Upload
rakib-hossain
View
9
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Countering Terrorism in Bd
Citation preview
July 2007
Countering Terrorism in Bangladesh
A Strategy Paper
Research Team
Mr. Farooq Sobhan Ambassador M. Shafiullah Mr. Shahab Enam Khan
Research Assistants
Towheedul Islam Zohra Akhter Imran Kabir
COUNTER TERRORISM CORE GROUP
Chairman
Former Foreign Secretary and
President, Bangldesh Enterprise Institute
Member
Former GOC, Chittagong who oversaw insurgency in
Chittagong Hill Tracts (CHT)
Former IGP, Secretary and Columnist
Research Director, Bangladesh Institute of International
and Strategic Studies (BIISS)
Editor, Defence and Strategic Affairs
The Daily Star
Director, DGFI
Specialist on religious education in Bangladesh and
Registrar, University of Asia Pacific, Bangladesh
Specialist on Regional Security and
Assistant Professor in International Relations
Jahangirnagar University
Senior Research Fellow and
Project Coordinator for
Bangladesh Enterprise Institute
Mr. Farooq Sobhan
Major General (Rtd.) Syed Muhammad Ibrahim
Mr. Muhammad Nurul Huda
Dr. Abdur Rob Khan
Brigadier General (Rtd.) Shahedul Anam Khan
Brigadier General A.T.M Amin
Air Commodore (Retd.) Ishfaq Ilahi Choudhury
Mr. Shahab Enam Khan
Ambassador M. Shafiullah
Major General (Rtd) Ghulam Quader
Brigadier General (Rtd.) Sakhawat Husain
Prof. Imtiaz Ahmed
Ms. Neila Husain Chowdhury
Executive Director
Center for Strategic and Peace Studies
Served in CHT, an insurgency-prone area and
Member, the Election Commission
Department of International Relations
University of Dhaka and Author of books on
Counter-terrorism
Counter-Terrorism Bureau,
Small Arms Specialist
Research Fellow, Bangladesh Institute of International
and Strategic Studies (BIISS)
and
Counter Terrorism Bureau
MEASURES FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE STRATEGY
a) Preventing terrorism by blocking the process ofRadicalization of Individuals and groups
b) Pursue Terrorists, Sponsors of Terrorism, andProviders of Sanctuary to the Terrorists
c) Protecting the Public, Key National Infrastructures,and National Interests
d) Preparing for the Consequences and Ensuring anIntegrated Incident Management Capability
03
10
CONTENTS
THE NATURE OF THE THREAT
INTRODUCTION01
02
RESPONDING TO TERRORISM: THE STRATEGY03
LESSONS FROM THE PAST: EXISTING PROBLEMS INIMPLEMENTING A COUNTER TERRORISM STRATEGYIN BANGLADESH
Terrorism:
the unlawful use of force or violence against persons or property to threaten or compel a government, the civilian
population, or any segment thereof, in furtherance of political and social objectives.
The nature of risks and vulnerabilities posed by terrorism in Bangladesh has become a serious threat to national
security today. In the last two decades militant groups have manifested their presence by violent acts of terrorism in
Bangladesh. Religious assassinations, political violence and bombings at public places of festivities and entertainment
and worship have stunned the country. Terrorism has become an threat to life, the economy and political and
religious pluralism in Bangladesh. For the religious terrorist groups terrorism has become a means of establishing
Islamic order in the society. For the extremist political groups terrorism is a weapon to gain political control of the
polity; and for the mainstream political parties terrorism has become a tool for political competition either to gain or to
retain political power.
In Bangladesh terrorists continue to adapt to defeat counter-measures and exploit opportunities and weaknesses in the
law enforcement agencies and political society. Countrywide terrorist bomb attacks in August 2005, including the
simultaneous detonation of over 500 bombs in multiple regions by JMB (Jama'atul Mujahideen Bangladesh)
demonstrated an ability to attack on a massive scale. It demonstrated that terrorists operating in this country are
developing new methods of attack and improving the efficiency of existing ones, increasing the pressure on
Bangladesh's counter-terrorist agencies. As a result the agencies are in a constant fight to stay one step ahead of the
terrorists. It can be concluded that the critical sectors in Bangladesh namely energy (power, and oil and natural gas),
transportation (airways, railways, roads, shipping, and space), law enforcement (defense, police intelligence, and the
judiciary), ICT (networks and telecom), the financial sector (banking, trade and commerce, financial instruments and
insurance) and public health (medical care, water, and sanitation) are becoming vulnerable to terrorist
activities.
In this strategy, a new security environment is represented which shapes both the language of threat and the
architecture of terrorism in Bangladesh. To address the uncertainties and probabilities, to assess the relative gravity of
impact of terrorist events, and to formulate a correct, feasible and efficient public policy response to terrorism, this
strategy paper has involved all the stakeholders existing in Bangladesh - public, private, and civil society. Delivery of
security depends upon partnerships with the state apparatuses and emergency services, local authorities and
administrations, as well as with the private sector and NGOs. The strategy emphasizes the need for constructive and
regular partnerships between these sectors, led by the government, and citizens and communities. Public awareness of
the threat, understanding of the measures needed to combat it, and active support and cooperation by the public are
critical to the accomplishment of this strategy. Bangladesh should be at the very forefront of efforts to promote both
regional and international cooperation to combat terrorism. Bangladesh must be open and transparent in terms of
facing criticism from both the local and international press. The cumulative effect of terrorism, if left unchecked, will
remain as detrimental as ever to the survival of Bangladesh as a democracy. Therefore, terrorism cannot be fully
defeated without . As long as terrorism is encouraged and allowed to thrive - either pro-actively or
through silence - combating terrorism will remain a futile exercise.
