53 1000 4 3998 1937 0.0336data4-1000-3998-54 1000 4 3998 1906 1.0155data4-1000-3998-55 1000 4 3998 1903 1.0141data4-1000-3998-56 1000 4 3998 1947 1.0125data4-1000-3998-57 1000 4 3998 1898 1.0163data4-1000-3998-58 1000 4 3998 1908 1.0146data4-1000-3998-59 1000 4 3998 1829 0.0327data4-1000-3998-60 1000 4 3998 1960 1.0128data4-1000-3998-61 1000 4 3998 1941 1.0128data4-1000-3998-62 1000 4 3998 1940 1.0193data4-1000-3998-63 1000 4 3998 1918 1.0133data4-1000-3998-64 1000 4 3998 1891 1.0117data4-1000-3998-65 1000 4 3998 1908 0.0325data4-1000-3998-66 1000 4 3998 1902 1.0142data4-1000-3998-67 1000 4 3998 1926 1.0123data4-1000-3998-68 1000 4 3998 1937 1.0163data4-1000-3998-69 1000 4 3998 1904 1.0184data4-1000-3998-70 1000 4 3998 1908 0.0330data4-1000-3998-71 1000 4 3998 1904 1.0171data4-1000-3998-72 1000 4 3998 1917 1.0127data4-1000-3998-73 1000 4 3998 1934 1.0139data4-1000-3998-74 1000 4 3998 1904 1.0111data4-1000-3998-75 1000 4 3998 1925 1.0157data4-1000-3998-76 1000 4 3998 1935 1.0114data4-1000-3998-77 1000 4 3998 1941 0.0342data4-1000-3998-78 1000 4 3998 1897 1.0155data4-1000-3998-79 1000 4 3998 1926 1.0166data4-1000-3998-80 1000 4 3998 1904 1.0148

Table 94: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 480: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-1000-3998-81 1000 4 3998 1926 0.7626data4-1000-3998-82 1000 4 3998 1911 1.0154data4-1000-3998-83 1000 4 3998 1932 1.0140data4-1000-3998-84 1000 4 3998 1913 1.0172data4-1000-3998-85 1000 4 3998 1933 1.0122data4-1000-3998-86 1000 4 3998 1930 1.0178data4-1000-3998-87 1000 4 3998 1919 1.0113data4-1000-3998-88 1000 4 3998 1920 1.0140data4-1000-3998-89 1000 4 3998 1909 0.6361data4-1000-3998-90 1000 4 3998 1932 1.0148data4-1000-3998-91 1000 4 3998 1937 1.0173data4-1000-3998-92 1000 4 3998 1914 0.2243data4-1000-3998-93 1000 4 3998 1988 1.0158data4-1000-3998-94 1000 4 3998 1920 1.0169data4-1000-3998-95 1000 4 3998 1930 1.0197data4-1000-3998-96 1000 4 3998 1956 1.0126data4-1000-3998-97 1000 4 3998 1885 1.0206data4-1000-3998-98 1000 4 3998 1923 1.0114data4-1000-3998-99 1000 4 3998 1928 1.0129data4-1000-3998-100 1000 4 3998 1896 1.0125data4-1000-3999-1 1000 4 3999 1882 1.0161data4-1000-3999-2 1000 4 3999 1953 0.2609data4-1000-3999-3 1000 4 3999 1966 1.0143data4-1000-3999-4 1000 4 3999 1932 1.0193data4-1000-3999-5 1000 4 3999 1939 1.0142data4-1000-3999-6 1000 4 3999 1922 1.0136data4-1000-3999-7 1000 4 3999 1908 1.0168data4-1000-3999-8 1000 4 3999 1932 1.0107data4-1000-3999-9 1000 4 3999 1920 1.0212data4-1000-3999-10 1000 4 3999 1909 1.0196data4-1000-3999-11 1000 4 3999 1950 1.0149data4-1000-3999-12 1000 4 3999 1901 1.0154data4-1000-3999-13 1000 4 3999 1932 1.0114data4-1000-3999-14 1000 4 3999 1899 1.0196data4-1000-3999-15 1000 4 3999 1911 1.0178data4-1000-3999-16 1000 4 3999 1888 0.6474data4-1000-3999-17 1000 4 3999 1939 1.0134data4-1000-3999-18 1000 4 3999 1919 0.0501data4-1000-3999-19 1000 4 3999 1894 1.0162data4-1000-3999-20 1000 4 3999 1897 1.0179data4-1000-3999-21 1000 4 3999 1946 1.0157data4-1000-3999-22 1000 4 3999 1914 1.0155data4-1000-3999-23 1000 4 3999 1889 1.0146data4-1000-3999-24 1000 4 3999 1937 0.0590data4-1000-3999-25 1000 4 3999 1949 1.0148data4-1000-3999-26 1000 4 3999 1935 1.0192data4-1000-3999-27 1000 4 3999 1969 1.0217data4-1000-3999-28 1000 4 3999 1944 1.0165data4-1000-3999-29 1000 4 3999 1913 1.0172data4-1000-3999-30 1000 4 3999 1953 1.0160data4-1000-3999-31 1000 4 3999 1924 0.5616data4-1000-3999-32 1000 4 3999 1951 1.0116data4-1000-3999-33 1000 4 3999 1934 1.0188data4-1000-3999-34 1000 4 3999 1922 1.0125data4-1000-3999-35 1000 4 3999 1913 1.0163data4-1000-3999-36 1000 4 3999 1915 1.0161data4-1000-3999-37 1000 4 3999 1912 1.0154data4-1000-3999-38 1000 4 3999 1915 1.0120data4-1000-3999-39 1000 4 3999 1866 1.0124data4-1000-3999-40 1000 4 3999 1934 1.0217data4-1000-3999-41 1000 4 3999 1933 1.0187data4-1000-3999-42 1000 4 3999 1916 1.0139data4-1000-3999-43 1000 4 3999 1923 1.0208data4-1000-3999-44 1000 4 3999 1897 1.0114data4-1000-3999-45 1000 4 3999 1880 1.0116data4-1000-3999-46 1000 4 3999 1941 0.2342data4-1000-3999-47 1000 4 3999 1905 0.0607data4-1000-3999-48 1000 4 3999 1907 1.0190data4-1000-3999-49 1000 4 3999 1934 0.0767data4-1000-3999-50 1000 4 3999 1916 1.0117

Table 95: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 481: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata4-1000-3999-51 1000 4 3999 1939 1.0187data4-1000-3999-52 1000 4 3999 1975 1.0187data4-1000-3999-53 1000 4 3999 1946 1.0144data4-1000-3999-54 1000 4 3999 1908 1.0165data4-1000-3999-55 1000 4 3999 1930 1.0121data4-1000-3999-56 1000 4 3999 1928 1.0106data4-1000-3999-57 1000 4 3999 1919 0.3643data4-1000-3999-58 1000 4 3999 1942 1.0167data4-1000-3999-59 1000 4 3999 1917 1.0192data4-1000-3999-60 1000 4 3999 1904 1.0113data4-1000-3999-61 1000 4 3999 1973 1.0178data4-1000-3999-62 1000 4 3999 1922 1.0131data4-1000-3999-63 1000 4 3999 1909 1.0137data4-1000-3999-64 1000 4 3999 1911 1.0126data4-1000-3999-65 1000 4 3999 1948 1.0143data4-1000-3999-66 1000 4 3999 1859 1.0125data4-1000-3999-67 1000 4 3999 1906 1.0107data4-1000-3999-68 1000 4 3999 1930 1.0181data4-1000-3999-69 1000 4 3999 1939 1.0192data4-1000-3999-70 1000 4 3999 1909 1.0201data4-1000-3999-71 1000 4 3999 1900 1.0195data4-1000-3999-72 1000 4 3999 1872 1.0109data4-1000-3999-73 1000 4 3999 1951 1.0189data4-1000-3999-74 1000 4 3999 1957 1.0134data4-1000-3999-75 1000 4 3999 1970 0.8057data4-1000-3999-76 1000 4 3999 1925 1.0145data4-1000-3999-77 1000 4 3999 1914 1.0140data4-1000-3999-78 1000 4 3999 1946 1.0202data4-1000-3999-79 1000 4 3999 1903 1.0127data4-1000-3999-80 1000 4 3999 1876 1.0144data4-1000-3999-81 1000 4 3999 1901 1.0154data4-1000-3999-82 1000 4 3999 1898 1.0131data4-1000-3999-83 1000 4 3999 1891 1.0131data4-1000-3999-84 1000 4 3999 1916 1.0117data4-1000-3999-85 1000 4 3999 1917 1.0173data4-1000-3999-86 1000 4 3999 1938 1.0153data4-1000-3999-87 1000 4 3999 1880 1.0129data4-1000-3999-88 1000 4 3999 1934 1.0153data4-1000-3999-89 1000 4 3999 1909 1.0180data4-1000-3999-90 1000 4 3999 1909 1.0150data4-1000-3999-91 1000 4 3999 1911 1.0145data4-1000-3999-92 1000 4 3999 1943 0.2505data4-1000-3999-93 1000 4 3999 1896 1.0157data4-1000-3999-94 1000 4 3999 1935 1.0185data4-1000-3999-95 1000 4 3999 1922 1.0163data4-1000-3999-96 1000 4 3999 1929 0.6222data4-1000-3999-97 1000 4 3999 1927 1.0121data4-1000-3999-98 1000 4 3999 1869 1.0128data4-1000-3999-99 1000 4 3999 1907 1.0181data4-1000-3999-100 1000 4 3999 1952 1.0175data7-1000-6993-1 1000 7 6993 4552 1.0386data7-1000-6993-2 1000 7 6993 4568 1.0187data7-1000-6993-3 1000 7 6993 4504 1.0462data7-1000-6993-4 1000 7 6993 4497 1.0192data7-1000-6993-5 1000 7 6993 4547 1.0461data7-1000-6993-6 1000 7 6993 4520 1.0457data7-1000-6993-7 1000 7 6993 4592 1.0395data7-1000-6993-8 1000 7 6993 4495 1.0268data7-1000-6993-9 1000 7 6993 4561 1.0196data7-1000-6993-10 1000 7 6993 4547 1.0252data7-1000-6993-11 1000 7 6993 4551 1.0251data7-1000-6993-12 1000 7 6993 4481 1.0293data7-1000-6993-13 1000 7 6993 4540 1.0360data7-1000-6993-14 1000 7 6993 4520 1.0234data7-1000-6993-15 1000 7 6993 4550 1.0226data7-1000-6993-16 1000 7 6993 4514 1.0236data7-1000-6993-17 1000 7 6993 4451 1.0429data7-1000-6993-18 1000 7 6993 4501 1.0413data7-1000-6993-19 1000 7 6993 4500 1.0241data7-1000-6993-20 1000 7 6993 4544 1.0313

Table 96: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 482: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-1000-6993-21 1000 7 6993 4606 1.0186data7-1000-6993-22 1000 7 6993 4596 1.0388data7-1000-6993-23 1000 7 6993 4532 1.0347data7-1000-6993-24 1000 7 6993 4556 1.0412data7-1000-6993-25 1000 7 6993 4534 1.0249data7-1000-6993-26 1000 7 6993 4599 1.0196data7-1000-6993-27 1000 7 6993 4522 1.0236data7-1000-6993-28 1000 7 6993 4621 1.0340data7-1000-6993-29 1000 7 6993 4567 1.0194data7-1000-6993-30 1000 7 6993 4448 1.0428data7-1000-6993-31 1000 7 6993 4572 1.0215data7-1000-6993-32 1000 7 6993 4557 1.0352data7-1000-6993-33 1000 7 6993 4553 1.0315data7-1000-6993-34 1000 7 6993 4563 1.0216data7-1000-6993-35 1000 7 6993 4534 1.0216data7-1000-6993-36 1000 7 6993 4509 1.0324data7-1000-6993-37 1000 7 6993 4668 1.0329data7-1000-6993-38 1000 7 6993 4472 1.0259data7-1000-6993-39 1000 7 6993 4497 1.0398data7-1000-6993-40 1000 7 6993 4487 1.0252data7-1000-6993-41 1000 7 6993 4574 1.0380data7-1000-6993-42 1000 7 6993 4579 1.0413data7-1000-6993-43 1000 7 6993 4624 1.0227data7-1000-6993-44 1000 7 6993 4495 1.0240data7-1000-6993-45 1000 7 6993 4495 1.0360data7-1000-6993-46 1000 7 6993 4512 1.0200data7-1000-6993-47 1000 7 6993 4470 1.0209data7-1000-6993-48 1000 7 6993 4542 1.0259data7-1000-6993-49 1000 7 6993 4582 1.0318data7-1000-6993-50 1000 7 6993 4559 1.0363data7-1000-6993-51 1000 7 6993 4495 1.0239data7-1000-6993-52 1000 7 6993 4536 1.0193data7-1000-6993-53 1000 7 6993 4519 1.0373data7-1000-6993-54 1000 7 6993 4514 1.0186data7-1000-6993-55 1000 7 6993 4520 1.0217data7-1000-6993-56 1000 7 6993 4515 1.0360data7-1000-6993-57 1000 7 6993 4543 1.0193data7-1000-6993-58 1000 7 6993 4554 1.0229data7-1000-6993-59 1000 7 6993 4541 1.0422data7-1000-6993-60 1000 7 6993 4540 1.0397data7-1000-6993-61 1000 7 6993 4603 1.0370data7-1000-6993-62 1000 7 6993 4537 1.0291data7-1000-6993-63 1000 7 6993 4503 1.0186data7-1000-6993-64 1000 7 6993 4516 1.0349data7-1000-6993-65 1000 7 6993 4515 1.0382data7-1000-6993-66 1000 7 6993 4553 1.0354data7-1000-6993-67 1000 7 6993 4636 1.0195data7-1000-6993-68 1000 7 6993 4589 1.0410data7-1000-6993-69 1000 7 6993 4464 1.0185data7-1000-6993-70 1000 7 6993 4572 1.0334data7-1000-6993-71 1000 7 6993 4569 1.0193data7-1000-6993-72 1000 7 6993 4540 1.0256data7-1000-6993-73 1000 7 6993 4618 1.0222data7-1000-6993-74 1000 7 6993 4513 1.0357data7-1000-6993-75 1000 7 6993 4549 1.0347data7-1000-6993-76 1000 7 6993 4615 1.0309data7-1000-6993-77 1000 7 6993 4537 1.0267data7-1000-6993-78 1000 7 6993 4581 1.0266data7-1000-6993-79 1000 7 6993 4467 1.0307data7-1000-6993-80 1000 7 6993 4498 1.0234data7-1000-6993-81 1000 7 6993 4538 1.0405data7-1000-6993-82 1000 7 6993 4529 1.0311data7-1000-6993-83 1000 7 6993 4471 1.0264data7-1000-6993-84 1000 7 6993 4506 1.0187data7-1000-6993-85 1000 7 6993 4640 1.0349data7-1000-6993-86 1000 7 6993 4587 1.0217data7-1000-6993-87 1000 7 6993 4534 1.0408data7-1000-6993-88 1000 7 6993 4571 1.0226data7-1000-6993-89 1000 7 6993 4503 1.0365data7-1000-6993-90 1000 7 6993 4550 1.0397

