Upload
steve-rojano-arcilla
View
34
Download
5
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Today, cancer continues to be one of the major chronic illnesses among children. When a family is confronted with the diagnosis of childhood cancer, various emotional reactions arise. The word “cancer” is associated with death, and for most people cancer cannot be associated with children, especially for the parents. It is said that for parents, having a child with cancer is both a psychological and existential challenge that is very difficult to cope with. Hence, this study focused on the assessment of the coping strategies of both parents, i.e. the mother and father, of children currently undergoing cancer treatment at the Philippine General Hospital (PGH).The purpose of the study was to determine the different coping strategies and resources that parents of children with cancer use in order to adapt or adjust to their situation in a healthy and well-balanced manner. It also aimed to determine the factors associated with the type of coping strategies that they adapted, as well as to describe the common problems and difficulties experienced by these parents with regard to their situation. A total of 83 parents, including 42 mothers and 41 fathers, participated in the study.The researcher used both quantitative and qualitative methods in conducting the research. Using the Kessler Psychological Distress Scale (K10), the depression and anxiety experienced by the respondents was determined, and using the Coping Strategies Questionnaire, a survey questionnaire created by the researcher, the different types of coping strategies adapted by the parents wereviiidentified. Likewise, the researcher conducted Key-Informant Interviews with six of the 83 respondents to further investigate the coping behavior as well as the quality of life of the parents after the diagnosis of their child’s cancer. Finally, both descriptive and inferential statistical analysis was performed by the researcher to analyze the data gathered.The results revealed that parents significantly used “Seeking Spiritual Support” among the other coping strategies, with “Substance Use” as the least adapted coping strategy. The remaining coping strategies were “Being Optimistic about the Situation,” “Communicating with Medical Staff and Other Parents,” “Wishful Thinking,” “Acquiring Social Support,” “Positive Reframing,” “Using Passive Appraisal,” “Self-blame,” and “Self-Isolation.” Factors identified to have influence over the type of coping strategies adapted by parents included sex, age, marital status, educational attainment, and monthly family income. Furthermore, results of the K10 showed that majority of the parents were “likely to be well,” although a significant percentage was observed as “likely to have moderate to severe disorder.”Finally, it was also reported that those parents who adapted the positive coping strategies were observed to have lower scores on K10, indicating that they experience less psychological distress. Thus, the hypothesis of the study stating that familiarity, as well as adequate and proper use, of the appropriate coping strategies would help the parents cope or adapt with their child’s cancer in a healthy and well-balanced manner was accepted.
Citation preview
University of the Philippines Manila
College of Arts and Sciences
Department of Behavioral Sciences
Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents
of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer
Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
An Undergraduate Thesis
Presented to
The Faculty of the Department of Behavioral Sciences
University of the Philippines Manila
In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements
for the Degree in Bachelor of Arts
Major in Behavioral Sciences
Presented by
Steve R. Arcilla
2007-68603
March 2011
i
UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES MANILA
COLLEGE OF ARTS AND SCIENCES
Padre Faura, Ermita, Manila
APPROVAL SHEET
This thesis entitled Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children
Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital,
prepared and submitted by Steve Rojano Arcilla, is hereby accepted and
approved in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of Bachelor of
Arts Major in Behavioral Sciences.
Professor Nymia P. Simbulan
Thesis Adviser
Department of Behavioral Sciences
This undergraduate thesis has been accepted as partial fulfillment of the
course requirements for the Degree of Bachelor of Arts Major in Behavioral
Sciences.
Professor Leonardo R. Estacio, Jr.
Chairperson
Department of Behavioral Sciences
ii
Acknowledgements
To my family and friends
who showed their support,
To my respondents
who trusted and helped me out,
To my very supportive and patient thesis adviser,
Prof. Nymia P. Simbulan;
And to you who is sparing some time to read this,
THANK YOU.
iii
Table of Contents
Approval Sheet i
Acknowledgements ii
List of Tables and Figures vi
Abstract vii
Chapter I Introduction 1
General State of the Topic 1
Statement of the Problem 3
Objectives of the Study 6
Hypothesis of the Study 7
Significance of the Study 7
Chapter II Research Frameworks 10
Theoretical Framework 10
Conceptual Framework 11
Operational Framework 13
Chapter III Review of Related Literature 15
Psychological Distress among Parents 15
Socio-demographic Characteristics of Parents
and Their Level of Distress
16
Some Positive Responses by Parents 18
Coping Strategies Adapted by Parents 18
Social Support 19
Communication 19
Search for Meaning 20
Other Coping Strategies 21
Factors Influencing Adjustment or Adaptation 22
Characteristics of Children 23
Characteristics of Parents 24
Coping Resources and Strategies 25
Life Events and Other Stressors 27
iv
Chapter IV Methodology 29
Research Design 29
Reference & Source Population 31
Sampling Design 31
Instrumentation 33
Data Gathering Procedure 38
Ethical Consideration 40
Scope and Limitations 40
Chapter V Presentation of Results 42
Socio-Demographic Profile of Respondents/Parents 42
Socio-Demographic Profile of Children with Cancer 44
Results of the Coping Strategies Questionnaire 46
Coping Strategies of Parents in Relation to
their Socio-Demographic Profile
53
Results of Kessler Psychological Distress Scale (K10) 60
Results of K10 in Relation to the Coping Strategies Adapted 65
Key-Informant Interviews 67
Couple with the Highest Monthly Family Income 68
Couple with the Lowest Monthly Family Income 72
Single Father 76
Single Mother 80
Chapter VI Discussion of Results 84
Socio-Demographic Profile of Parents 84
Common Problems/Difficulties Experienced by Parents 86
Financial Problems 86
Occupational Problems 88
Social-Relational Problems 89
Emotional and Psychological Problems 90
Coping Strategies Adapted by Parents 93
Factors Associated with Type of Coping Strategies Adapted
by Parents
99
Sex of Parent 99
Age of Parent 102
Marital Status of Parent 103
Educational Attainment of Parent 104
Monthly Gamily Income 105
Effects of the Coping Strategies on the Parents 107
v
Chapter VII Summary, Conclusion, and Recommendations 110
Summary 110
Conclusion 113
Recommendations 114
Recommendations to Parents 114
Recommendations to Cancer Institutions 114
Recommendations to Future Researchers 115
Bibliography 116
Appendices 121
Grammarian Letter of Certification 122
English Cover Letter and Informed Consent Form
to Participate in the Survey
123
English Questionnaire 124
Filipino Cover Letter and Informed Consent Form
to Participate in the Survey
128
Filipino Questionnaire 129
English Interview Guide 133
Filipino Interview Guide 134
Biodata ix
vi
List of Tables and Figures
Tables
1 Socio-Demographic Profile of Parents 44
2 Socio-Demographic Profile of Children 45
3 Communicating with Medical Staff and Other Parents 46
4 Acquiring Social Support 47
5 Self-Isolation 48
6 Wishful Thinking 48
7 Seeking Spiritual Support 49
8 Self-blame 50
9 Being Optimistic About the Situation 50
10 Using Passive Appraisal 51
11 Positive Reframing 52
12 Substance Use 52
13 Coping Strategies in Relation to Sex 54
14 Coping Strategies in Relation to Age 55
15 Coping Strategies in Relation to Marital Status 57
16 Coping Strategies in Relation to Educational Attainment 58
17 Coping Strategies in Relation to Monthly Family Income 60
18 Item Scores on Kessler Psychological Distress Scale 63
19 K10 Scores in Relation to Coping Strategies 66
Figures
1 Conceptual Model of the Study 11
2 Total Scores of Parents on K10 65
vii
Abstract
Today, cancer continues to be one of the major chronic illnesses among
children. When a family is confronted with the diagnosis of childhood cancer,
various emotional reactions arise. The word cancer is associated with death,
and for most people cancer cannot be associated with children, especially for the
parents. It is said that for parents, having a child with cancer is both a
psychological and existential challenge that is very difficult to cope with. Hence,
this study focused on the assessment of the coping strategies of both parents, i.e.
the mother and father, of children currently undergoing cancer treatment at the
Philippine General Hospital (PGH).