The purpose of this document is to examine the nature of the terrorist threat in Bangladesh and to present a
comprehensive framework for future action. The document examines areas where the effort could be stepped-up and
suggests practical ways of improving the response. The document breaks the response down into four areas:
terrorism, Terrorists and their sponsors, the public and for the consequences
of a terrorist strike. For ease of use an annex is included with the main recommendations depicted in tabular form.
In designing this document account has been taken of strategies in use in other countries and, where there is
commonality and evidence that the measures adopted in other countries have been successful, similar measures have
been recommended for Bangladesh. High level ownership of the strategy is essential if implementation is to be
successful. We that the Chief Adviser/Prime Minister's Office co-ordinates implementation.
increasing
increasingly
national consensus
Preventing Pursuing Protecting Preparing
recommend
INTRODUCTION
01 Countering Terrorism in Bangladesh: A Strategy PaperI
Countering Terrorism in Bangladesh: A Strategy Paper 02I
There will be no quick or easy end to the threat that is posed by terrorism. Combating terrorism andsecuring Bangladesh from future attacks have, therefore, become . Terrorism in Bangladeshhas five major characteristics:
i. it is premeditated and aims to create a climate of extreme fear or terror;
ii. it is directed at a wider audience or target than the immediate victims of the violence;
iii. it inherently involves attacks on random and symbolic targets, including civilians;
iv. the acts of violence committed are seen by the society (in which they occur) as extra-normal, in the
literal sense that they breach the social norms, thus causing a sense of outrage;
v. terrorism is generally used to try to influence political behavior in some way: for example to force
opponents to provoke an over-reaction, to serve as a catalyst for a more general conflict or to
publicize a political or religious cause; to vent deep hatred and quench the thirst for revenge, and to
help undermine governments and institutions designated as enemies by the terrorists.
The principal current terrorist threat is from radicalized individuals/groups who are
using a distorted version of Islam to justify violence. This radicalization is fed by the global Islamist
agenda.
In Bangladesh, the secondary level threat stems largely from the unhealthy
competition to retain power at any cost. In the competition for political support, the costs and
repercussions of terrorism have often been ignored by the mainstream parties.
Other terrorist threats transpire from acts of terror directed specifically against the
government and state institutions and officials. Acts of terror of this kind have previously been carried out
by ultra-left or ultra-right organizations. While religious extremists have also from time to time attacked
government officials and institutions, their motive for doing so has always been to further their religious
and political objectives, whereas in the case of the ultra-left or right parties, the objective has been to
challenge the local authorities and the private sector. Finally, ethnic terrorism in Bangladesh is rooted in
the quest of indigenous minorities to protect their lands from encroachment and to safeguard their own
ethnic identity. However, after the signing of the Chittagong Hill Tracts Peace Accord in 1997 between the
then government and PCJSS, the magnitude of ethnic terrorism has been substantially reduced.
top priorities
Primary level threat:
Secondary level threat:
Other threats:
THE NATURE OF THE THREAT
So far, the government of Bangladesh has not adopted a specific, concrete and well-coordinated strategy
to combat terrorism. Terrorism is seen primarily as a security issue that requires a military response.
Therefore, the military option has generally been the preferred mode of response by Bangladesh to deal
with terrorism. Political accommodation has been used as another method to deal with terrorism. The aim
has been to deal with the issue politically through negotiations. This approach has usually followed the use
of military options and has helped contain ethnic terrorism in Bangladesh.
In compliance with the UN Global Counter Terrorism Strategy, the strategy suggested in this paper is
directed towards continuous action against terrorism, the cumulative effect of which will initially disrupt,
over time degrade, and ultimately destroy the growth of terrorism and terrorist organizations in
Bangladesh by using all the tools of statecraft. The strategy is divided into four principal strands:
, and
The government of Bangladesh, at various times has either directly or indirectly relied on the use of
military forces to combat terrorism. Although military involvement has been perceived to have had a
positive impact in the short-term, many of the law and order problems re-surfaced almost immediately
after the military operations had ended. The question that needs to be answered in this backdrop is how
to collectively combine domestic energies to deal with the growing problem of terrorism. From this
strategy it has become clear that the use of military force alone will not suffice, it can be at best an
enabling instrument.
Another constraint when implementing a counter terrorism strategy in Bangladesh stems from an
unwillingness to realize the importance of the growing phenomenon of terrorism. This is a serious
impediment because it points to the heart of the debate in Bangladesh about whose responsibility it is to
counter terrorism, something that shows a reluctance to understand that the problem is too big to be the
sole responsibility of any one agency, be it the police or the military or any other agency. However, the
instigation of the preparation against terrorism must be decreed by the government as combating
terrorism is always, at the end of the day, a political decision. Active operations are and should be the
result of a political decision-making process.
It has also been witnessed in the past that the government has pursued lukewarm policies toward
combating terrorism which in turn only encouraged terrorism both in political and religious forms. It has
now become a matter of critical importance that Bangladesh should adopt a zero-tolerance policy towards
terrorist activities within its territory. In this regard, all instruments at the governments' disposal i.e.
diplomatic, economic and informational, law enforcing, military, financial and intelligence related, should
be effectively and efficiently employed.
RESPONDING TO TERRORISM:
THE STRATEGY
PREVENT, PURSUE, PROTECT PREPARE.