Table 97: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 483: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-1000-6993-91 1000 7 6993 4500 1.0186data7-1000-6993-92 1000 7 6993 4603 1.0313data7-1000-6993-93 1000 7 6993 4546 1.0376data7-1000-6993-94 1000 7 6993 4454 1.0263data7-1000-6993-95 1000 7 6993 4472 1.0277data7-1000-6993-96 1000 7 6993 4520 1.0199data7-1000-6993-97 1000 7 6993 4436 1.0194data7-1000-6993-98 1000 7 6993 4532 1.0429data7-1000-6993-99 1000 7 6993 4505 1.0254data7-1000-6993-100 1000 7 6993 4513 1.0222data7-1000-6994-1 1000 7 6994 4555 1.0212data7-1000-6994-2 1000 7 6994 4603 1.0411data7-1000-6994-3 1000 7 6994 4501 1.0291data7-1000-6994-4 1000 7 6994 4586 1.0352data7-1000-6994-5 1000 7 6994 4584 1.0208data7-1000-6994-6 1000 7 6994 4612 1.0424data7-1000-6994-7 1000 7 6994 4639 1.0248data7-1000-6994-8 1000 7 6994 4533 1.0191data7-1000-6994-9 1000 7 6994 4515 1.0326data7-1000-6994-10 1000 7 6994 4563 1.0434data7-1000-6994-11 1000 7 6994 4529 1.0296data7-1000-6994-12 1000 7 6994 4494 1.0366data7-1000-6994-13 1000 7 6994 4572 1.0401data7-1000-6994-14 1000 7 6994 4537 1.0336data7-1000-6994-15 1000 7 6994 4483 1.0482data7-1000-6994-16 1000 7 6994 4470 1.0231data7-1000-6994-17 1000 7 6994 4571 1.0289data7-1000-6994-18 1000 7 6994 4601 1.0255data7-1000-6994-19 1000 7 6994 4533 1.0356data7-1000-6994-20 1000 7 6994 4603 1.0382data7-1000-6994-21 1000 7 6994 4559 1.0254data7-1000-6994-22 1000 7 6994 4618 1.0373data7-1000-6994-23 1000 7 6994 4584 1.0264data7-1000-6994-24 1000 7 6994 4535 1.0407data7-1000-6994-25 1000 7 6994 4479 1.0242data7-1000-6994-26 1000 7 6994 4526 1.0301data7-1000-6994-27 1000 7 6994 4537 1.0193data7-1000-6994-28 1000 7 6994 4522 1.0237data7-1000-6994-29 1000 7 6994 4597 1.0303data7-1000-6994-30 1000 7 6994 4520 1.0282data7-1000-6994-31 1000 7 6994 4527 1.0316data7-1000-6994-32 1000 7 6994 4522 1.0311data7-1000-6994-33 1000 7 6994 4594 1.0289data7-1000-6994-34 1000 7 6994 4530 1.0379data7-1000-6994-35 1000 7 6994 4549 1.0294data7-1000-6994-36 1000 7 6994 4601 1.0446data7-1000-6994-37 1000 7 6994 4582 1.0245data7-1000-6994-38 1000 7 6994 4519 1.0233data7-1000-6994-39 1000 7 6994 4516 1.0260data7-1000-6994-40 1000 7 6994 4638 1.0186data7-1000-6994-41 1000 7 6994 4549 1.0285data7-1000-6994-42 1000 7 6994 4488 1.0232data7-1000-6994-43 1000 7 6994 4534 1.0361data7-1000-6994-44 1000 7 6994 4618 1.0243data7-1000-6994-45 1000 7 6994 4521 1.0243data7-1000-6994-46 1000 7 6994 4549 1.0301data7-1000-6994-47 1000 7 6994 4527 1.0395data7-1000-6994-48 1000 7 6994 4587 1.0214data7-1000-6994-49 1000 7 6994 4561 1.0404data7-1000-6994-50 1000 7 6994 4560 1.0224data7-1000-6994-51 1000 7 6994 4500 1.0198data7-1000-6994-52 1000 7 6994 4587 1.0299data7-1000-6994-53 1000 7 6994 4530 1.0336data7-1000-6994-54 1000 7 6994 4534 1.0262data7-1000-6994-55 1000 7 6994 4663 1.0271data7-1000-6994-56 1000 7 6994 4518 1.0330data7-1000-6994-57 1000 7 6994 4574 1.0205data7-1000-6994-58 1000 7 6994 4532 1.0377data7-1000-6994-59 1000 7 6994 4498 1.0255data7-1000-6994-60 1000 7 6994 4543 1.0234

Table 98: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 484: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-1000-6994-61 1000 7 6994 4579 1.0201data7-1000-6994-62 1000 7 6994 4624 1.0371data7-1000-6994-63 1000 7 6994 4558 1.0296data7-1000-6994-64 1000 7 6994 4541 1.0313data7-1000-6994-65 1000 7 6994 4564 1.0299data7-1000-6994-66 1000 7 6994 4553 1.0237data7-1000-6994-67 1000 7 6994 4573 1.0349data7-1000-6994-68 1000 7 6994 4597 1.0302data7-1000-6994-69 1000 7 6994 4618 1.0343data7-1000-6994-70 1000 7 6994 4559 1.0415data7-1000-6994-71 1000 7 6994 4564 1.0339data7-1000-6994-72 1000 7 6994 4600 1.0306data7-1000-6994-73 1000 7 6994 4578 1.0344data7-1000-6994-74 1000 7 6994 4508 1.0275data7-1000-6994-75 1000 7 6994 4608 1.0332data7-1000-6994-76 1000 7 6994 4542 1.0370data7-1000-6994-77 1000 7 6994 4558 1.0188data7-1000-6994-78 1000 7 6994 4538 1.0261data7-1000-6994-79 1000 7 6994 4550 1.0325data7-1000-6994-80 1000 7 6994 4602 1.0249data7-1000-6994-81 1000 7 6994 4617 1.0248data7-1000-6994-82 1000 7 6994 4554 1.0289data7-1000-6994-83 1000 7 6994 4524 1.0345data7-1000-6994-84 1000 7 6994 4548 1.0409data7-1000-6994-85 1000 7 6994 4493 1.0392data7-1000-6994-86 1000 7 6994 4551 1.0232data7-1000-6994-87 1000 7 6994 4510 1.0235data7-1000-6994-88 1000 7 6994 4652 1.0412data7-1000-6994-89 1000 7 6994 4614 1.0334data7-1000-6994-90 1000 7 6994 4552 1.0190data7-1000-6994-91 1000 7 6994 4587 1.0308data7-1000-6994-92 1000 7 6994 4695 1.0278data7-1000-6994-93 1000 7 6994 4601 1.0351data7-1000-6994-94 1000 7 6994 4531 1.0225data7-1000-6994-95 1000 7 6994 4511 1.0386data7-1000-6994-96 1000 7 6994 4583 1.0400data7-1000-6994-97 1000 7 6994 4538 1.0397data7-1000-6994-98 1000 7 6994 4499 1.0210data7-1000-6994-99 1000 7 6994 4493 1.0395data7-1000-6994-100 1000 7 6994 4527 1.0195data7-1000-6995-1 1000 7 6995 4601 1.0367data7-1000-6995-2 1000 7 6995 4553 1.0351data7-1000-6995-3 1000 7 6995 4569 1.0393data7-1000-6995-4 1000 7 6995 4598 1.0197data7-1000-6995-5 1000 7 6995 4571 1.0202data7-1000-6995-6 1000 7 6995 4560 1.0287data7-1000-6995-7 1000 7 6995 4643 1.0250data7-1000-6995-8 1000 7 6995 4620 1.0201data7-1000-6995-9 1000 7 6995 4649 1.0425data7-1000-6995-10 1000 7 6995 4521 1.0192data7-1000-6995-11 1000 7 6995 4535 1.0436data7-1000-6995-12 1000 7 6995 4549 1.0285data7-1000-6995-13 1000 7 6995 4589 1.0260data7-1000-6995-14 1000 7 6995 4539 1.0424data7-1000-6995-15 1000 7 6995 4494 1.0325data7-1000-6995-16 1000 7 6995 4573 1.0236data7-1000-6995-17 1000 7 6995 4523 1.0290data7-1000-6995-18 1000 7 6995 4655 1.0198data7-1000-6995-19 1000 7 6995 4583 1.0256data7-1000-6995-20 1000 7 6995 4536 1.0223data7-1000-6995-21 1000 7 6995 4566 1.0289data7-1000-6995-22 1000 7 6995 4553 1.0280data7-1000-6995-23 1000 7 6995 4599 1.0388data7-1000-6995-24 1000 7 6995 4492 1.0333data7-1000-6995-25 1000 7 6995 4553 1.0190data7-1000-6995-26 1000 7 6995 4581 1.0196data7-1000-6995-27 1000 7 6995 4555 1.0409data7-1000-6995-28 1000 7 6995 4586 1.0274data7-1000-6995-29 1000 7 6995 4508 1.0305data7-1000-6995-30 1000 7 6995 4624 1.0321

Table 99: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 485: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-1000-6995-31 1000 7 6995 4619 1.0187data7-1000-6995-32 1000 7 6995 4583 1.0293data7-1000-6995-33 1000 7 6995 4578 1.0319data7-1000-6995-34 1000 7 6995 4670 1.0361data7-1000-6995-35 1000 7 6995 4621 1.0252data7-1000-6995-36 1000 7 6995 4576 1.0464data7-1000-6995-37 1000 7 6995 4494 1.0346data7-1000-6995-38 1000 7 6995 4579 1.0297data7-1000-6995-39 1000 7 6995 4557 1.0247data7-1000-6995-40 1000 7 6995 4551 1.0276data7-1000-6995-41 1000 7 6995 4514 1.0246data7-1000-6995-42 1000 7 6995 4619 1.0273data7-1000-6995-43 1000 7 6995 4536 1.0376data7-1000-6995-44 1000 7 6995 4567 1.0348data7-1000-6995-45 1000 7 6995 4604 1.0235data7-1000-6995-46 1000 7 6995 4601 1.0182data7-1000-6995-47 1000 7 6995 4582 1.0365data7-1000-6995-48 1000 7 6995 4533 1.0321data7-1000-6995-49 1000 7 6995 4568 1.0222data7-1000-6995-50 1000 7 6995 4583 1.0324data7-1000-6995-51 1000 7 6995 4643 1.0274data7-1000-6995-52 1000 7 6995 4565 1.0394data7-1000-6995-53 1000 7 6995 4581 1.0400data7-1000-6995-54 1000 7 6995 4603 1.0323data7-1000-6995-55 1000 7 6995 4575 1.0303data7-1000-6995-56 1000 7 6995 4721 1.0425data7-1000-6995-57 1000 7 6995 4604 1.0285data7-1000-6995-58 1000 7 6995 4640 1.0234data7-1000-6995-59 1000 7 6995 4577 1.0372data7-1000-6995-60 1000 7 6995 4578 1.0401data7-1000-6995-61 1000 7 6995 4539 1.0284data7-1000-6995-62 1000 7 6995 4530 1.0359data7-1000-6995-63 1000 7 6995 4601 1.0361data7-1000-6995-64 1000 7 6995 4561 1.0400data7-1000-6995-65 1000 7 6995 4650 1.0395data7-1000-6995-66 1000 7 6995 4576 1.0340data7-1000-6995-67 1000 7 6995 4520 1.0281data7-1000-6995-68 1000 7 6995 4489 1.0401data7-1000-6995-69 1000 7 6995 4490 1.0194data7-1000-6995-70 1000 7 6995 4427 1.0422data7-1000-6995-71 1000 7 6995 4525 1.0424data7-1000-6995-72 1000 7 6995 4527 1.0381data7-1000-6995-73 1000 7 6995 4551 1.0223data7-1000-6995-74 1000 7 6995 4557 1.0205data7-1000-6995-75 1000 7 6995 4598 1.0299data7-1000-6995-76 1000 7 6995 4658 1.0194data7-1000-6995-77 1000 7 6995 4545 1.0313data7-1000-6995-78 1000 7 6995 4527 1.0421data7-1000-6995-79 1000 7 6995 4480 1.0396data7-1000-6995-80 1000 7 6995 4539 1.0235data7-1000-6995-81 1000 7 6995 4492 1.0242data7-1000-6995-82 1000 7 6995 4551 1.0313data7-1000-6995-83 1000 7 6995 4498 1.0218data7-1000-6995-84 1000 7 6995 4626 1.0257data7-1000-6995-85 1000 7 6995 4569 1.0387data7-1000-6995-86 1000 7 6995 4529 1.0367data7-1000-6995-87 1000 7 6995 4569 1.0373data7-1000-6995-88 1000 7 6995 4476 1.0300data7-1000-6995-89 1000 7 6995 4447 1.0366data7-1000-6995-90 1000 7 6995 4517 1.0193data7-1000-6995-91 1000 7 6995 4575 1.0214data7-1000-6995-92 1000 7 6995 4582 1.0208data7-1000-6995-93 1000 7 6995 4478 1.0351data7-1000-6995-94 1000 7 6995 4577 1.0402data7-1000-6995-95 1000 7 6995 4564 1.0211data7-1000-6995-96 1000 7 6995 4554 1.0210data7-1000-6995-97 1000 7 6995 4531 1.0196data7-1000-6995-98 1000 7 6995 4449 1.0361data7-1000-6995-99 1000 7 6995 4598 1.0344data7-1000-6995-100 1000 7 6995 4519 1.0390