The purpose of the study was to determine the different coping strategies
and resources that parents of children with cancer use in order to adapt or adjust
to their situation in a healthy and well-balanced manner. It also aimed to
determine the factors associated with the type of coping strategies that they
adapted, as well as to describe the common problems and difficulties
experienced by these parents with regard to their situation. A total of 83 parents,
including 42 mothers and 41 fathers, participated in the study.
The researcher used both quantitative and qualitative methods in
conducting the research. Using the Kessler Psychological Distress Scale (K10),
the depression and anxiety experienced by the respondents was determined, and
using the Coping Strategies Questionnaire, a survey questionnaire created by the
researcher, the different types of coping strategies adapted by the parents were
viii
identified. Likewise, the researcher conducted Key-Informant Interviews with six
of the 83 respondents to further investigate the coping behavior as well as the
quality of life of the parents after the diagnosis of their childs cancer. Finally,
both descriptive and inferential statistical analysis was performed by the
researcher to analyze the data gathered.
The results revealed that parents significantly used Seeking Spiritual
Support among the other coping strategies, with Substance Use as the least
adapted coping strategy. The remaining coping strategies were Being Optimistic
about the Situation, Communicating with Medical Staff and Other Parents,
Wishful Thinking, Acquiring Social Support, Positive Reframing, Using
Passive Appraisal, Self-blame, and Self-Isolation. Factors identified to have
influence over the type of coping strategies adapted by parents included sex, age,
marital status, educational attainment, and monthly family income. Furthermore,
results of the K10 showed that majority of the parents were likely to be well,
although a significant percentage was observed as likely to have moderate to
severe disorder.
Finally, it was also reported that those parents who adapted the positive
coping strategies were observed to have lower scores on K10, indicating that
they experience less psychological distress. Thus, the hypothesis of the study
stating that familiarity, as well as adequate and proper use, of the appropriate
coping strategies would help the parents cope or adapt with their childs cancer
in a healthy and well-balanced manner was accepted.
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
1
CHAPTER I Introduction
General State of the Topic
It is likely for children, starting from infancy to their childhood, to have
different health problems. For most children, these problems are mild and do not
interfere with their daily life as well as their development. However, those
children with chronic illnesses may have to suffer from their condition
throughout their childhood.
Today, one of the major chronic illnesses among children is cancer
(Hayman et al., 2002). It strikes randomly, unexpectedly, sparing no age group,
socio-economic status, ethnic group or geographic region. Children as young as a
few months, barely able to talk and walk, can already have cancer (Philippine
Information Agency, 2009). However, despite the major advances in treatment
and supportive care, cancer is still considered to be the leading cause of death
among children aged 14 and below (Philippine Cancer Society, 2007). Childhood
cancer survival rate in developed countries is as high as 95%. However, in the
Philippines, sadly, it is only 10 to 30% (International Union Against Cancer,
2005). Also, according to the Philippine Information Agency (2009), about 3,500
Filipino children fall victim to cancer every year, and every day, eight children
die; one in every three hours. Cases of children diagnosed with cancer continue
to increase annually in our country, and with the diagnosis, comes the long,
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
2
stressful, and painful medical journey that the patient, together with his or her
family, is about to go through.
A childs health concerns the parents as well as the other members of the
family (Warsh & Strong-Boag, 2005). That is why if a child is diagnosed to have
cancer, each member of the family becomes a part of one of the hardest battles
they will ever encounter. The childs parents, however, are the ones greatly
affected by their son or daughters cancer diagnosis and treatment. It is said to be
one of the worst news that a parent could ever receive. The emotional impact of
the diagnosis of cancer is intense and long lasting for them (Hashemi et al.,
2007). It is a psychological and an existential challenge for both of the parents
(Norberg, 2004). Also, with the gender difference between the parents, the effect
on the mother tends to differ with that of the father when confronted with
problems like this. Reactions, as well as adaptation, to the situation differ
between the mother and the father of the child (Magni et al., 1986). But as
parents, both of them try to provide all the support that they can give to their
children as they fight through cancer, and if these parents are not given or do not
receive the sufficient social and spiritual support from other people and if they
do not use the proper coping strategies, they may then experience and suffer
from psychological distress and maladjustments and emotional problems as well
(Hashemi et al., 2007).
For parents, coping with all the physical and emotional demands or
stressors that come along with their childs condition is not a very easy thing to
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
3
do. However, with the proper or appropriate coping strategies, dealing with the
situation might be a little easier for them (Hashemi et al., 2007).
In order to identify these appropriate coping techniques, it is essential to
assess the coping strategies used by the parents of children with cancer as well
as how good they have adapted to the situation using these strategies. It could
provide the coping strategies used by those parents who have already adapted
well and can therefore be used as reference by other parents. Thus, this study
was done to assess the adaptation as well as the coping strategies used by
mothers and fathers of children with cancer. And since the Philippine General
Hospital holds one of the leading cancer institutions in our country, this study
was carried out within its facilities.
Statement of the Problem
Children are the most valued and vulnerable members of a family, and if
one of them falls ill with a serious, life-threatening disease like cancer, the entire
family is thrown in a state of shock (Fromer, 1995).
Cancer is a disease that takes a child's strength, destroys organs and
bones, and weakens the body's defenses against other illnesses (Barrett et al.,
2005). According to Cancer.Net (2010), childhood cancer has become the second
leading cause of death among children, with Leukemia as the most common type
of childhood cancer. Also, the International Union Against Cancer (2005) showed
that about 160,000 children worldwide are diagnosed with cancer annually and
an estimated 90,000 will eventually die of their disease. In the Philippines,
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
4
children comprise 4050% of the population, and the proportion of childhood
cancer patients represents 310% of the total (International Union Against
Cancer, 2005). According to the Philippine Information Agency (2009), 8 kids die
every day because of cancer in the National Capital Region (NCR) alone. Also,
according to Dr. Mae Conception Dolendo (2009), a pediatric oncologist at the
Davao Medical Center (DMC), there are about 80-100% new cases of childhood
cancer at DMC every year. And lastly, the data provided by the Philippine
Information Agency (2009) showed that about 3,500 children fall victim to
cancer every year. These figures show how the incidence of children diagnosed
with cancer is rapidly increasing in the country, and for the family, especially the
parents, of these young children, this diagnosis is a devastating blow that creates
an instant crisis to their lives.
For parents, having a child diagnosed with cancer is not just a medical
journey. For them, it is a very difficult and heart-wrenching emotional
experience. It is learning to cope with seeing their child suffer from so much pain
and leaving them with feelings of helplessness and unable to provide any
solutions to make their child feel better. Also, childhood cancer changes the life
situation of the family and brings about stressors to the parents of varying
duration, predictability, and impact (Norberg, 2004). Normal daily life of the
family stops. The current situation implies demands and changes from the
parents everyday life. These demands include accepting intensity of ones own
reactions as well as handling with the reactions of other people, seeing the child
in pain as they undergo and suffer multiple hospitalizations, chemotherapy, etc.,
concerns about the childs future, the quality of care, aspects of the cancer
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
5
treatment itself, negative employment and financial consequences, and
supporting siblings of the ill child (Norberg, 2004). All these demands and
stressors become a part of the parents daily life starting from their childs cancer
diagnosis and all throughout his or her treatment. And for parents, this is a lot to
ask.