03 Countering Terrorism in Bangladesh: A Strategy PaperI
LESSONS FROM THE PAST:EXISTING PROBLEMS IN IMPLEMENTING A COUNTERTERRORISM STRATEGY IN BANGLADESH
a) Preventing terrorism by blocking the process of radicalization of individuals and groups
The first principle to make an effective counter terrorism strategy requires PREVENTING the elements that
facilitate the process of radicalization of individuals or groups in Bangladesh. A Counter-terrorism strategy
to prevent radicalization must include a addressing conditions conducive to
exploitation by terrorists to create or increase their power base. To prevent radicalization vis--vis
terrorism, the following strategies need to be undertaken:
Radicalization of individuals or groups needs to be tackled by addressing structural problems in
national, regional and international levels that may contribute to radicalization. This includes the
issues of: inequality, discrimination, youth unemployment, modernization of all streams of education,
and reform in democratic and electoral institutions to bring back confidence to the secular and
progressive political system.
The leaders of the terrorist groups generally use religiously indoctrinated fanatics who seek an early
entry into Paradise, and/or who seek large financial side payments to their families, as compensation
for engaging in acts of self-destruction for terrorism. Deterring leaders who facilitate terrorism and
encourage others to become terrorists is essential.
Essential tools in preventing radicalization in Bangladesh are a public-private partnership and political
consensus.
To prevent radicalization it is important to establish the causes and to address them. Radicalization
often stems from grievances, a sense of injustice, alienation, exclusion or lack of opportunity.
To improve coordination between the intelligence and law enforcement agencies and then to respond
to terrorism effectively, efficiently and rapidly, Bangladesh has to adopt a national counter-terrorism
strategy and a detailed action plan to combat radicalisation and recruitment.
Protecting/promoting democratic governance and its associated rule of law. A comprehensive political
system upholding democratic governance at both national and local levels should be pursed /
promoted as the lack of such a government breeds terrorism. Rule of law is a for curbing
terrorism, although there is a tendency to resort to extra-ordinary, extra-legal and extra-judicial
measures to deal with terrorism.
Madrassa education has long been a subject for profound blame, to be a breeding ground for terrorism
in Bangladesh. However, recent trends in terrorism in Bangladesh reject any significant correlation
between Madrassa education and its linkages with terrorism. Only 19% of those who were arrested for
terrorism were drawn from Madrassas. Even then, that percentage figure needs to be taken into
consideration and therefore, along with the mainstream curriculum, the Madrassa curriculum should
be revised and modernized.
The Madrassa graduates (both Q'awmi and Aliya) are likely to have very limited employment
opportunities because they lack the quality of general education of their peers who are graduates of
public/private schools. This leaves them vulnerable to radicalization. There is a greater need to
facilitate employment opportunities for the Madrassa graduates.
The government should ensure better education in the Bengali/ English oriented educational
institutions and the Madrassas, and promote tolerance, through the dialogues, human rights
education, internationally shared values, mutual understanding, and school textbooks. With the overall
long-term component
sine quo non
Countering Terrorism in Bangladesh: A Strategy Paper 04I
PREVENT
objective of upgrading the standard of primary and secondary education and imparting 'life' skills,
education should be relevant and inclusive; Madrassa education in the country should be brought at
par with mainstream education curricula.
A great asset in Bangladesh's fight against terrorism is that . But
this aversion needs to be converted into active resistance through awareness campaigns and
enlightened religious education in public places including worship places.
Media should be motivated to play a constructive role in the awareness campaign. While the society
should not compromise on the principle of free press/media, the media, in turn, should not
compromise on objective reporting avoiding opinionated reports.
Islamic organizations, Imams, religious organizations or institutions should be brought into the
terrorism discourse in Bangladesh. They should be trained and designated as important actors in
combating ideological fanaticism and restraining the process of radicalization in Bangladesh.
people are strongly against terrorism
05 Countering Terrorism in Bangladesh: A Strategy PaperI
PURSUE
b) Pursue Terrorists, Sponsors of Terrorism, and Providers of Sanctuary to the Terrorists:
The strategy's second strand stresses the need to identify terrorists and deny them sponsorship. Know
your enemy is one of the most accepted maxims in warfare. Unfortunately, knowledge of the inner
workings of most of the terrorists or terrorist organizations operating in Bangladesh is inadequate and
incomplete. This needs to be addressed.
Once identified terrorists need to be pursued within Bangladesh and across borders to deny sponsorship,
support and sanctuary that enable them to exist, gain strength, train, plan, and execute their attacks. This
will disrupt support networks, cutting off funding and access to attack materials, eventually bringing
terrorists to justice. The strategy to deny sponsorship, support, and sanctuary is three-fold:
and
The following measures need to be implemented under the Pursue strand of the strategy:
The intelligence and law enforcement agencies need
, map their command and control and support infrastructure, and
then ensure the broad, but appropriate, distribution of the intelligence to all the state agencies as well
as to our regional neighbors.
Coordinate activities of the government agencies and provide assessments regarding terrorist threats,
and multi-stakeholder based strategic decisions. These can be done by establishing a Cabinet
Committee on national security, a National Security Council (NSC), and a joint intelligence unit.
Good coordination between the intelligence and enforcement agencies is an essential quality to attain,
in order to carry out an effective and comprehensive assault against existing or potential terrorist
threats to Bangladesh. This could be done by establishing a Central Inter-agency Counter Terrorism
Coordination Cell to coordinate and monitor the activities of the Counter-terrorism cells in all of the
intelligence and law enforcement agencies.
Reforming
legislation, restructuring and modernizing the infrastructure, seeking regional and international
Cooperation.
to continue aggressive efforts to identify
terrorists and their organizations
Countering Terrorism in Bangladesh: A Strategy Paper 06I
The clear and present trans-national profile of domestic and international terrorism demands greater
international cooperation over a spectrum of activities, including suppressing and freezing terrorist
financing, prohibiting Bangladeshi nationals in home and abroad from financially supporting terrorists,
denying safe haven, and taking steps to prevent the movement of cross-border terrorists.