Table 100: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 486: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-1000-6996-1 1000 7 6996 4514 1.0344data7-1000-6996-2 1000 7 6996 4573 1.0331data7-1000-6996-3 1000 7 6996 4584 1.0251data7-1000-6996-4 1000 7 6996 4554 1.0420data7-1000-6996-5 1000 7 6996 4638 1.0219data7-1000-6996-6 1000 7 6996 4532 1.0207data7-1000-6996-7 1000 7 6996 4645 1.0327data7-1000-6996-8 1000 7 6996 4612 1.0209data7-1000-6996-9 1000 7 6996 4545 1.0295data7-1000-6996-10 1000 7 6996 4609 1.0223data7-1000-6996-11 1000 7 6996 4576 1.0365data7-1000-6996-12 1000 7 6996 4612 1.0394data7-1000-6996-13 1000 7 6996 4612 1.0363data7-1000-6996-14 1000 7 6996 4582 1.0233data7-1000-6996-15 1000 7 6996 4501 1.0415data7-1000-6996-16 1000 7 6996 4602 1.0322data7-1000-6996-17 1000 7 6996 4570 1.0343data7-1000-6996-18 1000 7 6996 4593 1.0271data7-1000-6996-19 1000 7 6996 4571 1.0341data7-1000-6996-20 1000 7 6996 4508 1.0414data7-1000-6996-21 1000 7 6996 4538 1.0299data7-1000-6996-22 1000 7 6996 4573 1.0345data7-1000-6996-23 1000 7 6996 4529 1.0362data7-1000-6996-24 1000 7 6996 4565 1.0205data7-1000-6996-25 1000 7 6996 4610 1.0338data7-1000-6996-26 1000 7 6996 4547 1.0240data7-1000-6996-27 1000 7 6996 4473 1.0204data7-1000-6996-28 1000 7 6996 4656 1.0237data7-1000-6996-29 1000 7 6996 4646 1.0277data7-1000-6996-30 1000 7 6996 4548 1.0347data7-1000-6996-31 1000 7 6996 4673 1.0399data7-1000-6996-32 1000 7 6996 4489 1.0266data7-1000-6996-33 1000 7 6996 4494 1.0203data7-1000-6996-34 1000 7 6996 4486 1.0197data7-1000-6996-35 1000 7 6996 4556 1.0376data7-1000-6996-36 1000 7 6996 4592 1.0255data7-1000-6996-37 1000 7 6996 4695 1.0251data7-1000-6996-38 1000 7 6996 4620 1.0195data7-1000-6996-39 1000 7 6996 4548 1.0201data7-1000-6996-40 1000 7 6996 4535 1.0397data7-1000-6996-41 1000 7 6996 4519 1.0210data7-1000-6996-42 1000 7 6996 4635 1.0226data7-1000-6996-43 1000 7 6996 4580 1.0325data7-1000-6996-44 1000 7 6996 4542 1.0320data7-1000-6996-45 1000 7 6996 4546 1.0290data7-1000-6996-46 1000 7 6996 4710 1.0210data7-1000-6996-47 1000 7 6996 4558 1.0262data7-1000-6996-48 1000 7 6996 4554 1.0321data7-1000-6996-49 1000 7 6996 4584 1.0319data7-1000-6996-50 1000 7 6996 4533 1.0222data7-1000-6996-51 1000 7 6996 4557 1.0191data7-1000-6996-52 1000 7 6996 4499 1.0192data7-1000-6996-53 1000 7 6996 4508 1.0255data7-1000-6996-54 1000 7 6996 4567 1.0394data7-1000-6996-55 1000 7 6996 4545 1.0399data7-1000-6996-56 1000 7 6996 4540 1.0209data7-1000-6996-57 1000 7 6996 4577 1.0286data7-1000-6996-58 1000 7 6996 4489 1.0329data7-1000-6996-59 1000 7 6996 4531 1.0394data7-1000-6996-60 1000 7 6996 4639 1.0297data7-1000-6996-61 1000 7 6996 4567 1.0190data7-1000-6996-62 1000 7 6996 4553 1.0213data7-1000-6996-63 1000 7 6996 4629 1.0220data7-1000-6996-64 1000 7 6996 4403 1.0362data7-1000-6996-65 1000 7 6996 4605 1.0212data7-1000-6996-66 1000 7 6996 4553 1.0307data7-1000-6996-67 1000 7 6996 4578 1.0236data7-1000-6996-68 1000 7 6996 4598 1.0394data7-1000-6996-69 1000 7 6996 4553 1.0255data7-1000-6996-70 1000 7 6996 4553 1.0206

Table 101: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 487: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-1000-6996-71 1000 7 6996 4577 1.0367data7-1000-6996-72 1000 7 6996 4577 1.0375data7-1000-6996-73 1000 7 6996 4544 1.0260data7-1000-6996-74 1000 7 6996 4559 1.0374data7-1000-6996-75 1000 7 6996 4542 1.0250data7-1000-6996-76 1000 7 6996 4541 1.0338data7-1000-6996-77 1000 7 6996 4576 1.0312data7-1000-6996-78 1000 7 6996 4597 1.0203data7-1000-6996-79 1000 7 6996 4597 1.0244data7-1000-6996-80 1000 7 6996 4477 1.0380data7-1000-6996-81 1000 7 6996 4564 1.0390data7-1000-6996-82 1000 7 6996 4533 1.0265data7-1000-6996-83 1000 7 6996 4513 1.0272data7-1000-6996-84 1000 7 6996 4511 1.0372data7-1000-6996-85 1000 7 6996 4588 1.0312data7-1000-6996-86 1000 7 6996 4573 1.0298data7-1000-6996-87 1000 7 6996 4595 1.0275data7-1000-6996-88 1000 7 6996 4580 1.0399data7-1000-6996-89 1000 7 6996 4522 1.0272data7-1000-6996-90 1000 7 6996 4507 1.0409data7-1000-6996-91 1000 7 6996 4579 1.0301data7-1000-6996-92 1000 7 6996 4599 1.0358data7-1000-6996-93 1000 7 6996 4544 1.0422data7-1000-6996-94 1000 7 6996 4556 1.0377data7-1000-6996-95 1000 7 6996 4514 1.0239data7-1000-6996-96 1000 7 6996 4484 1.0215data7-1000-6996-97 1000 7 6996 4572 1.0298data7-1000-6996-98 1000 7 6996 4542 1.0188data7-1000-6996-99 1000 7 6996 4517 1.0400data7-1000-6996-100 1000 7 6996 4593 1.0319data7-1000-6997-1 1000 7 6997 4598 1.0256data7-1000-6997-2 1000 7 6997 4520 1.0201data7-1000-6997-3 1000 7 6997 4546 1.0224data7-1000-6997-4 1000 7 6997 4470 1.0427data7-1000-6997-5 1000 7 6997 4523 1.0259data7-1000-6997-6 1000 7 6997 4568 1.0262data7-1000-6997-7 1000 7 6997 4588 1.0246data7-1000-6997-8 1000 7 6997 4528 1.0382data7-1000-6997-9 1000 7 6997 4525 1.0375data7-1000-6997-10 1000 7 6997 4563 1.0291data7-1000-6997-11 1000 7 6997 4602 1.0347data7-1000-6997-12 1000 7 6997 4479 1.0311data7-1000-6997-13 1000 7 6997 4624 1.0273data7-1000-6997-14 1000 7 6997 4565 1.0235data7-1000-6997-15 1000 7 6997 4551 1.0249data7-1000-6997-16 1000 7 6997 4633 1.0246data7-1000-6997-17 1000 7 6997 4595 1.0350data7-1000-6997-18 1000 7 6997 4586 1.0287data7-1000-6997-19 1000 7 6997 4541 1.0226data7-1000-6997-20 1000 7 6997 4499 1.0325data7-1000-6997-21 1000 7 6997 4551 1.0321data7-1000-6997-22 1000 7 6997 4535 1.0196data7-1000-6997-23 1000 7 6997 4539 1.0215data7-1000-6997-24 1000 7 6997 4527 1.0232data7-1000-6997-25 1000 7 6997 4607 1.0354data7-1000-6997-26 1000 7 6997 4505 1.0259data7-1000-6997-27 1000 7 6997 4573 1.0399data7-1000-6997-28 1000 7 6997 4673 1.0423data7-1000-6997-29 1000 7 6997 4513 1.0223data7-1000-6997-30 1000 7 6997 4505 1.0255data7-1000-6997-31 1000 7 6997 4458 1.0308data7-1000-6997-32 1000 7 6997 4489 1.0308data7-1000-6997-33 1000 7 6997 4564 1.0332data7-1000-6997-34 1000 7 6997 4526 1.0422data7-1000-6997-35 1000 7 6997 4518 1.0230data7-1000-6997-36 1000 7 6997 4597 1.0200data7-1000-6997-37 1000 7 6997 4531 1.0366data7-1000-6997-38 1000 7 6997 4475 1.0274data7-1000-6997-39 1000 7 6997 4565 1.0385data7-1000-6997-40 1000 7 6997 4608 1.0193

Table 102: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 488: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-1000-6997-41 1000 7 6997 4529 1.0434data7-1000-6997-42 1000 7 6997 4622 1.0224data7-1000-6997-43 1000 7 6997 4537 1.0222data7-1000-6997-44 1000 7 6997 4627 1.0248data7-1000-6997-45 1000 7 6997 4511 1.0255data7-1000-6997-46 1000 7 6997 4571 1.0287data7-1000-6997-47 1000 7 6997 4559 1.0262data7-1000-6997-48 1000 7 6997 4466 1.0289data7-1000-6997-49 1000 7 6997 4461 1.0405data7-1000-6997-50 1000 7 6997 4582 1.0217data7-1000-6997-51 1000 7 6997 4488 1.0329data7-1000-6997-52 1000 7 6997 4485 1.0268data7-1000-6997-53 1000 7 6997 4667 1.0182data7-1000-6997-54 1000 7 6997 4552 1.0254data7-1000-6997-55 1000 7 6997 4491 1.0331data7-1000-6997-56 1000 7 6997 4528 1.0354data7-1000-6997-57 1000 7 6997 4562 1.0416data7-1000-6997-58 1000 7 6997 4514 1.0369data7-1000-6997-59 1000 7 6997 4588 1.0435data7-1000-6997-60 1000 7 6997 4498 1.0300data7-1000-6997-61 1000 7 6997 4524 1.0352data7-1000-6997-62 1000 7 6997 4630 1.0360data7-1000-6997-63 1000 7 6997 4542 1.0225data7-1000-6997-64 1000 7 6997 4500 1.0248data7-1000-6997-65 1000 7 6997 4548 1.0220data7-1000-6997-66 1000 7 6997 4541 1.0361data7-1000-6997-67 1000 7 6997 4495 1.0325data7-1000-6997-68 1000 7 6997 4480 1.0333data7-1000-6997-69 1000 7 6997 4542 1.0358data7-1000-6997-70 1000 7 6997 4631 1.0202data7-1000-6997-71 1000 7 6997 4546 1.0302data7-1000-6997-72 1000 7 6997 4509 1.0232data7-1000-6997-73 1000 7 6997 4488 1.0303data7-1000-6997-74 1000 7 6997 4526 1.0358data7-1000-6997-75 1000 7 6997 4638 1.0407data7-1000-6997-76 1000 7 6997 4568 1.0351data7-1000-6997-77 1000 7 6997 4682 1.0223data7-1000-6997-78 1000 7 6997 4554 1.0257data7-1000-6997-79 1000 7 6997 4599 1.0185data7-1000-6997-80 1000 7 6997 4523 1.0308data7-1000-6997-81 1000 7 6997 4543 1.0353data7-1000-6997-82 1000 7 6997 4567 1.0251data7-1000-6997-83 1000 7 6997 4560 1.0321data7-1000-6997-84 1000 7 6997 4520 1.0264data7-1000-6997-85 1000 7 6997 4564 1.0307data7-1000-6997-86 1000 7 6997 4472 1.0192data7-1000-6997-87 1000 7 6997 4452 1.0377data7-1000-6997-88 1000 7 6997 4592 1.0388data7-1000-6997-89 1000 7 6997 4536 1.0224data7-1000-6997-90 1000 7 6997 4545 1.0229data7-1000-6997-91 1000 7 6997 4569 1.0296data7-1000-6997-92 1000 7 6997 4637 1.0235data7-1000-6997-93 1000 7 6997 4552 1.0324data7-1000-6997-94 1000 7 6997 4594 1.0201data7-1000-6997-95 1000 7 6997 4596 1.0241data7-1000-6997-96 1000 7 6997 4577 1.0187data7-1000-6997-97 1000 7 6997 4585 1.0250data7-1000-6997-98 1000 7 6997 4475 1.0344data7-1000-6997-99 1000 7 6997 4514 1.0367data7-1000-6997-100 1000 7 6997 4588 1.0414data7-1000-6998-1 1000 7 6998 4633 1.0332data7-1000-6998-2 1000 7 6998 4606 1.0216data7-1000-6998-3 1000 7 6998 4552 1.0359data7-1000-6998-4 1000 7 6998 4582 1.0288data7-1000-6998-5 1000 7 6998 4566 1.0272data7-1000-6998-6 1000 7 6998 4570 1.0409data7-1000-6998-7 1000 7 6998 4514 1.0364data7-1000-6998-8 1000 7 6998 4567 1.0392data7-1000-6998-9 1000 7 6998 4501 1.0322data7-1000-6998-10 1000 7 6998 4555 1.0268

Table 103: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 489: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-1000-6998-11 1000 7 6998 4546 1.0459data7-1000-6998-12 1000 7 6998 4463 1.0263data7-1000-6998-13 1000 7 6998 4499 1.0269data7-1000-6998-14 1000 7 6998 4512 1.0217data7-1000-6998-15 1000 7 6998 4474 1.0235data7-1000-6998-16 1000 7 6998 4511 1.0244data7-1000-6998-17 1000 7 6998 4569 1.0426data7-1000-6998-18 1000 7 6998 4685 1.0228data7-1000-6998-19 1000 7 6998 4575 1.0203data7-1000-6998-20 1000 7 6998 4506 1.0263data7-1000-6998-21 1000 7 6998 4539 1.0267data7-1000-6998-22 1000 7 6998 4467 1.0198data7-1000-6998-23 1000 7 6998 4702 1.0184data7-1000-6998-24 1000 7 6998 4523 1.0322data7-1000-6998-25 1000 7 6998 4633 1.0407data7-1000-6998-26 1000 7 6998 4560 1.0288data7-1000-6998-27 1000 7 6998 4568 1.0305data7-1000-6998-28 1000 7 6998 4560 1.0469data7-1000-6998-29 1000 7 6998 4512 1.0366data7-1000-6998-30 1000 7 6998 4561 1.0428data7-1000-6998-31 1000 7 6998 4553 1.0270data7-1000-6998-32 1000 7 6998 4444 1.0378data7-1000-6998-33 1000 7 6998 4607 1.0192data7-1000-6998-34 1000 7 6998 4672 1.0395data7-1000-6998-35 1000 7 6998 4519 1.0263data7-1000-6998-36 1000 7 6998 4510 1.0225data7-1000-6998-37 1000 7 6998 4548 1.0371data7-1000-6998-38 1000 7 6998 4533 1.0242data7-1000-6998-39 1000 7 6998 4553 1.0301data7-1000-6998-40 1000 7 6998 4587 1.0349data7-1000-6998-41 1000 7 6998 4598 1.0268data7-1000-6998-42 1000 7 6998 4602 1.0341data7-1000-6998-43 1000 7 6998 4565 1.0354data7-1000-6998-44 1000 7 6998 4554 1.0263data7-1000-6998-45 1000 7 6998 4583 1.0417data7-1000-6998-46 1000 7 6998 4573 1.0193data7-1000-6998-47 1000 7 6998 4639 1.0380data7-1000-6998-48 1000 7 6998 4577 1.0312data7-1000-6998-49 1000 7 6998 4570 1.0372data7-1000-6998-50 1000 7 6998 4564 1.0331data7-1000-6998-51 1000 7 6998 4558 1.0310data7-1000-6998-52 1000 7 6998 4572 1.0270data7-1000-6998-53 1000 7 6998 4650 1.0331data7-1000-6998-54 1000 7 6998 4542 1.0305data7-1000-6998-55 1000 7 6998 4668 1.0433data7-1000-6998-56 1000 7 6998 4558 1.0221data7-1000-6998-57 1000 7 6998 4603 1.0294data7-1000-6998-58 1000 7 6998 4569 1.0194data7-1000-6998-59 1000 7 6998 4534 1.0416data7-1000-6998-60 1000 7 6998 4652 1.0197data7-1000-6998-61 1000 7 6998 4516 1.0254data7-1000-6998-62 1000 7 6998 4521 1.0418data7-1000-6998-63 1000 7 6998 4558 1.0261data7-1000-6998-64 1000 7 6998 4559 1.0185data7-1000-6998-65 1000 7 6998 4513 1.0322data7-1000-6998-66 1000 7 6998 4496 1.0367data7-1000-6998-67 1000 7 6998 4538 1.0373data7-1000-6998-68 1000 7 6998 4529 1.0202data7-1000-6998-69 1000 7 6998 4701 1.0215data7-1000-6998-70 1000 7 6998 4536 1.0301data7-1000-6998-71 1000 7 6998 4523 1.0219data7-1000-6998-72 1000 7 6998 4566 1.0202data7-1000-6998-73 1000 7 6998 4601 1.0200data7-1000-6998-74 1000 7 6998 4532 1.0223data7-1000-6998-75 1000 7 6998 4657 1.0377data7-1000-6998-76 1000 7 6998 4598 1.0327data7-1000-6998-77 1000 7 6998 4638 1.0295data7-1000-6998-78 1000 7 6998 4637 1.0343data7-1000-6998-79 1000 7 6998 4532 1.0423data7-1000-6998-80 1000 7 6998 4608 1.0194

