Court of Appeals Opinion Gessler v. Ethics Commission

8/9/2019 Court of Appeals Opinion Gessler v. Ethics Commission

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/court-of-appeals-opinion-gessler-v-ethics-commission 1/28

!"#"$%&" !"($) "* %++,%#- !"#$%&'(!

..............................................................................

!/012 /3 %445678 9/: ;<!%=>?=!@2A 6BC !/0B2A /3 &5BD51 &@821@E2 !/012 9/: ;F!GF=<H;

I/B/16J75 I51J512 #: -251BK LLLK M0CN5 ..............................................................................

-E/22 O588751K @BC@D@C0677A 6BC @B P@8 /33@E@67 E646E@2A 68 !/7/16C/ -5E15261A /3-2625K

+76@B2@33Q%445776B2K

D:

&6B O1/88R6BK -677A I: I/4451K S@77 +@BTP6RK U622 -R@2PK 6BC $/85R61A

U618P677K @B 2P5@1 /33@E@67 E646E@2@58 68 R5RJ518 /3 2P5 LBC545BC5B2 ,2P@E8!/RR@88@/BV 6BC 2P5 LBC545BC5B2 ,2P@E8 !/RR@88@/BK

&535BC6B28Q%44577558: ..............................................................................

M(&OU,9) %**L$U,&

&@D@8@/B L"4@B@/B JA M(&O, O%S$L,#

)60JR6B 6BC S//168K MM:K E/BE01

%BB/0BE5C U6A ?K H=;W ..............................................................................

!AB2P@6 I: !/33R6BK %22/1B5A O5B5167K U@EP657 *16BE@8E/K %88@826B2 -/7@E@2/1O5B5167K X62P1AB %: -261B5776K %88@826B2 %22/1B5A O5B5167K &5BD51K !/7/16C/K3/1 +76@B2@33Q%445776B2

!AB2P@6 I: !/33R6BK %22/1B5A O5B5167K #@86 S15BB51 *15@R6BBK *@182 %88@826B2%22/1B5A O5B5167K $088577 S: X75@BK *@182 %88@826B2 %22/1B5A O5B5167K M/57 Y:X@585AK %88@826B2 %22/1B5A O5B5167K &5BD51K !/7/16C/K 3/1 &535BC6B28Q%44577558

#0@8 )/1/K U61N6152 +517K &5BD51K !/7/16C/K 3/1 %R@E08 !01@65 !/7/16C/ ,2P@E8Y62EP



;

Z ;

+76@B2@33K 3/1R51 !/7/16C/ -5E15261A /3 -2625 -E/22 O588751K

6445678 2P5 C@821@E2 E/012[8 \0CNR5B2 633@1R@BN 2P5 !/7/16C/

LBC545BC5B2 ,2P@E8 !/RR@88@/B[8 ]L,![8^ C5251R@B62@/B 2P62 P5

J156EP5C 2P5 40J7@E 21082 JA 08@BN 40J7@E 30BC8 3/1 4518/B67 6BC

4/7@2@E67 4014/858: Y5 E/BE70C5 2P62 2P5 L,! ];^ P6C \01@8C@E2@/B

/D51 2P@8 R62251V ]H^ C@C B/2 R6T5 6B 61J@2161A /1 E641@E@/08

C5E@8@/BV 6BC ]F^ C@C B/2 D@/7625 O588751[8 C05 41/E588 1@NP28 _@2P

15845E2 2/ 2P5 B/2@E5 /3 2P5 EP61N58 6N6@B82 P@R: %EE/1C@BN7AK _5

633@1R:

L: S6ETN1/0BC

Z H %2 677 2@R58 4512@B5B2 P515K O588751 _68 !/7/16C/[8 -5E15261A /3

-2625: LB %0N082 H=;HK P5 216D575C 2/ *7/1@C6 2/ 6225BC 6BC 41585B2

62 2P5 `962@/B67 ,75E2@/B #6_ -5R@B61Ka 6 2_/QC6A 41/N16R

84/B8/15C JA 2P5 $540J7@E6B 962@/B67 #6_A518 %88/E@62@/B ]$9#%^K

6BC 2P5B 2/ 6225BC 2P5 $540J7@E6B 962@/B67 !/BD5B2@/B ]$9!^K

_P@EP _68 J5@BN P57C @B 6 C@33515B2 *7/1@C6 E@2A: )P5 $9#% 85R@B61

5BC5C C01@BN 2P5 C6A /B %0N082 HWK H=;HK 6BC O588751 826A5C 6B

6CC@2@/B67 B@NP2 62 6B @BE15685C P/257 1625 6BC 62 2P5 82625 /3

!/7/16C/[8 5b45B85: )P5 B5b2 C6AK P5 216D575C 2/ 2P5 $9!:



H

Z F

%8 4512@B5B2 P515K O588751 085C P@8 826202/1@7A 41/D@C5C

C@8E152@/B61A 30BCK !"" c H<QdQ;=WK !:$:-: H=;< ]2P5 C@8E152@/B61A

30BC 8262025^K 2/ 46A 2P5 e;H?f:d= @B C/E0R5B25C 216D57 6BC R567

5b45B858 2P62 P5 @BE0115C 2/ 6225BC 2P5 $9#% 85R@B61: LB 6CC@2@/BK

P5 15g05825C 2P5 15@RJ0185R5B2 /3 `6BA 15R6@B@BN C@8E152@/B61A

30BC8a @B P@8 C@8E152@/B61A 6EE/0B2: I5 C@C B/2K P/_5D51K @B@2@677A

41/D@C5 6BA C/E0R5B262@/B 8044/12@BN 2P@8 15g0582:

9/2_@2P826BC@BN 2P5 6J85BE5 /3 C/E0R5B262@/BK P5 072@R6257A

15E5@D5C e;;?:dd 68 6 158072 /3 P@8 15g0582:

Z <

%R@E08 E01@65K !/7/16C/ ,2P@E8 Y62EPK 80J85g05B27A 3@75C 6

E/R476@B2 6N6@B82 O588751 _@2P 2P5 L,!: LB 2P@8 E/R476@B2K

!/7/16C/ ,2P@E8 Y62EP 6775N5C 2P62 O588751 P6C R6C5 36785

82625R5B28 /B 216D57 5b45B85 15@RJ0185R5B2 15g05828 80JR@225C 2/

2P5 82625 6BC P6C R@86441/41@625C 82625 30BC8 3/1 4518/B67 /1

4/7@2@E67 0858: )P5 L,! C5251R@B5C 2P62 2P5 E/R476@B2 _68 B/2

31@D/7/08 6BCK 63251 @BD582@N62@/BK E/BC0E25C 6B 5D@C5B2@61A P561@BN

62 _P@EP O588751 6445615C 2P1/0NP E/0B857 6BC 2582@3@5C:

Z W

)P5 L,! 072@R6257A 3/0BCK 6R/BN /2P51 2P@BN8K 2P62 ];^ O588751

845B2 e;H?f:d= /3 P@8 C@8E152@/B61A 6EE/0B2 41@R61@7A 3/1 4612@86BK

6BC 2P5153/15 4518/B67K 4014/858K @B D@/762@/B /3 2P5 C@8E152@/B61A



F

30BC 8262025[8 15g0@15R5B2 2P62 2P5 30BC J5 085C @B 401806BE5 /3

/33@E@67 J08@B588V ]H^ O588751[8 6EE5426BE5 /3 15@RJ0185R5B2 /3 2P5

J676BE5 /3 P@8 C@8E152@/B61A 6EE/0B2 _@2P/02 6BA C/E0R5B262@/B /1

C526@7 /3 5b45B858 @BE0115C D@/7625C 2P5 C@8E152@/B61A 30BC 8262025

J5E6085 2P5 46AR5B2 _68 4518/B67 @B B62015 6BC B/2 @B 401806BE5

/3 /33@E@67 J08@B588V 6BC ]F^ JA E/RR@22@BN 56EP /3 2P5 3/15N/@BN

D@/762@/B8K O588751 P6C 678/ J156EP5C 2P5 40J7@E 21082 3/1 41@D625

N6@BK @B D@/762@/B /3 2P5 40J7@E 21082 8262025K c H<Q;fQ;=FK !:$:-:

H=;<:

Z >

O588751 8/0NP2 \0C@E@67 15D@5_ /3 2P5 L,![8 3@BC@BN8K 688512@BN

2P62 ];^ 2P5 L,![8 5B6J7@BN 41/D@8@/B _68 0BE/B82@202@/B677A D6N05

6BC /D51J1/6CV ]H^ 2P5 L,![8 \01@8C@E2@/B @8 7@R@25C 2/ @BD582@N62@BN

@R41/451 N@328 2/ 40J7@E /33@E518 6BCK 2P08K 2P5 L,! 5bE55C5C @28

\01@8C@E2@/B P515V ]F^ 2P5 L,![8 3@BC@BN8 /3 36E2 _515 61J@2161A /1

E641@E@/08V 6BC ]<^ 2P5 L,! D@/7625C O588751[8 C05 41/E588 1@NP28 JAK

6R/BN /2P51 2P@BN8K 41/D@C@BN @B8033@E@5B2 B/2@E5 /3 2P5 EP61N58

6N6@B82 P@R: )P5 C@821@E2 E/012 072@R6257A 15\5E25C 2P585

E/B25B2@/B8K 5@2P51 5b415887A /1 @R47@E@27AK @B 6 C526@75C 6BC

2P/1/0NP _1@225B /4@B@/B:

Z ?

O588751 B/_ 6445678:



<

LL: M01@8C@E2@/B

Z f O588751 3@182 E/B25BC8 2P62 2P5 C@821@E2 E/012 5115C @B

E/BE70C@BN 2P62 2P5 L,! P6C \01@8C@E2@/B /D51 2P@8 E685 J5E6085

];^ 612@E75 hhLhK 85E2@/B W /3 2P5 !/7/16C/ !/B82@202@/B ]85E2@/B W^

6447@58 /B7A 2/ N@328K @B3705BE5 45CC7@BNK 6BC 826BC61C8 /3 E/BC0E2

6BC 154/12@BN 15g0@15R5B28 2P62 5b415887A C575N625 5B3/1E5R5B2 2/

2P5 L,!V ]H^ B5@2P51 2P5 C@8E152@/B61A 30BC 8262025 B/1 2P5 40J7@E

21082 8262025 36778 _@2P@B 2P5 6RJ@2 /3 85E2@/B WV 6BC ]F^ 2P5 L,! P68

E/B82105C @28 \01@8C@E2@/B 8/ J1/6C7A 68 2/ 15BC51 85E2@/B W D6N05

6BC /D51J1/6C: Y5 615 B/2 451806C5C JA 2P585 61N0R5B28:

%: -26BC61C /3 $5D@5_ 6BC $0758 /3 !/B8210E2@/B

Z d "B 644567 31/R 6 C@821@E2 E/012[8 15D@5_ /3 6 3@B67 6N5BEA

6E2@/BK _5 6447A 2P5 86R5 826BC61C /3 15D@5_ 68 2P5 C@821@E2 E/012K

B6R57AK 2P5 826BC61C 852 3/12P @B 85E2@/B H<Q<Q;=>]?^K !:$:-: H=;<:

$"" %&'() *+ ,"!-.// K H=;< !"% d?K Z H;K FFf +:FC ;=?fK ;=fH:

Z ;= -5E2@/B H<Q<Q;=>]?^ 41/D@C58K @B 4512@B5B2 4612i

L3 2P5 E/012 3@BC8 B/ 511/1K @2 8P677 633@1R 2P56N5BEA 6E2@/B: L3 @2 3@BC8 2P62 2P5 6N5BEA6E2@/B @8 61J@2161A /1 E641@E@/08K 6 C5B@67 /3826202/1A 1@NP2K E/B2161A 2/ E/B82@202@/B671@NP2K 4/_51K 41@D@75N5K /1 @RR0B@2AK @B 5bE588/3 826202/1A \01@8C@E2@/BK 602P/1@2AK 4014/858K/1 7@R@262@/B8K B/2 @B 6EE/1C _@2P 2P5



W

41/E5C0158 /1 41/E5C0167 7@R@262@/B8 /3 2P@8612@E75 /1 68 /2P51_@85 15g0@15C JA 76_K 6B6J085 /1 E75617A 0B_6116B25C 5b51E@85 /3C@8E152@/BK J685C 04/B 3@BC@BN8 /3 36E2 2P62 615

E75617A 511/B5/08 /B 2P5 _P/75 15E/1CK0B8044/125C JA 80J826B2@67 5D@C5BE5 _P5B 2P515E/1C @8 E/B8@C515C 68 6 _P/75K /1 /2P51_@85E/B2161A 2/ 76_K 2P5B 2P5 E/012 8P677 P/7C0B76_307 6BC 852 68@C5 2P5 6N5BEA 6E2@/B6BC : : : 633/1C 80EP /2P51 157@53 68 R6A J56441/41@625: LB R6T@BN 2P5 3/15N/@BNC5251R@B62@/B8K 2P5 E/012 8P677 15D@5_ 2P5_P/75 15E/1C /1 80EP 4/12@/B8 2P515/3 68 R6AJ5 E@25C JA 6BA 4612A:

Z ;; LB 6447A@BN 2P@8 826BC61CK _5 41580R5 2P5 D67@C@2A 6BC

15N0761@2A /3 6CR@B@82162@D5 41/E55C@BN8 6BC 158/7D5 677 1568/B6J75

C/0J28 68 2/ 2P5 E/115E2B588 /3 6CR@B@82162@D5 107@BN8 @B 36D/1 /3 2P5

6N5BEA: %&'() K Z H;K FFf +:FC 62 ;=fH:

Z ;H

LB 6CC@2@/BK 6 15D@5_@BN E/012 R082 N@D5 C53515BE5 2/ 2P5

1568/B6J75 @B251415262@/B8 /3 2P5 6CR@B@82162@D5 6N5BEA 2P62 @8

602P/1@j5C 2/ 6CR@B@8251 6BC 5B3/1E5 2P5 8262025 62 @8805: $""

0'11234 *+ 0'5'+ 0'22'4 03)!" K ;=H +:FC dddK ;==W ]!/7/: H==<^:

I/_5D51K

!/B82@202@/B67 @B251415262@/B 6BC 826202/1A@B251415262@/B 41585B2 g0582@/B8 /3 76_ 2P62 _515D@5_ C5 B/D/: %8 4612 /3 /01 C5 B/D/ 15D@5_K`_5 R6A E/B8@C51 6BC C5351 2/ 6B 6N5BEA[8@B251415262@/B /3 @28 /_B 5B6J7@BN 8262025 6BCk/3l 15N0762@/B8 2P5 6N5BEA P68 41/R07N625C:a



>

-0EP C53515BE5K P/_5D51K @8 B/2 _6116B25C_P515 : : : 2P5 6N5BEA[8 @B251415262@/B @8E/B2161A 2/ E/B82@202@/B67 6BC 826202/1A 76_:

6"!!5"7 *+ 0'5'+ 0'22'4 03)!" K H=;< !" <<K Z ?K FH? +:FC HFHK

HFW ]g0/2@BN 8&+ '1 04/9+ 0'22:7! *+ 0'5'+ ;)-+ </.5!+ 0'22:4 K

;W? +:FC ;=fFK ;=ff ]!/7/: H==?^V /2P51 E@262@/B8 /R@225C^V !"" 35!'