Taking action to thwart terrorist attacks and to bring terrorists to justice
through prosecution is essential. This includes strengthening the legal framework against terrorism,
such as enacting the draft anti-terrorism Act, updating the anti money laundering Act, strengthening
the financial intelligence unit, augmenting the capacity of Bangladesh Bank, and ensuring NGO
accountability.
Restructuring and modernizing the anti-terrorism
agencies should be seen as a continuously evolving process. This involves restructuring of
organizational jurisdiction, the improvement of efficiency of human resources, technical capacities and
the modernization of intelligence gathering techniques and gadgets. The task requires adequate funds
from the state.
It is necessary to prioritize efforts based on the immediate
and predicted future terrorist threats, and Bangladesh's national interests. The task depends on the
ability of other South Asian states to fulfill their obligations to combat terrorism both inside and
outside their borders. Regional and international cooperation, therefore, should be high on the agenda
in order to strengthen Bangladesh's intelligence effort and cross-border terrorism.
A comprehensive Anti-Money Laundering regime should be established as money laundering involves a
variety of modes and agencies, related to the broader issue of corruption. The existing Money
Laundering Prevention Act, 2002 needs to be revised with focus on defining 'predicate offence',
terrorist related money laundering offence and what reporting entities/institutions should be covered.
There is a need to strengthen the Financial Intelligence Unit in Bangladesh Bank to monitor money
laundering activities in the country. AML regime should cover all of the possible modes of money
laundering like . However, surveillance and compliance requirement should not
discourage legitimate banking transactions including savings, business and remittance.
Capacity of Bangladesh Bank needs to be strengthened. Therefore, investigative capacity and
jurisdiction of Bangladesh Bank should be widened.
There is a vacuum regarding inter-agency cooperation for pursuing anti-money laundering activities.
Inter-agency collaborative mechanisms among existing institutions like ACC, AG office, BB and law
enforcing agencies should be initiated as early as possible.
Introduce a NGO accountability system regarding NGO's financial disclosure and auditing systems.
Sign extradition treaties with the neighbouring countries to curtail cross-border movements of the
terrorists' and deny them shelters internationally. In this regard, regional and international measures
aimed at in the fight against terrorism should be initiated.
Technical capacity on, surveillance, investigation, apprehension, interview, protection, forensic,
interception, cyber crime and terrorism; explosives; Interview and Appraisal; Legal Handling;
Rendition and Covert Operations; Agent Running and Agent Recruitment, should be improved in
cooperation with international agencies and experts.
Reforming legislation:
Restructuring and modernizing the infrastructure:
Regional and international Cooperation:
Hundi/ Hawala
strengthening information exchange
PROTECT
07 Countering Terrorism in Bangladesh: A Strategy PaperI
c) Protecting the Public, Key National Infrastructure, and National Interests
Protection of human lives and properties, reduction of vulnerabilities to national infrastructures and key
installations, and above all, the preservation of national interests from domestic and external threats are
critical factors in combating terrorism in Bangladesh. The Third strand of this strategy is, therefore, aimed
to address the vulnerability of Bangladesh's interests. This covers a range of issues including:
The physical protection of Bangladesh, its , as well as the protection
of its democratic principles is a critical issue in Bangladesh's counter-terrorism efforts. In a world
which is becoming increasingly interconnected and technologically inter-linked Bangladesh must be
prepared to defend its interests. Through continuous law enforcement and strategic pursuit of terrorist
organizations, and by expanding physical protection and awareness, the vulnerability of Bangladesh's
people, critical infrastructure, and other interests can be reduced.
A key component of any nation's sovereignty is Like its immediate neighbors,
Bangladesh bears responsibility of the people and goods transiting its borders. While neighboring
states are expected to fulfill their similar obligations, Bangladesh nevertheless should be prepared to
interdict terrorist ground, air, maritime, and cyber traffic by positioning forces and assets to deny
terrorists' access to new recruits, financing, equipment, arms, and information. Stringent border
management system and security techniques should be adopted by strengthening the capacity of
BDR, introducing inclusive border management by including local bodies, improving identity
management and establishing cross-border cooperation.
The intelligence and law enforcement agencies in conjunction with the government service agencies
and private sector service/utility providers need to conduct regular reviews and assessments of
threats to utility services, transport and industrial infrastructures, installations, natural resources and
public health, and to develop plans that address the security of these areas.
To reduce the possibility of attacks in highly populated areas and on critical infrastructures, it is
necessary to adopt multi-faceted plans to maximize security. This could be done by establishing a
Joint-Surveillance Team comprised of personnel from different law enforcement agencies.
Modernization of the intelligence and law enforcement agencies is essential in terms of human
resources, equipment and technical competence. Institutional measures and adequate funding should
be guaranteed for these agencies.
Strengthen the capacity of BDR and the Coast Guard through advanced training, providing modern
and sophisticated communication system, logistics capacity and by improving their surveillance
capacity.
Stringent border management system and security techniques should be adopted which make use of
the knowledge of local bodies and thereby improves identity management.
Cross-border cooperation on an inter-state level with India and Myanmar should be instigated
. This can be done by signing MoUs and extradition treaties with these countries.
Measures to improve the protection of borders should also include modernization of immigration
procedures and of the Visa Information System. There is a need for joint exercises to prevent the
smuggling of radiological or hazardous materials which could be used to fabricate arms and weapons.