Table 104: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 490: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-1000-6998-81 1000 7 6998 4511 1.0345data7-1000-6998-82 1000 7 6998 4560 1.0222data7-1000-6998-83 1000 7 6998 4557 1.0219data7-1000-6998-84 1000 7 6998 4511 1.0413data7-1000-6998-85 1000 7 6998 4626 1.0231data7-1000-6998-86 1000 7 6998 4501 1.0372data7-1000-6998-87 1000 7 6998 4566 1.0195data7-1000-6998-88 1000 7 6998 4575 1.0354data7-1000-6998-89 1000 7 6998 4657 1.0255data7-1000-6998-90 1000 7 6998 4585 1.0238data7-1000-6998-91 1000 7 6998 4612 1.0407data7-1000-6998-92 1000 7 6998 4486 1.0284data7-1000-6998-93 1000 7 6998 4607 1.0380data7-1000-6998-94 1000 7 6998 4478 1.0287data7-1000-6998-95 1000 7 6998 4533 1.0241data7-1000-6998-96 1000 7 6998 4539 1.0227data7-1000-6998-97 1000 7 6998 4498 1.0291data7-1000-6998-98 1000 7 6998 4544 1.0252data7-1000-6998-99 1000 7 6998 4509 1.0285data7-1000-6998-100 1000 7 6998 4545 1.0213data7-1000-6999-1 1000 7 6999 4573 1.0402data7-1000-6999-2 1000 7 6999 4632 1.0279data7-1000-6999-3 1000 7 6999 4601 1.0280data7-1000-6999-4 1000 7 6999 4571 1.0239data7-1000-6999-5 1000 7 6999 4609 1.0277data7-1000-6999-6 1000 7 6999 4647 1.0231data7-1000-6999-7 1000 7 6999 4538 1.0294data7-1000-6999-8 1000 7 6999 4563 1.0201data7-1000-6999-9 1000 7 6999 4634 1.0322data7-1000-6999-10 1000 7 6999 4522 1.0355data7-1000-6999-11 1000 7 6999 4537 1.0199data7-1000-6999-12 1000 7 6999 4510 1.0377data7-1000-6999-13 1000 7 6999 4602 1.0193data7-1000-6999-14 1000 7 6999 4493 1.0320data7-1000-6999-15 1000 7 6999 4501 1.0257data7-1000-6999-16 1000 7 6999 4514 1.0421data7-1000-6999-17 1000 7 6999 4622 1.0331data7-1000-6999-18 1000 7 6999 4567 1.0217data7-1000-6999-19 1000 7 6999 4487 1.0354data7-1000-6999-20 1000 7 6999 4557 1.0311data7-1000-6999-21 1000 7 6999 4555 1.0348data7-1000-6999-22 1000 7 6999 4544 1.0377data7-1000-6999-23 1000 7 6999 4591 1.0190data7-1000-6999-24 1000 7 6999 4475 1.0203data7-1000-6999-25 1000 7 6999 4583 1.0198data7-1000-6999-26 1000 7 6999 4450 1.0416data7-1000-6999-27 1000 7 6999 4558 1.0299data7-1000-6999-28 1000 7 6999 4745 1.0213data7-1000-6999-29 1000 7 6999 4529 1.0273data7-1000-6999-30 1000 7 6999 4591 1.0374data7-1000-6999-31 1000 7 6999 4569 1.0209data7-1000-6999-32 1000 7 6999 4618 1.0347data7-1000-6999-33 1000 7 6999 4611 1.0185data7-1000-6999-34 1000 7 6999 4631 1.0391data7-1000-6999-35 1000 7 6999 4598 1.0227data7-1000-6999-36 1000 7 6999 4517 1.0416data7-1000-6999-37 1000 7 6999 4574 1.0407data7-1000-6999-38 1000 7 6999 4450 1.0290data7-1000-6999-39 1000 7 6999 4493 1.0221data7-1000-6999-40 1000 7 6999 4634 1.0405data7-1000-6999-41 1000 7 6999 4533 1.0335data7-1000-6999-42 1000 7 6999 4565 1.0267data7-1000-6999-43 1000 7 6999 4558 1.0416data7-1000-6999-44 1000 7 6999 4605 1.0207data7-1000-6999-45 1000 7 6999 4507 1.0394data7-1000-6999-46 1000 7 6999 4608 1.0328data7-1000-6999-47 1000 7 6999 4562 1.0232data7-1000-6999-48 1000 7 6999 4510 1.0348data7-1000-6999-49 1000 7 6999 4518 1.0210data7-1000-6999-50 1000 7 6999 4446 1.0210

Table 105: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 491: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata7-1000-6999-51 1000 7 6999 4525 1.0388data7-1000-6999-52 1000 7 6999 4603 1.0204data7-1000-6999-53 1000 7 6999 4535 1.0423data7-1000-6999-54 1000 7 6999 4566 1.0230data7-1000-6999-55 1000 7 6999 4519 1.0287data7-1000-6999-56 1000 7 6999 4547 1.0363data7-1000-6999-57 1000 7 6999 4571 1.0335data7-1000-6999-58 1000 7 6999 4624 1.0409data7-1000-6999-59 1000 7 6999 4528 1.0275data7-1000-6999-60 1000 7 6999 4648 1.0343data7-1000-6999-61 1000 7 6999 4635 1.0255data7-1000-6999-62 1000 7 6999 4587 1.0236data7-1000-6999-63 1000 7 6999 4679 1.0334data7-1000-6999-64 1000 7 6999 4530 1.0241data7-1000-6999-65 1000 7 6999 4525 1.0280data7-1000-6999-66 1000 7 6999 4552 1.0242data7-1000-6999-67 1000 7 6999 4519 1.0222data7-1000-6999-68 1000 7 6999 4604 1.0272data7-1000-6999-69 1000 7 6999 4522 1.0284data7-1000-6999-70 1000 7 6999 4597 1.0189data7-1000-6999-71 1000 7 6999 4574 1.0418data7-1000-6999-72 1000 7 6999 4596 1.0414data7-1000-6999-73 1000 7 6999 4528 1.0256data7-1000-6999-74 1000 7 6999 4635 1.0318data7-1000-6999-75 1000 7 6999 4505 1.0346data7-1000-6999-76 1000 7 6999 4571 1.0243data7-1000-6999-77 1000 7 6999 4560 1.0299data7-1000-6999-78 1000 7 6999 4560 1.0238data7-1000-6999-79 1000 7 6999 4532 1.0346data7-1000-6999-80 1000 7 6999 4458 1.0262data7-1000-6999-81 1000 7 6999 4526 1.0307data7-1000-6999-82 1000 7 6999 4648 1.0369data7-1000-6999-83 1000 7 6999 4542 1.0275data7-1000-6999-84 1000 7 6999 4557 1.0291data7-1000-6999-85 1000 7 6999 4593 1.0431data7-1000-6999-86 1000 7 6999 4507 1.0411data7-1000-6999-87 1000 7 6999 4537 1.0237data7-1000-6999-88 1000 7 6999 4550 1.0346data7-1000-6999-89 1000 7 6999 4588 1.0430data7-1000-6999-90 1000 7 6999 4539 1.0295data7-1000-6999-91 1000 7 6999 4595 1.0409data7-1000-6999-92 1000 7 6999 4600 1.0352data7-1000-6999-93 1000 7 6999 4681 1.0193data7-1000-6999-94 1000 7 6999 4568 1.0384data7-1000-6999-95 1000 7 6999 4509 1.0231data7-1000-6999-96 1000 7 6999 4534 1.0194data7-1000-6999-97 1000 7 6999 4643 1.0424data7-1000-6999-98 1000 7 6999 4552 1.0234data7-1000-6999-99 1000 7 6999 4615 1.0204data7-1000-6999-100 1000 7 6999 4647 1.0277data10-1000-9990-1 1000 10 9990 7990 1.0361data10-1000-9990-2 1000 10 9990 8131 1.0317data10-1000-9990-3 1000 10 9990 8269 1.0326data10-1000-9990-4 1000 10 9990 8037 1.0297data10-1000-9990-5 1000 10 9990 7869 1.0291data10-1000-9990-6 1000 10 9990 7996 1.0267data10-1000-9990-7 1000 10 9990 7939 1.0269data10-1000-9990-8 1000 10 9990 8032 1.0277data10-1000-9990-9 1000 10 9990 7991 1.0303data10-1000-9990-10 1000 10 9990 8154 1.0275data10-1000-9990-11 1000 10 9990 8244 1.0309data10-1000-9990-12 1000 10 9990 8017 1.0570data10-1000-9990-13 1000 10 9990 8080 1.0255data10-1000-9990-14 1000 10 9990 7997 1.0260data10-1000-9990-15 1000 10 9990 7995 1.0312data10-1000-9990-16 1000 10 9990 8091 1.0289data10-1000-9990-17 1000 10 9990 8085 1.0313data10-1000-9990-18 1000 10 9990 8068 1.0250data10-1000-9990-19 1000 10 9990 8107 1.0568data10-1000-9990-20 1000 10 9990 8247 1.0365

Table 106: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 492: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-1000-9990-21 1000 10 9990 8216 1.0292data10-1000-9990-22 1000 10 9990 8118 1.0326data10-1000-9990-23 1000 10 9990 8186 1.0324data10-1000-9990-24 1000 10 9990 8158 1.0285data10-1000-9990-25 1000 10 9990 8018 1.0272data10-1000-9990-26 1000 10 9990 8282 1.0434data10-1000-9990-27 1000 10 9990 8197 1.0341data10-1000-9990-28 1000 10 9990 8174 1.0271data10-1000-9990-29 1000 10 9990 8113 1.0281data10-1000-9990-30 1000 10 9990 7966 1.0257data10-1000-9990-31 1000 10 9990 8095 1.0369data10-1000-9990-32 1000 10 9990 8041 1.0468data10-1000-9990-33 1000 10 9990 8205 1.0315data10-1000-9990-34 1000 10 9990 8202 1.0294data10-1000-9990-35 1000 10 9990 8280 1.0264data10-1000-9990-36 1000 10 9990 8178 1.0343data10-1000-9990-37 1000 10 9990 8225 1.0344data10-1000-9990-38 1000 10 9990 8177 1.0258data10-1000-9990-39 1000 10 9990 7898 1.0266data10-1000-9990-40 1000 10 9990 7888 1.0242data10-1000-9990-41 1000 10 9990 8142 1.0305data10-1000-9990-42 1000 10 9990 7883 1.0397data10-1000-9990-43 1000 10 9990 8004 1.0612data10-1000-9990-44 1000 10 9990 7832 1.0630data10-1000-9990-45 1000 10 9990 8052 1.0264data10-1000-9990-46 1000 10 9990 8085 1.0616data10-1000-9990-47 1000 10 9990 8084 1.0419data10-1000-9990-48 1000 10 9990 8124 1.0569data10-1000-9990-49 1000 10 9990 8213 1.0302data10-1000-9990-50 1000 10 9990 8186 1.0278data10-1000-9990-51 1000 10 9990 8027 1.0362data10-1000-9990-52 1000 10 9990 8029 1.0257data10-1000-9990-53 1000 10 9990 7910 1.0413data10-1000-9990-54 1000 10 9990 8282 1.0339data10-1000-9990-55 1000 10 9990 8006 1.0343data10-1000-9990-56 1000 10 9990 8092 1.0366data10-1000-9990-57 1000 10 9990 7874 1.0448data10-1000-9990-58 1000 10 9990 8185 1.0524data10-1000-9990-59 1000 10 9990 7901 1.0685data10-1000-9990-60 1000 10 9990 7897 1.0346data10-1000-9990-61 1000 10 9990 8190 1.0251data10-1000-9990-62 1000 10 9990 8154 1.0288data10-1000-9990-63 1000 10 9990 8098 1.0274data10-1000-9990-64 1000 10 9990 8007 1.0373data10-1000-9990-65 1000 10 9990 8129 1.0539data10-1000-9990-66 1000 10 9990 8039 1.0296data10-1000-9990-67 1000 10 9990 7894 1.0309data10-1000-9990-68 1000 10 9990 8021 1.0341data10-1000-9990-69 1000 10 9990 7981 1.0404data10-1000-9990-70 1000 10 9990 8014 1.0330data10-1000-9990-71 1000 10 9990 8093 1.0358data10-1000-9990-72 1000 10 9990 8016 1.0262data10-1000-9990-73 1000 10 9990 8113 1.0353data10-1000-9990-74 1000 10 9990 8055 1.0252data10-1000-9990-75 1000 10 9990 7979 1.0268data10-1000-9990-76 1000 10 9990 8034 1.0266data10-1000-9990-77 1000 10 9990 8174 1.0267data10-1000-9990-78 1000 10 9990 7965 1.0269data10-1000-9990-79 1000 10 9990 7995 1.0273data10-1000-9990-80 1000 10 9990 8219 1.0270data10-1000-9990-81 1000 10 9990 8133 1.0377data10-1000-9990-82 1000 10 9990 7803 1.0301data10-1000-9990-83 1000 10 9990 8209 1.0359data10-1000-9990-84 1000 10 9990 8111 1.0292data10-1000-9990-85 1000 10 9990 8176 1.0362data10-1000-9990-86 1000 10 9990 8191 1.0316data10-1000-9990-87 1000 10 9990 7971 1.0343data10-1000-9990-88 1000 10 9990 8001 1.0326data10-1000-9990-89 1000 10 9990 8149 1.0251data10-1000-9990-90 1000 10 9990 8073 1.0352