Most parents do have a hard time moving on with their life after their
child has been diagnosed with cancer. When a child has to stay in the hospital for
a long period of time for his or her treatment, the uncertainty and
unpredictability of the current situation keep both parents in a continuous state
of anxiety, expectation, and fear, making these emotions hard to control and face
in a well-balanced manner (Barrett et al., 2005). According to the study of Kazak
et al. (2005), most parents find their childs treatment traumatic. Results of the
study showed that Posttraumatic Stress Symptoms (PTSS) do seem to be
common among parents of children currently undergoing cancer treatment. Out
of the sample parents, only one parent was reported not to have PTSS. This
shows that most parents really are having a hard time handling this kind of
situation properly which then leads to psychological and emotional problems or
maladjustments. However, with the proper amount of social and spiritual
support as well as the use of the appropriate coping strategies, parents may cope
with the situation in a healthy way. It is then important to know the appropriate
coping strategies that these parents should use.
Also, it should not be forgotten that this kind of situation affects the
mother and the father of the child differently. The gender of both parents shows
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
6
differences as to how they adjust and adapt to their childs cancer diagnosis
(Magni et al., 1986). Furthermore, considering the different socio-demographic
statuses of these parents, which also influence the coping strategies that they
adapt, such as socio-economic status, educational attainment, etc., also seems
important to the study.
Objectives of the Study
The main objective of this study is to determine the different coping
strategies and resources that parents, i.e. the mother and father, of children with
cancer use in order to adapt or adjust to the situation in a healthy and well-
balanced manner.
The specific objectives of this study are:
to describe the socio-demographic profile of parents of children
diagnosed with cancer,
to identify the common problems and difficulties, i.e. economic,
psychological-emotional, social-relational, etc. experienced by
parents of children diagnosed with cancer,
to describe the coping strategies adapted by mothers and fathers
of children with cancer,
to determine the factors associated with the type of coping
strategies adapted by parents, and
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
7
to determine the effects of these coping strategies on them as
parents.
Hypothesis of the Study
The study has the following hypotheses:
Ha: Familiarity, as well as adequate and proper use, of the
appropriate coping strategies would help the parents cope or
adapt with their childs cancer in a healthy and well-balanced
manner.
H0: Familiarity, as well as adequate and proper use, of the
appropriate coping strategies will have no effect on the parents
adaptation or adjustment to the situation.
Significance of the Study
The main focus of this study is the parents, including both the mother and
the father, of children diagnosed with cancer and are currently undergoing
treatment. These parents together with their family are facing one of the hardest
challenges in their life. They may be having the toughest time of their life. Also, as
presented by the Department of Health as well as the Philippine Information
Agency (2009), the number of children diagnosed with cancer in the Philippines
increases every year, which means that without the proper coping strategies, the
number of parents that may suffer from psychological and emotional problems
may increase as well. With all this in mind, it seems vital or important to identify
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
8
and provide these parents with the proper coping strategies that could help them
deal and cope with the situation in a more positive way.
Also, during the cancer treatment of the child, the parents ability to
manage or balance his or her psychological distress is vital not only to his or her
own consolation or comfort, but it can also influence the childs well-being and
his or her long-term psychological adjustment (Norberg, 2004). Therefore, this
study is not only significant for the parents well-being but is also beneficial to
the children diagnosed with cancer as well as the rest of the family members.
Since the Philippines is a third-world country, having a child in your
family diagnosed with cancer would already mean a big problem financially.
Parents in the family suffering from psychological distress could not afford to go
to a psychiatrist or get any professional help anymore. With this, it seems that
this study is not just significant but it seems practical as well. This study could
provide these parents the information to handle the situation better so as to
lessen any psychological and emotional problems.
Furthermore, this study may also be beneficial to the cancer institution
itself in planning services not just for the patient but also for the parents of the
patient. It may also highlight the areas of practice and administration in which
improvements can be made. This study may also help the institutions create the
necessary facilities to implement these coping strategies. And since coping is one
major concept in nursing, this study may also be significant for the nurses in
helping the parents of the patient adapt in their current situation supporting and
providing them with the proper information about coping. Moreover, this study
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
9
may also serve as a future reference for other researchers on the subject of
coping strategies of both parents of children with cancer.
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
10
CHAPTER II Research Frameworks
Theoretical Framework
The Family Stress and Coping Theory is used as the framework of this
study. This theoretical foundation provides a broad base from which questions
are presented and responses are analyzed. The Family Stress and Coping Theory
assumes that individuals and families adapt to stress, and that they view
stressors and resources according to their own perception (McCubbin &
Patterson, 1985). It also assumes that their adaptation is affected by the
supposed stressors, the way the situation is perceived, and the resources or
coping strategies available to help deal with the stress.
The Family Stress and Coping Theory uses two models: Hills ABCX Model
(Hill, 1949) and the Double ABCX Model of Family Adaptation and Adjustment
(McCubbin & Patterson, 1985). The ABCX Model, which was designed to explain
the families responses or reactions to war separation and reunion, uses the
interaction of three factors to determine if the family experiences a crisis. These
factors include the stressor, the familys available resources in dealing with the
crisis, and their definition of the stressor event.
On the other hand, the Double ABCX Model of Family Adaptation and
Adjustment assumes that factors, both inside and outside the family, affect or
influence how well families adapt to a chronic stressor, such as chronic illness in
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
11
a child, and in this case, cancer. It also states that in understanding a familys
response to a stressful life event, the coping process, both cognitive and
behavioral strategies, is a key aspect. Coping strategies that individuals use have
also been categorized as problem-focused or those that moderate or control the
problem, or emotion-focused or those that reduce the emotional distress.
Conceptual Framework
Figure 1. Conceptual Model of the Study
According to the related literature of this study, a childs cancer diagnosis
can bring about various emotional and psychological distresses to the parents
(Magni et al., 1986). This could include depression, anxiety, stress, as well as
insomnia, sleep disturbances, and other somatic symptoms. With all the various
emotional and psychological distresses together with the different demands of
the situation, both parents tend to use the available or preferred coping
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
12
strategies and resources in order to cope with the situation. However, as
illustrated on Figure 1 above, the dependent variable (DV) of this study or the
coping strategies that parents adapt in coping with the situation is influenced or
is dependent on several factors concerning the parents themselves, which make
up the independent variables (IV) of this study. These factors are basically some
of the socio-demographic information about the parents. One good example of
these is their sex. Since there is an existing gender dimension as to how their
childs cancer diagnosis affects them, mothers and fathers tend to adjust and
adapt differently to the situation, which results to the different coping strategies
used by each parent (Morrow et al., 1984). Other factors involving parents
include their age, attitude towards the disease of their child, educational
attainment, economic status or income, and their family support.
However, another set of variables that may affect the relationship
between the independent and dependent variables of the study have also been
observed by the researcher. These variables, such as sex, age, number of
hospitalizations, and duration of treatment of the child with cancer, are
considered to be the confounding variables (CV) of the study. These factors,
according to the related literature of this study, may also influence the behavior
of parents as they cope with the situation; that is why it is important for the
researcher to control or to minimize the effects of these variables in order to
obtain the proper relationship between the independent and dependent
variables.