Measures to improve the security of transport, including the adoption of a Port Security Directive, and
the initiative to improve security at airports are essential.
populace, property, and interests
control of its borders.
without
further delay
Countering Terrorism in Bangladesh: A Strategy Paper 08I
d) Preparing for the Consequences and Ensuring an Integrated Incident Management Capability
low:
medium: high: extreme:
In the end, the mitigation of catastrophic terrorism is dependent upon the people preparing themselves
for the impact of terrorism. The fourth and final strand of this strategy is concerned with guaranteeing
that Bangladesh is as ready as possible for the consequences of a terrorist attack. It requires solid
planning, preparation and immediate response to the acts of terrorism.
It is aimed at preparing citizens and helping them to mitigate against the impacts of terrorism in the spirit
of solidarity. This seeks to co-ordinate an effective response to terrorist attacks and attend to the needs of
victims, and manage and minimise the consequences of such attacks, by improving capabilities to deal
with the aftermath.
Principle factors in this strand are as follows:
An effective, integrated response to terrorism requires incident management planning, enhanced
interoperability, and coordination, based on and supported by rapid and effective decision-making. A
committee or group empowered to take rapid action should be formed to coordinate the response.
Given the vast range of potential terrorist attack scenarios, each orchestrating a wide range of
potential consequences, it is neither practical nor prudent to plan for every scenario. Instead, planning
seeks to produce generic plans of action that are flexible enough to cater to any terrorist situation.
A national counter-terrorism alert level system can be developed to guide national preparation and
planning and to dictate levels of precaution and vigilance to minimize the risk from and occurrence of
a terrorist incident. Such a system will also prevent the public from adopting wrong measures during
terrorist situations. A Four-tier alert system can be prescribed: terrorist attack is not expected,
terrorist attack could occur, terrorist attack is likely, terrorist attack is
imminent or has occurred.
Information on any precautionary activities should be brought into public attention. Information
dissemination and protection measures should be transmitted in a clear, comprehensible and precise
manner to ensure that public and media inquiries are catered for with adequacy.
To ensure a rapid response to crisis, Bangladesh may coordinate with and seek assistance of,
international and regional agencies and partners to develop plans for alerting, containing and, if
necessary, repelling an attack in progress while ensuring adequate resources are available to mitigate
PREPARE
There is also a need to develop a Strategy to curb the proliferation of Small Arms, Light Weapons and
Explosives by improving legal and administrative measures, stockpile management, establishing
regional and extra-regional cooperation and ensuring compliance by submitting the required national
report under the UN Program of Action to Prevent, Combat and Eradicate the Illicit Trade in Small
Arms and Light Weapons in All Its Aspects.'
A monitoring regime to control the manufacturing of substances used in the production of small arms
and explosives should be established with priority.
Security-related research and development needs to be encouraged by the government and private
sector to improve the protection of 'soft' and 'hard' targets against terrorism.
'
09 Countering Terrorism in Bangladesh: A Strategy PaperI
the damage. At the outset of a crisis, an interagency team capable of attending the affected area is
essential.
All appropriate agencies need to review and if necessary, amend their incident management
procedures for terrorist incidents involving the critical infrastructure and the national security interests
of Bangladesh. This requires continually evaluating and testing preparation measures to improve
response to incidents and learning lessons from incidents that have already taken place in Bangladesh
or in other countries.
Crisis management following any terrorist incident needs to be emphasized. Bangladesh has a good
track record for disaster management caused by natural calamities. Bangladesh needs a similar
management capacity to attend crises caused by terrorist incidents like bombings and other terrorism-
related violence. The establishment of a central coordinating body for crisis management, as well as
the enhancement of capacity of intelligence and security agencies is urgent. Information and analysis,
training capacity, logistics and equipment can be provided to these agencies.
Military assets and capabilities need to be identified which could support coordinated disaster response
efforts. The assets include strategic transport (air/sea), tactical transport (helicopters), medical units,
field hospitals and logistics.
Multinational exercises to test the readiness for crisis management should be held each year. Lessons
learned should be analyzed and adopted to improve crisis management.
A Financial Instrument for Community Action in the field of civil protection needs to be created. This
will enable the government to support and enhance the prevention, preparedness and response to
man-made and natural disasters both inside and outside the country.
Pilot projects are required to help victims of terrorism and their families. Additional funds for support
to victims need to be facilitated.
At the regional level, a Counter-Terrorism Coordinator can be appointed to establish an
. Operating procedures and an instruction
manual for crisis coordination arrangements can be published and should be available for mass public
dissemination.
Emergency
and Crisis Coordination Arrangements Organization
Countering Terrorism in Bangladesh: A Strategy Paper 10I
Counte
ring
Terr
orism
inBangla
desh
Tim
efr
am
e:
0-2
4m
onth
sI
MEASU
RES
REQ
UIR
ED
FO
RTH
EIM
PLEM
EN
TATIO
NO
FTH
ESTRATEG
Y
Str
ate
gy
of
In
terven
tio
n
Key
perfo
rm
an
ce
ind
icato
r
Key
au
tho
rit
ies/
ag
en
cie
sTim
eli
ne
for
imp
lem
en
tati
on
Mean
so
fV
erif
icati
on
Hyp
oth
esis
Rem
arks
Dem
ocra
tic
sett
ing
Non-d
em
ocra
tic
sett
ing
Toim
pro
ve
coord
ination
betw
een
the
inte
llig
ence
and
law
enfo
rcem
ent
agencie
sand
tore
spond
tote
rrorism
eff
ectively
,eff
icie
ntly
and
rapid
ly
Pro
tecting
dem
ocra
tic
govern
ance
and
rule
of
law
24
month
s(p
arlia
menta
ry)
12
month
s(C
are
taker
govern
ment)
National
Counte
r-te
rrorism
Str
ate
gy
Paper
by
the
govern
ment
Public
aw
are
ness
and
political
consensus
on
the
issues
regard
ing
terr
orism
Lack
of
good
govern
ance
syste
mhelp
sth
egro
wth
of
terr
orism
.