Table 107: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 493: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-1000-9990-91 1000 10 9990 7859 1.0328data10-1000-9990-92 1000 10 9990 7908 1.0315data10-1000-9990-93 1000 10 9990 7927 1.0266data10-1000-9990-94 1000 10 9990 7928 1.0243data10-1000-9990-95 1000 10 9990 8004 1.0309data10-1000-9990-96 1000 10 9990 8136 1.0432data10-1000-9990-97 1000 10 9990 8377 1.0633data10-1000-9990-98 1000 10 9990 7938 1.0262data10-1000-9990-99 1000 10 9990 8143 1.0301data10-1000-9990-100 1000 10 9990 8015 1.0557data10-1000-9991-1 1000 10 9991 8117 1.0559data10-1000-9991-2 1000 10 9991 8079 1.0473data10-1000-9991-3 1000 10 9991 8116 1.0349data10-1000-9991-4 1000 10 9991 8117 1.0573data10-1000-9991-5 1000 10 9991 8157 1.0247data10-1000-9991-6 1000 10 9991 8281 1.0319data10-1000-9991-7 1000 10 9991 8022 1.0610data10-1000-9991-8 1000 10 9991 8087 1.0282data10-1000-9991-9 1000 10 9991 8133 1.0267data10-1000-9991-10 1000 10 9991 8072 1.0274data10-1000-9991-11 1000 10 9991 8259 1.0283data10-1000-9991-12 1000 10 9991 8079 1.0327data10-1000-9991-13 1000 10 9991 8190 1.0371data10-1000-9991-14 1000 10 9991 7939 1.0307data10-1000-9991-15 1000 10 9991 8498 1.0380data10-1000-9991-16 1000 10 9991 8215 1.0329data10-1000-9991-17 1000 10 9991 8102 1.0574data10-1000-9991-18 1000 10 9991 8128 1.0252data10-1000-9991-19 1000 10 9991 8196 1.0603data10-1000-9991-20 1000 10 9991 7976 1.0253data10-1000-9991-21 1000 10 9991 8067 1.0348data10-1000-9991-22 1000 10 9991 7952 1.0423data10-1000-9991-23 1000 10 9991 8246 1.0648data10-1000-9991-24 1000 10 9991 8005 1.0296data10-1000-9991-25 1000 10 9991 8072 1.0262data10-1000-9991-26 1000 10 9991 8032 1.0321data10-1000-9991-27 1000 10 9991 8201 1.0448data10-1000-9991-28 1000 10 9991 8111 1.0268data10-1000-9991-29 1000 10 9991 7969 1.0260data10-1000-9991-30 1000 10 9991 8003 1.0277data10-1000-9991-31 1000 10 9991 8042 1.0273data10-1000-9991-32 1000 10 9991 8123 1.0289data10-1000-9991-33 1000 10 9991 7987 1.0277data10-1000-9991-34 1000 10 9991 7810 1.0277data10-1000-9991-35 1000 10 9991 8147 1.0301data10-1000-9991-36 1000 10 9991 7967 1.0334data10-1000-9991-37 1000 10 9991 8090 1.0267data10-1000-9991-38 1000 10 9991 8204 1.0283data10-1000-9991-39 1000 10 9991 8173 1.0334data10-1000-9991-40 1000 10 9991 8130 1.0294data10-1000-9991-41 1000 10 9991 8251 1.0319data10-1000-9991-42 1000 10 9991 8013 1.0313data10-1000-9991-43 1000 10 9991 7974 1.0319data10-1000-9991-44 1000 10 9991 8133 1.0367data10-1000-9991-45 1000 10 9991 8247 1.0489data10-1000-9991-46 1000 10 9991 8045 1.0299data10-1000-9991-47 1000 10 9991 7927 1.0273data10-1000-9991-48 1000 10 9991 7731 1.0367data10-1000-9991-49 1000 10 9991 7812 1.0395data10-1000-9991-50 1000 10 9991 8227 1.0264data10-1000-9991-51 1000 10 9991 8172 1.0362data10-1000-9991-52 1000 10 9991 8164 1.0281data10-1000-9991-53 1000 10 9991 8109 1.0297data10-1000-9991-54 1000 10 9991 8225 1.0313data10-1000-9991-55 1000 10 9991 7945 1.0619data10-1000-9991-56 1000 10 9991 8184 1.0267data10-1000-9991-57 1000 10 9991 8327 1.0274data10-1000-9991-58 1000 10 9991 8004 1.0266data10-1000-9991-59 1000 10 9991 8257 1.0251data10-1000-9991-60 1000 10 9991 8200 1.0357

Table 108: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 494: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-1000-9991-61 1000 10 9991 8252 1.0673data10-1000-9991-62 1000 10 9991 8036 1.0259data10-1000-9991-63 1000 10 9991 8000 1.0251data10-1000-9991-64 1000 10 9991 8233 1.0411data10-1000-9991-65 1000 10 9991 8142 1.0444data10-1000-9991-66 1000 10 9991 8017 1.0243data10-1000-9991-67 1000 10 9991 8129 1.0295data10-1000-9991-68 1000 10 9991 8126 1.0290data10-1000-9991-69 1000 10 9991 8154 1.0296data10-1000-9991-70 1000 10 9991 7987 1.0387data10-1000-9991-71 1000 10 9991 7947 1.0321data10-1000-9991-72 1000 10 9991 8308 1.0272data10-1000-9991-73 1000 10 9991 7949 1.0295data10-1000-9991-74 1000 10 9991 8153 1.0666data10-1000-9991-75 1000 10 9991 8082 1.0383data10-1000-9991-76 1000 10 9991 8037 1.0268data10-1000-9991-77 1000 10 9991 7776 1.0286data10-1000-9991-78 1000 10 9991 8124 1.0504data10-1000-9991-79 1000 10 9991 8136 1.0281data10-1000-9991-80 1000 10 9991 8224 1.0344data10-1000-9991-81 1000 10 9991 7785 1.0340data10-1000-9991-82 1000 10 9991 7929 1.0303data10-1000-9991-83 1000 10 9991 7897 1.0471data10-1000-9991-84 1000 10 9991 8371 1.0676data10-1000-9991-85 1000 10 9991 8092 1.0344data10-1000-9991-86 1000 10 9991 8153 1.0342data10-1000-9991-87 1000 10 9991 8121 1.0332data10-1000-9991-88 1000 10 9991 8226 1.0288data10-1000-9991-89 1000 10 9991 8190 1.0355data10-1000-9991-90 1000 10 9991 8082 1.0247data10-1000-9991-91 1000 10 9991 7951 1.0302data10-1000-9991-92 1000 10 9991 8087 1.0646data10-1000-9991-93 1000 10 9991 7923 1.0251data10-1000-9991-94 1000 10 9991 8100 1.0334data10-1000-9991-95 1000 10 9991 8016 1.0294data10-1000-9991-96 1000 10 9991 8152 1.0372data10-1000-9991-97 1000 10 9991 8156 1.0303data10-1000-9991-98 1000 10 9991 8011 1.0270data10-1000-9991-99 1000 10 9991 8101 1.0355data10-1000-9991-100 1000 10 9991 7987 1.0727data10-1000-9992-1 1000 10 9992 8048 1.0470data10-1000-9992-2 1000 10 9992 8127 1.0637data10-1000-9992-3 1000 10 9992 8079 1.0486data10-1000-9992-4 1000 10 9992 8315 1.0290data10-1000-9992-5 1000 10 9992 7867 1.0301data10-1000-9992-6 1000 10 9992 8316 1.0319data10-1000-9992-7 1000 10 9992 8130 1.0327data10-1000-9992-8 1000 10 9992 8269 1.0355data10-1000-9992-9 1000 10 9992 8138 1.0646data10-1000-9992-10 1000 10 9992 7997 1.0570data10-1000-9992-11 1000 10 9992 8056 1.0287data10-1000-9992-12 1000 10 9992 7935 1.0524data10-1000-9992-13 1000 10 9992 8016 1.0353data10-1000-9992-14 1000 10 9992 8205 1.0288data10-1000-9992-15 1000 10 9992 7945 1.0323data10-1000-9992-16 1000 10 9992 7978 1.0269data10-1000-9992-17 1000 10 9992 8383 1.0277data10-1000-9992-18 1000 10 9992 7970 1.0465data10-1000-9992-19 1000 10 9992 8161 1.0305data10-1000-9992-20 1000 10 9992 8154 1.0322data10-1000-9992-21 1000 10 9992 8157 1.0582data10-1000-9992-22 1000 10 9992 8090 1.0318data10-1000-9992-23 1000 10 9992 8155 1.0288data10-1000-9992-24 1000 10 9992 8304 1.0286data10-1000-9992-25 1000 10 9992 8217 1.0333data10-1000-9992-26 1000 10 9992 8184 1.0359data10-1000-9992-27 1000 10 9992 8252 1.0352data10-1000-9992-28 1000 10 9992 8172 1.0363data10-1000-9992-29 1000 10 9992 7989 1.0247data10-1000-9992-30 1000 10 9992 7981 1.0251

Table 109: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 495: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-1000-9992-31 1000 10 9992 8214 1.0336data10-1000-9992-32 1000 10 9992 8209 1.0285data10-1000-9992-33 1000 10 9992 8112 1.0467data10-1000-9992-34 1000 10 9992 8005 1.0310data10-1000-9992-35 1000 10 9992 8292 1.0290data10-1000-9992-36 1000 10 9992 8186 1.0303data10-1000-9992-37 1000 10 9992 8128 1.0296data10-1000-9992-38 1000 10 9992 8004 1.0489data10-1000-9992-39 1000 10 9992 7956 1.0246data10-1000-9992-40 1000 10 9992 8121 1.0272data10-1000-9992-41 1000 10 9992 8206 1.0258data10-1000-9992-42 1000 10 9992 8032 1.0345data10-1000-9992-43 1000 10 9992 8195 1.0350data10-1000-9992-44 1000 10 9992 8108 1.0338data10-1000-9992-45 1000 10 9992 7993 1.0510data10-1000-9992-46 1000 10 9992 8235 1.0350data10-1000-9992-47 1000 10 9992 8068 1.0527data10-1000-9992-48 1000 10 9992 7873 1.0417data10-1000-9992-49 1000 10 9992 8073 1.0297data10-1000-9992-50 1000 10 9992 8130 1.0325data10-1000-9992-51 1000 10 9992 8043 1.0266data10-1000-9992-52 1000 10 9992 8183 1.0275data10-1000-9992-53 1000 10 9992 8142 1.0315data10-1000-9992-54 1000 10 9992 8226 1.0383data10-1000-9992-55 1000 10 9992 8223 1.0346data10-1000-9992-56 1000 10 9992 8258 1.0254data10-1000-9992-57 1000 10 9992 8219 1.0343data10-1000-9992-58 1000 10 9992 8036 1.0369data10-1000-9992-59 1000 10 9992 7949 1.0370data10-1000-9992-60 1000 10 9992 8205 1.0325data10-1000-9992-61 1000 10 9992 8134 1.0306data10-1000-9992-62 1000 10 9992 7916 1.0336data10-1000-9992-63 1000 10 9992 7809 1.0429data10-1000-9992-64 1000 10 9992 8362 1.0371data10-1000-9992-65 1000 10 9992 8024 1.0500data10-1000-9992-66 1000 10 9992 8113 1.0286data10-1000-9992-67 1000 10 9992 8013 1.0276data10-1000-9992-68 1000 10 9992 8055 1.0305data10-1000-9992-69 1000 10 9992 8360 1.0374data10-1000-9992-70 1000 10 9992 7962 1.0283data10-1000-9992-71 1000 10 9992 8072 1.0364data10-1000-9992-72 1000 10 9992 8038 1.0595data10-1000-9992-73 1000 10 9992 8155 1.0345data10-1000-9992-74 1000 10 9992 8090 1.0309data10-1000-9992-75 1000 10 9992 8149 1.0341data10-1000-9992-76 1000 10 9992 8151 1.0494data10-1000-9992-77 1000 10 9992 8059 1.0316data10-1000-9992-78 1000 10 9992 8098 1.0654data10-1000-9992-79 1000 10 9992 8061 1.0257data10-1000-9992-80 1000 10 9992 8275 1.0337data10-1000-9992-81 1000 10 9992 7840 1.0320data10-1000-9992-82 1000 10 9992 8404 1.0634data10-1000-9992-83 1000 10 9992 7984 1.0324data10-1000-9992-84 1000 10 9992 8373 1.0365data10-1000-9992-85 1000 10 9992 8155 1.0277data10-1000-9992-86 1000 10 9992 8002 1.0564data10-1000-9992-87 1000 10 9992 8100 1.0304data10-1000-9992-88 1000 10 9992 7927 1.0366data10-1000-9992-89 1000 10 9992 8069 1.0248data10-1000-9992-90 1000 10 9992 8074 1.0282data10-1000-9992-91 1000 10 9992 8040 1.0345data10-1000-9992-92 1000 10 9992 7845 1.0280data10-1000-9992-93 1000 10 9992 8031 1.0325data10-1000-9992-94 1000 10 9992 8225 1.0539data10-1000-9992-95 1000 10 9992 8006 1.0245data10-1000-9992-96 1000 10 9992 8252 1.0340data10-1000-9992-97 1000 10 9992 7983 1.0250data10-1000-9992-98 1000 10 9992 7943 1.0342data10-1000-9992-99 1000 10 9992 8175 1.0538data10-1000-9992-100 1000 10 9992 8034 1.0347