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
13
Taking into account all these factors, the mother and the father now adapt
to the situation using coping strategies that may either help them adjust or adapt
positively, or lead them to a negative adjustment or adaptation. According to the
related literature, some coping strategies really help these parents cope with the
situation in a well-balanced manner thus, helping them adjust or adapt positively
to the situation. However, according to Wittrock et al. (1994), there are also
some coping strategies that instead of helping the parents cope positively with
the situation; they actually increase the parents depression and anxiety. Because
of the lack of proper emotional and social support, some parents tend to use
undesirable coping mechanisms, like alcohol abuse, thus leading them to a
maladjustment or maladaptation.
Operational Framework
Childs cancer diagnosis children, aged 1-14 years, presently diagnosed
with any type of cancer and is being treated at the Philippine General
Hospital (PGH)
Parents sex refers to the biological characteristics that determines the
parents reproductive role (e.g. male or female)
Parents (Mother/Father) age refers to the number of years that the
parent have existed or lived
Parents (Mother/Father) civil status refers to the current marital status
of the parents (e.g. single, married, divorced, etc.)
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
14
Parents (Mother/Father) socio-economic status refers to the
employment, income, as well as the social status in the community of the
parent
Parents (Mother/Father) educational attainment refers to the level of
education that the parent have achieved (e.g. primary, secondary, etc.)
Childs age refers to the number of years that the child diagnosed with
cancer have existed or lived
Childs sex refers to the biological characteristics that determines the
childs reproductive role
Number of hospitalizations refers to the number of times the child
diagnosed with cancer was hospitalized due to his/her illness
Duration of treatment refers to the length of time the child diagnosed
with cancer has been undergoing treatment
Coping strategies of parents refers to the different available or preferred
coping techniques or styles that the parents use as a response to their
childs cancer diagnosis
Positive adjustment a well-balanced psychological and emotional
adjustment or adaptation of parents to the demands and stress brought
about by the childs cancer diagnosis
Negative adjustment when parents engage in processes leading to poor
or negative adaptation or those that has become harmful than helpful
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
15
CHAPTER III Review of Related Literature
Psychological Distress among Parents
In a family, the children are the most cherished and vulnerable, and when
cancer strikes among them, various emotional reactions from the family will take
place. According to the studies of Dahlquist et al. (1993), and Magni et al. (1986),
most parents of children diagnosed with cancer, or children who are in
treatment, showed increased signs of psychological and emotional distress as
compared to the normative data of the studies. Also, in some longitudinal studies
(Fife et al., 1987; Sawyer et al., 1993), results showed that even months after the
diagnosis, parents still suffer from psychological distress such as anxiety,
depression, insomnia, as well as somatic symptoms. Feelings of depression as
well as sleep disturbances were reported among parents even after 8 months
since the diagnosis of their children (Magni et al., 1986), and according to
Sawyers et al. (1993) study, depression and somatic symptoms are still higher
one year after the diagnosis. Lastly, Powazek et al. (1980) reported that families,
one year after the diagnosis, still suffer from high levels of stress.
Other studies concerning parents with children undergoing active cancer
treatment also reported psychological distress among the parents (Larson et al.,
1994; Brown et al., 1993). Psychiatric disorders were diagnosed among 34% of
the mothers of children with cancer during the different phases of their childs
treatment (Brown et al., 1993). Also, results of the Beck Depression Inventory
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
16
(BDI) showed that the mothers diagnosed with psychiatric disorder got higher
scores on depression than those who were not diagnosed with any psychiatric
disorder.
Studies by Morrow et al. (1984) and Brown et al. (1993), also analyzed
parents of those children that were off treatment. Morrow et al. (1984) reported
these parents having the lowest scores on a scale measuring the psychological
adjustment to the illness. Brown et al. (1993) also found out that mothers of
children who were off treatment had significantly lower depression scores
compared to the mothers of children newly diagnosed with cancer, and mothers
of children one year after diagnosis.
For those parents with children that have survived cancer, emotional
disturbances were lesser compared to the normative data (Kazak et al., 1994).
However, Kazak et al. (1994) also reported that if the illness-related concerns of
the children of these parents will be taken into consideration, these parents still
seem to experience posttraumatic symptoms, feelings of uncertainty, and fear for
relapses. Worries about infertility, and uncertainties about the future are also
very common (Leventhal-Belfer et al., 1993).
Socio-demographic Characteristics of Parents and Their Level of Distress
Some of the socio-demographic characteristics of those parents of
children with cancer have been observed as factors in the difference in the levels
of distress that they experience. One major example of this is the sex of the
parent. Difference between the psychological distress experienced by the
mothers and the fathers of children diagnosed with cancer have been recorded in
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
17
some studies; for example, in a study made by Sloper (1998), 51% of mothers
were observed with high levels of distress, while only around 40% of fathers
displayed the same levels of distress. She also reported that predictors of
distress for mothers differ with that of the father. For mothers, their appraisal of
the strain of the illness, their own ability to deal with it, and family cohesion
were the significant predictors of distress while for the fathers, predictors of
distress included the risk factors of employment problems, and the number of
the child's hospital admissions (Sloper, 1998). Furthermore, a study by Brown et
al. (1993) showed that a year after the diagnosis, the emotional problems
experienced by mothers and fathers differ as well. Results of the study showed
that a high percentage of mothers were diagnosed as overanxious while fathers,
on the other hand, were diagnosed with major depression or increased feelings
of depression.
Another socio-demographic characteristic of parents that affects the
psychological distress that they experience is their socio-economic status (SES).
Parents with a low SES, or lower income, are said to have greater risks of having
psychological and emotional problems (Van Dongen-Melman et al., 1995).
Mothers with lower SES are also said to suffer from increased maladjustments
compared to those with higher SES.
Age and civil status are also considered to be factors affecting the parents
psychological distress. As Morrow et al. (1984) reported, younger parents had
significant greater psycho-social adjustment difficulties, while those parents that
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
18
were married tended to have moderately lower levels of depression and anxiety
than those who were currently not married.
Some Positive Responses by Parents
On another note, some positive responses are also reported by parents as
a result of their childs illness. These include their good support systems,
increased closeness within the family, strengthened marital relationships, and
new values and attitudes in life, as well as reports on how they value life more
(Peck et al., 1979). This shows that even this kind of event can still bring about
positive reactions in a family. Having said this, however, we cannot deny the
hardship brought about by the childs condition to their parents. This is where
appropriate coping strategies become significant and helpful.
Coping Strategies Adapted by Parents
Most of the studies related to this research have used similar scales or
questionnaires in measuring or assessing the coping strategies used in coping
with the cancer diagnosis among children. Three scales were used in more than
one study, and these are Social Support Questionnaire (SSQ), The Coping Health
Inventory for Parents (CHIP), and the Ways of Coping Scale and its adapted
version, the Coping Strategy Inventory (CSI). Different conceptualizations of
coping strategies such as positive and negative type of coping, disengagement
and engagement coping, and emotion and problem focused coping have been
identified from the different studies using these scales. Common coping
strategies observed in studies were social support (Morrow et al., 1984),
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
19
communication (Brown et al., 1993), and search for meaning (Bearison et al.,
1993).