Continuous
pro
cess
Adoption
of
National
Counte
r-te
rrorism
Str
ate
gy
Tru
st
inth
epolitical
syste
m
Cabin
et
Parlia
ment
The
Council
of
Advis
ers
Various
agencie
sin
clu
din
gACC,
Welfare
,Religio
n,
Ele
ction
Com
mis
sio
n,
Sport
sand
Youth
Requires
national
consensus
Willingness
of
the
political
part
ies
An
inclu
siv
epolitical
syste
mand
dem
ocra
tic
govern
ance
at
national
and
local
levels
Prevent
11 Countering Terrorism in Bangladesh: A Strategy PaperIS
trate
gy
of
In
terven
tio
n
Key
perfo
rm
an
ce
ind
icato
r
Key
au
tho
rit
ies/
ag
en
cie
sTim
eli
ne
for
imp
lem
en
tati
on
Mean
so
fV
erif
icati
on
Hyp
oth
esis
Dem
ocra
tic
sett
ing
Non-d
em
ocra
tic
sett
ing
M
adra
ssa
and
main
str
eam
curr
iculu
ms
should
be
revis
ed
and
modern
ized
Com
bating
ideolo
gic
al
fanaticis
mand
restr
ain
ing
the
pro
cess
of
radic
alization
Monitoring
and
surv
eilla
nce
of
Q'a
wm
iM
adra
ssas
Uniform
education
str
ate
gy
by
the
govern
ment
Media
cam
paig
ns,
Tra
inin
gof
Imam
sand
pers
onnel
involv
ed
with
religio
us
org
aniz
ations
and
institu
tions
Monitoring
com
mitte
eon
Q'a
wm
iM
adra
ssas
1.
This
will
facilitate
em
plo
ym
ent
opport
unitie
sfo
rth
eM
adra
ssa
gra
duate
s
2.
Reduce
the
feeling
of
madra
ssa
stu
dents
that
they
are
infe
rior
toth
eir
peers
inpublic
school
Genera
lpublic
are
again
st
terr
orism
There
isa
lack
of
govern
ment
surv
eilla
nce
or
monitoring
of
Q'a
wm
im
adra
ssas
Continuous
pro
cess
6m
onth
s
Adoption
of
auniform
education
curr
iculu
min
prim
ary
,secondary
and
inte
rmedia
tele
vels
Active
resis
tance
thro
ugh
aw
are
ness
cam
paig
ns
and
enlighte
ned
religio
us
education
Adoption
of
aguid
eline
for
the
Q'a
wm
iM
adra
ssa
Min
istr
yof
Education
and
rele
vant
agencie
sN
GO
sCiv
ilsocie
ty
M
inis
try
of
Education
and
rele
vant
agencie
s,
Civ
ilSocie
ty,
Isla
mic
org
aniz
ations
12
month
s
Media
,Is
lam
icorg
aniz
ations,
Imam
s,
religio
us
org
aniz
ations
or
institu
tions
Prevent
Rem
arks
Should
not
com
pro
mis
eon
the
princip
leof
free
pre
ss/m
edia
Curr
iculu
mof
the
Q'a
wm
im
adra
ssas
are
extr
em
ely
narr
ow
and
conserv
ative
Pro
mote
bett
er
education
inth
em
ediu
ms
of
Bengali,
English
and
Madra
ssas,
and
pro
mote
tole
rance,
thro
ugh
dia
logues,
hum
an
rights
education,
inte
rnationally
share
dvalu
es,
mutu
al
unders
tandin
g,
and
school
textb
ooks
Countering Terrorism in Bangladesh: A Strategy Paper 12I
Str
ate
gy
of
In
terven
tio
n
Key
perfo
rm
an
ce
ind
icato
r
Key
au
tho
rit
ies/
ag
en
cie
sTim
eli
ne
for
imp
lem
en
tati
on
Mean
so
fV
erif
icati
on
Hyp
oth
esis
Rem
arks
Dem
ocra
tic
sett
ing
Non-d
em
ocra
tic
sett
ing
Restr
uctu
re,
reorg
aniz
eand
refo
cus
the
org
anogra
m,
jurisdic
tion
and
opera
tional
capacity
Esta
blish
National
Security
Council
Restr
uctu
re,
reorg
aniz
ed
and
refo
cused
Bangla
desh
Police
Functional
National
Security
Council
Centr
ally
Coord
inate
dCounte
r-te
rrorism
Cell
Under
active
consid
era
tion
of
the
curr
ent
govern
ment
There
isa
lack
of
inte
llig
ence
capacity
Str
esses
the
purs
uit
and
identification
of
terr
orists
,denyin
gte
rrorists
the
sponsors
hip
,support
and
sanctu
ary
that
enable
them
toexis
t,gain
str
ength
,tr
ain
,pla
n,
and
execute
their
att
acks
Should
be
repre
sente
dby
wid
er
segm
ents
of
the
socie
tyw
hic
hin
clu
des
govern
ment,
arm
ed
forc
es,
private
secto
r,civ
ilsocie
ty,
academ
ia,
media
and
religio
us
institu
tions
Pre
vention
of
terr
orism
requires
eff
ective
coord
ination
at
each
level
of
the
Sta
te
Concern
ed
auth
orities
with
active
encoura
gem
ent
from
the
Care
taker
govern
ment
Min
istr
ies
of
Hom
eAff
airs,
Defe
nce,
Fore
ign
Aff
airs,
Police,
Arm
ed
Forc
es,
ACC,
Bangla
desh
Bank,
NG
OBure
au
12
month
s
Continuous
pro
cess
24
month
s(P
arlia
menta
ry)
12
month
s(C
are
taker
govern
ment)
The
Advis
ers
Council
of
Cabin
et
Parlia
ment
Should
em
pow
er
police
by