0./9 '1 =75.4>/'4 *+ ?00 K ;FF -: !2: ;f>FK ;f?; ]H=;F^ ]B/2@BN 2P62

2P5 C53515B2@67 826BC61C /3 15D@5_ B/1R677A 633/1C5C 6N5BEA

C5251R@B62@/B8 6447@58 5g0677A 2/ 6B 6N5BEA[8 E/B8210E2@/B /3 6

\01@8C@E2@/B67 41/D@8@/B /3 6 8262025 2P62 2P5 6N5BEA 6CR@B@82518^:

Z ;F Y@2P 15845E2 2/ E/B82@202@/B67 E/B8210E2@/BK

/01 /J7@N62@/B @8 2/ N@D5 5335E2 2/ 2P5 @B25B2 /32P5 575E2/1625 2P62 6C/425C @2: LB N@D@BN 5335E22/ 2P62 @B25B2K _5 7//T 2/ 2P5 _/1C8 085CK

156C@BN 2P5R @B E/B25b2 6BC 6EE/1C@BN 2P5R2P5@1 476@B 6BC /1C@B61A R56B@BN: YP5156RJ@N0@2@58 5b@82K _5 @B2514152 2P5E/B82@202@/B67 41/D@8@/B 68 6 _P/75 @B 6B6225R42 2/ P61R/B@j5 677 @28 46128:

@37(''& *+ $"43/" A3B'7./9 ?)4&C DD0 K ;<; +:FC d>HK d>< ]!/7/:

%44: H==>^: L3 2P5 76BN06N5 @8 0B6RJ@N0/08K _5 R082 5B3/1E5 @2 68

_1@225B: 0'5'+ E/F.G! H3/GF *+ $"43/" A3B'7./9 ?)4&C DD0 K H?W +:FC

>?<K >fH ]!/7/: %44: H=;=^K 311:& K H=;H !" ;HK H>d +:FC ;H<f: L3

2P5 76BN06N5 E/B26@B5C @B 6 E@2@j5BQ@B@2@625C R568015 @8 6RJ@N0/08K



?

`6 E/012 R6A 68E5126@B 2P5 @B25B2 /3 2P5 D/2518 JA E/B8@C51@BN /2P51

1575D6B2 R6251@678 80EP 68 2P5 J677/2 2@275 6BC 80JR@88@/B E76085

6BC 2P5 J@5BB@67 mS705J//TK[ _P@EP @8 2P5 6B67A8@8 /3 J677/2

41/4/8678 4154615C JA 2P5 75N@8762015:a %4 7" $)-2.!!.'4 '1

%4/"77'>3/'7."! '4 @')!" 8.55 IIJKLMN K d?d +:HC W<dK WW< ]!/7/:

;ddd^:

S: -E/45 /3 -5E2@/B W

Z ;<

%447A@BN 2P5 3/15N/@BN 41@BE@4758 /3 E/B82@202@/B67 E/B8210E2@/B

P515K _5 3@182 15\5E2 O588751[8 688512@/B 2P62 85E2@/B W 6447@58 /B7A 2/

N@328K @B3705BE5 45CC7@BNK 6BC 826BC61C8 /3 E/BC0E2 6BC 154/12@BN

15g0@15R5B28 2P62 5b415887A C575N625 5B3/1E5R5B2 2/ 2P5 L,!:

Z ;W -5E2@/B W 41/D@C58K @B 4512@B5B2 4612K `)P5 4014/85 /3 2P5

@BC545BC5B2 52P@E8 E/RR@88@/B 8P677 J5 2/ P561 E/R476@B28K @8805

3@BC@BN8K 6BC 688588 45B672@58K 6BC 678/ 2/ @8805 6CD@8/1A /4@B@/B8K

/B 52P@E8 @88058 61@8@BN 0BC51 2P@8 612@E75 34& )4&"7 349 '/F"7

!/34&37&! '1 G'4&)G/ 34& 7"O'7/.4> 7"P).7"2"4/! 3! O7'*.&"& -9

53( :a !/7/: !/B82: 612: hhLhK c W];^ ]5R4P68@8 6CC5C^: )P62 85E2@/B

3012P51 41/D@C58 2P62 2P5 L,! `8P677 P6D5 602P/1@2A 2/ 6C/42 80EP

1568/B6J75 10758 68 R6A J5 B5E58861A 3/1 2P5 4014/85 /3

6CR@B@8251@BN 6BC 5B3/1E@BN 2P5 41/D@8@/B8 /3 2P@8 612@E75 34& 349





d

"+>+C H"55! ?37>' 834QC ,+=+ *+ R'O1234 K HH> +:FC ;=>fK ;=?FQ?<

]!/7/: H=;=^ ]@B2514152@BN 2P5 4P1685 `15D@D5C 68 41/D@C5C JA 76_Ka

_P@EP 6445618 @B 2P5 8262025 E/BE51B@BN 2P5 15D@D67 /3 \0CNR5B28K

68 153511@BN 2/ 2P5 15D@D67 /3 \0CNR5B28 401806B2 2/ !:$:!:+: W<]P^^V

!"" 35!' AG03!534& *+ A.!Q"55 K fd= +:HC ;FHHK ;FH> ]9:U: !2: %44:

;dd<^ ]`Y5 2P@BT 2P5 4P16858 m@B 2P5 R6BB51 845E@677A 41/D@C5C JA

76_K[ /1 m@B 2P5 R6BB51 41/D@C5C JA 76_[ : : : R56B @B 6EE/1C6BE5

_@2P 5b@82@BN 826202/1A 41/E5C015:a^V 853GQ:! D3( S.G/.'4379 ;HH<

]>2P 5C: ;dd=^ ]C53@B@BN `41/D@C5C JA 76_a 2/ R56B `4158E1@J5C /1

41/D@C5C JA 8/R5 8262025a^:

Z ;? %EE/1C@BN7AK O588751[8 \01@8C@E2@/B67 EP6775BN5 J685C /B 2P5

76BN06N5 /3 85E2@/B W 36@78:

!:

+0J7@E )1082 -262025

Z ;f

O588751 3012P51 E/B25BC8 2P62 2P5 40J7@E 21082 8262025 C/58 B/2

3677 _@2P@B 2P5 6RJ@2 /3 85E2@/B W J5E6085 @2 @8 `P/1262/1Aa /B7A 6BC

C/58 B/2 41/D@C5 6 845E@3@E 826BC61C /3 E/BC0E2: %N6@BK _5 C@86N155:

Z ;d

)P5 40J7@E 21082 8262025K _P@EP 6445618 @B 6B 612@E75 5B2@275C

`-26BC61C8 /3 !/BC0E2a 6BC 6 4612 5B2@275C `!/C5 /3 ,2P@E8Ka

41/D@C58 @B 4512@B5B2 4612i



;=

)P5 P/7C@BN /3 40J7@E /33@E5 /1 5R47/AR5B2 @8 640J7@E 21082K E15625C JA 2P5 E/B3@C5BE5 _P@EP2P5 575E2/1625 154/858 @B 2P5 @B25N1@2A /3 40J7@E/33@E518K R5RJ518 /3 2P5 N5B5167 6885RJ7AK