Social Support
Social support refers to the emotional and physical comfort given to an
individual to help him or her cope with stress (Overholser and Fritz, 1990). A
study by Morrow et al. (1984) showed that support from family and friends of
parents have been very helpful to them. They reported that support from the
medical community as well as the other parents in the help group were
recognized by the parents as the most efficient sources of support. Also,
according to the study of Larson et al. (1994), among the parents, the mothers
are the ones that use social support more often. They reported that mothers of
children with cancer and even those of healthy controls receive more overall
informational as well as emotional support than did fathers. They also added that
mothers appeared to have more contact with their relatives and friends than
fathers do.
Communication
Communication also plays a vital role in the parents coping.
Communication here does not only refer to communication between the parents
and the child about the illness but it also refers to the communication between
the parents and their family and friends about their emotional experiences
(Leventhal-Belfer et al., 1993). Also, according to Brown et al. (1993),
understanding of the childs medical condition through communication with the
other parents going through the same situation as well as communication with
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
20
the medical staff that are a part or helps with the treatment of the child are also
seen by other parents as a good coping strategy. They reported that a good
relationship with the medical team is important for parents of children with
cancer. Parents try to build their trust on them as their childrens lives mostly
depend on their treatment. Magnis et al. (1986) study also reported that
parents of children with cancer gave more importance to their relationship with
their childrens medical team than the parents of children with other conditions.
In addition, Shapiro and Shumaker (1987), found that compared to the
fathers, mothers of children with cancer tend to have more open and more
frequent communication with their sick child. They also found that those parents
who were less well-educated and those that use passive coping tend to have
better relationships with the medical staff. Because parents can acquire
information and get support with their communication with other parents and
the medical staff, communication and support were seen as related to one
another (Brown et al. 1993).
Search for Meaning
Another common coping mechanism observed on parents of children
with cancer was searching for meaning. Bearison et al., (1993) stated that in
times of traumatic events, people try to search for the reason on why and how
the event occurred in order to understand and make sense about it and thus,
cope with it emotionally and gain some sense of control. They, however, found
that most of the parents resort in internal types of attributions and especially
self-blame in their search for meaning of their childs condition. In the study, it
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
21
was observed that mothers blamed themselves for their childs illness more
often. Fathers, on the other hand, often tend to accept that there was no reason
for the childs illness (Bearison et al., 1993). Other attributions such as
environmental factors as the cause of their childs illness were also observed in
their study.
Other Coping Strategies
Other coping strategies used more often by parents of children diagnosed
with cancer have also been mentioned or identified in some related literature.
This includes withdrawal (Fife et al., 1987), and wishful thinking, (Sawyer et al.,
1993). Petermann et al. (1986) also identified praying and religion as a coping
strategy. They found in their study that the fathers were the ones who most often
used praying as a coping strategy.
Other studies reported about coping strategies in terms of emotion or
problem-focused type of coping (Wittrock et al., 1994). Wittrock et al. (1994), for
example, identified five emotion-focused coping strategies, such as maintaining
emotional balance, relying on religion, being optimistic, denial and acceptance,
and three problem-focused coping strategies such as information seeking,
problem solving and help seeking. However, no correlations were found in using
these eight coping strategies.
Furthermore, Grootenhuis et al. (1996) also identified different types of
control strategies as the parents means of coping with childhood cancer. These
control strategies included predictive, vicarious, illusory and interpretative
control. Grootenhuis et al. (1996) reported that mothers tend to depend more on
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
22
interpretative and illusory control than fathers do. They also found that parents
of children in remission relied more on vicarious and predictive control than
those parents of children with a relapse.
Wishful thinking and attribution of special characteristics to the child
with cancer by their parents were also considered and investigated as a coping
strategy by Grootenhuis et al. (1996). This attribution of positive characteristics
to the child provides the parents with an image of their child as being special and
vital, which leads them to develop or create the illusion that fate will be kind to
them. Also, with the parents believing that their child is strong and can handle
the situation, their confidence that their child will survive increases (Grootenhuis
et al. 1996).
Factors Influencing Adjustment or Adaptation
These coping strategies may be helpful for some parents regarding their
adaptation and adjustment to the situation. However, there are still other factors
that may influence how well they adapt to their childs condition. According to
some studies, factors like the characteristics of the child with cancer (Van
Dongen-Melman et al., 1995), characteristics of the parents (Magni et al. 1986),
the kind of coping strategies these parents use (Morrow et al. 1984), and other
life events and stressors (Kalnins et al. 1980) all contribute or influence the
adjustment or coping of parents with children diagnosed with cancer.
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
23
Characteristics of Children
Some child-related factors have been reported to have affected the
parents adaptation and adjustment (Van Dongen-Melman et al., 1995). These
factors were reported to cause more emotional and psychological problems to
the parents. These include the number of hospitalizations of the child, and the
childs functional impairment. These factors are said to have caused more
depression among mothers as well as increased problems in both parents (Van
Dongen-Melman et al., 1995). Also, a lesser survival perspective of the child,
which is indicated by a relapse or second malignancy, was associated to more
emotional problems in both parents (Van Dongen-Melman et al., 1995).
Furthermore, the duration of the childs treatment was found to have a positive
correlation with maternal posttraumatic stress symptoms by Stuber et al.
(1994).
Other child-related factors like the age and sex of the child diagnosed with
cancer have also been reported to influence the parents adjustment. Kupst et al.
(1995), found that there is a relation between the parents adjustment to their
childrens age. According to the results of the study, parents with younger
children had difficulty coping than those parents with older children. Brown et
al. (1993), on the other hand, reported that parents, especially the mothers, with
male children diagnosed with cancer have shown higher levels of depression and
view their sons cancer diagnosis as having greater impact on them.
Lastly, Mulhern et al. (1992) also investigated the emotional reactions of
the children with cancer as a factor influencing the parents adaptation to the
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
24
situation. They reported that children showing higher levels of depression cause
depressive symptoms among mothers. They also found that the childrens
behavior problems as well as their difficulties in adjusting to their illness were
predictors for the mothers adjustment problems.
Characteristics of Parents
Factors involving the parents themselves were also seen to have
influenced their adjustment and adaptation. Of the parent-related factors, gender
is considered to be one of the most significant and has received the most
attention. According to the study of Magni et al. (1986), sex differences among
parents also show variances in adjustment and adaptation to the childs cancer
diagnosis. They reported that there is an increasing evidence of differences in the
levels of depression and anxiety for mothers and fathers. Also, according to their
study, fathers reactions to the situation differ in several ways. It was described
that fathers tend to have increased drinking and avoiding discussion of the
subject. Lastly, Magni et al. (1986) also reported that these differences may be
caused by the fathers tendency to deny or their failure to report the actual
distress that they are experiencing, and that this does not necessarily mean that
fathers experiences less distress.
Other factors affecting the parents adjustment to childhood cancer
include some of their socio-demographic background such as their age, civil
status, and socio-economic status. In a study made by Van Dongen-Melman et al.
(1995), the significance of the socio-economic status of the parents in their
adjustment to the situation was investigated. They have observed that parents
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
25
with lower income or low socio-economic status have higher risks of having
problems. They also found that those mothers with lower socio-economic status
adapted higher degrees of emotion-focused coping, which unfortunately was
associated with increased maladjustments. In addition to that, compared to those
parents in the study with higher socio-economic status, those parents with lower
socio-economic status were observed to have more self-criticism as well as self-
blame (Van Dongen-Melman et al. 1995).
Furthermore, Morrow et al. (1984) reported in their study that younger
parents, or those below the age of 30, had more difficulty coping or adjusting
than those older parents. They also suggested in their study that being married is
another factor influencing parents adjustment. They reported that parents
currently married had lesser emotional or psychological distress than those who
were not married.
