Upload
vania-azevedo
View
214
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/7/2019 corpo trabalho copia
1/12
Faculdade de Letras da Universidade do Porto
January 2011
Vnia Azevedo
Reflection on my Observation Process as
a Student Teacher
8/7/2019 corpo trabalho copia
2/12
INDEX
1. INTRODUCTION ---------------------------------------------- pages 1 42. Observation of my mentors lessons ------------------------ pages 4 63. Observation of my peers lessons ---------------------------- pages 6 84. CONCLUSION -------------------------------------------------- pages 8 105. Bibliography ----------------------------------------------------- page 106. Appendices
8/7/2019 corpo trabalho copia
3/12
1. INTRODUCTIONThe relevance of observation tasks
Classrooms [] are complex arenas where many processes co-occur and
overlap. It takes a skilled and trained eye to perceive, understand and
benefit from observing the proceedings of learning teaching. (Wajnryb
1992: 5)
During the first term of my traineeship in Escola Secundria/3 de
Ermesinde one of the good aspects of this process was the observation of
my peers and mentors lessons. I realized that this is a very positive way of
spreading good practice, talking through ideas, discussing new approaches
and above all it is a fantastic way of getting to know ourselves and those
who belong to the group (Ncleo de Estgio). This is because after each
lesson my peers, my mentor and I discuss what went good and what went
not so good during the lesson, we give advice and praise each other for the
effort and good performance.
The fact of observing my mentor and my peers teaching helped me to
broaden my horizons and to see beyond my own lesson plans and the
materials I use in my lessons. There is no doubt that observation plays an
important role when it comes to the improvement of teaching and learning.
I suppose that both the observer and the observed benefit from this
dynamic tool (which is observation) for professional growth. Wajnryb says
that observation is a skill that can be learned and can improve with
8/7/2019 corpo trabalho copia
4/12
practice. (Wajnryb 1992: 1) In fact, this is an aspect that I noticed
throughout the first term. At the beginning its seems its not easy to be an
observer. I didnt know quite well what and how to observe my mentors
and my peers lessons. However, as the time went by I started having a
purpose and an aim while observing a lesson and I also started taking other
elements into account such as interaction patterns, discipline, etc. In order
to observe what I intended, I had some observation tasks that I filled in
during the first term. Each observation task has a specific purpose and this
is good since it helps me to focus on just one aspect and thus it is easier for
me to establish aims and to reflect upon my observation later on. The
observation tasks or grids1 I used during my observation process were
related to the following:
1. Identifying strategies of learners in mixed ability classes;2. Interaction patterns;3. Techniques for maintaining discipline4. Specific learning tasks for students set by the teacher;5. Teachers Meta-language;6. Timing, Pace and Stages;7. Who is doing what?8. R
eflecting on theR
ole of theT
eacher9. Transitions in Events/Phases
1 Each observation sheet I filled in throughout the first term can be seen and analysed in
appendices.
8/7/2019 corpo trabalho copia
5/12
I thought these would be relevant aspects to be observed and I also wanted
to test myself while observing these items such as discipline and the
question of mixed ability classes. The 7th
D, one of my classes, is a very
good example of a mixed ability class. I realized this while I was observing
two different learners (a boy and a girl) and the girl has a weak level while
the boy belongs to a stronger level. In the grid related to this theme, I wrote
down the reasons why this happens and at the end of the lesson I talked to
my mentor about this and she confirmed that actually this is a mixed ability
class and thus in the second term we could work on this, i.e., to produce
different materials and even tests since the levels of these learners are
significantly varied. This is just one example that enable us , student
teachers, to understand that these observation tasks have a relevant role in
our professional growth and they help us to find problems that may exist
and we sometimes dont notice if we dont have some guidelines to follow.
Id also like to state that it is interesting to find that this observation tasks
are part of a gradual process. I learned that while teaching we cannot notice
everything and were not able to find every gap there is inside a classroom.
Therefore, if we, teachers, have the opportunity to sit down and observe a
class while someone else is teaching it is great because we, observers, see
beyond the person who is teaching. However, I learned that the observer
has to be patient and has to do one thing at a time, i.e., we establish an aim
8/7/2019 corpo trabalho copia
6/12
per lesson and in that lesson we only observe that specific aspect. If we
want to quickly look at every gap there is in a classroom then itll be
impossible to reach genuine and concise results.
2. Observation of my mentors lessons
My mentors name is Maria Emlia Gonalves and shes been teaching for
almost thirty years. Shes also the author of many coursebooks including
Get on 7andLog in 10 the coursebooks I use with my learners this school
year.
Before observing my peers lesson, I observed my mentors and this helped
me a lot with the production of my own lesson plans and it also allowed me
to reflect good teaching practice. I felt safe when I observed my mentor
teaching because its like a model to be followed. When I started my
observation process, before filling in those observation tasks, I established
beforehand some questions for self-reflection that helped me not to feel lost
during the first impact as a teacher. The questions were the fo llowing:
1. How does the teacher start the lesson?2. What kind of instructions (oral/written) does the teacher give the
learners?