7/E67 N/D51BR5B2 /33@E@678K 6BC 5R47/A558: %40J7@E /33@E51K R5RJ51 /3 2P5 N5B5167 6885RJ7AK7/E67 N/D51BR5B2 /33@E@67K /1 5R47/A55 8P677E611A /02 P@8 C02@58 3/1 2P5 J5B53@2 /3 2P545/475 /3 2P5 82625:

c H<Q;fQ;=F];^:

Z H= )P@8 76BN06N5 E156258 6 3@C0E@61A C02A @B 40J7@E /33@E@678K 6B

@B251415262@/B E/B3@1R5C JA 2P5 2@275 /3 2P5 85E2@/BK `+0J7@E 21082 n

J156EP /3 3@C0E@61A C02AKa 6BC 2P5 15R6@B@BN 41/D@8@/B /3 2P5

8262025K _P@EP 3/E0858 /B 15R5C@58 6D6@76J75 _P5B 6 40J7@E /33@E51[8

E/BC0E2 C546128 31/R P@8 /1 P51 3@C0E@61A C02@58: $"" c H<Q;fQ

;=F]H^ ]`% 40J7@E /33@E51 : : : _P/85 E/BC0E2 C546128 31/R P@8

3@C0E@61A C02A @8 7@6J75 2/ 2P5 45/475 /3 2P5 82625 68 6 2108255 /3

41/4512A 6BC 8P677 803351 80EP /2P51 7@6J@7@2@58 68 6 41@D625 3@C0E@61A

_/07C 803351 3/1 6J085 /3 P@8 21082:a^: %EE/1C@BN7AK 2P5 40J7@E 21082

8262025 8528 3/12P 845E@3@E 826BC61C8 /3 E/BC0E2:

Z H;

LB 6CC@2@/BK _5 B/25 2P62 612@E75 hhLhK 85E2@/B > /3 2P5

!/7/16C/ !/B82@202@/B 41/D@C58 6B 5b41588 15R5CA 3/1 D@/762@/B8 /3

2P5 40J7@E 21082 3/1 41@D625 N6@B: O588751[8 @B251415262@/B /3 2P5

40J7@E 21082 8262025 _/07C 61N06J7A 15BC51 2P62 E/B82@202@/B67



;;

41/D@8@/B 80451370/08 /1 6 B077@2AK 6BC _5 R082 6D/@C 6BA 80EP

E/B8210E2@/B: $"" 0'5'+ E&)G+ =!!:4 *+ T)// K ;f< +:FC >WK f= ]!/7/:

H==f^ ]B/2@BN 2P62 _5 R082 6D/@C 6BA E/B8210E2@/B 2P62 _/07C

15BC51 6 E/B82@202@/B67 41/D@8@/B 5@2P51 80451370/08 /1 6 B077@2A^:

Z HH

%EE/1C@BN7AK _5 E/BE70C5 2P62 2P5 40J7@E 21082 8262025 36778

_@2P@B 2P5 6RJ@2 /3 85E2@/B W:

&: )P5 &@8E152@/B61A *0BC -262025

Z HF

O588751 7@T5_@85 E/B25BC8 2P62 2P5 C@8E152@/B61A 30BC 8262025

C/58 B/2 3677 _@2P@B 2P5 6RJ@2 /3 85E2@/B W: )P62 8262025 R6T58

30BC8 6D6@76J75 2/ E5126@B 575E25C 82625 /33@E@678 `3/1 5b45BC@2015 @B

401806BE5 /3 /33@E@67 J08@B588 68 56EP 575E25C /33@E@67 8558 3@2:a c H<Q

dQ;=W: O588751 6885128 2P62 ];^ 2P5 8262025 1576258 2/ E/R45B862@/BK

6BC E/R45B862@/B @8 5b415887A 5bE70C5C 31/R 612@E75 hhLhV ]H^ P5

P68 0B3522515C C@8E152@/B /D51 2P5 085 /3 P@8 C@8E152@/B61A 30BC8V

6BC ]F^ 2P5 8262025 41/D@C58 B/ 845E@3@E 826BC61C /3 E/BC0E2 68

15g0@15C JA 612@E75 hhLh: Y5 15\5E2 56EP /3 2P585 61N0R5B28 @B

201B:

Z H<

*@182K _5 C@86N155 _@2P O588751[8 415R@85 2P62 612@E75 hhLh

5bE70C58 826BC61C8 /3 E/BC0E2 157625C 2/ E/R45B862@/B: LB 8044/12

/3 P@8 61N0R5B2K O588751 E@258 2/ 612@E75 hhLhK 85E2@/B ;]C^ /3 2P5



;H

!/7/16C/ !/B82@202@/B: )P62 85E2@/B 41/D@C58K `%BA 533/12 2/ 1567@j5

4518/B67 3@B6BE@67 N6@B 2P1/0NP 40J7@E /33@E5 /2P51 2P6B

E/R45B862@/B 41/D@C5C JA 76_ @8 6 D@/762@/B /3 k2P5 40J7@El 21082:a

)P5 85E2@/BK P/_5D51K @8 6 N5B5167 82625R5B2 /3 2P5 4014/858 /3

612@E75 hhLhK B/2 6 7@R@262@/B /B 2P5 L,![8 \01@8C@E2@/B: LBC55CK 2P5

85E2@/B C/58 B/2 5D5B R5B2@/B 2P5 L,!:

Z HW U/15/D51K 85E2@/B ;]C^ C/58 B/2 5b5R42 E/R45B862/1A

826BC61C8 31/R E/B8@C5162@/B: $62P51K @2 R6T58 E7561 2P62 40J7@E

/33@E@678 R6A 41/4517A J5 E/R45B8625C 68 41/D@C5C JA 76_ 3/1 2P5@1

_/1T J02 2P62 6BA 533/12 2/ 1567@j5 4518/B67 3@B6BE@67 N6@B J5A/BC

80EP 76_307 E/R45B862@/B D@/76258 2P5 40J7@E 21082: $"" .&+

Z H> ,D5B @3 85E2@/B ;]C^ E/07C J5 156C 68 5bE70C@BN 826BC61C8 /3

E/BC0E2 15N61C@BN E/R45B862@/B 31/R 2P5 L,![8 \01@8C@E2@/BK

P/_5D51K _5 C@86N155 _@2P O588751[8 688512@/B 2P62 2P5 C@8E152@/B61A

30BC E/B82@20258 E/R45B862@/B:

Z H? !/R45B862@/B @8 C53@B5C 68 `k1l5R0B5162@/B 6BC /2P51 J5B53@28

15E5@D5C @B 15201B 3/1 851D@E58 15BC515CV 584:K 86761A /1 _6N58:a

853GQ:! D3( S.G/.'4379 F<H ];=2P 5C: H==d^: )P5 C@8E152@/B61A

30BC8K _P@EP 615 41/D@C5C @B 826202/1@7A 3@b5C 6R/0B28K 615 B/2

15E5@D5C @B 15201B 3/1 851D@E58 15BC515C: 9/1 C/ 2P5A 15375E2



;F

15R0B5162@/BK N@D5B 2P62 2P5 R/B5A 15R6@B8 2P5 41/4512A /3 2P5

82625 6BC R6A /B7A J5 085C `@B 401806BE5 /3 /33@E@67 J08@B588:a $""

c H<QdQ;=WV !"" 35!' c H<QH;Q;=<]F^]E^K !:$:-: H=;< ]`kYlP5B5D51

R/B5A8 6441/41@625C 2/ 2P5 C54612R5B2 /3 82625 C01@BN 2P5 41@/1

3@8E67 A561 615 0B5b45BC5CK 86@C R/B5A8 8P677 J5 R6C5 6 4612 /3 2P5

6441/41@62@/B 2/ 2P5 C54612R5B2 /3 82625 3/1 2P5 B5b2 3@8E67

A561 : : : :a^V c H<Q?WQ;=H];^]6^K !:$:-: H=;< ]`,bE542 68 /2P51_@85

41/D@C5C JA 76_K 6BA R/B5A8 0B5b45BC5C /1 B/2 5BE0RJ515C 31/R

2P5 6441/41@62@/B 2/ 56EP C54612R5B2 3/1 6BA 3@8E67 A561 8P677 15D512

2/ 2P5 N5B5167 30BC /1K @3 R6C5 31/R 6 845E@67 30BCK 2/ 80EP 845E@67

30BC:a^: %EE/1C@BN7AK 2P5 C@8E152@/B61A 30BC C/58 B/2 E/B82@2025

`E/R45B862@/Ba 0BC51 2P5 476@B R56B@BN /3 2P62 251R:

Z Hf

Y5 615 B/2 451806C5C /2P51_@85 JA O588751[8 61N0R5B2 2P62

2P5 C@8E152@/B61A 30BC @8 B5E58861@7A E/R45B862@/B J5E6085 2P5

C@8E152@/B61A 30BC 8262025 6445618 _@2P@B 6B 612@E75 5B2@275C

`!/R45B862@/B /3 -2625 "33@E518:a )P5 86R5 612@E75 678/ P68 6

85E2@/B 6CC1588@BN R@756N5 15@RJ0185R5B28: $"" c H<QdQ;=<K

!:$:-: H=;<: U@756N5 15@RJ0185R5B28K JA C53@B@2@/BK 615

1546AR5B28 3/1 R/B5A 6CD6BE5CK B/2 E/R45B862@/B: $"" 853GQ:!

D3( S.G/.'4379 62 ;<?> ]C53@B@BN `15@RJ0185R5B2a 68 `k1l546AR5B2a



;<

/1 `k@lBC5RB@3@E62@/Ba^: %EE/1C@BN7AK 2P5 R515 36E2 2P62 2P5

C@8E152@/B61A 30BC 8262025 6445618 _@2P@B 2P5 2@275 15762@BN 2/

E/R45B862@/B C/58 B/2 B5E58861@7A R56B 2P62 2P5 30BC E/B82@20258

E/R45B862@/B:

Z Hd

-5E/BCK 2P5 C@8E152@/B61A 30BC 8262025K /B @28 36E5K C@C B/2 N@D5

O588751 0B3522515C C@8E152@/B /D51 2P5 085 /3 2P5 -5E15261A /3 -2625[8

C@8E152@/B61A 30BC8: )/ 2P5 E/B2161AK 2P5 085 /3 2P/85 30BC8 _68

]6BC @8^ 7@R@25C 2/ 2P5 `401806BE5 /3 /33@E@67 J08@B588:a c H<QdQ;=W:

U/15/D51K _5 451E5@D5 B/ 76BN06N5 @B 2P5 C@8E152@/B61A 30BC 8262025

@BC@E62@BN 2P62 O588751 _68 2P5 8/75 6BC 5bE708@D5 61J@251 /3 _P62

0858 _515 `@B 401806BE5 /3 /33@E@67 J08@B588Ka 15N61C7588 /3 P@8 085

/3 2P/85 30BC8: LBC55CK 2/ E/B82105 2P5 8262025 68 O588751 C/58

_/07C 756C 2/ 6J801C 1580728 J5E6085 @2 _/07C 677/_ 2P5 -5E15261A /3

-2625 2/ 845BC 2P5 30BC8 /B 6BA2P@BN P5 /1 8P5 _@8P58K 68 7/BN 68

P5 /1 8P5 86A8 2P5 085 @8 @B 2P5 401806BE5 /3 /33@E@67 J08@B588: Y5

E6BB/2 3/77/_ 6 826202/1A E/B8210E2@/B 2P62 _/07C 756C 2/ 6B 6J801C

158072: U'(4 '1 E7." *+ E3!'4 K ;f +:FC ;H?;K ;H?> ]!/7/: H==;^:

Z F=

)P@1CK 6880R@BN _@2P/02 C5E@C@BN 2P62 612@E75 hhLh 15g0@158

8033@E@5B27A 845E@3@E 826BC61C8 /3 E/BC0E2K 3/1 2P5 1568/B8 C@8E0885C

6J/D5K _5 C@86N155 _@2P O588751[8 688512@/B 2P62 @B 2P5





;>

41/D@8@/B @8 @R451R@88@J7A D6N05 @B 677 /3 @28 6447@E62@/B8: U3-5"

$"7*!+C DUS *+ @.GQ"45''O"7 K HW? +:FC ;H;=K ;H;W ]!/7/: %44: H=;;^:

% 76_ @8 @R451R@88@J7A D6N05 @3 @2 3/1J@C8 /1 15g0@158 2P5 C/@BN /3 6B

6E2 @B 251R8 8/ D6N05 2P62 4518/B8 /3 E/RR/B @B2577@N5BE5 R082

B5E58861@7A N0588 68 2/ @28 R56B@BN 6BC C@3351 68 2/ @28 6447@E62@/B:

%&+ 62 ;H;<: )51R8 B55C B/2K P/_5D51K J5 C53@B5C _@2P

R62P5R62@E67 415E@8@/B: %&+ $62P51K 2P5 41/D@8@/B R082 J5

8033@E@5B27A 845E@3@E 8/ 68 2/ N@D5 36@1 _61B@BN /3 2P5 E/BC0E2

41/P@J@25C: %&+

Z F< )/ 5826J7@8P 2P62 6 E/B82@202@/B67 41/D@8@/B @8

0BE/B82@202@/B677A /D51J1/6CK 6 476@B2@33 R082 8P/_ 2P62 2P5 76_

40B@8P58 6 80J826B2@67 6R/0B2 /3 41/25E25C 3155 8455EPK \0CN5C @B

15762@/B 2/ 2P5 41/D@8@/B[8 476@B7A 75N@2@R625 8_554: S355234 *+

T.//"7 K HHW +:FC >;=K >HW ]!/7/: H=;=^:

Z FW

I515K _5 B55C B/2 C5251R@B5 2P5 /0251 7@R@28 /3 2P5 L,![8

\01@8C@E2@/B: $62P51K _5 B55C /B7A B/25 2P62 _5 P6D5 E/B82105C

85E2@/B W 8/ 68 2/ 15E/NB@j5 2P5 6447@E6J75 7@R@28 2/ 2P5 L,![8

\01@8C@E2@/B: I6D@BN 2P08 E/B82105C 85E2@/B WK _5 B55C B/2 6CC1588

O588751[8 E/B2@BN5B2 688512@/B 2P62 6 C@33515B2 E/B8210E2@/B R@NP2

16@85 D6N05B588 /1 /D51J156C2P E/BE51B8:



;?