Coping Resources and Strategies
Also, as mentioned earlier, the coping resources and the kind of coping
strategies that the parents use also affect the parents coping with the situation.
Coping strategies play a vital role on the parents adjustment and parents use
different or various coping strategies. One of the coping resources that really
helped the parents was the social support that they received. According to
Morrow et al. (1984), support from friends and relatives are really helpful for
parents of children with cancer to cope better with their situation especially
after diagnosis and during treatment. Sex differences were also visible in the use
of social support as a coping strategy. According to study of Larson et al. (1994),
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
26
for both parents, social support was observed to be inversely related to anxiety
and depression, but it also appeared that mothers placed greater importance on
social support than the fathers.
Another example of coping strategy is communication. Brown et al.
(1993) reported that open and frequent disease-specific communication
between the parents and the medical staff, as well as communication between
the mother and the father were found to be positively correlated with good
adjustment as well as marital quality.
Other coping strategies that seem to be related to a positive adjustment
were also identified by Bearison et al., (1993). They included external types of
attributions and acceptance of the physicians advice that the cause was
unknown. These coping strategies are under the idea suggested by Bearison et
al., (1993) about searching for meaning in a traumatic event like this. They also
found that those parents who understand their childrens medical condition
better experience less distress. Furthermore, Petermann et al. (1986) have also
identified five coping techniques and reported that families tend to be more
stable and stress-resistant if they see their childs disease as a challenge.
According to their study, having a positive outlook about the childs disease will
bring about positive adjustment as well.
However, there are also some particular coping strategies which were
found to have caused maladjustments increasing the parents depression and
anxiety. These were found by Wittrock et al. (1994) to be disengaged coping and
emotion-focused coping styles.
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
27
In a study, however, made by Baskin et al. (1983), no relations between
coping strategies and adjustment or adaptation were reported. They stated that,
although parents experience high level of stress and say that they are coping
well, no correlations were found between coping strategies and adjustment.
They also reported that problem-focused coping and communication have no
relation whatsoever to adjustment.
Life Events and Other Stressors
The factors mentioned above all affect or contribute as to how well the
parents will cope with their childs condition. However, there are also other life
events or stressors that still continue to occur with the parents lives. As these
parents continue to face the demands brought about by their childrens
condition, most of them also continue dealing with other life events or
concurrent stressors. This was observed in the study made by Kalnins et al. in
1980. Kalnins et al. (1980) classified these problems as illness in other family
members, other major complications related to the childs illness, death of
another befriended child with cancer or other significant person, changes in their
occupation, and financial problems. According to Kalnins et al. (1980), financial
problems have the greatest impact on families. Overholser and Fritz (1990) also
found that financial problems experienced by parents were related to setbacks in
the mothers occupation or career. They also found that the mothers were the
ones who suffered setbacks in their occupation more often compared to the
fathers.
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
28
Furthermore, Brown et al. (1993) found that compared to those parents
with physically healthy children, parents of children with cancer encounter more
stressful life events. They also found that parents of children newly diagnosed
with cancer experience greater familial stressors. Moreover, it was found by
Kupst et al. (1995) that those parents who experience less additional life events
or stressors experience better adjustment or coping.
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
29
CHAPTER IV Methodology
Research Design
In this study, the researcher decided to use both quantitative and
qualitative designs. The quantitative part of the study was covered or provided
by the data collected after letting the participants of the study answer two
questionnaires, one of which is the Kessler Psychological Distress Scale, also
known as K10, and the other is the Coping Strategies Questionnaire, a survey
questionnaire created by the researcher so as to obtain the specific and
necessary data needed for the study. The questionnaire created by the
researcher was used to determine the coping strategies that the participants use
in relation to their current situation. The K10, on the other hand, was used to
determine the levels of psychological distress that they experience as an effect of
the situation.
Socio-demographic information about the participants, such as age, sex,
educational attainment, etc., was also obtained by the researcher. Also, as
observed in the related literature of the study, some information regarding the
child, such as their age, sex, number of hospitalizations, duration of treatment,
etc., also affects the parents adjustment and adaptation; that is why the
researcher has also decided to obtain the necessary information about the child
diagnosed with cancer.
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
30
Furthermore, correlations between all the observed factors affecting the
adaptation and adjustment of the participants, and the observed type of coping
and adjustment that the participants display were also provided by the
researcher as part of the quantitative data. To determine whether there is a
statistically significant association (represented by the P-value) between the
variables, the researcher applied the statistical tests such as the Independent
Samples T-Test, and One-way ANOVA on the data. Furthermore, a P-value of less
than 0.05 was considered significant.
On the other hand, the qualitative part of this study included Key-
Informant Interviews. These interviews were conducted in order to obtain other
information that may not have been covered by the quantitative part of the
study. They were also used to describe the quality of life of the parents after the
diagnosis of their childs cancer. Through these interviews the researcher has
obtained more candid and in-depth answers from the respondents regarding
their situation. Furthermore, with the help of the selected key-informants, the
researcher has assessed further the coping behavior of parents of children with
cancer.
The researcher has chosen both quantitative and qualitative designs in
order to have both the quantitative and qualitative data that are essential to this
study. The quantitative design is important in this study as it creates a statistical
model in an attempt to assess and explain the coping strategies used by the
participants. This design may also provide a precise measurement and analysis
of the levels of stress that the participants experience in relation to the coping
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
31
strategies that they adapt. The qualitative design, on the other hand, was also
chosen by the researcher so as to create a deeper analysis or understanding of
the participants current situation. Also, according to Gilgun (1992), the amount,
richness and depth of data acquired by the very nature of qualitative designs
help to fill in existing gaps in research through a focus on experiences within as
well as between families and outside systems.
Reference & Source Population
The participants of this study included the parents, both the mother and
father of children diagnosed with cancer who are currently being treated at the
Philippine General Hospital. The researcher also chose this specific setting where
the sample participants were obtained because of the fact that the PGH houses
one of the leading cancer institutions in the Philippines and also because PGH
offers a very cheap treatment, which means that people from different places
from the country tend to go here and get their treatment. Having said this, it
seems that the researcher has obtained or gathered respondents from a wide
range of participants, which somehow helped enrich the data of the research.
Sampling Design
The study employed a purposive sampling technique. Purposive sampling
is based on the assumption that one wants to discover, understand, gain insight;
therefore one needs to select a sample from which one can learn the most
(Merriam, 1988).
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
32
Purposive sampling is also criterion-based and the criteria used for the
selection of the participants are that their sons or daughters diagnosed with
cancer should be at the age of 18 years or below. Their son or daughter should
also be currently undergoing cancer treatment at the PGH and should be under
the supervision of an oncologist. No age limit was set for the participants.
With this, a total of 83 respondents participated in the study. This number
or sample size should be enough to represent the total population of parents of
children with cancer at the PGH.
With regard to the Key-Informant Interviews, the researcher decided to
have the couple with the highest monthly income, the couple with the lowest
monthly income, a single mother, and a single father among the respondents as
the key-informants of the study. Since according to the related literature, the
socio-economic status of parents is considered to be one of the major factors
influencing them as to what type of coping strategies they adapt with regard to
the situation, the researcher chose the couples with the highest and lowest
monthly income as key-informants. Also, the researcher chose a single mother
and father as key-informants because according again to the related literature,
marital status and sex also greatly affects the coping mechanisms of parents.