Table 110: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 496: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-1000-9993-1 1000 10 9993 8068 1.0279data10-1000-9993-2 1000 10 9993 8200 1.0279data10-1000-9993-3 1000 10 9993 7799 1.0251data10-1000-9993-4 1000 10 9993 8097 1.0339data10-1000-9993-5 1000 10 9993 8074 1.0308data10-1000-9993-6 1000 10 9993 8220 1.0263data10-1000-9993-7 1000 10 9993 8042 1.0253data10-1000-9993-8 1000 10 9993 8139 1.0256data10-1000-9993-9 1000 10 9993 8078 1.0298data10-1000-9993-10 1000 10 9993 8154 1.0335data10-1000-9993-11 1000 10 9993 8121 1.0317data10-1000-9993-12 1000 10 9993 8106 1.0333data10-1000-9993-13 1000 10 9993 8209 1.0532data10-1000-9993-14 1000 10 9993 8302 1.0269data10-1000-9993-15 1000 10 9993 8095 1.0258data10-1000-9993-16 1000 10 9993 8036 1.0289data10-1000-9993-17 1000 10 9993 8035 1.0599data10-1000-9993-18 1000 10 9993 8250 1.0336data10-1000-9993-19 1000 10 9993 8032 1.0466data10-1000-9993-20 1000 10 9993 8016 1.0268data10-1000-9993-21 1000 10 9993 7860 1.0515data10-1000-9993-22 1000 10 9993 8404 1.0544data10-1000-9993-23 1000 10 9993 7905 1.0294data10-1000-9993-24 1000 10 9993 8300 1.0450data10-1000-9993-25 1000 10 9993 8121 1.0345data10-1000-9993-26 1000 10 9993 8280 1.0261data10-1000-9993-27 1000 10 9993 7959 1.0350data10-1000-9993-28 1000 10 9993 7820 1.0305data10-1000-9993-29 1000 10 9993 8135 1.0451data10-1000-9993-30 1000 10 9993 8048 1.0507data10-1000-9993-31 1000 10 9993 8061 1.0333data10-1000-9993-32 1000 10 9993 8167 1.0292data10-1000-9993-33 1000 10 9993 8045 1.0283data10-1000-9993-34 1000 10 9993 8002 1.0270data10-1000-9993-35 1000 10 9993 7983 1.0258data10-1000-9993-36 1000 10 9993 7951 1.0257data10-1000-9993-37 1000 10 9993 8277 1.0396data10-1000-9993-38 1000 10 9993 7997 1.0259data10-1000-9993-39 1000 10 9993 8065 1.0529data10-1000-9993-40 1000 10 9993 8108 1.0296data10-1000-9993-41 1000 10 9993 8230 1.0298data10-1000-9993-42 1000 10 9993 8331 1.0305data10-1000-9993-43 1000 10 9993 7949 1.0278data10-1000-9993-44 1000 10 9993 8171 1.0301data10-1000-9993-45 1000 10 9993 8184 1.0277data10-1000-9993-46 1000 10 9993 8210 1.0347data10-1000-9993-47 1000 10 9993 8030 1.0319data10-1000-9993-48 1000 10 9993 8215 1.0305data10-1000-9993-49 1000 10 9993 7977 1.0346data10-1000-9993-50 1000 10 9993 8148 1.0300data10-1000-9993-51 1000 10 9993 8065 1.0304data10-1000-9993-52 1000 10 9993 8342 1.0320data10-1000-9993-53 1000 10 9993 8084 1.0295data10-1000-9993-54 1000 10 9993 7990 1.0290data10-1000-9993-55 1000 10 9993 8243 1.0352data10-1000-9993-56 1000 10 9993 8030 1.0270data10-1000-9993-57 1000 10 9993 7944 1.0277data10-1000-9993-58 1000 10 9993 8075 1.0398data10-1000-9993-59 1000 10 9993 8150 1.0395data10-1000-9993-60 1000 10 9993 8178 1.0299data10-1000-9993-61 1000 10 9993 8043 1.0273data10-1000-9993-62 1000 10 9993 8170 1.0322data10-1000-9993-63 1000 10 9993 8292 1.0345data10-1000-9993-64 1000 10 9993 8231 1.0445data10-1000-9993-65 1000 10 9993 8086 1.0316data10-1000-9993-66 1000 10 9993 8315 1.0254data10-1000-9993-67 1000 10 9993 8081 1.0353data10-1000-9993-68 1000 10 9993 8262 1.0341data10-1000-9993-69 1000 10 9993 8086 1.0387data10-1000-9993-70 1000 10 9993 8011 1.0279

Table 111: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 497: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-1000-9993-71 1000 10 9993 8161 1.0347data10-1000-9993-72 1000 10 9993 8133 1.0243data10-1000-9993-73 1000 10 9993 8018 1.0513data10-1000-9993-74 1000 10 9993 7869 1.0322data10-1000-9993-75 1000 10 9993 8160 1.0308data10-1000-9993-76 1000 10 9993 8145 1.0268data10-1000-9993-77 1000 10 9993 8126 1.0245data10-1000-9993-78 1000 10 9993 8159 1.0679data10-1000-9993-79 1000 10 9993 8223 1.0575data10-1000-9993-80 1000 10 9993 8213 1.0272data10-1000-9993-81 1000 10 9993 8019 1.0341data10-1000-9993-82 1000 10 9993 8186 1.0454data10-1000-9993-83 1000 10 9993 7935 1.0318data10-1000-9993-84 1000 10 9993 7998 1.0304data10-1000-9993-85 1000 10 9993 7869 1.0316data10-1000-9993-86 1000 10 9993 8323 1.0333data10-1000-9993-87 1000 10 9993 8219 1.0439data10-1000-9993-88 1000 10 9993 7941 1.0296data10-1000-9993-89 1000 10 9993 8161 1.0486data10-1000-9993-90 1000 10 9993 8193 1.0310data10-1000-9993-91 1000 10 9993 8036 1.0249data10-1000-9993-92 1000 10 9993 8194 1.0283data10-1000-9993-93 1000 10 9993 7873 1.0259data10-1000-9993-94 1000 10 9993 7870 1.0247data10-1000-9993-95 1000 10 9993 8105 1.0332data10-1000-9993-96 1000 10 9993 7863 1.0316data10-1000-9993-97 1000 10 9993 8198 1.0295data10-1000-9993-98 1000 10 9993 8222 1.0282data10-1000-9993-99 1000 10 9993 8005 1.0292data10-1000-9993-100 1000 10 9993 8031 1.0275data10-1000-9994-1 1000 10 9994 8122 1.0333data10-1000-9994-2 1000 10 9994 8036 1.0264data10-1000-9994-3 1000 10 9994 8157 1.0376data10-1000-9994-4 1000 10 9994 7907 1.0605data10-1000-9994-5 1000 10 9994 8124 1.0403data10-1000-9994-6 1000 10 9994 7991 1.0349data10-1000-9994-7 1000 10 9994 8303 1.0248data10-1000-9994-8 1000 10 9994 8090 1.0261data10-1000-9994-9 1000 10 9994 7961 1.0539data10-1000-9994-10 1000 10 9994 8450 1.0285data10-1000-9994-11 1000 10 9994 8192 1.0374data10-1000-9994-12 1000 10 9994 8166 1.0320data10-1000-9994-13 1000 10 9994 7939 1.0248data10-1000-9994-14 1000 10 9994 7988 1.0302data10-1000-9994-15 1000 10 9994 8188 1.0325data10-1000-9994-16 1000 10 9994 8102 1.0248data10-1000-9994-17 1000 10 9994 8056 1.0592data10-1000-9994-18 1000 10 9994 7919 1.0253data10-1000-9994-19 1000 10 9994 8168 1.0362data10-1000-9994-20 1000 10 9994 8294 1.0538data10-1000-9994-21 1000 10 9994 8001 1.0588data10-1000-9994-22 1000 10 9994 8315 1.0342data10-1000-9994-23 1000 10 9994 8190 1.0334data10-1000-9994-24 1000 10 9994 8301 1.0369data10-1000-9994-25 1000 10 9994 8129 1.0413data10-1000-9994-26 1000 10 9994 7973 1.0520data10-1000-9994-27 1000 10 9994 8008 1.0498data10-1000-9994-28 1000 10 9994 8276 1.0369data10-1000-9994-29 1000 10 9994 7927 1.0337data10-1000-9994-30 1000 10 9994 8137 1.0330data10-1000-9994-31 1000 10 9994 8091 1.0273data10-1000-9994-32 1000 10 9994 7806 1.0281data10-1000-9994-33 1000 10 9994 7938 1.0597data10-1000-9994-34 1000 10 9994 8243 1.0360data10-1000-9994-35 1000 10 9994 8202 1.0343data10-1000-9994-36 1000 10 9994 8107 1.0473data10-1000-9994-37 1000 10 9994 7940 1.0252data10-1000-9994-38 1000 10 9994 8259 1.0256data10-1000-9994-39 1000 10 9994 7845 1.0267data10-1000-9994-40 1000 10 9994 7935 1.0290

Table 112: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 498: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-1000-9994-41 1000 10 9994 8024 1.0663data10-1000-9994-42 1000 10 9994 7919 1.0303data10-1000-9994-43 1000 10 9994 8366 1.0492data10-1000-9994-44 1000 10 9994 8208 1.0369data10-1000-9994-45 1000 10 9994 8007 1.0344data10-1000-9994-46 1000 10 9994 8196 1.0271data10-1000-9994-47 1000 10 9994 7931 1.0552data10-1000-9994-48 1000 10 9994 7826 1.0268data10-1000-9994-49 1000 10 9994 8165 1.0375data10-1000-9994-50 1000 10 9994 7837 1.0331data10-1000-9994-51 1000 10 9994 7924 1.0367data10-1000-9994-52 1000 10 9994 8097 1.0646data10-1000-9994-53 1000 10 9994 8116 1.0579data10-1000-9994-54 1000 10 9994 8203 1.0342data10-1000-9994-55 1000 10 9994 8330 1.0364data10-1000-9994-56 1000 10 9994 7830 1.0637data10-1000-9994-57 1000 10 9994 8074 1.0332data10-1000-9994-58 1000 10 9994 8019 1.0339data10-1000-9994-59 1000 10 9994 7978 1.0267data10-1000-9994-60 1000 10 9994 8383 1.0308data10-1000-9994-61 1000 10 9994 8103 1.0578data10-1000-9994-62 1000 10 9994 8078 1.0344data10-1000-9994-63 1000 10 9994 7977 1.0322data10-1000-9994-64 1000 10 9994 8107 1.0342data10-1000-9994-65 1000 10 9994 8030 1.0440data10-1000-9994-66 1000 10 9994 8045 1.0256data10-1000-9994-67 1000 10 9994 8115 1.0270data10-1000-9994-68 1000 10 9994 8143 1.0321data10-1000-9994-69 1000 10 9994 8201 1.0621data10-1000-9994-70 1000 10 9994 8435 1.0398data10-1000-9994-71 1000 10 9994 8158 1.0343data10-1000-9994-72 1000 10 9994 8219 1.0303data10-1000-9994-73 1000 10 9994 8287 1.0672data10-1000-9994-74 1000 10 9994 8299 1.0356data10-1000-9994-75 1000 10 9994 7978 1.0330data10-1000-9994-76 1000 10 9994 8084 1.0308data10-1000-9994-77 1000 10 9994 8063 1.0269data10-1000-9994-78 1000 10 9994 8115 1.0252data10-1000-9994-79 1000 10 9994 8253 1.0290data10-1000-9994-80 1000 10 9994 8267 1.0296data10-1000-9994-81 1000 10 9994 8131 1.0342data10-1000-9994-82 1000 10 9994 8140 1.0427data10-1000-9994-83 1000 10 9994 8106 1.0411data10-1000-9994-84 1000 10 9994 7971 1.0533data10-1000-9994-85 1000 10 9994 8150 1.0542data10-1000-9994-86 1000 10 9994 7974 1.0304data10-1000-9994-87 1000 10 9994 8139 1.0395data10-1000-9994-88 1000 10 9994 7999 1.0530data10-1000-9994-89 1000 10 9994 7987 1.0436data10-1000-9994-90 1000 10 9994 8047 1.0472data10-1000-9994-91 1000 10 9994 8279 1.0382data10-1000-9994-92 1000 10 9994 8044 1.0322data10-1000-9994-93 1000 10 9994 7989 1.0289data10-1000-9994-94 1000 10 9994 7877 1.0249data10-1000-9994-95 1000 10 9994 7921 1.0604data10-1000-9994-96 1000 10 9994 8140 1.0668data10-1000-9994-97 1000 10 9994 8121 1.0273data10-1000-9994-98 1000 10 9994 8162 1.0625data10-1000-9994-99 1000 10 9994 8211 1.0514data10-1000-9994-100 1000 10 9994 8053 1.0355data10-1000-9995-1 1000 10 9995 7960 1.0275data10-1000-9995-2 1000 10 9995 8154 1.0269data10-1000-9995-3 1000 10 9995 8325 1.0551data10-1000-9995-4 1000 10 9995 8024 1.0417data10-1000-9995-5 1000 10 9995 8261 1.0608data10-1000-9995-6 1000 10 9995 8032 1.0285data10-1000-9995-7 1000 10 9995 8005 1.0280data10-1000-9995-8 1000 10 9995 8184 1.0515data10-1000-9995-9 1000 10 9995 8061 1.0309data10-1000-9995-10 1000 10 9995 8170 1.0268

Table 113: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 499: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-1000-9995-11 1000 10 9995 8311 1.0368data10-1000-9995-12 1000 10 9995 8118 1.0618data10-1000-9995-13 1000 10 9995 8074 1.0288data10-1000-9995-14 1000 10 9995 8355 1.0374data10-1000-9995-15 1000 10 9995 8026 1.0271data10-1000-9995-16 1000 10 9995 8048 1.0503data10-1000-9995-17 1000 10 9995 7942 1.0470data10-1000-9995-18 1000 10 9995 8111 1.0287data10-1000-9995-19 1000 10 9995 8032 1.0356data10-1000-9995-20 1000 10 9995 8277 1.0369data10-1000-9995-21 1000 10 9995 8063 1.0345data10-1000-9995-22 1000 10 9995 8139 1.0269data10-1000-9995-23 1000 10 9995 8068 1.0303data10-1000-9995-24 1000 10 9995 8238 1.0366data10-1000-9995-25 1000 10 9995 8202 1.0342data10-1000-9995-26 1000 10 9995 8023 1.0391data10-1000-9995-27 1000 10 9995 7936 1.0284data10-1000-9995-28 1000 10 9995 8152 1.0391data10-1000-9995-29 1000 10 9995 8163 1.0327data10-1000-9995-30 1000 10 9995 7896 1.0535data10-1000-9995-31 1000 10 9995 7998 1.0325data10-1000-9995-32 1000 10 9995 8098 1.0282data10-1000-9995-33 1000 10 9995 8144 1.0317data10-1000-9995-34 1000 10 9995 8074 1.0596data10-1000-9995-35 1000 10 9995 7787 1.0615data10-1000-9995-36 1000 10 9995 8236 1.0253data10-1000-9995-37 1000 10 9995 8139 1.0465data10-1000-9995-38 1000 10 9995 8223 1.0303data10-1000-9995-39 1000 10 9995 8192 1.0276data10-1000-9995-40 1000 10 9995 8188 1.0258data10-1000-9995-41 1000 10 9995 8192 1.0516data10-1000-9995-42 1000 10 9995 7935 1.0273data10-1000-9995-43 1000 10 9995 8032 1.0270data10-1000-9995-44 1000 10 9995 8283 1.0343data10-1000-9995-45 1000 10 9995 8214 1.0297data10-1000-9995-46 1000 10 9995 8224 1.0460data10-1000-9995-47 1000 10 9995 8214 1.0350data10-1000-9995-48 1000 10 9995 8114 1.0286data10-1000-9995-49 1000 10 9995 8085 1.0273data10-1000-9995-50 1000 10 9995 8071 1.0589data10-1000-9995-51 1000 10 9995 8220 1.0303data10-1000-9995-52 1000 10 9995 7993 1.0262data10-1000-9995-53 1000 10 9995 8059 1.0325data10-1000-9995-54 1000 10 9995 8130 1.0314data10-1000-9995-55 1000 10 9995 8211 1.0384data10-1000-9995-56 1000 10 9995 8066 1.0346data10-1000-9995-57 1000 10 9995 8010 1.0596data10-1000-9995-58 1000 10 9995 8225 1.0356data10-1000-9995-59 1000 10 9995 8157 1.0276data10-1000-9995-60 1000 10 9995 8286 1.0350data10-1000-9995-61 1000 10 9995 8115 1.0341data10-1000-9995-62 1000 10 9995 8233 1.0324data10-1000-9995-63 1000 10 9995 8009 1.0324data10-1000-9995-64 1000 10 9995 8012 1.0269data10-1000-9995-65 1000 10 9995 8061 1.0292data10-1000-9995-66 1000 10 9995 8084 1.0365data10-1000-9995-67 1000 10 9995 8178 1.0291data10-1000-9995-68 1000 10 9995 7923 1.0300data10-1000-9995-69 1000 10 9995 7952 1.0308data10-1000-9995-70 1000 10 9995 7995 1.0342data10-1000-9995-71 1000 10 9995 8042 1.0347data10-1000-9995-72 1000 10 9995 8136 1.0487data10-1000-9995-73 1000 10 9995 8220 1.0289data10-1000-9995-74 1000 10 9995 8398 1.0261data10-1000-9995-75 1000 10 9995 8151 1.0282data10-1000-9995-76 1000 10 9995 8000 1.0243data10-1000-9995-77 1000 10 9995 8260 1.0317data10-1000-9995-78 1000 10 9995 8150 1.0551data10-1000-9995-79 1000 10 9995 7985 1.0329data10-1000-9995-80 1000 10 9995 8045 1.0288