Z F>

*/1 677 /3 2P5 3/15N/@BN 1568/B8K _5 E/BE70C5 2P62 2P5 L,! P6C

\01@8C@E2@/B P515:

LLL: %1J@2161A /1 !641@E@/08

Z F? O588751 B5b2 E/B25BC8 2P62 @3 2P5 L,! P6C \01@8C@E2@/B P515K

2P5B @28 C5E@8@/B _68 61J@2161A /1 E641@E@/08 J5E6085 P5 41/4517A

085C P@8 C@8E152@/B61A 30BC8 2/ 6225BC 2P5 $9#% 85R@B61 6BC 2/

15@RJ0185 P@R8573 3/1 0B154/125C R@756N5: Y5 615 B/2 451806C5C:

%:

-26BC61C /3 $5D@5_

Z Ff %8 B/25C 6J/D5K /B 644567 31/R 6 C@821@E2 E/012[8 15D@5_ /3 6

3@B67 6N5BEA 6E2@/BK _5 6447A 2P5 86R5 826BC61C 68 2P5 C@821@E2

E/012K B6R57AK 2P5 6J/D5Qg0/25C 826BC61C 852 3/12P @B 85E2@/B H<Q<Q

;=>]?^: $"" %&'() K Z H;K FFf +:FC 62 ;=fH: (BC51 2P@8 826BC61CK 6

3@B67 6N5BEA C5E@8@/B R6A B/2 J5 15D5185C 0B7588K 68 4512@B5B2 P515K

@2 @8 61J@2161A /1 E641@E@/08: %&+V 3GG'7& c H<Q<Q;=>]?^:

Z Fd

LB /1C51 2/ E/BE70C5 2P62 6B 6CR@B@82162@D5 6N5BEA P68 6E25C

61J@2161@7A /1 E641@E@/087AK _5 R082 C5251R@B5 2P62 B/ 80J826B2@67

5D@C5BE5 5b@828 @B 2P5 15E/1C 2/ 8044/12 2P5 6N5BEA[8 C5E@8@/B:

A'93 *+ 0'5'+ D/&+ 632.4> 0'4/7'5 0'22:4 K f?= +:HC >H=K >H< ]!/7/:

%44: ;dd<^: )P515 R082 J5 6 E7561 511/1 /3 \0CNR5B2K 6BC _5 R6A

B/2 80J82@2025 /01 \0CNR5B2 3/1 2P62 /3 2P5 6N5BEA: $"" .&+ %B



;f

6N5BEA C5E@8@/B @8 B/2 61J@2161A /1 E641@E@/08 @3 @2 15375E28 6

`E/B8E@5B2@/08 533/12 2/ 1568/B6J7A 6447A 75N@8762@D5 826BC61C8 2/

4612@E0761 6CR@B@82162@D5 41/E55C@BN8:a %&+

S:

$9#% -5R@B61 6BC 2P5 $9!

Z <=

I515K 80J826B2@67 5D@C5BE5 @B 2P5 15E/1C 8044/128 2P5 L,![8

C5251R@B62@/B 2P62 O588751 @R41/4517A 085C P@8 C@8E152@/B61A 30BC

2/ 6225BC 2P5 $9#% 85R@B61 6BC 2P5 $9!: )P5 $9#%[8 R@88@/B

82625R5B2 @BE70C58 2P5 N/67 /3 6CD6BE@BN $540J7@E6B @C5678 6BC

41/D@C58K `)P5 $9#% 3012P51 J0@7C8 2P5 $540J7@E6B +612A N/678 6BC

@C5678 2P1/0NP 6 B62@/B_@C5 B52_/1T /3 8044/12@D5 76_A518 _P/

0BC51826BC 6BC C@15E27A 8044/12 $540J7@E6B 4/7@EAK 6N5BC68 6BC

E6BC@C6258:a U/15/D51K 2P5 L,! 3/0BCK 6BC O588751 C/58 B/2 644561

2/ C@84025K 2P62 2P5 $9#% 85R@B61 15N@82162@/B 3/1R 15g0@15C

6225BC558 2/ 82625 2P62 2P5A 8044/12 2P5 $9#%[8 R@88@/B:

Z <;

LB 6CC@2@/BK 85D5167 8588@/B8 62 2P5 85R@B61 6CC15885C

4612@86B 4/7@2@E67 @88058K 6BC O588751 2582@3@5C 2P62 P5 E/07C B/2

845E@3@E677A 15E677 C526@78 /3 _P62 _68 C@8E0885C 62 2P5 85R@B61K

@BE70C@BN 2P5 E/B25B28 /3 2P5 8588@/B 62 _P@EP P5 _68 6 8EP5C075C

8456T51: I5 2582@3@5C 62 8/R5 75BN2PK P/_5D51K 15N61C@BN P@8

6880R42@/B8 68 2/ _P62 80J\5E28 R@NP2 P6D5 J55B 6CC15885C:



;d

Z <H

%BC _P5B O588751 80JR@225C P@8 15g0582 2/ J5 15@RJ0185C 3/1

P@8 6225BC6BE5 62 2P5 $9#% 85R@B61 6BC 2P5 $9!K P5 82625CK `)P585

5b45B858 _515 @BE0115C _P@75 R552@BN _@2P E/B82@205B28K E/0B2A

E751T8K 7/JJA@828K 82633 6BC 75N@8762/18 2/ C@8E088 82625 J08@B588:a

I5K P/_5D51K E/07C /B7A 15E677 2P155 ]6BC 451P648 3@D5^ !/7/16C6B8

_@2P _P/R P5 R52 62 2P5 85R@B61K 6BC B/B5 _515 E/0B2A E751T8K

82633K /1 75N@8762/18:

Z <F

LB 7@NP2 /3 2P@8 5D@C5BE5K _5 E/BE70C5 2P62 2P5 L,![8 3@BC@BN

2P62 O588751 R@8085C P@8 C@8E152@/B61A 30BC 2/ 6225BC 2P5 $9#%

85R@B61 6BC 2P5 $9! _68 B/2 61J@2161A /1 E641@E@/08:

Z << Y5 615 B/2 451806C5C /2P51_@85 JA 2P5 80J85g05B2 L,!

6CD@8/1A /4@B@/B8 2P62 O588751 E@258 @B P@8 644577625 J1@538: O588751

E@258 2P585 /4@B@/B8 @B 2P5 E/B25b2 /3 P@8 61N0R5B2 2P62 2P5 L,![8

3@BC@BN8 _515 61J@2161A 6BC E641@E@/08: S5E6085 2P585 /4@B@/B8

_515 B/2 4612 /3 2P5 6CR@B@82162@D5 15E/1C /1 2P5 \0C@E@67 15D@5_

6E2@/BK P/_5D51K _5 N5B51677A R6A B/2 E/B8@C51 2P5R: $"" $."773

05)- *+ 8.55.4>!5"9 K ;>> +:FC F=dK F;> ]!/7/: %44: H==?^ ]B/2@BN 2P62

6B 644577625 E/012 R6A B/2 15D@5_ /B 644567 6 C/E0R5B2 2P62 _68

B/2 4612 /3 2P5 6CR@B@82162@D5 15E/1C^:



H=

Z <W

,D5B @3 _5 E/07C E/B8@C51 2P585 /4@B@/B8 JA _6A /3 26T@BN

\0C@E@67 B/2@E5K 68 O588751 6885125C 3/1 2P5 3@182 2@R5 C01@BN /167

61N0R5B2K 2P5A C/ B/2 451806C5 08 2P62 2P5 L,![8 3@BC@BN8 _515

61J@2161A 6BC E641@E@/08: "B5 /3 2P5 2_/ 6CD@8/1A /4@B@/B8 E/D515C

_P52P51 O588751 E/07C 41/4517A 6EE542 6 15N@82162@/B _6@D51 2/

6225BC 2P5 $9#%[8 B5b2 962@/B67 ,75E2@/B #6_ -5R@B61K 6BC 2P5

/2P51 6CC15885C _P52P51 O588751[8 &5402A -5E15261A /3 -2625 E/07C

41/4517A 6EE542 216D57 5b45B858 31/R P51 /33@E5 2/ 6EE/R46BA

O588751 2/ 2P5 85R@B61: $"" =GG"O/34G" '1 U73*"5 EVO"4!"! ;3.& -9

3 UF.7& ;37/9 K %CD@8/1A "4: 9/: ;<Q;= ]L,! M07A HFK H=;<^V

=GG"O/34G" '1 U73*"5 17'2 /F" $/3/" K %CD@8/1A "4: 9/: ;<Q;F ]L,!