Furthermore, the researcher believed that these people are enough to represent
the respondents of the study and provide the necessary and significant
additional information about the topic.
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
33
Instrumentation
After getting the appropriate sample for the study, quantitative and
qualitative data was then gathered from the participants using the selected
instruments of the researcher. The instruments used in this study included
Coping Strategies Questionnaire, a questionnaire created by the researcher,
which covered the coping strategies used by the parents, the Kessler
Psychological Distress Scale (K10), a psychological screening tool which
determined the levels of psychological distress experienced by the parents in the
past month prior to taking the test, and an open-ended, semi-structured
interview guide, which was used by the researcher to further assess the coping
behavior of the participants in the Key-Informant Interviews conducted.
The researcher also provided a demographic sheet that the participants
filled out with socio-demographic information, as well as other information that
was needed for the study, about themselves and their child, who was diagnosed
with cancer. The socio-demographic information gathered included the parents
name, age, gender, religion, occupation, monthly family income, educational
attainment, civil status, and number of children, as well as the childs name, age,
gender, and birth order. Other information about the childs illness included the
hospitalization times, duration of stay in the hospital, and the duration when
their child was diagnosed with cancer. All these information were seen by the
researcher, as well as some of the related literature of this study, to be significant
variables affecting both the mother and the fathers coping mechanism.
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
34
After that, the participants proceed to the Kessler Psychological Distress
Scale (K10). The K10 is a brief, simple, valid, and reliable screening tool
developed in 1992 by Professors Ron Kessler and Dan Mroczek that measures
non-specific psychological distress in the anxiety-depression spectrum (Kessler
et al., 1994). It has been widely used in researches and in population health
surveys in United States, Australia, as well as in other countries. It has also been
included in the WHO World Mental Health surveys, which are being carried out
in 30 countries around the world. Also, several translated versions of the K10,
including Arabic, Chinese, German, Dutch, Italian, Japanese, and other languages,
have already been developed. For this study, the K10 will also be translated into
Filipino by the researcher in order to get more accurate results from the Filipino
participants.
The Kessler Psychological Distress Scale consists of 10 questions about
non-specific psychological distress that seeks to determine the level of current
symptoms of depression and anxiety that a person may have experienced in the
past four weeks prior to the interview (Kessler et al., 1994). Items of the scale
cover different emotional states like feeling nervous, hopeless, restless or fidgety,
depressed, and worthless. It is a self-administered tool wherein a person
responds using a five-level response scale based on the amount of time that the
person reports experiencing the particular problem in each item. The response
categories for each of the items include: none of the time, a little of the time,
some of the time, most of the time, and all of the time. Some examples of the
items in the K10 are: 1) In the past 4 weeks, about how often did you feel tired out
for no good reason; 2) In the past 4 weeks, about how often did you feel nervous;
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
35
and 3) In the past 4 weeks, about how often did you feel so nervous that nothing
could calm you down. Completing the questionnaire may only take about 2-3
minutes.
As stated, the main function of K10 is to determine the level of current
psychological distress experienced by an individual. With regard to the
objectives of this study, this instrument is a good tool in collecting data regarding
the severity of psychological distress that the parents of children with cancer
experience as a result of their childs illness. Also, reliability tests on the K10
resulted values of the kappa and weighted kappa scores that ranged from 0.42 to
0.74 which indicates that K10 is a moderately reliable instrument.
Upon completing the K10, participants proceed to the Coping Strategies
Questionnaire created by the researcher which gathered data about the coping
strategies that they use as they adapt to the situation of being the parents of
children diagnosed with cancer. The questionnaire consisted of 30 statements or
phrases that will describe their reaction, behavior, or attitude in response to
their childs cancer diagnosis. It is self-administered and may take the
respondents 5-10 minutes to complete. The prefix for all the statement or phrase
in each item is, When my child was diagnosed with cancer I started, and each
item is rated by the participants based on how well each statement or phrase
describes their reaction, behavior, or attitude. Using a five-point Likert scale, the
participants choose from a range of 1-5, where 1 is Strongly Disagree and 5
means Strongly Agree.
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
36
The aim of this questionnaire is to determine which coping strategies that
the sample participants use. The researcher used ten types of coping strategies
as the scales of this questionnaire, with each scale represented by three items.
The researcher chose the ten coping strategies based on the related literature of
this study, as well as on some of the questionnaires that were used in most of the
related studies such as the Social Support Questionnaire (SSQ), The Coping
Health Inventory for Parents (CHIP), and the Ways of Coping Scale and its
adapted version, the Coping Strategy Inventory (CSI). Some of the items in this
questionnaire are also just revised versions of the ones found on the
questionnaires mentioned, while some were created by the researcher himself.
The coping strategies used by the researcher included Communicating with
Medical Staff and Other Parents (items 9, 3, 26), Acquiring Social Support (items
29, 14, 4), Wishful Thinking (11, 17, 1), Seeking Spiritual Support (items 5, 24,
18), Being Optimistic about the Situation (items 10, 28, 15), Using Passive
Appraisal (items 8, 22, 30), Substance Use (items 19, 6, 27), Self-blame (16, 12,
23), Positive Reframing (items 20, 2, 13), and Self-isolation (Items 7, 21, 25).
Some example of the items in the questionnaire are: 1) Hoping a miracle will
happen; 2) Trying to see my childs illness in a different light, to make it seem more
positive; and 3) Talking with the medical staff (nurses, social worker, etc.) about
my childs illness when we visit the medical center. Furthermore, after pretesting
the questionnaire, reliability of the scales of the questionnaire ranged from 0.692
to 0.831, which basically indicates that the instrument was relatively reliable.
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
37
The last instrument used in this study was the in-depth, semi-structured
interview guide for the Key-Informant Interviews, which provided the
qualitative data needed in this research. This interview guide, which took about
20-30 minutes, was used to determine the quality of life of these parents and
their family (through the help of the selected key-informants) as they go through
their situation in life. It consists of 10 open-ended questions about how the
childs cancer diagnosis affected their lives, about the problems and difficulties
that they have experienced, and about how they manage to cope with their
situation. The first and second questions were about their initial reactions when
their child was diagnosed with cancer, and the difficulty of accepting the
diagnosis. The third, fourth, and fifth questions, however, tackled concerns about
how the childs cancer diagnosis changed or impacted their lives as parents, as
well as the different problems and difficulties it brought to them. The fourth
question determines the effects of childs cancer diagnosis on more specific
aspects of the parents lives like their psychological-emotional health,
economical status, social relationships, etc. The sixth, seventh, and eighth
questions, on the other hand, were about the coping behavior that they adapt in
relation to their current situation. The ninth question asked the parents to
describe their current condition in relation to their childs illness, and lastly, the
tenth question was about the positive effect that might have been brought about
by the situation. Furthermore this interview guide was used by the researcher to
strengthen or support, as well as to fill the gaps of the data gathered in the
quantitative part of the study.
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
38
Data Gathering Procedure
The following instruments that were used in this study as mentioned
above have all been administered at the Philippine General Hospital itself. The
administration of tests, as well as the Key-Informant Interviews, was done in
certain length of time so as to achieve the desired number of participants as the
parents of children with cancer come and go to the cancer institute for their
treatment.
