Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Cucumber mosaic virus in snap beans: Symptoms, vectors and management
Brian A. NaultProfessor
Department of EntomologyCornell University
New York State Agricultural Experiment StationGeneva, NY
Last updated January 2016
Viruses Detected in Snap Bean Fields in Midwestern and Northeastern US Since 2000
• Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV)• Alfalfa mosaic virus (AMV)• Bean common mosaic virus (BCMV)• Bean yellow mosaic virus (BYMV)• Clover yellow vein virus (C1YVV)• White clover mosaic virus (WCMV)• Clover yellow mosaic virus (C1YMV)• Bean pod mottle virus (BPMV)• Tobacco streak virus (TSV)
Grau et al. (2002); Larsen et al. (2002); Shah et al. (2006)
Viruses Detected in Snap Bean Fields in Midwestern and Northeastern US Since 2000
• Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV)• Alfalfa mosaic virus (AMV)• Bean common mosaic virus (BCMV)• Bean yellow mosaic virus (BYMV)• Clover yellow vein virus (C1YVV)• White clover mosaic virus (WCMV)• Clover yellow mosaic virus (C1YMV)• Bean pod mottle virus (BPMV)• Tobacco streak virus (TSV)
Grau et al. (2002); Larsen et al. (2002); Shah et al. (2006)
* Implicated in causing yield loss in these regions
Most Common Virus in Snap Bean Fields in Midwestern and Northeastern US Since 2000
• Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV)• Alfalfa mosaic virus (AMV)• Bean common mosaic virus (BCMV)• Bean yellow mosaic virus (BYMV)• Clover yellow vein virus (C1YVV)• White clover mosaic virus (WCMV)• Clover yellow mosaic virus (C1YMV)• Bean pod mottle virus (BPMV)• Tobacco streak virus (TSV)
Grau et al. (2002); Larsen et al. (2002); Shah et al. (2006)
CMV Transmission• Primarily transmitted by aphids in a non-persistent, stylet-borne manner1
- Acquired and transmitted within seconds - Multiple plants can be infected, including non- crop plants
1 Nault, L. R. (1997). Ann. Entmol. Soc. Am. 90: 521-541.
Phloem
Hindgut
ASGPSGMidgut
FoodCanal or Stylet
SalivaryCanal
Haemocoel
virus
What Aphid Species are Spreading CMV in Snap Bean Fields?
Sampling Aphids• 5-year study• 5 to 9 traps/ field
• n = 56 fields
• Sampled weekly
• Aphids identified by Dr. Randi Eckel (RTWE Consulting)
ceramic tile on bottom+
propylene glycol + water
Most Common Aphid Species Captured in NY Snap Bean Fields (2002-2006)
Pea aphid(Acyrthosiphon pisum)
Corn leaf aphid(Rhopalosiphum maidis)
#3 (14.8%) #4 (9.2%)
Yellow clover aphid(Therioaphis trifolii)
Soybean aphid(Aphis glycines)
#1 (30.4%) #2 (19.7%)
Nault et al. (2009)
Total number of species= 90; Total number of aphids= 7,484
Most Common Aphid Species Captured in NY Snap Bean Fields (2002-2006)
Yellow clover aphid(Therioaphis trifolii)
Soybean aphid(Aphis glycines)
#1 (30.4%) #2 (19.7%)
Nault et al. (2009)
* Most highly associated with CMV epidemics
BuckthornRhamnus spp.
SoybeanGlycine max
Soybean Aphid has Two Hosts
Note: Snap bean, alfalfa and clover are not suitable hosts
“Bugs that irk city-dwellers horrify farmers; a field can hold billions”Canadian PressAugust 4, 2001
Baseball game in Toronto Skydome stopped in 3rd inning to close roof!