giv
ing
adm
inis
trative
and
financia
lauto
nom
y
Prevent
Modern
ization
of
Police
Impro
ve
inte
llig
ence
capacity
Pursue
13 Countering Terrorism in Bangladesh: A Strategy PaperIS
trate
gy
of
In
terven
tio
n
Key
perfo
rm
an
ce
ind
icato
r
Key
au
tho
rit
ies/
ag
en
cie
sTim
eli
ne
for
imp
lem
en
tati
on
Mean
so
fV
erif
icati
on
Hyp
oth
esis
Rem
arks
Dem
ocra
tic
sett
ing
Non-d
em
ocra
tic
sett
ing
Esta
blish
Cabin
et
Com
mitte
eon
national
security
Counte
r-te
rrorism
cells
Reduce
the
possib
ility
of
att
acks
inhig
hdensity
are
as
and
critical
infr
astr
uctu
res
Functional
Cabin
et
Com
mitte
eon
National
Security
Desig
nate
dand
custo
miz
ed
Counte
rte
rrorism
cells
inth
ese
are
as
Join
t-Surv
eilla
nce
Team
In
ter-
agency
part
icip
ation
should
inclu
de
inte
llig
ence
agencie
ssuch
as
infr
astr
uctu
respecia
lities
(i.e
.IC
Texpert
s,
engin
eers
,arc
hitects
)
Toexecute
decis
ions
on
security
issues
inclu
din
gte
rrorism
based
on
recom
mendatio
ns
of
the
National
Security
Council/P
ublic
Security
Council
Monitor
and
imple
ment
CT
activitie
sin
various
field
level
inte
llig
ence
and
law
enfo
rcem
ent
agencie
sin
clu
din
gfinancia
lin
stitu
tions
Pro
tection
of
public
pla
ces
and
critical
infr
astr
uctu
re
Min
istr
ies
of
Hom
eAff
airs,
Defe
nce,
Fore
ign
Aff
airs,
Police,
Arm
ed
Forc
es,
ACC,
Bangla
desh
Bank,
NG
OBure
au
Various
Govern
ment
agencie
s
24
month
s(P
arlia
menta
ry)
12
month
s(C
are
taker
govern
ment)
12
month
s
12
month
s
The
Council
of
Advis
ers
Cabin
et
Parlia
ment
Pursue
Countering Terrorism in Bangladesh: A Strategy Paper 14I
Str
ate
gy
of
In
terven
tio
n
Key
perfo
rm
an
ce
ind
icato
r
Key
au
tho
rit
ies/
ag
en
cie
sTim
eli
ne
for
imp
lem
en
tati
on
Dem
ocra
tic
sett
ing
Non-d
em
ocra
tic
sett
ing
Str
ingent
NG
Oauditin
gsta
ndard
and
transpare
nt
financia
lsyste
m
Revis
ed
Money
Laundering
Pre
vention
Act,
2002
Bangla
desh
Bank
NG
Oaccounta
bility
syste
m
Com
pre
hensiv
eanti
money
laundering
regim
ein
volv
ing
avariety
of
modes
and
agencie
s.
Esta
blish
Fin
ancia
lIn
tellig
ence
Unit
inBangla
desh
Bank
and
Str
ength
en
the
Capacity
of
Bangla
desh
Bank
18
month
s
6m
onth
s
Bangla
desh
Bank,
SEC,
NG
OBure
au
The
Council
ofAdvis
ers
Continuous
pro
cess
Mean
so
fV
erif
icati
on
Hyp
oth
esis
Rem
arks
Guid
elines
for
NG
Oaccounting
Revis
ed
Money
Laundering
Pre
vention
Act,
2002
Tra
inin
gof
pers
onnel,
modern
ization
of
bankin
gsyste
mand
surv
eilla
nce
Code
of
Corp
ora
teG
overn
ance
can
be
issued
tom
onitor
auditin
gsta
ndard
s
Under
active
consid
era
tion
of
the
curr
ent
govern
ment
BEI
and
SEC
have
already
form
ula
ted
Code
of
Corp
ora
teG
overn
ance
for
the
NG
Os
focusin
gon
its
auditin
gand
govern
ance
syste
ms
Surv
eilla
nce
and
com
pliance
requirem
ent
should
not
dis
coura
ge
legitim
ate
bankin
gtr
ansactions
inclu
din
gsavin
gs,
busin
ess
and
rem
itta
nce
In
vestigative
capacity
and
jurisdic
tion
of
Bangla
desh
Bank
should
be
wid
ened
Pursue
15 Countering Terrorism in Bangladesh: A Strategy PaperIS
trate
gy
of
In
terven
tio
n
Key
perfo
rm
an
ce
ind
icato
r
Key
au
tho
rit
ies/
ag
en
cie
sTim
eli
ne
for
imp
lem
en
tati
on
Mean
so
fV
erif
icati
on
Hyp
oth
esis
Rem
arks
Dem
ocra
tic
sett
ing
Non-d
em
ocra
tic
sett
ing
Collabora
tion
am
ong
ACC,
AG
off
ice,
BB
and
law
enfo
rcin
gagencie
s
Min
iste
rial
activitie
s
Tra
inin
gpro
gra
ms
and
adequate
budgeta
ryallocation
for
advancin
ghum
an
resourc
es,
equip
ments
and
technic
al
com
pete
ncie
s
Inte
r-agency
com
mitte
e
Extr
aditio
ntr
eaty
or
MoU
sor
dip
lom
atic
eff
ort
s
Vacuum
regard
ing
inte
r-agency
coopera
tion
for
purs
uin
ganti-
money
laundering
activitie
sexis
ts
Regio
naland
inte
rnational
measure
saim
ed
at
str
ength
enin
gin
form
ation
exchange
inth
efight
again
st
terr
orism
should
be
initia
ted
Regio
naland
inte
rnational
coopera
tion
could
be
sought
Inte
r-agency