Table 114: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 500: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-1000-9995-81 1000 10 9995 8164 1.0320data10-1000-9995-82 1000 10 9995 7965 1.0545data10-1000-9995-83 1000 10 9995 8133 1.0554data10-1000-9995-84 1000 10 9995 8021 1.0329data10-1000-9995-85 1000 10 9995 7934 1.0272data10-1000-9995-86 1000 10 9995 8070 1.0269data10-1000-9995-87 1000 10 9995 8297 1.0306data10-1000-9995-88 1000 10 9995 8254 1.0338data10-1000-9995-89 1000 10 9995 8268 1.0362data10-1000-9995-90 1000 10 9995 8139 1.0260data10-1000-9995-91 1000 10 9995 8043 1.0294data10-1000-9995-92 1000 10 9995 8078 1.0327data10-1000-9995-93 1000 10 9995 8056 1.0326data10-1000-9995-94 1000 10 9995 8177 1.0647data10-1000-9995-95 1000 10 9995 8228 1.0304data10-1000-9995-96 1000 10 9995 8042 1.0277data10-1000-9995-97 1000 10 9995 8350 1.0359data10-1000-9995-98 1000 10 9995 8181 1.0383data10-1000-9995-99 1000 10 9995 8124 1.0330data10-1000-9995-100 1000 10 9995 8138 1.0321data10-1000-9996-1 1000 10 9996 8270 1.0326data10-1000-9996-2 1000 10 9996 8150 1.0282data10-1000-9996-3 1000 10 9996 7842 1.0304data10-1000-9996-4 1000 10 9996 8015 1.0265data10-1000-9996-5 1000 10 9996 8127 1.0587data10-1000-9996-6 1000 10 9996 8100 1.0552data10-1000-9996-7 1000 10 9996 8203 1.0351data10-1000-9996-8 1000 10 9996 7965 1.0268data10-1000-9996-9 1000 10 9996 8288 1.0342data10-1000-9996-10 1000 10 9996 8069 1.0265data10-1000-9996-11 1000 10 9996 8272 1.0274data10-1000-9996-12 1000 10 9996 8169 1.0306data10-1000-9996-13 1000 10 9996 8115 1.0333data10-1000-9996-14 1000 10 9996 7993 1.0260data10-1000-9996-15 1000 10 9996 8229 1.0700data10-1000-9996-16 1000 10 9996 8261 1.0687data10-1000-9996-17 1000 10 9996 8055 1.0362data10-1000-9996-18 1000 10 9996 8161 1.0521data10-1000-9996-19 1000 10 9996 8339 1.0280data10-1000-9996-20 1000 10 9996 7968 1.0316data10-1000-9996-21 1000 10 9996 8172 1.0317data10-1000-9996-22 1000 10 9996 8019 1.0264data10-1000-9996-23 1000 10 9996 7943 1.0258data10-1000-9996-24 1000 10 9996 8328 1.0339data10-1000-9996-25 1000 10 9996 8076 1.0362data10-1000-9996-26 1000 10 9996 8020 1.0335data10-1000-9996-27 1000 10 9996 7974 1.0323data10-1000-9996-28 1000 10 9996 8254 1.0360data10-1000-9996-29 1000 10 9996 8098 1.0264data10-1000-9996-30 1000 10 9996 8208 1.0571data10-1000-9996-31 1000 10 9996 8079 1.0398data10-1000-9996-32 1000 10 9996 8031 1.0282data10-1000-9996-33 1000 10 9996 8112 1.0307data10-1000-9996-34 1000 10 9996 8130 1.0439data10-1000-9996-35 1000 10 9996 7945 1.0374data10-1000-9996-36 1000 10 9996 8092 1.0257data10-1000-9996-37 1000 10 9996 8034 1.0533data10-1000-9996-38 1000 10 9996 8087 1.0284data10-1000-9996-39 1000 10 9996 8070 1.0256data10-1000-9996-40 1000 10 9996 8032 1.0560data10-1000-9996-41 1000 10 9996 7968 1.0441data10-1000-9996-42 1000 10 9996 8274 1.0293data10-1000-9996-43 1000 10 9996 8353 1.0485data10-1000-9996-44 1000 10 9996 8165 1.0324data10-1000-9996-45 1000 10 9996 8147 1.0273data10-1000-9996-46 1000 10 9996 8037 1.0258data10-1000-9996-47 1000 10 9996 8045 1.0289data10-1000-9996-48 1000 10 9996 8179 1.0305data10-1000-9996-49 1000 10 9996 8246 1.0315data10-1000-9996-50 1000 10 9996 8080 1.0447

Table 115: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 501: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-1000-9996-51 1000 10 9996 8145 1.0406data10-1000-9996-52 1000 10 9996 8118 1.0349data10-1000-9996-53 1000 10 9996 8156 1.0344data10-1000-9996-54 1000 10 9996 8067 1.0500data10-1000-9996-55 1000 10 9996 7956 1.0269data10-1000-9996-56 1000 10 9996 8203 1.0364data10-1000-9996-57 1000 10 9996 8025 1.0377data10-1000-9996-58 1000 10 9996 8128 1.0295data10-1000-9996-59 1000 10 9996 8111 1.0330data10-1000-9996-60 1000 10 9996 8116 1.0272data10-1000-9996-61 1000 10 9996 8108 1.0267data10-1000-9996-62 1000 10 9996 8039 1.0568data10-1000-9996-63 1000 10 9996 8041 1.0264data10-1000-9996-64 1000 10 9996 8111 1.0302data10-1000-9996-65 1000 10 9996 8103 1.0293data10-1000-9996-66 1000 10 9996 8225 1.0312data10-1000-9996-67 1000 10 9996 7978 1.0304data10-1000-9996-68 1000 10 9996 8178 1.0355data10-1000-9996-69 1000 10 9996 8070 1.0382data10-1000-9996-70 1000 10 9996 8204 1.0333data10-1000-9996-71 1000 10 9996 8081 1.0385data10-1000-9996-72 1000 10 9996 8222 1.0372data10-1000-9996-73 1000 10 9996 8370 1.0576data10-1000-9996-74 1000 10 9996 8104 1.0399data10-1000-9996-75 1000 10 9996 8140 1.0246data10-1000-9996-76 1000 10 9996 7979 1.0297data10-1000-9996-77 1000 10 9996 7972 1.0285data10-1000-9996-78 1000 10 9996 8167 1.0323data10-1000-9996-79 1000 10 9996 7938 1.0257data10-1000-9996-80 1000 10 9996 8040 1.0382data10-1000-9996-81 1000 10 9996 8382 1.0299data10-1000-9996-82 1000 10 9996 8247 1.0300data10-1000-9996-83 1000 10 9996 8061 1.0295data10-1000-9996-84 1000 10 9996 8147 1.0478data10-1000-9996-85 1000 10 9996 8035 1.0364data10-1000-9996-86 1000 10 9996 8023 1.0541data10-1000-9996-87 1000 10 9996 8091 1.0283data10-1000-9996-88 1000 10 9996 7956 1.0364data10-1000-9996-89 1000 10 9996 8283 1.0334data10-1000-9996-90 1000 10 9996 8038 1.0367data10-1000-9996-91 1000 10 9996 8171 1.0271data10-1000-9996-92 1000 10 9996 8026 1.0333data10-1000-9996-93 1000 10 9996 8030 1.0452data10-1000-9996-94 1000 10 9996 8294 1.0428data10-1000-9996-95 1000 10 9996 8294 1.0566data10-1000-9996-96 1000 10 9996 8059 1.0393data10-1000-9996-97 1000 10 9996 8012 1.0339data10-1000-9996-98 1000 10 9996 8109 1.0416data10-1000-9996-99 1000 10 9996 8271 1.0297data10-1000-9996-100 1000 10 9996 8206 1.0247data10-1000-9997-1 1000 10 9997 8183 1.0296data10-1000-9997-2 1000 10 9997 7913 1.0620data10-1000-9997-3 1000 10 9997 8076 1.0272data10-1000-9997-4 1000 10 9997 8091 1.0362data10-1000-9997-5 1000 10 9997 8046 1.0507data10-1000-9997-6 1000 10 9997 8106 1.0333data10-1000-9997-7 1000 10 9997 8130 1.0364data10-1000-9997-8 1000 10 9997 8162 1.0357data10-1000-9997-9 1000 10 9997 8095 1.0331data10-1000-9997-10 1000 10 9997 7959 1.0428data10-1000-9997-11 1000 10 9997 8068 1.0493data10-1000-9997-12 1000 10 9997 8253 1.0388data10-1000-9997-13 1000 10 9997 7982 1.0251data10-1000-9997-14 1000 10 9997 8064 1.0380data10-1000-9997-15 1000 10 9997 8185 1.0290data10-1000-9997-16 1000 10 9997 7913 1.0260data10-1000-9997-17 1000 10 9997 8028 1.0254data10-1000-9997-18 1000 10 9997 7934 1.0361data10-1000-9997-19 1000 10 9997 8133 1.0683data10-1000-9997-20 1000 10 9997 8029 1.0315

Table 116: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 502: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-1000-9997-21 1000 10 9997 8031 1.0626data10-1000-9997-22 1000 10 9997 8159 1.0612data10-1000-9997-23 1000 10 9997 8253 1.0357data10-1000-9997-24 1000 10 9997 8320 1.0345data10-1000-9997-25 1000 10 9997 8194 1.0390data10-1000-9997-26 1000 10 9997 8058 1.0524data10-1000-9997-27 1000 10 9997 7971 1.0361data10-1000-9997-28 1000 10 9997 8205 1.0511data10-1000-9997-29 1000 10 9997 8228 1.0685data10-1000-9997-30 1000 10 9997 7916 1.0451data10-1000-9997-31 1000 10 9997 8242 1.0308data10-1000-9997-32 1000 10 9997 7952 1.0323data10-1000-9997-33 1000 10 9997 8082 1.0329data10-1000-9997-34 1000 10 9997 8179 1.0522data10-1000-9997-35 1000 10 9997 8216 1.0282data10-1000-9997-36 1000 10 9997 8019 1.0250data10-1000-9997-37 1000 10 9997 8143 1.0661data10-1000-9997-38 1000 10 9997 8350 1.0275data10-1000-9997-39 1000 10 9997 8223 1.0343data10-1000-9997-40 1000 10 9997 8217 1.0392data10-1000-9997-41 1000 10 9997 7986 1.0298data10-1000-9997-42 1000 10 9997 8067 1.0632data10-1000-9997-43 1000 10 9997 8300 1.0658data10-1000-9997-44 1000 10 9997 8225 1.0291data10-1000-9997-45 1000 10 9997 7943 1.0344data10-1000-9997-46 1000 10 9997 8179 1.0566data10-1000-9997-47 1000 10 9997 7929 1.0265data10-1000-9997-48 1000 10 9997 8369 1.0321data10-1000-9997-49 1000 10 9997 8085 1.0585data10-1000-9997-50 1000 10 9997 8032 1.0314data10-1000-9997-51 1000 10 9997 8226 1.0246data10-1000-9997-52 1000 10 9997 8286 1.0317data10-1000-9997-53 1000 10 9997 8138 1.0275data10-1000-9997-54 1000 10 9997 8125 1.0286data10-1000-9997-55 1000 10 9997 8256 1.0380data10-1000-9997-56 1000 10 9997 8042 1.0308data10-1000-9997-57 1000 10 9997 8045 1.0249data10-1000-9997-58 1000 10 9997 7937 1.0281data10-1000-9997-59 1000 10 9997 8036 1.0315data10-1000-9997-60 1000 10 9997 7965 1.0257data10-1000-9997-61 1000 10 9997 8246 1.0523data10-1000-9997-62 1000 10 9997 8191 1.0471data10-1000-9997-63 1000 10 9997 8143 1.0369data10-1000-9997-64 1000 10 9997 8172 1.0431data10-1000-9997-65 1000 10 9997 8178 1.0243data10-1000-9997-66 1000 10 9997 8143 1.0253data10-1000-9997-67 1000 10 9997 8108 1.0666data10-1000-9997-68 1000 10 9997 8357 1.0251data10-1000-9997-69 1000 10 9997 8117 1.0398data10-1000-9997-70 1000 10 9997 7974 1.0504data10-1000-9997-71 1000 10 9997 7996 1.0279data10-1000-9997-72 1000 10 9997 8079 1.0470data10-1000-9997-73 1000 10 9997 8064 1.0319data10-1000-9997-74 1000 10 9997 7838 1.0502data10-1000-9997-75 1000 10 9997 8111 1.0299data10-1000-9997-76 1000 10 9997 8366 1.0395data10-1000-9997-77 1000 10 9997 8259 1.0516data10-1000-9997-78 1000 10 9997 8138 1.0267data10-1000-9997-79 1000 10 9997 8193 1.0274data10-1000-9997-80 1000 10 9997 8217 1.0476data10-1000-9997-81 1000 10 9997 8109 1.0371data10-1000-9997-82 1000 10 9997 8198 1.0301data10-1000-9997-83 1000 10 9997 8011 1.0451data10-1000-9997-84 1000 10 9997 7951 1.0353data10-1000-9997-85 1000 10 9997 7988 1.0567data10-1000-9997-86 1000 10 9997 8299 1.0432data10-1000-9997-87 1000 10 9997 8201 1.0373data10-1000-9997-88 1000 10 9997 8250 1.0608data10-1000-9997-89 1000 10 9997 8284 1.0255data10-1000-9997-90 1000 10 9997 8047 1.0353