Alfalfa is a Major Host for CMV
• 13 to 18% of alfalfa plants infected with CMV in NY (Shah et al. 2006)
• Number of infected plants estimated @ 22,000 to 31,000/acre
• > 575,000 acres of alfalfa (>17-fold more acreage than snaps); concentrated in western NY
• Perennial (4 to 6 year rotation)• Neither alfalfa nor snap bean are good hosts
for soybean aphid
Questions
1. When during the season do soybean aphids fly into snap bean fields?
2. What years will soybean aphids be a problem?
3. How can soybean aphids and/ or CMV be managed in snap bean?
Impact of Timing of Virus Infection on Yield
• Infection during early plant development will cause greater losses in yield compared with infection during late developmental stages (Walkey 1991)
0 15 30 45 60 Days after Planting
emergence vegetative stages
bloom pin pod stage
Greater yieldloss
Lower yieldloss
Snap Bean
infection infection
N = 4 fields/year
Mean % CMV in Early-Planted New York Snap Bean Fields (2005-2006)
}
Early Planting Harvest
N = 4 fields/year
Mean % CMV in Mid Season-Planted New York Snap Bean Fields (2004-2006)
}Mid Planting Harvest
N = 4 fields/year
Mean % CMV in Late Season-Planted New York Snap Bean Fields (2004-2006)
Late Planting Harvest
}
soybean alfalfa
snap bean
CMV (-)
CMV (+)
Expected Sequence of Events
Soybean aphid
buckthorn???
buckthorn
?
Questions
1. When during the season do soybean aphids fly into snap bean fields?
2. What years will soybean aphids be a problem?
3. How can soybean aphids and/ or CMV be managed in snap bean?
Soybean Aphid – Every other year phenomenon during first decade
Predictable based on:
- Adults caught in suction traps in Fall (Sept. and Oct)
- Eggs deposited on buckthorn in Fall
Can Soybean Aphid Abundance be Predicted Based on Fall Suction Trap Capture?
2001 ? 2002 75 2003 10 2004 195 2005 30 2006 195 2007 2 2008 152 2009 ?
Year
IllinoisAvg. Soybean Aphid
Capture/ Trap (Sept + Oct)
http://www.ncipmc.org/traps/index.cfm.
North Central Regional Soybean Aphid Suction Trap Network
Questions
1. When during the season do soybean aphids fly into snap bean fields?
2. What years will soybean aphids be a problem?
3. How can soybean aphids and/ or CMV be managed in snap bean?
Managing Aphid-Transmitted Viruses/ Aphids (1 of 2)
Ineffective or Non-practical solutions• Insecticides (e.g., foliar sprays or seed treatments)• Biological control of aphids • Preventing aphids from landing on crop
- reflective mulches (e.g., tomato and pepper) - row covers
• Interfering with aphid’s ability to transmit virus - mineral and stylet oils (e.g., tomato and pepper)
• Manipulating immigrating aphid populations - border crop or barrier crop
• Separating crop from virus source - distance and time
Managing Aphid-Transmitted Viruses/ Aphids (2 of 2)
Effective solutions ✓ Cultivars resistant to virus (e.g., traditional breeding
or genetically modified)✓ Cultivars tolerant to virus
Screening for CMV Tolerance in Snap Bean Cultivars
Jim Ballerstein & Steve ReinersDept. of HorticultureCornell University
Current Management of CMV in Snap Beans
• Plant cultivars that yield well regardless if they are infected with CMV- Tolerant to virus
- High yielding even when infected with virus
• This strategy has been adopted by the processing snap bean industry throughout Great Lakes region (e.g., ‘Huntington’, ‘Summit’ )
Conclusions• Soybean aphid is likely the most important vector of CMV in snap bean fields
• Snap beans planted beyond late June are at highest risk for yield-reducing levels of CMV
• CMV epidemics during odd-numbered years in NY appear to be associated with soybean aphid population dynamics
• Until CMV-resistant cultivars are available, CMV-tolerant cultivars could be planted during last half of season to minimize risk of yield loss
The Bean Virus “Bug” TeamCollaborators at Cornell:➢Drs. Denis Shah, Helene Dillard and Marc Fuchs (PP&PMB)➢Drs. Phil Griffiths, Steve Reiners and Alan Taylor (Horticultural
Sciences)➢Dr. Julie Kikkert (CCE) and Keith Waldron (IPM)
Technical Assistance:➢Katie Straight, Mary Lou Hessney and students (Entomology)➢ Joe Shail and Jim Ballerstein (Horticultural Sciences)
Industry Assistance:➢Roger Ward (Farm Fresh First, Oakfield, NY)➢ Jeff Johnson (Seneca, Geneva, NY)
Funding:➢NYVRC/A and NYFVI
Questions?
Brian A. NaultDepartment of EntomologyCornell University - NYSAESGeneva, NY 14456