M07A HFK H=;<^: 95@2P51 /3 2P585 /4@B@/B8 C@15E27A 6CC15885C 5@2P51

2P5 C@8E152@/B61A 30BC 8262025 /1 2P5 40J7@E 21082 8262025: U/15/D51K

2P5 762251 /4@B@/B 5b415887A B/25C 2P62 @2 _68 7@R@25C 2/ 2P5 `845E@3@E

36E28 41585B25C JA 2P5 &5402A -5E15261A 2/ 2P5 !/RR@88@/BKa B/B5

/3 _P@EP R5B2@/B5C 6BA 4612@86B 4/7@2@E67 6E2@D@2@58: $"" =GG"O/34G"

'1 U73*"5 17'2 /F" $/3/" K %CD@8/1A "4: 9/: ;<Q;FK 62 <: %EE/1C@BN7AK

2P5 /4@B@/B8 615 B/2 4512@B5B2 P515K _P515 2P5 L,![8 C5E@8@/B C@C

B/2 201B /B 2P5 36E2 2P62 O588751 6225BC5C 2P5 $9#% 85R@B61K J02

162P51 /B P@8 P6D@BN 085C P@8 C@8E152@/B61A 30BC 41@R61@7A 3/1



H;

4612@86B 4/7@2@E67K 6BC 2P08 4518/B67K 4014/858K @BE70C@BN 6225BC@BN

2P5 $9!:

Z <>

*/1 2P5 86R5 1568/B8K _5 615 B/2 451806C5C JA O588751[8

61N0R5B2 2P62 P@8 E/BC0E2 E/07C B/2 P6D5 D@/7625C 6BA 6447@E6J75

826BC61C8 /3 E/BC0E2 J5E6085 2P5 !/7/16C/ -0415R5 !/012 P6C

6441/D5C P@8 6225BC6BE5 62 2P5 $9#% 85R@B61 3/1 E/B2@B0@BN 75N67

5C0E62@/B ]!#,^ E15C@2: %N6@BK 2P5 L,! C@C B/2 86BE2@/B O588751 3/1

6225BC@BN 2P5 85R@B61: L2 86BE2@/B5C P@R J5E6085 P5 085C P@8

C@8E152@/B61A 30BC 41@R61@7A 3/1 4612@86B 4/7@2@E67 4014/858K 5D5B

2P/0NP 6 4/12@/B /3 2P5 21@4 @BD/7D5C 6B 6441/D5C !#, 41/N16R:

!: U@756N5

Z <? -0J826B2@67 5D@C5BE5 @B 2P5 15E/1C 678/ 8044/128 2P5 L,![8

C5251R@B62@/B 2P62 O588751 @R41/4517A 085C P@8 C@8E152@/B61A 30BC

2/ 15@RJ0185 P@R8573 3/1 _P62 P5 B/_ E76@R8 _68 0BC/E0R5B25C

R@756N5:

Z <f O588751 2582@3@5C 2P62 P5 80JR@225C 6 7/2 /3 R@756N5

15@RJ0185R5B2 15g05828K J02 P5 5b476@B5C 2P62 P5 C@C B/2 C/ 8/

_@2P 15845E2 2/ 2P5 15@RJ0185R5B2 62 @8805 P515 J5E6085 `2/ N/

2P1/0NP 5D51A 8@BN75 45BBA 6BC R@75 6BC _P62B/2 @2 \082 5BC5C 04

J5@BN 6 _6825 /3 2@R5 _P5B 2P515 @8 B/ J5B53@2 31/R @2:a )P08K P5



HH

82625C 2P62 P5 2//T 2P5 15R6@BC51 /3 P@8 C@8E152@/B61A 30BC 68 6B

0B80J826B2@625C 4518/B67 46AR5B2 `J5E6085 @2 _68 e;;?K 6BC @2

_68 C/_B1@NP2 568@51 2/ 46A 2P5 26b58 8@BE5 RA 26b 1625 @8 8/ 7/_

B/_6C6A8 2P6B 2/ 15E/B8210E2 RA 5B2@15 E675BC61 2/ 3@BC /02 _P62

E/07C P6D5 J55B @B 2P515:a */1 2P@8 1568/B 67/B5K _5 E/BE70C5 2P62

2P5 L,! C@C B/2 6E2 61J@2161@7A /1 E641@E@/087A @B 15308@BN 2/ E15C@2

O588751[8 688512@/B 2P62 2P5 15@RJ0185R5B2 15g0582 _68 3/1 R@756N5:

O588751 EP/85 2/ 21562 2P/85 30BC8 68 6CC@2@/B67 E/R45B862@/BK B/2

68 6 R@756N5 15@RJ0185R5B2K 6BC P5 E6BB/2 36072 2P5 L,! 3/1 C/@BN

2P5 86R5:

Z <d #@T5_@85K 672P/0NP O588751 E76@R8 2P62 P5 76251 41/C0E5C

C/E0R5B262@/B 2/ 8044/12 P@8 E76@R 3/1 0B15@RJ0185C R@756N5K 2P5

L,! _68 B/2 15g0@15C 2/ E15C@2 2P62 C/E0R5B262@/BK 5845E@677A N@D5B

2P62 P@8 E/BC0E2 P515 _68 C@33515B2 31/R P/_ P5 P6C 41/E55C5C /B

41@/1 /EE68@/B8K _P5B P5 8044/125C 15@RJ0185R5B2 15g05828 _@2P

6226EP5C 15E5@428 /1 /2P51 E/B25R4/16B5/08 C/E0R5B262@/B: $""

835&(.4 *+ @)-"7 K HHF +:FC ;W=K ;WH ]!/7/: %44: H==d^

]`k&l5251R@B62@/B8 E/BE51B@BN 2P5 E15C@J@7@2A /3 2P5 _@2B58858K 2P5

_5@NP2 2/ J5 N@D5B 2/ 2P5 5D@C5BE5K 6BC 2P5 158/702@/B /3 6BA



HF

5D@C5B2@61A E/B37@E28 615 36E2067 R622518 8/757A _@2P@B 2P5 41/D@BE5 /3

2P5 k6N5BEAl 2/ C5E@C5 68 2P5 21@51 /3 36E2:a^:

Z W=

%EE/1C@BN7AK _5 E/BE70C5 2P62 2P5 L,![8 3@BC@BN 2P62 O588751

@R41/4517A 085C P@8 C@8E152@/B61A 30BC 2/ 15@RJ0185 P@R8573 3/1

0BC/E0R5B25C 5b45B858 _68 B/2 61J@2161A /1 E641@E@/08:

LG: +1/E5C0167 &05 +1/E588

Z W; *@B677AK O588751 E/B25BC8 2P62 P5 _68 C5B@5C 41/E5C0167 C05

41/E588 J5E6085 P5 _68 B/2 N@D5B 6CD6BE5 6BC 6C5g0625 B/2@E5 /3

2P5 826BC61C8 /3 E/BC0E2 2P62 P5 _68 6EE085C /3 P6D@BN D@/7625C:

Y5 C@86N155:

Z WH +1/E5C0167 C05 41/E588 15g0@158 2P62 6 1584/BC5B2 J5 B/2@3@5C

/3 2P5 B62015 /3 2P5 41/E55C@BN8 6BC 6441@85C /3 2P5 1@NP2 2/ 41585B2

5D@C5BE5 @B P@8 /1 P51 /_B J5P673: 0'5'+ $/3/" 8&+ '1 A"&+

EV32:7! *+ 8'95" K dH< +:HC ;;;FK ;;;? ]!/7/: %44: ;dd>^: */1

4014/858 /3 6N5BEA 6C\0C@E62/1A 41/E55C@BN8K

k6lBA 4518/B 5B2@275C 2/ B/2@E5 /3 6 P561@BN8P677 J5 N@D5B 2@R57A B/2@E5 /3 2P5 2@R5K 476E5K

6BC B62015 2P515/3K 2P5 75N67 602P/1@2A 6BC \01@8C@E2@/B 0BC51 _P@EP @2 @8 2/ J5 P57CK 6BC2P5 R622518 /3 36E2 6BC 76_ 6885125C: (B7588/2P51_@85 41/D@C5C JA 76_K 80EP B/2@E5 8P677 J5851D5C : : : 62 75682 2P@12A C6A8 41@/1 2/ 2P5P561@BN:



H<

c H<Q<Q;=W]H^]6^K !:$:-: H=;<:

Z WF ,D5B @3 2P5 B/2@E5 41/D@C5C @8 @B8033@E@5B2K P/_5D51K 511/18 @B

6CR@B@82162@D5 41/E55C@BN8 C/ B/2 15g0@15 15D51867 0B7588 2P5

E/R476@B@BN 4612A E6B 8P/_ 2P62 P5 /1 8P5 _68 415\0C@E5C:

W'!"OF *+ A."Q3 0'7O+K H=;H !"% f<K Z >?K HfH +:FC W=dK WH=:

Z W<

I515K _5 E/BE70C5 2P62 O588751 15E5@D5C R/15 2P6B 6R475

B/2@E5 /3 2P5 E76@R8 6885125C 6N6@B82 P@R: %72P/0NP 2P5 @B@2@67

E/R476@B2 3@75C JA !/7/16C/ ,2P@E8 Y62EP 6775N5C 2P5 D@/762@/B /3

2P155 E1@R@B67 82620258K 2P/85 D@/762@/B8 _515 415R@85C /B O588751[8

D@/762@/B /3 2P5 C@8E152@/B61A 30BC 8262025K _P@EP O588751 6CC15885C

62 75BN2P @B P@8 1584/B85 2/ 2P5 E/R476@B2: LB 6CC@2@/BK O588751

15E5@D5C J/2P 6 415QP561@BN /1C51 6BC 6B 6R5BC5C 415QP561@BN

/1C51 /D51 /B5 R/B2P J53/15 2P5 P561@BN: )P5 6R5BC5C 415QP561@BN

/1C51 852 3/12P 8@b 826BC61C8 /3 E/BC0E2 /1 154/12@BN 15g0@15R5B28

2P62 2P5 L,! 3572 _515 4/25B2@677A 6447@E6J75K @BE70C@BN 2P5

C@8E152@/B61A 30BC 6BC 40J7@E 21082 82620258 2P62 O588751 _68

072@R6257A 3/0BC 2/ P6D5 D@/7625C:

Z WW

%EE/1C@BN7AK _5 E/BE70C5 2P62 O588751 15E5@D5C E/B82@202@/B677A

6C5g0625 B/2@E5 P515: $"" c H<Q<Q;=W]H^]6^V 8'95" K dH< +:HC 62

;;;?:





H>

Z Wf

LB 6BA 5D5B2K 2P5 15E/1C J57@58 6BA E76@R /3 415\0C@E5 2/

O588751: O588751K 2P1/0NP 5b451@5BE5C 6BC 6J75 E/0B857K R/0B25C 6

D@N/1/08 C535B85 2/ 2P5 EP61N58 6N6@B82 P@RK @BE70C@BN @B P@8 415Q

P561@BN 533/128 2/ P6D5 2P5 E685 C@8R@885C 6BC 62 2P5 5D@C5B2@61A

P561@BN: I@8 4756C@BN8 6BC 2P5 5D@C5BE5 41585B25C 62 2P5 P561@BN

6R47A C5R/B821625 2P62 P5 _68 _577 6_615 /3 2P5 EP61N58 6N6@B82

P@R 6BC 2P62 P5 _68 6J75 2/ C535BC 6N6@B82 2P5R 3077A 6BC

6441/41@6257A: $"" W'!"OF K ZZ >?Q>fK HfH +:FC 62 WH=:

G: !/BE708@/B

Z Wd

*/1 2P585 1568/B8K 2P5 \0CNR5B2 @8 633@1R5C:

M(&O, )%(SU%9 6BC M(&O, S""$%- E/BE01:



!"#$%& %"!%&(!$!) $**+,!%& "- #.& /,!0,#&

"#$%#&'( () *+,+-+ ./0123 (45 6&'7&(5 )8 (45 *)#$( )8 ,995&:% 6&; <%%#5 8)$(;=three days after entry of the judgment. In worker’s compensation and#'569:);65'( <'%#$&'>5 >&%5%3 (45 6&'7&(5 )8 (45 *)#$( )8 ,995&:% 6&; <%%#5(4<$(;=)'5 7&;% &8(5$ 5'($; )8 (45 ?#7@65'(+ "#$%#&'( () *+,+-+ A+.0:23 (456&'7&(5 )8 (45 *)#$( )8 ,995&:% 6&; <%%#5 (B5'(;='<'5 7&;% &8(5$ (45 5'($; )8(45 ?#7@65'( <' &995&:% 8$)6 9$)>557<'@% <' 7595'75'>; )$ '5@:5>(+

C<:<'@ )8 & "5(<(<)' 8)$ -545&$<'@3 B<(4<' (45 (<65 95$6<((57 1; *+,+-+ .D3 B<::%(&; (45 6&'7&(5 #'(<: (45 >)#$( 4&% $#:57 )' (45 95(<(<)'+ C<:<'@ & "5(<(<)' 8)$E$<( )8 *5$(<)$&$< B<(4 (45 F#9$565 *)#$(3 B<(4<' (45 (<65 95$6<((57 1; *+,+-+GH012 B<:: &:%) %(&; (45 6&'7&(5 #'(<: (45 F#9$565 *)#$( 4&% $#:57 )' (45

"5(<(<)'+

IJ KLM *NO-KP ,:&' Q+ R)51*4<58 S#7@5

T,KMTP N>()15$ HA3 HD/.

"#$%&' $# (')*+,'-,'('.$'/ -0,$%'( ! #$% &'(')*+' ,*) -..'/0*10'2 3)'40+%. 5)%% 4'(621%%) *11')2%7. 02 * .8*(( 2689%) '5 *33%((*1% /*.%.: ;57'6 *)% )%3)%.%2102< 7'6).%(5 *2+ 8%%1 1$% &,- ('= 02/'8% >6*(050/*10'2.?7'6 8*7 *33(7 1' 1$% &,- 1' .%% 05 7'6) /*.% 8*7 9% /$'.%2 5') * 5)%%

(*=7%): @%(5A)%3)%.%21%+ 3*)10%. =$' *)% 021%)%.1%+ .$'6(+ 40.01 1$%-33%((*1% B)' ,'2' B)'<)*8 3*<% *1$113!CC===:/'9*):')<C02+%D:/58C;ECFGHIJ:

*#,#& "- %"1"(,0"

2 &345 6758 ,9:;<:

0:;9:=> %" ?@2@A

BC2@D E2FGF6F@

%.($* (H,! I,+1$!& J("%K%1&(K "- #.& %"+(# %.$&- 0&I+#H %1&(K

Documents

Court of Appeals Opinion Gessler v. Ethics Commission