Table 117: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 503: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-1000-9997-91 1000 10 9997 8200 1.0293data10-1000-9997-92 1000 10 9997 7937 1.0315data10-1000-9997-93 1000 10 9997 7791 1.0295data10-1000-9997-94 1000 10 9997 8224 1.0369data10-1000-9997-95 1000 10 9997 8282 1.0354data10-1000-9997-96 1000 10 9997 7981 1.0283data10-1000-9997-97 1000 10 9997 8074 1.0578data10-1000-9997-98 1000 10 9997 8210 1.0408data10-1000-9997-99 1000 10 9997 8130 1.0256data10-1000-9997-100 1000 10 9997 7998 1.0334data10-1000-9998-1 1000 10 9998 8009 1.0517data10-1000-9998-2 1000 10 9998 8313 1.0253data10-1000-9998-3 1000 10 9998 8092 1.0263data10-1000-9998-4 1000 10 9998 8329 1.0462data10-1000-9998-5 1000 10 9998 8061 1.0267data10-1000-9998-6 1000 10 9998 8290 1.0247data10-1000-9998-7 1000 10 9998 8107 1.0494data10-1000-9998-8 1000 10 9998 8051 1.0662data10-1000-9998-9 1000 10 9998 8204 1.0342data10-1000-9998-10 1000 10 9998 8047 1.0391data10-1000-9998-11 1000 10 9998 8201 1.0399data10-1000-9998-12 1000 10 9998 7979 1.0250data10-1000-9998-13 1000 10 9998 7979 1.0334data10-1000-9998-14 1000 10 9998 8205 1.0567data10-1000-9998-15 1000 10 9998 8150 1.0288data10-1000-9998-16 1000 10 9998 8208 1.0283data10-1000-9998-17 1000 10 9998 8206 1.0390data10-1000-9998-18 1000 10 9998 8277 1.0641data10-1000-9998-19 1000 10 9998 8214 1.0356data10-1000-9998-20 1000 10 9998 8208 1.0372data10-1000-9998-21 1000 10 9998 8153 1.0347data10-1000-9998-22 1000 10 9998 8198 1.0465data10-1000-9998-23 1000 10 9998 8225 1.0330data10-1000-9998-24 1000 10 9998 8205 1.0314data10-1000-9998-25 1000 10 9998 8141 1.0412data10-1000-9998-26 1000 10 9998 8202 1.0305data10-1000-9998-27 1000 10 9998 8119 1.0347data10-1000-9998-28 1000 10 9998 8005 1.0670data10-1000-9998-29 1000 10 9998 8130 1.0347data10-1000-9998-30 1000 10 9998 8110 1.0254data10-1000-9998-31 1000 10 9998 7994 1.0667data10-1000-9998-32 1000 10 9998 7909 1.0307data10-1000-9998-33 1000 10 9998 8386 1.0390data10-1000-9998-34 1000 10 9998 8165 1.0296data10-1000-9998-35 1000 10 9998 8170 1.0531data10-1000-9998-36 1000 10 9998 8040 1.0255data10-1000-9998-37 1000 10 9998 8118 1.0293data10-1000-9998-38 1000 10 9998 8201 1.0255data10-1000-9998-39 1000 10 9998 8176 1.0635data10-1000-9998-40 1000 10 9998 8237 1.0603data10-1000-9998-41 1000 10 9998 7844 1.0257data10-1000-9998-42 1000 10 9998 8050 1.0247data10-1000-9998-43 1000 10 9998 7895 1.0307data10-1000-9998-44 1000 10 9998 8166 1.0313data10-1000-9998-45 1000 10 9998 8226 1.0372data10-1000-9998-46 1000 10 9998 8076 1.0396data10-1000-9998-47 1000 10 9998 8077 1.0277data10-1000-9998-48 1000 10 9998 8213 1.0355data10-1000-9998-49 1000 10 9998 8377 1.0285data10-1000-9998-50 1000 10 9998 8036 1.0275data10-1000-9998-51 1000 10 9998 8217 1.0268data10-1000-9998-52 1000 10 9998 7930 1.0432data10-1000-9998-53 1000 10 9998 8324 1.0705data10-1000-9998-54 1000 10 9998 8273 1.0508data10-1000-9998-55 1000 10 9998 8124 1.0384data10-1000-9998-56 1000 10 9998 7992 1.0358data10-1000-9998-57 1000 10 9998 8208 1.0347data10-1000-9998-58 1000 10 9998 8100 1.0246data10-1000-9998-59 1000 10 9998 8217 1.0343data10-1000-9998-60 1000 10 9998 7798 1.0363

Table 118: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 504: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-1000-9998-61 1000 10 9998 7783 1.0364data10-1000-9998-62 1000 10 9998 8310 1.0338data10-1000-9998-63 1000 10 9998 8016 1.0572data10-1000-9998-64 1000 10 9998 7924 1.0675data10-1000-9998-65 1000 10 9998 8186 1.0251data10-1000-9998-66 1000 10 9998 8064 1.0335data10-1000-9998-67 1000 10 9998 8500 1.0433data10-1000-9998-68 1000 10 9998 8102 1.0286data10-1000-9998-69 1000 10 9998 8009 1.0302data10-1000-9998-70 1000 10 9998 8037 1.0329data10-1000-9998-71 1000 10 9998 8122 1.0604data10-1000-9998-72 1000 10 9998 8160 1.0251data10-1000-9998-73 1000 10 9998 8131 1.0309data10-1000-9998-74 1000 10 9998 8186 1.0598data10-1000-9998-75 1000 10 9998 7976 1.0311data10-1000-9998-76 1000 10 9998 8227 1.0342data10-1000-9998-77 1000 10 9998 8193 1.0350data10-1000-9998-78 1000 10 9998 8115 1.0345data10-1000-9998-79 1000 10 9998 8195 1.0341data10-1000-9998-80 1000 10 9998 8047 1.0597data10-1000-9998-81 1000 10 9998 8099 1.0319data10-1000-9998-82 1000 10 9998 8048 1.0268data10-1000-9998-83 1000 10 9998 8004 1.0248data10-1000-9998-84 1000 10 9998 8177 1.0421data10-1000-9998-85 1000 10 9998 8265 1.0504data10-1000-9998-86 1000 10 9998 8122 1.0329data10-1000-9998-87 1000 10 9998 8146 1.0598data10-1000-9998-88 1000 10 9998 8180 1.0479data10-1000-9998-89 1000 10 9998 8084 1.0461data10-1000-9998-90 1000 10 9998 8113 1.0477data10-1000-9998-91 1000 10 9998 7880 1.0269data10-1000-9998-92 1000 10 9998 8164 1.0266data10-1000-9998-93 1000 10 9998 8041 1.0603data10-1000-9998-94 1000 10 9998 8218 1.0285data10-1000-9998-95 1000 10 9998 7796 1.0638data10-1000-9998-96 1000 10 9998 8261 1.0309data10-1000-9998-97 1000 10 9998 8210 1.0591data10-1000-9998-98 1000 10 9998 8168 1.0274data10-1000-9998-99 1000 10 9998 8195 1.0280data10-1000-9998-100 1000 10 9998 7955 1.0513data10-1000-9999-1 1000 10 9999 7879 1.0516data10-1000-9999-2 1000 10 9999 8046 1.0418data10-1000-9999-3 1000 10 9999 8151 1.0242data10-1000-9999-4 1000 10 9999 8041 1.0281data10-1000-9999-5 1000 10 9999 8239 1.0281data10-1000-9999-6 1000 10 9999 8097 1.0618data10-1000-9999-7 1000 10 9999 8085 1.0339data10-1000-9999-8 1000 10 9999 8239 1.0498data10-1000-9999-9 1000 10 9999 8426 1.0284data10-1000-9999-10 1000 10 9999 8113 1.0577data10-1000-9999-11 1000 10 9999 8159 1.0300data10-1000-9999-12 1000 10 9999 8063 1.0378data10-1000-9999-13 1000 10 9999 8265 1.0580data10-1000-9999-14 1000 10 9999 7967 1.0313data10-1000-9999-15 1000 10 9999 8105 1.0643data10-1000-9999-16 1000 10 9999 8128 1.0341data10-1000-9999-17 1000 10 9999 8276 1.0258data10-1000-9999-18 1000 10 9999 8301 1.0566data10-1000-9999-19 1000 10 9999 8233 1.0366data10-1000-9999-20 1000 10 9999 8114 1.0291data10-1000-9999-21 1000 10 9999 8038 1.0308data10-1000-9999-22 1000 10 9999 8170 1.0300data10-1000-9999-23 1000 10 9999 8310 1.0436data10-1000-9999-24 1000 10 9999 8103 1.0251data10-1000-9999-25 1000 10 9999 8176 1.0435data10-1000-9999-26 1000 10 9999 8143 1.0631data10-1000-9999-27 1000 10 9999 8160 1.0515data10-1000-9999-28 1000 10 9999 7983 1.0345data10-1000-9999-29 1000 10 9999 8193 1.0327data10-1000-9999-30 1000 10 9999 8268 1.0324

Table 119: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 505: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

Name w h n Resh Timedata10-1000-9999-31 1000 10 9999 8367 1.0349data10-1000-9999-32 1000 10 9999 7969 1.0315data10-1000-9999-33 1000 10 9999 8130 1.0305data10-1000-9999-34 1000 10 9999 8444 1.0283data10-1000-9999-35 1000 10 9999 8239 1.0320data10-1000-9999-36 1000 10 9999 8071 1.0352data10-1000-9999-37 1000 10 9999 8341 1.0570data10-1000-9999-38 1000 10 9999 8271 1.0385data10-1000-9999-39 1000 10 9999 8227 1.0272data10-1000-9999-40 1000 10 9999 8066 1.0472data10-1000-9999-41 1000 10 9999 8222 1.0419data10-1000-9999-42 1000 10 9999 8342 1.0314data10-1000-9999-43 1000 10 9999 7979 1.0295data10-1000-9999-44 1000 10 9999 8169 1.0323data10-1000-9999-45 1000 10 9999 8154 1.0306data10-1000-9999-46 1000 10 9999 8002 1.0265data10-1000-9999-47 1000 10 9999 8207 1.0248data10-1000-9999-48 1000 10 9999 8321 1.0285data10-1000-9999-49 1000 10 9999 8056 1.0330data10-1000-9999-50 1000 10 9999 8270 1.0374data10-1000-9999-51 1000 10 9999 8274 1.0521data10-1000-9999-52 1000 10 9999 7980 1.0504data10-1000-9999-53 1000 10 9999 8022 1.0489data10-1000-9999-54 1000 10 9999 8308 1.0437data10-1000-9999-55 1000 10 9999 8132 1.0500data10-1000-9999-56 1000 10 9999 8244 1.0343data10-1000-9999-57 1000 10 9999 8011 1.0590data10-1000-9999-58 1000 10 9999 8198 1.0555data10-1000-9999-59 1000 10 9999 8266 1.0249data10-1000-9999-60 1000 10 9999 8121 1.0394data10-1000-9999-61 1000 10 9999 8302 1.0285data10-1000-9999-62 1000 10 9999 8204 1.0509data10-1000-9999-63 1000 10 9999 7924 1.0627data10-1000-9999-64 1000 10 9999 7917 1.0651data10-1000-9999-65 1000 10 9999 8145 1.0676data10-1000-9999-66 1000 10 9999 8139 1.0392data10-1000-9999-67 1000 10 9999 7868 1.0283data10-1000-9999-68 1000 10 9999 8101 1.0274data10-1000-9999-69 1000 10 9999 8082 1.0317data10-1000-9999-70 1000 10 9999 8099 1.0389data10-1000-9999-71 1000 10 9999 7958 1.0274data10-1000-9999-72 1000 10 9999 8189 1.0544data10-1000-9999-73 1000 10 9999 8215 1.0280data10-1000-9999-74 1000 10 9999 8107 1.0271data10-1000-9999-75 1000 10 9999 8459 1.0365data10-1000-9999-76 1000 10 9999 8124 1.0353data10-1000-9999-77 1000 10 9999 8194 1.0443data10-1000-9999-78 1000 10 9999 8394 1.0456data10-1000-9999-79 1000 10 9999 8381 1.0285data10-1000-9999-80 1000 10 9999 8155 1.0486data10-1000-9999-81 1000 10 9999 8136 1.0275data10-1000-9999-82 1000 10 9999 8121 1.0382data10-1000-9999-83 1000 10 9999 8018 1.0309data10-1000-9999-84 1000 10 9999 8082 1.0342data10-1000-9999-85 1000 10 9999 7998 1.0324data10-1000-9999-86 1000 10 9999 8068 1.0253data10-1000-9999-87 1000 10 9999 8023 1.0451data10-1000-9999-88 1000 10 9999 8275 1.0406data10-1000-9999-89 1000 10 9999 7991 1.0342data10-1000-9999-90 1000 10 9999 8079 1.0272data10-1000-9999-91 1000 10 9999 8277 1.0248data10-1000-9999-92 1000 10 9999 7986 1.0289data10-1000-9999-93 1000 10 9999 8029 1.0310data10-1000-9999-94 1000 10 9999 8052 1.0417data10-1000-9999-95 1000 10 9999 8116 1.0502data10-1000-9999-96 1000 10 9999 8348 1.0292data10-1000-9999-97 1000 10 9999 8249 1.0358data10-1000-9999-98 1000 10 9999 8037 1.0301data10-1000-9999-99 1000 10 9999 8271 1.0540data10-1000-9999-100 1000 10 9999 8155 1.0638

Table 120: Computational results on the set lbri

Page 506: Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithmtbacci/brp/instances/Computational_results.pdf · Computational results of the Bounded Beam Search algorithm Tiziano Bacci

References

M. Caserta, S. Voß, and M. Sniedovich. Applying the corridor method to a blocksrelocation problem. OR Spectrum, 33(4):915–929, 2011.

Y. Lee and Y. L. Lee. A heuristic for retrieving containers from a yard. Computers& Operations Research, 47:1139–1147, 2010.

T. Unluyurt and C. Aydin. Improved rehandling strategies for the container re-trieval process. Journal of Advanced Transportation, 46(4):378–393, 2012.

Y. Wan, J. Liu, and P-C. Tsai. The assignment of storage locations to containersfor a container stack. Naval Research Logistics (NRL), 56(8):699–713, 2009.

K. C. Wu and C. J. Ting. A beam search algorithm for minimizing reshuffle op-erations at container yards. nternational Conference on Logistics and MaritimeSystems, Busan, Korea, September 1517, 2010, 2010.

W. Zhu, H. Qin, A. Lim, and H. Zhang. Iterative deepening A* algorithms for thecontainer relocation problem. IEEE Transactions on Automation Science andEngineering, 9:710–722, 2012.