The quantitative data was first gathered by providing self-administered
questionnaires to the selected participants. The participants were first asked to
read a letter asking for their consent to participate in the study. This letter also
contained information about the whole process of the study such as the tests that
they have to undergo. If they agree to take part in the study, the participants
were given a pen and a copy of the questionnaire. First, participants complete the
socio-demographic information asked from them; this is basically the first part of
the questionnaire. After that, they proceed to answering the Kessler
Psychological Distress Scale (K10), which makes up the second part of the
questionnaire. Lastly, the participants complete the Coping Strategies
Questionnaire created by the researcher. While the participants were answering
the questionnaires, the researcher leaves the participants alone so as not to
affect or influence their answers. After a few minutes or so, the researcher
returns to the participant to see if he/she has already finished answering the
questionnaire.
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
39
In scoring the K10, a mark or a score of 1 was given to any question
answered with none of the time, a mark of 2 was given to any question answered
with a little of the time, and so on up to 5 for questions answered with all of the
time. The researcher then got the sum of the scores given by the respondents in
all 10 items to get the total score, which may yield a minimum score of 10 and a
maximum score of 50.
Generally, low scores on K10 indicate low levels of psychological distress
and high scores indicate high levels of psychological distress. However, more
specific interpretations of scores were also done using a set of cut-off scores
provided by the instrument. People who got a score under 20 were likely to be
well, those who score 20-24 were likely to have a mild mental disorder, those
who score 25-29 were likely to have a moderate mental disorder, and people
who score over 30 were likely to have a severe mental disorder.
On the other hand, the questionnaire created by the researcher, which
took the participants about 5-10 minutes to complete, was scored by the
researcher by simply getting the sum of the item scores for each scale. High
scores on some certain scale indicate the more frequent use of that specific
coping strategy.
After gathering all the data from the quantitative part of the study, the
researcher then selected the key-informants for the Key-Informant Interviews
from the respondents. The researcher contacted these people and conducted the
interviews on the date and place agreed upon by the researcher and the key-
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
40
informant. Interviews were also taped or recorded for more accurate
transcription.
Ethical Consideration
Prior to participating in the study, the participants were asked to read a
letter asking for their informed consent. No participant was forced to partake in
the study. All necessary information about the study, as well as the questionnaire
that the participants have to complete, was also be discussed by the researcher
to the participant beforehand. Also, as mentioned on the letter, information that
were given out by the participants were handled with great confidentiality and
were only used to achieve the objectives of the study that the researcher hopes
to somehow benefit them in return.
Scope and Limitations
This study focused on the assessment of coping strategies of the parents
of children with cancer that are currently undergoing treatment at the Philippine
General Hospital including how well they have adapted or adjusted
psychologically and emotionally to the situation using these strategies. It covered
and provided information about the importance of the coping strategies in
dealing and coping with this kind of situation. The study, however, was only
limited to the parents of the patient. It did not include other members of the
family. It was also restricted to those parents of children diagnosed with cancer
and are currently undergoing treatment. It did not include those parents of
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
41
children who have already survived cancer. It did not also deal with the effects of
the childs illness on the marital relationship of the parents. Furthermore, the
data of the study were limited only to the information that the respondents from
the selected institution, which is the PGH, have provided based on the
questionnaire and interview, as well as the data and information from the
related literature that were cited and reviewed.
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
42
CHAPTER V Presentation of Results
Socio-Demographic Profile of Respondents/Parents
A total of 83 parents participated in the study. As Table 1 below shows,
the sex distribution of the participants is closely even with 41 fathers (49%) and
42 mothers (50%). This is basically because most of the respondents are married
couples giving an even distribution of mothers and fathers. The age profile of the
parents showed that most of them are middle-aged adults. As presented, the
largest proportion of the respondents is in the 30-39 age category, which
comprises 37% of the respondents. Next to it is the 40-49 age category with 35%
of the respondents. Lastly, parents who belonged to the older age group of 50
and above only consisted of 9%.
Also, as mentioned earlier, majority of the parents who participated are
married couples. As presented below (Table 1), among the 83 parents who
participated, there were a total of 33 married couples, which comprises 80% of
the total respondents. The remaining parents were single, divorced, or widowed.
Overall, there were 33 couples, 5 single fathers, 2 widowed fathers, 1 divorced
father, 5 single mothers, 3 widowed mothers, and 1 divorced mother.
Regarding the parents educational background, as shown on the table,
only 41% of the participants have reached college or the tertiary level of
education, while more than half of the participants (52%) only reached the
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
43
secondary level (high school). The remaining 7%, on the other hand, have
reached only the primary or the elementary level. In addition, none of the
parents who participated was illiterate. Also, a total of 39 parents (47%) are
employed with only one parent (1%) unemployed. However, since majority of
the respondents are married couples, almost all of these employed parents are
fathers being the chief provider for the family. This explains the large number of
housewives in the respondents, which comprises 34% of the total respondents.
Occupations of those employed include government employee, police officer,
teacher, saleslady, driver, laborer, etc. Furthermore, as shown below, more than
half of the respondents (57%) are earning only about P5, 000-P9, 999 every
month. Only 26% of the respondents are earning P10, 000-P14, 999 monthly,
while 17% are earning less than P5, 000 every month. This just shows that most
of the families who go to PGH for the cancer treatment of a child in the family are
not really that well-off.
With regard to the parents religion, as presented below, a total of 86%
were Roman Catholic with the remaining 14% divided into Christian (1%),
Iglesia ni Cristo (6%), Muslim (1%), Ang Dating Daan (3%), Methodist (1%), and
Seventh-Day Adventist (2%). Obviously, large majority of the participants are
Roman Catholic since it is the dominant religion in the country.
Lastly, majority of the parents (37%) have three children, while about
23% have two children. Furthermore, 13% of the parents have only one child
and a total of 17% have five or more children.
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
44
Table 1. Socio-Demographic Profile of Parents (N=83)
Characteristics NO. %
Sex Male (Father) Female (Mother)
41 42
49 51
Age 20-29 Years 30-39 Years 40-49 Years 50 Years
16 31 29 7
19 37 35 9
Marital Status Single Married Divorced Widowed
6 66 5 6
7 80 6 7
Educational Attainment Elementary Level High School Level College Level
6 43 34
7 52 41
Occupational Status Employed Business Housewife Unemployed
39 15 28 1
47 18 34 1
Monthly Family Income < P5,000 P5,000-P9,999 P10,000-P14,999
14 48 21
17 57 26
Religion Roman Catholic Christian Iglesia ni Cristo Muslim Ang Dating Daan Methodist Seventh-Day Adventist
71 1 5 1 2 1 2
86 1 6 1 3 1 2
No. of Children 1 2 3 4 5
11 19 31 8
14
13 23 37 10 17
Socio-Demographic Profile of Children with Cancer
Since there are 33 married couples, 9 single mothers, and 8 single fathers
who participated, a total of 50 children with cancer have been a part of the study.
As presented on the Table 2 below, 62% of these children are males and 38% are
females. Majority of them (40%) are aged 6 years or below, while about 26% are
ARCILLA (2011) | Coping Strategies Used by Both Parents of Children Currently Undergoing Cancer Treatment at the Philippine General Hospital
45
aged 13-18 years. 34%, on the other hand, belonged to the 7-12 age category.
Furthermore, the youngest age among the children is 1 year old, while the oldest
age is 18 years old. Furthermore, as presented, 28% of these children are the
youngest child in the family, and about 34% are the eldest child. However,
majority of these children (38%) is the middle child of the family, meaning that
they were born as the second, third, etc. child in the family.
Table 2 below also shows the duration since when these children were
diagnosed with cancer. As shown below, 42% of these children have been
diagnosed with cancer for just less than a year, while only 20% were diagnosed
with can