coopera
tion
for
purs
uin
ganti-
money
laundering
activitie
s/
cam
paig
n
Sig
nextr
aditio
ntr
eaties
with
India
,M
yanm
ar,
Nepal,
Bhuta
n
Modern
ization
of
the
inte
llig
ence
and
law
enfo
rcem
ent
agencie
s
12
month
s
18
month
s
Continuous
pro
cess
Inte
r-agency
initia
tive
led
by
Bangla
desh
Bank
Min
istr
ies
of
Hom
eAff
airs,
Defe
nse,
Fore
ign
Aff
airs,
Police,
Arm
ed
Forc
es,
ACC,
Bangla
desh
Bank,
NG
OBure
au
Min
istr
ies
of
Fore
ign
Aff
airs,
Hom
eAff
airs,
the
Council
of
Advis
ers
Pursue
Countering Terrorism in Bangladesh: A Strategy Paper 16IS
trate
gy
of
In
terven
tio
n
Key
perfo
rm
an
ce
ind
icato
r
Key
au
tho
rit
ies/
ag
en
cie
sTim
eli
ne
for
imp
lem
en
tati
on
Mean
so
fV
erif
icati
on
Hyp
oth
esis
Rem
arks
Dem
ocra
tic
sett
ing
Non-d
em
ocra
tic
sett
ing
Eff
icie
nt
bord
er
patr
ollin
g,
modern
ization
of
imm
igra
tion
pro
cedure
sand
of
the
Vis
aIn
form
ation
Syste
m
Esta
blishm
ent
of
acentr
al
coord
inating
body
for
crisis
managem
ent
There
isa
need
for
cro
ss-b
ord
er
join
texerc
ises
topre
vent
the
sm
uggling
of
radio
logic
alor
hazard
ous
mate
rials
whic
hcould
be
used
tofa
bricate
arm
sand
weapons
This
should
focus
on
impro
vin
gle
gal
and
adm
inis
trative
measure
s,
sto
ckpile
managem
ent,
esta
blishin
gre
gio
naland
extr
a-
regio
nal
coopera
tion
and
ensuring
UN
com
pliance
Bangla
desh
has
agood
track
record
for
dis
aste
rm
anagem
ent
caused
by
natu
ral
cala
mitie
s
Four-
tier
ale
rtsyste
mcan
be
pre
scribed:
:te
rrorist
att
ack
isnot
expecte
d,
:te
rrorist
att
ack
could
occur,
:te
rrorist
att
ack
islikely
,:
terr
orist
att
ack
isim
min
ent
or
has
occurr
ed
low
med
ium
hig
h
extr
em
e
Enable
the
govern
ment
tosupport
pre
vention,
pre
pare
dness
and
response
Str
ingent
bord
er
managem
ent
syste
mand
security
techniq
ues.
Security
of
transport
,port
sand
public
pla
ces
Str
ate
gy
toCurb
the
pro
life
ration
of
Sm
all
Arm
s,
Lig
ht
Weapons
and
Explo
siv
es
Pre
or
post-
terr
orism
Crisis
managem
ent
Anational
counte
r-te
rrorism
ale
rtle
velsyste
m
Fin
ancia
lIn
str
um
ent
for
Com
munity
Action
Afinancia
lcom
mitte
e
Continuous
pro
cess
24
month
s(P
arlia
menta
ry)
12
month
s(C
are
taker
govern
ment)
12
month
s
12
month
s
6m
onth
s
AStr
ate
gy
paper
toCurb
the
pro
life
ration
of
Sm
all
Arm
s,
Lig
ht
Weapons
and
Explo
siv
es
Modern
ized
imm
igra
tion
pro
cedure
sand
passport
s
Centr
al
Coord
inating
Body
for
Crisis
Managem
ent
and
Response
Opera
ting
pro
cedure
sand
am
anualfo
rcrisis
coord
ination
arr
angem
ents
can
be
published
Centr
al
Coord
inating
Body
for
Fin
anci
al
Ass
ista
nce
toCrisi
sM
anagem
ent
and
Resp
onse
Am
anualcan
be
develo
ped
for
public
circula
tion
tounders
tand
thre
ats
and
tore
spond
tocrisis
Regio
naland
inte
rnational
assis
tance
has
been
inpra
ctice
Min
istr
ies
of
Hom
eAff
airs,
Defe
nse,
Fore
ign
Aff
airs,
Police,
Arm
ed
Forc
es
The
Council
of
Advis
ers
Inte
r-agency
initia
tive
inclu
din
gD
isaste
rM
anagem
ent
agencie
s
NationalSecurity
Council
(when
form
ed)
An
inte
r-agency
inte
llig
ence
com
mitte
ecan
be
form
ed
Inte
r-agency
initia
tive
Protect Prepare
The is an independent non-profit
research centre established in October, 2000. The Institute has established
for itself a reputation for excellence in its research and advocacy work
focusing on private sector development in Bangladesh, security and
promotion of regional cooperation. The Institute promotes issues of
importance to the private sector and initiates essential measures to
influence policy making for the development of a market-oriented economy.
BEI hopes to address the enormous challenge that Bangladesh faces in
securing a fair share of the global market. Since its inception, BEI has been
working as a catalyst to foster the growth of private sector in Bangladesh.
For details please visit
Bangladesh Enterprise Institute (BEI)
www.bei-bd.org