3. How does the teacher answer the learners questions?4. What is the teachers attitudes towards the learners answers?
8/7/2019 corpo trabalho copia
7/12
5. How many l arners does t e teacher guide indi idually and in whichsituations?
6. How does the teacher focus her attention to different learners (toneof voice, eye contact, gestures)?
7. How does the teacher ensure that everybody takes part in theclassroom actions?
8. How does the teacher end the lesson?I have to state that I didnt write down the answers to these questions. The
notes I took during the observations are integrated in the observation tasks
in the appendices. These were mere questions that worked as guidelines
during the first lessons I observed before I was given those formal
observation tasks to be filled in. After the first observed lessons I used to
reflect upon these questions I established for my own work and I also
described many lessons (from the 7th
and 10th
years) as a kind of diary that
hel ped me a lot during the planning of my first lessons as a teacher. The
lessons I described were my mentors lessons, those that I thoughtit would
work as a scheme and a model to follow like I stated before. Below is the
model of observation I created to help me in September and October while
observing my mentors lessons:
8/7/2019 corpo trabalho copia
8/12
In the appendices it will appear 7th
year, 10th
year and also 9th
year
observation sheets because in September and OctoberI used to observe the
my mentors 9th
year class but laterI decided to keep only the 7th
and 10th
years.
To conclude this section I can say that the two main factors I considered
important during the observation of my mentors lessons in the first term
were the good relationship there is between us and her availability to
answer my questions and to help me reflecting after each lesson. In my
point of view, the observation process can only be concluded when there is
a discussion about what I observed after the lessons (Post -observation
Discussion) and this happened most of the time between my mentor and I.
3. Observation of my peers lessonsAna and Joo are my peers and good friends that are with me in this
process ofbecoming a teacher. Weve always worked as a group since the
1st
year in the faculty and we feel lucky to be together as a group this year
(the year we all three expected to reach) and working in the same school.
One of the most important aspects in our traineeship is the peers and the
people with who we work every day. Since we are very good friends, Joo,
Ana and I have absolutely any problems regarding to comments related to
8/7/2019 corpo trabalho copia
9/12
each others lessons, observations and even evaluation of each others
performance. We feel completely comfortable to mention things that went
good but also not so good during the lessons.
I have to say that I feel proud and also nervous when I observe my peers
lessons. Since we are a team we have to help each other and I felt as if it
was myself that was teaching at that particular moment. During my peers
lessons I take notes and I exchange ideas with the peer next to me. We
comment on our colleagues performance and sometimes we give
suggestions. These observations are all registered so that we can talk about
them after the lesson with our peer who was teaching and our mentor. To
observe my mentors lessons is very important to me because it he lps me to
know what is correct and what is wrong to do. However, I prefer observing
my peers lessons because its like I am watching myself teaching. Of
course were unique and each person has a different view and way of
teaching but we have one big thing in common: its our first experience as
teachers and all we know is what we hear or read. So it is rewarding to see
how our peers efforts are reflected in mine and how they try to give their
best.
The fact of observing my peers in the first term made me more aware and
analytical about their ways of teaching. I saw new ideas and approaches
that I can perfectly adapt and incorporate in my teaching practice. Other
8/7/2019 corpo trabalho copia
10/12
aspects that I got from this experience as my peers observer were that I
have to be careful when I analyse the lesson after the observation (Post-
observation Phase). To give helpful and useful feedback to our peers, we,
observers, need to be sensitive to their aims; we also need to be realistic
and specific because when we tend to generalise we may not be helping our
peers to understand the point; we have to know how to balance positive and
negative feedback and we should know how to comment on our peers
work; above all we cant judge them.
4. CONCLUSION
At the beginning, in September of 2010, I wanted to observe every little
thing that happens inside a classroom. However,I
could conclude that with
time this kind of observation becomes less frequent and I concentrate on
some specific areas where I thinkI should work on later as a teacher. F rom
the observation process I could also find that it might be better to keep the
principle of non-involvement in our peers lessons, even when something
doesnt go so well. This can be an embarrassing situation for peers but it
can also change the course of the lesson. I learned that being an observer
within a group of peers and a mentor, in my case, is a very positive aspect
since we all work together in a supportive environment in order to improve
8/7/2019 corpo trabalho copia
11/12
teaching and also learning skills. Watching/ observing my mentors and my
peers lessons also fostered creative professional growth; I learned a lot
from their own experiences and findings while teaching, their methods and
experimentations.
As an observer, I constantly experienced varied styles of teaching, diff erent
ways of organizing a classroom and most importantly I get to see how my
peers of different personalities and styles teach a certain content and
sometimes the same content I taught but in very different ways.
Many teachers claim about this new law that was implemented in
Portuguese schools which has to do with observed lessons by peers. Those
teachers allege the fact ofbeing teachers for twenty or thirty years and thus
they dont need to be observed because they are experts and they already
know exactly what to do. I think that observation has nothing to do with
being an expert or not or having enough experience that observation is not
an important procedure: That is for student teachers, they normally say.
They have to take into account that throughout their teaching career
teachers are constantly being observed even if it is by their learners. From
this process I learned that being observed is a way of changing ideas,
learning new approaches and being professional. Constructive criticism is
one of the good aspects of observation. When we listen to others criticizing
8/7/2019 corpo trabalho copia
12/12
our work we learn to accept those ideas and become better professionals. I
can conclude by saying that to me observation is the same as awareness.
Bibliography
Wajnryb, Ruth (1992) Classroom Observation Tasks. A resource book for language teachers
and trainers. CUP, United Kingdom.